Extracted text: Proceedings of the 77th National Convention of the American Legion [1995] `
Extracted text: Proceedings of the 77th National Convention of the American Legion [1995] ` results
admin
Edited Text
PROCEEDINGS
of the
77th Annual National Convention
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Indianapolis Convention Center
Indianapolis, Indiana
September 4, 5, 6,1995
Printed in U.S.A.
StoctNo. 11-470
DISTRIBUTION
1 ea. to: N.E.C. & Alt. N.E.C.
Past National Commanders
National Officers
Finance Commission
Commission & Committee Chairman
3 ea. to: Foreign Departments (4)
Optional: Departments (51)
PROCEEDINGS
of the
77th Annual National Convention
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Indianapolis Convention Center
Indianapolis, Indiana
September 4, 5, 6,1995
Table of Contents
Foreword
Register of Resolutions
v«
ix
Monday, September 4,1995
Invocation
1
Dale Robertson
3
National Commander’s Report
5
POW/MIA Empty Chair Designation
7
Convention Call
7
The Honorable Evan Bayh Governor
11
Thomas Henderson
13
Reports: Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section I
13
The American Legion National Convention Corporation of Indiana
15
The Honorable Stephen Goldsmith
15
Report: Legislation and Rules
16
Jere Radcliffe, Chief Scout Executive
18
Presentation of Plaque for 1994 National Convention City Minneapolis, Minnesota . 22
Certificate of Appreciation to Rev. Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
23
Report: Children and Youth
23
Garland Murphy Award
25
Report: Americanism
26
Resolution No. 16: V-J Day Designation
27
Resolution No. 99: Illegal Aliens
27
The Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy
28
Ralph T. O’Neil Education Trophy
29
William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy
29
1995 Boys Nation President
30
Junior Shooting Sports Precision Champion
31
1995 Oratorical Champion
32
1994 Baseball Player of the Year
33
1995 Scout of the Year
34
Bo-Soon Song
35
The Honorable Robert J. Dole
35
Special Report: The American Legion and The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc
42
The Honorable Gerald B. H. Solomon
43
The Honorable G.V. Montgomery
44
Ike Pappas, President, Ike Pappas Network Productions
46
Society of American Legion Founders
47
W. T. Russ Ward, Dominion President, Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans
47
Hugh Greene, Dominion President, The Royal Canadian Legion
48
General Chao Yu, Vice Chairman, Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired
Servicemen
50
iii
Lt. General (Ret.) Jae-Yun Kim Vice President, The Korean Veterans Association ... 52
Chapel of Four Chaplains
53
Tuesday, September 5,1995
Invocation
57
The Honorable Jesse Brown, Secretary of Veterans Affairs
58
Korean War Veterans Advisory Committee
63
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
66
Employer of the Year Awards for Hiring Veterans
67
The Honorable richard W. Riley, Secretary of Education
70
Brigadier General Paul W. Tibbets, USAF (Ret.)
74
Report: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
76
Resolution No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
77
No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service .. 78
Report: Other Economic Matters
79
Resolution No. 24: Natural Resource Management
79
No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
80
No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
81
Lt. Gen. Claude M. Kicklighter, USA (Ret.)
82
Diane Carlson Evans
84
Mrs. Linda Newsome, National President, American Legion Auxiliary
87
Brig. General Wilma L. Vaught, USAF (RET.)
88
Sons of The American Legion
90
The Honorable Dan Burton
91
His Excellency Adriaan Jacobovits, Ambassador of the Netherlands
93
Report: Credential and Other Internal Matters, Section II
95
Resolution No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
96
No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
96
No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
96
No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
97
No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans” . 97
No. 93: The Enola Gay
98
No. 94: The Enola Gay
98
No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
99
No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
99
No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial .... 100
No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
100
No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
101
Report: Credential and Other Internal Matters, Section III (Membership)
103
1994-95 Recruiter of the Year
106
Gold Brigade Announcement
106
Report: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
107
Resolution No. 35: Oppose Centralization ofVA Claims Processing Centers 108
No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
109
iv
No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from
Further Review
109
No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to
Date The Deceased Veteran’s Claim was Filed
110
No. 141: The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan 110
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy
117
Reports: Finance
118
Foreign Relations
119
Resolution No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
120
No. 151: United Nations
121
No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
122
No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
123
No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
124
No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam . 125
Report: Constitutional Amendments
126
Resolution No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
127
Wednesday, September 6,1995
Invocation
Drawing for 1996 Buick LeSabre
MBNA America
Jackson National Life Insurance Company of Michigan
The Honorable Steve Buyer, United States House of Representatives
The Fourth Estate Award
General John M. Shalikashvili, USA, Chairman Joint Chiefs-of-Staff
Report: National Security
Resolution No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
No. 102: Quality of Life Features
No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military
Beneficiaries
No. 150: Support for The United States Coast Guard
Maj. Gen. Ervin C. Sharp, Jr., Deputy Director for Operation U.S. Pacific Command
Election ofNational Officers
Syble Deshotel, American Legion Auxiliary President
Benediction
137
138
139
139
140
143
145
150
151
152
153
155
156
157
158
161
163
168
186
186
Announcement of Annual Awards
Financial Report
Abbreviations
Index
189
196
207
209
:
V
FOREWORD
This booklet has been prepared for the information of members of The American
Legion. It has come to be known as the Summary of Proceedings of the National
Convention for the current year. It is a comprehensive resume, in as small space
as possible, of what took place at the Seventy-seventh Annual National Convention
in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4-6, 1995.
The financial report of the National Organization for the period ending December
31, 1994, and Balance sheet as of December 31, 1994 and Surplus Analysis,
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1994 are included in the Summary.
To make a quick distribution, speed has been necessary. Every precaution has been
taken to avoid errors, but some may have occurred in the rush of Convention events
and the hast of editing and printing.
Permission is hereby given to quote from this Summary without further consent.
However, because of the nature of our resolution process, I urge that the full text
of any or all resolve clause(s) is used when a quotation from a resolution is
required for publication.
Robert W. Spanogle
National Adjutant
Note: At various time, the National Vice Commanders, as follows, presided over
the Convention sessions, when called upon by presiding officer, in accordance with
the Uniform Code of Procedure as shown in the verbatim proceedings: Joseph T.
Craig, Alaska, Silas M. Noel, Kentucky, Calvin E. Patton, Maryland, H. Gordon
Burleigh, New York, and Vernon K. Grosenick, Wisconsin.
Register of Resolutions
(see abbreviations used at end of report)
Committee Action
AMER
AMER
AMER
Number Title
APPROVED
APPROVED W/A
R&R
R&R
AMER
AMER
R&R
R&R
AMER
AMER
AMER
AMER
REF
REF
REF
REF
AMER
AMER
AMER
CON AM
CON AM
CON AM
REF TO AMER
REF TO AMER
REF TO SEC
APPROVED
OUT OF ORDER
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
CON AM
REF TO INAF
REJECTED
CON AM
REJECTED
EC
APPROVED
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC/EVP
APPROVED
W/004 020
058 079 137
APPROVED W/A
W/087 133
CONS W/024
CONS W/024
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
APPROVED
TO
TO
TO
TO
AMER
AMER
AMER
AMER
Or igin
16 V-J DAY DESIGNATION
99 ILLEGAL ALIENS
59 THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE BE DECLARED AS THE
OFFICIAL UNITED STATES LANGUAGE
60 SUPPORT THE TRADITIONAL RENDITION OF THE
NATIONAL ANTHEM
61 POW/MIA FLAG DISPLAY AT POSTAL FACILITIES
96 NATIONAL STANDARDS FOR UNITED STATES
HISTORY
71 WEARING OF THE AMERICAN FLAG PATCH
76 CERTIFICATION OF FILIPINO SERVICE RECORDS
77 FILIPINO VETERANS FAMILY IMMIGRATION
78 REOPEN PERIOD FOR FILIPINO FILING OF
NATURALIZATION APPLICATIONS
134 AMERICAN LEGION MIDDLE SCHOOL ESSAY PROGRAM
135 PRAYER FOR POW/MIA
22 MILITIA ORGANIZATIONS
1 AMERICAN LEGION AUXILIARY ELIGIBILITY
25 CHANGE IN THE PREAMBLE OF THE CONSTITUTION
28 ELIGIBILITY FOR THE AMERICAN LEGION
AUXILIARY
83 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
117 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
121 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
130 ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP IN THE
AMERICAN LEGION
131 RETROACTIVE CHANGE FOR START OF MEMBER'S
CONTINUOUS YEARS
72 HEADQUARTERS POST MEMBERS PER CAPITA
11 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
98 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
147 SUPPORT EFFORTS TO INCREASE AND IMPROVE
FEDERAL ASSISTANCE TO AMERICA'S
VETERAN-ENTREPRENEUR
29 FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
24 NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
87
133
4
20
58
79
137
146
CO
0H
NY
NY
NY
OH
FL
PI
PI
PI
VA
NC
MT
NADJT
AK
AK
WI
NH
VT
SD
SD
KY
CO
OH
EC
DC
AK
NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
SURPLUS FEDERAL PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
REINVENTION OF VETERANS' EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
ix
WI
UT
KS
OR
NY
NE
VA
EC/EVP
Committee Action
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
APPROVED
W/010 030
046 048 051
081 085 128
132
CONS W/070
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
CONS W/070
CONS W/070
CONS W/070
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
CONS
CONS
CONS
CONS
CONS
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
EC/EVP
R&R
EC/EVP
FR/RL
FR/RL
R&R
APPROVED
APPROVED
W/075
APPROVED W/A
APPROVED W/A
APPROVED W/A
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
W/070
W/070
W/070
W/070
W/070
FR/RL
APPROVED W/A
W/057
CONS W/140
FR/RL
FR/RL
CONS W/151
R&R
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
R&R
R&R
R&R
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
INAF
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REJECTED
APPROVED
INAF
INAF
INAF
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
Number Title
Origin
70 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
FL
10 FUNDING FOR VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING PROGRAMS
30 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
46 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
48 SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT ASSISTANCE
ENTITLEMENTS
51 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
81 SUPPORT DVOP AND LVER PROGRAMS
85 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
128 SUPPORT DVOP AND LVER PROGRAMS
132 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
8 VETERANS PREFERENCE
9 VETERANS PREFERENCE
18 VETERANS PREFERENCE
49 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
50 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
80 OPPOSE TRANSFER OF VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
126 OPPOSE TRANSFER OF VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
127 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
152 NATO PARTNERSHIP FOR PEACE
151 UNITED NATIONS
CO
DC
SC
TX
TX
NE
WI
SD
UT
CO
CO
MA
TX
TX
NE
SD
SD
FR/RL
FR/RL
26 RELATIONS WITH CHINA CONCERNING TAIWAN
92 UPDATED PRIORITY POW/MIA ACTIONS
111 OPPOSITION TO AGREED FRAMEWORK WITH NORTH
KOREA
140 OPPOSITION TO NORMAL RELATIONS WITH VIETNAM
AK
MO
MD
57 WITHHOLD FUNDING FOR NORMALIZED RELATIONS
WITH VIETNAM
75 UNITED NATIONS REFORMS
110 GUIDELINES FOR RELATIONS WITH THE FORMER
SOVIET UNION
112 PRINCIPLES OF UNITED STATES FOREIGN POLICY
113 PRINCIPLES OF UNITED STATES FOREIGN AID
114 DEMOCRATIC ACTIVISIM AS UNITED STATES
NATIONAL SECURITY-FOREIGN POLICY GOAL
15 POW/MIA TRUST FUND PETITION
109 EXPANDING NATO
143 RELEASE OF SERVICE MEMBERS STATUS
145 JAPANESE APOLOGY FOR WORLD WAR II
40 REINSTATEMENT OF TRADE EMBARGO WITH VIETNAM
56 SUPPORT SERGEANT ALVIN C. YORK POSTAGE
STAMP
136 SUPPORT SUPERSONIC FLIGHT POSTAGE STAMP
153 APPRECIATION TO HOST CITY
154 WORLD WAR II COMMEMORATION DAY
TX
X
VA
MX
MD
MD
MD
MD
CO
MD
NJ
NY
IL
TX
WV
INAF
INAF
Committee Action
INAF
Number Title
INAF
APPROVED
W/002 003
APPROVED U/A
INAF
APPROVED W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
INAF
APPROVED W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
CONS W/091
CONS W/091
R&R
R&R
INAF
INAF
INAF
R&R
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF
REF
REF
REF
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF TO SEC
REJECTED
REJECTED
REJECTED
INAF
INAF
INAF/M
REJECTED
REJECTED
REF TO M&PA
INAF/M
SEC
SEC
SEC
SEC
SEC
REF TO M&PA
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
TO
TO
TO
TO
W/A
W/A
W/A
W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
Origin
91 RESTORATION OF LIBERTY MEMORIAL
MO
42 SPONSOR AND SUPPORT SALUTE TO JAPANESE
AMERICAN VETERANS
64 NATIONAL MEDIA COVERAGE FOR MILITARY
PERSONNEL
65 MIDWAY ISLANDS NATIONAL MEMORIAL ACT
93 THE ENOLA GAY
94 THE ENOLA GAY
100 COMMERCIAL VENDORS AT THE VIETNAM VETERANS
MEMORIAL
139 SUPPORT GEORGE C. MARSHALL HOME
PRESERVATION FUND
2 LIBERTY MEMORIAL
3 RESTORATION OF LIBERTY MEMORIAL
5 LEGAL IMMUNITY FOR VOLUNTEERS
6 AUTHORIZATION FOR THE AMERICAN LEGION TO
SEEK AN AMENDMENT TO INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
SEC. 501(c)(19) AND OTHER SECTIONS
63 SUPPORT AUDIE MURPHY POSTAGE STAMP
43 POW/MIA LOGO ON LEGION ENVELOPES
44 ROSTER PLAQUE FOR SONS OF THE AMERICAN
LEGION
55 THE SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION
67 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
82 ESTABLISH SUB COMMITTEE ON MEMBERSHIP
ELIGIBILITY DATES
84 SUPPORT RICHARD I. BONG HERITAGE CENTER
90 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
95 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
138 ESTABLISHMENT OF JOINT STUDY GROUP
CONCERNING AUXILIARY ELIGIBILITY
115 ESTABLISH AWARDS FOR EMERGENCY PERSONNEL
17 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
27 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
66 AMEND THE AMERICAN LEGION OFFICER'S GUIDE
AND MANUAL OF CEREMONIES ON MILITARY
FUNERALS
101 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
142 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
116 OTHER THAN ACTIVE MEMBERSHIP IN THE
AMERICAN LEGION
144 MEMORIAL POSTS
32 MODERNIZATION OF THE UNITED STATES ARMY
102 QUALITY OF LIFE FEATURES
104 RETIRED MILITARY PAY COLA EQUITY
105 DOMESTIC TERRORISM IN THE UNITED STATES
107 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE HEALTH CARE REFORM
FOR MILITARY BENEFICIARIES
148 REVISING THE 1972 ANTI-BALLISTIC MISSILE
TREATY
149 THE UNITED STATES AIR FORCE IN THE 21ST
CENTURY
150 SUPPORT FOR THE UNITED STATES COAST GUARD
xi
IL
NY
NY
NY
OH
OH
VA
KS
KS
KS
KS
NY
IL
IL
TX
FL
PA
WI
MO
OH
VA
MD
CO
AK
MN
MD
UT
MD
ME
DC
MD
MD
MD
MD
SEC
SEC
SEC
Committee Action
SEC
Origin
Number Title
R&R
23 UNITED STATES
COMMAND
FORCES UNDER UNITED NATIONS
MT
IN HAITI
SEC
R&R
33 RETAIN THE SELECTIVE SERVICE SYSTEM
DC
SEC
R&R
45 PRESERVE THE NATIONAL GUARD OF THE UNITED
SC
STATES
SEC
103 RETENTION OF THE UNIFORMED SERVICES
R&R
MD
UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
SEC
106 ANTI-ROTC POLICIES AT COLLEGES AND
R&R
MD
UNIVERSITIES
SEC
R&R
108 NATIONAL SECURITY PRINCIPLES
MD
SEC
R&R
125 ROTC
CA
IN PUBLIC SUPPORTED UNIVERSITIES AND
SECONDARY SCHOOLS
SEC
REF TO SEC
13 VA/DOO
JOINT VENTURE
FOR
FITZSIMONS ARMY
CO
MEDICAL CENTER
SEC
REF TO VA&R
14 STATE AND NATIONAL COMMITTEES
IN SUPPORT OF
CO
PERSIAN GULF VETERANS
SEC
REJECTED
12 CLASS ACTION
LAWSUIT AGAINST UNITED STATES
CO
GOVERNMENT
SEC
REJECTED
31
VA&R
APPROVED
141
W/122
VA&R
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF THE UNITED STATES ARMY
DC
THE AMERICAN LEGION HEALTH CARE REFORM PLAN
VA&R
124
APPROVED W/A
35 OPPOSE CENTRALIZATION OF VETERANS CLAIMS
ND
PROCESSING CENTERS
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
37
OPPOSE
AFFAIRS DISABILITY COMPENSATION
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
47 EXEMPT ALL CURRENT PENSION AND ENTITLEMENT
FROM
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
SC
FURTHER REVIEW
74 REVISE UNITED STATES CODE TO ALLOW
IL
RETROACTIVE DATE WHERE VETERAN DIES WHILE
CLAIM
VA&R
CONS W/141
IS
IN APPEAL PROCESS
122 ALLOW DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS TO
EXPAND ACCESS TO MEDICAL
CA
FACILITIES BY
ACCEPTING AND RETAINING THIRD PARTY
REIMBURSEMENTS
VA&R
CONS W/141
VA&R
R&R
124 PROVIDE PREVENTIVE MEDICINE TO VETERANS
7 EXEMPTION OF
HIRING CAPS
FOR DEPARTMENT OF
CA
KS
VETERANS AFFAIRS
VA&R
R&R
21
SUPPORT PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION
FUNDING
MT
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES
VA&R
R&R
34 SEEK AUTHORIZATION
FOR DEPARTMENT OF
ND
VETERANS AFFAIRS TO CONSIDER CURRENT
INCOME TO DETERMINE ELIGIBILITY
VA&R
R&R
FOR CARE
36 SEEK ADEQUATE APPROPRIATIONS FOR DEPARTMENT
ND
OF VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL PROGRAMS AND
PERSONNEL
VA&R
R&R
38 ESTABLISH AN OPEN ENROLLMENT PERIOD TO
VETERANS ELIGIBLE
VETERANS
VA&R
R&R
39
ND
FOR SERVICE DISABLED
INSURANCE
INCREASE THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF SERVICE
DISABLED VETERANS
ND
INSURANCE
VA&R
R&R
52 OPPOSE ANY REDUCTION
VA&R
R&R
53 REDUCE PROCESSING TIME ON CLAIMS TO SIX
IN VETERANS BENEFITS
TX
TX
MONTHS
VA&R
R&R
62 REQUEST
COUNTY,
FOR NATIONAL CEMETERY RICHMOND
NEW YORK
xii
NY
Committee Action
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REJECTED
Number Title
Origin
69 RESTORE BENEFITS TO REMARRIED WIDOWS OF
VETERANS
86 CREATE A COMMISSION TO STUDY THE
FL
WI
RESTORATION OF THE BURIAL ALLOWANCE
88 REVIEW THE RANKING OF AREAS IN NEED OF A
MO
NATIONAL CEMETERY
89 HEALTH CARE COVERAGE FOR NEWLY DISCHARGED
MO
VETERANS AND DEPENDENTS
97 SUPPORT PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION FUNDING
OH
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES PROGRAM
118 CONTINUE FULL SERVICE AT MANCHESTER VAMC
NH
AND WHITE RIVER JUNCTION VAMC
120 SUPPORTED PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION FUNDING NH
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES PROGRAM
123 INCREASE FUNDING FOR MEDICAL HEALTH
CA
RESEARCH
129 DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS ENSURE
SD
SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS ARE PROVIDED ANY
CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING CLAIMS
19 ELIGIBILITY REFORM AND FUNDING FOR VA
MA
HEALTH CARE
41 EXPANSION OF DECATUR, ILLINOIS OUTPATIENT
IL
CLINIC
68 RESTORE PRIORITY TO SOUTH FLORIDA VETERANS
FL
CEMETERY
73 PROVIDE DEPENDENT CHILDREN OF VETERANS IN
IL
NURSING HOMES GREATER PENSIONS
119 SEEK OUTPATIENT CLINIC TO BE LOCATED AT
NH
PEASE AIR FORCE BASE PORTSMOUTH NEW
HAMPSHIRE
54 OPPOSE CONSOLIDATION OF TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TX
VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL CENTERS
Abbreviations used in this report: AMER=AMERI CAN ISM; INAF/M=CREDENTIALS &
INTERNAL AFFAIRS/MEMBERSHIP; CON AM=CONSTI TUT IONAL AMENDENTS; CONS W/..^CONSOLIDATED
WITH
EC/EVP=ECONOMICS/EMPLOYMENT & VETERANS PREFERENCE; FR/RL=FOREIGN RELATIONS,NADJT=NATIONAL ADJUTANT; R&R=RECEIVED S RECORDED; REF=REFERRED; SEC=NATIONAL
SECURITY; VA&R=VETERANS AFFAIRS S REHABILITION C&Y=CHILDREN & YOUTH; W/A=WITH
AMENDMENTS
12/06/95
xiii
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
1
PROCEEDINGS
of the
77TH ANNUAL CONVENTION
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Monday, September 4, 1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegates were entertained by taped music of the ‘40s while slides of
World War II posters were displayed on large screens.
NATIONAL COMMANDER WILLIAM M. DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen,
the music that you have heard and the World War II poster art slides that you have seen are
designed to focus on the theme of our 77th National Convention: World War II
Commemorated.
... At 9:00 a.m., the Delegates assembled for the 77th Annual National Convention and
the following proceedings were conducted:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, please rise as the
Speedway Color Guard of American Legion Post No. 500 in Speedway, Indiana, presents
the Colors, and remain standing for the singing of the National Anthem by my son, Scott,
and my grandson, Scott Detweiler, Jr.. Right hand salute.
... The Speedway Color Guard from Post 500 in Speedway, Indiana advanced the Colors,
while the Delegation stood in right hand salute.
. . .Scott R. Detweiler and Scott R. Detweiler, Jr. sang the “Star Spangled Banner.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the invocation, I now call on our
National Chaplain, the Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., of American Legion Post 65 in Saluda,
South Carolina.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Let us pray. Most Holy Father, we invoke Your blessings upon this, the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion.
We come together as a body of volunteers to do that which is right for God and
Country.
As we deliberate this day, we pray that You would give us the insight to do those things
that will enhance this great organization of ours, and help it to continue to be what it should
to a force for God and Country in our world.
2
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Bless us, now we pray this in the Lord’s name. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, please join me
in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance.
... At this time the Delegation recited the Pledge of Allegiance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Fellow Legionnaires, would you please
join with me in reaffirming your commitment to the principles and ideals on which our great
American Legion was founded, by reciting with me the Preamble to the Constitution of The
American Legion.
... At this time, the Delegation stood and recited the Preamble to the Constitution of The
American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I now call on National Chaplain
Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., for the Post Everlasting Ceremony.
POST EVERLASTING CEREMONY
AND
LIGHTING OF PEACE CANDLE
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Ladies and Gentlemen, would you uncover and remain uncovered for this special
remembrance.
In mid-July, The American Legion lost two Past Commanders. One a World War II
veteran, the other a Korean War veteran.
J. Milton Patrick, the 1969-1970 National Commander was a World War II Army
veteran and a Life Member of Galentine Price Post 131 in Skiatook, Oklahoma.
Dale Renaud, the 1985-1986 National Commander was the only U.S. Coast Guard
veteran to lead our great organization.
While remaining seated, I ask you to pause for a moment of silent prayer of thanks for
the service of these men on behalf of America’s veterans.
... A moment of silence was observed.
Two days ago we marked the 50th Anniversary of the end of World War II. It was the
end of a long period of intense fighting, suffering and sacrifice. Peace, wonderful peace was
finally at hand. This morning we take time to remember the way it was a half a century ago.
16,112,568 Americans served during World War II. 406,000 of our comrades died to keep
the candle of peace burning for others. We remember those brave World War II men and
women who died during the war, and the countless millions of others that have since passed
away.
Family and friends; music and song, an abiding faith in God. These held our nation
together through those long war years. Now, let us reflect through music and song, through
written memories of gallant defenders of freedom, by the laying of a wreath, and by the
sounding of three bell tolls in memory of those who fought on land, on sea, and in the air.
... At this time the Delegation viewed a presentation of various videos and was entertained
by the American Cabaret Theater Singers.
National Commander Detweiler placed a wreath entitled “World War II
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
3
Commemorated” at center stage and the following occurred:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I place this wreath in memory of those
in World War II who have gone to their final resting place. Their service has not been
forgotten and will never be forgotten.
... At this time, National Sergeant-At-Arms, Charles D. Aucoin, tolled the bell three times.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Hand salute.
... The Delegation responded with right hand salute, while the American Cabaret Theater
Singers sang taps.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I call on National Sergeant-At-Arms
Charles Aucoin of Louisiana to light the Peace Candle.
... The lighting of the Peace Candle was had.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Please be seated.
... At this time the American Cabaret Theater Singers sang “The White Cliffs of Dover,”
after which the Delegation viewed a video entitled World War II Commemorated.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, our salute to
World War II veterans and their families continues with our first guest.
A U.S. Army veteran of World War II, he served in North Africa, Italy and Europe, but
it wasn’t until after the war that he would make a name for himself. Perhaps you know him
from one of the 63 motion pictures he made, including, The Farmer Takes A Wife, and the
Outcast of Poker Flats.
Or you might remember him from television: Death Valley Days, Tales of Wells
Fargo, and more recently, Dallas, and Dynasty. He’s a proud American who deeply
treasures his family and friends. And he’s a proud veteran of World War II.
Please welcome to our 77th National Convention, Mr. Dale Robertson.
Dale Robertson
Television Actor and World War II Veteran
I’m very, very proud to be here with The American Legion which goes back a long
time in my life.
When I was a young man, a much younger man, I played American Legion Baseball.
I always looked up to and admired the things that The American Legion has stood for.
I went to the Oklahoma Military College in Claremore, Oklahoma. I was going to set
out to be a permanent Army fixture. 1 loved it. I loved the whole idea of the Army at that
time. The school went on to become the third ranking military school in America. First was
West Point, then Annapolis, and then the Oklahoma Military College.
But the war hit just at the wrong time. We were going to graduate the following year
and become officers automatically, but they shut it down. I think it was ASTP or something
like that which came in. So when we went in the service we had to go in to Officers
Training, OTS, but most of us made it from that school. I don’t know of anybody that didn’t
make it.
We went on to different branches of the service. I started out in horse cavalry. They
ran out of horses I guess.
Then I went over into the tank corp, Armored Force they called it. And don’t ask me
how I got from the Armored Force into the engineers. But my buddy and I got orders one
4
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
day to report to Fort Belvoir, Virginia and thereby go to the School For Officers In
Engineering. Now, that school was for men who were brought into the service with
commissions, based on their experience in engineering. For five years of experience you
became a second lieutenant; 10 years a first lieutenant, etc. The school was to teach student
officers to hand salute, how to stand at attention. It didn’t teach anything about
engineering. You were given a problem: Construct a road from Fort Belvoir, Virginia back
to Washington, D.C. on such and such an azimuth; give us a worksheet of how many man
hours it’s going to take; how many people you’re going to need; how much cut and fill. My
buddy and I not only never passed the test, we never even took one. We didn’t know how
to take it.
But we graduated anyway, full-blown engineers.
I was sent to an outfit in San Luis Obispo, California. My first assignment was to
instruct the men on the construction and use of the gin pole. I got out there in front of my
new outfit and tried to explain to them exactly how I got there. “I don’t know why I got
here, but I’m here. Now, I’m supposed to give you instructions on the construction and use
of the gin pole, but there’s two things wrong with that: I don’t know how you use it and I
sure as hell don’t know how you construct it.”
It’s amazing when you get overseas how fast you can learn. First thing you know is
you’re building bridges and roads. We became a part of the 322nd Combat Engineer
Battalion.
I think I was present when one of the most famous statements of the war was made.
We were the spearhead of the 3rd Army. We had been stopping to remove mine fields and
losing eight, 10, 12 men every time we stopped. Every time we would put those men out
there in the field, there were snipers back there who would pick them off.
One day we received an order from General Patton that from hereafter the engineers
will no longer stop to remove the mine fields, but run through them and suffer the casualties.
When I read that to the men one of them hollered out: "Old Blood And Guts. Our blood and
his guts."
I don’t know whether that was where it originated or not. I know it was the first time
I ever heard it. And I know I repeated it many times.
But Patton’s strategy was a great one, because from that time on I don’t think we lost
over a half a dozen men, maybe eight to ten men, I don’t remember now, but we cut our
losses greatly.
We fought that war for a lot of great reasons: Home and country, and we won it
together as Americans.
Now, I’m not sure today that everything we fought for is still in place. We have a
country today that teaches that you can go to jail if you pray in school. Yet we’ve got
freedom of speech. Now you figure that one out.
I see the news media making heroes out of criminals, and making heavies, or let’s say
disrespect, for policemen. They’ll tell you all those stories on the front page. They’re
telling the children of this country that if you want to make the news in our town, if you
want to get on the evening news or on the front page, don’t think you’re going to get there
by helping little old ladies cross the street or by doing anything right. You take a shotgun
and blow the head off one of those little old ladies for no reason and we’ll have you on the
evening news and all your classmates are going to know who you are from there on out.
These are the things that we have to fight against today.
There’s a war on, whether people want to believe it or not. There’s a war on against
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
5
wrong. All of the things that we have fought for in World War II we are now going to have
to fight again but in our own country and not in Germany.
But above it all, I never believed that America was perfect. But I’ve always believed
that it’s the best place in the world to live. I know that we have muddied up our waters; we
have fouled up our air, but all of that was done through technology. There were many
people trying to do something better, and if they fouled it up, then I believe the great
American technology will get after it and get it cleaned up.
Once again, I’m proud to be here; I’m proud to be an American, and I’m proud to be
in Indianapolis today.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you, Dale. Legionnaire you’ll be
happy to know that he’s joined our ranks as a member of The American Legion. Well, I
guess if he could build bridges never having seen the inside of a real engineering school, I
guess he had no problem on those wagon trains and rounding up those cattle.
NATIONAL COMMANDER S REPORT
TO THE CONVENTION
William M. Detweiler (LA)
My report is about what follows in the next three days, the commission and committee
reports that will be presented reflecting the work and accomplishments of this organization
during the past year, what we together have accomplished.
It has been a busy year, a year in which we faced many challenges and many issues.
On numerous occasions the positions and the opinions of The American Legion were sought
by the media and by the general public. By the media because, I suppose, they were
newsworthy; by the general public because they were standing for what they believed in.
We have taken firm stands over this year. We have stood up to the revisionist
historians of the Smithsonian Institution in opposition to the so-called planned Enola Gay
exhibit, an exhibit that was to commemorate the end of World War II, but was nothing
further from the truth.
We stood up for the valor of the men and women whose accomplishments and valor
we commemorate at this Convention: the veterans of World War II. We stood up because
it was the right thing to do, because it was good for America. We stood tall when we argued
for the importance and the integrity of the Smithsonian Institution as a valued institution.
Our position was vindicated by the American people in overwhelming numbers, and even
the liberal media joining with us. We stood up for the history of this country. We said no,
you will not rewrite the proud history of this country. The decision of President Truman to
end a horrible blood bath and save hundreds of thousands of American men and women, and
at the same time save hundreds of thousands of Japanese lives, to make that decision to drop
that bomb was proper; he did the right thing; it was the moral thing, and we have nothing
as a people to apologize for.
And we stood up for the Flag of our country, by continuing and intensifying our efforts
to pass a constitutional amendment to protect the Flag from physical desecration. We have
pledged to put our time, our effort, and yes, our money into these grassroot movements to
see to the passage of this amendment. Not because it’s a veterans’ issue; not because it is
any other issue, or for any other reason, but it is an American issue. It’s the right thing to
6
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
do.
As Dale Robertson said, The American Legion is determined, as he feels strongly, to
preserve the values of this country because it is good for America. We stepped forward and
stood firm on the POW/MIA issue. We sought to keep alive the efforts of the American
people and our government to seek the fullest possible accounting for those who did not
return.
I am personally convinced, after going to Vietnam last winter, that the Vietnamese
continue to play the POW/MIA issue as a trump card to seek financial assistance from the
United States. I am convinced that the Vietnamese continue to withhold information and
documents that would resolve once and for all, many, but not all necessarily, of the fates of
those who did not return.
Last month I met with President Clinton and his staff, eyeball to eyeball in the Cabinet
Room. The American Legion will not break faith with the families of those who did not
return. We are against normalization from the standpoint of economic development or any
other reason which brings dishonor to the valor of those who did not return. It’s the right
thing to do and it’s the proper position to take.
We stepped forward again this year for the third or fourth time in recent years, to help
save the Selective Service System, our insurance policy against aggression.
We helped launch the long awaited memorial to women who have served side by side
with men in the defense of this country. We helped dedicate the long awaited Korean War
Memorial. Why? Because we as a people and we as an organization must never forget and
must never let future generations forget the deeds of the valiant men and women who
answered the call of this country, who asked no questions but gave their talents and time and
their lives, in many instances, to protect the freedoms and the peace that we all enjoy today.
Why? Because it’s the right thing to do. It’s the American thing to do.
During this convention you will be asked to step forward again. You will be asked to
approve a revolutionary approach to VA health care. We did it before, and we are prepared,
as we have been in the past, to do it again.
We stepped forward in the ‘20s and saw to the creation of the VA.
We stepped forward during World War II and saw to the passage of the greatest piece
of social legislation to be passed by the Congress and signed into law this century, the GI
Bill.
Why? Because it was the right thing to do. It was the American thing to do, because
it helped to create an educated America, because it gave those veterans the opportunity to
realize the American dream, to own a home and to raise our families in a better America.
Why? Because it was the right thing to do. It’s the American thing to do.
And we stood up to former Secretary McNamara, an individual who did not have the
backbone to stand up to his President and say no. He is an individual who, in not speaking
out, allowed thousands of America’s best and brightest to lose their lives; suffer individual
atrocities, and whose families do not know where those who did not come back, are lying
today, or whether they are dead or alive.
We have been speaking out this year and doing things that are not necessarily different
than anything we have done in the last 76 years. We are standing for the ideals and for the
principles of the American values that we have stood for since our founding. By our actions
and our deeds this year, we continue to work to protect those American values that form the
fabric of this country. We only did what we did because it was the right thing to do, and
it was good for America So I commend each and every one of you for your loyalty to those
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
7
founding principles. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for the support of my efforts
on behalf of The American Legion and America this year.
I believe that it is a distinct honor, and I have always said that, to be considered as a
candidate for National Commander. It has been an absolute privilege and a pleasure to have
had the opportunity to serve as your National Commander this year. On behalf of my family
and myself, I thank you, and I hope and pray that I have vindicated the trust that you have
placed in me this year.
God bless you; God bless America, and God bless The American Legion. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As a point of personal privilege since we
are all gathered here today, may I introduce my family again to you. First, my wife
Maureen, my oldest son, Scott, Christine, my daughter-in-law, the mother of the young one,
my daughter, Bonnie, a friend Bassan Messaike, my son, Keith, the lawyer, and his friend,
Meg Fineman, my daughter Jenny.
And the young lady that kept my office running over the last 12 months, my secretary,
Robin Castle.
And two close friends who took time out of their busy schedules to be with us today:
Dr. William Reeves of New Orleans and his wife, Sally Kitford Reeves of New Orleans.
Some of you may have seen this gentleman in the parade the other day. He’s 99 years
young. He walked the entire parade. In fact, he sort of ran behind the Alabama banner.
Charles Cook of Post 30 in Alabama. Charlie, it’s great to have you with us.
POW/MIA EMPTY CHAIR DESIGNATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: In this time of commemoration of events
and staggering costs of World War II, it is fitting that we also remember those who were
never accounted for. Vietnam, Korea and World War II left behind families who wondered
about the fate of their loved ones. As has been The American Legion tradition for many
years, we pause to remember the American prisoners of war and those listed as missing in
action from every war.
This morning our POW/MIA flag is placed reverently on an empty chair by Past
National Commander Robert Turner of Georgia, Chairman of the Special POW/MIA
Committee and Alan Hall of Florida, the Chairman of the Foreign Relations Commission,
to remember those who have not returned, whose whereabouts are unknown.
Let this flag remind us all that The American Legion has not forgotten. Let us now
pause for a moment of silence and personal prayer for those missing and their families.
... A moment of silence was observed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time, I call upon our National
Adjutant, Robert W. Spanogle of Michigan, to issue the Call for the Convention.
CONVENTION CALL
for the Seventy-Seventy Annual Convention
of
The American Legion
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: The call for the 77th Annual National
8
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Convention of the American Legion. By the authority of The National Executive
Committee, the 77th Annual National Convention of The American Legion is hereby called
to meet in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995. The convention business sessions
will be held at the Indiana Convention Center Halls “A” and “B” first floor.
PURPOSE
The Annual National Convention is a legislative body of The American Legion. The
convention is called for the purpose of setting the programs of The American Legion for
the ensuing year amending the National Constitution and Bylaws and for the transaction of
such other business that may be brought before it. At twelve o’clock noon on the final
session or at the conclusion of all other business of the National Convention, whichever first
occurs on Wednesday September 6, 1995, officers for the ensuing year will be elected.
These being the National Commander and five National Vice Commanders in that sequence.
REPRESENTATION
Representation in the convention shall be by department and in accordance with the
provisions of the National Constitution (Sec.3, Art.IV)
‘... each department shall be entitled to five delegates and one additional delegate for each
one thousand members or major fraction thereof whose current dues have been received by
the National Treasurer 30 days prior to the meeting of said convention August 7th, and
whose registration fees as fixed by the National Executive Committee for its total authorized
delegate strength have been paid and to one alternate for each delegate.’ (Sec.3, Art.V)
In addition to the above, the members of the National Executive Committee are
Delegates to the National Convention with vote which shall be exercised with their
respective departments, except the vote of the National Commander shall be exercised only
in his capacity as chairman of the National Convention. (Sec. 3, Art. VII)
‘Each duly registered delegate shall be entitled to one vote.’ (Sec. 4, Art. V)
Delegates to the National Convention shall be accredited in writing to the National
Adjutant to the number of manner described by Article 5 of the National Constitution. The
rights of the Departments to make and accredit substitutes for absentee delegates or
alternate delegates shall be recognized by the National Adjutant provided that such
substitutions shall be officially certified by the Department Commander, the Department
Adjutant at the time of certification required by the National Constitution or at any time
prior to the adjournment of the first session of the National Convention.
ALTERNATES
Alternates shall have power to vote only in the absence of regular delegates. The
selection of alternates who represent absent delegates is a matter for decision within the
respective delegations. The vote of any registered delegates absent and not represented by
an alternate shall be cast with the majority of registered delegates present from his or her
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
9
department.
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Meeting of the new National Executive Committee will be held at the call of the
National Commander within 24 hours after the adjournment of the National Convention as
provided by the National Bylaws.
DEPARTMENT OFFICIALS
Department officials, unless elected as delegates or alternates to the National
Convention, have no privileges in this convention except as guests of their respective
departments.
CONVENTION COMMITTEES
The 38th Annual National Convention, through revision of the National Constitution
(Section 6, Article V) directed that the National Executive Committee should provide a
Uniform Code of Procedure for the orderly organization and operation of National
Conventions unless it is amended, suspended, or repealed by a majority vote of the total
authorized representation at a National Convention. Such Code of Procedure was approved
by the National Executive Committee at the October 17, 18, 19, 1956 meeting.
Under the Code, Convention Committees are to be called for organization purposes in
advance of the opening session of the National Convention in the Convention city, with
subsequent meetings as called by the Chairman, providing that all final policy forming
reports shall be approved by such committees in meetings held after the National
Convention is formally convened. Each Department shall designate delegates or alternates
for service on each Convention Committee and shall file with the National Adjutant a list
of such designees at least two weeks prior to the opening session of the Convention. Each
Department must notify its designees of their appointments to committees by mail, stating
the time and place in the Convention city of the initial meetings of the committees.
Departments have the right of substitution of committee members providing proper
credentials are filed with the Temporary Chairman, or later, with the Permanent Secretary
of each Convention committee.
CONVENTION COMMITTEES
CONVENTION COMMITTEE
1. Americanism
2. Children & Youth
3. Constitutional Amendments
4.
Credential & Internal Affairs
Credentials & Other Internal Matters (Sec. I&II)
Membership (Sec. Ill)
Number of Members
to which each
Department is entitled
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
10
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
5. Economic
Employment & Veterans Preference
Other Economic Matters
6. Finance
7. Foreign Relations
8. Legislation & Rules
9. National Security Committee Joint Meeting
(Includes Aerospace, Defense Civil Preparedness,
Merchant Marine, Military Affairs, Naval Affairs,
Law & Order Convention Committees)
IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING NATIONAL SECURITY
JOINT MEETING
Aerospace
Merchant Marine
Military Affairs
Naval Affairs
Law and Order
10. Veterans Affairs & Rehabilitation
Claims & Rating
Hospitals and Medical Services
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
CREDENTIALS
Each Delegation Secretary arriving in advance of his delegation will bring with him
properly executed in triplicate, the official “Certification of Delegates and Alternates,”
which must contain the following information:
1. Name of Department
2. Number of Posts in the Department
3. Paid-up membership at the close of business, August 8, 1994 according to the books
of National Treasurer.
4. Delegation Chairman.
5. Delegation Secretary.
6. Names, addresses and post affiliations of delegates.
7. Names, addresses and post affiliates of alternates.
8. Signature of Department Commander, attested by
Department Adjutant.
DELEGATION HEADQUARTERS
Each delegation will establish headquarters in the hotel to which assigned. Upon
arrival in Indianapolis, all members of a Department delegation will report to their respective
delegation headquarters. They will receive all necessary instructions from the Secretary of
the delegation and will not report to the National Adjutant.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Mr. Commander, this concludes the Call for
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
11
the 77th National Convention of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWE1LER: I now declare the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion regularly convened.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is the man who for the
past seven years has been the leader of the Hoosier State. He began his term as governor,
set among his priorities improving education. In his time, he has developed into an
educational leader. Serving as the Chairman of the National Education Goals Panel and has
been Chairman of the Education Commission of the States and one of just two governors
on the National Assessment in Education Panel. Several publications have watched his
efforts with a keen eye and have found him to be one of the top governors in the nation in
terms of fiscal management. It is my pleasure to present to you the Governor of the great
State of Indiana, Evan Bayh.
THE HONORABLE EVAN BAYH
Governor of Indiana
On behalf of five and a half million Hoosiers, it’s an honor for me to welcome all of
you from across our country here to our fair state for your annual convention. I’m not going
to go on at great length. As a matter of fact, you can all relax, I’m not running for anything
this year.
I’m reminded of the wisdom of a local minister who invited me to his congregation on
a very important public occasion and walked up into the pulpit and looked out at a very
sizeable audience like this. It was being broadcast all over live radio in central Indiana. This
is a true story. He looked out at the congregation, spoke very clearly into the microphone
and said, “Governor, we humbly request that you be strong today, not long today.’ So I
followed his advice and it seemed to work pretty well, and I’ll try to do that again here
today.
I would like to acknowledge and salute the very able leadership of your National
Commander Bill Detweiler. I see my friend, Bob Spanogle, is here doing an able job with
your National Headquarters. Also, Bill Jackson and Dutch Bole and the very able leaders
of our Indiana Department who have done such a fine job. Also, my First Lady would give
me a very hard time when I go home if I don’t acknowledge the leadership of your National
Auxiliary who are with us here today.
I’d like to make just three main points and then we’ll get on with the convention. You
can hear from our mayor and, I believe, one of our senators today and several other
distinguished speakers.
First, I’d like to say how very proud we are as Hoosiers of The American Legion. We
are proud of your service to our country, we are proud of your service to our state. It is an
unceasing source of pride to us to have your National Headquarters located here in the state
of Indiana. It’s an honor for us and one that we acknowledge repeatedly on occasions like
this and others where veterans and citizens who care about the future of our country and
state have gathered.
If you have occasion during this convention to have some time to walk around
Indianapolis, you will see very tangible evidence of the pride that we have in the Legion and
for men and women who have served our country in time of war. The very center of our
12
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
state, the circle, the center of the focal point of our state capital, the center of Indiana, the
financial hub, has in its very midst a wonderful War Memorial to those who gave their lives
during the Civil War. Up on the War Memorial Plaza you will see other monuments that
stand giving testimony and paying tribute to those who served our country in time of armed
conflict. I’m proud to indicate today, for those of you who will come back and visit us in the
future, that next May 24th we will unveil a new memorial commemorating the service and
the sacrifice of those who served our country during the Korean and the Vietnam Wars.
I had a chance to review the outline of this memorial several months ago. I think you’ll
find that it’s a fitting tribute to those men and women, and it will stand as eloquent
testimony to their service to our country as well. So we are proud of The American Legion
and we thank you for your service.
The second point that I would like to make today is that there’s someone representing
the Boy Scouts who will be speaking to the conference a little later today. Assuming, that
is, in fact, not a Boy Scout, I may be the youngest speaker today at age 39. And on behalf
of the people of a younger generation, I would like to thank those of you who gave of your
youth so that we might enjoy ours. Those of you who sacrificed and your colleagues who,
in fact, gave their lives so that we could inherit the country that we see today that is
prosperous and proud and free. And I hope that we can follow your example which is,
perhaps, the most eloquent testimony that we can give of gratitude, and dedicate ourselves
to insuring that our country remains the kind of great world leader that you have handed
down to us.
Along those lines, I would like to salute the leadership of the Legion. For those of you
who haven’t had a chance to go to see a Boys State or a Girls State, I encourage you to do
that. I try and go to our Boys State every year that I can. It is a wonderful thing for those
of you who think that all of our country’s youth have dropped out and tuned out, and don’t
care, are couch potatoes and just members of the me-generation. Let me tell you that you
in the Legion are doing yeoman’s work in insuring that the concepts of patriotism and
sacrifice and heroism remain alive and well in the hearts of our young people. You owe it
to yourselves to see the kind of contribution that you are making through Boys State and
Girls State. So I want to thank you for that on behalf of all of the citizens of our state, but
particularly young people as well.
The final thing I would like to say today is that, in a democracy, memories tend to be
very short. Just more than 50 years ago we celebrated the end of the war in the Pacific, a
victory over Japan. It’s been just more than 20 years since the Vietnam War came to a
conclusion for the Americans who were fighting in that conflict. And we have a way of
focusing on the positive in our countiy. We are a peaceful nation. But for those of you who
have served in the armed forces during time of the armed conflict, it is vitally important that
you let those who are younger and have no living memory of such things know that concepts
such as freedom aren’t just words that we use during speeches like this, but are concepts that
are paid for with lives and with blood. And that if we are to remain a free countiy, and if our
children are to inherit from us the kind of world we would like to see them have, it is thanks
to those who are willing to put actions behind those concepts, those of you here today.
And so I would just like to conclude with the words of a decorated veteran who was
sworn into office as the youngest president in the history of our country. He concluded his
inaugural address by saying that, with a clear conscious, with history being the final judge
of our deeds. Let us go forward to lead this land we love asking for His help and for His
blessing but remembering always that here on earth God’s work must truly be our own.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
13
To those of you in The American Legion, to those of you who have served our country
and occasionally been through hell and back to do his work, I say, thank you. 1 say,
welcome. I hope you enjoy your stay with us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you Governor. It’s great to have
you back.
The state that hosts The American Legion National Convention always has plenty to
do to get ready for such a gathering. For Indiana, preparing for this National Convention
provided many extra challenges. And the leadership of Indiana, I can truly say, met them
all. They brought the convention to Indianapolis, pulling together plenty of details in just
six months, instead of the usual five years.
Please give a warm welcome to a U.S. Army veteran of the Korean era and a member
of Charles Pratt Post No. 94 in Valparaiso, Indiana, the 1995-96 Indiana Department
Commander Tom Henderson.
THOMAS HENDERSON
INDIANA DEPARTMENT COMMANDER
1995 - 1996
Thank you, Commander. Delegates to the 77th National Convention of the American
Legion, on behalf of the 140,000 Legionnaires of The Department of Indiana, I wish to
welcome you to the great state of Indiana and its beautiful capital, Indianapolis. The
Department of Indiana Convention Corporation has worked very hard to make your visit to
Indianapolis meaningful, memorable and fun. We absolutely have no objection if you wish
to leave large amounts of currency in and around the Indianapolis area. Be sure to take in
the many attractions the area has to offer and have a safe and enjoyable stay in our state.
We are very serious about our Hoosier hospitality, so do not hesitate to call on us if we can
be of any assistance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We truly appreciate the work of the
Indiana Department its preparation for this convention, because I know it was quite a chore.
The Chair now recognizes the distinguished Chairman of the National Convention
Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs, a gentleman that did yeoman work this year
on the Enola Gay issue along with myself and the Director of Internal Affairs. The Chair
recognizes Herman Harrington of New York for the purpose of a report.
REPORT OF SECTION ON CREDENTIALS
AND OTHER INTERNAL MATTERS
(of Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs)
Section I
Herman G. Harrington (NY), Chairman
It is a pleasure for me to report to the 77th Annual Convention of The American Legion
here assembled at Indianapolis. 48 members and guests of the section on Credentials and
Other Internal Affairs met at 9 a.m., September 2, 1995, in Room 101, first level of the
Indianapolis Convention Center, Indianapolis, Indiana. Herman G. Harrington from New
14
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
York was elected chairman and Larry J. Besson of Illinois was elected secretary. It was
regularly moved, seconded and carried to accept the delegate strength report as reported by
the National Adjutant certifying the membership of this organization 30 days prior to the
National Convention. It was regularly moved and seconded and carried that the report be
based upon the provisions of Section 3, Article 5, of the National Constitution to which five
delegates for each department plus one additional delegate for each one thousand members
or major fraction thereof whose current dues have been received by the National Treasurer
30 days prior to the opening of the convention, August 7, 1995, and one alternate for each
delegate.
In addition, in accordance with Section 3, Article 7, members of the National Executive
Committee, which committee includes the National Commander who exercises his vote only
in his capacity as Chairman of the National Convention and five National Vice Commanders
are delegates to the National Convention. All living Past National Commanders are
members of the National Executive Committee without vote and life delegates to the
National Convention with vote which is exercised in their respective departments.
Motion was adopted by majority vote of the committee, the chairman and secretary be
authorized to sign the committee report on behalf of the committee. In accordance with the
membership reports certified to the Convention Committee on Credentials and Internal
Affairs by the National Adjutant on August 7, 1995, and in accordance with Article 5 of the
National Constitution, the voting strength of the 55 departments is 3,311 which is allocated
as follows:
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Dist. Of Columbia
Florida
France
Georgia
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
32
16
43
31
162
32
39
16
10
127
9
53
104
136
28
73
19
70
13
32
91
21
220
54
34
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Mexico
Pennsylvania
Philippines
Puerto Rico
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
10
17
167
145
86
63
40
47
34
92
78
8
275
10
16
16
31
35
42
102
16
24
59
47
36
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
174
38
36
Wisconsin
Wyoming
15
88
14
Mr. Commander, as a duly elected delegate from the Department of New York I move
for the adoption of this report.
... The motion was duly seconded and carried.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Let’s look back five years to 1990. The
American Legion National Convention came to its home here in Indianapolis. I found that
our next guest was described then, as he is now, as a busy man. But not much has changed.
He’s a busy man who stepped forward a few months back to put committees together and
to meet every challenge that was presented. It’s always great to give a busy man something
else to do because he gets the job done. A veteran of United States Army and World War
II, he is a member of Post 250 Mitchell, Indiana. Please welcome the President of the
American Legion National Convention Corporation of Indiana, Gilbert ‘Gib’ Sheeks.
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL
CONVENTION CORPORATION OF INDIANA
Gilbert E. Sheeks (IN), President
Commander Detweiler, National Officers, Guests and Delegates. As the Commander
said some short time ago, we undertook the task of hosting the 1995 National Convention.
I thank those wonderful people from Indiana who have worked to make it comfortable and
make you welcome here. As you leave here Wednesday, we hope that you will have the
feeling in your heart that you would like to return to Hoosierland sometime in the future.
Commander, to you and all the Delegates and all the wonderful people that are
assembled, welcome to Indiana. We hope you enjoy your stay and please come back.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next guest is a respected leader of
the nation’s 12th largest city, the city The American Legion has been proud to call home
since 1919. He’s earned a reputation as one of the nation’s most innovative mayors, leading
cost saving efforts, increased service, lower cost and hold the line on taxes. Please give a
warm welcome to the Mayor of Indianapolis, the Honorable Steve Goldsmith, Mayor.
THE HONORABLE STEPHEN GOLDSMITH
Mayor of Indianapolis
Welcome back. We are delighted to have you back so quickly. I’m a little
disappointed that the introduction didn’t mention that I’m a 15-year member of The
American Legion, which should have come before I was listed as mayor.
I may be the last one in my post to pay his yearly dues, but I do get it done. In a whole
range of ways, first, we in Indianapolis are proud that you have allowed us to call you
residents of the city of Indianapolis and that we are allowed to be hosts of The American
Legion National Headquarters. It’s an honor for the city of Indianapolis to be able to have
you day by day and month by month in the center of our city. It’s a double honor, then,
when you bring your National Convention back to the city of Indianapolis.
16
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
I must say I enjoyed the parade as I ran along seeing a number of people, all of whom
were happy and pleased to be here. I think the weather had a little bit to do with it. The
Legion’s sponsorship of the SkyConcert that night, I thought, brought a patriotic cast to the
evening’s activities which were delightful for all of us.
And finally, Indianapolis. We’re the 12th largest city. Of all the large cities in the
country we have more public space dedicated to saying thanks to those who have given their
lives and sacrifice for our country than any large city in the country. And the large
American Legion Mall, the Soldiers and Sailors Monument, the World War Memorial, the
new USS Indianapolis Memorial, the areas that we have set aside to pay tribute to those who
fought in the Vietnam Conflict, all of those things, I think, bring to us a great sense of pride.
We in Indianapolis, I think, are much better off because we are able to have the values and
the patriotism and the sacrifice that The American Legion stands for in our home,
Indianapolis. And we thank you for coming back again this year. Thanks so much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair at this time recognizes Charles
Pesso of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Legislation and
Rules for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
LEGISLATION AND RULES
Charles Pesso (NY), Chairman
Mr. Commander, Officers of The American Legion and my fellow Delegates. The
Convention Committee on Legislation and Rules met at 10:00 a.m. on September 2nd, 1995,
in Room 209 of the Indiana Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. There were 45
delegates and 23 guests in attendance. Following preliminary activities to officially
organize the committee, the permanent chairman and secretary were elected. I, Charles
Pesso, a delegate from New York, was elected chairman and Claude Carpenter, a delegate
from Arkansas, was elected secretary.
The committee then proceeded to the business agenda by considering the rules of this
convention. A motion was approved by the committee to recommend adoption of the
Standing Rules of the Convention as they appear in the Uniform Code of Procedures for
Organizing National Conventions of The American Legion.
A motion was also approved to authorize the chairman and the secretary to sign the
report on behalf of the Convention Committee on Legislation and Rules. Patrick Ryan,
Democratic counsel and staff director for the House Veterans Affairs Committee, addressed
the convention committee regarding the budgetary concerns facing the Department of
Veterans Affairs. Since there were no resolutions referred to the committee for
consideration, the Legislation and Rules Committee wishes to offer to the delegates to this
convention a brief report on current congressional developments affecting issues of primary
interest to The American Legion.
The 104th Congress, under Republican leadership for the first time in 40 years, has set
an aggressive agenda to dramatically reduce the federal deficit and to substantially reform
the federal government. In June after much debate, Congress adopted a budget resolution
crafted to balance the federal budget within the next seven fiscal years.
This blueprint has established targeted funding levels through fiscal year 2002. Many
federal programs have been recommended for termination while others are slated for deep
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
17
budgetary cuts beginning in fiscal year 1996. Under this budget resolution, the Department
of Veterans Affairs funding will average about one percent annual growth rate. This
progression projection of minimal budget increases will force VA to make dramatic changes.
Every program dependent on discretionary funding will be impacted by these budgetary
limitations. Health care delivery, medical and prosthetics research, construction, the
National Cemetery System, the processing of claims and the adjudication of appeals will feel
these financial shortfalls.
Congress faces a very busy schedule. Appropriation bills will receive much attention
as the fiscal year deadline approaches. This year, The American Legion has already
presented testimony before nine appropriation subcommittees and will continue to play an
active role as these funding proposals are finalized.
President Clinton has expressed his disapproval of several of the House passed
appropriation bills and plans to exercise his veto power unless compromises are reached.
This threat could be backed up by a shutting down of the federal government. Such a
maneuver would have a devastating affect on the entire nation. The American Legion
continues to be deeply involved in the debates concerning VA reform. Repeatedly, The
American Legion has reminded Congress that 27 million veterans and the government’s
largest medical care delivery system cannot and must not be ignored.
The American Legion seeks eligibility reform that provides all veterans with a
guaranteed comprehensive medical benefits package. The VA medical system must have
constant and dependable funding sources that will adequately provide for needed medical
services. This will include retaining all third-party reimbursements for reinvestment into the
system. The VA must receive an initial financial transfusion to revamp its service delivery
system. The VA must retain its unique specialized missions in rehabilitation, prosthetics,
spinal cord injury, blindness, aging, mental health, and long-term care. And, finally, the VA
must continue to be a national asset in medical attention and medical education, medical
and prosthetics research and as a backup to the Department of Defense medical system.
As the National Legislative Commission Chairman, I must take this opportunity to
publicly thank the millions of Legionnaires, Auxiliary members, Sons of The American
Legion and other concerned Americans who have worked so long and so hard for the
protection of the American Flag.
The overwhelming support in the House of
Representatives Flag Amendment vote was truly generated by the grass roots of America.
Old Glory still has one last battle on Capitol Hill and that is in the United States Senate.
This campaign is so close to victory. Please contact your senators, urge their support for
Senate Joint Resolution 31, a Constitutional Amendment to protect the American Flag from
physical desecration.
On September 18th and 19th of this year, Legionnaires from across the United States
will accompany the new National Commander to Capitol Hill. Their mission will be to
discuss the legislative mandates of The American Legion with their congressional members.
The highlight of this event will be the National Commander’s testimony before a joint
session of the Senate and House Veterans Affairs Committees.
Mr. Commander, as a duly authorized delegate from the Department of New York to
this convention, I move the adoption of this report and the adoption of the standing rules of
the convention as they appear in the Uniform Code of Procedures for Organizing National
Conventions of The American Legion.
.. . The motion was duly seconded and carried.
18
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next speaker represents an
organization that has had the full support of The American Legion for 77 years, the Boy
Scouts of America. Jere Radcliffe took over the leadership of the Boy Scouts of America
in 1993, the job which provides considerable challenges. As National Commander and
doubly as an Eagle Scout, it is my pleasure to introduce to the delegates of this convention
the Chief Scout Jere Radcliffe.
BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA
Jere Radcliffe, Chief Scout Executive
I’m very much honored to be a part of such a long and distinguished line of presenters
and speakers that you have at your convention. As a matter of fact, I somewhat can relate
to the story of the Chicago Bulls’ basketball player, Stacey King. One night during his
rookie year, his famous teammate, Michael Jordan, scored 69 points. Stacey King’s night
was not so good. He scored only one point. But after the game a reporter wanted Stacey’s
reaction. Stacey said, “Well, I will always remember this as the night that Michael and I
combined for 70 points.”
It’s a great combination of the Boy Scouts of America and The American Legion and
its various Auxiliaries. Together we make a difference in the lives of young people across
America.
It’s exciting to be back in Indianapolis. A little over a year ago your Adjutant and I,
Bob Spanogle, had the opportunity to do a video together that promotes scouting within The
American Legion. It’s out on the road and it’s been well received. I appreciate that
opportunity to expand scouting.
My very first assignment in scouting happened to be in the state of South Carolina in
the upper part of that state, in the area of Greenville where I came to know one of your great
past commanders and one of your great scout leaders, E. Roy Stone, Jr. I look forward to
seeing him here today.
Another part of my background that might be of interest to you is that I took a
sabbatical through the years 1971 to 1974. I served as a district representative for U.S.
Congressman Floyd Spence in the second district of South Carolina. Then I served in the
Armed Services Committee, as it was called in those days, then as chairman of the House
National Security Committee, and then served on the Veterans Affairs Committee. So, I’m
well attuned to the concerns and needs of The American Legion. From a personal
experience, I’m very thankful for the relationship of Scouting and The American Legion.
As a member of Explorer Post 6, Springfield, Ohio, sponsored by the Kultis Ward Post
6,1 had the experience of being Explorer Scout. That experience set for me the direction
in which I have found that I have gone during my life. An Explorer advisor by the name of
Ralph Welch, who is no longer living, had a significant impact on many of the decisions I
still make today.
As was mentioned in the introductions, Scouting and the Legion have been together
since your first convention in 1919. Over those years, it’s been a very profitable partnership
for the organization and particularly for America’s young people. I’m proud to report to you
that within the Scouting units sponsored by Legion and Auxiliary and other units of The
American Legion, that you serve over 72,800 youth and almost 2500 scouts.
And in these times and days when it seems that every American institution that stands
up for something is declining, I’m glad to tell you that over the past four years your increase
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
19
in Scouting has been in excess of 15 percent. And I think there’s some very good reasons
why it makes good sense for our relationship with two organizations. Your Preamble states
clearly some very specific points of significance. Service to God and country, uphold and
defend the Constitution of the United States of America and an individual obligation to
community, state and to nation.
Reflected in the Boy Scout principles are these thoughts: Duty to God and country,
flag, education, character development and citizenship training and community service. I
think nowhere has this relationship been reflected better lately than in the May issue of The
American Legion Magazine. We read an article that stresses the Scouts and Legion working
together on Memorial Day to give tribute to our veterans.
A little story that occurred recently about one of your Scouting units occurred through
the Scout troop that’s sponsored by American Legion Post 784 in Cahokia, Illinois. That
troop has been there for the past 44 years. But a Life Scout by the name of Tommy O’Guinn
recently saved the life of another in a swimming pool near Salem, Missouri.
What makes this story a little more interesting is that the Scout troop, sponsored by the
American Legion Post in Cahokia, is a Scout troop organized for underprivileged or
economically deprived youngsters in that community, given an outreach that would not
occur if that American Legion Post was not there and giving that service.
Another thing that I have noticed about scouting in our organizations is that
Legionnaires tend to stick with things. The fact that the average tenure of one of your Scout
troops is about five times greater than the typical Scout troop across America. You have
many troops that have been in existence since their local posts were organized in the early
times of your movement. So I think my message says it pretty clearly, we’re here because
we are on the same team.
All we have to do today is pick up the newspaper or look at the television set and we
soon come to realize the tremendous challenge that it is to be a youngster in 1995. It’s
related to all types of social and family problems and problems to understand fundamental
responsibilities and to be able to adapt and adopt to a responsible lifestyle. We and our
young people are very much in a state of flux. We’ve seen this trend which is somewhat
detrimental and very negative develop over the past several years. We find that occurs for
one reason because families oftentimes are so engaged in the simple effort of trying to make
ends meet that they lack the time and the effort to be role models and the influence for
positive values that their children should have. We are calloused in many cases to some of
these circumstances.
Last week in the community I live, Fort Worth, Texas, we had a case where a teenager
killed two other teenagers. He knew them. Why did he kill them? To steal a stereo out of
an automobile, a stereo worth $1,000. Before he was caught he tried to pass this off for
$240. A sad story that equates to a sad commentary about things that affect our children, and
the children we are interested in, and the communities we live in.
Much of this, we know, is because of the absence of strong positive role models. In
this changing environment for young people, there is a growing complexity of decisions that
they have to make that will impact their lives. The degree to which they make these
decisions and apply ethics to these decisions will not only influence their lives, but will
truly influence the lives of every community across this great nation.
I had the opportunity a month ago to be in the Czech Republic. Right after the breakup
of the communist block, Scouting began to emerge again in those countries. I met with a
man who had been imprisoned in a concentration camp for 11 years when the communists
20
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
took over, simply because he was a leader in their Scouting movement. He has returned to
be the head of that movement which in some four years has already enrolled some 77,000
young people. I asked him why was he involved? What did he expect? You know,
sometimes when you don’t have something and then you come by it later, you put a little
more value on it than if you had it all along. I know many of you in your lives may feel that
way sometimes.
I asked what did he expect from the Scouting movement with his own people. He
simply said they must develop leadership with values. I had the opportunity last winter to
be out in a new republic of Palau out in Kongauru. And for some of you who come from
the World War II era, if you did time in the Pacific, you know that Kongauru is just a
neighbor to Peleliu. This is an emerging republic. I talked to the president. He is the third
president of Palau, the first two being assassinated. These people are trying to come forth
with a democracy in the 20th century and 21st centuries. I asked him why did he want
Scouting and why did they put a high value on Scouting there. He said, simply because they
must be able to maintain their traditional values in their young people and at the same time
prepare them for the dramatic change that’s going to occur in the world that they live in.
They must maintain their traditional values and prepare for the changes.
Since 1910, the Boy Scouts of America has tried to be monitors of these values. As
we’ve seen values shrink and the ability to make decisions change, we decided a few months
ago to do a study with Lou Harris and Associates from New York. The study was on the
values of men and boys in America. I won’t bore you with all the details, but there were
some results and outcomes of that study that could shock you.
Youngsters in Grades 1 through 12 were asked the following questions, with their
responses: Have you cheated on a homework test recently? 54 percent said yes. Have you
been drunk? 28 percent said yes. Shoplifted? 24 percent said yes. Used drugs like
marijuana, speed? 17 percent said yes. Carried a gun to school? 5 percent said yes.
What the study showed was that as boys become older, this rate of incident multiplies.
And I think it says something to those of us interested in young people. It says we have to
start early and we have to continue. We have to recognize and reinforce positive thoughts
and positive values and ethical behavior early, or it gets away as they get older. This is a
tremendous challenge that faces us all.
We found, too, in this study that the vast majority of those who had been in Scouting
had a different outcome to the response of these questions. And the longer they had been
in Scouting, the better those outcomes were. They seemed to be more socially responsible.
Men who had been in Scouting truly carried that influence forward with them throughout
their lives. They believed in family values. They believed that character growth is fostered
in Scouting and in the family and in other organizations. It is significant that we should
foster that.
Perhaps the most important conclusion that whole study presents to us is that men and
boys in this country need positive role models to reinforce the behavior they should choose.
Many six-year-olds in this country are making decisions from the time they get up in the
morning until they go to bed at night because a parent isn’t there. No one tells them that they
have a respect and a concern for their well-being.
We look at the Legion and the Boy Scouts of America going forward, as we meet this
21st century. I think the values and the representations of those that we see from this
study, and other studies we know about, give us a reason to refocus our efforts on being
advocates for traditional values for young people. Scouting will continue to work diligently
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
21
in cooperation with the Legion and other chartered organizations to assure that those role
models and those values are present for our young people. I think that’s the important
component of our partnership.
As I wind down here, let me challenge you as you go back home to your communities,
to your local Legion organization, to make a contact with your local Scout council. Let us
look back on the rich heritage that we have of 76 years in a partnership and say it can be just
as valuable and important today as ever, because of values we stand for; of those of duty to
God and country and responsible citizenship.
Make a contact with your local Scout council and offer your post or your own services
to be a role model, to be involved, to make a program like Scouting important in your
community. Help in other ways to support the idea that more youngsters should have this
experience.
I close with this little story. A grandfather and a grandson were walking on the beach
one day. The grandfather was picking up starfish and sand dollars which had been thrown
ashore by the tide. There were thousands of them up and down the beach. And yet he
would reach down, pick up one, and throw it back out. Finally the grandson asked him why
he was doing that, as there were thousands of sand dollars there. How can he possibly make
a difference by throwing a few back?
To answer him the grandfather simply reached down, picked up another sand dollar and
threw it back into the ocean. It makes a difference to that one. It makes a difference to that
one.
Scouting is a relationship, not only through scouting but through all your programs,
whether it be baseball, scholarships, or whatever it is, makes a difference. It’s the character
and the moral fiber and the values of leadership that will make the difference. It’s an
understanding of the constitutional government and an understanding of that flag. And I’m
happy to say the Boy Scouts of America was one to sign on in support of you for the Flag
Amendment.
The American flag is the primary symbol of our country and we applaud The American
Legion and the Citizens Flag Alliance (CFA) in their quest to secure the flag-protection
amendment. The Boy Scouts of America will do everything in its power to see that this
important measure becomes the law of the land. The American Legion and Boy Scouts of
America are partners in patriotism, and I can think of no greater act of patriotism than to do
what the vast majority of American citizens want—protect the flag of their country.
The one point is: You make a difference. We in Scouting thank you for that. We
appreciate you. We certainly believe, as you do, that America can be fundamentally sound
if we don’t lose the foundations of value that we’re built on. Thank you for all that you’ve
done and do for this country. Thank you for who you are. And above all, thank you for
what you believe in. Thank you, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I want to make sure that every Delegate
in this hall heard that commitment by the Boy Scouts of America to support the amendment
to protect the United States Flag from physical desecration. Now, we have the little roots.
Let’s utilize those little roots and make them feel a part of an histpric movement for the
people. This is the first time in the history of this country that an amendment to the
Constitution is coming from the people. It’s good that our youth, through the Boy Scouts
of America, are joining with us.
22
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
... At this time, the Delegation viewed a video.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Periodically during the meeting you will be
seeing vignettes and stories that were told and recorded here by some of our Legionnaires
who are present at the Convention, as part of this commemoration.
PRESENTATION OF PLAQUE
Minneapolis, Minnesota
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next order of business is to
recognize the city of Minneapolis, Minnesota. I hold a special place in my heart for
Minneapolis, the site of The American Legion’s first Convention, and the city where the
Delegates elected me as National Commander.
To help with this order of business, I call on Immediate Past National Commander,
Bruce Thiesen of California to make this presentation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER THIESEN: Commander Detweiler, distinguished
guests and Delegates to this, the 77th National Convention.
It is an honor for me to make this presentation, on behalf of myself, my family, those
National Officers that served you in the Diamond Jubilee Year of The American Legion, but
also the National staff. Through the efforts of those who were in charge of the Minneapolis
Convention Corporation under the presidency of Don Schroedl, and of course the
chairmanship of Steve George, it was a success. I can assure you that as I traveled from
Pittsburgh around this country and around the world representing The American Legion in
its Diamond Jubilee Year, we could have found no better place to end what I consider a very
successful year in coming home to Minneapolis to culminate 75 years of The American
Legion.
So on behalf The American Legion, I would like to bring Don Schroedl, the President
of the Minneapolis Convention Corporation, and present to the city of Minneapolis, and to
its Mayor, Sharon Sayles Belton, a Plaque of Appreciation. It states:
The American Legion, in appreciation of the hospitality of the City of
Minneapolis in commemorating the 76th Annual National Convention of
The American Legion, 1994.
It’s attested, signed by myself, the National Commander at that time, attested by Robert
Spanogle, the National Adjutant, and of course Don Schroedl, the President of The
American Legion Convention Corporation of Minneapolis.
Don, on behalf of myself, The American Legion and its three million members, I
would like to present this to the mayor of the city of Minneapolis.
DONALD SCHROEDL
President, The American Legion National Convention
Corporation of Minnesota, Inc.
Mayor Sharon Sayles Belton wants me to express her regrets that she cannot be here
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
23
today to accept this plaque. We have made arrangements with her office that I will present
this plaque to her at a city council meeting later this month.
The hotel and restaurant association, as well as the business community of the city of
Minneapolis and the state of Minnesota want to thank you for coming to our Convention last
year. Minneapolis has hosted four previous conventions. We had the first Convention in
1919, then again in 1959, 1975, and then last year in 1994. We had a great time and
convention. We look forward in the near future to The American Legion coming back to
Minneapolis again.
CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION
Rev. Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: When we recite the Preamble to The
American Legion Constitution, we begin with the words: “For God and Country.”
Since 1919, Legionnaires have remained committed to that lofty purpose for everything
they do. For the past year, it has been a privilege to serve with a man who has dedicated his
life to the highest ideals of such service.
The Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., served in the United States Navy during World War II.
He has served as the South Carolina Department Chaplain and as Chaplain of American
Legion Post 65 in Saluda, South Carolina. It is with great pride that I present to Reverend
Pryor this Certificate of Appreciation for his caring and devoted service to The American
Legion.
The American Legion Certificate of Appreciation is presented to the
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr., appointed and served as National Chaplain of
The American Legion, 1994-1995, given in recognition of faithful and
honorable service to The American Legion.
It’s attested to by Robert W. Spanogle, our National Adjutant, and signed by myself
as National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair now recognizes Eugene
Lindquist of Minnesota, the Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Children
and Youth for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
CHILDREN & YOUTH
Eugene V. Lindquist (MN), Chairman
The Convention Committee on Children & Youth met at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday,
September 2nd, 1995 in the Indianapolis Convention Center, Room 116. The meeting was
organized by electing Delegate Eugene Lindquist of Minnesota as Chairman, and Delegate
Elmer Fuhrhop of Ohio as Secretary. There were 47 members present at this meeting.
There were no resolutions brought before this Committee for consideration.
We’re just completing our “Seeds for Sight” program in conjunction with the
Foundation Fighting Blindness, which you have known before as the Retinitis Pigmentosa
24
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Foundation. This program has been very successful. There is still some money coming in,
but so far, The American Legion Child Welfare Foundation has received $39,108.65 as its
share of the 50 percent split from the proceeds of this activity. I would like to thank the
Departments of Michigan and Ohio for their great participation and the money that they
gave to this program. That is almost $10,000.00 more than the whole 1993 coupon project
generated and with a lot less administrative work from the staff and volunteers. I thank all
of the Posts and Units that took time to make this activity such a success. It means a great
deal to our Foundation to continue to receive these types of donations that are above and
beyond their regular contributions that are sent.
In conclusion, and as Vice President of the American Legion Child Welfare Foundation
Board of Directors, I thank all those who have supported us through this past year and
sincerely hope you will continue by making your contributions an annual event.
I would also like to thank the SAL Detachments and Squadrons for all they have done.
While it seems incredible that they gave more to the Foundation in the 1993-1994
contribution year than The American Legion, you might be surprised to learn that this past
1994-1995 year they did it again. This time however, they beat the Legion by almost
$4,000.00, by contributing $87,715.28. When you consider the size of our membership and
the number of Posts with the size of their membership and their number of Squadrons, it is
hard to understand how this can happen. We need much more active participation by
individual members of the Legion and from all other Posts, Districts and Departments.
I challenge all of you to take this message back to your Posts and Departments so that
when this report is given next year, we can proudly say that for the 1995-1996 contribution
year, The American Legion was responsible for at least $100,000.00 in donations to the
Foundation. This is a goal that should be easily attainable for this organization of three
million members. The American Legion Department of Florida, for example, this past year
raised just under $20,000.00 by itself, and we commend them for this effort.
Mr. Commander, this concludes my report. 1 move for the adoption of the report.
... National Vice Commander Vernon K. Grosenick assumed the Chair.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
BLOOD DRIVE
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Today is Labor Day. Millions of
Americans are enjoying the three day weekend. At holiday times the blood supply tends to
dwindle. The American Legion National Convention Blood Drive is designed to help.
Today, Delegates are providing critical supplies for the VA Flospital and several other
hospitals in Indianapolis.
This year the National Convention Blood Drive is even more remarkable. Not only are
they collecting whole blood to meet needs but, for the first time, other donors are providing
plasma and platelets, critical blood products.
This is our ninth year for the National Convention Blood Drive. Friday, the opening
day of the drive, 66 units were collected. That’s a good start. But in the next two days I
hope to see the number reach nearly 300 units of blood.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
25
THE AMERICAN LEGION DISPA TCH
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: It’s timely, it’s topical, it’s
thought-provoking. It’s The American Legion Dispatch, the national newspaper of our
organization. Subscribers can receive a collector’s pin if they sign up during the National
Convention.
BUICK PROMOTION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: It’s also appropriate to call your
attention to the display of beautiful 1996 Buicks in the exhibit area. Many of you have been
stopping by, dropping your donations off, and crossing your fingers. Someone will leave
on Wednesday knowing that they have won a 1996 Buick LeSabre. Because of everyone’s
interest, The American Legion-Buick Baseball Scholarship will be strengthened.
CONVENTION OPENING VIDEO
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Before we gavel this Convention
to a close on Wednesday, more than a dozen video productions are re-enforcing the theme:
“World War II Commemorated.” You can purchase a VHS tape with all of these
productions. Place your order at the Emblem Sales booth in the exhibit area. The cost is
$11.95, which includes tax and shipping.
CFA PHONE BANK/POST CARD
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: We are dealing with a wide range
of issues important to all veterans during our 77th National Convention. One of the most
important legislative efforts our organization has undertaken in recent years is seeking
protection of the American Flag from physical desecration. You have an important role to
play in this campaign. Stop by the Phone Bank and Post Card Station at the east end of the
exhibit area and take the time to call or write your Senator to express your support for a
Constitutional Amendment to protect the U.S. Flag from physical desecration. The Citizens
Flag Alliance needs your support.
GARLAND MURPHY AWARD
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The American Legion Child
Welfare Foundation is a tremendous asset to local Posts and the veterans they serve. One
of the active Legionnaires who brought the Child Welfare Foundation to life was Garland
Murphy.
Now is the time to present the award named in his honor. The Garland Murphy award
is presented to the Department that has the most participation in the foundation during the
past program year. This year the winning Department raised $29,307.36 to help the
American Legion Child Welfare Foundation in its work. The winner of the award is the
Department of Ohio.
The Garland Murphy, Jr. Award presented by The American Legion Child
26
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Welfare Foundation to the Department of Ohio for the program year
1994-1995.
In recognition of their designation as the number one Department, in total
contributions received from their volunteers, in support of our annual
programs designed to meet the physical, mental, emotional and spiritual
needs of our nation’s children through productive and meaningful grants.
It is signed by ‘Udie’ Grant, the president of The Child Welfare Foundation, and by
Terry Woodbum, the foundation’s executive secretary.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER JAMES MYERS, OHIO: I accept this plaque for the
Legion families from the Department of Ohio. We challenge all other Departments to move
forward with us in the coming year, because it is an outstanding program.
We thank the Children & Youth Foundation for this award.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The Chair recognizes Ray Smith
of North Carolina, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Americanism for
the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON AMERICANISM
Ray G. Smith (NC), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Delegates to this 77th Annual National Convention of The
American Legion, Your Convention Committee on Americanism met Saturday, September
the 2nd, 1995 in the Indiana Convention Center.
The Committee organized by electing Ray G. Smith of North Carolina as Chairman;
Joseph Caouette of New Hampshire as Vice Chairman, and Gary W. Sammons of Michigan
as the Secretary.
Before I move ahead on the agenda, I want to express my appreciation and that of the
National Americanism Commission to the Buick Motor Division for its continuing support
of The American Legion Baseball Program. During the last year, Buick provided over one
and a half million dollars of assistance to this outstanding Americanism program.
The Committee discussed 13 resolutions which were assigned to the Committee. The
resolutions which were considered continue to reflect the desire by many Departments of
The American Legion to address matters of patriotism and government, and to maintain
strong general Americanism programs that compliment the organization and benefit the
Nation.
Thirteen resolutions were considered, with one being approved; one approved as
amended; four received and recorded; six referred to the standing Americanism
Commission, and one referred to the National Security Commission.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
27
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 16: V-J Day Designation
Origin: CO
Submitted by: Americanism
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization of war veterans who have
dedicated themselves to the community, state and nation; and
WHEREAS, Their dedication during World War II resulted in an extremely high loss
of life as well as the defeat of the aggressor Japan; and
WHEREAS, These veterans both living and dead fought long hard and extremely
arduous battle under extreme conditions to defeat the aggressor Japan during World War II
that was initiated by the latter; and
WHEREAS, Parents of young children and children still unborn should not have to
distort the truth and make excuses to them for the defeat of Japan and the United States was
the injured country, injured in the dastardly attack on Pearl Harbor by Japan during the early
morning hours of December 7, 1941; and
WHEREAS, The political correct attitude should in no way be even considered to alter
the facts of what occurred on “V-J Day”; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That the government of the United States not
be influenced by the aggressor Japan or intimidated by them to delete the term “V-J Day”
from our vocabulary; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That the extreme number of veterans that lost their lives in total combat
will not have their ultimate sacrifice be forgotten to satisfy the political personnel now
involved in international diplomacy; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That the millions of veterans that gave the ultimate sacrifice and those
still living not have their valiant sacrifices and efforts made during World War II be
distorted by political correctness.
Resolution No. 99: Illegal Aliens
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Americanism
As Amended
WHEREAS, Despite various laws and enforcement agencies, the problem of illegal
aliens is growing rapidly and they continue to enter the United States of America by the
thousands, especially along our southern borders through the overcrowded immigration
facilities at our airports, and now by mass smuggling across our coast lines, jeopardizing our
security and our American way of life; and
WHEREAS, Since the United States sends out armed forces around the world to protect
the borders of other countries, we certainly should be willing to protect our own borders to
stop illegal entries; and
WHEREAS, Recently a bipartisan review of the 1986 Immigration Act was completed
and recommends numerous changes to tighten immigrant policy; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion petition the
President of the United States and the Congress to expand and strengthen the Customs and
28
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Immigration Services and the U. S. Coast Guard, and enact such emergency measures as will
prevent smuggling of illegal aliens and stop, detain and deport potential terrorists or those
with ties to terrorist groups; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That as appropriate, military resources be employed to assist in stopping
the flow of illegal aliens into the country, and all of the resources of the United States of
America be utilized to enforce the security of our country’s borders.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED:
Resolution No. 59 (NY) 1995 NC:
United States Language
Resolution No. 60 (NY) 1995 NC:
Anthem
Resolution No. 61 (NY) 1995 NC:
Resolution No. 96 (OH) 1995 NC:
The English Language Be Declared as the Official
Support the Traditional Rendition of the National
POW/MIA Flag Display at Postal Facilities
National Standards for United States History
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
AMERICANISM
Resolution No. 71 (FL) 1995 NC: Wearing of the American Flag Patch
Resolution No. 76 (PI) 1995 NC: Certification of Filipino Service Records
Resolution No. 77 (PI) 1995 NC: Filipino Veterans Family Immigration
Resolution No. 78 (PI) 1995 NC: Reopen Period for Filipino Filing of Naturalization
Applications
Resolution No. 134 (VA) 1995 NC: American Legion Middle School Essay Program
Resolution No. 135 (NC) 1995 NC: Prayer for POW/MIA
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 22 (MT) 1995 NC: Militia Organizations
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN SMITH: Mr. Commander that concludes my report. And
as a duly elected Delegate to this Convention, I move for the adoption of this Report.
... Motion was seconded and carried.
THE FRANK N. BELGRANO, JR. TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: With the adoption of the
Americanism report, it is appropriate to announce the winners of two Americanism awards.
The Frank Belgrano, Jr. Award is given annually to the Department rendering the most
outstanding service to the Boy Scouts of America Program during the 12 month period
beginning August 1st. This year’s winner is the Department of Maryland.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
29
RALPH T. O’NEIL EDUCATION TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The Ralph T. O’Neil Education
Award is given to the Department within the United States documenting the greatest activity
in using The American Legion School Medal Program. This year’s winner is the
Department of Florida.
WILLIAM RANDOLPH HEARST AMERICANISM TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: We recognize the one Department
achieving the most outstanding results in conducting Americanism programs. The winning
Department was selected by the National Americanism Commission on the basis of total
resources, manpower, as well as financial support, devoted to Americanism activities during
the Legion program year. The William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy is an
impressive award named in the honor of one of American journalism’s most prominent and
influential figures. With us today to announce the winner of the 1995 William Randolph
Hearst Americanism Trophy, is Otto Wick, Jr. Mr. Wick.
PRESENTATION
WILLIAM RANDOLPH HEARST AMERICANISM TROPHY
Otto Wick, Jr., Vice President and Publisher
Midland Daily News, Midland, Michigan
I’m honored both as a veteran myself and a member of this great organization, and as
a representative of the Hearst Corporation to present the William Randolph Hearst
Americanism Award for the seventh time. It was my pleasure to present this award in New
Orleans in 1978.
While I never personally met Mr. Hearst, I have been employed by his newspaper
group for 32 years. During that time I have learned that nothing could be more appropriate
than an award for Americanism in Mr. Hearst’s honor. He was unabashedly an American.
His newspapers pride themselves in their Americanism. It is a heritage he left that marks
each of his newspapers today. I think the best way to demonstrate this is not with my words,
but with his.
On November 20, 1920, the signed editorial entitled "Democracy Means Americanism"
appeared over Mr. Hearst’s signature in each of the Hearst newspapers. Allow me to share
part of that editorial with you. "Democracy means concrete things. It means the greatest
good for the greatest number. It means liberty, equality, opportunity, the cornerstone on
which our Republic rests. It means freedom; freedom of thought; freedom of speech;
freedom of publication and discussion; freedom of action within the law.
It means loyalty and devotion to our land, and to the aims and aspirations of our own
people. And it means an abstinence from the hatred and contention of foreign peoples, and
from entangling alliances with foreign nations, against which all great democrats of our
history, all the great Americans of our history have warned us.
Democracy means progress, but it means progress along the established line. Progress
in an orderly manner. Democracy means Americanism; it means concern for the people and
particular concern for our own people. It means liberty; equality; justice; independence.
The essential things this Republic was founded to secure."
30
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
As I said earlier, Mr. Hearst was proud of his Americanism. He wanted others to have
that pride, and he worked hard to encourage it.
Sometimes the rhetoric we hear about how Americans should act or what you should
do, muddies the water a bit, but I think that if we all could hold on to the clear vision of
Americanism that Mr. Hearst obviously had, we would all be better off.
Mr. Hearst’s Americanism was not complicated, it was not philosophical. It was
concrete. He believed in liberty; equality; justice; independence, the essential things this
republic was founded to secure.
It’s with a great sense of honor and pride both with my association with the Hearst
Corporation and in my Americanism, that I present this award on behalf of the Hearst
Corporation and in memory of William Randolph Hearst to the Department of Vermont.
Accepting the Hearst Trophy is Alan Grazini, immediate Past President, Department
Commander; George Bille, Department Commander, and Joe Murphy, Alternate National
Executive Committeeman.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: For me, the next part of today’s
business session is a great highlight. It is time to meet the outstanding young men and
women who have distinguished themselves through involvement in American Legion youth
programs. It is an honor to present to the Delegation of our 77th National Convention, the
youth champions of the year.
1995 BOYS NATION PRESIDENT
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our first champion is a young man
who was elected president of Boys Nation, and who is looking forward to someday
becoming a motivational speaker. He’s an Eagle Scout, was Governor of Oklahoma Boys
State, is active in student government, and has received plenty of recognition for his efforts.
He’s sponsored by the Hill-Huett Post 260 in his hometown of Tecumseh, Oklahoma.
Please welcome Rick Lam, Jr.
RICK LAM, JR.
1995 Boys Nation President
I would like to thank all of the members of The American Legion and friends and
guests for so graciously inviting me to be here to speak to you this morning.
They asked me to talk about Boys Nation, what the program does and what the program
means to me. It’s pretty hard to sum up an entire weeks worth of experiences into just a few
minutes, but I’m going to try.
I think if there is one main theme that I learned from Boys Nation is that we must have
faith. There are several things that I believe we must have faith in.
First, we have to have faith in our system, the American system. Our system has
worked for over 200 years, and while not being perfect, it’s the best form of government that
our world has ever seen. The American dream has to still exist, and for that to happen we
have to have faith in the American system.
Another thing we must have faith in is our leaders. We must continue to choose the
leaders that put forth character and that are the epitome of the kind of people that we want
in power. We have to choose our leaders wisely and must have faith in the ones that we
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
31
choose.
The third thing that we have to have faith in is ourselves and each other as Americans.
Remember, that we are above all else children of God. This is our country, and it was
founded by Americans. It’s led by fellow Americans, but not as a king or dictator. We have
to have faith in Americans so that we ourselves can uphold and maintain our great system.
And finally, we have to have faith in our future. We have to make sure that we have
children who are well equipped to handle the future. These children have to be intelligent,
they have to be able to solve the problems that they are going to face, and they have to have
character and integrity.
Through the programs that The American Legion sponsors, such as Boys Nation, I
believe that our future is in great hands. Boys Nation develops capable youth with character
and courage. Andrew Jackson once said: "One man with courage makes a majority." And
that’s exactly the kind of courage that our founding fathers of our country had.
With the continued support of the programs like Boys Nation, we will continue to build
our country’s leaders. For proof that this program works, we need to look no further than
the White House. It was only a matter of time until a Boys Nation alumnus landed there,
and it’s only a matter of time until it happens again.
Everyone has been gracious to us, here in Indianapolis. In my dealings that I have had
with The American Legion since going to the local Post in Tecumseh where my dad is a
member, I think there’s one thing, one lesson that I have learned from The American
Legion. The lesson is that whenever I see the American Flag go by in a parade whenever I
see the American Flag being brought forward for us to salute, and when I see the American
Flag raised at a football game or a sporting event to be saluted, I’m going to stand up and
salute that Flag. And it’s not because I was Governor of Oklahoma Boys State; and it’s not
because I was president of Boys Nation; it’s not just because I’m a member of the Citizens
Flag Alliance or because I’m an Eagle Scout, it’s because I choose to, and that’s the kind
of faith we need to have in America again.
I thank you for helping to instill this kind of faith in the youth of our nation.
In a religious service that I offered to a group of Boy Scouts about a year ago, I
summed up my feelings about faith in a very simple expression: Faith is not belief without
proof, but trust without reservation. Let us continue to have faith in America.
God bless you, God bless The American Legion, and God bless America. Thank you.
JUNIOR SHOOTING SPORTS PRECISION CHAMPION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our 1995 Junior Shooting Sports
Champion has established some records that will be hard to beat. He’s the only Junior
Shooter to win both Sporter and Precision in back-to-back years. He broke two records and
established a third last year. They still stand. This year he tied two records and broke
another.
Sponsored by American Legion Post Number 134 in Cherokee, North Carolina, please
welcome Terry Bradley.
TERRY BRADLEY
1995 Junior Shooting Sports Precision Champion
I bring you a proud hello from Cherokee and my sponsor American Legion Post 143.
32
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
I’m very honored to be a part of your Convention, because it is you who bring honor to this
great nation. Post 143 sponsors me and the Junior ROTC Program, and our rifle team at my
school. They see that we are provided with the best equipment and other things needed for
competition.
Until this Convention, I knew very little about The American Legion. But now I will
take back valuable knowledge of important programs that you sponsor, like educational
scholarships, child welfare, benefits for veterans, and the most pressing issues of preserving
the right of the people to decide on major issues like the desecration of our beloved flag.
Rest assured that I will leave this great city well-informed on the purpose and actions
of The American Legion. I’m truly impressed with the power, strength, love and
compassion that is most evident in each person here. With all of these great qualities, The
American Legion will be around for some time to come.
At this time I would like to comment on a person who represents the Army with honor
and pride, the person who has been instrumental in molding me into the person I am today.
He has taught me things no other teacher in the world could teach me, the ability to truly
believe in myself. The person I speak of is the greatest shooting coach in the world, Colonel
Thomas Johnson. Though he’s not physically with me today, he will always be beside me,
encouraging me and keeping me on the right path.
My family has also been super supportive of me. They have been patient and
understanding, especially my sister. She didn’t get too mad when I shot the heads off her
little dolls. Even though I won’t let her watch me shoot, my mom, Carol, gets a little
excited. Shooting is not a spectator sport.
Thanks also to the other Youth Champions. I have enjoyed sharing the past few days
with them. Thank you for allowing me a look into your lives and your futures. With your
strength, determination and ambition, you will do great things and make this nation proud.
I would also like to give a great thanks to our escort and friend Mike Buss, who has
been no less than excellent. Like all veterans, he has performed above and beyond the call
of duty a countless number of times.
1995 ORATORICAL CHAMPION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our next youth champion is
considering a law career. He’s developing critical skills, as your National High School
Oratorical Contest Winner. A senior in high school, he’s considering attending Princeton
University next year.
From Ballston Lake, New York, sponsored by Mohawk Post 1450, please welcome the
1995 Oratorical champion, Aron Egner.
ARON S. EGNER
1995 National Oratorical Contest Winner
When I first decided to do the Oratorical Contest, I had one simple goal: to win. I
wasn’t really concerned for, nor did I think too much about, what would happen to me along
the way while I was striving to reach that goal. I soon discovered, however, that the
Oratorical Contest isn’t just about reaching your goal, it’s about reaching for your goal, and
about what happens to you along the way.
My main speech was about voting, and in it I reminded people of their voting
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
33
responsibilities, and pointed out that those who failed to vote have no right to complain
about the failings of our government because they have failed in the most elemental duty of
citizenship. They were turning their backs on freedom.
In writing the speech and coming up with my own solutions and conclusions to solve
the problems of political apathy, I was forced to learn firsthand what the Constitution said;
what the Constitution meant; how it succeeded and how it failed. Along the way to my goal
I developed a very deep respect for America and for the ideals that it upholds. Along the
way I came to appreciate not only the benefits of citizenship, but the accompanying
responsibilities. But perhaps most importantly, I made countless friends from age sixteen
to age ninety-six.
As I stand here today and look out on the many, many familiar faces, I’m proud to say
that what I gained along the way was more important to me than my original, somewhat
narrow-minded goal of simply winning the contest. Still, I must admit the scholarship
money was a nice little added benefit.
Actually it was much more than that. In five days, I’ll be at Princeton University
majoring in politics. Without the Oratorical Contest and the nearly $30,000 in scholarships,
I never would have been able to afford the school, nor would I have realized that I want to
make a career out of public service.
But keep in mind that mine is just one story, just one life that was changed. I wish you
members knew just how many lives you really are affecting. Each of us here today knows
that we can’t always win, but everyone in the Oratorical Contest and the other Legion youth
programs, even if they don’t win, get to enjoy the same experience that I did. They learned.
They discovered a love for the Nation. They find new friends, and they do all of it as I did,
not necessarily by winning, but by challenging themselves along the way.
Now, most of the stories you will never hear. Most of the students that develop an
understanding and respect for the Constitution probably won’t bother to tell you. Most of
the kids that realized the power and the potential of words probably won’t take the time to
let you know. But rest assured that they are out there.
The 17 year-old-boy who gets up in front of his social studies class and is fully
confident in his speaking abilities, will be forever grateful to you.
The 34-year-old lawyer who gave a speech on Amendment 1 for her extemporaneous
section in the Oratorical Contest, and is now defending that same amendment in the
Supreme Court, will be forever grateful to you.
The 40-year-old Senator who’s doing what he believes is right based on the
constitutional law he first learned in the Oratorical Contest, will be forever grateful to you.
The 56-year-old admiral who must give a little speech and a lot of courage to his men
before they go into combat, will be forever grateful to you.
On behalf of the hundreds of thousands of others who have been involved with this
program, thank you. We will be forever grateful to you.
1994 BASEBALL PLAYER OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The 1994 American Legion
Baseball Player of the Year is our next champion. He is a sophomore at Florida
International University, preparing for a business career. This young man looked very
impressive on the mound last year in Boyertown. He won four games; lost none. His earned
run average was 0.00 for more than 32 innings. This pitching performance led the Miami,
34
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Florida Post No. 346 team to the championship of Legion Baseball last year.
Please welcome a terrific ball player, Fernando Rodriguez.
FERANDO RODRIQUEZ
1994 Baseball Player of the Year
I thank The American Legion for giving me this great honor of being here with you all
today. What I experienced last year playing for The American Legion has been the biggest
thrill of my life. Maybe one day I will be challenged with the opportunity of winning
another championship game. Nothing surpasses the thrill of winning your first
championship game. And this, along with my college scholarship, I owe to The American
Legion.
I especially would like to recognize three Legionnaires who did an outstanding job with
The American Legion, its baseball program and youth program. These are Chairman, Ray
Smith, Mr. Jim Quinlan and Mr. Mike Buss.
Secondly, 1 want to thank the two most important persons in my life who are here with
me on this very special day, my mother, Rita, and my father, Migel. If it hadn’t been for
my mother taking me to practice everyday after work, and my father’s unwavering
confidence and support, I would not be here. I cannot forget my brother, Migel, his constant
challenge and competitiveness keeping me on my toes. And my little sister Alex, who
passed away a few months before the tournament who was my biggest inspiration.
Also, I would like to mention my head coach, Carlos Hernandez, the coaching staff, and
the rest of my teammates who should be standing here with me today.
And finally, I cannot leave here today without thanking God, who bestowed on me the
honor of having been bom in this great country where my baseball playing abilities are
recognized and developed.
1995 SCOUT OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The American Legion Scout of the
Year could not be with us today. He’s beginning his college education at the US Military
Academy and couldn’t sneak away for the weekend. For his efforts, this young man,
sponsored by Brewster Cleveland Post No. 86 in Cedartown, Georgia, deserves our
recognition. Please give a warm round of applause for Zachary Lee Thomas.
... National Commander Detweiler assumed the chair.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: With our Youth Champions still on the
stage, it is appropriate to introduce our next guest. He is the President and CEO of Samsung
North America. I shared several warm moments with him during the recent dedication of
the Korean War Veterans Memorial in Washington, DC. Because of Samsung’s generosity,
some children of American veterans will be getting much needed financial help for college.
Please welcome Bo-Soon Song.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
35
BO-SOON SONG
President and CEO Samsung North America
First of all, I would like to thank Mr. Vice National Commander and members of The
American Legion for inviting me to partake in your annual convention. It is a great pleasure
for me to be here today.
On behalf of Samsung, I would like to pay tribute to those of you who served your
country to sustain peace throughout the world. Samsung recognizes the sacrifices and
commitment of U.S. servicemen and servicewomen, and we are especially grateful to those
of you who helped to maintain the security of the Korean peninsula during the Korea war.
Samsung also recognizes and commends the great efforts of The American Legion. Not
only is The American Legion the largest veterans’ organization in the United States, it is
deeply involved in educational programs devoted to the young people of America. At
Samsung we share a mutual respect for education. As a global company that is involved in
many of the fastest growing industries, we understand firsthand the need for an educated,
current and future work force. We, too, realize that the future of tomorrow lies with our
children and grandchildren. The greatest contribution a company can make is to support the
young people in their academic endeavors. We believe the best way to show our
appreciation to the United States and to the U.S. war veterans is to offer educational
opportunities to the children and grandchildren of American war veterans.
Last month, Samsung pledged to endow a $5 million scholarship fund to be
administered by The American Legion. This fund is called the Samsung American Legion
Scholarship.
Today we would like to present the $5 million check to The American Legion. It is
Samsung’s hope that this scholarship program will make a difference in the lives of
American students, and that Americans will accept this gesture as sincere gratitude for their
support.
... At this time there was presentation of a $5 million check.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is a leader in every sense
of the word. Perhaps he developed those skills as a young man growing up in Kansas during
the great depression and the dust storms of the prairie. Perhaps he developed those skills
as a platoon leader with the 10th Mountain Division in Italy during World War II where he
was seriously wounded twice and received two Purple Hearts with a bronze star — a Bronze
Star with Oak Leaf Cluster. Wherever his skills were developed, America has certainly
benefitted from them. It is my pleasure to ask you to welcome the Senate Majority Leader
and a proud Legionnaire from the Department of Kansas, Bob Dole.
THE HONORABLE ROBERT J. DOLE
Majority Leader United States Senate
[Senator Dole’s speech was often interrupted by applause]
We have some people from Kansas out there somewhere in the audience. I don’t see
them right now. They are on the far right where they belong.
No doubt about it, speaking to this convention is a great honor, and as I look out at all
the patriots who belong to The American Legion I can’t help but recall that perhaps the first
36
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
speech I made outside Kansas was in an American Legion hall in Indiana.
I was a freshman congressman and the local dinner committee knew they had to find
some way to get people to come. Nobody knew who I was and they didn’t care who I was.
They thought they would send me out to the local radio station where the announcer was
supposed to interview me to boost attendance.
We did have an interview but it wasn’t very accurate. He began with less than an
accurate rendition of my resume. 1 remember he said at the time that the guest at that night’s
dinner would be Congressman Bob Doyle. He will speak at The American Legion hall,
tickets had been slashed from $3.00 to $1.00. They were going to give away a color TV set,
but you had to be present to win. They were not going to draw until Doyle gets through
talking. He went on to say that Doyle was bom in Kansas, raised in Kansas, educated in
Kansas. He fought in Italy where he suffered a serious head injury and then went into
politics. So, that’s how it all got started.
I don’t know how you came here today. I’m sure they didn’t promise you a TV set, but
I understand there are at least, maybe, 200 from my home state and I know there are many
more. It’s hard to see when you are up here, but I know there’s a lot of people out there.
You are freedom’s heroes and American patriots and I’m proud to be among you. Each
of you have answered America’s call, whether it was to fight for our freedom or to defend
the peace in which we have prospered for so many years. Each of you know what it’s like
to wear the uniform of our country, to put your country first and to be willing to bear any
sacrifice to keep her free. And I assure you that we will never forget our obligation to those
who have worn the uniform in service to this great nation.
I know you support efforts to balance the federal budget, to stop the flow of red ink
that threatens the future of our children and our grandchildren. I also know that as veterans
you are very properly concerned about funding for the activities of the Department of
Veteran Affairs. Yes, we are going to balance the federal budget because it’s necessary.
And every program is going to be scrutinized with the exception of Social Security. But the
budget will not be balanced on the backs of America’s veterans; we have too much invested.
You and I know many who had the privilege of serving in the armed forces, and
because of that we are the freest country and the freest people on earth. You and I know that
we must stay that way. We must remain the strongest country on the face of the earth for
peace; that’s all we want is peace, peace. And that’s what I want to talk with you just for
a few moments today.
Keep America strong, in her mind and in her heart and in the face of external enemies
and in the presence of threats from within. America is still the land of the free and the home
of the brave. A great century of hope and opportunity is about to unfold before us. But
some in America believe our might is no longer needed. And some think our definition,
yours and mine, of what it means to be an American is out-of-date, that somehow we’re out
of touch. And of course neither is true.
Can there be any doubt that the world is still a dangerous place? True, the cold war is
over. We’ve won one of humanity’s greatest struggles against totalitarianism and
oppression. But today peace is threatened and dark forces are multiplying in almost every
comer of the world. The evil empire may be gone that President Reagan talked about, but
its missiles still exist in a volatile, unstable and unpredictable region. Despite our protests
Russia is selling nuclear arms to Iran. Iraq is manufacturing gruesome biological and
chemical weapons. North Korea will soon have a nuclear capability. And China is arming
Pakistan with nuclear missiles while just across their contested border, India already has
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
37
them. And central Europe is being eaten away by ethnic war and genocide.
The United Nations is impotent and until last week, the U.N. was calling the shots for
NATO. Now should be a time for greater vigilance, yet Washington seems filled with
people who want to dismantle our defenses. One thing I think is clear, regardless of our
political philosophy or party affiliation, I believe we must go back and look at what’s
happened. Our defense budget has been cut too far and too fast. And I think we’re now on
a path that would have ended with America spending about as much as our gross national
product on defense as we were when Pearl Harbor was attacked. That’s a big, big drop.
But the good news is that Congress refused to go along this year [with cuts]. We
rejected the policy that would lead us back to a hollow military. We kept the faith and we
increased spending on defense. I’ve always felt that if I was the President of the United
States and I had a choice of spending maybe a little too much or not spending enough, I’m
going to opt for spending a little too much. It seems to me that’s where the future is and
that’s what America is all about.
The demands of freedom require us to modernize our forces, to maintain our
technological edge, and to insure that America remains the world’s one and only
superpower. And we will never apologize for that. Our goal is not just to be strong enough
to turn back a threat. We must also be so strong that no one ever again be tempted to
threaten us at all. That’s what it’s all about, that’s where we need to be in the future.
But if we are going to return America to greatness we must do more than restore
America’s defenses. We must return as a people to the original concept of what it means to
be American. This means tackling subjects the arbitrators of political correctness don’t even
want discussed. For example, English must be recognized as America’s official language.
Western tradition and American greatness must be taught in our schools. The federal
government must end its war on traditional American values. America has always been more
than just a place on a map; it has held a claim on our hearts. We are a nation dedicated to
a proposition that all men and women are created equal, endowed by our Creator with
certain inalienable rights.
Our forefathers rejected race and religion as a basic force to form a nation, choosing
instead the ideals of freedom and democracy. It was a radical gamble at the time and ever
since we have held it to be an article of faith that those who would be American must first
abandon lesser allegiances. As Franklin Roosevelt, the Commander-in-Chief in my
generation, he said: “Americanism is not and never was a matter of race and ancestry.”
Succeeding waves of immigrants have been drawn to America by this idea. And
lacking the centuries-old primal bond of other nations, we have used our language, our
history and our code of values to make the American experiment work. We have used them
to forge millions of diverse individuals into one people with a common purpose.
Language, history and values: these are the strings that bind the hearts of America.
These are the forces that have held us together, allowing us to be diverse and yet united. To
absorb untold millions of immigrants while coming the closest that any country ever has to
the classless upwardly mobile society of our ideals. But these keys to unity are under attack
from our government and from intellectual elites who seem embarrassed by America. What
we see as an opportunity, they see as oppression. What we see as a proud past, they see as
a legacy of shame. What we hold as moral truth, they call intolerance. They have false
theories, long dissertations and endless studies to back them up. They know so much. But
somehow they missed the fact that the United States of America is the greatest force for
good the world has ever known.
38
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Yes, we have our faults, but part of what makes me so proud to be an American is the
constant effort of our people to do better, to make our country right and good and just.
Unfortunately some policies and programs borne out of that desire have gone awry. Begun
for the best of reasons and then hijacked by the ‘embarrassed-to-be-American crowd’,
certain federal programs are untying the strings of citizenship.
Affirmative action is one of those programs. Instead of making things better, it has
made things worse. No amount of tinkering can rescue it. It was never supposed to be
permanent. We know it has failed. Let’s stop dividing Americans by race and gender and
get back to the simple principle of equal treatment for all Americans. All Americans ought
to be treated alike regardless of their background, regardless of their color, regardless of
their economic status.
That’s why I have introduced legislation which prohibits the federal government from
ever using quotas, set-asides, or other race-based preferences in any form. Whether in
employment, contracting or any other federal program, our government must be in the
business of bringing our citizens closer together, not tearing us apart, not dividing us into
classes.
But nowhere is the focus on what divides us more alarmingly than what is happening
in our schools. The debate about what we teach our children is really a debate about who
we are as a people, and whether we are one people anymore at all. Do we embrace ideas that
unite us regardless of our sex or color or religion, or are we just a jostling crowd of
competing groups thrown by fate between two oceans.
One of the most important missions of our schools is to make citizens of our children.
And I believe that fluency in English should be a central educational goal of every state in
our nation. English is a language in which we still speak to each other across the frontiers
of culture and race. It is the language of the Constitution. It is the language in which we
conduct our great national debates, an essential ingredient of democracy. And insisting that
all our citizens are fluent in English is a welcoming act of inclusion. And insist on it we
must, otherwise, they are going to fall behind.
And I agree, yes, schools should provide the language classes our immigrants and their
families need as long as their primary purpose is the teaching of English. We have done this
since our founding to speed the melting of our melting pot. But we must stop the practice
of multilingual education as a means of instilling ethnic pride, or as a therapy for low esteem
or out of elitist guilt of a culture built on traditions of the West. With all the divisive forces
tearing at our country, we need the glue of language to help hold us together. If we want
to insure that all of our children have the same opportunities in life, alternative language
education is to be stopped and English should be acknowledged once and for all as the
official language of the United States of America.
And speaking of elitist guilt, yes, there have been dark moments in our past. There are
still cruel elements in our culture. We should not sanitize them when we teach our children
the history of America and western civilization. But we should not proselytize them either,
as too many educators and professors in our schools and universities today are attempting
to do. There is a shocking campaign afoot among educators at all levels, most evident in the
National History Standards already distributed to more than 20,000 teachers, administrators
and professors, to disparage America and disown the ideas and traditions of the West. Let
me give you a couple of examples of what I mean.
The History Standards were prepared with over $2 million in grants from the U.S.
Department of Education and the National Endowment for Humanities. They suggest that
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
39
we teach our students about America by concentrating on some of our worse moments, such
as the scourge of McCarthyism and the rise of the Ku Kiux Klan. George Washington is
never even described as our first president in this approach. Alexander Graham Bell, and
Thomas Edison, and Paul Revere disappear from the history of America. And the first time
the Constitution is mentioned, it is blamed for sidetracking the movement to end slavery.
Now if you are a student, and after years of that, would you love America? Probably not.
The purpose of the National History Standards seems not to teach our children certain
essential facts about our history, but to denigrate Americans story while sanitizing and
glorifying other cultures. This is wrong and it threatens us as surely as any foreign power
ever has. We must use a bully pulpit to make it clear that we will not stand still and allow
this campaign to be inflicted upon our children and our grandchildren across America.
Liberal academic elites control more than our schools, of course. Any institution touched
by a government is ripe for inspection, which is why we see this disdain for America
turning up in government-funded television, art and now, even our museums. The
Smithsonian [Institution] created a display to commemorate the anniversary of Hiroshima,
the day we effectively won a global war against the forces of evil. The message of the
Smithsonian was that the dropping of the bomb was an act of American violence against
Japanese culture. Somehow the Japanese were painted not as the aggressors but as the
victims of World War II. Veteran’s groups, like The American Legion which led the effort,
were dismissed as special interests who couldn’t be objective. That’s right. If you put your
life on the line for America, if you love this country so much you are willing to die for it,
maybe you do belong to a special interest, but that special interest used to be called the
people of the United States of America, and that’s the difference.
And if you had predicted the Smithsonian debacle to the soldiers crawling up the beach
in Okinawa, they never would have believed you. Today, even Japan has finally apologized
for its atrocities and aggression. So maybe it’s time the ‘embarrassed-about-America’ crowd
gets the message too, that we are proud of our country, we are proud of America. That’s why
we are here today, that’s why you’re here today, because we are the greatest country on the
face of the earth and that’s what America is all about.
We won’t put up with our tax dollars being used to drag it down or sow doubt about
the nobility of America in the minds of our children. They are the future of this country.
We must remember our children embrace what they learn, the American idea is not
automatic. We must teach them what we were taught and what we know to be true; that this
country is one of history’s most magnificent ideas. Our children must come to value
freedom as dearly as every refugee fleeing persecution who sailed or swam or scrambled
here to find it, as much as every soldier who died to preserve it. America must be in their
hearts as well as in their heads. It takes just one generation to snap the chain of freedom,
one generation for a nation based on an idea to forget who we are.
One of the most powerful symbols we use to remind ourselves of this, of course, is Old
Glory, the flag. Our flag is more than a piece of cloth. It is the embodiment of our sacred
ideals. I grew up as you all did, holding my hand over my heart and pledging allegiance to
it. Perhaps one of our problems is that too few of us do that anymore. We ought to teach
our children at an early age to respect the flag. We certainly ought to stop its public
denigration and I’m proud to stand with The American Legion in supporting a
Constitutional Amendment to protect our flag.
I just told your National Commander that we are going to bring it up this year. Don’t
worry about it. It’s going to come up in the United States Senate before the year is out. We
40
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
are going to need some votes as we are one or two short. There are always one or two over
there that just can’t decide. It happened on the balanced budget. Remember, we lost by one
vote. Regulatory reform, we lost by one vote. So we are going to need your help. We are
going to need your help. This is a priority for The American Legion, for a hundred other
organizations all across America, the newest group being the Boy Scouts of America.
Now, if we want to protect our flag and make it part of the Constitution, we will have
to send it out to the states and let them make the decisions. We [in the Senate] ought to do
it as soon as we can and I pledge to the Commander right now, we are going to do it this
year.
[The flag] is the value issue with me. Which brings me to the subject of values,
something I spoke a lot about this summer. To put it simply, values do count, not just in our
lives but in our society. I don’t care how strong our economy will become in the future it
will never be strong enough to transform a neighborhood where 80 percent of the children
lack a father and legitimate jobs are dismissed as ‘chump change.’
There will never be enough prisons or police to enforce order in our society if there is
growing disorder in our souls. The vast majority of Americans still hold fast to the values
that made America great. But now we must do more than just live by them. We must speak
out about our values and insist that our culture and our government reflect them. Yes, this
means braving ridicule of the cultural elites and then speaking out about our popular
entertainment, our movies and music, advertising and television. They do have a profound
impact on our children and it’s not for the good.
It’s much harder to rise out of the poverty when the culture derides the values that made
it possible. It’s much harder for society to control crime when role models preach impulsive
violence and those who would market evil through commerce, hate the light of scrutiny. But
I will continue my freedom campaign as you continue your freedom efforts to call them to
account. I will name their names until they feel the shame their actions deserve.
Time Warner, the producer of some of the foulest rap music, has already begun to have
second thoughts, and others will too. This is not a matter of right and left, this is a matter of
right and wrong, and we ought to speak out on a matter of right and wrong.
I said something awhile back, which wasn’t part of a speech. Somebody said, “Why,
he’s just too old fashioned.” What did I talk about? I talked about love of God, and country
and family; commitment to honesty and decency and personal responsibility, and
self-reliance tempered by a sense of community. I thought those were the values that made
us the greatest country on the face of the earth. There’s no doubt in my mind that we can
get back on the right track if we reassert the values again to our people, and if our
government returns the values to the nation as national policy.
Everywhere in the world we see examples of nations divided against themselves. The
tragedy of Bosnia is the most recent most horrifying, example of where we waited and
waited and waited. Thousands and thousands of innocent women and children were
slaughtered. I’m not suggesting sending ground troops but it seems to me what we’re doing
now could have been done months and months beforehand. By now we might be having
a real peace settlement. But in any event, we are finally doing the right thing. I commend
those who are flying the missions. I commend NATO for taking charge. For too long they
have been under the thumb of the United Nations. The last time I checked, nobody in the
United Nations was on the ballot anywhere in America. And if we are going to make
decisions committing our soldiers and our airmen, Navy, or whatever, it ought to be made
by the president of the United States and not Boutros Boutros-Ghali at the United Nations.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
41
So we see the tragedy in Bosnia. Even placid Canada today is threatened by ethnic
separatism. But the idea of America, if we hold onto, it is what will save us from that fate.
Back in 1874 a black high school principal in Ohio said, “In language, in civilization, in
fears and in hopes we are Americans.” We are defined not by our blood lines but by our
beliefs. And in this beautiful new world we have created a nation out of overcoming
differences with freedom.
But our freedom cannot be taken for granted. We must always insure its defense. We
do have diversity and should have diversity. It requires us to bind ourselves to the American
ideal in every way that we can. By speaking one language, by taking pride in our true
history, and by embracing the traditional American values which have guided us from the
beginning, these are the ways we remember who we are. Free individuals united by
democracy in the world’s newest, greatest and still evolving race, the nation of Americans.
I’m now speaking particularly to the World War II out there. I often wonder why there
weren’t more celebrations at the end of World War II. But I remember D-Day very well.
Maybe some of you were there as I was. I will just close with a story that made an
impression on me.
A lot of these veterans took their kids and their grandkids to the commemorations. I
guess your kids and grandkids never imagine us being 17, 18, 19-year-olds. They don’t
recall their granddad ever being that young, 19 or 20. But these were the men, in some cases
women too, who were on the beaches and in the air all over the world fighting for freedom
for us and millions of other people around the world. Remember we got a late start in World
War II. We had to come from behind in World War II. I looked into the faces of those
young people, the children in their 40s, the grandchildren in their 20s. As you looked into
the faces, you could see the emotion, you could see the tears and I said if only every
American could be here today.
Now 50 years is a long time. Then we had Korea, Vietnam, the Gulf War, Somali and
Haiti. But the point I would like to make is this, again talking specifically to my generation,
the World War II veterans. About four or five years ago when the Berlin Wall collapsed and
Communism collapsed, people started coming to America from all these different countries,
whether it was Poland or Hungry or the former Republic of the Soviet Union. They were
young and old, and men and women. Some had been locked up in jail for years because
they stood up and spoke out against the government. They came to see us as the leaders of
Congress. Almost without exception, they would say when they left something like this and they would speak in a very emotional way, with tears streaming down their cheeks in
some cases. You know what they said? They didn’t say give us foreign aid. They didn’t
say give us anything. They said they wanted to be like America. Finally they had the right
to vote and the right to worship. They had the right to send their children to school. They
had a right to travel, something we take for granted. They could pick-up the telephone.
They had that right without somebody tapping the other end.
All these basic rights suddenly were available to these 500 million people, who had
a little taste of freedom because of us, because of people in this audience and because of
Presidents Reagan and Bush, and yes, Carter, they didn’t give up but kept the pressure on.
We paid for it with taxes when we increased our defense, but the result was that 500 million
people are free.
We have opportunities now for a generation of peace. That’s why it’s so important to
pay a price for leadership. You do it every day in your business, whatever you may do. We
pay a price as a country for leadership. President Nixon wrote a book just before his death.
42
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
He said the American people are tired of the burden of leadership. They would like to give
it to somebody else. Ask yourself who? The Chinese, Japanese, Germany? No. It always
comes back to us and we pay a price for it. It’s called taxes. You pay a price. There’s no
alternative. There is no alternative. That’s why we continue talking about the greatness of
America. It’s not arrogance. It’s not conceit. It’s not immodest.
We are the leaders of the free world and we have a tremendous responsibility and
challenge. But we also have opportunities. We want to avoid war. We want someday to
see that there isn’t any American Legion or any other veteran’s group because there hasn’t
been any wars. That’s what America is all about and that’s what the future is all about.
You’ve made it possible and I’m honored to be here today to say so.
God Bless America.
COMMENTS BY NATIONAL COMMANDER ON CFA
AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
As you walk out of this Hall today and leave this Convention, I remind you that Senator
Dole has made a commitment to support and to work for the Constitutional Amendment to
protect the Flag.
Those of you who have followed the issue know that Senator Dole was the mainstay,
and this was his bill back in ‘89 and ‘90 when he attempted to push for passage of a
Constitutional Amendment to protect the Flag. He has been with us from day one.
There was concern about whether or not we would get the votes, get the support
necessary to bring this matter before the Senate before the end of this year. You heard him
commit to schedule the vote on this amendment before the end of this year. That resulted
from a short meeting with the Senator prior to his appearance. I tried to emphasize that it’s
because of your work and your continued commitment to the issue, that we can deliver. We
can deliver the 67 votes necessary. And Senator Dole, we will not embarrass the leadership.
Give us an opportunity to have the issue voted on. He said, “Yes.”
That issue will come before the Senate before the end of this year. It’s because of your
work. The only way that we can fail is apathy in our ranks, and we cannot allow that to
happen. So I ask you to join with us to keep up the work and keep the letters going in.
Make sure that we keep the pressure on those Senators who have not committed so that we
will be able to win this battle and that the amendment will be properly passed by the Senate
before the end of this year.
SPECIAL REPORT
The American Legion and The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I doubt that there is a single Delegate
here, nor any person in the audience, nor any member of The American Legion, the
American Legion Auxiliary, or the Sons of The American Legion who does not know about
our long campaign to protect the Flag by means of a Constitutional Amendment.
For six long years we have been seeking such an amendment in order to overturn that
narrow and utterly wrong decision by the United States Supreme Court in 1989 that said,
in effect, burning the American Flag was merely a form of political expression, and,
therefore, it was legally permissible under the free speech guarantees of the First
Amendment.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
43
We know that decision was wrong. We know it was wrong then, and we know it is
wrong now. And so do 80 percent of the American people who believe that wrong should
be righted by the Constitutional amendment.
Forty-nine of our 50 state legislatures have passed resolutions asking Congress to send
such an amendment back to the states for ratification. We have come a long way toward
achieving our goal, but the hardest part of the battle is still ahead.
Today we bring you an up-to-date status report on exactly where we stand. But we
must do to achieve that victory.
The best way to update you on the whole Flag Amendment campaign, is to share with
you a short video. This report, produced by the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated, will
summarize the entire background of the issue, and tell you where we stand in Congress right
now. After we have seen the video, I will update you on some very late developments, and
tell you exactly what each of us has to do to win this fight to get the Flag protection
amendment passed.
... At this time the Delegates viewed a video presentation.
The polls are strong. The new polling done is clearly an indication that we have now
moved to the point that this is a political issue.
We need your help. We need you to go to the phones. We have phones set up in the
lobby. Make the calls. It doesn’t matter whether or not you are in a state where your
Senator has not made a commitment. Go out there and make a phone call to a Senator who
has made a commitment and thank he or she for that commitment. And if your Senator has
not made a commitment, please go out there and also make those calls. The phones are
there. It doesn’t cost you anything.
Fill out the cards and the letters found in your packets. We’ll be happy to mail them
for you.
There are two people I also wish to thank, for without their leadership and support in
the Congress, we would not have won such a stunning victory. I’m talking about the
primary sponsors of House Joint Resolution 79, the Constitutional Amendment to return to
Congress and the States the power to prohibit physical desecration of the United States
Flag. Those two persons are the Honorable Gerald Solomon, the Republican of New York,
and the Honorable G.V. "Sonny" Montgomery, Democrat of Mississippi. Neither
Congressman was able to accept our invitation to be with us today, due to commitments
elsewhere. However, they have sent greetings and good wishes to their fellow members of
The American Legion by way of a video tape.
. . . At this time a video presentation was viewed by the Delegates, a transcription of the
video as follows:
THE HONORABLE GERALD B. H. SOLOMON
Chairman, Rules Committee United States House of Representatives
National Commander Bill Detweiler and all American Legion members across the
Country. This is Congressman Jerry Solomon, a Life Member of your organization. Once
again, I thank each of you for all you have done and continue to do for your country.
As the lead sponsor of the Constitutional Amendment to protect Old Glory, I wish I
44
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
could be in Indianapolis today to personally thank each of you for this unbelievable
grassroots effort spearheaded by The American Legion that brought us more than the
two-thirds votes needed to pass the Constitutional Amendment protecting our Flag. Without
the tireless, sustained effort, that is, of The American Legion, my friend, “Sonny”
Montgomery and I would not have succeeded in getting the 290 votes that we needed to pass
this extremely important amendment.
But my fellow Legionnaires, we are not quite there yet. There is another body
of Congress called the Senate which has to pass this same amendment. And you know, no
one can get the message across better than those of you who have served our nation and
carried our Flag so proudly.
Right now we’re only a few votes short of the 67 Senators out of 100 needed to pass
the Constitutional Amendment. We all need to double our efforts back home to get our
individual Senators to vote for if thereby giving the American people the right to ratify it.
And my fellow Legionnaires, I just want you to know that I predict it will be the fastest
Constitutional Amendment ever ratified by the people through their state legislatures. Why
do I say that? It’s because the overwhelming majority, more than 80 percent of the
American people want, that Flag protected.
My fellow Legionnaires, let’s go get those Senators.
THE HONORABLE G. V. MONTGOMERY
Ranking Democratic Member
House Veterans Affairs Committee United States House of Representatives
I’m very proud to be a member of The American Legion. I am a member of Post 21
in my hometown of Meridian, Mississippi. I’m a Life Member and I’ve been a member of
that Post for 50 years. And for you Legionnaires, have a great time in Indianapolis. I wish
I could be with you.
I’m very, very proud of The American Legion. You led the fight for us to pass a
Constitutional Amendment in the House of Representatives about the Flag; stopping these
‘nuts’ from burning the American Flag.
I worked with Jerry Solomon of New York. It was bipartisan. He brought along
Republican votes; I brought along the Democratic votes. We got two-thirds votes in the
House of Representatives to stop the burning of the American Flag, and The American
Legion did it.
Now we need your help. We have to pass this amendment in the United States Senate.
We need to get 67 votes. You have to go to work. If we can’t pass it out of the Senate, what
we’ve done in the House will be for nothing.
After it gets out of the Senate, we know it will get a three-fourths support of the
different states of the Union. We need 38 or 39 States in the Union to ratify this
amendment. It will be ratified if we get it out of the United States Senate.
I’m proud to be a member of The American Legion. Have a great time in Indianapolis.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, the quiet
revolution that we have been waging is quiet no more. As you saw in the video, it’s your
Flag, it’s your fight, and it’s up to us. And I know that together we’re going to win.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
45
PRESENTATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
Seated on the dais are some
representatives from the Department of Virginia. I understand that they have a presentation
to the CFA.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER WENDITZ, VIRGINIA: Mr. Commander, on behalf
of the proud Legionnaires of Virginia, we gladly present this check to the CFA for Flag
protection.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Eighteen hundred dollars. Thank you.
... Applause.
SPECIAL PRESENTATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time I want introduce an
individual who has worked behind the scenes for the Citizens Flag Alliance to help get our
message across to thousands of people. You saw him in the video just a few minutes ago.
In fact, he produced that video, as well as two or three others during the course of our
campaign.
He is Ike Pappas, the President of Ike Pappas Network Productions. Ike is a veteran
of television, having spent more than 30 years as a network news correspondent for both
CBS and ABC News, covering assignments all over the world, including a few shooting
wars. He also is a military veteran, like us, having served in the United States Army’s “Big
Red One” in Germany during the Korean War period.
I introduce the newest member of The American Legion, Ike Pappas, for the purpose
of a special presentation.
The Certificate reads:
Presented to Ike Pappas Network Productions. The 3.1 million members of
The American Legion in National Convention assembled, do hereby express
their heartfelt thanks to you for writing, producing and directing “Old
Glory”, and “Your Flag, Your Fight”. These two films inspired thousands
to join with us in the battle to secure a Constitutional amendment to protect
the United States Flag.
On behalf of eveiy member of the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated, we
do hereby express our appreciation to you for lending your considerable
creative talents to the cause. Presented during the 77th Annual National
Convention of The American Legion, September 1995.
