- Home
- Magazines, Newsletters and Press Releases
- Statement of Cathleen Wiblemo, Deputy Director for Health Care, National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission, The American Legion before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Committee on Veterans' Affairs, U.S. House of Representatives on the Medical Care Collection Fund (MCCF)
- OCR
Extracted text: Statement of Cathleen Wiblemo, Deputy Director for Health Care, National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission, The American Legion before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Committee on Veterans' Affairs, U.S. House of Representatives on the Medical Care Collection Fund (MCCF) `
Extracted text: Statement of Cathleen Wiblemo, Deputy Director for Health Care, National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission, The American Legion before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Committee on Veterans' Affairs, U.S. House of Representatives on the Medical Care Collection Fund (MCCF) ` results
admin
Edited Text
The American Legion
Joe Hovish (2 copies)
A
For God and Country
National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission
1608 K Street, N.W. • washington, D.C. 20006
Paul A. Morin, Chairman - Massachusetts
Carol J. Rutherford, Director - Maryland
May 7, 2003
No. 12-03
STATEMENT OF
CATHLEEN 'VIBLEMO, DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR HEALTH CARE
NATIONAL VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION
THE AMERICAN LEGION
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS' AFFAIRS
U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
THE MEDICAL CARE COLLECTION FUND (MCCF)
MAY 7, 2003
Mr. Chainnan and Members of the Subcommittee:
Thank you for this opportunity to present The Alnerican Legion's views on the Medical Care
Collection Fund (MCCF). We commend the Subcommittee for holding a hearing on this
important program.
Public Law 105-33, the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, established the Department of Veterans
Affairs' (VA) MCCF and requires that amounts collected or recovered after June 30, 1997, be
deposited into this fund.
MCCF is a depository for funds collected from third-party
reimbursements from private insurance plans, outpatient prescription copayments and other
medical charges and user fees. The funds collected may only be used for providing VA medical
care and services and for VA expenses for identification, billing, auditing and collection of
amounts owed the Federal government.
Funds collected through MCCF are used as an offset rather than a supplement to annual
discretionary appropriations for V A ' s medical care budget. The efficient and timely collection
of these reimbursable costs greatly benefit the VHA in Ineeting the demands of an increasingly
overburdened system. By off-setting these funds VA loses valuable funding that is not an
"Pioneering Quality Service to veterans and Their Families"
accurate representation of the veterans' population in Veterans Equitable Resource Allocation
(VERA) formula nor does it allow for the full utility of collecting from the nation's largest health
insurance provider - Medicare.
Currently, VA distributes discretionary funds to its 21 Veterans Integrated Service Networks
(VISN s) using the detailed VERA fOllliula. Although VERA contains numerous allocation
components, neither the number of enrolled Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans nor the number of
enrolled Medicare-eligible Priority Group 7 or 8 veterans are allocation factors. Yet V A treats
these veterans for nonservice-connected medical conditions with the expectation of collecting
both co-payments and third-party reimbursements. When these Priority 7 or 8 veterans have no
private insurance or list Medicare as their third-party insurer, VA cannot recoup the reasonable
cost of care for the treatment of nonservice-connected medical conditions. Since over half of the
current enrolled population consists of Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans, this is an extremely
critical funding flaw.
These fundmnental elements are crucial to improving MCCF's ability to improve the level of
funding for VA health care. VA must have the ability to bill, collect and administrate more
effectively a system established to help recover third-party reimbursements for the treatment of
nonservice-connected medical conditions. MCCF needs to utilize a viable means to help V A
effectively recover third-party reimbursements owed to VA.
The use of model agencies'
successful collection system, such as the Indian Health Services (IRS), can increase the
efficiency of MCCF activities.
OFFSET OF MCCF TO DISCRETIONARY APPROPRIATIONS
Offsetting collections are monies that are deducted from outlays rather that counted on the
receipt side of the budget. Outlays are the amount of money the Federal government actually
spends in a given year. Offsets are often payments received for goods or services provided by
the Federal government, such as medical care given to veterans by VA who are already covered
under another health plan (public or private). The Debt Collection Improvement Act of 1996
(DCIA), Pub. L. 104-134, 110 Stat. 1321, (Apr. 26, 1996), as codified in 31 U.S.C. 3716(c),
requires the Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and other disbursing officials to offset
Federal payments to collect debts owed to the United States. This also applies to debts "owed"
to the Treasury by Federal agencies that calculate offsets into discretionary budgets.
