Extracted text: [Statement of Shannon Middleton before the House Subcommittee on Health, Committee on Veterans' Affairs on Gulf War Exposures, July 26, 2007] `
Extracted text: [Statement of Shannon Middleton before the House Subcommittee on Health, Committee on Veterans' Affairs on Gulf War Exposures, July 26, 2007] ` results
admin
Edited Text
STATEMENT OF
SHANNON L. MIDDLETON, DEPUTY DIRECTOR
VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION
THE AMERICAN LEGION
TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS’ AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
GULF WAR EXPOSURES
July 26, 2007
Mr. Chairman and members of the Subcommittee:
The American Legion appreciates the opportunity to offer our views on this very
important issue. American military forces are currently engaged in combat operations in
Iraq and Afghanistan and it is easy to forget that there are still thousands of veterans from
the 1991 Gulf War still suffering from unexplained multi-symptom illnesses related to
their service in Southwest Asia. We applaud this subcommittee for not forgetting these
veterans and holding this hearing.
History of Undiagnosed Illness Compensation
Shortly after the end of the 1991 Gulf War, thousands of Gulf War veterans began
complaining of unexplained multi-symptom illnesses (headaches, fatigue, muscle pain,
joint pain, gastrointestinal problems, neurological signs and symptoms, etc.). In most
cases, doctors were not able to provide definitive diagnoses. As a result, compensation
claims filed with the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) were being denied outright
since VA was prohibited by law from ”service-connecting” conditions that could not be
diagnosed. As result of strong lobbying efforts by the veteran service organization
community and others to correct this problem, Public Law 103-446 (38 USC § 1117) was
enacted in 1994, authorizing VA to pay compensation to disabled Gulf War veterans
suffering from undiagnosed illnesses. The undiagnosed illness must have become
manifest either while the veteran was in the Southwest Asia theater of operations or prior
to January 1, 2012, if symptoms first developed after the veteran left Southwest Asia.
Although PL 103-446 was clearly intended to compensate ill Gulf War veterans suffering
from undiagnosed or medically unexplained conditions, vague wording in the final
version of the law allowed VA to publish restrictive implementing regulations, resulting
in a very high denial rate under the new law. Conditions such as fibromyalgia, irritable
bowel syndrome, and chronic fatigue syndrome, although medically unexplained, were
considered to be “diagnosed” conditions and were being denied under the new
undiagnosed illness law.
The VSO community again turned to Congress for help. The result was Public Law 107103, signed into law on December 27, 2001. Effective March 1, 2002, provisions of this
law clarified and further expanded the definition of undiagnosed illness under the law to
include medically unexplained chronic multi-symptom illness, such as chronic fatigue
syndrome, fibromyalgia, and irritable bowel syndrome, that is defined by a cluster of
signs or symptoms. Signs or symptoms that may be a manifestation of an undiagnosed or
chronic multi-symptom illness include the following: fatigue, unexplained rashes or other
dermatological signs or symptoms, muscle pain, joint pain, neurological signs or
symptoms, signs or symptoms involving the upper or lower respiratory system, sleep
disturbances, gastrointestinal signs or symptoms, cardiovascular signs or symptoms,
abnormal weight loss, or menstrual disorders. A disability is considered chronic if it has
existed for at least six months.
Despite the enactment of PL 107-103, clarifying and expanding the definition of
undiagnosed illness, the denial rate for these claims remains very high (approximately 75
percent). The restrictive nature of VA’s final rule, published in the Federal Register on
June 10, 2003, implementing the Gulf War provisions of PL 107-103 has reinforced this
pattern. As of May 2007, less than four thousand such claims, out of almost 15,000 that
have been processed, have been granted service connection.
The American Legion urges the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee to conduct
oversight of the Gulf War-related provisions of PL 107-103.
