Extracted text: A quick guide for leadership on frequently asked questions `
Extracted text: A quick guide for leadership on frequently asked questions ` results
Linna_Agne
Edited Text
THE AMERICAN LEGION
A QUICK GUIDE FOR LEADERSHIP ON FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Have we considered extending eligibility to Cold War veterans? This would
assist in increasing our membership.
There was a very detailed study conducted in 1985 and is known as the Godwin
Study (Membership Eligibility Study Committee Report). The study committee
was charged to do the following:
Study the history and precedents of all past eligibility studies and changes.
To evaluate the distinction between ―wartime veterans‖ and ―peacetime
veterans.‖
To estimate the timing requirements to effect the change in our
Congressional charter.
To analyze the ultimate change in The American Legion’s long-standing
history of being an organization of ―War Veterans‖ and the impact of any
change on the principles established at the founding of The American
Legion.
The bottom-line of the study and the policy of the National Executive Committee
adopted was that we would remain an organization of ―Wartime Veterans‖ and
that place of service does not impact eligibility, i.e., service in a combat zone is
not a requirement for American Legion membership eligibility. As far as aiding
veterans not eligible for The American Legion, our service officers will assist
these veterans with any issue just like they do our members. It makes no
difference if they are a member of The American Legion or not.
The Godwin study provides the most detailed and thorough review of eligibility
issues to date.
Has this policy on eligibility been reviewed since 1985?
Since the study, every National Convention except two has faced the issue of a
proposed change in eligibility. Resolutions received for the National Conventions
were reviewed by the Constitutional Amendments Convention Committee as well
as Credentials and Internal Affairs Convention Committee consisting of delegates
from the 55 departments and their actions were confirmed by the almost 3,000
delegates to the Conventions. All proposed changes to eligibility went thru this
process; all proposals to open eligibility were rejected. Hence, the considerations
reviewed by the Godwin Study Committee are still applicable to The American
Legion today.
Page 1 of 11
8/09/2010
If my post wants to try to change the eligibility for American Legion
membership, how do we do it?
The process starts with a resolution from the post level where individual thoughts
are distilled into a formal recommendation. It makes its way thru department to
the national level where it is reviewed and the Constitutional Amendments or
Credentials and Internal Affairs Convention Committee(s) make(s) their
recommendation to the National Convention delegates.
The process described above has served The American Legion well since 1919.
It takes individual thoughts/opinions and by a systematic procedure turns them
into corporate policy.
Our post has struggled to get new members. We are a small post with an
aging membership and we believe The American Legion should open
membership to all veterans so we can increase our membership.
There are more than 17 million veterans who are eligible to join The American
Legion who are not members. Nationally we have consistently penetrated 13% of
the eligible market. We have a very large market of fully qualified ―wartime
veterans‖ just waiting to be asked. Yes, there are posts that are struggling for
membership because of where they are located and where the eligible veterans
may be living.
What is the IAVA? My understanding is this is a veteran’s organization that
was just founded for the veterans of Iraq & Afghanistan. They are already
125,000 strong and growing. Why is there such a group? And why hasn't
The American Legion met their needs so they would not have to form such
a group?
The IAVA stands for ―Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America.‖ They are an
organization of veterans who served during Operation Iraqi Freedom and
Operation Enduring Freedom.
It is not uncommon for special interest organizations like IAVA to spring up after
wars and conflicts. It happened, for example, after the Vietnam War with the
Vietnam Student Organizations on college campuses.
The IAVA exists because of special interest funding and generational interests. If
history repeats itself, their members will join other veteran service organizations
because we all have similar interests. There are significant differences between
The American Legion and IAVA. An Iraq-Afghan veteran can join IAVA free of
charge. IAVA has no structure and no programs other than legislative issues. It
is basically a social network community that has no grassroots presence like The
Page 2 of 11
8/09/2010
American Legion. They are not chartered by Congress or recognized by the
Department of Veterans Affairs for veterans claims representation.
It may appear to some that The American Legion does not meet the needs of
these veterans because we do not reach out to them consistently on the local
level. We need to be there when they join the military service, when their unit
deploys overseas, when their families need help, and when they return from
assignment. We have the structure, the programs and we have 2.5 million
members in over 14,000 posts to extend a helping hand. We are a grassroots,
community-based organization, not just a social network of computers. We have
service officers to help them with their needs. We are there to help; we must see
to it that they know this. Every American Legion member needs to extend a
hand and thank these young veterans. Welcome them home and help them with
their issues—healthcare, scholarships, housing and employment, just to name a
few.
Why is so much emphasis placed on district commanders when these
offices are not even required by the organization?
The National
Constitution & By-Laws places restrictions on "intermediate bodies" and
national seems to be ignoring that provision and not defining what district
officers are responsible for.
The Constitution gives the department authority to create intermediate bodies
between posts and departments to promote the programs of The American
Legion. It further states that the Department Executive Committee shall define
the powers of the intermediate bodies (district, county, division, etc.) so as not to
invade the prerogatives invested in the post, department or National.
Information was derived from departments over the years on how they utilize
their intermediate organizations and we had several requests to put this
information in the Officer‟s Guide and Manual of Ceremonies.