Signed by myself, Bob Spanogle as National Adjutant, and Dan Wheeler, the President
of the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated.
I hope you will wear this American Legion pin with pride.
46
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
IKE PAPPAS, PRESIDENT
Ike Pappas Network Productions
I’m highly honored. It isn’t often that someone gets to work in the profession that he
loves, and receives this kind of recognition as well. I have had quite a moving experience
in joining with the CFA in this great crusade, and I believe that I have been privileged to do
so.
As you heard in that brief introduction, I did serve in the military. I was in toward the
end of the Korean War but did not go into Korea. I went to Germany where I proudly
served with the 1st Division in the Public Affairs Office. I was a writer. I did my share.
I wrote, and I must say the Army helped me a great deal in my career.
I didn’t get into a lot of scraps until I went with CBS one year in 1967. CBS sent me
first to Vietnam. After returning from Vietnam, I went to Bolivia to try to find Che’
Guevara in the midst of a civil war and do an interview with him. Then I wound up in the
Middle East in the Six Day War in 1967. By the end of that year I was convinced that CBS
was trying to kill me.
But I lived on, happily to found my own company and serve many, many clients’ with
many worthy causes. In particular this one.
I must say that I was very fortunate in the production of these videos, particularly the
one that you just saw. First of all I had the strong leadership and guidance of my good
friend, Dan Wheeler, who kept us on course in terms of a message. He developed into a
television star in his own right. He’s really talented. He really handles himself on camera
beautifully. He should be congratulated for the job that he’s done.
In any event, we were fortunate also to have on our staff some of the most talented,
dedicated people in television production on our staff. They were fully involved in this
project. They were committed to it and it, of course, could not have been done without
them, so I should not be accepting all of the congratulations here. My staff should be
congratulated too, and I accept this award on their behalf as well.
We were fortunate also to have the words and music of Porta Jordan to build this video
on. "That’s more than a flag you are burning, it's the American dream." What a wonderful
line to develop a video on. We were fortunate to have those words. And so because this
became the emotional nucleus of our video, I accept this award also on behalf of Porta
Jordan.
Finally, I am the son of immigrant parents who came to the United States at the early
part of this century to seek their share of the American dream that Porta Jordan sings about.
Because they passed the respect and the love that they had for this country on to their
children, because they taught us these high values and didn't fail this country, I accept this
award on their behalf also, and for all of those who came to these shores and helped to
weave the strong fabric of democracy that cloaks and protects our country today.
Because my parents worked hard, I became a television journalist, and as such have
staunchly defended the First Amendment all my life, guaranteeing the freedom of speech
and of free press. I deeply believe in that amendment, but I also believe that burning and
desecrating the American Flag is very, very wrong. And so on a personal level, our videos
represent a labor of love for me, too, and I hope and believe it shows up on the screen.
Our productions, as I mentioned earlier, are not the result of my efforts alone, they are
a team effort of the highest caliber. Editors, camera crews, producers, directors, have all
to be in sync; they all have to work together to get the job done.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
47
No one organization could have accomplished what the CFA has accomplished so far.
It had to be a conglomeration of organizations all working together, as they will in the final
stages of this effort. I am convinced that the CFA will ultimately be successful in the
Senate, and that the states will ratify this amendment and will become the law of the land.
When it does, we will be there to record it.
SOCIETY OF AMERICAN LEGION FOUNDERS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: From the trenches of World War I, to
the sand dunes of Desert Storm, The American Legion has continued to serve veterans, their
families and the children of this nation. Its been 77 years since the first Convention in
Minneapolis in 1919.
As we gather in Indianapolis, the Society of the Founders of The American Legion,
Incorporated, has just two men living who were present at the first National Convention.
I would like to read a brief message from George Bentley, Chairman of the Executive Board
of The American Legion Founders, who is unable to be with us today.
He writes: “I am pleased to send you greetings. Last year I attended the National
Convention in my home city of Minneapolis, and also remember the great convention held
before in 1990 in Indianapolis. There are now just two of us Founders remaining. Perhaps
my friend John Gable is with you there at the Convention. You should all realize that never
again will you see a Founder present at a National Convention. The era is soon coming to
a close.
“But for the sake of John and myself, please continue the ideals upon which The
American Legion was founded. And that can only come about through the strength of our
members, both in numbers and determination.
“I hope you have a great Convention.”
Ladies and gentlemen, I think we should rise and give a standing ovation in honor of
the Founders of The American Legion that are still with us, John Gable and George Bentley.
... At this time the Delegates viewed a video vignette.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is fitting that while the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion focuses on commemorating World War II, our next
guest is a World War II veteran of the Royal Canadian Navy. For years now he has been
actively working for veterans in Canada as a member of the Army, Navy and Air Force
Veterans in Canada. He holds many awards for his civic service.
It is my pleasure at this time to welcome the Dominion President of the Army, Navy
and Air Force Veterans in Canada, Mr. W. T. Russ Ward.
W. T. RUSS WARD
Dominion President, Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans
In Canada
It is with great pleasure that I bring greetings to you from your neighbor to the North.
It is with greater pleasure that I bring you greetings from Canada’s oldest veterans
association, the Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada.
For those of you who are unaware, we have a unit of our association within your
Legion. It is the Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada, United States Unit, and
48
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
abbreviated to ANIVICUS.
We trace our association with The American Legion back to 1948. In the ensuing years
our friendship has grown and the bonds of the friendship have strengthened, so that today
we are akin in our common concerns.
It is fitting that we join with you in your commemoration of the victory over Japan,
ending the Second World War. We, too, fought in the Pacific, although the bulk of our war
effort was concentrated in the European theater. We fought at Hong Kong and, in fact, our
Canadian soldiers were some of the first prisoners of the war taken by the Japanese on
Christmas Day, 1941, some two and a half weeks after the treacherous attack on Pearl
Harbor.
We fought with you in the Aleutians, in the clearing of Kiska and Attu, when we were
part of the Special Service Force. Our experiences were opportunities for us to join together
for the defeat of tyranny.
Today we very much appreciate the opportunity to join with you, our friends and
associates, to renew our fellowship and our association.
During the parade yesterday, we had the honor to see the Canadian Maple Leaf flag
being carried along with the Stars and Stripes with the New York State group. It made us
very proud.
To show our esteem for you, Commander Detweiler, and the association of The
American Legion, we present you with this gift.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much. I assure you that
we in The American Legion were also proud because I know that the Departments along the
Canadian border are very proud to have an active relationship between the Canadian
veterans organization and The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Also from Canada, our next guest is a
World War II veteran, having served in England and Europe from 1942 to 1946. He's a
former farmer and business man who today serves as the Dominion President of the Royal
Canadian Legion. In his years with the Royal Canadian Legion, he has served on
committees for youth, veterans services and seniors.
Please give a warm American Legion greeting to Mr. Hugh Greene.
HUGH GREENE
Dominion President, The Royal Canadian Legion
I’m honored today to be here and bring you greetings from your 560,000 comrades in
the Royal Canadian Legion in Canada. It’s a particular pleasure for me to be able to bring
these greetings in this year that marks the 50th anniversary that marks the end of the Second
World War. It’s a pleasure because our great nations did so much individually and as
partners to bring an end to the conflicts in Europe and in Asia. It wasn’t the first or the last
time either.
Many of our Canadian veterans served with your military forces during the horrors of
World War II, and many of yours served with us. Whether it was as individuals who
crossed that great undefended border to do what they thought was right or in the many
combined international commands that were formed during the war, whether it was at sea,
in the air or on land. There was a particular relationship that developed between American
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
49
and Canadian military forces that continues until this day. We share a continent of vast
proportions, and its defense against any type of aggression ensures that the relationship
forged during the world wars and the Korean War will continue.
This is particularly true of your military which has to get involved in the side of the
British military again. For it has been said that the real role of a Canuck in this world is to
spend his life explaining to the Brits about the Yanks and the Yanks about the Brits.
As you start your business session today, I wish all of you the best in your
deliberations, because I know that you are running into the same problems in the United
States as we are in Canada, especially in regards to veterans’ benefits. While our political
systems and some definitions may differ, you can be assured that we are as concerned as you
are because there seems to be a tendency to forget what our veterans have done for our
countries and many others in the world.
That forgetfulness may be brought on by the pressures of the issues that exist today,
issues that push the sacrifice of the past, to the priorities that are running governments these
days. It is our job, then, in both countries to insure this does not happen.
This year the Canadian veterans have seen the greatest outpouring of affection and have
been the subject of the most publicity I've seen since the end of the Second World War. I
suggest this has been true here in the United States of America also. What happens next
year and the year after that? Are our veterans, now that they have had the great public
acknowledgment they deserve, to slip into history with less and less attention being paid to
their needs?
I'm here to tell you that this is not going to happen in Canada as long as the Legion
exists there. I am certain the same is true in the United States where The American Legion
is a watchdog for veterans. Therefore, I ask you to deliberate carefully and look to the
future, never forgetting the past. To do so is to break trust with those who have gone before
us. “... as long as there are Legions.” I say that optimistically, even though in Canada
we are losing enough members for some to question the length of our organization's
viability. Our veteran population is decreasing at a normal rate in Canada, as the last real
war that qualified a Canadian service member as a veteran was in Korea. Most of those
20,000 veterans are now over 60 years old.
But we still have a large base on which to recruit, those who served in the military in
peacetime being the largest. And we are going after them just as you are from what I read
in The American Legion Dispatch. It is not easy and it won’t be easy for many reasons, but
if we don’t, who will look after those who are serving now in duty locations like Bosnia, the
Middle East, Africa, Asia, the Caribbean, Central and South America? Who is going to
look after their needs when their sacrifice to the nation is done?
We all know that what is stated by the politicians today can easily be changed. We also
know that revisionism is rampant on this continent. That is why the Legion, yours and ours,
exists, to insure that those who serve their countries are never forgotten in any way. That
is why I bring you greetings from your fellow Legionnaires north of the border. I also bring
you a message of encouragement and a message of support.
You have suffered your Enola Gay. We suffered with The Valor and the Horror, a film
documentary that was produced in our country decrying what Bomber Command, which
flew out of northern England, did to the German population, and we fought that. We didn’t
gain very much.
That message is to keep our Legions strong and to do everything we possibly can to
insure that they stay strong. The older veterans must realize that time has come to pass the
50
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
torch. The younger veterans among us must remember they are taking on a sacred trust to
refuel that torch so that its flame burns bright and strong.
For the sake of those who cannot be here and for those who can, continue to suffer
because of their service we must take on the forces of revisionism so their honorable
sacrifice is never diminished.
From what I have seen in my recent visit to your headquarters in Indianapolis, your
Veterans Service Bureau in Washington, your state organization in Montana, I know that
you are a strong, vibrant and dedicated organization that is capable of meeting these
challenges. With that said, I wish to thank The American Legion for the invitation to be
here to share with you the spirit of comradeship that has been forged in war and maintained
in peace.
I can truthfully say there are no greater nation of friends on the face of the earth today
than Canada and the United States, regardless of the politics that may come between us
from time to time. May it ever remain so, and I wish you every success in your deliberations
during this convention.
Commander Detweiler, in appreciation, I would like to present you with a gift from
your comrades in the Royal Canadian Legion. Also I bring to you at this time a plaque
which we had produced. It says:
Presented to the American Legion by the Royal Canadian Legion on the
occasion of the 77th Annual National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: One of the opportunities the National
Commander has is to visit our counterparts, those veterans who have served and represent
their nations in other countries of the world. Our next guest is a Vice Chairman of the
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen in the Republic of China. He’s
a man with a distinguished military career who has found a fulfdling second career in
serving his fellow veterans.
Would you please welcome a very delightful gentleman and a gentleman whose
hospitality I enjoyed last evening, Retired General Colonel Chao Yu.
GENERAL CHAO YU
Vice Chairman, Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
It’s my great honor to be able to attend your 77th annual convention on behalf of the
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen of the Republic of China. The
American Legion and the VACRS have enjoyed a history of association for nearly 20 years.
During the time, our two organizations have kept mutual visiting activities in which we
exchanged experiences of promoting veterans’ welfare and discussed on some subjects
which benefited us. And our relationship is thus growing firmer and sounder.
This year marks the 50th anniversary of the victory of the Second World War. On July
7th, 1937, the militants of Japan started the so-called ‘Cambridge Incident’ on the China
mainland and began an all-out invading war onto China. In order to defend our country the
Chinese civilians as well as soldiers, gallantly devoted themselves into the war, fighting
against the invaders. The Chinese troops fought unaided until the end of 1941 when the
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
51
Japanese gave a surprise attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7th the same year. The next
day, December 8th, your 77th Congress resoluted to declare war against Japan and thus
allied with my country, the Republic of China, and laid a firm and solid foundation for the
final victory of World War II.
At the time, President Roosevelt telegrammed Generalismo Chiang Kai-shek to express
his respect for the Chinese bloody fighting against the Japanese invasion during the previous
four years and urged that the Chinese and the Americans join efforts to fight against our
common enemies and stop the invasion. On January 3, 1942, President Roosevelt
recommended that Generalismo Chiang Kai-shek assume the post as the Supreme
Commander of the Allied Forces in the China theater, while the American General Joseph
Stilwell later followed by General Albert Wedemeyer was assigned to be the Chief-of-Staff.
The close cooperation between the solders of our two countries during this period led
to great victory in 1945. On July 26th of that year the United States, the Great British and
the Republic of China jointly signed the Potsdam Declaration and asked the Japanese to
surrender unconditionally. 20 days later the Japanese government finally accepted the
request and brought the Second World War to an end.
The people of the invaded countries were thus delivered from their enemy's threat,
restored to their right to live and dignity of being human. In retrospect in this path of
history, the veterans of our two countries feel proud and especially cherish the result of this
cooperation. Although half a century has passed, our friendship has not become weak. It
grows even stronger and firmer instead.
Just recently your senators invited Madame Chiang Kai-shek to a Capitol Hill party
which was held in her honor. This congressional gesture signifies that both of our two
countries hold the records of our past cooperation.
In the past 50 years, although the global situation and international relations have
undergone great changes, the veterans of our two countries have been maintaining the
ever-firm traditional friendship, because we have shared common ideals and objectives. We
are allies of difficult times, and the friendship between difficult times allies is sincere and
lasting. The American Legion has been offering us assistance and cooperation in the past.
It truly makes us treasure your friendship. I would like to once again extend our
appreciation for all you have done.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Before the general makes his
presentation, let me just assure him that The American Legion is a friend, now and in the
future.
GENERAL CHAO YU: In recognition of the outstanding performance and
contributions of your National Commander, Mr. Detweiler, the Vice Chairman Lieutenant
General Chao would like to present on behalf the president of my country, the Republic of
China, a medal of the Order of Cloud and Banner to the National Commander. The
Certificate reads:
Mr. William M. Detweiler, the National Commander of The American
Legion, has distinguished himself by his outstanding contributions to the
promotion of friendly relations between the peoples of the United States of
America and the Republic of China and to the enhancement of ties and
cooperation between the veterans of our two countries. In appreciation of
his meritorious service, National Commander Detweiler is presented the
52
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Order of Cloud and Banner with Clarity by the government of the Republic
of China in accordance with Article 11 of the Chinese Armed Forces
Declaration.
Resolutions signed by our State President Lee Teng-Hui, co-signed by Mr. Lien Chan,
the Premiere, and General Chiang Chung-Ling, the Minister of National Defense on
September 4th, 1995.
GENERAL YU: The American Legion and VACRS, the Vocational Assistance
Commission for the Retired Servicemen, of the Republic of China have been very close
friends in the past 20 years. Therefore, each year when we come here the chairman of my
organization, General Chou Shih-Pin would like to remember our close association in the
past, and present again, a plaque to the national president.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you, 1 am deeply honored by the
presentation. And I suggest to all of you, if you ever have an opportunity to go to Taipei,
Taiwan, if you have a chance to see the programs that the veterans of this organization,
VACRS, is involved in, they’re absolutely incredible; the work that they do, the industry
that they support, and the work that they provide for the veterans of their country.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next gentleman to bring greetings
to the 77th National Convention of The American Legion is also a distinguished military
officer. He served in the Korean Air Forces and retired more than ten years ago after
commanding the Korean Combat Air Command. Today he finds himself serving other
veterans in his role as Vice President of the Korean Veterans Association.
I am pleased to present Retired Lieutenant General Kim Jae-Yun.
LT. GENERAL (RET.) JAE-YUN KIM
Vice President, The Korean Veterans Association
It is a great privilege for me to be invited to attend your 1995 Annual Convention.
I extend warm greetings on behalf of all members of Korean Veterans Association.
Dear American Legionnaires, as the main strength of the United Nations forces, the
United States committed a total of 1.2 million troops during the Korean War and suffered
heavy casualties of 54,246 killed in action and 103,000 wounded in action. You saved our
country at such a great cost during our most serious crisis.
After the war, you provided us enormous support for our rehabilitation and progress.
Without your assistance the remarkable progress we now enjoy would never be possible.
We thank you very much from the bottom of our hearts.
The world is now pursuing reconciliation, peace and welfare of mankind. But, in spite
of this trend, North Korea has never abandoned its efforts to communize with South Korea.
They have not implemented the nuclear agreement made between the U.S. and North Korea.
They also rejected dialogue with South Korea. Therefore, the South/North relationship is
still in a cold war as before and we cannot escape from it.
Not only that, North Korea has deployed its major combat strength near to the truce
line. They appear intent on developing weapons for mass destruction and further enforcing
their conventional military strengths. These problems together with the nuclear issue make
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
53
North Korea a serious threat to peace on the Korean peninsula and the entire world as well.
We Koreans are happy that the historic U.S.-Korean War Veterans Memorial was
dedicated on July 27th this year in Washington, D.C. About 400 Korean War veterans from
our association attended the dedication ceremony. The memorial will serve as a reminder
for everlasting friendship between the people of our two countries.
Dear friends, we take great pride in our traditional friendship. I look forward to your
continued support in furthering the security and mutual interests of our two nations. In
closing, I sincerely hope your convention will be a successful and rewarding one.
LIEUTENANT GENERAL YUN: Ladies and Gentlemen, I would like to have the
honor of presenting a plaque to National Commander William M. Detweiler. It reads:
Presented to Mr. William M. Detweiler, National Commander The
American Legion. In grateful recognition of his dedicated contribution to
the support of national security of the Republic of Korea and to the
promotion of friendly relations between the two organizations. September
4th, 1995. Indianapolis, Indiana.
Signed by Chang Tae Wan, Major General Army Retired, President Korean Veterans
Association.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, General. I had
the opportunity to visit with General Chang briefly in Washington, and I have had the
opportunity to visit with him when I was in Korea. He bit me on the ear and I understand
he likes me. That was his expression. Great custom. Those gentlemen live in an area of the
world that all of you know is very much in flux and under a lot of pressure. The nuclear
capabilities of North Korea and China make a very unstable situation. The American forces
that are there help to make it a more stable place. And we thank both of you for coming and
being with us and we assure you of our continued friendship and support.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time I introduce Mr. Dante
Mattioni representing the Chapel of Four Chaplains in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, for the
purpose of a presentation.
PRESENTATION
LEGION OF HONOR BRONZE MEDALLION AWARD
THE CHAPEL OF FOUR CHAPLAINS
The example of the Four Chaplains: Fox; Goode; Poling and Washington, a Priest, a
Rabbi, two Protestant Ministers in giving their lifejackets to those without, on the deck of
the USS Dorchester on February 1943, remains the symbol of courage and selfless service.
It is the cornerstone of the work of the Friends of The Chapel of Four Chaplains.
During the past couple years that work has continued despite the move of the Chapel
from the Temple University campus in Philadelphia to Valley Forge. In fact, the activities
of the Friends of the Chapel of Four Chaplains has increased substantially. The Chapel
remains the center for interfaith cooperation, and its chaplains, now numbering more than
sixty around the country, consult regularly with military chaplains and others on matters of
54
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
interfaith cooperation.
Last year, the Chapel directed or assisted in more than 1,000 memorial services around
the country. And its news bulletin has been sent to more than 30,000 people four times a
year. In addition, the Chapel, as part of its youth program, has given more than 100 cash
grants to deserving young adults over the past two years. The Chapel continues its National
Legion of Honor program, stressing its theme of "Unity Without Uniformity," and its
mission, "Encouraging Cooperation and Selfless Service Among All People."
This afternoon, the Chapel honors Mr. William Detweiler, National Commander of
The American Legion. Mr. Detweiler has served The American Legion for more than 30
years as a Post Commander, District Vice Commander, Judge Advocate, and Chairman of
the National Public Relations Commission, National Foreign Relations Commission, and
National Vice Chairman. He is an attorney and the elected constable for the First City
Court in New Orleans. He served in the United States Army Intelligence Corps and in the
active and standby Reserves.
He has been actively involved in the New Orleans community, serving on dozens of
committees and chairing many of them. He is a long time member of the Los Angeles
Historical Society; a Co-chair of Operation Heroes Welcome in New Orleans; and chairs the
Advisory Commission for the Agent Orange Family Systems Project.
He is an outstanding family man, and is married to Maureen Reed. They have four
great children: Scott, Bonnie, Keith and Jeannie.
In a lifetime of service he has committed himself to the service of his country, the
service of his community, and the service of his family. We are honored and privileged on
behalf of the Chapel, to present the Bronze Medallion to Mr. Detweiler for his selfless
service and for encouraging cooperation and selfless service among all people. We have in
addition, a plaque, and at the top of this plaque there are the pictures of the Four Chaplains.
The plaque says:
The Legion of Honor Bronze Medallion, presented to William Detweiler,
National Commander of The American Legionl994-1995, by the Chapel of
Four Chaplains, Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, in recognition of outstanding
service to all people, regardless of race or faith. This award symbolizes for
all Americans and for all time, the unity of this Nation founded upon the
fatherhood of one God.
THE AMERICAN LEGION DISPA TCH
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The August 24th edition of the Dispatch
includes a special section on the reflections of Legionnaires who fought in World War II.
If you’re not a subscriber, please take advantage of the special discount rate offer
between now and September 30th.
BUICK PROMO
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Just before the gavel falls for this day,
I remind you of the drawing for a 1996 Buick LeSabre automobile. Ticket books are
included with your registration. You can also purchase additional tickets at the display
booth.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
55
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates, would you please join me in
a salute to the Flag of the United States of America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Flag.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will stand in recess until
9:00 o'clock tomorrow morning.
. . . At 2:17 P.M., the Convention recessed, to reconvene the following day, Tuesday,
September 5, 1995, at 9:00 A.M.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
57
PROCEEDINGS
SECOND DAY
Tuesday, September 5, 1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegates listened to the music of the AOs while slides of World War
II Posters were displayed on large screens.
... The Convention was called to order by National Commander William Detweiler at 9:00
A.M., EST.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates please stand and render a righthand salute to the Flag of the United States of America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the invocation, I call on our National
Chaplain, Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr. of South Carolina.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Let us pray. Oh Lord, God, we again invoke Your blessing upon this 77th meeting of
The American Legion Convention.
We ask that Your love and blessing may rest upon each of us as we carry out the duties
and responsibilities that have been placed upon us.
Flelp us to be kind and considerate, and lovable in all those things we do, and help us
this day to uphold God and Country. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, please remain
uncovered and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of
America.
... The Delegates stood and recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Convention is now in session.
As we begin the Second Day of this 77th National Convention, we continue our
commemoration of World War II and the men and women who gave so much.
With us this morning to help us relive the music and the songs of the war years, are
seven talented individuals from the American Cabaret Theater here in Indianapolis. These
are the same men and women who set the tone for the extremely moving Post Everlasting
Ceremony yesterday morning.
... At this time the Delegation was entertained by the American Cabaret Theater Singers,
followed by a video viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Yesterday, you answered my request to
make a few phone calls. Well, I want you to know that you filled all of the voice mailboxes
of those Senators that you called.
But I’m not satisfied.
58
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
I want you to go out there today and make a few more phone calls. I want you to make
those calls until you shut down those switchboards. Washington is going to get the message
that the American people mean business.
This is an issue, this is an American issue and they are going to hear this message loud
and clear: We want that amendment passed and we will do what we have to do as a people
to do it.
DONATION TO CFA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: And now I have a group of Legionnaires
from the great State of Ohio who are going to come up here and place something in the
hands. Let’s see how many matching placements in the hand we can get today, or in a
reasonable time.
At this time I introduce the State Chairman of the CFA, of the great Department of
Ohio, Dean Scholl.
DELEGATE DEAN SCHOLL, OHIO: Thank you for taking time out from your
schedule to allow us these few moments.
I introduce the gentlemen on the stage with me: Our NEC, Gerald Moore; Adjutant,
Roger Hight; Past Department Commanders, Klipstine; Gable; Hendrickson and Myers, and
our present elected Commander, Jerry Wilson.
Mr. Commander, when the House voted on their resolution, the amendment, we was
only able to give you 15 of our 19 representatives. When the Senate votes, at the present
time I can only promise you one, but we sure are working on the other one.
When the reports come out each month, Ohio is, and has been, fifth or sixth in the
amount of petitions turned in; fifth or sixth in the amount of donations, and fifth or sixth in
the total amount of donations that have been made.
In Ohio we have this motto: So long as one concerned American remains, we will
strive to protect our precious American Flag. We will not do it by force, we will do it by
the choice of the people and with the voice of the people. That is a message that we are
sending to Congress and the Oval Office.
Mr. Commander, on behalf of the Ohio American Legion Auxiliary, The American
Legion, and ail of the other organizations that have worked with us in the Department of
Ohio, I want to present to you this check for $10,000.00.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our first guest this morning is a man who
is well known to most of you. He’s a decorated combat veteran of the Vietnam War who
today heads the Department of Veterans Affairs. He’s responsible for a system that provides
health care services and benefit programs for our fellow veterans and their families.
Please welcome a member of Post 72 in Warrenton, Virginia, the Honorable Jesse
Brown, Secretary of Veterans Affairs.
THE HONORABLE JESSE BROWN
Secretary of Veterans Affairs
[Secretary Brown’s speech was often interrupted by applause.]
I want you to know that it is great to be here with all of you. I also want you to know
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
59
that this is where I come to stay in touch with who I am and who I want to be. I want to take
advantage of this opportunity to ask all of you to say a silent prayer for our Past National
Commander, Dale Renaud.
... A moment of silence was observed.
We will miss Dale. He was one of those special people who made this Nation great.
I’m sure that from somewhere near God, he is smiling on all of his friends gathered here at
this National Convention. Dale took great pride in The American Legion and its
accomplishments for veterans, and he was right to feel that way.
This organization has a distinguished record of fighting for veterans and their families.
Another chapter in this outstanding history was written this year. I want to commend the
Legion for speaking out against those who wanted to rewrite history when the Enola Gay
went on display in Washington D.C. I find it very irritating about some of these so-called
history professors. While they may have forgotten what you did, history will never forget.
The Enola Gay delivered the decisive message that ended the war and saved thousands of
our citizen soldiers.
Just three days ago, President Clinton and I honored our World War II veterans who
died in the Pacific. As we were there standing in the Punch Bowl, a National Cemetery,
looking at thousands of graves, I asked myself time and time again, how dare they try to
rewrite history. It was our veterans lives that were on the line in 1945, not some history
professor 50 years later setting in a classroom talking about what could have been. You told
it like it was, and would not accept anything less. You proved once again that The
American Legion is a powerful voice for right.
My friends, the past two and a half years as your Secretary for Veterans Affairs have
been the most challenging of my life, and I want to take advantage of this opportunity to
thank Bill Detweiler, Bob Spanogle, and especially John Sommer for their help. Together
we faced the tough issues by asking one question: What is best for veterans and their
families?
This cooperation is absolutely necessary if we are to achieve our goal of putting
veterans first. For example, our National Commander spent a lot of time visiting with
members of the House Appropriations Committee. His work, along with other leaders,
helped restore part of the two hundred and six million dollars they were trying to take away
from our 1995 budget. Once again the voices of veterans were heard.
Recently, I was reminded again of why we do what we do, and I want to tell you about
a special experience I had this summer. It took place when I stood with President Clinton
on the Mall in Washington as the Korean War Veterans Monument was dedicated. There I
saw countless men and women with tears in their eyes. It reminded me very, very clearly
once again that freedom is not free.
It reminded me of the dedication of another monument, the Vietnam Veterans
Memorial. That black polished wall contains over 58,000 names of our friends who never,
never came home. But it is not until you actually see the individual names that you feel the
magnitude of the loss.
I felt the same way at the dedication of the Korean War Veterans Memorial, which is
just across from the Wall, and again you could see that the cost of war was high. In Korea,
over 100,000 came back home wounded and they were the lucky ones. For you see, over
54,000 paid the ultimate sacrifice. And now plans are being made to build a memorial to the
men and women of World War II. I think it is about time that we honor our World War II
veterans. After all, they saved the world.
60
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
These are examples of why this Nation owes them and all of our veterans a tremendous
debt. It is a debt that The American Legion will make sure is paid. Working together we
have made important advances on issues such as improving health care; Agent Orange; Post
Traumatic Stress Disorder; Persian Gulf Syndrome; improving services for women
veterans; POWs; helping homeless veterans; and burying our veterans with dignity.
But my friends, we cannot stop now. For some reason we have reached a point where
those who defended the Nation must now defend themselves. Veterans benefits are under
attack. We are now in a period where the Nation must deal with the issues of balancing the
budget, reducing taxes and increasing defense spending.
We are all for lower taxes and eliminating the budget deficit. We also agree that we
need a strong national defense, and we all want a leaner, more efficient government. These
are clearly wise goals that will require difficult choices. In order to pay the one trillion
dollars for these goals, we as a Nation must establish priorities. But I say to you, the same
as I say to our leaders, we must not balance the budget and pay for tax reductions on the
backs of our veterans.
Veterans have already paid a tremendous price for their benefits, and I might add at the
risk of offending some, they are the only Americans to have done so.
And I’m troubled when I see and hear politicians talk about all of our social problems,
but most of them are not willing to talk about the impact that the budget would have on
veterans and their families. And that is why you and I cannot allow anyone to break the
moral obligation that this Nation has to its veterans. That is why we must remain alert. We
must remain alert because we have hypocrites in the land. They say nothing is too good for
veterans, and they turn right around and do just that, nothing.
There are those, as you know, for whatever reason, who feel that veterans are getting
a free ride, but I don’t hesitate asking them: Who do they think paid for the ticket?
It’s amazing to me as I travel all across the countiy, that politicians will come here and
there and promise you what they will do for you tomorrow, but they are not willing to pay
for today. For example, they keep telling me that we need to eliminate some VA hospitals
because the veterans population will continue to decline, but I keep telling them they ain’t
dead yet, they ain’t dead. And as far as I’m concerned, the Nation still has an obligation to
veterans. They must understand that we earned those hospitals and we’re not going to give
them up without a fight.
They are trying very, very hard to confuse us by calling the VA a sacred cow, but we
veterans, we in The American Legion, are not confused. They are the ones that are
confused. They have a cow mixed up with a lot of bull, if you know what I’m talking about.
It would be a sad time in our Nation’s history if we allowed the ill-informed to lead us away
from our most solemn obligation, the obligation of caring for our veterans. You and I know
from our own experience, it is a simple idea, you care for those who have cared for the
Nation.
And I have been personally the subject of many attacks. They call me the lobby fox
in the hen house, and suggested that I should not head the VA. But I say to you, the head
of the VA should be an advocate; he should be a lobby fox. I’m your lobby fox and I’m
proud of it.
There are some in Washington, D.C. who feel that the Nation can no longer afford to
say thanks to her veterans. For whatever reason, we veterans are on the verge of being
declared a luxury that costs too much. Who are these people attacking veterans programs?
Have they been to the river of death? Have they walked in our shoes? Have they even
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
61
served in the military? If they have not, they need to be very careful about how they treat
our citizen soldiers.
Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not against non-veterans, my mom is a non-veteran. But
I am against those who do not support our veterans and their families.
The President supports veterans. Take the VA’s budget for instance. He increased the
VA’s health care budget for next year by one billion dollars without cutting other veterans’
programs. But the Congress has other ideas. The House Appropriations Committee has just
provided an increase of $563 million for veterans health care. This may look and sound
good, but let me tell you who’s going to pay for it: we veterans are. They are going to take
money from service-connected veterans and other accounts like construction. They are
simply robbing Peter to pay Paul. This is wrong. It is bad for veterans and it is bad for the
country.
This means that we will not be able to build badly needed hospitals in California and
Florida. Also, we will lose some of the money that we need to renovate some of our older
facilities and to bring them up to community standards. The days of the 16 bed wards and
communal bathrooms must end. And they also want to stop compensation to some
incompetent veterans. This is outrageous. Now, let me tell you why.
They’re not talking about grandfathering anyone in. But let us say that we have a
World War II veteran who’s sustained a gunshot wound to the head. Because of brain
damage he’s incompetent. He has more than $25,000 in his estate, and as a result, the VA
will stop all of his compensation. That is not fair. It is nothing but a means test, and it
would push these service-connected veterans into poverty.
Congress did the right thing in 1992 by letting this legislation expire, and I hope that
they will do the right thing today by not reenacting this bad, bad public policy.
But some in Congress still do not get the message. The Congressional budget sends
a signal that the end of the Nation’s commitment to veterans and their families may be on
the horizon. If Congress follows through on it, by the year 2002, VA would be forced to fire
61,000 doctors, nurses, and other health care workers; close 41 hospitals; cancel 150
construction projects; deny care to a million veterans, most of them World War II and
Korean veterans that are already receiving it from the VA. They want to make poor
veterans, and I underline the word poor, pay more for their medication from the VA, and of
course make veterans wait longer to get a decision on their claims.
They are entertaining a lot of crazy proposals on Capitol Hill. Some even have
proposed changing the rules for determining service connection to only include those who
become disabled as a result of performing military service.
And what does this mean in the real world? You know those people out there, they
have a way with the King’s English. They try to make everything sound good. Well, what
does it really mean to the veterans who have paid the cost?
Let us say that your grandson, or your son or your daughter goes into the military and
is assigned to Germany. And on a weekend pass he’s in an accident, and becomes a
quadriplegic, paralyzed from the neck down. Today, and rightly so, VA would provide this
veteran with vocational rehabilitation, compensation, and medical care for the rest of his life.
But if some on Capitol Hill have their way, this soldier’s condition would be stabilized and
he would be discharged from the military, and then? And then he will be sent home so
mamma and daddy can take care of him for the rest of his life. He would not get
service-connected compensation, medical care, or vocational rehabilitation benefits. That
is not right and you and I are not going to allow that to happen.
62
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Are we coming to a time when our warriors are no longer appreciated? This budget
resolution is disgraceful, but we are also hearing other outrageous ideas. Let me give you
some examples.
Some want the means test compensation. Let me tell you why that’s a crazy proposal.
Let us again say that we have a World War II veteran who has lost an eye, both arms and
both legs at the Battle of the Bulge. Despite his disability, he opens up a little store and
becomes successful. His wife also works full time. Maybe she’s a teacher or a nurse.
Under their option they will take away his compensation if he and his wife make too much
money. That is not right. Compensation has nothing to do with his paycheck or his wife’s
income.
Our veterans should be compensated for their disabilities and not penalized for their
abilities. It is simply not right to take compensation from a man who left parts of his body
on the battlefields of the world. If they are going to do it, then give him back his eyesight;
give him back both his legs, both his arms, and I do not mean artificial limbs, if you get my
drift.
There are those who for whatever reason would tax compensation and pension benefits.
That is simply not fair. Our veterans have already paid taxes on their compensation and
pension benefits; paid them in full with their own blood and suffering.
And they are even talking about eliminating compensation for veterans rated 10 and 20
percent disabled. It’s not right. This Nation does not fight cheap wars. You and I know
that. We cannot allow nickel and dime politics to cut the heart out of our veterans programs.
Make no mistake about it, when they are talking about cutting Medicare, Medicaid and
veterans benefits, they are not talking about themselves, they are talking about us.
We hear a lot these days about sharing the burden and making sacrifices, but we’re not
hearing nearly enough about those who have already paid their dues, our veterans and their
families.
So let me ask you, the people who have been there, do you think that it is right to tax
compensation?
Do you think that it is right to stop compensation to incompetent veterans and deny
disability benefits to veterans hurt in the military?
Do you think that it is right to make poor veterans pay more for their medication; close
41 hospitals and slam the doors to a million sick veterans?
You’re absolutely right. We should look them right in the face and say to them in
clear, and plain English, “You ought to be ashamed of yourself.”
I don’t say this too much in a public forum, but I think it is ironic that all of these
assaults on veterans’ programs come at a time when only about 30 to 35 percent of the
members of Congress are veterans. About 70 percent or so are not veterans. Something is
wrong with that. And the only thing we are asking them to do is take a look, or at least take
your cue from the people who have been there; who understand what it is like to be of
service to the Nation; to be sensitive to the sacrifices that our veterans have made.
We are now in the process of commemorating the end of World War II, a war where
we lost 400,000 of our citizen soldiers. Over 700,000 of them came back home wounded
and disabled, and now they are talking about cutting VA hospitals. I say to them in clear
plain English: We honor our dead by responding to the needs of our living. That is the way
that we should run this country.
To those who do not understand why we in the veterans’ community do what we do,
come with me and I will show you the price of peace; come with me and look into the eyes
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
63
of a veteran who has lost a limb but not his dignity; look into the eyes of a mother or father
who has been told that their son or daughter would never, ever come home; look into the
eyes of a young wife learning that her husband will be disabled for life. If they look into
their eyes, and if their hearts are in the right place, they will see, as American Legion
members see, the real America, the America built on sacrifice, courage and love.
We can never repay the families for their pain. They have lost so much, and this Nation
has an obligation to them. With your help, that is an obligation we shall keep.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We make you this promise, that when the
VA is acting under your direction and you are acting as you have stated, on behalf of the
interests of the veterans of this country, we will be with you and will be your advocates. But
our moral obligation is also that when things are not going well, to be adversaries. That’s
the freedom we have in this country.
We congratulate you for all that you have done for the veterans of this country, and
we look forward to continue to work with you in the future.
Thank you very much for coming and being with us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Also with Secretary Brown is a
gentleman that some of you may have recognized who is now the Under-Secretary of
Intergovernmental Affairs, the former director of our VA in our office in Washington, John
Hanson.
The weather in our nation’s capitol was hot and muggy in July in stark contrast to the
bitter cold that we so often associated with the Korean War. Despite the weather, thousands
of Korean War veterans paraded in Washington and stood this July in the sweltering sun as
the Korean War Veterans Memorial was dedicated.
Our next guest is a Legionnaire who served on the Korean War Veterans Memorial
Advisory Committee with distinction. He is a Past National Commander, and he’s a man
that can sell refrigerators to Eskimos; make them think they’ve really gotten something for
their buck. This man just loves to raise money. If you have any causes out there and you
need somebody to raise money, get his card. Please welcome from the Thomas J. Roberts
Post No. 78 in West Roxbury, Massachusetts, ‘Jake’ Comer.
JOHN P. ‘JAKE’ COMER
Korean War Veterans Advisory Committee
We will be watching a brief tape of the dedication that can be ordered through Emblem
Sales. It is a review of that day’s activities, the beautiful culmination of eight years of hard
work by all of you and so many others to make the Korean War Memorial a
forgotten-no-more War.
Before we see the video tape, I certainly would be very remiss if I did not express into
the record some thanks to many individuals who were responsible for my efforts in making
The American Legion so successful in the fund raising efforts:
From the Washington Staff: Executive Director John Sommer; Mike Schlee, the
Director of the National Security and Foreign Relations; Cherrie Johnson, the Director of
Human Resources; Chuck Bums from the Legislative Committee; and Monica Moore, the
Executive Director’s Secretary.
From the Indianapolis National Staff: Bob Spanogle, National Adjutant; Phil
64
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Onderdonk, the National Judge Advocate; Joe Posato, the Assistant Director of Internal
Affairs and my excellent and enthusiastic liaison who couldn’t attend the dedication because
of military obligations; his boss, the Director of Internal Affair, Hugh Dagley; and Patty
Wykes the Internal Affairs and Membership secretary.
Also, I must express my gratitude to Past National Commander Miles Epling who
presented my name to President Bush for the original appointment to the KWV Board and
to each following National Commander: Robert Turner; Dominic DiFrancesco; Roger
Munson; Bruce Thiesen; and finally to Bill Detweiler. Bill did an exceptional job in
representing The American Legion at the dedication ceremonies.
I would like to thank Aurelia Pasowski of East Chicago Unit 369 of Indiana. A
member of the Auxiliary she was the No. 1 supporter, raising more money in selling pins
than anyone else in the country. I want that in the record. Aurelia deserves the thanks of the
American Legion Auxiliary and all of you.
Thanks, too, to Jack Cover from Post No. 69 in Robinson, Illinois, the Department
Chairman of the KWV in Illinois. I met Jack when I was first appointed. Past National
Commander John Geiger sent to me a Korean pin that was sold in Illinois. He thought I
should ask Jack Cover for permission to use this pin. I did and we raised something like
$80,000 just from the selling of those pins.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: That is only a clip of the actual film
which itself runs for about 35 minutes, showing the Commander’s Reception, to Samsung,
to the dedication, to the parade. It sells for $11.95.
I also want to thank Dan Wheeler, Milford Forrester, and the Magazine Commission.
Thanks also to Lew Wood, Lee Harris, and the Public Relations division who helped in
putting the video tape together, along with feeding publicity to the media.
The heat of that day was upwards of 94 to 96 degrees. The Kava Water Company
supplied the 700,000 little water jugs all throughout the day.
In the video, you saw Rhonda Skypeck adding insignias to the painting of those units
that served in Korea. Eveiy unit that served in Korea is on this Skypeck painting. It’s only
selling for a very minimal $25.
I have gone to many posts and have seen Vietnam and World War II planes and
insignias. This print now gives you the opportunity to show every unit in conversational
piece when individuals come into your post.
But as I said, the Korean War Veterans Memorial Advisory Board created plans for a
dignified celebration that was fitting tribute to those veterans that fought valiantly in Korea.
The plans for the dedication ceremonies included a wreath-laying ceremony, a Pusan Tent
City where The American Legion had an air-conditioned tent. Let me tell you, that certainly
came in handy. The other veterans’ organizations did not have the same. There was no one
but The American Legion that really was out front, first class.
We had over 400 members marching behind our National Commander in the parade.
Every national officer of The American Legion marched. We had the Canton Band of
Massachusetts, the Waltham Band, and the North Dakota State Band. And I counted up the
marchers of the VFW, the DAV, and the AM VETS, the Vietnam Veterans. Totally
combined, they had 52 marchers. So your American Legion was right out front as they
always are.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
65
A Legionnaire from Illinois was selling all kinds of caps out there, but there is nothing
with The American Legion emblem and dedicated to the Korean War Veterans. I’ve been
assured by the Emblem General Manager that you will be seeing on sale a Korean War
Memorial cap out of Emblem Sales in the future.
You heard about Samsung. Our Executive Director of the Korean War Veterans
Memorial Advisory Board, Bob Hanson was presented by Samsung a half million dollars
for dedication expenses. They also said they wanted to do something to help those that
helped their country remain free. They asked Bob where they could give a substantial
amount of money to an organization that would appreciate it. He directed them to The
American Legion, because he knew we had programs in place; scholarship programs and
individual programs that help our youth and everyone else in this nation. And I was proud
that if there was anything else we received out of this, getting that five million dollars was
another testimony to you, the members of The American Legion.
I’m working on another individual from Korea who possibly may give us another half
million dollars in scholarship money.
I will give you the to-date final figure of my final report: With the coin sales and with
all other contributions to-date, the figure officially will be $618,362.21. We started three
years later, but are less than $10,000 from being the top fund raiser in this nation.
Could Jack Cover and the National Commander come forward for a presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The plaque reads:
In grateful appreciation to Jack Cover for his outstanding commitment and
contributions of over $100,000 to the Korean War Veterans Memorial,
through the design and sale of the official American Legion Korean War
Veterans War Memorial pin. In witness whereof, this commemoration is
hereby attested to by the hands of the duly authorized officers of The
American Legion at National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, September
4 through 6, 1995.
Signed by myself as National Commander and Bob Spanogle as National Adjutant.
Jack, thank you very much.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: I introduce to you, Jack Cover from
Post 69 in Illinois.
JACK COVER
POST 69 (IL)
It’s with great honor that I receive this plaque. It was quite a shock. I didn’t expect
this.
Without all the help from you out there, each and every one of you gentlemen and
ladies, and non-veterans this pin would have never have made this much money.
I have something here that I would like to give to Jake also. I have a check here for
$2,500. It’s going to be a little tough to cash. It’s a big one, so he’s going to have to take
care of it. It’s from The American Legion of Illinois Korean War Memorial Committee;
remitter Jack Cover, Committee Chairman and made out to The Korean War Memorial
66
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Maintenance Fund of Washington, D.C.
It wouldn’t be right without having this here for Jake, for the hard work that he’s put
in on this. I also have something that only a few in southern Illinois have seen. It’s a big
image of what we have done with our pin. Jake, I would like for you to have this to hang
very proudly.
While we’re here, it wouldn’t be appropriate unless he had this one to go with it. From
the bottom of my heart this is dedicated to all POW/MIAs. I want it to be hung beside the
Korean Memorial pin very proudly.
We are looking forward to more sales. Help Jake out because he’s a go-getter. Without
his help, I could never get onto this.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: Thank you all again for your work. It’s
been my pleasure for the last five years to come to you at these conventions with updates.
I am thrilled and privileged and think you will be, too, when you see the monument. There
is no finer monument in the history of our nation. The Korean War Veterans will be
forgotten no more.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Those of you who had the opportunity
to be in Washington know what a moving event it was. And Jake mentioned 400 marchers
who were behind us all as part of the Legion delegation. I would suggest to you, Jake, that
there were a lot of other vehicles in that parade that we saw later on that were spaced out in
the parade that were from American Legion posts around the country. So I think that the
Legion was extremely well represented there without a doubt.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion’s ability to
provide service to our fellow veterans through a nationwide network of service officers and
our ability to provide temporary financial assistance to veterans’ families would not be
possible without The American Legion Endowment Fund.
To help each of you better understand the fund and how you and the members you
represent can make it stronger, I introduce the President of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation, a Legionnaire from Post 71 in Kansas City, Missouri, Mr.
A.G. Hays, Jr.
A.G. HAYS, JR., PRESIDENT
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
Last winter here in the National Headquarters, arrangements were made to produce a
video that would outline the duties and the responsibilities of The American Legion
Endowment Fund. Here to introduce the video to us this morning and tell us about it is a
member from the Board of Directors of The American Legion Endowment Fund, a man
heard speaking just a few minutes ago, Past National Commander ‘Jake’ Comer.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: We’ll be showing another short film.
Now you’ve realized what my next project is. And I have a booth out there for that, too.
Roll the film of the Endowment Fund that had contributions by Past National
Commander Jimmy Dean, Past National Commander Joe Matthews and myself in regards
to the Endowment Fund.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: Just think about it: 1925, $5 million
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
67
dollars; 1945, The American Legion donated $2 million; and here we are in 1995, for the
first time in 50 years, starting out on a fund-raising campaign. This is the most well-kept
secret in The American Legion. I don’t know how many really understood what The
American Legion Endowment Fund is all about or what it does. And now I hope you do.
So continue to do what you do best, giving of yourself, on behalf of The American Legion.
And now, A.J., please come forward.
I have the most outstanding department in this nation. There are times they wish I was
somewhere else. But to start this fund off and to get it on its right course, as we hope many
of you will do the same in your departments, I would like to present to you on behalf of the
Department of Massachusetts this check for $5,000.
DELEGATE HAYS: I, too, want to thank the Department of Massachusetts for your
very generous gift.
EMPLOYER OF THE YEAR AWARDS
FOR HIRING VETERANS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion is very proud of
the employers of America who have made hiring veterans a matter of good business. To
honor those companies, The American Legion Employer Of The Year Award was
established.
The companies we honor today have demonstrated a keen sense of understanding in
hiring veterans. This morning we recognize three such organizations as the 1994 Employers
Of The Year.
The awards are given in three categories: One for the companies employing fifty or
fewer people. Another for companies employing 51 to 200 people, and a third for
companies with more than 200 workers. Each is nominated by a Post and advances through
the Department and National competition levels. The 1994 Employer Of The Year Award
in the ‘under fifty’ category goes to Southwest Research Institute of San Antonio, Texas.
Richard Curtin, the executive vice president of the company, is here to accept the award.
RICHARD CURTIN
Southwest Research Institute, San Antonio, Texas
It’s always a great honor for a company to be recognized as an employer of the year.
But it’s particularly meaningful when that recognition comes from an organization as fine
and as proud as The American Legion.
As a veteran myself, I am very happy to be here to accept this award. We at the
institute have helped in our own small way to assist veterans in their transition from military
life to a life in the industrial sector, and we’re very proud to have helped. But I must tell
you that our motives were not entirely altruistic, because we believe, and I think you know,
that veterans make the best employees, bar none. They come very well trained and they
come with a very strong sense of duty.
So on behalf of the men and women of Southwest Research Institute, I’m very happy
to accept this award. I want to assure all of you that we will display it in a very prominent
place at the institute.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The award that is given to all three of our
68
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
winners reads as follows:
The American Legion National Award Outstanding Employer Of The Year
presented to the particular employer for an exceptional record in the
employment of veterans.
Presented at the 77th Annual National
Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, September 5, 1995.
And now the award in the ‘51 through 200 employees’ category goes to Caldwell
Machining, Incorporated of Emporium, Pennsylvania. Here to accept the award is the
president of the company, Joseph Caldwell.
JOSEPH CALDWELL
Caldwell Machining, Incorporated; Emporium, Pennsylvania
It is a great honor to be invited to your National Convention to be given an award by
the world’s largest veterans organization. I am indeed humbled and, at the same time, happy
to be here today.
The accomplishments of The American Legion on behalf of all veterans is second to
none. Seventy-seven years of service to God and Country is something that you can be
proud of.
The American Legion has kept faith with those that have served their country. After
military service and the return to civilian life, you joined this organization of individuals
who have continued to serve this great Nation by becoming a voice in national affairs.
America is a far richer country because of the never-ending contributions that Legionnaires
make to their communities. I salute your selfless service, your extraordinary patriotism, and
devotion to our Country.
My wife, Linda, who is my helpmate and business partner, works with me daily at our
business, Caldwell Machining, in the little town of Emporium, PA. We have been
completely overwhelmed upon receiving this award.
The veterans hired by us are our future. Working together we can build a future that
will result in creating more jobs. Veterans are not only good employees, they are good
citizens in our community. As a result of our experience in hiring veterans, I assure you,
veterans will be given first class treatment at Caldwell Machining.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The award in the category of200 or more
employees goes to Boeing Aerospace Operations, Incorporated of Midwest City, Oklahoma.
Here to accept the award are Ms. Constance Bruner, the Human Resource Manager,
and Mr. Paul Ray, Director of Aircraft and Training Operations for Boeing Aerospace
Operations, Incorporated.
RAY PAUL
Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc., Midwest City, Oklahoma
We’re very pleased to accept this award. At the Boeing Company in Oklahoma, for
every three employees that we go out after, we hire two veterans. And as was said earlier,
if there is one basic reason for our success, veterans are the most qualified people, no other
reason than that. So as a veteran myself, I’m happy to accept this award, and God speed.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
69
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We acknowledge these good people for
their employment of our veterans. They do us all and America a service in employing our
veterans and giving them an opportunity to return and to enter productive lives after taking
time out of their lives to serve our Country.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is my pleasure at this time to extend
a special opportunity for a distinguished Legionnaire to introduce our next guest.
Fellow Delegates, Mr. E. Roy Stone of South Carolina.
MR. E. ROY STONE, SOUTH CAROLINA: I am proud to have the honor to present
the next speaker. Our families have known one another for over 50 years. For over 20
years, our families would meet on January the 1st and have the usual New Years Day dinner.
Then our wives would get together and talk, and his father and I would go in and start
watching the football games and go to sleep.
I saw him grow up and go through high school. He was an athlete, a captain of the
senior football team at his high school.
Then he went to college and was president of the student council. And all of this
indicated that he was a leader. He graduated at Furman University cum laude, and then went
on and attended law school.
He followed his father Ted and his brother Pat into law practice. He served our county
in the House of Representatives and then as a Senator. He ran for governor of the state and
was the first governor of my state to succeed himself. He served for eight years.
His main interest, not only as a senator, but as governor, was education. Our state of
South Carolina, during his administration, made great strides in education during that time.
He was also Director of the Duke Endowment which was very friendly to education in our
area. And he also developed a large law firm with his father and brother.
A Democrat, active when Governor Clinton ran for President, where he showed his
worth there in being able to carry the many states that he was in charge of.
His alma mater, Furman University, named one of their science buildings for him. It’s
known on the campus as the Riley Building.
His devotion to education and our schools is great. He resigned his position with Duke
Endowment, a very lucrative position and gave up temporarily his law practice when
President Clinton asked him to be the Secretary of Education.
He and his wife have had their tragedies. They had twins, one died, one lived. So he
knows something about death. My wife and I had no children. But as I told his dad and his
mother, if we had a child, a boy, we would want him to be like our next speaker.
He served in the Navy after his graduation at Furman. He is a veteran during the
Korean period. He is a disabled veteran, and a member of my Post. I might add that he is
an artist, and one of the brightest lights, as I see it, in the Clinton Administration.
Delegates to this Convention, I present to you a great American, an outstanding patriot,
an educator, my friend, your friend, a fellow Legionnaire of my Post 3, the Honorable
Richard W. Riley.
70
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
THE HONORABLE RICHARD W. RILEY
Secretary of Education
[Secretary Riley’s speech was often interrupted by applause.]
Thank you, Roy, for that warm introduction. It’s a great honor for me to be here and
address this group, this 77th Annual American Legion Convention.
Roy knows how much I also cherish the friendship of our families. He and my father
were the best of friends. He was like a second father to me, and I can see them now asleep
in their chairs as I was trying to watch a football game on New Year’s Day.
Milford Forrester and all of my other friends from South Carolina, it’s great to be with
you.
I noted that my colleague in the Cabinet, The Honorable Jesse Brown, spoke with you
earlier today. He’s a distinguished veteran and fights for veterans all the time. It is my
pleasure to work closely with him as he serves as Secretary of Veterans Affairs.
My subject, of course, will be education, but I don’t plan to give you a lot of facts and
figures as some kind of expert. Everybody has their own ideas about their children and their
education. Everybody is entitled to that, and I respect it.
When I was Governor of South Carolina, I remember I was down at Myrtle Beach
making a speech one time. This older gentleman came up to me after it was over and said,
“Dick, it’s about lunchtime, why don’t you join me for a sandwich?” I said, “All right.” We
were sitting there talking, and he said, “You know, Dick, I just retired and moved down here
to Myrtle Beach, and I went to one of these senior citizens functions the other day. They
had an expert there,” and said, “and we were all sitting around in there. It was one of these
audience participation things, and he asked me to stand up, and I stood up. And he said,
‘How old are you?’ I said, ‘I’m eighty-five.’ He walked over to the blackboard and said,
‘Do you know there are three 85 year-old- women for every 85 year-old-man?’ He said,
“You know what I told him, Dick?” I said, “What?” “I told him that is the most useless
information I have ever received.”
So I’m going to try and not give you a whole lot of useless information.
First off, let me pay tribute to all of our Nation’s war veterans, and tell you that
America is deeply grateful for your service. This year, we pay special tribute to World War
II veterans. A few months ago President Clinton paid homage to these heroes when he said,
“We must draw inspiration from this extraordinary generation that won the war.” A few
members of the extraordinary generation, Brigadier General Paul Tibbets, pilot of the Enola
Gay, will receive the Legion’s Distinguished Service Award. I would like to share my
opinion about the controversy surrounding the Enola Gay Exhibit. No amount of historical
revisionism can change one basic fact: We were the good guys in that deal.
We were fighting for the freedom of the world. I was in Dallas with the President when
the press asked him about Truman’s decision. And he said that he clearly agreed with
President Truman. General Tibbets had a tough job; he did his duty and he helped end the
war, saving countless lives. I salute him for it.
Veterans of all of our wars have served with distinction. The service of Legionnaires
doesn’t end when they return from war. Legionnaires have become home-front heroes as
well, making their communities better in so many ways.
We have many problems in this Country, we all know that. But if everyone had the
same commitment to serve their fellow Americans as Legionnaires do, we would be a lot
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
71
closer to some solutions.
The Legion also has a long record of support for education of veterans’ children and
all adults. The Legion has often led the way in endorsing the support of education
improvement. The crown jewel of this effort, of course, was the GI Bill, which I received,
and was able to go to law school under it. It opened the doors of college to millions and
millions of veterans.
Today our scholarship programs, School Awards, Boys and Girls State, Boys and Girls
Nation and many other programs, support quality education for our youth. I also had the
good fortune of going to Boys State, and I was elected sheriff.
The Legion understands that if ever there was a time to focus on education, it’s now in
the information age, the age of education. Our freedom, our national security, our jobs, our
economy, even the survival of our most basic American values are more dependent upon
education now than ever before.
As Thomas Jefferson said, “Our laws and our Constitution must go hand-in-hand with
the progress of the human mind.” You see, in a democracy the educational level of our
people, where the people have the power, is very critical.
In that spirit, let me ask you to lead us in one more great crusade for America. You
won the war against fascism and communism. Now I ask you to help America win the war
against ignorance, and, more than that, win the war for excellence in education for all
Americans.
Respecting the American tradition of local control of schools, we’ve been working to
expand educational and training opportunities and to make every classroom a safe and
disciplined place, a first priority for this Country.
Let me take a few moments to tell you what we’ve been doing to support your efforts
and the efforts of millions of Americans who are working hard to improve education.
First, to make our schools hospitable to people of all faiths, the President instructed
me to offer guidance which would describe the religious activities that are allowable and
protected in the public schools under the First Amendment of the Constitution.
As the President said, when our students go in to the school building, they do not leave
their religious beliefs at the door. And they should not. Students have broad opportunities
to pray while in public schools. They may read the Bible; say grace before meals;
participate in extracurricular religious clubs and many, many other activities, so long as the
rights of all are respected. The Constitution already protects religious expression. And in
this God-fearing-Nation of ours, the public schools must not be hostile to religion.
We have also moved to support character education, because too many of our children
simply aren’t learning the difference between right and wrong. As one education leader has
put it, our Nation has gone from “Leave it to Beaver”, on the one hand, over to “Leave it to
Beavis and Butthead” on the other.
With the support of parents, character education programs teach children good
citizenship, responsibility, honesty, respect, discipline and hard work. In short, the values
that you would want a man in a fox hole next to you to have, are the very kind of values that
we are talking about.
To help the character development of children in my “State of American Education”
speech, February the 1st, I asked Hollywood to scale down the anti-violence on TV and in
movies. We are trying to put kids on the right track by supporting anti-drug and violence
prevention programs in the schools.
We have also launched a campaign to encourage greater parental involvement in
72
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
education, because we believe that parents, not governments, raise children. The Legion has
been very supportive in these family involvement in education efforts. I’ll tell you, parents
who know their children’s teacher; the parents who help with homework and who teach their
kids right from wrong, can make all the difference in a child’s education.
Now, when it comes to national defense, the importance of education in our nation’s
military has never been greater. I firmly believe that if America is to remain the world’s
number one military superpower as we are and have been, we must also become the world’s
number one education superpower.
Just ask any of our Desert Storm veterans to describe the high level of learning and
training that they needed to use the high tech weapons that won the war quickly. It simply
takes smart people to build and use smart bombs.
Our military knows that having recruits who are well educated, means higher retention
rates, reduced training time, and increased productivity. All of that helps to ensure unit
readiness. Two things that really count in war: One, Keep American casualties low.
Victory.
Today our National Defense is also linked to the strength of our economy, as you well
know, and our ability to create and keep jobs right here in the USA. Unfortunately, the real
income of the American middle class has been falling over the past 20 years. We are
attacking this problem by creating our Nation’s first school work apprenticeship program
to prepare high school graduates for real jobs with a real future.
We have called for tax breaks for workers seeking further education and further
training. We are expanding access to higher education by helping many more working
families pay for higher education.
Finally our Goal 2000 to Educate America Act, calls for high standards of learning,
with an emphasis on basics, learning computers, core academic subjects like English, math,
science, history and civics.
On the subject of standards, let me address an issue that has drawn wide comment. I’m
speaking about the guidelines for the teaching of American history that were proposed by
an independent education group late last year. These guidelines were criticized because they
cast American history in a bad light.
Let me make our position clear on that matter. The American History Standards were
developed under a grant awarded during the previous administration. The standards were
never endorsed by the U.S. Department of Education in the Clinton Administration, and
they were deeply disappointing to me. This wasn’t our grant. These were not our standards.
They do not represent my view of American history, and they don’t represent the President’s
view either.
No school in America is being asked by our administration to teach these standards, and
a respected group is now developing other history standards which we hope will be a big
improvement.
As for the study of American history itself, let me again be very clear. We must tell our
children the truth, and the truth is, that America is the greatest country in the history of the
world.
We have made mistakes; we have had peaks and valleys. Sometimes our greatest
strength has come forth in the valleys, but we have always tried to correct our mistakes.
America has been the world’s beacon of freedom for 219 years, and 1 want every single
school child in America to know and to honor that history.
There is a great thirst for knowledge out there among our children and among their
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
73
families. A recent poll showed 98 percent of all parents hope to send their children to
college, almost 100 percent. Yet there are some in Congress who seek to make the largest
cuts in aid to education in our nation’s history. These cuts will impact everybody in this
country. The cuts couldn’t come at a worse time. School enrollment will reach a record
high in just two years. Cutting back on education, just when we need it the most, would be
like cutting back on national defense right after Pearl Harbor.
As a result of your efforts and the efforts of so many others, we are beginning to see
real progress. SAT scores are up; dropout rates are down; math and science achievements
are up. We have a lot of work to do. We all know that. We have much more to do, but it
is positive that we are on the move.
American education is like a car that’s speeding up, but some in Congress want to
siphon off the gas, and that is a mistake.
Now America has a great choice to make. We can continue to go forward or we can
sound the retreat. I note that The American Legion has already made that choice. The
theme of your celebration of American Education Week is: Good Schools Are Great
Investments. So the Legion is moving forward.
Something else that saddens me about recent actions in Congress is the sharp break in
the proud American tradition of bipartisan support for education. Education should never
be a political football. When it comes to our kids, we need more thought and less noise.
After all, we don’t educate our children in this country as Democrats and Republicans and
Independents, but as Americans, and that’s what it should be.
And in this spirit of cooperation I will announce this week an exciting new initiative
called America Goes Back To School, a place for families and for community. And I invite
all Americans to reconnect to their schools and to become involved in activities to improve
education.
We have already asked members of the Armed Services to participate, and as usual they
have answered the call. America Goes Back To School is a perfect community service
opportunity for all of us to go back to the schools where we went, and for all Legion Posts
to get involved in that activity. I think you would find it a very rewarding experience.
So as I close, let me ask you to think about the children of America. It’s a complicated
time to grow up. It’s a complicated time for all young people. We all should do what we
can to see that all of them have the chance to get a quality education, because no person can
be successful in this country without having an education in this day and age.
Let me close with the words I think that say a very important message by a country and
western singer. I’m a little partial to country and western music. I don’t know if any of you
have ever heard of Kathy Mattea, but she’s a lovely person and has a wonderful poignant
voice.
My children gave Tucky and me a CD player for Christmas. We had two CDs. One
of them was by Kathy Mattea. The song that I heard and liked so much, is called “Seeds”.
Imagine, if you will, riding down the street and seeing a number of children playing in the
playground. The song goes like this: “Sometimes I stop on my way home and watch the
children play. And I wonder if they wonder what they’ll be someday. Some will dream big
dreams and make it all come true, and others will go on dreaming things that they’ll never
do. We’re all just seeds in God’s hand. We start the same; where we land is sometimes
fertile soil and sometimes sand; we’re all just seeds in God’s hand.”
Seems to me that our children of this powerful, wonderful democracy are the seeds of
greatness for this great country. They are certainly our future. Yes, some land in fertile soil
74
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
and have quality offered to them and every opportunity, and others land in sand and rocks.
But they all have great potential. They are all important.
I’m so proud that Legionnaires are working everyday to provide fertile soil in which
our children can grow, making sure that all of our children grow up straight and tall and
smart, no matter where they land.
For the Legion believes, I am certain, that here in America in 1995, there should be no
weeds in the gardens of our schools.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, over the past 12
months I have had the opportunity to stand up on your behalf against the revisionist forces
of the Smithsonian Institution and, in particular, the National Air and Space Museum.
During those months, I have had the great honor to stand up for the valor of the men that
you are about to meet, their historic mission, and to stand up for the courage of President
Truman in making the decisions; a decision to drop the bombs on Hiroshima and later on
Nagasaki; decisions which ended a devastating war. And it’s my distinct pleasure to have
this opportunity to present The American Legion’s highest honor, the Distinguished Service
Award to the crew of the Enola Gay.
Our award is presented to distinguished Americans annually in recognition of
outstanding service to the nation. And I can think of no more significant and meaningful
contribution than to have brought a sudden and decisive end to the bloodiest and most
destructive war in world history, as carried out by the courageous men on that most
important mission of the Enola Gay.
There is no doubt in my mind that many of you who are here today would not be here,
if it hadn’t been for the courageous mission of the men of the Enola Gay.
Please turn your attention to the screen to see and hear these men who delivered the
dawn of peace a half century ago, and in their own words describe their historic mission.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is one sad note about one of the
members of the crew that you saw in the movie, and that’s Bob Carron. Bob Carron passed
away some two months ago, and is sadly missed by his family and his fellow crew members
who are with us today. Let me also at this time now introduce to you the crew of the Enola
Gay.
Commander Paul Tibbets; the navigator, Dutch Van Kirk; the bombardier, Tom
Ferebee; and last, but not least, the radio operator, Dick Nelson.
This is a very historic moment for all of us. These gentlemen sought no publicity,
sought no recognition and have, in fact, avoided publicity and recognition. They only did
what their commander-in-chief asked them to do as good airmen, as good soldiers. They
carried out the mission on behalf of their country. We are most proud and grateful that they
have come to be with us today and to allow you — those, whose many lives were saved —
to acknowledge and thank them for their efforts.
BRIGADIER GENERAL PAUL W. TIBBETS, USAF (Ret.)
Pilot of The Enola Gay
We are certainly honored today by this recognition from The American Legion and the
presentations of their Distinguished Service Award. I must acknowledge those who put me
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
75
in a position to do what I did and what we did. Namely, the men and women of this great
nation who arose so determinedly following the attack on Pearl Harbor on December the
7th, 1941. That unprovoked attack united this nation as nothing had before and nothing has
since. A single determination prevailed which was, “You can’t get away with that and we
will show you.”
We allied ourselves with Britain and declared war on both the Axis powers and the
empire of Japan. Immediately thereafter, mobilization began by both industry and the armed
forces. Men of fighting age began enlisting and women left their homes to go into war
production factories to build the implements needed by the fighting men. Thus, war became
a family affair. Sacrifices were made without complaint. Everyone was out to win.
Then food, gasoline, butter and things previously taken for granted were rationed.
Victory gardens were planted and harvested. War bonds were sold. Scrap metal was
collected and returned as war needs. Automobile tires went from rubber to what they call
camel-backs. Does that sound familiar? I bet you haven’t heard that name in a long time.
What am I driving at? I’m driving at a performance miracle. When our war began,
Germany had some 4,000 combat airplanes. The British had about 2,000; and our
Army/Air Force squadrons had less than 800 total aircraft. Of those, about 50 are what I
would call combat, and some of those very first vintage B-17s were destroyed at Pearl
Harbor. Our fighters were obsolete, open-cockpit P-26 airplanes. We were not very well
equipped or armed to do battle.
It took time to get the factories going, but by mid ‘43 the factories were turning out
goods at a terrific rate. The Air Force historian recently stated on average American workers
produced 191 airplanes, 64 tanks, 1,761 trucks and 20,892 tons of shipping for every day
of the war. I would call that coming from behind and beating the competition; in other
words, real team work.
In 1944, in the Pacific we really started making gains. The Army and the Marines,
assisted by naval gun power and naval aviation, drove the Japanese off of the islands. We
badly needed to get runways close enough to Japan so that the B-29s could operate
successfully and bomb the Japanese homeland. At that particular time as we worked closer
to the Marines, and we took Okinawa, the Navy had actually blown the Japanese Navy out
of the water.
Between mid-September of ‘44 and early May of ‘45,1 organized and trained the 509
Composite group that you saw in the video. By mid-July, the unit was in place on Tinian
flying practice missions against Japan with facsimile-type bombs related to the bombs used
on Nagasaki, and those bombs were loaded with torpex.
All that remained was obtaining President Truman’s approval to use the weapons. This
approval was received the afternoon of the 5th of August. Then the Enola Gay crew and I
were on our way to Hiroshima. This was about 2:30 a.m. We released our weapon at 9:15,
and in a millisecond, the city ceased to exist.
We returned to Tinian about 2:30 p.m. after a 13-plus-hour round trip. In the final
analysis, Paul Tibbets and the Enola Gay crew could never have gotten to Tinian and
Hiroshima without the sacrifices of other thousands of men and women. These people
worked to make that possible. You veterans took the lands we needed. You made it happen.
I stand before you to thank you. I salute you for your most valuable contributions that
contributed to the successful ending of the World War II.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I’d like to recognize several very
important people who are in the audience with us, the wives of three of our crew members:
76
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Mrs. Van Kirk, Mrs. Ferebee and Mrs. Nelson. Please stand.
General Tibbets, and to you, those of you who served with then Colonel Tibbets, our
heartfelt thanks and gratitude for being with us. Be assured that the families of the crewmen
who are no longer with us will also receive their Distinguished Service Medals as soon as
possible. The American Legion is committed by resolution to continue to work to insure
that the Enola Gay is properly assembled, put back together and properly displayed in a
place of honor where it justly deserves that honor.
And I can assure you that during the week that we will be in Washington for the
Legislative Meetings after the 17th of September, that we will make every effort at that time
and I will make every effort at that time, if the incoming commander so desires, to sit down
with the representatives of the Smithsonian Institution to get this properly displayed. Let’s
get that aircraft displayed without further delay. If it’s necessary we’ll raise the money.
I want you all to note that all these gentlemen are members of The American Legion.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
Donation to CFA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We have another donation. Twenty
Delegates on the floor from the Department of Kentucky donated $10.00 each for a total of
$200 to the CFA, and we thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair now recognizes Allen Titus
of Indiana, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Economics, for the purpose
of a making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEES ON
EMPLOYMENT AND VETERANS’ PREFERENCE
AND OTHER ECONOMIC MATTERS
Allen L. Titus, (IN), Chairman
At 9:00 a.m. on September 1, 1995, 80 delegates assigned to the Convention
Committees on Employment and Veterans’ Preference and on Other Economic Matters
convened in Rooms 109-110 of the Indiana Convention Center, Indianapolis, Indiana, to
consider 29 resolutions assigned to the committees for action. Allen L. Titus of Indiana was
elected General Chairman and Jim Marks of Indiana was appointed Secretary. Henry Field
of South Carolina was elected Chairman of the Convention Committee on Employment and
Veterans’ Preference and Robert E. David of South Carolina was appointed Secretary.
William Christoffersen of Utah was elected Chairman of the Convention Committee on
Other Economic Matters and Wayne Slade of South Dakota was appointed Secretary.
In response to a call by the National Adjutant, a screening committee composed of five
members of the National Economic Commission and its affiliated committees convened in
Room 114 of the Indiana Convention Center on August 31 to make recommendations to the
Convention Committees on Economics. Members of this committee were Allen L. Titus
(IN), Chairman, James McMahon (ME), Henry Field (SC), Robert Boxdorfer (MO), and
William Christoffersen (UT). The report of the screening committee was presented to the
Convention Committees and was adopted, with Resolution No. 146 held for separate
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
77
consideration. Resolution No. 146 was discussed and then accepted for approval as the
screening committee had recommended. A motion was made, seconded and approved to
authorize the Chairman and Secretary to sign the committee report on behalf of the
committee. A motion was made, seconded and approved to allow the Chairman and
Secretary to make technical corrections.
EMPLOYMENT AND VETERANS’ PREFERENCE COMMITTEE
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
Origin: FL
Submitted by: Employment and Veterans Preference
As consolidated with 10 (CO), 30 (DC), 46 (SC), 48 (TX), 51 (TX), 81 (NE), 85 (WI), 128
(SD), 132 (UT).
WHEREAS, Congress has a proud history of fulfdling its commitment to the
joblessness and underemployment of those veterans who, after serving honorably for their
country in the armed forces of the United States, are attempting to reenter the civilian labor
force; and
WHEREAS, Congress has declared its sense and purpose to ensure that all veterans,
particularly veterans with disabilities, are provided the maximum of employment services,
including job counseling, job training or retraining, job placement or other relevant services;
and
WHEREAS, The Social Security Act of 1935 placed a tax upon employers to finance
an unemployment insurance system to offset the lost wages and to sustain the worker’s
purchasing power during periods of unemployment; and
WHEREAS, This legislation, better known as the Federal Unemployment Tax Act
(FUTA), established an unemployment trust fund to serve as a repository for the
Employment Security Administration Account, which is entirely separate from the General
Revenue Account used to run the federal government; and
WHEREAS, FUTA provides administrative funds for operation of the Employment
Service, Unemployment Insurance, and the Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
agencies, and pays unemployment compensation benefits to workers; and
WHEREAS, Congress also recognized the need to monitor veteran employment
preference by creating a federal position in each state, a State Veterans’ Employment
Representative, in the Wagner-Peyser Act; and
WHEREAS, Congress created a position of Local Veterans’ Employment
Representative, in that legislation, to assist those veterans with special employment
readjustment needs and to ensure that veterans receive preference in all employment service
offices; and
WHEREAS, Congress, recognizing the ever-growing special employment, Resolution
No.-employment and unemployment needs of our nation’s veterans, passed legislation to
enhance greatly the visibility of the Veterans’ Employment Service by first creating the
position of Deputy Assistant Secretary for Veterans’ Employment in 1977, then, in 1980,
elevating the Deputy Assistant Secretary to a full Assistant Secretary for Veterans’
Employment and made the Veterans’ Employment Service a separate agency within the
Department of Labor; and
78
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
WHEREAS, PL 96-466 mandated appointment of a Disabled Veterans’ Outreach
Program specialist for every 5300 disabled and Vietnam Era veterans residing in a state to
meet the ever-increasing employment needs of that population through outreach and
outstation sites; and
WHEREAS, While the downsizing of the armed forces is substantially complete, the
services will continue to release about 250,000 people per year from active duty for the
foreseeable future; and
WHEREAS, Repeal of Employment and Unemployment Service and the Veterans’
Employment and Training Service legislation (i.e., Title 38, Chapter 41, U.S. Code) would
eliminate the primary delivery agencies for preferential services to veterans and abolish
effective administrative oversight and monitoring of all federal Department of Labor
employment, training, retraining, counseling, and Resolution No.-employment programs for
veterans including the State Employment and Unemployment Insurance Agency for
veterans, the Disabled Veterans’ Outreach and Local Veterans’ Employment Representative
programs, Transition Assistance Programs and Disabled Transition Assistance Programs,
the Homeless Veterans’ Reintegration Project, Job Training Partnership Act Title IV-C
programs, Federal Contractor Job Listing Program, Federal Agency Veterans’ Preference
Programs, and Veterans’ Re-employment Rights; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion oppose any effort
to repeal any federal employment, training and Resolution No.-employment rights
legislation or abolish any such agency funded from Federal Unemployment Trust Account
employer tax revenue; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion oppose any efforts to change the Veterans’
Employment and Training Service and the employment and unemployment service delivery
system which would compromise their ability to provide the quality services that veterans
have earned through their service to the country.
Resolution No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Origin: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
Submitted by: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
WHEREAS, The current Administration is committed to reinventing the federal
government to make it more effective, efficient and responsive to this country’s needs; and
WHEREAS, The Veterans’ Employment and Training Service is an agency within the
Department of Labor which exists for the purpose of providing America’s veterans with
quality employment services; and
WHEREAS, The Assistant Secretary of Labor for Veterans’ Employment and Training
is responsible for ensuring that the agency continues to meet its mission despite increasing
reluctance by Congress to fund it properly; and
WHEREAS, In response to the reinvention initiative, the Assistant Secretary appointed
a Reinvention Team to analyze VETS and determine how it could restructure and streamline
itself for the purpose of improving the services it provides to its veteran clients; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion also concurs with the Assistant Secretary’s interest
in making the agency even more responsive to the needs of the veterans it serves; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion supports those
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
79
reorganizing efforts that will help to make the Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
more effective, more efficient and more responsive to the needs of America’s veterans; and
be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports any legislation necessary to
accomplish the goals of the Secretary of Labor for the benefit of all veterans.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 8 (CO) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 9 (CO) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 18 (MA) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 49 (TX) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
Resolution No. 50 (TX) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
Resolution No. 80 (NE) 1995 NC: Oppose Transfer of Veterans’ Employment and
Training Service
Resolution No. 126 (SD) 1995 NC: Oppose Transfer of Veterans’ Employment and
Training Service
Resolution No. 127 (SD) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
COMMITTEE ON OTHER ECONOMIC MATTERS
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 24: Natural Resource Management
Origin: AK
Submitted by: Economics
As amended and consolidated with 87 (WI), 133 (UT).
WHEREAS, The federal government and the United States Forest Service initiated the
establishment of a permanent industry in certain areas of the United States to achieve
maximum utilization of the renewable resources and provide year-round employment and
opportunities for community development throughout the region; and
WHEREAS, Many of the planners, engineers, laborers and other individuals who were
the catalyst of this effort were veterans of World Wars I and II and the Korean War, many
of whom came to these areas as servicemen, and chose to stay in these areas, build families
and carry on productive lives; and
WHEREAS, The management of the natural resources, in part by the veterans of past
wars, constitute models used around the world as examples of successful modern resource
management and evidence of how industry and the environment can productively co-exist;
and
WHEREAS, Modern integrated resource use, which depends upon the reliable raw
material supply from the various contract sources, enabled communities to build the kind
of infrastructure and realize the economic stability that was a primary objective of many
veterans who struggled to bring this industry to the region; and
WHEREAS, Countless restrictions are increasingly falling upon activities in our
country, restrictions which have as their common foundation a subjective judgment that
resource extraction is not an industry that our government should encourage; and
WHEREAS, The restrictions placed on industries engaged in natural resource
80
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
extraction result in thousands of jobs, hundreds of which were held by veterans, being lost
to those industries; and
WHEREAS, Payroll and benefits dollars which have been lost due to these restrictions
have not only directly impacted veterans who were employed by the industries affected by
the restrictions but also the veteran-owned businesses which depend on those payroll dollars;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion fully supports the
sound and wise management of the natural resources of the United States, and that we
believe that current natural resource management practices are more than adequate to insure
the well-being of fish and wildlife; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports the proposition that the United
States government should, to protect the interests of its veterans, insure an adequate natural
resource harvesting program for independent, small business and long-term contract holders
on lands held in the public trust, and that the federal government should cease its practice
of spending funds earmarked for resource extraction for other purposes and of offering only
meager amounts of these needed raw materials to industries in the region; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion is opposed to all government policies which
lead to the cancellation of long-term contracts for resource extraction and result in severe
economic and social hardship in the communities of the affected regions and to the veterans
who live and work there.
Resolution No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
Origin: DC
Submitted by: Economics
As consolidated with 4 (KS), 20 (OR), 58 (NY), 79 (NE), 137 (VA).
WHEREAS, Surplus federal property may be obtained by certain non-profit activities
exempt under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954; and
WHEREAS, Non-profit activities may include organizations which provide assistance
to homeless individuals, the elderly, and other citizens of the United States in need; and
WHEREAS, The purpose of allowing such access to surplus federal property is to
further the dual goals of the proper disposition of such excess property and to provide
assistance through its use to assist individuals in need; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is properly and lawfully chartered as an
organization under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 as an organization
dedicated to providing the types of services contemplated by federal and state laws of this
nation; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion should
specifically be authorized by the United States Congress during its 104th Session to have
legal authority to obtain by donation or by purchase such surplus federal property as deemed
appropriate by the Congress to further the goals of The American Legion’s service to needy
individual citizens of this nation; and be it further
RESOLVED, That such enactment of law by Congress permitting acquisition of such
surplus federal property will be mutually beneficial to The American Legion’s service to
needy citizens and to the federal government of the United States as proper use of such
surplus property to benefit the citizens of the United States; and be it finally
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
81
RESOLVED, That The American Legion respectfully request and encourage the United
States Congress to enact legislation during its 104th Session to authorize the proper and
lawful acquisition and use of surplus federal property for The American Legion’s stated
purpose of assisting needy United States citizens.
Resolution No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
Origin: Economics
Submitted by: Economics
WHEREAS, Federal assistance to America’s veteran-entrepreneurs dates back to the
passage of the Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944; and
WHEREAS, That legislation established a small business loan program for World War
II veterans that was to be administered by the Veterans Administration; and
WHEREAS, The first eight years of that program were so successful that Congress later
opened it to Korean War veterans; and
WHEREAS, In 1953 Congress passed legislation that created the Small Business
Administration (SBA) and provided for the transfer of the veterans’ loan program to the new
agency; and
WHEREAS, Despite the 1974 passage of PL 93-237, which mandated the SBA to
provide “special consideration to veterans of the Armed Forces and their survivors and
dependents,” little has been done by SBA to fulfill that mandate or to promote its veterans’
programs; and
WHEREAS, In spite of a lack of resources and support, SBA’s Office of Veterans’
Affairs (OVA) has, in recent years, made a valiant effort to meet its mission and continue
an ongoing dialogue with the veterans’ community; and
WHEREAS, During SBA’s recent reorganization, OVA’s staff was reduced from six
to three; and
WHEREAS, That reduction in staff has seriously compromised OVA’s ability to
provide effective and efficient services to America’s veteran-entrepreneurs; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion views the reduction in OVA’s staff and the
elimination of its field staff as yet another indication of SBA’s total lack of concern for
veterans; and
WHEREAS, Congress has drafted a discussion bill which provides for transferring
OVA to the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and combining it with that agency’s
Office of Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization, thus creating the Veterans’
Entrepreneurial Business Service; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that such a move would improve OVA’s
ability to provide entrepreneurial services to veterans; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion fully supports any
legislative or administrative proposal that would increase and improve federal assistance to
America’s veteran-entrepreneurs.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN TITUS: Mr. Commander, that completes the Report of
the Convention Committee on Economics.
As a Delegate from the Department of Indiana, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded, and carried.
82
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
BLOOD DRIVE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: This is the final day of the drive. So far
you have donated 193 units. I would like to see us meet or exceed the donations from the
last time we were here in Indianapolis, so please take time out to donate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the past five years, our nation has
taken time to remember the sacrifice and service of World War II veterans and their families.
With us at this time is the man who has maintained a steady course in helping coordinate
countless events from coast-to-coast and overseas during this period.
Please welcome the Executive Director of the World War II Commemorative
Committee, and a member of American Legion Post No. 141 in Richmond, Virginia, retired
Army Lieutenant General Claude Kicklighter.
LT. GEN. CLAUDE M. KICKLIGHTER, USA (Ret.)
Executive Director, WWII Commemorative Committee
It’s an honor and a privilege to be with you at our National Convention. For more than
76 years, The American Legion has been serving our veterans and our nation. The Legion
is a strong force for a better America. Thank you, American Legion, for all that you do for
our veterans, our communities, and especially our young people. The hallmark of this
organization is reaching out and helping and encouraging the youth of America. Thanks also
for the great support that you provide to the military members and their families. You are
an important part of what makes America great today.
Just one example of your contributions is what The American Legion did during World
War II when you drafted and pushed through Congress the GI Bill. It’s been said by many
that this was probably the best bill that ever came out of Congress. It gave young Americans
for the first time the opportunity to study, based on ability and not the fact that they were
born into affluence. That bill has filled our Congress, it’s filled the Supreme Court, the
corporate halls of America. Many of the leaders that built this nation would not have been
there without the GI Bill.
We’re now approaching the close of the 50th anniversary of World War II. This
morning I will update that program and what remains.
As you recall, the purpose of the program is to help the nation, our nation, a grateful
nation, to thank and honor the World War II veterans, their families, and especially the Gold
Star families, the families that lost loved ones in that war. It is also to thank those who
almost overnight turned America into the arsenal of democracy, those on the home front.
Never has our nation been so united as it was 50 years ago.
To help us reach the almost eight million World War II veterans that are still with us,
out of the 16 million that served in that war, we have now more than 7,000 World War II
commemorative communities and organizations all across this land that are thanking and
honoring our veterans at a very special level in their hometowns. More than seven hundred
of these commemorative communities are American Legion Posts and Auxiliaries. The
American Legion was one of the very first major organizations to become a World War II
commemorative organization when General Colin Powell came and presented the Flag
almost four years ago.
The American Legion has also not only volunteered their Posts, but they have recruited
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
83
and encouraged many other communities and supported the states that participate in this
program. I wish I had time to share with you some of the very emotional and special events
that take place in small town America as those veterans know that they haven’t been
forgotten.
Throughout this program, education has been a very high priority, and the Legion has
been with us ail the way on that. Together, we have provided more than 20,000 schools or
recipients of some veiy professional education materials that both the Legion and our office
have been able to disseminate.
But when this program comes to an end, together we must continue to encourage the
study of the history of this era. If we learn, and if we remain prepared and strong, maybe,
just maybe World War II will be recorded in history as the last world war. Maybe the
children and the grandchildren of the generation who we honor will never have to know
anything about a global war, and not have to go through what our veterans of World War
II had to go through.
We still have some very outstanding educational materials that are available, and I’m
asking the Legion to continue to be involved, to help us as we close the program, to get
these materials in the hands of the school teachers and the schools in your communities.
During the last four years we have commemorated the major battles of the war all over the
world, and the Legion has always been there to help make this happen.
Starting on about the 13th or 14th of August, just a couple of weeks ago, we began to
commemorate and to celebrate V-J Day, a victory that finally brought an end to the most
destructive war in history, the war where more than 15 million combatants laid their lives
down on the battlefield. More than 38 million civilians, mostly women and children, were
killed in that war because they were overrun by that war.
So as we came to the end of this war, and we came to V-J Day, we remember all the
battles that had taken place in the Pacific that had led us to that victory.
In Washington, D.C. we had the Vice President participating. About 9,000 veterans
took part in a great commemoration in Washington, North Carolina. In New York City in
Times Square we had a commemoration of the end of the war. So to in Atlantic City, New
Jersey. Former President Bush participated in Fredricksburg, Texas. Omaha, Nebraska
events went on for four days. We had about 10,000 veterans and the crew of the battleship
Missouri in Bremerton, and Seattle, Washington. In Honolulu President Clinton led the
commemorations, and we had more than 30 delegates from other nations.
So we have really reflected on this closing of the war and V-J Day in celebrating this
great victory. But as we reflected on the final victory, we couldn’t help but remember the
battles at the close of the war; the battles of Iwo Jima and Okinawa. And as you heard
General Tibbets say just a little while ago, as those battles came closer and closer to Japan,
they became more deadly and more violent. The small island of Okinawa was the last stop
before we went into Japan. Almost 6,000 sailors lost their lives in the ships supporting that
effort, and more than 8,000 soldiers and U.S. Marines lost their lives fighting that battle.
A hundred and ten thousand Japanese troops died, and 70,000 civilians.
We were poised after that battle to prepare for the invasion of Japan. The date was set
for 1 November, and the island selected was Kyushu. When we began planning the invasion
of Kyushu, the enemy strength on that island was 200,000. That was in June. By August,
that strength had grown to 550,000. That battle would have been horrendous, and the battles
on the other islands that would follow would be almost unimaginable in terms of deaths and
destruction. But a bomb was dropped on the 6th, another on the 9th of August, 1945.
84
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Finally Japan surrendered, saving millions of lives and shortening that war probably by
more than a year. President Truman, the Commander-In-Chief, as we heard this morning
made the right decision for the right reasons.
We will always remember those heroes that didn’t come home. Those who gave all
their tomorrows, and that’s a very high price when you’re 18 or 19 years old. History
reaffirms that they did not die in vain.
The closing week of the World War II commemorative program will take place the 4th
through the 11th of November. On Veterans Day, 11 November, the curtain will come
down on the 50th commemoration of World War II. And we will begin that week by
dedicating the site in Washington, D.C. where the World War II Memorial will be built.
There will be many events during the week of the 4th which will emphasize education.
The Legion, as they have done throughout this program, will be a major force in helping us
to properly end this commemoration.
I would also ask the Legion, as we come to the end, to help our Committee to write the
plan to properly commemorate the 50th anniversary of Korea as well as the 50th
anniversary of Vietnam. We ask you to help us develop those two very important plans
while we still have the experience of what we have accomplished in the last four and a half
years.
No generation of Americans has ever been given a tougher job than was the World War
II generation. President Roosevelt said: “Of some generations, much is asked; of other
generations, much is given, but this generation, the World War II generation, has a
rendezvous with destiny.” And so you did.
They fought the most destructive war in history, the war that we were not prepared for.
We had to buy time with the lives of young Americans to get prepare. But they fought that
war, they won that war, and they literally saved the world. Then they came home, took off
their uniforms, rolled up their sleeves, some going back to school, but all building this great
Nation that we have today. No matter what we do as a nation to honor this generation of
Americans, it won’t be enough. There is simply no way to do that. It’s been said that any
nation that forgets its veterans, ceases to be a great nation. But as long as we have a great
organization like The American Legion, America will never forget its veterans. A grateful
nation does remember.
We thank you, the World War II veteran in the audience, for the victory 50 years ago
that gave us this strong, free and beautiful America. When we wake up each morning, we
should remember that it didn’t just happen. We should never take this gift that you have
given us for granted. God bless you.
... At this time National Commander Detweiler presented General Kicklighter with a
commemorative T-shirt.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As we move forward with the business
of the 77th National Convention, it gives me a great deal of pleasure to present to you a
Minnesota Legionnaire who has earned the respect of millions. She is the chair and the
founder of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project, Incorporated. From Northfield Post 84
in Minnesota, please give a warm welcome to Diane Carlson Evans.
DIANE CARLSON EVANS
Chair and Founder Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project, Inc.
In a diary published after his death, U.S. naval aviator Lieutenant Frank Elkins said that
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
85
it’s easier to die for an ideal than to live for it. Dying takes only a moment’s courage, while
living is a battle against day-by-day eroding and grinding forces. To stand up to life and to
hold high standards sincerely is a more difficult price than an instantaneous death.
Lieutenant Elkins struggled in July 1966 with his fears, his thoughts, his hopes, his dreams
and his profession as a navy pilot in Vietnam. In October, 1966, he was killed when his
plane was shot down. I am honored, once again, to be invited here to speak and even more
honored to be with people in The American Legion who remind me of Lieutenant Elkins’
words. You hold high standards and daily stand up to be counted on the side that you and
we value most.
You did that, in your struggle with us to honor women veterans and help to build the
Vietnam Women’s Memorial. It was ten years ago in 1985 on the convention floor that
delegates passed a resolution to place a memorial honoring women at the Vietnam Veterans
Memorial. In the following years you raised over $100,000 for the project and helped us
pass two bills through Congress. In 1993,1 came before you to say the journey is almost
over. The statue had been cast in bronze in Loveland, Colorado, and was ready to be
dedicated on November 11th, 1993. You came by the thousands to honor your sister
veterans.
Now the memorial is healing the wounds and capturing the hearts of millions of
Americans and people from around the world, whether they served in Vietnam or whether
they opposed the Vietnam War.
One day as I visited the memorial recently, I stood back and listened unobtrusively to
the remarks being expressed. A little girl, probably about five years old, held her mother’s
hand and asked, “Mommy, what did those women do in the war?” I was struck by the
thought that question would never have been asked by that young girl if the statue wasn’t
there. The mother’s reply: “Honey, they are real heroines. They weren’t forced to go to the
war. They wanted to help, and I think they must have saved a lot of lives.”
The truth is now sculpted in bronze. The truth is that women contributed immeasurably
in ways that only those whose voices were silenced can truly tell, and those who lived carry
in their hearts every day.
We received hundred of letters from women veterans telling us what the memorial
means to them, but most letters come from men. Never in our wildest imagination did we
realize how much the memorial would mean to them also.
Perhaps this excerpt from a letter by a former Marine sums it up best. He said, “As you
unveiled the memorial, I wept and applauded. Thank you. Thank you for giving us, too,
the Women’s Memorial as well as giving us the opportunity to collectively release through
our tears, our hatred, our self-pity, regret, our feelings of being forgotten and our sadness.”
The memorial is there for us and for all future generations. But yet, while women paid
a heavy price in Vietnam, there’s still a price yet to be paid on the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial. The total ten-year budget for the memorial was under $4 million, but the
remaining loan obligation is still over $300,000 for the construction, design, lighting and
landscaping costs. Over these past few months we have solicited hundreds of corporations
with very little success.
Our most recent largest corporate donor was Martin Marietta with a donation of $5,000.
We have written to Hollywood stars, producers, authors and thousands of individuals.
Sometimes there is a surprise, like the donation from Roy Rogers in honor of Dale Evans.
It’s the thousands of people who continue to support the memorial effort with their small
donations that help us chisel away at this more than $300,000 debt.
86
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Many of you know that in 1993, to fund the project’s continuing mission of healing,
education, research and identifying the women who served, we introduced the Vietnam
Women’s Memorial Commemorative Coin Act. It passed quickly and unanimously in the
Senate, and we had over 300 cosponsors in the House.
However the bill was held up in subcommittee due to political complexities, too
numerous to mention here. As a proliferation of coin bills was being passed, a moratorium
was placed on coin legislation by the Secretary of Treasury. We had to put a hold on the
VWMP Commemorative Coin.
We asked the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund to help pay for the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial. They have donated a total of $25,000. This was in 1991. After several more
requests they have refused any further donations. You will recall that the fund paid for the
Wall and the statue of the three men.
The official memorandum of conveyance, turning the memorial over to the people of
America, has given the project the right to participate in Memorial Day and Veterans Day
ceremonies. We select a woman veteran for each ceremony, and we would welcome your
recommendations. Please send these names to our Washington address. Include a brief
biography of the woman as well as a telephone number and address so we can contact her
if she is selected. We look for diversity and are considering having the children of women
veterans also be considered for speakers.
Our Veterans Day speaker last year was Gail Hagger from Montana with the Army
Special Services, and on Memorial Day, we were represented by Lieutenant Colonel Regina
Ohn who survived the Operation Baby Lift crash which killed Mary Klinker, whose name
is on the Wall.
This gives you a brief report. We work weekly with students, producers and writers.
A children’s book on the Vietnam Womens Memorial project has been published and we
are currently working with PBS on a documentary. The work goes on.
The most alarming piece, however, that has been published on the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial has come from the Smithsonian Institution. A college professor wrote a book on
public art for the Smithsonian and said, I quote, “The Vietnam Women’s Memorial gives
a warped glorification of war typical of neo-conservative revisionists’ accounts of America’s
Vietnam experience and gender roles. Like the hart sculpture, the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial makes heroes of all military Veterans. It not only elevates American guts and
glory fantasies, but turns wartime pain and sacrifice into nothing more than a bronze wet
dream involving a GI and nurses.”
She goes on to write, of course, by avoiding allusions to the real context of American
foreign policy, the Vietnam Women’s Memorial shows itself as the perfect model of a
thoroughly politicized, right-wing recuperation of the war sentimentalized as an altruistic,
innocent and unfinished American adventure.
The woman who wrote this teaches college in Colorado and is the director of the
American Studies Program. So just what else does she teach her students about us Vietnam
veterans, and why did the Smithsonian Institution print this? I quoted this for you so that
you realize as we all realize since Enola Gay that our work is far from over.
I also came here today to thank you for continuing to support the project’s efforts. One
needs only to visit the statue to realize that we did something valuable and important for
America. You have our eternal thanks for standing beside us.
I want to now make a presentation to the Commander.
Commander Detweiler, on behalf of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial project, I present
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
87
you with a replica of the statue to thank The American Legion for all the wonderful work,
and support that you have given women veterans.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Diane brings up a good point again
about the Smithsonian. We sometimes fail to read what the revisionist historians write on
the plaques. We go in and we look at the artifacts and think we should be free to believe
by looking at the artifacts and interpret that artifact in our own way, which is the way it
should be. But we usually don’t read what they’re saying about the artifacts. That’s where
we must be vigilant about their version of American history.
We need to keep vigilant. This is not censorship. This is a situation of standing up
again for what’s right and for what’s good for this country, for future generations.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It’s been my pleasure to serve this past
year with a lady from Maryland who has had the special opportunity to lead the American
Legion Auxiliary during its Diamond Jubilee Year. Her theme for the year has been, 75
Years of Service, Not Self. At every opportunity, she has made good on that theme. The
American Legion Auxiliary has supported the Citizens Flag Alliance, worked tirelessly at
VA hospitals, and made Legion-family community programs successful. I thank her for a
year of service and support, for much of The American Legion’s success comes in no small
measure from the efforts of the American Legion Auxiliary.
I present to you the National President of the American Legion Auxiliary from
Greenbelt Unit 136 in Maryland, Linda Newsome.
MRS. LINDA NEWSOME
National President, American Legion Auxiliary
Thank you so very much for what you do. I want to thank Bill for serving as
Commander of The American Legion this year. When we took office yesterday, at least it
seems like it was sometimes, we set certain goals. In the American Legion Auxiliary during
our 75th year, our Diamond Jubilee Year, I, too, set goals. I set goals on membership. I
wanted to obtain 1 million members. I still want the 1 million members. No, we didn’t
reach our goal, and, yes, we still need the help of The American Legion. But what we did
do is to increase our membership by almost 6,000, and that’s no small feat.
Yes, we did make a commitment to the Citizens Flag Alliance. We have worked very
closely with The American Legion, with the Citizens Flag Alliance and certainly with all of
our members. We truly believe that we need the constitutional amendment to protect our
flag. And we don’t just talk about it amongst ourselves. We write the letters and we make
the phone calls. We make the personal contact and we put our money where our mouth is.
I am very proud of the efforts of the American Legion Auxiliary this year on the
Citizens Flag Alliance. We are not done, but don’t ever doubt that we will carry through.
My third emphasis was to make the public more aware of the American Legion
Auxiliary. “75 Years of Service, Not Self,” and we have carried through that motto by
donating more than $17 million to our communities just this year. We have given millions
of hours of volunteer time, whether it be in our communities, in our VA hospitals or
working with the children. Wherever we are, we do make a difference.
I have been so very proud to be the National President of the American Legion
Auxiliary. I have been proud to stand side by side with a National Commander who has
taken the lead in making sure that organizations and government commitments don’t change
88
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
our history. I commend Bill on what he has done this year. 1 only wish we had time to
spend more of it together. His schedule and my schedule rarely coincided. But when it did,
it was certainly a pleasure, as it has been a pleasure to be your Queen of Diamonds this year
of our 75 years.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is a retired Air Force
Brigadier General and a woman who knows how to get things done. She is the president of
Women in Military Service for America Memorial Foundation, Incorporated. For several
years, she has led the nation’s effort to build a memorial for all women in military service.
She said to me that I will be in Washington for the day of ground breaking of the memorial.
I never said no to a General.
Here she is, a member of American Legion Post 477 in Chrisman, Illinois. Wilma
Vaught.
BRIG. GENERAL WILMA L. VAUGHT USAF (RET.)
President, Women in Military Service for American Memorial Foundation, Inc.
We very much appreciated your being with us to speak at our reunion event and then
to be with us for the ground-breaking. It seems hard to believe that back in 1987 it was just
a small group of us who started out to bring about this memorial. We wanted it to be
something more than a statue, that is just granite or stone. We felt it needed to tell the story
of our women and their service to the nation. The site picked in 1988 was near the main
gate at Arlington National Cemetery. In 1989 we had a nationwide design competition and
got a memorial design that we felt really tells the story of women’s service to the nation.
It’s a design that tells it in many ways, from the arc of glass tablets with the quotations of
women who served etched in them to reflect on the wall inside, to the water fountain where
the sound of the water will be commemorative of women’s voices. And then, we also have
the computer register where you folks in the Legion have helped us so very much by getting
women registered from your home communities. That is critical to our success. We have
about a 125,000 women registered out of the 1.8 million who have served, so we have a
long, long way to go.
By this past spring, we had amassed just enough money to have the ground breaking
ceremony. This meant that we had covered the cost of construction. I only wish you all
could have been with Commander Detweiler, the President and the First Lady and all of the
other dignitaries who were there. Some 6,000 women veterans and their families heard
speaker after speaker tell about women’s service and listened to the six women whose
service represented the span of time from World War I to today’s service women. It was a
wonderful, historic moment. The hit of that was our World War I veteran who has 78 years
service with The American Legion. I bought a tape that shows her speaking along with the
President in the actual ground breaking. Now you can live it with us as we lived it on June
22nd.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
Unfortunately Commander Detweiler is not in the video. Because you weren’t there,
we have your shovel full of dirt in Washington. For now, here is your shovel.
Like Diane Carlson Evans, we still have money to raise and equipment to furnish the
education center. We had to take a $2.3 million line of credit to come up with the amount
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
89
of money for the ground breaking I hope we never have to draw on it and end up with a
debt. When we dedicate this Memorial in 1997,1 want it to be debt free.
We are raising more funds partially through the sale of these commemorative coins.
If you haven’t purchased yours, the only place you can buy them is from us or via the
POW/MIA group or via the Vietnam coin. The prices are $35 for the coin and $75 for the
necklace. The American Legion is very close now to having donated enough money to be
listed in one of the alcoves of the exhibit. I look forward to seeing The American Legion
there along with the American Legion Auxiliary.
I found out after the convention that your Commander had invited our World War I
lady to attend the entire convention. She’s here today to say a few words.
She served in both World War I and in the California National Guard in 1951 during
the Korean crisis. She is a real patriot.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I had the great honor, on the evening
prior to the ground-breaking, to be at the reception, or the reunion as it was called, at the
J.W. Marriott. Someone came to me and said there is a lady there that he wanted me to
meet. The lady had been a member of The American Legion for 77 years. She is an
incredible person. You saw her speak on the tape. She’s a beautiful lady. She is from the
Brooklyn Post No. 2.
We have a 75-year pin for her. I would like at this time for Ann Peterson Freeman to
come forward.
MRS. ANNE PEDERSON
Brooklyn Post No. 2
Fellow Legionnaires, you cannot imagine the thrill it is for me to be here with you after
being a Legion member for 78 years. What a year this has been for me meeting the
President and First Lady, speaking on national television, and then having our National
Commander Bill Detweiler invite my daughter and me to be the Legion’s guest during the
convention. Thank you very much, Commander.
Sometime in 1919, some of my fellow women navy yeomenettes at the Brooklyn Navy
Yard started organizing a Legion post, signing up women to join. When they asked me, I
said, oh, sure, of course I’ll join. I believe I was the 13th woman to sign up. We were the
first post to receive our charter, and it was No. 1. Then some people said [incorrectly] that
the first Legion post had been organized in Paris, France, so we should be No. 2. We were
then called the First Women’s Post of The American Legion No. 2.
1 was an active member there for many years until we moved to San Diego where I
joined the San Diego Women’s Post No. 451.1 might say that one of the members of San
Diego Women’s Post is here with you today. The women in this post had belonged to Post
6, a post with both men and women. With more than enough women, they had formed their
own post and that was in 1929. I did not live in California at that time.
It was a great day for me when the Veterans Hospital was opened in La Jolla,
California, and I had an opportunity to do volunteer work there. I spent a lot of time
crocheting and knitting lap robes. We gave each veteran a lap robe to take home with him
when he was discharged.
I was an active member in the 40 and 8 for several years, but finally had to drop out
because I was getting a little older and couldn’t handle so many activities anymore. I still
90
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
belong to the Auxiliary of California, and that’s a wonderful Auxiliary.
When I moved back to New York to live a few years ago, I became a member of the
Memorial New York Post 1627. I have remained in the Legion because I like the Legion’s
idea of helping people, veterans and their families. And I have always felt strongly about
our Child Welfare program.
I was delighted when I found out about the Women’s Memorial, and it was gratifying
to know that the Legion has supported it. I didn’t know about it until June of this year. I
can only hope that each legion post will work in its community to help find our women
veterans and get them registered so they can be honored as I am being honored.
Although I may have been the 13th to sign up for my Legion post, signing up was one
of the best things I ever did in my life.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ms. Freeman said she’s indebted to us.
We’re indebted to her, because without those World War I patriots, we surely wouldn’t be
here today. I feel very strongly that it would be interesting to see what America would be
like if The American Legion had not been founded some 77 years ago.
SONS OF THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is now an honor for me to present to
you the newly elected National Commander of the Sons of The American Legion. He’s
been a member of the Sons for 24 years, and believes his involvement at the national level
provides an opportunity to lead a renewal of the spirit of America in the nation’s children.
While he’s not tackling challenges the for Sons of The American Legion, he’s Housing
Inspector for the City of Covington, Kentucky.
Please welcome a member of Latonia Squadron 203, the National Commander of the
Sons of The American Legion, John Dietz.
JOHN DIETZ
National Commander
Sons of The American Legion
It is indeed a pleasure to be with you here today, but before I begin, I would like to
introduce another officer in the national organization of the Sons of The American Legion,
our National Adjutant Woodrow Mudge from Colorado.
It is indeed a pleasure for me to be here today. You know, nowhere in the world is
there an organization quite like The American Legion. Nowhere in the world is there an
organization whose members share the unique bond of service that your members do.
Nowhere in the world is there an organization that can lay claim to having such a dramatic
impact on the life of a nation as can The American Legion. You have a special heritage that
is unique in the life of America.
As Sons of The American Legion, we share that special heritage. We are indeed proud
possessors of that priceless heritage. And since our establishment in 1932, we have been
working to preserve the kind of America that Legion members have always fought to
defend.
But our Legion family is much more than hats and parades and conventions. Day-byday in communities all across this nation we are in the people business, to steal one of
Commander Detweiler’s terms. Getting involved in our communities, making a difference
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
91
in the lives of individuals, serving America, is our job. It is noble work and it is important
work that few other organizations can or will do.
As Sons of The American Legion (SAL), we seek to be involved in that noble effort.
We seek to be a full partner in the work that you do in communities and in the states and
across America.
For this year just completed under National Commander Joe Mayne, we reached
another all time high in membership, 187,000 members raised and contributed nearly
$250,000.00, and contributed 53,000 hours to veterans rehab.
This year, too, as for the past five years, we’ve been very involved in the Child Welfare
Foundation. We were fortunate this year, with the help of our members, to raise over
$87,000.00.
For this coming year, we have a mission objective. That objective is to make the Sons
a much more visible and a much more effective member of this Legion family. To achieve
that, we have outlined three goals: First, our Flying High Membership Campaign seeks to
achieve 200,000 plus members. We want to enlarge SAL participation in Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation through the VAVS program. And we want to get more Sons members
involved, in Legion youth programs, Baseball, Oratorical, Boys State, Junior Shooting
Sports.
It’s my understanding that the Child Welfare Foundation issued a challenge to The
American Legion to raise $100,000.00 this year. To go on public record, 1 would like to
meet that challenge. I would like to beat that challenge, and challenge the members of The
American Legion and the American Legion Auxiliary to raise that amount of money,
because the work of the Child Welfare Foundation is so important and we will be there.
The Sons continue to rely on your assistance and support throughout the Nation at your
Posts, your Districts, and counties across America. The Sons stand ready to support Legion
activities whenever and wherever, and we stand ready to finally win the fight for the
Citizens Flag Alliance for the Constitutional Amendment to protect the Flag.
I look forward to the opportunity to meet with many of you this year as I travel and
visit your Departments. And Commander Detweiler, I wish you the best of conventions and
a most successful and enjoyable term.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next speaker is a Congressman who
serves as the Chairman of the Subcommittee on Western Hemisphere of the International
Relations Committee. He has a strong voting record and supports a strong military as key
to peace through strength. He served in the United States Army in the late 1950s and has
held elected offices at the state and national level since 1969.
Please welcome from the 6th District of Indiana, Congressman Dan Burton.
Congressman.
THE HONORABLE DAN BURTON
United States House of Representatives (IN)
[Congressman Burton’s speech was interrupted by applause]
I understand that yesterday Senator Dole asked where the Kansas Delegation was, and
they were over on this side. He said that’s where they belong, on the far right. So I would
just like to ask those from Indiana, what are you doing over on the left? We need to move
92
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
you guys over here.
Well, it’s great to be with you. Since I served in the military back in the late ‘50s, as
the Commander said, 1 have had a great appreciation for those who served in actual combat.
I did not serve in combat, but I admire greatly those who laid their lives on the line around
the world for our freedoms. It’s because of that, that I feel it’s imperative that the
patriotism that you showed in defending our country be continued today, and that’s why I,
along with many of my colleagues, have sponsored legislation banning the burning of the
American Flag which you fought so valiantly to protect and defend.
I understand there’s been some comments made in the last day or so about cutting
veterans’ benefits and taxing veterans’ benefits. Let me just tell you, there are a lot of places
we can cut the budget without cutting into the benefits that you folks fought so valiantly to
get. You deserve what you get, and we’re going to do what we can to protect them.
One of the things that has concerned me greatly, over the past couple of years, is the
attitude that many in elective office have toward those who fought to defend our freedoms.
As a result of some of the things that have happened, I, and my colleagues in Congress,
have taken some actions and been very concerned that these things have happened. For
instance, let me give you a couple of examples of what’s happened in the last few years.
Four of the military attache to the White House, the creme de la creme of the military,
captains and lieutenants who were assigned to the White House staff to serve the President,
were asked to serve as waiters, at a political gathering. When I found out about that, I, and
my colleagues protested vigorously because we don’t believe that attitude should prevail in
the executive branch of government. And we received, as well as the military attache, an
apology for that, and we were assured it would never happen again.
It was brought to my attention that one of the chief assistants to the President told a two
star general that she wouldn’t speak to anybody in uniform. We thought that was wrong, and
we protested to the White House; there was an apology given, and we asked for that lady’s
resignation. Respect for the people who serve in our armed services should not be
compromised or questioned by anybody, all the way up to the Chief Executive’s office.
I became particularly concerned when the administration started talking about changing
V-J Day, Victory over Japan, to: End of the War in the Pacific Day. We thought that was
an abomination. V-J Day is V-J Day and it can’t be changed by any Executive Order. The
people who fought in the South Pacific to defeat Japan in World War II deserve our respect
and our honor, and changing the name of V-J Day to anything else is a slap in the face of
those who fought so valiantly in the South Pacific to give us victory.
Finally, one of the things that has concerned many of us in Congress who served in the
military and understands what happened in World War II, was some of the revisionists’
attitude about what happened when we brought an end to the war, when the bombing of
Japan took place at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Peter Jennings did a special, on ABC. He said
that it was analogous I believe to a holocaust for us to bomb the Japanese and to force an
end to World War II.
Anybody who knows anything about history and about what happened in World War
II in the South Pacific, knows that had we had to invade the Japanese mainland. If not, we
would have lost between four and five hundred thousand men and women, not to mention
the hundreds of thousands of Japanese that would have died when the invasion took place.
When Harry Truman ordered the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki he did the right thing,
because he brought an abrupt end to World War II and saved hundreds of thousands of lives.
Peter Jennings and the liberal media need to be taken to task for making those kinds of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
93
programs, and making those kinds of statements. You folks who fought in the South Pacific
and in Europe know what I’m talking about. You know what it is to go into hand-to-hand
combat to face an enemy; and you know how horrible it is to see your buddies die; and you
know how important it was to bring the war to its conclusion as quickly as possible not to
take lives, but to save lives.
I’m proud to be with you today and proud to be an American. I’m proud to be one of
those who admires each and eveiy one of you who sacrificed so greatly for our freedoms and
our liberties. And I’m proud to honor those who did not come back from the wars, who paid
that last full measure of devotion for our freedom, many of them your comrades.
I would like to leave you with this challenge, you and your loved ones, your kids and
your grandkids. Don’t let those who want to be politically correct, don’t let those who want
to revise history, change history. You and I, and those of us in Congress who feel as you
do, need to make sure that history is reported accurately. Only by doing that can we make
sure the mistakes of the past won’t be repeated in the future. We can’t let the liberal media
and those who want to change history, achieve their goals.
We want to leave to our kids and our grandkids and our great-grandkids and our entire
posterity the message that these freedoms that you fought so hard to preserve and to protect
and defend and give to them, and the sacrifices you made, should never be forgotten. So
that these generations will then have that sense of patriotism; that sense of dedication; that
sense of Americanism that you demonstrated so valiantly when you fought for our freedoms
all over the world.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We continue our World War II
commemoration activities of the 77th National Convention. The next distinguished guest
represents his nation in extending a special thank you to Americans for their valor and
commitment 50 years ago. This man has spent the last 30 years of his life in the foreign
service of his homeland. From Moscow, to Geneva, to London, to New York City, his
duties have continued to grow in the complex international relations arena. He comes to our
77th National Convention with a presentation that will touch each Department of this great
organization. A presentation will be made to further commemorate the men and women of
World War II.
I am pleased to present to you the Ambassador of the Netherlands, Adriaan Jacobovits.
HIS EXCELLENCY ADRIAAN JACOBOVITS
Ambassador of the Netherlands
Thank you very much for inviting me here in this very special year for you, the
veterans, and a very special year for us, the countries that were freed by you 50 years ago.
We have been celebrating that event in May when it was 50 years ago. We have
commemorated those who fell for our freedom, and I’m here today to thank you for all that
your veterans did for the liberation of my country.
Congressman Burton was quite right when he said that what you have done, your
sacrifice, will never be forgotten, and it has not been forgotten in the Netherlands.
Some 17 American divisions were there in the Netherlands, either fighting, or on their
way through to Germany. Some of them saw very heavy combat in the Operation
Marketgarden in particular. 2,635 Americans gave their lives for the freedom of the
Netherlands. Many more were injured; many of them severely.
94
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Today, the veterans of the Second World War, those who fought in the Netherlands,
may think every now and then what has happened in that country which they saw from their
fox hole. That wasn’t a very pleasant sight which you had then. There was a lot of rain;
some said it rained more than in Oregon; there was a lot of mud, and there was a lot of
misery. Well, you may imagine that is different now.
Let me point to two developments briefly which I think are interesting, one, economic,
and one in the military field.
Now, in the economic field we are a prosperous country. Rotterdam is again by far the
largest harbor in the world as far as tonnage is concerned which is being loaded and
unloaded there. The economic ties between the U.S. and the Netherlands are solid.
The Netherlands has become the gateway to Europe. Indeed, over 50 percent of all
exports to northwestern Europe from America and from Canada go via the Netherlands by
Rotterdam, Amsterdam, Fluessen. And indeed we have earned a lot of money by our
position, but we invest a lot of it abroad. And we are now the third largest investor in the
United States after Japan and the United Kingdom, but far ahead of other countries like
Germany or France. We think that the money is well placed, because we have a lot of trust
in America, and those people who were fighting for our freedom.
Now we have a single market, with some exceptions, in 15 European countries. That
is to say the Netherlands is in the center of a big market of 350 million people where there
is no border control and there’s free flow of goods, services and capital. And that means
that businesses can establish one distribution center to cover not only one country, but to
cover many countries in that market with the goods flowing freely on to the others, and the
Netherlands is one of the main distribution points for American industry. In fact, almost 50
percent of the Fortune 500 American companies that have decided to have a distribution
center in Europe, have it in the Netherlands, and the same goes for the Japanese industry.
It is because that we’re an industrious people and our labor productivity is on a par with
the United States and we two are the highest in the western world.
I always smile when I look at the OECD figures. The Organization for Economic
Development, said that the Netherlands had the highest labor productivity, and America was
second. But then I saw the American figures and it showed that America was first and the
Netherlands was second. But they are both on top and that is where we both want to be.
But that is on the economic side.
Maybe there is a far more fascinating development on the military side, particularly for
you veterans. Something happened that was unimaginable 50 years ago, or even 15 years
ago: the merger of the operative part of the Netherlands Army with the German Army. A
few days ago, the 30th of August, we combined our divisions under one
Netherlands/Germany Army Corps, with its headquarters in Munster, Germany. The first
commander is a Dutch general. The position of commander will rotate every three years
between the two countries.
But what is even more fascinating is that the headquarters will be totally integrated.
There will be 150 Dutch officers, 150 German officers working closely together. As you
may imagine, the working language will be English.
You gave us something also in the language sense.
It is an interesting phenomenon that there was no opposition to that, to speak of, in the
Dutch Parliament. And of course the Dutch Army was keen to work together with the
Germans over other nations, because for the last 40 years that we were defending the
northwestern plains we have been accustomed to work with each other, and we have esteem
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
95
for each other although we have our cultural differences. We are much less formal than the
Germans. The Germans have no women in their Armed Forces. So we’ll have to get more
accustomed to each other. But we both think that it is a very positive phenomenon that we
have been able to come to that merger, which is part of a phenomenon in Europe whereby
other multi-national Army Corps are coming up. There will also be a German/American
Army Corps and an American/German Army Corps. But contrary to ours, there will be a
lead country. That is to say that one country will command the corps, one country will
provide the headquarters, not an integrated headquarters as we have.
Now, I’m not here to tell you more about developments in Europe. I have found it
interesting to mention two of them, but the reason I’m here, of course, is to thank you for
our freedom.
And as a small token of our gratitude, I would like to present you with 55 hand-painted
plates which were made especially for this occasion by the oldest Netherlands company
from the 17th Century and has been headed by the same family since then, in Makkum in
Friesland. The plates are presented with an accompanying letter by the Prince of the
Netherlands, Bernard, who was our Commander-in-Chief in the Second World War, and is
now in his eighties but going very strong, and remembering what you did very much.
I would like to present to you this plate. I will read what is written there: In gratitude
for 50 years freedom. I would like to present this to the National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Each Department has been presented one
of these beautiful commemorative plates by the government of the Netherlands, and each
Adjutant of each Department may pick up one in the Convention Office. You have to sign
for it because it’s given to the Department; it’s a gift to the Department. The Adjutant has
to sign
Thank you Mr. Ambassador.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes Herman
Harrington of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Affairs for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF SECTION ON CREDENTIAL
AND OTHER INTERNAL MATTERS
(of Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs
Herman G. Harrington (NY), Chairman
Forty-eight members of the Credentials and Internal Affairs Committee, Section II,
considered thirty-two resolutions, thirty of which originated with Departments of The
American Legion and two of which were created by the committee. Of these, four were
approved, seven were approved as amended, three were consolidated into one which was
amended and approved, ten were referred, three were received and recorded, and five were
rejected.
96
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
Origin: TX
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, The Postmaster General of the United States Postal Service from time to
time issues stamps to commemorate great events in history and individuals of historical
significance; and
WHEREAS, The hero of the Battle of Argonne, Sergeant Alvin C. York, has not been
so honored; and
WHEREAS, In 1997, it will be the One Hundredth and Tenth Anniversary of Sergeant
York’s birth and the Eightieth Anniversary of the Battle of Argonne in 1918; and now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That we petition through proper channels to
the Postmaster General of the United States Postal Service to issue a commemorative stamp,
during the years of 1997 or 1998, in honor of Sergeant Alvin C. York, the most decorated
soldier of World War I.
Resolution No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
Origin: WV
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, October 14, 1997, marks the 50th anniversaiy of Captain Charles Yeager’s
historical flight in which he broke the sound barrier; and
WHEREAS, This feat began the age of supersonic flight, and made possible the
advantages in aviation and space exploration that we know today; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion petition the
Congress of the United States, and the United States Postal Service to authorize and issue
a commemorative postage stamp honoring the 50th anniversary of the beginning of the age
of supersonic flight.
Resolution No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
Origin: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, The 77th National Convention has been held in Indianapolis, Indiana,
September 4-September 6, 1995; and
WHEREAS, There has been a spirit of cooperation and friendship along with mutual
helpfulness evidenced by the Legionnaires of Indianapolis, Indiana, the officers of the
Convention Corporation and the Department, and by the officials and the people of
Indianapolis, Indiana; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, and 6, 1995, that we express our deep appreciation
to the Department of Indiana, Governor Evan Bayh, Lt. Governor Frank O’Bannon, Mayor
Stephen Goldsmith, the city officials of Indianapolis, including the Fire Department,
Police/Sheriffs Department, and other Public Safety officials, the military, especially the
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
97
38th Infantry Division, to the 1995 National Convention Corporation of Indiana, to local
citizens and Legionnaires and especially to the National Convention Corporation officers,
Gilbert E. Sheeks, President, K. Michael Ayers, Secretary, Norman E. Schlemmer,
Treasurer, Department Commander Ron Lowe, Allen Titus, K.W. Ohl, Vice Presidents,
Directors, George S. Wilkerson, Patrick Ryan, and Honorary member Thomas Henderson,
and Distinguished Guests/Finance Supervisor George Buskirk. Around this nucleus has been
built the moving force that provided for every necessity that made for a successful enjoyable
Convention.
Resolution No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
Origin: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, the “eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month,”
commemorates the moment of the end of World War I; and
WHEREAS, this place in time has great and significant meaning to Americans for those
who served their country; and
WHEREAS, December 7,1941, is another historic date to be forever remembered; and
WHEREAS, this date, marked the world’s darkest hour, and the beginning of four years
of great losses and sacrifices; and
WHEREAS, the eventual road to victory over the despots of the world was difficult,
brutal, and seemingly impossible; and
WHEREAS, this world-wide fight for freedom and survival was finally achieved in
1945, now therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by The American Legion in National Convention, assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion remember those
men, women, and children who gave everything for America when it mattered; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, that the time of 9:04 a.m. On September 2, 1945, should be forever
remembered as the end of World War II; and, be it further
RESOLVED, that The American Legion encourages all churches to ring their bells at
9:04 a.m. On September 2, 1996, and at 9:04 a.m. on each September 2 into perpetuity, to
pay tribute to all Americans, who championed the war effort in the trenches, on the sea, in
the air, and on the home front; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion petition the government of the United States
to establish an annual moment of observance every September 2 at 9:04 a.m. in honor of
those American citizens whose service for God and Country will never be forgotten.
Resolution No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
Origin: IL
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, During World War II, Japanese American veterans served patriotically in
both the Pacific and European theaters of war, and
WHEREAS, Those who served in the 100 Bn. And the 442nd Regimental Combat
Team became members of the most highly decorated units in the military history of the
United States, and
WHEREAS, Those who served in the Military Intelligence service in the Pacific
98
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
campaigns helped to shorten the war, and thus lessened the casualties for thousands of their
fellow American men and women, and
WHEREAS, The Japanese American National Museum proposes to sponsor a “Salute
to Japanese American Veterans” on November 8, 1995 at the Los Angeles Convention
Center, and
WHEREAS, The event will coincide with the opening of the Museum’s major
exhibition on Japanese American veterans entitled “Fighting for Tomorrow: Japanese
Americans in America’s Wars,” and
WHEREAS, This event will be organized in co-sponsorship with the Department of
Veterans Affairs, the Department of Defense, Japanese American veterans service
organizations, other veterans organizations, community organizations, community and
business leaders, and
WHEREAS, The “Salute to Japanese American Veterans” will be a part of the World
War II 50th Anniversary commemoration programs sponsored by the Department of
Veterans Affairs, now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports and
encourages the Japanese American National Museum in its sponsorship of a “Salute to
Japanese American Veterans” on Nov. 8, 1995 at the Los Angeles Convention Center.
Resolution No. 93: The Enola Gay
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, The American Legion’s recent involvement in a line by line review of a
planned exhibit of the Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion testimony before Congress has brought to light
other areas of concern for the Smithsonian Institution; and
WHEREAS, This insistence for historical correctness by The American Legion has
resulted in a much abbreviated but never the less, historically correct exhibit of that famed
airship “Enola Gay” that delivered the weapon to Japan thereby ending WWII; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That we express our appreciation to these
members of Congress whose unflagging support in this endeavor was critical to our success,
to the members of our organization and to all Veterans who never faltered in their support.
Resolution No. 94: The Enola Gay
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, In the closing days of World War II, the United States ordered atomic
bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki; and
WHEREAS, The Enola Gay has become a symbol of the might and power of the
United States military and atomic power; and
WHEREAS, Recently attempts have been made to use the Enola Gay in an exhibit in
Washington, D.C. In a manner which would be detrimental to the use of these weapons as
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
99
well as accusing the United States of criminal behavior in their use; and
WHEREAS, As Veterans, The American Legion has taken the challenge to task and
has caused the Smithsonian Institution to cancel this discriminatory exhibit, which will be
reduced to exhibit of the Enola Gay alone. Now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That at the conclusion of the exhibit, the
aircraft be removed from the control of the Smithsonian Institution and offered to a facility,
willing and able, to exhibit the Enola Gay in its entirety along with a truthful script
associated with its historic mission and its contribution to end World War II.
Resolution No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, Through their heroic action, Gary Gordon and Randall Shughart,
U. S. Army in Mogadishu, Somalia, saved the life of Michael Durant, one of the survivors
of a downed helicopter, by defending said helicopter crew against a large group of armed
Somalis until all the other crew members were killed, and they themselves were killed; and
WHEREAS, On May 23, 1994, President Clinton presented to the widows of Gary
Gordon and Randall Shughart the Medal of Honor posthumously for their husbands’ bravery
in Mogadishu on October 3, 1993; and
WHEREAS, Such heroic action exemplifies all such deserving acts; and
WHEREAS, The Awarding of the Medal of Honor is the most prestigious honor our
Nation can bestow on any militaiy person and merits media coverage of major proportions;
and
WHEREAS, Proper media coverage for the awarding of the medals was not provided
or requested by the Presidential Public Affairs Office; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That in keeping with its trusted role of
promoting Americanism, we encourage all members of the national media to provide
appropriate coverage of future occasions.