Technically, MCCF is not considered a Treasury offset because the funds collected do not
actually go back to the MCCF Treasury account, but remain within VRA and are used as
operating funds. Instead, in developing a budget proposal, it appears that the total appropriation
request is reduced by the estimate for MCCF for the fiscal year in question. The American
Legion fails to understand the difference in the net effect to the VISNs and V AMCs . Offsetting
estimated MCCF funds largely defeats the purpose of realigning VHA's financial model to more
closely approximate the private sector. The American Legion adamantly opposes offsetting
annual VA discretionary funding by the MCCF recovery.
2
IMPROVING MCCF COLLECTIONS via INDIAN HEALTH SERVICES MODEL
Recent changes by the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) in the way medical care costs are
recovered has had a dramatically positive effect on the amount of revenue collected. The
implelTIentation of the VHA Revenue Cycle Enhancement Plan in early FY 2002 resulted in
significantly higher receipts than projected; so much so that VHA recently doubled the amount
VA expects to receive in FY 2004 from $1.03 billion to $2 .1 billion. However, MCCF systelTI
can benefit from agency models that clearly exemplify the efficiencies gained through practical
application.
Five members of The American Legion's National staff visited IHS Headquarters in Rockville,
MD to review and discuss the IHS experience with Medicare billing and collection. This was
followed by a site visit by four National staff members to the Albuquerque Area Office of IHS
for a detailed overview of the "Third Party Revenue Cycle." This was an extensive briefing on
the individuals, interactions and functions necessary to generate revenue collection, with a
particular emphasis on the Medicare component. Afterward, three National staff traveled to the
Acoma-Canoncita-Laguna (ACL) Hospital in San Fidel, NM for a demonstration of the billing
and collection process.
BACKGROUND
IHS was established to meet the government's responsibility to provide health care to Native
Americans. Like VA health care, it is not an "entitlement" program. Primary care is their basic
mission, but they also deal with Public Health issues, such as sanitation. IHS treats about 1.5
lTIillion patients a year (based on use within the past three years) of a population census of 2.2
million. There are about 50 facilities, many of them small rural clinics.
In 1976, Congress enacted title IV of the Indian Health Care Improvement Act (IHCIA) which
amended titles XIII (Medicare) and titles XIX (Medicaid) of the Social Security Act (SSA). This
allowed IRS to bill for Inedical services provided by IRS facilities to Native AlTIericans eligible
for Medicare (Part A) or Medicaid. Billing for Medicare Part B was authorized in 2002.
Initially, there was cultural and bureaucratic resistance to the billing and collection of Medicare
and Medicaid. In 1990, IRS collected only about $200,000. After absorbing significant cost
increases that were never funded in FY 1992-1996, an emphasis was placed on collections for
sheer survival. IHS now collects about $500 million a year. Of this, about $100 million is from
Medicare billing. The bulk of collections come from Medicaid, which is consistent with the
circumstances of the Native American population where, historically, there are lower incomes
and shorter life spans.
FINDINGS
Medicare billing and collection has been successfully implemented within IRS. The benefits of
successful ilnplementation:
../ Improved quality of care
../ Accurate and complete medical docun1entation
3
./
./
./
./
./
./
Enhanced provider profiling capabilities
Reduced n1alpractice and tOli action liability
Improved Risk Management for physicians and hospitals
Facilitated Quality Assurance
Compliance with rules and regulations
Third-party resource maximization
KEY ELEMENTS
In contrast to Department of Defense (DOD) Medicare Subvention Pilot Demonstration, illS has
no level of effort associated with its Medicare collection program. IHS collaborates with the
Services Center for Medicare and Medicaid, (eMS) through an advisory group that deals with
policy decisions. There must be "buy-in" from the top with leadership focused on and closely
monitoring the process. There was an initial investment in training people, and there was a
learning curve in the business process, where there is a deliberate billing process that requires
attention to detail. A maj or lesson learned was too lnuch emphasis on the billing process rather
than the collection of accounts receivable. Although billing is important, accounts receivable
activities ultimately determine a successful collection rate.