Compensation for Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
Preliminary findings of a joint Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Department of
Defense (DoD) study, released in December 2001, of nearly 2.5 million veterans
indicated that deployed Gulf War veterans (August 2, 1990 to July 31, 1991) are twice as
likely as their non-deployed counterparts to develop ALS. The Secretary of Veterans
Affairs immediately announced that he would explore VA’s options for compensating
Gulf War veterans who have been diagnosed with ALS. VA subsequently directed all
VA regional offices to submit all Gulf War ALS cases to VA Central Office for
expeditious adjudication. VA service-connected all Gulf War veterans (with service in
Southwest Asia during the period of August 2, 1990 to July 31, 1991) identified with
ALS at that time (approximately 40) on a direct basis, using the preliminary research
findings as evidence to link ALS to the veterans Gulf War service.
Despite the Secretary’s announcement and subsequent action, VA did not have plans to
draft a regulation establishing an ALS presumption under current law guaranteeing
compensation for Gulf War veterans who develop ALS in the future. The joint VA and
DoD study was published in the scientific journal “Neurology” in September 2003,
resulting in the Secretary publicly announcing that this “final study” supports his 2001
decision to compensate Gulf War veterans stricken with ALS. Despite this public
announcement and the Secretary’s initial decision to expeditiously service-connect, on a
direct basis, Gulf War veterans diagnosed with ALS, VA informed The American Legion
that it would be “premature” to create a regulatory presumption of service connection for
2
Gulf War veterans with ALS. Bottom-line, although VA expeditiously service-connected
a small number of veterans diagnosed with ALS, it has not established ALS as an official
Gulf War presumptive disability and it has no plans to do so at this time based on its
responses to specific American Legion inquiries. Without an actual presumption in
place, there is nothing to ensure that Gulf War veterans diagnosed with ALS in the future
will receive the same treatment as those discussed above. Due to the media coverage of
VA’s actions to expeditiously service-connect Gulf War veterans with ALS in December
2001, many people are under the erroneous belief that ALS is a Gulf War presumptive
disability.
Additional studies have shown that military veterans in general have a greater likelihood
than non-veterans of developing ALS. A study published in 2005 in the journal
“Neurology” titled “Prospective study of military service and mortality from ALS,”
[M.G. Weisskopf et al., 2005; 64:32–37] evaluated ALS risk for veterans from World
War 2, and the Korean and Vietnam Wars. This study concluded that these veterans were
at significantly higher risk for ALS compared to civilians. In November 2006, the
Institute of Medicine (IOM) released a report concluding “there is limited and suggestive
evidence of an association between military service and later development of ALS.” We
understand that VA has finished its evaluation of the November 2006 IOM report in order
to determine if any changes in VA health care or disability compensation policies are
warranted but has determined that more research is needed and a presumption is not
warranted at this time. Although IOM also noted that additional research is needed
regarding a link between military service and ALS, we submit that IOM’s finding of
“limited and suggestive” evidence between ALS and military service is sufficient, under
current law, for VA to move forward and establish official ALS service connection
presumptions. Even though veterans can, in theory, establish service connection without
a specific military presumption, it is extremely difficult in most cases for the veteran to
meet the burden of proof required by VA for establishing direct service connection and
many veterans will be precluded from establishing entitlement to service connection for
ALS without an actual presumption.
Gulf War Presumptive Disabilities
Research is inextricably intertwined with an ill Gulf War veteran’s ability to receive VA
compensation for specific conditions he/she believes are related to his/her Gulf War
service. 38 USC § 1118 (PL 105-277), allows the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to
establish presumptions of service connection for specific diagnosed conditions/diseases
when scientific research supports a positive association with a known Gulf War exposure
(vaccines, nerve agents, depleted uranium (DU), oil well smoke, etc.). The Secretary
relies primarily on the IOM literature reviews and subsequent reports (Gulf War and
Health) to determine whether a positive association exists to justify the establishment of a
presumption. IOM‘s reports to date (Volume 1: Depleted Uranium, Pyridostigmine
Bromide, Sarin, Vaccines; Volume 2: Insecticides and Solvents; Volume 3: Fuels,
Combustion Products, and Propellants; Volume 4: Health Effects of Serving in the Gulf
War; Volume 5: Infectious Disease), and an August 2004 updated literature review of
sarin have not provided the scientific evidence necessary for VA to establish
3
presumptive disabilities for any of the exposures looked at by IOM so far. As a result,
not one presumptive disability has been established to date under this law.
