Extracted text: Legislative point papers, 2017 `

Extracted text: Legislative point papers, 2017 ` results

admin
Edited Text
115TH CONGRESS – 1ST SESSION
LEGISLATIVE POINT PAPERS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
MAINTAINING STRENGTH OF THE FORCE AND PROTECTING DEFENSE FUNDING
THE FUTURE OF VA HEALTHCARE
VA APPEALS MODERNIZATION

INSTITUTE GENDER-SPECIFIC HEALTH CARE FOR WOMEN
RECLASSIFY CANNABIS FOR MEDICAL RESEARCH

SUPPORT THOSE WHO CARE FOR WOUNDED VETERANS
PROVIDE MANDATORY END-OF-SERVICE EXAMS FOR GUARD AND RESERVE
REPEAL UNFAIR OFFSETS THAT PENALIZE DISABLED VETERANS AND WIDOWS
DEFEND VETERAN EDUCATION BENEFITS
UNIFORMED SERVICES EMPLOYMENT AND REEMPLOYMENT RIGHTS ACT (USERRA)
CREATE OPPORTUNITIES FOR VETERAN BUSINESS OWNERS
END VETERAN HOMELESSNESS
THE AMERICAN LEGION 100TH ANNIVERSARY COMMEMORATIVE COIN
PROTECT THE AMERICAN FLAG
February 2017

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

MAINTAINING STRENGTH OF THE FORCE AND
PROTECTING DEFENSE FUNDING
The American Legion strongly supports strengthening the U.S. military at this time of war,
in personnel, support services and equipment. The president, leaders at the Pentagon,
and members of Congress must do everything possible to ensure our nation, citizens and
allies are protected.
During the presidential campaign, Donald Trump guaranteed he would increase the U.S.
Armed Forces and furnish necessary tools to protect this nation. The National Defense
Authorization Act of 2017 was signed into law by President Barack Obama on December
23, 2016 supporting an increase in the Active Duty and Army Reserve end strength,
bringing an end to the military’s troop drawdown. Active-Army increased from 475,000 to
476,000; the Air Force Active Duty increased from 317,000 to 321,000; the U.S. Navy
and the Marine Corps increased from 15,500 to 18,500; Army Reserve end strength
increased to 199,000; National Guard increased to 343,000.
The global war on terrorism is far from over. Addressing these challenges to defend the
nation requires strong national defense funding to directly support a new operational
posture in strategic regions, as well as, innovative and enhanced cyber capabilities. 2017
approved appropriations will provide funding stability and protection of vital benefits for
military servicemembers and their families and will facilitate ongoing operations at home
and abroad.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
 The No. 1 task for Congress is to pass the 2017 president’s budget of $582.7
billion in discretionary funds, which complies with the Bipartisan Budget Act of
2015, to fund the Department of Defense.
KEY POINTS
 The FY17 budget reflects recent strategic threats and changes that have taken
place in Asia, the Middle East and Europe.
 Russian Aggression, terrorism by the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL)
and China’s claims of sovereignty in international waters all necessitate
changes in our strategic outlooks and operational commitments.
 Threats and actions originating in Iran and North Korea negatively affect our
interests and our allies.
 These challenges have sharpened the focus of planning and budgeting in
Department of Defense.

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

THE FUTURE OF VA HEALTHCARE
The American Legion supported passage of the Veterans Access, Choice and
Accountability Act of 2014 as a temporary fix to help veterans get the health care they
need, regardless of distance from VA facilities or appointment scheduling pressure. The
Veterans Choice Program was authorized by this emergency legislation for three years
and expires in August of this year, so critical policy choices must be made.
A community care option is now a basic expectation for enrollees in VA’s health care
system. Over the last two years, care delivered in the community has grown from 21
percent to 31 percent today. The American Legion supports moving care into the
community where it makes sense. However, the Choice program is clearly not the future
veterans need or want.
In fact, an internal watchdog at the VA released findings in January confirming what many
veterans and lawmakers already knew: the $10 billion Choice Program created to give
veterans access to private health care has been “cumbersome” and “confusing” to use.
Veterans continually tell us that even with the ability to seek care in the community, they
want VA services. Also, of the more than 1 million veterans who have taken advantage
of the Choice program, only about 5,000 have sought care solely in the community. The
rest used both VA and community services. Additionally, excessive outsourcing would
render the Veterans Health Administration too small to function economically or preserve
quality of care and essentially dismantle it.
Building a 21st century health care system for veterans requires consolidating all of VA’s
authorities for outside care, including Choice, PC3, Project ARCH and others, under one
authority to help veterans only when and where VA cannot meet demand. The American
Legion supports a strong VA that is an integrated system of care that would strengthen
services within VA that are essential for veteran well-being, and would use services in the
community that can serve veterans with better outcomes and greater value to the
taxpayer.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
•
•
•
•

Congress should pass legislation to unify VA’s multiple non-VA care programs
with VA as the coordinator and guarantor of care.
Ensure that non-VA providers are compensated fairly in regions where costs
exceed standard federal payment guidelines.
Ensure VA’s non-VA claims and reimbursement system is automated and using
the latest technology.
Ensure that medical records flow seamlessly within the integrated network of VA
and non-VA providers.

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

VA APPEALS MODERNIZATION
Modernizing VA's archaic appeals process is a top priority for The American Legion.
The current VA appeals process is broken and is providing a frustrating veterans
experience. The status quo isn’t acceptable! Congress must pass appeals
modernization legislation that would provide veterans with a simple, fair, and
transparent appeals process in which the vast majority would receive a final appeals
decision within one year of filing an appeal by 2022. If the current process remains in
place, VA estimates that by 2027 veterans will wait an average of 10 years to hear a
decision on their appeals. We can’t let that happen.
The American Legion currently holds power of attorney on about three quarters of a
million veteran claimants. We spend more than two million dollars a year on veteran
claims and appeals processing and assistance. Our success rate at the BVA hovers at
around 80 percent, either outright grants of benefits or remands to properly process a
claim that VA had failed to properly process at the lower level of the Regional Office.
Just as we did when we worked in partnership with VA to roll out the Fully Developed
Claims process, The American Legion is willing to put in the necessary work to ensure
Appeals Modernization is successful. We recognize the increased burden it can place
on veterans; we also recognize that our approximately 3,000 accredited representatives
have the tools to ensure success for the veterans and claimants we represent.
Throughout the process, we will continue to work with our representatives, our
members, and most importantly, our veterans to understand the changes in law that
would result, and how they will be able to succeed with these changes.
The American Legion urges Congress to pass Appeals Modernization legislation as
soon as possible. Appeals reform legislation passed in the House of Representatives in
late 2016, only to fail in the Senate. This year, Appeals Modernization should be
considered must-pass legislation VA needs in order to put veterans first.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
The American Legion supports the following veterans’ appeals modernization legislative
proposals currently under consideration by Congress:
•