Everyone in the process must understand their role. The trmnlng of coders is extremely
important, and the coders should be certified. Pay grade of certified coders should be more
comparable to the private sector for successful recruitment and retention purposes. IHS and
DOD use electronic medical records that have the capability to generate billing infonnation. It
was suggested that software solutions are now available that make it feasible for VA to succeed
in the business practice.
CONCLUSION
The Indian Health Service's experience with Medicare collections demonstrates that a Federal
agency can successfully manage l\1edicare billing and collection. It further creates a blue print
that is applicable to similar action by VA, when reimbursement is authorized. IRS has had a
targeted goal for the use of its Medicare and Medicaid collections since inception: to improve
the quality of care, in particular, as indicated by accreditation, such as, the Joint Commission on
Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO). The JCAHO scores for the 2001
Corporate Survey of the six facilities within the Albuquerque IRS Area ranged from 92 to 97.
All were above the national average score of 88. This would seem to indicate that success in the
revenue collection program has con-elated with success in meeting the accreditation goal.
IHS has a 10-year exemption (through 2004) from reporting to CMS the actual cost of care. IHS
personnel have develop a process for capturing such data actually based on VA's data collection
model.
The American Legion is pleased with the progress in collections that VHA has made to date. If
VA is to provide timely access to quality care for veterans, MCCF must become a substantial
portion of VRA's operating revenue. The American Legion supports the President's FY 2004
budget request's legislative initiative requiring Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and
4
Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) to consider YHA a network provider or preferred
provider, respectively. This legislation would prevent HMOs and PPOs from using the lack of a
participating network or preferred provider agreement as a reason for non-payment to Y A for
services provided for other than urgent conditions.
If Y A can become a network provider or preferred provider for HMOs or PPOs, The American
Legion wonders why VA can't become a designated Medicare provider, as well.
The American Legion also supports another legislative initiative in the President's FY 2004
budget request to require enrolled veterans to identify all of the public and private health
insurance coverage to help facilitate Y A's billing and collection activities.
MEDICARE REIMBURSEMENT TO MCCF
Medicare is a Federal health insurance program. Nearly every person is mandated, by law, to
make monthly contributions to Medicare throughout his or her working career. Employees must
pay 1.45 percent of taxable wages. The employer must match that amount, yet unlike Social
Security, there is no cap. Therefore, the majority of beneficiaries make significant monetary
contributions to Medicare before ever becoming eligible for coverage. The more money made
by an individual, the higher the combined payment to Medicare. Medicare is a pyramid-based
funding scheme - spreading out the risk an10ng its potential beneficiaries and those who are
actually receiving coverage. Medicare is considered an entitlement; therefore, it receives annual
Federal mandatory appropriations.
Generally, any person is eligible for Medicare if:
• that person or their spouse worked for at least 10 years in a Medicare-covered employment,
• that person is 65 years of age or older, and
• that person is a citizen or permanent resident of the United States.
Others may qualify for coverage if:
• they are under age 65 with severe disabilities, or
• are diagnosed with end-stage renal disease (permanent kidney failure requiring dialysis or a
transplant).
Medicare has two basic components:
• Part A (Hospital Insurance) - basic coverage provided for allowable health care services.
• Part B (Medical Insurance) - additional coverage available on a premium basis for
additional health care services.
• Supplemental Coverage - available through private insurance providers on a premium basis
for charges not covered by Part A and Part B coverage.
Medicare offers certain choices to include:
• The original Medicare program, or
5
•
Medicare+Choice including Medicare Managed Care Plans and Medicare Private Fee-forService Plans.
VHA is the largest Federal integrated health care delivery system. Eligibility for enrollment in
VHA is based on honorable military service and limited by existing appropriations. Currently,
there are 24 million veterans. Nearly 7 million are currently enrolled in VHA, but thousands of
additional veterans are waiting to enroll. Currently, access to care is detennined on a priority
basis. Priority Group 1 has the highest priority to care, while Priority Group 8 has the lowest
priority to enroll for care. Each Priority Group is clearly defined in Title 38, United States Code
(USC).
