Extracted text: [Statement of Steve Robertson before the House Committee on Veterans' Affairs on Report of the President's Task Force to Improve Health Care Delivery for Our Nation's Veterans, June 17, 2003] `

Extracted text: [Statement of Steve Robertson before the House Committee on Veterans' Affairs on Report of the President's Task Force to Improve Health Care Delivery for Our Nation's Veterans, June 17, 2003] ` results

admin
Edited Text
STATEMENT OF
STEVE ROBERTSON, DIRECTOR
NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
THE AMERICAN LEGION
BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS’ AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
REPORT OF THE PRESIDENT’S TASK FORCE TO IMPROVE HEALTH CARE
DELIVERY FOR OUR NATION’S VETERANS
JUNE 17, 2003
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, The American Legion would like to take this
opportunity to publicly thank the Commission Members of the President’s Task Force (PTF) for
their time, energy, effort, and cooperation throughout this process. I would also be remiss if I
failed to applaud the PTF’s professional staff for an exceptional performance. From the very
first day, the professional staff established an unprecedented working relationship with the entire
veterans’ community. Although not recognized in the Report’s bibliography, attached to this
testimony are samples of the material provided to the PTF’s professional staff by The American
Legion. All material was readily accepted, but closely scrutinized by Commission Members.
This included information gathered during a visit with the Indian Health Services in
Albuquerque, NM to learn more about their successful billing and collection practices of thirdparty insurers, to include Medicare and Medicaid. Although Members of the PTF made two
separate trips to Albuquerque to visit the New Mexico VA Health Care System and 377th Air
Force Medical Group, Kirtland AFB, New Mexico, they never visited the Indian Health Services
located just blocks away.
The American Legion continues to work closely with the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA),
the Department of Defense (DOD), and Congress towards a mutual goal – meeting the needs of
America’s veterans and their families. Although this is a shared objective, each seems to have its
own “road map” for achieving that vision. Frequently, compromise is reached and life is made
just a little better for veterans and their families, but unfortunately there is still rough terrain to
traverse to improve health care delivery for the Nation’s veterans.
Executive Order 13214’s mandates were clear:
• Identify ways to improve benefits and services for the Department of Veterans Affairs
beneficiaries and Department of Defense military retirees who are also eligible for benefits
from the Department of Veterans Affairs through better coordination of the activities of the
two Departments;
• Review barriers and challenges that impede Department of Veterans Affairs and
Department of Defense coordination, including budgetary processes, timely billing, cost
accounting, information technology, and reimbursement. Identify opportunities to improve
such business practices to ensure high-quality and cost-effective health care; and
• Identify opportunities for improved resource utilization through partnership between the
Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense to maximize the use of

resources and infrastructure, including buildings, information technology and data sharing
systems, procurement of supplies, equipment and services, and delivery of care.
Clearly, The American Legion embraces these mandates. Long before President Bush created
this bold initiative, The American Legion developed an internal task force with a simple mandate
– design an integrated health care delivery system to meet the needs of all veterans and their
families.
G.I. Bill of Health
Over a decade ago, The American Legion offered its blueprint for VA in the 21st Century called
the G.I. Bill of Health. The vision was to create a national integrated veterans’ health care
network accessible by all veterans and their dependents, including military retirees and their
eligible family members. This bold plan called for Congress, beneficiaries, and third-party
insurance providers to meet their respective fiscal obligations.
Federal Government Pays Only One Veterans’ Health Care Delivery System
The first step called for enrollment of all beneficiaries seeking enrollment in the Veterans Health
Administration (VHA). Enrollment would provide the VA Secretary with a quantified and
defined patient population. Once enrolled, each beneficiary would identify how his or her health
care coverage would be paid. If a beneficiary was eligible for full health care coverage paid for
by just the Federal government (Medicare-eligible, 100 percent service-connected disabled
veteran or military retiree), Congress would appropriate funds to cover that cost. However, if the
beneficiary was eligible for full health care coverage paid by several Federal agencies (a
Medicare-eligible, 100 percent service-connected disabled veteran, and a military retiree),
Congress would make only one payment; however, the beneficiary would seek health care only
within VHA unless referred to the private sector for care. Medicare-eligible veterans choosing
this option would be authorized to seek health care only from within VHA medical facilities
(Medicare+Choice model).
Third-Party Reimbursements Contribute to the Costs
Those beneficiaries choosing to enroll, with private or public health benefit coverage, would
identify their third-party insurance provider and would agree to meet all co-payments and
deductibles described by their policy. Should the third-party insurer refuse to make
reimbursements to VA for the treatment of nonservice-connected medical conditions, the
beneficiary would be denied enrollment.
Uninsured Beneficiaries have Affordable Options
For those beneficiaries choosing to enroll with no health benefit coverage, VA would be
authorized to offer affordable health benefit packages to meet their individual health care needs.
The Secretary would establish the premiums for each health benefit package and could waiver
premiums on a case-by-case basis.