Congress directed IOM’s reports to be based on findings from the full range of human
and animal studies that provide information on the effects of Gulf War-related exposures,
as well as both diagnosed and undiagnosed illnesses affecting Gulf War veterans. IOM’s
“Gulf War and Health” series of reports, as commissioned by VA, have not adhered to
requirements set forth by Congress in mandating the reports. As a result, they have not
comprehensively addressed key questions regarding Gulf War-related health conditions
in relation to Gulf War exposures. IOM’s reports to date have not considered findings
from epidemiologic studies of Gulf War veterans (i.e. association of Gulf War veterans’
illnesses with exposures), nor have they considered animal studies in drawing its
conclusions. A perfect example of this is the August 2004 updated literature review of
sarin. The Secretary of VA commissioned this review because studies published
subsequent to IOM’s September 2000 report (Volume 1), that addressed sarin, showed
that exposure to sarin even at levels too low to cause immediate/acute effects can still
have long-term adverse health effects (brain damage). Even though these studies were
the reason the Secretary wanted IOM to look at sarin again, IOM did not even consider
this research when drawing its conclusions because they were animal-based studies.
Research
In the Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans’ Illness (RACGWI) initial
report released in November 2004, it was found that, for a large majority of ill Gulf War
veterans, their illnesses could not be explained by stress or psychiatric illness and
concluded that current scientific evidence supports a probable link between neurotoxin
exposure and subsequent development of Gulf War veterans’ illnesses. Earlier
government panels concluded that deployment-related stress, not the numerous
environmental and other exposures troops were exposed to during the war, was likely
responsible for the numerous unexplained symptoms reported by thousands of Gulf War
veterans.
Gulf War research is moving away from the previous stress theories and is actually
starting to narrow down possible causes. However, research regarding viable treatment
options is still lacking. The American Legion applauds Congress for having the foresight
to provide funding to the Southwestern Medical Center’s Gulf War Illness research
program. The Center, headed by Dr. Robert Haley at the University of Texas
Southwestern, was awarded $15 million, renewable for five years, to further the scientific
knowledge on Gulf War Veterans Illnesses research. This research will not only impact
veterans of the 1991 Gulf War, but may prove beneficial for those currently serving in the
Southwest Asia Theater and the Middle East during the Global War on Terror. The
purpose of the research is to fill in the gaps of knowledge where there is little, yet
suggestive, information. Dr. Haley’s research will further this knowledge about Gulf
War veterans’ illnesses and hopefully help improve the lives of ill Gulf War veterans, and
their families who suffer beside them. We owe ill Gulf War veterans our exhaustive
efforts in finding treatments for their ailments. The American Legion believes that VA
4
should continue to fund research projects consistent with the recommendations of the
Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans’ Illness (RACGWI). It is
important that VA continues to focus its research on finding medical treatments that will
alleviate veterans’ suffering as well as on figuring out the causes of that suffering. The
American Legion also recommends that the Subcommittee thoroughly review the
RACGWI’s second report, which will be released this fall.
Health Care
Public Law 103-210, which authorized the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to provide
priority health care to the veterans of the Persian Gulf War who have been exposed to
toxic substances and environmental hazards, allowed Gulf War Veterans to enroll into
Priority Group 6. The last sunset date for this authority was December 31, 2002. Since
this date, information provided to veterans and VA hospitals has been conflicting. Some
hospitals continue to honor Priority Group 6 enrollment for ill Gulf War veterans seeking
care for their ailments. Other hospitals, well aware of the sunset date, deny Priority
Group 6 enrollment for these veterans and notify them that they qualify for Priority
Group 8. To the veterans’ dismay, they are completely denied enrollment because the
VA has restricted enrollment for Priority Group 8 since January of 2003. Even more
confounding is the fact that eligibility information disseminated via internet and printed
materials does not consistently reflect this change in enrollment eligibility for Priority
Group 6. The American Legion has been assured by VA that this issue will be rectified.