Although access to VHA is an earned benefit, it is not considered an "entitlement"; therefore,
funding is dependent upon annual discretionary appropriations rather than mandatory
appropriations. Title 38, USC, identifies which veterans shall receive care at no personal cost.
VHA is authorized to bill, collect, and retain all co-payments and third-party reimbursements.
Even though Medicare is one of the Federal health insurance programs, VHA is prohibited from
billing or collecting third-party reimburselnents. There is no logical explanation or justification
for this prohibition in Title 38, USC, especially since IHS and DoD's TRICARE for Life include
Medicare's fee-for-service model in their systems.
After Congress finalizes the budget process, V A ' has a structured fonnula for the internal
distribution of its annual discretionary appropriations through VERA. This fonnula is based on
specific components that determine exactly how much money will go to each of the 21 VISNs.
Although the nUlnber of Medicare-eligible or Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans make up over half
of VA's patient population, they are not actual funding components in detennining distribution.
The funding components are based on:
• Number of veterans requiring basic care (vested and non-vested);
• Number of veterans requiring complex care;
• Geographic Price Adjustment;
• Research Support;
• Education Support;
• Equipment Support; and
• Nonrecurring Maintenance.
The Alnerican Legion strongly supports allowing VA to bill and collect from CMS for the
treatment of nonservice-connected disabilities of enrolled Medicare-eligible veterans.
As a Medicare provider, VHA would be authorized to bill and collect allowable third-party
reimbursements from the Medicare Trust Fund for the treatment of nonservice-connected
medical conditions of enrolled Medicare-eligible veterans. There are logical reasons to justify
Medicare reimbursements:
• Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) detennine Medicare-eligibility.
• All Medicare-eligible beneficiaries are free to choose their health care providers.
• Only military service detennines eligibility for enrollment in VHA - Medicare-eligibility is
not a factor.
6
•
•
•
•
•
•
VHA is mandated by law to bill and collect third-party rein1bursements for the treatment of
nonservice-connected medical conditions of enrolled veterans, except from Federal health
insurance programs like Medicare.
VHA is an integrated health care delivery system providing a full continuum of health care
services and treatinents .
IHS has successfully demonstrated how Medicare reimbursements can be successfully
accomplished to improve the quality of care to beneficiaries.
VHA does not receive adequate annual Federal discretionary appropriations to meet the
health care needs of its growing patient population.
Congressional oversight of CMS and VHA greatly reduces opportunities for fraud, waste,
or abuse in billing or treatment of Medicare-eligible beneficiaries.
The number of veterans emolled in VHA is contingent upon existing appropriations, copayments and third-party reimbursements.
The Medicare Trust Fund is funded to make reimbursements for quality health care delivered to
beneficiaries by qualified Medicare providers. VHA, like IHS, provides quality health care to a
unique patient population by using a combination of funding sources: discretionary
appropriations and third-party reimbursements.
Mr. Chairman, in passing the Veterans' Health Care Eligibility Reform Act of 1996, Pub. L. 104262, Congress required VA to furnish hospital care and medical services to, among others, any
veteran with a cOlnpensable service-connected disability or who is unable to defray the expenses
of necessary medical care and services. It further authorized the V A, with respect to veterans not
otherwise eligible for such care and services, to furnish needed hospital, medical, and nursing
home care.
The overwhelming response from the veterans' population was largely unanticipated and badly
under funded, leading to the recent suspension of Priority Group 8 veterans enrollment. The
American Legion believes the VHA is on the right track to developing the fiscal means to
comply with the Congress' intent to provide health care to all this nation's veterans. Allowing
access to all available Federal and non-Federal funding sources and to achieve the efficiencies
described above can only accelerate VA's compliance with that Inandate.
Finally, The American Legion is deeply concen1ed about veterans with no private health
insurance. The American Legion strongly recommends Congress consider authorizing VA to
offer health benefit packages on a premium basis much like DoD's TRICARE program. When
DoD was faced with n1eeting timely access standards for military retirees and dependents, it
created TRICARE which offers premium-based health benefit packages based on the individual
health care needs of its beneficiaries. The American Legion believes a similar benefit should be
made available for Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans, especially those cunently prohibited from
enrolling. The funds collected through premiuln-based health care plans would provide a much
needed additional revenue stream for an already over burdened system.