Resolution No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
•
WHEREAS, History shows that Battle of Midway in 1942 was a pivotal battle that
turned the course of WWII; and
WHEREAS, The Imperial Japanese Fleet was defeated in this battle by a handful of
Naval, Marine and Army aviators flying obsolescent aircraft; and
WHEREAS, The US Navy in September of 1993 closed Midway as an operational base
after 90 years of stewardship; and
WHEREAS, The US Fish & Wildlife Service has requested that Midway be turned over
to them primarily as a wildlife refuge and would then demolish most buildings and firing
positions, thereby removing forever any outward trace of Midway Islands; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
100
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, To emphatically oppose the surrender of
Midway Islands by the US Navy, and support legislation designed or intended to prevent
conversion of the Midway area from a significant historic military site of an American
victory into a wildlife refuge.
Resolution No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, The Vietnam Veterans Memorial is a structure designed to honor those
men and women who sacrificed their lives when their Country asked them to do so; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial, including as it does, engraved in granite, the names of
those who died and those who remain missing and unaccounted for in that War; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial is the most visited Memorial in the City of Washington and
is the site of unregulated sales of trinkets, T-shirts and souvenirs purporting to be sold for
purposes related to the Memorial; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial is the property and responsibility of the National Park
Service; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion encourages the
National Park Service to establish reasonable rules and policies to govern the sale of items
on the Vietnam Veterans Memorial grounds so as to ensure the preservation of the dignity
and solemnity of the Memorial and respect the memory of those it was established to honor;
and be it finally
RESOLVED, That the concern of The American Legion be communicated to
appropriate officials of the National Park Service and other appropriate agencies of
government.
Resolution No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
Origin: VA
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, In his distinguished military career, General George C. Marshall led
members of the Armed Forces of the United States who are now members of The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, As a statesman, George C. Marshall served with distinction as Secretary
of State, leaving the lasting legacy of the Marshall Plan, which led to the reconstruction of
Europe enabling the Western Democracies to stand and prevail against the forces of
Totalitarianism, Fascism and Communism; and
WHEREAS, The George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund is now establishing the
Marshall Home in Leesburg, Virginia, to inform successor generations of our principles
whereby free men and women willingly answered the call to arms to preserve that freedom
against aggressors however dangerous; and
WHEREAS, General George C. Marshall gave our comrades and our fellow
countrymen 59 years of selfless public service to shape the world in which we live; and
WHEREAS, Following application to the Department of Historic Resources of the
Commonwealth of Virginia and meeting the requirements for matching funds set forth in
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
101
the Code of Virginia by the George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund, the Treasurer on
behalf of the Commonwealth of Virginia provided $490,000 to The Fund toward the
purchase of Dodona Manor, General Marshall’s home in Leesburg, Virginia; and
WHEREAS, The George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund purchased Dodona
Manor, General Marshall’s Home in Leesburg, Virginia, on Thursday, 9 February 1995, for
the purpose of honoring George C. Marshall by establishing there at the Marshall
International Center which will; place Dodona Manor on the State and National Register of
historic properties and place a historic easement on the property to ensure its survival in
perpetuity; and establish at the center programs to foster the standards of leadership and
public service exhibited by George C. Marshall as well as Marshall’s axiom that free trade
and economic stability are essential to world peace; and
WHEREAS, The government of the United States has seen fit to place its imprimatur
on this fitting tribute to General George C. Marshall by providing a $1,000,000 through a
Special Purpose H.U.D. Grant to develop the George C. Marshall International Center in
Leesburg, Virginia; now therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995 endorses this fitting tribute to an outstanding
soldier-statesman and urges its members to support its noble efforts; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion interposes no objection the George C.
Marshall Home Preservation Fund soliciting funds to put in place a shrine to the efforts in
which he played so great a part in the Century of America.
Resolution No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
Origin: MO
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Consolidated with 2 (KS), 3 (KS)
As Amended
WHEREAS, The Kansas City historic Liberty Memorial is the only monument in the
United States to the more than 112,000 brave Americans who gave their lives defending
freedom during World War I, and
WHEREAS, The Liberty Memorial (1) is in danger of disintegrating and is closed to
the public for reasons of safety (2) is 68 years of age (3) is a towering 217 feet above ground
level, looking down on the Kansas City, Missouri Station, and
WHEREAS, The physical condition of The Liberty Memorial is worsening with water
seepage throughout the surface limestone and aggregate, galvanized by circles of freezing
and thawing, has collected in the concrete support piers and rusted out the essential metal
rods within those piers. The piers range in height from 12 feet on the south side to 40 feet
on the north, and
WHEREAS, Engineering estimates put the restoration cost at $25,000,000, and
WHEREAS, The preservation of the Classic Monument, The Liberty Memorial,
represents a major step in the march of freedom, and
WHEREAS, President Calvin Coolidge dedicated the Liberty Memorial in 1926, and
WHEREAS, U. S. General of the Armies, John J. Pershing born in Laclede, Missouri
said at the 1926 dedication, “This memorial.... Symbolized the obligation that rests upon
present and future generations to preserve that for which those men and women offered their
all,” now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
102
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion support efforts
to restore The Liberty Memorial in Kansas City, Missouri.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 5 (KS) 1995 NC: Legal Immunity for Volunteers
Resolution No. 6 (KS) 1995 NC: Authorization for The American Legion to Seek an
Amendment to Internal Revenue Code Sec. 501(c) (19) and Other sections
Resolution No. 63 (NY) 1995 NC: Support Audie Murphy Postage Stamp
REFERRED TO STANDING COMMISSION ON
INTERNAL AFFAIRS
Resolution No. 43 (IL) 1995 NC: POW/MIA Logo on Legion Envelopes
Resolution No. 44 (IL) 1995 NC: Roster Plaque for Sons of The American Legion
Resolution No. 55 (TX) 1995 NC: The Smithsonian Institution
Resolution No. 82 (PA) 1995 NC: Establish Subcommittee on Membership Eligibility
Dates
Resolution No. 84 (Wl) 1995 NC: Support Richard I. Bong Heritage Center
Resolution No. 67 (FL) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 90 (MO) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 95 (OH) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 138 (VA) 1995 NC: Establishment of Joint Study Group Concerning
Auxiliary Eligibility
REFERRED TO STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 115 (MD) 1995 NC: Establish Awards for Emergency Personnel
REJECTED
Resolution No. 17 (CO) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 27 (AK) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 101 (MD) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 142 (UT) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 66 (MN) 1995 NC: Amend The American Legion Officer’s Guide and
Manual of Ceremonies on Military Funerals
It was regularly moved, seconded and carried that the Committee Chairman and
Secretary be authorized to sign the Committee report on behalf of the Committee.
It was also regularly moved, seconded and carried that the Committee Chairman and
Secretary be authorized to make technical corrections to the resolutions reported out of this
Committee to insure proper wording and form without changing the substance or meaning
of the resolution(s).
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
103
Mr. Commander, as a duly elected registered delegate from the Department of New
York, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes Bettylou Evans of
Delaware, Chair of the National Convention Committee on Membership and Post Activities
for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE
ON CREDENTIALS AND INTERNAL MATTERS
Section III, (Membership)
Bettylou Evans (DE), Chairman
50 members of the Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs, Section 3,
Membership and Guests, met at 9 a.m., September 2nd, 1995, in Room 102 of the
Indianapolis Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. Bettylou Evans of Delaware was
elected chairman and Gerald Goetzinger of South Dakota was elected secretary.
The following resolutions were referred to the Membership and the Post Activities
Committee: Resolution No. 116 from Maryland, “Other Than Active Membership in the
American Legion” and Resolution No. 144, Maine, “Memorial Posts”.
National staff provided reports on current activity and future statistics for the following
topics: The 1995 Membership Year, the 1996 Membership Promotion, DMS and Direct
Renewal, Membership Task Force Recruiting, Military Installation/Urban Area Recruiting
and an Individual Awards Incentive Program. As of Friday, September 1, 1995,
membership for the 1995 year stands at 2,945,812 members.
A “Ducks in a Row” contest began January 15 and continued through to the Delegate
Strength Target Date on August the 7th, 1995. One department in each of six categories won
a prize or its value of limousine service, rental car, stuffed duck or a live duck to be awarded
at this convention. The other 28 departments each received $50 towards cab fare during the
convention.
Winners of the limousine service included: Minnesota, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota,
Vermont and Delaware. Winners of the rental car include: Ohio, Wisconsin, Missouri, New
Hampshire, Idaho and Alaska. Winners of a stuffed duck include: Florida, New Jersey,
Washington, Alabama, Puerto Rico and Nevada. Winners of a live duck include: California,
Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas, Mississippi and Philippines.
They were quite a hit during the parade on Saturday. [Ducks were heard quacking in
the audience.]
The following departments received certificates as the “Biggest Ugly Duckling in the
Pond;” that is, those who did not have much success early in the year. But they did come
on strong from January to August: Florida, Texas, Georgia, Kentucky, New Mexico and the
Philippines.
During the 1996 National Membership Workshop, a drawing was held from among
those members of the Gold Brigade for an award of a $1,000 gift certificate. The winners
of those certificates were: Robert Mattison of Post 336, Pennsylvania; Jerry Harter of Post
529, New York; Forrest Simpson of Post 13, West Virginia; Andrew Knapp, Jr. of Post 4,
Michigan; Arnold Anderson of Post 7, South Dakota.
The 1996 membership promotion “Still Serving America” was introduced at the July
104
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Workshop. It is intended to motivate all levels of members to increase membership to the
ultimate goal of an all-time high. Membership for 1996 stands at 1,067,475. 32 departments
met or exceeded the first target date on August 16, 1995.
It was regularly moved, seconded and carried that the committee chairman and
secretary be authorized to sign the committee report on behalf of the committee. The
meeting was adjourned at 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Vice Commander, as a duly elected and registered delegate from the Department
of Delaware, I move for the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE CHAIRMAN COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes, again, Herman
Harrington of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Affairs. Herm.
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): Mr. Vice Commander, with
your permission I would like to take a moment, if I could, as Chairman of the National
Emergency Fund, to accept a contribution from some of the representatives of our
departments. With your permission we will bring to the podium the Department Adjutant
of the state of Washington, Bill Fortson, their National Executive Committeeman Mr.
Richard Calahan and Past Department Commander and incoming Alternate National
Executive Committeeman Mr. Dick Smith, who are to make a special presentation.
DELEGATE CALAHAN, (WASHINGTON): Commander, from the great Evergreen
State of Washington, we present $5,000 to the Emergency Services.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much.
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): That contribution that
brings us even closer to our goal of a million dollars of ready cash to help our comrades in
times of disaster. And I can assure you that every penny of it is available when the need
arises. Mr. Commander, with one additional point of privilege, if I could, I would like to
make a little remark of my own.
Since 1991, it’s been my privilege to serve as chairman of the World War II
Commemorative Committee. During those years we have recalled great victories, marked
the turning points, and counted the losses of that terrible war. This week much of that has
changed as we bring down the curtain on four years of remembrance and celebrate the
victory.
I’m sure that you will agree that our convention this year beginning with Saturday’s
SkyConcert, the fire works, the displays, the parade and the presentation to the Enola Gay
crew that you have seen, the concessions and all the special events of this convention speak
in no uncertain terms that even if no one else remembers, The American Legion remembers.
We of the World War II generation have had yet another day in the sun, and I know
that you will join me in saying we are grateful for the tremendous work, the great detail and
planning, the careful thought that our national staff put into World War II Commemorated
here in Indianapolis. Not only have we felt anew the pride of our services, but we have seen
in the faces of our younger comrades, in the faces of the people of Indianapolis and in the
faces of all in the Legion family, a new measure of pride in what our generation gave to this
nation. To the professionals, the staff, the volunteers, we are grateful to all who made it
happen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, Herman. It’s
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
105
always a pleasure for the National Commander to make the following type of presentation.
We have just adopted the report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee.
Membership continues to be very critical to The American Legion. Without an active,
growing membership our programs will lose strength, our voice in Washington will be
weakened and our service to veterans will suffer.
During the past year, two departments took their membership efforts to a higher level
by posting all-time highs. I ask that Richard Hall, Department Commander of Delaware and
John Marston of Mexico join me at the lectern. Gentlemen, the efforts of the men and
women you represent in your departments is heartening. Through determination, hard work
and commitment your membership grew to the highest level ever. It is with gratitude that
I present a plaque to each of you noting this achievement.
The plaque reads:
The American Legion Award for Outstanding Performance Presented to the
Department of Delaware and Mexico [separate plaques] for performing
meritorious service by enrolling this past year, a membership surpassing its
previous all-time high. In witness whereof, this plaque is given under the
hand and seal of the National Commander duly attested by the National
Adjutant at the 77th National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, this 5th
day of September, 1995.
Please take the message to your members that everyone appreciates their hard work and
service, that they have helped to keep The American Legion strong.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER RICHARD HALL, (DELAWARE): We will be
back next year to collect another one of these. Thank you.
DELEGATE JOHN MARSTON, (MEXICO): I never thought I would ever stand here
before you saying that No. 1 in the whole world was my department. But it is. Mexico is
No. 1 in membership. I’m honored by this presentation and I graciously receive it on behalf
of the Blue Cap Legionnaires that worked so hard to make me look so good. I would like
to recognize our Department Adjutant Joe Paulsen without whom this could not have been
done.
The Junior Past National Commander Bruce Thiesen and National Vice Commander
Joe Craig for all their help and encouragement. And to the Headquarters Staff member
Wayne Vanover whom I owe a great debt to.
And, Commander, if I might take a point of professional privilege, a long time ago a
phrase was coined. It said behind every man, there’s a woman. And that phrase is as valid
today as the day it was written. With that in mind, I would like to introduce you to the
woman behind me, my bride, Kathleen. She not only stood beside me for this past year to
make things easier, she also found time during the year to become President of Auxiliary
Unit No. 7.
Finally, Commander, my relief has already been elected and he is Dean Geddes.
Commander Geddes assures me, next year when you meet in Salt Lake City, he will be here
to accept this award again.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have another membership award to
present to George. It is The American Legion Department Commander of the Year. George,
this special plaque certifies the outstanding results of your leadership. Congratulations on
106
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
a very successful year.
In addition to these awards, the Department of Mexico has earned these two gift
certificates valued at $1500 each for surpassing 110 percent of its department goal. I
understand the department has agreed to use these awards for a special purpose.
DELEGATE GEORGE MARSTON, (MEXICO): Yes, we have, Commander. It’s my
privilege to now represent you with these certificates to be presented to the Citizens Flag
Alliance.
I might add, that with the previous contributions my Department has made, and these
contributions today, it brings the Department of Mexico per capita contribution to three
dollars per member. I would like to see every Department at least meet that and hopefully
exceed it.
1994-95 RECRUITER OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The success of The American Legion
over 77 years has its foundation in one element, a strong, vibrant membership. And since
membership is the life-blood of our organization, it is appropriate to introduce to you an
individual who has set the standard this past year.
The National Recruiter Of The Year recruited 552 new members to earn this honor for
the third time. Since the cut-off date, he has signed up additional members, for a total of
796 new 1995 members.
Please give a warm round of applause to a dedicated Legionnaire from Post 790 in
California, Joe Chilelli.
JOE CHILELLI, (MX)
1994-95 Recruiter of the Year
I can’t do it in three or four words, Commander, but I will tell you this. Membership
is the life-blood of every organization. Without membership we can’t get along.
Now, membership is the easiest thing in the world to get.
Now, you would think the hardest place in the world to get Legion membership would
be at a National Convention of The American Legion, wouldn’t it? In this lobby, I was
walking around for a few minutes when I went out for lunch, and Commander, you just
presented me with a plaque; I would like to present you with 11 new members.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: See that? Right out in the lobby. There
you go. How’s that?
You know what the difference between this gentleman and most of us in this room?
He asks; he asks, and he’s not afraid to ask because he can answer the questions. The simple
question of why should I belong to The American Legion.
GOLD BRIGADE ANNOUNCEMENT
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: This has been a year in which The
American Legion received an enormous amount of national exposure. That exposure came
because the members of our organization are willing to take a stand against the wrong
decision of the United States Supreme Court and the misguided efforts of historical
revisionists.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
107
At the same time, many of our individual membership recruiters have met the
challenge, carried the message of The American Legion to fellow veterans at home, and
recruited at least 50 new members. They are the members of The American Legion Gold
Brigade. I thank each and every one of you who helped to make The American Legion
stronger. Members of the 1995 Gold Brigade who are here today stand and be recognized.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Chester F. Stellar
of Ohio, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Veterans Affairs and
Rehabilitation, for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION ON
VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION
Chester F. Stellar (OH), Chairman
Eighty-four members of your Committee on Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation met
at 9:00 a.m. on September 2, 1995 in the Indiana Convention Center, Rooms 105-106, 1st
Level, and agreed on the following report which is respectfully submitted for your
consideration.
The Committee was called to order by Carroll Williams, Maryland, Liaison
Representative appointed by the National Adjutant to act as temporary chairman. Frank
Buxton, DC, Deputy Director, VA&R Commission, acted as temporary secretary and called
the roll. A quorum being present, nominations were received for permanent chairman.
Chester F. Stellar, Ohio, Chairman of the Standing National Veterans Affairs and
Rehabilitation Commission, was unanimously elected Chairman of the Convention
Committee.
With unanimous consent, the Chairman appointed Pat Phillips, Georgia, as Committee
Secretary, Richard Santos, Maryland, Chairman, and Vollie McCollum, Tennessee,
Secretary of the Medical and Hospital Subcommittee; and J.G. “Tracy” Taylor, Florida,
Chairman, and Doris Gross, Washington, Secretary of the Claims and Rating Subcommittee.
Subcommittee liaison assignments were as follows: Frank C. Buxton, Deputy Director,
to Medical and Hospital; Carroll Williams, Director and Harold T. Kelly, Assistant Director
for Program Management to Claims and Rating.
As has been the custom for the 51 previous National Conventions, a Special
Department Service Officers Committee on Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Resolutions,
in a three-day pre-convention meeting, screened and grouped the resolutions. A report of
their analysis, with recommendations, was presented to the Convention Committee for
consideration.
The Screening Committee conserved the time of the Convention Committee
substantially. The Screening Committee was composed of the following Department
Service Officers:
REGION
REGION
REGION
REGION
REGION
45678-
E. L. Reeves (MS)
Don Lanthom (OH)
Steve Burger (NE)
Duane Willis (UT), Secretary
Gerald Schleining (OR), Chairman
108
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
The Convention Committee recommended that such a Committee be appointed for this
purpose to serve the Seventy-seventh National Convention Committee on Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation.
The 32 Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation resolutions presented for consideration of
this Convention were referred by the Resolutions Assignment Committee.
The following action on the resolutions was taken by the Convention Committee:
Approved or Approved as Amended
5
Consolidated with Resolutions Approved
2
Referred to the Standing Commission
6
Received and Recorded
18
Rejected
1
A report of action taken on the 6 resolutions referred to the Standing National Veterans
Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission will be made to the National Executive Committee
and to the Adjutant of the Department concerned, and, in addition, will be contained in the
National Adjutant’s report to the Seventy-seventh Annual National Convention.
I now turn it over to Mr. Pat Phillips of Georgia to read the report.
REPORTED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 35: Oppose Centralization of VA Claims Processing Centers
Origin: ND
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, Currently there are 58 VA regional offices located in the 50 states, Puerto
Rico, and the Philippines, to provide service to veterans, their dependents, and survivors;
and
WHEREAS, This enables veterans and other claimants, including their accredited
representative, to have reasonable access to the VA claim file; and
WHEREAS, In any claim action, such accessibility helps ensure the claimant is
afforded full due process without undue delay or hardship; and
WHEREAS, Because of continuing Federal budgetary restrictions and a large backlog
of pending benefit claims, VA has designated certain regional offices with proportionally
lower workloads to handle certain categories of claims, i.e. Montgomery GI Bill, Persian
Gulf, certain home loan guaranty cases, and POW disabilities; and
WHEREAS, The records in such case have been physically transferred to the particular
regional processing center which retains possession of the records up to a year after action
on the claim is completed; and
WHEREAS, This procedure deprives the claimant reasonable access to the VA records,
including information as to the status of the case or disposition and inhibits the ability of the
organization to effectively advise and assist, i.e. “represent”, such claimants based on the
power of attorney; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion oppose the
centralization or regionalization of VA claims processing centers.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
109
Resolution No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
Origin: ND
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, The Tax Simplification Plan, released by the Department of the Treasury
in November 1984, proposed the federal taxation of VA disability compensation benefits;
and
WHEREAS, In the entire history of the disability compensation program these benefits
have never been subject to taxation at either the federal, state or local levels; and
WHEREAS, Taxation of these benefits would amount to nothing more than a
permanent, enduring reduction in benefits and would demean the sacrifice and service of our
nation’s service-connected disabled veteran population; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion vigorously
oppose any proposal that would subject VA disability compensation benefits to taxation.
Resolution No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review
Origin: SC
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, Chapter 11 of title 38, United States Code, sets forth a program of
compensation for service-connected disabilities; and
WHEREAS, Specific sections of Chapter 11 pertain to presumptions relating to certain
diseases and disabilities; and
WHEREAS, Presumptive service connection was first established as an important
feature of the World War Veterans Act of 1924, adopted June 7, 1924; and
WHEREAS, Liberalizing and amendatory legislation was adopted by subsequent
sessions of Congress, with The American Legion taking a leading role in the development
and implementation of the improved laws; and
WHEREAS, The current disability compensation program has proven to be a fair and
equitable manner in which to indemnify veterans suffering disabilities that are incurred or
aggravated in line of duty in the active military, naval or air service; and
WHEREAS, Many of these people, because of their disabilities, have had to resort to
financial help from the government to make their way through life, and
WHEREAS, In a landmark decision of the Supreme Court on May 23, 1983, Justice
William H. Rehnquist stated as follows:
Veterans have been obligated to drop their own affairs and take up the
burdens of the nation, subjecting themselves to the mental and physical
hazards as well as the economic and family detriments which are peculiar
to military service and which do not exist in normal civil life.
Our country has a long-standing policy of compensating veterans for their
past contributions by providing them with numerous advantages. This
policy has always been deemed to be legitimate.; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion embraces the intent of this eloquent statement as
it echoes the long-standing philosophy of this organization; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is totally supportive of every benefit that is
currently provided to veterans, as each of them had a purpose when enacted, and each has
110
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
proven currently to be meeting a legitimate need of the veteran population; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion oppose any
administrative or legislative proposal to dilute or eliminate any provision of the disability
compensation program; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion oppose the elimination or reduction of any
other benefit that is currently provided to the veterans of this nation, or to their dependents
and survivors.
Resolution No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to
Date The Deceased Veteran’s Claim was Filed
Origin: IL
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization of war veterans who have
dedicated themselves to the service of the community, state, and nation; and
WHEREAS, If a veteran should die while a claim is pending, including an appeal to
the Board of Veterans Appeals or the Court of Veterans Appeals, under 38 USC 5121, the
surviving spouse, dependents, or other eligibles are limited to one year retroactive accrued
benefits; and
WHEREAS, Veterans who have filed a benefit claim are having to wait six months to
a year or more for a decision by the regional office and following that, wait over two years
or more for a decision by the Board of Veterans Appeals and another year or more on their
case by the U. S. Court of Veterans Appeals; and
WHEREAS, Given the fact that a claim can be in a pending status for upwards of 4 or
more years, many veterans whose cases are in this category will die before a final decision
is rendered; and
WHEREAS, The families of these deceased veterans receive only a small portion of the
benefits that are due and otherwise payable to the veteran had he or she remained alive;
now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion seek legislation
to amend 38 USC 5121 to provide for the payment of accrued benefits in a pending claim,
including an appeal to the Board of Veterans Appeals or the U. S. Court of Veterans Appeals
to date the deceased veteran’s claim was filed.
Resolution No. 141: The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
Origin: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
WHEREAS, The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical care system was
created to provide domiciliary and medical care to veterans; and
WHEREAS, VA initially provided care to disabled veterans, indigent veterans, and
other veterans based on a resource and space available basis; and
WHEREAS, Since the establishment, Congress has significantly expanded the medical
care responsibilities of the Department of Veterans Affairs; and
WHEREAS, Today, the Veterans Health Administration is responsible for providing
a range of comprehensive health care services to the Nation’s veterans. This is
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
111
accomplished through the operation of 172 VA medical centers, 235 outpatient clinics, 128
nursing homes, and 35 domiciliaries. VHA operates an integrated medical care system
committed to four primary missions:
* To develop, maintain and operate a national health care delivery system for eligible
veterans.
* To carry out a program of education and training of health care personnel.
* To carry out a program of medical care research.
* To furnish health care services to members of the armed forces during a war or national
emergency; and to civilians during national emergencies; and
WHEREAS, In recent years, the Department of Veterans Affairs medical care system
has been progressively impeded by rules, regulations, funding shortages and geographic
constraints which have made receipt of medical care by all eligible veterans more of an
achievement than an earned benefit; and
WHEREAS, In February 1992, The American Legion developed a comprehensive
blueprint to alleviate the anomalies relating to eligibility for medical care provided by the
Veterans Health Administration and the Department of Veterans Affairs and named the plan
“The American Legion Proposal to Improve Veterans Health Care,” also known as the Gold
Book; and
WHEREAS, The impact of recent Congressional budget shortfalls may place the
system in serious jeopardy and prevent VA from receiving adequate funding and legislative
relief to accomplish its myriad missions which would have a deleterious effect on veterans
seeking care for service-connected and non-service-connected conditions; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes the Federal Government must live up to
its legal and moral obligations and the expectations of the veteran and the American people
with regard to access to VA health care services for all veterans; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has developed a comprehensive legislative proposal
to implement the Gold Book named “The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security
Plan; and
WHEREAS, This legislation will revolutionize the way VA delivers health care
benefits to our Nation’s veterans and release VA from severe and restrictive eligibility
constraints.
The legislation will also provide ways to fund VA’s care of
non-service-connected, poor and catastrophically ill veterans; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion accept as its
policy on veterans health care, “The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan”
which will:
1.
Reorganize the Veterans Health Administration to improve access, quality
and efficiency of the medical care provided to veterans;
2.
Operate the veterans health care system based upon the principles of
“managed care”;
3.
Assure all veterans with service-connected illnesses and disabilities access
to all services necessary for the treatment of their disabilities at no charge
112
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
to the veteran;
4.
5.
Assure all veterans with a service-connected disability rating of 50 percent
or greater, access to all VA health care services at no cost;
Assure all special category veterans, indigent veterans and
service-connected veterans rated under 50 percent disabled, access to VA
health services at no charge or reduced charge;
6.
Assure the long-term viability of the veterans health care system by
encouraging veterans who presently do not receive care, and their
dependents, to enroll in the Department of Veterans Affairs Health Care
Security Plan;
7.
Improve the long-term financial health of the veterans’ health care system
by increasing other resources of the system to include other federal
programs, third-party payers and employers of veterans;
8.
Permit VA to retain all payments made to the Department for health care
services;
9.
Eliminate unnecessary, duplicated or contradictory regulations which
hamper the ability of the veterans health care system to operate effectively
and efficiently;
10. Federal appropriations for the DVA health care system shall be based upon
a capitated method using the calculation of fully-allocated costs of care to
service-connected and other veterans receiving care at no charge;
11. Require the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to report to the Congress at designated
intervals on the financial soundness of the system, the budget-neutrality of the system
and the quality of care rendered; and, be it finally,
RESOLVED, That all previous American Legion resolutions in conflict with this
resolution are hereby rescinded.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
VETERANS AFFAIRS & REHABILITATION
Resolution No. 14 (CO) 1995 NC: State and National Committees in Support of Persian
Gulf Veterans
Resolution No. 19 (MA) 1995 NC: Eligibility Reform and Funding for VA Health Care
Resolution No. 41 (IL) 1995 NC: Expansion of Decatur, Illinois Outpatient Clinic
Resolution No. 68 (FL) 1995 NC: Restore Priority to South Florida Veterans Cemetery
Resolution No. 73 (IL) 1995 NC: Provide Dependent Children of Veterans in Nursing
Homes Greater Pensions for Incidental Expenses
Resolution No. 119 (NH) 1995 NC: Seek Outpatient Clinic to be Located at Peace Air
Force Base, Portsmouth, New Hampshire
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
113
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 7 (KS) 1995 NC: Exemption of Hiring Caps for Department of Veterans
Affairs
Resolution No. 21 (MT) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes
Resolution No. 34 (ND) 1995 NC: Seek Authorization for Department of Veterans
Affairs to Consider Current Income to Determine Eligibility for Care
Resolution No. 36 (ND) 1995 NC: Seek Adequate Appropriations for Department of
Veterans Affairs Medical Programs and Personnel.
Resolution No. 38 (ND) 1995 NC: Establish an Open Enrollment Period to Veterans
Eligible for Service Disabled Veterans Insurance
Resolution No. 39 (ND) 1995 NC: Increase the Maximum Amount of Service Disabled
Veterans Insurance
Resolution No. 52 (TX) 1995 NC: Oppose any Reduction in Veterans Benefits
Resolution No. 53 (TX) 1995 NC: Reduce Processing Time on Claims to Six Months
Resolution No. 62 (NY) 1995 NC: Request for National Cemetery Richmond County,
New York
Resolution No. 69 (FL) 1995 NC: Restore Benefits to Remarried Widows of Veterans
Resolution No. 86 (WI) 1995 NC: Create a Commission to Study the Restoration of the
Burial Allowance
Resolution No. 88 (MO) 1995 NC: Review the Ranking of Areas in Need of a National
Cemetery
Resolution No. 89 (MO) 1995 NC: Health Care Coverage for Newly Discharged
Veterans and Dependents
Resolution No. 97 (OH) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes Program
Resolution No. 118 (NH) 1995 NC: Continue Full Services at Manchester VAMC and
White River Junction VAMC
Resolution No. 120 (NH) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes Program
Resolution No. 123 (CA) 1995 NC: Increase Funding for Medical and Health Research
Resolution No. 129 (SD) 1995 NC: DVA Ensure Veteran Service Organizations are
Provided any Correspondence Regarding Claims
REJECTED
Resolution No. 54 (TX) 1995 NC: Oppose Consolidation of Texas Department of
Veterans Affairs Medical Centers
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate from the
Department of Ohio, I move the adoption of the VA&R Report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. Any
discussion?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone number what, Four?
114
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): Herman Harrington,
Delegate to this Convention from the Department of New York. I move, you, sir, that
Resolution No. 141 be set aside for the purposes of discussion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Without objection, so set aside. Now,
we have a motion to set aside of Resolution No. 141. We have a motion to adopt the report
with the exception of 141. Do I hear a second? Any discussion? All those in favor signify
by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Now, Mr. Chairman, you will now read the resolution in its entirety.
... At this time, Chairman Stellar read Resolution No. 141.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate from the
Department of Ohio, I move the adoption of Resolution 141.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion. Is there a second?
Any discussion?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 5.
DELEGATE EDWIN J. DENTZ (VIRGINIA): Eddie Dentz, duly registered Delegate
from the Department of Virginia.
I wonder, Commander, why The American Legion feels the need to promote a plan
such as this. Why don’t we allow the VA to continue to function as it is presently doing?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Delegate, that is a very good question.
There’s a mood in the Congress to reduce the budget, to cut the deficit by cutting
discretionary spending. VA health care is discretionary spending. We see nothing but
diminishing resources for veterans benefits, especially health care to where the point is the
VA will actually go away.
We want to be proactive. We want to be the leader in this to see to it that the VA
receives the funds from outside sources such as Medicare and third-party payers, and to
make sure the system stays alive. This is the way for the veterans to determine the fate of
the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Any other questions? Microphone 6.
DELEGATE GLENN R. GREEN, (SOUTH DAKOTA): Glenn Green, Delegate from
the State of South Dakota.
Now that you have the lights on in here, you can surely see that I’m not a Gulf veteran.
So with that, myself and others have the question on this plan as to whether I can use my
Medicare through the VA.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Boy, you can look at me too, Glenn, and tell
that I’m eligible for Medicare.
If you are a Medicare eligible veteran, you may enroll in this special benefit for
veterans and have all of your care taken care of by the Department of Veterans Affairs. And
the beautiful part about it is, under Medicare as it now stands, you have a large deductible;
with the VA, under this plan, if you enroll, and it’s voluntary, there would be no deductible.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you. Okay. There’s a flashlight.
Microphone No. 1.
DELEGATE GERALD L. MOORE (OHIO): This is Jerry Moore, duly elected
Delegate from Ohio. I would like to ask through the Chair to the Chairman, what effect this
would have on a military retiree and his dependent.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Very good question because I think this is
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
115
one of the greatest helps for the military retiree that I have ever known.
At the present time, many military bases are being closed and, therefore, medical care
to the retiree is not available where those hospitals have been closed along with the bases.
If you use your CHAMPUS, as I understand that program, you have a 25 percent deductible
on any operations that you might have. A $100,000 operation for a heart bypass would then
cost that veteran $25,000.
If you are over sixty-five, you will be able to use your Medicare in the VA if Congress
approves this, or if you use your CHAMPUS or use your CHAMPUS benefit and enroll, you
will be able to have full benefits from the VA. And since you are a veteran you could join
the plan on your own and take with it your dependents.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE GEORGE BLAIR, (COLORADO): Mr. Chairman, duly elected Delegate
of Colorado, George Blair. I would have to question what was just said about services to
military retirees at the VA Hospital. Unless the reform of eligibility and treatment changes,
according to the transcript from the secretary’s office, the military retiree over 65 years of
age right now has no Medicare service except in a private hospital, where $350 a month or
$400 a month is paid to that HMO just to administer our records.
I would like to also address the fact that Colorado did submit No. 14 that was referred,
and No. 14 was in concert with the Secretary of Veterans Affairs transcript for reforming the
system, whereby the military retirees and their dependents would be authorized treatment,
and was considering veterans and their dependents’ treatment.
Department of Veterans Affairs needs to take over the health care of all veterans,
whether they be career or non-career. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: That’s what this plan seeks to do. It’s
exactly what the plan seeks to do. Any comments as to Resolution 14 would, of course, be
out of order because that was contained in the actual full report.
Any other questions? No. 5.
DELEGATE ANTONIO RABBIA, (NEW HAMPSHIRE): Comrade Commander,
Tony Rabbia, Delegate from New Hampshire. If you are on Medicare and you want to join
the other plan, do you have to be 62 years old or 65? Is there an age limit?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: To qualify under Medicare, that is a separate
issue. If you have Medicare and you have qualified for it, then you are eligible to enroll in
this plan if you so desire and are then qualified for the full benefits.
DELEGATE RABBIA, (NEW HAMPSHIRE): So there is no age limit; am I correct?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: All you have to do is qualify for Medicare.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 4.
DELEGATE LOU DIMMERMAN, (OHIO): Mr. Commander, Lou Dimmerman, a
duly elected Delegate from the Department of Ohio.
I am wondering how this would affect me as a veteran and an employee of a large
corporation? Would I have access to that? Would my corporation be able to purchase that
for me?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Under this new plan, your employer would
be able to work with VA to make the VA plan an option you could choose or VA could
contract with your provider to care for you.
Again, I might stress that you are not compelled to enroll with the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 3.
DELEGATE ROD MATHISON, (WISCONSIN): Mr. Commander, Rod Mathison,
116
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Delegate from the Department of Wisconsin.
As a government employee, what would be the enrollment procedures under this plan?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: If you are a federal government employee at
the present time, as I understand the group insurance program for federal employees, you
have many, many options under HMOs that they offer you to choose from. Under this plan
there would be, then, another option that you could choose if you wanted to enroll into the
VA through your federal employee health benefits plan.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Now, just to make it very clear, this plan
takes in all veterans. It opens up, it includes, as opposed to excluding as the VA is set up
now.
Microphone No. 3.
DELEGATE TOM CADMUS, (MICHIGAN): Mr. Commander, Tom Cadmus from
the Department of Michigan.
I thought the ‘Gold Book’ was our health care plan. Is this something different?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: To the Delegate from Michigan, that’s exactly
right. The ‘Gold Book’ has been our health plan and continues to be our health plan. This
is the authorization for us to introduce it as legislation.
We, in the past, gave this out to all the legislators so that they could utilize it. We
hoped that they would see the light and would provide this kind of care. They don’t see fit
to do so. So, therefore, we are going to introduce the legislation to make the ‘Gold Book’
have some teeth and become part of the law helping the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 3.
DELEGATE JOHN TITUS, (PENNSYLVANIA): Comrade Commander, John Titus,
Delegate from Pennsylvania.
I thought The American Legion was opposed to bringing non-veterans into the VA
system. Is this a change in our policy?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: This is going to change just somewhat our
policy, in that we’re going to allow the veterans and their dependents to come into this
program if they so desire.
Now, you will remember several years ago there was a plan offered by the VA at that
time to take a bunch of people into a VA hospital who were not veterans, and we vetoed that
quickly.
At least this plan has a veterans’ flavor to it and the veteran and his dependents will be
allowed to be enrolled in this plan and their care provided by the Department of Veterans
Affairs.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 4?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Yes, Mr. Chairman. For clarification, you had
mentioned 65 year old veterans would be able to use CHAMPUS, I believe. 1 may have
misunderstood that, but veterans over sixty-five are not entitled to CHAMPUS. Could we
clarify that?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: It’s exactly right, sir. Some veterans retirees
under sixty-five are eligible for CHAMPUS. They could enroll in this plan. If you are over
sixty-five, then you become Medicare eligible, and they could enroll under this plan under
that program.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The last gentleman at No. 4 identify
himself and his Department please, for the record.
DELEGATE GEORGE BLAIR, (COLORADO): George Blair, Department of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
117
Colorado.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 6?
DELEGATE HAL GOLDMAN, (CALIFORNIA): Comrade Commander, Hal
Goldman, registered Delegate from the Department of California.
I have a question not only about the plan, but we’re asking to accept this on its face
value, with the many hospitals that have been closing; with the fact that all of the VA
facilities are in fact teaching hospitals affiliated with most universities; how is this going to
affect that relationship, and what is going to take place in the facilities if we lose that type
of support? If we find out the universities do not want to join this program, are we taking
into consideration what happens then?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: You’re questioning whether the medical
affiliation of hospitals and the medical schools would continue? Yes, they would continue.
And that’s one of the things that this would benefit. There would be a greater utilization of
the VA so that the medical schools would clamor to be affiliated with the VA. I hope that
answers the question you wanted.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
This actually infuses additional
third-party dollars into the system. No. 4.
DELEGATE TOM BURTON, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, this is Tom Burton
from New York State.
Under Medicare, all of the veterans go onto Medicare at sixty-five; will their
dependents be entitled to that care at that time?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Yes. They would be eligible. When the
veteran goes in, he can take his dependents in, depending on what kind of a plan they might
want. But they would go with him.
DELEGATE BURTON, (NEW YORK): At the present time there are about four
categories. There’s the disabled veterans and then the other three categories. They are not
all entitled to medical care or to veterans care at the VA hospital at this time.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: The service-connected, at 50 percent or
greater will be entitled to full care of all their infirmities at no cost. This is a change from
what it is at the present time. If you’re taken in with a non-service-connected ailment, even
though you are service-connected, you will be billed for that. Under this new plan, if you
are 50 percent or more, all expenses will be paid. Those that are less than 50 percent will
pay a lesser premium for their coverage, and they can enroll and have full access to coverage
in the VA. And those, the categories that we have known as A, B and C, will be gone.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion calling for the question.
All of those in favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
There’s a motion on the floor and a second. The debate has been closed. All those in
favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Motion is adopted.
WILLIAM F. LENKER NATIONAL SERVICE TROPHY
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: With the adoption of the Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation report, it is appropriate to announce the winner of the William F. Lenker
National Service Trophy. The trophy is awarded annually to the Department which best
supports and implements programs to benefit veterans, their families and their survivors.
For the 1994-1995 program year, the trophy is awarded to the Department of Ohio.
Accepting the award is Roger Hight, the Department Adjutant of Ohio. The trophy is quite
118
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
large, as most of you know, so it has been shipped, and I am presenting a certificate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes the Honorable
George W. Boucek of Illinois, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Finance,
for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
FINANCE
George W. Boucek (IL), Chairman
Forty-two members met at the Westin Hotel on Saturday, September the 2nd, in
Indianapolis, Indiana.
Paul Allen, the National Finance Director, opened the meeting as staff liaison, and
conducted the selection of the Chairman and the Secretary. George Boucek, myself, was
elected as Chairman, and Anthony Minei of New York was elected as Secretary.
The audit report of George S. Olive & Co.’s certified audit was presented to the
Committee, and it shows a deficit of $1,561,180 for the year ending December the 31st,
1994, but the Delegates were reminded that we will have a surplus in 1995. And incidently,
that entire audit report is contained in your official program book for this year, the last 12
pages of this booklet.
Daniel Wheeler, whom you have met, and who is the President of the Citizens Flag
Alliance, spoke about the successful House of Representatives Flag Amendment vote of 312
to 120 last July, and informed the Committee about the very crucial vote in the Senate,
which hopefully will take place in late October or early November. And you heard Bob
Dole tell you yesterday that he expects to bring that up for a vote before the end of the year.
Currently, 56 Senators have signed on as co-sponsors, and six Senators have informed
us that they will vote for the amendment but will not sign on as co-sponsors. For the Flag
Amendment to pass, we need 67 votes.
Mr. Wheeler informed the Committee they have set up a special Phone Bank and I’m
reminding you of that again. The Phone Bank beyond the Emblem Sales booth, and a Post
Card station in the Exhibit Area at the Convention Center urging all Legion family members
to call their Senator’s office and/or send a post card which have been placed in everyone’s
Convention packet.
Steve Salerno, the newly selected editor of The American Legion Magazine, made a
report that the Magazine had a surplus of 1.2 million in 1994, but due to the environmental
impact of postage and paper costs and printing increases, it appears that the Magazine will
probably have a million dollar deficit in 1995. Mr. Salerno did report that they are
expecting to hit their high of 8.7 million advertising sales budget for the year 1995.
National Treasurer Webber LaGrange gave the Committee a summary of our
investments. He then recommended the 1996 dues be set at $9.00. There will be no dues
increase.
A motion was made by Thomas O’Connor of Pennsylvania that the 1996 per capita
dues remain at $9.00; seconded by Don Desch of Wisconsin, and adopted by unanimous
vote.
Stanley Hanson of Colorado made a motion to empower the Chairman and the
Secretary to write and/or amend the report on behalf of the Convention Committee of
Finance, and Charles Wallace of Kansas seconded the motion which was also adopted by
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
119
unanimous vote. We had no resolutions.
There was no other business before the Committee, and the meeting adjourned at 9:40
a.m.
As a Delegate to this Convention, I now make a motion that this report be approved.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Alan Hall,
Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Foreign Relations for the purpose of
making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Alan P. Hall (FL), Chairman
At 8:30 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 43 Delegates and Alternates assigned to the
Convention Committee on Foreign Relations met in Room 205, 2nd Level of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. Mr. Alan P. Hall (Florida) was elected
Chairman and Mr. Robert Bowen (Virginia) was appointed Secretary.
Following this initial meeting, five Ad Hoc Administrative convention Subcommittees
met in separate locations to consider the resolutions which had been assigned to them. The
following were appointed Chairmen:
General Foreign Policy: Chairman A.J. Forestiere (Arkansas)
European Affairs: Chairman Dick Pfaffinger (Minnesota)
Far Eastern Affairs: Chairman Keith Baker (Iowa)
Inter-American Affairs: Chairman George D. Triplett (Mexico)
Middle Eastern & African Affairs: Chairman Vinton R. Guy (Colorado)
At 10:00 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 43 Delegates and Alternates assigned to
the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations met in Room 205, 2nd Level of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana for a final meeting of the Convention Committee
on Foreign Relations. At this meeting, motions were approved authorizing the committee
chairman and secretary to make technical corrections to the resolutions reported out of the
committee to ensure proper wording and form, but without changing the substance or
meaning of the resolutions considered. Reports of all convention ad hoc administrative
subcommittees were read and their recommended actions on resolutions considered. A total
of 15 resolutions were assigned to the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations and two
resolutions were originated by the Committee.
The following ad hoc subcommittee reports contain resolutions which will, in
conjunction with resolutions previously adopted, provide an effective and viable foreign
relations program for The American Legion. That program will fully support a strong and
dynamic U.S. Foreign policy to promote democracy around the world and discharge
America’s responsibility as leader of the Free World in the continuing struggle to defend and
promote liberty.
120
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
GENERAL FOREIGN POLICY
A. J. Forestiere (AR), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
Origin: MO
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended
WHEREAS, The American Legion is convinced, based on available evidence, that
American POWs were detained by Vietnam after Operation Homecoming in 1973, and there
is sufficient evidence to lead us to believe there is a better than average probability of
American POWs still being held in Indochina today; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes normalization of relations with Vietnam
will make it harder, not easier, to resolve the POW/MIA issue, but will continue to do
whatever it takes to achieve the fullest possible accounting of POW/MIA in Vietnam.
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes U.S. Government POW/MIA operations
are still inadequate, and the President’s normalization of relations with Vietnam will not
achieve substantially greater progress; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion believes the
following priority actions should be taken by the U.S. Government:
1.
Centralize POW/MIA responsibilities in a powerful office reporting directly
to the Secretary of Defense, remove the Defense Intelligence Agency from
all POW/MIA responsibilities and make each military service responsible
for its own POW/MIAs.
2.
Provide necessary resources so field operations can be conducted at a
maximum rate of activity with more timely follow-up of live sighting
reports.
3.
Declassify all POW/MIA information (except that revealing intelligence
sources or methods) in a form readily available to public review.
4.
Provide adequate personnel and resources so that investigative efforts of
World War II, Cold War, and Korean War POW/MIA situations can be
broadened and accelerated.
5.
Initiate or strengthen joint commissions with Russia, the People’s Republic
of China, and North Korea to increase POW/MIA recovery efforts.
6.
Establish a centralized office responsible to keep POW/MIA families
informed on their loved ones.
7.
Establish a joint standing congressional committee on POW/MIA affairs to
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
121
ensure continued action by the executive branch in addressing the
POW/MIA issue.
8.
Take further favorable actions toward Vietnam only after Hanoi provides
the fullest possible accounting for POW/MIAs in Vietnam or in areas of
Laos and Cambodia it controlled during the Vietnam War.
9.
Take favorable actions toward Laos or Cambodia only after those nations
provide the fullest possible accounting for POW/MIAs.
10. “Fullest possible accounting” is defined as turning over live prisoners,
repatriating remains of those who were killed in action or died in captivity,
or providing a valid, conclusive report when neither is possible.
Resolution No. 151: United Nations
Origin: Foreign Relations Committee
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As consolidated with No. 75 (MX)
WHEREAS, The American Legion played a significant role in helping to establish the
United Nations after World War II, believing it would help prevent the outbreak of future
wars; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has remained generally supportive of the United
nations over the succeeding years, although it has been critical of particular ineffective,
wasteful or undesirable activities of the United Nations; and
WHEREAS, Although the United Nations in half a century of operation has not
fulfilled the lofty of purposes unwise international operations and enable the United States
to work from within the United Nations for long overdue reforms; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the U. S.
Government to seek the following reforms in the United Nations and to use American
leverage to obtain the desired ends by such means as withdrawal from ineffective UN
agencies and withholding of funds:
1.
Ratify expeditiously the “UN Convention on the Protection of Peacekeepers” and
encourage all other nations to do the same.
2.
Encourage the United Nations to focus on limited, necessary, achievable tasks that truly
better the lot of humankind in a sensible, cost-effective manner.
3.
Encourage the United Nations not to infringe on national sovereignty when operating
economic and social programs.
4.
Adopt weighted voting procedures in the General Assembly, allotting voting power in
relation to funds contributed by each member nation to the United Nations.
5.
Eliminate the Trusteeship Council and all other redundant or unneeded agencies.
122
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
6.
Professionalize the UN staff on the basis of merit and qualifications.
7.
Provide truly independent authority to the Inspector General and see that UN agencies
become subject to periodic, unannounced auditing, the finding of such audits to be
reported to member nations.
8.
Admit the Republic of China to full membership in the United Nations since that nation
has fulfilled all that is expected of a developing country by adopting democracy,
respect for human rights, free enterprise, and a peaceful foreign policy.
9.
Reduce the U.S. Share of the regular budget from 25 percent to 20 percent.
10. Reduce the U.S. Share of peacekeeping funding from 31.7 percent to 20 percent.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Resolution No. 15 (CO) 1995 NC: POW/MIA Trust Fund Petition
Resolution No. 143 (NJ) 1995 NC: Release of Service Member’s Status
Resolution No. 145 (NY) 1995 NC: Japanese Apology for World War II
RECEIVED & RECORDED
Resolution No. 112 (MD) 1995 NC: Principles of U.S. Foreign Policy
Resolution No. 113 (MD) 1995 NC: Principles of U.S. Foreign Aid
Resolution No. 114 (MD) 1995 NC: Democratic Activism as U.S. National SecurityForeign Policy Goal
CHAIRMAN A.J. FORESTIERE, (ARKANSAS): Mr. Chairman, this completes the
report of the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on General Foreign Policy.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman, the next report
is from Chairman Dick Pfaffinger of Minnesota, European Affairs.
EUROPEAN AFFAIRS
Dick Pfaffinger (MN), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
Origin: Foreign Relations Committee
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
WHEREAS, A. U.S. Initiative, Partnership for Peace (PFP) was launched by the
January 1994 NATO Summit to establish strong links between NATO, its new democratic
partners in the former Soviet bloc, and some of Europe’s traditionally neutral countries to
enhance European security; and
WHEREAS, It provides a framework for enhanced political and military cooperation
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
123
for joint multilateral crisis management activities, such as humanitarian assistance and
peacekeeping; and
WHEREAS, It enables PFP members to consult with NATO when faced with a direct
threat to its security but does not extend NATO security guarantees. Participation in PFP
does not guarantee entry into NATO, but it is the best preparation for states interested in
becoming NATO members; and
WHEREAS, 26 countries have joined; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports
NATO’s Partnership for Peace.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Resolution No. 109 (MD) 1995 NC: Expanding The North Atlantic Treaty
RECEIVED & RECORDED
Resolution No. 110 (MD) 1995 NC: Guidelines for Relations with The Former Soviet
Union
CHAIRMAN DICK PFAFFINGER, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Chairman, that completes
my record of the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on European Affairs.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The last
report is from Chairman Keith Baker of Iowa, Far Eastern Affairs.
FAR EASTERN AFFAIRS
Keith Baker (IA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
Origin: AK
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
WHEREAS, The Republic of China on Taiwan is a long-time friend and ally of the
United States, with a democratic government and free enterprise economic system, and is
the seventh largest trading partner of the United States; and
WHEREAS, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, as leader of the Republic of China for
many years, closely cooperated with the United States during World War II against Japanese
Imperialism, and assisted the allied efforts against Communism in the Korean War and the
Vietnam War; and
WHEREAS, The Republic of China occupies the island of Taiwan, which is of great
strategic interest economically, politically, and militarily to the United States; and
WHEREAS, The Taiwan Relations Act (Public Law 96-8) commits the government of
the United States to providing defense articles and services to the Republic of China, such
that Taiwan can maintain a sufficient self-defense capability; and
124
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
WHEREAS, Dr. Lee Leng-Hui, the President of the Republic of China, was invited by
his alma mater, Cornell University, to visit the United States to receive an Honorary
Doctorate for his contributions as an outstanding alumnus of Cornell University; and
WHEREAS, President Lee’s visit enhanced the peaceful and cooperative relationship
between the Republic of China and the United States; and
WHEREAS, Both the United States Senate and the House of Representatives
supported President Lee’s visit in near-unanimous votes, such that the State Department
issued a visa for President Lee’s visit; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion supports the
peaceful re-unification of China under the Three Principles of the People, as enunciated by
Dr. Sun Yat-Sen, the founder of the Republic of China; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports continued sales of military
equipment to the Republic of China as a means of safeguarding its existence; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports the initiation of discussions with the
government authorities of the Republic of China for American use of facilities on Taiwan;
and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion advocates the full implementation of the
Taiwan Relations Act in precedence over any contrary relationships with the Chinese
Communists (Mainland China); and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion applauds the actions of the United States
Government to grant President Lee Teng-Hui entrance to the United States to speak at his
alma mater, Cornell University, despite the protests of the Peoples Republic of China.
Resolution No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
Origin: MD
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended
WHEREAS, North Korea has consistently taken actions violating two nuclear
agreements it has signed; the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) (1985) and the
Non-Nuclear Declaration with the Republic of Korea (1992); and
WHEREAS, Instead of insisting that North Korea adhere to the two agreements, when
confronted by North Korea’s expanding nuclear weapons program, the U.S. Government,
in effect, agreed to pay “blackmail money” to North Korea in an attempt to halt the
unwelcome, threatening development of North Korean nuclear weapons, by signing the
Agreed Framework in October 1994, calling for providing North Korea two nuclear reactors
worth $4.5 billion, allegedly to be paid for by the Republic of Korea (ROK) an Japan, and
large deliveries of free oil, paid for by American taxpayers; and
WHEREAS, Soon after the Agreed Framework was signed, North Korea commenced
violating it by diverting some of the free oil to military use and objecting to the ROK
providing the two nuclear reactors; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion believes the U.S.
Government made a huge mistake by signing the Agreed Framework with North Korea with
the intention of hindering North Korea’s growing nuclear weapons program by seeing that
North Korea receive free oil and nuclear reactors, thus creating a precedent that emerging
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
125
nuclear powers can profit from their illegal nuclear weapons program; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion calls on the U.S. Government to be firm and
insistent in implementing the Agreed framework to prevent North Korea from receiving
additional financial rewards beyond those already promised, continuing to develop nuclear
weapons and long-range delivery means, and hindering U.S.-ROK cooperation.
Resolution No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
Origin: VA
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended and consolidated with No. 57 (TX)
WHEREAS, More than 2,000 American servicemen remain unaccounted for from the
Vietnam War; and
WHEREAS, The President of the United States on July 11, 1995 said he was satisfied
with the efforts the government of Vietnam has put forth toward resolving those missing in
action and prisoner of war cases; and
WHEREAS, The President used that rationale in announcing that he was extending full
diplomatic relations to Vietnam; and
WHEREAS, The “fullest possible” accounting the President had promised as his
requirement for normalizing relations with Vietnam has not been accomplished; and
WHEREAS, Past negotiations with the government of Vietnam show that the
communist leadership in Hanoi deal only from a position of strength; and
WHEREAS, The position of strength employed by the government in Vietnam has
been the information it holds about our POWs/MIAs; and
WHEREAS, Normalizing relations removes the requirement for Vietnam to continue
providing information about our POW/MIAs; and
WHEREAS, Congress must authorize the funds needed to establish offices in Hanoi
to administer to the President’s recognition of Vietnam; and
WHEREAS, Such authorization has not yet been approved; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports
legislation to withhold funding for normalizing relations with Vietnam until the President
certifies to Congress that the government of Vietnam is doing all it can to provide for the
fullest possible accounting of America’s POW/MIAs from the Vietnam conflict.
REJECTED
Resolution No. 40 (IL) 1995 NC: Reinstatement of Trade Embargo with Vietnam
CHAIRMAN KEITH BAKER, (IOWA): Mr. Chairman, that completes the report of
the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on Far Eastern Affairs.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr.
Chairman as a duly elected delegate to the Convention from the Department of Florida, I
move the adoption of the report of the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes John Bamaba of New
York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments for
the purpose of making a report.
126
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
John Barnaba (NY), Chairman
Mr. Commander, Reverend Chaplain, Fellow Delegates, the Committee on
Constitutional Amendments met at 9 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, at the Indiana
Convention Center, Room 143, 1st floor. Committee Liaison Phillip B. Onderdonk, Jr.
called the role and announced that 50 members of the Constitutional Amendments
Committee were present.
The meeting was opened by Philip B. Onderdonk, Jr. of Maryland who acted as
temporary chairman. He stated a quorum was present and proceeded to the first order of
business which was the election of a permanent chairman and secretary. John A. Barnaba
of New York was elected Chairman and Byron Lewis, Utah, was elected Secretary, who
assumed their respective places.
Copies of all the resolutions, the reports of the Standing Committee and copies of the
National Constitution and By-Laws as revised January 2, 1992, were made available to all
members of the committee.
A motion was made and seconded that all members of the Standing Committee who
were present at the meeting be seated with voice but no vote. This was unanimously carried.
The Chair called upon Philip B. Onderdonk, Jr., National Judge Advocate, to give a
summary background report on the resolutions to the committee, which was done.
The Chair announced the passing of two distinguished past members of the committee,
namely Milton S. Applebaum of Illinois and Bertram Davis of New York and requested that
the meeting be recessed in their memory.
The Chair stated that there were 11 resolutions for consideration by the Convention
Committee. The Chair ruled the following resolutions to be out of order in accordance with
the rationale stated in the Report of the Standing Committee as not being in proper form and
suitable for passage as a constitutional amendment.
The resolutions were: Resolution No. 25, Alaska; Resolution No. 28, Alaska;
Resolution No. 83, Wisconsin; Resolution No. 117, New Hampshire; Resolution No. 121,
Vermont; Resolution No. 130, South Dakota and Resolution No. 131, South Dakota.
The Chair placed on the floor for consideration Resolution No. 1, NEC Seeking to
expand Auxiliary Membership to include Grandmothers. A motion was made by Lloyd
Wagener (Wisconsin) and seconded by Thomas Miller (Florida) to approve said resolution.
The motion was carried with one nay vote. The Chair ruled the motion as passed.
The Chair referred to Resolution No. 72 (Kentucky) and requested a motion from the
floor that this resolution be referred to the Internal Affairs Commission for review and
action by the National Executive Committee. A motion was made to refer said resolution
by James Gilbert (California) and seconded by Raymond Jacquez (Maryland). The motion
was unanimously carried.
Resolution No. 11 was next submitted on the floor for consideration by the committee.
Motion was made by Walt Landi (France) and seconded by Ed Wearing (Colorado) to
approve the resolution. Following the discussion, Frank Giordano, chairman of the Standing
Committee, moved to refer Resolution No. 11 of Colorado to a study committee for further
review. That motion was seconded by Charles Tracy (New Hampshire). The motion to
refer the resolution was defeated and further discussion on the main motion, Resolution No.
11, continued. The Chair called the question and a roll call vote was held with 34 voting yes,
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
127
14 votes no and 2 abstentions. The Chair ruled that Resolution No. 11, Colorado, passed.
Resolution No. 98 (Ohio) was a final resolution submitted for consideration to the
committee. Since the subject matter of this resolution was similar to that of Resolution No.
11 (Colorado) the Chair stated that further consideration of the Ohio resolution was now
moot, whereupon Lydia Pickup of Washington moved to reject the resolution and John Titus
(Pennsylvania) seconded the motion. And the motion was carried.
There being no further business for consideration by the committee at this time, and
upon request of the Chair, a motion was made and carried to authorize the chairman and
secretary to sign the report of the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments.
A moment of silence was held in the memory of Milton S. Applebaum (Illinois), Past
Committee Chairman and Bertram Davis, Past National Judge Advocate. The meeting was
declared at recess subject to the call of the Chair. The resolutions follow.
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
Origin: National Adjutant
Submitted by: Constitutional Amendment
WHEREAS, Eligibility for membership in the American Legion Auxiliary is now
limited to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters
of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters,
granddaughters and great-granddaughters of all men and women who were in the Armed
Forces of the United States during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31, 1955;
December 22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States; all dates inclusive, or who, being
citizens of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty in the
Armed Forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of
said periods, and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women who
of their own right are eligible for membership in The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, There are many women who are grandmothers of men and women who
have served in the Armed Forces during the eligibility periods established by The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, Many of these women have expressed a desire to become members of the
American Legion Auxiliary but are not presently eligible for membership; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion Auxiliary National Executive Committee has
requested The American Legion to adopt an amendment to Article XIII, Section 1 of the
National Constitution of The American Legion to allow grandmothers to be included in the
American Legion Auxiliary; and
WHEREAS, The National Executive Committee of The American Legion has agreed
and recommended said change to The American Legion National Convention; now,
therefore, be it further
RESOLVED, By the National Convention of The American Legion in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that Article XIII, Section 2 of
the National Constitution of The American Legion which presently reads:
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
128
Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the
mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters
of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters,
sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters of all men and women
who were in the Armed Forces of the United States during any of the
following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7,
1941, to December 31,1946; June 25,1950 to January 31,1955; December
22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of
hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States; all dates
inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United States at the time of their
entry therein, served on active duty in the Armed Forces of any of the
governments associated with the United States during any of said periods,
and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women
who of their own right are eligible for membership in The American Legion.
be amended to read:
Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the
mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters, great-granddaughters
and grandmothers of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers,
wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters, great-granddaughters and
grandmothers of all men and women who were in the Armed Forces of the
United States during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to
November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25,
1950, to January 31, 1955; December 22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24,
1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20, 1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2,
1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government
of the United States; all dates inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United
States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty in the Armed
Forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during
any of said periods, and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge;
and to those women who of their own right are eligible for membership in
The American Legion.
and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That this amendment is made on the express condition that the National
Convention of the American Legion Auxiliary adopt an identically worded amendment to
Article III, Section 1 of its National Constitution and shall not be effective until said express
condition is ratified.
Resolution No. 11: Change in Eligibility Dates for Membership in The American Legion
Origin: CO
Submitted by: Constitutional Amendments
WHEREAS, The eligibility dates for membership in The American Legion are
determined by the Congress of the United States of America by the establishment of specific
dates during which the United States of America was involved in a war, declared or
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
129
undeclared, or other hostilities; and
WHEREAS, Members of the Armed Services of the United States of America were
called upon to defend the principles of democracy and justice in all parts of the world,
including Vietnam beginning July 1, 1958 to May 7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion membership eligibility dates for Vietnam are
beginning December 22, 1961, to and including May 7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, Members of the Armed Forces of the United States of America were
called upon to defend the principles of democracy and justice in all parts of the world,
including Vietnam with their supreme sacrifice beginning July 8,1959, to an including May
7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, No action was taken prior to this time by The American Legion to petition
Congress to change the eligibility dates for those members of the Armed Service who were
ready, willing and able and did in fact serve honorably during the aforementioned period of
time; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is not asking the VA to recognize these dates for
eligibility for benefits; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Colorado Membership Committee, recommended that
The American Legion extend its eligibility for membership to the period of July 1, 1958, to
and including May 7, 1975 (the period of time the presence of American troops were in the
Vietnam Conflict) and the Department of Colorado delegates to the State Convention
recommended such changes at convention assembled on June 22-25, 1995 at Sterling,
Colorado; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That the National Legislative Commission
be and is hereby authorized and directed to petition Congress of the United States and to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled, “An Act to Incorporate the American Legion”,
Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress, approved September 16, 1919, Chapter 59, Section 5,
41 Stat. 285; October 29, 1942, Chapter 633, Section 2, 56 Stat. 1012; July 9, 1946,
Chapter 546, 60 Stat. 524; December 28, 1950, Chapter 1177, 64 Stat. 1122; July 26, 1955,
Chapter 386, Section 2, 69 Stat. 380; September 1, 1966, Public Law 89-550, Section 2, 80
Stat 372; December 27, 1974, Public Law 93-557, 88 Stat. 1792; August 17, 1978, Public
Law 95-346, 92 Stat. 485; December 21, 1979, Public Law 96-155, 93 Stat. 1165; October
30, 1990, Public Law 101-478, 104 Stat. 1157; December 3, 1991, Public Law 102-179, 105
Stat. 1229; Title 36 U.S. Code Section 45 as amended to read when amended as follows:
Section 5. That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he
has served in the naval or military services of the United States at some time
during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31,
1955; July 1, 1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984;
December 20, 1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of
cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States, all dates inclusive, or who being a citizen of the United States at the
time of entry therein, served in the military or naval service of any
governments associated with the United States during said wars or
hostilities. Provided, however, that such person shall have an honorable
discharge or separation from such service or continues to serve honorably
130
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
after any of the aforesaid terminal dates,
and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts the above
amendment, and the President of the United States shall have approved the same and it
becomes law, then the National Constitution of the American Legion shall be deemed
amended in conformance therewith, but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions
in the Constitution contained, all is provided for under Article XVII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, Section 2 of the National Constitution of the American
Legion shall read as follows:
Article IV - Eligibility
Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in the American Legion who was
a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast Guard or Air Force of the United States
and assigned to active duty at some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917,
to November 11, 1918; December7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January
31, 1955; July 1, 1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990 to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being a
citizen of the United States at the time of his entry therein, served on active duty in the
armed forces of any of the Governments associated with the United States during any of the
said periods; provided, however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable
discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any of said periods;
provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to membership who being in such service
during any of said periods, refused on conscientious, political or other grounds to subject
himself to military discipline or unqualified service.
Article XIII - Auxiliaries:
Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to mothers, wives,
daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters of members of the American
Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and
great-granddaughters of all men and women who were in the armed forces of the United
States during any of the following periods:
April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31, 1955; July 1,
1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20, 1989, to January
31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United
States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty of the United States of any of
the governments associated with the United States during any said periods and died in the
line of the duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right are
eligible for membership in The American Legion.
CHAIRMAN JOHN BARNABA, (NEW YORK): As a registered delegate to this
Convention, I move the adoption of this report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s been a motion that the Report of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
131
the Constitutional Amendments be approved. There is a second. Any discussion.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): My name is Dan Foley, a registered
delegate from Minnesota, and I’m requesting that Resolution No. 11 be set aside from this
report for separate consideration.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s been a request that Resolution
11 be set aside. Objection? None.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s a motion and a second. Any
discussion? All those in favor signify with a sign of aye; Opposed? Ayes have it. The
report is adopted by a two-thirds vote.
... At this time the Chairman of the Constitutional Amendments read Resolution number
11.
DELEGATE JOHN BARNABA, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, in as much as we
have passed just recently Resolution number 1 of the NEC to add the term “grandmothers”,
I would ask that the section which is referred to in the Auxiliary, Section 2, under Article
XIII also include the category “grandmothers” as part of the amendment.
As Chairman of the Committee on Constitutional Amendments, Mr. Commander, and
as a delegate to this convention, I move the adoption of this resolution.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second?
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Commander, point of order, please.
I’m a registered delegate from Minnesota. My name is Foley. I wish with your permission
to make a parliamentary inquiry to your Judge Advocate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Yes.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Judge Advocate, so that all of us on
this floor understand the situation, I ask you now if a delegate on this floor is in favor of the
change of dates contained in Resolution 11 they would vote ‘yes’; is that true?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is correct,
sir.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): If a delegate on this floor is opposed
to the change of dates contained and proposed by Resolution 11 they would vote ‘no’.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is also
correct, sir.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): One other thing. In order to amend the
Constitution of The American Legion under Resolution 11, would it not require atwo-thirds
vote of this convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is correct,
sir. That is required in the National Constitution of The American Legion and the Article
entitled Amendments.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It requires a two-thirds vote for passage.
Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE AL LANCE, (IDAHO): Mr. Commander, A1 Lance, duly authorized
delegate from the Department of Idaho. Mr. Commander, I rise to speak in opposition to
Resolution 11 for the following reasons. Before I state my reasons, I would like to
commend those individuals in the Department of Colorado who have conducted their
research. However, what the resolution purports to do is to advance the date of eligibility
for Vietnam by some 42 months. It calls upon the Legislative Commission to go before
Congress and to try to once again change the public law under which The American Legion
was first organized in 1919. That public law has been amended 11 times as a result of
132
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
actions of changes in our By-Laws and our Constitution.
Mr. Commander and Delegates, as I think you are aware, we have several major
initiatives before the Congress of the United States presently pending, and those which will
be pending. First and foremost is the Flag protection bill which will require a great deal of
the resources of The American Legion Legislative Commission.
Secondly, of course, we have passed Resolution 141, which is the road map for the
implementation of the ‘Gold Book’ which has been described as being potentially the
greatest piece of social legislation that this country has known in the 20th century. That’s
going to take your resources and mine and those of the Legislative Commission.
But let me point out, Mr. Commander, by advancing the eligibility dates by some
42 months, what we are really doing is changing the date from 1955 to 1958. Now the
volunteers who were in Vietnam and Southeast Asia probably are already eligible for this
organization as a result of their service prior to 1955. And those who made a career of the
military, of course, probably are already eligible as a result of their service after December
22nd of 1961.
I think additional research, Mr. Commander, would be in order to ascertain precisely
how many individuals we are talking about and how many are already eligible for
participation as members in The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 3.
DELEGATE BILL BARBKNECHT, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Commander, Bill
Barbknecht, Delegation Chairman of Minnesota. I wish to speak to the convention in
regards to the eligibility change. I also look forward to a great day tomorrow and a day for
our Commander-elect to lead our great national organization. If we are to change the
eligibility dates, I remind the delegates that are here today of the IRS tax code 501 C 19
which is for veterans of wartime organizations.
When we have an attorney from New York come to speak before our Judge Advocates
as they did on Saturday and speak of the troubles we are having in Baltimore, Maryland, and
as we witness receiving a check for over $5 million, is that going to be IRS taxable? That
is a question I ask you delegates to think about.
We have problems with IRS, and they are not pleasant people to deal with at times.
Since 1974, we have had difficulties before the Constitution By-Laws Committee when
change was asked for in eligibility dates. I believe we have more pressing business before
us at this time.
I am a Vietnam-era veteran, who also has a son and daughter who have served during
the Persian Gulf. They are very proud to be wartime veterans and members of this great
organization. And I believe it is time that The American Legion proceeds with the issues
that we have before us, because we are not talking about that many people at this time. And
I urge the delegates to vote no, because we do not need anymore problems with IRS.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE ED WEARING, (COLORADO): Mr. Commander, Ed Wearing, Delegate
from Colorado.
We have got the issue on the taxes. That is incorrect. We are trying to make this
resolution take July 1, 1958 and make it a wartime era.
There’s an Executive Order from President Johnson, Executive Order 11231. This is
on the Expeditionary Medal and the Vietnam Service Medal, from July 1, 1958 until 1964.
That Expeditionary Medal was issued to the servicemen who were over there. As of July
8th, 1965, President Johnson put together this Executive Order stating that it allowed any
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
133
serviceman that served during those time periods to be issued a Vietnam Service Medal. So
that time period as far as our President at that time and the Department of Defense, was
recognized as being a wartime period. We need to recognize those veterans. We have been
trying to do this for some long period of time. I think it’s about time now that we recognize
those Vietnam veterans that were there.
We’ve got 16 names sitting up on top of that Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall, sixteen
who are not be eligible for The American Legion with our current dates. The 17th name on
that wall is December 22nd, 1961. That is where we came up with our last resolution on
changing this period.
We, as Delegates to this Convention, need to do it now. We need to recognize the
Vietnam Era as to what it was. We have a President, we have a Department of Defense who
have recognized it. Why, can’t we as veterans, recognize it? I am asking you here today
to look at this resolution.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE WALT LANDI, (FRANCE): Thank you, Commander, Walt Landi from
the Department of France, birthplace of The American Legion, duly authorized Delegate to
this Convention.
As a Vietnam veteran who earned the Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal on my first
trip over there before the Vietnam Campaign Ribbon was even thought of, we stand in
support of this resolution.
We have heard some of the bad things that might happen should we do this. The IRS
might start looking at us even harder. There might be a bigger shortfall in the Veterans
Administration’s budget to cope with the increased caseload of the new eligible veterans.
I submit to this body that the budget of the VA belongs in the House Appropriations
Committee. If we need care for those veterans, we should stand up and say, “Guys, you’re
missing somebody.”
There’s also been questions about when are we going to stop trying to change the dates
of the Vietnam Era. I submit to this body that every month documents are being
declassified, and every month the American public is learning more about the real truth of
when Vietnam began.
The first American casualty in Indo-China was in 1946. But in the more modem era,
the two airmen who died at Vinh Ninhwa Air Base in 1958 in July, led to the decision of the
July, 1958 date.
Well, a couple weeks ago when the President of the United States made his speech on
television, he said that recognizing North Vietnam would close the chapter of Vietnamese
American relations that began during the days of the Eisenhower Administration. We
strongly believe that the veterans who served there from 1958 onward should be entitled to
be members of this fine organization.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE EDWARD J. VOISARD, (OHIO):Mr. Commander, Ed Voisard, Delegate
from the Department of Ohio.
All this week we have been honoring those men and women who have served in World
War II, and given them recognition for what they have done. Resolution 11 seeks to honor
the members of the Armed Forces that served this country in harms way on foreign soils.
Some have given their lives, and as was stated before, the names are inscribed on the
wall of the Vietnam Memorial in our Nation’s capitol. I urge the passage of Resolution 11
to honor those of our comrades who served in that period.
134
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE HAROLD E. HEINLY, (CALIFORNIA): Harold Heinly, Delegate from
California, rises to speak against the motion on two main issues.
One is the authority to retain lobbyists by The American Legion, and the second is to
retain this nonprofit status.
I would like to point out to you Delegates here, that the Supreme Court of the United
States has already ruled that The American Legion is a special category, it has a special
privilege because the members are veterans who served during times of war. For that reason,
they are entitled to that special category of allowing themselves to have lobbyists who
participate in Washington, D.C. and still maintain the organizations nonprofit status.
I don’t recall which organization it was that raised the issue. It was one of the other
nonprofit organizations, such as the Elks, the Moose, or something like that. This is what
the Supreme Court said. The American Legion is different.
And I would urge you to vote no against this resolution. You are subjecting the people
who make contributions; you’re subjecting yourself to a profit status and it isn’t worth the
risk.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion; the question has been
called. Is there a second?
The Chairman will come forward and close the debate.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN BARNABA: Mr. Commander, this issue is not new to
this body. It’s been presented on the floor at previous Conventions.
We have all heard the same discussions and the same arguments regarding our tax
exempt status. By increasing and opening up the membership rolls to non-wartime veterans
is going to affect our tax exempt status. It is. It’s currently being affected because there are
intrusions into many, many activities of The American Legion. In my own state of New
York I know of many, of two or three instances recently, where the IRS has entered the halls
of an American Legion Post and subjected the Post to extensive audits. It’s not an old thing,
it’s coming. It’s a new thing.
The state of Maryland itself is encountering some very severe audits and attacks by the
United States government on this particular issue.
Something to give some thought to. The Congress determines periods of war. And we
in The American Legion traditionally have upheld our membership eligibility dates to the
times and dates that Congress has mandated. Yet today we are attempting to go beyond
those dates. We are a wartime veterans organization.
Today we’ve seen clips on the TV screens here which commemorates the veterans of
World War II, and prior to that, of World War I.
The World War I veterans started this organization. It was their purpose that it be a
dying organization. The tradition here is to have an organization composed of wartime
veterans. Are we to maintain that tradition? Are we to uphold that or not? I maintain we
should. Let’s honor these veterans who started this organization and maintain that tradition.
For that reason, Mr. Commander, and in line with the Preamble of this great
organization, I feel that we should continue to be and resolve to be an organization
composed of wartime veterans.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The debate has been ended. The
Chairman has the right to end the debate.
DELEGATE MARVIN E. JONES, (CALIFORNIA): Mr. Commander, Marvin Jones,
a Delegate to this Convention from California.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
135
My point of order is this: You have not taken the vote to cut off debate, and yet you
are allowing the Chairman to close debate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have closed the debate by the motion
to end the debate, and accepted a second, and now I’m calling for a vote on that motion.
And the Chairman has the last say.
All those in favor of the motion to close debate on the question, signify by saying aye.
Opposed? Ayes have it.
We will, now vote on the motion.
All those in favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? The no’s have
it. Motion fails.
... At this time a video vignette was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates, please join me in a salute to
the Flag of the United States of America. Hand salute.
. . . The Delegation stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will stand in recess
until 9:00 a.m., tomorrow morning. Thank you.
... At 3:25 P.M., Tuesday, September 5, 1995, the Convention recessed, to reconvene the
following day, September 6, 1995, at 9:00 A.M.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
137
PROCEEDINGS
THIRD DAY
Wednesday, September 6,1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegation listened to the music of the ‘40s while slides of World War
II posters were displayed on large screens.
... At 9:00 a.m., the Delegates assembled for the Third Day of the 77th Annual Convention,
and the following proceedings were had:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will come to order.
Delegates will stand and render a right hand salute to the Flag of the United States of
America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Please uncover, and I call for the
invocation, the Reverend Roy Pryor of South Carolina, our National Chaplain.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr., (SC)
National Chaplain
This morning as we go to prayer, we’re saddened by the loss of Don Livingston of
Iowa, who passed away this morning.
Will you pray with me in silence for the loss of Don, and that God will strengthen his
family at this time. Let us pray.
... The Delegation stood in silent prayer.
Holy Father, we invoke Your blessings upon our great Convention at this time. Please
accept our sincere thanks for all that has been accomplished. Always there are those things,
Father, that we wished could have been done that were not done, but we give You thanks
for all of the good things that we have accomplished.
We pray now for our new Commander-Elect and for those who will assist him, to carry
on the work of this great organization. Give them the tenacity to carry on for God and
Country.
We pray this prayer in Your name. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, please join me
in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of our Country.
. . . At this time National Commander Detweiler led the Delegation in the Pledge of
Allegiance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention is now in session.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
CFA PHONE BANK AND POST CARD UPDATE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, before we start
the business of the meeting, let me thank you very much for your responses to my request
that you give a call to our Senators regarding the Citizens Flag Alliance and the amendment
to protect the Flag from physical desecration. We had some complaints from some Senators
138
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
that we were calling them too often.
I don’t quite understand that, but I don’t think really they’re complaints from Senators
as much as complaints from staffers who don’t feel like answering the calls. We had a few
complaints from Senator Moseley-Braun of Illinois. A few complaints from Senator John
Glenn of Ohio. We also had a few complaints from a couple of Senators. Senator
Bradley’s office and Senator Specter’s office had complaints to the effect that some of you
out there who were calling them were not residents of their states.
The response of a couple of a couple of you callers was: “Wait a minute, I’m an
American. This is my Constitution and I can call any Senator I wish to call.”
I want to compliment you also on the fact that as late as 5:00 o’clock or so last night,
the CFA booth was still open and you were still making calls. Well, the Convention is not
over; the phones are still open; the cards are still there. I again request that you make those
calls. Washington has got to understand that this is a people issue. The Constitution says:
“We the people.” Please make the calls and let them know we are around, we’re determined,
and we’re going to win the issue.
We have a few donations before we move on.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER KENNETH PANNELL, OKLAHOMA: We have
$200.00 for the Citizens Flag Alliance this morning, Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, we appreciate it.
Another one from Idaho.
NECMAN ALAN G. LANCE, IDAHO: On behalf of Commander Dunlap and the
Delegates of the Department of Idaho, we are pleased to present to you this check for $500
so we can keep those phones ringing.
DRAWING FOR 1996 BUICK LeSABRE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The first order of business this morning
is finding the winner of the 1996 Buick LeSabre.
I would like to have Larry Hice, Assistant General Sales Manager of the Western
Region, and Dave Lyons, the Manager, Dealer Merchandising of Buick Motor Division of
General Motors Corporation, to join me at the giant drum.
While the Buick representatives are here, I want to extend on behalf of all Legionnaires,
our thanks for the support of Buick for the scholarship effort and support of American
Legion Baseball. Buick is making a real difference for tomorrow in the lives of many young
Americans. Thank you very much.
From Portage, Ohio, Richard Zulch is the winner of the Buick. This program has
generated for American Legion Baseball $1,585,000
LARRY K. HICE
Buick Motor Division, GMC
On behalf of the Buick Motor Division and the 2,958 Buick dealers across this great
Countiy of ours, we want to thank you for the opportunity to participate in this program. As
this association continues to grow and mature, it becomes better for Legion members, better
for Buick dealers, and better for us. It’s a win-win situation, so we want to thank you.
And on a personal note, as a proud Vietnam veteran, and a proud member of Post 413
in Grand Blanc, Michigan, I want to thank you for your continuing effort to keep America
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
139
strong and keep America what it is.
MBNA AMERICA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We talk about the Legion family and its
partners. Our second corporate partner is one that most of you are familiar with, MBNA
America, who issues The American Legion Visa and Master Cards. Since 1988, MBNA has
contributed over $12,000,000 to The American Legion. Each of you who use these cards
are responsible for this positive result. In addition, MBNA has donated $5,000 to the
Family Assistance Program; $25,000 to the Disaster Relief Fund; and as a CFA member,
pledged $50,000 in matching funds for monies donated to CFA on The American Legion
Visa and Master Cards.
We will draw for two, $1,000 CDS, and three, $500 CDS. Here to conduct the drawing
is Pat Murray, a member of the FBI Post in Washington, D.C.
PAT MURRAY
MBNA America
The first winner of the $1,000 CD is Donna Fuelling of 24646 McDonald Street in
Dublin Heights, Michigan.
The second winner of a $1,000 CD is Wilma J. Mayfield of 512 Worthington Lane,
Bridgeport, West Virginia.
The winner of one of the $500 CDS, Lana Bowen of 7 Nancy Drive, Waterloo, New
York.
The next winner of a $500 CD is Jack A. Waggoner, 1155 North State Road 75,
Thomtown, Indiana.
The next winner is Donna Bisaillon, 485 Briarcliff Lane, in Bourbonnais, Illinois.
As your business partner, I join the 13,500 people of MBNA America in making these
Certificates of Deposits available to you and to the membership of The American Legion.
And we are also pleased to make a contribution of $5,000 to the Disaster Relief Fund for the
sixth straight year, which makes a grand total of $30,000.
JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF MICHIGAN
The American Legion Annuity Program
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion Annuity Program
by Jackson National Life is providing a twenty-five inch TV at this Convention. Attending
today is Cliff Harris who is the Indianapolis Regional Manager of the Jackson National Life;
he will conduct the drawing.
The winner is Katena Karnes.
CLIFFORD HARRIS
Jackson National Life Insurance Company
On behalf of Jackson National Life, we are very excited to be entering into our second
year of the annuity program with The American Legion. Hopefully this weekend you had
an opportunity to stop by our booth and learn a little bit more about the annuity program that
140
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
you are eligible for. Currently that annuity is paying 9.6 percent. You also will learn
something about Jackson National Life, the largest underwriter of single premium deferred
annuities in the United States.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It’s now my pleasure to introduce to you
a member of the House Veterans Affairs Committee, the House National Security
Committee and the House Judicial Committee. He’s a Desert Storm veteran, and continues
to serve as a member of the United States Army Reserves. He’s an outstanding individual.
I wish we had more Congressmen whose mothers and fathers are the legislative contacts for
our organization. When we have an issue of importance, we call his mother.
It’s my pleasure to welcome to the podium, a member of Thornton Williams American
Legion Post No. 81 in Monticello, Indiana, the Honorable Steve Buyer.
THE HONORABLE STEVE BUYER
United States House of Representatives
When my father said he was going to be my Legion legislative liaison, I said, “I would
only permit you to lobby me from a fishing boat on the Tippecanoe River,” and so far he’s
tried to uphold that pledge.
Let me give a good morning to all of you, and my special thanks to Commander
Detweiler for inviting me to give remarks here this morning. I have enjoyed my associations
with the Commander, and I have really appreciated the leadership he’s shown on many of
the issues nationally.
If many of you could have seen his negotiations on the Enola Gay issue, you would be
as eminently proud of him as I was. A lot of people love to jump on that particular issue at
the end when the train pulls into the station. I remember last fall when he met with Peter
Blute of Massachusetts, Sam Johnson of Texas, and myself of Indiana. When I look
back on that particular issue, my only regret, having been scathed by editorial writers around
the country, was that we did not share with America that every time the Commander would
negotiate on the transcript, the Smithsonian Institution would then send it to Japan for their
okay. I wish we had shared that insight with America; perhaps it wouldn’t have been as
scathing.
Before I begin, also let me give a special appreciation and thanks to the State
Commander of Indiana, Thomas Henderson, for his leadership and the members of his staff,
to my good friend Kenny Ohl who gives me personal counsel and advice, and to your
Washington, D.C. staff. You should know that they do an excellent job. You are being well
served by Steve Robertson, Kimo Hollingsworth and Jim Hubbard. And I also appreciate
the counsel and advice of Bob Spanogle.
But I think that just for me to say they’re doing a good job is not enough. The
congressmen and women need your pressure. They need your pressure because
Washington, D.C. is an incredible town of politics, and you always must maintain the motto
and policy of The American Legion, but policy should always override politics.
There is no joy at all in sailing across calm waters on a windless day under blue sky.
The ebb and flow of the world is very dynamic, and what guides us through the turbulent
waters is the hand upon the rudder, that being our internal moral compass of the nation, a
unique attribute we call the American character. It was formed in the crucible of the
American Revolution and through our infancy as a growing nation. And I assure you I will
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
141
continually expound in my service in the United States Congress, of the wisdom of the
founding fathers of our country.
You see, they created a nation of laws, not of people. They created a nation of
principle, not of emotion of the moment. They created a nation of hope, focused on liberty
and economic opportunity; a nation assumed to be guided by the internal moral compass.
Not to be strayed by situational ethics or the pursuit of profits overriding common decency;
a nation whose compass is focused upon true north, that being: “One Nation Under God.”
I am concerned because there is a movement afoot to transform our society from that
one based upon religious principles, to one based on humanistic principles; that human
beings can do whatever they want, so long as they feel good and don’t hurt others.
Do you realize in America today, that you could have a speaker at a high school
commencement address, and they could be a communist, a fascist, a socialist, a neo-Nazi,
a racist? They could even stand there and bum the American Flag, and their speech and
conduct would find protection by the Supreme Court in the First Amendment. What a great
example of how upside down things have become in our society.
Thank you for keeping the pressure on the members of Congress and the United States
Senate for the Flag Amendment. You bet I was a co-sponsor of the amendment, with my
parents right over my shoulder.
And I was glad to hear you applaud when the National Commander said that the
Senators were whining, because when they’re whining and crying in Washington, you ought
to be cheering back at home, because you’re making them uncomfortable and that’s what
they need to be is off balance at times.
That internal moral compass that I spoke of consists of principles oriented in the forms
of values and teachings that enable, fulfill, empower and inspire people. The lessons of
history show that nations whose principles are properly woven into the fabric of society
have endured and have prospered. These values are reflections of our cultural background.
From childhood, our cultural influences, personal discoveries and family heritage all
contribute to our sense of a value system. They form one’s glasses through which they see
the world. It is their dimension of how they understand the world.
Indiana is farm country. I represent 20 counties. You name the cornfield and I
probably represent it. We have pragmatic and practical common sense because the laws of
the farm teach us that you must work the ground, plant the seed, cultivate it, nurture it for
growth and development to maturity, for there is no shortcut to the harvest. Likewise,
communities of a nation that care for their young, instill them with character, good values
for life, and a proper education, will provide the opportunity and hope rooted in the dignity
of work and reward for achievement. To use a biblical version, “Raise up a child in the way
he should go, and when he is old, he will not depart from it.”
You see, I was raised in an American Legion family. My grandfather, a World War I
veteran, was a Post Commander; my father, a Korean War veteran, was a Post Commander
and is now an Executive Officer of the District. My mother in the Indiana Auxiliary is
Department Chaplain. My wife is a member of the Auxiliary. My daughter is in the Junior
Auxiliary and my son is a member of the Sons of The American Legion. Now how’s that?
You see, words such as duty, honor, country, family, community, respect, reverence,
accountability, responsibility are such foreign words in Washington. But they are the fabric
of our soul of society. That’s what binds us.
Even though I was raised in an American Legion family, I did not fully understand the
terms of life. I thought I did. I will never forget as a sixteen year old senior in high school,
142
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
going with my father down to the Citadel. He was a graduate there and my brother was a
freshman. I’ll never forget standing in the museum of the Citadel. My father had not been
back to the university for many years. He stood there in the corner by a memorial where
there was a series of books. I was in another part of the room looking at the machine guns
and other items. As I walked over to my father, I saw him standing there. He had his hands
on the books and on the pictures of classmates who were killed in the Korean War. As he
stood there with his fingers on their faces, he would call out their nicknames. And it was
the first time that I had ever seen the tears of my father. However then at 16, I did not
understand the tears of my father.
Many years later I found myself on an air transport to the Gulf. The second lieutenant
that sat next to me was later killed. A Vietnam veteran once said that those who serve their
country on a distant battlefield see life in a dimension that the protected may never know.
I stand here today and understand the tears of my father. You see, the bond for which
we all share, we who are in this hall today, come from all walks of life all across the nation
from all ages. But there is something that binds us together. It’s a value system and it’s a
dimension of common understanding; it’s our heritage. Ordinary citizens are called upon
to perform extraordinary deeds, and it’s done with courage and it’s done with valor.
I’ll never forget walking into an American Legion Post where I was going to speak.
A Legionnaire was waiting for me. He walked out of the bar and as he walked up to me, he
had on tattered blue jeans, tennis shoes that looked like he just mowed the lawn in them; his
shirt half in, half out, with a seed cap on his head.
As he came up to me he had something in his hand. It was all wrapped up in tissues.
He took his seed cap off and he said, "Congressman, I have been waiting to see you. I want
you to have this in honor of my comrades." And as I opened up the tissue, I looked and I
saw a Silver Star. I said, "I cannot accept your Silver Star." I thought to myself, I know
exactly what this man went through to have earned that Silver Star. He witnessed the long
dark shadows of horror and he spat into the face of death.
But he kind of shrugged his shoulders and aid, "No, Congressman, I want you to have
it." And I said, "I can’t." And as he walked away from me he said, "That’s all right, I have
another." He had two Silver Stars. If you come to my Washington office, you will find that
Silver Star right next to my desk.
The message I have to share with you today is a very simple message. I have an equal
responsibility, just as you do, to help share the dimension and understanding that we have
here today. A majority of the new majority in the United States Congress was elected in
the 1990s, many of whom have never had military service. I was stunned a couple of
months ago when a new member came and sat down next to me and said, "Steve, I know
you served in the Gulf, is that what makes you a veteran?" Think of that. Is that what
makes you a veteran? Now, I was stunned by that.
I share that with you because I sat down and helped tried to educate him as to what that
means. Those of you here today who have a new member of Congress or have a new
Senator, take time and sit down with them. Don’t take it for granted that they know what
a veteran is. Constructively educate. It is vitally important. Do not question their sincerity,
that is a lesson that I have learned in the Congress. Just because they don’t share the same
dimension that we may have, doesn’t mean we should question their sincerity or their belief.
We need to educate constructively.
For one solid year, I parked my Jeep everyday next to a Congresswoman that had a
bumper sticker on her car which had “It will be a great day in America when schools have
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
143
all of the money they want, and the Air Force has to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber.” I
read that for one solid year, everyday. There are a lot of people in Congress who don’t share
the same dimension as I do. But I don’t question their sincerity.
Now, I enjoyed speaking with that congresswoman because we had nothing in
common. And I can stand here today and say she’s no longer in the United States Congress.
In Congress I served on the Veterans Affairs and National Security Committees. From
the start, a Congressman or woman takes the oath to defend the Constitution with his or her
life, and it ends when the bronze plaque marker is placed upon the grave. I take the
responsibility of serving very seriously whether it’s the issues under my direct
responsibility, such as the erosion of the benefits of the GI Bill or the necessity of
restructuring America’s colleges and universities. I have no interest at all in throwing more
money at a problem. That is not at all the answer.
I am exhausted by the tone and the tenor and the themes of Washington, D.C. that
somehow money is the measurement of compassion. Since when do you measure love by
the dollar? It’s not done. When dollars become restricted, you begin to leverage those
dollars and you begin to think, and that’s what must be done.
I’m reminded of General Patton as he stood over a cemetery in Europe. He stood there
to give comments, looking upon all the little white crosses and Stars of David. He said, “I
am not here to pay honor at all to those who have given their lives, but to pay honor that
they had lived.” How appropriate.
I thank God that He placed human beings upon this earth that might have the
compassion and the sincerity for fellow men and women who would lay down their lives for
others whom they don’t even know. That’s the dimension and understanding.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
Thank you very much, Mr.
Congressman. If we only had about four hundred thirty-five or so Steve Buyers in the
Congress, this country would be in excellent shape.
THE FOURTH ESTATE AWARD
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: On Monday we presented the William
Randolph Hearst Trophy to the Department of Vermont for their outstanding Americanism
efforts for the past program year. This morning we present the Fourth Estate Award to the
Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau for an outstanding series of articles on the national
debt and its crushing impact on our country.
Here to accept the award for the Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau and the
Albany Times Union of Albany, New York, is Marcia Stepanek.
The American Legion 1995 Fourth Estate Award for outstanding
achievement in the field of journalism is presented to Marcia Stepanek and
Charles J. Lewis of Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau and to the
Albany Times Union for a comprehensive five-part series on the national
debt. Presented at the 77th National Convention, September 6, 1995, in
Indianapolis, Indiana.
It is signed by myself as National Commander, Robert W. Spanogle, National Adjutant
and Thomas Kouyeas, Public Relations Commission Chairman. I congratulate you on this
144
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
outstanding work.
MS. MARCIA STEPANEK
Hearst Newspapers
We are deeply honored by this award. On everyone’s top 10 things to reduce is the
national debt and contain the federal budget deficit. Politicians preach against them and
economists testify to their ruinous effects.
Though we pay more taxes, it’s still not enough to cover the cost of our government.
Every year the interest we pay on the national debt takes an ever bigger bite out of our
national wealth. Now the national debt has emerged as a stubborn symbol of increasing
public frustration.
In Washington we have seen that in the last election, and we continue to see it. No
doubt we will see it again next year. For four months, from late 1993 through the spring of
1994 The Times Union of Albany, New York, and The Times Union, Washington Bureau,
Hearst Newspapers in Washington, tried to put a human face on this otherwise mindnumbing topic to examine the size of the debt, how we got into debt so deep as a nation,
why the debt keeps rising, and what the implications of the debt are for Americans and their
hopes for the future.
We conducted dozens of interviews. Our turf ranged from Washington State to
Washington, D.C.; points like Capitol Hill, the Treasury, the White House; out to the
grassroots of New York, to upstate New York, Plattsburgh Air Force Base; citizens of all
ages. In Minnesota, Illinois, Wisconsin, Virginia, and California, we talked to dozens and
dozens of people about that topic. We tapped into that frustration that had been felt leading
up to this last congressional election which illustrated some of the frustrations that had been
very long-standing over the debt.
The result of our research shows the debt to be one of America’s great dilemmas.
Cutting the debt can hurt as much as the long-term costs of borrowing. More citizens seem
to want it both ways. They want more money for solving society’s ills without having
anything cut from the existing budget. Yet, everybody wants to cut taxes.
Politicians don’t often, if ever, get reelected for cutting spending or raising taxes, and
this leads to this political dynamic in favor of deficit spending. On Wall Street, financiers
of the nation’s debt make money from the debt. The more money Uncle Sam must borrow,
the more money Wall Street must raise, and the more their firms make in profit for that
effort.
Yet without efforts to slow spending, the nation will be mortgaging its future and, say
some, draining Americans’ resources for this generation and generations to come.
When we started writing the series, the national debt was $4.4 trillion. Now it’s 4.9
trillion and rising at this current pace it could top $6 trillion in 1998.
On behalf of Hearst Newspapers, the Albany Times Union, Charles Lewis, The
Washington Bureau Chief of Hearst Newspapers and myself, thank you all for honoring this
project and honoring us. We are deeply grateful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The man I now have the great pleasure
of introducing is making his first appearance before an American Legion National
Convention. He’s a man who has proven himself a true military leader. His travels have
taken him around the globe more times than once for sure. Now he serves as the Chairman
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
145
ot the Joint Chiefs-of-Staff after a brilliant military career. He is the principal military
advisor to the President of the United States, the Secretary of Defense and the National
Security Counsel. Please welcome General John Shalikashvili.
GENERAL JOHN M. SHALIKASHVILI, USA
Chairman Joint Chiefs-of-Staff
I have just returned from Hawaii and the 50th commemoration of the end of the Second
World War. It was a moving and inspirational occasion, just like being here with all of you.
It was particularly thrilling to have been in Hawaii among so many thousands of
veterans from World War II, men and women like you who served our nation in a time of
extreme peril and who performed so magnificently. As you probably know, The American
Legion was there in Hawaii in full force, proudly filling the ranks of each and every one of
those moving events.
Those proud veterans there, and World War II veterans here this morning, are the living
monuments of a remarkable moment in our history. But unquestionably, the most moving
event of all was the remembrance ceremony in the Cemetery of the Pacific a few days ago.
When you stand among the hundreds of rows of white silent tombstones, each one marking
the resting place of an American patriot, one thought cries out for all Americans to hear. It
is the same stark imperative we have learned time and again in our history, and it is for that
reason we must keep our defenses strong. We must never again allow our military to
become weak or unready. You above all others understand that lesson well. After all, you
were and still are the true guardians of America’s security. You are great patriots all.
I knew that there was at least one place in America that I could go where there are men
and women who appreciate the need to keep our defenses strong, men and women who have
observed this lesson firsthand, and that is right here. That’s why it is so great to be among
all of you here this morning.
But there’s another group of men and women who understand this as well, and they are
the men and women who are following in your footsteps today. They proudly wear
America’s uniform. And as I travel around the world to see them, no matter where they are,
from the DMZ in Korea where they are still standing guard over the nation so many of you
fought to keep free, to places like Haiti or Kuwait or to Germany, wherever they are, I see
the same thing again and again. I see courage and spirit and toughness. They are by any
measure our most precious asset. They are one and a half million strong following in your
footsteps and carrying on the march that you started.
For after all, it was you here in this hall who fought and bled to protect our freedom and
to give us our future, and we will not, we must not, let it slip through our fingers. I know
you would be proud to see the job that these young men and women are doing. For I tell
you, as one soldier to another, they are magnificent.
It is on their behalf that I wanted to talk to you today about our future challenges. It
was not long ago that many Americans were talking about peace dividends and the need to
cut our forces deeper. But we were fortunate; there were many cooler heads. And certainly
The American Legion was at the head of that list. You argued that the days ahead could
prove very turbulent, and that we must at all costs preserve our military strength. You were
right, for you have only to look at the past month to make that judgment.
We began the month of August by deploying combat forces to Kuwait the moment that
we learned that Saddam Hussein was planning to attack that country once again, and
146
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
possibly Saudi Arabia as well. We ended the month with our aircraft flying combat
missions over Bosnia as they are still today.
When you add to that our people serving in places like I just mentioned, like Haiti or
Macedonia or Korea or Germany and mention to them the word 'peace dividend, you get
a hearty chuckle. They, like you, know that if you want peace you have to pay for it. The
nation must pay for it by keeping our Armed Forces the very best in the world. Our men
and women in uniform must pay for it with their dedication, with their skill, with their
courage and, if need be, even with their very lives. They know what you know. There’s
only one peace dividend, and that is peace itself.
So we have, after all, found ourselves in an era of great challenges. Yes, the Cold War
is over, but what has taken its place is anything but well-ordered. A peaceful world that
some imagined would come about has not done so. It is long past time for us to be looking
backward and wondering what we can afford to cut. Rather, it is time for us to look forward
to the future and ask ourselves what it is that we must build.
I’m convinced that there are two great challenges that we must meet if we are to protect
all that you here fought so hard to gain for our country. The first of these is the global
challenge posed by the disintegration of the Soviet Empire. This is a challenge of managing
the enormous changes unleashed by the end of the Cold War. The second challenge is to
reshape our Armed Forces to insure that we have the right force with all the right capabilities
to confront the uncertainties of the next century and to protect America’s worldwide
interests.
Certainly, the end of the Cold War set in motion a wholly new world in world affairs.
For 45 years we lived in a world that was tense and divided. Over time we grew used to that
struggle; we even understood it. Its twists and turns even settled into a reasonably
predictable pattern.
But all of that has now changed. We have been cast into a surging sea of great change
and uncertainty. Just think, in the past few years we have created more new countries and
more new international boundaries have been changed, then even at the end of World War
II.
We have already seen enough of this era to appreciate the measure of our challenge. We
have seen first that it is far more complex and far more dangerous than many thought. You
have only to look back on the list of military operations we have engaged in to understand
that.
Second, we have seen that this new world is filled with great unpredictability. You
never know when or where the next Saddam Hussein will raise his head. But I guarantee
you that he’s out there lurking amidst the uncertainty, and it is only a matter of time before
he will challenge us. We must be ready for him.
Third, it is also an era filled with incredible opportunities, opportunities that can make
the next century so much more peaceful and so much more stable than the bloody century
we are leaving behind today. Just think, over 2 billion new citizens are laboring to try to
join the global free market, a huge expansion. If it succeeds, it will make America vastly
more prosperous in the next century. Also, dozens of nations are enmeshed in dramatic
political reforms. They are struggling to shed old habits of tyranny, to embrace democracy,
and to join the ranks of democratic allies that you helped build at the end of the Second
World War.
Just imagine what it will mean if these hopes are met. Think back to the end of World
War II when you struggled to help our former enemies recover and rebuild. Eventually
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
147
single global market was organized to encompass some 1 billion of the world’s people.
Look at what that accomplishment has given us over the past 50 years.
But the opportunity at our feet today is to reach out beyond the old walls of
containment and to bring several billion former adversaries into the community of
democratic nations with free and open markets. This is much greater by comparison. If we
succeed for our children and for our grandchildren, just imagine what their world will be
like.
I am convinced that there is only one key that will unlock these hopes. That key is
American leadership. We must be the architects of the next century. But leadership
demands strength. You cannot lead from weakness. After all, it has been our strength that
has created these opportunities, and it must be our leadership that seizes them.
While we cannot be the world’s policemen, only we have the resources, the power, and
the reach to help mold a better world. To shape the world of tomorrow does demand that
we stay engaged in the world today. You here in this room set this example for us. You did
not shrink from your challenges, and we will not shrink from ours. We must stay always
focused on the future even as we are tending to the challenges of today.
While today’s challenges might be in places like Bosnia, North Korea, Iraq, or even
in a place like Haiti, the future isn’t being shaped there. The future is being shaped in places
like Moscow, Beijing, and Tokyo. While today’s challenges deserve our attention and, at
times, our intervention, we cannot ignore the main events that could directly threaten our
vital national interests. We must never, never lose sight that the fundamental purpose of our
Armed Forces is to fight and win our nation’s wars. We must not let events drive us, but we
must have the vision and the strength to shape events. We owe that to our children.
And that leads me to the second challenge. That challenge is to shape our Armed
Forces to insure that they are prepared to meet the challenges of the next century, a century
that is only a short five years away. We must make sure that our Armed Forces remain
unequaled by any other in the world. And that must mean that we avoid the rueful cycle of
the century, the same cycle we followed after the First World War, after the Second World
War and after Korea and, yes, even after Vietnam when we thought our struggles were
somehow behind us. As a result, we allowed our strength to atrophy. We neglected to
modernize, we permitted our readiness to dry up, and in the end, we paid dearly for our
mistakes. We must not allow that to happen again.
For it is a fact that in the history of this country’s Armed Forces, no man or woman in
uniform has ever completed a 20-year career that was not marked by American involvement
in armed conflict. Just think about it. And the force that we build must be powerful enough
to protect our worldwide interests, if more than one dictator were to challenge us. If we are
challenged in a place like Korea, we must still retain the strength to stop another dictator
at the same time somewhere else halfway around the world.
Certainly, our experience in the past two years has validated the need for a force with
this capability. Just in June of last year we were, in fact, reinforcing our forces in Korea
when the tensions over North Korea’s nuclear program had become so serious that we were
afraid that it could come to an armed conflict there. And by October of that same year, only
a few weeks after our forces began entering Haiti, we had to dispatch yet another force to
Kuwait after we detected several of Saddam Hussein’s Republican Guard divisions bolting
south towards our allies’ borders. In light of this experience, anything less ignores the world
we are living in, much less the world that may develop out of the uncertainty of the future.
You, the ranks of The American Legion, can attest that you do not build a military
148
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
force on wishful thinking. You build it on, a reality. With the ending of the cold war, our
military budget has been reduced by nearly 40 percent. I say, enough is enough. This
nation’s security demands that we cut no more.
And this nation’s security demands, as well, that we replace our equipment as it wears
out, that we modernize when necessary, even as we protect our near-term readiness. For
unless we replace our equipment, unless we modernize, we are jeopardizing tomorrow’s
readiness.
I believe that our experiences of the past two years have shown that the quality of our
men and women has, in fact, remained every bit as high as it has ever been. You can see this
everywhere that our men and women have been. In a superb way they have handled the
many missions that we have sent them to perform. You can see this in Haiti, where for a
year now they have performed magnificently and where results today have been exceeding
our most optimistic expectations.
You just saw two months ago when a young Air Force pilot named Scott O’Grady was
shot down while helping to reinforce the no-fly zone over Bosnia. From the moment his
plane went down, his comrades mounted an around-the-clock effort to find him. For nearly
a week, Captain O’Grady eluded capture, using the first-class training he had received and
through an extraordinary amount of pluck and courage. And the moment he was found, a
textbook rescue operation was executed, one that flew through dangerous skies to pull this
young hero to safety.
Or you could see just five months ago off the coast of Somalia where our Marines led
an international force to insure the safe departure of the last of the United Nations’
contingent still in that troubled land. It was a very dangerous and a very risky operation.
It was performed so flawlessly and in such a textbook fashion, that the entire operation was
accomplished without the loss of a single ally or United Nations Soldier or a single Marine.
Just as importantly, we showed by this action that the United States stands by its
commitments.
It is these men and women who have been and are performing these missions and are
making our Armed Forces, thus, the very finest in the world. If you wish to keep them in
uniform and to recruit more like them, then we must protect their pay and their benefits and
the quality of life that they and their families so richly deserve.
I like to say that they are a Superbowl team but without Superbowl wages. And the last
place we should look for savings is in their paychecks and in their benefits.
Since the start of the Second World War, it was our nation that had been the architect
of this century, America’s century. Many of you here in this hall were the builders. You
produced the victories upon which our freedoms were secured and upon which the Cold War
was won.
The challenge today is to insure that our nation is the architect for the next century as
well. If we are to do so, then we have to continue to lead. We are going to need men and
women in uniform every bit as good as you have been. Today they are. You can see this
if you go to the Aviano Air Base and watch them launch plane after plane into the skies
over Bosnia. You can see the cool determination in their eyes and the silent courage of
those performing the dangerous mission. It gives you the confidence that we will meet all
our challenges.
As I said earlier, they are, in fact, a Superbowl team, and we must never allow that to
change. But if we are to keep our defenses strong, then we need your support and your
assistance. That is what I have come here to ask of you.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
149
We need you, our country’s veterans, to continue to maintain your stand for a strong
national defense. You must continue to be our people’s standard bearer on that message.
Nothing less than a strong defense will do. We also need your help in finding and attracting
young men and women with outstanding qualities who are willing to spend a few years or
even a career serving our country. Spread the word through your communities. Uncle Sam
is still hiring. Your country needs you, and the rewards are beyond measure.
On behalf of those magnificent men and women of our Armed Forces, I salute you and
again, thank you for your remarkable service that you have given to our country. In our
times, of trial you were there. And thank God you were.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: General, be assured of the continued
strong support of The American Legion for our young men and women in uniform, and for
that readiness that is so important to peace in the world today.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, National Vice
Commanders have asked for permission to address the body. Permission granted.
PRESENTATION BY VICE COMMANDERS
VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Your Officers have felt that you have done an
outstanding job. So we decided we should give you something very special to remember
us by for your year of service.
Recently an artist in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin painted two pictures. One was of a Zero
over the Arizona.
The second one was of the Enola Gay, which was supposed to end the war. They came
out in Oshkosh at the EAA. We decided that this would be something that the Commander
could remember his year from, because he and his staff worked very hard, preserving the
true idea of the Enola Gay.
Commander, it’s all yours.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Well, Vem, and my Vice Commanders
and my Chaplain and Sergeant-At-Arms and other National Officers, you couldn’t have
given me anything more appreciated than that painting. It has been the hallmark of this year,
to stand up for the decision and to stand up for that wonderful plane. I thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The National Adjutant has asked for
permission to address this body. Permission granted.
PRESENTATION TO NATIONAL COMMANDER BY NATIONAL STAFF
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: I, too, want to thank you, Mr. Commander.
I know that the Delegates to the Convention elect a National Commander annually, and
certainly he travels almost a half a million miles per year carrying the message of The
American Legion.
We of the staff, however, get to work very closely with the National Commander. The
Delegates should know of the leadership demonstrated by the National Commander this
150
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
year, of his stewardship of your trust, and of his courage against the revisionist historians
regarding the Enola Gay. He carried on the traditional values in our quest for a
Constitutional amendment to protect the symbol of our country from physical desecration.
This has been deeply appreciated by me and his staff.
We have taken up a small collection for a symbolic gift to our National Commander.
Our thinking was just like that of the other national officers. We did not know what they
were going to present him.
I would like to have Hugh Dagley join me. On behalf of the staff of The American
Legion, we present to the National Commander, a hand-carved model of the Enola Gay.
General Tibbets and the crew who were here have signed this model in the positions
that they flew in the plane.
MR. HUGH DAGLEY: The National Commander has asked me to read the engraved
plaque.
To William M. Detweiler, National Commander 1994-1995. He led the last
battle of World War II for the people and for our common heritage.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have an outstanding staff. They gave
a lot of time and a lot of devotion. In order to work for a nonprofit group, the staff must feel
for what the organization stands for. I assure you, from the executive director, to all the
other directors, to the person that cleans the buildings, to the person that drives the
Commander, to those that send out the mail, whatever it takes, the staff are always willing
to do whatever it takes. I am most appreciative.
I spent 30 years in this organization, working on the National level but didn’t really
know what the staff does and how devoted they were. But I had the opportunity to work
with them closely and saw them in action. I thank all of them from the bottom of my heart
for making this year what it was. It wasn’t a one-man show, I assure you. A lot of hard
dedicated work went into the effort.
One of these days I hope that I can put together some sort of a history of the year,
because so many things happened. We look back at the issues, such as the Enola Gay or the
Flag Amendment; or the restoration of funding in the VA or the controversy over the
McNamara book. So many things that happened. When you look back, you see certain
decisions that were made that seemed rather insignificant at the time, but which were
important to bring about the outcome.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Tony Jordan of
Maine, the Chairman of the National Convention Committee on National Security for the
purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Anthony G. Jordan (ME), Chairman
At 9:00 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 301 delegates and alternates assigned to the
Convention Committee on Security met initially in Rooms 206-207 of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. At this meeting, motions were approved
authorizing the Committee Chairman and his Secretary to make technical corrections to the
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
151
resolutions reported out of the Committee to ensure proper wording and form without
changing the substance or meaning of the resolutions. Mr. Anthony G. Jordan (Maine) was
elected Chairman and Mr. Walter G. Miete (Maine) was appointed Secretary.
The six authorized Convention Committees (Aerospace, Defense Civil Preparedness,
Law and Order, Merchant Marine, Military Affairs, and Naval Affairs) met in separate
meeting rooms. An additional Ad Hoc committee was appointed for General Security
resolutions which required special attention. The following were elected Chairmen and
Secretaries of the Convention Security Committees:
Aerospace
Robert C. Gabrielson, Chairman (South Dakota)
William A. Lindsay, Secretary (Montana)
Defense Civil Preparedness Frank J. D’Amico, Chairman (New York)
John Schurrer, Secretary (Wisconsin)
Law and Order
Dudley W. Robbins, Chairman (North Carolina)
Jack M. Rainey, Secretary (Virginia)
Merchant Marine
Charles Moreland, Chairman (Florida)
Charles P. Powell, Secretary (Virginia)
Military Affairs
Norbert Harmeyer, Chairman (Iowa)
Ronald Smith, Secretary (Virginia)
Robert L. Klipstine Chairman (Ohio)
Naval Affairs:
Jerry A. Ball, Secretary (Oklahoma)
J.B. Broussard, Chairman (Louisiana)
General Security Ad Hoc
Alexander Maclnnes, Secretary (New York)
Later that day, September 2, 1995, the delegates reassembled in Rooms 206 and 207
of the Indianapolis Convention Center for a final meeting of the Convention Committee on
Security. Reports of all Convention Committees were read and their recommended actions
on resolutions considered. A total of 18 resolutions were assigned to the Convention
Committee on Security or prepared by the Committee to meet problems which were held to
be of concern to The American Legion and germane to its principles and objectives.
Our first Committee Chairman will be General Security Ad Hoc, Committee Chairman
J.B. Broussard.
GENERAL SECURITY AD HOC COMMITTEE
J.B. Broussard (LA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
Origin: National Security
Submitted by: National Security
WHEREAS, The Anti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty of 1972 between the United
States and the Soviet Union placed a cap on deploying missile defense systems and limited
more advanced research on such defensive systems; and
WHEREAS, Despite the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Russia appears to be
continuing the modernization of strategic missile systems; and
152
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
WHEREAS, Since one of the signatories, the Soviet Union, no longer exists, there is
doubt as to whether the treaty is still legally in effect; and
WHEREAS, For many years, The American Legion has been on record in support of
a broad interpretation of the treaty to permit maximum research to develop essential missile
defenses; and
WHEREAS, As unreliable, hostile nations such as Iran and Iraq seem determined to
acquire the capability to deliver a nuclear strike over long distances, including striking the
continental United States, the need for a national missile defense for the continental United
States has become more urgent; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the United
States Government to renegotiate, modify or abrogate the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty of
1972 to clear the way for the development and deployment of a national missile defense
system and theater missile defense systems which are in the national interest of the United
States.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 23 (MT) 1995 NC: United States Forces Under U.N. Command In Haiti
Resolution No. 106 (MD) 1995 NC: Anti-ROTC Policies at Colleges and Universities
Resolution No. 108 (MD) 1995 NC: National Security Principles
Resolution No. 125 (CA) 1995 NC: ROTC in Public Supported Universities and
Secondary Schools
REJECTED
Resolution No. 12 (CO) 1995 NC: Class Action Lawsuit Against U.S. Government
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Aerospace, Bob Gabrielson.
AEROSPACE COMMITTEE
Robert C. Gabrielson (SD), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
Origin: National Security
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The Secretary of the Air Force has emphasized that while resources have
diminished, demands for air and space power are increasing; and that in a world defined by
contingencies, the United States Air Force was focusing on three major objectives which
included maintaining combat readiness, shaping tomorrow’s Air Force, and supporting
people programs; and
WHEREAS, The United States Air Force has taken the lead in reducing its force
structure to meet Bottom-Up Review and Nuclear Posture Review requirements, and, in so
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
153
doing, freed up resources to maintaining combat readiness, supporting essential
modernization and providing a decent quality of life for its airmen and women; and
WHEREAS, Support ability and sustain ability have been enhanced by improved
readiness forecasting, better distribution of mission tasks, new ways to logistically support
weapons systems, and an improved approach to resolve engine problems; and
WHEREAS, The Air Force has focused its modernization in the following areas:
Providing rapid global mobility; achieving air superiority; conducting lethal surface attack;
and dominating the information environment. The five Air Force modernization priorities
over the next decade include the C-17 airlifter, B-2 bomber, F-22 fighter, upgraded precision
munitions, and the development of improved space launch capabilities; and
WHEREAS, The Air Force is strongly committed to providing a reasonable quality of
life which includes providing acceptable standards of living, treating people with dignity
and respect, and managing stresses associated with high deployment tempos; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to appropriately support and defend defense budgets which reflect the three major
objectives of the United States Air Force which include maintaining its combat readiness,
shaping tomorrow’s Air Force and supporting Air Force people programs; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges congressional action to support and
fund the modernization priorities of the Air Force including the C-17 airlifter, B-2 bomber,
F-22 fighter, upgraded precision munitions, and the development of improved space launch
capabilities.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN GABR1ELSON: Mr. Chairman, that concludes my
portion of the Report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Defense Civil Preparedness, Frank D’Mico.
DEFENSE CIVIL PREPAREDNESS COMMITTEE
Frank J. D’Amico (NY), Chairman
No new resolutions were received. The Committee conducted a review
of previously adopted resolutions and reaffirmed their relevance.
This concludes the Civil Defense Preparedness portion of the Report of the National
Security Commission.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Law and Order, Dudley Robbins.
LAW AND ORDER COMMITTEE
W. Dudley Robbins (NC), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security Committee
WHEREAS, The Preamble of the Constitution states: "We the People of the United
154
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
States, in order to form a more Perfect Union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility...
Do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America;" and
WHEREAS, Terrorist attacks in the United States by individuals or small groups have
been on the upswing: According to the FBI, 32 terrorist incidents occurred in the United
States between 1989 and 1993 while 23 attacks were prevented and another 20 attacks were
suspected as terrorist instigated; and
WHEREAS, In recent years, foreign state-sponsored terrorist attacks, with a few
notable exceptions, have not been directed against targets in the United States, rather, there
appears to be little, if any, overall pattern or correlation of terrorist groups which have
attacked major targets in the United States in recent years; and
WHEREAS, Car bombings have been the weapons of choice for Middle East terrorist
groups; and the bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993 appears to have been
masterminded by a Muslim cleric operating independently rather than being directed from
abroad; and
WHEREAS, The recent car bombing of the Federal building in Oklahoma City, clearly
the worst terrorist attack in United States history killing scores of people and injuring
hundreds, appears to be attributable to domestic American Para-military extremist groups;
and
WHEREAS, Regardless of whether these terrorist attacks are of domestic or foreign
origin, Americans are being intimidated into believing that no institution or locality is
exempt from terrorism in the United States; and
WHEREAS, The United States must be capable of detecting and responding to other
possible forms of terrorist activity including the use of biological or chemical attacks as
occurred in the Japanese subway system; and
WHEREAS, To make concessions to terrorists or alter policy as the result of terrorist
actions, although possibly expedient in the short run, invites even more terrorist actions in
the long run; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, that The American Legion condemns all
terrorist activity in the United States and that it urges the United States Government and its
law enforcement and other agencies to assign the highest priority to combating domestic
terrorism and to act swiftly and decisively against perpetrators of terrorist acts; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, That whenever terrorist activity in the United States, whether of domestic
or foreign origin, results in the loss of American lives and/or property, that The American
Legion urges such perpetrators be rapidly apprehended, prosecuted in American courts, and
subjected to capital punishment, when appropriate; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the Federal Government to exert
maximum efforts to protecting American citizens and safeguarding federal and other
facilities from terrorist attacks to include closer monitoring, surveillance and other necessary
and prudent scrutiny of foreign and domestic groups in the United States which may be
inimical to American institutions.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN ROBBINS: Mr. Chairman, that concludes my portion of
the report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Merchant Marine, Chuck Moreland.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
155
MERCHANT MARINE COMMITTEE
Charles F. Moreland (FL), Chairman
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. No new resolutions were received. The Committee
conducted a review of previously adopted resolutions and reaffirmed their relevance.
Mr. Chairman, this concludes my report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Military Affairs, Norbert Harmeyer.
MILITARY AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
Norbert Harmeyer (IA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
Origin: DC
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The United States has adopted a new National Security Strategy, marked
by the development of new national security and military strategies; and
WHEREAS, The United States Army is America’s strategic land combat force for
power projection and sustained land combat operations; and
WHEREAS, Unlike the Cold War strategy of containment, the emerging strategy
demands a versatile Army- a smaller Army capable of a wider range of operations and
organized to generate tailored forces; and an Army capable of meeting the following
demands: The capability to deploy rapidly and to fight two nearly simultaneous major
regional conflicts; a continuing robust Army forward presence is required in Europe and
Asia; refining its capabilities to conduct peacekeeping, peace enforcement and other
interventions; pursuing and expanding a series or nation assistance programs; and to provide
domestic support to local authorities in times of disaster; and
WHEREAS, The ability of the Army to maintain its combat readiness in the force of
budgetary and manpower reductions in increasingly threatened by the pace of peacetime
operations; and the mix of declining resources, increasing missions and an uncertain
strategic environment necessitate constant review of the relationships between maintaining
our national military capabilities, Army force structures and required resources; and
WHEREAS, On any given day, nearly 20,000 troops are committed worldwide and the
average soldier spends nearly 138 days a year away from home; and since 1989 nearly 700
Purple Hearts were presented to soldiers wounded or killed in combat; and
WHEREAS, The Army’s procurement and research and development budgets have
become bill payers to ensure near-term readiness accounts are sustained: The downward
trend in procurement dollars could jeopardize the lives of servicemen and women in future
conflicts; and
WHEREAS, America’s Army at the end of FY 1993 consisted of four Corps, 14 active
Divisions, and eight National Guard Divisions which contrasts with Cold War Army of five
Corps, 19 active Divisions and 10 National Guard Divisions; two active Divisions (the 6th
and 7th Divisions) are to be inactivated during FY 1994, and two more Divisions are to
deactivate by FY 1997, bringing the total active Divisions to 10 and National Guard
Divisions to five (+) Divisions by FY 1997; and
156
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
WHEREAS, Early access to the Army National Guard and Army Reserves, which
provide strategic depth, is the critical linchpin to a smaller, U.S.- based power projection
Army; and strategic mobility is the cornerstone of the emerging National Military Strategy;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to retain and fully fund no fewer than 12 active Army Divisions and an end
strength of approximately 530,000 troops for FY 1996 and the foreseeable future as the
absolute minimum levels in order to maintain America’s credibility in the new strategic
environment; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion also urges the Congress to sustain readiness
accounts as well as procurement and acquisition accounts in FY 1995 and beyond, to include
the procurement of, for example, improved equipment for the detection, identification,
characterization and defense against chemical and biological warfare agents; additional
Blackhawk helicopters, vehicles, new radios, Ml tank and Bradley Fighting Vehicle
upgrades, the Apache Longbow system, the RAH-66 Comanche; and fully funding the Army
Force XXI program; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion has long recognized that a strong Army
requires strong people programs and is highly dependent on recruiting and retaining quality
soldiers, and it urges that voluntary and involuntary separation programs be phased-out so
as to stabilize the Army’s fighting capabilities while retaining a quality and fully-manned
force which is professionally led.
Resolution No. 102: Quality of Life Features
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security
As amended.
WHEREAS, The American Legion has always supported quality of life features for
members of the Armed Forces and their dependents as well as military retirees, as people
are the foundation of our Nation’s fighting forces; and
WHEREAS, Without highly qualified, dedicated men and women, even the most
sophisticated weaponry will not provide the deterrent force necessary for this Nation to
remain at peace; and
WHEREAS, The United States Government has the inherent and moral responsibility
for providing for the well-being of members of the active and reserve components and their
dependents and military retirees and their dependents; and
WHEREAS, Military pay must be reasonably comparable to compensation in the
private sector if the Armed Forces aspire to compete for quality volunteers and retain an
experienced military force for the long term; and
WHEREAS, Military compensation is only one factor in the quality of life equation as
to whether a good service member and his family remain in the service: Other major factors
include fair treatment, career stability and regular promotions, adequate quarters, adequate
health care and commissaries, and day care facilities, all of which ease the numerous
sacrifices that are demanded of service members and their families; and
WHEREAS, Our military retirees and their dependents and military survivors are
deserving and rightfully entitled to adequate health care treatment and regular cost-of-living
adjustments (COLAs) to military retirement pay and survivor benefit plans; now, therefore,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
157
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress and the Department of Defense to support and fund such quality of life features
including but not limited to, the following:
1. Military Pay comparability for the Armed Forces.
2. Increased Basic Allowance for Quarters (BAQ) so as to cover at least 65
percent of median housing costs.
3. Adequate medical and dental services; morale, welfare and recreational
facilities; and non-privatized exchanges and commissary facilities.
4. Retaining an attractive retirement system for the active and reserve
components which safeguards retirement benefits in effect at the time of the
service members’ entry into military service
5. Requiring that the Services perform mandatoiy physical examinations,
without waivers, for all separating veterans.
6. Fully funding the concurrent receipt of military retirement pay, military
separation pays, and VA disability compensation.
7. Amending Public Law 99-145 as to eliminate the automatic age 62 offset
of Survivors’ Benefits Plan benefits with Social Security benefits
particularly for those survivors who have earned Social Security benefits in
their own right.
8. Adequate health care treatment for military retirees, their dependents and
military survivors, and regular cost-of-living adjustments to military
retirement pay and survivor benefit plans.
9. Non-taxation of military allowances to include moving allowances.
10. Congressional Re-enactment of Impact Aid to fund the local public school
education of military dependents.
11. Amend IRS codes to increase the current monthly exclusion for all officers
serving in a combat zone from $500 to $2,000.
Resolution No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (OBRA) of 1993 drastically
altered the 30-year relationship of military and Federal retirees COLAS by delaying the
receipt of military retiree COLAS by 39 months and delaying the receipt of other Federal
retiree COLAS by only 9 months, cumulatively, between April 1, 1994 and January 1,
1999; and
WHEREAS, By 1999, the delay in military COLAS would cost the average military
retiree at least $3,000 annually in retired pay while a Federal civilian retiree with
comparable retired pay would forfeit only $603; and
WHEREAS, Military retirees as a group comprise only three percent of the population
eligible to receive Federal COLAS, yet they are being forced to bear 88 percent of the total
COLA sacrifice; and
WHEREAS; Military retired pay is not a gratuitous gift from the taxpayer but is earned,
deferred compensation for accepting the unique demands and sacrifices of decades of
military service for careerists who often served and fought in two or more wars or conflicts;
158
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
and
WHEREAS, If the Government allows the quality of life of retired military members
to erode over time, or if the retirement promises that induced them to serve arduous careers
are not kept, this will undoubtedly inhibit retention in the active duty and reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, The vast majority of military careerists are forced to retire in their early
40's and their annual retirement pay and COLAS never catch up with the annual incomes
of single-career Federal civilians of comparable age, education, and job experience; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to correct the gross inequity in military retiree COLAS by providing sufficient
funding to equalize the delays in the receipt of military retirement pay with those of Federal
retired civilians for FY 1996 and beyond; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion opposes any further Congressional attempts
to delay, reduce or deny military retirement COLAS for authorized recipients of military
retirement pay.