In summary, the district (county, region or division in some departments
depending on size and desire) commander is the department commander’s link
between department and posts in order to enhance The American Legion
programs. This vital link serves to extend the communications span of the
department commander but does not usurp his/her responsibilities. The district
commander is the liaison between the post and department, but also has the
implied obligation to provide guidance and supervision within the guidelines
established by the department executive committee. The district commander is a
vital communications link between department and posts in conducting The
American Legion programs. The Officer‟s Guide stresses how to organize
committees, conduct meetings and evaluate post programs.
Page 3 of 11
8/09/2010
If you look at other veterans’ service organizations’ (VSOs) life membership
programs you will see they are less expensive for their members to
purchase. For example in one VSO for the age group of 50 to 60 a life
membership is around $400. For the same age group in The American
Legion it is around $700.
When The American Legion Paid Up For Life plan was set up, the actuaries
anticipated that departments and posts would increase their dues only when
national increased the national per capita dues. This has not been the case
inasmuch as the national per capita is increased once every seven years or so
while some posts/departments increase their dues on a more frequent basis.
Therefore, for several years national was required to send more money to
various posts and departments than had been anticipated in the actuarial charts.
This was corrected by the NEC over the course of several years by enacting
resolutions which froze the amount of reimbursement to posts, departments and
national at the level existing when the PUFL was purchased.
Meanwhile, it was discovered that, out of some 225,000 existing PUFLs, about
30,000 were deceased and that fact had not been reported to either the
departments or national by the posts. This was causing some $600,000 a year
to be drained out of the trust.
Additionally, upon close scrutiny, we discovered there were a number of people
(small, yet significant) who had incorrectly stated their age at the time they paid
for the PUFL, thereby skewing the actuarial tables and payment charts.
All of this was corrected in 2009 with an actuarial recalculation of rates, a
requirement that proof of age be submitted, a regular system installed to ensure
that national was apprised of deaths, and a requirement put in place for an
actuarial reassessment every year.
The rates that are currently charged by national are based on your age at
application and the dues currently being paid. It is an accurate rate which will
ensure the trust always has sufficient money to pay the dues to the posts,
departments and national (which were in effect at the time of purchase) and the
individual will not have to pay any additional money after entering the program.
You can be assured The American Legion will never renege on its commitment
to those who have purchased PUFLs, nor will the Legion ever ask current PUFLs
to pay more. The rates will be adjusted from time to time as required to keep the
trust actuarially sound, and persons contemplating the purchase of a PUFL can
Page 4 of 11
8/09/2010
consider the current rate and decide to purchase or not, knowing full well that if
they do the Legion will fulfill its promise.
Some veterans in our community received a certificate of membership
nomination from National Headquarters asking them to join the Legion for
$25.00 by putting a sticker on the acceptance form without showing any
discharge papers. Is this legitimate?
Yes, this is the Direct Membership Solicitation (DMS) program. The DMS
program has been in effect since 1982 in very much the same form as it is now.
The introductory rate is $25. The renewal rate is the same as the headquarters
post rate in the department where they live. The individual must certify their
eligibility on the application they return to national by indicating the dates they
served on active duty, their character of discharge, their branch of service and
their birth date. While occasionally someone has joined who was not eligible,
this has not been a problem. Over 1.6 million members have joined through the
DMS program and less than 500 were found to be ineligible when they went to a
local post to transfer their membership from a headquarters post. It is still a
requirement for the local post to verify eligibility when these members transfer
into the local post.
The DMS program is a highly effective membership tool to augment the
traditional recruiting efforts done by the 14,000 posts in order to reach many of
the eligible veterans who are not members of The American Legion.
Why not include DMS in membership and all award calculations?
Emphasis on our award system is to reward volunteers who do the work. This
argues for just including those members that posts, districts and department
membership teams can influence to join---our traditional members. DMS is
merely a tool to increase membership or replace attrition. DMS members are
procured by national and then offered to departments after their first renewal if
placed in traditional posts. However, these members count towards the
department’s delegate strength for the National Convention.
Why can’t Vietnam-era veterans attend the National Legion College?
The Legion College is designed to mold leaders for the future. Our Vietnam-era
members are typically, already in various leadership positions. The purpose of
Legion College is for the graduates to take what they have learned and train
members in the department because not every member can attend the National
American Legion College.
Criteria to attend the Legion College is toward post-Vietnam veterans as first
priority; however, if the department has one fully qualified candidate (post
Vietnam) they can nominate a Vietnam-era veteran as an additional candidate.
Page 5 of 11
8/09/2010
Several departments have done this and we have had several Vietnam veterans
attend. We don’t like to see any of the 50 seats go unfilled in the annual
program. First priority is a candidate from each department who is a postVietnam veteran and has at least two years in The American Legion. In selection
of candidates, preference should be given to members who have or are holding
leadership roles no higher than district/county level. It serves no purpose to send
a past or current department officer.
This criterion is outlined on the Legion College application form, either in the hard
copy sent to the departments or in the application that is posted on the Legion
Web site. (www.legion.org).