Thank you for this opportunity to present The American Legion views on this important topic.
That concludes my testimony.
7
Joe Hovish (2 copies)
A
For God and Country
National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Commission
1608 K Street, N.W. • washington, D.C. 20006
Paul A. Morin, Chairman - Massachusetts
Carol J. Rutherford, Director - Maryland
May 7, 2003
No. 12-03
STATEMENT OF
CATHLEEN 'VIBLEMO, DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR HEALTH CARE
NATIONAL VETERANS AFFAIRS AND REHABILITATION COMMISSION
THE AMERICAN LEGION
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS
COMMITTEE ON VETERANS' AFFAIRS
U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
ON
THE MEDICAL CARE COLLECTION FUND (MCCF)
MAY 7, 2003
Mr. Chainnan and Members of the Subcommittee:
Thank you for this opportunity to present The Alnerican Legion's views on the Medical Care
Collection Fund (MCCF). We commend the Subcommittee for holding a hearing on this
important program.
Public Law 105-33, the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, established the Department of Veterans
Affairs' (VA) MCCF and requires that amounts collected or recovered after June 30, 1997, be
deposited into this fund.
MCCF is a depository for funds collected from third-party
reimbursements from private insurance plans, outpatient prescription copayments and other
medical charges and user fees. The funds collected may only be used for providing VA medical
care and services and for VA expenses for identification, billing, auditing and collection of
amounts owed the Federal government.
Funds collected through MCCF are used as an offset rather than a supplement to annual
discretionary appropriations for V A ' s medical care budget. The efficient and timely collection
of these reimbursable costs greatly benefit the VHA in Ineeting the demands of an increasingly
overburdened system. By off-setting these funds VA loses valuable funding that is not an
"Pioneering Quality Service to veterans and Their Families"
accurate representation of the veterans' population in Veterans Equitable Resource Allocation
(VERA) formula nor does it allow for the full utility of collecting from the nation's largest health
insurance provider - Medicare.
Currently, VA distributes discretionary funds to its 21 Veterans Integrated Service Networks
(VISN s) using the detailed VERA fOllliula. Although VERA contains numerous allocation
components, neither the number of enrolled Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans nor the number of
enrolled Medicare-eligible Priority Group 7 or 8 veterans are allocation factors. Yet V A treats
these veterans for nonservice-connected medical conditions with the expectation of collecting
both co-payments and third-party reimbursements. When these Priority 7 or 8 veterans have no
private insurance or list Medicare as their third-party insurer, VA cannot recoup the reasonable
cost of care for the treatment of nonservice-connected medical conditions. Since over half of the
current enrolled population consists of Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans, this is an extremely
critical funding flaw.
These fundmnental elements are crucial to improving MCCF's ability to improve the level of
funding for VA health care. VA must have the ability to bill, collect and administrate more
effectively a system established to help recover third-party reimbursements for the treatment of
nonservice-connected medical conditions. MCCF needs to utilize a viable means to help V A
effectively recover third-party reimbursements owed to VA.
The use of model agencies'
successful collection system, such as the Indian Health Services (IRS), can increase the
efficiency of MCCF activities.
OFFSET OF MCCF TO DISCRETIONARY APPROPRIATIONS
Offsetting collections are monies that are deducted from outlays rather that counted on the
receipt side of the budget. Outlays are the amount of money the Federal government actually
spends in a given year. Offsets are often payments received for goods or services provided by
the Federal government, such as medical care given to veterans by VA who are already covered
under another health plan (public or private). The Debt Collection Improvement Act of 1996
(DCIA), Pub. L. 104-134, 110 Stat. 1321, (Apr. 26, 1996), as codified in 31 U.S.C. 3716(c),
requires the Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and other disbursing officials to offset
Federal payments to collect debts owed to the United States. This also applies to debts "owed"
to the Treasury by Federal agencies that calculate offsets into discretionary budgets.
