Extracted text: Proceedings of the American Legion National Rehabilitation Conference, February 28-March 3, 1961 `
Extracted text: Proceedings of the American Legion National Rehabilitation Conference, February 28-March 3, 1961 ` results
Linna_Agne
Media of
Edited Text
PROCEEDINGS
The American Legion
National Rehabilitation Conference
HOTEL
STATLER
WASHINGTON,
FEBRUARY
D. C.
28- MARCH
3, 1961
PROCEEDINGS
The American Legion
National Rehabilitation Conference
HOTEL
STATLER
WASHINGTON,
FEBRUARY
D. C.
28- MARCH
3, 1961
Table
Tuesday
Afternoon
February
28,
of
Contents
Session
Page
1961
Call to order by Mr. Robert M. McCurdy,
Chairman of the National Rehabilitation
Commission. vescassssnssnsnssosionsseneesss
invocation
National
2 sleiere s
1
by Rev. William H. Moss,
Chaplain. sevessiesnosvnsssvmenssvesives
1
Greetings:
Mrs.
James
A.
DeForce,
Department
President,
District of Columbia, American Legion
AUXIN
ary. co ctv ive evininsnvesve essen sissivinsinis visio
2
Mrs. Bealon J. Orr, National Executive
Committeewoman,
District of Columbia,
American
Legion
Auxiliary....c..ci00eevnnnennn..
3
Mr. Joseph G. Weeda,
Department Commander,
Digtrict of Columbia.
ie vesnessanseiosnssnnsivin
3
Mr. Harold D.
Committeeman,
Beaton, National Executive
District of Columbia... ..cceesiniss
4
Mr. John J. Corcoran,
Director, National
Rehabilitation CommiSSion..
cessive sencevsnccnsis
4
Remarks:
Announcement
of
Conference
Rules...
ceezeeseosnss
5
Announcement of Conference Committee on
Recommendations. .ovesssesnvssecsvssunvosvsonsss
6
Insurance
7
Panel....ccvessivensesissssssnnnsoansontss
Address by Mr. P. J.
Director, Veterans
Budd, Acting Chief Insurance
Administration. .cescessceonns
10
Mr. John S. Gleason, Administrator of Veterans
Affairs. oon ivi vives Poise sicie v sPsiss un tualiin bre. thn a nee Ae
24
Address:
Wednesday Morning Session
March 1, :1961
Panel
on
VA
Automatic
Wednesday Afternoon
March 1, 1961
Panel
Page
on-New:
Data
Processing
Program....
29
(PL. 86-211).
cesses csicvee
75
Session
Pension
Law
Remarks:
Mr. Nicholas Lynch, Jr., Director, National
Pield Service von inenv sss sionsisnesocinisessns
vines 2d
Presentation
Panel
on
to
Mrs.
Veterans
and
Rachel
Koch...
vein ssiidicson
Dependents
ClaimS....c.e...
94
95
Thursday Morning Session
March 2, 1961
Invocation
National
Panel
on
by Rev. William H. Moss,
Chaplaif<scecoosvessesasswsnsmanmvensssr
Medical
and
Hospital
ServiceS...ccece...
L23
123
Address:
Dr. William S. Middleton,
Chief Medical
Director, Veterans Administration... ..ess.s.veni124
Remarks:
Mrs. J. Howard McKay, Chairman, National
Rehabilitation Commission, American
Legion AURELIary ue. vies cesses sion oicss.s since does
146
Panel on Veterans Administration Voluntary
SOY ViCOS ae suave sv issavesigvsaiseciuiaie
die
edsieinedeledilsy
Thursday Afternoon
March 2, 1961
Session
Remarks:
Mr. James W. Stancil, Chairman, Board of
Veterans Appeals, Veterans Administration......
162
Remarks:
Dr.
E.
Mandell,
VA
Policy
and
Evaluation
Staff..
169
Thursday Afternoon Session
March 2, 1961 (Cont'd)
Page
Remarks:
Mr. Robert H. Grant, Former Director,
Special Staff on Aging, Department of
Health, Education and Welfare... ....o<vrveor.-»
+174
Remarks:
Mr. Warren Roudebush, Acting Director,
Special Staff on Aging, Department of
Health, Education and Welfare......
ovens
Report
the
White
of
American
House
Legion
Conference
Delegates
to
176
on Aging......cceee...
179
Invocation by Rev. William Adams, Past
Department Commander,
District of Columbia...
185
Friday Morning Session
March 3, 1961
Remarks:
Mr. Warren H. MacDonald, Assistant Director
of Rehabilitation.
vee evis es esisestosesnivssnsssis
185
Panel on Vocational Rehabilitation
Bd
BANC AL LOD 5 sisie ss ieroiaserw dissin oioie. vis bin vin vi oie nintnie:. sr HBO
Remarks:
Mr. T. O. Kraabel,
Director, Vocational
Rehabilitation and Education,
Veterans Administration..eceececeecceccececccs
188
Address:
Honorable
Veterans'
Adjournment
MEETING
OF
Olin E.
Affairs
Teague, Chairman, House
Committee....c.cvevosssses
199
.ceeceecececescececscsocosccscccnscnsccn
204
REHABILITATION
Report
of
COMMISSION
Committee......e.o...
204
Report of Subcommittee on Certificates of
Appreciation. .ceessissssessessessssrsnisncnnins
210
Report
216
of
Recommendation
Subcommittee
on
Aging.....eceecessss
Friday
March
Morning
3,
Session
1961
Page
(Cont'd)
Report
of
Area
Report
of
Insurance
Benediction,
Commission
CRAITMANcelencsvasessnnssnssssnnes
Rev.
Ad
Advisory
Williams
Board.....ee.eve.-e
218
AdamS..c.ec.cocncnvee’:
219
ournment cee cs cv
JOINT SESSIONS OF COMMISSION
DELEGATES TO THE NATIONAL
217
cavsinsosetoncseorne
218
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND
COMMANDER'S CONFERENCE
Wednesday
Morning
SeSSioN.e.
ss ssessesisnvevveiann
220
Thursday
Afternoon
SesSsion..eevessssvsivssvsiaiv:
224
TUESDAY
AFTERNOON
FEBRUARY
28,
SESSION
1961
The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference of The
American Legion convened in the Congressional Room, Hotel
Statler, Washington, D. C., at 2 p.m.,Mr. Robert M. McCurdy,
Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Commission, presiding.
MR. McCURDY:
We have a full program with two distinguished speakers this afternoon.
To give us proper guidance and start on an
aesthetic tone this Rehabilitation Conference, we have with us today our National Chaplain,
the
Reverend William H. Moss.
REVEREND MOSS:
Just before I offer the prayer,
I want
to say that the most cherished letter that has come to me being your National Chaplain, was from a disabled veteran who
died only recently.
I would like to read just two sentences
from this letter.
with
I am
life
"I have had a stroke of paralysis,
and can only scribble
my injured hand and a pencil.
My stroke was heavy, but
grateful that I can think,
read, and reason clearly,
and
is still great
to me.”
I
May
we
thought
it
fitting
to
mention
that
for
this
Conference.
pray.
Most merciful God, we thank Thee for the Rehabilitation
Program of The American Legion.
It is truly the heart of our
organization.
We remember how important Thou didst make the
service to those who suffered and were in need, when
Thou
didst say, "Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least
of these ye have done it unto Me."
Oh, God, in turn, may we receive a blessing from men,
like the writer of the letter, who, from wheel chairs and
hospital beds can smile and say, "Life is still great to me."
most.
we not
it
was
Help us to gain from them the inspiration
For these comrades, who daily call on us
turn aside -- is our prayer.
In
Thy
Holy
MR.
McCURDY:
Comrades,
voted
to
by
Name,
dedicate
utmay
Amen.
Thank
this
to do our
for help,
you,
Chaplain
action
in
this
meeting
Conference
Moss.
assembled
in
the
yesterday,
memory
of
Watson B. Miller.
I am sure that you all knew Watson,
but in
keeping with the mandate of the Commission, we have prepared
a few words for the record, which I know express the thought
of all of us.
Watson B. Miller,
a gentleman with a gallantry of the
old school, with an intellect sharp and witty, with a compassion of the deepest, with an understanding of the broadest,
with the executive and administrative capacity of the greatest, with a friendliness of the most far reaching, with affection for family and friends, with a sincerity, with a devotion
to the Almighty,
and a loyalty to the country beyond question,
1
and with a personality of the most engaging.
That was our
distinguished and late departed friend, Watson Miller,
at rest
in the bosom of the verdant hills of Arlington,
enshrouded in
the
modst
of
eternity.
His legacy to us was a lifetime of work and talent in
behalf of others.
Gone, but not forgotten, departed and yet
living in the hearts of all of us, his spirit abides this day
and the days to come whenever and wherever the cause of the
nation;s endeavors engage the thoughts and words of his fellow
countrymen,
his colleagues,
and The American Legion.
From the deep recess of our composite heart, we
you, Watson,
and we give thanks for what you have done
for what you have been,
I
Watson
would ask
Miller.
A
to
stand
one
of
silence
was
observed.
McCURDY:
Thank
you,
Comardes.
moment
MR.
We
Comrades
greeting
you
have with us on
and ladies,
and
at this time.
First, we have Mrs.
President of the District
liary, Mrs. DeForce.
minute
in
the platform some
I am going to ask
silence
most
them
James A. DeForce,
the
of Columbia, American
salute
and
for
distinguished
for a word of
Department
Legion Auxi-
MRS. DEFORCE:
Mr, Chairman, National Commander Burke,
Mr. Corcoran,
distinguished guests,
and delegates to this
Conference,
to rehabilitate is defined as ''to reestablish,
to
reinstate,
or to put or bring into good repute again."
This is exactly what we of The American Legion Auxiliary are attempting.
Our aim and purpose is to restore the
veteran through a service of repair -- the worker to industry,
the citizen to society,
the man to himself.
In this Department,
as in others, we accomplish these results through the
leadership of our Rehabilitation Chairman and our volunteer
hospital director.
We sponsor regularly scheduled parties at
all the hospitals
in which there are veterans.
We have Christman
all
gift
free
shops
of
where
the
charge,
gifts
veterans
for
may
their
select
families.
and
have
mailed,
We have carnivals and watermelon parties on the hospital grounds.
We have parties for special holidays.
Our hospital workers work ikumany fields in the VA hospitals and by so
doing,
enable the nurses and hospital personnel to have more
time
for
the
disabled
veteran.
Nationally we have a new program of Volunteens which
gives our juniors a chance to not only keep themselves busy,
but to do worthwhile work in the VA hospitals.
A brand new
program is being slowly put into action here this year called
Companion Therapy, which simply means beside visits to a
specific patient over the period of time required to give the
patient the specific help needed both mentally and physically.
Each
year,
we
give
special
gifts
to
the
hospital
such
as
comfort and
TV sets, which directly add to the patients;
the man and wife teams in our hospital
We encourage
pleasure.
they are able to do much for the hospitalized
Together,
work.
I understand that again our national organization
veteran.
sum to the Legion for its replans to give a substantial
rehabilitation work in addition to all of the programs we carry
So you see, we of The American Legion Auxiliary not
out.
only say we shall, but we do participate in and contribute to
the aims and purposes of The American Legion.
We are proud to be
and we of the Department
that The American Legion
that we do.
an Auxiliary to The American Legion,
of the District of Columbia hope
will always be proud of the work
It is indeed an honor to extend to you greetings from
The American Legion Auxiliary, Department of the District of
Columbia,
and to wish for you a most constructive Conference.
May God grant you wisdom and courage along the path of peace
with justice for all and may you in your wisdom help keep our
asking God's blessing and his
great country strong and free,
help, but knowing that here on earth God's work must be done
truly as our own.
Thank
MR.
National
umbia,
you,
McCURDY:
Executive
Mrs.
Bealon
We
have
another
Committeewoman
J.
distinguished
the
from
lady,
the
of
Col-
District
Orr.
MRS. ORR:
Mr. Chairman,
allyou fine Legionnaires,
all
I am delighted to be here and
and guests,
Auxiliary members,
to greet you on this very important occasion and to say weleven though you have been
come to the District of Columbia,
here many times.
I hope that you will have a happy visit,
and
may you have a most successful Conference.
Thank
MR.
you
very
McCURDY:
much
for
inviting
Thank
you
Mrs,
I might tell you if you are
ing the Womens Division take care
them any time.
me.
Orr.
in
of
trouble for
Just
that.
We have some distinguished Comrades and I
to you the Department Commander of the District
Mr. Joe. GCG. Weeda, Joe.
food or
consult
houswith
want to present
of Columbia,
MR. WEEDA:
Chaplain Moss, Mr. Chairman,
delegates to
if I were a Commissioner
this 38th Rehabilitation Conference,
of the District of Columbia,
which I am not, of course,
I
would bid you welcome to this city named after the first President and founder of our country,
George Washington.
I would,
of course,
invite you to visit all of our government facilities.
I would also want to remind you that there are three and a half
million dollars worth of them for which the District of Columbia
receives no taxes.
They are exempt.
I
Secondly,
if I were
certainly would ask you
President
Kennedy
has
not
the President of the Board of
to spend and spend lavishly.
declared
Washington
to
be
a
Trade,
Although
depressed
economic
11
and
area,
February
yet
with
11,
our
the
70
inches
merchants
of
snow,
could
use
between
the
December
money.
But,
as
the Department Commander of the District,
and on behalf of all
my comrades here, we certainly bid you a hearty welcome.
We
certainly hope that your goals and your aims, and the purposes
for which you meet today will be further accomplished and we
certainly do, in our own
way, want to help any of you.
Our
facilities,
what limited facilities we have, are open to you.
Do not ask us to do anything for you that might be illegal,
immoral,
or sinful.
That we cannot do,
But I think we can
do just about everything else.
So let me extend this welcome
to
you.
If we can be of
quarters, . Thankiyou,
of
service to you,
Mr. Chairman.
MR.
McCURDY:
Thank
Our
National
Executive
Columbia
is
present,
also
you
give
us
a
call
at
head-
Commander.
Committeeman
Mr.
Harold
from
D.
the
District
Beaton.
Comrade
Beaton.
MR. BEATON:
Chairman McCurdy, National Chaplain Moss,
members of this National Rehabilitation Conference,
it is
indeed a great honor and pleasure for me to welcome you on
behalf of the Department of the District of Columbia.
Yours
is a dedicated task.
1 can think of offhand no higher aim in
life than to dedicate ourselves
to the rehabilitation of our
worthy veterans and their needy families.
I know that you
are anxious to hear the words of wisdom from Mr. Budd of the
Veterans Administration on the VA program and that you are
also looking forward to hearing from our Past National Commander, Jack Gleason,
who is presently the Administrator of
Veterans!
Affairs.
So
may
I be
brief.
I bid you welcome.
I bid you Godspeed in your endeavors.
I bid you fruitful deliberations,
a pleasant stay with us here
in the District of Columbia,
and a safe journey home.
Thank
you very much.
MR. McCURDY:
While the Commander was a little chicken
and declared himself out of some of your problems, Hal tells
me he will take charge of all the liquor and police problems
that you may have.
just
Thank you,
gave you.
informs
charge
Hal,
for
that
fine
volunteer
offer
The Commander always takes a legal approach.
me that he is an attorney and it is
too bad
him for
the
ad,
but
he
Now,
.I would like to
Corcoran,
who will ~xnlain
remarks
to the Conference.
New York and Washington.
MR.
watch
space,
he
that
He
we
now
can't
call on'our Director,
John: J.
the rules and bring the opening
Our Director, John J. Corcoran,
better
said
I
professionally.
you
he
Bob,
you
the Commander for advertising
advice that he gave us.
When
CORCORAN:
wants
that
they
could
4
do
may
out.
charge
everything
You
of
charge
you
except
for
that
the
which was illegal,
anything left that
I
would
immoral,
and sinful,
I
was of any interest to
like
to
make
just
one
or
wondered
anybody.
two
the
the
past.
The
of
these
Rules.
so:
this
the
ones
that
and
have
Rehabilitation
I
won't
name
than
as
take
will
No.
2.
without
‘No
No. 3.
Conference is
the Committee
of
used
has
and
applied
approved
They
are
in
the
rather
use
short
long.
seeking
use the
Department
once
been
now.
was
of our Conference.
The Conference Rules
Commission
read them
No. 1.
Any person
upon recognition,
shall,
her
same
there
announcements
an administrative nature at the beginning
The first point is the Conference Rules.
are
if
before
person
shall
unanimous
to address
microphone
the
and
Conference
state his or
proceeding.
speak
on
the
same
subject
more
consent.
Any recommendation raised on the floor of the
to be submitted in writing by its sponsor to
on Recommendations,
through the staff liaison
representative,
as
soon
after
a
word
of
representatives
to
the
the
close
of
the
session
as
practical.
Let
son
me
add
explanation
Committee
there.
on
staff
liai-
Recommendations,
The
which
Bob McCurdy will announce as soon as I finish,
are:
Warren
MacDonald and Ray macdouall.
They will work
with the Committee
as they have
in previous years, during the week.
They will
also see that the necessary stenographic and clerical assistance
are
available
and
they will
be up
recommendations
that
are
proposed
submitted in writing
soon as possible and
the convenient
time.
to
at
one
the
here
on the platform.
The
during
the session
should
be
of those
close of
staff representatives
as
the session,
if that is
No. 4.
The Committee on Recommendations shall receive
and consider all recommendations of the National Conference,
and shall report on same to the National Rehabilitation Commission at its meeting on Friday.
No. 5.
The Committee on Recommendations
shall hold such
meetings as it may deem necessary to consider all recommendations so received and to prepare its report;
such technical
and administrative services as may be required to be supplied
by the staff liaison representatives.
No. 6.
The Committee on Recommendations
is empowered to
consolidate duplicate recommendations,
to restate recommendations in proper form, without changing their intent,
and to
prepare such other recommendations
as directed.
No. 7.
In its report to the Commission,
the Committee
on Recommendations
shall recommend approval,
approval with
amendment,
rejection,
or further study by the Commission,
of
each recommendation
as it sees fit.
Another
announcement,
Many
of
you
like
the
would
so
that
you
can
service
Veterans
review
this
one
officers
have
Administration
them
in
5
the
not
on
the
rules.
notified
to
Central
call
us
in
Office.
that
certain
I
you
cases
remind
you that those cases
are available in Sam Rose's office on the
first floor in the Veterans Administration Central Office,
and
I hope that you will find time this week to review the file.
If you need any help from one of our staff members,
please let us know.
We have asked our staff people to make
themselves available to you at all times throughout
the week,
that is, at all times up until about midnight.
If you want to
find one of the staff, you can find him either by checking
over in The Legion Headquarters with our Chief of Contact,
or
here at the registration desk.
We have been asked by the House Veterans Committee to
call to the attention of those of you who have not seen this,
that they have published what they
call a calculator.
It is. a
rather handy device which provides some basic information.
To
this extent,
those of you who are completely familiar with rates
of compensation,
and the educational and loan provisions,
and
the
places
would
and
not
need
nature
this
of
hospitals
through
your
Department
calculator.
On the other hand,
for those of you who would find some
benefit in this essential
and basic information,
this calculator is" available,
The price,
according to. this, is 60
cents.
The House Committee said that,
anticipating somewhat
large gales,
they can make them available for 30 cents,
so we
will have a supply of these at the registration desk beginning
tomorrow.
If
haven't
back
you
been
the
out
in
them,
they are 50
because the House
calculators
The
make is
tribute
want
hurt
last:
not
and
the
that
comment,
you
Mr.
don't
cents.
If you
Committee will
pick
Chairman,
don't,
simply
we
take
up.
that
I
would
like
to
of an administrative nature, but it is a note of
respect to someone who is a staff employee sitting
audience.
We
have
reference
to
Rachel
Koch.
Rachel,
as most of you know,
is retiring today from her employ with
The American Legion National Rehabilitation Commission.
She
has completed a service of over 39 years in the Rehabilitation
Commission.
She has seen that Commission and its staff grow
from
a
one
or
two-man
for many years
Dependents and
ference
to
office
to
its
assist
the
reporter
with
information,
Rachel
volunteered
to
ference,
though
technically
and
severs
for
even
as
of
status.
Rachel,
names
work
and
other
through
legally
her
of
Con-
technical
this
Con-
employment
today.
I wonder
Rachel,
as
MR.
present
in addition to having been our Supervisor
Veterans'
Claims,
has the
job during this
if you could
I ask her to
CORCORAN:
Thank
join me
stand.
in a moment
(Applause).
of
you
much.
you,
very
Thank
applause
Mr.
Chair-
man.
MR, cMcCURDY: . Rachel,
TI just want to add
never forget your retirement date.
I, too, am
from service with the City of Pasadena of more
This is also my retirement date, and I propose
have a good party.
We
have
to
announce
the
Recommendations
6
that IT will
retiring today
than 30 years.
we go out and
Committee,
and
it
as
he
is
has not been possible for me
yet, and if there is any one
cannot serve, will he please
adjourned?
From
Price
Area
of New
A,
Fred
Clough
York;
from
Area
to contact all these people
that is appointed that feels
contact me before this meeting
of
C,
Maine;
Stan
from Area
Hudson
of
B,
Arthur
Kentucky;
from
Area D, "Skin" Laid of Iowa; and from Area E, K. Klemmetson
of Washington.
That is a subcommittee of the Commission.
They
are all Commission members and will serve as the Conference
Committee on Recommendations,
who will give their final report
on Friday.
We now will start with our official program,
and as you
know,
and which I would like to mention again, we have a most
important sub-theme,
"Aging with Dignity," and if we all think
of that,
aging with dignity is one of the greatest accomplishments that we could do for our
World War I men who are aging,
and now we are getting into World War II men that are aging.
What higher purpose or greater goal could this group of
dedicated folks have then to guarantee
these men their aging
with dignity?
So I commend the staff that selected this theme
for this Conference,
and I believe that for everything we do,
and not only we, but those other
fine committees and commissions
of The Legion that are meeting here jointly with us, we will
find a great program in our theme and I am sure we all are
happy about it.
One thing that lightens
the burden of the Chairman -- it
is not a burden, Comrades:
it is a lot of fun because you
fellows have been such nice guys to work for and with,
although
it
does
take
time
and
effort
--is
having
outstanding
and
fine
Vice Chairmen who have always stood ready and willing to share
a part of the work,
and presiding at this afternoon's meeting,
we have one of our very fine Vice Chairmen from the Department
of Illinois,
our Vice Chairman,
Comrade Milton Applebaum,
and
I am going to ask Milton to take over at this time.
Milton.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, Bob.
My function here will
be primarily to introduce at this time the members of our panel.
I want to direct your attention to the fact that we start on
page 4 and we are running ahead of schedule.
I believe we will
expect the Veterans Administrator,
the speaker of the afternoon,
to appear here somewhat earlier than on our printed schedule,
so
you will understand that we may interrupt our discussion for the
purpose of receiving our distinguished visitor at that time.
At
minute,
are
on
this time,
1
and await our
the
printed
am going to ask you all
Legion panelists.
Will
program
come
up
to
the
to relax for a
the members who
platform?
Let
me
introduce to you the panelists who are here:
Roy Riley of
Alabama;
Leland L. Day of Colorado,
Ralph J. Henry, Missouri;
and our staff representative Chuck Mattingly.
He is getting
our panel together so he will be up later.
MR. CORCORAN:
Milt,
let me interrupt for a minute.
Veterans Administration officials have not arrived yet, so
your indulgence,
I will make a few additional remarks.
I
ference
might allude somewhat briefly
that we are having tlis year.
7
to
I
the new
am sure
The
with
type of Conit has come to
your notice that this year we have something larger and bigger,
and we all hope better,
than the Conference that we have had
in the past.
This year the National Commander has combined at
the time of our meetings,
the annual meetings of the Rehabilita-
tion
Commission
and
Conference,
meetings
of
all
such
other
Commission that usually meet in Washington.
The National Commander has assigned to this Conference which,
as you know,
is
the National Commander's Conference,
an over-all theme, namely,
"The American Legion in America's Future,” As Bob mentioned a
few minutes ago,
the National Rehabilitation Commission has
adopted as its sub-theme - "Aging With Dignity."
The Commander has charged all Commissions
to appraise
their present structure,
organization,
program,
and mission
with particular attention to the needs of the future.
While
we recognize in the National Rehabilitation Commission that
the needs of veterans and their survivors are varied and many,
we felt that if we had to select one particular program to
devote special attention to it would be the problem of aging.
As Bob indicated,
we are devoting increased emphasis
and attention,
therefore,
at this time in the immediate and
the long-range future to the problem of the aging and aged
veteran,
I
need
not
mention
‘that
the
problems
include
the
in
econo-
mic difficulties,
the social difficulties,
the housing difficulties,
and many others.
We felt that if we could completely
satisfy the sub-theme that we have adopted,
that is, "Aging
with Dignity,'" as far as the aging war veteran is concerned,
we would be doing him the greatest possible service.
In the field,
for example,
of non-service-connected
pension,
if we provide a disability pension to the aging
veteran that permits him to maintain his dignity and his standing in the community,
then we have done both him and the country
a great service.
So we wanted to call your attention at this
time,
and I think it was most appropriate that we do
that,
the
fact that we have a place this year in a larger group of meetings, namely,
the National Commander's Conference.
I think it would also be timely to say a few words at
this time on the program of the National Rehabilitation Commission for the coming year.
As you know,
the program of the
Commission is established and is assigned by the policy-making
bodies of the Legion.
The first step in this policy-making procedure is the
National Rehabilitation Commission,
but it is the National
Executive Committee and it is the National Convention which
establishes the program that we are given to execute.
We have
over 80 resolutions currently in effect, which require some
action by the National Rehabilitation Commission,
and its staff.
Over 30 of these are legislative in nature.
The balance require either administrative action or some research and study
on the part of the staff and the
Commission.
In order to properly execute this mission,
the Rehabilitation Commission has taken what I think is a unique step in
the national organization.
It has established a particular
section of the staff with the immediate responsibility of making sure that the program we are given is adequately executed.
8
The
in
name
charge
Warren
of
of
that
section
to
to
all
our
completely
given
to
us
We
is
think
the
Program
one
that
of
our
we
can
Management
Section,
assistant
say,
directors,
therefore,
of you Legionnaires and we think we
Commission,
we are doing everything
execute
by
is
section
MacDonald,
assurance
assurance
to
that
the
Generally,
I
and
satisfactorily
policy-making
think
we
bodies
could
say
perform
and
with
can say
that we
the
with
can
platform
of
The
American
that
the
program
Legion.
we
are
given falls into three categories.
One is in the Claims category.
You are most concerned with that here this week.
I think you
will agree,
those of you who have had experience with us, we have
at your disposal in Washington a rather complete,
and I say
adequate,
staff of Claims specialists.
As you know, we have specialists on the Appeals Section,
on the Discharge Review Section, Correction Boards, Death
Claims, Veterans'
Claims,
and Insurance.
We try to cover
every possible field in the claims category.
You also know that
we have available expert medical and legal advice.
We have very
qualified professional men assisting these Claims representatives
when complicated medical and legal issues arise.
So I
part
ma jor
would say that
of our program
speaking in generalities,
is the Claims effort.
the
first
A second major part or aspect is the one to which I referred before,
that is, the area of making sure that the program is executed.
As a kind of a subdivision of that, we have
a very important responsibility and that is the research and
information
field,
also
under
Warren
MacDonald
Management Section.
We have placed in that
ponsibility for performing complete research
benefits
and
both
Commission
the
then
supplying
and
to
the
the
product
men
and
of
in
the
Program
Section the resinto veterans’
that
women
research
in
the
to
field.
Now,
this particular function is not to be lightly
taken.
Constantly,
studies are being performed by the cognizant agencies in the government,
such as the Veterans Administration and the House Veterans'
Affairs Committees.
Studies
are being performed appraising and evaluating the veterans;
programs.
It is necessary that we atthe very least stay abreast
of these studies and, where possible,
that we enable ourselves
and
empower
in
the
ourselves
to
anticipate
proposals
that
may
be
made
future.
This research takes us into sociological fields,
takes
us into economic fields,
and we are trying, as I said,
to give
sufficient attention to that endeavor and to make sure that the
Commission receives the results of our investigation so that
The Legion will be in a position to take a responsible stand on
any proposal that is made.
The last general area into which I would categorize our
national program is the legislative area.
As you know,
the
Legislative Commission has the ultimate responsibility for the
proper execution of the legislative program.
Therefore,
we work
in cooperation with and generally under the aegis of the National
Legislative Commission.
It is always somewhat hazaraous to
attempt to establish any priority of legislative proposals,
but
it is equally true that when you have resolutions,
over 30 of
them, calling for legislation,
it is just physically impossible
to devote the same amount of time and attention to all of these
9
resolutions.
Therefore, we have narrowed dowm to a smaller number at
the request of the Director of the Legislative Commission,
the
number of resolutions which we feel will require the most em-
phasis
and
require
the
most
effort
in
the
coming
year.
Incidentally,
the National Commander
touched upon several
of these this morning at the hearing before the House Veterans’
Affairs Committee.
The first one that we put on our list is the request that
Congress grant increases
in the rates of disability and death
compensation.
I won't go into detail on that, except to say
that we feel it is necessary for the Congress to face the
realities of the times that we are in, to give accord to the
inflationary spiral,
and to make the appropriate adjustments in
disability and death compensation.
Another major proposal is to ask the Veterans Administration to expand its medical care of the aged.
This may or
may not require legislation.
Another one, and this is very
important,
is to attempt to have
reopened for one
year the
National Service Life Insurance program.
We will be calling
on you ladies and gentlemen during the year for help on that
gone, and the others,
The last one that I would mention at this time
is a
demand on the part of The American Legion that Congress appropriate sufficient funds for the orderly and liberal administration of the entire VA program.
Mr.
Chairman,
like to make
Commission.
MR.
including
that
concludes
on the program
Thank you.
of
the
the
remarks
National
APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, .John.,.
T
Walter Kownaski from New York.
that
I
would
Rehabilitation
think we are all
here
Walter,
take a bow.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
When the Empire State is represented,
I
think we can proceed.
Our distinguished guests are here and
you will notice from your
program that we have Mr. P. J.
Budd,
Acting Chief Insurance Director of the Veterans Administration,
here in Washington.
Mr. Budd, would you like to
a pleasure to have you here and I
answers from you for sure, now.
ADDRESS OF P. J. BUDD,
VETERANS ADMINISTRATION:
and
I
MR.
BUDD;
are
pleased
Mr.
to
ACTING
Chairman,
have
introduce your staff?
It is
know we are going to get the
the
today.
We have had a number
we assume that you will have
ladies
CHIEF
INSURANCE
and
gentlemen,
opportunity
to
appear
of questionssubmitted
more from the floor.
DIRECTOR,
my
staff
before
to us
you
and
Before we begin with the questions,
I would like to mention several items that I feel will be of interest to vou.
They were of interest to your Insurance Advisory Board, when
we met Saturday afternoon,
and I hope they are to you, also.
Everyone
is
aware
of
President Kennedy's
10
instructions
to the VA, that we pay the 1961 dividends as quickly as possible.
It did not take us long to buckle down and get
things under
way.
The question was asked Saturday about the man who has an
option other than cash,
and leaves his dividends on deposit or
wants them for credit under the old P. L. 36.
What happens
to
him?
We are processing his dividend credit at the same time,
All veterans who have options other than cash are being credited
now in accordance with the option they had chosen.
They will
receive a statement from us showing the new credit and the new
balance.
Another question that seems to always come up currently is
disaussion groups,
is the special dividend.
This might anticipate some of the questions you might have.
Much interest has
been expressed in the President's statement that he hoped that
a special dividend could be paid this fall,
To date, no decision has been reached.
Early next week, we will take a preliminary step and lay
the facts before the Administrator,
Mr.
Gleason, who then will be in a position to determine what the
next step will be.
We anticipate that Mr. Gleason will want
to place this
matter before his Insurance Actuarial Advisory Committee and we
in the Department,
of course,
are anxious for a determination
because if there is to be special dividends in the fall, we will
need all the time, we can get to develop the ground rules and
the mechanics for paying them.
One last word.
Let me just say a word about ADP, Automatic
Data Processing.
I know that you know that there is ADP in the
Department of Veterans'
Benefits,
Maybe you don't know that we
also have
3,000,000 national life insurance accounts in Philadelphia on magnetic tape.
We have converted our N.S.L.I.
records --those are the World War II -- in Philadelphia.
We have
not converted World War 1, the U.S.G.L.I.,
nor have we converted our records in Denver or St. Paul.
Our plans today
provide that we will start converting our Denver insurance
records in October of this year,
and finish by April of 1962;
and that we will start converting our St. Paul records in May
of 1962,
and: finish in October of 1962.
There
is
a
chance
that
we
will
not
proceed
as
scheduled.
We can assure you that we will be the first to recommend further delay in the conversion of these offices,
if we have the
slightest fear that
we cannot convert smoothly and maintain
a service to our veterans
that meets our high standards.
Probably the best thing to do is to start
tions.
Before we do, let me introduce my staff
first gentleman is Mr. Robert Brown.
He is the
Insurance Director.
him
The next gentlemen
probably many times.
Department
of
Insurance.
is Mr,
He is
The
Oliver Clay.
the Insurance
next
gentleman
Mr. McGurn, Director of Insurance Claims.
is Tom Willett,
Director of Underwriting.
man is Ernie Benke,
the Manager of our VA
Colorado.
MR.
APPLEBAUM:
Conferees,
11
I
want
to
on the questo you.
The
Deputy Chief
You have seen
Counsel for the
you
have
seen
also,
The next gentleman
And the next gentleCenter in Denver,
point
out
to
you
the
two mikes in the center aisle.
They are stationary mikes,
and
at the question period be sure you get in front of the mike to
get the attention of the Chairman,
inasmuch as we want every
question heard distinctly by all of you,
as well as, perhaps
more
has
important,
worked
Legion
for
on
the
answers
veterans'
many
years
to
thereto.
insurance
come
back
I
on
to
do
expect
behalf
the
of
the
The
platform
man
who
American
and
I refer
to none other than Past National Commander, Milo J. Warner of
Ohio,
and when he comes in, I will ask him to take a bow in
case any of you should not be acquainted with Milo.
So he
will be back,
I am sure.
cussion
Meanwhile,
leaders,
may
Roy
I turn the meeting
Riley of Alabama?
over
to
one
of
our
dis-
MR. RILEY:
Mr. Chairman,
as you know, Alabama is quite
wet at this time,
and I sincerely hope that I shall not feel
the same when this panel is over.
However, we do have a very
interesting discussion here this afternoon based upon the questions that have been submitted and I think in all fairness to
those people who submitted the questions that we shall answer
the printed questions before entertaining any questions from
the audience.
As a member of the Insurance Advisory Board,
and I consider that a high privilege,
I am very much concerned with and
interested in legislation that will be sponsored this year by
The American Legion and that is the reopening of the national
life insurance for at least one year to give those boys who
allowed their insurance to lapse,
the opportunity of obtaining
the same.
In my humble opinion,
I believe that last year was our
greatest opportunity to have this legislation passed.
Unfortunately,
it failed.
This year, we have the same opportunity,
but our position may be weaker.
I do not know.
I say, again
in my own opinion,
our position may grow weaker each year, not
only from the standpoint of aging of the veteran, but from the
growing resistance of the large insurance companies.
Let me urge you, my comrades, when the staff calls upon
you for support to not hesitate to let the word get out in your
respective states not only to members of The American Legion,
but to rank and file veterans throughout the country,
that they
need contact their Congressman.
I don't care how, but you have
telegraph lines or whatever you want to call them
in your
section of the country.
Let them contact that way, telephone,
personal contact,
or any way they can.
We musthave the support
from the members in the field if we are to secure this legislation.
I believe at this time,
I should like to turn the mike
to Milton Applebaum.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
I do want to introduce Milo Warner, who
I announced before, was temporarily absent from the platform,
Past National Commander,
Milo J. Warner of Ohio, who has been
Chairman and is now Chairman of the Insurance Advisory Board to
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
Past Commander Warner.
The
rules
of
our
Conference
permit
us to
give
privileges should he hear something that he wishes
bute from his vast experience and knowledge.
12
him
to
floor
contri-
I think we should
questions at least,
and
now proceed,
conferees,
to the
then go forward from there.
printed
MR. RILEY:
Thank you, Milton.
I am going to call on
the members of the panel to read the printed questions and I
shall ask Mr. Kownaski of New York to read questions 1 and 2,
Mr. Day of Colorado to read questions 3 and Mr. Henry to read
questions 4 and 5.
I am sure that they do not desire to answer
the questions and will refer them to members of the Veterans
Administration.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
Akin of Georgia.
total disability
appealed?
connected
of
The
The
first
question
rejection
was
based
disability.
Mr.
Budd,
MR.
‘BUDD:
Tom
Willett
MR.
WILLETT:
Insurance
was
May the rejection of an
income provisions
(TDIP)
Yes.
for
It
has
been
a number
of
upon
will
a
our
take
where
by Mr.
minor
answer
policy
years
very
you
will
submitted
application for the
to an
NSLI policy be
service
that?
it,
in
the
the
.Department-
rejection
of
an
application,
involving medical examination,
is due to an impairment which is not acceptable from a selection point of
view,
the
veteran
has
the
opportunity
to
come
back
to
the
District Office and protest.
Upon review.of this protest by
the District Office,
they still feel they must
reject the
application,
our procedure provides that the application and
insurance file be sent to the Central Office for final review.
It is reviewed by our medical consultant within the Department
of Insurance from an insurability standpoint,
that is, medically.
When required our doctor or lay medical examiner will consult
the Department of Medicine and Surgery for the specialist's
viewpoint as to whether or not this impairment
is one that can
be waived.
We have in many instances overlooked certain impairments.
In other cases, we have asked the rating boards
to review the rating again to see whether or not they could include this minor disability,
that you refer to in the basic
rating.
Veterans have had,
as I say, over the years many opportunities and have submitted many cases through the District Offices
to Washington for the final review.
We are not permitted to
submit
these
to
the
Board
by the General Counsel's
that these cases are not
bility.
Therefore,
they
Appeals.
But
resentatives
have
reversed
there
here
the
are
in
of
Appeals.
There
has
been
a
ruling
Office in the Veterans Administration
benefits.
These are cases of insurashould not be given to the Board of
many,
many
Washington
District
instances,
can
Offices,
vouch
and
and
for
that,
suggested
your
rep-
where
that they
we
accept the application or call for an additional or supplemental
examination which would lead them to accept the application.
Thank you.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
Any
comments
from
the
conferees?
Now, we will go to question number 2.
What,
is being done to improve the handling of insurance
with the Automatic Data Processing Center?
to
we
MR. BUDD:
We have given an awful lot
this.
This is an area that has troubled
have devoted a lot of time and attention
13
of
us
to
if anything,
deductions
time and effort
very much, and
it, and I would
like to ask Mr. Melidosian, who is our Manager at the VA
delphia Insurance Office,
to speak on this because this
something he has been very close to.
MR.
MELIDOSIAN:
Thank
Philais
you.
Needless to say,
this subject has attracted a great deal
of attention.
You folks discussed it in Miami.
We honestly
think that there is a real improvement
taking place in the area.
I am not going to start back and talk about discontinuances,
the problem of whether we get it from the Hines Center to our
own center,
and then start the Data Processing,
but I think to
bring you up to date, we should tell you that for the past two
months,
and it is
going to continue in the next month and as
long as it is
necessary,
we have been
reconsiling the tape
records that we have in Philadelphia against the tape records
that are at Hines and we have washed out a great number of
discrepancies.
These discrepancies as far as the insurance
is
concerned,
are minor in nature.
However,
they are sufficient
that they disturb his account,
so 1 ami sure that he is really
not concerned about the extent of the discrepancy on the tape
record, but the fact that he is not getting service he wants.
Just to pick out one statistic from a whole raft of then,
that we found in trying to bring these records together,
in the
first go-around, which hdd about 1400 discrepancies in it, of
the reconciliations,
we had about 775
or so where a claims
number was wrong.
Now, in the Veterans Benefits Department,
the claims number is terribly important and that is how the
claims are handled there.
In our accounts, we chose aninsurance number and while
we may carry this claim number with a discrepancy in ir or
maybe didn't have the claim number,
it no way interfered until
the two
systems became linked.
This type of thing is easy to
correct.
We either went to the folder file some place, or to
an index where most of them were actually resolved,
and as
they are washed out one after another,
it is certainly going
to put both records in much better shape to give the man the
service that he is entitled to.
I think,
also,
the communications from Hines to our
center is certainly improving,
and speeding up.
We are becoming
more cognizant of the due dates,
the period of time beginning
the next check out, because the 30 days run very quickly,
This
will also
prevent a long period of time of back and forth
correspondence.
Hines,
of course,
has also stopped some of their payments
outside the system which should eliminate some of the problems
for us also.
We are taking steps in both Hines and the Philadelphia Insurance Center to make program corrections where
there are certain paper documents.
These are just forms, con-
ventionally
be
very
referred
shortly
to
converted
as
forms.
to
the
Some
of
these
punch
card
forms.
we
hope
will
While this is just another piece of paper,
as far as the
insurance is concerned,
it is a piece of paper which has one
less clerical operation on it.
It means it speeds forward that
much more quickly into the system andrwith that much less error.
I think in substance this is where we have been over the past
three or four months.
I think the picture looks quite wholesome
14
from
our
standpoint.
If
record conciliations
errors.
find
which
a great
deal
of
satisfaction
from
been
made
and
washing
these
have
out
Unless there are some questions,
I think that you should
find a marked change.
I think you would be interested to know,
also, in Philadelphia,
that we now have inventoried the number
of cases that we have which we think we have some problems with,
and we intend to move these up to a high priority and to start
work on these cases,
and I think that this should be the residuals that we know and these other cases may individually turn
up, but in large way this
should start to purge the system and
bring us up to the level we know you want us to
be at.
MR.
APPLEBAUM:
Any
comments?
MR. BLALOCK:
(NORTH CAROLINA)
- We are
trouble now under Appendix O.
Payments with
tions.
I would just like you to clarify how
deductions when we have to pay our claimants
cy procedure of Appendix O.
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
I
I hope you will save that
Benefits Section.
took
MR.
care
BLALOCK:
of it,
I
just
am not
until
going to
tomorrow
wondered
how
having some
insurance deducyou do make the
under the emergen-
venture
for the
your
into that
Veterans!
insurance
area.
division
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
Remember,
there are two computers and we
actually accept nothing on our deduction accounts which are on
tape, which are under the computer system in Philadelphia,
unless we receive some sort of documentation from Hines.
Unless
we receive that paper,
that documentation,
our machine will
take no action.
This doesn't come though as an independent
piece of paper that we wait for.
It goes in a separate pile.
These come through to us
and whatever the instructions are on
that piece of paper the machine slavishly begins to follow,
so
in this particular case, we basically look for the input to
our particular machine from the Hines Center and I think this
is the origin of the point you have.
MR. BLALOCK:
What we do is tell our claimants
going to pay them under Appendix ©.
For two
months,
pay the insurance premium direct.
if
we
we are
better
MR. BUDD:
No, I would not say that is necessary.
You can
be assured that if a man is paid his compensation or pension
without a deduction and he has a legitimate deduction authorized,
he is not going to suffer.
We have arranged with the Department
of Veterans'
Benefits to adjust that.
He is not in any danger.
There is no jeopardy to his insurance,
even though there might
be an emergency payment where some one failed to deduct that
premium.
MR. BLALOCK:
That is reminiscent of the time you sent us
a wire down
and said, '"Now, we didn't deduct in July,
so we paid
July, but we are going to deduct in August,’ and then we came
along in August and you didn't deduct either.
I hope you will
work it out better under insurance than you did under that.
MR.
BUDD:
Yes,
sir,
we
will,
15
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
I think in conclusion on this point,
I
will just reiterate what Mr. Budd has said, that if the money
is in the VA, while the veteran may have some inconvenience to
him, his insurance will not be in jeopardy.
The accounts are
there and the money is with the VA.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
MR.
DAY:
1
Any
other
submitted
comments?
question
3,
In the past, VA has refused to apply an annual dividend
on a pro-rated basis,
subsequent to the declaration of such
dividend and prior to an insurance policy's anniversary date
where an insured dies and his policy has lapsed but the proportionate part of the dividend is sufficient to pay premiums
in arrears and maintain the contract in force to death.
What
effect will President Kennedy's instruction concerning acceleration of dividends have on the existing VA ruling concerning
the above?
Mr. Budd,would you or one of your staff answer
that, please?
MR. BUDD:
Yes,
I would just say this.
This has been
discussed many times and I would like to ask Mr. Clay, our
Insurance Counsel,
to speak to that, and possibly Mr. Poissant,
also, because it does have an actuarial aspect to it.
MR. CLAY:
Ladies and gentlemen,
this proposal and the
ones I have seen in the past are restricted only to death cases.
Of course,
yow cannot run an insurance business by taking out
premiums only where the man dies.
Also,
it discriminates
against living insureds who have to pay premiums timely in
order to keep their insurance in force.
Let me go a little farther and see what we are getting
into.
The proposal would only affect those people who have a
dividend credit option or an option to use their dividends to
pay premiums.
This is a relatively small percentage of our
participating policyholders,
somewhere around 23 per cent.
Also,
the vast majority of the people who have a dividend credit
leave that money on credit.
It is a sort of bank account,
and
they earn interest on it every year.
They use the dividend
credit to prevent inadvertent lapse where they may be out of
town and something happens or they forget to pay.
There is a
small percentage of policyholders who every time they get a
dividend applied to their dividend credit,
they quit paying
premiums until the dividend credit is exhausted.
However,
every time we withdraw money from a dividend
credit account to pay a monthly premium the insured is sent a
notice which shows him the amount of the withdrawal,
the remaining balance,
the month for which the premium is paid, and when
his next premium is due.
Likewise, when an insured uses the
dividend to pay premium in advance,
he is sent a notice showing
how much in advance that money pays the premiums.
If the insured exhausts his credit and his insurance lapses, he also
gets
been
a
lapse
fully
notice,
thus,
advised
exhausted,
lapses.
as
and
premiums
The
dividends
law,
will
what
to
you
how
can
much
he
see
money
has
that
paid,
he
the
has
and
insured
left,
when
when
the
has
which provides for dividend credits,
states
be applied in payment of premiums which are
16
it
is
insurance
that
due
subsequent
to the date the dividend is payable.
In order to
have a pro-rated dividend,
as proposed,
it would mean that we
would have to pay dividends every month to approximately
5,000,000
policyholders.
You could not pay them just to the
insureds who have a dividend credit because an insured has a
cash dividend option,
has just as much right to payment as the
insured who has a dividend credit option.
You can see this
would be very costly,
and would create many administrative headaches.
As far as the accelerated dividend payment that President
Kennedy requested us to pay, it has nothing to do with pro-rated
dividends.
We are merely paying dividends in March for those
policies with anniversary dates between March and December.
That is entirely different
than the proposal to pro-rate dividends in death cases.
Are there any questions about that?
Thank you.
MR.
DAY:
Mr.
Mattingly?
MR. MATTINGLY:
Mr. Clay,
as I understand it, your inability to use these dividends in the past on a pro-rated basis
was that the dividend was not payable until the anniversary date.
The question that still is not quite clear in my mind is this:
recently,
the President declared these dividends payable and
you are now paying them on an accelerated basis.
You are paying these dividends,
so under the circumstances,
in spite of
the fact that a man's anniversary date might be in
October,
November
or December, would you not then have the dividend
available to prevent future lapse some time
between now and his
anniversary date?
MR. CLAY:
What you are saying is that since we made them
payable in March he’ is being credited with his entire dividend
in March.
That is true, Charlie, but if we started paying
dividends once a year that would not be pro-rating dividends
in death cases.
It would not help the man who pays three
or
four premiums then lets his policy lapse,
and subsequently
dies.
The thing that the insured should do, of course,
if he
has a dividend credit,
is leave his dividends on credit to
prevent inadvertent lapses.
