Extracted text: Proceedings of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion [May 1966] `
Extracted text: Proceedings of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion [May 1966] ` results
admin
Edited Text
PROCEEDINGS
of the
National Executive Committee
THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
MAY 4-5, 1966
INDEX
Page
Page
EMBLEM
166
Resolutions following:
No.
AMERICANISM
50
7—
Resolution following:
Non-Legislative Policy Resolutions . 168
No.
8—
10—
Planning Religious Programs in the
for Emblem Division Merchandise .. 169
Job Corps Centers
54
11—
Support Legislation Which Would
Make it a Crime to Desecrate the
FOREIGN RELATIONS
57
United States Flag
54
Resolutions following:
12—
Daily Display of the American Flag
No.
Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam 54
41—
16—Support Legislation to Amend the
Immigration and Nationality Act to
42—
Make
Provisions
for
Necessary
Communist Forces and Supplies into
Travel Control for United States
South Viet Nam
114
Residents Outside of This Country.. 54
20—Change in the Method of Selecting
INTERNAL AFFAIRS
90
the Winner of the William Randolph
Hearst Trophy
54
NATIONAL CONSTITUTION AND BYLAWS STANDING COMMITTEE,
CHILD WELFARE
35
SUBCOMMITTEE
93
Resolution following:
TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS
95
No.
28—
Commend
Youth AND AWARDS37, 84
SPECIAL TROPHIES
PRESENTED
29—
Need
for Expanded Research and 97
Educational
Program
Concerning
GRAVES REGISTRATION AND MEGenetic Diseases
37, 85
MORIAL
93
30—
Drugs Intended for Child Use and
Resolutions following:
Other Hazardous Materials
85
No.
CONVENTION
62
1—
Post No. 13, Hohenfels, Germany .. 102
Resolution following:
2—
No.
Howard Post No. 8, Sam Miguel de
27—Satisfaction of Indebtedness of UniAllende, Gto., Mexico
103
formed Groups at National Conven18—
tions
64
tee Reports and Resolutions to De38—Authorization for National Adjutant
partment Delegations at the National
of The American Legion to Accept
Convention (Origin; Res. 153 (47th
Advertising for National Convention
National Convention.))
103
Souvenir Program
64
19—
for 1966
104
CONVENTION, Report of 1965
65
24—Future Changes in Manual of Ceremonies
105
ECONOMIC
38
26—Support Legislation to Erect General
Resolution following:
John J. Pershing Memorial in Washington, D. C
105
No.
31—
6—Support Legislation to Amend the
of Individuals Convicted of Treason 105
Cold War GI Bill (Public Law 8932—
358) to Provide Assistance in OnEmilio Aguinaldo Post 45, Cubao,
the-Job Training Programs
47
W.C., Philippines
106
33—Support the Establishment of a SuitFIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE 13
able National Cemetery Policy
106
Resolutions following:
No.
LEGISLATIVE
85
15—Commemoration of Fiftieth Anniversary of First American Legion National Convention in Minneapolis,
LIFE INSURANCE AND TRUST
32
Minnesota
18
Resolutions following:
14—50th Anniversary Observance of the
No.
Founding of The American Legion 18, 72
39—Approval to Reimburse The American
17—Commemoration of 50th Anniversary
Legion for Life Insurance Expenses 170
of St. Louis, Missouri, Caucus of
The American Legion
20, 83
43—Approval to Prepare Agreement for
American Legion Life Insurance
Plan
170
FINANCE
165
COMMISSION, COMMITTEE AND
SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS
Page
MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES 122
Resolution following::
No.
25—Change in Regulations for Awarding
the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of
The American Legion Trophy
126
MEMBERSHIP SPECIAL ELIGIBILITY 127
Resolution following:
No.
23—Amendments to Sections 3 and 5 of
the Federal Act Incorporating The
American Legion, and to Article IV,
Section 1, and to Article XIII, Section 2 of the National Constitution
of The American Legion, to extend
Eligibility for Membership in The
American Legion to those persons
who served in the Armed Forces from
on or after August 5, 1964
141
PUBLICATIONS
PUBLIC RELATIONS
66,71
21
Page
SECURITY
23
Resolutions following:
No.
3—
States Armory in Springfield Massachusetts
24
4—
shey, Director of Selective Service
System
24
5—
for the Late Fleet Admiral Chester
W. Nimitz
24
9—Support Passage of S. 2351 to Protect Harassment of Families of Servicemen in Viet Nam
24
13—Support Legislation Proposed by
Departments of Defense and the Bolte
Committee to Provide Uniformity
for Improvement of Career Opportunities in the Military Services ....
24
21—
22—
Nam
25
REHABILITATION
162
Resolutions following:
MISCELLANEOUS
No.
American Legion Auxiliary
35—
Legislation
to Amend
38 USCPresident
641 to
Mrs. Walter
H. Glynn,
Increase the Per Diem Payment to
Batts, Dianna Lynn, Miss U.S.A
States for Hospital Care of War
Benediction
Veterans
162, 171
ChartersofofRetired
American
LegionPerPosts and
36—
Eligibility
Military
Squadron Cancellations
sonnel for Treatment in Veterans
Administration Hospitals
162, 171
Colors Saluted
3, 112,
37—
Sponsor
and Support
Legislation
to
Commander
L. Eldon
James
Provide Nursing Home Care for
Opening Remarks
Veterans Living in Alaska and HaClosing Remarks
waii
163, 172
Tribute, Louis A. Johnson
E. Meade Wilson
REORGANIZATION
117
Correction Approval
Resolution following:
Endowment Fund Meeting Room
No.
Fall Meeting Dates Approved
34—Referral
of Resolution
Creating
Historians President, Hugh P. HaughAmerican Legion Auxiliary Departerty, National Association of Department in the Philippines to the Nament Historians
tional Organization of The American
Interim
Appointments, Confirmed
Legion Auxiliary
119
Introduction of Guests
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Invocation, Rev. Alfred C. Thompson,
REPORT
18
National Chaplain
3,
Memorial Resolutions
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Presentation to National Chaplain
FINAL REPORT
172
Report on Viet Nam, Past National ComResolution following:
mander Cocke
No.
Roll Call
40—Commend the American Bible Society
Subcommittee Appointments, Resolutions
on its 150th Anniversary
172
6
48
176
173
176
6
176
9
152
175
12
175
7
172
6
112
8
3
107
3
6
PROCEEDINGS
of the
National Executive Committee
THE AMERICAN LEGION
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
May 4, 1966
The opening session of the National Executive Committee meeting of The
American Legion, held at National Headquarters, 700 North Pennsylvania
Street, Indianapolis, Indiana, convened at 9:30 A. M. on Wednesday, May 4,
1966, Mr. L. Eldon James, National Commander, presiding.
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore acted as Secretary.
SALUTE TO THE COLORS
The Colors having been posted, the Committeemen rose and saluted the
flag of our country.
INVOCATION
Rev. Alfred C. Thompson (New York)
National Chaplain
Let us pray, again, our Father, we come to Thee with grateful hearts
for these United States in which we live. Thank you for the opportunities
which are ours, for the privileges which we share, for the responsibilities
which are also ours. We pray, oh God, especially this morning that Thou be
upon us as we gather here to discuss and promote legislative programs and
to carry out those programs that refer to the aims of The American Legion.
Help us in our service to Thee and to our Nation. Grant unto us Thy wisdom and Thy guidance that when all is said and done it might be done to
Thine honor and glory. We ask it in Thy Name, amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Let the record show that the
opening session of the National Executive Committee in the spring of 1966
is in session.
I will ask the Chaplain if he will come with me to the microphone, please.
PRESENTATION
At this time, the National Commander, on behalf of the Friends of the
Chapel of the Four Chaplains presented to Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, a life
membership in the order of the Friends of the Chapel of the Four Chaplains.
ROLL CALL
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore called the roll and the following were
present:
3
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 1,, 1966
4
OFFICERS
National Commander L. Eldon James, Virginia
National Chaplain Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, New York
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore, Wyoming
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDERS
John R. Quinn, California
Harry W. Colmery, Kansas
Milo J. Warner, Ohio
Warren H. Atherton, California
Paul H. Griffith, Pennsylvania
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire
S. Perry Brown, Texas
Erie Cocke, Jr., Georgia
Seaborn P. Collins, New Mexico
J. Addington Wagner, Michigan
John S. Gleason, Jr., Illinois
Charles L. Bacon, Missouri
Daniel F. Foley, Minnesota
Donald E. Johnson, Iowa
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDERS
Soleng Tom, Arizona
Dr. A. R. Choppin, Louisiana
William E. Galbraith, Nebraska
Robert 0. Phillips, Philippines
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Department
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Canada
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
D. of C.
Florida
France
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Italy
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Mexico
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
Committeeman
Hugh Overton
George Petrovich
Ralph A. Watkins, Jr.
Ulys A. Lovell
A. Lee Oder
Forrest Monner
Robert Grauberger
Joseph G. Leonard
Charles E. Jackson
Allyn E. Donaldson
E. Meade Wilson
Sedley Peck
W. D. Harrell
Wallace C. A. Young
Bernard F. Gratton
Karl Yost
Robert L. Kuntz
Robert Lounsberry
Sexson E. Humphreys
V. L. Lehr
Kenneth Fern
Alternate
Robert E. Cockrill
Norman M. Lyon
Francis G. Garris
Frank J. Specht
Arthur M. MacCarthy
Lt. Col. F. J. Deyeso
Frank A. Kelly
Morris “Bob” Nooner
Melvin H. Heckman
Maurice E. McKeniry
Maurice R. Parisien
H. Laird Roeder
Gabriel T. Olga
Harry Wright
John M. Carey
Eugene V. Lindquist
Ralph M. Godwin
James F. Kerr
William Lindsay
Robert W. Lowry (Acting)
Thomas W. Miller
George Abalan
Victor F. Whittlesea
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
5
Alternate
Committeeman
Department
Raymond F. Mudge
New Hampshire
Edmund G. Lyons
William G. McKinley
New Jersey
Dr. D. H. “Tiny” Reed
New Mexico
Louis E. Drago
New York
Leslie R. Brady, Sr.
North Carolina
W. D. Robbins
John E. Davis
North Dakota
Patrick T. Milloy
Ohio
Alec J. Blair
Oklahoma
Gene Hassman
William Stevens
Oregon
Raymond G. Bush
Panama
Daniel A. Drew
Pennsylvania
Alfredo C. Sese
Philippines
Gilberto M. Font
Puerto Rico
John A. Ryer
Rhode Island
E. Roy Stone, Jr.
South Carolina
Richard W. Small
Glenn R. Green
South Dakota
Whit LaFon
Tennessee
J. Walter Janko
Texas
William E. Christofferson
Utah
Ray Greenwood
Vermont
Dr. Thomas H. S. Ely
Virginia
Aiden F. Russell
Washington
L. O. Bickel
West Virginia
James E.Mulder
Wisconsin
Wyoming
C. B. Metz
NATIONAL ADJUTANT BLACKMORE : A quorum is present.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: I would ask the unanimous consent to seat Dr.
“Tiny” Reed to serve in place of Peter McAtee, as he will not be here this
time, without vote.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Any objection? Hearing none, it
is so ordered.
MR. SESE, Philippines: I am Alfredo C. Sese for Charles A. Park of
the Philippines.
Following the Roll Call the Commander declared that a quorum was present.
INTRODUCTIONS
At this time opportunity was given for the introduction of distinguished
guests and visitors.
OPENING REMARKS OF NATIONAL COMMANDER L. ELDON JAMES
Those who have had the experience of visiting with me. as I come into
your Departments know that my problem is when I start talking I don’t know
when to stop. But you also know that I feel that actions speak louder than
words, so we have no opening remarks this morning, except to thank the
Committee for the work that you have been doing and chastise you for the
work you haven’t been doing. And to those who have really been working,
thanks. And to the great majority, you are setting a great example for the
others. And to the others, if you feel you are in that category, we only say,
go and do likewise. And with that, I think we should get right along with
the business, because you are cast in this role because you love The American Legion. And I think that you gain satisfaction from using every moment
that you can to be about that work.
So that is what we should do, and we will get right along with the business. But before we do, I would like to announce that the dinner tonight will
be in the Ballroom of the Indianapolis Athletic Club at 7:00 P. M.; there will
be a reception in the French Room before dinner from 6:00 to 7:00. The
speaker at the dinner will be our National President, Mrs. Walter Glynn.
This may be some deviation from precedent, gentlemen, but we have not
been bound by precedent I think this year in some respects, and the National
President has just returned from a trip into areas of the world that are
6
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
disturbed, and areas to which we have been giving attention. And I
feel that she can bring a message to us tonight based on her experiences
and the feelings that she has developed. I am sure you will find it a very
entertaining program.
APPOINTMENT OP SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESOLUTIONS
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following
subcommittee appointments were approved:
E. Roy Stone, Jr., South Carolina, Chairman
Robert B. Grauberger, Colorado
Glenn R. Green, South Dakota
Whit LaFon, Tennessee
James E. Mulder, Wisconsin.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I would like to have Past National Commander Don Johnson and the Committeeman from Iowa to escort
our distinguished National President of the American Legion Auxiliary to
the rostrum.
... At this time Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, Iowa, National President of The
American Legion Auxiliary, was escorted to the rostrum.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I have said this many times to
the members of the Auxiliary, and I would like to say it now to this group
so that you may pass this message back to your Auxiliary members where
I have not said it personally. I would like to thank the American Legion
Auxiliary for the great thing that they have done for me this year in giving
me such a fine President to work with. It has been a real experience. This
lady is a sound inspiration, a business lady, a charming person doing a
magnificent job for the American Legion Auxiliary, and therefore for The
American Legion.
We are honored to have you pay us a special visit this morning, but save
some of the steam for tonight, do whatever you want to do right now.
MRS. WALTER H. GLYNN, Iowa
National President
American Legion Auxiliary
Thank you, Mr. Commander, thank you for that wonderful introduction.
Distinguished gentlemen of The American Legion and especially to the group
over there from Iowa, it is wonderful to greet you all at this particular occasion. I was sorry last fall not to have had the opportunity to come here
and say hello to each and every one of you personally and to wish you well
as we went into a new year. I did send a little recorded message, and when
I am through here today, you might decide that it might have been better
if I would have stuck to the tape instead of being here in person. But anyway, it is nice to see all of you gathered here.
I have had an opportunity to greet many of you in the last two days,
and many of you have been over to the office. And I might say, if you have
an opportunity before you leave, we would like to welcome you over there.
Particularly this morning, I want to thank you for all that you have done
for the American Legion Auxiliary, and to keep up inspired in such a way
that we continue to be proud to be associated with gentlemen of your caliber.
Everywhere I go in the nation and throughout my trips abroad, I have
grown more and more aware of the great potential which you gentlemen
have in this world in the way of leadership in which you really do well in
the way of leadership and so, as your Auxiliary, and speaking for the nearly
million members of our Auxiliary, I thank you for asking us to be associated with you over these many years, and I hope that this association
will go on and on and on, and that the only way it may ever end is because
there is never a need or there is no new eligibility for The American Legion,
because this way we know that perhaps at last the world has found peace
and we can all find a different way to serve our nation and the world.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
7
I do have a real special mission. I know that this will come as no surprise
to you, because it has been done several years now, but it gives me a great
thrill to do this as President of the American Legion Auxiliary, because over
the past years, I have been particularly privileged to serve in the capacity
of Child Welfare Chairman and Rehabilitation Chairman for the American
Legion Auxiliary, and so, I would like to ask that the group from the Child
Welfare Committee and the group from the Rehabilitation Committee come
forward—Miss Jean Ryan, our National Rehabilitation Chairman, Mr. Bob
McCurdy, The American Legion Rehabilitation Chairman, and Dr. Corcoran,
the Director, and Vernon Randall, our Child Welfare Chairman, and Randel
Shake, the Director, and Bob Nooner, the Chairman.
As the Commander mentioned, I am looking forward to speaking to you
tonight, and will save most of my message for that. But this is the real
reason for our appearing before you today, and, Mr. Commander, it is a
pleasure for me to be able to present to you on behalf of the American
Legion Auxiliary a check for $20,000 for use in the rehabilitation service of
our organization. This is just by way of thanking you for the service you
have given us over the years, and that you are continuing to do for the veterans of our nation.
And from our National Child Welfare, Helen Randall, we have here
two checks for the Child Welfare program, $20,000 for the Child Welfare
Commission program itself, a $10,000 check for the Child Welfare Foundation. We know that this too will find good use by you.
Considering these people whom you see before you, I wanted them to be
a part of this program, because they have given so much over the years to
the people associated in our organization, and these ladies who are Chairmen this year in our organization, they continue to be dedicated to the programs of rehabilitation and child welfare, and I wanted them to be a part
of the program this morning so this Auxiliary can say thank you for all you
do for us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Madam President, Chairmen, on
behalf of this group of men who would like to make about a ten minute
speech, we say thank you so very much, and we assure you that these
funds will be put to good use in the name of The American Legion and the
American Legion Auxiliary. Thank you so very much.
NATIONAL AUXILIARY PRESIDENT GLYNN: Before I leave this
room I want to say thank you to our National Commander for all the wonderful cooperation he has given our organization, and to thank you for giving me the opportunity of serving with him. It is a wonderful experience to
have had this year with all of you. Thanks so much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: While we are still here, I would
like to introduce three members of the Auxiliary who are present and ask
them to take a bow, Past National President Betty Burdett, Past National
President Betty Anahamiler, and a member of the Auxiliary Finance Committee, Mary Mae Vicker.
You have seen the people that received the glory but now I would like to
present one that does the work, Doris Anderson, the National Legion Auxiliary Secretary.
HUGH P. HAUGHERTY,
President, National Association of Department Historians
of The American Legion
Commander James, Vice Commanders, Adjutant Blackmore, Past National
Commanders, members of the Executive Committee, fellow Historians, ladies
and gentlemen:
I am cognizant of the privilege accorded me and the National Association
of Department Historians of The American Legion when I, their President,
come before you. I wish to express my appreciation to my NEC man, Gene
Hassman, for making arrangements for me.
What is the present status of American Legion history? We have a wonderful library here in National Headquarters under the able supervision of
8
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Librarian Tom Hull. Our National Historian Harold Shindler is doing excellent work, but what is the condition in the Departments and the Posts? Certain of the Departments have excellent histories complete from 1919 to the
current year. Some have a rather good compilation of their history, and
there are others who have practically no chronological history, and many
Posts do not elect or appoint a Post Historian.
. This condition of affairs will continue to be the case until the Historian
is accorded the recognition, status and finances necessary to accomplish the
work.
We might ask the question—“Why concern ourselves with National, Department and Post history?” We must admit that in a practical way its value
is hard to define. It cannot be counted as are things mathematical or formulated as can be a chemical.
History is a recording of man and his works, good and bad. Ours is a
book of good works to be pondered after all of us now active have “gone
west.
You who are here came for the purpose of carrying on that good work
and in all likelihood, will pave the way for another important chapter for
“our book.”
You are in a position to render a valuable service to The American
Legion in your various Departments. Carry the message to your Department
Commanders, Department Executive Committeemen, District Commanders, and
other “working” Legionnaires, the necessity for support for those good, efficient and sincere Historians now so diligently doing their work, and secure
some good working Historians at all levels, and please let us cease the practice of making Historians of people whose qualifications are limited to being
“a good old boy,” or “a real nice lady.” Let us have Historians who can and
will function.
There is not a Post that has not performed acts of service to their community of which they are justly proud. There is not a Department that has
not undertaken numerous projects for the betterment of their state and fellow man. We have been fortunate in having many sincere and dedicated Historians who have seen and now are attempting to pass the torch of our performance to light the path of another generation, who are even now knocking
at our gates. It should be our proud duty to hold up before these younger
eyes “The tablet of performance” on which is graven our devotion to country,
our willingness to serve in both peace and war, and our undying devotion
to her aims and to her purposes.
When the book upon which we write is closed, and the angel of the record
has closed the clasp upon it, we hope to leave upon its shining pages, the
joy of service that we have felt and that these shining pages shall be a
light unto the feet of those who shall serve their God and Country, as has
been our privilege.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Hugh. And I say to
you, gentlemen, Patrick Henry once said in essence that the lamplight of
history is the only guide to the steps of the future. I would say that the making of history is important and glamorous, and the proper recording of it is
essential to guide us so that those who make history will not repeat the
mistakes of the past.
So I commend to you the works of the Historians and urge your support
of their work.
MEMORIAL RESOLUTIONS
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN E. ROY STONE: Mr. Commander, I
now ask that you call the Executive Committee to attention for the purpose
of Memorial Resolutions.
. . . The National Executive Committee stood at attention during the reading of the following resolutions by Subcommittee Chairman Stone:
Proceedings of Wednesday, May
if,
1966
9
Louis A. Johnson
(West Virginia)
WHEREAS, It has pleased Almighty God, the Great Commander, to
summon to His immortal legions our beloved comrade, Louis A. Johnson, who
served as National Executive Committeeman, Department Commander, and
National Commander in the year 1932-33. He was member, Vice President
and, at the time of his death, Director of the American Legion Endowment
Fund Corporation, having served on this Corporation since 1942.
WHEREAS, We humbly bow to the will of Divine Providence, while ever
cherishing in our hearts the memory of his distinguished service to our country and his outstanding contributions to American Legion comradeship:
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled on this May 4-5 in the year of our
Lord, nineteen hundred sixty-six, does mourn the passing of our distinguished Legionnaire, Louis A. Johnson; that we commend to all men his works,
and to God his spirit; and be it further
RESOLVED, That in token of our common grief, a copy of this resolution be presented to his family.
Farewell, dear Legionnaire—’twill not be long.
Thy work is done—now may peace rest with thee.
Thy kindly thoughts and deeds—they will live on.
This is not death—-’tis immortality.
Farewell, dear Legionnaire—the river winds and turns,
The cadence of thy song wafts near to me,
And now thou know’st the thing that all men learn;
There is no death—there’s immortality.
John J. Barnhardt
(North Carolina)
John J. Barnhardt, who served on several national committees, and since
1946 to the time of his death was a member of the Foreign Relations Commission.
L. Gooden Callaway
(Delaware)
L. Gooden Callaway, who served as Department Commander, as Department Service Officer since 1963, and as Vice Chairman of Area “B”, Rehabilitation Commission from 1965 until the time of his death.
Forrest G. Cooper
(Mississippi)
Forrest G. Cooper, who served on many Department Committees and National Commissions, as Department Commander, National Executive Committeeman and National Vice Commander.
Leland L. Day
(Colorado)
Leland L. Day, who served as Department Service Officer, Assistant Department Adjutant and at the time of his death was Department Adjutant.
Maj. Gen. George W. Fisher
(California)
Maj. Gen. George W. Fisher, who served on several commissions and committees and, at the time of his death, was a member of the National Security
Commission.
10
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Arthur Gabriel
(Oregon)
Arthur Gabriel, who at the time of his death was a member of the National Civil Defense Committee.
Delbert James Kenny
(Wisconsin)
Delbert James Kenny who served as Department Commander, National
Executive Committeeman and, at the time of his death was Vice Chairman
of the National Distinguished Guests Committee.
Edmond A. Littlefield
(Utah)
Edmond A. “Ted” Littlefield, who served as Department Commander,
National Executive Committeeman, on many commissions and committees, and
as National Vice Commander 1943-44.
W. Rex McCrosson
(New Jersey)
W. Rex McCrosson, who served as Department Commander, on many committees and commissions, both locally and nationally, and who at the time of
his death was a General Member, Area B, National Rehabilitation Commission.
Bert Florian Nowinski
(Indiana)
Bert Florian Nowinski, who served on several committees and commissions and at the time of his death was a member of the National Americanism Commission.
Edward M. White, Sr.
(Nevada)
Edward M. White, Sr., who served as Department Commander and at the
time of his death was a General Member, Area “E” National Child Welfare
Commission.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I now recognize Past National
Commander Griffith for the purpose of directing his remarks to the Memorial
Resolutions.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GRIFFITH:
Mr. Commander and
members of the National Executive Committee, I would like to take just a few
minutes of your time this morning to do honor and pay respect to an outstanding National Commander of The American Legion, and to an outstanding American citizen. I refer to Past National Commander Louis Johnson.
I knew him well as many of you also knew him. It was my privilege to
serve as Department Commander of Pennsylvania during his administration
as National Commander, along with Tom Miller who served that year as Commander of the Department of Delaware. Out of that relationship grew a
great friendship. I later served as his Executive Officer when he was the
Assistant Secretary of War. I served as his assistant when he was sent to
the Middle and Far East into India as a personal representative of the
President with the rank of Ambassador. And after the war, I served as the
Assistant Secretary of Defense when he was the Secretary, and so with this
association I believe I am qualified to say that I knew a man.
His death marks the passing of a truly great leader, a leader in his
home state, in his community, in his adopted state, and in the nation.
His record as a soldier, lawyer, legislator, diplomat, leader of veterans
and a policy maker for the Federal Government marked him as a great
American, and as a citizen of honor, and service. I valued his friendship
and his comradeship as I am sure those of you who knew him did.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
11
As National Commander of The American Legion Louis Johnson alerted
the American people to the growing threat from abroad, and he continued
this advice to the nation during his service as Assistant Secretary of War.
I am sure I can say without doubt that the casualty lists of World War II
and the length of that war would have been extended greatly if Louis Johnson had not had the foresight that he had.
The American Legion came first with him, above politics, above financial
gain or personal aggrandizement. Louis has gone to his final resting place,
but our nation must remain. For his great service The American Legion will
always perpetuate the memory of this distinguished Legionnaire.
He served long and well through tasks that were often very difficult,
and so I can say for all of us who loved him, farewell, Louis, there is a plan
far greater than we know, there is a landscape broader than the one we see.
There is a place where storm-tossed souls may go, some call it death, we call
it immortality. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman Tom Miller.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: National Commander James, fellow members of
the National Executive Committee and fellow Legionnaires, it has been my
sad privilege over the last year or so to take this rostrum to pay honor to
our departed leaders, Bill Stern, Louis Johnson, and James Ringley.
My first association with Louis Johnson was when we were members of
the National Executive Committee, he from West Virginia, and I from Delaware in the 1920s. As your Past National Commander Paul Griffith told
you, we both had the honor and distinction of being Department Commanders
in the year 1932 to 1933, and of course, we supported him in his successful
bid for election at the Portland Convention in 1932.
We had a particular association with Louis. With all due respect to the
splendid leaders of our organization that preceded him and have succeeded
him, in those days, when they had the national Distinguished Guests Dinner
at the National Convention, it was the province and the policy of the National Commander to invite to be seated with them at his table those of us
who were Department Commanders under his regime. And be it said to the
credit of Louis, and I am not detracting one bit from any of his predecessors
or successors, the tables of the 1933 class of the Department Commanders
had more guests than any other. The class of 1933 was a very distinctive
class under him.
In the succeeding years it was my privilege to not only know him, but
work in an official capacity that brought me to Washington. And that vacant
seat back there alongside of National Committeeman Bickel was where
Louis Johnson always sat. We were able to consult with him and he to consult with us. I can’t add any personal capacity more than Paul Griffith has
given you in homage to our great leader. He will be sorely missed not only
as a leader, but for me, as a great personal friend.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman L. O. Bickel.
MR. BICKEL, West Virginia: Commander James, members of this Executive Committee and guests, in 1954 when I was Department Commander
of West Virginia, I became acquainted with Louis Johnson the man. All
through the remaining years of his life when he was physically able, he gave
counsel and advice to us in The American Legion in West Virginia. And
I can truthfully say that Louis Johnson's interest in The American Legion
was well founded, and we looked upon him as a man who gave us that advice.
Many, many times he came to West Virginia and gave his aid financially
in The American Legion. I know that more than one Convention, when the
Convention would be short financially, Louis Johnson would pick up the tab,
and that is truly his spirit in The American Legion. And I can say that
all of the West Virginia people, Legionnaires have lost a great friend.
One thing that Louis Johnson was always proud of, and that was his
Department Commander from West Virginia. When we would go to Washington in respective years, regardless of whether it would be business with the
Legion or otherwise, Louis made it his business to show you around Washington. Thank you very much.
12
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Thank you, L. 0. I am sure
there are others that have deep feelings and thoughts in their minds this
morning. If any of you care later to have those brief feelings recorded in the
proceedings, you may do so.
I would simply say this, this man gave unlimited service and inspiration
to the organization he loved. This man gave incomparable service and devotion tp his country. The effect of that inspiration and service will be a glowing, living testimonial to his contribution to a better America. His absence
from us creates a void, but his memory will do much to fill it.
Gentlemen, I had hoped that this morning there would be three of Col.
Johnson’s fellow members of the first National Executive Committee present.
Two of them are here, the third one, Robert L. Moorhead, would have been
here. He is a young fellow, just 91 years old, but he suffered a fall this morning
a little while ago, and could not make it. But the other two members who
were a part of that original Committee and I believe these three are the
only three living ones at this time if my facts are correct are present in
the room, and I would like them to stand and take a bow on this solemn
occasion.
Tom Miller of Nevada, he was then of Delaware, and John J. Wicker,
Jr. of Virginia—would you gentlemen stand.
. , . Mr. Wicker and Mr. Miller stood and acknowledged their presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: It was mentioned that Col. Johnson had had a part in the Endowment Fund Corporation of The American
Legion. Present in this room this morning are certain members or directors
of that corporation. In a moment, I would ask them to stand and take a
bow, but before I do, I would like to officially call to the attention of this
Committee a recent and beautiful contribution that these gentlemen have personally made to The American Legion.
ENDOWMENT FUND MEETING ROOM
As you have moved back and forth down the third floor of this building,
you have seen a very, very beautiful room off to the right as you enter the
executive suite. This room as it now appears is the result of not only the
imagination and dreams of the members of this Corporation, but of their
specific individual and direct contribution, 100%, to make it possible. Any of
you who may have feared that the Chairman of the Finance Commission
may have been disturbed by this, your fears may be allayed. It cost the Legion not one penny. It is there because of the love and affection of the members of this Corporation, a contribution they have made. I think you should
know that.
At this time, I would like to ask the members of the Corporation, Harry
Colmery as the Chairman, to please stand and take a bow.
. . . Mr. Colmery and other members of the Endowment Corporation stood
and acknowledged their presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Harry, would you come forward,
please, if you would like a moment to address the group.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COLMERY: Mr. Commander and
gentlemen of the Executive Committee, before I comment on that which primarily moves me to rise, may I tell you that The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation Board of Directors and members gathered together
yesterday and adopted an appropriate memorial resolution in memory of Louis
Johnson.
On their behalf, I would not attempt following the eulogy paid by Tom
Miller, Paul Griffith and the Committeeman of West Virginia to repeat what
they have said. Of course, we knew him, and I knew him personally in that
great cornerstone of free society. The confidence and the exchange of views
and thoughts of his inquisitive mind, his dynamic leadership and his dedication not only to his country but to The American Legion and to the interests
of the veteran were 100%. We will miss him greatly, and we will always re-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
13
member his work in The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation,
and likewise The American Legion as such.
I am here only symbolic of The American Legion Endowment Fund
Corporation, its image and its members and Board of Directors. We got this
idea because sometimes our combinations were not too good, because we have
to devote ourselves with considerable dedication to the consideration of the
handling of this seven million, two hundred and some thousand dollar fund
which we have. We thought it would be a good idea first to provide a place
where we could meet in comfort, and then we got the idea also that while
we were doing it, maybe we should make something available likewise,
because we only use it at certain periods during the year, and we thought it
might be then better done than we might have otherwise done it, and make
it available for some other purposes, particularly for that of the National
Commander, because in certain instances, it would provide an excellent conference room and an excellent place to greet and meet and visit with people
interested in The American Legion as they come to Indianapolis.
I think, and this is not the time to do it, but since under the reorganization plan we no longer report to the National Executive Committee, there
may be a good deal of mystery about the Endowment Fund, but maybe on an
occasion, and this is not the day, as a change-over occurs in the membership
of this Committee, I am brazen enough to say that maybe we should report
to the Committee some of these days to let those of you who may not have
had the opportunity in the past to know about it, the origin and just what
we do, and why we do it presented to you. I am going to ask that privilege
one of these days before the National Executive Committee, because I think
it should be of current interest, and we should all be knowledgeable with
respect to what it is and what we do and why we do it.
I appreciate, Mr. Commander, your fine comment, and on behalf of the
members and the Board of Directors of the Endowment Fund Corporation
express to you our appreciation and our gratitude for your kindly compliments
which you have just made with respect to what we think is a fine contribution, the equipping and the establishing of this room on the third floor.
Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I direct to you and through you
to the members of the Corporation our thanks for this recent specific and
beautiful contribution, but more important, for the continued diligent work
that you perform on behalf of the organization. Thank you so much.
REPORT OF
THE FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
May 4-5, 1966
Albert V. LaBiche (Louisiana), Chairman
Pursuant to the provisions of Resolution No. 229, adopted by the Annual
National Convention of The American Legion in Portland, Oregon in August
1965, National Commander L. Eldon James appointed a 50th Anniversary
Committee in January 1966. Copy of Resolution No. 229 is attached, as is a
copy of the official roster of the committee members. Albert V. LaBiche,
Louisiana, was appointed Chairman; Donald E. Johnson, Iowa, Vice Chairman.
An Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee held its first
meeting in the Washington office of the National Headquarters at the time
of the Washington Conference on March 2 and 3, 1966. At that time a general
discussion was held concerning various projects, plans, and programs that
might be undertaken to appropriately commemorate the 50th anniversary of
Armistice Day, November 11, 1918, and the 50th anniversary of the founding
of The American Legion.
14
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
At that first meeting’ a number of initial decisions were made. Among
these was an agreement on the official dates of the 50th anniversary commemoration that will be observed. These are:
1. The 50th National Convention to be held in Milwaukee, Wisconsin in
1968.
2. Veterans’ Day, November 11, 1968 in Washington, D.C.
3. The 50th anniversary of the birthday of The American Legion—March
15-17, 1969.
4. The 50th anniversary of the St. Louis Caucus in May 1969.
5. The 50th anniversary of the First National Convention of The American Legion on Veterans’ Day, 1969.
It was decided to call on all Departments to appoint 50th Anniversary
Chairmen to work with the National Committee and to coordinate departmental and post participation in the 50th anniversary activities. This action
has been taken and a number of Department Chairmen have already been
appointed.
It was decided to suggest to the National Executive Committee that it hold
its regular meeting in May 1969 in St. Louis, Missouri, rather than Indianapolis, in connection with commemoration of the 50th anniversary of the St.
Louis caucus. A resolution to this effect has been prepared and presented
to the Resolutions Subcommittee, and will be presented following this report.
It was decided to recommend that a national observance of major proportions be held in Minneapolis on November 11, 1969 to commemorate the first
National Convention of The American Legion. It was also decided to ask the
President’s Advisory Committee on observance of Veterans’ Day, to designate Minneapolis as one of the regional centers for Veterans’ Day 1969
observance. A resolution to this effect has been prepared and is to be presented following this report.
It was decided that serious study and consideration should be given to
the advisability of employing outside public relations counsel to guide and
assist The American Legion in connection with observance of these most
important events.
A special subcommittee was appointed for this purpose and held a first
meeting in New York City in the office of The American Legion Magazine on
April 5 and 6, 1966. Chairman of the special subcommittee is Albert V. LaBiche, Louisiana. The special subcommittee met again in Indianapolis on
May 2 and 3 and received formal presentations from two major public relations firms. On the basis of these presentations, it was decided to submit
a firm recommendation to the National Executive Committee that the National Commander and National Adjutant be authorized to enter into a contract with the firm of Bozell and Jacobs, to retain that firm to guide and
assist The American Legion in connection with its 50th Anniversary observance. A resolution to that effect has been prepared and will be presented
following this report.
In its meeting in New York, the special subcommittee formalized the four
basic objectives The American Legion would seek to accomplish through its
50th Anniversary observance. These are:
1. The American Legion wishes to lead the nation in appropriate activities
commemorating the Armistice of November 11, 1918 and victory in World
War I.
2. The American Legion wishes to bring to the attention of the whole
American people the circumstances and events that led to the founding of
The American Legion and the significance of this fact within the perspective
of the historical moment in the life of the nation attending the close of
World War I.
3. The American Legion wishes to call to the attention of the American
people the record of achievements that have been accomplished by The American Legion during the fifty years since its founding, to emphasize the impact the organization has had upon the American society, and the extent of
its contribution to the national security and welfare.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
15
4. The American Legion wishes to set forth the objectives and the aims
that will motivate its programs and activities during the years ahead and to
illustrate the contribution it is intended these activities will make to the future
of our country.
A further meeting of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee was held in Indianapolis on May 2 and 3. At this time there was
further review of plans and preparations for observance of the 50th anniversary. These are many and varied, and it is felt that a more detailed report should be submitted at a later date as the Committee’s work takes more
definite form.
In conclusion, the Committee would report to the National Executive Committee that it has found vast enthusiasm within the ranks of The American
Legion for an appropriate observance of the organization’s 50th anniversary.
There is every hope that national participation from all segments of the
country can be arranged.
Representatives of the 50th Anniversary Committee have called upon the
National Finance Commission to discuss the matter of appropriation of national funds to assist the Committee to accomplish its work. The Finance
Commission was receptive to a recitation of initial plans and indicated that an
effort would be made to find necessary funds, contingent upon authority
and approval that may be extended by the National Executive Committee.
It is hoped that a full meeting of the 50th Anniversary Committee can
be called to be held at the time of the Washington, D. C. National Convention in August, 1966. At that time it is also contemplated that Department Chairmen will be invited to attend such a meeting at no expense to the
National Organization.
Respectfully submitted,
ALBERT V. LaBICHE, Chairman
“Creation of A Special Committee to Formulate Plans For Observance
of 50th Anniversary of The American Legion and Also the Entry of
United States Into First World War”
Resolution No. 229 (Submitted by: The Fiftieth Anniversary Committee).
WHEREAS, The year 1967 will mark the 50th anniversary of the entry
of the United States into the Great War, now known as World War I, and
The American Legion had its inception through the foresight of the participants of that war; and
WHEREAS, It is fitting and proper that we commemorate the Declaration
of War, the heroic deeds of our Armed Forces, and the Armistice that followed, by appropriate observances, and at the same time give recognition
to the 50th anniversary of the founding of The American Legion; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled
in Portland, Oregon, August 24-26, 1965, that the National Organization form
a special temporary committee to formulate plans for the observance of these
great dates in our history, and to disseminate such to all Posts in order
that suitable ceremonies may be arranged well in advance of the respective
anniversary date.
50TH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
(To serve until completion of planning and final report on commemoration.)
CHAIRMAN—-Albert V. LaBiche, 301 Baronne Street, New Orleans,
Louisiana 70112
VICE CHAIRMAN—Donald E. Johnson, Drawer A, West Branch, Iowa
52358
Alfred P. Chamie, 8480 Beverly Boulevard, Los Angeles, California
90048
William R. Egan, 304 West Prospect Avenue, Danville, California 94526
(Colorado)
16
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
C. D. DeLoaeh, 1109 Morningside Lane, Alexandria, Virginia 22308
(District of Columbia)
Frank A. Kelly, P. 0. Box 1363, Savannah, Georgia 31402
A. L. Starshak, 7221 South Luella Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60649
Robert E. Gates, 701 West Park Drive, Columbia City, Indiana 46725
Ray Murphy, 15671 Peach Hill Road, Saratoga, California 95070 (Iowa)
Harry W. Colmery, 138 Greenwood, Topeka, Kansas 66606
David Aronberg, P. O. Box 591, Ashland, Kentucky 41101
Frank L. Orfanello, 2 Shenandoah Street, Dorchester, Massachusetts
02124
Donald J. Smith, Route 3, French Road, St. Johns, Michigan 48879
Daniel F. Foley, P. O. Box 228, Wabasha, Minnesota 55981
Joseph A. Bernard, 5549 Pershing Avenue, St. Louis, Missouri 63112
Milton Carpenter, 1640 Grape, St. Louis, Missouri 63147
William E. Galbraith, RFD 1, Beemer, Nebraska 68716
Frank R. Schwengel, Artillery Lane, Scarsdale, New York 10584
Maurice Stember, 305 Hall of Records, 31 Chambers Street, New York,
New York 10007
The Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, 658 East 32nd Street, Brooklyn, New
York 11210
John E. Davis, 216 West Owens Avenue, Bismarck, North Dakota 58501
Hollis C. Hull, P. O. Box 63586, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73106
Robert H. Hazen, Franklin Building, S. W. 5th and Stark, Portland,
Oregon 97204
Paul H. Griffith, Suite 1010, Shoreham Building, Washington, D. C.
20005 (Pennsylvania)
Sam L. Latimer, Jr., 703 Barringer Building, Columbia, South Carolina
29201
Albert D. Brown, Jr., Ill West Laurel, Suite 223, San Antonio, Texas
78212
Clarence S. Campbell, 50 Garden Street, Barre, Vermont 35801
E. Ralph James, P. O. Box 38, Hampton, Virginia 23369
Emmett G. Lenihan, 1114 Norton Building, Seattle, Washington 98104
Bernard Strachota, 4370 Imperial Drive, Brookfield, Wisconsin 53005
HONORARY VICE CHAIRMEN
Paul R. Baldwin, National President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 1166 Whittier, Grosse Pointe Park, Michigan 48230
Gen. Lawrence H. Whiting, Past Natl. President, Society of American
Legion Founders, 1500 Lake Shore Dr., Chicago, Illinois 60611
Gale F. Johnston, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 3 Brentmoor Park, St. Louis, Missouri 63105
Frank R. Schwengel, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, Artillery Lane, Scarsdale, New York 10584
Alvin M. Owsley, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 1424 Davis Bldg., Dallas, Texas 75202
John J. Wicker, Jr., Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 706 Mutual Bldg., Richmond, Virginia 23219
Jerome F. Duggan, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 705 Chestnut St., St. Louis, Missouri 63101
EXECUTIVE SECTION
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire (Chairman)
Donald E. Johnson, Iowa (Vice Chairman)
Alfred P. Chamie, California
William R. Egan, Colorado
C. D. DeLoaeh, District of Columbia
Daniel F. Foley, Minnesota
Joseph Bernard, Missouri
Milton Carpenter, Missouri
William E. Galbraith, Nebraska
Maurice Stember, New York
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
17
John E. Davis, North Dakota
Hollis Hull, Oklahoma
Robert Hazen, Oregon
Paul H. Griffith, Pennsylvania
E. Ralph James, Virginia
Bernard Strachota, Wisconsin
EX-OFFICIO MEMBERS
E. A. Blackmore, Wyoming
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire
Churchill Williams (National Finance Comm. (Iowa))
Wilbur Walker, Virginia
AUXILIARY LIAISON
Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, National President, American Legion Auxiliary,
777 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 (Iowa)
Miss Doris Anderson, National Secretary, American Legion Auxiliary,
777 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 (Texas)
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: First of all, I would
like to move the adoption of the written report as corrected with the substitution of James O’Neil as Chairman of the Special Subcommittee.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard, Connecticut.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion is to adopt and it has
been seconded. Any comments?
Commander Johnson, would you like to address your remarks to the Committee?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: Yes. Thank you, Mr.
Commander. Members of the National Executive Committee and Chairman
LaBiche, the reason for the move to adopt the report I think to me is most
important, because if you vote affirmatively on the adoption of the report
you have then determined the objectives of The American Legion in carrying
out the resolution which you passed at the National Convention in Portland.
I think it is only proper that these objectives be clearly defined and clearly articulated so that the whole country may know the role that The American Legion has played in 50 years of service to God and Country.
It says in the report, and I call them to your attention specifically, that
The American Legion wishes to lead the nation in appropriate activities commemorating the Armistice of November 11, 1918 and victory in World War I;
Two, that The American Legion wishes to bring to the attention of all the
American people the circumstances and events that led to the founding of
The American Legion and the significance of this fact within the perspective of the historical movement in the life of the nation attending the
close of World War I.
Three, for once we are going to toot our own horn, The American Legion
wishes to call to the attention of the American people the records and achievements and accomplishments by our organization during these last 50 years.
I had often said from the podium and I sincerely believe it, that no other
organization in the United States has had such a profound impact upon the
social, economic and political life of this nation as has The American Legion.
And now we have the vehicle to tell the American people what we have done.
And this brings me to the fourth point then in the report and the fourth
objective.
That is that after we gather all of this information, after we bring it to
the American people and as we digest it ourselves, I think that we shall then
be able to determine what our aims will be in the years to come, and in the
decades ahead, determine the role of The American Legion.
Thus, gentlemen of this Committee, I urge you to adopt the report so
that we first of all specify the dates as the Chairman has articulated to
you, and secondly, to make the definition of the objectives of what we plan
to do in this area.
18
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Don.
Now, is there any further discussion on the motion to adopt the report?
Hearing none, are you ready for the question? Those in favor signify by
saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes have it and the report is adopted.
Mr. Stone.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
. .. Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Commemoration of Fiftieth Anniversary of First American Legion
National Convention in Minneapolis, Minnesota”
Resolution No. 15 (Submitted by: Special 50th Anniversary Committee.
(Subject to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the 50th Anniversary of The American Legion will occur in
the year 1969; and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention of The American Legion, meeting in Portland, Oregon in August 1965, directed that a special committee be appointed by the National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, such special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed,
and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies be
arranged in Minneapolis, Minnesota on November 11, 1969, commemorating at
such time both the Armistice ending the First World War, and the 50th Anniversary of the First Annual National Convention of The American Legion
held in the City of Minneapolis in November 1919; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this committee
concurs with such recommendation; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Executive Committee authorizes and directs that appropriate ceremonies and other activities be arranged for November 11, 1969 to commemorate at such time the two significant events referred
to above; and be it further
RESOLVED, that a communication be directed to the Administrator of
Veterans Affairs in his capacity as Chairman of the President’s coordinating committee for the observance of Veterans Day, requesting that committee
to designate Minneapolis, Minnesota as one of the regional locations for the
official national observance of Veterans Day 1969.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida, and adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: The next resolution is No. 14,
and, Mr. Commander, for the benefit of the Reporter who is taking the records of this meeting, may he show that the time of this first reading is now
10:50 A. M. May 4th. This is pursuant to Rule 8-A of this Committee. The
resolution reads as follows:
“50th Anniversary Observance of the Founding of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 14 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the year 1969 will be the 50th anniversary year of the founding of The American Legion, and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary, and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
19
WHEREAS, such a special 50th Anniversary Committee has been so appointed, and
WHEREAS, an Executive Section of said 50th Anniversary Committee
has held meetings on March 2 and 3, and May 2 and 3, and
WHEREAS, it is the consensus of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee that it would be to the best interests of The American
Legion to retain the services of a public relations firm to guide and assist
The American Legion with its 50th anniversary observance, and
WHEREAS, the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee
has considered presentations from public relations firms and has a specific
recommendation for the employment of such firm at an agreed cost in fees,
out-of-pocket expenses, and certain other additional costs, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana on May 4 and 5, 1966, that the National
Commander and the National Adjutant are hereby authorized and directed to
negotiate, with the guidance and approval of The American Legion Special
50th Anniversary Committee, and to execute a contract with the public relations and advertising firm of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc., said contract to extend over a period to conclude approximately December 31, 1969, with necessary stipulations for cancellation by either party in accordance with conditions of sound business practice, and be it further
RESOLVED that in consideration of services to be rendered by Bozell
and Jacobs, Inc. which services are to be set forth in all necessary detail in
said contract, The American Legion will agree to pay to the firm of Bozell
and Jacobs, Inc. agency fees not to exceed $250,000.00 during the life of said
contract, and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall also provide for reimbursement to
representatives of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. for out-of-pocket expenses not to
exceed $44,000.00 specifically required by The American Legion and incurred
in the service of The American Legion, said expenses to be itemized and
submitted at regular intervals for audit and prior approval by the National
Adjutant and National Treasurer of The American Legion prior to payment,
and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall further provide that the firm of
Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. will submit to The American Legion at regular intervals complete and itemized statements justifying all agency fees, out-ofpocket expenses, and any other charges to be provided for in said contract,
and be it further
RESOLVED that the National Executive Committee does authorize and
direct the 50th Anniversary Committee to determine and recommend such other sum or sums that may be necessary, not to exceed $50,000.00, in connection with the 50th anniversary observance to be used for projects and programs requiring material expenditures such as materials for Post and Departmental participation, radio, TV, film, newspaper, and all other types of
suitable publicity, and that such recommendation or recommendations be submitted to the National Executive Committee as soon as possible for its consideration, and be it further
RESOLVED that the 50th Anniversary Committee is charged by the National Executive Committee to exercise close supervision and guidance of all
activities involving the 50th anniversary observance and the expenditures of
American Legion monies therefor, with reports at regular intervals to the
National Executive Committee and to the Finance Commission, and be it
further
RESOLVED that the National Finance Commission is requested to provide for necessary funds for the expenses of the 50th Anniversary Committee to enable it to fulfill the charge herein set forth, and be it further
RESOLVED that prior to the completion of the contract authorized herein, such contract shall have the approval as to form from the National Judge
Advocate.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee shall move
that this matter be approved, and I shall wait to make the official motion at
20
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
the appropriate time that the Commander might set upon the agenda for four
hours, pursuant to the four-hour rule of 8-A.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, under Rule 8-A this
matter being one that affects fiscal policy must be considered under two
readings and the second must be at least four hours after the first.
Now in order for this to be proper and to be handled according to the
rules, it is required that you have a written copy of this resolution on your
desk. I would like to first make an inquiry to the body, is there any member
of the Committee present in this room who does not have a copy, a written
copy of the resolution on his desk?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: The resolution separately?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The resolution from the digest,
Resolution No. 14.
MR. McKINLEY: All right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let the record show that upon inquiry there was no report of absence from any desk, so we will assume that
each of you have a copy in accordance with the rule 8-A.
MR. LOUNSBERRY (Iowa): Mr. Commander, I move you that this resolution be made a special order of business before this Committee at 3:30
this afternoon.
... The motion was seconded by Mr. Grauberger, Colorado, and adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we have a
companion resolution which is No. 17 which is also subject to Rule 8-A of this
body, and I ask that the records show that the reading of this resolution took
place at 11:00 A. M.
“Commemoration of 50th Anniversary of St. Louis, Missouri, Caucus
of The American Legion.”
Resolution No. 17 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, The year 1969 will be the 50th Anniversary year of the
founding of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, Such a special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed, and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies
be arranged in St. Louis, Missouri in May 1969 in commemoration of the
St. Louis Caucus of May 1919; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed fitting and proper that the National Executive
Committee should hold its constitutionally ordained meeting in May 1969 in
the city of the founding of this organization; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this Committee, for reasons good and proper, shall hold its regular meeting in May
1969 in the City of St. Louis, Missouri; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Adjutant is hereby directed to make the
necessary arrangements, and to communicate to the National Finance Commission an estimate of expenses involved so that necessary funds for this
purpose may be provided; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this Committee shall cooperate in every way possible
with the 50th Anniversary Committee in connection with suitable ceremonies
and other activities honoring the City of St. Louis and commemorating the
founding of The American Legion in May 1919.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, the record
shows that it is now three minutes past 11:00 A. M. Your Committee shall
move to have this resolution approved after the four hours wait, and I ask
that this be included, sir, in a special order of business at 3:30 P. M.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
21
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Did you so move?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE : I will make that motion.
. . . The motion was seconded by Past National Commander Quinn and
adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE:
This completes the reading
of the resolutions of the 50th Anniversary Committee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much, Roy.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL PUBLIC RELATIONS COMMISSION
C. D. DeLoach (District of Columbia), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN DE LOACH: Mr. Commander, members of
the National Executive Committee and fellow Legionnaires. This is the report
on Public Relations. This is not a report asking for money. My report is to
be brief.
The National Public Relations Commission has handled considerable work
within the past two days.
The American Legion National Public Relations Commission met in Room
106, National Headquarters, The American Legion, Indianapolis, Indiana, on
May 2 and 3. Chairman C. D. DeLoach called the meeting to order. The
following members were authorized and present:
C. D. DeLoach, Chairman (District of Columbia)
Sam L. Latimer, Jr.. Vice Chairman (South Carolina)
Madison B. Graves (Nevada)
Louis J. Greco (Pennsylvania)
Arthur McDowell (Indiana)
A1 Weinberg (California)
Paul R. Greenaway (Florida)
Lem W. Houston (Virginia)
Phillip A. Thomas (Iowa)
Frank A. Kelly (Georgia)
Ward Husted (Wyoming)
Harold A. Cummins (Illinois)
NEC Liaison: Donald E. Johnson, Chairman (Iowa)
Also in attendance:
Duane T. Brigstock (Michigan)
Sexson Humphreys (Italy)
We discussed and made plans regarding the future handling of internal
public relations in The American Legion. We made plans to make even better
improvements in the American Legion News Service. We chose three worthy
and notable recipients of the Fourth Estate Award to be given at this
year’s National Convention in Washington, D. C.
We covered in its entirety the successes of the Public Relations at this
year’s Annual Commander’s Conference in Washington, D. C. The luncheon
honoring Leonard H. Goldenson, President, American Broadcasting Company
has not only brought The American Legion added prestige, but also established
for us a new and strong ally in the communications media. Now this conference saw once again the value of setting up TV and radio programs with
an ever-increasing number of Senators and Representatives from your home
states.
But, gentlemen, with your permission, I would like to devote the rest of
my brief allotted time to one topic, that of “The American Legion Story.”
This project is almost completed. The manuscript is in the hands of the publisher. Here is the front cover of it. I am holding up a sample version of it
which you will be seeing across America within just a few weeks from now.
As a matter of fact, the issuance date of our History, “The American Legion Story,” will be on August 15th, 1966 in ample time for our National
Convention.
22
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
The sale price for non-Legionnaires will be $4.95; the Legionnaires, a
reduced price of $3.95, and if you buy in bulk form or 500 or more we will
have further reductions.
“The American Legion Story” will be told in over five hundred exciting
pages, factually based pages upon our history. We are now rapidly completing
the final reading of the galley proofs.
A number of the distinguished and history steeped members, I might say,
of this Executive Committee, the National Executive Committee, are assisting
us in this regard. I will tell you very frankly, we are very proud of this book.
The National Public Relations Commission has worked long and hard and
at great personal sacrifice to have your story told in the best manner possible, and I might say at this moment, we are very proud, very proud to tell
the story of such patriotic giants as Louis Johnson who you have honored in
great memorial tribute here today, and others, Tom Miller, Bill McKinley,
Harry Colmery, John Wicker, and many, many others which are told throughout this exciting factual history of The American Legion, “The American
Legion Story.”
Let me put this on the record, everyone’s name could not be brought out
prominently; everyone’s pet incident could not be mentioned in the interests
of space. There may be a few hurt feelings, but in the glory of our organization and in the manner in which you have played a great part, and many
of you have played a great part in establishing the glory of this organization,
it is demonstrated throughout.
Let me at this time take sixty seconds of your time to read you the foreword of this book:
“The American Legion is truly an American institution, in origin, purpose and operation. Born from America’s struggle to maintain liberty in
World War I, The American Legion has become an inextricable part of the
American story. Every patriotic citizen, from Anchorage to Miami, from
Honolulu to Boston, salutes the brave men and women of the Legion—men
and women whose exploits in war and peace have placed their fellow countrymen eternally in their debt.
“In addition, Legionnaires have taken America’s youth to heart. Highly
effective youth programs, such as Boys State and Nation, the National High
School Oratorical Contest, American Legion Baseball, have touched the lives
of thousands of our boys and girls. Here is an affirmation of good citizenship, a belief that every person in a free society has not only rights and
privileges but also duties and responsibilities. Many of our national leaders
today have been influenced by the positive Americanism of The American
Legion.
“Above all, The American Legion is a symbol for other citizens—a symbol
meaning faith in liberty. Americans see in The American Legion an organization of devoted men and women, working for country above self, for service
to others over selfish, partisan and narrow interests. This is an influence
which is felt not only nationally, but in every state, city, town and hamlet
of these United States.
“ ‘The American Legion History’ by Raymond Moley, Jr., is an excellent
book. It sets forth, with skill and precision, the history of this great organization. American citizens in all walks of life should know more about The
American Legion. To read Mr. Moley’s interesting narrative is to relive the
history of our nation in this mid-twentieth century.”
Signed, J. Edgar Hoover.
Gentlemen, the remainder of this book, I assure you, is equally as stirring
and factually correct as the foreword I have just read to you.
Now to just take 15 more seconds of our report, I turn to another topic
briefly. I understand as Chief of Investigations for the FBI, that the FBI
is having slight difficulty, only slight, I remind you, in establishing the
identity of certain fugitives and distinguished world travelers from the Sovereign State of Virginia. The FBI is constantly on the lookout to solve this
problem, and we wish at this time to personally brand and identify one of
the fastest moving and distinguished fugitives of all American history, the
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
23
man from Hampton, “El” James. Towards this purpose, the National
Public Relations Commission takes pride in presenting Commander “El” a
pair of specially made cuff links made from his own distinctive fingerprints.
He will be forevermore an easy target of identity.
... At this time Mr. DeLoach presented cuff links to National Commander
James.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I might say that I am grateful
that this imprint is from fingerprints rather than from noses, because if the
second were true, I am afraid the cuff links would be so large they would
be a burden to carry.
In addition to the joy, they will be a constant reminder not only of the
close friendship and wonderful working relationship with your part of the
organization, but a constant reminder of a great arm of our Government so
important at this time. Thank you.
C. D. DE LOACH: Mr. Commander, that completes my report, thank you
very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
William C. Doyle (New Jersey), Chairman
The following members of the National Security Commission and Committees met in the fourth floor auditorium of the Department of Indiana
Headquarters May 2-3, 1966:
William C. Doyle, New Jersey, Chairman
Hugh W. Overton, Alabama, NEC Liaison Chairman
John E. Davis, North Dakota, Vice Chairman
Roseoe Turner, Indiana
E. Ralph Janies, Virginia
Norman Lyons, California
Charles Gibbons, Illinois
Les Lam, Virginia
Elmer Kuhlmann, Missouri
Stacey Garner, Tennessee
Ralph Watkins, Arizona, NEC
Earnest N. Schmit, North Dakota
William A. Lindsay, Montana, NEC
Roseoe Morse, California
Granville S. Ridley, Tennessee
Joseph Caracci, Illinois
Clifford Cowan, New York
Charles Lugar, Missouri
Alexander N. Branch, Virginia
Robert H. Bush, Iowa
Frank R. Kossa, Indiana
Leon Myers, Georgia
James R. Wilson, Pennsylvania, Director
The importance of the widening struggle in Viet Nam in relation to Communism’s present and future plans has been clear to The American Legion.
Our policies and programs have constantly warned that Viet Nam is the testing ground for so-called “wars of liberation” which, if successful, will be
intensified in every now free country in the world. The ultimate objective
would be world domination; the oft stated goal of international atheistic
Communism.
The National Security Commission took a critical view of the manner in
which the war in Viet Nam is being waged. Over-control of our fighting men
has placed serious restraints on their ability to fight to win. We firmly
believe if our forces, ever increasing in numbers, are to remain committed
in Viet Nam, they should be directed toward military victory. This, in turn,
should provide a more promising basis for discussions leading to peace in
that beleaguered nation.
24
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Contrary to the opinion of groups opposing our nation’s participation in
Viet Nam, The American Legion does not view the conflict there as a civil
war. The aggression was and is clearly Communist inspired, initiated and
supported.
Wars are never pleasant, and mounting casualty lists are a source of
heartache, yet sacrifice is the continuing price free men pay to halt the ambitions of evil men.
We commend the men and women of our Armed Forces for carrying out
their assignments around the world, especially in Viet Nam. Thank God
that the overwhelming majority of young Americans are accepting the responsibilities of citizenship by entering the Armed Forces without fanfare.
Their conduct, as contrasted to the draft dodging, card burning characters
who defile both flag and country, warrants our heartfelt thanks and appreciation.
The truly magnificent performance of elements of the Air National
Guard’s Troop Carrier Command, in support of our troops in Viet Nam, is a
matter of record. It is puzzling indeed and difficult to equate their recent
accomplishments with the decision to deactivate these three Heavy Transport
units and eight squadrons of Air Force Reserve Troop Carriers. From all indications, no diminution of need has occurred or appears in the offing to
justify such action and we are opposed to it.
The National Security Commission reiterated its support for the development and deployment at the earliest possible date of the anti-missile system,
an advanced manned strategic bomber to replace the B-52’s and B-58’s
being phased out of our Air Force. In testimony presented to the House Appropriations Committee on the 1967 Defense Appropriations last week The
American Legion spokesman, in urging the development of these vital weapon
systems, said:
“No one will question the fact that a military budget approaching $60
billion is large. Yet for a rich nation with a gross national product near
$700 billion annually, needed weapon systems which could provide an added
margin of safety and security should not be rejected or deferred by virtue of
cost alone. Evidence seems to indicate, however, that the contrary is true,
which recalls to mind the words of Sir Winston Churchill:
‘“We shall not fail or falter; we shall not weaken or tire. Neither the
sudden shock of battle nor the long-drawn trials of vigilance and exertion will
wear us down. Give us the tools and we will finish the job.’ ”
We feel this same admonition applies “across the board” to ammunition,
training, equipment and whatever other requirements our servicemen need
to fulfill their assigned mission, particularly in Viet Nam.
The American Legion is of the firm opinion that this is not a time to
weaken our defense in the name and for the sake of economy. If trim we
must, let it be in non-defense spending where the need does not relate itself
directly to the present and future security of our nation.
. . . National Vice Commander Choppin assumed the chair.
MR. DOYLE : Mr. Commander, that ends my report.
. . . The portion of the report in regard to resolutions is as follows:
Approved
Resolution No. 3—“Oppose the closing of the United States Armory in
Springfield, Massachusetts.”
Resolution No. 4—“Commending General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of
Selective Service System.”
Resolution No. 5-—“Name next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier for the late Fleet
Admiral Chester W. Nimitz.”
Resolution No. 9—“Support passage of S.2351 to protect harassment of
families of servicemen in Viet Nam.”
Resolution No. 13—“Support legislation proposed by Department of Defense and the Bolte Committee to provide uniformity for improvement of
career opportunities in the military services.”
Proceedings of Wednesday, May h, 1966
25
Resolution No. 21—“Reserve Training.”
Resolution No. 22—“Defense Department Policy in Viet Nam.”
Register No. 1221 (Wisconsin)—“Commending Men Who Accept Their
Obligations in the Armed Forces by Enlistment or Call of Draft.” Approved
in principle.
Referred
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts)—“Bestow Posthumously the Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John F. Kennedy.” Approved
in principle but not for Medal of Honor. Referred to Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonies Committee with Recommendation that he be considered for American Legion’s Distinguished Service Medal.
Held For Further Study
Register No. 1097 (Massachusetts)—“Armed Services Retirement Policies.”
Resolutions 364, 366 and 525 are being held for further study by the Promotions Subcommittee.
Resolutions 87 (Massachusetts), 193 (Nevada), 264 (Georgia), 300 (Tennessee), 365 (Maryland), 472 (New York), and 524 (Virginia)—“Manpower
Procurement for Armed Forces.” Held for further study by the Manpower
Subcommittee.
Rejected
Register No. 1229 (New York); Register No. 1250 (Pennsylvania)—“Destruction of Selective Service Draft Cards.” Rejected as moot as law (PL
89-152 has been passed providing penalties for destruction of draft cards).
Register No. 1222 (Ohio)—“Realignment of Army Reserve Components
Opposed.” Resolution No. 587 adopted by the 1965 Portland National Convention is substantially same as this resolution.
Register No. 1164 (New Jersey)—“20th Anniversary Observance of Raising the Stars and Stripes on Mt. Suribachi (Iwo Jima), February 1965.”
Received too late for consideration other than by the May 1965 meetings of
NEC which followed 20th Anniversary celebration. The American Legion was,
however, represented by four members of Washington Office at ceremonies
held by Marine Corps on this anniversary in 1965.
Register No. 1153 (New Jersey)—“Misuse of Armed Services Ribbons and
Medals.” Rejected as moot by virtue of adoption of Resolutions 390 and 427
at the Dallas National Convention in 1964.
Register No. 1251 (Pennsylvania)—“Asking Selective Service System to
Provide Best Transportation possible for men being sent for Physical Examination and Induction.”
ADVANCE REPORT OF
THE NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
The National Security Commission has met only once since the Fall, 1965
meeting of the National Executive Committee. This was in Washington, D. C.,
March 1, 2, and 3, 1966.
There was, however, a very small meeting of a Subcommittee on Manpower on Sunday and Monday, February 27 and 28, 1966. The Committee,
appointed from among the membership of the National Security Commission
plus' two Past National Commanders as consultants, was to determine the
present attitude of Congress, the Selective Service System and the Armed
Forces on (1) Universal Military Training and (2) Extension of Selective
Service, which expires in July of next year.
26
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
During its two day meeting the Committee, comprised of Granville S.
Ridley, Chairman, Emmett G. Lenihan and Henry C. Parke; members and Past
National Commanders S. Perry Brown and Erie Cocke, Jr., met with General
Lewis B. Hershey, Director, Selective Service System; Senator John Stennis,
Senate Armed Services Committee; Congressman Leslie Arends, Congressman
Charles E. Bennett, House Armed Services Committee; and representatives
of Assistant Secretary of Defense (Manpower) Thomas D. Morris; General
J. B. Lampart and General Jefferson Irvine.
To the National Security Commission during its business session Thursday, March 3rd, Chairman Ridley reported these principal points:
1. That contacts with Defense, Congress and Selective Service had alerted
them to American Legion interest and activity in manpower problems
generally.
2. Ascertained through meetings with National President Opal Glynn that
the American Legion Auxiliary would lend its support if a favorable
climate of opinion on Universal Military Training was established.
3. The American Legion should support no less than a four (4) year extension of Selective Service.
4. Urged the continuance of the Committee in order to fulfill its assigned
mission.
NOTE: This recommendation No. 4 was approved by the National
Security Commission.
The importance of airpower, the state of America’s Merchant Marine,
Viet Nam and other vital aspects of our national defense were discussed during the 3-day meetings of the National Security Commission in Washington.
Among the speakers were some of America’s foremost spokesmen from the
military, Congress, government and the private sector.
On March 1, members of the National Security Commission journeyed to
the Industrial College of the Armed Forces, Fort McNair, Washington, D. C.
Lt General August Schomburg, Commandant, and members of his staff were
host to more than 100 members of the National Security Commission and
Committees headed by Chairman William C. Doyle, New Jersey, and Vice
Chairman John E. Davis, North Dakota. The all day session included briefings on military forces of the principal world powers, the Far East and
geopolitics.
Highlighting the second day was an hour long discussion of U. S. airpower,
missiles and nuclear weapons by General Thomas S. Power, USAF, recently
retired Commander of the Strategic Air Command and Personal Representative of the National Commander on the National Security Commission. Representing the Armed Forces were: Admiral Horacio R. Rivero, Jr., USN, Vice
Chief of Naval Operations; LT. General Hewitt T. Wheless, Assistant Vice
Chief of Staff, U. S. Air Force and LT. General John L. Throckmorton, former
Deputy Commander-in Chief, U. S. Forces in Viet Nam. Other speakers included: Congressman Melvin R. Laird (Wisconsin) a ranking member of the
House Appropriations Committee; Dr. James D. Atkinson, Associate Professor of Government at Georgetown University, and John C. Broger, Director of
Armed Forces Information and Education for the Department of Defense.
On March 3rd, civil defense to space exploration was covered by such
high ranking government officials as: Franklin B. Dryden, Acting Director,
Office of Emergency Planning; Congressman Edward A. Garmatz (Maryland), Chairman of the House Committee on Merchant Marine & Fisheries;
and Milton Rosen, Senior Scientist to the Deputy Associate Administrator for
Defense Affairs, National Space Agency.
The closing session of the Legion’s Security Commission meetings heard
a free and open discussion on Military Manpower and Reserve Forces. Top
military experts on the Reserve Components included Brig. Gen. Jefferson
Irvine, USA, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs;
Brig. Gen. Thomas A. Kenan, USA, Deputy Chief, Office of Reserve Components, USA, Major General James F. Cantwell, President, National Guard
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
27
Association, and Admiral Jackson, representing the Reserve Officers Association.
During the business session Thursday afternoon the Commission was privileged to receive an excellent briefing as to why the Springfield Armory, Massachusetts should not be closed by Charles V. Ryan, Jr., Mayor, Henry T
Downey, Consultant and James Massa.
Reports were also received from Granville S. Ridley, Chairman of the
Committee on Manpower and Joseph Hodges, Chairman of the Committee on
Promotions. These two ad hoc committees were appointed at the October
Meetings in Indianapolis.
The National Security Commission considered 12 resolutions. The action
which it will recommend to the National Executive Committee on these resolutions is appended to this report.
RESOLUTIONS CONSIDERED BY THE NATIONAL SECURITY
COMMISSION-COMMITTEES DURING THE WASHINGTON
CONFERENCE, March 1-3, 1966
Approved
Unnumbered Resolution—“Commend Lt. General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service System.”
Unnumbered Resolution—“Next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier be Named for
the late Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz.”
Unnumbered Resolution—“Support Legislation Incorporating Bolte Proposals.”
Register No. 1221 (Wisconsin)—“Commending Men Who Accept Their
Obligations in the Armed Forces by Enlistment or Call of Draft.” Approved
m principle for incorporation in report of National Security Commission
to May 1966 NEC.
Unnumbered Resolution—“Springfield Armory.” Approved in principle.
Incorporate in Statement of Policy, NSC Report to May NEC.
Referred
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts)—“Bestow Posthumously the Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John F. Kennedy.” Approved
in principle but not for Medal of Honor. Referred to Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonies Committee with recommendation that he be considered for American Legion’s Distinguished Service Medal.
Held For Further Study
Register No. 1097 (Massachusetts)'—“Armed Services Retirement Policies.” Resolutions 364, 366 and 525 are being held for further study by the
Promotions Subcommittee.
Resolutions 87 (Massachusetts), 193 (Nevada), 264 (Georgia), 300 (Tennessee), 365 (Maryland), 472 (New York) and 524 (Virginia). “Manpower
Procurement for Armed Forces.” Held for further study by the Manpower
Subcommittee.
Rejected
Register No. 1229 (New York)—“Destruction of Selective Service Draft
Cards.” Rejected as moot as law (PL 89-152) has been passed providing
penalties for destruction of draft cards.
Register No. 1222 (Ohio)—-“Realignment of Army Reserve Components
Opposed.” Resolution 587 adopted by the 1965 Portland National Convention
is substantially same as this resolution.
Register No. 1164 (New Jersey)—“20th Anniversary Observance of Raising the Stars and Stripes on Mt. Suribachi (Iwo Jima), February 1965.”
Received too late for consideration other than by the May 1965 meetings
of NEC which followed 20th Anniversary celebration. The American Legion
was, however, represented by four members of Washington Office at ceremonies held by Marine Corps on this anniversary in 1965.
28
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Register No. 1153 (New Jersey)—“Misuse of Armed Services
Medals.” Rejected as moot by virtue of adoption of Resolutions
at the Dallas National Convention in 1964.
Upon motion by Mr. Overton, Alabama, seconded by Mr.
Carolina, the report was received and filed.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Mr. Stone,
any resolutions?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
Ribbons and
390 and 427
Stone, South
do you have
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
. . . Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions
which were unanimously adopted as amended:
“Oppose the Closing of the United States Armory in Springfield,
Massachusetts”
Resolution No. 3 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense on November 19, 1964 ordered
the U. S. Armory, Springfield, Massachusetts “phased out” as an economy
measure, and
WHEREAS, The personnel of said Armory disputed this economy move,
providing evidence that this was not an economical move, and
WHEREAS, Booz, Allen and Hamilton Company, private consultants hired
to investigate the Armory problem, substantiated Armory figures showing
said Armory to be equal to or more efficient than outside contractors, and
WHEREAS, Booz, Allen & Hamilton Company has upon consultation
with Cyrus R. Vance, Assistant Secretary of Defense, recommended not only
to close the Springfield Armory but to adopt a new philosophy in Department of Defense policy spelling the doom of the entire arsenal system of our
government, in contradiction of the study submitted by the U. S. Army
Material Command upon the request of Army Chief of Staff, dated December
18, 1964, and
WHEREAS, Outside contractors have repeatedly refused to bid on vital
material needed in Viet Nam because of quantity size of orders not assuring
them of substantial profits, the burden of producing same falling back on
Springfield Armory, and
WHEREAS, Springfield Armory has produced weapons of outstanding
quality at economical cost (of comparable guns manufactured by Springfield
Armory and outside contractor’s, errors found in guns were 85% outside
contractor’s—15% Springfield Armory); now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that we
oppose the closing of the United States Armory, Springfield, Massachusetts,
said Armory being the only arsenal set up for Research, Development, Procurement and Pilot Line production of small arms vitally needed in Viet Nam.
“Commending General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service
System”
Resolution No. 4 (Submitted by:
National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, The United States of America is involved in a war in Viet
Nam to prevent Communist imperialism over-running Asia and the Far East
and in line with its long-standing policy of supporting the forces of freedom
over the forces of Communism, and
’
WHEREAS, The American Legion at all times espouses “peace and understanding” among people as well as nations but at the same time wholeheartedly supports our government and our Armed Forces in Viet Nam; now,
therefore, be it
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
29
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that The
American Legion congratulate General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service, for his outstanding and faithful administration of selective service in his contributions to our nation in providing the needed manpower for
our Armed Forces; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to General
Hershey.
“Name Next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier for the Late Fleet Admiral
Chester W. Nimitz”
Resolution No. 5 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz assumed the responsibility
as Commander-in-Chief of the Pacific Fleet following the attack on Pearl
Harbor in 1941, and
WHEREAS, He assumed command at a time when there was a grave
shortage of men, ships, planes and supplies yet carried on defensive warfare
which eventually enabled American forces to halt the Japanese advance, and
WHEREAS, Through his brilliant leadership and outstanding skill as a
strategist shifted the Pacific war from a defensive to offensive operation
molding the world’s greatest naval fleet, and
WHEREAS, He lead this heroic armada to decisive victories in sea warfare in all areas of the Pacific Theater, which contributed much toward the
ultimate surrender of Japan, and
WHEREAS, The late Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz had long been a
close friend of The American Legion and in 1945 received its Distinguished
Service Medal in recognition of his outstanding service to the United States,
and
WHEREAS, A nuclear powered aircraft carrier is to be built as part of
the 1966-67 fleet construction program of the U. S. Navy, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, in Indianapolis, Indiana, that the
Secretary of the Navy and the Secretary of Defense be requested to name
the next nuclear powered aircraft carrier, “THE ADMIRAL CHESTER W.
NIMITZ,” as a lasting tribute to this naval officer who rendered the
highest possible service to his nation in peace and war.
“Support Passage of S. 2351 to Protect Harassment of Families of
Servicemen in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 9 (Submitted by: National Security Commission. (Pursuant to Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, There has been an outbreak of vicious, outrageous telephone
calls harassing and threatening widows and relatives of servicemen killed in
Viet Nam, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization comprised exclusively of veterans who served during wartime and, therefore, have a deep understanding of the effect of harassment on the families of servicemen, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion wholeheartedly supports the American
position in Viet Nam to curtail the spread of Communism throughout the
“Free World,” and
WHEREAS, There is presently a Bill (S-2351) before the Congress designed to protect the morale and efficiency of members of the Armed Forces
by making it a federal offense for anyone to make threats or harass members
of the Armed Forces, their wives, widows or families; Now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that
The American Legion support S-2351 and urge its immediate passage by the
Congress.
30
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
“Support Legislation Proposed by Department of Defense and the
Bolte Committee to Provide Uniformity for Improvement of Career
Opportunities in the Military Services”
Resolution No. 13 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, different policies prevail in the armed services governing the
appointment, promotion, separation and retirement of military officers in the
defense establishment due to the divergence of the separate laws affecting
officer status; and
WHEREAS, such laws result in serious personal career inequities and in
differing rates of career progression among the military services; and
WHEREAS, proper officer personnel administration requires that such
laws be brought into uniformity and that qualified officers be fairly distributed by grade, age and service in each of the service departments; and
WHEREAS, such disparities among officer career opportunities within the
services should be eliminated so that they may offer more attractive career
features and assist in the procurement of qualified and capable officers necessary to the security of the nation; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that we
reiterate our support of the principles incorporated in the so-called Bolte
proposals, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That The American Legion offer supporting
testimony in any hearings on the revised Bolte legislation when it is considered by committees of the current Congress.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This has the approval of your
Legislative Commission, your Committee approves and I move adoption of the
resolution.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: In seconding that motion, I would like to ask
the Chairman to suggest what the Bolte legislation is. I know we were considering this before the Legislative Commission yesterday afternoon but we
were wholly in the dark about who Bolte refers to and what he is or who
he is.
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Tom, what you are asking is incorporated in the preamble of the resolution. Bolte is the former Chief of
Staff of the United States Army, retired, who originally proposed this bill
many years ago actually in the Congress when he was in the service, and
because of courtesy to him, his name was put on the resolution. Actually it
makes the uniformity of promotion and career opportunities in the service.
One outstanding inequity for instance is the fact that regular Generals are
in the Army, and one outstanding example, they are authorized in the Army
and Air Force, but they are not authorized in the Navy. For instance, a
Commodore in the equivalent rank in the one area to the same rank of the
Army and Air Force is only permitted in war time in the Navy. But actually
the bill brings more uniformity to promotion programs in all three of the
services as well as the career incentive and career programs, bringing them
up to a higher level so there is not one promotion regulation for time and
grade qualifications in the Air Force, different from that in the Army, which
again would be different than that of the Navy.
Actually, it is a uniform career program for the services.
MR. MILLER: One other question, and I am in agreement with what
the Chairman just said, if you remember, we would like to have a set of
proper names designating legislation like the Easton Bill or the Feighan Bill,
and we would like to know the House and Senate number of these, of this
legislation. Do you have it available? Does Jimmy Wilson have it?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: I don’t believe we have it here.
MR. MILLER: There must be someone who does.
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Jimmy says there is a series of
bills which will be instituted, Tom, on this same thing. The Bolte Bill was
the one that we originally decided was the one best for the services.
The number of the Bill I don’t know. We will get it for you.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
31
MR. MILLER: Has it been introduced in the 89th Congress?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Yes.
MR. MILLER: I don’t want to be meticulous, but having been mixed up
in legislative business for a great number of years and having been connected with our Legislative Commission in our meetings here, when they had
the names of Congressmen and Senators, I would respectfully suggest that
we be let in on the military secret as to what the number is of the Senate
or the number of the House.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Chairman and Commander, we will accept that amendment if Mr. Miller will make it to the effect
that the number of the bill be substituted for the name.
MR. MILLER: Yes, sir, I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: Mr. Commander, I think what Mr. Miller was
talking about that in addition to the name the number be added, not substituted.
MR. MILLER: Whatever, Mr. Commander, will properly identify it is
satisfactory with me. If they will insert the number of the House or the
Senate Bill that the Bolte legislation is covered by, this will be fine.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We have accepted that.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN:
Will you accept that
amendment?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Yes, sir.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Since your amendment
has been accepted by the Chairman, there is no necessity of voting on the
amendment.
Any further discussion on the motion?
All those in favor will please say aye; opposed. So ordered.
“Reserve Training”
Resolution No. 21 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, this country has traditionally relied upon the Reserve Components of our Military Establishment, as a pool of trained forces ready for
active duty in times of military emergency, and
WHEREAS, we are now facing a national emergency because of our commitments in Viet Nam and elsewhere, and
WHEREAS, our Reserve Components are unable to maintain an adequate
training program because they have been relieved of much of their equipment for use by our regular Military Establishment, and
WHEREAS, our Regular Military Establishment has not been able to furnish the manpower to adequately train our volunteers and inductees, and
WHEREAS, with adequate equipment and training our Reserve Components could be of invaluable use in the training of volunteers and inductees
in our Regular Military Establishment and their use would in fact constitute
a military economy, and
WHEREAS, the Army, due to lack of training facilities is unable to train
Reserve Component individuals to top combat readiness, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion strongly recommends and urges,
1. That our Reserve Military Components be supplied with the necessary
equipment in order that they may maintain an adequate training program commensurate with maximum combat readiness;
2. That the Department of Defense open additional training facilities in
order to train the backlog of enlistments in the Reserve Components
who have not received six months active duty training;
32
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
3. That the Training Divisions of the Reserve Components be called for
active service if the Regular Forces are unable to perform this service,
and used in the training of volunteers and inductees in our Regular
Military Establishment in order to relieve the manpower shortage
faced by our regular military in providing such training.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Oder, California, and adopted.
“Defense Department Policy in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 22 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, in early 1962, spokesmen for the Defense Department reported that our war in Viet Nam was going so well that 1,000 military personnel could be removed in a month, and the remaining Americans by 1965,
and
WHEREAS, now our troops in Viet Nam have been increased to over
250,000 from the approximately 3,000 there as of December 1961, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has supported military systems necessary for the defense and security of this country, including the B-70-Supersonic bomber, the Dynasoar, the Anti-Missile programs, and others—all of
which have been written down or canceled by the Department of Defense,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that we recommend to the President and the Congress of the United States
that the Viet Nam conflict be re-evaluated as to strategy, tactics, and the
logistical support, and that the leadership and concepts of our military people,
trained in the art of war for the security of this country, be given primary
consideration in the planning, execution and conclusion of this conflict, and
be it further
RESOLVED, That we use every military effort to successfully conclude
this war, and be it further
RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the President of the United States and to the Chairmen of the Senate and House
Armed Services Committees.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF LIFE INSURANCE & TRUST COMMITTEE
William S. Todd (Tennessee), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN TODD: Mr. Commander and gentlemen, your
Life Insurance and Trust Committee met in the two days preceding this
meeting down at the Athletic Club with all members present except two.
The report I believe has been laid on your desk, the report which we have
submitted through the Finance Commission, but the Chairman, Mr. Redden,
because of some additions on the report insisted that we make this this
morning.
We have reports from the Administrator of the program, Mr. R. H. Gore
of Chicago and the insurance carrier, Occidental Life of California through
Mr. John Llewelyn. The important thing that we wanted to report on is the
fact that our Subcommittee which had been appointed at the Portland Convention to look into the feasibility of negotiating a new promotion agreement reported that a new agreement should be negotiated and the new Administrator was desirous in cooperating to this end. Detailed studies as to the
extension and the promotion of The American Legion Life Insurance plan
were presented to the Committee by both the Subcommittee and the Administrator, Vic Whittlesea of Nevada and William Baxter of New York and
John Shea of Missouri, together with the Chairman of the Committee. We
felt that the sliding scale of compensation would be fair under all circumstances. This is set forth at the bottom of the first page of the report.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
33
In regard to the rate of compensation, I would like to point out to you
that under the law we have to handle the group states and the policy states
m a different fashion. The states of New York and Puerto Rico, the fee
,Te ls 01}ly 2% for those, but this is the big lump, and we worked out this
sliding scale.
The Trust Fund is presently $988,000, and it will reach a million dollars
this year.
We do have two resolutions, but they will be reported at the time of our
parent Commission report, the Finance Commission tomorrow. Thank you
very much, Mr. Commander.
. . . The printed report of Mr. Todd is as follows:
REPORT OF THE AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE AND
TRUST COMMITTEE TO THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
May 4-5, 1966
William S. Todd, Chairman
(Submitted through Finance Commission)
The American Legion Life Insurance and Trust Committee met in Indianapolis, Indiana in the Athletic Club on May 2-3, 1966 with only two members absent.
The Committee heard reports from representatives of the Administrator
of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, R. H. Gore Company of Chicago, Illinois, and of Occidental Life Insurance Company of California; the
Insurance Carrier, which revealed that participation in the plan has steadily
increased.
A Special Subcommittee consisting of John Shea of Missouri, and Vie
Whittlesea of Nevada reported on a special Pilot Study of concentrated promotional activity in the St. Louis Area. It was reported that 35 of the 44
Posts in St. Louis County were represented at the initial meeting at which
Paul L. Weber, Staff Liaison, gave a full explanation of the Insurance Plan
and how it could be best promoted at the local level. While the Committee
was of the opinion that the local posts had not followed through, it was felt
that this was primarily due to a local problem in failing to disseminate the
basic materials and that this experience would be of considerable value in
future promotion.
The report of Mr. John Brogan, representing the Administrator, revealed
that participation in the plan had increased during 1965 to approximately
72,000 members with some 45,000 in the group states, and 27,000 in the policy
states, and that we have now attained an annual premium of approximately
$1,550,000, and that approximately $3,325,000 has been paid out in claims since
1958.
Mr. John Llewelyn, representing the Insurance Carrier, explained that the
Company is well pleased with the progress that has been made, and that the
Catastrophe Reserve, required by law, has been accumulated in the approximate amount of $50,000, and that no further deposits will need to be made to
this reserve.
Another Subcommittee appointed at the Portland National Convention to
investigate the feasibility of negotiating a new Administration and Promotion Agreement, consisting of Stanley Van Dyk of Illinois, Gilbert Sheeks of
Indiana, and John Shea of Missouri, which had met in Washington during the
Commander’s Conference, advised the Committee that a new agreement should
be negotiated and that the Administrator was desirous of cooperation
toward this end. Detailed study of the expenses of Administration and
Promotion of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan were presented to the
Committee by both the Subcommittee and the Administrator following which
Vic Whittlesea of Nevada, William Baxter of New York, and John Shea of
Missouri, together with the Chairman of the Committee, had a special meeting
with the representative of the Administration in which the specific compensa-
34
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U> 1966
tions of the Administrator were discussed, delineated, and negotiated to the
mutual satisfaction of the parties.
,, . . . .
. „
It is the sincere feeling of this Committee that the Administrator has
been diligent, devoted, and dedicated in its administration of The American
Legion Life Insurance Plan, and that a new Administration and
Agreement should be prepared and executed to be effective on January 1, 1967,
with the Administrator’s compensation to be based on a sliding scale as follows:
,,
, .
1. Ten percent on the first $1,000,000 of premium from the group states.
2. Eight percent of said premium from $1,000,000 to $1,500,000.
3. Seven percent of said premium between $1,500,000 and $2,000,000.
4. That when the amount of premium from the group states reaches
$2,000,000 the rate of compensation shall be re-examined and rene5. That^the Administrator will bear full expense of all IBM and tabulating costs incurred in the administration of the plan, which it was formerly reimbursed 60 % of the said costs by the Insurance Carrier, and
which will result in a savings in excess of $8,000 annually.
Further, said agreement should provide that the Administrator shall expend not less than fifteen percent of its total fee for the promotion and
furtherance of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, over and above
the expenses of the Staff Liaison, and the direct mail activity in the policy
states, and that said Administrator should be required to submit a Promotional Budget to the Committee at its annual Spring Meeting for its approval
and adoption, and any part of said fifteen percent promotional funds not
expended in any year shall be carried over for future promotion and shall
not revert to the Administrator.
It is recommended that said agreement should be effective for one year,
automatically renewable, unless terminated by either party by giving 120 days
written notice before the end of any calendar year, and that all files, records,
IBM cards, and other data pertaining to The American Legion Life Insurance
Plan, which are not the property of the Insurance Carrier, shall be the property of The American Legion upon termination of said agreement.
Mr. Paul Weber our staff liaison displayed for the Committee copies of the
Department and Post publications which had cooperated in publicizing the
Insurance Plan, and he advised the Committee that he had received excellent
cooperation from all Divisions of the National Organization in his efforts
to make this plan a full-grown member of the family.
The Committee adopted a resolution to reimburse The American Legion
in the sum of $10,171.37 from The Life Insurance Trust Fund for expenses
incurred by The American Legion in connection with the Insurance Plan.
This resolution was delivered to the Finance Commission for processing.
The Committee plans to look into the manner in which the Trust Funds
are being invested in an effort to ascertain whether or not maximum yield
is being received under the guideline laid down in the Trust Agreement and
whether said Trust Agreement could be amended to allow more advantageous
investment.
This Committee is most pleased that the National Commander has appointed a Special Committee to coordinate activities in connection with the
observance of the “Golden Anniversary” of The American Legion, and plans
to work closely with said Committee so that the maximum emphasis and
publicity possible to be derived from this anniversary may be realized.
The Committee has been extremely impressed with the able manner in
which Mr. Paul Weber, Staff Liaison of The American Legion Life Insurance Department, has coordinated the promotional activities of the Administrator with the various Divisions of The American Legion and feels
confident that great benefit will accrue to the program as a result.
The Committee wishes to express its appreciation to all of the National
Officers for their continued cooperation and assistance.
Respectfully submitted,
WILLIAM S. TODD, Chairman
American Legion Life Insurance Trust Committee
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
35
REPORT OF NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Morris “Bob” Nooner, Jr. (Illinois), Chairman
Mr. Commander and members of the National Executive Committee:
Executive Section of your National Child Welfare Commission
met at the National Headquarters in Indianapolis, Indiana on Monday and
Tuesday, May 2-3, 1966. Meeting with our Commission was the National Child
Welfare Committee of the American Legion Auxiliary an the Child Welfare
Committee of the Eight and Forty. We were also privileged to have with us
lor a brief period, the National President and National Secretary.
Our Commission wishes to extend its appreciation to Wally Young, Chairman of the Child Welfare Liaison Committee, for his faithful attendance
and counsel throughout our meeting.
I am pleased to report to you that we have had numerous indications
at our recent Area Conferences and from other sources within the Departments of a renewed enthusiasm in the Child Welfare program and we
are anticipating the largest annual child welfare report in the history of the
program for presentation to the National Convention.
Part of our deliberations the past two days were concerned with selection of the major points of emphasis for our 1967 child welfare program
those subjects selected include: an active Child Welfare Chairman in every
Post and Unit, juvenile delinquency, mentally ill children, eye safety
(with emphasis on eye safety legislation), outdoor recreation and support of
the American Legion Child Welfare Foundation.
Although The American Legion ChildnWelfare Foundation is a separate
entity from our Child Welfare program, it is by Convention action a part
of our total American Legion Child Welfare Program since it is concerned
with prevention and prevention is one of the four basic methods of operation
tor conducting our program. I am pleased to report to you that support for
the Foundation has increased substantially thus far this year compared to
the same period for last year. To further strengthen the important work of
the Foundation, we are recommending that Department Child Welfare
Chairmen include dissemination of information concerning the Child Welfare
Foundation as a part of their responsibilities.
Our five Area Child Welfare Conferences provide us with an invaluable
tool for the successful operation of the Child Welfare program. Total attendance
at our conferences the past two years has been the best in the past ten years
This past year we made some sweeping changes in the format of our meetings m an effort to increase their effectiveness. These changes involved the
use of devices designed to increase participation by the conference delegates.
These changes have been well received and will be continued at next year’s
conferences.
For your information, the dates and locations for the 1966-67 Area Child
Welfare Conferences are:
Southern Area
Oct. 27-29
Atlanta, Georgia
Midwestern Area
Nov. 3-5
Indianapolis, Indiana
Western Area
Nov. 17-19
Albuquerque, New Mexico
New England Area
Dec. 1-3
Providence, Rhode Island
Middle Atlantic Area
Jan. 5-7
Norfolk, Virginia
Expenditures for dependent children of veterans from our temporary financial assistance program are at a relatively low level due in large part to
our level of prosperity. On the other hand, we are receiving an increasing
number of requests for assistance to children who are already receiving aid
through such programs as Aid to Families with Dependent Children. Payments in such programs are meeting a smaller percentage of children’s basic
needs as the cost of living continues to rise. Failure of public programs to
reflect the increased cost of living could become an increased burden on
our own temporary financial assistance program.
36
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Last fall I made a report to you on our efforts to secure four pieces of
state legislation concerning children. Our efforts were directed at laws to
require mandatory testing of newborn babies for PKU (a metabolic disorder
which causes mental retardation but which is easily corrected by d
y
means if detected early), legislation to require reporting by physicians and
hospital authorities of suspected cases of physical abuse of children, legislation requiring students in shop-type classes and laboratories to wear eye
protectee devices, and laws designed to more adequately control the distribution of the so-called dangerous drugs.
We now have a complete tabulation of our efforts which we believe were
most successful. Forty-eight states have enacted laws to protect the physically
abused child. Thirty-three states have enacted legislation or adopted administrative regulations requiring hospitals to test the newborn for PKU. All
but one state now has a law controlling the distribution and sale of dangerous drugs and 20 states enacted laws requiring pupils to wear eye protective devices in classes where there are potential hazards to the eyes.
Next year most of the state legislatures will be meeting and we are
developing plans for further efforts in cooperation with Departments in the
area of eye safety and improvement of some states laws dealing with child
abuse.
Our Commission is concerned with the stigma that has been attached to
our teen-agers through sensationalized items reaching the public through our
various communications media. It would appear that only those youth who
get into trouble have press agents. Actually, only a bare three per cent of
all youth ever get involved in behavior where they run afoul of the law.
The vast majority of our youth evidence a high level of academic achievement, loyalty to country and sound character. Our Commission has recommended a resolution on this subject for your consideration.
We are vitally concerned with the increasing number of accidents to children resulting in death for 15,000 and injuries to an additional 17 million
annually. Nearly half of these accidental deaths to children occur m the
home. Many of these deaths in the home occur as the result of ingestion of
poisons or overdoses of drugs and amphetamines.
There is legislation pending in the Congress presently which seeks to
amend the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act to require safety closures
on drug containers and limit the amount of child aspirin which may be placed
in a single container. This proposed legislation would also mend the Federal
Hazardous Substances Labeling Act to ban hazardous toys and articles for
children as well as other articles so hazardous as to be dangerous m the
home regardless of their labeling.
Our Commission feels such legislation would be helpful to reduction of
accidents to children in their homes and we have prepared a resolution endorsing such legislation for your consideration.
Your Child Welfare Commission is fully cognizant of the responsibilities
they have accepted.
The design of the programs which have been developed for 1967 indicates
that a continued interest is being displayed and concerted efforts are being
made to further our organization’s role in the areas related to Child Welfare.
With the continuing cooperation and support of your Committee, we reaffirm our pledge, to give our best efforts to meet the responsibilities given to
us and maintain The American Legion’s leadership role in all matters relating to our nation’s youth and children.
. . . Upon motion by Mr. Jackson, Delaware, seconded by Mr. Oder,
California, the report was received and filed.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Are there resolutions,
Mr. Stone?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
37
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously adopted:
“Commend Youth”
Resolution No. 28 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, There is considerable material reaching the general public
today through our various public media concerned with youth crime and antisocial behavior on the part of young people, and
WHEREAS, A bare 3 per cent of our young people ever come in contact
with law enforcement agencies, and
WHEREAS, The overwhelming majority of our youth show promise of
outstanding citizenship as evidenced in a number of ways, most recently by
their expression of support for the American Policy in Viet Nam and support
of The American Legion National Program of “Show Your Colors”- now
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it express its wholehearted confidence in the youth of America and’
commends American youth for its accomplishments in the areas of academic
achievement, loyal citizenship and character development.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: While we are waiting
for the distribution of these resolutions, let’s go ahead with the reading of
the next two, then we will entertain a motion on all of them or each one of
them separately.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, there is probably something wrong with our communications from our office down to the
mimeograph pool, and possibly this is coming in in one of the supplements.
In the interest of time, I will be glad to read the entire resolution and
pass on it. These are actually “Motherhood” resolutions.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN:
You have heard the recommendation of the Chairman of the Resolutions Committee.
. . . The motion was seconded.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Motion has been made
and carried. Any objection? Hearing none, it is so ordered.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I consider Resolution 28 has
already been put to the body.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Resolution 28 has already
been put to the body.
“Need for Expanded Research and Educational Program Concerning
Genetic Diseases”
Resolution No. 29 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, Chromosomal diseases are a major cause of disabling conditions among children including such commonly known disabilities as retardation, and
WHEREAS, Research has demonstrated that many of these diseases
can be prevented by a chromosomal study of prospective parents, and
WHEREAS, There are many diseases remaining among children which
are suspected to be of genetic origin, and
WHEREAS, There is an urgent need to disseminate available information
concerning diseases of genetic origin to prospective parents as a means
of preventing such disorders, and
WHEREAS, There is a need for further extensive research in the field
of genetics, now, therefore, be it
38
Proceedings of Wecbiesday, May b, 1966
HE SOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that it urges an aggressive educational effort be made to familiarize
prospective parents of the need for a chromosomal study as a means of
preventing such diseases, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That every effort be made to expand genetic
research through appropriate agencies of government and private sources.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Is there any discussion?
MR. LEONARD, Connecticut: I feel that we are out of order entirely
with this way of doing business. We at least should have this digest to read
it or know what he is talking about, and he can’t do it himself up there, so
we should have something on it. I suggest we discontinue voting on resolutions that we don’t have the digest on and let’s have some other Committee
report in the meantime.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Joe, it is true what you
say that you like to have them, but this body already went on record giving
him permission to proceed, and you have already taken a vote without objection. So I think we have to proceed with that. You want to renew that
motion?
MR. LEONARD: I will renew the motion. I will make a substitute, if it
possible or something, that we don’t proceed any further with resolutions until we have the digest and let some other Committee make their report.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Is there a second to the
motion?
MR. PETROVICH, Alaska: Mr. Chairman, I will second the motion and
support the Committeeman from Connecticut.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Motion is that we hold
this and discontinue any further procedure on resolutions until we get them
in the digest. What is your pleasure, gentlemen?
. . . Question.
All those in favor of the motion please say aye; opposed no. The ayes
have it.
We will have to defer to you and withhold any further resolutions until
such time as we can get the resolutions in the digest.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: Mr. Commander, Mr. Flynn
is here. Can we get his report?
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: I was just getting ready
to ask the Chairman John Flynn to give us the Economic report at this time.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION REPORT
John J. Flynn (California), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN FLYNN: Mr. Commander and Members of
the National Executive Committee:
You have been supplied a copy of our Advance Report covering Commission actions taken at our March Executive Section Meeting. Since our Commission did not meet here in Indianapolis, and in view of this rather detailed
report, we will be brief at this time by highlighting a couple considerations
contained in our Advance Report and certain matters that have required our
attention since the first of April.
Our books have been cleared of all referred resolutions and Register matters with the exception of two. These are Resolution No. 231 (Illinois) and
Register No. 1224 (New Hampshire). The Illinois Resolution requesting legislation to outlaw discrimination in employment because of age was referred by the 1965 National Convention to the Subcommittee on the Problems of the Aged and Aging. At this Subcommittee’s March meeting it was
recommended that the resolution be approved with the proviso that such dis-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
39
crimination be condemned only when the applicant is qualified for such employment and is under age 65. This resolution will be further considered at our
next meeting.
Register No. 1224 protesting the import of electronic components which
allegedly is causing unemployment among veterans, has been deferred for
further study and will be reported on at a later date.
There were two resolutions emanating with the Commission at our March
meeting. One resolution has to do with legislation to provide for assistance
in on-the-job training programs for Viet Nam and Cold War Veterans who
normally would be eligible for veterans’ educational assistance under the new
Cold War Bill. The Act as passed and approved on March 3, 1966, does not
provide assistance for on-the-job training as was afforded World War II and
Korean veterans. Many veterans will not be able financially or otherwise to
further their education through college or other educational channels. Therefore we see the need of on-the-job training programs. Also there is a need for
skilled workers in all industries. This new group of veterans will be a definite
source from which skilled workers can be recruited and trained. We urge the
adoption of Resolution No. 6. We should perhaps point out that HR 13850
as pending in Committee will not only provide for assistance to these Cold
War Veterans in on-the-job training, but will also extend educational assistance in on-the-farm training programs, etc.
The other resolution emanating with our Commission and contained in
our Advance Report opposing HR 6277 has been withdrawn by the Resolutions Subcommittee of the National Executive Committee with the consent of
the Commission. Withdrawal action resulted after pertinent discussions between the NEC Resolutions Subcommittee, the National Legislative Commission and the Economic Commission. Hearings on HR 6277 were held April
19 and 21, 1966, before a Special Subcommittee, Senate Committee on Foreign Relations. The Assistant Director, National Legislative Commission, by
virtue of authority granted in a 1965 National Convention Resolution, testified on April 21st. In view of these hearings adoption of the Commission’s
emanated resolution at this late date would serve no useful purpose. Further, to oppose HR 6277 in its entirety as resolved in the resolution would be
in conflict with existing mandates of the Foreign Affairs Committee.
More detailed information on HR 6277 and its adverse effect on veterans’
preference will be found in our Advance Report. However, in passing we
want to emphasize that our fight in opposition to the two adverse Sections
(Sections 29 and 32 )is an up-hill climb. We will need every possible ounce of
support. Therefore you are urged to either write your Senator or contact
him personally advising him of The American Legion’s opposition to this
measure and specifically request that he oppose Sections 29 and 32 of the
Bill. As you know HR 6277 passed the House last year.
This Saturday, May 7th, we will close out our eighth observance of
“Employ the Older Worker Week.” It is a little early yet to determine if
there is an increase in participation over last year. However, we are hopeful
that most Departments will participate and we certainly would urge that
you do so, even if it is necessary for the award presentation to be made
at a date subsequent to the designated week.
As to 1967 appropriations for the Veterans Employment Service and the
Office of Veterans Re-employment Rights, we are pleased to report that this
year we do not anticipate any opposition in having the necessary amounts
appropriated as requested when we testified before the House Committee on
Appropriations.
One further item I would like to bring to your attention is a matter relative to the staff. As reported in our Advance Report, decisions denying
waiver of GI Home Loan Indebtedness are now appealable to the VA’s
Board of Veterans Appeals. This is a new endeavor for the Economic Commission Staff. We enthusiastically accept this added responsibility in the
field of housing.
Members of our staff have now been accredited by the VA to represent
appellants before the Board of Veterans Appeals. We have been given excellent cooperation by the Chairman of the Board and his staff in order that
40
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
all housing indebtedness appeals may be handled as expeditiously as possible. We solicit your cooperation by urging that all housing matters including indebtedness appeals to the Board of Veterans Appeals be forwarded
promptly to the Economic Division’s Director at our Washington “K”
Street address.
Briefly with reference to future Area Economic Conferences, we are pleased
to report that in our opinion each of the four (4) conferences held during
The American Legion year 1965-66 were successful. We are going to schedule
four (4) conferences for the forthcoming American Legion year. We would
urge each of you to stimulate interest in your particular area and attend at
least one conference yourself if at all possible. Area Conference schedules will
be announced at a future date.
. . . The printed Advance Report is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5, 1966
by
JOHN J. FLYNN (California), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
The following report covers the activities of the National Economic Commission and its three affiliated Committees from October 7, 1965 to April 1,
1966.
I. NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION MEETINGS
In conjunction with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference on March
1-3, 1966, an Executive Section of the Economic Commission met in the New
York Room, Statler Hilton Hotel, Washington, D. C. John J. Flynn, Chairman of the National Economic Commission presided over these three-day
meetings with the Chairman of each of the three affiliated Committees serving as Moderator during their respective Committee Panel. In addition to the
Commission and Committee Chairmen also attending these meetings were: the
Commission’s Vice Chairman; Vice Chairman of each of the three Committees; thirty-two members of the Commission and affiliated Committees; Chairman of the National Executive Committee Liaison Committee to the National
Economic Commission; the National Commander’s Representative to the Commission; Department Commanders, Adjutants and National Executive Committeemen; Department Service Officers, County and Post Service Officers;
Veterans Employment Representatives; Economic Commission Staff Members
and numerous other persons interested in the Economic Program of The
American Legion.
Twelve Representatives of Government, Labor and Industry appeared before the Commission and informed us of their respective programs and its
relationship to the economic welfare of veterans.
Past National Chaplain Dr. Tom B. Clark and our Housing Committee
Chairman, offered the daily opening prayer.
One of the highlights of the sessions was an address by John W. Macy,
Jr., Chairman, United States Civil Service Commission. The Economic Commission was honored by having National Commander L. Eldon James present to introduce Mr. Macy.
In our deliberations all programs and functions under the Commission’s
jurisdiction were extensively studied. All sessions were well attended, interesting, informative and we believe reasonable progress was made in our continued effort to find solutions to some of our employment, housing and veterans preference problems. Members in attendance recognized their responsi-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May k, 1966
41
bility in favorably considering only those matters which were correctly under
jurisdiction of the Economic Commission and germane to veterans’ affairs.
All items other than resolutions and registered matters acted upon and
relating directly to one of the three Committees; Employment, Housing or
Veterans’ Preference, will be considered under its designated Committee heading. Following are actions on matters considered together with reports received by the Commission.
A. 1965 National Convention Resolution Referred to the Commission:
1. Resolution No. 279 (Pennsylvania) seeks preferential employment
consideration in the nation’s public employment system for veterans with
service in those campaigns for which the Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal
has been or will be awarded in the future. REJECTED. Subject matter is now
law, “Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966.” (Public Law 89-358) approved March 3, 1966.
B. Action on Referred Register Matters:
1. Register No. 1210 (New Jersey Department Convention) protests the
preference afforded non-veteran displaced Federal employees over veterans
whose names appear on a Civil Service Register resulting from a competitive
examination and thereby delaying eligible veterans of an appointment to
Federal jobs. REJECTED. It is reasonable to give perference to separated
career employees and is not considered as a violation of the Veterans’ Preference Act.
2. Register No. 1124 (New Hampshire Department Executive Committee)
protests the foreign import of electronic components which is alleged to cause
unemployment among veterans and their families who are employed in American plants. DEFERRED to the Economic Staff for further study.
C. Commission—Initiated Resolutions:
The following two unnumbered resolutions emanating with the Commission
are being presented for National Executive Committee action at its May 4-5,
1966 Meeting.
(1) Oppose the Bill HR 6277, 89th Congress, in its present form and request that the United States Senate where the bill is now pending reject the
bill.
(2) Support legislation to amend the Veterans’ Readjustment Benefits
Act of 1966 (Public Law 89-358) so as to provide eligible cold war veterans
assistance in on-the-job training programs.
D. Report of Joint Economic-Rehabilitation Subcommittee on Problems of
the Aged and Aging:
The Joint Economic-Rehabilitation Subcommittee on Problems of the Aged
and Aging met February 28, 1966 in Room 401, of The American Legion
Building in connection with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. Milton S. Applebaum, Chairman of the Subcommittee. and all members were
present. There was considerable discussion on Medicare, the Nursing Care
Program, Nursing Home Facilities and the Older American Act of 1965 (Public Law 89-73).
The Subcommittee took the following action on a Referred 1965 National Convention Resolution.
Resolution No. 231 (Illinois) asking that discrimination in employment
of the older worker be made an unlawful employment practice under Federal
law was recommended for approval with the proviso that such discrimination
be condemned only when the applicant is qualified for such employment and
is under age 65. Resolution No. 231 will receive further consideration at the
next meeting of the National Economic Commission.
E. Report and Recommendations of Area Economic Conferences:
The report and recommendations of the Chairman of each of the four
Area Economic Conferences was received by the Commission. The Chairman,
Area, Location and dates are as follows:
42
,
Proceedings of Wednesday May U, 1966
John H. Geiger, Mid-Western Area, Chicago, Illinois, November 13-14,
1965.
James A. Tadlock, Western Area, Albuquerque, New Mexico, January 2830, 1966.
Thomas J. Harvey, Jr., Southern Area, Atlanta, Georgia, February 11-13,
1966.
Joseph Holzka, New England-Mid-Atlantic Area, Staten Island, New York,
February 19, 1966.
Federal and State Government, industry and labor was represented at
each Conference. The Conferences were well attended, interesting and informative for those persons seeking information and solutions to problems
which come under jurisdiction of the Economic Commission.
In light of favorable response from the four areas, and recommendations
from each Conference, the Economic Commission unanimously voted to continue holding four Area Economic Conferences annually. The following two
Conference recommendations were also approved by the Commission:
(1) That each Department of The American Legion be urged to conduct
local Economic Conferences, similar to those being held on an Area level;
and
(2) Opposition to the weakening or reduction of any veteran benefit pertaining to the economic welfare of veterans.
II. EMPLOYMENT COMMITTEE CONSIDERATIONS
An Executive Section of this Committee, Chairmaned by William J. Chisholm met with the Economic Commission March 1-3, 1966. During the Employment Panel discussions and deliberations all phases of The American Legion Employment Program were considered. The following speakers addressed the Committee and were most helpful in our deliberations. Carlos
Moore, Legislative Assistant, International Brotherhood of Teamsters; Edward L. Omohundro, Chief, Veterans Employment Service; Thomas A. Tinsley,
Director, Bureau of Employees’ Compensation; Hugh W. Bradley, Director,
Office of Veterans’ Reemployment Rights; and William P. McCahill, Executive Secretary, President’s Committee on Employment of the Handicapped.
Most of the speakers after reviewing their respective program, accomplishments and goals sought, left a challenge with the Economic Commission and
the Employment Committee. The challenge has been accepted and is expressed by certain recommendations set forth in this report.
A. Citation Award Programs:
The American Legion programs of awarding national citations to employers who have done an outstanding job in the employment of the handicapped
and older workers have been working well. We are appreciative of the increased interest shown by some Departments of The American Legion who
have accepted their responsibility in these fields.
“National Employ the Handicapped Week,” was observed October 2-9, 1965,
in cooperation with the President’s Committee on Employment of the Handicapped. Thirty-one Departments participated in the program by presenting a
national citation award to an employer who had done an outstanding job
in hiring the handicapped, especially the disabled veteran. For a complete
list of the participating Departments and recipients of the Handicapped
Awards see The American Legion Magazine for March 1966 (pages 34-35).
The Employment Committee has announced in the Economic Commission
Activities Bulletin No. 8-66 of March 1966 its 1966 citation award program
for, “Employ the Older Worker Week.” The week will be observed May 1-7,
1966 and each Department of The American Legion has been encouraged to
participate by recognizing an outstanding employer of the older worker.
In connection with our older worker program, the Economic Commission
Staff recently submitted testimony before the Subcommittee of the House
Appropriations Committee in compliance with Resolution No. 489 of the 1965
National Convention. In our testimony we urged the Congress to make adequate appropriations for the required extension of specialized service for
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
43
older workers in all local offices of the several state employment services
and throughout other affiliated offices of the U. S. Employment Service,
particularly through the provisions of staff time budget realistically related
to the needs of the older worker.
B. Veterans Employment Service:
The Economic Commission is most appreciative of the support given our
employment programs throughout the country by the Veterans Employment
Service and the State Employment Security Agencies. We are also pleased
with the excellent manner in which these operating agencies have discharged
their responsibilities in the placement of some 25 million veterans in the past
two decades. However, there is a continuing need for this employment service
to veterans especially now with the passage of the Cold War GI Bill.
During fiscal year 1965 the Veterans Employment Service and the State
Employment Security Agencies received some 1.2 million new veteran applications of whom 122,000 were disabled veterans. Of the total veteran applications received, over 933,000 were placed in non-agricultural jobs and 99,000
of these placements were disabled veterans.
e nev
moT>>
^ "Cold
Warother
GI Bill,”
thejob
“Veterans
Readjustment
Benefits
Act of
1966, provides
among
things,
counseling
and employment
placement
assistance to veterans who served on active duty at any time after January
'TW ■
who arewill
separated
from
honorableEmployment
conditions.
This1955
newand
legislation
increase
the such
work service
load ofunder
the Veterans
Service. Since January 31, 1955 about 4 million individuals have been separated from the Armed Services of whom at least 100,000 are currently unemployed. This coupled with the fact that as of December 31, 1965 more
than two months before enactment of the GI Bill approximately 350,000 war
veterans were actively seeking employment. Additionally, it is estimated that
some 56,000 military retirees and about 400,000 cold war veterans will be
separated from the Armed Services each year commencing in 1967. Many of
these veterans will be seeking employment assistance. These young Viet
Nam veterans with little or no employment experience and the military retirees normally in the 40 to 45 age group will both need special counseling
assistance.
The Veterans Employment Service Budget request for fiscal year 1967 is
$1,732,000. In compliance with the 1965 National Convention Resolution No.
37 the staff on February 24, 1966, testified before the appropriate Subcommittee of the House Committee on Appropriations. The requested sum of
$1,732,000 was supported as being fair and reasonable, and the minimum required for the operation of the Veterans Employment Service. The figure
requested and supported by the Economic Commission will provide for the
same number of positions as in previous years.
C. Recommended Amendments to the Cold War GI Bill:
Many cold war veterans that normally would be eligible for veterans’ educational assistance under the Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966
will not be able financially or otherwise to further their education through
college or other formal education channels. Further, there is a continuing
need for skilled workers in all industries of the nation and the returning cold
war veteran could well be a prime source from which skilled workers can
be recruited and trained. Therefore, after due consideration of all factors
involved, the Committee went on record, recommending by virtue of a resolution, which will be submitted for National Executive Committee consideration, that the new Cold War GI Bill be amended to provide for assistance in
on-the-job training programs, for eligible veterans.
D. Veterans Reemployment Rights:
When last reporting to this body we advised you of the urgent need for
an amendment to the Universal Military Training and Service Act in order
to protect reemployment rights of enlistees or Reservists who voluntarily or
involuntarily, because of the national emergency, extend their active duty
period beyond the four year limitation as specified in the present Reemployment Rights Statutes. And in so extending for the convenience of the
government many servicemen unknowingly forfeit their reemployment
44
Proceedings of Wednesday, May If, 1966
rights normally afforded under the present law. 1965 National Convention
Resolution No. 576 requested and supported such an amendment. HR 11509
will satisfy our resolution, and we are pleased to report that this bill passed
the House March 7, 1966. Hearings have been held before the Senate Armed
Services Committee and the bill is now pending consideration before the Senate.
Certain new procedures recently negotiated between the Departments of
Defense and Labor have resulted in the lessening of the complaint case load
before the Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights.
The reorganization of the Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights has
just about been completed. The original 19 field offices have now been reduced to 11 and we understand when certain further negotiations are completed, will be reduced to 10 field offices. The Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights reassures us that the reorganization will in no way diminish
the service to returning servicemen as afforded under the Veterans Reemployment Rights Statutes.
E. Manpower Development and Training Act:
In addition to referring veterans to job openings, local employment offices
refer veterans to occupational training courses established under provisions
of the Manpower Development and Training Act of 1962. For the three
year period September 1, 1962 and September 1, 1965, more than 33,000
veterans received institutional training. Veterans represent slightly over onefourth of all of the males enrolled in this type of training. With the influx
as a result of the “Cold War GI Bill” it is anticipated that these figures
will increase substantially. In compliance with Resolution No. 174 of our
1964 National Convention, in recent testimony before the House Appropriations Subcommittee, the staff urged that Congress appropriate sufficient funds
for carrying out the purpose and intent of the Manpower Development and
Training Act.
III. HOUSING COMMITTEE ACTIVITIES
An Executive Section of the Housing Committee, Chairmaned by Dr. Tom
B. Clark, met with the Economic Commission March 1-3, 1966. During panel
discussions and deliberations the Committee heard from Philip N. Brownstein, Assistant Secretary, Department of Housing and Urban Development;
John M. Dervan, Director, Loan Guaranty Service, Veterans Administration;
and Philip S. Brown, Director, Information Staff, Farmers Home Administration, Department of Agriculture.
A. VA Home Loan Activities:
The VA Home Loan Program will he reactivated as a result of the enactment of the loan provisions of the Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act
of 1966. Many of some 3% or 4 million veterans serving in the Armed Forces
since January 31, 1955, will be eligible for VA guaranteed and direct home
loan benefits. The guarantee of a loan by a private lender remains the same
as for World War II and Korean War veterans—$7500, however, in
areas established as direct loan areas where guaranteed financing has not
generally been available, the maximum direct loan has been increased from
$15,000 to $17,500. The VA interest rate was also increased to 5 % % on March
3, 1966 when the new Cold War GI Bill was signed, in accordance with authority granted therein. This will put VA interest rates on a competitive
basis with FHA rates and consequently should make more mortgage money
available for VA home loans.