Technically, MCCF is not considered a Treasury offset because the funds collected do not
actually go back to the MCCF Treasury account, but remain within VRA and are used as
operating funds. Instead, in developing a budget proposal, it appears that the total appropriation
request is reduced by the estimate for MCCF for the fiscal year in question. The American
Legion fails to understand the difference in the net effect to the VISNs and V AMCs . Offsetting
estimated MCCF funds largely defeats the purpose of realigning VHA's financial model to more
closely approximate the private sector. The American Legion adamantly opposes offsetting
annual VA discretionary funding by the MCCF recovery.
2
IMPROVING MCCF COLLECTIONS via INDIAN HEALTH SERVICES MODEL
Recent changes by the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) in the way medical care costs are
recovered has had a dramatically positive effect on the amount of revenue collected. The
implelTIentation of the VHA Revenue Cycle Enhancement Plan in early FY 2002 resulted in
significantly higher receipts than projected; so much so that VHA recently doubled the amount
VA expects to receive in FY 2004 from $1.03 billion to $2 .1 billion. However, MCCF systelTI
can benefit from agency models that clearly exemplify the efficiencies gained through practical
application.
Five members of The American Legion's National staff visited IHS Headquarters in Rockville,
MD to review and discuss the IHS experience with Medicare billing and collection. This was
followed by a site visit by four National staff members to the Albuquerque Area Office of IHS
for a detailed overview of the "Third Party Revenue Cycle." This was an extensive briefing on
the individuals, interactions and functions necessary to generate revenue collection, with a
particular emphasis on the Medicare component. Afterward, three National staff traveled to the
Acoma-Canoncita-Laguna (ACL) Hospital in San Fidel, NM for a demonstration of the billing
and collection process.
BACKGROUND
IHS was established to meet the government's responsibility to provide health care to Native
Americans. Like VA health care, it is not an "entitlement" program. Primary care is their basic
mission, but they also deal with Public Health issues, such as sanitation. IHS treats about 1.5
lTIillion patients a year (based on use within the past three years) of a population census of 2.2
million. There are about 50 facilities, many of them small rural clinics.
In 1976, Congress enacted title IV of the Indian Health Care Improvement Act (IHCIA) which
amended titles XIII (Medicare) and titles XIX (Medicaid) of the Social Security Act (SSA). This
allowed IRS to bill for Inedical services provided by IRS facilities to Native AlTIericans eligible
for Medicare (Part A) or Medicaid. Billing for Medicare Part B was authorized in 2002.
Initially, there was cultural and bureaucratic resistance to the billing and collection of Medicare
and Medicaid. In 1990, IRS collected only about $200,000. After absorbing significant cost
increases that were never funded in FY 1992-1996, an emphasis was placed on collections for
sheer survival. IHS now collects about $500 million a year. Of this, about $100 million is from
Medicare billing. The bulk of collections come from Medicaid, which is consistent with the
circumstances of the Native American population where, historically, there are lower incomes
and shorter life spans.
FINDINGS
Medicare billing and collection has been successfully implemented within IRS. The benefits of
successful ilnplementation:
../ Improved quality of care
../ Accurate and complete medical docun1entation
3
./
./
./
./
./
./
Enhanced provider profiling capabilities
Reduced n1alpractice and tOli action liability
Improved Risk Management for physicians and hospitals
Facilitated Quality Assurance
Compliance with rules and regulations
Third-party resource maximization
KEY ELEMENTS
In contrast to Department of Defense (DOD) Medicare Subvention Pilot Demonstration, illS has
no level of effort associated with its Medicare collection program. IHS collaborates with the
Services Center for Medicare and Medicaid, (eMS) through an advisory group that deals with
policy decisions. There must be "buy-in" from the top with leadership focused on and closely
monitoring the process. There was an initial investment in training people, and there was a
learning curve in the business process, where there is a deliberate billing process that requires
attention to detail. A maj or lesson learned was too lnuch emphasis on the billing process rather
than the collection of accounts receivable. Although billing is important, accounts receivable
activities ultimately determine a successful collection rate.