Resolution No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military
Beneficiaries
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security Committee
WHEREAS, The promise of lifetime military health care for military retirees, their
dependents, and military survivors is contained in law and tradition and dates back to the
Army Appropriations Act of 1884; and
WHEREAS, A sense of the Congress resolution contained in the Fiscal Year 1993
National Defense Authorization Act states that "members and former members of the
Uniformed Services and their dependents and survivors should have access to health care
under the Health Care Delivery System of the Uniformed Services regardless of age and
health care status;" and
WHEREAS, The present health care system for military retirees direly requires reform
as the CHAMPUS entitlement system for beneficiaries under 65 has been annually under
funded, bureaucratically administered and inconsistent; and military retirees over 65
comprise the only group of retired Government "employees" who essentially lose their
military health care entitlement, after having served 20 or more years in the most demanding
and dangerous of professions; and
WHEREAS, Under the TRICARE system, CHAMPUS eligible beneficiaries will
choose among three options: TRICARE Prime, whereby patients rely on a single primary
care provider for most health care needs; TRICARE Extra, a preferred civilian provider
network with a higher choice of physicians; and TRICARE Standard, a fee-for-service plan
which is essentially the CHAMPUS system. Those who choose TRICARE Prime or Extra
would waive their rights to use military hospitals or pharmacy benefits; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has a number of concerns with the TRICARE
package, namely, that military beneficiaries would be required to pay annual "registration"
fees whether they used their plan or not; questions remain concerning the amount of
increased out-of-pocket expenses; premiums for self-employed military retirees; the viability
of MEDICARE reimbursement to the Department of Defense; and whether a TRICARE
program would be extended to military beneficiaries residing overseas; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
159
WHEREAS, Military retirees, dependents and military survivors constitute at least 43
percent of the total 9.2 million eligible military medical beneficiaries; and over 500,000
retirees have lost or will lose their access to military health care as a result of military
treatment facilities’ closures; and
WHEREAS, The collective voices of The American Legion and other organizations
need to be heard by Congress, the Administration and the American people regarding
military retiree entitlement to quality, timely and consistent health care which retirees were
always promised; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion recommends the
following guidelines be incorporated as an inherent part of the Department of Defense
TRICARE health care package, or any military health care package, for military retirees,
dependents and military survivors:
1.
The U.S. Government must honor its obligation to provide lifetime health
care to military retirees in exchange for their numerous sacrifices made over
decades of service to the nation.
2.
Timely access to a continuum of quality, comprehensive and equitable
health care benefits covering the full array of services ranging from
preventive health care and dental treatment plans to prescription services for
all military beneficiaries, regardless of age or health care status.
3.
Preservation of the space-available system for CHAMPUS and MF.nTCA.RP
eligible military retirees and their dependents in military treatment facilities
depending on facility capabilities.
4.
CHAMPUS coverage should continue for the lifetime of military retirees
and not end at age 65. Additionally, military retirees who become 100
percent disabled before 65 should continue with CHAMPUS coverage for
their lifetimes with MEDICARE as second payer.
5.
DoD health care treatment facilities should be reimbursed by the Health
Care Financing Administration for care provided to MEDICARE eligible
military beneficiaries (MEDICARE Subvention).
6.
MEDICARE subvention will save money for both the government and
taxpayers. Equally important, it will preserve military medical readiness
and keep faith with military beneficiaries who relied on repeated
government promises of lifetime health care in return for their decades of
career military service.
7.
Adequate military medical personnel should be retained on active duty to
provide health care for active duty and retired military personnel and their
dependents.
8.
MEDICARE eligible retirees are not allowed to enroll in TRICARE Prime
160
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
as DoD does not fund the medical treatment of these retirees. Additionally,
TRICARE annual enrollment fees are imposed only on retirees and their
dependents and survivors which is discriminatory. These enrollment fees
are excessive for CHAMPUS eligible retirees. The American Legion also
opposes the proposed imposition of user fees in military treatment facilities.
9.
TRICARE choice is restricted by the imposition of more restrictive
non-availability statements. These statements must be obtained from
military facilities as well as from civilian networks.
10. The retirees’ catastrophic cap should be reduced from $7,500 to $2,500 for
enrollees in TRICARE Prime to conform to similar caps for other HMOs.
11. Cost-sharing in TRICARE plans should be reasonable and legislatively
fixed by law.
12. TRICARE health care plans should be extended to eligible military
beneficiaries residing in overseas areas.
13. Oppose the DoD charging of user fees for those PRIMUS and NAVCARE
clinics established after September 30, 1994, based on TRICARE Prime
rates.
14.
Oppose the imposition of enrollment fees in the Uniformed Services
Family Health Plan which is the only DoD health care program which has
not disenfranchised MEDICARE eligible retirees.
15. Pharmacy networks and mail-order pharmacy programs should be extended
beyond the 40-mile radius of closing military bases and they should operate
on a flat-rate basis rather that one based on percentage of costs.
16. The imposition of penalty assessments should be waived for those military
retirees who elected not to enroll in Part B of MEDICARE as they believed
they would receive continuing military health care from DoD facilities
which were subsequently identified for closure.
17. Authorizing the use of Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Centers by
non-service-connected military retirees and their dependents who are
CHAMPUS or MEDICARE eligible, particularly in those areas where
military bases with medical facilities are closing or closed.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 13 (CO) 1995 NC: VA/DoD Joint Venture for Fitzsimons Army Medical
Center
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
161
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 33 (DC) 1995 NC: Retain the Selective Service System
Resolution No. 45 (SC) 1995 NC: Preserve the National Guard of The United States
Resolution No. 103 (MD) 1995 NC: Retention of The Uniformed Service University of
Health Sciences (USUHS)
REJECTED
Resolution No. 31 (DC) 1995 NC: National Museum of The United States Army
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Naval Affairs, Bob Klipstine.
NAVAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
Robert L. Klipstine (OH), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 150: Support for The United States Coast Guard
Origin: National Security
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, By public law the United States Coast Guard is at all times one of the
Armed Forces of the United States; and
WHEREAS, Included in the numerous peacetime and wartime missions of the Coast
Guard are law enforcement in its many facets to include drug interdiction and interception
of illegal aliens; environmental protection, maritime safety including search and rescue
responsibilities and inspecting and licensing Merchant Marine ships; and National Security
to include port security and serving as an essential wartime partner of the U.S. Navy; and
WHEREAS, To carry out these critical missions it is essential that highly skilled and
motivated men and women continue to be attracted and retained by the Coast Guard and its
Reserves and that ships, aircraft, and required facilities be fully funded; and
WHEREAS, It is vital to the National Security, economic and environmental
well-being of the United States that waterway safety receive high priority within the
Nation’s transportation infrastructure so as to assure the safe and efficient maritime transport
of critical raw materials, petroleum products and finished cargoes to domestic and
international markets; and
WHEREAS, It is also in the national interest for the Coast Guard to acquire new ships
and aircraft so that new technology can be maximized; and
WHEREAS, Without adequate resources, the United States Coast Guard will be unable
to meet its national and international commitments to the detriment of the American people;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Minneapolis, Minnesota, September 6,7,8, 1994. That The American Legion urges the
Administration and the Congress to fully fund the United States Coast Guard to carry out
its numerous vital missions, including law enforcement, environmental protection, maritime
safety and national security and other missions as assigned; and, be it further
162
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports pay parity for Coast Guard men and
women so that they receive compensation comparable with their partners at the Department
of Defense; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the Congress and the Department of
Transportation to support and fund such quality of life features as pertain to the other Armed
Forces of the United States.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: I am particularly pleased to announce the winners of the
National Blood Donor Awards for this past year.
Category I - Departments with 100,000 or more members
Post and Individual Participation - Department of Florida
Individual Participation- Department of Minnesota
Category II - 70,000 to 99,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Wisconsin
Category III - 40,000 to 69,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Georgia
Category IV - 25,000 to 39,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Tennessee
Category V - 10,000 to 24,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Rhode Island
Category VI - Less than 10,000 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Delaware
The results of the competition for the Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy are as follows
FOR 1994-1995:
Over fifty Departments participated in the ROTC Awards Program this year. A total
of over 10,000 Medals were awarded to deserving cadets in College ROTC and Junior
ROTC Units. There were fourteen Departments which were awarded the Paul H. Griffith
ROTC Trophy plaques and they included the Departments of Alabama, Alaska, Delaware,
District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Puerto
Rico, Rhode Island, and Vermont, which speaks well for these Departments and The
American Legion in its recognition of the youth of America enrolled in ROTC programs.
. At this time National Vice Commander Calvin E. Patton assumed the Chair.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate to this Convention, from the
Department of Maine, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was duly seconded and carried.
... National Commander resumed the Chair.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
163
BLOOD DONOR REPORT
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As we near the end of our 77th National
Convention, I’m happy to report that we have recorded another excellent Blood Drive.
Because of a generosity of the Delegates to this Convention, 257 units were collected.
Blood Center workers estimate this will assist 1,028 patients at several central Indiana
hospitals, including the VA Medical Center. I congratulate you for your support, and ask
that you carry the message of the importance of donating blood back to your local posts. The
American Legion can continue to be the largest identifiable group of blood donors in the
nation.
... At this time a video vignette was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I hope you have appreciated these
vignettes as much as the staff appreciated the opportunity to put those together. I think they
have really helped to carry out the commemoration of World War II and this convention.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: 50 years ago, World War II was finally
over. Today the U.S. Military continues to have a strong presence in the Pacific theater.
Our next guest is a man who carries a heavy responsibility to insure that America’s readiness
in this area of the world remains high. He’s Deputy Director for Operations of the U.S.
Pacific Command, responsible for all joint operations, exercises, and operational command
and control throughout the Pacific Command. He’s a decorated pilot, first seeing action in
Southeast Asia and most recently flying one of his 242 combat missions during Operation
Desert Storm.
It gives me great honor to welcome to our 77th National Convention, Major General
E.C. ‘Sandy’ Sharp.
MAJOR GENERAL ERVIN C. SHARP, JR.
Deputy Director for Operation U.S. Pacific Command
Thank you, Commander Detweiler, it is a great personal privilege for me to be here
today with you in this hall of my comrades in arms and great American patriots. And, on
behalf of Admiral Richard C. Mackey, Commander-in-Chief of the United States Pacific
Command, we send greetings and aloha from Camp H.M. Smith, Hawaii.
As we speak, Admiral Mackey is about to begin his second day of conferences with all
of his Pacific commanders, discussing many of the details of the Pacific strategy that he
asked me to share with you today. As Admiral Mackey typically does, I will start with what
he emphatically believes to be at the core of the Pacific strategy and the key to its execution.
His twin priorities are war fighting and people.
Our business in the military is war fighting. We must be ready to fight and win our
nation’s wars. War fighting means readiness. Readiness means of a relentless pursuit to
continuously improve, field and maintain the best equipment we can for the troops.
Readiness means leveraging the accelerating emergence of technological marvels
certain to unfold in the 21st century. Readiness means steadfast support for the best training
that money can buy for every member of our Armed Forces.
But as you know, it’s not our equipment nor our technology nor our training nor even
our doctrine that makes us the greatest military power in the world. It’s our people. Without
164
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
quality people and an adequate quality of life for those people, such as in housing, pay,
medical care, and retirement war fighting readiness is impossible.
We simply must never abandon these two fundamental priorities if we hope to have any
military strategy succeed or more importantly, if we wish to remain the world’s most
effective fighting force.
With those two priorities clearly in focus, let me now share with you the Admiral’s
perspective of the Pacific and the Pacific strategy as we approach the year 2000 and beyond.
I’ll do this in two parts.
To begin with, I will talk briefly about why we as Americans should be interested in
and concerned about the Asia/Pacific region. Then how we of the United States and of the
Pacific Command address our cares and concerns about the region.
First, why should we care about the Pacific? At the heart of the answer lies a basic
principal of our national strategy. That says democracy is in the best interests of the
American people. Over time we have learned that democracy has some excellent habits.
Democracies don’t declare war on each other and don’t support terrorism, produce refugees,
or traffic in drugs.
Democracies do foster free market economies and protect human rights. Therefore the
enlargement of the community of free democracies is a vital interest of the United States.
When you lift the hood of these democracies, particularly the late models found in the
Pacific region, you find the engine driving the phenomenal growth in the world’s
transnational marketplace.
Many share the Pacific command’s view that our nation’s economic future is clearly
in the Asia/Pacific region, an area of over one-half the earth’s surface and one-half of the
earth’s gross domestic product. The Pacific encompasses two-thirds of the world’s
population organized into more than 40 nations. Five of them are defense treaty partners
with the United States. 36 percent of our trade is in this region, three times our trade with
Latin America and one and a half times our trade with Europe.
Portions of the Asia/Pacific region are growing six times faster than the global average.
The economic miracle is especially apparent in the rapid growth of China, the world’s
fastest growing economy, with a 9.5 percent annual growth average over the last ten years,
and the four newly industrialized economies of South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and
Singapore.
Certainly from all of this it’s not difficult to argue that we should care about the Pacific,
and I believe most do. However, at the same time, we also must be concerned with the
enduring realties of the Asia/Pacific region. Even with the end of the cold war we have seen
that the world is still a dangerous place. Witness Desert Storm, Chechnya and the ongoing
conflict in Bosnia, just to name a few.
Our current national military strategy warns of four emerging global dangers, all of
which are clearly at work in the Pacific.
First, there are regional dangers. In addition to 40 years eyeball-to-eyeball over the
DMZ in Korea, there are ethnic, ideological and territorial disputes both within and between
Pacific nations which are also home to the world’s seven largest Armed Forces.
Second, there are dangers from the proliferation of weapons both of mass destruction
and conventional.
Third, there are dangers to democracy from within with a tendency to relapse into
autocratic forms of government when they see their privileges threatened.
And finally, there are economic dangers of falling behind economically or that
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
165
economic tensions may lapse into protectionism.
Thus viewed in the foregoing context, we see a complex region with many positive
trends that offer enormous potential for national and global prosperity. Yet, at the same
time, we must not lose sight of the unfavorable consequences should we ignore the region’s
enduring realities and disturbing trends.
Obviously, the same complexities require a balanced and aggressive national and
supporting military strategy. Additionally, as a Pacific nation ourselves, one of the central
tenants of that strategy must be shared responsibility.
President Clinton made that abundantly clear during his July, 1993, trip to Asia when
he described his vision of the “theater grand strategy.” He described a Pacific community
built on shared strength, shared prosperity, and a shared commitment to democratic values.
His themes of security and active engagement in the region are also formalized in our
national security strategy of engagement and enlargement and more recently in the East Asia
strategy report.
Engagement is defined as presence in the region. A full partner in peace and crisis thus
becomes the mission of the Pacific command, that is to insure the enlargement of the
community of free and open societies.
To accomplish that mission, Admiral Mackey must find ways to link our military
means to our national ends. He does this through a theater military strategy called
cooperative engagement. The means available to us are forces, funds, programs and asset.
The desired ends we are trying achieve are engagement and reassurance in peace, deterrents
and cooperation in crisis, and swift victory in conflict.
The three principle ways we use to link these ends and means are forward presence,
strong alliances and crisis response.
First, forward presence. Everywhere we visit in the Asia/Pacific region, people tell us
how important it is for the United States to remain engaged there. We are engaged. The
most credible way we demonstrate our commitment to the region is through forward
deployment of our soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines, and in many cases, their families
as well. We have, and intend to keep, about 100,000 of our troops forward deployed. That
number brings us about into balance with the number of troops that we intend to keep in
Europe.
Countries of the region watch our presence very carefully and for good reason.
Economic progress depends on stability. Stability depends on mutual security and
reassurance. Mutual security and reassurance depends on United States security guarantees
and a United States presence.
Our 100,000 forward deployed troops consist of maritime forces, which are
continuously deployed in the western Pacific, the Third Marine Expeditionary Force in
Okinawa, tactical fighter wings in Korea and Japan, the eighth U.S. Army in Korea and
rotational deployments, such as air force squadrons to Singapore. These are backed up by
forward-based forces in Hawaii, Alaska, Guam and Pacific Command forces on the west
coast of the continental United States. In total, these 330,000 troops of all our services
represent one-fifth of our total U.S. military.
The second way we link our means to achieve our ends is through strong alliances.
Five of the seven units mutual defense treaties worldwide are in the Pacific Command’s area
of responsibility. In addition to our commitment to treaties with the Philippines, Australia,
Republic of Korea, Thailand and Japan, we have established a network of bilateral and
multi-lateral relationships with the majority of the 45 nations in the theater.
166
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
Our third link is crisis response, which brings us full circle. As you recall, I said in the
beginning that should deterrents and cooperation fail to divert conflict, our business in the
Pacific Command is war fighting, and war fighting means readiness. The Pacific Command
is composed of our nation’s finest men and women actively engaged and present in the
region, fully trained with our regional friends and treaty partners for joint and coalition
warfare. They stand ready to respond to any crisis to achieve swift and certain victory.
Last weekend it was my honor and privilege to help host thousands of World War II
veterans in Hawaii as we commemorated V-J Day, the end of the war in the Pacific and the
end of World War II. Many veterans came to the dais to remind of us of the enormous
sacrifice that victory required. World War II destroyed whole cities, it ravaged countrysides.
It cost and totaled the lives of 55 million people.
The Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Jessie Brown, said more than 4 million of America’s
best and brightest served in World War II in the Pacific. More than 100,000 died. Almost
200,000 were wounded and about 35,000 were prisoners of war. Veteran Virgil Stewart
who was at Hickam Field on December 7, 1941, said, “We don’t want anyone to forget what
happened. We don’t want it to happen again. No way.”
President Clinton said, “It is only fitting that here in the middle of the ocean whose
name means peace, we honor the men and women that saved our world. We honor the men
and women that saved our world. We who are the heirs of their legacy must always be the
guardian of their dreams. It falls to us to stand against those who sow the seeds of war and
to stand with those who take the risks of peace to create a new prosperity for ourselves and
for others.”
Hopefully, my report to you today has been a clear signal that the best and the
brightest, the men and women of the U.S. Pacific Command, are prepared for and totally
committed to this sacred mission. We want to assure Virgil Stewart that we have not
forgotten what happened, and we are not going to let it happen again. No way.
Once again, on behalf of Admiral Mackey and all the Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and
Marines of the U.S. CINCPAC, thank you, National Commander Detweiler, and all of the
great Americans in the Legion, the Auxiliary and the Sons of The American Legion, for the
opportunity to bring you this report on the Pacific. We all loudly applaud and deeply
appreciate your enormous efforts on behalf of those who served and those who serve today.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: General Sharp, be assured that The
American Legion will continue to work in support of the necessary foreign and defense
policies to keep our forces in the Pacific strong and to continue to maintain those strong
forces in those countries.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Would Peter Ole please join me at the
podium. You know, I’m not sure how many years he has been with us.
MR. OLE: This is my 20th year.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion is grateful to
present to Peter Ole this certificate of appreciation:
In recognition and sincere appreciation of outstanding service and assistance
which contributed immeasurably to the success of The American Legion
National Convention in Indianapolis, Indiana, in the year 1995.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
167
Signed by myself and Bob Spanogle. Thank you, Peter.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Would National Vice Commander
Vernon Grosenick preside over the next order of business.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Ladies and Gentlemen, I am honored
to preside over the next order of business during the 77th National Convention. This is the
time when we present to our National Commander Bill Detweiler of Louisiana, a plaque and
the Colors of his year in office. I now call on Mr. E. Roy Stone of South Carolina to present
the plaque.
PRESENTATION
E. ROY STONE, JR., (SOUTH CAROLINA): Last year it was my privilege to swear
in the commander who has served us this past year. I am further honored now to be given
this opportunity to bestow special recognition upon our National Commander. I have know
Bill Detweiler for many years. I have watched him serve our great organization and our
nation with true dedication.
As we mark the close of this year with him, as our National Commander, let us look
back at the issues he has tackled and the prestige he has brought to The American Legion.
Most noteworthy during this year was his leadership in insuring historical accuracy about
the end of World War II and, in the process, preserving the honor of those veterans.
He also took a highly visible road in mobilizing our forces in support for Old Glory,
talking with lawmakers at every opportunity about the need for a Constitutional Amendment
to protect the flag. Look at this insightful work in guiding the development of new
strategies that are being recommended for the VA hospital system. These initiatives, if
adopted, will preserve the VA while allowing access to VA medical care for more veteran.
It is a great honor to ask Commander Detweiler to join me at the lectern.
Mr. Commander, I wish to present to you on behalf of The American Legion this
plaque which shoes that you were elected to the high office of National Commander of The
American Legion for the 1994 to 1995. It is given to you in appreciation for your dedicated
leadership and in recognition of your devoted services to God and county. As a token of
high esteem of your fellow Legionnaires. Given on this 6th day of September, 1995, before
the delegates assembled at the National Convention in Indianapolis, Indiana.
Congratulations, Commander Detweiler, and I do it with quite a bit of emotion when
I say God bless you and thank you.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: At this time, I would like to call
Past National Commander John Geiger from Illinois to present the Colors.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Will the delegates to this National
Convention please rise.
. . . The Delegates stood.
Ladies and Gentlemen, the ceremonial Color Guard is the 1995, 1996 National
Champion Color Guard from Speedway Post 500, Speedway, Indiana.
Color Guard, prepare to retrieve the Colors of our National Commander.
... The Colors were retired.
Commander Detweiler, these beautiful Colors, the flag of the United States and the
168
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
bright crimson banner of the national commander symbolize your term of leadership of the
American Legion.
I know that Robert Charles Smith and A1 LaBiche are here in spirit with the
Department of Louisiana and your family and friends as these proud Colors are presented
to you in final salute.
On behalf of the 3 million members of our American Legion, we present them to you
with deep gratitude and appreciation for your outstanding commandership. May God bless
you and your family. Commander, these are your Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWE1LER: Hand salute.
Thank you very much, Commander Stone, Commander Geiger, my Fellow
Legionnaires, and Ladies and Gentlemen. On behalf of my family who is gathered with me
here on this stage, thank you very much for an incredible year. As I said earlier, it would
have really been impossible to predict what was going to happen this year when 1 was
elected in Minneapolis. I had no idea that we would have been involved in the issues we
have been involved in this year nor that we would have the opportunity to put forth our
opinions which were newsworthy and which were valued by the American public. I thank
you again very much for the opportunity of serving.
ELECTION OF NATIONAL OFFICERS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We now come to a Special Order of
Business, the Election of National Officers. The National Judge Advocate, Philip
Onderdonk of Maryland will read the rules of the Convention governing the nomination and
election of officers.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK: The rules for election of National
Officers:
Rule 15. Final sentence: The election of National Officers shall be by roll call.
Rule 17. Prior to the election of National Officers, the National Commander shall appoint,
subject to the approval of the Convention, a judge of election and such number of tellers as
he deems necessary, provided that the total number of tellers so appointed shall be an odd
number. In a contested election, each candidate going to the ballot shall be entitled to one
teller of his choice.
Rule 18. Nominations for National Officers shall be from the floor on roll call of the
Departments alphabetically arranged. Each Department may present as many candidates as
it chooses.
Rule 19. Nominating speeches for National Officers shall be limited to five minutes each.
Not more than two seconding speeches shall be made for any candidate, and said speeches
shall be limited to three minutes.
Rule 20. When more than two candidates are nominated for any office, balloting shall
continue until one candidate receives the majority of the votes of the Convention, except in
the election of National Vice Commanders.
Rule 21. In a contested election for National Vice Commanders, balloting shall continue
until (a) majorities and (b) pluralities are established for one or more candidates under the
following provisions: If, on any ballot taken, less than five candidates receive the necessary
majority to elect, the candidate or candidates receiving a majority vote shall be declared
elected and a new ballot shall be taken for the remaining number of places to be filled. The
candidate receiving the lowest number of votes on the preceding ballot shall be disqualified;
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
169
except, should two candidates remain to fill one place, a new ballot shall be taken.
Rule 22. The Convention will nominate and elect a National Commander and five National
Vice Commanders in this sequence.
Rule 23. At the conclusion of balloting on National Vice Commanders, each Department
Delegation Chairman shall deliver a written ballot to the tellers. Such ballots shall be in the
hands of the tellers before communication is made to the National Commander for
announcement of the results.
Mr. Commander, this completes the reading of the rules pertaining to the election of
National Officers.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As Chairman of this Convention, I now
appoint as Judge of the Election, that judicious adjutant from Louisiana, Jim Tripp, and as
Tellers of the Election, Lyle Foltz of Minnesota; Carey Bankhead of Missouri and Hugh
Hess of Michigan. Will the Judge and the Tellers of the Election please come forward?
I will call on the National Adjutant, Robert Spanogle, who will call the Roll of the
Departments. The purpose of the Roll Call is to receive nominations for National
Commander of The American Legion.
ROLL CALL
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Proceeding with the roll call. Alabama.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ORION J. HYDE, ALABAMA: I’m O.J. Hyde,
Department Commander and chairman of The American Legion Delegation from Alabama.
At this time Alabama yields to Minnesota.
DELEGATE BILL BARBKNECHT: Bill Barbknecht, Delegate to this National
Convention, hereby, Mr. Commander, ask you to recognize one of the finest Minnesota
Legionnaires from the Gopher State of Minnesota, very proud moment, the Honorable Past
National Commander, Judge Daniel Foley, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Past National Commander Foley is
recognized for the purpose of a nomination.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER HONORABLE DANIEL F. FOLEY,
MINNESOTA: At the outset, Commander Bill, I join my voice to the rank and file of The
American Legion to salute and applaud you for a year of outstanding service. You stood tall
in the face of great challenge, and deserve our respect and admiration for your leadership.
Your legacy, Commander, is that you have reminded all of us to be faithful to the lessons
we have learned from history, and for that alone I salute you.
It is my high honor and great personal privilege to place the name of an outstanding
Minnesota Legionnaire in nomination for election as National Commander.
The recorded history of The American Legion at every level tells us how far we have
come and what we have accomplished in pursuit of our goals as an organization. Our life
and times will dictate how we should pursue those goals in these last few years of the 20th
Century and into the next.
We labor in the vineyard of The American Legion, in the midst of changing and indeed
challenging circumstances in our national life and within our organization as well. We have
concern for the needs of the aging veteran, the homeless veteran, ill and dependent veterans,
and our concern for America challenged by crime and drugs. And we continue our valent
effort to protect our national symbol from physical desecration.
170
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
All of these concerns and more will require imagination, resourcefulness, discipline of
will, strength of numbers, and a steadfast Commander with spirit to lead The American
Legion. We present a man who will serve us well, and honor our organization by his quality
of leadership, his character and high moral conduct He will lend great dignity to the office.
This is a red letter day for his family; for the Department of Minnesota and for our National
Organization.
Our candidate is personable; he is popular; and he is schooled in the history of The
American Legion in its aims and purposes.
He was with the Navy in the submarine service during the Vietnam Era. He is
committed to the view that we must maintain a strong national defense. He is totally
committed to the cause of the POWs and MI As.
In his home Department of Minnesota he has served as Commander at every level:
Post, District and Department Commander. He has achieved an all-time-high in membership
with each command. In addition, he has served our Department as Department Chaplain.
Our candidate has shown additional leadership by heading up the Brain Science
Foundation in Minnesota, establishing a chair at the new VA Medical Center in Minneapolis
to study diseases of the brain. These studies and findings will ultimately help not just
veterans, but all of humankind for untold generations.
Under his leadership, over a million dollars was raised in a little over one year within
The American Legion and its Auxiliary in Minnesota, and matched by the University of
Minnesota. The studies are well underway.
Our candidate is a devoted family man, proud of his children, John and Ann. With his
lovely wife, Mary at his side, he is an ideal candidate to promote our Children and
Youth programs, and set an example for The American Legion family.
Our candidate has served actively on the National level on commissions and
committees, including Chairman of Foreign Relations. He is molded in the tradition of The
American Legion, a tradition which is reflected in the countless accomplishments of our
organization at every level, and of the effort of the men and women would have and do serve
our cause.
Our candidate is mindful of our tradition and mindful, too, of the mandate of our
Preamble: For God and Country we associate ourselves together to preserve the memories
of incidents of our association. To uphold and defend the Constitution. To transmit to
posterity the principles of justice, freedom and democracy.
Our candidate is determined as well to oppose with vigor any effort to reduce veterans
benefits, benefits which are the gift of a grateful nation for honorable service.
On the great seal of the State of Minnesota is the motto of our state: L’Etoile Du Nord,
The Star Of The North. This state, so rich in the history of our country with its lakes and
streams, its beautiful forests and fertile prairies, productive farms, its famed Iron Range, and
most of all its greatest resource, its people, is proud to proclaim him. Avon and Albany in
central Minnesota where he grew up as a boy and where his family roots run deep, are proud
to proclaim him. Red Wing, where he now makes his home, is proud to proclaim him. This
proud Department, with an eye to the bright sunlight of tomorrow, with its hope and
promise for peace in the world, proclaims him. I am honored to proclaim him.
Together with the Minnesota Delegates here assembled, and for all 130,000 Minnesota
Legionnaires for whom I speak, and with a heart filled with pride and emotion, I place in
nomination for election to the office of National Commander, our Star Of The North, a
Legionnaires’ Legionnaire, the name of Daniel A. Ludwig of Red Wing, Minnesota.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
171
... At this time a demonstration ensued in support of the nomination of Daniel A. Ludwig
as National Commander.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Alaska.
DELEGATE JESSE EUBANKS, ALASKA: Jesse Eubanks, Department Commander
of the great state of Alaska, The Land Of The Midnight Sun, I do hereby yield to Virginia
for the purpose of seconding the nomination of our incoming Commander, Daniel A.
Ludwig, of the greatest organization on earth.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Virginia.
DELEGATE ROGER MESSIER, VIRGINIA: Mr. Commander, Roger Messier, NEC
Delegate from the great state of Virginia. I rise for the request for you to recognize the Past
Department Commander and Chairman of our Delegation, Harold "Butch" Miller, for the
purpose of seconding the nomination of Dan Ludwig, our next National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes "Butch" Miller for
the purpose of seconding the nomination.
DELEGATE HAROLD L. "BUTCH" MILLER, VIRGINIA: As the Delegation
Chairman and the Past Commander of the Department of Virginia, and I might add a
member of the Southern Caucus, I am proud to rise and second the nomination of Daniel A.
Ludwig to the office of National Commander.
During the entire history of this great organization of The American Legion, only 76
Legionnaires have been granted the privilege I have been granted right now. But I can
unquestionably assure you that none have had the honor of placing the second upon the
nomination of a more dedicated, deserving and capable person.
Famous UCLA basketball coach, John Wooden once said, "Be concerned with your
character rather than your reputation. For your reputation is nothing more than what other
people think of you, while your character is what you truly are."
My fellow Legionnaires, the character of The American Legion will be in very, very
good hands with Dan Ludwig as our Commander.
Bom in a small town in Minnesota, Dan was raised on the traditional values of Love
of God and Love of Country. That should sound very familiar to all of us because for God
and Country are one of the founding ideals of this great organization. It is upon those same
ideals that Dan Ludwig lives.
Dan joined the Navy in 1964, and served in that capacity for eight years during the
Vietnam Era. He has been a member of Leo Peterson Post 54 in Red Wing, Minnesota since
1974. His wife, Mary and his daughter Ann are members of the Auxiliary, and his son John
is a member of the SAL. As you can see, they represent a truly American Legion family.
Since 1973, Dan has been employed by the Northern States Power Company at a nuclear
power plant in Red Wing, Minnesota as a radiation protection specialist. And even though
he represents a very bright star on the horizon for the future of The American Legion, I have
been told that Dan does not glow in the dark.
On a very personal note, I would like to thank Dan for allowing me to second his
nomination. While I am here representing the great Department of Virginia, I want the
record to show that I would have been just as proud to second his nomination had I not been
born and raised in Wabasha, Minnesota, just a few miles from Dan’s home.
My fellow Legionnaires, I ask that you join me in supporting a real American and a
dedicated Legionnaire from the Department of Minnesota, Daniel A. Ludwig, as our
National Commander for 1995-1996.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Arizona.
172
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JIM PHILLIPS, ARIZONA: Jim Phillips, Delegation
Chairman, Department Commander of the great state of Arizona, where hopefully in the
future we can hold another National Convention.
I yield to Maine.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Maine.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DONALD COLE, JR., MAINE: Worthy Commander,
Donald Cole, Department Commander, Delegation Chairman to this 77th National
Convention, I would request permission for our own Anthony Jordan to approach the
rostrum for the purpose of seconding the highest office in this great organization.
DELEGATE ANTHONY JORDAN, MAINE:. My name is Anthony Jordan, Delegate
to this 77th National Convention.
It is a privilege and honor to second the nomination of a friend and a Legionnaire, and
a man that brings with him family values that The American Legion has stood for since
1919. He is a man who has made The American Legion part of his everyday way of life
starting with the Leo C. Peterson Post 54 in Red Wing, to serving as Department
Commander of Minnesota in 1991 and 1992.
He served as a National Chairman of the Foreign Relations Commission in 1992 and
1993, and served on the Distinguished Guest Committee and Naval Affairs Committee. He
is serving as a member of the Policy, Coordination and Action Group in the Citizens Flag
Alliance. He believes in God and Country, and the veterans of this nation, dedicated to
veterans’ issues on the local and the national level. Strong leadership has always been the
foundation of The American Legion, and the 1995-96 year will be no exception.
On a personal note, I have known Dan and his wife Mary and children Ann and John ever
since they came on the National level. This is a National Commander and a family we will
learn to love.
It is with personal pride that I second the nomination of Daniel A. Ludwig of the
Department of Minnesota for the high office of National Commander of The American
Legion in 1995-96.
... At this time, the National Adjutant recognizes each Department in turn.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN CLAUDE CARPENTER, ARKANSAS: Mr. Chairman,
fellow Delegates, my name is Claude Carpenter, Chairman of the Arkansas Delegation, and
it is with great pleasure that I rise to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig to be National
Commander of this great organization.
DELEGATE JOSEPH EARLEY, CALIFORNIA: Joe Earley, Delegate to this
Convention; State Commander of California, where the National Convention will be held
in Anaheim in 1999, is honored to second the nomination for Dan Ludwig for the high
office of National Commander for the year 1995-96.
DELEGATE ED WEARING, COLORADO: Ed Wearing, Department Commander,
duly authorized Delegate from the Department of Colorado proudly seconds the nomination
of Daniel Ludwig for the National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN LEWIS WALLER, CONNECTICUT: Lewis Waller,
Delegate Chairman from the great little state of Connecticut, seconds the nomination for
Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE RICHARD HALL, DELAWARE: Department Commander, Membership
Chairman, I’m from the great state of Delaware with nine all time highs in membership,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RAYMOND J. POTOCKI, D.C.: Comrade Commander,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
173
my name is Raymond Potocki, the Delegation Chairman from the District of Columbia,
seconds the nomination for Daniel A. Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE WILSON TIMMONS, FLORIDA: Wilson Timmons, Past Department
Commander of the Sunshine State and home of the Convention to come up in 1997, proudly
second the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE WILLIAM MARSHALL, FRANCE: Bill Marshall, Department
Commander, Department of France. It’s with pride I can state that the birthplace of this
great organization, The American Legion, proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig
for National Commander and our leader for 1995-1996.
DELEGATE WILLIE PITTS, JR., GEORGIA: Willie Pitts, Commander of the great
Peach second the nomination of Ludwig for 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM DAVES, HAWAII: Aloha. Bill Daves,
Department Commander and Delegate Chairman, also from the home of the 1995 American
Legion Baseball Team, proudly seconds Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOHN DUNLAP, IDAHO: Department Commander
duly elected Chairman from the gem state of Idaho, proudly seconds the nomination for Dan
Ludwig for National Commander for 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN KERMIT HOLGREWE, ILLINOIS: Kermit Holgrewe,
Delegate Chairman from the state of Illinois, the Prairie State, proudly second the
nomination and the support of Daniel A. Ludwig for our next National Commander.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, INDIANA: Indiana proudly seconds the nomination
for Daniel Ludwig for Commander 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN NORBERT HARMEYER, IOWA: Delegate Chairman
for the State of Iowa, seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE RICHARD NIELSEN, KANSAS: Mr. Chairman, Dick Nielsen, State
Commander for the State of Kansas, on behalf of our 63 Delegates to this Convention are
proud to second the nomination for Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RANDALL COFFMAN, KENTUCKY: Randall
Coffman, Department Commander and Delegate Chairman from the great state of Kentucky,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan the man for the job of The American Legion
National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RUSSELL HENRY, LOUISIANA: Mr. Chairman,
Russell Henry, Past Department Commander, Chairman of the Delegation of the great state
of Louisiana proudly endorses, Dan Ludwig for Commander for 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ROBERT M. JOHNSON, MARYLAND:
Mr.
Commander, Robert M. Johnson, Department Commander, Delegate Chairman for the state
of Maryland, takes great pride in seconding the nomination of Dan Ludwig for the high
office of National Commander for the administrative year 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ARTHUR SMITH, MASSACHUSETTS:
Mr.
Chairman, Arthur L. Smith, Department Commander, Chairman of the Delegation, proudly
endorses and seconds Daniel A. Ludwig for the Department- for the National Commander,
1995-1996.
DELEGATE H. DEAN GEDDES, MEXICO: Buenos dias. This is the Department of
Mexico Commander, Dean Geodes. We were the first in membership for 1995, and we
intend to be right back on that podium in 1996 helping the new National Commander
achieve three million members. We want to second the nomination for our new
Commander, Dan Ludwig.
174
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM F. MILLER, MICHIGAN: Bill Miller,
Delegation Chairman, Michigan, proudly supports Dan Ludwig.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, MISSISSIPPI: Mississippi proudly supports Daniel A.
Ludwig for National Commander for 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN NORRIS PRESTON, MISSOURI: Delegation Chairman,
Dr. Norris Preston from the Show Me State of Missouri, the home of the first Legionnaire
to become President of the United States, Harry Truman, the man from Independence.
Many in this hall and thousands of your fellow veterans across the country, and for that
matter across the ocean, owe their last 50 years of their lives to this famous Missourian.
Harry Truman was the right man in the right place at the right time, and he made the
right decision. We all know it and must never let the world forget it.
Missouri proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig of Red Wing, Minnesota, to
be the next National Commander of The American Legion.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOHN PELLEGRINI, MONTANA: John Pellegrini,
Delegate Chairman from Montana, the Big Sky Country, proudly endorse and second the
nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE ROBERT H. ZERSEN, NEBRASKA: Bob Zersen, State Commander,
home of the world’s largest American Legion Post and the birthplace of the Enola Gay
where she first flew in Bellevue, Nebraska, proudly endorses Dan Ludwig for the high office
of National Commander.
DELEGATE ARCHIE POZZI, NEVADA: Archie Pozzi, National Executive
Committeeman, proudly endorses and seconds the nomination for Daniel Ludwig.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: New Hampshire.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ROBERT G. BOURNIVAL, NEW HAMPSHIRE: New
Hampshire, Bob Boumival, Department Commander and Delegate Chairman is proud to
second the nomination of Dan Ludwig for the office of the National Commander for the year
1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN GEORGE DIEM, NEW JERSEY: George Diem,
Delegate Chairman from the Garden State, the home of the 1995 National American Legion
Woman Of The Year, our Governor, Christy Whitman, proudly endorses Dan the man
Ludwig.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, NEW MEXICO: New Mexico, the Land of
Enchantment, home of the Atomic Museum, offers a home to the Enola Gay, seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DAVID J. VARNEY, NEW YORK: New York. Mr.
Commander, David J. Varney, duly elected Chairman of the Delegation of New York,
proudly seconds the nomination of a proven great leader in The American Legion, Dan
Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE GARNETT SHROPSHIRE, NORTH CAROLINA: Garnett Shropshire,
duly elected, standing in for our Chairman, Bob Patton, proudly endorses Daniel A.
Ludwig.
DELEGATE SUZANNE KIME, NORTH DAKOTA: Suzanne Kime, Department
Commander of North Dakota. The Department of North Dakota that for over 35 years has
enrolled the highest percentage of veterans into The American Legion, and has also hosted
the World Series in 1995 and two times previous, is very proud to present and second the
nomination, of our friend from across the Red River, Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JAMES E. MEYERS, OHIO: Jim Meyers, Delegation
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
175
Chairman from the Department of Ohio, home of the largest Boys State in the Nation,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, OKLAHOMA: Oklahoma proudly seconds the motion
for the nomination of Mr. Ludwig.
DELEGATE WILLIAM G. BOYER, OREGON: Oregon. This is Bill Boyer, Past
Department Commander, I second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE ALFRED PIROLLI, PENNSYLVANIA: Pennsylvania, Alfred Pirolli,
Past National Executive Committeeman and a Delegate to the 77th Annual Convention,
proudly seconds the nomination for Daniel A. Ludwig.
DELEGATE GIL V. ALDEA, PHILIPPINES: Mr. Chairman and fellow Delegates, I’m
Gil Aldea, Department Commander of the Philippines, proudly, honorably and are
privileged to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE ANIBAL CASTRO-FIRPI, PUERTO RICO: Anibal Castro-Firpi,
Department Commander for the island Puerto Rico, proudly casts 16 votes to Mr. Dan
Ludwig for National Commander in 1995-1996.
DELEGATE JAMES J. CONVERSE, RHODE ISLAND: Jim Converse, NECman
from the Department of Rhode Island. The Delegation from the Department of Rhode Island
is proud to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig as our next National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN W. M. MCLAUGHLIN, SOUTH CAROLINA: Mr.
Commander, W. M. McLaughlin, Past Department Commander and Delegation Chairman,
is proud to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE DON MASON, SOUTH DAKOTA: Mr. Chairman, Don Mason,
Alternate National Executive Committeeman, Acting Delegation Chairman, the State of
South Dakota is very proud to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOE W. YOUNG, TENNESSEE: Mr. Chairman, Joe
Young, Delegation Chairman from the Volunteer State of Tennessee, is proud to second the
nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM C. FARMER, TEXAS: Bill Farmer,
Delegate and Chairman of the great state of Texas the first state to pass the resolution on the
Flag, not once but twice, proudly endorses Dan for the high office of National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DALE BROCKBANK, UTAH: Dale Brockbank as
Chairman of our Delegation, am proud to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig, and
welcome you to Salt Lake City for our next National Convention.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN GEORGE BILLE, VERMONT: Mr. Commander,
George Bille, Delegate Chairman from Vermont, on behalf of the veterans of the great state
of Vermont, home of the Green Mountain Boys, is proud to second the nomination of Dan
Ludwig for Commander 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RICHARD D. SMITH, WASHINGTON: Dick Smith,
Past Department Commander, Chairman of this Delegation, proudly support Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE FORREST SIMPSON, WEST VIRGINIA: Forrest Simpson, Delegate
from the State of West Virginia, home of Past National Commander Miles Epling, who
cannot be with us this year because of illness, proudly seconds the nomination of Daniel
Ludwig.
DELEGATE RUSSELL H. HANSETER, WISCONSIN: Mr. Chairman, Russ
Hanseter, Commander, Department of Wisconsin, The Badger State, proudly seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig of our great neighboring state of Minnesota. Dan is our man for
National Commander.
176
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN TODD E. WHITE, WYOMING: Todd White,
Delegation Chairman from the equality state of Wyoming, supports and seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Mr. Commander, that completes the roll call.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE DAVID BARNEY, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, David Barney,
Department of New York. In view of the fact that there is but one candidate for National
Commander, I move that we suspend the rules of this convention, close nominations and that
the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote for the entire delegate strength of this
convention, and that Daniel A. Ludwig, Department of Minnesota, be elected National
Commander by acclamation.
I now make this first motion. Mr. Commander, I move that we suspend the rules of the
convention pertaining to the election of the National Commander and the nomination of the
election of the National Vice Commanders, which rules shall be reinstated at the conclusion
of the election for National Vice Commanders.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. There
is a motion before us to suspend the rules of the convention pertaining to the election of the
National Commander and the nomination and election of the National Vice Commanders,
which rules shall automatically be reinstated at the conclusion of the election of National
Vice Commanders. The motion is non-debatable and requires a two-thirds vote.
All those in favor signify by the sign of aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 1.
DELEGATE DALE BROADWAY, (UTAH): Mr. Commander, Dale Broadway from
the Delegation of Utah. I move the nomination for the office of National Commander be
closed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. The
motion to close nominations is non-debatable and requires a two-thirds vote.
All those in favor signify by saying aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE SIMMONS, (VERMONT): Mr. Commander, Doc Simmons, duly elected
delegate from the State of Vermont. I move that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast
one vote representing the entire delegate strength of this convention, and that Daniel A.
Ludwig be elected National Commander by acclamation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? Hearing a second.
There is a motion before us that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote
representing the entire delegate strength of this convention, and that Daniel A. Ludwig be
elected National Commander by acclamation. All those favor of the motion signify by
saying aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: As National Adjutant, I cast one vote
representing the entire delegate strength of this convention for the election of Daniel A.
Ludwig of Minnesota as the National Commander of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As National Commander and Chairman
of this convention, I declare Daniel A. Ludwig elected National Commander of The
American Legion. Congratulations.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Will the Sergeant-at-Arms assist as the
new National Commander of The American Legion is escorted to the platform by Bill
Barbknecht and Lloyd Ricker.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
177
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Past National
Commander John Geiger for the purpose of administering the oath of office to our new
National Commander.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Commander, this is a very important
moment in this history of The American Legion as we commence another year of service
to our God and Country. As I obligate this National Commander, I ask each of you
American Legionnaires and members of the Auxiliary to personally and privately pledge
yourself to carry out faithfully this year the objectives The American Legion is assigning to
this new National Commander. So, in your hearts and minds, join with us as we introduce
to the American Legion our new National Commander.
Commander, congratulations on your election. If you are prepared to assume the
responsibilities of National Commander, you will please raise your right hand and repeat
after me giving your full name.
I, Daniel A. Ludwig, do solemnly pledge myself, to perform faithfully and
impartially, the duties of the office of National Commander of The
American Legion. I further pledge that I will support and defend the
Constitution of the United States of America, and the National Constitution
and By-Laws of The American Legion. And I do not subscribe to the
principles of any group opposed to our form of government, so help me
God.
NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Commander, congratulations to you and your
family.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I present to you the 1995-96 National Commander of The
American Legion, Daniel A. Ludwig of Minnesota.
ACCEPTANCE SPEECH
Daniel A. Ludwig, Minnesota
National Commander
1995-1996
[ Commander Ludwig’s speech was often interrupted with applause.]
First of all, I would like to thank Past National Commander Judge Dan Foley for
nominating me. I would also like to thank Tony Jordan and ‘Butch’ Miller for their
seconding speeches. I’m also grateful to Past National Commander John Geiger for
administering the Oath of Office. And most of all, I want to thank each of you for the great
privilege to serve as National Commander.
I proudly accept and promise to serve this great organization and every Legionnaire
to the best of my ability. I have the highest regard and appreciation for Bill Detweiler, his
leadership and his counsel. I will do my best to carry on with the many important things he
has accomplished during his outstanding year as National Commander.
And now I want you to meet my wonderful wife, Mary, and our fine children, Ann and
John. I certainly would have not come to this moment without their love, their
understanding and their support. Also here with me is my sister, Mary, and her husband,
Ron Sadlowsky.
Permit me to say thank you to Post 54 in Red Wing, Minnesota, and the entire
178
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
Minnesota Legion family for their encouragement and their support. It means so very much
to me. I’m also most grateful for the friendship and assistance of my aid, Jerry Diercks and
his wife, Rosie, as well as my campaign secretary, Shirley Perkins, and her husband, Bob,
and my campaign chairman, Don Shradel.
Each one of these people I mentioned has one thing in common with each other and
with all of you. They believe in service, service to their families and to one another, to The
American Legion, to their communities and to our nation. That’s because they’re part of
The American Legion family. Service is not just an idea, it is not just a word. Service is
action, service is being involved. It’s assisting veterans and their families, it’s helping
youngsters to become good citizens. Service is making our communities better places to
live. And it’s about keeping our nation strong and free.
The Legion is about doing what is necessary to make all these things happen. We’ve
been doing it for 76 years. Our main theme this year sums up everything I’m talking about.
The American Legion is still serving America. I repeat, the American Legion is still serving
America.
My remarks today will not be lengthy. However I’m going to briefly mention four
things that are critically important to us at this time. The first is absolutely essential to
everything that we do, for without it we cannot keep on serving America. We need the
strength of numbers. I’m talking about membership, and I’m going to talk about it all year
long. Our ability to carry out the great programs we’ve had for so many years for veterans,
for children and youth, for the community and for America depends on one thing our
strength of membership.
For many years, we have had strength and influence at home and on Capitol Hill for
one reason only. We are the largest veterans’ organization there is, and everyone knows we
represent the broad cross-section of America from all walks of life including all political,
economic, religious and racial backgrounds. We must maintain that strength and influence.
The recent decrease in our membership is over. We shall turn it around this year.
Each and every Legionnaire has to be an active, person-to-person recruiter, and we
must recognize that the makeup of our membership is going to be changing. There are more
young veterans including women veterans as well as current active duty servicemen and
women who are all eligible to join The American Legion. We need to seek out every
eligible veteran, young or old, male or female, regardless of race, creed or color. We need
to recruit them as active members, and we must make them feel welcome as part of The
American Legion family. We must also encourage them to play a leading role in our
organization.
At this time, our Posts must play an active role in the lives of these young veterans as
well as all our members. These are our sons and grandsons, our daughters and
granddaughters. They face the same problems and needs as we and all previous generations
who served and fought for their country. These newer veterans deserve the opportunities
provided by a decent GI Bill just like veterans of days gone by.
The American Legion is a place where they can find support for all these things. Our
Posts must be a place where they can help their community, where veterans can help other
veterans, and where they can help themselves. American Legion Posts must become
sanctuaries for active duty men and women who need a place to call home. Wherever they
go, the Legion welcome mat must be out. That’s how we’ll gain new members, that’s how
we’ll maintain our strength and our influence. Legionnaires, 1996 will be the year we go
back over the 3 million mark in membership!
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
179
While the character of our membership may be changing, let us not forget that for over
50 years The American Legion has been fortunate to have at its core a generation of the most
patriotic and service-minded veterans that history has ever known, the veterans of World
War II. We are now coming to the conclusion of the five-year period commemorating the
50th anniversary of World War II. This National Convention has been totally dedicated to
them and their honorable service in that great war. The World War II veterans have been
the mainstay of this organization for a long time. They have made certain that we have
steadfastly carried on with the principles and the programs that come from the vision of our
Legion founders, the veterans of World War I. But it is up to every one of us, no matter
where or when we served, to carry on that legacy and to pass it on to the new veterans who
join us.
A few weeks ago, I was proud to attend the dedication of the memorial to the Korean
War veterans. We all know that’s been called ‘the forgotten war.’ We in The American
Legion do not forget any war or any veteran, whether it be from World War I, World War
II, Korea, Vietnam, Lebanon, Granada, Panama or the Persian Gulf. By our very preamble,
we preserved the memories and incidents of our associations in the great wars, because a
veteran is a veteran regardless of the branch or period of service. None should be slighted.
And all should be made welcome in The American Legion.
Taking care of veterans is a principle reason for The American Legion’s existence, and
veterans’ health care has been one of our primary concerns. For too long, the VA health
care system has struggled because of too little money and too many complicated eligibility
rules. Many veterans who would use the VA health care system are turned away because
of these restrictions. The American Legion has constantly lobbied Congress to give VA
enough money to provide the type of medical care that veterans deserve. But the VA budget
which Congress approves each year doesn’t even begin to keep pace with the rising cost of
medical care.
Another problem is that the VA is not permitted to receive money from insurance, such
as Medicare or Medicaid when it treats eligible veterans who are covered by these programs.
Five years ago, The American Legion suggested a plan to improve the VA health care
system and reform its unfair eligibility rules. Those proposals were contained in our ‘Gold
Book’ and our ‘Silver Book.’
At this convention, Resolution Numberl41 contains proposed legislation language to
achieve this new, revolutionary reform of the entire VA health care system. This new
proposal completely revamps the way VA delivers health care to our nation’s veterans. It
would do away with those unfair and restrictive eligibility rules in order to open up a system
to all veterans and their families. And it would provide new methods of funding. This
proposal will be among our top priorities when I testify before the House and Senate
Veterans Affairs Committee later this month.
Finally, I want to say a few words about our Number 1 priority, our campaign for a
Constitutional Amendment to protect our flag from willful, physical desecration. We have
come a long way in the last six years. But the toughest part of our fight still lies ahead. The
vote in the U.S. Senate on the flag amendment is likely to be taken soon, and just because
the measure was overwhelmingly approved in the House of Representatives in June doesn’t
mean we can relax and expect an easy victory in the Senate.
Far from it. We’ve got to keep working until we get the 67 votes we need for Senate
approval. You’ve already heard much about the details of our mission and which Senators
we must convince to join us. But we must all go home from this convention determined to
180
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
contact our Senators by phone and by mail, regardless of whether they have announced their
support or not. In fact, you still have a chance to stop by the Citizens Flag Alliance phone
bank and postcard station in the convention center to make those contacts.
Solidify and reaffirm your Senator’s support and be sure to thank them for their
backing, even if you have done it before. Or persuade them to approve the proposed
amendment, to send back to the states allowing the voice of the people to be heard through
the ratification process, mindful that the Constitution must change with the times. A
hallmark of this democracy is to keep government close to the people.
The overwhelming number of American people support us in this endeavor. We are
so close to victory. Protecting the American Flag from physical desecration shall be our
greatest victory. We must press forward. This achievement will let everyone know that The
American Legion is still serving America.
Again, I thank you for the confidence and the trust you have placed in me. God bless
you, God bless The American Legion and may God bless America.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE PAUL A. MORIN, (MASSACHUSETTS): Mr. Commander, Paul A.
Morin, Delegate, Department of Massachusetts. Since the rules of this convention have
been suspended, I move that the nominations for the Office of National Vice Commander
be made from the floor of this convention. I so move.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? All those in favor
signify by the sign of Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone 1.
. .. Entertaining nominations for National Vice Commander.
DELEGATE KEN LAMOW, (IOWA): Mr. Chairman, Ken Lamow, Delegate
Chairman from the State of Iowa, wishes to yield the microphone to Ken Danielson for the
purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: You are recognized the purpose of a
nomination.
DELEGATE KEN DANILSON, (IOWA): As a duly elected Delegate from the
Department of Iowa, I have the distinct honor to nominate Keith Baker, a dedicated
Legionnaire to the high office of Vice Commander of The American Legion.
Keith was born and raised in rural Iowa. He entered military service in September,
1946, and served until February, 1969. Keith worked his way up through the ranks and
achieved the grade of Major and a Senior Pilot rating. His service in Vietnam in 1966 and
1967 earned him the Air Medal with five oak leaf clusters and the Distinguished Flying
Cross. In 1969, Keith retired to a small farm in northwest Iowa.
While a farmer, Keith also served as a state representative in the Iowa legislature, as
mayor of the city of Linn Grove, Boyna County supervisor and as a Director of the Iowa
Department of Veteran Affairs. He has since returned to his farm where he and his wife,
Betty, run a Christmas tree operation.
Keith is an active, paid-up-for-life member and has served in many positions with the
local post, county, department and national Legion organizations.
At the district level, he was 9th District Commander, 1979-80, served on the
Resolutions, Legislative and Constitutional Committees and presently serves as chairman
of the district POW/MIA Committee and is district Boys State Chairman.
In the Iowa Department, Keith has served as Chairman of the Internal Security
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
181
Committee, National Affairs Commission and the Legislative Commission. He presently
serves as chairman of the POW/MIA Committee and is a member of the Long-Range
Planning Committee. He serves on the board of directors of The American Legion Bible
Foundation and has been an Iowa Boys State counselor for the past nine years.
On the national level, Keith has served on the Foreign Relations Commission since
1976 and has been vice chairman of that commission since 1981. He is chairman of the Far
East Foreign Affairs Subcommittee within the commission and served as chair of the United
Nations study group. He is a past chairman of the national POW/MIA Committee, serving
in that position since its inception in 1981 to 1991. He has attended every National
Convention of The American Legion since 1974.
Keith presently resides in Linn Grove, Iowa, with his wife, Betty. They have three
grown children and four grandsons. On behalf of the Iowa Legion, it is both an honor and
privilege to place in nomination, Keith Baker for the high office of National Vice
Commander of The American Legion for the year 1995-96.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Keith Baker’s name has been placed in
nomination for the Office of National Vice Commander.
Any other nominations?
Microphone 6.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DONALD COLE, JR., MAINE: Comrade Commander,
Donald Cole, Delegate Chairman, Department Commander for this convention. Great state
of Maine, home of Past National Commander Bill Rogers, requests permission for Maine’s
Ralph Smart to approach the podium for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Permission is granted for the purpose of
a nomination.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RALPH SMART, MAINE: Thank you, Commander
Detweiler, Commander Ludwig, National Officers, Delegates and guests. It’s with great
pride and extreme pleasure to present in nomination for the National Vice Commander the
name of a Korean and Vietnam Era veteran, a 22 year retiree of the United States Air Force.
Maine’s candidate has been an active Legionnaire at all levels. He served as Maine’s
Department Commander in 1980-81; Department Service Officer in 1987; and Alternate
Executive Committeeman, 1988 and 1990. He is currently serving as Maine’s NEC, a
position he’s held since 1990. He currently serves as the Vice Chairman of the National
Legislative Council.
‘Chick’ is married. He and his wife have four grown children, and seven
grandchildren.
‘Chick’ is a dedicated Legionnaire with a deep and sincere desire to serve The
American Legion from a National level as a National Vice Commander. He wants to bring
to The American Legion, his deep and abiding spirit of comradeship. His legislative and
membership experience will help him bring an exciting voice to these programs.
On behalf of the 27,000 Legionnaires of the Department of Maine, I wish to place in
nomination the name of a Legion member from Post 202 in Topsham, Maine, William L.
Ciciotte.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of William L. Ciciotte has
been placed in nomination for National Vice Commander.
Microphone 4.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM BOYER, OREGON: Mr. Commander, my
name is Bill “Boyer, Delegate Chairman from the Department of Oregon. I would ask that
the Chair please recognize our National Executive Committeeman, T. Les Galloway, for the
182
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: T. Les Galloway is recognized for the
purpose of a nomination.
NECman T. LES GALLOWAY, OREGON: Commander Detweiler, Commander
Ludwig, National Officers, both past and present, my fellow Delegates, alternates and
guests. My name is T. Les Galloway. I am a duly authorized Delegate from the great
Department of Oregon.
It is indeed an honor and a special privilege for me this afternoon to present a great
friend and fellow Legionnaire from the Department of Oregon to the high office of National
Vice Commander.
Robert D. "Bob" Scott is a 33 year member of Sanian Post 51 in Lebanon, Oregon. A
U.S. Air Force veteran where he served from 1952 to 1965 as a flight mechanic and line
chief during the Korean and the Vietnam Eras.
Bob has served Post 51 in many capacities, including Judge Advocate,
Sergeant-At-Arms, Chaplain, First and Second Vice Commander, and was a Post All-TimeHigh Commander in 1978-79. He has served equally as well on the District level, including
Rehab Chairman, Legislative Chairman, Judge Advocate, District Vice Commander, and
was an All Time High District Commander in 1979-80.
Bob has served the Department of Oregon on many commissions and committees, and
was elected Department Vice Commander in 1981, and served as Department Commander
in 1982-83.
Bob is currently serving as the Chairman of the Citizens Flag Alliance Team in Oregon.
He was instrumental in getting the Oregon legislature just this year to pass a memorializing
resolution to protect the Flag from desecration. He has served the National organization on
the Distinguished Guest Committee, National Legislative Council, Children and Youth
Commission, and has served as Oregon’s Alternate NECman for the past nine years.
His community activities have been many and varied, and 1 will only mention a few,
including the City of Lebanon Planning Commission; City Councilman; Citizen Veteran of
the Year; manager of the Lebanon Chamber of Commerce, and was appointed by three
different governors in Oregon on the Advisory Committee to the Director of the Oregon
Department of Veterans Affairs Board.
In addition, he has served as Chairman of the Veterans Rehab Centers in Oregon,
California and Washington. He is a member of the United Veterans Group of Oregon, the
DAV, Air Force Sergeants Association, a Past Governor of the Pacific Northwest District
of Optimist International, covering Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Alaska and British
Columbia.
He and his wife Clara, who is very active in the American Legion Auxiliary, are the
proud parents of two children, Catherine and Larry, and have seven grandchildren and three
great grandchildren. In addition, Bob and his wife Clara raised 23 foster children. He is
self-employed and owns and operates Scott Enterprises and Marketing in Lebanon.
His great love for The American Legion and its programs, and his qualifications and
past record of achievements, assures us a strong capable leadership. It is, therefore, my
pleasure and honor to place in nomination the name of Robert D. "Bob" Scott for the office
of National Vice Commander for the 1995-1996 Legion year.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Robert D. Scott has been
placed in nomination for National Vice Commander.
Microphone 6.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
183
DELEGATE DON MASON, SOUTH DAKOTA: Mr. Commander, I’m Don Mason,
Delegate from South Dakota, and I request the Chair recognize Donald Clarke, National
Executive Committeeman from South Dakota, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Don Clarke is recognized for the purpose
of a nomination..
NECman DONALD T. CLARKE, SOUTH DAKOTA: National Commander
Detweiler, distinguished guests and friends, and the Delegates to this 77th Annual
Convention assembled in Indianapolis this afternoon. It is with a great deal of pride to have
the rare privilege to place in nomination for the high office of National Vice Commander
a close friend of mine, as well as an outstanding Legionnaire, who has already proven
himself as an outstanding Legion leader in our Department and also on the National level.
It is with a great deal of pleasure this afternoon that I place in nomination to this
Convention, Darrel Haskell for National Vice Commander.
I’m going to highlight just a few of the achievements that Darrel has already
accomplished as a Legionnaire and a community leader in his home community in Conde,
South Dakota.
Darrel served as our State Commander in 1986, the year that Dale Renaud was our
National Commander. Darrel is a 42 year veteran and continuous member of The American
Legion in South Dakota. He has continuous membership and has a Life membership in our
department.
Those years have been veiy busy years for Darrel. After completing all of the offices
in his Post, District, Area, and becoming our Department Commander in 1967, he began
editing and publishing a Post paper for his Post. And he has continued to do that for 25
years, finally conceding and delegating that duty to a young Vietnam veteran in his Legion
Post.
Yes, he has held offices on all the levels in our Department. Darrel served on South
Dakota’s 50th Anniversary Committee and our Spirit of ‘76 Committee, chairing both of
those committees. He was Chairman of South Dakota’s Vietnam Era study in 1984,
working with John Sommer, who went on to become the Executive Director of our National
Office in Washington, D.C. He is a member of the National American Legion Press
Association and has served as their Sergeant-At-Arms.
This Legionnaire, friend and comrade of mine, has been a Delegate to more than 20
National Conventions with more and more of the many National assignments that go with
those Conventions.
Darrel has served for many years as a member of the National
Cemetery Committee.
Darrel was bom and raised in Conde, South Dakota, and he’s lived there all of his life.
His profession is in the field of agriculture. We call that farming in South Dakota; it is a
very demanding way to make a living. But Darrel has always found the time to be an active
community leader, serving on the many committees and the many assignments that come
from the town and the community. For example he has been on the Board of Education and
has served as Chairman of the Trustees of the United Methodist Church in Conde.
And perhaps best of all, he and his wife Joyce have five children and eleven
grandchildren. I know personally that Joyce and his family are dedicated and active in their
Legion and Auxiliary activities wherever they may be.
We in the Department of South Dakota are very, very proud of Darrel Haskell. We
know that with his dedication and his talent, he will make an outstanding National Vice
Commander. He will contribute much to National Commander Ludwig’s upcoming year
184
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
as he joins Dan’s team. It is now my distinct pleasure to officially place in nomination the
name of Darrel Haskell for National Vice Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Darrel Haskell has been
placed in nomination.
Microphone 4.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOE YOUNG, TENNESSEE: Mr. Commander, Joe
Young, Delegate Chairman from the Department of Tennessee. We request you recognize
our National Executive Committeeman, John L. Jones, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes John Jones for the
purpose of a nomination for National Vice Commander.
NECman JOHN L. JONES, TENNESSEE: I am John Jones, the NECman from the
state of Tennessee. I place in nomination Ralph J. Reel, a Past Department Commander
from the Volunteer State of Tennessee, and wish him well. I know he will do a first class
job that Vice Commanders are expected to do.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Ralph Reel has been placed
in nomination.
DELEGATE THOMAS HENDERSON, INDIANA: Tom Henderson, Delegate from
Indiana. Mr. Commander, I move that nominations for the office of National Vice
Commander be closed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? All those in favor
signify by the sign of Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE JOHN A. BRIEDAN, TEXAS: Mr. Commander, John Briedan,
Department Commander of the great state of Texas, and a duly authorized Delegate to this
Convention. I move that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote for the entire
Delegate strength of this Convention, and that Keith Baker from the Department of Iowa;
William Ciciotte from the Department of Maine; Robert Scott from the Department of
Oregon; Darrel Haskell from the Department of South Dakota, and Ralph Reel from the
Department of Tennessee be elected National Vice Commanders by acclamation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. Any
discussion? All those in favor say Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. The Adjutant will cast
one vote.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: As National Adjutant of The American
Legion, I cast one vote representing the entire Delegate strength of this Convention for Keith
Baker of Iowa; William L. Ciciotte of Maine; Robert D. Scott of Oregon; C. Darrel Haskell
of South Dakota, and Ralph J. Reel of Tennessee for the offices of National Vice
Commander of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As Chairman of this Delegation to this
Convention, I now declare the following Legionnaires have been elected National Vice
Commanders of The American Legion:
Keith Baker of Iowa.
William L. Ciciotte of Maine.
Robert D. Scott of Oregon.
C. Darrel Haskell of South Dakota.
Ralph J. Reel of Tennessee.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
185
I now call on Harlowe Johnson of Minnesota to present the Colors to our Incoming
National Commander. Mr. Johnson.
DELEGATE HARLOWE JOHNSON, (MINNESOTA): Delegates, it’s a great personal
privilege and honor to be representing the great Department of Minnesota in this
presentation ceremony. The audience will please rise as the Color Guard presents the Colors
to the Incoming National Commander of The American Legion.
... Hand Salute.
DELEGATE HARLOWE JOHNSON, (MINNESOTA): Audience may be seated.
National Commander Ludwig, all your comrades join in congratulating you upon your
election as National Commander. We, in Minnesota, are extremely proud to have one of our
distinguished Legionnaires as National Commander of this great organization. By your
dedication and unselfish service, you have brought honor to your Post, to the Third District,
and to the Department of Minnesota. We know that you will continue this dedication as you
embark upon your duties as our National Commander.
We presented these Colors, the glorious Flag of the United States, and the National
Colors of The American Legion, guarding it against the forces that would physically
desecrate it in the name of human rights. As you assume the duties and responsibilities of
your office, we are confident that you will use all your talents and efforts to maintain the
respect and the dignity that our flag deserves.
We are fully confident that in your hands, the flag of our country and the National
Colors of The American Legion will continue to wave ever so proudly from your year of
service.
Commander Dan, take with you our best wishes for God’s blessing and protection as
you answer the summons to this call to service as our National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER-ELECT LUDWIG: To my good friend, Harlow
Johnson, thank you for presenting my Colors to me.
Keenly aware of the service and sacrifice of those National Commanders before me and
mindful of the rich history of The American Legion, I accept these Colors with pride and
with humility. I pledge to all assembled here that I will cherish and protect them always.
And I further pledge that while I have life, these Colors will not run and while I have breath
these Colors shall not touch the ground. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Chair recognizes the Commander of
Minnesota for a presentation.
COMMANDER PERSING: Mary, on behalf of the extended family from the
Department of Minnesota, I present these flowers to you. Congratulations and good luck in
the coming year.
MRS. LUDWIG: Thank you one and all.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Fellow Legionnaires, this is a special
time in the business of this convention. The time when we will meet the distinguished lady
who will lead nearly one million patriotic women over the next year. You can imagine my
honor in presenting a fellow resident of Louisiana to you. I believe she will be a highly
visible leader, md will focus her efforts on the incoming year toward women’s shelters,
caring for the elderly and disabled, community housing needs and youth projects.
Please welcome the newly elected national president of the American Legion Auxiliary
from Lake Charles Williamson Unit No. 1 in Louisiana, Mrs. Syble Deshotel. Syble.
186
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
SYBLE DESHOTEL
American Legion Auxiliary President
1995-1996
Before I present some special people who came with me this morning, I would like to
tell you that as Bill and I were beating the bushes and acting like candidates, someone asked
me to serve on another committee in the same year? My answer was, oh, no. We want The
American Legion to have a dynamic man from Louisiana one year and then go in on the
second year and have a President from the Department of Louisiana. By the time we get
finished with you, you’ll all be Cajuns.
With me today is my husband I.J., my veteran and my support, my best friend.
Also is the newly installed National Vice President Phyllis Buckman of New York and
the National Secretary of the American Legion Auxiliary, Peggy Sappenfield, from the
Department of Indiana.
Today is a day for pledges and oaths of office. I come to you today to pledge my
abilities and my knowledge as the American Legion Auxiliary’s National President, but I
also pledge that as one family, the almost 1 million members of the American Legion
Auxiliary will be at your side to work in all the programs and activities of both of our
organizations. I think we have some wonderful things to do as we climb on that train
heading toward the 21st century. It’s a fast-running train, but I think we can handle it.
Dan, I congratulate you. Legionnaires, I congratulate you on your selection as National
Commander. Dan and I have had a chance to get to know each other, and I’m sure as we
travel, he and I and Mary and I.J. will get to know each other so much better. But I have
already coined him as a Legionnaire’s Legionnaire.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Madame President, would you please
remain with us for a few moments. I want the delegates of this convention to greet you and
our newly elected National Commander. Ladies and Gentlemen, National Commander Dan
Ludwig and National President Syble Deshotel.
NATIONAL COMMANDER-ELECT COMMANDER LUDWIG: Ladies and
Gentlemen, I truly look forward to working with this wonderful, gracious lady and all the
ladies of the Auxiliary as we continue to work together as a Legion and Legion Auxiliary
family.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Immediately following the adjournment
of this meeting there will be a Post-NEC meeting right after the convention. Is there any
further business to come before this convention?
Please uncover as the outgoing National Chaplain, the Reverend Roy Pryor, Jr., of
South Carolina offers the Benediction.
BENEDICTION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, South Carolina
National Chaplain
Let us pray.
Most Holy Father, You have granted us a wonderful year under the capable leadership
of Commander William Detweiler and his capable staff. We offer our sincere thanks for
this, and now, we, as a body at this time, ask You to give unto our new Commander Daniel
Ludwig and his staff, Your blessings. That, as they work together under their leadership,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
187
we may continue to help others in this great organization, The American Legion. So now
I say unto you, go in peace, my comrades and friends, and may the God of peace watch over
you and keep you, not only this day, but forever more. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Color Guard will retire the Flag of
the United States. The delegates will stand at right-hand salute on my command.
... Hand Salute.
With great pleasure, I now declare the 77th Annual National Convention of The
American Legion adjourned, sine die.
... At 1:12 p.m., the 77th Annual National Convention of The American Legion adjourned.
189
ANNOUNCEMENT OF ANNUAL AWARDS
National American Legion Distinguished Service Medal Award: Awarded annually for
outstanding service to the nation and to the programs of The American Legion.
WINNER: The Enola Gay Crew
The Henry D. Lindsley Trophy: Awarded annually to the Department attaining the
highest percentage of membership over its preceding year's membership by March 31.
WINNER: North Dakota (92.45%)
The North Carolina Trophy: Awarded annually to the Department, not included among
the several state Departments or the Department of the District of Columbia, attaining the
highest percentage of membership as of March 31, over its preceding year's membership.
WINNER: Mexico (126.62%)
General Henri Gouraud Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department in each of six
categories established by the National Membership and Post Activities Committee, each of
said Department having been the first in its respective category to attain or exceed its
nationally assigned membership quota (effective 1986).
WINNERS:
Category None
Category IINone
Category IIINone
Category IVNone
Category VNone
Category VINone
The O. L. Bodenhamer Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department designated to lead
the parade at the time of the ensuing National Convention.
WINNER: Delaware (99.24%)
General John J. Pershing Honor Award: Awarded annually to that Department having
the greatest percentage of its posts receiving the Honor Ribbon for having 100 percent or
more, of the post's previous year's membership enrolled for the coming year by December
31, and having reported such achievement to National Headquarters by not later than
January 31.
WINNER: Delaware (31.25%)
The Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion Trophy: Awarded annually to
that Detachment of Sons of The American Legion in each of three membership size
categories (I - 1-999 members; II- 1,000-2,000 members; III - 3,000 members or more), each
of said Detachments attaining the greatest percentage of increase over previous year's
membership when compared with all Detachments in its category.
1994 WINNERS: (I)
Arkansas
162.7%
(II) West Virginia
129.2%
(III) Pennsylvania
113.5%
The Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department which has
190
rendered the most outstanding service during the year to the program of the Boy Scouts of
America.
WINNER: Maryland
The Ralph T. O'Neil Education Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department within the
continental limits in the United States showing the greatest Americanism activity in use of
The American Legion School Medal Awards.
WINNER: Florida
William Randolph Hearst Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department attaining the
greatest number of percentage points compiled from information contained in the
Consolidated Post Reports, and supporting Department narrative.
WINNER: Vermont
Spafford National Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department of The American
Legion having within its jurisdiction the winner of the National High School Oratorical
Contest.
WINNER: New York (Aron Egner, Ballston Lake, NY)
The Howard P. Savage Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department having the baseball
team which becomes the Champion as a result of playing in The American Legion World
Series.
WINNER: Hawaii (Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii), outside sponsor
Commissioner of Baseball Trophy: Awarded annually at the Major League World Series
to that baseball team which becomes the National Champion as a result of playing in The
American Legion World Series.
WINNER: Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Dr. Irvin L. "Click" Cowger Memorial R.B.I. Award: Awarded annually to The
American Legion Baseball player who is credited with the most runs batted in by the official
scorers of the respective regional tournaments and World Series of American Legion
Baseball.
WINNER:
Bobby Morgan, Post 19, Columbia, TN &
Dorn Crispo, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
Rawlings "Big Stick" Award: Awarded annually to that American Legion Baseball player
having the highest total number of bases as determined by the official scorers of the
respective regional tournaments and World Series of American Legion Baseball.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Bob Feller Award: Awarded annually to that American Legion Baseball player recording
the greatest number of strikeouts during the regional tournaments and World Series of
American Legion Baseball.
WINNER: Woody Heath, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
Jack Williams Memorial Leadership Award: Awarded annually to the manager and
191
coach of the national championship team, as representative of the adult leadership Jack
Williams stressed during his lifetime.
WINNERS:
Manager Alan Higuchi, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Coaches Garrett Mago & Garret Yukumoto Aiea Legion Baseball,
Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Louisville Slugger Trophy: Plaque is presented to recipient, or designated representative,
by appropriate official upon the conclusion of The American Legion Baseball World Series.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
George W. Rulon Baseball Player of the Year: Plaque is presented to recipient by
appropriate official upon conclusion of The American Legion Baseball World Series.
Citation is presented to recipient at a special Hall of Fame ceremony at Cooperstown, NY,
the following summer.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
James F. Daniel, Jr. Memorial Sportsmanship Award: Awarded to The American
Legion Baseball player participating in the World Series that represents the principle of
good sportsmanship emphasized by the program.
WINNER: Woody Heath, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
American Legion Baseball Graduate of The Year Award: Presented to the major league
baseball player who played American Legion Baseball as a teenager and best exemplifies
the principles and purposes of the program in sportsmanship, citizenship, general good
conduct, integrity, and playing ability.
WINNER: Bob Tewksbury, Texas Ranger
Ford C. Frick Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department having within its jurisdiction
the runner-up team in the National Finals of The American Legion Baseball program.
WINNER: Washington (outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA)
The Lemuel Bolles Trophy: Awarded annually to that band winning first prize in
competition with all other bands during the annual National Convention.
WINNER:
American Legion Band of the Tonawandas, Post 264, Tonawanda,
New York
The Arch M. Cantrall Trophy: Awarded annually to that American Legion Band winning
first prize in competition with all other American Legion bands during the annual National
Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER:
American Legion Band of the Tonawandas, Post 264, Tonawanda, New
York
The Four Chaplains Trophy: Awarded annually to the winner of The American Legion
Firing Squad competition at the National Convention.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
The Glen R. Hillis Trophy: Awarded annually to that Color Guard winning first prize in
192
competition with all other Color Guards during the annual National Convention of The
American Legion.
WINNER: Speedway Post 500 Honor Guard; Speedway, Indiana
Emblem Sales Trophy: To be awarded annually to that Junior sponsored Color Guard
winning first prize in competition with all other Junior sponsored Color Guards during the
annual National Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
National Adjutant's Trophy: Awarded annually to that American Legion Firing Squad
winning first prize in competition with all other Firing Squads during the annual National
Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
Fourth Estate Award: Awarded to press, radio, TV, or other communications media; to
associations of same, to owners, executive heads or staff members; such award to be in
recognition of outstanding service to community, state, or nation, which service shall have
been in accordance with or the furtherance of established American Legion policies and
programs.
WINNER:
Marcia Stepanek & Charles J. Lewis,
Hearst Newspapers, Washington
Bureau/Albany Times Union
National Commander's Public Relations Award: Awarded to an outstanding individual
and/or organization for distinguished public service in the field of communications.
WINNER: To be presented at '96 DC Conference
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy: Awarded annually to that State Department
of The American Legion excelling in welfare work for war veterans, providing the
membership of that Department shall be no less than 80% of the membership of the
preceding year.
WINNER: Ohio
The American Legion Military Academy Award: Awarded annually to cadet of the
graduating class at the United States Military Academy with the highest standing in
Chemistry.
WINNER: Garth S. Herbert, West Point, New York
The American Legion Naval Academy Award: Awarded annually to that graduating
midshipman of the United States Naval Academy who stands highest in those English,
History and Government courses taken to complete a Foreign Affairs major.
WINNER: Benjamin A. Shupp, Houston, Texas
The American Legion Coast Guard Academy Award: Awarded annually to that cadet
of the graduating class of the United States Coast Guard Academy who is considered to have
personally excelled in athletics.
WINNER: Cadet Blake L. Novak, New London, CT
193
The American Legion Air Force Academy Award: Awarded annually to that cadet of the
graduating class at the Air Force Academy who demonstrates the highest proficiency in all
academic subjects.
WINNER: Douglas P. Wickert, Beavercreek, Ohio
The American Legion Merchant Marine Academy Award: Awarded annually to that
graduating midshipman of the Merchant Marine Academy, enrolled in the PreCommissioning Seminar Course, and selected by the Academy Faculty, as achieving the
highest grade pertaining to a 1,000 word composition dealing with the subject of National
Security.
WINNER: Award Not Presented in 1995*
* No midshipman fulfilled the criteria for award
Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department giving the highest
degree of support to the ROTC program within its jurisdiction, based on criteria drawn up
by the National Security Commission.
WINNERS: Alabama, Alaska, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia,
Hawaii, Illinois, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Puerto Rico, Rhode
Island, and Vermont
National Department History Contest Awards: Awarded annually at the Fall Meeting
of the National Executive Committee to those contestants entered in the National
Department History Contest having submitted the One-Year History Narrative or Yearbook
of the Department which best meets the standards established for that particular competition.
WINNERS: North Carolina
(One-Year Narrative History)
Hawaii
(One-Year Yearbook History)
National Post History Contest Awards: Awarded annually to those contestants entered
in the National Post History Contest deemed by a duly authorized panel of judges to have
submitted the One-Year History of the Post which best meets the standards established for
the competitions.
WINNERS: Hartford Post 26, White River Jet., Vermont
(One-Year Narrative History)
Kirby Stewart Post 24, Bradenton, Florida
(One-Year Yearbook History)
International Amity Award: Awarded by the National Commander with the advice and
consent of the National Executive Committee at such times and places as may be consistent
and appropriate.
WINNERS: Tae-Wan Chang (Republic of Korea)
Emmanual V. DeOcampo (Philippines)
Yang Ting-Yun (Republic of China)
194
Canadian Friendship Award: Awarded by the National Commander with the advice and
consent of the National Executive Committee at such times and places as may be consistent
and appropriate.
WINNERS: Norman H. Baildham
Tom Barton
Gerald Belanger
Terry Buchanan
Brent G. Burns
Robert Carslaw
Norah Fyfe
Bernard Halstead
Albert Himes
Onesime Lanteigne
Douglas J. Loukes
John William Newman
Robert C. Simser
Department Award for 100% Post Children & Youth Reporting: Awarded annually to
those Departments which achieve 100% of Posts indicating Children & Youth activity on
Consolidated Post reports.
WINNERS: Delaware, Florida, North Dakota, Vermont, & Virginia
Employer of the Year Award for Hiring Veterans: Awarded to an employer in
recognition of outstanding achievement in the employment and retraining of veterans.
1994 WINNERS:
Category I - Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc.; Mid City,
Oklahoma
Category II
Caldwell Machining, Inc.; Emporium,
Pennsylvania
Category III - Southwest Research Institute; San Antonio, Texas
Employment Service Awards: Awarded in three categories: Local Veterans Employment
Representative (LVER) of the Year; Disabled Veterans Outreach Program Specialist
(DVOP) of the Year; Employment Service (ES) Office of the Year.
1994 WINNERS:
LVER of the Year: Joseph A. Monday; Hudson, Florida
DVOP of the Year: Jerry A. Work; Dade City, Florida
ES Office of the Year: Charles City Workforce Center;
Charles City, Iowa
BALANCE SHEET
December 31,1994
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
EXHIBIT A
Current Fund
Cash
Restricted cash
Agent Orange program
Accounts receivable
Emblem Division
Publications Division
Other
Accrued interest on investments
Inventories
Emblem Division
Publications Division
Prepaid expenses and supplies
Prepaid pension expense
Deferred membership expense
Deferred direct membership solicitation expense
Postal deposits
DECEMBER 31
1994
$ 67,901
26,827
12,525
$ 399,584
26,082
49,805
113,182
1,459,188
2,178,926
123,593
123,575
1,790,430
1,776,730
139,405
1,411,246
240,425
148,879
6,247,793
22,356
3,112,304
55,000
1,293,121
272,305
449.211
5,561,158
136,812
3,549,665
55,000
' 15~622.883
15.220 145
Investments
Segregated for Designated Funds
Segregated for Washington, D. C., building
Other
Investment in subsidiary
Investment in affiliate
Property and equipment
Land—Indianapolis parking lot
Washington, D. C„ real estate
Land
Building
Furniture, fixtures, and equipment in
National Headquarters building, Indianapolis, Ind.
Washington. D. C„ building
12,265,338
682,427
17,561,966
100,887
1,018,714
31,629.332
238,3
1993
11,670,800
557,506
14,916,629
21,050
27,165,985
238,359
80,000
4,116,940
8,149,913
1,366,064
13,951,276
(6,464,405)
7,486,871
54,336,348
7,818,655
1,352,825
13,606,779
(5,185,763)
8,421,016
51.209,884
Nonexpendable Funds
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
Cash
Accrued interest on investments
Investments
49,557
14,262
893,316
41,975
14,398
893,316
949,689
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
Cash
Accrued interest on investments
Investments
5,000
101,656
21,019,232
5,000
129,030
17,881,773
$76,419,371
$70,175,376
Accumulated depreciation and amortization
196
18.015.~BS5
See notes to financial statements.
nmmnoaim
Current Fund
Liabilities
Accounts payable
Cash overdraft
Agent Orange program
Deposits on Emblem merchandise sales
Deferred advertising income
Deferred dues income
Deferred income—direct membership solicitation
Accrued vacation benefits
Provision for health insurance liability
Other liabilities
Due to the Restricted Fund
Due to other restricted funds
Total liabilities
Fund balances
Restricted funds
Oratorical Contest Fund
Other restricted funds
Designated funds
The Restricted Fund
The Reserve Fund
Appropriated funds
Unappropriated
Total fund balances
Nonexpendable Funds
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
Fund balance
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
Due to current fund
Fund balance
DECEMBER 31
1994
$ 3,720,381
562,119
12,525
139,183
75,908
20,812,306
673,907
508,809
45,000
301,130
135,064
1993
$2,815,693
49,805
135,204
113,315
14,058,207
877,040
540,608
44,986
661,624
1,075,000
135,088
20,506.570
240,485
6,156,277
234,566
5,597,390
10,047,621
2,217,718
18,662,101
1,615,725
7,072,190
27,350,016
54,336,348
9,452,725
2,218,075
17,502,756
1,567,188
11,633,370
30,703,314
51,209.884
326,809
20,799,079
$70,175,376
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
Unappropriated
STATEMENT OF REVENUE, EXPENSES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCES:
Current Fund, Year Ended December 31,1994
EXHIBIT B, SHEET 1
Appropriated Funds
Designated and Restricted Funds
REVENUE
National dues
Sales of Emblem items
Advertising revenue
Investment income
Direct membership solicitation
Revenue enhancement
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation income
Amounts withdrawn from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Other restricted income
Other income
$17,302,920
6,680,617
8,967,975
773,906
1,767,974
790,057
537,035
985,904
375,016
5,795,682
' 43,977,086
48,637
1993
Total Current Fund
$17,302,920
6,680,617
8,967,975
1,560,737
1.767,974
790,057
537,035
1.122,904
680,565
7,234,656
46.645.440
$16,644,736
6,243,759
7,431,341
1,845,957
1,617,808
709,758
544,071
1,112,055
978,112
8,054,290
45,181,887
4.460.472
8,313,609
1,486,830
5,404,621
12,671,711
766,309
1,216,130
5,921,132
4,333,678
2,378,477
7,586,078
60,078.575
8,307.102
939,106
4,690,437
12,326,028
877,145
1,114,565
5,849,385
3,964,910
2,246,687
6,516,640
46,832,005
(1.840,655)
(3,433,135)
(1,650,118)
$ 786,831
$ 48,537
1994
Total Current Fund
137,000
305,549
1,390,437
2,619,817
EXPENSES
Salaries
Employee benefits
Cost of sales
Direct publication expenses
Executive and staff travel
Commission and committee
Operational
Office and postage expenses
Occupancy
Special projects and programs
8,313,609
1,486,830
5,404,621
12,671,711
766,309
1,216,130
5,921,132
4,333,678
2,378,477
3,125,606
4.460.472
46,618,103
Excess (Deficiency) of Operating
Revenue Over Expenses
Equity in Income (Loss) of Wholly Owned Subsidiary
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses
Fund Balances, Beginning of Year
(1.641,017)
79,837
(1,561,180)
48,537
11,633,370
1,567,188
79,837
20,595
(1,840,655)
(3,353,298)
(1,629,523)
17,502,756
30,703,314
28,046,853
Transfer of funds from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
4,285,984
Transfer of funds
(3,000,000)
Fund Balances, End of Year
$7,072,190
See notes to financial statements.
$18,662,101
$27,350,016
$30,703,314
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
STATEMENT OF REVENUE, EXPENSES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCES:
Designated and Restricted Funds, Year Ended December 31,1994
EXHIBIT B, SHEET 2
Designated Funds
Year Ended December 31
The
Restricted
Fund
Oratorical
Contest
Fund
The
Reserve
Fund
Other
Restricted
Funds
(continued)
REVENUE
$786,831
Investment income
Amounts withdrawn from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Restricted contributions
Other income
137,000
305,549
305,549
1,390,437
1,390,437
1,887,921
2,619,817
4,329,034
4,460,115
EXPENSE
357
Sundry expense
Special projects and programs
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue
Over Expenses
Fund Balances, Beginning of Year
Transfer of funds
Fund Balances, End of Year
See notes to financial statements.
Total
Designated
& Restricted
Funds
4,329,034
594,896
(357)
5,919
(2,441,113)
(1,840,655)
9,452,725
2,218,075
234,566
5,597,390
17,502,756
3,000,000
3,000,000
$6,156,277
$18,662,101
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
Increase (Decrease) in Cash, Year Ended December 31,1994
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
EXHIBIT C
Current Fund
Overseas Graves Decoration Trust
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fees
1994 Total
OPERATING ACTIVITIES
Excess (deficiency) of revenue over expenses
Depreciation charged to operations not requiring cash
Equity in income of subsidiary
(Gain) loss on sale of investments
Loss from sale of fixed assets
Certain working capital transactions
Restricted cash
Accounts receivable
Accrued interest on investments
Inventories
Prepaid expenses and supplies
Deferred expenses
Accounts payable
$(3,353,298)
1,318,354
$ 7,446
$2,783,276
(79,837)
39,047
1,447
(384,129)
(745)
(60,561)
15,812
136
27.374
(86,245)
(386,303)
551,817
904,688
Due to current fund
326,809
$(108,871)
1,318,354
1,299.163
(79,837)
(345,082)
(20,594)
377,820
1.447
24,835
(745)
(60,561)
43.322
350,949
(1.053,157)
54,202
(86,245)
(386,303)
(203.347)
(1,032.303)
551,817
(650,634)
904,688
326,809
Restricted grant
Deposits on emblem merchandise sales
Deferred advertising
3,979
(37,407)
Funds in transit to American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Deferred income
6,550,966
Accrued vacation
Other liabilities
(31,799)
(360,504)
Total provided (used) by operations
4,989,411
7,582
2.753,330
1993 Total
$(562,576)
106,395
3,979
(37,407)
(348,942)
(62,162)
64,969
6,550,966
(2,523)
978,043
(31.799)
950
(360,504)
7,750,323
70,392
(154,815)
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Additions to property and equipment
Proceeds from sale of fixed assets
Transfer of funds from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Purchases of investments
Sales of investments
Total provided (used) by investing activities
(385,816)
(385,816)
160
(254,159)
160
1,329
(19,676,500)
15,253,943
(27,433,542)
24,680,212
(47,110,042)
39,934,155
4,285,984
(27,964,980)
25,500,128
(4,808,213)
(2,753,330)
(7,561,543)
1,568,302
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Payments on restricted fund note
Cash overdrafts
Total used by financing activities
INCREASE(DECREASE) IN CASH
(1,075,000)
562,119
(512,881)
(1,075,000)
(900,000)
562,119
(512,881)
(129,209)
(1,029,209)
(324,101)
384,278
(331,683)
7,582
CASH, BEGINNING OF YEAR
399,584
41,975
5,000
446,559
62,281
CASH,END OF YEAR
$ 67,901
$ 49,557
S 5,000
$ 122,458
$ 446,559
See notes to financial statements.
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT
ACCOUNTING POLICIES
General
The American Legion National Headquarters (the Legion) is a
national veterans' organization which was declared to be a corporate body by an Act of the United States Congress on Sept. 16,
1919.
According to the Original Act and Subsequent Amendments, the
purpose of the Organization is: “To uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace and goodwill
among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of the
earth: to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World
Wars and the other great hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to
cement the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the efforts of its members to mutual helpfulness and service
to their country."
Basis of Presentation
The Legion generally reports for financial statement purposes on
the accrual method of accounting, recognizing income when
earned and expenses when incurred.
The Legion maintains its accounts on a fund accounting basis
wherein the accountability for certain segments of its operations
are presented in specific designated and restricted fund balances.
Further, the Legion has designated certain amounts for future projects or purposes, which amounts are presented as appropriated
funds in the accompanying financial statements.
The revenue and expenses of nonexpendable funds are not included in the Statement of Revenue, Expenses and Changes in Fund
Balances—Current Fund. Instead, they are recorded directly to the
nonexpendable funds involved as set forth in the footnotes to the
financial statements.
The amounts shown for 1993 in the accompanying Statement of
Revenue, Expenses and Changes in Fund Balances—Current Fund
and Statement of Cash Flows are included only to provide a basis
for comparison with 1994 amounts.
Accounts Receivable
The direct charge-off method is used to account for losses in collection of accounts receivable. An allowance for uncollectible
accounts receivable is considered unnecessary by the Legion
because all significant accounts expected to be uncollectible have
been written off.
Inventories
Inventories, which consist of Emblem items held for sale and magazine paper and publication rights, are valued at the lower of cost or
market. Supplies which are not intended for sale are expensed
when purchased.
Investments
Investments are recorded at cost. Premiums or discounts on
investments are generally recognized at the time of disposal or
maturity.
Investment in Subsidiary
The Legion accounts for the investment in common stock of its
wholly owned subsidiary, Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., on the
equity method.
Property and Equipment
Furniture, fixtures and equipment are carried at cost and are depreciated beginning in the month of acquisition on the straight-line
method based on the estimated useful lives of the assets involved.
Leasehold improvements and repairs are expensed when incurred.
In addition to other methods of obtaining new members, the Legion
uses direct mail and other direct marketing approaches. The
income generated from the direct membership solicitation is recognized in the applicable membership period (calendar year) and the
expenses incurred to obtain these memberships are deferred and
written off in the period in which the income is recognized.
The Legion is involved in various revenue enhancement programs.
The revenue and expenses related to the programs are recognized
in the periods to which they apply.
Income from The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
is recorded when received. These receipts are for projects and programs conducted in the year of receipt.
Pension Plan
The Legion has a defined-benefit pension plan covering substantially all of its employees, as well as those of certain affiliated and
subordinated groups. The plan was established in 1944 by vote of
the Legion's National Convention. Contributions to the plan are
made by the Legion and other participating groups on the basis of
annual actuarial valuations.
Federal Income Tax
The Legion is exempt from federal income tax (except on unrelated
business income) under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code.
The Legion is not considered to be a private foundation.
Depreciation on the Washington, D. C., building is computed on the
straight-line method using a 30-year life.
Depreciation expense amounted to $1,318,354 in 1994 and
$1,299,163 in 1993.
Income
Dues are recognized as income in the applicable membership period. which is on a calendar-year basis.
ro
o
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INVESTMENT IN SUBSIDIARY
On Sept. 28, 1990, the Legion purchased all of the outstanding
shares of Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., a corporation engaged
in the creation and management of direct response advertising and
marketing strategies. The Legion has chosen to account for this
investment on the equity method since consolidation would not
necessarily result in meaningful information and since the reporting
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
differences are immaterial. Details of the Legion’s investment in
subsidiary are as follows:
1994
Investment in subsidiary
Original investment.
Loss (9/28/90-12/31/93)
Income (1/1/94-12/31/94)
$101,000
(79.950)
79,837
$101,000
(79,950)
$100,887
' $21,050
Key significant balance sheet and income statement information of Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. is as follows:
Year Ended December 31
Balance sheet information
Accounts receivable—The Amencan Legion
Furniture and fixtures—net
Other assets
Total assets
$296,907
263,574
280,318
~$840,799
$252,091
169,510
249,331
$670,932
Notes payable—The American Legion
Other liabilities
Stockholder's (deficit)
Total liabilities and stockholder's deficit
$339,167
699.118
...(197,486)
.$840,799
$367,254
585.999
(282,321)
0,932
1994
Income statement information
Sales (including sales to The American Legion of $3,369,004 and $4,147,764)
Income from operations
Net income
Accounts receivable—other on the Legion’s balance sheet includes $339,167 due on a note receivable, from Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., bearing interest at 9% Beginning Auqust 1991
Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. began to repay the note, with an original balance of $400,000, in 120 equal monthly installments of $5,000.
The Legion has a sublease agreement with Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. for office space. The lease is a 10-year operating lease which expires in November 2000.
The following is a schedule of future minimum rental payments required under this lease.
Years Ending December 31
i395"
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
'
■
'
~
zzz
'
:
TT30.M0
130.000
130.000
130.000
130.000
130.000
The Legion is an unconditional guarantor of a $188,000 relating to loans outstanding that Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. carries with a bank.
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INVESTMENT IN AFFILIATE
During 1994, the Legion in conjunction with approximately 80 other
organizations, created a nonprofit corporation known as The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc. (CFA, Inc.) for the purpose of aiding in the
campaign to secure a constitutional amendment empowering the
Congress and the States to enact legislation to protect the Flag of
accordingly, the Legion’s investments in the affiliate have been
reduced by this amount, and a corresponding charge has been
reflected in other restricted funds.
the United States of America from physical desecration.
To support these efforts, the Legion invested $3,000,000 in the
program during 1994.
Since the program began in June of 1994, CFA, Inc. has recognized
a (deficiency) of revenue over expenses of $1,981,286 and,
The Legion also guarantees a contract of CFA, Inc. with a public
relations firm for approximately $135,000 monthly.
INVESTMENTS (CURRENT FUND)
The cost and market value of Current Fund investments are as follows:
1993
1994
December 31
Segregated for Designated Fund
U. S. Government obligations
Accrued interest—restricted
Money market accounts
Uninvested cash
Due from General Fund
Segregated for Wash., D.C., building
U. S. Government obligations
Other
U. S. Government obligations
Repurchase agreements
Money market accounts
Certificates of deposit
Mutual funds
Due from General Fund
Cost
Market Value
Cost
Market Value
$11,258,442
146,479
860,417
$10,845,439
146,479
860,417
12,265,338
11,852,335
$9,707,603
127,900
760.000
297
1,075,000
11,670,800
$10,239,366
127,900
760.000
297
1,075,000
12,202,563
682,427
643,019
557,506
568,002
7,060,247
6,749,271
9,593,560
255,961
517,134
135,064
17,561,966
9,593,559
255,961
492,073
135,064
17,225,928
7,657,703
1,500,000
5,623,838
7,502,143
1,531,950
5,623,838
135,088
14,916,629
135,088
14,793,019
21,050
21,050
$27,165,985
$27,584,634
100,887
100,887 *
Investment in affiliate
1,018,714
1,018,714 *
Total investments
$31,629,332
Investment in subsidiary
202
•Book value, market value not determined
$30,840,883
ho
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
OPERATING LEASES
The Legion rents computer equipment, copiers and cash registers
under operating leases. Total rental expense on these operating
leases was $602,285 in 1994 and $489,201 in 1993.
Committee. Earnings of the Fund may be used for the general operations of the Legion, but the principal can be expended only:
Minimum rental payments under operating leases are as follows:
1995
1996
(b) By two-thirds affirmative vote of the National Executive Committee in two successive meetings not less than 60 days apart.
In addition, the Legion has a lease with the State of Indiana for
rental of the National Headquarters building in Indianapolis through
November 1997. According to the terms of the lease, in lieu of
rental payments the Legion is required to maintain the interior of the
building, as well as provide adequate insurance on the building. The
cost of maintenance approximated $348,000 in 1994 and
$349,000 in 1993. Insurance coverage is included in the Legion’s
general insurance policy.
APPROPRIATED FUNDS
The balances of appropriated funds were as follows:
December 31
1994
1993
Computer Reserve
$500,000 $500,000
Real Estate Reserve
841,977
841,977
Convention Reserve
100,000
100,000
Employee Insurance Premium
Stabilization Reserve
100,000
100,000
Convention Stabilization Fund
73,748
25,211
Totals
$1,615,725 $1,567,188
RESTRICTED AND DESIGNATED FUNDS
Receipts which are restricted by the donor are credited to the
appropriate restricted fund, against which all expenditures for the
related project or program are charged. Periodically, the Legion
may add to restricted funds through allocations from unappropriated funds for specific future purposes and projects.
(a) By action of the Legion at its National Convention, or
The Restricted Fund, a designated fund, is restricted as to use by
action of the National Finance Commission and National Executive
Committee. Earnings of the Fund, as well as principal, can be
expended only on the recommendation of the National Finance
Committee and a two-thirds affirmative vote of the National Executive Committee at two successive meetings. It is the policy of The
American Legion to transfer 10 percent of the prior year's defined
net income to the Restricted Fund. There were no transfers in 1994
or 1993 to the Restricted Fund due to net losses.
NONEXPENDABLE FUNDS
The earnings of the Overseas Graves Decoration Fund are being
used to honor, preserve and decorate the graves of those who
served in the United States armed forces who are buried overseas.
The Fund is to continue at the will of the National Convention of the
Legion or the National Executive Committee. The Fund's trust
agreement may be amended, changed or succeeded at the will of
the National Executive Committee, provided that the purpose for
which the Fund was created is retained.
During 1991, the Restricted Fund loaned $4,100,000 to the General
Fund for the financing of the new membership computer system.
Total interest paid to the Restricted Fund amounted to $58,385 and
$148,437 in 1994 and 1993. Total principal payments made were
$1,075,000 and $900,000 in 1994 and 1993. The loan was paid in
full during 1994.
In October 1974, the National Executive Committee approved the
establishment of a life membership plan available to any member of
a participating department. In accordance with the plan, the assets
of the Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund are segregated in a trust
account from which funds equal to the annual dues of life members
are withdrawn for current operations each year. The trust agreement provides that the Legion has the right to withdraw part or all
of the assets of the trust account and to modify or terminate the
trust agreement at its discretion.
The Reserve Fund, a designated fund, also is restricted as to use by
action of the National Finance Commission and National Executive
LO
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
Changes in Nonexpendable Funds are as follows:
Year Ended December 31,1994
Overseas Graves Paid-Up-For-Life
Decoration Fund Membership Fund
Revenue
Paid-Up-For-Life membership
dues collected
$ 4,407,252
Investment income
$56,711
1,272.239
56,711
5,679.491
Expenses
Membership dues withdrawn
2,503,057
Decoration of graves
49,265
Administrative expense
326,809
Trust fees
66,349
49,265
2,896,215
Excess of revenue over expenses
Fund balances, January 1,1994
Fund balances, December 31,1994
7,446
949,689
$957,135
2,783,276
18,015,803
$20,799,079
The cost and market value of investments in the Nonexpendable
Funds are as follows:
December 31
1994
1993
Cost
Market
Cost
Market
Vajue
Value
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
U.S. Government obligations $893.316 $840,553 $893,316 S 926.688
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
U. S. Government obligations 7,035,633 6,877,192 5,443,576 5,656,871
Money market accounts
2,374,915 2,374,915 3,000,489 3,000,489
Common and preferred stocks 9,931,146 10,540,847 6,992,684 8,230,650
Nongovernment obligations
1,677,538 1,567,710 2.445,024 2,516.676
21,019,232 21,360.664 17,881,773 19,404,686
Total investments
$21,912,548 $22,201,217 $18,775,089 $20.331,372
$517,887
141,866
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
AMERICAN LEGION ENDOWMENT
FUND CORPORATION
The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation (the Endowment Fund) was incorporated in 1925 as a not-for-profit corporation with perpetual existence to act as trustee for the American
Legion Endowment Fund, which was created to provide permanent
funding for rehabilitation of American veterans and assistance to
orphans of veterans. In August 1946, the Legion transferred securities having a market value of $2,001,000 to the Endowment Fund.
The assets transferred have been held segregated by the Endowment Fund and the principal related to the 1946 transfer, which had
a market value of $1,982,624 at December 31,1994, may be withdrawn by the Legion, if needed, for rehabilitation of veterans or
assistance to orphans of veterans.
Income earned on the investments of the Endowment Fund, net of
administrative expenses, is payable to the Legion to support its
programs for the above-mentioned purposes. Income from the
Endowment Fund amounted to $537,035 in 1994 and $547,071 in
1993.
LIFE INSURANCE PLAN
In connection with The American Legion's Life Insurance Plan, the
Legion had created a Trust to which the First National Bank of
Kansas City, Mo., as Trustee, held legal title. During October, 1992,
the National Executive Committee approved a resolution to terminate the Life Insurance Trust. This dissolution occurred during April
1993. On the date of dissolution, funds remaining in the Plan
totalling $4,285,984 were transferred to a non-trust sub-account
(The American Legion Life Insurance Plan) under control of the
Legion for the use of youth programs. The American Legion Life
Insurance Plan is included with the restricted funds in the accompanying financial statements. The trust funds, prior to the dissolution, were available for the following purposes:
(a)
(b)
due from participants.
(c)
(d)
(e)
and programs serving the interest of the Legion and its members,
provided that such distributions are not disapproved in writing by a
majority of the participants.
Subsequent to the dissolution of the Trust, the funds of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan are used primarily for youth programs. The Legion’s National Executive Committee has approved
partial funding of the Oratorical Contest, Boys Nation, American
Legion Baseball, and other programs of the Legion. At December 31, 1994, $1,102,170 in funds had been approved for use in
designated programs during 1995.
PENSION PLAN
The funded status of the pension plan at the end of the year was:
December 31
1994
Actuarial present value of plan benefits
Vested
$(13,526,159)
Nonvested
(428,427)
1993
The discount rate and rate of increase in future compensation levels
used in determining the actuarial present value of the projected
benefit obligation were 8.75 percent and 3 percent, respectively, for
1994 and 7 percent and 3 percent, respectively, for 1993. The
assumed rate of return on plan assets was 6 percent for 1994 and
1993.
LITIGATION
The Legion is currently involved in and/or has been mentioned as a
defendant or co-defendant in several legal actions. It is the opinion
of the National Judge Advocate that these claims are without merit
and any ultimate liability of the Legion with respect to these actions
will not materially affect the financial position of the Legion.
$(14,378,971)
(491,826)
Accumulated benefit obligation $(13,954,586)
£(14,870,797)
Projected benefit obligation
$(15,077,680)
Plans assets at fair value, primarily listed
stocks, bonds, and U. S. securities 27,864,346
Excess of plan assets over
projected benefit obligation
12,786,666
Unrecognized net gain
(5,854,739)
Prior service cost not yet recognized
in net periodic pension cost
1,285,938
Unrecognized net asset at
end of year
(1,970,072)
Prepaid pension expense
$6,247,793
$(16,249,877)
29,838,817
13,588,940
(6,435,076)
669,229
(2,261,935)
$5,561,158
Net pension income included the following components:
1994
1993
To
increase the Trust fund.
Service
cost—benefits earned
To
reduce or pay in full the life insurance premiums thereafter
during
the year
$616,509
$661,751
Interest cost on projected
To
provide additional life insurance benefits for the participants.
benefit
obligation
1,148,908
1,041,944
To
make refunds to the participants.
1,133,148
(2,508,638)
Actual return on assets
To make distributions to the Legion in support of its activities
212,622
(3,294,462)
Net amortization and deferral
Net pension expense (credit)
$(395,897)
$(592,321)
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
RECONCILIATION OF AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
TO INTERNAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS:
SCHEDULE 1
Year Ended December 31
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses—
Internal Financial Statements
Excess of expenses over revenue for certain designated
and restricted funds not included in internal financials
Excess of revenue over expenses for certain appropriated funds
not included in internal financials
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses—
Audited Financial Statements
1994
Total Current Fund
$(1,561,180)
(1,840,655)
48,537
$(3,353,298)
AMERICAN LEGION ENDOWMENT FUND CORPORATION
Foreseeing the necessity of a recurring income source for funding
its war veterans’ rehabilitation and child welfare programs, The
American Legion conducted a national campaign in 1925 which
raised approximately $5 million for this purpose. The funds contributed were entrusted to the custody of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation.
December 31
Total assets
Investments at cost
Interest income
Expenses
Excess income over expense
Funds transferred to The American Legion
Average yield on book value of investments
The Corporation was incorporated under the laws of the State of
Delaware in 1925 and a trust agreement between The American
Legion and the Corporation was signed in accordance with which
the funds are administered by the Corporation with the annual net
investment income being paid to The American Legion for use in
the two programs involved.
1994
$7,846,801
$7,644,325
$550,155
46,472
$503,683
$537,035
$7,867,425
$7,665,491
$568,759
26,594
$542,165
$544,071
The operations and financial condition of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation for each of the last five years are
summarized below (taken from the annual audit reports prepared
by Geo. S. Olive & Co. LLC, Indianapolis, Ind.).
$7,802,473
$7,595,545
$652,342
32,304
$620,038
$547,467
$7,714,042
$7,590,564
$710,453
33,103
$677,350
$595,268
$7,495,544
$7,374,020
$627,284
53,173
$574,111
$549,378
N5
o
<y>
207
Abbreviations
ABM
AFP
AMVETS
ANIVICUS
ASTP
AS VET
BAQ
BRAC
CBS
CD
CEO
CFA
CHAMPUS
COLA
DAV
DMS
DOD
DOL
DVA
DVOP
ES
FBI
FUTA
FY
HMO
HPSP
HUD
ICBM
IHS
INS
IRS
JTPA
KWV
LIT
LVER
MBNA
MIA
MTTP
NATO
Anti-Ballistic Missile
Armed Forces of the Philippines
American Veterans of World War II, Korea and Vietnam
Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada, United States
Army Specialized Training Program
Assistant Secretary of Veterans Employment and Training
Basic Allowance for Quarters
Base Realignment & Closure Commission
Columbia Broadcasting System
Compact Disc
Chief Executive Officer
Citizens Flag Alliance
Civilian Health & Medical Program of the Uniformed Services
Cost-of-Living Adjustments
Disabled American Veterans
Direct Membership Solicitation
Department of Defense
Department of Labor
Department of Veterans Affairs
Disabled Veterans Outreach Program
Employment Service
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Federal Unemployment Tax Act
Fiscal Year
Health Maintenance Organization
Health Professional Scholarship Program
Housing & Urban Development
Inter Continental Ballistic Missile
Indian Health Service
Immigration and Naturalization Service
Internal Revenue Service
Job Training Partnership Act
Korean War Veterans
Legionnaire Insurance Trust
Local Veterans Employment Representative
Merchants Bank North America
Missing In Action
Membership Team Training Program
North Atlantic Treaty Organization
208
NC
NEC
NPT
NSLI
OBRA
OCS
OECD
OVA
PFP
PO W
PVOA
ROK
ROTC
SAL
SAT
SBA
SMOCTA
US CINCPAC
UN
US
USERRA
USPHS
USS
USSR
USUHS
V-J Day
VA
VACRS
VETS
VFW
VHS
National Convention
National Executive Committee
Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty
National Service Life Insurance
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act
Officer Candidate School
Organization for Economic Development
Office of Veterans’ Affairs
Partnership for Peace
Prisoner of War
Philippine Veterans Office Affairs
Republic of Korea
Reserved Officers Training Corp.
Sons of The American Legion
Scholastic Aptitude Test
Small Business Administration
Service Members Occupational Conversion and Training Act
United States Commander in Chief, Pacific
United Nations
United States
Uniformed Service Employment and Re-employment Rights Act
United States Public Health Service
United States Ship
Union of Soviet Socialists Republic
Uniformed Services University of Health Science
Victory Over Japan Day
Veterans Affairs
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Veterans of Foreign Wars
Video High Speed
209
Index
Treaty of 1972
Air Force
American Cabaret Theater Singers
American Studies Program
ANIVICUS
Annuity Program
Anti-Ballistic Missile
Apache Longbow System
Appreciation to Host City
Armed Forces
Army
Army Force XXI Program
Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans In Canada
Auxiliary
Auxiliary Eligibility
awards, annual
ABM
B-2 bomber
Baker, Keith
Baseball Player of the Year
Battle of Midway
Bayh, Evan
Belton, Sharon Sayles
Benediction
Bentley, Geroge
Bernard, Prince of the Netherlands
Bille, George
Blackhawk helicopters
Blood Donor Awards
Blood Drive
Blute, Peter
Board of Veterans Appeals
Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc
Bosnia
Bottom-Up Review
Boy Scouts of America
Boys Nation
Bradley Fighting Vehicles
Bradley, Bill
Bradley, Terry
Brown, Jesse
Bruner, Constance
Buick LeSabre
151
152
3, 57
86
'48
139
151
156
96
156
155
156
47
87
127
189
153
184
33
99
11
22
186
47
95
30
156
162
24,82,163
140
110
68
40
152
18, 28
30
156
138
31
58, 166
68
25
210
Buick Motor Division
Burton, Dan
Buyer, Stephen E
C-17 airlifter
26, 138
91
140
153
Caldwell Machining, Incorporated
68
Caldwell, Joseph
68
Cambodia
121
Cambridge Incident
50
Camp H.M. Smith, Hawaii
163
CBS
46
CHAMPUS
115,116,158
Child Welfare Foundation
24,91
Chilelli, Joe
106
China, People's Republic of
120, 122, 123
Ciciotte, William L
184
Citizens Flag Alliance
25, 45, 58, 87, 118, 137, 139, 180
claims
108, 110
Clinton, Bill
6
Coast Guard
28, 161
Comer, John P. ‘Jake’
63
commemorative postage stamp
96
Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
100
constitutional amendment to protect the Flag
5, 21, 39, 141, 179
Constitutional Amendments of The American Legion
126
Coolidge, Calvin
101
Cover, Jack
64, 65
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section II
95
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section III
103
Curtin, Richard
67
Customs and Immigration Services
27
Defense Intelligence Agency
Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military Beneficiaries
Deshotel, Syble
Detweiler, Jr., Scott
Dietz, John
disability compensation benefits
Disabled Veterans’ Outreach ProgramLocal Veterans’ Employment Repre
Disabled Veterans’ Outreach Program
Disaster Relief Fund
Dispatch
Dodona Manor
Dole, Robert J
Domestic Terrorism in the United States
DucksinaRow
120
158
186
1
90
109
78
78
139
25
101
35, 42
153
103
211
Durant, Michael
Dutch Army
99
94
Egner, Aron
32
Eighth U.S. Army
165
election of national officers
168
eligibility
128
Elkins, Frank
§4
Employer of the Year Awards
67
Employment and Unemployment Service
78
Employment and Veterans' Preference and Other Economic Matters
76
English as official language of the United States
37, 38
Enola Gay
5, 13, 49, 59, 70, 74, 86, 92, 98, 104, 140, 149
Evans, Dale
85
Evans, Diane Carlson
84
Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review
109
F-22 fighter
Family Assistance Program
Federal Agency Veterans’ Preference Programs
Federal Contractor Job Listing Program
Federal Surplus Property
Fighting for Tomorrow: Japanese Americans in America’s Wars
Films:
Valor and the Horror
Finance Committee
Financial Report
First Women’s Post of The American Legion No. 2
Fish & Wildlife Service
Flying High Membership Campaign
Foreign Relations Committee
Forest Service
Founders of The American Legion
Fourth Estate Award
Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy
Freeman, Ann Peterson
Funding and Support for Employment Programs
Gable, John
Garland Murphy Award
Geiger, John
George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
George, Steve
German Army
GI BiH
Glenn, John
153
139
78
78
80
98
49
118
196-206
89
99
91
119
79
47
143
28
89
77
47
25
167
100
22
94
6, 82
138
Gold Book
Gold Brigade
Goldsmith, Stephen
Gordon, Gary
grandmothers in the American Legion Auxilairy
Grazini, Alan
Greene, Hugh
Hagger, Gail
Harris, Clifford
Haskell, C. Darrel
Hays, Jr., A. G
Health Care Delivery System of the Uniformed Services
Health Care Security Plan
Hearst Newspapers
Henderson, Thomas
Hice, Larry K
Historic Resources of the Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of
History Standards
Homeless Veterans’ Reintegration Project
Ike Pappas Network Productions
Illegal Aliens
Immigration Act 1986
Indianapolis, Indiana
Internal Revenue Service
Invocation
Jackson National Life Insurance Company
Jacobovits, Adriaan
Japan
Japanese American National Museum
Jennings, Peter
Job Training Partnership Act Title IV-C
Johnson, Sam
Junior Shooting Sports Champion
Kava Water Company
Kicklighter, Claude M
Klinker, Mary
Korean War Memorial
Korean War Veterans Memorial Advisory Board
LaBiche, A1
Lam, Jr., Rick
Ill, 116, 179
107
15
99
127
30
48
86
139
184
66
158
110
143
13
138
100
38
78
45
27
27
96
134
1, 57, 137
139
93
27, 99
98
92
78
140
31
64
82
86
6, 34, 59, 63
64
168
30
213
Laos
121
J24
144
10j
2
137
78
]77
Lee, Tneg-hui
Lewis, Charles
Liberty Memorial
Lighting of Peace Candle
Livingston, Don
Local Veterans’ Employment Representative Program
Ludwig, Daniel A
Mackey, Richard C
Magazine
Marshall, George C
Martin Marietta
MBNA America
Medal of Honor
medical schools
Medicare
membership
Midland Daily News
Midway Islands National Memorial Act
Military compensation
Military retired pay
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Modernization of the United States Army
Montgomery, G.V. ‘Sonny’
Moseley-Braun, Carol
Murphy, Joseph
Murray, Pat
National Air and Space Museum
National Defense Authorization Act
National High School Oratorical Contest Winner
National History Standards
National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
National Security
National Security Strategy
NATO
NATO Partnership for Peace
Natural Resource Management
NAVCARE
Netherlands
Newsome, Linda
Newspapers:
Albany Times Union
Dispatch
Midland Daily News
163
Hg
100
35
139
99
117
115-117, 159
17g
29
99
156
157
23
155
43
13g
30
I39
'i
9g
158
32
38
99
150
155
. 40
122
79
’' ’ ’ ” 160
93
87
143
49
29
214
Nuclear Posture Review
152
Ohn , Regina
Old Glory
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (OBRA) of 1993
Operation Baby Lift
Oppose Centralization of 5 VA-Claims Processing Centers
Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
Oratorical Contest Winner
Organization for Economic Development
86
45
157
86
108
109
124
125
32
94
Pacific Command
Pappas, Ike
Park Service
Partnership for Peace
Pasowski, Aurelia
Patrick, J. Milton
Patton, General George
Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy
Pearl Harbor
Pershing, John J
Phone Bank
Post No. 500
Post Everlasting Ceremony
postage stamp
Postal Service
POW/MIA
POW/MIA Empty Chair Designation
presumptive service
PRIMUS
Proposal to Improve Veterans Health Care
Pryor, Sr., Reverend Roy
164
45
100
122
64
2
143
162
27
101
118, 137
1
2
96
96
6, 120, 125
7
109
160
Ill
1, 23
Quality of Life Features
156
Radcliffe, Jere
RAH-66 Comanche
Ralph T. O’Neil Education Trophy
Ray, Paul
Recruiter Of The Year
Reel, Ralph J
Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Reinvention Team
Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
18
156
28
68
106
184
78
28
123
215
Renaud, Dale
2 59
Report:
Americanism
26
Children and Youth
23
Citizens Flag Alliance
42
Constitutional Amendments
126
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section I
13
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section II
95
Credentials and Internal Matters: Section III
103
Employment and Veterans’ Preference and Other Economic Matters
76
Finance
Hg
Foreign Relations
119
Legislation and Rules
16
National Commander
5
National Security
150
Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
107
Resolutions:
100 156
No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
127
No. 16: V-J Day Designation
27
No. 24: Natural Resource Management
79
No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
123
No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
80
No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
155
No. 35: Oppose Centralization of 5 VA Claims Processing Centers
108
No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
109
No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
97
No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review .. 109
No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
96
No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
99
No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
99
No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
77
No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to Date
the Deceased Veteran’s Claim Was Filed
110
No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
101
No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
120
No. 93: The Enola Gay
98
No. 94: The Enola Gay
98
No. 99: Illegal Aliens
27
No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
100
No. 102: Quality of Life Features
156
No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
157
No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
153
No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military Beneficiaries 158
No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
124
No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
96
No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
100
No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
125
216
No. 141: American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
No. 150: Support for the United States Coast Guard
No. 151: United Nations
No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
Restoration of Liberty Memorial
Retinitis Pigmentosa Foundation
Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
Riley, Richard W
Robertson, Dale
Rodriguez, Fernando
Rogers, Roy
roll call
ROTC Trophy
Royal Canadian Legion
Russia
110
78
81
151
152
161
121
122
96
97
101
23
157
151
69
3, 6
34
85
'69
162
48
120, 151
Salerno, Steve
118
Samsung
34, 35, 65
Samsung American Legion Scholarship
35
Scholl, Dean
58
School Medal Program
29
Schroedl, Don
22
Scott, Robert D
184
Scout of the Year
34
Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to Deceased
Veteran’s Claim was Filed
HO
Selective Service System
6
Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944
81
Shalikashvili, John M
145
Sharp, Jr., Ervin C
163
Sheeks, Gilbert E
15
Shughart, Randall
99
Silver Book
129
SkyConcert
104
Skypeck, Rhonda
64
Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization
81
Small Business Administration
81
Smith, Robert Charles
168
Smithsonian Institution
5, 39, 86, 98, 99
217
Society of the Founders of The American Legion
Solomon, Gerald
Somalia
Song, Bo-Soon
Sons of The American Legion
Southwest Research Institute
Specter, Arlen
Speedway Color Guard
Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
State Employment and Unemployment Insurance Agency
Stepanek, Marcia
Stewart, Virgil
Still Serving America
Stone, E. Roy, Jr
Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to America’s
Veteran-Entrepreneurs
Support for the United States Coast Guard
Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
Taiwan Relations Act
tax exempt status
Tax Simplification Plan
teaching hospitals
terrorist attacks
Third Marine Expeditionary Force
Thomas, Zachary Lee
Tibbets, Paul W
Time Warner
TRICARE
UN Convention on the Protection of Peacekeepers
United Nations
United States Air Force in the 21st Century
United States Court of Veterans Appeals
Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
V-JDay
V-J Day Designation
Valor and the Horror
Vaught, Wilma L
Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
Veterans’ Re-employment Rights
47
43
99
34
90
67
138
1
97
78
143
166
103
69, 167
81
161
100
96
96
123
134
109
117
154
165
34
74
40
158
121
40 121
152
110
120
27,92,166
27
49
88
107
78
110, 111
78
218
Videos:
Old Glory
Your Flag, Your Fight
Vietnam
Vietnam Service Medal
Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund
Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
Ward, W.T. Russ
Wick, Jr., Otto
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy
William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy
Women in Military Service for American Memorial Foundation, Inc
World Trade Center
World War I
World War II
World War II Commemoration Day
World War II Commemorative Committee
World War II poster art slides
45
45
6, 120, 121, 125
132
100, 133
86
84
50
47
29
117
29
88
154
96, 101
97-100
97
104
1
Yeager, Charles
96
York, Alvin C
Yu, Chao
96
50
of the
77th Annual National Convention
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Indianapolis Convention Center
Indianapolis, Indiana
September 4, 5, 6,1995
Printed in U.S.A.
StoctNo. 11-470
DISTRIBUTION
1 ea. to: N.E.C. & Alt. N.E.C.
Past National Commanders
National Officers
Finance Commission
Commission & Committee Chairman
3 ea. to: Foreign Departments (4)
Optional: Departments (51)
PROCEEDINGS
of the
77th Annual National Convention
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Indianapolis Convention Center
Indianapolis, Indiana
September 4, 5, 6,1995
Table of Contents
Foreword
Register of Resolutions
v«
ix
Monday, September 4,1995
Invocation
1
Dale Robertson
3
National Commander’s Report
5
POW/MIA Empty Chair Designation
7
Convention Call
7
The Honorable Evan Bayh Governor
11
Thomas Henderson
13
Reports: Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section I
13
The American Legion National Convention Corporation of Indiana
15
The Honorable Stephen Goldsmith
15
Report: Legislation and Rules
16
Jere Radcliffe, Chief Scout Executive
18
Presentation of Plaque for 1994 National Convention City Minneapolis, Minnesota . 22
Certificate of Appreciation to Rev. Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
23
Report: Children and Youth
23
Garland Murphy Award
25
Report: Americanism
26
Resolution No. 16: V-J Day Designation
27
Resolution No. 99: Illegal Aliens
27
The Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy
28
Ralph T. O’Neil Education Trophy
29
William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy
29
1995 Boys Nation President
30
Junior Shooting Sports Precision Champion
31
1995 Oratorical Champion
32
1994 Baseball Player of the Year
33
1995 Scout of the Year
34
Bo-Soon Song
35
The Honorable Robert J. Dole
35
Special Report: The American Legion and The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc
42
The Honorable Gerald B. H. Solomon
43
The Honorable G.V. Montgomery
44
Ike Pappas, President, Ike Pappas Network Productions
46
Society of American Legion Founders
47
W. T. Russ Ward, Dominion President, Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans
47
Hugh Greene, Dominion President, The Royal Canadian Legion
48
General Chao Yu, Vice Chairman, Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired
Servicemen
50
iii
Lt. General (Ret.) Jae-Yun Kim Vice President, The Korean Veterans Association ... 52
Chapel of Four Chaplains
53
Tuesday, September 5,1995
Invocation
57
The Honorable Jesse Brown, Secretary of Veterans Affairs
58
Korean War Veterans Advisory Committee
63
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
66
Employer of the Year Awards for Hiring Veterans
67
The Honorable richard W. Riley, Secretary of Education
70
Brigadier General Paul W. Tibbets, USAF (Ret.)
74
Report: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
76
Resolution No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
77
No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service .. 78
Report: Other Economic Matters
79
Resolution No. 24: Natural Resource Management
79
No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
80
No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
81
Lt. Gen. Claude M. Kicklighter, USA (Ret.)
82
Diane Carlson Evans
84
Mrs. Linda Newsome, National President, American Legion Auxiliary
87
Brig. General Wilma L. Vaught, USAF (RET.)
88
Sons of The American Legion
90
The Honorable Dan Burton
91
His Excellency Adriaan Jacobovits, Ambassador of the Netherlands
93
Report: Credential and Other Internal Matters, Section II
95
Resolution No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
96
No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
96
No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
96
No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
97
No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans” . 97
No. 93: The Enola Gay
98
No. 94: The Enola Gay
98
No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
99
No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
99
No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial .... 100
No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
100
No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
101
Report: Credential and Other Internal Matters, Section III (Membership)
103
1994-95 Recruiter of the Year
106
Gold Brigade Announcement
106
Report: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
107
Resolution No. 35: Oppose Centralization ofVA Claims Processing Centers 108
No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
109
iv
No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from
Further Review
109
No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to
Date The Deceased Veteran’s Claim was Filed
110
No. 141: The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan 110
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy
117
Reports: Finance
118
Foreign Relations
119
Resolution No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
120
No. 151: United Nations
121
No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
122
No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
123
No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
124
No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam . 125
Report: Constitutional Amendments
126
Resolution No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
127
Wednesday, September 6,1995
Invocation
Drawing for 1996 Buick LeSabre
MBNA America
Jackson National Life Insurance Company of Michigan
The Honorable Steve Buyer, United States House of Representatives
The Fourth Estate Award
General John M. Shalikashvili, USA, Chairman Joint Chiefs-of-Staff
Report: National Security
Resolution No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
No. 102: Quality of Life Features
No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military
Beneficiaries
No. 150: Support for The United States Coast Guard
Maj. Gen. Ervin C. Sharp, Jr., Deputy Director for Operation U.S. Pacific Command
Election ofNational Officers
Syble Deshotel, American Legion Auxiliary President
Benediction
137
138
139
139
140
143
145
150
151
152
153
155
156
157
158
161
163
168
186
186
Announcement of Annual Awards
Financial Report
Abbreviations
Index
189
196
207
209
:
V
FOREWORD
This booklet has been prepared for the information of members of The American
Legion. It has come to be known as the Summary of Proceedings of the National
Convention for the current year. It is a comprehensive resume, in as small space
as possible, of what took place at the Seventy-seventh Annual National Convention
in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4-6, 1995.