2

For those beneficiaries identified in title 38, United States Code (USC), for the VA Secretary to
provide care, Congress would appropriate funds to cover the cost of the required health benefit
coverage necessary, based on their individual health care needs. For those beneficiaries
identified by the DOD Secretary to receive care, Congress would appropriate funds to cover the
cost of the required health benefit coverage necessary, based on their individual health care
needs. For those Medicare-eligible beneficiaries, Congress would appropriate funds to cover the
cost of the required health benefit coverage necessary, based on their individual health care
needs. All other beneficiaries would be responsible for meeting their health care needs through
co-payments, deductibles, premiums, or third-party reimbursements from public or private
insurance providers. All revenue streams (Federal appropriations, co-payments, deductibles,
premiums, and third-party reimbursements) would go to a Veterans Health Trust Fund, similar to
the Social Security and Medicare Trust Funds.
TRICARE
At the time as The American Legion was developing its G.I. Bill of Health, DOD’s military
health care system was experiencing tremendous problems in meeting its commitment to its
beneficiaries, especially its large military retirement community. The cost of providing health
care to all of its beneficiaries grew tremendously which forced many of its patients to “game” the
system in order to receive timely access to health care.
Shared Cost of Health Care
DOD’s solution was the creation of TRICARE – a unique quasi-governmental health care
network consisting of the military health care system and private contractors. Under TRICARE,
active-duty service members and their eligible beneficiaries receive health care coverage paid for
by DOD; however, all other beneficiaries have four health care options to choose from that also
require out-of-pocket costs:
• TRICARE Standard (fee-for-service – co-payments and deductibles)
• TRICARE Extra (preferred provider organization – co-payments and deductibles)
• TRICARE Prime (health maintenance organization – enrollment fee and co-payments)
• TRICARE for Life (Medicare+Choice option – must have Part B coverage and stay within
the system)
President’s Task Force To Improve Health Care Delivery For Our Nation’s
Veterans
The PTF’s challenge was clear from the very beginning. Although VA and DOD are committed
to the timely delivery of quality health care, each health care network is truly distinctive in its
leadership structure, operational mandates, information technologies, procurement systems, and
are equally committed to meeting their unique missions. Nearly all of the witnesses testifying
before the PTF from the veterans’ community shared the same key message point – maintain
each health care delivery system as an independent entity – don’t try to consolidate into one
Federal health care delivery network. All Commission Members unanimously agreed to the
following recommendations, with the exception of Recommendation 5.3.