In addition to eligible veterans already discharged from the Armed Forces
since January 31, 1955, it is estimated that about 400,000 cold war veterans
will be separated from the Armed Services each year commencing in 1967.
Many of these veterans will be eligible for GI home loans under the new
legislation.
Home loan benefits for remaining eligible World War II veterans will
terminate July 25, 1967, and Korean War veterans’ entitlement will continue for some, until January 31, 1975.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
45
Waivers and Compromises: The Veterans Administration Central Office
Committee on Waivers and Compromises has been abolished. In lieu thereof,
there has been established a Loan Guaranty Committee on Compromises at
the VA Central Office and a Regional Loan Guaranty Committee on
Waivers and Compromises at each field station having a loan guaranty division.
Decisions of the Regional Committees or the Central Office Committee
denying waiver of indebtedness are appealable to the Board of Veterans
Appeals.
B. FHA Veteran Loan Program:
The Housing and Urban Development Act of 1965, provided, among other
things, a special Federal Housing Administration insured loan program for
all honorably discharged servicemen, including cold war veterans. There is
no limitation in the law as to the number of times an eligible serviceman
may avail himself of these special FHA loan benefits, except in the case of
a veteran who has previously utilized his entitlement under the VA Home
Loan Program. In his case he is barred from any benefits. This discriminates
against certain war veterans. Therefore, in compliance with Resolution No.
577 of the 1965 National Convention, the staff in recent testimony before
the Subcommittee on Housing, House Committee on Banking and Currency,
supported HR 11858, a bill to eliminate the above mentioned unwarranted
discriminatory provision under the present FHA law. If enacted this legislation will give all qualified veterans the same advantage in applying for
the liberalized mortgage financing terms as granted other servicemen.
C. Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act:
Because of the rise in the cost of living your Commission has for several
years approved resolutions requesting legislation to amend Section 300 of the
Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act of 1940, in order to provide increased
protection against the eviction of dependents from premises rendered for
dwelling purposes. On one occasion in the 88th Congress our Bill S 384
passed the Senate on May 28, 1963, however, come to a standstill in the House.
At this time we are pleased to note that the new Cold War GI Bill amended
the aforementioned section of the Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act by
increasing protection for individuals who are renting homes when called to
service from $80 monthly rental to $150 monthly rental.
D. GI Home Loans in Foreign Countries:
In compliance with 1964 National Convention Resolution No. 643 Bill HR
13170 was introduced at the request of The American Legion on March 1,
1966. This legislation if enacted would authorize loans for the purchase or
construction of homes to otherwise eligible veterans who are citizens of the
United States residing in foreign countries.
IV. VETERANS’ PREFERENCE COMMITTEE ACTIVITIES
An Executive Section of the Veterans’ Preference Committee, Chairmaned
by Raymond R. McEvoy met in conjunction with the Economic Commission
meetings of March 1-3, 1966. Those addressing the Committee and who were
most helpful in our deliberations were the following officials of the Civil
Service Commission: John W. Macy, Jr., Chairman; L. J. Andolsek, Vice
Chairman; Robert E. Hampton, Commissioner; George F. Dwyer, Director,
Career Placement Service.
A. Civil Service Liaison Service:
The revised Liaison Service between veteran organizations and the Civil
Service Commission as initiated last year, wherein Vice Chairman L. J. Andolsek was assigned the responsibility of representing the Civil Service Commission in contacts and consultations with major veteran organizations at the
national level is working very well. Vice Chairman Andolsek, has addressed
most of the Economic Commission meetings, including Area Conferences since
assuming this responsibility. This top level contact has made it possible to
keep abreast of all Federal personnel administration matters, especially those
in the field of veterans’ preference. Quite frequently conferences are sched-
46
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
uled by the Commissioner’s office to afford representatives of veteran organizations the opportunity to sit down with policymaking officials of the
Civil Service Commission and other government agencies to discuss veterans’
preference, proposed changes in Civil Service Commission regulations and
procedures, and other matters of mutual interest.
B. Preference for Cold War Veterans:
Section 2 of the Veterans’ Preference Act is amended by virtue of the
“Cold War GI Bill.” Preference in Federal employment is now extended on
the same basis as is currently applicable to war veterans, to honorably separated members of the Armed Forces who have served on active duty, (other
than for training) for more than 180 consecutive days after January 31,
1955. It should be noted, however, that the 180 consecutive days of active
duty as required for preference under the new law will not apply to Korean
War veterans with service between April 28, 1952 and July 1, 1955,
who have heretofore been entitled under Section 2 (6) of the Veterans’ Preference Act.
Veterans now comprise about 51 percent of the total Federal work force
and about 64 percent of the male Federal work force. With the added
category of preference eligibles, the percentage should increase considerably.
This will mean that the potential case workload of the Economic staff pertaining to Veterans’ Preference matters will be on the increase.
C. Continued Veterans’ Preference Attack:
The House passed Bill HR 6277, as reported on at your last meeting,
which would remove some 10,000 employees of the Department of State,
United States Information Agency and Agency for International Development
from Civil Service and Veterans’ Preference Benefits, is still pending before
the Senate Post Office and Civil Service Committee. Hearings have not as
yet been scheduled. As mentioned in previous reports, if HR 6277 was to
become law, a dangerous precedent would be established and many other
branches of the Federal government would obviously seek similar legislation
to be excluded from Civil Service and veterans’ preference. Resolution No. 76
of the 1965 National Convention specifically opposes Section 29 and 32 of
HR 6277. However, in view of extensive amendments to the original bill,
HR 6277, the Veterans’ Preference Committee and the Economic Commission
when further studying this matter at its recent March meetings decided that a
more pointed resolution should be drawn up. In view of this, a resolution
covering this matter will be submitted to the National Executive Committee
for consideration at its forthcoming meetings May 4-5, 1966.
D. Back Pay Act of 1966:
Some government agencies over the years have failed to comply with recommendations of the Civil Service Commission when employees are ordered
restored retroactively to their positions following illegal or unjustified suspensions, dismissals or demotions. Because of this, many veterans have been
forced to seek remedy in the courts. This has been true even though Section 14
of the Veterans’ Preference Act, in the next to the last provisions states
that, “it shall be mandatory for such administrative officer (who has improperly discharged the veteran) to take such corrective action as the (Civil
Service) Commission finally recommends.” Also Section 19 of the Veterans’
Preference Act states, “Any recommendation by the Civil Service Commission . . . shall be complied with by such agency.”
In view of our deep concern with this matter for the past ten years we
are pleased to report that the Back Pay Act (HR 1647) was approved March
31, 1966 (Public Law 89-380). The Back Pay Act in point with 1964 National
Convention Resolution No. 640, will give all employees, veteran and nonveteran, probationary and career the benefits of the present law at its best,
and liberalize the law by allowing credit for pay increases and accumulation
of annual leave which otherwise would have accrued. In other words, it puts
the employee in the same position he would have been in had the unjustified
or erroneous personnel action not taken place.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN J. FLYNN, Chairman
National Economic Commission
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
47
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Resolutions, Mr. Stone?
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously adopted:
REPORT OP RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION
“Support Legislation to Amend the Cold War GI Bill (Public Law
89-358) to Provide Assistance in On-the-job Training Programs”
Resolution No. 6 (Submitted by: National Economic Commission).
WHEREAS, Approximately 3.5 million ex-servicemen and ex-servicewomen
who were on active duty after January 31, 1955, are now classified as veterans, and
WHEREAS, It is estimated that 2,256,000 (68%) of the 3,327,000 cold
war veterans now in civilian life are in the 25-34 age bracket, with approximately one million of these between the ages of 20 and 24, and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense estimates that during the period
1966-1970 such veterans discharged from the Armed Services will number
from 500,000 to 600,000 annually, with the majority of these newly discharged
veterans in the 20-24 age bracket, and
WHEREAS, There is a continuing demand for skilled workers in virtually
all industries of the nation, and
WHEREAS, The returning cold war veteran is a prime potential
source from which such skilled workers can be recruited and trained, and
WHEREAS, Many thousands of these returning cold war veterans will
not, for reasons beyond their control, be able to further their education
through college or other formal education channels, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Legislative Commission be, and it is hereby authorized
and directed to support legislation in the Congress of the United States to
amend the “Cold War GI Bill” (PL 89-358), so as to provide for assistance
in on-the-job training programs similar to the provisions contained in SubChapter VI, Paragraph 1651 of Title 38, United States Code and thus provide these cold war veterans with better job opportunities, and industry with
a more adequate supply of skilled workers, all to the economic betterment of
our country.
(Subject to Rule 8-B, Approved by Legislative Commission.)
48
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
May 4, 1966
... At 1:30 p. m. the National Executive Committee was called to order
by National Commander Eldon James.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will the Committee come to attention, please.
I will ask the Sergeant-at-Arms to escort the distinguished and charming
guest to the front of the room.
. . . Miss U.S.A. 1966 was escorted to the rostrum.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: As some of you may know, the
48th National Convention of The American Legion will be held in Washington, D. C. on August 26th to September 1st, and this has something to do
with this pleasant experience this afternoon.
One of the strongest impressions that I carried away from Viet Nam
when I visited recently was the morale of our fighting men. We are pleased
and honored this afternoon to have with us a young lady who personally
can claim a generous portion of the credit for the good spirit of our young
men there.
The reason is obvious.
Already a veteran of Bob Hope’s well remembered tour to serve Viet
Nam last December, this lovely young lady is planning another return visit
to Viet Nam with Vic Damone’s special troop next summer.
Before that duty, she will visit Guantanamo for the troops there. Miss
U.S.A. incidentally is a product of the Commonwealth of Virginia. She is the
daughter of a Marine Corps War II combat veteran, she was a secretary at
the Pentagon for the Air Force—no partiality among the services. This
gracious young lady, and she is gracious, because she hasn’t forgotten, shall
I say, the old timers who once wore a uniform, is here in the capacity of
an ambassador of goodwill, Miss U.S.A., Dianna Lynn Batts, to inspire the
boys over there to help to win and inspire us here today, may I present Miss
U.S.A., Dianna Lynn Batts.
DIANNA LYNN BATTS
Miss U.S.A., 1966
On behalf of the City of Washington, D. C., I would like to extend an
invitation to the National Commander and all Legionnaires to come to Washington in August for the 48th Annual Convention, thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The invitation is beautiful, the
courier is better.
Today, and on behalf of The American Legion, I want to present to you
a certificate of appreciation. This certificate cites not only your patriotic
contribution to the cause of freedom in Viet Nam, but your fine interest
as ambassador of good will, and it reads as follows:
“The American Legion commends this gracious young lady, who as Miss
U.S.A. made personal and patriotic contributions supporting the policy of
the United States of America in assisting the South Vietnamese people to
defend themselves against the onslaught of Communistic invasion and subversion.
“She visited twenty United States military bases in South Viet Nam
and traveled more than 150,000 miles in her successful efforts to bolster
the morale of combat troops in this war-torn land and frontier of freedom.
“The American Legion is proud to have her as an Ambassador of Good
Will to extend invitations to its 48th Annual National Convention in Washington, D. C., August 26-September 1, 1966.”
Signed, C. D. DeLoach, Chairman, James C. Watkins, Director.
This is properly inscribed, and this is our plaque for you.
May I have your attention, please? Past Commander Griffith.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
49
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GRIFFITH: Is that Miss Virginia
that I see there in front of this group?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen of the Committee and
guests, Dianna as you have heard has spent considerable time in Viet Nam.
She talked with many of our representatives there. She came away with a
deep affection as many of you have with respect to the work our men are
doing and here for a few minutes she is going to tell you about that, Dianna.
MISS BATTS: First of all, I would like to thank you for this certificate
of appreciation. It was quite an honor to come down here today and to meet
you. I want to meet as many as I can, and I know that I will take back
many, many wonderful memories of my visit and look forward to your arrival in Washington in August.
I guess it was about six months ago that I made a trip with Bob Hope
overseas to Viet Nam, and when I think of all the trips that I have taken
this year that will be the one most remembered, because to me it was the fulfillment of doing something. We went over and tried to boost the morale of
many young men. We went to about 28 military installations and in that time,
I think I saw more men than I ever have in my whole life, and I am not
complaining.
It was quite a trip as far as feelings went. I know that when we left
California to go to Viet Nam, we all had a feeling of excitement that we
were going to Viet Nam, but it wasn’t until we were there that we realized
that there was a more important purpose, and that purpose was to be there
amongst the boys and their feelings and actions. We were able to talk to
many young men and in talking to them, we found out they realized that they
had a purpose in being there. That purpose was you sitting here, and
their mothers and fathers and their brothers and sisters and their wives and
their beloved ones, and they were glad that they were there, and glad that
they were fighting for this country.
We went to many hospitals, and we tried to boost the morale of young
men who were injured and would never be the same. And they realized
this. But they had the courage, and they were so wonderful m their thoughts
of saying that if they had to do it again, they would, because they loved
their country.
I learned so much through this trip. I learned so much from the young
men there, and in every man’s eye there was one look, and that was a look
of gratitude. They couldn’t show enough gratitude for what you were doing
there.
And at this point, I would like to say that you all honor Bob Hope.
Well, I think the world of him. I think he is not only the greatest entertainer in the world, but he is the most wonderful man I know. He is sincere
and humble, and the men think of him this way. I was so happy to be a part
of the trip, to be a part of Bob Hope’s show. We loved our trip over there,
and when we put on our last show, our eyes were full of tears, because we
know that this was the last show that we would be amongst the boys. And
because of the very, very tight security, the boys wouldn’t know until the
night before or even that morning that we were coming, and it was very*
very short notice before you would go out on the stage. And you couldn t
see the end of the crowd. And that is how many that wanted to see the show.
And I am so happy that I had a chance to be part of this. If I ever do have
a chance to do so again, I will. And I hope to go back to Viet Nam again.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I think the welcome you have received, the response from these men indicates our appreciation to you for the
wonderful work you are doing on behalf of God and Country and the men in
the service, and before you leave, I would like to introduce another gracious
Virginian, I would like to introduce my wife to the Committee.
. . . Mrs. Eldon James acknowledged her introduction.
. .. Miss U.S.A., 1966 was escorted from the rostrum.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following report was received and filed:
50
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
REPORT OF NATIONAL AMERICANISM COMMISSION
Daniel J. O’Connor (New York), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN O’CONNOR: Mr. Commander, members of
the National Executive Committee, even with the Stars and Stripes in my
eyes and the shamrock in my voice, it is a heck of a position to be placed
in to follow the act we just had.
. . . National Vice Commander Phillips in the Chair.
The National Americanism Commission met in the National Executive Committee Room, National Headquarters, The American Legion, Indianapolis,
Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966. There were nineteen members of the Commission present; National Commander’s Representative, Mr. Donald G. Hanning;
Dr. J. E. Martie, Chairman of the Counter-Subversive Activities Committee;
an
_d National Executive Committee Liaison to the National Americanism Commission, Mr. L. O. Bickel of West Virginia. The members of the Commission
were delighted to have as a guest during their deliberations Mrs. Charles
G. Shaw of Paxton, Illinois, National Chairman of the Americanism Committee of the American Legion Auxiliary. Also present was National Chaplain Rev. Alfred C. Thompson.
In the interest of conserving your valuable time, this Report will deal
briefly with the operations of the programs and recommendations on resolutions considered at this meeting.
LEGION BASEBALL
Progress of the 1966 season was reviewed with strong indications of expanding activity in many areas in keeping with the exploding youth population. Staff preparations for the tournaments, supervised by National Headquarters, which will climax the 41st year of competition, are progressing satisfactorily.
Invitations for 1967 Regional Tournaments were studied, with awards
being made as follows:
Regional No. 1—Manchester, New Hampshire
Regional No. 2—Bridgeton, New Jersey
Regional No. 3—Gadsden, Alabama ,
Regional No. 4—Memphis, Tennessee
Regional No. 5—Canton, Illinois
Regional No. 6—Hastings, Nebraska
Regional No. 7—Helena, Montana
Regional No. 8—Ontario, California
Invitations for the 1968 World Series were received from two communities.
After considerable discussion and consideration, Manchester, New Hampshire (Henry J. Sweeney Post No. 2) was awarded this important event. A
bid was also received from Bridgeton, New Jersey.
Pairings for the 1966 Tournaments were made and schedules were approved. Location of these Tournaments was assigned a year ago.
D&fes and Pa'r'nSs for the 1967 World Series, previously awarded to
Memphis, Tennessee, were approved from August 28 through September 4,
Eddie Fisher, of the Chicago White Sox, was designated as the 1965
American Legion Baseball Graduate of the Year. Commander L. Eldon James
is scheduled to present the award in program ceremonies at Chicago, July 30.
Your attention is drawn to the fact that Babe Ruth League, Inc., a youth
baseball organization previously functioning in the 13-15 year-old age bracket
has announced a program of expansion into the 16-18 year-old age group!
ihis is in direct competition with our American Legion Baseball Program.
A representative of the Babe Ruth League Program met with Director Webb,
Assistant Director Rulon of this Commission, and me in Indianapolis, March
S ted there
ilevel.
' , em
v? we seriously
. would question.
be no conflict
programs
the local
This
The between
matter these
will be
observedat carefully
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
51
throughout the summer in all parts of the country. Should any of you have
personal knowledge of problems developing between The American Legion
Baseball Program and the Babe Ruth League, the National Americanism Commission would appreciate your bringing the circumstances to our staff’s attention immediately. Gentlemen, I cannot overemphasize this part of this
report.
COUNTER-SUBVERSIVE
The present status of the National Americanism Commission’s publication,
Firing Line, was discussed by members of the Commission and it was the
consensus of opinion that it is more acceptable in its present form than it
ever has been and that the material therein can be utilized and quoted since
it is all factual and documented. We are continuing to stress the importance
of this publication and have been engaged in an extensive promotional campaign during recent months. Copies were sent to 13,000 American Legion
Auxiliary Units, with an accompanying letter from Mrs. Charles G. Shaw,
National Chairman of the Americanism Committee of the American Legion
Auxiliary, urging them to subscribe to this publication and then distribute
copies to school libraries and public libraries; copies have gone to . all members of the Americanism Commission, all members of the Americanism Council and members of the Counter-Subversive Activities Committee, which, means
that approximately 1,500 of these individuals have been reached; additionally,
some 35,000 Post Commanders and Post Adjutants have received copies
through the pages of Advance, In the near future, a letter, over the signature
of Dr. J. E. Martie, Chairman, will be addressed to all members of the
Counter-Subversive Activities Committee, urging that they support this
publication in a positive way. We are happy to report that income for t inng
Line so far this year is up $1,000 over the corresponding period last year.
We definitely feel this is a direct result of this promotional program and
we would like to mention that, in any type of promotion, a 4% or o% return
is considered excellent.
This year, we have again made up a Sample copy of Firing Line for
insertion in Department Convention packets. Director Webb sent a letter to
all Departments, advising them of the availability of this Sample copy and
enclosed an order blank for their convenience. The response has been overwhelming and we are happy to report that to date we have received requests
from 39 Departments for a total of 46,350 copies.
Correspondence dealing with counter-subversive subjects continues to be
heavy. This involves careful study and evaluation of each letter before a
reply is forwarded. It has been and continues to be the policy of this Uommission to answer all correspondence, no matter how difficult and involved
it is.
ORATORICAL CONTEST
The following dates for the 1967 National High School Oratorical Contest
were adopted by the Americanism Commission:
a. National Regional Contests, Monday, April 3, 1967
b. National Sectional Contests, Monday, April 10, 1967
c. National Finals Contest, Thursday, April 13,1967
d. Deadline date for Departments to certify their State winners to the
National Contest, March 20, 1967.
After due deliberation on the seven Departments who had submitted invitations, the 1967 Contest was awarded to the Department of Nebraska.
Your Commission recommends the sponsorship of a meeting here at National Headquarters for Department Oratorical Chairmen to review procedures, rules and to update phases of the National Oratorical program. It is
believed this will be very valuable to the future of the program and lead to
greater support and participation within and outside of our organization.
Plans for the conference will be forwarded to each Department with a request
that each Department Oratorical Contest Chairman be present to participate.
Each member of the National Executive Committee will receive copies of the
52
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
correspondence and we urge your support in helping the Americanism Commission to make this first Oratorical Conference a success.
EDUCATION AND SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM
A meeting of the Joint Committee of The American Legion and the National Education Association was held on April 30, May 1-2, where emphasis
was given to common interests in the field of education.
It was reported that the Joint Committee’s brochure on the new program
Homebase had a distribution in excess of 100,000 copies since its adoption
at the National Convention in Portland, Oregon. Requests for the material
revealed its wide use among schools as well as community groups outside the
sponsoring organizations.
During the school year requests for Guidelines for Teaching About Communism, exceeded 17,500 copies, with most of the copies going to future social
studies teachers currently attending colleges.
The Education and Scholarship program has continued to expand and
serves the increased number of high school and college students. The annual
distribution of the fifteenth edition of Need A Lift? will exceed 109,000 copies.
The updated popular A Guide for Parents and Students, which is provided
to students at all levels of high school, has had a distribution in excess of
one-half million copies since school started last fall.
OTHER PROGRAMS
The Americanism Commission expressed strong support for our continued
efforts in implementing our programs as they relate to Boys’ Clubs, Boy
Scouts, Boys State, Boys Nation, and other programs administered by this
Commission. I might add here that, at the session of the 1966 Boys Nation
program to be held on the campus of the University of Maryland, the subject
of cold war education will he included as an area of study for thsse young
men.
CONCLUSION
We are grateful to this National Executive Committee, the Finance Commission and The American Legion Magazine for their splendid cooperation
and assistance in promoting the Americanism Youth programs.
We have a tentative program scheduled on the campus of the University
of Maryland and we hope to have a member of the “Green Berets” present
to give an account of his experiences in South Viet Nam.
Just before I conclude as I give you the recommendations on the Resolutions, I would like to make a very terse observation, and I ask for your
forbearance and attention.
My dear friends, the American Flag has been desecrated on college campuses in this, country, and it has been desecrated on the so-called stage in
Greenwich Village in New York City, and while your National Commander
m his role as the leader of our great organization asked the President of the
United States by letter only a few weeks ago to call a White House conference on the origin of the United States Flag, he received an answer of
encouragement in this sense, that The American Legion was advised, and he
was advised to have the Flag Code revision taken up with the Congress of
the United States.
. Well, I submit to you that it will be given to you by Roy Stone in a few
minutes from now, a resolution which I feel merits your very share and
devoted attention.
You know that it was no crime to assassinate President Kennedy Well
it is no crime to desecrate the American Flag, federally. It is no crime to
spit on it or destroy it. Now the time has come for the greatest veterans
organization m the world to support legislation making it a crime to desecrate the American Flag.
My dear friends, one final observation concerning the Babe Ruth League.
You know as well as I do that since the first day of June, 1925, Legionnaire
volunteers, giving their time and their effort and their talents have made
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
53
our American Legion Baseball Program the magnificent accomplishment that
it is and of which we are proud. But this competition from the Babe Ruth
League is not coming from men who have the ideals of American youth at
heart in the same manner as you have. Rather, they are men who are receiving executive salaries pouring out through all parts of the country seeking commercial as well as major league support to increase that subsidy, and
the time has come for us to consider some increased financial support for
our American Legion Baseball Program. And this means that we will have
to go before the major leagues to seek an increased subsidy. And we will also
not frown upon any legitimate proposition put to us by an enterprise, that
is not identified with alcohol or tobacco, so that we shall not be criticized
in what we are attempting to do in order to expand our baseball program
because of the youth explosion in this country and these population statistics
mean that we in the National Americanism Commission .must look to the
future and not rest on our laurels. And that is why it is important that we
have increased support for our baseball program.
Gentlemen, going to the resolutions:
At the meeting of the National Americanism Commission, held at National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966, the Commission considered a total of seventeen (17) resolutions, which were acted upon
as follows: Action was deferred on two (2) resolutions; nine (9) resolutions
were recommended for rejection; four (4) resolutions were recommence
for approval and two (2) were consolidated and recommended for approva .
Defer Action
Resolution, Register No. 1238 (Michigan)—Subject: Opposition to Hiring of Professors and Teachers Who Are Not Loyal to United States Government.
Resolution, Register No. 1240 (Pennsylvania)—Subject: Protesting An
Individual’s Unpatriotic Actions Against United States Government s Policy
in Viet Nam.
Rejected
Resolution No. 10 (Florida)—Subject: Display of the American Flag.
Reason: Contrary to the established policy of The American Legion.
Resolution No. 88 (Massachusetts)—Subject: Change Rule 8 of American Legion Baseball Rules. And I submit that they might have made a mistake or a typographical error on Rule 8, they were probably referring to
Rule 3. Reason: Contrary to the established successful policy of The American
Legion.
Resolution No. 388 (Louisiana)—Subject:
Endorsement of Statement
Concerning Communist Strategy. Reason: Can be handled administratively
by a letter to said organization.
I happen to be a member of that organization, and certainly there will be
no affront of our handling this matter administratively.
. . . National Commander James resumed the Chair.
Resolution No. 1212 (New Jersey)—Subject: Amend American Legion
Baseball Rules. Reason: Contrary to the established successful policy of
The American Legion and the expressed recommendation of the Department
Baseball Chairmen.
Resolution, Register No. 1219 (New Jersey)—Subject: American Legion
Baseball Rule Book Revision. Reason: Already the established policy of
The American Legion and, in the absence of documentation as to the need
for a change, the rule remains the successful policy of The American Legion.
Resolution, Register No. 1225 (Tennessee)—Subject:
South Viet Nam
Demonstrations. Reason: Already the established policy of The American Legion through Resolution No. 19, adopted by the National Executive Committee,
May, 1965.
54
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
Resolution, Register No. 1227 (New York)—Subject:
Opposition To
Anti-American Demonstrations. Reason: Already the established policy of
The American Legion through Resolution No. 19, adopted by the National
Executive Committee, May, 1965.
Resolution, Register No. 1239 (Rhode Island)—Subject: Amendment to
the United States Flag Code. This is praiseworthy, but it is not one from
the standpoint that we thought we could implement.
Resolution, Register No. 1244 (Pennsylvania)—Subject: Change in Rules
National High School Oratorical Contest. Reason: A Department may hold
its Oratorical Contest at any time prior to the deadline.
Recommended For Approval
Resolution No. 10 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject:
ning Religious Programs in the Job Corps Centers.
Plan-
Resolution No. 11 (Pennsylvania Register No. 1242) and (District of
Columbia Register No. 1253)—Subject: Support Legislation Which Would
Make It a Crime to Desecrate the United States Flag.
Resolution No. 12 (New York Register No. 1228)—Subject: Daily Display of the American Flag Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam.
Resolution No. 16 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject: Support Legislation to Amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to Make
Provisions for Necessary Travel Control for United States Residents Outside
of This Country.
Resolution No. 20 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject: Change
in the Method of Selecting the Winner of the William Randolph Hearst
Trophy.
Mr. Commander, that completes our report.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: I move the report be received
and filed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I wonder if, Committeeman Donaldson, if you will alter that motion to receive and file, to receive and file the
first five pages down to “Recommendations on Resolutions.”
MR. DONALDSON: I accept that amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the motion?
MR. LEONARD, Connecticut: I second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded to receive and file that part of the report that goes through page
five; all those in favor signify by saying aye; all opposed no. The ayes
have it and it is so ordered. The first five pages of the report are received
and filed. Committeeman Stone.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL AMERICANISM COMMISSION
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, I move that
the part of the report that deals with the rejected resolutions, deferred action resolutions, be adopted.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: May I make an inquiry? The motion is to approve that part of the report beginning on page six that includes
deferred action and rejected action?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded. All those in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes
have it and it is carried.
Committee Chairman Stone.
55
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were approved:
“Planning Religious Programs in the Job Corps Centers”
Resolution No. 10 (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission).
WHEREAS, The Government of the United States of America has established centers for the training of unemployed young people of our Nation so
that they can be assisted in assuming a meaningful and profitable part in
American Society; and
WHEREAS, The provision for regular religious ministries of Job Corps
Centers has not been provided; and
WHEREAS, The Conference of the Department Chaplains of The American Legion, meeting in Indianapolis, Indiana, on November 4, 1965, went on
record recommending to American Legion Posts located in areas having Job
Corps Centers that, as a part of their program of Service to God and Country, Post Chaplains devise ways and means to initiate action among ami cooperation with churches to provide religious services at Job Corps Centers,
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis,. Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion go on record endorsing the action of the Department Chaplains Conference as heretofore stated, and that a recommendation be made to the Job Corps to do its part in planning more intensive
religious programs in the Job Corps Centers.
“Support Legislation Which Would Make It a Crime to Desecrate the
United States Flag”
Resolution No. 11 (Res. Reg. No. 1242 and No. 1253)
(Submitted by:
National Americanism Commission. (Approved: National Legislative Commission under Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, Wide national publicity has been given to groups and individuals who have demonstrated against the foreign policy of the United States
in Yiet Nam; and
WHEREAS, These demonstrations have at times included desecration of
our National Colors by tearing, burning and trampling our Flag underfoot;
and
WHEREAS, Members of The American Legion and all loyal Americans
recognize our National Colors as the symbol of freedom and liberty; and
WHEREAS, It is this same freedom and liberty which permits these individuals the freedom of demonstration; and
WHEREAS, Members of The American Legion and all loyal Americans
are violently opposed to any demonstration which results in dishonor and
desecration of our National Colors, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that it go on record as opposing any demonstration resulting in desecration of our National Colors, and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion support legislation which would
make it a crime, including a monetary fine or imprisonment or both, to
desecrate the Flag of the United States.
“Daily Display of the American Flag Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 12 (Res. Reg. No. 1228) (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission).
WHEREAS, The current Viet Nam war has been plagued with subversive actions on the part of minority groups within the citizenship of these
great United States of America by such actions as protest demonstrations
wherein there have been posters denouncing our support in View Nam, at-
56
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
tempted blocking of shipments to our troops, attempted blocking of troop
movement, burning of draft cards by professed objectors, and other related
incidents on our college and university campuses; and
WHEREAS, Our military personnel are in daily combat in Viet Nam,
being killed and wounded during this period of undeclared war; and
WHEREAS, It is the avowed policy of The American Legion to foster
and perpetuate a one hundred percent Americanism, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion rededicate itself through all its membership by
encouragement of flying the greatest symbol of this democracy of ours through
the daily display of the American Flag by each member until peace is restored in Viet Nam.
“Support Legislation to Amend the Immigration and Nationality Act
to Make Provisions for Necessary Travel Control for United States
Residents Outside of This Country”
Resolution No. 16 (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission.
(Approved: National Legislative Commission)).
WHEREAS, There has been introduced in the Senate a Bill (S 3243),
to amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to make provisions for necessary travel control for United States residents outside of this country; and
WHEREAS, A companion Bill (HR 14488), has been introduced in the
House of Representatives, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it is in full accord and support of the proposed legislation and that
copies of this resolution be forwarded to the President of the Senate and
Speaker of the House and to The American Legion Legislative Division.
“Change in the Method of Selecting the Winner of the William
Randolph Hearst Trophy”
Resolution No. 20 (Submitted by:
National Americanism Commission
(National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee.) (Approved: Internal Affairs Division)).
WHEREAS, the William Randolph Hearst Trophy is now awarded annually to that Department which is judged from written reports to have sponsored the best all around Americanism activities during the previous Legion
year—July 1 to July 1—with three members of the National Americanism
Commission acting as judges; and,
WHEREAS, in order to improve and enlarge competition for said Trophy
a change in the method of selecting the winner is needed; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion
in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that it
does hereby authorize the National Americanism Commission to change the
method of selecting the winner of the William Randolph Hearst Trophy in the
1966-67 Legion year, and subsequent years, from the present system, as heretofore outlined, to a system using a compilation by Departments, consisting of
a percentage point system based on information contained in the Americanism and Post Activities report forms, already in existence.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE : Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
ADDRESS BY ROBERT H. MILLER
Director of the Department of State’s Viet Nam Working Group
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Gentlemen and guests of the
Committee, may I have your attention, please? Those who do not have seats,
would you make yourself comfortable?
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
57
We have a special speaker at this time who has just come in from Washington to talk off the record. If there are any people here inclined to take
notes for reporting to the news media or recording any of this proceeding,
I would ask that they desist. The speaker is here to provide us with an
up-to-date assessment of the Viet Nam situation.
This gentleman has been made available to us by the Department of State
upon my personal request to Secretary of State Dean Rusk to provide us
with a Department spokesman for a factual presentation.
Mr. Robert H. Miller is Director of the Viet Nam Working Group within
the State Department. He is a native of Washington State, received his AB
Degree from Stanford University, and his Masters from Harvard. He is a
veteran of service in the United States Army from 1945 to 1947. Mr. Miller
entered the Foreign Service of the United States in 1951, and since then has
served in our NATO mission in Paris, and in our Embassy at Saigon. In
Viet Nam, he served under three United States Ambassadors from 1962 to
1965. His last assignment there was as Deputy Chief of the Political Section.
I am pleased to present to this Committee at this time Mr. Robert H.
Miller, Director of the Department of State’s Viet Nam Working Group.
Mr. Miller spoke to the National Executive Committee off the record.
REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5, 1966
by
Thomas E. Whelan (North Dakota), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
You have been furnished a copy of the Advance Report of the Foreign
Relations Commission covering the action taken at the Washington Conference meetings held 1, 2 and 3 March 1966.
An Executive Section of the Commission met at National Headquarters 2, 3
and 4 May 1966 to consider matters that have arisen since the March meeting.
Present were Thomas E. Whelan, North Dakota, Chairman; Henry H. Dudley and John H. Keriakedes, Nebraska. Allyn C. Donaldson, District of Columbia, Chairman NEC Liaison Committee also met with the members of
your Commission.
The Section approved of the final resolution forms to implement the recommendations of the Advance Report and agreed that three Register Resolutions, filed since the March Meeting, should be referred to the Pre-Convention session of the Commission.
The Section was saddened by the report of the untimely passing of John
J. Barnhardt, North Carolina, long-time member of the Commission. His astute
and timely counsel and rare good humor will be greatly missed by all members
of the Commission and The American Legion as well as his community, state
and nation.
This concludes the report of actions taken at this Indianapolis Meeting.
Respectfully submitted,
THOMAS E. WHELAN, Chairman
The Advance Report of the National Foreign Relations Commission
is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
Your Foreign Relations Commission met as authorized in Washington,
D. C., on March 1, 2, and 3, 1966, in conjunction with the 6th Annual Wash-
58
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
ington Conference of The American Legion. All sessions were held in the
Hall of Flags Auditorium of the Legion Building, other than for a visit to
the Department of State.
The following members of the Commission were present:
Thomas E. Whelan, Chairman, North Dakota
James P. Heneghan, Vice Chairman, New York
Frank E. Barnett, Commander’s Representative, Illinois
John J. Barnhardt, North Carolina
Jack Beck, Pennsylvania
Fred Colehour, Illinois
William T. Coyner, Virginia
Allyn C. Donaldson, District of Columbia
Henry H. Dudley, Nebraska
Walter C. Head, Jr., Alabama
E. Dean Hunter, Colorado
Rogers Kelly, Texas
John H. Keriakedes, Nebraska
Jacob Kessler, Massachusetts
Thomas J. Kirk, Mississippi
Frank K. Knapp, Wyoming
George T. Lewis, Jr., Tennessee
Eli A. Marcoux, New Hampshire
Frost P. Patterson, Iowa
Dr. Carl J. Rees, Delaware
M. A. Fred Rennie, Oklahoma
David C. Stripling, Georgia
Norbert Schmelkes, Mexico, Ex Officio
In addition to Norbert Schmelkes, Chairman of the Foreign Relations
Council, the following Vice Chairmen of the Council participated in the Commission’s program:
M. C. “Mike” Gehr, Louisiana; George Vieto, Canal
Zone; and Herbert D. Black, South Carolina. Representing the NEC Liaison
Subcommittee throughout the meetings were: Allyn C. Donaldson, District
of Columbia, Chairman; and Gilberto M. Font, Puerto Rico. The Commission
was pleased also to have former chairman and Past National Vice Commander Emilio S. Iglesias present during the meetings.
Miss Vivian M. Titus, Chairman, Foreign Relations Committee, the American Legion Auxiliary, served as the Auxiliary’s liaison representative and
provided the Commission with a report on the Auxiliary’s 1966 foreign relations project, the Philippines Barrio Program. In this project, the Auxiliary
raises funds to furnish—in cooperation with CARE—tools and self-help
supplies for Philippine villagers. Miss Titus also presented the Auxiliary’s
recently developed slide series on its over-all foreign relations program.
Through the services of Mr. Walter McPherson of the Department of
State’s Office of Public Services, the Commission received a series of special
briefings at the Department, on the morning of March 2. The scheduled
speakers on this occasion were: Robert M. Sayre, Deputy Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Inter-American Affairs; J. Robert Schaetzel, Deputy Assytont Secretary Bureau of European Affairs; and, Thomas S. Estes,
United States Ambassador to Upper Volta.
During this session, the Commission was greatly honored by the appearance0for
! Secretary
of State
Dean with
Rusk.our
Mr.
Rusk, at
initiative
had
asked
an opportunity
to meet
members
andhisto own
discuss
informally
the key issues concerning United States involvement in Viet Nam. National
Commander Eldon James attended this portion of the morning’s program
and asked the Secretary for his thoughts as to additional ways in which the
Legion might be helpful in bolstering public support for United States efforts m Viet Nam. Mr. Rusk s response was to the effect that local Posts of
The American Legion would be ideally suited for serving to bring about
greater understanding of the Vietnamese conflict, the nature of the United
States commitment to South Viet Nam, and the relationship of the struggle
there to our own security interests. He pointed out that the Legion could
provide the necessary leadership to help solidify public support for the ad-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
59
ministration’s Viet Nam policy by sponsoring forums in which community
leaders and representatives of other patriotic and civic organizations might
take part.
In the meetings at the Legion Building, the Commission’s program included addresses by: Ambassador Jacob D. Beam and General Fred M. Dean,
Assistant Directors of the United States Arms Control and Disarmament
Agency; Ambassador Leonard Unger, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State
for Far Eastern Affairs (and Chairman, Viet Nam Coordinating Committee) ; General Harry G. Woodbury, Engineering Agent for the AtlanticPacific Interoceanic Canal Study Commission; William J. Crockett, Deputy
Under Secretary of State for Administration; and, Frank R. Barnett, President of the National Strategy Information Center (also National Commander’s
Representative on the Foreign Relations Commission). In addition, Allyn C.
Donaldson, Chairman, NEC Foreign Relations Liaison Subcommittee, provided
the Commission with a comprehensive report on the Newcomb Mott case, the
American who was imprisoned in the USSR last Fall for entering that country without a visa, and who allegedly took his own life while being transported
to a labor camp. Mr. Donaldson is Director of the State Department’s
Office of Special Consular Services. Wilbur Walker, Adjutant of the Department of Virginia, spoke to the Commission as representative of W. C. “Dan”
Daniel, Coordinator of the Foreign Relations-National Security Commissions.
Past National Commander Daniel was unable to be present personally by
reason of his duties as a member of the Senate of the Virginia State Legislature. Mr. Walker furnished the Commission with a report on Commander
James’ October visit to Viet Nam, and on the purposes and progress of
The American Legion’s Viet Nam Relief Fund.
On the evening of March 1, the Department of State American Legion Post No. 68, District of Columbia Department, held a reception honoring
the members of the Foreign Relations Commission. This took place in the
Diplomatic Suite of the State Department Building. The affair was attended
by Secretary of State Rusk and other principal officers of the Department;
by National Commander Eldon James and other Legion officials; by Mrs.
Walter H. Glynn, National President of the Auxiliary, and members of her
party. Approximately 350 persons were present, most of whom were employees of the Department of State. The Commission unanimously approved a
resolution of appreciation to Commander George S. Knight and the members of Post 68.
In its business session, the Commission dealt with two pending resolutions
referred for study by the 1965 National Convention. They are identified below,
with an indication of the action taken on each.
Resolution No. 259 (Mexico)—“Employment of American Citizens Abroad
by United States Department of State.”
The Commission accepted the recommendation of the subcommittee, to which
this resolution was assigned for study, to the effect that it be disapproved.
The subcommittee took into its consideration the information contained in the
letter of February 7, 1966, from the Deputy Under Secretary of State for
Administration to the Commission’s staff liaison. The letter reviewed the
State Department’s policies concerning the hiring by its overseas posts of
Americans residing abroad and agreed with the resolution’s “general proposition that Americans resident overseas constitute a valuable actual and
potential asset to the Department.” It went on to report that, on December
8, 1965, all overseas posts were asked to prepare a study on the availability
in their respective areas of citizens of the United States qualified for employment, and an analysis of the types of positions for which resident
Americans could be employed “in place of long-term staff employees available for world-wide service.” These reports have not as yet been received
from all posts. The Commission’s staff is instructed to remain informed concerning the findings of this study, which may lead to further liberalization
of State Department policy on employment of Americans residing abroad.
Resolution No. 439 (Oregon)—“Support United States Program of Establishing Free Educational Television in Free Foreign Countries.”
80
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
The subcommittee which studied this resolution felt that it was too narrow
in scope and, in order not to prejudice the case it makes for greater use of
educational TV in the underdeveloped nations which the United States is
attempting to help, recommended that it be returned to the originating department for revision if the department sees fit. The subcommittee suggested that the intent of the resolution might be broadened to include reference to all modern techniques of assistance to underdeveloped countries, in
keeping with The American Legion’s overall position on the United States
foreign aid program. The Commission accepted the recommendation and, upon
the filing of this report, the staff will proceed to refer the matter back to
the department concerned, with a full explanation.
The Commission had before it only one “register” resolution for study.
This is Register No. 1225, on the subject of “South Viet Nam Demonstrations,” submitted by the Tennessee Department Executive Committee. The
resolution is concerned with demonstrations within this country against United
States policy in Viet Nam. The Commission therefore believes that the resolution should be reassigned to the Americanism Commission. This would be in
keeping with the policy followed at the last National Convention, whereby
resolutions dealing with the internal or domestic aspects of our Government’s
Viet Nam position were handled through the Convention Committee on Americanism.
In addition to the foregoing actions, the Commission approved the report of
its special subcommittee on new resolutions as follows:
I. That the Commission recommend that the National Executive Committee,
by appropriate resolution—
A. Commend the administration’s policy of support for Viet Nam;
B. Reiterate the position of The American Legion on Viet Nam, as stated
at Portland and previously; and
C. Urge the taking of more vigorous measures for halting the flow of
supplies to the enemy, as military judgment determines necessary, including denial of the use of the port of Haiphong (by blockading, mining, bombing, or whatever means are required).
II. That the Commission recommend the approval by the National Executive
Committee of an American Legion Post program of support for United States
efforts, in keeping with the suggestion of the Secretary of State. For such a
program, the Commission contemplates that appropriate informational materials would be made available to posts, through department headquarters,
for the use of local Legion representatives in organizing and leading community-wide forums on support of United States policy in Viet Nam. Information on availability of visual aids would also be disseminated regularly,
as has already been done (through Advance and The American Legion News
Service) in the case of certain films produced by the armed services. The
Commission staff would stand ready to provide specific information as required by posts implementing this worthwhile patriotic program.
Resolutions to give effect to these recommendations have been prepared
and submitted to your Subcommittee on Resolutions.
... Upon motion by Mr. Wilson, Florida, seconded by Mr. Donaldson,
District of Columbia, the report was received and filed except for the resolutions.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are there resolutions, Mr. Chairman?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we have two
resolutions from the Foreign Relations Commission which have been received in the last hour and one half. They are not on the gentlemen’s desks
and if it is the desire of the National Executive Committeemen I will read
the resolutions in full and take them up at this time, otherwise we will wait
the pleasure of the National Executive Committee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What is your pleasure gentlemen? Do you want to hear the resolutions read or do you want to wait for
the digest?
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
61
MR. WILSON, Florida: I make a motion to defer until the digest is here.
. . . The motion was seconded.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We will consider that as consent,
and we will go on.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: On the subject that is under
discussion, I have a proposal to submit to this Commission if you want me to
submit it at this time, the processing of the present policy in the District of
Columbia. We can use this time now.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I think it better go to the Commission. Has it been to the Commission? Are you submitting a proposal directly to this Committee?
MR. DONALDSON: No, I am submitting a proposed procedure which
the various Posts may undertake to carry out our policy and carry out the
request of General Green.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is this coming from the Commission or coming directly from you?
MR. DONALDSON: Directly from me.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, sir.
MR. DONALDSON: Mr. Commander, members of the Commission, you
will recall that last October General Green of the Marine Corps appeared
before this Committee and asked for your assistance in carrying out their
program in the Viet Nam.
After his appearance before this Commission, we went back to Washington, D. C. and asked the General, “What can we do to help you out?” It
developed that the Marine Corps has taken a number of pictures of action
in Viet Nam. They have developed a program whereby these colored pictures in some cases are sent to the individual who requested to have a meeting. We used the District of Columbia for a guinea pig to see how it worked.
We undertook to ask the employees of the Department of State to look
at two pictures, one was called “The Battle”; the other was called “Full
Blaze.”
“The Battle” is an actual operation in Viet Nam in which the functional operation of the Marine Corps takes place. Here you see in action
what is taking place in Viet Nam. As I heard questions from the floor here
today, what is taking place, and what is going on in Viet Nam. There is an
old Chinese saying that a picture is worth 1,000 words, and these pictures
are worth many thousands of words.
On the first exhibit, 450 people filled the auditorium. We had hoped to
hold a second showing. We tried then at the departmental monthly meeting,
and we showed the pictures again, and they were well received. It is now
accepted that the Marine Corps will undertake this same service to Posts
throughout the United States of America.
Now, the “Full Blaze” shows in operation the handling of the public under the community program. This is what your troops are doing now to try
and engender the good will and bring behind our fighting forces a sense of
cooperation instead of one of antagonism that has existed for some time.
A team consisting of three with a hand-carried projector and a film will
come to your Post any place in the United States, show the picture and give
a statement of how things are going as the Marine Corps sees it.
Now, there is being distributed to you a list which is marked “Location
of NCR Training Facilities.” These are all the states, the nearest Post
of the Marine Corps. You can address them and ask them to send a film
and if you want to have it shown it will be shown.
Your second list is a list of the films which we have set up. We have
here in the library of the Headquarters these films. The Adjutant tells me
that the demand is substantial, there is a waiting list. Now if you want it
done in your local community, the Marine Corps will send out the team to
show you these films. We suggest that you invite in the ministers, the com-
62
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
munity leaders, the Mayor, people who want to know what is going: on in
Viet Nam.
Our experience was that people would come to us and say, “I would like
to contribute to your CARE program to help out Viet Nam. We have added
to the membership of Posts the people that want to be affiliated because of
the work that we are doing.
I commend the Commander for his “Show Your Colors” Program. We
have now over $100,000 collected in funds that are being used in Viet Nam
on this community program.
This will assist the furtherance of both of these programs.
You also have in what is being distributed to you, what is known as the
information sheet on the Marine Corps programs. And then you will get the
throwaway which is given to all the public and attached to it is a CARE
program envelope with which your contributions could be made to CARE
to carry out this program.
We feel this has been a successful operation. We recommend it to you
throughout the country, and we hope that you will turn to the Marine
Corps and let them know what your desires are when it comes to the tvDe
of picture you want to see.
., There is a new one now, the “Corps Men.” This picture originates on
the battlefield. They practically pick up the soldier as he is shot. He is carried then into the Field Headquarters, the Red Cross Unit, onto the flattop, back to the United States. These are action photographs, and
I commend them to all of you to try and help the Marine Corps and our
forces in Viet Nam with your action at home, because we need the people
m the grass roots to understand why we are in Viet Nam, and I think
these pictures will tell the story better than all the speeches that we can
hear from people in this country. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman Donaldson, I thank
you for calling this to the attention of the Committee. Let me say this sir
we commend you for bringing to us and recommend to the members’here
that they take it to heart and explore its possibilities. Thank you very
The following report was duly received and filed:
REPORT OF THE
NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMISSION
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5, 1966
James V. Demarest (New York), Chairman
The National Convention Commission met on May 2-3, 1966 with the following members present:
Convention Commission
James V. Demarest, Chairman, New York
Harry L. Foster, Vice Chairman, California
John H. Geiger, Illinois
Bert M. Count, Minnesota
Dr. A. R. Choppin, Louisiana
Thomas Roumell, Michigan
Harry K. Stinger, Pennsylvania
Lawrence E. Hoffman, Florida
John R. McNamara, New York
Donald M. McSween, Tennessee
Henry R. Kruse, Washington
Robert H. Hazen, Oregon
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
63
National Commander’s Representative
Thomas Coll, District of Columbia
NEC Liaison
Louis E. Drago, Chairman, New York
Advisory Board
Maurice Stember, New York
Jack Williams, North Dakota
Tommy E. Jones, West Virginia
Distinguished Guests Committee
A. L. Starshak, Chairman, Illinois
A final report was received from the President of the 1965 Convention
Corporation, Robert Hazen, on the 1965 Convention. Mr. Hazen will be making a report to the National Executive Committee at the conclusion of my
report.
The Chairman of the Contest Supervisory Committee, Don Birkett, appeared before the Commission and outlined certain administrative changes in
procedures to be followed in the conduct of the contest. Also, the Contest
Committee presented a resolution regarding indebtedness of uniformed groups
participating in contests at our National Conventions and this Commission
concurs in this action. The resolution is being submitted through the Subcommittee on Resolutions. From all indications, it would appear that there
will be tremendous contest activity in conjunction with this year’s National
Convention in Washington, D. C. It has been decided that the final Drum
and Bugle Corps Contest which is to be held at District of Columbia Stadium
on August 28, be of the same type as those contests held during the last
two years in that the five top junior corps and the five top senior corps will
participate in the final event.
As you gentlemen know, The Ford Motor Company has for many years
supplied the official autos for our National Conventions. However, during
our meetings we were informed that The Ford Motor Company, because
of a change in policy, could no longer carry on with this program and,
consequently, it is necessary for us to explore the possibility of securing this
type service from another manufacturer.
In view of the termination of our contract with Charles Thorpe of Football Publications for the solicitation of advertising in the National Convention Souvenir Program, authorization is requested for the acceptance of advertising that is offered us on a voluntary basis. A resolution on this subject is being submitted through the Subcommittee on Resolutions.
A report was received from Herbert J. Jacobi, President of the 1966
National Convention Corporation of the District of Columbia, relative to the
progress of plans for the convention and it appears that we can look forward
to an outstanding convention this year.
In recent years the number of cities interested in hosting one of our National Conventions has increased tremendously. A great deal of the Commission’s activities at all meetings involves presentations by these cities. Our
meeting here during the past two days has been no exception. Those cities
appearing before the Commission were:
New Orleans, Louisiana
Atlanta, Georgia
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Boston, Massachusetts
Phoenix, Arizona
Chicago, Illinois
Portland, Oregon
Indianapolis, Indiana
St. Louis, Missouri
Miami Beach, Florida
Also, telegrams were received from Houston, Texas reiterating that city s desire to host a National Convention.
64
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
It is recommended that tentative convention awards be made as follows:
1967—Boston, Massachusetts—August 25-31
1969—
Atlanta, Georgia—August 2
1970—
New Orleans, Louisiana—A
1971—
Phoenix, Arizona—August 2
As you are aware, a tentative award has already been made to the City of
Milwaukee, Wisconsin for the 1968 Convention, the dates there to be August
23-29.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES V. DEMAREST, Chairman
. . . Upon motion by Mr. Wilson, Florida, seconded by Mr. Watkins, Arizona, the report was accepted.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I recognize now the Chairman of the Subcommittee on Resolutions.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Satisfaction of Indebtedness of Uniformed Groups
at National Conventions”
Resolution No. 27 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission—National Contests Supervisory Committee).
WHEREAS, The American Legion annually sponsors numerous uniformed
groups contests at its National Convention; and
WHEREAS, such uniformed groups can and do much to contribute to the
reputation of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, the reputation of The American Legion may be damaged if
such uniformed groups do not satisfy their indebtedness incurred in the process of participating in The American Legion National Conventions; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
The American Legion recommends that effective with 1966 National Convention, in the event any uniformed group, at least 90 days prior to any National Convention shall not have satisfied all proper and legal indebtedness
incurred in the process of participation in a previous convention city, then it
shall be barred from future competition at any National Convention and shall
remain so barred until said indebtedness shall have been paid in full.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This comes from the Contests
Supervisory Committee; it has the approval of the Convention Commission
also. Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin and
adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A of this
Committee, we have a Resolution 38 which you do not have on your desk, but
in the interests of the four-hour rule, Mr. Commander, we would take’this
up and then handle it in time for in the morning, otherwise we will have to
read it in the morning and possibly maybe some of the men would be late
m getting their planes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Unless I hear objection, this is
for information only, as it fulfills Rule 8-A, you may proceed.
“Authorization for National Adjutant of The American Legion to
Accept Advertising for National Convention Souvenir Program”
Resolution No. 38 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion has in the past and does now publish
a Convention Souvenir Program; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
65
WHEREAS, It has in the past employed the services of outside individuals and/or corporations to secure advertising for the said Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, At the present time The American Legion has no contractual
arrangement with any outside person, firm or corporation to solicit or secure
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It is the desire of The American Legion to have advertising contained in the Convention Souvenir Program—all of which is to be
handled by and through the office of the National Adjutant—now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5,
1966, that the National Adjutant be and he is hereby authorized to accept
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program together with the gross
proceeds thereof.
(Pursuant to Rule 8-A)
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A of this
Committee, this resolution was read at 3:25 p. m. on May 4th, and may the
record so indicate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Mr. Stone.
To conclude the Convention report, we will now call upon the President
of the 1965 Convention Committee, Bob Hazen of Portland, Oregon for his
final and concluding report.
REPORT OF 1965 NATIONAL CONVENTION
PRESIDENT ROBERT HAZEN: Mr. Commander James, members of
the National Executive Committee, I will be brief. I think you know the
success of our Portland Convention. You heard your Chairman Col. Demarest
report that Portland, Oregon made an official bid for 1975. That is what it
meant to us. We hope it will be honored when the time comes.
I just say to all of you once again, that Portland is indebted to you members here for granting us the Convention. I don’t think there is a day goes
by that some comment isn’t made in some circles regarding the fine Convention that was held in our city, and we are very indebted to you for coming,
and we do sincerely hope that you come back again.
I want to reiterate once again the fine work that your General Convention Manager Bill Miller did in handling our Convention. It was outstanding,
and I think you will find that the same thing is true in your next Convention.
The budget was $98,058. We went over the budget in income by $12,242,
and we went over budget by expense $1,398. So we had a net operating income of $10,844.02, and it is with great pleasure that I turn over to your National Commander a check from our National Convention Corporation on behalf of your corporate city and the Department of Oregon, a check for half
of that, the other half going to our Department, a check for $4,672.01, Mr.
Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Bob, may I say to you, that we are
grateful for the outstanding job that you and your co-workers did in Portland.
You have shown a profit in dollars and cents, but I am sure it is the
consensus of this group and all Legionnaires that visited Portland that you
showed a greater profit in the good will for your community the way our
people were treated there. I hear this everywhere I go throughout the country. Thank you very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION
James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
PUBLISHER O’NEIL: Mr. Commander and fellow members of the National Executive Committee, I am reporting for the Chairman, Jimmy Pow-
66
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
ers, Past National Commander, and Chairman of the Commission who cannot
be with us because of a bond issue operation in his county. He expresses
his regrets. I am submitting the report from him.
On your desk is a copy of the digest of the meeting held in New York
in February and subsequent to that, there have been some things that have
happened. There is an addendum to that report, both of these I recommend
to you for reading. This is the most important business, I believe operating
within The American Legion, and I commend you to the reading of this report and its supplement.
Now, in pursuit of what has taken place since that time, the operating
statement for the three months of The American Legion Magazine ending
March 31st, 1966 shows the Magazine operating well within its budget and
for this period the net gain to the Magazine totaled $131,090.47, or approximately $6,700 more than for the same period in 1965. It should be our hope
that we could maintain the pace established for the first three months, but
in view of our involvements, particularly as they relate to the operation forced
upon us by the Post Office Department, this seems unlikely.
In the report of the proceedings for February references were made to
the auditing and study to which The American Legion subscribes. This study
actually was a must for The American Legion Magazine if we hoped to receive any consideration in the advertising agencies. Each magazine has its
guaranteed circulation, as we do, of 2,500,000. But the Simmons auditing
study gives us a factor of measurement similar to those used in other publications, and for radio and TV presentations. If any questions develop in
your mind, I will be available tomorrow, Mr. National Commander, and to the
National Executive Committee, and of course for the rest of the day.
That concludes the report, thank you.
. . . The printed Advance Report of the National Publications Commission
is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION REPORT
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5,1966
by
Mr. James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
The meetings of the Publications Commission were held in New York City
on February 10th and 11th in the office of The American Legion Magazine
at 720 Fifth Avenue.
Presiding over the sessions was Past National Commander James E. Powers of Georgia, Chairman, and in attendance were the following Commission
members:
Adolph Bremer, Minnesota, Vice Chairman
ADVERTISING
Robert H. Wilder, Alabama, Chairman
Chris E. Hernandez, Georgia
Frank C. Love, New York
Morris Meyer, Mississippi
CIRCULATION PROMOTION
Benjamin B. Truskoski, Connecticut, Chairman
Howard E. Lohman, Minnesota
J. H. Morris, Louisiana
Wayne L. Talbert, Indiana
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
67
EDITORIAL
Raymond Fields, Oklahoma, Chairman
Bradley Stephens, California
Robert W. Mitchler, Illinois
Clovis Copeland, Arkansas
FINANCE-PERSONNEL
Dr. Charles R. Logan, Iowa, Chairman
Harry H. Schaffer, Pennsylvania
George D. Levy, South Carolina
MANUFACTURING
Charles E. Booth, West Virginia, Chairman
John Cicero, Pennsylvania
E. J. Cooper, Florida
E. Meade Wilson of Florida, Chairman of the National Executive Committee Liaison, also was present, as were Consultant Edward McSweeney of
New York, and Circulation Manager Dean B. Nelson of Indianapolis.
The following Commission members were absent: Lang Armstrong, Washington, because of a conflict in business commitments, and Congressman
Dague, Pennsylvania, due to illness in the family.
Members of the Editorial and Advertising Staffs joined Publisher James
F. O’Neil, Editor Robert B. Pitkin and Advertising Director Robert P. Redden
in participating in the deliberations.
Recommendations were adopted calling for the appointment by the National Commander of a Special Committee to study the ramifications that
have developed over the indiscriminate use of The American Legion Magazine
mailing lists with a view to seeking a clarification of the existing policy relating thereto.
Other matters discussed were the problems arising from resolutions adopted without complete information relating to the subject matter; computers and the conversion of the mailing list to make automated equipment
effective; the distribution of magazines to men in the Armed Forces; paper
and printing costs; advertising problems and the techniques being developed
in an effort to solve same and the impact of the editorial content and its
general acceptance.
It was recommended that $323.67 in editorial and art inventory items be
declared obsolete.
On the opening day, luncheon was held at the Metropolitan Club, at which
Mr. McSweeney reviewed the situation in the world of mass media, with
special reference to the status of The American Legion Magazine. Edgar A.
Grunwald, Editor and Publisher of Purchasing Week of the McGraw-Hill Publications, who has been writing the “Personal” column in The American Legion Magazine for ten years, also spoke. He discussed the general economic
picture, emphasizing the impact of the Viet Nam war as it relates to the
1966 financial outlook. In his opinion prices will rise, but living standards
will move ahead sharply as well.
Kenneth B. Haynes, President of the Fawcett-Haynes Printing Corporation, and Frank W. Whatton, Vice President, also attended the luncheon, as did
National Executive Committeemen Lou Drago of New York and William G.
McKinley of New Jersey, and the respective National Chairmen James V. Demarest (Convention) New York; Dan O’Connor (Americanism) of New YorkNew York Judge Advocate Frank Giordano and Legislative Director Herald
E. Stringer of the Washington Office. The latter addressed the Commission
meeting on Friday, announcing that one of the great Legislative goals of 1966
had been achieved with the passage of the “Cold War GI Bill” now awaiting
the anticipated signature of the President.
Mr. Haynes told of plans to erect a new 20 million dollar printing plant
in Louisville, expected to be ready for occupancy within three years. It is
68
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
to be a one-million square foot, one-floor building, providing an economical
and efficient layout that could inure to the benefit of The American Legion
Magazine.
Mr. O’Neil gave an account of his stewardship and that of his associates
during the past year. The American Legion Magazine returned a net profit,
or gain to the National Organization in 1965 in the sum of $616,952.80, or
$68,464.70 less than in 1964. Increased operating cost were—Printing, $12,000;
Payroll, $11,800 and Magazine Mailings, $5,600. The libel case award and
attorney’s fees, etc., amounted to $33,000 and another unanticipated outlay
was approximately $11,000 for the study resulting from the Zip Code directive of the Post Office Department. Total of all these items is $73,400.
Slight increases in advertising and subscription revenues were recorded
in 1965.
Announcement was made of the appointment of Edgar L. Schultz as Electronic Data Processing Supervisor. He will begin his duties on March 1st,
1966, and will participate in the decisions to be made shortly thereafter on
the type of computer to be installed at Indianapolis for the magazine, and
the service bureau to effect the conversion of the mailing list from the present system to a computerized version. It is anticipated that determination
will be made before April 1st as to the service bureau to do the conversion
and the computer to be installed at Indianapolis.
The non-member subscription status was reviewed by both Mr. Nelson
and Mr. O’Neil. The latter cited the fine work accomplished by Mr. Lohman in promoting yearly subscriptions to the magazine in his district in
Minnesota for placement in school libraries, doctors’ and dentists’ offices
and other places of exposure. Copies of the material used in the campaign
were distributed by Mr. Lohman.
Mr. Pitkin gave a run-down on the editorial accomplishments achieved
in 1965, stressing the fine reception of the articles. Both he and Mr. O’Neil
mentioned the lead story in the November, 1965, issue as being an instance
of great impact—The Systematic Terror of the Viet Cong. Its content becomes more valid as news comes to us from the war in Viet Nam. Hundreds
of thousands of reprints have been distributed. Among those engaged in this
operation are the members of the Junior Chamber of Commerce.
SIGNIFICANTLY, THE MUTUAL BROADCASTING SYSTEM ASKED EDITOR PITKIN TO PARTICIPATE IN A
BROADCAST ON THE ARTICLE OVER ITS NETWORK.
THIS ONE-HALF HOUR PROGRAM TITLED “THE BIG
LIE” WAS HEARD SATURDAY FEBRUARY 12, AT NOON.
THIS MORNING, FEBRUARY 15th, BOB RECEIVED A
CALL FROM MR. MOYERS AT THE WHITE HOUSE STATING THAT PRESIDENT JOHNSON HAD LISTENED TO
THE BROADCAST AND INVITED BOB TO COME IN FOR
A VISIT WITH THE PRESIDENT WHEN HE IS IN
WASHINGTON.
Mr. Redden explained some of the advertising plans with particular reference to the Simmons Study. The latter is an accepted measurement of
media among advertising agencies. It is hoped that its findings will become
an asset in promoting advertising sales. References also were made by Mr.
Redden to the more acceptable American Legion Magazine because of the
integrity of the editorial content.
The following reports were unanimously adopted:
ADVERTISING
Present were, Chairman Wilder and Messrs. Hernandez, Love and Meyer.
Advertising Director Redden took part in the proceedings.
The Simmons Report, which is expected out around April 15th was discussed. It considered what the Simmons Report could mean in regard to the
Magazine’s future advertising revenues. This Report, as it is understood, will
analyze the total readership of our Magazine and hopefully show the greater
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
69
buying power of the Legion audience. This should demonstrate to the advertising agencies and the accounts that we truly represent an effective advertising medium.
If the results from the Simmons Report are what the Committee hopes,
then we may expect that a substantial increase in national advertising will
follow.
The question of personnel was fully discussed. One new member has been
added to the staff within the last year—Mr. Mark Neider. He appears to be
making satisfactory progress and, further, the Committee anticipates the
hiring of an additional man in the very near future. It is hoped that there
will be less turnover in personnel in the future since the commission arrangements on new business, which has been established, should be substantial
enough to make it worthwhile for personnel to remain in our employ.
The Advertising Subcommittee notes with satisfaction that with. all the
difficulties encountered in the past year, the year ended with an increase
ip net advertising revenues over 1964.
CIRCULATION AND PROMOTION
Subcommittee members present included: Chairman Truskoski and Messrs.
Morris and Talbert.
Circulation Manager Nelson was present throughout the meeting, and
Mr. Wilson, NEC Liaison, and Chairman Powers participated in our deliberations at our invitation. Their views and thoughts were appreciated.
In his usual capable manner, Mr. Nelson, supplemented his remarks made
earlier to the Publications Commission by providing additional observations
on several subjects, including non-member subscriptions, indexing of 1 he
American Legion Magazine, operations of the Circulation Division and on
his experiences in recent months with data processing equipment and its allied problems. It was particularly noteworthy to hear Dean express the opinion that long range benefits will inure to The American Legion with the
installation of electronic equipment.
He suggested, and the Committee approved:
(1) The effort to promote and develop non-member subscription sales
by utilizing the resourcefulness of the American Legion Auxiliary
members, assuming that concurrence of the National Officers of
the Auxiliary is obtained.
(2) A letter similar in content to that directed to Post Commanders in
advance urging purchase of non-member subscriptions. to The
American Legion Magazine for residents of the respective communities of men now serving in the Armed Forces.
It is understood that Units would be urged to coordinate their efforts with
the local Posts.
We see no need to propose a recommendation on this matter knowing that
the Circulation Manager, with the approval of the Publisher, will explore this
possible source for increasing non-member subscriptions.
The Committee devoted a greater part of the session to the problem referred to us by resolution of the Commission, namely, the consideration of
alternatives, and the submission of recommendations on the use and sale of
American Legion membership rolls as mailing lists. In considering same, we
see a complicated problem filled with intangibles, temptations, advantages,
pitfalls, ramifications and obstacles. We do not feel confident to offer a
specific solution today. A comprehensive study of all aspects is essential.
Moreover, such a study involves national policy and in consequence the organization as a whole, and not merely The American Legion Magazine, is involved.
We believe that with background information furnished by the Publisher,
Chairman Powers and the Members of the National Executive Committee
Liaison, the National Commander of The American Legion will agree to
the necessity of appointing a representative group of American Legionnaires
who will tackle this problem on a broader and more comprehensive scale.
70
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
We offer the following recommendations: That the Publication Commission recommend the appointment by the National Commander of a Special
Committee who will study, review and consider the sale of American Legion
membership rolls as mailing lists, and to recommend the advisability of
amending, revising or promulgating policy for guidance of the national organization and its departments on this subject.
We appreciate the interest and consideration of all those who assisted us
in our deliberations.
EDITORIAL
Subcommittee members present were: Chairman Fields, and Messrs. Copeland, Mitchler and Stephens.
Mr. Wilson, NEC Liaison representative, visited with the Committee during its deliberations, and National Legislative Director Stringer was a guest
visitor.
Staff members present were: Editor Pitkin and A1 Marshall, Art Director; John Andreola, Assistant Editor and Roy Miller and James Swartz,
Associate Editors.
Mr. Stringer expressed satisfaction with the support given by the Magazine to the Legion’s National Legislative Program.
The Subcommittee members, the staff and visitors to the Subcommittee
earnestly discussed several subjects, including:
(1) The problem of improper resolutions to govern the administration or
content of the Magazine surviving Post, District and Department Conventions
and coming before the National Convention.
(2) The need to place copies of The American Legion Magazine in the
hands of present-day servicemen.
(3) The problem of the whole Legion, including the Magazine, in appealing to the varied interests of its diverse age-groups.
(4) The acceptance of the Legion and its Magazine in the various branches
of the Federal Government.
The Subcommittee adopted a motion that a suitable letter of appreciation
be sent to the Mutual Broadcasting System for its featuring of the article
The Systematic Terror of the Viet Cong on its Big Lie program, such
article having appeared in the November, 1965, issue of The American Legion
Magazine.
The Subcommittee adopted a motion approving the expenditure of editorial
funds for preliminary research in the development of some article ideas.
The Subcommittee approved a report of the Editor recommending the
killing of a total $323.67 of inventory in art and manuscript items. A copy
of the report is submitted herewith.
Ms. Voucher 2685:
Art Voucher 2146:
Art Vouchers 3489
3490
3491
3492
Art Voucher 3758
Translation from Soviet Political
Dictionary by Mrs. Helen Chavchavdze
Hanford: New York World’s Fair: Adams
Platnick: Vignettes of History:
eight charges in total on these
four vouchers, paid to Adams, Culver
Pix, Bettman Archives
Pitkin: Legion Far East Trip: Elliot
$150.00
7.52
163.85
2.30
$323.67
Respectfully submitted,
ROBERT B. PITKIN, Editor
FINANCE AND PERSONNEL
Members of the Finance-Personnel Subcommittee present were Chairman
Logan, and Messrs. Levy and Schaffer. Chairman Powers and National Executive Committee Liaison Representative Wilson also attended.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
71
We found all matters to be in order and in keeping with the decisions of
the Publications Commission.
The 1966 budget was accepted by the National Finance Commission and
the National Executive Committee without change, except as it related to
an across-the-board increase in salaries for all employees. This, too had
been anticipated because of the discussions at the pre-National Convention
Publications Commission meeting in Portland, Oregon.
In addition, the National Finance Commission and the National Executive
Committee has placed $300,000 in escrow to accommodate any possible expenditures concerning the transfer to a proposed computerized operation.
It is also understood that should added funds be necessary later in 1966
that they will in all likelihood be approved.
The Publications Division has operated during the year 1965 within its
proposed 1965 budget, and is continuing to do so in this early part of 1966.
Advertising income and membership revenues showed a slight increase in
1965 compared to ’64.
Relative to the personnel in the New York office and in the division of
publications in Indianapolis, we find a most satisfactory situation.
MANUFACTURING
The Subcommittee on Finance joined the Manufacturing Subcommittee in
the meeting in Publisher O’Neil’s office. Present for the Manufacturing Committee: Charles E. Booth, Chairman, West Virginia; John Cicero, Pennsylvania and E. J. Cooper, Florida.
An increase in the paper price of $10 per ton was noted. This will represent a boost of $40,000 to $50,000 in costs this year. It was included in the
budget for 1966.
The controversy between The American Legion Magazine and the FawcettHaynes Printing Corporation at Louisville, Kentucky, has been resolved in
favor of The American Legion Magazine on a satisfactory and apparently
permanent basis for the duration of the present contract.
Everything else concerning the production of the magazine appears to be
on an efficient and satisfactory basis to The American Legion Magazine,
and we are glad to be able to make such a report.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES E. POWERS, Chairman
. . . The Addendum to the National Publications Commission report is as
follows:
ADDENDUM
NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION REPORT
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5, 1966
Mr. James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
Mr. Commander and
Fellow Members of
The National Executive Committee:
The digest of the proceedings of the meetings of the Publications Commission held in New York on February 10th and 11th, 1966, have been distributed to you. With a view to bringing you up to date, I will now submit this addendum.
The American Legion Magazine is now in the process of creating the systems and the programs for the Electronic Data Processing equipment to be
72
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
installed at National Headquarters. Pursuant to the authority granted by the
National Executive Committee, a five-year contract has been entered into
with Honeywell for the leasing—with a purchase option—of an H-200. Delivery date is November.
The American Legion Magazine also has made arrangements with a service
bureau to convert the mailing lists to meet the Zip Code requirements of the
Post Office Department. This project will require at least six months to complete.
We are assembling what we consider to be a capable team to direct our
new activities. As the new system becomes operative on an installment basis,
the current one will be phased out. This, of course, is a major problem.
In summation, from a financial standpoint, the cost to The American
Legion of the arbitrary directive of the Post Office Department will total more
than a half million dollars. Under arrangements worked out with the Finance
Commission, the financing of same has and is being developed without any
impact, we hope, on the annual operating budget of The American Legion.
Conferences also have been held with the Membership and Post Activities
Division looking toward the most effective and most economic utilization of
the Electronic Data Processing equipment.
In connection therewith, consideration is being given to the establishment
of a new two-part membership card for 1968, with supplemental register
print-outs to provide alphabetical and Post listings for all American Legion
members for Department and Post records. You will be hearing more about
this development in the weeks ahead. It will be our purpose to cooperate
with the Membership folks in making the new facilities work to the advantage
of the respective Posts and Departments as well as National.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES E. POWERS, Chairman
Publications Commission
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is upon us
for a special order of business. You recall that special order is the consideration of Resolution No. 14 coming from the 50th Anniversary Committee. As
I recall, Mr. Stone, 14 and 17, and 14 has been read first.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I will read Resolution No. 14.
“50th Anniversary Observance of the Founding of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 14 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the year 1969 will be the 50th anniversary year of the founding of The American Legion, and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th anniversary, and
WHEREAS, such a special 50th Anniversary Committee has been so appointed, and
WHEREAS, an Executive Section of said 50th Anniversary Committee
has held meetings on March 2 and 3, and May 2 and 3, and
WHEREAS, it is the consensus of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee that it would be to the best interests of The American
Legion to retain the services of a public relations firm to guide and assist
The American Legion with its 50th anniversary observance, and
WHEREAS, the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee has
considered presentations from public relations firms and has a specific recommendation for the employment of such firm at an agreed cost in fees, outof-pocket expenses, and certain other additional costs, now, therefore, be it
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
73
RESOLVED by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana on May 4 and 5, 1966, that the National
Commander and the National Adjutant are hereby authorized and directed to
negotiate, with the guidance and approval of The American Legion Special
50th Anniversary Committee, and to execute a contract with the public relations and advertising firm of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc., said contract to extend over a period to conclude approximately December 31, 1969, with necessary stipulations for cancellation by either party in accordance with conditions of sound business practice, and be it further
RESOLVED that in consideration of services to be rendered by Bozell and
Jacobs, Inc. which services are to be set forth in all necessary detail in said
contract, The American Legion will agree to pay to the firm of Bozell and
Jacobs, Inc. agency fees not to exceed $250,000 during the life of said contract, and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall also provide for reimbursement to
representatives of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. for out-of-pocket expenses not to
exceed $44,000 specifically required by The American Legion and incurred
in the service of The American Legion, said expenses to be itemized and submitted at regular intervals for audit and prior approval by the National
Adjutant and National Treasurer of The American Legion prior to payment,
and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall further provide that the firm of
Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. will submit to The American Legion at regular intervals Complete and itemized statements justifying all agency fees, out-ofpocket expenses, and any other charges to be provided for in said contract,
and be it further
R.ESOLVED that the National Executive Committee does authorize and
direct the 50th Anniversary Committee to determine and recommend such
other sum or sums that may be necessary, not to exceed $50,000, in connection With the 50th anniversary observance to be used for projects and programs requiring material expenditures such as materials for Post and Departmental participation, radio, TV, film, newspaper, and all other types
of suitable publicity, and that such recommendation or recommendations be
submitted to the National Executive Committee as soon as possible for its
consideration, and be it further
RESOLVED that the 50th Anniversary Committee is charged by the National Executive Committee to exercise close supervision and guidance of all
activities involving the 50th anniversary observance and the expenditures of
American Legion monies therefor, with reports at regular intervals to the
National Executive Committee and to the Finance Commission, and be it
further
RESOLVED that the National Finance Commission is requested to provide
for necessary funds for the expenses of the 50th Anniversary Committee
to enable it to fulfill the charge herein set forth, and be it further
RESOLVED that prior to the completion of the contract authorized herein,
such contract shall have the approval as to form from the National Judge
Advocate.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander and members
of the National Executive Committee, this completes the second reading of
this resolution pursuant to Rule 8-A, and may the record show that this was
read at 3:40 p. m. on May 4th.
Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Chair will recognize the
Chairman of the Committee so that he can make an explanation, and then
the floor will be open for comments and questions.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN LaBICHE: I have had quite a few questions asked in the last few days, particularly since the reading of our resolution this morning, and I thought it would be best to try to answer some
of these questions that were asked, and if you will, I will attempt to answer
many of them now.
74
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
One of the questions was, there is no member of this Committee that is a
member of Bozell and Jacobs, and no one of our Committee owns any type of
stock in Bozell and Jacobs. The first time I heard of the firm was when
we met them in New York on April 5th.
I would like to tell you, and of course not being familiar with the laws,
that is the reason why I haven’t, I would like to tell you what we did pertaining to bringing this resolution before you. We appeared before the Finance Commission and presented this entire problem, and the Finance Commission, we wanted them to first know whether we could get into such a
program, and after discussing with them thoroughly, they advised this, and
we have discussed it later with the Chairman of the Finance Commission,
and we have even discussed our resolution, to make sure that we will
do this thing right, that we wouldn’t come to you and after we passed with
you and you supported it, that we wouldn’t have problems later. So we wanted to clear everything first.
They tell us we are on the right track, and to also make certain that we
were right, we went to the Judge Advocate. We presented it to him, and we
discussed it thoroughly, and made many changes to please him, and had the
resolution, as far as the Judge Advocate legally was concerned, correct.
We found our resolutions completely in order. We discussed it naturally
with our National Commander to get him completely informed of what we
are doing, our whole Committee. Also, we discussed it completely with our
National Adjutant so that he would be completely informed. We appeared
before your Resolutions Committee Chairman Roy Stone, your Committee with
all members present discussed it thoroughly with us and if any of you gentlemen have appeared before the Resolutions Committee and discussed anything, you know they ask some pretty important questions. And you know
that all of these type of people that ask the big questions ask them, and we
had to give the answers. And I think that we have answered everyone to
their satisfaction. In fact, they were, I thought without exception, they were
pleased, and they were thoroughly familiar with what this Committee was
doing.
Now let me get down to the money deal. We are talking about $344,000.
And I think we have to be 100% right in all of these things that I mentioned
to you, all of these people felt that it had to be right, and that we wouldn’t
even, they wouldn’t even allow us to get this far unless they thought we
were on the right track.
$250,000 is the contract that we wish to sign with these people, and this
contract will be this type of a contract, it is a public relations firm, we are
buying services, talent, the same as you buy of a lawyer. We have to have a
dead end. We just couldn’t come in and ask you to give us something without
any strings attached to it.
We estimated this program over a period of four years. Now we are not
talking of a one-shot deal, we are talking of four years. They estimated this
program for four years would not exceed $250,000. They are willing to sign a
contract with us to furnish seven professional people, people as someone said,
in the neighborhood of $10,000 a year income people to work with us for
four years to implement our program, plus their staff of 325 people, plus
some 12 major offices throughout the United States, with another 25 offices
that they have working agreements with, which gives us the whole national
coverage. It means that we are going to be able to turn to every nook and
hole in the nation with this four-year program.
This $250,000 will be the contract with these people, and maybe we will
only spend $200,000. That is the top figure. We could spend a million dollars
worth of services. These are big people, financially able to support what they
say, but the contract stops at $250,000.
Now how does our contract work? We have an open-end contract with
them which the Judge Advocate and our people will draw that we can cancel at any time within 90 days. They have the right of 90 days too. We
have the right of 90 days on their $250,000.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
75
How are we going to pay them their $250,000? Now I will give you a
breakdown of how we think the $344,000 will be spent, and in what years they
will be spent.
Next, we have what we call out-of-pocket money. They estimate that it
could run as much as a thousand dollars a month out-of-pocket money. This
is 44 months, that is where you get your $44,000, out-of-pocket money, which
they put in there that they will demand of us. For example, if we tell them
we want some special stationery, we want to do some certain things that
would, say, take them outside of the entire program, this they call out-ofpocket money. If we would ask that specific people would become involved
with them, they would like to have them come in and work with our membership Committee or with our PR Department or with other sections or committees of The American Legion, and we want this particular skilled person
to come in here and work with them and spend some time, this is called
out-of-pocket money, which we have to pay the expenses, purely the expenses
of bringing this person in to do that. That is out-of-pocket money. This outof-pocket money, we took the top figure, because in going into a program,
we can’t come back to you every six months in the middle of the spring and
fall and tell you we need another thousand dollars or two thousand dollars.
So we took the top figure of $44,000 out of $1,000 a month as they term outof-pocket money. This is where that figure comes from.
Your next figure is $50,000, which completes your $344,000. That $50,000
is the figure that is what they intend to do, and they have many events
they wish to cover. Gosh, the events that they have presented to us, which
our Committee yet haven’t gone into is over 35 different types of events over
this four-year period. This will be, I think, $50,000 worth of money that would
be used to make up packages, to contact the Chairmen of all the Departments,
to contact all the Posts, to send packets to the Posts with resolutions keeping
them completely informed to be able to have big celebrations right down at the
grass roots level. This is a good realistic figure that they estimate that this
job can be done for, $50,000 or less.
Again, we took the figure that we think the right kind of job can be done
with.
I think I have given you, explained to you a little, and I might mention
one other thing to you, some of the things that, a similar organization in a
sense, you say, well, it is not like some of the organizations that these people
today represent, but for 17 years they have been representing the Electrical
Company Public Information Program, this program is owned by 85 Electrical
Utilities. They are their PR people for that, which is a service. They represent the American Gas Association for the United States. They conceived
Boys Town. The famous poster, “He is not heavy; he is my brother,” that is
Mr. Jacobs’ development. They have handled this program which I know
many of you have all seen, the United States Air Force Recruiting Program.
You may say this is not like our type of organization, but these are still organizations that have done that sort of thing that fit into our type of thing.
I will give you that little background, and I think I have answered most
of the questions that have been asked me in the last four hours, Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Al.
Any discussion?
Mr. McKinley?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander and colleagues, I hope
you will be a little bit tolerant with me, Mr. Commander, if I do wander a
little bit.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Tolerance will be the order of
the day.
MR. McKINLEY: Comments, I am appearing perhaps in the guise of
the devil’s advocate. I am overwhelmingly in favor of what this Committee
wants to do. I have had some opportunity completely to review their program, and I think their present programming is sound and sensible.
76
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
But the thing that I am puzzled a little bit on, and I want to rouse this
Executive Committee to your responsibilities here, you are not just a bunch
of “yes men” you are here to administer a very important phase of the Legion
business, and that has to do with their money.
Now it was my unhappy recollection some years ago to sit here in this
Executive Committee and to have a fellow like Art Connell and a number
of other very fine Legionnaires get up here and make some statements substantially the same in an appeal that A1 LaBiche has made to you. Their
enthusiasm was tremendous and they were unquestionable in their sincerity.
But they asked us to sign a contract. The contract was not physically here.
Nobody knew exactly what its provisions were, but the contract was signed,
and we were, when we were through with it, we were eight or nine hundred
thousand dollars in the red. And it took us four years or more to bail ourselves out. And I just don’t want to see us plunge into a similar situation
without giving very serious thought to some control or restrictions over the
spending of this money.
'
f
_ Now I had a thought with our esteemed Chairman of the Finance Committee, A1 Redden, believe me, he is one of God’s own among the Legion, as
far as I am concerned. How the devil he keeps these figures in the back of
his head I don’t know, he is not basically a banker or a bookkeeper or an
accountant or anything like that, so it is really a miracle how that man has
these figures on his fingertips, and he told me last night, yes, if the National Executive Committee on the advice of counsel with this Committee, of
course, directs them to find the money, they can find it within certain limitations.
We are in a liquid state at the present time. We are not in debt, but we
are certainly not rolling in wealth. So we do have to be a little bit cautious.
I didn’t press Harold too much, but roughly if I recall in conversations
he said that possibly they could find without too much trouble if this is
distributed over a four-year period, as much as $400,000. Well, that is apparently just a little bit in excess of what A1 has represented to you now.
Now this is the thing I want to be assured of, that the conditions of this
contract will contain no wide-open clause whereby the estimated amount of
money given to you here on which you will vote, you suddenly find out
there were extras and extras and extras, and the first thing you know, you
are in debt. Now there is, there are enough lawyers in this room, and I
know there are enough contractors in the room that know that if you want
to ruin a project, all you have got to do is add the extras on. These are
the afterthoughts. I want to, so far as we can do so, in our voting here,
Mr. Commander, now be assured there will be some limitations on this extra
business that could lead us into debt.
I want to assure you, my comrades, I have supreme faith in Don Johnson
and A1 LaBiche and ali the other fellows that have been working on this
thing. I think they are absolutely on the up and up and on the level, but I
just raised my voice for the purpose of shaking you fellows up on this Executive Committee. This is your responsibility. Don’t pass the buck. If you
don’t believe in this thing, don’t vote for it.
But I feel that we ought to just stop long enough to think about this
money business, how much we are going to give, how far are you going to
extend the credit of this organization to this very fine Committee? Can we
put a stop somewheres in this contract to prevent just going on and spending
this money on the theory of extras and extras and something new that we
hadn t thought of ? That is what gets you in debt. That is what I have to
say, Mr. Commander. I hope that some of the other fellows may pick this up
I am not trying to defeat this thing, I am thoroughly in favor of what they
want to do. I am only hollering, stop, look and listen. This is your dough.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Bill.
In view of some of the statements made, I would like for the Judge Advocate to answer a question, and then I believe we will recognize first Past
National Commander Johnson, and then others. I would like to ask this ques-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
77
tion of the Judge Advocate, since I gather that your reference was to that
colorful “Red, White and Blue.”
MR. McKINLEY: Oh, it was colorful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then I would suggest that there
may be more contrast than comparison between the two experiences, so I
would like to ask the Judge Advocate if this resolution as prepared now
and as proposed for adoption containing language where it refers to each
dollar amount, and there are three of them, including the words “not to
exceed” and in one instance “$250,000” and the other, “not to exceed $44,000,”
and the next one, “not to exceed $50,000”; with that language, is it correct
that any expenditure or any contract that would include provisions that would
permit any expenditure in excess of those amounts would require action by
this Committee before the contract could be entered into?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Absolutely.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: And in the resolution there is
reference to necessary stipulations for canceling by either party in accordance
with conditions of business practice, could you elaborate on that, please?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes, in all contracts that
we sign of any great amounts, it is customary—before I answer the
question, let me say this, this is going to be negotiated, this contract by the
National Commander, by and with the aid of this Special Committee. The
Commander will negotiate with the firm of Bozell and Jacobs with the aid
of the Committee.
Now directing myself to your question, Mr. Commander, any contract that
I draw for The American Legion or that I negotiate involving substantial
sums of money, I insist that there be included in addition to conditions
precedent for the cancellation of a contract, an out clause of not more than
90 days. It is usually 60 days, not a unilateral 60 days, a 60 day termination
clause, and a cancellation clause which may be exercised by either party so
that they can’t come in at a later time and say.this was a one-way street,
unilateral contract and it is illegal. I give both sides 60 or 90 days terminations and in this contract, I can assure you that we will have a termination
clause and it is anticipated it will be 60 days, but I am going to wait until
the Commander gets into negotiations, but there will be a termination clause.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: A point of information, as
long as Bert is at the Chair, if the right to terminate would be exercised by
either party as you speak of, I am satisfied that what your answer will be,
but I am asking for the benefit of the Committee, only that amount of this
figure, total figure, we’ll say the figure of $250,000 that the public relations
firm have earned to the point of termination would be paid to them, is that
so?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Let me pursue it.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes. The answer is yes.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Let me ask the question
anyway, so that when we contract or sign a contract that uses the figure
$250,000, and therefore would apply to the other provisions of the contract
where money is expressed “not to exceed” and so forth, if we were to terminate, we would not then obligate outselves to whatever balance, of the
$250,000 not yet earned.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Let me answer you this way,
that is anticipated. I have not seen any contract. All we have, and I have
not perused it carefully, is a proposal. There are several options which; may
be exercised. The cost of the project is dependent upon which options we
choose. Some options are more expensive than others. Now my reading of
the proposal, not carefully, but my reading of the proposal in a hurried
manner, yesterday, leads me to believe that in the course of the negotiating
of this contract we will insist that as we make a choice and the job is completed, we will be billed with an itemized statement, and we will nay, but in
no event, I as a lawyer for The American Legion would never obligate you
78
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
to a four-year contract and commit you to $250,000 without knowing specifically whether we are going to get what we will bargain for.
We will pay for it as they do it, and then there will be provisions in
there—as I say, there is no contract, we are negotiating, and the Commander
will negotiate, but I can assure you in my talks with Mr. Chamie who is
an outstanding lawyer, that it is his position. I am sure I cannot speak
for the Commander, but that is my position.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you. Past National Commander Don Johnson.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: Thank you. Mr. Commander and members of this Committee, I had hoped to rise before the
lawyers did get their bid in, in view of Bill’s earlier comments this morning.
Bill, I think that your comments are well taken, particularly those that
charge this Committee with the responsibility of looking out for the money
of that organization.
Certainly no one is more concerned about this than I am, and always
have been. I think that the questions have been well answered. I don’t believe,
Bill, that there is any analogy whatsoever between the previous contract to
which you refer and this one. The fact that we have a stop clause and cancellation clause, we pay only for what we get upon the presentation of
properly substantiated invoicing and billing, and I don’t believe there is any
danger which you inferred during your comments.
I think that another thing that we must recognize is that we are dealing
with a top flight firm in the United States.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: I will go along with that. I endorse that.
I am thoroughly convinced of their responsibility. They are one of the finest
in the country.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: And the fact that whether or not we enter the contract in front of all the members of this Committee
to me makes no difference, because as a non-professional, a contract would
be laid before me, and I wouldn’t, it wouldn’t mean anything.
You talked about the legalistic language. If I were to see it, it wouldn’t
make any difference. I have to rely on our National Judge Advocate who
is the legal counsel for this organization to insure to me that it is in proper
legal form. I know the facts that we want, but he is the one that must do it.
We have to rely upon his ability. This is why we have him. I think that we
should go ahead after the expression of all of the members of this Committee and pass this.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Don. Committeeman
from Idaho, Mr. Gratton.
MR. GRATTON, Idaho:
Mr. Commander, Past National Commander
Johnson answered one of my questions, and you answered one of my questions, and the Judge Advocate took the rostrum; in the interest of time, and
because there are many of this Committee who have had the Committee experience that Mr. McKinley has and the memories and associations of probably some previous disappointing maneuvers and actions taken by this Board,
could we not have the Chairman of the Finance Commission here? I notice
he is not in the room right at the moment, could we have him to indicate
his approval? I am sure everybody in this Committee has the utmost confidence in Mr. Redden and also our Judge Advocate, and we can proceed with
a vote on this matter.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
We can make inquiry of the
Chairman. He is not available at this time. We can make some inquiry.
The Judge Advocate has had some discussion with him, and I think I
know what the Finance Chairman’s answer will be, but I ask the Judge Advocate if he will address himself very briefly to that.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Mr. Gratton, under the structural organization of The American Legion, the Finance Commission as such
does not set policy. You gentlemen set policy. If the Finance Commission
recommended approval of this before you had an opportunity to act, it would
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
79
be improper. The Finance Commission should not address themselves to this
matter except informally by inquiry until this body has acted and told that
body what it wants.
So I do not think the Finance Commission Chairman will address himself
to the question, and I think he has expressed himself in those words.
MR. GRATTON: Mr. Davis, I would say this to you, sir, in Bill’s remarks about his conversations with Harold Redden, he said we will be able
to find some nearly half a million dollars or in excess of a quarter of a
million dollars. I think my point in talking to the Chairman of the Finance
Commission is that this would be at whose expense, or at what program’s
expense that this body here controls?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is a matter for the
Finance Commission.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We will see if we can find the
Chairman.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, members of the Executive
Committee, I don’t know if I am the devil’s advocate, or is it Bill McKinley,
or the distinguished former National Commander Don Johnson. I know
that McKinley doesn’t love lawyers, and I know that this morning as well
as last year, he called all the lawyers that he knew a bunch of
.
Now I happen to be one of those fellows who likes to go along with progress. I like this whole idea, because it projects The American Legion into the
future, it will give The American Legion, in my opinion, that image which
we have needed for many years.
I also feel that never before have I seen such an illustrious number of
fine businessmen, lawyers, men like Jimmy O’Neil and A1 Chamie on this
Committee, brilliant lawyers, businessmen, who probably do millions of dollars worth of business. And I am one of those “yes men” who believe that a
Committee should be given the opportunity to go ahead.
Now it sounded a little bit off color to have a man like A1 LaBiche say
that none of the men on this Committee have anything to do with this firm.
We should take that for granted. I don’t think that the past experience that
we have had should be a deterrent in this contract.
We should learn by the past, and I find no fault by the others, because
I wasn’t versed enough to know what happened. But when I heard Bill
say this morning that this contract should be put in layman’s language, it
means nothing to a lawyer, and I happen to be a lawyer. All the contract does
in its legal form is to insure that which you as laymen and these businessmen want in the dealings with another firm.
Now three things are important in my mind. You have a wonderful reputation in the firm that will do business with The American Legion, an outstanding firm that wants to give service, and I believe will give service. You
have men like Dan Foley, A1 Chamie and others that will watch and protect
our legal interests. And I say without any fear of contradiction, that we have
one of the finest Judge Advocates that I would want to draw up this contract.
Now he may be young, but believe me, I have been in contact with this
man, and he has drawn contracts involving millions of dollars worth of business, and I know of nothing that has happened that has put the Legion in
any embarrassing situation, financially or otherwise.
I looked this Committee over, and I don’t think you could get a finer
bunch of men, the only mistake the Commander made is that he didn’t include
me.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: How many people have commended me and congratulated me on not doing so!
MR. DRAGO: I believe it, because I would probably be the one that
would contact this public relations firm for a little side dollar.
Well, I didn’t get myself on this Committee, but it did get a fellow from
Brooklyn, the Rev. Thompson, and I am sure that he will watch it with me
behind just like Wallace and his wife.
80
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
So, gentlemen, really sincerely with a Commander like we have who is a
lawyer, with Bert Davis, with men with great business instincts like Don
and boys like Dan Foley, Don Johnson and the rest of you, Jimmy O’Neil,
I read this over carefully, and I have no fear, and in this case, I would be a
“yes man,” because I am going to follow whatever this Committee wants,
and I think it will be a great job, and I think you are going to have something to look forward to and be happy about it. Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you.
MR. OVERTON, Alabama: Mr. Commander, my colleagues, I sense that
you are nearing the time that you want to vote, and I certainly shan’t belabor this. I think in deference to those who are new on the Committee, that
I ought to say a little something about what my good colleague McKinley
said relative to “Red, White and Blue.” I sat in this chair then, and I sit
here now, and we made a contract with “Red, White and Blue” and sort of
got in the show business, and nothing is so disheartening, and I might mention, we were quite disappointed when we went into the hole $400,000. For
just a moment, let’s examine how we got in show business to promote a
show. We were sold on something up here. I don’t think the Committee is on
trial today for their integrity. Certainly, I think what McKinley wants to
alert us to, I believe he wants to alert you to your responsibilities or to move
you to that. I think we ought to be moved, but in “Red, White and Blue,”
let me remind you, there are several of you sitting like I was, that they
came back and said, well, fellows, we got into a poker game like this; in the
end we have $225,000, shall we go to Chicago or not? And just exactly what
you have talked about, we came back to the Commander, and we discussed
it, and we debated, and we said that we had gotten into it, and what do we
want to do about it, do we want to go ahead. And we did, not because of
some slick contract, but we went along with it, the National Committee, and
we got in a little deeper, and then we got in a little deeper. I recommended
that my Department go in $10,000. It is a wonder I am really here.
This Committee was charitable with the national organization to take it
up from the states, and they amortized it and paid it off. I say this, we made
a mistake, yes, but don’t you think we might be a little stronger? I think the
debate has been good. I don’t think anything is alarming about “Red,
White and Blue.” Certainly Mr. Davis and Mr. Commander, there was no
contractual problem.
I see Jimmy O’Neil smiling, and I love to hear about the devotion of Art
Connell who tried and put his soul into it, but we just weren’t showmen, and
it was not a contract, it was a fact we got into, and we wanted to get out,
like so many of you got in the game of chance, we didn’t get our money
back. I wanted to clear that up, thank you.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER O’NEIL: Mr. Commander, and my
colleagues of the National Executive Committee, references have been made
to me, and of course, in that I am a participant in the 50th Anniversary
Committee, I think it might be well for me to clarify some issues here.
Reference has been made to the late lamented “Red, White and Blue,”
and of course, the ghost of that tragedy will stick in this Committee room
forever, and it is good that it does.
I concur in Bill McKinley’s proposal to get this before this National Executive Committee in its fullest position.
It became our responsibility, incidentally, to close “Red, White and Blue,”
so I know many of the details connected with it. I became the representative
to bring the show to its conclusion in Chicago. The loss was mentioned by
Mr. McKinley of $900,000, and I think you mentioned $400,000. The exact
figure, gentlemen, was $678,000.
But I say this to you, that if we had a professional public relations firm
to guide us on that occasion, such as we have for this program, we would
never have been involved. That was our mistake, that we didn’t go to the professional agency to get the assistance we needed.
Now in the very beginning, that is the opening sessions of the Committee
of the 50th Anniversary Committee, the point was raised about our observance
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
81
of the 50th Anniversary, and we only have this chance once, gentlemen, and
it was concluded that we should get a professional agency to direct us.
And in connection therewith, because of the fact that I am available and
most of the agencies that function in this field headquarter in and around
New York City, it became my duty to contact them and screen them out.
And in connection therewith, I went to the top people in the business in both
public relations activities, and in the advertising agency field so that I could
get the benefit of the thinking of both groups. And so out of it we had two
presentations made to the Executive Committee of your 50th Anniversary
observations, one by Bozell & Jacobs, and the other by Hill and Nolton, two
excellent firms. The better presentation was submitted by Bozell & Jacobs.
I am sure that we are headed in the right direction.
There isn’t anyone in this room, and with all due deference to all of
you, that is more conscious of dollars and cents than possibly I am. I have
participated in negotiations of many contracts involving hundreds of thousands
of dollars for this organization and in connection therewith, I join with my
friend the Committeeman from New York in praising our National Judge
Advocate, because I have been on the firing line with him, and I know what
he has done for this organization in preserving the integrity of the organization in relation to contracts.
I am satisfied that this is a good contract. Bernie Gratton, I believe was
asked what program would be sacrificed in The American Legion to carry
out the provisions of this. Frankly, Bernie, The American Legion Magazine
will pay the freight. I can say this to you in all honesty, that it would be
my opinion, if we get in any kind of, if we get any kind of break at all,
in the four years of this observance, plus the improved image that The American Legion might develop, or this program might inure to its benefit, that the
revenues of the magazine could be improved. To be sure, I am talking in
intangibles right now, but let me say this to you, in the last two years, The
American Legion Magazine has returned to this national organization a net
gain in profit of almost $1,300,000.
So I am conscious of dollars and cents, as well as Mr. McKinley, and he
knows this only too well.
I think we are on the right road, because, gentlemen, we need to recapture public recognition, and this has been lost to us now for a long number
of years.
I have heard much criticism about our operations, public relations wise.
Gentlemen, in the main, they are unjustified. We are the victims of a system,
and I would be hopeful with some professional help, we would be able to
overcome many of the difficulties. Thank you very much.
MR. RYER, Rhode Island: Mr. Commander, I would like to take this
opportunity to commend Bill for bringing this out. Certainly, I am going to
vote for it. After all, I have slept with LaBiche for the last three nights, and
God knows that would happen to me if I didn’t vote for this. I would like to
point out to you, if Bill hadn’t brought this up, it is quite conceivable that
somebody made a motion that we pass it and go right along. The last half
hour I have learned much, much more than I had any idea. After all, we
are spending more than a quarter of a million dollars. I think we as a deliberative body have taken the long road. If somebody hadn’t brought it up,
somebody hadn’t discussed it, we would not have learned this. I learned, for
instance, that the National Magazine is going to take care of the thing. That
is fine. Any worries I had before are completely dispelled.
But I just want to say this, that some of you might have thought, and
I love to use these words of Tom Miller and Bill McKinley, “my colleagues,”
some of us might have thought when we brought it up, that we were bringing
something up just for the sake of creating a hassle and so forth and so on.
I commend them for it, because I think there isn’t a man in the room that
hasn’t learned something as a result of this. And I think the record will show
later on that rather than the hassle that was created over this little item that
happened just prior to the time I came on the National Executive Committee
14 years ago, “Red, White and Blue,” which I never heard the real story,
I think that the record here today, regardless of what happens as far as
82
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
the 50th Anniversary today, the records here will show as Bill McKinley
requested, certainly proves the point.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Red, I think you well expressed
the sentiments of everyone here.
MR. MILLOY, North Dakota: One short question. I don’t know how they
evaluate their services. Is it conceivable in the first two years that this
firm could earn their $250,000 and terminate the contract and let us go it
on our own, or would it be, the service and the compensation, prorated over
the four-year period?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN LaBICHE: In our contract, it will specifically be stated in some sort of breakdown, and we think it will run about
like this, that 1966 will get $50,000, 1967 $100,000, ’68 $75,000, ’69 $25,000,
and that is the $250,000. Now, the Commander will negotiate the contract, ’66
might be $55,000, or it might be some more, but it will specify so much each
year. They bill us each month, and if we do by chance terminate our contract
in 90 days, it will cut off right at that point.
I might say this, Mr. Commander, I hate to say this, but I think this
is good business, and this is a business group that we are dealing with, we
are business people, we think we picked the top firm, but if we get in four
or five months from now, and we think the job is not being done, we want
to stop it, because we are going to have to put this four-year deal on, this
Legion, we are going to have to have five celebrations, as I told you about,
and we are going to have to keep this money and put it on, so we can’t make
a mistake. If we are going to have a mistake, we are going to know about it,
and 90 days later we are going to put a stop to it and then we can go
somewhere else and put a show on that you are proud of.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I would like to recognize Past National Commander Harry Colmery.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COLMERY: Mr. Commander and
gentlemen of the Committee, if I couldn’t make a slight contribution to your
discussion, I wouldn’t be here. In the first place, there is a lesson in the
“Red, White and Blue” for all of you in the projection of this program. I
think I know a little bit about it. I took it on myself in Topeka, Kansas,
notably one of the worst show towns in America. We showed it there for
two nights and turned in a handsome profit. The basic reason that program
did not succeed was because the Legionnaires of America didn’t get off their
fannies and work at it. That is exactly why it didn’t succeed.
Now this is projected to you and as a public relations concern goes to
work and this 50th Anniversary Committee projects the program there is a
lesson in “Red, White and Blue” to you, to carry out in the field of things
that have to be done, to make it click and to make it successful.
Now in the second place, I have confidence that the contract, if you get
into relative obligations of responsibilities, you will have done the job, and
I believe the Committee as the Judge Advocate indicates, the National Commander will get that done. I think what you are worrying about here mostly rests on the administration of the contract after you launch the program.
I might say that I am a country lawyer, but with some little experience
m making some policies and having them implemented in some fairly substantial operations, one of which involves over $35 million in the last three
years. What you need basically is a strong dedicated small Executive Committee within the 50th Anniversary Committee that will watch this as it goes
along, and sees that the provisions, the contract provisions are carried out,
and try to protect it in a manner to make it successful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Harry. Are you ready
for the question?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander, if everybody has spoken, I would like just one closing comment.
I am going to vote for the resolution. I have satisfied myself with what
I intended to do, and that was to make my colleagues, to shake my colleagues
up in expression of their responsibility in dealing with a complicated question and expense involved.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May It, 1966
83
We have too often sat on the floor of this Committee, A1 will remember,
and I am as guilty as the next one, and just passed a resolution without
knowing what it contains. I don’t want them to come along and say they
don’t know anything about it.
NATIONAL COMMANDE R JAME S: Thank you, Bill.
The question having been called for, those in favor of the motion to approve the resolution signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The resolution is adopted.
Let me say this also to underscore Red Ryer, you have performed a great
service in many ways, Bill, because the members of this Committee who have
voted, and I sense the vote to have been unanimous, will have to answer
questions when they go home, perhaps for the next four years, and so you
have served a great purpose in helping to fortify them.
You have also brought out the comment by Past National Commander Colmery that may be much more keen than you thought, because I would say
there is no easy road to success, and there is no substitute for personal
effort, and the success of this program will not rest solely on the shoulders
of the Committee nor on Bozell and Jacobs, but on the Legionnaires throughout the country and you as leaders, so thank you for that.
MR. LOVELL, Arkansas: Mr. Commander, my vote was no.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, it shall be recorded.
Anyone else?
. . . Subcommittee Chairman Stone continued the resolutions as follows:
“Commemoration of 50th Anniversary of St. Louis, Missouri,
Caucus of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 17 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, The year 1969 will be the 50th Anniversary year of the
founding of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, Such a special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed,
and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies be
arranged in St. Louis, Missouri in May 1969 in commemoration of the St.
Louis Caucus of May 1919; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed fitting and proper that the National Executive
Committee should hold its constitutionally ordained meeting in May 1969 in
the city of the founding of this organization; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this Committee,
for reasons good and proper, shall hold its regular meeting in May 1969 in
the City of St. Louis, Missouri; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Adjutant is hereby directed to make the
necessary arrangements, and to communicate to the National Finance Commission an estimate of expenses involved so that necessary funds for this
purpose may be provided; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this Committee shall cooperate in every way possible
with the 50th Anniversary Committee in connection with suitable ceremonies
and other activities honoring the City of St. Louis and commemorating the
founding of The American Legion in May 1919.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A, this is
the second reading which the record should show was completed at 4:30 p. m.
on May 4th. Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
.. . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin.
84
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
MR. KERR, Missouri: May I ask the question, these dates that are set
forth, are these concrete or may this be just a little more fluid to come closer
to the actual St. Louis Caucus in 1919?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We understand that these are
the dates of the Caucus.
MR. KERR: I was under the impression that it was May 8th to 10th,
perhaps I am wrong.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Where are the founding fathers?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What is the intent of the resolution?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Might we amend to read that the dates shall
be those which shall be later found by the Committee to be the exact dates?
Why don’t we make it fluid?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we can
do this, we can just cut it off after the “hold its regular meeting in May
1969” after that cut out this part of the sentence, “during the days 17, 18
and 19 of said month.” Eliminate that, and then I think we have the resolution in a fluid condition.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Mr. Chairman, why don’t you substitute “during the appropriate dates”?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Well, I thought maybe this
would simplify it, and the Committee—it makes no difference to us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is what I thought.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We accept that.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES : You accept it. Does the mover and
seconder accept the amendment?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You know what you are voting
on? Anyone want a clarifying statement?
Ready for the question? All in favor signify by saying aye; all opposed
no. The amendment is adopted.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Commend Youth”
Resolution No. 28 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, There is considerable material reaching the general public
today through our various public media concerned with youth crime and antisocial behavior on the part of young people, and
WHEREAS, A bare 3 per cent of our young people ever come in contact
with law enforcement agencies, and
WHEREAS, The overwhelming majority of our youth show promise of
outstanding citizenship as evidenced in a number of ways, most recently by
their expression of support for the American policy in Viet Nam and support
of The American Legion National Program of “Show Your Colors,” now
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it express its wholehearted confidence in the youth of America and
commends American youth for its accomplishments in the areas of academic
achievement, loyal citizenship and character development.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May k, 1966
85
“Drugs Intended for Child Use and Other Hazardous Materials”
Resolution No. 30 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission.
Approved: National Legislative Commission (Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, Accidents continue to be the leading cause of death and
disability among children, and
WHEREAS, Many of these accidents can be prevented by the use of
special packaging, special capping devices, and cautionary labels, and
WHEREAS, Many substances now being used in the manufacture of children’s toys and household items are considered hazardous, now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee, assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that it urges federal legislation be enacted
to protect children and others from accidental death or injury by amending
existing laws with respect to drugs intended for children’s use, safety closures on drug containers, cautionary labeling of containers, and ban hazardous toys and articles intended for children.
The foregoing resolutions were approved and adopted.
“Need for Expanded Research and Educational Program
Concerning Genetic Diseases”
Resolution No. 29 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, Chromosomal diseases are a major cause of disabling conditions among children including such commonly known disabilities as retardation, and
WHEREAS, research has demonstrated that many of these diseases
can be prevented by a chromosomal study of prospective parents, and
WHEREAS, There are many diseases remaining among children which are
suspected to be of genetic origin, and
WHEREAS, There is an urgent need to disseminate available information concerning diseases of genetic origin to prospective parents as a means
of preventing such disorders, and
WHEREAS, There is a need for further extensive research in the field of
genetics, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966 that it urges an aggressive educational effort be made to familiarize
prospective parents of the need for a chromosomal study as a means of preventing such diseases, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That every effort be made to expand genetic
research through appropriate agencies of Government and private sources.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Upon the recommendation of
the Subcommittee on Resolutions and the Chairman of the National Child_ Welfare Commission Bob Noonan, it has been referred back to their Commission
for further edification and revision.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Does that finish your resolutions?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: That completes it.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN HORTON: A subcommittee of your National Legislative Commission met in Room 407 in the National Headquarters
86
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Building, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2 and 3, 1966 with the following
members in attendance:
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
L. A. “Bill” Williams (Washington), Secretary
Harry W. Colmery (Kansas), Consultant
Robert F. “Sam” Murphy (Massachusetts), Special Consultant
Bernie C. McLeish (Michigan)
James V. Day (Maine)
Walter W. Barnard (Montana)
Edward F. McGinnis (Illinois)
David E. Weichman (Iowa)
Eric H. Smith (Illinois)
In addition, the following members of your Liaison Committee were in attendance :
Thomas W. Miller (Nevada), Chairman
George Petrovich (Alaska)
Bernard F. Gratton (Idaho)
Karl Yost (Illinois)
Gene Hassman (Oklahoma)
John A. Ryer (Rhode Island)
The subcommittee reviewed the Legislative program and heard reports
from the Subcommittee Chairmen and members of the staff. All members of
the Commission were unanimous in their expression of appreciation to the
National Commander for his untiring efforts and splendid leadership during
the year.
Your subcommittee learned with great regret of the illness of our Vice
Chairman Jared Maddux of Tennessee, who recently suffered a heart attack.
We are distressed also to report to his friends of the continuing illness
of Harry Miller of Arkansas, a member of our Commission.
Once again your subcommittee discussed the matter of increasing the circulation of our National Legislative Bulletin.
I had hoped that time would permit that we could call upon the Chairman
of our Liaison Committee to talk to you briefly on that subject, but I will not
impose upon you at this time. We hope you will subscribe.
This publication is a vital tool in our efforts to keep the membership informed of our legislative activities and stimulate support in Congress for
our program.
Now I just add one thing, in the next report you will find a reference
to Item 37 to sponsor and legislate nursing homes for veterans in Alaska
and Hawaii. Since we have been here our Director Herald Stringer has received an EWS from Washington informing us that the Subcommittee on
Intermediate Care concluded its hearings today, and favorably reported a bill
by Mr. Rivers of Alaska to eliminate some requirements for the intermediate
care for veterans.
All resolutions referred from your Subcommittee on Resolutions were considered in accordance with the provisions of National Executive Committee
Rule 8(b). These resolutions will be presented to you through your Subcommittee on Resolutions. For your information they are identified according
to number and short descriptive title in the annex to this report. Thank vou
Mr. Commander.
... The Advance Report of the National Legislative Commission is as
fnilnwQ*
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
87
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
by
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
This advance report of your National Legislative Commission covers the
period from October 7, 1965 to April 12, 1966. It summarizes the activity of
the Commission during that period. Any meaningful developments between
April 12 and your meeting May 4-5, 1966, will be covered in a supplemental
report.
Since your last meeting our Legislative Bulletin has kept you informed
of developments in the field of legislation and activity of the Commission.
Detailed information on our legislative program will be contained in our report to the 1966 National Convention.
1st Session—89th Congress
The 1st session of the 89th Congress adjourned last October 23 shortly
after your 1965 Fall meeting. On October 21, two days prior to adjournment,
action was completed on HR 168, the bill to increase service-connected compensation payments and make certain improvements in the VA nursing care
program. Your Commission regards the passage of this measure as one of
the major legislative accomplishments of the Congress last year. The bill
was signed by the President on October 31 as Public Law 89-311. (See National Legislative Bulletin No. 15, 1965, for details.)
On October 3, 1965, the President approved HR 2580, the bill amending
our immigration and nationality law (Public Law 89-236). You will recall
that this bill as finally passed meets the five basic criteria recommended by
The American Legion in Resolution No. 74, adopted at the 1965 National
Convention.
In closing my report on the 1st Session of the 89th Congress a brief
summary of its activities may be of interest to you. Seldom in one session
of Congress have we seen so much activity. The Senate was in session 177
days and the House 173 days. When it adjourned in October over 16,000 measures had been introduced with 563 public and private bills enacted into law.
The session established a new record for quorum calls and roll call votes.
It produced wide-ranging new programs dealing with an endless variety of
subjects. It appropriated more money than any other in peacetime history.
It was a unique and interesting session but with all of the other activity the
veterans’ program was not overlooked. In addition to the appropriation bills
some 35 measures were enacted last year in which we had a specific interest.
2nd Session—89th Congress
The 2nd Session of the present Congress convened on January 10 of this
year. The war in Viet Nam and problems concomitant therewith have been
the dominant factor in legislative efforts to date. Notwithstanding these troublesome issues the first major piece of legislation enacted in the 2nd Session
was Public Law 89-358, the new GI Bill for Viet Nam veterans. This legislation was unanimously approved on roll call votes in both Houses of Congress: 381-0 in the House and 99-0 in the Senate. The new law satisfies the
over-all objective of 1965 National Convention Resolution No. 22, adopted by
the National Executive Committee last October. We are hopeful that other
proposals contained in your Resolution No. 22 will be favorably considered
at this session of the Congress. In his appearance before the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs on March 1st National Commander L. Eldon
James made special reference to the fact that Viet Nam veterans should be
made eligible for war compensation rates, death and disability pension and
burial allowances.
88
Proceedings of Wednesday, May It, 1966
New Legislation
Since this session of the 89th Congress convened we have had the following
bills introduced to accomplish objectives of American Legion resolutions:
HR 12186. This was our GI Bill for Viet Nam veterans and as heretofore noted, the objective of our resolutions has been substantially accomplished.
HR 12300, introduced on January 25, is a bill to increase the travel allowance authorized for VA beneficiaries. Our Resolution is No. 14, adopted by
the National Executive Committee at its 1965 Spring meeting.
The following bills were introduced on February 9:
HR 12723, a bill to authorize the VA to furnish medical treatment and
services and drugs and medicines to veterans receiving additional pension
under the old law based on a need for regular aid and attendance. Our
Resolution is No. 20, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its
1965 Fall meeting.
HR 12724, a bill to provide that a chronic functional psychosis manifested
to a compensable degree within three years after termination of wartime
service shall be deemed to have been incurred in or aggravated by such
service, notwithstanding the fact that there is no record of evidence of such
disease during the period of service. Our Resolution is No. 50, approved
by the 1965 National Convention.
HR 12736, a bill to authorize the Administrator of Veterans Affairs to
pay disability compensation to veterans who have received disability severance
pay for the same disability.
HR 13059 was introduced by Congressman Ralph J. Rivers (Alaska) on
February 24. This bill would establish a national policy for the further development and expansion of our national cemetery system. It would create a
National Cemetery Site Selection Advisory Board which would operate in
conjunction with the Secretary of the Army in selecting and developing needed national cemetery sites and the expansion of existing national cemeteries.