The financial report of the National Organization for the period ending December
31, 1994, and Balance sheet as of December 31, 1994 and Surplus Analysis,
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1994 are included in the Summary.
To make a quick distribution, speed has been necessary. Every precaution has been
taken to avoid errors, but some may have occurred in the rush of Convention events
and the hast of editing and printing.
Permission is hereby given to quote from this Summary without further consent.
However, because of the nature of our resolution process, I urge that the full text
of any or all resolve clause(s) is used when a quotation from a resolution is
required for publication.
Robert W. Spanogle
National Adjutant
Note: At various time, the National Vice Commanders, as follows, presided over
the Convention sessions, when called upon by presiding officer, in accordance with
the Uniform Code of Procedure as shown in the verbatim proceedings: Joseph T.
Craig, Alaska, Silas M. Noel, Kentucky, Calvin E. Patton, Maryland, H. Gordon
Burleigh, New York, and Vernon K. Grosenick, Wisconsin.
Register of Resolutions
(see abbreviations used at end of report)
Committee Action
AMER
AMER
AMER
Number Title
APPROVED
APPROVED W/A
R&R
R&R
AMER
AMER
R&R
R&R
AMER
AMER
AMER
AMER
REF
REF
REF
REF
AMER
AMER
AMER
CON AM
CON AM
CON AM
REF TO AMER
REF TO AMER
REF TO SEC
APPROVED
OUT OF ORDER
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
OUT OF ORDER
CON AM
CON AM
REF TO INAF
REJECTED
CON AM
REJECTED
EC
APPROVED
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC
EC/EVP
APPROVED
W/004 020
058 079 137
APPROVED W/A
W/087 133
CONS W/024
CONS W/024
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
CONS W/029
APPROVED
TO
TO
TO
TO
AMER
AMER
AMER
AMER
Or igin
16 V-J DAY DESIGNATION
99 ILLEGAL ALIENS
59 THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE BE DECLARED AS THE
OFFICIAL UNITED STATES LANGUAGE
60 SUPPORT THE TRADITIONAL RENDITION OF THE
NATIONAL ANTHEM
61 POW/MIA FLAG DISPLAY AT POSTAL FACILITIES
96 NATIONAL STANDARDS FOR UNITED STATES
HISTORY
71 WEARING OF THE AMERICAN FLAG PATCH
76 CERTIFICATION OF FILIPINO SERVICE RECORDS
77 FILIPINO VETERANS FAMILY IMMIGRATION
78 REOPEN PERIOD FOR FILIPINO FILING OF
NATURALIZATION APPLICATIONS
134 AMERICAN LEGION MIDDLE SCHOOL ESSAY PROGRAM
135 PRAYER FOR POW/MIA
22 MILITIA ORGANIZATIONS
1 AMERICAN LEGION AUXILIARY ELIGIBILITY
25 CHANGE IN THE PREAMBLE OF THE CONSTITUTION
28 ELIGIBILITY FOR THE AMERICAN LEGION
AUXILIARY
83 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
117 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
121 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
130 ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP IN THE
AMERICAN LEGION
131 RETROACTIVE CHANGE FOR START OF MEMBER'S
CONTINUOUS YEARS
72 HEADQUARTERS POST MEMBERS PER CAPITA
11 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
98 CHANGE IN ELIGIBILITY DATES FOR MEMBERSHIP
IN THE AMERICAN LEGION
147 SUPPORT EFFORTS TO INCREASE AND IMPROVE
FEDERAL ASSISTANCE TO AMERICA'S
VETERAN-ENTREPRENEUR
29 FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
24 NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
87
133
4
20
58
79
137
146
CO
0H
NY
NY
NY
OH
FL
PI
PI
PI
VA
NC
MT
NADJT
AK
AK
WI
NH
VT
SD
SD
KY
CO
OH
EC
DC
AK
NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
SURPLUS FEDERAL PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
FEDERAL SURPLUS PROPERTY
REINVENTION OF VETERANS' EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
ix
WI
UT
KS
OR
NY
NE
VA
EC/EVP
Committee Action
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
APPROVED
W/010 030
046 048 051
081 085 128
132
CONS W/070
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
CONS W/070
CONS W/070
CONS W/070
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
EC/EVP
CONS
CONS
CONS
CONS
CONS
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
R&R
EC/EVP
R&R
EC/EVP
FR/RL
FR/RL
R&R
APPROVED
APPROVED
W/075
APPROVED W/A
APPROVED W/A
APPROVED W/A
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
W/070
W/070
W/070
W/070
W/070
FR/RL
APPROVED W/A
W/057
CONS W/140
FR/RL
FR/RL
CONS W/151
R&R
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
R&R
R&R
R&R
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
FR/RL
INAF
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REF TO FR/RL
REJECTED
APPROVED
INAF
INAF
INAF
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
Number Title
Origin
70 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
FL
10 FUNDING FOR VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING PROGRAMS
30 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
46 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
48 SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT ASSISTANCE
ENTITLEMENTS
51 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
81 SUPPORT DVOP AND LVER PROGRAMS
85 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
128 SUPPORT DVOP AND LVER PROGRAMS
132 FUNDING AND SUPPORT FOR EMPLOYMENT PROGRAMS
8 VETERANS PREFERENCE
9 VETERANS PREFERENCE
18 VETERANS PREFERENCE
49 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
50 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
80 OPPOSE TRANSFER OF VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
126 OPPOSE TRANSFER OF VETERANS EMPLOYMENT AND
TRAINING SERVICE
127 VETERANS PREFERENCE IN GOVERNMENT JOBS
152 NATO PARTNERSHIP FOR PEACE
151 UNITED NATIONS
CO
DC
SC
TX
TX
NE
WI
SD
UT
CO
CO
MA
TX
TX
NE
SD
SD
FR/RL
FR/RL
26 RELATIONS WITH CHINA CONCERNING TAIWAN
92 UPDATED PRIORITY POW/MIA ACTIONS
111 OPPOSITION TO AGREED FRAMEWORK WITH NORTH
KOREA
140 OPPOSITION TO NORMAL RELATIONS WITH VIETNAM
AK
MO
MD
57 WITHHOLD FUNDING FOR NORMALIZED RELATIONS
WITH VIETNAM
75 UNITED NATIONS REFORMS
110 GUIDELINES FOR RELATIONS WITH THE FORMER
SOVIET UNION
112 PRINCIPLES OF UNITED STATES FOREIGN POLICY
113 PRINCIPLES OF UNITED STATES FOREIGN AID
114 DEMOCRATIC ACTIVISIM AS UNITED STATES
NATIONAL SECURITY-FOREIGN POLICY GOAL
15 POW/MIA TRUST FUND PETITION
109 EXPANDING NATO
143 RELEASE OF SERVICE MEMBERS STATUS
145 JAPANESE APOLOGY FOR WORLD WAR II
40 REINSTATEMENT OF TRADE EMBARGO WITH VIETNAM
56 SUPPORT SERGEANT ALVIN C. YORK POSTAGE
STAMP
136 SUPPORT SUPERSONIC FLIGHT POSTAGE STAMP
153 APPRECIATION TO HOST CITY
154 WORLD WAR II COMMEMORATION DAY
TX
X
VA
MX
MD
MD
MD
MD
CO
MD
NJ
NY
IL
TX
WV
INAF
INAF
Committee Action
INAF
Number Title
INAF
APPROVED
W/002 003
APPROVED U/A
INAF
APPROVED W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
INAF
APPROVED W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
CONS W/091
CONS W/091
R&R
R&R
INAF
INAF
INAF
R&R
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
REF TO INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF
REF
REF
REF
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
REF TO SEC
REJECTED
REJECTED
REJECTED
INAF
INAF
INAF/M
REJECTED
REJECTED
REF TO M&PA
INAF/M
SEC
SEC
SEC
SEC
SEC
REF TO M&PA
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
SEC
APPROVED
TO
TO
TO
TO
W/A
W/A
W/A
W/A
INAF
INAF
INAF
INAF
Origin
91 RESTORATION OF LIBERTY MEMORIAL
MO
42 SPONSOR AND SUPPORT SALUTE TO JAPANESE
AMERICAN VETERANS
64 NATIONAL MEDIA COVERAGE FOR MILITARY
PERSONNEL
65 MIDWAY ISLANDS NATIONAL MEMORIAL ACT
93 THE ENOLA GAY
94 THE ENOLA GAY
100 COMMERCIAL VENDORS AT THE VIETNAM VETERANS
MEMORIAL
139 SUPPORT GEORGE C. MARSHALL HOME
PRESERVATION FUND
2 LIBERTY MEMORIAL
3 RESTORATION OF LIBERTY MEMORIAL
5 LEGAL IMMUNITY FOR VOLUNTEERS
6 AUTHORIZATION FOR THE AMERICAN LEGION TO
SEEK AN AMENDMENT TO INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
SEC. 501(c)(19) AND OTHER SECTIONS
63 SUPPORT AUDIE MURPHY POSTAGE STAMP
43 POW/MIA LOGO ON LEGION ENVELOPES
44 ROSTER PLAQUE FOR SONS OF THE AMERICAN
LEGION
55 THE SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION
67 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
82 ESTABLISH SUB COMMITTEE ON MEMBERSHIP
ELIGIBILITY DATES
84 SUPPORT RICHARD I. BONG HERITAGE CENTER
90 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
95 USS MISSOURI MEMORIAL
138 ESTABLISHMENT OF JOINT STUDY GROUP
CONCERNING AUXILIARY ELIGIBILITY
115 ESTABLISH AWARDS FOR EMERGENCY PERSONNEL
17 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
27 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
66 AMEND THE AMERICAN LEGION OFFICER'S GUIDE
AND MANUAL OF CEREMONIES ON MILITARY
FUNERALS
101 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
142 AMERICAN LEGION LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMS
116 OTHER THAN ACTIVE MEMBERSHIP IN THE
AMERICAN LEGION
144 MEMORIAL POSTS
32 MODERNIZATION OF THE UNITED STATES ARMY
102 QUALITY OF LIFE FEATURES
104 RETIRED MILITARY PAY COLA EQUITY
105 DOMESTIC TERRORISM IN THE UNITED STATES
107 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE HEALTH CARE REFORM
FOR MILITARY BENEFICIARIES
148 REVISING THE 1972 ANTI-BALLISTIC MISSILE
TREATY
149 THE UNITED STATES AIR FORCE IN THE 21ST
CENTURY
150 SUPPORT FOR THE UNITED STATES COAST GUARD
xi
IL
NY
NY
NY
OH
OH
VA
KS
KS
KS
KS
NY
IL
IL
TX
FL
PA
WI
MO
OH
VA
MD
CO
AK
MN
MD
UT
MD
ME
DC
MD
MD
MD
MD
SEC
SEC
SEC
Committee Action
SEC
Origin
Number Title
R&R
23 UNITED STATES
COMMAND
FORCES UNDER UNITED NATIONS
MT
IN HAITI
SEC
R&R
33 RETAIN THE SELECTIVE SERVICE SYSTEM
DC
SEC
R&R
45 PRESERVE THE NATIONAL GUARD OF THE UNITED
SC
STATES
SEC
103 RETENTION OF THE UNIFORMED SERVICES
R&R
MD
UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
SEC
106 ANTI-ROTC POLICIES AT COLLEGES AND
R&R
MD
UNIVERSITIES
SEC
R&R
108 NATIONAL SECURITY PRINCIPLES
MD
SEC
R&R
125 ROTC
CA
IN PUBLIC SUPPORTED UNIVERSITIES AND
SECONDARY SCHOOLS
SEC
REF TO SEC
13 VA/DOO
JOINT VENTURE
FOR
FITZSIMONS ARMY
CO
MEDICAL CENTER
SEC
REF TO VA&R
14 STATE AND NATIONAL COMMITTEES
IN SUPPORT OF
CO
PERSIAN GULF VETERANS
SEC
REJECTED
12 CLASS ACTION
LAWSUIT AGAINST UNITED STATES
CO
GOVERNMENT
SEC
REJECTED
31
VA&R
APPROVED
141
W/122
VA&R
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF THE UNITED STATES ARMY
DC
THE AMERICAN LEGION HEALTH CARE REFORM PLAN
VA&R
124
APPROVED W/A
35 OPPOSE CENTRALIZATION OF VETERANS CLAIMS
ND
PROCESSING CENTERS
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
37
OPPOSE
AFFAIRS DISABILITY COMPENSATION
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
47 EXEMPT ALL CURRENT PENSION AND ENTITLEMENT
FROM
VA&R
APPROVED W/A
SC
FURTHER REVIEW
74 REVISE UNITED STATES CODE TO ALLOW
IL
RETROACTIVE DATE WHERE VETERAN DIES WHILE
CLAIM
VA&R
CONS W/141
IS
IN APPEAL PROCESS
122 ALLOW DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS TO
EXPAND ACCESS TO MEDICAL
CA
FACILITIES BY
ACCEPTING AND RETAINING THIRD PARTY
REIMBURSEMENTS
VA&R
CONS W/141
VA&R
R&R
124 PROVIDE PREVENTIVE MEDICINE TO VETERANS
7 EXEMPTION OF
HIRING CAPS
FOR DEPARTMENT OF
CA
KS
VETERANS AFFAIRS
VA&R
R&R
21
SUPPORT PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION
FUNDING
MT
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES
VA&R
R&R
34 SEEK AUTHORIZATION
FOR DEPARTMENT OF
ND
VETERANS AFFAIRS TO CONSIDER CURRENT
INCOME TO DETERMINE ELIGIBILITY
VA&R
R&R
FOR CARE
36 SEEK ADEQUATE APPROPRIATIONS FOR DEPARTMENT
ND
OF VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL PROGRAMS AND
PERSONNEL
VA&R
R&R
38 ESTABLISH AN OPEN ENROLLMENT PERIOD TO
VETERANS ELIGIBLE
VETERANS
VA&R
R&R
39
ND
FOR SERVICE DISABLED
INSURANCE
INCREASE THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF SERVICE
DISABLED VETERANS
ND
INSURANCE
VA&R
R&R
52 OPPOSE ANY REDUCTION
VA&R
R&R
53 REDUCE PROCESSING TIME ON CLAIMS TO SIX
IN VETERANS BENEFITS
TX
TX
MONTHS
VA&R
R&R
62 REQUEST
COUNTY,
FOR NATIONAL CEMETERY RICHMOND
NEW YORK
xii
NY
Committee Action
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
R&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REF TO VA&R
VA&R
REJECTED
Number Title
Origin
69 RESTORE BENEFITS TO REMARRIED WIDOWS OF
VETERANS
86 CREATE A COMMISSION TO STUDY THE
FL
WI
RESTORATION OF THE BURIAL ALLOWANCE
88 REVIEW THE RANKING OF AREAS IN NEED OF A
MO
NATIONAL CEMETERY
89 HEALTH CARE COVERAGE FOR NEWLY DISCHARGED
MO
VETERANS AND DEPENDENTS
97 SUPPORT PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION FUNDING
OH
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES PROGRAM
118 CONTINUE FULL SERVICE AT MANCHESTER VAMC
NH
AND WHITE RIVER JUNCTION VAMC
120 SUPPORTED PER DIEM AND CONSTRUCTION FUNDING NH
FOR STATE VETERANS HOMES PROGRAM
123 INCREASE FUNDING FOR MEDICAL HEALTH
CA
RESEARCH
129 DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS ENSURE
SD
SERVICE ORGANIZATIONS ARE PROVIDED ANY
CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING CLAIMS
19 ELIGIBILITY REFORM AND FUNDING FOR VA
MA
HEALTH CARE
41 EXPANSION OF DECATUR, ILLINOIS OUTPATIENT
IL
CLINIC
68 RESTORE PRIORITY TO SOUTH FLORIDA VETERANS
FL
CEMETERY
73 PROVIDE DEPENDENT CHILDREN OF VETERANS IN
IL
NURSING HOMES GREATER PENSIONS
119 SEEK OUTPATIENT CLINIC TO BE LOCATED AT
NH
PEASE AIR FORCE BASE PORTSMOUTH NEW
HAMPSHIRE
54 OPPOSE CONSOLIDATION OF TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TX
VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL CENTERS
Abbreviations used in this report: AMER=AMERI CAN ISM; INAF/M=CREDENTIALS &
INTERNAL AFFAIRS/MEMBERSHIP; CON AM=CONSTI TUT IONAL AMENDENTS; CONS W/..^CONSOLIDATED
WITH
EC/EVP=ECONOMICS/EMPLOYMENT & VETERANS PREFERENCE; FR/RL=FOREIGN RELATIONS,NADJT=NATIONAL ADJUTANT; R&R=RECEIVED S RECORDED; REF=REFERRED; SEC=NATIONAL
SECURITY; VA&R=VETERANS AFFAIRS S REHABILITION C&Y=CHILDREN & YOUTH; W/A=WITH
AMENDMENTS
12/06/95
xiii
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
1
PROCEEDINGS
of the
77TH ANNUAL CONVENTION
of
THE AMERICAN LEGION
Monday, September 4, 1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegates were entertained by taped music of the ‘40s while slides of
World War II posters were displayed on large screens.
NATIONAL COMMANDER WILLIAM M. DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen,
the music that you have heard and the World War II poster art slides that you have seen are
designed to focus on the theme of our 77th National Convention: World War II
Commemorated.
... At 9:00 a.m., the Delegates assembled for the 77th Annual National Convention and
the following proceedings were conducted:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, please rise as the
Speedway Color Guard of American Legion Post No. 500 in Speedway, Indiana, presents
the Colors, and remain standing for the singing of the National Anthem by my son, Scott,
and my grandson, Scott Detweiler, Jr.. Right hand salute.
... The Speedway Color Guard from Post 500 in Speedway, Indiana advanced the Colors,
while the Delegation stood in right hand salute.
. . .Scott R. Detweiler and Scott R. Detweiler, Jr. sang the “Star Spangled Banner.”
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the invocation, I now call on our
National Chaplain, the Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., of American Legion Post 65 in Saluda,
South Carolina.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Let us pray. Most Holy Father, we invoke Your blessings upon this, the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion.
We come together as a body of volunteers to do that which is right for God and
Country.
As we deliberate this day, we pray that You would give us the insight to do those things
that will enhance this great organization of ours, and help it to continue to be what it should
to a force for God and Country in our world.
2
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Bless us, now we pray this in the Lord’s name. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, please join me
in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance.
... At this time the Delegation recited the Pledge of Allegiance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Fellow Legionnaires, would you please
join with me in reaffirming your commitment to the principles and ideals on which our great
American Legion was founded, by reciting with me the Preamble to the Constitution of The
American Legion.
... At this time, the Delegation stood and recited the Preamble to the Constitution of The
American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I now call on National Chaplain
Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., for the Post Everlasting Ceremony.
POST EVERLASTING CEREMONY
AND
LIGHTING OF PEACE CANDLE
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Ladies and Gentlemen, would you uncover and remain uncovered for this special
remembrance.
In mid-July, The American Legion lost two Past Commanders. One a World War II
veteran, the other a Korean War veteran.
J. Milton Patrick, the 1969-1970 National Commander was a World War II Army
veteran and a Life Member of Galentine Price Post 131 in Skiatook, Oklahoma.
Dale Renaud, the 1985-1986 National Commander was the only U.S. Coast Guard
veteran to lead our great organization.
While remaining seated, I ask you to pause for a moment of silent prayer of thanks for
the service of these men on behalf of America’s veterans.
... A moment of silence was observed.
Two days ago we marked the 50th Anniversary of the end of World War II. It was the
end of a long period of intense fighting, suffering and sacrifice. Peace, wonderful peace was
finally at hand. This morning we take time to remember the way it was a half a century ago.
16,112,568 Americans served during World War II. 406,000 of our comrades died to keep
the candle of peace burning for others. We remember those brave World War II men and
women who died during the war, and the countless millions of others that have since passed
away.
Family and friends; music and song, an abiding faith in God. These held our nation
together through those long war years. Now, let us reflect through music and song, through
written memories of gallant defenders of freedom, by the laying of a wreath, and by the
sounding of three bell tolls in memory of those who fought on land, on sea, and in the air.
... At this time the Delegation viewed a presentation of various videos and was entertained
by the American Cabaret Theater Singers.
National Commander Detweiler placed a wreath entitled “World War II
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
3
Commemorated” at center stage and the following occurred:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I place this wreath in memory of those
in World War II who have gone to their final resting place. Their service has not been
forgotten and will never be forgotten.
... At this time, National Sergeant-At-Arms, Charles D. Aucoin, tolled the bell three times.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Hand salute.
... The Delegation responded with right hand salute, while the American Cabaret Theater
Singers sang taps.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I call on National Sergeant-At-Arms
Charles Aucoin of Louisiana to light the Peace Candle.
... The lighting of the Peace Candle was had.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Please be seated.
... At this time the American Cabaret Theater Singers sang “The White Cliffs of Dover,”
after which the Delegation viewed a video entitled World War II Commemorated.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and Gentlemen, our salute to
World War II veterans and their families continues with our first guest.
A U.S. Army veteran of World War II, he served in North Africa, Italy and Europe, but
it wasn’t until after the war that he would make a name for himself. Perhaps you know him
from one of the 63 motion pictures he made, including, The Farmer Takes A Wife, and the
Outcast of Poker Flats.
Or you might remember him from television: Death Valley Days, Tales of Wells
Fargo, and more recently, Dallas, and Dynasty. He’s a proud American who deeply
treasures his family and friends. And he’s a proud veteran of World War II.
Please welcome to our 77th National Convention, Mr. Dale Robertson.
Dale Robertson
Television Actor and World War II Veteran
I’m very, very proud to be here with The American Legion which goes back a long
time in my life.
When I was a young man, a much younger man, I played American Legion Baseball.
I always looked up to and admired the things that The American Legion has stood for.
I went to the Oklahoma Military College in Claremore, Oklahoma. I was going to set
out to be a permanent Army fixture. 1 loved it. I loved the whole idea of the Army at that
time. The school went on to become the third ranking military school in America. First was
West Point, then Annapolis, and then the Oklahoma Military College.
But the war hit just at the wrong time. We were going to graduate the following year
and become officers automatically, but they shut it down. I think it was ASTP or something
like that which came in. So when we went in the service we had to go in to Officers
Training, OTS, but most of us made it from that school. I don’t know of anybody that didn’t
make it.
We went on to different branches of the service. I started out in horse cavalry. They
ran out of horses I guess.
Then I went over into the tank corp, Armored Force they called it. And don’t ask me
how I got from the Armored Force into the engineers. But my buddy and I got orders one
4
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
day to report to Fort Belvoir, Virginia and thereby go to the School For Officers In
Engineering. Now, that school was for men who were brought into the service with
commissions, based on their experience in engineering. For five years of experience you
became a second lieutenant; 10 years a first lieutenant, etc. The school was to teach student
officers to hand salute, how to stand at attention. It didn’t teach anything about
engineering. You were given a problem: Construct a road from Fort Belvoir, Virginia back
to Washington, D.C. on such and such an azimuth; give us a worksheet of how many man
hours it’s going to take; how many people you’re going to need; how much cut and fill. My
buddy and I not only never passed the test, we never even took one. We didn’t know how
to take it.
But we graduated anyway, full-blown engineers.
I was sent to an outfit in San Luis Obispo, California. My first assignment was to
instruct the men on the construction and use of the gin pole. I got out there in front of my
new outfit and tried to explain to them exactly how I got there. “I don’t know why I got
here, but I’m here. Now, I’m supposed to give you instructions on the construction and use
of the gin pole, but there’s two things wrong with that: I don’t know how you use it and I
sure as hell don’t know how you construct it.”
It’s amazing when you get overseas how fast you can learn. First thing you know is
you’re building bridges and roads. We became a part of the 322nd Combat Engineer
Battalion.
I think I was present when one of the most famous statements of the war was made.
We were the spearhead of the 3rd Army. We had been stopping to remove mine fields and
losing eight, 10, 12 men every time we stopped. Every time we would put those men out
there in the field, there were snipers back there who would pick them off.
One day we received an order from General Patton that from hereafter the engineers
will no longer stop to remove the mine fields, but run through them and suffer the casualties.
When I read that to the men one of them hollered out: "Old Blood And Guts. Our blood and
his guts."
I don’t know whether that was where it originated or not. I know it was the first time
I ever heard it. And I know I repeated it many times.
But Patton’s strategy was a great one, because from that time on I don’t think we lost
over a half a dozen men, maybe eight to ten men, I don’t remember now, but we cut our
losses greatly.
We fought that war for a lot of great reasons: Home and country, and we won it
together as Americans.
Now, I’m not sure today that everything we fought for is still in place. We have a
country today that teaches that you can go to jail if you pray in school. Yet we’ve got
freedom of speech. Now you figure that one out.
I see the news media making heroes out of criminals, and making heavies, or let’s say
disrespect, for policemen. They’ll tell you all those stories on the front page. They’re
telling the children of this country that if you want to make the news in our town, if you
want to get on the evening news or on the front page, don’t think you’re going to get there
by helping little old ladies cross the street or by doing anything right. You take a shotgun
and blow the head off one of those little old ladies for no reason and we’ll have you on the
evening news and all your classmates are going to know who you are from there on out.
These are the things that we have to fight against today.
There’s a war on, whether people want to believe it or not. There’s a war on against
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
5
wrong. All of the things that we have fought for in World War II we are now going to have
to fight again but in our own country and not in Germany.
But above it all, I never believed that America was perfect. But I’ve always believed
that it’s the best place in the world to live. I know that we have muddied up our waters; we
have fouled up our air, but all of that was done through technology. There were many
people trying to do something better, and if they fouled it up, then I believe the great
American technology will get after it and get it cleaned up.
Once again, I’m proud to be here; I’m proud to be an American, and I’m proud to be
in Indianapolis today.
Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you, Dale. Legionnaire you’ll be
happy to know that he’s joined our ranks as a member of The American Legion. Well, I
guess if he could build bridges never having seen the inside of a real engineering school, I
guess he had no problem on those wagon trains and rounding up those cattle.
NATIONAL COMMANDER S REPORT
TO THE CONVENTION
William M. Detweiler (LA)
My report is about what follows in the next three days, the commission and committee
reports that will be presented reflecting the work and accomplishments of this organization
during the past year, what we together have accomplished.
It has been a busy year, a year in which we faced many challenges and many issues.
On numerous occasions the positions and the opinions of The American Legion were sought
by the media and by the general public. By the media because, I suppose, they were
newsworthy; by the general public because they were standing for what they believed in.
We have taken firm stands over this year. We have stood up to the revisionist
historians of the Smithsonian Institution in opposition to the so-called planned Enola Gay
exhibit, an exhibit that was to commemorate the end of World War II, but was nothing
further from the truth.
We stood up for the valor of the men and women whose accomplishments and valor
we commemorate at this Convention: the veterans of World War II. We stood up because
it was the right thing to do, because it was good for America. We stood tall when we argued
for the importance and the integrity of the Smithsonian Institution as a valued institution.
Our position was vindicated by the American people in overwhelming numbers, and even
the liberal media joining with us. We stood up for the history of this country. We said no,
you will not rewrite the proud history of this country. The decision of President Truman to
end a horrible blood bath and save hundreds of thousands of American men and women, and
at the same time save hundreds of thousands of Japanese lives, to make that decision to drop
that bomb was proper; he did the right thing; it was the moral thing, and we have nothing
as a people to apologize for.
And we stood up for the Flag of our country, by continuing and intensifying our efforts
to pass a constitutional amendment to protect the Flag from physical desecration. We have
pledged to put our time, our effort, and yes, our money into these grassroot movements to
see to the passage of this amendment. Not because it’s a veterans’ issue; not because it is
any other issue, or for any other reason, but it is an American issue. It’s the right thing to
6
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
do.
As Dale Robertson said, The American Legion is determined, as he feels strongly, to
preserve the values of this country because it is good for America. We stepped forward and
stood firm on the POW/MIA issue. We sought to keep alive the efforts of the American
people and our government to seek the fullest possible accounting for those who did not
return.
I am personally convinced, after going to Vietnam last winter, that the Vietnamese
continue to play the POW/MIA issue as a trump card to seek financial assistance from the
United States. I am convinced that the Vietnamese continue to withhold information and
documents that would resolve once and for all, many, but not all necessarily, of the fates of
those who did not return.
Last month I met with President Clinton and his staff, eyeball to eyeball in the Cabinet
Room. The American Legion will not break faith with the families of those who did not
return. We are against normalization from the standpoint of economic development or any
other reason which brings dishonor to the valor of those who did not return. It’s the right
thing to do and it’s the proper position to take.
We stepped forward again this year for the third or fourth time in recent years, to help
save the Selective Service System, our insurance policy against aggression.
We helped launch the long awaited memorial to women who have served side by side
with men in the defense of this country. We helped dedicate the long awaited Korean War
Memorial. Why? Because we as a people and we as an organization must never forget and
must never let future generations forget the deeds of the valiant men and women who
answered the call of this country, who asked no questions but gave their talents and time and
their lives, in many instances, to protect the freedoms and the peace that we all enjoy today.
Why? Because it’s the right thing to do. It’s the American thing to do.
During this convention you will be asked to step forward again. You will be asked to
approve a revolutionary approach to VA health care. We did it before, and we are prepared,
as we have been in the past, to do it again.
We stepped forward in the ‘20s and saw to the creation of the VA.
We stepped forward during World War II and saw to the passage of the greatest piece
of social legislation to be passed by the Congress and signed into law this century, the GI
Bill.
Why? Because it was the right thing to do. It was the American thing to do, because
it helped to create an educated America, because it gave those veterans the opportunity to
realize the American dream, to own a home and to raise our families in a better America.
Why? Because it was the right thing to do. It’s the American thing to do.
And we stood up to former Secretary McNamara, an individual who did not have the
backbone to stand up to his President and say no. He is an individual who, in not speaking
out, allowed thousands of America’s best and brightest to lose their lives; suffer individual
atrocities, and whose families do not know where those who did not come back, are lying
today, or whether they are dead or alive.
We have been speaking out this year and doing things that are not necessarily different
than anything we have done in the last 76 years. We are standing for the ideals and for the
principles of the American values that we have stood for since our founding. By our actions
and our deeds this year, we continue to work to protect those American values that form the
fabric of this country. We only did what we did because it was the right thing to do, and
it was good for America So I commend each and every one of you for your loyalty to those
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
7
founding principles. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for the support of my efforts
on behalf of The American Legion and America this year.
I believe that it is a distinct honor, and I have always said that, to be considered as a
candidate for National Commander. It has been an absolute privilege and a pleasure to have
had the opportunity to serve as your National Commander this year. On behalf of my family
and myself, I thank you, and I hope and pray that I have vindicated the trust that you have
placed in me this year.
God bless you; God bless America, and God bless The American Legion. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As a point of personal privilege since we
are all gathered here today, may I introduce my family again to you. First, my wife
Maureen, my oldest son, Scott, Christine, my daughter-in-law, the mother of the young one,
my daughter, Bonnie, a friend Bassan Messaike, my son, Keith, the lawyer, and his friend,
Meg Fineman, my daughter Jenny.
And the young lady that kept my office running over the last 12 months, my secretary,
Robin Castle.
And two close friends who took time out of their busy schedules to be with us today:
Dr. William Reeves of New Orleans and his wife, Sally Kitford Reeves of New Orleans.
Some of you may have seen this gentleman in the parade the other day. He’s 99 years
young. He walked the entire parade. In fact, he sort of ran behind the Alabama banner.
Charles Cook of Post 30 in Alabama. Charlie, it’s great to have you with us.
POW/MIA EMPTY CHAIR DESIGNATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: In this time of commemoration of events
and staggering costs of World War II, it is fitting that we also remember those who were
never accounted for. Vietnam, Korea and World War II left behind families who wondered
about the fate of their loved ones. As has been The American Legion tradition for many
years, we pause to remember the American prisoners of war and those listed as missing in
action from every war.
This morning our POW/MIA flag is placed reverently on an empty chair by Past
National Commander Robert Turner of Georgia, Chairman of the Special POW/MIA
Committee and Alan Hall of Florida, the Chairman of the Foreign Relations Commission,
to remember those who have not returned, whose whereabouts are unknown.
Let this flag remind us all that The American Legion has not forgotten. Let us now
pause for a moment of silence and personal prayer for those missing and their families.
... A moment of silence was observed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time, I call upon our National
Adjutant, Robert W. Spanogle of Michigan, to issue the Call for the Convention.
CONVENTION CALL
for the Seventy-Seventy Annual Convention
of
The American Legion
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: The call for the 77th Annual National
8
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Convention of the American Legion. By the authority of The National Executive
Committee, the 77th Annual National Convention of The American Legion is hereby called
to meet in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995. The convention business sessions
will be held at the Indiana Convention Center Halls “A” and “B” first floor.
PURPOSE
The Annual National Convention is a legislative body of The American Legion. The
convention is called for the purpose of setting the programs of The American Legion for
the ensuing year amending the National Constitution and Bylaws and for the transaction of
such other business that may be brought before it. At twelve o’clock noon on the final
session or at the conclusion of all other business of the National Convention, whichever first
occurs on Wednesday September 6, 1995, officers for the ensuing year will be elected.
These being the National Commander and five National Vice Commanders in that sequence.
REPRESENTATION
Representation in the convention shall be by department and in accordance with the
provisions of the National Constitution (Sec.3, Art.IV)
‘... each department shall be entitled to five delegates and one additional delegate for each
one thousand members or major fraction thereof whose current dues have been received by
the National Treasurer 30 days prior to the meeting of said convention August 7th, and
whose registration fees as fixed by the National Executive Committee for its total authorized
delegate strength have been paid and to one alternate for each delegate.’ (Sec.3, Art.V)
In addition to the above, the members of the National Executive Committee are
Delegates to the National Convention with vote which shall be exercised with their
respective departments, except the vote of the National Commander shall be exercised only
in his capacity as chairman of the National Convention. (Sec. 3, Art. VII)
‘Each duly registered delegate shall be entitled to one vote.’ (Sec. 4, Art. V)
Delegates to the National Convention shall be accredited in writing to the National
Adjutant to the number of manner described by Article 5 of the National Constitution. The
rights of the Departments to make and accredit substitutes for absentee delegates or
alternate delegates shall be recognized by the National Adjutant provided that such
substitutions shall be officially certified by the Department Commander, the Department
Adjutant at the time of certification required by the National Constitution or at any time
prior to the adjournment of the first session of the National Convention.
ALTERNATES
Alternates shall have power to vote only in the absence of regular delegates. The
selection of alternates who represent absent delegates is a matter for decision within the
respective delegations. The vote of any registered delegates absent and not represented by
an alternate shall be cast with the majority of registered delegates present from his or her
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
9
department.
NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Meeting of the new National Executive Committee will be held at the call of the
National Commander within 24 hours after the adjournment of the National Convention as
provided by the National Bylaws.
DEPARTMENT OFFICIALS
Department officials, unless elected as delegates or alternates to the National
Convention, have no privileges in this convention except as guests of their respective
departments.
CONVENTION COMMITTEES
The 38th Annual National Convention, through revision of the National Constitution
(Section 6, Article V) directed that the National Executive Committee should provide a
Uniform Code of Procedure for the orderly organization and operation of National
Conventions unless it is amended, suspended, or repealed by a majority vote of the total
authorized representation at a National Convention. Such Code of Procedure was approved
by the National Executive Committee at the October 17, 18, 19, 1956 meeting.
Under the Code, Convention Committees are to be called for organization purposes in
advance of the opening session of the National Convention in the Convention city, with
subsequent meetings as called by the Chairman, providing that all final policy forming
reports shall be approved by such committees in meetings held after the National
Convention is formally convened. Each Department shall designate delegates or alternates
for service on each Convention Committee and shall file with the National Adjutant a list
of such designees at least two weeks prior to the opening session of the Convention. Each
Department must notify its designees of their appointments to committees by mail, stating
the time and place in the Convention city of the initial meetings of the committees.
Departments have the right of substitution of committee members providing proper
credentials are filed with the Temporary Chairman, or later, with the Permanent Secretary
of each Convention committee.
CONVENTION COMMITTEES
CONVENTION COMMITTEE
1. Americanism
2. Children & Youth
3. Constitutional Amendments
4.
Credential & Internal Affairs
Credentials & Other Internal Matters (Sec. I&II)
Membership (Sec. Ill)
Number of Members
to which each
Department is entitled
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
10
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
5. Economic
Employment & Veterans Preference
Other Economic Matters
6. Finance
7. Foreign Relations
8. Legislation & Rules
9. National Security Committee Joint Meeting
(Includes Aerospace, Defense Civil Preparedness,
Merchant Marine, Military Affairs, Naval Affairs,
Law & Order Convention Committees)
IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING NATIONAL SECURITY
JOINT MEETING
Aerospace
Merchant Marine
Military Affairs
Naval Affairs
Law and Order
10. Veterans Affairs & Rehabilitation
Claims & Rating
Hospitals and Medical Services
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
One Delegate
CREDENTIALS
Each Delegation Secretary arriving in advance of his delegation will bring with him
properly executed in triplicate, the official “Certification of Delegates and Alternates,”
which must contain the following information:
1. Name of Department
2. Number of Posts in the Department
3. Paid-up membership at the close of business, August 8, 1994 according to the books
of National Treasurer.
4. Delegation Chairman.
5. Delegation Secretary.
6. Names, addresses and post affiliations of delegates.
7. Names, addresses and post affiliates of alternates.
8. Signature of Department Commander, attested by
Department Adjutant.
DELEGATION HEADQUARTERS
Each delegation will establish headquarters in the hotel to which assigned. Upon
arrival in Indianapolis, all members of a Department delegation will report to their respective
delegation headquarters. They will receive all necessary instructions from the Secretary of
the delegation and will not report to the National Adjutant.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Mr. Commander, this concludes the Call for
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
11
the 77th National Convention of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWE1LER: I now declare the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion regularly convened.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is the man who for the
past seven years has been the leader of the Hoosier State. He began his term as governor,
set among his priorities improving education. In his time, he has developed into an
educational leader. Serving as the Chairman of the National Education Goals Panel and has
been Chairman of the Education Commission of the States and one of just two governors
on the National Assessment in Education Panel. Several publications have watched his
efforts with a keen eye and have found him to be one of the top governors in the nation in
terms of fiscal management. It is my pleasure to present to you the Governor of the great
State of Indiana, Evan Bayh.
THE HONORABLE EVAN BAYH
Governor of Indiana
On behalf of five and a half million Hoosiers, it’s an honor for me to welcome all of
you from across our country here to our fair state for your annual convention. I’m not going
to go on at great length. As a matter of fact, you can all relax, I’m not running for anything
this year.
I’m reminded of the wisdom of a local minister who invited me to his congregation on
a very important public occasion and walked up into the pulpit and looked out at a very
sizeable audience like this. It was being broadcast all over live radio in central Indiana. This
is a true story. He looked out at the congregation, spoke very clearly into the microphone
and said, “Governor, we humbly request that you be strong today, not long today.’ So I
followed his advice and it seemed to work pretty well, and I’ll try to do that again here
today.
I would like to acknowledge and salute the very able leadership of your National
Commander Bill Detweiler. I see my friend, Bob Spanogle, is here doing an able job with
your National Headquarters. Also, Bill Jackson and Dutch Bole and the very able leaders
of our Indiana Department who have done such a fine job. Also, my First Lady would give
me a very hard time when I go home if I don’t acknowledge the leadership of your National
Auxiliary who are with us here today.
I’d like to make just three main points and then we’ll get on with the convention. You
can hear from our mayor and, I believe, one of our senators today and several other
distinguished speakers.
First, I’d like to say how very proud we are as Hoosiers of The American Legion. We
are proud of your service to our country, we are proud of your service to our state. It is an
unceasing source of pride to us to have your National Headquarters located here in the state
of Indiana. It’s an honor for us and one that we acknowledge repeatedly on occasions like
this and others where veterans and citizens who care about the future of our country and
state have gathered.
If you have occasion during this convention to have some time to walk around
Indianapolis, you will see very tangible evidence of the pride that we have in the Legion and
for men and women who have served our country in time of war. The very center of our
12
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
state, the circle, the center of the focal point of our state capital, the center of Indiana, the
financial hub, has in its very midst a wonderful War Memorial to those who gave their lives
during the Civil War. Up on the War Memorial Plaza you will see other monuments that
stand giving testimony and paying tribute to those who served our country in time of armed
conflict. I’m proud to indicate today, for those of you who will come back and visit us in the
future, that next May 24th we will unveil a new memorial commemorating the service and
the sacrifice of those who served our country during the Korean and the Vietnam Wars.
I had a chance to review the outline of this memorial several months ago. I think you’ll
find that it’s a fitting tribute to those men and women, and it will stand as eloquent
testimony to their service to our country as well. So we are proud of The American Legion
and we thank you for your service.
The second point that I would like to make today is that there’s someone representing
the Boy Scouts who will be speaking to the conference a little later today. Assuming, that
is, in fact, not a Boy Scout, I may be the youngest speaker today at age 39. And on behalf
of the people of a younger generation, I would like to thank those of you who gave of your
youth so that we might enjoy ours. Those of you who sacrificed and your colleagues who,
in fact, gave their lives so that we could inherit the country that we see today that is
prosperous and proud and free. And I hope that we can follow your example which is,
perhaps, the most eloquent testimony that we can give of gratitude, and dedicate ourselves
to insuring that our country remains the kind of great world leader that you have handed
down to us.
Along those lines, I would like to salute the leadership of the Legion. For those of you
who haven’t had a chance to go to see a Boys State or a Girls State, I encourage you to do
that. I try and go to our Boys State every year that I can. It is a wonderful thing for those
of you who think that all of our country’s youth have dropped out and tuned out, and don’t
care, are couch potatoes and just members of the me-generation. Let me tell you that you
in the Legion are doing yeoman’s work in insuring that the concepts of patriotism and
sacrifice and heroism remain alive and well in the hearts of our young people. You owe it
to yourselves to see the kind of contribution that you are making through Boys State and
Girls State. So I want to thank you for that on behalf of all of the citizens of our state, but
particularly young people as well.
The final thing I would like to say today is that, in a democracy, memories tend to be
very short. Just more than 50 years ago we celebrated the end of the war in the Pacific, a
victory over Japan. It’s been just more than 20 years since the Vietnam War came to a
conclusion for the Americans who were fighting in that conflict. And we have a way of
focusing on the positive in our countiy. We are a peaceful nation. But for those of you who
have served in the armed forces during time of the armed conflict, it is vitally important that
you let those who are younger and have no living memory of such things know that concepts
such as freedom aren’t just words that we use during speeches like this, but are concepts that
are paid for with lives and with blood. And that if we are to remain a free countiy, and if our
children are to inherit from us the kind of world we would like to see them have, it is thanks
to those who are willing to put actions behind those concepts, those of you here today.
And so I would just like to conclude with the words of a decorated veteran who was
sworn into office as the youngest president in the history of our country. He concluded his
inaugural address by saying that, with a clear conscious, with history being the final judge
of our deeds. Let us go forward to lead this land we love asking for His help and for His
blessing but remembering always that here on earth God’s work must truly be our own.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
13
To those of you in The American Legion, to those of you who have served our country
and occasionally been through hell and back to do his work, I say, thank you. 1 say,
welcome. I hope you enjoy your stay with us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you Governor. It’s great to have
you back.
The state that hosts The American Legion National Convention always has plenty to
do to get ready for such a gathering. For Indiana, preparing for this National Convention
provided many extra challenges. And the leadership of Indiana, I can truly say, met them
all. They brought the convention to Indianapolis, pulling together plenty of details in just
six months, instead of the usual five years.
Please give a warm welcome to a U.S. Army veteran of the Korean era and a member
of Charles Pratt Post No. 94 in Valparaiso, Indiana, the 1995-96 Indiana Department
Commander Tom Henderson.
THOMAS HENDERSON
INDIANA DEPARTMENT COMMANDER
1995 - 1996
Thank you, Commander. Delegates to the 77th National Convention of the American
Legion, on behalf of the 140,000 Legionnaires of The Department of Indiana, I wish to
welcome you to the great state of Indiana and its beautiful capital, Indianapolis. The
Department of Indiana Convention Corporation has worked very hard to make your visit to
Indianapolis meaningful, memorable and fun. We absolutely have no objection if you wish
to leave large amounts of currency in and around the Indianapolis area. Be sure to take in
the many attractions the area has to offer and have a safe and enjoyable stay in our state.
We are very serious about our Hoosier hospitality, so do not hesitate to call on us if we can
be of any assistance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We truly appreciate the work of the
Indiana Department its preparation for this convention, because I know it was quite a chore.
The Chair now recognizes the distinguished Chairman of the National Convention
Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs, a gentleman that did yeoman work this year
on the Enola Gay issue along with myself and the Director of Internal Affairs. The Chair
recognizes Herman Harrington of New York for the purpose of a report.
REPORT OF SECTION ON CREDENTIALS
AND OTHER INTERNAL MATTERS
(of Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs)
Section I
Herman G. Harrington (NY), Chairman
It is a pleasure for me to report to the 77th Annual Convention of The American Legion
here assembled at Indianapolis. 48 members and guests of the section on Credentials and
Other Internal Affairs met at 9 a.m., September 2, 1995, in Room 101, first level of the
Indianapolis Convention Center, Indianapolis, Indiana. Herman G. Harrington from New
14
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
York was elected chairman and Larry J. Besson of Illinois was elected secretary. It was
regularly moved, seconded and carried to accept the delegate strength report as reported by
the National Adjutant certifying the membership of this organization 30 days prior to the
National Convention. It was regularly moved and seconded and carried that the report be
based upon the provisions of Section 3, Article 5, of the National Constitution to which five
delegates for each department plus one additional delegate for each one thousand members
or major fraction thereof whose current dues have been received by the National Treasurer
30 days prior to the opening of the convention, August 7, 1995, and one alternate for each
delegate.
In addition, in accordance with Section 3, Article 7, members of the National Executive
Committee, which committee includes the National Commander who exercises his vote only
in his capacity as Chairman of the National Convention and five National Vice Commanders
are delegates to the National Convention. All living Past National Commanders are
members of the National Executive Committee without vote and life delegates to the
National Convention with vote which is exercised in their respective departments.
Motion was adopted by majority vote of the committee, the chairman and secretary be
authorized to sign the committee report on behalf of the committee. In accordance with the
membership reports certified to the Convention Committee on Credentials and Internal
Affairs by the National Adjutant on August 7, 1995, and in accordance with Article 5 of the
National Constitution, the voting strength of the 55 departments is 3,311 which is allocated
as follows:
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Dist. Of Columbia
Florida
France
Georgia
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
32
16
43
31
162
32
39
16
10
127
9
53
104
136
28
73
19
70
13
32
91
21
220
54
34
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Mexico
Pennsylvania
Philippines
Puerto Rico
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
10
17
167
145
86
63
40
47
34
92
78
8
275
10
16
16
31
35
42
102
16
24
59
47
36
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
174
38
36
Wisconsin
Wyoming
15
88
14
Mr. Commander, as a duly elected delegate from the Department of New York I move
for the adoption of this report.
... The motion was duly seconded and carried.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Let’s look back five years to 1990. The
American Legion National Convention came to its home here in Indianapolis. I found that
our next guest was described then, as he is now, as a busy man. But not much has changed.
He’s a busy man who stepped forward a few months back to put committees together and
to meet every challenge that was presented. It’s always great to give a busy man something
else to do because he gets the job done. A veteran of United States Army and World War
II, he is a member of Post 250 Mitchell, Indiana. Please welcome the President of the
American Legion National Convention Corporation of Indiana, Gilbert ‘Gib’ Sheeks.
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL
CONVENTION CORPORATION OF INDIANA
Gilbert E. Sheeks (IN), President
Commander Detweiler, National Officers, Guests and Delegates. As the Commander
said some short time ago, we undertook the task of hosting the 1995 National Convention.
I thank those wonderful people from Indiana who have worked to make it comfortable and
make you welcome here. As you leave here Wednesday, we hope that you will have the
feeling in your heart that you would like to return to Hoosierland sometime in the future.
Commander, to you and all the Delegates and all the wonderful people that are
assembled, welcome to Indiana. We hope you enjoy your stay and please come back.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next guest is a respected leader of
the nation’s 12th largest city, the city The American Legion has been proud to call home
since 1919. He’s earned a reputation as one of the nation’s most innovative mayors, leading
cost saving efforts, increased service, lower cost and hold the line on taxes. Please give a
warm welcome to the Mayor of Indianapolis, the Honorable Steve Goldsmith, Mayor.
THE HONORABLE STEPHEN GOLDSMITH
Mayor of Indianapolis
Welcome back. We are delighted to have you back so quickly. I’m a little
disappointed that the introduction didn’t mention that I’m a 15-year member of The
American Legion, which should have come before I was listed as mayor.
I may be the last one in my post to pay his yearly dues, but I do get it done. In a whole
range of ways, first, we in Indianapolis are proud that you have allowed us to call you
residents of the city of Indianapolis and that we are allowed to be hosts of The American
Legion National Headquarters. It’s an honor for the city of Indianapolis to be able to have
you day by day and month by month in the center of our city. It’s a double honor, then,
when you bring your National Convention back to the city of Indianapolis.
16
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
I must say I enjoyed the parade as I ran along seeing a number of people, all of whom
were happy and pleased to be here. I think the weather had a little bit to do with it. The
Legion’s sponsorship of the SkyConcert that night, I thought, brought a patriotic cast to the
evening’s activities which were delightful for all of us.
And finally, Indianapolis. We’re the 12th largest city. Of all the large cities in the
country we have more public space dedicated to saying thanks to those who have given their
lives and sacrifice for our country than any large city in the country. And the large
American Legion Mall, the Soldiers and Sailors Monument, the World War Memorial, the
new USS Indianapolis Memorial, the areas that we have set aside to pay tribute to those who
fought in the Vietnam Conflict, all of those things, I think, bring to us a great sense of pride.
We in Indianapolis, I think, are much better off because we are able to have the values and
the patriotism and the sacrifice that The American Legion stands for in our home,
Indianapolis. And we thank you for coming back again this year. Thanks so much.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair at this time recognizes Charles
Pesso of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Legislation and
Rules for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
LEGISLATION AND RULES
Charles Pesso (NY), Chairman
Mr. Commander, Officers of The American Legion and my fellow Delegates. The
Convention Committee on Legislation and Rules met at 10:00 a.m. on September 2nd, 1995,
in Room 209 of the Indiana Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. There were 45
delegates and 23 guests in attendance. Following preliminary activities to officially
organize the committee, the permanent chairman and secretary were elected. I, Charles
Pesso, a delegate from New York, was elected chairman and Claude Carpenter, a delegate
from Arkansas, was elected secretary.
The committee then proceeded to the business agenda by considering the rules of this
convention. A motion was approved by the committee to recommend adoption of the
Standing Rules of the Convention as they appear in the Uniform Code of Procedures for
Organizing National Conventions of The American Legion.
A motion was also approved to authorize the chairman and the secretary to sign the
report on behalf of the Convention Committee on Legislation and Rules. Patrick Ryan,
Democratic counsel and staff director for the House Veterans Affairs Committee, addressed
the convention committee regarding the budgetary concerns facing the Department of
Veterans Affairs. Since there were no resolutions referred to the committee for
consideration, the Legislation and Rules Committee wishes to offer to the delegates to this
convention a brief report on current congressional developments affecting issues of primary
interest to The American Legion.
The 104th Congress, under Republican leadership for the first time in 40 years, has set
an aggressive agenda to dramatically reduce the federal deficit and to substantially reform
the federal government. In June after much debate, Congress adopted a budget resolution
crafted to balance the federal budget within the next seven fiscal years.
This blueprint has established targeted funding levels through fiscal year 2002. Many
federal programs have been recommended for termination while others are slated for deep
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
17
budgetary cuts beginning in fiscal year 1996. Under this budget resolution, the Department
of Veterans Affairs funding will average about one percent annual growth rate. This
progression projection of minimal budget increases will force VA to make dramatic changes.
Every program dependent on discretionary funding will be impacted by these budgetary
limitations. Health care delivery, medical and prosthetics research, construction, the
National Cemetery System, the processing of claims and the adjudication of appeals will feel
these financial shortfalls.
Congress faces a very busy schedule. Appropriation bills will receive much attention
as the fiscal year deadline approaches. This year, The American Legion has already
presented testimony before nine appropriation subcommittees and will continue to play an
active role as these funding proposals are finalized.
President Clinton has expressed his disapproval of several of the House passed
appropriation bills and plans to exercise his veto power unless compromises are reached.
This threat could be backed up by a shutting down of the federal government. Such a
maneuver would have a devastating affect on the entire nation. The American Legion
continues to be deeply involved in the debates concerning VA reform. Repeatedly, The
American Legion has reminded Congress that 27 million veterans and the government’s
largest medical care delivery system cannot and must not be ignored.
The American Legion seeks eligibility reform that provides all veterans with a
guaranteed comprehensive medical benefits package. The VA medical system must have
constant and dependable funding sources that will adequately provide for needed medical
services. This will include retaining all third-party reimbursements for reinvestment into the
system. The VA must receive an initial financial transfusion to revamp its service delivery
system. The VA must retain its unique specialized missions in rehabilitation, prosthetics,
spinal cord injury, blindness, aging, mental health, and long-term care. And, finally, the VA
must continue to be a national asset in medical attention and medical education, medical
and prosthetics research and as a backup to the Department of Defense medical system.
As the National Legislative Commission Chairman, I must take this opportunity to
publicly thank the millions of Legionnaires, Auxiliary members, Sons of The American
Legion and other concerned Americans who have worked so long and so hard for the
protection of the American Flag.
The overwhelming support in the House of
Representatives Flag Amendment vote was truly generated by the grass roots of America.
Old Glory still has one last battle on Capitol Hill and that is in the United States Senate.
This campaign is so close to victory. Please contact your senators, urge their support for
Senate Joint Resolution 31, a Constitutional Amendment to protect the American Flag from
physical desecration.
On September 18th and 19th of this year, Legionnaires from across the United States
will accompany the new National Commander to Capitol Hill. Their mission will be to
discuss the legislative mandates of The American Legion with their congressional members.
The highlight of this event will be the National Commander’s testimony before a joint
session of the Senate and House Veterans Affairs Committees.
Mr. Commander, as a duly authorized delegate from the Department of New York to
this convention, I move the adoption of this report and the adoption of the standing rules of
the convention as they appear in the Uniform Code of Procedures for Organizing National
Conventions of The American Legion.
.. . The motion was duly seconded and carried.
18
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next speaker represents an
organization that has had the full support of The American Legion for 77 years, the Boy
Scouts of America. Jere Radcliffe took over the leadership of the Boy Scouts of America
in 1993, the job which provides considerable challenges. As National Commander and
doubly as an Eagle Scout, it is my pleasure to introduce to the delegates of this convention
the Chief Scout Jere Radcliffe.
BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA
Jere Radcliffe, Chief Scout Executive
I’m very much honored to be a part of such a long and distinguished line of presenters
and speakers that you have at your convention. As a matter of fact, I somewhat can relate
to the story of the Chicago Bulls’ basketball player, Stacey King. One night during his
rookie year, his famous teammate, Michael Jordan, scored 69 points. Stacey King’s night
was not so good. He scored only one point. But after the game a reporter wanted Stacey’s
reaction. Stacey said, “Well, I will always remember this as the night that Michael and I
combined for 70 points.”
It’s a great combination of the Boy Scouts of America and The American Legion and
its various Auxiliaries. Together we make a difference in the lives of young people across
America.
It’s exciting to be back in Indianapolis. A little over a year ago your Adjutant and I,
Bob Spanogle, had the opportunity to do a video together that promotes scouting within The
American Legion. It’s out on the road and it’s been well received. I appreciate that
opportunity to expand scouting.
My very first assignment in scouting happened to be in the state of South Carolina in
the upper part of that state, in the area of Greenville where I came to know one of your great
past commanders and one of your great scout leaders, E. Roy Stone, Jr. I look forward to
seeing him here today.
Another part of my background that might be of interest to you is that I took a
sabbatical through the years 1971 to 1974. I served as a district representative for U.S.
Congressman Floyd Spence in the second district of South Carolina. Then I served in the
Armed Services Committee, as it was called in those days, then as chairman of the House
National Security Committee, and then served on the Veterans Affairs Committee. So, I’m
well attuned to the concerns and needs of The American Legion. From a personal
experience, I’m very thankful for the relationship of Scouting and The American Legion.
As a member of Explorer Post 6, Springfield, Ohio, sponsored by the Kultis Ward Post
6,1 had the experience of being Explorer Scout. That experience set for me the direction
in which I have found that I have gone during my life. An Explorer advisor by the name of
Ralph Welch, who is no longer living, had a significant impact on many of the decisions I
still make today.
As was mentioned in the introductions, Scouting and the Legion have been together
since your first convention in 1919. Over those years, it’s been a very profitable partnership
for the organization and particularly for America’s young people. I’m proud to report to you
that within the Scouting units sponsored by Legion and Auxiliary and other units of The
American Legion, that you serve over 72,800 youth and almost 2500 scouts.
And in these times and days when it seems that every American institution that stands
up for something is declining, I’m glad to tell you that over the past four years your increase
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
19
in Scouting has been in excess of 15 percent. And I think there’s some very good reasons
why it makes good sense for our relationship with two organizations. Your Preamble states
clearly some very specific points of significance. Service to God and country, uphold and
defend the Constitution of the United States of America and an individual obligation to
community, state and to nation.
Reflected in the Boy Scout principles are these thoughts: Duty to God and country,
flag, education, character development and citizenship training and community service. I
think nowhere has this relationship been reflected better lately than in the May issue of The
American Legion Magazine. We read an article that stresses the Scouts and Legion working
together on Memorial Day to give tribute to our veterans.
A little story that occurred recently about one of your Scouting units occurred through
the Scout troop that’s sponsored by American Legion Post 784 in Cahokia, Illinois. That
troop has been there for the past 44 years. But a Life Scout by the name of Tommy O’Guinn
recently saved the life of another in a swimming pool near Salem, Missouri.
What makes this story a little more interesting is that the Scout troop, sponsored by the
American Legion Post in Cahokia, is a Scout troop organized for underprivileged or
economically deprived youngsters in that community, given an outreach that would not
occur if that American Legion Post was not there and giving that service.
Another thing that I have noticed about scouting in our organizations is that
Legionnaires tend to stick with things. The fact that the average tenure of one of your Scout
troops is about five times greater than the typical Scout troop across America. You have
many troops that have been in existence since their local posts were organized in the early
times of your movement. So I think my message says it pretty clearly, we’re here because
we are on the same team.
All we have to do today is pick up the newspaper or look at the television set and we
soon come to realize the tremendous challenge that it is to be a youngster in 1995. It’s
related to all types of social and family problems and problems to understand fundamental
responsibilities and to be able to adapt and adopt to a responsible lifestyle. We and our
young people are very much in a state of flux. We’ve seen this trend which is somewhat
detrimental and very negative develop over the past several years. We find that occurs for
one reason because families oftentimes are so engaged in the simple effort of trying to make
ends meet that they lack the time and the effort to be role models and the influence for
positive values that their children should have. We are calloused in many cases to some of
these circumstances.
Last week in the community I live, Fort Worth, Texas, we had a case where a teenager
killed two other teenagers. He knew them. Why did he kill them? To steal a stereo out of
an automobile, a stereo worth $1,000. Before he was caught he tried to pass this off for
$240. A sad story that equates to a sad commentary about things that affect our children, and
the children we are interested in, and the communities we live in.
Much of this, we know, is because of the absence of strong positive role models. In
this changing environment for young people, there is a growing complexity of decisions that
they have to make that will impact their lives. The degree to which they make these
decisions and apply ethics to these decisions will not only influence their lives, but will
truly influence the lives of every community across this great nation.
I had the opportunity a month ago to be in the Czech Republic. Right after the breakup
of the communist block, Scouting began to emerge again in those countries. I met with a
man who had been imprisoned in a concentration camp for 11 years when the communists
20
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
took over, simply because he was a leader in their Scouting movement. He has returned to
be the head of that movement which in some four years has already enrolled some 77,000
young people. I asked him why was he involved? What did he expect? You know,
sometimes when you don’t have something and then you come by it later, you put a little
more value on it than if you had it all along. I know many of you in your lives may feel that
way sometimes.
I asked what did he expect from the Scouting movement with his own people. He
simply said they must develop leadership with values. I had the opportunity last winter to
be out in a new republic of Palau out in Kongauru. And for some of you who come from
the World War II era, if you did time in the Pacific, you know that Kongauru is just a
neighbor to Peleliu. This is an emerging republic. I talked to the president. He is the third
president of Palau, the first two being assassinated. These people are trying to come forth
with a democracy in the 20th century and 21st centuries. I asked him why did he want
Scouting and why did they put a high value on Scouting there. He said, simply because they
must be able to maintain their traditional values in their young people and at the same time
prepare them for the dramatic change that’s going to occur in the world that they live in.
They must maintain their traditional values and prepare for the changes.
Since 1910, the Boy Scouts of America has tried to be monitors of these values. As
we’ve seen values shrink and the ability to make decisions change, we decided a few months
ago to do a study with Lou Harris and Associates from New York. The study was on the
values of men and boys in America. I won’t bore you with all the details, but there were
some results and outcomes of that study that could shock you.
Youngsters in Grades 1 through 12 were asked the following questions, with their
responses: Have you cheated on a homework test recently? 54 percent said yes. Have you
been drunk? 28 percent said yes. Shoplifted? 24 percent said yes. Used drugs like
marijuana, speed? 17 percent said yes. Carried a gun to school? 5 percent said yes.
What the study showed was that as boys become older, this rate of incident multiplies.
And I think it says something to those of us interested in young people. It says we have to
start early and we have to continue. We have to recognize and reinforce positive thoughts
and positive values and ethical behavior early, or it gets away as they get older. This is a
tremendous challenge that faces us all.
We found, too, in this study that the vast majority of those who had been in Scouting
had a different outcome to the response of these questions. And the longer they had been
in Scouting, the better those outcomes were. They seemed to be more socially responsible.
Men who had been in Scouting truly carried that influence forward with them throughout
their lives. They believed in family values. They believed that character growth is fostered
in Scouting and in the family and in other organizations. It is significant that we should
foster that.
Perhaps the most important conclusion that whole study presents to us is that men and
boys in this country need positive role models to reinforce the behavior they should choose.
Many six-year-olds in this country are making decisions from the time they get up in the
morning until they go to bed at night because a parent isn’t there. No one tells them that they
have a respect and a concern for their well-being.
We look at the Legion and the Boy Scouts of America going forward, as we meet this
21st century. I think the values and the representations of those that we see from this
study, and other studies we know about, give us a reason to refocus our efforts on being
advocates for traditional values for young people. Scouting will continue to work diligently
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
21
in cooperation with the Legion and other chartered organizations to assure that those role
models and those values are present for our young people. I think that’s the important
component of our partnership.
As I wind down here, let me challenge you as you go back home to your communities,
to your local Legion organization, to make a contact with your local Scout council. Let us
look back on the rich heritage that we have of 76 years in a partnership and say it can be just
as valuable and important today as ever, because of values we stand for; of those of duty to
God and country and responsible citizenship.
Make a contact with your local Scout council and offer your post or your own services
to be a role model, to be involved, to make a program like Scouting important in your
community. Help in other ways to support the idea that more youngsters should have this
experience.
I close with this little story. A grandfather and a grandson were walking on the beach
one day. The grandfather was picking up starfish and sand dollars which had been thrown
ashore by the tide. There were thousands of them up and down the beach. And yet he
would reach down, pick up one, and throw it back out. Finally the grandson asked him why
he was doing that, as there were thousands of sand dollars there. How can he possibly make
a difference by throwing a few back?
To answer him the grandfather simply reached down, picked up another sand dollar and
threw it back into the ocean. It makes a difference to that one. It makes a difference to that
one.
Scouting is a relationship, not only through scouting but through all your programs,
whether it be baseball, scholarships, or whatever it is, makes a difference. It’s the character
and the moral fiber and the values of leadership that will make the difference. It’s an
understanding of the constitutional government and an understanding of that flag. And I’m
happy to say the Boy Scouts of America was one to sign on in support of you for the Flag
Amendment.
The American flag is the primary symbol of our country and we applaud The American
Legion and the Citizens Flag Alliance (CFA) in their quest to secure the flag-protection
amendment. The Boy Scouts of America will do everything in its power to see that this
important measure becomes the law of the land. The American Legion and Boy Scouts of
America are partners in patriotism, and I can think of no greater act of patriotism than to do
what the vast majority of American citizens want—protect the flag of their country.
The one point is: You make a difference. We in Scouting thank you for that. We
appreciate you. We certainly believe, as you do, that America can be fundamentally sound
if we don’t lose the foundations of value that we’re built on. Thank you for all that you’ve
done and do for this country. Thank you for who you are. And above all, thank you for
what you believe in. Thank you, sir.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I want to make sure that every Delegate
in this hall heard that commitment by the Boy Scouts of America to support the amendment
to protect the United States Flag from physical desecration. Now, we have the little roots.
Let’s utilize those little roots and make them feel a part of an histpric movement for the
people. This is the first time in the history of this country that an amendment to the
Constitution is coming from the people. It’s good that our youth, through the Boy Scouts
of America, are joining with us.
22
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
... At this time, the Delegation viewed a video.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Periodically during the meeting you will be
seeing vignettes and stories that were told and recorded here by some of our Legionnaires
who are present at the Convention, as part of this commemoration.
PRESENTATION OF PLAQUE
Minneapolis, Minnesota
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next order of business is to
recognize the city of Minneapolis, Minnesota. I hold a special place in my heart for
Minneapolis, the site of The American Legion’s first Convention, and the city where the
Delegates elected me as National Commander.
To help with this order of business, I call on Immediate Past National Commander,
Bruce Thiesen of California to make this presentation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER THIESEN: Commander Detweiler, distinguished
guests and Delegates to this, the 77th National Convention.
It is an honor for me to make this presentation, on behalf of myself, my family, those
National Officers that served you in the Diamond Jubilee Year of The American Legion, but
also the National staff. Through the efforts of those who were in charge of the Minneapolis
Convention Corporation under the presidency of Don Schroedl, and of course the
chairmanship of Steve George, it was a success. I can assure you that as I traveled from
Pittsburgh around this country and around the world representing The American Legion in
its Diamond Jubilee Year, we could have found no better place to end what I consider a very
successful year in coming home to Minneapolis to culminate 75 years of The American
Legion.
So on behalf The American Legion, I would like to bring Don Schroedl, the President
of the Minneapolis Convention Corporation, and present to the city of Minneapolis, and to
its Mayor, Sharon Sayles Belton, a Plaque of Appreciation. It states:
The American Legion, in appreciation of the hospitality of the City of
Minneapolis in commemorating the 76th Annual National Convention of
The American Legion, 1994.
It’s attested, signed by myself, the National Commander at that time, attested by Robert
Spanogle, the National Adjutant, and of course Don Schroedl, the President of The
American Legion Convention Corporation of Minneapolis.
Don, on behalf of myself, The American Legion and its three million members, I
would like to present this to the mayor of the city of Minneapolis.
DONALD SCHROEDL
President, The American Legion National Convention
Corporation of Minnesota, Inc.
Mayor Sharon Sayles Belton wants me to express her regrets that she cannot be here
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
23
today to accept this plaque. We have made arrangements with her office that I will present
this plaque to her at a city council meeting later this month.
The hotel and restaurant association, as well as the business community of the city of
Minneapolis and the state of Minnesota want to thank you for coming to our Convention last
year. Minneapolis has hosted four previous conventions. We had the first Convention in
1919, then again in 1959, 1975, and then last year in 1994. We had a great time and
convention. We look forward in the near future to The American Legion coming back to
Minneapolis again.
CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION
Rev. Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: When we recite the Preamble to The
American Legion Constitution, we begin with the words: “For God and Country.”
Since 1919, Legionnaires have remained committed to that lofty purpose for everything
they do. For the past year, it has been a privilege to serve with a man who has dedicated his
life to the highest ideals of such service.
The Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr., served in the United States Navy during World War II.
He has served as the South Carolina Department Chaplain and as Chaplain of American
Legion Post 65 in Saluda, South Carolina. It is with great pride that I present to Reverend
Pryor this Certificate of Appreciation for his caring and devoted service to The American
Legion.
The American Legion Certificate of Appreciation is presented to the
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr., appointed and served as National Chaplain of
The American Legion, 1994-1995, given in recognition of faithful and
honorable service to The American Legion.
It’s attested to by Robert W. Spanogle, our National Adjutant, and signed by myself
as National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair now recognizes Eugene
Lindquist of Minnesota, the Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Children
and Youth for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
CHILDREN & YOUTH
Eugene V. Lindquist (MN), Chairman
The Convention Committee on Children & Youth met at 9:00 a.m. on Saturday,
September 2nd, 1995 in the Indianapolis Convention Center, Room 116. The meeting was
organized by electing Delegate Eugene Lindquist of Minnesota as Chairman, and Delegate
Elmer Fuhrhop of Ohio as Secretary. There were 47 members present at this meeting.
There were no resolutions brought before this Committee for consideration.
We’re just completing our “Seeds for Sight” program in conjunction with the
Foundation Fighting Blindness, which you have known before as the Retinitis Pigmentosa
24
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Foundation. This program has been very successful. There is still some money coming in,
but so far, The American Legion Child Welfare Foundation has received $39,108.65 as its
share of the 50 percent split from the proceeds of this activity. I would like to thank the
Departments of Michigan and Ohio for their great participation and the money that they
gave to this program. That is almost $10,000.00 more than the whole 1993 coupon project
generated and with a lot less administrative work from the staff and volunteers. I thank all
of the Posts and Units that took time to make this activity such a success. It means a great
deal to our Foundation to continue to receive these types of donations that are above and
beyond their regular contributions that are sent.
In conclusion, and as Vice President of the American Legion Child Welfare Foundation
Board of Directors, I thank all those who have supported us through this past year and
sincerely hope you will continue by making your contributions an annual event.
I would also like to thank the SAL Detachments and Squadrons for all they have done.
While it seems incredible that they gave more to the Foundation in the 1993-1994
contribution year than The American Legion, you might be surprised to learn that this past
1994-1995 year they did it again. This time however, they beat the Legion by almost
$4,000.00, by contributing $87,715.28. When you consider the size of our membership and
the number of Posts with the size of their membership and their number of Squadrons, it is
hard to understand how this can happen. We need much more active participation by
individual members of the Legion and from all other Posts, Districts and Departments.
I challenge all of you to take this message back to your Posts and Departments so that
when this report is given next year, we can proudly say that for the 1995-1996 contribution
year, The American Legion was responsible for at least $100,000.00 in donations to the
Foundation. This is a goal that should be easily attainable for this organization of three
million members. The American Legion Department of Florida, for example, this past year
raised just under $20,000.00 by itself, and we commend them for this effort.
Mr. Commander, this concludes my report. 1 move for the adoption of the report.
... National Vice Commander Vernon K. Grosenick assumed the Chair.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
BLOOD DRIVE
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Today is Labor Day. Millions of
Americans are enjoying the three day weekend. At holiday times the blood supply tends to
dwindle. The American Legion National Convention Blood Drive is designed to help.
Today, Delegates are providing critical supplies for the VA Flospital and several other
hospitals in Indianapolis.
This year the National Convention Blood Drive is even more remarkable. Not only are
they collecting whole blood to meet needs but, for the first time, other donors are providing
plasma and platelets, critical blood products.
This is our ninth year for the National Convention Blood Drive. Friday, the opening
day of the drive, 66 units were collected. That’s a good start. But in the next two days I
hope to see the number reach nearly 300 units of blood.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
25
THE AMERICAN LEGION DISPA TCH
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: It’s timely, it’s topical, it’s
thought-provoking. It’s The American Legion Dispatch, the national newspaper of our
organization. Subscribers can receive a collector’s pin if they sign up during the National
Convention.
BUICK PROMOTION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: It’s also appropriate to call your
attention to the display of beautiful 1996 Buicks in the exhibit area. Many of you have been
stopping by, dropping your donations off, and crossing your fingers. Someone will leave
on Wednesday knowing that they have won a 1996 Buick LeSabre. Because of everyone’s
interest, The American Legion-Buick Baseball Scholarship will be strengthened.
CONVENTION OPENING VIDEO
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Before we gavel this Convention
to a close on Wednesday, more than a dozen video productions are re-enforcing the theme:
“World War II Commemorated.” You can purchase a VHS tape with all of these
productions. Place your order at the Emblem Sales booth in the exhibit area. The cost is
$11.95, which includes tax and shipping.
CFA PHONE BANK/POST CARD
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: We are dealing with a wide range
of issues important to all veterans during our 77th National Convention. One of the most
important legislative efforts our organization has undertaken in recent years is seeking
protection of the American Flag from physical desecration. You have an important role to
play in this campaign. Stop by the Phone Bank and Post Card Station at the east end of the
exhibit area and take the time to call or write your Senator to express your support for a
Constitutional Amendment to protect the U.S. Flag from physical desecration. The Citizens
Flag Alliance needs your support.
GARLAND MURPHY AWARD
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The American Legion Child
Welfare Foundation is a tremendous asset to local Posts and the veterans they serve. One
of the active Legionnaires who brought the Child Welfare Foundation to life was Garland
Murphy.
Now is the time to present the award named in his honor. The Garland Murphy award
is presented to the Department that has the most participation in the foundation during the
past program year. This year the winning Department raised $29,307.36 to help the
American Legion Child Welfare Foundation in its work. The winner of the award is the
Department of Ohio.
The Garland Murphy, Jr. Award presented by The American Legion Child
26
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Welfare Foundation to the Department of Ohio for the program year
1994-1995.
In recognition of their designation as the number one Department, in total
contributions received from their volunteers, in support of our annual
programs designed to meet the physical, mental, emotional and spiritual
needs of our nation’s children through productive and meaningful grants.
It is signed by ‘Udie’ Grant, the president of The Child Welfare Foundation, and by
Terry Woodbum, the foundation’s executive secretary.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER JAMES MYERS, OHIO: I accept this plaque for the
Legion families from the Department of Ohio. We challenge all other Departments to move
forward with us in the coming year, because it is an outstanding program.
We thank the Children & Youth Foundation for this award.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The Chair recognizes Ray Smith
of North Carolina, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Americanism for
the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON AMERICANISM
Ray G. Smith (NC), Chairman
Mr. Commander and Delegates to this 77th Annual National Convention of The
American Legion, Your Convention Committee on Americanism met Saturday, September
the 2nd, 1995 in the Indiana Convention Center.
The Committee organized by electing Ray G. Smith of North Carolina as Chairman;
Joseph Caouette of New Hampshire as Vice Chairman, and Gary W. Sammons of Michigan
as the Secretary.
Before I move ahead on the agenda, I want to express my appreciation and that of the
National Americanism Commission to the Buick Motor Division for its continuing support
of The American Legion Baseball Program. During the last year, Buick provided over one
and a half million dollars of assistance to this outstanding Americanism program.
The Committee discussed 13 resolutions which were assigned to the Committee. The
resolutions which were considered continue to reflect the desire by many Departments of
The American Legion to address matters of patriotism and government, and to maintain
strong general Americanism programs that compliment the organization and benefit the
Nation.
Thirteen resolutions were considered, with one being approved; one approved as
amended; four received and recorded; six referred to the standing Americanism
Commission, and one referred to the National Security Commission.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
27
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 16: V-J Day Designation
Origin: CO
Submitted by: Americanism
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization of war veterans who have
dedicated themselves to the community, state and nation; and
WHEREAS, Their dedication during World War II resulted in an extremely high loss
of life as well as the defeat of the aggressor Japan; and
WHEREAS, These veterans both living and dead fought long hard and extremely
arduous battle under extreme conditions to defeat the aggressor Japan during World War II
that was initiated by the latter; and
WHEREAS, Parents of young children and children still unborn should not have to
distort the truth and make excuses to them for the defeat of Japan and the United States was
the injured country, injured in the dastardly attack on Pearl Harbor by Japan during the early
morning hours of December 7, 1941; and
WHEREAS, The political correct attitude should in no way be even considered to alter
the facts of what occurred on “V-J Day”; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That the government of the United States not
be influenced by the aggressor Japan or intimidated by them to delete the term “V-J Day”
from our vocabulary; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That the extreme number of veterans that lost their lives in total combat
will not have their ultimate sacrifice be forgotten to satisfy the political personnel now
involved in international diplomacy; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That the millions of veterans that gave the ultimate sacrifice and those
still living not have their valiant sacrifices and efforts made during World War II be
distorted by political correctness.
Resolution No. 99: Illegal Aliens
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Americanism
As Amended
WHEREAS, Despite various laws and enforcement agencies, the problem of illegal
aliens is growing rapidly and they continue to enter the United States of America by the
thousands, especially along our southern borders through the overcrowded immigration
facilities at our airports, and now by mass smuggling across our coast lines, jeopardizing our
security and our American way of life; and
WHEREAS, Since the United States sends out armed forces around the world to protect
the borders of other countries, we certainly should be willing to protect our own borders to
stop illegal entries; and
WHEREAS, Recently a bipartisan review of the 1986 Immigration Act was completed
and recommends numerous changes to tighten immigrant policy; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion petition the
President of the United States and the Congress to expand and strengthen the Customs and
28
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Immigration Services and the U. S. Coast Guard, and enact such emergency measures as will
prevent smuggling of illegal aliens and stop, detain and deport potential terrorists or those
with ties to terrorist groups; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That as appropriate, military resources be employed to assist in stopping
the flow of illegal aliens into the country, and all of the resources of the United States of
America be utilized to enforce the security of our country’s borders.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED:
Resolution No. 59 (NY) 1995 NC:
United States Language
Resolution No. 60 (NY) 1995 NC:
Anthem
Resolution No. 61 (NY) 1995 NC:
Resolution No. 96 (OH) 1995 NC:
The English Language Be Declared as the Official
Support the Traditional Rendition of the National
POW/MIA Flag Display at Postal Facilities
National Standards for United States History
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
AMERICANISM
Resolution No. 71 (FL) 1995 NC: Wearing of the American Flag Patch
Resolution No. 76 (PI) 1995 NC: Certification of Filipino Service Records
Resolution No. 77 (PI) 1995 NC: Filipino Veterans Family Immigration
Resolution No. 78 (PI) 1995 NC: Reopen Period for Filipino Filing of Naturalization
Applications
Resolution No. 134 (VA) 1995 NC: American Legion Middle School Essay Program
Resolution No. 135 (NC) 1995 NC: Prayer for POW/MIA
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 22 (MT) 1995 NC: Militia Organizations
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN SMITH: Mr. Commander that concludes my report. And
as a duly elected Delegate to this Convention, I move for the adoption of this Report.
... Motion was seconded and carried.
THE FRANK N. BELGRANO, JR. TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: With the adoption of the
Americanism report, it is appropriate to announce the winners of two Americanism awards.
The Frank Belgrano, Jr. Award is given annually to the Department rendering the most
outstanding service to the Boy Scouts of America Program during the 12 month period
beginning August 1st. This year’s winner is the Department of Maryland.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
29
RALPH T. O’NEIL EDUCATION TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The Ralph T. O’Neil Education
Award is given to the Department within the United States documenting the greatest activity
in using The American Legion School Medal Program. This year’s winner is the
Department of Florida.
WILLIAM RANDOLPH HEARST AMERICANISM TROPHY
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: We recognize the one Department
achieving the most outstanding results in conducting Americanism programs. The winning
Department was selected by the National Americanism Commission on the basis of total
resources, manpower, as well as financial support, devoted to Americanism activities during
the Legion program year. The William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy is an
impressive award named in the honor of one of American journalism’s most prominent and
influential figures. With us today to announce the winner of the 1995 William Randolph
Hearst Americanism Trophy, is Otto Wick, Jr. Mr. Wick.
PRESENTATION
WILLIAM RANDOLPH HEARST AMERICANISM TROPHY
Otto Wick, Jr., Vice President and Publisher
Midland Daily News, Midland, Michigan
I’m honored both as a veteran myself and a member of this great organization, and as
a representative of the Hearst Corporation to present the William Randolph Hearst
Americanism Award for the seventh time. It was my pleasure to present this award in New
Orleans in 1978.
While I never personally met Mr. Hearst, I have been employed by his newspaper
group for 32 years. During that time I have learned that nothing could be more appropriate
than an award for Americanism in Mr. Hearst’s honor. He was unabashedly an American.
His newspapers pride themselves in their Americanism. It is a heritage he left that marks
each of his newspapers today. I think the best way to demonstrate this is not with my words,
but with his.
On November 20, 1920, the signed editorial entitled "Democracy Means Americanism"
appeared over Mr. Hearst’s signature in each of the Hearst newspapers. Allow me to share
part of that editorial with you. "Democracy means concrete things. It means the greatest
good for the greatest number. It means liberty, equality, opportunity, the cornerstone on
which our Republic rests. It means freedom; freedom of thought; freedom of speech;
freedom of publication and discussion; freedom of action within the law.
It means loyalty and devotion to our land, and to the aims and aspirations of our own
people. And it means an abstinence from the hatred and contention of foreign peoples, and
from entangling alliances with foreign nations, against which all great democrats of our
history, all the great Americans of our history have warned us.
Democracy means progress, but it means progress along the established line. Progress
in an orderly manner. Democracy means Americanism; it means concern for the people and
particular concern for our own people. It means liberty; equality; justice; independence.
The essential things this Republic was founded to secure."
30
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
As I said earlier, Mr. Hearst was proud of his Americanism. He wanted others to have
that pride, and he worked hard to encourage it.
Sometimes the rhetoric we hear about how Americans should act or what you should
do, muddies the water a bit, but I think that if we all could hold on to the clear vision of
Americanism that Mr. Hearst obviously had, we would all be better off.
Mr. Hearst’s Americanism was not complicated, it was not philosophical. It was
concrete. He believed in liberty; equality; justice; independence, the essential things this
republic was founded to secure.
It’s with a great sense of honor and pride both with my association with the Hearst
Corporation and in my Americanism, that I present this award on behalf of the Hearst
Corporation and in memory of William Randolph Hearst to the Department of Vermont.
Accepting the Hearst Trophy is Alan Grazini, immediate Past President, Department
Commander; George Bille, Department Commander, and Joe Murphy, Alternate National
Executive Committeeman.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: For me, the next part of today’s
business session is a great highlight. It is time to meet the outstanding young men and
women who have distinguished themselves through involvement in American Legion youth
programs. It is an honor to present to the Delegation of our 77th National Convention, the
youth champions of the year.
1995 BOYS NATION PRESIDENT
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our first champion is a young man
who was elected president of Boys Nation, and who is looking forward to someday
becoming a motivational speaker. He’s an Eagle Scout, was Governor of Oklahoma Boys
State, is active in student government, and has received plenty of recognition for his efforts.
He’s sponsored by the Hill-Huett Post 260 in his hometown of Tecumseh, Oklahoma.
Please welcome Rick Lam, Jr.
RICK LAM, JR.
1995 Boys Nation President
I would like to thank all of the members of The American Legion and friends and
guests for so graciously inviting me to be here to speak to you this morning.
They asked me to talk about Boys Nation, what the program does and what the program
means to me. It’s pretty hard to sum up an entire weeks worth of experiences into just a few
minutes, but I’m going to try.
I think if there is one main theme that I learned from Boys Nation is that we must have
faith. There are several things that I believe we must have faith in.
First, we have to have faith in our system, the American system. Our system has
worked for over 200 years, and while not being perfect, it’s the best form of government that
our world has ever seen. The American dream has to still exist, and for that to happen we
have to have faith in the American system.
Another thing we must have faith in is our leaders. We must continue to choose the
leaders that put forth character and that are the epitome of the kind of people that we want
in power. We have to choose our leaders wisely and must have faith in the ones that we
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
31
choose.
The third thing that we have to have faith in is ourselves and each other as Americans.
Remember, that we are above all else children of God. This is our country, and it was
founded by Americans. It’s led by fellow Americans, but not as a king or dictator. We have
to have faith in Americans so that we ourselves can uphold and maintain our great system.
And finally, we have to have faith in our future. We have to make sure that we have
children who are well equipped to handle the future. These children have to be intelligent,
they have to be able to solve the problems that they are going to face, and they have to have
character and integrity.
Through the programs that The American Legion sponsors, such as Boys Nation, I
believe that our future is in great hands. Boys Nation develops capable youth with character
and courage. Andrew Jackson once said: "One man with courage makes a majority." And
that’s exactly the kind of courage that our founding fathers of our country had.
With the continued support of the programs like Boys Nation, we will continue to build
our country’s leaders. For proof that this program works, we need to look no further than
the White House. It was only a matter of time until a Boys Nation alumnus landed there,
and it’s only a matter of time until it happens again.
Everyone has been gracious to us, here in Indianapolis. In my dealings that I have had
with The American Legion since going to the local Post in Tecumseh where my dad is a
member, I think there’s one thing, one lesson that I have learned from The American
Legion. The lesson is that whenever I see the American Flag go by in a parade whenever I
see the American Flag being brought forward for us to salute, and when I see the American
Flag raised at a football game or a sporting event to be saluted, I’m going to stand up and
salute that Flag. And it’s not because I was Governor of Oklahoma Boys State; and it’s not
because I was president of Boys Nation; it’s not just because I’m a member of the Citizens
Flag Alliance or because I’m an Eagle Scout, it’s because I choose to, and that’s the kind
of faith we need to have in America again.
I thank you for helping to instill this kind of faith in the youth of our nation.
In a religious service that I offered to a group of Boy Scouts about a year ago, I
summed up my feelings about faith in a very simple expression: Faith is not belief without
proof, but trust without reservation. Let us continue to have faith in America.
God bless you, God bless The American Legion, and God bless America. Thank you.
JUNIOR SHOOTING SPORTS PRECISION CHAMPION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our 1995 Junior Shooting Sports
Champion has established some records that will be hard to beat. He’s the only Junior
Shooter to win both Sporter and Precision in back-to-back years. He broke two records and
established a third last year. They still stand. This year he tied two records and broke
another.
Sponsored by American Legion Post Number 134 in Cherokee, North Carolina, please
welcome Terry Bradley.
TERRY BRADLEY
1995 Junior Shooting Sports Precision Champion
I bring you a proud hello from Cherokee and my sponsor American Legion Post 143.
32
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
I’m very honored to be a part of your Convention, because it is you who bring honor to this
great nation. Post 143 sponsors me and the Junior ROTC Program, and our rifle team at my
school. They see that we are provided with the best equipment and other things needed for
competition.
Until this Convention, I knew very little about The American Legion. But now I will
take back valuable knowledge of important programs that you sponsor, like educational
scholarships, child welfare, benefits for veterans, and the most pressing issues of preserving
the right of the people to decide on major issues like the desecration of our beloved flag.
Rest assured that I will leave this great city well-informed on the purpose and actions
of The American Legion. I’m truly impressed with the power, strength, love and
compassion that is most evident in each person here. With all of these great qualities, The
American Legion will be around for some time to come.
At this time I would like to comment on a person who represents the Army with honor
and pride, the person who has been instrumental in molding me into the person I am today.
He has taught me things no other teacher in the world could teach me, the ability to truly
believe in myself. The person I speak of is the greatest shooting coach in the world, Colonel
Thomas Johnson. Though he’s not physically with me today, he will always be beside me,
encouraging me and keeping me on the right path.
My family has also been super supportive of me. They have been patient and
understanding, especially my sister. She didn’t get too mad when I shot the heads off her
little dolls. Even though I won’t let her watch me shoot, my mom, Carol, gets a little
excited. Shooting is not a spectator sport.
Thanks also to the other Youth Champions. I have enjoyed sharing the past few days
with them. Thank you for allowing me a look into your lives and your futures. With your
strength, determination and ambition, you will do great things and make this nation proud.
I would also like to give a great thanks to our escort and friend Mike Buss, who has
been no less than excellent. Like all veterans, he has performed above and beyond the call
of duty a countless number of times.
1995 ORATORICAL CHAMPION
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Our next youth champion is
considering a law career. He’s developing critical skills, as your National High School
Oratorical Contest Winner. A senior in high school, he’s considering attending Princeton
University next year.
From Ballston Lake, New York, sponsored by Mohawk Post 1450, please welcome the
1995 Oratorical champion, Aron Egner.
ARON S. EGNER
1995 National Oratorical Contest Winner
When I first decided to do the Oratorical Contest, I had one simple goal: to win. I
wasn’t really concerned for, nor did I think too much about, what would happen to me along
the way while I was striving to reach that goal. I soon discovered, however, that the
Oratorical Contest isn’t just about reaching your goal, it’s about reaching for your goal, and
about what happens to you along the way.
My main speech was about voting, and in it I reminded people of their voting
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
33
responsibilities, and pointed out that those who failed to vote have no right to complain
about the failings of our government because they have failed in the most elemental duty of
citizenship. They were turning their backs on freedom.
In writing the speech and coming up with my own solutions and conclusions to solve
the problems of political apathy, I was forced to learn firsthand what the Constitution said;
what the Constitution meant; how it succeeded and how it failed. Along the way to my goal
I developed a very deep respect for America and for the ideals that it upholds. Along the
way I came to appreciate not only the benefits of citizenship, but the accompanying
responsibilities. But perhaps most importantly, I made countless friends from age sixteen
to age ninety-six.
As I stand here today and look out on the many, many familiar faces, I’m proud to say
that what I gained along the way was more important to me than my original, somewhat
narrow-minded goal of simply winning the contest. Still, I must admit the scholarship
money was a nice little added benefit.
Actually it was much more than that. In five days, I’ll be at Princeton University
majoring in politics. Without the Oratorical Contest and the nearly $30,000 in scholarships,
I never would have been able to afford the school, nor would I have realized that I want to
make a career out of public service.
But keep in mind that mine is just one story, just one life that was changed. I wish you
members knew just how many lives you really are affecting. Each of us here today knows
that we can’t always win, but everyone in the Oratorical Contest and the other Legion youth
programs, even if they don’t win, get to enjoy the same experience that I did. They learned.
They discovered a love for the Nation. They find new friends, and they do all of it as I did,
not necessarily by winning, but by challenging themselves along the way.
Now, most of the stories you will never hear. Most of the students that develop an
understanding and respect for the Constitution probably won’t bother to tell you. Most of
the kids that realized the power and the potential of words probably won’t take the time to
let you know. But rest assured that they are out there.
The 17 year-old-boy who gets up in front of his social studies class and is fully
confident in his speaking abilities, will be forever grateful to you.
The 34-year-old lawyer who gave a speech on Amendment 1 for her extemporaneous
section in the Oratorical Contest, and is now defending that same amendment in the
Supreme Court, will be forever grateful to you.
The 40-year-old Senator who’s doing what he believes is right based on the
constitutional law he first learned in the Oratorical Contest, will be forever grateful to you.
The 56-year-old admiral who must give a little speech and a lot of courage to his men
before they go into combat, will be forever grateful to you.
On behalf of the hundreds of thousands of others who have been involved with this
program, thank you. We will be forever grateful to you.
1994 BASEBALL PLAYER OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The 1994 American Legion
Baseball Player of the Year is our next champion. He is a sophomore at Florida
International University, preparing for a business career. This young man looked very
impressive on the mound last year in Boyertown. He won four games; lost none. His earned
run average was 0.00 for more than 32 innings. This pitching performance led the Miami,
34
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Florida Post No. 346 team to the championship of Legion Baseball last year.
Please welcome a terrific ball player, Fernando Rodriguez.
FERANDO RODRIQUEZ
1994 Baseball Player of the Year
I thank The American Legion for giving me this great honor of being here with you all
today. What I experienced last year playing for The American Legion has been the biggest
thrill of my life. Maybe one day I will be challenged with the opportunity of winning
another championship game. Nothing surpasses the thrill of winning your first
championship game. And this, along with my college scholarship, I owe to The American
Legion.
I especially would like to recognize three Legionnaires who did an outstanding job with
The American Legion, its baseball program and youth program. These are Chairman, Ray
Smith, Mr. Jim Quinlan and Mr. Mike Buss.
Secondly, 1 want to thank the two most important persons in my life who are here with
me on this very special day, my mother, Rita, and my father, Migel. If it hadn’t been for
my mother taking me to practice everyday after work, and my father’s unwavering
confidence and support, I would not be here. I cannot forget my brother, Migel, his constant
challenge and competitiveness keeping me on my toes. And my little sister Alex, who
passed away a few months before the tournament who was my biggest inspiration.
Also, I would like to mention my head coach, Carlos Hernandez, the coaching staff, and
the rest of my teammates who should be standing here with me today.
And finally, I cannot leave here today without thanking God, who bestowed on me the
honor of having been bom in this great country where my baseball playing abilities are
recognized and developed.
1995 SCOUT OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: The American Legion Scout of the
Year could not be with us today. He’s beginning his college education at the US Military
Academy and couldn’t sneak away for the weekend. For his efforts, this young man,
sponsored by Brewster Cleveland Post No. 86 in Cedartown, Georgia, deserves our
recognition. Please give a warm round of applause for Zachary Lee Thomas.
... National Commander Detweiler assumed the chair.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: With our Youth Champions still on the
stage, it is appropriate to introduce our next guest. He is the President and CEO of Samsung
North America. I shared several warm moments with him during the recent dedication of
the Korean War Veterans Memorial in Washington, DC. Because of Samsung’s generosity,
some children of American veterans will be getting much needed financial help for college.
Please welcome Bo-Soon Song.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
35
BO-SOON SONG
President and CEO Samsung North America
First of all, I would like to thank Mr. Vice National Commander and members of The
American Legion for inviting me to partake in your annual convention. It is a great pleasure
for me to be here today.
On behalf of Samsung, I would like to pay tribute to those of you who served your
country to sustain peace throughout the world. Samsung recognizes the sacrifices and
commitment of U.S. servicemen and servicewomen, and we are especially grateful to those
of you who helped to maintain the security of the Korean peninsula during the Korea war.
Samsung also recognizes and commends the great efforts of The American Legion. Not
only is The American Legion the largest veterans’ organization in the United States, it is
deeply involved in educational programs devoted to the young people of America. At
Samsung we share a mutual respect for education. As a global company that is involved in
many of the fastest growing industries, we understand firsthand the need for an educated,
current and future work force. We, too, realize that the future of tomorrow lies with our
children and grandchildren. The greatest contribution a company can make is to support the
young people in their academic endeavors. We believe the best way to show our
appreciation to the United States and to the U.S. war veterans is to offer educational
opportunities to the children and grandchildren of American war veterans.
Last month, Samsung pledged to endow a $5 million scholarship fund to be
administered by The American Legion. This fund is called the Samsung American Legion
Scholarship.
Today we would like to present the $5 million check to The American Legion. It is
Samsung’s hope that this scholarship program will make a difference in the lives of
American students, and that Americans will accept this gesture as sincere gratitude for their
support.
... At this time there was presentation of a $5 million check.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is a leader in every sense
of the word. Perhaps he developed those skills as a young man growing up in Kansas during
the great depression and the dust storms of the prairie. Perhaps he developed those skills
as a platoon leader with the 10th Mountain Division in Italy during World War II where he
was seriously wounded twice and received two Purple Hearts with a bronze star — a Bronze
Star with Oak Leaf Cluster. Wherever his skills were developed, America has certainly
benefitted from them. It is my pleasure to ask you to welcome the Senate Majority Leader
and a proud Legionnaire from the Department of Kansas, Bob Dole.
THE HONORABLE ROBERT J. DOLE
Majority Leader United States Senate
[Senator Dole’s speech was often interrupted by applause]
We have some people from Kansas out there somewhere in the audience. I don’t see
them right now. They are on the far right where they belong.
No doubt about it, speaking to this convention is a great honor, and as I look out at all
the patriots who belong to The American Legion I can’t help but recall that perhaps the first
36
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
speech I made outside Kansas was in an American Legion hall in Indiana.
I was a freshman congressman and the local dinner committee knew they had to find
some way to get people to come. Nobody knew who I was and they didn’t care who I was.
They thought they would send me out to the local radio station where the announcer was
supposed to interview me to boost attendance.
We did have an interview but it wasn’t very accurate. He began with less than an
accurate rendition of my resume. 1 remember he said at the time that the guest at that night’s
dinner would be Congressman Bob Doyle. He will speak at The American Legion hall,
tickets had been slashed from $3.00 to $1.00. They were going to give away a color TV set,
but you had to be present to win. They were not going to draw until Doyle gets through
talking. He went on to say that Doyle was bom in Kansas, raised in Kansas, educated in
Kansas. He fought in Italy where he suffered a serious head injury and then went into
politics. So, that’s how it all got started.
I don’t know how you came here today. I’m sure they didn’t promise you a TV set, but
I understand there are at least, maybe, 200 from my home state and I know there are many
more. It’s hard to see when you are up here, but I know there’s a lot of people out there.
You are freedom’s heroes and American patriots and I’m proud to be among you. Each
of you have answered America’s call, whether it was to fight for our freedom or to defend
the peace in which we have prospered for so many years. Each of you know what it’s like
to wear the uniform of our country, to put your country first and to be willing to bear any
sacrifice to keep her free. And I assure you that we will never forget our obligation to those
who have worn the uniform in service to this great nation.
I know you support efforts to balance the federal budget, to stop the flow of red ink
that threatens the future of our children and our grandchildren. I also know that as veterans
you are very properly concerned about funding for the activities of the Department of
Veteran Affairs. Yes, we are going to balance the federal budget because it’s necessary.
And every program is going to be scrutinized with the exception of Social Security. But the
budget will not be balanced on the backs of America’s veterans; we have too much invested.
You and I know many who had the privilege of serving in the armed forces, and
because of that we are the freest country and the freest people on earth. You and I know that
we must stay that way. We must remain the strongest country on the face of the earth for
peace; that’s all we want is peace, peace. And that’s what I want to talk with you just for
a few moments today.
Keep America strong, in her mind and in her heart and in the face of external enemies
and in the presence of threats from within. America is still the land of the free and the home
of the brave. A great century of hope and opportunity is about to unfold before us. But
some in America believe our might is no longer needed. And some think our definition,
yours and mine, of what it means to be an American is out-of-date, that somehow we’re out
of touch. And of course neither is true.
Can there be any doubt that the world is still a dangerous place? True, the cold war is
over. We’ve won one of humanity’s greatest struggles against totalitarianism and
oppression. But today peace is threatened and dark forces are multiplying in almost every
comer of the world. The evil empire may be gone that President Reagan talked about, but
its missiles still exist in a volatile, unstable and unpredictable region. Despite our protests
Russia is selling nuclear arms to Iran. Iraq is manufacturing gruesome biological and
chemical weapons. North Korea will soon have a nuclear capability. And China is arming
Pakistan with nuclear missiles while just across their contested border, India already has
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
37
them. And central Europe is being eaten away by ethnic war and genocide.
The United Nations is impotent and until last week, the U.N. was calling the shots for
NATO. Now should be a time for greater vigilance, yet Washington seems filled with
people who want to dismantle our defenses. One thing I think is clear, regardless of our
political philosophy or party affiliation, I believe we must go back and look at what’s
happened. Our defense budget has been cut too far and too fast. And I think we’re now on
a path that would have ended with America spending about as much as our gross national
product on defense as we were when Pearl Harbor was attacked. That’s a big, big drop.
But the good news is that Congress refused to go along this year [with cuts]. We
rejected the policy that would lead us back to a hollow military. We kept the faith and we
increased spending on defense. I’ve always felt that if I was the President of the United
States and I had a choice of spending maybe a little too much or not spending enough, I’m
going to opt for spending a little too much. It seems to me that’s where the future is and
that’s what America is all about.
The demands of freedom require us to modernize our forces, to maintain our
technological edge, and to insure that America remains the world’s one and only
superpower. And we will never apologize for that. Our goal is not just to be strong enough
to turn back a threat. We must also be so strong that no one ever again be tempted to
threaten us at all. That’s what it’s all about, that’s where we need to be in the future.
But if we are going to return America to greatness we must do more than restore
America’s defenses. We must return as a people to the original concept of what it means to
be American. This means tackling subjects the arbitrators of political correctness don’t even
want discussed. For example, English must be recognized as America’s official language.
Western tradition and American greatness must be taught in our schools. The federal
government must end its war on traditional American values. America has always been more
than just a place on a map; it has held a claim on our hearts. We are a nation dedicated to
a proposition that all men and women are created equal, endowed by our Creator with
certain inalienable rights.
Our forefathers rejected race and religion as a basic force to form a nation, choosing
instead the ideals of freedom and democracy. It was a radical gamble at the time and ever
since we have held it to be an article of faith that those who would be American must first
abandon lesser allegiances. As Franklin Roosevelt, the Commander-in-Chief in my
generation, he said: “Americanism is not and never was a matter of race and ancestry.”
Succeeding waves of immigrants have been drawn to America by this idea. And
lacking the centuries-old primal bond of other nations, we have used our language, our
history and our code of values to make the American experiment work. We have used them
to forge millions of diverse individuals into one people with a common purpose.
Language, history and values: these are the strings that bind the hearts of America.
These are the forces that have held us together, allowing us to be diverse and yet united. To
absorb untold millions of immigrants while coming the closest that any country ever has to
the classless upwardly mobile society of our ideals. But these keys to unity are under attack
from our government and from intellectual elites who seem embarrassed by America. What
we see as an opportunity, they see as oppression. What we see as a proud past, they see as
a legacy of shame. What we hold as moral truth, they call intolerance. They have false
theories, long dissertations and endless studies to back them up. They know so much. But
somehow they missed the fact that the United States of America is the greatest force for
good the world has ever known.
38
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Yes, we have our faults, but part of what makes me so proud to be an American is the
constant effort of our people to do better, to make our country right and good and just.
Unfortunately some policies and programs borne out of that desire have gone awry. Begun
for the best of reasons and then hijacked by the ‘embarrassed-to-be-American crowd’,
certain federal programs are untying the strings of citizenship.
Affirmative action is one of those programs. Instead of making things better, it has
made things worse. No amount of tinkering can rescue it. It was never supposed to be
permanent. We know it has failed. Let’s stop dividing Americans by race and gender and
get back to the simple principle of equal treatment for all Americans. All Americans ought
to be treated alike regardless of their background, regardless of their color, regardless of
their economic status.
That’s why I have introduced legislation which prohibits the federal government from
ever using quotas, set-asides, or other race-based preferences in any form. Whether in
employment, contracting or any other federal program, our government must be in the
business of bringing our citizens closer together, not tearing us apart, not dividing us into
classes.
But nowhere is the focus on what divides us more alarmingly than what is happening
in our schools. The debate about what we teach our children is really a debate about who
we are as a people, and whether we are one people anymore at all. Do we embrace ideas that
unite us regardless of our sex or color or religion, or are we just a jostling crowd of
competing groups thrown by fate between two oceans.
One of the most important missions of our schools is to make citizens of our children.
And I believe that fluency in English should be a central educational goal of every state in
our nation. English is a language in which we still speak to each other across the frontiers
of culture and race. It is the language of the Constitution. It is the language in which we
conduct our great national debates, an essential ingredient of democracy. And insisting that
all our citizens are fluent in English is a welcoming act of inclusion. And insist on it we
must, otherwise, they are going to fall behind.
And I agree, yes, schools should provide the language classes our immigrants and their
families need as long as their primary purpose is the teaching of English. We have done this
since our founding to speed the melting of our melting pot. But we must stop the practice
of multilingual education as a means of instilling ethnic pride, or as a therapy for low esteem
or out of elitist guilt of a culture built on traditions of the West. With all the divisive forces
tearing at our country, we need the glue of language to help hold us together. If we want
to insure that all of our children have the same opportunities in life, alternative language
education is to be stopped and English should be acknowledged once and for all as the
official language of the United States of America.
And speaking of elitist guilt, yes, there have been dark moments in our past. There are
still cruel elements in our culture. We should not sanitize them when we teach our children
the history of America and western civilization. But we should not proselytize them either,
as too many educators and professors in our schools and universities today are attempting
to do. There is a shocking campaign afoot among educators at all levels, most evident in the
National History Standards already distributed to more than 20,000 teachers, administrators
and professors, to disparage America and disown the ideas and traditions of the West. Let
me give you a couple of examples of what I mean.
The History Standards were prepared with over $2 million in grants from the U.S.
Department of Education and the National Endowment for Humanities. They suggest that
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
39
we teach our students about America by concentrating on some of our worse moments, such
as the scourge of McCarthyism and the rise of the Ku Kiux Klan. George Washington is
never even described as our first president in this approach. Alexander Graham Bell, and
Thomas Edison, and Paul Revere disappear from the history of America. And the first time
the Constitution is mentioned, it is blamed for sidetracking the movement to end slavery.
Now if you are a student, and after years of that, would you love America? Probably not.
The purpose of the National History Standards seems not to teach our children certain
essential facts about our history, but to denigrate Americans story while sanitizing and
glorifying other cultures. This is wrong and it threatens us as surely as any foreign power
ever has. We must use a bully pulpit to make it clear that we will not stand still and allow
this campaign to be inflicted upon our children and our grandchildren across America.
Liberal academic elites control more than our schools, of course. Any institution touched
by a government is ripe for inspection, which is why we see this disdain for America
turning up in government-funded television, art and now, even our museums. The
Smithsonian [Institution] created a display to commemorate the anniversary of Hiroshima,
the day we effectively won a global war against the forces of evil. The message of the
Smithsonian was that the dropping of the bomb was an act of American violence against
Japanese culture. Somehow the Japanese were painted not as the aggressors but as the
victims of World War II. Veteran’s groups, like The American Legion which led the effort,
were dismissed as special interests who couldn’t be objective. That’s right. If you put your
life on the line for America, if you love this country so much you are willing to die for it,
maybe you do belong to a special interest, but that special interest used to be called the
people of the United States of America, and that’s the difference.
And if you had predicted the Smithsonian debacle to the soldiers crawling up the beach
in Okinawa, they never would have believed you. Today, even Japan has finally apologized
for its atrocities and aggression. So maybe it’s time the ‘embarrassed-about-America’ crowd
gets the message too, that we are proud of our country, we are proud of America. That’s why
we are here today, that’s why you’re here today, because we are the greatest country on the
face of the earth and that’s what America is all about.
We won’t put up with our tax dollars being used to drag it down or sow doubt about
the nobility of America in the minds of our children. They are the future of this country.
We must remember our children embrace what they learn, the American idea is not
automatic. We must teach them what we were taught and what we know to be true; that this
country is one of history’s most magnificent ideas. Our children must come to value
freedom as dearly as every refugee fleeing persecution who sailed or swam or scrambled
here to find it, as much as every soldier who died to preserve it. America must be in their
hearts as well as in their heads. It takes just one generation to snap the chain of freedom,
one generation for a nation based on an idea to forget who we are.
One of the most powerful symbols we use to remind ourselves of this, of course, is Old
Glory, the flag. Our flag is more than a piece of cloth. It is the embodiment of our sacred
ideals. I grew up as you all did, holding my hand over my heart and pledging allegiance to
it. Perhaps one of our problems is that too few of us do that anymore. We ought to teach
our children at an early age to respect the flag. We certainly ought to stop its public
denigration and I’m proud to stand with The American Legion in supporting a
Constitutional Amendment to protect our flag.
I just told your National Commander that we are going to bring it up this year. Don’t
worry about it. It’s going to come up in the United States Senate before the year is out. We
40
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
are going to need some votes as we are one or two short. There are always one or two over
there that just can’t decide. It happened on the balanced budget. Remember, we lost by one
vote. Regulatory reform, we lost by one vote. So we are going to need your help. We are
going to need your help. This is a priority for The American Legion, for a hundred other
organizations all across America, the newest group being the Boy Scouts of America.
Now, if we want to protect our flag and make it part of the Constitution, we will have
to send it out to the states and let them make the decisions. We [in the Senate] ought to do
it as soon as we can and I pledge to the Commander right now, we are going to do it this
year.
[The flag] is the value issue with me. Which brings me to the subject of values,
something I spoke a lot about this summer. To put it simply, values do count, not just in our
lives but in our society. I don’t care how strong our economy will become in the future it
will never be strong enough to transform a neighborhood where 80 percent of the children
lack a father and legitimate jobs are dismissed as ‘chump change.’
There will never be enough prisons or police to enforce order in our society if there is
growing disorder in our souls. The vast majority of Americans still hold fast to the values
that made America great. But now we must do more than just live by them. We must speak
out about our values and insist that our culture and our government reflect them. Yes, this
means braving ridicule of the cultural elites and then speaking out about our popular
entertainment, our movies and music, advertising and television. They do have a profound
impact on our children and it’s not for the good.
It’s much harder to rise out of the poverty when the culture derides the values that made
it possible. It’s much harder for society to control crime when role models preach impulsive
violence and those who would market evil through commerce, hate the light of scrutiny. But
I will continue my freedom campaign as you continue your freedom efforts to call them to
account. I will name their names until they feel the shame their actions deserve.
Time Warner, the producer of some of the foulest rap music, has already begun to have
second thoughts, and others will too. This is not a matter of right and left, this is a matter of
right and wrong, and we ought to speak out on a matter of right and wrong.
I said something awhile back, which wasn’t part of a speech. Somebody said, “Why,
he’s just too old fashioned.” What did I talk about? I talked about love of God, and country
and family; commitment to honesty and decency and personal responsibility, and
self-reliance tempered by a sense of community. I thought those were the values that made
us the greatest country on the face of the earth. There’s no doubt in my mind that we can
get back on the right track if we reassert the values again to our people, and if our
government returns the values to the nation as national policy.
Everywhere in the world we see examples of nations divided against themselves. The
tragedy of Bosnia is the most recent most horrifying, example of where we waited and
waited and waited. Thousands and thousands of innocent women and children were
slaughtered. I’m not suggesting sending ground troops but it seems to me what we’re doing
now could have been done months and months beforehand. By now we might be having
a real peace settlement. But in any event, we are finally doing the right thing. I commend
those who are flying the missions. I commend NATO for taking charge. For too long they
have been under the thumb of the United Nations. The last time I checked, nobody in the
United Nations was on the ballot anywhere in America. And if we are going to make
decisions committing our soldiers and our airmen, Navy, or whatever, it ought to be made
by the president of the United States and not Boutros Boutros-Ghali at the United Nations.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
41
So we see the tragedy in Bosnia. Even placid Canada today is threatened by ethnic
separatism. But the idea of America, if we hold onto, it is what will save us from that fate.
Back in 1874 a black high school principal in Ohio said, “In language, in civilization, in
fears and in hopes we are Americans.” We are defined not by our blood lines but by our
beliefs. And in this beautiful new world we have created a nation out of overcoming
differences with freedom.
But our freedom cannot be taken for granted. We must always insure its defense. We
do have diversity and should have diversity. It requires us to bind ourselves to the American
ideal in every way that we can. By speaking one language, by taking pride in our true
history, and by embracing the traditional American values which have guided us from the
beginning, these are the ways we remember who we are. Free individuals united by
democracy in the world’s newest, greatest and still evolving race, the nation of Americans.
I’m now speaking particularly to the World War II out there. I often wonder why there
weren’t more celebrations at the end of World War II. But I remember D-Day very well.
Maybe some of you were there as I was. I will just close with a story that made an
impression on me.
A lot of these veterans took their kids and their grandkids to the commemorations. I
guess your kids and grandkids never imagine us being 17, 18, 19-year-olds. They don’t
recall their granddad ever being that young, 19 or 20. But these were the men, in some cases
women too, who were on the beaches and in the air all over the world fighting for freedom
for us and millions of other people around the world. Remember we got a late start in World
War II. We had to come from behind in World War II. I looked into the faces of those
young people, the children in their 40s, the grandchildren in their 20s. As you looked into
the faces, you could see the emotion, you could see the tears and I said if only every
American could be here today.
Now 50 years is a long time. Then we had Korea, Vietnam, the Gulf War, Somali and
Haiti. But the point I would like to make is this, again talking specifically to my generation,
the World War II veterans. About four or five years ago when the Berlin Wall collapsed and
Communism collapsed, people started coming to America from all these different countries,
whether it was Poland or Hungry or the former Republic of the Soviet Union. They were
young and old, and men and women. Some had been locked up in jail for years because
they stood up and spoke out against the government. They came to see us as the leaders of
Congress. Almost without exception, they would say when they left something like this and they would speak in a very emotional way, with tears streaming down their cheeks in
some cases. You know what they said? They didn’t say give us foreign aid. They didn’t
say give us anything. They said they wanted to be like America. Finally they had the right
to vote and the right to worship. They had the right to send their children to school. They
had a right to travel, something we take for granted. They could pick-up the telephone.
They had that right without somebody tapping the other end.
All these basic rights suddenly were available to these 500 million people, who had
a little taste of freedom because of us, because of people in this audience and because of
Presidents Reagan and Bush, and yes, Carter, they didn’t give up but kept the pressure on.
We paid for it with taxes when we increased our defense, but the result was that 500 million
people are free.
We have opportunities now for a generation of peace. That’s why it’s so important to
pay a price for leadership. You do it every day in your business, whatever you may do. We
pay a price as a country for leadership. President Nixon wrote a book just before his death.
42
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
He said the American people are tired of the burden of leadership. They would like to give
it to somebody else. Ask yourself who? The Chinese, Japanese, Germany? No. It always
comes back to us and we pay a price for it. It’s called taxes. You pay a price. There’s no
alternative. There is no alternative. That’s why we continue talking about the greatness of
America. It’s not arrogance. It’s not conceit. It’s not immodest.
We are the leaders of the free world and we have a tremendous responsibility and
challenge. But we also have opportunities. We want to avoid war. We want someday to
see that there isn’t any American Legion or any other veteran’s group because there hasn’t
been any wars. That’s what America is all about and that’s what the future is all about.
You’ve made it possible and I’m honored to be here today to say so.
God Bless America.
COMMENTS BY NATIONAL COMMANDER ON CFA
AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
As you walk out of this Hall today and leave this Convention, I remind you that Senator
Dole has made a commitment to support and to work for the Constitutional Amendment to
protect the Flag.
Those of you who have followed the issue know that Senator Dole was the mainstay,
and this was his bill back in ‘89 and ‘90 when he attempted to push for passage of a
Constitutional Amendment to protect the Flag. He has been with us from day one.
There was concern about whether or not we would get the votes, get the support
necessary to bring this matter before the Senate before the end of this year. You heard him
commit to schedule the vote on this amendment before the end of this year. That resulted
from a short meeting with the Senator prior to his appearance. I tried to emphasize that it’s
because of your work and your continued commitment to the issue, that we can deliver. We
can deliver the 67 votes necessary. And Senator Dole, we will not embarrass the leadership.
Give us an opportunity to have the issue voted on. He said, “Yes.”
That issue will come before the Senate before the end of this year. It’s because of your
work. The only way that we can fail is apathy in our ranks, and we cannot allow that to
happen. So I ask you to join with us to keep up the work and keep the letters going in.
Make sure that we keep the pressure on those Senators who have not committed so that we
will be able to win this battle and that the amendment will be properly passed by the Senate
before the end of this year.
SPECIAL REPORT
The American Legion and The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I doubt that there is a single Delegate
here, nor any person in the audience, nor any member of The American Legion, the
American Legion Auxiliary, or the Sons of The American Legion who does not know about
our long campaign to protect the Flag by means of a Constitutional Amendment.
For six long years we have been seeking such an amendment in order to overturn that
narrow and utterly wrong decision by the United States Supreme Court in 1989 that said,
in effect, burning the American Flag was merely a form of political expression, and,
therefore, it was legally permissible under the free speech guarantees of the First
Amendment.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
43
We know that decision was wrong. We know it was wrong then, and we know it is
wrong now. And so do 80 percent of the American people who believe that wrong should
be righted by the Constitutional amendment.
Forty-nine of our 50 state legislatures have passed resolutions asking Congress to send
such an amendment back to the states for ratification. We have come a long way toward
achieving our goal, but the hardest part of the battle is still ahead.
Today we bring you an up-to-date status report on exactly where we stand. But we
must do to achieve that victory.
The best way to update you on the whole Flag Amendment campaign, is to share with
you a short video. This report, produced by the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated, will
summarize the entire background of the issue, and tell you where we stand in Congress right
now. After we have seen the video, I will update you on some very late developments, and
tell you exactly what each of us has to do to win this fight to get the Flag protection
amendment passed.
... At this time the Delegates viewed a video presentation.
The polls are strong. The new polling done is clearly an indication that we have now
moved to the point that this is a political issue.
We need your help. We need you to go to the phones. We have phones set up in the
lobby. Make the calls. It doesn’t matter whether or not you are in a state where your
Senator has not made a commitment. Go out there and make a phone call to a Senator who
has made a commitment and thank he or she for that commitment. And if your Senator has
not made a commitment, please go out there and also make those calls. The phones are
there. It doesn’t cost you anything.
Fill out the cards and the letters found in your packets. We’ll be happy to mail them
for you.
There are two people I also wish to thank, for without their leadership and support in
the Congress, we would not have won such a stunning victory. I’m talking about the
primary sponsors of House Joint Resolution 79, the Constitutional Amendment to return to
Congress and the States the power to prohibit physical desecration of the United States
Flag. Those two persons are the Honorable Gerald Solomon, the Republican of New York,
and the Honorable G.V. "Sonny" Montgomery, Democrat of Mississippi. Neither
Congressman was able to accept our invitation to be with us today, due to commitments
elsewhere. However, they have sent greetings and good wishes to their fellow members of
The American Legion by way of a video tape.
. . . At this time a video presentation was viewed by the Delegates, a transcription of the
video as follows:
THE HONORABLE GERALD B. H. SOLOMON
Chairman, Rules Committee United States House of Representatives
National Commander Bill Detweiler and all American Legion members across the
Country. This is Congressman Jerry Solomon, a Life Member of your organization. Once
again, I thank each of you for all you have done and continue to do for your country.
As the lead sponsor of the Constitutional Amendment to protect Old Glory, I wish I
44
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
could be in Indianapolis today to personally thank each of you for this unbelievable
grassroots effort spearheaded by The American Legion that brought us more than the
two-thirds votes needed to pass the Constitutional Amendment protecting our Flag. Without
the tireless, sustained effort, that is, of The American Legion, my friend, “Sonny”
Montgomery and I would not have succeeded in getting the 290 votes that we needed to pass
this extremely important amendment.
But my fellow Legionnaires, we are not quite there yet. There is another body
of Congress called the Senate which has to pass this same amendment. And you know, no
one can get the message across better than those of you who have served our nation and
carried our Flag so proudly.
Right now we’re only a few votes short of the 67 Senators out of 100 needed to pass
the Constitutional Amendment. We all need to double our efforts back home to get our
individual Senators to vote for if thereby giving the American people the right to ratify it.
And my fellow Legionnaires, I just want you to know that I predict it will be the fastest
Constitutional Amendment ever ratified by the people through their state legislatures. Why
do I say that? It’s because the overwhelming majority, more than 80 percent of the
American people want, that Flag protected.
My fellow Legionnaires, let’s go get those Senators.
THE HONORABLE G. V. MONTGOMERY
Ranking Democratic Member
House Veterans Affairs Committee United States House of Representatives
I’m very proud to be a member of The American Legion. I am a member of Post 21
in my hometown of Meridian, Mississippi. I’m a Life Member and I’ve been a member of
that Post for 50 years. And for you Legionnaires, have a great time in Indianapolis. I wish
I could be with you.
I’m very, very proud of The American Legion. You led the fight for us to pass a
Constitutional Amendment in the House of Representatives about the Flag; stopping these
‘nuts’ from burning the American Flag.
I worked with Jerry Solomon of New York. It was bipartisan. He brought along
Republican votes; I brought along the Democratic votes. We got two-thirds votes in the
House of Representatives to stop the burning of the American Flag, and The American
Legion did it.
Now we need your help. We have to pass this amendment in the United States Senate.
We need to get 67 votes. You have to go to work. If we can’t pass it out of the Senate, what
we’ve done in the House will be for nothing.
After it gets out of the Senate, we know it will get a three-fourths support of the
different states of the Union. We need 38 or 39 States in the Union to ratify this
amendment. It will be ratified if we get it out of the United States Senate.
I’m proud to be a member of The American Legion. Have a great time in Indianapolis.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, the quiet
revolution that we have been waging is quiet no more. As you saw in the video, it’s your
Flag, it’s your fight, and it’s up to us. And I know that together we’re going to win.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
45
PRESENTATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
Seated on the dais are some
representatives from the Department of Virginia. I understand that they have a presentation
to the CFA.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER WENDITZ, VIRGINIA: Mr. Commander, on behalf
of the proud Legionnaires of Virginia, we gladly present this check to the CFA for Flag
protection.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Eighteen hundred dollars. Thank you.
... Applause.
SPECIAL PRESENTATION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time I want introduce an
individual who has worked behind the scenes for the Citizens Flag Alliance to help get our
message across to thousands of people. You saw him in the video just a few minutes ago.
In fact, he produced that video, as well as two or three others during the course of our
campaign.
He is Ike Pappas, the President of Ike Pappas Network Productions. Ike is a veteran
of television, having spent more than 30 years as a network news correspondent for both
CBS and ABC News, covering assignments all over the world, including a few shooting
wars. He also is a military veteran, like us, having served in the United States Army’s “Big
Red One” in Germany during the Korean War period.
I introduce the newest member of The American Legion, Ike Pappas, for the purpose
of a special presentation.
The Certificate reads:
Presented to Ike Pappas Network Productions. The 3.1 million members of
The American Legion in National Convention assembled, do hereby express
their heartfelt thanks to you for writing, producing and directing “Old
Glory”, and “Your Flag, Your Fight”. These two films inspired thousands
to join with us in the battle to secure a Constitutional amendment to protect
the United States Flag.
On behalf of eveiy member of the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated, we
do hereby express our appreciation to you for lending your considerable
creative talents to the cause. Presented during the 77th Annual National
Convention of The American Legion, September 1995.
Signed by myself, Bob Spanogle as National Adjutant, and Dan Wheeler, the President
of the Citizens Flag Alliance, Incorporated.
I hope you will wear this American Legion pin with pride.
46
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
IKE PAPPAS, PRESIDENT
Ike Pappas Network Productions
I’m highly honored. It isn’t often that someone gets to work in the profession that he
loves, and receives this kind of recognition as well. I have had quite a moving experience
in joining with the CFA in this great crusade, and I believe that I have been privileged to do
so.
As you heard in that brief introduction, I did serve in the military. I was in toward the
end of the Korean War but did not go into Korea. I went to Germany where I proudly
served with the 1st Division in the Public Affairs Office. I was a writer. I did my share.
I wrote, and I must say the Army helped me a great deal in my career.
I didn’t get into a lot of scraps until I went with CBS one year in 1967. CBS sent me
first to Vietnam. After returning from Vietnam, I went to Bolivia to try to find Che’
Guevara in the midst of a civil war and do an interview with him. Then I wound up in the
Middle East in the Six Day War in 1967. By the end of that year I was convinced that CBS
was trying to kill me.
But I lived on, happily to found my own company and serve many, many clients’ with
many worthy causes. In particular this one.
I must say that I was very fortunate in the production of these videos, particularly the
one that you just saw. First of all I had the strong leadership and guidance of my good
friend, Dan Wheeler, who kept us on course in terms of a message. He developed into a
television star in his own right. He’s really talented. He really handles himself on camera
beautifully. He should be congratulated for the job that he’s done.
In any event, we were fortunate also to have on our staff some of the most talented,
dedicated people in television production on our staff. They were fully involved in this
project. They were committed to it and it, of course, could not have been done without
them, so I should not be accepting all of the congratulations here. My staff should be
congratulated too, and I accept this award on their behalf as well.
We were fortunate also to have the words and music of Porta Jordan to build this video
on. "That’s more than a flag you are burning, it's the American dream." What a wonderful
line to develop a video on. We were fortunate to have those words. And so because this
became the emotional nucleus of our video, I accept this award also on behalf of Porta
Jordan.
Finally, I am the son of immigrant parents who came to the United States at the early
part of this century to seek their share of the American dream that Porta Jordan sings about.
Because they passed the respect and the love that they had for this country on to their
children, because they taught us these high values and didn't fail this country, I accept this
award on their behalf also, and for all of those who came to these shores and helped to
weave the strong fabric of democracy that cloaks and protects our country today.
Because my parents worked hard, I became a television journalist, and as such have
staunchly defended the First Amendment all my life, guaranteeing the freedom of speech
and of free press. I deeply believe in that amendment, but I also believe that burning and
desecrating the American Flag is very, very wrong. And so on a personal level, our videos
represent a labor of love for me, too, and I hope and believe it shows up on the screen.
Our productions, as I mentioned earlier, are not the result of my efforts alone, they are
a team effort of the highest caliber. Editors, camera crews, producers, directors, have all
to be in sync; they all have to work together to get the job done.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
47
No one organization could have accomplished what the CFA has accomplished so far.
It had to be a conglomeration of organizations all working together, as they will in the final
stages of this effort. I am convinced that the CFA will ultimately be successful in the
Senate, and that the states will ratify this amendment and will become the law of the land.
When it does, we will be there to record it.
SOCIETY OF AMERICAN LEGION FOUNDERS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: From the trenches of World War I, to
the sand dunes of Desert Storm, The American Legion has continued to serve veterans, their
families and the children of this nation. Its been 77 years since the first Convention in
Minneapolis in 1919.
As we gather in Indianapolis, the Society of the Founders of The American Legion,
Incorporated, has just two men living who were present at the first National Convention.
I would like to read a brief message from George Bentley, Chairman of the Executive Board
of The American Legion Founders, who is unable to be with us today.