The American Legion believes priority health care should be again extended to Gulf War
veterans seeking treatment for ailments related to environmental exposures in theater.
Although these veterans can file claims for these ailments and possibly gain access to the
health care system once a disability percentage rate is granted, those whose claims are
denied cannot enroll. According to the May 2007 version of VA’s Gulf War Veterans
Information System (GWVIS), there were 14,874 claims processed for undiagnosed
illnesses. Of those undiagnosed illness claims processed, 11,136 claims were denied.
Because the nature of these illnesses are difficult to understand and information about
individual exposures may not be available, many ill veterans are not able to present
strong claims. They are then forced to seek care from private physicians who may not
have enough information about Gulf War veterans’ illnesses to provide appropriate care.
Since VA doctors would be more knowledgeable about the exposures Gulf War veterans
experienced in theater, it is important that VA keeps Gulf War Continuing Medical
Education (CME) updated to reflect current science. It is equally important that, once
updated, VA makes Gulf War CMEs a requirement, not an option, to better serve this
population of ill veterans. Although reputable research committees have shown that Gulf
War veterans are sicker than those who did not deploy to the Southwest Asia theater, The
American Legion is still contacted by veterans complaining that some VA doctors do not
know how to treat their Gulf War illnesses. In fact, some ill Gulf War veterans are still
being told that their illnesses are all in their heads.
5
Outreach
It is The American Legion’s understanding that VA has stopped mailing out printed
copies of the Gulf War Review and is now only posting it on-line. We are concerned, not
only because not all Gulf War veterans have internet access, but the VA’s Gulf War
veterans page is difficult to locate from VA’s main web page. Only those who know
where it is located, or that it even exists, will have access to the information. The
American Legion has had several calls from those who inquired about the printed
newsletter, as well as those who were interested but had no internet access. We urge VA
to resume mailing out printed versions of the Gulf War Review in addition to posting it
on the web.
Again, thank you Mr. Chairman for giving The American Legion this opportunity to
present its views on such an important issue. We look forward to working with the
Subcommittee to address this and other issues affecting veterans.
6
SHANNON L. MIDDLETON, DEPUTY DIRECTOR
VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION
THE AMERICAN LEGION
TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON HEALTH
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS’ AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
GULF WAR EXPOSURES
July 26, 2007
Mr. Chairman and members of the Subcommittee:
The American Legion appreciates the opportunity to offer our views on this very
important issue. American military forces are currently engaged in combat operations in
Iraq and Afghanistan and it is easy to forget that there are still thousands of veterans from
the 1991 Gulf War still suffering from unexplained multi-symptom illnesses related to
their service in Southwest Asia. We applaud this subcommittee for not forgetting these
veterans and holding this hearing.
History of Undiagnosed Illness Compensation
Shortly after the end of the 1991 Gulf War, thousands of Gulf War veterans began
complaining of unexplained multi-symptom illnesses (headaches, fatigue, muscle pain,
joint pain, gastrointestinal problems, neurological signs and symptoms, etc.). In most
cases, doctors were not able to provide definitive diagnoses. As a result, compensation
claims filed with the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) were being denied outright
since VA was prohibited by law from ”service-connecting” conditions that could not be
diagnosed. As result of strong lobbying efforts by the veteran service organization
community and others to correct this problem, Public Law 103-446 (38 USC § 1117) was
enacted in 1994, authorizing VA to pay compensation to disabled Gulf War veterans
suffering from undiagnosed illnesses. The undiagnosed illness must have become
manifest either while the veteran was in the Southwest Asia theater of operations or prior
to January 1, 2012, if symptoms first developed after the veteran left Southwest Asia.
Although PL 103-446 was clearly intended to compensate ill Gulf War veterans suffering
from undiagnosed or medically unexplained conditions, vague wording in the final
version of the law allowed VA to publish restrictive implementing regulations, resulting
in a very high denial rate under the new law. Conditions such as fibromyalgia, irritable
bowel syndrome, and chronic fatigue syndrome, although medically unexplained, were
considered to be “diagnosed” conditions and were being denied under the new
undiagnosed illness law.