3

Introduction and Background
Recommendation 1.1: The interagency leadership committee should, on an annual basis,
report to the Secretaries on the status of implementing its collaboration and sharing initiatives
and the recommendations in this Final Report, together with any other matters that the
committee deems appropriate. Within 60 days after receipt, the Secretaries shall transmit the
report, together with any related comments, to the President.
The American Legion sees merit to this recommendation. Suggested collaboration and sharing
initiatives should be formally recognized and monitored for desired results. However, those
recommendations not accomplished should also be recognized and monitored to determine the
obstacles prohibiting collaboration and sharing initiatives.
The Need for Leadership, Collaboration, and Oversight
Recommendation 2.1: Congress should amend the fiscal year 2003 National Defense
Authorization Act to create a broader charter beyond health care for the interagency leadership
committee. Additionally, consideration should be given to using civilian experts as consultants
to the committee to bring in new perspectives regarding collaboration and sharing.
The American Legion strongly agrees with the first part of this recommendation calling for a
broader charter. This Committee and the Committee on Armed Services should provide timely
oversight to monitor the focused commitment and leadership to achieve effective collaboration
and sharing. The American Legion noted greater collaboration and sharing at the joint
operations hosted by VA rather than DOD. With current discussion of another round of base
closings, there well may be opportunities for collaboration and sharing initiatives, especially if
DOD decides to close yet more Military Treatment Facilities (MTFs).
The American Legion disagrees with the second part of this recommendation to hire civilian
experts as consultants to the committee. Both agencies employ resourceful, professional health
care administrators. Given encouragement and motivation by the senior leadership to unleash
their creative juices, these current employees will produce positive results.
Recommendation 2.2: The Departments should consistently utilize a joint strategic planning
and budgeting process for collaboration and sharing to institutionalize the development of joint
objectives, strategies, and best practices, also with accountability for outcome.
The American Legion agrees with this recommendation. By placing this requirement in
performance standards for each Department’s strategic planners and budgeters, this would also
demonstrate the commitment of senior leadership. More importantly, successful collaboration
and sharing initiatives should be rewarded both publicly and professionally.
Recommendation 2.3: The Departments should jointly develop metrics (with indicated
accountability) that measure health care outcomes related to access, quality, and cost as well as
progress toward objectives for collaboration, sharing and desired outcomes. In the annual
report recommended in Recommendation 1.1, the interagency leadership committee should
include these results and discuss the coming year’s goals.
4

The American Legion strongly supports this “scorecard” management style. Accountability is
key to the successful measure of desired outcomes. Again, senior leadership’s focus on
collaboration and sharing initiatives will generate attention at every level.
Providing a Seamless Transition to Veteran Status
Recommendation 3.1: VA and DOD should develop and deploy by fiscal year 2005 electronic
medical records that are interoperable, bi-directional, and standards-based.
The American Legion fully supports this recommendation and recognizes the importance of
electronic medical records, especially for veterans with service-connected disabled medical
conditions. The electronic medical records should also be accessible for those in the Reserve
components. A service member going from active-duty to the National Guard or Reserves
should not close one set of medical records and open another set with no connectivity until
collected and consolidated by VA.
Having access to a patient’s entire medical record is extremely important and helpful to health
care professions, especially in large integrated health care systems like VA and DOD. In today’s
military, a veteran may have several forms of medical records. It is not uncommon for a service
member to become a military dependent upon discharge from active duty; however, seldom will
the active-duty military medical record be consolidated with the military dependent’s medical
record, because a military family member is filed under the active-duty service members social
security number. This situation is further aggravated if the military family member enlists into
the National Guard or Reserves, the military dependent’s medical record and prior service
medical records are not consolidated with the Reserve component’s medical records. Electronic
medical records should make consolidation easier.
When a veteran enrolls in VA for health care or files a disability claim, consolidating a veteran’s
total military medical record is extremely important. The faster this consolidation occurs, the
faster quality health care can be provided or a disability claim can be adjudicated.
Recommendation 3.2: The Administration should direct HHS to declare the two Departments
to be a single health care system for purposes of implementing HIPAA regulations.
The American Legion supports this recommendation.
Recommendation 3.3: The Departments should implement by fiscal year 2005 a mandatory
single separation physical as a prerequisite of promptly completing the military separation
process. Upon separation, DOD should transmit an electronic DD214 to VA.
The American Legion supports a mandatory single separation physical and the transfer of an
electronic DD Form 214 to VA. The mandatory single separation physical established an
important health care baseline. This is extremely important, especially when dealing with
medical conditions that may manifest over a period of time.