He writes: “I am pleased to send you greetings. Last year I attended the National
Convention in my home city of Minneapolis, and also remember the great convention held
before in 1990 in Indianapolis. There are now just two of us Founders remaining. Perhaps
my friend John Gable is with you there at the Convention. You should all realize that never
again will you see a Founder present at a National Convention. The era is soon coming to
a close.
“But for the sake of John and myself, please continue the ideals upon which The
American Legion was founded. And that can only come about through the strength of our
members, both in numbers and determination.
“I hope you have a great Convention.”
Ladies and gentlemen, I think we should rise and give a standing ovation in honor of
the Founders of The American Legion that are still with us, John Gable and George Bentley.
... At this time the Delegates viewed a video vignette.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is fitting that while the 77th National
Convention of The American Legion focuses on commemorating World War II, our next
guest is a World War II veteran of the Royal Canadian Navy. For years now he has been
actively working for veterans in Canada as a member of the Army, Navy and Air Force
Veterans in Canada. He holds many awards for his civic service.
It is my pleasure at this time to welcome the Dominion President of the Army, Navy
and Air Force Veterans in Canada, Mr. W. T. Russ Ward.
W. T. RUSS WARD
Dominion President, Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans
In Canada
It is with great pleasure that I bring greetings to you from your neighbor to the North.
It is with greater pleasure that I bring you greetings from Canada’s oldest veterans
association, the Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada.
For those of you who are unaware, we have a unit of our association within your
Legion. It is the Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada, United States Unit, and
48
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
abbreviated to ANIVICUS.
We trace our association with The American Legion back to 1948. In the ensuing years
our friendship has grown and the bonds of the friendship have strengthened, so that today
we are akin in our common concerns.
It is fitting that we join with you in your commemoration of the victory over Japan,
ending the Second World War. We, too, fought in the Pacific, although the bulk of our war
effort was concentrated in the European theater. We fought at Hong Kong and, in fact, our
Canadian soldiers were some of the first prisoners of the war taken by the Japanese on
Christmas Day, 1941, some two and a half weeks after the treacherous attack on Pearl
Harbor.
We fought with you in the Aleutians, in the clearing of Kiska and Attu, when we were
part of the Special Service Force. Our experiences were opportunities for us to join together
for the defeat of tyranny.
Today we very much appreciate the opportunity to join with you, our friends and
associates, to renew our fellowship and our association.
During the parade yesterday, we had the honor to see the Canadian Maple Leaf flag
being carried along with the Stars and Stripes with the New York State group. It made us
very proud.
To show our esteem for you, Commander Detweiler, and the association of The
American Legion, we present you with this gift.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much. I assure you that
we in The American Legion were also proud because I know that the Departments along the
Canadian border are very proud to have an active relationship between the Canadian
veterans organization and The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Also from Canada, our next guest is a
World War II veteran, having served in England and Europe from 1942 to 1946. He's a
former farmer and business man who today serves as the Dominion President of the Royal
Canadian Legion. In his years with the Royal Canadian Legion, he has served on
committees for youth, veterans services and seniors.
Please give a warm American Legion greeting to Mr. Hugh Greene.
HUGH GREENE
Dominion President, The Royal Canadian Legion
I’m honored today to be here and bring you greetings from your 560,000 comrades in
the Royal Canadian Legion in Canada. It’s a particular pleasure for me to be able to bring
these greetings in this year that marks the 50th anniversary that marks the end of the Second
World War. It’s a pleasure because our great nations did so much individually and as
partners to bring an end to the conflicts in Europe and in Asia. It wasn’t the first or the last
time either.
Many of our Canadian veterans served with your military forces during the horrors of
World War II, and many of yours served with us. Whether it was as individuals who
crossed that great undefended border to do what they thought was right or in the many
combined international commands that were formed during the war, whether it was at sea,
in the air or on land. There was a particular relationship that developed between American
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
49
and Canadian military forces that continues until this day. We share a continent of vast
proportions, and its defense against any type of aggression ensures that the relationship
forged during the world wars and the Korean War will continue.
This is particularly true of your military which has to get involved in the side of the
British military again. For it has been said that the real role of a Canuck in this world is to
spend his life explaining to the Brits about the Yanks and the Yanks about the Brits.
As you start your business session today, I wish all of you the best in your
deliberations, because I know that you are running into the same problems in the United
States as we are in Canada, especially in regards to veterans’ benefits. While our political
systems and some definitions may differ, you can be assured that we are as concerned as you
are because there seems to be a tendency to forget what our veterans have done for our
countries and many others in the world.
That forgetfulness may be brought on by the pressures of the issues that exist today,
issues that push the sacrifice of the past, to the priorities that are running governments these
days. It is our job, then, in both countries to insure this does not happen.
This year the Canadian veterans have seen the greatest outpouring of affection and have
been the subject of the most publicity I've seen since the end of the Second World War. I
suggest this has been true here in the United States of America also. What happens next
year and the year after that? Are our veterans, now that they have had the great public
acknowledgment they deserve, to slip into history with less and less attention being paid to
their needs?
I'm here to tell you that this is not going to happen in Canada as long as the Legion
exists there. I am certain the same is true in the United States where The American Legion
is a watchdog for veterans. Therefore, I ask you to deliberate carefully and look to the
future, never forgetting the past. To do so is to break trust with those who have gone before
us. “... as long as there are Legions.” I say that optimistically, even though in Canada
we are losing enough members for some to question the length of our organization's
viability. Our veteran population is decreasing at a normal rate in Canada, as the last real
war that qualified a Canadian service member as a veteran was in Korea. Most of those
20,000 veterans are now over 60 years old.
But we still have a large base on which to recruit, those who served in the military in
peacetime being the largest. And we are going after them just as you are from what I read
in The American Legion Dispatch. It is not easy and it won’t be easy for many reasons, but
if we don’t, who will look after those who are serving now in duty locations like Bosnia, the
Middle East, Africa, Asia, the Caribbean, Central and South America? Who is going to
look after their needs when their sacrifice to the nation is done?
We all know that what is stated by the politicians today can easily be changed. We also
know that revisionism is rampant on this continent. That is why the Legion, yours and ours,
exists, to insure that those who serve their countries are never forgotten in any way. That
is why I bring you greetings from your fellow Legionnaires north of the border. I also bring
you a message of encouragement and a message of support.
You have suffered your Enola Gay. We suffered with The Valor and the Horror, a film
documentary that was produced in our country decrying what Bomber Command, which
flew out of northern England, did to the German population, and we fought that. We didn’t
gain very much.
That message is to keep our Legions strong and to do everything we possibly can to
insure that they stay strong. The older veterans must realize that time has come to pass the
50
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
torch. The younger veterans among us must remember they are taking on a sacred trust to
refuel that torch so that its flame burns bright and strong.
For the sake of those who cannot be here and for those who can, continue to suffer
because of their service we must take on the forces of revisionism so their honorable
sacrifice is never diminished.
From what I have seen in my recent visit to your headquarters in Indianapolis, your
Veterans Service Bureau in Washington, your state organization in Montana, I know that
you are a strong, vibrant and dedicated organization that is capable of meeting these
challenges. With that said, I wish to thank The American Legion for the invitation to be
here to share with you the spirit of comradeship that has been forged in war and maintained
in peace.
I can truthfully say there are no greater nation of friends on the face of the earth today
than Canada and the United States, regardless of the politics that may come between us
from time to time. May it ever remain so, and I wish you every success in your deliberations
during this convention.
Commander Detweiler, in appreciation, I would like to present you with a gift from
your comrades in the Royal Canadian Legion. Also I bring to you at this time a plaque
which we had produced. It says:
Presented to the American Legion by the Royal Canadian Legion on the
occasion of the 77th Annual National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: One of the opportunities the National
Commander has is to visit our counterparts, those veterans who have served and represent
their nations in other countries of the world. Our next guest is a Vice Chairman of the
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen in the Republic of China. He’s
a man with a distinguished military career who has found a fulfdling second career in
serving his fellow veterans.
Would you please welcome a very delightful gentleman and a gentleman whose
hospitality I enjoyed last evening, Retired General Colonel Chao Yu.
GENERAL CHAO YU
Vice Chairman, Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
It’s my great honor to be able to attend your 77th annual convention on behalf of the
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen of the Republic of China. The
American Legion and the VACRS have enjoyed a history of association for nearly 20 years.
During the time, our two organizations have kept mutual visiting activities in which we
exchanged experiences of promoting veterans’ welfare and discussed on some subjects
which benefited us. And our relationship is thus growing firmer and sounder.
This year marks the 50th anniversary of the victory of the Second World War. On July
7th, 1937, the militants of Japan started the so-called ‘Cambridge Incident’ on the China
mainland and began an all-out invading war onto China. In order to defend our country the
Chinese civilians as well as soldiers, gallantly devoted themselves into the war, fighting
against the invaders. The Chinese troops fought unaided until the end of 1941 when the
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
51
Japanese gave a surprise attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7th the same year. The next
day, December 8th, your 77th Congress resoluted to declare war against Japan and thus
allied with my country, the Republic of China, and laid a firm and solid foundation for the
final victory of World War II.
At the time, President Roosevelt telegrammed Generalismo Chiang Kai-shek to express
his respect for the Chinese bloody fighting against the Japanese invasion during the previous
four years and urged that the Chinese and the Americans join efforts to fight against our
common enemies and stop the invasion. On January 3, 1942, President Roosevelt
recommended that Generalismo Chiang Kai-shek assume the post as the Supreme
Commander of the Allied Forces in the China theater, while the American General Joseph
Stilwell later followed by General Albert Wedemeyer was assigned to be the Chief-of-Staff.
The close cooperation between the solders of our two countries during this period led
to great victory in 1945. On July 26th of that year the United States, the Great British and
the Republic of China jointly signed the Potsdam Declaration and asked the Japanese to
surrender unconditionally. 20 days later the Japanese government finally accepted the
request and brought the Second World War to an end.
The people of the invaded countries were thus delivered from their enemy's threat,
restored to their right to live and dignity of being human. In retrospect in this path of
history, the veterans of our two countries feel proud and especially cherish the result of this
cooperation. Although half a century has passed, our friendship has not become weak. It
grows even stronger and firmer instead.
Just recently your senators invited Madame Chiang Kai-shek to a Capitol Hill party
which was held in her honor. This congressional gesture signifies that both of our two
countries hold the records of our past cooperation.
In the past 50 years, although the global situation and international relations have
undergone great changes, the veterans of our two countries have been maintaining the
ever-firm traditional friendship, because we have shared common ideals and objectives. We
are allies of difficult times, and the friendship between difficult times allies is sincere and
lasting. The American Legion has been offering us assistance and cooperation in the past.
It truly makes us treasure your friendship. I would like to once again extend our
appreciation for all you have done.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Before the general makes his
presentation, let me just assure him that The American Legion is a friend, now and in the
future.
GENERAL CHAO YU: In recognition of the outstanding performance and
contributions of your National Commander, Mr. Detweiler, the Vice Chairman Lieutenant
General Chao would like to present on behalf the president of my country, the Republic of
China, a medal of the Order of Cloud and Banner to the National Commander. The
Certificate reads:
Mr. William M. Detweiler, the National Commander of The American
Legion, has distinguished himself by his outstanding contributions to the
promotion of friendly relations between the peoples of the United States of
America and the Republic of China and to the enhancement of ties and
cooperation between the veterans of our two countries. In appreciation of
his meritorious service, National Commander Detweiler is presented the
52
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
Order of Cloud and Banner with Clarity by the government of the Republic
of China in accordance with Article 11 of the Chinese Armed Forces
Declaration.
Resolutions signed by our State President Lee Teng-Hui, co-signed by Mr. Lien Chan,
the Premiere, and General Chiang Chung-Ling, the Minister of National Defense on
September 4th, 1995.
GENERAL YU: The American Legion and VACRS, the Vocational Assistance
Commission for the Retired Servicemen, of the Republic of China have been very close
friends in the past 20 years. Therefore, each year when we come here the chairman of my
organization, General Chou Shih-Pin would like to remember our close association in the
past, and present again, a plaque to the national president.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you, 1 am deeply honored by the
presentation. And I suggest to all of you, if you ever have an opportunity to go to Taipei,
Taiwan, if you have a chance to see the programs that the veterans of this organization,
VACRS, is involved in, they’re absolutely incredible; the work that they do, the industry
that they support, and the work that they provide for the veterans of their country.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The next gentleman to bring greetings
to the 77th National Convention of The American Legion is also a distinguished military
officer. He served in the Korean Air Forces and retired more than ten years ago after
commanding the Korean Combat Air Command. Today he finds himself serving other
veterans in his role as Vice President of the Korean Veterans Association.
I am pleased to present Retired Lieutenant General Kim Jae-Yun.
LT. GENERAL (RET.) JAE-YUN KIM
Vice President, The Korean Veterans Association
It is a great privilege for me to be invited to attend your 1995 Annual Convention.
I extend warm greetings on behalf of all members of Korean Veterans Association.
Dear American Legionnaires, as the main strength of the United Nations forces, the
United States committed a total of 1.2 million troops during the Korean War and suffered
heavy casualties of 54,246 killed in action and 103,000 wounded in action. You saved our
country at such a great cost during our most serious crisis.
After the war, you provided us enormous support for our rehabilitation and progress.
Without your assistance the remarkable progress we now enjoy would never be possible.
We thank you very much from the bottom of our hearts.
The world is now pursuing reconciliation, peace and welfare of mankind. But, in spite
of this trend, North Korea has never abandoned its efforts to communize with South Korea.
They have not implemented the nuclear agreement made between the U.S. and North Korea.
They also rejected dialogue with South Korea. Therefore, the South/North relationship is
still in a cold war as before and we cannot escape from it.
Not only that, North Korea has deployed its major combat strength near to the truce
line. They appear intent on developing weapons for mass destruction and further enforcing
their conventional military strengths. These problems together with the nuclear issue make
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
53
North Korea a serious threat to peace on the Korean peninsula and the entire world as well.
We Koreans are happy that the historic U.S.-Korean War Veterans Memorial was
dedicated on July 27th this year in Washington, D.C. About 400 Korean War veterans from
our association attended the dedication ceremony. The memorial will serve as a reminder
for everlasting friendship between the people of our two countries.
Dear friends, we take great pride in our traditional friendship. I look forward to your
continued support in furthering the security and mutual interests of our two nations. In
closing, I sincerely hope your convention will be a successful and rewarding one.
LIEUTENANT GENERAL YUN: Ladies and Gentlemen, I would like to have the
honor of presenting a plaque to National Commander William M. Detweiler. It reads:
Presented to Mr. William M. Detweiler, National Commander The
American Legion. In grateful recognition of his dedicated contribution to
the support of national security of the Republic of Korea and to the
promotion of friendly relations between the two organizations. September
4th, 1995. Indianapolis, Indiana.
Signed by Chang Tae Wan, Major General Army Retired, President Korean Veterans
Association.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, General. I had
the opportunity to visit with General Chang briefly in Washington, and I have had the
opportunity to visit with him when I was in Korea. He bit me on the ear and I understand
he likes me. That was his expression. Great custom. Those gentlemen live in an area of the
world that all of you know is very much in flux and under a lot of pressure. The nuclear
capabilities of North Korea and China make a very unstable situation. The American forces
that are there help to make it a more stable place. And we thank both of you for coming and
being with us and we assure you of our continued friendship and support.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: At this time I introduce Mr. Dante
Mattioni representing the Chapel of Four Chaplains in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, for the
purpose of a presentation.
PRESENTATION
LEGION OF HONOR BRONZE MEDALLION AWARD
THE CHAPEL OF FOUR CHAPLAINS
The example of the Four Chaplains: Fox; Goode; Poling and Washington, a Priest, a
Rabbi, two Protestant Ministers in giving their lifejackets to those without, on the deck of
the USS Dorchester on February 1943, remains the symbol of courage and selfless service.
It is the cornerstone of the work of the Friends of The Chapel of Four Chaplains.
During the past couple years that work has continued despite the move of the Chapel
from the Temple University campus in Philadelphia to Valley Forge. In fact, the activities
of the Friends of the Chapel of Four Chaplains has increased substantially. The Chapel
remains the center for interfaith cooperation, and its chaplains, now numbering more than
sixty around the country, consult regularly with military chaplains and others on matters of
54
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
interfaith cooperation.
Last year, the Chapel directed or assisted in more than 1,000 memorial services around
the country. And its news bulletin has been sent to more than 30,000 people four times a
year. In addition, the Chapel, as part of its youth program, has given more than 100 cash
grants to deserving young adults over the past two years. The Chapel continues its National
Legion of Honor program, stressing its theme of "Unity Without Uniformity," and its
mission, "Encouraging Cooperation and Selfless Service Among All People."
This afternoon, the Chapel honors Mr. William Detweiler, National Commander of
The American Legion. Mr. Detweiler has served The American Legion for more than 30
years as a Post Commander, District Vice Commander, Judge Advocate, and Chairman of
the National Public Relations Commission, National Foreign Relations Commission, and
National Vice Chairman. He is an attorney and the elected constable for the First City
Court in New Orleans. He served in the United States Army Intelligence Corps and in the
active and standby Reserves.
He has been actively involved in the New Orleans community, serving on dozens of
committees and chairing many of them. He is a long time member of the Los Angeles
Historical Society; a Co-chair of Operation Heroes Welcome in New Orleans; and chairs the
Advisory Commission for the Agent Orange Family Systems Project.
He is an outstanding family man, and is married to Maureen Reed. They have four
great children: Scott, Bonnie, Keith and Jeannie.
In a lifetime of service he has committed himself to the service of his country, the
service of his community, and the service of his family. We are honored and privileged on
behalf of the Chapel, to present the Bronze Medallion to Mr. Detweiler for his selfless
service and for encouraging cooperation and selfless service among all people. We have in
addition, a plaque, and at the top of this plaque there are the pictures of the Four Chaplains.
The plaque says:
The Legion of Honor Bronze Medallion, presented to William Detweiler,
National Commander of The American Legionl994-1995, by the Chapel of
Four Chaplains, Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, in recognition of outstanding
service to all people, regardless of race or faith. This award symbolizes for
all Americans and for all time, the unity of this Nation founded upon the
fatherhood of one God.
THE AMERICAN LEGION DISPA TCH
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The August 24th edition of the Dispatch
includes a special section on the reflections of Legionnaires who fought in World War II.
If you’re not a subscriber, please take advantage of the special discount rate offer
between now and September 30th.
BUICK PROMO
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Just before the gavel falls for this day,
I remind you of the drawing for a 1996 Buick LeSabre automobile. Ticket books are
included with your registration. You can also purchase additional tickets at the display
booth.
Proceedings of Monday, September 4, 1995
55
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates, would you please join me in
a salute to the Flag of the United States of America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Flag.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will stand in recess until
9:00 o'clock tomorrow morning.
. . . At 2:17 P.M., the Convention recessed, to reconvene the following day, Tuesday,
September 5, 1995, at 9:00 A.M.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
57
PROCEEDINGS
SECOND DAY
Tuesday, September 5, 1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegates listened to the music of the AOs while slides of World War
II Posters were displayed on large screens.
... The Convention was called to order by National Commander William Detweiler at 9:00
A.M., EST.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates please stand and render a righthand salute to the Flag of the United States of America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the invocation, I call on our National
Chaplain, Reverend Roy Pryor, Sr. of South Carolina.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr. (SC)
National Chaplain
Let us pray. Oh Lord, God, we again invoke Your blessing upon this 77th meeting of
The American Legion Convention.
We ask that Your love and blessing may rest upon each of us as we carry out the duties
and responsibilities that have been placed upon us.
Flelp us to be kind and considerate, and lovable in all those things we do, and help us
this day to uphold God and Country. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, please remain
uncovered and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of
America.
... The Delegates stood and recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Convention is now in session.
As we begin the Second Day of this 77th National Convention, we continue our
commemoration of World War II and the men and women who gave so much.
With us this morning to help us relive the music and the songs of the war years, are
seven talented individuals from the American Cabaret Theater here in Indianapolis. These
are the same men and women who set the tone for the extremely moving Post Everlasting
Ceremony yesterday morning.
... At this time the Delegation was entertained by the American Cabaret Theater Singers,
followed by a video viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Yesterday, you answered my request to
make a few phone calls. Well, I want you to know that you filled all of the voice mailboxes
of those Senators that you called.
But I’m not satisfied.
58
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
I want you to go out there today and make a few more phone calls. I want you to make
those calls until you shut down those switchboards. Washington is going to get the message
that the American people mean business.
This is an issue, this is an American issue and they are going to hear this message loud
and clear: We want that amendment passed and we will do what we have to do as a people
to do it.
DONATION TO CFA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: And now I have a group of Legionnaires
from the great State of Ohio who are going to come up here and place something in the
hands. Let’s see how many matching placements in the hand we can get today, or in a
reasonable time.
At this time I introduce the State Chairman of the CFA, of the great Department of
Ohio, Dean Scholl.
DELEGATE DEAN SCHOLL, OHIO: Thank you for taking time out from your
schedule to allow us these few moments.
I introduce the gentlemen on the stage with me: Our NEC, Gerald Moore; Adjutant,
Roger Hight; Past Department Commanders, Klipstine; Gable; Hendrickson and Myers, and
our present elected Commander, Jerry Wilson.
Mr. Commander, when the House voted on their resolution, the amendment, we was
only able to give you 15 of our 19 representatives. When the Senate votes, at the present
time I can only promise you one, but we sure are working on the other one.
When the reports come out each month, Ohio is, and has been, fifth or sixth in the
amount of petitions turned in; fifth or sixth in the amount of donations, and fifth or sixth in
the total amount of donations that have been made.
In Ohio we have this motto: So long as one concerned American remains, we will
strive to protect our precious American Flag. We will not do it by force, we will do it by
the choice of the people and with the voice of the people. That is a message that we are
sending to Congress and the Oval Office.
Mr. Commander, on behalf of the Ohio American Legion Auxiliary, The American
Legion, and ail of the other organizations that have worked with us in the Department of
Ohio, I want to present to you this check for $10,000.00.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our first guest this morning is a man who
is well known to most of you. He’s a decorated combat veteran of the Vietnam War who
today heads the Department of Veterans Affairs. He’s responsible for a system that provides
health care services and benefit programs for our fellow veterans and their families.
Please welcome a member of Post 72 in Warrenton, Virginia, the Honorable Jesse
Brown, Secretary of Veterans Affairs.
THE HONORABLE JESSE BROWN
Secretary of Veterans Affairs
[Secretary Brown’s speech was often interrupted by applause.]
I want you to know that it is great to be here with all of you. I also want you to know
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
59
that this is where I come to stay in touch with who I am and who I want to be. I want to take
advantage of this opportunity to ask all of you to say a silent prayer for our Past National
Commander, Dale Renaud.
... A moment of silence was observed.
We will miss Dale. He was one of those special people who made this Nation great.
I’m sure that from somewhere near God, he is smiling on all of his friends gathered here at
this National Convention. Dale took great pride in The American Legion and its
accomplishments for veterans, and he was right to feel that way.
This organization has a distinguished record of fighting for veterans and their families.
Another chapter in this outstanding history was written this year. I want to commend the
Legion for speaking out against those who wanted to rewrite history when the Enola Gay
went on display in Washington D.C. I find it very irritating about some of these so-called
history professors. While they may have forgotten what you did, history will never forget.
The Enola Gay delivered the decisive message that ended the war and saved thousands of
our citizen soldiers.
Just three days ago, President Clinton and I honored our World War II veterans who
died in the Pacific. As we were there standing in the Punch Bowl, a National Cemetery,
looking at thousands of graves, I asked myself time and time again, how dare they try to
rewrite history. It was our veterans lives that were on the line in 1945, not some history
professor 50 years later setting in a classroom talking about what could have been. You told
it like it was, and would not accept anything less. You proved once again that The
American Legion is a powerful voice for right.
My friends, the past two and a half years as your Secretary for Veterans Affairs have
been the most challenging of my life, and I want to take advantage of this opportunity to
thank Bill Detweiler, Bob Spanogle, and especially John Sommer for their help. Together
we faced the tough issues by asking one question: What is best for veterans and their
families?
This cooperation is absolutely necessary if we are to achieve our goal of putting
veterans first. For example, our National Commander spent a lot of time visiting with
members of the House Appropriations Committee. His work, along with other leaders,
helped restore part of the two hundred and six million dollars they were trying to take away
from our 1995 budget. Once again the voices of veterans were heard.
Recently, I was reminded again of why we do what we do, and I want to tell you about
a special experience I had this summer. It took place when I stood with President Clinton
on the Mall in Washington as the Korean War Veterans Monument was dedicated. There I
saw countless men and women with tears in their eyes. It reminded me very, very clearly
once again that freedom is not free.
It reminded me of the dedication of another monument, the Vietnam Veterans
Memorial. That black polished wall contains over 58,000 names of our friends who never,
never came home. But it is not until you actually see the individual names that you feel the
magnitude of the loss.
I felt the same way at the dedication of the Korean War Veterans Memorial, which is
just across from the Wall, and again you could see that the cost of war was high. In Korea,
over 100,000 came back home wounded and they were the lucky ones. For you see, over
54,000 paid the ultimate sacrifice. And now plans are being made to build a memorial to the
men and women of World War II. I think it is about time that we honor our World War II
veterans. After all, they saved the world.
60
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
These are examples of why this Nation owes them and all of our veterans a tremendous
debt. It is a debt that The American Legion will make sure is paid. Working together we
have made important advances on issues such as improving health care; Agent Orange; Post
Traumatic Stress Disorder; Persian Gulf Syndrome; improving services for women
veterans; POWs; helping homeless veterans; and burying our veterans with dignity.
But my friends, we cannot stop now. For some reason we have reached a point where
those who defended the Nation must now defend themselves. Veterans benefits are under
attack. We are now in a period where the Nation must deal with the issues of balancing the
budget, reducing taxes and increasing defense spending.
We are all for lower taxes and eliminating the budget deficit. We also agree that we
need a strong national defense, and we all want a leaner, more efficient government. These
are clearly wise goals that will require difficult choices. In order to pay the one trillion
dollars for these goals, we as a Nation must establish priorities. But I say to you, the same
as I say to our leaders, we must not balance the budget and pay for tax reductions on the
backs of our veterans.
Veterans have already paid a tremendous price for their benefits, and I might add at the
risk of offending some, they are the only Americans to have done so.
And I’m troubled when I see and hear politicians talk about all of our social problems,
but most of them are not willing to talk about the impact that the budget would have on
veterans and their families. And that is why you and I cannot allow anyone to break the
moral obligation that this Nation has to its veterans. That is why we must remain alert. We
must remain alert because we have hypocrites in the land. They say nothing is too good for
veterans, and they turn right around and do just that, nothing.
There are those, as you know, for whatever reason, who feel that veterans are getting
a free ride, but I don’t hesitate asking them: Who do they think paid for the ticket?
It’s amazing to me as I travel all across the countiy, that politicians will come here and
there and promise you what they will do for you tomorrow, but they are not willing to pay
for today. For example, they keep telling me that we need to eliminate some VA hospitals
because the veterans population will continue to decline, but I keep telling them they ain’t
dead yet, they ain’t dead. And as far as I’m concerned, the Nation still has an obligation to
veterans. They must understand that we earned those hospitals and we’re not going to give
them up without a fight.
They are trying very, very hard to confuse us by calling the VA a sacred cow, but we
veterans, we in The American Legion, are not confused. They are the ones that are
confused. They have a cow mixed up with a lot of bull, if you know what I’m talking about.
It would be a sad time in our Nation’s history if we allowed the ill-informed to lead us away
from our most solemn obligation, the obligation of caring for our veterans. You and I know
from our own experience, it is a simple idea, you care for those who have cared for the
Nation.
And I have been personally the subject of many attacks. They call me the lobby fox
in the hen house, and suggested that I should not head the VA. But I say to you, the head
of the VA should be an advocate; he should be a lobby fox. I’m your lobby fox and I’m
proud of it.
There are some in Washington, D.C. who feel that the Nation can no longer afford to
say thanks to her veterans. For whatever reason, we veterans are on the verge of being
declared a luxury that costs too much. Who are these people attacking veterans programs?
Have they been to the river of death? Have they walked in our shoes? Have they even
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
61
served in the military? If they have not, they need to be very careful about how they treat
our citizen soldiers.
Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not against non-veterans, my mom is a non-veteran. But
I am against those who do not support our veterans and their families.
The President supports veterans. Take the VA’s budget for instance. He increased the
VA’s health care budget for next year by one billion dollars without cutting other veterans’
programs. But the Congress has other ideas. The House Appropriations Committee has just
provided an increase of $563 million for veterans health care. This may look and sound
good, but let me tell you who’s going to pay for it: we veterans are. They are going to take
money from service-connected veterans and other accounts like construction. They are
simply robbing Peter to pay Paul. This is wrong. It is bad for veterans and it is bad for the
country.
This means that we will not be able to build badly needed hospitals in California and
Florida. Also, we will lose some of the money that we need to renovate some of our older
facilities and to bring them up to community standards. The days of the 16 bed wards and
communal bathrooms must end. And they also want to stop compensation to some
incompetent veterans. This is outrageous. Now, let me tell you why.
They’re not talking about grandfathering anyone in. But let us say that we have a
World War II veteran who’s sustained a gunshot wound to the head. Because of brain
damage he’s incompetent. He has more than $25,000 in his estate, and as a result, the VA
will stop all of his compensation. That is not fair. It is nothing but a means test, and it
would push these service-connected veterans into poverty.
Congress did the right thing in 1992 by letting this legislation expire, and I hope that
they will do the right thing today by not reenacting this bad, bad public policy.
But some in Congress still do not get the message. The Congressional budget sends
a signal that the end of the Nation’s commitment to veterans and their families may be on
the horizon. If Congress follows through on it, by the year 2002, VA would be forced to fire
61,000 doctors, nurses, and other health care workers; close 41 hospitals; cancel 150
construction projects; deny care to a million veterans, most of them World War II and
Korean veterans that are already receiving it from the VA. They want to make poor
veterans, and I underline the word poor, pay more for their medication from the VA, and of
course make veterans wait longer to get a decision on their claims.
They are entertaining a lot of crazy proposals on Capitol Hill. Some even have
proposed changing the rules for determining service connection to only include those who
become disabled as a result of performing military service.
And what does this mean in the real world? You know those people out there, they
have a way with the King’s English. They try to make everything sound good. Well, what
does it really mean to the veterans who have paid the cost?
Let us say that your grandson, or your son or your daughter goes into the military and
is assigned to Germany. And on a weekend pass he’s in an accident, and becomes a
quadriplegic, paralyzed from the neck down. Today, and rightly so, VA would provide this
veteran with vocational rehabilitation, compensation, and medical care for the rest of his life.
But if some on Capitol Hill have their way, this soldier’s condition would be stabilized and
he would be discharged from the military, and then? And then he will be sent home so
mamma and daddy can take care of him for the rest of his life. He would not get
service-connected compensation, medical care, or vocational rehabilitation benefits. That
is not right and you and I are not going to allow that to happen.
62
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Are we coming to a time when our warriors are no longer appreciated? This budget
resolution is disgraceful, but we are also hearing other outrageous ideas. Let me give you
some examples.
Some want the means test compensation. Let me tell you why that’s a crazy proposal.
Let us again say that we have a World War II veteran who has lost an eye, both arms and
both legs at the Battle of the Bulge. Despite his disability, he opens up a little store and
becomes successful. His wife also works full time. Maybe she’s a teacher or a nurse.
Under their option they will take away his compensation if he and his wife make too much
money. That is not right. Compensation has nothing to do with his paycheck or his wife’s
income.
Our veterans should be compensated for their disabilities and not penalized for their
abilities. It is simply not right to take compensation from a man who left parts of his body
on the battlefields of the world. If they are going to do it, then give him back his eyesight;
give him back both his legs, both his arms, and I do not mean artificial limbs, if you get my
drift.
There are those who for whatever reason would tax compensation and pension benefits.
That is simply not fair. Our veterans have already paid taxes on their compensation and
pension benefits; paid them in full with their own blood and suffering.
And they are even talking about eliminating compensation for veterans rated 10 and 20
percent disabled. It’s not right. This Nation does not fight cheap wars. You and I know
that. We cannot allow nickel and dime politics to cut the heart out of our veterans programs.
Make no mistake about it, when they are talking about cutting Medicare, Medicaid and
veterans benefits, they are not talking about themselves, they are talking about us.
We hear a lot these days about sharing the burden and making sacrifices, but we’re not
hearing nearly enough about those who have already paid their dues, our veterans and their
families.
So let me ask you, the people who have been there, do you think that it is right to tax
compensation?
Do you think that it is right to stop compensation to incompetent veterans and deny
disability benefits to veterans hurt in the military?
Do you think that it is right to make poor veterans pay more for their medication; close
41 hospitals and slam the doors to a million sick veterans?
You’re absolutely right. We should look them right in the face and say to them in
clear, and plain English, “You ought to be ashamed of yourself.”
I don’t say this too much in a public forum, but I think it is ironic that all of these
assaults on veterans’ programs come at a time when only about 30 to 35 percent of the
members of Congress are veterans. About 70 percent or so are not veterans. Something is
wrong with that. And the only thing we are asking them to do is take a look, or at least take
your cue from the people who have been there; who understand what it is like to be of
service to the Nation; to be sensitive to the sacrifices that our veterans have made.
We are now in the process of commemorating the end of World War II, a war where
we lost 400,000 of our citizen soldiers. Over 700,000 of them came back home wounded
and disabled, and now they are talking about cutting VA hospitals. I say to them in clear
plain English: We honor our dead by responding to the needs of our living. That is the way
that we should run this country.
To those who do not understand why we in the veterans’ community do what we do,
come with me and I will show you the price of peace; come with me and look into the eyes
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
63
of a veteran who has lost a limb but not his dignity; look into the eyes of a mother or father
who has been told that their son or daughter would never, ever come home; look into the
eyes of a young wife learning that her husband will be disabled for life. If they look into
their eyes, and if their hearts are in the right place, they will see, as American Legion
members see, the real America, the America built on sacrifice, courage and love.
We can never repay the families for their pain. They have lost so much, and this Nation
has an obligation to them. With your help, that is an obligation we shall keep.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We make you this promise, that when the
VA is acting under your direction and you are acting as you have stated, on behalf of the
interests of the veterans of this country, we will be with you and will be your advocates. But
our moral obligation is also that when things are not going well, to be adversaries. That’s
the freedom we have in this country.
We congratulate you for all that you have done for the veterans of this country, and
we look forward to continue to work with you in the future.
Thank you very much for coming and being with us.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Also with Secretary Brown is a
gentleman that some of you may have recognized who is now the Under-Secretary of
Intergovernmental Affairs, the former director of our VA in our office in Washington, John
Hanson.
The weather in our nation’s capitol was hot and muggy in July in stark contrast to the
bitter cold that we so often associated with the Korean War. Despite the weather, thousands
of Korean War veterans paraded in Washington and stood this July in the sweltering sun as
the Korean War Veterans Memorial was dedicated.
Our next guest is a Legionnaire who served on the Korean War Veterans Memorial
Advisory Committee with distinction. He is a Past National Commander, and he’s a man
that can sell refrigerators to Eskimos; make them think they’ve really gotten something for
their buck. This man just loves to raise money. If you have any causes out there and you
need somebody to raise money, get his card. Please welcome from the Thomas J. Roberts
Post No. 78 in West Roxbury, Massachusetts, ‘Jake’ Comer.
JOHN P. ‘JAKE’ COMER
Korean War Veterans Advisory Committee
We will be watching a brief tape of the dedication that can be ordered through Emblem
Sales. It is a review of that day’s activities, the beautiful culmination of eight years of hard
work by all of you and so many others to make the Korean War Memorial a
forgotten-no-more War.
Before we see the video tape, I certainly would be very remiss if I did not express into
the record some thanks to many individuals who were responsible for my efforts in making
The American Legion so successful in the fund raising efforts:
From the Washington Staff: Executive Director John Sommer; Mike Schlee, the
Director of the National Security and Foreign Relations; Cherrie Johnson, the Director of
Human Resources; Chuck Bums from the Legislative Committee; and Monica Moore, the
Executive Director’s Secretary.
From the Indianapolis National Staff: Bob Spanogle, National Adjutant; Phil
64
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Onderdonk, the National Judge Advocate; Joe Posato, the Assistant Director of Internal
Affairs and my excellent and enthusiastic liaison who couldn’t attend the dedication because
of military obligations; his boss, the Director of Internal Affair, Hugh Dagley; and Patty
Wykes the Internal Affairs and Membership secretary.
Also, I must express my gratitude to Past National Commander Miles Epling who
presented my name to President Bush for the original appointment to the KWV Board and
to each following National Commander: Robert Turner; Dominic DiFrancesco; Roger
Munson; Bruce Thiesen; and finally to Bill Detweiler. Bill did an exceptional job in
representing The American Legion at the dedication ceremonies.
I would like to thank Aurelia Pasowski of East Chicago Unit 369 of Indiana. A
member of the Auxiliary she was the No. 1 supporter, raising more money in selling pins
than anyone else in the country. I want that in the record. Aurelia deserves the thanks of the
American Legion Auxiliary and all of you.
Thanks, too, to Jack Cover from Post No. 69 in Robinson, Illinois, the Department
Chairman of the KWV in Illinois. I met Jack when I was first appointed. Past National
Commander John Geiger sent to me a Korean pin that was sold in Illinois. He thought I
should ask Jack Cover for permission to use this pin. I did and we raised something like
$80,000 just from the selling of those pins.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: That is only a clip of the actual film
which itself runs for about 35 minutes, showing the Commander’s Reception, to Samsung,
to the dedication, to the parade. It sells for $11.95.
I also want to thank Dan Wheeler, Milford Forrester, and the Magazine Commission.
Thanks also to Lew Wood, Lee Harris, and the Public Relations division who helped in
putting the video tape together, along with feeding publicity to the media.
The heat of that day was upwards of 94 to 96 degrees. The Kava Water Company
supplied the 700,000 little water jugs all throughout the day.
In the video, you saw Rhonda Skypeck adding insignias to the painting of those units
that served in Korea. Eveiy unit that served in Korea is on this Skypeck painting. It’s only
selling for a very minimal $25.
I have gone to many posts and have seen Vietnam and World War II planes and
insignias. This print now gives you the opportunity to show every unit in conversational
piece when individuals come into your post.
But as I said, the Korean War Veterans Memorial Advisory Board created plans for a
dignified celebration that was fitting tribute to those veterans that fought valiantly in Korea.
The plans for the dedication ceremonies included a wreath-laying ceremony, a Pusan Tent
City where The American Legion had an air-conditioned tent. Let me tell you, that certainly
came in handy. The other veterans’ organizations did not have the same. There was no one
but The American Legion that really was out front, first class.
We had over 400 members marching behind our National Commander in the parade.
Every national officer of The American Legion marched. We had the Canton Band of
Massachusetts, the Waltham Band, and the North Dakota State Band. And I counted up the
marchers of the VFW, the DAV, and the AM VETS, the Vietnam Veterans. Totally
combined, they had 52 marchers. So your American Legion was right out front as they
always are.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
65
A Legionnaire from Illinois was selling all kinds of caps out there, but there is nothing
with The American Legion emblem and dedicated to the Korean War Veterans. I’ve been
assured by the Emblem General Manager that you will be seeing on sale a Korean War
Memorial cap out of Emblem Sales in the future.
You heard about Samsung. Our Executive Director of the Korean War Veterans
Memorial Advisory Board, Bob Hanson was presented by Samsung a half million dollars
for dedication expenses. They also said they wanted to do something to help those that
helped their country remain free. They asked Bob where they could give a substantial
amount of money to an organization that would appreciate it. He directed them to The
American Legion, because he knew we had programs in place; scholarship programs and
individual programs that help our youth and everyone else in this nation. And I was proud
that if there was anything else we received out of this, getting that five million dollars was
another testimony to you, the members of The American Legion.
I’m working on another individual from Korea who possibly may give us another half
million dollars in scholarship money.
I will give you the to-date final figure of my final report: With the coin sales and with
all other contributions to-date, the figure officially will be $618,362.21. We started three
years later, but are less than $10,000 from being the top fund raiser in this nation.
Could Jack Cover and the National Commander come forward for a presentation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The plaque reads:
In grateful appreciation to Jack Cover for his outstanding commitment and
contributions of over $100,000 to the Korean War Veterans Memorial,
through the design and sale of the official American Legion Korean War
Veterans War Memorial pin. In witness whereof, this commemoration is
hereby attested to by the hands of the duly authorized officers of The
American Legion at National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, September
4 through 6, 1995.
Signed by myself as National Commander and Bob Spanogle as National Adjutant.
Jack, thank you very much.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: I introduce to you, Jack Cover from
Post 69 in Illinois.
JACK COVER
POST 69 (IL)
It’s with great honor that I receive this plaque. It was quite a shock. I didn’t expect
this.
Without all the help from you out there, each and every one of you gentlemen and
ladies, and non-veterans this pin would have never have made this much money.
I have something here that I would like to give to Jake also. I have a check here for
$2,500. It’s going to be a little tough to cash. It’s a big one, so he’s going to have to take
care of it. It’s from The American Legion of Illinois Korean War Memorial Committee;
remitter Jack Cover, Committee Chairman and made out to The Korean War Memorial
66
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Maintenance Fund of Washington, D.C.
It wouldn’t be right without having this here for Jake, for the hard work that he’s put
in on this. I also have something that only a few in southern Illinois have seen. It’s a big
image of what we have done with our pin. Jake, I would like for you to have this to hang
very proudly.
While we’re here, it wouldn’t be appropriate unless he had this one to go with it. From
the bottom of my heart this is dedicated to all POW/MIAs. I want it to be hung beside the
Korean Memorial pin very proudly.
We are looking forward to more sales. Help Jake out because he’s a go-getter. Without
his help, I could never get onto this.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: Thank you all again for your work. It’s
been my pleasure for the last five years to come to you at these conventions with updates.
I am thrilled and privileged and think you will be, too, when you see the monument. There
is no finer monument in the history of our nation. The Korean War Veterans will be
forgotten no more.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Those of you who had the opportunity
to be in Washington know what a moving event it was. And Jake mentioned 400 marchers
who were behind us all as part of the Legion delegation. I would suggest to you, Jake, that
there were a lot of other vehicles in that parade that we saw later on that were spaced out in
the parade that were from American Legion posts around the country. So I think that the
Legion was extremely well represented there without a doubt.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion’s ability to
provide service to our fellow veterans through a nationwide network of service officers and
our ability to provide temporary financial assistance to veterans’ families would not be
possible without The American Legion Endowment Fund.
To help each of you better understand the fund and how you and the members you
represent can make it stronger, I introduce the President of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation, a Legionnaire from Post 71 in Kansas City, Missouri, Mr.
A.G. Hays, Jr.
A.G. HAYS, JR., PRESIDENT
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
Last winter here in the National Headquarters, arrangements were made to produce a
video that would outline the duties and the responsibilities of The American Legion
Endowment Fund. Here to introduce the video to us this morning and tell us about it is a
member from the Board of Directors of The American Legion Endowment Fund, a man
heard speaking just a few minutes ago, Past National Commander ‘Jake’ Comer.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: We’ll be showing another short film.
Now you’ve realized what my next project is. And I have a booth out there for that, too.
Roll the film of the Endowment Fund that had contributions by Past National
Commander Jimmy Dean, Past National Commander Joe Matthews and myself in regards
to the Endowment Fund.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER COMER: Just think about it: 1925, $5 million
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
67
dollars; 1945, The American Legion donated $2 million; and here we are in 1995, for the
first time in 50 years, starting out on a fund-raising campaign. This is the most well-kept
secret in The American Legion. I don’t know how many really understood what The
American Legion Endowment Fund is all about or what it does. And now I hope you do.
So continue to do what you do best, giving of yourself, on behalf of The American Legion.
And now, A.J., please come forward.
I have the most outstanding department in this nation. There are times they wish I was
somewhere else. But to start this fund off and to get it on its right course, as we hope many
of you will do the same in your departments, I would like to present to you on behalf of the
Department of Massachusetts this check for $5,000.
DELEGATE HAYS: I, too, want to thank the Department of Massachusetts for your
very generous gift.
EMPLOYER OF THE YEAR AWARDS
FOR HIRING VETERANS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion is very proud of
the employers of America who have made hiring veterans a matter of good business. To
honor those companies, The American Legion Employer Of The Year Award was
established.
The companies we honor today have demonstrated a keen sense of understanding in
hiring veterans. This morning we recognize three such organizations as the 1994 Employers
Of The Year.
The awards are given in three categories: One for the companies employing fifty or
fewer people. Another for companies employing 51 to 200 people, and a third for
companies with more than 200 workers. Each is nominated by a Post and advances through
the Department and National competition levels. The 1994 Employer Of The Year Award
in the ‘under fifty’ category goes to Southwest Research Institute of San Antonio, Texas.
Richard Curtin, the executive vice president of the company, is here to accept the award.
RICHARD CURTIN
Southwest Research Institute, San Antonio, Texas
It’s always a great honor for a company to be recognized as an employer of the year.
But it’s particularly meaningful when that recognition comes from an organization as fine
and as proud as The American Legion.
As a veteran myself, I am very happy to be here to accept this award. We at the
institute have helped in our own small way to assist veterans in their transition from military
life to a life in the industrial sector, and we’re very proud to have helped. But I must tell
you that our motives were not entirely altruistic, because we believe, and I think you know,
that veterans make the best employees, bar none. They come very well trained and they
come with a very strong sense of duty.
So on behalf of the men and women of Southwest Research Institute, I’m very happy
to accept this award. I want to assure all of you that we will display it in a very prominent
place at the institute.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The award that is given to all three of our
68
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
winners reads as follows:
The American Legion National Award Outstanding Employer Of The Year
presented to the particular employer for an exceptional record in the
employment of veterans.
Presented at the 77th Annual National
Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, September 5, 1995.
And now the award in the ‘51 through 200 employees’ category goes to Caldwell
Machining, Incorporated of Emporium, Pennsylvania. Here to accept the award is the
president of the company, Joseph Caldwell.
JOSEPH CALDWELL
Caldwell Machining, Incorporated; Emporium, Pennsylvania
It is a great honor to be invited to your National Convention to be given an award by
the world’s largest veterans organization. I am indeed humbled and, at the same time, happy
to be here today.
The accomplishments of The American Legion on behalf of all veterans is second to
none. Seventy-seven years of service to God and Country is something that you can be
proud of.
The American Legion has kept faith with those that have served their country. After
military service and the return to civilian life, you joined this organization of individuals
who have continued to serve this great Nation by becoming a voice in national affairs.
America is a far richer country because of the never-ending contributions that Legionnaires
make to their communities. I salute your selfless service, your extraordinary patriotism, and
devotion to our Country.
My wife, Linda, who is my helpmate and business partner, works with me daily at our
business, Caldwell Machining, in the little town of Emporium, PA. We have been
completely overwhelmed upon receiving this award.
The veterans hired by us are our future. Working together we can build a future that
will result in creating more jobs. Veterans are not only good employees, they are good
citizens in our community. As a result of our experience in hiring veterans, I assure you,
veterans will be given first class treatment at Caldwell Machining.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The award in the category of200 or more
employees goes to Boeing Aerospace Operations, Incorporated of Midwest City, Oklahoma.
Here to accept the award are Ms. Constance Bruner, the Human Resource Manager,
and Mr. Paul Ray, Director of Aircraft and Training Operations for Boeing Aerospace
Operations, Incorporated.
RAY PAUL
Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc., Midwest City, Oklahoma
We’re very pleased to accept this award. At the Boeing Company in Oklahoma, for
every three employees that we go out after, we hire two veterans. And as was said earlier,
if there is one basic reason for our success, veterans are the most qualified people, no other
reason than that. So as a veteran myself, I’m happy to accept this award, and God speed.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
69
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We acknowledge these good people for
their employment of our veterans. They do us all and America a service in employing our
veterans and giving them an opportunity to return and to enter productive lives after taking
time out of their lives to serve our Country.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is my pleasure at this time to extend
a special opportunity for a distinguished Legionnaire to introduce our next guest.
Fellow Delegates, Mr. E. Roy Stone of South Carolina.
MR. E. ROY STONE, SOUTH CAROLINA: I am proud to have the honor to present
the next speaker. Our families have known one another for over 50 years. For over 20
years, our families would meet on January the 1st and have the usual New Years Day dinner.
Then our wives would get together and talk, and his father and I would go in and start
watching the football games and go to sleep.
I saw him grow up and go through high school. He was an athlete, a captain of the
senior football team at his high school.
Then he went to college and was president of the student council. And all of this
indicated that he was a leader. He graduated at Furman University cum laude, and then went
on and attended law school.
He followed his father Ted and his brother Pat into law practice. He served our county
in the House of Representatives and then as a Senator. He ran for governor of the state and
was the first governor of my state to succeed himself. He served for eight years.
His main interest, not only as a senator, but as governor, was education. Our state of
South Carolina, during his administration, made great strides in education during that time.
He was also Director of the Duke Endowment which was very friendly to education in our
area. And he also developed a large law firm with his father and brother.
A Democrat, active when Governor Clinton ran for President, where he showed his
worth there in being able to carry the many states that he was in charge of.
His alma mater, Furman University, named one of their science buildings for him. It’s
known on the campus as the Riley Building.
His devotion to education and our schools is great. He resigned his position with Duke
Endowment, a very lucrative position and gave up temporarily his law practice when
President Clinton asked him to be the Secretary of Education.
He and his wife have had their tragedies. They had twins, one died, one lived. So he
knows something about death. My wife and I had no children. But as I told his dad and his
mother, if we had a child, a boy, we would want him to be like our next speaker.
He served in the Navy after his graduation at Furman. He is a veteran during the
Korean period. He is a disabled veteran, and a member of my Post. I might add that he is
an artist, and one of the brightest lights, as I see it, in the Clinton Administration.
Delegates to this Convention, I present to you a great American, an outstanding patriot,
an educator, my friend, your friend, a fellow Legionnaire of my Post 3, the Honorable
Richard W. Riley.
70
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
THE HONORABLE RICHARD W. RILEY
Secretary of Education
[Secretary Riley’s speech was often interrupted by applause.]
Thank you, Roy, for that warm introduction. It’s a great honor for me to be here and
address this group, this 77th Annual American Legion Convention.
Roy knows how much I also cherish the friendship of our families. He and my father
were the best of friends. He was like a second father to me, and I can see them now asleep
in their chairs as I was trying to watch a football game on New Year’s Day.
Milford Forrester and all of my other friends from South Carolina, it’s great to be with
you.
I noted that my colleague in the Cabinet, The Honorable Jesse Brown, spoke with you
earlier today. He’s a distinguished veteran and fights for veterans all the time. It is my
pleasure to work closely with him as he serves as Secretary of Veterans Affairs.
My subject, of course, will be education, but I don’t plan to give you a lot of facts and
figures as some kind of expert. Everybody has their own ideas about their children and their
education. Everybody is entitled to that, and I respect it.
When I was Governor of South Carolina, I remember I was down at Myrtle Beach
making a speech one time. This older gentleman came up to me after it was over and said,
“Dick, it’s about lunchtime, why don’t you join me for a sandwich?” I said, “All right.” We
were sitting there talking, and he said, “You know, Dick, I just retired and moved down here
to Myrtle Beach, and I went to one of these senior citizens functions the other day. They
had an expert there,” and said, “and we were all sitting around in there. It was one of these
audience participation things, and he asked me to stand up, and I stood up. And he said,
‘How old are you?’ I said, ‘I’m eighty-five.’ He walked over to the blackboard and said,
‘Do you know there are three 85 year-old- women for every 85 year-old-man?’ He said,
“You know what I told him, Dick?” I said, “What?” “I told him that is the most useless
information I have ever received.”
So I’m going to try and not give you a whole lot of useless information.
First off, let me pay tribute to all of our Nation’s war veterans, and tell you that
America is deeply grateful for your service. This year, we pay special tribute to World War
II veterans. A few months ago President Clinton paid homage to these heroes when he said,
“We must draw inspiration from this extraordinary generation that won the war.” A few
members of the extraordinary generation, Brigadier General Paul Tibbets, pilot of the Enola
Gay, will receive the Legion’s Distinguished Service Award. I would like to share my
opinion about the controversy surrounding the Enola Gay Exhibit. No amount of historical
revisionism can change one basic fact: We were the good guys in that deal.
We were fighting for the freedom of the world. I was in Dallas with the President when
the press asked him about Truman’s decision. And he said that he clearly agreed with
President Truman. General Tibbets had a tough job; he did his duty and he helped end the
war, saving countless lives. I salute him for it.
Veterans of all of our wars have served with distinction. The service of Legionnaires
doesn’t end when they return from war. Legionnaires have become home-front heroes as
well, making their communities better in so many ways.
We have many problems in this Country, we all know that. But if everyone had the
same commitment to serve their fellow Americans as Legionnaires do, we would be a lot
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
71
closer to some solutions.
The Legion also has a long record of support for education of veterans’ children and
all adults. The Legion has often led the way in endorsing the support of education
improvement. The crown jewel of this effort, of course, was the GI Bill, which I received,
and was able to go to law school under it. It opened the doors of college to millions and
millions of veterans.
Today our scholarship programs, School Awards, Boys and Girls State, Boys and Girls
Nation and many other programs, support quality education for our youth. I also had the
good fortune of going to Boys State, and I was elected sheriff.
The Legion understands that if ever there was a time to focus on education, it’s now in
the information age, the age of education. Our freedom, our national security, our jobs, our
economy, even the survival of our most basic American values are more dependent upon
education now than ever before.
As Thomas Jefferson said, “Our laws and our Constitution must go hand-in-hand with
the progress of the human mind.” You see, in a democracy the educational level of our
people, where the people have the power, is very critical.
In that spirit, let me ask you to lead us in one more great crusade for America. You
won the war against fascism and communism. Now I ask you to help America win the war
against ignorance, and, more than that, win the war for excellence in education for all
Americans.
Respecting the American tradition of local control of schools, we’ve been working to
expand educational and training opportunities and to make every classroom a safe and
disciplined place, a first priority for this Country.
Let me take a few moments to tell you what we’ve been doing to support your efforts
and the efforts of millions of Americans who are working hard to improve education.
First, to make our schools hospitable to people of all faiths, the President instructed
me to offer guidance which would describe the religious activities that are allowable and
protected in the public schools under the First Amendment of the Constitution.
As the President said, when our students go in to the school building, they do not leave
their religious beliefs at the door. And they should not. Students have broad opportunities
to pray while in public schools. They may read the Bible; say grace before meals;
participate in extracurricular religious clubs and many, many other activities, so long as the
rights of all are respected. The Constitution already protects religious expression. And in
this God-fearing-Nation of ours, the public schools must not be hostile to religion.
We have also moved to support character education, because too many of our children
simply aren’t learning the difference between right and wrong. As one education leader has
put it, our Nation has gone from “Leave it to Beaver”, on the one hand, over to “Leave it to
Beavis and Butthead” on the other.
With the support of parents, character education programs teach children good
citizenship, responsibility, honesty, respect, discipline and hard work. In short, the values
that you would want a man in a fox hole next to you to have, are the very kind of values that
we are talking about.
To help the character development of children in my “State of American Education”
speech, February the 1st, I asked Hollywood to scale down the anti-violence on TV and in
movies. We are trying to put kids on the right track by supporting anti-drug and violence
prevention programs in the schools.
We have also launched a campaign to encourage greater parental involvement in
72
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
education, because we believe that parents, not governments, raise children. The Legion has
been very supportive in these family involvement in education efforts. I’ll tell you, parents
who know their children’s teacher; the parents who help with homework and who teach their
kids right from wrong, can make all the difference in a child’s education.
Now, when it comes to national defense, the importance of education in our nation’s
military has never been greater. I firmly believe that if America is to remain the world’s
number one military superpower as we are and have been, we must also become the world’s
number one education superpower.
Just ask any of our Desert Storm veterans to describe the high level of learning and
training that they needed to use the high tech weapons that won the war quickly. It simply
takes smart people to build and use smart bombs.
Our military knows that having recruits who are well educated, means higher retention
rates, reduced training time, and increased productivity. All of that helps to ensure unit
readiness. Two things that really count in war: One, Keep American casualties low.
Victory.
Today our National Defense is also linked to the strength of our economy, as you well
know, and our ability to create and keep jobs right here in the USA. Unfortunately, the real
income of the American middle class has been falling over the past 20 years. We are
attacking this problem by creating our Nation’s first school work apprenticeship program
to prepare high school graduates for real jobs with a real future.
We have called for tax breaks for workers seeking further education and further
training. We are expanding access to higher education by helping many more working
families pay for higher education.
Finally our Goal 2000 to Educate America Act, calls for high standards of learning,
with an emphasis on basics, learning computers, core academic subjects like English, math,
science, history and civics.
On the subject of standards, let me address an issue that has drawn wide comment. I’m
speaking about the guidelines for the teaching of American history that were proposed by
an independent education group late last year. These guidelines were criticized because they
cast American history in a bad light.
Let me make our position clear on that matter. The American History Standards were
developed under a grant awarded during the previous administration. The standards were
never endorsed by the U.S. Department of Education in the Clinton Administration, and
they were deeply disappointing to me. This wasn’t our grant. These were not our standards.
They do not represent my view of American history, and they don’t represent the President’s
view either.
No school in America is being asked by our administration to teach these standards, and
a respected group is now developing other history standards which we hope will be a big
improvement.
As for the study of American history itself, let me again be very clear. We must tell our
children the truth, and the truth is, that America is the greatest country in the history of the
world.
We have made mistakes; we have had peaks and valleys. Sometimes our greatest
strength has come forth in the valleys, but we have always tried to correct our mistakes.
America has been the world’s beacon of freedom for 219 years, and 1 want every single
school child in America to know and to honor that history.
There is a great thirst for knowledge out there among our children and among their
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
73
families. A recent poll showed 98 percent of all parents hope to send their children to
college, almost 100 percent. Yet there are some in Congress who seek to make the largest
cuts in aid to education in our nation’s history. These cuts will impact everybody in this
country. The cuts couldn’t come at a worse time. School enrollment will reach a record
high in just two years. Cutting back on education, just when we need it the most, would be
like cutting back on national defense right after Pearl Harbor.
As a result of your efforts and the efforts of so many others, we are beginning to see
real progress. SAT scores are up; dropout rates are down; math and science achievements
are up. We have a lot of work to do. We all know that. We have much more to do, but it
is positive that we are on the move.
American education is like a car that’s speeding up, but some in Congress want to
siphon off the gas, and that is a mistake.
Now America has a great choice to make. We can continue to go forward or we can
sound the retreat. I note that The American Legion has already made that choice. The
theme of your celebration of American Education Week is: Good Schools Are Great
Investments. So the Legion is moving forward.
Something else that saddens me about recent actions in Congress is the sharp break in
the proud American tradition of bipartisan support for education. Education should never
be a political football. When it comes to our kids, we need more thought and less noise.
After all, we don’t educate our children in this country as Democrats and Republicans and
Independents, but as Americans, and that’s what it should be.
And in this spirit of cooperation I will announce this week an exciting new initiative
called America Goes Back To School, a place for families and for community. And I invite
all Americans to reconnect to their schools and to become involved in activities to improve
education.
We have already asked members of the Armed Services to participate, and as usual they
have answered the call. America Goes Back To School is a perfect community service
opportunity for all of us to go back to the schools where we went, and for all Legion Posts
to get involved in that activity. I think you would find it a very rewarding experience.
So as I close, let me ask you to think about the children of America. It’s a complicated
time to grow up. It’s a complicated time for all young people. We all should do what we
can to see that all of them have the chance to get a quality education, because no person can
be successful in this country without having an education in this day and age.
Let me close with the words I think that say a very important message by a country and
western singer. I’m a little partial to country and western music. I don’t know if any of you
have ever heard of Kathy Mattea, but she’s a lovely person and has a wonderful poignant
voice.
My children gave Tucky and me a CD player for Christmas. We had two CDs. One
of them was by Kathy Mattea. The song that I heard and liked so much, is called “Seeds”.
Imagine, if you will, riding down the street and seeing a number of children playing in the
playground. The song goes like this: “Sometimes I stop on my way home and watch the
children play. And I wonder if they wonder what they’ll be someday. Some will dream big
dreams and make it all come true, and others will go on dreaming things that they’ll never
do. We’re all just seeds in God’s hand. We start the same; where we land is sometimes
fertile soil and sometimes sand; we’re all just seeds in God’s hand.”
Seems to me that our children of this powerful, wonderful democracy are the seeds of
greatness for this great country. They are certainly our future. Yes, some land in fertile soil
74
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
and have quality offered to them and every opportunity, and others land in sand and rocks.
But they all have great potential. They are all important.
I’m so proud that Legionnaires are working everyday to provide fertile soil in which
our children can grow, making sure that all of our children grow up straight and tall and
smart, no matter where they land.
For the Legion believes, I am certain, that here in America in 1995, there should be no
weeds in the gardens of our schools.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, over the past 12
months I have had the opportunity to stand up on your behalf against the revisionist forces
of the Smithsonian Institution and, in particular, the National Air and Space Museum.
During those months, I have had the great honor to stand up for the valor of the men that
you are about to meet, their historic mission, and to stand up for the courage of President
Truman in making the decisions; a decision to drop the bombs on Hiroshima and later on
Nagasaki; decisions which ended a devastating war. And it’s my distinct pleasure to have
this opportunity to present The American Legion’s highest honor, the Distinguished Service
Award to the crew of the Enola Gay.
Our award is presented to distinguished Americans annually in recognition of
outstanding service to the nation. And I can think of no more significant and meaningful
contribution than to have brought a sudden and decisive end to the bloodiest and most
destructive war in world history, as carried out by the courageous men on that most
important mission of the Enola Gay.
There is no doubt in my mind that many of you who are here today would not be here,
if it hadn’t been for the courageous mission of the men of the Enola Gay.
Please turn your attention to the screen to see and hear these men who delivered the
dawn of peace a half century ago, and in their own words describe their historic mission.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is one sad note about one of the
members of the crew that you saw in the movie, and that’s Bob Carron. Bob Carron passed
away some two months ago, and is sadly missed by his family and his fellow crew members
who are with us today. Let me also at this time now introduce to you the crew of the Enola
Gay.
Commander Paul Tibbets; the navigator, Dutch Van Kirk; the bombardier, Tom
Ferebee; and last, but not least, the radio operator, Dick Nelson.
This is a very historic moment for all of us. These gentlemen sought no publicity,
sought no recognition and have, in fact, avoided publicity and recognition. They only did
what their commander-in-chief asked them to do as good airmen, as good soldiers. They
carried out the mission on behalf of their country. We are most proud and grateful that they
have come to be with us today and to allow you — those, whose many lives were saved —
to acknowledge and thank them for their efforts.
BRIGADIER GENERAL PAUL W. TIBBETS, USAF (Ret.)
Pilot of The Enola Gay
We are certainly honored today by this recognition from The American Legion and the
presentations of their Distinguished Service Award. I must acknowledge those who put me
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
75
in a position to do what I did and what we did. Namely, the men and women of this great
nation who arose so determinedly following the attack on Pearl Harbor on December the
7th, 1941. That unprovoked attack united this nation as nothing had before and nothing has
since. A single determination prevailed which was, “You can’t get away with that and we
will show you.”
We allied ourselves with Britain and declared war on both the Axis powers and the
empire of Japan. Immediately thereafter, mobilization began by both industry and the armed
forces. Men of fighting age began enlisting and women left their homes to go into war
production factories to build the implements needed by the fighting men. Thus, war became
a family affair. Sacrifices were made without complaint. Everyone was out to win.
Then food, gasoline, butter and things previously taken for granted were rationed.
Victory gardens were planted and harvested. War bonds were sold. Scrap metal was
collected and returned as war needs. Automobile tires went from rubber to what they call
camel-backs. Does that sound familiar? I bet you haven’t heard that name in a long time.
What am I driving at? I’m driving at a performance miracle. When our war began,
Germany had some 4,000 combat airplanes. The British had about 2,000; and our
Army/Air Force squadrons had less than 800 total aircraft. Of those, about 50 are what I
would call combat, and some of those very first vintage B-17s were destroyed at Pearl
Harbor. Our fighters were obsolete, open-cockpit P-26 airplanes. We were not very well
equipped or armed to do battle.
It took time to get the factories going, but by mid ‘43 the factories were turning out
goods at a terrific rate. The Air Force historian recently stated on average American workers
produced 191 airplanes, 64 tanks, 1,761 trucks and 20,892 tons of shipping for every day
of the war. I would call that coming from behind and beating the competition; in other
words, real team work.
In 1944, in the Pacific we really started making gains. The Army and the Marines,
assisted by naval gun power and naval aviation, drove the Japanese off of the islands. We
badly needed to get runways close enough to Japan so that the B-29s could operate
successfully and bomb the Japanese homeland. At that particular time as we worked closer
to the Marines, and we took Okinawa, the Navy had actually blown the Japanese Navy out
of the water.
Between mid-September of ‘44 and early May of ‘45,1 organized and trained the 509
Composite group that you saw in the video. By mid-July, the unit was in place on Tinian
flying practice missions against Japan with facsimile-type bombs related to the bombs used
on Nagasaki, and those bombs were loaded with torpex.
All that remained was obtaining President Truman’s approval to use the weapons. This
approval was received the afternoon of the 5th of August. Then the Enola Gay crew and I
were on our way to Hiroshima. This was about 2:30 a.m. We released our weapon at 9:15,
and in a millisecond, the city ceased to exist.
We returned to Tinian about 2:30 p.m. after a 13-plus-hour round trip. In the final
analysis, Paul Tibbets and the Enola Gay crew could never have gotten to Tinian and
Hiroshima without the sacrifices of other thousands of men and women. These people
worked to make that possible. You veterans took the lands we needed. You made it happen.
I stand before you to thank you. I salute you for your most valuable contributions that
contributed to the successful ending of the World War II.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I’d like to recognize several very
important people who are in the audience with us, the wives of three of our crew members:
76
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Mrs. Van Kirk, Mrs. Ferebee and Mrs. Nelson. Please stand.
General Tibbets, and to you, those of you who served with then Colonel Tibbets, our
heartfelt thanks and gratitude for being with us. Be assured that the families of the crewmen
who are no longer with us will also receive their Distinguished Service Medals as soon as
possible. The American Legion is committed by resolution to continue to work to insure
that the Enola Gay is properly assembled, put back together and properly displayed in a
place of honor where it justly deserves that honor.
And I can assure you that during the week that we will be in Washington for the
Legislative Meetings after the 17th of September, that we will make every effort at that time
and I will make every effort at that time, if the incoming commander so desires, to sit down
with the representatives of the Smithsonian Institution to get this properly displayed. Let’s
get that aircraft displayed without further delay. If it’s necessary we’ll raise the money.
I want you all to note that all these gentlemen are members of The American Legion.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
Donation to CFA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We have another donation. Twenty
Delegates on the floor from the Department of Kentucky donated $10.00 each for a total of
$200 to the CFA, and we thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair now recognizes Allen Titus
of Indiana, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Economics, for the purpose
of a making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEES ON
EMPLOYMENT AND VETERANS’ PREFERENCE
AND OTHER ECONOMIC MATTERS
Allen L. Titus, (IN), Chairman
At 9:00 a.m. on September 1, 1995, 80 delegates assigned to the Convention
Committees on Employment and Veterans’ Preference and on Other Economic Matters
convened in Rooms 109-110 of the Indiana Convention Center, Indianapolis, Indiana, to
consider 29 resolutions assigned to the committees for action. Allen L. Titus of Indiana was
elected General Chairman and Jim Marks of Indiana was appointed Secretary. Henry Field
of South Carolina was elected Chairman of the Convention Committee on Employment and
Veterans’ Preference and Robert E. David of South Carolina was appointed Secretary.
William Christoffersen of Utah was elected Chairman of the Convention Committee on
Other Economic Matters and Wayne Slade of South Dakota was appointed Secretary.
In response to a call by the National Adjutant, a screening committee composed of five
members of the National Economic Commission and its affiliated committees convened in
Room 114 of the Indiana Convention Center on August 31 to make recommendations to the
Convention Committees on Economics. Members of this committee were Allen L. Titus
(IN), Chairman, James McMahon (ME), Henry Field (SC), Robert Boxdorfer (MO), and
William Christoffersen (UT). The report of the screening committee was presented to the
Convention Committees and was adopted, with Resolution No. 146 held for separate
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
77
consideration. Resolution No. 146 was discussed and then accepted for approval as the
screening committee had recommended. A motion was made, seconded and approved to
authorize the Chairman and Secretary to sign the committee report on behalf of the
committee. A motion was made, seconded and approved to allow the Chairman and
Secretary to make technical corrections.
EMPLOYMENT AND VETERANS’ PREFERENCE COMMITTEE
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
Origin: FL
Submitted by: Employment and Veterans Preference
As consolidated with 10 (CO), 30 (DC), 46 (SC), 48 (TX), 51 (TX), 81 (NE), 85 (WI), 128
(SD), 132 (UT).
WHEREAS, Congress has a proud history of fulfdling its commitment to the
joblessness and underemployment of those veterans who, after serving honorably for their
country in the armed forces of the United States, are attempting to reenter the civilian labor
force; and
WHEREAS, Congress has declared its sense and purpose to ensure that all veterans,
particularly veterans with disabilities, are provided the maximum of employment services,
including job counseling, job training or retraining, job placement or other relevant services;
and
WHEREAS, The Social Security Act of 1935 placed a tax upon employers to finance
an unemployment insurance system to offset the lost wages and to sustain the worker’s
purchasing power during periods of unemployment; and
WHEREAS, This legislation, better known as the Federal Unemployment Tax Act
(FUTA), established an unemployment trust fund to serve as a repository for the
Employment Security Administration Account, which is entirely separate from the General
Revenue Account used to run the federal government; and
WHEREAS, FUTA provides administrative funds for operation of the Employment
Service, Unemployment Insurance, and the Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
agencies, and pays unemployment compensation benefits to workers; and
WHEREAS, Congress also recognized the need to monitor veteran employment
preference by creating a federal position in each state, a State Veterans’ Employment
Representative, in the Wagner-Peyser Act; and
WHEREAS, Congress created a position of Local Veterans’ Employment
Representative, in that legislation, to assist those veterans with special employment
readjustment needs and to ensure that veterans receive preference in all employment service
offices; and
WHEREAS, Congress, recognizing the ever-growing special employment, Resolution
No.-employment and unemployment needs of our nation’s veterans, passed legislation to
enhance greatly the visibility of the Veterans’ Employment Service by first creating the
position of Deputy Assistant Secretary for Veterans’ Employment in 1977, then, in 1980,
elevating the Deputy Assistant Secretary to a full Assistant Secretary for Veterans’
Employment and made the Veterans’ Employment Service a separate agency within the
Department of Labor; and
78
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
WHEREAS, PL 96-466 mandated appointment of a Disabled Veterans’ Outreach
Program specialist for every 5300 disabled and Vietnam Era veterans residing in a state to
meet the ever-increasing employment needs of that population through outreach and
outstation sites; and
WHEREAS, While the downsizing of the armed forces is substantially complete, the
services will continue to release about 250,000 people per year from active duty for the
foreseeable future; and
WHEREAS, Repeal of Employment and Unemployment Service and the Veterans’
Employment and Training Service legislation (i.e., Title 38, Chapter 41, U.S. Code) would
eliminate the primary delivery agencies for preferential services to veterans and abolish
effective administrative oversight and monitoring of all federal Department of Labor
employment, training, retraining, counseling, and Resolution No.-employment programs for
veterans including the State Employment and Unemployment Insurance Agency for
veterans, the Disabled Veterans’ Outreach and Local Veterans’ Employment Representative
programs, Transition Assistance Programs and Disabled Transition Assistance Programs,
the Homeless Veterans’ Reintegration Project, Job Training Partnership Act Title IV-C
programs, Federal Contractor Job Listing Program, Federal Agency Veterans’ Preference
Programs, and Veterans’ Re-employment Rights; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion oppose any effort
to repeal any federal employment, training and Resolution No.-employment rights
legislation or abolish any such agency funded from Federal Unemployment Trust Account
employer tax revenue; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion oppose any efforts to change the Veterans’
Employment and Training Service and the employment and unemployment service delivery
system which would compromise their ability to provide the quality services that veterans
have earned through their service to the country.
Resolution No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Origin: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
Submitted by: Employment and Veterans’ Preference
WHEREAS, The current Administration is committed to reinventing the federal
government to make it more effective, efficient and responsive to this country’s needs; and
WHEREAS, The Veterans’ Employment and Training Service is an agency within the
Department of Labor which exists for the purpose of providing America’s veterans with
quality employment services; and
WHEREAS, The Assistant Secretary of Labor for Veterans’ Employment and Training
is responsible for ensuring that the agency continues to meet its mission despite increasing
reluctance by Congress to fund it properly; and
WHEREAS, In response to the reinvention initiative, the Assistant Secretary appointed
a Reinvention Team to analyze VETS and determine how it could restructure and streamline
itself for the purpose of improving the services it provides to its veteran clients; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion also concurs with the Assistant Secretary’s interest
in making the agency even more responsive to the needs of the veterans it serves; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion supports those
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
79
reorganizing efforts that will help to make the Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
more effective, more efficient and more responsive to the needs of America’s veterans; and
be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports any legislation necessary to
accomplish the goals of the Secretary of Labor for the benefit of all veterans.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 8 (CO) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 9 (CO) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 18 (MA) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference
Resolution No. 49 (TX) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
Resolution No. 50 (TX) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
Resolution No. 80 (NE) 1995 NC: Oppose Transfer of Veterans’ Employment and
Training Service
Resolution No. 126 (SD) 1995 NC: Oppose Transfer of Veterans’ Employment and
Training Service
Resolution No. 127 (SD) 1995 NC: Veterans’ Preference in Government Jobs
COMMITTEE ON OTHER ECONOMIC MATTERS
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 24: Natural Resource Management
Origin: AK
Submitted by: Economics
As amended and consolidated with 87 (WI), 133 (UT).
WHEREAS, The federal government and the United States Forest Service initiated the
establishment of a permanent industry in certain areas of the United States to achieve
maximum utilization of the renewable resources and provide year-round employment and
opportunities for community development throughout the region; and
WHEREAS, Many of the planners, engineers, laborers and other individuals who were
the catalyst of this effort were veterans of World Wars I and II and the Korean War, many
of whom came to these areas as servicemen, and chose to stay in these areas, build families
and carry on productive lives; and
WHEREAS, The management of the natural resources, in part by the veterans of past
wars, constitute models used around the world as examples of successful modern resource
management and evidence of how industry and the environment can productively co-exist;
and
WHEREAS, Modern integrated resource use, which depends upon the reliable raw
material supply from the various contract sources, enabled communities to build the kind
of infrastructure and realize the economic stability that was a primary objective of many
veterans who struggled to bring this industry to the region; and
WHEREAS, Countless restrictions are increasingly falling upon activities in our
country, restrictions which have as their common foundation a subjective judgment that
resource extraction is not an industry that our government should encourage; and
WHEREAS, The restrictions placed on industries engaged in natural resource
80
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
extraction result in thousands of jobs, hundreds of which were held by veterans, being lost
to those industries; and
WHEREAS, Payroll and benefits dollars which have been lost due to these restrictions
have not only directly impacted veterans who were employed by the industries affected by
the restrictions but also the veteran-owned businesses which depend on those payroll dollars;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion fully supports the
sound and wise management of the natural resources of the United States, and that we
believe that current natural resource management practices are more than adequate to insure
the well-being of fish and wildlife; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports the proposition that the United
States government should, to protect the interests of its veterans, insure an adequate natural
resource harvesting program for independent, small business and long-term contract holders
on lands held in the public trust, and that the federal government should cease its practice
of spending funds earmarked for resource extraction for other purposes and of offering only
meager amounts of these needed raw materials to industries in the region; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion is opposed to all government policies which
lead to the cancellation of long-term contracts for resource extraction and result in severe
economic and social hardship in the communities of the affected regions and to the veterans
who live and work there.
Resolution No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
Origin: DC
Submitted by: Economics
As consolidated with 4 (KS), 20 (OR), 58 (NY), 79 (NE), 137 (VA).
WHEREAS, Surplus federal property may be obtained by certain non-profit activities
exempt under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954; and
WHEREAS, Non-profit activities may include organizations which provide assistance
to homeless individuals, the elderly, and other citizens of the United States in need; and
WHEREAS, The purpose of allowing such access to surplus federal property is to
further the dual goals of the proper disposition of such excess property and to provide
assistance through its use to assist individuals in need; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is properly and lawfully chartered as an
organization under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 as an organization
dedicated to providing the types of services contemplated by federal and state laws of this
nation; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion should
specifically be authorized by the United States Congress during its 104th Session to have
legal authority to obtain by donation or by purchase such surplus federal property as deemed
appropriate by the Congress to further the goals of The American Legion’s service to needy
individual citizens of this nation; and be it further
RESOLVED, That such enactment of law by Congress permitting acquisition of such
surplus federal property will be mutually beneficial to The American Legion’s service to
needy citizens and to the federal government of the United States as proper use of such
surplus property to benefit the citizens of the United States; and be it finally
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
81
RESOLVED, That The American Legion respectfully request and encourage the United
States Congress to enact legislation during its 104th Session to authorize the proper and
lawful acquisition and use of surplus federal property for The American Legion’s stated
purpose of assisting needy United States citizens.
Resolution No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
Origin: Economics
Submitted by: Economics
WHEREAS, Federal assistance to America’s veteran-entrepreneurs dates back to the
passage of the Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944; and
WHEREAS, That legislation established a small business loan program for World War
II veterans that was to be administered by the Veterans Administration; and
WHEREAS, The first eight years of that program were so successful that Congress later
opened it to Korean War veterans; and
WHEREAS, In 1953 Congress passed legislation that created the Small Business
Administration (SBA) and provided for the transfer of the veterans’ loan program to the new
agency; and
WHEREAS, Despite the 1974 passage of PL 93-237, which mandated the SBA to
provide “special consideration to veterans of the Armed Forces and their survivors and
dependents,” little has been done by SBA to fulfill that mandate or to promote its veterans’
programs; and
WHEREAS, In spite of a lack of resources and support, SBA’s Office of Veterans’
Affairs (OVA) has, in recent years, made a valiant effort to meet its mission and continue
an ongoing dialogue with the veterans’ community; and
WHEREAS, During SBA’s recent reorganization, OVA’s staff was reduced from six
to three; and
WHEREAS, That reduction in staff has seriously compromised OVA’s ability to
provide effective and efficient services to America’s veteran-entrepreneurs; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion views the reduction in OVA’s staff and the
elimination of its field staff as yet another indication of SBA’s total lack of concern for
veterans; and
WHEREAS, Congress has drafted a discussion bill which provides for transferring
OVA to the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and combining it with that agency’s
Office of Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization, thus creating the Veterans’
Entrepreneurial Business Service; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes that such a move would improve OVA’s
ability to provide entrepreneurial services to veterans; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion fully supports any
legislative or administrative proposal that would increase and improve federal assistance to
America’s veteran-entrepreneurs.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN TITUS: Mr. Commander, that completes the Report of
the Convention Committee on Economics.
As a Delegate from the Department of Indiana, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded, and carried.
82
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
BLOOD DRIVE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: This is the final day of the drive. So far
you have donated 193 units. I would like to see us meet or exceed the donations from the
last time we were here in Indianapolis, so please take time out to donate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: For the past five years, our nation has
taken time to remember the sacrifice and service of World War II veterans and their families.
With us at this time is the man who has maintained a steady course in helping coordinate
countless events from coast-to-coast and overseas during this period.
Please welcome the Executive Director of the World War II Commemorative
Committee, and a member of American Legion Post No. 141 in Richmond, Virginia, retired
Army Lieutenant General Claude Kicklighter.
LT. GEN. CLAUDE M. KICKLIGHTER, USA (Ret.)
Executive Director, WWII Commemorative Committee
It’s an honor and a privilege to be with you at our National Convention. For more than
76 years, The American Legion has been serving our veterans and our nation. The Legion
is a strong force for a better America. Thank you, American Legion, for all that you do for
our veterans, our communities, and especially our young people. The hallmark of this
organization is reaching out and helping and encouraging the youth of America. Thanks also
for the great support that you provide to the military members and their families. You are
an important part of what makes America great today.
Just one example of your contributions is what The American Legion did during World
War II when you drafted and pushed through Congress the GI Bill. It’s been said by many
that this was probably the best bill that ever came out of Congress. It gave young Americans
for the first time the opportunity to study, based on ability and not the fact that they were
born into affluence. That bill has filled our Congress, it’s filled the Supreme Court, the
corporate halls of America. Many of the leaders that built this nation would not have been
there without the GI Bill.
We’re now approaching the close of the 50th anniversary of World War II. This
morning I will update that program and what remains.
As you recall, the purpose of the program is to help the nation, our nation, a grateful
nation, to thank and honor the World War II veterans, their families, and especially the Gold
Star families, the families that lost loved ones in that war. It is also to thank those who
almost overnight turned America into the arsenal of democracy, those on the home front.
Never has our nation been so united as it was 50 years ago.
To help us reach the almost eight million World War II veterans that are still with us,
out of the 16 million that served in that war, we have now more than 7,000 World War II
commemorative communities and organizations all across this land that are thanking and
honoring our veterans at a very special level in their hometowns. More than seven hundred
of these commemorative communities are American Legion Posts and Auxiliaries. The
American Legion was one of the very first major organizations to become a World War II
commemorative organization when General Colin Powell came and presented the Flag
almost four years ago.
The American Legion has also not only volunteered their Posts, but they have recruited
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
83
and encouraged many other communities and supported the states that participate in this
program. I wish I had time to share with you some of the very emotional and special events
that take place in small town America as those veterans know that they haven’t been
forgotten.
Throughout this program, education has been a very high priority, and the Legion has
been with us ail the way on that. Together, we have provided more than 20,000 schools or
recipients of some veiy professional education materials that both the Legion and our office
have been able to disseminate.
But when this program comes to an end, together we must continue to encourage the
study of the history of this era. If we learn, and if we remain prepared and strong, maybe,
just maybe World War II will be recorded in history as the last world war. Maybe the
children and the grandchildren of the generation who we honor will never have to know
anything about a global war, and not have to go through what our veterans of World War
II had to go through.
We still have some very outstanding educational materials that are available, and I’m
asking the Legion to continue to be involved, to help us as we close the program, to get
these materials in the hands of the school teachers and the schools in your communities.
During the last four years we have commemorated the major battles of the war all over the
world, and the Legion has always been there to help make this happen.
Starting on about the 13th or 14th of August, just a couple of weeks ago, we began to
commemorate and to celebrate V-J Day, a victory that finally brought an end to the most
destructive war in history, the war where more than 15 million combatants laid their lives
down on the battlefield. More than 38 million civilians, mostly women and children, were
killed in that war because they were overrun by that war.
So as we came to the end of this war, and we came to V-J Day, we remember all the
battles that had taken place in the Pacific that had led us to that victory.
In Washington, D.C. we had the Vice President participating. About 9,000 veterans
took part in a great commemoration in Washington, North Carolina. In New York City in
Times Square we had a commemoration of the end of the war. So to in Atlantic City, New
Jersey. Former President Bush participated in Fredricksburg, Texas. Omaha, Nebraska
events went on for four days. We had about 10,000 veterans and the crew of the battleship
Missouri in Bremerton, and Seattle, Washington. In Honolulu President Clinton led the
commemorations, and we had more than 30 delegates from other nations.
So we have really reflected on this closing of the war and V-J Day in celebrating this
great victory. But as we reflected on the final victory, we couldn’t help but remember the
battles at the close of the war; the battles of Iwo Jima and Okinawa. And as you heard
General Tibbets say just a little while ago, as those battles came closer and closer to Japan,
they became more deadly and more violent. The small island of Okinawa was the last stop
before we went into Japan. Almost 6,000 sailors lost their lives in the ships supporting that
effort, and more than 8,000 soldiers and U.S. Marines lost their lives fighting that battle.
A hundred and ten thousand Japanese troops died, and 70,000 civilians.
We were poised after that battle to prepare for the invasion of Japan. The date was set
for 1 November, and the island selected was Kyushu. When we began planning the invasion
of Kyushu, the enemy strength on that island was 200,000. That was in June. By August,
that strength had grown to 550,000. That battle would have been horrendous, and the battles
on the other islands that would follow would be almost unimaginable in terms of deaths and
destruction. But a bomb was dropped on the 6th, another on the 9th of August, 1945.
84
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Finally Japan surrendered, saving millions of lives and shortening that war probably by
more than a year. President Truman, the Commander-In-Chief, as we heard this morning
made the right decision for the right reasons.
We will always remember those heroes that didn’t come home. Those who gave all
their tomorrows, and that’s a very high price when you’re 18 or 19 years old. History
reaffirms that they did not die in vain.
The closing week of the World War II commemorative program will take place the 4th
through the 11th of November. On Veterans Day, 11 November, the curtain will come
down on the 50th commemoration of World War II. And we will begin that week by
dedicating the site in Washington, D.C. where the World War II Memorial will be built.
There will be many events during the week of the 4th which will emphasize education.
The Legion, as they have done throughout this program, will be a major force in helping us
to properly end this commemoration.
I would also ask the Legion, as we come to the end, to help our Committee to write the
plan to properly commemorate the 50th anniversary of Korea as well as the 50th
anniversary of Vietnam. We ask you to help us develop those two very important plans
while we still have the experience of what we have accomplished in the last four and a half
years.
No generation of Americans has ever been given a tougher job than was the World War
II generation. President Roosevelt said: “Of some generations, much is asked; of other
generations, much is given, but this generation, the World War II generation, has a
rendezvous with destiny.” And so you did.
They fought the most destructive war in history, the war that we were not prepared for.
We had to buy time with the lives of young Americans to get prepare. But they fought that
war, they won that war, and they literally saved the world. Then they came home, took off
their uniforms, rolled up their sleeves, some going back to school, but all building this great
Nation that we have today. No matter what we do as a nation to honor this generation of
Americans, it won’t be enough. There is simply no way to do that. It’s been said that any
nation that forgets its veterans, ceases to be a great nation. But as long as we have a great
organization like The American Legion, America will never forget its veterans. A grateful
nation does remember.
We thank you, the World War II veteran in the audience, for the victory 50 years ago
that gave us this strong, free and beautiful America. When we wake up each morning, we
should remember that it didn’t just happen. We should never take this gift that you have
given us for granted. God bless you.
... At this time National Commander Detweiler presented General Kicklighter with a
commemorative T-shirt.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As we move forward with the business
of the 77th National Convention, it gives me a great deal of pleasure to present to you a
Minnesota Legionnaire who has earned the respect of millions. She is the chair and the
founder of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project, Incorporated. From Northfield Post 84
in Minnesota, please give a warm welcome to Diane Carlson Evans.
DIANE CARLSON EVANS
Chair and Founder Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project, Inc.
In a diary published after his death, U.S. naval aviator Lieutenant Frank Elkins said that
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
85
it’s easier to die for an ideal than to live for it. Dying takes only a moment’s courage, while
living is a battle against day-by-day eroding and grinding forces. To stand up to life and to
hold high standards sincerely is a more difficult price than an instantaneous death.
Lieutenant Elkins struggled in July 1966 with his fears, his thoughts, his hopes, his dreams
and his profession as a navy pilot in Vietnam. In October, 1966, he was killed when his
plane was shot down. I am honored, once again, to be invited here to speak and even more
honored to be with people in The American Legion who remind me of Lieutenant Elkins’
words. You hold high standards and daily stand up to be counted on the side that you and
we value most.
You did that, in your struggle with us to honor women veterans and help to build the
Vietnam Women’s Memorial. It was ten years ago in 1985 on the convention floor that
delegates passed a resolution to place a memorial honoring women at the Vietnam Veterans
Memorial. In the following years you raised over $100,000 for the project and helped us
pass two bills through Congress. In 1993,1 came before you to say the journey is almost
over. The statue had been cast in bronze in Loveland, Colorado, and was ready to be
dedicated on November 11th, 1993. You came by the thousands to honor your sister
veterans.
Now the memorial is healing the wounds and capturing the hearts of millions of
Americans and people from around the world, whether they served in Vietnam or whether
they opposed the Vietnam War.
One day as I visited the memorial recently, I stood back and listened unobtrusively to
the remarks being expressed. A little girl, probably about five years old, held her mother’s
hand and asked, “Mommy, what did those women do in the war?” I was struck by the
thought that question would never have been asked by that young girl if the statue wasn’t
there. The mother’s reply: “Honey, they are real heroines. They weren’t forced to go to the
war. They wanted to help, and I think they must have saved a lot of lives.”
The truth is now sculpted in bronze. The truth is that women contributed immeasurably
in ways that only those whose voices were silenced can truly tell, and those who lived carry
in their hearts every day.
We received hundred of letters from women veterans telling us what the memorial
means to them, but most letters come from men. Never in our wildest imagination did we
realize how much the memorial would mean to them also.
Perhaps this excerpt from a letter by a former Marine sums it up best. He said, “As you
unveiled the memorial, I wept and applauded. Thank you. Thank you for giving us, too,
the Women’s Memorial as well as giving us the opportunity to collectively release through
our tears, our hatred, our self-pity, regret, our feelings of being forgotten and our sadness.”
The memorial is there for us and for all future generations. But yet, while women paid
a heavy price in Vietnam, there’s still a price yet to be paid on the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial. The total ten-year budget for the memorial was under $4 million, but the
remaining loan obligation is still over $300,000 for the construction, design, lighting and
landscaping costs. Over these past few months we have solicited hundreds of corporations
with very little success.
Our most recent largest corporate donor was Martin Marietta with a donation of $5,000.
We have written to Hollywood stars, producers, authors and thousands of individuals.
Sometimes there is a surprise, like the donation from Roy Rogers in honor of Dale Evans.
It’s the thousands of people who continue to support the memorial effort with their small
donations that help us chisel away at this more than $300,000 debt.
86
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Many of you know that in 1993, to fund the project’s continuing mission of healing,
education, research and identifying the women who served, we introduced the Vietnam
Women’s Memorial Commemorative Coin Act. It passed quickly and unanimously in the
Senate, and we had over 300 cosponsors in the House.
However the bill was held up in subcommittee due to political complexities, too
numerous to mention here. As a proliferation of coin bills was being passed, a moratorium
was placed on coin legislation by the Secretary of Treasury. We had to put a hold on the
VWMP Commemorative Coin.
We asked the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund to help pay for the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial. They have donated a total of $25,000. This was in 1991. After several more
requests they have refused any further donations. You will recall that the fund paid for the
Wall and the statue of the three men.
The official memorandum of conveyance, turning the memorial over to the people of
America, has given the project the right to participate in Memorial Day and Veterans Day
ceremonies. We select a woman veteran for each ceremony, and we would welcome your
recommendations. Please send these names to our Washington address. Include a brief
biography of the woman as well as a telephone number and address so we can contact her
if she is selected. We look for diversity and are considering having the children of women
veterans also be considered for speakers.
Our Veterans Day speaker last year was Gail Hagger from Montana with the Army
Special Services, and on Memorial Day, we were represented by Lieutenant Colonel Regina
Ohn who survived the Operation Baby Lift crash which killed Mary Klinker, whose name
is on the Wall.
This gives you a brief report. We work weekly with students, producers and writers.
A children’s book on the Vietnam Womens Memorial project has been published and we
are currently working with PBS on a documentary. The work goes on.
The most alarming piece, however, that has been published on the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial has come from the Smithsonian Institution. A college professor wrote a book on
public art for the Smithsonian and said, I quote, “The Vietnam Women’s Memorial gives
a warped glorification of war typical of neo-conservative revisionists’ accounts of America’s
Vietnam experience and gender roles. Like the hart sculpture, the Vietnam Women’s
Memorial makes heroes of all military Veterans. It not only elevates American guts and
glory fantasies, but turns wartime pain and sacrifice into nothing more than a bronze wet
dream involving a GI and nurses.”
She goes on to write, of course, by avoiding allusions to the real context of American
foreign policy, the Vietnam Women’s Memorial shows itself as the perfect model of a
thoroughly politicized, right-wing recuperation of the war sentimentalized as an altruistic,
innocent and unfinished American adventure.
The woman who wrote this teaches college in Colorado and is the director of the
American Studies Program. So just what else does she teach her students about us Vietnam
veterans, and why did the Smithsonian Institution print this? I quoted this for you so that
you realize as we all realize since Enola Gay that our work is far from over.
I also came here today to thank you for continuing to support the project’s efforts. One
needs only to visit the statue to realize that we did something valuable and important for
America. You have our eternal thanks for standing beside us.
I want to now make a presentation to the Commander.
Commander Detweiler, on behalf of the Vietnam Women’s Memorial project, I present
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
87
you with a replica of the statue to thank The American Legion for all the wonderful work,
and support that you have given women veterans.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Diane brings up a good point again
about the Smithsonian. We sometimes fail to read what the revisionist historians write on
the plaques. We go in and we look at the artifacts and think we should be free to believe
by looking at the artifacts and interpret that artifact in our own way, which is the way it
should be. But we usually don’t read what they’re saying about the artifacts. That’s where
we must be vigilant about their version of American history.
We need to keep vigilant. This is not censorship. This is a situation of standing up
again for what’s right and for what’s good for this country, for future generations.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It’s been my pleasure to serve this past
year with a lady from Maryland who has had the special opportunity to lead the American
Legion Auxiliary during its Diamond Jubilee Year. Her theme for the year has been, 75
Years of Service, Not Self. At every opportunity, she has made good on that theme. The
American Legion Auxiliary has supported the Citizens Flag Alliance, worked tirelessly at
VA hospitals, and made Legion-family community programs successful. I thank her for a
year of service and support, for much of The American Legion’s success comes in no small
measure from the efforts of the American Legion Auxiliary.
I present to you the National President of the American Legion Auxiliary from
Greenbelt Unit 136 in Maryland, Linda Newsome.
MRS. LINDA NEWSOME
National President, American Legion Auxiliary
Thank you so very much for what you do. I want to thank Bill for serving as
Commander of The American Legion this year. When we took office yesterday, at least it
seems like it was sometimes, we set certain goals. In the American Legion Auxiliary during
our 75th year, our Diamond Jubilee Year, I, too, set goals. I set goals on membership. I
wanted to obtain 1 million members. I still want the 1 million members. No, we didn’t
reach our goal, and, yes, we still need the help of The American Legion. But what we did
do is to increase our membership by almost 6,000, and that’s no small feat.
Yes, we did make a commitment to the Citizens Flag Alliance. We have worked very
closely with The American Legion, with the Citizens Flag Alliance and certainly with all of
our members. We truly believe that we need the constitutional amendment to protect our
flag. And we don’t just talk about it amongst ourselves. We write the letters and we make
the phone calls. We make the personal contact and we put our money where our mouth is.
I am very proud of the efforts of the American Legion Auxiliary this year on the
Citizens Flag Alliance. We are not done, but don’t ever doubt that we will carry through.
My third emphasis was to make the public more aware of the American Legion
Auxiliary. “75 Years of Service, Not Self,” and we have carried through that motto by
donating more than $17 million to our communities just this year. We have given millions
of hours of volunteer time, whether it be in our communities, in our VA hospitals or
working with the children. Wherever we are, we do make a difference.
I have been so very proud to be the National President of the American Legion
Auxiliary. I have been proud to stand side by side with a National Commander who has
taken the lead in making sure that organizations and government commitments don’t change
88
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
our history. I commend Bill on what he has done this year. 1 only wish we had time to
spend more of it together. His schedule and my schedule rarely coincided. But when it did,
it was certainly a pleasure, as it has been a pleasure to be your Queen of Diamonds this year
of our 75 years.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next guest is a retired Air Force
Brigadier General and a woman who knows how to get things done. She is the president of
Women in Military Service for America Memorial Foundation, Incorporated. For several
years, she has led the nation’s effort to build a memorial for all women in military service.
She said to me that I will be in Washington for the day of ground breaking of the memorial.
I never said no to a General.
Here she is, a member of American Legion Post 477 in Chrisman, Illinois. Wilma
Vaught.
BRIG. GENERAL WILMA L. VAUGHT USAF (RET.)
President, Women in Military Service for American Memorial Foundation, Inc.
We very much appreciated your being with us to speak at our reunion event and then
to be with us for the ground-breaking. It seems hard to believe that back in 1987 it was just
a small group of us who started out to bring about this memorial. We wanted it to be
something more than a statue, that is just granite or stone. We felt it needed to tell the story
of our women and their service to the nation. The site picked in 1988 was near the main
gate at Arlington National Cemetery. In 1989 we had a nationwide design competition and
got a memorial design that we felt really tells the story of women’s service to the nation.
It’s a design that tells it in many ways, from the arc of glass tablets with the quotations of
women who served etched in them to reflect on the wall inside, to the water fountain where
the sound of the water will be commemorative of women’s voices. And then, we also have
the computer register where you folks in the Legion have helped us so very much by getting
women registered from your home communities. That is critical to our success. We have
about a 125,000 women registered out of the 1.8 million who have served, so we have a
long, long way to go.
By this past spring, we had amassed just enough money to have the ground breaking
ceremony. This meant that we had covered the cost of construction. I only wish you all
could have been with Commander Detweiler, the President and the First Lady and all of the
other dignitaries who were there. Some 6,000 women veterans and their families heard
speaker after speaker tell about women’s service and listened to the six women whose
service represented the span of time from World War I to today’s service women. It was a
wonderful, historic moment. The hit of that was our World War I veteran who has 78 years
service with The American Legion. I bought a tape that shows her speaking along with the
President in the actual ground breaking. Now you can live it with us as we lived it on June
22nd.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
Unfortunately Commander Detweiler is not in the video. Because you weren’t there,
we have your shovel full of dirt in Washington. For now, here is your shovel.
Like Diane Carlson Evans, we still have money to raise and equipment to furnish the
education center. We had to take a $2.3 million line of credit to come up with the amount
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
89
of money for the ground breaking I hope we never have to draw on it and end up with a
debt. When we dedicate this Memorial in 1997,1 want it to be debt free.
We are raising more funds partially through the sale of these commemorative coins.
If you haven’t purchased yours, the only place you can buy them is from us or via the
POW/MIA group or via the Vietnam coin. The prices are $35 for the coin and $75 for the
necklace. The American Legion is very close now to having donated enough money to be
listed in one of the alcoves of the exhibit. I look forward to seeing The American Legion
there along with the American Legion Auxiliary.
I found out after the convention that your Commander had invited our World War I
lady to attend the entire convention. She’s here today to say a few words.
She served in both World War I and in the California National Guard in 1951 during
the Korean crisis. She is a real patriot.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I had the great honor, on the evening
prior to the ground-breaking, to be at the reception, or the reunion as it was called, at the
J.W. Marriott. Someone came to me and said there is a lady there that he wanted me to
meet. The lady had been a member of The American Legion for 77 years. She is an
incredible person. You saw her speak on the tape. She’s a beautiful lady. She is from the
Brooklyn Post No. 2.
We have a 75-year pin for her. I would like at this time for Ann Peterson Freeman to
come forward.
MRS. ANNE PEDERSON
Brooklyn Post No. 2
Fellow Legionnaires, you cannot imagine the thrill it is for me to be here with you after
being a Legion member for 78 years. What a year this has been for me meeting the
President and First Lady, speaking on national television, and then having our National
Commander Bill Detweiler invite my daughter and me to be the Legion’s guest during the
convention. Thank you very much, Commander.
Sometime in 1919, some of my fellow women navy yeomenettes at the Brooklyn Navy
Yard started organizing a Legion post, signing up women to join. When they asked me, I
said, oh, sure, of course I’ll join. I believe I was the 13th woman to sign up. We were the
first post to receive our charter, and it was No. 1. Then some people said [incorrectly] that
the first Legion post had been organized in Paris, France, so we should be No. 2. We were
then called the First Women’s Post of The American Legion No. 2.
1 was an active member there for many years until we moved to San Diego where I
joined the San Diego Women’s Post No. 451.1 might say that one of the members of San
Diego Women’s Post is here with you today. The women in this post had belonged to Post
6, a post with both men and women. With more than enough women, they had formed their
own post and that was in 1929. I did not live in California at that time.
It was a great day for me when the Veterans Hospital was opened in La Jolla,
California, and I had an opportunity to do volunteer work there. I spent a lot of time
crocheting and knitting lap robes. We gave each veteran a lap robe to take home with him
when he was discharged.
I was an active member in the 40 and 8 for several years, but finally had to drop out
because I was getting a little older and couldn’t handle so many activities anymore. I still
90
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
belong to the Auxiliary of California, and that’s a wonderful Auxiliary.
When I moved back to New York to live a few years ago, I became a member of the
Memorial New York Post 1627. I have remained in the Legion because I like the Legion’s
idea of helping people, veterans and their families. And I have always felt strongly about
our Child Welfare program.
I was delighted when I found out about the Women’s Memorial, and it was gratifying
to know that the Legion has supported it. I didn’t know about it until June of this year. I
can only hope that each legion post will work in its community to help find our women
veterans and get them registered so they can be honored as I am being honored.
Although I may have been the 13th to sign up for my Legion post, signing up was one
of the best things I ever did in my life.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ms. Freeman said she’s indebted to us.
We’re indebted to her, because without those World War I patriots, we surely wouldn’t be
here today. I feel very strongly that it would be interesting to see what America would be
like if The American Legion had not been founded some 77 years ago.
SONS OF THE AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It is now an honor for me to present to
you the newly elected National Commander of the Sons of The American Legion. He’s
been a member of the Sons for 24 years, and believes his involvement at the national level
provides an opportunity to lead a renewal of the spirit of America in the nation’s children.
While he’s not tackling challenges the for Sons of The American Legion, he’s Housing
Inspector for the City of Covington, Kentucky.
Please welcome a member of Latonia Squadron 203, the National Commander of the
Sons of The American Legion, John Dietz.
JOHN DIETZ
National Commander
Sons of The American Legion
It is indeed a pleasure to be with you here today, but before I begin, I would like to
introduce another officer in the national organization of the Sons of The American Legion,
our National Adjutant Woodrow Mudge from Colorado.
It is indeed a pleasure for me to be here today. You know, nowhere in the world is
there an organization quite like The American Legion. Nowhere in the world is there an
organization whose members share the unique bond of service that your members do.
Nowhere in the world is there an organization that can lay claim to having such a dramatic
impact on the life of a nation as can The American Legion. You have a special heritage that
is unique in the life of America.
As Sons of The American Legion, we share that special heritage. We are indeed proud
possessors of that priceless heritage. And since our establishment in 1932, we have been
working to preserve the kind of America that Legion members have always fought to
defend.
But our Legion family is much more than hats and parades and conventions. Day-byday in communities all across this nation we are in the people business, to steal one of
Commander Detweiler’s terms. Getting involved in our communities, making a difference
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
91
in the lives of individuals, serving America, is our job. It is noble work and it is important
work that few other organizations can or will do.
As Sons of The American Legion (SAL), we seek to be involved in that noble effort.
We seek to be a full partner in the work that you do in communities and in the states and
across America.
For this year just completed under National Commander Joe Mayne, we reached
another all time high in membership, 187,000 members raised and contributed nearly
$250,000.00, and contributed 53,000 hours to veterans rehab.
This year, too, as for the past five years, we’ve been very involved in the Child Welfare
Foundation. We were fortunate this year, with the help of our members, to raise over
$87,000.00.
For this coming year, we have a mission objective. That objective is to make the Sons
a much more visible and a much more effective member of this Legion family. To achieve
that, we have outlined three goals: First, our Flying High Membership Campaign seeks to
achieve 200,000 plus members. We want to enlarge SAL participation in Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation through the VAVS program. And we want to get more Sons members
involved, in Legion youth programs, Baseball, Oratorical, Boys State, Junior Shooting
Sports.
It’s my understanding that the Child Welfare Foundation issued a challenge to The
American Legion to raise $100,000.00 this year. To go on public record, 1 would like to
meet that challenge. I would like to beat that challenge, and challenge the members of The
American Legion and the American Legion Auxiliary to raise that amount of money,
because the work of the Child Welfare Foundation is so important and we will be there.
The Sons continue to rely on your assistance and support throughout the Nation at your
Posts, your Districts, and counties across America. The Sons stand ready to support Legion
activities whenever and wherever, and we stand ready to finally win the fight for the
Citizens Flag Alliance for the Constitutional Amendment to protect the Flag.
I look forward to the opportunity to meet with many of you this year as I travel and
visit your Departments. And Commander Detweiler, I wish you the best of conventions and
a most successful and enjoyable term.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Our next speaker is a Congressman who
serves as the Chairman of the Subcommittee on Western Hemisphere of the International
Relations Committee. He has a strong voting record and supports a strong military as key
to peace through strength. He served in the United States Army in the late 1950s and has
held elected offices at the state and national level since 1969.
Please welcome from the 6th District of Indiana, Congressman Dan Burton.
Congressman.
THE HONORABLE DAN BURTON
United States House of Representatives (IN)
[Congressman Burton’s speech was interrupted by applause]
I understand that yesterday Senator Dole asked where the Kansas Delegation was, and
they were over on this side. He said that’s where they belong, on the far right. So I would
just like to ask those from Indiana, what are you doing over on the left? We need to move
92
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
you guys over here.
Well, it’s great to be with you. Since I served in the military back in the late ‘50s, as
the Commander said, 1 have had a great appreciation for those who served in actual combat.
I did not serve in combat, but I admire greatly those who laid their lives on the line around
the world for our freedoms. It’s because of that, that I feel it’s imperative that the
patriotism that you showed in defending our country be continued today, and that’s why I,
along with many of my colleagues, have sponsored legislation banning the burning of the
American Flag which you fought so valiantly to protect and defend.
I understand there’s been some comments made in the last day or so about cutting
veterans’ benefits and taxing veterans’ benefits. Let me just tell you, there are a lot of places
we can cut the budget without cutting into the benefits that you folks fought so valiantly to
get. You deserve what you get, and we’re going to do what we can to protect them.
One of the things that has concerned me greatly, over the past couple of years, is the
attitude that many in elective office have toward those who fought to defend our freedoms.
As a result of some of the things that have happened, I, and my colleagues in Congress,
have taken some actions and been very concerned that these things have happened. For
instance, let me give you a couple of examples of what’s happened in the last few years.
Four of the military attache to the White House, the creme de la creme of the military,
captains and lieutenants who were assigned to the White House staff to serve the President,
were asked to serve as waiters, at a political gathering. When I found out about that, I, and
my colleagues protested vigorously because we don’t believe that attitude should prevail in
the executive branch of government. And we received, as well as the military attache, an
apology for that, and we were assured it would never happen again.
It was brought to my attention that one of the chief assistants to the President told a two
star general that she wouldn’t speak to anybody in uniform. We thought that was wrong, and
we protested to the White House; there was an apology given, and we asked for that lady’s
resignation. Respect for the people who serve in our armed services should not be
compromised or questioned by anybody, all the way up to the Chief Executive’s office.
I became particularly concerned when the administration started talking about changing
V-J Day, Victory over Japan, to: End of the War in the Pacific Day. We thought that was
an abomination. V-J Day is V-J Day and it can’t be changed by any Executive Order. The
people who fought in the South Pacific to defeat Japan in World War II deserve our respect
and our honor, and changing the name of V-J Day to anything else is a slap in the face of
those who fought so valiantly in the South Pacific to give us victory.
Finally, one of the things that has concerned many of us in Congress who served in the
military and understands what happened in World War II, was some of the revisionists’
attitude about what happened when we brought an end to the war, when the bombing of
Japan took place at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Peter Jennings did a special, on ABC. He said
that it was analogous I believe to a holocaust for us to bomb the Japanese and to force an
end to World War II.
Anybody who knows anything about history and about what happened in World War
II in the South Pacific, knows that had we had to invade the Japanese mainland. If not, we
would have lost between four and five hundred thousand men and women, not to mention
the hundreds of thousands of Japanese that would have died when the invasion took place.
When Harry Truman ordered the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki he did the right thing,
because he brought an abrupt end to World War II and saved hundreds of thousands of lives.
Peter Jennings and the liberal media need to be taken to task for making those kinds of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
93
programs, and making those kinds of statements. You folks who fought in the South Pacific
and in Europe know what I’m talking about. You know what it is to go into hand-to-hand
combat to face an enemy; and you know how horrible it is to see your buddies die; and you
know how important it was to bring the war to its conclusion as quickly as possible not to
take lives, but to save lives.
I’m proud to be with you today and proud to be an American. I’m proud to be one of
those who admires each and eveiy one of you who sacrificed so greatly for our freedoms and
our liberties. And I’m proud to honor those who did not come back from the wars, who paid
that last full measure of devotion for our freedom, many of them your comrades.
I would like to leave you with this challenge, you and your loved ones, your kids and
your grandkids. Don’t let those who want to be politically correct, don’t let those who want
to revise history, change history. You and I, and those of us in Congress who feel as you
do, need to make sure that history is reported accurately. Only by doing that can we make
sure the mistakes of the past won’t be repeated in the future. We can’t let the liberal media
and those who want to change history, achieve their goals.
We want to leave to our kids and our grandkids and our great-grandkids and our entire
posterity the message that these freedoms that you fought so hard to preserve and to protect
and defend and give to them, and the sacrifices you made, should never be forgotten. So
that these generations will then have that sense of patriotism; that sense of dedication; that
sense of Americanism that you demonstrated so valiantly when you fought for our freedoms
all over the world.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We continue our World War II
commemoration activities of the 77th National Convention. The next distinguished guest
represents his nation in extending a special thank you to Americans for their valor and
commitment 50 years ago. This man has spent the last 30 years of his life in the foreign
service of his homeland. From Moscow, to Geneva, to London, to New York City, his
duties have continued to grow in the complex international relations arena. He comes to our
77th National Convention with a presentation that will touch each Department of this great
organization. A presentation will be made to further commemorate the men and women of
World War II.
I am pleased to present to you the Ambassador of the Netherlands, Adriaan Jacobovits.
HIS EXCELLENCY ADRIAAN JACOBOVITS
Ambassador of the Netherlands
Thank you very much for inviting me here in this very special year for you, the
veterans, and a very special year for us, the countries that were freed by you 50 years ago.
We have been celebrating that event in May when it was 50 years ago. We have
commemorated those who fell for our freedom, and I’m here today to thank you for all that
your veterans did for the liberation of my country.
Congressman Burton was quite right when he said that what you have done, your
sacrifice, will never be forgotten, and it has not been forgotten in the Netherlands.
Some 17 American divisions were there in the Netherlands, either fighting, or on their
way through to Germany. Some of them saw very heavy combat in the Operation
Marketgarden in particular. 2,635 Americans gave their lives for the freedom of the
Netherlands. Many more were injured; many of them severely.
94
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Today, the veterans of the Second World War, those who fought in the Netherlands,
may think every now and then what has happened in that country which they saw from their
fox hole. That wasn’t a very pleasant sight which you had then. There was a lot of rain;
some said it rained more than in Oregon; there was a lot of mud, and there was a lot of
misery. Well, you may imagine that is different now.
Let me point to two developments briefly which I think are interesting, one, economic,
and one in the military field.
Now, in the economic field we are a prosperous country. Rotterdam is again by far the
largest harbor in the world as far as tonnage is concerned which is being loaded and
unloaded there. The economic ties between the U.S. and the Netherlands are solid.
The Netherlands has become the gateway to Europe. Indeed, over 50 percent of all
exports to northwestern Europe from America and from Canada go via the Netherlands by
Rotterdam, Amsterdam, Fluessen. And indeed we have earned a lot of money by our
position, but we invest a lot of it abroad. And we are now the third largest investor in the
United States after Japan and the United Kingdom, but far ahead of other countries like
Germany or France. We think that the money is well placed, because we have a lot of trust
in America, and those people who were fighting for our freedom.
Now we have a single market, with some exceptions, in 15 European countries. That
is to say the Netherlands is in the center of a big market of 350 million people where there
is no border control and there’s free flow of goods, services and capital. And that means
that businesses can establish one distribution center to cover not only one country, but to
cover many countries in that market with the goods flowing freely on to the others, and the
Netherlands is one of the main distribution points for American industry. In fact, almost 50
percent of the Fortune 500 American companies that have decided to have a distribution
center in Europe, have it in the Netherlands, and the same goes for the Japanese industry.
It is because that we’re an industrious people and our labor productivity is on a par with
the United States and we two are the highest in the western world.
I always smile when I look at the OECD figures. The Organization for Economic
Development, said that the Netherlands had the highest labor productivity, and America was
second. But then I saw the American figures and it showed that America was first and the
Netherlands was second. But they are both on top and that is where we both want to be.
But that is on the economic side.
Maybe there is a far more fascinating development on the military side, particularly for
you veterans. Something happened that was unimaginable 50 years ago, or even 15 years
ago: the merger of the operative part of the Netherlands Army with the German Army. A
few days ago, the 30th of August, we combined our divisions under one
Netherlands/Germany Army Corps, with its headquarters in Munster, Germany. The first
commander is a Dutch general. The position of commander will rotate every three years
between the two countries.
But what is even more fascinating is that the headquarters will be totally integrated.
There will be 150 Dutch officers, 150 German officers working closely together. As you
may imagine, the working language will be English.
You gave us something also in the language sense.
It is an interesting phenomenon that there was no opposition to that, to speak of, in the
Dutch Parliament. And of course the Dutch Army was keen to work together with the
Germans over other nations, because for the last 40 years that we were defending the
northwestern plains we have been accustomed to work with each other, and we have esteem
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
95
for each other although we have our cultural differences. We are much less formal than the
Germans. The Germans have no women in their Armed Forces. So we’ll have to get more
accustomed to each other. But we both think that it is a very positive phenomenon that we
have been able to come to that merger, which is part of a phenomenon in Europe whereby
other multi-national Army Corps are coming up. There will also be a German/American
Army Corps and an American/German Army Corps. But contrary to ours, there will be a
lead country. That is to say that one country will command the corps, one country will
provide the headquarters, not an integrated headquarters as we have.
Now, I’m not here to tell you more about developments in Europe. I have found it
interesting to mention two of them, but the reason I’m here, of course, is to thank you for
our freedom.
And as a small token of our gratitude, I would like to present you with 55 hand-painted
plates which were made especially for this occasion by the oldest Netherlands company
from the 17th Century and has been headed by the same family since then, in Makkum in
Friesland. The plates are presented with an accompanying letter by the Prince of the
Netherlands, Bernard, who was our Commander-in-Chief in the Second World War, and is
now in his eighties but going very strong, and remembering what you did very much.
I would like to present to you this plate. I will read what is written there: In gratitude
for 50 years freedom. I would like to present this to the National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Each Department has been presented one
of these beautiful commemorative plates by the government of the Netherlands, and each
Adjutant of each Department may pick up one in the Convention Office. You have to sign
for it because it’s given to the Department; it’s a gift to the Department. The Adjutant has
to sign
Thank you Mr. Ambassador.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes Herman
Harrington of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Affairs for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF SECTION ON CREDENTIAL
AND OTHER INTERNAL MATTERS
(of Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs
Herman G. Harrington (NY), Chairman
Forty-eight members of the Credentials and Internal Affairs Committee, Section II,
considered thirty-two resolutions, thirty of which originated with Departments of The
American Legion and two of which were created by the committee. Of these, four were
approved, seven were approved as amended, three were consolidated into one which was
amended and approved, ten were referred, three were received and recorded, and five were
rejected.
96
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
Origin: TX
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, The Postmaster General of the United States Postal Service from time to
time issues stamps to commemorate great events in history and individuals of historical
significance; and
WHEREAS, The hero of the Battle of Argonne, Sergeant Alvin C. York, has not been
so honored; and
WHEREAS, In 1997, it will be the One Hundredth and Tenth Anniversary of Sergeant
York’s birth and the Eightieth Anniversary of the Battle of Argonne in 1918; and now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That we petition through proper channels to
the Postmaster General of the United States Postal Service to issue a commemorative stamp,
during the years of 1997 or 1998, in honor of Sergeant Alvin C. York, the most decorated
soldier of World War I.
Resolution No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
Origin: WV
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, October 14, 1997, marks the 50th anniversaiy of Captain Charles Yeager’s
historical flight in which he broke the sound barrier; and
WHEREAS, This feat began the age of supersonic flight, and made possible the
advantages in aviation and space exploration that we know today; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion petition the
Congress of the United States, and the United States Postal Service to authorize and issue
a commemorative postage stamp honoring the 50th anniversary of the beginning of the age
of supersonic flight.
Resolution No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
Origin: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, The 77th National Convention has been held in Indianapolis, Indiana,
September 4-September 6, 1995; and
WHEREAS, There has been a spirit of cooperation and friendship along with mutual
helpfulness evidenced by the Legionnaires of Indianapolis, Indiana, the officers of the
Convention Corporation and the Department, and by the officials and the people of
Indianapolis, Indiana; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, and 6, 1995, that we express our deep appreciation
to the Department of Indiana, Governor Evan Bayh, Lt. Governor Frank O’Bannon, Mayor
Stephen Goldsmith, the city officials of Indianapolis, including the Fire Department,
Police/Sheriffs Department, and other Public Safety officials, the military, especially the
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
97
38th Infantry Division, to the 1995 National Convention Corporation of Indiana, to local
citizens and Legionnaires and especially to the National Convention Corporation officers,
Gilbert E. Sheeks, President, K. Michael Ayers, Secretary, Norman E. Schlemmer,
Treasurer, Department Commander Ron Lowe, Allen Titus, K.W. Ohl, Vice Presidents,
Directors, George S. Wilkerson, Patrick Ryan, and Honorary member Thomas Henderson,
and Distinguished Guests/Finance Supervisor George Buskirk. Around this nucleus has been
built the moving force that provided for every necessity that made for a successful enjoyable
Convention.
Resolution No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
Origin: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
WHEREAS, the “eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month,”
commemorates the moment of the end of World War I; and
WHEREAS, this place in time has great and significant meaning to Americans for those
who served their country; and
WHEREAS, December 7,1941, is another historic date to be forever remembered; and
WHEREAS, this date, marked the world’s darkest hour, and the beginning of four years
of great losses and sacrifices; and
WHEREAS, the eventual road to victory over the despots of the world was difficult,
brutal, and seemingly impossible; and
WHEREAS, this world-wide fight for freedom and survival was finally achieved in
1945, now therefore, be it
RESOLVED, by The American Legion in National Convention, assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion remember those
men, women, and children who gave everything for America when it mattered; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, that the time of 9:04 a.m. On September 2, 1945, should be forever
remembered as the end of World War II; and, be it further
RESOLVED, that The American Legion encourages all churches to ring their bells at
9:04 a.m. On September 2, 1996, and at 9:04 a.m. on each September 2 into perpetuity, to
pay tribute to all Americans, who championed the war effort in the trenches, on the sea, in
the air, and on the home front; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion petition the government of the United States
to establish an annual moment of observance every September 2 at 9:04 a.m. in honor of
those American citizens whose service for God and Country will never be forgotten.
Resolution No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
Origin: IL
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, During World War II, Japanese American veterans served patriotically in
both the Pacific and European theaters of war, and
WHEREAS, Those who served in the 100 Bn. And the 442nd Regimental Combat
Team became members of the most highly decorated units in the military history of the
United States, and
WHEREAS, Those who served in the Military Intelligence service in the Pacific
98
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
campaigns helped to shorten the war, and thus lessened the casualties for thousands of their
fellow American men and women, and
WHEREAS, The Japanese American National Museum proposes to sponsor a “Salute
to Japanese American Veterans” on November 8, 1995 at the Los Angeles Convention
Center, and
WHEREAS, The event will coincide with the opening of the Museum’s major
exhibition on Japanese American veterans entitled “Fighting for Tomorrow: Japanese
Americans in America’s Wars,” and
WHEREAS, This event will be organized in co-sponsorship with the Department of
Veterans Affairs, the Department of Defense, Japanese American veterans service
organizations, other veterans organizations, community organizations, community and
business leaders, and
WHEREAS, The “Salute to Japanese American Veterans” will be a part of the World
War II 50th Anniversary commemoration programs sponsored by the Department of
Veterans Affairs, now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports and
encourages the Japanese American National Museum in its sponsorship of a “Salute to
Japanese American Veterans” on Nov. 8, 1995 at the Los Angeles Convention Center.
Resolution No. 93: The Enola Gay
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, The American Legion’s recent involvement in a line by line review of a
planned exhibit of the Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion testimony before Congress has brought to light
other areas of concern for the Smithsonian Institution; and
WHEREAS, This insistence for historical correctness by The American Legion has
resulted in a much abbreviated but never the less, historically correct exhibit of that famed
airship “Enola Gay” that delivered the weapon to Japan thereby ending WWII; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That we express our appreciation to these
members of Congress whose unflagging support in this endeavor was critical to our success,
to the members of our organization and to all Veterans who never faltered in their support.
Resolution No. 94: The Enola Gay
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, In the closing days of World War II, the United States ordered atomic
bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki; and
WHEREAS, The Enola Gay has become a symbol of the might and power of the
United States military and atomic power; and
WHEREAS, Recently attempts have been made to use the Enola Gay in an exhibit in
Washington, D.C. In a manner which would be detrimental to the use of these weapons as
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
99
well as accusing the United States of criminal behavior in their use; and
WHEREAS, As Veterans, The American Legion has taken the challenge to task and
has caused the Smithsonian Institution to cancel this discriminatory exhibit, which will be
reduced to exhibit of the Enola Gay alone. Now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That at the conclusion of the exhibit, the
aircraft be removed from the control of the Smithsonian Institution and offered to a facility,
willing and able, to exhibit the Enola Gay in its entirety along with a truthful script
associated with its historic mission and its contribution to end World War II.
Resolution No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, Through their heroic action, Gary Gordon and Randall Shughart,
U. S. Army in Mogadishu, Somalia, saved the life of Michael Durant, one of the survivors
of a downed helicopter, by defending said helicopter crew against a large group of armed
Somalis until all the other crew members were killed, and they themselves were killed; and
WHEREAS, On May 23, 1994, President Clinton presented to the widows of Gary
Gordon and Randall Shughart the Medal of Honor posthumously for their husbands’ bravery
in Mogadishu on October 3, 1993; and
WHEREAS, Such heroic action exemplifies all such deserving acts; and
WHEREAS, The Awarding of the Medal of Honor is the most prestigious honor our
Nation can bestow on any militaiy person and merits media coverage of major proportions;
and
WHEREAS, Proper media coverage for the awarding of the medals was not provided
or requested by the Presidential Public Affairs Office; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That in keeping with its trusted role of
promoting Americanism, we encourage all members of the national media to provide
appropriate coverage of future occasions.
Resolution No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
Origin: NY
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
•
WHEREAS, History shows that Battle of Midway in 1942 was a pivotal battle that
turned the course of WWII; and
WHEREAS, The Imperial Japanese Fleet was defeated in this battle by a handful of
Naval, Marine and Army aviators flying obsolescent aircraft; and
WHEREAS, The US Navy in September of 1993 closed Midway as an operational base
after 90 years of stewardship; and
WHEREAS, The US Fish & Wildlife Service has requested that Midway be turned over
to them primarily as a wildlife refuge and would then demolish most buildings and firing
positions, thereby removing forever any outward trace of Midway Islands; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
100
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, To emphatically oppose the surrender of
Midway Islands by the US Navy, and support legislation designed or intended to prevent
conversion of the Midway area from a significant historic military site of an American
victory into a wildlife refuge.
Resolution No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Origin: OH
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, The Vietnam Veterans Memorial is a structure designed to honor those
men and women who sacrificed their lives when their Country asked them to do so; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial, including as it does, engraved in granite, the names of
those who died and those who remain missing and unaccounted for in that War; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial is the most visited Memorial in the City of Washington and
is the site of unregulated sales of trinkets, T-shirts and souvenirs purporting to be sold for
purposes related to the Memorial; and
WHEREAS, The Memorial is the property and responsibility of the National Park
Service; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion encourages the
National Park Service to establish reasonable rules and policies to govern the sale of items
on the Vietnam Veterans Memorial grounds so as to ensure the preservation of the dignity
and solemnity of the Memorial and respect the memory of those it was established to honor;
and be it finally
RESOLVED, That the concern of The American Legion be communicated to
appropriate officials of the National Park Service and other appropriate agencies of
government.
Resolution No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
Origin: VA
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
As Amended
WHEREAS, In his distinguished military career, General George C. Marshall led
members of the Armed Forces of the United States who are now members of The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, As a statesman, George C. Marshall served with distinction as Secretary
of State, leaving the lasting legacy of the Marshall Plan, which led to the reconstruction of
Europe enabling the Western Democracies to stand and prevail against the forces of
Totalitarianism, Fascism and Communism; and
WHEREAS, The George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund is now establishing the
Marshall Home in Leesburg, Virginia, to inform successor generations of our principles
whereby free men and women willingly answered the call to arms to preserve that freedom
against aggressors however dangerous; and
WHEREAS, General George C. Marshall gave our comrades and our fellow
countrymen 59 years of selfless public service to shape the world in which we live; and
WHEREAS, Following application to the Department of Historic Resources of the
Commonwealth of Virginia and meeting the requirements for matching funds set forth in
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
101
the Code of Virginia by the George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund, the Treasurer on
behalf of the Commonwealth of Virginia provided $490,000 to The Fund toward the
purchase of Dodona Manor, General Marshall’s home in Leesburg, Virginia; and
WHEREAS, The George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund purchased Dodona
Manor, General Marshall’s Home in Leesburg, Virginia, on Thursday, 9 February 1995, for
the purpose of honoring George C. Marshall by establishing there at the Marshall
International Center which will; place Dodona Manor on the State and National Register of
historic properties and place a historic easement on the property to ensure its survival in
perpetuity; and establish at the center programs to foster the standards of leadership and
public service exhibited by George C. Marshall as well as Marshall’s axiom that free trade
and economic stability are essential to world peace; and
WHEREAS, The government of the United States has seen fit to place its imprimatur
on this fitting tribute to General George C. Marshall by providing a $1,000,000 through a
Special Purpose H.U.D. Grant to develop the George C. Marshall International Center in
Leesburg, Virginia; now therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995 endorses this fitting tribute to an outstanding
soldier-statesman and urges its members to support its noble efforts; and be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion interposes no objection the George C.