H.R. 457: VA Appeals Modernization Act of 2017 sponsored by Representative
Dina Titus (NV)

Background
The Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA) was established in 1933 to serve as the
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) appellate body for veterans’ claims. In the ensuing
decades since BVA’s establishment, layers of processes and procedures have been
added to VA’s appellate system; these layers have resulted in straining the process and
adding years to have decisions rendered on veterans’ appeals.
The VA’s claims backlog peaked in March 2013, and the Department has maintained a
focus on eliminating the backlog by the end of 2015. To accomplish this goal, VA
regional offices redirected resources from their appeals teams to adjudicate original
claims. Meanwhile, VA was adjudicating original claims at higher rates. With increased
adjudications, it is expected to have proportionally increased appeals.
According to VA, in 2015, there were 1.4 million claims for veterans’ disability claims
processed, and the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) is on track to surpass that
number this year. VA has a static 10-12 percent appeals rate, therefore the workload at
the BVA will likely never disappear. VA’s swelling 500,000 appeals inventory prompted
VA senior leadership to work with Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) to design a
streamlined appeals process. Beginning in March 2015, The American Legion and
representatives from other VSOs engaged in numerous meetings with senior leaders of
the VBA and BVA.
VA Appeals Modernization framework agreed to in those meetings would provide
veterans additional options while maintaining effective date protection back to the initial
claim filing date. In the proposed framework veterans can elect to choose one of three
lanes to have their appeal reviewed. A primary benefit to the reform initiative is
removing a layer of bureaucracy from VA’s appellate process. A positive feature is the
removal of the Notice of Disagreement (NOD), a process that currently takes 409.8
days according to the August 8, 2016 Monday Morning Workload Report (MMWR). 1
VA Appeals Modernization would give veterans clear options after receiving an initial
decision on their claim by consolidating the current appeals process into three distinct
lanes.
 The first lane is the Local Higher-Level Review Lane (Difference of Opinion). This
option will provide the opportunity for a quick early resolution of the issue(s) in
dispute at the Agency of Original Jurisdiction (AOJ) level to have an original
decision reviewed at the Regional Office (RO) through a Difference of Opinion
before appealing to the Board, or submitting new evidence in a supplemental
claim. This option would also endure an additional quality check on claims
decisions within the VBA.
 The second lane is the New Evidence (Supplemental Claim) Lane. This lane will
allow veterans, who have received an initial decision on their claim, to submit
new evidence. This lane would serve as a good option for veterans who believe
1

VBA Monday Morning Workload Report:(August 8, 2016)

2

they can succeed on their claim by providing additional evidence for review by a
Regional Office adjudicator. VA’s goal would be to consider new evidence and
issue a new decision within 125 days of receiving a supplemental claim.
 The third lane is the Board Review (Appeal) Lane. This lane provides the
opportunity for veterans to appeal directly to the Board while bypassing the
layers of appellate review currently found in the RO process. Veterans would
have the ability to choose between two options for review at the Board. The first
option would be a non-hearing where veterans receive an expedited review with
no new evidence submitted. The second option would allow veterans to either
have a board hearing and submit evidence or, alternatively, submit evidence
without a hearing.
Reforming a process as complex as the disability claims system is not simple, and not
every aspect of appeals reform is able to be legislated. Some parts are more nuanced
and require the attention of all stakeholders. The American Legion urges VA to address
all claims, to include its growing inventory of appeals in an expeditious and accurate
manner, and that VA create no program that diminishes a veteran’s due process rights. 2
VA has drafted the proposed legislative language required to implement the new
framework.
The American Legion through congressional testimony at House Veterans’ Affairs
Committee (HVAC) and Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee (SVAC) legislative
hearings supported VA Appeals Modernization.
The American Legion National Commander, Charles E. Schmidt has stated: We expect
both parties to work together responsibly to pass legislation which includes a simple and
fair appeals process that provides veterans and their families their earned benefits in a
timely manner.

2

American Legion Resolution No. 5: (Sept. 2016): Department of Veterans Affairs Appeals Process

3

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

INSTITUTE GENDER-SPECIFIC HEALTH CARE FOR WOMEN
Women veterans are the fastest growing demographic population serving in the U.S.
military. Since 2000, women veterans receiving VA health care from VA has doubled
from 159,000 to 337,000 and these numbers are projected to increase due to the
increasing numbers of women veterans in the military that will be eligible for VA health
care once they leave the military.
Women veterans face remarkably different experiences than their male counterparts
when they transition out of the military. While VA has made significant advancements in
women veterans health care throughout the VA health care system, there is still room
for improvements. We want every woman veteran who walks through the doors of a VA
medical facility to feel the facility was designed with them in mind and no longer has the
looks of a “For Male” only facility. As a result of the growth in the number of women
veterans in September 2016, The American Legion passed Resolution 14, entitled
Women Veterans, which calls for the VA to ensure that all women veterans receive
gender-specific quality health care.
In 2013, The American Legion System Worth Saving Task Force turned their attention
to women veterans’ health care and identified a number of challenges women veterans
face when receiving VA health care to include: 1
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Many women veterans do not identify themselves as veterans.
Many women veterans do not know or understand what benefits they are entitled
to receive.
VA medical facilities across the system do not have adequate baseline plans to
close the gender gaps and improve use of facilities and services for women.
Additional research is needed to determine the purpose, goals, and effectiveness
of three VA women models of care on overall outreach, communication and
coordination of women veterans health services.
Many VA facilities do not offer inpatient/residential mental health care programs
for women veterans.
Many VA facilities do not offer child care services for women veterans seeking
health care appointments.
The time it takes for women veterans to receive results from their mammogram
screening.