Can National help in funding a local memorial or education center?
There is a long standing policy that the national headquarters will not financially
support memorials, museums or education centers that are not in the greater
Washington, DC, area and federally funded. In addition, they must be supported
by Congress and the National Parks System.
Due to the increasing number of proposed memorials coming to the attention of
the Internal Affairs Commission, it is not possible for The American Legion to
honor all such requests for financial support; therefore, the Commission adopted
the following policy:
The Internal Affairs Commission does not feel it can set aside one memorial for
American Legion financial support from the many requests which are all worthy
and deserving of consideration.
At the same time and in accordance with the Preamble of The American
Legion Constitution, the Commission is mindful of the importance to ...
"Preserve the memories and incidents of our associations in the great wars"
and does not wish to inhibit in any way the construction of those memorials
honoring the veterans of this nation. It is, accordingly, recommended that the
Internal Affairs Commission, as a matter of policy, refrain from recommending
financial support for one memorial at the exclusion of all other memorial
requests. It is also recommended that the Internal Affairs Commission accept
those national memorial requests honoring the veterans of this nation that
have federal approval and to utilize all means available to The American
Legion to encourage The American Legion membership, as well as the
general public, to financially support these worthwhile projects.
The Commission feels that due to the complexities and potential financial
obligations that The American Legion might be faced with in supporting a
particular initiative that there should be an EXCEPTIONAL DEMONSTRATED
NEED for such support with the following accompanying documentation
Page 6 of 11
8/09/2010
attached to the resolution so that the Commission can make a proper
recommendation to the National Executive Committee:
Stated objectives of the Association/Foundation/ Sponsoring Activity
Amount of funds needed to complete the project and a plan for how to
achieve the funds
Plan to sustain and maintain the memorial, monument, education center,
etc.
Copy of incorporation papers
List of the Board Of Directors
A copy of the last audit
A copy of the most recent financial statement(s)
A copy of annual meeting minutes of Board Of Directors, certified by CEO
What is the policy for designating a poem, book, march, or song as
“official” for The American Legion?
Occasionally, resolutions are received seeking to make an original composition
an official American Legion march, song, book, poem, etc. Most of these
creations show great professional competence and reveal a sincere affection for
The American Legion and its principles.
However, the Internal Affairs
Commission does not feel that it has the authority to judge, among many artistic
creations, those which are so superior that they should be designated as official
American Legion marches, songs, poems, etc. Furthermore, a review of the
record found that in 1922 a musical contribution ―Armistice Day Forever‖ by Barry
J. Sick was given the status of official American Legion march by the National
Executive Committee.
There have been numerous occasions since then when musical compositions
have been so honored, but the record also shows that the assignment of the
words ―official‖ to a particular composition by the National Convention or the
National Executive Committee in no way guarantees that the composition will be
used throughout the organization. The Internal Affairs Commission has since
adopted a policy that it would refrain from designating or recognizing any artistic
work as ―official‖ or to recommend the use of any composition by The American
Legion to the exclusion of other compositions.
The Internal Affairs Commission is mindful of the high compliment paid to The
American Legion by its members who use their talents to create artistic works
dedicated to the Legion or intended for the use of the Legion, and we do not wish
to do anything to inhibit the artistic expression that members exhibit for The
American Legion.
When I see how my Congress members vote on veterans’ entitlement
issues, I have a feeling they don’t really care about veterans. When is The
Page 7 of 11
8/09/2010
American Legion going to make their votes public? Why don't you have a
wall of shame for all elected officials who vote against veterans issues?
All votes of members of Congress are public – there are no secret votes;
unfortunately, many veterans’ bills are agreed to under unanimous consent
(voice vote). Another problem is that veterans’ bills are often included in
omnibus legislative packages; that means there are many other provisions not
related to veterans’ benefits or issues that are controversial. A member’s vote
against or for such omnibus bills may not reflect a member’s true position on a
veterans’ benefit or issue.
We have seen other organizations develop scorecards and our feeling in some
cases is that they were inadequate in measuring a member’s support of veterans’
and their families. Frequently, these scorecards are used by politicians to muster
support or opposition in political races. Very few veterans’ benefits or issues are
passed as free-standing bills or by roll call votes that would clearly reflect a
member’s support or opposition.
The fact is that it takes a majority in the House and the Senate to get bills to the
White House. The First Session of the 111th Congress was extremely successful
for the veterans’ community. Congress passed Public Law 111-81 providing
advance appropriations for VA medical care accounts – a top priority for The
American Legion and many other veterans’ service organizations. VA
appropriations for FY 2010 met or exceeded every recommendation made by
The American Legion and were in an omnibus appropriations bill with a number
of other appropriations bills passed under unanimous consent.
The best way to know a lawmaker’s position is to ask them – by letter, phone
call, town hall meeting, etc. Make your judgment based on his or her response to
you. Hold your two Senators and your representative accountable.
On the whole, veterans’ benefits have improved significantly. Rather than a wall
of shame, one could argue that there are many veterans’ champions in
Congress. The American Legion has never been and will never be a single-issue
national wartime veterans’ service organization. For the most part, Congress is
veteran-friendly.