Our Resolution is No. 11 adopted by the National Executive Committee at its
1965 Fall meeting. Congressman Rivers is Chairman of the Subcommittee on
National Parks and Recreation, House Committee on Interior and Insular
Affairs, the Subcommittee having jurisdiction of all legislation pertaining to
national cemeteries.
HR 13072 was introduced by Congressman Michael A. Feighan (Ohio),
on February 24. This bill would facilitate the entry under our new immigration lav/ of alien sons and daughters of World War I veterans of the United
States Armed Forces. Our Resolution is No. 186 adopted by the 1964 National Convention.
HR 13170 was introduced on March 1 by Congressman Thomas E. Morgan (Pennsylvania), Chairman of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs.
This bill would extend entitlement to Veterans Administration home loans to
United States veterans residing in Canada and Mexico. This program would
be administered by the Secretary of State and is in a sense a pilot program
to determine the feasibility of extending these loans to United States veterans
residing abroad. Our Resolution is No. 643 of the 1964 National Convention.
On March 7, 1966, Congressman Barrat O’Hara (Illinois), introduced HR
13318, which is very similar to the Morgan bill.
Washington Conference
The
1-3, in
tion to
bers of
National Legislative Commission met in Washington, D. C., March
conjunction with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. In addiyour Chairman and Vice Chairman Jared Maddux, twenty-six memthe Commission were present including Clarence Olson, the National
Representative. Also present were the following members of
the NEC Liaison Committee: Thomas W. Miller, Chairman, Gene Hassman,
Bernard F. Grattan, Karl Yost and John A. Ryer.
In addition to Commander James and Congressman Olin E. Teague, Chairman, House Committee on Veterans Affairs, a number of Congressional staff
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
89
members addressed the Commission including Oliver E. Meadows, Staff Director, HVAC, Gene Godley, Chief Research Assistant to Senator Ralph Yarborough, and Dr. Edward M. O’Connor, Staff Director, Joint Committee on
Immigration and Nationality Policy.
Again this year four Chairmen and one Director of other National Commissions discussed their legislative programs with the Legislative Commission.
Mrs. Arthur B. Hanell, National Legislative Chairman of the American Legion Auxiliary, was present at all meetings of the Commission and participated in the program. She addressed the Commission on March 2nd and outlined her own program that she has developed to assist the Commission in
its legislative efforts.
Activity in 2nd Session in Support
of Legislative Program
Again this year in accordance with 1965 National Convention Resolution
No. 341 The American Legion supported the House Committee on Un-American Activities and its budget request. Over the usual objections the House of
Representatives on January 27 approved a budget of $425,000 for use of the
Committee in FY 1967. The roll call vote was 299-24 in favor of the appropriation. The amount approved was $5,000 more than the total for FY
1966.
On February 28 testimony was presented on behalf of the National
Economic Commission to the Subcommittee on Housing, House Committee on
Banking and Currency, in support of HR 11858, a bill to amend the recently
enacted housing and Urban Development Act of 1965. The 1965 Act provided,
among other things, for preferential treatment in housing loans to all servicemen including veterans. Eligible veterans were barred, however, from availing themselves of these special benefits they had previously used their
GI Home Loan entitlement. The prohibition was discriminatory because
servicemen were permitted to apply for the benefits more than once if otherwise entitled. HR 11858 would eliminate this discriminatory provision and is
in accordance with Resolution No. 577 adopted at the 1965 National Convention.
On March 17 the National Rehabilitation Commission presented testimony
to the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs in support of our bill HR 7570
which seeks improvements in the Dependency and Indemnity Compensation
program for dependent parents. HR 7570 was introduced for The American
Legion in accordance with Resolution No. 6, approved by the Executive Committee at your 1964 Fall meeting.
On March 24 testimony was submitted on behalf of the Economic Commission to the Subcommittee on Labor, Health, Education and Welfare, House
Committee on Appropriations, in support of the FY 1967 budget request of
the Department of Labor for the operation of the Veterans’ Employment Service and related programs.
HR 1647 was signed by the President March 31 and is Public Law 89-380.
This new law makes it mandatory for Government agencies to abide by the
recommendations of the Civil Service Commission in connection with successful appeals by employees from adverse action by their employing agencies.
Section 14 of the Veterans’ Preference Act grants such appeals to veteran
employees. In the past some agencies had failed to follow the Commission’s
recommendation and refused to grant the employee back pay and restore
him to his former status. Public Law 89-380 accomplishes the objectives of
Resolution No. 640, adopted at the 1964 National Convention. Earlier this year
testimony was presented to the Subcommittee on Civil Service, Senate Committee on Post Office and Civil Service, in support of this legislation. The
bill had passed the House early in 1965.
CONCLUSION
Our current legislative program encompasses some 150 resolutions pertaining to all facets of Legion programs requiring legislative action. A total of
222 resolutions have been received by your Commission during the 89th Congress. Many of these resolutions directed us to support appropriations for the
90
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
executive agencies administering programs for servicemen and veterans.
Others directed us to seek funds necessary for the operation of the Committees of Congress whose work The American Legion supports.
The substantive accomplishments of The American Legion is impressive
when compared to the efforts of other national organizations. Your Legislative Commission believes that these accomplishments are evidence of the
high regard that the Congress and the people of this Nation hold for war
veterans and for The American Legion.
In conclusion, I express to National Commander L. Eldon James the appreciation of the Commission and its staff for his splendid cooperation and
leadership, particularly in connection with his efforts concerning the Cold
War GI Bill while it was under consideration by the Senate Committee on
Finance.
I also thank the administrative officials of the National Organization,
Messrs. E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant, and William F. Hauck, Director of the Washington Office, who were, as always, helpful to the Commission.
We are grateful to the Chairmen and staffs of the other Commissions who
continue to cooperate with us in our work. On behalf of the Commission I
acknowledge and thank Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, National President of the
American Legion Auxiliary, her Legislative Chairman, Mrs. Arthur B. Hanell,
and all the members of the Auxiliary for their continuing support.
This report would not be complete if I failed to mention, also, our hard
working Legislative Director and his dedicated staff. The Commission is proud
of our record in this Congress and we will continue to represent you and
the national organization to the best of our ability.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN JACOBI: Mr. Commander, members of the
National Executive Committee, I take it that you have received a complete
report, and have a copy on your desk. Therefore, I will refer merely to
the highlights of that report.
Your Internal Affairs Commission with an executive section of nine members present met May 2-3 at National Headquarters, together with William
McKinley and Sedley Peck as liaison from the National Executive Committee.
The number of resolutions considered directly by this Commission was
at a minimum since the committees under the supervision of this Commission
were also in session. Most of the resolutions being offered for your approval
resulted from the deliberations of these committees and are included as attachments to the formal report of the Internal Affairs Commission.
National Convention Resolution No. 153 (Ohio)—“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and Resolutions to Department Delegates at National Convention” is recommended for your approval as an increased and
necessary assist to the Departments by increasing the number of convention
reports available two hours in advance. We have been assured that this can
be handled at a nominal cost and without additional personnel being required at the convention.
100Twn resolutions are recommended for rejection—Resolution Register No.
1234 (New Jersey)—“American Nurses Day” requesting American Legion
support for an American Nurses Day is recommended for rejection as not
being germane to The American Legion’s programs.
T,he, second resolution, Register No. 1254 from the District of Columbia,
entitled ‘Protecting Privacy of Veterans’ Personnel Files and Records.” This
resolution is recommended for rejection also. A letter from the National Judge
Advocate Bert Davis dated September 3, 1965 to a District of Columbia Legionnaire who is a plaintiff in a civil action in the District of Columbia and
information contained in a letter from Samuel C. Borzilleri, Legal Assistant
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
91
to the Rehab Commission, were used as the basis for rejecting the resolution
as not being a proper case for the intervening of The American Legion.
The additional resolutions that will be presented by your Resolutions
Committee are covered in the attached reports of the Graves, Registration and
Memorials Committee, the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, and
the Constitution and By-Laws Committee. The Internal Affairs Commission
has concurred in the recommended action contained in these reports.
I would like to call your attention particularly to the prepared report of
the Graves, Registration and Memorials Committee. This is worthy of your
study.
The special resolution concerning eligibility will be discussed by that particular Special Committee.
Several matters concerning the Internal operation of our organization received our attention and you can expect more detailed reports at a later date.
Among these would be the effects on the Internal Affairs Division of the
conversion of our Magazine mailing list to a computer operation, and the
advisability of making advance preparation to welcome the Viet Nam Veterans in the event these are made eligible by National Convention action.
Since none of our other discussions involved resolutions, I will not take
your time now to discuss these in detail, but I can assure you that many of
them are of some importance to The American Legion.
Our thanks to Mr. McKinley for his assistance and also to the staff.
That completes the first portion of my report, the second being the
Special Committee action.
. . . The Report of the Executive Section of the National Internal Affairs
Commission is as follows:
REPORT OF EXECUTIVE SECTION OF
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5,1966
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee: Pursuant to the call of the National Commander, the Executive Section of the
National Internal Affairs Commission met May 2-3, 1966, in Room 301, at National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, with the following members present:
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
Max R. Brents (California), Vice Chairman
Ralph R. Storm (Indiana)
Frank A. Nietupski (Massachusetts)
Ben Holmes (Alabama)
Harry R. Harn (Idaho)
Dr. Charles W. Hoshall (Oklahoma)
Lawrence E. Fisher (Arkansas)
William G. McKinley (New Jersey), NEC Liaison
Sedley Peck (France), NEC Liaison
Mr. Max Brents (California), was appointed secretary for the meetings.
Staff Liaison J. Lloyd Wignall, Assistant National Director of Membership, and Mrs. Mary Hutchinson, acting as secretary, were present.
The number of resolutions considered directly by this Commission was at
a minimum since the committees under the supervision of this Commission
were in session, and most of the resolutions being offered for your approval
resulted from the deliberations of these committees.
92
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
National Convention Resolution No. 153 (Ohio)—“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and resolutions to Department Delegates at
National _ Conventions.” This resolution is recommended for your approval.
While this will increase the number of prepared reports being distributed to
the departments, we have been assured that this can be handled at a nominal
cost and without additional personnel being required at the Convention.
Resolution Register No. 1234 (New Jersey)—“American Nurses Day,”
requesting American Legion support for an American Nurses Day is recommended for rejection as not being germane to The American Legion’s programs.
Resolution Register No. 1254 (District of Columbia)—“Protecting Privacy
of Veterans’ Personnel Piles and Records.” This resolution is recommended for
rejection. A letter from National Judge Advocate Bert Davis dated September 3, 1965, to a Legionnaire who is a plaintiff in a civil action in the District
of Columbia, and information contained in a letter from Samuel C. Borzilleri
were used as a basis for rejecting the resolution as not being a proper case
for the intervention of The American Legion.
Other resolutions will be before this National Executive Committee as the
result of actions taken by the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee,
The Graves. Registration and Memorial Committee, the Membership and
Post Activities Committee, and the Constitution and By-Laws Committee. Your
Internal Affairs Commission has concurred in the recommended actions contained in the reports of these committees which, with the exception of the
Membership and Post Activities Committee report, are attached and are a
part of the formal Internal Affairs Commission report.
Your commission spent considerable time in hearing reports concerning
the effect of the Automatic Data Processing conversion of our Magazine
mailing list as it concerns the Internal Affairs Division. To date, we are
optimistic that this change will be beneficial, particularly in the membership
phase of our operation. We will continue to watch the development of this
conversion.
Another area that received our attention is in connection with the special
resolution which will be considered by the 1966 National Convention to change
the eligibility requirements for membership in our organization. We do not
feel we are anticipating the action of the convention, but in the event there
is a change and a new generation of veterans become eligible for membership
m the American Legion, we feel that we should be better prepared to welcome them than we were when we opened our ranks to the Korean veterans.
JNo formal action was taken, but a number of ideas were discussed and it
is anticipated that the staff will spend additional time between now and our
National Convention so that if the resolution is approved and the change receives Congressional approval, we will have a program ready to implement
at once that will assist at every level of operation.
Your commission also initiated action for a review of the statement of
purpose of the commission and the subcommittees under its supervision. We
hope to have recommendations ready to be submitted to the Reorganization
Committee at the time of the fall National Executive Committee meetings.
The International Amity Awards caused some discussion, primarily because there had developed a different concept in the Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonials Committee and that originally intended when the award was
authorized by this body. Through action of the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, supplemented by action of this commission, eleven people
are being recommended to you for the International Amity Award. This is
the subject of a resolution that will be submitted through the Resolutions
Assignment Committee.
Your Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee has spent considerable time m reviewing the awards now being made. The resolutions which
are being submitted on the Hearest Trophy and the Houghton Trophy were
carefully drawn, and are recommended for your approval.
Your chairman would like to recommend for your study the report of
the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee (attached to this report)
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
93
and also asks that you give special consideration to the resolutions being
presented from that committee. There now appears to be a chance that we
may achieve one of our objectives and that hearings will be held toward the
establishment of a National Cemetery Policy that will continue the growth
of our National Cemeteries in an orderly fashion. We are going to need the
cooperation of this body and, in fact, Legionnaires everywhere, and we are
going to need it very soon. You will be receiving bulletins and information in
the near future, and we sincerely request your full cooperation.
The National Adjutant had referred to our commission a request from The
American Defenders of Bataan and Corregidor that our posts be solicited for
ten dollars each to be used in purchasing mobile X-ray units and de-worming
units—the balance to help in constructing a Bataan Memorial Chapel and
recreational area at the surrender site on Bataan Peninsula. This request
is being recommended for rejection on the basis that it is contrary to our
established policy as it concerns direct solicitations of our posts.
Your chairman had requested that the Membership and Post Activities
Committee consider the possibility of establishing posts at large. A reply was
received from that committee indicating a negative attitude toward such posts.
We also had an opinion from the National Judge Advocate that the establishment of posts at large would raise Constitutional questions and would require
some changes in the basic philosophy of The American Legion. As a result,
the Internal Affairs Commission concurred with the Membership and Post
Activities Committee in rejecting this proposal.
Our thanks are extended to Mr. William G. McKinley for his cooperation and to the staff.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ HERBERT J. JACOBI, Chairman
Internal Affairs Commission
. . . The Report of the Subcommittee of the National Constitution and
By-Laws Standing Committee is as follows:
REPORT
SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE NATIONAL CONSTITUTION AND
BY-LAWS STANDING COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 2-3, 1966
Pursuant to a directive issued by the National Commander, the subcommittee of the National Constitution and By-laws Committee met in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966.
The meeting was called to order by Chairman A. F. Wells, of Illinois.
Present were: Francis Giordano, Vice Chairman (New York), and William
D. Packer (Pennsylvania), National Commander’s Representative.
The first order of business was the consideration of a special Resolution
submitted by the Special Membership Eligibility Committee, appointed by the
National Commander to prepare and submit a report and a resolution pursuant to an enabling Resolution No. 571 adopted at the National Convention
in Portland, Oregon, in 1965. This Committee considered and discussed the
Special Report of this Special Membership Eligibility Committee, and it considered and studied the resolution submitted by this same Committee as indicated. After considerable discussion, this Committee, on motion made by
Francis Giordano, and seconded by William Packer, adopted the Report and
Resolution unanimously.
It is, therefore, recommended to the Internal Affairs Commission that
this Resolution be ADOPTED.
Your Committee, after considerable discussion, feels impelled to. call to the
attention of the Internal Affairs Commission that language contained in nu-
94
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
merical paragraph three, page four, of the Advance Report of the Special
Membership Eligibility Committee, chairmanned by Past National Commander
J. Addington Wagner.
This language addresses itself to a discussion of the possibility that the
proposed constitutional amendment contains language indicating that the date
relative to cessation of hostilities could conceivably not terminate with the
end of hostilities in Viet Nam.
The next item of business was consideration of Resolution Register No.
1226, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Tennessee.
This Committee was cognizant of the fact that this submitted Resolution was
considered by the Special Committee on Eligibility at Washington, D. C. Further, it was noted that this Resolution calls for a change in eligibility dates
covering a period involving the Korean War. The substance of this Resolution as submitted, has been the subject of consideration at previous National Conventions. As presented, it is not in proper form in that it fails
to meet specifically the technical requirements for amending constitutional
provisions. Further, it is noted that no new reasons are given for extending
the Korean War dates. Therefore, on motion by Francis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, this Committee recommends DISAPPROVAL of this
Resolution.
The next item on the agenda was resolution identified as Register No.
1236, submitted to the National Executive Committee by the Executive Committee of the Department of Texas. This Resolution, although it appears to
be in proper form, requires a change of eligibility dates covering the Korean
War, starting on June 25, 1950 and continuing without interruption to
some date in the future as may be determined by the United States Government. Inasmuch as this continuous period covers dates already acted upon by
Congress and The American Legion in fixing the termination of eligibility
relating to the Korean War, and inasmuch as the balance of the resolution
is already covered by resolution submitted by the Special Committee on Eligibility, this Committee acted as follows: On motion by Francis Giordano,
seconded by William Packer, the Committee voted to REJECT this Resolution.
It may be further noted that, in effect, the continuous period of eligibility
would, in effect, change the character of The American Legion to include
veterans serving only during so-called “peace-time” periods.
The next order of business was consideration of Register Resolution
No. 1252, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Pennsylvania. After careful consideration, it was the conclusion of this Committee
that this resolution is technically not in proper form in that it petitions
action by the National Legislative Commission. It purports to be a resolution
of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion instead of the
Executive Committee of the Department of Pennsylvania. Aside from these
technicalities, however, the Resolution is, in effect, an endorsement of the
resolution adopted by the Special Committee on Eligibility, and for that reason it was considered for REJECTION. On motion of Francis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, this resolution was not recommended for further
consideration.
The Committee further considered resolution designated as Register No.
1198, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Mexico.
This resolution asks that the present Viet Nam Conflict be entitled the
War,” and that combattants thereof be made eligible for membersmp. The said resolution is not in proper form. However, since the resolution
of the Special Committee calls for the inclusion of veterans serving during the
period of the Viet Nam Conflict for eligibility for membership, the instant
resolution is not recommended for further consideration. Accordingly, on mo“°n °trJrancis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, the Resolution was
REJECTED.
Submitted by,
/s/ A. F. WELLS, Chairman
• . . The Report of the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee is as follows:
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
95
REPORT OF
NATIONAL TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE, THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5,1966
Thomas S. Donahue (Illinois), Vice Chairman
The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee met Sunday
and Monday, May 1, 2, 1966, in Room 207 of National Headquarters. Meeting
was called to order at 10:00 a. m. by Vice Chairman Thomas S. Donahue with
the following members answering roll call: Thomas S. Donahue (Illinois);
George H. Werkley (New York); Gus Draeb (North Dakota); B. B. Jenkins
(California); and Stanley J. Arabas (New York).
Eighteen nominations for the International Amity Award were considered.
The committee voted unanimously to recommend the presentation of the
award to the following:
Nominated By
Country
Name
George H. Werkley
Canada
Byron Wilson
F. Glen Starr
Canada
W. Lorne Manchester
Frank Kossa
Canada
E. K. Carter
Howard Dulin
France
General Pierre Koenig
Lewis K. Gough
Israel
Meir Bar Rav Hay
Donald E. Johnson
Australia
A. J. Lee
One nomination was recommended for rejection on the grounds that the
person nominated had already received the award.
Eleven other nominations, some of which are to be referred to the nominators for further documentation, were taken under advisement by the committee
for consideration at its meeting prior to the spring meeting of the National
Executive Committee in 1967. In recommending the above nominations for the
International Amity Award, the committee wishes to reiterate its previously
stated policy of a maximum of six recommendations—a maximum of three to
any one country—in any one year for this award.
Recognizing that the Manual of Ceremonies has reached that stage of development in which there are needed changes in its contents—usually _ corrections and/or improvements in grammar and word usage, which neither
reflect nor imply any basic changes in American Legion principle or purpose—the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee in submitting a resolution concerning the procedure for submission of future changes in the
official Manual of Ceremonies for approval of the National Executive
Committee.
Suggestions submitted by Robert Maxwell of the Department of Illinois,
pertaining to the Manual of Ceremonies, were taken under advisement. The
committee considered the suggestions to be constructive and worthy of serious
attention. However, the committee deemed it advisable to forego any suggested
changes in the official Manual of Ceremonies, pending possible action by
the 1966 National Convention on the question of membership eligibility. Although the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee traditionally meets
but once a year, just prior to the May meeting of the National Executive
Committee, the committee recommends that, in the event the 1966 National
Convention approves an expansion of membership eligibility, a meeting of the
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee be also scheduled prior to the
fall NEC meeting. This special meeting in the fall would permit any necessary revision of the Manual of Ceremonies to include the new generation of
members.
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts) 1964 National Convention—“Bestow
Posthumously The Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John
F. Kennedy”—was re-referred to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee by the National Security Commission which, at its March 1-3 meeting,
96
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
had approved the resolution in principle but not for the Medal of Honor.
In referring Resolution No. 447 to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials
Committee, the National Security Commission recommended that the late
President Kennedy be considered for The American Legion’s Distinguished
Service Medal. The Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee concurs
with the National Security Commission in approving Resolution 447 in principle, but the committee recommends rejection on the grounds that the. late
President Kennedy has already been awarded The American Legion Distinguished Service Medal—in 1961, which is the highest honor within our capacity to bestow.
Resolution 452 (Michigan) 1965 National Convention, which recommends
the presentation of a “Legion of Honor Medal” by The American Legion to
the late Adlai Stevenson, was referred to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee by the Convention Committee on Credentials and Internal
Affairs. Your committee recommends rejection of this resolution on the
grounds that there is no such award in existence.
A review of all trophies and awards currently authorized and presented
by the National Organization of The American Legion has been undertaken
by the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee. A preliminary report
of this review and recommendations by your committee is attached as a part
of this report.
Also attached as a part of this report is a report of special citations and
awards presented by the National Organization of The American Legion since
the May 1965 meeting of the National Executive Committee.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The Preliminary Report of the Review of American Legion Trophies
and Awards Committee is as follows:
PRELIMINARY REPORT
REVIEW OF AMERICAN LEGION TROPHIES AND AWARDS
BY NATIONAL TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS
COMMITTEE
In its report to the National Executive Committee, May 5-6, 1965, the
National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee recommended a
thorough review of all trophies and awards presently authorized. Such a review was recommended to be undertaken with the cooperation and counsel of
the standing commission or committee within whose area of interest said
awards are now being presented.
In order to determine the current effectiveness of the existing trophies
and awards, each commission or committee having such awards falling within
its purview was asked to submit specific, detailed information on the history
of the trophy or award and an analysis of the participation for such recognition, of the rules and procedures governing the trophy or award, and any
recommendations for possible revision of the rules and procedures. The
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee wishes to express its sincere
appreciation and commendation to the commissions and committees for their
cooperation in this matter. Each report was detailed thoroughly, containing
constructive suggestions and recommendations for the benefit of this committee.
Because of the scope of this undertaking, this report of necessity must
be a preliminary one. Some changes in rules and procedures are pending further study within the respective commission or committee.
The Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, as the result of its
review of American Legion trophies and awards presently authorized, submits the following recommendations:
1. Americanism—Your committee commends the National Americanism
Commission and staff for a thorough report. Your committee recommends
that the National Americanism Commission give serious consideration of new
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
97
criteria and guidelines for the determination of winners of the Janies A.
Drain Trophy (community service) and the Frank N. Belgrano, Jr., Trophy
(Boy Scout). Your committee concurs with the National Americanism Commission’s proposal for changes in the rules governing the Hearst Americanism Trophy, said changes submitted in a resolution for consideration by the
National Executive Committee.
2. Membership and Post Activities—Your committee commends the National Membership and Post Activities Committee for a highly informative
report. Your committee recommends that a complete study be made of the
physical condition of all active trophies awarded by The American Legion,
most of which appear to have suffered deterioration. Should such a study
determine that refurbishing of these trophies is unfeasible, it is recommended that whatever administrative action is necessary be taken to assure continuity of these trophy symbols in a physical form befitting the purpose for
which they were established. Your committee concurs with the changes in rules
proposed by the National Membership and Post Activities Committee with
reference to the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion Trophy,
said changes submitted in a resolution for consideration by the National Executive Committee.
3. Rehabilitation—No recommendations from your committee, pending a
final report from the National Rehabilitation Commission concerning the rules
governing the National Service Trophy.
4. Awards to Graduates of Armed Service Academies—Your committee
recommends that every effort be made for greater publicity concerning these
awards in order that members of The American Legion may be aware of
such honors bestowed by their organization.
5. Child Welfare—Your committee recommends that the Department 100%
Post Child Welfare Reporting Award (established in 1963) and Area Child
Welfare Reporting Award for Departments (established in 1962) be included
in the manual of Trophies and Awards Sponsored by the National Organization of The American Legion in accordance with Resolution No. 29, NEC,
May 5-6, 1965.
6. Public Relations—Your committee commends the National Public Relations Commission for its action bringing up-to-date the information on its
award and recommends that the necessary administrative action be taken to
correct the manual of Trophies and Awards with reference to the Fourth
Estate Award.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The report of Special Trophies and Awards Committee is as follows:
REPORT OF SPECIAL TROPHIES AND AWARDS PRESENTED
BY THE AMERICAN LEGION
May 6, 1965—May 5, 1966
Pursuant to Resolution No. 29, NEC, May 5-6, 1965, this will report the
issuance of the following awards and citations for the period of May 6,
1965, to May 5, 1966:
1. Roy L. Vingers Post 52, Department of Wisconsin, Certificate of Commendation, by action of National Americanism Commission.
2. Congressman Olin E. Teague, special award, upon recommendation
of the National Rehabilitation Commission.
3. Mr. Leonard Goldenson, President of American Broadcasting Companies, a special award.
4. Mr. Eugene C. Pulliam, a special journalistic achievement award.
5. Washington College, Maryland, and the student body of Washington
College, Maryland, two special citations presented upon recommendation of Department of Maryland.
98
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
6. Mr. Prank M. Greene, a member of the National Contests Supervisory
Committee, a special certificate of appreciation, upon recommendation
of the NCSC.
Respectfully submitted,
/si THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The report of the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee is as
follows:
REPORT OF
GRAVES REGISTRATION AND MEMORIAL COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 2-3, 1966
Joseph H. Hackett, Rhode Island, Chairman
The meeting of the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee was
called to order by Chairman Joseph H. Hackett (Rhode Island) at 9:60 a. m.,
May 2. All members of the Executive Section of the committee were present,
as follows: Joseph H. Hackett (Rhode Island), Charles H. Lugar (Missouri),
Carl L. Lundgren (Minnesota), Thomas R. Peden (South Carolina), A. M.
Renick (Virginia). One visitor was present, O. B. Yorker (Colorado), a
member of the committee.
Dr. Park. W. Huntington (Delaware) was elected secretary of the meeting.
The committee reviewed a report prepared by Chairman Hackett on action
to date concerning our efforts to achieve a national cemetery policy. The contents of that report are included in this report, as follows:
Since our last meeting several things have happened with which you
should be acquainted. Prior to discussing what has happened recently, however, I would like to spend a few moments reviewing our activities in recent
years.
On March 5-6-7, 1962, the Subcommittee on National Parks of the Committee on Internal and Insular Affairs of the House of Representatives held
hearings on the subject of a National Cemetery Policy. The American Legion
^e?? hearings and expressed their deep concern that there be
established a policy that would insure the orderly development of the National
Cemeteries as needed.
,. Up to that time, our organization had been placing resolutions and having
bills submitted on a piecemeal basis for cemeteries in various parts of the
country. At the 44th National Convention, Las Vegas, Nevada, October 9-101962, The American Legion adopted what I feel is a much more realistic
attitude with the approval of the following resolution.
“National Cemetery Policy”
Resolution No. 610 (Originating in Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Organization).
WHEREAS, In the past decade, hundreds of requests have been made upon
Congress for the creation of new national cemeteries and the enlargement of
existing national cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, The Congress, by its refusal to favorably consider such reqU es
at d
ex r
-rywill
“enot
Pconsider
ession of
Congressmen,
has strongly
indii r\,
cated
thatl it
thisindividual
increasingly
complex program
on a piecemeal basis; and
Whereas, In the Second Session of the 87th Congress, the Subcommittee
on National Parks of the House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs
conducted extensive hearings on the entire national cemeteries issues, with a
view toward developing a permanent national policy governing national cemeteries; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
99
WHEREAS, As an outgrowth of these hearings, Congressman J. T. Rutherford, Chairman of the Subcommittee on National Parks, and Congressman
J. P. Saylor, ranking Minority Member, introduced legislation of similar
nature, each having the purpose of developing a national policy on national
cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, It is anticipated that identical or similar legislation will be
proposed in the 88th Congress; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That The American Legion in National Convention assembled in Las Vegas, Nevada, October 9-11, 1962, supports the declaration of
national policy on national cemeteries by the Congress of the United States
and that it vigorously presses for the enactment of legislation to accomplish
same; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That it is the concensus of the convention that resolutions
now before this convention proposing piecemeal correction of this national
problem be held in abeyance until such time as a satisfactory national policy
has been developed by the Congress.
Unfortunately, the unchanging attitude of the Administrative Branch of
our Federal Government has been such that we have not been able to secure
further hearings or passage of bills such as HR 143—88th Congress—“National Cemetery Policy.”
At the time Daniel F. Foley was National Commander a letter was directed to the White House, and a very negative reply was received. In fact,
this reply was most disturbing and did not, in our opinion, express the will
of the country. Generally, we continued to operate under the policy expressed
in Resolution No. 610, and our Legislative Division was directed not to
introduce piecemeal recommendations for specific National Cemeteries.
At the time that I was made Chairman of this particular committee, we
began work on a more comprehensive policy statement which we. hoped could
lead to specific Legion legislation. As a result, there was action taken at
Portland where we adopted Resolution No. 501 (Virginia) (as amended)—
“National Cemetery Policy.”
WHEREAS, For more than a century it has been United States Government policy to provide its war veterans with a burial site in a national cemetery, such policy having been reaffirmed by the Congress on May 14, 1948,
when it enacted the most recent basic eligibility statute (62 Stat. 234); and
WHEREAS, Veterans and Congress are aware that space in some national cemeteries is exhausted and in others is being rapidly expended at an
ever increasing rate; and
WHEREAS, In the past decade hundreds of bills have been introduced in
Congress from all sections of the country seeking the establishment of new
national cemeteries and the enlargement of existing national cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, The great concern of many members of Congress over this
acute, vital problem was undoubtedly responsible for the extensive hearings
on this subject the second session of the 87th Congress (1962) by the Subcommittee on National Parks, House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs; and
WHEREAS, The administrative branch of the Federal Government has
adopted a policy that further expansion of the national cemetery system would
inevitably be both inequitable and extremely costly and that the fair and effective way for the Federal Government to participate in the burial of
veterans is through the payment of cash burial allowances presently provided
for by payments made by the Veterans Administration and under the Social
Security System; and
WHEREAS, The adoption of a bill to govern the further development of
the national cemetery system by establishing a National Cemeteries Site Selection Advisory Board, which would, in conjunction with the Secretary of
the Army, advise and report to Congress on the suitability of future
sites and expansions of national cemeteries, would be a step in the right
direction; and
100
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
WHEREAS, It is the responsibility of Congress to either provide for
burial sites within the national cemetery system for this nation’s war veterans,
or declare that this century old policy will be abandoned after existing sites
are filled; and
WHEREAS, HR 143, as introduced by Congressman John P. Saylor of
Pennsylvania, embodies certain provisions which are not acceptable to The
American Legion, including Section 4e and Section 6, although the basic purposes of the bill are in accord with American Legion policies; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the Forty-seventh National Convention of The American
Legion assembled in Portland, Oregon, August 24-26, 1965, that The American Legion urges the Congress of the United States to reaffirm its policy of
furnishing war veterans a burial site in national cemeteries, and to initiate
prompt action to establish a national cemetery policy within the framework of
which the national cemetery system can be continued and expanded as needed
m an orderly fashion.
From this resolution there was drafted a bill specifically covering the
policy as outlined in the above statement. A bill was introduced on February 24, 1966, by Congressman Rivers of Alaska as HR 13059.
, ^j£h the bill introduced, an attempt was made to hold meetings during
the 1966 Washington Conference to discuss strategy on how support could be
built for this bill. Due to circumstances beyond anyone’s control, it was not
possible to hold formal meetings, but a series of informal meetings and subsequent correspondence did give us a course to follow. In the meantime, increased local pressure from such areas as Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and
California, had begun to be felt in Congress and there was an awareness
among our Representatives that the critical point concerning our National
Cemeteries was soon to be, or had already been, reached.
One article in the Philadelphia Evening Bulletin of February 17, 1966,
devoted itself to the closing of Beverly National Cemetery in New Jersey.
It also contained a quote that left all of the major veterans’ organizations
mystified. That quote is as follows :
“Patten told the delegation that a representative of the White House said
no change was contemplated in the current policy toward the expansion
of national cemeteries without any unified efforts by national veterans’
organizations.
Cahill said the administration’s position has been conveyed to various
national commanders with the request that positive action be taken to
develop a unified program but no response has been received.”
Another bit of information came our way just prior to the Washington
Conference. In a memorandum from Robert F. Murphy, Assistant Director
of the Legislative Division, to John Corcoran, Director of the Rehabilitation
Division, the following paragraph was included:
“Mr. Meadows anticipates that the HVAC is going to explore the
National Cemetery situation. At the moment he has no definite thoughts
as to what direction the Committee might be headed. Because of the great
concern of so many members of Congress who feel that this situation
has become acute, Mr. Teague now believes that his Committee should
possibly play a part in this program.”
The possibility of hearings by the House Veterans Affairs Committee was
most encouraging and it was felt that it was time to develop positive support
from Legionnaires at every level of our organization. As a result, a bulletin
was drafted and copies were sent to Herbert J. Jacobi, Chairman of the
Internal Affairs Committee, Clarence Horton, Chairman of the Legislative
Commission’ and to the Director of the Legislative Division of our Washington Office. Each of these gentlemen was asked to make comments on the
contents of the bulletin prior to the time it was sent to the Department Commanders, Adjutants, NECmen, and members of this committee. There was
a slight delay until it had been determined that the House Veterans Affairs
Committee actually did have some intention of holding hearings on the subject of National Cemeteries, although all of the bills to date had been re-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
101
ferred to the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs of the House of Representatives. As soon as this clearance was received, the bulletin was distributed.
The Legislative Division cooperated by giving excellent coverage of the
National Cemetery Bill in the issues of March 15, 1966, and April 1, 1966.
The April 1 article was particularly good.
Plans had already been completed, and there has now been distributed
an article concerning our bill in the May 1966 issue of the ADVANCE.
All of these things were beginning to have an effect. There was an increased interest among the Legislators and we were quite confident that hearings would be held this spring.
Two recent happenings should be noted. On April 19, 1966, a telegram was directed to the President, signed by the Commanders of the six
major veterans’ organizations. Copy of that telegram is attached.
Congressman Saylor, Ranking Minority Member on the House Veterans
Affairs Committee and Subcommittee on National Parks of the Committee on
Interior and Insular Affairs, introduced HR 14438—89th Congress—“To amend
title 38 of the United States Code in order to establish in the Veterans Administration a national veterans’ cemetery system consisting of all cemeteries
of the United States in which veterans of any war or conflict are or may
be buried.”
An identical bill was introduced by Olin Teague, Chairman of the House
Veterans’ Affairs Committee, with the thought that since these two identical
bills dealt with Title 38 of the United States Code, “A codification of laws
affecting Veterans,” that the bills would be referred to the House Veterans
Affairs Committee. This did not happen. Both bills were referred to the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs and we are now awaiting further
word on what effect this will have on possible hearings during this Session
of Congress.
The gist of HR 14438 is that the control of National Cemeteries would be
transferred to the Veterans Administration.
There are other matters before our committee, including two resolutions
but the prime purpose behind our meetings here at this time is to rurtner
the development of an orderly system of National Cemeteries.
Because the possibility of hearings before the House Veterans’ Affairs
Committee could possibly involve questions of primary concern to our Rehabilitation Division, further meetings are planned with representatives of
the Rehabilitation Commission and the Rehabilitation Division so that a unified stand can be presented.
Perhaps the most encouraging aspect is that we are now. beginning to get
the support from the field that is so necessary for any legislative effort.
(End of Chairman’s report)
Under future promotion we are requesting that:
1 The National Executive Committee take appropriate action instructing
all its members to take back to their individual departments requesting department action if possible at their department conventions in full support
of HR 13059—“A Bill to Govern Further Development of the National Cemetery System” and that all posts in each department write or wire their full
support of HR 13059 to their respective United States Senators and Representatives to urge their support of HR 13059 and also wire 'or-write Rep.
Ralph J. Rivers (D.-Alaska), Chairman, and the members of the Subcommittee on National Parks and Recreation,, urging Congress (1) to reaffirm
its policy of furnishing war veterans a burial site m national cemeteries; ana
(2) To initiate prompt action to establish a national cemetery policy within
the framework of which the National Cemetery System can be continued and
expanded as needed in an orderly fashion.
2. The National Commander contact the National President, Mrs. Walter
H. Glynn, asking the Auxiliary to cooperate in the passage of HR 13059
and to contact Auxiliary units in a letter writing campaign to their respective
102
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
United States Senators and Representatives to urge their support of HR
13059.
3. The National Commander contact the six national veterans’ organizations that signed the telegram to the President in establishing a firm national cemetery policy that these six organizations and any other veterans’
groups, such as retired officers, retired reserves, National Guard, Fleet Reserve, etc., support passage of HR 13059 through their National Headquarters and through their individual posts, units, camps, etc. Also, these six
organizations and other veterans’ groups send wires to the White House of
the imperative present and future need of taking care of the increasing demands for burials in national cemeteries.
4. Appreciation be expressed to Lloyd Wignall for his devotion and dedication to our committee’s continuing work and also for the fine support of
Clarence Horton, chairman of the Legislative Commission; to Herald Stringer,
director of the Legislative Division, and his assistant, John S. Mears, and
the entire membership of the Internal Affairs Commission headed by Chairman Herbert J. Jacobi for their continued interest in the committee’s work.
5. Congratulations be expressed to Chairman Hacket for his job well done
in preparing the condensed report for this meeting and for his continued
aggressive work in the overall program of our committee.
6. All members of the commission be mailed a copy of “Briefing Session
With Representatives of the Department of the Army on National Cemetery
Policy,” Monday, February 1, 1965.
Resolutions being presented through the Internal Affairs Commission for
your approval are as follows:
1. Resolution Register No. 1235 (District of Columbia DEC)—approved.
2. Resolution Register No. 1233 (New Jersey DEC)—approved.
3. Resolution Register No. 1249 (Pennsylvania DEC)—approved with necessary changes.
4. Resolution Register No. 1248 (Pennsylvania DEC)—rejected.
A number of other individual cemetery matters were discussed but are
being held in accordance with Resolution No. 610.
Your Graves Registration and Memorial Committee Chairman and committee members extend their appreciation for the cooperation that is being
given to them in their efforts toward resolving the national cemetery problems.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ JOSEPH H. HACKETT, Chairman
Attest *
/s/ DR. PARK W. HUNTINGTON, Secretary
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously approved:
“Authorize Chartering of Hohenfels Post No. 13,
Hohenfels, Germany”
Resolution No. 1 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
loreign Posts shall .be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the National Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
103
WHEREAS, The Department of France submitted an application for a
temporary charter on September 27, 1965, over the signature of Department
Commander Helmut Isenberg, for a Post to be known as Hohenfels Post 13
at Hohenfels, Germany, and to be affiliated with the Department of France;
and
WHEREAS, Jesse J. Trotter, Lt. Col., Infantry, Commanding, Headquarters, Seventh Army Training Center, Hohenfels Training Area, APO
United States Forces 09173, on March 28, 1966, submitted a statement that:
“This headquarters has no objection to the establishment of an American
Legion Post at Hohenfels, Germany, in the vicinity of Hohenfels Training
Area” and further reminding that the members of this proposed Post must
maintain an American organization which is a model of comportment as its
actions will be constantly observed by the local German populace”; and
WHEREAS, The temporary Commander of the proposed Post has certified that the Post will have expenses of approximately $45 per month and
income of approximately $400 per month and that the group is financially
solvent; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
Post to be known as Hohenfels Post 13, to be located at Hohenfels, Germany,
and to be affiliated with the Department of France.
“Authorize Chartering of Raymond Howard Post No. 8,
San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico
Resolution No. 2 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
foreign Posts shall be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that “no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the rational Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Mexico on February 11, 1966, over the
signature of Gordon A. Ballantyne, Department Commander, submitted an
application for charter for a proposed Raymond Howard Post 8, to be located at San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico; and
WHEREAS, Department Commander Ballantyne, by letter dated March
10, 1966, states that he and other officials of the Department of Mexico have
personally visited the proposed Post; that “this Department (Mexico) wi
not permit nor accept any activity or conduct which Y1*1,, eSbaJra!\-vV^
American Legion”; that the Post will have the ability to ^afford stabili y
and the means to meet any reasonably incurred liabilities ; and that tne
Post plans to engage in community service activities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
That the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
Post to be known as Raymond Howard Post No. 8, and to be located at
San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico, and to be affiliated with the Department
of Mexico.
“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and Resolutions to
Department Delegations at the National Convention
(Origin: Res. 153 (47th National Convention))
Resolution No. 18 (Submitted by: Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, Annually there appears less and less interest on the part of
delegates to annual National Conventions of The American Legion m the
affairs of the organization on the floor of said convention; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
104
V/HEREAS, It appears from a study of this inattention it is because
delegates lack the information to take the necessary interest in the affairs of
the convention; and
WHEREAS, Said lack of interest is for the most part caused by the fact
that delegates have little chance to become informed because (1) constitutional
amendments or resolutions are unavailable, except to a chosen few, in time to
permit any study, and (2) so much noise and extraneous conversation is carried on on the floor of the convention, notwithstanding attempts by the Chair
and Assistant Sergeants-at-Arms to maintain quiet; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that effective with the 1966 National Convention of The American Legion, the
National Adjutant, or his assistants, shall cause to be made available to
chairmen of department delegations or the secretaries thereof, resolutions and
constitutional amendments based on the following distribution:
One copy to each delegate assigned to a convention committee;
Departments of fifty (50) or less accredited delegates, 3 copies of each
committee report;
Departments of more than fifty (50) and less than one hundred (100)
accredited delegates, 5 copies of each report;
Departments with from 101 to 200 accredited delegates, 10 copies of each
report;
Departments with more than 200 accredited delegates, 15 copies of each
report; and be it further
RESOLVED, That no report shall be made on the floor of the National
Convention unless said committee report, in the numbers specified above, has
been in the hands of the chairman or secretary of the department delegation
at least two hours in advance of its delivery, unless administratively impossible.
“International Amity Award Winners for 1966”
^Resolution No. 19 (Submitted by: Internal Affairs Commission—National trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee).
WHEREAS, The National Executive
adopted at its meeting, October 25-26,
Amity Award and charged the National
Committee with the administration of such
Committee through Resolution 21
1961, established an International
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials
award; and
WHEREAS, The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee
has screened all nominations for said award; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled at National Headquarters at Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that the International Amity Award for 1966
be presented to the following:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Byron Wilson, Canada
W. Lome Manchester, Canada
E. K. Carter, Canada
Meir Bar Rav Hay, Israel
Pierre Koenig, France
A. J. Lee, Australia
Rev. H. Berry, Canada
Harold Berry, Canada
John Hall, Canada
George Waters, Canada
T. L. Fraser, Canada
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
105
“Future Changes in Manual of Ceremonies”
Resolution No. 24 (Submitted by: National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee,
since 1942, has been responsible for submitting recommendations of any necessary changes in the official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion
to the National Executive Committee for final approval; and
WHEREAS, The official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion
has been developed to include the various ceremonial rituals associated with
both organizational activities and public programs germane to The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, The official Manual of Ceremonies has now reached that
stage of development in which needed changes are usually corrections and
improvements in grammar and word usage which do not reflect or imply any
basic changes in American Legion principle or purpose; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled at National Headquarters in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee is hereby authorized and directed to make those editorial
changes, revisions, corrections, deletions, or alterations in future editions of
the official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion which are deemed
necessary and proper to effect ceremonial rituals; and be it further
RESOLVED, That said proposed editorial changes, revisions, corrections,
deletions or alterations shall be submitted as a separate exhibit attached to
and a part of the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee
report for final approval by the National Executive Committee in any session
during which such changes are contemplated.
“Support Legislation to Erect General John J. Pershing
Memorial in Washington, D. C.”
Resolution No. 26 (Res. Reg. No. 1235) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission. (Approved:
National Legislative Commission—Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, General John J. Pershing commanded the American Expeditionary Force in World War I with distinction; and
WHEREAS, For nearly half a century there has been no adequate memorial in the city of Washington to this great American; and
WHEREAS, There are pending in the Congress two bills (HR 10107 and
S 2338) designed to speed action on plans for such a memorial; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the Congress be urged to approve this legislation and that action on the
proposed memorial be expedited.
“Oppose Burial in National Cemeteries of
Individuals Convicted of Treason”
Resolution No. 31 (Res. Reg. No. 1233) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, Burial in a National Cemetery is an honor reserved only
for a veteran who has served honorably in the Service of his Country; and
WHEREAS, veterans may be found guilty of treason, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion opposes the burial of any veteran in a National Cemetery who has been convicted of treason.
106
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
“Authorize Chartering of General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45,
Cubao, Quezon City, Philippines”
Resolution No. 32 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
foreign Posts shall be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that “no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the National Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
WHEREAS, The Department of the Philippines on April 27, 1966, over
the signature of Edward T. Berling, Department Commander, submitted an
application for charter for a proposed General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45, to
be located at No. 6—10th Avenue, Cubao, Quezon City, Republic of the Philippines; and
WHEREAS, There was also submitted with the application for charter an
attested copy of a statement of assets of said proposed post, showing assets
on hand of P120.00 cash and P515.00 in equipment, and no liabilities; and
WHEREAS, Said application for charter was delivered to the National
Headquarters with the recommendation of National Vice Commander Robert
Phillips; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
post to be known as General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45 and to be located at
No. 6—10th Avenue, Cubao, Quezon City, and to be affiliated with the Department of the Philippines.
“Support the Establishment of a Suitable
National Cemetery Policy”
Resolution No. 33 (Res. Reg. No. 1249) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission (Approved by
National Legislative Commission—Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, The acute shortage of burial sites in National Cemeteries is
becoming increasingly serious each day, and for many years, it has been
the policy of each Administration of the Federal Government to oppose and
discourage the future development and expansion of the National Cemetery
System; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion strongly opposes this policy and believes it is the responsibility of Congress to decide without further delay the
future status of the National Cemetery System; and
WHEREAS, There has been introduced HR 143 in the first session of the
89th Congress and HR 13059 in the second session of the 89th Congress,
both bills asking for the establishment of a National Cemetery site selection
advisory board; and
WHEREAS, Two members of the Veterans Affairs Committee have introduced identical bills in the second session of the 89th Congress, asking for the
establishment of a National Veterans Cemetery System within the Veterans
Administration; and
WHEREAS, The purpose of these bills would be the establishment of a
National Policy by the Federal Government for dealing with the future development and expansion of the National Cemeteries System; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion continues to support the establishment of a suitable National Cemetery policy and urges immediate consideration of bills before the Congress that would achieve this end.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U. 1966
107
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This has the approval of the
Legislative Commission, under Rule 8-B submitted by the Graves Registration, and it has the approval of the Internal Affairs Commission; your
Committee recommends approval and I so move.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This completes this portion
of the Internal Affairs Commission report.
... At 5:00 p. m., the National Executive Committee resolved itself into
executive session.
. . . At 5:20 p. m., the National Executive Committee again went into regular session and the following proceedings were had:
REPORT ON VIET NAM
Erie Cocke (Georgia), Past National Commander
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: I hope that all of you will
consider yourself in recess.
I have been coming to Executive Meetings for 20 years now starting in
June of 1946, and what I thought I would say to you is what you can say
at home.
Many times you come here and do not have the opportunity to speak from
the record when you go home. I have just finished a most unusual experience in Viet Nam, as well as in Thailand and in Laos. I had the opportunity
of living not only with General Westmoreland, but with General Stilwell and
Ambassador Sullivan. I spent the first part of the month of April there, and
had the unique experience in the sense that after I was there about two days,
he put me to work, General Westmoreland, I mean.
I am real quick to say that there are several things that are well worth
saying to you, and should be repeated from the platform.
Number one, we are winning this war and
Number two, we are very effectively winning this war, but it is going
to take the patience of the American public to understand what is going on.
I would predict that it is about 18 months from the military standpoint
of view to complete the mission, and we have got about a 10-year program
in terms of aid and other responsibilities of building a nation. But I know
of nothing that was more substantially brought home of the effectiveness of
the 16 years that we have had in Korea than to watch the Capital Division
of South Koreans fighting in Viet Nam. If we can grow that type of leadership in South Viet Nam in the next 10 or 15 years of leadership, this will be
fine. We probably will have a challenge from the communistic approaches that
we have at the present time out of Peking. Peking is the dangerous element
in this particular operation.
As far as the medical situation is concerned, it is about 17 minutes from
the time you are hit to the time you are at an aid station, and that first
medic is the man that makes the clearest and the most calculated decision,
as far as progress is concerned, because he makes the decision on first sight as
to whether that man can probably go to duty in 30 days. If so, he stays in the
country. Otherwise, he is back in Clarks Field in the Philippines in three
hours, about 17 hours to Hawaii, and approximately 30 hours back to as
far back as Walter Reid in Washington.
That I think is something that is well worth saying to the American
public. As to the impact brought out by Mr. Miller today, there are 600,000
forces in South Viet Nam. Don’t get the idea we are doing all the fighting,
because we are not. This is allied action. There are 43 Provinces, and there
are 43 separate actions going on.
I walked out to an artillery position, and the guns were set one to the
north, one to the south, one to the east and one to the west. I said, “Sergeant, isn’t that unusual?” He said, “It is a little unusual, but yesterday we
fired in all four directions.”
I think that is about all, is about as illustrative as almost any point that
you could make of the impact of time and concentration. I was there at a
108
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
time when there were Coups and anti-Coups. Certainly the strength of this
government is important. They have already started moving away from August elections, talking about September elections. My prediction is that we
will probably have October elections out there.
In response to the question as to what type of an election we will get, we
will get a typical Oriental election, not a typical American election, because
the system that is going to be used is in terms of pictures. The pictures of
the candidates will be offered, and they will put them into the ballot box,
riot names, because of the illiteracy.
I think you will find out that we are producing a new concept in terms
of democracy. This is an unusual country to fight in. The temperature is 100
degrees in the shade, about 119 in the sun. It was very hot and dusty when
I was there. The monsoon winds had just started. The rains will just start
at about this time. There is about five months of water, and seven months
of dust, and that pretty well summarizes it.
I am real quick to comment about the impact of the importance of Thailand. Thailand today has done a very effective and outstanding job of being prepared. We can handle the brigade there in a matter of an hour; we
can handle a division in a matter of a day, and we can handle a corps there
in a matter of a week. I don’t think you will ever have the problems in Thailand because of its military hierarchy and the fact that they have been an
independent nation between the French and the British lo these last 150-odd
years.
As far as Laos is concerned, that is an entirely different story. It is an
intriguing country within its impact. Vientiane, the capital, is probably one of
the most interesting ones in the world. The Dean of the Diplomatic Corps
is from Peking. The Russians are there in the International Peace Commission. There are 40 Indian officers, approximately 70 Polish officers, and 40
Canadian officers there, a most intriguing operation in itself, but it happens
to be the only capital in the world that recognizes both South Viet Nam and
North Viet Nam Ambassadors, and ironically, they live within the same
block. It is a real point of contact, and it is important.
I had the experience of being with the Navy out on the carrier Kitty
Hawk, and with an opportunity to fly into North Viet Nam on a mission,
which was most interesting. I would say that we are going to do the job,
and are doing the job. I will say right quick, I got a “pungy” stick here.
Fortunately, it didn’t get infected. Those that don’t get infected last about
five to six months, those that do get infected, that is a very nasty problem.
Now, a pungy stick is a bamboo stick with a poisoned end to it, and it
pretty well lasts about five or six months from the time it is planted with
that poisonous problem. We have lots of wounds with them.
The Famous Sergeant Sadler in his “Green Beret” wrote all about the
pungy sticks. I don’t have to get me a guitar but I am real quick to say it
is to your interest to know of the impact that we made.
I think that General Westmoreland is probably one of the most effective
Commanders that I have ever seen in the field. I rode with an awful lot of
three and four star Generals in both the second war, as well as in Korea,
and I will put him up against any of them that I have had any dealings
with. He is 52 years old, and 30 years out of West Point this particular
June. He certainly is a man of destiny and he has a real problem out
there.
The cost and expense, no equivocation as to its reservation. Shortages,
yes. Obviously shortages of some sorts, like making change for a dollar,
you can use two 50<£ pieces, four quarters, ten dimes, 20 nickels or 100 pennies.
There is some combination that you can use. And when the requirement would
be a 500 pound bomb, if there is no 500 pound bomb, certainly there are two
250s or some combination of making change. So that when you ask about the
shortage question, I am real quick to say that at a given time, on a given
item probably there is a shortage, but I am real quick to say that they are
taken care of.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
109
I happened to be there at the time when the hotel I was supposed to
stay in was blown up, with some 200 casualties, and some 70-odd killed. I
happened to also be flying off the airport at the time that it was bombed.
The experiences are there. You don’t have to go to the front lines. There
are no front lines. The front line changes at every location.
Now as to the war, what is it? It is a war of rice and war of economics,
it is a war of opportunity. In the Me Kong Kiver, certainly it has a marvelous climate and a marvelous beach. The beach is unusual. Distances are
something that most people miss. The distance between North Viet Nam and
South Viet Nam from tip to tip is approximately the distance from Washington, D. C. to Los Angeles. The distance from the northern point of
South Viet Nam to the tip of South Viet Nam is about like the distance
in coastline from Cape Cod, Massachusetts to Cape Kennedy in Florida. Those
are the types of things that the average person doesn’t take the time to
realize and what an impact we are talking about and the strategy that we
have.
We have approximately 250,000 people there now. I would predict without
question that it will probably take double that amount before we get through
in the next 18 months. Rotation is working out beautifully. The First
Cavalry for example took over some 17,000 people in August and September
of last year. Much to my amazement, they have already rotated 6,000 of
their 17,000 people. They rotated people, and the big argument that came
up at that time was a man that had only some eight weeks to go, yet he went
to Viet Nam, he rotated the ninth week and came home. As a result of this,
they have kept this rotation going.
Critical items are pilots, because in the First Cavalry there are 1,000
pilots alone, and most of them have rotated their 680 hours two weeks ago.
That is the answer. The answer is the rotation side of it. They are moving
very fast and very effectively. Most everybody will come home at the higher
echelon, they say a month early or a month late. When you get down to the
brigade they will say three weeks early or three weeks late. When you get
down to battalion, the man says he is leaving at this hour and this hour,
and it is almost right on it, as far as that goes. We are going to go the
second cycle on many people.
The need for French speaking officers is most important, as well as those
that can handle the problems that we have in both of these, or in these three
countries. The big question is still Cambodia.
I don’t worry about Cambodia. It is one of the places that I didn’t go to.
It still may be our biggest question. In Viet Nam we are invited in, and we
are in at the invitation there of the Government. Now in Cambodia, I expect
an all-out invasion, and I expect an all-out takeover and military occupation
of the type we knew in Germany and Japan.
Now those are the type of statements that need to be understood by the
American public, because there is a difference in the challenge of the people
that we have.
I am going to close with one simple story, having been interested in
prisoners of war, not only having been a prisoner of war of the Germans
in the second war, but also having served on the Commission of the 21 people
that were turncoats in Korea, I have always had a continuing interest in
prisoners. Actually, I witnessed an execution. That did not bother me, because
of the French standards and the French atmosphere, it was almost a beauteous type of Ronald Colman-Gary Cooper type of operation. But I watched
the reaction of the men that performed that mission, and I watched how they
talked and how they fought. And certainly, it is a story with impact with its
own power, without equivocation of any kind that I could tell, for there they
brought out a man, and they tied his hands behind his back, and they put a
blindfold on him. And he stood up as a spy, as he came from North Viet
Nam. He stood up and was there, and what did he say? “I live for Ho Chi
Minh, and I die for Ho Chi Minh’s philosophy. That is what I die for, and
I am standing as witness for him.” And about that time they killed him.
Hollywood couldn’t have done a better show, couldn’t have had more impact, couldn’t have been more dynamic in its impact on the few people that
110
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
saw it. But then when the story goes on, and you sit down and you talk
to that Sergeant and watch his own officers handle the most important question, as he says, “Sergeant, weren’t you a little uneasy about it, wasn’t this
your first execution?” And the South Vietnamese Sergeant nodded that it
was, but then he said, “What is bothering me, was not the impact of taking
a man’s life in the execution of a military obligation and the carrying out
of a court martial, a man caught red-handed as a spy appearing in black
pajamas as is the custom of the day.” But the simple fact was that he said,
“I was born in North Viet Nam, and I have been selected to go back to North
Viet Nam as a spy as a civilian, and not in the protection of a military
uniform, and I am probably going to be caught,” he says to his officer,
and “Who do I die for when my time comes?” And there was no answer.
That is the difference of the impact of what is going on there for the
North Vietnamese that are indoctrinated, that are dedicated with that vital
understanding of its importance. And the South Vietnamese don’t have that
dedication, they don’t have that symbol, and they don’t have it, except in the
power of the American forces there.
Nothing has been more emphatic, nothing has been more dramatic, nothing
has been more challenging than the fact that the American forces have done
in hours what the French lost in 30 years, and what the Japanese lost in
four years.
They have had a lot of experience of occupation, they have had lots of
experience of a foreign military system, particularly a white face. But above
it all, we are winning because we have got the patience to not only build a
military operation as we go, but I could tell you for an hour or so on the
civil side of this operation, for as we fight a war by the day, we plan a government by night. And we protect ourselves by night and with it, we are
having the challenge that we have.
I would say to you that anybody that burns a draft card ought to have
the disgrace of the uniformed groups around him ever imprinted upon his
mind, for that man that is doing a job in Viet Nam today is probably the
finest type of professional qualified soldier we have ever had, for the simple
reason that all non-coms and all officers for all practical purpose, except in
a very few junior Lieutenants and the very junior Privates have already had
combat experience in either the second war or in Korea. And this is for
younger folks, and this is the first time I ever got to a place where I became
an old man.
Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you. I don’t want anybody
to feel that they have got to stay.
NATIONAL CHAPLAIN THOMPSON: I just completed two weeks of
active duty in St. Albans Naval Hospital in New York. They have over 200
wounded veterans from Viet Nam. They have a high rate of infection or
communicable disease in the hospital, to such an extent that they have had
to isolate them, remove them out on the main section of the hospital and put
them down in the ramp over in separate units because of this infectious disease.
I fail to be able to reconcile how we can boast on how we get our men
out of there in 17 minutes. We get them in the States within a week, and
they come back here with such an infectious disease that we dare not keep
them with the rest of the patients in the hospital.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: I am not particularly familiar with your problem, but I saw the gunshot wound at positions, they were
moving so fast that I saw this, it was impressive certainly to me, because
nobody in an automobile accident in any major city in this country can be as
quickly removed as what I saw there.
Now on the different diseases, there is no question about it, we have
got a high venereal disease problem in Viet Nam. And I might say that, we
might say that it looks like we took it over there.
NATIONAL CHAPLAIN THOMPSON: In venereal disease, you got a
special condition, you got, you catch a man sitting on a toilet, and he will
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
111
get his head cut. You don’t have the problem alone among the military and
in the hospital or even in the barracks, and I don’t think you can write it
off as being a venereal disease. These are diseases which are contrary to these
diseases, social diseases that we are used to, and I think this is a problem
that we ought to be concerned with, and maybe we of the Legion ought to be
aware of it.
MR. HASSMAN, Oklahoma: I would like to know whether we might
have in written form some of these remarks that you have made so we can
take them back, or can they be mailed to us?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: Everything I said is on the
record. I stopped a long time ago arguing with the press about what was on
and off the record.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I wondered about the remarks of the Chaplain,
isn’t it so that some of these diseases are not too well knovm, and they
isolate these people so that they are able to contain them until they learn
more about the so-called exotic diseases?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: Could be. There is no question about the fact that it’s been very effective to wateh the transition of
progress that medicine has made.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, I wonder if we might
stand and salute the Colors and dismiss at this time.
... The NEC stood and saluted the Colors.
... At 5:40 o’clock p. m., the NEC recessed, to reconvene the following
morning, May 5,1966, at 9:30 o’clock a. m.
112
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
THURSDAY SESSION
May 5, 1966
, . . The meeting of the National Executive Committee convened at 9:30
a. m., National Commander L. Eldon James presiding.
. . . The members of the National Executive Committee joined the National
Commander in the Salute to the Colors.
INVOCATION
Rev. Alfred C. Thompson
National Chaplain
Let us pray. On this beautiful day, oh God, we are mindful of Thee and
Thy great creation and Thy care over each one of us. We pray this morning
Thy continued blessing on our National Executive Committee, praying again
for wisdom and guidance in those decisions that would help further the
destiny of The American Legion and our nation and each one of us, we ask
it in Thy name. Amen.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Pursuant to Rule 8-A, Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolution which was adopted:
“Authorization for National Adjutant of The American Legion to
Accept Advertising for National Convention Souvenir Program”
Resolution No. 38 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion has in the past and does now publish a
Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It has in the past employed the services of outside individuals and/or corporations to secure advertising for the said Convention
Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, At the present time The American Legion has no contractual
arrangement with any outside person, firm or corporation to solicit or secure
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It is the desire of The American Legion to have advertising
contained in the Convention Souvenir Program—all of which is to be handled by and through the office of the National Adjutant—now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and
5, 1966, that the National Adjutant be and he is hereby authorized to accept advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program together with the gross
proceeds thereof.
(Pursuant to Rule 8-A)
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A, may the
record show that this was read on May 5th at 9:40 a. m.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted:
“Viet Nam Informational Program”
Resolution No. 41 (Submitted by: National Foreign Relations Commission).
WHEREAS, the United States has given to the people of South Viet Nam
a solemn pledge that it will help them defend themselves against Communist
aggression; and
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
113
WHEREAS, United States’ objectives in Viet Nam are 1) to preserve
the independence of South Viet Nam, 2) to protect American interests in the
Pacific and Southeast Asia, 3) to convince North Viet Nam that it cannot
take over its neighbors by force, 4) to convince the Communist world generally
that it cannot expand further through armed aggression, including by means
of the device which it deceitfully calls “wars of national liberation”; and 5)
to convince the small, and particularly the uncommitted nations that the
United States will stand by its commitments; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is committed by National Convention
action to the support of these objectives of our government, and is convinced
that the early and successful attainment of these objectives is of critical importance to our national security and to the future of the free world; and
WHEREAS, for the fulfillment of the United States commitment to South
Viet Nam, it is essential that our government have the strong and continuing
backing of the American people for its efforts in Viet Nam; and
WHEREAS, many of those who dissent from United States policy on
Viet Nam have, both inadvertently and purposefully, disseminated misinformation and caused confusion concerning the issue, and have otherwise detracted from a consensus favoring United States efforts in Viet Nam; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that all concerned Americans
must do whatever they can to bolster public support for United States efforts
in Viet Nam, and to make it clear to the rest of the world that the dissenter’s view is not the prevailing one in this country and that the overwhelming majority of the American people are determined that this country
will fulfill its Viet Nam commitment; and
WHEREAS, American Legion Posts are ideally suited for serving to
bring about greater understanding of the Viet Nam problem and, thereby,
increased support for United States efforts there; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, That each Post of The American Legion is urged to organize and
implement within its community a continuing program of information about
United States efforts in Viet Nam, designed to help build increased public
support for those efforts through the development, on the part of all concerned citizens, of a fuller understanding of the true nature of the Vietnamese conflict, and of a greater awareness of the critical relationship of
that conflict to our own national security and to the survival of freedom everywhere ; and be it further
RESOLVED, That in the planning and implementing of such informational programs, it is recommended that Posts invite the cooperation of all
interested community leaders and officials of other local civic and patriotic
organizations; and be it further
RESOLVED, That a given Post’s Viet Nam Informational Program should
be suited to the needs and resources of its particular community, but should
include—
1) the sponsorship of Viet Nam forums, not for debate but for the presentation of factual data relative to the reasons underlying United States
policy on Viet Nam,
2) arranging for speakers having special knowledge of the subject (such
as United States military and civilian personnel recently returned from
Viet Nam assignments),
3) the showing of available films dealing with the Viet Nam situation, and
4) the distribution of pertinent literature and other informational materials; and be it further
RESOLVED, That the responsible elements of the National Headquarters
shall provide, for Posts undertaking to carry out this resolution, such support
services as are appropriate and feasible, through special bulletins to their
respective department headquarters and through the regular national publications.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just where is that insertion?
114
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE:
Right after “United States
efforts”—“in Viet Nam, designed to help build increased public support for
those efforts.” We continue on, “through the development on the part of all
concerned citizens, of a fuller understanding of the true nature of the Vietnamese conflict, and of a greater awareness of the critical relationship of
that conflict to our own national security and to the survival of freedom
everywhere; and be it further ...”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: If I might comment very briefly,
just a matter of emphasis, this program apparently developed as a result
of a question that was put to the Secretary of State, what, can The American Legion do in this instance, and he felt that our organization was eminently qualified to stimulate the spread of information at the community level,
and I think that may have been the organization of this particular thought.
“Urge Measures to Halt Flow of Communist Forces and Supplies
into South Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 42 (Submitted by: National Foreign Relations Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that fulfillment of the United
States’ commitment to help the people of South Viet Nam defend themselves
against Communist aggression is of critical importance to our own national
security and to the future of the entire free world; and
WHEREAS, the Communist leaders have thus far blocked every attempt
of the United States and others to bring the Vietnamese war to a peaceful
settlement, and North Viet Nam (aided and abetted by Red China and the
U.S.S.R.) has continued to infiltrate troops and war materiel into South Viet
Nam at a high and increasing rate; and
WHEREAS, it has become clear that, for the early and successful attainment of United States objectives in Viet Nam, North Viet Nam’s ability
to furnish the Viet Cong with men and supplies must be eliminated; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion reiterates its position, taken at the Portland National Convention and previously, of strong support for United States objectives and policy in Viet Nam, and approves of the actions taken thus far, but
believes that further steps are now required in order to halt Communist
aggression against South Viet Nam and the increasing killing and wounding
of our men and boys; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the taking of more vigorous measures—as military judgment determines necessary—for stopping the
flow of Communist forces and supplies to the Viet Cong, including the positive
interdiction of the Ho Chi Minh trail, the destruction of enemy fuel supplies
wherever same may be found, and the denial of the use of the port of Haiphong and other supply facilities, by blockading, mining, bombing, or whatever means are required.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: May I speak to this resolution?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Yes, use the mike, please.
MR. DONALDSON: Mr. Commander and members of the Executive Committee, I want to thank Tom Whelan and commend him for bringing this
resolution in. Some people may have the idea that it is just another series
of resolutions in which the Legion is again declaring itself. The connotations
of this resolution go farther. We today are fighting a war in the Viet Nam
of a vicious, well-trained and able enemy. The present tactics of infiltration
from the Viet Cong, the Ho Chi Minh setup is required reading for the military officers’ instructions.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
115
It is common practice in Washington today to refer to the infiltrators as
a fish floating in the pond of society. This is the infiltration that takes
place by the so-called “black pajama men.” You start your men and they are
gone.
In other words, to be effective, we are faced now with two schools of
thought. The headlines of your papers, and the paraders on the sidewalks
of the major cities of the nation have developed the psychology of nonescalation; non-escalation is another way of saying a revolution delivered
from the present government, which is the Communistic line.
The other school of thought follows our military thinking, and here the
men in the field are still getting their targets from Washington. And when
the attack starts, they are not given a free hand to take a target while enroute.
What we are saying here, we wish to go on record, and we are standing
up to be counted, that we want to conclude this war with the military operation and stop the killing of our boys in Viet Nam.
Now we tried hard, our government at 46 capitals of the world endeavored
to negotiate a settlement of this conflict. This is the same procedure that was
used in the first World War and the second World War and Korea, and these
procedures have all been tried. Ho Chi Minh refuses to talk. This is backed
up by Peking. It is backed up by Moscow. There is only one logical conclusion, Ho Chi Minh and company think they are going to win.
We of the school of thought think that we can terminate this by active
military operation and are now going on record to make it clear. So that
you won’t be misled, the last statistics, even the Ho Chi Minh trail is being
bombed. Now it is one of these separate targets. But you have an infiltration from the north running 4,000 men amongst them, running bicycles and
bringing in four to six hundred pounds of ammunition. This is the supply
line. If we don’t eliminate it, and as we term it in the military field, we want
to eliminate those sources of supply and facilities that will be of help
to the enemy in carrying out its policy against South Viet Nam. This is a
broad sweep complex.
. . . National Vice Commander Galbraith in the Chair.
MR. DONALDSON: We are not asking that they do anything to injure
the civilians. From the air, we are dropping leaflets today before ANTAC
goes in. Humane warfare is being conducted. I regret that as has happened
too many times in dealing with the communist countries, the North Viet Nam
government is a party to the Geneva Conventions of 1946, and those conventions describe the means with which the civilized world will deal with
prisoners of war, civilians, Navy personnel and wounded. I think it will shock
you to know that they refuse to recognize their obligations under any one
of them. This is not unusual, they have done this before.
We have today over 100 prisoners of the north. We have never been able
to communicate with them. Under the Convention which we have declared
that we will follow, we permit the International Committee of the Red Cross
to go into the prisoner camps, investigate them for health, medical conditions
and report back. But the ICRC to the north, they can’t get in, and they refuse to let them in. Fortunately, one of our flyers dropped in China, and he
is getting a package a month. His wife is communicating with him and with
the other three prisoners in Communist China today. But as soon as you get
over into Viet Nam territory, we are frozen.
Now the President has taken notice of this situation. I talked with Washington yesterday. He has appointed Governor Harriman as the Ambassador
at Large. Governor Harriman is now in London, and he will then go to Geneva, and his mission is to try and use his best efforts to implement the Geneva Convention.
I would certainly hope that you who do know any of the prisoners in
Viet Nam territory would write through Hong Kong to them. We are trying
to force letters through. And 12 have gone through, by the way—no packages.
We have got wounded men there and we would like to get them out, but un-
116
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
til they comply with the Convention and their obligations, our hands are tied.
It is a pleasure for me to second this motion and resolution, thank you.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GALBRAITH: Thank you, Mr. Donaldson. Commander James will now make a presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, I don’t believe it is
necessary to do a lot of talking about this resolution, but because I feel so
strongly about it, because I live it every day seven days a week, living with
this problem that is facing the American people, as I travel around the country, I want to comment briefly on this to help to emphasize and underscore
to you what you will be doing if you approve this resolution.
The question that I get as I go around the country is first, can we win?
And I say yes. And then they say, well, why don’t we get on with doing
it? This is the kind of question I get.
Now it seems to me from what I have heard and talked with people,
studied, that Ho Chi Minh is looking for one of several things. First, a military victory, if possible. We say this is not possible.
Secondly, the fall of the government or the arriving at a condition so
that there can be no stable government in Saigon. Therefore it will fall of
its own weight.
Third, that international public opinion will turn against the opposition
or,
Fourth, that we will be forced to withdraw from a division from within
our own country.
Now it seems to me that if we are going to help insure that Ho Chi
Minh is not successful in any of these goals, and incidentally, as long as he
feels that there is hope of arriving at any of these goals, I don’t believe he is
going to negotiate.
And so it is important that we do everything we can to see that none of
these things happen.
This resolution so far as I am concerned, the important language is in the
first resolve, fourth line, where it says that we reiterate our strong support
for United States objectives and policy in Viet Nam. And of course, we go
ahead and approve the action up to this time, but now it is critical, “but
believe that further steps are now required in order to halt Communist aggression.” And we speak of the killing of our boys and men. “Further steps
are required.” We don’t say specifically what they are, but further steps are
required.
In the second resolve, we urge the taking of more vigorous measures, and
this is very pertinent language, gentlemen, “as military judgment determines
necessary,” to stop the flow of Communist forces and supplies to the Viet
Cong.
Then we suggest various things that might be done. But “as military judgment determines necessary.” Gentlemen, I believe that the temper of America today is strongly for this position.
In the past, we have not waited, we have taken the lead; The American
Legion has been out front so many times, and if there was ever a time in
our lives when we need to be out front, it is now.
We can talk about fighting a humanitarian war, not bombing here and
not bombing there, but when we stay back and when we neglect or are slow
to take an action to stop these materials and supplies, then we are increasing
the casualties among our own, and although you might consider it a cliche,
I have said it and I will say it again, I think it is so true, that humanitarianism is just like charity, it should begin at home.
So I hope that you will enthusiastically understand and then act affirmatively on this resolution, and having done so, you will carry the message
across to America personally, because passing a resolution alone doesn’t do
it. We have to go out and stand up and be counted. I thank you.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: May the record show that
the casualties of the United States so far in the Viet Nam exceed those of
the Mexican-American War and the Spanish-American War so far.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
117
MR. LINDSAY, Montana: Mr. Commander, I am happy to second the
motion on this resolution, but as a matter of semantics on the last sentence
there, the last line, the wording of “our men and boys.” Now it is true
that perhaps we have a lot of 18 and 19 year old young men over there, but
I am wondering if we shouldn’t perhaps delete that “and boys” for the main
reason that we don’t want to imply that we are sending a bunch of youngsters
over there. After all, these boys are doing a man’s job, so I would suggest
that we delete “and boys.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Lindsay, are you proposing an
amendment?
MR. LINDSAY: No, it wasn’t an amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We don’t want it, we were just
asking if you were proposing anything.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We will accept the suggestion
for the elimination of the words “and boys.”
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: Mr. Chairman, may I respond
to that? This very subject was discussed in the Committee, and in the draft,
because the 18 year old group is involved, the effect it will have on public
relations, the connotations it will have with our society at large, it was put
in there intentionally.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Then your position is that it
should remain?
MR. DONALDSON: We wish to have it in there and that is the Committee’s position.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then we will take a vote on the
resolution as it is.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: You have an amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, he didn’t propose an amendment.
MR. LINDSAY, Montana: Yes we did.
I move, I so move that we make a motion to amend the resolution.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wright, Mexico.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Do you want to make that amendment then, Bill Lindsay?
MR. LINDSAY: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then make an amendment.
MR. LINDSAY: I would like to make a motion that we amend this
resolution to delete “and boys” because after all, these boys are doing a
man’s job.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to this?
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The question then, there is a discussion first on this amendment to delete “and boys.” Is there any discussion
of this amendment?
. . . The question was called.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you ready to vote on the
amendment? All in favor signify by saying aye; opposed no. The amendment
is defeated.
Now we will vote to the main resolution. All those in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. It is carried.
REPORT OF SUBCOMMITTEE ON REORGANIZATION
William G. McKinley (New Jersey), Chairman
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following
report was received and filed:
118
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
• ; COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN McKINLEY: Gentlemen, I am reporting to
you now as Chairman of your Subcommittee on Reorganization of this National Executive Committee.
The Subcommittee on Reorganization of the National Executive Committee
met in Room 401 of the Washington, D. C. office March 3, 1966, with the
following members present:
William G. McKinley, New Jersey, Chairman
John A. Ryer, Rhode Island
Thomas W. Miller, Nevada
Gene Hassman, Oklahoma
W. Peter McAtee, New Mexico
L. O. Bickel, West Virginia
The principal matter of business was the consideration of a Resolution of
the Department of the Philippines requesting that authority be granted by
the National Organization for the organization of a Department of the Philippines, the American Legion Auxiliary. This resolution (Register No. 1202,
September 14, 1965) was originally directed to the Forty-Seventh Annual
National Convention, Portland, Oregon, but was withdrawn by the Department of the Philippines with the request that it be referred to this Subcommittee for study and report to the National Executive Committee for
appropriate action. .
Your Subcommittee gave much thought to this request and has had it reviewed by the National President of the American Legion Auxiliary, Mrs.
Walter H. Glynn, to obtain the benefit of the thinking of that organization.'
Mrs. Glynn had the subject reviewed in depth by a special committee which
in turn reported the matter to the National Executive Committee of the
American Legion Auxiliary at its February 1966 meeting in Washington,
D. G.
. . . National Commander James in the Chair.
MR. McKINLEY: And as a side comment, I might say that you will
recall in Mrs. Glynn’s talk to you last night at the dinner she mentioned
this subject.
In support of this recommendation, the American Legion Auxiliary points
out that the membership of the existing units of the Auxiliary in the Department of the Philippines is now approaching the 1,000 member requirement of a Department organization. It also invites attention to the increasing activity of The American Legion in the Philippines with concomitant
increase in Auxiliary activity. This calls for more efficient planning and direction of Auxiliary programs and for better discipline throughout its organization.
The need for a Department Auxiliary is emphasized by attempts to
devise better organization through the establishment of an extra-legal Council of Auxiliary Units. Such an organization is without authority to enforce
its instructions and it is not competent to carry out many other duties and
responsibilities normally the task of a Department organization.
Several Past National Presidents who have visited the Philippines have
emphasized the urgent need for a Department Auxiliary in order to keep up
with the increasing responsibilities required of both The American Legion
and the American Legion Auxiliary. The particular and special nature of the
circumstances prevailing in the Philippines calls for the best of organization
and leadership.
Therefore, from the viewpoint of the American Legion Auxiliary there is a
vital need for a Department of the Philippines, the American Legion Auxiliary.
In coming to a decision on this present request, your Committee has
chosen to take a realistic view of the matter. The Department of the Philippines is a live and growing organization. It has overcome many difficulties
with which it was beset during the Japanese occupation of World War II
and many hectic political and economic postwar problems. It deserves National encouragement in its endeavors to maintain an outpost of American
culture for American veterans in that distant place.
The expansion of American Legion Auxiliary activities is parallel to and
in direct association with that of its parent body. It will serve no good purpose
to now make a distinction where, in fact, no distinction exists.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
119
It is the recommendation of your Subcommittee that the resolution of The
American Legion, Department of the Philippines (Register 1202) be referred
to the National Organization of the American Legion Auxiliary for appropriate action.
Certain other business of your Subcommittee remains under study.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
SUBCOMMITTEE ON REORGANIZATION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolution which
was adopted:
“Referral of Resolution Creating American Legion Auxiliary Department
in the Philippines to the National Organization of the American
Legion Auxiliary”
Resolution No. 34 (Res. Reg. No. 1202) (Submitted by: NEC Subcommittee on Reorganization).
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4 and.5,
1966, that the resolution of The American Legion, Department of the Philippines (Register No. 1202) requesting the organization of an American Legion
Auxiliary, Department of the Philippines be referred to the National Organization of the American Legion Auxiliary for appropriate action.
(A copy of Resolution Register No. 1202 is on file in the National Headquarters Library.)
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved as
amended, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL MEMBERSHIP AND
POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
Earl D. Franklin, Jr. (Colorado), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN: Mr. Commander and members
of the Committee, each member of this Committee has received the Advance Report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee, and 1 am
sure has taken time to review it in detail prior to coming to this meeting.
However, there are several items that I believe are of such vital importance
that they are worthy of your serious attention.
I can think of no more important part of this report than to give you
the current standing of our 1966 membership efforts. As of two o clock yesterday afternoon, we had enrolled 2,431,168 members for this year, and that
is iust 7,705 short of our fifth target date to be postmarked prior to May 3rd.
And the goal we are shooting for is 2,438,873. This gives us a gam at the
present time of 11,831 over the corresponding day a year ago, and gives me the
opportunity to predict that when all the mail for May 3rd is in, we will not
only exceed our target, but will be put in the position of anticipating another
modest gain for the year 1966.
I know that you are all aware that we ended the year 1965 with a gain
of 2 809 members, and we are looking forward to an increase m 1966 greater
than that number, and are anticipating somewhere between five and ten
thousand again.
Mav I also point out that when this 1966 campaign is brought to a successful conclusion on December 31st and we have recorded a gam over 1965,
it will give us two successive years of membership increase, and this
hasn’t happened since 1952 and 1953 during the height of the Korean War.
Your Membership Committee at its January meeting, gave thought and
planning to three membership years—1966, 1967, and 1968. For 1966, our
concern was that a year that had had a very auspicious beginning should
end with a gain. For 1967, our problem was to design a complete program
for that year, even though we are faced with great uncertainties for the
120
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
immediate future. For 1968, we had to consider the effects of the automation of Circulation and membership records on our long-standing procedures.
May I add that those effects will be tremendous—but, we believe, advantageous.
Your Committee believes that one of the major contributing factors to the
success of the 1966 program has been the enthusiastic and courageous leadership of National Commander L. Eldon James. We are especially grateful for
the personal interest he has taken in all phases of the membership program,
for his personal efforts to insure its success, and the continuing support he
has extended from the day of his election until the present moment. The National Membership Workshop, which was first held in the summer of 1964
and again last year, has definitely stimulated better early planning and a
more coordinated campaign. The 1966 program itself, with the six major target dates, was extremely well received by the Departments. Most of them
adapted this same program to their Departments, and have cooperated fully
in stressing each date. As you know, we have more than met our national
target on each of the prior four dates, and I have no doubt that some time
today we will surpass our fifth target date. More than 40 Departments have
met their individual targets on each turn-in date, and 49 of the 58 Departments reached 100 per cent or more of their March 31 targets.
Many improvements have been made in the program being offered to the
Posts, and the quality of our materials is being constantly upgraded. We
feel that the membership program developed over the past several years by
your Committee and implemented by the staff has contributed materially to
the increase of 1965 and our expectations for 1966.
I especially want to call your attention to the 1967 planning guide, “The
Big Year” and our brand-new application for membership, the “New Challenge” which replaces our previous magazine formula. We feel that they have
done a lot toward upgrading our material. We will be using this material in
the coming years.
A study of successful new Posts chartered during the past three years
revealed the significant and highly encouraging fact that, in these new
Posts, an average of 30 per cent of their members are Korean War veterans.
The drive to start new Posts, primarily in suburban areas, has picked up
some momentum and is getting somewhat better reception. We still, however,
have a great many more new American Legion Posts to be established before every eligible veteran will have a reasonable opportunity to become
a member.
It is also my privilege to report that our junior organization, The Sons
of The American Legion, continues to show steady growth, and we confidently anticipate that 1966 will close with our 12th consecutive year of membership gain. A special subcommittee of the Membership and Post Activities
Committee supervises this activity and subjected the entire program to review and study at our January meeting. Several steps were taken that will
add further strength to the SAL. These were of an administrative nature
and do not need to absorb your time at this meeting.
Although at the time we met, 1966 had barely begun, yet most of our
work at the January meeting was directed towards the 1967 membership
program. We are again planning a National Membership Workshop to be
held here in Indianapolis.
. . . National Vice Commander Tom in the Chair.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN:
This National Membership
Workshop has been planned for Indianapolis, on August 4th and 5th, and it
has been approved by the National Finance Commission.
The publisher of The American Legion Magazine, Mr. James F. O’Neil,
has kept you well informed on the necessity to automate the circulation procedures of the National Magazine and of progress being made in this area.
You are also well aware that the automation of circulation procedures will
have a profound effect on membership operations, since it will involve the
development of a membership card suitable for electronic data processing.
From the standpoint of membership operations, we believe that the conver-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
121
sion to an automated, electronic system, expensive though it may initially
be, offers the potential of a vastly more efficient program.
While there will undoubtedly be many problems arising from the conversion in 1967 and 1968, the Membership and Post Activities Committee
heartily endorses the change and is confident that the new system will give
us much greater flexibility, a more efficient and businesslike administration,
and greater service to Departments and Posts.
During the past two yars, I have been privileged to serve first on the
Eligibility Study Committee, and now as ex-officio member of the Eligibility
Committee. Our Membership staff has also provided services for these two
Committees. The preliminary report of the Special Membership Eligibility
Committee, headed by Past National Commander J. Addington Wagner, was
reviewed by the Membership and Post Activities Committee at our January
meeting. The Membership Committee at that time adopted a formal endorsement of the Eligibility Committee’s recommendation that a new period of
eligibility be established, beginning with August 5, 1964, and we heartily
recommend the adoption of the Eligibility Committee’s proposed resolution.
The National Membership Committee believes that the privilege of membership should be extended to a new generation of war veterans as a matter
of right, and not through any selfish motive. Actually, we do not anticipate
any immediate great impact on our current membership if veterans of the
present war are made eligible. For one thing, most of them will still be in
service and will not be eligible to join until they are discharged or the
hostilities are ended. However, we will have a tremendous opportunity to
start bringing new blood, new ideas, and new vitality into our Posts.
But, if we are going to be successful in adapting our organization to the
needs of a new generation of veterans, we must make a conscious. and sustained effort. It will not be enough merely to change our eligibility rules.
We must prove to the Viet Nam veteran that The American Legion is an
organization which can and will represent him, that he will be welcomed
as an equal within our ranks, and will be afforded every chance to take his
rightful place in our Posts, our Departments, and the National Organization. Whether we like it or not, differences in age must be taken into account. There is today substantially the same age difference between the
active serviceman and the World War II veteran that there, was .in 1945 between the World War II serviceman and the World War I Legionnaire.
Much has already been done to bring today’s serviceman and The American Legion Post into contact. Operation “Show Your Colors,” The Viet Nam
Relief Fund, hometown newspapers for servicemen provided by the American Legion Auxiliary, decals for service families provided by Membership
and Post Activities, support of the new GI Bill, Legion Magazines going
to military units, and countless other Department and Post activities of a
similar nature have done much to lay the ground work for the day when the
man or woman now in service becomes a member of an American Legion
Post. But a great deal more needs to be done in the immediate future. Recognition and services should be provided by The. American Legion entirely as
a normal responsibility of a patriotic organization. These should be provided
without regard to whether or not we anticipate making the Viet Nam veteran eligible for membership.
If we are going to expect any considerable number of veterans of the
current conflict to become members of The American Legion, we and our
Posts are going to have to do a great deal more than we did after the
Korean War to welcome these new veterans, to convince them that we want
them as a part of the Legion, and to bring them into our Posts as responsible, equal, and functioning members. We are going to have to accommodate
ourselves to an even greater age spread among our members than we have
ever had. New activities, both social and service, will be needed at all levels—
activities that are in tune with a younger generation. Competent younger
veterans will need to be added to our staff at National Headquarters to replace those who retire. And, in our opinion, we don’t have too much time left
to paint the crib, double up the two older boys in one room to make a nur-
122
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
sery available, and reorganize our insurance policy to take into consideration
the fact that our family is going to be bigger, and our family obligations
are going to go on longer than we had planned.
Action on Resolutions
One resolution to make a minor change in the rules for awarding the SAL
Arthur D. Houghton Trophy is being referred to you through the usual
channels.
Resolution Register No. 1206 (Michigan)—“American Legion Membership
Dues statement —is recommended for rejection.
Resolution Register No. 1220 (New Jersey)—“Sons of The American Legum Continuous Membership Insignia”—is being handled administratively and
no action is required by the National Executive Committee.
Resolution No 275 (Pennsylvania) and Resolution No. 117 (California)
°°j
The Sons of The American Legion Program”—are recommended entitled
for rejection.
In closing, on behalf of the entire Membership and Post Activities ComIwpuid like to extend appreciation to the National Executive Committee, National Officers, and the National Headquarters for the cooperation
and support you have given our program during the past year. Especially,
do we wish to thank National Commander L. Eldon James. His support,
understanding, and leadership have been an inspiration to us and have made
Thank you ^
US t0 optlmistically
Predict a successful campaign for 1966.
ceived'and filtdI0NAL C0MMANDER QUINN: I move the report be re. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida.
C0M
MANDER JAMES: I trust the Chairman of this Committee will humor me by letting me offer an amendment to his report.
, / ,W”UM
to offer the following amendment, that this statement be
added at the end of the report:
Phased to close this report with this current and encouraging stater
May 3rd. a1966
, membership goal has now been exceeded, the goal
w q i no ' -ifT® tota
L ® of thls moment is 2,442,033. We exceeded the target
re ahead now of
w-+t
,
last year by 20,156. We have met every goal
y Ur
selvesear
°
^ep we wlR meet the final goal we have set for our-
94?8’«7q
ment^^^^^E CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN:
I gladly accept the amend-
• : The. Advance Report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT
MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Earl D. Franklin, Jr. (Colorado), Chairman
h P a d
plannin^mie
' , £ ?°st Activities Committee held its annual
iQfifiningj-mg at National Headquarters m Indianapolis, Januarv 28-29
mRteea?ht “ actc°rdaace ™th the rules of the Natfonal ExecStWe Com-’
^frn^tng it theat1meetnhPr^r report
^distribution in advance of your May
was averalin^some^fwrn i
7** written, our 1966 membership
Heve^hal ^
W ile
£
membm'ship^predfctio'ns^re always6 h^aldZT^ete-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
123
that 1965 also recorded a gain (of 2,809). We expect our 1966 increase to be
greater than the one in 1965.
Your Membership Committee, at its January meeting, gave thought and
planning to three membership years—1966, 1967, and 1968. For 1966, our
concern was that a year that had had a very auspicious beginning should
end with a gain. For 1967, our problem was to design a complete program
for that year, even though we are faced with great uncertainties for the
immediate future. For 1968, we had to consider the effects of the automation of Circulation and membership records on our long-standmg procedures.
May I add that those effects will be tremendous—but, we believe, advantageous.
Factors Contributing to 1966 Program
Your committee believes that one of the major contributing factors to the
success of the 1966 program has been the enthusiastic and courageous leadership of National Commander L. Eldon James. We are especially grateful tor
the personal interest he has taken in all phases of the membership program,
for his personal efforts to insure its success, and the continuing support he
has extended from the day of his election until the present moment. 1 he
National Membership Workshop, which was first held in the summer ol 19b
and again last year, has definitely stimulated better early planning and a more
coordinated campaign. The 1966 program itself, with the six major target
dates, was extremely well received by the departments. Most of them adapted
this same program to their departments and have cooperated fully in stressing each date. As you know, we have more than met our national target on
each of the prior four dates, and I have no doubt that, when all transmittals
postmarked prior to midnight, May 3, have been tabulated, we will have surpassed our fifth target of 2,438,873. More than 40 departments have met
their individual targets on each turn-in date, and 49 of the 58 departments
reached 100 per cent or more of their March 31 targets.
Many other improvements have been made in the program being offered
to the posts, and the quality of our materials is being constantly upgraded.
We feel that the membership program developed over the past several years
by your committee and implemented by our staff has contributed materially
to the increase of 1965 and our expectations for 1966.
A study of successful new posts chartered during the past three years revealed the significant and highly encouraging fact that, in these new posts,
an average of 30 per cent of their members are Korean War veterans, lhe
drive to start new posts, primarily in suburban areas, has picked up some
momentum and is getting somewhat better reception. We still, however, have
a great many more new American Legion Posts to be established before eveiy
eligible veteran will have a reasonable opportunity to become a member.
Sons of The American Legion
It is also my privilege to report that our junior organization, The Sons
of The American Legion, continues to show steady growth, and we confidently
anticipate that 1966 will close with our 12th consecutive year of membership
gain A special subcommittee of the Membership and Post Activities Committee supervises this activity and subjected the entire program to review
and study at our January meeting. Several steps were taken that will add
further strength to the SAL. These were of an administrative nature and
do not need to absorb your time at this meeting.
However for the record, I remind you that there are still two unresolved
questions relating to the SAL. First, should the SAL have a national organization? A number of our more active departments now do have a fully
organized and functioning detachment organization. (In the SAL, detachment” compares with an American Legion “department.”) Some of the detachment leaders would like to see us set up a national SAL organization
with national officers and a national convention.
The second question is: Should the SAL be designated as the heir to The
American Legion if and when The American Legion goes out of existence?
124
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Quite a few Legionnaires believe that this is already the case. However,
under our present rules and organizational structure, there cannot be an
SAL squadron without a Legion Post to sponsor it. So, should the Legion
cease to exist, the SAL would also.
Our SAL subcommittee, while believing that eventually the SAL may develop to the size and the maturity to justify a full-fledged national organization, reports that this level has not yet been reached and does not at this
time make any recommendation toward a movement in that direction. The
subcommittee also feels that it would be logical and proper at some time in
the future to recognize the SAL as the designated heir to The American Legion, but again recommends that the organization should be more fully developed and gain greater stability before this step should be offered to The
American Legion. With both of these recommendations, your Membership and
Post Activities Committee is in agreement.
1967 Membership Program
Although, at the time we met, 1966 had barely begun, most of our work
at the January meeting was directed toward our 1967 program. Various new
materials were approved, and the post membership program in detail has now
been incorporated in the 1967 Membership Planning Guide, entitled “The Big
Xear. An advance copy of that publication will be distributed to you at your
ay meeting. Improvements were made in our procedures for contacting Legionnaires who move from their home communities to other states and for
helping posts to prospect for new members.
We are again planning a National Membership Workshop on August 4-5,
and may hold one regional workshop, with the approval of the National Finance Commission.
With a very minimum expenditure of funds, a motion picture of American
Legion rituals is being taken and will be available for post use this fall.
IT rl7Ua J)afket offei;ed this past year to stimulate initiation of new memJlad \ very f‘ne and wide acceptance. We are convinced that properly
f°n.“acted Post meetings are essential to membership growth and that steps
?ost meetings must be included in any complete membership prof “5 Amrencan Legion Film Library, which is also operated under the
.P °gram, offers another aid to interesting meetings. Obsolete
turns are being disposed of; new films acquired; an automatic checking and
1 f m af er eve ry u e
devewLw
! also
i u
,
i
a revised film catalog
developed
that will
be available
for instituted;
next year’s and
operations.
The American Legion Advance continues to be the National Headauarters
primary means of communication with post commanders and adjutants Every
mdle tes th
and of its general acceptance.
?
For
e wide
membersh
use of the
p, as
publication
well as for
at everv
the post
national
level
the
L7eStoofnf
HSt-%ini?leMeducation
Tted.at and
P°st level, the rAXance Is an
essential tool ofmadministration,
promotion.
Automation of Membership Records
The publisher of The American Legion Magazine, Mr. James F
n the
O’Neil
toautomate
ceauies of the National Magazine
°
and of progress being the
made
drculaiion
in this area
pS
You are also well aware that the automation of circulftion procedures wni
r
develonmp
nt°
d
p ent
rnd effeft °?- meml?el'ship operations, since it will involve The
fJ®„° “
°f a membership card suitable for electronic data processing Ren
In!!fftlVeS ?£ the Membership and Post Activities Committee sat on the
committee
mend*«
appointed
by the
Commander
to study
mend an answer to
the problem
of National
automation.
At the staff
level and
the recomMemP arK
pnufk'
Post Activities Section has held numerous, at times almost dailv
matior^asTTre^ates
Fom h™ jPivision and the National Comptroller! AutoreIate
TtoJu Ad
AV* ,
s
to
membership, was discussed last fall at the Command,JUtants Conference, again during the Washington Conference this
11
Sln
hei
repj esentat
hv From
Frnl T
f *, ? 2”*]*
'
ive
adjutants
try.
the standpoint
of membership
operations,
we throughout
believe thatthe
thecouncon-
125
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
version to an automated, electronic system, expensive though it may initially
be, offers the potential of a vastly more efficient program.
Detailed planning is now far enough advanced that we are already designing our 1968 membership card. When the 1968 cards areshipped from
National Headquarters in the late spring or early summer of 1967 they will
have already been pre-printed with the names and addresses of 1967 members.
This in itself will be a tremendous time and work saver for the post adjutant. In addition, the system now being developed will, we believe provide
both the post and the department a much more usable record of their cur
rent membership. The plan will be fully worked out during the summer
months for presentation to Department Adjutants at their conference nex
fall-
. .
„
While there will undoubtedly be many problems(arising: from the conversion in 1967 and 1968, the Membership and Post Activities Committee heartily
endorses the change and is confident that the new system will give us much
greater flexibility, a more efficient and business-like administration, and
greater service to departments and posts.
Viet Nam Hostilities
For the past two years, I have been privileged to serve as a“
member, first, of the Eligibility Study Committee, and now °f the Specml
Membership Eligibility Committee Our membership staff has also provided
services for these two committees. The preliminary report of the Special Mem
bership Eligibility Committee, headed by Past National Commander J. Addington Wagner, was reviewed by the Membership and Post Activities Committee at our January meeting. The Membership Committee at that time adopt
ed a formal endorsement of the Eligibility Committee s recommendation that
a new period of eligibility be established, beginning with August 5, 1964 and
we heartily recommend the adoption of the Eligibility Committees proposed
resolution.
We believe that the privilege of membership should be extended to a new
generation of war veterans as a matter of right, and not through any selfish
motive. Actually, we do not anticipate any immediate great impact on our
current membership if veterans of the present war are made eligible, h or
one thing, most of them will still be in service and will not be eligible to
join until they are discharged or the hostilities are ended. However, we will
have a tremendous opportunity to start bringing new blood, new ideas, and
new vitality into our posts.
_
.
But, if we are going to be successful in adapting our organization to
the needs of a new generation of veterans, we must make a conscious and
sustained effort. It will not be enough merely to change our eligibility rules.
We must prove to the Viet Nam veteran that The American Legion is an
organization which can and will represent him, that he will be welcomed as
an equal within our ranks, and will be afforded every chance to take his
rightful place in our posts, our departments, and the National Organization.
Whether we like it or not, differences in age must be taken into account.
There is today substantially the same age difference between the active serviceman and the World War II veteran that there was in 1945 between the
World War II serviceman and the World War I Legionnaire.
Much has already been done to bring today’s serviceman and The American Legion Post into contact. Operation “Show Your Colors, the Viet Nam
Relief Fund, hometown newspapers for servicemen provided by the American
Legion Auxiliary, decals for service families provided by Membership and
Post Activities, support of the new GI Bill, Legion Magazines going to mi itary units, and countless other department and post activities of a simiiai
nature have done much to lay the ground work for the day when the man
or woman now in service becomes a member of an American Legion Post. But
a great deal more needs to be done in the immediate future. Recognition and
services should be provided by The American Legion entirely as a normal responsibility of a patriotic organization. These should be provided without regard to whether or not we anticipate making the Viet Nam veteran eligible
for membership.
126
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
But, if we are going to expect any considerable number of veterans of the
current conflict to become members of The American Legion, we and our posts
are going to have to do a great deal more than we did after the Korean War
to welcome these new veterans, to convince them that we want them as a
part of the Legion, and to bring them into our posts as responsible, equal,
and functioning members. We are going to have to accommodate ourselves to
an even greater age spread among our members than we have ever had. New
activities, both social and service, will be needed at all levels—activities that
are in tune with a younger generation. Competent younger veterans will need
to be added to our staff at National Headquarters to replace those who retire. And, in our opinion, we don’t have too much time left to paint the crib,
double up the two older boys in one room to make a nursery available, and
reorganize our insurance policy to take into consideration the fact that our
family is going to be bigger and our family obligations are going to go on
longer than we had planned.
Action on Resolutions
One resolution to make a minor change in the rules for awarding the
SAL Arthur D. Houghton Trophy is being referred to you through the usual
channels.
Resolution Register No. 1206 (Michigan)—“American Legion Membership
Dues Statement”—is recommended for rejection. The resolution asks the National Organization to provide without charge a return-envelope type of dues
notice. This envelope notice was developed about a year-and-a-half ago and is
currently sold through National Emblem Sales. We believe the envelope is an
excellent way to collect dues and would like to provide them without charge.
However, this would involve an added printing cost of approximately $50,000
to our budget, and we don’t have the money.
Resolution Register No. 1220 (New Jersey)—“Sons of The American Legion Continuous Membership Insignia”—is being handled administratively and
no action is required by the National Executive Committee.
Resolution No. 275 (Pennsylvania) and Resolution No. 117 (California)
both entitled “The Sons of The American Legion Program”—are recommended for rejection. Both resolutions request the appointment of a special National Sons of The American Legion Committee. We do not at this time see the
need for such a committee, since the National Constitution of The Sons of
the American Legion provides for a subcommittee of the National Membership and P°s.t Activities Committee to handle national matters relating to this
activity. It is possible that at some future time the program will have be^®m,e,s0 large that a committee of the SAL could be justified. If and when
that happens, the proper procedure would be to amend the SAL Constitution
to create such a committee.
Appreciation
On behalf of the entire Membership and Post Activities Committee, I
would like to extend appreciation to the National Executive Committee, National Officers, and the National Headquarters for the cooperation and sup£55
f1/!? °ur program during the past year. Especially, do we
thank National Commander L. Eldon James. His support, understanding, and leadership have been an inspiration to us.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
was adopt^
Chairman
Stone
submitted the following resolution which
“Change in Regulations for Awarding the Arthur D. Houghton
Sons of The American Legion Trophy”
,. Resolution No. 25 (Submitted by: National Membership and Post Arll^^S2oS£SS.Tr0phtoBi AWardS 3nd Ceremonials Committee-1
127
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
WHEREAS, By action of the National Executive Committee at its meeting of May 1941 the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion
Trophy was established; and
WHEREAS, The conditions for the awarding of this annual trophy
provide that it shall be awarded annually to that Detachment of The Sons
of The American Legion which on January 1 of each year has attained the
greatest percentage of increase over the previous year’s total membership,
except that to be eligible for the award the Detachment must have had a
minimum membership of at least 100 during the previous year; and
WHEREAS, In its continuing study of the SAL program, the National
Membership and Post Activities Committee finds that a minimum of 100 members during the previous year is too low and this provision of the present
rules is not in accord with the growing size of The Sons of The American
Legion; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 19ob,
that the rules for the awarding of the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of 1 he
American Legion Trophy be amended, effective with the 1966 award, so that
Detachments to become eligible for award of said trophy must have had a
minimum membership of at least 200 for the previous year.
REPORT OF SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
J. Addington Wagner (Michigan), Past National Commander
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Thank you very much, Commander Eldon, members of this distinguished Committee, may I first of■
say how very privileged I feel to be able once again to appear before this
distinguished Committee, because I think once again yesterday afternoon
you exemplified and justified the remarks that have been made m the past
by some of the leaders of our nation that this is one of the greatest deliberative bodies of our country, one in whose hands the affairs of our nation
could well be entrusted.
I believe this remark was by Mr. Walter Chrysler when he appeared before this Committee some years ago, and now to proceed with the Special
Membership Eligibility Committee report.
THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
Indianapolis, Ind. 46206
March 23, 1966
MEMO TO: National Executive Committee
FROM: Eldon James, National Commander
SUBJECT: Advance Report, Special Membership Eligibility Committee
In accordance with NEC Resolution No. 26, October 8-10, 1958, entitled
“Reporting Policy to the National Executive Committee,” the Special Membership Eligibility Committee has made available an advance, written copy
of the report that it will submit to the NEC meeting on May 4-5, 1966.
The special committee has performed an outstanding service on a very difficult assignment, and I hope that you will give the report and the proposed
resolution thoughtful study before our May meeting. In order that it may
carry out its assigned task of bringing an eligibility resolution before the National Convention, the special committee is asking the National Executive
Committee to adopt the resolution appended to the report for referral to
the National Convention.
128
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Because of the importance of the report, I am also causing distribution to
be made to the officials and appointees listed at the bottom of this memorandum.
cc: Department Commanders
Department Adjutants
Internal Affairs Commission
Membership and Post Activities Committee
Constitution and By-Laws Committee
Special Membership Eligibility Committee
ADVANCE REPORT OF
SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
To
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
J. Addington Wagner, Michigan, Chairman
The Special Membership Eligibility Committee, authorized by Resolution
No. 571, 47th Annual National Convention and appointed by National Commander L. Eldon James on October 11, 1965, has held three meetings—November 19, 1965, in Indianapolis, and March 2 and 3, 1966, in Washington, D. C.
During the March 2 meeting, an open round table discussion was held for
department representatives attending the National Commander’s Conference,
which was in session at that time.
All members of the Special Committee attended all meetings, and every
decision reached by the committee was a unanimous decision.
Scope of Committee’s Work
As set forth in 47th National Convention Resolution No. 571, the committee was “charged with the responsibility of preparing a resolution in
proper form, meeting all of the technical legal requirements necessary for a
constitutional amendment, which resolution shall represent the consensus of
the maljy resolutions submitted to this and previous conventions dealing with
the subject of extending the eligibility requirements for membership in The
American Legion, and upon the completion of the said resolution, said Committee is authorized and directed to circulate on or before 1 March, 1966, to
the several Departments of The American Legion the said completed resolution for their study and recommendation for the ultimate submission thereof
to the 1966 National Convention to be convened in the City of Washington,
District of Columbia.”
a
rL. Eldon
,his James
letter offurther
PP°intm
ent dated
11, 1965,
NationalThe
Commander
defined
the October
committee’s
assignment.
National
Commander wrote: “We are mandated by the 1965 Convention to place before the 1966 Convention these simple issues:
(1) Will the eligibility requirements be extended to provide the opportunity for membership in The
American Legion to persons having honorably served in the Armed Forces
since July 27, 1953? If the eligibility requirements are to be extended what
will be the exact nature of the change?”
The National Commander’s instructions further stated, “ .
in order
to complete your assignment, your end product should be a proposed constitutional amendment, in proper form, meeting all technical requirements
setting forth a recommended time period or other specific criteria for new
ehgibles for membership. With this the delegates can vote first as to whether
or not they wish to open up membership eligibility in The American Legion:
and
,. ?ec.°n<C whether they wish to accept your specific recommendation or
modify it as they deem proper.”
Very early in the committee’s work, it began to receive suggestions to extend eligibility to ex-servicemen other than those serving during the current
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
129
hostilities. Many of these suggestions were that the dates of American Legion eligibility should coincide with dates of eligibility for certain benefits
administered by the Veterans Administration for World War II or the
Korean War. Since we were directed to draw up a resolution representing a
consensus of the resolutions referred to the 1965 National Convention, we reviewed the text of those 31 resolutions and found that, with a very few
exceptions, it was the intent of these resolutions to extend eligibility to veterans of the present period of hostilities, now centered in Viet Nam. We
further asked for clarification on this question from the National Commander and were advised by him that the committee should confine its deliberations to the question of whether those serving during the present period
of hostilities should be offered the privilege of membership and, if so, how
this should be accomplished.
In excluding from our consideration suggestions for eligibility changes
other than those related to the present period of hostilities, the committee
is not passing judgment on the merits of any of the proposals it has received. The committee’s assignment has been very clearly defined for us, and
we have attempted to fulfill that assignment without permitting the central
issue to become diffused or confused. The fact that we have so limited our
recommendation does not in any way preclude any department from submitting, through its department convention, resolutions seeking other changes
in our National Charter and our National Consitution. The method by which
the National Constitution and By-Laws may be amended is clearly set forth
in the National Constitution and By-Laws, and departments so desiring may
avail themselves of their right to bring recommended constitutional changes
before the National Convention without the necessity of channeling such recommendations through the Special Membership Eligibility Committee.
However, if we read the temper of the last National Convention correctly,
delegates do want to vote on a clearcut issue of extending eligibility. The
proposed resolution at the close of this report will offer that opportunity if
adopted by the National Executive Committee for referral to the National
Convention. We would urge that those who may be interested in other possible periods of eligibility draft specific resolutions covering their proposals rather than attempt to amend the committee’s resolution. We make
this request, not harboring any illusion that we have reached the final and
only solution to eligibility problems, but solely in the interest of keeping
the issues clearly defined for the final decision of the delegates to the next
National Convention.
Basic Preliminary Decisions
Early in the committee’s work, there was unanimous agreement that the
basic concept of The American Legion as an organization open to all veterans
who served the United States honorably during a period of war should be
preserved. Technically, a state of war was never declared during the Korean
hostilities, but there was no problem in determining that a state of war did
in fact exist from the time that the United States Government reacted to
the crossing of the 38th parallel by the North Korean Army on June 25, 1950.
Today there is no question that a similar state of war exists in Viet
Nam. Since a war does exist, there can also be no question that those serving
in the military forces during this period should be extended the privilege of
membership, just as World War II and Korean War veterans were offered
that privilege. This was the first basic decision reached by your special committee—that our eligibility requirements should be changed to permit veterans
of the current hostilities to become members.
The Korean War began on June 25 with the crossing of the 38th parallel
by massive North Korean forces and the immediate response of our Government in committing United States military forces to halt that aggression.
Without the massive and timely response by the United States government,
made requisite by that aggression, there would have been no Korean War
(and, undoubtedly, there would not be today a free South Korea). Thus, the
criterion of whether a war does or does not exist is seen to be the nature
and the extent of the response required of the United States government to
130
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
an act of aggression on the part of a foreign power. The deployment of
military forces is a normal concomitant of the pursuit of foreign policy goals
on the part of every modern government. But the mere deployment of military forces or even the direct confrontation of a foreign military force by our
troops, as in the case of the Cuban crisis, does not in itself constitute a war.
The question of when the war in Viet Nam began can be re-phrased as:
When did the response of the United States government to the aggression
by North Viet Nam in South Viet Nam take on the characteristics of war?
There have been armed conflicts, guerrilla warfare, skirmishes, and terrorism in this unhappy corner of Asia since 1940. We have been extending
economic and military assistance to South Viet Nam since the collapse of
French colonial Indo-China in 1954. By July 1, 1958, United States military
personnel serving in South Viet Nam were authorized, the Armed . Forces
Expeditionary Medal. This is the same medal that was given for service during the Cuban crisis, in Lebanon, Quemoy and Matsu Island, and various
other areas where our military forces have been involved during periods of
crisis. Until August 5, 1964, our military involvement in Viet Nam was not
essentially different from operations in many other quarters of the globe—
such as Greece and Turkey during the late 40’s.
However, it is now generally recognized that on August 5, 1964, our military operations in Viet Nam changed in nature. That was the date of the
United States retaliatory attack on North Vietnamese forces in the Gulf of
Tonkin. Prior to that time, our military presence in Viet Nam had been
essentially advisory, supportive, and defensive. The response of our government in the attack on the Gulf of Tonkin can be compared to the response
of our government 14 years earlier in ordering troops from Japan to Korea
to repel the invading North Koreans. The Gulf of Tonkin attack was followed five days later by Congressional approval of that which has now become
known as the Gulf of Tonkin resolution, giving full Congressional approval
to the action and to whatever military steps were necessary in the future to
defend the independence of South Viet Nam.
For the reasons outlined above, your committee recommends that those
serving honorably in the United States Armed Forces since August 5, 1964, be
made eligible for membership in The American Legion.
We have no idea when the hostilities in Viet Nam will end. Similarly,
when World War II and Korean War veterans were made eligible, The American Legion did not know when those conflicts would end. The resolution that
we are recommending to you places the terminal date for this new period
of eligibility as the “date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
government of the United States.” This is the same language used when
Korea veterans were made eligible. How hostilities will cease, you and I do
not know. When they do cease, it will be the responsibility of a future
National Convention to take cognizance of that fact and to petition the Congress of the United States to substitute for the present wording (“the date
of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States”) a specific date upon which it is determined that hostilities have
ceased. Action by the Congress in accepting the recommended ending date will
in itself constitute determination by the Government of a cessation of hostitilities within the context of American Legion membership eligibility.
In all of our discussions, the sentiment was never expressed that American Legion eligibility should be based on place of service rather than time of
service. In reading the report of the eligibility study committee which functioned last year and reported to you in May 1965, I note that this committee
also agreed unanimously that, if a change in eligibility requirements were to
be made, eligibility should continue to be based on time of service.
These, then, are the basic decisions reached on a step-by-step basis by
your committee:
1. Even though undeclared, a state of war does in fact exist in Viet Nam,
and in accordance with the traditions, principles, and purposes of The American Legion, the privilege of membership should be extended to those serving
honorably in the military forces of the United States during this period.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
131
2. This new period of eligibility should date from August 5, 1964, since
the attack on the Gulf of Tonkin on that date marked the end of our purely
advisory, supportive, and defensive military presence.
3. This period of eligibility will terminate when the United States government determines that hostilities have ceased. Obviously, if at the time hostilities cease in Viet Nam there are comparable hostilities involving United
States forces in another part of the world, which we prayerfully hope will
not be the case, the present general period of hostilities would not have
ended and eligibility would remain open. The war in Viet Nam is the occasion for a new period of eligibility, but the new period would not close
with the cessation of hostilities there in the unhappy event that hostilities
comparable in nature and scope involved United States forces in another
country when the Viet Nam hostilities end. In any event, a future National
Convention will have the responsibility of petitioning Congress at the appropriate time to terminate eligibility.
4. In all respects, the action recommended parallels similar action taken
during World War II and the Korean War. Those on active military duty
anywhere in the world during the prescribed period should be eligible to join
The American Legion. They would be able to join upon the honorable termination of their service or upon the cessation of hostilities. Those who are
now in service would not be able to join until either their active duty had
been honorably terminated or it was determined that hostilities had ceased
in the manner heretofore described.
Procedure
Your committee recommends that the resolution which is appended to this
report and made a part of the report be adopted by the National Executive
Committee for referral to the 1966 National Convention. If you concur in
the recommended action, the resolution will then be routinely circulated
among the departments at least 20 days prior to the next National Convention by the National Adjutant, in accordance with the requirements of our
Constitution. At the National Convention, the resolution would be referred
to the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments and reported out
by that committee with a recommendation to approve or to reject. A twothirds vote of the delegates to the National Convention will be required to
adopt the resolution, since it includes an amendment to the National Constitution.
If adopted by the National Convention, our National Legislative Commission will then be instructed to petition Congress to amend our Federal Charter in accordance with the resolution. Action by the Congress could be a matter of days or of months, and I will not attempt to predict when it would
be possible for the first Viet Nam veteran to join The American Legion.
If and when Congress acts and the President signs a bill amending our charter, our National Constitution will automatically be amended in accordance
with our revised Charter, and on that day any person who has honorably
terminated a period of service in the United States Armed Forces since August 5, 1964, may be accepted for membership by any American Legion Post.
This report has been given advance distribution to the members of the Executive Committee and to the Departments. It is our hope that many Departments at their conventions this summer will adopt the resolution that we are
recommending in the form that it appears here.
I would like to also acknowledge that Resolution 1214, 1215 and 1216
from the Department of New Jersey Executive Committee have been administratively disposed of through the adoption and recommendation by your
Special Committee of the resolution which will be offered at the conclusion
of this report.
Also Resolution Register No. 1152 from the District of Columbia Executive Committee. Resolution No. 1188, Department of Pennsylvania Executive
Committee, no action was taken on these by your Special Committee inasmuch as only informational copies were referred to us, and they have been
referred to the Internal Affairs Commission.
132
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Appreciation
On behalf of the entire committee, we express our deep appreciation to
National Commander L. Eldon James for his support and guidance and for
the continuing interest which he has shown in our problems. We have been
afforded every help by National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore, and have relied
heavily on the staff of the Membership and Post Activities Section in the
development of the essential background information and statistical data,
and particularly upon its director, C. W. (Pat) Geile. We are grateful for
this assistance. We also wish to thank the National Judge Advocate, Bertram Davis, for his help in drafting the resolution that we present to you
and for his assistance on other technical matters arising from our assignment. We have his assurance that the resolution at the close of this report
is in proper form for action by you and for referral to the National Convention.