The VSO community again turned to Congress for help. The result was Public Law 107103, signed into law on December 27, 2001. Effective March 1, 2002, provisions of this
law clarified and further expanded the definition of undiagnosed illness under the law to
include medically unexplained chronic multi-symptom illness, such as chronic fatigue
syndrome, fibromyalgia, and irritable bowel syndrome, that is defined by a cluster of
signs or symptoms. Signs or symptoms that may be a manifestation of an undiagnosed or
chronic multi-symptom illness include the following: fatigue, unexplained rashes or other
dermatological signs or symptoms, muscle pain, joint pain, neurological signs or
symptoms, signs or symptoms involving the upper or lower respiratory system, sleep
disturbances, gastrointestinal signs or symptoms, cardiovascular signs or symptoms,
abnormal weight loss, or menstrual disorders. A disability is considered chronic if it has
existed for at least six months.
Despite the enactment of PL 107-103, clarifying and expanding the definition of
undiagnosed illness, the denial rate for these claims remains very high (approximately 75
percent). The restrictive nature of VA’s final rule, published in the Federal Register on
June 10, 2003, implementing the Gulf War provisions of PL 107-103 has reinforced this
pattern. As of May 2007, less than four thousand such claims, out of almost 15,000 that
have been processed, have been granted service connection.
The American Legion urges the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee to conduct
oversight of the Gulf War-related provisions of PL 107-103.
Compensation for Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
Preliminary findings of a joint Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Department of
Defense (DoD) study, released in December 2001, of nearly 2.5 million veterans
indicated that deployed Gulf War veterans (August 2, 1990 to July 31, 1991) are twice as
likely as their non-deployed counterparts to develop ALS. The Secretary of Veterans
Affairs immediately announced that he would explore VA’s options for compensating
Gulf War veterans who have been diagnosed with ALS. VA subsequently directed all
VA regional offices to submit all Gulf War ALS cases to VA Central Office for
expeditious adjudication. VA service-connected all Gulf War veterans (with service in
Southwest Asia during the period of August 2, 1990 to July 31, 1991) identified with
ALS at that time (approximately 40) on a direct basis, using the preliminary research
findings as evidence to link ALS to the veterans Gulf War service.
Despite the Secretary’s announcement and subsequent action, VA did not have plans to
draft a regulation establishing an ALS presumption under current law guaranteeing
compensation for Gulf War veterans who develop ALS in the future. The joint VA and
DoD study was published in the scientific journal “Neurology” in September 2003,
resulting in the Secretary publicly announcing that this “final study” supports his 2001
decision to compensate Gulf War veterans stricken with ALS. Despite this public
announcement and the Secretary’s initial decision to expeditiously service-connect, on a
direct basis, Gulf War veterans diagnosed with ALS, VA informed The American Legion
that it would be “premature” to create a regulatory presumption of service connection for
2
Gulf War veterans with ALS. Bottom-line, although VA expeditiously service-connected
a small number of veterans diagnosed with ALS, it has not established ALS as an official
Gulf War presumptive disability and it has no plans to do so at this time based on its
responses to specific American Legion inquiries. Without an actual presumption in
place, there is nothing to ensure that Gulf War veterans diagnosed with ALS in the future
will receive the same treatment as those discussed above. Due to the media coverage of
VA’s actions to expeditiously service-connect Gulf War veterans with ALS in December
2001, many people are under the erroneous belief that ALS is a Gulf War presumptive
disability.