5

The DD Form 214 is the “passkey” to every VA benefit because it establishes eligibility of
veteran’s status. Providing VA with an electronic version of the DD Form 214 will help ease the
transition.
Recommendation 3.4: VA and DOD should expand the one-stop shopping process to facilitate
a more effective seamless transition to veteran status. This process would provide, at a
minimum: 1) a standard discharge examination suitable to document conditions that might
indicate a compensable condition; 2) full outreach; 3) claimant counseling; and 4) when
appropriate, referral for a Compensation and Pension examination and follow-up claims
adjudication and rating.
Clearly, The American Legion and other veterans’ and military service organizations can play an
important role in this effort. The American Legion and other veterans’ service organizations
have well-trained service officers around the country to assist veterans, free of charge, in filing
disability claims with VA and other claims assistance.
Recommendation 3.5: VA and DOD should expand their collaboration in order to identify,
collect, and maintain the specific data needed by both Departments to recognize, treat, and
prevent illness and injury resulting from occupational exposures and hazards experienced while
serving in the Armed Forces; and to conduct epidemiological studies to understand the
consequences of such events
The American Legion supports this recommendation. Over the years, The American Legion has
lobbied Congress, VA, and DOD on such exposure issues as Agent Orange, radiation, and Gulf
War Illness. Each and every time, DOD’s and VA’s medical record-keeping shortfalls hampered
timely access to quality health care and just compensation of service-connected medical
disabilities.
Recommendation 3.6: By fiscal year 2004, VA and DOD should initiate a process for routine
sharing of each service member’s assignment history, location, occupational exposure, and
injuries information.
The American Legion supports this recommendation and believes this is not a technological, but
rather a philosophical barrier. There appears to be a reluctance by DOD to fully cooperate with
VA in providing much of this information, because of its sensitivity. The American Legion
believes declassified information could be developed to meet this recommendation without
compromising classified information. Exact locations can be vague, but the fact a veteran was
within an area exposed to high levels of radiation or contamination. This information would
provide valuable information to a claims adjudicator without revealing the veteran’s exact
physical location, mission, or other classified data. With senior leadership’s focus and support,
this recommendation is achievable.
Recommendation 3.7: The Departments should: 1) add an ex officio member from VA to the
Armed Forces Epidemiological Board and to the DOD Safety and Occupational Health
Committee; 2) implement continuous health surveillance and research programs to identify the
long-term health consequences of military service in high-risk occupations, settings, or events;

6

and 3) jointly issue an annual report on Force Health Protection, and make it available to the
public.
The American Legion supports this recommendation.
Removing Barriers to Collaboration
Recommendation 4.1: The Secretaries of Veterans Affairs and Defense should revise their
health care organization structures in order to provide more effective and coordinated
management of their individual health care systems, enhance overall health care outcomes, and
improve the structural congruence between the two Departments.
The American Legion agrees with this recommendation. Currently, VA has 21 Veterans
Integrated Service Networks (VISNs), while TRICARE consists of three regions. The American
Legion suggests VA reevaluate its current decentralized organizational structure and consider
reducing the number of VISNs.
In addition, VA should also reevaluate the current Veterans Equitable Resource Allocation
(VERA) formula for the distributions of annual appropriations. One area of great concern is the
failure to account for all enrolled veterans rather than excluding Priority Groups 7 and 8, even if
they are noncompensable, service-connected disabled veterans. If they are enrolled, then they
are patients and should be treated as such in the consideration of fiscal distributions.
Another area of concern is ending VERA at the VISN level rather than the facility level. The
distribution of resources is formula based to the VERA director – from that point on, it is purely
subjective. The American Legion believes that the factors used in determining the VERA
allocation to the VISN should also apply to the further distribution to the local medical facility.
Finally, all third-party reimbursements should be retained by the medical facility providing the
service, not redistributed to other medical facilities within or outside the VISN.
Recommendation 4.2: The Secretaries of Veterans Affairs and Defense, based on the
recommendations of the interagency leadership committee, should provide significantly
enhanced authority, accountability, and incentives to health care managers at the local and
regional levels in order to enhance standardized and collaborative activities that improve health
care delivery and control costs.
The American Legion supports this recommendation.
Recommendation 4.3: VA and DOD should integrate clinical pharmacy initiatives through the
coordinated development of: 1) a national joint core formulary; and 2) a single, common clinical
data screening tool by fiscal year 2005 that ensures reliable, electronic access to complete
pharmaceutical profiles for VA/DOD dual users across both systems.
The American Legion supports this recommendation and strongly encourages collaboration and
sharing initiatives with all 7 VA Consolidated Mail Outpatient Pharmacies (CMOP) sites. In

