Extracted text: [Statement for the Record of The American Legion to the House Committee on Veterans' Affairs on "From Tumult to Transformation: the Commission on Care and the Future of the VA Healthcare System," September 7, 2016] `

Extracted text: [Statement for the Record of The American Legion to the House Committee on Veterans' Affairs on "From Tumult to Transformation: the Commission on Care and the Future of the VA Healthcare System," September 7, 2016] ` results

admin
Edited Text
STATEMENT FOR THE RECORD OF
THE AMERICAN LEGION
TO THE
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS’ AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
“FROM TUMULT TO TRANSFORMATION: THE COMMISSION ON CARE AND
THE FUTURE OF THE VA HEALTHCARE SYSTEM”
SEPTEMBER 7, 2016
Chairman Miller, Acting Ranking Member Takano and distinguished members of the committee,
on behalf of National Commander Charles E. Schmidt and The American Legion; the country’s
largest patriotic wartime service organization for veterans, comprising over 2 million members
and serving every man and woman who has worn the uniform for this country; we thank you for
the opportunity to comment regarding The American Legion’s position on the Commission on
Care and the future of the VA healthcare system.
The American Legion has worked extensively on matters concerning veterans for nearly 100
years. Our work includes all business lines managed and operated by The Department of
Veterans Affairs (VA) through sustained physical involvement, review of national policy, and
donations of resources, funding, personnel, and experience.
It is with the voice and support of the largest voting block of veterans in the country that The
American Legion presents the following analysis and recommendations regarding the report
offered by The Commission on Care dated June 30, 2016.
The American Legion acknowledges the Commission relied heavily on the Independent
Assessment as per congressional instructions, as well as some limited testimony from VA,
Veteran Service Organizations (VSO), and media reports; but the primary foundation for
discussion and findings were based on internal discussions among commissioners based on
individual filters, experiences, and loyalties; and thus this report is reflective of those individual
opinions.
The American Legion will not address the entire report, rather we will highlight the parts we
believe have merit for further study or implementation, and those areas where we believe
implementation would be detrimental to all veterans seeking healthcare from the VA, whether
directly, or through a managed community relationship.
We are in general agreement with most of the Commission’s recommendations and are pleased
to see they are in line with transformation currently underway at VA through the MyVA
initiative.
As you know, three of 15 Commission members did not sign the final report, with two
commissioners opposing the final report because they felt it didn’t go far enough. Commissioner

Michael Blecker also did not sign, saying the main recommendation, for the Veterans Health
Administration (VHA) Care System, went too far.
The American Legion’s positioning on the report places us closer to Commissioner Blecker’s. As
he explained in his June 29 dissent:
I cannot agree to the Commission’s first and most significant recommendation,
establishment of a proposed “VHA Care System.” Given the design of this proposed new
delivery model, the adoption of this proposal would threaten the survival of our nation’s
veteran-centered health care system as a choice for the millions of veterans who rely on
it. Although this is only one of many recommendations in the Report, this single
recommendation risks undermining rather than strengthening our veteran-centered
health care system, and I cannot agree to it. 1
We also believe that recommendations of more privatization that some are trying to mask as
“Choice” fail to take into consideration that veterans already have a myriad of choices, more so
than most Americans. Choosing to see a contracted primary care physician as opposed to a VA
primary care physician is a choice most veterans using VA health care already have through their
private insurance, Tricare, Medicare, Medicaid or several other options. These “choices” also
come with additional expenses to the veteran. Converting VA health care to an insurance payer
would increase out-of-pocket expenses for veterans who rely solely on VA for all of their health
care needs, and who may not have alternate insurance options.
That said, here are our initial comments on a few of the most important recommendations:
Recommendation #1: Across the United States, with local input and knowledge, VHA should
establish high-performing, integrated community health care networks, to be known as the VHA
Care System, from which veterans will access high-quality health care services.
This recommendation includes several sub-recommendations. Here we will address two of the
most salient ones separately because they each have separate and distinct implications and will
require individualized policy and/or legislative modifications in order to accomplish. The
overarching theme of this recommendation involves a robust and integrated community care
network.
A. The American Legion supports realigning VA’s community care program and has provided
testimony that discusses its restructuring. In relevant part, we said:
The American Legion believes in a strong, robust veterans’ healthcare system that is
designed to treat the unique needs of those men and women who have served their country.
However, even in the best of circumstances there are situations where the system cannot keep
up with the health care needs of the growing veteran population requiring VA services, and
the veteran must seek care in the community. Rather than treating this situation as an
afterthought, an add-on to the existing system, The American Legion has called for the
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to “develop a well-defined and consistent non-VA care
1