Today, most of these challenges still exist for our nation’s women veterans. On
September 29, 2016, the 114th Congress passed Public Law 114-228, Department of
1

American Legion System Worth Saving Report on Women Veterans Health Care (2013)

Veterans Affairs Expiring Authorities Act of 2015. Section 105 extended the pilot
program on assistance for child care for certain veterans receiving VA health care
through December 2017. Child Care continues to be a significant challenge for younger
veterans. The American Legion urges Congress to pass legislation to provide child care
services to veterans with children in order for the veteran to receive access to the
quality care that they have earned. 2

2

American Legion Resolution No. 43 (Sept. 2016): Department of Veterans Affairs Child Care Program

2

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

DEVELOP ALTERNATIVE HELP FOR VETERANS
STRUGGLING WITH MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES AND BRAIN
INJURIES TO INCLUDE RECLASSIFY CANNABIS FOR
MEDICAL RESEARCH
The American Legion is deeply concerned about the increased numbers of veterans
who are returning home, from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, suffering from
Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI) and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). These
inquiries which have often been referred to as the “signature wounds” of the War on
Terrorism if not properly recognized and treated, can detrimentally impact a veteran’s
ability to readjust back into civilian life. To ensure these veterans were being properly
cared for at the Departments of Defense (DOD) and Veterans Affairs (VA) medical
facilities, in 2010, The American Legion established a TBI and PTSD Committee for the
purpose of investigating the existing science and medical procedures as well as
researching alternative methods for treating veterans who suffer from TBI and PTSD.
Studies have shown that medical cannabis is a viable option for treating pain,
inflammation, autoimmune diseases, as well as other illnesses. However, The American
Legion believes additional research is needed to determine if there are medical benefits
from using medical cannabis as an appropriate treatment for veterans who are suffering
from a traumatic brain injury or post traumatic stress disorder. However, one barrier that
must be overcome is reclassifying medical cannabis, remove cannabis from schedule I
and reclassify it in a category that at a minimum will recognize cannabis as a drug with
potential medical value. Schedule I drugs include Heroin, Lysergic acid diethylamide
(LSD), Marijuana, Mescaline, Ecstasy, Acid, Psilocybin, Methaqualone, Khat, and Bath
Salts and are considered to have no medical benefits. By excluding cannabis from
schedule I, it would become more readily available to researchers and scientists for the
purpose of scientific research for its therapeutic value. Therefore, The American Legion
supports increased research into cannabis as treatment and therapy. 1
Additionally, The American Legion urges Congress to pass legislation that would
expand and improve the care provided to veterans and servicemembers who have
mental health issues or who are at risk for suicide. 2.
Furthermore, The American Legion urges Congress to increase the budgets of DOD
and VA to improve the research, screening, diagnosis, and treatment of TBI/PTSD as
well as provide oversight over DOD/VA to develop a joint office for collaboration
between DOD/VA research. The American Legion urges Congress to exercise
1
2

Resolution No. 11: Medical Marijuana Research
Resolution No. 292: Traumatic Brain Injury and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Programs

oversight over DOD/VA to ensure servicemembers and veterans are only prescribed
evidence-based treatments for TBI/PTSD and not prescribed off-label and non-Federal
Drug Administration approved medications or treatments for TBI/PTSD. 3
Lastly, The American Legion urges Congress to provide oversight and funding to the VA
for innovative, evidence-based, complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in
treating various illnesses and disabilities and to pass legislation that would improve the
pain management policies of the DOD and VA.
The American Legion believes that all health care possibilities should be considered
and explored in an attempt to find treatments, therapies, and cures for TBI and PTSD
that are based on individual veteran needs. Healthcare, as well, should include
alternative medical treatments and therapies. These treatments need to be accessible
to all veterans; and if alternative treatments and therapies are deemed to be effective
they should be made available and integrated into veterans current health care models
of care.

3

2

Ibid

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

SUPPORT THOSE WHO CARE FOR WOUNDED VETERANS
The American Legion is a membership organization founded on the common bond of
wartime service during any active U.S. period of war. As such, The American Legion
has always advocated on the principle of equal benefits for equal service.
The Caregivers and Veterans Omnibus Health Services Act of 2010 (Public Law 111163) amended Title 38, United States Code, to provide assistance to caregivers of
veterans and improve the provision of health care to veterans. The law created two
distinct caregiver support programs which provided a stipend to caregivers of Operation
Enduring Freedom (OEF) and Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF) veterans, however;
caregivers of veterans from previous eras were excluded.
The American Legion by Resolution 146 passed at the 2016 National Convention
supports the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) expanding caregiver benefits to all
eligible enrolled veterans, regardless of when they served. Caregiver benefits should
not be limited to only post- 9/11 veterans.
The American Legion believes it is time veterans from all eras receive the same benefits
for their service. The family members who have cared for veterans in other eras are no
less deserving of caregivers assistance than those of the post- 911 veterans.
Key Points:
•
•
•

There are 5.5 million caregivers who are caring for veterans, but are not eligible
for any assistance from the VA.
Caregivers suffer higher rates of depression and health problems than others.
Veterans from different eras and theaters of operations are receiving different
levels of VA benefits based solely on their dates and locations of service, rather
than their honorable service.

WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
•
•

1

Pass legislation that would authorize VA to provide Caregivers benefits to all
eligible veterans, regardless of the dates or theaters of operations during their
military service and for,
Congress should review current legislation and public laws to ensure that
veterans benefits are provided equitably and consistently for all veterans. 1

American Legion Resolution No.146 (Sept. 1, 2016): Veterans Receive Same Level of Benefits

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

PROVIDE MANDATORY END-OF-SERVICE EXAMS FOR
GUARD AND RESERVE
National Security Resolution No. 85, entitled Support for Military Quality of Life Standards
mandated, in part, asks that The American Legion urge Congress and the Department of
Defense to support and fund quality of life features including “requiring the Services
perform mandatory physical examinations, without waivers, for all separating and retiring
servicemembers within 90 days of separation from service”.
Last Congress, Representative Mike Coffman (CO) introduced H.R. 4251, the Guard and
Reserve Equal Access to Health Act, to amend title 10, United States Code, to ensure
that the Secretary of Defense affords each member of a reserve component of the Armed
Forces with the opportunity for a physical examination before the member separates from
the Armed Forces. Specifically, that bill directed the Secretary of the military department
concerned to provide a physical examination to each member of a reserve component
who: (1) will not otherwise receive one through that department, and (2) elects to receive
such examination. Further, it required the Secretary to: (1) provide such examination
during the 90-day period before such member's scheduled date of separation, and (2)
provide such member with a record of the examination.
However, while active component servicemembers must undergo a separation physical
examination (it may be waived if an examination had been undergone within the last year
of service, but servicemembers retiring from active service are required to have an
examination), this same right to an end-of-service physical examination is not mandated
for reserve component servicemembers. This policy of unfair treatment must be
corrected. A reserve component servicemember must have an initial physical
examination to show they are fit for duty. Thus, it is only right that when they return to
civilian life they undergo an end-of-service physical examination to have an assessment
of their health condition, determine if any existing medical condition arose during their
time of service, and have the documentation of the state of their health provided to them
at the end of their military career.
Legislation to allow end-of-service exams is important for many reasons. It is a Military
Quality of Life Standards matter and the current double standard of health care end-ofservice physical examinations between active and reserve component service members
must end. Reserve component servicemembers face the same risks and make the same
sacrifices as those on active duty. They should have the right to an end-of-service
physical examination that documents the state of their health at the end of their military
career and have the medical documentation, if needed, for their VA earned benefits.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
• Congress can reintroduce legislation that was from the 114th Congress entitled the
Guard and Reserve Equal Access to Health Act.
3/27/2018

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

REPEAL UNFAIR OFFSETS THAT PENALIZE
DISABLED VETERANS AND WIDOWS
DISABLED VETERANS TAX
Background:
The Disabled Veterans’ Tax (also known as concurrent receipt) references the
practice which bars certain retired veterans from receiving both their full military
retired pay and their full service-connected disability compensation benefit pay.
Prior to the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) of 2004, all veterans who
received disability compensation from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)
would have their military retired pay reduced by an ”offset”, preventing these
retired warriors from receiving their full retired pay as earned by their military
service. With the passage of that law, a phased progression was put in place to
work downwards from 100 percent service-disabled veterans to 50 percent
service-disabled veterans to allow the more severely disabled veterans to receive
both their earned benefits in full. This phase-in provides for the addition of levels
of disabilities at a rate of approximately 10 percent per year and was fully
implemented in 2014.
The American Legion worked hard for this law.
However, The American Legion will not rest until Retirement pay and disability
all of our retired, service-disabled warriors compensation are two entirely
receive both of the benefits they earned due to different benefits created for
two distinct and different
their selfless sacrifice and duty to our nation. reasons.
Today, our federal government still takes money
away from veterans receiving 40 percent or lower rates of service-connected
disability compensation (VA service-connected disability compensation is divided
into rates at 10 percent intervals: 0 percent, 10 percent, 20 percent, etc.) and the
financial discrimination against these retired warriors of ‘offsetting’ their military
retired pay against their service-connected disability compensation dollar-fordollar must end!
The American Legion calls this unfair practice by our federal government the
”Disabled Veterans’ Tax”, and we adamantly oppose this unfair ‘tax’ on our
wounded, injured, and ill retired veterans who suffered their disabilities because
of their military service to this country.
In addition, those servicemembers medically retired without 20 years of service
(Chapter 61 retirees) have never been included in relief from this offset, as the
phased offset is intended only for 20-year military retirees.

Let us be clear. Military retired pay is compensation for longevity of honorable
military service. VA service-connected disability compensation is payment for
medical conditions incurred or aggravated while on active duty. These two
earned benefits to a retired veteran are thus made for two very distinct and very
different reasons.
Disabled Veterans Tax bills in the 115th Congress:
On January 5, 2017, Representative Gus Bilirakis (FL) introduced H.R. 303, the
Retired Pay Restoration Act, to amend title 10, United States Code, to permit
additional retired members of the Armed Forces who have a service-connected
disability to receive both disability compensation from the Department of
Veterans Affairs for their service-connected disability and their retired pay by
reason of their years of military service or Combat-Related Special
Compensation. His bill currently has fourteen cosponsors.
On January 5, 2017, Representative Sanford Bishop (GA) introduced H. R. 333,
the Disabled Veterans Tax Termination Act, which amends federal military retired
pay provisions to: (1) permit veterans with a service-connected disability of less
than 50 percent to receive concurrent payment of both retired pay and veterans’
disability compensation and (2) extend eligibility for concurrent receipt to chapter
61 disability retirees with less than 20 years of retirement-creditable service. His
bill currently has six cosponsors.
On January 9, 2017, Senator Dean Heller (NV) introduced S. 66, the Retired Pay
Restoration Act, to permit certain retired members of the uniformed services who
have a service-connected disability to receive compensation from the
Department of Veterans Affairs and either retired pay by reason of their years of
military service or Combat-Related Special Compensation. His bill currently has
two cosponsors.
All bills are assigned to their respective Armed Services Committees for action.
Legion Position:
The American Legion’s support for full Concurrent Receipt is based upon
Resolution No. 224 and support also comes from Resolution 85, which
supports our mandate for Military Quality of Life Standards. It is essential The
American Legion continue to make the case for fairness and equity for our
nation’s warriors. In this case, retired pay and disability compensation are two
entirely different types of earned benefit payments and our federal government
must not discriminate against these retired warriors by taking their money away
from them.
Currently in law, a veteran may receive, in part or in full, other federal and nonfederal benefits, in addition to VA service-connected disability compensation. For
example, a veteran can receive service-connected disability compensation--without offsets, reductions, or limits---with:
•
•

Unemployment Compensation;
Social Security;

•
•
•
•
•

Federal Civil Service pay;
Private sector job pay;
Federal civil service retirement (including disability retirement);
Retirement pension from non-federal employment; and,
Federal workers compensation (benefits for work-caused disability or
illness provided under FECA).