7

fact, The American Legion advocates increasing the number of CMOP sites across the Nation
should increased demands exceed the current ability to deliver prescriptions in a timely manner.
Recommendation 4.4: VA and DOD should collaborate on policy and program changes,
through local sharing arrangements, which would permit prescriptions written by either VA or
MTF providers to be filled for dual users by the other Department’s pharmacies.
The American Legion supports this recommendation and would consider expanding this
authority to any Federal health care provider, including Indian Health Services.
Recommendation 4.5: VA and DOD should work with industry to establish a uniform
methodology for medical supplies and equipment identification and standardization and to
facilitate additional joint contracting initiatives. VA and DOD should identify opportunities for
joint acquisitions in all areas of products and services.
The American Legion supports this recommendation.
Recommendation 4.6: The interagency leadership committee should identify those functional
areas where the Departments have similar information requirements so that they can work
together to reengineer business processes and information technology in order to enhance
interoperability and efficiency.
The American Legion fully advocates this recommendation.
Recommendation 4.7: VA and DOD should implement facility lifecycles management practices
on an enterprise-wide basis. This should be accomplished by aligning business rules,
eliminating statutory barriers, and adopting best practices.
The American Legion supports this recommendation.
Recommendation 4.8: VA and DOD should declare that joint ventures are integral to the
standard operations of both Departments. Through the interagency leadership committee, the
Departments should articulate policy requiring that: 1) all major initiatives of each Department
be designed and tested for effectiveness and suitability in joint venture sites; 2) lessons learned
from successful joint ventures be shared with other joint venture sites and also throughout the
health care delivery systems of the two Departments; and 3) all proposed VA and DOD facility
construction within a geographic area be evaluated as a potential joint venture.
The American Legion fully supports this recommendation, especially with renewed talks
regarding another round of base closures. Before any future MTF is selected for closure, join
venture operations should be explored.
With increased dependence on Reserve components, VA and DOD should evaluate possible
collaboration and sharing initiatives for meeting the health care needs of National Guard and
Reserve personnel. Serious consideration should also be given to the establishment of more
Reserve component billets for health care professionals.

8

Recommendation 4.9: VA and DOD should work together to identify and address staffing
shortfalls, develop consistent clinical scopes of practices for non-physician providers, and
ensure that their provider credentialing systems interface with each other.
The American Legion supports this recommendation with special emphasis being placed on
recruiting, educating, credentialing and hiring recently separated active-duty service members,
especially those with service-connected medical disabilities. Both agencies should also consider
recruiting, educating, credentialing and hiring members of the National Guard and Reserve.
Veterans make great employees because they are certifiably drug-free, possess a good work
ethic, understand teamwork, are trainable to standards, and understand the military life style.
Another window-of-opportunity is the recruitment of health care specialists, faced with
extremely high malpractice insurance premium, to join VA and DOD professional staff. Many
highly qualified health care specialist, especially neurosurgeons, ob-gyns, emergency physicians,
orthopedic surgeons, and general surgeons. For an example, the average annual cost of medicalliability premium for a neurosurgeon is approximately $71,200, but in Chicago, it is $283,000
and in Philadelphia, it is $267,000. This represents a 35.6 percent increase from 2001 to 2002.
According to the American Medical Association, seven hospital obstetrics units have closed and
six medical centers no longer perform mammographies, just in Florida. In Pennsylvania, over
900 doctors have either closed practices, limited their services, or left the state since 2001. In
Nevada, more than 30 ob-gyns have closed their practices. In Tacoma, Washington, have of the
ob-gyns won’t deliver babies. This medical-malpractice crisis in 18 states (NY, CT, NJ, PA,
WV, OH, KY, NC, GA, FL, IL, MO, AR, MS, TX, NV, OR, and WA) offers a unique
opportunity for recruit by both VA and DOD for specialists.
Timely Access to Health Services and the Mismatch Between Demand and Funding
The American Legion believes this is the most salient and challenging issue addressed by the
PTF. Clearly, The American Legion strongly believes timely access to quality health care is a
moral, ethical, and legal obligation of any health care delivery system. Preventive medicine has
demonstrated its life-saving benefits, not to mention the economical impact as well.
For years, The American Legion watched the national rationing of VA health care through a
complex and complicated maze of rules, regulations, and policies governing who would receive
health care in what setting under which conditions. The American Legion advocated a dramatic
shift from a hospital-based to a managed-care health care system. Finally, Congress stopped the
madness with enactment of the Veterans’ Health Care Eligibility Reform Act of 1996 (Public
Law 104-262). The vision called for opening enrollment in VHA to any eligible veteran seeking
access to quality health care, within existing appropriations. The idea was to receive copayments and third-party reimbursements for the treatment of nonservice-connected medical
conditions to help supplement VA’s discretionary appropriations. Unfortunately, the largest
single identified health insurance program (Medicare) is exempt from reimbursing VA for the
treatment of Medicare-eligible veterans’ nonservice-connected medical conditions.
Secondly, many private health insurance providers failed to recognize VA as a medical care
provider and refused to reimburse VA for treating their policyholders. Others effectively
9