As chairman, I also wish to express my personal appreciation to each
member of the committee: Ralph A. Watkins (Arizona), David Weichman
(Iowa), Henry H. Dudley (Nebraska), Joseph S. Deutschle (Ohio), Edward
T. Hoak (Pennsylvania), Lem W. Houston (Virginia), and Earl D. Franklin,
Jr. (Colorado) (ex-officio member). As I indicated at the opening, we have
had three meetings. Every member has attended every meeting. Every member has participated fully in discussions and deliberations, and every decision
was a unanimous decision. It has been a cherished privilege to have served
as the chairman of such a group.
Proposed Resolution
Following is the resolution that is recommended for your adoption:
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, The military forces of the United States are and have been
engaged in armed conflict in defense of freedom in Viet Nam, which conflict
has cost the lives of Americans and has involved an increasing number of
military units; and
WHEREAS, On August 5, 1964, at the direction of the President, United
States Military Forces engaged in the first retaliatory military action to
preserve the right of democracy in South Viet Nam through the attack in
the Gulf of Tonkin; and
WHEREAS, In accordance with the history, tradition, and purposes of
The American Legion, it is proper that the privilege of membership in The
American Legion should be extended to military personnel serving during
the current period of hostilities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to further
amend Section 3 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The American
Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September 16, 1919,
(c. 59, Sec. 3, 41, Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 1, 56 Stat. 1012, as
amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 1, 69 Stat. 379; Title 36, U.S.C.A., Sec.
43, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 43, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part), to
read when amended as follows:
“Section 3.
“That the purpose of this corporation shall be: To uphold and defend
the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace and
good will among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of
the earth; to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World Wars
and the other Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to cement
the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the efforts
of its members to mutual helpfulness and service to their country,”
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
133
and be it further
RESOLVED, That the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The
American Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September
16, 1919, (c. 59, Sec. 5, 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 2, 56 Stat.
1012; July 9, 1946, c. 546, 60 Stat. 524; Dec. 28, 1950, c. 1177, 64 Stat. 1122,
as amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 2, 69 Stat. 380, Title 36 U.S.C.A.,
Sec. 45, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 45, 1965, Cumulative Annual Pocket
Part), to read when amended as follows:
“Section 5.
“That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has
served in the naval or military services of the United States at some
time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July
27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of entry therein,
served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities: Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any
of the aforesaid terminal dates,”
and be it further
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts
the above amendments, and the President of the United States shall have
approved the same and they become law, then the National Constitution
of The American Legion shall be deemed amended in conformance therewith,
but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions in the Constitution
contained, all as provided for under Article XVIII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, Section 2, of the aforesaid National Constitution of The American Legion, shall read as follows:
“Article IV
Eligibility
“Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in The American
Legion who was a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast
Guard, or Air Force of the United States and assigned to active duty at
some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to
July 27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of his entry therein,
served on active duty in the armed forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of said periods; provided,
however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any of said
periods; provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to membership who, being in such service during any of said periods, refused on
conscientious, political or other grounds to subject himself to military discipline or unqualified service.”
“Article XIII
Auxiliaries
“Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited
to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of all men
and women who were in the Armed Forces of the United States during
any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; De-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
134
cember 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27, 1953;
\ugust 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
Government of United States, all dates inclusive, or who being citizens
of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served on active
duty in the Armed Forces of any of the Governments associated v/ith the
United States during any of said periods, and died in line of duty or
after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right
are eligible for membership in The American Legion,”
and be it
FINALLY RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution proposing amendments to the National Constitution of The American Legion, be forwarded to
the National Adjutant of The American Legion with a request that he cause
it to be circulated to the several departments and members of the National
Executive Committee of The American Legion by mailing the same to them at
least twenty (20) days prior to the convening of the next National Convention, all as provided for under Article XVI of the National Constitution of
The American Legion.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, I would like to address an
inquiry to Past National Commander Wagner.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Could we get a motion to receive
and file?
. . . Motion was so made by Mr. Donaldson, District of Columbia.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We have gotten the motion from
at least half of the Committee.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Carey, Michigan.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: And at least half of the Committee have seconded it.
MR. DRAGO, New York: First of all, I wish to state that I admire
and am in favor of the admission of the Vietnamese veterans to the ranks
of The American Legion. There is only one question that worries me, I
know that legal ability of Mr. Wagner will certainly ease my mind when I
get through with a few preliminary statements which honestly worries me, because I was on the original Membership Committee.
There is no question that this Committee was formed for the purpose of
adopting a proper resolution for the admittance of veterans now engaged in
the Viet Nam War regardless of place.
My inquiry has to do with the termination of the eligibility clause as it
will be amended.
Now it says that the termination of hostilities will be fixed by Congressional action as regards Viet Nam. There would be no problem. But in
reading Section 3 on page four, it would appear to me that perhaps this
Committee is going a little further than the original intent of the resolution and of all the Committees that followed your instructions to this Committee, because they seem to feel as follows, and I have to read this addendum, because this is what worries me, “This period of eligibility will terminate when the United States government determines that hostilities have
ceased.”
I assume we mean in Viet Nam. Obviously if at the time hostilities
cease in Viet Nam there are comparable hostilities involving the United
States forces in another part of the world which we prayerfully hope will
not be the case then the general period of hostilities would not have ended,
and eligibility would have remained open.
Now in World War I and II, the word “War” was used. In the Korean
Conflict the word “Conflict” was used. “State of Emergency” was used, and
then it opened up now to the word “Hostilities.”
I would construe the word “Hostilities” to mean skirmishes and other words
described in this fine report, guerrilla warfare, terrorism and so forth.
Let’s assume that there is a cessation in Viet Nam hostilities in 1967.
Would there be any more need of another resolution or amendment under
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
135
this resolution, or would we keep on admitting the veterans by reason of, for
example some hostilities in Lebanon, or in East Germany, or in Santo Domingo or Cuba?
I thought perhaps the words in the resolution after the words “termination of hostilities”—“in Viet Nam” might clear the situation, because I don’t
think it should remain open forever, and it might be possible under those
circumstances, if they do want the eligibility clause reopened again, we can
do it with the same formula. But something, some legal technician might say,
“Well, there is a hostility in Lebanon, we have a situation and a motion, and
in we come. Why don’t we use the words “in Viet Nam” in that part
of the resolution resolve, Section 5 where it says “ ... no person shall be a
member of The American Legion except from these dates” and I would like the
date “August 5, 1964 to the date of cessation of hostilities” and put in there,
“In Viet Nam as determined by the Government of the United States.” I
would like to do this instead of leaving it open as you say, there might be
five or six other hostilities or skirmishes, and we might be bound under these
circumstances to admit these others.
Mr. Wagner, is that the intent of this report, or are we limiting it exclusively to the men who are serving in Viet Nam?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: We are not limiting it exclusively to the men serving in Viet Nam. That was discussed by your Committee
and deliberated at quite great length. And the handicap under which you7’
Committee operated at this time was the inability to see into the future.
I think also that at least to my mind, the connotation of hostilities is
equally strong as the term conflict, which was used at the time that the Korean War veterans were made eligible before it was known what the termination would be. And this phraseology is exactly the same phraseology that
was used at the time eligibility was opened to the Korean War veterans—
the cessation of hostilities, not hostilities in Korea, but to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States.
I think another thing which even adds greater meaning and import to
what your Committee has in mind and what this resolution intends, if you
will refer to the resolution which is Resolution 23 in the digest, if my
memory serves me correct, the first resolving portion which amends Section
3 states, “incidents of the two World Wars and the other Great Hostilities.”
These are the type of hostilities that your Committee is referring to.
I can assure you this Special Committee, that at such time as the. hostilities have been terminated in Viet Nam, if there are no similar hostilities
in any other part of the world, which we would certainly hope there will not
be, and I am sure that the Committee would go along with putting it to the
date of Cessation of hostilities in Viet Nam, but we have been guided here
by exactly the same phraseology as when our eligibility was opened to World
War II veterans, and also to the Korean War veterans.
MR. DRAGO: Let me ask you this, if hostilities in Korea have not
terminated, then under your phraseology, why wouldn’t the Viet Nam be admitted under that amendment, the same language was being used? In other
words, as you said before, if hostilities are continual in one part of the world,
hostilities begin in another, why do we keep open the doors to the Viet Nam
without the need of a constitutional amendment?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
Let me ask you this, Committeeman Drago, I don’t recall when World War II was terminated in Europe, and I was serving in Japan, and because I was in Japan and somebody
else was serving in Europe, that those that were serving in Europe were
eligible for The American Legion any earlier than I was in the Pacific, if
my memory serves me correct.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: May I indulge for a moment to direct a query
to Chairman Wagner? Having been somewhat responsible for the introduction
and promulgation of the original Charter of The American Legion in August
1919, I was thoroughly in accord with the inquiry made by the Committeeman
from New York, in fact, he anticipated the inquiry I was going to make, and
stated it more concisely than I am able to do, so I concur, Mr. Drago, in
136
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
the suggestion you are making in your inquiry. But I would like to address
this question to you, Ad. This proposal will go before the House Committee
on the Judiciary as an opener, because that is where we introduced the
original Charter of The American Legion in 1919. There are some very
active birds on that Committee, not only the Chairman Mr. Celler, but it
will probably be composed of a number of veterans, members of Congress
who are probably members of The American Legion or other veteran organizations.
I can very well foresee that they will raise the very point that Committeeman Drago has raised here. I mean, we should anticipate it and expect it.
Therefore, when it comes to deciding on the date for the cessation of hostilities, I think some of them are going to make the suggestion that Committeeman Drago made, and others will also raise the point as to whether
the date, when the cessation of hostilities will arise. We pray to heaven it will
be somewhat in the near future. They will say, we will have to come back
again, and with a further amendment to your Charter. Did you anticipate
that?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: This was true, I understand, Mr.
Miller, in World War II, and also in Korea, that again, and I don’t desire to
appear disrespectful or facetious, but I ask this question, was this question
raised by the Judiciary Committee when this same language was used at the
same time our eligibility was opened to World War II and Korean veterans?
This was the identical language that was used at that time.
MR. MILLER: Well, I concur in what Committeeman Drago said. I do
not know whether he is going to make it the subject of a motion or not, but
I think, without being repetitious—
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: It will be required, and it will
be the responsibility of a future Convention and of tbe National Executive
Committee probably prior to that time to petition the Congress to set a terminal date.
MR. MILLER: Well, in other words, you expect the Constitution and
By-Laws Committee of the National Convention to probably take cognizance
of the question that has been raised here today?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Pardon?
MR. MILLER: You expect the Committee on Constitution of the National
Convention to probably anticipate some of those suggestions or inquiries
that are made here today?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Well, maybe I didn’t make myself clear, Committeeman Miller. When I referred to future Conventions, I
was referring to a Convention probably far more distant than the one in Washington, D. C., the Convention that will be meeting at the time that these
hostilities have ceased, and it will be necessary for The American Legion to
take the appropriate action to petition Congress to put the terminal date as
we did in Korea and World War II.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, since we
are discussing the matter of the Special Committee’s report, I should like to
address myself to that and perhaps at the same time ask a parliamentary
inquiry of the Judge Advocate if I am in procedural order.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You may proceed.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, as I listened to the discussion with respect to this report, and perhaps debate the
discussion that may come with respect to the resolution itself, I am mindful
of the fact that the object of this Special Committee as I read it on page
two is to present a resolution that would be in proper form for consideration
by the National Convention.
I also read this report, and the attitude of the Committee as not indicating that those who vote for this resolution, assuming it to be a majority, necessarily concur in the specific dates mentioned, because on page two, the observation is made by the Committee, that those that may differ on dates or
some portion of it submit and propose their own resolutions through their
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
137
Department Conventions, and those in turn would then come before the
Constitutional Amendments Committee at the Convention.
As I read this thing, it would be tended to make certain that a resolution
in the proper procedural form covering all of the language necessary to accomplish the amendment would be made, so my suggestion is that if there are
those that disagree with certain language of this resolution, they have ample opportunity to present a resolution to their Department Convention, and
those in turn will be submitted all at the same time to the Constitution
Amendments Committee, which brings me to my parliamentary inquiry, Mr.
Judge Advocate. I don’t know if this is the proper time, because the resolution
has not been offered. But if this resolution is now adopted or passed, it is
not adopted, it is only passed with a recommendation, that would not mean
at the National Convention, would it, the Constitutional Amendments and
By-Laws Committee could not change dates if a majority saw fit without having it circularized throughout the rest of the Departments?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is correct.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: So the sole purpose of it is
to make certain that a proper resolution in proper form is read and then
the Constitutional Amendments Committee will take such action as those of
the Committee will see fit.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: They make the recommendation to the National Convention, the recommendation is made from the Constitution Convention Committee.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Mr. Commander, a point of
information, many of us didn’t understand what the reply of the Judge Advocate was.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is why we want the inquiry
made again, and the answer specific.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Should I restate the inquiry?
Assuming that the resolution attached to this report is passed as it is
now written, it will then be forwarded on to the National Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: It would undoubtedly procedurally be assigned to consideration by the Constitutional Amendments Committee of the National Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: My inquiry in connection
with the resolution then would be this, if a majority of the members of the
Constitution Amendments Committee saw fit to change dates and eligibility
requirements or other language of the resolution, that body would have the
power to make such changes and if adopted by the majority of that Committee, pass that recommendation on to the floor without further circularizing it to the Departments or deferring it to another Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: No, on the first issue of
changing dates, they would have that authority, but you have to be more
specific with respect to the other changes you are talking about and language, for this reason, that under the National Constitution of The American
Legion, a constitutional amendment may be amended by a Convention Committee provided that the amendment they propose does not increase the constitutional amendment proffered to them.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: And assuming that it is
not increased, they have quite a bit of power?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: That answers my inquiry.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There may be other constitutional
amendments proposed that come up from a state properly circulated 20 days
before the Convention that might have a larger enlarged eligibility, those
could be considered, sir.
138
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: That is provided on page
two of the report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Yes, sir, that is right.
MR MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander, after consulting my associate
Committeeman Drago, I do not want to be appearing running counter to the
suggestions of our distinguished Past National Commander Dan Foley or the
Judge Advocate, but the purpose of bringing this resolution here today was
to dress it up in as strong a position as possible to be submitted to the National Convention Committee.
I am unwilling in view of the discussion taken here today to trust that
Committee in having the information that we have had here today, and I
firmly believe, and Committeeman Drago. agrees with me, that wherever the
word “hostilities” appears in the Resolution No. 23, that we should add the
words “in Viet Nam” and I make such a motion.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Drago, New York.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Are you going to amend this
report? Let’s get the parliamentary situation straight, gentlemen.
We are now having a general discussion with the Chairman on his report We haven’t even had a motion to receive and file the report, and if we
receive and file the report, we have not adopted or approved any language
anywhere in here. We then get to that issue on the resolution, and may I
suggest that all of this comment at this time is background and enlightening
information that will eventually pin-point our specific argument when we get
to action on the resolution.
MR. MILLER: All right. I will make that motion when the resolution
is formally presented to us.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: I move it be received and
filed.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Lovell, Arkansas.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded to receive and file. Is there any discussion?
MR GRATTON, Idaho: Thank you, Mr. Commander, I would like to address a question to the Chairman, if I may. Commander Wagner, you state
in your report, this is the point of issue here with Committeemen Drago and
Miller that the date of cessation of hostilities is determined by the Government of the United States, the date which you believe will determine the
eligibility for the Viet Nam veteran. This is a real important issue m practically every Department in this great organization of ours. Dates don t coincide with the thinking of my own Department, and I ask you this question,
if you are going to let the termination be decided by the Government ot
the United States, was the date of August 5th, 1964 determined by the Government of the United States as to the active participation in the Viet Nam
War, or how did you set upon that date?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
The beginning date was not
set by the Government of the United States. This was a date determined by
your Special Committee as related in the report, based upon the scope and
the nature of services performed by the United States troops in Viet Nam.
MR. GRATTON: In other words, I can tell the members of my Department and others who discuss this, that this was our beginning date and
it had nothing to do with the Government of the United States or the Department of Defense or anything else?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: That is correct. And also in answer to the further part of your question, I believe it was your question, it
would be my conception, at least, that the terminal date would likewise be
determined by future action of The American Legion, as I indicated in the
report, and the matter of petitioning Congress, and this would be the action
of the United States Government setting the terminal date.
MR. GRATTON: What point, Mr. Chairman? I don’t believe you were
in the room yesterday when we were in executive session, the National Execu-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
139
tive Committee was discussing the nominations for the Distinguished Service
Award to be granted by this organization, and there were only Committeemen present. I believe if you were in the room, I don’t know whether you
were or not—
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: I was not, no.
MR. GRATTON: You would have been receptive, as I was, when the
National Commander read the heroics of the gentleman who was nominated
for the Distinguished Service Award. He went into great detail, I am sure
in the room everybody felt deep emotions and distress at this. And I am calling
it to your attention, that at the conclusion of this, and Commander James
was reading from the citation which enabled this man to receive the Congressional Medal of Honor, those acts of heroism took place on July 6, 1964,
and the accompanying citation of the remarks were read by Commander
James, and that certainly would indicate that there was a major hostility
then in process in Viet Nam. This gentleman survived his wounds, and his
tenure of service continued, and he is eligible, possibly eligible to join this
organization. He happens to be a Korean War veteran, and of course his
particular eligibility is not in question.
I am very pleased that Commander Foley said that the dates are, and
I believe you concur, Mr. Judge Advocate, that the dates can be changed,
but the language in this constitutional amendment of this resolution should
not be changed when we go home to present this in our respective Departments.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: May I just, Ad, may I make a
comment, two comments, first of all, any Department can come in with the
resolutions they desire. It doesn’t have to follow this language. It is merely
being suggested by this Committee that this proposed amendment is in proper
form so that it can get over all technical, legal and parliamentary hurdles
at a Convention, so that the 2,900 plus delegates in Washington can act
on the merits, and that if there is a Department that wishes to have a different content as to the criteria of eligibility, whether it be date or otherwise, they may come in with that. But it is suggested that it would be well
in other words that they avoid parliamentary or legal loopholes and problems, that they follow this general arrangement.
Now if you wanted to put in “Korean hostilities,” “Viet Nam hostilities,”
or whatever along that line, you will be able to do so.
Now also, you will be able to change the date. I would assume that from
the ruling that the Judge Advocate made that if we at the Convention in a
Constitutional Amendments Committee change the resolution from just hostilities to some more specific and more delimiting hostilities, this is not enlarging the resolution, and would be permitted, is that correct?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is correct.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: But this does not keep any Department from coming in with any resolution they want, provided they get
it in time to be circulated 20 days before the Convention.
Now on the other point, Ad, I would like to add an annotation about
whether the Government set the beginning date that we have here. I would
suggest that it didn’t, in terms of writing out a date dictating to us, but in
terms of the Government’s action, the action of the Government in taking on
combat, moving a combat operation, did determine that. That is the difference
in the sense that we think of the Government determining the date.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Mr. Commander, I swore
I wasn’t going to say anything at this Executive Session.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We would rather swear if you didn’t,
Past National Commander.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: I want to commend you
for your fine foresight in appointing an able Committee to do the thing that
you have indicated here, because my experience has been that it is practically
impossible for a Department to come in with a constitutional amendment on
any major subject that conforms to all the technicalities.
140
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
They have done a great job.
Now you know as well as I know, the two things that are bothering Bill
and Drago and Gratton, one of them wants to extend the date, which I don’t
think can be done, that is why I asked for a further explanation about it,
you can’t move it up, if Ad’s Committee says ’64, you can’t move that up to
extend it, can you?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Not with this particular proposed
amendment, but if another state came in with one it could broaden it.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Well, young man, you are
dreaming when you think any Department is going to come in with one,
because they haven’t got time, they don’t know how to do it, and it will
finally finish up by throwing it out.
Now I think that we ought to have discussion here, we ought to have
discussion on whether or not the first date is too restrictive or whether the
last date is too wide open as to its termination.
Personally, I think that the thing that should be done is to adopt this
resolution as it stands now, and then the Department Executive Committee
will then be on notice as you have so ably stated so many, many times,
the only thing is, they don’t want to take the responsibility of going back to
their Department and bringing in a legal constitutional amendment.
You have one here. It may not conform to all the points, but I think
that what should be done is that we should refer this to the Convention with
our approval, and then let all these people who are on notice, if they don’t
agree with the thinking of this able Committee, and this is a real good one.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Mr. Past National Commander,
let me make an observation, because we are rapidly getting into a point of debating a resolution that is not before us.
I would like to say that I neither express the hope nor the desire that
a Department would come in with another resolution, but the possibility is
that they could.
Now may I suggest for orderliness, gentlemen, we are still debating the
report, we don’t want to have to debate the report and come back with the
same debate on the resolution.
Would you consider it appropriate to receive and file?
It has been moved and seconded that the report be received and filed.
All in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes have it
and the report has been received and filed.
Gentlemen, before anyone takes the floor at the moment, we do not have
any resolution on the floor. In order to get it, we have to recognize the
Chairman of the Subcommittee on Resolutions and at this point, let me say
this, so many of us never give any consideration or thought to the work of
the Subcommittee on Resolutions, and the trying time that the Chairman has
particularly with a fellow in, with spurs in the Chair, who rides me all the
time, and I want you to know what this fellow is doing. We have a historic
moment coming up and I think he may want to express himself on something
not quite germane to the resolution, and he has the permission of the Chair
to do so.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Thank you very much, Mr.
Commander, for those very kind remarks.
Resolution No. 23 has been distributed and is on your desk. You have
in reading and hearing Mr. Wagner’s report, have practically the same resolution as has already been read before this group.
However, that is a matter of three pages, and in the interest of time, I
think each man can individually read the resolution, and it is couched in
Proceedings of Thursday,, May 51 1966
141
judicial language, I think, which is in keeping with the constitutional amendments, it has to be that way.
Now, Mr. Commander and members of the Executive Committee, I have
been on this Committee, and I am now in my 13th year.
Prior to my coming on the Committee, I met and became very well acquainted with the gentleman who today is serving his last meeting at the
May meeting. He is completing 20 years of service on this Committee. He has
served on the Subcommittee on Resolutions and it has been my pleasure to
serve under him and to some extent have been trained by him.
He is a very close personal friend which has been developed and which
has been nurtured by our friendship in The American Legion There is one
doggone thing about it, he can sure fish, and I have been fishing with him
a number of times, and there is nothing any closer than a comradeship that
you gain while you are fishing with a buddy.
I am asking the permission, Mr. Commander, that Mr. Wilson be given
the privilege of, let us say considering this resolution as read by Mr. Wilson, that he come to the front and move the approval of the adoption of the
resolution in behalf of the Subcommittee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Past Chairman of the Resolutions Subcommittee to this Committee is recognized for that purpose.
. . . Mr. Wilson, Florida, presented the following resolution:
“Amendments to Sections 3 and 5 of the Federal Act Incorporating
The American Legion, and to Article IV, Section 1, and to Article
XIII Section 2 of the National Constitution of The American Legion,
to extend Eligibility for Membership in The American Legion to those
persons who served in the Armed Forces from on or after August 5, 19b
Resolution No. 23 (Submitted by: Special Membership Eligibility Committee-National Constitution and By-Laws Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, The military forces of the United States are and have been
engaged in armed conflict in defense of freedom in Viet Nam, which conflict
has cost the lives of Americans and has involved an increasing number of military units; and
,
WHEREAS On August 5, 1964, at the direction of the President, United
States Military Forces engaged in the first retaliatory military action to
preserve the right of democracy in South Viet Nam through the attack m
the Gulf of Tonkin; and
WHEREAS, In accordance with the history, tradition, and purposes of
The American Legion, it is proper that the privilege of membership m lhe
American Legion should be extended to military personnel serving during the
current period of hostilities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized
and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to further amend
Section 3 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The American Legion
(Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September 16 1919, (c. 59,
Sec 3 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 1, 56 Stat. 1012, as amended
July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 1, 69 Stat. 379; Title 36 U.S.C.A Sec. 43, and
Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 43, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part), to read
when amended as follows:
“Section 3.
“That the purpose of this corporation shall be: To uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace
and good will among the peoples of the United States and all the nations
of the earth; to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World
Wars and the other Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to cement the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the
efforts of its members to mutual helpfulness and service to their country,
and be it further
142
Proceedings
of
Thursday, May
5t 1966
RESOLVED, That the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The
American Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September
16, 1919 (c. 69, Sec. 5, 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 2, 56 Stat. 1012;
July 9, 1946, c. 546, 60 Stat. 524; Dec. 28, 1950, c. 1177, 64 Stat. 1122, as
amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 2, 69 Stat. 380, Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec.
45, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 45, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part),
to read when amended as follows:
“Section 5.
“That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has
served in the naval or military services of the United States at some
time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July
27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of entry therein,
served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities: Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any
of the aforesaid terminal dates,”
and be it further
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts
the above amendments, and the President of the United States shall have
approved the same and they become law, then the National Constitution of
The American Legion shall be deemed amended in conformance therewith,
but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions in the Constitution
contained, all as provided for under Article XVIII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, section 2, of the aforesaid National Constitution of The American Legion, shall read as follows:
“Article IV
Eligibility
“Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in The American Legion who was a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast
Guard, or Air Force of the United States and assigned to active duty at
some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950,
to July 27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities
as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive,
or who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of his entry
therein, served on active duty in the armed forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of said periods; provided, however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any
of said periods; provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to
membership who, being in such service during any of said periods, refused on conscientious, political or other grounds to subject himself to
military discipline or unqualified service.”
“Article XIII
Auxiliaries
“Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of members of The
American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of
all men and women who were in the Armed Forces of the United States
during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27 1953August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
143
the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being
citizens of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served
on active duty in the Armed Forces of any of the Governments associated
with the United States, during any of said periods, and died in line of duty
or after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right
are eligible for membership in The American Legion,”
and be it
FINALLY RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution proposing amendments to the National Constitution of The American Legion, be forwarded to
the National Adjutant of The American Legion with a request that he cause
it to be circulated to the several departments and members of the National
Executive Committee of The American Legion by mailing the same to them at
least twenty (20) days prior to the convening of the next National Convention, all as provided for under Article XVI of the National Constitution
of The American Legion.
MR. WILSON: As the Chairman has said to you, Resolution 23 has
the approval of the Committee, and I so move you, sir, that your approval
be given.
... The motion was seconded by Mr. Watkins, Arizona.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The floor is now open for discussion on the resolution.
The Dean of this organization is now recognized, Committeeman Miller.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander and members of the Committee I thoroughly echo the statements of our National Commander a moment ago for so calling our attention to the fact that we did not know it
and appreciate that this Commission has worked under Ad Wagner, has
worked long and hard, and I have no desire whatsoever to in any way mess
up their splendid work. But I would like to call your attention again to the
fact that this is brought before us today, the National Executive Committee,
to dress it up in the strongest terms possible so that when it is sent into
the Constitutional Committee of the National Convention, it will reflect our
mature ideas on the subject.
As I told you a while ago when Committeeman Drago so properly and
adequately presented this matter to you, I did not want to be repetitious
so I will not renew any of the arguments you already heard then. But I
personally and firmly believe that we should send this on to the various Departments dressed up as strongly as possible, because I can see if this gets
into a hassle before the Constitution and By-Laws Committee with 50 or
60 more delegates, they might not be able to give it the mature consideration
that we have been permitted to give it here today m view of the splendid
report made by Chairman Wagner and his Committee. Therefore, I am
to follow the suggestion of Committeeman Drago and on page 14 o± the
Resolution No. 23, Section 5, at the bottom of the page, where the word
“hostilities” appears, on page 15, “Article IV, Eligibility,,f> where the word
“hostilities” appears and Article XIII entitled Auxiliaries, Section 2, where
the word “hostilities” appears, just to insert the words m Viet Nam.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let’s be sure, Committeeman Miller, that we have the full text of your amendment.
Let’s start with the first resolve on page 14 in the middle of the page,
does your amendment offer any change in the language to Section 3 under
that resolve?
MR. MILLER: No.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, let’s take the second
resolve in Section 5, does your amendment offer any change in the language
of that Section 5?
MR. MILLER: Yes, sir, the words “in Viet Nam.” After the word
“hostilities.”
.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What line is that on, sir?
144
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, I960
MR. MILLER: Line five.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right now, we will take the
first resolve on page 15. There is a Section 1 and a Section 2. Is Section 1
involved?
MR. MILLER: No, Article IV “Eligibility.” and it is down there, it is
line six after the word “hostilities.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: “In Viet Nam.” All right, sir. I
ask the question then under Article XIII, Section 2, the same language would
be—
MR. MILLER: On the seventh line the word “hostilities” then add the
words “in Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are there any other proposed
changes?
MR. MILLER: No, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: So three changes.
As I understand your amendment now, your amendment is to offer the
insertion of the words “in Viet Nam” in the following places: the resolve
at the bottom of page 14 under Section 5, line six; on page 15 under Article
IV, Eligibility, Section 1, the words will be added in the sixth line after the
word “hostilities,” and under Article XIII “Auxiliaries,” Section 2, the words
to be added after “hostilities” in the seventh line. Those three places. Now
are we all clear on your amendment?
Is that it?
MR. MILLER: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: This is an amendment which has
been seconded by Committeeman Drago.
Is there any discussion?
Mr. Chairman, would you like to address yourself to the amendment?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
Thank you, Mr. Commander.
Gentlemen, with regard to this amendment, I would only ask that you consider this, because at the round table discussions in Washington this question
was asked. Because of the wording in our report and the use of the words
“South Viet Nam” or “Viet Nam” it was the intent of our report and the intent of the resolution to restrict eligibility to those serving in Viet Nam
only.
It was the determination of your Special Committee and those at that
round table discussion were so advised, that your Special Committee had no
such intent, because historically in The American Legion our membership
eligibility has been based upon the time of service and not where we served.
This I feel is important to remember. I think you are getting dangerously
close by adding the words “in Viet Nam.” After the word “hostilities” in
Section 5 the first resolve, Section 1 of the second resolve and in Section 2
of the second resolve. I think you are getting dangerously close to this being
interpreted that we mean people who served in our Armed Forces from August 5, 1964 to the date of cessation of hostilities in Viet Nam only, thereby
departing drastically from the historic premise of membership in The American Legion.
Another thing I would like to point out is that I don’t believe that this
amendment would accomplish what I interpret the desire of Committeeman
Drago and Committeeman Miller to accomplish, and that is that we in The
American Legion petition Congress to set a terminal date.
Even with the inclusion of this amendment, the Judge Advocate can correct me if I am wrong, I still feel that it will be necessary for The American
Legion to petition Congress to set a terminal date.
This is still going to have to be done by this Executive Committee for
the resolution or a proposed amendment to the National Convention by a National Convention to the Congress of the United States.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
145
The language that is contained in the resolution presently will require
the same action of this Executive Committee and of a subsequent National
Convention.
So I think there are two dangers, one danger of having this resolution
construed as limiting our eligibility to membership of those who served in
the Armed Forces of Viet Nam only,
Secondly, I don’t think you accomplish anything that isn’t going to have
to be done by this Committee, and by subsequent Conventions anyway to ask
Congress to set a terminal date.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, Mr. Wagner and members of
the Executive Committee, I know that Ad Wagner is not trying to divert this
issue, but probably misunderstood me.
I have been a known advocate that any man that is serving in the Armed
Forces of the United States during a time of emergency or conflict or war
is eligible to join The American Legion. This language is simple. I am trying to see to it that this resolution will pass at our Convention with a
minimum amount of trouble. And I don’t want hostilities to come into this
picture.
I am only interested in the war in Viet Nam at this time. Now if there
should come a time when there are other hostilities, and we think that there
should be admission to veterans in that war, let us go through this procedure
again.
Now this language is clear. I am trying to be specific, and I don t care
what that Committee said. This is a resolution before the National Executive
Committee, and I cannot in conscience approve a resolution which will leave
this open from now until 2000, 35 years from now. The intent here is
admit every veteran who served in the Armed Forces during the period ot
hostilities in the Viet Nam War.
Now that makes it specific, and that is all I ask. If I went back to New
York and said, well, there may be other hostilities in the Dominican Republic,
or Guatemala, let them go through this procedure again as we did this time.
I only want to be clear, that we are interested right now in the Soldiers,
Sailors and Marines and Air Force men, no matter where they serve, who
will be eligible, providing they come in after the date which will be fixed,
and I don’t care when Congress fixes it. But it must pertain to Viet Nam
and nothing else.
Now I don’t want this Committee to leave it open so that they can come
in later and say, well, there was a hostility, there was a confrontation, and
there was a skirmish, and under this resolution, you make a motion to admit
them.
I want it simple and specific. I am not taking away any iota of the intent of this resolution.
I simply want the words “of Viet Nam” so there will be no discussion later
that we opened the door to peacetime, or discourage veterans who are confrontation veterans. I want the words “termination of hostilities, where,
concerning Viet Nam. There is no limitation as to the question of place, Mr.
Wagner The time is the essence, wherever you serve, in the United States,
Europe, Asia, they will be eligible, but I think we ought to close it simply
by inserting these words, and it will be specific. It will be clear, and I think
we will have no trouble at the Convention, because I feel, you know, that
there were 31 resolutions passed last time by different Departments, and
every one of them was defective. We don’t know how to do this.
Now we have this brain work now, why not limit it to what the Convention
wanted and what the Commander himself stated in his orders that we confine ourselves to the Viet Nam War and no other?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Now just a moment. The Chair
is trying strictly not to comment in a way that would show partiality. So
I will make my comment by asking you a question, Lou.
MR. DRAGO: Yes, sir.
146
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I gather it is your intent to try
to tighten up the language to limit to a period identified with the struggle
over the problem in Viet Nam?
MR. DRAGO: That is right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I tried to frame my question without using the word “in” but I found it very difficult. Now we use the word
“in” with respect to any geographical location, aren’t you then bringing
geography in it and although you are trying to simplify it, do you not complicate it?
MR. DRAGO: You are right—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Have we used the word “in” with
respect to any other eligibility criteria during World War I, during World
War II, in Korea? Did we use “in Korean hostilities”? Now, in respect to
Viet Nam, they are not limited to “in” Viet Nam, so I suggest that you
may be on target with what your goal is, it may be a little fuzzy, and will
you review it a little as we debate this?
MR. DRAGO: Right, and that is the way I would like the interpretation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Think about it before you come up
with another one that won’t have another very, very little flaw in it.
MR. DRAGO: It would be my right as a member of the National Executive Committee, regardless of your statement.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: It certainly would.
MR. DREW, Pennsylvania: Mr. Commander, as a freshman member of
the NEC, I feel I should not be on my feet, but I am interested in this
eligibility resolution.
I would like to ask the Judge Advocate if he can read off to us the ultimate
result of the Korean opening of our Charter, what was the closing phrase
as to hostilities? Are we not using that same phraseology in this resolution?
If we are using the same phraseology in this resolution, I don’t believe that
we have any problems, or that they had any problems when they closed out
the Korean conflict as it affects the American Legionnaires.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will the Judge Advocate address
yourself to that question?
. . .National Vice Commander Choppin in the Chair.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: I am reading to you Title
36 of the United States Codes Annotated 1965 Cumulative Pocket Edition,
Section 43 of the Code which corresponds to Section 3 of your Code. I quote:
“The purpose of this corporation shall be to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of American; to promote peace and good will
among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of the earth;
to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World Wars and the other
Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy.” You want me to read any
more?
That pertains in correspondence to Section 3 of the resolution you are
amending.
MR. JANKO, Texas: I would like to ask a question.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Ask a question of who?
MR. JANKO: The Judge Advocate.
In regard to parliamentary procedure on this particular issue, now you
have an amendment to this resolution, if we vote this amendment favorably
will that prohibit any further amendments on this resolution?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Amendments where, in this
body?
MR. JANKO: In this body.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: If this body amends this
resolution and adopts the amendment, if may adopt another amendment. And
in Robert’s Rules of Order you may amend to the second degree.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
147
MR. JANKO: I wish to make another amendment later on, but I don’t
want to confuse the issue with this.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Why do you not, sir, address yourself to this amendment? You can further amend this amendment.
You can go to the second degree, or do you approve of this amendment? You
want the resolution adopted, and then you want to make an amendment?
MR. JANKO: I want to amend the resolution in a different manner.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I wonder if the Judge Advocate,
just to move this along, I think Walter has an amendment that has nothing
to do with the proposed amendment at this time. It has to do with the
dates, doesn’t it, Walter?
MR. JANKO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let’s keep it separate. You will
be given ample opportunity to pose any amendment.
I think yours doesn’t apply to the definition of hostilities?
MR. JANKO: Right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You will be given ample opportunity, I can assure you.
MR. FERN, Kentucky: Mr. Commander, I have a question of the Judge
Advocate, will you continue reading from the Code in Section 5?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That part to correspond with
Section 5?
MR. FERN: Yes, that part which coincides with Section 5 of this resolution.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: I quote from Section 45, Title
36, United States Code Annotated, Cumulative Annual Pocket Part:
“No person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has served
in the naval or military services of the United States at some time during
any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941 to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27, 1953, and all
dates inclusive, or who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of
entry therein, served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities:
Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any of the
aforesaid terminal dates. As amended July 26, 1955, Chapter 386, Section 2,
Statute 69-380.”
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander and members of the Committee,
I ask the unanimous consent to withdraw the amendment I submitted a while
ago with the agreement of my second.
Do I have it?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I will make the inquiry. Does he
have it?
MR. DRAGO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: If it is withdrawn, there is no
amendment on the floor.
MR. MILLER: Following out the suggestion the National Commander
made—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Now wait just a minute.
MR. MILLER: I withdraw that too.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You are going to be ruled out of
order although you were here in 1919.
MR MILLER: And the substitution of the amendment, in substitution
of the amendment I withdrew, I make the following motion, after the word
“hostilities” as it appears on pages 14 to 15 of Resolution 23, add the words
“which date shall apply to the war in Viet Nam. You get it. You got it in
148
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
front of you there. In other words, after the word “hostilities” add the words
“which date shall apply to the war in Viet Nam.”
Do I have a second?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just a minute, what is your amendment?
MR. MILLER: After the word “hostilities” where it appears in Resolution 23 on pages 14 and 15, add these words “which date shall apply to
the war in Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You have changed it from the
other one, you have just added a few other words, Committeeman Miller.
Would you address yourself to the semantics of the difference between this
and what you had before?
MR. MILLER: Well, I think it follows out the suggestion that our National Commander made—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, it does not. You may swear
me under oath and I will testify that it does not.
MR. MILLER: Then I will stand up here barefaced and make it on
my own. In other words, I will state it again, so that there won’t be any
ambiguity, in Resolution 23 on pages 14 and 15 after the word “hostilities”
where it appears, insert the following, “which date shall apply to the war
in Viet Nam.” That is all I am saying to you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to that?
MR. DRAGO, New York: I will second it.
MR. JACKSON, Delaware: Mr. Commander, I believe that every Committeeman in this room has his mind made up as to which way they are
going to vote on the resolution, and so I would like to move the previous question.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just a moment now, Charlie. I
appreciate your wanting to act on this thing, but when I recognized you,
Committeeman Ralph Godwin was on the floor. I don’t think he was on the
floor earlier, plus the fact that Committeeman Janko has already been given
the assurance that he will be given an opportunity to amend the resolution.
I think it unfair and a violation of my trust if I would not recognize him.
So can we permit Committeeman Godwin to address the Committee before we
tender the motion?
MR. JACKSON: I will withdraw my motion.
MR. GODWIN, Mississippi: Isn’t it correct that we are merely saying
that this resolution appears to us to be in proper legal form? We have been
so assured by the Judge Advocate, we are not giving our approval to it,
our own individual Departments, every Department in the Legion may change
it when we go home.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, sir.
MR. GODWIN: We cannot bind our Departments by our vote today.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is correct. But there are two
different things, Ralph, first, this Committee will take action to go before the
National Convention recommended from this Committee by this Committee.
Now of course there can be dissent from this Committee, and no one is bound
if they voted against it, or voted against the way he wanted to go. But
they will see if he votes for this here, he is saying, I am going along with
this, and I support it, but this doesn’t mean that his Department might not
mandate him to do something different at that Convention.
There is an amendment on the floor at this time, gentlemen. We cannot
even entertain your motion, Charlie, and we can’t entertain Walter’s yet until
we dispose of Committeeman Miller’s amendment.
I will ask Ad Wagner to wind up on that before we vote on that. As
Chairman of the Committee, he has that right under the rules.
COMMITTEE GHAIRMAN WAGNER: I was somewhat concerned,about
the possibility of misinterpretation on both amendments proposed previously
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
149
by Committeeman Drago or Committeeman Miller. The use of the words
“in Viet Nam” and the present amendment really concern me. If you add the
words after “hostilities” in Section 5, Section 1 and Section 2, these words,
“which date shall apply as to the war in Viet Nam,” gentlemen, I don’t see
how you can escape the conclusion that you are talking about the servicemen
in Viet Nam only.
I urge you, as strongly as I am capable of doing so, to defeat this amendment, with all due respects to Committeeman Miller.
As I stated in my report, the language used in this in respect to the date
of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States is exactly the same terminology which was used when we opened
our eligibility to the Korean War veterans during the Korean War, and before
we knew the terminal date, and also World War II.
I would only add this, and I add this without having had the opportunity
to confer with the other members of the Committee, very frankly, I see no
danger and no harm in the language of the resolution as it is proposed. But
if you are determined to amend it, to cover the matters which have been
suggested, then I suggest that you use the words after “hostilities” in all
three places, “such as Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I believe we are ready for the
question.
MR. RYER, Rhode Island: Mr. Commander, may I ask, and I hope this
might solve the problem.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right now, remember the Committeeman has closed debate on it, but we will permit you to ask one question, we will put it that way, and then we will get on with the vote.
MR. RYER: The entire hassle apparently has stemmed from the comments on paragraph three of Section 3 of the report preceding the resolution
which says, “This period of eligibility will terminate when the
United States Government ...” and so forth and so on, the present general
period of and eligibility would remain open. The war in Viet Nam is the occasion for a new period of eligibility, but the new period would not close until
the cessation of hostilities and so forth and so on.
I just wonder if the Chairman of the Committee, and I know how hard they
have worked on this, I just wonder if the Chairman _ of the Committee
would delete this paragraph number three or dress it up in such a manner—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I am sorry, you are out of order.
The report has been received and filed.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Chairman—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you addressing the question
to the Chairman based on his remarks?
Chairman Wagner has closed debate on your amendment. Right? You are
directing a question to him?
MR. MILLER: He made a very pertinent suggestion which as the proposer of the amendment and my seconder Mr. Drago are perfectly willing
to accept. I am very happy to see that you meet us halfway when he suggested that it would be agreeable to them.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you now withdrawing your
amendment and suggesting another?
MR. MILLER: I am going to withdraw the amendment made for the
second time with the permission of my second.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There is now no amendment on
the floor to vote on.
MR. MILLER: Here is the motion I am going to make here, wherever
the word “hostilities” appears in Resolution No. 23, pages 14 and 15, insert
after the word “hostilities”—“such as Viet Nam.”
I am following the Chairman’s suggestion.
150
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: “Such as Viet Nam?”
Is there a second to that motion?
... The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Tom.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There is an amendment on the
floor that would amend Section 5 on page 14, Section 1 and Section 2 on
15 to add the words after the word “hostilities”—“such as Viet Nam.”
Is there any discussion on that amendment?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Are we through with debate? I want to
raise a parliamentary question. Are you through with debate?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, no, the Committee Chairman
is going to close the debate, since no one wants to speak.
You want to speak on this matter, Harry?
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I don’t think semantically that is a correct
statement. I am sure the word “in” is missing there. You can’t say “such
as Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much, very good,
you made your point.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Thank you, Mr. Commander, this
will be brief, gentlemen.
I just wanted to clarify one point. I think Committeeman Miller inadvertently quoted me as saying that I suggested this. I did not intend to suggest it. I believe my terminology was that if you are determined to make
an amendment along this line, this would be the way I think it could be
done with the least damage.
I still do not feel that this amendment is necessary. I will remind you
that this is the same terminology used when we opened the eligibility on two
previous occasions and again, I would urge that you defeat this amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you ready for the question?
A parliamentary inquiry by the Committeeman from New Jersey.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander, if we are now ready to
vote, I would like to ask that the vote be taken by a show of hands. There
are far more in this room than there are Executive Committeemen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much.
We now vote on the amendment which would add the words “such as
Viet Nam” in the three places previously indicated behind the word “hostilities.”
All in favor of the amendment who are voting members of the Committee
will signify that you are in favor of the amendment by raising your hand.
Will you make a count, Mr. Judge Advocate?
All opposed raise your hands. The amendment is repealed.
Is there anyone who wishes to be recorded?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Yes, I wish to be recorded as voting in favor
of the amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Anyone else?
All right, gentlemen, we are now on the main Resolution No. 23.
The Chair will recognize the Committeeman from Texas who has a proposal.
MR. JANKO, Texas: First, I would like to direct another question to
the Judge Advocate. Mention was made a few minutes ago about should we
adopt this resolution, send it to the National Convention and the Constitution
and By-Laws would take it up there.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: The Convention’s Committee
on Constitutional Amendments.
MR. JANKO: Then the Departments could substitute other, rather adopt
and present other resolutions pertaining to the opening up of new eligibility
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
151
dates. One was made mention of that if it does not enlarge, what does that
mean, does that mean enlargement of the inclusive dates?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Let me see if I can clarify
your thinking on procedure so that we can answer. Maybe it will obviate
this question. If this body adopts this resolution, it will then be circulated
and go into the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments.
Now, the fact that this body adopts this resolution does not preclude any
Department in The American Legion from adopting a resolution of its own
which is the same, different, many combinations of the resolution which this
body has adopted.
Now the Department resolutions which are adopted will, as this resolution,
be circulated, and they will go into the Committee on Constitutional Amendments of the Convention. It will then be the duty of the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments to decide which resolution it will adopt.
The issue raised earlier as to the enlargement of a constitutional amendment is a statement which involves a statement which is contained in the National Constitution, and while I don’t quote it to you exactly, I will tell you
what I think it means.
If a constitutional amendment is put before the Convention Committee on
Constitutional Amendments, that body may not further amend that constitutional amendment if it will enlarge the constitutional amendment that was
submitted to it. Why? The reason for circulation of the constitutional amendment is so that everybody has notice, consequently if the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments could of its own volition, enlarge constitutional amendments, it has violated the circulation clause notice, see? Does
that answer your question?
MR. JANKO: Very well, thank you, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will you proceed, Walter?
MR. JANKO: Mr. Commander and members of this National Executive
Committee, the Executive Committee of the Department of Texas met April
3rd, 1966 and adopted a resolution identical to the one that is before you
now with the exception, the beginning date begins with the beginning of
hostilities, or the close of them, rather as defined in our Constitution, of
the Korean Conflict.
In other words, we adopted a resolution to open the ranks of the Legion
from the end of the Korean and up to the present date, to the end of present
day’s hostilities, such as the War in Viet Nam and so forth.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you offering an amendment
with this to coincide with your comment, is that the intent?
MR. JANKO: Yes, sir, and this resolution has been forwarded to the
National Adjutant, and I so move you, sir, that we amend the resolution
before us to include “open the ranks of The Legion to the beginning date
of June 25th, 1950.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the motion?
The motion to amend is to substitute “June 5th, 1950” wherever the date
“August 5,1964” appears in the resolution. Is that it, simply stated?
MR. JANKO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the proposed
amendment?
There being no second, the amendment dies for lack of it.
We are now on the floor on Resolution 23.
Are you ready to vote on Resolution 23, gentlemen?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: If I may make one remark.
I was asked to make this remark by Past National Commander Milo Warner and with your permission, Mr. Commander and members of this Executive
Committee, Past National Commander Warner was very hopeful, that this
matter would come up yesterday when he could be here. He had to leave early
152
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
this morning, and he asked me if I would make it a matter of record, that
he desired to second the motion for the adoption of this resolution. His
reason for it as stated to me was that when discussion was had and this
body considered opening the eligibility to members serving in World War
II, members of the Armed Forces serving in World War II, he was one of
the first to speak in opposition to that.
He said that he wanted to clear himself of that error of judgment. If he
had been here, he said that he would advise you that he was “eating crow”
because he realizes that the action then taken and subsequently taken has
added to the building of the cathedral which is The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Ad.
May I say this, that the record will show that this motion was seconded
by Fast National Commander Milo Warner and by every member of this
Committee who votes in favor of it.
Are you ready to vote?
. . . The question was called.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Those in favor of Resolution 23
signify by saying aye; those opposed no.
The ayes have it and it is adopted.
MR. JANKO: May the record show that I voted in opposition to it?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, gentlemen, you have
taken a momentous step. I want to thank you for your patience.
We have some other business, one a very important matter now before we
*0 the Rehabilitation and Finance reports, and I call on Committeeman
McKinley from New Jersey.
Let’s keep order, please, gentlemen.
TRIBUTE TO E. MEADE WILSON, FLORIDA
,
MR McKINLEY New Jersey: Gentlemen, what I now have to say may
be a bit of pleasant interlude between the very spirited discussion. Believe
me 1 watched you sit here today, and it was such a healthy discussion on the
part of this Executive Committee with such participation and debate on a certain question, that I kept my mouth shut.
is perunentt0
y U JUSt a little piece of
°
Poetry- It isn’t complete, but it
If with pleasure you are viewing
Any work a man is doing
If you like and love him
tell him now.
Do not wait till life is over
and he is underneath the clover;
For he cannot read his tombstone
when he is deceased.
I address that little thing, that parlance to the fact, and fortunatelv before it is too late, that our good friend Meade Wilson is substantially serving his last session on this Executive Committee after 20 years of service He
is leaving this Executive Committee, I know very much against his will and I
am led to believe that the boys in Florida don’t like his* departing from the
scene either because many of them have spoken. But he is doing it because
his doctors told him that it is wise for him to do this, curtail many of his
activities so that he may enjoy a little additional span of life, and he is
wisely obeying that admonition.
’
So, gentlemen, I say I would like to just review briefly Meade’s experiences
on this Executive Committee, and possibly the excuse for my opening this
is because R was his misfortune, upon coming upon this Executive Committee
that his first assignment was to fall under my evil influence as a member
of the, my Committee at that time, the Resolutions Committee.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
153
Meade served on that Committee very faithfully. He fumbled and he stumbled a little bit, hut he was very attentive to the duties of that, and I assumed some other responsibilities back in ’46 and ’47, namely the reorganization of our Commissions, and it was necessary for me to find a Chairman
or a Vice Chairman, and I asked Meade if he wouldn’t pick up the load and
he did. He carried on magnificently. Over these last 20 years or so, Meade
has been a very active member of this Committee. He has a charming personality which intrigues me. He has a wealth, or he did have a wealth of
cheerful energy and forceful energy. He was a gracious friend and a gracious
host with ability to give attention to almost anything without indicating any
annoyance or dissatisfaction.
In all of his operations on this Committee, he has endeavored to further
the interests and the best interests and the purposes of our organization in
cooperation with his colleagues, and I know that in many instances he has
intervened between some of our colleagues who weren’t just looking eye to
eye, and in his magnanimous way persuaded them to be friendly rather than
enemies. That is really worth while, very much worth while.
There is one sidelight comment that I make in this connection, the famous
subject of mine, maybe I am making a speech to myself to some extent, it is
unfortunate that some of our Departments have written into their Constitutions or into their methods of relieving Executive Committeemen every two
years. It takes four to six years to really grasp the import of much of the
business of this Executive Committee. Some Departments are denying to
themselves the benefit of long service such as Meade has performed and withholding from us the benefit of a trained member of our Executive Committee.
The younger members of the Committee will understand the significance
of what I am saying.
Meade at the present time is serving as Chairman of the Liaison Committee of Education, and he has been very active, and contributed substantially to their affairs, and I am sure they can attest to that. Meade, it is with
sincere regret, so far as I am concerned, I am sorry to see you leave our
midst. We can only hope that in the fortune of things, have you talked to
Tom Miller and the Committee on cakes and cookies? Maybe they will find a
cookie so that you can come back and join us.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. National Commander, members of the Committee, I feel certain that the remarks I am about to make now will be
received with more approval than the ones I made from the rostrum a
moment ago.
My associate and colleague Bill McKinley has said that it was in 1946
that Meade Wilson and myself came onto the National Executive Committee,
and we have been serving together for over 20 years. In his Department he
came up the hard way, Post, District and Department offices of every caliber, and when he was the Department Commander for it in 1945, he saw to
it that the Legislature of the State of Florida passed the Florida State Veterans Commissioner Law, and he was able to have the Governor appoint six
of the seven members who were outstanding Legionnaires.
You have already heard what Bill has said about his splendid service.
He was the originator, if I am correct, of putting the Committee on Resolutions of the National Executive Committee on a firm basis so that our mandates would be properly prepared and considered by this Committee. He
well trained his successor here, Roy Stone from South Carolina, and if for
no other reason, we want to be thankful, Meade, that you left such a good
understudy as Roy has been since you went off that Committee.
Having served on the Committee on Committees as McKinley says, for
the last few years, I was well aware of the fact that we have various Committeemen who do not know quite how to operate, and needed a little bit of
assistance on the side, but not so for Meade Wilson. He always appeared
before our Committee on Committees with his lists neatly printed and the
history of the nominees properly outlined. Our only question was where the
Department of Florida got enough stationery to carry out all the multi-
154
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
tudinous recommendations that he was making, because he didn’t miss a single bet to put up somebody from Florida for any one of those Committees,
and in that, I think you have the record here in the National Executive Committee meeting.
Also at this time that he was serving The American Legion in the capacity
that we have very meagerly outlined to you, he was a very busy and successful businessman. He was Chairman of the Assistant to the Vice President of
the International Metals and Chemical Corporation, which is, if you do not
know, has its direct roots right out there in Wall Street.
I won’t go into the details of how Wall Street at times tried to bend
his arm when it came to the Legion actions here, but both for the League
°f National Commanders and other matters, because that is a secret
that only Meade and a few of us know about. So for the record, I won’t put
that in, Meade.
He also went back to Mulberry, Florida which is his home, and has been
a very successful and active businessman there, having been officially retired
for ten years. And I commend you, Meade, that you not only attend to your
personal business there, but keep your activities in the various fields of civic
community welfare that you have so ably handled over these years.
Sitting on the floor of Congress in 1951 when Douglas McArthur addressed that body, he said, “Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.”
Well, I know Meade is not going to fade away, because we want him here
with us right along for many a year to come. Thank you.
MR, GODWIN, Mississippi:
Mr. Commander and my colleagues, the
hour is very late, just as late for us as it is for anyone. Meade Wilson, our
friend, has to catch a train in about 45 minutes, but this man has given 20
years of his life in one position in The American Legion, and he is going
to get an extra five minutes of my time if I am the only man listening to it.
I know you love him as I do. I want to tell you just what I think about
him.
What an accomplishment to look back upon, one so many of us will never,
you and I here will never achieve, 20 years of dedicated service to The
American Legion as National Executive Committeeman from the same Department.
It is with a feeling of sadness and regret, my colleagues, that I realize
the inexorable passage of time that has brought us to the moment of the
last meeting in National Headquarters in which Meade Wilson and you and
I will be associated together in our respective capacities as National Executive Committeemen.
One of my greatest privileges and pleasures has been that of knowing
him and learning, I hope, from his great wisdom and his experiences, and
having the advantage of bis long association in this organization that we all
love, The American Legion.
Eleven years ago I was a freshman on the NEC. I was doubtful of the
right way to proceed. I was unfamiliar with the operations of this great
group, but I too had a desire to serve, and I found a man who, being a fellow
Southerner, as I was, who being a fellow alumnus of a great university in
the South as I was, but most of all a colleague with a similar desire to
serve The American Legion as I did, he volunteered his assistance to me,
his counsel and his understanding, and I know he has made me a better
Legionnaire and a better member of this Committee. And through these
past eleven years, we have been close friends.
But this experience of mine is not unusual or uncommon. Many NEC men
through the years, many of you here present, have a similar situation, you
too have benefited by his great Legionnaire’s counsel, advice and friendship.
,, As the prime organizer and the only Chairman we have ever had in
the Southern Caucus, Meade Wilson has been a great instrument of merit
in welding the so-called “Southern Bloc” into an entity of this national organization. It has grown greatly in size and influence, so great that now
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
155
not only the near and deep Southern states in it, but everyone that we see
fit to allow to come in is applying for membership. There too he will be
missed, but he will never be forgotten.
Now as the Sage of Mulberry puts away his red cap and turns his Legion endeavors into fields less exacting on account of his health and strength,
I want to say to this Committee publicly and to him, “May God bless you,
Uncle Meade, and give you many more years of health, happiness and service to The American Legion.”
You carry with you the respect, the admiration of your colleagues, the
National Executive Committee will miss you, but it will never forget you.
All your friends will miss you, but they will never forget you. And as a
little personal thing, may I tell you that 27,000 Legionnaires in Mississippi,
many of whom know you will miss you. But they will never forget you.
So I say, on behalf of many of your friends, thanks, Uncle Meade, for a
job well done. We will be seeing you around from time to time, and we will
also be working together for the good of The American Legion.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Past National Commander Dan
Foley.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, my colleagues of the National Executive Committee, I am happy to be given the
opportunity to say a word or two at this time. There is no particular way
that one says goodbye to an old friend. There is no phrase perhaps or group
of phrases that could fully express our feelings as we say goodbye to Uncle
Meade as all of us know him so well refer to him.
I think Bill McKinley made his remarks, and he talked about Uncle Meade
when he first came on stumbling a little bit here and there until Bill
explained to him procedures and ways of this National Executive Committee.
Well, I suppose in my own way, I was one of those younger members of the
Committee that stumbled and tripped and fell along the way, but somewhere
along the line, I came under the guidance and tutelage and the inspiration
of Meade Wilson, and found him over the years to not only be a good leader
of the Legion, very valued counselor, but I found him more importantly to
be a good friend.
I know that everyone here who knows and has worked with Meade have
their own feelings and affection for him, and in their own way, will have
their many reminiscences of this great acquaintance. But, Uncle Meade,
I say to you as I would say to any good and trusted friend, as I say goodbye to them, what the Irishman says in a toast that means so much to him
and the person to whom he extends it, and in this way express to you in
those words my feeling for you:
May the roads always rise with you, may the wind be ever at your back,
and may the Lord forever hold you in the hollow of His hand.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is late. There
is much I would like to say.
You want to take the floor, Mr. Chairman? You have a resolution?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I want to thank these men
personally here who have participated in the memorial to Meade—memorial
to the services that he has given.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: His services will never die.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Chairman, Mr. Commander, due to the lack of time and for the fact that I am a little bit emotional
at this moment, I would like to say that a special committee be appointed to
formulate a resolution in order, outlining the services of this fine Legionnaire for the 20 years’ service that he has given, and that the resolution be
framed or embossed and be presented to him at the next NEC meeting. I so
move.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Committee has already been
appointed constituting those who have spoken, with you as the Chairman.
156
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Gentlemen, the hour is late. I would only like to say this to you, Uncle
Meade, having shown I believe my well concealed patience and restraint, I
left myself no time to comment at this hour, except it appears to me that
the highest aspiration that one might have in view of this testimonial to you
is to return for office of Past National Committeeman.
Past National Committeeman, we thank you so much. There is so much
we would like to say, thank you.
. . . The NEC stood and applauded as National Executive Committeeman
E. Meade Wilson left the room.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is late. You
have been very patient, and two Committee Chairmen have been most patient.
We will now hear from the Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission,
Bob McCurdy, for his report. Boh?
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN McCURDY: Mr. Commander and comrades,
nothing has made me happier than to have my time taken for the purpose
for which it was taken. I have been privileged to know Meade for the full
20 years that he was here, and to serve with him, and I want to second
the motion of everything that has been said and done on his behalf.
Now I know the hour is late, and many of you have transportation problems.
On April 15th we mailed you the advance report which I am sure you
all read and studied.
Today, we have circulated another seven-page report that explains in
detail the actions of the Committee at this meeting.
We have three resolutions that will follow my report here and so, without taking any more of your time at all, unless you have questions, I wish
to thank the Commander for his fine help. I wish to thank Blackie and
Paul and Bill Hauck for their great assistance during the year, and especially
John Corcoran of the Rehabilitation staff for a job well done. Thank you,
Mr. Commander.
. . . The Advance Report is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
by
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
The following report covers the activities of the National Rehabilitation
Commission from October 7, 1965 to April 15, 1966.
I. MEETINGS OF THE NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
The National Rehabilitation Commission has held two meetings since the
National Executive Committee last met. Both sessions were held in the Statler
Hilton Hotel, Washington, D. C., in connection with the 43rd Annual National Rehabilitation Conference, and as part of the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. The first session was held Monday, February 28, 1966 and
the second Friday, March 4, 1966.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
157
Actions on matters considered during these meetings, together with an
outline of the various reports received by the Commission, are noted as follows.
a. Resolutions and Register matters referred to the Committee.
The following resolutions, with accompanying staff studies, were presented
to the Commission for consideration and action. A short digest of the resolution and action taken by the Commission are shown after each resolution.
1) Resolutions referred by the 1964 National Convention
Resolution No. 33 (Kentucky)—urges The American Legion to sponsor and
support legislation to be known as the Prisoner of War Disability Compensation Act. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 545 (Texas)—urges support of HR 174, a bill to provide
that all diagnosed diseases and disabilities of World War II and the Korean
War be considered as service-connected. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 602 (Virginia)—urges the VA to provide adequate facilities
and staff at the VA hospital, Kecoughtan, Virginia, for conducting examinations and providing out-patient treatment. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 606 (Virginia)—urges return to the Roanoke Regional Office of those VR&E activities previously transferred to the jurisdiction of
the Veterans Benefits Office, Washington, D. C. No action taken (accomplished).
2) Resolution referred by the 1965 National Convention
Resolution No. 256 (Maine)—urges that steps be taken to obtain a revision of law to provide that the additional amount of annuity payable under the Railroad Retirement Act, by the inclusion of the family group, be
excluded from determinations of annual income, similar to the provisions
of the VA regulation which permits exclusion of the additional amount of Social Security benefits payable for dependents in the family group. Deferred
(for further study).
Resolution No. 427 (Texas)—urges support of HR 7571, a bill to prevent
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs or other officer, employee, department
or agency, from establishing an indebtedness against gratuitous benefits to
liquidate indebtedness in connection with a loan default. Deferred (for further
study).
Resolution No. 512 (Virginia)—urges that the privilege of an appeal be
afforded all veterans who have been denied insurance under PL 88-664. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 513 (Virginia)—urges that medical examination units in
VA hospitals be placed under the supervision and control of regional office
managers. Rejected.
Resolution No. 533 (Oklahoma)—urges VA to send a letter with VA Form
21-6799 explaining how a spouse’s income affects a veteran s pension. No
action taken (accomplished).
Resolution No. 565 (Puerto Rico)—urges amendment of law to provide
that veterans age 72, and over, who are receiving disability pension benefits,
not be required to file annual income questionnaires. Rejected.
3) Pending Register matters
Register No. 1192 (Pennsylvania)—urges that a statutory award be provided Under 38 USC(k) or (p) for loss or loss of use of a lung. Rejected.
b. Commission Initiated Resolutions
At its meeting of March 4, 1966, the following resolutions emanating from
the Commission were approved. All will be handled administratively.
1) That the Rehabilitation staff offer its services to the Economic Commission staff in handling appeal cases on loan guaranty matters, if the Economic Commission so desires.
158
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
2) That the Department of Defense arrange for a traveling board for
Correction of Records and Discharge Review cases, in order that more veterans may have the opportunity to make personal appearances before the
boards.
3) That the Rehabilitation staff secure and send to Department Service
Officers slip laws on newly enacted legislation.
4) That the Rehabilitation Commission contact all Departments, before
their respective budgets are formulated, to request support of Area Rehabilitation Conferences by appropriating sufficient funds to enable their respective
Rehabilitation Commission member (or members) and their Department
Service Officer, as a minimum, and such others as they can afford, to attend
the Area Conferences.
c. Report of The Subcommittee on Certificate of Appreciation
W. Bea Waldrip, Michigan, Chairman of the Commission’s Subcommittee
on Certificates of Appreciation, reported that 30 recommendations had been
referred to the Subcommittee for consideration. All were recommended for
approval.
The Commission approved the Subcommittee report. Accordingly, Certificates have been prepared and distributed to the following individuals:
ALABAMA
Dr. Wesley C. Corson, Chief of Staff, VA Hospital,
Montgomery
Dr. Joseph J. Mack, Medical Rating Specialist, RegionARKANSAS
al Office, Little Rock
ILLINOIS
James R. Richey, Assistant for Education, Regional
Office, Chicago
INDIANA
Arthur W. Hendricks, Assistant Adjudication Officer,
Regional Office, Indianapolis
Wilbur W. Jones, Chief Contact Representative, Regional Office, Indianapolis
KENTUCKY
Emerson O. Mann, Management Analyst, Regional Office, Louisville
J. Regan O’Connor Loan Guaranty Officer, Regional Office, Louisville
MAINE
Solomon Crasnick, Chief, Adjudication Division, VA
Center, Togus
MICHIGAN
Michael E. Goetz, Loan Guaranty Officer, Regional
Office, Detroit
NEBRASKA
Dr. Charles W. Way, Chief, Outpatient Clinic, VA Hospital, Omaha
NEW MEXICO
James M. Keating, Chairman, Rating Board, Regional
Office, Albuquerque
Robert J. Shepard, Contact Officer, VA Hospital, Albuquerque
NEW YORK
Lertie M. Hylton, Adjudication Officer, Regional Office, New York
Leo V. Lanning, Manager, Regional Office, Buffalo
Leo J. Ross, Chief Attorney, Regional Office, New York
NORTH CAROLINA J. D. DeRamus, Manager, Regional Office, WinstonSalem
A. H. Dalton, Adjudication Officer, Regional Office,
OKLAHOMA
Muskogee
Menter G. Baker, Manager, Regional Office, Muskogee
PENNSYLVANIA
Howard J. Corcoran, Registrar, VA Hospital, Philadelphia
SOUTH CAROLINA Dr. Henry J. Bayon, Chief of Staff and Examining
Physician, Outpatient Clinic, Columbia
James W. Storey, Medical Technician, VA Hospital,
Columbia
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WISCONSIN
VA CENTRAL
OFFICE
159
Dr. A. Ray Dawson, Chief of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation, VA Hospital, Richmond
Dr. Norbert Trauba, Director, VA Hospital, Spokane
John P. Cullen, Manager, Regional Office, Milwaukee
Oliver L. Clay, Insurance Counsel
Mrs. Helen S. Cone, Legal Assistant, Insurance Service
Timothy F. Daley, Assistant General Counsel
Willard E. LaRosa, Claim Examiner, Insurance
Samuel Rose, Chief of Central Office Contact Division
d. Report of Joint Rehabilitation-Economic Subcommittee on Problems
of the Aged and Aging
The joint Rehabilitation-Economic Subcommittee on Problems of the Aged
and Aging met February 28, 1966. Subcommittee Chairman Milton S. Applebaum delivered the Report to the National Rehabilitation Commission:
“Discussion was had on Medicare, the nursing care program, nursing home
facilities, and general topics relating to new legislation on the older American.
“The Older Americans Act of 1965, PL 89-73, was discussed with interest,
but the newness of the Act prevented any further consideration. Edward McGrail of the national staff stated that his investigation showed no conflict
between the programs of the Administration on Aging and any existing program of the Veterans Administration.
“Considerable time was spent on 1965 Convention Resolution No. 231 asking that discrimination in employment of the older worker be made an unlawful employment practice under federal law. It was voted _ to recommend
approval of the resolution, with the proviso that such discrimination be condemned only when applicant is under 65 or otherwise qualified for such employment.”
e. Report of Conference Committee on Recommendations
Constituted as a Subcommittee of the Commission, the 1965 Rehabilitation
Conference Committee on Recommendations consisted of: Joseph B. Halloway,
Virginia, Chairman; Thomas W. Byers, Connecticut; Carle B. Lenker,
South Dakota; J. Earl Merifield, California; and Joe F. Hudgens, Tennessee. Chairman Halloway delivered the report which included four recommendations, all of which enamated from the conferees. Three were recommended
for approval and one was tabled. The recommendations and actions taken on
each were reported in Rehabilitation Bulletin 13-66 dated March 29, 1966.
The approved recommendations will be handled administratively.
f. Miscellaneous Reports Received by the Commission
1) Discussion on Certain Topics Relating to the VA Hospital Program
John J. Corcoran, Director, National Rehabilitation Commission, invited
attention to certain existing problems relating to the administration and operation of the VA hospital program. A primary cause of some problems, Mr.
Corcoran told the Commission, is the VA’s inability to meet the budgetary
needs of its hospitals. As an illustration, he cited the case wherein the Accreditation Committee of the American Medical Association was forced to cancel the accreditation for the Department of Radiology in a particular VA
hospital because the equipment was obsolete and the staff was inadequate.
Also, in certain cases, limitations on budgetary allowances to certain hospitals affiliated with medical schools is causing a breach in the relationship
between the VA hospital and the medical school and is jeopardizing the affiliation. The steadily rising cost of medical care and equipment, Mr. Corcoran advised, is a factor in the creation of these problems.
Other topics discussed related to the problem faced by the VA in competing for medical personnel with private and other sources (especially m
those medical fields where there is a scarcity of specialists), and the need
for updating the VA’s domiciliary and restoration center programs.
In summarizing, Mr. Corcoran stated that the Legion should concern itself with these problems, as they reflect the challenges we face in our en-
160
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
deavor to see that veterans continue to be provided high quality medical
care.
2) Discussion on Printing the Commission’s Annual Report in Advance
of Government Printing
Mr. Corcoran advised that the annual report of the Rehabilitation Commission to our National Convention, though prepared in July, is not printed
by the Government Printing Office until May of the following year. For
instance, the report prepared in July 1965 will not be printed and distributed
until May 1966.
Pointing out that much informative data relating to the veterans affairs
program and the Commission’s activities is carried in the reports, he requested
an expression from the members to a suggestion that the Commission have
a printing made at its own expense, so that timely distribution can be
made.
The estimated cost of 500 copies of the complete report, for distribution to
key Legion officials, would be $1370. The estimated cost of 5000 “flyers”,
containing only a condensed version of the report, for distribution to delegates
to the National Convention, would be $173.
A motion by National Executive Committeeman Joe Leonard to have 500
copies of the complete report printed, as well as a sufficient number of flyers
for distribution to the National Convention delegates, was approved.
3) Report on Disposition of Closed VA Hospital Facilities
A report was given the Commission on disposition of seven of the hospital
and domiciliary facilities closed by the Veterans Administration.
The VA hospital, Sunmount, New York, was transferred to the State of
New York, and has been converted to a hospital for mentally retarded children.
The VA hospital, Dwight, Illinois, was transferred to the State of Illinois, and has become a hospital for retarded children.
The VA hospital, Fort Bayard, New Mexico, was transferred to the State
of New Mexico, and is a state hospital for mental and geriatric patients.
The VA hospital, Brecksville, Ohio, was acquired by the State of Ohio
and is currently used as a hospital for mentally ill and retarded persons.
The VA hospital, McKinney, Texas, was transferred by the General Services administration to the Office of Economic Opportunity and is currently
being used as a Job Corps Center.
The VA domiciliary, Clinton, Iowa, has not as yet been transferred
from the VA but it is expected that the General Services Administration will
assign it to the Office of Economic Opportunity.
The VA domiciliary, Thomasville, Georgia, is to be transferred to the
State of Georgia as soon as negotiations between the State and Federal Government are completed.
4) Report on S 9 (PL 89-358), the recently enacted Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966
Mr. Corcoran reported on the status of S 9, which had not at that time been
signed by the President. After outlining the provisions in the Act, he commented that, though it did not provide a full spectrum of wartime benefits
for Viet Nam era veterans, and though the Legion was dissatisfied with the
rates of allowances provided in the educational feature of the Act, we wholeheartedly endorsed its enactment.
Aside from the benefits provided, it satisfies a major policy position of
the Legion, namely, that the VA maintain sole responsibility for administration of this program. The Bureau of the Budget had introduced a proposal
(HR 11985) which, if enacted, would have divided responsibility for the administration of the educational program between the VA and the Department
of Health, Education and Welfare. Mr. Corcoran commended the House Committee on Veterans Affairs and the Senate Labor and Public Welfare
Committee for retaining the integrity of the Veterans Administration.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5± 1966
161
5) Discussion on National Service Trophy Award
The Commission was advised that as a result of action taken by the National Executive Committee at its Spring 1965 meeting, Chairman McCurdy
had received a request from the National Trophies and Awards Committee
for a recommendation as to whether the Award(s) made by the National
Rehabilitation Commission should be continued.
The only award given by the Commission is the National Service Trophy.
After discussing the matter and concluding the award of the Trophy had
not been as effective as desired, the Commission felt that a revision of the
governing rules might stimulate competition and encourage more Departments
to increase their rehabilitation services.
Accordingly, the Commission authorized Chairman Bob McCurdy to appoint a Committee to study the history of the National Service Trophy, and
the governing rules, and to report back to the Commission with recommendations for changes in the rules.
Chairman McCurdy appointed the following as members of the Committee.
Emory L. O’Connell, Colorado, Chairman; John Walsh, Massachusetts, and
Joe Hudgens, Tennessee.
II. CONFERENCES
a. Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
More than 500 persons, representing every state in the nation, attended
The American Legion’s 43rd Annual National Rehabilitation Conference,
March 1-4, in Washington, D. C.
Among those participating were members of the Rehabilitation Commission, department service officers, department rehabilitation committeemen,
county and post service officers, volunteer hospital workers, members ol the
Auxiliary, and other national, department, and post officials interested in
The American Legion’s rehabilitation program.
National Rehabilitation Chairman Robert M. McCurdy and Vice Chairman Emory L. O’Connell presided over the meetings of conferees and top
officials of the Veterans Administration; the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare; and the Department of Defense. This year, the .panel
discussions were exceptionally well attended, indicating the intense desire on
the part of our service officers and government agency representatives to
exchange ideas and seek answers to the problems encountered m the care
and benefits programs for veterans and their dependents.
National Commander L. Eldon James keynoted this intensity of purpose
at the time of his appearance before the House Veterans Affairs Committee.
Accompanied by many of the conferees, the Commander pointed to the Eegion s
long history of service to veterans and stressed the need for further legislative action in the fields of compensation, pension, and medical care, he
noted that of major importance at present is recognition of the need lor
wartime benefits for veterans of the Viet Nam era.
Major panel discussions during the Rehabilitation Conference covered: VA
medical and hospital practices and policies; Veterans benefits compensation, pension, loan guaranty, vocational rehabilitation and education; VA
insurance; VA’s Board of Veterans Appeals; and Department of Defense review of discharges and correction of military records.
William J. Driver, Administrator of Veterans Affairs, reporting on VA
activities, said, “In the area of medicine, in 1967 we have for the fifth year
asked for something in excess of a billion dollars. One and a quarter billion
dollars today goes to operate the VA medical system, the 165 hospitals we
have.”
Regarding the VA nursing care program, he advised that the 1967 budget
provides for bringing into the VA system by June 30, 1967, all 4,000 nursing
care beds now authorized by law. It is expected that the number of these beds
will average 3,000 during the new fiscal year.
Community and state nursing facilities for VA patients will operate at
increased levels in the new year, bringing the average daily patient load up to
162
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
3,487. To date, the VA has approved about 2,000 beds in state nursing facilities, and 900 of these beds were occupied by veterans at the end of 1965.
Other VA representatives appearing before the Conference included Dr.
H. Martin Engle, Chief Medical Director; A. W. Stratton, Chief Benefits
Director; Philip J. Budd, Chief Data Management Director; and, James W.
Stancil, Chairman, Board of Veterans Appeals.
Representing the Department of Defense were Col. H. G. MacDaniel, Deputy Director, Secretary of the Air Force Personnel Council; and the executive secretaries of the boards for correction of records for the Army, Navy,
and Air Force.
Alvin M. David, Assistant Commissioner for Program Evaluation and
Planning, Social Security Administration, Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare, spoke to the conferees on various aspects of the recently enacted Medicare program.
B. Area Rehabilitation Conferences
Area C held its Rehabilitation Conference December 12-14, 1965, in Nashville, Tenn. John Corcoran and C. E. Mattingly represented the staff at this
meeting.
No other Area Conferences were held.
.. . The report of the Rehabilitation Commission is as follows:
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION REPORT
To The
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
Robert M. McCurdy, California, Chairman
A Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation
Commission met in National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2
and 3, 1966, to consider matters referred for study and action as well as current problems and topics pertinent to the Rehabilitation program of The
American Legion. The Subcommittee was composed of the following Commission members:
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
Emory L. O’Connell (Colorado), Vice Chairman
Arthur W. Price (New York)
Joseph B. Halloway (Virginia)
Harvey V. Higley (Wisconsin), Consultant
Also present was Joseph G. Leonard (Connecticut), Chairman of the National Executive Committee Rehabilitation Commission Liaison Committee.
Present during the discussions and deliberations of the Committee was Frank
Bottigliero, Director of Rehabilitation, Department of Illinois. Staff members present were John J. Corcoran, Director, and Assistant Director for
Claims, Edward H. Golembieski.
In outline from, the following actions were taken by the Subcommittee
during the meeting:
I. RESOLUTIONS TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Resolution No. 35-—Legislation to amend 38 USC 641 to increase the per
diem payment to States for hospital care of war veterans. (Origin: Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
Resolution No. 36—Eligibility of retired military personnel for treatment
in Veterans’ Administration hospitals. (Origin: Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
163
Resolution No. 37—Sponsor and support legislation to provide nursing
home care for veterans living in Alaska and Hawaii. (Origin: Subcommittee
of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
II. ACTIONS ON REGISTER MATTERS
Register 1230 (New York)—Urges support of HR 424, a bill to provide
a deduction for income tax purposes, in the case of a disabled individual, for
expenses for transportation to and from work; and to provide an additional
exemption for income tax purposes for a taxpayer or spouse who is disabled.
Rejected.
Register 1241 (Pennsylvania)—Seeks legislation to liberalize the two
year continuous operation requirement of certain schools in the education and
training of veterans. Rejected.
Register 1245 (Pennsylvania)—Urges legislation to amend the pension
provisions of title 38, United States Code, to exclude all income from determinations of entitlement to pension. Rejected. The purpose of the resolution
is in conflict with the policy established by past National Conventions that
entitlement to pension be determined by a needs test. Resolution No. 159 of
the 1965 National Convention established the current pension legislative objectives.
Register 1246 (Pennsylvania)—Urges The American Legion to approve a
National Bonus for all honorably discharged World War II and Korean War
veterans, their widows, or children. Rejected.
III. ACTIONS ON REFERRED 1964 CONVENTION RESOLUTIONS
Resolution No. 602 (Virginia)—Requests the Veterans Administration to
enlarge the staff and expand the facilities at the Kecoughtan, Virginia, hospital for outpatient treatment and examination purposes. Tabled for the reason that reports from the VA Chief Medical Director indicate that specific
action is being taken to expand the outpatient facilities as part of the plan
to modernize the Kecoughtan VA Center.
IV. ACTIONS ON REFERRED 1965 CONVENTION RESOLUTIONS
Resolution No. 427 (Texas)—Urges support of HR 7571, a bill to prevent
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs or other officer, employee, department
or agency, from withholding benefit payments, without written consent, from
an individual because of an indebtedness arising out of the default of a Veterans Administration loan guaranty. Accomplished. The provisions of this bill
have been embodied in 38 USC, Chapter 37, as amended by PL89-358.
Resolution No. 512 (Virginia)—Urges that the right of appeal be afforded veterans who have been denied a contract of insurance under the limited insurance reopening provisions of PL 88-664. Rejected. (Staff experience indicates that the soundest and most constructive approach to the purpose of this resolution is to continue to submit these denials of contract for
consideration by the Office of the Director of the VA Insurance Service.)
MATTERS RECEIVED, CONSIDERED, AND
ACTED UPON BY THE COMMISSION
During its meeting, Past National Commander George N. Craig appeared
and asked the Subcommittee to consider the advisability of re-establishing the
Medical Advisory Board. In connection with his request, the Subcommittee
took cognizance of the Chairman’s existing authority to convene a board whenever the necessity arises. Because of this continuing authority given the
Chairman, the Subcommittee believes that the existing arrangement is satisfactory.
In addition, the Subcommittee received the remarks of F. Gordon Wright,
Legislative Chairman, USA National Council, Royal Canadian Legion, suggesting that The American Legion support legislation to establish a program
of reciprocal benefits for Canadian veterans now residing in the United
States. In reply, the Subcommittee advised Mr. Wright that they would study
164
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
and consider the suggestions of the Royal Canadian Legion and advise him
later of their decision.
The Subcommittee considered the effects of Public Law 89-332, an Act
which provides for the right of persons to be represented in matters before
Federal Agencies. Of concern to the Subcommittee were those instances in
which The American Legion was designated as the representative on VA
Form 23-22 and, later, the claimant designates an attorney to represent him
in a specific claim or action with the Veterans Administration. With respect to these cases, the Subcommittee approved the policy that the Staff of
the Rehabilitation Commission would not retain the Power of Attorney.
Veterans Administration Department of Medicine and Surgery standards
of care and adequacy of facilities and staff in medical school and university affiliated and nonaffiliated hospitals were reviewed and discussed by
the Subcommittee. The Subcommittee concluded that the Commission should
continue to keep the VA hospital system and facilities under continued surveillance and study to assure that there is no let-down in the Veterans Administration staffing, equipment, education, and planning to maintain the
present high standards of medical and hospital care of veterans.
In connection with the planning for observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary, the Subcommittee discussed the part that the Rehabilitation Commission could play to assure that the observance was a
success in terms of its program. To obtain the views or suggestions of the
full Commission, each member will be advised on the purpose of the 50th
Anniversary celebration and asked to suggest a plan or program which
would effectively portray the program of Rehabilitation as carried out since
our founding.
Some discussion was given by the Subcommittee to the purpose of the
Community Hospital Industrial Rehabilitation Program (CHIRP) and the
effect on individual rehabilitation motivation of counting income derived from
this program as income for pension purposes. Being aware of the consideration
being given by the VA Department of Veterans Benefits and Department of
Medicine and Surgery to determine if counting such income is destructive to
motivation, the Subcommittee suggested that this program be kept under
study until such time as the VA has made its determination.
The Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission reported on Staff
activities in connection with S 2748, a bill to assure adequate and complete
medical care for veterans by the VA in medical community planning and for
the sharing of advanced medical technology and equipment between the Veterans Administration and other public and private hospitals. Director Corcoran had testified on the bill on March 25, 1966 before the Senate Subcommittee on Veterans Affairs pointing out at that time that the language
was broad enough to legalize the cross servicing arrangement which we so
vigorously opposed early in 1965. Corcoran urged the Senate Subcommittee
not to act favorably on S 2748 until adequate safeguards are established to
assure that the Veterans Administration hospital system will be maintained
primarily for veterans. The Subcommittee approved of the actions taken by the
Staff feeling that the Commission should view the present language of the
bill with reservation. It was also agreed that existing policy and resolutions
granted sufficient authority to oppose enactment of this legislation should
the language of the bill not be changed to meet the objections of the Commission.
The Subcommittee discussed the purpose of HR 13642. This bill would
amend the savings provisions of old law pension cases to provide that annuities and pensions payable under the Railroad Retirement Act would count
as income in determinations of continued entitlement to death and disability
pension. According to VA estimates, this change would affect 8500 cases
with a first year’s savings of $8 million. Because the bill would effect a
substantial reduction in benefits to a group of aged veterans, the Subcommittee expressed disapproval of the purpose of this bill.
Also, the Subcommittee was concerned with the purpose of HR 13643,
a bill to amend the burial provisions of title 38, United States Code, to provide that the maximum burial allowance payable shall be the difference be-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
165
tween $250 and any amount payable under the Social Security Act, or any
other Act providing for the payment of expenses of funeral, transportation,
and interment. In view of the fact that The American Legion is supporting
enactment of legislation to increase the burial allowance, payable by the Veterans Administration, and in view of the fact that burial and funeral costs
are escalating, the Subcommittee recommended that the passage of this legislation should be opposed.
A report was given the Subcommittee by the Director of the National
Rehabilitation Commission on the study urged by Resolution 36 of the May
1963 meeting of repatriated prisoners of war and of the progress reported by
the Veterans Administration in selecting numbers and categories of cases
for study and control and of the status of the questionnaire to be sent selected
repatriated prisoners of war (Europe, Japan, and Korean) to obtain, current
information on their post repatriation adjustment. Referred Resolutions No.
33 and 545 of the 1964 National Convention, both directed to the problems
of repatriated prisoners of war, are retained in a referred status pending
completion of this study.
Because of a request from the Department of Tennessee and others, the
National Rehabilitation Commission re-examined its policy (approved by the
Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission in 1960 at Miami Beach, Florida) that the Staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission
not afford representation in cases in which the veteran did not have some
wartime service. In view of the fact that PL 89-358 established entitlement
to readjustment and other benefits to those with service after January 31,
1955, it was the belief of the Department of Tennessee, and others, that this
policy was causing them embarrassment in certain cases. Based on these and
other facts, the Subcommittee set aside the policy adopted in 1960 to.the extent
that Commission Staff may provide representation in those cases with service
after January 31, 1955.
The Chairman and Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission
reported on Staff activities, travel, budget problems, and personnel changes
and transfers that have occurred since the meeting of the full Commission
in March 1966.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL FINANCE COMMISSION
Harold P. Redden (Massachusetts), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN REDDEN: I want to give you a brief summarization of the status of your Endowment Fund which you are required
to report on.
The total assets in the Endowment Fund of which Harry Colmery is
President of that Corporation, is $7,237,232.25. They received in just last
year some $238,853, and their expenses were $8,061. Excess of income
over expenditures, $230,792. The transfer of earnings, that amount to your
National Treasurer in accordance with previous action of the National Executive Committee was split 50-50 between Child Welfare and Rehab. The earnings last year on the total sum figured out to 3.331 interest in dividends received.
That is the report submitted to us to be submitted to you people as the
report of the Endowment Corporation.
This Finance Commission report is as follows:
This report covers both the Washington and the present meeting of your
Finance Commission.
The 1966 budget was reviewed and, with the exception of the cost of the
Viet Nam Campaign, we appear to be operating within the budget approved
items.
The Auditor’s Report for Fiscal 1965 was analyzed and approved, subject to final approval of the National Convention Finance Committee.
166
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
In accordance with the mandate of the 14th National Convention, the sum
of $367,377.10 was transferred to the Restricted Fund. This sum with accumulated earnings can be expended only by a vote of two thirds of the National Executive Committee and the Finance Commission.
This fund now amounts to $804,448.
As far as Health Insurance, it was reviewed and changes made of a
beneficial nature. The added cost will be slightly less than $400 of present
costs. The raising of rates by Blue Cross would have added prohibitive costs
to the existing plan.
Approval was given for repairs and replacements in the Washington Building. The costs were determined from competitive bids, and were charged
against the depreciation reserve.
Reports were received and approved from the Insurance Committee
and Emblem Committee. Your body has heard the report of the Insurance
Committee; the Emblem Committee report will be submitted as a part of this
report. I have read the report of the Endowment Corporation.
Respectfully submitted, Harold P. Redden.
. . . The report of the National Emblem Committee is as follows:
REPORT OF THE
NATIONAL EMBLEM COMMITTEE
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5,1966
THRU: National Finance Commission
MR. COMMANDER AND GENTLEMEN OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE:
Your National Emblem Committee met in a regularly called session at
Indianapolis, Indiana, May 2, 3, 1966. Seven members were present—Julius
Levy, Chairman (Pennsylvania); Garland Owen, Vice Chairman (Virginia);
Nicholas Scaramella (Massachusetts); V. C. Christensen (Wyoming); Leo
Crawford (California); John A. Gelish (Illinois); and Joseph Paul (Michigan), the National Commander’s Representative. Committee members Hart
Snyder (Washington); Robert M. Summitt (Tennessee); and Walter
Sokolowski (New York) were unable to attend. Mr. Sokolowski is recovering
from a heart condition in the Buffalo, New York VA Hospital. The committee signed an appropriate card wishing Walter a speedy and complete
recovery.
The Outline For The Meeting, a copy of which is attached, was received
and discussed.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT
The Gross Sales for 1965 was $1,400,247.09. Net profit after distribution
was $121,571.17. The entire financial picture was reviewed in connection
with the March 31, 1966 Operating Statement and Statement of Budget. The
profit and loss statement is attached to this report.
CATALOG
The 1966 catalog was extensively discussed along with advance planning
for the 1967 catalog. The cost of the 1966 catalog was discussed and the fact
that it was much higher than previous catalogs. The paper used was a much
better quality, sheet fed press with complete new art work with models
being the reason for the increase in cost. The committee felt that the catalog
was a prestige piece and was much better than the previous three editions.
The committee discussed with the General Manager and his assistant who
handles the catalog, the possibility of reducing the cost of the 1967 catalog,
and it was brought out that much of the art work could be and would be
utilized in the 1967 issue thus reducing the art cost. It was also determined
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
167
that the sheet fed press was preferred over the web press and that the use of a
good quality paper should be continued. Efforts will be made to strike a
happy medium similar to the 1961 and 1962 catalogs which would be most
satisfactory and save approximately $12,000 on the 1967 catalog over the
cost of the 1966 catalog.
INVENTORY
The committee was gratified by the condition of the inventory with the
average monthly inventory for 1965 being $239,769.71.
Contract and non-contract purchases were considered at length. The advertising program was reviewed and approved and the committee voiced rts
appreciation for The American Legion Magazine’s aid and cooperation.
OFFICIAL REPRESENTATIVES
The committee discussed at length Licensed Official Representatives and
volume of business from same. The Committee approved a motion that all
Official Representatives be required to purchase $500 minimum gross sales
per year or relinquish their license effective following one year s operation
or their -next renewal date whichever is longer.
50TH ANNIVERSARY COMMEMORATIVE MEDAL
The General Manager reported that the National Commander had complied with the Resolution No. 229 emanating from the Portland 1965 National Convention. He had appointed a special temporary committee to formulate plans for the observance of the 50th Anniversary. Revised sketches of the
sculptor’s ideas insofar as a commemorative medal was concerned was reviewed by the committee and in view of the 50th Anniversary Committee s
action in connection with this type of an item, the committee authorized the
chairman and General Manager to act as liaison with the 50th Anniversary
Committee to avoid duplication of effort and to offer full cooperation and
support of the National Emblem Sales Division. The Chairman, Vice Chairman arid General Manager appeared before the 50th Anniversary Committee
at their invitation and discussed the commemorative medal and the tact that
the Division was most desirous of cooperating in every way and ottered the
back page of the 1968 catalog to assist in the promotion of the 50th Anniversary. It was determined that the 50th Anniversary Committee would
through their procedure, select the design for the commemorative medal and
other similar items which would be sold, and then work with the Emblem
Division in formulating final promotion and selling procedures.
Resolution No. 451 (Michigan and Resolution No. 482 (Connecticut)Subiect: Color of lettering on Department caps. The resolutions were referred to
the National Emblem Committee from the 1965 Portland, Oregon National
Convention. The resolutions were discussed by the committee and both resolutions rejected.
Many items germane to the Emblem Division’s operation were reviewed
and discussed throughout the two-day meeting of the committee.
BOOTLEG AND MISUSE OF THE AMERICAN LEGION EMBLEM
The Chairman and the General Manager called to the attention of the
committee again that many complaints of misuse of The American Legion emblem were continuing to occur. Reference is hereby made to the National
Emblem Committee’s report of April 30—May 1, 1964 with the following
paragraph quoted therefrom:
“The Emblem Committee has received several complaints regarding manufacturers bootlegging the emblems. It has been more than 10 years since
the Emblem Division employed a person to investigate the bootlegging of
the emblem. The Emblem Committee voted unanimously to authorize the
Chairman to employ an investigator for a period of one year, following
approval of the Finance Commission and the granting of a budget item
for this purpose. If a violation is found, then the Judge Advocate and
other proper parties are authorized to proceed with litigation to prohibit illegal use of the emblem.”
168
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
The Emblem Committee is now firming up a decision as to what extent
they will pursue investigating the bootlegging of The American Legion emblem.
The committee took special note of the 20 consecutive years of service
(19 as chairman) of Chairman Julius Levy and of the 22 consecutive years
of service of member Nicholas Scaramella. Their efforts throughout this period of time were lauded by the committee.
The committee expressed satisfaction with the overall operation of the
division under the direction of James S. Whitfield, General Manager and
asked that he relay this information to his staff.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
JULIUS LEVY, Chairman (Pennsylvania)
GARLAND OWEN, Vice Chairman (Virginia)
NICHOLAS SCARAMELLA (Massachusetts)
V. C. CHRISTENSEN (Wyoming)
LEO CRAWFORD (California)
JOHN A. GELISH (Illinois)
JOSEPH PAUL (Michigan), National Commander’s Representative
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL FINANCE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted:
“Rescinding of National Emblem Sales Non-Legislative
Policy Resolutions”
Resolution No. 7 (Submitted by:
National Emblem Committee. Approved: National Finance Commission).
WHEREAS, In accordance with resolutions of the 1959 and 1960 National Conventions, the National Executive Committee, through its Program
Study Committee, has caused to be made a review of all non-legislative policy
resolutions; and such action has been taken in further accordance with the
action of the 1936 National Convention which established policy on the life
of such resolutions; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, That the following resolutions be and they are hereby rescinded by
reason of (1) being obsolete, (2) accomplishment of purpose, (3) being superseded by later resolutions, (4) being in conflict with later resolutions, (5)
being duplicated in later resolutions, (6) having no value because of later
changes in program, (7) and for other reasons, hereinafter indicated:
Date
1963
May 1-2
1963
Sept. 8
1964
Apr. 30
May 1
1964
Sept. 20
Reference
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes
Pages 101-102
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes, Page 9
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes
Pages 147-148
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes, Page 8
Resolution or Other
Rescinded by
Identification
Reason Of
Resolution 38—Specifications, bids
2
and contracts for Emblem Division
Merchandise for 1964
Awarding of Emblem contracts for
year 1964
2
Resolution 60—Specifications, bids
and contracts for Emblem Division
Merchandise for 1965
2
Resolution 2—Awarding of Emblem Contracts for year 1965.
2
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
169
“Specifications, bids and contracts for Emblem Division Merchandise”
Resolution No. 8 (Submitted by:
National Emblem Committee).
BE IT RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, at a regular meeting held at Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5,
1966, that approval is hereby given to thirteen (13) specifications relating
to the following merchandise bearing thereon the emblems of The American
Legion, American Legion Auxiliary, and Sons of The American Legion, each
specification bearing the date May 4, 1966, and bearing thereon an identifying number, namely:
Specification No. 1—American Legion caps
Specification No. 2—American Legion colors
Specification No. 3—American Legion Auxiliary colors
Specification No. 4—Sons of The American Legion colors
Specification No. 5—American Legion embroidered insignia
Specification No. 6—American Legion Auxiliary embroidered insignia
Specification No. 7—Sons of The American Legion embroidered insignia
Specification No. 10—American Legion bronze grave markers
Specification No. 11—American Legion Auxiliary bronze grave markers
Specification No. 12—American Legion buttons, pins, badges, rings, and
miscellaneous insignia
Specification No. 13—American Legion Auxiliary pins, badges, rings, and
miscellaneous
Specification No. 16—American Legion shirts
Specification No. 18—American Legion school award medals, brooch and
plaque,
and the above numbered specifications are attached hereto, and made a part
of this resolution for filing among the official records under the custodian
ship of the National Adjutant, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Emblem Sales and Emblem Committee, within their determination, are hereby authorized to transmit
the foregoing specifications to such concerns which manufacture, fabricate process or produce, any of the above described merchandise, for
the submission of proposals and bids to the National Emblem Committee, for
the supplying of merchandise for the period of one year from January 1,
1967 through December 31, 1967, such bids to be received no later than twelve
o’clock noon, local Indianapolis Time, Wednesday, July 27, 1966, at the National Emblem Sales, National Headquarters, The American Legion, 700 North
Pennsylvania Street, (P. 0. Box 1055), Indianapolis, Indiana, to be opened
before the National Emblem Committee at the next meeting to be held at
the National Headquarters, The American Legion, at the 48th Annual National Convention of The American Legion at Washington, D. C., said bids
to be opened at ten o’clock in the morning, local Washington, D. C. Time,
Thursday, August 25, 1966, and be it further
RESOLVED, that upon the determination of the lowest, responsible bidders for each type of merchandise as shown in the above numbered specifications, or any or all sections of any of such said specifications, that a report, as provided by the Rules of Procedure of the National
Executive Committee, be made by the Emblem Committee with its recommendations to the National Executive Committee, at its pre-convention meeting to be held at Washington, D. C., on August 28, 1966, for its consideration
and action thereon, and be it further
RESOLVED, that upon the approval and awarding of contracts
to the successful bidders, by action of the National Executive Committee as aforesaid, such contracts be approved as to form by the National
Judge Advocate, authority is hereby given for their execution by the National
Commander and National Adjutant.
170
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
“Approval to Reimburse The American Legion for Life Insurance
Expenses”
Resolution No. 39 (Submitted by:
Trust Committee).
American Legion Life Insurance and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has incurred expenses in connection
with its Insurance Plan from January 1, 1965, through December 31, 1965,
namely Committees and related expenses as certified by the National treasurer, and these expenses were paid out of the general funds but never reimbursed The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The Administrator for the program has solicited each insured member in the Group States and a majority of the insured have indicated they do approve reimbursing The American Legion from out of the
Life Insurance Trust Fund for its expenses; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966 That in compliance with Section 3.2, Provision (e) of the Trust Agreement as Amended, that the Trustor, The American Legion, instruct the Trustee within 30 days of the approval date of this resolution, to reimburse The
American Legion $10,171.37.
“Approval to Prepare Agreement for American Legion Life
Insurance Plan”
Resolution No. 43 (Submitted by: American Legion Life Insurance and
Trust Committee).
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that a new Administration and Promotion Agreement be prepared and executed by the First National Bank of Kansas City, Missouri, as trustee, as
of January 1, 1967, with the R. H. Gore Company of Chicago, Illinois, as
Administrator, of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, said agreement
to provide in addition to the matters in the present agreement, that the
Administrator will receive for its service compensation on a sliding scale as
follows:
(1) 10% on the first $1,000,000 of premium from the group states
(2) 8% of said premium from $1,000,000 to $1,500,000
(3) 7% of said premium from $1,500,000 to $2,000,000
and, be it further
RESOLVED, That said agreement shall also provide that the Administrator will bear the full expense of all IBM and tabulating costs, and that all
IBM cards, records, data, etc., which do not belong to the insurance carrier,
shall be the property of The American Legion; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That the Administrator shall be required to expend not less
than 15% of its total fee for the promotion and furtherance of the Life Insurance Plan, over and above the expense of the Staff Liaison and the direct
mail activity in the policy states, and to this end be required to submit to
The American Legion Life Insurance and Trust Committee at its annual
spring meeting a promotional budget for its approval and adoption, and that
any part of said 15% promotional funds not expended in any year shall be
carried over for future promotion and shall not revert to the Administrator.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
171
“Legislation to Amend 38 USC 641 to Increase the Per Diem Payment
to States for Hospital Care of War Veterans”
Resolution No. 35 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, 38 USC 641 provides a per diem rate of $2.50 for each veteran of any war receiving hospital or domiciliary care in a State home if
the veteran is eligible for hospital or domiciliary care in a Veterans Administration facility; and
WHEREAS, this section also provides a per diem of $3.50 for each veteran of any war receiving nursing home care in a State home if the veteran is unable to pay the expenses of necessary nursing home care; and
WHEREAS, it is well established that the per diem cost of hospital
patient care is greater than the per diem cost of nursing care patients and
of domiciliary members; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that the per diem payment
of State homes for hospital care of war veterans should be increased to an
amount that bears a proper relationship to the nursing care and domiciliary
per diem rates; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion shall sponsor and support legislation to amend
38 USC 641 to provide a per diem rate of $5 for each veteran of any war
receiving hospital care in a State home in such State if the veteran is eligible
for hospital care in a Veterans Administration facility; however, the payment
shall not be more, in any case, than one-half the cost of the veterans maintenance in the State home.
(Rule 8-B.)
“Eligibility of Retired Military Personnel for Treatment in
Veterans Administration Hospitals”
Resolution No. 36 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, legislation is under consideration to authorize health benefits
programs for retired members of the Armed Forces of the United States;
and
WHEREAS, this legislation would provide medical treatment and care
in Veterans Administration facilities which the Administrator of Veterans
Affairs determines are available for this purpose; and
WHEREAS, this legislation would permit retired military personnel to receive care for nonservice-connected conditions without the necessity of their
establishing an inability to pay for such care or treatment at their own
expense; and
WHEREAS, retired military personnel are eligible for care and treatment
in Veterans Administration hospitals for service incurred conditions; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is cognizant of the obligation incurred
by the United States to provide within military facilities, medical and hospital care for these military personnel for any condition; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion looks with disfavor on those administrative or legislative efforts that would modify the admission priorities to permits VA hospital care of retired military personnel or other persons ahead of
eligible veterans; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion oppose the enactment of legislation to provide that
retired military personnel may be permitted admission to Veterans Administration facilities under priorities and standards of eligibility different than
those applicable to war veterans for service-connected and non service-connected hospital care.
(Rule 8-B.)
172
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
“Sponsor and Support Legislation to Provide Nursing Home Care for
Veterans Living in Alaska and Hawaii”
Resolution No. 37 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, Section 620 of Title 38, United States Code, provides that
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs may transfer any veteran, who has
been furnished care by the Veterans Administration in a hospital under the
direct and exclusive jurisdiction of the Administrator, to any public or private institution not under the jurisdiction of the Veterans Administration
which furnishes nursing home care, for care at the expense of the United
States; and
WHEREAS, the Administrator of Veterans Affairs does not operate and
have under his exclusive jurisdiction any hospital in the States of Alaska
and Hawaii, there being no VA hospital in those states; and
WHEREAS, this provision of 38 USC 620 therefore denies to veterans
residing or domiciled in the States of Alaska and Hawaii nursing care treatment at the expense of the United States; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion feels that veterans living in Alaska
and Hawaii should not be denied entitlement to this essential benefit merely
for the reason that the Administrator of Veterans Affairs does not have any
VA hospital in those States in which an eligible veteran can receive care;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
That The American Legion shall sponsor and support legislation to amend 38
USC 620 to provide that any veteran who is furnished care by the Veterans
Administration in a hospital in Alaska or Hawaii may be furnished nursing
home care at the expense of the United States even if the hospital is not
under the direct and exclusive jurisdiction of the Administrator of Veterans
Affairs.
(Rule 8-B.)
FINAL REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I have one
little matter, Resolution 40. This is a resolution emanating from the National
Chaplin Alfred C. Thompson.
“Commend the American Bible Society on its 150th Anniversary”
Resolution No. 40 (Submitted by: National Chaplain Alfred C. Thompson),
WHEREAS, the Preamble of the Constitution of The American Legion
recognizes Legionnaires’ duty to God; and
WHEREAS, The Bible for centuries, has been the Book of faith; and
WHEREAS, Men who have seriously read the Bible, have found it to be
a Book of promise and hope; and
WHEREAS, America from its beginnings, has been a nation with deep
roots in the Bible; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
That we urge our own members, and all America to revitalize the practice
of personal Bible reading consonant with their beliefs and free will; and be
it finally
RESOLVED, That we commend the American Bible Society on this, its
150th Anniversary, for it has played a major role in making the Bible a
heritage of faith for our own people and people around the world.
CONFIRMATION OF INTERIM APPOINTMENTS
I would like to propose without reading the confirmation of Interim
Appointments which you have made, I understand they are all in proper order,
so I will make that motion.
173
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Galbraith.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Adjutant advises me they are
in order.
Those in favor signify by saying aye; contrary minded no. The ayes
have it and it is adopted.
INTERIM APPOINTMENTS
Joseph J. Bajdek, Indiana—Member, Americanism Commission, 1966replacing Bert F. Nowinski, Indiana, deceased.
Anthony Badamo, Illinois—Vice Chairman, Americanism Council, 1966.
Falon A. Fraley, Nevada—Member, Western Area, Child Welfare Commission, 1968—replacing Ed M. White, Sr., Nevada, deceased.
William G. Clark, Illinois—Vice Chairman, Distinguished Guests Committee, 1966.
Walter M. Rapp, Oklahoma—Consultant, Employment Committee, 1966.
J. Alvis Carver, North Carolina—Member, Foreign Relations Commission,
1967—replacing John J. Barnhardt, North Carolina, deceased.
Robert F. Murphy, Massachusetts—Special Consultant, Legislative Commission, 1966.
Roscoe T. Morse, California—Member, National Security Commission, 1968
replacing George W. Fisher, California, deceased.
Frank Rehberg, Oregon—Member, Civil Defense Committee, 1968—replacing Arthur Gabriel, Oregon, deceased.
Charles Sclafani, New York—Vice Chairman, National Security Council,
Garland Bloodsworth, Jr., Delaware—Rehabilitation Commission, Area “B.”
Fr. Paul Schwaab, Nebraska—Vice Chairman, Americanism.
CONFIRMATION AND CANCELLATION OF
POST AND/OR SQUADRON CHARTERS
MR McKINLEY: I would like to move at this time also the approval of
the confirmation and cancellation of Post and/or Squadron Charters. The
Adiutant has assured me that they are all in proper order, and that there
is no controversy on all of them, and rather than read them, I now move
they be approved.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Fern, Kentucky.
The aforementioned Charters are as follows:
No.
Location
Department
Name of Post
Arkansas
Morgan-W illiams
147
California
Beacon
Havens-Rodriguez Memorial
Barstow
Middletown
La Mirada
Tarzana Missile
343 Los Angeles
535 Simi
663 Barstow
677 Middletown
683 La Mirada
687 Tarzana
Connecticut
Sgt. Richard William Morgan
Sgt. Casper S. Davis, Jr.
Broad Brook
Rogers Brothers
Paul Deschenes
John Benke
New Haven Police Dept.
55 Mystic
136 W aterville
145 Broad Brook
149 Bridgeport
166 Waterbury
185 Bridgeport
191 New Haven
Idaho
Edgar Rae
121
Belleville
Crouch
174
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Location
Department
Name of Post
No.
Illinois
Dwyer-Smith
Verne Hyre
Mark White
Victor F. Lawson
Medina
Hanover Township Memorial
618
637
939
1111
1250
1959
Cooksville
Palestine
Chicago
Chicago
Mossville
Streamwood
Kansas
Thompson-Tyler
Brad Mills
Will L. Pine
James Fippins
Kanorado Memorial
29
82
114
360
395
Salina
Coffeyville
Spearville
Great Bend
Kanorado
Louisiana
Westgate
362
Westgate
Maryland
Baltimore
Westport
Little Italy
Cecil Randolph, Jr.
Howard County
6
33
177
271
286
Baltimore
Westport
Baltimore
Frostburg
Ellicott City
Massachusetts
Capitol Hill
402
Boston
Michigan
Hanes-Malloy
474
Kalamazoo
Minneapolis
Granger
554
Granger
Mississippi
James E. White
215
Hernando
Montana
Jefferson
Toole
Isaac Matt
Rocky Boy
46
52
110
132
Magee-Stevenson
136
Boulder
Shelby
Babb
Rocky Boy’s
Indian
Reservation
E. Glacier Park
New York
Joan of Arc
Hartford
Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake
Morrisania Memorial
North Carolina
Alamance
Junie Ammons
Charlie Humphrey
Hugh Pete Stephenson
1527
1767
1817
1851
83
124
179
186
Bronx
Hartford
Burnt Hills
Bronx
Graham
Clinton
Roxboro
Pendleton
North Dakota
Clyde
289
Clyde
Ohio
Cleveland Transit
Brewer-Kellis
Roy G. Fitzgerald, Jr.
206
393
589
Cleveland
Lynchburg
Oakwood
Oklahoma
Hollarn-Perry
283
Cyril
Pennsylvania
John R. McKinley
Ainsworth-Wernher
Burrell-Saunders
Penn Township
Golden Triangle
Columbia Turn Verein Mem.
West Reading
115
427
704
706
767
872
930
Corsica
Swarthmore
Homestead
Crescent Hills
Pittsburgh
Philadelphia
West Reading
South Carolina
James-Victor-Gardner
The James-Victor-Gardner
116
168
Holly Hill
Travelers Rest
175
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Name of Post
Department
No.
Location
Texas
Ray Wingren
The Lackland City
Hager-Weaver
Cruiser Houston
Ferrel-Cross
Kenedy
Early Carver
W. D. Miller
64 Burnet
81 San Antonio
167 Rule
325 Houston
641 Sylvester
642 Kenedy
906 San Marcos
907 Levelland
Virginia
South Norfolk
Corporal John Herr
Buena Vista
Courtland
Harry S. Walters
108 South Norfolk
171 Arlington
261 Buena Vista
275 Courtland
283 Edinburg
West Virginia
William Alexander
72
Clarksburg
Respectfully yours,
E. A. BLACKMORE, National Adjutant.
SAL SQUADRONS
Department
Name of Squadron
Connecticut
Sgt. Richard William Morgan
Illinois
William Schaefer
Peter Umathum
William R. Edmondson
Wauconda
Park Forest
Mexican-American
Michigan
No.
55
44
412
832
911
1198
505
Location
Mystic
Pekin
Woodstock
Willow Springs
Wauconda
Park Forest
Detroit
Ohio
Pearce-Kems
Isaac Van Wert
Firestone Memorial
Shadyside
Niles Richards
120 Urbana
178 Van Wert
449 Akron
521 Shadyside
708 Hollansburg
Oklahoma
Carter C. Hanner
129
Wisconsin
21
Stillwater
Kenosha
Kenosha
Respectfully yours,
E. A. BLACKMORE, National Adjutant.
AUTHORITY GIVEN TO NATIONAL COMMANDER
AND ADJUTANT FOR CORRECTIONS
MR. McKINLEY: Mr. Commander, I now move that it be shown on the
record the authority is given to the Commander and the Adjutant to make
such amendments of our record as to reflect the facts.
.. . The motion was seconded and carried.
CONFIRMATION OF DATES FOR FALL MEETINGS
MR. McKINLEY: I move that the fall meeting dates of Monday, October
10th through Friday, October 14th, 1966 be confirmed.
.... The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard, Connecticut, and adopted.
176
Proceedings o£ Thursday, May 5, 1966
CLOSING REMARKS OF NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES
Gentlemen, the Chair has much that he would like to say. Let me do it
this way if I may.
There are two, I believe only two Chairmen in the room, I know them well.
You know their records. They typify the magnificent service of men of this
organization who worked, Harold Redden, of the Finance Commission, and
Bob McCurdy of Rehabilitation.
As I look around the room, there are also a few staff members. They
exemplify the other devoted great servants of this organization.
So to you specifically, gentlemen, and through you to all the rest, let me
say thank you so very much for what you have done.
I would like to say this to so many people, to the Chairmen of all the
Special Committees that have been working this year, I would say thank
you, Ad Wagner, to them, thanks for all the work they have been doing.
Your example of a magnificent job typifies their work also.
We want to express our appreciation to them.
There is so much else we could say, but may I just wind it up this
way, at times my words may have been harsh and occasionally the needle
may have been sharp, but neither can possibly match the intense desire of
your Commander to bring out the best in each of you, no matter what your
stand might be. In a mutual deep desire to serve our God and our Country
and our great organization The American Legion, I would sum it up this
way, a man may have thoughts, hopes, dreams, and they may enrich his life,
but they serve no useful purpose beyond that of self enjoyment unless he
uses his talents and his energies to convert those thoughts, those hopes and
those dreams to constructive action.
This Committee is generously endowed with such men who convert their
talents and their energies to work of this organization. They are generously
endowed with Committeemen and Committee Members co-workers of the same
ilk. For this, your National Commander has incurred a debt to you, and to
them, he will never be able to repay. But he will devote the best of his time
and talent and energy in the years ahead to satisfying that debt.
And with this, all I can say is, you have my gratitude and thanks.
Is there anything further to come before this meeting?
If not, the National Chaplain.
BENEDICTION
NATIONAL CHAPLIN THOMPSON: Let us pray.
Almighty God, as we now close this session of the National Executive
Committee, we pray to you to bless and sanctify those decisions which we
have made, may these actions help to strengthen our American Legion and
further the aims and the purposes for which we have been organized. Grant,
oh God, as we leave this meeting we may have traveling mercies, and
may the Grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God the Father, the
fellowship and the communion of the Holy Spirit be with you forevermore.
Amen.
... At this time the National Executive Committee saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the meeting is adjourned.
... At 12:45 p. m., the spring meeting of the National Excutive Committee
adjourned.
of the
National Executive Committee
THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
MAY 4-5, 1966
INDEX
Page
Page
EMBLEM
166
Resolutions following:
No.
AMERICANISM
50
7—
Resolution following:
Non-Legislative Policy Resolutions . 168
No.
8—
10—
Planning Religious Programs in the
for Emblem Division Merchandise .. 169
Job Corps Centers
54
11—
Support Legislation Which Would
Make it a Crime to Desecrate the
FOREIGN RELATIONS
57
United States Flag
54
Resolutions following:
12—
Daily Display of the American Flag
No.
Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam 54
41—
16—Support Legislation to Amend the
Immigration and Nationality Act to
42—
Make
Provisions
for
Necessary
Communist Forces and Supplies into
Travel Control for United States
South Viet Nam
114
Residents Outside of This Country.. 54
20—Change in the Method of Selecting
INTERNAL AFFAIRS
90
the Winner of the William Randolph
Hearst Trophy
54
NATIONAL CONSTITUTION AND BYLAWS STANDING COMMITTEE,
CHILD WELFARE
35
SUBCOMMITTEE
93
Resolution following:
TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS
95
No.
28—
Commend
Youth AND AWARDS37, 84
SPECIAL TROPHIES
PRESENTED
29—
Need
for Expanded Research and 97
Educational
Program
Concerning
GRAVES REGISTRATION AND MEGenetic Diseases
37, 85
MORIAL
93
30—
Drugs Intended for Child Use and
Resolutions following:
Other Hazardous Materials
85
No.
CONVENTION
62
1—
Post No. 13, Hohenfels, Germany .. 102
Resolution following:
2—
No.
Howard Post No. 8, Sam Miguel de
27—Satisfaction of Indebtedness of UniAllende, Gto., Mexico
103
formed Groups at National Conven18—
tions
64
tee Reports and Resolutions to De38—Authorization for National Adjutant
partment Delegations at the National
of The American Legion to Accept
Convention (Origin; Res. 153 (47th
Advertising for National Convention
National Convention.))
103
Souvenir Program
64
19—
for 1966
104
CONVENTION, Report of 1965
65
24—Future Changes in Manual of Ceremonies
105
ECONOMIC
38
26—Support Legislation to Erect General
Resolution following:
John J. Pershing Memorial in Washington, D. C
105
No.
31—
6—Support Legislation to Amend the
of Individuals Convicted of Treason 105
Cold War GI Bill (Public Law 8932—
358) to Provide Assistance in OnEmilio Aguinaldo Post 45, Cubao,
the-Job Training Programs
47
W.C., Philippines
106
33—Support the Establishment of a SuitFIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE 13
able National Cemetery Policy
106
Resolutions following:
No.
LEGISLATIVE
85
15—Commemoration of Fiftieth Anniversary of First American Legion National Convention in Minneapolis,
LIFE INSURANCE AND TRUST
32
Minnesota
18
Resolutions following:
14—50th Anniversary Observance of the
No.