How can I get The American Legion at the local, state and national level to
support a candidate running for Congress from my hometown that
supports veterans’ issues as well as supports a number of important
positions held by The American Legion?
According to Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution of The American Legion,
―The American Legion shall be absolutely nonpolitical and shall not be used for
the dissemination of partisan principles nor for the promotion of the candidacy of
any person seeking public office or preferment.‖ Therefore, we are unable to
Page 8 of 11
8/09/2010
help the candidate; however, you as a private citizen can do whatever is legal
and ethical to advance his/her candidacy.
Why doesn’t The American Legion establish a male auxiliary or allow male
spouses of female veterans to join The Sons of The American Legion?
Female veterans are most certainly welcome in The American Legion and have
been since 1919 and well before women could vote in this nation. Your issue is
with their spouses who have not joined the military.
The Sons of The American Legion was established in 1932 as a program,
comprised of male descendants, adopted sons, and stepsons of members of The
American Legion. Sons of female veterans who are eligible to join The American
Legion are qualified for The Sons of The American Legion. In 1972 and 1973, the
National Executive Committee (NEC) created a National SAL under the full
supervision and control of the NEC with over watch delegated to the Internal
Affairs Commission. The key to eligibility is male lineage of a veteran parent or
grandparent as outlined above.
According to the Veterans Administration there are 1.5 million female veterans.
A study conducted in 2005 by the Defense Department Advisory Committee on
Women in Services states that 81% of male spouses of female veterans have
served in the military. Based on these statistics and adjustments for marriages
after leaving active duty, there could be slightly over 30,000 male spouses of
female veterans who could not join The American Legion based on their own
eligibility. However, a sizeable number of these male spouses could be eligible
for the SAL based on their father, grandfather or step father eligibility for The
American Legion. This estimated population is significantly smaller than 30,000.
The corporate process to make changes starts with a resolution from the post
level where individual thoughts are distilled into a formal recommendation. The
resolution makes its way through department to the National level where it is
reviewed and the Constitutional Amendments or Credentials and Internal Affairs
Convention Committee(s) make(s) their recommendation for a change to the
Legion Constitution to the almost 3,000 National Convention delegates from all
55 departments.
Over the last few years, Internal Affairs has had three resolutions on male
spouses of female veterans (two to join the SAL and one to establish a separate
male auxiliary) that were considered by the various Convention Committees and
all three were rejected.
In all cases they have validated the basic principles that The American Legion
should not establish a male auxiliary or change the lineage for the Sons of The
American Legion. The process as described above has served The American
Page 9 of 11
8/09/2010
Legion well since 1919 where it takes individual thoughts/opinions and by a
systematic procedure turns them into a corporate policy.
What is The American Legion doing about the USS Liberty tragedy?
The tragic mistaken identity attack by Israelis on the USS Liberty on June 8,
1967 provoked a great deal of controversy among surviving members of the crew
and family members. Though residual anger and suspicions remain, the incident
was the subject of ten US investigations and three by the Israelis. In the
American investigations, the full weight of the US Government allowed access to
all of the relevant security information. Though some accusations were made
suggesting the reports sought to hide facts or protect Israel, no credible evidence
for these charges has been produced at the US Government level.
The Foreign Relations Convention Committee of The American Legion reviewed
the action taken by OSD and Congress on this incident and they voted to reject
Resolution 235 submitted by the Department of District of Columbia at the 84th
Annual National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina, August 2002.
What is the status of “on-line” renewals?
An ―On-line‖ renewal system has been successfully tested in five departments.
The National Commander appointed an ad hoc committee to study implementing
in all departments. At the 2010 Spring Meetings, a resolution was approved to
make the required changes to the Constitution and By-Laws at the 92d National
Convention in Milwaukee. At the National Convention, the delegates will vote on
the required constitutional changes in order to implement ―on-line‖ renewals in
June 2011.
As budgets get tighter and Congress looks for “bill payers” and so called
“peace dividends”, we must always fight to maintain the benefits for our
military, our veterans and their families. The history of America's veterans
began in 1636 with the creation of veterans' benefits by the Plymouth
Colony Pilgrims in Massachusetts, who were at war with the Indians.
According to the Pilgrims: "If any man shall be sent forth as a soldier and
shall return maimed, he shall be maintained competently by the colony
during his life."
The American Legion firmly believes that veterans and their families have earned
every benefit awarded to them by a grateful nation because of their selfless
service. Indeed, this basic principle was succinctly written into law when the
Supreme Court stated in 1983:
“It is … not irrational for Congress to decide that, even though it will not subsidize
substantial lobbying by charities generally, it will subsidize lobbying by veterans‟
Page 10 of 11
8/09/2010
organizations. Veterans have „been obliged to drop their own affairs and take up
the burdens of the nation, subjecting themselves to the mental and physical
hazards as well as the economic and family detriments which are peculiar to
military service and which do not exist in normal civil life.‟ Our country has a
long-standing policy of compensating veterans for their past contributions by
providing them numerous advantages. This policy has „always been deemed to
be legitimate.‟” Chief Justice of the United States William H. Rehnquist (5/83)
Page 11 of 11
8/09/2010
A QUICK GUIDE FOR LEADERSHIP ON FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Have we considered extending eligibility to Cold War veterans? This would
assist in increasing our membership.