If he
has a cash option he should
change it to a dividend credit option.
MR. MATTINGLY:
Mr. Clay,
let's assume the man has a dividend credit option and that his anniversary date, for simplicity,
is December 1, and let's say he lapses in August and that
he dies in November.
Under the circumstances,
the dividend became payable when the President announced it.
Would not you be
able to prevent this policy from lapsing by taking the premiums out of the dividend account?
MR. CLAY:
If the insured has a dividend credit option,
we would pay the 1961 dividend into such credit account in
March.
If he lapsed,
the dividend credit would be used to pay
premiums until it was exhausted.
However,
that is not what is
proposed in pro-rating dividends.
Tf you pay dividends once a
vear,
as we are doing pretty .much this year,
that would not help
the man who
dies,
after his dividend credit has been exhausted
and the insurance is lapsed.
MR. MATTINGLY:
When
credited to him.
While it
the dividend became payable,
it was
is laying there, may it be used.
x7
MR. CLAY:
It will be used until it is exhausted.
However, what you are really asking us to
do in pro-rating dividends in death cases,
is you are asking us to pay dividends
every month so that every month the insured has a dividend
payable to prevent a subsequent lapse.
MR. MATTINGLY:
I think really we are confused and I
don't want to belabor the point, but I would like to go back
and rephrase the question once more and we will let it go at
that.
We are talking about the man who has the dividend option.
When the dividend became payable on March 1 or whenever the
President made this announcement,
then technically speaking,
at that time, this man's dividends became payable?
MR. CLAY:
The dividend
to his account.
is
dited
MR.
is
true.
If
he
has
date
of
going
back
again,
if
1,
and
MATTINGLY:
December
if
the
1,
That
then
dividend
credit
September, October,
and
use those dividends?
Here
payable
was
November
March
sufficient
premium,
MR. CLAY:
Absolutely.
I am
is what I am trying to say.
You have
dend placed on
man lapses and
exhausted,
but
in
not
an
he
then
saying
and
is
cre-
anniversary
lapsed
August
to pay
the
August,
would
not
you
that
at
all
Chuck.
a dividend payable once.
Now, then,
that divicredit will be used to pay premiums whenever the
it will be there until the dividend credit is
let's take this example:
Suppose the dividend is payable on the anniversary date
of the policy in March and the dividend is based on the premiums paid during the preceding policy year.
The insured uses
that dividend under the dividend credit option to pay premiums
for the
months of March, April, May and June.
He lapses in
July and dies in November.
The next dividend is not payable
until March next year.
The proposal for pro-rating dividends
in death cases is to
use the dividend which may accrue from
premium payments for the months from March thru June to keep
the insurance in force until
November even tho next year's dividend is not declared and is not payable until March next year.
Also,
this is only to be done in death cases where it will keep
the insurance in force until death.
MR.
CLAY:
MR.
RILEY:
MR.
DAY:
Anything
I
else,
believe
gentlemen?
you
answered
the
question.
or
comments
from
Thank
you.
Any
questions
the
floor?
MR. EGAN:
(Delaware) - What we have here
is a simple proposition that has happened before and perhaps the Veterans
Administration Insurance Section is reversing its previous
policy.
Many claims have been paid in the past in similar cases
of this type based simply and solely and wholly on the intent of
the veteran.
In this case, we have a Presidential directive
to accelerate rate of payment of the accumulated reserve on the
policy.
Unfortunately,
the intent of the veteran at all times
was to keep the policy in force.
18
Suppose,
as happened recently in a case which will be
down here
shortly,
the veteran and his wife were in an automobile accident.
The veteran died before he ever arrived at
the hospital.
The wife will be hospitalized for many months.
Now, we take that case as it is now.
Suppose that man had
received the accelerated payments and had no carry-over and
he had carried on for a few months and then died.
His wife
is incapable of protecting his entitlement.
The concern of the
family is for the well-being of both.
The insurance, whether
it is in force or not,
is incidental to the pressing needs of
the family.
The intent was always there to keep the policy in
force.
The question simply resolved itself to this point:
has
there been sufficient accumulated reserve based upon intent to
keep that policy in force so that the veteran can be covered
on his insurance?
I think that is the whole problem.
It has been down here
before and we have won cases on that basis,
the intent of the
veteran,
I want to know definitely,
do you intend to nullify
the intent of the veteran of keeping the policy in force,
and
do you intend to nullify the action of the veteran by intent,
because you recognize a Presidential directive,
but refuse to
grant him the additional coverage of protection that should be
accorded him.
with
have
your
here,
that
MR. POISSANT:
Somebody said the road to hell was paved
good intentions.
It is
not enough to have an intent.
You
to meet certain contractual obligations.
You have to pay
premium when it comes due.
As I understand the problem
you want to apply this money retroactively when you know
the man has died.
Suppose that we set up an
insurance organization and
wrote contracts with a stipulation that we would not collect
any money from anybody until they died and at that time we could
take it out of the face of the policy.
Nobody is going to buy
any stock in this insurance company,
I am sure.
You are always
out of pocket.
You deduct the premium from the face amount.
The policy would always be paying out money and collecting nothing.
This is tantamount to what you want to do.
You want to
take this dividend money and apply it to pay for the protection,
but only after the man has died.
This is not fair to the other
veterans,
If you could take this dividend money and apply it across
the board like we collect premiums across the board,
this would
be a sound insurance proposition.
You want to take the dividend
out after death occurs.
You should apply it all the way through
so that we would not be out of pocket in all of these transactions.
Does that answer the question?
Did I get the idea across,
or am I confused?
Maybe,
I could explain,
too; that a dividend,
according to law, is not payable until the administrator
says it
is payable.
The Administrator made that declaration last December and said that a dividend was going to be paid but it was going to be paid on yhe day before each policy's anniversary.
This is our regular custom.
We pay the dividend on the day
prior to the anniversary in calendar year.
Because of the President's desire to do something to add purchasing power to the
economy, we accelerated the payment of these dividends,
but this
is on a condition that if we overpay anybody we will collect it
19
from any source that is available to us in the insurance department.
We changed his declaration and now say that the dividend
is going to be paid as soon as possible,
but not, of course,
after the policy anniversary.
This is a legal question.
The question at issue probably here is when does surplus evolve from a policy;
that is
the basic question.
Theoretically,
every time you pay a monthly premium a certain part of it is surplus, but that surplus
does not become a dividend until the Administrator says so,
according to law.
The Administrator has to make a declaration
that the amount of surplus which is part of the monthly premium
is payable as a dividend,
and each .year he decides when that
dividend is to be paid.
Is that cleared up at
all?
and
MR.
EGAN:
I
again
pose
the
would
like
question
to
that
answer
we
that
proposed
question
in
part
before.
You
say
that the dividend is not declared until it is declared by the
Administrator.
I believe that the President appoints the Administrator and I don't believe that any Administrator will
ever attempt to nullify or revoke a directive from the President.
Then,
in addition to the dividend which has already been
declared, which only tends to exemplify the program which we
are printing here,
the President has also requested the insurance section to make a review as to
the available money which
may be distributed at a later date which the accumulated reserve on these policies,
which you must admit does exist,
and
you have only declared that which your actuarial table showed
would not completely deplete the reserve and the additional
dividend is pending by Presidential directive,
subject toa
review and an accounting by the new Administrator to the
President.
Why could not that fund, because it does exist -- I am
quite sure that the President knows what he is talking about,
that it does exist -- be used to cover the contengency of the
reserve money which
we are discussing?
MR. POISSANT:
Even under the accelerated dividend plan,
if a man has elected a cash option and we pay him his money,
he is going to get his whole year's dividend.
He is on a cash
option dividend basis.
This man gets it in cash.
If this
policy lapses,
one or two months or three months afterwards,
we are not going to retroactively use this money to keep this
policy. in force.
Maybe there is a misconception there, because we cannot,
as I explained before,
retroactively write insurance and just
collect premiums from the face amount of the policy, when a
man dies.
The man has made an election.
He wants it in cash.
If he says,
"I want my dividend to carry the insurance forward
onder a dividend credit option," that's all right.
We willddo
that.
But he has not made that election.
He had this choice
and he didn't make it, so he wants it in cash.
I don't see
that the accelerated dividend plan changes the situation to any
extent as far as the difference between those who had elected
a cash option and those who elected a dividend credit option.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
I am going to come back to this just a
little later.
We do have several more questions and I want the
conferees who have submitted them as well as the answers to
get before this meeting before we proceed further.
If we have
time later, certainly we will come back to this knotty question
20
of Tom
actual
Egan's,
case, I
which is
believe.
a
good
one,
because
it
was
based
on
an
MR. HENRY:
Question No. 4 was submitted by the National
Rehabilitation staff.
The Administrator's decisiom No. 969,
approved under date of December 7, 1960, deals with payment of
permanent and total disability insurance benefits
(USGLI).
Will
the regulation,
when published,
have retroactive effect?
Please
discuss this change briefly.
MR. BUDD:
This is
most happy to speak to.
speak on this one.
MR.
recall,
out
that
MCGURN:
last year
if
an
one that we were very happy to
I would like to ask Mr. McGurn
see
to
and
This is a subject which we discussed,as you
at your meeting.
At that time,
I pointed
insured
who
was
found
permanently
and
totally
disabled under a United States Government Life Insurance
tract elected not to receive the monthly income payments
stopped paying his premiums
there would be a retroactive
of the insurance in the event that we subsequently found
he recovered from his disability.
Conand
lapse
that
This was because of a Comptroller General's decision
which held that if a man recovers from permanent and total disability you must consider
that he never,
in fact, was permanently totally disabled.
Accordingly,
under the circumstances
which I indicated we must consider that the policy did not
mature.
Because the man did
not pay his premiums the policy
would have lapsed.
This was a problem which gave us quite a
bit of concern for quite a while.
It was something which we
were
not
satisfied
with.
I am
glad
that
today
I am
able
to
tell you that the possibility of lapse in insurance under these
conditions can now entirely be eliminated by the Administrator's
decision 969 and the regulation which is based on it.
The Administrator's decision and revised regulation now
recognized that the insured is entitled to a waiver of premiums
during any period that we find that he is permanently and totally
disabled,
notwithstanding that he elects not to receive the
payments,
notwithstanding
that he may be later found to have
recovered,
As to those men who have elected not to receive the payments, we will let the payments accrue to their credit.
If they
later wish to receive them, we will pay them to them in lump
sum.
Otherwise, we will pay them to the beneficiary at the
time of his death.
If a man elects not to receive the monthly
income
payments
and
does
not
pay
the
premiums
because
he
no
longer has to, in the event of his recovery, he can continue
the protection under his policy simply by paying the future
premiums as they fall
due after the date of recovery.
Presently, we have 229 of these cases
on our rolls.
30
of these insured are still paying the premiums in order to
protect themselves.
The Administrator's decision will apply
to all of these cases.
We will credit these men with all the
installments which have accumulated up to this time.
We will
continue to credit them with the installments as they become due
in
the
future.
they
have
paid
and
totally
We
will
for
the
refund
period
to
these
that
we
disabled.
21
men
rated
any
them
premiums
as
which
permanently
MR.
a moment.
minutes.
RILEY:
We
We expect
are
the
going to halt
Administrator
the proceedings for just
in just a
few short
MR. BUDD:
I introduced these gentlemen earlier,
since
then another man has joined the group.
I would now like to
introduce John R. Murphy,
our VA Manager in St. Paul,Minnesota.
MR.
HENRY:
Question
Rehabilitation
staff.
What
do
effect
MCGURN:
5
was
disabilities
example alcoholism) have
for insurance purposes?
MR.
No.
The
on
fact
that
is
the
difficulty
an
we
impairment
have
in
within
Many of us
enjoy our
a sociable drink.
None of
feel that we are incurring
ism,
by
of misconduct
determination
the
conduct nature is entirely immaterial
man's rights for disability insurance
connection with alcoholism is not its
becomes
submitted
of
a
member
origin
total
disability
is
of
(for
disability
of
a mis-
as far as determining a
benefits.
The problem in
misconduct origin.
It
determining
when
the
of
meaning
the
our
condition
contract.
cocktail before dinner.
We enjoy
us, I am sure,
in taking a drink,
a disability.
This is not alcohol=
On the other hand, we know that people sometimes die
from alcoholism.
It is apparent,
therefore,
that somewhere
between these two extremes,
there is a point at which the continued use of alcohol can become a disease.
The point at which
it becomes a disease when it is no longer a matter of choice,
but a disease is very difficult to determine.
All I can say
is that,
generally,
we will consider alcoholism to be a disease
within the meaning of our contract, when the habit has become
very profound, when a man has reached the point,
so to speak,
of no
return, where he has reached a stage where he cannot get
a job if he wants it and he could not hold it even if he did.
It is seldom that we have to try to resolve this question
solely on the basis of the alcoholism.
There are other related
factors.
There is a question of the cause of the habit and a
question of the results.
We know that frequently there are
underlying psychiatric and emotional disturbances which cause
the habit.
We know,
too, that invariably,
there will be deterioration,
physically and mentally,
as a result of the continued and excessive use of alcohol --nervous and mental disorders, neuritis,
cirrhosis of the liver,
and impairments of
the cardiovascular system and others.
It is
these conditions together with the alcoholism which
constitute the total picture of disability.
The fact that
these conditions or the habit itself is due to misconduct has
no effect on a man's right.
MR. RILEY:
Are there any questions from the floor now,
particularly with reference to question 4 read previously on
Administrator's Decision 969?
That is something brand new.
Is there any one here that would like to discuss that particular
question further or the last question?
Are there any questions
from
the
floor?
MR.
HENRY:
In
regards
to
22
question
No.
3,
about
applying
dividends to the payment of insurance to the payment of insurance,
if this dividend check was received by the veteran either
prior to his death or shortly after and he was never able to
cash it and the widow later returned it to the VA, would that
insurance dividend be able to apply to the premiums and pay it
to her in a lump sum?
MR. CLAY:
You are asking,
1 gather,
that if a man asked
for his
dividends in cash and we paid them in cash,
and he
dies before his check is cashed,
or negotiated, will that be
used to pay premiums.
The answer is no.
The man has requested
that it be paid in cash, not to be used to apply to premiums.
Does that answer the question,
or did I understand it correctly?
MR.
HENRY:
That
answers
the
question.
MR. GORDON B. PEFLEY (Oregon):
I would like to refer to
question No. 3.
I would like to make it crystal clear that in
the minds of a lot of us
that portion of our insurance payments
which eventually will become repayable as dividends at the end
of the year is not actually earned then until the Administrator
says that they are payable.
If that is true,
that is one thing,
but if they are earned out of a portion of each one of the insurance payments that we make by what right do they say that
they are not earned until the Administrator says they
are payable?
They are still earned during the year not when the Administrator says they are payable,
but when the payments were
actually made.
MR. POISSANT:
I will admit that some surplus develops
each time you pay a monthly premium,
but the Administrator has
to make a declaration as to when gains and savings warrant the
declaration of a dividend.
You say the dividend is earned.
All right.
What do 1 do with it?
Some of them made a cash dividend option and some of them
have elected a dividend credit.
Do I apply everybody's dividend
that carries insurance,
or do I wait until the man dies and
then apply it?
This is the crucial, basic question at issue
here.
You can't just apply it on death cases.
You must apply
it on all the cases and in all the
cases you can't apply it
because some people have elected a cash option.
Is that clear?
To make it an insurance proposition,
I have to apply it on
everybody across the board and I cannot do that because a lot
of these policyholders,
in fact 75
per cent of them, have
elected the cash option.
We operate this program on a sound
technical basis to maintain equity among our policyholders.
It
would not be fair to do it the way it is suggested that it be
done.
time,
time,
MR. RILEY: We are going to conclude this panel at
since there are no further printed questions,
and
Mr. Applebaum,
I will return the mike to you.
CHAIRMAN APPLEBAUM:
Thank you.
to turn the meeting back at this time
all take a short stretch at this time
CHAIRMAN
to have
speaker
Today
the
and
MCCURDY:
Will
the
this
at this
My sole function will be
to California.
Will you
and remain in your seats?
meeting
come
to
order,please.
it is
indeed a high honor that is presented to me
rare privilege of introducing a most distinguished
I say distinguished advisedly.
I say rare advisedly.
23
We have a speaker today who has a long period of service and
not only a long period of just service, but service to The
American Legion,
and more particularly service to the veteran
and our disabled veteran.
You all know that for six years he
served as a Vice-Chairman of this Commissiom.
You all know
that he served,
and with distinction and honor,
as our National
Commander.
It is indeed a happy day today when we can welcome
our comrade here as the Administrator of Veterans! Affairs.
Our distinguished quest, Jack Gleason.
ADDRESS
OF
OF
THE HONORABLE JOHN
AFFAIRS
VETERANS'
S.
GLEASON,
ADMINISTRATOR
Mr. Gleason.
Mr. Chairman,
fellow Legionnaires,
and
fellow Americans,
I think all of you know without my having to
say it, that I am extremely happy and proud to have this
opportunity to be with you,
and I hope that you will still consider
me
years
from
one
of
now,
officially
at
your
for
least.
friends,
our
one,
two
relationship
or
will
even
possibly
be
little
a
more
changed-
A few years ago,
I had the great honor to serve as your
National Commander.
I now stand before you as the Administrator
of Veterans' Affairs,
a post that I am proud and humble to have
been appointed to by the President of the United States.
And so my friends,
our official relationship shifts. Although I certainly count on continuing
to be a part of your
family,
there may be times when you view me as something of an
"in-law,"
But
bank
I hope
tellers
you
thought
don't
ever
of
mother-in
his
think
of
law.
me
the
way
one
of
our
His boss confronted the teller and said: Joe,
you're a
liar.
You asked for yesterday off to bury your mother-in-law,
and yet I met her walking in the park this morning."
she
Joe thought fast,
then said,
was dead.
I just said I would
As all of you know, my job is
my assignment it will be to work as
very best of my ability -- to serve
for
the
United
States
of America.
"Sir,
I
like to
didn't actually say
go to her funeral.’
new to me, and as I view
hard as I can -- to the
all veterans who fought
But to do this I'll need all the help,
all the cooperation
and all the understanding I can possibly get from The American
Legion and from other responsible veterans!
organizations.
And I am not too proud to go hat in hand to ask for it.
For I know that The American Legion -- and especially,
you men
and women sitting here today,
are the very embodiment of service
to the veterans of our country.
Yet, today there are those who charge that leaders of
veterans'
organizations
are ''self-servers' who continually lobby
so that veterans may ''gorge at the public trough," or ''ride a
perpetual gravy train" of "undeserved benefits."
they
Such irresponsible
allegations have been heard
will be heard again.
These charges are not
new
24
before,
and
to you or
: |
myself
--
and
certainly
they
are
not
true.
Those who voice them should acquaint themselves with the
facts.
They should learn -- as I have -- that men like you and
other leaders in this work have a sense of responsibility,
high purpose and sincere dedication that is unexcelled in any
walk of American life.
To claim a disregard of national interest by veterans'
organizations
is not to know -- or to
simply
ignore -- your many programs which are aimed at a stronger,
more efficient,
and finer America.
For
the
past
few
weeks,
I
have
been
learning
about
this
vast Veterans Administration that I am now privileged to head,
and although after serving as your National Commander,
getting
all of my facts from Bob McCurdy in the past,
I was not absolutely ''green' about the agency,
I have been amazed by its
dimensions:
up -- down -- in -- out... measure it in any direction and the VA represents one big package.
The Veterans Administration employs about 170,000 people
more people by the way, Mr. McCurdy,
than live in Pasadena,
California,
Bridgeport,
Connecticut,
or Topeka, Kansas.
The Veterans Administration receives more mail each year
all of the people living in a city the size of Pittsburgh.
than
VA
than the
America.
hospitals use more sheets and pillow cases
combined amount used by 150
of our biggest
I've learned that the
more than a hundred million
aspirins ‘annually.
As
cargo
Administrator,
I find that I even hold
vessels that were torpedoes by U-boats
This
makes
which
is
me,
quite
I
suppose
a title
VA's
for
per year
hotels in
Veterans Administration purchases
eggs each year, and over 22 million
Our people provide guardianship service for
in-arms,
and pensions for Civil War widows and old
fighters,
to say nothing of benefits and services
of veterans of more recent wars.
66
-
an
Admiral
Army
of
the
more babesIndian War
for millions
title to
in World
Sunken
Fleet
some
War I.
--
man.
I knew that the VA had to keep lots of records, but I was
a little surprised to find that we have master index record
cards on more than 30 million veterans,
both living and dead.
As you might expect,
there are lots of Smiths on this roster...
300,000 in fact, and about 13,000 of them are named Bill;
12,000 named Bob, and 11,000 named John.
I learned also that I am keeping good company on the list
with 394 other John Gleasons,
and there are 133 John F. Kennedys,
including a former PT boat commander who now lives across the
park from the VA building.
(Despite all this duplication, we
found only eight Robert M. McCurdys, which just proves what I
have always known -- you have to go
a long way to find people
like
Bob
McCurdy).
Now, my purpose
and complexity is not
your indulgence.
in
to
detailing these statistics
impress you, but rather it
25
of
is
magnitude
to ask
This I ask, because in an agency
always been and there always will
have
I
present
am
just
areas
beginning
of
consideration.
it would be an
to know all the
We
will
to
concern
--
get
at
a
as
be
closer
questions
vast as the
problems.
look
that
at
some
deserve
VA
there
of
the
earnest
Knowing the short time I've been on the job,
insult to your intelligence for me to presume
answers.
But I want to emphasize this:
recognize
we will identify
they might be.
the
and
areas
never
of
hide
concern
from
our
whenever
problems,
and
and
whatever
Above all, we plan to meet our problems head on,and do
our level best to achieve proper and reasonable solutions.
The very foundation of the Veterans Administration is a sound
and durable, structure of benefits built by the Congress,
in
response to the will of the American people.
At the very
core of this entire structure stands this simple fundamental
principle -- Service to Veterans.
For in the Veterans Administration,
our job is to
serve
veterans,
their widows,
and their orphans in keeping with the
laws of the land. It may be that I'm old fashioned ... or call
me a fundamentalist
if you will... but I heppen to believe that
service to veterans is the very reason for our existence.
I
believe that all projects and undertakings in the VA must be
aimed at this goal of service.
Earlier this month, when I first came with the Veterans
Administration,
I received my initial marching orders personally
from President Kennedy,
The President said he wanted a ''speed
up" in the payment of the quarter billion dollar 1961 G.I. insurance dividend as an aid to some five million veterans and
as a stimulus to the nation's economy.
It is early in the game,
but I have learned already that when the President wants actionhe does mean action - and he means right now.
Considering
that it normally takes a full 12 months to
pay the dividend,
the question we asked ourselves was, ''"how
fast can we do it?"
At first, we set our sights on completion by not later
than June 30 -which would cut in half the normal payment
schedule -- but we were determined to beat that date,
if we
could.
Let me now give you the very latest report, which in
my mind stands as a tremendous tribute to the willingness and
energetic enterprise of all the people associated with our
Department of Insurance.
As of today, VA employees who are
working around the clock, have completed the processing of
over three million dividend payments.
over
it
Right now -- at this moment
140 million dollars into the
needed
a 1ift.
And
what's
-- this program has
American economy at
more..,
it
looks
now
like
pumped
a time
we
will
have this crash program completed by March 17.
For all of you
who don't know,
this is St. Patrick's Day. This would mean completion of the crash program within about six weeks from the
time President Kennedy ordered '"full speed ahead."
and
The VA has problems and challenges,
but it also has friends
supporters,
and you men here this afternoon are typical of
26
them.
And speaking of friends and supporters,
I personally -the Veterans Administration,
and veterans everywhere have lost
one of their staunchest
friends in the death of our beloved
Watson
B.
Miller,
understanding
America.
and
for
he
was
truly
was
a man
a
of binding
standard
But his spirit will go on...
will be carried forward by the Bob
and by all of you.
bearer
his great
McCurdys,
wisdom
for
and
great
veterans
of
pioneering work
the John Corcorans-
Any Administrator of Veterans Affairs needs lots of help
and assistance to do his job.
Fortunately,
I have good help
and great assistance right in the VA family,
and at this time
I would like to salute the loyalty,
the dedication,
and the
competence of my co-workers that make the VA the great organization it is.
An Administrator needs the cooperation and guidance
that
Congress
can
provide,
and
here
again,
I
consider
myself very lucky.
The Chairmen of these Committees,
especially
important to us - Senator Byrd, Senator Magnuson,
Senator Hill,
Senator Yarborough,
Congressman Albert Thomas,
and members of
these Committees are men of stature and have sincere interest
in the welfare of the veterans of the United States.
But the veterans of America owe an even greater personal
debt to Congressman Olin Teague, Chairman of the only Congressional Committee devoted entirely and exclusively to their
affairs.
It has been said that Olin Teague is tough.
That is
true.
But I can assure you, he is honest,
he is kind,
and
what's most important of all, he is fearless.
The Veterans
Administration and its Administrator are most fortunate to have
this man, and the dedicated members and staff of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs as our advisors on "The Hill."
But
perhaps
most
of
all,
I
need
the
''grass
roots"
kind
of understanding and constructive criticism that only the
American’ Legion and other responsible veterans'
organizations
can provide.
I am counting honestly and sincerely on your support,
each of you, and I assure you that I will perform my job as
Administrator to the very best of my abilities in order to
merit your support.
Even with all this help,
I might still
need just a wee bit of the luck o' the Irish. With my name and
my face,
it doesn't seem to me that this is too much to ask.
Mr. Chairman,
and all of you who are my friends,
thanks
for the opportunity to come back home with all of you.
Thank
you for
inviting me to join in your sessions,
It. .is good to be
with old friends once again.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I know that you are sure
good supporters.
It was
and I could not help but
would
buy
silver
fizzes
That's our boy!
Administrator Jack,
that we are your good friends and
interesting how much mail you receive
think that as many eggs as they buy
for
the
whole
group
for
a year.
And
I didn't quite catch the connection,
but I did hear him mention
the babes-in-arms
and I am more interested in that subject.
We
do know, Jack,
that you are a Major General; we know you are the
Administrator
of
your status is
We know, also,
changing,
but we are not about to
that you are a life member of The
Veterans'
Affairs;
27
and
we
know
you
stated
that
let it change.
American Legion,
and while you have these titles and you have these great responsibilities,
I am reminded,
and only bring forth this thought
to govern our future associations on the part of everyone in
this room,
that there is a place in the initiation ceremony of
The American Legion that says there is no rank among us and
each serves as the equal of his comrades,
and certainly this
group has always considered that and it is the great point
in
our ceremony that makes The American Legion a terrific,
strong
organization because we have men at the top like Jack, and
we
have
some
we
have
a
the
benefit
like
common
of
me,
and
ground
each
some
where
that
he
other.
we
gets
are
the
not
so
proud
benefit
and
of,
we
but
get
I say that in a most friendly spirit, Jack, and you can
be sure that you will always remain our comrade.
We may have
some arguments with you and I have never been known to get
along too long with someone without
arguing with him, but you
will always have our deepest admiration and you will always
have our deep respect,
and we certainly are going to try to be
your strong,
right arm.
We thank you sincerely for coming down
today.
Thank you, Jack.
I
want
tomorrow
to
call
morning,
attention
Commander
that
Burke
promptly
requests
at
that
here and in your seats..At nine o'clock sharp
ing he has a message of great importance.
nine
If there is nothing
tomorrow morning.
.
at
9:00
.
a,
.
At
m.,
4:05
p.m.
Wednesday,
further,
the
we
Conference
March
28
1,
will
be
all
o'clock
of
tomorrow
in
recessed
:1961...
nine
recess
to
you
be
mornuntil
reconvene
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 1, 1961
. . . The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel Statler, Washington, D. C., at 9:30 a. m,, Mr. Robert M.
McCurdy, Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Commission,
presiding...
This
Will you please come to order.
CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
that we
morning, we have one of the most important discussions
have had yet, certainly one of our most challenging problems,
and in presiding at this meeting, I have asked the help of
another fine and great National Vice Chairman of the Rehabilia gentleman from the State of Alabama, Vice
tation Commission,
Chairman, Comrade Clarence Horton.
Clarence.
Good morning,
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
We have a few little procedural problems
ladies and gentlemen.
to solve here this morning before beginning upon this most imI believe those of you who know me reasonably
portant panel.
Therewell might agree that I am not given to exaggeration.
fore, when I say to you that I believe the subject which we
have for discussion this morning is the most important which
perhaps any Rehabilitation Conference of the preceding five
years or of the coming five years has been faced with,
I am
almost tempted to say that since the National Recovery Act of
1933 no single thing involving veterans'
benefits has aroused
more interest and brought more pressure from the field than
the subject of Automatic Data Processing.
So great was the
pressure that for the first time in my recollection the National
Director of Rehabilitation,
John Corcoran,
and his assistant,
Ed Golembieski,
have found it desirable and necessary to visit
VA installations all over the country to try to arrive at some
solution to the perplexing problem which we have before us today.
Some insight into the depth and breadth of the problem
might be envisioned by the fact that when the Rehabilitation
staff prepared its rehabilitation memo on the subject of
Automatic Data Processing they began by saying,
"Into each
life,
some raih must fall,”
They
America
in
undoubtedly
would
supply
knew
the
next
that
every
line.
"but
service
too
officer
much
has
in
fallen
mine.”
It reminds me also of another guitar-plucking tune which
many of you might recall.
It goes something like this: "I
thought
I had seen pretty girls in my life, but that was before
I met you." Now, you will paraphrase it for me and you will say,
"I thought I knew what confusion was, but that was be A.D.P."
I believe, my friends,
that we have arrived at
of procedure which will please each of you, although
require some understanding on your part.
a method
it will
First of all,
I want to present to you your National
Director of Rehabilitation,
John Corcoran,
to make a sort of
opening announcement,
after which you will see the sequence
which follows.
We were primarily concerned in our little onstage discussion this morning with your feeling.
We want to be
extremely
careful
not
to
set
up
29
a
pre-planned
program
which
might lead you to believe that you were being excluded from
your right to participate
in the discussion,
but we did come
to the reasonable and sensible conclusion that if you would
allow us, first,
to present a sort of an over-all picture before we began to deal with specifics,
and individual matters,
we would all probably be a little bit better off, so expecting you as you always are, to be considerate of the rest of
the Conference and to be believing in our own
good conscience
in the matter,
I would like to present to you now your National
Director of Rehabilitation, Mr. John Corcoran.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Clarence.
I can begin by saying that I concur in your comments on the seriousness and the
importance of the subject that we are about to discuss.
In
our view,
it is the most important subject that will be discussed at this Conference.
A
gone
best
word
on
format.
along with the
approach,
that
that
Bill
Driver
or
The
panel
has
requested,
and
request,
because it seems to us
we follow the following format.
a member
of his
staff,
make
an
we
have
to be the
We ask
opening
presentation.
Then, we ask that the panel members headed by
Earl Merifield,
make statements and then that the subject be
open for discussion by all of the participants
in the Conference.
The major difference between this and other panels is
that we will not, unless you so request,
take up the questions
that have been submitted in advance.
The questions that have
been submitted in advance have been answered by the Veterans
Administration and their answers have already been distributed.
We
urge
questions
answered
you,
as
to
bring
and
if
time
you
permits,
feel
those
that
to
read
they
questions
up
over
have
in
your
not
the
particular
been
satisfactorily
course
of
the
debate.
At the same time, we urge you, when the floor is thrown
open for full discussion,
to bring up any question, whether
submitted in advance or not, which you feel is fundamental
to
the question before us.
I thought
that I might well begin the
panel by reading the resolution which is under discussion by
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
This is Resolution
No. 149 from the National Convention at Miami Beach.
This is
somewhat long,
so I am going to read it rather fast. The subject,
of course,
is disbursing VA compensation and pension checks by
Automatic Data Processing.
"Whereas,
in January 1960 the Veterans Administration began converting all monthly payments of compensation and pension
to automatic data processing by establishing a Center in Chicago
and many unlooked-for problems and delays in paying veterans
and their dependents have been and are being encountered in this
new system creating extreme Hardship to thousands of beneficiaries and in addition because of the complexities of the system
and the additional work involved in processing so many duplicate
awards huge backlogs have been created in the Administrative and
Adjudication Divisions of many offices which have delayed the
processing of new and reopened claims;
and
it is
shall
"Whereas, Congress has, on many occasions,
announced that
its intention that benefits and service to the veteran
be provided with the least possible difficulty;
and
"Whereas,
the
Veterans
Administration
30
has
repeatedly
stated that it is
dedicated to give the
men and women who have
served,
and their families,
their dependent widows and orphans
and parents,
the best service possible under the law; and
"Whereas,
The American Legion through the years has advocated and insisted on the decentralization of VA operations
in order to give improved service,
as experience has shown the
centralization of any of the operations has resulted in poorer
service;
and The American Legion has insisted that in any re=or
ganization plans of the Veterans Administration or consolidation
of workloads that they be given assurance that service to the
veteran would not be impaired and that only high quality service
be continued;
and
"Whereas,
the Administrator of Veterans' Affairs in 1959
stated that it was essential to use available modern business
methods to improve service to veterans and the VA has stated in
adopting ADP that it would improve service
to veterans and produce an over-all reduction in operating costs;
and further,
promises were made that this system would result in many improvements in service to beneficiaries
-- none of which has so far
been realized;
and
"Whereas,
after nine months of trial and error there
appears to be little satisfactory improvements in the correction
of basic problems that have arisen in attempting to apply this
system to VA payments,
and there still continues
to be a large
number of complaints because of nonreceipt of checks;
and huge
backlogs in the processing of claims are still evident,
and
the fact that an increasing number of payments in various categories must be paid outside of the system clearly proving the
system is not properly functioning;
and
"Whereas,
experience in some lines of industry has revealed that ADP does not necessarily lend itself to every phase
of business and endeavor and has had to be abandoned in many
instances after being thoroughly tried, and because of its
complexities,
the question arises as to whether it can be
adapted to the efficient and prompt payment of compensation and
pension because of the constant adjustments necessary in these
accounts;
and
"Whereas,
The American Legion,
realizing its responsibility to guard the interests of the veterans, his widow and
orphan,
to assure that he receives nothing but the best of care
and service,
questions under the circumstances whether ADP can
be made to work for their best interests,
for their better service and at a reduced cost; now,
therefore, be it
"Resolved,
By The American Legion in National Convention
assembled October 17-20,
1960 in Miami Beach, Florida,
that
the National Rehabilitation Commission is directed to immediately cause to be conducted a thorough investigation and survey
of the automatic data processing system for making benefit payments in the Veterans Administration,
for the purpose of determining whether its continued operation will be to the best
interests of the veteran;
and that they cause to be made a
careful comparison between this system and the prewious system
of processing awards to the local Finance Division and payments by a local Disbursing Office,
and that the approximate
costs between the two systems be determined;
and that if it be
found that the operation of the ADP system will be to the
31
benefit of the veteran and his dependent and will result in
lower costs,
that The American Legion pledge its assistance
to the VA in every way to perfect the system, but if on the
other hand, it be concluded that continuation of the system
will primarily result in poorer service and secondarily,
in
increased costs,
that every attempt be made to prevail on the
Federal Government
to abandon the plan;
and be it further
"Resolved,
that the National Rehabilitation Commission
of The American Legion immediately on completion of this survey make a determination as to the future position of The
American Legion with respect to the operation of ADP as it
affects veterans,
their dependents and survivors and that in
the meantime,
The American Legion insist that no additional
regional
offices
be
converted."
This resolution was approved by the National Convention
and, as you can see, mandated the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission to conduct a thorough study and report
back to the Commission.
This resolution actually instructed
us to do something that we had undertaken to do long before
October,
1960,
As Clarence said, members of our staff have traveled far
and wide in these United States.
We have been to Philadelphia,
to Detroit,
to Chicago,
to Los Angeles,
to Indianapolis,
to
Atlanta,
to Florida.
We have been many places.
The study and
the investigation is still going
on.
An important,
if not perhaps the most important, part of
this study will be the discussion here this morning.
What you
say, and what you suggest,
and what you feel will be a vital
element,
I am sure,
in the determination
to be made finally by
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
With
that,
Mr.
CHAIRMAN
HORTON:
We
with
tinguished
have
friends
us
Chairman,
I
conclude
Thank
you
very
this
from
the
morning,
Veterans
of
my
much
remarks.
Johnny.
course,
our
Administration,
very
dis-
headed
by
one in whom we have great confidence.
He is a man of many
talents and a man who
deservingly speaks this morning for the
Veterans Administration in connection with this most difficult
problem.
I think that when I speak his name by the applause
which you extend to him, you will join me in congratulation
upon his recent elevation to be Deputy Administrator of the
Veterans Administration.
Without further
comment,
I present
to you. Bill Driver.
MR. DRIVER:
Thank you very much, Clarence.
Ladies and
gentlemen,
this has been a very pleasant meeting and I wish
that we could terminate it now.
I have heard a great deal
about ADP already and I am sure that most of you have also.
You know,
there were days last year when we were working on
the new pension law when some of us thought that we never
would find an issue to take its place.
I think it is
a mark of
something -- I won't say what -- that we have succeeded so
admirably.
This is a simple procedural matter,
as distinguished
from something in the substantive law, and yet it has come along
and consumed us.
It burns feverishly in our breasts and in our
minds,
and I am sure that it will burn
some other things here
this morning.
32
I think that no better vehicle on which to base our discussion of this subject can be selected than the resolution
which John Corcoran referred
to.
I will feel
my way through,
referring,
if I may, to the salient points in that resolution
and indicate in a very brief fashion how we feel about the
subjects at issue.
Then I am sure you would prefer that I
sit down and:let someone
else talk.
I know that those of you who are here in the audience
this morning also are anxious to contribute to this most important subject.
Briefly,
however,
I would like to indicate
at the outset that ADP did not just happen.
It came along
after a very careful analysis reaching back over a number of
years.
In fact,
in 1957,
we began our initial planning to use
the automatic data processing system and we made better than
a year's analysis of the procedures
that would be affected and
the programs which would be necessary if we were to have a
successful operation.
Following that, we invited a management firm to come in
and review what we had done, either to bolster our convictions
that it was feasible,
or to
tell us wherein it was not. They
spent six months looking at the operation,
looking at the proposal that we intended to follow,
also examining the type of
equipment that it was our intention to use. Their conclusions,
with some modifications from our original findings, were
that this was indeed a suitable operation to be
handled through
a computer,
so we did go to it and we have had our moments
since,
It was not easy to change the basic program so that we
could use a computer instead of the
mechanized system consisting of the more conventional tabulating equipment and the
punched cards which have become so familiar on the American
scene,
in the form of a check,
in the form of a notice from
some business company that we receive magazines from, or even
bills.
We switched from this system to one using a computer -a computer which uses magnetic tape,
and which,
of course,
can
function much more rapidly than any other mechanical equipment
we had in effect prior to that time.
The
payments
Veterans
are
Administration
scattered
among
67
operations
regional
having
offices,
to
so
do
we
with
had
to
pick a place to start.
We sélected a group representing about
400,000 accounts in six offices.
We scheduled them for conversion after we had written approximately 250,000
individual
instructions
to
accommodate
the
system
to
the
computer.
In writing these instructions we made mistakes.
We made
plenty of them.
I think perhaps this is a natural thing.
We
are free to admit it and sorry indeed, but we did make them
and they caused a good many errors to come about in the conversion process,
errors which simply resulted in the fact that
the accounts that we fed into the equipment from the regional
offices did not convert to the magnetic tape from the punch
card,
thereby
dropping
.tions that were
to convert.
It
to
load
the
regional
that
was
While
office
before
all
out
of
payment
status,
under
the
opera-
in effect at that time,
the accounts that failed
also meant that these accounts had to go back
of
to
be
reprocessed,
us
at
that
this
was
taking
33
time.
adding
This
place,
we
to
the
work-
too
complicated
had
already
life.
alerted
another six offices to convert. We had proceeded down the
road with them to the point where we felt we could not retrace
our steps.
There were many people who recommended that we not
convert them.
I would have to say on hindsight
that I wish we
had not,
too, but faced with the decision at that time, we
felt we had proceeded too far with the conversion in the second
six offices and so we proceeded with them also.
ing
At
the
the
death
same
time,
accounts
you
from
will
the
recall,
we
Philadelphia
had
been
district
decentraliz-
office
to
all regional offices.
This was an action which I know all of
you are most interested in because it is
a principle for which
I think all of us stand -- that the basic adjudicative process
can best be carried out close to the veteran,
as near as you
can operate a large system which is what we have in the regional
offices.
This meant #n toto that we had then committed ourselves
to conversion of something in the neighborhood of with amounted
to, then, a million three hundred thousand accounts:
1,300,000
running awards.
We have today in the files something more nearly approximating one and a half million because,
of course,
the
offices whose accounts were converted have fed more new cases
in there since conversion.
So we have today for consideration
about one and a half million accounts in the automatic data
processing system being paid from Chicago.
The
in
the
resolution
early
part
to
which
Mr.
Corcoran
"unlooked-for
read
problems"
to
you
having
referred
been
en-
countered up to October and I would admit there is now no
question but what there were '"unlooked-for problems.'
There
were unlooked-for errors in the programs;
there were unlookédfor errors in the records which has been converted;
and therefore,
there were unlooked-for workloads at a time when we could
ill afford to receive them.
We, I
problem and
However, we
and we have
unlooked-for
we
have
think, have to say we could not anticipate every
I must say we succeeded admirably in not doing so.
have benefited by the experience we have gained,
corrected them to the point where I, think that the
problems cannot be said to exist today.
I think
recovered
our
position,
have,
to the point where
for the job and they are
with some benchmarks why
and
I
thank
the
Lord
that
we
the programs certainly are adequate
doing the job, and I will indicate
we think that, a little bit later.
The resolution refers to delays in payment being encountered.
We certainly agree to
this but I would like at this
point to remind you that in the adjudicative process,
the
veteran is concerned with one thing.
He makes application for
a benefit and then in some prescribed period,
he hopes he will
get a check from the Veterans Administration if he is found
entitled.
From the point when the application is received in the
Veterans Administration,
we try to keep track of the time which
elapses until a check is mailed to the veteran from the Treasury
Department.
Prior to the conversion to automatic data processing, we were meeting the acceptable range of somewhere between 70 and 90°‘days.
We succeeded because of conversion,
but
also because of the fact that we received 18 new pieces of legislation last year including the pension law,
which alone resulted
in a workload of better than 250,000
actions that had to be taken
34
in our 67 offices; we succeeded with all of this workload which
we processed at a more rapid rate than
we have ever in our history -- and at a time when we were losing trained adjudicators
and Rating Board members because of age of World War I veterans,
thereby further complicating life with a retraining program;
we succeeded in building up large backlogs of work which only
recently have begun to come within manageable form.
The workload which is coming to us now is down.
It is down to more
reasonable proportions.
The impact of the pension legislation
and the psychological effect that it had on any number of World
War I veterans to beat the July 1 deadline with an application
for pension so they could have the right of election either
way, created a tremendous workload.
That workload is gone, but
we got hundreds of thousands of applications which would not
have arrived on the scene had it not been for that one deadline
alone.
All
process
of
in
this
the
caused
steps
delay.
which
It
are
taken
lengthened
before
the
ADP
adjudicative
ever
enters
into it; points where we develop the case,
examine the evidence,
and this kind of thing.
:It increased those from 30 to 40, to
50,
to 60
days in many cases,
In this phase,
you realize,
there also is the examination.
We ask the hospital or the
clinic for an examination
and any delays that incur there add
to the total.
The point after adjudication,
the point when
the award is authorized,
where ADP really comes into play, represents only a handful of days compared to the two or three
months represented in the build-up,
so I must say that I consider we are concerned here this morning only with the time
between the point where authorization say, "Yes, pay the man,"
and the point where the checks go out to them.
This is the area
that
in
the
main
represents
the
ADP
procedures,
not
the
build-
up in the beginning.
The build-up in the beginning was complicated by ADP to some extent because of the workload it created,
but I would remind you in talking about delays in payment,
that
most of the delay occurred because of the large backlog that
developed from the new legislation,
the training,
the loss of
people,
and so on.
ADP had
its part, but it should not be
cursed,
I submit,
because of the total.
"The new system created hardships for thousands."
(Qoutes
from Resolution 149).Admitted. Because of the conversion procedures
that were followed in the beginning thousands of cases
were dropped from payment status.
This has long since been
modified.
All of you, of course,
are familiar with the fact
that local authority is present for the regional manager to pay
any
case.
I
believe
that
the
reports
we
have
received
recently,
(and I am sure we will hear some talk about them this morning)
indicate that it is
not impossible to get a case
processed.
In fact,
it is normally not difficult
to get a case paid once
it has been identified as a problem case.
We believe the procedures we now follow,
and willin the future,
are so modified
that that will not occur again.
Here again, we have benefited
by the experience we have gained.
I would like very much to
be able to say that it didn't happen.
It did.
We must admit
it, but I will indicate in this area the benchmark wherein we
think improvement
is definitely identified.
Now,
let
us
look
at
what
we
consider
to
be
the
benchmarks
or the indicators that tell us whether this plan is running
properly or running improperly.
We received at a high point in
September,
a little over 21,000 inquiries from veterans whose
35
checks were being paid from the Chicago Data Processing Center.
On converted accounts only, we received just about 21,000-plus
inquiries.
About half of these inquiries involved cases where
a check had been issued but there was a delivery problem.
The
address was not properly indicated on the check,
either because
the veteran did not inform us promptly,
or we did not process
it promptly;
or in printing it the Treasury Department garbled
the address or even the name to the point where
it could not
be delivered.
In
about half the situations this was the situation.
In most of the others,
a check had been issued, but the
amount was questioned.
These are still categorized as inquiries.
The remaining represented cases where a check had
not been issued,
and this was where
the trouble stemmed back
from the beginning.
This was in September,
just prior to the
time when you passed Resolution 140,
In February,
the month just passed, we received 10,191
inquiries as compared to 21,000 in September.
In half of these
cases,
a check had been issued to the veteran but we still had
the delivery problem.
We get down to a point somewhere under
5,000
where a‘check had not
been issued,
and this is out of
one and a half million accounts.
I believe that this indicates
improvement.
We, of course,
are still not satisfied.
We are determined to do something about the change of
address problem which has plagued us for years, but no one ever
thought it sufficiently serious to try to do anything about it.
Never in the history of the VA have we ever made
any attempt
to find out in how many cases veterans are moving without notifying us.
We intend to hit this hard.
We intend to make an
intensive campaign;
first to remind the man himself,
or the
woman,
that they must come
to us and tell us when they move
if we are to give them prompt service;
second,
to improve the
method whereby we process these changes of address after we get
them.
We are flirting now with the idea that we will handle
this by teletype instead of having the forms processed through
normdl mail.
I think there is a tremendous amount that can be
done in this area and we intend to do it.
Also
the
area
of
improvement
--
another
reason
that
causes difficulty with a case, as I explained earlier,
is the
fact that for some reason it cannot be accommodated on the
electronic equipment after it is
sent to the center for payment
or for change.
In September we were rejecting a little better than ten
per cent of all of the actions which were submitted for processing through the computer.
In October between nine and ten
per cent.were being rejected.
In the month of January,
this
figure had dropped to 1.7 per cent.
We are handling between
150,000
and 180,000 actions a month involving changes in the
status of the accounts on the computer.
We had been rejecting
at our high point approximately 10 per cent and are now down
to 1.7 per cent and still going
down.
There has been a decline in each month since September.
This results from the fact that the data coming from the regional offices has improved;
the péople there are better trained;
they are furnishing a higher quality of input data for the equipment.
Also the programs by which the computer functions have
been modified in many cases to remove errors which were in them
in the beginning:
errors consisting of inability to accommodate
36
certain
many of
types
these
functions
The
of transactions,
errors,
and for
for
that
example:
We have
removed
reason
the
entire
operation
better.
1.7
figure
bothers
us.
We
would
like
to
see
nothing
rejected, but remember,
this figure includes the cases that
are rejected quite properly.