Founding of The American Legion 18, 72
39—Approval to Reimburse The American
17—Commemoration of 50th Anniversary
Legion for Life Insurance Expenses 170
of St. Louis, Missouri, Caucus of
The American Legion
20, 83
43—Approval to Prepare Agreement for
American Legion Life Insurance
Plan
170
FINANCE
165
COMMISSION, COMMITTEE AND
SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS
Page
MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES 122
Resolution following::
No.
25—Change in Regulations for Awarding
the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of
The American Legion Trophy
126
MEMBERSHIP SPECIAL ELIGIBILITY 127
Resolution following:
No.
23—Amendments to Sections 3 and 5 of
the Federal Act Incorporating The
American Legion, and to Article IV,
Section 1, and to Article XIII, Section 2 of the National Constitution
of The American Legion, to extend
Eligibility for Membership in The
American Legion to those persons
who served in the Armed Forces from
on or after August 5, 1964
141
PUBLICATIONS
PUBLIC RELATIONS
66,71
21
Page
SECURITY
23
Resolutions following:
No.
3—
States Armory in Springfield Massachusetts
24
4—
shey, Director of Selective Service
System
24
5—
for the Late Fleet Admiral Chester
W. Nimitz
24
9—Support Passage of S. 2351 to Protect Harassment of Families of Servicemen in Viet Nam
24
13—Support Legislation Proposed by
Departments of Defense and the Bolte
Committee to Provide Uniformity
for Improvement of Career Opportunities in the Military Services ....
24
21—
22—
Nam
25
REHABILITATION
162
Resolutions following:
MISCELLANEOUS
No.
American Legion Auxiliary
35—
Legislation
to Amend
38 USCPresident
641 to
Mrs. Walter
H. Glynn,
Increase the Per Diem Payment to
Batts, Dianna Lynn, Miss U.S.A
States for Hospital Care of War
Benediction
Veterans
162, 171
ChartersofofRetired
American
LegionPerPosts and
36—
Eligibility
Military
Squadron Cancellations
sonnel for Treatment in Veterans
Administration Hospitals
162, 171
Colors Saluted
3, 112,
37—
Sponsor
and Support
Legislation
to
Commander
L. Eldon
James
Provide Nursing Home Care for
Opening Remarks
Veterans Living in Alaska and HaClosing Remarks
waii
163, 172
Tribute, Louis A. Johnson
E. Meade Wilson
REORGANIZATION
117
Correction Approval
Resolution following:
Endowment Fund Meeting Room
No.
Fall Meeting Dates Approved
34—Referral
of Resolution
Creating
Historians President, Hugh P. HaughAmerican Legion Auxiliary Departerty, National Association of Department in the Philippines to the Nament Historians
tional Organization of The American
Interim
Appointments, Confirmed
Legion Auxiliary
119
Introduction of Guests
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Invocation, Rev. Alfred C. Thompson,
REPORT
18
National Chaplain
3,
Memorial Resolutions
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Presentation to National Chaplain
FINAL REPORT
172
Report on Viet Nam, Past National ComResolution following:
mander Cocke
No.
Roll Call
40—Commend the American Bible Society
Subcommittee Appointments, Resolutions
on its 150th Anniversary
172
6
48
176
173
176
6
176
9
152
175
12
175
7
172
6
112
8
3
107
3
6
PROCEEDINGS
of the
National Executive Committee
THE AMERICAN LEGION
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
May 4, 1966
The opening session of the National Executive Committee meeting of The
American Legion, held at National Headquarters, 700 North Pennsylvania
Street, Indianapolis, Indiana, convened at 9:30 A. M. on Wednesday, May 4,
1966, Mr. L. Eldon James, National Commander, presiding.
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore acted as Secretary.
SALUTE TO THE COLORS
The Colors having been posted, the Committeemen rose and saluted the
flag of our country.
INVOCATION
Rev. Alfred C. Thompson (New York)
National Chaplain
Let us pray, again, our Father, we come to Thee with grateful hearts
for these United States in which we live. Thank you for the opportunities
which are ours, for the privileges which we share, for the responsibilities
which are also ours. We pray, oh God, especially this morning that Thou be
upon us as we gather here to discuss and promote legislative programs and
to carry out those programs that refer to the aims of The American Legion.
Help us in our service to Thee and to our Nation. Grant unto us Thy wisdom and Thy guidance that when all is said and done it might be done to
Thine honor and glory. We ask it in Thy Name, amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Let the record show that the
opening session of the National Executive Committee in the spring of 1966
is in session.
I will ask the Chaplain if he will come with me to the microphone, please.
PRESENTATION
At this time, the National Commander, on behalf of the Friends of the
Chapel of the Four Chaplains presented to Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, a life
membership in the order of the Friends of the Chapel of the Four Chaplains.
ROLL CALL
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore called the roll and the following were
present:
3
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 1,, 1966
4
OFFICERS
National Commander L. Eldon James, Virginia
National Chaplain Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, New York
National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore, Wyoming
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDERS
John R. Quinn, California
Harry W. Colmery, Kansas
Milo J. Warner, Ohio
Warren H. Atherton, California
Paul H. Griffith, Pennsylvania
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire
S. Perry Brown, Texas
Erie Cocke, Jr., Georgia
Seaborn P. Collins, New Mexico
J. Addington Wagner, Michigan
John S. Gleason, Jr., Illinois
Charles L. Bacon, Missouri
Daniel F. Foley, Minnesota
Donald E. Johnson, Iowa
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDERS
Soleng Tom, Arizona
Dr. A. R. Choppin, Louisiana
William E. Galbraith, Nebraska
Robert 0. Phillips, Philippines
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Department
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Canada
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
D. of C.
Florida
France
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Italy
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Mexico
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
Committeeman
Hugh Overton
George Petrovich
Ralph A. Watkins, Jr.
Ulys A. Lovell
A. Lee Oder
Forrest Monner
Robert Grauberger
Joseph G. Leonard
Charles E. Jackson
Allyn E. Donaldson
E. Meade Wilson
Sedley Peck
W. D. Harrell
Wallace C. A. Young
Bernard F. Gratton
Karl Yost
Robert L. Kuntz
Robert Lounsberry
Sexson E. Humphreys
V. L. Lehr
Kenneth Fern
Alternate
Robert E. Cockrill
Norman M. Lyon
Francis G. Garris
Frank J. Specht
Arthur M. MacCarthy
Lt. Col. F. J. Deyeso
Frank A. Kelly
Morris “Bob” Nooner
Melvin H. Heckman
Maurice E. McKeniry
Maurice R. Parisien
H. Laird Roeder
Gabriel T. Olga
Harry Wright
John M. Carey
Eugene V. Lindquist
Ralph M. Godwin
James F. Kerr
William Lindsay
Robert W. Lowry (Acting)
Thomas W. Miller
George Abalan
Victor F. Whittlesea
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
5
Alternate
Committeeman
Department
Raymond F. Mudge
New Hampshire
Edmund G. Lyons
William G. McKinley
New Jersey
Dr. D. H. “Tiny” Reed
New Mexico
Louis E. Drago
New York
Leslie R. Brady, Sr.
North Carolina
W. D. Robbins
John E. Davis
North Dakota
Patrick T. Milloy
Ohio
Alec J. Blair
Oklahoma
Gene Hassman
William Stevens
Oregon
Raymond G. Bush
Panama
Daniel A. Drew
Pennsylvania
Alfredo C. Sese
Philippines
Gilberto M. Font
Puerto Rico
John A. Ryer
Rhode Island
E. Roy Stone, Jr.
South Carolina
Richard W. Small
Glenn R. Green
South Dakota
Whit LaFon
Tennessee
J. Walter Janko
Texas
William E. Christofferson
Utah
Ray Greenwood
Vermont
Dr. Thomas H. S. Ely
Virginia
Aiden F. Russell
Washington
L. O. Bickel
West Virginia
James E.Mulder
Wisconsin
Wyoming
C. B. Metz
NATIONAL ADJUTANT BLACKMORE : A quorum is present.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: I would ask the unanimous consent to seat Dr.
“Tiny” Reed to serve in place of Peter McAtee, as he will not be here this
time, without vote.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Any objection? Hearing none, it
is so ordered.
MR. SESE, Philippines: I am Alfredo C. Sese for Charles A. Park of
the Philippines.
Following the Roll Call the Commander declared that a quorum was present.
INTRODUCTIONS
At this time opportunity was given for the introduction of distinguished
guests and visitors.
OPENING REMARKS OF NATIONAL COMMANDER L. ELDON JAMES
Those who have had the experience of visiting with me. as I come into
your Departments know that my problem is when I start talking I don’t know
when to stop. But you also know that I feel that actions speak louder than
words, so we have no opening remarks this morning, except to thank the
Committee for the work that you have been doing and chastise you for the
work you haven’t been doing. And to those who have really been working,
thanks. And to the great majority, you are setting a great example for the
others. And to the others, if you feel you are in that category, we only say,
go and do likewise. And with that, I think we should get right along with
the business, because you are cast in this role because you love The American Legion. And I think that you gain satisfaction from using every moment
that you can to be about that work.
So that is what we should do, and we will get right along with the business. But before we do, I would like to announce that the dinner tonight will
be in the Ballroom of the Indianapolis Athletic Club at 7:00 P. M.; there will
be a reception in the French Room before dinner from 6:00 to 7:00. The
speaker at the dinner will be our National President, Mrs. Walter Glynn.
This may be some deviation from precedent, gentlemen, but we have not
been bound by precedent I think this year in some respects, and the National
President has just returned from a trip into areas of the world that are
6
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
disturbed, and areas to which we have been giving attention. And I
feel that she can bring a message to us tonight based on her experiences
and the feelings that she has developed. I am sure you will find it a very
entertaining program.
APPOINTMENT OP SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESOLUTIONS
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following
subcommittee appointments were approved:
E. Roy Stone, Jr., South Carolina, Chairman
Robert B. Grauberger, Colorado
Glenn R. Green, South Dakota
Whit LaFon, Tennessee
James E. Mulder, Wisconsin.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I would like to have Past National Commander Don Johnson and the Committeeman from Iowa to escort
our distinguished National President of the American Legion Auxiliary to
the rostrum.
... At this time Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, Iowa, National President of The
American Legion Auxiliary, was escorted to the rostrum.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I have said this many times to
the members of the Auxiliary, and I would like to say it now to this group
so that you may pass this message back to your Auxiliary members where
I have not said it personally. I would like to thank the American Legion
Auxiliary for the great thing that they have done for me this year in giving
me such a fine President to work with. It has been a real experience. This
lady is a sound inspiration, a business lady, a charming person doing a
magnificent job for the American Legion Auxiliary, and therefore for The
American Legion.
We are honored to have you pay us a special visit this morning, but save
some of the steam for tonight, do whatever you want to do right now.
MRS. WALTER H. GLYNN, Iowa
National President
American Legion Auxiliary
Thank you, Mr. Commander, thank you for that wonderful introduction.
Distinguished gentlemen of The American Legion and especially to the group
over there from Iowa, it is wonderful to greet you all at this particular occasion. I was sorry last fall not to have had the opportunity to come here
and say hello to each and every one of you personally and to wish you well
as we went into a new year. I did send a little recorded message, and when
I am through here today, you might decide that it might have been better
if I would have stuck to the tape instead of being here in person. But anyway, it is nice to see all of you gathered here.
I have had an opportunity to greet many of you in the last two days,
and many of you have been over to the office. And I might say, if you have
an opportunity before you leave, we would like to welcome you over there.
Particularly this morning, I want to thank you for all that you have done
for the American Legion Auxiliary, and to keep up inspired in such a way
that we continue to be proud to be associated with gentlemen of your caliber.
Everywhere I go in the nation and throughout my trips abroad, I have
grown more and more aware of the great potential which you gentlemen
have in this world in the way of leadership in which you really do well in
the way of leadership and so, as your Auxiliary, and speaking for the nearly
million members of our Auxiliary, I thank you for asking us to be associated with you over these many years, and I hope that this association
will go on and on and on, and that the only way it may ever end is because
there is never a need or there is no new eligibility for The American Legion,
because this way we know that perhaps at last the world has found peace
and we can all find a different way to serve our nation and the world.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
7
I do have a real special mission. I know that this will come as no surprise
to you, because it has been done several years now, but it gives me a great
thrill to do this as President of the American Legion Auxiliary, because over
the past years, I have been particularly privileged to serve in the capacity
of Child Welfare Chairman and Rehabilitation Chairman for the American
Legion Auxiliary, and so, I would like to ask that the group from the Child
Welfare Committee and the group from the Rehabilitation Committee come
forward—Miss Jean Ryan, our National Rehabilitation Chairman, Mr. Bob
McCurdy, The American Legion Rehabilitation Chairman, and Dr. Corcoran,
the Director, and Vernon Randall, our Child Welfare Chairman, and Randel
Shake, the Director, and Bob Nooner, the Chairman.
As the Commander mentioned, I am looking forward to speaking to you
tonight, and will save most of my message for that. But this is the real
reason for our appearing before you today, and, Mr. Commander, it is a
pleasure for me to be able to present to you on behalf of the American
Legion Auxiliary a check for $20,000 for use in the rehabilitation service of
our organization. This is just by way of thanking you for the service you
have given us over the years, and that you are continuing to do for the veterans of our nation.
And from our National Child Welfare, Helen Randall, we have here
two checks for the Child Welfare program, $20,000 for the Child Welfare
Commission program itself, a $10,000 check for the Child Welfare Foundation. We know that this too will find good use by you.
Considering these people whom you see before you, I wanted them to be
a part of this program, because they have given so much over the years to
the people associated in our organization, and these ladies who are Chairmen this year in our organization, they continue to be dedicated to the programs of rehabilitation and child welfare, and I wanted them to be a part
of the program this morning so this Auxiliary can say thank you for all you
do for us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Madam President, Chairmen, on
behalf of this group of men who would like to make about a ten minute
speech, we say thank you so very much, and we assure you that these
funds will be put to good use in the name of The American Legion and the
American Legion Auxiliary. Thank you so very much.
NATIONAL AUXILIARY PRESIDENT GLYNN: Before I leave this
room I want to say thank you to our National Commander for all the wonderful cooperation he has given our organization, and to thank you for giving me the opportunity of serving with him. It is a wonderful experience to
have had this year with all of you. Thanks so much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: While we are still here, I would
like to introduce three members of the Auxiliary who are present and ask
them to take a bow, Past National President Betty Burdett, Past National
President Betty Anahamiler, and a member of the Auxiliary Finance Committee, Mary Mae Vicker.
You have seen the people that received the glory but now I would like to
present one that does the work, Doris Anderson, the National Legion Auxiliary Secretary.
HUGH P. HAUGHERTY,
President, National Association of Department Historians
of The American Legion
Commander James, Vice Commanders, Adjutant Blackmore, Past National
Commanders, members of the Executive Committee, fellow Historians, ladies
and gentlemen:
I am cognizant of the privilege accorded me and the National Association
of Department Historians of The American Legion when I, their President,
come before you. I wish to express my appreciation to my NEC man, Gene
Hassman, for making arrangements for me.
What is the present status of American Legion history? We have a wonderful library here in National Headquarters under the able supervision of
8
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Librarian Tom Hull. Our National Historian Harold Shindler is doing excellent work, but what is the condition in the Departments and the Posts? Certain of the Departments have excellent histories complete from 1919 to the
current year. Some have a rather good compilation of their history, and
there are others who have practically no chronological history, and many
Posts do not elect or appoint a Post Historian.
. This condition of affairs will continue to be the case until the Historian
is accorded the recognition, status and finances necessary to accomplish the
work.
We might ask the question—“Why concern ourselves with National, Department and Post history?” We must admit that in a practical way its value
is hard to define. It cannot be counted as are things mathematical or formulated as can be a chemical.
History is a recording of man and his works, good and bad. Ours is a
book of good works to be pondered after all of us now active have “gone
west.
You who are here came for the purpose of carrying on that good work
and in all likelihood, will pave the way for another important chapter for
“our book.”
You are in a position to render a valuable service to The American
Legion in your various Departments. Carry the message to your Department
Commanders, Department Executive Committeemen, District Commanders, and
other “working” Legionnaires, the necessity for support for those good, efficient and sincere Historians now so diligently doing their work, and secure
some good working Historians at all levels, and please let us cease the practice of making Historians of people whose qualifications are limited to being
“a good old boy,” or “a real nice lady.” Let us have Historians who can and
will function.
There is not a Post that has not performed acts of service to their community of which they are justly proud. There is not a Department that has
not undertaken numerous projects for the betterment of their state and fellow man. We have been fortunate in having many sincere and dedicated Historians who have seen and now are attempting to pass the torch of our performance to light the path of another generation, who are even now knocking
at our gates. It should be our proud duty to hold up before these younger
eyes “The tablet of performance” on which is graven our devotion to country,
our willingness to serve in both peace and war, and our undying devotion
to her aims and to her purposes.
When the book upon which we write is closed, and the angel of the record
has closed the clasp upon it, we hope to leave upon its shining pages, the
joy of service that we have felt and that these shining pages shall be a
light unto the feet of those who shall serve their God and Country, as has
been our privilege.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Hugh. And I say to
you, gentlemen, Patrick Henry once said in essence that the lamplight of
history is the only guide to the steps of the future. I would say that the making of history is important and glamorous, and the proper recording of it is
essential to guide us so that those who make history will not repeat the
mistakes of the past.
So I commend to you the works of the Historians and urge your support
of their work.
MEMORIAL RESOLUTIONS
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN E. ROY STONE: Mr. Commander, I
now ask that you call the Executive Committee to attention for the purpose
of Memorial Resolutions.
. . . The National Executive Committee stood at attention during the reading of the following resolutions by Subcommittee Chairman Stone:
Proceedings of Wednesday, May
if,
1966
9
Louis A. Johnson
(West Virginia)
WHEREAS, It has pleased Almighty God, the Great Commander, to
summon to His immortal legions our beloved comrade, Louis A. Johnson, who
served as National Executive Committeeman, Department Commander, and
National Commander in the year 1932-33. He was member, Vice President
and, at the time of his death, Director of the American Legion Endowment
Fund Corporation, having served on this Corporation since 1942.
WHEREAS, We humbly bow to the will of Divine Providence, while ever
cherishing in our hearts the memory of his distinguished service to our country and his outstanding contributions to American Legion comradeship:
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled on this May 4-5 in the year of our
Lord, nineteen hundred sixty-six, does mourn the passing of our distinguished Legionnaire, Louis A. Johnson; that we commend to all men his works,
and to God his spirit; and be it further
RESOLVED, That in token of our common grief, a copy of this resolution be presented to his family.
Farewell, dear Legionnaire—’twill not be long.
Thy work is done—now may peace rest with thee.
Thy kindly thoughts and deeds—they will live on.
This is not death—-’tis immortality.
Farewell, dear Legionnaire—the river winds and turns,
The cadence of thy song wafts near to me,
And now thou know’st the thing that all men learn;
There is no death—there’s immortality.
John J. Barnhardt
(North Carolina)
John J. Barnhardt, who served on several national committees, and since
1946 to the time of his death was a member of the Foreign Relations Commission.
L. Gooden Callaway
(Delaware)
L. Gooden Callaway, who served as Department Commander, as Department Service Officer since 1963, and as Vice Chairman of Area “B”, Rehabilitation Commission from 1965 until the time of his death.
Forrest G. Cooper
(Mississippi)
Forrest G. Cooper, who served on many Department Committees and National Commissions, as Department Commander, National Executive Committeeman and National Vice Commander.
Leland L. Day
(Colorado)
Leland L. Day, who served as Department Service Officer, Assistant Department Adjutant and at the time of his death was Department Adjutant.
Maj. Gen. George W. Fisher
(California)
Maj. Gen. George W. Fisher, who served on several commissions and committees and, at the time of his death, was a member of the National Security
Commission.
10
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Arthur Gabriel
(Oregon)
Arthur Gabriel, who at the time of his death was a member of the National Civil Defense Committee.
Delbert James Kenny
(Wisconsin)
Delbert James Kenny who served as Department Commander, National
Executive Committeeman and, at the time of his death was Vice Chairman
of the National Distinguished Guests Committee.
Edmond A. Littlefield
(Utah)
Edmond A. “Ted” Littlefield, who served as Department Commander,
National Executive Committeeman, on many commissions and committees, and
as National Vice Commander 1943-44.
W. Rex McCrosson
(New Jersey)
W. Rex McCrosson, who served as Department Commander, on many committees and commissions, both locally and nationally, and who at the time of
his death was a General Member, Area B, National Rehabilitation Commission.
Bert Florian Nowinski
(Indiana)
Bert Florian Nowinski, who served on several committees and commissions and at the time of his death was a member of the National Americanism Commission.
Edward M. White, Sr.
(Nevada)
Edward M. White, Sr., who served as Department Commander and at the
time of his death was a General Member, Area “E” National Child Welfare
Commission.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I now recognize Past National
Commander Griffith for the purpose of directing his remarks to the Memorial
Resolutions.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GRIFFITH:
Mr. Commander and
members of the National Executive Committee, I would like to take just a few
minutes of your time this morning to do honor and pay respect to an outstanding National Commander of The American Legion, and to an outstanding American citizen. I refer to Past National Commander Louis Johnson.
I knew him well as many of you also knew him. It was my privilege to
serve as Department Commander of Pennsylvania during his administration
as National Commander, along with Tom Miller who served that year as Commander of the Department of Delaware. Out of that relationship grew a
great friendship. I later served as his Executive Officer when he was the
Assistant Secretary of War. I served as his assistant when he was sent to
the Middle and Far East into India as a personal representative of the
President with the rank of Ambassador. And after the war, I served as the
Assistant Secretary of Defense when he was the Secretary, and so with this
association I believe I am qualified to say that I knew a man.
His death marks the passing of a truly great leader, a leader in his
home state, in his community, in his adopted state, and in the nation.
His record as a soldier, lawyer, legislator, diplomat, leader of veterans
and a policy maker for the Federal Government marked him as a great
American, and as a citizen of honor, and service. I valued his friendship
and his comradeship as I am sure those of you who knew him did.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
11
As National Commander of The American Legion Louis Johnson alerted
the American people to the growing threat from abroad, and he continued
this advice to the nation during his service as Assistant Secretary of War.
I am sure I can say without doubt that the casualty lists of World War II
and the length of that war would have been extended greatly if Louis Johnson had not had the foresight that he had.
The American Legion came first with him, above politics, above financial
gain or personal aggrandizement. Louis has gone to his final resting place,
but our nation must remain. For his great service The American Legion will
always perpetuate the memory of this distinguished Legionnaire.
He served long and well through tasks that were often very difficult,
and so I can say for all of us who loved him, farewell, Louis, there is a plan
far greater than we know, there is a landscape broader than the one we see.
There is a place where storm-tossed souls may go, some call it death, we call
it immortality. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman Tom Miller.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: National Commander James, fellow members of
the National Executive Committee and fellow Legionnaires, it has been my
sad privilege over the last year or so to take this rostrum to pay honor to
our departed leaders, Bill Stern, Louis Johnson, and James Ringley.
My first association with Louis Johnson was when we were members of
the National Executive Committee, he from West Virginia, and I from Delaware in the 1920s. As your Past National Commander Paul Griffith told
you, we both had the honor and distinction of being Department Commanders
in the year 1932 to 1933, and of course, we supported him in his successful
bid for election at the Portland Convention in 1932.
We had a particular association with Louis. With all due respect to the
splendid leaders of our organization that preceded him and have succeeded
him, in those days, when they had the national Distinguished Guests Dinner
at the National Convention, it was the province and the policy of the National Commander to invite to be seated with them at his table those of us
who were Department Commanders under his regime. And be it said to the
credit of Louis, and I am not detracting one bit from any of his predecessors
or successors, the tables of the 1933 class of the Department Commanders
had more guests than any other. The class of 1933 was a very distinctive
class under him.
In the succeeding years it was my privilege to not only know him, but
work in an official capacity that brought me to Washington. And that vacant
seat back there alongside of National Committeeman Bickel was where
Louis Johnson always sat. We were able to consult with him and he to consult with us. I can’t add any personal capacity more than Paul Griffith has
given you in homage to our great leader. He will be sorely missed not only
as a leader, but for me, as a great personal friend.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman L. O. Bickel.
MR. BICKEL, West Virginia: Commander James, members of this Executive Committee and guests, in 1954 when I was Department Commander
of West Virginia, I became acquainted with Louis Johnson the man. All
through the remaining years of his life when he was physically able, he gave
counsel and advice to us in The American Legion in West Virginia. And
I can truthfully say that Louis Johnson's interest in The American Legion
was well founded, and we looked upon him as a man who gave us that advice.
Many, many times he came to West Virginia and gave his aid financially
in The American Legion. I know that more than one Convention, when the
Convention would be short financially, Louis Johnson would pick up the tab,
and that is truly his spirit in The American Legion. And I can say that
all of the West Virginia people, Legionnaires have lost a great friend.
One thing that Louis Johnson was always proud of, and that was his
Department Commander from West Virginia. When we would go to Washington in respective years, regardless of whether it would be business with the
Legion or otherwise, Louis made it his business to show you around Washington. Thank you very much.
12
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Thank you, L. 0. I am sure
there are others that have deep feelings and thoughts in their minds this
morning. If any of you care later to have those brief feelings recorded in the
proceedings, you may do so.
I would simply say this, this man gave unlimited service and inspiration
to the organization he loved. This man gave incomparable service and devotion tp his country. The effect of that inspiration and service will be a glowing, living testimonial to his contribution to a better America. His absence
from us creates a void, but his memory will do much to fill it.
Gentlemen, I had hoped that this morning there would be three of Col.
Johnson’s fellow members of the first National Executive Committee present.
Two of them are here, the third one, Robert L. Moorhead, would have been
here. He is a young fellow, just 91 years old, but he suffered a fall this morning
a little while ago, and could not make it. But the other two members who
were a part of that original Committee and I believe these three are the
only three living ones at this time if my facts are correct are present in
the room, and I would like them to stand and take a bow on this solemn
occasion.
Tom Miller of Nevada, he was then of Delaware, and John J. Wicker,
Jr. of Virginia—would you gentlemen stand.
. , . Mr. Wicker and Mr. Miller stood and acknowledged their presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: It was mentioned that Col. Johnson had had a part in the Endowment Fund Corporation of The American
Legion. Present in this room this morning are certain members or directors
of that corporation. In a moment, I would ask them to stand and take a
bow, but before I do, I would like to officially call to the attention of this
Committee a recent and beautiful contribution that these gentlemen have personally made to The American Legion.
ENDOWMENT FUND MEETING ROOM
As you have moved back and forth down the third floor of this building,
you have seen a very, very beautiful room off to the right as you enter the
executive suite. This room as it now appears is the result of not only the
imagination and dreams of the members of this Corporation, but of their
specific individual and direct contribution, 100%, to make it possible. Any of
you who may have feared that the Chairman of the Finance Commission
may have been disturbed by this, your fears may be allayed. It cost the Legion not one penny. It is there because of the love and affection of the members of this Corporation, a contribution they have made. I think you should
know that.
At this time, I would like to ask the members of the Corporation, Harry
Colmery as the Chairman, to please stand and take a bow.
. . . Mr. Colmery and other members of the Endowment Corporation stood
and acknowledged their presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Harry, would you come forward,
please, if you would like a moment to address the group.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COLMERY: Mr. Commander and
gentlemen of the Executive Committee, before I comment on that which primarily moves me to rise, may I tell you that The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation Board of Directors and members gathered together
yesterday and adopted an appropriate memorial resolution in memory of Louis
Johnson.
On their behalf, I would not attempt following the eulogy paid by Tom
Miller, Paul Griffith and the Committeeman of West Virginia to repeat what
they have said. Of course, we knew him, and I knew him personally in that
great cornerstone of free society. The confidence and the exchange of views
and thoughts of his inquisitive mind, his dynamic leadership and his dedication not only to his country but to The American Legion and to the interests
of the veteran were 100%. We will miss him greatly, and we will always re-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
13
member his work in The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation,
and likewise The American Legion as such.
I am here only symbolic of The American Legion Endowment Fund
Corporation, its image and its members and Board of Directors. We got this
idea because sometimes our combinations were not too good, because we have
to devote ourselves with considerable dedication to the consideration of the
handling of this seven million, two hundred and some thousand dollar fund
which we have. We thought it would be a good idea first to provide a place
where we could meet in comfort, and then we got the idea also that while
we were doing it, maybe we should make something available likewise,
because we only use it at certain periods during the year, and we thought it
might be then better done than we might have otherwise done it, and make
it available for some other purposes, particularly for that of the National
Commander, because in certain instances, it would provide an excellent conference room and an excellent place to greet and meet and visit with people
interested in The American Legion as they come to Indianapolis.
I think, and this is not the time to do it, but since under the reorganization plan we no longer report to the National Executive Committee, there
may be a good deal of mystery about the Endowment Fund, but maybe on an
occasion, and this is not the day, as a change-over occurs in the membership
of this Committee, I am brazen enough to say that maybe we should report
to the Committee some of these days to let those of you who may not have
had the opportunity in the past to know about it, the origin and just what
we do, and why we do it presented to you. I am going to ask that privilege
one of these days before the National Executive Committee, because I think
it should be of current interest, and we should all be knowledgeable with
respect to what it is and what we do and why we do it.
I appreciate, Mr. Commander, your fine comment, and on behalf of the
members and the Board of Directors of the Endowment Fund Corporation
express to you our appreciation and our gratitude for your kindly compliments
which you have just made with respect to what we think is a fine contribution, the equipping and the establishing of this room on the third floor.
Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I direct to you and through you
to the members of the Corporation our thanks for this recent specific and
beautiful contribution, but more important, for the continued diligent work
that you perform on behalf of the organization. Thank you so much.
REPORT OF
THE FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
May 4-5, 1966
Albert V. LaBiche (Louisiana), Chairman
Pursuant to the provisions of Resolution No. 229, adopted by the Annual
National Convention of The American Legion in Portland, Oregon in August
1965, National Commander L. Eldon James appointed a 50th Anniversary
Committee in January 1966. Copy of Resolution No. 229 is attached, as is a
copy of the official roster of the committee members. Albert V. LaBiche,
Louisiana, was appointed Chairman; Donald E. Johnson, Iowa, Vice Chairman.
An Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee held its first
meeting in the Washington office of the National Headquarters at the time
of the Washington Conference on March 2 and 3, 1966. At that time a general
discussion was held concerning various projects, plans, and programs that
might be undertaken to appropriately commemorate the 50th anniversary of
Armistice Day, November 11, 1918, and the 50th anniversary of the founding
of The American Legion.
14
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
At that first meeting’ a number of initial decisions were made. Among
these was an agreement on the official dates of the 50th anniversary commemoration that will be observed. These are:
1. The 50th National Convention to be held in Milwaukee, Wisconsin in
1968.
2. Veterans’ Day, November 11, 1968 in Washington, D.C.
3. The 50th anniversary of the birthday of The American Legion—March
15-17, 1969.
4. The 50th anniversary of the St. Louis Caucus in May 1969.
5. The 50th anniversary of the First National Convention of The American Legion on Veterans’ Day, 1969.
It was decided to call on all Departments to appoint 50th Anniversary
Chairmen to work with the National Committee and to coordinate departmental and post participation in the 50th anniversary activities. This action
has been taken and a number of Department Chairmen have already been
appointed.
It was decided to suggest to the National Executive Committee that it hold
its regular meeting in May 1969 in St. Louis, Missouri, rather than Indianapolis, in connection with commemoration of the 50th anniversary of the St.
Louis caucus. A resolution to this effect has been prepared and presented
to the Resolutions Subcommittee, and will be presented following this report.
It was decided to recommend that a national observance of major proportions be held in Minneapolis on November 11, 1969 to commemorate the first
National Convention of The American Legion. It was also decided to ask the
President’s Advisory Committee on observance of Veterans’ Day, to designate Minneapolis as one of the regional centers for Veterans’ Day 1969
observance. A resolution to this effect has been prepared and is to be presented following this report.
It was decided that serious study and consideration should be given to
the advisability of employing outside public relations counsel to guide and
assist The American Legion in connection with observance of these most
important events.
A special subcommittee was appointed for this purpose and held a first
meeting in New York City in the office of The American Legion Magazine on
April 5 and 6, 1966. Chairman of the special subcommittee is Albert V. LaBiche, Louisiana. The special subcommittee met again in Indianapolis on
May 2 and 3 and received formal presentations from two major public relations firms. On the basis of these presentations, it was decided to submit
a firm recommendation to the National Executive Committee that the National Commander and National Adjutant be authorized to enter into a contract with the firm of Bozell and Jacobs, to retain that firm to guide and
assist The American Legion in connection with its 50th Anniversary observance. A resolution to that effect has been prepared and will be presented
following this report.
In its meeting in New York, the special subcommittee formalized the four
basic objectives The American Legion would seek to accomplish through its
50th Anniversary observance. These are:
1. The American Legion wishes to lead the nation in appropriate activities
commemorating the Armistice of November 11, 1918 and victory in World
War I.
2. The American Legion wishes to bring to the attention of the whole
American people the circumstances and events that led to the founding of
The American Legion and the significance of this fact within the perspective
of the historical moment in the life of the nation attending the close of
World War I.
3. The American Legion wishes to call to the attention of the American
people the record of achievements that have been accomplished by The American Legion during the fifty years since its founding, to emphasize the impact the organization has had upon the American society, and the extent of
its contribution to the national security and welfare.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
15
4. The American Legion wishes to set forth the objectives and the aims
that will motivate its programs and activities during the years ahead and to
illustrate the contribution it is intended these activities will make to the future
of our country.
A further meeting of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee was held in Indianapolis on May 2 and 3. At this time there was
further review of plans and preparations for observance of the 50th anniversary. These are many and varied, and it is felt that a more detailed report should be submitted at a later date as the Committee’s work takes more
definite form.
In conclusion, the Committee would report to the National Executive Committee that it has found vast enthusiasm within the ranks of The American
Legion for an appropriate observance of the organization’s 50th anniversary.
There is every hope that national participation from all segments of the
country can be arranged.
Representatives of the 50th Anniversary Committee have called upon the
National Finance Commission to discuss the matter of appropriation of national funds to assist the Committee to accomplish its work. The Finance
Commission was receptive to a recitation of initial plans and indicated that an
effort would be made to find necessary funds, contingent upon authority
and approval that may be extended by the National Executive Committee.
It is hoped that a full meeting of the 50th Anniversary Committee can
be called to be held at the time of the Washington, D. C. National Convention in August, 1966. At that time it is also contemplated that Department Chairmen will be invited to attend such a meeting at no expense to the
National Organization.
Respectfully submitted,
ALBERT V. LaBICHE, Chairman
“Creation of A Special Committee to Formulate Plans For Observance
of 50th Anniversary of The American Legion and Also the Entry of
United States Into First World War”
Resolution No. 229 (Submitted by: The Fiftieth Anniversary Committee).
WHEREAS, The year 1967 will mark the 50th anniversary of the entry
of the United States into the Great War, now known as World War I, and
The American Legion had its inception through the foresight of the participants of that war; and
WHEREAS, It is fitting and proper that we commemorate the Declaration
of War, the heroic deeds of our Armed Forces, and the Armistice that followed, by appropriate observances, and at the same time give recognition
to the 50th anniversary of the founding of The American Legion; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled
in Portland, Oregon, August 24-26, 1965, that the National Organization form
a special temporary committee to formulate plans for the observance of these
great dates in our history, and to disseminate such to all Posts in order
that suitable ceremonies may be arranged well in advance of the respective
anniversary date.
50TH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
(To serve until completion of planning and final report on commemoration.)
CHAIRMAN—-Albert V. LaBiche, 301 Baronne Street, New Orleans,
Louisiana 70112
VICE CHAIRMAN—Donald E. Johnson, Drawer A, West Branch, Iowa
52358
Alfred P. Chamie, 8480 Beverly Boulevard, Los Angeles, California
90048
William R. Egan, 304 West Prospect Avenue, Danville, California 94526
(Colorado)
16
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
C. D. DeLoaeh, 1109 Morningside Lane, Alexandria, Virginia 22308
(District of Columbia)
Frank A. Kelly, P. 0. Box 1363, Savannah, Georgia 31402
A. L. Starshak, 7221 South Luella Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60649
Robert E. Gates, 701 West Park Drive, Columbia City, Indiana 46725
Ray Murphy, 15671 Peach Hill Road, Saratoga, California 95070 (Iowa)
Harry W. Colmery, 138 Greenwood, Topeka, Kansas 66606
David Aronberg, P. O. Box 591, Ashland, Kentucky 41101
Frank L. Orfanello, 2 Shenandoah Street, Dorchester, Massachusetts
02124
Donald J. Smith, Route 3, French Road, St. Johns, Michigan 48879
Daniel F. Foley, P. O. Box 228, Wabasha, Minnesota 55981
Joseph A. Bernard, 5549 Pershing Avenue, St. Louis, Missouri 63112
Milton Carpenter, 1640 Grape, St. Louis, Missouri 63147
William E. Galbraith, RFD 1, Beemer, Nebraska 68716
Frank R. Schwengel, Artillery Lane, Scarsdale, New York 10584
Maurice Stember, 305 Hall of Records, 31 Chambers Street, New York,
New York 10007
The Rev. Alfred C. Thompson, 658 East 32nd Street, Brooklyn, New
York 11210
John E. Davis, 216 West Owens Avenue, Bismarck, North Dakota 58501
Hollis C. Hull, P. O. Box 63586, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73106
Robert H. Hazen, Franklin Building, S. W. 5th and Stark, Portland,
Oregon 97204
Paul H. Griffith, Suite 1010, Shoreham Building, Washington, D. C.
20005 (Pennsylvania)
Sam L. Latimer, Jr., 703 Barringer Building, Columbia, South Carolina
29201
Albert D. Brown, Jr., Ill West Laurel, Suite 223, San Antonio, Texas
78212
Clarence S. Campbell, 50 Garden Street, Barre, Vermont 35801
E. Ralph James, P. O. Box 38, Hampton, Virginia 23369
Emmett G. Lenihan, 1114 Norton Building, Seattle, Washington 98104
Bernard Strachota, 4370 Imperial Drive, Brookfield, Wisconsin 53005
HONORARY VICE CHAIRMEN
Paul R. Baldwin, National President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 1166 Whittier, Grosse Pointe Park, Michigan 48230
Gen. Lawrence H. Whiting, Past Natl. President, Society of American
Legion Founders, 1500 Lake Shore Dr., Chicago, Illinois 60611
Gale F. Johnston, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 3 Brentmoor Park, St. Louis, Missouri 63105
Frank R. Schwengel, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, Artillery Lane, Scarsdale, New York 10584
Alvin M. Owsley, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 1424 Davis Bldg., Dallas, Texas 75202
John J. Wicker, Jr., Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 706 Mutual Bldg., Richmond, Virginia 23219
Jerome F. Duggan, Past Natl. President, Society of American Legion
Founders, 705 Chestnut St., St. Louis, Missouri 63101
EXECUTIVE SECTION
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire (Chairman)
Donald E. Johnson, Iowa (Vice Chairman)
Alfred P. Chamie, California
William R. Egan, Colorado
C. D. DeLoaeh, District of Columbia
Daniel F. Foley, Minnesota
Joseph Bernard, Missouri
Milton Carpenter, Missouri
William E. Galbraith, Nebraska
Maurice Stember, New York
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
17
John E. Davis, North Dakota
Hollis Hull, Oklahoma
Robert Hazen, Oregon
Paul H. Griffith, Pennsylvania
E. Ralph James, Virginia
Bernard Strachota, Wisconsin
EX-OFFICIO MEMBERS
E. A. Blackmore, Wyoming
James F. O’Neil, New Hampshire
Churchill Williams (National Finance Comm. (Iowa))
Wilbur Walker, Virginia
AUXILIARY LIAISON
Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, National President, American Legion Auxiliary,
777 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 (Iowa)
Miss Doris Anderson, National Secretary, American Legion Auxiliary,
777 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 (Texas)
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: First of all, I would
like to move the adoption of the written report as corrected with the substitution of James O’Neil as Chairman of the Special Subcommittee.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard, Connecticut.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion is to adopt and it has
been seconded. Any comments?
Commander Johnson, would you like to address your remarks to the Committee?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: Yes. Thank you, Mr.
Commander. Members of the National Executive Committee and Chairman
LaBiche, the reason for the move to adopt the report I think to me is most
important, because if you vote affirmatively on the adoption of the report
you have then determined the objectives of The American Legion in carrying
out the resolution which you passed at the National Convention in Portland.
I think it is only proper that these objectives be clearly defined and clearly articulated so that the whole country may know the role that The American Legion has played in 50 years of service to God and Country.
It says in the report, and I call them to your attention specifically, that
The American Legion wishes to lead the nation in appropriate activities commemorating the Armistice of November 11, 1918 and victory in World War I;
Two, that The American Legion wishes to bring to the attention of all the
American people the circumstances and events that led to the founding of
The American Legion and the significance of this fact within the perspective of the historical movement in the life of the nation attending the
close of World War I.
Three, for once we are going to toot our own horn, The American Legion
wishes to call to the attention of the American people the records and achievements and accomplishments by our organization during these last 50 years.
I had often said from the podium and I sincerely believe it, that no other
organization in the United States has had such a profound impact upon the
social, economic and political life of this nation as has The American Legion.
And now we have the vehicle to tell the American people what we have done.
And this brings me to the fourth point then in the report and the fourth
objective.
That is that after we gather all of this information, after we bring it to
the American people and as we digest it ourselves, I think that we shall then
be able to determine what our aims will be in the years to come, and in the
decades ahead, determine the role of The American Legion.
Thus, gentlemen of this Committee, I urge you to adopt the report so
that we first of all specify the dates as the Chairman has articulated to
you, and secondly, to make the definition of the objectives of what we plan
to do in this area.
18
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Don.
Now, is there any further discussion on the motion to adopt the report?
Hearing none, are you ready for the question? Those in favor signify by
saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes have it and the report is adopted.
Mr. Stone.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY COMMITTEE
. .. Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Commemoration of Fiftieth Anniversary of First American Legion
National Convention in Minneapolis, Minnesota”
Resolution No. 15 (Submitted by: Special 50th Anniversary Committee.
(Subject to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the 50th Anniversary of The American Legion will occur in
the year 1969; and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention of The American Legion, meeting in Portland, Oregon in August 1965, directed that a special committee be appointed by the National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, such special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed,
and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies be
arranged in Minneapolis, Minnesota on November 11, 1969, commemorating at
such time both the Armistice ending the First World War, and the 50th Anniversary of the First Annual National Convention of The American Legion
held in the City of Minneapolis in November 1919; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this committee
concurs with such recommendation; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Executive Committee authorizes and directs that appropriate ceremonies and other activities be arranged for November 11, 1969 to commemorate at such time the two significant events referred
to above; and be it further
RESOLVED, that a communication be directed to the Administrator of
Veterans Affairs in his capacity as Chairman of the President’s coordinating committee for the observance of Veterans Day, requesting that committee
to designate Minneapolis, Minnesota as one of the regional locations for the
official national observance of Veterans Day 1969.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida, and adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: The next resolution is No. 14,
and, Mr. Commander, for the benefit of the Reporter who is taking the records of this meeting, may he show that the time of this first reading is now
10:50 A. M. May 4th. This is pursuant to Rule 8-A of this Committee. The
resolution reads as follows:
“50th Anniversary Observance of the Founding of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 14 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the year 1969 will be the 50th anniversary year of the founding of The American Legion, and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary, and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
19
WHEREAS, such a special 50th Anniversary Committee has been so appointed, and
WHEREAS, an Executive Section of said 50th Anniversary Committee
has held meetings on March 2 and 3, and May 2 and 3, and
WHEREAS, it is the consensus of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee that it would be to the best interests of The American
Legion to retain the services of a public relations firm to guide and assist
The American Legion with its 50th anniversary observance, and
WHEREAS, the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee
has considered presentations from public relations firms and has a specific
recommendation for the employment of such firm at an agreed cost in fees,
out-of-pocket expenses, and certain other additional costs, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana on May 4 and 5, 1966, that the National
Commander and the National Adjutant are hereby authorized and directed to
negotiate, with the guidance and approval of The American Legion Special
50th Anniversary Committee, and to execute a contract with the public relations and advertising firm of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc., said contract to extend over a period to conclude approximately December 31, 1969, with necessary stipulations for cancellation by either party in accordance with conditions of sound business practice, and be it further
RESOLVED that in consideration of services to be rendered by Bozell
and Jacobs, Inc. which services are to be set forth in all necessary detail in
said contract, The American Legion will agree to pay to the firm of Bozell
and Jacobs, Inc. agency fees not to exceed $250,000.00 during the life of said
contract, and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall also provide for reimbursement to
representatives of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. for out-of-pocket expenses not to
exceed $44,000.00 specifically required by The American Legion and incurred
in the service of The American Legion, said expenses to be itemized and
submitted at regular intervals for audit and prior approval by the National
Adjutant and National Treasurer of The American Legion prior to payment,
and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall further provide that the firm of
Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. will submit to The American Legion at regular intervals complete and itemized statements justifying all agency fees, out-ofpocket expenses, and any other charges to be provided for in said contract,
and be it further
RESOLVED that the National Executive Committee does authorize and
direct the 50th Anniversary Committee to determine and recommend such other sum or sums that may be necessary, not to exceed $50,000.00, in connection with the 50th anniversary observance to be used for projects and programs requiring material expenditures such as materials for Post and Departmental participation, radio, TV, film, newspaper, and all other types of
suitable publicity, and that such recommendation or recommendations be submitted to the National Executive Committee as soon as possible for its consideration, and be it further
RESOLVED that the 50th Anniversary Committee is charged by the National Executive Committee to exercise close supervision and guidance of all
activities involving the 50th anniversary observance and the expenditures of
American Legion monies therefor, with reports at regular intervals to the
National Executive Committee and to the Finance Commission, and be it
further
RESOLVED that the National Finance Commission is requested to provide for necessary funds for the expenses of the 50th Anniversary Committee to enable it to fulfill the charge herein set forth, and be it further
RESOLVED that prior to the completion of the contract authorized herein, such contract shall have the approval as to form from the National Judge
Advocate.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee shall move
that this matter be approved, and I shall wait to make the official motion at
20
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
the appropriate time that the Commander might set upon the agenda for four
hours, pursuant to the four-hour rule of 8-A.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, under Rule 8-A this
matter being one that affects fiscal policy must be considered under two
readings and the second must be at least four hours after the first.
Now in order for this to be proper and to be handled according to the
rules, it is required that you have a written copy of this resolution on your
desk. I would like to first make an inquiry to the body, is there any member
of the Committee present in this room who does not have a copy, a written
copy of the resolution on his desk?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: The resolution separately?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The resolution from the digest,
Resolution No. 14.
MR. McKINLEY: All right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let the record show that upon inquiry there was no report of absence from any desk, so we will assume that
each of you have a copy in accordance with the rule 8-A.
MR. LOUNSBERRY (Iowa): Mr. Commander, I move you that this resolution be made a special order of business before this Committee at 3:30
this afternoon.
... The motion was seconded by Mr. Grauberger, Colorado, and adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we have a
companion resolution which is No. 17 which is also subject to Rule 8-A of this
body, and I ask that the records show that the reading of this resolution took
place at 11:00 A. M.
“Commemoration of 50th Anniversary of St. Louis, Missouri, Caucus
of The American Legion.”
Resolution No. 17 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, The year 1969 will be the 50th Anniversary year of the
founding of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, Such a special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed, and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies
be arranged in St. Louis, Missouri in May 1969 in commemoration of the
St. Louis Caucus of May 1919; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed fitting and proper that the National Executive
Committee should hold its constitutionally ordained meeting in May 1969 in
the city of the founding of this organization; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this Committee, for reasons good and proper, shall hold its regular meeting in May
1969 in the City of St. Louis, Missouri; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Adjutant is hereby directed to make the
necessary arrangements, and to communicate to the National Finance Commission an estimate of expenses involved so that necessary funds for this
purpose may be provided; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this Committee shall cooperate in every way possible
with the 50th Anniversary Committee in connection with suitable ceremonies
and other activities honoring the City of St. Louis and commemorating the
founding of The American Legion in May 1919.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, the record
shows that it is now three minutes past 11:00 A. M. Your Committee shall
move to have this resolution approved after the four hours wait, and I ask
that this be included, sir, in a special order of business at 3:30 P. M.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
21
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Did you so move?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE : I will make that motion.
. . . The motion was seconded by Past National Commander Quinn and
adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE:
This completes the reading
of the resolutions of the 50th Anniversary Committee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much, Roy.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL PUBLIC RELATIONS COMMISSION
C. D. DeLoach (District of Columbia), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN DE LOACH: Mr. Commander, members of
the National Executive Committee and fellow Legionnaires. This is the report
on Public Relations. This is not a report asking for money. My report is to
be brief.
The National Public Relations Commission has handled considerable work
within the past two days.
The American Legion National Public Relations Commission met in Room
106, National Headquarters, The American Legion, Indianapolis, Indiana, on
May 2 and 3. Chairman C. D. DeLoach called the meeting to order. The
following members were authorized and present:
C. D. DeLoach, Chairman (District of Columbia)
Sam L. Latimer, Jr.. Vice Chairman (South Carolina)
Madison B. Graves (Nevada)
Louis J. Greco (Pennsylvania)
Arthur McDowell (Indiana)
A1 Weinberg (California)
Paul R. Greenaway (Florida)
Lem W. Houston (Virginia)
Phillip A. Thomas (Iowa)
Frank A. Kelly (Georgia)
Ward Husted (Wyoming)
Harold A. Cummins (Illinois)
NEC Liaison: Donald E. Johnson, Chairman (Iowa)
Also in attendance:
Duane T. Brigstock (Michigan)
Sexson Humphreys (Italy)
We discussed and made plans regarding the future handling of internal
public relations in The American Legion. We made plans to make even better
improvements in the American Legion News Service. We chose three worthy
and notable recipients of the Fourth Estate Award to be given at this
year’s National Convention in Washington, D. C.
We covered in its entirety the successes of the Public Relations at this
year’s Annual Commander’s Conference in Washington, D. C. The luncheon
honoring Leonard H. Goldenson, President, American Broadcasting Company
has not only brought The American Legion added prestige, but also established
for us a new and strong ally in the communications media. Now this conference saw once again the value of setting up TV and radio programs with
an ever-increasing number of Senators and Representatives from your home
states.
But, gentlemen, with your permission, I would like to devote the rest of
my brief allotted time to one topic, that of “The American Legion Story.”
This project is almost completed. The manuscript is in the hands of the publisher. Here is the front cover of it. I am holding up a sample version of it
which you will be seeing across America within just a few weeks from now.
As a matter of fact, the issuance date of our History, “The American Legion Story,” will be on August 15th, 1966 in ample time for our National
Convention.
22
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
The sale price for non-Legionnaires will be $4.95; the Legionnaires, a
reduced price of $3.95, and if you buy in bulk form or 500 or more we will
have further reductions.
“The American Legion Story” will be told in over five hundred exciting
pages, factually based pages upon our history. We are now rapidly completing
the final reading of the galley proofs.
A number of the distinguished and history steeped members, I might say,
of this Executive Committee, the National Executive Committee, are assisting
us in this regard. I will tell you very frankly, we are very proud of this book.
The National Public Relations Commission has worked long and hard and
at great personal sacrifice to have your story told in the best manner possible, and I might say at this moment, we are very proud, very proud to tell
the story of such patriotic giants as Louis Johnson who you have honored in
great memorial tribute here today, and others, Tom Miller, Bill McKinley,
Harry Colmery, John Wicker, and many, many others which are told throughout this exciting factual history of The American Legion, “The American
Legion Story.”
Let me put this on the record, everyone’s name could not be brought out
prominently; everyone’s pet incident could not be mentioned in the interests
of space. There may be a few hurt feelings, but in the glory of our organization and in the manner in which you have played a great part, and many
of you have played a great part in establishing the glory of this organization,
it is demonstrated throughout.
Let me at this time take sixty seconds of your time to read you the foreword of this book:
“The American Legion is truly an American institution, in origin, purpose and operation. Born from America’s struggle to maintain liberty in
World War I, The American Legion has become an inextricable part of the
American story. Every patriotic citizen, from Anchorage to Miami, from
Honolulu to Boston, salutes the brave men and women of the Legion—men
and women whose exploits in war and peace have placed their fellow countrymen eternally in their debt.
“In addition, Legionnaires have taken America’s youth to heart. Highly
effective youth programs, such as Boys State and Nation, the National High
School Oratorical Contest, American Legion Baseball, have touched the lives
of thousands of our boys and girls. Here is an affirmation of good citizenship, a belief that every person in a free society has not only rights and
privileges but also duties and responsibilities. Many of our national leaders
today have been influenced by the positive Americanism of The American
Legion.
“Above all, The American Legion is a symbol for other citizens—a symbol
meaning faith in liberty. Americans see in The American Legion an organization of devoted men and women, working for country above self, for service
to others over selfish, partisan and narrow interests. This is an influence
which is felt not only nationally, but in every state, city, town and hamlet
of these United States.
“ ‘The American Legion History’ by Raymond Moley, Jr., is an excellent
book. It sets forth, with skill and precision, the history of this great organization. American citizens in all walks of life should know more about The
American Legion. To read Mr. Moley’s interesting narrative is to relive the
history of our nation in this mid-twentieth century.”
Signed, J. Edgar Hoover.
Gentlemen, the remainder of this book, I assure you, is equally as stirring
and factually correct as the foreword I have just read to you.
Now to just take 15 more seconds of our report, I turn to another topic
briefly. I understand as Chief of Investigations for the FBI, that the FBI
is having slight difficulty, only slight, I remind you, in establishing the
identity of certain fugitives and distinguished world travelers from the Sovereign State of Virginia. The FBI is constantly on the lookout to solve this
problem, and we wish at this time to personally brand and identify one of
the fastest moving and distinguished fugitives of all American history, the
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
23
man from Hampton, “El” James. Towards this purpose, the National
Public Relations Commission takes pride in presenting Commander “El” a
pair of specially made cuff links made from his own distinctive fingerprints.
He will be forevermore an easy target of identity.
... At this time Mr. DeLoach presented cuff links to National Commander
James.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I might say that I am grateful
that this imprint is from fingerprints rather than from noses, because if the
second were true, I am afraid the cuff links would be so large they would
be a burden to carry.
In addition to the joy, they will be a constant reminder not only of the
close friendship and wonderful working relationship with your part of the
organization, but a constant reminder of a great arm of our Government so
important at this time. Thank you.
C. D. DE LOACH: Mr. Commander, that completes my report, thank you
very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
William C. Doyle (New Jersey), Chairman
The following members of the National Security Commission and Committees met in the fourth floor auditorium of the Department of Indiana
Headquarters May 2-3, 1966:
William C. Doyle, New Jersey, Chairman
Hugh W. Overton, Alabama, NEC Liaison Chairman
John E. Davis, North Dakota, Vice Chairman
Roseoe Turner, Indiana
E. Ralph Janies, Virginia
Norman Lyons, California
Charles Gibbons, Illinois
Les Lam, Virginia
Elmer Kuhlmann, Missouri
Stacey Garner, Tennessee
Ralph Watkins, Arizona, NEC
Earnest N. Schmit, North Dakota
William A. Lindsay, Montana, NEC
Roseoe Morse, California
Granville S. Ridley, Tennessee
Joseph Caracci, Illinois
Clifford Cowan, New York
Charles Lugar, Missouri
Alexander N. Branch, Virginia
Robert H. Bush, Iowa
Frank R. Kossa, Indiana
Leon Myers, Georgia
James R. Wilson, Pennsylvania, Director
The importance of the widening struggle in Viet Nam in relation to Communism’s present and future plans has been clear to The American Legion.
Our policies and programs have constantly warned that Viet Nam is the testing ground for so-called “wars of liberation” which, if successful, will be
intensified in every now free country in the world. The ultimate objective
would be world domination; the oft stated goal of international atheistic
Communism.
The National Security Commission took a critical view of the manner in
which the war in Viet Nam is being waged. Over-control of our fighting men
has placed serious restraints on their ability to fight to win. We firmly
believe if our forces, ever increasing in numbers, are to remain committed
in Viet Nam, they should be directed toward military victory. This, in turn,
should provide a more promising basis for discussions leading to peace in
that beleaguered nation.
24
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Contrary to the opinion of groups opposing our nation’s participation in
Viet Nam, The American Legion does not view the conflict there as a civil
war. The aggression was and is clearly Communist inspired, initiated and
supported.
Wars are never pleasant, and mounting casualty lists are a source of
heartache, yet sacrifice is the continuing price free men pay to halt the ambitions of evil men.
We commend the men and women of our Armed Forces for carrying out
their assignments around the world, especially in Viet Nam. Thank God
that the overwhelming majority of young Americans are accepting the responsibilities of citizenship by entering the Armed Forces without fanfare.
Their conduct, as contrasted to the draft dodging, card burning characters
who defile both flag and country, warrants our heartfelt thanks and appreciation.
The truly magnificent performance of elements of the Air National
Guard’s Troop Carrier Command, in support of our troops in Viet Nam, is a
matter of record. It is puzzling indeed and difficult to equate their recent
accomplishments with the decision to deactivate these three Heavy Transport
units and eight squadrons of Air Force Reserve Troop Carriers. From all indications, no diminution of need has occurred or appears in the offing to
justify such action and we are opposed to it.
The National Security Commission reiterated its support for the development and deployment at the earliest possible date of the anti-missile system,
an advanced manned strategic bomber to replace the B-52’s and B-58’s
being phased out of our Air Force. In testimony presented to the House Appropriations Committee on the 1967 Defense Appropriations last week The
American Legion spokesman, in urging the development of these vital weapon
systems, said:
“No one will question the fact that a military budget approaching $60
billion is large. Yet for a rich nation with a gross national product near
$700 billion annually, needed weapon systems which could provide an added
margin of safety and security should not be rejected or deferred by virtue of
cost alone. Evidence seems to indicate, however, that the contrary is true,
which recalls to mind the words of Sir Winston Churchill:
‘“We shall not fail or falter; we shall not weaken or tire. Neither the
sudden shock of battle nor the long-drawn trials of vigilance and exertion will
wear us down. Give us the tools and we will finish the job.’ ”
We feel this same admonition applies “across the board” to ammunition,
training, equipment and whatever other requirements our servicemen need
to fulfill their assigned mission, particularly in Viet Nam.
The American Legion is of the firm opinion that this is not a time to
weaken our defense in the name and for the sake of economy. If trim we
must, let it be in non-defense spending where the need does not relate itself
directly to the present and future security of our nation.
. . . National Vice Commander Choppin assumed the chair.
MR. DOYLE : Mr. Commander, that ends my report.
. . . The portion of the report in regard to resolutions is as follows:
Approved
Resolution No. 3—“Oppose the closing of the United States Armory in
Springfield, Massachusetts.”
Resolution No. 4—“Commending General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of
Selective Service System.”
Resolution No. 5-—“Name next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier for the late Fleet
Admiral Chester W. Nimitz.”
Resolution No. 9—“Support passage of S.2351 to protect harassment of
families of servicemen in Viet Nam.”
Resolution No. 13—“Support legislation proposed by Department of Defense and the Bolte Committee to provide uniformity for improvement of
career opportunities in the military services.”
Proceedings of Wednesday, May h, 1966
25
Resolution No. 21—“Reserve Training.”
Resolution No. 22—“Defense Department Policy in Viet Nam.”
Register No. 1221 (Wisconsin)—“Commending Men Who Accept Their
Obligations in the Armed Forces by Enlistment or Call of Draft.” Approved
in principle.
Referred
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts)—“Bestow Posthumously the Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John F. Kennedy.” Approved
in principle but not for Medal of Honor. Referred to Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonies Committee with Recommendation that he be considered for American Legion’s Distinguished Service Medal.
Held For Further Study
Register No. 1097 (Massachusetts)—“Armed Services Retirement Policies.”
Resolutions 364, 366 and 525 are being held for further study by the Promotions Subcommittee.
Resolutions 87 (Massachusetts), 193 (Nevada), 264 (Georgia), 300 (Tennessee), 365 (Maryland), 472 (New York), and 524 (Virginia)—“Manpower
Procurement for Armed Forces.” Held for further study by the Manpower
Subcommittee.
Rejected
Register No. 1229 (New York); Register No. 1250 (Pennsylvania)—“Destruction of Selective Service Draft Cards.” Rejected as moot as law (PL
89-152 has been passed providing penalties for destruction of draft cards).
Register No. 1222 (Ohio)—“Realignment of Army Reserve Components
Opposed.” Resolution No. 587 adopted by the 1965 Portland National Convention is substantially same as this resolution.
Register No. 1164 (New Jersey)—“20th Anniversary Observance of Raising the Stars and Stripes on Mt. Suribachi (Iwo Jima), February 1965.”
Received too late for consideration other than by the May 1965 meetings of
NEC which followed 20th Anniversary celebration. The American Legion was,
however, represented by four members of Washington Office at ceremonies
held by Marine Corps on this anniversary in 1965.
Register No. 1153 (New Jersey)—“Misuse of Armed Services Ribbons and
Medals.” Rejected as moot by virtue of adoption of Resolutions 390 and 427
at the Dallas National Convention in 1964.
Register No. 1251 (Pennsylvania)—“Asking Selective Service System to
Provide Best Transportation possible for men being sent for Physical Examination and Induction.”
ADVANCE REPORT OF
THE NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
The National Security Commission has met only once since the Fall, 1965
meeting of the National Executive Committee. This was in Washington, D. C.,
March 1, 2, and 3, 1966.
There was, however, a very small meeting of a Subcommittee on Manpower on Sunday and Monday, February 27 and 28, 1966. The Committee,
appointed from among the membership of the National Security Commission
plus' two Past National Commanders as consultants, was to determine the
present attitude of Congress, the Selective Service System and the Armed
Forces on (1) Universal Military Training and (2) Extension of Selective
Service, which expires in July of next year.
26
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
During its two day meeting the Committee, comprised of Granville S.
Ridley, Chairman, Emmett G. Lenihan and Henry C. Parke; members and Past
National Commanders S. Perry Brown and Erie Cocke, Jr., met with General
Lewis B. Hershey, Director, Selective Service System; Senator John Stennis,
Senate Armed Services Committee; Congressman Leslie Arends, Congressman
Charles E. Bennett, House Armed Services Committee; and representatives
of Assistant Secretary of Defense (Manpower) Thomas D. Morris; General
J. B. Lampart and General Jefferson Irvine.
To the National Security Commission during its business session Thursday, March 3rd, Chairman Ridley reported these principal points:
1. That contacts with Defense, Congress and Selective Service had alerted
them to American Legion interest and activity in manpower problems
generally.
2. Ascertained through meetings with National President Opal Glynn that
the American Legion Auxiliary would lend its support if a favorable
climate of opinion on Universal Military Training was established.
3. The American Legion should support no less than a four (4) year extension of Selective Service.
4. Urged the continuance of the Committee in order to fulfill its assigned
mission.
NOTE: This recommendation No. 4 was approved by the National
Security Commission.
The importance of airpower, the state of America’s Merchant Marine,
Viet Nam and other vital aspects of our national defense were discussed during the 3-day meetings of the National Security Commission in Washington.
Among the speakers were some of America’s foremost spokesmen from the
military, Congress, government and the private sector.
On March 1, members of the National Security Commission journeyed to
the Industrial College of the Armed Forces, Fort McNair, Washington, D. C.
Lt General August Schomburg, Commandant, and members of his staff were
host to more than 100 members of the National Security Commission and
Committees headed by Chairman William C. Doyle, New Jersey, and Vice
Chairman John E. Davis, North Dakota. The all day session included briefings on military forces of the principal world powers, the Far East and
geopolitics.
Highlighting the second day was an hour long discussion of U. S. airpower,
missiles and nuclear weapons by General Thomas S. Power, USAF, recently
retired Commander of the Strategic Air Command and Personal Representative of the National Commander on the National Security Commission. Representing the Armed Forces were: Admiral Horacio R. Rivero, Jr., USN, Vice
Chief of Naval Operations; LT. General Hewitt T. Wheless, Assistant Vice
Chief of Staff, U. S. Air Force and LT. General John L. Throckmorton, former
Deputy Commander-in Chief, U. S. Forces in Viet Nam. Other speakers included: Congressman Melvin R. Laird (Wisconsin) a ranking member of the
House Appropriations Committee; Dr. James D. Atkinson, Associate Professor of Government at Georgetown University, and John C. Broger, Director of
Armed Forces Information and Education for the Department of Defense.
On March 3rd, civil defense to space exploration was covered by such
high ranking government officials as: Franklin B. Dryden, Acting Director,
Office of Emergency Planning; Congressman Edward A. Garmatz (Maryland), Chairman of the House Committee on Merchant Marine & Fisheries;
and Milton Rosen, Senior Scientist to the Deputy Associate Administrator for
Defense Affairs, National Space Agency.
The closing session of the Legion’s Security Commission meetings heard
a free and open discussion on Military Manpower and Reserve Forces. Top
military experts on the Reserve Components included Brig. Gen. Jefferson
Irvine, USA, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs;
Brig. Gen. Thomas A. Kenan, USA, Deputy Chief, Office of Reserve Components, USA, Major General James F. Cantwell, President, National Guard
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
27
Association, and Admiral Jackson, representing the Reserve Officers Association.
During the business session Thursday afternoon the Commission was privileged to receive an excellent briefing as to why the Springfield Armory, Massachusetts should not be closed by Charles V. Ryan, Jr., Mayor, Henry T
Downey, Consultant and James Massa.
Reports were also received from Granville S. Ridley, Chairman of the
Committee on Manpower and Joseph Hodges, Chairman of the Committee on
Promotions. These two ad hoc committees were appointed at the October
Meetings in Indianapolis.
The National Security Commission considered 12 resolutions. The action
which it will recommend to the National Executive Committee on these resolutions is appended to this report.
RESOLUTIONS CONSIDERED BY THE NATIONAL SECURITY
COMMISSION-COMMITTEES DURING THE WASHINGTON
CONFERENCE, March 1-3, 1966
Approved
Unnumbered Resolution—“Commend Lt. General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service System.”
Unnumbered Resolution—“Next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier be Named for
the late Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz.”
Unnumbered Resolution—“Support Legislation Incorporating Bolte Proposals.”
Register No. 1221 (Wisconsin)—“Commending Men Who Accept Their
Obligations in the Armed Forces by Enlistment or Call of Draft.” Approved
m principle for incorporation in report of National Security Commission
to May 1966 NEC.
Unnumbered Resolution—“Springfield Armory.” Approved in principle.
Incorporate in Statement of Policy, NSC Report to May NEC.
Referred
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts)—“Bestow Posthumously the Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John F. Kennedy.” Approved
in principle but not for Medal of Honor. Referred to Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonies Committee with recommendation that he be considered for American Legion’s Distinguished Service Medal.
Held For Further Study
Register No. 1097 (Massachusetts)'—“Armed Services Retirement Policies.” Resolutions 364, 366 and 525 are being held for further study by the
Promotions Subcommittee.
Resolutions 87 (Massachusetts), 193 (Nevada), 264 (Georgia), 300 (Tennessee), 365 (Maryland), 472 (New York) and 524 (Virginia). “Manpower
Procurement for Armed Forces.” Held for further study by the Manpower
Subcommittee.
Rejected
Register No. 1229 (New York)—“Destruction of Selective Service Draft
Cards.” Rejected as moot as law (PL 89-152) has been passed providing
penalties for destruction of draft cards.
Register No. 1222 (Ohio)—-“Realignment of Army Reserve Components
Opposed.” Resolution 587 adopted by the 1965 Portland National Convention
is substantially same as this resolution.
Register No. 1164 (New Jersey)—“20th Anniversary Observance of Raising the Stars and Stripes on Mt. Suribachi (Iwo Jima), February 1965.”
Received too late for consideration other than by the May 1965 meetings
of NEC which followed 20th Anniversary celebration. The American Legion
was, however, represented by four members of Washington Office at ceremonies held by Marine Corps on this anniversary in 1965.
28
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Register No. 1153 (New Jersey)—“Misuse of Armed Services
Medals.” Rejected as moot by virtue of adoption of Resolutions
at the Dallas National Convention in 1964.
Upon motion by Mr. Overton, Alabama, seconded by Mr.
Carolina, the report was received and filed.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Mr. Stone,
any resolutions?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
Ribbons and
390 and 427
Stone, South
do you have
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL SECURITY COMMISSION
. . . Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions
which were unanimously adopted as amended:
“Oppose the Closing of the United States Armory in Springfield,
Massachusetts”
Resolution No. 3 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense on November 19, 1964 ordered
the U. S. Armory, Springfield, Massachusetts “phased out” as an economy
measure, and
WHEREAS, The personnel of said Armory disputed this economy move,
providing evidence that this was not an economical move, and
WHEREAS, Booz, Allen and Hamilton Company, private consultants hired
to investigate the Armory problem, substantiated Armory figures showing
said Armory to be equal to or more efficient than outside contractors, and
WHEREAS, Booz, Allen & Hamilton Company has upon consultation
with Cyrus R. Vance, Assistant Secretary of Defense, recommended not only
to close the Springfield Armory but to adopt a new philosophy in Department of Defense policy spelling the doom of the entire arsenal system of our
government, in contradiction of the study submitted by the U. S. Army
Material Command upon the request of Army Chief of Staff, dated December
18, 1964, and
WHEREAS, Outside contractors have repeatedly refused to bid on vital
material needed in Viet Nam because of quantity size of orders not assuring
them of substantial profits, the burden of producing same falling back on
Springfield Armory, and
WHEREAS, Springfield Armory has produced weapons of outstanding
quality at economical cost (of comparable guns manufactured by Springfield
Armory and outside contractor’s, errors found in guns were 85% outside
contractor’s—15% Springfield Armory); now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that we
oppose the closing of the United States Armory, Springfield, Massachusetts,
said Armory being the only arsenal set up for Research, Development, Procurement and Pilot Line production of small arms vitally needed in Viet Nam.
“Commending General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service
System”
Resolution No. 4 (Submitted by:
National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, The United States of America is involved in a war in Viet
Nam to prevent Communist imperialism over-running Asia and the Far East
and in line with its long-standing policy of supporting the forces of freedom
over the forces of Communism, and
’
WHEREAS, The American Legion at all times espouses “peace and understanding” among people as well as nations but at the same time wholeheartedly supports our government and our Armed Forces in Viet Nam; now,
therefore, be it
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
29
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that The
American Legion congratulate General Lewis B. Hershey, Director of Selective Service, for his outstanding and faithful administration of selective service in his contributions to our nation in providing the needed manpower for
our Armed Forces; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to General
Hershey.
“Name Next Nuclear Aircraft Carrier for the Late Fleet Admiral
Chester W. Nimitz”
Resolution No. 5 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz assumed the responsibility
as Commander-in-Chief of the Pacific Fleet following the attack on Pearl
Harbor in 1941, and
WHEREAS, He assumed command at a time when there was a grave
shortage of men, ships, planes and supplies yet carried on defensive warfare
which eventually enabled American forces to halt the Japanese advance, and
WHEREAS, Through his brilliant leadership and outstanding skill as a
strategist shifted the Pacific war from a defensive to offensive operation
molding the world’s greatest naval fleet, and
WHEREAS, He lead this heroic armada to decisive victories in sea warfare in all areas of the Pacific Theater, which contributed much toward the
ultimate surrender of Japan, and
WHEREAS, The late Fleet Admiral Chester W. Nimitz had long been a
close friend of The American Legion and in 1945 received its Distinguished
Service Medal in recognition of his outstanding service to the United States,
and
WHEREAS, A nuclear powered aircraft carrier is to be built as part of
the 1966-67 fleet construction program of the U. S. Navy, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, in Indianapolis, Indiana, that the
Secretary of the Navy and the Secretary of Defense be requested to name
the next nuclear powered aircraft carrier, “THE ADMIRAL CHESTER W.
NIMITZ,” as a lasting tribute to this naval officer who rendered the
highest possible service to his nation in peace and war.
“Support Passage of S. 2351 to Protect Harassment of Families of
Servicemen in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 9 (Submitted by: National Security Commission. (Pursuant to Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, There has been an outbreak of vicious, outrageous telephone
calls harassing and threatening widows and relatives of servicemen killed in
Viet Nam, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization comprised exclusively of veterans who served during wartime and, therefore, have a deep understanding of the effect of harassment on the families of servicemen, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion wholeheartedly supports the American
position in Viet Nam to curtail the spread of Communism throughout the
“Free World,” and
WHEREAS, There is presently a Bill (S-2351) before the Congress designed to protect the morale and efficiency of members of the Armed Forces
by making it a federal offense for anyone to make threats or harass members
of the Armed Forces, their wives, widows or families; Now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that
The American Legion support S-2351 and urge its immediate passage by the
Congress.
30
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
“Support Legislation Proposed by Department of Defense and the
Bolte Committee to Provide Uniformity for Improvement of Career
Opportunities in the Military Services”
Resolution No. 13 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, different policies prevail in the armed services governing the
appointment, promotion, separation and retirement of military officers in the
defense establishment due to the divergence of the separate laws affecting
officer status; and
WHEREAS, such laws result in serious personal career inequities and in
differing rates of career progression among the military services; and
WHEREAS, proper officer personnel administration requires that such
laws be brought into uniformity and that qualified officers be fairly distributed by grade, age and service in each of the service departments; and
WHEREAS, such disparities among officer career opportunities within the
services should be eliminated so that they may offer more attractive career
features and assist in the procurement of qualified and capable officers necessary to the security of the nation; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in meeting assembled May 4-5, 1966, at Indianapolis, Indiana, that we
reiterate our support of the principles incorporated in the so-called Bolte
proposals, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That The American Legion offer supporting
testimony in any hearings on the revised Bolte legislation when it is considered by committees of the current Congress.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This has the approval of your
Legislative Commission, your Committee approves and I move adoption of the
resolution.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: In seconding that motion, I would like to ask
the Chairman to suggest what the Bolte legislation is. I know we were considering this before the Legislative Commission yesterday afternoon but we
were wholly in the dark about who Bolte refers to and what he is or who
he is.
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Tom, what you are asking is incorporated in the preamble of the resolution. Bolte is the former Chief of
Staff of the United States Army, retired, who originally proposed this bill
many years ago actually in the Congress when he was in the service, and
because of courtesy to him, his name was put on the resolution. Actually it
makes the uniformity of promotion and career opportunities in the service.
One outstanding inequity for instance is the fact that regular Generals are
in the Army, and one outstanding example, they are authorized in the Army
and Air Force, but they are not authorized in the Navy. For instance, a
Commodore in the equivalent rank in the one area to the same rank of the
Army and Air Force is only permitted in war time in the Navy. But actually
the bill brings more uniformity to promotion programs in all three of the
services as well as the career incentive and career programs, bringing them
up to a higher level so there is not one promotion regulation for time and
grade qualifications in the Air Force, different from that in the Army, which
again would be different than that of the Navy.
Actually, it is a uniform career program for the services.
MR. MILLER: One other question, and I am in agreement with what
the Chairman just said, if you remember, we would like to have a set of
proper names designating legislation like the Easton Bill or the Feighan Bill,
and we would like to know the House and Senate number of these, of this
legislation. Do you have it available? Does Jimmy Wilson have it?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: I don’t believe we have it here.
MR. MILLER: There must be someone who does.
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Jimmy says there is a series of
bills which will be instituted, Tom, on this same thing. The Bolte Bill was
the one that we originally decided was the one best for the services.
The number of the Bill I don’t know. We will get it for you.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
31
MR. MILLER: Has it been introduced in the 89th Congress?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Yes.
MR. MILLER: I don’t want to be meticulous, but having been mixed up
in legislative business for a great number of years and having been connected with our Legislative Commission in our meetings here, when they had
the names of Congressmen and Senators, I would respectfully suggest that
we be let in on the military secret as to what the number is of the Senate
or the number of the House.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Chairman and Commander, we will accept that amendment if Mr. Miller will make it to the effect
that the number of the bill be substituted for the name.
MR. MILLER: Yes, sir, I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: Mr. Commander, I think what Mr. Miller was
talking about that in addition to the name the number be added, not substituted.
MR. MILLER: Whatever, Mr. Commander, will properly identify it is
satisfactory with me. If they will insert the number of the House or the
Senate Bill that the Bolte legislation is covered by, this will be fine.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We have accepted that.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN:
Will you accept that
amendment?
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN DOYLE: Yes, sir.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Since your amendment
has been accepted by the Chairman, there is no necessity of voting on the
amendment.
Any further discussion on the motion?
All those in favor will please say aye; opposed. So ordered.
“Reserve Training”
Resolution No. 21 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, this country has traditionally relied upon the Reserve Components of our Military Establishment, as a pool of trained forces ready for
active duty in times of military emergency, and
WHEREAS, we are now facing a national emergency because of our commitments in Viet Nam and elsewhere, and
WHEREAS, our Reserve Components are unable to maintain an adequate
training program because they have been relieved of much of their equipment for use by our regular Military Establishment, and
WHEREAS, our Regular Military Establishment has not been able to furnish the manpower to adequately train our volunteers and inductees, and
WHEREAS, with adequate equipment and training our Reserve Components could be of invaluable use in the training of volunteers and inductees
in our Regular Military Establishment and their use would in fact constitute
a military economy, and
WHEREAS, the Army, due to lack of training facilities is unable to train
Reserve Component individuals to top combat readiness, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion strongly recommends and urges,
1. That our Reserve Military Components be supplied with the necessary
equipment in order that they may maintain an adequate training program commensurate with maximum combat readiness;
2. That the Department of Defense open additional training facilities in
order to train the backlog of enlistments in the Reserve Components
who have not received six months active duty training;
32
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
3. That the Training Divisions of the Reserve Components be called for
active service if the Regular Forces are unable to perform this service,
and used in the training of volunteers and inductees in our Regular
Military Establishment in order to relieve the manpower shortage
faced by our regular military in providing such training.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Oder, California, and adopted.
“Defense Department Policy in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 22 (Submitted by: National Security Commission).
WHEREAS, in early 1962, spokesmen for the Defense Department reported that our war in Viet Nam was going so well that 1,000 military personnel could be removed in a month, and the remaining Americans by 1965,
and
WHEREAS, now our troops in Viet Nam have been increased to over
250,000 from the approximately 3,000 there as of December 1961, and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has supported military systems necessary for the defense and security of this country, including the B-70-Supersonic bomber, the Dynasoar, the Anti-Missile programs, and others—all of
which have been written down or canceled by the Department of Defense,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that we recommend to the President and the Congress of the United States
that the Viet Nam conflict be re-evaluated as to strategy, tactics, and the
logistical support, and that the leadership and concepts of our military people,
trained in the art of war for the security of this country, be given primary
consideration in the planning, execution and conclusion of this conflict, and
be it further
RESOLVED, That we use every military effort to successfully conclude
this war, and be it further
RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the President of the United States and to the Chairmen of the Senate and House
Armed Services Committees.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF LIFE INSURANCE & TRUST COMMITTEE
William S. Todd (Tennessee), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN TODD: Mr. Commander and gentlemen, your
Life Insurance and Trust Committee met in the two days preceding this
meeting down at the Athletic Club with all members present except two.
The report I believe has been laid on your desk, the report which we have
submitted through the Finance Commission, but the Chairman, Mr. Redden,
because of some additions on the report insisted that we make this this
morning.
We have reports from the Administrator of the program, Mr. R. H. Gore
of Chicago and the insurance carrier, Occidental Life of California through
Mr. John Llewelyn. The important thing that we wanted to report on is the
fact that our Subcommittee which had been appointed at the Portland Convention to look into the feasibility of negotiating a new promotion agreement reported that a new agreement should be negotiated and the new Administrator was desirous in cooperating to this end. Detailed studies as to the
extension and the promotion of The American Legion Life Insurance plan
were presented to the Committee by both the Subcommittee and the Administrator, Vic Whittlesea of Nevada and William Baxter of New York and
John Shea of Missouri, together with the Chairman of the Committee. We
felt that the sliding scale of compensation would be fair under all circumstances. This is set forth at the bottom of the first page of the report.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
33
In regard to the rate of compensation, I would like to point out to you
that under the law we have to handle the group states and the policy states
m a different fashion. The states of New York and Puerto Rico, the fee
,Te ls 01}ly 2% for those, but this is the big lump, and we worked out this
sliding scale.
The Trust Fund is presently $988,000, and it will reach a million dollars
this year.
We do have two resolutions, but they will be reported at the time of our
parent Commission report, the Finance Commission tomorrow. Thank you
very much, Mr. Commander.
. . . The printed report of Mr. Todd is as follows:
REPORT OF THE AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE AND
TRUST COMMITTEE TO THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
May 4-5, 1966
William S. Todd, Chairman
(Submitted through Finance Commission)
The American Legion Life Insurance and Trust Committee met in Indianapolis, Indiana in the Athletic Club on May 2-3, 1966 with only two members absent.
The Committee heard reports from representatives of the Administrator
of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, R. H. Gore Company of Chicago, Illinois, and of Occidental Life Insurance Company of California; the
Insurance Carrier, which revealed that participation in the plan has steadily
increased.
A Special Subcommittee consisting of John Shea of Missouri, and Vie
Whittlesea of Nevada reported on a special Pilot Study of concentrated promotional activity in the St. Louis Area. It was reported that 35 of the 44
Posts in St. Louis County were represented at the initial meeting at which
Paul L. Weber, Staff Liaison, gave a full explanation of the Insurance Plan
and how it could be best promoted at the local level. While the Committee
was of the opinion that the local posts had not followed through, it was felt
that this was primarily due to a local problem in failing to disseminate the
basic materials and that this experience would be of considerable value in
future promotion.
The report of Mr. John Brogan, representing the Administrator, revealed
that participation in the plan had increased during 1965 to approximately
72,000 members with some 45,000 in the group states, and 27,000 in the policy
states, and that we have now attained an annual premium of approximately
$1,550,000, and that approximately $3,325,000 has been paid out in claims since
1958.
Mr. John Llewelyn, representing the Insurance Carrier, explained that the
Company is well pleased with the progress that has been made, and that the
Catastrophe Reserve, required by law, has been accumulated in the approximate amount of $50,000, and that no further deposits will need to be made to
this reserve.
Another Subcommittee appointed at the Portland National Convention to
investigate the feasibility of negotiating a new Administration and Promotion Agreement, consisting of Stanley Van Dyk of Illinois, Gilbert Sheeks of
Indiana, and John Shea of Missouri, which had met in Washington during the
Commander’s Conference, advised the Committee that a new agreement should
be negotiated and that the Administrator was desirous of cooperation
toward this end. Detailed study of the expenses of Administration and
Promotion of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan were presented to the
Committee by both the Subcommittee and the Administrator following which
Vic Whittlesea of Nevada, William Baxter of New York, and John Shea of
Missouri, together with the Chairman of the Committee, had a special meeting
with the representative of the Administration in which the specific compensa-
34
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U> 1966
tions of the Administrator were discussed, delineated, and negotiated to the
mutual satisfaction of the parties.
,, . . . .
. „
It is the sincere feeling of this Committee that the Administrator has
been diligent, devoted, and dedicated in its administration of The American
Legion Life Insurance Plan, and that a new Administration and
Agreement should be prepared and executed to be effective on January 1, 1967,
with the Administrator’s compensation to be based on a sliding scale as follows:
,,
, .
1. Ten percent on the first $1,000,000 of premium from the group states.
2. Eight percent of said premium from $1,000,000 to $1,500,000.
3. Seven percent of said premium between $1,500,000 and $2,000,000.
4. That when the amount of premium from the group states reaches
$2,000,000 the rate of compensation shall be re-examined and rene5. That^the Administrator will bear full expense of all IBM and tabulating costs incurred in the administration of the plan, which it was formerly reimbursed 60 % of the said costs by the Insurance Carrier, and
which will result in a savings in excess of $8,000 annually.
Further, said agreement should provide that the Administrator shall expend not less than fifteen percent of its total fee for the promotion and
furtherance of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, over and above
the expenses of the Staff Liaison, and the direct mail activity in the policy
states, and that said Administrator should be required to submit a Promotional Budget to the Committee at its annual Spring Meeting for its approval
and adoption, and any part of said fifteen percent promotional funds not
expended in any year shall be carried over for future promotion and shall
not revert to the Administrator.
It is recommended that said agreement should be effective for one year,
automatically renewable, unless terminated by either party by giving 120 days
written notice before the end of any calendar year, and that all files, records,
IBM cards, and other data pertaining to The American Legion Life Insurance
Plan, which are not the property of the Insurance Carrier, shall be the property of The American Legion upon termination of said agreement.
Mr. Paul Weber our staff liaison displayed for the Committee copies of the
Department and Post publications which had cooperated in publicizing the
Insurance Plan, and he advised the Committee that he had received excellent
cooperation from all Divisions of the National Organization in his efforts
to make this plan a full-grown member of the family.
The Committee adopted a resolution to reimburse The American Legion
in the sum of $10,171.37 from The Life Insurance Trust Fund for expenses
incurred by The American Legion in connection with the Insurance Plan.
This resolution was delivered to the Finance Commission for processing.
The Committee plans to look into the manner in which the Trust Funds
are being invested in an effort to ascertain whether or not maximum yield
is being received under the guideline laid down in the Trust Agreement and
whether said Trust Agreement could be amended to allow more advantageous
investment.
This Committee is most pleased that the National Commander has appointed a Special Committee to coordinate activities in connection with the
observance of the “Golden Anniversary” of The American Legion, and plans
to work closely with said Committee so that the maximum emphasis and
publicity possible to be derived from this anniversary may be realized.
The Committee has been extremely impressed with the able manner in
which Mr. Paul Weber, Staff Liaison of The American Legion Life Insurance Department, has coordinated the promotional activities of the Administrator with the various Divisions of The American Legion and feels
confident that great benefit will accrue to the program as a result.
The Committee wishes to express its appreciation to all of the National
Officers for their continued cooperation and assistance.
Respectfully submitted,
WILLIAM S. TODD, Chairman
American Legion Life Insurance Trust Committee
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
35
REPORT OF NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Morris “Bob” Nooner, Jr. (Illinois), Chairman
Mr. Commander and members of the National Executive Committee:
Executive Section of your National Child Welfare Commission
met at the National Headquarters in Indianapolis, Indiana on Monday and
Tuesday, May 2-3, 1966. Meeting with our Commission was the National Child
Welfare Committee of the American Legion Auxiliary an the Child Welfare
Committee of the Eight and Forty. We were also privileged to have with us
lor a brief period, the National President and National Secretary.
Our Commission wishes to extend its appreciation to Wally Young, Chairman of the Child Welfare Liaison Committee, for his faithful attendance
and counsel throughout our meeting.
I am pleased to report to you that we have had numerous indications
at our recent Area Conferences and from other sources within the Departments of a renewed enthusiasm in the Child Welfare program and we
are anticipating the largest annual child welfare report in the history of the
program for presentation to the National Convention.
Part of our deliberations the past two days were concerned with selection of the major points of emphasis for our 1967 child welfare program
those subjects selected include: an active Child Welfare Chairman in every
Post and Unit, juvenile delinquency, mentally ill children, eye safety
(with emphasis on eye safety legislation), outdoor recreation and support of
the American Legion Child Welfare Foundation.
Although The American Legion ChildnWelfare Foundation is a separate
entity from our Child Welfare program, it is by Convention action a part
of our total American Legion Child Welfare Program since it is concerned
with prevention and prevention is one of the four basic methods of operation
tor conducting our program. I am pleased to report to you that support for
the Foundation has increased substantially thus far this year compared to
the same period for last year. To further strengthen the important work of
the Foundation, we are recommending that Department Child Welfare
Chairmen include dissemination of information concerning the Child Welfare
Foundation as a part of their responsibilities.
Our five Area Child Welfare Conferences provide us with an invaluable
tool for the successful operation of the Child Welfare program. Total attendance
at our conferences the past two years has been the best in the past ten years
This past year we made some sweeping changes in the format of our meetings m an effort to increase their effectiveness. These changes involved the
use of devices designed to increase participation by the conference delegates.
These changes have been well received and will be continued at next year’s
conferences.
For your information, the dates and locations for the 1966-67 Area Child
Welfare Conferences are:
Southern Area
Oct. 27-29
Atlanta, Georgia
Midwestern Area
Nov. 3-5
Indianapolis, Indiana
Western Area
Nov. 17-19
Albuquerque, New Mexico
New England Area
Dec. 1-3
Providence, Rhode Island
Middle Atlantic Area
Jan. 5-7
Norfolk, Virginia
Expenditures for dependent children of veterans from our temporary financial assistance program are at a relatively low level due in large part to
our level of prosperity. On the other hand, we are receiving an increasing
number of requests for assistance to children who are already receiving aid
through such programs as Aid to Families with Dependent Children. Payments in such programs are meeting a smaller percentage of children’s basic
needs as the cost of living continues to rise. Failure of public programs to
reflect the increased cost of living could become an increased burden on
our own temporary financial assistance program.
36
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Last fall I made a report to you on our efforts to secure four pieces of
state legislation concerning children. Our efforts were directed at laws to
require mandatory testing of newborn babies for PKU (a metabolic disorder
which causes mental retardation but which is easily corrected by d
y
means if detected early), legislation to require reporting by physicians and
hospital authorities of suspected cases of physical abuse of children, legislation requiring students in shop-type classes and laboratories to wear eye
protectee devices, and laws designed to more adequately control the distribution of the so-called dangerous drugs.
We now have a complete tabulation of our efforts which we believe were
most successful. Forty-eight states have enacted laws to protect the physically
abused child. Thirty-three states have enacted legislation or adopted administrative regulations requiring hospitals to test the newborn for PKU. All
but one state now has a law controlling the distribution and sale of dangerous drugs and 20 states enacted laws requiring pupils to wear eye protective devices in classes where there are potential hazards to the eyes.
Next year most of the state legislatures will be meeting and we are
developing plans for further efforts in cooperation with Departments in the
area of eye safety and improvement of some states laws dealing with child
abuse.
Our Commission is concerned with the stigma that has been attached to
our teen-agers through sensationalized items reaching the public through our
various communications media. It would appear that only those youth who
get into trouble have press agents. Actually, only a bare three per cent of
all youth ever get involved in behavior where they run afoul of the law.
The vast majority of our youth evidence a high level of academic achievement, loyalty to country and sound character. Our Commission has recommended a resolution on this subject for your consideration.
We are vitally concerned with the increasing number of accidents to children resulting in death for 15,000 and injuries to an additional 17 million
annually. Nearly half of these accidental deaths to children occur m the
home. Many of these deaths in the home occur as the result of ingestion of
poisons or overdoses of drugs and amphetamines.
There is legislation pending in the Congress presently which seeks to
amend the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act to require safety closures
on drug containers and limit the amount of child aspirin which may be placed
in a single container. This proposed legislation would also mend the Federal
Hazardous Substances Labeling Act to ban hazardous toys and articles for
children as well as other articles so hazardous as to be dangerous m the
home regardless of their labeling.
Our Commission feels such legislation would be helpful to reduction of
accidents to children in their homes and we have prepared a resolution endorsing such legislation for your consideration.
Your Child Welfare Commission is fully cognizant of the responsibilities
they have accepted.
The design of the programs which have been developed for 1967 indicates
that a continued interest is being displayed and concerted efforts are being
made to further our organization’s role in the areas related to Child Welfare.
With the continuing cooperation and support of your Committee, we reaffirm our pledge, to give our best efforts to meet the responsibilities given to
us and maintain The American Legion’s leadership role in all matters relating to our nation’s youth and children.
. . . Upon motion by Mr. Jackson, Delaware, seconded by Mr. Oder,
California, the report was received and filed.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Are there resolutions,
Mr. Stone?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
37
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously adopted:
“Commend Youth”
Resolution No. 28 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, There is considerable material reaching the general public
today through our various public media concerned with youth crime and antisocial behavior on the part of young people, and
WHEREAS, A bare 3 per cent of our young people ever come in contact
with law enforcement agencies, and
WHEREAS, The overwhelming majority of our youth show promise of
outstanding citizenship as evidenced in a number of ways, most recently by
their expression of support for the American Policy in Viet Nam and support
of The American Legion National Program of “Show Your Colors”- now
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it express its wholehearted confidence in the youth of America and’
commends American youth for its accomplishments in the areas of academic
achievement, loyal citizenship and character development.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: While we are waiting
for the distribution of these resolutions, let’s go ahead with the reading of
the next two, then we will entertain a motion on all of them or each one of
them separately.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, there is probably something wrong with our communications from our office down to the
mimeograph pool, and possibly this is coming in in one of the supplements.
In the interest of time, I will be glad to read the entire resolution and
pass on it. These are actually “Motherhood” resolutions.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN:
You have heard the recommendation of the Chairman of the Resolutions Committee.
. . . The motion was seconded.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Motion has been made
and carried. Any objection? Hearing none, it is so ordered.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I consider Resolution 28 has
already been put to the body.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Resolution 28 has already
been put to the body.
“Need for Expanded Research and Educational Program Concerning
Genetic Diseases”
Resolution No. 29 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, Chromosomal diseases are a major cause of disabling conditions among children including such commonly known disabilities as retardation, and
WHEREAS, Research has demonstrated that many of these diseases
can be prevented by a chromosomal study of prospective parents, and
WHEREAS, There are many diseases remaining among children which
are suspected to be of genetic origin, and
WHEREAS, There is an urgent need to disseminate available information
concerning diseases of genetic origin to prospective parents as a means
of preventing such disorders, and
WHEREAS, There is a need for further extensive research in the field
of genetics, now, therefore, be it
38
Proceedings of Wecbiesday, May b, 1966
HE SOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that it urges an aggressive educational effort be made to familiarize
prospective parents of the need for a chromosomal study as a means of
preventing such diseases, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That every effort be made to expand genetic
research through appropriate agencies of government and private sources.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Is there any discussion?
MR. LEONARD, Connecticut: I feel that we are out of order entirely
with this way of doing business. We at least should have this digest to read
it or know what he is talking about, and he can’t do it himself up there, so
we should have something on it. I suggest we discontinue voting on resolutions that we don’t have the digest on and let’s have some other Committee
report in the meantime.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Joe, it is true what you
say that you like to have them, but this body already went on record giving
him permission to proceed, and you have already taken a vote without objection. So I think we have to proceed with that. You want to renew that
motion?
MR. LEONARD: I will renew the motion. I will make a substitute, if it
possible or something, that we don’t proceed any further with resolutions until we have the digest and let some other Committee make their report.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Is there a second to the
motion?
MR. PETROVICH, Alaska: Mr. Chairman, I will second the motion and
support the Committeeman from Connecticut.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Motion is that we hold
this and discontinue any further procedure on resolutions until we get them
in the digest. What is your pleasure, gentlemen?
. . . Question.
All those in favor of the motion please say aye; opposed no. The ayes
have it.
We will have to defer to you and withhold any further resolutions until
such time as we can get the resolutions in the digest.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: Mr. Commander, Mr. Flynn
is here. Can we get his report?
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: I was just getting ready
to ask the Chairman John Flynn to give us the Economic report at this time.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION REPORT
John J. Flynn (California), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN FLYNN: Mr. Commander and Members of
the National Executive Committee:
You have been supplied a copy of our Advance Report covering Commission actions taken at our March Executive Section Meeting. Since our Commission did not meet here in Indianapolis, and in view of this rather detailed
report, we will be brief at this time by highlighting a couple considerations
contained in our Advance Report and certain matters that have required our
attention since the first of April.
Our books have been cleared of all referred resolutions and Register matters with the exception of two. These are Resolution No. 231 (Illinois) and
Register No. 1224 (New Hampshire). The Illinois Resolution requesting legislation to outlaw discrimination in employment because of age was referred by the 1965 National Convention to the Subcommittee on the Problems of the Aged and Aging. At this Subcommittee’s March meeting it was
recommended that the resolution be approved with the proviso that such dis-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
39
crimination be condemned only when the applicant is qualified for such employment and is under age 65. This resolution will be further considered at our
next meeting.
Register No. 1224 protesting the import of electronic components which
allegedly is causing unemployment among veterans, has been deferred for
further study and will be reported on at a later date.
There were two resolutions emanating with the Commission at our March
meeting. One resolution has to do with legislation to provide for assistance
in on-the-job training programs for Viet Nam and Cold War Veterans who
normally would be eligible for veterans’ educational assistance under the new
Cold War Bill. The Act as passed and approved on March 3, 1966, does not
provide assistance for on-the-job training as was afforded World War II and
Korean veterans. Many veterans will not be able financially or otherwise to
further their education through college or other educational channels. Therefore we see the need of on-the-job training programs. Also there is a need for
skilled workers in all industries. This new group of veterans will be a definite
source from which skilled workers can be recruited and trained. We urge the
adoption of Resolution No. 6. We should perhaps point out that HR 13850
as pending in Committee will not only provide for assistance to these Cold
War Veterans in on-the-job training, but will also extend educational assistance in on-the-farm training programs, etc.
The other resolution emanating with our Commission and contained in
our Advance Report opposing HR 6277 has been withdrawn by the Resolutions Subcommittee of the National Executive Committee with the consent of
the Commission. Withdrawal action resulted after pertinent discussions between the NEC Resolutions Subcommittee, the National Legislative Commission and the Economic Commission. Hearings on HR 6277 were held April
19 and 21, 1966, before a Special Subcommittee, Senate Committee on Foreign Relations. The Assistant Director, National Legislative Commission, by
virtue of authority granted in a 1965 National Convention Resolution, testified on April 21st. In view of these hearings adoption of the Commission’s
emanated resolution at this late date would serve no useful purpose. Further, to oppose HR 6277 in its entirety as resolved in the resolution would be
in conflict with existing mandates of the Foreign Affairs Committee.
More detailed information on HR 6277 and its adverse effect on veterans’
preference will be found in our Advance Report. However, in passing we
want to emphasize that our fight in opposition to the two adverse Sections
(Sections 29 and 32 )is an up-hill climb. We will need every possible ounce of
support. Therefore you are urged to either write your Senator or contact
him personally advising him of The American Legion’s opposition to this
measure and specifically request that he oppose Sections 29 and 32 of the
Bill. As you know HR 6277 passed the House last year.
This Saturday, May 7th, we will close out our eighth observance of
“Employ the Older Worker Week.” It is a little early yet to determine if
there is an increase in participation over last year. However, we are hopeful
that most Departments will participate and we certainly would urge that
you do so, even if it is necessary for the award presentation to be made
at a date subsequent to the designated week.
As to 1967 appropriations for the Veterans Employment Service and the
Office of Veterans Re-employment Rights, we are pleased to report that this
year we do not anticipate any opposition in having the necessary amounts
appropriated as requested when we testified before the House Committee on
Appropriations.
One further item I would like to bring to your attention is a matter relative to the staff. As reported in our Advance Report, decisions denying
waiver of GI Home Loan Indebtedness are now appealable to the VA’s
Board of Veterans Appeals. This is a new endeavor for the Economic Commission Staff. We enthusiastically accept this added responsibility in the
field of housing.
Members of our staff have now been accredited by the VA to represent
appellants before the Board of Veterans Appeals. We have been given excellent cooperation by the Chairman of the Board and his staff in order that
40
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
all housing indebtedness appeals may be handled as expeditiously as possible. We solicit your cooperation by urging that all housing matters including indebtedness appeals to the Board of Veterans Appeals be forwarded
promptly to the Economic Division’s Director at our Washington “K”
Street address.
Briefly with reference to future Area Economic Conferences, we are pleased
to report that in our opinion each of the four (4) conferences held during
The American Legion year 1965-66 were successful. We are going to schedule
four (4) conferences for the forthcoming American Legion year. We would
urge each of you to stimulate interest in your particular area and attend at
least one conference yourself if at all possible. Area Conference schedules will
be announced at a future date.
. . . The printed Advance Report is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5, 1966
by
JOHN J. FLYNN (California), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
The following report covers the activities of the National Economic Commission and its three affiliated Committees from October 7, 1965 to April 1,
1966.
I. NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION MEETINGS
In conjunction with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference on March
1-3, 1966, an Executive Section of the Economic Commission met in the New
York Room, Statler Hilton Hotel, Washington, D. C. John J. Flynn, Chairman of the National Economic Commission presided over these three-day
meetings with the Chairman of each of the three affiliated Committees serving as Moderator during their respective Committee Panel. In addition to the
Commission and Committee Chairmen also attending these meetings were: the
Commission’s Vice Chairman; Vice Chairman of each of the three Committees; thirty-two members of the Commission and affiliated Committees; Chairman of the National Executive Committee Liaison Committee to the National
Economic Commission; the National Commander’s Representative to the Commission; Department Commanders, Adjutants and National Executive Committeemen; Department Service Officers, County and Post Service Officers;
Veterans Employment Representatives; Economic Commission Staff Members
and numerous other persons interested in the Economic Program of The
American Legion.
Twelve Representatives of Government, Labor and Industry appeared before the Commission and informed us of their respective programs and its
relationship to the economic welfare of veterans.
Past National Chaplain Dr. Tom B. Clark and our Housing Committee
Chairman, offered the daily opening prayer.
One of the highlights of the sessions was an address by John W. Macy,
Jr., Chairman, United States Civil Service Commission. The Economic Commission was honored by having National Commander L. Eldon James present to introduce Mr. Macy.
In our deliberations all programs and functions under the Commission’s
jurisdiction were extensively studied. All sessions were well attended, interesting, informative and we believe reasonable progress was made in our continued effort to find solutions to some of our employment, housing and veterans preference problems. Members in attendance recognized their responsi-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May k, 1966
41
bility in favorably considering only those matters which were correctly under
jurisdiction of the Economic Commission and germane to veterans’ affairs.
All items other than resolutions and registered matters acted upon and
relating directly to one of the three Committees; Employment, Housing or
Veterans’ Preference, will be considered under its designated Committee heading. Following are actions on matters considered together with reports received by the Commission.
A. 1965 National Convention Resolution Referred to the Commission:
1. Resolution No. 279 (Pennsylvania) seeks preferential employment
consideration in the nation’s public employment system for veterans with
service in those campaigns for which the Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal
has been or will be awarded in the future. REJECTED. Subject matter is now
law, “Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966.” (Public Law 89-358) approved March 3, 1966.
B. Action on Referred Register Matters:
1. Register No. 1210 (New Jersey Department Convention) protests the
preference afforded non-veteran displaced Federal employees over veterans
whose names appear on a Civil Service Register resulting from a competitive
examination and thereby delaying eligible veterans of an appointment to
Federal jobs. REJECTED. It is reasonable to give perference to separated
career employees and is not considered as a violation of the Veterans’ Preference Act.
2. Register No. 1124 (New Hampshire Department Executive Committee)
protests the foreign import of electronic components which is alleged to cause
unemployment among veterans and their families who are employed in American plants. DEFERRED to the Economic Staff for further study.
C. Commission—Initiated Resolutions:
The following two unnumbered resolutions emanating with the Commission
are being presented for National Executive Committee action at its May 4-5,
1966 Meeting.
(1) Oppose the Bill HR 6277, 89th Congress, in its present form and request that the United States Senate where the bill is now pending reject the
bill.
(2) Support legislation to amend the Veterans’ Readjustment Benefits
Act of 1966 (Public Law 89-358) so as to provide eligible cold war veterans
assistance in on-the-job training programs.
D. Report of Joint Economic-Rehabilitation Subcommittee on Problems of
the Aged and Aging:
The Joint Economic-Rehabilitation Subcommittee on Problems of the Aged
and Aging met February 28, 1966 in Room 401, of The American Legion
Building in connection with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. Milton S. Applebaum, Chairman of the Subcommittee. and all members were
present. There was considerable discussion on Medicare, the Nursing Care
Program, Nursing Home Facilities and the Older American Act of 1965 (Public Law 89-73).
The Subcommittee took the following action on a Referred 1965 National Convention Resolution.
Resolution No. 231 (Illinois) asking that discrimination in employment
of the older worker be made an unlawful employment practice under Federal
law was recommended for approval with the proviso that such discrimination
be condemned only when the applicant is qualified for such employment and
is under age 65. Resolution No. 231 will receive further consideration at the
next meeting of the National Economic Commission.
E. Report and Recommendations of Area Economic Conferences:
The report and recommendations of the Chairman of each of the four
Area Economic Conferences was received by the Commission. The Chairman,
Area, Location and dates are as follows:
42
,
Proceedings of Wednesday May U, 1966
John H. Geiger, Mid-Western Area, Chicago, Illinois, November 13-14,
1965.
James A. Tadlock, Western Area, Albuquerque, New Mexico, January 2830, 1966.
Thomas J. Harvey, Jr., Southern Area, Atlanta, Georgia, February 11-13,
1966.
Joseph Holzka, New England-Mid-Atlantic Area, Staten Island, New York,
February 19, 1966.
Federal and State Government, industry and labor was represented at
each Conference. The Conferences were well attended, interesting and informative for those persons seeking information and solutions to problems
which come under jurisdiction of the Economic Commission.
In light of favorable response from the four areas, and recommendations
from each Conference, the Economic Commission unanimously voted to continue holding four Area Economic Conferences annually. The following two
Conference recommendations were also approved by the Commission:
(1) That each Department of The American Legion be urged to conduct
local Economic Conferences, similar to those being held on an Area level;
and
(2) Opposition to the weakening or reduction of any veteran benefit pertaining to the economic welfare of veterans.
II. EMPLOYMENT COMMITTEE CONSIDERATIONS
An Executive Section of this Committee, Chairmaned by William J. Chisholm met with the Economic Commission March 1-3, 1966. During the Employment Panel discussions and deliberations all phases of The American Legion Employment Program were considered. The following speakers addressed the Committee and were most helpful in our deliberations. Carlos
Moore, Legislative Assistant, International Brotherhood of Teamsters; Edward L. Omohundro, Chief, Veterans Employment Service; Thomas A. Tinsley,
Director, Bureau of Employees’ Compensation; Hugh W. Bradley, Director,
Office of Veterans’ Reemployment Rights; and William P. McCahill, Executive Secretary, President’s Committee on Employment of the Handicapped.
Most of the speakers after reviewing their respective program, accomplishments and goals sought, left a challenge with the Economic Commission and
the Employment Committee. The challenge has been accepted and is expressed by certain recommendations set forth in this report.
A. Citation Award Programs:
The American Legion programs of awarding national citations to employers who have done an outstanding job in the employment of the handicapped
and older workers have been working well. We are appreciative of the increased interest shown by some Departments of The American Legion who
have accepted their responsibility in these fields.
“National Employ the Handicapped Week,” was observed October 2-9, 1965,
in cooperation with the President’s Committee on Employment of the Handicapped. Thirty-one Departments participated in the program by presenting a
national citation award to an employer who had done an outstanding job
in hiring the handicapped, especially the disabled veteran. For a complete
list of the participating Departments and recipients of the Handicapped
Awards see The American Legion Magazine for March 1966 (pages 34-35).
The Employment Committee has announced in the Economic Commission
Activities Bulletin No. 8-66 of March 1966 its 1966 citation award program
for, “Employ the Older Worker Week.” The week will be observed May 1-7,
1966 and each Department of The American Legion has been encouraged to
participate by recognizing an outstanding employer of the older worker.
In connection with our older worker program, the Economic Commission
Staff recently submitted testimony before the Subcommittee of the House
Appropriations Committee in compliance with Resolution No. 489 of the 1965
National Convention. In our testimony we urged the Congress to make adequate appropriations for the required extension of specialized service for
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
43
older workers in all local offices of the several state employment services
and throughout other affiliated offices of the U. S. Employment Service,
particularly through the provisions of staff time budget realistically related
to the needs of the older worker.
B. Veterans Employment Service:
The Economic Commission is most appreciative of the support given our
employment programs throughout the country by the Veterans Employment
Service and the State Employment Security Agencies. We are also pleased
with the excellent manner in which these operating agencies have discharged
their responsibilities in the placement of some 25 million veterans in the past
two decades. However, there is a continuing need for this employment service
to veterans especially now with the passage of the Cold War GI Bill.
During fiscal year 1965 the Veterans Employment Service and the State
Employment Security Agencies received some 1.2 million new veteran applications of whom 122,000 were disabled veterans. Of the total veteran applications received, over 933,000 were placed in non-agricultural jobs and 99,000
of these placements were disabled veterans.
e nev
moT>>
^ "Cold
Warother
GI Bill,”
thejob
“Veterans
Readjustment
Benefits
Act of
1966, provides
among
things,
counseling
and employment
placement
assistance to veterans who served on active duty at any time after January
'TW ■
who arewill
separated
from
honorableEmployment
conditions.
This1955
newand
legislation
increase
the such
work service
load ofunder
the Veterans
Service. Since January 31, 1955 about 4 million individuals have been separated from the Armed Services of whom at least 100,000 are currently unemployed. This coupled with the fact that as of December 31, 1965 more
than two months before enactment of the GI Bill approximately 350,000 war
veterans were actively seeking employment. Additionally, it is estimated that
some 56,000 military retirees and about 400,000 cold war veterans will be
separated from the Armed Services each year commencing in 1967. Many of
these veterans will be seeking employment assistance. These young Viet
Nam veterans with little or no employment experience and the military retirees normally in the 40 to 45 age group will both need special counseling
assistance.
The Veterans Employment Service Budget request for fiscal year 1967 is
$1,732,000. In compliance with the 1965 National Convention Resolution No.
37 the staff on February 24, 1966, testified before the appropriate Subcommittee of the House Committee on Appropriations. The requested sum of
$1,732,000 was supported as being fair and reasonable, and the minimum required for the operation of the Veterans Employment Service. The figure
requested and supported by the Economic Commission will provide for the
same number of positions as in previous years.
C. Recommended Amendments to the Cold War GI Bill:
Many cold war veterans that normally would be eligible for veterans’ educational assistance under the Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966
will not be able financially or otherwise to further their education through
college or other formal education channels. Further, there is a continuing
need for skilled workers in all industries of the nation and the returning cold
war veteran could well be a prime source from which skilled workers can
be recruited and trained. Therefore, after due consideration of all factors
involved, the Committee went on record, recommending by virtue of a resolution, which will be submitted for National Executive Committee consideration, that the new Cold War GI Bill be amended to provide for assistance in
on-the-job training programs, for eligible veterans.
D. Veterans Reemployment Rights:
When last reporting to this body we advised you of the urgent need for
an amendment to the Universal Military Training and Service Act in order
to protect reemployment rights of enlistees or Reservists who voluntarily or
involuntarily, because of the national emergency, extend their active duty
period beyond the four year limitation as specified in the present Reemployment Rights Statutes. And in so extending for the convenience of the
government many servicemen unknowingly forfeit their reemployment
44
Proceedings of Wednesday, May If, 1966
rights normally afforded under the present law. 1965 National Convention
Resolution No. 576 requested and supported such an amendment. HR 11509
will satisfy our resolution, and we are pleased to report that this bill passed
the House March 7, 1966. Hearings have been held before the Senate Armed
Services Committee and the bill is now pending consideration before the Senate.
Certain new procedures recently negotiated between the Departments of
Defense and Labor have resulted in the lessening of the complaint case load
before the Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights.
The reorganization of the Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights has
just about been completed. The original 19 field offices have now been reduced to 11 and we understand when certain further negotiations are completed, will be reduced to 10 field offices. The Office of Veterans Reemployment Rights reassures us that the reorganization will in no way diminish
the service to returning servicemen as afforded under the Veterans Reemployment Rights Statutes.
E. Manpower Development and Training Act:
In addition to referring veterans to job openings, local employment offices
refer veterans to occupational training courses established under provisions
of the Manpower Development and Training Act of 1962. For the three
year period September 1, 1962 and September 1, 1965, more than 33,000
veterans received institutional training. Veterans represent slightly over onefourth of all of the males enrolled in this type of training. With the influx
as a result of the “Cold War GI Bill” it is anticipated that these figures
will increase substantially. In compliance with Resolution No. 174 of our
1964 National Convention, in recent testimony before the House Appropriations Subcommittee, the staff urged that Congress appropriate sufficient funds
for carrying out the purpose and intent of the Manpower Development and
Training Act.
III. HOUSING COMMITTEE ACTIVITIES
An Executive Section of the Housing Committee, Chairmaned by Dr. Tom
B. Clark, met with the Economic Commission March 1-3, 1966. During panel
discussions and deliberations the Committee heard from Philip N. Brownstein, Assistant Secretary, Department of Housing and Urban Development;
John M. Dervan, Director, Loan Guaranty Service, Veterans Administration;
and Philip S. Brown, Director, Information Staff, Farmers Home Administration, Department of Agriculture.
A. VA Home Loan Activities:
The VA Home Loan Program will he reactivated as a result of the enactment of the loan provisions of the Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act
of 1966. Many of some 3% or 4 million veterans serving in the Armed Forces
since January 31, 1955, will be eligible for VA guaranteed and direct home
loan benefits. The guarantee of a loan by a private lender remains the same
as for World War II and Korean War veterans—$7500, however, in
areas established as direct loan areas where guaranteed financing has not
generally been available, the maximum direct loan has been increased from
$15,000 to $17,500. The VA interest rate was also increased to 5 % % on March
3, 1966 when the new Cold War GI Bill was signed, in accordance with authority granted therein. This will put VA interest rates on a competitive
basis with FHA rates and consequently should make more mortgage money
available for VA home loans.
In addition to eligible veterans already discharged from the Armed Forces
since January 31, 1955, it is estimated that about 400,000 cold war veterans
will be separated from the Armed Services each year commencing in 1967.
Many of these veterans will be eligible for GI home loans under the new
legislation.
Home loan benefits for remaining eligible World War II veterans will
terminate July 25, 1967, and Korean War veterans’ entitlement will continue for some, until January 31, 1975.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
45
Waivers and Compromises: The Veterans Administration Central Office
Committee on Waivers and Compromises has been abolished. In lieu thereof,
there has been established a Loan Guaranty Committee on Compromises at
the VA Central Office and a Regional Loan Guaranty Committee on
Waivers and Compromises at each field station having a loan guaranty division.
Decisions of the Regional Committees or the Central Office Committee
denying waiver of indebtedness are appealable to the Board of Veterans
Appeals.
B. FHA Veteran Loan Program:
The Housing and Urban Development Act of 1965, provided, among other
things, a special Federal Housing Administration insured loan program for
all honorably discharged servicemen, including cold war veterans. There is
no limitation in the law as to the number of times an eligible serviceman
may avail himself of these special FHA loan benefits, except in the case of
a veteran who has previously utilized his entitlement under the VA Home
Loan Program. In his case he is barred from any benefits. This discriminates
against certain war veterans. Therefore, in compliance with Resolution No.
577 of the 1965 National Convention, the staff in recent testimony before
the Subcommittee on Housing, House Committee on Banking and Currency,
supported HR 11858, a bill to eliminate the above mentioned unwarranted
discriminatory provision under the present FHA law. If enacted this legislation will give all qualified veterans the same advantage in applying for
the liberalized mortgage financing terms as granted other servicemen.
C. Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act:
Because of the rise in the cost of living your Commission has for several
years approved resolutions requesting legislation to amend Section 300 of the
Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act of 1940, in order to provide increased
protection against the eviction of dependents from premises rendered for
dwelling purposes. On one occasion in the 88th Congress our Bill S 384
passed the Senate on May 28, 1963, however, come to a standstill in the House.
At this time we are pleased to note that the new Cold War GI Bill amended
the aforementioned section of the Soldiers and Sailors Civil Relief Act by
increasing protection for individuals who are renting homes when called to
service from $80 monthly rental to $150 monthly rental.