Everyone in the process must understand their role. The trmnlng of coders is extremely
important, and the coders should be certified. Pay grade of certified coders should be more
comparable to the private sector for successful recruitment and retention purposes. IHS and
DOD use electronic medical records that have the capability to generate billing infonnation. It
was suggested that software solutions are now available that make it feasible for VA to succeed
in the business practice.
CONCLUSION
The Indian Health Service's experience with Medicare collections demonstrates that a Federal
agency can successfully manage l\1edicare billing and collection. It further creates a blue print
that is applicable to similar action by VA, when reimbursement is authorized. IRS has had a
targeted goal for the use of its Medicare and Medicaid collections since inception: to improve
the quality of care, in particular, as indicated by accreditation, such as, the Joint Commission on
Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO). The JCAHO scores for the 2001
Corporate Survey of the six facilities within the Albuquerque IRS Area ranged from 92 to 97.
All were above the national average score of 88. This would seem to indicate that success in the
revenue collection program has con-elated with success in meeting the accreditation goal.
IHS has a 10-year exemption (through 2004) from reporting to CMS the actual cost of care. IHS
personnel have develop a process for capturing such data actually based on VA's data collection
model.
The American Legion is pleased with the progress in collections that VHA has made to date. If
VA is to provide timely access to quality care for veterans, MCCF must become a substantial
portion of VRA's operating revenue. The American Legion supports the President's FY 2004
budget request's legislative initiative requiring Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and
4
Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) to consider YHA a network provider or preferred
provider, respectively. This legislation would prevent HMOs and PPOs from using the lack of a
participating network or preferred provider agreement as a reason for non-payment to Y A for
services provided for other than urgent conditions.
If Y A can become a network provider or preferred provider for HMOs or PPOs, The American
Legion wonders why VA can't become a designated Medicare provider, as well.
The American Legion also supports another legislative initiative in the President's FY 2004
budget request to require enrolled veterans to identify all of the public and private health
insurance coverage to help facilitate Y A's billing and collection activities.
MEDICARE REIMBURSEMENT TO MCCF
Medicare is a Federal health insurance program. Nearly every person is mandated, by law, to
make monthly contributions to Medicare throughout his or her working career. Employees must
pay 1.45 percent of taxable wages. The employer must match that amount, yet unlike Social
Security, there is no cap. Therefore, the majority of beneficiaries make significant monetary
contributions to Medicare before ever becoming eligible for coverage. The more money made
by an individual, the higher the combined payment to Medicare. Medicare is a pyramid-based
funding scheme - spreading out the risk an10ng its potential beneficiaries and those who are
actually receiving coverage. Medicare is considered an entitlement; therefore, it receives annual
Federal mandatory appropriations.
Generally, any person is eligible for Medicare if:
• that person or their spouse worked for at least 10 years in a Medicare-covered employment,
• that person is 65 years of age or older, and
• that person is a citizen or permanent resident of the United States.
Others may qualify for coverage if:
• they are under age 65 with severe disabilities, or
• are diagnosed with end-stage renal disease (permanent kidney failure requiring dialysis or a
transplant).
Medicare has two basic components:
• Part A (Hospital Insurance) - basic coverage provided for allowable health care services.
• Part B (Medical Insurance) - additional coverage available on a premium basis for
additional health care services.
• Supplemental Coverage - available through private insurance providers on a premium basis
for charges not covered by Part A and Part B coverage.
Medicare offers certain choices to include:
• The original Medicare program, or
5
•
Medicare+Choice including Medicare Managed Care Plans and Medicare Private Fee-forService Plans.
VHA is the largest Federal integrated health care delivery system. Eligibility for enrollment in
VHA is based on honorable military service and limited by existing appropriations. Currently,
there are 24 million veterans. Nearly 7 million are currently enrolled in VHA, but thousands of
additional veterans are waiting to enroll. Currently, access to care is detennined on a priority
basis. Priority Group 1 has the highest priority to care, while Priority Group 8 has the lowest
priority to enroll for care. Each Priority Group is clearly defined in Title 38, United States Code
(USC).
Although access to VHA is an earned benefit, it is not considered an "entitlement"; therefore,
funding is dependent upon annual discretionary appropriations rather than mandatory
appropriations. Title 38, USC, identifies which veterans shall receive care at no personal cost.