Marshall Home Preservation Fund soliciting funds to put in place a shrine to the efforts in
which he played so great a part in the Century of America.
Resolution No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
Origin: MO
Submitted by: Credentials & Internal Affairs
Consolidated with 2 (KS), 3 (KS)
As Amended
WHEREAS, The Kansas City historic Liberty Memorial is the only monument in the
United States to the more than 112,000 brave Americans who gave their lives defending
freedom during World War I, and
WHEREAS, The Liberty Memorial (1) is in danger of disintegrating and is closed to
the public for reasons of safety (2) is 68 years of age (3) is a towering 217 feet above ground
level, looking down on the Kansas City, Missouri Station, and
WHEREAS, The physical condition of The Liberty Memorial is worsening with water
seepage throughout the surface limestone and aggregate, galvanized by circles of freezing
and thawing, has collected in the concrete support piers and rusted out the essential metal
rods within those piers. The piers range in height from 12 feet on the south side to 40 feet
on the north, and
WHEREAS, Engineering estimates put the restoration cost at $25,000,000, and
WHEREAS, The preservation of the Classic Monument, The Liberty Memorial,
represents a major step in the march of freedom, and
WHEREAS, President Calvin Coolidge dedicated the Liberty Memorial in 1926, and
WHEREAS, U. S. General of the Armies, John J. Pershing born in Laclede, Missouri
said at the 1926 dedication, “This memorial.... Symbolized the obligation that rests upon
present and future generations to preserve that for which those men and women offered their
all,” now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
102
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion support efforts
to restore The Liberty Memorial in Kansas City, Missouri.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 5 (KS) 1995 NC: Legal Immunity for Volunteers
Resolution No. 6 (KS) 1995 NC: Authorization for The American Legion to Seek an
Amendment to Internal Revenue Code Sec. 501(c) (19) and Other sections
Resolution No. 63 (NY) 1995 NC: Support Audie Murphy Postage Stamp
REFERRED TO STANDING COMMISSION ON
INTERNAL AFFAIRS
Resolution No. 43 (IL) 1995 NC: POW/MIA Logo on Legion Envelopes
Resolution No. 44 (IL) 1995 NC: Roster Plaque for Sons of The American Legion
Resolution No. 55 (TX) 1995 NC: The Smithsonian Institution
Resolution No. 82 (PA) 1995 NC: Establish Subcommittee on Membership Eligibility
Dates
Resolution No. 84 (Wl) 1995 NC: Support Richard I. Bong Heritage Center
Resolution No. 67 (FL) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 90 (MO) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 95 (OH) 1995 NC: U.S.S. Missouri Memorial
Resolution No. 138 (VA) 1995 NC: Establishment of Joint Study Group Concerning
Auxiliary Eligibility
REFERRED TO STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 115 (MD) 1995 NC: Establish Awards for Emergency Personnel
REJECTED
Resolution No. 17 (CO) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 27 (AK) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 101 (MD) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 142 (UT) 1995 NC: American Legion Life Insurance Programs
Resolution No. 66 (MN) 1995 NC: Amend The American Legion Officer’s Guide and
Manual of Ceremonies on Military Funerals
It was regularly moved, seconded and carried that the Committee Chairman and
Secretary be authorized to sign the Committee report on behalf of the Committee.
It was also regularly moved, seconded and carried that the Committee Chairman and
Secretary be authorized to make technical corrections to the resolutions reported out of this
Committee to insure proper wording and form without changing the substance or meaning
of the resolution(s).
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
103
Mr. Commander, as a duly elected registered delegate from the Department of New
York, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes Bettylou Evans of
Delaware, Chair of the National Convention Committee on Membership and Post Activities
for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF COMMITTEE
ON CREDENTIALS AND INTERNAL MATTERS
Section III, (Membership)
Bettylou Evans (DE), Chairman
50 members of the Committee on Credentials and Internal Affairs, Section 3,
Membership and Guests, met at 9 a.m., September 2nd, 1995, in Room 102 of the
Indianapolis Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. Bettylou Evans of Delaware was
elected chairman and Gerald Goetzinger of South Dakota was elected secretary.
The following resolutions were referred to the Membership and the Post Activities
Committee: Resolution No. 116 from Maryland, “Other Than Active Membership in the
American Legion” and Resolution No. 144, Maine, “Memorial Posts”.
National staff provided reports on current activity and future statistics for the following
topics: The 1995 Membership Year, the 1996 Membership Promotion, DMS and Direct
Renewal, Membership Task Force Recruiting, Military Installation/Urban Area Recruiting
and an Individual Awards Incentive Program. As of Friday, September 1, 1995,
membership for the 1995 year stands at 2,945,812 members.
A “Ducks in a Row” contest began January 15 and continued through to the Delegate
Strength Target Date on August the 7th, 1995. One department in each of six categories won
a prize or its value of limousine service, rental car, stuffed duck or a live duck to be awarded
at this convention. The other 28 departments each received $50 towards cab fare during the
convention.
Winners of the limousine service included: Minnesota, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota,
Vermont and Delaware. Winners of the rental car include: Ohio, Wisconsin, Missouri, New
Hampshire, Idaho and Alaska. Winners of a stuffed duck include: Florida, New Jersey,
Washington, Alabama, Puerto Rico and Nevada. Winners of a live duck include: California,
Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas, Mississippi and Philippines.
They were quite a hit during the parade on Saturday. [Ducks were heard quacking in
the audience.]
The following departments received certificates as the “Biggest Ugly Duckling in the
Pond;” that is, those who did not have much success early in the year. But they did come
on strong from January to August: Florida, Texas, Georgia, Kentucky, New Mexico and the
Philippines.
During the 1996 National Membership Workshop, a drawing was held from among
those members of the Gold Brigade for an award of a $1,000 gift certificate. The winners
of those certificates were: Robert Mattison of Post 336, Pennsylvania; Jerry Harter of Post
529, New York; Forrest Simpson of Post 13, West Virginia; Andrew Knapp, Jr. of Post 4,
Michigan; Arnold Anderson of Post 7, South Dakota.
The 1996 membership promotion “Still Serving America” was introduced at the July
104
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Workshop. It is intended to motivate all levels of members to increase membership to the
ultimate goal of an all-time high. Membership for 1996 stands at 1,067,475. 32 departments
met or exceeded the first target date on August 16, 1995.
It was regularly moved, seconded and carried that the committee chairman and
secretary be authorized to sign the committee report on behalf of the committee. The
meeting was adjourned at 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Vice Commander, as a duly elected and registered delegate from the Department
of Delaware, I move for the adoption of this report.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE CHAIRMAN COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes, again, Herman
Harrington of New York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Credentials
and Internal Affairs. Herm.
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): Mr. Vice Commander, with
your permission I would like to take a moment, if I could, as Chairman of the National
Emergency Fund, to accept a contribution from some of the representatives of our
departments. With your permission we will bring to the podium the Department Adjutant
of the state of Washington, Bill Fortson, their National Executive Committeeman Mr.
Richard Calahan and Past Department Commander and incoming Alternate National
Executive Committeeman Mr. Dick Smith, who are to make a special presentation.
DELEGATE CALAHAN, (WASHINGTON): Commander, from the great Evergreen
State of Washington, we present $5,000 to the Emergency Services.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much.
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): That contribution that
brings us even closer to our goal of a million dollars of ready cash to help our comrades in
times of disaster. And I can assure you that every penny of it is available when the need
arises. Mr. Commander, with one additional point of privilege, if I could, I would like to
make a little remark of my own.
Since 1991, it’s been my privilege to serve as chairman of the World War II
Commemorative Committee. During those years we have recalled great victories, marked
the turning points, and counted the losses of that terrible war. This week much of that has
changed as we bring down the curtain on four years of remembrance and celebrate the
victory.
I’m sure that you will agree that our convention this year beginning with Saturday’s
SkyConcert, the fire works, the displays, the parade and the presentation to the Enola Gay
crew that you have seen, the concessions and all the special events of this convention speak
in no uncertain terms that even if no one else remembers, The American Legion remembers.
We of the World War II generation have had yet another day in the sun, and I know
that you will join me in saying we are grateful for the tremendous work, the great detail and
planning, the careful thought that our national staff put into World War II Commemorated
here in Indianapolis. Not only have we felt anew the pride of our services, but we have seen
in the faces of our younger comrades, in the faces of the people of Indianapolis and in the
faces of all in the Legion family, a new measure of pride in what our generation gave to this
nation. To the professionals, the staff, the volunteers, we are grateful to all who made it
happen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, Herman. It’s
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
105
always a pleasure for the National Commander to make the following type of presentation.
We have just adopted the report of the Membership and Post Activities Committee.
Membership continues to be very critical to The American Legion. Without an active,
growing membership our programs will lose strength, our voice in Washington will be
weakened and our service to veterans will suffer.
During the past year, two departments took their membership efforts to a higher level
by posting all-time highs. I ask that Richard Hall, Department Commander of Delaware and
John Marston of Mexico join me at the lectern. Gentlemen, the efforts of the men and
women you represent in your departments is heartening. Through determination, hard work
and commitment your membership grew to the highest level ever. It is with gratitude that
I present a plaque to each of you noting this achievement.
The plaque reads:
The American Legion Award for Outstanding Performance Presented to the
Department of Delaware and Mexico [separate plaques] for performing
meritorious service by enrolling this past year, a membership surpassing its
previous all-time high. In witness whereof, this plaque is given under the
hand and seal of the National Commander duly attested by the National
Adjutant at the 77th National Convention, Indianapolis, Indiana, this 5th
day of September, 1995.
Please take the message to your members that everyone appreciates their hard work and
service, that they have helped to keep The American Legion strong.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER RICHARD HALL, (DELAWARE): We will be
back next year to collect another one of these. Thank you.
DELEGATE JOHN MARSTON, (MEXICO): I never thought I would ever stand here
before you saying that No. 1 in the whole world was my department. But it is. Mexico is
No. 1 in membership. I’m honored by this presentation and I graciously receive it on behalf
of the Blue Cap Legionnaires that worked so hard to make me look so good. I would like
to recognize our Department Adjutant Joe Paulsen without whom this could not have been
done.
The Junior Past National Commander Bruce Thiesen and National Vice Commander
Joe Craig for all their help and encouragement. And to the Headquarters Staff member
Wayne Vanover whom I owe a great debt to.
And, Commander, if I might take a point of professional privilege, a long time ago a
phrase was coined. It said behind every man, there’s a woman. And that phrase is as valid
today as the day it was written. With that in mind, I would like to introduce you to the
woman behind me, my bride, Kathleen. She not only stood beside me for this past year to
make things easier, she also found time during the year to become President of Auxiliary
Unit No. 7.
Finally, Commander, my relief has already been elected and he is Dean Geddes.
Commander Geddes assures me, next year when you meet in Salt Lake City, he will be here
to accept this award again.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have another membership award to
present to George. It is The American Legion Department Commander of the Year. George,
this special plaque certifies the outstanding results of your leadership. Congratulations on
106
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
a very successful year.
In addition to these awards, the Department of Mexico has earned these two gift
certificates valued at $1500 each for surpassing 110 percent of its department goal. I
understand the department has agreed to use these awards for a special purpose.
DELEGATE GEORGE MARSTON, (MEXICO): Yes, we have, Commander. It’s my
privilege to now represent you with these certificates to be presented to the Citizens Flag
Alliance.
I might add, that with the previous contributions my Department has made, and these
contributions today, it brings the Department of Mexico per capita contribution to three
dollars per member. I would like to see every Department at least meet that and hopefully
exceed it.
1994-95 RECRUITER OF THE YEAR
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The success of The American Legion
over 77 years has its foundation in one element, a strong, vibrant membership. And since
membership is the life-blood of our organization, it is appropriate to introduce to you an
individual who has set the standard this past year.
The National Recruiter Of The Year recruited 552 new members to earn this honor for
the third time. Since the cut-off date, he has signed up additional members, for a total of
796 new 1995 members.
Please give a warm round of applause to a dedicated Legionnaire from Post 790 in
California, Joe Chilelli.
JOE CHILELLI, (MX)
1994-95 Recruiter of the Year
I can’t do it in three or four words, Commander, but I will tell you this. Membership
is the life-blood of every organization. Without membership we can’t get along.
Now, membership is the easiest thing in the world to get.
Now, you would think the hardest place in the world to get Legion membership would
be at a National Convention of The American Legion, wouldn’t it? In this lobby, I was
walking around for a few minutes when I went out for lunch, and Commander, you just
presented me with a plaque; I would like to present you with 11 new members.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: See that? Right out in the lobby. There
you go. How’s that?
You know what the difference between this gentleman and most of us in this room?
He asks; he asks, and he’s not afraid to ask because he can answer the questions. The simple
question of why should I belong to The American Legion.
GOLD BRIGADE ANNOUNCEMENT
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: This has been a year in which The
American Legion received an enormous amount of national exposure. That exposure came
because the members of our organization are willing to take a stand against the wrong
decision of the United States Supreme Court and the misguided efforts of historical
revisionists.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
107
At the same time, many of our individual membership recruiters have met the
challenge, carried the message of The American Legion to fellow veterans at home, and
recruited at least 50 new members. They are the members of The American Legion Gold
Brigade. I thank each and every one of you who helped to make The American Legion
stronger. Members of the 1995 Gold Brigade who are here today stand and be recognized.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Chester F. Stellar
of Ohio, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Veterans Affairs and
Rehabilitation, for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION ON
VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION
Chester F. Stellar (OH), Chairman
Eighty-four members of your Committee on Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation met
at 9:00 a.m. on September 2, 1995 in the Indiana Convention Center, Rooms 105-106, 1st
Level, and agreed on the following report which is respectfully submitted for your
consideration.
The Committee was called to order by Carroll Williams, Maryland, Liaison
Representative appointed by the National Adjutant to act as temporary chairman. Frank
Buxton, DC, Deputy Director, VA&R Commission, acted as temporary secretary and called
the roll. A quorum being present, nominations were received for permanent chairman.
Chester F. Stellar, Ohio, Chairman of the Standing National Veterans Affairs and
Rehabilitation Commission, was unanimously elected Chairman of the Convention
Committee.
With unanimous consent, the Chairman appointed Pat Phillips, Georgia, as Committee
Secretary, Richard Santos, Maryland, Chairman, and Vollie McCollum, Tennessee,
Secretary of the Medical and Hospital Subcommittee; and J.G. “Tracy” Taylor, Florida,
Chairman, and Doris Gross, Washington, Secretary of the Claims and Rating Subcommittee.
Subcommittee liaison assignments were as follows: Frank C. Buxton, Deputy Director,
to Medical and Hospital; Carroll Williams, Director and Harold T. Kelly, Assistant Director
for Program Management to Claims and Rating.
As has been the custom for the 51 previous National Conventions, a Special
Department Service Officers Committee on Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Resolutions,
in a three-day pre-convention meeting, screened and grouped the resolutions. A report of
their analysis, with recommendations, was presented to the Convention Committee for
consideration.
The Screening Committee conserved the time of the Convention Committee
substantially. The Screening Committee was composed of the following Department
Service Officers:
REGION
REGION
REGION
REGION
REGION
45678-
E. L. Reeves (MS)
Don Lanthom (OH)
Steve Burger (NE)
Duane Willis (UT), Secretary
Gerald Schleining (OR), Chairman
108
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
The Convention Committee recommended that such a Committee be appointed for this
purpose to serve the Seventy-seventh National Convention Committee on Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation.
The 32 Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation resolutions presented for consideration of
this Convention were referred by the Resolutions Assignment Committee.
The following action on the resolutions was taken by the Convention Committee:
Approved or Approved as Amended
5
Consolidated with Resolutions Approved
2
Referred to the Standing Commission
6
Received and Recorded
18
Rejected
1
A report of action taken on the 6 resolutions referred to the Standing National Veterans
Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission will be made to the National Executive Committee
and to the Adjutant of the Department concerned, and, in addition, will be contained in the
National Adjutant’s report to the Seventy-seventh Annual National Convention.
I now turn it over to Mr. Pat Phillips of Georgia to read the report.
REPORTED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 35: Oppose Centralization of VA Claims Processing Centers
Origin: ND
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, Currently there are 58 VA regional offices located in the 50 states, Puerto
Rico, and the Philippines, to provide service to veterans, their dependents, and survivors;
and
WHEREAS, This enables veterans and other claimants, including their accredited
representative, to have reasonable access to the VA claim file; and
WHEREAS, In any claim action, such accessibility helps ensure the claimant is
afforded full due process without undue delay or hardship; and
WHEREAS, Because of continuing Federal budgetary restrictions and a large backlog
of pending benefit claims, VA has designated certain regional offices with proportionally
lower workloads to handle certain categories of claims, i.e. Montgomery GI Bill, Persian
Gulf, certain home loan guaranty cases, and POW disabilities; and
WHEREAS, The records in such case have been physically transferred to the particular
regional processing center which retains possession of the records up to a year after action
on the claim is completed; and
WHEREAS, This procedure deprives the claimant reasonable access to the VA records,
including information as to the status of the case or disposition and inhibits the ability of the
organization to effectively advise and assist, i.e. “represent”, such claimants based on the
power of attorney; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion oppose the
centralization or regionalization of VA claims processing centers.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
109
Resolution No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
Origin: ND
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, The Tax Simplification Plan, released by the Department of the Treasury
in November 1984, proposed the federal taxation of VA disability compensation benefits;
and
WHEREAS, In the entire history of the disability compensation program these benefits
have never been subject to taxation at either the federal, state or local levels; and
WHEREAS, Taxation of these benefits would amount to nothing more than a
permanent, enduring reduction in benefits and would demean the sacrifice and service of our
nation’s service-connected disabled veteran population; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion vigorously
oppose any proposal that would subject VA disability compensation benefits to taxation.
Resolution No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review
Origin: SC
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, Chapter 11 of title 38, United States Code, sets forth a program of
compensation for service-connected disabilities; and
WHEREAS, Specific sections of Chapter 11 pertain to presumptions relating to certain
diseases and disabilities; and
WHEREAS, Presumptive service connection was first established as an important
feature of the World War Veterans Act of 1924, adopted June 7, 1924; and
WHEREAS, Liberalizing and amendatory legislation was adopted by subsequent
sessions of Congress, with The American Legion taking a leading role in the development
and implementation of the improved laws; and
WHEREAS, The current disability compensation program has proven to be a fair and
equitable manner in which to indemnify veterans suffering disabilities that are incurred or
aggravated in line of duty in the active military, naval or air service; and
WHEREAS, Many of these people, because of their disabilities, have had to resort to
financial help from the government to make their way through life, and
WHEREAS, In a landmark decision of the Supreme Court on May 23, 1983, Justice
William H. Rehnquist stated as follows:
Veterans have been obligated to drop their own affairs and take up the
burdens of the nation, subjecting themselves to the mental and physical
hazards as well as the economic and family detriments which are peculiar
to military service and which do not exist in normal civil life.
Our country has a long-standing policy of compensating veterans for their
past contributions by providing them with numerous advantages. This
policy has always been deemed to be legitimate.; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion embraces the intent of this eloquent statement as
it echoes the long-standing philosophy of this organization; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is totally supportive of every benefit that is
currently provided to veterans, as each of them had a purpose when enacted, and each has
110
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
proven currently to be meeting a legitimate need of the veteran population; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion oppose any
administrative or legislative proposal to dilute or eliminate any provision of the disability
compensation program; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion oppose the elimination or reduction of any
other benefit that is currently provided to the veterans of this nation, or to their dependents
and survivors.
Resolution No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to
Date The Deceased Veteran’s Claim was Filed
Origin: IL
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
WHEREAS, The American Legion is an organization of war veterans who have
dedicated themselves to the service of the community, state, and nation; and
WHEREAS, If a veteran should die while a claim is pending, including an appeal to
the Board of Veterans Appeals or the Court of Veterans Appeals, under 38 USC 5121, the
surviving spouse, dependents, or other eligibles are limited to one year retroactive accrued
benefits; and
WHEREAS, Veterans who have filed a benefit claim are having to wait six months to
a year or more for a decision by the regional office and following that, wait over two years
or more for a decision by the Board of Veterans Appeals and another year or more on their
case by the U. S. Court of Veterans Appeals; and
WHEREAS, Given the fact that a claim can be in a pending status for upwards of 4 or
more years, many veterans whose cases are in this category will die before a final decision
is rendered; and
WHEREAS, The families of these deceased veterans receive only a small portion of the
benefits that are due and otherwise payable to the veteran had he or she remained alive;
now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion seek legislation
to amend 38 USC 5121 to provide for the payment of accrued benefits in a pending claim,
including an appeal to the Board of Veterans Appeals or the U. S. Court of Veterans Appeals
to date the deceased veteran’s claim was filed.
Resolution No. 141: The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
Origin: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
Submitted by: Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
WHEREAS, The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical care system was
created to provide domiciliary and medical care to veterans; and
WHEREAS, VA initially provided care to disabled veterans, indigent veterans, and
other veterans based on a resource and space available basis; and
WHEREAS, Since the establishment, Congress has significantly expanded the medical
care responsibilities of the Department of Veterans Affairs; and
WHEREAS, Today, the Veterans Health Administration is responsible for providing
a range of comprehensive health care services to the Nation’s veterans. This is
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
111
accomplished through the operation of 172 VA medical centers, 235 outpatient clinics, 128
nursing homes, and 35 domiciliaries. VHA operates an integrated medical care system
committed to four primary missions:
* To develop, maintain and operate a national health care delivery system for eligible
veterans.
* To carry out a program of education and training of health care personnel.
* To carry out a program of medical care research.
* To furnish health care services to members of the armed forces during a war or national
emergency; and to civilians during national emergencies; and
WHEREAS, In recent years, the Department of Veterans Affairs medical care system
has been progressively impeded by rules, regulations, funding shortages and geographic
constraints which have made receipt of medical care by all eligible veterans more of an
achievement than an earned benefit; and
WHEREAS, In February 1992, The American Legion developed a comprehensive
blueprint to alleviate the anomalies relating to eligibility for medical care provided by the
Veterans Health Administration and the Department of Veterans Affairs and named the plan
“The American Legion Proposal to Improve Veterans Health Care,” also known as the Gold
Book; and
WHEREAS, The impact of recent Congressional budget shortfalls may place the
system in serious jeopardy and prevent VA from receiving adequate funding and legislative
relief to accomplish its myriad missions which would have a deleterious effect on veterans
seeking care for service-connected and non-service-connected conditions; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes the Federal Government must live up to
its legal and moral obligations and the expectations of the veteran and the American people
with regard to access to VA health care services for all veterans; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has developed a comprehensive legislative proposal
to implement the Gold Book named “The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security
Plan; and
WHEREAS, This legislation will revolutionize the way VA delivers health care
benefits to our Nation’s veterans and release VA from severe and restrictive eligibility
constraints.
The legislation will also provide ways to fund VA’s care of
non-service-connected, poor and catastrophically ill veterans; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion accept as its
policy on veterans health care, “The American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan”
which will:
1.
Reorganize the Veterans Health Administration to improve access, quality
and efficiency of the medical care provided to veterans;
2.
Operate the veterans health care system based upon the principles of
“managed care”;
3.
Assure all veterans with service-connected illnesses and disabilities access
to all services necessary for the treatment of their disabilities at no charge
112
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
to the veteran;
4.
5.
Assure all veterans with a service-connected disability rating of 50 percent
or greater, access to all VA health care services at no cost;
Assure all special category veterans, indigent veterans and
service-connected veterans rated under 50 percent disabled, access to VA
health services at no charge or reduced charge;
6.
Assure the long-term viability of the veterans health care system by
encouraging veterans who presently do not receive care, and their
dependents, to enroll in the Department of Veterans Affairs Health Care
Security Plan;
7.
Improve the long-term financial health of the veterans’ health care system
by increasing other resources of the system to include other federal
programs, third-party payers and employers of veterans;
8.
Permit VA to retain all payments made to the Department for health care
services;
9.
Eliminate unnecessary, duplicated or contradictory regulations which
hamper the ability of the veterans health care system to operate effectively
and efficiently;
10. Federal appropriations for the DVA health care system shall be based upon
a capitated method using the calculation of fully-allocated costs of care to
service-connected and other veterans receiving care at no charge;
11. Require the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to report to the Congress at designated
intervals on the financial soundness of the system, the budget-neutrality of the system
and the quality of care rendered; and, be it finally,
RESOLVED, That all previous American Legion resolutions in conflict with this
resolution are hereby rescinded.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
VETERANS AFFAIRS & REHABILITATION
Resolution No. 14 (CO) 1995 NC: State and National Committees in Support of Persian
Gulf Veterans
Resolution No. 19 (MA) 1995 NC: Eligibility Reform and Funding for VA Health Care
Resolution No. 41 (IL) 1995 NC: Expansion of Decatur, Illinois Outpatient Clinic
Resolution No. 68 (FL) 1995 NC: Restore Priority to South Florida Veterans Cemetery
Resolution No. 73 (IL) 1995 NC: Provide Dependent Children of Veterans in Nursing
Homes Greater Pensions for Incidental Expenses
Resolution No. 119 (NH) 1995 NC: Seek Outpatient Clinic to be Located at Peace Air
Force Base, Portsmouth, New Hampshire
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
113
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 7 (KS) 1995 NC: Exemption of Hiring Caps for Department of Veterans
Affairs
Resolution No. 21 (MT) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes
Resolution No. 34 (ND) 1995 NC: Seek Authorization for Department of Veterans
Affairs to Consider Current Income to Determine Eligibility for Care
Resolution No. 36 (ND) 1995 NC: Seek Adequate Appropriations for Department of
Veterans Affairs Medical Programs and Personnel.
Resolution No. 38 (ND) 1995 NC: Establish an Open Enrollment Period to Veterans
Eligible for Service Disabled Veterans Insurance
Resolution No. 39 (ND) 1995 NC: Increase the Maximum Amount of Service Disabled
Veterans Insurance
Resolution No. 52 (TX) 1995 NC: Oppose any Reduction in Veterans Benefits
Resolution No. 53 (TX) 1995 NC: Reduce Processing Time on Claims to Six Months
Resolution No. 62 (NY) 1995 NC: Request for National Cemetery Richmond County,
New York
Resolution No. 69 (FL) 1995 NC: Restore Benefits to Remarried Widows of Veterans
Resolution No. 86 (WI) 1995 NC: Create a Commission to Study the Restoration of the
Burial Allowance
Resolution No. 88 (MO) 1995 NC: Review the Ranking of Areas in Need of a National
Cemetery
Resolution No. 89 (MO) 1995 NC: Health Care Coverage for Newly Discharged
Veterans and Dependents
Resolution No. 97 (OH) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes Program
Resolution No. 118 (NH) 1995 NC: Continue Full Services at Manchester VAMC and
White River Junction VAMC
Resolution No. 120 (NH) 1995 NC: Support Per Diem and Construction Funding for
State Veterans Homes Program
Resolution No. 123 (CA) 1995 NC: Increase Funding for Medical and Health Research
Resolution No. 129 (SD) 1995 NC: DVA Ensure Veteran Service Organizations are
Provided any Correspondence Regarding Claims
REJECTED
Resolution No. 54 (TX) 1995 NC: Oppose Consolidation of Texas Department of
Veterans Affairs Medical Centers
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate from the
Department of Ohio, I move the adoption of the VA&R Report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. Any
discussion?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone number what, Four?
114
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
DELEGATE HERMAN HARRINGTON, (NEW YORK): Herman Harrington,
Delegate to this Convention from the Department of New York. I move, you, sir, that
Resolution No. 141 be set aside for the purposes of discussion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Without objection, so set aside. Now,
we have a motion to set aside of Resolution No. 141. We have a motion to adopt the report
with the exception of 141. Do I hear a second? Any discussion? All those in favor signify
by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Now, Mr. Chairman, you will now read the resolution in its entirety.
... At this time, Chairman Stellar read Resolution No. 141.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate from the
Department of Ohio, I move the adoption of Resolution 141.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion. Is there a second?
Any discussion?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Mr. Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 5.
DELEGATE EDWIN J. DENTZ (VIRGINIA): Eddie Dentz, duly registered Delegate
from the Department of Virginia.
I wonder, Commander, why The American Legion feels the need to promote a plan
such as this. Why don’t we allow the VA to continue to function as it is presently doing?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Delegate, that is a very good question.
There’s a mood in the Congress to reduce the budget, to cut the deficit by cutting
discretionary spending. VA health care is discretionary spending. We see nothing but
diminishing resources for veterans benefits, especially health care to where the point is the
VA will actually go away.
We want to be proactive. We want to be the leader in this to see to it that the VA
receives the funds from outside sources such as Medicare and third-party payers, and to
make sure the system stays alive. This is the way for the veterans to determine the fate of
the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Any other questions? Microphone 6.
DELEGATE GLENN R. GREEN, (SOUTH DAKOTA): Glenn Green, Delegate from
the State of South Dakota.
Now that you have the lights on in here, you can surely see that I’m not a Gulf veteran.
So with that, myself and others have the question on this plan as to whether I can use my
Medicare through the VA.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Boy, you can look at me too, Glenn, and tell
that I’m eligible for Medicare.
If you are a Medicare eligible veteran, you may enroll in this special benefit for
veterans and have all of your care taken care of by the Department of Veterans Affairs. And
the beautiful part about it is, under Medicare as it now stands, you have a large deductible;
with the VA, under this plan, if you enroll, and it’s voluntary, there would be no deductible.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you. Okay. There’s a flashlight.
Microphone No. 1.
DELEGATE GERALD L. MOORE (OHIO): This is Jerry Moore, duly elected
Delegate from Ohio. I would like to ask through the Chair to the Chairman, what effect this
would have on a military retiree and his dependent.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Very good question because I think this is
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
115
one of the greatest helps for the military retiree that I have ever known.
At the present time, many military bases are being closed and, therefore, medical care
to the retiree is not available where those hospitals have been closed along with the bases.
If you use your CHAMPUS, as I understand that program, you have a 25 percent deductible
on any operations that you might have. A $100,000 operation for a heart bypass would then
cost that veteran $25,000.
If you are over sixty-five, you will be able to use your Medicare in the VA if Congress
approves this, or if you use your CHAMPUS or use your CHAMPUS benefit and enroll, you
will be able to have full benefits from the VA. And since you are a veteran you could join
the plan on your own and take with it your dependents.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE GEORGE BLAIR, (COLORADO): Mr. Chairman, duly elected Delegate
of Colorado, George Blair. I would have to question what was just said about services to
military retirees at the VA Hospital. Unless the reform of eligibility and treatment changes,
according to the transcript from the secretary’s office, the military retiree over 65 years of
age right now has no Medicare service except in a private hospital, where $350 a month or
$400 a month is paid to that HMO just to administer our records.
I would like to also address the fact that Colorado did submit No. 14 that was referred,
and No. 14 was in concert with the Secretary of Veterans Affairs transcript for reforming the
system, whereby the military retirees and their dependents would be authorized treatment,
and was considering veterans and their dependents’ treatment.
Department of Veterans Affairs needs to take over the health care of all veterans,
whether they be career or non-career. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: That’s what this plan seeks to do. It’s
exactly what the plan seeks to do. Any comments as to Resolution 14 would, of course, be
out of order because that was contained in the actual full report.
Any other questions? No. 5.
DELEGATE ANTONIO RABBIA, (NEW HAMPSHIRE): Comrade Commander,
Tony Rabbia, Delegate from New Hampshire. If you are on Medicare and you want to join
the other plan, do you have to be 62 years old or 65? Is there an age limit?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: To qualify under Medicare, that is a separate
issue. If you have Medicare and you have qualified for it, then you are eligible to enroll in
this plan if you so desire and are then qualified for the full benefits.
DELEGATE RABBIA, (NEW HAMPSHIRE): So there is no age limit; am I correct?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: All you have to do is qualify for Medicare.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 4.
DELEGATE LOU DIMMERMAN, (OHIO): Mr. Commander, Lou Dimmerman, a
duly elected Delegate from the Department of Ohio.
I am wondering how this would affect me as a veteran and an employee of a large
corporation? Would I have access to that? Would my corporation be able to purchase that
for me?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Under this new plan, your employer would
be able to work with VA to make the VA plan an option you could choose or VA could
contract with your provider to care for you.
Again, I might stress that you are not compelled to enroll with the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 3.
DELEGATE ROD MATHISON, (WISCONSIN): Mr. Commander, Rod Mathison,
116
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Delegate from the Department of Wisconsin.
As a government employee, what would be the enrollment procedures under this plan?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: If you are a federal government employee at
the present time, as I understand the group insurance program for federal employees, you
have many, many options under HMOs that they offer you to choose from. Under this plan
there would be, then, another option that you could choose if you wanted to enroll into the
VA through your federal employee health benefits plan.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Now, just to make it very clear, this plan
takes in all veterans. It opens up, it includes, as opposed to excluding as the VA is set up
now.
Microphone No. 3.
DELEGATE TOM CADMUS, (MICHIGAN): Mr. Commander, Tom Cadmus from
the Department of Michigan.
I thought the ‘Gold Book’ was our health care plan. Is this something different?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: To the Delegate from Michigan, that’s exactly
right. The ‘Gold Book’ has been our health plan and continues to be our health plan. This
is the authorization for us to introduce it as legislation.
We, in the past, gave this out to all the legislators so that they could utilize it. We
hoped that they would see the light and would provide this kind of care. They don’t see fit
to do so. So, therefore, we are going to introduce the legislation to make the ‘Gold Book’
have some teeth and become part of the law helping the VA.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 3.
DELEGATE JOHN TITUS, (PENNSYLVANIA): Comrade Commander, John Titus,
Delegate from Pennsylvania.
I thought The American Legion was opposed to bringing non-veterans into the VA
system. Is this a change in our policy?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: This is going to change just somewhat our
policy, in that we’re going to allow the veterans and their dependents to come into this
program if they so desire.
Now, you will remember several years ago there was a plan offered by the VA at that
time to take a bunch of people into a VA hospital who were not veterans, and we vetoed that
quickly.
At least this plan has a veterans’ flavor to it and the veteran and his dependents will be
allowed to be enrolled in this plan and their care provided by the Department of Veterans
Affairs.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 4?
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE: Yes, Mr. Chairman. For clarification, you had
mentioned 65 year old veterans would be able to use CHAMPUS, I believe. 1 may have
misunderstood that, but veterans over sixty-five are not entitled to CHAMPUS. Could we
clarify that?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: It’s exactly right, sir. Some veterans retirees
under sixty-five are eligible for CHAMPUS. They could enroll in this plan. If you are over
sixty-five, then you become Medicare eligible, and they could enroll under this plan under
that program.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The last gentleman at No. 4 identify
himself and his Department please, for the record.
DELEGATE GEORGE BLAIR, (COLORADO): George Blair, Department of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
117
Colorado.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: No. 6?
DELEGATE HAL GOLDMAN, (CALIFORNIA): Comrade Commander, Hal
Goldman, registered Delegate from the Department of California.
I have a question not only about the plan, but we’re asking to accept this on its face
value, with the many hospitals that have been closing; with the fact that all of the VA
facilities are in fact teaching hospitals affiliated with most universities; how is this going to
affect that relationship, and what is going to take place in the facilities if we lose that type
of support? If we find out the universities do not want to join this program, are we taking
into consideration what happens then?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: You’re questioning whether the medical
affiliation of hospitals and the medical schools would continue? Yes, they would continue.
And that’s one of the things that this would benefit. There would be a greater utilization of
the VA so that the medical schools would clamor to be affiliated with the VA. I hope that
answers the question you wanted.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
This actually infuses additional
third-party dollars into the system. No. 4.
DELEGATE TOM BURTON, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, this is Tom Burton
from New York State.
Under Medicare, all of the veterans go onto Medicare at sixty-five; will their
dependents be entitled to that care at that time?
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: Yes. They would be eligible. When the
veteran goes in, he can take his dependents in, depending on what kind of a plan they might
want. But they would go with him.
DELEGATE BURTON, (NEW YORK): At the present time there are about four
categories. There’s the disabled veterans and then the other three categories. They are not
all entitled to medical care or to veterans care at the VA hospital at this time.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN STELLAR: The service-connected, at 50 percent or
greater will be entitled to full care of all their infirmities at no cost. This is a change from
what it is at the present time. If you’re taken in with a non-service-connected ailment, even
though you are service-connected, you will be billed for that. Under this new plan, if you
are 50 percent or more, all expenses will be paid. Those that are less than 50 percent will
pay a lesser premium for their coverage, and they can enroll and have full access to coverage
in the VA. And those, the categories that we have known as A, B and C, will be gone.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion calling for the question.
All of those in favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
There’s a motion on the floor and a second. The debate has been closed. All those in
favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. Motion is adopted.
WILLIAM F. LENKER NATIONAL SERVICE TROPHY
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: With the adoption of the Veterans Affairs
and Rehabilitation report, it is appropriate to announce the winner of the William F. Lenker
National Service Trophy. The trophy is awarded annually to the Department which best
supports and implements programs to benefit veterans, their families and their survivors.
For the 1994-1995 program year, the trophy is awarded to the Department of Ohio.
Accepting the award is Roger Hight, the Department Adjutant of Ohio. The trophy is quite
118
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
large, as most of you know, so it has been shipped, and I am presenting a certificate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes the Honorable
George W. Boucek of Illinois, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Finance,
for the purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
FINANCE
George W. Boucek (IL), Chairman
Forty-two members met at the Westin Hotel on Saturday, September the 2nd, in
Indianapolis, Indiana.
Paul Allen, the National Finance Director, opened the meeting as staff liaison, and
conducted the selection of the Chairman and the Secretary. George Boucek, myself, was
elected as Chairman, and Anthony Minei of New York was elected as Secretary.
The audit report of George S. Olive & Co.’s certified audit was presented to the
Committee, and it shows a deficit of $1,561,180 for the year ending December the 31st,
1994, but the Delegates were reminded that we will have a surplus in 1995. And incidently,
that entire audit report is contained in your official program book for this year, the last 12
pages of this booklet.
Daniel Wheeler, whom you have met, and who is the President of the Citizens Flag
Alliance, spoke about the successful House of Representatives Flag Amendment vote of 312
to 120 last July, and informed the Committee about the very crucial vote in the Senate,
which hopefully will take place in late October or early November. And you heard Bob
Dole tell you yesterday that he expects to bring that up for a vote before the end of the year.
Currently, 56 Senators have signed on as co-sponsors, and six Senators have informed
us that they will vote for the amendment but will not sign on as co-sponsors. For the Flag
Amendment to pass, we need 67 votes.
Mr. Wheeler informed the Committee they have set up a special Phone Bank and I’m
reminding you of that again. The Phone Bank beyond the Emblem Sales booth, and a Post
Card station in the Exhibit Area at the Convention Center urging all Legion family members
to call their Senator’s office and/or send a post card which have been placed in everyone’s
Convention packet.
Steve Salerno, the newly selected editor of The American Legion Magazine, made a
report that the Magazine had a surplus of 1.2 million in 1994, but due to the environmental
impact of postage and paper costs and printing increases, it appears that the Magazine will
probably have a million dollar deficit in 1995. Mr. Salerno did report that they are
expecting to hit their high of 8.7 million advertising sales budget for the year 1995.
National Treasurer Webber LaGrange gave the Committee a summary of our
investments. He then recommended the 1996 dues be set at $9.00. There will be no dues
increase.
A motion was made by Thomas O’Connor of Pennsylvania that the 1996 per capita
dues remain at $9.00; seconded by Don Desch of Wisconsin, and adopted by unanimous
vote.
Stanley Hanson of Colorado made a motion to empower the Chairman and the
Secretary to write and/or amend the report on behalf of the Convention Committee of
Finance, and Charles Wallace of Kansas seconded the motion which was also adopted by
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
119
unanimous vote. We had no resolutions.
There was no other business before the Committee, and the meeting adjourned at 9:40
a.m.
As a Delegate to this Convention, I now make a motion that this report be approved.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Alan Hall,
Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Foreign Relations for the purpose of
making a report.
REPORT OF THE CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Alan P. Hall (FL), Chairman
At 8:30 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 43 Delegates and Alternates assigned to the
Convention Committee on Foreign Relations met in Room 205, 2nd Level of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. Mr. Alan P. Hall (Florida) was elected
Chairman and Mr. Robert Bowen (Virginia) was appointed Secretary.
Following this initial meeting, five Ad Hoc Administrative convention Subcommittees
met in separate locations to consider the resolutions which had been assigned to them. The
following were appointed Chairmen:
General Foreign Policy: Chairman A.J. Forestiere (Arkansas)
European Affairs: Chairman Dick Pfaffinger (Minnesota)
Far Eastern Affairs: Chairman Keith Baker (Iowa)
Inter-American Affairs: Chairman George D. Triplett (Mexico)
Middle Eastern & African Affairs: Chairman Vinton R. Guy (Colorado)
At 10:00 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 43 Delegates and Alternates assigned to
the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations met in Room 205, 2nd Level of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana for a final meeting of the Convention Committee
on Foreign Relations. At this meeting, motions were approved authorizing the committee
chairman and secretary to make technical corrections to the resolutions reported out of the
committee to ensure proper wording and form, but without changing the substance or
meaning of the resolutions considered. Reports of all convention ad hoc administrative
subcommittees were read and their recommended actions on resolutions considered. A total
of 15 resolutions were assigned to the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations and two
resolutions were originated by the Committee.
The following ad hoc subcommittee reports contain resolutions which will, in
conjunction with resolutions previously adopted, provide an effective and viable foreign
relations program for The American Legion. That program will fully support a strong and
dynamic U.S. Foreign policy to promote democracy around the world and discharge
America’s responsibility as leader of the Free World in the continuing struggle to defend and
promote liberty.
120
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
GENERAL FOREIGN POLICY
A. J. Forestiere (AR), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
Origin: MO
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended
WHEREAS, The American Legion is convinced, based on available evidence, that
American POWs were detained by Vietnam after Operation Homecoming in 1973, and there
is sufficient evidence to lead us to believe there is a better than average probability of
American POWs still being held in Indochina today; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes normalization of relations with Vietnam
will make it harder, not easier, to resolve the POW/MIA issue, but will continue to do
whatever it takes to achieve the fullest possible accounting of POW/MIA in Vietnam.
WHEREAS, The American Legion believes U.S. Government POW/MIA operations
are still inadequate, and the President’s normalization of relations with Vietnam will not
achieve substantially greater progress; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion believes the
following priority actions should be taken by the U.S. Government:
1.
Centralize POW/MIA responsibilities in a powerful office reporting directly
to the Secretary of Defense, remove the Defense Intelligence Agency from
all POW/MIA responsibilities and make each military service responsible
for its own POW/MIAs.
2.
Provide necessary resources so field operations can be conducted at a
maximum rate of activity with more timely follow-up of live sighting
reports.
3.
Declassify all POW/MIA information (except that revealing intelligence
sources or methods) in a form readily available to public review.
4.
Provide adequate personnel and resources so that investigative efforts of
World War II, Cold War, and Korean War POW/MIA situations can be
broadened and accelerated.
5.
Initiate or strengthen joint commissions with Russia, the People’s Republic
of China, and North Korea to increase POW/MIA recovery efforts.
6.
Establish a centralized office responsible to keep POW/MIA families
informed on their loved ones.
7.
Establish a joint standing congressional committee on POW/MIA affairs to
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
121
ensure continued action by the executive branch in addressing the
POW/MIA issue.
8.
Take further favorable actions toward Vietnam only after Hanoi provides
the fullest possible accounting for POW/MIAs in Vietnam or in areas of
Laos and Cambodia it controlled during the Vietnam War.
9.
Take favorable actions toward Laos or Cambodia only after those nations
provide the fullest possible accounting for POW/MIAs.
10. “Fullest possible accounting” is defined as turning over live prisoners,
repatriating remains of those who were killed in action or died in captivity,
or providing a valid, conclusive report when neither is possible.
Resolution No. 151: United Nations
Origin: Foreign Relations Committee
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As consolidated with No. 75 (MX)
WHEREAS, The American Legion played a significant role in helping to establish the
United Nations after World War II, believing it would help prevent the outbreak of future
wars; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has remained generally supportive of the United
nations over the succeeding years, although it has been critical of particular ineffective,
wasteful or undesirable activities of the United Nations; and
WHEREAS, Although the United Nations in half a century of operation has not
fulfilled the lofty of purposes unwise international operations and enable the United States
to work from within the United Nations for long overdue reforms; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the U. S.
Government to seek the following reforms in the United Nations and to use American
leverage to obtain the desired ends by such means as withdrawal from ineffective UN
agencies and withholding of funds:
1.
Ratify expeditiously the “UN Convention on the Protection of Peacekeepers” and
encourage all other nations to do the same.
2.
Encourage the United Nations to focus on limited, necessary, achievable tasks that truly
better the lot of humankind in a sensible, cost-effective manner.
3.
Encourage the United Nations not to infringe on national sovereignty when operating
economic and social programs.
4.
Adopt weighted voting procedures in the General Assembly, allotting voting power in
relation to funds contributed by each member nation to the United Nations.
5.
Eliminate the Trusteeship Council and all other redundant or unneeded agencies.
122
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
6.
Professionalize the UN staff on the basis of merit and qualifications.
7.
Provide truly independent authority to the Inspector General and see that UN agencies
become subject to periodic, unannounced auditing, the finding of such audits to be
reported to member nations.
8.
Admit the Republic of China to full membership in the United Nations since that nation
has fulfilled all that is expected of a developing country by adopting democracy,
respect for human rights, free enterprise, and a peaceful foreign policy.
9.
Reduce the U.S. Share of the regular budget from 25 percent to 20 percent.
10. Reduce the U.S. Share of peacekeeping funding from 31.7 percent to 20 percent.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Resolution No. 15 (CO) 1995 NC: POW/MIA Trust Fund Petition
Resolution No. 143 (NJ) 1995 NC: Release of Service Member’s Status
Resolution No. 145 (NY) 1995 NC: Japanese Apology for World War II
RECEIVED & RECORDED
Resolution No. 112 (MD) 1995 NC: Principles of U.S. Foreign Policy
Resolution No. 113 (MD) 1995 NC: Principles of U.S. Foreign Aid
Resolution No. 114 (MD) 1995 NC: Democratic Activism as U.S. National SecurityForeign Policy Goal
CHAIRMAN A.J. FORESTIERE, (ARKANSAS): Mr. Chairman, this completes the
report of the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on General Foreign Policy.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman, the next report
is from Chairman Dick Pfaffinger of Minnesota, European Affairs.
EUROPEAN AFFAIRS
Dick Pfaffinger (MN), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
Origin: Foreign Relations Committee
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
WHEREAS, A. U.S. Initiative, Partnership for Peace (PFP) was launched by the
January 1994 NATO Summit to establish strong links between NATO, its new democratic
partners in the former Soviet bloc, and some of Europe’s traditionally neutral countries to
enhance European security; and
WHEREAS, It provides a framework for enhanced political and military cooperation
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
123
for joint multilateral crisis management activities, such as humanitarian assistance and
peacekeeping; and
WHEREAS, It enables PFP members to consult with NATO when faced with a direct
threat to its security but does not extend NATO security guarantees. Participation in PFP
does not guarantee entry into NATO, but it is the best preparation for states interested in
becoming NATO members; and
WHEREAS, 26 countries have joined; therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports
NATO’s Partnership for Peace.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
FOREIGN RELATIONS
Resolution No. 109 (MD) 1995 NC: Expanding The North Atlantic Treaty
RECEIVED & RECORDED
Resolution No. 110 (MD) 1995 NC: Guidelines for Relations with The Former Soviet
Union
CHAIRMAN DICK PFAFFINGER, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Chairman, that completes
my record of the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on European Affairs.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The last
report is from Chairman Keith Baker of Iowa, Far Eastern Affairs.
FAR EASTERN AFFAIRS
Keith Baker (IA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
Origin: AK
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
WHEREAS, The Republic of China on Taiwan is a long-time friend and ally of the
United States, with a democratic government and free enterprise economic system, and is
the seventh largest trading partner of the United States; and
WHEREAS, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, as leader of the Republic of China for
many years, closely cooperated with the United States during World War II against Japanese
Imperialism, and assisted the allied efforts against Communism in the Korean War and the
Vietnam War; and
WHEREAS, The Republic of China occupies the island of Taiwan, which is of great
strategic interest economically, politically, and militarily to the United States; and
WHEREAS, The Taiwan Relations Act (Public Law 96-8) commits the government of
the United States to providing defense articles and services to the Republic of China, such
that Taiwan can maintain a sufficient self-defense capability; and
124
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
WHEREAS, Dr. Lee Leng-Hui, the President of the Republic of China, was invited by
his alma mater, Cornell University, to visit the United States to receive an Honorary
Doctorate for his contributions as an outstanding alumnus of Cornell University; and
WHEREAS, President Lee’s visit enhanced the peaceful and cooperative relationship
between the Republic of China and the United States; and
WHEREAS, Both the United States Senate and the House of Representatives
supported President Lee’s visit in near-unanimous votes, such that the State Department
issued a visa for President Lee’s visit; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that The American Legion supports the
peaceful re-unification of China under the Three Principles of the People, as enunciated by
Dr. Sun Yat-Sen, the founder of the Republic of China; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports continued sales of military
equipment to the Republic of China as a means of safeguarding its existence; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports the initiation of discussions with the
government authorities of the Republic of China for American use of facilities on Taiwan;
and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion advocates the full implementation of the
Taiwan Relations Act in precedence over any contrary relationships with the Chinese
Communists (Mainland China); and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion applauds the actions of the United States
Government to grant President Lee Teng-Hui entrance to the United States to speak at his
alma mater, Cornell University, despite the protests of the Peoples Republic of China.
Resolution No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
Origin: MD
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended
WHEREAS, North Korea has consistently taken actions violating two nuclear
agreements it has signed; the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) (1985) and the
Non-Nuclear Declaration with the Republic of Korea (1992); and
WHEREAS, Instead of insisting that North Korea adhere to the two agreements, when
confronted by North Korea’s expanding nuclear weapons program, the U.S. Government,
in effect, agreed to pay “blackmail money” to North Korea in an attempt to halt the
unwelcome, threatening development of North Korean nuclear weapons, by signing the
Agreed Framework in October 1994, calling for providing North Korea two nuclear reactors
worth $4.5 billion, allegedly to be paid for by the Republic of Korea (ROK) an Japan, and
large deliveries of free oil, paid for by American taxpayers; and
WHEREAS, Soon after the Agreed Framework was signed, North Korea commenced
violating it by diverting some of the free oil to military use and objecting to the ROK
providing the two nuclear reactors; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By the American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion believes the U.S.
Government made a huge mistake by signing the Agreed Framework with North Korea with
the intention of hindering North Korea’s growing nuclear weapons program by seeing that
North Korea receive free oil and nuclear reactors, thus creating a precedent that emerging
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
125
nuclear powers can profit from their illegal nuclear weapons program; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion calls on the U.S. Government to be firm and
insistent in implementing the Agreed framework to prevent North Korea from receiving
additional financial rewards beyond those already promised, continuing to develop nuclear
weapons and long-range delivery means, and hindering U.S.-ROK cooperation.
Resolution No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
Origin: VA
Submitted By: Foreign Relations Committee
As amended and consolidated with No. 57 (TX)
WHEREAS, More than 2,000 American servicemen remain unaccounted for from the
Vietnam War; and
WHEREAS, The President of the United States on July 11, 1995 said he was satisfied
with the efforts the government of Vietnam has put forth toward resolving those missing in
action and prisoner of war cases; and
WHEREAS, The President used that rationale in announcing that he was extending full
diplomatic relations to Vietnam; and
WHEREAS, The “fullest possible” accounting the President had promised as his
requirement for normalizing relations with Vietnam has not been accomplished; and
WHEREAS, Past negotiations with the government of Vietnam show that the
communist leadership in Hanoi deal only from a position of strength; and
WHEREAS, The position of strength employed by the government in Vietnam has
been the information it holds about our POWs/MIAs; and
WHEREAS, Normalizing relations removes the requirement for Vietnam to continue
providing information about our POW/MIAs; and
WHEREAS, Congress must authorize the funds needed to establish offices in Hanoi
to administer to the President’s recognition of Vietnam; and
WHEREAS, Such authorization has not yet been approved; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion supports
legislation to withhold funding for normalizing relations with Vietnam until the President
certifies to Congress that the government of Vietnam is doing all it can to provide for the
fullest possible accounting of America’s POW/MIAs from the Vietnam conflict.
REJECTED
Resolution No. 40 (IL) 1995 NC: Reinstatement of Trade Embargo with Vietnam
CHAIRMAN KEITH BAKER, (IOWA): Mr. Chairman, that completes the report of
the Ad Hoc Subcommittee on Far Eastern Affairs.
CHAIRMAN ALAN P. HALL, (FLORIDA): Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr.
Chairman as a duly elected delegate to the Convention from the Department of Florida, I
move the adoption of the report of the Convention Committee on Foreign Relations.
... The motion was seconded and carried.
VICE COMMANDER COLEMAN: The Chair now recognizes John Bamaba of New
York, Chairman of the National Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments for
the purpose of making a report.
126
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
John Barnaba (NY), Chairman
Mr. Commander, Reverend Chaplain, Fellow Delegates, the Committee on
Constitutional Amendments met at 9 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, at the Indiana
Convention Center, Room 143, 1st floor. Committee Liaison Phillip B. Onderdonk, Jr.
called the role and announced that 50 members of the Constitutional Amendments
Committee were present.
The meeting was opened by Philip B. Onderdonk, Jr. of Maryland who acted as
temporary chairman. He stated a quorum was present and proceeded to the first order of
business which was the election of a permanent chairman and secretary. John A. Barnaba
of New York was elected Chairman and Byron Lewis, Utah, was elected Secretary, who
assumed their respective places.
Copies of all the resolutions, the reports of the Standing Committee and copies of the
National Constitution and By-Laws as revised January 2, 1992, were made available to all
members of the committee.
A motion was made and seconded that all members of the Standing Committee who
were present at the meeting be seated with voice but no vote. This was unanimously carried.
The Chair called upon Philip B. Onderdonk, Jr., National Judge Advocate, to give a
summary background report on the resolutions to the committee, which was done.
The Chair announced the passing of two distinguished past members of the committee,
namely Milton S. Applebaum of Illinois and Bertram Davis of New York and requested that
the meeting be recessed in their memory.
The Chair stated that there were 11 resolutions for consideration by the Convention
Committee. The Chair ruled the following resolutions to be out of order in accordance with
the rationale stated in the Report of the Standing Committee as not being in proper form and
suitable for passage as a constitutional amendment.
The resolutions were: Resolution No. 25, Alaska; Resolution No. 28, Alaska;
Resolution No. 83, Wisconsin; Resolution No. 117, New Hampshire; Resolution No. 121,
Vermont; Resolution No. 130, South Dakota and Resolution No. 131, South Dakota.
The Chair placed on the floor for consideration Resolution No. 1, NEC Seeking to
expand Auxiliary Membership to include Grandmothers. A motion was made by Lloyd
Wagener (Wisconsin) and seconded by Thomas Miller (Florida) to approve said resolution.
The motion was carried with one nay vote. The Chair ruled the motion as passed.
The Chair referred to Resolution No. 72 (Kentucky) and requested a motion from the
floor that this resolution be referred to the Internal Affairs Commission for review and
action by the National Executive Committee. A motion was made to refer said resolution
by James Gilbert (California) and seconded by Raymond Jacquez (Maryland). The motion
was unanimously carried.
Resolution No. 11 was next submitted on the floor for consideration by the committee.
Motion was made by Walt Landi (France) and seconded by Ed Wearing (Colorado) to
approve the resolution. Following the discussion, Frank Giordano, chairman of the Standing
Committee, moved to refer Resolution No. 11 of Colorado to a study committee for further
review. That motion was seconded by Charles Tracy (New Hampshire). The motion to
refer the resolution was defeated and further discussion on the main motion, Resolution No.
11, continued. The Chair called the question and a roll call vote was held with 34 voting yes,
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
127
14 votes no and 2 abstentions. The Chair ruled that Resolution No. 11, Colorado, passed.
Resolution No. 98 (Ohio) was a final resolution submitted for consideration to the
committee. Since the subject matter of this resolution was similar to that of Resolution No.
11 (Colorado) the Chair stated that further consideration of the Ohio resolution was now
moot, whereupon Lydia Pickup of Washington moved to reject the resolution and John Titus
(Pennsylvania) seconded the motion. And the motion was carried.
There being no further business for consideration by the committee at this time, and
upon request of the Chair, a motion was made and carried to authorize the chairman and
secretary to sign the report of the Convention Committee on Constitutional Amendments.
A moment of silence was held in the memory of Milton S. Applebaum (Illinois), Past
Committee Chairman and Bertram Davis, Past National Judge Advocate. The meeting was
declared at recess subject to the call of the Chair. The resolutions follow.
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
Origin: National Adjutant
Submitted by: Constitutional Amendment
WHEREAS, Eligibility for membership in the American Legion Auxiliary is now
limited to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters
of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters,
granddaughters and great-granddaughters of all men and women who were in the Armed
Forces of the United States during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November
11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31, 1955;
December 22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States; all dates inclusive, or who, being
citizens of the United States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty in the
Armed Forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during any of
said periods, and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women who
of their own right are eligible for membership in The American Legion; and
WHEREAS, There are many women who are grandmothers of men and women who
have served in the Armed Forces during the eligibility periods established by The American
Legion; and
WHEREAS, Many of these women have expressed a desire to become members of the
American Legion Auxiliary but are not presently eligible for membership; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion Auxiliary National Executive Committee has
requested The American Legion to adopt an amendment to Article XIII, Section 1 of the
National Constitution of The American Legion to allow grandmothers to be included in the
American Legion Auxiliary; and
WHEREAS, The National Executive Committee of The American Legion has agreed
and recommended said change to The American Legion National Convention; now,
therefore, be it further
RESOLVED, By the National Convention of The American Legion in regular meeting
assembled in Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, that Article XIII, Section 2 of
the National Constitution of The American Legion which presently reads:
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
128
Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the
mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters
of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters,
sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters of all men and women
who were in the Armed Forces of the United States during any of the
following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918; December 7,
1941, to December 31,1946; June 25,1950 to January 31,1955; December
22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of
hostilities as determined by the Government of the United States; all dates
inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United States at the time of their
entry therein, served on active duty in the Armed Forces of any of the
governments associated with the United States during any of said periods,
and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women
who of their own right are eligible for membership in The American Legion.
be amended to read:
Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to the
mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters, great-granddaughters
and grandmothers of members of The American Legion, and to the mothers,
wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters, great-granddaughters and
grandmothers of all men and women who were in the Armed Forces of the
United States during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to
November 11, 1918; December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25,
1950, to January 31, 1955; December 22, 1961, to May 7, 1975; August 24,
1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20, 1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2,
1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government
of the United States; all dates inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United
States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty in the Armed
Forces of any of the governments associated with the United States during
any of said periods, and died in line of duty or after honorable discharge;
and to those women who of their own right are eligible for membership in
The American Legion.
and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That this amendment is made on the express condition that the National
Convention of the American Legion Auxiliary adopt an identically worded amendment to
Article III, Section 1 of its National Constitution and shall not be effective until said express
condition is ratified.
Resolution No. 11: Change in Eligibility Dates for Membership in The American Legion
Origin: CO
Submitted by: Constitutional Amendments
WHEREAS, The eligibility dates for membership in The American Legion are
determined by the Congress of the United States of America by the establishment of specific
dates during which the United States of America was involved in a war, declared or
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
129
undeclared, or other hostilities; and
WHEREAS, Members of the Armed Services of the United States of America were
called upon to defend the principles of democracy and justice in all parts of the world,
including Vietnam beginning July 1, 1958 to May 7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion membership eligibility dates for Vietnam are
beginning December 22, 1961, to and including May 7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, Members of the Armed Forces of the United States of America were
called upon to defend the principles of democracy and justice in all parts of the world,
including Vietnam with their supreme sacrifice beginning July 8,1959, to an including May
7, 1975; and
WHEREAS, No action was taken prior to this time by The American Legion to petition
Congress to change the eligibility dates for those members of the Armed Service who were
ready, willing and able and did in fact serve honorably during the aforementioned period of
time; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion is not asking the VA to recognize these dates for
eligibility for benefits; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Colorado Membership Committee, recommended that
The American Legion extend its eligibility for membership to the period of July 1, 1958, to
and including May 7, 1975 (the period of time the presence of American troops were in the
Vietnam Conflict) and the Department of Colorado delegates to the State Convention
recommended such changes at convention assembled on June 22-25, 1995 at Sterling,
Colorado; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That the National Legislative Commission
be and is hereby authorized and directed to petition Congress of the United States and to
further amend Section 5 of the Act entitled, “An Act to Incorporate the American Legion”,
Public Law No. 47, 66th Congress, approved September 16, 1919, Chapter 59, Section 5,
41 Stat. 285; October 29, 1942, Chapter 633, Section 2, 56 Stat. 1012; July 9, 1946,
Chapter 546, 60 Stat. 524; December 28, 1950, Chapter 1177, 64 Stat. 1122; July 26, 1955,
Chapter 386, Section 2, 69 Stat. 380; September 1, 1966, Public Law 89-550, Section 2, 80
Stat 372; December 27, 1974, Public Law 93-557, 88 Stat. 1792; August 17, 1978, Public
Law 95-346, 92 Stat. 485; December 21, 1979, Public Law 96-155, 93 Stat. 1165; October
30, 1990, Public Law 101-478, 104 Stat. 1157; December 3, 1991, Public Law 102-179, 105
Stat. 1229; Title 36 U.S. Code Section 45 as amended to read when amended as follows:
Section 5. That no person shall be a member of this corporation unless he
has served in the naval or military services of the United States at some time
during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31,
1955; July 1, 1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984;
December 20, 1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of
cessation of hostilities as determined by the Government of the United
States, all dates inclusive, or who being a citizen of the United States at the
time of entry therein, served in the military or naval service of any
governments associated with the United States during said wars or
hostilities. Provided, however, that such person shall have an honorable
discharge or separation from such service or continues to serve honorably
130
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
after any of the aforesaid terminal dates,
and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That when and if the Congress of the United States enacts the above
amendment, and the President of the United States shall have approved the same and it
becomes law, then the National Constitution of the American Legion shall be deemed
amended in conformance therewith, but subject to all consistent limitations and restrictions
in the Constitution contained, all is provided for under Article XVII thereof, so that Article
IV, Section 1, and Article XIII, Section 2 of the National Constitution of the American
Legion shall read as follows:
Article IV - Eligibility
Section 1. Any person shall be eligible for membership in the American Legion who was
a member of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Coast Guard or Air Force of the United States
and assigned to active duty at some time during any of the following periods: April 6, 1917,
to November 11, 1918; December7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January
31, 1955; July 1, 1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20,
1989, to January 31, 1990; August 2, 1990 to the date of cessation of hostilities as
determined by the Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being a
citizen of the United States at the time of his entry therein, served on active duty in the
armed forces of any of the Governments associated with the United States during any of the
said periods; provided, however, that such service shall have been terminated by honorable
discharge or honorable separation, or continued honorably after any of said periods;
provided, further, that no person shall be entitled to membership who being in such service
during any of said periods, refused on conscientious, political or other grounds to subject
himself to military discipline or unqualified service.
Article XIII - Auxiliaries:
Section 2. Membership in the American Legion Auxiliary shall be limited to mothers, wives,
daughters, sisters, granddaughters and great-granddaughters of members of the American
Legion, and to the mothers, wives, daughters, sisters, granddaughters and
great-granddaughters of all men and women who were in the armed forces of the United
States during any of the following periods:
April 6, 1917, to November 11, 1918;
December 7, 1941, to December 31, 1946; June 25, 1950, to January 31, 1955; July 1,
1958, to May 7, 1975; August 24, 1982, to July 31, 1984; December 20, 1989, to January
31, 1990; August 2, 1990, to the date of cessation of hostilities as determined by the
Government of the United States, all dates inclusive, or who, being citizens of the United
States at the time of their entry therein, served on active duty of the United States of any of
the governments associated with the United States during any said periods and died in the
line of the duty or after honorable discharge; and to those women who of their own right are
eligible for membership in The American Legion.
CHAIRMAN JOHN BARNABA, (NEW YORK): As a registered delegate to this
Convention, I move the adoption of this report.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s been a motion that the Report of
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
131
the Constitutional Amendments be approved. There is a second. Any discussion.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): My name is Dan Foley, a registered
delegate from Minnesota, and I’m requesting that Resolution No. 11 be set aside from this
report for separate consideration.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s been a request that Resolution
11 be set aside. Objection? None.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There’s a motion and a second. Any
discussion? All those in favor signify with a sign of aye; Opposed? Ayes have it. The
report is adopted by a two-thirds vote.
... At this time the Chairman of the Constitutional Amendments read Resolution number
11.
DELEGATE JOHN BARNABA, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, in as much as we
have passed just recently Resolution number 1 of the NEC to add the term “grandmothers”,
I would ask that the section which is referred to in the Auxiliary, Section 2, under Article
XIII also include the category “grandmothers” as part of the amendment.
As Chairman of the Committee on Constitutional Amendments, Mr. Commander, and
as a delegate to this convention, I move the adoption of this resolution.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second?
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Commander, point of order, please.
I’m a registered delegate from Minnesota. My name is Foley. I wish with your permission
to make a parliamentary inquiry to your Judge Advocate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Yes.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Judge Advocate, so that all of us on
this floor understand the situation, I ask you now if a delegate on this floor is in favor of the
change of dates contained in Resolution 11 they would vote ‘yes’; is that true?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is correct,
sir.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): If a delegate on this floor is opposed
to the change of dates contained and proposed by Resolution 11 they would vote ‘no’.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is also
correct, sir.
DELEGATE DAN FOLEY, (MINNESOTA): One other thing. In order to amend the
Constitution of The American Legion under Resolution 11, would it not require atwo-thirds
vote of this convention?
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK, (MARYLAND): That is correct,
sir. That is required in the National Constitution of The American Legion and the Article
entitled Amendments.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It requires a two-thirds vote for passage.
Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE AL LANCE, (IDAHO): Mr. Commander, A1 Lance, duly authorized
delegate from the Department of Idaho. Mr. Commander, I rise to speak in opposition to
Resolution 11 for the following reasons. Before I state my reasons, I would like to
commend those individuals in the Department of Colorado who have conducted their
research. However, what the resolution purports to do is to advance the date of eligibility
for Vietnam by some 42 months. It calls upon the Legislative Commission to go before
Congress and to try to once again change the public law under which The American Legion
was first organized in 1919. That public law has been amended 11 times as a result of
132
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
actions of changes in our By-Laws and our Constitution.
Mr. Commander and Delegates, as I think you are aware, we have several major
initiatives before the Congress of the United States presently pending, and those which will
be pending. First and foremost is the Flag protection bill which will require a great deal of
the resources of The American Legion Legislative Commission.
Secondly, of course, we have passed Resolution 141, which is the road map for the
implementation of the ‘Gold Book’ which has been described as being potentially the
greatest piece of social legislation that this country has known in the 20th century. That’s
going to take your resources and mine and those of the Legislative Commission.
But let me point out, Mr. Commander, by advancing the eligibility dates by some
42 months, what we are really doing is changing the date from 1955 to 1958. Now the
volunteers who were in Vietnam and Southeast Asia probably are already eligible for this
organization as a result of their service prior to 1955. And those who made a career of the
military, of course, probably are already eligible as a result of their service after December
22nd of 1961.
I think additional research, Mr. Commander, would be in order to ascertain precisely
how many individuals we are talking about and how many are already eligible for
participation as members in The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 3.
DELEGATE BILL BARBKNECHT, (MINNESOTA): Mr. Commander, Bill
Barbknecht, Delegation Chairman of Minnesota. I wish to speak to the convention in
regards to the eligibility change. I also look forward to a great day tomorrow and a day for
our Commander-elect to lead our great national organization. If we are to change the
eligibility dates, I remind the delegates that are here today of the IRS tax code 501 C 19
which is for veterans of wartime organizations.
When we have an attorney from New York come to speak before our Judge Advocates
as they did on Saturday and speak of the troubles we are having in Baltimore, Maryland, and
as we witness receiving a check for over $5 million, is that going to be IRS taxable? That
is a question I ask you delegates to think about.
We have problems with IRS, and they are not pleasant people to deal with at times.
Since 1974, we have had difficulties before the Constitution By-Laws Committee when
change was asked for in eligibility dates. I believe we have more pressing business before
us at this time.
I am a Vietnam-era veteran, who also has a son and daughter who have served during
the Persian Gulf. They are very proud to be wartime veterans and members of this great
organization. And I believe it is time that The American Legion proceeds with the issues
that we have before us, because we are not talking about that many people at this time. And
I urge the delegates to vote no, because we do not need anymore problems with IRS.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE ED WEARING, (COLORADO): Mr. Commander, Ed Wearing, Delegate
from Colorado.
We have got the issue on the taxes. That is incorrect. We are trying to make this
resolution take July 1, 1958 and make it a wartime era.
There’s an Executive Order from President Johnson, Executive Order 11231. This is
on the Expeditionary Medal and the Vietnam Service Medal, from July 1, 1958 until 1964.
That Expeditionary Medal was issued to the servicemen who were over there. As of July
8th, 1965, President Johnson put together this Executive Order stating that it allowed any
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
133
serviceman that served during those time periods to be issued a Vietnam Service Medal. So
that time period as far as our President at that time and the Department of Defense, was
recognized as being a wartime period. We need to recognize those veterans. We have been
trying to do this for some long period of time. I think it’s about time now that we recognize
those Vietnam veterans that were there.
We’ve got 16 names sitting up on top of that Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall, sixteen
who are not be eligible for The American Legion with our current dates. The 17th name on
that wall is December 22nd, 1961. That is where we came up with our last resolution on
changing this period.
We, as Delegates to this Convention, need to do it now. We need to recognize the
Vietnam Era as to what it was. We have a President, we have a Department of Defense who
have recognized it. Why, can’t we as veterans, recognize it? I am asking you here today
to look at this resolution.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE WALT LANDI, (FRANCE): Thank you, Commander, Walt Landi from
the Department of France, birthplace of The American Legion, duly authorized Delegate to
this Convention.
As a Vietnam veteran who earned the Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal on my first
trip over there before the Vietnam Campaign Ribbon was even thought of, we stand in
support of this resolution.
We have heard some of the bad things that might happen should we do this. The IRS
might start looking at us even harder. There might be a bigger shortfall in the Veterans
Administration’s budget to cope with the increased caseload of the new eligible veterans.
I submit to this body that the budget of the VA belongs in the House Appropriations
Committee. If we need care for those veterans, we should stand up and say, “Guys, you’re
missing somebody.”
There’s also been questions about when are we going to stop trying to change the dates
of the Vietnam Era. I submit to this body that every month documents are being
declassified, and every month the American public is learning more about the real truth of
when Vietnam began.
The first American casualty in Indo-China was in 1946. But in the more modem era,
the two airmen who died at Vinh Ninhwa Air Base in 1958 in July, led to the decision of the
July, 1958 date.
Well, a couple weeks ago when the President of the United States made his speech on
television, he said that recognizing North Vietnam would close the chapter of Vietnamese
American relations that began during the days of the Eisenhower Administration. We
strongly believe that the veterans who served there from 1958 onward should be entitled to
be members of this fine organization.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE EDWARD J. VOISARD, (OHIO):Mr. Commander, Ed Voisard, Delegate
from the Department of Ohio.
All this week we have been honoring those men and women who have served in World
War II, and given them recognition for what they have done. Resolution 11 seeks to honor
the members of the Armed Forces that served this country in harms way on foreign soils.
Some have given their lives, and as was stated before, the names are inscribed on the
wall of the Vietnam Memorial in our Nation’s capitol. I urge the passage of Resolution 11
to honor those of our comrades who served in that period.
134
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE HAROLD E. HEINLY, (CALIFORNIA): Harold Heinly, Delegate from
California, rises to speak against the motion on two main issues.
One is the authority to retain lobbyists by The American Legion, and the second is to
retain this nonprofit status.
I would like to point out to you Delegates here, that the Supreme Court of the United
States has already ruled that The American Legion is a special category, it has a special
privilege because the members are veterans who served during times of war. For that reason,
they are entitled to that special category of allowing themselves to have lobbyists who
participate in Washington, D.C. and still maintain the organizations nonprofit status.
I don’t recall which organization it was that raised the issue. It was one of the other
nonprofit organizations, such as the Elks, the Moose, or something like that. This is what
the Supreme Court said. The American Legion is different.
And I would urge you to vote no against this resolution. You are subjecting the people
who make contributions; you’re subjecting yourself to a profit status and it isn’t worth the
risk.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion; the question has been
called. Is there a second?
The Chairman will come forward and close the debate.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN BARNABA: Mr. Commander, this issue is not new to
this body. It’s been presented on the floor at previous Conventions.
We have all heard the same discussions and the same arguments regarding our tax
exempt status. By increasing and opening up the membership rolls to non-wartime veterans
is going to affect our tax exempt status. It is. It’s currently being affected because there are
intrusions into many, many activities of The American Legion. In my own state of New
York I know of many, of two or three instances recently, where the IRS has entered the halls
of an American Legion Post and subjected the Post to extensive audits. It’s not an old thing,
it’s coming. It’s a new thing.
The state of Maryland itself is encountering some very severe audits and attacks by the
United States government on this particular issue.
Something to give some thought to. The Congress determines periods of war. And we
in The American Legion traditionally have upheld our membership eligibility dates to the
times and dates that Congress has mandated. Yet today we are attempting to go beyond
those dates. We are a wartime veterans organization.
Today we’ve seen clips on the TV screens here which commemorates the veterans of
World War II, and prior to that, of World War I.
The World War I veterans started this organization. It was their purpose that it be a
dying organization. The tradition here is to have an organization composed of wartime
veterans. Are we to maintain that tradition? Are we to uphold that or not? I maintain we
should. Let’s honor these veterans who started this organization and maintain that tradition.
For that reason, Mr. Commander, and in line with the Preamble of this great
organization, I feel that we should continue to be and resolve to be an organization
composed of wartime veterans.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The debate has been ended. The
Chairman has the right to end the debate.
DELEGATE MARVIN E. JONES, (CALIFORNIA): Mr. Commander, Marvin Jones,
a Delegate to this Convention from California.
Proceedings of Tuesday, September 5, 1995
135
My point of order is this: You have not taken the vote to cut off debate, and yet you
are allowing the Chairman to close debate.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have closed the debate by the motion
to end the debate, and accepted a second, and now I’m calling for a vote on that motion.
And the Chairman has the last say.
All those in favor of the motion to close debate on the question, signify by saying aye.
Opposed? Ayes have it.
We will, now vote on the motion.
All those in favor of the motion signify by the sign of aye. Opposed? The no’s have
it. Motion fails.
... At this time a video vignette was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Delegates, please join me in a salute to
the Flag of the United States of America. Hand salute.
. . . The Delegation stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will stand in recess
until 9:00 a.m., tomorrow morning. Thank you.
... At 3:25 P.M., Tuesday, September 5, 1995, the Convention recessed, to reconvene the
following day, September 6, 1995, at 9:00 A.M.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
137
PROCEEDINGS
THIRD DAY
Wednesday, September 6,1995
... At 8:30 a.m., the Delegation listened to the music of the ‘40s while slides of World War
II posters were displayed on large screens.
... At 9:00 a.m., the Delegates assembled for the Third Day of the 77th Annual Convention,
and the following proceedings were had:
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention will come to order.
Delegates will stand and render a right hand salute to the Flag of the United States of
America.
... The Delegates stood and saluted the Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Please uncover, and I call for the
invocation, the Reverend Roy Pryor of South Carolina, our National Chaplain.
INVOCATION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, Sr., (SC)
National Chaplain
This morning as we go to prayer, we’re saddened by the loss of Don Livingston of
Iowa, who passed away this morning.
Will you pray with me in silence for the loss of Don, and that God will strengthen his
family at this time. Let us pray.
... The Delegation stood in silent prayer.
Holy Father, we invoke Your blessings upon our great Convention at this time. Please
accept our sincere thanks for all that has been accomplished. Always there are those things,
Father, that we wished could have been done that were not done, but we give You thanks
for all of the good things that we have accomplished.
We pray now for our new Commander-Elect and for those who will assist him, to carry
on the work of this great organization. Give them the tenacity to carry on for God and
Country.
We pray this prayer in Your name. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, please join me
in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of our Country.
. . . At this time National Commander Detweiler led the Delegation in the Pledge of
Allegiance.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Convention is now in session.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
CFA PHONE BANK AND POST CARD UPDATE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, before we start
the business of the meeting, let me thank you very much for your responses to my request
that you give a call to our Senators regarding the Citizens Flag Alliance and the amendment
to protect the Flag from physical desecration. We had some complaints from some Senators
138
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
that we were calling them too often.
I don’t quite understand that, but I don’t think really they’re complaints from Senators
as much as complaints from staffers who don’t feel like answering the calls. We had a few
complaints from Senator Moseley-Braun of Illinois. A few complaints from Senator John
Glenn of Ohio. We also had a few complaints from a couple of Senators. Senator
Bradley’s office and Senator Specter’s office had complaints to the effect that some of you
out there who were calling them were not residents of their states.
The response of a couple of a couple of you callers was: “Wait a minute, I’m an
American. This is my Constitution and I can call any Senator I wish to call.”
I want to compliment you also on the fact that as late as 5:00 o’clock or so last night,
the CFA booth was still open and you were still making calls. Well, the Convention is not
over; the phones are still open; the cards are still there. I again request that you make those
calls. Washington has got to understand that this is a people issue. The Constitution says:
“We the people.” Please make the calls and let them know we are around, we’re determined,
and we’re going to win the issue.
We have a few donations before we move on.
DEPARTMENT COMMANDER KENNETH PANNELL, OKLAHOMA: We have
$200.00 for the Citizens Flag Alliance this morning, Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Thank you very much, we appreciate it.
Another one from Idaho.
NECMAN ALAN G. LANCE, IDAHO: On behalf of Commander Dunlap and the
Delegates of the Department of Idaho, we are pleased to present to you this check for $500
so we can keep those phones ringing.
DRAWING FOR 1996 BUICK LeSABRE
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The first order of business this morning
is finding the winner of the 1996 Buick LeSabre.
I would like to have Larry Hice, Assistant General Sales Manager of the Western
Region, and Dave Lyons, the Manager, Dealer Merchandising of Buick Motor Division of
General Motors Corporation, to join me at the giant drum.
While the Buick representatives are here, I want to extend on behalf of all Legionnaires,
our thanks for the support of Buick for the scholarship effort and support of American
Legion Baseball. Buick is making a real difference for tomorrow in the lives of many young
Americans. Thank you very much.
From Portage, Ohio, Richard Zulch is the winner of the Buick. This program has
generated for American Legion Baseball $1,585,000
LARRY K. HICE
Buick Motor Division, GMC
On behalf of the Buick Motor Division and the 2,958 Buick dealers across this great
Countiy of ours, we want to thank you for the opportunity to participate in this program. As
this association continues to grow and mature, it becomes better for Legion members, better
for Buick dealers, and better for us. It’s a win-win situation, so we want to thank you.
And on a personal note, as a proud Vietnam veteran, and a proud member of Post 413
in Grand Blanc, Michigan, I want to thank you for your continuing effort to keep America
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
139
strong and keep America what it is.
MBNA AMERICA
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We talk about the Legion family and its
partners. Our second corporate partner is one that most of you are familiar with, MBNA
America, who issues The American Legion Visa and Master Cards. Since 1988, MBNA has
contributed over $12,000,000 to The American Legion. Each of you who use these cards
are responsible for this positive result. In addition, MBNA has donated $5,000 to the
Family Assistance Program; $25,000 to the Disaster Relief Fund; and as a CFA member,
pledged $50,000 in matching funds for monies donated to CFA on The American Legion
Visa and Master Cards.
We will draw for two, $1,000 CDS, and three, $500 CDS. Here to conduct the drawing
is Pat Murray, a member of the FBI Post in Washington, D.C.
PAT MURRAY
MBNA America
The first winner of the $1,000 CD is Donna Fuelling of 24646 McDonald Street in
Dublin Heights, Michigan.
The second winner of a $1,000 CD is Wilma J. Mayfield of 512 Worthington Lane,
Bridgeport, West Virginia.
The winner of one of the $500 CDS, Lana Bowen of 7 Nancy Drive, Waterloo, New
York.
The next winner of a $500 CD is Jack A. Waggoner, 1155 North State Road 75,
Thomtown, Indiana.
The next winner is Donna Bisaillon, 485 Briarcliff Lane, in Bourbonnais, Illinois.
As your business partner, I join the 13,500 people of MBNA America in making these
Certificates of Deposits available to you and to the membership of The American Legion.
And we are also pleased to make a contribution of $5,000 to the Disaster Relief Fund for the
sixth straight year, which makes a grand total of $30,000.
JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF MICHIGAN
The American Legion Annuity Program
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion Annuity Program
by Jackson National Life is providing a twenty-five inch TV at this Convention. Attending
today is Cliff Harris who is the Indianapolis Regional Manager of the Jackson National Life;
he will conduct the drawing.
The winner is Katena Karnes.
CLIFFORD HARRIS
Jackson National Life Insurance Company
On behalf of Jackson National Life, we are very excited to be entering into our second
year of the annuity program with The American Legion. Hopefully this weekend you had
an opportunity to stop by our booth and learn a little bit more about the annuity program that
140
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
you are eligible for. Currently that annuity is paying 9.6 percent. You also will learn
something about Jackson National Life, the largest underwriter of single premium deferred
annuities in the United States.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: It’s now my pleasure to introduce to you
a member of the House Veterans Affairs Committee, the House National Security
Committee and the House Judicial Committee. He’s a Desert Storm veteran, and continues
to serve as a member of the United States Army Reserves. He’s an outstanding individual.
I wish we had more Congressmen whose mothers and fathers are the legislative contacts for
our organization. When we have an issue of importance, we call his mother.
It’s my pleasure to welcome to the podium, a member of Thornton Williams American
Legion Post No. 81 in Monticello, Indiana, the Honorable Steve Buyer.
THE HONORABLE STEVE BUYER
United States House of Representatives
When my father said he was going to be my Legion legislative liaison, I said, “I would
only permit you to lobby me from a fishing boat on the Tippecanoe River,” and so far he’s
tried to uphold that pledge.
Let me give a good morning to all of you, and my special thanks to Commander
Detweiler for inviting me to give remarks here this morning. I have enjoyed my associations
with the Commander, and I have really appreciated the leadership he’s shown on many of
the issues nationally.
If many of you could have seen his negotiations on the Enola Gay issue, you would be
as eminently proud of him as I was. A lot of people love to jump on that particular issue at
the end when the train pulls into the station. I remember last fall when he met with Peter
Blute of Massachusetts, Sam Johnson of Texas, and myself of Indiana. When I look
back on that particular issue, my only regret, having been scathed by editorial writers around
the country, was that we did not share with America that every time the Commander would
negotiate on the transcript, the Smithsonian Institution would then send it to Japan for their
okay. I wish we had shared that insight with America; perhaps it wouldn’t have been as
scathing.
Before I begin, also let me give a special appreciation and thanks to the State
Commander of Indiana, Thomas Henderson, for his leadership and the members of his staff,
to my good friend Kenny Ohl who gives me personal counsel and advice, and to your
Washington, D.C. staff. You should know that they do an excellent job. You are being well
served by Steve Robertson, Kimo Hollingsworth and Jim Hubbard. And I also appreciate
the counsel and advice of Bob Spanogle.
But I think that just for me to say they’re doing a good job is not enough. The
congressmen and women need your pressure. They need your pressure because
Washington, D.C. is an incredible town of politics, and you always must maintain the motto
and policy of The American Legion, but policy should always override politics.
There is no joy at all in sailing across calm waters on a windless day under blue sky.
The ebb and flow of the world is very dynamic, and what guides us through the turbulent
waters is the hand upon the rudder, that being our internal moral compass of the nation, a
unique attribute we call the American character. It was formed in the crucible of the
American Revolution and through our infancy as a growing nation. And I assure you I will
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
141
continually expound in my service in the United States Congress, of the wisdom of the
founding fathers of our country.
You see, they created a nation of laws, not of people. They created a nation of
principle, not of emotion of the moment. They created a nation of hope, focused on liberty
and economic opportunity; a nation assumed to be guided by the internal moral compass.
Not to be strayed by situational ethics or the pursuit of profits overriding common decency;
a nation whose compass is focused upon true north, that being: “One Nation Under God.”
I am concerned because there is a movement afoot to transform our society from that
one based upon religious principles, to one based on humanistic principles; that human
beings can do whatever they want, so long as they feel good and don’t hurt others.
Do you realize in America today, that you could have a speaker at a high school
commencement address, and they could be a communist, a fascist, a socialist, a neo-Nazi,
a racist? They could even stand there and bum the American Flag, and their speech and
conduct would find protection by the Supreme Court in the First Amendment. What a great
example of how upside down things have become in our society.
Thank you for keeping the pressure on the members of Congress and the United States
Senate for the Flag Amendment. You bet I was a co-sponsor of the amendment, with my
parents right over my shoulder.
And I was glad to hear you applaud when the National Commander said that the
Senators were whining, because when they’re whining and crying in Washington, you ought
to be cheering back at home, because you’re making them uncomfortable and that’s what
they need to be is off balance at times.
That internal moral compass that I spoke of consists of principles oriented in the forms
of values and teachings that enable, fulfill, empower and inspire people. The lessons of
history show that nations whose principles are properly woven into the fabric of society
have endured and have prospered. These values are reflections of our cultural background.
From childhood, our cultural influences, personal discoveries and family heritage all
contribute to our sense of a value system. They form one’s glasses through which they see
the world. It is their dimension of how they understand the world.
Indiana is farm country. I represent 20 counties. You name the cornfield and I
probably represent it. We have pragmatic and practical common sense because the laws of
the farm teach us that you must work the ground, plant the seed, cultivate it, nurture it for
growth and development to maturity, for there is no shortcut to the harvest. Likewise,
communities of a nation that care for their young, instill them with character, good values
for life, and a proper education, will provide the opportunity and hope rooted in the dignity
of work and reward for achievement. To use a biblical version, “Raise up a child in the way
he should go, and when he is old, he will not depart from it.”
You see, I was raised in an American Legion family. My grandfather, a World War I
veteran, was a Post Commander; my father, a Korean War veteran, was a Post Commander
and is now an Executive Officer of the District. My mother in the Indiana Auxiliary is
Department Chaplain. My wife is a member of the Auxiliary. My daughter is in the Junior
Auxiliary and my son is a member of the Sons of The American Legion. Now how’s that?
You see, words such as duty, honor, country, family, community, respect, reverence,
accountability, responsibility are such foreign words in Washington. But they are the fabric
of our soul of society. That’s what binds us.
Even though I was raised in an American Legion family, I did not fully understand the
terms of life. I thought I did. I will never forget as a sixteen year old senior in high school,
142
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
going with my father down to the Citadel. He was a graduate there and my brother was a
freshman. I’ll never forget standing in the museum of the Citadel. My father had not been
back to the university for many years. He stood there in the corner by a memorial where
there was a series of books. I was in another part of the room looking at the machine guns
and other items. As I walked over to my father, I saw him standing there. He had his hands
on the books and on the pictures of classmates who were killed in the Korean War. As he
stood there with his fingers on their faces, he would call out their nicknames. And it was
the first time that I had ever seen the tears of my father. However then at 16, I did not
understand the tears of my father.
Many years later I found myself on an air transport to the Gulf. The second lieutenant
that sat next to me was later killed. A Vietnam veteran once said that those who serve their
country on a distant battlefield see life in a dimension that the protected may never know.
I stand here today and understand the tears of my father. You see, the bond for which
we all share, we who are in this hall today, come from all walks of life all across the nation
from all ages. But there is something that binds us together. It’s a value system and it’s a
dimension of common understanding; it’s our heritage. Ordinary citizens are called upon
to perform extraordinary deeds, and it’s done with courage and it’s done with valor.
I’ll never forget walking into an American Legion Post where I was going to speak.
A Legionnaire was waiting for me. He walked out of the bar and as he walked up to me, he
had on tattered blue jeans, tennis shoes that looked like he just mowed the lawn in them; his
shirt half in, half out, with a seed cap on his head.
As he came up to me he had something in his hand. It was all wrapped up in tissues.
He took his seed cap off and he said, "Congressman, I have been waiting to see you. I want
you to have this in honor of my comrades." And as I opened up the tissue, I looked and I
saw a Silver Star. I said, "I cannot accept your Silver Star." I thought to myself, I know
exactly what this man went through to have earned that Silver Star. He witnessed the long
dark shadows of horror and he spat into the face of death.
But he kind of shrugged his shoulders and aid, "No, Congressman, I want you to have
it." And I said, "I can’t." And as he walked away from me he said, "That’s all right, I have
another." He had two Silver Stars. If you come to my Washington office, you will find that
Silver Star right next to my desk.
The message I have to share with you today is a very simple message. I have an equal
responsibility, just as you do, to help share the dimension and understanding that we have
here today. A majority of the new majority in the United States Congress was elected in
the 1990s, many of whom have never had military service. I was stunned a couple of
months ago when a new member came and sat down next to me and said, "Steve, I know
you served in the Gulf, is that what makes you a veteran?" Think of that. Is that what
makes you a veteran? Now, I was stunned by that.
I share that with you because I sat down and helped tried to educate him as to what that
means. Those of you here today who have a new member of Congress or have a new
Senator, take time and sit down with them. Don’t take it for granted that they know what
a veteran is. Constructively educate. It is vitally important. Do not question their sincerity,
that is a lesson that I have learned in the Congress. Just because they don’t share the same
dimension that we may have, doesn’t mean we should question their sincerity or their belief.
We need to educate constructively.
For one solid year, I parked my Jeep everyday next to a Congresswoman that had a
bumper sticker on her car which had “It will be a great day in America when schools have
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
143
all of the money they want, and the Air Force has to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber.” I
read that for one solid year, everyday. There are a lot of people in Congress who don’t share
the same dimension as I do. But I don’t question their sincerity.
Now, I enjoyed speaking with that congresswoman because we had nothing in
common. And I can stand here today and say she’s no longer in the United States Congress.
In Congress I served on the Veterans Affairs and National Security Committees. From
the start, a Congressman or woman takes the oath to defend the Constitution with his or her
life, and it ends when the bronze plaque marker is placed upon the grave. I take the
responsibility of serving very seriously whether it’s the issues under my direct
responsibility, such as the erosion of the benefits of the GI Bill or the necessity of
restructuring America’s colleges and universities. I have no interest at all in throwing more
money at a problem. That is not at all the answer.
I am exhausted by the tone and the tenor and the themes of Washington, D.C. that
somehow money is the measurement of compassion. Since when do you measure love by
the dollar? It’s not done. When dollars become restricted, you begin to leverage those
dollars and you begin to think, and that’s what must be done.
I’m reminded of General Patton as he stood over a cemetery in Europe. He stood there
to give comments, looking upon all the little white crosses and Stars of David. He said, “I
am not here to pay honor at all to those who have given their lives, but to pay honor that
they had lived.” How appropriate.
I thank God that He placed human beings upon this earth that might have the
compassion and the sincerity for fellow men and women who would lay down their lives for
others whom they don’t even know. That’s the dimension and understanding.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER:
Thank you very much, Mr.
Congressman. If we only had about four hundred thirty-five or so Steve Buyers in the
Congress, this country would be in excellent shape.
THE FOURTH ESTATE AWARD
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: On Monday we presented the William
Randolph Hearst Trophy to the Department of Vermont for their outstanding Americanism
efforts for the past program year. This morning we present the Fourth Estate Award to the
Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau for an outstanding series of articles on the national
debt and its crushing impact on our country.
Here to accept the award for the Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau and the
Albany Times Union of Albany, New York, is Marcia Stepanek.
The American Legion 1995 Fourth Estate Award for outstanding
achievement in the field of journalism is presented to Marcia Stepanek and
Charles J. Lewis of Hearst Newspapers, Washington Bureau and to the
Albany Times Union for a comprehensive five-part series on the national
debt. Presented at the 77th National Convention, September 6, 1995, in
Indianapolis, Indiana.
It is signed by myself as National Commander, Robert W. Spanogle, National Adjutant
and Thomas Kouyeas, Public Relations Commission Chairman. I congratulate you on this
144
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
outstanding work.
MS. MARCIA STEPANEK
Hearst Newspapers
We are deeply honored by this award. On everyone’s top 10 things to reduce is the
national debt and contain the federal budget deficit. Politicians preach against them and
economists testify to their ruinous effects.
Though we pay more taxes, it’s still not enough to cover the cost of our government.
Every year the interest we pay on the national debt takes an ever bigger bite out of our
national wealth. Now the national debt has emerged as a stubborn symbol of increasing
public frustration.
In Washington we have seen that in the last election, and we continue to see it. No
doubt we will see it again next year. For four months, from late 1993 through the spring of
1994 The Times Union of Albany, New York, and The Times Union, Washington Bureau,
Hearst Newspapers in Washington, tried to put a human face on this otherwise mindnumbing topic to examine the size of the debt, how we got into debt so deep as a nation,
why the debt keeps rising, and what the implications of the debt are for Americans and their
hopes for the future.
We conducted dozens of interviews. Our turf ranged from Washington State to
Washington, D.C.; points like Capitol Hill, the Treasury, the White House; out to the
grassroots of New York, to upstate New York, Plattsburgh Air Force Base; citizens of all
ages. In Minnesota, Illinois, Wisconsin, Virginia, and California, we talked to dozens and
dozens of people about that topic. We tapped into that frustration that had been felt leading
up to this last congressional election which illustrated some of the frustrations that had been
very long-standing over the debt.
The result of our research shows the debt to be one of America’s great dilemmas.
Cutting the debt can hurt as much as the long-term costs of borrowing. More citizens seem
to want it both ways. They want more money for solving society’s ills without having
anything cut from the existing budget. Yet, everybody wants to cut taxes.
Politicians don’t often, if ever, get reelected for cutting spending or raising taxes, and
this leads to this political dynamic in favor of deficit spending. On Wall Street, financiers
of the nation’s debt make money from the debt. The more money Uncle Sam must borrow,
the more money Wall Street must raise, and the more their firms make in profit for that
effort.
Yet without efforts to slow spending, the nation will be mortgaging its future and, say
some, draining Americans’ resources for this generation and generations to come.
When we started writing the series, the national debt was $4.4 trillion. Now it’s 4.9
trillion and rising at this current pace it could top $6 trillion in 1998.
On behalf of Hearst Newspapers, the Albany Times Union, Charles Lewis, The
Washington Bureau Chief of Hearst Newspapers and myself, thank you all for honoring this
project and honoring us. We are deeply grateful.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The man I now have the great pleasure
of introducing is making his first appearance before an American Legion National
Convention. He’s a man who has proven himself a true military leader. His travels have
taken him around the globe more times than once for sure. Now he serves as the Chairman
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
145
ot the Joint Chiefs-of-Staff after a brilliant military career. He is the principal military
advisor to the President of the United States, the Secretary of Defense and the National
Security Counsel. Please welcome General John Shalikashvili.
GENERAL JOHN M. SHALIKASHVILI, USA
Chairman Joint Chiefs-of-Staff
I have just returned from Hawaii and the 50th commemoration of the end of the Second
World War. It was a moving and inspirational occasion, just like being here with all of you.
It was particularly thrilling to have been in Hawaii among so many thousands of
veterans from World War II, men and women like you who served our nation in a time of
extreme peril and who performed so magnificently. As you probably know, The American
Legion was there in Hawaii in full force, proudly filling the ranks of each and every one of
those moving events.
Those proud veterans there, and World War II veterans here this morning, are the living
monuments of a remarkable moment in our history. But unquestionably, the most moving
event of all was the remembrance ceremony in the Cemetery of the Pacific a few days ago.
When you stand among the hundreds of rows of white silent tombstones, each one marking
the resting place of an American patriot, one thought cries out for all Americans to hear. It
is the same stark imperative we have learned time and again in our history, and it is for that
reason we must keep our defenses strong. We must never again allow our military to
become weak or unready. You above all others understand that lesson well. After all, you
were and still are the true guardians of America’s security. You are great patriots all.
I knew that there was at least one place in America that I could go where there are men
and women who appreciate the need to keep our defenses strong, men and women who have
observed this lesson firsthand, and that is right here. That’s why it is so great to be among
all of you here this morning.
But there’s another group of men and women who understand this as well, and they are
the men and women who are following in your footsteps today. They proudly wear
America’s uniform. And as I travel around the world to see them, no matter where they are,
from the DMZ in Korea where they are still standing guard over the nation so many of you
fought to keep free, to places like Haiti or Kuwait or to Germany, wherever they are, I see
the same thing again and again. I see courage and spirit and toughness. They are by any
measure our most precious asset. They are one and a half million strong following in your
footsteps and carrying on the march that you started.
For after all, it was you here in this hall who fought and bled to protect our freedom and
to give us our future, and we will not, we must not, let it slip through our fingers. I know
you would be proud to see the job that these young men and women are doing. For I tell
you, as one soldier to another, they are magnificent.
It is on their behalf that I wanted to talk to you today about our future challenges. It
was not long ago that many Americans were talking about peace dividends and the need to
cut our forces deeper. But we were fortunate; there were many cooler heads. And certainly
The American Legion was at the head of that list. You argued that the days ahead could
prove very turbulent, and that we must at all costs preserve our military strength. You were
right, for you have only to look at the past month to make that judgment.
We began the month of August by deploying combat forces to Kuwait the moment that
we learned that Saddam Hussein was planning to attack that country once again, and
146
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
possibly Saudi Arabia as well. We ended the month with our aircraft flying combat
missions over Bosnia as they are still today.
When you add to that our people serving in places like I just mentioned, like Haiti or
Macedonia or Korea or Germany and mention to them the word 'peace dividend, you get
a hearty chuckle. They, like you, know that if you want peace you have to pay for it. The
nation must pay for it by keeping our Armed Forces the very best in the world. Our men
and women in uniform must pay for it with their dedication, with their skill, with their
courage and, if need be, even with their very lives. They know what you know. There’s
only one peace dividend, and that is peace itself.
So we have, after all, found ourselves in an era of great challenges. Yes, the Cold War
is over, but what has taken its place is anything but well-ordered. A peaceful world that
some imagined would come about has not done so. It is long past time for us to be looking
backward and wondering what we can afford to cut. Rather, it is time for us to look forward
to the future and ask ourselves what it is that we must build.
I’m convinced that there are two great challenges that we must meet if we are to protect
all that you here fought so hard to gain for our country. The first of these is the global
challenge posed by the disintegration of the Soviet Empire. This is a challenge of managing
the enormous changes unleashed by the end of the Cold War. The second challenge is to
reshape our Armed Forces to insure that we have the right force with all the right capabilities
to confront the uncertainties of the next century and to protect America’s worldwide
interests.
Certainly, the end of the Cold War set in motion a wholly new world in world affairs.
For 45 years we lived in a world that was tense and divided. Over time we grew used to that
struggle; we even understood it. Its twists and turns even settled into a reasonably
predictable pattern.
But all of that has now changed. We have been cast into a surging sea of great change
and uncertainty. Just think, in the past few years we have created more new countries and
more new international boundaries have been changed, then even at the end of World War
II.
We have already seen enough of this era to appreciate the measure of our challenge. We
have seen first that it is far more complex and far more dangerous than many thought. You
have only to look back on the list of military operations we have engaged in to understand
that.
Second, we have seen that this new world is filled with great unpredictability. You
never know when or where the next Saddam Hussein will raise his head. But I guarantee
you that he’s out there lurking amidst the uncertainty, and it is only a matter of time before
he will challenge us. We must be ready for him.
Third, it is also an era filled with incredible opportunities, opportunities that can make
the next century so much more peaceful and so much more stable than the bloody century
we are leaving behind today. Just think, over 2 billion new citizens are laboring to try to
join the global free market, a huge expansion. If it succeeds, it will make America vastly
more prosperous in the next century. Also, dozens of nations are enmeshed in dramatic
political reforms. They are struggling to shed old habits of tyranny, to embrace democracy,
and to join the ranks of democratic allies that you helped build at the end of the Second
World War.
Just imagine what it will mean if these hopes are met. Think back to the end of World
War II when you struggled to help our former enemies recover and rebuild. Eventually
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
147
single global market was organized to encompass some 1 billion of the world’s people.
Look at what that accomplishment has given us over the past 50 years.
But the opportunity at our feet today is to reach out beyond the old walls of
containment and to bring several billion former adversaries into the community of
democratic nations with free and open markets. This is much greater by comparison. If we
succeed for our children and for our grandchildren, just imagine what their world will be
like.
I am convinced that there is only one key that will unlock these hopes. That key is
American leadership. We must be the architects of the next century. But leadership
demands strength. You cannot lead from weakness. After all, it has been our strength that
has created these opportunities, and it must be our leadership that seizes them.
While we cannot be the world’s policemen, only we have the resources, the power, and
the reach to help mold a better world. To shape the world of tomorrow does demand that
we stay engaged in the world today. You here in this room set this example for us. You did
not shrink from your challenges, and we will not shrink from ours. We must stay always
focused on the future even as we are tending to the challenges of today.
While today’s challenges might be in places like Bosnia, North Korea, Iraq, or even
in a place like Haiti, the future isn’t being shaped there. The future is being shaped in places
like Moscow, Beijing, and Tokyo. While today’s challenges deserve our attention and, at
times, our intervention, we cannot ignore the main events that could directly threaten our
vital national interests. We must never, never lose sight that the fundamental purpose of our
Armed Forces is to fight and win our nation’s wars. We must not let events drive us, but we
must have the vision and the strength to shape events. We owe that to our children.
And that leads me to the second challenge. That challenge is to shape our Armed
Forces to insure that they are prepared to meet the challenges of the next century, a century
that is only a short five years away. We must make sure that our Armed Forces remain
unequaled by any other in the world. And that must mean that we avoid the rueful cycle of
the century, the same cycle we followed after the First World War, after the Second World
War and after Korea and, yes, even after Vietnam when we thought our struggles were
somehow behind us. As a result, we allowed our strength to atrophy. We neglected to
modernize, we permitted our readiness to dry up, and in the end, we paid dearly for our
mistakes. We must not allow that to happen again.
For it is a fact that in the history of this country’s Armed Forces, no man or woman in
uniform has ever completed a 20-year career that was not marked by American involvement
in armed conflict. Just think about it. And the force that we build must be powerful enough
to protect our worldwide interests, if more than one dictator were to challenge us. If we are
challenged in a place like Korea, we must still retain the strength to stop another dictator
at the same time somewhere else halfway around the world.
Certainly, our experience in the past two years has validated the need for a force with
this capability. Just in June of last year we were, in fact, reinforcing our forces in Korea
when the tensions over North Korea’s nuclear program had become so serious that we were
afraid that it could come to an armed conflict there. And by October of that same year, only
a few weeks after our forces began entering Haiti, we had to dispatch yet another force to
Kuwait after we detected several of Saddam Hussein’s Republican Guard divisions bolting
south towards our allies’ borders. In light of this experience, anything less ignores the world
we are living in, much less the world that may develop out of the uncertainty of the future.
You, the ranks of The American Legion, can attest that you do not build a military
148
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
force on wishful thinking. You build it on, a reality. With the ending of the cold war, our
military budget has been reduced by nearly 40 percent. I say, enough is enough. This
nation’s security demands that we cut no more.
And this nation’s security demands, as well, that we replace our equipment as it wears
out, that we modernize when necessary, even as we protect our near-term readiness. For
unless we replace our equipment, unless we modernize, we are jeopardizing tomorrow’s
readiness.
I believe that our experiences of the past two years have shown that the quality of our
men and women has, in fact, remained every bit as high as it has ever been. You can see this
everywhere that our men and women have been. In a superb way they have handled the
many missions that we have sent them to perform. You can see this in Haiti, where for a
year now they have performed magnificently and where results today have been exceeding
our most optimistic expectations.
You just saw two months ago when a young Air Force pilot named Scott O’Grady was
shot down while helping to reinforce the no-fly zone over Bosnia. From the moment his
plane went down, his comrades mounted an around-the-clock effort to find him. For nearly
a week, Captain O’Grady eluded capture, using the first-class training he had received and
through an extraordinary amount of pluck and courage. And the moment he was found, a
textbook rescue operation was executed, one that flew through dangerous skies to pull this
young hero to safety.
Or you could see just five months ago off the coast of Somalia where our Marines led
an international force to insure the safe departure of the last of the United Nations’
contingent still in that troubled land. It was a very dangerous and a very risky operation.
It was performed so flawlessly and in such a textbook fashion, that the entire operation was
accomplished without the loss of a single ally or United Nations Soldier or a single Marine.
Just as importantly, we showed by this action that the United States stands by its
commitments.
It is these men and women who have been and are performing these missions and are
making our Armed Forces, thus, the very finest in the world. If you wish to keep them in
uniform and to recruit more like them, then we must protect their pay and their benefits and
the quality of life that they and their families so richly deserve.
I like to say that they are a Superbowl team but without Superbowl wages. And the last
place we should look for savings is in their paychecks and in their benefits.
Since the start of the Second World War, it was our nation that had been the architect
of this century, America’s century. Many of you here in this hall were the builders. You
produced the victories upon which our freedoms were secured and upon which the Cold War
was won.
The challenge today is to insure that our nation is the architect for the next century as
well. If we are to do so, then we have to continue to lead. We are going to need men and
women in uniform every bit as good as you have been. Today they are. You can see this
if you go to the Aviano Air Base and watch them launch plane after plane into the skies
over Bosnia. You can see the cool determination in their eyes and the silent courage of
those performing the dangerous mission. It gives you the confidence that we will meet all
our challenges.
As I said earlier, they are, in fact, a Superbowl team, and we must never allow that to
change. But if we are to keep our defenses strong, then we need your support and your
assistance. That is what I have come here to ask of you.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
149
We need you, our country’s veterans, to continue to maintain your stand for a strong
national defense. You must continue to be our people’s standard bearer on that message.
Nothing less than a strong defense will do. We also need your help in finding and attracting
young men and women with outstanding qualities who are willing to spend a few years or
even a career serving our country. Spread the word through your communities. Uncle Sam
is still hiring. Your country needs you, and the rewards are beyond measure.
On behalf of those magnificent men and women of our Armed Forces, I salute you and
again, thank you for your remarkable service that you have given to our country. In our
times, of trial you were there. And thank God you were.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: General, be assured of the continued
strong support of The American Legion for our young men and women in uniform, and for
that readiness that is so important to peace in the world today.
... At this time a video was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Ladies and gentlemen, National Vice
Commanders have asked for permission to address the body. Permission granted.
PRESENTATION BY VICE COMMANDERS
VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Your Officers have felt that you have done an
outstanding job. So we decided we should give you something very special to remember
us by for your year of service.
Recently an artist in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin painted two pictures. One was of a Zero
over the Arizona.
The second one was of the Enola Gay, which was supposed to end the war. They came
out in Oshkosh at the EAA. We decided that this would be something that the Commander
could remember his year from, because he and his staff worked very hard, preserving the
true idea of the Enola Gay.
Commander, it’s all yours.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Well, Vem, and my Vice Commanders
and my Chaplain and Sergeant-At-Arms and other National Officers, you couldn’t have
given me anything more appreciated than that painting. It has been the hallmark of this year,
to stand up for the decision and to stand up for that wonderful plane. I thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The National Adjutant has asked for
permission to address this body. Permission granted.
PRESENTATION TO NATIONAL COMMANDER BY NATIONAL STAFF
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: I, too, want to thank you, Mr. Commander.
I know that the Delegates to the Convention elect a National Commander annually, and
certainly he travels almost a half a million miles per year carrying the message of The
American Legion.
We of the staff, however, get to work very closely with the National Commander. The
Delegates should know of the leadership demonstrated by the National Commander this
150
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
year, of his stewardship of your trust, and of his courage against the revisionist historians
regarding the Enola Gay. He carried on the traditional values in our quest for a
Constitutional amendment to protect the symbol of our country from physical desecration.
This has been deeply appreciated by me and his staff.
We have taken up a small collection for a symbolic gift to our National Commander.
Our thinking was just like that of the other national officers. We did not know what they
were going to present him.
I would like to have Hugh Dagley join me. On behalf of the staff of The American
Legion, we present to the National Commander, a hand-carved model of the Enola Gay.
General Tibbets and the crew who were here have signed this model in the positions
that they flew in the plane.
MR. HUGH DAGLEY: The National Commander has asked me to read the engraved
plaque.
To William M. Detweiler, National Commander 1994-1995. He led the last
battle of World War II for the people and for our common heritage.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I have an outstanding staff. They gave
a lot of time and a lot of devotion. In order to work for a nonprofit group, the staff must feel
for what the organization stands for. I assure you, from the executive director, to all the
other directors, to the person that cleans the buildings, to the person that drives the
Commander, to those that send out the mail, whatever it takes, the staff are always willing
to do whatever it takes. I am most appreciative.
I spent 30 years in this organization, working on the National level but didn’t really
know what the staff does and how devoted they were. But I had the opportunity to work
with them closely and saw them in action. I thank all of them from the bottom of my heart
for making this year what it was. It wasn’t a one-man show, I assure you. A lot of hard
dedicated work went into the effort.
One of these days I hope that I can put together some sort of a history of the year,
because so many things happened. We look back at the issues, such as the Enola Gay or the
Flag Amendment; or the restoration of funding in the VA or the controversy over the
McNamara book. So many things that happened. When you look back, you see certain
decisions that were made that seemed rather insignificant at the time, but which were
important to bring about the outcome.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Tony Jordan of
Maine, the Chairman of the National Convention Committee on National Security for the
purpose of making a report.
REPORT OF THE NATIONAL CONVENTION COMMITTEE ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Anthony G. Jordan (ME), Chairman
At 9:00 a.m., Saturday, September 2, 1995, 301 delegates and alternates assigned to the
Convention Committee on Security met initially in Rooms 206-207 of the Indiana
Convention Center in Indianapolis, Indiana. At this meeting, motions were approved
authorizing the Committee Chairman and his Secretary to make technical corrections to the
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
151
resolutions reported out of the Committee to ensure proper wording and form without
changing the substance or meaning of the resolutions. Mr. Anthony G. Jordan (Maine) was
elected Chairman and Mr. Walter G. Miete (Maine) was appointed Secretary.
The six authorized Convention Committees (Aerospace, Defense Civil Preparedness,
Law and Order, Merchant Marine, Military Affairs, and Naval Affairs) met in separate
meeting rooms. An additional Ad Hoc committee was appointed for General Security
resolutions which required special attention. The following were elected Chairmen and
Secretaries of the Convention Security Committees:
Aerospace
Robert C. Gabrielson, Chairman (South Dakota)
William A. Lindsay, Secretary (Montana)
Defense Civil Preparedness Frank J. D’Amico, Chairman (New York)
John Schurrer, Secretary (Wisconsin)
Law and Order
Dudley W. Robbins, Chairman (North Carolina)
Jack M. Rainey, Secretary (Virginia)
Merchant Marine
Charles Moreland, Chairman (Florida)
Charles P. Powell, Secretary (Virginia)
Military Affairs
Norbert Harmeyer, Chairman (Iowa)
Ronald Smith, Secretary (Virginia)
Robert L. Klipstine Chairman (Ohio)
Naval Affairs:
Jerry A. Ball, Secretary (Oklahoma)
J.B. Broussard, Chairman (Louisiana)
General Security Ad Hoc
Alexander Maclnnes, Secretary (New York)
Later that day, September 2, 1995, the delegates reassembled in Rooms 206 and 207
of the Indianapolis Convention Center for a final meeting of the Convention Committee on
Security. Reports of all Convention Committees were read and their recommended actions
on resolutions considered. A total of 18 resolutions were assigned to the Convention
Committee on Security or prepared by the Committee to meet problems which were held to
be of concern to The American Legion and germane to its principles and objectives.
Our first Committee Chairman will be General Security Ad Hoc, Committee Chairman
J.B. Broussard.
GENERAL SECURITY AD HOC COMMITTEE
J.B. Broussard (LA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
Origin: National Security
Submitted by: National Security
WHEREAS, The Anti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty of 1972 between the United
States and the Soviet Union placed a cap on deploying missile defense systems and limited
more advanced research on such defensive systems; and
WHEREAS, Despite the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Russia appears to be
continuing the modernization of strategic missile systems; and
152
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
WHEREAS, Since one of the signatories, the Soviet Union, no longer exists, there is
doubt as to whether the treaty is still legally in effect; and
WHEREAS, For many years, The American Legion has been on record in support of
a broad interpretation of the treaty to permit maximum research to develop essential missile
defenses; and
WHEREAS, As unreliable, hostile nations such as Iran and Iraq seem determined to
acquire the capability to deliver a nuclear strike over long distances, including striking the
continental United States, the need for a national missile defense for the continental United
States has become more urgent; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the United
States Government to renegotiate, modify or abrogate the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty of
1972 to clear the way for the development and deployment of a national missile defense
system and theater missile defense systems which are in the national interest of the United
States.
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 23 (MT) 1995 NC: United States Forces Under U.N. Command In Haiti
Resolution No. 106 (MD) 1995 NC: Anti-ROTC Policies at Colleges and Universities
Resolution No. 108 (MD) 1995 NC: National Security Principles
Resolution No. 125 (CA) 1995 NC: ROTC in Public Supported Universities and
Secondary Schools
REJECTED
Resolution No. 12 (CO) 1995 NC: Class Action Lawsuit Against U.S. Government
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Aerospace, Bob Gabrielson.
AEROSPACE COMMITTEE
Robert C. Gabrielson (SD), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
Origin: National Security
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The Secretary of the Air Force has emphasized that while resources have
diminished, demands for air and space power are increasing; and that in a world defined by
contingencies, the United States Air Force was focusing on three major objectives which
included maintaining combat readiness, shaping tomorrow’s Air Force, and supporting
people programs; and
WHEREAS, The United States Air Force has taken the lead in reducing its force
structure to meet Bottom-Up Review and Nuclear Posture Review requirements, and, in so
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
153
doing, freed up resources to maintaining combat readiness, supporting essential
modernization and providing a decent quality of life for its airmen and women; and
WHEREAS, Support ability and sustain ability have been enhanced by improved
readiness forecasting, better distribution of mission tasks, new ways to logistically support
weapons systems, and an improved approach to resolve engine problems; and
WHEREAS, The Air Force has focused its modernization in the following areas:
Providing rapid global mobility; achieving air superiority; conducting lethal surface attack;
and dominating the information environment. The five Air Force modernization priorities
over the next decade include the C-17 airlifter, B-2 bomber, F-22 fighter, upgraded precision
munitions, and the development of improved space launch capabilities; and
WHEREAS, The Air Force is strongly committed to providing a reasonable quality of
life which includes providing acceptable standards of living, treating people with dignity
and respect, and managing stresses associated with high deployment tempos; now, therefore,
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to appropriately support and defend defense budgets which reflect the three major
objectives of the United States Air Force which include maintaining its combat readiness,
shaping tomorrow’s Air Force and supporting Air Force people programs; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges congressional action to support and
fund the modernization priorities of the Air Force including the C-17 airlifter, B-2 bomber,
F-22 fighter, upgraded precision munitions, and the development of improved space launch
capabilities.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN GABR1ELSON: Mr. Chairman, that concludes my
portion of the Report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Defense Civil Preparedness, Frank D’Mico.
DEFENSE CIVIL PREPAREDNESS COMMITTEE
Frank J. D’Amico (NY), Chairman
No new resolutions were received. The Committee conducted a review
of previously adopted resolutions and reaffirmed their relevance.
This concludes the Civil Defense Preparedness portion of the Report of the National
Security Commission.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Law and Order, Dudley Robbins.
LAW AND ORDER COMMITTEE
W. Dudley Robbins (NC), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security Committee
WHEREAS, The Preamble of the Constitution states: "We the People of the United
154
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
States, in order to form a more Perfect Union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility...
Do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America;" and
WHEREAS, Terrorist attacks in the United States by individuals or small groups have
been on the upswing: According to the FBI, 32 terrorist incidents occurred in the United
States between 1989 and 1993 while 23 attacks were prevented and another 20 attacks were
suspected as terrorist instigated; and
WHEREAS, In recent years, foreign state-sponsored terrorist attacks, with a few
notable exceptions, have not been directed against targets in the United States, rather, there
appears to be little, if any, overall pattern or correlation of terrorist groups which have
attacked major targets in the United States in recent years; and
WHEREAS, Car bombings have been the weapons of choice for Middle East terrorist
groups; and the bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993 appears to have been
masterminded by a Muslim cleric operating independently rather than being directed from
abroad; and
WHEREAS, The recent car bombing of the Federal building in Oklahoma City, clearly
the worst terrorist attack in United States history killing scores of people and injuring
hundreds, appears to be attributable to domestic American Para-military extremist groups;
and
WHEREAS, Regardless of whether these terrorist attacks are of domestic or foreign
origin, Americans are being intimidated into believing that no institution or locality is
exempt from terrorism in the United States; and
WHEREAS, The United States must be capable of detecting and responding to other
possible forms of terrorist activity including the use of biological or chemical attacks as
occurred in the Japanese subway system; and
WHEREAS, To make concessions to terrorists or alter policy as the result of terrorist
actions, although possibly expedient in the short run, invites even more terrorist actions in
the long run; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, that The American Legion condemns all
terrorist activity in the United States and that it urges the United States Government and its
law enforcement and other agencies to assign the highest priority to combating domestic
terrorism and to act swiftly and decisively against perpetrators of terrorist acts; and, be it
further
RESOLVED, That whenever terrorist activity in the United States, whether of domestic
or foreign origin, results in the loss of American lives and/or property, that The American
Legion urges such perpetrators be rapidly apprehended, prosecuted in American courts, and
subjected to capital punishment, when appropriate; and be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the Federal Government to exert
maximum efforts to protecting American citizens and safeguarding federal and other
facilities from terrorist attacks to include closer monitoring, surveillance and other necessary
and prudent scrutiny of foreign and domestic groups in the United States which may be
inimical to American institutions.
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN ROBBINS: Mr. Chairman, that concludes my portion of
the report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Merchant Marine, Chuck Moreland.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
155
MERCHANT MARINE COMMITTEE
Charles F. Moreland (FL), Chairman
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. No new resolutions were received. The Committee
conducted a review of previously adopted resolutions and reaffirmed their relevance.
Mr. Chairman, this concludes my report.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Military Affairs, Norbert Harmeyer.
MILITARY AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
Norbert Harmeyer (IA), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
Origin: DC
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The United States has adopted a new National Security Strategy, marked
by the development of new national security and military strategies; and
WHEREAS, The United States Army is America’s strategic land combat force for
power projection and sustained land combat operations; and
WHEREAS, Unlike the Cold War strategy of containment, the emerging strategy
demands a versatile Army- a smaller Army capable of a wider range of operations and
organized to generate tailored forces; and an Army capable of meeting the following
demands: The capability to deploy rapidly and to fight two nearly simultaneous major
regional conflicts; a continuing robust Army forward presence is required in Europe and
Asia; refining its capabilities to conduct peacekeeping, peace enforcement and other
interventions; pursuing and expanding a series or nation assistance programs; and to provide
domestic support to local authorities in times of disaster; and
WHEREAS, The ability of the Army to maintain its combat readiness in the force of
budgetary and manpower reductions in increasingly threatened by the pace of peacetime
operations; and the mix of declining resources, increasing missions and an uncertain
strategic environment necessitate constant review of the relationships between maintaining
our national military capabilities, Army force structures and required resources; and
WHEREAS, On any given day, nearly 20,000 troops are committed worldwide and the
average soldier spends nearly 138 days a year away from home; and since 1989 nearly 700
Purple Hearts were presented to soldiers wounded or killed in combat; and
WHEREAS, The Army’s procurement and research and development budgets have
become bill payers to ensure near-term readiness accounts are sustained: The downward
trend in procurement dollars could jeopardize the lives of servicemen and women in future
conflicts; and
WHEREAS, America’s Army at the end of FY 1993 consisted of four Corps, 14 active
Divisions, and eight National Guard Divisions which contrasts with Cold War Army of five
Corps, 19 active Divisions and 10 National Guard Divisions; two active Divisions (the 6th
and 7th Divisions) are to be inactivated during FY 1994, and two more Divisions are to
deactivate by FY 1997, bringing the total active Divisions to 10 and National Guard
Divisions to five (+) Divisions by FY 1997; and
156
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
WHEREAS, Early access to the Army National Guard and Army Reserves, which
provide strategic depth, is the critical linchpin to a smaller, U.S.- based power projection
Army; and strategic mobility is the cornerstone of the emerging National Military Strategy;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to retain and fully fund no fewer than 12 active Army Divisions and an end
strength of approximately 530,000 troops for FY 1996 and the foreseeable future as the
absolute minimum levels in order to maintain America’s credibility in the new strategic
environment; and, be it further
RESOLVED, That The American Legion also urges the Congress to sustain readiness
accounts as well as procurement and acquisition accounts in FY 1995 and beyond, to include
the procurement of, for example, improved equipment for the detection, identification,
characterization and defense against chemical and biological warfare agents; additional
Blackhawk helicopters, vehicles, new radios, Ml tank and Bradley Fighting Vehicle
upgrades, the Apache Longbow system, the RAH-66 Comanche; and fully funding the Army
Force XXI program; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion has long recognized that a strong Army
requires strong people programs and is highly dependent on recruiting and retaining quality
soldiers, and it urges that voluntary and involuntary separation programs be phased-out so
as to stabilize the Army’s fighting capabilities while retaining a quality and fully-manned
force which is professionally led.
Resolution No. 102: Quality of Life Features
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security
As amended.
WHEREAS, The American Legion has always supported quality of life features for
members of the Armed Forces and their dependents as well as military retirees, as people
are the foundation of our Nation’s fighting forces; and
WHEREAS, Without highly qualified, dedicated men and women, even the most
sophisticated weaponry will not provide the deterrent force necessary for this Nation to
remain at peace; and
WHEREAS, The United States Government has the inherent and moral responsibility
for providing for the well-being of members of the active and reserve components and their
dependents and military retirees and their dependents; and
WHEREAS, Military pay must be reasonably comparable to compensation in the
private sector if the Armed Forces aspire to compete for quality volunteers and retain an
experienced military force for the long term; and
WHEREAS, Military compensation is only one factor in the quality of life equation as
to whether a good service member and his family remain in the service: Other major factors
include fair treatment, career stability and regular promotions, adequate quarters, adequate
health care and commissaries, and day care facilities, all of which ease the numerous
sacrifices that are demanded of service members and their families; and
WHEREAS, Our military retirees and their dependents and military survivors are
deserving and rightfully entitled to adequate health care treatment and regular cost-of-living
adjustments (COLAs) to military retirement pay and survivor benefit plans; now, therefore,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
157
be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress and the Department of Defense to support and fund such quality of life features
including but not limited to, the following:
1. Military Pay comparability for the Armed Forces.
2. Increased Basic Allowance for Quarters (BAQ) so as to cover at least 65
percent of median housing costs.
3. Adequate medical and dental services; morale, welfare and recreational
facilities; and non-privatized exchanges and commissary facilities.
4. Retaining an attractive retirement system for the active and reserve
components which safeguards retirement benefits in effect at the time of the
service members’ entry into military service
5. Requiring that the Services perform mandatoiy physical examinations,
without waivers, for all separating veterans.
6. Fully funding the concurrent receipt of military retirement pay, military
separation pays, and VA disability compensation.
7. Amending Public Law 99-145 as to eliminate the automatic age 62 offset
of Survivors’ Benefits Plan benefits with Social Security benefits
particularly for those survivors who have earned Social Security benefits in
their own right.
8. Adequate health care treatment for military retirees, their dependents and
military survivors, and regular cost-of-living adjustments to military
retirement pay and survivor benefit plans.
9. Non-taxation of military allowances to include moving allowances.
10. Congressional Re-enactment of Impact Aid to fund the local public school
education of military dependents.
11. Amend IRS codes to increase the current monthly exclusion for all officers
serving in a combat zone from $500 to $2,000.
Resolution No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (OBRA) of 1993 drastically
altered the 30-year relationship of military and Federal retirees COLAS by delaying the
receipt of military retiree COLAS by 39 months and delaying the receipt of other Federal
retiree COLAS by only 9 months, cumulatively, between April 1, 1994 and January 1,
1999; and
WHEREAS, By 1999, the delay in military COLAS would cost the average military
retiree at least $3,000 annually in retired pay while a Federal civilian retiree with
comparable retired pay would forfeit only $603; and
WHEREAS, Military retirees as a group comprise only three percent of the population
eligible to receive Federal COLAS, yet they are being forced to bear 88 percent of the total
COLA sacrifice; and
WHEREAS; Military retired pay is not a gratuitous gift from the taxpayer but is earned,
deferred compensation for accepting the unique demands and sacrifices of decades of
military service for careerists who often served and fought in two or more wars or conflicts;
158
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
and
WHEREAS, If the Government allows the quality of life of retired military members
to erode over time, or if the retirement promises that induced them to serve arduous careers
are not kept, this will undoubtedly inhibit retention in the active duty and reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, The vast majority of military careerists are forced to retire in their early
40's and their annual retirement pay and COLAS never catch up with the annual incomes
of single-career Federal civilians of comparable age, education, and job experience; now,
therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4,5,6, 1995, That The American Legion urges the
Congress to correct the gross inequity in military retiree COLAS by providing sufficient
funding to equalize the delays in the receipt of military retirement pay with those of Federal
retired civilians for FY 1996 and beyond; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion opposes any further Congressional attempts
to delay, reduce or deny military retirement COLAS for authorized recipients of military
retirement pay.