There was a very detailed study conducted in 1985 and is known as the Godwin
Study (Membership Eligibility Study Committee Report). The study committee
was charged to do the following:
Study the history and precedents of all past eligibility studies and changes.
To evaluate the distinction between ―wartime veterans‖ and ―peacetime
veterans.‖
To estimate the timing requirements to effect the change in our
Congressional charter.
To analyze the ultimate change in The American Legion’s long-standing
history of being an organization of ―War Veterans‖ and the impact of any
change on the principles established at the founding of The American
Legion.
The bottom-line of the study and the policy of the National Executive Committee
adopted was that we would remain an organization of ―Wartime Veterans‖ and
that place of service does not impact eligibility, i.e., service in a combat zone is
not a requirement for American Legion membership eligibility. As far as aiding
veterans not eligible for The American Legion, our service officers will assist
these veterans with any issue just like they do our members. It makes no
difference if they are a member of The American Legion or not.
The Godwin study provides the most detailed and thorough review of eligibility
issues to date.
Has this policy on eligibility been reviewed since 1985?
Since the study, every National Convention except two has faced the issue of a
proposed change in eligibility. Resolutions received for the National Conventions
were reviewed by the Constitutional Amendments Convention Committee as well
as Credentials and Internal Affairs Convention Committee consisting of delegates
from the 55 departments and their actions were confirmed by the almost 3,000
delegates to the Conventions. All proposed changes to eligibility went thru this
process; all proposals to open eligibility were rejected. Hence, the considerations
reviewed by the Godwin Study Committee are still applicable to The American
Legion today.
Page 1 of 11
8/09/2010
If my post wants to try to change the eligibility for American Legion
membership, how do we do it?
The process starts with a resolution from the post level where individual thoughts
are distilled into a formal recommendation. It makes its way thru department to
the national level where it is reviewed and the Constitutional Amendments or
Credentials and Internal Affairs Convention Committee(s) make(s) their
recommendation to the National Convention delegates.
The process described above has served The American Legion well since 1919.
It takes individual thoughts/opinions and by a systematic procedure turns them
into corporate policy.
Our post has struggled to get new members. We are a small post with an
aging membership and we believe The American Legion should open
membership to all veterans so we can increase our membership.
There are more than 17 million veterans who are eligible to join The American
Legion who are not members. Nationally we have consistently penetrated 13% of
the eligible market. We have a very large market of fully qualified ―wartime
veterans‖ just waiting to be asked. Yes, there are posts that are struggling for
membership because of where they are located and where the eligible veterans
may be living.
What is the IAVA? My understanding is this is a veteran’s organization that
was just founded for the veterans of Iraq & Afghanistan. They are already
125,000 strong and growing. Why is there such a group? And why hasn't
The American Legion met their needs so they would not have to form such
a group?
The IAVA stands for ―Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America.‖ They are an
organization of veterans who served during Operation Iraqi Freedom and
Operation Enduring Freedom.
It is not uncommon for special interest organizations like IAVA to spring up after
wars and conflicts. It happened, for example, after the Vietnam War with the
Vietnam Student Organizations on college campuses.
The IAVA exists because of special interest funding and generational interests. If
history repeats itself, their members will join other veteran service organizations
because we all have similar interests. There are significant differences between
The American Legion and IAVA. An Iraq-Afghan veteran can join IAVA free of
charge. IAVA has no structure and no programs other than legislative issues. It
is basically a social network community that has no grassroots presence like The
Page 2 of 11
8/09/2010
American Legion. They are not chartered by Congress or recognized by the
Department of Veterans Affairs for veterans claims representation.
It may appear to some that The American Legion does not meet the needs of
these veterans because we do not reach out to them consistently on the local
level. We need to be there when they join the military service, when their unit
deploys overseas, when their families need help, and when they return from
assignment. We have the structure, the programs and we have 2.5 million
members in over 14,000 posts to extend a helping hand. We are a grassroots,
community-based organization, not just a social network of computers. We have
service officers to help them with their needs. We are there to help; we must see
to it that they know this. Every American Legion member needs to extend a
hand and thank these young veterans. Welcome them home and help them with
their issues—healthcare, scholarships, housing and employment, just to name a
few.
Why is so much emphasis placed on district commanders when these
offices are not even required by the organization?
The National
Constitution & By-Laws places restrictions on "intermediate bodies" and
national seems to be ignoring that provision and not defining what district
officers are responsible for.
The Constitution gives the department authority to create intermediate bodies
between posts and departments to promote the programs of The American
Legion. It further states that the Department Executive Committee shall define
the powers of the intermediate bodies (district, county, division, etc.) so as not to
invade the prerogatives invested in the post, department or National.
Information was derived from departments over the years on how they utilize
their intermediate organizations and we had several requests to put this
information in the Officer‟s Guide and Manual of Ceremonies.