http://www.prweb.com/releases/2016/07/prweb13535231.htm

2

coordination program, policy and procedure that includes a patient centered care strategy
which takes veterans’ unique medical injuries and illnesses as well as their travel and
distance into account. 2
Over the years, VA has implemented a number of non-VA care programs to manage
veterans’ health care when such care is not available at a VA facility, could not be provided
in a timely manner, or is more cost effective through contracting vehicles. Programs such as
Fee-Basis, Project Access Received Closer to Home (ARCH), Patient-Centered Community
Care (PC3), and the Veterans Choice Program (VCP) were enacted by Congress to ensure
eligible veterans could be referred outside the VA for needed, and timely, health care
services.
Congress created the VCP after learning in 2014 that VA facilities were falsifying
appointment logs to disguise delays in patient care. However, it quickly became apparent that
layering yet another program on top of the numerous existing non-VA care programs, each
with their own unique set of requirements, resulted in a complex and confusing landscape for
veterans and community providers, as well as the VA employees that serve and support them.
Therefore, Congress passed the Surface Transportation and Veterans Health Care Choice
Improvement Act of 2015 (VA Budget and Choice Improvement Act) in July 2015 after VA
sought the opportunity to consolidate its multiple care in the community authorities and
programs. This legislation required VA to develop a plan to consolidate existing community
care programs.
On October 30, 2015, VA delivered to Congress the department’s Plan to Consolidate
Community Care Programs, its vision for the future outlining improvements for how VA will
deliver health care to veterans. The plan seeks to consolidate and streamline existing
community care programs into an integrated care delivery system and enhance the way VA
partners with other federal health care providers, academic affiliates and community
providers. It promises to simplify community care and gives more veterans access to the best
care anywhere through a high performing network that keeps veterans at the center of care.
Generally, The American Legion supports the plan to consolidate VA’s multiple and
disparate purchased care programs into one New Veterans Choice Program (New VCP). We
believe it has the potential to improve and expand veterans’ access to health care.
Network Structure
The American Legion supports allowing VA to set up tiered networks. As we understand it,
this structure is meant to empower veterans to make informed choices, provide access to the
highest possible quality care by identifying the best performing providers in the community,
and enabling better coordination of care for better outcomes. However, it does not dictate
how veterans will use the network. The American Legion wants to make clear, though, that
we do not support a wholesale option to circumvent the VA infrastructure or healthcare
system entirely.

2

Resolution No. 46: (Oct 2012): Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Non-VA Care Programs

3

Prompt Pay
We support a provision mandating that all claims be made electronically by January 1, 2019
and an eligible provider should submit claims to Secretary within 180 days of furnishing care
or services.
Episode of Care
Provisions ensuring that an eligible veteran receives such care and services through the
completion of the episode of care, including all specialty and ancillary services deemed
necessary as part of the treatment recommended in the course of such care and services.
Emergency/Urgent Treatment
The American Legion supports requiring VA to reimburse veterans for the reasonable value
of emergency treatment or urgent care furnished in a non-Department facility in a final bill.
Conclusion
Ensuring veterans have access to appropriate, timely, high-quality care is critical. VA needs
to overhaul its outside care reimbursement programs, consolidating them into a more
efficient bureaucracy able to dynamically interact with the network of federal, public, and
private providers that are to supplement VA direct provided care. 3
B. Choice of primary care provider
The American Legion opposes allowing a complete option of primary care providers within the
proposed VHA Care System based on the Commission’s faulty analysis. The Commission
supports this recommendation based on a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimate of cost
that was calculated using Medicare rates. The Commission, however, gave no consideration to
Medicare rules for billing structure and how those rules would apply to the current quality of
care provided to veterans through VHA primary care physicians. VHA physicians are not
restricted as to the amount of time they are able dedicate to each patient, or the number of
presentations per patient. Medicare, on the other hand only provides payment based on a 10 or
15 minute consultation, which then denies veterans the full complement and quality of care they
are entitled to through their earned benefits. If scored by CBO properly, the cost of this
recommendation would be at least triple if not more, and is thus financially unsustainable. The
American Legion finds the recommendation and subsequent analysis by the Commission to be in
error and believe that it should not be considered by the Administration.
Recommendation #9: Establish a board of directors to provide overall VHA Care System
governance, set long-term strategy, and direct and oversee the transformation process.
The American Legion does not support the creation of a governing board. We do find value in
the Commission’s discussion and recommendations that point out inconsistent leadership due to
rotating political appointments and a leadership vision with a lack of continuity. The American
3