We may be trying to do something
which is impossible.
We may be trying, for example,
to pay
an amount to the veteran for a disability which is not provided
for in the rating schedule.
The electronic equipment
is geared
to scan the information which comes to it in any one situation
and because it already has programmed into it, already has in
its mind,
if you will,
all of the data that is in the rating
schedule,
when
a
case
passes
through,
if
there
is
an
impossible
combination under the schedule,
it will throw it out and
say,
"Please correct
this,
there is something wrong with it."
When
we converted the cases in the first instance from the regional
offices,
we
found
any
number
of
thousands
of
situations
like
this.
1 think that our records should be accurate,
1" would
hope you would agree.
We certainly would like to think that
in this area the machine offers a definite improvement over
what we have had in the past.
I think that the last point I would like to mention from
the resolution is the question that I think is uppermost in
your minds -- it
certainly is in ours -- the question of decentralization versus centralization in regard to whether it is
providing adequate or inadequate service.
TI indicated earlier that it is our belief .that the basic
ad judicative process should take place at the regional office
level.
This is the reason we decentralized the running award
death cases from the district offices.
We feel that the veteran's case file,
the records whereupon you establish the
validity of a claim,
should be located so that the representative
of the man, you,
if you will,
can examine them where the veteran
resides,
so that you can have him come to the Veterans Administration and demonstrate to him or even plead in his own behalf
in regard to the claim he has presented.
We think this is
essential and we think that this serves the veteran's best
interests.
However, when it comes to the administrative processes, we do
not see the
essentiality,
in regard to service,
in having the operation,
the procedural details involving the
check
And
the
issuance,
for
example,
this is the area
regional office.
which
located
we
have,
at
in
the
veteran's
effect,
doorstep.
removed
from
I would also remind you that prior to conversion not all
regional offices had in their facility the finance activity.
I will use, for example,
the Phoenix Regional office.
Payment
activity for Phoenix accounts was located in Los Angeles.
The
payment activity for some other stations in the Southwest was
located in Dallas.
The payment activity for New England states
was located in Boston.
Payment records were not in all the
regional offices.
About 45
had payment activity and the
remaining 20-plus did not.
You also know that the Treasury maintained
about
22
disbursing
offices
prior
some along with our conversion and
Chicago,
so that not all of the 67
fiscal activities.
What
we
have
done
now
is
to
-37
to
conversion.
They
have
closed
transferred their records to
regional offices had these
embark
on
a
course
whereby
there will be no such
tions.
This activity
procedural device.
I
fiscal activities in any of our 67 locawould take place in Chicago.
It is a
believe that so long as we can render
satisfactory
in
service
terms
of
getting
the
check
to
the
vet-
eran promptly after it is authorized in the regional office,
and I think that the record of improvement that I have mentioned
here this morning is indicative of the fact that it can be done
with this equipment
-- under these circumstances we are not only
justified,
but impelled to conclude that such a system is
feasible and proper.
Thank you very much.
We will be glad to
participate in any discussion or questions you have on the subject.
Thank
you,
Clarence.
CHAIRMAN
HORTON:
Bill,
before
you
take
you present by name to the Conference those
on this panel from Veterans Administration?
your
seat,
associated
would
with
you
MR. DRIVER:
Yes,
I shall be happy to and I apologize
to you for not doing so earlier.
On my immediate left is Mr.
Ferdinand Petraitis,
Executive Assistant
to the Chief Benefits
Director;
and his left, Mr. Wallace Koseluk,
the ADP Director;
on
his
left,
Service
and
of
the
the
Director
Department
of
of
the
Systems
and
Veterans' Benefits,
Standards
Mr.
Gene
Mock.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
For fear I overlooked this very important mission,
I would like to present to you by name also the
staff representatives on this panel, Mr. Ed Golembieski,
Assistant Director for Claims.
I am about to introduce The
American Legion Panel for the discussion of our problems of
today.
After I have done that,
I hope to be allowed to take
my seat near the rear of the platform and I will not expect to
return to this lecture,
except in the unlikely situation where
it might be necessary to restore order,
or to
call the expiration of time, or to make sure that you in the audience have
an opportunity to express yourself.
To represent The American Legion,
I .think that we do
have
indeed a distinguished group of experienced service officers
and field representatives.
I think perhaps that you would like
to join with me in commending the Director or the person responsible for having selected these people to speak for The
American Legion at the head table,
so to speak, on the matter
of the automatic data processing.
The fact that one of the
gentlemen is from Alabama is no slight recommendation.
The fact
that another comes from the home state of our National Chairman
is not without being worthy of note.
But to be more serious,
the man who will preside as Chairman of this particular group
is a man who comes from a fully converted station with something
more than one year's bitter experience and I think that I would
be
unfair
to
him
and
to
the
great
days
and
hours
of
work
that
he has devoted to documenting his position if I did not call
your attention the fine attributes which this man possesses
and the devotion to the cause which is jointly yours, Earl
Merifield from California,
the Chairman of the panel.
bers
He will, as opportunity affords,
of the panel.
Mr. Merifield.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Thank
Veterans Administration
and
introduce
the
other
to
mem-
you, Mr. Chairman.
Gentlemen of the
members of the Conference,
I believe
38
I would first like to introduce to you who
may not know them,
the members of the panel of which Clarence mentioned.
First,
Charles A. Zeglin, Department Service Officer,
Pennsylvania,
J. B. Clark, Department Service Officer of North Carolina,
W. W. Wadsworth, Department Service Officer of Alabama,
Leo M.
Leggett, Department Service Officer, Michigan, John Corcoran
has very capably set forth the primary purpose of this panel
and what we expect to accomplish.
I was reminded of an article
I read here when
Johnny read that part of the resolution that
mentioned the fact that experience has shown that automatic
data processing is not necessarily adaptable to all lines of
endeavor.
I read an article here from the Navy Management Review
by an outstanding representative,
in fact the Chief of the
Navy Management office.
I thought it would be appropriate to
read it to: you,
"Today,
everyone is fairly well familiar with the premium
placed upon painstaking detail in computer installations.
Yet,
many installations
are failures and most of the successful
installations have so far provided only extremely marginal economic benefits.
As a matter of fact, when it comes to business
logistics applications,
electronic computers appear to be
like
politicians,
full of promises,
but short on performance,
and
there are many who think it is high time that we voted them
out of office.”
The American Legion is dedicated and has been built on
service and the rehabilitation division service to the veteran
and his survivor.
If we permit situations and conditions to
arise that prevent us from giving that service,
then we may
as well go out of business.
The American Legion has zealously
guarded
the
rights
and
benefits
of
the
war
veterans.
down through the years,
has been to recommend means
service to him by Federal agencies can be improved.
Our aim
by
which
The American Legion beginning as far back as 1942, with
the World War Veterans Act has insisted on the decentralization
of Veterans Administration operations
in order to give the
veteran better service.
That was proven when the old district
office set up was decentralized to regional offices. We successfully opposed certain provisions of the management survey
report made of the Veterans Administration a few years ago,
which attempted to reorganize it by centralizing many of its
activities.
We fought
finally won our
thereby.
service
service
It
to
as
has
fer years
point and
been
veterans is
a result.
our
to decentralize death claims and
the survivors of veterans benefited
experience
centralized
that
he
when
suffers
any
a
form
reduction
of
in
The National Executive Committee,
at its meeting last
May went on record that in any reorganization plans of the
Veterans Administration,
or consolidation of workloads The
American Legion be given assurance that service to veterans
not be impaired,
and so we come to the subject for discussion
today,
automatic data processing,
ADP.
ADP is primarily a system of centralizing payments to
veterans and because of our experience as cited before, we
must scrutinize very carefully any plan for centralization.
39
I am not going to take the time to go
tails of what we in converted offices
have had to go through in the past 13
touched on that.
into the harrowing deand veterans involved
months.
Mr. Driver
You who have experienced it need not be reminded and
those of you in non-converted stations have either heard about
it, or have some knowledge as to what you can expect through
your simulated processing.
All
created
VA
and
officials
the
problems
admit
that
the
chaotic
still
exist.
situation
They
which
tell
you
was
of
the improvement
that has taken place.
This is admitted.
It
difficult to see how it could have become any worse.
They
tell you about further improvements
that can be expected.
These I will .accept with tongue in cheek;
they have made so
many
promises
as
to
when
the
system
would
function
is
properly
that have not materialized.
I am sure they must understand our
position,
but for sake of argument let us agree with them that
the operation will continue to improve.
I have neverdoubted
that from an operational standpoint it can be made to work.
I remember on several occasions Mr. Whittier,
former Administrator,
telling me it must be made to work.
However,
the
question in my opinion,
and which is before us today,
is after
it has been made to work operationally,
will it offer improved
service to the veterans and their survivors,
and here is where
we who have had experience in converted stations and have
studied the system from every angle part company with those
officials of the VA who are trying $ohard to sell their system
to
us.
Remember,
improved service was the reason
for adopting this system.
The Administrator of
Affairs in 1959 said
and I quote:
given to us
Veterans!
"It is essential to use available modern business methods to improve service to the veterans."
And further,
"In
adopting automatic data processing to VA payments it would
produce an over-all reduction in operating costs.
Mr. Whittier in his letter of resignation to the President
of the United States,
as Administrator of Veterans! Affairs,
as late as December 31, 1960, said in part in outlining the
accomplishments of his administration,
and I quote:
"The ultimate result will benefit the nation in terms
of tax dollars saved and veterans and their dependents in
terms of improvement
in service rendered."
This I emphasize
is the only reason that I know that has been given for adopting
this system and if this cannot be accomplished then surely
there is no purpose in using it.If The American Legion should
permit the Veterans Administration without raising its voice
in protest to adopt any system that will result in poorer service to the veteran,
then we have failed in our responsibilities
and our
obligations
to him.
So far we have seen
nothing but poorer service.
All we
have had is promises that it will ultimately be better than
before.
When I think of service to the veteran I am thinking
in terms of personal and sympathetic service that can, and
has been rendered in the past by the Veterans Administration,
and the representatives of the veterans'
organizations.
40
the
What
is
Department
the
of
ultimate
service
Veterans
Benefits?
the
veteran
I say
expects
it
is
the
from
timely
adjudication of his claim and the
prompt payment of benefits
due him.
I say to you, based on my experience,
that an
electronic computer in Hines,
Illinois can never give him
this.
No matter how efficiently the system can be made to
work,
it can never give the veteran better service,
nor can
it give him as good service as under the mechanized system of
payments.
What is more important to the needy veteran than to be
promptly informed as to when he can expect his adjustment
check as a result of an original or an amended award,
or to
be told immediately on his making inquiry as to why he did
not receive his check and when he may expect it?
They may
reduce the time that
it now admittedly takes of from nine to
26 days to get a write-out from the computer to show the status
of the account to only a few days;
they may reduce the time
that it now takes to get the Form 6566
in the file,
indicating
what the master record shows, from a minimum of two weeks to
probably five or six days;
they may reduce the time it now
takes to get an answer by wire from the data processing center
to a check inquiry to a few days;
they may even reduce the
time it now takes to pay a rejected award or a hardship case,
under appendix O.
But when and if eventually they reath these goals,
they
are still far shostiof the service that all of us, the Veterans
Administration included, were capable of giving the veteran
while he was stillin the office or on the telephone,
or in
reply to correspondence under the mechanized system,
and as
a result they can never reach their announced goal of improved
service,
but, on the contrary,
this new system has and will
result in poorer service to him -- and that, my friends and
comrades,
is the crux of the situation and, in my opinion,
the
only part of this highly complicated and involved system in
which The American Legion is interested -- I would be remiss
in my duties as discussion leader,
if I did not comment on
some of the remarks that Mr. Driver has made and also some
that
appear in a Review of VA ADP System for Benefit Payments,
dated
March 1, that is signed by the Chief Benefits Director.
but
I
the
do
not
know
Administrator
how
of
many
of
you
Veterans'
are
familiar
Affairs
in
with
last
the
October
fact,
called for an evaluation of the ADP program to be completed
by the end of December.
This is in three -- at least I have
had the opportunity of seeing three -- large columes of this
report.
I noted that some of the figures that Mr. Driver gave
appear in that report,
but in any that have been
given to you
or any that will be given by Mr. Driver's staff here during
the course
of the discussion,
I want to call to your attention
one particular paragraph that is contained in that report so
that you will keep it in mind when they give you figures of
accomplishments,
and it reads as follows:
This,
mind
you,
is
an
evaluation
of
the
ADP
program
by
the agency itself, by experts in the Veterans Administration.
"The ADP impact on service,
costs,
savings, backlog,
productivity,
or staffing cannot be accurately estimated by the
Veterans Administration from available information.
This is
true both for defects that have occurred thus far,
and for
those expected in the future.
41
has
I also wish to refer to another paragraph
great meaning and has great significance,
a
possibly
they
program
and
follows:
"It
will
give
you
the
figures
of
its
accomplishment,
is
recognized
of
Veterans Benefits
Department
that
cost
this
and
so
evaluation
comes
at
a
because it
when later
forth
of
and
reads
it
of
time
this
ADP
in
when
as
the
current
problems obscure the prospects of a more rewarding future.
This evaluation has attempted to give the timing of the study
full weight and the projections throughout it are considered
to be as optimistic as possible.
"However,
in order to achieve desired goals,
the Department must direct its efforts toward many basic improvements
and establish controls to insure their accomplishment."
There are
challenge,
like
‘office,
and
several
myself,
there
is
one
here that I know
you particularly
here
that
you would want to
from a converted
I am
sure
you
from
non-
converted offices would want to challenge.
One of these has
to do with a comparison,
and this is fundamental because it
has to do with the job that the staff, under the resolution,
has to perform this comparison with the operations of ADP
with the operation of the mechanized system prior to ADP.
We who have converted stations particularly have had to
work with this tremendous number of check inquiries and the
difficulties involved,
and in this report the Veterans Administration says:
"The precise volume of such inquiries received prior to ADP is not known."
That is admitted.
They
do not know.
But then they go on to say: "The task
force
that looked into this indicates that the inquiries equalled
one per cent of the total number of running awards."
I
challenge that figure.
The Los Angeles Office converted
160,000 accounts and not by the widest stretch of the imagination did we have 1600 such inquiries on checks,
and I believe that every one of the rest of your offices will challenge
that
figure.
They
admit
they
do
not
have
a figure
as
to
how
many inquiries prior to ADP, but then they use a figure that
is all out
of proportion to the experience that you and I have
had.
I know that today in the Los Angeles office, we have
14 full-time people in an inquiry control point, who do
nothing but spend their entire time on check inquiries,
and
I know that before ADP we didn't have a single one in such a
division and it was easily handled by the Contact Service.
So
I desire to challenge that point as being inaccurate.
Let me read another one that I am sure you from converted stations will agree with me we cannot buy. "The ADP
system itself adds little,
if any, impact to the current workload in the regional offices."
And Bill made the remark that,
after all, all ADP has anything to do with,
in this whole 70
to 90-day processing -- which is now from 90 on up in our experience
--
is
all ratings and
sure that there
that
all
are
take
exception
to
other
operations,
me:
about
to
new
small
portion
at
the
authorizations have
those of you on the
that,
that
it
takes
no
because
I have
had
too
end
of
the
thing after
been completed.
I am
floor who are going to
longer
on any of
many
of you
talk
these
to
‘it.
And they say this:
"These conditions were due primarily
legislation."
Some 18 pieces of legislation were
42
referred to.
You and I know that four-fifths of that legislation created no workloads, practically no workloads whatsoever.
You also,
I am sure, will agree with me that the
ma jor portion of the
workload created by new laws was Public
Law 86-211,
and you also know, and I think I can make the
statement,
that every office in the country was allowed additional permanent personnel to take care of what was projected
as an additional worklodd created by that law.
I believe in
the Los Angeles office, we have eight full-time people as the
figure given which was supposed to take up the slack of that
Public Law 86-211.
Therefore,
I say that we cannot charge
that Public Law 86-211 created the workload because they were
given additional personnel to take care of it.
So,
we only
had a couple of laws there that temporarily would disturb their
workloads,
and they did.
Public Law 86-663 did considerably
to disturb it, but it was only temporary.
It is nothing new.
We have had new legislation in every Congress since I can
remember,
and we have always had to take care of a temporary
increase in workload,
so, therefore,
I cannot buy the thing
that it was not ADP that created this situation;
it was new
legislation.
And here is one I want to leave for someone else to
answer,
In this summary,
the evaluation of the ADP program,
they called attention to the increased time lag for adjudicating original claims,
showing how the line went up from some
70 days to 95
days.
Then, they say further on this new legislation, "But look,
in non-converted stations the line also
went up in proportion,
the same as converted stations,' and
therefore,
they deduce it could not have been due to ADP.
"It
must be due to new legislation because it is the same in both
stations," and I want you people in non-converted stations to
listen because I am not in a non-converted station,
and I
cannot
answer,
"We
have
but
no
some
of
evidence
you can
that
answer
these
this,
I
simulated
am
sure.
procedures
are adding to current workload situations.”
I will leave that
for some of you to answer.
I know that you probably can hardly
wait.” Those are to my mind at this time the most important
things
that
should
be
brought
to
your
attention,
and
with
the
permission of the Chairman,
I would like to give just a few
minutes to each of our discussion leaders on the panel here
to make any comments that they care to before this is thrown
onto the floor.
We will start out with Mr. Ziglin of Pennsylvania,
MR.
ZEGLIN:
Let's
go
to
the
grass
roots
of
the
auto-
matic data processing.
Mr. Driver stated that there was an
improvement in the service.
I would like to just generalize
on several situations which we have in the Pittsburgh office.
We have a case of a widow who has never received her check in
the system from the beginning.
I could not get anywhere with
it.
I appealed to John Corcoran'’s office.
They paid her, I
guess, on the "hard copy."
To date, she is still not in the
system.
Every month
comes up and we have to pay her under
Appendix 0; and that definitely is not an improvement.
Around the middle of February,
I received a 'phone call
from a postmaster in a small town in the western part of Pennsylvania,
He told me, "I usually get 40 to 50 Veterans Administration checks in the mail.
"This month," -- that is the end
of January -- ''there are none.' “These
people are making
43
inquiries and I am at
could have happened."
we
to
a
loss
to
give
them
any
reply
as
to
what
We had to take those cases
individually,
and I am sure
didn't find them all, and make inquiries and ask the system
check this out,
Here is an
example of an entire shipment
that
just
dropped
out
of
sight.
I would
briefly
like
to
make
a comment on the blind aspect of this system.
A while back,
I
got a letter from a veteran.
He said, "Thank you for continuing
the payment of my pension check.
You told me that I was not
entitled to any more, but you keep sending them to me and I do
appreciate them."
where
How
the
initial
many checks are
veteran doesn't
payment
payment,
I téll
they ask you for
it will stop and
is
being
in the system
speak up?
We
repeated,
say,
that
have
$400
are being paid
cases where the
or
$500
initial
the veteran,
"Put the money in the bank until
it, because if I make inquiry to the system
Lord knows when you will get your check."
We are faced with the change of address.
I say to the
veteran,
"Heavens,
don't change your address.
If there is
any way of forwarding your check you have it forwarded.
Don't
change your address because your check will fall out of the
system and Lord knows when you will get it."
That is a very
bad situation.
As I say again,
there is a blind aspect to this
system.
You can't ask the system,
"Now is that man entitled?
1s he getting a pension?"
Or, Is he entitled to get a check?”
They-éan't tell you,
It. is up to the: individual. to report.
What if this poor widow I cited didn't have a telephone?
She
is bedfast.
She is sick.
She asked somebody to make the call
for her.
If they didn't speak up, she would never get a check.
So the system is not good and at the grass roots it is not
working.
That is ail I have.
is
MR. MERIFIELD:
there any comment
MR.
CEARK:
It
Thank you.
you care to
would
be
Mr. Clark
make?
rather
of
difficult
North
to
Carolina,
add
anything
to what Mr. Merifield has already stated, but Mr. Driver in
trying to sell the ADP system to the committee the other day,
remarked about these machines are ‘the same as those being used
by the Army to compile data in regard to our missiles program.
Now, we know why it isn't working.
The same situation exists
in Winston-Salem,
I think,
that exists in all the other converted stations.
They talk about the improvement being shown
in statistics;
they are showing improvement.
They had to.
The
situation could not have gotten worse.
But it is only cleaning
up a mess that they
created themselves by adopting ADP, and a
service officer inr the field cannot any longer render service
to the veteran,
and, as the Administrator said yesterday,
that
is our primary purpose.
If they continue with this they may
as well just do away with all service officers.
Thank you.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Mr.
Wadsworth
Thank
of
you
Mr.
Clark.
Alabama.
MR. WADSWORTH:
I think Chairman Bob McCurdy pretty well
described it to some of us yesterday whenhe said, "It ought
to be changed to automatic dementia praecox.'"
Unless there is
much improvement
in a very short period I don't think we will
have enough beds to take care
of the service officers alone who
44
are being subjected to ADP.
Frankly,
and I thank the Lord
every day I am from a non-converted station and I certainly
hope that prior to going under the system or going back to
the mechanized system,
that there will be a great deal of
improvement;
this is the first time in my 16 years of experience and work that I am left hopelessly without an answer
and know nothing I can do.
You can obtain the C-folder,
or
the XC folder. There is no explanation as to
why a check was
not issued or received.
There is no explanation that you can
give as to when a check will be forthcoming.
It has taken
away
from
the
service
officer
for the beneficiary in
confusion,
overpayment
initiative
to
a critical situation,
and so forth.
the
We
do
something
talk
about
I ran a little survey in my non-converted station.
We
only have 23 per cent of our running awards under the system.
During the fiscal year 1960,
there were only 73 overpayments
in
the
regional
office.
From
July
through
December,
under
the
automatic processing alone,
and bearing in mind only 23 per
cent of the caseload under the system,
there were 282 overpayments.
I certainly think that if we are to continue in
this field that the Veterans Administration should set up some
type of liaison service between automatic data processing and
the disbursing office,
and the post office.
We are leaving
the burden of proof on the veteran when he does not get a
check to follow through in every aspect.
him
erans
a
The VA say, "We issued you the check.'
Then they
lost-check letter.
That doesn't come back to the
Administration.
It
comes
back
to
the
disbursing
send
Vet-
office
through the post office.
We don't give him service from the
VA standpoint,
in my opinion,
to help him find that check,
and help him locate the check,
and locate the difficulty which
caused him not to receive the check.
I certainly think that
during this critical period some type of liaison should be
set up to tell that veteran immediately why he didn't get his
check and when he will receive his check.
I certainly would like to see a great deal of improvement in the time period from non-receipt of the check until
an answer is received as to why a new check was not received.
We are experiencing at the earliest some 16 or 18
days after
we submit the inquiry before he gets an answer,
Quite often,
the answer is not satisfactory.
But all we get is we, is we
get the check number and a Form 162 letter was sent to the
beneficiary.
In that period of time, we are just about due for
another check to be issued,
and we still have not located the
first check.
I think that the Veterans Administration must
certainly do something to expedite,
if nothing else,
the
answer to the veteran as to non-receipt of payment.
improve
There
the
is
one
system.
other
The
thing
that
regional
I
think
office
we
hands
should
are
do
tied
to
after
they get that check number.
They said,
"There is nothing we
can do.
We can't pay under Appendix 0, or any other procedure."
I think we have to work the bugs out of this thing and set up
some type
of system to cancel and immediately issue a check
under Appendix 0 from the regional office.
Thank you very
much.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
And
Mr.
Leggett
45
from
Michigan.
Mr.Leggett
is
from
a
converted
office.
MR. LEGGETT:
Thank you, Earl.
Ladies and gentlemen,
certainly heard the pros and cons on this issue.
I am
have
going
to
repeat
observations
As Earl said,
at that time
ment in this
in Detroit.
fested
by
things
here,
other
than
to
just
empress
a
you
not
few
that I have concerning the Detroit regional office.
we were one of the first converted offices,
and
I couldn't foresee the possibility of any improvething for years to come.
I have seen improvement
Whether or not this improvement has been mani-
efficiency
in
the
worthwhile
efforts
of
the
Veterans
Administration employees themselves, I do not know, however,
I say this relative to the automatic data processing:
the
amount of inquiries that we are currently receiving of the
VA in Detroit certainly does not reflect a greater efficiency
on the part of ADP.
The inquiries that we are currently receiving have increased over the past months.
I have a member of my staff in
the office conducting a survey since this automatic data processing system became involved in the situation,
and we see
no definite improvement in payments.
We see in some areas
where a check was rejected and Appendix O put into force that
these individuals never are back into the system in a running
award.
It seems that you run into cases where they are continually being rejected,
each and every one, for no apparent
reason.
It
is
a
question
such
as
we
have
already
presented
here.
How do we stop these things?
It is an
impossibility certainly
on the part of all of us to do anything about it, other than
to advise a veteran that we cannot give an answer,
We can
only go to the VA and attempt to resolve this problem.
In the Detroit regional office we have had VA employees
working many hours of overtime to try and catch up with this
backlog.
We in Detroit,
have a terrific backlog in the adjudicative division.
When ADP came along, we had individuals who ©
had filed, who had not been awarded claims in eight, nine,
ten
and 11 and 12 months'
time, waiting all this time for a check.
The backlog in our office was very bad.
In summation,
I would just say this:
that I see no immediate improvement in the automatic data processing itself.
We
have shown very definite gmprovement in our own regional office
in the backlog that we incurred in the adjudicative division.
In talking with and in questioning the other individuals in the
various organizations
concerning this ADP matter,
they and my-
self
would
recommend
that
it
be
abolished.
Thank
you.
MR. MERIFIELD:
The Chairman,and Vice Chairman,
and the
discussion leaders agree that those who have sent in questions
on ADP for the Veterans Administration officials that have
attended this forum should be given the opportunity to express
themselves on this subject, particularly as to whether or not
they are satisfied with the answers that have been given by
the Veterans Administration to their questions so I will now
entertain that discussion by those who submitted questions.
I
have not. had an opportunity to go over the answers as yet.
They
appear
to
this.
Are
be
Administration
very
complete
personnel
there
any
and
for
I
want
their
questions?
46
fine
to
compliment
mathod
of
the
Veterans
presenting
MR. POWERS (GEORGIA:
We submitted some questions and
they cover a rather broad field.
I share with you the doubtful
privilege of being in a converted station,
and in addressing
myself to our questions and discussion that has taken place
here this morning,
I would like to review the entire matter
Just a bit.
I have been privileged to be here for 12 years.
In this
room are what I consider
to be the people who work most closely
with the Veterans and their dependents in rendering service to
them and in this 12 years'
time I don't recall having
to take
up the subject of getting the money into the hands of the
veterans and their dependents,
after the awards had been laboriously caught up and after we did succeed in getting the claim
through,
We had never been troubled with the payment so I am
disturbed
have
at
all
of
this
had
no
difficulty
In
our
station,
effort
with
we
to
over
were
correct
the
a situation
past
getting
12
that
we
on
new
years.
excellent
service
cases and amended awards and on those mistakes that needed
correction we were able to get one-day service
on the checks
and tell the people exactly when they could get their checks.
That was exactly what we wanted to render to them in the way
of service.
We carefully went along with the study of the ADP
system after it took place in Georgia.
We worked with every
one in our regional office in an -effort to be cooperative.
We
even withheld complains as long as we could on the non-receipt
of checks,
and the unavailability of information,
and we reached the point, finally,
of complete exhaustion,
and we reached
the point where our regional offices and our service establishment in Georgia were unable to render the service to veterans
that we felt they were entitled to.
Then we teed off on ADP and it is
our belief from our
careful study that you will never be able under ADP to render
a service to the veterans and their dependents equivalent
to
that which was being rendered under the old system.
We base
that
on
the
fact
of
the
growing
number
of
new
cases,
the
grow-
ing number of death awards,
and the growing number of amended
awards,
and our study shows that in each of those from the date
of final adjudication,
the date that the decision is finally
made to pay the man,
there is a lag of 21 days at best.
They
can correct the mails all they please,
and correct the machines
all they please, but they can't possibly tell the people that
under this system they can expect their checks before 21 days,
and that is not correction enough for most people who have not
received their very livelihood on the day that they are entitled
to receive the check.
Through
in
the
answer
this
to
whole
one
of
thing
our
there
runs
questions
as
the
to
tenor
what
which
effect
I
is
note
going
to come out of the teemendous overpayments that are involved,
and they say, '""We see no bad effect because we believe that
those are running awards and the people are still entitled to
the money and the VA will lose nothing because they can recover
that money."
That is a point that disturbs a service officer because
every bit of that recovery comes from people who cashed their
checks believing that they were entdtled to them.
They spend
the money for their livelihood and are later called on to have
it deducted from their running awards,
and the hardship and the
47
loss
to
gotten
on the
enough
In our
of the
those
people
we
serve
is
tremendous.
Had
they
not
the mistaken check,
they would have gotten by perhaps
amount to which they are entitled.
They are not smart
in every case to know they have gotten too much money.
regional office, we have gone from the very beginning
filing of the case right on through and we find not a
single
process
that
has
not
been
adversely
affected
by
ADP.
Certainly,
at the present
time,
there has been improvement,
but
I had a friend who suffered a complete hemiplegia,
and 30 days
later when he moved a little finger they said there has been a
dramatic improvement,
and that is the expression that has been
used in this, "There has been improvement and there will be
more in the mechanical process," but everything that has been
done to make that improvement reached its crux by this of
spending money,
every penny available,
I believe, for overtime
that the Veterans Administration has been expending.
Non-converted stations have had funds withdrawn from them
to pay for overtime in converted stations,
to pay for this
crash program of bringing this this up to the very best point
it could be by the time of this meeting,
and that point is far
from satisfactory to those of us who serve the veteran in the
field.
We cannot,
after careful study see any possible tiein with,
if you please,
1.7 per cent rejects or mistakes,
with
better than 700 brand new cases arising from deaths every day,
with every amended or every new case.
After all of the laborious process of weighing the case,
we don't believe that we should have to say, "There will be a
minimum of 21 days before we can do anything about it.
We
can't answer your question before that time.
We can't tell
you where it is or the date you are going to get your check."
In effect, we can't render advice to the veterans at the
Veterans Administration and in the 12 years I have been privileged to come here,
I have had nothing that has shaken the
confidence of the general public and the veterans and their
dependents in the Veterans Administration,
and in the service
officers
themselves
than
has
this
ADP
program.
It
does
not
render equivalent service to the old system.
It can never
render equivalent service,
and if The American Legion accepts
anything less than equivalnt or better service for the veteran,
then,
as Earl said to begin with, we ought to close up the
store and go home.
We are here to serve veterans and this
program will not serve them with the efficiency that the previous program would.
the
We in Georgia belive
quicker,
the better.
that
it
ought
to
be
abolished
and
MR. BLALOCK (NORTH CAROLINA):
If you will look you will
find that North Carolina has about eight
of the questions that
the VA has answered.
They reviewed the entire problem that we
have run into in our Winston-Salem office.
We will not go into
that because we have page after page of explanations as to what
they are trying to do to get rid of these problems.
Suffice
to say, we in North Carolina don't like the system.
The service
has completely broken down,
as far as the service officer is
concerned.
I think many of the things that have been
answered
here in much detail explain why we take exception.
We
have
seen
the
improved
48
procedures
at
work.
They
do
get
them paid occasionally and they do help to some extent.
I do
want to cite a few figures that we are running into in our
own individual office.
Before conversion to ADP we had one
GS-4 working half-time handling every payment.
He worked halftime.
We had between 150
and 200 overpayment-accounts outstanding.
As of February 23, 1961, we had 1,046 overpayment
accounts outstanding.
At one time we had up in our correction
room, and that is about all you can call it, 14 people working
up there to make this ADP work,
seven of these at one time
were our top-flight adjudicators.
No wonder we have a backlog
in adjudication.
At the present time, we still have four of our top-flight
adjudicators trying to make ADP work.
The number of people
working in adjudication at the present time, is 88 as compared
to 78 we had before all this started.
At one time, we had a
28.6 work day backlog in adjudication.
After spending 11,000
overtime manhours to get to this particular point, we are still
6.8 days behind in adjudication.
I wish we had time to go
into individual cases,
but we want to talk about the general
over-all picture and I would like to give the floor to Colin
McKine from North Carolina and let him discuss the over-all
economy and service in North Carolina.
MR. MCKINNE (NORTH CAROLINA):
My remarks in many respects are really to reinforce or substantiate
the remarks by
my collegue from Georgia.
Last October
the then Administrator
of the Veterans' Affairs, Mr. Whittier,
came down to North
Carolina in the regional office there at Winston-Salem.
He
seemed quite surprised at the position which we took concerning
ADP,
1 would like to say that, frankly,
1 do not think Mr.
Whittier
action
in
was
fully
informed
or
the
field
until
visited
he
had
full
our
knowledge
of
the
re-
office.
At that time, I discussed the over-all aspects of ADP
with him and he agreed with me that what we are after, basically,
is efficiency.
By nature and by my own individual training and
formal education,
I am sympathetic to any system which will
improve any administrative operation.
He agreed with me that
efficiency
could
be
brown
into
two
factoss.
One was
economy
of
operation and the other was quality of service.
Certainly,
when we are dealing with human beings and veterans,
and even
more important,
the confidence of those veterans,
the quality
of service is the most important of these two factors.
Mr.
Whittier conceded this.
I then proceeded to point out to him
that a standard for the service would be service definitely
which is no less or no worse than the service we enjoyed under
our then existing system,
our former system
of payment.
To
this he agreed.
We showed him then conclusively that ADP not only is not
as good, but is much worse,
and at that time we could show no
real improvement in the quality of service.
As for economy of
operation,
I had then seen
no figures on what was anticipated
through economy.
Mr. Whittier gave me no information and I
expected no detailed information from him, and I gave him questions and these questions prompted the meeting with Mr. Whittier,
and a written statement.
I was surprised to get a reply to my question:
''When
can we expect to be as economical and efficient as under the
mechanized system?"
Im part,
I say compare the two
systems on
-49
the
basis
of
economics.
Since the 18 pieces of 1960 legislation are already introduced,
the aging veteran population increased and with economic conditions such as they were, we experienced a workload
increase.
All of these things were fully known before ADP was
initiated
and
forced
into
these
other
offices.
Mr. Teague stood in this room a year ago, and told us
they expected Public Law 86-211 to be passed.
The Veterans
Administration,
so far as I can tell, completely ignored what
was coming and forced this thing through,
anyway.
They then
come along and compare the two things in their economic study.
The thing, as I have seen it, is giving us no better quality
of service.
As I see it, there is no economy of operation.
We in North Carolina agree with Georgia.
We do not think the
system will work and frankly, we are sick and tired of it.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Thank
you.
Mr.
Dixon,
MR. DIXON (FLORIDA:
I think I probably stand here in a
rather confused state.
I have the greatest respect for my
friend,
Bill Driver.
I don't want ito say this, but I am of
the opinion that a lot of the decisions made in CO that I have
been involved in the Florida office have been based on figures
that I don't see how they can be substantiated.
Certain figures for Florida and the ones I have made do not coincide.
I will cite only
one example.
You
can
take
the
contact control
point.
They
keep
score
two ways, cases under seven days and cases over seven days.
They will
tell you it takes an average time of six days to get
an answer from Chicago.
My own figures show it takes an
average of 16 to 18 days to get an answer from Chicago.
I know
when you get to arguing these things based on what you have,
you run into a bunch of @obwebs that will drive you crazy. I
can't see why there is such a differnce.
What I can't seem
to get from the Veterans Administration any more is an honest
answer.
Let me give you something that I have happened to
steal.
This is how tough it is to get things these days.
This is for the week of January 3, 1961.
Inquiries less than
7 days 146, over seven days, 271; delays 1-2 months 56,
over
two months,
166.
This doesn't average 6 days.
To me it is
information that you can't get, it seems, for the men who rely
on the Veterans Administration for it.
Let me talk about the process that takes place up to the
time the award is to be paid.
The only information we get is
regarding ''pay rejects"
Nobody will tabulate these 7,000 to
8,000 6560's
that are coming into Florida every month that
somebody has to go over.
You go through this God-awful thing,
this long sheet of paper;I see 6 or 7 people trying to figure
out just exactly why this thing has been sent back,
so I say
to you, there is quite a delay in adjudication and I will say
to you also that in the finance service there were 3600 6560's
on accounts receivable that somebody had to go over. There is
no work measurement
to do this.
There are no people assigned
in any finance division to do this work.
They seem to do it in
their space time.
You can talk to people at the VA supervisory level and
it seems we receive the pat story that the situation is improving and it is going to work, but when you talk to people on the
50
rating boards,
invariably they will tell you it takes from
10:to 20 percent
longer to rate the case.
.You talk to authorizing people and they tell you it takes 30 per cent longer to
authorize a case.
I am not too concerned about the checks.
You can pay them thru the KKK as far as I am concerned.
I
don't know, but I feel that the luck will change.
What I am
concerned about is the guy who doesn't get his check,
I can't
even get a case file sometimes because you have so many of
them stacked up around the Veterans Administration
that it
takes these people from 30 to 40
days to secure the files
from
the
Veterans
We
have
appeals
that
Administration.
numerous
have
to
veterans
wait
coming
there
for
4
into
or
5
our
office
hours
and
on
have
to
go home without a hearing.
If it is in the ADP control he has
marked his time, because we can't pull them out of this thing
and talk to people.
You say you have no measuring point. We
do
have.
I
can
take
you
into
my
own
shop.
take care of check inquiries in my shop.
a half people following up on checks.
One
Now,
person
we
used
to
two
and
have
There is no doubt in anybody's mind that you can make
this work if you spend enough money and sacrifice enough veterans,
This may be the thing that will eventually work,
but
whether or not we can stand it is the question,
I have had
people come to me and say, "What is The American Legion going
to do about this?"
And I am talking about people in the
Veterans Administration.
You have beaten the people to death
and I say to you that no one has worked any harder than the
people in VA.
They have worked Saturday and Sunday and spent
11,000 in overtime since January 1.
We have cooperated.
We
have been apologizing around the country for the Veterans
Administration.
We just can't do it any more because we are
getting into irouble.
We heard here today about a report that was made by the
Veterans Administration itself in reference to ADP.
I understand one went to the Administrator and because the report was
not favorable,
it was rejected and another report was ansked
for.
I would like some
comment on this particular question.
take
MR.
MERIFIELD.
MR.
DRIVER:
On
your
question,
it
is
Mr.
Driver,
the
question
there
of
was
a
the
report,
report.
I
and
this
assume
I
you
are referring to the one covering the survey which was made
by the Administrator's staff on ADP, -- the one we have been
discussing this morning having to do with regional office payments.
There was only one evaluation.
The report itself
actually came from a number of drafts from a number of people
who participated in the avuluation.
So far as I know,
there
was only one report and I am happy to hear you say it was
favorable.
Frankly,
I must say I think the report in many
areas is properly critical.
I would also like to say while I have the opportunity
that I would like to stress myself,
the point you made about
the cooperation of The American Legion and other veterans’
organizations,
We are quite proud of the fact that you have
done this and we thank you.
At
of
the
the
same
regional
time,
office
I
must
personnel
51
acknowledge
have
been
too,
that
Herculean.
the
efforts
I
think
they do deserve the praise you have given them.
At the risk
of perhaps overburdening the subject,
I would like to join in
this.
I am happy
to work with people who are as dedicated as
these people are.
I must underline the fact, however,
that the
workload which they have encountere this past year is not
strictly the result of ADP.
It is
the result of everything
else which has been discussed here this morning.
We have had
more legislation in this past year than in the previous seven
years.
A lot has been said from the standpoint of overpayments.
You realize,
of course, many of these overpayments existed in
the records at the time of the conversion,
but were unknown
to any of us.
We discovered them because of the ADP system -=
and this is an advantage.
They must be recognized and dealt
with and we hope to keep them under control.
We believe in the system or we would not be
The question gets down to a discussion of whether
tremely high speed system is adequate in terms of
the veteran.
We want the veteran to have all the
may need that is relevant.
trying it.
this exservice to
data that he
MR. DIXON:
With respect to the report that I am referring to, I have heard rumors floating around,
and this is why I
asked my question,
that it was originated by some guy named
Riley and it went to the Administrator and he said that there
was too much adverse stuff,
Take it back.
Work on it some more.
This is what I wanted.
MR. DRIVER:
Frank Reilly was the director of the staff
which prepared the report that was referred to this morning.
As one of the staff he made his own studies in his particular
area
just
like
the
other
members.
I
presume
he
prepared
drafts
and may have discussed this with the Administrator,
but the
report,
and the only report I know of, is the one we made
available to your organization -- the report confronting the
new Administrator of Veterans' Affairs.
Frank Reilly was in a
large measure responsible for the report
.
Frank Reilly is the
man and that is the rfport.
There may have been several drafts
of the
report.
I
I would
hope
they
assume
they were
would
be.
Just
for a trial, you
You do your best
thing.
And this
start out and rewrite over and over again,
to make sure
that you have identified everyis how we get the report we have.
reviewed
ana reported
as a lawyer
prepares
a
out,
brief
MR. BLALOCK:
The statement was made here that we should
compare what we were getting to what we have under ADP.
In our
regional office, we had an average of some 20 check inquiries
a month before ADP.
Since this system went into effect we had
1,107 in October,
in November,
671,
in December,
568,
and in
February 308.
Those are the figures as of February 23.
I
have figures for the same months
that were given to me in
December and they are not the same figures.
Both were given to
me by the VA.
MR. DRIVER:
In the area of where the veteran says,
"I
don't get my check," or "I got it in the wrong amount," -- Before ADP there was no attempt made to count the inquiries in
this area.
I know that inquiries regarding checks and amounts
were handled in various divisions of the regional offices before
conversion to ADP, mostly in the finance activity.
They still
52
are in non-conveted stations.
One figure that we do
know,
that bears directly on inquiries is the fact that there were
more than 30,000 address changes put into the ADP system last
month,
The figures I just gave you showed the decline.
I
indicated that insofar as figures since ADP, in converted
accounts we had a high of 21,000 in the month of September
and it was down in February to 10,000.
This is the reason why
I say wei are improving ana:1 think this will work,
MR. DIXON:
In Florida, we get about 3,000 changes of
address a month.
There are about 5,000
laying there to be
transferred after ADP freeze.
We have these case files which
have to be moved from Florida to somewhere else,
With the
average number of employees
that you have today to transfer
file cases it would take three years.
You are getting current
and vou
are getting improvement.
Have you taken a good look at your diary system?
In
Florida, we got current last month.
I know also that the diary
system increased from 2500
to 6,000.
I found a lot ot it down
there.
MR.
DRIVER:
A
lot
of
work
naturally
results
in
a
aiary.
MR. DIXON:
[It is still-pending..
1 say it looks to
like you in the VA have used every means available to you
put us in a position where we have to buy this ADP.
This
resent,
MR. . DRIVER:
1 think, Mr. Dixon, we are
every effort to make this work and I am happy
we have done everything we possibly can to do
MR.
MERIFIELD:
As
MR.
PEFLEY
as
we
are
concerned,
forth
you say
is
the
Are
there
any
of
those
on
the
floor
who
(OREGON):
I am
rather
green
as
far
as
end of the questions.
care to discuss this?
far
putting
to hear
so.
me
to
I
that
this
service work is concerned,
but I do know something about the
mechanics of the thing.
Nothing has been said
so far about
the mechanical errors running into the system.
I visited a
regional office where they are simulating ADP ana I ran a program on the flexowriters.
It is my understanding under the
program the flexowriters
are to prepare the data to go into
the
computer.
You
are
supposed
to
be
able
to
run
the
tape
back
through the machine and it would write out the same as you put
in it in the first place.
There were three flexowriters
and
not a one of them could do it.
If that is so, we are going to
be fouled up in
the pure mechanical stage from here on out.
There is also one of these overlays to attempt to read it.
I
am told by those in the office there that it takes anywhere
from two to four hours to run it down, and then they just give
up because they can't find anything wrong,
so it must be purely
mechanical error again.
Nothing
machine.
has
been
said
so
MR. DRIVER:
TI am sure
could make suggestions as to
improved -- our training and
We
do
have
all
the
far
about
the
purely
mechanical
that you all are interested
how you think this ought to
conversion of the system to
flexowriter
53
equipment
available
in
and
be
ADP.
local
offices to prepare the punch tapes and when the time comes to
convert,
the operators will be properly trained.
We are very
much aware of the fact that the in-put data is the key to the
successful operation of this whole thing.
The fact is the number of transaction rejections has declined just as rapidly as
the pay rejects,
The same is {rue of all the other areas
where rejection have occurred.
The question of mechanical
error in the tape is absolutely de minimis.
I don't know that
you want to get into a technical discussion of how this
works.
I think the best possible answer would be for all of you interested in this to visit a regional office and sit down and
go through the steps with the service officers at the converted
station,
and I would hope that they would testify to the fact
that the ability of the personnel to handle this has improved
along
with everything else.
that
MR.
were
PEFLEY:
Don't these flexowriters
put in there in the first place?
put
in
the
errors
MR. DRIVER:
If the operator is beginning to learn he
might make errors.
But we would not expect him to write the
errors in.
1f you type an ®a’- into the thing and vou mean to
type an l'o!, you are going to get an "al out.
MR. PEFLEY:
@ don't seem to have made my point clear.
At the same time,
the machine punches a punch it also types
a copy so you can see what has been written,
and it is the same
thing you have typed in the first place.
with
MR. DRIVER:
Then,
the equipment.
MR.
PERLEY:
"YT
there
is
so,
too.
think
abviously
MR. DRIVER:
I don't agree with that
haven't had the benefit of operation yet.
has gone in and they have been maintaining
have done very
well.
something
wrong
as a whole.
You
The Friden Company
them and I think
MR. MERIFIELD:
Several of the fellows have brought up
this question of inaccurate statistics.
I thought I would
like to quote you one sentence from this evaluation report.
Several of you have mentioned what appears to be a conflict in
the statistics that you get.
In this summary of ADP you have
a sentence which reads:
"One of the important objectives of
conversion to ADP, accuracy of statistical records,
has not
been realized.
MR. WOODS:
(ARIZONA)
I would like to make one or two
comments on ADP,
something which you fellows have gone
through,
and that is with respect to the interim file, which is a nice
way of saying,
"Send this back to the file room until we can
take: a. ilook at it.
sent
We have found cases that have already
back into the interim file with action
This
we
have
corrected,
but
we
can
only
been rated benefits
to put it in ADP.
correct
those
that
have
come to our attention.
Very recently I received power of
attorney from our service officer
in Dallas.
It was stamped
in the regional office,
"August 8, 1960," and went to the
interim file.
This was an original claim for service connection.
On February 6, the Phoenix regional office made the
54
original request for military records.
They
on that claim when it was filed in August of
direet result of ADP.
have
MR.
gone
MERIFIELD:
Your
into the interim
point
file,
MR.
DRIVER:
say
1
would
took no action
1960.
This is
is that claim
I think.
more
than
never
a
should
that.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Mr. Driver made a statement
in which he
used the example of an office prior to conversion not having
its own finance office.
A representative of the Washington
central office was in L.A. not long ago, and
made the statement
that he loves offices that do not have finance offices,
because
this type of station gets better service under ADP.
Coming
from
coming
such
a
from
station,
such
a
would
you
care
MR. WOOD:
There has been a
months ago.
There is no question
been working overtime.
They have
long
some
to
comment
on
that,
you
station?
as I can
remember
on this
improvement,
but
I cannot
change from what we saw two
of that.
The people have
been working Saturdays and
problem,
say
it
and so there
has
been
compares
favorably
to
the old system.
We used to be able to get checks out in five
to seven days in the ordinary case and the hardship case in
two or three days.
The ordinary check was knocked out in about
seven days.
Now, I would say 30 days.
The thing has been so
complicated and so disastrous as far as Service Officers are
concerned,
that I also started a crash program to solve the
inquiries
that
you
get
the
first
of
every
month
and
I
started
this the first of February.
