Extracted text: Proceedings of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion [September 1932] `

Extracted text: Proceedings of the National Executive Committee of The American Legion [September 1932] ` results

admin
Edited Text
Digest of Minutes
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETINGS
Portland, Oregon
September 11 and September 15, 1932

Digest of Minutes
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETING
Portland, Oregon, September 11, 1932
The pre-Convention meeting of the National Executive Committee of The
American Legion was called to order in the Municipal Auditorium, Portland,
Oregon, on Sunday, September 11, 1932, at 3:20 o'clock in the afternoon,
by the Chairman, National Commander Henry L. Stevens, Jr., National Adjutant
James F. Barton acted as Secretary of the meeting.
The committee stood in silent prayer for one minute in memory of
E . R. Wren, member of the committee representing the Department of Alabama,
who died recently.
Roll Call by the Secretary showed five Past National Commanders, and
three National Vice-Commanders present and thirty-two Departments represented.
Reading of the minutes of the preceding meeting was dispensed with.
NATIONAL FINANCE COMMITTEE
The following report of the National Finance Committee, submitted by
Wilder S. Metcalf, Kansas, Chairman, was adopted*
"The National Finance Committee desires to bring to your notice the
following report of certain dispositions which it has made in regard to the
financial affairs of the National Organization, and to present recommend­
ations which it deems deserving of your attention and approval.
"At its meeting in Indianapolis on May 4, 1932, the National Finance
Committee created a sub-Committee, which consisted of the National Treasurer,
the National Adjutant and the National Judge Advocate, and directed the said
sub-committee to make a thorough survey of the detailed costs of operating
the National Organization, this with a view to promoting and putting into
effect all proper economies and, importantly, to arranging such revision in
the salary schedule of employees as would be appropriate to the state of the
times, to the lower level of compensation that is commonly current, and to
any probable falling off of income that might occur in the near future in the
revenues of the National Organization. In order that such a study of costs
might be of most searching character and of greatest worth to the under
taking, the sub-committee was authorized to engage and employ the services
of competent technical advisors, experienced in the conduct of such cost
studies and in cost analysis directed to economical practice without sacri­
fice of efficiency.
"The work thus directed has been carried forward and has been the
subject of most careful review and consideration by our sub-committee. It
has now been scrutinized and discussed by the entire membership of the Nat­
ional Finance Committee. In respect of pay roll changes, it will interest
you to know that by unanimous decision of our membership, reductions in the
aggregate of $21,984.18 per annum have been adopted, to take effect October
1, 1932. The savings, thus derived, will amount to $5,496.04 during the
last three months of the present calender year.

-2"Certain changes in business administration and internal office
practice under control of the National Officers have also been approved and
will be instituted as soon as they can be suitably accommodated to existing
procedure. From these changes it may be confidently expected that further
substantial savings will ensue.
"There is, however, the possibility of reducing costs to a still
greater extent through the consolidation of certain national committees and
through a well considered co-relation of committee activities where over­
lapping now occurs. This, in our opinion, is a matter that is beyond the
primary jurisdiction of the National Finance Committee since, to some ex­
tent at least, it involves revision of convention actions, or else, as in
some cases, of constitutional requirements. In regard, therefore, to this
phase of our broad program for achieving new and proper economies without
sacrifice of efficiency, it is our recommendation that the National Execu­
tive Committee appoint a sub-committee of three of its members to review
the suggestions that are before us in this regard, and to work out an
orderly procedure by means of which the projects in mind can best be drawn
up, presented and realized in accordance with whatever their acceptable
merit may be found to be. We offer the thought that, in this connection,
you may desire to invite the National Finance Committee to designate one or
two of its members to be additional members of your sub-committee in order
that liaison and cooperation in relation to financial aspects of this under­
taking may be available.
"So much for the general subject of economy.
"Pursuant to the direction of the National Finance Committee at its
last meeting, the National Judge Advocate has established contact with ap­
proximately forty-five surety companies in this country and has outlined to
them a general bonding plan as hereinafter described. The great majority
of the bonding companies have signified their willingness to cooperate.
"The plan as recommended and approved by the Finance Committee is
as follows:
" 'It having come to the attention of the National Finance Committee
that compliance with Section 1 of Article 6 of the By-Laws which requires
that all National, Department and Post officials handling American Legion
money shall be properly bonded with a good and solvent bonding company as
surety thereon, has not been complied with by Posts, except by some and
except as the latter found to be convenient or desirable, and that hereto­
fore the United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company has been designated
as the surety and the bond written by that company approved; that the
United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company has for some years expended
with our hearty appreciation its energies in a campaign of education, but
that it would be advisable to throw this matter open to all surety compa­
nies which will participate under the conditions proposed, writing the
business upon a uniform approved bond; that the conditions to be imposed
upon these companies writing the bond being (l) that the companies will
only contact Posts in Departments where a compulsory bonding plan has not
been adopted; (2) that they will write only the uniform approved bond;
(3) that they will, on October 1 of each year, advise National Headquarters
of bonds v/ritten; (4) that the companies will agree to write the bond for