Additional studies have shown that military veterans in general have a greater likelihood
than non-veterans of developing ALS. A study published in 2005 in the journal
“Neurology” titled “Prospective study of military service and mortality from ALS,”
[M.G. Weisskopf et al., 2005; 64:32–37] evaluated ALS risk for veterans from World
War 2, and the Korean and Vietnam Wars. This study concluded that these veterans were
at significantly higher risk for ALS compared to civilians. In November 2006, the
Institute of Medicine (IOM) released a report concluding “there is limited and suggestive
evidence of an association between military service and later development of ALS.” We
understand that VA has finished its evaluation of the November 2006 IOM report in order
to determine if any changes in VA health care or disability compensation policies are
warranted but has determined that more research is needed and a presumption is not
warranted at this time. Although IOM also noted that additional research is needed
regarding a link between military service and ALS, we submit that IOM’s finding of
“limited and suggestive” evidence between ALS and military service is sufficient, under
current law, for VA to move forward and establish official ALS service connection
presumptions. Even though veterans can, in theory, establish service connection without
a specific military presumption, it is extremely difficult in most cases for the veteran to
meet the burden of proof required by VA for establishing direct service connection and
many veterans will be precluded from establishing entitlement to service connection for
ALS without an actual presumption.
Gulf War Presumptive Disabilities
Research is inextricably intertwined with an ill Gulf War veteran’s ability to receive VA
compensation for specific conditions he/she believes are related to his/her Gulf War
service. 38 USC § 1118 (PL 105-277), allows the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to
establish presumptions of service connection for specific diagnosed conditions/diseases
when scientific research supports a positive association with a known Gulf War exposure
(vaccines, nerve agents, depleted uranium (DU), oil well smoke, etc.). The Secretary
relies primarily on the IOM literature reviews and subsequent reports (Gulf War and
Health) to determine whether a positive association exists to justify the establishment of a
presumption. IOM‘s reports to date (Volume 1: Depleted Uranium, Pyridostigmine
Bromide, Sarin, Vaccines; Volume 2: Insecticides and Solvents; Volume 3: Fuels,
Combustion Products, and Propellants; Volume 4: Health Effects of Serving in the Gulf
War; Volume 5: Infectious Disease), and an August 2004 updated literature review of
sarin have not provided the scientific evidence necessary for VA to establish
3
presumptive disabilities for any of the exposures looked at by IOM so far. As a result,
not one presumptive disability has been established to date under this law.
Congress directed IOM’s reports to be based on findings from the full range of human
and animal studies that provide information on the effects of Gulf War-related exposures,
as well as both diagnosed and undiagnosed illnesses affecting Gulf War veterans. IOM’s
“Gulf War and Health” series of reports, as commissioned by VA, have not adhered to
requirements set forth by Congress in mandating the reports. As a result, they have not
comprehensively addressed key questions regarding Gulf War-related health conditions
in relation to Gulf War exposures. IOM’s reports to date have not considered findings
from epidemiologic studies of Gulf War veterans (i.e. association of Gulf War veterans’
illnesses with exposures), nor have they considered animal studies in drawing its
conclusions. A perfect example of this is the August 2004 updated literature review of
sarin. The Secretary of VA commissioned this review because studies published
subsequent to IOM’s September 2000 report (Volume 1), that addressed sarin, showed
that exposure to sarin even at levels too low to cause immediate/acute effects can still
have long-term adverse health effects (brain damage). Even though these studies were
the reason the Secretary wanted IOM to look at sarin again, IOM did not even consider
this research when drawing its conclusions because they were animal-based studies.
Research
In the Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans’ Illness (RACGWI) initial
report released in November 2004, it was found that, for a large majority of ill Gulf War
veterans, their illnesses could not be explained by stress or psychiatric illness and
concluded that current scientific evidence supports a probable link between neurotoxin
exposure and subsequent development of Gulf War veterans’ illnesses. Earlier
government panels concluded that deployment-related stress, not the numerous
environmental and other exposures troops were exposed to during the war, was likely
responsible for the numerous unexplained symptoms reported by thousands of Gulf War
veterans.