Resolution No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military
Beneficiaries
Origin: MD
Submitted By: National Security Committee
WHEREAS, The promise of lifetime military health care for military retirees, their
dependents, and military survivors is contained in law and tradition and dates back to the
Army Appropriations Act of 1884; and
WHEREAS, A sense of the Congress resolution contained in the Fiscal Year 1993
National Defense Authorization Act states that "members and former members of the
Uniformed Services and their dependents and survivors should have access to health care
under the Health Care Delivery System of the Uniformed Services regardless of age and
health care status;" and
WHEREAS, The present health care system for military retirees direly requires reform
as the CHAMPUS entitlement system for beneficiaries under 65 has been annually under
funded, bureaucratically administered and inconsistent; and military retirees over 65
comprise the only group of retired Government "employees" who essentially lose their
military health care entitlement, after having served 20 or more years in the most demanding
and dangerous of professions; and
WHEREAS, Under the TRICARE system, CHAMPUS eligible beneficiaries will
choose among three options: TRICARE Prime, whereby patients rely on a single primary
care provider for most health care needs; TRICARE Extra, a preferred civilian provider
network with a higher choice of physicians; and TRICARE Standard, a fee-for-service plan
which is essentially the CHAMPUS system. Those who choose TRICARE Prime or Extra
would waive their rights to use military hospitals or pharmacy benefits; and
WHEREAS, The American Legion has a number of concerns with the TRICARE
package, namely, that military beneficiaries would be required to pay annual "registration"
fees whether they used their plan or not; questions remain concerning the amount of
increased out-of-pocket expenses; premiums for self-employed military retirees; the viability
of MEDICARE reimbursement to the Department of Defense; and whether a TRICARE
program would be extended to military beneficiaries residing overseas; and
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
159
WHEREAS, Military retirees, dependents and military survivors constitute at least 43
percent of the total 9.2 million eligible military medical beneficiaries; and over 500,000
retirees have lost or will lose their access to military health care as a result of military
treatment facilities’ closures; and
WHEREAS, The collective voices of The American Legion and other organizations
need to be heard by Congress, the Administration and the American people regarding
military retiree entitlement to quality, timely and consistent health care which retirees were
always promised; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Indianapolis, Indiana, September 4, 5, 6, 1995, That The American Legion recommends the
following guidelines be incorporated as an inherent part of the Department of Defense
TRICARE health care package, or any military health care package, for military retirees,
dependents and military survivors:
1.
The U.S. Government must honor its obligation to provide lifetime health
care to military retirees in exchange for their numerous sacrifices made over
decades of service to the nation.
2.
Timely access to a continuum of quality, comprehensive and equitable
health care benefits covering the full array of services ranging from
preventive health care and dental treatment plans to prescription services for
all military beneficiaries, regardless of age or health care status.
3.
Preservation of the space-available system for CHAMPUS and MF.nTCA.RP
eligible military retirees and their dependents in military treatment facilities
depending on facility capabilities.
4.
CHAMPUS coverage should continue for the lifetime of military retirees
and not end at age 65. Additionally, military retirees who become 100
percent disabled before 65 should continue with CHAMPUS coverage for
their lifetimes with MEDICARE as second payer.
5.
DoD health care treatment facilities should be reimbursed by the Health
Care Financing Administration for care provided to MEDICARE eligible
military beneficiaries (MEDICARE Subvention).
6.
MEDICARE subvention will save money for both the government and
taxpayers. Equally important, it will preserve military medical readiness
and keep faith with military beneficiaries who relied on repeated
government promises of lifetime health care in return for their decades of
career military service.
7.
Adequate military medical personnel should be retained on active duty to
provide health care for active duty and retired military personnel and their
dependents.
8.
MEDICARE eligible retirees are not allowed to enroll in TRICARE Prime
160
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
as DoD does not fund the medical treatment of these retirees. Additionally,
TRICARE annual enrollment fees are imposed only on retirees and their
dependents and survivors which is discriminatory. These enrollment fees
are excessive for CHAMPUS eligible retirees. The American Legion also
opposes the proposed imposition of user fees in military treatment facilities.
9.
TRICARE choice is restricted by the imposition of more restrictive
non-availability statements. These statements must be obtained from
military facilities as well as from civilian networks.
10. The retirees’ catastrophic cap should be reduced from $7,500 to $2,500 for
enrollees in TRICARE Prime to conform to similar caps for other HMOs.
11. Cost-sharing in TRICARE plans should be reasonable and legislatively
fixed by law.
12. TRICARE health care plans should be extended to eligible military
beneficiaries residing in overseas areas.
13. Oppose the DoD charging of user fees for those PRIMUS and NAVCARE
clinics established after September 30, 1994, based on TRICARE Prime
rates.
14.
Oppose the imposition of enrollment fees in the Uniformed Services
Family Health Plan which is the only DoD health care program which has
not disenfranchised MEDICARE eligible retirees.
15. Pharmacy networks and mail-order pharmacy programs should be extended
beyond the 40-mile radius of closing military bases and they should operate
on a flat-rate basis rather that one based on percentage of costs.
16. The imposition of penalty assessments should be waived for those military
retirees who elected not to enroll in Part B of MEDICARE as they believed
they would receive continuing military health care from DoD facilities
which were subsequently identified for closure.
17. Authorizing the use of Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Centers by
non-service-connected military retirees and their dependents who are
CHAMPUS or MEDICARE eligible, particularly in those areas where
military bases with medical facilities are closing or closed.
REFERRED TO THE STANDING COMMISSION ON
NATIONAL SECURITY
Resolution No. 13 (CO) 1995 NC: VA/DoD Joint Venture for Fitzsimons Army Medical
Center
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
161
RECEIVED AND RECORDED
Resolution No. 33 (DC) 1995 NC: Retain the Selective Service System
Resolution No. 45 (SC) 1995 NC: Preserve the National Guard of The United States
Resolution No. 103 (MD) 1995 NC: Retention of The Uniformed Service University of
Health Sciences (USUHS)
REJECTED
Resolution No. 31 (DC) 1995 NC: National Museum of The United States Army
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Naval Affairs, Bob Klipstine.
NAVAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
Robert L. Klipstine (OH), Chairman
RECOMMENDED ACTION ON RESOLUTIONS
APPROVED
Resolution No. 150: Support for The United States Coast Guard
Origin: National Security
Submitted By: National Security
WHEREAS, By public law the United States Coast Guard is at all times one of the
Armed Forces of the United States; and
WHEREAS, Included in the numerous peacetime and wartime missions of the Coast
Guard are law enforcement in its many facets to include drug interdiction and interception
of illegal aliens; environmental protection, maritime safety including search and rescue
responsibilities and inspecting and licensing Merchant Marine ships; and National Security
to include port security and serving as an essential wartime partner of the U.S. Navy; and
WHEREAS, To carry out these critical missions it is essential that highly skilled and
motivated men and women continue to be attracted and retained by the Coast Guard and its
Reserves and that ships, aircraft, and required facilities be fully funded; and
WHEREAS, It is vital to the National Security, economic and environmental
well-being of the United States that waterway safety receive high priority within the
Nation’s transportation infrastructure so as to assure the safe and efficient maritime transport
of critical raw materials, petroleum products and finished cargoes to domestic and
international markets; and
WHEREAS, It is also in the national interest for the Coast Guard to acquire new ships
and aircraft so that new technology can be maximized; and
WHEREAS, Without adequate resources, the United States Coast Guard will be unable
to meet its national and international commitments to the detriment of the American people;
now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, By The American Legion in National Convention assembled in
Minneapolis, Minnesota, September 6,7,8, 1994. That The American Legion urges the
Administration and the Congress to fully fund the United States Coast Guard to carry out
its numerous vital missions, including law enforcement, environmental protection, maritime
safety and national security and other missions as assigned; and, be it further
162
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
RESOLVED, That The American Legion supports pay parity for Coast Guard men and
women so that they receive compensation comparable with their partners at the Department
of Defense; and, be it finally
RESOLVED, That The American Legion urges the Congress and the Department of
Transportation to support and fund such quality of life features as pertain to the other Armed
Forces of the United States.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: I am particularly pleased to announce the winners of the
National Blood Donor Awards for this past year.
Category I - Departments with 100,000 or more members
Post and Individual Participation - Department of Florida
Individual Participation- Department of Minnesota
Category II - 70,000 to 99,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Wisconsin
Category III - 40,000 to 69,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Georgia
Category IV - 25,000 to 39,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Tennessee
Category V - 10,000 to 24,999 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Rhode Island
Category VI - Less than 10,000 members
Post and Individual Participation- Department of Delaware
The results of the competition for the Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy are as follows
FOR 1994-1995:
Over fifty Departments participated in the ROTC Awards Program this year. A total
of over 10,000 Medals were awarded to deserving cadets in College ROTC and Junior
ROTC Units. There were fourteen Departments which were awarded the Paul H. Griffith
ROTC Trophy plaques and they included the Departments of Alabama, Alaska, Delaware,
District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Puerto
Rico, Rhode Island, and Vermont, which speaks well for these Departments and The
American Legion in its recognition of the youth of America enrolled in ROTC programs.
. At this time National Vice Commander Calvin E. Patton assumed the Chair.
CHAIRMAN JORDAN: Mr. Commander, as a Delegate to this Convention, from the
Department of Maine, I move the adoption of this report.
... The motion was duly seconded and carried.
... National Commander resumed the Chair.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
163
BLOOD DONOR REPORT
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As we near the end of our 77th National
Convention, I’m happy to report that we have recorded another excellent Blood Drive.
Because of a generosity of the Delegates to this Convention, 257 units were collected.
Blood Center workers estimate this will assist 1,028 patients at several central Indiana
hospitals, including the VA Medical Center. I congratulate you for your support, and ask
that you carry the message of the importance of donating blood back to your local posts. The
American Legion can continue to be the largest identifiable group of blood donors in the
nation.
... At this time a video vignette was viewed by the Delegation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: I hope you have appreciated these
vignettes as much as the staff appreciated the opportunity to put those together. I think they
have really helped to carry out the commemoration of World War II and this convention.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: 50 years ago, World War II was finally
over. Today the U.S. Military continues to have a strong presence in the Pacific theater.
Our next guest is a man who carries a heavy responsibility to insure that America’s readiness
in this area of the world remains high. He’s Deputy Director for Operations of the U.S.
Pacific Command, responsible for all joint operations, exercises, and operational command
and control throughout the Pacific Command. He’s a decorated pilot, first seeing action in
Southeast Asia and most recently flying one of his 242 combat missions during Operation
Desert Storm.
It gives me great honor to welcome to our 77th National Convention, Major General
E.C. ‘Sandy’ Sharp.
MAJOR GENERAL ERVIN C. SHARP, JR.
Deputy Director for Operation U.S. Pacific Command
Thank you, Commander Detweiler, it is a great personal privilege for me to be here
today with you in this hall of my comrades in arms and great American patriots. And, on
behalf of Admiral Richard C. Mackey, Commander-in-Chief of the United States Pacific
Command, we send greetings and aloha from Camp H.M. Smith, Hawaii.
As we speak, Admiral Mackey is about to begin his second day of conferences with all
of his Pacific commanders, discussing many of the details of the Pacific strategy that he
asked me to share with you today. As Admiral Mackey typically does, I will start with what
he emphatically believes to be at the core of the Pacific strategy and the key to its execution.
His twin priorities are war fighting and people.
Our business in the military is war fighting. We must be ready to fight and win our
nation’s wars. War fighting means readiness. Readiness means of a relentless pursuit to
continuously improve, field and maintain the best equipment we can for the troops.
Readiness means leveraging the accelerating emergence of technological marvels
certain to unfold in the 21st century. Readiness means steadfast support for the best training
that money can buy for every member of our Armed Forces.
But as you know, it’s not our equipment nor our technology nor our training nor even
our doctrine that makes us the greatest military power in the world. It’s our people. Without
164
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
quality people and an adequate quality of life for those people, such as in housing, pay,
medical care, and retirement war fighting readiness is impossible.
We simply must never abandon these two fundamental priorities if we hope to have any
military strategy succeed or more importantly, if we wish to remain the world’s most
effective fighting force.
With those two priorities clearly in focus, let me now share with you the Admiral’s
perspective of the Pacific and the Pacific strategy as we approach the year 2000 and beyond.
I’ll do this in two parts.
To begin with, I will talk briefly about why we as Americans should be interested in
and concerned about the Asia/Pacific region. Then how we of the United States and of the
Pacific Command address our cares and concerns about the region.
First, why should we care about the Pacific? At the heart of the answer lies a basic
principal of our national strategy. That says democracy is in the best interests of the
American people. Over time we have learned that democracy has some excellent habits.
Democracies don’t declare war on each other and don’t support terrorism, produce refugees,
or traffic in drugs.
Democracies do foster free market economies and protect human rights. Therefore the
enlargement of the community of free democracies is a vital interest of the United States.
When you lift the hood of these democracies, particularly the late models found in the
Pacific region, you find the engine driving the phenomenal growth in the world’s
transnational marketplace.
Many share the Pacific command’s view that our nation’s economic future is clearly
in the Asia/Pacific region, an area of over one-half the earth’s surface and one-half of the
earth’s gross domestic product. The Pacific encompasses two-thirds of the world’s
population organized into more than 40 nations. Five of them are defense treaty partners
with the United States. 36 percent of our trade is in this region, three times our trade with
Latin America and one and a half times our trade with Europe.
Portions of the Asia/Pacific region are growing six times faster than the global average.
The economic miracle is especially apparent in the rapid growth of China, the world’s
fastest growing economy, with a 9.5 percent annual growth average over the last ten years,
and the four newly industrialized economies of South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and
Singapore.
Certainly from all of this it’s not difficult to argue that we should care about the Pacific,
and I believe most do. However, at the same time, we also must be concerned with the
enduring realties of the Asia/Pacific region. Even with the end of the cold war we have seen
that the world is still a dangerous place. Witness Desert Storm, Chechnya and the ongoing
conflict in Bosnia, just to name a few.
Our current national military strategy warns of four emerging global dangers, all of
which are clearly at work in the Pacific.
First, there are regional dangers. In addition to 40 years eyeball-to-eyeball over the
DMZ in Korea, there are ethnic, ideological and territorial disputes both within and between
Pacific nations which are also home to the world’s seven largest Armed Forces.
Second, there are dangers from the proliferation of weapons both of mass destruction
and conventional.
Third, there are dangers to democracy from within with a tendency to relapse into
autocratic forms of government when they see their privileges threatened.
And finally, there are economic dangers of falling behind economically or that
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
165
economic tensions may lapse into protectionism.
Thus viewed in the foregoing context, we see a complex region with many positive
trends that offer enormous potential for national and global prosperity. Yet, at the same
time, we must not lose sight of the unfavorable consequences should we ignore the region’s
enduring realities and disturbing trends.
Obviously, the same complexities require a balanced and aggressive national and
supporting military strategy. Additionally, as a Pacific nation ourselves, one of the central
tenants of that strategy must be shared responsibility.
President Clinton made that abundantly clear during his July, 1993, trip to Asia when
he described his vision of the “theater grand strategy.” He described a Pacific community
built on shared strength, shared prosperity, and a shared commitment to democratic values.
His themes of security and active engagement in the region are also formalized in our
national security strategy of engagement and enlargement and more recently in the East Asia
strategy report.
Engagement is defined as presence in the region. A full partner in peace and crisis thus
becomes the mission of the Pacific command, that is to insure the enlargement of the
community of free and open societies.
To accomplish that mission, Admiral Mackey must find ways to link our military
means to our national ends. He does this through a theater military strategy called
cooperative engagement. The means available to us are forces, funds, programs and asset.
The desired ends we are trying achieve are engagement and reassurance in peace, deterrents
and cooperation in crisis, and swift victory in conflict.
The three principle ways we use to link these ends and means are forward presence,
strong alliances and crisis response.
First, forward presence. Everywhere we visit in the Asia/Pacific region, people tell us
how important it is for the United States to remain engaged there. We are engaged. The
most credible way we demonstrate our commitment to the region is through forward
deployment of our soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines, and in many cases, their families
as well. We have, and intend to keep, about 100,000 of our troops forward deployed. That
number brings us about into balance with the number of troops that we intend to keep in
Europe.
Countries of the region watch our presence very carefully and for good reason.
Economic progress depends on stability. Stability depends on mutual security and
reassurance. Mutual security and reassurance depends on United States security guarantees
and a United States presence.
Our 100,000 forward deployed troops consist of maritime forces, which are
continuously deployed in the western Pacific, the Third Marine Expeditionary Force in
Okinawa, tactical fighter wings in Korea and Japan, the eighth U.S. Army in Korea and
rotational deployments, such as air force squadrons to Singapore. These are backed up by
forward-based forces in Hawaii, Alaska, Guam and Pacific Command forces on the west
coast of the continental United States. In total, these 330,000 troops of all our services
represent one-fifth of our total U.S. military.
The second way we link our means to achieve our ends is through strong alliances.
Five of the seven units mutual defense treaties worldwide are in the Pacific Command’s area
of responsibility. In addition to our commitment to treaties with the Philippines, Australia,
Republic of Korea, Thailand and Japan, we have established a network of bilateral and
multi-lateral relationships with the majority of the 45 nations in the theater.
166
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
Our third link is crisis response, which brings us full circle. As you recall, I said in the
beginning that should deterrents and cooperation fail to divert conflict, our business in the
Pacific Command is war fighting, and war fighting means readiness. The Pacific Command
is composed of our nation’s finest men and women actively engaged and present in the
region, fully trained with our regional friends and treaty partners for joint and coalition
warfare. They stand ready to respond to any crisis to achieve swift and certain victory.
Last weekend it was my honor and privilege to help host thousands of World War II
veterans in Hawaii as we commemorated V-J Day, the end of the war in the Pacific and the
end of World War II. Many veterans came to the dais to remind of us of the enormous
sacrifice that victory required. World War II destroyed whole cities, it ravaged countrysides.
It cost and totaled the lives of 55 million people.
The Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Jessie Brown, said more than 4 million of America’s
best and brightest served in World War II in the Pacific. More than 100,000 died. Almost
200,000 were wounded and about 35,000 were prisoners of war. Veteran Virgil Stewart
who was at Hickam Field on December 7, 1941, said, “We don’t want anyone to forget what
happened. We don’t want it to happen again. No way.”
President Clinton said, “It is only fitting that here in the middle of the ocean whose
name means peace, we honor the men and women that saved our world. We honor the men
and women that saved our world. We who are the heirs of their legacy must always be the
guardian of their dreams. It falls to us to stand against those who sow the seeds of war and
to stand with those who take the risks of peace to create a new prosperity for ourselves and
for others.”
Hopefully, my report to you today has been a clear signal that the best and the
brightest, the men and women of the U.S. Pacific Command, are prepared for and totally
committed to this sacred mission. We want to assure Virgil Stewart that we have not
forgotten what happened, and we are not going to let it happen again. No way.
Once again, on behalf of Admiral Mackey and all the Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and
Marines of the U.S. CINCPAC, thank you, National Commander Detweiler, and all of the
great Americans in the Legion, the Auxiliary and the Sons of The American Legion, for the
opportunity to bring you this report on the Pacific. We all loudly applaud and deeply
appreciate your enormous efforts on behalf of those who served and those who serve today.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: General Sharp, be assured that The
American Legion will continue to work in support of the necessary foreign and defense
policies to keep our forces in the Pacific strong and to continue to maintain those strong
forces in those countries.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Would Peter Ole please join me at the
podium. You know, I’m not sure how many years he has been with us.
MR. OLE: This is my 20th year.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The American Legion is grateful to
present to Peter Ole this certificate of appreciation:
In recognition and sincere appreciation of outstanding service and assistance
which contributed immeasurably to the success of The American Legion
National Convention in Indianapolis, Indiana, in the year 1995.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
167
Signed by myself and Bob Spanogle. Thank you, Peter.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Would National Vice Commander
Vernon Grosenick preside over the next order of business.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: Ladies and Gentlemen, I am honored
to preside over the next order of business during the 77th National Convention. This is the
time when we present to our National Commander Bill Detweiler of Louisiana, a plaque and
the Colors of his year in office. I now call on Mr. E. Roy Stone of South Carolina to present
the plaque.
PRESENTATION
E. ROY STONE, JR., (SOUTH CAROLINA): Last year it was my privilege to swear
in the commander who has served us this past year. I am further honored now to be given
this opportunity to bestow special recognition upon our National Commander. I have know
Bill Detweiler for many years. I have watched him serve our great organization and our
nation with true dedication.
As we mark the close of this year with him, as our National Commander, let us look
back at the issues he has tackled and the prestige he has brought to The American Legion.
Most noteworthy during this year was his leadership in insuring historical accuracy about
the end of World War II and, in the process, preserving the honor of those veterans.
He also took a highly visible road in mobilizing our forces in support for Old Glory,
talking with lawmakers at every opportunity about the need for a Constitutional Amendment
to protect the flag. Look at this insightful work in guiding the development of new
strategies that are being recommended for the VA hospital system. These initiatives, if
adopted, will preserve the VA while allowing access to VA medical care for more veteran.
It is a great honor to ask Commander Detweiler to join me at the lectern.
Mr. Commander, I wish to present to you on behalf of The American Legion this
plaque which shoes that you were elected to the high office of National Commander of The
American Legion for the 1994 to 1995. It is given to you in appreciation for your dedicated
leadership and in recognition of your devoted services to God and county. As a token of
high esteem of your fellow Legionnaires. Given on this 6th day of September, 1995, before
the delegates assembled at the National Convention in Indianapolis, Indiana.
Congratulations, Commander Detweiler, and I do it with quite a bit of emotion when
I say God bless you and thank you.
NATIONAL VICE COMMANDER GROSENICK: At this time, I would like to call
Past National Commander John Geiger from Illinois to present the Colors.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Will the delegates to this National
Convention please rise.
. . . The Delegates stood.
Ladies and Gentlemen, the ceremonial Color Guard is the 1995, 1996 National
Champion Color Guard from Speedway Post 500, Speedway, Indiana.
Color Guard, prepare to retrieve the Colors of our National Commander.
... The Colors were retired.
Commander Detweiler, these beautiful Colors, the flag of the United States and the
168
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
bright crimson banner of the national commander symbolize your term of leadership of the
American Legion.
I know that Robert Charles Smith and A1 LaBiche are here in spirit with the
Department of Louisiana and your family and friends as these proud Colors are presented
to you in final salute.
On behalf of the 3 million members of our American Legion, we present them to you
with deep gratitude and appreciation for your outstanding commandership. May God bless
you and your family. Commander, these are your Colors.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWE1LER: Hand salute.
Thank you very much, Commander Stone, Commander Geiger, my Fellow
Legionnaires, and Ladies and Gentlemen. On behalf of my family who is gathered with me
here on this stage, thank you very much for an incredible year. As I said earlier, it would
have really been impossible to predict what was going to happen this year when 1 was
elected in Minneapolis. I had no idea that we would have been involved in the issues we
have been involved in this year nor that we would have the opportunity to put forth our
opinions which were newsworthy and which were valued by the American public. I thank
you again very much for the opportunity of serving.
ELECTION OF NATIONAL OFFICERS
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: We now come to a Special Order of
Business, the Election of National Officers. The National Judge Advocate, Philip
Onderdonk of Maryland will read the rules of the Convention governing the nomination and
election of officers.
NATIONAL JUDGE ADVOCATE ONDERDONK: The rules for election of National
Officers:
Rule 15. Final sentence: The election of National Officers shall be by roll call.
Rule 17. Prior to the election of National Officers, the National Commander shall appoint,
subject to the approval of the Convention, a judge of election and such number of tellers as
he deems necessary, provided that the total number of tellers so appointed shall be an odd
number. In a contested election, each candidate going to the ballot shall be entitled to one
teller of his choice.
Rule 18. Nominations for National Officers shall be from the floor on roll call of the
Departments alphabetically arranged. Each Department may present as many candidates as
it chooses.
Rule 19. Nominating speeches for National Officers shall be limited to five minutes each.
Not more than two seconding speeches shall be made for any candidate, and said speeches
shall be limited to three minutes.
Rule 20. When more than two candidates are nominated for any office, balloting shall
continue until one candidate receives the majority of the votes of the Convention, except in
the election of National Vice Commanders.
Rule 21. In a contested election for National Vice Commanders, balloting shall continue
until (a) majorities and (b) pluralities are established for one or more candidates under the
following provisions: If, on any ballot taken, less than five candidates receive the necessary
majority to elect, the candidate or candidates receiving a majority vote shall be declared
elected and a new ballot shall be taken for the remaining number of places to be filled. The
candidate receiving the lowest number of votes on the preceding ballot shall be disqualified;
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
169
except, should two candidates remain to fill one place, a new ballot shall be taken.
Rule 22. The Convention will nominate and elect a National Commander and five National
Vice Commanders in this sequence.
Rule 23. At the conclusion of balloting on National Vice Commanders, each Department
Delegation Chairman shall deliver a written ballot to the tellers. Such ballots shall be in the
hands of the tellers before communication is made to the National Commander for
announcement of the results.
Mr. Commander, this completes the reading of the rules pertaining to the election of
National Officers.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As Chairman of this Convention, I now
appoint as Judge of the Election, that judicious adjutant from Louisiana, Jim Tripp, and as
Tellers of the Election, Lyle Foltz of Minnesota; Carey Bankhead of Missouri and Hugh
Hess of Michigan. Will the Judge and the Tellers of the Election please come forward?
I will call on the National Adjutant, Robert Spanogle, who will call the Roll of the
Departments. The purpose of the Roll Call is to receive nominations for National
Commander of The American Legion.
ROLL CALL
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Proceeding with the roll call. Alabama.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ORION J. HYDE, ALABAMA: I’m O.J. Hyde,
Department Commander and chairman of The American Legion Delegation from Alabama.
At this time Alabama yields to Minnesota.
DELEGATE BILL BARBKNECHT: Bill Barbknecht, Delegate to this National
Convention, hereby, Mr. Commander, ask you to recognize one of the finest Minnesota
Legionnaires from the Gopher State of Minnesota, very proud moment, the Honorable Past
National Commander, Judge Daniel Foley, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Past National Commander Foley is
recognized for the purpose of a nomination.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER HONORABLE DANIEL F. FOLEY,
MINNESOTA: At the outset, Commander Bill, I join my voice to the rank and file of The
American Legion to salute and applaud you for a year of outstanding service. You stood tall
in the face of great challenge, and deserve our respect and admiration for your leadership.
Your legacy, Commander, is that you have reminded all of us to be faithful to the lessons
we have learned from history, and for that alone I salute you.
It is my high honor and great personal privilege to place the name of an outstanding
Minnesota Legionnaire in nomination for election as National Commander.
The recorded history of The American Legion at every level tells us how far we have
come and what we have accomplished in pursuit of our goals as an organization. Our life
and times will dictate how we should pursue those goals in these last few years of the 20th
Century and into the next.
We labor in the vineyard of The American Legion, in the midst of changing and indeed
challenging circumstances in our national life and within our organization as well. We have
concern for the needs of the aging veteran, the homeless veteran, ill and dependent veterans,
and our concern for America challenged by crime and drugs. And we continue our valent
effort to protect our national symbol from physical desecration.
170
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
All of these concerns and more will require imagination, resourcefulness, discipline of
will, strength of numbers, and a steadfast Commander with spirit to lead The American
Legion. We present a man who will serve us well, and honor our organization by his quality
of leadership, his character and high moral conduct He will lend great dignity to the office.
This is a red letter day for his family; for the Department of Minnesota and for our National
Organization.
Our candidate is personable; he is popular; and he is schooled in the history of The
American Legion in its aims and purposes.
He was with the Navy in the submarine service during the Vietnam Era. He is
committed to the view that we must maintain a strong national defense. He is totally
committed to the cause of the POWs and MI As.
In his home Department of Minnesota he has served as Commander at every level:
Post, District and Department Commander. He has achieved an all-time-high in membership
with each command. In addition, he has served our Department as Department Chaplain.
Our candidate has shown additional leadership by heading up the Brain Science
Foundation in Minnesota, establishing a chair at the new VA Medical Center in Minneapolis
to study diseases of the brain. These studies and findings will ultimately help not just
veterans, but all of humankind for untold generations.
Under his leadership, over a million dollars was raised in a little over one year within
The American Legion and its Auxiliary in Minnesota, and matched by the University of
Minnesota. The studies are well underway.
Our candidate is a devoted family man, proud of his children, John and Ann. With his
lovely wife, Mary at his side, he is an ideal candidate to promote our Children and
Youth programs, and set an example for The American Legion family.
Our candidate has served actively on the National level on commissions and
committees, including Chairman of Foreign Relations. He is molded in the tradition of The
American Legion, a tradition which is reflected in the countless accomplishments of our
organization at every level, and of the effort of the men and women would have and do serve
our cause.
Our candidate is mindful of our tradition and mindful, too, of the mandate of our
Preamble: For God and Country we associate ourselves together to preserve the memories
of incidents of our association. To uphold and defend the Constitution. To transmit to
posterity the principles of justice, freedom and democracy.
Our candidate is determined as well to oppose with vigor any effort to reduce veterans
benefits, benefits which are the gift of a grateful nation for honorable service.
On the great seal of the State of Minnesota is the motto of our state: L’Etoile Du Nord,
The Star Of The North. This state, so rich in the history of our country with its lakes and
streams, its beautiful forests and fertile prairies, productive farms, its famed Iron Range, and
most of all its greatest resource, its people, is proud to proclaim him. Avon and Albany in
central Minnesota where he grew up as a boy and where his family roots run deep, are proud
to proclaim him. Red Wing, where he now makes his home, is proud to proclaim him. This
proud Department, with an eye to the bright sunlight of tomorrow, with its hope and
promise for peace in the world, proclaims him. I am honored to proclaim him.
Together with the Minnesota Delegates here assembled, and for all 130,000 Minnesota
Legionnaires for whom I speak, and with a heart filled with pride and emotion, I place in
nomination for election to the office of National Commander, our Star Of The North, a
Legionnaires’ Legionnaire, the name of Daniel A. Ludwig of Red Wing, Minnesota.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
171
... At this time a demonstration ensued in support of the nomination of Daniel A. Ludwig
as National Commander.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Alaska.
DELEGATE JESSE EUBANKS, ALASKA: Jesse Eubanks, Department Commander
of the great state of Alaska, The Land Of The Midnight Sun, I do hereby yield to Virginia
for the purpose of seconding the nomination of our incoming Commander, Daniel A.
Ludwig, of the greatest organization on earth.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Virginia.
DELEGATE ROGER MESSIER, VIRGINIA: Mr. Commander, Roger Messier, NEC
Delegate from the great state of Virginia. I rise for the request for you to recognize the Past
Department Commander and Chairman of our Delegation, Harold "Butch" Miller, for the
purpose of seconding the nomination of Dan Ludwig, our next National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes "Butch" Miller for
the purpose of seconding the nomination.
DELEGATE HAROLD L. "BUTCH" MILLER, VIRGINIA: As the Delegation
Chairman and the Past Commander of the Department of Virginia, and I might add a
member of the Southern Caucus, I am proud to rise and second the nomination of Daniel A.
Ludwig to the office of National Commander.
During the entire history of this great organization of The American Legion, only 76
Legionnaires have been granted the privilege I have been granted right now. But I can
unquestionably assure you that none have had the honor of placing the second upon the
nomination of a more dedicated, deserving and capable person.
Famous UCLA basketball coach, John Wooden once said, "Be concerned with your
character rather than your reputation. For your reputation is nothing more than what other
people think of you, while your character is what you truly are."
My fellow Legionnaires, the character of The American Legion will be in very, very
good hands with Dan Ludwig as our Commander.
Bom in a small town in Minnesota, Dan was raised on the traditional values of Love
of God and Love of Country. That should sound very familiar to all of us because for God
and Country are one of the founding ideals of this great organization. It is upon those same
ideals that Dan Ludwig lives.
Dan joined the Navy in 1964, and served in that capacity for eight years during the
Vietnam Era. He has been a member of Leo Peterson Post 54 in Red Wing, Minnesota since
1974. His wife, Mary and his daughter Ann are members of the Auxiliary, and his son John
is a member of the SAL. As you can see, they represent a truly American Legion family.
Since 1973, Dan has been employed by the Northern States Power Company at a nuclear
power plant in Red Wing, Minnesota as a radiation protection specialist. And even though
he represents a very bright star on the horizon for the future of The American Legion, I have
been told that Dan does not glow in the dark.
On a very personal note, I would like to thank Dan for allowing me to second his
nomination. While I am here representing the great Department of Virginia, I want the
record to show that I would have been just as proud to second his nomination had I not been
born and raised in Wabasha, Minnesota, just a few miles from Dan’s home.
My fellow Legionnaires, I ask that you join me in supporting a real American and a
dedicated Legionnaire from the Department of Minnesota, Daniel A. Ludwig, as our
National Commander for 1995-1996.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Arizona.
172
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JIM PHILLIPS, ARIZONA: Jim Phillips, Delegation
Chairman, Department Commander of the great state of Arizona, where hopefully in the
future we can hold another National Convention.
I yield to Maine.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Maine.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DONALD COLE, JR., MAINE: Worthy Commander,
Donald Cole, Department Commander, Delegation Chairman to this 77th National
Convention, I would request permission for our own Anthony Jordan to approach the
rostrum for the purpose of seconding the highest office in this great organization.
DELEGATE ANTHONY JORDAN, MAINE:. My name is Anthony Jordan, Delegate
to this 77th National Convention.
It is a privilege and honor to second the nomination of a friend and a Legionnaire, and
a man that brings with him family values that The American Legion has stood for since
1919. He is a man who has made The American Legion part of his everyday way of life
starting with the Leo C. Peterson Post 54 in Red Wing, to serving as Department
Commander of Minnesota in 1991 and 1992.
He served as a National Chairman of the Foreign Relations Commission in 1992 and
1993, and served on the Distinguished Guest Committee and Naval Affairs Committee. He
is serving as a member of the Policy, Coordination and Action Group in the Citizens Flag
Alliance. He believes in God and Country, and the veterans of this nation, dedicated to
veterans’ issues on the local and the national level. Strong leadership has always been the
foundation of The American Legion, and the 1995-96 year will be no exception.
On a personal note, I have known Dan and his wife Mary and children Ann and John ever
since they came on the National level. This is a National Commander and a family we will
learn to love.
It is with personal pride that I second the nomination of Daniel A. Ludwig of the
Department of Minnesota for the high office of National Commander of The American
Legion in 1995-96.
... At this time, the National Adjutant recognizes each Department in turn.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN CLAUDE CARPENTER, ARKANSAS: Mr. Chairman,
fellow Delegates, my name is Claude Carpenter, Chairman of the Arkansas Delegation, and
it is with great pleasure that I rise to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig to be National
Commander of this great organization.
DELEGATE JOSEPH EARLEY, CALIFORNIA: Joe Earley, Delegate to this
Convention; State Commander of California, where the National Convention will be held
in Anaheim in 1999, is honored to second the nomination for Dan Ludwig for the high
office of National Commander for the year 1995-96.
DELEGATE ED WEARING, COLORADO: Ed Wearing, Department Commander,
duly authorized Delegate from the Department of Colorado proudly seconds the nomination
of Daniel Ludwig for the National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN LEWIS WALLER, CONNECTICUT: Lewis Waller,
Delegate Chairman from the great little state of Connecticut, seconds the nomination for
Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE RICHARD HALL, DELAWARE: Department Commander, Membership
Chairman, I’m from the great state of Delaware with nine all time highs in membership,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RAYMOND J. POTOCKI, D.C.: Comrade Commander,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
173
my name is Raymond Potocki, the Delegation Chairman from the District of Columbia,
seconds the nomination for Daniel A. Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE WILSON TIMMONS, FLORIDA: Wilson Timmons, Past Department
Commander of the Sunshine State and home of the Convention to come up in 1997, proudly
second the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE WILLIAM MARSHALL, FRANCE: Bill Marshall, Department
Commander, Department of France. It’s with pride I can state that the birthplace of this
great organization, The American Legion, proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig
for National Commander and our leader for 1995-1996.
DELEGATE WILLIE PITTS, JR., GEORGIA: Willie Pitts, Commander of the great
Peach second the nomination of Ludwig for 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM DAVES, HAWAII: Aloha. Bill Daves,
Department Commander and Delegate Chairman, also from the home of the 1995 American
Legion Baseball Team, proudly seconds Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOHN DUNLAP, IDAHO: Department Commander
duly elected Chairman from the gem state of Idaho, proudly seconds the nomination for Dan
Ludwig for National Commander for 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN KERMIT HOLGREWE, ILLINOIS: Kermit Holgrewe,
Delegate Chairman from the state of Illinois, the Prairie State, proudly second the
nomination and the support of Daniel A. Ludwig for our next National Commander.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, INDIANA: Indiana proudly seconds the nomination
for Daniel Ludwig for Commander 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN NORBERT HARMEYER, IOWA: Delegate Chairman
for the State of Iowa, seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE RICHARD NIELSEN, KANSAS: Mr. Chairman, Dick Nielsen, State
Commander for the State of Kansas, on behalf of our 63 Delegates to this Convention are
proud to second the nomination for Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RANDALL COFFMAN, KENTUCKY: Randall
Coffman, Department Commander and Delegate Chairman from the great state of Kentucky,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan the man for the job of The American Legion
National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RUSSELL HENRY, LOUISIANA: Mr. Chairman,
Russell Henry, Past Department Commander, Chairman of the Delegation of the great state
of Louisiana proudly endorses, Dan Ludwig for Commander for 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ROBERT M. JOHNSON, MARYLAND:
Mr.
Commander, Robert M. Johnson, Department Commander, Delegate Chairman for the state
of Maryland, takes great pride in seconding the nomination of Dan Ludwig for the high
office of National Commander for the administrative year 1995-1996.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ARTHUR SMITH, MASSACHUSETTS:
Mr.
Chairman, Arthur L. Smith, Department Commander, Chairman of the Delegation, proudly
endorses and seconds Daniel A. Ludwig for the Department- for the National Commander,
1995-1996.
DELEGATE H. DEAN GEDDES, MEXICO: Buenos dias. This is the Department of
Mexico Commander, Dean Geodes. We were the first in membership for 1995, and we
intend to be right back on that podium in 1996 helping the new National Commander
achieve three million members. We want to second the nomination for our new
Commander, Dan Ludwig.
174
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM F. MILLER, MICHIGAN: Bill Miller,
Delegation Chairman, Michigan, proudly supports Dan Ludwig.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, MISSISSIPPI: Mississippi proudly supports Daniel A.
Ludwig for National Commander for 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN NORRIS PRESTON, MISSOURI: Delegation Chairman,
Dr. Norris Preston from the Show Me State of Missouri, the home of the first Legionnaire
to become President of the United States, Harry Truman, the man from Independence.
Many in this hall and thousands of your fellow veterans across the country, and for that
matter across the ocean, owe their last 50 years of their lives to this famous Missourian.
Harry Truman was the right man in the right place at the right time, and he made the
right decision. We all know it and must never let the world forget it.
Missouri proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig of Red Wing, Minnesota, to
be the next National Commander of The American Legion.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOHN PELLEGRINI, MONTANA: John Pellegrini,
Delegate Chairman from Montana, the Big Sky Country, proudly endorse and second the
nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE ROBERT H. ZERSEN, NEBRASKA: Bob Zersen, State Commander,
home of the world’s largest American Legion Post and the birthplace of the Enola Gay
where she first flew in Bellevue, Nebraska, proudly endorses Dan Ludwig for the high office
of National Commander.
DELEGATE ARCHIE POZZI, NEVADA: Archie Pozzi, National Executive
Committeeman, proudly endorses and seconds the nomination for Daniel Ludwig.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: New Hampshire.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN ROBERT G. BOURNIVAL, NEW HAMPSHIRE: New
Hampshire, Bob Boumival, Department Commander and Delegate Chairman is proud to
second the nomination of Dan Ludwig for the office of the National Commander for the year
1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN GEORGE DIEM, NEW JERSEY: George Diem,
Delegate Chairman from the Garden State, the home of the 1995 National American Legion
Woman Of The Year, our Governor, Christy Whitman, proudly endorses Dan the man
Ludwig.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, NEW MEXICO: New Mexico, the Land of
Enchantment, home of the Atomic Museum, offers a home to the Enola Gay, seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DAVID J. VARNEY, NEW YORK: New York. Mr.
Commander, David J. Varney, duly elected Chairman of the Delegation of New York,
proudly seconds the nomination of a proven great leader in The American Legion, Dan
Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATE GARNETT SHROPSHIRE, NORTH CAROLINA: Garnett Shropshire,
duly elected, standing in for our Chairman, Bob Patton, proudly endorses Daniel A.
Ludwig.
DELEGATE SUZANNE KIME, NORTH DAKOTA: Suzanne Kime, Department
Commander of North Dakota. The Department of North Dakota that for over 35 years has
enrolled the highest percentage of veterans into The American Legion, and has also hosted
the World Series in 1995 and two times previous, is very proud to present and second the
nomination, of our friend from across the Red River, Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JAMES E. MEYERS, OHIO: Jim Meyers, Delegation
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
175
Chairman from the Department of Ohio, home of the largest Boys State in the Nation,
proudly seconds the nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
UNIDENTIFIED DELEGATE, OKLAHOMA: Oklahoma proudly seconds the motion
for the nomination of Mr. Ludwig.
DELEGATE WILLIAM G. BOYER, OREGON: Oregon. This is Bill Boyer, Past
Department Commander, I second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE ALFRED PIROLLI, PENNSYLVANIA: Pennsylvania, Alfred Pirolli,
Past National Executive Committeeman and a Delegate to the 77th Annual Convention,
proudly seconds the nomination for Daniel A. Ludwig.
DELEGATE GIL V. ALDEA, PHILIPPINES: Mr. Chairman and fellow Delegates, I’m
Gil Aldea, Department Commander of the Philippines, proudly, honorably and are
privileged to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE ANIBAL CASTRO-FIRPI, PUERTO RICO: Anibal Castro-Firpi,
Department Commander for the island Puerto Rico, proudly casts 16 votes to Mr. Dan
Ludwig for National Commander in 1995-1996.
DELEGATE JAMES J. CONVERSE, RHODE ISLAND: Jim Converse, NECman
from the Department of Rhode Island. The Delegation from the Department of Rhode Island
is proud to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig as our next National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN W. M. MCLAUGHLIN, SOUTH CAROLINA: Mr.
Commander, W. M. McLaughlin, Past Department Commander and Delegation Chairman,
is proud to second the nomination of Daniel Ludwig.
DELEGATE DON MASON, SOUTH DAKOTA: Mr. Chairman, Don Mason,
Alternate National Executive Committeeman, Acting Delegation Chairman, the State of
South Dakota is very proud to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOE W. YOUNG, TENNESSEE: Mr. Chairman, Joe
Young, Delegation Chairman from the Volunteer State of Tennessee, is proud to second the
nomination of Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM C. FARMER, TEXAS: Bill Farmer,
Delegate and Chairman of the great state of Texas the first state to pass the resolution on the
Flag, not once but twice, proudly endorses Dan for the high office of National Commander.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DALE BROCKBANK, UTAH: Dale Brockbank as
Chairman of our Delegation, am proud to second the nomination of Dan Ludwig, and
welcome you to Salt Lake City for our next National Convention.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN GEORGE BILLE, VERMONT: Mr. Commander,
George Bille, Delegate Chairman from Vermont, on behalf of the veterans of the great state
of Vermont, home of the Green Mountain Boys, is proud to second the nomination of Dan
Ludwig for Commander 1995-96.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RICHARD D. SMITH, WASHINGTON: Dick Smith,
Past Department Commander, Chairman of this Delegation, proudly support Dan Ludwig.
DELEGATE FORREST SIMPSON, WEST VIRGINIA: Forrest Simpson, Delegate
from the State of West Virginia, home of Past National Commander Miles Epling, who
cannot be with us this year because of illness, proudly seconds the nomination of Daniel
Ludwig.
DELEGATE RUSSELL H. HANSETER, WISCONSIN: Mr. Chairman, Russ
Hanseter, Commander, Department of Wisconsin, The Badger State, proudly seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig of our great neighboring state of Minnesota. Dan is our man for
National Commander.
176
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN TODD E. WHITE, WYOMING: Todd White,
Delegation Chairman from the equality state of Wyoming, supports and seconds the
nomination of Dan Ludwig for National Commander.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: Mr. Commander, that completes the roll call.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone 4.
DELEGATE DAVID BARNEY, (NEW YORK): Mr. Commander, David Barney,
Department of New York. In view of the fact that there is but one candidate for National
Commander, I move that we suspend the rules of this convention, close nominations and that
the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote for the entire delegate strength of this
convention, and that Daniel A. Ludwig, Department of Minnesota, be elected National
Commander by acclamation.
I now make this first motion. Mr. Commander, I move that we suspend the rules of the
convention pertaining to the election of the National Commander and the nomination of the
election of the National Vice Commanders, which rules shall be reinstated at the conclusion
of the election for National Vice Commanders.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. There
is a motion before us to suspend the rules of the convention pertaining to the election of the
National Commander and the nomination and election of the National Vice Commanders,
which rules shall automatically be reinstated at the conclusion of the election of National
Vice Commanders. The motion is non-debatable and requires a two-thirds vote.
All those in favor signify by the sign of aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 1.
DELEGATE DALE BROADWAY, (UTAH): Mr. Commander, Dale Broadway from
the Delegation of Utah. I move the nomination for the office of National Commander be
closed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. The
motion to close nominations is non-debatable and requires a two-thirds vote.
All those in favor signify by saying aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE SIMMONS, (VERMONT): Mr. Commander, Doc Simmons, duly elected
delegate from the State of Vermont. I move that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast
one vote representing the entire delegate strength of this convention, and that Daniel A.
Ludwig be elected National Commander by acclamation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? Hearing a second.
There is a motion before us that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote
representing the entire delegate strength of this convention, and that Daniel A. Ludwig be
elected National Commander by acclamation. All those favor of the motion signify by
saying aye; opposed? Ayes have it.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: As National Adjutant, I cast one vote
representing the entire delegate strength of this convention for the election of Daniel A.
Ludwig of Minnesota as the National Commander of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As National Commander and Chairman
of this convention, I declare Daniel A. Ludwig elected National Commander of The
American Legion. Congratulations.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Will the Sergeant-at-Arms assist as the
new National Commander of The American Legion is escorted to the platform by Bill
Barbknecht and Lloyd Ricker.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
177
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes Past National
Commander John Geiger for the purpose of administering the oath of office to our new
National Commander.
PAST NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Commander, this is a very important
moment in this history of The American Legion as we commence another year of service
to our God and Country. As I obligate this National Commander, I ask each of you
American Legionnaires and members of the Auxiliary to personally and privately pledge
yourself to carry out faithfully this year the objectives The American Legion is assigning to
this new National Commander. So, in your hearts and minds, join with us as we introduce
to the American Legion our new National Commander.
Commander, congratulations on your election. If you are prepared to assume the
responsibilities of National Commander, you will please raise your right hand and repeat
after me giving your full name.
I, Daniel A. Ludwig, do solemnly pledge myself, to perform faithfully and
impartially, the duties of the office of National Commander of The
American Legion. I further pledge that I will support and defend the
Constitution of the United States of America, and the National Constitution
and By-Laws of The American Legion. And I do not subscribe to the
principles of any group opposed to our form of government, so help me
God.
NATIONAL COMMANDER GEIGER: Commander, congratulations to you and your
family.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I present to you the 1995-96 National Commander of The
American Legion, Daniel A. Ludwig of Minnesota.
ACCEPTANCE SPEECH
Daniel A. Ludwig, Minnesota
National Commander
1995-1996
[ Commander Ludwig’s speech was often interrupted with applause.]
First of all, I would like to thank Past National Commander Judge Dan Foley for
nominating me. I would also like to thank Tony Jordan and ‘Butch’ Miller for their
seconding speeches. I’m also grateful to Past National Commander John Geiger for
administering the Oath of Office. And most of all, I want to thank each of you for the great
privilege to serve as National Commander.
I proudly accept and promise to serve this great organization and every Legionnaire
to the best of my ability. I have the highest regard and appreciation for Bill Detweiler, his
leadership and his counsel. I will do my best to carry on with the many important things he
has accomplished during his outstanding year as National Commander.
And now I want you to meet my wonderful wife, Mary, and our fine children, Ann and
John. I certainly would have not come to this moment without their love, their
understanding and their support. Also here with me is my sister, Mary, and her husband,
Ron Sadlowsky.
Permit me to say thank you to Post 54 in Red Wing, Minnesota, and the entire
178
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
Minnesota Legion family for their encouragement and their support. It means so very much
to me. I’m also most grateful for the friendship and assistance of my aid, Jerry Diercks and
his wife, Rosie, as well as my campaign secretary, Shirley Perkins, and her husband, Bob,
and my campaign chairman, Don Shradel.
Each one of these people I mentioned has one thing in common with each other and
with all of you. They believe in service, service to their families and to one another, to The
American Legion, to their communities and to our nation. That’s because they’re part of
The American Legion family. Service is not just an idea, it is not just a word. Service is
action, service is being involved. It’s assisting veterans and their families, it’s helping
youngsters to become good citizens. Service is making our communities better places to
live. And it’s about keeping our nation strong and free.
The Legion is about doing what is necessary to make all these things happen. We’ve
been doing it for 76 years. Our main theme this year sums up everything I’m talking about.
The American Legion is still serving America. I repeat, the American Legion is still serving
America.
My remarks today will not be lengthy. However I’m going to briefly mention four
things that are critically important to us at this time. The first is absolutely essential to
everything that we do, for without it we cannot keep on serving America. We need the
strength of numbers. I’m talking about membership, and I’m going to talk about it all year
long. Our ability to carry out the great programs we’ve had for so many years for veterans,
for children and youth, for the community and for America depends on one thing our
strength of membership.
For many years, we have had strength and influence at home and on Capitol Hill for
one reason only. We are the largest veterans’ organization there is, and everyone knows we
represent the broad cross-section of America from all walks of life including all political,
economic, religious and racial backgrounds. We must maintain that strength and influence.
The recent decrease in our membership is over. We shall turn it around this year.
Each and every Legionnaire has to be an active, person-to-person recruiter, and we
must recognize that the makeup of our membership is going to be changing. There are more
young veterans including women veterans as well as current active duty servicemen and
women who are all eligible to join The American Legion. We need to seek out every
eligible veteran, young or old, male or female, regardless of race, creed or color. We need
to recruit them as active members, and we must make them feel welcome as part of The
American Legion family. We must also encourage them to play a leading role in our
organization.
At this time, our Posts must play an active role in the lives of these young veterans as
well as all our members. These are our sons and grandsons, our daughters and
granddaughters. They face the same problems and needs as we and all previous generations
who served and fought for their country. These newer veterans deserve the opportunities
provided by a decent GI Bill just like veterans of days gone by.
The American Legion is a place where they can find support for all these things. Our
Posts must be a place where they can help their community, where veterans can help other
veterans, and where they can help themselves. American Legion Posts must become
sanctuaries for active duty men and women who need a place to call home. Wherever they
go, the Legion welcome mat must be out. That’s how we’ll gain new members, that’s how
we’ll maintain our strength and our influence. Legionnaires, 1996 will be the year we go
back over the 3 million mark in membership!
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
179
While the character of our membership may be changing, let us not forget that for over
50 years The American Legion has been fortunate to have at its core a generation of the most
patriotic and service-minded veterans that history has ever known, the veterans of World
War II. We are now coming to the conclusion of the five-year period commemorating the
50th anniversary of World War II. This National Convention has been totally dedicated to
them and their honorable service in that great war. The World War II veterans have been
the mainstay of this organization for a long time. They have made certain that we have
steadfastly carried on with the principles and the programs that come from the vision of our
Legion founders, the veterans of World War I. But it is up to every one of us, no matter
where or when we served, to carry on that legacy and to pass it on to the new veterans who
join us.
A few weeks ago, I was proud to attend the dedication of the memorial to the Korean
War veterans. We all know that’s been called ‘the forgotten war.’ We in The American
Legion do not forget any war or any veteran, whether it be from World War I, World War
II, Korea, Vietnam, Lebanon, Granada, Panama or the Persian Gulf. By our very preamble,
we preserved the memories and incidents of our associations in the great wars, because a
veteran is a veteran regardless of the branch or period of service. None should be slighted.
And all should be made welcome in The American Legion.
Taking care of veterans is a principle reason for The American Legion’s existence, and
veterans’ health care has been one of our primary concerns. For too long, the VA health
care system has struggled because of too little money and too many complicated eligibility
rules. Many veterans who would use the VA health care system are turned away because
of these restrictions. The American Legion has constantly lobbied Congress to give VA
enough money to provide the type of medical care that veterans deserve. But the VA budget
which Congress approves each year doesn’t even begin to keep pace with the rising cost of
medical care.
Another problem is that the VA is not permitted to receive money from insurance, such
as Medicare or Medicaid when it treats eligible veterans who are covered by these programs.
Five years ago, The American Legion suggested a plan to improve the VA health care
system and reform its unfair eligibility rules. Those proposals were contained in our ‘Gold
Book’ and our ‘Silver Book.’
At this convention, Resolution Numberl41 contains proposed legislation language to
achieve this new, revolutionary reform of the entire VA health care system. This new
proposal completely revamps the way VA delivers health care to our nation’s veterans. It
would do away with those unfair and restrictive eligibility rules in order to open up a system
to all veterans and their families. And it would provide new methods of funding. This
proposal will be among our top priorities when I testify before the House and Senate
Veterans Affairs Committee later this month.
Finally, I want to say a few words about our Number 1 priority, our campaign for a
Constitutional Amendment to protect our flag from willful, physical desecration. We have
come a long way in the last six years. But the toughest part of our fight still lies ahead. The
vote in the U.S. Senate on the flag amendment is likely to be taken soon, and just because
the measure was overwhelmingly approved in the House of Representatives in June doesn’t
mean we can relax and expect an easy victory in the Senate.
Far from it. We’ve got to keep working until we get the 67 votes we need for Senate
approval. You’ve already heard much about the details of our mission and which Senators
we must convince to join us. But we must all go home from this convention determined to
180
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
contact our Senators by phone and by mail, regardless of whether they have announced their
support or not. In fact, you still have a chance to stop by the Citizens Flag Alliance phone
bank and postcard station in the convention center to make those contacts.
Solidify and reaffirm your Senator’s support and be sure to thank them for their
backing, even if you have done it before. Or persuade them to approve the proposed
amendment, to send back to the states allowing the voice of the people to be heard through
the ratification process, mindful that the Constitution must change with the times. A
hallmark of this democracy is to keep government close to the people.
The overwhelming number of American people support us in this endeavor. We are
so close to victory. Protecting the American Flag from physical desecration shall be our
greatest victory. We must press forward. This achievement will let everyone know that The
American Legion is still serving America.
Again, I thank you for the confidence and the trust you have placed in me. God bless
you, God bless The American Legion and may God bless America.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Microphone No. 6.
DELEGATE PAUL A. MORIN, (MASSACHUSETTS): Mr. Commander, Paul A.
Morin, Delegate, Department of Massachusetts. Since the rules of this convention have
been suspended, I move that the nominations for the Office of National Vice Commander
be made from the floor of this convention. I so move.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? All those in favor
signify by the sign of Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone 1.
. .. Entertaining nominations for National Vice Commander.
DELEGATE KEN LAMOW, (IOWA): Mr. Chairman, Ken Lamow, Delegate
Chairman from the State of Iowa, wishes to yield the microphone to Ken Danielson for the
purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: You are recognized the purpose of a
nomination.
DELEGATE KEN DANILSON, (IOWA): As a duly elected Delegate from the
Department of Iowa, I have the distinct honor to nominate Keith Baker, a dedicated
Legionnaire to the high office of Vice Commander of The American Legion.
Keith was born and raised in rural Iowa. He entered military service in September,
1946, and served until February, 1969. Keith worked his way up through the ranks and
achieved the grade of Major and a Senior Pilot rating. His service in Vietnam in 1966 and
1967 earned him the Air Medal with five oak leaf clusters and the Distinguished Flying
Cross. In 1969, Keith retired to a small farm in northwest Iowa.
While a farmer, Keith also served as a state representative in the Iowa legislature, as
mayor of the city of Linn Grove, Boyna County supervisor and as a Director of the Iowa
Department of Veteran Affairs. He has since returned to his farm where he and his wife,
Betty, run a Christmas tree operation.
Keith is an active, paid-up-for-life member and has served in many positions with the
local post, county, department and national Legion organizations.
At the district level, he was 9th District Commander, 1979-80, served on the
Resolutions, Legislative and Constitutional Committees and presently serves as chairman
of the district POW/MIA Committee and is district Boys State Chairman.
In the Iowa Department, Keith has served as Chairman of the Internal Security
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
181
Committee, National Affairs Commission and the Legislative Commission. He presently
serves as chairman of the POW/MIA Committee and is a member of the Long-Range
Planning Committee. He serves on the board of directors of The American Legion Bible
Foundation and has been an Iowa Boys State counselor for the past nine years.
On the national level, Keith has served on the Foreign Relations Commission since
1976 and has been vice chairman of that commission since 1981. He is chairman of the Far
East Foreign Affairs Subcommittee within the commission and served as chair of the United
Nations study group. He is a past chairman of the national POW/MIA Committee, serving
in that position since its inception in 1981 to 1991. He has attended every National
Convention of The American Legion since 1974.
Keith presently resides in Linn Grove, Iowa, with his wife, Betty. They have three
grown children and four grandsons. On behalf of the Iowa Legion, it is both an honor and
privilege to place in nomination, Keith Baker for the high office of National Vice
Commander of The American Legion for the year 1995-96.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Keith Baker’s name has been placed in
nomination for the Office of National Vice Commander.
Any other nominations?
Microphone 6.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN DONALD COLE, JR., MAINE: Comrade Commander,
Donald Cole, Delegate Chairman, Department Commander for this convention. Great state
of Maine, home of Past National Commander Bill Rogers, requests permission for Maine’s
Ralph Smart to approach the podium for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Permission is granted for the purpose of
a nomination.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN RALPH SMART, MAINE: Thank you, Commander
Detweiler, Commander Ludwig, National Officers, Delegates and guests. It’s with great
pride and extreme pleasure to present in nomination for the National Vice Commander the
name of a Korean and Vietnam Era veteran, a 22 year retiree of the United States Air Force.
Maine’s candidate has been an active Legionnaire at all levels. He served as Maine’s
Department Commander in 1980-81; Department Service Officer in 1987; and Alternate
Executive Committeeman, 1988 and 1990. He is currently serving as Maine’s NEC, a
position he’s held since 1990. He currently serves as the Vice Chairman of the National
Legislative Council.
‘Chick’ is married. He and his wife have four grown children, and seven
grandchildren.
‘Chick’ is a dedicated Legionnaire with a deep and sincere desire to serve The
American Legion from a National level as a National Vice Commander. He wants to bring
to The American Legion, his deep and abiding spirit of comradeship. His legislative and
membership experience will help him bring an exciting voice to these programs.
On behalf of the 27,000 Legionnaires of the Department of Maine, I wish to place in
nomination the name of a Legion member from Post 202 in Topsham, Maine, William L.
Ciciotte.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of William L. Ciciotte has
been placed in nomination for National Vice Commander.
Microphone 4.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN WILLIAM BOYER, OREGON: Mr. Commander, my
name is Bill “Boyer, Delegate Chairman from the Department of Oregon. I would ask that
the Chair please recognize our National Executive Committeeman, T. Les Galloway, for the
182
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: T. Les Galloway is recognized for the
purpose of a nomination.
NECman T. LES GALLOWAY, OREGON: Commander Detweiler, Commander
Ludwig, National Officers, both past and present, my fellow Delegates, alternates and
guests. My name is T. Les Galloway. I am a duly authorized Delegate from the great
Department of Oregon.
It is indeed an honor and a special privilege for me this afternoon to present a great
friend and fellow Legionnaire from the Department of Oregon to the high office of National
Vice Commander.
Robert D. "Bob" Scott is a 33 year member of Sanian Post 51 in Lebanon, Oregon. A
U.S. Air Force veteran where he served from 1952 to 1965 as a flight mechanic and line
chief during the Korean and the Vietnam Eras.
Bob has served Post 51 in many capacities, including Judge Advocate,
Sergeant-At-Arms, Chaplain, First and Second Vice Commander, and was a Post All-TimeHigh Commander in 1978-79. He has served equally as well on the District level, including
Rehab Chairman, Legislative Chairman, Judge Advocate, District Vice Commander, and
was an All Time High District Commander in 1979-80.
Bob has served the Department of Oregon on many commissions and committees, and
was elected Department Vice Commander in 1981, and served as Department Commander
in 1982-83.
Bob is currently serving as the Chairman of the Citizens Flag Alliance Team in Oregon.
He was instrumental in getting the Oregon legislature just this year to pass a memorializing
resolution to protect the Flag from desecration. He has served the National organization on
the Distinguished Guest Committee, National Legislative Council, Children and Youth
Commission, and has served as Oregon’s Alternate NECman for the past nine years.
His community activities have been many and varied, and 1 will only mention a few,
including the City of Lebanon Planning Commission; City Councilman; Citizen Veteran of
the Year; manager of the Lebanon Chamber of Commerce, and was appointed by three
different governors in Oregon on the Advisory Committee to the Director of the Oregon
Department of Veterans Affairs Board.
In addition, he has served as Chairman of the Veterans Rehab Centers in Oregon,
California and Washington. He is a member of the United Veterans Group of Oregon, the
DAV, Air Force Sergeants Association, a Past Governor of the Pacific Northwest District
of Optimist International, covering Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Alaska and British
Columbia.
He and his wife Clara, who is very active in the American Legion Auxiliary, are the
proud parents of two children, Catherine and Larry, and have seven grandchildren and three
great grandchildren. In addition, Bob and his wife Clara raised 23 foster children. He is
self-employed and owns and operates Scott Enterprises and Marketing in Lebanon.
His great love for The American Legion and its programs, and his qualifications and
past record of achievements, assures us a strong capable leadership. It is, therefore, my
pleasure and honor to place in nomination the name of Robert D. "Bob" Scott for the office
of National Vice Commander for the 1995-1996 Legion year.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Robert D. Scott has been
placed in nomination for National Vice Commander.
Microphone 6.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
183
DELEGATE DON MASON, SOUTH DAKOTA: Mr. Commander, I’m Don Mason,
Delegate from South Dakota, and I request the Chair recognize Donald Clarke, National
Executive Committeeman from South Dakota, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Don Clarke is recognized for the purpose
of a nomination..
NECman DONALD T. CLARKE, SOUTH DAKOTA: National Commander
Detweiler, distinguished guests and friends, and the Delegates to this 77th Annual
Convention assembled in Indianapolis this afternoon. It is with a great deal of pride to have
the rare privilege to place in nomination for the high office of National Vice Commander
a close friend of mine, as well as an outstanding Legionnaire, who has already proven
himself as an outstanding Legion leader in our Department and also on the National level.
It is with a great deal of pleasure this afternoon that I place in nomination to this
Convention, Darrel Haskell for National Vice Commander.
I’m going to highlight just a few of the achievements that Darrel has already
accomplished as a Legionnaire and a community leader in his home community in Conde,
South Dakota.
Darrel served as our State Commander in 1986, the year that Dale Renaud was our
National Commander. Darrel is a 42 year veteran and continuous member of The American
Legion in South Dakota. He has continuous membership and has a Life membership in our
department.
Those years have been veiy busy years for Darrel. After completing all of the offices
in his Post, District, Area, and becoming our Department Commander in 1967, he began
editing and publishing a Post paper for his Post. And he has continued to do that for 25
years, finally conceding and delegating that duty to a young Vietnam veteran in his Legion
Post.
Yes, he has held offices on all the levels in our Department. Darrel served on South
Dakota’s 50th Anniversary Committee and our Spirit of ‘76 Committee, chairing both of
those committees. He was Chairman of South Dakota’s Vietnam Era study in 1984,
working with John Sommer, who went on to become the Executive Director of our National
Office in Washington, D.C. He is a member of the National American Legion Press
Association and has served as their Sergeant-At-Arms.
This Legionnaire, friend and comrade of mine, has been a Delegate to more than 20
National Conventions with more and more of the many National assignments that go with
those Conventions.
Darrel has served for many years as a member of the National
Cemetery Committee.
Darrel was bom and raised in Conde, South Dakota, and he’s lived there all of his life.
His profession is in the field of agriculture. We call that farming in South Dakota; it is a
very demanding way to make a living. But Darrel has always found the time to be an active
community leader, serving on the many committees and the many assignments that come
from the town and the community. For example he has been on the Board of Education and
has served as Chairman of the Trustees of the United Methodist Church in Conde.
And perhaps best of all, he and his wife Joyce have five children and eleven
grandchildren. I know personally that Joyce and his family are dedicated and active in their
Legion and Auxiliary activities wherever they may be.
We in the Department of South Dakota are very, very proud of Darrel Haskell. We
know that with his dedication and his talent, he will make an outstanding National Vice
Commander. He will contribute much to National Commander Ludwig’s upcoming year
184
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
as he joins Dan’s team. It is now my distinct pleasure to officially place in nomination the
name of Darrel Haskell for National Vice Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Darrel Haskell has been
placed in nomination.
Microphone 4.
DELEGATION CHAIRMAN JOE YOUNG, TENNESSEE: Mr. Commander, Joe
Young, Delegate Chairman from the Department of Tennessee. We request you recognize
our National Executive Committeeman, John L. Jones, for the purpose of a nomination.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Chair recognizes John Jones for the
purpose of a nomination for National Vice Commander.
NECman JOHN L. JONES, TENNESSEE: I am John Jones, the NECman from the
state of Tennessee. I place in nomination Ralph J. Reel, a Past Department Commander
from the Volunteer State of Tennessee, and wish him well. I know he will do a first class
job that Vice Commanders are expected to do.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The name of Ralph Reel has been placed
in nomination.
DELEGATE THOMAS HENDERSON, INDIANA: Tom Henderson, Delegate from
Indiana. Mr. Commander, I move that nominations for the office of National Vice
Commander be closed.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Is there a second? All those in favor
signify by the sign of Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it.
Microphone No. 4.
DELEGATE JOHN A. BRIEDAN, TEXAS: Mr. Commander, John Briedan,
Department Commander of the great state of Texas, and a duly authorized Delegate to this
Convention. I move that the National Adjutant be authorized to cast one vote for the entire
Delegate strength of this Convention, and that Keith Baker from the Department of Iowa;
William Ciciotte from the Department of Maine; Robert Scott from the Department of
Oregon; Darrel Haskell from the Department of South Dakota, and Ralph Reel from the
Department of Tennessee be elected National Vice Commanders by acclamation.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: There is a motion and a second. Any
discussion? All those in favor say Aye. Opposed? Ayes have it. The Adjutant will cast
one vote.
NATIONAL ADJUTANT SPANOGLE: As National Adjutant of The American
Legion, I cast one vote representing the entire Delegate strength of this Convention for Keith
Baker of Iowa; William L. Ciciotte of Maine; Robert D. Scott of Oregon; C. Darrel Haskell
of South Dakota, and Ralph J. Reel of Tennessee for the offices of National Vice
Commander of The American Legion.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: As Chairman of this Delegation to this
Convention, I now declare the following Legionnaires have been elected National Vice
Commanders of The American Legion:
Keith Baker of Iowa.
William L. Ciciotte of Maine.
Robert D. Scott of Oregon.
C. Darrel Haskell of South Dakota.
Ralph J. Reel of Tennessee.
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
185
I now call on Harlowe Johnson of Minnesota to present the Colors to our Incoming
National Commander. Mr. Johnson.
DELEGATE HARLOWE JOHNSON, (MINNESOTA): Delegates, it’s a great personal
privilege and honor to be representing the great Department of Minnesota in this
presentation ceremony. The audience will please rise as the Color Guard presents the Colors
to the Incoming National Commander of The American Legion.
... Hand Salute.
DELEGATE HARLOWE JOHNSON, (MINNESOTA): Audience may be seated.
National Commander Ludwig, all your comrades join in congratulating you upon your
election as National Commander. We, in Minnesota, are extremely proud to have one of our
distinguished Legionnaires as National Commander of this great organization. By your
dedication and unselfish service, you have brought honor to your Post, to the Third District,
and to the Department of Minnesota. We know that you will continue this dedication as you
embark upon your duties as our National Commander.
We presented these Colors, the glorious Flag of the United States, and the National
Colors of The American Legion, guarding it against the forces that would physically
desecrate it in the name of human rights. As you assume the duties and responsibilities of
your office, we are confident that you will use all your talents and efforts to maintain the
respect and the dignity that our flag deserves.
We are fully confident that in your hands, the flag of our country and the National
Colors of The American Legion will continue to wave ever so proudly from your year of
service.
Commander Dan, take with you our best wishes for God’s blessing and protection as
you answer the summons to this call to service as our National Commander.
NATIONAL COMMANDER-ELECT LUDWIG: To my good friend, Harlow
Johnson, thank you for presenting my Colors to me.
Keenly aware of the service and sacrifice of those National Commanders before me and
mindful of the rich history of The American Legion, I accept these Colors with pride and
with humility. I pledge to all assembled here that I will cherish and protect them always.
And I further pledge that while I have life, these Colors will not run and while I have breath
these Colors shall not touch the ground. Thank you.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Chair recognizes the Commander of
Minnesota for a presentation.
COMMANDER PERSING: Mary, on behalf of the extended family from the
Department of Minnesota, I present these flowers to you. Congratulations and good luck in
the coming year.
MRS. LUDWIG: Thank you one and all.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Fellow Legionnaires, this is a special
time in the business of this convention. The time when we will meet the distinguished lady
who will lead nearly one million patriotic women over the next year. You can imagine my
honor in presenting a fellow resident of Louisiana to you. I believe she will be a highly
visible leader, md will focus her efforts on the incoming year toward women’s shelters,
caring for the elderly and disabled, community housing needs and youth projects.
Please welcome the newly elected national president of the American Legion Auxiliary
from Lake Charles Williamson Unit No. 1 in Louisiana, Mrs. Syble Deshotel. Syble.
186
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
SYBLE DESHOTEL
American Legion Auxiliary President
1995-1996
Before I present some special people who came with me this morning, I would like to
tell you that as Bill and I were beating the bushes and acting like candidates, someone asked
me to serve on another committee in the same year? My answer was, oh, no. We want The
American Legion to have a dynamic man from Louisiana one year and then go in on the
second year and have a President from the Department of Louisiana. By the time we get
finished with you, you’ll all be Cajuns.
With me today is my husband I.J., my veteran and my support, my best friend.
Also is the newly installed National Vice President Phyllis Buckman of New York and
the National Secretary of the American Legion Auxiliary, Peggy Sappenfield, from the
Department of Indiana.
Today is a day for pledges and oaths of office. I come to you today to pledge my
abilities and my knowledge as the American Legion Auxiliary’s National President, but I
also pledge that as one family, the almost 1 million members of the American Legion
Auxiliary will be at your side to work in all the programs and activities of both of our
organizations. I think we have some wonderful things to do as we climb on that train
heading toward the 21st century. It’s a fast-running train, but I think we can handle it.
Dan, I congratulate you. Legionnaires, I congratulate you on your selection as National
Commander. Dan and I have had a chance to get to know each other, and I’m sure as we
travel, he and I and Mary and I.J. will get to know each other so much better. But I have
already coined him as a Legionnaire’s Legionnaire.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Madame President, would you please
remain with us for a few moments. I want the delegates of this convention to greet you and
our newly elected National Commander. Ladies and Gentlemen, National Commander Dan
Ludwig and National President Syble Deshotel.
NATIONAL COMMANDER-ELECT COMMANDER LUDWIG: Ladies and
Gentlemen, I truly look forward to working with this wonderful, gracious lady and all the
ladies of the Auxiliary as we continue to work together as a Legion and Legion Auxiliary
family.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: Immediately following the adjournment
of this meeting there will be a Post-NEC meeting right after the convention. Is there any
further business to come before this convention?
Please uncover as the outgoing National Chaplain, the Reverend Roy Pryor, Jr., of
South Carolina offers the Benediction.
BENEDICTION
Reverend Roy L. Pryor, South Carolina
National Chaplain
Let us pray.
Most Holy Father, You have granted us a wonderful year under the capable leadership
of Commander William Detweiler and his capable staff. We offer our sincere thanks for
this, and now, we, as a body at this time, ask You to give unto our new Commander Daniel
Ludwig and his staff, Your blessings. That, as they work together under their leadership,
Proceedings of Wednesday, September 6, 1995
187
we may continue to help others in this great organization, The American Legion. So now
I say unto you, go in peace, my comrades and friends, and may the God of peace watch over
you and keep you, not only this day, but forever more. Amen.
NATIONAL COMMANDER DETWEILER: The Color Guard will retire the Flag of
the United States. The delegates will stand at right-hand salute on my command.
... Hand Salute.
With great pleasure, I now declare the 77th Annual National Convention of The
American Legion adjourned, sine die.
... At 1:12 p.m., the 77th Annual National Convention of The American Legion adjourned.
189
ANNOUNCEMENT OF ANNUAL AWARDS
National American Legion Distinguished Service Medal Award: Awarded annually for
outstanding service to the nation and to the programs of The American Legion.
WINNER: The Enola Gay Crew
The Henry D. Lindsley Trophy: Awarded annually to the Department attaining the
highest percentage of membership over its preceding year's membership by March 31.
WINNER: North Dakota (92.45%)
The North Carolina Trophy: Awarded annually to the Department, not included among
the several state Departments or the Department of the District of Columbia, attaining the
highest percentage of membership as of March 31, over its preceding year's membership.
WINNER: Mexico (126.62%)
General Henri Gouraud Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department in each of six
categories established by the National Membership and Post Activities Committee, each of
said Department having been the first in its respective category to attain or exceed its
nationally assigned membership quota (effective 1986).
WINNERS:
Category None
Category IINone
Category IIINone
Category IVNone
Category VNone
Category VINone
The O. L. Bodenhamer Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department designated to lead
the parade at the time of the ensuing National Convention.
WINNER: Delaware (99.24%)
General John J. Pershing Honor Award: Awarded annually to that Department having
the greatest percentage of its posts receiving the Honor Ribbon for having 100 percent or
more, of the post's previous year's membership enrolled for the coming year by December
31, and having reported such achievement to National Headquarters by not later than
January 31.
WINNER: Delaware (31.25%)
The Arthur D. Houghton Sons of The American Legion Trophy: Awarded annually to
that Detachment of Sons of The American Legion in each of three membership size
categories (I - 1-999 members; II- 1,000-2,000 members; III - 3,000 members or more), each
of said Detachments attaining the greatest percentage of increase over previous year's
membership when compared with all Detachments in its category.
1994 WINNERS: (I)
Arkansas
162.7%
(II) West Virginia
129.2%
(III) Pennsylvania
113.5%
The Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department which has
190
rendered the most outstanding service during the year to the program of the Boy Scouts of
America.
WINNER: Maryland
The Ralph T. O'Neil Education Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department within the
continental limits in the United States showing the greatest Americanism activity in use of
The American Legion School Medal Awards.
WINNER: Florida
William Randolph Hearst Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department attaining the
greatest number of percentage points compiled from information contained in the
Consolidated Post Reports, and supporting Department narrative.
WINNER: Vermont
Spafford National Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department of The American
Legion having within its jurisdiction the winner of the National High School Oratorical
Contest.
WINNER: New York (Aron Egner, Ballston Lake, NY)
The Howard P. Savage Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department having the baseball
team which becomes the Champion as a result of playing in The American Legion World
Series.
WINNER: Hawaii (Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii), outside sponsor
Commissioner of Baseball Trophy: Awarded annually at the Major League World Series
to that baseball team which becomes the National Champion as a result of playing in The
American Legion World Series.
WINNER: Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Dr. Irvin L. "Click" Cowger Memorial R.B.I. Award: Awarded annually to The
American Legion Baseball player who is credited with the most runs batted in by the official
scorers of the respective regional tournaments and World Series of American Legion
Baseball.
WINNER:
Bobby Morgan, Post 19, Columbia, TN &
Dorn Crispo, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
Rawlings "Big Stick" Award: Awarded annually to that American Legion Baseball player
having the highest total number of bases as determined by the official scorers of the
respective regional tournaments and World Series of American Legion Baseball.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Bob Feller Award: Awarded annually to that American Legion Baseball player recording
the greatest number of strikeouts during the regional tournaments and World Series of
American Legion Baseball.
WINNER: Woody Heath, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
Jack Williams Memorial Leadership Award: Awarded annually to the manager and
191
coach of the national championship team, as representative of the adult leadership Jack
Williams stressed during his lifetime.
WINNERS:
Manager Alan Higuchi, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Coaches Garrett Mago & Garret Yukumoto Aiea Legion Baseball,
Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
Louisville Slugger Trophy: Plaque is presented to recipient, or designated representative,
by appropriate official upon the conclusion of The American Legion Baseball World Series.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
George W. Rulon Baseball Player of the Year: Plaque is presented to recipient by
appropriate official upon conclusion of The American Legion Baseball World Series.
Citation is presented to recipient at a special Hall of Fame ceremony at Cooperstown, NY,
the following summer.
WINNER: Jason Adaro, Aiea Legion Baseball, Inc., Aiea, Hawaii
James F. Daniel, Jr. Memorial Sportsmanship Award: Awarded to The American
Legion Baseball player participating in the World Series that represents the principle of
good sportsmanship emphasized by the program.
WINNER: Woody Heath, outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA
American Legion Baseball Graduate of The Year Award: Presented to the major league
baseball player who played American Legion Baseball as a teenager and best exemplifies
the principles and purposes of the program in sportsmanship, citizenship, general good
conduct, integrity, and playing ability.
WINNER: Bob Tewksbury, Texas Ranger
Ford C. Frick Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department having within its jurisdiction
the runner-up team in the National Finals of The American Legion Baseball program.
WINNER: Washington (outside sponsor, Bellevue, WA)
The Lemuel Bolles Trophy: Awarded annually to that band winning first prize in
competition with all other bands during the annual National Convention.
WINNER:
American Legion Band of the Tonawandas, Post 264, Tonawanda,
New York
The Arch M. Cantrall Trophy: Awarded annually to that American Legion Band winning
first prize in competition with all other American Legion bands during the annual National
Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER:
American Legion Band of the Tonawandas, Post 264, Tonawanda, New
York
The Four Chaplains Trophy: Awarded annually to the winner of The American Legion
Firing Squad competition at the National Convention.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
The Glen R. Hillis Trophy: Awarded annually to that Color Guard winning first prize in
192
competition with all other Color Guards during the annual National Convention of The
American Legion.
WINNER: Speedway Post 500 Honor Guard; Speedway, Indiana
Emblem Sales Trophy: To be awarded annually to that Junior sponsored Color Guard
winning first prize in competition with all other Junior sponsored Color Guards during the
annual National Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
National Adjutant's Trophy: Awarded annually to that American Legion Firing Squad
winning first prize in competition with all other Firing Squads during the annual National
Convention of The American Legion.
WINNER: No Contest in 1995
Fourth Estate Award: Awarded to press, radio, TV, or other communications media; to
associations of same, to owners, executive heads or staff members; such award to be in
recognition of outstanding service to community, state, or nation, which service shall have
been in accordance with or the furtherance of established American Legion policies and
programs.
WINNER:
Marcia Stepanek & Charles J. Lewis,
Hearst Newspapers, Washington
Bureau/Albany Times Union
National Commander's Public Relations Award: Awarded to an outstanding individual
and/or organization for distinguished public service in the field of communications.
WINNER: To be presented at '96 DC Conference
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy: Awarded annually to that State Department
of The American Legion excelling in welfare work for war veterans, providing the
membership of that Department shall be no less than 80% of the membership of the
preceding year.
WINNER: Ohio
The American Legion Military Academy Award: Awarded annually to cadet of the
graduating class at the United States Military Academy with the highest standing in
Chemistry.
WINNER: Garth S. Herbert, West Point, New York
The American Legion Naval Academy Award: Awarded annually to that graduating
midshipman of the United States Naval Academy who stands highest in those English,
History and Government courses taken to complete a Foreign Affairs major.
WINNER: Benjamin A. Shupp, Houston, Texas
The American Legion Coast Guard Academy Award: Awarded annually to that cadet
of the graduating class of the United States Coast Guard Academy who is considered to have
personally excelled in athletics.
WINNER: Cadet Blake L. Novak, New London, CT
193
The American Legion Air Force Academy Award: Awarded annually to that cadet of the
graduating class at the Air Force Academy who demonstrates the highest proficiency in all
academic subjects.
WINNER: Douglas P. Wickert, Beavercreek, Ohio
The American Legion Merchant Marine Academy Award: Awarded annually to that
graduating midshipman of the Merchant Marine Academy, enrolled in the PreCommissioning Seminar Course, and selected by the Academy Faculty, as achieving the
highest grade pertaining to a 1,000 word composition dealing with the subject of National
Security.
WINNER: Award Not Presented in 1995*
* No midshipman fulfilled the criteria for award
Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy: Awarded annually to that Department giving the highest
degree of support to the ROTC program within its jurisdiction, based on criteria drawn up
by the National Security Commission.
WINNERS: Alabama, Alaska, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia,
Hawaii, Illinois, Nevada, New York, Oregon, Puerto Rico, Rhode
Island, and Vermont
National Department History Contest Awards: Awarded annually at the Fall Meeting
of the National Executive Committee to those contestants entered in the National
Department History Contest having submitted the One-Year History Narrative or Yearbook
of the Department which best meets the standards established for that particular competition.
WINNERS: North Carolina
(One-Year Narrative History)
Hawaii
(One-Year Yearbook History)
National Post History Contest Awards: Awarded annually to those contestants entered
in the National Post History Contest deemed by a duly authorized panel of judges to have
submitted the One-Year History of the Post which best meets the standards established for
the competitions.
WINNERS: Hartford Post 26, White River Jet., Vermont
(One-Year Narrative History)
Kirby Stewart Post 24, Bradenton, Florida
(One-Year Yearbook History)
International Amity Award: Awarded by the National Commander with the advice and
consent of the National Executive Committee at such times and places as may be consistent
and appropriate.
WINNERS: Tae-Wan Chang (Republic of Korea)
Emmanual V. DeOcampo (Philippines)
Yang Ting-Yun (Republic of China)
194
Canadian Friendship Award: Awarded by the National Commander with the advice and
consent of the National Executive Committee at such times and places as may be consistent
and appropriate.
WINNERS: Norman H. Baildham
Tom Barton
Gerald Belanger
Terry Buchanan
Brent G. Burns
Robert Carslaw
Norah Fyfe
Bernard Halstead
Albert Himes
Onesime Lanteigne
Douglas J. Loukes
John William Newman
Robert C. Simser
Department Award for 100% Post Children & Youth Reporting: Awarded annually to
those Departments which achieve 100% of Posts indicating Children & Youth activity on
Consolidated Post reports.
WINNERS: Delaware, Florida, North Dakota, Vermont, & Virginia
Employer of the Year Award for Hiring Veterans: Awarded to an employer in
recognition of outstanding achievement in the employment and retraining of veterans.
1994 WINNERS:
Category I - Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc.; Mid City,
Oklahoma
Category II
Caldwell Machining, Inc.; Emporium,
Pennsylvania
Category III - Southwest Research Institute; San Antonio, Texas
Employment Service Awards: Awarded in three categories: Local Veterans Employment
Representative (LVER) of the Year; Disabled Veterans Outreach Program Specialist
(DVOP) of the Year; Employment Service (ES) Office of the Year.
1994 WINNERS:
LVER of the Year: Joseph A. Monday; Hudson, Florida
DVOP of the Year: Jerry A. Work; Dade City, Florida
ES Office of the Year: Charles City Workforce Center;
Charles City, Iowa
BALANCE SHEET
December 31,1994
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
EXHIBIT A
Current Fund
Cash
Restricted cash
Agent Orange program
Accounts receivable
Emblem Division
Publications Division
Other
Accrued interest on investments
Inventories
Emblem Division
Publications Division
Prepaid expenses and supplies
Prepaid pension expense
Deferred membership expense
Deferred direct membership solicitation expense
Postal deposits
DECEMBER 31
1994
$ 67,901
26,827
12,525
$ 399,584
26,082
49,805
113,182
1,459,188
2,178,926
123,593
123,575
1,790,430
1,776,730
139,405
1,411,246
240,425
148,879
6,247,793
22,356
3,112,304
55,000
1,293,121
272,305
449.211
5,561,158
136,812
3,549,665
55,000
' 15~622.883
15.220 145
Investments
Segregated for Designated Funds
Segregated for Washington, D. C., building
Other
Investment in subsidiary
Investment in affiliate
Property and equipment
Land—Indianapolis parking lot
Washington, D. C„ real estate
Land
Building
Furniture, fixtures, and equipment in
National Headquarters building, Indianapolis, Ind.
Washington. D. C„ building
12,265,338
682,427
17,561,966
100,887
1,018,714
31,629.332
238,3
1993
11,670,800
557,506
14,916,629
21,050
27,165,985
238,359
80,000
4,116,940
8,149,913
1,366,064
13,951,276
(6,464,405)
7,486,871
54,336,348
7,818,655
1,352,825
13,606,779
(5,185,763)
8,421,016
51.209,884
Nonexpendable Funds
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
Cash
Accrued interest on investments
Investments
49,557
14,262
893,316
41,975
14,398
893,316
949,689
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
Cash
Accrued interest on investments
Investments
5,000
101,656
21,019,232
5,000
129,030
17,881,773
$76,419,371
$70,175,376
Accumulated depreciation and amortization
196
18.015.~BS5
See notes to financial statements.
nmmnoaim
Current Fund
Liabilities
Accounts payable
Cash overdraft
Agent Orange program
Deposits on Emblem merchandise sales
Deferred advertising income
Deferred dues income
Deferred income—direct membership solicitation
Accrued vacation benefits
Provision for health insurance liability
Other liabilities
Due to the Restricted Fund
Due to other restricted funds
Total liabilities
Fund balances
Restricted funds
Oratorical Contest Fund
Other restricted funds
Designated funds
The Restricted Fund
The Reserve Fund
Appropriated funds
Unappropriated
Total fund balances
Nonexpendable Funds
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
Fund balance
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
Due to current fund
Fund balance
DECEMBER 31
1994
$ 3,720,381
562,119
12,525
139,183
75,908
20,812,306
673,907
508,809
45,000
301,130
135,064
1993
$2,815,693
49,805
135,204
113,315
14,058,207
877,040
540,608
44,986
661,624
1,075,000
135,088
20,506.570
240,485
6,156,277
234,566
5,597,390
10,047,621
2,217,718
18,662,101
1,615,725
7,072,190
27,350,016
54,336,348
9,452,725
2,218,075
17,502,756
1,567,188
11,633,370
30,703,314
51,209.884
326,809
20,799,079
$70,175,376
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
Unappropriated
STATEMENT OF REVENUE, EXPENSES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCES:
Current Fund, Year Ended December 31,1994
EXHIBIT B, SHEET 1
Appropriated Funds
Designated and Restricted Funds
REVENUE
National dues
Sales of Emblem items
Advertising revenue
Investment income
Direct membership solicitation
Revenue enhancement
American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation income
Amounts withdrawn from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Other restricted income
Other income
$17,302,920
6,680,617
8,967,975
773,906
1,767,974
790,057
537,035
985,904
375,016
5,795,682
' 43,977,086
48,637
1993
Total Current Fund
$17,302,920
6,680,617
8,967,975
1,560,737
1.767,974
790,057
537,035
1.122,904
680,565
7,234,656
46.645.440
$16,644,736
6,243,759
7,431,341
1,845,957
1,617,808
709,758
544,071
1,112,055
978,112
8,054,290
45,181,887
4.460.472
8,313,609
1,486,830
5,404,621
12,671,711
766,309
1,216,130
5,921,132
4,333,678
2,378,477
7,586,078
60,078.575
8,307.102
939,106
4,690,437
12,326,028
877,145
1,114,565
5,849,385
3,964,910
2,246,687
6,516,640
46,832,005
(1.840,655)
(3,433,135)
(1,650,118)
$ 786,831
$ 48,537
1994
Total Current Fund
137,000
305,549
1,390,437
2,619,817
EXPENSES
Salaries
Employee benefits
Cost of sales
Direct publication expenses
Executive and staff travel
Commission and committee
Operational
Office and postage expenses
Occupancy
Special projects and programs
8,313,609
1,486,830
5,404,621
12,671,711
766,309
1,216,130
5,921,132
4,333,678
2,378,477
3,125,606
4.460.472
46,618,103
Excess (Deficiency) of Operating
Revenue Over Expenses
Equity in Income (Loss) of Wholly Owned Subsidiary
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses
Fund Balances, Beginning of Year
(1.641,017)
79,837
(1,561,180)
48,537
11,633,370
1,567,188
79,837
20,595
(1,840,655)
(3,353,298)
(1,629,523)
17,502,756
30,703,314
28,046,853
Transfer of funds from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
4,285,984
Transfer of funds
(3,000,000)
Fund Balances, End of Year
$7,072,190
See notes to financial statements.
$18,662,101
$27,350,016
$30,703,314
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
STATEMENT OF REVENUE, EXPENSES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCES:
Designated and Restricted Funds, Year Ended December 31,1994
EXHIBIT B, SHEET 2
Designated Funds
Year Ended December 31
The
Restricted
Fund
Oratorical
Contest
Fund
The
Reserve
Fund
Other
Restricted
Funds
(continued)
REVENUE
$786,831
Investment income
Amounts withdrawn from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Restricted contributions
Other income
137,000
305,549
305,549
1,390,437
1,390,437
1,887,921
2,619,817
4,329,034
4,460,115
EXPENSE
357
Sundry expense
Special projects and programs
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue
Over Expenses
Fund Balances, Beginning of Year
Transfer of funds
Fund Balances, End of Year
See notes to financial statements.
Total
Designated
& Restricted
Funds
4,329,034
594,896
(357)
5,919
(2,441,113)
(1,840,655)
9,452,725
2,218,075
234,566
5,597,390
17,502,756
3,000,000
3,000,000
$6,156,277
$18,662,101
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
Increase (Decrease) in Cash, Year Ended December 31,1994
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
EXHIBIT C
Current Fund
Overseas Graves Decoration Trust
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fees
1994 Total
OPERATING ACTIVITIES
Excess (deficiency) of revenue over expenses
Depreciation charged to operations not requiring cash
Equity in income of subsidiary
(Gain) loss on sale of investments
Loss from sale of fixed assets
Certain working capital transactions
Restricted cash
Accounts receivable
Accrued interest on investments
Inventories
Prepaid expenses and supplies
Deferred expenses
Accounts payable
$(3,353,298)
1,318,354
$ 7,446
$2,783,276
(79,837)
39,047
1,447
(384,129)
(745)
(60,561)
15,812
136
27.374
(86,245)
(386,303)
551,817
904,688
Due to current fund
326,809
$(108,871)
1,318,354
1,299.163
(79,837)
(345,082)
(20,594)
377,820
1.447
24,835
(745)
(60,561)
43.322
350,949
(1.053,157)
54,202
(86,245)
(386,303)
(203.347)
(1,032.303)
551,817
(650,634)
904,688
326,809
Restricted grant
Deposits on emblem merchandise sales
Deferred advertising
3,979
(37,407)
Funds in transit to American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Deferred income
6,550,966
Accrued vacation
Other liabilities
(31,799)
(360,504)
Total provided (used) by operations
4,989,411
7,582
2.753,330
1993 Total
$(562,576)
106,395
3,979
(37,407)
(348,942)
(62,162)
64,969
6,550,966
(2,523)
978,043
(31.799)
950
(360,504)
7,750,323
70,392
(154,815)
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Additions to property and equipment
Proceeds from sale of fixed assets
Transfer of funds from The American Legion Life Insurance Plan
Purchases of investments
Sales of investments
Total provided (used) by investing activities
(385,816)
(385,816)
160
(254,159)
160
1,329
(19,676,500)
15,253,943
(27,433,542)
24,680,212
(47,110,042)
39,934,155
4,285,984
(27,964,980)
25,500,128
(4,808,213)
(2,753,330)
(7,561,543)
1,568,302
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Payments on restricted fund note
Cash overdrafts
Total used by financing activities
INCREASE(DECREASE) IN CASH
(1,075,000)
562,119
(512,881)
(1,075,000)
(900,000)
562,119
(512,881)
(129,209)
(1,029,209)
(324,101)
384,278
(331,683)
7,582
CASH, BEGINNING OF YEAR
399,584
41,975
5,000
446,559
62,281
CASH,END OF YEAR
$ 67,901
$ 49,557
S 5,000
$ 122,458
$ 446,559
See notes to financial statements.
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT
ACCOUNTING POLICIES
General
The American Legion National Headquarters (the Legion) is a
national veterans' organization which was declared to be a corporate body by an Act of the United States Congress on Sept. 16,
1919.
According to the Original Act and Subsequent Amendments, the
purpose of the Organization is: “To uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of America; to promote peace and goodwill
among the peoples of the United States and all the nations of the
earth: to preserve the memories and incidents of the two World
Wars and the other great hostilities fought to uphold democracy; to
cement the ties and comradeship born of service; and to consecrate the efforts of its members to mutual helpfulness and service
to their country."
Basis of Presentation
The Legion generally reports for financial statement purposes on
the accrual method of accounting, recognizing income when
earned and expenses when incurred.
The Legion maintains its accounts on a fund accounting basis
wherein the accountability for certain segments of its operations
are presented in specific designated and restricted fund balances.
Further, the Legion has designated certain amounts for future projects or purposes, which amounts are presented as appropriated
funds in the accompanying financial statements.
The revenue and expenses of nonexpendable funds are not included in the Statement of Revenue, Expenses and Changes in Fund
Balances—Current Fund. Instead, they are recorded directly to the
nonexpendable funds involved as set forth in the footnotes to the
financial statements.
The amounts shown for 1993 in the accompanying Statement of
Revenue, Expenses and Changes in Fund Balances—Current Fund
and Statement of Cash Flows are included only to provide a basis
for comparison with 1994 amounts.
Accounts Receivable
The direct charge-off method is used to account for losses in collection of accounts receivable. An allowance for uncollectible
accounts receivable is considered unnecessary by the Legion
because all significant accounts expected to be uncollectible have
been written off.
Inventories
Inventories, which consist of Emblem items held for sale and magazine paper and publication rights, are valued at the lower of cost or
market. Supplies which are not intended for sale are expensed
when purchased.
Investments
Investments are recorded at cost. Premiums or discounts on
investments are generally recognized at the time of disposal or
maturity.
Investment in Subsidiary
The Legion accounts for the investment in common stock of its
wholly owned subsidiary, Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., on the
equity method.
Property and Equipment
Furniture, fixtures and equipment are carried at cost and are depreciated beginning in the month of acquisition on the straight-line
method based on the estimated useful lives of the assets involved.
Leasehold improvements and repairs are expensed when incurred.
In addition to other methods of obtaining new members, the Legion
uses direct mail and other direct marketing approaches. The
income generated from the direct membership solicitation is recognized in the applicable membership period (calendar year) and the
expenses incurred to obtain these memberships are deferred and
written off in the period in which the income is recognized.
The Legion is involved in various revenue enhancement programs.
The revenue and expenses related to the programs are recognized
in the periods to which they apply.
Income from The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation
is recorded when received. These receipts are for projects and programs conducted in the year of receipt.
Pension Plan
The Legion has a defined-benefit pension plan covering substantially all of its employees, as well as those of certain affiliated and
subordinated groups. The plan was established in 1944 by vote of
the Legion's National Convention. Contributions to the plan are
made by the Legion and other participating groups on the basis of
annual actuarial valuations.
Federal Income Tax
The Legion is exempt from federal income tax (except on unrelated
business income) under Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code.
The Legion is not considered to be a private foundation.
Depreciation on the Washington, D. C., building is computed on the
straight-line method using a 30-year life.
Depreciation expense amounted to $1,318,354 in 1994 and
$1,299,163 in 1993.
Income
Dues are recognized as income in the applicable membership period. which is on a calendar-year basis.
ro
o
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INVESTMENT IN SUBSIDIARY
On Sept. 28, 1990, the Legion purchased all of the outstanding
shares of Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., a corporation engaged
in the creation and management of direct response advertising and
marketing strategies. The Legion has chosen to account for this
investment on the equity method since consolidation would not
necessarily result in meaningful information and since the reporting
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
differences are immaterial. Details of the Legion’s investment in
subsidiary are as follows:
1994
Investment in subsidiary
Original investment.
Loss (9/28/90-12/31/93)
Income (1/1/94-12/31/94)
$101,000
(79.950)
79,837
$101,000
(79,950)
$100,887
' $21,050
Key significant balance sheet and income statement information of Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. is as follows:
Year Ended December 31
Balance sheet information
Accounts receivable—The Amencan Legion
Furniture and fixtures—net
Other assets
Total assets
$296,907
263,574
280,318
~$840,799
$252,091
169,510
249,331
$670,932
Notes payable—The American Legion
Other liabilities
Stockholder's (deficit)
Total liabilities and stockholder's deficit
$339,167
699.118
...(197,486)
.$840,799
$367,254
585.999
(282,321)
0,932
1994
Income statement information
Sales (including sales to The American Legion of $3,369,004 and $4,147,764)
Income from operations
Net income
Accounts receivable—other on the Legion’s balance sheet includes $339,167 due on a note receivable, from Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc., bearing interest at 9% Beginning Auqust 1991
Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. began to repay the note, with an original balance of $400,000, in 120 equal monthly installments of $5,000.
The Legion has a sublease agreement with Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. for office space. The lease is a 10-year operating lease which expires in November 2000.
The following is a schedule of future minimum rental payments required under this lease.
Years Ending December 31
i395"
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
'
■
'
~
zzz
'
:
TT30.M0
130.000
130.000
130.000
130.000
130.000
The Legion is an unconditional guarantor of a $188,000 relating to loans outstanding that Haynes and Pittenger Direct Inc. carries with a bank.
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
INVESTMENT IN AFFILIATE
During 1994, the Legion in conjunction with approximately 80 other
organizations, created a nonprofit corporation known as The Citizens Flag Alliance, Inc. (CFA, Inc.) for the purpose of aiding in the
campaign to secure a constitutional amendment empowering the
Congress and the States to enact legislation to protect the Flag of
accordingly, the Legion’s investments in the affiliate have been
reduced by this amount, and a corresponding charge has been
reflected in other restricted funds.
the United States of America from physical desecration.
To support these efforts, the Legion invested $3,000,000 in the
program during 1994.
Since the program began in June of 1994, CFA, Inc. has recognized
a (deficiency) of revenue over expenses of $1,981,286 and,
The Legion also guarantees a contract of CFA, Inc. with a public
relations firm for approximately $135,000 monthly.
INVESTMENTS (CURRENT FUND)
The cost and market value of Current Fund investments are as follows:
1993
1994
December 31
Segregated for Designated Fund
U. S. Government obligations
Accrued interest—restricted
Money market accounts
Uninvested cash
Due from General Fund
Segregated for Wash., D.C., building
U. S. Government obligations
Other
U. S. Government obligations
Repurchase agreements
Money market accounts
Certificates of deposit
Mutual funds
Due from General Fund
Cost
Market Value
Cost
Market Value
$11,258,442
146,479
860,417
$10,845,439
146,479
860,417
12,265,338
11,852,335
$9,707,603
127,900
760.000
297
1,075,000
11,670,800
$10,239,366
127,900
760.000
297
1,075,000
12,202,563
682,427
643,019
557,506
568,002
7,060,247
6,749,271
9,593,560
255,961
517,134
135,064
17,561,966
9,593,559
255,961
492,073
135,064
17,225,928
7,657,703
1,500,000
5,623,838
7,502,143
1,531,950
5,623,838
135,088
14,916,629
135,088
14,793,019
21,050
21,050
$27,165,985
$27,584,634
100,887
100,887 *
Investment in affiliate
1,018,714
1,018,714 *
Total investments
$31,629,332
Investment in subsidiary
202
•Book value, market value not determined
$30,840,883
ho
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
OPERATING LEASES
The Legion rents computer equipment, copiers and cash registers
under operating leases. Total rental expense on these operating
leases was $602,285 in 1994 and $489,201 in 1993.
Committee. Earnings of the Fund may be used for the general operations of the Legion, but the principal can be expended only:
Minimum rental payments under operating leases are as follows:
1995
1996
(b) By two-thirds affirmative vote of the National Executive Committee in two successive meetings not less than 60 days apart.
In addition, the Legion has a lease with the State of Indiana for
rental of the National Headquarters building in Indianapolis through
November 1997. According to the terms of the lease, in lieu of
rental payments the Legion is required to maintain the interior of the
building, as well as provide adequate insurance on the building. The
cost of maintenance approximated $348,000 in 1994 and
$349,000 in 1993. Insurance coverage is included in the Legion’s
general insurance policy.
APPROPRIATED FUNDS
The balances of appropriated funds were as follows:
December 31
1994
1993
Computer Reserve
$500,000 $500,000
Real Estate Reserve
841,977
841,977
Convention Reserve
100,000
100,000
Employee Insurance Premium
Stabilization Reserve
100,000
100,000
Convention Stabilization Fund
73,748
25,211
Totals
$1,615,725 $1,567,188
RESTRICTED AND DESIGNATED FUNDS
Receipts which are restricted by the donor are credited to the
appropriate restricted fund, against which all expenditures for the
related project or program are charged. Periodically, the Legion
may add to restricted funds through allocations from unappropriated funds for specific future purposes and projects.
(a) By action of the Legion at its National Convention, or
The Restricted Fund, a designated fund, is restricted as to use by
action of the National Finance Commission and National Executive
Committee. Earnings of the Fund, as well as principal, can be
expended only on the recommendation of the National Finance
Committee and a two-thirds affirmative vote of the National Executive Committee at two successive meetings. It is the policy of The
American Legion to transfer 10 percent of the prior year's defined
net income to the Restricted Fund. There were no transfers in 1994
or 1993 to the Restricted Fund due to net losses.
NONEXPENDABLE FUNDS
The earnings of the Overseas Graves Decoration Fund are being
used to honor, preserve and decorate the graves of those who
served in the United States armed forces who are buried overseas.
The Fund is to continue at the will of the National Convention of the
Legion or the National Executive Committee. The Fund's trust
agreement may be amended, changed or succeeded at the will of
the National Executive Committee, provided that the purpose for
which the Fund was created is retained.
During 1991, the Restricted Fund loaned $4,100,000 to the General
Fund for the financing of the new membership computer system.
Total interest paid to the Restricted Fund amounted to $58,385 and
$148,437 in 1994 and 1993. Total principal payments made were
$1,075,000 and $900,000 in 1994 and 1993. The loan was paid in
full during 1994.
In October 1974, the National Executive Committee approved the
establishment of a life membership plan available to any member of
a participating department. In accordance with the plan, the assets
of the Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund are segregated in a trust
account from which funds equal to the annual dues of life members
are withdrawn for current operations each year. The trust agreement provides that the Legion has the right to withdraw part or all
of the assets of the trust account and to modify or terminate the
trust agreement at its discretion.
The Reserve Fund, a designated fund, also is restricted as to use by
action of the National Finance Commission and National Executive
LO
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
Changes in Nonexpendable Funds are as follows:
Year Ended December 31,1994
Overseas Graves Paid-Up-For-Life
Decoration Fund Membership Fund
Revenue
Paid-Up-For-Life membership
dues collected
$ 4,407,252
Investment income
$56,711
1,272.239
56,711
5,679.491
Expenses
Membership dues withdrawn
2,503,057
Decoration of graves
49,265
Administrative expense
326,809
Trust fees
66,349
49,265
2,896,215
Excess of revenue over expenses
Fund balances, January 1,1994
Fund balances, December 31,1994
7,446
949,689
$957,135
2,783,276
18,015,803
$20,799,079
The cost and market value of investments in the Nonexpendable
Funds are as follows:
December 31
1994
1993
Cost
Market
Cost
Market
Vajue
Value
Overseas Graves Decoration Fund
U.S. Government obligations $893.316 $840,553 $893,316 S 926.688
Paid-Up-For-Life Membership Fund
U. S. Government obligations 7,035,633 6,877,192 5,443,576 5,656,871
Money market accounts
2,374,915 2,374,915 3,000,489 3,000,489
Common and preferred stocks 9,931,146 10,540,847 6,992,684 8,230,650
Nongovernment obligations
1,677,538 1,567,710 2.445,024 2,516.676
21,019,232 21,360.664 17,881,773 19,404,686
Total investments
$21,912,548 $22,201,217 $18,775,089 $20.331,372
$517,887
141,866
NOTES TO FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
AMERICAN LEGION ENDOWMENT
FUND CORPORATION
The American Legion Endowment Fund Corporation (the Endowment Fund) was incorporated in 1925 as a not-for-profit corporation with perpetual existence to act as trustee for the American
Legion Endowment Fund, which was created to provide permanent
funding for rehabilitation of American veterans and assistance to
orphans of veterans. In August 1946, the Legion transferred securities having a market value of $2,001,000 to the Endowment Fund.
The assets transferred have been held segregated by the Endowment Fund and the principal related to the 1946 transfer, which had
a market value of $1,982,624 at December 31,1994, may be withdrawn by the Legion, if needed, for rehabilitation of veterans or
assistance to orphans of veterans.
Income earned on the investments of the Endowment Fund, net of
administrative expenses, is payable to the Legion to support its
programs for the above-mentioned purposes. Income from the
Endowment Fund amounted to $537,035 in 1994 and $547,071 in
1993.
LIFE INSURANCE PLAN
In connection with The American Legion's Life Insurance Plan, the
Legion had created a Trust to which the First National Bank of
Kansas City, Mo., as Trustee, held legal title. During October, 1992,
the National Executive Committee approved a resolution to terminate the Life Insurance Trust. This dissolution occurred during April
1993. On the date of dissolution, funds remaining in the Plan
totalling $4,285,984 were transferred to a non-trust sub-account
(The American Legion Life Insurance Plan) under control of the
Legion for the use of youth programs. The American Legion Life
Insurance Plan is included with the restricted funds in the accompanying financial statements. The trust funds, prior to the dissolution, were available for the following purposes:
(a)
(b)
due from participants.
(c)
(d)
(e)
and programs serving the interest of the Legion and its members,
provided that such distributions are not disapproved in writing by a
majority of the participants.
Subsequent to the dissolution of the Trust, the funds of The American Legion Life Insurance Plan are used primarily for youth programs. The Legion’s National Executive Committee has approved
partial funding of the Oratorical Contest, Boys Nation, American
Legion Baseball, and other programs of the Legion. At December 31, 1994, $1,102,170 in funds had been approved for use in
designated programs during 1995.
PENSION PLAN
The funded status of the pension plan at the end of the year was:
December 31
1994
Actuarial present value of plan benefits
Vested
$(13,526,159)
Nonvested
(428,427)
1993
The discount rate and rate of increase in future compensation levels
used in determining the actuarial present value of the projected
benefit obligation were 8.75 percent and 3 percent, respectively, for
1994 and 7 percent and 3 percent, respectively, for 1993. The
assumed rate of return on plan assets was 6 percent for 1994 and
1993.
LITIGATION
The Legion is currently involved in and/or has been mentioned as a
defendant or co-defendant in several legal actions. It is the opinion
of the National Judge Advocate that these claims are without merit
and any ultimate liability of the Legion with respect to these actions
will not materially affect the financial position of the Legion.
$(14,378,971)
(491,826)
Accumulated benefit obligation $(13,954,586)
£(14,870,797)
Projected benefit obligation
$(15,077,680)
Plans assets at fair value, primarily listed
stocks, bonds, and U. S. securities 27,864,346
Excess of plan assets over
projected benefit obligation
12,786,666
Unrecognized net gain
(5,854,739)
Prior service cost not yet recognized
in net periodic pension cost
1,285,938
Unrecognized net asset at
end of year
(1,970,072)
Prepaid pension expense
$6,247,793
$(16,249,877)
29,838,817
13,588,940
(6,435,076)
669,229
(2,261,935)
$5,561,158
Net pension income included the following components:
1994
1993
To
increase the Trust fund.
Service
cost—benefits earned
To
reduce or pay in full the life insurance premiums thereafter
during
the year
$616,509
$661,751
Interest cost on projected
To
provide additional life insurance benefits for the participants.
benefit
obligation
1,148,908
1,041,944
To
make refunds to the participants.
1,133,148
(2,508,638)
Actual return on assets
To make distributions to the Legion in support of its activities
212,622
(3,294,462)
Net amortization and deferral
Net pension expense (credit)
$(395,897)
$(592,321)
o
THE AMERICAN LEGION NATIONAL HEADQUARTERS
RECONCILIATION OF AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
TO INTERNAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS:
SCHEDULE 1
Year Ended December 31
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses—
Internal Financial Statements
Excess of expenses over revenue for certain designated
and restricted funds not included in internal financials
Excess of revenue over expenses for certain appropriated funds
not included in internal financials
Excess (Deficiency) of Revenue Over Expenses—
Audited Financial Statements
1994
Total Current Fund
$(1,561,180)
(1,840,655)
48,537
$(3,353,298)
AMERICAN LEGION ENDOWMENT FUND CORPORATION
Foreseeing the necessity of a recurring income source for funding
its war veterans’ rehabilitation and child welfare programs, The
American Legion conducted a national campaign in 1925 which
raised approximately $5 million for this purpose. The funds contributed were entrusted to the custody of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation.
December 31
Total assets
Investments at cost
Interest income
Expenses
Excess income over expense
Funds transferred to The American Legion
Average yield on book value of investments
The Corporation was incorporated under the laws of the State of
Delaware in 1925 and a trust agreement between The American
Legion and the Corporation was signed in accordance with which
the funds are administered by the Corporation with the annual net
investment income being paid to The American Legion for use in
the two programs involved.
1994
$7,846,801
$7,644,325
$550,155
46,472
$503,683
$537,035
$7,867,425
$7,665,491
$568,759
26,594
$542,165
$544,071
The operations and financial condition of The American Legion
Endowment Fund Corporation for each of the last five years are
summarized below (taken from the annual audit reports prepared
by Geo. S. Olive & Co. LLC, Indianapolis, Ind.).
$7,802,473
$7,595,545
$652,342
32,304
$620,038
$547,467
$7,714,042
$7,590,564
$710,453
33,103
$677,350
$595,268
$7,495,544
$7,374,020
$627,284
53,173
$574,111
$549,378
N5
o
<y>
207
Abbreviations
ABM
AFP
AMVETS
ANIVICUS
ASTP
AS VET
BAQ
BRAC
CBS
CD
CEO
CFA
CHAMPUS
COLA
DAV
DMS
DOD
DOL
DVA
DVOP
ES
FBI
FUTA
FY
HMO
HPSP
HUD
ICBM
IHS
INS
IRS
JTPA
KWV
LIT
LVER
MBNA
MIA
MTTP
NATO
Anti-Ballistic Missile
Armed Forces of the Philippines
American Veterans of World War II, Korea and Vietnam
Army, Navy and Air Force Veterans in Canada, United States
Army Specialized Training Program
Assistant Secretary of Veterans Employment and Training
Basic Allowance for Quarters
Base Realignment & Closure Commission
Columbia Broadcasting System
Compact Disc
Chief Executive Officer
Citizens Flag Alliance
Civilian Health & Medical Program of the Uniformed Services
Cost-of-Living Adjustments
Disabled American Veterans
Direct Membership Solicitation
Department of Defense
Department of Labor
Department of Veterans Affairs
Disabled Veterans Outreach Program
Employment Service
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Federal Unemployment Tax Act
Fiscal Year
Health Maintenance Organization
Health Professional Scholarship Program
Housing & Urban Development
Inter Continental Ballistic Missile
Indian Health Service
Immigration and Naturalization Service
Internal Revenue Service
Job Training Partnership Act
Korean War Veterans
Legionnaire Insurance Trust
Local Veterans Employment Representative
Merchants Bank North America
Missing In Action
Membership Team Training Program
North Atlantic Treaty Organization
208
NC
NEC
NPT
NSLI
OBRA
OCS
OECD
OVA
PFP
PO W
PVOA
ROK
ROTC
SAL
SAT
SBA
SMOCTA
US CINCPAC
UN
US
USERRA
USPHS
USS
USSR
USUHS
V-J Day
VA
VACRS
VETS
VFW
VHS
National Convention
National Executive Committee
Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty
National Service Life Insurance
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act
Officer Candidate School
Organization for Economic Development
Office of Veterans’ Affairs
Partnership for Peace
Prisoner of War
Philippine Veterans Office Affairs
Republic of Korea
Reserved Officers Training Corp.
Sons of The American Legion
Scholastic Aptitude Test
Small Business Administration
Service Members Occupational Conversion and Training Act
United States Commander in Chief, Pacific
United Nations
United States
Uniformed Service Employment and Re-employment Rights Act
United States Public Health Service
United States Ship
Union of Soviet Socialists Republic
Uniformed Services University of Health Science
Victory Over Japan Day
Veterans Affairs
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Veterans of Foreign Wars
Video High Speed
209
Index
Treaty of 1972
Air Force
American Cabaret Theater Singers
American Studies Program
ANIVICUS
Annuity Program
Anti-Ballistic Missile
Apache Longbow System
Appreciation to Host City
Armed Forces
Army
Army Force XXI Program
Army, Navy, Air Force Veterans In Canada
Auxiliary
Auxiliary Eligibility
awards, annual
ABM
B-2 bomber
Baker, Keith
Baseball Player of the Year
Battle of Midway
Bayh, Evan
Belton, Sharon Sayles
Benediction
Bentley, Geroge
Bernard, Prince of the Netherlands
Bille, George
Blackhawk helicopters
Blood Donor Awards
Blood Drive
Blute, Peter
Board of Veterans Appeals
Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc
Bosnia
Bottom-Up Review
Boy Scouts of America
Boys Nation
Bradley Fighting Vehicles
Bradley, Bill
Bradley, Terry
Brown, Jesse
Bruner, Constance
Buick LeSabre
151
152
3, 57
86
'48
139
151
156
96
156
155
156
47
87
127
189
153
184
33
99
11
22
186
47
95
30
156
162
24,82,163
140
110
68
40
152
18, 28
30
156
138
31
58, 166
68
25
210
Buick Motor Division
Burton, Dan
Buyer, Stephen E
C-17 airlifter
26, 138
91
140
153
Caldwell Machining, Incorporated
68
Caldwell, Joseph
68
Cambodia
121
Cambridge Incident
50
Camp H.M. Smith, Hawaii
163
CBS
46
CHAMPUS
115,116,158
Child Welfare Foundation
24,91
Chilelli, Joe
106
China, People's Republic of
120, 122, 123
Ciciotte, William L
184
Citizens Flag Alliance
25, 45, 58, 87, 118, 137, 139, 180
claims
108, 110
Clinton, Bill
6
Coast Guard
28, 161
Comer, John P. ‘Jake’
63
commemorative postage stamp
96
Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
100
constitutional amendment to protect the Flag
5, 21, 39, 141, 179
Constitutional Amendments of The American Legion
126
Coolidge, Calvin
101
Cover, Jack
64, 65
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section II
95
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section III
103
Curtin, Richard
67
Customs and Immigration Services
27
Defense Intelligence Agency
Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military Beneficiaries
Deshotel, Syble
Detweiler, Jr., Scott
Dietz, John
disability compensation benefits
Disabled Veterans’ Outreach ProgramLocal Veterans’ Employment Repre
Disabled Veterans’ Outreach Program
Disaster Relief Fund
Dispatch
Dodona Manor
Dole, Robert J
Domestic Terrorism in the United States
DucksinaRow
120
158
186
1
90
109
78
78
139
25
101
35, 42
153
103
211
Durant, Michael
Dutch Army
99
94
Egner, Aron
32
Eighth U.S. Army
165
election of national officers
168
eligibility
128
Elkins, Frank
§4
Employer of the Year Awards
67
Employment and Unemployment Service
78
Employment and Veterans' Preference and Other Economic Matters
76
English as official language of the United States
37, 38
Enola Gay
5, 13, 49, 59, 70, 74, 86, 92, 98, 104, 140, 149
Evans, Dale
85
Evans, Diane Carlson
84
Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review
109
F-22 fighter
Family Assistance Program
Federal Agency Veterans’ Preference Programs
Federal Contractor Job Listing Program
Federal Surplus Property
Fighting for Tomorrow: Japanese Americans in America’s Wars
Films:
Valor and the Horror
Finance Committee
Financial Report
First Women’s Post of The American Legion No. 2
Fish & Wildlife Service
Flying High Membership Campaign
Foreign Relations Committee
Forest Service
Founders of The American Legion
Fourth Estate Award
Frank N. Belgrano, Jr. Trophy
Freeman, Ann Peterson
Funding and Support for Employment Programs
Gable, John
Garland Murphy Award
Geiger, John
George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
George, Steve
German Army
GI BiH
Glenn, John
153
139
78
78
80
98
49
118
196-206
89
99
91
119
79
47
143
28
89
77
47
25
167
100
22
94
6, 82
138
Gold Book
Gold Brigade
Goldsmith, Stephen
Gordon, Gary
grandmothers in the American Legion Auxilairy
Grazini, Alan
Greene, Hugh
Hagger, Gail
Harris, Clifford
Haskell, C. Darrel
Hays, Jr., A. G
Health Care Delivery System of the Uniformed Services
Health Care Security Plan
Hearst Newspapers
Henderson, Thomas
Hice, Larry K
Historic Resources of the Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of
History Standards
Homeless Veterans’ Reintegration Project
Ike Pappas Network Productions
Illegal Aliens
Immigration Act 1986
Indianapolis, Indiana
Internal Revenue Service
Invocation
Jackson National Life Insurance Company
Jacobovits, Adriaan
Japan
Japanese American National Museum
Jennings, Peter
Job Training Partnership Act Title IV-C
Johnson, Sam
Junior Shooting Sports Champion
Kava Water Company
Kicklighter, Claude M
Klinker, Mary
Korean War Memorial
Korean War Veterans Memorial Advisory Board
LaBiche, A1
Lam, Jr., Rick
Ill, 116, 179
107
15
99
127
30
48
86
139
184
66
158
110
143
13
138
100
38
78
45
27
27
96
134
1, 57, 137
139
93
27, 99
98
92
78
140
31
64
82
86
6, 34, 59, 63
64
168
30
213
Laos
121
J24
144
10j
2
137
78
]77
Lee, Tneg-hui
Lewis, Charles
Liberty Memorial
Lighting of Peace Candle
Livingston, Don
Local Veterans’ Employment Representative Program
Ludwig, Daniel A
Mackey, Richard C
Magazine
Marshall, George C
Martin Marietta
MBNA America
Medal of Honor
medical schools
Medicare
membership
Midland Daily News
Midway Islands National Memorial Act
Military compensation
Military retired pay
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Modernization of the United States Army
Montgomery, G.V. ‘Sonny’
Moseley-Braun, Carol
Murphy, Joseph
Murray, Pat
National Air and Space Museum
National Defense Authorization Act
National High School Oratorical Contest Winner
National History Standards
National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
National Security
National Security Strategy
NATO
NATO Partnership for Peace
Natural Resource Management
NAVCARE
Netherlands
Newsome, Linda
Newspapers:
Albany Times Union
Dispatch
Midland Daily News
163
Hg
100
35
139
99
117
115-117, 159
17g
29
99
156
157
23
155
43
13g
30
I39
'i
9g
158
32
38
99
150
155
. 40
122
79
’' ’ ’ ” 160
93
87
143
49
29
214
Nuclear Posture Review
152
Ohn , Regina
Old Glory
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (OBRA) of 1993
Operation Baby Lift
Oppose Centralization of 5 VA-Claims Processing Centers
Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
Oratorical Contest Winner
Organization for Economic Development
86
45
157
86
108
109
124
125
32
94
Pacific Command
Pappas, Ike
Park Service
Partnership for Peace
Pasowski, Aurelia
Patrick, J. Milton
Patton, General George
Paul H. Griffith ROTC Trophy
Pearl Harbor
Pershing, John J
Phone Bank
Post No. 500
Post Everlasting Ceremony
postage stamp
Postal Service
POW/MIA
POW/MIA Empty Chair Designation
presumptive service
PRIMUS
Proposal to Improve Veterans Health Care
Pryor, Sr., Reverend Roy
164
45
100
122
64
2
143
162
27
101
118, 137
1
2
96
96
6, 120, 125
7
109
160
Ill
1, 23
Quality of Life Features
156
Radcliffe, Jere
RAH-66 Comanche
Ralph T. O’Neil Education Trophy
Ray, Paul
Recruiter Of The Year
Reel, Ralph J
Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Reinvention Team
Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
18
156
28
68
106
184
78
28
123
215
Renaud, Dale
2 59
Report:
Americanism
26
Children and Youth
23
Citizens Flag Alliance
42
Constitutional Amendments
126
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section I
13
Credentials and Other Internal Matters: Section II
95
Credentials and Internal Matters: Section III
103
Employment and Veterans’ Preference and Other Economic Matters
76
Finance
Hg
Foreign Relations
119
Legislation and Rules
16
National Commander
5
National Security
150
Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation
107
Resolutions:
100 156
No. 1: American Legion Auxiliary Eligibility
127
No. 16: V-J Day Designation
27
No. 24: Natural Resource Management
79
No. 26: Relations with the Republic of China on Taiwan
123
No. 29: Federal Surplus Property
80
No. 32: Modernization of the United States Army
155
No. 35: Oppose Centralization of 5 VA Claims Processing Centers
108
No. 37: Oppose Taxation of DVA Disability Compensation
109
No. 42: Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
97
No. 47: Exempt All Current Pension and Entitlements from Further Review .. 109
No. 56: Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
96
No. 64: National Media Coverage for Military Personnel
99
No. 65: Midway Islands National Memorial Act
99
No. 70: Funding and Support for Employment Programs
77
No. 74: Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to Date
the Deceased Veteran’s Claim Was Filed
110
No. 91: Restoration of Liberty Memorial
101
No. 92: Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
120
No. 93: The Enola Gay
98
No. 94: The Enola Gay
98
No. 99: Illegal Aliens
27
No. 100: Commercial Vendors at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial
100
No. 102: Quality of Life Features
156
No. 104: Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
157
No. 105: Domestic Terrorism in the United States
153
No. 107: Department of Defense Health Care Reform for Military Beneficiaries 158
No. Ill: Opposition to Agreed Framework with North Korea
124
No. 136: Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
96
No. 139: Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
100
No. 140: Opposition to Normalization of Relations with Vietnam
125
216
No. 141: American Legion Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
No. 146: Reinvention of Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
No. 147: Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to
America’s Veteran-Entrepreneurs
No. 148: Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
No. 149: The United States Air Force in the 21st Century
No. 150: Support for the United States Coast Guard
No. 151: United Nations
No. 152: NATO Partnership for Peace
No. 153: Appreciation to Host City
No. 154: World War II Commemoration Day
Restoration of Liberty Memorial
Retinitis Pigmentosa Foundation
Retired Military Pay COLA Equity
Revising the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty
Riley, Richard W
Robertson, Dale
Rodriguez, Fernando
Rogers, Roy
roll call
ROTC Trophy
Royal Canadian Legion
Russia
110
78
81
151
152
161
121
122
96
97
101
23
157
151
69
3, 6
34
85
'69
162
48
120, 151
Salerno, Steve
118
Samsung
34, 35, 65
Samsung American Legion Scholarship
35
Scholl, Dean
58
School Medal Program
29
Schroedl, Don
22
Scott, Robert D
184
Scout of the Year
34
Seek Legislation to Pay Accrued Benefits in a Pending Claim to Deceased
Veteran’s Claim was Filed
HO
Selective Service System
6
Servicemen’s Readjustment Act of 1944
81
Shalikashvili, John M
145
Sharp, Jr., Ervin C
163
Sheeks, Gilbert E
15
Shughart, Randall
99
Silver Book
129
SkyConcert
104
Skypeck, Rhonda
64
Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization
81
Small Business Administration
81
Smith, Robert Charles
168
Smithsonian Institution
5, 39, 86, 98, 99
217
Society of the Founders of The American Legion
Solomon, Gerald
Somalia
Song, Bo-Soon
Sons of The American Legion
Southwest Research Institute
Specter, Arlen
Speedway Color Guard
Sponsor and Support “Salute to Japanese American Veterans”
State Employment and Unemployment Insurance Agency
Stepanek, Marcia
Stewart, Virgil
Still Serving America
Stone, E. Roy, Jr
Support Efforts to Increase and Improve Federal Assistance to America’s
Veteran-Entrepreneurs
Support for the United States Coast Guard
Support George C. Marshall Home Preservation Fund
Support Sergeant Alvin C. York Postage Stamp
Support Supersonic Flight Postage Stamp
Taiwan Relations Act
tax exempt status
Tax Simplification Plan
teaching hospitals
terrorist attacks
Third Marine Expeditionary Force
Thomas, Zachary Lee
Tibbets, Paul W
Time Warner
TRICARE
UN Convention on the Protection of Peacekeepers
United Nations
United States Air Force in the 21st Century
United States Court of Veterans Appeals
Updated Priority POW/MIA Actions
V-JDay
V-J Day Designation
Valor and the Horror
Vaught, Wilma L
Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Committee
Veterans’ Employment and Training Service
Veterans’ Health Care Security Plan
Veterans’ Re-employment Rights
47
43
99
34
90
67
138
1
97
78
143
166
103
69, 167
81
161
100
96
96
123
134
109
117
154
165
34
74
40
158
121
40 121
152
110
120
27,92,166
27
49
88
107
78
110, 111
78
218
Videos:
Old Glory
Your Flag, Your Fight
Vietnam
Vietnam Service Medal
Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund
Vietnam Women’s Memorial Project
Vocational Assistance Commission for Retired Servicemen
Ward, W.T. Russ
Wick, Jr., Otto
William F. Lenker National Service Trophy
William Randolph Hearst Americanism Trophy
Women in Military Service for American Memorial Foundation, Inc
World Trade Center
World War I
World War II
World War II Commemoration Day
World War II Commemorative Committee
World War II poster art slides
45
45
6, 120, 121, 125
132
100, 133
86
84
50
47
29
117
29
88
154
96, 101
97-100
97
104
1
Yeager, Charles
96
York, Alvin C
Yu, Chao
96
50