-3a uniform rate; that the National Adjutant be authorized and directed to
execute agreements with the surety companies in compliance with this plan
and be directed to advise the Departments of the plan and to cause those
Departments in which there is no compulsory plan adopted to advise the
Posts of the plan in detail; that the National Adjutant shall be author­
ized to enter into contracts subsequently with any other companies which
desire to participate under the plan and to cause notice to be given to
the Departments under such conditions as he may deem advisable; that it
is the opinion of the National Finance Committee that such plan will
secure a more complete compliance with the provisions of the By-Laws than
the plan now in force.'
"It is recommended that the National Executive Committee confirm the
National Finance Committee in this expression of the latter's opinion and
that National Headquarters publish and forward to each Department Adjutant
an approved form of bond and a list of the companies which will participate
at the uniform rate.
"This report is submitted with the unanimous approval of the National
Finance Committee.
"Respectfully,
(Signed) Wilder S. Metcalf.
Chairman.”

SUB-COMMITTEE ON THE NEW MEXICO SITUATION
The following report of the special sub-committee appointed by the
National Commander to consider the petition for appeal from the New Mexico
Department was submitted by the Chairman, Forrest G. Cooper, Mississippi,
and adopted after a general discussion:
Your sub-committee has been in session all day and just finished
its report, having heard testimony and giving as full consideration as the
length of time and the seriousness of the question would permit. The
question submitted to us was a petition with a request for revocation or
suspension of the charter of the Department of New Mexico.
"The Sub-Committee on Petition for Appeal from the Department of
New Mexico reports as follows:
"Charge 1: That the constitutionality and regularity of the Depart­
ment Convention of the Department of New Mexico is a matter of legal con­
clusion based on a construction of the constitution of the Department of
New Mexico and of rules of order and procedure and this committee makes
no finding thereon.
"That it is the opinion of this committee that neither the allegations
of Charge 1 nor the proof offered in support thereof warrants the suspension
or revocation of a charter at this time.

-4"Charges 2 and 3 : The allegations of Charges 2 and 3 are not
sufficiently definite or specific to justify suspension or revocation of
charter. The proof offered in support of Charges 2 and 3, while attending
to prove constitutional irregularities in administration and discipline
in some past years, does not relate to incidents of sufficiently recent
date or of such nature as to predicate the conclusion that the incoming
administration will be guilty of breaches of the obligations of the
constitution in the future.
"The sub-committee recommends that the Executive Committee deny
the appeal as presented; that the alleged constitutional violations
complained of be called to the specific attention of the Department of
New Mexico and that the observance of the Legion Constitution by the in­
coming Department of New Mexico be investigated by some representative
of The American Legion to be appointed by the incoming National Commander
and report be made to the meeting of the Executive Committee, to be held
in May, 1933, and that further report be made to the meeting of the
Executive Committee to be held immediately prior to the 1933 National
Convenion of The American Legion.

"Respectfully submitted,
(Signed) Forrest G. Cooper, Chairman
Sidney S. George
W. T. Joyner
H. H. Lark
Sub-committee."
PROPOSED INTERNATIONAL BRIDGE TOURNAMENT
The National Commander was authorized to appoint a special sub-com­
mittee of five members to make an investigation of the proposed International
Bridge Tournament contract entered into by the American Legion Building
Paris, Inc., (Pershing Hall), such committee to submit its report at the
Post-Convention meeting of the National Executive Committee. The members
of the committee appointed were as follows8
Charles A. Mills, Florida, Chairman,
Sam H. Jones, Louisiana.
Dr. W. W. Yates, Wyoming.
Wm. Stern, North Dakota.
J. Monroe Johnson, South Carolina.
NATIONAL EMBLEM RESOLUTION
The following resolution, read by the National Judge Advocate,
Remster A. Bingham, was adopted:
"Whereas, The Emblem Division of The American Legion was established
for the purpose of retaining control of the sale of merchandise involving
the official emblem, to render a service to members, Posts and Departments
of The American Legion, and to provide a revenue for the purpose of carry­
ing on the authorized activities of the National Organization; and

-5"Whereas, Changes in business conditions have made it evident that
certain changes in the present policies of the Emblem Division are advisable
and necessary; be it
"RESOLVED, That there be appointed a National Emblem Committee of
three members, to be selected on the basis of merchandising knowledge and
ability, one to be appointed for one year, one for two years, and one for
three years, and thereafter all subsequent appointments for three years,
starting November 1, 1932, which committee shall be authorized to make a
thorough study of the operation and problems of the Emblem Division and to
prepare and submit to the National. Executive Committee its suggestions or
recommendations dealing with changes and general policy to be followed and
to make such further recommendations to the National Executive Committee
that may be deemed best and advisable in the future."
CHARTERS PRESENTED FOR CANCELLATION
The cancellation of post charters, as recommended by the respective
Departments, was authorized. The list of the posts whose charters were
cancelled follows:
Department