D. GI Home Loans in Foreign Countries:
In compliance with 1964 National Convention Resolution No. 643 Bill HR
13170 was introduced at the request of The American Legion on March 1,
1966. This legislation if enacted would authorize loans for the purchase or
construction of homes to otherwise eligible veterans who are citizens of the
United States residing in foreign countries.
IV. VETERANS’ PREFERENCE COMMITTEE ACTIVITIES
An Executive Section of the Veterans’ Preference Committee, Chairmaned
by Raymond R. McEvoy met in conjunction with the Economic Commission
meetings of March 1-3, 1966. Those addressing the Committee and who were
most helpful in our deliberations were the following officials of the Civil
Service Commission: John W. Macy, Jr., Chairman; L. J. Andolsek, Vice
Chairman; Robert E. Hampton, Commissioner; George F. Dwyer, Director,
Career Placement Service.
A. Civil Service Liaison Service:
The revised Liaison Service between veteran organizations and the Civil
Service Commission as initiated last year, wherein Vice Chairman L. J. Andolsek was assigned the responsibility of representing the Civil Service Commission in contacts and consultations with major veteran organizations at the
national level is working very well. Vice Chairman Andolsek, has addressed
most of the Economic Commission meetings, including Area Conferences since
assuming this responsibility. This top level contact has made it possible to
keep abreast of all Federal personnel administration matters, especially those
in the field of veterans’ preference. Quite frequently conferences are sched-
46
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
uled by the Commissioner’s office to afford representatives of veteran organizations the opportunity to sit down with policymaking officials of the
Civil Service Commission and other government agencies to discuss veterans’
preference, proposed changes in Civil Service Commission regulations and
procedures, and other matters of mutual interest.
B. Preference for Cold War Veterans:
Section 2 of the Veterans’ Preference Act is amended by virtue of the
“Cold War GI Bill.” Preference in Federal employment is now extended on
the same basis as is currently applicable to war veterans, to honorably separated members of the Armed Forces who have served on active duty, (other
than for training) for more than 180 consecutive days after January 31,
1955. It should be noted, however, that the 180 consecutive days of active
duty as required for preference under the new law will not apply to Korean
War veterans with service between April 28, 1952 and July 1, 1955,
who have heretofore been entitled under Section 2 (6) of the Veterans’ Preference Act.
Veterans now comprise about 51 percent of the total Federal work force
and about 64 percent of the male Federal work force. With the added
category of preference eligibles, the percentage should increase considerably.
This will mean that the potential case workload of the Economic staff pertaining to Veterans’ Preference matters will be on the increase.
C. Continued Veterans’ Preference Attack:
The House passed Bill HR 6277, as reported on at your last meeting,
which would remove some 10,000 employees of the Department of State,
United States Information Agency and Agency for International Development
from Civil Service and Veterans’ Preference Benefits, is still pending before
the Senate Post Office and Civil Service Committee. Hearings have not as
yet been scheduled. As mentioned in previous reports, if HR 6277 was to
become law, a dangerous precedent would be established and many other
branches of the Federal government would obviously seek similar legislation
to be excluded from Civil Service and veterans’ preference. Resolution No. 76
of the 1965 National Convention specifically opposes Section 29 and 32 of
HR 6277. However, in view of extensive amendments to the original bill,
HR 6277, the Veterans’ Preference Committee and the Economic Commission
when further studying this matter at its recent March meetings decided that a
more pointed resolution should be drawn up. In view of this, a resolution
covering this matter will be submitted to the National Executive Committee
for consideration at its forthcoming meetings May 4-5, 1966.
D. Back Pay Act of 1966:
Some government agencies over the years have failed to comply with recommendations of the Civil Service Commission when employees are ordered
restored retroactively to their positions following illegal or unjustified suspensions, dismissals or demotions. Because of this, many veterans have been
forced to seek remedy in the courts. This has been true even though Section 14
of the Veterans’ Preference Act, in the next to the last provisions states
that, “it shall be mandatory for such administrative officer (who has improperly discharged the veteran) to take such corrective action as the (Civil
Service) Commission finally recommends.” Also Section 19 of the Veterans’
Preference Act states, “Any recommendation by the Civil Service Commission . . . shall be complied with by such agency.”
In view of our deep concern with this matter for the past ten years we
are pleased to report that the Back Pay Act (HR 1647) was approved March
31, 1966 (Public Law 89-380). The Back Pay Act in point with 1964 National
Convention Resolution No. 640, will give all employees, veteran and nonveteran, probationary and career the benefits of the present law at its best,
and liberalize the law by allowing credit for pay increases and accumulation
of annual leave which otherwise would have accrued. In other words, it puts
the employee in the same position he would have been in had the unjustified
or erroneous personnel action not taken place.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN J. FLYNN, Chairman
National Economic Commission
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
47
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Resolutions, Mr. Stone?
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously adopted:
REPORT OP RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL ECONOMIC COMMISSION
“Support Legislation to Amend the Cold War GI Bill (Public Law
89-358) to Provide Assistance in On-the-job Training Programs”
Resolution No. 6 (Submitted by: National Economic Commission).
WHEREAS, Approximately 3.5 million ex-servicemen and ex-servicewomen
who were on active duty after January 31, 1955, are now classified as veterans, and
WHEREAS, It is estimated that 2,256,000 (68%) of the 3,327,000 cold
war veterans now in civilian life are in the 25-34 age bracket, with approximately one million of these between the ages of 20 and 24, and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense estimates that during the period
1966-1970 such veterans discharged from the Armed Services will number
from 500,000 to 600,000 annually, with the majority of these newly discharged
veterans in the 20-24 age bracket, and
WHEREAS, There is a continuing demand for skilled workers in virtually
all industries of the nation, and
WHEREAS, The returning cold war veteran is a prime potential
source from which such skilled workers can be recruited and trained, and
WHEREAS, Many thousands of these returning cold war veterans will
not, for reasons beyond their control, be able to further their education
through college or other formal education channels, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Legislative Commission be, and it is hereby authorized
and directed to support legislation in the Congress of the United States to
amend the “Cold War GI Bill” (PL 89-358), so as to provide for assistance
in on-the-job training programs similar to the provisions contained in SubChapter VI, Paragraph 1651 of Title 38, United States Code and thus provide these cold war veterans with better job opportunities, and industry with
a more adequate supply of skilled workers, all to the economic betterment of
our country.
(Subject to Rule 8-B, Approved by Legislative Commission.)
48
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
May 4, 1966
... At 1:30 p. m. the National Executive Committee was called to order
by National Commander Eldon James.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will the Committee come to attention, please.
I will ask the Sergeant-at-Arms to escort the distinguished and charming
guest to the front of the room.
. . . Miss U.S.A. 1966 was escorted to the rostrum.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: As some of you may know, the
48th National Convention of The American Legion will be held in Washington, D. C. on August 26th to September 1st, and this has something to do
with this pleasant experience this afternoon.
One of the strongest impressions that I carried away from Viet Nam
when I visited recently was the morale of our fighting men. We are pleased
and honored this afternoon to have with us a young lady who personally
can claim a generous portion of the credit for the good spirit of our young
men there.
The reason is obvious.
Already a veteran of Bob Hope’s well remembered tour to serve Viet
Nam last December, this lovely young lady is planning another return visit
to Viet Nam with Vic Damone’s special troop next summer.
Before that duty, she will visit Guantanamo for the troops there. Miss
U.S.A. incidentally is a product of the Commonwealth of Virginia. She is the
daughter of a Marine Corps War II combat veteran, she was a secretary at
the Pentagon for the Air Force—no partiality among the services. This
gracious young lady, and she is gracious, because she hasn’t forgotten, shall
I say, the old timers who once wore a uniform, is here in the capacity of
an ambassador of goodwill, Miss U.S.A., Dianna Lynn Batts, to inspire the
boys over there to help to win and inspire us here today, may I present Miss
U.S.A., Dianna Lynn Batts.
DIANNA LYNN BATTS
Miss U.S.A., 1966
On behalf of the City of Washington, D. C., I would like to extend an
invitation to the National Commander and all Legionnaires to come to Washington in August for the 48th Annual Convention, thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The invitation is beautiful, the
courier is better.
Today, and on behalf of The American Legion, I want to present to you
a certificate of appreciation. This certificate cites not only your patriotic
contribution to the cause of freedom in Viet Nam, but your fine interest
as ambassador of good will, and it reads as follows:
“The American Legion commends this gracious young lady, who as Miss
U.S.A. made personal and patriotic contributions supporting the policy of
the United States of America in assisting the South Vietnamese people to
defend themselves against the onslaught of Communistic invasion and subversion.
“She visited twenty United States military bases in South Viet Nam
and traveled more than 150,000 miles in her successful efforts to bolster
the morale of combat troops in this war-torn land and frontier of freedom.
“The American Legion is proud to have her as an Ambassador of Good
Will to extend invitations to its 48th Annual National Convention in Washington, D. C., August 26-September 1, 1966.”
Signed, C. D. DeLoach, Chairman, James C. Watkins, Director.
This is properly inscribed, and this is our plaque for you.
May I have your attention, please? Past Commander Griffith.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
49
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GRIFFITH: Is that Miss Virginia
that I see there in front of this group?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen of the Committee and
guests, Dianna as you have heard has spent considerable time in Viet Nam.
She talked with many of our representatives there. She came away with a
deep affection as many of you have with respect to the work our men are
doing and here for a few minutes she is going to tell you about that, Dianna.
MISS BATTS: First of all, I would like to thank you for this certificate
of appreciation. It was quite an honor to come down here today and to meet
you. I want to meet as many as I can, and I know that I will take back
many, many wonderful memories of my visit and look forward to your arrival in Washington in August.
I guess it was about six months ago that I made a trip with Bob Hope
overseas to Viet Nam, and when I think of all the trips that I have taken
this year that will be the one most remembered, because to me it was the fulfillment of doing something. We went over and tried to boost the morale of
many young men. We went to about 28 military installations and in that time,
I think I saw more men than I ever have in my whole life, and I am not
complaining.
It was quite a trip as far as feelings went. I know that when we left
California to go to Viet Nam, we all had a feeling of excitement that we
were going to Viet Nam, but it wasn’t until we were there that we realized
that there was a more important purpose, and that purpose was to be there
amongst the boys and their feelings and actions. We were able to talk to
many young men and in talking to them, we found out they realized that they
had a purpose in being there. That purpose was you sitting here, and
their mothers and fathers and their brothers and sisters and their wives and
their beloved ones, and they were glad that they were there, and glad that
they were fighting for this country.
We went to many hospitals, and we tried to boost the morale of young
men who were injured and would never be the same. And they realized
this. But they had the courage, and they were so wonderful m their thoughts
of saying that if they had to do it again, they would, because they loved
their country.
I learned so much through this trip. I learned so much from the young
men there, and in every man’s eye there was one look, and that was a look
of gratitude. They couldn’t show enough gratitude for what you were doing
there.
And at this point, I would like to say that you all honor Bob Hope.
Well, I think the world of him. I think he is not only the greatest entertainer in the world, but he is the most wonderful man I know. He is sincere
and humble, and the men think of him this way. I was so happy to be a part
of the trip, to be a part of Bob Hope’s show. We loved our trip over there,
and when we put on our last show, our eyes were full of tears, because we
know that this was the last show that we would be amongst the boys. And
because of the very, very tight security, the boys wouldn’t know until the
night before or even that morning that we were coming, and it was very*
very short notice before you would go out on the stage. And you couldn t
see the end of the crowd. And that is how many that wanted to see the show.
And I am so happy that I had a chance to be part of this. If I ever do have
a chance to do so again, I will. And I hope to go back to Viet Nam again.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I think the welcome you have received, the response from these men indicates our appreciation to you for the
wonderful work you are doing on behalf of God and Country and the men in
the service, and before you leave, I would like to introduce another gracious
Virginian, I would like to introduce my wife to the Committee.
. . . Mrs. Eldon James acknowledged her introduction.
. .. Miss U.S.A., 1966 was escorted from the rostrum.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and carried, the following report was received and filed:
50
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
REPORT OF NATIONAL AMERICANISM COMMISSION
Daniel J. O’Connor (New York), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN O’CONNOR: Mr. Commander, members of
the National Executive Committee, even with the Stars and Stripes in my
eyes and the shamrock in my voice, it is a heck of a position to be placed
in to follow the act we just had.
. . . National Vice Commander Phillips in the Chair.
The National Americanism Commission met in the National Executive Committee Room, National Headquarters, The American Legion, Indianapolis,
Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966. There were nineteen members of the Commission present; National Commander’s Representative, Mr. Donald G. Hanning;
Dr. J. E. Martie, Chairman of the Counter-Subversive Activities Committee;
an
_d National Executive Committee Liaison to the National Americanism Commission, Mr. L. O. Bickel of West Virginia. The members of the Commission
were delighted to have as a guest during their deliberations Mrs. Charles
G. Shaw of Paxton, Illinois, National Chairman of the Americanism Committee of the American Legion Auxiliary. Also present was National Chaplain Rev. Alfred C. Thompson.
In the interest of conserving your valuable time, this Report will deal
briefly with the operations of the programs and recommendations on resolutions considered at this meeting.
LEGION BASEBALL
Progress of the 1966 season was reviewed with strong indications of expanding activity in many areas in keeping with the exploding youth population. Staff preparations for the tournaments, supervised by National Headquarters, which will climax the 41st year of competition, are progressing satisfactorily.
Invitations for 1967 Regional Tournaments were studied, with awards
being made as follows:
Regional No. 1—Manchester, New Hampshire
Regional No. 2—Bridgeton, New Jersey
Regional No. 3—Gadsden, Alabama ,
Regional No. 4—Memphis, Tennessee
Regional No. 5—Canton, Illinois
Regional No. 6—Hastings, Nebraska
Regional No. 7—Helena, Montana
Regional No. 8—Ontario, California
Invitations for the 1968 World Series were received from two communities.
After considerable discussion and consideration, Manchester, New Hampshire (Henry J. Sweeney Post No. 2) was awarded this important event. A
bid was also received from Bridgeton, New Jersey.
Pairings for the 1966 Tournaments were made and schedules were approved. Location of these Tournaments was assigned a year ago.
D&fes and Pa'r'nSs for the 1967 World Series, previously awarded to
Memphis, Tennessee, were approved from August 28 through September 4,
Eddie Fisher, of the Chicago White Sox, was designated as the 1965
American Legion Baseball Graduate of the Year. Commander L. Eldon James
is scheduled to present the award in program ceremonies at Chicago, July 30.
Your attention is drawn to the fact that Babe Ruth League, Inc., a youth
baseball organization previously functioning in the 13-15 year-old age bracket
has announced a program of expansion into the 16-18 year-old age group!
ihis is in direct competition with our American Legion Baseball Program.
A representative of the Babe Ruth League Program met with Director Webb,
Assistant Director Rulon of this Commission, and me in Indianapolis, March
S ted there
ilevel.
' , em
v? we seriously
. would question.
be no conflict
programs
the local
This
The between
matter these
will be
observedat carefully
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
51
throughout the summer in all parts of the country. Should any of you have
personal knowledge of problems developing between The American Legion
Baseball Program and the Babe Ruth League, the National Americanism Commission would appreciate your bringing the circumstances to our staff’s attention immediately. Gentlemen, I cannot overemphasize this part of this
report.
COUNTER-SUBVERSIVE
The present status of the National Americanism Commission’s publication,
Firing Line, was discussed by members of the Commission and it was the
consensus of opinion that it is more acceptable in its present form than it
ever has been and that the material therein can be utilized and quoted since
it is all factual and documented. We are continuing to stress the importance
of this publication and have been engaged in an extensive promotional campaign during recent months. Copies were sent to 13,000 American Legion
Auxiliary Units, with an accompanying letter from Mrs. Charles G. Shaw,
National Chairman of the Americanism Committee of the American Legion
Auxiliary, urging them to subscribe to this publication and then distribute
copies to school libraries and public libraries; copies have gone to . all members of the Americanism Commission, all members of the Americanism Council and members of the Counter-Subversive Activities Committee, which, means
that approximately 1,500 of these individuals have been reached; additionally,
some 35,000 Post Commanders and Post Adjutants have received copies
through the pages of Advance, In the near future, a letter, over the signature
of Dr. J. E. Martie, Chairman, will be addressed to all members of the
Counter-Subversive Activities Committee, urging that they support this
publication in a positive way. We are happy to report that income for t inng
Line so far this year is up $1,000 over the corresponding period last year.
We definitely feel this is a direct result of this promotional program and
we would like to mention that, in any type of promotion, a 4% or o% return
is considered excellent.
This year, we have again made up a Sample copy of Firing Line for
insertion in Department Convention packets. Director Webb sent a letter to
all Departments, advising them of the availability of this Sample copy and
enclosed an order blank for their convenience. The response has been overwhelming and we are happy to report that to date we have received requests
from 39 Departments for a total of 46,350 copies.
Correspondence dealing with counter-subversive subjects continues to be
heavy. This involves careful study and evaluation of each letter before a
reply is forwarded. It has been and continues to be the policy of this Uommission to answer all correspondence, no matter how difficult and involved
it is.
ORATORICAL CONTEST
The following dates for the 1967 National High School Oratorical Contest
were adopted by the Americanism Commission:
a. National Regional Contests, Monday, April 3, 1967
b. National Sectional Contests, Monday, April 10, 1967
c. National Finals Contest, Thursday, April 13,1967
d. Deadline date for Departments to certify their State winners to the
National Contest, March 20, 1967.
After due deliberation on the seven Departments who had submitted invitations, the 1967 Contest was awarded to the Department of Nebraska.
Your Commission recommends the sponsorship of a meeting here at National Headquarters for Department Oratorical Chairmen to review procedures, rules and to update phases of the National Oratorical program. It is
believed this will be very valuable to the future of the program and lead to
greater support and participation within and outside of our organization.
Plans for the conference will be forwarded to each Department with a request
that each Department Oratorical Contest Chairman be present to participate.
Each member of the National Executive Committee will receive copies of the
52
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
correspondence and we urge your support in helping the Americanism Commission to make this first Oratorical Conference a success.
EDUCATION AND SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM
A meeting of the Joint Committee of The American Legion and the National Education Association was held on April 30, May 1-2, where emphasis
was given to common interests in the field of education.
It was reported that the Joint Committee’s brochure on the new program
Homebase had a distribution in excess of 100,000 copies since its adoption
at the National Convention in Portland, Oregon. Requests for the material
revealed its wide use among schools as well as community groups outside the
sponsoring organizations.
During the school year requests for Guidelines for Teaching About Communism, exceeded 17,500 copies, with most of the copies going to future social
studies teachers currently attending colleges.
The Education and Scholarship program has continued to expand and
serves the increased number of high school and college students. The annual
distribution of the fifteenth edition of Need A Lift? will exceed 109,000 copies.
The updated popular A Guide for Parents and Students, which is provided
to students at all levels of high school, has had a distribution in excess of
one-half million copies since school started last fall.
OTHER PROGRAMS
The Americanism Commission expressed strong support for our continued
efforts in implementing our programs as they relate to Boys’ Clubs, Boy
Scouts, Boys State, Boys Nation, and other programs administered by this
Commission. I might add here that, at the session of the 1966 Boys Nation
program to be held on the campus of the University of Maryland, the subject
of cold war education will he included as an area of study for thsse young
men.
CONCLUSION
We are grateful to this National Executive Committee, the Finance Commission and The American Legion Magazine for their splendid cooperation
and assistance in promoting the Americanism Youth programs.
We have a tentative program scheduled on the campus of the University
of Maryland and we hope to have a member of the “Green Berets” present
to give an account of his experiences in South Viet Nam.
Just before I conclude as I give you the recommendations on the Resolutions, I would like to make a very terse observation, and I ask for your
forbearance and attention.
My dear friends, the American Flag has been desecrated on college campuses in this, country, and it has been desecrated on the so-called stage in
Greenwich Village in New York City, and while your National Commander
m his role as the leader of our great organization asked the President of the
United States by letter only a few weeks ago to call a White House conference on the origin of the United States Flag, he received an answer of
encouragement in this sense, that The American Legion was advised, and he
was advised to have the Flag Code revision taken up with the Congress of
the United States.
. Well, I submit to you that it will be given to you by Roy Stone in a few
minutes from now, a resolution which I feel merits your very share and
devoted attention.
You know that it was no crime to assassinate President Kennedy Well
it is no crime to desecrate the American Flag, federally. It is no crime to
spit on it or destroy it. Now the time has come for the greatest veterans
organization m the world to support legislation making it a crime to desecrate the American Flag.
My dear friends, one final observation concerning the Babe Ruth League.
You know as well as I do that since the first day of June, 1925, Legionnaire
volunteers, giving their time and their effort and their talents have made
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
53
our American Legion Baseball Program the magnificent accomplishment that
it is and of which we are proud. But this competition from the Babe Ruth
League is not coming from men who have the ideals of American youth at
heart in the same manner as you have. Rather, they are men who are receiving executive salaries pouring out through all parts of the country seeking commercial as well as major league support to increase that subsidy, and
the time has come for us to consider some increased financial support for
our American Legion Baseball Program. And this means that we will have
to go before the major leagues to seek an increased subsidy. And we will also
not frown upon any legitimate proposition put to us by an enterprise, that
is not identified with alcohol or tobacco, so that we shall not be criticized
in what we are attempting to do in order to expand our baseball program
because of the youth explosion in this country and these population statistics
mean that we in the National Americanism Commission .must look to the
future and not rest on our laurels. And that is why it is important that we
have increased support for our baseball program.
Gentlemen, going to the resolutions:
At the meeting of the National Americanism Commission, held at National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966, the Commission considered a total of seventeen (17) resolutions, which were acted upon
as follows: Action was deferred on two (2) resolutions; nine (9) resolutions
were recommended for rejection; four (4) resolutions were recommence
for approval and two (2) were consolidated and recommended for approva .
Defer Action
Resolution, Register No. 1238 (Michigan)—Subject: Opposition to Hiring of Professors and Teachers Who Are Not Loyal to United States Government.
Resolution, Register No. 1240 (Pennsylvania)—Subject: Protesting An
Individual’s Unpatriotic Actions Against United States Government s Policy
in Viet Nam.
Rejected
Resolution No. 10 (Florida)—Subject: Display of the American Flag.
Reason: Contrary to the established policy of The American Legion.
Resolution No. 88 (Massachusetts)—Subject: Change Rule 8 of American Legion Baseball Rules. And I submit that they might have made a mistake or a typographical error on Rule 8, they were probably referring to
Rule 3. Reason: Contrary to the established successful policy of The American
Legion.
Resolution No. 388 (Louisiana)—Subject:
Endorsement of Statement
Concerning Communist Strategy. Reason: Can be handled administratively
by a letter to said organization.
I happen to be a member of that organization, and certainly there will be
no affront of our handling this matter administratively.
. . . National Commander James resumed the Chair.
Resolution No. 1212 (New Jersey)—Subject: Amend American Legion
Baseball Rules. Reason: Contrary to the established successful policy of
The American Legion and the expressed recommendation of the Department
Baseball Chairmen.
Resolution, Register No. 1219 (New Jersey)—Subject: American Legion
Baseball Rule Book Revision. Reason: Already the established policy of
The American Legion and, in the absence of documentation as to the need
for a change, the rule remains the successful policy of The American Legion.
Resolution, Register No. 1225 (Tennessee)—Subject:
South Viet Nam
Demonstrations. Reason: Already the established policy of The American Legion through Resolution No. 19, adopted by the National Executive Committee,
May, 1965.
54
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
Resolution, Register No. 1227 (New York)—Subject:
Opposition To
Anti-American Demonstrations. Reason: Already the established policy of
The American Legion through Resolution No. 19, adopted by the National
Executive Committee, May, 1965.
Resolution, Register No. 1239 (Rhode Island)—Subject: Amendment to
the United States Flag Code. This is praiseworthy, but it is not one from
the standpoint that we thought we could implement.
Resolution, Register No. 1244 (Pennsylvania)—Subject: Change in Rules
National High School Oratorical Contest. Reason: A Department may hold
its Oratorical Contest at any time prior to the deadline.
Recommended For Approval
Resolution No. 10 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject:
ning Religious Programs in the Job Corps Centers.
Plan-
Resolution No. 11 (Pennsylvania Register No. 1242) and (District of
Columbia Register No. 1253)—Subject: Support Legislation Which Would
Make It a Crime to Desecrate the United States Flag.
Resolution No. 12 (New York Register No. 1228)—Subject: Daily Display of the American Flag Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam.
Resolution No. 16 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject: Support Legislation to Amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to Make
Provisions for Necessary Travel Control for United States Residents Outside
of This Country.
Resolution No. 20 (National Americanism Commission)—Subject: Change
in the Method of Selecting the Winner of the William Randolph Hearst
Trophy.
Mr. Commander, that completes our report.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: I move the report be received
and filed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I wonder if, Committeeman Donaldson, if you will alter that motion to receive and file, to receive and file the
first five pages down to “Recommendations on Resolutions.”
MR. DONALDSON: I accept that amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the motion?
MR. LEONARD, Connecticut: I second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded to receive and file that part of the report that goes through page
five; all those in favor signify by saying aye; all opposed no. The ayes
have it and it is so ordered. The first five pages of the report are received
and filed. Committeeman Stone.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL AMERICANISM COMMISSION
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, I move that
the part of the report that deals with the rejected resolutions, deferred action resolutions, be adopted.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: May I make an inquiry? The motion is to approve that part of the report beginning on page six that includes
deferred action and rejected action?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded. All those in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes
have it and it is carried.
Committee Chairman Stone.
55
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were approved:
“Planning Religious Programs in the Job Corps Centers”
Resolution No. 10 (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission).
WHEREAS, The Government of the United States of America has established centers for the training of unemployed young people of our Nation so
that they can be assisted in assuming a meaningful and profitable part in
American Society; and
WHEREAS, The provision for regular religious ministries of Job Corps
Centers has not been provided; and
WHEREAS, The Conference of the Department Chaplains of The American Legion, meeting in Indianapolis, Indiana, on November 4, 1965, went on
record recommending to American Legion Posts located in areas having Job
Corps Centers that, as a part of their program of Service to God and Country, Post Chaplains devise ways and means to initiate action among ami cooperation with churches to provide religious services at Job Corps Centers,
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis,. Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion go on record endorsing the action of the Department Chaplains Conference as heretofore stated, and that a recommendation be made to the Job Corps to do its part in planning more intensive
religious programs in the Job Corps Centers.
“Support Legislation Which Would Make It a Crime to Desecrate the
United States Flag”
Resolution No. 11 (Res. Reg. No. 1242 and No. 1253)
(Submitted by:
National Americanism Commission. (Approved: National Legislative Commission under Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, Wide national publicity has been given to groups and individuals who have demonstrated against the foreign policy of the United States
in Yiet Nam; and
WHEREAS, These demonstrations have at times included desecration of
our National Colors by tearing, burning and trampling our Flag underfoot;
and
WHEREAS, Members of The American Legion and all loyal Americans
recognize our National Colors as the symbol of freedom and liberty; and
WHEREAS, It is this same freedom and liberty which permits these individuals the freedom of demonstration; and
WHEREAS, Members of The American Legion and all loyal Americans
are violently opposed to any demonstration which results in dishonor and
desecration of our National Colors, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that it go on record as opposing any demonstration resulting in desecration of our National Colors, and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion support legislation which would
make it a crime, including a monetary fine or imprisonment or both, to
desecrate the Flag of the United States.
“Daily Display of the American Flag Until Peace is Restored in Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 12 (Res. Reg. No. 1228) (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission).
WHEREAS, The current Viet Nam war has been plagued with subversive actions on the part of minority groups within the citizenship of these
great United States of America by such actions as protest demonstrations
wherein there have been posters denouncing our support in View Nam, at-
56
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
tempted blocking of shipments to our troops, attempted blocking of troop
movement, burning of draft cards by professed objectors, and other related
incidents on our college and university campuses; and
WHEREAS, Our military personnel are in daily combat in Viet Nam,
being killed and wounded during this period of undeclared war; and
WHEREAS, It is the avowed policy of The American Legion to foster
and perpetuate a one hundred percent Americanism, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion rededicate itself through all its membership by
encouragement of flying the greatest symbol of this democracy of ours through
the daily display of the American Flag by each member until peace is restored in Viet Nam.
“Support Legislation to Amend the Immigration and Nationality Act
to Make Provisions for Necessary Travel Control for United States
Residents Outside of This Country”
Resolution No. 16 (Submitted by: National Americanism Commission.
(Approved: National Legislative Commission)).
WHEREAS, There has been introduced in the Senate a Bill (S 3243),
to amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to make provisions for necessary travel control for United States residents outside of this country; and
WHEREAS, A companion Bill (HR 14488), has been introduced in the
House of Representatives, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it is in full accord and support of the proposed legislation and that
copies of this resolution be forwarded to the President of the Senate and
Speaker of the House and to The American Legion Legislative Division.
“Change in the Method of Selecting the Winner of the William
Randolph Hearst Trophy”
Resolution No. 20 (Submitted by:
National Americanism Commission
(National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee.) (Approved: Internal Affairs Division)).
WHEREAS, the William Randolph Hearst Trophy is now awarded annually to that Department which is judged from written reports to have sponsored the best all around Americanism activities during the previous Legion
year—July 1 to July 1—with three members of the National Americanism
Commission acting as judges; and,
WHEREAS, in order to improve and enlarge competition for said Trophy
a change in the method of selecting the winner is needed; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion
in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that it
does hereby authorize the National Americanism Commission to change the
method of selecting the winner of the William Randolph Hearst Trophy in the
1966-67 Legion year, and subsequent years, from the present system, as heretofore outlined, to a system using a compilation by Departments, consisting of
a percentage point system based on information contained in the Americanism and Post Activities report forms, already in existence.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE : Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
ADDRESS BY ROBERT H. MILLER
Director of the Department of State’s Viet Nam Working Group
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Gentlemen and guests of the
Committee, may I have your attention, please? Those who do not have seats,
would you make yourself comfortable?
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
57
We have a special speaker at this time who has just come in from Washington to talk off the record. If there are any people here inclined to take
notes for reporting to the news media or recording any of this proceeding,
I would ask that they desist. The speaker is here to provide us with an
up-to-date assessment of the Viet Nam situation.
This gentleman has been made available to us by the Department of State
upon my personal request to Secretary of State Dean Rusk to provide us
with a Department spokesman for a factual presentation.
Mr. Robert H. Miller is Director of the Viet Nam Working Group within
the State Department. He is a native of Washington State, received his AB
Degree from Stanford University, and his Masters from Harvard. He is a
veteran of service in the United States Army from 1945 to 1947. Mr. Miller
entered the Foreign Service of the United States in 1951, and since then has
served in our NATO mission in Paris, and in our Embassy at Saigon. In
Viet Nam, he served under three United States Ambassadors from 1962 to
1965. His last assignment there was as Deputy Chief of the Political Section.
I am pleased to present to this Committee at this time Mr. Robert H.
Miller, Director of the Department of State’s Viet Nam Working Group.
Mr. Miller spoke to the National Executive Committee off the record.
REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5, 1966
by
Thomas E. Whelan (North Dakota), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
You have been furnished a copy of the Advance Report of the Foreign
Relations Commission covering the action taken at the Washington Conference meetings held 1, 2 and 3 March 1966.
An Executive Section of the Commission met at National Headquarters 2, 3
and 4 May 1966 to consider matters that have arisen since the March meeting.
Present were Thomas E. Whelan, North Dakota, Chairman; Henry H. Dudley and John H. Keriakedes, Nebraska. Allyn C. Donaldson, District of Columbia, Chairman NEC Liaison Committee also met with the members of
your Commission.
The Section approved of the final resolution forms to implement the recommendations of the Advance Report and agreed that three Register Resolutions, filed since the March Meeting, should be referred to the Pre-Convention session of the Commission.
The Section was saddened by the report of the untimely passing of John
J. Barnhardt, North Carolina, long-time member of the Commission. His astute
and timely counsel and rare good humor will be greatly missed by all members
of the Commission and The American Legion as well as his community, state
and nation.
This concludes the report of actions taken at this Indianapolis Meeting.
Respectfully submitted,
THOMAS E. WHELAN, Chairman
The Advance Report of the National Foreign Relations Commission
is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee:
Your Foreign Relations Commission met as authorized in Washington,
D. C., on March 1, 2, and 3, 1966, in conjunction with the 6th Annual Wash-
58
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
ington Conference of The American Legion. All sessions were held in the
Hall of Flags Auditorium of the Legion Building, other than for a visit to
the Department of State.
The following members of the Commission were present:
Thomas E. Whelan, Chairman, North Dakota
James P. Heneghan, Vice Chairman, New York
Frank E. Barnett, Commander’s Representative, Illinois
John J. Barnhardt, North Carolina
Jack Beck, Pennsylvania
Fred Colehour, Illinois
William T. Coyner, Virginia
Allyn C. Donaldson, District of Columbia
Henry H. Dudley, Nebraska
Walter C. Head, Jr., Alabama
E. Dean Hunter, Colorado
Rogers Kelly, Texas
John H. Keriakedes, Nebraska
Jacob Kessler, Massachusetts
Thomas J. Kirk, Mississippi
Frank K. Knapp, Wyoming
George T. Lewis, Jr., Tennessee
Eli A. Marcoux, New Hampshire
Frost P. Patterson, Iowa
Dr. Carl J. Rees, Delaware
M. A. Fred Rennie, Oklahoma
David C. Stripling, Georgia
Norbert Schmelkes, Mexico, Ex Officio
In addition to Norbert Schmelkes, Chairman of the Foreign Relations
Council, the following Vice Chairmen of the Council participated in the Commission’s program:
M. C. “Mike” Gehr, Louisiana; George Vieto, Canal
Zone; and Herbert D. Black, South Carolina. Representing the NEC Liaison
Subcommittee throughout the meetings were: Allyn C. Donaldson, District
of Columbia, Chairman; and Gilberto M. Font, Puerto Rico. The Commission
was pleased also to have former chairman and Past National Vice Commander Emilio S. Iglesias present during the meetings.
Miss Vivian M. Titus, Chairman, Foreign Relations Committee, the American Legion Auxiliary, served as the Auxiliary’s liaison representative and
provided the Commission with a report on the Auxiliary’s 1966 foreign relations project, the Philippines Barrio Program. In this project, the Auxiliary
raises funds to furnish—in cooperation with CARE—tools and self-help
supplies for Philippine villagers. Miss Titus also presented the Auxiliary’s
recently developed slide series on its over-all foreign relations program.
Through the services of Mr. Walter McPherson of the Department of
State’s Office of Public Services, the Commission received a series of special
briefings at the Department, on the morning of March 2. The scheduled
speakers on this occasion were: Robert M. Sayre, Deputy Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Inter-American Affairs; J. Robert Schaetzel, Deputy Assytont Secretary Bureau of European Affairs; and, Thomas S. Estes,
United States Ambassador to Upper Volta.
During this session, the Commission was greatly honored by the appearance0for
! Secretary
of State
Dean with
Rusk.our
Mr.
Rusk, at
initiative
had
asked
an opportunity
to meet
members
andhisto own
discuss
informally
the key issues concerning United States involvement in Viet Nam. National
Commander Eldon James attended this portion of the morning’s program
and asked the Secretary for his thoughts as to additional ways in which the
Legion might be helpful in bolstering public support for United States efforts m Viet Nam. Mr. Rusk s response was to the effect that local Posts of
The American Legion would be ideally suited for serving to bring about
greater understanding of the Vietnamese conflict, the nature of the United
States commitment to South Viet Nam, and the relationship of the struggle
there to our own security interests. He pointed out that the Legion could
provide the necessary leadership to help solidify public support for the ad-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
59
ministration’s Viet Nam policy by sponsoring forums in which community
leaders and representatives of other patriotic and civic organizations might
take part.
In the meetings at the Legion Building, the Commission’s program included addresses by: Ambassador Jacob D. Beam and General Fred M. Dean,
Assistant Directors of the United States Arms Control and Disarmament
Agency; Ambassador Leonard Unger, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State
for Far Eastern Affairs (and Chairman, Viet Nam Coordinating Committee) ; General Harry G. Woodbury, Engineering Agent for the AtlanticPacific Interoceanic Canal Study Commission; William J. Crockett, Deputy
Under Secretary of State for Administration; and, Frank R. Barnett, President of the National Strategy Information Center (also National Commander’s
Representative on the Foreign Relations Commission). In addition, Allyn C.
Donaldson, Chairman, NEC Foreign Relations Liaison Subcommittee, provided
the Commission with a comprehensive report on the Newcomb Mott case, the
American who was imprisoned in the USSR last Fall for entering that country without a visa, and who allegedly took his own life while being transported
to a labor camp. Mr. Donaldson is Director of the State Department’s
Office of Special Consular Services. Wilbur Walker, Adjutant of the Department of Virginia, spoke to the Commission as representative of W. C. “Dan”
Daniel, Coordinator of the Foreign Relations-National Security Commissions.
Past National Commander Daniel was unable to be present personally by
reason of his duties as a member of the Senate of the Virginia State Legislature. Mr. Walker furnished the Commission with a report on Commander
James’ October visit to Viet Nam, and on the purposes and progress of
The American Legion’s Viet Nam Relief Fund.
On the evening of March 1, the Department of State American Legion Post No. 68, District of Columbia Department, held a reception honoring
the members of the Foreign Relations Commission. This took place in the
Diplomatic Suite of the State Department Building. The affair was attended
by Secretary of State Rusk and other principal officers of the Department;
by National Commander Eldon James and other Legion officials; by Mrs.
Walter H. Glynn, National President of the Auxiliary, and members of her
party. Approximately 350 persons were present, most of whom were employees of the Department of State. The Commission unanimously approved a
resolution of appreciation to Commander George S. Knight and the members of Post 68.
In its business session, the Commission dealt with two pending resolutions
referred for study by the 1965 National Convention. They are identified below,
with an indication of the action taken on each.
Resolution No. 259 (Mexico)—“Employment of American Citizens Abroad
by United States Department of State.”
The Commission accepted the recommendation of the subcommittee, to which
this resolution was assigned for study, to the effect that it be disapproved.
The subcommittee took into its consideration the information contained in the
letter of February 7, 1966, from the Deputy Under Secretary of State for
Administration to the Commission’s staff liaison. The letter reviewed the
State Department’s policies concerning the hiring by its overseas posts of
Americans residing abroad and agreed with the resolution’s “general proposition that Americans resident overseas constitute a valuable actual and
potential asset to the Department.” It went on to report that, on December
8, 1965, all overseas posts were asked to prepare a study on the availability
in their respective areas of citizens of the United States qualified for employment, and an analysis of the types of positions for which resident
Americans could be employed “in place of long-term staff employees available for world-wide service.” These reports have not as yet been received
from all posts. The Commission’s staff is instructed to remain informed concerning the findings of this study, which may lead to further liberalization
of State Department policy on employment of Americans residing abroad.
Resolution No. 439 (Oregon)—“Support United States Program of Establishing Free Educational Television in Free Foreign Countries.”
80
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
The subcommittee which studied this resolution felt that it was too narrow
in scope and, in order not to prejudice the case it makes for greater use of
educational TV in the underdeveloped nations which the United States is
attempting to help, recommended that it be returned to the originating department for revision if the department sees fit. The subcommittee suggested that the intent of the resolution might be broadened to include reference to all modern techniques of assistance to underdeveloped countries, in
keeping with The American Legion’s overall position on the United States
foreign aid program. The Commission accepted the recommendation and, upon
the filing of this report, the staff will proceed to refer the matter back to
the department concerned, with a full explanation.
The Commission had before it only one “register” resolution for study.
This is Register No. 1225, on the subject of “South Viet Nam Demonstrations,” submitted by the Tennessee Department Executive Committee. The
resolution is concerned with demonstrations within this country against United
States policy in Viet Nam. The Commission therefore believes that the resolution should be reassigned to the Americanism Commission. This would be in
keeping with the policy followed at the last National Convention, whereby
resolutions dealing with the internal or domestic aspects of our Government’s
Viet Nam position were handled through the Convention Committee on Americanism.
In addition to the foregoing actions, the Commission approved the report of
its special subcommittee on new resolutions as follows:
I. That the Commission recommend that the National Executive Committee,
by appropriate resolution—
A. Commend the administration’s policy of support for Viet Nam;
B. Reiterate the position of The American Legion on Viet Nam, as stated
at Portland and previously; and
C. Urge the taking of more vigorous measures for halting the flow of
supplies to the enemy, as military judgment determines necessary, including denial of the use of the port of Haiphong (by blockading, mining, bombing, or whatever means are required).
II. That the Commission recommend the approval by the National Executive
Committee of an American Legion Post program of support for United States
efforts, in keeping with the suggestion of the Secretary of State. For such a
program, the Commission contemplates that appropriate informational materials would be made available to posts, through department headquarters,
for the use of local Legion representatives in organizing and leading community-wide forums on support of United States policy in Viet Nam. Information on availability of visual aids would also be disseminated regularly,
as has already been done (through Advance and The American Legion News
Service) in the case of certain films produced by the armed services. The
Commission staff would stand ready to provide specific information as required by posts implementing this worthwhile patriotic program.
Resolutions to give effect to these recommendations have been prepared
and submitted to your Subcommittee on Resolutions.
... Upon motion by Mr. Wilson, Florida, seconded by Mr. Donaldson,
District of Columbia, the report was received and filed except for the resolutions.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are there resolutions, Mr. Chairman?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we have two
resolutions from the Foreign Relations Commission which have been received in the last hour and one half. They are not on the gentlemen’s desks
and if it is the desire of the National Executive Committeemen I will read
the resolutions in full and take them up at this time, otherwise we will wait
the pleasure of the National Executive Committee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What is your pleasure gentlemen? Do you want to hear the resolutions read or do you want to wait for
the digest?
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
61
MR. WILSON, Florida: I make a motion to defer until the digest is here.
. . . The motion was seconded.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We will consider that as consent,
and we will go on.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: On the subject that is under
discussion, I have a proposal to submit to this Commission if you want me to
submit it at this time, the processing of the present policy in the District of
Columbia. We can use this time now.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I think it better go to the Commission. Has it been to the Commission? Are you submitting a proposal directly to this Committee?
MR. DONALDSON: No, I am submitting a proposed procedure which
the various Posts may undertake to carry out our policy and carry out the
request of General Green.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is this coming from the Commission or coming directly from you?
MR. DONALDSON: Directly from me.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, sir.
MR. DONALDSON: Mr. Commander, members of the Commission, you
will recall that last October General Green of the Marine Corps appeared
before this Committee and asked for your assistance in carrying out their
program in the Viet Nam.
After his appearance before this Commission, we went back to Washington, D. C. and asked the General, “What can we do to help you out?” It
developed that the Marine Corps has taken a number of pictures of action
in Viet Nam. They have developed a program whereby these colored pictures in some cases are sent to the individual who requested to have a meeting. We used the District of Columbia for a guinea pig to see how it worked.
We undertook to ask the employees of the Department of State to look
at two pictures, one was called “The Battle”; the other was called “Full
Blaze.”
“The Battle” is an actual operation in Viet Nam in which the functional operation of the Marine Corps takes place. Here you see in action
what is taking place in Viet Nam. As I heard questions from the floor here
today, what is taking place, and what is going on in Viet Nam. There is an
old Chinese saying that a picture is worth 1,000 words, and these pictures
are worth many thousands of words.
On the first exhibit, 450 people filled the auditorium. We had hoped to
hold a second showing. We tried then at the departmental monthly meeting,
and we showed the pictures again, and they were well received. It is now
accepted that the Marine Corps will undertake this same service to Posts
throughout the United States of America.
Now, the “Full Blaze” shows in operation the handling of the public under the community program. This is what your troops are doing now to try
and engender the good will and bring behind our fighting forces a sense of
cooperation instead of one of antagonism that has existed for some time.
A team consisting of three with a hand-carried projector and a film will
come to your Post any place in the United States, show the picture and give
a statement of how things are going as the Marine Corps sees it.
Now, there is being distributed to you a list which is marked “Location
of NCR Training Facilities.” These are all the states, the nearest Post
of the Marine Corps. You can address them and ask them to send a film
and if you want to have it shown it will be shown.
Your second list is a list of the films which we have set up. We have
here in the library of the Headquarters these films. The Adjutant tells me
that the demand is substantial, there is a waiting list. Now if you want it
done in your local community, the Marine Corps will send out the team to
show you these films. We suggest that you invite in the ministers, the com-
62
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
munity leaders, the Mayor, people who want to know what is going: on in
Viet Nam.
Our experience was that people would come to us and say, “I would like
to contribute to your CARE program to help out Viet Nam. We have added
to the membership of Posts the people that want to be affiliated because of
the work that we are doing.
I commend the Commander for his “Show Your Colors” Program. We
have now over $100,000 collected in funds that are being used in Viet Nam
on this community program.
This will assist the furtherance of both of these programs.
You also have in what is being distributed to you, what is known as the
information sheet on the Marine Corps programs. And then you will get the
throwaway which is given to all the public and attached to it is a CARE
program envelope with which your contributions could be made to CARE
to carry out this program.
We feel this has been a successful operation. We recommend it to you
throughout the country, and we hope that you will turn to the Marine
Corps and let them know what your desires are when it comes to the tvDe
of picture you want to see.
., There is a new one now, the “Corps Men.” This picture originates on
the battlefield. They practically pick up the soldier as he is shot. He is carried then into the Field Headquarters, the Red Cross Unit, onto the flattop, back to the United States. These are action photographs, and
I commend them to all of you to try and help the Marine Corps and our
forces in Viet Nam with your action at home, because we need the people
m the grass roots to understand why we are in Viet Nam, and I think
these pictures will tell the story better than all the speeches that we can
hear from people in this country. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Committeeman Donaldson, I thank
you for calling this to the attention of the Committee. Let me say this sir
we commend you for bringing to us and recommend to the members’here
that they take it to heart and explore its possibilities. Thank you very
The following report was duly received and filed:
REPORT OF THE
NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMISSION
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5, 1966
James V. Demarest (New York), Chairman
The National Convention Commission met on May 2-3, 1966 with the following members present:
Convention Commission
James V. Demarest, Chairman, New York
Harry L. Foster, Vice Chairman, California
John H. Geiger, Illinois
Bert M. Count, Minnesota
Dr. A. R. Choppin, Louisiana
Thomas Roumell, Michigan
Harry K. Stinger, Pennsylvania
Lawrence E. Hoffman, Florida
John R. McNamara, New York
Donald M. McSween, Tennessee
Henry R. Kruse, Washington
Robert H. Hazen, Oregon
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
63
National Commander’s Representative
Thomas Coll, District of Columbia
NEC Liaison
Louis E. Drago, Chairman, New York
Advisory Board
Maurice Stember, New York
Jack Williams, North Dakota
Tommy E. Jones, West Virginia
Distinguished Guests Committee
A. L. Starshak, Chairman, Illinois
A final report was received from the President of the 1965 Convention
Corporation, Robert Hazen, on the 1965 Convention. Mr. Hazen will be making a report to the National Executive Committee at the conclusion of my
report.
The Chairman of the Contest Supervisory Committee, Don Birkett, appeared before the Commission and outlined certain administrative changes in
procedures to be followed in the conduct of the contest. Also, the Contest
Committee presented a resolution regarding indebtedness of uniformed groups
participating in contests at our National Conventions and this Commission
concurs in this action. The resolution is being submitted through the Subcommittee on Resolutions. From all indications, it would appear that there
will be tremendous contest activity in conjunction with this year’s National
Convention in Washington, D. C. It has been decided that the final Drum
and Bugle Corps Contest which is to be held at District of Columbia Stadium
on August 28, be of the same type as those contests held during the last
two years in that the five top junior corps and the five top senior corps will
participate in the final event.
As you gentlemen know, The Ford Motor Company has for many years
supplied the official autos for our National Conventions. However, during
our meetings we were informed that The Ford Motor Company, because
of a change in policy, could no longer carry on with this program and,
consequently, it is necessary for us to explore the possibility of securing this
type service from another manufacturer.
In view of the termination of our contract with Charles Thorpe of Football Publications for the solicitation of advertising in the National Convention Souvenir Program, authorization is requested for the acceptance of advertising that is offered us on a voluntary basis. A resolution on this subject is being submitted through the Subcommittee on Resolutions.
A report was received from Herbert J. Jacobi, President of the 1966
National Convention Corporation of the District of Columbia, relative to the
progress of plans for the convention and it appears that we can look forward
to an outstanding convention this year.
In recent years the number of cities interested in hosting one of our National Conventions has increased tremendously. A great deal of the Commission’s activities at all meetings involves presentations by these cities. Our
meeting here during the past two days has been no exception. Those cities
appearing before the Commission were:
New Orleans, Louisiana
Atlanta, Georgia
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Boston, Massachusetts
Phoenix, Arizona
Chicago, Illinois
Portland, Oregon
Indianapolis, Indiana
St. Louis, Missouri
Miami Beach, Florida
Also, telegrams were received from Houston, Texas reiterating that city s desire to host a National Convention.
64
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
It is recommended that tentative convention awards be made as follows:
1967—Boston, Massachusetts—August 25-31
1969—
Atlanta, Georgia—August 2
1970—
New Orleans, Louisiana—A
1971—
Phoenix, Arizona—August 2
As you are aware, a tentative award has already been made to the City of
Milwaukee, Wisconsin for the 1968 Convention, the dates there to be August
23-29.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES V. DEMAREST, Chairman
. . . Upon motion by Mr. Wilson, Florida, seconded by Mr. Watkins, Arizona, the report was accepted.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I recognize now the Chairman of the Subcommittee on Resolutions.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Satisfaction of Indebtedness of Uniformed Groups
at National Conventions”
Resolution No. 27 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission—National Contests Supervisory Committee).
WHEREAS, The American Legion annually sponsors numerous uniformed
groups contests at its National Convention; and
WHEREAS, such uniformed groups can and do much to contribute to the
reputation of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, the reputation of The American Legion may be damaged if
such uniformed groups do not satisfy their indebtedness incurred in the process of participating in The American Legion National Conventions; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
The American Legion recommends that effective with 1966 National Convention, in the event any uniformed group, at least 90 days prior to any National Convention shall not have satisfied all proper and legal indebtedness
incurred in the process of participation in a previous convention city, then it
shall be barred from future competition at any National Convention and shall
remain so barred until said indebtedness shall have been paid in full.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This comes from the Contests
Supervisory Committee; it has the approval of the Convention Commission
also. Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin and
adopted.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A of this
Committee, we have a Resolution 38 which you do not have on your desk, but
in the interests of the four-hour rule, Mr. Commander, we would take’this
up and then handle it in time for in the morning, otherwise we will have to
read it in the morning and possibly maybe some of the men would be late
m getting their planes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Unless I hear objection, this is
for information only, as it fulfills Rule 8-A, you may proceed.
“Authorization for National Adjutant of The American Legion to
Accept Advertising for National Convention Souvenir Program”
Resolution No. 38 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion has in the past and does now publish
a Convention Souvenir Program; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
65
WHEREAS, It has in the past employed the services of outside individuals and/or corporations to secure advertising for the said Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, At the present time The American Legion has no contractual
arrangement with any outside person, firm or corporation to solicit or secure
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It is the desire of The American Legion to have advertising contained in the Convention Souvenir Program—all of which is to be
handled by and through the office of the National Adjutant—now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5,
1966, that the National Adjutant be and he is hereby authorized to accept
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program together with the gross
proceeds thereof.
(Pursuant to Rule 8-A)
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A of this
Committee, this resolution was read at 3:25 p. m. on May 4th, and may the
record so indicate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Mr. Stone.
To conclude the Convention report, we will now call upon the President
of the 1965 Convention Committee, Bob Hazen of Portland, Oregon for his
final and concluding report.
REPORT OF 1965 NATIONAL CONVENTION
PRESIDENT ROBERT HAZEN: Mr. Commander James, members of
the National Executive Committee, I will be brief. I think you know the
success of our Portland Convention. You heard your Chairman Col. Demarest
report that Portland, Oregon made an official bid for 1975. That is what it
meant to us. We hope it will be honored when the time comes.
I just say to all of you once again, that Portland is indebted to you members here for granting us the Convention. I don’t think there is a day goes
by that some comment isn’t made in some circles regarding the fine Convention that was held in our city, and we are very indebted to you for coming,
and we do sincerely hope that you come back again.
I want to reiterate once again the fine work that your General Convention Manager Bill Miller did in handling our Convention. It was outstanding,
and I think you will find that the same thing is true in your next Convention.
The budget was $98,058. We went over the budget in income by $12,242,
and we went over budget by expense $1,398. So we had a net operating income of $10,844.02, and it is with great pleasure that I turn over to your National Commander a check from our National Convention Corporation on behalf of your corporate city and the Department of Oregon, a check for half
of that, the other half going to our Department, a check for $4,672.01, Mr.
Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Bob, may I say to you, that we are
grateful for the outstanding job that you and your co-workers did in Portland.
You have shown a profit in dollars and cents, but I am sure it is the
consensus of this group and all Legionnaires that visited Portland that you
showed a greater profit in the good will for your community the way our
people were treated there. I hear this everywhere I go throughout the country. Thank you very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION
James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
PUBLISHER O’NEIL: Mr. Commander and fellow members of the National Executive Committee, I am reporting for the Chairman, Jimmy Pow-
66
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
ers, Past National Commander, and Chairman of the Commission who cannot
be with us because of a bond issue operation in his county. He expresses
his regrets. I am submitting the report from him.
On your desk is a copy of the digest of the meeting held in New York
in February and subsequent to that, there have been some things that have
happened. There is an addendum to that report, both of these I recommend
to you for reading. This is the most important business, I believe operating
within The American Legion, and I commend you to the reading of this report and its supplement.
Now, in pursuit of what has taken place since that time, the operating
statement for the three months of The American Legion Magazine ending
March 31st, 1966 shows the Magazine operating well within its budget and
for this period the net gain to the Magazine totaled $131,090.47, or approximately $6,700 more than for the same period in 1965. It should be our hope
that we could maintain the pace established for the first three months, but
in view of our involvements, particularly as they relate to the operation forced
upon us by the Post Office Department, this seems unlikely.
In the report of the proceedings for February references were made to
the auditing and study to which The American Legion subscribes. This study
actually was a must for The American Legion Magazine if we hoped to receive any consideration in the advertising agencies. Each magazine has its
guaranteed circulation, as we do, of 2,500,000. But the Simmons auditing
study gives us a factor of measurement similar to those used in other publications, and for radio and TV presentations. If any questions develop in
your mind, I will be available tomorrow, Mr. National Commander, and to the
National Executive Committee, and of course for the rest of the day.
That concludes the report, thank you.
. . . The printed Advance Report of the National Publications Commission
is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION REPORT
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5,1966
by
Mr. James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
The meetings of the Publications Commission were held in New York City
on February 10th and 11th in the office of The American Legion Magazine
at 720 Fifth Avenue.
Presiding over the sessions was Past National Commander James E. Powers of Georgia, Chairman, and in attendance were the following Commission
members:
Adolph Bremer, Minnesota, Vice Chairman
ADVERTISING
Robert H. Wilder, Alabama, Chairman
Chris E. Hernandez, Georgia
Frank C. Love, New York
Morris Meyer, Mississippi
CIRCULATION PROMOTION
Benjamin B. Truskoski, Connecticut, Chairman
Howard E. Lohman, Minnesota
J. H. Morris, Louisiana
Wayne L. Talbert, Indiana
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
67
EDITORIAL
Raymond Fields, Oklahoma, Chairman
Bradley Stephens, California
Robert W. Mitchler, Illinois
Clovis Copeland, Arkansas
FINANCE-PERSONNEL
Dr. Charles R. Logan, Iowa, Chairman
Harry H. Schaffer, Pennsylvania
George D. Levy, South Carolina
MANUFACTURING
Charles E. Booth, West Virginia, Chairman
John Cicero, Pennsylvania
E. J. Cooper, Florida
E. Meade Wilson of Florida, Chairman of the National Executive Committee Liaison, also was present, as were Consultant Edward McSweeney of
New York, and Circulation Manager Dean B. Nelson of Indianapolis.
The following Commission members were absent: Lang Armstrong, Washington, because of a conflict in business commitments, and Congressman
Dague, Pennsylvania, due to illness in the family.
Members of the Editorial and Advertising Staffs joined Publisher James
F. O’Neil, Editor Robert B. Pitkin and Advertising Director Robert P. Redden
in participating in the deliberations.
Recommendations were adopted calling for the appointment by the National Commander of a Special Committee to study the ramifications that
have developed over the indiscriminate use of The American Legion Magazine
mailing lists with a view to seeking a clarification of the existing policy relating thereto.
Other matters discussed were the problems arising from resolutions adopted without complete information relating to the subject matter; computers and the conversion of the mailing list to make automated equipment
effective; the distribution of magazines to men in the Armed Forces; paper
and printing costs; advertising problems and the techniques being developed
in an effort to solve same and the impact of the editorial content and its
general acceptance.
It was recommended that $323.67 in editorial and art inventory items be
declared obsolete.
On the opening day, luncheon was held at the Metropolitan Club, at which
Mr. McSweeney reviewed the situation in the world of mass media, with
special reference to the status of The American Legion Magazine. Edgar A.
Grunwald, Editor and Publisher of Purchasing Week of the McGraw-Hill Publications, who has been writing the “Personal” column in The American Legion Magazine for ten years, also spoke. He discussed the general economic
picture, emphasizing the impact of the Viet Nam war as it relates to the
1966 financial outlook. In his opinion prices will rise, but living standards
will move ahead sharply as well.
Kenneth B. Haynes, President of the Fawcett-Haynes Printing Corporation, and Frank W. Whatton, Vice President, also attended the luncheon, as did
National Executive Committeemen Lou Drago of New York and William G.
McKinley of New Jersey, and the respective National Chairmen James V. Demarest (Convention) New York; Dan O’Connor (Americanism) of New YorkNew York Judge Advocate Frank Giordano and Legislative Director Herald
E. Stringer of the Washington Office. The latter addressed the Commission
meeting on Friday, announcing that one of the great Legislative goals of 1966
had been achieved with the passage of the “Cold War GI Bill” now awaiting
the anticipated signature of the President.
Mr. Haynes told of plans to erect a new 20 million dollar printing plant
in Louisville, expected to be ready for occupancy within three years. It is
68
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
to be a one-million square foot, one-floor building, providing an economical
and efficient layout that could inure to the benefit of The American Legion
Magazine.
Mr. O’Neil gave an account of his stewardship and that of his associates
during the past year. The American Legion Magazine returned a net profit,
or gain to the National Organization in 1965 in the sum of $616,952.80, or
$68,464.70 less than in 1964. Increased operating cost were—Printing, $12,000;
Payroll, $11,800 and Magazine Mailings, $5,600. The libel case award and
attorney’s fees, etc., amounted to $33,000 and another unanticipated outlay
was approximately $11,000 for the study resulting from the Zip Code directive of the Post Office Department. Total of all these items is $73,400.
Slight increases in advertising and subscription revenues were recorded
in 1965.
Announcement was made of the appointment of Edgar L. Schultz as Electronic Data Processing Supervisor. He will begin his duties on March 1st,
1966, and will participate in the decisions to be made shortly thereafter on
the type of computer to be installed at Indianapolis for the magazine, and
the service bureau to effect the conversion of the mailing list from the present system to a computerized version. It is anticipated that determination
will be made before April 1st as to the service bureau to do the conversion
and the computer to be installed at Indianapolis.
The non-member subscription status was reviewed by both Mr. Nelson
and Mr. O’Neil. The latter cited the fine work accomplished by Mr. Lohman in promoting yearly subscriptions to the magazine in his district in
Minnesota for placement in school libraries, doctors’ and dentists’ offices
and other places of exposure. Copies of the material used in the campaign
were distributed by Mr. Lohman.
Mr. Pitkin gave a run-down on the editorial accomplishments achieved
in 1965, stressing the fine reception of the articles. Both he and Mr. O’Neil
mentioned the lead story in the November, 1965, issue as being an instance
of great impact—The Systematic Terror of the Viet Cong. Its content becomes more valid as news comes to us from the war in Viet Nam. Hundreds
of thousands of reprints have been distributed. Among those engaged in this
operation are the members of the Junior Chamber of Commerce.
SIGNIFICANTLY, THE MUTUAL BROADCASTING SYSTEM ASKED EDITOR PITKIN TO PARTICIPATE IN A
BROADCAST ON THE ARTICLE OVER ITS NETWORK.
THIS ONE-HALF HOUR PROGRAM TITLED “THE BIG
LIE” WAS HEARD SATURDAY FEBRUARY 12, AT NOON.
THIS MORNING, FEBRUARY 15th, BOB RECEIVED A
CALL FROM MR. MOYERS AT THE WHITE HOUSE STATING THAT PRESIDENT JOHNSON HAD LISTENED TO
THE BROADCAST AND INVITED BOB TO COME IN FOR
A VISIT WITH THE PRESIDENT WHEN HE IS IN
WASHINGTON.
Mr. Redden explained some of the advertising plans with particular reference to the Simmons Study. The latter is an accepted measurement of
media among advertising agencies. It is hoped that its findings will become
an asset in promoting advertising sales. References also were made by Mr.
Redden to the more acceptable American Legion Magazine because of the
integrity of the editorial content.
The following reports were unanimously adopted:
ADVERTISING
Present were, Chairman Wilder and Messrs. Hernandez, Love and Meyer.
Advertising Director Redden took part in the proceedings.
The Simmons Report, which is expected out around April 15th was discussed. It considered what the Simmons Report could mean in regard to the
Magazine’s future advertising revenues. This Report, as it is understood, will
analyze the total readership of our Magazine and hopefully show the greater
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
69
buying power of the Legion audience. This should demonstrate to the advertising agencies and the accounts that we truly represent an effective advertising medium.
If the results from the Simmons Report are what the Committee hopes,
then we may expect that a substantial increase in national advertising will
follow.
The question of personnel was fully discussed. One new member has been
added to the staff within the last year—Mr. Mark Neider. He appears to be
making satisfactory progress and, further, the Committee anticipates the
hiring of an additional man in the very near future. It is hoped that there
will be less turnover in personnel in the future since the commission arrangements on new business, which has been established, should be substantial
enough to make it worthwhile for personnel to remain in our employ.
The Advertising Subcommittee notes with satisfaction that with. all the
difficulties encountered in the past year, the year ended with an increase
ip net advertising revenues over 1964.
CIRCULATION AND PROMOTION
Subcommittee members present included: Chairman Truskoski and Messrs.
Morris and Talbert.
Circulation Manager Nelson was present throughout the meeting, and
Mr. Wilson, NEC Liaison, and Chairman Powers participated in our deliberations at our invitation. Their views and thoughts were appreciated.
In his usual capable manner, Mr. Nelson, supplemented his remarks made
earlier to the Publications Commission by providing additional observations
on several subjects, including non-member subscriptions, indexing of 1 he
American Legion Magazine, operations of the Circulation Division and on
his experiences in recent months with data processing equipment and its allied problems. It was particularly noteworthy to hear Dean express the opinion that long range benefits will inure to The American Legion with the
installation of electronic equipment.
He suggested, and the Committee approved:
(1) The effort to promote and develop non-member subscription sales
by utilizing the resourcefulness of the American Legion Auxiliary
members, assuming that concurrence of the National Officers of
the Auxiliary is obtained.
(2) A letter similar in content to that directed to Post Commanders in
advance urging purchase of non-member subscriptions. to The
American Legion Magazine for residents of the respective communities of men now serving in the Armed Forces.
It is understood that Units would be urged to coordinate their efforts with
the local Posts.
We see no need to propose a recommendation on this matter knowing that
the Circulation Manager, with the approval of the Publisher, will explore this
possible source for increasing non-member subscriptions.
The Committee devoted a greater part of the session to the problem referred to us by resolution of the Commission, namely, the consideration of
alternatives, and the submission of recommendations on the use and sale of
American Legion membership rolls as mailing lists. In considering same, we
see a complicated problem filled with intangibles, temptations, advantages,
pitfalls, ramifications and obstacles. We do not feel confident to offer a
specific solution today. A comprehensive study of all aspects is essential.
Moreover, such a study involves national policy and in consequence the organization as a whole, and not merely The American Legion Magazine, is involved.
We believe that with background information furnished by the Publisher,
Chairman Powers and the Members of the National Executive Committee
Liaison, the National Commander of The American Legion will agree to
the necessity of appointing a representative group of American Legionnaires
who will tackle this problem on a broader and more comprehensive scale.
70
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
We offer the following recommendations: That the Publication Commission recommend the appointment by the National Commander of a Special
Committee who will study, review and consider the sale of American Legion
membership rolls as mailing lists, and to recommend the advisability of
amending, revising or promulgating policy for guidance of the national organization and its departments on this subject.
We appreciate the interest and consideration of all those who assisted us
in our deliberations.
EDITORIAL
Subcommittee members present were: Chairman Fields, and Messrs. Copeland, Mitchler and Stephens.
Mr. Wilson, NEC Liaison representative, visited with the Committee during its deliberations, and National Legislative Director Stringer was a guest
visitor.
Staff members present were: Editor Pitkin and A1 Marshall, Art Director; John Andreola, Assistant Editor and Roy Miller and James Swartz,
Associate Editors.
Mr. Stringer expressed satisfaction with the support given by the Magazine to the Legion’s National Legislative Program.
The Subcommittee members, the staff and visitors to the Subcommittee
earnestly discussed several subjects, including:
(1) The problem of improper resolutions to govern the administration or
content of the Magazine surviving Post, District and Department Conventions
and coming before the National Convention.
(2) The need to place copies of The American Legion Magazine in the
hands of present-day servicemen.
(3) The problem of the whole Legion, including the Magazine, in appealing to the varied interests of its diverse age-groups.
(4) The acceptance of the Legion and its Magazine in the various branches
of the Federal Government.
The Subcommittee adopted a motion that a suitable letter of appreciation
be sent to the Mutual Broadcasting System for its featuring of the article
The Systematic Terror of the Viet Cong on its Big Lie program, such
article having appeared in the November, 1965, issue of The American Legion
Magazine.
The Subcommittee adopted a motion approving the expenditure of editorial
funds for preliminary research in the development of some article ideas.
The Subcommittee approved a report of the Editor recommending the
killing of a total $323.67 of inventory in art and manuscript items. A copy
of the report is submitted herewith.
Ms. Voucher 2685:
Art Voucher 2146:
Art Vouchers 3489
3490
3491
3492
Art Voucher 3758
Translation from Soviet Political
Dictionary by Mrs. Helen Chavchavdze
Hanford: New York World’s Fair: Adams
Platnick: Vignettes of History:
eight charges in total on these
four vouchers, paid to Adams, Culver
Pix, Bettman Archives
Pitkin: Legion Far East Trip: Elliot
$150.00
7.52
163.85
2.30
$323.67
Respectfully submitted,
ROBERT B. PITKIN, Editor
FINANCE AND PERSONNEL
Members of the Finance-Personnel Subcommittee present were Chairman
Logan, and Messrs. Levy and Schaffer. Chairman Powers and National Executive Committee Liaison Representative Wilson also attended.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
71
We found all matters to be in order and in keeping with the decisions of
the Publications Commission.
The 1966 budget was accepted by the National Finance Commission and
the National Executive Committee without change, except as it related to
an across-the-board increase in salaries for all employees. This, too had
been anticipated because of the discussions at the pre-National Convention
Publications Commission meeting in Portland, Oregon.
In addition, the National Finance Commission and the National Executive
Committee has placed $300,000 in escrow to accommodate any possible expenditures concerning the transfer to a proposed computerized operation.
It is also understood that should added funds be necessary later in 1966
that they will in all likelihood be approved.
The Publications Division has operated during the year 1965 within its
proposed 1965 budget, and is continuing to do so in this early part of 1966.
Advertising income and membership revenues showed a slight increase in
1965 compared to ’64.
Relative to the personnel in the New York office and in the division of
publications in Indianapolis, we find a most satisfactory situation.
MANUFACTURING
The Subcommittee on Finance joined the Manufacturing Subcommittee in
the meeting in Publisher O’Neil’s office. Present for the Manufacturing Committee: Charles E. Booth, Chairman, West Virginia; John Cicero, Pennsylvania and E. J. Cooper, Florida.
An increase in the paper price of $10 per ton was noted. This will represent a boost of $40,000 to $50,000 in costs this year. It was included in the
budget for 1966.
The controversy between The American Legion Magazine and the FawcettHaynes Printing Corporation at Louisville, Kentucky, has been resolved in
favor of The American Legion Magazine on a satisfactory and apparently
permanent basis for the duration of the present contract.
Everything else concerning the production of the magazine appears to be
on an efficient and satisfactory basis to The American Legion Magazine,
and we are glad to be able to make such a report.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES E. POWERS, Chairman
. . . The Addendum to the National Publications Commission report is as
follows:
ADDENDUM
NATIONAL PUBLICATIONS COMMISSION REPORT
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Indianapolis, Indiana
May 4-5, 1966
Mr. James E. Powers (Georgia), Chairman
Mr. Commander and
Fellow Members of
The National Executive Committee:
The digest of the proceedings of the meetings of the Publications Commission held in New York on February 10th and 11th, 1966, have been distributed to you. With a view to bringing you up to date, I will now submit this addendum.
The American Legion Magazine is now in the process of creating the systems and the programs for the Electronic Data Processing equipment to be
72
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
installed at National Headquarters. Pursuant to the authority granted by the
National Executive Committee, a five-year contract has been entered into
with Honeywell for the leasing—with a purchase option—of an H-200. Delivery date is November.
The American Legion Magazine also has made arrangements with a service
bureau to convert the mailing lists to meet the Zip Code requirements of the
Post Office Department. This project will require at least six months to complete.
We are assembling what we consider to be a capable team to direct our
new activities. As the new system becomes operative on an installment basis,
the current one will be phased out. This, of course, is a major problem.
In summation, from a financial standpoint, the cost to The American
Legion of the arbitrary directive of the Post Office Department will total more
than a half million dollars. Under arrangements worked out with the Finance
Commission, the financing of same has and is being developed without any
impact, we hope, on the annual operating budget of The American Legion.
Conferences also have been held with the Membership and Post Activities
Division looking toward the most effective and most economic utilization of
the Electronic Data Processing equipment.
In connection therewith, consideration is being given to the establishment
of a new two-part membership card for 1968, with supplemental register
print-outs to provide alphabetical and Post listings for all American Legion
members for Department and Post records. You will be hearing more about
this development in the weeks ahead. It will be our purpose to cooperate
with the Membership folks in making the new facilities work to the advantage
of the respective Posts and Departments as well as National.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES E. POWERS, Chairman
Publications Commission
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is upon us
for a special order of business. You recall that special order is the consideration of Resolution No. 14 coming from the 50th Anniversary Committee. As
I recall, Mr. Stone, 14 and 17, and 14 has been read first.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I will read Resolution No. 14.
“50th Anniversary Observance of the Founding of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 14 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, the year 1969 will be the 50th anniversary year of the founding of The American Legion, and
WHEREAS, the 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th anniversary, and
WHEREAS, such a special 50th Anniversary Committee has been so appointed, and
WHEREAS, an Executive Section of said 50th Anniversary Committee
has held meetings on March 2 and 3, and May 2 and 3, and
WHEREAS, it is the consensus of the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee that it would be to the best interests of The American
Legion to retain the services of a public relations firm to guide and assist
The American Legion with its 50th anniversary observance, and
WHEREAS, the Executive Section of the 50th Anniversary Committee has
considered presentations from public relations firms and has a specific recommendation for the employment of such firm at an agreed cost in fees, outof-pocket expenses, and certain other additional costs, now, therefore, be it
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
73
RESOLVED by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana on May 4 and 5, 1966, that the National
Commander and the National Adjutant are hereby authorized and directed to
negotiate, with the guidance and approval of The American Legion Special
50th Anniversary Committee, and to execute a contract with the public relations and advertising firm of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc., said contract to extend over a period to conclude approximately December 31, 1969, with necessary stipulations for cancellation by either party in accordance with conditions of sound business practice, and be it further
RESOLVED that in consideration of services to be rendered by Bozell and
Jacobs, Inc. which services are to be set forth in all necessary detail in said
contract, The American Legion will agree to pay to the firm of Bozell and
Jacobs, Inc. agency fees not to exceed $250,000 during the life of said contract, and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall also provide for reimbursement to
representatives of Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. for out-of-pocket expenses not to
exceed $44,000 specifically required by The American Legion and incurred
in the service of The American Legion, said expenses to be itemized and submitted at regular intervals for audit and prior approval by the National
Adjutant and National Treasurer of The American Legion prior to payment,
and be it further
RESOLVED that said contract shall further provide that the firm of
Bozell and Jacobs, Inc. will submit to The American Legion at regular intervals Complete and itemized statements justifying all agency fees, out-ofpocket expenses, and any other charges to be provided for in said contract,
and be it further
R.ESOLVED that the National Executive Committee does authorize and
direct the 50th Anniversary Committee to determine and recommend such
other sum or sums that may be necessary, not to exceed $50,000, in connection With the 50th anniversary observance to be used for projects and programs requiring material expenditures such as materials for Post and Departmental participation, radio, TV, film, newspaper, and all other types
of suitable publicity, and that such recommendation or recommendations be
submitted to the National Executive Committee as soon as possible for its
consideration, and be it further
RESOLVED that the 50th Anniversary Committee is charged by the National Executive Committee to exercise close supervision and guidance of all
activities involving the 50th anniversary observance and the expenditures of
American Legion monies therefor, with reports at regular intervals to the
National Executive Committee and to the Finance Commission, and be it
further
RESOLVED that the National Finance Commission is requested to provide
for necessary funds for the expenses of the 50th Anniversary Committee
to enable it to fulfill the charge herein set forth, and be it further
RESOLVED that prior to the completion of the contract authorized herein,
such contract shall have the approval as to form from the National Judge
Advocate.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander and members
of the National Executive Committee, this completes the second reading of
this resolution pursuant to Rule 8-A, and may the record show that this was
read at 3:40 p. m. on May 4th.
Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Chair will recognize the
Chairman of the Committee so that he can make an explanation, and then
the floor will be open for comments and questions.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN LaBICHE: I have had quite a few questions asked in the last few days, particularly since the reading of our resolution this morning, and I thought it would be best to try to answer some
of these questions that were asked, and if you will, I will attempt to answer
many of them now.
74
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
One of the questions was, there is no member of this Committee that is a
member of Bozell and Jacobs, and no one of our Committee owns any type of
stock in Bozell and Jacobs. The first time I heard of the firm was when
we met them in New York on April 5th.
I would like to tell you, and of course not being familiar with the laws,
that is the reason why I haven’t, I would like to tell you what we did pertaining to bringing this resolution before you. We appeared before the Finance Commission and presented this entire problem, and the Finance Commission, we wanted them to first know whether we could get into such a
program, and after discussing with them thoroughly, they advised this, and
we have discussed it later with the Chairman of the Finance Commission,
and we have even discussed our resolution, to make sure that we will
do this thing right, that we wouldn’t come to you and after we passed with
you and you supported it, that we wouldn’t have problems later. So we wanted to clear everything first.
They tell us we are on the right track, and to also make certain that we
were right, we went to the Judge Advocate. We presented it to him, and we
discussed it thoroughly, and made many changes to please him, and had the
resolution, as far as the Judge Advocate legally was concerned, correct.
We found our resolutions completely in order. We discussed it naturally
with our National Commander to get him completely informed of what we
are doing, our whole Committee. Also, we discussed it completely with our
National Adjutant so that he would be completely informed. We appeared
before your Resolutions Committee Chairman Roy Stone, your Committee with
all members present discussed it thoroughly with us and if any of you gentlemen have appeared before the Resolutions Committee and discussed anything, you know they ask some pretty important questions. And you know
that all of these type of people that ask the big questions ask them, and we
had to give the answers. And I think that we have answered everyone to
their satisfaction. In fact, they were, I thought without exception, they were
pleased, and they were thoroughly familiar with what this Committee was
doing.
Now let me get down to the money deal. We are talking about $344,000.
And I think we have to be 100% right in all of these things that I mentioned
to you, all of these people felt that it had to be right, and that we wouldn’t
even, they wouldn’t even allow us to get this far unless they thought we
were on the right track.
$250,000 is the contract that we wish to sign with these people, and this
contract will be this type of a contract, it is a public relations firm, we are
buying services, talent, the same as you buy of a lawyer. We have to have a
dead end. We just couldn’t come in and ask you to give us something without
any strings attached to it.
We estimated this program over a period of four years. Now we are not
talking of a one-shot deal, we are talking of four years. They estimated this
program for four years would not exceed $250,000. They are willing to sign a
contract with us to furnish seven professional people, people as someone said,
in the neighborhood of $10,000 a year income people to work with us for
four years to implement our program, plus their staff of 325 people, plus
some 12 major offices throughout the United States, with another 25 offices
that they have working agreements with, which gives us the whole national
coverage. It means that we are going to be able to turn to every nook and
hole in the nation with this four-year program.
This $250,000 will be the contract with these people, and maybe we will
only spend $200,000. That is the top figure. We could spend a million dollars
worth of services. These are big people, financially able to support what they
say, but the contract stops at $250,000.
Now how does our contract work? We have an open-end contract with
them which the Judge Advocate and our people will draw that we can cancel at any time within 90 days. They have the right of 90 days too. We
have the right of 90 days on their $250,000.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
75
How are we going to pay them their $250,000? Now I will give you a
breakdown of how we think the $344,000 will be spent, and in what years they
will be spent.
Next, we have what we call out-of-pocket money. They estimate that it
could run as much as a thousand dollars a month out-of-pocket money. This
is 44 months, that is where you get your $44,000, out-of-pocket money, which
they put in there that they will demand of us. For example, if we tell them
we want some special stationery, we want to do some certain things that
would, say, take them outside of the entire program, this they call out-ofpocket money. If we would ask that specific people would become involved
with them, they would like to have them come in and work with our membership Committee or with our PR Department or with other sections or committees of The American Legion, and we want this particular skilled person
to come in here and work with them and spend some time, this is called
out-of-pocket money, which we have to pay the expenses, purely the expenses
of bringing this person in to do that. That is out-of-pocket money. This outof-pocket money, we took the top figure, because in going into a program,
we can’t come back to you every six months in the middle of the spring and
fall and tell you we need another thousand dollars or two thousand dollars.
So we took the top figure of $44,000 out of $1,000 a month as they term outof-pocket money. This is where that figure comes from.
Your next figure is $50,000, which completes your $344,000. That $50,000
is the figure that is what they intend to do, and they have many events
they wish to cover. Gosh, the events that they have presented to us, which
our Committee yet haven’t gone into is over 35 different types of events over
this four-year period. This will be, I think, $50,000 worth of money that would
be used to make up packages, to contact the Chairmen of all the Departments,
to contact all the Posts, to send packets to the Posts with resolutions keeping
them completely informed to be able to have big celebrations right down at the
grass roots level. This is a good realistic figure that they estimate that this
job can be done for, $50,000 or less.
Again, we took the figure that we think the right kind of job can be done
with.
I think I have given you, explained to you a little, and I might mention
one other thing to you, some of the things that, a similar organization in a
sense, you say, well, it is not like some of the organizations that these people
today represent, but for 17 years they have been representing the Electrical
Company Public Information Program, this program is owned by 85 Electrical
Utilities. They are their PR people for that, which is a service. They represent the American Gas Association for the United States. They conceived
Boys Town. The famous poster, “He is not heavy; he is my brother,” that is
Mr. Jacobs’ development. They have handled this program which I know
many of you have all seen, the United States Air Force Recruiting Program.
You may say this is not like our type of organization, but these are still organizations that have done that sort of thing that fit into our type of thing.
I will give you that little background, and I think I have answered most
of the questions that have been asked me in the last four hours, Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Al.
Any discussion?
Mr. McKinley?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander and colleagues, I hope
you will be a little bit tolerant with me, Mr. Commander, if I do wander a
little bit.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Tolerance will be the order of
the day.
MR. McKINLEY: Comments, I am appearing perhaps in the guise of
the devil’s advocate. I am overwhelmingly in favor of what this Committee
wants to do. I have had some opportunity completely to review their program, and I think their present programming is sound and sensible.
76
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
But the thing that I am puzzled a little bit on, and I want to rouse this
Executive Committee to your responsibilities here, you are not just a bunch
of “yes men” you are here to administer a very important phase of the Legion
business, and that has to do with their money.
Now it was my unhappy recollection some years ago to sit here in this
Executive Committee and to have a fellow like Art Connell and a number
of other very fine Legionnaires get up here and make some statements substantially the same in an appeal that A1 LaBiche has made to you. Their
enthusiasm was tremendous and they were unquestionable in their sincerity.
But they asked us to sign a contract. The contract was not physically here.
Nobody knew exactly what its provisions were, but the contract was signed,
and we were, when we were through with it, we were eight or nine hundred
thousand dollars in the red. And it took us four years or more to bail ourselves out. And I just don’t want to see us plunge into a similar situation
without giving very serious thought to some control or restrictions over the
spending of this money.
'
f
_ Now I had a thought with our esteemed Chairman of the Finance Committee, A1 Redden, believe me, he is one of God’s own among the Legion, as
far as I am concerned. How the devil he keeps these figures in the back of
his head I don’t know, he is not basically a banker or a bookkeeper or an
accountant or anything like that, so it is really a miracle how that man has
these figures on his fingertips, and he told me last night, yes, if the National Executive Committee on the advice of counsel with this Committee, of
course, directs them to find the money, they can find it within certain limitations.
We are in a liquid state at the present time. We are not in debt, but we
are certainly not rolling in wealth. So we do have to be a little bit cautious.
I didn’t press Harold too much, but roughly if I recall in conversations
he said that possibly they could find without too much trouble if this is
distributed over a four-year period, as much as $400,000. Well, that is apparently just a little bit in excess of what A1 has represented to you now.
Now this is the thing I want to be assured of, that the conditions of this
contract will contain no wide-open clause whereby the estimated amount of
money given to you here on which you will vote, you suddenly find out
there were extras and extras and extras, and the first thing you know, you
are in debt. Now there is, there are enough lawyers in this room, and I
know there are enough contractors in the room that know that if you want
to ruin a project, all you have got to do is add the extras on. These are
the afterthoughts. I want to, so far as we can do so, in our voting here,
Mr. Commander, now be assured there will be some limitations on this extra
business that could lead us into debt.
I want to assure you, my comrades, I have supreme faith in Don Johnson
and A1 LaBiche and ali the other fellows that have been working on this
thing. I think they are absolutely on the up and up and on the level, but I
just raised my voice for the purpose of shaking you fellows up on this Executive Committee. This is your responsibility. Don’t pass the buck. If you
don’t believe in this thing, don’t vote for it.
But I feel that we ought to just stop long enough to think about this
money business, how much we are going to give, how far are you going to
extend the credit of this organization to this very fine Committee? Can we
put a stop somewheres in this contract to prevent just going on and spending
this money on the theory of extras and extras and something new that we
hadn t thought of ? That is what gets you in debt. That is what I have to
say, Mr. Commander. I hope that some of the other fellows may pick this up
I am not trying to defeat this thing, I am thoroughly in favor of what they
want to do. I am only hollering, stop, look and listen. This is your dough.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Bill.
In view of some of the statements made, I would like for the Judge Advocate to answer a question, and then I believe we will recognize first Past
National Commander Johnson, and then others. I would like to ask this ques-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
77
tion of the Judge Advocate, since I gather that your reference was to that
colorful “Red, White and Blue.”
MR. McKINLEY: Oh, it was colorful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then I would suggest that there
may be more contrast than comparison between the two experiences, so I
would like to ask the Judge Advocate if this resolution as prepared now
and as proposed for adoption containing language where it refers to each
dollar amount, and there are three of them, including the words “not to
exceed” and in one instance “$250,000” and the other, “not to exceed $44,000,”
and the next one, “not to exceed $50,000”; with that language, is it correct
that any expenditure or any contract that would include provisions that would
permit any expenditure in excess of those amounts would require action by
this Committee before the contract could be entered into?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Absolutely.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: And in the resolution there is
reference to necessary stipulations for canceling by either party in accordance
with conditions of business practice, could you elaborate on that, please?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes, in all contracts that
we sign of any great amounts, it is customary—before I answer the
question, let me say this, this is going to be negotiated, this contract by the
National Commander, by and with the aid of this Special Committee. The
Commander will negotiate with the firm of Bozell and Jacobs with the aid
of the Committee.
Now directing myself to your question, Mr. Commander, any contract that
I draw for The American Legion or that I negotiate involving substantial
sums of money, I insist that there be included in addition to conditions
precedent for the cancellation of a contract, an out clause of not more than
90 days. It is usually 60 days, not a unilateral 60 days, a 60 day termination
clause, and a cancellation clause which may be exercised by either party so
that they can’t come in at a later time and say.this was a one-way street,
unilateral contract and it is illegal. I give both sides 60 or 90 days terminations and in this contract, I can assure you that we will have a termination
clause and it is anticipated it will be 60 days, but I am going to wait until
the Commander gets into negotiations, but there will be a termination clause.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: A point of information, as
long as Bert is at the Chair, if the right to terminate would be exercised by
either party as you speak of, I am satisfied that what your answer will be,
but I am asking for the benefit of the Committee, only that amount of this
figure, total figure, we’ll say the figure of $250,000 that the public relations
firm have earned to the point of termination would be paid to them, is that
so?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Let me pursue it.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Yes. The answer is yes.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Let me ask the question
anyway, so that when we contract or sign a contract that uses the figure
$250,000, and therefore would apply to the other provisions of the contract
where money is expressed “not to exceed” and so forth, if we were to terminate, we would not then obligate outselves to whatever balance, of the
$250,000 not yet earned.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Let me answer you this way,
that is anticipated. I have not seen any contract. All we have, and I have
not perused it carefully, is a proposal. There are several options which; may
be exercised. The cost of the project is dependent upon which options we
choose. Some options are more expensive than others. Now my reading of
the proposal, not carefully, but my reading of the proposal in a hurried
manner, yesterday, leads me to believe that in the course of the negotiating
of this contract we will insist that as we make a choice and the job is completed, we will be billed with an itemized statement, and we will nay, but in
no event, I as a lawyer for The American Legion would never obligate you
78
Proceedings of Wednesday, May A, 1966
to a four-year contract and commit you to $250,000 without knowing specifically whether we are going to get what we will bargain for.
We will pay for it as they do it, and then there will be provisions in
there—as I say, there is no contract, we are negotiating, and the Commander
will negotiate, but I can assure you in my talks with Mr. Chamie who is
an outstanding lawyer, that it is his position. I am sure I cannot speak
for the Commander, but that is my position.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you. Past National Commander Don Johnson.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: Thank you. Mr. Commander and members of this Committee, I had hoped to rise before the
lawyers did get their bid in, in view of Bill’s earlier comments this morning.
Bill, I think that your comments are well taken, particularly those that
charge this Committee with the responsibility of looking out for the money
of that organization.
Certainly no one is more concerned about this than I am, and always
have been. I think that the questions have been well answered. I don’t believe,
Bill, that there is any analogy whatsoever between the previous contract to
which you refer and this one. The fact that we have a stop clause and cancellation clause, we pay only for what we get upon the presentation of
properly substantiated invoicing and billing, and I don’t believe there is any
danger which you inferred during your comments.
I think that another thing that we must recognize is that we are dealing
with a top flight firm in the United States.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: I will go along with that. I endorse that.
I am thoroughly convinced of their responsibility. They are one of the finest
in the country.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER JOHNSON: And the fact that whether or not we enter the contract in front of all the members of this Committee
to me makes no difference, because as a non-professional, a contract would
be laid before me, and I wouldn’t, it wouldn’t mean anything.
You talked about the legalistic language. If I were to see it, it wouldn’t
make any difference. I have to rely on our National Judge Advocate who
is the legal counsel for this organization to insure to me that it is in proper
legal form. I know the facts that we want, but he is the one that must do it.
We have to rely upon his ability. This is why we have him. I think that we
should go ahead after the expression of all of the members of this Committee and pass this.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Don. Committeeman
from Idaho, Mr. Gratton.
MR. GRATTON, Idaho:
Mr. Commander, Past National Commander
Johnson answered one of my questions, and you answered one of my questions, and the Judge Advocate took the rostrum; in the interest of time, and
because there are many of this Committee who have had the Committee experience that Mr. McKinley has and the memories and associations of probably some previous disappointing maneuvers and actions taken by this Board,
could we not have the Chairman of the Finance Commission here? I notice
he is not in the room right at the moment, could we have him to indicate
his approval? I am sure everybody in this Committee has the utmost confidence in Mr. Redden and also our Judge Advocate, and we can proceed with
a vote on this matter.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
We can make inquiry of the
Chairman. He is not available at this time. We can make some inquiry.
The Judge Advocate has had some discussion with him, and I think I
know what the Finance Chairman’s answer will be, but I ask the Judge Advocate if he will address himself very briefly to that.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Mr. Gratton, under the structural organization of The American Legion, the Finance Commission as such
does not set policy. You gentlemen set policy. If the Finance Commission
recommended approval of this before you had an opportunity to act, it would
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
79
be improper. The Finance Commission should not address themselves to this
matter except informally by inquiry until this body has acted and told that
body what it wants.
So I do not think the Finance Commission Chairman will address himself
to the question, and I think he has expressed himself in those words.
MR. GRATTON: Mr. Davis, I would say this to you, sir, in Bill’s remarks about his conversations with Harold Redden, he said we will be able
to find some nearly half a million dollars or in excess of a quarter of a
million dollars. I think my point in talking to the Chairman of the Finance
Commission is that this would be at whose expense, or at what program’s
expense that this body here controls?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is a matter for the
Finance Commission.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We will see if we can find the
Chairman.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, members of the Executive
Committee, I don’t know if I am the devil’s advocate, or is it Bill McKinley,
or the distinguished former National Commander Don Johnson. I know
that McKinley doesn’t love lawyers, and I know that this morning as well
as last year, he called all the lawyers that he knew a bunch of
.
Now I happen to be one of those fellows who likes to go along with progress. I like this whole idea, because it projects The American Legion into the
future, it will give The American Legion, in my opinion, that image which
we have needed for many years.
I also feel that never before have I seen such an illustrious number of
fine businessmen, lawyers, men like Jimmy O’Neil and A1 Chamie on this
Committee, brilliant lawyers, businessmen, who probably do millions of dollars worth of business. And I am one of those “yes men” who believe that a
Committee should be given the opportunity to go ahead.
Now it sounded a little bit off color to have a man like A1 LaBiche say
that none of the men on this Committee have anything to do with this firm.
We should take that for granted. I don’t think that the past experience that
we have had should be a deterrent in this contract.
We should learn by the past, and I find no fault by the others, because
I wasn’t versed enough to know what happened. But when I heard Bill
say this morning that this contract should be put in layman’s language, it
means nothing to a lawyer, and I happen to be a lawyer. All the contract does
in its legal form is to insure that which you as laymen and these businessmen want in the dealings with another firm.
Now three things are important in my mind. You have a wonderful reputation in the firm that will do business with The American Legion, an outstanding firm that wants to give service, and I believe will give service. You
have men like Dan Foley, A1 Chamie and others that will watch and protect
our legal interests. And I say without any fear of contradiction, that we have
one of the finest Judge Advocates that I would want to draw up this contract.
Now he may be young, but believe me, I have been in contact with this
man, and he has drawn contracts involving millions of dollars worth of business, and I know of nothing that has happened that has put the Legion in
any embarrassing situation, financially or otherwise.
I looked this Committee over, and I don’t think you could get a finer
bunch of men, the only mistake the Commander made is that he didn’t include
me.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: How many people have commended me and congratulated me on not doing so!
MR. DRAGO: I believe it, because I would probably be the one that
would contact this public relations firm for a little side dollar.
Well, I didn’t get myself on this Committee, but it did get a fellow from
Brooklyn, the Rev. Thompson, and I am sure that he will watch it with me
behind just like Wallace and his wife.
80
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
So, gentlemen, really sincerely with a Commander like we have who is a
lawyer, with Bert Davis, with men with great business instincts like Don
and boys like Dan Foley, Don Johnson and the rest of you, Jimmy O’Neil,
I read this over carefully, and I have no fear, and in this case, I would be a
“yes man,” because I am going to follow whatever this Committee wants,
and I think it will be a great job, and I think you are going to have something to look forward to and be happy about it. Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you.
MR. OVERTON, Alabama: Mr. Commander, my colleagues, I sense that
you are nearing the time that you want to vote, and I certainly shan’t belabor this. I think in deference to those who are new on the Committee, that
I ought to say a little something about what my good colleague McKinley
said relative to “Red, White and Blue.” I sat in this chair then, and I sit
here now, and we made a contract with “Red, White and Blue” and sort of
got in the show business, and nothing is so disheartening, and I might mention, we were quite disappointed when we went into the hole $400,000. For
just a moment, let’s examine how we got in show business to promote a
show. We were sold on something up here. I don’t think the Committee is on
trial today for their integrity. Certainly, I think what McKinley wants to
alert us to, I believe he wants to alert you to your responsibilities or to move
you to that. I think we ought to be moved, but in “Red, White and Blue,”
let me remind you, there are several of you sitting like I was, that they
came back and said, well, fellows, we got into a poker game like this; in the
end we have $225,000, shall we go to Chicago or not? And just exactly what
you have talked about, we came back to the Commander, and we discussed
it, and we debated, and we said that we had gotten into it, and what do we
want to do about it, do we want to go ahead. And we did, not because of
some slick contract, but we went along with it, the National Committee, and
we got in a little deeper, and then we got in a little deeper. I recommended
that my Department go in $10,000. It is a wonder I am really here.
This Committee was charitable with the national organization to take it
up from the states, and they amortized it and paid it off. I say this, we made
a mistake, yes, but don’t you think we might be a little stronger? I think the
debate has been good. I don’t think anything is alarming about “Red,
White and Blue.” Certainly Mr. Davis and Mr. Commander, there was no
contractual problem.
I see Jimmy O’Neil smiling, and I love to hear about the devotion of Art
Connell who tried and put his soul into it, but we just weren’t showmen, and
it was not a contract, it was a fact we got into, and we wanted to get out,
like so many of you got in the game of chance, we didn’t get our money
back. I wanted to clear that up, thank you.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER O’NEIL: Mr. Commander, and my
colleagues of the National Executive Committee, references have been made
to me, and of course, in that I am a participant in the 50th Anniversary
Committee, I think it might be well for me to clarify some issues here.
Reference has been made to the late lamented “Red, White and Blue,”
and of course, the ghost of that tragedy will stick in this Committee room
forever, and it is good that it does.
I concur in Bill McKinley’s proposal to get this before this National Executive Committee in its fullest position.
It became our responsibility, incidentally, to close “Red, White and Blue,”
so I know many of the details connected with it. I became the representative
to bring the show to its conclusion in Chicago. The loss was mentioned by
Mr. McKinley of $900,000, and I think you mentioned $400,000. The exact
figure, gentlemen, was $678,000.
But I say this to you, that if we had a professional public relations firm
to guide us on that occasion, such as we have for this program, we would
never have been involved. That was our mistake, that we didn’t go to the professional agency to get the assistance we needed.
Now in the very beginning, that is the opening sessions of the Committee
of the 50th Anniversary Committee, the point was raised about our observance
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
81
of the 50th Anniversary, and we only have this chance once, gentlemen, and
it was concluded that we should get a professional agency to direct us.
And in connection therewith, because of the fact that I am available and
most of the agencies that function in this field headquarter in and around
New York City, it became my duty to contact them and screen them out.
And in connection therewith, I went to the top people in the business in both
public relations activities, and in the advertising agency field so that I could
get the benefit of the thinking of both groups. And so out of it we had two
presentations made to the Executive Committee of your 50th Anniversary
observations, one by Bozell & Jacobs, and the other by Hill and Nolton, two
excellent firms. The better presentation was submitted by Bozell & Jacobs.
I am sure that we are headed in the right direction.
There isn’t anyone in this room, and with all due deference to all of
you, that is more conscious of dollars and cents than possibly I am. I have
participated in negotiations of many contracts involving hundreds of thousands
of dollars for this organization and in connection therewith, I join with my
friend the Committeeman from New York in praising our National Judge
Advocate, because I have been on the firing line with him, and I know what
he has done for this organization in preserving the integrity of the organization in relation to contracts.
I am satisfied that this is a good contract. Bernie Gratton, I believe was
asked what program would be sacrificed in The American Legion to carry
out the provisions of this. Frankly, Bernie, The American Legion Magazine
will pay the freight. I can say this to you in all honesty, that it would be
my opinion, if we get in any kind of, if we get any kind of break at all,
in the four years of this observance, plus the improved image that The American Legion might develop, or this program might inure to its benefit, that the
revenues of the magazine could be improved. To be sure, I am talking in
intangibles right now, but let me say this to you, in the last two years, The
American Legion Magazine has returned to this national organization a net
gain in profit of almost $1,300,000.
So I am conscious of dollars and cents, as well as Mr. McKinley, and he
knows this only too well.
I think we are on the right road, because, gentlemen, we need to recapture public recognition, and this has been lost to us now for a long number
of years.
I have heard much criticism about our operations, public relations wise.
Gentlemen, in the main, they are unjustified. We are the victims of a system,
and I would be hopeful with some professional help, we would be able to
overcome many of the difficulties. Thank you very much.
MR. RYER, Rhode Island: Mr. Commander, I would like to take this
opportunity to commend Bill for bringing this out. Certainly, I am going to
vote for it. After all, I have slept with LaBiche for the last three nights, and
God knows that would happen to me if I didn’t vote for this. I would like to
point out to you, if Bill hadn’t brought this up, it is quite conceivable that
somebody made a motion that we pass it and go right along. The last half
hour I have learned much, much more than I had any idea. After all, we
are spending more than a quarter of a million dollars. I think we as a deliberative body have taken the long road. If somebody hadn’t brought it up,
somebody hadn’t discussed it, we would not have learned this. I learned, for
instance, that the National Magazine is going to take care of the thing. That
is fine. Any worries I had before are completely dispelled.
But I just want to say this, that some of you might have thought, and
I love to use these words of Tom Miller and Bill McKinley, “my colleagues,”
some of us might have thought when we brought it up, that we were bringing
something up just for the sake of creating a hassle and so forth and so on.
I commend them for it, because I think there isn’t a man in the room that
hasn’t learned something as a result of this. And I think the record will show
later on that rather than the hassle that was created over this little item that
happened just prior to the time I came on the National Executive Committee
14 years ago, “Red, White and Blue,” which I never heard the real story,
I think that the record here today, regardless of what happens as far as
82
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
the 50th Anniversary today, the records here will show as Bill McKinley
requested, certainly proves the point.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Red, I think you well expressed
the sentiments of everyone here.
MR. MILLOY, North Dakota: One short question. I don’t know how they
evaluate their services. Is it conceivable in the first two years that this
firm could earn their $250,000 and terminate the contract and let us go it
on our own, or would it be, the service and the compensation, prorated over
the four-year period?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN LaBICHE: In our contract, it will specifically be stated in some sort of breakdown, and we think it will run about
like this, that 1966 will get $50,000, 1967 $100,000, ’68 $75,000, ’69 $25,000,
and that is the $250,000. Now, the Commander will negotiate the contract, ’66
might be $55,000, or it might be some more, but it will specify so much each
year. They bill us each month, and if we do by chance terminate our contract
in 90 days, it will cut off right at that point.
I might say this, Mr. Commander, I hate to say this, but I think this
is good business, and this is a business group that we are dealing with, we
are business people, we think we picked the top firm, but if we get in four
or five months from now, and we think the job is not being done, we want
to stop it, because we are going to have to put this four-year deal on, this
Legion, we are going to have to have five celebrations, as I told you about,
and we are going to have to keep this money and put it on, so we can’t make
a mistake. If we are going to have a mistake, we are going to know about it,
and 90 days later we are going to put a stop to it and then we can go
somewhere else and put a show on that you are proud of.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I would like to recognize Past National Commander Harry Colmery.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COLMERY: Mr. Commander and
gentlemen of the Committee, if I couldn’t make a slight contribution to your
discussion, I wouldn’t be here. In the first place, there is a lesson in the
“Red, White and Blue” for all of you in the projection of this program. I
think I know a little bit about it. I took it on myself in Topeka, Kansas,
notably one of the worst show towns in America. We showed it there for
two nights and turned in a handsome profit. The basic reason that program
did not succeed was because the Legionnaires of America didn’t get off their
fannies and work at it. That is exactly why it didn’t succeed.
Now this is projected to you and as a public relations concern goes to
work and this 50th Anniversary Committee projects the program there is a
lesson in “Red, White and Blue” to you, to carry out in the field of things
that have to be done, to make it click and to make it successful.
Now in the second place, I have confidence that the contract, if you get
into relative obligations of responsibilities, you will have done the job, and
I believe the Committee as the Judge Advocate indicates, the National Commander will get that done. I think what you are worrying about here mostly rests on the administration of the contract after you launch the program.
I might say that I am a country lawyer, but with some little experience
m making some policies and having them implemented in some fairly substantial operations, one of which involves over $35 million in the last three
years. What you need basically is a strong dedicated small Executive Committee within the 50th Anniversary Committee that will watch this as it goes
along, and sees that the provisions, the contract provisions are carried out,
and try to protect it in a manner to make it successful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Harry. Are you ready
for the question?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander, if everybody has spoken, I would like just one closing comment.
I am going to vote for the resolution. I have satisfied myself with what
I intended to do, and that was to make my colleagues, to shake my colleagues
up in expression of their responsibility in dealing with a complicated question and expense involved.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May It, 1966
83
We have too often sat on the floor of this Committee, A1 will remember,
and I am as guilty as the next one, and just passed a resolution without
knowing what it contains. I don’t want them to come along and say they
don’t know anything about it.
NATIONAL COMMANDE R JAME S: Thank you, Bill.
The question having been called for, those in favor of the motion to approve the resolution signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The resolution is adopted.
Let me say this also to underscore Red Ryer, you have performed a great
service in many ways, Bill, because the members of this Committee who have
voted, and I sense the vote to have been unanimous, will have to answer
questions when they go home, perhaps for the next four years, and so you
have served a great purpose in helping to fortify them.
You have also brought out the comment by Past National Commander Colmery that may be much more keen than you thought, because I would say
there is no easy road to success, and there is no substitute for personal
effort, and the success of this program will not rest solely on the shoulders
of the Committee nor on Bozell and Jacobs, but on the Legionnaires throughout the country and you as leaders, so thank you for that.
MR. LOVELL, Arkansas: Mr. Commander, my vote was no.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, it shall be recorded.
Anyone else?
. . . Subcommittee Chairman Stone continued the resolutions as follows:
“Commemoration of 50th Anniversary of St. Louis, Missouri,
Caucus of The American Legion”
Resolution No. 17 (Submitted by: 50th Anniversary Committee. (Subject
to Rule 8-A)).
WHEREAS, The year 1969 will be the 50th Anniversary year of the
founding of The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The 47th Annual National Convention meeting in Portland,
Oregon in August 1965 directed that a special committee be appointed by the
National Commander to plan and guide the suitable observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary; and
WHEREAS, Such a special 50th Anniversary Committee was so appointed,
and has recommended, among other things, that appropriate ceremonies be
arranged in St. Louis, Missouri in May 1969 in commemoration of the St.
Louis Caucus of May 1919; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed fitting and proper that the National Executive
Committee should hold its constitutionally ordained meeting in May 1969 in
the city of the founding of this organization; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and 5, 1966, that this Committee,
for reasons good and proper, shall hold its regular meeting in May 1969 in
the City of St. Louis, Missouri; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Adjutant is hereby directed to make the
necessary arrangements, and to communicate to the National Finance Commission an estimate of expenses involved so that necessary funds for this
purpose may be provided; and be it further
RESOLVED, that this Committee shall cooperate in every way possible
with the 50th Anniversary Committee in connection with suitable ceremonies
and other activities honoring the City of St. Louis and commemorating the
founding of The American Legion in May 1919.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A, this is
the second reading which the record should show was completed at 4:30 p. m.
on May 4th. Your Committee recommends approval and I so move.
.. . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Choppin.
84
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
MR. KERR, Missouri: May I ask the question, these dates that are set
forth, are these concrete or may this be just a little more fluid to come closer
to the actual St. Louis Caucus in 1919?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We understand that these are
the dates of the Caucus.
MR. KERR: I was under the impression that it was May 8th to 10th,
perhaps I am wrong.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Where are the founding fathers?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What is the intent of the resolution?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Might we amend to read that the dates shall
be those which shall be later found by the Committee to be the exact dates?
Why don’t we make it fluid?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Commander, we can
do this, we can just cut it off after the “hold its regular meeting in May
1969” after that cut out this part of the sentence, “during the days 17, 18
and 19 of said month.” Eliminate that, and then I think we have the resolution in a fluid condition.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Mr. Chairman, why don’t you substitute “during the appropriate dates”?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Well, I thought maybe this
would simplify it, and the Committee—it makes no difference to us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is what I thought.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We accept that.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES : You accept it. Does the mover and
seconder accept the amendment?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Yes.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER CHOPPIN: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You know what you are voting
on? Anyone want a clarifying statement?
Ready for the question? All in favor signify by saying aye; all opposed
no. The amendment is adopted.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL CHILD WELFARE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions:
“Commend Youth”
Resolution No. 28 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, There is considerable material reaching the general public
today through our various public media concerned with youth crime and antisocial behavior on the part of young people, and
WHEREAS, A bare 3 per cent of our young people ever come in contact
with law enforcement agencies, and
WHEREAS, The overwhelming majority of our youth show promise of
outstanding citizenship as evidenced in a number of ways, most recently by
their expression of support for the American policy in Viet Nam and support
of The American Legion National Program of “Show Your Colors,” now
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that it express its wholehearted confidence in the youth of America and
commends American youth for its accomplishments in the areas of academic
achievement, loyal citizenship and character development.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May k, 1966
85
“Drugs Intended for Child Use and Other Hazardous Materials”
Resolution No. 30 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission.
Approved: National Legislative Commission (Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, Accidents continue to be the leading cause of death and
disability among children, and
WHEREAS, Many of these accidents can be prevented by the use of
special packaging, special capping devices, and cautionary labels, and
WHEREAS, Many substances now being used in the manufacture of children’s toys and household items are considered hazardous, now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee, assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that it urges federal legislation be enacted
to protect children and others from accidental death or injury by amending
existing laws with respect to drugs intended for children’s use, safety closures on drug containers, cautionary labeling of containers, and ban hazardous toys and articles intended for children.
The foregoing resolutions were approved and adopted.
“Need for Expanded Research and Educational Program
Concerning Genetic Diseases”
Resolution No. 29 (Submitted by: National Child Welfare Commission).
WHEREAS, Chromosomal diseases are a major cause of disabling conditions among children including such commonly known disabilities as retardation, and
WHEREAS, research has demonstrated that many of these diseases
can be prevented by a chromosomal study of prospective parents, and
WHEREAS, There are many diseases remaining among children which are
suspected to be of genetic origin, and
WHEREAS, There is an urgent need to disseminate available information concerning diseases of genetic origin to prospective parents as a means
of preventing such disorders, and
WHEREAS, There is a need for further extensive research in the field of
genetics, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966 that it urges an aggressive educational effort be made to familiarize
prospective parents of the need for a chromosomal study as a means of preventing such diseases, and, be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, That every effort be made to expand genetic
research through appropriate agencies of Government and private sources.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Upon the recommendation of
the Subcommittee on Resolutions and the Chairman of the National Child_ Welfare Commission Bob Noonan, it has been referred back to their Commission
for further edification and revision.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Does that finish your resolutions?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: That completes it.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN HORTON: A subcommittee of your National Legislative Commission met in Room 407 in the National Headquarters
86
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
Building, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2 and 3, 1966 with the following
members in attendance:
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
L. A. “Bill” Williams (Washington), Secretary
Harry W. Colmery (Kansas), Consultant
Robert F. “Sam” Murphy (Massachusetts), Special Consultant
Bernie C. McLeish (Michigan)
James V. Day (Maine)
Walter W. Barnard (Montana)
Edward F. McGinnis (Illinois)
David E. Weichman (Iowa)
Eric H. Smith (Illinois)
In addition, the following members of your Liaison Committee were in attendance :
Thomas W. Miller (Nevada), Chairman
George Petrovich (Alaska)
Bernard F. Gratton (Idaho)
Karl Yost (Illinois)
Gene Hassman (Oklahoma)
John A. Ryer (Rhode Island)
The subcommittee reviewed the Legislative program and heard reports
from the Subcommittee Chairmen and members of the staff. All members of
the Commission were unanimous in their expression of appreciation to the
National Commander for his untiring efforts and splendid leadership during
the year.
Your subcommittee learned with great regret of the illness of our Vice
Chairman Jared Maddux of Tennessee, who recently suffered a heart attack.
We are distressed also to report to his friends of the continuing illness
of Harry Miller of Arkansas, a member of our Commission.
Once again your subcommittee discussed the matter of increasing the circulation of our National Legislative Bulletin.
I had hoped that time would permit that we could call upon the Chairman
of our Liaison Committee to talk to you briefly on that subject, but I will not
impose upon you at this time. We hope you will subscribe.
This publication is a vital tool in our efforts to keep the membership informed of our legislative activities and stimulate support in Congress for
our program.
Now I just add one thing, in the next report you will find a reference
to Item 37 to sponsor and legislate nursing homes for veterans in Alaska
and Hawaii. Since we have been here our Director Herald Stringer has received an EWS from Washington informing us that the Subcommittee on
Intermediate Care concluded its hearings today, and favorably reported a bill
by Mr. Rivers of Alaska to eliminate some requirements for the intermediate
care for veterans.
All resolutions referred from your Subcommittee on Resolutions were considered in accordance with the provisions of National Executive Committee
Rule 8(b). These resolutions will be presented to you through your Subcommittee on Resolutions. For your information they are identified according
to number and short descriptive title in the annex to this report. Thank vou
Mr. Commander.
... The Advance Report of the National Legislative Commission is as
fnilnwQ*
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
87
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
by
Clarence C. Horton (Alabama), Chairman
This advance report of your National Legislative Commission covers the
period from October 7, 1965 to April 12, 1966. It summarizes the activity of
the Commission during that period. Any meaningful developments between
April 12 and your meeting May 4-5, 1966, will be covered in a supplemental
report.
Since your last meeting our Legislative Bulletin has kept you informed
of developments in the field of legislation and activity of the Commission.
Detailed information on our legislative program will be contained in our report to the 1966 National Convention.
1st Session—89th Congress
The 1st session of the 89th Congress adjourned last October 23 shortly
after your 1965 Fall meeting. On October 21, two days prior to adjournment,
action was completed on HR 168, the bill to increase service-connected compensation payments and make certain improvements in the VA nursing care
program. Your Commission regards the passage of this measure as one of
the major legislative accomplishments of the Congress last year. The bill
was signed by the President on October 31 as Public Law 89-311. (See National Legislative Bulletin No. 15, 1965, for details.)
On October 3, 1965, the President approved HR 2580, the bill amending
our immigration and nationality law (Public Law 89-236). You will recall
that this bill as finally passed meets the five basic criteria recommended by
The American Legion in Resolution No. 74, adopted at the 1965 National
Convention.
In closing my report on the 1st Session of the 89th Congress a brief
summary of its activities may be of interest to you. Seldom in one session
of Congress have we seen so much activity. The Senate was in session 177
days and the House 173 days. When it adjourned in October over 16,000 measures had been introduced with 563 public and private bills enacted into law.
The session established a new record for quorum calls and roll call votes.
It produced wide-ranging new programs dealing with an endless variety of
subjects. It appropriated more money than any other in peacetime history.
It was a unique and interesting session but with all of the other activity the
veterans’ program was not overlooked. In addition to the appropriation bills
some 35 measures were enacted last year in which we had a specific interest.
2nd Session—89th Congress
The 2nd Session of the present Congress convened on January 10 of this
year. The war in Viet Nam and problems concomitant therewith have been
the dominant factor in legislative efforts to date. Notwithstanding these troublesome issues the first major piece of legislation enacted in the 2nd Session
was Public Law 89-358, the new GI Bill for Viet Nam veterans. This legislation was unanimously approved on roll call votes in both Houses of Congress: 381-0 in the House and 99-0 in the Senate. The new law satisfies the
over-all objective of 1965 National Convention Resolution No. 22, adopted by
the National Executive Committee last October. We are hopeful that other
proposals contained in your Resolution No. 22 will be favorably considered
at this session of the Congress. In his appearance before the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs on March 1st National Commander L. Eldon
James made special reference to the fact that Viet Nam veterans should be
made eligible for war compensation rates, death and disability pension and
burial allowances.
88
Proceedings of Wednesday, May It, 1966
New Legislation
Since this session of the 89th Congress convened we have had the following
bills introduced to accomplish objectives of American Legion resolutions:
HR 12186. This was our GI Bill for Viet Nam veterans and as heretofore noted, the objective of our resolutions has been substantially accomplished.
HR 12300, introduced on January 25, is a bill to increase the travel allowance authorized for VA beneficiaries. Our Resolution is No. 14, adopted by
the National Executive Committee at its 1965 Spring meeting.
The following bills were introduced on February 9:
HR 12723, a bill to authorize the VA to furnish medical treatment and
services and drugs and medicines to veterans receiving additional pension
under the old law based on a need for regular aid and attendance. Our
Resolution is No. 20, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its
1965 Fall meeting.
HR 12724, a bill to provide that a chronic functional psychosis manifested
to a compensable degree within three years after termination of wartime
service shall be deemed to have been incurred in or aggravated by such
service, notwithstanding the fact that there is no record of evidence of such
disease during the period of service. Our Resolution is No. 50, approved
by the 1965 National Convention.
HR 12736, a bill to authorize the Administrator of Veterans Affairs to
pay disability compensation to veterans who have received disability severance
pay for the same disability.
HR 13059 was introduced by Congressman Ralph J. Rivers (Alaska) on
February 24. This bill would establish a national policy for the further development and expansion of our national cemetery system. It would create a
National Cemetery Site Selection Advisory Board which would operate in
conjunction with the Secretary of the Army in selecting and developing needed national cemetery sites and the expansion of existing national cemeteries.
Our Resolution is No. 11 adopted by the National Executive Committee at its
1965 Fall meeting. Congressman Rivers is Chairman of the Subcommittee on
National Parks and Recreation, House Committee on Interior and Insular
Affairs, the Subcommittee having jurisdiction of all legislation pertaining to
national cemeteries.
HR 13072 was introduced by Congressman Michael A. Feighan (Ohio),
on February 24. This bill would facilitate the entry under our new immigration lav/ of alien sons and daughters of World War I veterans of the United
States Armed Forces. Our Resolution is No. 186 adopted by the 1964 National Convention.
HR 13170 was introduced on March 1 by Congressman Thomas E. Morgan (Pennsylvania), Chairman of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs.
This bill would extend entitlement to Veterans Administration home loans to
United States veterans residing in Canada and Mexico. This program would
be administered by the Secretary of State and is in a sense a pilot program
to determine the feasibility of extending these loans to United States veterans
residing abroad. Our Resolution is No. 643 of the 1964 National Convention.
On March 7, 1966, Congressman Barrat O’Hara (Illinois), introduced HR
13318, which is very similar to the Morgan bill.
Washington Conference
The
1-3, in
tion to
bers of
National Legislative Commission met in Washington, D. C., March
conjunction with the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. In addiyour Chairman and Vice Chairman Jared Maddux, twenty-six memthe Commission were present including Clarence Olson, the National
Representative. Also present were the following members of
the NEC Liaison Committee: Thomas W. Miller, Chairman, Gene Hassman,
Bernard F. Grattan, Karl Yost and John A. Ryer.