In summary, the district (county, region or division in some departments
depending on size and desire) commander is the department commander’s link
between department and posts in order to enhance The American Legion
programs. This vital link serves to extend the communications span of the
department commander but does not usurp his/her responsibilities. The district
commander is the liaison between the post and department, but also has the
implied obligation to provide guidance and supervision within the guidelines
established by the department executive committee. The district commander is a
vital communications link between department and posts in conducting The
American Legion programs. The Officer‟s Guide stresses how to organize
committees, conduct meetings and evaluate post programs.
Page 3 of 11
8/09/2010
If you look at other veterans’ service organizations’ (VSOs) life membership
programs you will see they are less expensive for their members to
purchase. For example in one VSO for the age group of 50 to 60 a life
membership is around $400. For the same age group in The American
Legion it is around $700.
When The American Legion Paid Up For Life plan was set up, the actuaries
anticipated that departments and posts would increase their dues only when
national increased the national per capita dues. This has not been the case
inasmuch as the national per capita is increased once every seven years or so
while some posts/departments increase their dues on a more frequent basis.
Therefore, for several years national was required to send more money to
various posts and departments than had been anticipated in the actuarial charts.
This was corrected by the NEC over the course of several years by enacting
resolutions which froze the amount of reimbursement to posts, departments and
national at the level existing when the PUFL was purchased.
Meanwhile, it was discovered that, out of some 225,000 existing PUFLs, about
30,000 were deceased and that fact had not been reported to either the
departments or national by the posts. This was causing some $600,000 a year
to be drained out of the trust.
Additionally, upon close scrutiny, we discovered there were a number of people
(small, yet significant) who had incorrectly stated their age at the time they paid
for the PUFL, thereby skewing the actuarial tables and payment charts.
All of this was corrected in 2009 with an actuarial recalculation of rates, a
requirement that proof of age be submitted, a regular system installed to ensure
that national was apprised of deaths, and a requirement put in place for an
actuarial reassessment every year.
The rates that are currently charged by national are based on your age at
application and the dues currently being paid. It is an accurate rate which will
ensure the trust always has sufficient money to pay the dues to the posts,
departments and national (which were in effect at the time of purchase) and the
individual will not have to pay any additional money after entering the program.
You can be assured The American Legion will never renege on its commitment
to those who have purchased PUFLs, nor will the Legion ever ask current PUFLs
to pay more. The rates will be adjusted from time to time as required to keep the
trust actuarially sound, and persons contemplating the purchase of a PUFL can
Page 4 of 11
8/09/2010
consider the current rate and decide to purchase or not, knowing full well that if
they do the Legion will fulfill its promise.
Some veterans in our community received a certificate of membership
nomination from National Headquarters asking them to join the Legion for
$25.00 by putting a sticker on the acceptance form without showing any
discharge papers. Is this legitimate?
Yes, this is the Direct Membership Solicitation (DMS) program. The DMS
program has been in effect since 1982 in very much the same form as it is now.
The introductory rate is $25. The renewal rate is the same as the headquarters
post rate in the department where they live. The individual must certify their
eligibility on the application they return to national by indicating the dates they
served on active duty, their character of discharge, their branch of service and
their birth date. While occasionally someone has joined who was not eligible,
this has not been a problem. Over 1.6 million members have joined through the
DMS program and less than 500 were found to be ineligible when they went to a
local post to transfer their membership from a headquarters post. It is still a
requirement for the local post to verify eligibility when these members transfer
into the local post.
The DMS program is a highly effective membership tool to augment the
traditional recruiting efforts done by the 14,000 posts in order to reach many of
the eligible veterans who are not members of The American Legion.
Why not include DMS in membership and all award calculations?
Emphasis on our award system is to reward volunteers who do the work. This
argues for just including those members that posts, districts and department
membership teams can influence to join---our traditional members. DMS is
merely a tool to increase membership or replace attrition. DMS members are
procured by national and then offered to departments after their first renewal if
placed in traditional posts. However, these members count towards the
department’s delegate strength for the National Convention.
Why can’t Vietnam-era veterans attend the National Legion College?
The Legion College is designed to mold leaders for the future. Our Vietnam-era
members are typically, already in various leadership positions. The purpose of
Legion College is for the graduates to take what they have learned and train
members in the department because not every member can attend the National
American Legion College.
Criteria to attend the Legion College is toward post-Vietnam veterans as first
priority; however, if the department has one fully qualified candidate (post
Vietnam) they can nominate a Vietnam-era veteran as an additional candidate.
Page 5 of 11
8/09/2010
Several departments have done this and we have had several Vietnam veterans
attend. We don’t like to see any of the 50 seats go unfilled in the annual
program. First priority is a candidate from each department who is a postVietnam veteran and has at least two years in The American Legion. In selection
of candidates, preference should be given to members who have or are holding
leadership roles no higher than district/county level. It serves no purpose to send
a past or current department officer.
This criterion is outlined on the Legion College application form, either in the hard
copy sent to the departments or in the application that is posted on the Legion
Web site. (www.legion.org).
Can National help in funding a local memorial or education center?