Thus, in part, The American Legion position is
simply that because veterans can earn income
from all those other sources listed above
without offset, as a matter of law and public
policy, as well as fairness, then serviceconnected disabled retired veterans must be able to earn their military retired pay
without it being offset as well.
Military retirees are the only
federal employees who must
offset their retired pay with their
VA disability compensation.

Equitable economic justice is one reason to end the Disabled Veterans’ Tax.
Military retirees are the ONLY federal employees who must offset their retired
pay with their VA service-connected disability compensation. Another more
important reason to end this discriminatory practice, and The American Legion
believes must be argued, is that, in the interests of our national security and
given the unique nature of military service with its sacrifices and hardships, our
nation must respect those military retirees, who served twenty or more years of
their life in uniform and suffered because of that service. These warriors became
wounded, ill, or injured during their military service, their disabilities are
recognized by our government, and they must receive both benefits because a
grateful nation respects their long term, selfless service and sacrifice for this
country.
VA service-connected disability compensation is awarded for physical and
mental disabilities incurred or aggravated while in military service. These
disabilities cannot be equated with disabilities incurred in civilian life. Military
service rendered in defense, and on behalf, of the Nation deserves special
consideration in determining public policy toward benefit offsets. It is a moral and
ethical responsibility to award equitable treatment to these veterans, given their
sacrifices and hardships incurred during their honorable military service.
The American Legion urges Congress to complete the repeal of the prohibition
on receiving the earned payments from both these programs.

WIDOW’S TAX
Under current federal law, if the surviving spouse of a military retiree is eligible to
receive the monthly Survivor Benefit Program (SBP) annuity payment and is also
awarded a monthly Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC) benefit by
the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), the SBP annuity is offset, dollar-fordollar, by the amount of DIC received. This offset is commonly referred to as the
“Military Widows’ Tax”. The American Legion believes this offset is an injustice to
surviving spouses of America’s heroes. Our support for this legislation is
mandated by Resolution 85.

Retired servicemembers are eligible to participate in the SBP. SBP is an optional
annuity insurance plan designed to pay an eligible surviving spouse a monthly
payment to help make up for the loss of military retirement income. Those
military retirees who choose to enroll in SBP have deductions made from their
military retired pay to purchase their survivor’s annuity. Under the plan, upon the
military retiree’s death, the annuity is paid monthly to eligible beneficiaries.
Among the earned benefits awarded by VA to service-connected disabled
veterans and their survivors is the DIC program. DIC is an earned benefit
awarded monthly to the eligible surviving spouse of a service-connected disabled
veteran by a grateful nation. DIC is a tax-free benefit (like service-connected
disability compensation) for the surviving spouse and dependent children. VA
also adds a transitional benefit of $250 to the surviving spouse's monthly DIC if
there are children under age 18. The amount is based on a family unit, not
individual children. It is paid for two years from the date that entitlement to DIC
commences, but is discontinued earlier when there is no child under age 18 or no
child on the surviving spouse's DIC for any reason.
Clearly, SBP is first a personal financial decision made by a military retiree to
provide a degree of financial security for the surviving military spouse; whereas,
DIC is an earned benefit awarded for a veteran’s death due to a serviceconnected medical condition. The American Legion believes the VA indemnity
compensation should be added to the SBP that the military retiree paid for with
personal funds, and not be subject to the dollar-for-dollar offset.
SBP and DIC are two distinct and independent programs with unique eligibility
criteria. SBP is optional for military retirees and mandates personal financial
contributions from that individual retiree, whereas DIC is awarded only to
survivors of service-connected disabled veterans.
Widow’s Tax bills in the 115th Congress:
On February 7, 2017, Senator Bill Nelson introduced S. 339, a bill to amend title
10, United States Code, to repeal the requirement for reduction of survivor
annuities under the Survivor Benefit Plan for military surviving spouses to offset
the receipt of veterans dependency and indemnity compensation, and for other
purposes. His bill has one cosponsor.
Legion Position:
The American Legion wants to repeal the requirement for reduction of survivor
annuities under the Survivor Benefit Plan by veterans' dependency and indemnity
compensation.

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

DEFEND VETERAN EDUCATION BENEFITS
The American Legion has fought to provide post-service career opportunities for
veterans since its formation. The original GI Bill, passed in 1944, provided rights,
education benefits and loans for homes, businesses and farms. That investment fueled
America’s rise to an economic superpower over the last 70 years. The Post-9/11 GI Bill,
also championed by The American Legion, updated those benefits for 21st century
student-veterans and career seekers. While we continue to work to preserve and
improve this important benefit, we must not forget about thousands of young veterans
and servicemembers who have had their GI Bill benefits either withheld or wasted at
institutions that had sudden shutdowns.
RESTORE ENTITLEMENTS TO RESERVISTS DENIED GI BILL CREDIT
The American Legion was troubled to learn that many reservists and Guard members
have been excluded from accruing Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits while on two types of
active duty orders, and believes these servicemember should have their benefits retroactively awarded:
12304b was added at the request of DOD to provide service secretaries with the
authority to involuntarily activate state reserve components to support preplanned missions without requiring POTUS approval. 4,915 reservists have
been activated under 12304b between 2012 and 2016.
12301(h) authorizes the Secretary of Defense to order a member of a reserve
component to active duty to receive authorized medical care, to be medically
evaluated for disability, or complete a required DOD health care study. In 2014
the DOD Reserve Forces Policy Board (RFPB) advised that Congress change
the law regarding the definition of active duty to include this order. 19,647
reservists were placed on 12301(h) orders from 2007 to 2013, with an estimated
additional 7,000 to be placed on those orders from 2014 through 2020.
The reason for the failure:
Section 3301(1)(B) of Title 38 defines the term “active duty” for the purposes of
educational benefits, and does not include 12304b or 12301(h):
The term “active duty” has the meanings as follows (subject to the limitations
specified in sections 3002(6) and 3311(b)): In the case of members of the
reserve components of the Armed Forces, service on active duty under a call or