I don't write your check.
I wish
I did.
I would write you one right now.
Go see the VA.
Write
a letter to Barry Goldwater.
Write the President,
write to
anybody about your troubles, because I am sick of them.
MR.
KLEMMETSON
(Washington):
I come
from
a state,
Conners,
Minnesota,
where we teach our boys football and to respect the
name of the first President of the United States.
Two years
ago, I had an opportunity to teach a little history to the
Department of Wisconsin,
and some history to the Department of
Minnesota.
Now, going back to the question,
I think we all
agree that we are not getting any place.
We agree that ADP
does not work.
So the only thing here is a resolution.
I
would like to suggest that you bring out the problem before the
Resolutions
Committee.
:
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
I would like to suggest to the Conference that we not entertain any resolutions at this moment.
I would like to suggest that you withhold any recommendation or
resolution.
We must stop in ten minutes.
If you will indulge
me to that extent,
I will be grateful,
MR.
KLEMMETSON:
I
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Is
bow
to
there
the
wisdom
further
of
the
Chairman.
discussion?
MR. YOUNG (VERMONT):
I, too, come from a small station in
northern New England, where current payments are paid out of
Boston.
Presently all of our awards are still being paid from
Boston, but we have a very few death cases that are in the system -- only 16 or 17.
However,
the point I want to emphasize
is this, and we are back to service now,
If someone comes to
5
me now and asks about an award or when he can get
his check,
and bear in mind that the payment is made from
Boston,
I get
an answer for them within a very reasonable length of time,
if
it is paid from Bostonm but if someone comes to me and asks
me about a missing check in the system,
I am lost.
A widow,
when she first went into the system lived in Chester, Vermont
and her check was not received at the end of the month.
Her
daughter happened to be teaching my child in another town.
It
took
seven
her
checks
months
kept
to
get
going
to
this
case
straightened
Chester,
out
because
Virginia.
Somebody suggested we make a change of address and I said,
"Heavens
, no.
They will be sending it to Chester Gunsmoke."
In the meantime,
my boy's marks were going down, but when I
finally got this straightened out,
they started going up.
the
had
MR. BLALOCK:
This is one that the ADP knows
Treasury Department knows about.
The lady for
her checks addressed to Mrs. Silas City, Silas
North
Carolina.
said it was
and someone
After
four
months
and
telephone
and
months
calls
they
going to be right.
They made
the September
check
took it -we returned this check twice -- and
stuck
the woman's
ed this September
name down
on the front
of
check
back
to her,
and the
the same thing on it.
I am going to
Silas City.
That case
was too much.
case and the service officer wrote a
you have the poem.
Do you know that
woman in January under Appendix 07?
don't buy it.
the
four
about
seven
City,
MR. MERIFIELD:
Anyone
suggestion was made that
Date
affixed
and
$90.00
For
a
And
a piece of green
72,058
that can be
is
is
January
added
the
widow
seen,
31,
1961
for
fun.
just
in red there appears
this does add to our
while
Cora:B.
change her name to Mrs.
We have had this same
little poem.
Mr. Wilenski,
they still had to pay the
If that is service,
I just
else?
He mentioned the poem and
it would be polite to read it.
Enclosed is
With number
Circled
My, how
the
envelope,
mailcheck still
had
a name
fame
got
checks
our
faith
have
to
start
and
play
in
as
Haith
that
did
restore
It
looks
like
we
Or
go
join
the
VA
all
the
over
clover.
MR. DIXON:
I am sure that everybody up here from a conveted station has a big file on what is the situation with
reference to ADP.
Down in area C there was a recommendation
made in refernce to the automatic processing system.
I just
wonder when the representatives of the committee meet whether
it might be a good idea to thrash out that point as to what
we in The Legion are going to do rather than digging it out on
the floor right here.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
I
believe
that
the
proper
procedure
will be to present it to the Recommendations Committee, which
is a subcommittee of the Rehabilitation Committee.
I would
hope that the Recommendations Committee would give careful
NN
56
consideration to the thoughts expressed of the problem and that
they would attempt to bring forth a resolution to this Conference that is in keeping with the thoughts and wishes of all
the delegates,
you men who have the greatest knowledge of the
problem.
If you have
Committee so that
they will act on.
a recommendation give it
they may have a specific
to the Resolutions
resolution which
MR. EGAN (Delaware):
I just want to refer to the remarks of Bill concerning
the decision which has been made at
many of these previous Conferences and that the Veterans Administration concurred in, to adjudicate claims in the area of
residence
of
the
beneficiary.
Two
years
ago,
they
froze
the
transfer of claims and you can look at the panel that sits in
front of you and every member of that panel has had communications from me
because claims that belong in Delaware are
handled in their office as jurisdiction has been assigned there
by the central office.
I have just received correspondence from a claimant for
whom I filed a claim last February.
He told me in
answer to
a letter that I wrote him in November that when he finally
located his folder he found it went to adjudication in October.
1 want to thank Leo in the Detroit Office for an answer in
Delaware.
The claimant is from Delaware.
MR.
anything
MERIFIELD:
else
to
offer?
MR.
DRIVER:
No,
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Mr.
Driver,
we
are
Thank
do
you
or
your
people
have
finished.
you,
gentlemen.
We
appreciate
very much your coming and explaining ADP from your viewpoint,
and we have had the opportunity to give our impression of it
from
the
delegates
that
are
here,
and
we
hope
that
along the line, we can have a reconciliation of
Mr. Driver informs me that they have prepared a
they have given you this morning.
With
that,
I
will
turn
the
podium
back
to
somewhere
these viewpoints.
handout of what
you,
Clarence
Horton.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Before we close,
I want to thank the
participants on this panel.
I heard a story about a gentleman
of the Jewish faith who was asked about the death of his wife.
He was asked what was the cause of her death and his reply
was, "She died of improvement."
He was asked, "How?"
He replied,
"Every time I called the hospital and asked about her I
was told she was improving;
so I think she died of improvement."
Let us hope that there is not a parallel situation here.
mm
—————
Announcements
=-=====-
CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
Thank you very much,
Clarence and
gentlemen of the panel.
That completes the session for this
morning,
and please be in your seats promptly at 1:30 this
afternoon.
«
vene
at
« o At 11:30 a. m. the conference
1:30ip., m. the same day.
. .
57
recessed,
to
recon-
the
Due
the
The Veterans Administration has supplied the answers to
following questions which were submitted for discussion.
to time limitations
these questions were not reached on
regular agenda.
ADP
QUESTIONS
AND
ANSWERS
For more logical discussion,
questions and answers have
assembled by category of subject matter and arranged as
SUBJECT
QUESTION
Expedited
Processing
SRE
UE
Y6,:10
Hardship
Payments
15,11,
Transfers
Insurance
General
20,
Premiums
NO.
SRG
PR
Lr aN
4
21.22
16
Interest
ok
58
Firiel
9,2 8
E13
13,
been
follows:
A.
L.
Blalock
NATIONAL
REHABILITATION
-
Carolina
Loyd
V.
Q.
What can be done about getting expeditious
processing of the award through ADP System
Awards
a
North
CONFERENCE
leaving
minimum
through
of
the
the
North
Carolina
twenty-one
system
in that minimum
complication in
or is rejected,
days.
days
and
ADP
checks
time,
if
Chicago.
there is
they
No.5
action for the
in Chicago?
Office
can
issued,and
1961
Question
Regional
before
-
get
this
require
processed
happens,
only
the award does not run
into some
If it runs into a complication
further delay for as much as ninety
Time lags which occur in our over-all processing are considered our most significant problem at the present time.
This is a serious problem to us
not only because of its
obvious influence on service but also because of its effect
on all types of transactions.
It is
also a basic cause of
our inquiry workload.
We are concentrating our efforts in this area.
steps we are taking to solve this comprehensive
include:
Specific
problem
a.
Intensive study of data flow,
both regional offices and the
b.
Preparation of simplified procedures
and organizational
changes designed to bring about better coordinated efforts in processing ADP input,
inquiries,
rejects and
other feedback information as well as Changes of Address
and Returned Checks.
c.
Clarification
instructions.
d.
Improvement in data transmission between regional
offices and the Data Processing Center and between
Treasury
and the veteran.
e.
Continued and more intensive training
and Data Processing Center personnel.
of
computer
inclusing controls,
in
Data Processing Center.
writeouts
and
of
their
related
regional
office
We have found that the time-lag between completion of authorization action and dispatch of the check has been aggravated somewhat by increased workloads.
However, by concentrating on procedural and control problems we are confident
that our over-all processing will be speeded up considerably.
With any new system such as ADP,
there is a tendency to overcontrol at first - then as experience is gained you find
that some of the time-consuming controls and procedural
steps can be eliminated.
For example -
All
transactions
are
submitted
to
the
Data
Processing
Center under what we call an "ADP Transmittal Control
Sheet."
Each day's transactions consist of awards which
are punched into paper tape and various code sheets
including
those
for
changes
of
adaress,
all
included
on
ADP
Transmittal
Control
Sheet.
total
are
one
computed
on
rates,
59
dates,
and
of
C-number
which
are
Control
for
all
items on the ADP Transmittal Control Sheet sent to the
data Processing Center.
These figures not only have to
be computed and balanced at the regional office but also
at the Data Processing Center.
Also, whenever a single
transaction covered by the ADP Transmittal Control Sheet
is rejected at the Center,
the figures must be
re-computed and balanced.
We now believe that it may be possible to simplify the control procedure and save time at both the regional offices
and the Data Processing Center.
We feel that equal benefits
will be achieved from our efforts to improve data flow, data
transmission,
instructional material and training of personnel.
At the present time the post-adjudicative process in regional offices is taking about 5 days;
transmission to the
Data Processing Center is averaging 2 days; processing at
the Data Processing Center is completed in approximately
9 days; and operations at the Treasury Department require
2 days.
Considering the improvements
that already have
been made and those which we anticipate in the next several
months
we
feel
sure that
we
can
reach
our
"interim
Post-ad judicative processing
Transmission
DPC processing
Treasury operations
2
1.5
4.5
2
goal"
of-
days
days
days
days
The problem of ''rejects'" has been substantially lessened
in the past two months.
First,
the number of award actions
which cannot be processed for payment has dropped sharply.
Second,
the time required to return rejected transactions
to regional offices has been reduced.
office processing for resubmission has
Third, regional
been facilitated
by improving the :messages'" used by the Data Processing
Center to indicate the reason why the transaction was rejected.
All three of these contribute toward expected
final action.
As an added safety factor, where the Manager
feels that immediate payment should be made, he is authorized to pay any amounts currently due on rejected cases
through the use of our '"hardship'" procedure.
Loyd
V.
Q.
What can be done about getting adjustment checks for cases
converted from the old pension law to PL 86-211 or adjustment checks due retroactively for hospitalization,
or increase in compensation for addition of dependents,
etc.,?
This
Blalock
type
-
of
North
Carolina
adjustment
often
ADP
takes
Question
three
and two or three different awards as the
quite often rejects not once but twice.
to
No.
2
four
months
original
award
Most of the problem cases in these areas arose when the
action which should have created an adjustment check occurred
during conversion,
This was especially true with PL 86-211
elections at those stations which converted last July.
Practically all of our former conversion difficulties have
been identified and corrected.
However, we know that there
is still a hard core of problem cases.
However,
if you
feel:
that we are overlooking any of these,
you can help by
bringing
them to our attention.
60
ADP
Question
No.2
Processing
time-lags
difficulties
have
where
been some
have been
adjustment
procedural
responsible
checks
changes,
are
and
for
some
of
involved.
some
our
There
refinement
in
the Bata Processing Center operations,
but the biggest contribution toward overcoming the problem has been the experience gained in regional offices.
There is a much
better understanding of how awards are prepared, but we recognize the need for a more intensified training program.
There has also been the problem of accepting cases which
contain discrepant data.
The program changes whereby we
accept for payment those cases which contain identification
of the veteran, his address,
the rate and its effective
date have done much to minimize the problem.
Lloyd
Q.
V.
-
North
Carolina
ADP
Question
No.3
What can be done about getting dependent parents paid where
the veteran is hospitalized and the dependent parent is receiving an apportioned share?
We have had to resort to
special procedures,
including Appendix 0, on numbers of
these cases to get them paid one time, and then the next
month they still were not in the system and did not receive
their checks;
therefore, we had to resort to Appendix 0 procedure for the second month.
Very often, we have had to
have
A.
Blalock
these
dependent
as
four
months
At
this
time
we
mothers
or
under
Appendix
know
of
no
fathers
paid
for
as
much
O.
general
difficulty
being
ex-
perienced in processing apportioned awards to dependent
parents.
If you are still having problems with specific
cases in this area we would appreciate your identifying
them for us so we can straightened them out.
Individual
cases may involve difficulties other than programming.
The difficulties which we experienced in handling
cases were primarily due to programming problems.
programming changes have resulted in the solution
problems,
and as far as we know,
our programs are
of handling all types of apportioned cases.
apportioned
Recent
of these
capable
A.
V.
9
Q.
Why does the VA consider that the ADP method is better, when
everything being equal,
it takes a minimum of twenty-one
days more before the widows and orphans receive
their checks?
A.
: The VA certainly would not try to tell anyone that the ADP
method was better if it took a minimum of 21 days more before beneficiaries receive a check.
We know that processing ‘times vary from office to office,
and even by cases
within an office.
We, too, have seen many figures quoted
as representative of processing times.
But the importaat
thing is that we are not satisfied with any of these figures
and will not be satisfied until we reach the timeliness
goals established for our ADP system.
Frank
Q.
Akin,
C.
The
Jr.
-
Georgia
Bottigliero
time
limit
on
ADP
Illinois
a
cycle
61
ADP
at
the
Question
No.
Question
Automatic
Data
No.
14
Processing
ADP
Question
No.
14
(Cont'd)
Center should be 48 hours, but it varies from one week to
14 days.
Is anything to be done to comply with the oeiginal intent?
In our ADP procedures we repeatedly refer to '"bi-daily"
processing.
By this we mean that every two days (or 48
hours) we will introduce into the computer all transactions
that have been received and are ready for processing.
This
should not be confused with the total time required to
process a transaction.
The Data Processing Center is now
introducing transactions into the computer on a bi-daily
basis.
However, because of operations required before and
after
computer
Data
Processing
processing
Center
Our interim goal is to
Data Processing Center
Frank
Q.
C.
Bottigliero
-
the
will
over-all
normally
process all
within four
Illinois
time
exceed
required
48
transactions
and one half
ADP
Question
at
the
hours.
through
(4-1/2)
No.
the
days.
17
What,
it anything,
is going to be done to improve and expedite the 6560
form received at the Regional Office from
Center following transaction?
The time required to produce and forward VA Forms 20-6560
to regional offices has been reduced in the past two months,
and will continue to bé improved as we progress with the
plans we outlined in answering Question No. 5,
for expediting the processing of all types of transactions.
In addition we have a specific project underway to expedite
transmission of VA Forms 20-6560
to regional offices,
to
improve the legends which appear on this form,
to clarify
our instructions for interpreting them, and to simplify the
processing actions which should result from receipt of the
VA Forms 2066560.
For the February processing cycles,
eight shipments of Forms
6560
were made to field stations.
These shipments were
dispatched from the DPC on January 26 and 28, February 6,
30, 11,715
and "18,
Frank
Lloyd
Q.
C.
V.
Bottigliero - Illinois
Blalock - North Carolina
What can be done to
cessed into the ADP
month's check to go
ADP
Question
No.
1
expedite a change of address being prosystem in order to permit the following
out to the correct address on time?
The "Change of Address' has always been a document deserving
special attention.
The problems that have been associated
with it for many years have been highlighted by the advent
of ADP.
However, we are not content to live with them.
We
are examining every facet of the change of address procedure
in a determined effort to speed up their processing.
Here
a.
are
some
of
the
areas
In the regional office,
permitting transmission
62
receiving
we
of
special
have speeded up
certain address
attention:
processing
changes to
by
the
a.
Data Processing Center without reference to the claims
folder.
This eliminates the time required to pull,
review and refile the folder.
We will expand this method
as far as we can.
Also,
the simplification of the
transmittal control we mentioned before,
could further
reduce processing time.
b.
We are working closely with the Treasury Disbursing
Office to get addresses changed up to
as close to the
mailing of the check as possible.
Just this past month
procedures were changed at the Data Processing Center.
All address changes received near the end of the month
are now processed ahead of everything else and gummed
labels are sent to Treasury for redirecting the check
envelope.
The recent installation of a computer in the
Disbursing Office opens up new possibilities for improvement in this area.
We are determined that nothing
will be overlooked.
¢c.
We have found that the Post Office is as anxious as we
to resolve this long-standing problem.
Jointly we hope
to expand and expedite the exchange of information and
are exploring other means of expediting delivery of
checks.
One of these might be a method by which the
Post Office could be advised when a change of address
is received immediately after Treasury has released a
check.
Despite repeated attempts in the past to inform our beneficiaries as to what to do when they move,
they still fail to
notify the VA and many write to the Treasury to have their
address changed.
But we will try again.
We are planning an
intensified public-education program stressing the need for
promptly
notifying
both
serve
veteran
can
the
believe
We
results
address
ceive,
not
but
Lloyd
Blalock
Q.
V.
that
only
also
the
help
our
VA
and
the
in
this
regard.
Post
across-the-board
Office.
efforts
will
All
who
bring
in expediting the processing of changes
reducing the number of inquiries we now
of
re-
-
6
North
Carolina
ADP
Question
No.
What can be done about getting expeditious replies to check
inquiries?
When the Automatic Data Processing System was
established the accredited representatives were promised
three days'
service on check inquiries.
We consider ten
days now a speedy reply.
Sometimes it takes sixty days or
longer to get an answer that will really tell us anything.
We recognize the problem which exists in the inquiry area
but believe it is
possible ultimately to meet the originally
established three day standard for receipt of replies from
the Data Processing Center.
One of the basic problems in this area is the need for complete training of all field station personnel so they can
correctly interpret information which is available to them
within the station.
We must also assure that essential
information is available to them for interpretation.
Our
objective was, and still is, to make the claims folder self
sufficient insofar as providing all basic and essential
63
information
concerning
the
individual
beneficiary.
We
are
making every effort to insure that needed training and
information is furnished,
the meaning of documents is
clarified,
and that essential documents are filed in the
claims folders promptly.
When this is done, a much larger
number of inquiries will be promptly resolved and answered
in the regional offices.
For those inquiries which require information from the Data
Processing Center or the Chicago Regional Disbursing Office,
substantial improvements have been mand are continuing to
be made.
Specifically,
we have refined the processing of
inquiries at the Data Processing Center by a.
Establishing a permanently staffed Inquiry Unit to replace the previously temporarily detailed employees.
b.
Increasing
productivity
(1)
Intensive
(2)
Making sources
to them.
c.
of
permanent
employees
by
-
training
of
information
more
readily
Using a punch card as basic document throughout
entire Data Processing Center processing.
available
the
Also, we have tested a system to shorten the inquiry message and expedite preparation of the punch-card processing
document and are exploring the possibility of extracting
data from the master record in a form which could be used
to transmit it back to the regional office,
thus reducing
both processing and transmission time.
The comprehensive action we mentioned in answering Question
No. 5 that we are taking steps to solve the '"time-lag'" problem also will improve the inquiry situation.
Improvement
of procedures and simplification of controls in Regional
Offices and the Data Processing Center will reduce processing time,
reduce workloads,
and in turn, reduce the volume
of inquiries,
thus permitting faster processing of those
which are received.
A.
V.
Akin,
Jr.
Georgia
Q.
Why
doesn't
the
when
their
checks
being
returned
their
files
VA
due
they
make
are
to
would
an
effort
ADP
Question
to
locate
No.
10
beneficiaries
returned,
as
some
of
the
checks
errors
the
VA,
and
by
checking
in
are
find this?
On July 26, 1960,
in all-station letter No. 21-15
regional
offices were instructed to review the claims folder whenever the Data Processing Center advised that a check had
been
returned,
many
times
These
instructions
have
been
reiterated
since.
The VA is very anxious to release returned checks that could
not be delivered because of an incorrect address.
In the
past two months changes have been made
which we feel will
make it easier to get these checks to the veteran.
First:
All returned checks are run against
cords as soon as they are received.
64
the master reWhen we find
the
imme-
that a Change of Address was received after
returned check was originally processed, we
diately release it to the new address.
change of address is found we notify
The first such returned check
Office,
If no recent
the Regional
Second:
not
does
re-
effort
"every
to make
told
been
have
the
Instead,
payments.
future
stop
offices
gional
possible to obtain a new address or verify the
existing address" and notify the Data Processing
Center so the check can be released.
If the
address in the claims folder is very close to the
regional office there would be no objection to an
attempt
to
contact
as a general
the payee at
found
Third:
was
the
payee
policy, we
an address
incorrect,
personally.
feel that
which the
would
not
The Treasury Disbursing Office
equipment which caused many of
This will reduce the number of
However,
efforts to reach
Post Office
be
productive.
has replaced its old
the "garbled" checks.
checks returned.
You may be aware of a test that
has just begun whereby the
Treasury Regional Disbursing Office simultaneously notifies
the appropriate regional office and the Data Processing
Center when a check has been returned.
We feel this ad-
vance
to
notice
release
to
the
returned
Bottigliero
-
regional
checks
F.
C.
Q.
What,
if anything,
is
of Appendix 0 cases?
office
much
will
Illinois
ADP
being
make
it
possible
faster.
done
to
Question
improve
the
No.
15
handling
In some cases paid under Appendix 0 we receive a call a
month or so later that a check is not received.
In checking the case, we are advised that an overpayment is being
carried against the veteran. We understand the Regional
Office reports an Appendix 0 payment to the Data Processing
Center as an account receivable,
Why is this necessary?
a.
b.
An overpayment doesn't actually exist.
In some cases,
the 'overpayment' does not get into
the record and duplicate payments are made.
In some cases,
the 'overpayment' gets into the
machine and stops all future payments.
Ch
Why
can't
Data
Processing
the
Regional
Office
Center
pick
pay
up
the
all
back
future
payments
due
and
payments?
The fact that recurring payments are not picked up by the
Data Processing Center after an Appendix 0 payment is made
locally could result from a number of situations all of
which would be caused by erroneous processing.
Usually
in some
awards.
Appendix O
cases they
The
award
payments cover
include current
is
prepared
retroactive amounts but
monthly payments on new
showing
the
effective
date
of entitlement even though:zthe retroactive portion is paid
under Appendix O.
Since the Appendix O payment duplicates
the retroactive portion,
the award is introduced into the
ADP system accompanied by an Accounts Receivable equal to
65
the
are
amount that already has been paid.
If both actions
correctly prepared and submitted together,
the accounts
receivable
will
immediately
amount generated
. payments will be
be
offset
by the computer,
issued.
by
and
the
future
retroactive
recurring
However,
if the accounts receivable is incorrectly prepared
it will not be processed and a check will be issued as
though no Appendix O payment had been made.
When the corrected accounts receivable is resubmitted and processed at
the Data Processing Center the existence of a duplicate
payment will be discovered and an overpayment will be established.
This will,
in turn, be recovered from future
recurring payments.
When the duplicate check is returned,
the amount’ would offset the overpayment and recurring payments would be resumed.
One
other
pared
situation
accounts
could
result
receivable.
If
from
the
an
incorrectly.pre-
duplicate
payment
were
returned and processed by the Data Processing Center before the accounts receivable is corrected and resubmitted,
it could not offset the overpayment because that record
still had not been introduced into the machine.
This
situation would result in the automatic suspension of the
case,
and preparation of a notice to the regional office
which then must investigate the causes and take necessary
action
to
resume
the
proper
payments.
All of these
cessing,
and
provement in
complications can be avoided by proper proour experience to date has shown a marked imthe accuracy of original submissions.
There
reason
is
no
why
the
regional
offices
could
not
make
all back payments including those cases where an award had
already been submitted to the Data Processing Center. However,
the disadvantages in such action mitigate against
such
a
procedure
because
-
ai
The regional office may not know, precisely,
how
much money is due.
Under the present operations the
computer verifies the computations made by the regional office and adjusts the amount due if the
Appendix 0 payments were too much or too little.
b.
If an
award had previously
regional office decided an
in order,
a new award with
would have to be prepared.
been prepared and the
Appendix 0 payment was
the new effective date
Since a concentrated effort is being made to improve workload and processing conditions, we feel that this will produce a greater benefit by eliminating the need for Appendix
0 payments.
A.
V,
Akin,
Jr.
-
Georgia
ADP
Q.
If ADP is to correct all the ills of processing the checks,
then why does the Finance Officer
(Birmingham,
Alabama,
for instance) have to issue a check and send it Air Mail
when we have exhausted every means at our disposal to get
the award paid under extreme hardship conditions?
We
appreciate this being done on new awards-- but why does it
66
Question
No.
11
have
to
taken
as
come
on
to
a
continuing
awards
change-over
under
that
the
have
new
had
no
action
law?
As stated in answering Question No. 15,
when extreme hardship cases are properly prepared and submitted to the Data
Processing Center,
recurring payments will be initiated
and continued.
However,
incorrect processing of these
cases could disrupt the normal routine in which case they
would have to be returned to the regional office for
further action.
A large part of the difficulties we have had in the past
in making initial and recurring payments occurred from
conversion operations,
PL 86-211 elections or a combination of both.
However,
there should be no
difficulty in
these areas now, as we know of no
type of case where payment cannot be made provided it is submitted correctly.
There
ments
have
been
were
a
few
interrupted
which
caused
could
cases
be used to make
but in order to
an
award
a
and
check
an
isolated
because
to
be
cases
returned.
Q.
V.
Blalock
-
accounts
What
can
be
When
we
return
North
done
receivable
Carolina
about
these
recurring
difficulties
Appendix
O
pay-
procedures
an extreme hardship payment in these
reinstitute the recurring payment
submitted to the Data Processing
conditions we feel that the need
ments where there is a recurring
Lloyd
where
of mailing
must
ADP
eliminating
duplicate
be
prepared
and
Center.
Under present
for extreme hardship paypayment should be very rare.
Question
duplicate
payments,
Category 7, sometimes our claimants
of returned checks and it is two or
can get their checks started again.
even
No.
4
payments?
marked
under
are suspended by reason
three months before we
Everyone of the steps we mentioned in answering Question
No. 5 for reducing processing time-lags also will minimize
the possibility of duplicate
checks being issued.
To a large extent duplicate payments resulted from special
procedures
initiated to insure that the beneficiary received
a check.
However,
in some instances they were caused by
failure to "hold" a check which was to have been replaced
by another with a revised amount.
Our present Appendix O procedure permits regional offices
to authorize expedited local payment.
As explained in answering Question No. 15,
it may create a duplicate payment
if not followed properly.
However, precautions have been
taken to insure that the return of a check will not suspend
the ‘account.
The number of duplicate payments released in the last two
months reflect a sharp reduction in problems of this nature.
We feel that as conditions improve and Appendix O payments
are no longer necessary,
it will all but be eliminated.
Reuben
Q.
B.
Garnett
-
Washington
A veteran formerly
being converted to
ADP
Question
No.
20
resided in an area which has been or is
ADP.
Month after month payment
inquiries
67
are necessary in order for him to receive his check. There
is vast and undue delay.
Why can't the Regional Office
having
his
claims
file,
transfer
it
to
having jurisdiction over the area to
This would facilitate setting up his
him paid regularly through the local
the
Regional
Office
which he has moved?
pay card and getting
disbursing office.
We feel that the delays mentioned
‘in this question have
been reduced materially in the past month or two and that
our plans for concentrated action for further improvement
will produce greater benefits than a change in our transfer
policy.
One of the new features under our ADP system is based on
furnishing a Mailing Code which reflects the State and in
some instances the City to which the check is to be
mailed.
This makes it possible for the Disbursing Office to sort
the checks and deliver them to the Post Office in ample
time to assure delivery on the first of the month regardless of how far from Chicago the payee lives.
Under this
coordinated VA-Treasury-Post Office operation,
once a case
has been converted to ADP,
the location of the claims
folder should have no effect on prompt receipt of the check.
There are situations which justify
living-veteran case (see answer to
when
such
a
up for local
System.
case
is
payment
transferred
but
continue
transfer
Question
benefits
to
be
of a
21).
are
made
converted
But even
not
picked
under
the
ADP
Since we have been concentrating on improving the efficiency
of personnel at converted stations, we feel that any action
on a converted case can be handled faster and more accurately
by
Robert
Q.
these
E.
employees.
Wilson
-
Minnesota
ADP
Question
No.
21
Refusal to transfer cases into or out of stations converted
to ADP is working a hardship on veterans who are trying to
dewelop their claims.
It is causing a great increase in work
for Department Service Officers who must review cases at
his station for the benefit ot those in other states, not
to
mention
the
extreme
difficulty
encountered
by
a service
officer trying to develop a case not available for his review.
I was recently notified by an Adjudication Officer
in another state that it was their policy not to advise
out-of-state service officers of action in a case.
How
can I serve the veteransand their dependents of my state if
I am not informed?
I am convinced that considering all
aspects of the problem,
it would be easier and less expensive
to
take
accounts
out
of
ADP,
or
enter
them,
than
to
cope with all of the problems encountered by the refusal
transfer.
Certainly
there should be no freeze on the
transfer of cases not on the payroll.
to
(This question is similar to No. 20.
However,
different and should be commented on).
are
the
facts
In October 1960, we advised all regional offices that
TEMPORARY transfer of claims and XC folders between converted
and non-converted stations was authorized for development of
a case up to the point of actually rating the claim.
(This
68
was
now
contained in our Emergency Interim Issue 20-60
has been incorporated in Appendix J of our ADP
Since
a folder
can
be
made
available
basis for developing a claim,
this
you seek in assisting a veteran.
which
procedures).
on
a temporary
transfer
should
serve
purpose
the
Whenever a service organization has been instrumental in
developing a case our procedures provide that a copy of the
final award or disallowance action be furnished that service
organization.
We believe service otficers can help one
another
in
this
matter
if
the
one
located
having jurisdiction over the folder
the one who helped develop the case
in
the
would send
in another
office
the copy
office.
to
There are no restrictions on the transfer of a folder which
does not contain a claim for Compensation or Pension.
If
you are developing the first such claim,
even though the
veteran may have applied previously for other benefits such
as hospitalization or education,
the claims folder may be
transferred permanently to the office having jurisdiction
over
the
veteranls
address.
However,
if
the
veteran
had
filed,
and his claim was disallowed or terminated,
all the
statistical data relating to that case would be converted
to the ADP system at the same time all the running awards
were converted.
Therefore,
it is essential that such
a
case continue to be processed under ADP requirements primarily because all the basic data already is available and
the case can be processed with far fewer operations than
are
required
to
reopen
a
non-converted
case.
As
stated
in answering Question No. 20, we feel the actions relating
to such a case could be handled better and faster by trained,
experienced personnel at the converted station rather than
transferring it for action at a non-converted station.
Robert
Q.
E.
Wilson
-
Minnesota
ADP
Question
No.
22
The same problems referred
to in
question 21 attend the
jurisdictional rules concerning death cases,
1 am convinced
that we would all benefit by a rule, providing that the
widow is the principal beneficiary,
that the case file be
created in or transferred to the office having
jurisdiction
over her residence;
if there is no widow,
the residence of
the children would control;
and if no children,
the residence of the dependent parents would control.
I realize
that there are cases that involve multiple beneficiaries,
but estimate that those comprise no more than 5% of
the
total number,
It would be a simple matter to notify parents
that a case file has been transferred to the office serving
a widow or children.
In an
agency which boasts of regional
offices to provide service to veterans,
it seems riciculous
that I should have to write The American Legion in San
Francisco so that they could secure the case file to learn
that the Adjudication Officer had requested the Chief
Attorney,
whose office is next door to mine, to determine
whether benefits can be paid to my neighbor on behalf of her
children.
In
why
our
the
answers
transfer
to
Questions
of
C
and
20
XC
and
claims
21
we
outlined
folders
is
the
reasons
restricted.
Our rules for establishing jurisdiction in death cases are
based, primarily,
on the location of the veteran's folder at
69
the time
with the
ferring
of death.
In the majority of cases this coincides
address of the widow.
The restriction on transXC
Folders
of
does
not
duplicate
apply
-
a.
Adjustment
b.
Veterans
c.
K
d.
Benefits
e.
The primary beneficiary has a foreign address.
(Comp.
& Pension Manual 8-1 provides that the WIDOW will be
considered the principal beneficiary,
children are
second and parents follow children).
died
Insurance
in
is
are
claim
when
numbers
is
required.
Service.
active
payable
at
time
of
veteran's
under
US
Code
38,
death.
Section
412.
We expect very shortly,
to look into the possibility of
relaxing restrictions on transferring XC folders decentralized from the Philadelphia District Office since
these
acounts
are
all
converted
and
every
Regional
Office
has some of them.
We are particularly interested in reinstating the policy which would allow transfer of an XC
folder when such action would serve the best interest of
the principal beneficiarye.
Guardianship Folders are always located in the office hav-.
ing jurisdiction over the address of the guardian,
regard-
less
of
location
of
the
claims
that benefits have been
and they reside in your
well to check initially
office.
or XC
folder.
If
you
know
applied for on behalf of children
jurisdiction,
it perhaps would be
with the Chief Attorney in your
As we stated before,
you can now obtain the XC Folder
temporary transfer,
for review and development.
This
allow you to provide the type of service you desire.
Frank
Q.
C.
Bottigliero
-
Illinois
Question
No.
16
What,
if anything,
is being done to improve the handling
insurance deductions with the Automatic Data Processing
Center,
We have seen many cases
cerned in the fact that
made
by
Office
and
since
(This
the adoption by the Automatic
question is also submitted to
Panel).
During
the
cases
heavy
workload
were
stopped
for one
periods
erroneously
of
reason
August
as
a
of
has become confrom compensation
Regional
some
the
where the veteran
he had deductions
this payment stopped
Processing Program.
NSLI
A.
ADP
on
should
and
or
another
September,
by-product
of
special procedures which necessitated payments being made
outside the ADP system.
If these included accounts from
which premiums were being deducted,
suspension of the deduction resulted.
However,
in no case was this allowed to
lapse the insurance policy.
There are slighly under 62,000 accounts at the Data Processing Center from which Insurance Premiums are deducted.
Actions taken as the result of a reconciliation of the
70
Insurance records in Philadelphia and the DVB records at
the Data Processing Center, made at the end of last December,
have resulted in our accounts being brought into complete
agreement.
It was necessary to adjust some amounts during
January but in all of these cases the deductions were reconciled and the
Insurance policies were in full effect.
Robert E. Wilson - Minnesota
Charles A. Zeglin - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Is it possible to include one
that the service organization
present
system
keeping
our
is
causing
Post
and
more copy
can have
an
County
Question
g3
in
two
the flexo so
copies?
The
Officers
informed.
enormous
Service
No.
amount
It would, of course, be possible to produce
of the award letter.
However, we would not
such a step without a thorough study of the
would be achieved.
of
work
in
one more copy
like to take
benefits
that
At present, we buy blank award letters in sets consisting
of an original and 3 copies with carbon paper interleafed.
One of these copies is furnished the service organization
where one is involved.
This type of form is expensive but
since it simplifies the flexowriter operation and saves
the
manhours
forms
required
exactly,
we
to
feel
insert
the
carbon
cost
is
paper
and
align
the
justified.
We do not have specific data which tell us how many of our
actions do or do not require a copy for a service organization. We do
know that by adding one copy of the letter
and
one
piece
of
carbon
paper
to
our
present
sets,
the
cost
would increase by about $6 for every thousand sets purchased.
Before incurring
any additional cost, we would
have to compare this increase with the cost of reproducing
a single copy of award letters only in those cases where
an extra copy is essential.
Collin McKinne- North Carolina
Charles J. Kohler - Pennsylvania
Q.
When
can
we
expect
efficient and
ment System.
In
terms
of
service
economical
speed
and
ADP
under
as
ADP
Question
to
No.
be
at
the
Mechanized
it
is
under
accuracy
of
processing,
that within the next several months,
ADP System should exceed that of the
7
least
we
as
Pay-
anticipate
the efficiency of the
Mechanized Benefit Pay-
ment System.
The current improvements in our processing
time and the planned improvements discussed under Question
5 will make achievement of this goal completely realistic.
One
the
of
the
basic
accuracy
of
purposes
our
of
records,
the
ADP
Because
System
of
the
is
to
increase
computer's
capacity it is
able to perform many more checks than was
possible under the Mechanized Benefit Payment System.
In
addition we now have available statistical information that
is far beyond what was previously recorded.
It is difficult
to compare the two systems on the basis of
""economics' especially since in 1960 18 pieces of legislation were introduced,
the aging veteran population
71
increased,
and economic conditions
experienced a workload increase.
were
such
that
we
We do not have available at this time
the type of cost and
savings data that we feel are necessary and desirable for
preparing a statement on the economics of ADP; however,
plans are being develeped to assemble and compile this
essential data on a continuing basis.
There is no question in our minds but that the system will
ultimately provide substantial economies as well as operating improvements.
K. Klemmetson - Washington
Charles A. Zéglin - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Question
No.
19
Seven months have passed since the last Regional Office was
converted to ADP, yet the Center is unable to overcome
problems that still create hardships to veterans and beneficiaries all over the country through overpayments,
underpayments, delayed or no payments at all.
How much longer
is it going to take to get ADP on the track and running
efficiently?
A.
We think
has been
efficiency
No
our
and
of
additional
answers to previous
will continue to be
the
questions show that much
done to increase the
system.
conversions
will
be
undertaken
until
we
have
assured ourselves that all conditions are favorable for
such a move,
In order to make this determination we are
establishing criteria by which to measure the acceptability
of conditions.
These measurements will indicate a.
The current status of ADP operations.
rejects or inquiries can not be beyond
level.
b.
The readiness of a station to be converted.
This means
no out-of-line conditions as to workload,
staffing or
other operating factors - also that it will have reached
an established degree of proficiency through training
under simulated procedures.
c.
The capacity of the Data Processing Center to accommodate
additional accounts.
This is not restricted to computer
capacity,
alone, but includes adequacy of staffing and
proficiency of personnel as well.
When a detailed evaluation
teria have been met in all
additional conversions.
For example,
an acceptable
indicates that established crithree areas,
then we will consider
In anticipation of that time we have developed a new and
simplified conversion procedure.
Stripped of all technicalities it provides
that a.
During the conversion period,
the field station will
continue to make all payments;
the Data Processing
Center will operate a parallel system but without any
payment
functions.
b.
At
end
the
of
the
conversion
72
period
a
reconciliation
will
be made to assure that accounts converted and updated at
the Data Processing Center are in agreement with those at
the
€.
field
station.
Any account that cannot successfully be converted will
remain at the regional office for payment until it can
be converted without any interruption of continued payment.
We believe this new system will eliminate the problems we
experienced during previous conversions.
However, before
resuming any full-scale conversion it will be tested to
make sure it will achieve the objective of continued,
uninterrupted service.
Collin McKinme- North Carolina
Charles J. Kohler - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Question
No.
8
When is it
calculated that the Veterans Administration will
recoup through ADP operations the losses sustained by this
conversion?
In this estimate include losses incurred from
errors. and excessive payment which.the Government will
never
expect
to
recover,
The installation of any large system such as ADP requires
a sizeable capital investment and unusual operating expenses in order to change over to the new system.
Since
the VA has spread out its conversion schedule,
it will take
longer to realize ultimate savings than we originally anticipated.
However, based on a recent VA-wide study, we
estimate that by April 1969 we will start to accrue some
"net profits."
At that point we will have amortized our
investment and will start accruing annual savings at the
rate
of
a million dollars
annually.
Should the VA decide to purchase the ADP equipment instead
of continuing to rent it, we would increase our initial
cost but recover it faster by not having to pay equipment
rent which amounts to more than $1,000,000.00 a year.
In
turn, this would move the 'break-even'" point forward by
about three years.
We have no reason to believe that there will be any material
losses from errors or overpayments.
Most of the beneficiaries
who may have been overpaid are still drawing benefits from
which recovery can be made.
In addition,
since we have consolidated the records of converted stations into a single
file, we have found a number of overpayments which had
become disassociated from the payment records and have been
able to take recovery action.
We should not lose sight of the fact that the ADP system is
benefiting other departments too.
For instance,
the Treasury
Department estimates that by the end of F.Y, 1970,
it will
realize an additional potential savings of more than
$18,000,000,00 through consolidation of its offices and refinement of its operations in conjunction with our ADP system.
A.
V.
Akin,
Jr.
-
Georgia
ADP
Q.
If the mechanized process for payments to claimants is reestablished in Atlanta, how long will be required before
every claimant can be assured they will receive their checks
73
Question
No.
12
each
month?
This
this
is a question
time.
that
we
cannot
answer
specifically
at
To re-establish the Mechanized Benefit Payment
system in
Atlanta we would have to go through the same process to
UNDO what we have done: write computer programs;
reconstruct the punched card records;
and re-establish old
methods of processing Compensation & Pension payments
through the Finance Division.
Further,
since the Treasury
Department has closed its Atlanta Office we would have to
know whether that Department wanted to keep the Atlanta
accounts in Chicago or transfer them to Birmingham for
payment with your other benefits.
All
this
mine
been
A.V.
Q.
would
require
extensive
study
to
followed.
Such
the methods
undertaken.
Akin,
Jr.
-
be
Georgia
ADP
in
order
studies
Question
No.
to
deter-
have
not
13
Since every thinking person knows that we are in the machine
age, and that machines can do the job when the proper machine
is employed,
couldn't Central Office of the Veterans Administration secure and place smaller ADP machines in Regional
locations to get away from the larger operation which has
caused many VA claimants to suffer for the lack of necessities due to non-receipt of VA checks?
When the VA first became interested in the possibilities of
using an ADP system,
serious study was made as to feasibility of installing small ADP machines in regional offices.
However, we found it would not be practical,
efficient nor
economical to do this - or even to place such equipment in
a number of Payment Centers.
Garland
Charles
Charles
0.
H.
J.
A.
Woods - Arizona
Kohler - Pennsylvania
Zeglin - Pennsylvania
ADP
It is requested that
up-to-date report on
the
the
Veterans
progress
dation
of
any
problem
we
have
blems
that
we
might
We
feel
that
the
Question
No.
Administration give an
of ADP concerning liqui-
met
in
the
meet
in
the
future.
answers
to
all
the
other
past
and
questions
identified and reviewed the problems of the
picture of our current status,
and provided
we can anticipate for the future.
74
18
any
pro-
have
past, given a
a look at what
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON
MARCH 1, 1961
SESSION
. « « The National Rehabilitation Conference of The American
Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room, Statler Hotel,
Washington,
D.C.Vice Chairman J. Ross Foust, presiding.
. .
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
Ladies and gentlemen of the Conference,
we have quite a number of important matters to bring before our
Conference this afternoon.
As you know, ADP utilized all the
time this morning so we will have quite a load this afternoon,
and I know you will join with me and expedite_matters
as best
we
can.
At this time, I would like to present our discussion
leaders for this afternoon:
first,
the Department Service
Officer, Comrade Likens from the great State of Nebraska,
and
the Department Service Officer from Massachusetts,
our Comrade
Buckley,
our Department Service Officer, Comrade Jensen from
the State of Georgia,
and the Department Service Officer from
Montana, Comrade Callaghan.
Comrade Weiss will be here a
little
for me
this
later.
He
to present
morning
from
has been detained.
I don't think it necessary
these fine gentlemen who served us so capably
the
Veterans
If, however,
there
us this morning,
and you
will be glad to hear from
Administration.
are any additions to those who served
would care to make that fact known,
I
you.
MR. STRATTON:
Thank you.
I am very happy to be back with
you again this year, or should I say this afternoon,
rather than
this morning.
I see that we finally got the group down to the
12 converted stations.
We were trying to see some dim light
of optimism this morning and somebody said, "Well,
after all,
you could have come to this conference with 5
stations converted and 12 non-converted stations."
And this is our shining
light.
I would like to introduce to you the group that will
attempt to answer your questions this afternoon,
and I know
that you are going to burst into tumultuous applause,
so if you
will wait
until we get all through here,
then we will hold it
down to one.
First is Mr. Edwaed Reinmuth, who is my assistant, who
works with me in the Compensation and Pension Service,
a good,
capable right arm; Mr. Louis Townsend,
staff assistant in the
Director's Office; Herb Moore,
the Assistant Director for
Policy and Planning, who has been with many of you at your field
stations; working in the same group with Mr. Moore, Mr. J. C.
Peckarsky, who is the Chief of our Projects staff and Mr. Jim
Donald, who is the Chief of our Policy Staff,
(I think in the
audience), Mr. Arthur Farmer, who is the Assistant Director for
Benefits Consultants.
He is the gentleman that handles your
administrative reviews and restores your service connections.
Next’is Mr. Sidney Kaltz, who works with Mr, Farmer and is in
charge of one of the consultants groups;
Woodie Morris,
recently the adjudication officer from Albuquerque,
New Mexico, now
we are pleased to say,
in central office, Chief of another
consultants group; Mr. Arthur Thompson,
the Assistant Director
for Analysis and Standards;
Dr. Nevill Joyner,
the Chairman of
the
Disability
Policy
Board.
This
75
gentleman
is
in
charge
of
the
group that writes and rewrites your rating schedule.
With
Dr. Joyner, we have Dr, Robert Muilenburg,
a medical consultant
on this same
board.
Also, we have W. B. Johnson,
recently. in
the Veterans Administration,
who is the Chairman of the Board
on Waivers and Forfeitures.
From other services,
if the gentleman will permit me, we
have Mr. Cahrly Curtis that all of you know very well,
the
Director of the Administrative Service.
Then I think we have
Mr. John Jackson, who is in the Office of Chief Benefits
Director.
Now,
Mr.
Chairman,
we
are
ready
to
deal
with
questions.
-CHAIRMAN FOUST:
Thank you very much.
Is the Department
Service Officer from Pennsylvania,
Mr. Weiss, here? If not, our
discussion leaders will take over
at this point, but before they
do, I think it only right and proper,
for fear some of you may
not know our good friend,
to introduce the Assistant Director
for
Claims,
who
will
serve
today
as
the
staff
moderator,
Ed
Golembieski.
Now we will proceed to our discussion on the
law, P. L. 86-211.
The discussion leaders will take over.
great
MR. LIKENS:
Mr. Chairman and members of the panel,
it is
indeed a privilege for me personally,
as well as the Department
of Nebraska to be able to participate in this program.
I have
a fine panel that has been assigned with me.
We are behind
time
so
to
curtail
with asking the
Service Officer
Jensen,
any
further
delay,
we
will
start
questions and we will start with
from the great State of Georgia,
right
the
Mr.
off
Department
Edward D.
MR. JENSEN:
Thank you, Val,
The first question was submitted by Akin of Georgia.
Why does the VA use different
standards of deriving "met profit" from sale of property on
various instructions for completing annual income questionnaires
for those on pension rolls?
MR. STRATTON:
Mr. Peckarsky will answer this question and,
Mr. Chairman,
if we may,
there are several related questions
here, Number 3 and Number 5,
and if hé could handle those at
the same time and ask the question and also answer, Mr. Peckarsky
will now filibuster,
MR. LIKENS:
No. 3. Is the VA contemplating revision of
instructions for income questionnaire forms?
Please comment,
No.
puting
net
5.
Why
income
veterans,
widows
there
be
not
is
there
from
and
a difference
sales
of
children
uniformity
in
for
this
in
property
PL
the
between
86-211
methods
of
com-
parents,
purposes?
Should
report?
MR PECKARSKY:
Mr. Chairman and ladies and gentlemen,
let
me take the third question first,
as to whether or not we propose to revise our instructions for the annual income questionnaires.
Yes, we do.
We try to improve them every year. As
you know, we revised them this year.
Right at the moment,
since we have them in what we consider the best shape we can
get them in, we don't have any concrete direction for a revision,
If you can suggest any, we would certainly be glad to
consider them.