http://www.legion.org/legislative/testimony/231623/pending-veterans-affairs-legislation

4

Legion supports appointing a Veterans Health Administration (VHA) leader for a minimum of a
5 year term, with an option for an additional 5 year reappointment. We could also support the
same consistency for the Deputy Secretary position.
Congress is also part of the problem here. When Representative Beto O’Rourke addressed the
Commission on Care on March 22nd of this year, he noted that part of the problem with VA has
been a severe lack of continuity in oversight due to an unwillingness of Members to serve on the
VA committees: it’s not glamorous, there are real problems to be addressed, and there are no
“mission accomplished” banners. Members tend to leave the committee as soon as they are able
– to the point that, on day one as a new congressman assigned to the committee, he found
himself third in seniority on the Democratic side.
The American Legion thinks consideration should also be given to proposals that the Secretary
of Veterans Affairs develop and submit to Congress a Future-Years Veterans Program and a
quadrennial veteran’s review. 4
Recommendation #15: Create a simple-to-administer alternative personnel system, in law and
regulation, which governs all VHA employees, applies best practices from the private sector to
human capital management, and supports pay and benefits that are competitive with the private
sector.
This proposal to shift all 300,000 VHA employees away from Title Five and onto Title 38 to
provide the department with more flexibility in pay, benefits and recruiting is worth serious
consideration. While the change would be designed to ease hiring and firing at the agency, the
report says the new system should maintain due process appeal rights and merit system
principles and we concur.
Recommendation #18: Establish an expert body to develop recommendations for VA care
eligibility and benefit design.
Included in this recommendation is consideration of the feasibility of allowing veterans’ family
members and currently ineligible veterans to purchase VHA care through their health plans in
areas where VHA hospitals and other facilities might otherwise need to close. In many parts of
the country, VHA currently maintains hospitals and other health care facilities that are
underutilized or in danger of becoming so. A related challenge is maintaining safe volume of
care when patient loads decline.
As the report notes, “closing a low-volume hospital may be the answer in some instances. But
closing VHA facilities reduces the choices available to veterans. Increasing the volume of
patients treated by VHA in areas where it currently has excess capacity may ameliorate these
challenges.”
Appendix C of the report discusses the outline of developing pilot programs to test the feasibility
of avoiding VA hospital closures by allowing veterans’ spouses and currently ineligible veterans
4

https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/216

5

to purchase VA care in selected areas. The American Legion supports further investigation of
this proposal.
The American Legion appreciates the hard work from all of the commission members and we
look forward to working with this administration and the incoming Congress and administration
to ensure veterans are provided with the high level of expert health care that they have earned.
Secretary McDonald’s words on the report serve as a worthy stopping point for now: “However,
until all veterans say they are satisfied, I won’t be satisfied. Nobody at VA will be satisfied, but
our progress so far proves that VA’s current leadership, direction and momentum can produce
the necessary transformation.”
Conclusion
As always, The American Legion thanks this committee for the opportunity to explain the
position of the over 2 million veteran members of this organization. For additional information
regarding this testimony, please contact Mr. Warren J. Goldstein at The American Legion’s
Legislative Division at (202) 861-2700 or wgoldstein@legion.org.

6