Gulf War research is moving away from the previous stress theories and is actually
starting to narrow down possible causes. However, research regarding viable treatment
options is still lacking. The American Legion applauds Congress for having the foresight
to provide funding to the Southwestern Medical Center’s Gulf War Illness research
program. The Center, headed by Dr. Robert Haley at the University of Texas
Southwestern, was awarded $15 million, renewable for five years, to further the scientific
knowledge on Gulf War Veterans Illnesses research. This research will not only impact
veterans of the 1991 Gulf War, but may prove beneficial for those currently serving in the
Southwest Asia Theater and the Middle East during the Global War on Terror. The
purpose of the research is to fill in the gaps of knowledge where there is little, yet
suggestive, information. Dr. Haley’s research will further this knowledge about Gulf
War veterans’ illnesses and hopefully help improve the lives of ill Gulf War veterans, and
their families who suffer beside them. We owe ill Gulf War veterans our exhaustive
efforts in finding treatments for their ailments. The American Legion believes that VA
4
should continue to fund research projects consistent with the recommendations of the
Research Advisory Committee on Gulf War Veterans’ Illness (RACGWI). It is
important that VA continues to focus its research on finding medical treatments that will
alleviate veterans’ suffering as well as on figuring out the causes of that suffering. The
American Legion also recommends that the Subcommittee thoroughly review the
RACGWI’s second report, which will be released this fall.
Health Care
Public Law 103-210, which authorized the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to provide
priority health care to the veterans of the Persian Gulf War who have been exposed to
toxic substances and environmental hazards, allowed Gulf War Veterans to enroll into
Priority Group 6. The last sunset date for this authority was December 31, 2002. Since
this date, information provided to veterans and VA hospitals has been conflicting. Some
hospitals continue to honor Priority Group 6 enrollment for ill Gulf War veterans seeking
care for their ailments. Other hospitals, well aware of the sunset date, deny Priority
Group 6 enrollment for these veterans and notify them that they qualify for Priority
Group 8. To the veterans’ dismay, they are completely denied enrollment because the
VA has restricted enrollment for Priority Group 8 since January of 2003. Even more
confounding is the fact that eligibility information disseminated via internet and printed
materials does not consistently reflect this change in enrollment eligibility for Priority
Group 6. The American Legion has been assured by VA that this issue will be rectified.
The American Legion believes priority health care should be again extended to Gulf War
veterans seeking treatment for ailments related to environmental exposures in theater.
Although these veterans can file claims for these ailments and possibly gain access to the
health care system once a disability percentage rate is granted, those whose claims are
denied cannot enroll. According to the May 2007 version of VA’s Gulf War Veterans
Information System (GWVIS), there were 14,874 claims processed for undiagnosed
illnesses. Of those undiagnosed illness claims processed, 11,136 claims were denied.
Because the nature of these illnesses are difficult to understand and information about
individual exposures may not be available, many ill veterans are not able to present
strong claims. They are then forced to seek care from private physicians who may not
have enough information about Gulf War veterans’ illnesses to provide appropriate care.
Since VA doctors would be more knowledgeable about the exposures Gulf War veterans
experienced in theater, it is important that VA keeps Gulf War Continuing Medical
Education (CME) updated to reflect current science. It is equally important that, once
updated, VA makes Gulf War CMEs a requirement, not an option, to better serve this
population of ill veterans. Although reputable research committees have shown that Gulf
War veterans are sicker than those who did not deploy to the Southwest Asia theater, The
American Legion is still contacted by veterans complaining that some VA doctors do not
know how to treat their Gulf War illnesses. In fact, some ill Gulf War veterans are still
being told that their illnesses are all in their heads.
5
Outreach
It is The American Legion’s understanding that VA has stopped mailing out printed
copies of the Gulf War Review and is now only posting it on-line. We are concerned, not
only because not all Gulf War veterans have internet access, but the VA’s Gulf War
veterans page is difficult to locate from VA’s main web page. Only those who know
where it is located, or that it even exists, will have access to the information. The
American Legion has had several calls from those who inquired about the printed
newsletter, as well as those who were interested but had no internet access. We urge VA
to resume mailing out printed versions of the Gulf War Review in addition to posting it
on the web.
Again, thank you Mr. Chairman for giving The American Legion this opportunity to
present its views on such an important issue. We look forward to working with the
Subcommittee to address this and other issues affecting veterans.
6