order to active duty under section 688, 12301(a), 12301(d), 12301(g), 12302, or
12304 of title 10or section 712 of title 14.
Solution:
Amend Section 3301(1)(B) of title 38, United States Code, to include “12304b” and
“12301(h)”, thereby qualifying these orders as “active duty”.
Reference: Resolution No. 349 (Sept. 2016): Support Legislation to Improve the Post9/11 GI Bill
PROTECT VETERANS AFFECTED BY SCHOOL CLOSURES
Veterans, and military family members are too often singled out and targeted for
recruitment by unscrupulous institutions eager to take advantage of their GI Bill. The
result of this targeting can have a devastating impact. This past year, ITT Technical
Institute abruptly shut down all 130 of its campuses, affecting over 40,000 students
expecting to attend the fall semester. Unlike their civilian counterparts using federal
student aid, there are no statutory or regulatory provisions that provide relief to nearly
7,000 veterans who used GI Bill educational assistance benefits to attend the
institution. The American Legion believes these veterans should not be held responsible
for institutional malfeasance. Additionally, with uncertainty surrounding the status of the
accrediting institution ACICS (American Council on Independent Colleges and Schools)
the risk of sudden school closures remains high.
To further protect veterans and military families from attending schools at risk of sudden
closure, Congress must oppose weakening the:
Gainful Employment Rule, which enforces the Higher Education Act’s
requirement that career education programs receiving federal student aid must
“prepare students for gainful employment in a recognized occupation for career
education programs.
Ban on Incentive Compensation, which was enacted with broad bipartisan
support to reduce high-pressure, deceptive sales tactics. Sales commissions
incentivize college recruiter to “do anything and say anything” to get veterans to
enroll. In 2015, the Education Department’s Inspector General called for greater
oversight and enforcement of the ban to prevent fraud and abuse.
The Enforcement Unit at the Education Department, which is taking steps to
protect all students from any illegal conduct by colleges.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?:
The American Legion urges Congress to reintroduce the provisions of the “Protecting
Our Veterans From School Closures Act” (H.R. 6003-114th Congress).
2

The “Protecting Our Veterans From School Closures Act” restores veterans’ GI Bill
educational benefits to any veterans who are using their benefits at an educational
institution that closes, preventing them from completing their degree. The bill would
apply to all veterans who were enrolled at ITT Tech at the time it closed.
Reference:
Resolution No. 21 (Oct. 2016): Education Benefit Forgiveness and Relief for Displaced
Student-Veterans
Resolution No. 327 (Sept. 2016): Support Further Assessment and Evaluation of
Institutions of Higher Learning to Enable Veterans to Make Informed Education Choices

3

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

UNIFORMED SERVICES EMPLOYMENT AND
REEMPLOYMENT RIGHTS ACT (USERRA)
The Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act (USERRA) of 1994,
38 United States Code (U.S.C.) §§ 4301-4334, was signed into law on October 13, 1994.
USERRA prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of an individual’s: prior
service in the uniformed services; current obligations as a member of the uniformed
services; or, intent to join the uniformed services. USERRA also provides reemployment
rights with the pre-service employer following qualifying service in the uniformed services.
In general, the protected person is to be reemployed with the status, seniority, and rate
of pay as if continuously employed during the period of service. USERRA applies to
private employers, the Federal Government, and state and local governments. It applies
to United States employers operating overseas as well.
Over 14 years of war has caused record high deployment rates of citizen soldiers, who
have the responsibility of maintaining civilian employment while waiting for the call to
serve their country. Many who already struggle daily to balance their dual military and
civilian lives, have returned home from deployment only to find that same contract of
balance was not upheld by their employers. Servicemembers should not come home from
a military leave of absence to find they have no job or that their seniority has been taken
from them. An individual should never be forced to choose between serving in the
National Guard or Reserve, and keeping their civilian employment.
A recent case involved a Navy Reservist who claimed that his civilian employer fired him
because he was deployed to Afghanistan, which is a violation of USERRA. However, the
servicemember lost his case because it was noted that the veteran signed a preemployment arbitration agreement (contract) which prohibited him from suing his former
employer. The American Legion strongly supports legislation that will strengthen
USERRA to alleviate any ambiguities that will strip servicemembers of the ability to sue
employers by an arbitration agreement.
We are deeply concerned with the protection of the servicemember and the prevention of
the servicemember not being reemployed by their previous employer after deployment(s).
With the rising numbers of USERRA cases across the country, they have become more
complex than in the past and frequently involve multiple issues. This is due to longer and
more frequent deployments of National Guard and Reserve members. In FY 2014, the
Department of Labor’s Veterans’ Employment and Training Service (VETS) staff closed
1,140 USERRA complaints, and in FY 2015, VETS staff closed 1,223 USERRA
complaints, recovering lost wages and benefits from servicemembers who are called to

active-duty to serve and protect their country. In FY 2015, Military Obligation
Discrimination complaints were at 39.6 percent. This is extremely concerning.
Section 4311(a) of USERRA states:
"A person who is a member of, applies to be a member of, performs, has performed,
applies to perform, or has an obligation to perform service in the uniformed services shall
not be denied initial employment, reemployment, retention in employment, promotion, or
any benefit of employment by an employer on the basis of that membership, application
for membership, performance of service, application for service, or obligation."
Section 4311(c) of USERRA further states:
"An employer may not discriminate in employment against or take any adverse
employment action against any person because such person has taken an action to
enforce a protection afforded any person under this chapter, has testified or otherwise
made a statement in or in connection with any proceeding under this chapter, has assisted
or otherwise participated in an investigation under this chapter, or has exercised a right
provided for in this chapter."
In conclusion, millions of service members depend on USERRA protection while they are
called to serve their country. USERRA was created to prohibit discrimination against and
eliminate the disadvantages faced by deployed servicemembers. Again, The American
Legion recommends strengthening the enforcement of USERRA. There needs to be
effective consequences for non-compliance or proactive regulation of this Act to ensure
that veterans are not disadvantaged or unable to return to their previous jobs, due to their
honorable service to our Nation.
Reference:
Resolution No. 315 (Sept. 2016): Support Employment and Reemployment Rights of
National Guard and Reservist Returning from Deployment