VHA is authorized to bill, collect, and retain all co-payments and third-party reimbursements.
Even though Medicare is one of the Federal health insurance programs, VHA is prohibited from
billing or collecting third-party reimburselnents. There is no logical explanation or justification
for this prohibition in Title 38, USC, especially since IHS and DoD's TRICARE for Life include
Medicare's fee-for-service model in their systems.
After Congress finalizes the budget process, V A ' has a structured fonnula for the internal
distribution of its annual discretionary appropriations through VERA. This fonnula is based on
specific components that determine exactly how much money will go to each of the 21 VISNs.
Although the nUlnber of Medicare-eligible or Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans make up over half
of VA's patient population, they are not actual funding components in detennining distribution.
The funding components are based on:
• Number of veterans requiring basic care (vested and non-vested);
• Number of veterans requiring complex care;
• Geographic Price Adjustment;
• Research Support;
• Education Support;
• Equipment Support; and
• Nonrecurring Maintenance.
The Alnerican Legion strongly supports allowing VA to bill and collect from CMS for the
treatment of nonservice-connected disabilities of enrolled Medicare-eligible veterans.
As a Medicare provider, VHA would be authorized to bill and collect allowable third-party
reimbursements from the Medicare Trust Fund for the treatment of nonservice-connected
medical conditions of enrolled Medicare-eligible veterans. There are logical reasons to justify
Medicare reimbursements:
• Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) detennine Medicare-eligibility.
• All Medicare-eligible beneficiaries are free to choose their health care providers.
• Only military service detennines eligibility for enrollment in VHA - Medicare-eligibility is
not a factor.
6
•
•
•
•
•
•
VHA is mandated by law to bill and collect third-party rein1bursements for the treatment of
nonservice-connected medical conditions of enrolled veterans, except from Federal health
insurance programs like Medicare.
VHA is an integrated health care delivery system providing a full continuum of health care
services and treatinents .
IHS has successfully demonstrated how Medicare reimbursements can be successfully
accomplished to improve the quality of care to beneficiaries.
VHA does not receive adequate annual Federal discretionary appropriations to meet the
health care needs of its growing patient population.
Congressional oversight of CMS and VHA greatly reduces opportunities for fraud, waste,
or abuse in billing or treatment of Medicare-eligible beneficiaries.
The number of veterans emolled in VHA is contingent upon existing appropriations, copayments and third-party reimbursements.
The Medicare Trust Fund is funded to make reimbursements for quality health care delivered to
beneficiaries by qualified Medicare providers. VHA, like IHS, provides quality health care to a
unique patient population by using a combination of funding sources: discretionary
appropriations and third-party reimbursements.
Mr. Chairman, in passing the Veterans' Health Care Eligibility Reform Act of 1996, Pub. L. 104262, Congress required VA to furnish hospital care and medical services to, among others, any
veteran with a cOlnpensable service-connected disability or who is unable to defray the expenses
of necessary medical care and services. It further authorized the V A, with respect to veterans not
otherwise eligible for such care and services, to furnish needed hospital, medical, and nursing
home care.
The overwhelming response from the veterans' population was largely unanticipated and badly
under funded, leading to the recent suspension of Priority Group 8 veterans enrollment. The
American Legion believes the VHA is on the right track to developing the fiscal means to
comply with the Congress' intent to provide health care to all this nation's veterans. Allowing
access to all available Federal and non-Federal funding sources and to achieve the efficiencies
described above can only accelerate VA's compliance with that Inandate.
Finally, The American Legion is deeply concen1ed about veterans with no private health
insurance. The American Legion strongly recommends Congress consider authorizing VA to
offer health benefit packages on a premium basis much like DoD's TRICARE program. When
DoD was faced with n1eeting timely access standards for military retirees and dependents, it
created TRICARE which offers premium-based health benefit packages based on the individual
health care needs of its beneficiaries. The American Legion believes a similar benefit should be
made available for Priority Group 7 and 8 veterans, especially those cunently prohibited from
enrolling. The funds collected through premiuln-based health care plans would provide a much
needed additional revenue stream for an already over burdened system.
Thank you for this opportunity to present The American Legion views on this important topic.
That concludes my testimony.
7