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
(PENNSYLVANIA)
76
Make
them
simpler.
in
am
aware
The
of no
basic
put
out.
we
sheets
made
were
that
are
that
we
take
property,
the
to
of
substantially
selling
the
from
that
subtract
They
any
in
difference
is
rule
general
concern themselves with differences
from the sale of property and I
questions
primarily
The other two
computing income
and if
glad to
to do, Mike,
certainly be
That we would like
MR. PECKARSKY:
you can suggest ways to do it, we would
incorporate them in our instructions.
the
price,
instruction
four
the
worded
the
same.
to
the
net
cost
subtract
any
the
expenses
base
subtract
payees,
improvements
of
sale,
There has to, of
left is reportable as net income.
be a slight difference on the various forms that
and this is from the
various categories of payees,
of equity.
and what's
necessity,
pertain to
standpoint
in the case of a veteran we cannot in good
For example,
conscience charge him with any profit that accrued to him before
so we tell
the day he became permanently and totally disabled,
the veteran to either report his cost when he bought the probecame
property
report
what
the
permanently
and
totally
to
or
perty
was
worth
the
on
day
he
disabled.
in the case of a widow we cannot in good conSimilarly,
science charge her with any income that accrued prior to the
date of the veteran's death where she acquired property prior
and so on the instruction to her we say that she
to his death,
shall report either the cost to her or the value of the property on the date of his death. Outside of those exceptions in
I know of no differences
the method of computing basic cost,
I
in our method of computing income from sale of property.
believe the instruction sheets are 'virtually identical in all
four instances.
MR.
comment
on
Val
for
to
JENSEN:
anybody
Does
this
from
the
the
rest
of
floor?
the
have
If
any
not,
further
I will
questions
turn
this
or
back
questions.
The next individual to ask questions is
MR. LIKENS:
Past President of the Department Service Officer Association,
Mr. Callaghan,
from the State of Montana.
What explanation should a Service
No. 2:
MR. CALLAGHAN:
Officer give a claimant when information contained in the
various instructions conflict with instructions furnished in
dated March 11, 19587?
VA Bulletin EM-21-9,
With
That was a short rest.
MR. PECKARSKY:
mission, Mr. Chairman, Question No. 9 is virtually
Shall I read it?
question.
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
Go
your perthe same
ahead.
When property is held
Question No. 9 is:
MR. PECKARSKY:
jointly by husband and wife and a claim is filed under PL 86-211,
considerable misunderstanding arises from the two different
rules followed by adjudication in making determinations of
corpus of estate and of income derived from this property.
two
the
What are the principal points of difference
Has the VA given any thought
determinations?
same standards of ownership to determinations
77
between these
to applying
of income as
are applied to corpus of estate when the property is held in
joint tenancy?
Here I.believe is possibly one of the questions
that was implicit in the first group that I answered.
It is
true
that
we
have
a different
rule
for
computing
property than we have for computing ownership
counted as corpus of estate and the differnce
difference
in
the
law.
Income,
as
you
know,
income
from
of property
stems from the
is
anything
that
can be relied on for maintenance.
It is
what the claimant Has
available for maintenance,
and in computing income the Attorney
General has told us in the decision in the Burkey case that
it
would not be equitable to differentiate between the laws of the
various states and to recognize such things as community property laws for divisions of income,
since this would give a
veteran,
let us say, in California the right to cut his
income
in half because half of it belongs to his wife.
For this reason, our regulations have required that in computing income
we go to the actual equitable ownership of the property whose money bought it, who earned it, and by that determine
all the money is reportable as income of the owner, regardless
of whether it is
a joint tenancy, whether he owns it in his own
name, or whether by operation of the community property law it
is in the names of he and his wife.
With corpus of estate we have a different situation.
Here the property has not yet been converted into cash,
and remember that in income we count only profit after it is converted to cash, but in corpus,
the property is still real property, and ,the determination in corpus is based on what does
the veteran have that is of such value that he could reasonably
be required to consume some part of it for his own maintenance?
Here
the
law
places
another
restriction
on
us
and
says,
"Now, in the case of a veteran,
although you may
count all
of his wife's income over $1,200,
you may count for purposes
of corpus of estate only what belongs to the veteran.
You may
not count the wife's corpus."
So that in determining corpus,
we have to restrict ourselves to what is the veteran's and we
have to restrict ourselves to what he can dispose of.
For
that reason,
in the corpus of estate portion of the instruction
to Public Law 86-211, we said that we would follow the recorded
title to the property and would not go behind it.
If it appears
as joint tenancy we will follow the joint tenancy rule and
count half of it as his, half of it his wife's,
and therefore,
when computing his corpus only his half counts.
It would be
nice if the rule could be the same for both corpus and income.
Under the law as presemtly written, we do
not think that it.
could be done.
Are there any further questions on this point?
MR. MARKOWITZ:
If you threw the corpus of
altogether we would be all right, would we not?
solwe the problem for you and for
us.
MR.
PECKARSKY:
It
would
solve
this
estate out
That would
particular
problem,
yes.
MR. CALLAGHAN:
No. 4:
Has the VA suggested that Congress
liberalize the obvious inequity which permits a widow to deduct
from her income the just debts,
the expenses of last sickness
and burial in the case of a deceased veteran,
but prohibits
the same application to a veteran in the event of the sickness
and burial of his wife?
78
will
Moore
Herb
Mr.
STRATTON:
MR.
question.
this
answer
I believe the discussion on this started
MR. MOORE:
We were talking about the section of
right here last year.
211 that permitted a widow or child to offset against their
the
income an amount equal to the amount thet they paid on
of course, would include the
just debts of the veteran which,
A bill has been introexpenses of last illness and burial.
Congressman
duced to do something similar for the veteran.
on January 6, 1961,introduced a bill which iis H.R.
O'Konski,
and it would exclude from his income amounts equal to
1954,
of
amounts paid by a veteran for the last illness and burial
That is pending before the Congress now.
his wife or child.
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
No.
6:
there
Are
this
any
questions
of
of
painting
houses
gentle-
man?
Why
purposes not be
cost of repairs
fore
deductible
porting
ceiving
cost
the
would
the
on expenses,
rental property,
a deductible item
as maintenance of
from
income for
pension or
the
income
gross
widows,
veterans,
death pension?
of
same as the
and there-
in
re-
children
re-
property
such
parents
and
rental
for
Now, to prove to you that we made these
MR. STRATTON:
question assignments when Mr. Peckarsky was off on sick leave,
he will answer this question.
This is a very easy question to answer
MR. PECKARSKY:
it is proper to
It does count,
because we agree with you.
any
subtract this item and as long as this is rental property,
upkeep, including painting, may be subtracted from net profit.
If you do have a case in which this was not done, or you feel
that your station does not understand this and
the case we will be glad to reassure them that
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
Are
there
any
questions
will give
it can be
us
deducted.
concerning
that?
We have a bunch of smart officers here this
MR. LIKENS:
Mr.
I am sure you have some questions some place.
afternoon.
I might
Stratton says "They must be in a state of shock."
go
suggest that if you do have any questions, please rise and
to one of the microphones in the middle aisle because it is
and when you get there please talk to
rather hard to hear,
if you don't
the microphone because it is just like a spittoon;
The next panel member to ask the
hit it, it is worthless.
questions is Mr. Francis W. Weiss, Jr., from Pennsylvania.
having
ing in
the
No. 7:
MR. WEISS:
a guardian living
another town with
eight
MR.
of
election
STRATION:
for
Mr.
incompetent widow
In the case of an
and her minor child 1livin one town,
a separate guardian, who would have
benefits
Art
under
PL
86-2117?
Parmer.
The short answer is the widow's guardian has
MR. FARMER:
It should be understood that
the right to make the election.
the child's rights are derived
when there is a widow living,
a widow, whether she is
There is one provision:
through her.
cannot reduce the
incompetent or not, by electing under 86-211,
That is
amount that the child will get under the old law.
paragraph 7¢0){3).
right in the instructions,
79
MR.
WEISS:
Any
questions?
No. 8, submitted by yours truly:
VA Technical Bulletin
8-265,
dated June 14, 1955,
based on an
opinion of the General
Counsel,
authorized waiver of pension or retirement benefit
payable under a private or public retirement plan for the
purpose of meeting annual income limitations for disability or
death pension.
Accordingly,
before the release of Technical Bulletin
8-272,
a number of waivers were executed by individuals under
private or public retirement plans and the reduced income established eligibility to death or disability pension which they
had received through December 1960.
IB 21-34, dated December 30, 1960, refers to a recent
decision of the General Counsel which states that the VA cannot
recognize any waivers of pension or retirement pay for pension
purposes other than those expressly authorized by Federal
statute.
This bulletin also stated that the instruction sheet
accompanying
the Annual Income Questionnaire directed the beneficiary to list those amounts previously waived which were not
specifically
authorized
by
statute.
What
is
the
status
of
a
beneficiary who reports on the Income Questionnaire for 1960-61
those amounts of private or public retirement previously waived
under
the
PL 86-211
under the
limits of
authority
of
TB
8-265?
Will
the
savings
provision
of
maintain the beneficiary's entitlement to receive
old law if the annual income reported is below the
$1,400 or $2,700?
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
MOORE:
Mr.
In
Moore
answer
to
the
question
as
to
what
is
the
status of someone who has relied on the provisions of the
TB 8-265
-- who secured a waiver, we acknowledged it and we
accepted it, I assume that this inquires as to whether we will
create an overpayment or whether we will adjust it as of the
date of last payment.
I believe the answer will be this:
Under
our Regulation 1253
(e), if a person notifies us promptly when
he knows that he is going to exceed his income limit, we will
discontinue as of the date of last payment and we will not go
back,
and I believe that regulation will be for application here.
This is where,
of course,
the claimant in good faith did
waive under the TB 8-265
and had no other knowledge.
We clarified this late in 1960.
In the instruction sheets to the
questionnaires we told them that they could not waive.
This
was their first knowledge,
so if
they did come in in
January
1961 and tell us of the waiver,
this would be prompt notice and
we would not create an overpayment.
As to part 2 of this question,
as to whether they will be
protected under the old law, we have felt
in the past that if
a person were receiving a pension on June 30, 1960, and we did
not go back and create an overpayment for that time,
that he
would be protected.
I will have to admit that a legal question
has arisen,
however,
in this situation as to
the propriety of
the June payment,
so we are going to have to submit this wuestion to the General Counsel.
We are now submitting it.
I am
sorry
do
get
I
cannot
the
MR.
give
answer
we
MARKOWITZ:
you
a
will
That
definite
answer
distribute
is
my
80
man
now.
it
and
up
there
As
send
that
it
soon
as
we
out
to
you.
asked
the
I decided not to say anything, but I cannot help
question.
I think there is a little misgexplaining a little further.
We have a situation in a depressed area in
understanding.
and the President is
There are many such places,
Pennsylvania.
with the
very much concerned and everybody else is concerned
We did not make the decision as to whether
depressed areas,
That was $100 a month origithis waiver should be permitted.
that they received from the Anthracite
nally and ‘then $50
longer able
Mine Union on behalf of those veterans who were no
We were permitted to make those waivers until some
to work.
smart guy working for the Veterans Administration decided,
The
"We better look up the thing and maybe it is illegal.”
it was
Veterans Administration itself made the decision that
it
legal first, and then they changed their mind and called
We are not concerned about the
illegal and now it is illegal.
We know that you are not trying to collect the
overpayment.
We understand that, but we are concerned about the
overpayment.
in a
hundreds or thousands of veterans who find themselves
to maybe $40
predicament where they have been cut from $78.75
I
a month or whatever amount under this new-fangled law which
do not know anything about, never heard of 4t, and I hope'l
never will be able to understand it, and I hope it will be
changed soon so that everybody understands it.
that is the crux of the problem and 1 think since
Anyhow,
the VA legal guys told these fellows they were entitled to
the veteran
that consideration and then changed their minds,
should not be penalized and his pension should be permitted to
be
remain at the old rate under the old law and he should not
That is the thing we
burdened with having his pension cut.
I do not
Whether you can answer. that question,
want to know.
know.
That is exactly the question
That is right.
MR.MOORE:
later
as I understand it and as you say, we said one thing,
that we
I believe,
we clarified it, and it is on this basis,
are not going back and create an overpayment where they do
As to whether they
and tell us in January 1961.
come in now
as I said, where a person dia get
will get this protection,
pension payments under the old law on June 30, 1960, and we
have not created an overpayment over that time and not attempted
to
get
it
back,
then
we
felt
have
that
they
would
be
protected.
in this situation there is a question whether there
However,
and this is the question we are submitting.
was a proper payment,
As soon as we do get the answer we will certainly let you know.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Counsel and give us a
Use your influence
favorable report.
with
the
General
I would add thereto and assure you
Mike,
MR. STRATTON:
will not
that when we submit this to the General Counsel, we
but we will make sure that we all
ask a flat legal question,
about,
have a common understanding of the things you are talking
and the
the administrative things that were done in the past,
the entire history of this thing,
bulletins,
different technical
so that he can look at it the fullest way possible.
you
are
very
Tell
him
also
Back on
possible
the
for
As
same question.
all these veterans
the
MR. MARKOWITZ:
problem.
TB
MR. WEISS:
made it
8-265
81
sympathetic
to
the
you know,
to waive and
subsequent TB 8-272, which I want to
for when you bring it to the General
in part as follows:
bring to your attention,
Counsel's attention,
states
"The entire matter of waiving a part of all of
pension or retirement benefits payable under a
private or public retirement plan for the purpose
of reducing the claimant's income to the amount within
the annual income limitations of Part 3, Veterans
Regulation
1(a),
as
amended,
and
Public
Law
484,
73rd
Congress,
as amended,
is being reconsidered pending
receipt of further instructions'" -- and I underline
"pending receipt of further instructions."
"No waivers of retirement or pension benefits will be
recognized by the Veterans Administration for the purpose of ‘reducing a claimant's annual income in an
amount which would render him eligible to receive
pension under Part 3."
Now, the Chief Adjudication Officer at the Wilkes-Barre
Regional Office -- I can't speak for other offices, but I can
speak for the Wilkes-Barre Regional Office -- at that time
stated to us that pending receipt of further instructions,
he
would continue the waiver of retirement benefits.
He has never
received those further instructions and for this reason we feel
that they should be given that right.
MR. STRATTON:
We are aware of this and this also is an
integral part of the history that we have to include in our
submission to the General Counsel.
There was a question at
this time
specifically on this group in Pennsylvania which
led us to continue this for a period and certainly it adds some
credence to the argument that you give us here.
Again,
I
assure you and Mike both
that the entire matter will be completely and historically documented when we send it up.
MR. LIKENS:
Are there any other questions directed to
this particular question?
We are about to conclude our portion of the questions and answers and the man to ask the
questions in the final phase is our friend Mr. Timothy J.
Buckley
from
the
State
of
Massachusetts.
MR. BUCKLEY:
The next question is No. 10.
A veteran,
his son and daughter were involved in a car accident.
The
veteran and the son were fatally injured.
The daughter was
hospitalized in a critical condition.
The mother and widow
of deceased
veteran
was
insurance
resulting
from
beneficiary
the
of
veteran's
$10,000
commercial
Will the VA allow the funeral expense of the
hospital expense of the daughter to be
deducted as
when the widow applies for pension?
MR.
tion
think
we
STRATTON:
have
they
had
may
to
have
This
this
heard
perhaps
point.
the
is
To
first
life
death.
the
most
make
sure,
part
of
son and
the
just debts
provocative
your
and
I
do
quesnot
question,
the
significance,
of course,
is one where the veteran has been killed
in an automobile accident.
One of the children has also been
killed in that accident.
The second child has been severely
imjured in that accident.
The question is what can the widow
offset against her income for the year of the death in deciding
82
whether or not she comes within the limitation on income for
the receipt of pension.
Of course,
the law, 86-211, permits
her to offset against that income the last expenses of the
illness and death of the veteran,
so we do not have a problem
there.
Our problem is she also can offset the just debts of
the veteran existing at the time of death.
We get then to
this point:
Are the funeral expenses of the child and the
medical expenses of the second child incurred in the same
accident just debts at the time of his death so that she
can offset them?
I will immediately say that the people that you see at
the front table are very sympathetic to this type
of situation.
It gets very complicated,
though, when you get into the
legal aspects of it.
It is
the type of situation that in the
legal profession you cannot avoid on occasion, but it is such a
fine line that you must hit it.
What we have here basically
probably in the legal aeea is did the father,
that is, the
veteran,
die first,
or did the child die first?
I do not know
that the question will fall or stand on that issue.
I do know,
however,
that there is a presumption generally in the common
law as to survivorship,
where it is not known in a common
accident as to which one died first,
that the older of the
group died first.
If the question ends up being settled on
that issue it would mean that the veteran died first and that
this would be a just debt of the widow and could be offset,
but it is
a very complex thing and, very frankly,
I would like
to say to the gentleman that asked the question that I would
appreciate it if you could give me a case in point on this
thing so that we could get a definite answer.
MR.
BUCKLEY:
Is
MR.
PRATOR:
Yes.
MR.
request?
BUCKLEY:
Do
MR.
PRATOR,
Yes.
MR.
STRATTON:
Mr.
Prator
from
you
intend
to
comply
us
a
It
would
help
Oklahoma
in
with
great
the
Mr.
deal
hall?
Stratton's
if
you
will.
MR. BUCKLEY:
Thank you.
The next question is No. 11. A
single veteran, whose minor child has been adopted by his former
wife and her present husband, has been found entitled to pension
under PL 86-211.
A.
Is he to be considered a veteran with
purpose of the annual income
computation?
B.
May he be paid additional pension for
C.
If
hospitalized
by
the
VA
in
excess
his payments would be subject to reduction
payments of the balance of his entitlement
behalf
of
MR.
the
child
STRATTON:
if
Mr.
need
is
shown?
to
be
of
a
child
his
two
for
child?
months
the
and
$30 monthly, would
made to or
on
Moore.
MR. MOORE:
The answers to the first two questions to this
are in the affirmative.
First,
in the case of the veteran with
a child, for the purpose of annual income computation under our
Regulation 1057
and 1058,
a child adopted out of the veteran's
family either during his lifetime or after his death is
83
nonetheless considered a child,
so for income computation
purposes we would consider that the veteran had a child notwithstanding
the fact that it had been adopted out of his
family.
May he be paid additional pension for his child?
The
answer again here is yes.
The law only requires that he have
a child.
It does not specifically require that he reasonably
contribute to the child's support,
so as long as he has the
child we would pay him the additional amount.
On the third
portion
of
this
question,
we
have
considerable
relates to whether we might apportion
the veteran had been hospitalized for
You
recall
tion
to
the
part
our
the
instruction.
wife
or
child,
it
might
be
First,
of
the
child
We
for
two
this
full
indicated
that
depending
questioned
adopted
out
of
on
doubt.
we
their
could
appor-
need.
whether
the
That
child after
calendar months.
there
was
veteran's
need
on
family.
We
have not had any case in point.
If you have a case, please
let us have it and we willget an answer for you.
As of this
time,
tbough, we have not had any case in point.
If you do
send that in, may I ask that you get evidence relating to the
child's need’ so that we may have the full facts when we decide
the
point.
rather
right
MR. STRATTON:
1 might add here, Mr.
striking coincidence you have given
Chairman,
that by a
us three questions
in
part
row
where
This
is
not
the
way
will
admit,
but
it
that
you
had
to
a
have
asked
defer
our
we
could
we
like
us
give
three
immediately say
on all the rest
that we will
of them.
MR.
Any
you
operate,
through,
answers.
BUCKLEY:
not
to
happens
I
straight
I will
try
as
I
of
apologize
for
to
a
you
BUCKLEY:
Mike
coincidence
where
that
we
and
have
then
definitive
answer
questions?
MR. FELLER (NEW YORK):
In the next panel,
is a question that I would also like to raise in
because I had a case in point to outline.
May I
tion?
MR.
answer.
even
complete
questions
give
the
think
know,
= You
may,
Question No. 6
this panel,
read the ques-
sir.
MR. FELLER:
It is
presented by Charles Kohler of Pennsylvania.
Under present conditions, peacetime veterans who are
zero percent service connected cannot receive VA outpatient
treatment or hospitalization for that condition.
Are any
changes contemplated in the regulations with respect to such
cases?
is
a
Now,
the
point
boy
with
a
according
to
your
that
peacetime
I
would
like
to
rating
schedule,
because
Rochester,
New
Eastman
York,
Kodak
and
he
Company
attempts
or
any
of
to
is
this
is
panel
rated
of
an
than 10 percent.
community such as
He
apply
the
to
hernia
it
innocent hernia and easily reparable,
less
then is zero percent.
He then goes into a
with
raise
service-connected
somewhat
for
larger
employment
choice
employ-
ment
opportunities.
It becomes
an integral
part
of that
employment
process
that
he pass
a physical
examination.
It is
impossible
for
him
to pass
this physical
examination.
With
the hernia
they will
not
take
him.
Then we submit
a 10-P-10
to
is
the hospital and we
out.
He is euchred
nowledged
it
is
get
out
service-connected
equity
the
way
this
Code 38 thrown at
of all benefits.
condition.
thing
84
works
It
now
us
He
does
and
I
and
has
the boy
an ack-
not
seem
would
like
that
to
present
sidered
the question to
in this respect
MR.
BUCKLEY:
Do
this panel.
Is
at this time?
you
care
to
anything
answer
that,
being
Mr,
con-
Stratton?
MR. STRATION:
I think that the basic question that you
selected there,
sir, comes before the medical panel tomorrow,
but you have established it as
part of this.
I will do my
best
to
answer.
I
just
assured
you
that
we
would
answer
all
the rest of them,
sol
‘am going to try.
It is true that under
the law, the person who has only peacetime service or regular
establishment
service cannot get VA hospitalization unless he
was discharged for a disability incurred in line of duty or he
is in receipt of compensation.
That is the basic requirement.
This veteran that you are speaking of here is zero percent
for a disability which did not cause his discharge from the
service.
Therefore,
he is not in receipt of compensation.
He was not CDD'd for that disability and under the law he is
not entitled to hospitalization.
of.
Now we get
He comes to
percent,
IT.
think
on the merry-go-round that you are
Adjudication and he says, "Instead
that
1
am
entitled
to
‘ten
percent
speaking
of zero
because
1
have a hervia.”
They rate the case and they say, "This hernia
is operable.
Therefore,
you are not entitled to ten percent."
He says,
"How can. 1. get ten percent?"
They say, "We have to
find out after you have been
operated on whether or not the
residuals would warrant it."
He says,
"How do I do that?"
He goes to the hospital and they say, '"We can't take you in
unless Adjudication gives you ten percent.’
He is on the merry-go-round and we acknowledge this is
somewhat of a merry-go-round.
It is created by the exact language of the law,
I fear, but I do know that there have been
bills introduced in past sessions of Congress.
I do not know
about this session.
But I would bring it up at the medical
panel session.
There have been bills introduced which would
correct the thing that you are speaking of.
MR. BUCKLEY:
Any further questions?
If not, we will pass
on to 12.
A World War II widow and her two
children had no
entitlement prior to the enactment of PL 86-211.
Her income
for 1960 is $1,400,
$200 of which is received from January 1,
1960, to June 30, 1960, and $1,200 of which was received from
July I, 1960,
to December 31, 1960,
What
1,
1960,
rate
to
MR.
of
pension
December
STRATTON:
should
31,
19607
Mr.
Moore.
this
widow
be
paid
from
July
MR. MOORE:
This, of course,
involves our proportionate
computation rule.
The widow would get $40 for
herself with an
additional: $15 for her
child, or a total of $33 from the date
of her entitlement,
July 1, 1960,
In this case
we have,
I
believe,
a pretty simple rule that we follow,
We do proportionately compute from the effective date in the case of any
veteran or widow.
In this case eligibility is first established
July 1, 1960.
The total income from July lst through the end
of
the
an
an
annual basis,
annual income
year
is
$1,200,
is
at
or
at
a rate
of
%200
per
month.
This,
$2,400.,
so her payments would be based on
the increment between $2,000 and $3,000.
85
on
We
pay
I
will
her
$40
plus
the
$15
MR. BUCKLEY:
Any
return the panel
MR.
LIKENS:
We have
members
unless
there
this
question
pertaining
CRIDER
the
child.
questions from the floor?
Hearing none,
to our Chairman, Val Likens of Nebraska.
panel
MR.
for
one more
question
from
one of our
is another
question
from
the floor,
to
PL
(TENNESSEE):
86-211,
Let
me
Mr.
go
Crider.
back
just
a minute
to this question on the zero percent peacetime veteran.
You
know,
in the past when a public law was passed we read it one
way and then when the instructions are written we do not recognize it to be
the law as passed.
Why can't you write instructions as you do on most of these laws regardless of what
the law says and go on
and fix it where the peacetime veteran
can be hospitalized,
because I am sure you have wiggled these
laws around in the past where you have done that.
Why didn't
you do this with the peacetime veteran?
MR. STRATTON:
I would prefer to just wiggle those laws
that pertain to compensation and pension rather than to the
Department of Medicine and Surgery but, as I recall, Jim, and
I have to call on my recollection here, because this is not
entirely
in my
MR.
field,
CRIDER:
Part
MR. STRATTON:
the law itself, not
tion of a peacetime
sation or unless he
in
line
of
duty.
as
you
of
for
disability
--
it.
As I recall,
the language of the law today,
the instructions, would prohibit hospitaiizaveteran unless he was in receipt of compenwas discharged for a disability incurred
It is
a little
could be interpreted so that
peacetime only, who had
zero
get the compensation and, on
not
know
incurred
hard
for
me
to
see
how
that
you could put a man in the hospital,
percent and has failed there to
the other hand, was discharged
in
line
of duty.
MR. CRIDER:
You come out with the 86-211 and others
where there is nothing said about these instructions and you
wrote instructions applying to it not identified in the law in
any way, and that is why I say if you can do that, why don't
you do the same thing on peacetime veterans?
You have done it.
It has been legal so far.
MR. STRATTON:
I think your latter remark certainly does
not apply to this panel and if you would show us where we have
broken the law 211 I will be glad to look at the instruction.
were
MR. CRIDER:
never in the
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
CRIDER:
1 say
law.
you
Almost
Thank
have
all
written
of
pages
them have
on
been
211
that
liberal.
you.
MR. LIKENS:
Are there any other questions from the floor?
If not, we will let one of the panel members, Mr. Weiss,
ask
this question.
if
the
MR. WEISS:
Mr, Stratton,
General Counsel contends
86
going back to Question .8 again,
that the veteran is eligible to
receive benefits under the old law, then what would happen to
this veteran who subsequent to January 1, 1961, had no other
alternative but to accept benefits under Public Law 86-2117
Would he be given the right to return to the old law, even
though he accepted and cashed his initial check under Public
Law 86-2117
MR. STRATTON:
I am going to need
I think.
This gentlemen under Question
cause of this waiver problem?
MR. WEISS:
of
or
under
MR.
"WBISS:.
one,
be-
Right.
MR. STRATTON:
At that point,
his union subsidy, he would have
$1,800
some help on this
8 has been barred
though,
a total
even counting
income under
all
$3,000.
Correct.
MR. STRATTON:
And at that point your question would go
to the fact that
he does then take benefits under 211.
At
some future date, perhaps when the payments are reduced from
the union,
and he gets back under $1,400, would he be
able to
come back under the old law, if the General Counsel so rules
on this retroactive payment?
I think I have loused this up.
MR.
this
WEISS:
Providing
that
income
is within
that
$1,400
year.
MR.MOORE:
Actually,
I was just milling this through my
mind.
The thought occurred to me that until he elects,
a man
does not come under 211.
He does not lose protection under
the old law if he were entitled on June 30, 1960, until he
elects,
and I believe that based on that theory,
if he did not
elect to receive under 211 and the decision is that he has
protection under the old laws, we could pay him under the old
law.
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
If
it is
MR.
MOORE:
is
correct.
That
declared
to be
legal.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Would he receive retroactive benefits
from July 1, 1960, when he did elect because he would have no
other recourse?
If the General Counsel decides it is legal,
will he be given retroactive benefits under the old law?
MR. MOORE:
We have another problem here, Mike.
As you
recall,
a man that has eligibility under the old law, that is,
he is protected under the old law and is receiving benefits on
June 30, 1960, and he elects under 211, we cannot pay him
under
211 prior to the date of receipt of his election.
In other
words, he has to take the good with the bad, does he not?
MR. WEISS:
We have here a miner at the present time.
His
income does not permit him to continue his normal
obligations.
Therefore,
he has no other alternative but to accept benefits
under 211,
It is a hardship to him so he elects to receive
under 211, but subsequently the General Counsel says he is entitled to payments under the old law.
Is he going to be penalized because he accepted that check under 2117
MR.
MOORE:
If
he
elects
87
under
211
and
receives
a
check
and negotiates it, he is bound to thereafter
211 only.
I realize the difficulty we might
which means that we are going to have to get
this
question
MR.
General
from
him
to
you
real
fast.
MARKOWITZ:
No, we
Counsel decides that
or
under
the
are
you
old law
you
receive under
get him into here,
the answer to
confusing the thing.
took his right under
took
it
away
from
If
211
him
the
away
and
you forced him to take benefits under 211, the man is innocent,
but he has to have dough.
He has to live on whatever he can
get.
He has no income,
or very little,
Are you going to
penalize
that fellow by keeping him under 211, or are you going
to permit him to go back where he ought to be?
Will you have
the
General Counsel
answer
Will you please include
to the General Counsel?
MR.
MOORE:
Suppose
it
that
in
the
part
your
of
very
General
the
question,
sympathetic
Counsel
protected.
If he
does,
I think we can.pay
all of this year, because no election will
he has no protection there is no election.
says
too?
presentation
is
not
him under 211
be required.
he
for
If
MR. MARKOWITZ:
If the General Counsel says,
"Yes, you
are entitled under the old law," will you let him go back to
that?
MR. STRATTON:
Mike, my earlier point where he helped
me out,
there I think was well taken.
In other words, what
Herb was saying was to exercise an election you hawe:to have
a right to two different
things.
You have to have two.
The
word absolutely requires that in its interpretation,
and since
you do not lose your protection until you elect,
the person
we are talking about here does not have a right to two things,
unless the General Counsel says he is protected;
he has only
a right to 211.
If the General Counsel says he is protected,
and he has, nevertheless,
taken pension under 211 because his
1961 income is over $1,400, he has made an election and must
stay under the new law.
Or he can wait - not take under 211 and then, if his income is reduced below $1,400 next year, he
can come back on the rolls under the old law.
MR.
WEISS:
We
will
accept.
MR. WOORS (ARIZONA):
I have a similar question along
that same line, except this pertains to a widow,
and this came
up very recently,
in fact in the past two weeks.
This widow
was under the old law and shortly after,
sometime in June or
July, we received the pamphlet and the stuff that went out on
the new law,
Now, at that time
we did not have enough questionnaires for the election.
We ran out.
So they sent out a 4100
form and there was another instruction in this, but we do not
know exactly what it was.
At any rate,
at that time the widow
was drawing about $1,000 social security, but she had failed
to report it, did not think that it counted as income,
so the
4100 came back, went into the file,
and she was put under the
new law.
She did not know that she was making an election.
There is nothing in the case file that indicates
that that
widow made an election under the new law.
She has
no instructions as to what they thought she was going to get under the
new law.
Now,
then, when the income questionnaire comes in now
I fill it out for her, but with the social security, which
should have been
in at first, but she did not know, she was
88
still under $1,400.
However,
this drops her down under the
new law.
Now, my contention is that this widow did not know
that she was making an election,
and she willmake such a statement.
1 am going to try to straighten it out, but she has
cashed all those checks since she went under the new law.
MR. MOORE:
Mr. Woods, do I understand that she at no
time actually elected,
that is, she sent in a Form 4100 but
at no time elected to go under 2117
MR.
elected,
strued
try
to
WOODS:
There
is
nothing
And you think
election?
MR.
WOODS:
Yes.
MR.
MOORE:
What
have
they
MR. WOODS:
They
correct. it,
have
indicated
that
not,
us
MOORE:
If
they
do
MR. LIKENS:
Are there
floor?
If not, I would like
Georgia once again.
MR. JENSEN:
1
conferees here if we
at this time to give
date.
MR.
STRATTON:
out
on
the
same
the
there
MR. MOORE:
this as an
MR.
start
in
that says that
regional
said
let
to
you
she
office
miscon-
about
it?
they
are
going
to
know.
any other questions from the
to recognize Mr. Jensen from
believe it would be interesting to the
would give Mr. Stratton an opportunity
the VA's experience under PL 86-211 to
Of
course,
base,
on
to
retrace
March
lst
we
a
little
sent
the
bit
so
we
election
form to all of the pensioners that come under 211.
Now,
immediately after we started receiving elections.
We continued
to receive elections to this time.
We received in the month
of January,
1,500
a week,
or about 6,000 during the month of
January alone.
This is about 500
more per week than we received
in December.
We received about 1,000 per week in December.
I
think the reason for that increase in January would be apparent
to you.
They got an income questionnaire and it rang a bell and
they said,
"Didn't I get something in last March on this
pension deal," and they looked into it and decided to elect.
I would not expect that 1,500
to continue indefinitely,
perhaps through February,
but not
probably through March.
As to
our experience totally in elections to date, we have received
about 17-1/2 percent elections.
About 255,000
elections have
been filed and have been accepted.
In the area of corpus of
estates, which is probably the subject that we
spent the most
time on in this conference shortly after 211 was passed,
I
can give you some experience under that.
As you know, we set up in the instructions a requirement
that we will review in Washington every decision that is made
denying pension benefits because of excessive corpus.
We also
asked to look at cases that were allowed where the estate
exceeded $10,000 so that we could have a cross-section of both
types of cases for one purpose only, and that was to see whether
89
the criterion
quate and how
that we had written in the instruction was adecould we improve it.
As to the immediate reaction
to
estate,
corpus
of
the large
represent
They came
that that
the
first
decisions
we
got,
of
course,
or
bulk of them, even today, were those decisions that
corpus of estate determinations made on elections.
out of these 255,000,
or that additional figure over
were not accepted.
Remember
that
we
told
the
claimants,
"Do
not
hold
back
on an election because you fear that the estate would be a bar,"
so when we got those they had not decided whether it was a bar.
They sent them in to us.
If we agreed it was a bar,
then the
person there,
the electee,
lost nothing.
It merely meant that
he stayed under the old law; he did not come under the new.
We have received since July 1st about 175,000
new claims for
pensions,
probably in that neighborhood,
which would also be
subjected to the corpus of estate test.
figure
I
I
give
am
you
going
this
to
background
furnish
now.
so
you
In
can
other
relate
words,
it
out
to
of
the
255,000
elections and about 175,000
new claims that are 211
only, or about 400,000 cases that are subject to the corpus
of estate test, we have disallowed 930.
This is the figure
that we have here
in Washington today.
As to equalization,
perhaps the greatest attention that should be given to 211 now,
and I think that most of the states are recognizing this,
is
more publicity on equalization.
We estimated early in the
game that we would probaply not get, but that there were
probably about 200,000 beneficiaries or dependents in the
country that would be qualified for the first time under 211
because no longer did they have to have this gimmick we had
before,
the service-connected disability at the time of death.
Now, here I am just estimating,
but the best figures
that I have would indicate that around 40,000 to 45,000
new
cases have gone on the rolls solely because &f equalization.
As to the 70 percent that was estimated,
the item that Mr.
Markowitz always wants to discuss,
the 70 percent figure was
not a figure of who would come in and elect.
It could not be.
But to Congress we are required to tell them the total number
that we feel would be entitled under any new piece of legislation.
The best figures we had at that time, based primarily,
it is
true, on 1954
and 1955
economic data, indicated that
about 70 percent of the people on the rolls would be entitled
to an
increase under 211.
This figure has been severely
challenged in many directions.
I will now give you the results
of the study that we made recently which I think to a very large
extent would seem to justify this original estimate and would
indicate that there are literally thousands of people still
throughout the country that on the basis of their present
income would get more dollars if they elected under 211.
We made a study
judicated in one week
had about 2,900 cases
What
did
we do
with
of every new pension case that was adin December,
all over the country.
We
that were adjudicated during that week.
them?
We
asked
each
office
to
code
for
us certain information about that case.
We asked them to make
a determination as to entitlement in every one of those cases
both under the old law and under the new law, even though we
knew
that
after
could
July 1, 1960.
We got income data
think of in connection with this.
most
of
these
were
only
90
211
cases
and
Of
because
they
everything
the number
filed
that
that
we
we
got,
and
I would
stand
back
of
these
figures
without
any
fear
because,
as I say, they were put on code sheets and they were
not run through the computer, Mike,
and they were sent to
Washington and we punched cards on them and ran
our counts,
we found that counting everything,
80 percent of the people
who had their cases adjudicated during that week in December
got more money or got money where they would not have gotten
it before.
Eighty percent of them were benefited by 211 in
some way.
There
were
a
number
of
them,
of
course,
who
were
not
en-
titled under either one of the laws because basically you have
to be P&T.
You have to have been honorably discharged;
you
have to have 90 days service, be unemployable,
et cetérag.
There were about 350
of them not entitled under either law.
In attempting to find out from this group what percentage
would be equivalent to the elect#ees on July 1, 19607 we restricted
ourselves
there
to
those
people
who
would
be
en-
titled under both laws to something,
on the assumption and
as an equivalent that electee,
after all, on July lst was entitled under the old law, was entitled under the new,law,
and
had
a right
of
election,
so
we
reduced
this
figure,
this
80
percent I spoke of, down to the number of people in that week
in December who were entitled under both laws basically to
something,
and without any preconception of what this figure
would show,
it turns out that 71.6 percent of these people
in that week in December got more money under 211 than they
would
have
The
that were
decreased
484
of
gotten
under
Public
Law
Noi2.
:
average amount of increase that they got of those
increased was $13.51
a month.
The ones that
were
under the new law, and, of course,
there were some,
them,
they
lost
$13.41.
The
spouses'
incomes
out
of
these 2,900 cases caused a reduction in what he would have
gotten under the old law in 23
cases out of 2,900.
The spouse's
income barred him from the receipt of pension in nine cases,
so
the spouse's income played a part in this to the tune of 32
cases out of the entire 2,900.
As to equalization,
and here a moment ago I gave you a
figure of about 40,000 to 45,000,
we found in that one week
670 favorable adjudications out of the 2,900 that would not
have been put on the rolls if it had not been for the equalization feature.
You can see at that rate, 670 a week, even at
the late date in December,
although we are still publicizing
equalization,
the big push is over.
Even at that point we were
getting around 2,600 a month in the country actually being put
on the rolls because of equalization.
The increased income
ceiling
from
$1,400
to
people.
Out
of
number
the
corpus
cause
of
the
of
$1,800
and
2,800,
estate.
$2,700
to
$3,000
we
disallowed
This
basically
that we have up to this point.
This figure of
is in my opinion not a firm comparison at this
70
percent
we
are
in
the
election
going
to
figure
try
When people
game,
this
great
deal
of
order
to
qualify
to
come on
is when
significance
coup
it
in
the
part
of
the
third.
on
the
first
I
that
clear
I spoke
this
the
the
for
cases
is
the
173
be-
resume
71.6 percent
point with the
one
reason
and
up.
rolls for the first time early
recoupment feature carries a
because
income
year,
maybe
it
feel
that
we
91
of
helped
20
if
means
you
part
of
had
a
have
to
recoup
that
generally
larger
number
the
second,
in
you
and
of
re-
maybe
recoupment cases in these new cases adjudicated in the 2,900,
a figure that is out of proportion to what we would have had on
comparing them with those on the rolls July 1, 1960,
and I
think that we are going to have to reduce that 71.6 by this
recoupment difference and we are calling a number of those
cases to Washington to find out exactly how significant
recoupment was, and we will honestly reduce the figure at that
time.
At that stage it is
my opinion that we will come up
with a percentage which is reasonably equivalent to the percentage of people on the rolls today under the old law that
would benefit under the new law.
I would hesitate to guess.
I think it will be reduced from 71.6 down to perhaps 65
percent, perhaps even a little bit lower.
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA:
I think those figures were
very interesting that Mr. Stratton gave us.
Do you have a
breakdown now on those percentages as to how many of them were
live cases and how many death cases?
The reason I am asking
the question, Mr. Stratton,
is that all of the live cases that
you include in that percentage are also subject to reductions
if they go into the hospital under 211 which they would not
have been under the old law.
MR, STRATTON:
1 do not have, Lou, with me here today a
breakdown as to
how many of these cases were live cases and
how many death cases.
The death cases are somewhat larger than
they would be ordinarily because this equalization brought them
in.
I do not know.
I can give you one additional figure on
the point that you mentioned,
though.
Of the 2,900, 484 people
got less under the new law than they would have gotten under
the old as against 1,221 who got more under the new law than
they would have under the old.
Of the 483 who got less under the new law, 458
of them
got less because of the annual income;
23 of them got less because of the spouse's income;
and only three of them got less
because they were in the hospital at the time and were going
to be reduced under this automatic reduction.
They would have
gotten more under the old law between the second and the fourth
month
we
get
those
cut
off
the
first day of
entire group
when
the
got
third month,
less because
but only three cases
of hospitalization.
out
of
(MISSOURI):
The
MR.
HENRY
cases.
These
men
figures
were
given
by Mr.
that
Stratton
are a little misleading
in the overall picture for the simple
reason that almost all veterans who are over age 65
going
under the new law for the first time will have credit coming
from
their
but in the
would be a
MR.
about
a
social
security
and
they will
be
following
reduction
year they will have to
if they were under the
STRATTON:
Yes,
sir.
We
recognize
moment
ago.
That
was
that
in
what
for
the
$90
have $75,
old law.
I
those
was
bracket,
which
talking
people
who
get
$90 today,
in that week in December,
because they are in the
recoupment area,
it would not be fair when we are trying to
make this figure equivalent to the 70 percent on elections to
count that disproportionate share in the category you mention
and that is what I said.
We are going to pull those cases in
and find out how much we should reduce that percentage to adequately represent what we actually had on the rolls on July 1,
1960, but you are correct,
after the recoupment he could end
up in a year and a half or two years getting less under the new
2
law
than
floor
we
are
under
MR.
the
old.
LIKENS:
to Mr.
Any
Foust.
CHAIRMAN
FOUST:
indeed
honored
other
questions?
Ladies
this
and
I
will
gentlemen
of
afternoon
to
have
return
in
the
the
conference,
our
midst
a
gentleman whom most of you should know and some of us are privileged to know,
and we are most happy to present to you at
this time for a bow the Honorable Oliver Meadows, who is the
staff director of the House Veterans' Affairs Committee.
We
are very happy to have you with us.
At this time I want to thank our members of the panel
who so efficiently served us in
this discussion,
and at this
time we will discharge them with a vote of thanks.
Ladies and gentlemen of the conference, we have in our
great organization a group of very fine Legionnaires who for
many years have been doing an outstanding job for us.
I am
referring,
of course,
to our field representatives,
and they
are headed by a very fine, capable,
and outstanding gentleman
whom we all love and admire,
and at this time for brief remarks I am very happy to present to you the Director of our
Field Service, Nicholas Lynch,
affectionately known to us as
Nick.
REMARKS OF NICHOLAS LYNCH, JR.
DIRECTOR, NATIONAL FIELD SERVICE
MR.
LYNCH:
Chairman
Baldy
and
my
fellow
workers
in
the
rehabilitation program of The American Legion:
Again it is
an honor to be granted an opportunity to bring the greetings
of the staff of your National Field Service,
as well as a
personal message.
This is a working conference because it is
composed of men who are dedicated in their work and who continually strive to make each day more fruitful.
The role of
a service officer is an honorable one and while the financial
remuneration is not great,
there is a remuneration that is of
far
greater
value
than
a pay check.
It is
human being
derives
the
form
of
the remuneration and satisfaction
from assisting his fellowman.
that
which
is
received
in
that
a
In the rehabilitation program of The American Legion
there is a double remuneration,
the remuneration that The
American Legion receives as an organization devoted to the
service of those who have served their country in time of war,
and the survivors of those veterans who have been
called to
their final muster,
and there is that remuneration which each
of you as an individual receives from serving his country as
well as his fellowman.
Over the past 40 years the term ''service' has become
synonymous with the name American Legion.
You and your predecessors have established a record unmatched in history,
but I
wonder many times how many of you who have surveyed in your
own minds and thoughts some of the developments,
innovations,
and changes that have taken place in veter ans programs and
policies have given thought to what will
be the final tally of
these events, what will be their ultimate relationship to
veterans .rehabilitation programs,
and yes, even the future role
of the Service Officer.
93
Will these
amen to the
fit,
fessional
of
in
your
the
it is
great
and
service
National
ranks
of
changing practices and
planned elimination of
policies
the role
Field
serve
officers?
the
improver,
is
my
as
review
they
rehabilitation
my belief that
rehabilitation
an
From
Service
army
of
of
target
of
some
of
the
with
The
the work of the Service
program of which he has
a
serve a proof the pro-
our
observations
you
American
daily
Legion,
Officer,
like the
been an architect
opponents
because
if the role of the Service Officer is de-emphasized and his
work hampered,
then it will become just so much easier to proceed with their attack on the program itself.
It is
not my intention here today to pinpoint or to
single out any one development,
even, or change that has
brought me to this conclusion, but I would like to leave this
request with you:
To review in your own minds and thoughts
events of the past ten years, of which many .of you are more
familiar than I, and analyze how each of these events has
affected
you
as
your
That
is
Service
role
as
a Service
something
Officers
that
could
I
Officer.
think
give
each
a great
and
every
amount
of
one
of
thinking
to.
In closing I want to express my sincere thanks to each
and every one of you for the always fine cooperation which we
have received,
and to Chairman Bob McCurdy and Director John
Corcoran our gratitude for the privilege of working with their
fine
staff
--
really
they. are
the
cream
of
the
land
--
and
to
assure you that we are always ready to march with you in the
service of our disabled veterans and to add further prestige
to The American Legion for God and Country.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
say, we appreciate the
are performing for our
Thank you very much, Nick.
very fine job you and your
great organization.
Needless to
assistants
Members of the conference,
at this time our Director,
John Corcoran,
has a very important and a most pleasing job to
perform and I would like at this time
to call upon our Director,
John Corcoran.
MR.
most
CORCORAN:
pleasing
task
Thank
and
it
you,
will
Baldy.
be
a
I do
surprise
rise
to
to perform
the
a
recipient.
Yesterday I told you of a woman who has worked with the
National Rehabilitation Commission for over 39 years,
and I
told you of her not only devotion to duty, her dedication to
service, but also of her great competence.
She is a woman who
symbolizes the growth of The American Legion rehabilitation
program and she is a person that the members of her fair -sex
can well be proud of because not only has she no equal among
her fellow associates,
her male employees,
but she has, as I
indicated yesterday,
risen to supervisory status in our organization.
When I told you about Rachel you joined me in applauding
her.
Today it gives me a great deal of pleasure to announce
that I have been authorized by the Chairman and the members of
the National Rehabilitation Commission to present a citation,
a somewhat more tangible evidence
of our esteem.
me
Ray, will you please
‘read this Citation.
Tt
bring
says:
94
Rachel
up
to
the
platform?
Let
"The American Legion National Rehabilitation
Commission Citation for Meritorious Service.
For meritorious service and loyal cooperation
in The American Legion's Rehabilitation Program,
Rachel Koch is awarded this Citation in
recognition thereof by the National Rehabilitation
Commission
:
It is
Director.
signed
by
of
the
The
American
Legion."
National Chairman
and
by
the
National
MRS. KOCH:
I am speechless.
Thank you all very much.
It has been an extreme pleasure to work with all of you and to
work mostly in behalf of widows and dependents,
although in
some years passed I have also
worked on veterans claims, but
when this was segregated in the Veterans Administration I felt
that my best service and my heart lied mostly with the widows
and dependents,
and so I chose to follow that line of work.