In addition to Commander James and Congressman Olin E. Teague, Chairman, House Committee on Veterans Affairs, a number of Congressional staff
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
89
members addressed the Commission including Oliver E. Meadows, Staff Director, HVAC, Gene Godley, Chief Research Assistant to Senator Ralph Yarborough, and Dr. Edward M. O’Connor, Staff Director, Joint Committee on
Immigration and Nationality Policy.
Again this year four Chairmen and one Director of other National Commissions discussed their legislative programs with the Legislative Commission.
Mrs. Arthur B. Hanell, National Legislative Chairman of the American Legion Auxiliary, was present at all meetings of the Commission and participated in the program. She addressed the Commission on March 2nd and outlined her own program that she has developed to assist the Commission in
its legislative efforts.
Activity in 2nd Session in Support
of Legislative Program
Again this year in accordance with 1965 National Convention Resolution
No. 341 The American Legion supported the House Committee on Un-American Activities and its budget request. Over the usual objections the House of
Representatives on January 27 approved a budget of $425,000 for use of the
Committee in FY 1967. The roll call vote was 299-24 in favor of the appropriation. The amount approved was $5,000 more than the total for FY
1966.
On February 28 testimony was presented on behalf of the National
Economic Commission to the Subcommittee on Housing, House Committee on
Banking and Currency, in support of HR 11858, a bill to amend the recently
enacted housing and Urban Development Act of 1965. The 1965 Act provided,
among other things, for preferential treatment in housing loans to all servicemen including veterans. Eligible veterans were barred, however, from availing themselves of these special benefits they had previously used their
GI Home Loan entitlement. The prohibition was discriminatory because
servicemen were permitted to apply for the benefits more than once if otherwise entitled. HR 11858 would eliminate this discriminatory provision and is
in accordance with Resolution No. 577 adopted at the 1965 National Convention.
On March 17 the National Rehabilitation Commission presented testimony
to the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs in support of our bill HR 7570
which seeks improvements in the Dependency and Indemnity Compensation
program for dependent parents. HR 7570 was introduced for The American
Legion in accordance with Resolution No. 6, approved by the Executive Committee at your 1964 Fall meeting.
On March 24 testimony was submitted on behalf of the Economic Commission to the Subcommittee on Labor, Health, Education and Welfare, House
Committee on Appropriations, in support of the FY 1967 budget request of
the Department of Labor for the operation of the Veterans’ Employment Service and related programs.
HR 1647 was signed by the President March 31 and is Public Law 89-380.
This new law makes it mandatory for Government agencies to abide by the
recommendations of the Civil Service Commission in connection with successful appeals by employees from adverse action by their employing agencies.
Section 14 of the Veterans’ Preference Act grants such appeals to veteran
employees. In the past some agencies had failed to follow the Commission’s
recommendation and refused to grant the employee back pay and restore
him to his former status. Public Law 89-380 accomplishes the objectives of
Resolution No. 640, adopted at the 1964 National Convention. Earlier this year
testimony was presented to the Subcommittee on Civil Service, Senate Committee on Post Office and Civil Service, in support of this legislation. The
bill had passed the House early in 1965.
CONCLUSION
Our current legislative program encompasses some 150 resolutions pertaining to all facets of Legion programs requiring legislative action. A total of
222 resolutions have been received by your Commission during the 89th Congress. Many of these resolutions directed us to support appropriations for the
90
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
executive agencies administering programs for servicemen and veterans.
Others directed us to seek funds necessary for the operation of the Committees of Congress whose work The American Legion supports.
The substantive accomplishments of The American Legion is impressive
when compared to the efforts of other national organizations. Your Legislative Commission believes that these accomplishments are evidence of the
high regard that the Congress and the people of this Nation hold for war
veterans and for The American Legion.
In conclusion, I express to National Commander L. Eldon James the appreciation of the Commission and its staff for his splendid cooperation and
leadership, particularly in connection with his efforts concerning the Cold
War GI Bill while it was under consideration by the Senate Committee on
Finance.
I also thank the administrative officials of the National Organization,
Messrs. E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant, and William F. Hauck, Director of the Washington Office, who were, as always, helpful to the Commission.
We are grateful to the Chairmen and staffs of the other Commissions who
continue to cooperate with us in our work. On behalf of the Commission I
acknowledge and thank Mrs. Walter H. Glynn, National President of the
American Legion Auxiliary, her Legislative Chairman, Mrs. Arthur B. Hanell,
and all the members of the Auxiliary for their continuing support.
This report would not be complete if I failed to mention, also, our hard
working Legislative Director and his dedicated staff. The Commission is proud
of our record in this Congress and we will continue to represent you and
the national organization to the best of our ability.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN JACOBI: Mr. Commander, members of the
National Executive Committee, I take it that you have received a complete
report, and have a copy on your desk. Therefore, I will refer merely to
the highlights of that report.
Your Internal Affairs Commission with an executive section of nine members present met May 2-3 at National Headquarters, together with William
McKinley and Sedley Peck as liaison from the National Executive Committee.
The number of resolutions considered directly by this Commission was
at a minimum since the committees under the supervision of this Commission
were also in session. Most of the resolutions being offered for your approval
resulted from the deliberations of these committees and are included as attachments to the formal report of the Internal Affairs Commission.
National Convention Resolution No. 153 (Ohio)—“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and Resolutions to Department Delegates at National Convention” is recommended for your approval as an increased and
necessary assist to the Departments by increasing the number of convention
reports available two hours in advance. We have been assured that this can
be handled at a nominal cost and without additional personnel being required at the convention.
100Twn resolutions are recommended for rejection—Resolution Register No.
1234 (New Jersey)—“American Nurses Day” requesting American Legion
support for an American Nurses Day is recommended for rejection as not
being germane to The American Legion’s programs.
T,he, second resolution, Register No. 1254 from the District of Columbia,
entitled ‘Protecting Privacy of Veterans’ Personnel Files and Records.” This
resolution is recommended for rejection also. A letter from the National Judge
Advocate Bert Davis dated September 3, 1965 to a District of Columbia Legionnaire who is a plaintiff in a civil action in the District of Columbia and
information contained in a letter from Samuel C. Borzilleri, Legal Assistant
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
91
to the Rehab Commission, were used as the basis for rejecting the resolution
as not being a proper case for the intervening of The American Legion.
The additional resolutions that will be presented by your Resolutions
Committee are covered in the attached reports of the Graves, Registration and
Memorials Committee, the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, and
the Constitution and By-Laws Committee. The Internal Affairs Commission
has concurred in the recommended action contained in these reports.
I would like to call your attention particularly to the prepared report of
the Graves, Registration and Memorials Committee. This is worthy of your
study.
The special resolution concerning eligibility will be discussed by that particular Special Committee.
Several matters concerning the Internal operation of our organization received our attention and you can expect more detailed reports at a later date.
Among these would be the effects on the Internal Affairs Division of the
conversion of our Magazine mailing list to a computer operation, and the
advisability of making advance preparation to welcome the Viet Nam Veterans in the event these are made eligible by National Convention action.
Since none of our other discussions involved resolutions, I will not take
your time now to discuss these in detail, but I can assure you that many of
them are of some importance to The American Legion.
Our thanks to Mr. McKinley for his assistance and also to the staff.
That completes the first portion of my report, the second being the
Special Committee action.
. . . The Report of the Executive Section of the National Internal Affairs
Commission is as follows:
REPORT OF EXECUTIVE SECTION OF
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5,1966
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Members of the National Executive Committee: Pursuant to the call of the National Commander, the Executive Section of the
National Internal Affairs Commission met May 2-3, 1966, in Room 301, at National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, with the following members present:
Herbert J. Jacobi (District of Columbia), Chairman
Max R. Brents (California), Vice Chairman
Ralph R. Storm (Indiana)
Frank A. Nietupski (Massachusetts)
Ben Holmes (Alabama)
Harry R. Harn (Idaho)
Dr. Charles W. Hoshall (Oklahoma)
Lawrence E. Fisher (Arkansas)
William G. McKinley (New Jersey), NEC Liaison
Sedley Peck (France), NEC Liaison
Mr. Max Brents (California), was appointed secretary for the meetings.
Staff Liaison J. Lloyd Wignall, Assistant National Director of Membership, and Mrs. Mary Hutchinson, acting as secretary, were present.
The number of resolutions considered directly by this Commission was at
a minimum since the committees under the supervision of this Commission
were in session, and most of the resolutions being offered for your approval
resulted from the deliberations of these committees.
92
Proceedings of Wednesday, May J, 1966
National Convention Resolution No. 153 (Ohio)—“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and resolutions to Department Delegates at
National _ Conventions.” This resolution is recommended for your approval.
While this will increase the number of prepared reports being distributed to
the departments, we have been assured that this can be handled at a nominal
cost and without additional personnel being required at the Convention.
Resolution Register No. 1234 (New Jersey)—“American Nurses Day,”
requesting American Legion support for an American Nurses Day is recommended for rejection as not being germane to The American Legion’s programs.
Resolution Register No. 1254 (District of Columbia)—“Protecting Privacy
of Veterans’ Personnel Piles and Records.” This resolution is recommended for
rejection. A letter from National Judge Advocate Bert Davis dated September 3, 1965, to a Legionnaire who is a plaintiff in a civil action in the District
of Columbia, and information contained in a letter from Samuel C. Borzilleri
were used as a basis for rejecting the resolution as not being a proper case
for the intervention of The American Legion.
Other resolutions will be before this National Executive Committee as the
result of actions taken by the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee,
The Graves. Registration and Memorial Committee, the Membership and
Post Activities Committee, and the Constitution and By-Laws Committee. Your
Internal Affairs Commission has concurred in the recommended actions contained in the reports of these committees which, with the exception of the
Membership and Post Activities Committee report, are attached and are a
part of the formal Internal Affairs Commission report.
Your commission spent considerable time in hearing reports concerning
the effect of the Automatic Data Processing conversion of our Magazine
mailing list as it concerns the Internal Affairs Division. To date, we are
optimistic that this change will be beneficial, particularly in the membership
phase of our operation. We will continue to watch the development of this
conversion.
Another area that received our attention is in connection with the special
resolution which will be considered by the 1966 National Convention to change
the eligibility requirements for membership in our organization. We do not
feel we are anticipating the action of the convention, but in the event there
is a change and a new generation of veterans become eligible for membership
m the American Legion, we feel that we should be better prepared to welcome them than we were when we opened our ranks to the Korean veterans.
JNo formal action was taken, but a number of ideas were discussed and it
is anticipated that the staff will spend additional time between now and our
National Convention so that if the resolution is approved and the change receives Congressional approval, we will have a program ready to implement
at once that will assist at every level of operation.
Your commission also initiated action for a review of the statement of
purpose of the commission and the subcommittees under its supervision. We
hope to have recommendations ready to be submitted to the Reorganization
Committee at the time of the fall National Executive Committee meetings.
The International Amity Awards caused some discussion, primarily because there had developed a different concept in the Trophies, Awards and
Ceremonials Committee and that originally intended when the award was
authorized by this body. Through action of the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, supplemented by action of this commission, eleven people
are being recommended to you for the International Amity Award. This is
the subject of a resolution that will be submitted through the Resolutions
Assignment Committee.
Your Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee has spent considerable time m reviewing the awards now being made. The resolutions which
are being submitted on the Hearest Trophy and the Houghton Trophy were
carefully drawn, and are recommended for your approval.
Your chairman would like to recommend for your study the report of
the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee (attached to this report)
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
93
and also asks that you give special consideration to the resolutions being
presented from that committee. There now appears to be a chance that we
may achieve one of our objectives and that hearings will be held toward the
establishment of a National Cemetery Policy that will continue the growth
of our National Cemeteries in an orderly fashion. We are going to need the
cooperation of this body and, in fact, Legionnaires everywhere, and we are
going to need it very soon. You will be receiving bulletins and information in
the near future, and we sincerely request your full cooperation.
The National Adjutant had referred to our commission a request from The
American Defenders of Bataan and Corregidor that our posts be solicited for
ten dollars each to be used in purchasing mobile X-ray units and de-worming
units—the balance to help in constructing a Bataan Memorial Chapel and
recreational area at the surrender site on Bataan Peninsula. This request
is being recommended for rejection on the basis that it is contrary to our
established policy as it concerns direct solicitations of our posts.
Your chairman had requested that the Membership and Post Activities
Committee consider the possibility of establishing posts at large. A reply was
received from that committee indicating a negative attitude toward such posts.
We also had an opinion from the National Judge Advocate that the establishment of posts at large would raise Constitutional questions and would require
some changes in the basic philosophy of The American Legion. As a result,
the Internal Affairs Commission concurred with the Membership and Post
Activities Committee in rejecting this proposal.
Our thanks are extended to Mr. William G. McKinley for his cooperation and to the staff.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ HERBERT J. JACOBI, Chairman
Internal Affairs Commission
. . . The Report of the Subcommittee of the National Constitution and
By-Laws Standing Committee is as follows:
REPORT
SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE NATIONAL CONSTITUTION AND
BY-LAWS STANDING COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 2-3, 1966
Pursuant to a directive issued by the National Commander, the subcommittee of the National Constitution and By-laws Committee met in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2-3, 1966.
The meeting was called to order by Chairman A. F. Wells, of Illinois.
Present were: Francis Giordano, Vice Chairman (New York), and William
D. Packer (Pennsylvania), National Commander’s Representative.
The first order of business was the consideration of a special Resolution
submitted by the Special Membership Eligibility Committee, appointed by the
National Commander to prepare and submit a report and a resolution pursuant to an enabling Resolution No. 571 adopted at the National Convention
in Portland, Oregon, in 1965. This Committee considered and discussed the
Special Report of this Special Membership Eligibility Committee, and it considered and studied the resolution submitted by this same Committee as indicated. After considerable discussion, this Committee, on motion made by
Francis Giordano, and seconded by William Packer, adopted the Report and
Resolution unanimously.
It is, therefore, recommended to the Internal Affairs Commission that
this Resolution be ADOPTED.
Your Committee, after considerable discussion, feels impelled to. call to the
attention of the Internal Affairs Commission that language contained in nu-
94
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
merical paragraph three, page four, of the Advance Report of the Special
Membership Eligibility Committee, chairmanned by Past National Commander
J. Addington Wagner.
This language addresses itself to a discussion of the possibility that the
proposed constitutional amendment contains language indicating that the date
relative to cessation of hostilities could conceivably not terminate with the
end of hostilities in Viet Nam.
The next item of business was consideration of Resolution Register No.
1226, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Tennessee.
This Committee was cognizant of the fact that this submitted Resolution was
considered by the Special Committee on Eligibility at Washington, D. C. Further, it was noted that this Resolution calls for a change in eligibility dates
covering a period involving the Korean War. The substance of this Resolution as submitted, has been the subject of consideration at previous National Conventions. As presented, it is not in proper form in that it fails
to meet specifically the technical requirements for amending constitutional
provisions. Further, it is noted that no new reasons are given for extending
the Korean War dates. Therefore, on motion by Francis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, this Committee recommends DISAPPROVAL of this
Resolution.
The next item on the agenda was resolution identified as Register No.
1236, submitted to the National Executive Committee by the Executive Committee of the Department of Texas. This Resolution, although it appears to
be in proper form, requires a change of eligibility dates covering the Korean
War, starting on June 25, 1950 and continuing without interruption to
some date in the future as may be determined by the United States Government. Inasmuch as this continuous period covers dates already acted upon by
Congress and The American Legion in fixing the termination of eligibility
relating to the Korean War, and inasmuch as the balance of the resolution
is already covered by resolution submitted by the Special Committee on Eligibility, this Committee acted as follows: On motion by Francis Giordano,
seconded by William Packer, the Committee voted to REJECT this Resolution.
It may be further noted that, in effect, the continuous period of eligibility
would, in effect, change the character of The American Legion to include
veterans serving only during so-called “peace-time” periods.
The next order of business was consideration of Register Resolution
No. 1252, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Pennsylvania. After careful consideration, it was the conclusion of this Committee
that this resolution is technically not in proper form in that it petitions
action by the National Legislative Commission. It purports to be a resolution
of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion instead of the
Executive Committee of the Department of Pennsylvania. Aside from these
technicalities, however, the Resolution is, in effect, an endorsement of the
resolution adopted by the Special Committee on Eligibility, and for that reason it was considered for REJECTION. On motion of Francis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, this resolution was not recommended for further
consideration.
The Committee further considered resolution designated as Register No.
1198, submitted by the Executive Committee of the Department of Mexico.
This resolution asks that the present Viet Nam Conflict be entitled the
War,” and that combattants thereof be made eligible for membersmp. The said resolution is not in proper form. However, since the resolution
of the Special Committee calls for the inclusion of veterans serving during the
period of the Viet Nam Conflict for eligibility for membership, the instant
resolution is not recommended for further consideration. Accordingly, on mo“°n °trJrancis Giordano, seconded by William Packer, the Resolution was
REJECTED.
Submitted by,
/s/ A. F. WELLS, Chairman
• . . The Report of the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee is as follows:
Proceedings of Wednesday, May i, 1966
95
REPORT OF
NATIONAL TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE, THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5,1966
Thomas S. Donahue (Illinois), Vice Chairman
The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee met Sunday
and Monday, May 1, 2, 1966, in Room 207 of National Headquarters. Meeting
was called to order at 10:00 a. m. by Vice Chairman Thomas S. Donahue with
the following members answering roll call: Thomas S. Donahue (Illinois);
George H. Werkley (New York); Gus Draeb (North Dakota); B. B. Jenkins
(California); and Stanley J. Arabas (New York).
Eighteen nominations for the International Amity Award were considered.
The committee voted unanimously to recommend the presentation of the
award to the following:
Nominated By
Country
Name
George H. Werkley
Canada
Byron Wilson
F. Glen Starr
Canada
W. Lorne Manchester
Frank Kossa
Canada
E. K. Carter
Howard Dulin
France
General Pierre Koenig
Lewis K. Gough
Israel
Meir Bar Rav Hay
Donald E. Johnson
Australia
A. J. Lee
One nomination was recommended for rejection on the grounds that the
person nominated had already received the award.
Eleven other nominations, some of which are to be referred to the nominators for further documentation, were taken under advisement by the committee
for consideration at its meeting prior to the spring meeting of the National
Executive Committee in 1967. In recommending the above nominations for the
International Amity Award, the committee wishes to reiterate its previously
stated policy of a maximum of six recommendations—a maximum of three to
any one country—in any one year for this award.
Recognizing that the Manual of Ceremonies has reached that stage of development in which there are needed changes in its contents—usually _ corrections and/or improvements in grammar and word usage, which neither
reflect nor imply any basic changes in American Legion principle or purpose—the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee in submitting a resolution concerning the procedure for submission of future changes in the
official Manual of Ceremonies for approval of the National Executive
Committee.
Suggestions submitted by Robert Maxwell of the Department of Illinois,
pertaining to the Manual of Ceremonies, were taken under advisement. The
committee considered the suggestions to be constructive and worthy of serious
attention. However, the committee deemed it advisable to forego any suggested
changes in the official Manual of Ceremonies, pending possible action by
the 1966 National Convention on the question of membership eligibility. Although the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee traditionally meets
but once a year, just prior to the May meeting of the National Executive
Committee, the committee recommends that, in the event the 1966 National
Convention approves an expansion of membership eligibility, a meeting of the
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee be also scheduled prior to the
fall NEC meeting. This special meeting in the fall would permit any necessary revision of the Manual of Ceremonies to include the new generation of
members.
Resolution No. 447 (Massachusetts) 1964 National Convention—“Bestow
Posthumously The Congressional Medal of Honor on the Late President John
F. Kennedy”—was re-referred to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee by the National Security Commission which, at its March 1-3 meeting,
96
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
had approved the resolution in principle but not for the Medal of Honor.
In referring Resolution No. 447 to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials
Committee, the National Security Commission recommended that the late
President Kennedy be considered for The American Legion’s Distinguished
Service Medal. The Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee concurs
with the National Security Commission in approving Resolution 447 in principle, but the committee recommends rejection on the grounds that the. late
President Kennedy has already been awarded The American Legion Distinguished Service Medal—in 1961, which is the highest honor within our capacity to bestow.
Resolution 452 (Michigan) 1965 National Convention, which recommends
the presentation of a “Legion of Honor Medal” by The American Legion to
the late Adlai Stevenson, was referred to the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee by the Convention Committee on Credentials and Internal
Affairs. Your committee recommends rejection of this resolution on the
grounds that there is no such award in existence.
A review of all trophies and awards currently authorized and presented
by the National Organization of The American Legion has been undertaken
by the Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee. A preliminary report
of this review and recommendations by your committee is attached as a part
of this report.
Also attached as a part of this report is a report of special citations and
awards presented by the National Organization of The American Legion since
the May 1965 meeting of the National Executive Committee.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The Preliminary Report of the Review of American Legion Trophies
and Awards Committee is as follows:
PRELIMINARY REPORT
REVIEW OF AMERICAN LEGION TROPHIES AND AWARDS
BY NATIONAL TROPHIES, AWARDS AND CEREMONIALS
COMMITTEE
In its report to the National Executive Committee, May 5-6, 1965, the
National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee recommended a
thorough review of all trophies and awards presently authorized. Such a review was recommended to be undertaken with the cooperation and counsel of
the standing commission or committee within whose area of interest said
awards are now being presented.
In order to determine the current effectiveness of the existing trophies
and awards, each commission or committee having such awards falling within
its purview was asked to submit specific, detailed information on the history
of the trophy or award and an analysis of the participation for such recognition, of the rules and procedures governing the trophy or award, and any
recommendations for possible revision of the rules and procedures. The
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee wishes to express its sincere
appreciation and commendation to the commissions and committees for their
cooperation in this matter. Each report was detailed thoroughly, containing
constructive suggestions and recommendations for the benefit of this committee.
Because of the scope of this undertaking, this report of necessity must
be a preliminary one. Some changes in rules and procedures are pending further study within the respective commission or committee.
The Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee, as the result of its
review of American Legion trophies and awards presently authorized, submits the following recommendations:
1. Americanism—Your committee commends the National Americanism
Commission and staff for a thorough report. Your committee recommends
that the National Americanism Commission give serious consideration of new
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
97
criteria and guidelines for the determination of winners of the Janies A.
Drain Trophy (community service) and the Frank N. Belgrano, Jr., Trophy
(Boy Scout). Your committee concurs with the National Americanism Commission’s proposal for changes in the rules governing the Hearst Americanism Trophy, said changes submitted in a resolution for consideration by the
National Executive Committee.
2. Membership and Post Activities—Your committee commends the National Membership and Post Activities Committee for a highly informative
report. Your committee recommends that a complete study be made of the
physical condition of all active trophies awarded by The American Legion,
most of which appear to have suffered deterioration. Should such a study
determine that refurbishing of these trophies is unfeasible, it is recommended that whatever administrative action is necessary be taken to assure continuity of these trophy symbols in a physical form befitting the purpose for
which they were established. Your committee concurs with the changes in rules
proposed by the National Membership and Post Activities Committee with
reference to the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion Trophy,
said changes submitted in a resolution for consideration by the National Executive Committee.
3. Rehabilitation—No recommendations from your committee, pending a
final report from the National Rehabilitation Commission concerning the rules
governing the National Service Trophy.
4. Awards to Graduates of Armed Service Academies—Your committee
recommends that every effort be made for greater publicity concerning these
awards in order that members of The American Legion may be aware of
such honors bestowed by their organization.
5. Child Welfare—Your committee recommends that the Department 100%
Post Child Welfare Reporting Award (established in 1963) and Area Child
Welfare Reporting Award for Departments (established in 1962) be included
in the manual of Trophies and Awards Sponsored by the National Organization of The American Legion in accordance with Resolution No. 29, NEC,
May 5-6, 1965.
6. Public Relations—Your committee commends the National Public Relations Commission for its action bringing up-to-date the information on its
award and recommends that the necessary administrative action be taken to
correct the manual of Trophies and Awards with reference to the Fourth
Estate Award.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The report of Special Trophies and Awards Committee is as follows:
REPORT OF SPECIAL TROPHIES AND AWARDS PRESENTED
BY THE AMERICAN LEGION
May 6, 1965—May 5, 1966
Pursuant to Resolution No. 29, NEC, May 5-6, 1965, this will report the
issuance of the following awards and citations for the period of May 6,
1965, to May 5, 1966:
1. Roy L. Vingers Post 52, Department of Wisconsin, Certificate of Commendation, by action of National Americanism Commission.
2. Congressman Olin E. Teague, special award, upon recommendation
of the National Rehabilitation Commission.
3. Mr. Leonard Goldenson, President of American Broadcasting Companies, a special award.
4. Mr. Eugene C. Pulliam, a special journalistic achievement award.
5. Washington College, Maryland, and the student body of Washington
College, Maryland, two special citations presented upon recommendation of Department of Maryland.
98
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
6. Mr. Prank M. Greene, a member of the National Contests Supervisory
Committee, a special certificate of appreciation, upon recommendation
of the NCSC.
Respectfully submitted,
/si THOMAS S. DONAHUE, Vice Chairman
. . . The report of the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee is as
follows:
REPORT OF
GRAVES REGISTRATION AND MEMORIAL COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 2-3, 1966
Joseph H. Hackett, Rhode Island, Chairman
The meeting of the Graves Registration and Memorial Committee was
called to order by Chairman Joseph H. Hackett (Rhode Island) at 9:60 a. m.,
May 2. All members of the Executive Section of the committee were present,
as follows: Joseph H. Hackett (Rhode Island), Charles H. Lugar (Missouri),
Carl L. Lundgren (Minnesota), Thomas R. Peden (South Carolina), A. M.
Renick (Virginia). One visitor was present, O. B. Yorker (Colorado), a
member of the committee.
Dr. Park. W. Huntington (Delaware) was elected secretary of the meeting.
The committee reviewed a report prepared by Chairman Hackett on action
to date concerning our efforts to achieve a national cemetery policy. The contents of that report are included in this report, as follows:
Since our last meeting several things have happened with which you
should be acquainted. Prior to discussing what has happened recently, however, I would like to spend a few moments reviewing our activities in recent
years.
On March 5-6-7, 1962, the Subcommittee on National Parks of the Committee on Internal and Insular Affairs of the House of Representatives held
hearings on the subject of a National Cemetery Policy. The American Legion
^e?? hearings and expressed their deep concern that there be
established a policy that would insure the orderly development of the National
Cemeteries as needed.
,. Up to that time, our organization had been placing resolutions and having
bills submitted on a piecemeal basis for cemeteries in various parts of the
country. At the 44th National Convention, Las Vegas, Nevada, October 9-101962, The American Legion adopted what I feel is a much more realistic
attitude with the approval of the following resolution.
“National Cemetery Policy”
Resolution No. 610 (Originating in Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Organization).
WHEREAS, In the past decade, hundreds of requests have been made upon
Congress for the creation of new national cemeteries and the enlargement of
existing national cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, The Congress, by its refusal to favorably consider such reqU es
at d
ex r
-rywill
“enot
Pconsider
ession of
Congressmen,
has strongly
indii r\,
cated
thatl it
thisindividual
increasingly
complex program
on a piecemeal basis; and
Whereas, In the Second Session of the 87th Congress, the Subcommittee
on National Parks of the House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs
conducted extensive hearings on the entire national cemeteries issues, with a
view toward developing a permanent national policy governing national cemeteries; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
99
WHEREAS, As an outgrowth of these hearings, Congressman J. T. Rutherford, Chairman of the Subcommittee on National Parks, and Congressman
J. P. Saylor, ranking Minority Member, introduced legislation of similar
nature, each having the purpose of developing a national policy on national
cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, It is anticipated that identical or similar legislation will be
proposed in the 88th Congress; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That The American Legion in National Convention assembled in Las Vegas, Nevada, October 9-11, 1962, supports the declaration of
national policy on national cemeteries by the Congress of the United States
and that it vigorously presses for the enactment of legislation to accomplish
same; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That it is the concensus of the convention that resolutions
now before this convention proposing piecemeal correction of this national
problem be held in abeyance until such time as a satisfactory national policy
has been developed by the Congress.
Unfortunately, the unchanging attitude of the Administrative Branch of
our Federal Government has been such that we have not been able to secure
further hearings or passage of bills such as HR 143—88th Congress—“National Cemetery Policy.”
At the time Daniel F. Foley was National Commander a letter was directed to the White House, and a very negative reply was received. In fact,
this reply was most disturbing and did not, in our opinion, express the will
of the country. Generally, we continued to operate under the policy expressed
in Resolution No. 610, and our Legislative Division was directed not to
introduce piecemeal recommendations for specific National Cemeteries.
At the time that I was made Chairman of this particular committee, we
began work on a more comprehensive policy statement which we. hoped could
lead to specific Legion legislation. As a result, there was action taken at
Portland where we adopted Resolution No. 501 (Virginia) (as amended)—
“National Cemetery Policy.”
WHEREAS, For more than a century it has been United States Government policy to provide its war veterans with a burial site in a national cemetery, such policy having been reaffirmed by the Congress on May 14, 1948,
when it enacted the most recent basic eligibility statute (62 Stat. 234); and
WHEREAS, Veterans and Congress are aware that space in some national cemeteries is exhausted and in others is being rapidly expended at an
ever increasing rate; and
WHEREAS, In the past decade hundreds of bills have been introduced in
Congress from all sections of the country seeking the establishment of new
national cemeteries and the enlargement of existing national cemeteries; and
WHEREAS, The great concern of many members of Congress over this
acute, vital problem was undoubtedly responsible for the extensive hearings
on this subject the second session of the 87th Congress (1962) by the Subcommittee on National Parks, House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs; and
WHEREAS, The administrative branch of the Federal Government has
adopted a policy that further expansion of the national cemetery system would
inevitably be both inequitable and extremely costly and that the fair and effective way for the Federal Government to participate in the burial of
veterans is through the payment of cash burial allowances presently provided
for by payments made by the Veterans Administration and under the Social
Security System; and
WHEREAS, The adoption of a bill to govern the further development of
the national cemetery system by establishing a National Cemeteries Site Selection Advisory Board, which would, in conjunction with the Secretary of
the Army, advise and report to Congress on the suitability of future
sites and expansions of national cemeteries, would be a step in the right
direction; and
100
Proceedings of Wednesday, May b, 1966
WHEREAS, It is the responsibility of Congress to either provide for
burial sites within the national cemetery system for this nation’s war veterans,
or declare that this century old policy will be abandoned after existing sites
are filled; and
WHEREAS, HR 143, as introduced by Congressman John P. Saylor of
Pennsylvania, embodies certain provisions which are not acceptable to The
American Legion, including Section 4e and Section 6, although the basic purposes of the bill are in accord with American Legion policies; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the Forty-seventh National Convention of The American
Legion assembled in Portland, Oregon, August 24-26, 1965, that The American Legion urges the Congress of the United States to reaffirm its policy of
furnishing war veterans a burial site in national cemeteries, and to initiate
prompt action to establish a national cemetery policy within the framework of
which the national cemetery system can be continued and expanded as needed
m an orderly fashion.
From this resolution there was drafted a bill specifically covering the
policy as outlined in the above statement. A bill was introduced on February 24, 1966, by Congressman Rivers of Alaska as HR 13059.
, ^j£h the bill introduced, an attempt was made to hold meetings during
the 1966 Washington Conference to discuss strategy on how support could be
built for this bill. Due to circumstances beyond anyone’s control, it was not
possible to hold formal meetings, but a series of informal meetings and subsequent correspondence did give us a course to follow. In the meantime, increased local pressure from such areas as Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and
California, had begun to be felt in Congress and there was an awareness
among our Representatives that the critical point concerning our National
Cemeteries was soon to be, or had already been, reached.
One article in the Philadelphia Evening Bulletin of February 17, 1966,
devoted itself to the closing of Beverly National Cemetery in New Jersey.
It also contained a quote that left all of the major veterans’ organizations
mystified. That quote is as follows :
“Patten told the delegation that a representative of the White House said
no change was contemplated in the current policy toward the expansion
of national cemeteries without any unified efforts by national veterans’
organizations.
Cahill said the administration’s position has been conveyed to various
national commanders with the request that positive action be taken to
develop a unified program but no response has been received.”
Another bit of information came our way just prior to the Washington
Conference. In a memorandum from Robert F. Murphy, Assistant Director
of the Legislative Division, to John Corcoran, Director of the Rehabilitation
Division, the following paragraph was included:
“Mr. Meadows anticipates that the HVAC is going to explore the
National Cemetery situation. At the moment he has no definite thoughts
as to what direction the Committee might be headed. Because of the great
concern of so many members of Congress who feel that this situation
has become acute, Mr. Teague now believes that his Committee should
possibly play a part in this program.”
The possibility of hearings by the House Veterans Affairs Committee was
most encouraging and it was felt that it was time to develop positive support
from Legionnaires at every level of our organization. As a result, a bulletin
was drafted and copies were sent to Herbert J. Jacobi, Chairman of the
Internal Affairs Committee, Clarence Horton, Chairman of the Legislative
Commission’ and to the Director of the Legislative Division of our Washington Office. Each of these gentlemen was asked to make comments on the
contents of the bulletin prior to the time it was sent to the Department Commanders, Adjutants, NECmen, and members of this committee. There was
a slight delay until it had been determined that the House Veterans Affairs
Committee actually did have some intention of holding hearings on the subject of National Cemeteries, although all of the bills to date had been re-
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
101
ferred to the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs of the House of Representatives. As soon as this clearance was received, the bulletin was distributed.
The Legislative Division cooperated by giving excellent coverage of the
National Cemetery Bill in the issues of March 15, 1966, and April 1, 1966.
The April 1 article was particularly good.
Plans had already been completed, and there has now been distributed
an article concerning our bill in the May 1966 issue of the ADVANCE.
All of these things were beginning to have an effect. There was an increased interest among the Legislators and we were quite confident that hearings would be held this spring.
Two recent happenings should be noted. On April 19, 1966, a telegram was directed to the President, signed by the Commanders of the six
major veterans’ organizations. Copy of that telegram is attached.
Congressman Saylor, Ranking Minority Member on the House Veterans
Affairs Committee and Subcommittee on National Parks of the Committee on
Interior and Insular Affairs, introduced HR 14438—89th Congress—“To amend
title 38 of the United States Code in order to establish in the Veterans Administration a national veterans’ cemetery system consisting of all cemeteries
of the United States in which veterans of any war or conflict are or may
be buried.”
An identical bill was introduced by Olin Teague, Chairman of the House
Veterans’ Affairs Committee, with the thought that since these two identical
bills dealt with Title 38 of the United States Code, “A codification of laws
affecting Veterans,” that the bills would be referred to the House Veterans
Affairs Committee. This did not happen. Both bills were referred to the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs and we are now awaiting further
word on what effect this will have on possible hearings during this Session
of Congress.
The gist of HR 14438 is that the control of National Cemeteries would be
transferred to the Veterans Administration.
There are other matters before our committee, including two resolutions
but the prime purpose behind our meetings here at this time is to rurtner
the development of an orderly system of National Cemeteries.
Because the possibility of hearings before the House Veterans’ Affairs
Committee could possibly involve questions of primary concern to our Rehabilitation Division, further meetings are planned with representatives of
the Rehabilitation Commission and the Rehabilitation Division so that a unified stand can be presented.
Perhaps the most encouraging aspect is that we are now. beginning to get
the support from the field that is so necessary for any legislative effort.
(End of Chairman’s report)
Under future promotion we are requesting that:
1 The National Executive Committee take appropriate action instructing
all its members to take back to their individual departments requesting department action if possible at their department conventions in full support
of HR 13059—“A Bill to Govern Further Development of the National Cemetery System” and that all posts in each department write or wire their full
support of HR 13059 to their respective United States Senators and Representatives to urge their support of HR 13059 and also wire 'or-write Rep.
Ralph J. Rivers (D.-Alaska), Chairman, and the members of the Subcommittee on National Parks and Recreation,, urging Congress (1) to reaffirm
its policy of furnishing war veterans a burial site m national cemeteries; ana
(2) To initiate prompt action to establish a national cemetery policy within
the framework of which the National Cemetery System can be continued and
expanded as needed in an orderly fashion.
2. The National Commander contact the National President, Mrs. Walter
H. Glynn, asking the Auxiliary to cooperate in the passage of HR 13059
and to contact Auxiliary units in a letter writing campaign to their respective
102
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
United States Senators and Representatives to urge their support of HR
13059.
3. The National Commander contact the six national veterans’ organizations that signed the telegram to the President in establishing a firm national cemetery policy that these six organizations and any other veterans’
groups, such as retired officers, retired reserves, National Guard, Fleet Reserve, etc., support passage of HR 13059 through their National Headquarters and through their individual posts, units, camps, etc. Also, these six
organizations and other veterans’ groups send wires to the White House of
the imperative present and future need of taking care of the increasing demands for burials in national cemeteries.
4. Appreciation be expressed to Lloyd Wignall for his devotion and dedication to our committee’s continuing work and also for the fine support of
Clarence Horton, chairman of the Legislative Commission; to Herald Stringer,
director of the Legislative Division, and his assistant, John S. Mears, and
the entire membership of the Internal Affairs Commission headed by Chairman Herbert J. Jacobi for their continued interest in the committee’s work.
5. Congratulations be expressed to Chairman Hacket for his job well done
in preparing the condensed report for this meeting and for his continued
aggressive work in the overall program of our committee.
6. All members of the commission be mailed a copy of “Briefing Session
With Representatives of the Department of the Army on National Cemetery
Policy,” Monday, February 1, 1965.
Resolutions being presented through the Internal Affairs Commission for
your approval are as follows:
1. Resolution Register No. 1235 (District of Columbia DEC)—approved.
2. Resolution Register No. 1233 (New Jersey DEC)—approved.
3. Resolution Register No. 1249 (Pennsylvania DEC)—approved with necessary changes.
4. Resolution Register No. 1248 (Pennsylvania DEC)—rejected.
A number of other individual cemetery matters were discussed but are
being held in accordance with Resolution No. 610.
Your Graves Registration and Memorial Committee Chairman and committee members extend their appreciation for the cooperation that is being
given to them in their efforts toward resolving the national cemetery problems.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ JOSEPH H. HACKETT, Chairman
Attest *
/s/ DR. PARK W. HUNTINGTON, Secretary
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL INTERNAL AFFAIRS COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were unanimously approved:
“Authorize Chartering of Hohenfels Post No. 13,
Hohenfels, Germany”
Resolution No. 1 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
loreign Posts shall .be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the National Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
103
WHEREAS, The Department of France submitted an application for a
temporary charter on September 27, 1965, over the signature of Department
Commander Helmut Isenberg, for a Post to be known as Hohenfels Post 13
at Hohenfels, Germany, and to be affiliated with the Department of France;
and
WHEREAS, Jesse J. Trotter, Lt. Col., Infantry, Commanding, Headquarters, Seventh Army Training Center, Hohenfels Training Area, APO
United States Forces 09173, on March 28, 1966, submitted a statement that:
“This headquarters has no objection to the establishment of an American
Legion Post at Hohenfels, Germany, in the vicinity of Hohenfels Training
Area” and further reminding that the members of this proposed Post must
maintain an American organization which is a model of comportment as its
actions will be constantly observed by the local German populace”; and
WHEREAS, The temporary Commander of the proposed Post has certified that the Post will have expenses of approximately $45 per month and
income of approximately $400 per month and that the group is financially
solvent; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
Post to be known as Hohenfels Post 13, to be located at Hohenfels, Germany,
and to be affiliated with the Department of France.
“Authorize Chartering of Raymond Howard Post No. 8,
San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico
Resolution No. 2 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
foreign Posts shall be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that “no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the rational Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Mexico on February 11, 1966, over the
signature of Gordon A. Ballantyne, Department Commander, submitted an
application for charter for a proposed Raymond Howard Post 8, to be located at San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico; and
WHEREAS, Department Commander Ballantyne, by letter dated March
10, 1966, states that he and other officials of the Department of Mexico have
personally visited the proposed Post; that “this Department (Mexico) wi
not permit nor accept any activity or conduct which Y1*1,, eSbaJra!\-vV^
American Legion”; that the Post will have the ability to ^afford stabili y
and the means to meet any reasonably incurred liabilities ; and that tne
Post plans to engage in community service activities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
That the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
Post to be known as Raymond Howard Post No. 8, and to be located at
San Miguel de Allende, Gto., Mexico, and to be affiliated with the Department
of Mexico.
“Distribution of Convention Committee Reports and Resolutions to
Department Delegations at the National Convention
(Origin: Res. 153 (47th National Convention))
Resolution No. 18 (Submitted by: Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, Annually there appears less and less interest on the part of
delegates to annual National Conventions of The American Legion m the
affairs of the organization on the floor of said convention; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
104
V/HEREAS, It appears from a study of this inattention it is because
delegates lack the information to take the necessary interest in the affairs of
the convention; and
WHEREAS, Said lack of interest is for the most part caused by the fact
that delegates have little chance to become informed because (1) constitutional
amendments or resolutions are unavailable, except to a chosen few, in time to
permit any study, and (2) so much noise and extraneous conversation is carried on on the floor of the convention, notwithstanding attempts by the Chair
and Assistant Sergeants-at-Arms to maintain quiet; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that effective with the 1966 National Convention of The American Legion, the
National Adjutant, or his assistants, shall cause to be made available to
chairmen of department delegations or the secretaries thereof, resolutions and
constitutional amendments based on the following distribution:
One copy to each delegate assigned to a convention committee;
Departments of fifty (50) or less accredited delegates, 3 copies of each
committee report;
Departments of more than fifty (50) and less than one hundred (100)
accredited delegates, 5 copies of each report;
Departments with from 101 to 200 accredited delegates, 10 copies of each
report;
Departments with more than 200 accredited delegates, 15 copies of each
report; and be it further
RESOLVED, That no report shall be made on the floor of the National
Convention unless said committee report, in the numbers specified above, has
been in the hands of the chairman or secretary of the department delegation
at least two hours in advance of its delivery, unless administratively impossible.
“International Amity Award Winners for 1966”
^Resolution No. 19 (Submitted by: Internal Affairs Commission—National trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee).
WHEREAS, The National Executive
adopted at its meeting, October 25-26,
Amity Award and charged the National
Committee with the administration of such
Committee through Resolution 21
1961, established an International
Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials
award; and
WHEREAS, The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee
has screened all nominations for said award; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion, in regular meeting assembled at National Headquarters at Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that the International Amity Award for 1966
be presented to the following:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Byron Wilson, Canada
W. Lome Manchester, Canada
E. K. Carter, Canada
Meir Bar Rav Hay, Israel
Pierre Koenig, France
A. J. Lee, Australia
Rev. H. Berry, Canada
Harold Berry, Canada
John Hall, Canada
George Waters, Canada
T. L. Fraser, Canada
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
105
“Future Changes in Manual of Ceremonies”
Resolution No. 24 (Submitted by: National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, The National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee,
since 1942, has been responsible for submitting recommendations of any necessary changes in the official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion
to the National Executive Committee for final approval; and
WHEREAS, The official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion
has been developed to include the various ceremonial rituals associated with
both organizational activities and public programs germane to The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, The official Manual of Ceremonies has now reached that
stage of development in which needed changes are usually corrections and
improvements in grammar and word usage which do not reflect or imply any
basic changes in American Legion principle or purpose; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled at National Headquarters in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966, that the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee is hereby authorized and directed to make those editorial
changes, revisions, corrections, deletions, or alterations in future editions of
the official Manual of Ceremonies of The American Legion which are deemed
necessary and proper to effect ceremonial rituals; and be it further
RESOLVED, That said proposed editorial changes, revisions, corrections,
deletions or alterations shall be submitted as a separate exhibit attached to
and a part of the National Trophies, Awards and Ceremonials Committee
report for final approval by the National Executive Committee in any session
during which such changes are contemplated.
“Support Legislation to Erect General John J. Pershing
Memorial in Washington, D. C.”
Resolution No. 26 (Res. Reg. No. 1235) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission. (Approved:
National Legislative Commission—Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, General John J. Pershing commanded the American Expeditionary Force in World War I with distinction; and
WHEREAS, For nearly half a century there has been no adequate memorial in the city of Washington to this great American; and
WHEREAS, There are pending in the Congress two bills (HR 10107 and
S 2338) designed to speed action on plans for such a memorial; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the Congress be urged to approve this legislation and that action on the
proposed memorial be expedited.
“Oppose Burial in National Cemeteries of
Individuals Convicted of Treason”
Resolution No. 31 (Res. Reg. No. 1233) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, Burial in a National Cemetery is an honor reserved only
for a veteran who has served honorably in the Service of his Country; and
WHEREAS, veterans may be found guilty of treason, now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion opposes the burial of any veteran in a National Cemetery who has been convicted of treason.
106
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
“Authorize Chartering of General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45,
Cubao, Quezon City, Philippines”
Resolution No. 32 (Submitted by: E. A. Blackmore, National Adjutant).
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 42, adopted by the National Executive Committee at its meeting April 29-30—May 1, 1959, provided that no additional
foreign Posts shall be chartered “until and unless very careful scrutiny be
given same as to financial and other responsibilities” and provided further
that “no charter for a foreign or outlying Post shall be issued until the National Executive Committee has approved its application and it has been assigned to and accepted by a given Department”; and
WHEREAS, The Department of the Philippines on April 27, 1966, over
the signature of Edward T. Berling, Department Commander, submitted an
application for charter for a proposed General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45, to
be located at No. 6—10th Avenue, Cubao, Quezon City, Republic of the Philippines; and
WHEREAS, There was also submitted with the application for charter an
attested copy of a statement of assets of said proposed post, showing assets
on hand of P120.00 cash and P515.00 in equipment, and no liabilities; and
WHEREAS, Said application for charter was delivered to the National
Headquarters with the recommendation of National Vice Commander Robert
Phillips; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that the National Adjutant is authorized to issue a temporary charter to a
post to be known as General Emilio Aguinaldo Post 45 and to be located at
No. 6—10th Avenue, Cubao, Quezon City, and to be affiliated with the Department of the Philippines.
“Support the Establishment of a Suitable
National Cemetery Policy”
Resolution No. 33 (Res. Reg. No. 1249) (Submitted by: Graves Registration and Memorial Committee—Internal Affairs Commission (Approved by
National Legislative Commission—Rule 8-B)).
WHEREAS, The acute shortage of burial sites in National Cemeteries is
becoming increasingly serious each day, and for many years, it has been
the policy of each Administration of the Federal Government to oppose and
discourage the future development and expansion of the National Cemetery
System; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion strongly opposes this policy and believes it is the responsibility of Congress to decide without further delay the
future status of the National Cemetery System; and
WHEREAS, There has been introduced HR 143 in the first session of the
89th Congress and HR 13059 in the second session of the 89th Congress,
both bills asking for the establishment of a National Cemetery site selection
advisory board; and
WHEREAS, Two members of the Veterans Affairs Committee have introduced identical bills in the second session of the 89th Congress, asking for the
establishment of a National Veterans Cemetery System within the Veterans
Administration; and
WHEREAS, The purpose of these bills would be the establishment of a
National Policy by the Federal Government for dealing with the future development and expansion of the National Cemeteries System; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion continues to support the establishment of a suitable National Cemetery policy and urges immediate consideration of bills before the Congress that would achieve this end.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U. 1966
107
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This has the approval of the
Legislative Commission, under Rule 8-B submitted by the Graves Registration, and it has the approval of the Internal Affairs Commission; your
Committee recommends approval and I so move.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: This completes this portion
of the Internal Affairs Commission report.
... At 5:00 p. m., the National Executive Committee resolved itself into
executive session.
. . . At 5:20 p. m., the National Executive Committee again went into regular session and the following proceedings were had:
REPORT ON VIET NAM
Erie Cocke (Georgia), Past National Commander
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: I hope that all of you will
consider yourself in recess.
I have been coming to Executive Meetings for 20 years now starting in
June of 1946, and what I thought I would say to you is what you can say
at home.
Many times you come here and do not have the opportunity to speak from
the record when you go home. I have just finished a most unusual experience in Viet Nam, as well as in Thailand and in Laos. I had the opportunity
of living not only with General Westmoreland, but with General Stilwell and
Ambassador Sullivan. I spent the first part of the month of April there, and
had the unique experience in the sense that after I was there about two days,
he put me to work, General Westmoreland, I mean.
I am real quick to say that there are several things that are well worth
saying to you, and should be repeated from the platform.
Number one, we are winning this war and
Number two, we are very effectively winning this war, but it is going
to take the patience of the American public to understand what is going on.
I would predict that it is about 18 months from the military standpoint
of view to complete the mission, and we have got about a 10-year program
in terms of aid and other responsibilities of building a nation. But I know
of nothing that was more substantially brought home of the effectiveness of
the 16 years that we have had in Korea than to watch the Capital Division
of South Koreans fighting in Viet Nam. If we can grow that type of leadership in South Viet Nam in the next 10 or 15 years of leadership, this will be
fine. We probably will have a challenge from the communistic approaches that
we have at the present time out of Peking. Peking is the dangerous element
in this particular operation.
As far as the medical situation is concerned, it is about 17 minutes from
the time you are hit to the time you are at an aid station, and that first
medic is the man that makes the clearest and the most calculated decision,
as far as progress is concerned, because he makes the decision on first sight as
to whether that man can probably go to duty in 30 days. If so, he stays in the
country. Otherwise, he is back in Clarks Field in the Philippines in three
hours, about 17 hours to Hawaii, and approximately 30 hours back to as
far back as Walter Reid in Washington.
That I think is something that is well worth saying to the American
public. As to the impact brought out by Mr. Miller today, there are 600,000
forces in South Viet Nam. Don’t get the idea we are doing all the fighting,
because we are not. This is allied action. There are 43 Provinces, and there
are 43 separate actions going on.
I walked out to an artillery position, and the guns were set one to the
north, one to the south, one to the east and one to the west. I said, “Sergeant, isn’t that unusual?” He said, “It is a little unusual, but yesterday we
fired in all four directions.”
I think that is about all, is about as illustrative as almost any point that
you could make of the impact of time and concentration. I was there at a
108
Proceedings of Wednesday, May 4, 1966
time when there were Coups and anti-Coups. Certainly the strength of this
government is important. They have already started moving away from August elections, talking about September elections. My prediction is that we
will probably have October elections out there.
In response to the question as to what type of an election we will get, we
will get a typical Oriental election, not a typical American election, because
the system that is going to be used is in terms of pictures. The pictures of
the candidates will be offered, and they will put them into the ballot box,
riot names, because of the illiteracy.
I think you will find out that we are producing a new concept in terms
of democracy. This is an unusual country to fight in. The temperature is 100
degrees in the shade, about 119 in the sun. It was very hot and dusty when
I was there. The monsoon winds had just started. The rains will just start
at about this time. There is about five months of water, and seven months
of dust, and that pretty well summarizes it.
I am real quick to comment about the impact of the importance of Thailand. Thailand today has done a very effective and outstanding job of being prepared. We can handle the brigade there in a matter of an hour; we
can handle a division in a matter of a day, and we can handle a corps there
in a matter of a week. I don’t think you will ever have the problems in Thailand because of its military hierarchy and the fact that they have been an
independent nation between the French and the British lo these last 150-odd
years.
As far as Laos is concerned, that is an entirely different story. It is an
intriguing country within its impact. Vientiane, the capital, is probably one of
the most interesting ones in the world. The Dean of the Diplomatic Corps
is from Peking. The Russians are there in the International Peace Commission. There are 40 Indian officers, approximately 70 Polish officers, and 40
Canadian officers there, a most intriguing operation in itself, but it happens
to be the only capital in the world that recognizes both South Viet Nam and
North Viet Nam Ambassadors, and ironically, they live within the same
block. It is a real point of contact, and it is important.
I had the experience of being with the Navy out on the carrier Kitty
Hawk, and with an opportunity to fly into North Viet Nam on a mission,
which was most interesting. I would say that we are going to do the job,
and are doing the job. I will say right quick, I got a “pungy” stick here.
Fortunately, it didn’t get infected. Those that don’t get infected last about
five to six months, those that do get infected, that is a very nasty problem.
Now, a pungy stick is a bamboo stick with a poisoned end to it, and it
pretty well lasts about five or six months from the time it is planted with
that poisonous problem. We have lots of wounds with them.
The Famous Sergeant Sadler in his “Green Beret” wrote all about the
pungy sticks. I don’t have to get me a guitar but I am real quick to say it
is to your interest to know of the impact that we made.
I think that General Westmoreland is probably one of the most effective
Commanders that I have ever seen in the field. I rode with an awful lot of
three and four star Generals in both the second war, as well as in Korea,
and I will put him up against any of them that I have had any dealings
with. He is 52 years old, and 30 years out of West Point this particular
June. He certainly is a man of destiny and he has a real problem out
there.
The cost and expense, no equivocation as to its reservation. Shortages,
yes. Obviously shortages of some sorts, like making change for a dollar,
you can use two 50<£ pieces, four quarters, ten dimes, 20 nickels or 100 pennies.
There is some combination that you can use. And when the requirement would
be a 500 pound bomb, if there is no 500 pound bomb, certainly there are two
250s or some combination of making change. So that when you ask about the
shortage question, I am real quick to say that at a given time, on a given
item probably there is a shortage, but I am real quick to say that they are
taken care of.
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
109
I happened to be there at the time when the hotel I was supposed to
stay in was blown up, with some 200 casualties, and some 70-odd killed. I
happened to also be flying off the airport at the time that it was bombed.
The experiences are there. You don’t have to go to the front lines. There
are no front lines. The front line changes at every location.
Now as to the war, what is it? It is a war of rice and war of economics,
it is a war of opportunity. In the Me Kong Kiver, certainly it has a marvelous climate and a marvelous beach. The beach is unusual. Distances are
something that most people miss. The distance between North Viet Nam and
South Viet Nam from tip to tip is approximately the distance from Washington, D. C. to Los Angeles. The distance from the northern point of
South Viet Nam to the tip of South Viet Nam is about like the distance
in coastline from Cape Cod, Massachusetts to Cape Kennedy in Florida. Those
are the types of things that the average person doesn’t take the time to
realize and what an impact we are talking about and the strategy that we
have.
We have approximately 250,000 people there now. I would predict without
question that it will probably take double that amount before we get through
in the next 18 months. Rotation is working out beautifully. The First
Cavalry for example took over some 17,000 people in August and September
of last year. Much to my amazement, they have already rotated 6,000 of
their 17,000 people. They rotated people, and the big argument that came
up at that time was a man that had only some eight weeks to go, yet he went
to Viet Nam, he rotated the ninth week and came home. As a result of this,
they have kept this rotation going.
Critical items are pilots, because in the First Cavalry there are 1,000
pilots alone, and most of them have rotated their 680 hours two weeks ago.
That is the answer. The answer is the rotation side of it. They are moving
very fast and very effectively. Most everybody will come home at the higher
echelon, they say a month early or a month late. When you get down to the
brigade they will say three weeks early or three weeks late. When you get
down to battalion, the man says he is leaving at this hour and this hour,
and it is almost right on it, as far as that goes. We are going to go the
second cycle on many people.
The need for French speaking officers is most important, as well as those
that can handle the problems that we have in both of these, or in these three
countries. The big question is still Cambodia.
I don’t worry about Cambodia. It is one of the places that I didn’t go to.
It still may be our biggest question. In Viet Nam we are invited in, and we
are in at the invitation there of the Government. Now in Cambodia, I expect
an all-out invasion, and I expect an all-out takeover and military occupation
of the type we knew in Germany and Japan.
Now those are the type of statements that need to be understood by the
American public, because there is a difference in the challenge of the people
that we have.
I am going to close with one simple story, having been interested in
prisoners of war, not only having been a prisoner of war of the Germans
in the second war, but also having served on the Commission of the 21 people
that were turncoats in Korea, I have always had a continuing interest in
prisoners. Actually, I witnessed an execution. That did not bother me, because
of the French standards and the French atmosphere, it was almost a beauteous type of Ronald Colman-Gary Cooper type of operation. But I watched
the reaction of the men that performed that mission, and I watched how they
talked and how they fought. And certainly, it is a story with impact with its
own power, without equivocation of any kind that I could tell, for there they
brought out a man, and they tied his hands behind his back, and they put a
blindfold on him. And he stood up as a spy, as he came from North Viet
Nam. He stood up and was there, and what did he say? “I live for Ho Chi
Minh, and I die for Ho Chi Minh’s philosophy. That is what I die for, and
I am standing as witness for him.” And about that time they killed him.
Hollywood couldn’t have done a better show, couldn’t have had more impact, couldn’t have been more dynamic in its impact on the few people that
110
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
saw it. But then when the story goes on, and you sit down and you talk
to that Sergeant and watch his own officers handle the most important question, as he says, “Sergeant, weren’t you a little uneasy about it, wasn’t this
your first execution?” And the South Vietnamese Sergeant nodded that it
was, but then he said, “What is bothering me, was not the impact of taking
a man’s life in the execution of a military obligation and the carrying out
of a court martial, a man caught red-handed as a spy appearing in black
pajamas as is the custom of the day.” But the simple fact was that he said,
“I was born in North Viet Nam, and I have been selected to go back to North
Viet Nam as a spy as a civilian, and not in the protection of a military
uniform, and I am probably going to be caught,” he says to his officer,
and “Who do I die for when my time comes?” And there was no answer.
That is the difference of the impact of what is going on there for the
North Vietnamese that are indoctrinated, that are dedicated with that vital
understanding of its importance. And the South Vietnamese don’t have that
dedication, they don’t have that symbol, and they don’t have it, except in the
power of the American forces there.
Nothing has been more emphatic, nothing has been more dramatic, nothing
has been more challenging than the fact that the American forces have done
in hours what the French lost in 30 years, and what the Japanese lost in
four years.
They have had a lot of experience of occupation, they have had lots of
experience of a foreign military system, particularly a white face. But above
it all, we are winning because we have got the patience to not only build a
military operation as we go, but I could tell you for an hour or so on the
civil side of this operation, for as we fight a war by the day, we plan a government by night. And we protect ourselves by night and with it, we are
having the challenge that we have.
I would say to you that anybody that burns a draft card ought to have
the disgrace of the uniformed groups around him ever imprinted upon his
mind, for that man that is doing a job in Viet Nam today is probably the
finest type of professional qualified soldier we have ever had, for the simple
reason that all non-coms and all officers for all practical purpose, except in
a very few junior Lieutenants and the very junior Privates have already had
combat experience in either the second war or in Korea. And this is for
younger folks, and this is the first time I ever got to a place where I became
an old man.
Thank you very much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you. I don’t want anybody
to feel that they have got to stay.
NATIONAL CHAPLAIN THOMPSON: I just completed two weeks of
active duty in St. Albans Naval Hospital in New York. They have over 200
wounded veterans from Viet Nam. They have a high rate of infection or
communicable disease in the hospital, to such an extent that they have had
to isolate them, remove them out on the main section of the hospital and put
them down in the ramp over in separate units because of this infectious disease.
I fail to be able to reconcile how we can boast on how we get our men
out of there in 17 minutes. We get them in the States within a week, and
they come back here with such an infectious disease that we dare not keep
them with the rest of the patients in the hospital.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: I am not particularly familiar with your problem, but I saw the gunshot wound at positions, they were
moving so fast that I saw this, it was impressive certainly to me, because
nobody in an automobile accident in any major city in this country can be as
quickly removed as what I saw there.
Now on the different diseases, there is no question about it, we have
got a high venereal disease problem in Viet Nam. And I might say that, we
might say that it looks like we took it over there.
NATIONAL CHAPLAIN THOMPSON: In venereal disease, you got a
special condition, you got, you catch a man sitting on a toilet, and he will
Proceedings of Wednesday, May U, 1966
111
get his head cut. You don’t have the problem alone among the military and
in the hospital or even in the barracks, and I don’t think you can write it
off as being a venereal disease. These are diseases which are contrary to these
diseases, social diseases that we are used to, and I think this is a problem
that we ought to be concerned with, and maybe we of the Legion ought to be
aware of it.
MR. HASSMAN, Oklahoma: I would like to know whether we might
have in written form some of these remarks that you have made so we can
take them back, or can they be mailed to us?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: Everything I said is on the
record. I stopped a long time ago arguing with the press about what was on
and off the record.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I wondered about the remarks of the Chaplain,
isn’t it so that some of these diseases are not too well knovm, and they
isolate these people so that they are able to contain them until they learn
more about the so-called exotic diseases?
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COCKE: Could be. There is no question about the fact that it’s been very effective to wateh the transition of
progress that medicine has made.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, I wonder if we might
stand and salute the Colors and dismiss at this time.
... The NEC stood and saluted the Colors.
... At 5:40 o’clock p. m., the NEC recessed, to reconvene the following
morning, May 5,1966, at 9:30 o’clock a. m.
112
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
THURSDAY SESSION
May 5, 1966
, . . The meeting of the National Executive Committee convened at 9:30
a. m., National Commander L. Eldon James presiding.
. . . The members of the National Executive Committee joined the National
Commander in the Salute to the Colors.
INVOCATION
Rev. Alfred C. Thompson
National Chaplain
Let us pray. On this beautiful day, oh God, we are mindful of Thee and
Thy great creation and Thy care over each one of us. We pray this morning
Thy continued blessing on our National Executive Committee, praying again
for wisdom and guidance in those decisions that would help further the
destiny of The American Legion and our nation and each one of us, we ask
it in Thy name. Amen.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
Pursuant to Rule 8-A, Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolution which was adopted:
“Authorization for National Adjutant of The American Legion to
Accept Advertising for National Convention Souvenir Program”
Resolution No. 38 (Submitted by: National Convention Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion has in the past and does now publish a
Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It has in the past employed the services of outside individuals and/or corporations to secure advertising for the said Convention
Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, At the present time The American Legion has no contractual
arrangement with any outside person, firm or corporation to solicit or secure
advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program; and
WHEREAS, It is the desire of The American Legion to have advertising
contained in the Convention Souvenir Program—all of which is to be handled by and through the office of the National Adjutant—now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4 and
5, 1966, that the National Adjutant be and he is hereby authorized to accept advertising for the Convention Souvenir Program together with the gross
proceeds thereof.
(Pursuant to Rule 8-A)
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Pursuant to Rule 8-A, may the
record show that this was read on May 5th at 9:40 a. m.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted:
“Viet Nam Informational Program”
Resolution No. 41 (Submitted by: National Foreign Relations Commission).
WHEREAS, the United States has given to the people of South Viet Nam
a solemn pledge that it will help them defend themselves against Communist
aggression; and
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
113
WHEREAS, United States’ objectives in Viet Nam are 1) to preserve
the independence of South Viet Nam, 2) to protect American interests in the
Pacific and Southeast Asia, 3) to convince North Viet Nam that it cannot
take over its neighbors by force, 4) to convince the Communist world generally
that it cannot expand further through armed aggression, including by means
of the device which it deceitfully calls “wars of national liberation”; and 5)
to convince the small, and particularly the uncommitted nations that the
United States will stand by its commitments; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is committed by National Convention
action to the support of these objectives of our government, and is convinced
that the early and successful attainment of these objectives is of critical importance to our national security and to the future of the free world; and
WHEREAS, for the fulfillment of the United States commitment to South
Viet Nam, it is essential that our government have the strong and continuing
backing of the American people for its efforts in Viet Nam; and
WHEREAS, many of those who dissent from United States policy on
Viet Nam have, both inadvertently and purposefully, disseminated misinformation and caused confusion concerning the issue, and have otherwise detracted from a consensus favoring United States efforts in Viet Nam; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that all concerned Americans
must do whatever they can to bolster public support for United States efforts
in Viet Nam, and to make it clear to the rest of the world that the dissenter’s view is not the prevailing one in this country and that the overwhelming majority of the American people are determined that this country
will fulfill its Viet Nam commitment; and
WHEREAS, American Legion Posts are ideally suited for serving to
bring about greater understanding of the Viet Nam problem and, thereby,
increased support for United States efforts there; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, That each Post of The American Legion is urged to organize and
implement within its community a continuing program of information about
United States efforts in Viet Nam, designed to help build increased public
support for those efforts through the development, on the part of all concerned citizens, of a fuller understanding of the true nature of the Vietnamese conflict, and of a greater awareness of the critical relationship of
that conflict to our own national security and to the survival of freedom everywhere ; and be it further
RESOLVED, That in the planning and implementing of such informational programs, it is recommended that Posts invite the cooperation of all
interested community leaders and officials of other local civic and patriotic
organizations; and be it further
RESOLVED, That a given Post’s Viet Nam Informational Program should
be suited to the needs and resources of its particular community, but should
include—
1) the sponsorship of Viet Nam forums, not for debate but for the presentation of factual data relative to the reasons underlying United States
policy on Viet Nam,
2) arranging for speakers having special knowledge of the subject (such
as United States military and civilian personnel recently returned from
Viet Nam assignments),
3) the showing of available films dealing with the Viet Nam situation, and
4) the distribution of pertinent literature and other informational materials; and be it further
RESOLVED, That the responsible elements of the National Headquarters
shall provide, for Posts undertaking to carry out this resolution, such support
services as are appropriate and feasible, through special bulletins to their
respective department headquarters and through the regular national publications.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just where is that insertion?
114
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE:
Right after “United States
efforts”—“in Viet Nam, designed to help build increased public support for
those efforts.” We continue on, “through the development on the part of all
concerned citizens, of a fuller understanding of the true nature of the Vietnamese conflict, and of a greater awareness of the critical relationship of
that conflict to our own national security and to the survival of freedom
everywhere; and be it further ...”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: If I might comment very briefly,
just a matter of emphasis, this program apparently developed as a result
of a question that was put to the Secretary of State, what, can The American Legion do in this instance, and he felt that our organization was eminently qualified to stimulate the spread of information at the community level,
and I think that may have been the organization of this particular thought.
“Urge Measures to Halt Flow of Communist Forces and Supplies
into South Viet Nam”
Resolution No. 42 (Submitted by: National Foreign Relations Commission).
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that fulfillment of the United
States’ commitment to help the people of South Viet Nam defend themselves
against Communist aggression is of critical importance to our own national
security and to the future of the entire free world; and
WHEREAS, the Communist leaders have thus far blocked every attempt
of the United States and others to bring the Vietnamese war to a peaceful
settlement, and North Viet Nam (aided and abetted by Red China and the
U.S.S.R.) has continued to infiltrate troops and war materiel into South Viet
Nam at a high and increasing rate; and
WHEREAS, it has become clear that, for the early and successful attainment of United States objectives in Viet Nam, North Viet Nam’s ability
to furnish the Viet Cong with men and supplies must be eliminated; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion reiterates its position, taken at the Portland National Convention and previously, of strong support for United States objectives and policy in Viet Nam, and approves of the actions taken thus far, but
believes that further steps are now required in order to halt Communist
aggression against South Viet Nam and the increasing killing and wounding
of our men and boys; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the taking of more vigorous measures—as military judgment determines necessary—for stopping the
flow of Communist forces and supplies to the Viet Cong, including the positive
interdiction of the Ho Chi Minh trail, the destruction of enemy fuel supplies
wherever same may be found, and the denial of the use of the port of Haiphong and other supply facilities, by blockading, mining, bombing, or whatever means are required.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Your Committee recommends
approval and I so move.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: May I speak to this resolution?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Yes, use the mike, please.
MR. DONALDSON: Mr. Commander and members of the Executive Committee, I want to thank Tom Whelan and commend him for bringing this
resolution in. Some people may have the idea that it is just another series
of resolutions in which the Legion is again declaring itself. The connotations
of this resolution go farther. We today are fighting a war in the Viet Nam
of a vicious, well-trained and able enemy. The present tactics of infiltration
from the Viet Cong, the Ho Chi Minh setup is required reading for the military officers’ instructions.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
115
It is common practice in Washington today to refer to the infiltrators as
a fish floating in the pond of society. This is the infiltration that takes
place by the so-called “black pajama men.” You start your men and they are
gone.
In other words, to be effective, we are faced now with two schools of
thought. The headlines of your papers, and the paraders on the sidewalks
of the major cities of the nation have developed the psychology of nonescalation; non-escalation is another way of saying a revolution delivered
from the present government, which is the Communistic line.
The other school of thought follows our military thinking, and here the
men in the field are still getting their targets from Washington. And when
the attack starts, they are not given a free hand to take a target while enroute.
What we are saying here, we wish to go on record, and we are standing
up to be counted, that we want to conclude this war with the military operation and stop the killing of our boys in Viet Nam.
Now we tried hard, our government at 46 capitals of the world endeavored
to negotiate a settlement of this conflict. This is the same procedure that was
used in the first World War and the second World War and Korea, and these
procedures have all been tried. Ho Chi Minh refuses to talk. This is backed
up by Peking. It is backed up by Moscow. There is only one logical conclusion, Ho Chi Minh and company think they are going to win.
We of the school of thought think that we can terminate this by active
military operation and are now going on record to make it clear. So that
you won’t be misled, the last statistics, even the Ho Chi Minh trail is being
bombed. Now it is one of these separate targets. But you have an infiltration from the north running 4,000 men amongst them, running bicycles and
bringing in four to six hundred pounds of ammunition. This is the supply
line. If we don’t eliminate it, and as we term it in the military field, we want
to eliminate those sources of supply and facilities that will be of help
to the enemy in carrying out its policy against South Viet Nam. This is a
broad sweep complex.
. . . National Vice Commander Galbraith in the Chair.
MR. DONALDSON: We are not asking that they do anything to injure
the civilians. From the air, we are dropping leaflets today before ANTAC
goes in. Humane warfare is being conducted. I regret that as has happened
too many times in dealing with the communist countries, the North Viet Nam
government is a party to the Geneva Conventions of 1946, and those conventions describe the means with which the civilized world will deal with
prisoners of war, civilians, Navy personnel and wounded. I think it will shock
you to know that they refuse to recognize their obligations under any one
of them. This is not unusual, they have done this before.
We have today over 100 prisoners of the north. We have never been able
to communicate with them. Under the Convention which we have declared
that we will follow, we permit the International Committee of the Red Cross
to go into the prisoner camps, investigate them for health, medical conditions
and report back. But the ICRC to the north, they can’t get in, and they refuse to let them in. Fortunately, one of our flyers dropped in China, and he
is getting a package a month. His wife is communicating with him and with
the other three prisoners in Communist China today. But as soon as you get
over into Viet Nam territory, we are frozen.
Now the President has taken notice of this situation. I talked with Washington yesterday. He has appointed Governor Harriman as the Ambassador
at Large. Governor Harriman is now in London, and he will then go to Geneva, and his mission is to try and use his best efforts to implement the Geneva Convention.
I would certainly hope that you who do know any of the prisoners in
Viet Nam territory would write through Hong Kong to them. We are trying
to force letters through. And 12 have gone through, by the way—no packages.
We have got wounded men there and we would like to get them out, but un-
116
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
til they comply with the Convention and their obligations, our hands are tied.
It is a pleasure for me to second this motion and resolution, thank you.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GALBRAITH: Thank you, Mr. Donaldson. Commander James will now make a presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, I don’t believe it is
necessary to do a lot of talking about this resolution, but because I feel so
strongly about it, because I live it every day seven days a week, living with
this problem that is facing the American people, as I travel around the country, I want to comment briefly on this to help to emphasize and underscore
to you what you will be doing if you approve this resolution.
The question that I get as I go around the country is first, can we win?
And I say yes. And then they say, well, why don’t we get on with doing
it? This is the kind of question I get.
Now it seems to me from what I have heard and talked with people,
studied, that Ho Chi Minh is looking for one of several things. First, a military victory, if possible. We say this is not possible.
Secondly, the fall of the government or the arriving at a condition so
that there can be no stable government in Saigon. Therefore it will fall of
its own weight.
Third, that international public opinion will turn against the opposition
or,
Fourth, that we will be forced to withdraw from a division from within
our own country.
Now it seems to me that if we are going to help insure that Ho Chi
Minh is not successful in any of these goals, and incidentally, as long as he
feels that there is hope of arriving at any of these goals, I don’t believe he is
going to negotiate.
And so it is important that we do everything we can to see that none of
these things happen.
This resolution so far as I am concerned, the important language is in the
first resolve, fourth line, where it says that we reiterate our strong support
for United States objectives and policy in Viet Nam. And of course, we go
ahead and approve the action up to this time, but now it is critical, “but
believe that further steps are now required in order to halt Communist aggression.” And we speak of the killing of our boys and men. “Further steps
are required.” We don’t say specifically what they are, but further steps are
required.
In the second resolve, we urge the taking of more vigorous measures, and
this is very pertinent language, gentlemen, “as military judgment determines
necessary,” to stop the flow of Communist forces and supplies to the Viet
Cong.
Then we suggest various things that might be done. But “as military judgment determines necessary.” Gentlemen, I believe that the temper of America today is strongly for this position.
In the past, we have not waited, we have taken the lead; The American
Legion has been out front so many times, and if there was ever a time in
our lives when we need to be out front, it is now.
We can talk about fighting a humanitarian war, not bombing here and
not bombing there, but when we stay back and when we neglect or are slow
to take an action to stop these materials and supplies, then we are increasing
the casualties among our own, and although you might consider it a cliche,
I have said it and I will say it again, I think it is so true, that humanitarianism is just like charity, it should begin at home.
So I hope that you will enthusiastically understand and then act affirmatively on this resolution, and having done so, you will carry the message
across to America personally, because passing a resolution alone doesn’t do
it. We have to go out and stand up and be counted. I thank you.
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: May the record show that
the casualties of the United States so far in the Viet Nam exceed those of
the Mexican-American War and the Spanish-American War so far.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
117
MR. LINDSAY, Montana: Mr. Commander, I am happy to second the
motion on this resolution, but as a matter of semantics on the last sentence
there, the last line, the wording of “our men and boys.” Now it is true
that perhaps we have a lot of 18 and 19 year old young men over there, but
I am wondering if we shouldn’t perhaps delete that “and boys” for the main
reason that we don’t want to imply that we are sending a bunch of youngsters
over there. After all, these boys are doing a man’s job, so I would suggest
that we delete “and boys.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Lindsay, are you proposing an
amendment?
MR. LINDSAY: No, it wasn’t an amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We don’t want it, we were just
asking if you were proposing anything.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: We will accept the suggestion
for the elimination of the words “and boys.”
MR. DONALDSON, District of Columbia: Mr. Chairman, may I respond
to that? This very subject was discussed in the Committee, and in the draft,
because the 18 year old group is involved, the effect it will have on public
relations, the connotations it will have with our society at large, it was put
in there intentionally.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Then your position is that it
should remain?
MR. DONALDSON: We wish to have it in there and that is the Committee’s position.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then we will take a vote on the
resolution as it is.
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: You have an amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, he didn’t propose an amendment.
MR. LINDSAY, Montana: Yes we did.
I move, I so move that we make a motion to amend the resolution.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wright, Mexico.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Do you want to make that amendment then, Bill Lindsay?
MR. LINDSAY: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Then make an amendment.
MR. LINDSAY: I would like to make a motion that we amend this
resolution to delete “and boys” because after all, these boys are doing a
man’s job.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to this?
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The question then, there is a discussion first on this amendment to delete “and boys.” Is there any discussion
of this amendment?
. . . The question was called.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you ready to vote on the
amendment? All in favor signify by saying aye; opposed no. The amendment
is defeated.
Now we will vote to the main resolution. All those in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. It is carried.
REPORT OF SUBCOMMITTEE ON REORGANIZATION
William G. McKinley (New Jersey), Chairman
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following
report was received and filed:
118
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
• ; COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN McKINLEY: Gentlemen, I am reporting to
you now as Chairman of your Subcommittee on Reorganization of this National Executive Committee.
The Subcommittee on Reorganization of the National Executive Committee
met in Room 401 of the Washington, D. C. office March 3, 1966, with the
following members present:
William G. McKinley, New Jersey, Chairman
John A. Ryer, Rhode Island
Thomas W. Miller, Nevada
Gene Hassman, Oklahoma
W. Peter McAtee, New Mexico
L. O. Bickel, West Virginia
The principal matter of business was the consideration of a Resolution of
the Department of the Philippines requesting that authority be granted by
the National Organization for the organization of a Department of the Philippines, the American Legion Auxiliary. This resolution (Register No. 1202,
September 14, 1965) was originally directed to the Forty-Seventh Annual
National Convention, Portland, Oregon, but was withdrawn by the Department of the Philippines with the request that it be referred to this Subcommittee for study and report to the National Executive Committee for
appropriate action. .
Your Subcommittee gave much thought to this request and has had it reviewed by the National President of the American Legion Auxiliary, Mrs.
Walter H. Glynn, to obtain the benefit of the thinking of that organization.'
Mrs. Glynn had the subject reviewed in depth by a special committee which
in turn reported the matter to the National Executive Committee of the
American Legion Auxiliary at its February 1966 meeting in Washington,
D. G.
. . . National Commander James in the Chair.
MR. McKINLEY: And as a side comment, I might say that you will
recall in Mrs. Glynn’s talk to you last night at the dinner she mentioned
this subject.
In support of this recommendation, the American Legion Auxiliary points
out that the membership of the existing units of the Auxiliary in the Department of the Philippines is now approaching the 1,000 member requirement of a Department organization. It also invites attention to the increasing activity of The American Legion in the Philippines with concomitant
increase in Auxiliary activity. This calls for more efficient planning and direction of Auxiliary programs and for better discipline throughout its organization.
The need for a Department Auxiliary is emphasized by attempts to
devise better organization through the establishment of an extra-legal Council of Auxiliary Units. Such an organization is without authority to enforce
its instructions and it is not competent to carry out many other duties and
responsibilities normally the task of a Department organization.
Several Past National Presidents who have visited the Philippines have
emphasized the urgent need for a Department Auxiliary in order to keep up
with the increasing responsibilities required of both The American Legion
and the American Legion Auxiliary. The particular and special nature of the
circumstances prevailing in the Philippines calls for the best of organization
and leadership.
Therefore, from the viewpoint of the American Legion Auxiliary there is a
vital need for a Department of the Philippines, the American Legion Auxiliary.
In coming to a decision on this present request, your Committee has
chosen to take a realistic view of the matter. The Department of the Philippines is a live and growing organization. It has overcome many difficulties
with which it was beset during the Japanese occupation of World War II
and many hectic political and economic postwar problems. It deserves National encouragement in its endeavors to maintain an outpost of American
culture for American veterans in that distant place.
The expansion of American Legion Auxiliary activities is parallel to and
in direct association with that of its parent body. It will serve no good purpose
to now make a distinction where, in fact, no distinction exists.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
119
It is the recommendation of your Subcommittee that the resolution of The
American Legion, Department of the Philippines (Register 1202) be referred
to the National Organization of the American Legion Auxiliary for appropriate action.
Certain other business of your Subcommittee remains under study.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
SUBCOMMITTEE ON REORGANIZATION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolution which
was adopted:
“Referral of Resolution Creating American Legion Auxiliary Department
in the Philippines to the National Organization of the American
Legion Auxiliary”
Resolution No. 34 (Res. Reg. No. 1202) (Submitted by: NEC Subcommittee on Reorganization).
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4 and.5,
1966, that the resolution of The American Legion, Department of the Philippines (Register No. 1202) requesting the organization of an American Legion
Auxiliary, Department of the Philippines be referred to the National Organization of the American Legion Auxiliary for appropriate action.
(A copy of Resolution Register No. 1202 is on file in the National Headquarters Library.)
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and approved as
amended, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL MEMBERSHIP AND
POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
Earl D. Franklin, Jr. (Colorado), Chairman
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN: Mr. Commander and members
of the Committee, each member of this Committee has received the Advance Report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee, and 1 am
sure has taken time to review it in detail prior to coming to this meeting.
However, there are several items that I believe are of such vital importance
that they are worthy of your serious attention.
I can think of no more important part of this report than to give you
the current standing of our 1966 membership efforts. As of two o clock yesterday afternoon, we had enrolled 2,431,168 members for this year, and that
is iust 7,705 short of our fifth target date to be postmarked prior to May 3rd.
And the goal we are shooting for is 2,438,873. This gives us a gam at the
present time of 11,831 over the corresponding day a year ago, and gives me the
opportunity to predict that when all the mail for May 3rd is in, we will not
only exceed our target, but will be put in the position of anticipating another
modest gain for the year 1966.
I know that you are all aware that we ended the year 1965 with a gain
of 2 809 members, and we are looking forward to an increase m 1966 greater
than that number, and are anticipating somewhere between five and ten
thousand again.
Mav I also point out that when this 1966 campaign is brought to a successful conclusion on December 31st and we have recorded a gam over 1965,
it will give us two successive years of membership increase, and this
hasn’t happened since 1952 and 1953 during the height of the Korean War.
Your Membership Committee at its January meeting, gave thought and
planning to three membership years—1966, 1967, and 1968. For 1966, our
concern was that a year that had had a very auspicious beginning should
end with a gain. For 1967, our problem was to design a complete program
for that year, even though we are faced with great uncertainties for the
120
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
immediate future. For 1968, we had to consider the effects of the automation of Circulation and membership records on our long-standing procedures.
May I add that those effects will be tremendous—but, we believe, advantageous.
Your Committee believes that one of the major contributing factors to the
success of the 1966 program has been the enthusiastic and courageous leadership of National Commander L. Eldon James. We are especially grateful for
the personal interest he has taken in all phases of the membership program,
for his personal efforts to insure its success, and the continuing support he
has extended from the day of his election until the present moment. The National Membership Workshop, which was first held in the summer of 1964
and again last year, has definitely stimulated better early planning and a
more coordinated campaign. The 1966 program itself, with the six major target dates, was extremely well received by the Departments. Most of them
adapted this same program to their Departments, and have cooperated fully
in stressing each date. As you know, we have more than met our national
target on each of the prior four dates, and I have no doubt that some time
today we will surpass our fifth target date. More than 40 Departments have
met their individual targets on each turn-in date, and 49 of the 58 Departments reached 100 per cent or more of their March 31 targets.
Many improvements have been made in the program being offered to the
Posts, and the quality of our materials is being constantly upgraded. We
feel that the membership program developed over the past several years by
your Committee and implemented by the staff has contributed materially to
the increase of 1965 and our expectations for 1966.
I especially want to call your attention to the 1967 planning guide, “The
Big Year” and our brand-new application for membership, the “New Challenge” which replaces our previous magazine formula. We feel that they have
done a lot toward upgrading our material. We will be using this material in
the coming years.
A study of successful new Posts chartered during the past three years
revealed the significant and highly encouraging fact that, in these new
Posts, an average of 30 per cent of their members are Korean War veterans.
The drive to start new Posts, primarily in suburban areas, has picked up
some momentum and is getting somewhat better reception. We still, however,
have a great many more new American Legion Posts to be established before every eligible veteran will have a reasonable opportunity to become
a member.
It is also my privilege to report that our junior organization, The Sons
of The American Legion, continues to show steady growth, and we confidently anticipate that 1966 will close with our 12th consecutive year of membership gain. A special subcommittee of the Membership and Post Activities
Committee supervises this activity and subjected the entire program to review and study at our January meeting. Several steps were taken that will
add further strength to the SAL. These were of an administrative nature
and do not need to absorb your time at this meeting.
Although at the time we met, 1966 had barely begun, yet most of our
work at the January meeting was directed towards the 1967 membership
program. We are again planning a National Membership Workshop to be
held here in Indianapolis.
. . . National Vice Commander Tom in the Chair.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN:
This National Membership
Workshop has been planned for Indianapolis, on August 4th and 5th, and it
has been approved by the National Finance Commission.
The publisher of The American Legion Magazine, Mr. James F. O’Neil,
has kept you well informed on the necessity to automate the circulation procedures of the National Magazine and of progress being made in this area.
You are also well aware that the automation of circulation procedures will
have a profound effect on membership operations, since it will involve the
development of a membership card suitable for electronic data processing.
From the standpoint of membership operations, we believe that the conver-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
121
sion to an automated, electronic system, expensive though it may initially
be, offers the potential of a vastly more efficient program.
While there will undoubtedly be many problems arising from the conversion in 1967 and 1968, the Membership and Post Activities Committee
heartily endorses the change and is confident that the new system will give
us much greater flexibility, a more efficient and businesslike administration,
and greater service to Departments and Posts.
During the past two yars, I have been privileged to serve first on the
Eligibility Study Committee, and now as ex-officio member of the Eligibility
Committee. Our Membership staff has also provided services for these two
Committees. The preliminary report of the Special Membership Eligibility
Committee, headed by Past National Commander J. Addington Wagner, was
reviewed by the Membership and Post Activities Committee at our January
meeting. The Membership Committee at that time adopted a formal endorsement of the Eligibility Committee’s recommendation that a new period of
eligibility be established, beginning with August 5, 1964, and we heartily
recommend the adoption of the Eligibility Committee’s proposed resolution.
The National Membership Committee believes that the privilege of membership should be extended to a new generation of war veterans as a matter
of right, and not through any selfish motive. Actually, we do not anticipate
any immediate great impact on our current membership if veterans of the
present war are made eligible. For one thing, most of them will still be in
service and will not be eligible to join until they are discharged or the
hostilities are ended. However, we will have a tremendous opportunity to
start bringing new blood, new ideas, and new vitality into our Posts.
But, if we are going to be successful in adapting our organization to the
needs of a new generation of veterans, we must make a conscious. and sustained effort. It will not be enough merely to change our eligibility rules.
We must prove to the Viet Nam veteran that The American Legion is an
organization which can and will represent him, that he will be welcomed
as an equal within our ranks, and will be afforded every chance to take his
rightful place in our Posts, our Departments, and the National Organization. Whether we like it or not, differences in age must be taken into account. There is today substantially the same age difference between the
active serviceman and the World War II veteran that there, was .in 1945 between the World War II serviceman and the World War I Legionnaire.
Much has already been done to bring today’s serviceman and The American Legion Post into contact. Operation “Show Your Colors,” The Viet Nam
Relief Fund, hometown newspapers for servicemen provided by the American Legion Auxiliary, decals for service families provided by Membership
and Post Activities, support of the new GI Bill, Legion Magazines going
to military units, and countless other Department and Post activities of a
similar nature have done much to lay the ground work for the day when the
man or woman now in service becomes a member of an American Legion
Post. But a great deal more needs to be done in the immediate future. Recognition and services should be provided by The. American Legion entirely as
a normal responsibility of a patriotic organization. These should be provided
without regard to whether or not we anticipate making the Viet Nam veteran eligible for membership.
If we are going to expect any considerable number of veterans of the
current conflict to become members of The American Legion, we and our
Posts are going to have to do a great deal more than we did after the
Korean War to welcome these new veterans, to convince them that we want
them as a part of the Legion, and to bring them into our Posts as responsible, equal, and functioning members. We are going to have to accommodate
ourselves to an even greater age spread among our members than we have
ever had. New activities, both social and service, will be needed at all levels—
activities that are in tune with a younger generation. Competent younger
veterans will need to be added to our staff at National Headquarters to replace those who retire. And, in our opinion, we don’t have too much time left
to paint the crib, double up the two older boys in one room to make a nur-
122
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
sery available, and reorganize our insurance policy to take into consideration
the fact that our family is going to be bigger, and our family obligations
are going to go on longer than we had planned.
Action on Resolutions
One resolution to make a minor change in the rules for awarding the SAL
Arthur D. Houghton Trophy is being referred to you through the usual
channels.
Resolution Register No. 1206 (Michigan)—“American Legion Membership
Dues statement —is recommended for rejection.
Resolution Register No. 1220 (New Jersey)—“Sons of The American Legum Continuous Membership Insignia”—is being handled administratively and
no action is required by the National Executive Committee.
Resolution No 275 (Pennsylvania) and Resolution No. 117 (California)
°°j
The Sons of The American Legion Program”—are recommended entitled
for rejection.
In closing, on behalf of the entire Membership and Post Activities ComIwpuid like to extend appreciation to the National Executive Committee, National Officers, and the National Headquarters for the cooperation
and support you have given our program during the past year. Especially,
do we wish to thank National Commander L. Eldon James. His support,
understanding, and leadership have been an inspiration to us and have made
Thank you ^
US t0 optlmistically
Predict a successful campaign for 1966.
ceived'and filtdI0NAL C0MMANDER QUINN: I move the report be re. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Wilson, Florida.
C0M
MANDER JAMES: I trust the Chairman of this Committee will humor me by letting me offer an amendment to his report.
, / ,W”UM
to offer the following amendment, that this statement be
added at the end of the report:
Phased to close this report with this current and encouraging stater
May 3rd. a1966
, membership goal has now been exceeded, the goal
w q i no ' -ifT® tota
L ® of thls moment is 2,442,033. We exceeded the target
re ahead now of
w-+t
,
last year by 20,156. We have met every goal
y Ur
selvesear
°
^ep we wlR meet the final goal we have set for our-
94?8’«7q
ment^^^^^E CHAIRMAN FRANKLIN:
I gladly accept the amend-
• : The. Advance Report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT
MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
to
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Earl D. Franklin, Jr. (Colorado), Chairman
h P a d
plannin^mie
' , £ ?°st Activities Committee held its annual
iQfifiningj-mg at National Headquarters m Indianapolis, Januarv 28-29
mRteea?ht “ actc°rdaace ™th the rules of the Natfonal ExecStWe Com-’
^frn^tng it theat1meetnhPr^r report
^distribution in advance of your May
was averalin^some^fwrn i
7** written, our 1966 membership
Heve^hal ^
W ile
£
membm'ship^predfctio'ns^re always6 h^aldZT^ete-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
123
that 1965 also recorded a gain (of 2,809). We expect our 1966 increase to be
greater than the one in 1965.
Your Membership Committee, at its January meeting, gave thought and
planning to three membership years—1966, 1967, and 1968. For 1966, our
concern was that a year that had had a very auspicious beginning should
end with a gain. For 1967, our problem was to design a complete program
for that year, even though we are faced with great uncertainties for the
immediate future. For 1968, we had to consider the effects of the automation of Circulation and membership records on our long-standmg procedures.
May I add that those effects will be tremendous—but, we believe, advantageous.
Factors Contributing to 1966 Program
Your committee believes that one of the major contributing factors to the
success of the 1966 program has been the enthusiastic and courageous leadership of National Commander L. Eldon James. We are especially grateful tor
the personal interest he has taken in all phases of the membership program,
for his personal efforts to insure its success, and the continuing support he
has extended from the day of his election until the present moment. 1 he
National Membership Workshop, which was first held in the summer ol 19b
and again last year, has definitely stimulated better early planning and a more
coordinated campaign. The 1966 program itself, with the six major target
dates, was extremely well received by the departments. Most of them adapted
this same program to their departments and have cooperated fully in stressing each date. As you know, we have more than met our national target on
each of the prior four dates, and I have no doubt that, when all transmittals
postmarked prior to midnight, May 3, have been tabulated, we will have surpassed our fifth target of 2,438,873. More than 40 departments have met
their individual targets on each turn-in date, and 49 of the 58 departments
reached 100 per cent or more of their March 31 targets.
Many other improvements have been made in the program being offered
to the posts, and the quality of our materials is being constantly upgraded.
We feel that the membership program developed over the past several years
by your committee and implemented by our staff has contributed materially
to the increase of 1965 and our expectations for 1966.
A study of successful new posts chartered during the past three years revealed the significant and highly encouraging fact that, in these new posts,
an average of 30 per cent of their members are Korean War veterans, lhe
drive to start new posts, primarily in suburban areas, has picked up some
momentum and is getting somewhat better reception. We still, however, have
a great many more new American Legion Posts to be established before eveiy
eligible veteran will have a reasonable opportunity to become a member.
Sons of The American Legion
It is also my privilege to report that our junior organization, The Sons
of The American Legion, continues to show steady growth, and we confidently
anticipate that 1966 will close with our 12th consecutive year of membership
gain A special subcommittee of the Membership and Post Activities Committee supervises this activity and subjected the entire program to review
and study at our January meeting. Several steps were taken that will add
further strength to the SAL. These were of an administrative nature and
do not need to absorb your time at this meeting.
However for the record, I remind you that there are still two unresolved
questions relating to the SAL. First, should the SAL have a national organization? A number of our more active departments now do have a fully
organized and functioning detachment organization. (In the SAL, detachment” compares with an American Legion “department.”) Some of the detachment leaders would like to see us set up a national SAL organization
with national officers and a national convention.
The second question is: Should the SAL be designated as the heir to The
American Legion if and when The American Legion goes out of existence?
124
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Quite a few Legionnaires believe that this is already the case. However,
under our present rules and organizational structure, there cannot be an
SAL squadron without a Legion Post to sponsor it. So, should the Legion
cease to exist, the SAL would also.
Our SAL subcommittee, while believing that eventually the SAL may develop to the size and the maturity to justify a full-fledged national organization, reports that this level has not yet been reached and does not at this
time make any recommendation toward a movement in that direction. The
subcommittee also feels that it would be logical and proper at some time in
the future to recognize the SAL as the designated heir to The American Legion, but again recommends that the organization should be more fully developed and gain greater stability before this step should be offered to The
American Legion. With both of these recommendations, your Membership and
Post Activities Committee is in agreement.
1967 Membership Program
Although, at the time we met, 1966 had barely begun, most of our work
at the January meeting was directed toward our 1967 program. Various new
materials were approved, and the post membership program in detail has now
been incorporated in the 1967 Membership Planning Guide, entitled “The Big
Xear. An advance copy of that publication will be distributed to you at your
ay meeting. Improvements were made in our procedures for contacting Legionnaires who move from their home communities to other states and for
helping posts to prospect for new members.
We are again planning a National Membership Workshop on August 4-5,
and may hold one regional workshop, with the approval of the National Finance Commission.
With a very minimum expenditure of funds, a motion picture of American
Legion rituals is being taken and will be available for post use this fall.
IT rl7Ua J)afket offei;ed this past year to stimulate initiation of new memJlad \ very f‘ne and wide acceptance. We are convinced that properly
f°n.“acted Post meetings are essential to membership growth and that steps
?ost meetings must be included in any complete membership prof “5 Amrencan Legion Film Library, which is also operated under the
.P °gram, offers another aid to interesting meetings. Obsolete
turns are being disposed of; new films acquired; an automatic checking and
1 f m af er eve ry u e
devewLw
! also
i u
,
i
a revised film catalog
developed
that will
be available
for instituted;
next year’s and
operations.
The American Legion Advance continues to be the National Headauarters
primary means of communication with post commanders and adjutants Every
mdle tes th
and of its general acceptance.
?
For
e wide
membersh
use of the
p, as
publication
well as for
at everv
the post
national
level
the
L7eStoofnf
HSt-%ini?leMeducation
Tted.at and
P°st level, the rAXance Is an
essential tool ofmadministration,
promotion.
Automation of Membership Records
The publisher of The American Legion Magazine, Mr. James F
n the
O’Neil
toautomate
ceauies of the National Magazine
°
and of progress being the
made
drculaiion
in this area
pS
You are also well aware that the automation of circulftion procedures wni
r
develonmp
nt°
d
p ent
rnd effeft °?- meml?el'ship operations, since it will involve The
fJ®„° “
°f a membership card suitable for electronic data processing Ren
In!!fftlVeS ?£ the Membership and Post Activities Committee sat on the
committee
mend*«
appointed
by the
Commander
to study
mend an answer to
the problem
of National
automation.
At the staff
level and
the recomMemP arK
pnufk'
Post Activities Section has held numerous, at times almost dailv
matior^asTTre^ates
Fom h™ jPivision and the National Comptroller! AutoreIate
TtoJu Ad
AV* ,
s
to
membership, was discussed last fall at the Command,JUtants Conference, again during the Washington Conference this
11
Sln
hei
repj esentat
hv From
Frnl T
f *, ? 2”*]*
'
ive
adjutants
try.
the standpoint
of membership
operations,
we throughout
believe thatthe
thecouncon-
125
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
version to an automated, electronic system, expensive though it may initially
be, offers the potential of a vastly more efficient program.
Detailed planning is now far enough advanced that we are already designing our 1968 membership card. When the 1968 cards areshipped from
National Headquarters in the late spring or early summer of 1967 they will
have already been pre-printed with the names and addresses of 1967 members.
This in itself will be a tremendous time and work saver for the post adjutant. In addition, the system now being developed will, we believe provide
both the post and the department a much more usable record of their cur
rent membership. The plan will be fully worked out during the summer
months for presentation to Department Adjutants at their conference nex
fall-
. .
„
While there will undoubtedly be many problems(arising: from the conversion in 1967 and 1968, the Membership and Post Activities Committee heartily
endorses the change and is confident that the new system will give us much
greater flexibility, a more efficient and business-like administration, and
greater service to departments and posts.
Viet Nam Hostilities
For the past two years, I have been privileged to serve as a“
member, first, of the Eligibility Study Committee, and now °f the Specml
Membership Eligibility Committee Our membership staff has also provided
services for these two committees. The preliminary report of the Special Mem
bership Eligibility Committee, headed by Past National Commander J. Addington Wagner, was reviewed by the Membership and Post Activities Committee at our January meeting. The Membership Committee at that time adopt
ed a formal endorsement of the Eligibility Committee s recommendation that
a new period of eligibility be established, beginning with August 5, 1964 and
we heartily recommend the adoption of the Eligibility Committees proposed
resolution.
We believe that the privilege of membership should be extended to a new
generation of war veterans as a matter of right, and not through any selfish
motive. Actually, we do not anticipate any immediate great impact on our
current membership if veterans of the present war are made eligible, h or
one thing, most of them will still be in service and will not be eligible to
join until they are discharged or the hostilities are ended. However, we will
have a tremendous opportunity to start bringing new blood, new ideas, and
new vitality into our posts.
_
.
But, if we are going to be successful in adapting our organization to
the needs of a new generation of veterans, we must make a conscious and
sustained effort. It will not be enough merely to change our eligibility rules.
We must prove to the Viet Nam veteran that The American Legion is an
organization which can and will represent him, that he will be welcomed as
an equal within our ranks, and will be afforded every chance to take his
rightful place in our posts, our departments, and the National Organization.
Whether we like it or not, differences in age must be taken into account.
There is today substantially the same age difference between the active serviceman and the World War II veteran that there was in 1945 between the
World War II serviceman and the World War I Legionnaire.
Much has already been done to bring today’s serviceman and The American Legion Post into contact. Operation “Show Your Colors, the Viet Nam
Relief Fund, hometown newspapers for servicemen provided by the American
Legion Auxiliary, decals for service families provided by Membership and
Post Activities, support of the new GI Bill, Legion Magazines going to mi itary units, and countless other department and post activities of a simiiai
nature have done much to lay the ground work for the day when the man
or woman now in service becomes a member of an American Legion Post. But
a great deal more needs to be done in the immediate future. Recognition and
services should be provided by The American Legion entirely as a normal responsibility of a patriotic organization. These should be provided without regard to whether or not we anticipate making the Viet Nam veteran eligible
for membership.
126
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
But, if we are going to expect any considerable number of veterans of the
current conflict to become members of The American Legion, we and our posts
are going to have to do a great deal more than we did after the Korean War
to welcome these new veterans, to convince them that we want them as a
part of the Legion, and to bring them into our posts as responsible, equal,
and functioning members. We are going to have to accommodate ourselves to
an even greater age spread among our members than we have ever had. New
activities, both social and service, will be needed at all levels—activities that
are in tune with a younger generation. Competent younger veterans will need
to be added to our staff at National Headquarters to replace those who retire. And, in our opinion, we don’t have too much time left to paint the crib,
double up the two older boys in one room to make a nursery available, and
reorganize our insurance policy to take into consideration the fact that our
family is going to be bigger and our family obligations are going to go on
longer than we had planned.
Action on Resolutions
One resolution to make a minor change in the rules for awarding the
SAL Arthur D. Houghton Trophy is being referred to you through the usual
channels.
Resolution Register No. 1206 (Michigan)—“American Legion Membership
Dues Statement”—is recommended for rejection. The resolution asks the National Organization to provide without charge a return-envelope type of dues
notice. This envelope notice was developed about a year-and-a-half ago and is
currently sold through National Emblem Sales. We believe the envelope is an
excellent way to collect dues and would like to provide them without charge.
However, this would involve an added printing cost of approximately $50,000
to our budget, and we don’t have the money.
Resolution Register No. 1220 (New Jersey)—“Sons of The American Legion Continuous Membership Insignia”—is being handled administratively and
no action is required by the National Executive Committee.
Resolution No. 275 (Pennsylvania) and Resolution No. 117 (California)
both entitled “The Sons of The American Legion Program”—are recommended for rejection. Both resolutions request the appointment of a special National Sons of The American Legion Committee. We do not at this time see the
need for such a committee, since the National Constitution of The Sons of
the American Legion provides for a subcommittee of the National Membership and P°s.t Activities Committee to handle national matters relating to this
activity. It is possible that at some future time the program will have be^®m,e,s0 large that a committee of the SAL could be justified. If and when
that happens, the proper procedure would be to amend the SAL Constitution
to create such a committee.
Appreciation
On behalf of the entire Membership and Post Activities Committee, I
would like to extend appreciation to the National Executive Committee, National Officers, and the National Headquarters for the cooperation and sup£55
f1/!? °ur program during the past year. Especially, do we
thank National Commander L. Eldon James. His support, understanding, and leadership have been an inspiration to us.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL MEMBERSHIP AND POST ACTIVITIES COMMITTEE
was adopt^
Chairman
Stone
submitted the following resolution which
“Change in Regulations for Awarding the Arthur D. Houghton
Sons of The American Legion Trophy”
,. Resolution No. 25 (Submitted by: National Membership and Post Arll^^S2oS£SS.Tr0phtoBi AWardS 3nd Ceremonials Committee-1
127
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
WHEREAS, By action of the National Executive Committee at its meeting of May 1941 the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion
Trophy was established; and
WHEREAS, The conditions for the awarding of this annual trophy
provide that it shall be awarded annually to that Detachment of The Sons
of The American Legion which on January 1 of each year has attained the
greatest percentage of increase over the previous year’s total membership,
except that to be eligible for the award the Detachment must have had a
minimum membership of at least 100 during the previous year; and
WHEREAS, In its continuing study of the SAL program, the National
Membership and Post Activities Committee finds that a minimum of 100 members during the previous year is too low and this provision of the present
rules is not in accord with the growing size of The Sons of The American
Legion; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 19ob,
that the rules for the awarding of the Arthur D. Houghton Sons of 1 he
American Legion Trophy be amended, effective with the 1966 award, so that
Detachments to become eligible for award of said trophy must have had a
minimum membership of at least 200 for the previous year.
REPORT OF SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
J. Addington Wagner (Michigan), Past National Commander
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Thank you very much, Commander Eldon, members of this distinguished Committee, may I first of■
say how very privileged I feel to be able once again to appear before this
distinguished Committee, because I think once again yesterday afternoon
you exemplified and justified the remarks that have been made m the past
by some of the leaders of our nation that this is one of the greatest deliberative bodies of our country, one in whose hands the affairs of our nation
could well be entrusted.
I believe this remark was by Mr. Walter Chrysler when he appeared before this Committee some years ago, and now to proceed with the Special
Membership Eligibility Committee report.
THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
Indianapolis, Ind. 46206
March 23, 1966
MEMO TO: National Executive Committee
FROM: Eldon James, National Commander
SUBJECT: Advance Report, Special Membership Eligibility Committee
In accordance with NEC Resolution No. 26, October 8-10, 1958, entitled
“Reporting Policy to the National Executive Committee,” the Special Membership Eligibility Committee has made available an advance, written copy
of the report that it will submit to the NEC meeting on May 4-5, 1966.
The special committee has performed an outstanding service on a very difficult assignment, and I hope that you will give the report and the proposed
resolution thoughtful study before our May meeting. In order that it may
carry out its assigned task of bringing an eligibility resolution before the National Convention, the special committee is asking the National Executive
Committee to adopt the resolution appended to the report for referral to
the National Convention.
128
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Because of the importance of the report, I am also causing distribution to
be made to the officials and appointees listed at the bottom of this memorandum.
cc: Department Commanders
Department Adjutants
Internal Affairs Commission
Membership and Post Activities Committee
Constitution and By-Laws Committee
Special Membership Eligibility Committee
ADVANCE REPORT OF
SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
THE AMERICAN LEGION
To
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
J. Addington Wagner, Michigan, Chairman
The Special Membership Eligibility Committee, authorized by Resolution
No. 571, 47th Annual National Convention and appointed by National Commander L. Eldon James on October 11, 1965, has held three meetings—November 19, 1965, in Indianapolis, and March 2 and 3, 1966, in Washington, D. C.
During the March 2 meeting, an open round table discussion was held for
department representatives attending the National Commander’s Conference,
which was in session at that time.
All members of the Special Committee attended all meetings, and every
decision reached by the committee was a unanimous decision.
Scope of Committee’s Work
As set forth in 47th National Convention Resolution No. 571, the committee was “charged with the responsibility of preparing a resolution in
proper form, meeting all of the technical legal requirements necessary for a
constitutional amendment, which resolution shall represent the consensus of
the maljy resolutions submitted to this and previous conventions dealing with
the subject of extending the eligibility requirements for membership in The
American Legion, and upon the completion of the said resolution, said Committee is authorized and directed to circulate on or before 1 March, 1966, to
the several Departments of The American Legion the said completed resolution for their study and recommendation for the ultimate submission thereof
to the 1966 National Convention to be convened in the City of Washington,
District of Columbia.”
a
rL. Eldon
,his James
letter offurther
PP°intm
ent dated
11, 1965,
NationalThe
Commander
defined
the October
committee’s
assignment.
National
Commander wrote: “We are mandated by the 1965 Convention to place before the 1966 Convention these simple issues:
(1) Will the eligibility requirements be extended to provide the opportunity for membership in The
American Legion to persons having honorably served in the Armed Forces
since July 27, 1953? If the eligibility requirements are to be extended what
will be the exact nature of the change?”
The National Commander’s instructions further stated, “ .
in order
to complete your assignment, your end product should be a proposed constitutional amendment, in proper form, meeting all technical requirements
setting forth a recommended time period or other specific criteria for new
ehgibles for membership. With this the delegates can vote first as to whether
or not they wish to open up membership eligibility in The American Legion:
and
,. ?ec.°n<C whether they wish to accept your specific recommendation or
modify it as they deem proper.”
Very early in the committee’s work, it began to receive suggestions to extend eligibility to ex-servicemen other than those serving during the current
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
129
hostilities. Many of these suggestions were that the dates of American Legion eligibility should coincide with dates of eligibility for certain benefits
administered by the Veterans Administration for World War II or the
Korean War. Since we were directed to draw up a resolution representing a
consensus of the resolutions referred to the 1965 National Convention, we reviewed the text of those 31 resolutions and found that, with a very few
exceptions, it was the intent of these resolutions to extend eligibility to veterans of the present period of hostilities, now centered in Viet Nam. We
further asked for clarification on this question from the National Commander and were advised by him that the committee should confine its deliberations to the question of whether those serving during the present period
of hostilities should be offered the privilege of membership and, if so, how
this should be accomplished.
In excluding from our consideration suggestions for eligibility changes
other than those related to the present period of hostilities, the committee
is not passing judgment on the merits of any of the proposals it has received. The committee’s assignment has been very clearly defined for us, and
we have attempted to fulfill that assignment without permitting the central
issue to become diffused or confused. The fact that we have so limited our
recommendation does not in any way preclude any department from submitting, through its department convention, resolutions seeking other changes
in our National Charter and our National Consitution. The method by which
the National Constitution and By-Laws may be amended is clearly set forth
in the National Constitution and By-Laws, and departments so desiring may
avail themselves of their right to bring recommended constitutional changes
before the National Convention without the necessity of channeling such recommendations through the Special Membership Eligibility Committee.
However, if we read the temper of the last National Convention correctly,
delegates do want to vote on a clearcut issue of extending eligibility. The
proposed resolution at the close of this report will offer that opportunity if
adopted by the National Executive Committee for referral to the National
Convention. We would urge that those who may be interested in other possible periods of eligibility draft specific resolutions covering their proposals rather than attempt to amend the committee’s resolution. We make
this request, not harboring any illusion that we have reached the final and
only solution to eligibility problems, but solely in the interest of keeping
the issues clearly defined for the final decision of the delegates to the next
National Convention.
Basic Preliminary Decisions
Early in the committee’s work, there was unanimous agreement that the
basic concept of The American Legion as an organization open to all veterans
who served the United States honorably during a period of war should be
preserved. Technically, a state of war was never declared during the Korean
hostilities, but there was no problem in determining that a state of war did
in fact exist from the time that the United States Government reacted to
the crossing of the 38th parallel by the North Korean Army on June 25, 1950.
Today there is no question that a similar state of war exists in Viet
Nam. Since a war does exist, there can also be no question that those serving
in the military forces during this period should be extended the privilege of
membership, just as World War II and Korean War veterans were offered
that privilege. This was the first basic decision reached by your special committee—that our eligibility requirements should be changed to permit veterans
of the current hostilities to become members.
The Korean War began on June 25 with the crossing of the 38th parallel
by massive North Korean forces and the immediate response of our Government in committing United States military forces to halt that aggression.
Without the massive and timely response by the United States government,
made requisite by that aggression, there would have been no Korean War
(and, undoubtedly, there would not be today a free South Korea). Thus, the
criterion of whether a war does or does not exist is seen to be the nature
and the extent of the response required of the United States government to
130
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
an act of aggression on the part of a foreign power. The deployment of
military forces is a normal concomitant of the pursuit of foreign policy goals
on the part of every modern government. But the mere deployment of military forces or even the direct confrontation of a foreign military force by our
troops, as in the case of the Cuban crisis, does not in itself constitute a war.
The question of when the war in Viet Nam began can be re-phrased as:
When did the response of the United States government to the aggression
by North Viet Nam in South Viet Nam take on the characteristics of war?
There have been armed conflicts, guerrilla warfare, skirmishes, and terrorism in this unhappy corner of Asia since 1940. We have been extending
economic and military assistance to South Viet Nam since the collapse of
French colonial Indo-China in 1954. By July 1, 1958, United States military
personnel serving in South Viet Nam were authorized, the Armed . Forces
Expeditionary Medal. This is the same medal that was given for service during the Cuban crisis, in Lebanon, Quemoy and Matsu Island, and various
other areas where our military forces have been involved during periods of
crisis. Until August 5, 1964, our military involvement in Viet Nam was not
essentially different from operations in many other quarters of the globe—
such as Greece and Turkey during the late 40’s.
However, it is now generally recognized that on August 5, 1964, our military operations in Viet Nam changed in nature. That was the date of the
United States retaliatory attack on North Vietnamese forces in the Gulf of
Tonkin. Prior to that time, our military presence in Viet Nam had been
essentially advisory, supportive, and defensive. The response of our government in the attack on the Gulf of Tonkin can be compared to the response
of our government 14 years earlier in ordering troops from Japan to Korea
to repel the invading North Koreans. The Gulf of Tonkin attack was followed five days later by Congressional approval of that which has now become
known as the Gulf of Tonkin resolution, giving full Congressional approval
to the action and to whatever military steps were necessary in the future to
defend the independence of South Viet Nam.
For the reasons outlined above, your committee recommends that those
serving honorably in the United States Armed Forces since August 5, 1964, be
made eligible for membership in The American Legion.
We have no idea when the hostilities in Viet Nam will end. Similarly,
when World War II and Korean War veterans were made eligible, The American Legion did not know when those conflicts would end. The resolution that
we are recommending to you places the terminal date for this new period
of eligibility as the “date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
government of the United States.” This is the same language used when
Korea veterans were made eligible. How hostilities will cease, you and I do
not know. When they do cease, it will be the responsibility of a future
National Convention to take cognizance of that fact and to petition the Congress of the United States to substitute for the present wording (“the date
of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States”) a specific date upon which it is determined that hostilities have
ceased. Action by the Congress in accepting the recommended ending date will
in itself constitute determination by the Government of a cessation of hostitilities within the context of American Legion membership eligibility.
In all of our discussions, the sentiment was never expressed that American Legion eligibility should be based on place of service rather than time of
service. In reading the report of the eligibility study committee which functioned last year and reported to you in May 1965, I note that this committee
also agreed unanimously that, if a change in eligibility requirements were to
be made, eligibility should continue to be based on time of service.
These, then, are the basic decisions reached on a step-by-step basis by
your committee:
1. Even though undeclared, a state of war does in fact exist in Viet Nam,
and in accordance with the traditions, principles, and purposes of The American Legion, the privilege of membership should be extended to those serving
honorably in the military forces of the United States during this period.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
131
2. This new period of eligibility should date from August 5, 1964, since
the attack on the Gulf of Tonkin on that date marked the end of our purely
advisory, supportive, and defensive military presence.
3. This period of eligibility will terminate when the United States government determines that hostilities have ceased. Obviously, if at the time hostilities cease in Viet Nam there are comparable hostilities involving United
States forces in another part of the world, which we prayerfully hope will
not be the case, the present general period of hostilities would not have
ended and eligibility would remain open. The war in Viet Nam is the occasion for a new period of eligibility, but the new period would not close
with the cessation of hostilities there in the unhappy event that hostilities
comparable in nature and scope involved United States forces in another
country when the Viet Nam hostilities end. In any event, a future National
Convention will have the responsibility of petitioning Congress at the appropriate time to terminate eligibility.
4. In all respects, the action recommended parallels similar action taken
during World War II and the Korean War. Those on active military duty
anywhere in the world during the prescribed period should be eligible to join
The American Legion. They would be able to join upon the honorable termination of their service or upon the cessation of hostilities. Those who are
now in service would not be able to join until either their active duty had
been honorably terminated or it was determined that hostilities had ceased
in the manner heretofore described.
Procedure
Your committee recommends that the resolution which is appended to this
report and made a part of the report be adopted by the National Executive
Committee for referral to the 1966 National Convention. If you concur in
the recommended action, the resolution will then be routinely circulated
among the departments at least 20 days prior to the next National Convention by the National Adjutant, in accordance with the requirements of our
Constitution. At the National Convention, the resolution would be referred
to the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments and reported out
by that committee with a recommendation to approve or to reject. A twothirds vote of the delegates to the National Convention will be required to
adopt the resolution, since it includes an amendment to the National Constitution.
If adopted by the National Convention, our National Legislative Commission will then be instructed to petition Congress to amend our Federal Charter in accordance with the resolution. Action by the Congress could be a matter of days or of months, and I will not attempt to predict when it would
be possible for the first Viet Nam veteran to join The American Legion.
If and when Congress acts and the President signs a bill amending our charter, our National Constitution will automatically be amended in accordance
with our revised Charter, and on that day any person who has honorably
terminated a period of service in the United States Armed Forces since August 5, 1964, may be accepted for membership by any American Legion Post.
This report has been given advance distribution to the members of the Executive Committee and to the Departments. It is our hope that many Departments at their conventions this summer will adopt the resolution that we are
recommending in the form that it appears here.
I would like to also acknowledge that Resolution 1214, 1215 and 1216
from the Department of New Jersey Executive Committee have been administratively disposed of through the adoption and recommendation by your
Special Committee of the resolution which will be offered at the conclusion
of this report.
Also Resolution Register No. 1152 from the District of Columbia Executive Committee. Resolution No. 1188, Department of Pennsylvania Executive
Committee, no action was taken on these by your Special Committee inasmuch as only informational copies were referred to us, and they have been
referred to the Internal Affairs Commission.
132
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Appreciation
On behalf of the entire committee, we express our deep appreciation to
National Commander L. Eldon James for his support and guidance and for
the continuing interest which he has shown in our problems. We have been
afforded every help by National Adjutant E. A. Blackmore, and have relied
heavily on the staff of the Membership and Post Activities Section in the
development of the essential background information and statistical data,
and particularly upon its director, C. W. (Pat) Geile. We are grateful for
this assistance. We also wish to thank the National Judge Advocate, Bertram Davis, for his help in drafting the resolution that we present to you
and for his assistance on other technical matters arising from our assignment. We have his assurance that the resolution at the close of this report
is in proper form for action by you and for referral to the National Convention.