2

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

CREATE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
VETERAN BUSINESS OWNERS
With the drawdown of our armed forces, more servicemembers are now becoming
veterans. Equipped with the skills and mental attitude to enter the civilian workforce, many
veterans are opening small businesses, which is not only good for them, but also for other
veterans and the American economy. Trends show that veterans are likely to hire other
veterans because they know the true value of the skills that veterans receive while serving
their country.
The first step to opening a small business is having access to capital. Many aspiring
business owners resort to obtaining investors or they risk using their personal funds.
However, in the 114th Congress S.1870: VET Act of 2016 was introduced in Congress,
if passed it would create a three year pilot program that would allow veterans and
servicemembers to turn their G.I. Bill education benefits into financial capital to start a
Veteran-Owned Small Business. The program would allow up to 250 veterans eligible for
GI Bill benefits who apply to the program to start a new business or purchase an existing
business or franchise. This is a grand idea that very well may allow veterans to determine
their future, take control of their benefits, lower the veteran unemployment rate and
furnish veterans with a sense of self all while providing for their families and stimulating
the economy.
In addition, some veteran-owned small businesses compete for federal contracts,
meaning they focus on providing services to the U.S. government. One way The
American Legion is serving veterans is by encouraging the reintroduction, passage, and
implementation of a piece of legislation from the last Congress (H.R. 1694: Fairness to
Veterans for Infrastructure Investment Act) that gives our veterans access to
transportation and infrastructure contracts. This measure calls for states that receive
federal money for transportation projects to include veteran-owned businesses in their
contracting processes. Creating parity for veterans in the federal contracting process is
vital for veteran-owned small businesses. It assists them in obtaining contracts; which
also benefits the U.S. government.
The American Legion supports both of the above measures. Reintroducing, and ultimately
passing S. 1870 would create a pilot program that would establish a way for service
members and veterans to utilize their education benefits to better suit their business
desires. Reintroducing and passing H.R. 1694 would create parity for veterans within the
federal contracting process. Both of these measures stand to better our nation’s heroes
all while benefiting the economy.
Reference: Resolution No 339: (Sept. 2016): Support Reasonable Set-Aside of Federal
Procurements and Contracts for Business Owned and Operated by Veterans
Resolution No. 303: (Sept. 2016): Expanding Post-9/11 GI Bill for Entrepreneurship
3/27/2018

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

END VETERAN HOMELESSNESS
In 2010, then-VA Secretary Eric Shinseki pledged to devote resources necessary to end
veteran homelessness by the end of 2015. Although this robust goal was not met – there
has been progress in combating veteran homelessness. Former VA Secretary Robert
McDonald stated that eliminating veteran homelessness – functional zero nationwide –
was still a top priority for the Department. VA has worked closely with Congress to provide
resources in affordable housing and supportive services programs to help more veterans
and their families. According to the Department of Housing and Urban Development
(HUD) there were fewer than 40,000 homeless veterans (or 9 percent of homeless adults)
on a single night in January 2016. Two thirds of homeless veterans (67 percent or 26,404
veterans) were staying in emergency shelters, transitional housing programs, or safe
havens, while a third (33 percent or 13,067 veterans) were found in places not suitable to
human habitation. Veteran homelessness dropped by 47 percent, or nearly 35,000
people, between 2010 and 2016. Between 2015 and 2016 alone the number of homeless
veterans dropped by 8,000 people (or 17 percent).
A full continuum of care — housing, employment training and placement, healthcare,
substance abuse treatment, legal aid, and follow-up case management — depends on
many organizations working together to provide services and adequate funding. The
availability of homeless veteran services, and continued community and government
support for them, depends on vigilant advocacy and public education efforts on the local,
state, and federal levels. The complexity of issues affecting all homeless veterans (the
extreme shortage of affordable housing, livable income, and access to healthcare), as
well as the fact that a large number of displaced and at-risk veterans live with the effects
of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), substance abuse, and a lack of family and
social support networks mandates VA must, in order to meet its commitments, have
additional resources.
As 2017 begins, The American Legion believes programs dedicated to battling veteran
homelessness should continue to be funded even beyond the 2015 goal. This is because
even if cities and/or states are successful in achieving a “functional zero” of homeless
veterans, veteran homelessness is often a temporary circumstance. If a functional zero
is achieved, the focus should shift to ensuring that those veterans who become homeless
are able to be quickly transitioned from homelessness to economic stability, including
stable housing and meaningful employment. These programs are a necessary means to
ensure that we, as a nation, are able to retain a functional zero in veteran homelessness.

3/27/2018

WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
The American Legion recommends funding for a broad range of appropriate and effective
interventions, including:
•

Congress must appropriate funds ($300 million) and permanently re-authorize the
Supportive Services for Veteran Families program (SSVF). SSVF funds have been
used effectively by community organizations to prevent many veterans from
becoming homeless, and to quickly re-house veterans who need nothing more
than short-term rental assistance and limited case management in order to get
back on their feet. SSVF funds can also be used to pay for employment services,
utility assistance, child care costs, and other housing-related expenses.

•

Congress must continue support for VA's Grant and Per Diem (GPD) Program.
This critical program provides short-term housing help to homeless veterans,
allowing them to get connected with jobs, supportive services, more permanent
housing, and ultimately to become self-sufficient. Promising new models for using
grant and per diem funds, including allowing veterans to remain in their GPD
housing unit once support from the program ends and new programs focused on
women veterans, are helping to ensure that GPD continues to meet the ever
changing needs of returning veterans and their families.

•

Congress must increase appropriations for Homeless Veterans Reintegration
Program (HVRP) to $50 million, the program's authorized level since 2005, and
continue fully funding the program through the foreseeable future.

•

Congress must provide funding for dental care and legal services for homeless
veterans.