I
would like to say too, for the people in the Veterans Administration,
that I have made
many friends among your people and
I have enjoyed working with them,
and I am just sorry that the
time has come to terminate the association,
that is, the active
association,
but I will never forget any of you.
Thank you
very much,
we
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
have to lose such
I
a
know you
prominent
join with me in sorrow
ubdividual as Rachel.
that
Tonight we will start to proceed with our panel on the
subject of veterans and Dependents Claims Service.
Tonight
I would like the panel members to present themselves at the
platform,
namely, Harry Carper, Jr., Virginia, Department Service Officer; Walter T. Hyde, Rhode Island, Department Service
Officer; Vinson Rabern, Georgia, Accredited Representative;
Kenneth L. Harms, Kansas, Claims Supervisor;
and Dudley L.
Smith,
Idaho, Department Claims Representative.
And with this
group I would like to extend a most cordial invitation to those
who were unable to serve this morning because of the time limit
and I invite the following members to join in this panel,namely,
James
L.
man;
Gordon
Officer;
Crider,
Tennessee,
French,
Mentor
C.
Department
Connecticut,
Murphy,
New
Service
Acting
York,
Officer,
Department
Regional
Chair-
Service
Service
Director;
J. P.
Hone, Ohio, Department Service Director and; Glenn H.
Howe, Oregon, Department Service Officer.
In addition to this
group our staff representatives are R. F. Macdouall and B. A.
Nolan.
MR. CARPER:
Ladies and gentlemen,
there has been a change
in your printed program and that panel scheduled for eleven
o'clock this morning has been combined with the panel scheduled
for
3:15
this
afternoon
and
we
will
serve
as
your
panel.
Before
proceeding I would like to introduce very hastily the members
of the panel.
You have already been introduced to the VA
members of the panel.
I would like to introduce and have them
stand for a bow the remaining members.
Mr. Gordon French,
Acting Department Service Officer from Connecticut} Mr. Mentor
C. Murphy, Regional Service Director from New York; Mr. J. P.
Hone, Department Service Officer from Ohio; Mr. Walter T. Hyde,
Department Service Officer from Rhode Island; Mr. Vinson Rabern,
Accredited Representative from the state of Georgia; Mr. Kenneth
L. Harms, Claims Supervisor from Kansas;
and Mr. Dudley L. Smith,
95
Department Claims Representative from
number of questions on this panel and
body
off
from
a discussion,
but
we
Idaho.
do not
have
30
We have quite a
wish to cut any-
scheduled
questions
and I understand there are some from the floor.
We will allow
the members of the panel to take four questions each and they
have already been scheduled and we will for brevity allow them
to remain in their seats and call the questions and the microphone will be passed from one to another,
If the VA personnel
would like to stay in their seats I believe we can expedite
these questions.
I understand that questions two, three,
and
seven will be answered all at the same time.
If you will
turn to page 11 of your agenda we will proceed with the ques-
tions.
Tonight
I will
ask
Mr.
French
to
read
the
first
four
questions.
A.
V.
MR. FRENCH:
The
Akin of Georgia.
No.l:
Social
directors in lieu of
almost any statement
it that
nations
MR.
the
know,
quire
first
first
Security
to
admit
questions
accepts
as
of
it
submitted
from
They will
of birth.
by
funeral
also
Why
accept
is
liberal in making their determibirth and proof of death?
I will
that
were
statements
death certificates.
of evidence of proof
the VA cannot be
concerning proof
STRATTON:
four
attempt
that
becomes
somewhat
to you and to others that
different types of proof,
if
I may.
I would
aggravating,
be
I
different federal agencies rebut more aggravating, different
federal agencies have different rules or laws as to what is a
marriage, what is acceptable as a child,
et cetera.
This latter
to me, while it is
not part of this question,
is a very broad
area which I think the government can certainly improve on.
Being more specific,
however,
as to thesduestion, we require a
death certificate,
it is
true.
As 1 understand it, the Social
Security will accept something less than that.
We, however,
in
our
business
do
not
have
the
methods
of
verification
that
they
have,
that is, the tax deduction would continue in Social
Security if the person were not truly deceased.
We do
not feel
that basically we could eliminate the requirement of a death
certificate and our
experience has indicated that it is not
really too much of an imposition on the claimant to get the
death certificate.
As to the birth records,
that is, what will
prove the birth,
I really believe that basically our rules
are more liberal in this regard than Social Security.
We list
as acceptable items of proof a number of different things.
Social Security also lists these things almost entirely the same.
There is one difference,
however.
The Veterans Administration
does not require that these different types of proof be submitted in a certain order of preference;
in other words,
a
birth certificate first,
and if you cannot do that then something else, and if you cannot do that,
then do something else.
We will accept any one of these things as proof of birth and
will
not
go
for
the
best
evidence
if we
have
any
one
of
these
items.
From the Social Security handbook that I have an excerpt
from here it would indicate that they have about the same types
of proof listed, but they would require that they be submitted
in the following order of preference,
so I do not believe that
there would be any liberalization of the VA rule in this respect.
MR. FRENCH:
No. two, three and
time.
Are there any questions?
If
seven which will be answered
96
not
all
I will read
at the same
No. 2:
Social Security sendsto their beneficiaries at the
end of each calendar year income questionnaires
to be signed
only if they have exceeded their income limitation.
Why can't
the VA follow the same procedure?
No. 3:
Why is income from savings,
dividends,
considered as income by the VA
Security?
No. 7:
Why doesn't the VA
Social Security,
so as to reduce
increase their efficiency?
such as
and not
interest on
by Social
use income forms
some unnecessary
similar to
workload and
MR. MOORE:
I believe that all three of these actually
go to the same point.
Let me take No. three first,
the interest
on savings.
The VA is concerned with income and Social Security
is concerned with earnings,
so actually what we are looking for
here are two separate things.
Social Security does not consider
interest as earnings unless,
of course,
the claimant,
the wage
earner in their case,
is engaged in a business where he gets
interest as an earning.
For VA purposes it is income.
It
determines whether it shall be counted in meeting the needs
of the veteran and exceeds the income limitation so it does
count as income for our purposes and I believe this is the
difference between the two agencies.
As to questions two and seven,
they go to the procedure
we follow to get data relating to continued entitlement.
Here
again Social Security needs information concerning earnings.
The Veterans Administration needs information relating to income.
Now, for Social Security purposes I can imagine that it
isn't too difficult to define earnings.
Of course,
there are
many if's, but's and wherefor's in our laws and regulations
pertaining to what is income so we do require a statement each
year so that the claimant can tell us what his income is.
In
some cases we may not consider it income and in other cases we
may.
The Social Security does not require the detailed evaluation.
Another reason,
of course,
is under 86-211 we require
the
spouse's
income
to
be
reported.
We
require
corpus
of
es-
tate information.
Of course,
eventually all will be under 86211.
Social Security sends out a card, as I understand it,
once each year.
They state that the claimant should inform
them if his earnings exceed $1.200.
If this comes back in
the affirmative then they
send out a form and request detailed
information.
We, on the other hand, go for the detailed in-
formation
in
each
case.
The
gentleman
that
asked
this
ques-
tion undoubtedly had in mind the peak workload that we have
in January of each year,
and this is true.
We are working on
this, however, with the thought of perhaps spreading some of
this work out over the year. As you may have noticed,
over
the past two years we have coding each claimant into an income
group and we hope to use this in order to level our workload
which we have been getting all in January.
Any questions on
this?
you
MR. AKIN (GEORGIA:
Our questions on these matters,
remember as a carry over from Montgomery, Area C.
MR.
those
MOORE:
I
remember
MR. AKIN:
I thought
of us working in the
Montgomery
you would.
field,
that
S97
Herb,
well.
We find repeatedly,
the same claimants,
if
you please,
in many cases are dealing with their Social Security
contact people and on the other hand they
are dealing with our
people.
We are asked repeatedly why on the one hand Social
Security is asking for certain verification of documents.
Once
the contact man had an opportunity to take a look at them, they
are satisfied.
They pay death benefits and monetary benefits
as you do and we do, as you assist them in getting,
and they
continue
to
ask
us
why
in
so many
ways
it
is
so difficult
for
them to convince the VA.
Where, on the other hand, another
federal agency seems to want to pay them and they tell us, and
I have to share their feeling,
that the VA tries every way in
the world to keep from paying them.
That is the problem, Herb,
as we find it out in the field and I think a lot of these other
fellows have the same problem.
On the question about the income limitation,
the questionnaires,
they have a similar problem.
We know that a lot of
the income questionnaires year in and year out are strictly
down the line none, none, none, or within very rigid limitand your people have to spend yheir time considering
ations,
these questionnaires when they could probably be classified
and put out of the way and the claimant notified that if his
income does get extended to let you know,
just as you are required to do on a change of status.
Wouldn't that expedite
not only in Jamuary of every year, but won't it help the claimants all the way around?
Wouldn't it simplify things and
wouldn't it be an advantage
to do that?
That is our problem.
MR. MOORE:
It may be that in doing what we have in mind,
as I indicated,
the coding of the income groups, we will come
up with something along those lines.
Right now I don't think
we can promise you.
I believe we are headed in that direction.
When we will actually get to it I am not able to say.
However,
the proposal that we have,
the work that we have been doing
in coding these income groups,
could result in a similar procedure where the income is nil.
MR. EGAN:
Mr. Chairman,
I would like to revert to the
first item, because I was on the other side of the room,
the
Veterans Administration
acceptable proof of death.
I believe
that I am the only doctor of mortuary science present in this
room.
In other words,
I am an Undertaker.
Death certificates
are something that we seem to know something about, or should.
The answer that they do require a death certificate is not
true.
The Veterans Administration cannot obtain and neither
can a Service Officer obtain proof of records which do not exist.
Harry will tell you, and this is a specific case at instance.
The veteran died prior to 1913 in Virginia.
The official records of death in Virginia start in 1913,
The question at issue
in this case was a statement from the Undertaker that he buried
the veteran.
Failing in this the Veterans Administration then
requested the widow to obtain..a certificate from the sexton of
the cemetery.
It was a Negro cemetery at Hampton, Virginia,
which had been overcome in a real estate development.
The
records of the church were dissipated.
A simple statement
under 209 that she did not know that there was a legal impediment to her marriage was sufficient to grant entitlement to the
widow.
The death certificate was never produced.
MR. STRATTON:
I stand corrected.
I do
that we require a death certificate.
This is
is also not required on a preflerential basis,
98
recall saying
not correct.
just like the
This
birth
certificate, but I believe that also in the regulations we do
have a number of other ways that death could be established
which will be acceptable.
MR. EGAN:
you needed
ment
That is right, but you
death certificate.
a
MR.
STRATION:
MR.
HYDE:
I
know.
Question
You
are
number
made
going
the
to
catch
state-
me.
four.
No. 4:
On VA Form 21-4179, who can be
of deducting unusual medical expenses?
poses
definite
included
for
pur-
MR. FARMER:
Any persons who are members of the family
are included for the purposes of deducting unusual medical expenses
That's a slightly different rule than the just debts
under Public Law 211,
before
MR. CARPER:
proceeding
That concludes
I would like to
our first four questions,
make an announcement.
but
«ne esANIIOUNCEMENt
....,
We
will
continue
with
question
No.
5
and
I
will
call
have
one
question.
on
Mr.
Hyde.
MR.
SHORTER
(COLORADO):
I
just
Mr.
Moore made a statement
that everyone would ewentually be under
86-211.
Do you have any late scoop on that?
Are we going to
do
this
because
the
MR.
MOORE:
I
MR.
but
old
ones
are
going
to
die
off?
What
is
long
time
to
get
the
reaction
SHORTER:
couldnit
You got the reaction.
get the mike.
.I
got
up
MR.
MOORE:
The
MR.
SHORTER:
MR.
HYDE:
No.
that
5:
he
the
story?
waited
a
to
that,
times
only
thing
I
can
suggest
is
here
three
let's
wait
Thank
you,
and
see,
know
under
Section
timely
law
That
Question
a
No.
of
Title
38,
MR. FARMER:
The short
specifically requires
it
the date on which his
qualifying conditions
would
tainly
answer.
done for a veteran who
an automebile or other
USC,
and
therefore
did not
conveyance
did
not
answer to that is no, because the
be filed within the time limit spe-
You have five years after discharge to apply and in
if the qualifying disability arose after service,
he
has had three years
Notwithstanding the
that
VA
5.
Can anything be
was eligible for
1901
typical
apply?
cified.
addition
I
is
time
certainly
limit
like
MR.
to
AKIN:
to file.
And then there is
time limit specified he has
entitlement to
was determined
basis,
like
Mr.
to
see
any
take
a
look
at
it.
Thank
you,
sir.
Akin.
99
final right.
year from
compensation for
in which to file
claim
If
the
one
you
that
have
I am not
at
one of the
a claim.
has
been
I would
cer-
the
moment
familiar
one
denied
on
with where
brought to
that
your
MR.
ZEGLIN:
MR.
HYDE:
question originated
attention.
I
have
Question
three
No.
of
but
I
will
see
that
it
is
them.
6.
No. 6:
Will the VA authorize the cost of nursing care
in behalf of a veteran who is rated 100 percent service- connected for a neuropsychiatric condition to a member of his
family in whose home he is receiving such care?
A.
MR. STRATTON:
Mr. Akin, we
here in this question,
aid and
MR.
AKIN;
No.
are talking
attendance?
about
A.
And
sir.
MR. STRATTON:
You are not talking about aid and attendance.
Are you
talking about the possibility of some future proceedings
in the law under the Department of Medicine and Surgery whereby
some compensation might be paid for people outside the hospital
in the way of nursing care,
intermediate care?
Is that what you
are speaking to?
asked
which
If we
MR. AKIN:
I wish I could answer it but this
by one of the members in my department and I
one.
I will have to try to see him and pass
have a question we will bring it back.
question was
am not sure
it along.
MR. STRATTON:
Let's give it two shots.
I will talk about
A.and A, for a minute and then tomorrow you ask the
same questions of the Medical Panel.
In paying an additional allowance
for aid and attendance to a psychiatric veteran rated 100 percent outside the hospital there, of course,
is no bar whatsoever in the law to paying this additional amount which would
be the staturory L. rate just because the nurse that he contemplates is a member of his family.
There is no bar in this
regard whatsoever.
On the nursing home,
if that is the aspect
that you are
concerned about,
I would suggest that you discuss
that tomorrow.
I know this is a controversial subject right now.
If you would ask the Department of Medicine and Surgery they
could discuss it.
MR. HYDE:
question No. 8.
No.
7
having
been
answered
we
will
jump
to
No. 8:
Records Control Schedule VB-1 and other directives
charge the manager of a VA Regional Office with the responsibility of removing from claims folders for disposal,
duplicate
and unnecessary record material.
What are the qualifications
and training of personnel assigned to the removal of this
material?
When the removed material is ready for disposal,
is
it reviewed by adjudication personnel to assure that ondy material authorized has been removed?
the
MR. STRATTON:
We have Mr. Curtiss that you all know from
Kdministrative Service here and he will answer that question.
MR. CURTISS:
In answering this question,
and it has been
asked by several of the offices,
our TB 20-11 was issued last
July and the subject is "Unnecessary Material in Veterans Records."
It specified the Regional Office Managers are responsible for
100
assuring that employees designated to remove material from
veterans folders are qualified to make that determination,
The
designation of such employees is left entirely to the judgment
of the manager so that he may select the best qualified employees without restriction.
The directive stipulates that
employees delegated to remove material from veterdms folders
will be properly trained.
Again the training is the responsibility of the manager and it is
geared so that he may pick
out and select the employees who can do this best.
The Central
Office directives do not require that all material removed from
veterans
folders
be
reviewed
by
adjudication
personnel
before
it is disposed of.
Certain material is so sharply defined in
the directives and in the Records Control Schedule that it may
properly be removed by adequately trained administrative employees without review by Adjudication Division personnel. Other
material is authorized for disposal only after a responsible
Adjudication Division person has said that it could be removed.
It is not necessaey for adjudication personnel to review all
material in this category, but they may make spot-checks if the
material has been rémmved by trained personnel who have demonstrated their ability to make the proper selection.
In this
‘connection,
and I am sure you are all aware of this,
all of us
are equally concerned with the proper retention of necessary
records.
It is
really a reinstatement of the old policy of the
Veterans Administration and of our department.
We receive,
create, and maintain all records necessary to insure that significant action taken in reference to a claim is adequately
protected and documented.
This safeguard to protect the interests of the claimant and of the agency,
represents the basic
records
management
although of major
basic policy.
policy
of
practical
the
department.
importance,
is
Disposal
secondary
of
to
records,
this
We insist upon adequate documentation,
but we are desirous
that no unnecessary material be filed down and that the record
material of transitory walue be disposed of after the purpose
has been served.
If the material under consideration falls
within the description of records to be disposed of, that action
should be taken by whoever is compdtent and authorized to do so.
If the authority for disposition is questionable,
the decision
must favor retention in the folder.
If there is any doubt about
it we want it left there.
In this connection the VA has a
double responsibility both to the veteran and his dependents
and to the VA.
Disposal instructions will be developed,
coordinated,
and approved with full knowledge of this responsibility.
MR.
staff
CARPER:
would
like
Tonight
to make
Mr.
Golembieski
from
the
Washington
a comment.
MR. GOLEMBIESKI:
I just want to inform you that the
question was propounded because of a discussion that I had had
with Bill Grund of New Jersey.
He was concerned over the calibre,
and training,
and supervision of the personnel that were charged
with the removal of these redundant or surplus records from the
veterans claims folder,
and I see that Bill is getting ready to
rise to the question.
I would appreciate it very«much if you
would speak to it.
MR.
letter to
feel that
WILLIAM
GRUND
(NEW
JERSEY):
Our
manager
wrote
a
the Central Office in regard to this situation.
We
a mere clerk in Administrative certainly isn't quali101
fied to determine what should be taken out of a case folder
and destroyed.
We have had this edperience.
The clerk goes
back, particularly the folders of World War I, and pulls out
duplicate records just because they are duplicate records without reading or making any determination as to whether or not
they have any value.
I think that you will agree with me that
when this was done some years ago Adjudication was the one to
make the determination.
We feel that the Adjudication Division
should be the one to make the determination whether or not
material shall be removed from that folder.
At the present time
all gf the material that has been removed from case folders in
the Newark office has been retained because of the protests
being
made
by
the
Service
am just wondering also,
letter from our manager
from
MR.
the
CURTISS:
Newark
It
office,
Officer
Mr.
has
from
all
organizations.
Chairman, whether or
been answered to the
has.
I
were
might
sent,
say
that
with
I believe,
I
not this
Newark office.
two
the
letter
examples
of
what had been removed and I will read this one paragraph of our
reply.
Part of this letter contains some of the information
I just gave you before.
We have this answer with respect to
the exhibits they sent
in.
"We have examined the copies of materials submitted
with
your letter.
However, we cannot tell definitely the real
advantages
of
documents in
Adjudication
these
papers
the folder.
Officer?"
without
reference
What
the
was
to
other
decision
of
your
I might tell you this:
That this is nothing
new in the
history of the VA.
We have the same interest exactly that you
have.
There are many papers in these folders that can be removed by anyone with any intelligence and a little trainig -copies of the old changes of address and things of that sort.
There are others which are on the border line as to whether
they should or should not be retained.
If there is any doubt
about it, we keep them.
I think in the case of Newark, (and I
might tell you this letter is dated February 16 and I have a
copy here
and will be glad to show it to you if you would like
to
see
the
adjudication
should
it),
we
have
told
the
manager
to
refer
this
material
to
officer.
The two exhibits that were
not have been removed.
sent
in,in
my
personal
opinion,
MR. GRUND:
But this is not going to be found on the spot
check which is being done at the present time.
In other words,
they take this material and just spot check it.
MR. CURTISS:
1It depends entirely on who is doing it, the
training he has had and the confidence the manager and the adjudication officer have in those people.
Frankly, we have had
people in the administrative division that we wouldn't dare
permit to remove materials.
MR.
qualified
GRUND:
to make
We say that a poor clerk
that determination.
certainly
isn't
MR. CURTISS:
The answer to that is that the manager has
to pick people upon whom he can rely and in whom the adjudication officer has some confidence.
102
not
be
(RHODE
BROWNING
MR.
evidence
medical
any
will
there
folder?
the
from
removed
assume
I
Can
ISLAND):
MR. CURTISS:
The material which is to be removed is
listed not in its entirety,
but by examples,
in the TB 20-11,
The type of things we are talking about
issued July 20, 1960.
are these: Duplicate material,
including material specifically
required to be removed by VA directives,
such as duplicates
when the originals are the official copies.We dre talking about
exact duplicates.
We are not talking about copies that have
additional notations on them, but copies which duplicate the
official record copy,
including unnecessary suspense,
control,
and other duplicate copies of letters,
memoranda,
and forms,
copies and photostats of
documents,
unnecessary material which
has
no
reference
value
after
it
has
served
its
purpose
to
trans-
mit and/or to control that for which it was created.
These are
suspense and control copies of forms,
correspondence and
memoramdurs which were prepared solely for the purpose of suspense, pending,
or follow-up and which do not contain notations
of record value, diary cards which have expired,
envelopes,
transmittal media,
including those which are returned as
acknowledgements or receipts and which do not contain notations
of record value.
The key words throughout are 'of record value."
MR.
BROWNING:
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
Mr.
you.
Golembieski
would
like
to
ask
an
additional
question.
MR. GOLEMBIESKI:
Mr.
to the question of removing
non-record material when it
understand
that
in
Curtiss,
I wonder if you would
redundant or transmittal media
is received in the mail room.
in
room
that
the
the
the
mail
letter
adjudicating
of
some
offices
strip
transmittal
and
you
do
have
incoming
then
forward
trained
record
the
speak
or
I
personnel
material
material
from
to
the
unit.
MR. CURTISS:
That is correct,
Ed.
As you know, we have
had considerable discussion about one office where the service
officer complained to the manager,
and I believe to the Washington office here,
that our mail room people were taking off
transmittal memoranda in the mail room and sending the documents with the file to the adjudication officer.
However, we
find from tk manager that he has an agreement with the service
officers.
I omitted one salient thing.
Each of these letters
that is taken off in the mail room is returned to the service
officer.
The service officer
knows what was taken off and he
is at liberty and has on occasion taken up with the manager any
case where in his opinion he felt the transmittal should not
have been so removed.
My
there
recollection
were
four
such
of
cases
it --
and
out
of
this
a
was
great
sometime
number
of
back--
is
transmittal
media.
MR. CORCORAN:
Charlie,
I would like to make a comment
on that point because I think it is terribly important.
It may
be more important than the question raised by the prepared
submission.
We are talking not about deleting from the record
evidence or material that was at one time necessary to document and support some decision,
but now we are discussing
material submitted and screened from the view of the adjudicators
103
and the adjudicating agency before
one, your reference to the service
not
cover
thie
bulk
of
the
people
any decision is made.
Point
organizations obviously does
who
are not
represented
by
a
service organization.
Point two, you say that where there is
a question about the essentiality or the value of the piece of
mail the matter will be taken up with
someone in the adjudicating division,
but you
have to have experience and you have
to have knowledge before a question arises in your mind and I
am not at all sure that the complete interests of the claimants
are being properly safeguarded by permitting persons other than
those trained and experienced in adjudication procedures to
screen out material.
MR. KORELLA (MISSOURI):
I have been wondering whether
the
purpose of removing these papers from the case file is merely a
matter of reducing the size and the space occupancy of the folder.
In that case, if that is true has the VA ever considered
microfilming
sheet rather
the records
than having
and having the
a folder, say,
thick?
I would like to know what
their thoughts on microfilming.
the
record on one-half
four or five inches
measure
is
of
the
VA
and
MR. CURTISS:
I am not able to tell you what the thoughts
are on microfilming,
except to say, for more than a year,
there
has been one or more groups in the VA concerned about doing
something about the folder.
This is one of our expensive expensive records
and certainly the most important.
I at one
time had been a member of such a group.
Microfilming has been
considered.
As of the moment,
so far as I know,
it was not
gone into because of the costs involved and the difficulties
of adjudicating cases on micro film.
I don't know what tomorrow will bring,
but the last report going to the administrator made the statement
that in view of the fast advance in
technology,
microphotography,
and so on, we don't know what
we might do tomorrow.
It is something that is now being considered by the VA.
How actively,
I couldn't say, but it certainly is one of the
things we want to do.
To answer your other question, we have
a dual purpose in keeping unnecessary papers out of the file.
The size of the folder is the major purpose.
Space is the least
one.
It costs money to find the space to put the equipment in,
but above everything else it takes your time, and the adjudicators'
time, and the time of the rating boards,
and the Board
of
Appeals
and
any
to
wade
unnecessary.
paper from a
through
itself
and
if
you
we
be
the
first
will
MR.
HURLEY
a
maze
We haven't
folder that
know
of
of
papers
which
are
irrelevant
the slightest intention of taking
has any
bearing whatever on the case
any
to
agree
(KANSAS
CITY,
instance
where
that
has
with
and
correct
it.
you
MISSOURI,
REGIONAL
been
done,
OFFICE):
I
would like to know what liability the Veterans Administration
recognizes where important pieces of paper have been removed
from the file such as an informal claim.
We submit a transmittal form on the bottom of which is specifies,
"This is submitted as an informal claim for part 3." or part 1, or. .whatever it is,
Two weeks later,
three weeks later, or maybe six
or eight,
it shows up.
We review it again for some reason.
It
comes
to.
the
is in the file
documents were
cation officer
rating
board
six
months
with a date stamp
submitted,
but in
says that so long
104
later
and
there
the
2-22
on it, the same date that both
our regional office the ad judias this other piece of paper has
been apparently thrown away by someone,
they cannot recognize
the date of the informal claim.
All they can recognize is the
date of the 526,
which may be two weeks later or six weeks
later, and consequently,
we have had possibly three or four
cases in the same exact category which the veteran has lost
anywhere from two or three days to six weeks pay.
Would you
recognize that you are responsible for the loss of pay to the
veteran to the extent of recognizing my copy in my office
and my 2-22 with a date stamp of the date that the informal
claim was filed.
That is my specific question.
MR. CURTISS:
That is:-a question: 1 wouldn't attempt to
answer but I will say this much.
If that is being done in the
regional office they had better get a new man.
MR.HURLEY.:
Now that the horse got out we. lock the
We have the situation changed.
But how about these ones
have already lost some money on the basis of your people
ing away vital records?
door.
that
throw-
MR. STRATION:
In the first place,
I certainly agree with
Mr. Curtiss that it should not be done.
The most innocent looking document sometimes
is very important and that is the type
of thing you are talking about.
In the individual case that
you are talking about, do you want my opinion? If I had your
file copy and your certification that you did submit this and
your 2-22 on the same day,
I would take it as an informal claim
whether
they
threw
it
out
of
the
Would
you
notify
MR.
HURLEY:
MR.
take
STRATTON:
I
care of it.
folder
Mr.
or
not.
Halloran
to
that
effect,
sir?
will
will
not
only
notify
Mr.
Halloran;
we
MR. CRIDER (TENNESSEE):
Let me go in a little different
vein,
I guess not so much of keeping something in as still
getting more out.
A paeticular interest of mine for more than
a year,
and the central office has been considering it, but
to what extent I do not know, has been the question of retaining
marriage certificates,
divorce decrees and birth certificates,
where
they
have
served
their
purpose
and
we
have
seen
files
where there has been as many as six marriage certificates
and
they just keep filing them in there.
Social security is a good
example,
where they certify that they have seen this divorce
decree or this marriage certificate and then give it back to the
man.
In other words, VA is the only agency that keeps it.
If
it goes to another agency first,
they certify it and give it
back to him.
If it goes to the VA, first they keep it and then
when he goes to other agencies he has to get another copy.
What has been done along this line, about keeping those out or
making them certify those?
MR. MOORE:
You threw a mickey at me there at the last
point.
I was goihg to say lt may fit in with this.
We are
testing in the Wilkes-Barre office right now a procedure on
what will be retained in the claims folder and active folder.
We have an action folder,
I believe it is called.
This is
being tested.
It goes to what will be retained in the folder
that is
apt to be needed immediately.
Then for a while the inactive material will be kept separately and perhaps ultimately
disposed of.
This is now being tested.
The results are not
yet
known.
This is being done by the group that Mr. Curtiss referred
105
to.
MR. CRIDER:
Herb, does
divorce decrees,
and such?
MR.
MOORE:
All
that
documents
in
include
marriage
claims
folder.
certificates,
MR. €RIDER:
The reason I say that is Russ Turrill came
down to Tennessee a year or so ago and we went to the welfare
department and the social security and the VA and we compared
the three and all three need in most instances approximately
the same information.
The welfare and social security had
that marked on a sheet.
The VA had them stuck in the file and,
as you know, many
of these increase the size of the file tremendously,
and 1f you want to reduce the file there is the
quickest way to reduce the file.
Our veterans and women in
Tennessee marry a lot of times and they get divorces once in a
while.
That is the way as I see it, that we can do more to
reduce the size of those files
than any other thing
right at
this point,
and it causes a hardship to the veteran in many
instances because he has only one copy.
If he ever gets to
the VA first,
then he is going to
have to get another copy for
these other agencies.
give
MR.
CARPER:
time
for
two
MR.
CENTOLA
Because
more
of
the
questions.
(LOUISIANA):
lateness
of
I have
refer
to
the
hour,
back
I
to
will
the
previous speaker, Mr. Curtiss.
First of all, I would like to
correct the record.
There is no agreement,
if he is talking
about my particular department, between the service officer and
the VA down there.
It is
true we are getting those things, but
we are doing it only to protect the veteran.
Secondly,
and the general opinion around here seems:
to be
that the adjudication department seems to be the place where
the removal should be done;
it is not being done and we forwarded five cases where it has been injurious to these veterans
and we would like to know wht it is still being
taken out at
the mail room level.
MR. CURTISS:
As I understand it, in the whole
letters that were sent up here there were four.
Was
talked to the manager, someone
in your office?
MR.
CENTOLA:
That's
MR.
CURTISS:
On
those
question about it they would
they do go back to when they
group of
it you who
right.
we
told
him
that
if
stay in the folder.
are removed?
there
Am
was
I
any
correct
MR. CENTOLA:
They go to the service officer
but we
be doing their work and our work, too. But how about those
gone over by a service organization?
can't
not
MR. CURTISS:
Let's put it this way.
We have 67 regional
offices.
As of right now I know of two from whom we have heard
anything at all on this subject.
One is the New Orleans office
and the other is Newark.
In your case have the exhibits which
were sent in given any indication that what was being removed
the Newark office was wrong.
In the case of the New Orleans
office as to
the exhibits that we saw there was nothing in
them that we could find that would alter the decision down there.
106
They were transmittal
heard this morning on
in adjudication.
media almost
this ADP and
in entirety and I think you
others about the workload
consider
1142
am
talking
about
one
the
MR.
CENTOLA:
Do
you
MR.
letters.
CURTISS:
No.
I
MR.
CENTOLA:
That
was
of
a
transmittal?
the
cases
typewritten
we
sent
up
here.
MR. CURTISS:
That one would have been corrected in that
particular case and again,
it is a question of training.
Don't
forget the adjudication personnel are just as human as any
other personnel.
Whether they are in one division or the other
doesn't affect their judgment.
room
is
MR.
CENTOLA:
and
it
is
Except
disposed
MR. CURTISS:
that correct?
when
you
take
it
away
from
it,
they
are
not
getting
them
at
the
mail
of,
As
I
understand
MR.
CENTOLA:
We
are not
MR.
CURTISS:
You
are
MR.“CENTOLA:
' No,
sir.
this
destroyed;
point.
not?
MR. CARPER:
1 hate to shorten this discussion because I
realize it is important,
but I am going to ask the gentleman in
the rear to give his question and let's hasten along, please.
MR. HENRY(MISSOURI):
Along this liné last year|I believe
it was, instructions came out that they were going to go through
death cases and pick out the permanent information and put it in
a separate folder and hold it in the filing section and then
the original folder would be stored in a separate place down in
the basement or somewhere else.
I just wondered what happened
to that and if there has been any development on it.
in
MR. MOORE:
Wilkes-Barre,
MR.
will
That is the
Pennsylvania
MARKOWITZ:
The
test that
I
right now.
mentioned
is
going
place
could
in
the
best
you
MR. CARPER:
We will proceed with the
ask Mr. Rabern to read the question.
find
question
now
on
world.
and
I
MR. RABERN:
This question was submitted by Reuben Garnett
of Washington.
"On February 11, 1959,
veteran wrote to VA advising he is 47 years old and has just suffered a heart attack and
was ordered by his physician to quit work and 'how was he to
apply for disability pension.'"
He was sent a formal application that was executed and returned to VA on September 8, 1959,
claiming heart attack in 1958
and retired due to disability
January 1959.
He was examined by VA in October 1959
and it was
confirmed that he had sufficient disability to meet the schedular
requirement for a permanent and total rating.
Based on this
information on what date should disability pension commence?"
MR.
FARMER:
This
is
a
loaded
107
question.
I
recognize
it
as
such.
First,
it would be paid, under the facts that have
been recited,
from the date of the informal claim;
that is, the
date the informal claim was received by the VA, namely, February
11, 1959,
That is premised onthe basis that it is a good in=
formal claim and that within one year, namely, by September
8, 1959
a formal claim was filed.
He filed his form 526.
It is
also premised on the fact that he was in fact permanently and
totally disabled throughout that entire period.
MR.
RABERN:
Question
10
comes
from
Virginia.
"Information Bulletin 8-13, Paragraph 9, provides in substance a 0 per cent rating for resection of the right middle
lobe of the lung, whereas the Rating Schedule
provides a 30
per cent rating for removal of either of the remaining lobes.
Since there is some disability resulting from the removal of
the middle lobe, why is there not provided a rating of 10 per
cent or 20 per cent for the removal of the middle lobe?"
MR. STRATTON:
The rating schedule has to be based on the
average loss of earning capacity because of these different
degrees of disability.
This is the mandate we have in the law.
Apparently,
and at this point I don't think we have received
cases to indicate this is wrong,
the best medical opinion at
this time would indicate the average person is not economically
impaired because of the removal of the middle lobe of the right
lung.
This is the only way they could justify the zero per
cent that has been assigned.
Now,
this schedule is constantly being revised,
and let
ne take it more in order.
If you had an individual case that
had nothing but this disability,
and I mean this is your only
problem,
middle lobe,
and in this individual case it is
apparent
to you that he has been economically impaired because of this
we would have the authority in Washington,
if you would document this and send it to us in that unusual case,
to grant an
extra schedular rating.
If we received a sufficient number of
these to indicate that the average loss economically is not
zero, but is ten or 20, or 30 per cent,
then we would immediately
recommend to the Administrator
that he approve the proper percentage,
MR.
RABERN:
Thank
you.
Question number11 is submitted by my colleague, A. V.
Akin from the State of Georgia.
"May a widow continue to draw
increased compensation benefits at the same time the child is
receiving training under the War Orphans'
Educational Program?"
MR.
PECKARSKY:
The
answer
to
that
question
depends
on
the
age and the condition of the child.
Once there has been an
election of Orphans Educational Assistance for a child over the
age of 18, then concurrent benefits cannot be paid, but as long
as the child is under 18 or helpless,
both benefits can be paid.
MR.
RABERN:
'Thank
you.
Question number 12 comes from Illinois.
"It is our understanding that effective July 1, 1961,
retired civil service
employees will be eligible to obtain health
insurance through
the
Government.
to
$6
per
The
month toward
Government,
the
as
premium.
108
we
understand,
Will
the
$3
to
will
pay
$3
$6
paid
by
the Government be considered
service benefits?"
about
MR.
MOORE:
this
and
We
we
talked
found
income
to
that
the
there
for
Civil
are
veterans
drawing
Service
Commission
two
types
of
non-
policies
or insurance plans that the claimants could take.
One would
be where the Government makes a direct contribution of $3 or
$6 and paid this directly to an insurance company.
In another
situation the $3 or $6 could be paid to the claimant who would
pay for his
own plan,
They tell us that in the latter case
they will follow up to be sure that the claimant did pay this
to the company for his own plan.
If they find that he did not,
they will recover the money from him and on the basis of this
information on February 24 we released a teletype to all of
our regional offices telling them that this
$3 or $6 would not
count as income.
tion
MR.
13.
CARPER:
I
will
ask
Mr.
Harms
to
continue
with
ques-
MR. HARMES:
Number 13:
"Is it possible for the VA
do away with the requirement of information pertaining to
employability in cases of veterans over 65
years of age?"
to
un-
MR. FARMER:
“The answer to that is no.
«Section 321 of
Title 38 requires that a veteran in order to be entitled
to
pension,
that is, World War I, iil and Korea, must be permanently and totally disabled,
and there is no exception for
veterans that are over 63.
I think you are all familiar with
TB
21-18
which
makes
the
point
that
the
older
the
veteran
and
the higher the disability,
the less evidence of unemployability
is the rule,
That's the guiding light and certainly,
the
veteran over 65
with only the 10 per cent requirement with
evidence of unemployment
is in that category.
It just occurs
to me that if the TB 21-18 is followed,
the problem would be
minimal in this area.
MR. HARMS:
Number 14:
"Why cannot the VA make the
effective date granted cases considered under VAR 1142 by the
service organizations comparable to the dates assigned when
the case is submitted by the local rating board?!
MR. FARMER:
That is a good one.
As you all know, for
many years when cases were submitted under old VA Regulation
1142, the effective date was the date the CO approved it.
That was regardless of whether it had been submitted by a
service organization or whether it was submitted by the regional
office.
When the Administrator changed the effective date of
VAR 1142 cases to the date evidence shows entitlement or date of
claim, whichever was later, we were in a different situation.
Requests from the service organization are in the nature of
administrative review.
When it gets to the Central Office we
have to examine that case and we might apply
VA Regulation
1105(a)
to
determine
whether
or
not the
regional
office
made
a clear, unmistakable error in failing to submit that case
under what is now known as VA Regulation 1321.
That is old
1142.
If it is determined that the rating board or the regional
office should have submitted that case under that regulation
and that it was a clear and unmistakable error in failing to do
so, then CO will establish the effective date in the same manner
109
as they would have had the regional office submitted it; but,
on the other hand,
if the difference is in the area of opinion
we then have to apply the VA Regulation 1105(b)
which calls
for a prospective effective date;
that is, the date CO makes
the decision,
1t is as simple as that.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
It doesn't sound simple to me.
If a
fellow is entitled to it at the time it gets in your office,
and if you find he should have gotten it in August,
you should
pay him in August,
not in December.
MR.
FARMER:
What
difference between
able doubt,
and we
are
talking
about
1105(a)
and
could spend
we
1105(b),
the day
just as under reasonon that subject.
the
MR. HARMSs
case back to
differs
with
Number 15:
the rating
will
not
the
example
in
We
almost
birth
MR.
read
that
STRATTON:
now
is
the
'Why cannot the adjudicator
board when the veteran's date
considered
by
the
rating
board?"
the
example.
send
of
I
this.
have
to
read
I
have an answer here and now that I have looked at it and read
the example a little better I believe that the answer I have
written here is wrong.
The example that was given was that
the
rating board looks at a case.
They think the man is
over 65.
They don't look at the disability too carefully because he only needs 10 per cent.
At this point I would have to say that they should not
do this, but they go ahead and grant P and T.
This is the
example.
This goes to the adjudicator.
The adjudicator
decides the evidence he has in the file indicates that the man
is under 65.
Now, the example goes on to say that under these
circumstances
it
is
thenrvery
difficult
to
erase
the
of the case by the rating board.
In this case I get
pression that it was allowed first, etc.
I believe,
I know the purpose of the question and can answer it
denial
the imthough,
this way?
If a rating board grants P & T to a man they think is
over 65
and he has only a 10 per cent degree of disability,
if it turns out, and the adjudicator takes it back to them and
shows tham that the man is really under 65,
it is
impossible
for the board at that point to disallow that case. They have
already said that he is unemployable due to his disability
and once they
say that they either have to grant it locally
if he
meets their percentage standards or they have to submit
it in here to Mr. Farmer where the percentage standards have
nothing whatsoever to do with it, so I must say to the gentleman, from Illinogis that I am not as concerned about his example,
that is, the question itself,
as by the implication here that
a rating board
says in one breath that the man is unemployable
due to his disability and then when they find his age is not
quite what they thought it was, they then say he is employable
regardless of his disability.
This to me is wrong and if this
is happening in the region the question originated from, we
will certainly correct it.
MR. CRIDER:
Let me ask you about something in the same
vein, Mr. Stratton.
I have seen the rating boards take a case
and consider a man permanently and totally disabled and date
it from the date he reached 65.
Now,
the evidence was submitted and there has been no change from three or four months
110
before
when
he
filed
his
claim,
but
from
the
date
he
is
65
when
he
from
the
date
he
filed
his
claim.
MR.
STRATION:
MR. CRIDER:
couldn't do it if
That
is
was
they
will
permanent
That
only date
and
happens
it
total,
every
not
day.
right.
In a reverse trend you just said
they went from a different term.
that
they
MR. STRATTON:
Don't let me say anything too wrong here,
Art, but, as I understand,
it ‘is possible to grant that case
locally to get some money to that veteran immediately and pay
it from his 65th
birthday.
They are supposed to, after they
make the award,
send it in to
us to see if we can grant it at
an earlier date.
are
MR.
CRIDER:
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
going
= They
haven't
This
is
in
FARMER:
We knew they
to promise to give it
done
that,
an
that
is
being
printed.
were going
to them.
to
ask
it
IB
for
so
we
MR. STRATTON:
This makes sense to me.
If the man is
pretty close to being 65
and he meets the local percentage requirements and he is unemployable due to disability,
what we
are going to tell them to do is to
pay the man P.and T from
his 65th
birthday locally,
get the money to him, and then
immediately submit the case to us to see if we can't grant it
from
an
earlier
date.
MR. HARMS:
Number 16:
"It is requested that regional
offices be once again instructed concerning their responsibility
in forwarding an employment statement
to the veteran when it is
indicated on the 10-2545
that he might be eligible for a 100
per cent rating.”
MR. STRATTON:
I certainly would hope that rating boards
are doing this.
I would agree immediately with the implication
of the question,
that if a rating board has before them a document, whether it is an examination report or whatever and there
is an
indication medically,
for instance,
and they should look
to that first,
that the man is entitled to an increased rating,
that
is what
the
man
should
get.
If
any
other
aspect
of
that
document including the employment
information that he furnishes
indicates that he can't work because of his disability,
then
the case ought to be developed.
This is a criticism that I
have not heard before.
We have told
our boards to do this, but
on the chance that this is not being done it is so important,
because it is
this total rating that we are seeking here; we
are going to put out an IB
item which will tell them once more
that they have to watch this.
MR. CARPER:
Because of the lateness of the hour we would
like to proceed with the questions and then if you have one you
want to ask a question about at the close, would you please at
that time ask the question?
We will proceed and get to our
questions because we are running way behind.
MR. HONE:
Number 17:
'Would it be possible for the Administrator to bring again to the attention of the Postmaster
General and the postmasters
throughout the United States that VA
111
checks
may
be
forwarded
on
the
basis
of
a change
of
address
with the post affice?
All personnel of the many post offices
should be once again advised of the serious problem that develops
when a benefit check is returned to the Treasury Department
rather than being forwarded to an address on record with the
local post office."
Office
MR.
PECKARSKY:
Department.
We
We
have
are
very good
both
relations
interested
in
with
the
same
the
Post
thing,
which is getting as many checks as possible out to the right
address.
It was brought to our attention at a couple of local
stations that certain local postmasters were not forwarding
mail.
We called this to the attention of the Post Office and
through their regional supervision they corrected this at the
local stations.
Then it occurred to us that possibly there
were other postmasters
throughout
the country that were not
complying with their regulations that they forward mail to
the beneficiary at his new address.
So we again got in touch
with the Post Office Department and late in October -- I think
it
was
around
the
23rd
--
they
published
in
one
of
their
national postal bulletins a directive ordering all postmasters
to comply with their regulation that mail must be forwarded
where the veteran has left a forwarding address.
any
the
We watch this pretty closely.
If we hear any more about
further need of this we will certainly get in touch with
Post Office again, but we have heard no recent complaints.
MR, HONE:
Number 18:
"Why is it not possible for a
guardian of a minor beneficiary to pay the expenses of last
sickness
of his
sation
and
burial
national
benefits
of
a
deceased
veteran
from
the
proceeds
service life insurance policy or death compenthat have been
approved to his minor child?"
MR. PECKARSKY:
There are two things that prevent it.
The
first,
of course,
is that the Federal Exemption Statutes prohibit the use of these gratuitous benefits to pay debts.
Probably,
the most important criterion is the fact that although
the child has a moral obligation to pay for his deceased father's
funeral, he really doesn't have any legal obligation to do so.
There are a few states that do have an enabling statute where,
if there isn't anybody else who can come forward to pay this,
to
avoid
a
pauper's
grave
and
a
burden
to
the
state,
these
few states have enabling statutes which will permit payment
of a limited amount for burial out of the child's estate.
This
is not, however,
true in most states.
In most states the
guardian just would not be empowered by the court that appointed
him to pay a moral and not a legal obligation out of the estate
of thei child.
MR. HONE:
Number 19:
'Why isn't something being done to
alleviate the critical shortage of funds and personnel in DVB
field stations,
especially compensation and pension, where
these shortages are resulting in retarded handling
of claims
due to backlog?"
MR. STRATTON:
I knew we would get to it eventually.
In
the interest, Mr. Chairman,
of the speed that you want to go
at here, 1 am not going to repeat the things that Mr. Driver
mentioned this morning.
I am merely going to say a very few
things.
112
I am
a little
bit
offended
at
the
word
"backlog"
in
the
question as representative of what we were faced with in
September.
I think it is
too stong a term.
I would prefer the
term "horrible mess."
We had at that time over
160,000 cases
in adjudication all over the country.
We are now down to
133,000.
We have cut about 12,000 off during this past month
dueing the peak of the income questionnaire period.
We are
going in the right direction.
We have spent thousands of
dollars in overtime.
There have been many things that have
influenced this backlog.
Most of them Mr. Driver mentioned
this morning.
We are in better shape on income questionnaires
today than we were at this time last
year,
even though we have
a lot of 211's which are rougher than the others.
Again,
I
merely acknowledge that we had the horrible mess and then the
backlog.
We are not out of the woods yet.
As we have to increase
our capacity and our
productivity,
it reflects directly on you
gentlemen.
Then you have to press also,
We would be, as I said,
at about 130,000.
We are aiming for 85,000,
which is where we
were about a year ago.
Eighty-five thousand would represent
about a six-day workload,
not backlog,
not horrible mess.
We are
going to make it, but it is
going to take a little time because
as of the first of March, which is today,
over 100,000 pensioners
who did not send their income questionnaires to us are going to
suddenly realize that their payments have been suspended.
85,000
or 90,000 of those are going to come to us
tomorrow morning and when they do, they are going to file the income questionnaire we are going to have 85
or 90
thousand more cases in
the next three days,
God help us,
to
be
MR. CARTER:
‘a ‘real mess,
MR.
With
officers
that
"No.
20.
Some
years
have
elapsed
been
revised.
When
will
the
MOORE:
Soon!
MR.
CARTER:
I
MR.
service
has
MR.
budget
the
HONE:
Manual M8-5
manual?"
tions.
I
questions
all
want
to
thank
Mr.
failed to
beginning
introduce him.
Mr.
with question 21.
MURPHY:
Question
message
to
Congress
21:
Hone
for
Murphy
''President
mentioned,
VA
under
is
since
issue
those
will
going
VA
a
new
ques-
take
the
Eisenhower's
recent
compensation
and
pension,
‘expenditures for service connected death and disability compensation benefits continue a slow decline from the
1959
peak as compensation rolls are reduced by the death of the
veterans
of
their
widows
or
by
the
transfer
of
many
veterans
to the pension rolls."
Was not a great percentage of the
cline in the compensation benefits due to the reduction in
compensation ratings under the National Authorized Review?