Post Name

Number

Location

Alabama

Barbour County
Community

14
54

Clayton
Lafayette

Delaware

Peninsula

9

Laurel

Illinois

Union Park
Royce V. Wallace
Galatia

656
621
655

Chicago
Chicago
Galatia

Kentucky

Martwick
Benham

154
182

Martwick
Benham

Michigan

Francis E. Dow
Columbiaville
Moquin-Nichols

349
132
340

Detroit
Columbiaville
Reece

Louisiana

Howard Gay
Fortson-Carter

168
169

Zwolle
Greenwood

Maryland

Claude A. McGee
Capitol Heights

9
23

Baltimore
Capitol Heights

Nebraska

Stanley

253

Cortland

New York

Benjamin Franklin, Jr.
F. W. Galbraith

463
999

Ovid
New York City

Oklahoma

John Talley

214

County Line

Chile,
South America

Chuquicamata

1

Chuquicamata

Department

Post Name

Puerto Castilla,
Honduras
Puerto Castilla

Number

Location

2

Puerto Castilla

Alaska

Jack Pierson

7

Juneau

Virginia

Kinley-Supthin
George Washington

62
94

Floyd
Portsmouth

Kansas

Asa Phipps

377

McDonald

Colombia,
South America

Cartagena

2

Cartagena

Ceiba, Honduras

Forgotten Comrade

1

Ceiba

China

Hankow

5

Hankow

The committee adjourned at 4:45 P.

F. b a r t o n ,
National Adjutant.

-7-

Digest of Minutes
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETING
Portland, Oregon, September 15, 1932
The Post-Convention meeting of the National Executive Committee of
The American Legion was called to order at the Municipal Auditorium, Port­
land, Oregon, on Thursday afternoon, September 15, 1932, at 3:05 o'clock,
by Louis A. Johnson, National Commander, National Adjutant James P. Barton
acted as Secretary.
Invocation by the National Chaplain, Rev. Irving Q. Wood.
Roll Call by the Secretary showed two Past National Commanders and
three National Vice-Commanders present, and forty-one Departments represented.
The nomination of the National Adjutant by the National Commander
and the election of a National Treasurer, National Judge Advocate and Nat­
ional Historian, by the National Executive Committee, were postponed until
the regular meeting of the Committee in November.
SUB-COMMITTEE ON INTERNATIONAL BRIDGE TOURNAMENT.
The following report of the sub-committee, authorized at the September
11 meeting of the National Executive Committee, was submitted by the Chairman,
Charles A. Mills, Florida, and unanimously adopted:
"The committee met and had before it report of the sub-committee of
the National Executive Committee at its meeting in 1928 appointed for the
purpose of considering the raising of funds for the American Legion Building,
Paris, Inc. as required on the authority granted that corporation at the
Paris Convention in 1927.
"As a condition precedent to the incorporation of The American Legion
Building, Paris, Inc. your Executive Committee demanded certain changes in
the Articles, and that Plans for Raising of the necessary money outside of
France meet with the approval of the Nat, Ex. Com, The only plan approved
by your Committee for raising funds outside of France was one for the sale
of stock other than through Legion channels.
"It is, therefore, the opinion of the committee that the present
bridge tournament arrangement is in violation of the authority granted for
the purposes of raising funds and that the promoters and beneficiaries of
the bridge tournament are improperly using a name other than the name author­
ized by the Legion and that the proposed plan of raising money by means of
a tournament violates the well-established national policy which forbids
money raising activities without departmental consent.
"It is therefore, recommended by your committee that the Commander,
with the assistance of the Judge Advocate and Adjutant, as diplomatically as
possible and as firmly, require strict conformity with the authority granted
as to raising funds and as to nomenclature of the enterprise.

-8"Further, we commend the position taken by our Commander as being
in strict conformity with the previous action of this body.
"And lastly, we hereby reassure the American Legion Building, Paris,
Inc. that it is our desire to cooperate with it in the final accomplishment
of its aims and in that beautiful and lasting memorial, Pershing Hall.
"Charles A. Mills, Chairman
"William Stern
"J. Monroe Johnson"
PRESENTATION OF PAST NATIONAL ADJUTANT'S BADGE
Past National Commander Henry L. Stevens, Jr., presented a Past Nat­
ional Adjutant's badge to the retiring National Adjutant, James F. Barton.
DATES FOR NOVEMBER MEETINGS
November 14 and 15, 1932, were chosen as the dates for the next
meeting of the National Executive Committee, in Indianapolis. Dates for
the Annual Conference of Department Commanders and Department Adjutants,
at Indianapolis, authorized by the National Convention, were set as
November 16, 17 and 18, 1932.
LETTER OF SYMPATHY
The National Adjutant was directed to communicate with Robert B.
McDougle, member of the National Executive Committee representing the
Department of West Virginia, expressing to him the concern and sympathy
of the members of the Committee over his illness and the desire for his
early return to strength and health.
The Committee adjourned at 3:30 P. M. to meet November 14 and 15,
in Indianapolis.

JAMES F. BARTON,
National Adjutant

'

'

■

V ____