The American Legion continues to lead communities by volunteering, fundraising, and
advocating for programs and resources to help homeless veterans. In addition, The
American Legion directly provides housing for homeless veterans and their families,
including facilities in Connecticut and Pennsylvania. One of the goals of The American
Legion is to help bring federal agencies, nonprofit organizations, faith-based institutions
and other stakeholders to the table to discuss best practices, along with funding
opportunities, so homeless veterans and their families can obtain the necessary care and
help to properly transition from the streets and shelters to gainful employment and
independent living.
Over the span of seven years, veteran homelessness has fallen 46 percent, with 33,896
fewer homeless veterans in 2016 than in 2009. This decline includes both large
decreases in the number of veterans found in unsheltered locations (16,891 fewer
veterans), and in veterans experiencing homelessness in shelters and transitional
housing projects (17,005 fewer veterans). Still, despite this good news, there remains
work to be done in order to ensure that our homeless veterans are cared for.
Reference:
Resolution No. 324 (Sept. 2016): Support Funding for Homeless Veterans
2

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

THE AMERICAN LEGION 100TH ANNIVERSARY
COMMEMORATIVE COIN
To celebrate 100 years of humanitarian and patriotic service, The American Legion is
working with the United States Mint and the U.S. Congress to produce limited-edition,
exquisitely crafted commemorative coins. Authorized by Congress, commemorative
coins celebrate and honor American people, places, events, and institutions. Each coin
is crafted to be rich in symbolic history. They represent not only an investment in
maintaining our American past, but also in ensuring our nation’s future.
Unique among U.S. Mint products, these coins help raise money for important causes
as well as commemorating important aspects of American history. These products not
only provide beautiful additions to any coin collection, they capture the American
culture. Proceeds from the sale of the coins would support the programs and services
offered under the four pillars of our organization.
It goes without saying that The American Legion, the nation’s largest wartime veterans
organization, warrants such recognition.
The American Legion will begin its centennial recognition at the 100th National
Convention in Minneapolis, site of the 1st American Legion National Convention, in
August 2018. In March 2019, the organization will celebrate its 100th birthday in Paris,
and Sept.16, 2019, will mark the 100th anniversary of The American Legion’s federal
charter.
If authorized by Congress, coins minted would be issued only during the 1-year period
beginning on January 1, 2019.
Legislative staff is working with congressional offices on bill language. Please note,
commemorative coin bills require cosponsorship by two-thirds of the members in both
the House and Senate.
WHAT CAN CONGRESS DO?
Please ask your Members of Congress to sign on as cosponsors when the bills have
been introduced.

The American Legion Legislative Point Paper

PROTECT THE AMERICAN FLAG
“The Congress shall have power to prohibit the physical desecration of the flag of the
United States.” A proposed amendment to the United States Constitution; which The
American Legion fully supports.
Background
The U.S. Supreme Court’s 1989 decision in Texas v. Johnson held that the physical
desecration of Old Glory was “protected speech.” In this case, the Court struck down
existing flag desecration laws in 48 states and the District of Columbia. The American
Legion believes the Court misinterpreted the Constitution by calling flag desecration
“speech” and that this imprudent decision overturned a century of American law and
tradition. Acts of physical desecration are conduct, not speech. Accordingly, these acts
should not be recognized and protected as “speech” by the First Amendment. President
Abraham Lincoln once remarked, “… If the policy of the government on vital questions
affecting the whole people is to be irrevocably fixed
President Abraham Lincoln
by decisions of the Supreme Court the people will
once remarked, “… If the policy
have ceased to be their own rulers….” The
of the government on vital
American people intend to return flag protection
questions affecting the whole
authority to Congress where it belongs and not
people is to be irrevocably fixed
allow the Supreme Court to have the final say.
by decisions of the Supreme
Court the people will have
The American Legion believes the final say should
ceased to be their own
be with the People, as expressed through the
rulers….”
Congress and the 50 state legislatures. All 50 state
legislatures have passed memorializing resolutions asking Congress to pass this
proposed amendment and send it to the states for ratification. The proposed
amendment returns the power to protect Old Glory to the People. This is the true
essence of the amendment and why it must prevail.
House Actions
In the first session of the 115th Congress, Representative Steve Womack (AR)
reintroduced House Joint Resolution (H.J. Res.) 61, a proposed constitutional
amendment supported by The American Legion and the Citizens Flag Alliance (CFA).
The resolution was referred to the Committee on the Judiciary at introduction on
February 2, 2017.

The Judiciary Committee chairman is Rep. Bob Goodlatte (VA) and the chairman of the
Constitution and Civil Justice Subcommittee is Rep. Trent Franks (AZ). Both are known
supporters of the proposed constitutional amendment. Nevertheless, even with
supportive committee leadership in the last several Congresses, no hearings were held
and the amendment never came up for a vote.
There are currently 23 cosponsors of the bill. Please ask your representative to sign on
as a cosponsor, if they have not already done so.
Senate Actions
No companion bill has been introduced yet in the Senate. Legislative staff is actively
seeking a Senate sponsor for this measure. If your Senator is interested in being the
lead sponsor of this bill, please contact the Legislative staff.
The Judiciary Committee is chaired by Senator Chuck Grassley (IA), and the chairman
of the Constitution Subcommittee is Sen. Ted Cruz (TX).
Discussion
The American Legion strongly believes the flag is a symbol of our nation’s freedom and
all that we hold in common as Americans, secured by the servicemen and women who
sacrificed so much for all citizens. That is why The American Legion continues to urge
Congress to approve an amendment to the U.S. Constitution that would allow the
Congress to prohibit the physical desecration of the American flag, our nation’s
enduring symbol of unity and freedom.
The civic purpose of our constitutional freedom of speech in a democratic republic is to
enable the political discussion necessary for a self-governing citizenry to remain free
and united. The political deliberative purpose of our freedom of speech is why it must
include the freedom to criticize current officials but not necessarily the right to attack a
symbol of national unity. The nature of a republic’s deliberations presupposes the
existence of a “common good” -- a metaphorical table around which to discuss. We are
supposed to be deliberating how to achieve that good, but that we are constituted to
achieve that good is a settled question and is not up for debate apart from revolution or
constitutional amendment. Our nation’s flag is a symbol of that common good. To burn
that flag is like overturning the common table.
Our belief is not to silence those who protest perceived injustices. Americans have
every right to voice their views in respectful ways. Rather than fearing such a
constitutional amendment, Members of Congress concerned about supporting the
amendment should embrace it. The proposed flag protection amendment is no
infringement on the Bill of Rights; instead, it restores the traditional meaning of the First
Amendment and is a wonderful exercise in the popular sovereignty the Bill of Rights
was designed to protect.

2