MR.
FARMER:
We
have
to
start
from
the
premise
that
de-
the
review did have an effect on the running awards.
The precise
amount is a little difficult to measure,
but taking the six
years, fiscal 1955
through 1960,
after all the terminations
that were made
in the compensation and pension program,
7.4
per cent of them can be ascribed to the review.
In taking
that figure you have to remember that every case that was
subject to the review which came in routinely,
and we ordered
113
the re-examination on it, was ascribed to the review.
We know
that an unknown number of those cases would have come in any
way and the results would have been the same whether they were
under the review or not, so when I gave you the figure 7.4
per cent,
it really has to be minimized to an
unknown extent,
that is, how many cases would have come in routinely and would
have received terminations.
Yet, we do
report them under the
review.
To answer the question as succunctly as possible:
about 7.4 per cent
MR. MURPHY:
Question 22
from Minnesota:
'In a pension
program based on need, how can you justify denying pension to
a farmer earning $1200 per year, because he had mever earned
more than that, when pension is allowed to a person who retired
voluntarily from employment and whose income is more than the
statutory limits, while his contribution to a retirement fund
is being recouped?
The farmer cannot risk quitting until his
pension is assured.”
MR. FARMER:
Well,
of course, we have to start from the
premise that it is not proper to deny a pension to a farmer
earning $1200 because that is all he ever earned in his life.
If you will remember TB 21-18 has an unequivocal statement "Denial should never be based solely on the fact tgat this type
of farmer never operated his farm on a larger scale."
When
you
get
to
the
question
of
the
amount
of
income,
(out
of
the
employability feature),
the man who is recouping his annuity
does not have his income counted until it is recouped, whereas
the farmer is not subject to that recoupment feature and if I
understand this question,
they are not saying that the man
is denied because his income was excessive,
because obviously
$1200 would not bar him.
They are saying that he was denied
because he never earned more than $1200,
and I am saying that
we have already published a rather clear instruction which
says that isn't a proper basis for denial.
There really are
two different
things mixed up here, one income,
and the other,
the evaluation assigned.
MR.
MURPHY:
Thank
you.
Question 23 from Pennsylvania:
''Manual 8-1,40.07 D,
reveals in part that VA Regulations 2645
and 2973 provide that
where total amount of benefits payable on behalf of a child or
children, who are in the widow's custody, does not exceed $100,
payment will be made to the widow as the legal custodian without reference to the Chief Attorney.
Why cannot the amount be
increased to $300,
thus expediting claims much faster and preventing time-consuming work by adjudication and legal divisions?"
MR. MOORE:
We recently consolidated these two regulations
referred to.
It is now VA Regulation 1850(c)
that has already
been amended to increase the amount from $100 to $200.
There
was some delay in printing it so we released a teletype to the
regional offices announcing this change.
This $200 will permit
payments without appointment of a custodian where there is just
one child's pension payments under 211 for about six months,
and if there are two, for about eight
months.
We think that this
is reasonable and that is double the amount that was permitted
previously.
MR.
MURPHY:
MR.
WEISS
Thank
you
very
much.
A
legal
(Pennsylvania):
114
regulation
was
submitted
to the Legal Division on August 30, 1960.
The Adjudication
Division was not notified of this increase from $100 to $200
until January of this year.
Couldn't
there be more coordination between the legal and adjudication divisions?
that
that
MR. MOORE:
Somebody jumped the gun.
It was
long ago.
There was some delay in printing.
is the reason we released it by teletype.
not approved
As I say,
MR.
thing
they
the
MR.
include
WEISS:
According to the
some time in September.
MOORE:
the
$200.
The
Regulation
In
September
lease
was
ments
MR, WEISS: In addition,
of the guardian such as
not
want
legal
division
1850(c)
1960.
was
I
not
would
received
approved
say
that
to
the
re-
premature.
to
accept
at
small
are you aware that the appointa bank and trust company,
they do
stations
because
of
the
amount
of
work involved in paying this extra clerical work.
The VA
regional office in Wilkes-Barre experienced this fact because
in the smaller states the banks and money agencies don't want
to handle this,
MR. MOORE:
Normally I believe where the widow has custody
of the children we will pay the widow rather than a bank anyway.
That is the usual practice,
so I don't believe the amount here
goes: 10 that point, does it?
rating
MR.
WEISS:
Thank
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
MR.
MURPHY:
you.
Why
don't
Question
24,
"Please explain
board."
the
duties
you
compromise
submitted
of
the
and
from
say
$3007?
Pennsylvania:
medical
member
of
the
MR. STRATTON:
I will tackle it.
I will say the doctor
I used to work with on a rating board out in Wyoming for many
years used to tell me "Stratton,
if you will just leave these
legal questions
to me and concentrate on the medical questions
we will get these cases out a hell of a lot faster."
A medical rating specialist is equally responsible with
the other members of the board for the accuracy of the decision
that is rendered.
At the same time we certainly would expect
him to devote his skill to the end result.
He has to know what
every doctor should know over and above the treatment aspect,
which is of course the most important.
He has to be able to
determine the medical principles
in the case, the reasonable
probabilities in the case medically.
He has to be able to
associate primary conditions with secondary conditions that
originate after service.
He has to know immediately the direct
and perhaps the more complicated contributory cause of the
death,
These things he is responsible for.
These things in
my opinion he is doing in the country today.
We have some very
excellent medical rating specialists and it is of particular
interest to me on my rare visits to offices in talking to some
of
them
and
have taken
beyond the
some
of
these
doctors
to this work that you and I do
medical aspects
of the case.
it
is
rather
striking
and
have
gone
115
how
way
Some
hold
doctors
tbeir
own
with
in
the
some
offices
lawyers
in
that
the
I
have
office
met
on
can
the
almost
regulations
and the different
things that go into ratings.
We are
bettér on recruiting them now.
In the last quarter we
We. got nine.
We are actively recruiting for about six
doing
lost ten.
right
now.
The
but
the
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I find the reverse in the many instances.
doctor does a good job and he also knows the legal aspects,
I resent the fact that lawyers try to be doctors.
That is
point.
MR.
Question
CARTER:
1
will
now
ask
Mr.
Smith
to
continue
with
25.
MR. SMITH:
No. 25
comes from Pennsylvania:
"Too many
disallowances are being made on pension claims where a veteran
has passed his 64th birthday.
He is not employed and in many
instances has been retired for disability.
What can be done
to give this type of veteran a better break on his pension?"
MR. STRATTON:
Of course when you have advanced age
coupled with disability it is much easier in those cases to
prove that those two things have caused a man to be unemployed
and these are the things that are required.
Certainly almost
all of the claimants we get now,
that is, a high percentage of
the ones we get, are well over 64,
In fact, the majority of
them are over 65.
Once the Board has determined,
however,
that he is unemployable due to disabilities where he is less
than 100 per cent under the schedule,
they have no choice but
to either grant it or
send it in to Art Farmer and the rate of
allowance on those 1142cases
that come in here under that
regulation is extremely high,
I think iti/is around 30 per cent.
MR.
ZEGLIN
(Pennsylvania):
I would
like
to
refer
back
to
24.
The reason I put that question in is in many instances regardless of what the medical examiner says, quite pointedly
that his condition is apparently stemming from a serviceconnected condition,
and it is so constructed that there is no
way that the Board could deny this case for service connection,
for example,
a nervous condition is the result of a serviceconnected condition,
the rating board goes on ahead and says
no service connection where the medical examiner specializes
in his field says yes,
this is the result.
That is the reason
I posed that question.
That is being done.
MR.
CARPER:.
Thank
you.
MR. SMITH:
No. 26:
"In resolving service connection
based on field examination of a doctor's medical record,
in
the absence of written records,
the case is usually disallowed,
despite any statement made by the veteran's physician indicating his complete knowledge of the medical aspects of the case.
Please discuss. this."
in
the
MR. STRATTON:
I think that this is part of the
comment you just made,
is it not, Mr. Zeglin?
question
MR, ZEGLIN:
That is right,
1 would just like to pose
one question on that.
Is it necessary that the doctor produce
a record?
I mean should the Board give credence to the doctor's
word?
116
MR.
STRATTON:
MR,
ZEGLIN:
MR.
“Yes,
They
STRATTON:
to
when
he
sir.
don't
They
should
treated
the
word
as
what
you
referred
to.
MR.
ZEGLIN:
1I
MR.
STRATTON:
give
man
credence
to
what
found.
That
Washington,
just
and
he
the
doctor's
is
:
called
a
case
down
to
to
it.
one,
I
would
like
see
MR. ZEGLIN:
It is
along these lines.
A veteran is on
a short form 526
claim for service connection for a mervous
condition.
He is psychotic and needs help.
The doctor says,
"Yes, 1. saw this boy medically,” and it is apparent that he did
because he made claim for a nervous condition before he was
discharged on the short form,
and yet the doctor was unable to
produce a record.
They don't believe him.
It has been disallowed.
MR. STRATTON:
There must have been other things that have
led them to this.
I must say that,
of course,
the best evidence
you can get from the doctor is an actual transcript of his record.
This is the best type
of evidence.
But a statement from
the doctor should be given credence,
even thoughhe cannot produce the official record from his office.
In this case I don't
know.
I would like to see it,
Have you appealed this case?
MR. : ZEGLIN:.
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
ZEGLIN:
Yes,
And
Yes.
1
appedled
they
Of
it.
disallowed
course
you
it?
know
Appeals.
MR. STRATTON:
I do know.
C&P started this and don't be
too harsh on the Board of Veterans Appeals right now because
he wouldn't have had to go there if we had not disallowed it
in the first place, but at this point we probably couldn't
do anything about it if the Board of Veterans Appeals has acted
on it.
However,
I. will be glad to take a look at it.
MR. ZEGLIN:
They have been disallowing every case.
Where the doctor can't lay his hands on the record they will
disallow it.
MR. STRATTON:
I cannot condone this as a general practice.
At the same time,
I cannot deny that it would be very possible
after all of the facts of the case were known and laid before
you that they would differ or they would disagree or they would
perhaps challenge what the file has said, but we make specific
admonishments
in this direction in our regulations where we
have said that a doctor's
statement will not be disregarded
merely because,
et cetera,
et cetera,
and no doubt will be
cast on the case unless there is good reason for it, but here
we get in such a factual situation that we have to sit down
and look at a case together before I could really answer it.
MR. SMITH:
No. 27:
"In severance of service connection
under the National Review,
the medical question involved
is not
actually considered,
especially in cases which involve tropic
117
diseases.
In fact,
there are not too many medical men who, in
our judgment,
are familiar with cases involving disease incurred in tropics.
Please discuss what means of review are
taken when severance in such case is referred to Central Office
byithe local rating. board.”
tell
MR. FARMER:
We bear down pretty heavily on
you that.
Tropical diseases are of course a
restricted
field
of
medicine
and
I can
assure
you
it.
I can
somewhat
that
there
is
not thé slightest hesitancy in submitting cases to the Chief
Medical Director for opinion of his consultants in this area.
We have done
it repeatedly and frankly we haven't seen any
cases that would indicate that that it has not been done where
appropriate.
We have ample facilities in CO.
There is no
barrier at all to submitting such cases and I am a little surprised to see this question come up.
MR. ZEGLIN:
The reason I brought that up is we have a
case of a man that has been severed of service connection.
He
had a diagnosis of cerebral malaria, with the result of hemiplegia,
and after all these years they severed service
connection
because apparently this paralysis,
this hemiplegia,
is not the
result of his malaria,
and we nosed around and it went through
our office.
Of
course
you
concurred
then
with
us have served in the tropics and we
we read a little about it.
There is
sporulation that causes paralysis.
MR.
FARMER:
There
is
a
lawyer
the
know
what
severance.
a little
you call
talking
like
Many
of
about it and
spontaneous
a
doctor,
Mike!
MR. ZEGLIN:
It is our business to know these things, but
I think it is most unfair in cases like this and other severances
too. I have a man where they severed service connection for a
chronic dislocation of his shoulder.
They blame it on an extraeous 8-hour day.
He would have to do some extraneous
labor in
the mill and they said due to that it preexisted service, where
it clearly showed it was a traumatic incident.
I think the
Veterans Administration is just a trifle loose on severing service connection.
MR. FARMER:
pletely but it is
a
proposal
to
sever
I don't expect
true that every
service
you to agree with this comcase that comes in here with
connection
means
that
three
men
are
on the rating board thought it should be severed.
Each case
that comes in here is subjected to painstaking scrutiny before
we say "Yes, go ahead."
Then after that we give them the routine
notice and he also has the right to appeal.
You have really
three distinct echelons,
each one of which is taking a hard look
at these.
Of course on any individual case you and I are going
to aggue about what probative value the-evidence has, but the
only thing we can say at this point is that we try real hard
to make certain that if there are any cases on which there is a
reasonable basis on which service connection can be maintained,
we do ii.
MR. SMITH:
No. 28, the last question,
by Mr. Zeglin:
"The application for benefits by dependent parents is being
denied where a slight margin of income,
above the set requirements,
is indicated.
Why are these cases
disallowed since
118
VAR 1250-B states
that consideration should be
mode of living the parents are accustomed to?"
does
says
given
to
the
MR. PECKARSKY:
One slight inaccuracy.
The Regulation
not say the mode of living they are accustomed to.
It
the reasonable mode of life of the parents.
There is an
element
of
reason.
If
they
have
been
living
at
$100,000
a year
we can't support them at that level.
However,
you are right
in every other aspect.
The dollar figures set in the regulation
are conclusive figures.
If those are met there is no further
question of dependency.
If those are not
met we then look at
all
of
the
other
elements
of
the
case
and
we
look
at
this
reason-
able mode of living in conjunction with where do they live,
in
the city or in
the country,
do they own a home, do they have any °
assets or not,
and all of these other things.
Taken altegether.
if we then find that under an equitable consideration of the case
we can hold dependency we do.
Two years ago, in 1959,
you asked
the same question and got the same answer.
In fact, we said if
you had a case you should send it in and we didn't get any.
In
1960 you let us off.
Maybe somebody needs reminding.
So we would be glad to
reissue this instruction in the form of an information bulletin.
MR. ZEGLIN:
This is the third year I asked this question,
but in regard to this run-down you gave us about we have considered this and we will consider that,
they don't do it.
They
just look at their income,
it is over, and that is it.
Goodbye.
I mean they don't examine into how they have lived or what the
resources are.
1 am particularly interested in one old man.
He
is seventy years old.
He lost two sons in combat.
He is only
two bucks over and that man is aged now.
He has to have somebody
come in and do his laundry,
and cut his grass,
and do this and
do that,
and he is disallowed and it is
not fair.
That is the
reason I keep plugging this thing.
Thank you.
MR.
STRATTON:
Send
that
case
in.
MR. ZEGLIN:
Question 29 deals with contact service and
will be read by me.
"Why has it become necessary,
as we are informed,
to discontinue weekly visits of contact representatives
at state and city hospitals?
Under new procedure,
contact representatives will only visit these hospitals upon request of the
hospital.
It is noted that in the Philadelphia Regional Office
the contact representatives were reduced from 31 to 26
during
the
calendar
ing
considered.
year
of
1958
and
it
seems
that
further
cuts
are be-
"This creates a hardship on the veteran,
as well as the VA
service,
as now we must depend upon unskilled clerks at these
institutions to notify the VA if the veteran is a service connected mental or tubercular case,I would
-appreciate your comment
if it seems to be a general problem or whether it is only a problem of local importance in the Philadelphia aeea.
In other
words,
is this procedure general throughout the country in the
various Regional Offices?"
each
ing
MR. KEITH:
Let me say under
manager is responsible within
service,
particularly
mental patients
regional office
be
rendered
once
to
the
the existing. instructions
budget limitations for render-
State
and
City
hospitals
where
are housed. We feel that the manager of the
is better qualified to say what service should
a
week,
or
that
119
the
need
is
only
once
a
month,
or
that
it
is
on-call
basis.
General
guidelines
to
the
manager
do say that he will render the service in the fashion and in such
frequency as to assure that service is reasonably available to
the veteran patient who is in
a non-VA hospital.
If you have
discussed the matter with your regional office manager and are
not satisfied that service on that basis is being rendered, we
would be happy to take it up with the regional manager for you.
I believe that answers that all right.
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
you,
George.
MR. CHARLES J. KOHLER (Penmsylvania):
I anticipated such
reply and I already contacted the regional manager and he blames
you people.
No. 1, you have said the thing so far, for these
last three days has been the service.
There are no mental beds
available for these types
of patients so what you do is you do
not accept these mental cases, because there are no available
beds.
You send them over to the city hospital.
They are de-
prived
already
of
one
service.
No. 2, there is no contact representative available.
You
do not know how long that man is in that particular hospital.
There is no follow-up.
We have cases sometimes over a period
of six months where a claim is not filed.
There are TB cases in
some of these hospitals
and you are crying for the TB beds, and
in other hospitals they are laying empty,
and I don't know how
many other important items you can stress for the cause of a
service connected patient that could be in a hospital.
We already
had one incident and somebody will have to pay the bill and refer it back to the regional office.
So if the theme is service,
you certainly are retarding your service and the manager said -
"It
is
coming
from
Central
Office,
not
fromime."
MR. KEITH:
I don't want to pass the buck back to the
regional manager since he has handed it to us but let me say
this:
That the fact that service we used to render in your
state involved weekly visits to the hospital does not necessarily
mean that the manager now needs to make weekly visits.
For
example,
if the number of veteran patients admitted to the hospital is increasing, we would expect the manager to re-evaluate
the need and go twice a week,
if the number were increased.
On
the other hand,
if the number were decreased, we would expect
him to re-evaluate the thing and go twice a month.
If the manager has said to you that he does not have the
personnel to render this service,
this is news to us
in Contact
because they haven't asked us for any more people to do it.
We
will be glad to get in touch with him and try to resolve the
question of whether he needs more people or not in order to
render that service.
answer
MR.
to
KOHLER:
I wish
everything.
you
would.
MR.
KEITH:
Be
to
do
it.
MR.
KOHLER:
Thank
very
much.
MR.
CARPER:
We
happy
next
you
come
to
I
think
Question
No.
that
would
be
the
30:
"Please discuss
the VA's Work Measurement Program.
We find
that the personnel of the VA is spending anywhere from twelve to
fifteen percent
of their working time coding,
screening,
and doing
120
the
endless
"The
paper
work
involved
abolishment
of
this
in
this
program
increased production,
especially in
the backlogs are daily mounting."
program.
will
the
definitely
claims
reflect
field, where
MR. STRATTON:
I am going to try to do this very briefly.
Work measurement has the following procedure.
When a case comes
into Adjudication we put a little card inside that case
and we
put a card number down on it as
to what the issue is in that case
and we have numbers for that.
We put down the man's name, C
number,
as. 1 recall,
and the date that it comes in, That's all,
That card stays inside that file throughout the adjudication
process.
It is not a handicap to authorization.
It is not a
handicap to the rating board.
The card is pulled off the
case
when it leaves the division and the issue has been settled.
The
card is filed and at the end of the month, usually by a machine,
those things are counted and the report is very simple.
This is
work
measurement.
We
spend
about
one
minute
per
day
per
case.
I think here what we are talking about really is quality control.
We do require our supervisors to look at a certain number of
cases every day to see whether or not the quality is good or bad.
I would expect that we would continue and extend this because
frankly,
I am more concerned about quality than I am about timeliness.
The third thing is that probably part of this questiom is
surveys.
We have not made any surveys in the past year.
Because of the work load situation we have not wanted to interfere
with the local office.
We plan to revise this type of procedure,
but I would be less than honest with you if I didn't say first
that work measurement
is here to stay and it is
no extra work,
that quality control is here to stay and will be amplified and
extended,
and that surveys in perhaps a modified form will
have
to
be
get
speeded
up.
We
will
this
present
situation
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
have
to
do
more
of
them
as
soon
as
we
concluded.
you.
That concludes the printed questions.
I want to take this
opportunity to thank the members of the VA for their efforts this
morning and this afternoon.
We appreciate their remarks and also
the members of the Panel who have assisted in this presentation
this afternoon.
Do you have one final question?
Is it
very
important?
DR. GORDON PEFLEY (Oregon):
It is in regard to work measurement.
I am wondering about the value of work measurement in the
Department of Social Services where it is being introduced at the
present time.
MR. STRATTON:
The Department of
the Department of Medicine and Surgery
question.
value
had
DR. PEFLEY:
The sort of work measurements there,and
it is, and how it could be justified.
I don't know.
what
MR.
we
they
Bernie
Social Services is under
and I cannot answer your
STRATTON:
will
not
If
find
they
it
have
difficult
the
to
same
experience
that
have
justify.
MR. CARPER:
I want to thank you for your attention and also
Nolan for assistance with this Panel.
Thank you, gentlemen.
121
CHAIRMAN
FOUST:
I
have
two
announcements,
«s+.
Announcements....
please.
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
I want to reiterate the thanks of the
Staff and all of the conferees present,
to members of the
Veterans Administration for their remarks and kind cooperation
this afternoon.
The
meeting
(Whereupon,
stands
adjourned.
at
p.
4:25
m.
122
the
conference
was
adjourned)
THURSDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
. . « The 38th Annual National
of The American Legion reconvened in
Hotel Statler, Washington,
'D. €., at
Booher, Vice Chairman,
presiding.
Rehabilitation Conference
the Congressional Room,
9:07 a. wm. Dr... Ns R.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Good morning.
May we have your attention,
ladies and gentlemen?
It is now seven minutes after nine.
We are seven minutes late, but we are going to start.
The cream
of the crop is here and the rest will just have to come when
they get their breakfast.
If I may,
I believe that our deliberations here might well
be opened by appealing to divine providence for assistance and
I will ask you to stand for the morning devotion by the National
Chaplain,
Reverend Moss of Pulaski,
Tennessee.
REVEREND MOSS:
Again,
our heavenly Father, we bow reverently in Thy Presence.
We come this morning thanking Thee for the
all going work of this Commission.
We thank You for the needs
of men that cause us to
give of our time and service.
We thank
Thee that this world is not complete in every respect.
There are
things that need to be done and we are called of Thee to render
such aid to our beloved comrades.
We pray that throughout this
day that spirit may undergird us and that much good will be done,
and that through it all the bonds of friendship and the tides of
love may make this a great calling,
and a great profession for
us.
In Thy name, we pray, Amen.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I think a pleasant note to begin the
morning with is for you to have called to your attention,
if
you haven't already seen it, that the House Un-American Activities Committee budget was passed to the tune of $331,000
late yesterday afternoon in the House.
this
It
has
been
particular
my
privilege
part
of
the
over
the
years
Rehabilitation
to
preside
Conference
many
at
times and actually I am always reminded of the story of the
young shiek who inherited the old shiek's harem.
Some of his
friends said,
"What are you going to do with it?"
He said,
"It is not a question of what I am going to do with it' it is
just a question of where to start."
I
am
going
to
do
a little
I may, with Dr. Middleton's and
like to introduce to you first,
on this morning's panel and the
will go to Dr. Middleton and his
As
chairman
of
the
panel
differently
this
morning,
if
his staff's permission.
I would
The American Legion representatives
staff helping them, and then we
staff.
today,
we
have
the
Department
Rehabilitation Chairman of the Department of Georgia, A. V.
Akin, Jr., and on his panel with him Maynard R. Young, Department Service Officer, Department of Vermont; Charles L. Michael,
Department Service Officer, Maryland;
Frank C. Bottigliero,
from our good Department
of Illinois; Director of Rehabilitation;
and finally,
that guy with the good Yankee name, Reuben B.
Garnett
like
of Washington.’
For
those
very
few
you
to
our
Chief
know
of
you
who
Medical
123
do
not
know
Consultant,
him,
Dr.
I would
Irving
Brick,
who
Dr.
is so helpful
Brick.
in
all
of
these
things
in
rehabilitation.
:
By the way, before I go any further, back here in the
back of the program there are a few places.
I hope you have
some paper to write on out there.
We don't have too many
written questions,
but knowing this panel from years past,
that does not mean a thing, Dr. Middleton.
I would like for
you to write questions that you have on your mind and get
them
up
to
the
table.
That
little more orderly
pass these along to
your questions,
and
audience as soon as
that are printed in
serves
two
purposes.
It
gives
us
a
procedure.
It also gives us a chance to
the VA experts that are here to answer
we will take up the question from the
we have finished the discussion of those
your program and in your hand.
Without further talk, on my part, I would like to bring
to the microphone at this time for I don't know how many years
it is now, but a very pleasant number,
the Chief Medical
Director of the Veterans Administration,
Dr. Middleton, who will
have a message for us and then in turn will introduce his people.
Dr. Middleton,
ADDRESS OF DR. WILLIAM S. MIDDLETON,
CHIEF
MEDICAL DIRECTOR, VETERANS ADMINISTRATION
DR. MIDDLETON:
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Aikin,
ladies and gentlemen, friends, Dr. Brick,
the opportunity to meet with you again,
my sixth year completed and this is the seventh appearance,
is
a welcome one.
Obviously,
the stewardship of the medical program of the Veterans Administration is a serious one and one
which we will periodically give an accounting of to any responsible American citizen.
As the representatives of The American
Legion deeply interested in the welfare of the American veteran,
you certainly have first call on any information,
any programs,
any progress that we may report.
Therefore,
it is with a warm feeling of responsiveness
on your part that I address myself to the progress of the past
year.
This has been a year in which there have been very
material developments
in the area of operations. The bringing
of the Area Medical Directors into line has meant a complete
change of the philosophy of the functions of this particular
element in our organizational pattern.
Under the old design
of the Gray Modification of the Booz-Allen-Hamilton recommendations they were really the watch-dogs of the Central Office,
reporting to the Central Office the effect of such policies,
such programs as outlined in the Central Office, or perhaps
even initiated from the area, but in the last analysis they
were not in line.
They had certain responsibilities without authority,
the anomalous condition that has been remedied,
first, starting October 1, 1959,
by putting the St. Louis
into
line
and
the
remaining
area
six
areas
into
line.
no
feeling
on
There
is
lst
of July,
the
part
1960,
of
putting
any
member
all
of
of
the
the
Central Office staff that there is omniscience in their numbers.
If there were such an individual,
I would like to single
him out and take him behind the woodshed.
We do not feel
that part.
Accordingly,
to attempt to organize,
to attempt to
operate,
under the 170 hospitals,
91 clinics,
and 18 domiciliaries from a central point without delegation of control
to areas was in our judgment an entirely fallacious approach.
124
With the areas in line,
there has been, of course, granted to
them the control of funds, and the purse strings are in the
last analysis the controlling element in the operation of the
field.
I
would
have
it
perfectly
clear
to
each
and
every
one
of
you here that Central Office does not hold a cushion of sums
that are available on call to relieve the weakened member in
the field.
These sums are all divided among the seven Area
Medical Directors.
With appropriate backing in personnel they
are able to control the operation of the field stations on a
very intimate level with ability to relieve minor pressures
and ability to control overages in other stations.
This is,
of course, fundamentally sound from an operational standpoint,
and it means that we are able,
through channels of communication
from the stations in the field to the area to Assistant Chief
Medical Director For Operation, Dr. Zink,
and then ultimately
to the Chief Medical Director,
better to control this total
operation.
It has been successful procedure to the present
time,
We ask for further experience before we can give a
final
reading
pattern,
on
this
rather
drastic
change
in
our
operational
By the same token, we have attempted to consolidate our
advantage in the field from a professional standpoint in the
marriage of the Out-Patient Clinic to the hospital.
This has
been the subject of consideration discussion by our own representatives and by individual veterans. Detroit-Dearborn consolidation has just been effected and two more are in progress,
namely, Kansas City and Hartford-Newington.
May I indicate
at the outset this is not a movement in the interest of economy.
There is not a prevailing thought of saving of a dollar.
It
is a movement in the interest of the better utilization of our
professional skills.
At this moment,
if there were any suggestions that this did not improve the care of the American Veteran,
I will tell you that the entire program would be scuttled, but
the real circumstance of concern to us is the deterioration of
medical service that will attend the aging staff in our detached clinics. Only by bringing these elements into the atmosphere of an active hospital program where they may follow
the profession of medicine,
where they may follow their patients
actually in person as they are admitted to the hospital,
as
they may participate in the educational programs and the actual
professional activities of the hospital,
can we hope to bring
rejuvenation to this very vital program.
The out-patient clinic constitutes the outguard,
the
actual outpost,
of our medical program.
We have the front line
in our hospitals,
it is true, but there is no medicine practices
at the Area Office,
or in the Central Office.
As a matter of
fact, we do not know how sick we are in the Central Office.
This,
I am saying lightly,
but what I am indicating is that this
entire system depends on integrity of the field stations.
I have said seriously to the central administrators that we
could abolish the Central Office.
We could actually get on
without Area Office in a technical sense, because the real work
is done in the field.
It is our desire to make these out-patient
clinics as strong as possible by the consolidation of our professional staffs.
We have had the tremendous advantage of the
letter
the
was
of
February
ceiling
granted
of
to
26,
1959
from
President
Eisenhower
fixing
125,000
beds.
Within that ceiling full latitude
the Administrator
to distribute beds according
125
to geographic need and to the functional requirement.
This,
of course,
is a very forward movement because, for this group
there has been given now a latitude,
a freedom of action,
that
has never existed before February 26, 1959.
The Administrator,
Mr. Gleason,
at the present time,
can distribute beds, wards,
buildings and actual hospitals according to the geographic
needs and to the diagnostic constituency of these patients in
such hospitals.
This means that he can move beds according to
the need.
He can move actual hospitals according to need.
Under
these
terms,
we
have
previously
outlined
to
you,
the
circumstances of growing pressure in the '50's,
there moved a
total population of 1,600,000 into Florida.
In the 1950's,
there moved into California 5,800,000.
There are also pressure
points in southern Texas,
in New Orleans,
in St. Louis,
and
particularly in the psychiatric requirement about New York.
This is a circumstance of immediate need for action and it has
been taken effectively in Florida.
Time only is denied us.
It
is part of the planning for the other areas mentioned,
but
keep sharply in focus the figure that I gave you in California,
because it is
pertinent to our discussion.
In the geographic movement
there is, of course,
the
change in the diagnostic constituency of our patient population.
1954
was the peak of demand for TB beds, approximating 16,000.
We have fallen below to 8,500.
We therefore have here a cushion
of beds that will be absorbed in other directions.
It has been
our privilege to change the designation of eight of our tuberculosis hospitals to GMS hospitals.
We have given up two
of our TB hospitals,
Waukesha,oWisconsin, andi-Kennedy General in
Memphis,
Tennessee,
and have consolidated those beds elsewhere.
I cite these experiences to indicate that we do now have the
capacity and the authority to move according to geographic and
functional needs.
With regard to the construction program familiar to all of
you, the tremendous gain under Mr. Whittier,
the $75
million
program of construction for 12 years,
the $900 million he has
reported to you before.
Of course it continues to be dependent
upon the action of Congress each year and the $75
million of the
current year is being appropriately expended for new construction.
I say new construction advisedly,
because actually of new hospitals there is only one, and that is Brecksville,
that will unquestionably be dedicated in September this year, completing the
original program of post-World War II construction;
but replacements are now under construction at Martinez, Jackson and
at
Nashville.
one in
put out
school
The
program
goes
locally
for the
the end
particularly interested we hope
replacement of Mount Alto girls
of June,
1961.
which we are
to contract
hospital,
by
forward
regularly.
The
first
to
We have a prospect of tremendous development
and of substantial growth.
It is not one of these flash-in-the-pan movements, but by reason of geographic study of needs and by reason
of the assessment of our physical properties, we have been able
to come up with clearer planning and with definite design for
the future.
As we turn to the real mission of the Department of Medicine and Surgery,
it involves patients and, obviously,
in this
direction already indicated
we can take care of more patients
by
reason
efforts to
reason for
of
the
gain
improve the
considering
in
the
field
of
TB.
We
have
care of the mentally ill.
the aging population,
and
126
studied
We have cogent
in this respect
I should like to direct your attention to one of the most important movements now under consideration and that is the
reconstitution of the design for the domiciliaries.
This,
is. still
in the planning.
With the assistance of the Policy and Evaluation
Staff of the Administrator,
the entire program of domiciliaries
has been reviewed.
As you recall, we have 18 domiciliaries and
of those 18 domiciliaries plants only two, if there were replacement under the present terms of reference of the physical plant,
Dublin, Georgia,
and Bonham,
Texas,
are in modern structures
that would not need modernization or replacement.
The other 16
would.
To accomplish this end under the present terms of reference would require approximately $181 million.
It is time then,
since some of these go back to the 1860's and early 1870's,
that
this entire situation be reviewed,
first,
as to
the responsibility
of the Federal Government,
and second,
as to how best to resolve
this problem.
Into this picture comes the very sharp relief of
Resolution 25
from The American Legion,
that suggested the development
of
convalescent
centers.
Under the present thinking we are attempting to resolve
our approach into the social responsibility and the medical
responsibility.
The social aspect can be taken over by other
elements gradually by very carefully devised methods of transtion.
There will be no crash program,
no idea of a sudden
movement of responsibility for now approximately 17,000 veteran
members.
These veteran members have certain call upon our interests,
certain call upon our care that cannot be discharged
fiat,
Accordingly,
of
developing
convalescent
there
is
Restoration
cottage
or
a design
Centers
center
of
off
on
replace
the
idea
Resolution
25,
In
to
to
start
a program
of
the
substance
these restoration centers of 150,
not to exceed 250
bed units
attached to General Medical and Surgery Hospitals to avoid no
dilution of medical care and will receive patients only in
transfer from the hospitals.
There, patients must have
a prospect of a definite gain, where there is definitely projection
for their restoration to society.
Now, I am speaking of physical,
sociologic,
and psychologic rehabilitation.
Under these
terms these will not be-@ead-end houses.
These will not be
centers to which patients are admitted in terminal illness,
where there is no prospect of restoration.
If we have this
objective clearly in mind, we are going to afford a cushion for
the added care of the American veterans.
We are going to better
testore
these
patients
to
health
and
self-sufficiency.
an entirely new approach and it will require study,
will not eliminate our domiciliary program at once,
maintain a certain number of the larger ones over a
years.
This
is
study that
but will
period of
We do not know the number of years actually,
because this
is entirely a new experience.
This will be a matter of careful
study,
initiated first in a pilot plantat Hines.
The plans
are already afoot and before the end of this fiscal year, June
30, we should have this plant under way at Hines.
Other trial
runs will be made and then gradually going into this program,
we hope to transform the now unsatisfactory domiciliary program into a revitalized Restoration Center program with responsibility for the medical care.
The social aspect would be
referred to the state,
the community and individual with
appropriate subsidy from the Federal Government.
That in brief
is a very broad,
and we think,
a very constructive approach to
27
the
situation.
"At the last session of Congress there was passed a bill
affording pre-hospital examination and post-hospital care to
non-service connected veterans.
This is an exceedingly important element in extending the usefulness of our beds, but
there are two sides to this particular point.
I have been quite
amazed to find certain of our hospital staff members saying,
"But we do not have a problem.
There is no waiting list.”
This,
folks,
ignores
the
other
side
of
the
coin.
If
I have
a hernia
and require surgery,
I would be in the hospital for three days
before surgery can be performed.
As you know, under these new
terms that three days could be gained if the patient were, as
in
civilian
practice,
given
those
tests
before
he
comes
into
the hospital.
We would like to improve our record on the
length of hospital stay.
This is one direction,
and at the
terminal period as to
discharge,
he may be discharged with the
request that he come back in a week or three weeks for the
surgeon to investigate his handiwork.
There is the other side
of this coin.
That patient will in that period be relieved
from hospital care before he comes .in and after he leaves, he
will be able to pursue his ordinary activities.
This,
I feel
is an exceedingly important advantage.
Our research program has grown from $5
million in 1955
to
$21,500,000
now.
The prospect for some amendment to that in
the present bill before Congress is indeed encouraging,
but we
are not
interested in overwhelming financial responsibilities
here.
We have the mandate of Congress that our research will
be directed toward problems affecting the health and welfare
of veterans.
We are following that mandate very closely and
I can assure you that we can give not only the sound account-
ing
im~the
field
of
the
treatment
of
TB
which
is
internationally
acclaimed,
but also in many other areas.
We have the unexcelled
opportunity for cooperative studies,
this fixed population that
enables us to keep our controls better than in any other segment
of the American public.
There is afoot a study in Boston that
involves these octogenarian veterans of the Spanish-American War,
and we find that the insurance companies are intensely interested.
We know that we have a very important part to play in the health
of
the
general
American
companiegrexpress
a
public,
tremendous
We .have
interest
found
that: theiinsurance
in
Boston
the
study.
Those
of you who know businessmen and how hard-headed they can
be in such matters, will agree with me that this is not entirely
an altruistic interest.
They want to know whom they should
insure and who will be the better risk.
I was interested to find
that
many
of
these
figures
were
figures
physically,
like
Winston
Churchill,
which gave me some heart that my pyknic constitution
was not going to shorten my years.
What I am driving at, ladies
and gentlemen,
is that there is no area of our research within
the Veterans Administration that does not affect the entire
American,
and indeed the entire civilized population of the world.
to
the
These
are
mundane
matters
detail
of
of
tremendous
budget.
May
concern
I
say
and
very
I
come
briefly
lastly
that
the budget for the Department of Medicine and Surgery now before
the House Subcommittee on Appropriations
is a very sound budget.
We have indicated the construction and the grain in research.
There is a gain in education of $519,000,
if it is approved,
and
remember that all these figures I am giving you relative to the
budget now before Congress are public information,
but they are
not
fixed
figures
because
action
128
has
not
been
taken
on
the
budget.
I would like to say that we are in a very healthy state in this
budget so far as in-patient care is concerned.
Improved staffing is assured if this bill goes through as it stands.
The outpatient is receiving bet¢er attention,
so that by and large it
is a very constructive and a very healthy budget for the care of
the American veteran,
the sick or disabled.
Thank you very much.
Then, if I may, introduce the folks who really do the work
in Central Office, we have Mr. Pauls who was in the chair next
to me a moment ago, but Mr. Pauls is interested in the Automatic
Data Processing.
We have a very definite interest and stake
in this area.
We hope to work out our problems before these
matters are brought into operation in the field.
Then, Dr. Arnett,
of course,
is in professional services;
Mr. Bowers is in operation; Dr. Zink in operations;
Dr. Cohen
in professional services;
Dr. Fauber, denistry, Dr. Casey,
psychiatry;
Miss Hauge, Chief of Nursing;
and Dr. Timm in
operations.
Hiding behind him is Dr. Blasko;
then Jim Parke, of course,
in voluntary service and his right bower, Pete Miller;
completes
our quota.
There are folks still working over in the Department
of Medicine and Surgery, but Norm Booher insisted that we had cut
down on him.
He said, "You usually give me 40 and now you have
20."
We do not have quite that quota.
There was a request from
Mr. Corcoran that we afford you some report of what is being
done in Automatic Data Processing in the Department of Medicine
and Surgery.
I have asked Mr. Pauls to present this particular
subject.
I would like to indicate that the Department of Medicine
and Surgery suffered a tremendous blow in the sudden death of
Dr. Milton Schwalbe, who had headed this particular effort and
who died in Union Station while hurrying to catch a train to go
to the West Coast, but Mr. Pauls will present our interest in
the field of Automatic Data Processing.
Mr. Pauls.
MR. PAULS:
Thank you doctor.
Mr. Chairman,
distinguished
members of the panel, members of DM&S staff, kind distinguished
guests,
I am sure you have heard much and read much about data
processing,
the emphasis that it has been receiving within the
Veterans Administration,
the Department of Veterans!
Benefits,
the Department of Insurance,
and very probably you have heard
rumors and tales of what is going on in the Department of Medicine
and Surgery.
While we have only had a staff formally established with
a planed program and policy in regard to data processing for
a relatively short period of time, one year to be exact.
1
think just a few words to bring your attention and ours to the
fact that the Department of Medicine and Surgery,
of course,
has been engaged in data processing activities for quite some
time, perhaps not to the degree of the other departments and
other governmental agencies.
In speaking of data processing within the Department, we
consider not only electronic data processing techniques and the
use of electronic equipment,
computers and other electronic
devices,
but we also consider the mechanized system,
the use
of punch cards and tabulating equipment,
and also within the
data
processing
plan
all systems, methods,
related and referable
and
program
of
the
department,
we
and techniques,
and applications
to data processing techniques.
129
consider
that
are
In
supply
this
regard,
operation
we
within
have
the
had
a
very
department
highly
and
mechanized
the
agency
for
many
years.
We have also, of course, been using mechanical equipment to handle many of the statistics and operational programs
of the out-patient program within the department.
We, of course,
use mechanized equipment for our
statistical applications in
central office.
Some of our personnel statistics are derived
through
the
use
of
mechanized
equipment
and
some
of
our
fiscal
applications.
The department has been using mechanized equipment for many years, for biometric purposes and administrative
reports and analyses.
In addition to this,
in medical activities,
from the
standpoint of clinical medicine and medical research many activities have been
going on at the field station level.
The vast
ma jority of these activities have been related directly to specific clinical and medical research projects and the work that
has been done has been done by the individuals concerned in
developing, perhaps building,
or finding electronic means to
conduct medical research projects
and to examine uses to which
electronics could be applied in the field of clinical medicine.
Early in 1958
the Department of Medicine and Surgery conducted a feasibility study.
This was aimed at determining to
what use we could put computers in particular,
but also other
electronic equipment - this new equipment within the Department
of Medicine and Surgery,
to aid us in
three principal areas,
and they are the
three principal areas of activity in which
any medical organization generally is engaged.
This is administration or administrative management,
as you may call it,
clinical medicine,
and medical research and education.
A small staff
devoted
a period
of
about
one
year
to
the
study of possible application,
ending up in a recommendation as
to what could be a feasible application of electronic data
processing equipment within the Department of Medicine and
Surgery.
Because,
in the conduct of this study we were asked
to consider in the administrative areas the needs and requirements of the other departments and the agency as a whole in
the fields of administration,
the
recommendation that emanated
from the department was necessarily one of rather large scope.
Since
it
affected
the
other
departments
and
the
whole in the administrative areas,
the agency
a much closer look at the recommendations and
needs of the agency.
agency
as
a
decided to take
the probable
This latter study was conducted in a period of about six
months.
Following that study,
the data processing staff within
the department was established with two major responsibilities,
one in the area of administration,
which considers the development and design of systems in what we call common service areas;
and these are in the major program areas of fiscal management,
supply management, pay administration with related personnel,
and medical and administrative operations.
The second and the other major interest of the department
are those things which are inherent in the department's own
program,
specifically those areas of interest which are directly related to our patient care and treatment program. The department then,
since January a year ago, has been engaged in the
development of the systems within the administrative areas.
We are supplemented by members of the key staff offices within
130
the agency and we
ment of Veterans'
maintain
Benefits
close coordination with the Departand Department of Insurance.
As of this moment,
there are perhaps ten people who have
programmed a payroll application considering the nationwide
personnel strength of the agency.
Integrated with this payroll
administrative application are personnel statistics.
Also
integrated in this application are fiscal accounting,
budgetary
considerations,
and cost distribution factors.
Our desire here
is to build an efficient and effective system to enable us within the department and the agency as a whole to relate dollars
to functional cost,
to operational activity,
and to personnel.
In addition to this, we have started an interim phase
of mechanization in the fiscal areas within the department.
To this extent, we have embarked on an installation program of
punch card equipment within hospitals to first, handle our
fiscal activities,
that is, fiscal accounting,
payroll within
hospitals,
and cost distribution.
This program has first
priority within the hospital.
Following this, other programs
will be mechanized within the hospital.
These will be in the
area of medical administration,
within supply and within the
capability of equipment to handle certain medical research
interests,
and certain other administrative activities.
By the end of this fiscal year,
approximately 40 of our
hospitals will have installed mechanized equipment which will
be in operation in one or more of these areas.
In the area
of supply management, while we are attempting to develop and
design an over-all supply management application for computer
technology, we are also interested in reviewing the total
supply management picture within the department.
To this end,
we now have in test at several stations a very simplified
supply system designed to reduce paper work,
to more effectively
determine cost,
and to get supplies from the depot to the hospi-
tal
and
into
the
hands
of
the
users
more
efficiently.
The project which happens has particular interest to us
within the department is a special project that is being worked
on at this time and is related to a national cooperative cancer
and results study.
This particular project, of which the Department of Medicine and Surgery is only a participant, perhaps a
major participant,
but only one of several,
is designed to
analyze and examine data regarding cancer cases at a certain
cut-off period.
Today it has been determined that at the expiration of
five years of a follow-up study,
one may examine the data,
determine prognosis on cancer cases,
and perhaps evaluate certain factors. The reason we are considering an electronic application for the cancer case study is that the volume of data has
become so great and the complexity with which the data must be
updated following a patient's admission,
treatment and disposition has become so voluminous that it can no longer be handled
with ordinary mechanical equipment.
We are endeavoring to construct a magnetic tape computer application for this cancer data
so that by the expiration of five years, we will be able to
analyze and evaluate certain of this data.
In addition to these things,
the department's primary
concern is how can we help the individual hospital,
the individual themselves and the individual staffs within hospitals,
131
to better perform their jobs.
We feel that the best approach
to this problem is to work within the field station environment, and as the first phase of this approach to do certain
research and development work which will evaluate needs of the
administrative elements of the hospital,
the clinical medical
elements,
the physicians,
the nurses,
the supporting staffs,
and the
medical research groups within individual hospitals.
To this end, we have embarked on, as I said,
a research and
development effort in conjunction with a research and development organization.
This very briefly covers the activities
to date, again much of which are in the development stage.
Thank you.
DR.
MIDDLETON:
CHAIRMAN
Thank
BOOHER:
I
ss
you
want
very
to
much
make
one
o+Announcement
i. .
announcement,
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I would like to now get to the thing
that is always of the greatest interest to this particular
part of our Conference,
the questions and answers.
I hope
that you have been writing some out there in the audience,
and
will send them up to us, but in order to start the ball rolling,
we will go to those on page 16 in your program that have been
handed in in advance,
as we asked you to do.
turn
will
To carry on the Dall for us on this phase of it, IT will
it over to Mr. Akin
of the Department of Georgia.
He
carry on.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
It is always a
pleasure to have an opportunity to serve with Dr. Middleton and
his staff.
I thought we were going to keep this particular
panel clean and almost before they started they began talking
about ADP, and in Georgia that is a dirty word.
We are going
to call on our good friend from Vermont, Mr. Maynard R. Young,
the Department Service Officer,
to lead off with the first
question.
MR. YOUNG:
Thank you, Mr. Akin.
The first three questions directed to this panel were submitted by the illustrious
gentleman from Georgia who is presently chairing the panel, Mr.
Akin.
and
is
Question Number one.
When a veteran becomes
acutely
taken to a charity ward of a civilian hospital,
why
the
emergency
VA
hospital?
DR.
in
his
case
cease
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers?
for
purposes
of
admission
ill
does
to
a
MR. BOWERS:
I believe we discussed this question two
years ago.
We apparently were not successful,
but we will try
again.
Priorities for admission to VA hospitals
are predicated
on the entitlement of the veteran to such care under the law.
However,
our regulations provide that emergencies will be
accepted ahead of any non-emergent applicants,
including the
service connected.
The reason is obvious -- and delay in hospitalization in an emergency may well endanger life.
However,
when the veteran has been hospitalized in a non-VA hospital,
he is receiving the emergency medical care which he requires.
For the purpose of hospital admission,
there is, then no
132
medical emergency and we cannot accord the veteran emergency
priority based on medical need even though there may exist an
emergent economic situation.
If the applicant is hospitalized
in a non-VA hospital,
he is then considered for priority purposes in accordance with his basic legal entitlement generally
in the urgent category.
To do
otherwise,
would be unfair to
the many other veterans hospitalized in non-VA hospitals who
have requested admission
to a VA hospital.
MR.
YOUNG:
Next
question.
the new 750-bed
GMS VA hospital
as to insure its opening by not
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Could
the
in Atlanta
later than
construction
be speeded
January 1,
of
up so
1963?