As chairman, I also wish to express my personal appreciation to each
member of the committee: Ralph A. Watkins (Arizona), David Weichman
(Iowa), Henry H. Dudley (Nebraska), Joseph S. Deutschle (Ohio), Edward
T. Hoak (Pennsylvania), Lem W. Houston (Virginia), and Earl D. Franklin,
Jr. (Colorado) (ex-officio member). As I indicated at the opening, we have
had three meetings. Every member has attended every meeting. Every member has participated fully in discussions and deliberations, and every decision
was a unanimous decision. It has been a cherished privilege to have served
as the chairman of such a group.
Proposed Resolution
Following is the resolution that is recommended for your adoption:
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, The military forces of the United States are and have been
engaged in armed conflict in defense of freedom in Viet Nam, which conflict
has cost the lives of Americans and has involved an increasing number of
military units; and
WHEREAS, On August 5, 1964, at the direction of the President, United
States Military Forces engaged in the first retaliatory military action to
preserve the right of democracy in South Viet Nam through the attack in
the Gulf of Tonkin; and
WHEREAS, In accordance with the history, tradition, and purposes of
The American Legion, it is proper that the privilege of membership in The
American Legion should be extended to military personnel serving during
the current period of hostilities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to further
amend Section 3 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The American
Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September 16, 1919,
(c. 59, Sec. 3, 41, Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 1, 56 Stat. 1012, as
amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 1, 69 Stat. 379; Title 36, U.S.C.A., Sec.
43, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 43, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part), to
read when amended as follows:
“Section 3.
“That the purpose of this corporation shall be: To uphold and defend
the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace and
good will among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of
the earth; to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World Wars
and the other Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to cement
the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the efforts
of its members to mutual helpfulness and service to their country,”
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
133
and be it further
RESOLVED, That the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The
American Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September
16, 1919, (c. 59, Sec. 5, 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 2, 56 Stat.
1012; July 9, 1946, c. 546, 60 Stat. 524; Dec. 28, 1950, c. 1177, 64 Stat. 1122,
as amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 2, 69 Stat. 380, Title 36 U.S.C.A.,
Sec. 45, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 45, 1965, Cumulative Annual Pocket
Part), to read when amended as follows:
“Section 5.
“That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has
served in the naval or military services of the United States at some
time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July
27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of entry therein,
served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities: Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any
of the aforesaid terminal dates,”
and be it further
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts
the above amendments, and the President of the United States shall have
approved the same and they become law, then the National Constitution
of The American Legion shall be deemed amended in conformance therewith,
but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions in the Constitution
contained, all as provided for under Article XVIII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, Section 2, of the aforesaid National Constitution of The American Legion, shall read as follows:
“Article IV
Eligibility
“Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in The American
Legion who was a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast
Guard, or Air Force of the United States and assigned to active duty at
some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to
July 27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of his entry therein,
served on active duty in the armed forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of said periods; provided,
however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any of said
periods; provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to membership who, being in such service during any of said periods, refused on
conscientious, political or other grounds to subject himself to military discipline or unqualified service.”
“Article XIII
Auxiliaries
“Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited
to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of all men
and women who were in the Armed Forces of the United States during
any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; De-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
134
cember 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27, 1953;
\ugust 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
Government of United States, all dates inclusive, or who being citizens
of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served on active
duty in the Armed Forces of any of the Governments associated v/ith the
United States during any of said periods, and died in line of duty or
after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right
are eligible for membership in The American Legion,”
and be it
FINALLY RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution proposing amendments to the National Constitution of The American Legion, be forwarded to
the National Adjutant of The American Legion with a request that he cause
it to be circulated to the several departments and members of the National
Executive Committee of The American Legion by mailing the same to them at
least twenty (20) days prior to the convening of the next National Convention, all as provided for under Article XVI of the National Constitution of
The American Legion.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, I would like to address an
inquiry to Past National Commander Wagner.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Could we get a motion to receive
and file?
. . . Motion was so made by Mr. Donaldson, District of Columbia.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We have gotten the motion from
at least half of the Committee.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Carey, Michigan.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: And at least half of the Committee have seconded it.
MR. DRAGO, New York: First of all, I wish to state that I admire
and am in favor of the admission of the Vietnamese veterans to the ranks
of The American Legion. There is only one question that worries me, I
know that legal ability of Mr. Wagner will certainly ease my mind when I
get through with a few preliminary statements which honestly worries me, because I was on the original Membership Committee.
There is no question that this Committee was formed for the purpose of
adopting a proper resolution for the admittance of veterans now engaged in
the Viet Nam War regardless of place.
My inquiry has to do with the termination of the eligibility clause as it
will be amended.
Now it says that the termination of hostilities will be fixed by Congressional action as regards Viet Nam. There would be no problem. But in
reading Section 3 on page four, it would appear to me that perhaps this
Committee is going a little further than the original intent of the resolution and of all the Committees that followed your instructions to this Committee, because they seem to feel as follows, and I have to read this addendum, because this is what worries me, “This period of eligibility will terminate when the United States government determines that hostilities have
ceased.”
I assume we mean in Viet Nam. Obviously if at the time hostilities
cease in Viet Nam there are comparable hostilities involving the United
States forces in another part of the world which we prayerfully hope will
not be the case then the general period of hostilities would not have ended,
and eligibility would have remained open.
Now in World War I and II, the word “War” was used. In the Korean
Conflict the word “Conflict” was used. “State of Emergency” was used, and
then it opened up now to the word “Hostilities.”
I would construe the word “Hostilities” to mean skirmishes and other words
described in this fine report, guerrilla warfare, terrorism and so forth.
Let’s assume that there is a cessation in Viet Nam hostilities in 1967.
Would there be any more need of another resolution or amendment under
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
135
this resolution, or would we keep on admitting the veterans by reason of, for
example some hostilities in Lebanon, or in East Germany, or in Santo Domingo or Cuba?
I thought perhaps the words in the resolution after the words “termination of hostilities”—“in Viet Nam” might clear the situation, because I don’t
think it should remain open forever, and it might be possible under those
circumstances, if they do want the eligibility clause reopened again, we can
do it with the same formula. But something, some legal technician might say,
“Well, there is a hostility in Lebanon, we have a situation and a motion, and
in we come. Why don’t we use the words “in Viet Nam” in that part
of the resolution resolve, Section 5 where it says “ ... no person shall be a
member of The American Legion except from these dates” and I would like the
date “August 5, 1964 to the date of cessation of hostilities” and put in there,
“In Viet Nam as determined by the Government of the United States.” I
would like to do this instead of leaving it open as you say, there might be
five or six other hostilities or skirmishes, and we might be bound under these
circumstances to admit these others.
Mr. Wagner, is that the intent of this report, or are we limiting it exclusively to the men who are serving in Viet Nam?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: We are not limiting it exclusively to the men serving in Viet Nam. That was discussed by your Committee
and deliberated at quite great length. And the handicap under which you7’
Committee operated at this time was the inability to see into the future.
I think also that at least to my mind, the connotation of hostilities is
equally strong as the term conflict, which was used at the time that the Korean War veterans were made eligible before it was known what the termination would be. And this phraseology is exactly the same phraseology that
was used at the time eligibility was opened to the Korean War veterans—
the cessation of hostilities, not hostilities in Korea, but to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States.
I think another thing which even adds greater meaning and import to
what your Committee has in mind and what this resolution intends, if you
will refer to the resolution which is Resolution 23 in the digest, if my
memory serves me correct, the first resolving portion which amends Section
3 states, “incidents of the two World Wars and the other Great Hostilities.”
These are the type of hostilities that your Committee is referring to.
I can assure you this Special Committee, that at such time as the. hostilities have been terminated in Viet Nam, if there are no similar hostilities
in any other part of the world, which we would certainly hope there will not
be, and I am sure that the Committee would go along with putting it to the
date of Cessation of hostilities in Viet Nam, but we have been guided here
by exactly the same phraseology as when our eligibility was opened to World
War II veterans, and also to the Korean War veterans.
MR. DRAGO: Let me ask you this, if hostilities in Korea have not
terminated, then under your phraseology, why wouldn’t the Viet Nam be admitted under that amendment, the same language was being used? In other
words, as you said before, if hostilities are continual in one part of the world,
hostilities begin in another, why do we keep open the doors to the Viet Nam
without the need of a constitutional amendment?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
Let me ask you this, Committeeman Drago, I don’t recall when World War II was terminated in Europe, and I was serving in Japan, and because I was in Japan and somebody
else was serving in Europe, that those that were serving in Europe were
eligible for The American Legion any earlier than I was in the Pacific, if
my memory serves me correct.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: May I indulge for a moment to direct a query
to Chairman Wagner? Having been somewhat responsible for the introduction
and promulgation of the original Charter of The American Legion in August
1919, I was thoroughly in accord with the inquiry made by the Committeeman
from New York, in fact, he anticipated the inquiry I was going to make, and
stated it more concisely than I am able to do, so I concur, Mr. Drago, in
136
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
the suggestion you are making in your inquiry. But I would like to address
this question to you, Ad. This proposal will go before the House Committee
on the Judiciary as an opener, because that is where we introduced the
original Charter of The American Legion in 1919. There are some very
active birds on that Committee, not only the Chairman Mr. Celler, but it
will probably be composed of a number of veterans, members of Congress
who are probably members of The American Legion or other veteran organizations.
I can very well foresee that they will raise the very point that Committeeman Drago has raised here. I mean, we should anticipate it and expect it.
Therefore, when it comes to deciding on the date for the cessation of hostilities, I think some of them are going to make the suggestion that Committeeman Drago made, and others will also raise the point as to whether
the date, when the cessation of hostilities will arise. We pray to heaven it will
be somewhat in the near future. They will say, we will have to come back
again, and with a further amendment to your Charter. Did you anticipate
that?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: This was true, I understand, Mr.
Miller, in World War II, and also in Korea, that again, and I don’t desire to
appear disrespectful or facetious, but I ask this question, was this question
raised by the Judiciary Committee when this same language was used at the
same time our eligibility was opened to World War II and Korean veterans?
This was the identical language that was used at that time.
MR. MILLER: Well, I concur in what Committeeman Drago said. I do
not know whether he is going to make it the subject of a motion or not, but
I think, without being repetitious—
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: It will be required, and it will
be the responsibility of a future Convention and of tbe National Executive
Committee probably prior to that time to petition the Congress to set a terminal date.
MR. MILLER: Well, in other words, you expect the Constitution and
By-Laws Committee of the National Convention to probably take cognizance
of the question that has been raised here today?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Pardon?
MR. MILLER: You expect the Committee on Constitution of the National
Convention to probably anticipate some of those suggestions or inquiries
that are made here today?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Well, maybe I didn’t make myself clear, Committeeman Miller. When I referred to future Conventions, I
was referring to a Convention probably far more distant than the one in Washington, D. C., the Convention that will be meeting at the time that these
hostilities have ceased, and it will be necessary for The American Legion to
take the appropriate action to petition Congress to put the terminal date as
we did in Korea and World War II.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, since we
are discussing the matter of the Special Committee’s report, I should like to
address myself to that and perhaps at the same time ask a parliamentary
inquiry of the Judge Advocate if I am in procedural order.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You may proceed.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, as I listened to the discussion with respect to this report, and perhaps debate the
discussion that may come with respect to the resolution itself, I am mindful
of the fact that the object of this Special Committee as I read it on page
two is to present a resolution that would be in proper form for consideration
by the National Convention.
I also read this report, and the attitude of the Committee as not indicating that those who vote for this resolution, assuming it to be a majority, necessarily concur in the specific dates mentioned, because on page two, the observation is made by the Committee, that those that may differ on dates or
some portion of it submit and propose their own resolutions through their
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
137
Department Conventions, and those in turn would then come before the
Constitutional Amendments Committee at the Convention.
As I read this thing, it would be tended to make certain that a resolution
in the proper procedural form covering all of the language necessary to accomplish the amendment would be made, so my suggestion is that if there are
those that disagree with certain language of this resolution, they have ample opportunity to present a resolution to their Department Convention, and
those in turn will be submitted all at the same time to the Constitution
Amendments Committee, which brings me to my parliamentary inquiry, Mr.
Judge Advocate. I don’t know if this is the proper time, because the resolution
has not been offered. But if this resolution is now adopted or passed, it is
not adopted, it is only passed with a recommendation, that would not mean
at the National Convention, would it, the Constitutional Amendments and
By-Laws Committee could not change dates if a majority saw fit without having it circularized throughout the rest of the Departments?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is correct.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: So the sole purpose of it is
to make certain that a proper resolution in proper form is read and then
the Constitutional Amendments Committee will take such action as those of
the Committee will see fit.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: They make the recommendation to the National Convention, the recommendation is made from the Constitution Convention Committee.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Mr. Commander, a point of
information, many of us didn’t understand what the reply of the Judge Advocate was.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is why we want the inquiry
made again, and the answer specific.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Should I restate the inquiry?
Assuming that the resolution attached to this report is passed as it is
now written, it will then be forwarded on to the National Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: It would undoubtedly procedurally be assigned to consideration by the Constitutional Amendments Committee of the National Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: My inquiry in connection
with the resolution then would be this, if a majority of the members of the
Constitution Amendments Committee saw fit to change dates and eligibility
requirements or other language of the resolution, that body would have the
power to make such changes and if adopted by the majority of that Committee, pass that recommendation on to the floor without further circularizing it to the Departments or deferring it to another Convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: No, on the first issue of
changing dates, they would have that authority, but you have to be more
specific with respect to the other changes you are talking about and language, for this reason, that under the National Constitution of The American
Legion, a constitutional amendment may be amended by a Convention Committee provided that the amendment they propose does not increase the constitutional amendment proffered to them.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: And assuming that it is
not increased, they have quite a bit of power?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is right.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: That answers my inquiry.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There may be other constitutional
amendments proposed that come up from a state properly circulated 20 days
before the Convention that might have a larger enlarged eligibility, those
could be considered, sir.
138
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: That is provided on page
two of the report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Yes, sir, that is right.
MR MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander, after consulting my associate
Committeeman Drago, I do not want to be appearing running counter to the
suggestions of our distinguished Past National Commander Dan Foley or the
Judge Advocate, but the purpose of bringing this resolution here today was
to dress it up in as strong a position as possible to be submitted to the National Convention Committee.
I am unwilling in view of the discussion taken here today to trust that
Committee in having the information that we have had here today, and I
firmly believe, and Committeeman Drago. agrees with me, that wherever the
word “hostilities” appears in the Resolution No. 23, that we should add the
words “in Viet Nam” and I make such a motion.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Drago, New York.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Are you going to amend this
report? Let’s get the parliamentary situation straight, gentlemen.
We are now having a general discussion with the Chairman on his report We haven’t even had a motion to receive and file the report, and if we
receive and file the report, we have not adopted or approved any language
anywhere in here. We then get to that issue on the resolution, and may I
suggest that all of this comment at this time is background and enlightening
information that will eventually pin-point our specific argument when we get
to action on the resolution.
MR. MILLER: All right. I will make that motion when the resolution
is formally presented to us.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: I move it be received and
filed.
. . . The motion was seconded by Mr. Lovell, Arkansas.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Motion has been made and seconded to receive and file. Is there any discussion?
MR GRATTON, Idaho: Thank you, Mr. Commander, I would like to address a question to the Chairman, if I may. Commander Wagner, you state
in your report, this is the point of issue here with Committeemen Drago and
Miller that the date of cessation of hostilities is determined by the Government of the United States, the date which you believe will determine the
eligibility for the Viet Nam veteran. This is a real important issue m practically every Department in this great organization of ours. Dates don t coincide with the thinking of my own Department, and I ask you this question,
if you are going to let the termination be decided by the Government ot
the United States, was the date of August 5th, 1964 determined by the Government of the United States as to the active participation in the Viet Nam
War, or how did you set upon that date?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
The beginning date was not
set by the Government of the United States. This was a date determined by
your Special Committee as related in the report, based upon the scope and
the nature of services performed by the United States troops in Viet Nam.
MR. GRATTON: In other words, I can tell the members of my Department and others who discuss this, that this was our beginning date and
it had nothing to do with the Government of the United States or the Department of Defense or anything else?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: That is correct. And also in answer to the further part of your question, I believe it was your question, it
would be my conception, at least, that the terminal date would likewise be
determined by future action of The American Legion, as I indicated in the
report, and the matter of petitioning Congress, and this would be the action
of the United States Government setting the terminal date.
MR. GRATTON: What point, Mr. Chairman? I don’t believe you were
in the room yesterday when we were in executive session, the National Execu-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
139
tive Committee was discussing the nominations for the Distinguished Service
Award to be granted by this organization, and there were only Committeemen present. I believe if you were in the room, I don’t know whether you
were or not—
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: I was not, no.
MR. GRATTON: You would have been receptive, as I was, when the
National Commander read the heroics of the gentleman who was nominated
for the Distinguished Service Award. He went into great detail, I am sure
in the room everybody felt deep emotions and distress at this. And I am calling
it to your attention, that at the conclusion of this, and Commander James
was reading from the citation which enabled this man to receive the Congressional Medal of Honor, those acts of heroism took place on July 6, 1964,
and the accompanying citation of the remarks were read by Commander
James, and that certainly would indicate that there was a major hostility
then in process in Viet Nam. This gentleman survived his wounds, and his
tenure of service continued, and he is eligible, possibly eligible to join this
organization. He happens to be a Korean War veteran, and of course his
particular eligibility is not in question.
I am very pleased that Commander Foley said that the dates are, and
I believe you concur, Mr. Judge Advocate, that the dates can be changed,
but the language in this constitutional amendment of this resolution should
not be changed when we go home to present this in our respective Departments.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: May I just, Ad, may I make a
comment, two comments, first of all, any Department can come in with the
resolutions they desire. It doesn’t have to follow this language. It is merely
being suggested by this Committee that this proposed amendment is in proper
form so that it can get over all technical, legal and parliamentary hurdles
at a Convention, so that the 2,900 plus delegates in Washington can act
on the merits, and that if there is a Department that wishes to have a different content as to the criteria of eligibility, whether it be date or otherwise, they may come in with that. But it is suggested that it would be well
in other words that they avoid parliamentary or legal loopholes and problems, that they follow this general arrangement.
Now if you wanted to put in “Korean hostilities,” “Viet Nam hostilities,”
or whatever along that line, you will be able to do so.
Now also, you will be able to change the date. I would assume that from
the ruling that the Judge Advocate made that if we at the Convention in a
Constitutional Amendments Committee change the resolution from just hostilities to some more specific and more delimiting hostilities, this is not enlarging the resolution, and would be permitted, is that correct?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That is correct.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: But this does not keep any Department from coming in with any resolution they want, provided they get
it in time to be circulated 20 days before the Convention.
Now on the other point, Ad, I would like to add an annotation about
whether the Government set the beginning date that we have here. I would
suggest that it didn’t, in terms of writing out a date dictating to us, but in
terms of the Government’s action, the action of the Government in taking on
combat, moving a combat operation, did determine that. That is the difference
in the sense that we think of the Government determining the date.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Mr. Commander, I swore
I wasn’t going to say anything at this Executive Session.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: We would rather swear if you didn’t,
Past National Commander.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: I want to commend you
for your fine foresight in appointing an able Committee to do the thing that
you have indicated here, because my experience has been that it is practically
impossible for a Department to come in with a constitutional amendment on
any major subject that conforms to all the technicalities.
140
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
They have done a great job.
Now you know as well as I know, the two things that are bothering Bill
and Drago and Gratton, one of them wants to extend the date, which I don’t
think can be done, that is why I asked for a further explanation about it,
you can’t move it up, if Ad’s Committee says ’64, you can’t move that up to
extend it, can you?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Not with this particular proposed
amendment, but if another state came in with one it could broaden it.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER QUINN: Well, young man, you are
dreaming when you think any Department is going to come in with one,
because they haven’t got time, they don’t know how to do it, and it will
finally finish up by throwing it out.
Now I think that we ought to have discussion here, we ought to have
discussion on whether or not the first date is too restrictive or whether the
last date is too wide open as to its termination.
Personally, I think that the thing that should be done is to adopt this
resolution as it stands now, and then the Department Executive Committee
will then be on notice as you have so ably stated so many, many times,
the only thing is, they don’t want to take the responsibility of going back to
their Department and bringing in a legal constitutional amendment.
You have one here. It may not conform to all the points, but I think
that what should be done is that we should refer this to the Convention with
our approval, and then let all these people who are on notice, if they don’t
agree with the thinking of this able Committee, and this is a real good one.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES:
Mr. Past National Commander,
let me make an observation, because we are rapidly getting into a point of debating a resolution that is not before us.
I would like to say that I neither express the hope nor the desire that
a Department would come in with another resolution, but the possibility is
that they could.
Now may I suggest for orderliness, gentlemen, we are still debating the
report, we don’t want to have to debate the report and come back with the
same debate on the resolution.
Would you consider it appropriate to receive and file?
It has been moved and seconded that the report be received and filed.
All in favor signify by saying aye; those opposed no. The ayes have it
and the report has been received and filed.
Gentlemen, before anyone takes the floor at the moment, we do not have
any resolution on the floor. In order to get it, we have to recognize the
Chairman of the Subcommittee on Resolutions and at this point, let me say
this, so many of us never give any consideration or thought to the work of
the Subcommittee on Resolutions, and the trying time that the Chairman has
particularly with a fellow in, with spurs in the Chair, who rides me all the
time, and I want you to know what this fellow is doing. We have a historic
moment coming up and I think he may want to express himself on something
not quite germane to the resolution, and he has the permission of the Chair
to do so.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
SPECIAL MEMBERSHIP ELIGIBILITY COMMITTEE
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Thank you very much, Mr.
Commander, for those very kind remarks.
Resolution No. 23 has been distributed and is on your desk. You have
in reading and hearing Mr. Wagner’s report, have practically the same resolution as has already been read before this group.
However, that is a matter of three pages, and in the interest of time, I
think each man can individually read the resolution, and it is couched in
Proceedings of Thursday,, May 51 1966
141
judicial language, I think, which is in keeping with the constitutional amendments, it has to be that way.
Now, Mr. Commander and members of the Executive Committee, I have
been on this Committee, and I am now in my 13th year.
Prior to my coming on the Committee, I met and became very well acquainted with the gentleman who today is serving his last meeting at the
May meeting. He is completing 20 years of service on this Committee. He has
served on the Subcommittee on Resolutions and it has been my pleasure to
serve under him and to some extent have been trained by him.
He is a very close personal friend which has been developed and which
has been nurtured by our friendship in The American Legion There is one
doggone thing about it, he can sure fish, and I have been fishing with him
a number of times, and there is nothing any closer than a comradeship that
you gain while you are fishing with a buddy.
I am asking the permission, Mr. Commander, that Mr. Wilson be given
the privilege of, let us say considering this resolution as read by Mr. Wilson, that he come to the front and move the approval of the adoption of the
resolution in behalf of the Subcommittee.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Past Chairman of the Resolutions Subcommittee to this Committee is recognized for that purpose.
. . . Mr. Wilson, Florida, presented the following resolution:
“Amendments to Sections 3 and 5 of the Federal Act Incorporating
The American Legion, and to Article IV, Section 1, and to Article
XIII Section 2 of the National Constitution of The American Legion,
to extend Eligibility for Membership in The American Legion to those
persons who served in the Armed Forces from on or after August 5, 19b
Resolution No. 23 (Submitted by: Special Membership Eligibility Committee-National Constitution and By-Laws Committee—Internal Affairs Commission).
WHEREAS, The military forces of the United States are and have been
engaged in armed conflict in defense of freedom in Viet Nam, which conflict
has cost the lives of Americans and has involved an increasing number of military units; and
,
WHEREAS On August 5, 1964, at the direction of the President, United
States Military Forces engaged in the first retaliatory military action to
preserve the right of democracy in South Viet Nam through the attack m
the Gulf of Tonkin; and
WHEREAS, In accordance with the history, tradition, and purposes of
The American Legion, it is proper that the privilege of membership m lhe
American Legion should be extended to military personnel serving during the
current period of hostilities; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, that the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized
and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to further amend
Section 3 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The American Legion
(Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September 16 1919, (c. 59,
Sec 3 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 1, 56 Stat. 1012, as amended
July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 1, 69 Stat. 379; Title 36 U.S.C.A Sec. 43, and
Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 43, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part), to read
when amended as follows:
“Section 3.
“That the purpose of this corporation shall be: To uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace
and good will among the peoples of the United States and all the nations
of the earth; to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World
Wars and the other Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to cement the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the
efforts of its members to mutual helpfulness and service to their country,
and be it further
142
Proceedings
of
Thursday, May
5t 1966
RESOLVED, That the National Legislative Commission be and it is hereby authorized and directed to petition the Congress of the United States to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled “An Act to Incorporate The
American Legion,” (Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress), approved September
16, 1919 (c. 69, Sec. 5, 41 Stat. 285; Oct. 29, 1942, c. 633, Sec. 2, 56 Stat. 1012;
July 9, 1946, c. 546, 60 Stat. 524; Dec. 28, 1950, c. 1177, 64 Stat. 1122, as
amended July 26, 1955, c. 386, Sec. 2, 69 Stat. 380, Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec.
45, and Title 36 U.S.C.A., Sec. 45, 1965 Cumulative Annual Pocket Part),
to read when amended as follows:
“Section 5.
“That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has
served in the naval or military services of the United States at some
time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July
27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or
who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of entry therein,
served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities: Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any
of the aforesaid terminal dates,”
and be it further
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts
the above amendments, and the President of the United States shall have
approved the same and they become law, then the National Constitution of
The American Legion shall be deemed amended in conformance therewith,
but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions in the Constitution
contained, all as provided for under Article XVIII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, section 2, of the aforesaid National Constitution of The American Legion, shall read as follows:
“Article IV
Eligibility
“Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in The American Legion who was a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast
Guard, or Air Force of the United States and assigned to active duty at
some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950,
to July 27, 1953; August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities
as determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive,
or who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of his entry
therein, served on active duty in the armed forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of said periods; provided, however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any
of said periods; provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to
membership who, being in such service during any of said periods, refused on conscientious, political or other grounds to subject himself to
military discipline or unqualified service.”
“Article XIII
Auxiliaries
“Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of members of The
American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters and sisters of
all men and women who were in the Armed Forces of the United States
during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27 1953August 5, 1964, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
143
the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being
citizens of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served
on active duty in the Armed Forces of any of the Governments associated
with the United States, during any of said periods, and died in line of duty
or after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right
are eligible for membership in The American Legion,”
and be it
FINALLY RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution proposing amendments to the National Constitution of The American Legion, be forwarded to
the National Adjutant of The American Legion with a request that he cause
it to be circulated to the several departments and members of the National
Executive Committee of The American Legion by mailing the same to them at
least twenty (20) days prior to the convening of the next National Convention, all as provided for under Article XVI of the National Constitution
of The American Legion.
MR. WILSON: As the Chairman has said to you, Resolution 23 has
the approval of the Committee, and I so move you, sir, that your approval
be given.
... The motion was seconded by Mr. Watkins, Arizona.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The floor is now open for discussion on the resolution.
The Dean of this organization is now recognized, Committeeman Miller.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander and members of the Committee I thoroughly echo the statements of our National Commander a moment ago for so calling our attention to the fact that we did not know it
and appreciate that this Commission has worked under Ad Wagner, has
worked long and hard, and I have no desire whatsoever to in any way mess
up their splendid work. But I would like to call your attention again to the
fact that this is brought before us today, the National Executive Committee,
to dress it up in the strongest terms possible so that when it is sent into
the Constitutional Committee of the National Convention, it will reflect our
mature ideas on the subject.
As I told you a while ago when Committeeman Drago so properly and
adequately presented this matter to you, I did not want to be repetitious
so I will not renew any of the arguments you already heard then. But I
personally and firmly believe that we should send this on to the various Departments dressed up as strongly as possible, because I can see if this gets
into a hassle before the Constitution and By-Laws Committee with 50 or
60 more delegates, they might not be able to give it the mature consideration
that we have been permitted to give it here today m view of the splendid
report made by Chairman Wagner and his Committee. Therefore, I am
to follow the suggestion of Committeeman Drago and on page 14 o± the
Resolution No. 23, Section 5, at the bottom of the page, where the word
“hostilities” appears, on page 15, “Article IV, Eligibility,,f> where the word
“hostilities” appears and Article XIII entitled Auxiliaries, Section 2, where
the word “hostilities” appears, just to insert the words m Viet Nam.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Second the motion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let’s be sure, Committeeman Miller, that we have the full text of your amendment.
Let’s start with the first resolve on page 14 in the middle of the page,
does your amendment offer any change in the language to Section 3 under
that resolve?
MR. MILLER: No.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, let’s take the second
resolve in Section 5, does your amendment offer any change in the language
of that Section 5?
MR. MILLER: Yes, sir, the words “in Viet Nam.” After the word
“hostilities.”
.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: What line is that on, sir?
144
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, I960
MR. MILLER: Line five.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right now, we will take the
first resolve on page 15. There is a Section 1 and a Section 2. Is Section 1
involved?
MR. MILLER: No, Article IV “Eligibility.” and it is down there, it is
line six after the word “hostilities.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: “In Viet Nam.” All right, sir. I
ask the question then under Article XIII, Section 2, the same language would
be—
MR. MILLER: On the seventh line the word “hostilities” then add the
words “in Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are there any other proposed
changes?
MR. MILLER: No, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: So three changes.
As I understand your amendment now, your amendment is to offer the
insertion of the words “in Viet Nam” in the following places: the resolve
at the bottom of page 14 under Section 5, line six; on page 15 under Article
IV, Eligibility, Section 1, the words will be added in the sixth line after the
word “hostilities,” and under Article XIII “Auxiliaries,” Section 2, the words
to be added after “hostilities” in the seventh line. Those three places. Now
are we all clear on your amendment?
Is that it?
MR. MILLER: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: This is an amendment which has
been seconded by Committeeman Drago.
Is there any discussion?
Mr. Chairman, would you like to address yourself to the amendment?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER:
Thank you, Mr. Commander.
Gentlemen, with regard to this amendment, I would only ask that you consider this, because at the round table discussions in Washington this question
was asked. Because of the wording in our report and the use of the words
“South Viet Nam” or “Viet Nam” it was the intent of our report and the intent of the resolution to restrict eligibility to those serving in Viet Nam
only.
It was the determination of your Special Committee and those at that
round table discussion were so advised, that your Special Committee had no
such intent, because historically in The American Legion our membership
eligibility has been based upon the time of service and not where we served.
This I feel is important to remember. I think you are getting dangerously
close by adding the words “in Viet Nam.” After the word “hostilities” in
Section 5 the first resolve, Section 1 of the second resolve and in Section 2
of the second resolve. I think you are getting dangerously close to this being
interpreted that we mean people who served in our Armed Forces from August 5, 1964 to the date of cessation of hostilities in Viet Nam only, thereby
departing drastically from the historic premise of membership in The American Legion.
Another thing I would like to point out is that I don’t believe that this
amendment would accomplish what I interpret the desire of Committeeman
Drago and Committeeman Miller to accomplish, and that is that we in The
American Legion petition Congress to set a terminal date.
Even with the inclusion of this amendment, the Judge Advocate can correct me if I am wrong, I still feel that it will be necessary for The American
Legion to petition Congress to set a terminal date.
This is still going to have to be done by this Executive Committee for
the resolution or a proposed amendment to the National Convention by a National Convention to the Congress of the United States.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
145
The language that is contained in the resolution presently will require
the same action of this Executive Committee and of a subsequent National
Convention.
So I think there are two dangers, one danger of having this resolution
construed as limiting our eligibility to membership of those who served in
the Armed Forces of Viet Nam only,
Secondly, I don’t think you accomplish anything that isn’t going to have
to be done by this Committee, and by subsequent Conventions anyway to ask
Congress to set a terminal date.
MR. DRAGO, New York: Mr. Commander, Mr. Wagner and members of
the Executive Committee, I know that Ad Wagner is not trying to divert this
issue, but probably misunderstood me.
I have been a known advocate that any man that is serving in the Armed
Forces of the United States during a time of emergency or conflict or war
is eligible to join The American Legion. This language is simple. I am trying to see to it that this resolution will pass at our Convention with a
minimum amount of trouble. And I don’t want hostilities to come into this
picture.
I am only interested in the war in Viet Nam at this time. Now if there
should come a time when there are other hostilities, and we think that there
should be admission to veterans in that war, let us go through this procedure
again.
Now this language is clear. I am trying to be specific, and I don t care
what that Committee said. This is a resolution before the National Executive
Committee, and I cannot in conscience approve a resolution which will leave
this open from now until 2000, 35 years from now. The intent here is
admit every veteran who served in the Armed Forces during the period ot
hostilities in the Viet Nam War.
Now that makes it specific, and that is all I ask. If I went back to New
York and said, well, there may be other hostilities in the Dominican Republic,
or Guatemala, let them go through this procedure again as we did this time.
I only want to be clear, that we are interested right now in the Soldiers,
Sailors and Marines and Air Force men, no matter where they serve, who
will be eligible, providing they come in after the date which will be fixed,
and I don’t care when Congress fixes it. But it must pertain to Viet Nam
and nothing else.
Now I don’t want this Committee to leave it open so that they can come
in later and say, well, there was a hostility, there was a confrontation, and
there was a skirmish, and under this resolution, you make a motion to admit
them.
I want it simple and specific. I am not taking away any iota of the intent of this resolution.
I simply want the words “of Viet Nam” so there will be no discussion later
that we opened the door to peacetime, or discourage veterans who are confrontation veterans. I want the words “termination of hostilities, where,
concerning Viet Nam. There is no limitation as to the question of place, Mr.
Wagner The time is the essence, wherever you serve, in the United States,
Europe, Asia, they will be eligible, but I think we ought to close it simply
by inserting these words, and it will be specific. It will be clear, and I think
we will have no trouble at the Convention, because I feel, you know, that
there were 31 resolutions passed last time by different Departments, and
every one of them was defective. We don’t know how to do this.
Now we have this brain work now, why not limit it to what the Convention
wanted and what the Commander himself stated in his orders that we confine ourselves to the Viet Nam War and no other?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Now just a moment. The Chair
is trying strictly not to comment in a way that would show partiality. So
I will make my comment by asking you a question, Lou.
MR. DRAGO: Yes, sir.
146
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I gather it is your intent to try
to tighten up the language to limit to a period identified with the struggle
over the problem in Viet Nam?
MR. DRAGO: That is right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I tried to frame my question without using the word “in” but I found it very difficult. Now we use the word
“in” with respect to any geographical location, aren’t you then bringing
geography in it and although you are trying to simplify it, do you not complicate it?
MR. DRAGO: You are right—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Have we used the word “in” with
respect to any other eligibility criteria during World War I, during World
War II, in Korea? Did we use “in Korean hostilities”? Now, in respect to
Viet Nam, they are not limited to “in” Viet Nam, so I suggest that you
may be on target with what your goal is, it may be a little fuzzy, and will
you review it a little as we debate this?
MR. DRAGO: Right, and that is the way I would like the interpretation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Think about it before you come up
with another one that won’t have another very, very little flaw in it.
MR. DRAGO: It would be my right as a member of the National Executive Committee, regardless of your statement.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: It certainly would.
MR. DREW, Pennsylvania: Mr. Commander, as a freshman member of
the NEC, I feel I should not be on my feet, but I am interested in this
eligibility resolution.
I would like to ask the Judge Advocate if he can read off to us the ultimate
result of the Korean opening of our Charter, what was the closing phrase
as to hostilities? Are we not using that same phraseology in this resolution?
If we are using the same phraseology in this resolution, I don’t believe that
we have any problems, or that they had any problems when they closed out
the Korean conflict as it affects the American Legionnaires.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will the Judge Advocate address
yourself to that question?
. . .National Vice Commander Choppin in the Chair.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: I am reading to you Title
36 of the United States Codes Annotated 1965 Cumulative Pocket Edition,
Section 43 of the Code which corresponds to Section 3 of your Code. I quote:
“The purpose of this corporation shall be to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of American; to promote peace and good will
among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of the earth;
to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World Wars and the other
Great Hostilities fought to uphold democracy.” You want me to read any
more?
That pertains in correspondence to Section 3 of the resolution you are
amending.
MR. JANKO, Texas: I would like to ask a question.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Ask a question of who?
MR. JANKO: The Judge Advocate.
In regard to parliamentary procedure on this particular issue, now you
have an amendment to this resolution, if we vote this amendment favorably
will that prohibit any further amendments on this resolution?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Amendments where, in this
body?
MR. JANKO: In this body.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: If this body amends this
resolution and adopts the amendment, if may adopt another amendment. And
in Robert’s Rules of Order you may amend to the second degree.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
147
MR. JANKO: I wish to make another amendment later on, but I don’t
want to confuse the issue with this.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Why do you not, sir, address yourself to this amendment? You can further amend this amendment.
You can go to the second degree, or do you approve of this amendment? You
want the resolution adopted, and then you want to make an amendment?
MR. JANKO: I want to amend the resolution in a different manner.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I wonder if the Judge Advocate,
just to move this along, I think Walter has an amendment that has nothing
to do with the proposed amendment at this time. It has to do with the
dates, doesn’t it, Walter?
MR. JANKO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Let’s keep it separate. You will
be given ample opportunity to pose any amendment.
I think yours doesn’t apply to the definition of hostilities?
MR. JANKO: Right.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You will be given ample opportunity, I can assure you.
MR. FERN, Kentucky: Mr. Commander, I have a question of the Judge
Advocate, will you continue reading from the Code in Section 5?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: That part to correspond with
Section 5?
MR. FERN: Yes, that part which coincides with Section 5 of this resolution.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: I quote from Section 45, Title
36, United States Code Annotated, Cumulative Annual Pocket Part:
“No person shall be a member of this corporation unless he has served
in the naval or military services of the United States at some time during
any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941 to September 2, 1945; June 25, 1950, to July 27, 1953, and all
dates inclusive, or who, being a citizen of the United States at the time of
entry therein, served in the military or naval service of any of the governments associated with the United States during said wars or hostilities:
Provided, However, That such person shall have an honorable discharge or
separation from such service or continues to serve honorably after any of the
aforesaid terminal dates. As amended July 26, 1955, Chapter 386, Section 2,
Statute 69-380.”
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Commander and members of the Committee,
I ask the unanimous consent to withdraw the amendment I submitted a while
ago with the agreement of my second.
Do I have it?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I will make the inquiry. Does he
have it?
MR. DRAGO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: If it is withdrawn, there is no
amendment on the floor.
MR. MILLER: Following out the suggestion the National Commander
made—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Now wait just a minute.
MR. MILLER: I withdraw that too.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You are going to be ruled out of
order although you were here in 1919.
MR MILLER: And the substitution of the amendment, in substitution
of the amendment I withdrew, I make the following motion, after the word
“hostilities” as it appears on pages 14 to 15 of Resolution 23, add the words
“which date shall apply to the war in Viet Nam. You get it. You got it in
148
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
front of you there. In other words, after the word “hostilities” add the words
“which date shall apply to the war in Viet Nam.”
Do I have a second?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just a minute, what is your amendment?
MR. MILLER: After the word “hostilities” where it appears in Resolution 23 on pages 14 and 15, add these words “which date shall apply to
the war in Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: You have changed it from the
other one, you have just added a few other words, Committeeman Miller.
Would you address yourself to the semantics of the difference between this
and what you had before?
MR. MILLER: Well, I think it follows out the suggestion that our National Commander made—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, it does not. You may swear
me under oath and I will testify that it does not.
MR. MILLER: Then I will stand up here barefaced and make it on
my own. In other words, I will state it again, so that there won’t be any
ambiguity, in Resolution 23 on pages 14 and 15 after the word “hostilities”
where it appears, insert the following, “which date shall apply to the war
in Viet Nam.” That is all I am saying to you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to that?
MR. DRAGO, New York: I will second it.
MR. JACKSON, Delaware: Mr. Commander, I believe that every Committeeman in this room has his mind made up as to which way they are
going to vote on the resolution, and so I would like to move the previous question.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Just a moment now, Charlie. I
appreciate your wanting to act on this thing, but when I recognized you,
Committeeman Ralph Godwin was on the floor. I don’t think he was on the
floor earlier, plus the fact that Committeeman Janko has already been given
the assurance that he will be given an opportunity to amend the resolution.
I think it unfair and a violation of my trust if I would not recognize him.
So can we permit Committeeman Godwin to address the Committee before we
tender the motion?
MR. JACKSON: I will withdraw my motion.
MR. GODWIN, Mississippi: Isn’t it correct that we are merely saying
that this resolution appears to us to be in proper legal form? We have been
so assured by the Judge Advocate, we are not giving our approval to it,
our own individual Departments, every Department in the Legion may change
it when we go home.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, sir.
MR. GODWIN: We cannot bind our Departments by our vote today.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: That is correct. But there are two
different things, Ralph, first, this Committee will take action to go before the
National Convention recommended from this Committee by this Committee.
Now of course there can be dissent from this Committee, and no one is bound
if they voted against it, or voted against the way he wanted to go. But
they will see if he votes for this here, he is saying, I am going along with
this, and I support it, but this doesn’t mean that his Department might not
mandate him to do something different at that Convention.
There is an amendment on the floor at this time, gentlemen. We cannot
even entertain your motion, Charlie, and we can’t entertain Walter’s yet until
we dispose of Committeeman Miller’s amendment.
I will ask Ad Wagner to wind up on that before we vote on that. As
Chairman of the Committee, he has that right under the rules.
COMMITTEE GHAIRMAN WAGNER: I was somewhat concerned,about
the possibility of misinterpretation on both amendments proposed previously
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
149
by Committeeman Drago or Committeeman Miller. The use of the words
“in Viet Nam” and the present amendment really concern me. If you add the
words after “hostilities” in Section 5, Section 1 and Section 2, these words,
“which date shall apply as to the war in Viet Nam,” gentlemen, I don’t see
how you can escape the conclusion that you are talking about the servicemen
in Viet Nam only.
I urge you, as strongly as I am capable of doing so, to defeat this amendment, with all due respects to Committeeman Miller.
As I stated in my report, the language used in this in respect to the date
of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States is exactly the same terminology which was used when we opened
our eligibility to the Korean War veterans during the Korean War, and before
we knew the terminal date, and also World War II.
I would only add this, and I add this without having had the opportunity
to confer with the other members of the Committee, very frankly, I see no
danger and no harm in the language of the resolution as it is proposed. But
if you are determined to amend it, to cover the matters which have been
suggested, then I suggest that you use the words after “hostilities” in all
three places, “such as Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I believe we are ready for the
question.
MR. RYER, Rhode Island: Mr. Commander, may I ask, and I hope this
might solve the problem.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right now, remember the Committeeman has closed debate on it, but we will permit you to ask one question, we will put it that way, and then we will get on with the vote.
MR. RYER: The entire hassle apparently has stemmed from the comments on paragraph three of Section 3 of the report preceding the resolution
which says, “This period of eligibility will terminate when the
United States Government ...” and so forth and so on, the present general
period of and eligibility would remain open. The war in Viet Nam is the occasion for a new period of eligibility, but the new period would not close until
the cessation of hostilities and so forth and so on.
I just wonder if the Chairman of the Committee, and I know how hard they
have worked on this, I just wonder if the Chairman _ of the Committee
would delete this paragraph number three or dress it up in such a manner—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: I am sorry, you are out of order.
The report has been received and filed.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. Chairman—
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you addressing the question
to the Chairman based on his remarks?
Chairman Wagner has closed debate on your amendment. Right? You are
directing a question to him?
MR. MILLER: He made a very pertinent suggestion which as the proposer of the amendment and my seconder Mr. Drago are perfectly willing
to accept. I am very happy to see that you meet us halfway when he suggested that it would be agreeable to them.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you now withdrawing your
amendment and suggesting another?
MR. MILLER: I am going to withdraw the amendment made for the
second time with the permission of my second.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There is now no amendment on
the floor to vote on.
MR. MILLER: Here is the motion I am going to make here, wherever
the word “hostilities” appears in Resolution No. 23, pages 14 and 15, insert
after the word “hostilities”—“such as Viet Nam.”
I am following the Chairman’s suggestion.
150
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: “Such as Viet Nam?”
Is there a second to that motion?
... The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Tom.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: There is an amendment on the
floor that would amend Section 5 on page 14, Section 1 and Section 2 on
15 to add the words after the word “hostilities”—“such as Viet Nam.”
Is there any discussion on that amendment?
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Are we through with debate? I want to
raise a parliamentary question. Are you through with debate?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: No, no, the Committee Chairman
is going to close the debate, since no one wants to speak.
You want to speak on this matter, Harry?
MR. WRIGHT, Mexico: I don’t think semantically that is a correct
statement. I am sure the word “in” is missing there. You can’t say “such
as Viet Nam.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much, very good,
you made your point.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: Thank you, Mr. Commander, this
will be brief, gentlemen.
I just wanted to clarify one point. I think Committeeman Miller inadvertently quoted me as saying that I suggested this. I did not intend to suggest it. I believe my terminology was that if you are determined to make
an amendment along this line, this would be the way I think it could be
done with the least damage.
I still do not feel that this amendment is necessary. I will remind you
that this is the same terminology used when we opened the eligibility on two
previous occasions and again, I would urge that you defeat this amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you ready for the question?
A parliamentary inquiry by the Committeeman from New Jersey.
MR. McKINLEY, New Jersey: Mr. Commander, if we are now ready to
vote, I would like to ask that the vote be taken by a show of hands. There
are far more in this room than there are Executive Committeemen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you very much.
We now vote on the amendment which would add the words “such as
Viet Nam” in the three places previously indicated behind the word “hostilities.”
All in favor of the amendment who are voting members of the Committee
will signify that you are in favor of the amendment by raising your hand.
Will you make a count, Mr. Judge Advocate?
All opposed raise your hands. The amendment is repealed.
Is there anyone who wishes to be recorded?
MR. DRAGO, New York: Yes, I wish to be recorded as voting in favor
of the amendment.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Anyone else?
All right, gentlemen, we are now on the main Resolution No. 23.
The Chair will recognize the Committeeman from Texas who has a proposal.
MR. JANKO, Texas: First, I would like to direct another question to
the Judge Advocate. Mention was made a few minutes ago about should we
adopt this resolution, send it to the National Convention and the Constitution
and By-Laws would take it up there.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: The Convention’s Committee
on Constitutional Amendments.
MR. JANKO: Then the Departments could substitute other, rather adopt
and present other resolutions pertaining to the opening up of new eligibility
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
151
dates. One was made mention of that if it does not enlarge, what does that
mean, does that mean enlargement of the inclusive dates?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE DAVIS: Let me see if I can clarify
your thinking on procedure so that we can answer. Maybe it will obviate
this question. If this body adopts this resolution, it will then be circulated
and go into the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments.
Now, the fact that this body adopts this resolution does not preclude any
Department in The American Legion from adopting a resolution of its own
which is the same, different, many combinations of the resolution which this
body has adopted.
Now the Department resolutions which are adopted will, as this resolution,
be circulated, and they will go into the Committee on Constitutional Amendments of the Convention. It will then be the duty of the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments to decide which resolution it will adopt.
The issue raised earlier as to the enlargement of a constitutional amendment is a statement which involves a statement which is contained in the National Constitution, and while I don’t quote it to you exactly, I will tell you
what I think it means.
If a constitutional amendment is put before the Convention Committee on
Constitutional Amendments, that body may not further amend that constitutional amendment if it will enlarge the constitutional amendment that was
submitted to it. Why? The reason for circulation of the constitutional amendment is so that everybody has notice, consequently if the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments could of its own volition, enlarge constitutional amendments, it has violated the circulation clause notice, see? Does
that answer your question?
MR. JANKO: Very well, thank you, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Will you proceed, Walter?
MR. JANKO: Mr. Commander and members of this National Executive
Committee, the Executive Committee of the Department of Texas met April
3rd, 1966 and adopted a resolution identical to the one that is before you
now with the exception, the beginning date begins with the beginning of
hostilities, or the close of them, rather as defined in our Constitution, of
the Korean Conflict.
In other words, we adopted a resolution to open the ranks of the Legion
from the end of the Korean and up to the present date, to the end of present
day’s hostilities, such as the War in Viet Nam and so forth.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Are you offering an amendment
with this to coincide with your comment, is that the intent?
MR. JANKO: Yes, sir, and this resolution has been forwarded to the
National Adjutant, and I so move you, sir, that we amend the resolution
before us to include “open the ranks of The Legion to the beginning date
of June 25th, 1950.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the motion?
The motion to amend is to substitute “June 5th, 1950” wherever the date
“August 5,1964” appears in the resolution. Is that it, simply stated?
MR. JANKO: Yes.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Is there a second to the proposed
amendment?
There being no second, the amendment dies for lack of it.
We are now on the floor on Resolution 23.
Are you ready to vote on Resolution 23, gentlemen?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN WAGNER: If I may make one remark.
I was asked to make this remark by Past National Commander Milo Warner and with your permission, Mr. Commander and members of this Executive
Committee, Past National Commander Warner was very hopeful, that this
matter would come up yesterday when he could be here. He had to leave early
152
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
this morning, and he asked me if I would make it a matter of record, that
he desired to second the motion for the adoption of this resolution. His
reason for it as stated to me was that when discussion was had and this
body considered opening the eligibility to members serving in World War
II, members of the Armed Forces serving in World War II, he was one of
the first to speak in opposition to that.
He said that he wanted to clear himself of that error of judgment. If he
had been here, he said that he would advise you that he was “eating crow”
because he realizes that the action then taken and subsequently taken has
added to the building of the cathedral which is The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Thank you, Ad.
May I say this, that the record will show that this motion was seconded
by Fast National Commander Milo Warner and by every member of this
Committee who votes in favor of it.
Are you ready to vote?
. . . The question was called.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Those in favor of Resolution 23
signify by saying aye; those opposed no.
The ayes have it and it is adopted.
MR. JANKO: May the record show that I voted in opposition to it?
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: All right, gentlemen, you have
taken a momentous step. I want to thank you for your patience.
We have some other business, one a very important matter now before we
*0 the Rehabilitation and Finance reports, and I call on Committeeman
McKinley from New Jersey.
Let’s keep order, please, gentlemen.
TRIBUTE TO E. MEADE WILSON, FLORIDA
,
MR McKINLEY New Jersey: Gentlemen, what I now have to say may
be a bit of pleasant interlude between the very spirited discussion. Believe
me 1 watched you sit here today, and it was such a healthy discussion on the
part of this Executive Committee with such participation and debate on a certain question, that I kept my mouth shut.
is perunentt0
y U JUSt a little piece of
°
Poetry- It isn’t complete, but it
If with pleasure you are viewing
Any work a man is doing
If you like and love him
tell him now.
Do not wait till life is over
and he is underneath the clover;
For he cannot read his tombstone
when he is deceased.
I address that little thing, that parlance to the fact, and fortunatelv before it is too late, that our good friend Meade Wilson is substantially serving his last session on this Executive Committee after 20 years of service He
is leaving this Executive Committee, I know very much against his will and I
am led to believe that the boys in Florida don’t like his* departing from the
scene either because many of them have spoken. But he is doing it because
his doctors told him that it is wise for him to do this, curtail many of his
activities so that he may enjoy a little additional span of life, and he is
wisely obeying that admonition.
’
So, gentlemen, I say I would like to just review briefly Meade’s experiences
on this Executive Committee, and possibly the excuse for my opening this
is because R was his misfortune, upon coming upon this Executive Committee
that his first assignment was to fall under my evil influence as a member
of the, my Committee at that time, the Resolutions Committee.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
153
Meade served on that Committee very faithfully. He fumbled and he stumbled a little bit, hut he was very attentive to the duties of that, and I assumed some other responsibilities back in ’46 and ’47, namely the reorganization of our Commissions, and it was necessary for me to find a Chairman
or a Vice Chairman, and I asked Meade if he wouldn’t pick up the load and
he did. He carried on magnificently. Over these last 20 years or so, Meade
has been a very active member of this Committee. He has a charming personality which intrigues me. He has a wealth, or he did have a wealth of
cheerful energy and forceful energy. He was a gracious friend and a gracious
host with ability to give attention to almost anything without indicating any
annoyance or dissatisfaction.
In all of his operations on this Committee, he has endeavored to further
the interests and the best interests and the purposes of our organization in
cooperation with his colleagues, and I know that in many instances he has
intervened between some of our colleagues who weren’t just looking eye to
eye, and in his magnanimous way persuaded them to be friendly rather than
enemies. That is really worth while, very much worth while.
There is one sidelight comment that I make in this connection, the famous
subject of mine, maybe I am making a speech to myself to some extent, it is
unfortunate that some of our Departments have written into their Constitutions or into their methods of relieving Executive Committeemen every two
years. It takes four to six years to really grasp the import of much of the
business of this Executive Committee. Some Departments are denying to
themselves the benefit of long service such as Meade has performed and withholding from us the benefit of a trained member of our Executive Committee.
The younger members of the Committee will understand the significance
of what I am saying.
Meade at the present time is serving as Chairman of the Liaison Committee of Education, and he has been very active, and contributed substantially to their affairs, and I am sure they can attest to that. Meade, it is with
sincere regret, so far as I am concerned, I am sorry to see you leave our
midst. We can only hope that in the fortune of things, have you talked to
Tom Miller and the Committee on cakes and cookies? Maybe they will find a
cookie so that you can come back and join us.
MR. MILLER, Nevada: Mr. National Commander, members of the Committee, I feel certain that the remarks I am about to make now will be
received with more approval than the ones I made from the rostrum a
moment ago.
My associate and colleague Bill McKinley has said that it was in 1946
that Meade Wilson and myself came onto the National Executive Committee,
and we have been serving together for over 20 years. In his Department he
came up the hard way, Post, District and Department offices of every caliber, and when he was the Department Commander for it in 1945, he saw to
it that the Legislature of the State of Florida passed the Florida State Veterans Commissioner Law, and he was able to have the Governor appoint six
of the seven members who were outstanding Legionnaires.
You have already heard what Bill has said about his splendid service.
He was the originator, if I am correct, of putting the Committee on Resolutions of the National Executive Committee on a firm basis so that our mandates would be properly prepared and considered by this Committee. He
well trained his successor here, Roy Stone from South Carolina, and if for
no other reason, we want to be thankful, Meade, that you left such a good
understudy as Roy has been since you went off that Committee.
Having served on the Committee on Committees as McKinley says, for
the last few years, I was well aware of the fact that we have various Committeemen who do not know quite how to operate, and needed a little bit of
assistance on the side, but not so for Meade Wilson. He always appeared
before our Committee on Committees with his lists neatly printed and the
history of the nominees properly outlined. Our only question was where the
Department of Florida got enough stationery to carry out all the multi-
154
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
tudinous recommendations that he was making, because he didn’t miss a single bet to put up somebody from Florida for any one of those Committees,
and in that, I think you have the record here in the National Executive Committee meeting.
Also at this time that he was serving The American Legion in the capacity
that we have very meagerly outlined to you, he was a very busy and successful businessman. He was Chairman of the Assistant to the Vice President of
the International Metals and Chemical Corporation, which is, if you do not
know, has its direct roots right out there in Wall Street.
I won’t go into the details of how Wall Street at times tried to bend
his arm when it came to the Legion actions here, but both for the League
°f National Commanders and other matters, because that is a secret
that only Meade and a few of us know about. So for the record, I won’t put
that in, Meade.
He also went back to Mulberry, Florida which is his home, and has been
a very successful and active businessman there, having been officially retired
for ten years. And I commend you, Meade, that you not only attend to your
personal business there, but keep your activities in the various fields of civic
community welfare that you have so ably handled over these years.
Sitting on the floor of Congress in 1951 when Douglas McArthur addressed that body, he said, “Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.”
Well, I know Meade is not going to fade away, because we want him here
with us right along for many a year to come. Thank you.
MR, GODWIN, Mississippi:
Mr. Commander and my colleagues, the
hour is very late, just as late for us as it is for anyone. Meade Wilson, our
friend, has to catch a train in about 45 minutes, but this man has given 20
years of his life in one position in The American Legion, and he is going
to get an extra five minutes of my time if I am the only man listening to it.
I know you love him as I do. I want to tell you just what I think about
him.
What an accomplishment to look back upon, one so many of us will never,
you and I here will never achieve, 20 years of dedicated service to The
American Legion as National Executive Committeeman from the same Department.
It is with a feeling of sadness and regret, my colleagues, that I realize
the inexorable passage of time that has brought us to the moment of the
last meeting in National Headquarters in which Meade Wilson and you and
I will be associated together in our respective capacities as National Executive Committeemen.
One of my greatest privileges and pleasures has been that of knowing
him and learning, I hope, from his great wisdom and his experiences, and
having the advantage of bis long association in this organization that we all
love, The American Legion.
Eleven years ago I was a freshman on the NEC. I was doubtful of the
right way to proceed. I was unfamiliar with the operations of this great
group, but I too had a desire to serve, and I found a man who, being a fellow
Southerner, as I was, who being a fellow alumnus of a great university in
the South as I was, but most of all a colleague with a similar desire to
serve The American Legion as I did, he volunteered his assistance to me,
his counsel and his understanding, and I know he has made me a better
Legionnaire and a better member of this Committee. And through these
past eleven years, we have been close friends.
But this experience of mine is not unusual or uncommon. Many NEC men
through the years, many of you here present, have a similar situation, you
too have benefited by his great Legionnaire’s counsel, advice and friendship.
,, As the prime organizer and the only Chairman we have ever had in
the Southern Caucus, Meade Wilson has been a great instrument of merit
in welding the so-called “Southern Bloc” into an entity of this national organization. It has grown greatly in size and influence, so great that now
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
155
not only the near and deep Southern states in it, but everyone that we see
fit to allow to come in is applying for membership. There too he will be
missed, but he will never be forgotten.
Now as the Sage of Mulberry puts away his red cap and turns his Legion endeavors into fields less exacting on account of his health and strength,
I want to say to this Committee publicly and to him, “May God bless you,
Uncle Meade, and give you many more years of health, happiness and service to The American Legion.”
You carry with you the respect, the admiration of your colleagues, the
National Executive Committee will miss you, but it will never forget you.
All your friends will miss you, but they will never forget you. And as a
little personal thing, may I tell you that 27,000 Legionnaires in Mississippi,
many of whom know you will miss you. But they will never forget you.
So I say, on behalf of many of your friends, thanks, Uncle Meade, for a
job well done. We will be seeing you around from time to time, and we will
also be working together for the good of The American Legion.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Past National Commander Dan
Foley.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER FOLEY: Mr. Commander, my colleagues of the National Executive Committee, I am happy to be given the
opportunity to say a word or two at this time. There is no particular way
that one says goodbye to an old friend. There is no phrase perhaps or group
of phrases that could fully express our feelings as we say goodbye to Uncle
Meade as all of us know him so well refer to him.
I think Bill McKinley made his remarks, and he talked about Uncle Meade
when he first came on stumbling a little bit here and there until Bill
explained to him procedures and ways of this National Executive Committee.
Well, I suppose in my own way, I was one of those younger members of the
Committee that stumbled and tripped and fell along the way, but somewhere
along the line, I came under the guidance and tutelage and the inspiration
of Meade Wilson, and found him over the years to not only be a good leader
of the Legion, very valued counselor, but I found him more importantly to
be a good friend.
I know that everyone here who knows and has worked with Meade have
their own feelings and affection for him, and in their own way, will have
their many reminiscences of this great acquaintance. But, Uncle Meade,
I say to you as I would say to any good and trusted friend, as I say goodbye to them, what the Irishman says in a toast that means so much to him
and the person to whom he extends it, and in this way express to you in
those words my feeling for you:
May the roads always rise with you, may the wind be ever at your back,
and may the Lord forever hold you in the hollow of His hand.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is late. There
is much I would like to say.
You want to take the floor, Mr. Chairman? You have a resolution?
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I want to thank these men
personally here who have participated in the memorial to Meade—memorial
to the services that he has given.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: His services will never die.
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: Mr. Chairman, Mr. Commander, due to the lack of time and for the fact that I am a little bit emotional
at this moment, I would like to say that a special committee be appointed to
formulate a resolution in order, outlining the services of this fine Legionnaire for the 20 years’ service that he has given, and that the resolution be
framed or embossed and be presented to him at the next NEC meeting. I so
move.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Committee has already been
appointed constituting those who have spoken, with you as the Chairman.
156
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Gentlemen, the hour is late. I would only like to say this to you, Uncle
Meade, having shown I believe my well concealed patience and restraint, I
left myself no time to comment at this hour, except it appears to me that
the highest aspiration that one might have in view of this testimonial to you
is to return for office of Past National Committeeman.
Past National Committeeman, we thank you so much. There is so much
we would like to say, thank you.
. . . The NEC stood and applauded as National Executive Committeeman
E. Meade Wilson left the room.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the hour is late. You
have been very patient, and two Committee Chairmen have been most patient.
We will now hear from the Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission,
Bob McCurdy, for his report. Boh?
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following
report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN McCURDY: Mr. Commander and comrades,
nothing has made me happier than to have my time taken for the purpose
for which it was taken. I have been privileged to know Meade for the full
20 years that he was here, and to serve with him, and I want to second
the motion of everything that has been said and done on his behalf.
Now I know the hour is late, and many of you have transportation problems.
On April 15th we mailed you the advance report which I am sure you
all read and studied.
Today, we have circulated another seven-page report that explains in
detail the actions of the Committee at this meeting.
We have three resolutions that will follow my report here and so, without taking any more of your time at all, unless you have questions, I wish
to thank the Commander for his fine help. I wish to thank Blackie and
Paul and Bill Hauck for their great assistance during the year, and especially
John Corcoran of the Rehabilitation staff for a job well done. Thank you,
Mr. Commander.
. . . The Advance Report is as follows:
ADVANCE REPORT OF
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
to the
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
by
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
The following report covers the activities of the National Rehabilitation
Commission from October 7, 1965 to April 15, 1966.
I. MEETINGS OF THE NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
The National Rehabilitation Commission has held two meetings since the
National Executive Committee last met. Both sessions were held in the Statler
Hilton Hotel, Washington, D. C., in connection with the 43rd Annual National Rehabilitation Conference, and as part of the Sixth Annual Washington Conference. The first session was held Monday, February 28, 1966 and
the second Friday, March 4, 1966.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
157
Actions on matters considered during these meetings, together with an
outline of the various reports received by the Commission, are noted as follows.
a. Resolutions and Register matters referred to the Committee.
The following resolutions, with accompanying staff studies, were presented
to the Commission for consideration and action. A short digest of the resolution and action taken by the Commission are shown after each resolution.
1) Resolutions referred by the 1964 National Convention
Resolution No. 33 (Kentucky)—urges The American Legion to sponsor and
support legislation to be known as the Prisoner of War Disability Compensation Act. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 545 (Texas)—urges support of HR 174, a bill to provide
that all diagnosed diseases and disabilities of World War II and the Korean
War be considered as service-connected. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 602 (Virginia)—urges the VA to provide adequate facilities
and staff at the VA hospital, Kecoughtan, Virginia, for conducting examinations and providing out-patient treatment. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 606 (Virginia)—urges return to the Roanoke Regional Office of those VR&E activities previously transferred to the jurisdiction of
the Veterans Benefits Office, Washington, D. C. No action taken (accomplished).
2) Resolution referred by the 1965 National Convention
Resolution No. 256 (Maine)—urges that steps be taken to obtain a revision of law to provide that the additional amount of annuity payable under the Railroad Retirement Act, by the inclusion of the family group, be
excluded from determinations of annual income, similar to the provisions
of the VA regulation which permits exclusion of the additional amount of Social Security benefits payable for dependents in the family group. Deferred
(for further study).
Resolution No. 427 (Texas)—urges support of HR 7571, a bill to prevent
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs or other officer, employee, department
or agency, from establishing an indebtedness against gratuitous benefits to
liquidate indebtedness in connection with a loan default. Deferred (for further
study).
Resolution No. 512 (Virginia)—urges that the privilege of an appeal be
afforded all veterans who have been denied insurance under PL 88-664. Deferred (for further study).
Resolution No. 513 (Virginia)—urges that medical examination units in
VA hospitals be placed under the supervision and control of regional office
managers. Rejected.
Resolution No. 533 (Oklahoma)—urges VA to send a letter with VA Form
21-6799 explaining how a spouse’s income affects a veteran s pension. No
action taken (accomplished).
Resolution No. 565 (Puerto Rico)—urges amendment of law to provide
that veterans age 72, and over, who are receiving disability pension benefits,
not be required to file annual income questionnaires. Rejected.
3) Pending Register matters
Register No. 1192 (Pennsylvania)—urges that a statutory award be provided Under 38 USC(k) or (p) for loss or loss of use of a lung. Rejected.
b. Commission Initiated Resolutions
At its meeting of March 4, 1966, the following resolutions emanating from
the Commission were approved. All will be handled administratively.
1) That the Rehabilitation staff offer its services to the Economic Commission staff in handling appeal cases on loan guaranty matters, if the Economic Commission so desires.
158
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
2) That the Department of Defense arrange for a traveling board for
Correction of Records and Discharge Review cases, in order that more veterans may have the opportunity to make personal appearances before the
boards.
3) That the Rehabilitation staff secure and send to Department Service
Officers slip laws on newly enacted legislation.
4) That the Rehabilitation Commission contact all Departments, before
their respective budgets are formulated, to request support of Area Rehabilitation Conferences by appropriating sufficient funds to enable their respective
Rehabilitation Commission member (or members) and their Department
Service Officer, as a minimum, and such others as they can afford, to attend
the Area Conferences.
c. Report of The Subcommittee on Certificate of Appreciation
W. Bea Waldrip, Michigan, Chairman of the Commission’s Subcommittee
on Certificates of Appreciation, reported that 30 recommendations had been
referred to the Subcommittee for consideration. All were recommended for
approval.
The Commission approved the Subcommittee report. Accordingly, Certificates have been prepared and distributed to the following individuals:
ALABAMA
Dr. Wesley C. Corson, Chief of Staff, VA Hospital,
Montgomery
Dr. Joseph J. Mack, Medical Rating Specialist, RegionARKANSAS
al Office, Little Rock
ILLINOIS
James R. Richey, Assistant for Education, Regional
Office, Chicago
INDIANA
Arthur W. Hendricks, Assistant Adjudication Officer,
Regional Office, Indianapolis
Wilbur W. Jones, Chief Contact Representative, Regional Office, Indianapolis
KENTUCKY
Emerson O. Mann, Management Analyst, Regional Office, Louisville
J. Regan O’Connor Loan Guaranty Officer, Regional Office, Louisville
MAINE
Solomon Crasnick, Chief, Adjudication Division, VA
Center, Togus
MICHIGAN
Michael E. Goetz, Loan Guaranty Officer, Regional
Office, Detroit
NEBRASKA
Dr. Charles W. Way, Chief, Outpatient Clinic, VA Hospital, Omaha
NEW MEXICO
James M. Keating, Chairman, Rating Board, Regional
Office, Albuquerque
Robert J. Shepard, Contact Officer, VA Hospital, Albuquerque
NEW YORK
Lertie M. Hylton, Adjudication Officer, Regional Office, New York
Leo V. Lanning, Manager, Regional Office, Buffalo
Leo J. Ross, Chief Attorney, Regional Office, New York
NORTH CAROLINA J. D. DeRamus, Manager, Regional Office, WinstonSalem
A. H. Dalton, Adjudication Officer, Regional Office,
OKLAHOMA
Muskogee
Menter G. Baker, Manager, Regional Office, Muskogee
PENNSYLVANIA
Howard J. Corcoran, Registrar, VA Hospital, Philadelphia
SOUTH CAROLINA Dr. Henry J. Bayon, Chief of Staff and Examining
Physician, Outpatient Clinic, Columbia
James W. Storey, Medical Technician, VA Hospital,
Columbia
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WISCONSIN
VA CENTRAL
OFFICE
159
Dr. A. Ray Dawson, Chief of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation, VA Hospital, Richmond
Dr. Norbert Trauba, Director, VA Hospital, Spokane
John P. Cullen, Manager, Regional Office, Milwaukee
Oliver L. Clay, Insurance Counsel
Mrs. Helen S. Cone, Legal Assistant, Insurance Service
Timothy F. Daley, Assistant General Counsel
Willard E. LaRosa, Claim Examiner, Insurance
Samuel Rose, Chief of Central Office Contact Division
d. Report of Joint Rehabilitation-Economic Subcommittee on Problems
of the Aged and Aging
The joint Rehabilitation-Economic Subcommittee on Problems of the Aged
and Aging met February 28, 1966. Subcommittee Chairman Milton S. Applebaum delivered the Report to the National Rehabilitation Commission:
“Discussion was had on Medicare, the nursing care program, nursing home
facilities, and general topics relating to new legislation on the older American.
“The Older Americans Act of 1965, PL 89-73, was discussed with interest,
but the newness of the Act prevented any further consideration. Edward McGrail of the national staff stated that his investigation showed no conflict
between the programs of the Administration on Aging and any existing program of the Veterans Administration.
“Considerable time was spent on 1965 Convention Resolution No. 231 asking that discrimination in employment of the older worker be made an unlawful employment practice under federal law. It was voted _ to recommend
approval of the resolution, with the proviso that such discrimination be condemned only when applicant is under 65 or otherwise qualified for such employment.”
e. Report of Conference Committee on Recommendations
Constituted as a Subcommittee of the Commission, the 1965 Rehabilitation
Conference Committee on Recommendations consisted of: Joseph B. Halloway,
Virginia, Chairman; Thomas W. Byers, Connecticut; Carle B. Lenker,
South Dakota; J. Earl Merifield, California; and Joe F. Hudgens, Tennessee. Chairman Halloway delivered the report which included four recommendations, all of which enamated from the conferees. Three were recommended
for approval and one was tabled. The recommendations and actions taken on
each were reported in Rehabilitation Bulletin 13-66 dated March 29, 1966.
The approved recommendations will be handled administratively.
f. Miscellaneous Reports Received by the Commission
1) Discussion on Certain Topics Relating to the VA Hospital Program
John J. Corcoran, Director, National Rehabilitation Commission, invited
attention to certain existing problems relating to the administration and operation of the VA hospital program. A primary cause of some problems, Mr.
Corcoran told the Commission, is the VA’s inability to meet the budgetary
needs of its hospitals. As an illustration, he cited the case wherein the Accreditation Committee of the American Medical Association was forced to cancel the accreditation for the Department of Radiology in a particular VA
hospital because the equipment was obsolete and the staff was inadequate.
Also, in certain cases, limitations on budgetary allowances to certain hospitals affiliated with medical schools is causing a breach in the relationship
between the VA hospital and the medical school and is jeopardizing the affiliation. The steadily rising cost of medical care and equipment, Mr. Corcoran advised, is a factor in the creation of these problems.
Other topics discussed related to the problem faced by the VA in competing for medical personnel with private and other sources (especially m
those medical fields where there is a scarcity of specialists), and the need
for updating the VA’s domiciliary and restoration center programs.
In summarizing, Mr. Corcoran stated that the Legion should concern itself with these problems, as they reflect the challenges we face in our en-
160
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
deavor to see that veterans continue to be provided high quality medical
care.
2) Discussion on Printing the Commission’s Annual Report in Advance
of Government Printing
Mr. Corcoran advised that the annual report of the Rehabilitation Commission to our National Convention, though prepared in July, is not printed
by the Government Printing Office until May of the following year. For
instance, the report prepared in July 1965 will not be printed and distributed
until May 1966.
Pointing out that much informative data relating to the veterans affairs
program and the Commission’s activities is carried in the reports, he requested
an expression from the members to a suggestion that the Commission have
a printing made at its own expense, so that timely distribution can be
made.
The estimated cost of 500 copies of the complete report, for distribution to
key Legion officials, would be $1370. The estimated cost of 5000 “flyers”,
containing only a condensed version of the report, for distribution to delegates
to the National Convention, would be $173.
A motion by National Executive Committeeman Joe Leonard to have 500
copies of the complete report printed, as well as a sufficient number of flyers
for distribution to the National Convention delegates, was approved.
3) Report on Disposition of Closed VA Hospital Facilities
A report was given the Commission on disposition of seven of the hospital
and domiciliary facilities closed by the Veterans Administration.
The VA hospital, Sunmount, New York, was transferred to the State of
New York, and has been converted to a hospital for mentally retarded children.
The VA hospital, Dwight, Illinois, was transferred to the State of Illinois, and has become a hospital for retarded children.
The VA hospital, Fort Bayard, New Mexico, was transferred to the State
of New Mexico, and is a state hospital for mental and geriatric patients.
The VA hospital, Brecksville, Ohio, was acquired by the State of Ohio
and is currently used as a hospital for mentally ill and retarded persons.
The VA hospital, McKinney, Texas, was transferred by the General Services administration to the Office of Economic Opportunity and is currently
being used as a Job Corps Center.
The VA domiciliary, Clinton, Iowa, has not as yet been transferred
from the VA but it is expected that the General Services Administration will
assign it to the Office of Economic Opportunity.
The VA domiciliary, Thomasville, Georgia, is to be transferred to the
State of Georgia as soon as negotiations between the State and Federal Government are completed.
4) Report on S 9 (PL 89-358), the recently enacted Veterans Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966
Mr. Corcoran reported on the status of S 9, which had not at that time been
signed by the President. After outlining the provisions in the Act, he commented that, though it did not provide a full spectrum of wartime benefits
for Viet Nam era veterans, and though the Legion was dissatisfied with the
rates of allowances provided in the educational feature of the Act, we wholeheartedly endorsed its enactment.
Aside from the benefits provided, it satisfies a major policy position of
the Legion, namely, that the VA maintain sole responsibility for administration of this program. The Bureau of the Budget had introduced a proposal
(HR 11985) which, if enacted, would have divided responsibility for the administration of the educational program between the VA and the Department
of Health, Education and Welfare. Mr. Corcoran commended the House Committee on Veterans Affairs and the Senate Labor and Public Welfare
Committee for retaining the integrity of the Veterans Administration.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5± 1966
161
5) Discussion on National Service Trophy Award
The Commission was advised that as a result of action taken by the National Executive Committee at its Spring 1965 meeting, Chairman McCurdy
had received a request from the National Trophies and Awards Committee
for a recommendation as to whether the Award(s) made by the National
Rehabilitation Commission should be continued.
The only award given by the Commission is the National Service Trophy.
After discussing the matter and concluding the award of the Trophy had
not been as effective as desired, the Commission felt that a revision of the
governing rules might stimulate competition and encourage more Departments
to increase their rehabilitation services.
Accordingly, the Commission authorized Chairman Bob McCurdy to appoint a Committee to study the history of the National Service Trophy, and
the governing rules, and to report back to the Commission with recommendations for changes in the rules.
Chairman McCurdy appointed the following as members of the Committee.
Emory L. O’Connell, Colorado, Chairman; John Walsh, Massachusetts, and
Joe Hudgens, Tennessee.
II. CONFERENCES
a. Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
More than 500 persons, representing every state in the nation, attended
The American Legion’s 43rd Annual National Rehabilitation Conference,
March 1-4, in Washington, D. C.
Among those participating were members of the Rehabilitation Commission, department service officers, department rehabilitation committeemen,
county and post service officers, volunteer hospital workers, members ol the
Auxiliary, and other national, department, and post officials interested in
The American Legion’s rehabilitation program.
National Rehabilitation Chairman Robert M. McCurdy and Vice Chairman Emory L. O’Connell presided over the meetings of conferees and top
officials of the Veterans Administration; the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare; and the Department of Defense. This year, the .panel
discussions were exceptionally well attended, indicating the intense desire on
the part of our service officers and government agency representatives to
exchange ideas and seek answers to the problems encountered m the care
and benefits programs for veterans and their dependents.
National Commander L. Eldon James keynoted this intensity of purpose
at the time of his appearance before the House Veterans Affairs Committee.
Accompanied by many of the conferees, the Commander pointed to the Eegion s
long history of service to veterans and stressed the need for further legislative action in the fields of compensation, pension, and medical care, he
noted that of major importance at present is recognition of the need lor
wartime benefits for veterans of the Viet Nam era.
Major panel discussions during the Rehabilitation Conference covered: VA
medical and hospital practices and policies; Veterans benefits compensation, pension, loan guaranty, vocational rehabilitation and education; VA
insurance; VA’s Board of Veterans Appeals; and Department of Defense review of discharges and correction of military records.
William J. Driver, Administrator of Veterans Affairs, reporting on VA
activities, said, “In the area of medicine, in 1967 we have for the fifth year
asked for something in excess of a billion dollars. One and a quarter billion
dollars today goes to operate the VA medical system, the 165 hospitals we
have.”
Regarding the VA nursing care program, he advised that the 1967 budget
provides for bringing into the VA system by June 30, 1967, all 4,000 nursing
care beds now authorized by law. It is expected that the number of these beds
will average 3,000 during the new fiscal year.
Community and state nursing facilities for VA patients will operate at
increased levels in the new year, bringing the average daily patient load up to
162
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
3,487. To date, the VA has approved about 2,000 beds in state nursing facilities, and 900 of these beds were occupied by veterans at the end of 1965.
Other VA representatives appearing before the Conference included Dr.
H. Martin Engle, Chief Medical Director; A. W. Stratton, Chief Benefits
Director; Philip J. Budd, Chief Data Management Director; and, James W.
Stancil, Chairman, Board of Veterans Appeals.
Representing the Department of Defense were Col. H. G. MacDaniel, Deputy Director, Secretary of the Air Force Personnel Council; and the executive secretaries of the boards for correction of records for the Army, Navy,
and Air Force.
Alvin M. David, Assistant Commissioner for Program Evaluation and
Planning, Social Security Administration, Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare, spoke to the conferees on various aspects of the recently enacted Medicare program.
B. Area Rehabilitation Conferences
Area C held its Rehabilitation Conference December 12-14, 1965, in Nashville, Tenn. John Corcoran and C. E. Mattingly represented the staff at this
meeting.
No other Area Conferences were held.
.. . The report of the Rehabilitation Commission is as follows:
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION REPORT
To The
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA
May 4-5, 1966
Robert M. McCurdy, California, Chairman
A Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation
Commission met in National Headquarters, Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 2
and 3, 1966, to consider matters referred for study and action as well as current problems and topics pertinent to the Rehabilitation program of The
American Legion. The Subcommittee was composed of the following Commission members:
Robert M. McCurdy (California), Chairman
Emory L. O’Connell (Colorado), Vice Chairman
Arthur W. Price (New York)
Joseph B. Halloway (Virginia)
Harvey V. Higley (Wisconsin), Consultant
Also present was Joseph G. Leonard (Connecticut), Chairman of the National Executive Committee Rehabilitation Commission Liaison Committee.
Present during the discussions and deliberations of the Committee was Frank
Bottigliero, Director of Rehabilitation, Department of Illinois. Staff members present were John J. Corcoran, Director, and Assistant Director for
Claims, Edward H. Golembieski.
In outline from, the following actions were taken by the Subcommittee
during the meeting:
I. RESOLUTIONS TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Resolution No. 35-—Legislation to amend 38 USC 641 to increase the per
diem payment to States for hospital care of war veterans. (Origin: Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
Resolution No. 36—Eligibility of retired military personnel for treatment
in Veterans’ Administration hospitals. (Origin: Subcommittee of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
163
Resolution No. 37—Sponsor and support legislation to provide nursing
home care for veterans living in Alaska and Hawaii. (Origin: Subcommittee
of the Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission)
II. ACTIONS ON REGISTER MATTERS
Register 1230 (New York)—Urges support of HR 424, a bill to provide
a deduction for income tax purposes, in the case of a disabled individual, for
expenses for transportation to and from work; and to provide an additional
exemption for income tax purposes for a taxpayer or spouse who is disabled.
Rejected.
Register 1241 (Pennsylvania)—Seeks legislation to liberalize the two
year continuous operation requirement of certain schools in the education and
training of veterans. Rejected.
Register 1245 (Pennsylvania)—Urges legislation to amend the pension
provisions of title 38, United States Code, to exclude all income from determinations of entitlement to pension. Rejected. The purpose of the resolution
is in conflict with the policy established by past National Conventions that
entitlement to pension be determined by a needs test. Resolution No. 159 of
the 1965 National Convention established the current pension legislative objectives.
Register 1246 (Pennsylvania)—Urges The American Legion to approve a
National Bonus for all honorably discharged World War II and Korean War
veterans, their widows, or children. Rejected.
III. ACTIONS ON REFERRED 1964 CONVENTION RESOLUTIONS
Resolution No. 602 (Virginia)—Requests the Veterans Administration to
enlarge the staff and expand the facilities at the Kecoughtan, Virginia, hospital for outpatient treatment and examination purposes. Tabled for the reason that reports from the VA Chief Medical Director indicate that specific
action is being taken to expand the outpatient facilities as part of the plan
to modernize the Kecoughtan VA Center.
IV. ACTIONS ON REFERRED 1965 CONVENTION RESOLUTIONS
Resolution No. 427 (Texas)—Urges support of HR 7571, a bill to prevent
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs or other officer, employee, department
or agency, from withholding benefit payments, without written consent, from
an individual because of an indebtedness arising out of the default of a Veterans Administration loan guaranty. Accomplished. The provisions of this bill
have been embodied in 38 USC, Chapter 37, as amended by PL89-358.
Resolution No. 512 (Virginia)—Urges that the right of appeal be afforded veterans who have been denied a contract of insurance under the limited insurance reopening provisions of PL 88-664. Rejected. (Staff experience indicates that the soundest and most constructive approach to the purpose of this resolution is to continue to submit these denials of contract for
consideration by the Office of the Director of the VA Insurance Service.)
MATTERS RECEIVED, CONSIDERED, AND
ACTED UPON BY THE COMMISSION
During its meeting, Past National Commander George N. Craig appeared
and asked the Subcommittee to consider the advisability of re-establishing the
Medical Advisory Board. In connection with his request, the Subcommittee
took cognizance of the Chairman’s existing authority to convene a board whenever the necessity arises. Because of this continuing authority given the
Chairman, the Subcommittee believes that the existing arrangement is satisfactory.
In addition, the Subcommittee received the remarks of F. Gordon Wright,
Legislative Chairman, USA National Council, Royal Canadian Legion, suggesting that The American Legion support legislation to establish a program
of reciprocal benefits for Canadian veterans now residing in the United
States. In reply, the Subcommittee advised Mr. Wright that they would study
164
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
and consider the suggestions of the Royal Canadian Legion and advise him
later of their decision.
The Subcommittee considered the effects of Public Law 89-332, an Act
which provides for the right of persons to be represented in matters before
Federal Agencies. Of concern to the Subcommittee were those instances in
which The American Legion was designated as the representative on VA
Form 23-22 and, later, the claimant designates an attorney to represent him
in a specific claim or action with the Veterans Administration. With respect to these cases, the Subcommittee approved the policy that the Staff of
the Rehabilitation Commission would not retain the Power of Attorney.
Veterans Administration Department of Medicine and Surgery standards
of care and adequacy of facilities and staff in medical school and university affiliated and nonaffiliated hospitals were reviewed and discussed by
the Subcommittee. The Subcommittee concluded that the Commission should
continue to keep the VA hospital system and facilities under continued surveillance and study to assure that there is no let-down in the Veterans Administration staffing, equipment, education, and planning to maintain the
present high standards of medical and hospital care of veterans.
In connection with the planning for observance of The American Legion’s 50th Anniversary, the Subcommittee discussed the part that the Rehabilitation Commission could play to assure that the observance was a
success in terms of its program. To obtain the views or suggestions of the
full Commission, each member will be advised on the purpose of the 50th
Anniversary celebration and asked to suggest a plan or program which
would effectively portray the program of Rehabilitation as carried out since
our founding.
Some discussion was given by the Subcommittee to the purpose of the
Community Hospital Industrial Rehabilitation Program (CHIRP) and the
effect on individual rehabilitation motivation of counting income derived from
this program as income for pension purposes. Being aware of the consideration
being given by the VA Department of Veterans Benefits and Department of
Medicine and Surgery to determine if counting such income is destructive to
motivation, the Subcommittee suggested that this program be kept under
study until such time as the VA has made its determination.
The Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission reported on Staff
activities in connection with S 2748, a bill to assure adequate and complete
medical care for veterans by the VA in medical community planning and for
the sharing of advanced medical technology and equipment between the Veterans Administration and other public and private hospitals. Director Corcoran had testified on the bill on March 25, 1966 before the Senate Subcommittee on Veterans Affairs pointing out at that time that the language
was broad enough to legalize the cross servicing arrangement which we so
vigorously opposed early in 1965. Corcoran urged the Senate Subcommittee
not to act favorably on S 2748 until adequate safeguards are established to
assure that the Veterans Administration hospital system will be maintained
primarily for veterans. The Subcommittee approved of the actions taken by the
Staff feeling that the Commission should view the present language of the
bill with reservation. It was also agreed that existing policy and resolutions
granted sufficient authority to oppose enactment of this legislation should
the language of the bill not be changed to meet the objections of the Commission.
The Subcommittee discussed the purpose of HR 13642. This bill would
amend the savings provisions of old law pension cases to provide that annuities and pensions payable under the Railroad Retirement Act would count
as income in determinations of continued entitlement to death and disability
pension. According to VA estimates, this change would affect 8500 cases
with a first year’s savings of $8 million. Because the bill would effect a
substantial reduction in benefits to a group of aged veterans, the Subcommittee expressed disapproval of the purpose of this bill.
Also, the Subcommittee was concerned with the purpose of HR 13643,
a bill to amend the burial provisions of title 38, United States Code, to provide that the maximum burial allowance payable shall be the difference be-
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
165
tween $250 and any amount payable under the Social Security Act, or any
other Act providing for the payment of expenses of funeral, transportation,
and interment. In view of the fact that The American Legion is supporting
enactment of legislation to increase the burial allowance, payable by the Veterans Administration, and in view of the fact that burial and funeral costs
are escalating, the Subcommittee recommended that the passage of this legislation should be opposed.
A report was given the Subcommittee by the Director of the National
Rehabilitation Commission on the study urged by Resolution 36 of the May
1963 meeting of repatriated prisoners of war and of the progress reported by
the Veterans Administration in selecting numbers and categories of cases
for study and control and of the status of the questionnaire to be sent selected
repatriated prisoners of war (Europe, Japan, and Korean) to obtain, current
information on their post repatriation adjustment. Referred Resolutions No.
33 and 545 of the 1964 National Convention, both directed to the problems
of repatriated prisoners of war, are retained in a referred status pending
completion of this study.
Because of a request from the Department of Tennessee and others, the
National Rehabilitation Commission re-examined its policy (approved by the
Executive Section of the National Rehabilitation Commission in 1960 at Miami Beach, Florida) that the Staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission
not afford representation in cases in which the veteran did not have some
wartime service. In view of the fact that PL 89-358 established entitlement
to readjustment and other benefits to those with service after January 31,
1955, it was the belief of the Department of Tennessee, and others, that this
policy was causing them embarrassment in certain cases. Based on these and
other facts, the Subcommittee set aside the policy adopted in 1960 to.the extent
that Commission Staff may provide representation in those cases with service
after January 31, 1955.
The Chairman and Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission
reported on Staff activities, travel, budget problems, and personnel changes
and transfers that have occurred since the meeting of the full Commission
in March 1966.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, voted on and passed, the following report was received and filed:
REPORT OF NATIONAL FINANCE COMMISSION
Harold P. Redden (Massachusetts), Chairman
COMMISSION CHAIRMAN REDDEN: I want to give you a brief summarization of the status of your Endowment Fund which you are required
to report on.
The total assets in the Endowment Fund of which Harry Colmery is
President of that Corporation, is $7,237,232.25. They received in just last
year some $238,853, and their expenses were $8,061. Excess of income
over expenditures, $230,792. The transfer of earnings, that amount to your
National Treasurer in accordance with previous action of the National Executive Committee was split 50-50 between Child Welfare and Rehab. The earnings last year on the total sum figured out to 3.331 interest in dividends received.
That is the report submitted to us to be submitted to you people as the
report of the Endowment Corporation.
This Finance Commission report is as follows:
This report covers both the Washington and the present meeting of your
Finance Commission.
The 1966 budget was reviewed and, with the exception of the cost of the
Viet Nam Campaign, we appear to be operating within the budget approved
items.
The Auditor’s Report for Fiscal 1965 was analyzed and approved, subject to final approval of the National Convention Finance Committee.
166
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
In accordance with the mandate of the 14th National Convention, the sum
of $367,377.10 was transferred to the Restricted Fund. This sum with accumulated earnings can be expended only by a vote of two thirds of the National Executive Committee and the Finance Commission.
This fund now amounts to $804,448.
As far as Health Insurance, it was reviewed and changes made of a
beneficial nature. The added cost will be slightly less than $400 of present
costs. The raising of rates by Blue Cross would have added prohibitive costs
to the existing plan.
Approval was given for repairs and replacements in the Washington Building. The costs were determined from competitive bids, and were charged
against the depreciation reserve.
Reports were received and approved from the Insurance Committee
and Emblem Committee. Your body has heard the report of the Insurance
Committee; the Emblem Committee report will be submitted as a part of this
report. I have read the report of the Endowment Corporation.
Respectfully submitted, Harold P. Redden.
. . . The report of the National Emblem Committee is as follows:
REPORT OF THE
NATIONAL EMBLEM COMMITTEE
TO THE
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
May 4-5,1966
THRU: National Finance Commission
MR. COMMANDER AND GENTLEMEN OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE:
Your National Emblem Committee met in a regularly called session at
Indianapolis, Indiana, May 2, 3, 1966. Seven members were present—Julius
Levy, Chairman (Pennsylvania); Garland Owen, Vice Chairman (Virginia);
Nicholas Scaramella (Massachusetts); V. C. Christensen (Wyoming); Leo
Crawford (California); John A. Gelish (Illinois); and Joseph Paul (Michigan), the National Commander’s Representative. Committee members Hart
Snyder (Washington); Robert M. Summitt (Tennessee); and Walter
Sokolowski (New York) were unable to attend. Mr. Sokolowski is recovering
from a heart condition in the Buffalo, New York VA Hospital. The committee signed an appropriate card wishing Walter a speedy and complete
recovery.
The Outline For The Meeting, a copy of which is attached, was received
and discussed.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT
The Gross Sales for 1965 was $1,400,247.09. Net profit after distribution
was $121,571.17. The entire financial picture was reviewed in connection
with the March 31, 1966 Operating Statement and Statement of Budget. The
profit and loss statement is attached to this report.
CATALOG
The 1966 catalog was extensively discussed along with advance planning
for the 1967 catalog. The cost of the 1966 catalog was discussed and the fact
that it was much higher than previous catalogs. The paper used was a much
better quality, sheet fed press with complete new art work with models
being the reason for the increase in cost. The committee felt that the catalog
was a prestige piece and was much better than the previous three editions.
The committee discussed with the General Manager and his assistant who
handles the catalog, the possibility of reducing the cost of the 1967 catalog,
and it was brought out that much of the art work could be and would be
utilized in the 1967 issue thus reducing the art cost. It was also determined
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
167
that the sheet fed press was preferred over the web press and that the use of a
good quality paper should be continued. Efforts will be made to strike a
happy medium similar to the 1961 and 1962 catalogs which would be most
satisfactory and save approximately $12,000 on the 1967 catalog over the
cost of the 1966 catalog.
INVENTORY
The committee was gratified by the condition of the inventory with the
average monthly inventory for 1965 being $239,769.71.
Contract and non-contract purchases were considered at length. The advertising program was reviewed and approved and the committee voiced rts
appreciation for The American Legion Magazine’s aid and cooperation.
OFFICIAL REPRESENTATIVES
The committee discussed at length Licensed Official Representatives and
volume of business from same. The Committee approved a motion that all
Official Representatives be required to purchase $500 minimum gross sales
per year or relinquish their license effective following one year s operation
or their -next renewal date whichever is longer.
50TH ANNIVERSARY COMMEMORATIVE MEDAL
The General Manager reported that the National Commander had complied with the Resolution No. 229 emanating from the Portland 1965 National Convention. He had appointed a special temporary committee to formulate plans for the observance of the 50th Anniversary. Revised sketches of the
sculptor’s ideas insofar as a commemorative medal was concerned was reviewed by the committee and in view of the 50th Anniversary Committee s
action in connection with this type of an item, the committee authorized the
chairman and General Manager to act as liaison with the 50th Anniversary
Committee to avoid duplication of effort and to offer full cooperation and
support of the National Emblem Sales Division. The Chairman, Vice Chairman arid General Manager appeared before the 50th Anniversary Committee
at their invitation and discussed the commemorative medal and the tact that
the Division was most desirous of cooperating in every way and ottered the
back page of the 1968 catalog to assist in the promotion of the 50th Anniversary. It was determined that the 50th Anniversary Committee would
through their procedure, select the design for the commemorative medal and
other similar items which would be sold, and then work with the Emblem
Division in formulating final promotion and selling procedures.
Resolution No. 451 (Michigan and Resolution No. 482 (Connecticut)Subiect: Color of lettering on Department caps. The resolutions were referred to
the National Emblem Committee from the 1965 Portland, Oregon National
Convention. The resolutions were discussed by the committee and both resolutions rejected.
Many items germane to the Emblem Division’s operation were reviewed
and discussed throughout the two-day meeting of the committee.
BOOTLEG AND MISUSE OF THE AMERICAN LEGION EMBLEM
The Chairman and the General Manager called to the attention of the
committee again that many complaints of misuse of The American Legion emblem were continuing to occur. Reference is hereby made to the National
Emblem Committee’s report of April 30—May 1, 1964 with the following
paragraph quoted therefrom:
“The Emblem Committee has received several complaints regarding manufacturers bootlegging the emblems. It has been more than 10 years since
the Emblem Division employed a person to investigate the bootlegging of
the emblem. The Emblem Committee voted unanimously to authorize the
Chairman to employ an investigator for a period of one year, following
approval of the Finance Commission and the granting of a budget item
for this purpose. If a violation is found, then the Judge Advocate and
other proper parties are authorized to proceed with litigation to prohibit illegal use of the emblem.”
168
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
The Emblem Committee is now firming up a decision as to what extent
they will pursue investigating the bootlegging of The American Legion emblem.
The committee took special note of the 20 consecutive years of service
(19 as chairman) of Chairman Julius Levy and of the 22 consecutive years
of service of member Nicholas Scaramella. Their efforts throughout this period of time were lauded by the committee.
The committee expressed satisfaction with the overall operation of the
division under the direction of James S. Whitfield, General Manager and
asked that he relay this information to his staff.
RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED,
JULIUS LEVY, Chairman (Pennsylvania)
GARLAND OWEN, Vice Chairman (Virginia)
NICHOLAS SCARAMELLA (Massachusetts)
V. C. CHRISTENSEN (Wyoming)
LEO CRAWFORD (California)
JOHN A. GELISH (Illinois)
JOSEPH PAUL (Michigan), National Commander’s Representative
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL FINANCE COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted:
“Rescinding of National Emblem Sales Non-Legislative
Policy Resolutions”
Resolution No. 7 (Submitted by:
National Emblem Committee. Approved: National Finance Commission).
WHEREAS, In accordance with resolutions of the 1959 and 1960 National Conventions, the National Executive Committee, through its Program
Study Committee, has caused to be made a review of all non-legislative policy
resolutions; and such action has been taken in further accordance with the
action of the 1936 National Convention which established policy on the life
of such resolutions; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966, That the following resolutions be and they are hereby rescinded by
reason of (1) being obsolete, (2) accomplishment of purpose, (3) being superseded by later resolutions, (4) being in conflict with later resolutions, (5)
being duplicated in later resolutions, (6) having no value because of later
changes in program, (7) and for other reasons, hereinafter indicated:
Date
1963
May 1-2
1963
Sept. 8
1964
Apr. 30
May 1
1964
Sept. 20
Reference
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes
Pages 101-102
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes, Page 9
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes
Pages 147-148
N.E.C. Meeting
Digest of
Minutes, Page 8
Resolution or Other
Rescinded by
Identification
Reason Of
Resolution 38—Specifications, bids
2
and contracts for Emblem Division
Merchandise for 1964
Awarding of Emblem contracts for
year 1964
2
Resolution 60—Specifications, bids
and contracts for Emblem Division
Merchandise for 1965
2
Resolution 2—Awarding of Emblem Contracts for year 1965.
2
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
169
“Specifications, bids and contracts for Emblem Division Merchandise”
Resolution No. 8 (Submitted by:
National Emblem Committee).
BE IT RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion, at a regular meeting held at Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5,
1966, that approval is hereby given to thirteen (13) specifications relating
to the following merchandise bearing thereon the emblems of The American
Legion, American Legion Auxiliary, and Sons of The American Legion, each
specification bearing the date May 4, 1966, and bearing thereon an identifying number, namely:
Specification No. 1—American Legion caps
Specification No. 2—American Legion colors
Specification No. 3—American Legion Auxiliary colors
Specification No. 4—Sons of The American Legion colors
Specification No. 5—American Legion embroidered insignia
Specification No. 6—American Legion Auxiliary embroidered insignia
Specification No. 7—Sons of The American Legion embroidered insignia
Specification No. 10—American Legion bronze grave markers
Specification No. 11—American Legion Auxiliary bronze grave markers
Specification No. 12—American Legion buttons, pins, badges, rings, and
miscellaneous insignia
Specification No. 13—American Legion Auxiliary pins, badges, rings, and
miscellaneous
Specification No. 16—American Legion shirts
Specification No. 18—American Legion school award medals, brooch and
plaque,
and the above numbered specifications are attached hereto, and made a part
of this resolution for filing among the official records under the custodian
ship of the National Adjutant, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the National Emblem Sales and Emblem Committee, within their determination, are hereby authorized to transmit
the foregoing specifications to such concerns which manufacture, fabricate process or produce, any of the above described merchandise, for
the submission of proposals and bids to the National Emblem Committee, for
the supplying of merchandise for the period of one year from January 1,
1967 through December 31, 1967, such bids to be received no later than twelve
o’clock noon, local Indianapolis Time, Wednesday, July 27, 1966, at the National Emblem Sales, National Headquarters, The American Legion, 700 North
Pennsylvania Street, (P. 0. Box 1055), Indianapolis, Indiana, to be opened
before the National Emblem Committee at the next meeting to be held at
the National Headquarters, The American Legion, at the 48th Annual National Convention of The American Legion at Washington, D. C., said bids
to be opened at ten o’clock in the morning, local Washington, D. C. Time,
Thursday, August 25, 1966, and be it further
RESOLVED, that upon the determination of the lowest, responsible bidders for each type of merchandise as shown in the above numbered specifications, or any or all sections of any of such said specifications, that a report, as provided by the Rules of Procedure of the National
Executive Committee, be made by the Emblem Committee with its recommendations to the National Executive Committee, at its pre-convention meeting to be held at Washington, D. C., on August 28, 1966, for its consideration
and action thereon, and be it further
RESOLVED, that upon the approval and awarding of contracts
to the successful bidders, by action of the National Executive Committee as aforesaid, such contracts be approved as to form by the National
Judge Advocate, authority is hereby given for their execution by the National
Commander and National Adjutant.
170
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
“Approval to Reimburse The American Legion for Life Insurance
Expenses”
Resolution No. 39 (Submitted by:
Trust Committee).
American Legion Life Insurance and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has incurred expenses in connection
with its Insurance Plan from January 1, 1965, through December 31, 1965,
namely Committees and related expenses as certified by the National treasurer, and these expenses were paid out of the general funds but never reimbursed The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, The Administrator for the program has solicited each insured member in the Group States and a majority of the insured have indicated they do approve reimbursing The American Legion from out of the
Life Insurance Trust Fund for its expenses; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5,
1966 That in compliance with Section 3.2, Provision (e) of the Trust Agreement as Amended, that the Trustor, The American Legion, instruct the Trustee within 30 days of the approval date of this resolution, to reimburse The
American Legion $10,171.37.
“Approval to Prepare Agreement for American Legion Life
Insurance Plan”
Resolution No. 43 (Submitted by: American Legion Life Insurance and
Trust Committee).
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that a new Administration and Promotion Agreement be prepared and executed by the First National Bank of Kansas City, Missouri, as trustee, as
of January 1, 1967, with the R. H. Gore Company of Chicago, Illinois, as
Administrator, of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan, said agreement
to provide in addition to the matters in the present agreement, that the
Administrator will receive for its service compensation on a sliding scale as
follows:
(1) 10% on the first $1,000,000 of premium from the group states
(2) 8% of said premium from $1,000,000 to $1,500,000
(3) 7% of said premium from $1,500,000 to $2,000,000
and, be it further
RESOLVED, That said agreement shall also provide that the Administrator will bear the full expense of all IBM and tabulating costs, and that all
IBM cards, records, data, etc., which do not belong to the insurance carrier,
shall be the property of The American Legion; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That the Administrator shall be required to expend not less
than 15% of its total fee for the promotion and furtherance of the Life Insurance Plan, over and above the expense of the Staff Liaison and the direct
mail activity in the policy states, and to this end be required to submit to
The American Legion Life Insurance and Trust Committee at its annual
spring meeting a promotional budget for its approval and adoption, and that
any part of said 15% promotional funds not expended in any year shall be
carried over for future promotion and shall not revert to the Administrator.
REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
FOLLOWING REPORT OF
NATIONAL REHABILITATION COMMISSION
Subcommittee Chairman Stone submitted the following resolutions which
were adopted.
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
171
“Legislation to Amend 38 USC 641 to Increase the Per Diem Payment
to States for Hospital Care of War Veterans”
Resolution No. 35 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, 38 USC 641 provides a per diem rate of $2.50 for each veteran of any war receiving hospital or domiciliary care in a State home if
the veteran is eligible for hospital or domiciliary care in a Veterans Administration facility; and
WHEREAS, this section also provides a per diem of $3.50 for each veteran of any war receiving nursing home care in a State home if the veteran is unable to pay the expenses of necessary nursing home care; and
WHEREAS, it is well established that the per diem cost of hospital
patient care is greater than the per diem cost of nursing care patients and
of domiciliary members; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that the per diem payment
of State homes for hospital care of war veterans should be increased to an
amount that bears a proper relationship to the nursing care and domiciliary
per diem rates; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion shall sponsor and support legislation to amend
38 USC 641 to provide a per diem rate of $5 for each veteran of any war
receiving hospital care in a State home in such State if the veteran is eligible
for hospital care in a Veterans Administration facility; however, the payment
shall not be more, in any case, than one-half the cost of the veterans maintenance in the State home.
(Rule 8-B.)
“Eligibility of Retired Military Personnel for Treatment in
Veterans Administration Hospitals”
Resolution No. 36 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, legislation is under consideration to authorize health benefits
programs for retired members of the Armed Forces of the United States;
and
WHEREAS, this legislation would provide medical treatment and care
in Veterans Administration facilities which the Administrator of Veterans
Affairs determines are available for this purpose; and
WHEREAS, this legislation would permit retired military personnel to receive care for nonservice-connected conditions without the necessity of their
establishing an inability to pay for such care or treatment at their own
expense; and
WHEREAS, retired military personnel are eligible for care and treatment
in Veterans Administration hospitals for service incurred conditions; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is cognizant of the obligation incurred
by the United States to provide within military facilities, medical and hospital care for these military personnel for any condition; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion looks with disfavor on those administrative or legislative efforts that would modify the admission priorities to permits VA hospital care of retired military personnel or other persons ahead of
eligible veterans; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
that The American Legion oppose the enactment of legislation to provide that
retired military personnel may be permitted admission to Veterans Administration facilities under priorities and standards of eligibility different than
those applicable to war veterans for service-connected and non service-connected hospital care.
(Rule 8-B.)
172
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
“Sponsor and Support Legislation to Provide Nursing Home Care for
Veterans Living in Alaska and Hawaii”
Resolution No. 37 (Submitted by: National Rehabilitation Commission).
WHEREAS, Section 620 of Title 38, United States Code, provides that
the Administrator of Veterans Affairs may transfer any veteran, who has
been furnished care by the Veterans Administration in a hospital under the
direct and exclusive jurisdiction of the Administrator, to any public or private institution not under the jurisdiction of the Veterans Administration
which furnishes nursing home care, for care at the expense of the United
States; and
WHEREAS, the Administrator of Veterans Affairs does not operate and
have under his exclusive jurisdiction any hospital in the States of Alaska
and Hawaii, there being no VA hospital in those states; and
WHEREAS, this provision of 38 USC 620 therefore denies to veterans
residing or domiciled in the States of Alaska and Hawaii nursing care treatment at the expense of the United States; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion feels that veterans living in Alaska
and Hawaii should not be denied entitlement to this essential benefit merely
for the reason that the Administrator of Veterans Affairs does not have any
VA hospital in those States in which an eligible veteran can receive care;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by the National Executive Committee of The American
Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, May 4-5, 1966,
That The American Legion shall sponsor and support legislation to amend 38
USC 620 to provide that any veteran who is furnished care by the Veterans
Administration in a hospital in Alaska or Hawaii may be furnished nursing
home care at the expense of the United States even if the hospital is not
under the direct and exclusive jurisdiction of the Administrator of Veterans
Affairs.
(Rule 8-B.)
FINAL REPORT OF RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE
RESOLUTIONS SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STONE: I have one
little matter, Resolution 40. This is a resolution emanating from the National
Chaplin Alfred C. Thompson.
“Commend the American Bible Society on its 150th Anniversary”
Resolution No. 40 (Submitted by: National Chaplain Alfred C. Thompson),
WHEREAS, the Preamble of the Constitution of The American Legion
recognizes Legionnaires’ duty to God; and
WHEREAS, The Bible for centuries, has been the Book of faith; and
WHEREAS, Men who have seriously read the Bible, have found it to be
a Book of promise and hope; and
WHEREAS, America from its beginnings, has been a nation with deep
roots in the Bible; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the National Executive Committee of The American Legion in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, on May 4-5, 1966,
That we urge our own members, and all America to revitalize the practice
of personal Bible reading consonant with their beliefs and free will; and be
it finally
RESOLVED, That we commend the American Bible Society on this, its
150th Anniversary, for it has played a major role in making the Bible a
heritage of faith for our own people and people around the world.
CONFIRMATION OF INTERIM APPOINTMENTS
I would like to propose without reading the confirmation of Interim
Appointments which you have made, I understand they are all in proper order,
so I will make that motion.
173
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
. . . The motion was seconded by National Vice Commander Galbraith.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: The Adjutant advises me they are
in order.
Those in favor signify by saying aye; contrary minded no. The ayes
have it and it is adopted.
INTERIM APPOINTMENTS
Joseph J. Bajdek, Indiana—Member, Americanism Commission, 1966replacing Bert F. Nowinski, Indiana, deceased.
Anthony Badamo, Illinois—Vice Chairman, Americanism Council, 1966.
Falon A. Fraley, Nevada—Member, Western Area, Child Welfare Commission, 1968—replacing Ed M. White, Sr., Nevada, deceased.
William G. Clark, Illinois—Vice Chairman, Distinguished Guests Committee, 1966.
Walter M. Rapp, Oklahoma—Consultant, Employment Committee, 1966.
J. Alvis Carver, North Carolina—Member, Foreign Relations Commission,
1967—replacing John J. Barnhardt, North Carolina, deceased.
Robert F. Murphy, Massachusetts—Special Consultant, Legislative Commission, 1966.
Roscoe T. Morse, California—Member, National Security Commission, 1968
replacing George W. Fisher, California, deceased.
Frank Rehberg, Oregon—Member, Civil Defense Committee, 1968—replacing Arthur Gabriel, Oregon, deceased.
Charles Sclafani, New York—Vice Chairman, National Security Council,
Garland Bloodsworth, Jr., Delaware—Rehabilitation Commission, Area “B.”
Fr. Paul Schwaab, Nebraska—Vice Chairman, Americanism.
CONFIRMATION AND CANCELLATION OF
POST AND/OR SQUADRON CHARTERS
MR McKINLEY: I would like to move at this time also the approval of
the confirmation and cancellation of Post and/or Squadron Charters. The
Adiutant has assured me that they are all in proper order, and that there
is no controversy on all of them, and rather than read them, I now move
they be approved.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Fern, Kentucky.
The aforementioned Charters are as follows:
No.
Location
Department
Name of Post
Arkansas
Morgan-W illiams
147
California
Beacon
Havens-Rodriguez Memorial
Barstow
Middletown
La Mirada
Tarzana Missile
343 Los Angeles
535 Simi
663 Barstow
677 Middletown
683 La Mirada
687 Tarzana
Connecticut
Sgt. Richard William Morgan
Sgt. Casper S. Davis, Jr.
Broad Brook
Rogers Brothers
Paul Deschenes
John Benke
New Haven Police Dept.
55 Mystic
136 W aterville
145 Broad Brook
149 Bridgeport
166 Waterbury
185 Bridgeport
191 New Haven
Idaho
Edgar Rae
121
Belleville
Crouch
174
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Location
Department
Name of Post
No.
Illinois
Dwyer-Smith
Verne Hyre
Mark White
Victor F. Lawson
Medina
Hanover Township Memorial
618
637
939
1111
1250
1959
Cooksville
Palestine
Chicago
Chicago
Mossville
Streamwood
Kansas
Thompson-Tyler
Brad Mills
Will L. Pine
James Fippins
Kanorado Memorial
29
82
114
360
395
Salina
Coffeyville
Spearville
Great Bend
Kanorado
Louisiana
Westgate
362
Westgate
Maryland
Baltimore
Westport
Little Italy
Cecil Randolph, Jr.
Howard County
6
33
177
271
286
Baltimore
Westport
Baltimore
Frostburg
Ellicott City
Massachusetts
Capitol Hill
402
Boston
Michigan
Hanes-Malloy
474
Kalamazoo
Minneapolis
Granger
554
Granger
Mississippi
James E. White
215
Hernando
Montana
Jefferson
Toole
Isaac Matt
Rocky Boy
46
52
110
132
Magee-Stevenson
136
Boulder
Shelby
Babb
Rocky Boy’s
Indian
Reservation
E. Glacier Park
New York
Joan of Arc
Hartford
Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake
Morrisania Memorial
North Carolina
Alamance
Junie Ammons
Charlie Humphrey
Hugh Pete Stephenson
1527
1767
1817
1851
83
124
179
186
Bronx
Hartford
Burnt Hills
Bronx
Graham
Clinton
Roxboro
Pendleton
North Dakota
Clyde
289
Clyde
Ohio
Cleveland Transit
Brewer-Kellis
Roy G. Fitzgerald, Jr.
206
393
589
Cleveland
Lynchburg
Oakwood
Oklahoma
Hollarn-Perry
283
Cyril
Pennsylvania
John R. McKinley
Ainsworth-Wernher
Burrell-Saunders
Penn Township
Golden Triangle
Columbia Turn Verein Mem.
West Reading
115
427
704
706
767
872
930
Corsica
Swarthmore
Homestead
Crescent Hills
Pittsburgh
Philadelphia
West Reading
South Carolina
James-Victor-Gardner
The James-Victor-Gardner
116
168
Holly Hill
Travelers Rest
175
Proceedings of Thursday, May 5, 1966
Name of Post
Department
No.
Location
Texas
Ray Wingren
The Lackland City
Hager-Weaver
Cruiser Houston
Ferrel-Cross
Kenedy
Early Carver
W. D. Miller
64 Burnet
81 San Antonio
167 Rule
325 Houston
641 Sylvester
642 Kenedy
906 San Marcos
907 Levelland
Virginia
South Norfolk
Corporal John Herr
Buena Vista
Courtland
Harry S. Walters
108 South Norfolk
171 Arlington
261 Buena Vista
275 Courtland
283 Edinburg
West Virginia
William Alexander
72
Clarksburg
Respectfully yours,
E. A. BLACKMORE, National Adjutant.
SAL SQUADRONS
Department
Name of Squadron
Connecticut
Sgt. Richard William Morgan
Illinois
William Schaefer
Peter Umathum
William R. Edmondson
Wauconda
Park Forest
Mexican-American
Michigan
No.
55
44
412
832
911
1198
505
Location
Mystic
Pekin
Woodstock
Willow Springs
Wauconda
Park Forest
Detroit
Ohio
Pearce-Kems
Isaac Van Wert
Firestone Memorial
Shadyside
Niles Richards
120 Urbana
178 Van Wert
449 Akron
521 Shadyside
708 Hollansburg
Oklahoma
Carter C. Hanner
129
Wisconsin
21
Stillwater
Kenosha
Kenosha
Respectfully yours,
E. A. BLACKMORE, National Adjutant.
AUTHORITY GIVEN TO NATIONAL COMMANDER
AND ADJUTANT FOR CORRECTIONS
MR. McKINLEY: Mr. Commander, I now move that it be shown on the
record the authority is given to the Commander and the Adjutant to make
such amendments of our record as to reflect the facts.
.. . The motion was seconded and carried.
CONFIRMATION OF DATES FOR FALL MEETINGS
MR. McKINLEY: I move that the fall meeting dates of Monday, October
10th through Friday, October 14th, 1966 be confirmed.
.... The motion was seconded by Mr. Leonard, Connecticut, and adopted.
176
Proceedings o£ Thursday, May 5, 1966
CLOSING REMARKS OF NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES
Gentlemen, the Chair has much that he would like to say. Let me do it
this way if I may.
There are two, I believe only two Chairmen in the room, I know them well.
You know their records. They typify the magnificent service of men of this
organization who worked, Harold Redden, of the Finance Commission, and
Bob McCurdy of Rehabilitation.
As I look around the room, there are also a few staff members. They
exemplify the other devoted great servants of this organization.
So to you specifically, gentlemen, and through you to all the rest, let me
say thank you so very much for what you have done.
I would like to say this to so many people, to the Chairmen of all the
Special Committees that have been working this year, I would say thank
you, Ad Wagner, to them, thanks for all the work they have been doing.
Your example of a magnificent job typifies their work also.
We want to express our appreciation to them.
There is so much else we could say, but may I just wind it up this
way, at times my words may have been harsh and occasionally the needle
may have been sharp, but neither can possibly match the intense desire of
your Commander to bring out the best in each of you, no matter what your
stand might be. In a mutual deep desire to serve our God and our Country
and our great organization The American Legion, I would sum it up this
way, a man may have thoughts, hopes, dreams, and they may enrich his life,
but they serve no useful purpose beyond that of self enjoyment unless he
uses his talents and his energies to convert those thoughts, those hopes and
those dreams to constructive action.
This Committee is generously endowed with such men who convert their
talents and their energies to work of this organization. They are generously
endowed with Committeemen and Committee Members co-workers of the same
ilk. For this, your National Commander has incurred a debt to you, and to
them, he will never be able to repay. But he will devote the best of his time
and talent and energy in the years ahead to satisfying that debt.
And with this, all I can say is, you have my gratitude and thanks.
Is there anything further to come before this meeting?
If not, the National Chaplain.
BENEDICTION
NATIONAL CHAPLIN THOMPSON: Let us pray.
Almighty God, as we now close this session of the National Executive
Committee, we pray to you to bless and sanctify those decisions which we
have made, may these actions help to strengthen our American Legion and
further the aims and the purposes for which we have been organized. Grant,
oh God, as we leave this meeting we may have traveling mercies, and
may the Grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God the Father, the
fellowship and the communion of the Holy Spirit be with you forevermore.
Amen.
... At this time the National Executive Committee saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER JAMES: Gentlemen, the meeting is adjourned.
... At 12:45 p. m., the spring meeting of the National Excutive Committee
adjourned.