There is a long standing policy that the national headquarters will not financially
support memorials, museums or education centers that are not in the greater
Washington, DC, area and federally funded. In addition, they must be supported
by Congress and the National Parks System.
Due to the increasing number of proposed memorials coming to the attention of
the Internal Affairs Commission, it is not possible for The American Legion to
honor all such requests for financial support; therefore, the Commission adopted
the following policy:
The Internal Affairs Commission does not feel it can set aside one memorial for
American Legion financial support from the many requests which are all worthy
and deserving of consideration.
At the same time and in accordance with the Preamble of The American
Legion Constitution, the Commission is mindful of the importance to ...
"Preserve the memories and incidents of our associations in the great wars"
and does not wish to inhibit in any way the construction of those memorials
honoring the veterans of this nation. It is, accordingly, recommended that the
Internal Affairs Commission, as a matter of policy, refrain from recommending
financial support for one memorial at the exclusion of all other memorial
requests. It is also recommended that the Internal Affairs Commission accept
those national memorial requests honoring the veterans of this nation that
have federal approval and to utilize all means available to The American
Legion to encourage The American Legion membership, as well as the
general public, to financially support these worthwhile projects.
The Commission feels that due to the complexities and potential financial
obligations that The American Legion might be faced with in supporting a
particular initiative that there should be an EXCEPTIONAL DEMONSTRATED
NEED for such support with the following accompanying documentation
Page 6 of 11
8/09/2010
attached to the resolution so that the Commission can make a proper
recommendation to the National Executive Committee:
Stated objectives of the Association/Foundation/ Sponsoring Activity
Amount of funds needed to complete the project and a plan for how to
achieve the funds
Plan to sustain and maintain the memorial, monument, education center,
etc.
Copy of incorporation papers
List of the Board Of Directors
A copy of the last audit
A copy of the most recent financial statement(s)
A copy of annual meeting minutes of Board Of Directors, certified by CEO
What is the policy for designating a poem, book, march, or song as
“official” for The American Legion?
Occasionally, resolutions are received seeking to make an original composition
an official American Legion march, song, book, poem, etc. Most of these
creations show great professional competence and reveal a sincere affection for
The American Legion and its principles.
However, the Internal Affairs
Commission does not feel that it has the authority to judge, among many artistic
creations, those which are so superior that they should be designated as official
American Legion marches, songs, poems, etc. Furthermore, a review of the
record found that in 1922 a musical contribution ―Armistice Day Forever‖ by Barry
J. Sick was given the status of official American Legion march by the National
Executive Committee.
There have been numerous occasions since then when musical compositions
have been so honored, but the record also shows that the assignment of the
words ―official‖ to a particular composition by the National Convention or the
National Executive Committee in no way guarantees that the composition will be
used throughout the organization. The Internal Affairs Commission has since
adopted a policy that it would refrain from designating or recognizing any artistic
work as ―official‖ or to recommend the use of any composition by The American
Legion to the exclusion of other compositions.
The Internal Affairs Commission is mindful of the high compliment paid to The
American Legion by its members who use their talents to create artistic works
dedicated to the Legion or intended for the use of the Legion, and we do not wish
to do anything to inhibit the artistic expression that members exhibit for The
American Legion.
When I see how my Congress members vote on veterans’ entitlement
issues, I have a feeling they don’t really care about veterans. When is The
Page 7 of 11
8/09/2010
American Legion going to make their votes public? Why don't you have a
wall of shame for all elected officials who vote against veterans issues?
All votes of members of Congress are public – there are no secret votes;
unfortunately, many veterans’ bills are agreed to under unanimous consent
(voice vote). Another problem is that veterans’ bills are often included in
omnibus legislative packages; that means there are many other provisions not
related to veterans’ benefits or issues that are controversial. A member’s vote
against or for such omnibus bills may not reflect a member’s true position on a
veterans’ benefit or issue.
We have seen other organizations develop scorecards and our feeling in some
cases is that they were inadequate in measuring a member’s support of veterans’
and their families. Frequently, these scorecards are used by politicians to muster
support or opposition in political races. Very few veterans’ benefits or issues are
passed as free-standing bills or by roll call votes that would clearly reflect a
member’s support or opposition.
The fact is that it takes a majority in the House and the Senate to get bills to the
White House. The First Session of the 111th Congress was extremely successful
for the veterans’ community. Congress passed Public Law 111-81 providing
advance appropriations for VA medical care accounts – a top priority for The
American Legion and many other veterans’ service organizations. VA
appropriations for FY 2010 met or exceeded every recommendation made by
The American Legion and were in an omnibus appropriations bill with a number
of other appropriations bills passed under unanimous consent.
The best way to know a lawmaker’s position is to ask them – by letter, phone
call, town hall meeting, etc. Make your judgment based on his or her response to
you. Hold your two Senators and your representative accountable.
On the whole, veterans’ benefits have improved significantly. Rather than a wall
of shame, one could argue that there are many veterans’ champions in
Congress. The American Legion has never been and will never be a single-issue
national wartime veterans’ service organization. For the most part, Congress is
veteran-friendly.