challenged VA’s billing and collection practices, then denied payments. VA’s Medical Care
Collection Fund (MCCF) had far more excuses than solutions to their billing and collection
process. In fact, their collection rate was well below acceptable industry standards. A major
contributing factor was VA’s inability to collect from Medicare. In order to collect from
Medicare supplemental insurance providers, VA had to bill Medicare, as though VA could
collect, to reflect the amount due from the supplemental insurers.
Although VA medical care receives discretionary appropriations, those appropriations are offset
by the amount of third-party collections Congress determines achievable. VA’s billing and
collection process has improved dramatically in recent years; however, it will never realize its
true potential until it can collect from its largest customer – the Centers for Medicare and
Medicaid Services (CMS).
Medicare-eligibility is not a factor in determining eligibility to enroll in either VA, Indian Health
Services, or DOD’s TRICARE, yet TRICARE providers do receive Medicare reimbursements
and DOD serves as the supplemental insurer. Indian Health Services is authorized to bill and
collect from CMS for the treatment of both Medicare-eligible and Medicaid-eligible
beneficiaries. Both health care systems receive annual discretionary appropriations, just like
VA. All three health care systems have eligible criteria that do not mention eligibility in any
CMS program.
Recommendation 5.1: The Federal Government should provide full funding to ensure that
enrolled veterans in Priority Groups 1 through 7 are provided the current comprehensive benefit
in accordance with VA’s established access standards. Full funding should occur through
modifications to the current budget and appropriations process, by using a mandatory funding
mechanism, or by some other changes in the process that achieve the desired goal.
The American Legion fully supports designating VA medical care as mandatory funding. The
American Legion defines “full funding” or “guaranteed funding” as mandatory funding.
Mandatory funding does not require any modifications to the current budget or appropriations
process. The American Legion believes mandatory funding represents the ongoing cost of
freedom.
Recommendation 5.2: VA facilities should be held accountable to meet the VA’s access
standards for enrolled Priority Groups 1 through 7. In instances where an appointment cannot
be offered within the access standards, VA should be required to arrange for care with a non-VA
provider, unless the veteran elects to wait for an available appointment within VA.
The American Legion fully supports this recommendation. The American Legion believes this is
VA’s moral, ethical, and legal obligation to its beneficiaries. No veteran should ever die, waiting
for a medical appointment more than 30 days.
Since the PTF was tasked with “improving health care delivery between VA and DOD,” The
American Legion would strongly recommend that veterans be referred to TRICARE health care
providers rather than non-VA providers as recommended in the Report of the Congressional
Commission on Servicemembers and Veterans Transition Assistance in 1999, as Issue III.F
– Increase VA use of DOD’s TRICARE for Selected VA Medical Services. Since many VA
10