How can I get The American Legion at the local, state and national level to
support a candidate running for Congress from my hometown that
supports veterans’ issues as well as supports a number of important
positions held by The American Legion?
According to Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution of The American Legion,
―The American Legion shall be absolutely nonpolitical and shall not be used for
the dissemination of partisan principles nor for the promotion of the candidacy of
any person seeking public office or preferment.‖ Therefore, we are unable to
Page 8 of 11
8/09/2010
help the candidate; however, you as a private citizen can do whatever is legal
and ethical to advance his/her candidacy.
Why doesn’t The American Legion establish a male auxiliary or allow male
spouses of female veterans to join The Sons of The American Legion?
Female veterans are most certainly welcome in The American Legion and have
been since 1919 and well before women could vote in this nation. Your issue is
with their spouses who have not joined the military.
The Sons of The American Legion was established in 1932 as a program,
comprised of male descendants, adopted sons, and stepsons of members of The
American Legion. Sons of female veterans who are eligible to join The American
Legion are qualified for The Sons of The American Legion. In 1972 and 1973, the
National Executive Committee (NEC) created a National SAL under the full
supervision and control of the NEC with over watch delegated to the Internal
Affairs Commission. The key to eligibility is male lineage of a veteran parent or
grandparent as outlined above.
According to the Veterans Administration there are 1.5 million female veterans.
A study conducted in 2005 by the Defense Department Advisory Committee on
Women in Services states that 81% of male spouses of female veterans have
served in the military. Based on these statistics and adjustments for marriages
after leaving active duty, there could be slightly over 30,000 male spouses of
female veterans who could not join The American Legion based on their own
eligibility. However, a sizeable number of these male spouses could be eligible
for the SAL based on their father, grandfather or step father eligibility for The
American Legion. This estimated population is significantly smaller than 30,000.
The corporate process to make changes starts with a resolution from the post
level where individual thoughts are distilled into a formal recommendation. The
resolution makes its way through department to the National level where it is
reviewed and the Constitutional Amendments or Credentials and Internal Affairs
Convention Committee(s) make(s) their recommendation for a change to the
Legion Constitution to the almost 3,000 National Convention delegates from all
55 departments.
Over the last few years, Internal Affairs has had three resolutions on male
spouses of female veterans (two to join the SAL and one to establish a separate
male auxiliary) that were considered by the various Convention Committees and
all three were rejected.
In all cases they have validated the basic principles that The American Legion
should not establish a male auxiliary or change the lineage for the Sons of The
American Legion. The process as described above has served The American
Page 9 of 11
8/09/2010
Legion well since 1919 where it takes individual thoughts/opinions and by a
systematic procedure turns them into a corporate policy.
What is The American Legion doing about the USS Liberty tragedy?
The tragic mistaken identity attack by Israelis on the USS Liberty on June 8,
1967 provoked a great deal of controversy among surviving members of the crew
and family members. Though residual anger and suspicions remain, the incident
was the subject of ten US investigations and three by the Israelis. In the
American investigations, the full weight of the US Government allowed access to
all of the relevant security information. Though some accusations were made
suggesting the reports sought to hide facts or protect Israel, no credible evidence
for these charges has been produced at the US Government level.
The Foreign Relations Convention Committee of The American Legion reviewed
the action taken by OSD and Congress on this incident and they voted to reject
Resolution 235 submitted by the Department of District of Columbia at the 84th
Annual National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina, August 2002.
What is the status of “on-line” renewals?
An ―On-line‖ renewal system has been successfully tested in five departments.
The National Commander appointed an ad hoc committee to study implementing
in all departments. At the 2010 Spring Meetings, a resolution was approved to
make the required changes to the Constitution and By-Laws at the 92d National
Convention in Milwaukee. At the National Convention, the delegates will vote on
the required constitutional changes in order to implement ―on-line‖ renewals in
June 2011.
As budgets get tighter and Congress looks for “bill payers” and so called
“peace dividends”, we must always fight to maintain the benefits for our
military, our veterans and their families. The history of America's veterans
began in 1636 with the creation of veterans' benefits by the Plymouth
Colony Pilgrims in Massachusetts, who were at war with the Indians.
According to the Pilgrims: "If any man shall be sent forth as a soldier and
shall return maimed, he shall be maintained competently by the colony
during his life."
The American Legion firmly believes that veterans and their families have earned
every benefit awarded to them by a grateful nation because of their selfless
service. Indeed, this basic principle was succinctly written into law when the
Supreme Court stated in 1983:
“It is … not irrational for Congress to decide that, even though it will not subsidize
substantial lobbying by charities generally, it will subsidize lobbying by veterans‟
Page 10 of 11
8/09/2010
organizations. Veterans have „been obliged to drop their own affairs and take up
the burdens of the nation, subjecting themselves to the mental and physical
hazards as well as the economic and family detriments which are peculiar to
military service and which do not exist in normal civil life.‟ Our country has a
long-standing policy of compensating veterans for their past contributions by
providing them numerous advantages. This policy has „always been deemed to
be legitimate.‟” Chief Justice of the United States William H. Rehnquist (5/83)
Page 11 of 11
8/09/2010