enrollees are also TRICARE-eligible, this would enhance collaboration and sharing of scarce
resources.
Recommendation 5.3: The present uncertain access status and funding of Priority Group 8
veterans is unacceptable. Individual veterans have not known from year to year if they will be
granted access to VA care. The President and Congress should work together to solve this
problem.
The American Legion adamantly opposes this recommendation and views it as absolutely
unconscionable! Veterans are taught to leave nobody behind on the battlefield – The American
Legion believes that this same philosophy should be carried into the VA health care system.
Veterans are in this together – not as individuals.
Dissenting Commission Members to this recommendation – the only dissent in the entire report –
offered suggestions based on allowing Priority Group 8 veterans to enroll and receive timely
access to quality VA health care. While Recommendations 5.1 and 5.2 direct Congress to
provide adequate funding to cover the cost of health care for Priority Groups 1 through 7, some
Commission Members offered an alternative that allows Priority Group 8 veterans choose from
one of three health benefits just like TRICARE:
• All enrolled Priority Group 8 veterans would be required to identify their public/private
health insurers.
This is similar to an initiative in the President’s budget request for FY 2004.
•

VA would be authorized as a Medicare provider for Priority Group 8 veterans and be
permitted to bill, collect and retain all or some defined portion of third-party
reimbursements from CMS for the treatment of non-service-connected medical conditions.

Just like participating private physicians are doing under TRICARE for Life.
•

VA should be authorized to offer a premium-based health insurance policy to any enrolled
Priority Group 8 veteran with no public/private health insurance.

Just like CMS does for Medicare.
•

All enrolled Priority Group 8 veterans would be required to make co-payments for the
treatment of non-service connected medical conditions and prescriptions.

Just like they are currently doing.
•

All enrolled Priority Group 8 veterans with no public/private health insurance would agree
to make co-payments and pay reasonable charges for treatment of non-service connected
medical conditions.

Just like in the private sector.

11

Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, the vast majority of the veterans’ population falls
into Priority Group 8, yet the majority of the PTF voted against providing a substantive
recommendation regarding Priority Group 8 veterans’ eligibility for VA health care. They even
described Priority Group 8 veterans as “those veterans without compensable service-connected
conditions whose incomes are above a geographically-adjusted means test” as though that makes
them different from any other veteran. In reality, the only difference between some Priority
Group 7 and Priority Group 8 is their zip code.
A veteran is a veteran. There are Priority Group 1 veterans that never left the shores of the
United States, yet there are Priority Group 8 veterans that served in theaters of armed conflicts.
How the majority of the PTF Commission could leave so many members of the “Greatest
Generation,” the “Forgotten War,” Vietnam War, the Persian Gulf War, and Bosnia “standing on
the doorsteps” of VA without a single recommendation is irresponsible and a tremendous
disappointment to the veterans’ community.
The recommendations of the dissenting Commission members are fiscally responsible and, if
enacted, should be scored as budget neutral. If a private sector health care provider were to treat
them for nonservice-connected medical conditions, the Priority Group 8 veterans would be asked
to comply with these same guidelines offered in the dissenting remarks, so why should VA hold
them to the same requirements for treatment?
By not making any recommendations for Priority Group 8, the PTF sends a message to all
Priority Group 8 veterans – to be granted timely access to VA health care -- consider other
alternatives to qualify:
• Become financially destitute and qualify as a Priority Group 5 veteran.
• Become catastrophically disabled and qualify as a Priority Group 4 veteran.
• Move to a compatible HUD geographically indexed area and qualify as a Priority Group 7
veteran.
These are veterans of the armed forces being denied enrollment and timely access to quality
health care in the VA integrated health care network even if they have a means to pay for their
medical treatment. Some how The American Legion does not believe this represents the “thanks
of a grateful Nation.”
In the military upon successful conclusion of a task, it is customary to say: “Mission complete!”
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, although the PTF has published a final report,
their mission is incomplete – they left about 20 million veterans behind.
Thank you for the opportunity to participate in this hearing. That concludes my testimony. I
welcome any questions.

12