Arnett?
DR. ARNETT:
Mr. Akin,
I think there was a little program
propaganda to this because the last time you and I talked we
acknowledge it was a 580-bed
hospital.
The new GM&S hospital
at Atlanta will be a 580-bed
GM&S hospital.
The present
scheduling calls for its completion by late 1964 or early. 1963,
The Veterans Administration has requested technical services
(money for architects'
fee) dueing the fiscal year 1962.
It
requires approximately nine months for the blue prints to be
completed by the architect.
Following this, there is a 2 to
2-1/2 year period necessary for construction.
If there are
any delays due to strikes or shortages of materials further
delays could occur.
The hospital planning is being reviewed
by one of the country's best hospital consultants
and will
have the latest advancements
incorporated in its structure. No
earlier date than mentioned above can be assured.
Shall I
answer this other question, Mr. Akin?
MR.
better
MARKOWITZ
talk
to
the
(PENNSYLVANIA):
President.
He
May
says
he
I
comment
wants
to
here?
You
speed
up
everything in that deal because it is economic.
I just want
to help my friend from Georgia.
I think you have a point,
Mr. Chairman,
and I think that Dr. Arnett ought to take into
consideration,
and everybody ought to take into consideration
the problem that the President is posing to everybody in the
United States,
speed up all kinds of construction,
speed up
all kinds of things that can be accomplished faster than have
been planned,
and I believe if you do that you would get your
hospital in 1962, not in 1963.
MR. AKIN:
Please state your name when you come to the
mike and your department.
I believe that the questions being
submitted from the floor we will hold so that the VA people
can have plenty of time to study them.
We don't want them to
make any slips.
We want them to have every benefit of time
and we are going to hold the questions submitted from the floor
until
the
prepared
questions
are
answered.
Dr.
Arnett,
1
want to say this to you.
We said 750.
You say 580.
You
cannot blame us for trying. The next question will be taken
by Charles L. Michael,
from Maryland,
the Department Service
Officer.
MR. MICHAEL:
Question number three.
A veteran who is
service connected for multiple arthritis had all his teeth
removed by the VA Dental Service and dentures were furnished.
These dentures are now ill-fitting and he cannot properly
masticate his food.
May the VA provide him with new dentures
now?
Does the nature of the veteran's service connected
133
condition (stomach
this regard?
DR.
%Yilcer,
MIDDLETON:
for
Dr.
example)
make
any
difference
in
Fauber?
DR. FAUBER:
For the condition of multiple arthritis I
would say no, unless the physician treating this serviceconnected multiple arthritis prescribes new dentures for this
veteran,
This situation holds in practically every physical
service connected disability that exists.
If in the opinion
of the physician treating this veteran,
that veteran requires
some dentistry,
regardless of what the nature of that dentistry
be, whether it be filligs,
dentures,
bridges or what not,
if
this physician feels that the prescribing of this dental treatment will aid and assist in the treatment of this physical
service connected,
them it can be done.
As a matter of fact,
this is not a dental service determination.
This is a medical
determination.
Brooks
MR.
of
MICHAEL:
Ohio.
Question
Please
number
discuss
the
four,
reasons
submitted
for
by
Fred
long.delays
in
out-patient
treatment authorizations
in cases where the outpatient clinic is divorced from the regional office as in
Cincinnati,
Ohio.
Where there is no established treatment
folder on file, we find that the average period of time between
date of a veteran's application for treatment and date he is
called for examination to determine need for treatment is
approximately one and a half months.
We acknowledge that reimbursement may be made under certain circumstances for unauthorized emergency treatment,
but we have seen many cases
where such treatment was given by private physicians without
subsequent approval by the VA of a claim for reimbursement.
In
many instances,
the fault lies with the private physician
who undertook to give treatment too quickly, or who refused to
complete an adequate report within the time limitation.
In many other cases,
the veteran seeks private care during the long delay and when finally called by the VA is told
that no treatment is indicated.
We feel that return of the
clinics to the regional office jurisdiction would materially
reduce the delay between application and treatment,
and thereby minimize the problems referred to above.
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Zink.
DR. ZINK:
We know, of course,
that delays occur when a
veteran applies for out-patient treatment and no treatment
folder is in existence at the clinic.
Usually it is
necessary
to request a rating from Adjudication in these instances.
As
soon as the adjudicative decision is made,
action is taken to
authorize medical service to which the veteran is entitled.
The delays involved in these cases are directly attributable
to the time required to adjudicate the claim for service connection.
Therefore,
whether the out-patient clinic is located
at a regional office or consolidated with a hospital,
service
to the veteran will be the same.
It is
our constant aim, and
we are working constantly,
to decrease the time involved here,
but it must wait
on adjudicative action and if you have any
instances specifically wherein there is an excessive delay
here or problem we
certainly would like to look into it, but
we can see
no reason
because of the relationswe have with the
regional office why there is any difference between the geographic locations mentioned.
134
MR.
AKIN:
Any
questions?
MR. BROOKS (OHIO):
Not only does
this man have to wait
until they determine whether or not to call him in for an
examination,
but during the interim of this waiting period he
seeks private medical care and then when he does get in the
regional office the condition has become symptomatic and he
gets another slap in the face by them telling him he needs no
treatment.
I .don't think this dis fair, nor: is this a service
to the veteran who does need that treatment.
You cannot turn
that ‘condition on and off like a water tap.
DR. ZINK:
I couldn't be more in accord with what the
gentleman says.
However, we cannot accomplish treatment until
service connection has been determined.
This,
as we all know,
is an adjudicative function,
not a medical function.
The
element in that this we can hopefully improve is speeding up
the process once adjudication has been made.
This, we are
constantly trying to do, but the application must be adjudicated
before we have any authority to authorize or examine or recommend home town care or treatment.
This is something beyond
our control,
and as I said, we can see no relation to the geographic
juxtaposition of the clinic in this particular problem.
MR.
AKIN:
Mr.
Brooks,
are
you
satisfied?
MR. BROOKS:
No.
Your 2731 you acknowledge is your delay
in these cases, but it seems to me that there should be some
other recourse to speeding this thing up such as copies of
rating sheets on those cases going to the out-patient service
and set up in a file the same as your military files are in
your administrative division and when that man's application
comes in it can be run over in that file.
If he has an adequate
rating sheet in there showing his service connection that should
be basis enough for setting up and calling him in as quickly
as possible.
DR. ZINK:
1I believe in this latter instance you are assuming that there has been a rating, and in this instance there is
no problem necessarily,
and many times we do handle these by
‘phone.
Again,
the problem occurs of delay,
generally speaking,
in those cases that have not been adjudicated and determined to
be service connected, but certainly we use the 'phone frequently in securing the data just as easily as walking into the
office next door.
However,
unless there has been ad judicative
action,
there is some delay and that is just unavoidable.
MR. BROOKS:
I am speaking of the adjudicated claim and as
far as a woman is concerned,
yes.
If a man walks into the outpatient clinic and applies there they will call and sometimes
that man will wait three or four hours for a reply back from
Adjudication because the folder is out some place and they
have to hunt it, but what I am saying is this man has a service
connected disability,
but he does not have an established
service connected treatment folder,
and he is a man who is applying and they are not going to make a phone call on every 2827
that comes in.
They will use the routine 2731 form.
DR.
are
ZINK:
constantly
"I
can
reviewing
only
our
reply
to:
that
procedures
as
in
these things up. We will continue to do so.
any particular problem we would be happy to
135
I
an
did
before.
effort
to
Again,
go over
if
it
We
speed
you have
with you
further.
Certainly a constant effort is being made to speed
up the procedures,
either in hospitals,
clinics,
or any place
else to get the veteran treatment that he is entitled to just
as rapidly as we can.
MR.
BROOKS:
I
have
nothing
else.
MR. BROWNING (Rhode Island):
I have just one thought here.
With the study it might be possible that in all cases after they
are rated for service connection a treatment folder could be
made up of the rating and filed in the medical department.
Then
when they came
in they could pull the folder and there would be
no delay.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you.
Let me remind you that we urge you
to scribble down any questions that you want to present to Dr.
Middleton and his staff.
Send them up to the end table here
and we will be glad to slip them
over to him and get you the
answer
at
the
end
of
the
printed
questions.
Any
further
ques-
tions or discussion on question number four?
If not, we are
going to call on Brother Bottigliero of Illinois,
the Director
of Rehabilitation,
to give question number five, which I believe
he presents himself to the conference.
MR. BOTTIGLIERO:
has three parts to it.
approved July 7, 1960,
Thank you, Chairman Akin.
To what extent has Public
been implemented?
A.
Have any qualified
purposes of giving effect
to
been appoint?
to
B.
If
making
the
not,
what
is
services
the
optometrists been appointed for
this law?
Have any area directors
future
authorized
planning
with
this
available?
by
C.
What has been the experience
the number of requests by veterans for
metrist under PL 86-598?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Question five
Law 86-598,
law
reference
of Central Office as to
treatment by an opto-
Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
For many years wherever they have been
required, we have utilized the services of qualified optometrists
on the staff of VA hospitals under the supervision of full-time
ophthalmologists.
As of
March 31, 1960 there were 16 on duty.
The annual census to be taken the end
of this month will reflect the changes resulting from PL 86-598.
No
area
directors
have
been
appointed
and
we
have
no
need
for any
at this time.
Insofar as the Public Law is concerned,
it
was actually implemented by a DM&S circular on August 23, 1960,
and as demands for these services develop, we anticipate that
we will move into the useage of optometrists in the clinics in
the manner in which we have utilized them in our hospitals.
Several clinics
in several states have authorized fee optometric care as a result of the new law.
California has authorized
some
20
cases
in
the
past
few
months
to
optometrists.
MR. AKIN:
Any questions from the floor?
Question number
six in the discussion.
We are moving to questions six and seven
and we are going to call on our colleague,
Reuben Garnett of the
State of Washington,
the Department Service Officer,
for questions
136
six
and
seven.
MR. GARNETT:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Question number
six is submitted by Kohler of Pennsylvania.
Under present conditions, peacetime veterans who are 0 per cent service connected
cannot receive VA out-patient
treatment or hospitalization for
that condition.
Are any changes contemplated in the regulations
with respect to such cases?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers.
MR. BOWERS:
Veterans who have peacetime service only,
must meet the basic requirements of the law to be entitled to
out-patient
treatment or hospitalization.
They must have been
separated for disability incurred in line of duty or be
in
receipt of, or but for the receipt of retirement pay would be
entitled to, disability compensation.
The peacetime veteran who does not meet either of these
requirements but who has a disability incurred in service
rated O per cent is not entitled to treatment or hospitalization
for the service incurred disability.
Since such veterans do
not meet the requirements of the law, it is
not possible for
the VA to change regulations in this regard.
A change in the
basic law would be necessary.
is
it
MR. KOHLER (PENNSYLVANIA):
In your
necessary to have the law amended?
MR.
BOWERS:
Yes,
sir,
it
estimation,
Mr.
Bowers,
is.
MR. KOHLER:
The reason I brought that question up, was
this past October at a breakfast with the former Administrator,
we brought this up and he was quite startled to learn that
these zero per cent cases were not afforded treatment and he
made mention to one of his assistants who was with him to make
note of that because he wanted to bring it up and he thought
it was a very deserving issue to take up.
I was wondering
whether there are any changes contemplated.
on
that
the
MR. BOWERS:
part of the
There would have to be legislative action
Congress.
Of course,
you have access to
just
and
as
we
do
it
is
a
question
of
whether
or
not
this
will be presented.
There have been bills presented.
I think
there are one or two in the hopper now, which touch on this area.
I am not aware that there is any that would specifically make
the amendment that would provide that the peacetime man who has
a no per cent disability and has no other entitlement would be
entitled to treatment.
It does require-legislative change.
MR. GARNETT:
Question number seven submitted by our good .
friend from Arizona, Garland Wood.
Would it be possible for
central office to once again remind the VA hospital managers
that it is most important
in regard to severely disabled service
connected veterans that there be included in the hospital
summary some comment as to whether or not the veteran has been
employed and whether or not he might be employed in the future?
the
DR.
MIDDLETON:
MR.
BOWERS:
hospitalized
quirements
for
It
Mr.
Bowers.
is
presumed
service
temporary
connected
total
137
that
the
veteran
rating
under
question
who
the
meets
pertains
the
provisions
to
re-
of
Paragraphs 29 or 30 of the Schedule for Rating Disabilities.
VA Manual MI, Part I, Chapter 6 contains specific instructions
for the inclusion in the hospital summary of appropriate recommendations as to the capacity of such veterans for posthospitalization employment.
We are not aware of deficiencies,
nor have any deficiencies been previously brought to our
attention in this regard.
However, we shall be glad to consider any local problem you may present, or if this is a general
problem, we will bring it to the attention of all hospital managers.
MR. AKIN:
Woodie,
are you present,
and are you satisfied
with that?
Arizona prepared that question.
We are letting
them off too lightly.
We are still waiting for some good
questions up here.
We will move to number 8 and this comes
from the staff.
The
extend
to
provisions
veterans
of
for
Section
VA
106
purposes
(d),
the
Title
38,
U.S.C.,
"portal
to
portal”
principle
(traveling to and from drills or other training without specific orders).
If a person who is covered by this
section is severely injured while traveling to or fromwsuch
training,
and is taken to a private hospital for emergency
treatment,
is the VA responsible for reimbursing the payment
of these medical expenses?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers.
MR. BOWERS:
VA regulations provide
urauthorized medical expenses incurred by
under the following circumstances:
for reimbursement
eligible veterans
of
1.
Treatment must be for a disease or injury adjudicatservice connected by the VA.
2.
Treatment must have been rendered in a medical emergency.
3.
Government facilities were not feasibly available.
4,
Delay would have been hazardous.
ed
Persons whose basic entitlement
to medical benefits from
the VA would be predicated on the provisions of Section 106(d),
Title 38, U.S.C., would have to establish such entitlement by
filing a claim for compensation and receiving an approved award.
Reimbursement for unauthorized hospital expenses could then be
favorably considered from the date compensation was paid,
even
though compensation was paid retroactively, provided all other
requirements of the regulations were met.
if
he
MR. AKIN:
will come
I
in
am
on
going
this.
to
ask
Ray
Macdouall
of
the
staff
MR. MACDOUALL:
The question was submitted because opinions
have been rendered both by the medical department and the claims
service regarding this particular incident. A man was on authorized weekend training in the Marine Corps, and while returning home in a private plane crashed and was severely injured.
He was taken to a private hospital for treatment,
the treatment
in the private hospital for one day, and I believe that ran in
the vicinity of $80,
under Section 106(d)
The
question
to $100..
Service
the foliowing day.
now
arises
who
138
is
connection
going
to
pay
was
granted
for
that
one-
day hospitalization.
Under Code 10 the Department of the Army
says that they cannot pay it.
The Department of the Navy says
that they
cannot pay it, that Section 106(d) of Title 38 was
promulgated just to protect this man.
The man
has been to the
service department for pay.
He has been to the Veterans Administration to pay this one-day.
Neither government agency
wishes to assume the responsibility for this one-day hospitalization in question.
MR. BOWERS:
Mr. Macdouall is right.
We have faced this
problem.
I believe our General Counsel held that this man was
in service throughout the day of the occurrence of the incident
so that we can only pick him up after he is out of service,
so to speak, or on the termination of the day on which he performed this duty.
I believe the service department has also
stated that they do not have authority to pay for hospital care
in private facilities for this type of care.
I don't know the
answer, frankly.
It is a question that I believe will have to
be clarified either by perhaps clarifying some of the legislation,
or some agreement has to be developed between the military and the VA,
MR. MACDOUALL:
That is the answer I have been getting
for two years.
The Navy tells me they cannot pay.
They write
us a letter and say that the Commandant of the Marine Corps
has vested a great interest in this thing;
the Members of the
House and Senate have also shown an interest in this thing;
the President of the United States has shown an interest in
this thing.
But our hands are tied.
They say that Title 38
protects
this
man;
they
cannot
do
it.
Now,
the
Veterans
Ad-
ministration tells me that they cannot pay this man's reimbursement of medical expenses because he was not service
connected until the day following separation.
again
MR.
and
MARKOWITZ:
I think he
Mr. Bowers,
you ought
has the power today.
MR.
MACDOUALL:
Thank
you,
to
look
it
over
Mike,
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA):
Ray, I believe you said that
in this case you are talking about the VA rated him service
connected and my question is, did they include the day that
the General Counsel ruled that he was still in military service?
If so, I think the General Counsel,
and Adjudication,
and
Department of Medicine and Surgery better get together.
MR. MACDOUALL:
They
from the day following the
the 13th of the month.
He
of the month.
have approved service connection
injury,
The injury was incurred on
was service connected from the 14th
MR. AKIN:
Ray, you must feel by this time like the party
Clarence Horton told us about yesterday that was improving,
improving,
improving,
and finally they buried him,
We have two
questions
there any
submitted from the floor
further discussion?
but
we
want
to
first
ask,
is
MR. FELLER (NEW YORK):
I would like to refer back now,
as long as you have completed the printed questions,
to question
number 7,
It involves the zero per cent man and hospitalization.
It isn't clear to me from what I have heard, and I am not certain of just where the responsibility lies, but I would 1ike to
ask the question of this panel if there has been any recommendation
139
made
by
the
Veterans
Administration
for
a change
in
this
law
to take care of these unusual cases of where the veteran does
experience a service connected disability and it screams for
justice, but he still can't get it because he cannot get the
case rated at ten per cent or more and he is denied hospitalization because it is
less than then per cent.
Isn't it the
responsibility of the Veterans Administration to make recommendations and have these recommendations made?
MR, BOWERS:
This problem has been considered by the
Veterans Administration.
To my knowledge,
no specific legislation has been submitted.
The Department of Medicine and
Surgery has brought this matter to the attention of the former
Administrator.
One of the major problems involved here is the
dental
care.
The
no
per
cent
dental
cases
mendously large number of veterans and
considerable expenditure of funds. .
would
would
cover
involve
a
tre-
perhaps
MR. FELLER:
I hate to belabor this group with another recitation of the individual problem involved,
and after I recited
it yesterday I was informed that this
is not unusual,
that there
are many, many, many, many of these cases,
and the
man I was
talking to could think of probably a hundred cases not identical.
to the one I was talking about, but that involved hospitalization
of
a similar
nature.
:
This young man went into service and came out with an
acknowledged inguinal hernia.
Near the end of his tour of duty,
he was advised by the doctor at the station to wait until he got
home so it wouldn't hold up his discharge and let the Veterans
Administration do it at
his leisure.
The case goes into adjudication.
It is acknowledged,
It is in the service record
and then they adjudicate.
That becomes a problem to the man
because he cannot get first-class employment in many communities
because he cannot pass their physical examination.
You go to
VA.
It is the responsibility of the United States
Government.
Remember,
yes,
they drafted this young man in the service.
He
didn't volunteer and say, "I
want to get in there."
They
drafted him into service,
and the hernia occurred in service.
Doesn't the government have complete and full responsibility
and shouldn't something be done about such things?
MR, BOWERS:
Personally,
I would say yes, and
we have had
cases like this come to our attention.
As a matter of fact,
a
case of a similar nature was presented to the Berd of Appeals
and then brought to our attention.
The Board in this instance
gave
ten
per
cent
and his disability
This has been done
ment.
Frequently,
cent rating and we
and Dr. Middleton,
about this problem.
service
connection.
We
operated
on
the
man
rating was reduced to no per cent again.
where the no per cent man does require treatthe adjudicative boards will give a ten per
can treat him.
However,
I agree with you,
has gone on record in favor of doing something
MR. KLEMMETSON:
In a case of this kind where a man is kept
from employment because of a hernia condition he has, even say
it was non-service connected, wouldn't the Veterans Administration be good enough to take into account that this man cannot
work unless he gets this
condition taken care of and even on a
non service basis,
if you would say that is an employment emergency,
couldn't you put him in the hospital and take care of him
so he could go back to work?
140
MR. BOWERS:
If
per cent cases again,
service for that man.
you are
we have
talking about the peacetime no
no legal authority to render any
MR. KLEMMETSON:
non-service connected
No, I
case.
was
MR.
BOWERS:
An
eligible
not.
I
am
talking
about
the
veteran?
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Yes.
You do admit that there is such
thing as employment emergency which would take into account
when a man needs hospitalization for disability so he can go
back to work?
a
MR. BOWERS:
Oh, yes, we give consideration to the econoemergency.
We don't classify it as emergency,
but he is in
urgent category,
and we certainly would give consideration
mic
the
to
that
kind
of
case.
MR. DIXON (FLORIDA):
Doctor,
let me ask you a question.
I would like to know why you in the medical department discriminate against service connected cases in reference to 2507
examinations.
You say you do not. I say to you that in the medical
division we have a service connected World War I veterans who
files for a non-service connected pension.
The claim is labeled
on 2507
a reopened case,
and this is a group 2 priority in your
shop for examination.
In Florida, we had backlogs on 2507's
here not too long
ago -- we are a little better now -- where this group 2 priority
2507
was not even being considered or scheduled for any Act 1
examination.
You will find the same situation existing in the
service connected case on application for increase.
It is a
reopened claim.
It comes to your shop and under your group of
categories on examination it is a group 2 prioritye.
I contend
that this is discrimination against the service connected case
and this is the only place in the VA I can find it existing.
I
think that you ought to re-examine your priority of examinations
in the Veterans Administration because if every state is like
the State of Florida,
there is a great backlog of 2507
examinations.
There is a great delay in the length of time it takes
this man to be examined from the date the 2507
is received in
the medical department.
I, for one, just cannot figure out why
the service connected man does not get as good a break as the
veteran who has no service connected disability and comes in
and files for a non-service connected pension.
Yet, he gets
examined before the man who has been carrying the service
connected condition for the last 30 or 40 years.
I don't understand it and I think it should be corrected.
MR. BOWERS:
Mr. Dixon,
I would have to agree with you.
We should consider such reopened claims as top priority cases.
These are the cases that should be handled at once,
and processed
as rapidly as possible.
I would have to agree with you that
we
have
that
this
not
been
able,
to
we would desire.
We
as you know.
regard,
reduce
are
the
making
amount
of
time
considerable
to
the
progress
extent
in
MR. DIXON:
All you would have to do would be to rewrite
your old regulations and eliminate your group 2 priorities and
take all those men's claims as of the date you get them.
It
would certainly help a lot,
At least,
you would not be discriminating against a service connected reopened case.
141
MR. BOWERS:
We will look into that.
I wasn't aware we
are still classifying them in this manner.
We will check into
that.
1 agree these
are all top
priority cases. that should be
handled as soon as they get to the regional office.
MR. DIXON:
You don't have this problem until you get a
big backlog of 2507's,
but we have the big backlog of 2507's
and you
can have two men who file their claims the same day
who live next door to each other and the service connected man
will
be six
connected.
MR.
months
behind
BOWERS:
You
the
mean
man
the
who
didn't
initial
have
claim
is
the
service
handled
first?
MR. DIXON:
The original claim is the number one priority.
The reopened claim has number two priority.
The serviceconnected man is in the reopened category because he had a
service connected disability and he is discriminated against.
It ‘is not right.
MR.
BOWERS:
If
MR.
DIXON:
It is
he
is
filing
still
a
for
a
pension
reopened
--
claim.
MR. BOWERS:
This is not the problem that we discussed
at the local Atlanta Conference where they were
considering
this as a delayed reopened claim?
The man who has been examined, turned down, and then comes back again?
MR. DIXON:
another category.
what
No,
this
is
took
care
of
will
look
into
very
much.
MR.
BOWERS:
We
MR.
DIXON:
:Yes.,
MR. BOWERS:
we can do.
We
MR.
Thank
DIXON:
you
different
all
together.
that
one?
it,
Mr.
Dixon,
This
and
is
see
MR. AKIN:
We promised in the beginning we would give
priority to the prepared questions.
As soon as we get those we
will go right back to the floor.
We have a question submitted
by Korella of Missouri for Dr. Middleton.
What progress is
being made to add 250
beds to the Cochran Hospital at St. Louis?
Will it be possible to get action on the crying need for additional beds?
Dr. Middleton?
DR.:
MIDDLETON:
*Dr.
"Arnett.
DR. ARNETT:
I presume that also in this question you
considered the need for NP beds in this area, which is now under
study at Jefferson Barracks.
As you know,
at Cochran we are
very severely limited by the property we own.
To answer your
question,
specifically,
yes,
it is in our plan.
1 am not able
to give you the date because it is
beyond 1963.
of
at
MR.
beyond
KORELLA:
400 every
Jefferson
here
a
few
We have at Cochran Hospital
day.
There are some 590
on
Barracks.
months
ago.
The
He
late
was
142
a waiting list
the waiting list
Dr.
Drubn
met
an
untimely
death
very,
very
much
interested.
The
work that he has done at Jefferson Barracks is
markable and we were all very serry to see him
had done a job there that was nothing short of
certainly rego because he
miraculous.
Dr. Clairborne at the Cochran Hospital is what I might
call hog-tied as far as trying to do a job because he does not
have the beds to put these men into.
1 appreciate the fact
that your location does not have an awful lot of space,
but I
wonder if it would not be feasible to put the addition in back
of Cochran Hospital because we are pestered in the St. Louis
office every day by people who call up or some man's wife will
come in and say, "But, John has been on the waiting list now
for five months.
He will probably die before he gets into
the
hospital."
My primary interest is getting service for the
veteran that needs it and needs the service badly,
and I would
like to do so as quickly as possible,
and if you gentlemen
have any way in sort of boosting the construction of these
additional beds or allocating them from some other place where
they are not needed,
1 think our troubles can be solved.
Thank
you very much.
that
MR.
BROWNING:
zero
peacetime
I
want
to go
veteran
back
just
question.
I
for
a
second
presented
a
to
resolution
to The American Legion a few years back and was promptly informed that The American Legion had no authority to enter any
legislation for peacetime veterans, which I looked into and
found out is correct, but we have two newly elected men on our
Congressional staff,
a new Senator and a new Representative
in
Rhode Island and I am going to
ask as a citizen and as a
veteran,
not through the Legion,
that they submit a bill to
Congress providing for this zero peacetime man to get out-patient
treatment,
and also hospitalization,
Now, if some of the other
states will do the same thing, maybe we can get that.
Thank you.
MR.
AKIN:
The
next
question
flows
from
the
floor
by
Neikirk of Ohio.
Why is it necessary for periodic examination
for OPT purposes upon a veteran whose OPT is of many years’
duration,
and whose disability is indicated as static,
and who
medically requires said OPT with extreme regularity?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Zink.
DR. ZINK:
This position of periodic review of cases
is
dictated by good medical practice.
True, we may feel that the
case is static and may remain static for a long period of time,
but no one can predict unless we periodically re-examine that
this condition is a static situation and continued treatment frequently does not entail a complete recheck of the case to determine the progress of the diseases.
We feel in the interest of
good,
sound medical practice that periodically a complete review
of the case should be done.
MR.
go
back
AKIN:
now
MR.
program
to
HYDE
on
Any
my
(RHODE
mental
question
friend
in
from
the
ISLAND):
health
the
gentleman
from
center
aisle.
We
in
Providence
service
connected
concerning
have
Ohio?
a
I
pilot
veterans,
mostly out of Brockton.
Could you give us briefly your current
evaluation of this project and also your
opinion of its future
prospects?
We are quite interested in the project.
While answering that, what is the possibility of extending this to true nonservice connected mental cases?
143
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Casey.
DR. CASEY:
The day care center is one of the new things
that has been established.
We feel that this idea has very
excellent promise,
indeed, because it follows the line of psychiatric
thinking throughout the world at the present time in
relation to the care of patients, particularly those that have
been able to leave the hospital,
but who need a little bit more
supervision and care to help them
remain out of the hospital.
We, at the present time, have 11 such day-care centers throughout the United States,
the one you mentioned being one of them.
As I say, we feel that this is very much a coming thing.
We
plan to extend these programs as widely as possible as funds
are available to establish them.
The question of extending
this
to
a
non-service
connected
patient,
of
course,
is
a
legal
one and at the present time this is not possible unless we are
able to establish such a clinic in a hospital.
The recent
law passed last year would permit us to
do it if such a clinic
were established in a hospital and non-service connected patients
could come back to the hospital,
but not in a regularly constituted out-patient clinic.
Patients treated in such clinics
must be service connected under the law.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I am glad that the back row finally had a
chance to say something.
I thought all the brains were up front.
Particularly Bowers had all the answers.
I haven't heard Mr.
Bailey say anything.
I think that the question that I am going
to pose may be of interest here,
too, because it involves nursing care,
and I think very highly of nurses.
I have three of
them right along side of me
here from Pennsylvania.
Dr. Middleton,
I was very, very happy to hear your statement with reference to
the convalescent
care type
of thing we are trying to establish.
You know that I have been very much
interested in this for a number of years because I knew I was going to get old some day
and I am sure the young men here are beginning to appreciate the
fact that they are not always going to remain young, but I don't
think we are going fast enough.
I think we are planning too much; I think we are talking
too much; we are holding too many conferences.
I think that
we ought to go to the Congress.
I think you ought to go to the
Congress and I think we all ought to go to the Congress and
impress upon them the need for this.
Here is a hospital system,
the largest in the world,
the Veterans Administration and the
people who are entitled to hospitalization in these institutions
are all men and women who have served their country in time of
need.
They ought to be given primary consideration when they get
old, a little bit extra, beyond those of the other citizenry of
our nation,
and I think that the Veterans Administration should
be
in
the
I
think
I
trust
fast
forefront
in
the
would
to
have
over
we
DR.
there
are
like
leadership
elaborate,
actually
MIDDLETON:
you
of
this
elaborate,
further
on
this
or
particular
any
matter
activity.
of
your
and
see
brain
how
moving.
Dr.
Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
Mr. Markowitz,
I think you will recognize
that any new program that we begin designed to serve veterans
ought to be a good one.
You don't want us to begin a program
that we are not satisfied is going to serve the needs of the
veteran.
Our program,
the pilot project that Dr. Middleton referred to at Hines,
is designed to give us insight as to whether
we are stepping off on the right foot.
If we find that we are
144
proceeding apace and are satisfied we are moving in the right
direction, we intend to institute a program designed to build up
in tempo the number of facilities in locations where we feel
veteran need exists,
and I think you will be satisfied with the
progress.
We are beyond the thinking stage now.
We are beyond
the planning stage.
We are actually now in the moving stage.
MR.
for
not
my
be
MARKOWITZ:
I
hope
it
continues,
but
DR. MIDDLETON:
Mr. Chairman,
if I may
fellow Pennsylvanian's satisfaction.
taken from the 125,000
ceiling.
That
more
rapidly.
add just one point
These beds will
is very vital.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Might I point out to you, doctor, while
we are on that same subject,
that we are not depending entirely
on you,
We have asked the Congress by Resolution 25
to appropriate sufficient funds to do this job in addition to the regular funds that are being appropriated for the use of the
Bureau of Medicine and Surgery and I hope the Congress will look
upon-it with favor.
:
MR. AKIN:
At this time,
I would like to recognize our
distinguished Vice Chairman,
Dr. Booher,
for an announcement.
CHAIRMAN
BOOHER:
It
always
seems,
ladies
and
gentlemen,
a terrifically wasteful thing at this stage in our Conference
if we don't bring
before you our own
Medical Director.
He
travels all over the country.
As you all know, he has a great
deal of knowledge.
Apparently,
he does not have anything
bothering him,
too, but I still want to bring Dr. Brick to the
microphone for a few remarks.
Dr. Brick.
DR. BRICK:
I really don't have much to say and Dr. Booher
is just doing this to put me on the spot because there was nothing specific that I wanted to direct my remarks to.
At the
Medical Advisory Board meeting on Sunday, with some very distinguished Legionnaires a problem was brought up which has
plagued us over the past year, the problem of the effect of research in the VA hospitals on medical care, and I think it was
aired quite frankly and quite extensively.
There has been a
survey of research in the VA hospital system by the National
Research Council.
This survey was a rather lengthy one and our
staff has not yet had the opportunity to fully digest it, but
we are going to try to evaluate the survey.
I am sure that the
people on my left have digested this fully.
The sum total of
the discussion that took place with reference to research on
medical care in the VA system was to highlight its great im-
portance
not
only
with
reference
to
the
high
standard
of
care
in the institutions in which this research is taking place,
but also,
and this is most important,
to all of us, the availability of personnel in these hospitals largely depends on the
availability of the opportunity to do research,
This research,
as was pointed out briefly by Dr. Middleton,
not only benefits
the veterans throughout the country,
but the research is of a
caliber and character that benefits the whole medical profession in the United States,
and it has always seemed to me
that this is one of our great allies in any discussion of the
value of the Veterans Administration medical system not to the
veterans alone, but to the public in general,
and even to the
American Medical Association of which all the doctors on this
staff are members in good standing.
Thank you.
145
MR. AKIN:
Before
colleagues on the panel
It seems that there are
not,
I
will
turn
the
closing,
I would like to ask my
if any of them have comments or questions.
no further questions from the floor.
If
program
now
to:Dr,
Booher,
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I want to take this opportunity to thank
in your behalf not only Dr. Middleton and his
staff, but our fine
people from the Legion, Mr. Akin and his panel,
for their participation in this part of our program.
I have a couple of announce-
ments
I would
like
to make
.
eis.
before
any
of
the
AARIOUNCEMENTS,
ou.
rest
of
you
get
away.
At this time, we will conclude this part of our program
in order to bring you a very interesting program for the remainder of the morning.
I hope you will all stay and thank you very
much,
ladies and gentlemen, for your attendance.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I wonder if we might return to our seats,
ladies and gentiemen,
so we will keep this show on time.
It is
now eleven o'clock.
We will proceed.
Ladies and gentlemen,
in our work in rehabilitation,
which
we seek to feel is the heart of the work of The American Legion,
we have a good right hand always helping us. Representing that
large group of our auxiliary who make up that right hand it is
my privilege this morning to present to
you a lady who is a
past Department Auxiliary President,
the great Department of
Pennsylvania,
a member of the Auxiliary for over 30 years, has
been Chairman in her Department of the Legislative,
Child Welfare,
and Americanism Committees,
and has finally really reached
the
pinnacle of usefulness
in being our National Chairman of the
Women's Auxiliary Rehabilitation Commission.
She has been a
volunteer hospital worker,
you people in the VA on this panel
will be interested to know, and has put in over 800 hours in
the past two years in a hospital in her area.
Probably the most
important thing that she would have me tell you is that she has
six grandchildren.
It is
a great pleasure on behalf of the
Commission to present to you at this time Mrs. J. Howard McKay
of Springfield,
Pennsylvania,
the Chairman of the National
Rehabilitation Commission of the American legion Auxiliary.
Mrs. McKay.
ADDRESS OF MRS. J. HOWARD MCKAY, CHAIRMAN,
REHABILITATION COMMISSION, AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL
AUXILIARY
MRS. MCKAY:
Mr. Chairman and members of this Conference,
it is
a great pleasure to be
with you today and I wish to thank
everyone for all the
courtesies that have been extended to me.
I have learned much on rehabilitation and also on ADP.
I hope
that you note I said 'rehabilitation'.
We have been having a
little bit of fun in the Auxiliary this year and if anyone says
"rehab" we have been fining them ten cents and that is to go to
a project of our National President,
and I was sitting in the
meeting this morning and I thought,
"Well,
the Legionnaires are
better than we are."
I have very seldom heard the word "rehab"
in this Conference,
and lo and behold,
the Chairman of this
panel
him
used
about
the
word
rehab,
so
1
shall
certainly
have
to
talk
to
it.
Rehabilitation is such a beautiful word, meaning the rebuilding or the recreating and concerning the veteran it means
the recreating and the rebuilding of the body and the mind.
So
146
this year, we are all saying "rehabilitation."
So be warned
from now on.
‘First, 1 would like to thank Mr. John J. Corcoran,
Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission;
Mr. Nicholas
Lynch, Jr., Director of National Field Services and his representatives, wno have been so helpful in our Area Conference;
Mr. Doyle in Dallas, Mr. Burke in Providence,
Rhode Island, Mr.
Chillington in San Francisco, Mr. Toloczko in Washington,
D. C.,
and Mr. Morgan in St. Paul, Mr. Robert McCurdy, National Rehabilitation Chairman of The American Legion;
and the Public
Relations Division of the Legion for newspaper,
radio and tele-
vision
coverage
of
the
Conferences.
I would like to say a special "thank you" to the Field
Service Representatives who so ably assisted in planning our
meetings,
secured excellent speakers from whom we gained much
information,
arranged visits to VA hospitals,
and gave us a
little sightseeing along the way.
We also appreciated speakers
who came to us from other Commissions of the Legion speaking on
legislation,
insurance and other matters concerning rehabilitation.
I know I speak for my entire committee when I say it has been a
pleasure to be associated with such fine gentlemen.
Several weeks ago,
I enjoyed a Lincoln's Day program,
where the featured speaker told about the activities of women
during the Civil War.
Did you know that 400 women actually
served in the ranks of that war?
We learned of Dr. Elizabeth
Blackwell,
the first woman to concern herself with the plight
of mentally deranged persons and who was able,
through her tireless efforts,
to improve their condition;
Clara Barton,
a nurse;
and then Mother Bickerdike,
appointed by Secretary of War
Stanton to be in charge of the sanitary commission for the camps.
She supervised the spending of over three million dollars raised
by women of the North, mainly through bazaars to improve conditions in army camps.
Mother Bickerdike,
called the Cyclone in
Calico, went into the camps,
cooked, washed and sewed, had scant
patience for the purely feminine social visitors.
She wanted
action to make the camps more sanitary and the food more
palatable.
Even when
travel was not available,
and she was a poor
woman,
she got from camp to camp, becoming the nemesis of camp
commanders,
but she
did improve conditions for the men.
This,
starting with Florence Nightingale,
has been womens!
work during wars and following wars.
She has still served as
an angel of mercy to the disabled,
the ill and their dependents.
In the words of Dr. Osler,
it is our highest calling when "We
care for those unable to care for themselves, who need about them
gentle hands and tender hearts." The women of The American Legion
Auxiliary have been assisting in the program for veteran patients
since World War I in 1918.
This volunteer assistance at that
time was largely uncoordinated and the follow through,
the emphasis
upon integrating the VA hospital into the community life as part
and parcel of the community living,
thinking and planning, was
not implemented on a nationwide scale.
During World War II, the vast potential of service available through a coordinated volunteer program was early seen and
plans were developed which resulted in the establishment of coordinating agencies to mold the activities of hundreds of service
and welfare groups,
into a smooth working volunteer program for
members of the armed forces.
With the end of the war in 1045,
the immediate focal point of interest for many volunteer groups
over the country seemed lost,
But the leaders of these groups
147
realized that the training
certed and directed effort
outlet for their activity.
of
these
volunteers
the volunteers had received in conneed not be lost, if there was an
Since the focal point of interest
during
the
war had
been
members
of
the
armed
forces,
it was only natural that their leaders should see an
excellent carry-over of their war efforts to a peacetime activity
for men and women veteran patients. With such service in mind,
various organizations
leaders discussed with the Administrator
of Veterans!
Affairs the possible role their organizations might
play in the VA program for veteran patients.
Action on the matter was referred to the Assistant Administrator for Special Services and on April 8, 1946, The American
Legion and The
American Legion Auxiliary representatives met in
Washington with representatives of other groups to formulate
and suggest to the VA regulations
and procedures for the use of
volunteer assistance in the VA Special Service program for hospitalized veterans and in the establishment of the VAVS Advisory
Committee.
In 1950
came the United Nations stand against Communism
in Korea with the United States bearing the major part.
The
new wounded began coming home and hospital volunteers had
veterans of three wars for which to care.
The initials VAVS
stand for Veterans Administration Voluntary Service,
a plan for
community participation in the VA program for hospitalized
veterans.
One VA Administrator has called the VAVS the Vim and
Vigor Society.
The slogan of the rehabilitation committee of
the American Legion Auxiliary this year has been Service -- the
Volunteer Trademark.
Volunteers have come a long way since the
early days, when they were used mainly at the reception desk,
in recreation and personal service.
Much time was spent in
occupational
therapy,
needed.
The
recognized.
therapeutic
and
many
value
volunteers
skilled
of
busy
keeping
in
has
arts
were
always
been
Dr. Kirkbride of Pennsylvania wrote "Work is useful in
improving the health of the sick as in maintaining that of the
well,"
In a book entitled "Recent Advances in Psychiatry,”
an
example
is
quoted
of
improvement
from
occupations
when
a
mental patient became so intensely interested in weaving on a
small loom,
that he joyfully declared to the superintendent of
the hospital in which he was receiving
treatment,
"This house
has altered indeed.
It is now worth living in."
Nurses and
doctors
are
busy
people;
a
patient
can
receive
actual
service
from a nurse only about two hours out of the 24, and this is
where the volunteer enters into the pdcture.
They teach crafts
such as weaving,
copper enameling,
ceramics, painting and
knitting,
aid in the library,
the pharmacy,
the X-ray department,
the chapel and the blood bank program.
They teach dancing,
show
movies, write letters,
read to the blind,
lead songfests,
distribute mail,
sew and mend,
roll bandages.
There are very few
departments in the hospital where a volunteer cannot serve in
these
days.
Our greatest achievement
this year is the organization
of a corps of volunteers at the Carville Leprosarium
in Carville,
Louisiana.
There they are carrying out many of the
activities
that our volunteers do in other hospitals.
We now
have over eleven thousand volunteers serving in VA and non-VA
hospitals.
Recorded have been over one million hours of service by volunteers of all ages, husband-wife teams, mother and
148
daughter
teams,
and our
newest
volunteers,
our
Volunteens.
Articles distributed by our volunteers are too many to list
completely but thousands of cigarettes,
a thousand pounds of
candy,
cookies,
thousands of dollars worth Canteen books,
as
well as toilet articles,
stationery,
stamps, greeting cards,
scuffies,
pajamas,
bath robes and special napkins and tray
favors for all holidays,
as well as flowers, make our hospitals
cherry places.
Our Christmas Gift Shop program was carried on in 186
hospitals, with 318,376 gifts being selected by patients to
send home to their families,
at no cost to themselves.
Gaily
wrapped gifts, wrapped in brown paper for mailing, processed
by post offices set up in the hospitals,
cost Auxiliary units
over $500,000.
The total cost of the Christmas program of
gifts for each veteran was $263,654,
which gifts valued from
one dollar to ten dollars.
Noteworthy gifts were matching
dresses and sweaters for women patients,
a silver dollar on a
breakfast try Christmas morning,
telephone calls home on
Christmas Day and Christmas gifts left to be put under the tree
on Christmas morning,
for those patients unable to go home.
Devotion to duty even took some Auxiliary members into the
hospitals on Christmas Day for gift distribution.
We were delighted to have many Legionnaires help us and
they were invaluable in the Gift Shops.
In many departments,
the Christmas gift program for the veteran is carried on
jointly with the Legion and Auxiliary,
each contributing a
like sum for the cost of the gift to the veteran.
The Christmas
gift card bears the name of the President of the Auxiliary and
the Commander of the Post and they personally visit the hospi-
tals
to
make
the
gift
distribution.
By executive board action,
this year we shall present to
The American Legion $20,000 to further the rehabilitation program.
We cooperate
in the Hospital Veterans Writing Project,
the national organization and several of the departments contributing cash for awards.
Our volunteer hospitals workers are
urging participation in this contest to all patients.
Many
of our department presidents have special projects and I could
almost say they range from A for an aspirator and continue down
to Z for Zinnias.
Radios, High-Fi, Television,
record players,
lawn chairs,
service carts, motorized book carts,
soft drink
coolers,
libraphones,
a print washer for developing pictures,
furniture for day rooms,
sewing machines,
picnic tables,
softee
ice cream machines,
a tilt bed,
a kitchen for a soldier's home,
and planters for lobbies are just a few of the many desirable
items that make hospital life a bit more pleasant.
Some of the noteworthy special projects being carried out
constantly by departments
include gifts for veterans to send
home on Mothers' Day and their children's birthdays, wheel chairs
on loan when a patient is released from the hospital,
nurseries
where mothers may leave their children when visiting
their husbands,
insulin funds for indigent patients,
and the Craft Shop
in Chicago, where over $90,000 worth of veteran-made articles
were sold in 1960.
This shop is 30 West Washington Boulevard,
Chicago,
two blocks from Marshall Field's Department Store -visit it the next time you are in Chicago.
Several departments
help their Legion maintain mountain camps for convalescent
veterans,
149
One
season,
department
be tanned
to
collected
discarded
collected deer skins during the
and used in therapy craft work.
gold
and
silver
articles
relatives to the bedside of seriously
celebrating their centennial year and
made carpet bags.
for
hunting
Another
funds
to
bring
ill patients.
Kansas is
they are selling veteran-
We have many home-front volunteers,
the ones who live too
far away from any hospital to work there.
They are just at home,
baking cookies and cakes,
sewing needed hospital articles,
collecting gifts for the Gift Shops,
collecting coupons to redeem,
and holding rummage sales and card parties,
all necessary
to earn the money needed to carry on this vast program.
The
home-front volunteers,
the ones who live
too far away from any
hospital are also recognizing the needs of the older veteran in
the community, whether he is living at home or confined to a
nursing home.
Also,
the home-front workers are contacting the
families of a hospitalized veteran to determine if there is
need there.
On the return of the veteran from a hospital,
the
home-front worker calls to see if there is need of adjustment
or the need of a helping hand.
We must learn that we have a
new role to play -- we must not make the VA hospital,
an island
of
care
for
the
veteran.
be in need of help in
private nursing Home.
his
We
must
own
home,
remember
in
a
that
state
the
veteran
hospital,
may
ora
I remember the words of Milton Caniff in one of his comic
strips regarding the celebration of Veterans Day when he has
ane of his characters say, "I guess we'd all settle for a kind
word now and then from the folks who may be still alive because
we helped put out the
first so long ago."
Texas
Dr.
Buckholts,
had
this
to
say
manager
of
a
of
the
volunteer,
VA
hospital
'"What
in
makes
Dallas,
a
volunteer?
Not the headaches,
the sore feet and the sore back -- not for
glory,
not for pay, but for this feeling,
"I am my brother's
keeper!"
I shall close with the reading of an article written
by a volunteer in the Lebanon, Pennsylvania VA hospital entitled
"Certainly 1 Got Paid.”
Many times folks have asked me, "Do you get paid for what
you do at the veterans'
hospital?"
My answer has been, "Certainly
not.
I'm a volunteer!"
That statement set me thinking -- then
I realized I was not giving the correct answer.
Certainly I get
paid.
I get paid just by having the opportunity of helping sick
people.
I get paid when a patient says,
"Thank you," for an
eagerly looked-for
letter.
I get paid when I arrange a bouguet
of flowers and return them to receive a smile of gratitude.
I
get paid in the satisfaction of knowing that what may seem like
a very insignificant
task,
like helping a patient to Emergency,
directing a patient to the clinic,
steadying a cup while giving
nourishment,
even such a small task, is at the moment,
the most
important thing in the world.
"I get paid in knowing since there are people who must depend on others for help,
that I can give some part of that help.
I get paid in the friendships
I've made.
There are many things
in life that have no price tag and on which there is no room
for: a. dollar sign.
we
are
"In our
little
not doing big
corner of the world at
things,
just every day
150
the VA
little
hospital,
things,
helping
wide
our
field
brethern.
of
It's
service,
but
a
small
do
you
I am the richest person in the
another job at a higher salary
me,
Do I get paid?
Certainly
part
know
I
play
something?
world.
No one
-- there is no
I get paid.”
iin
this
I
big,
feel
can offer me
better job for
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Thank you very much, Mrs. McKay.
I
think I would be derelict
if I didn't take just a second to
call your attention to the fact that Mrs. Ahnemiller,
the
National President of the Legion Auxiliary has come to the
- room.
Would you stand and let them all see you?
we
The things that
doctors talk about
loving
care.
The
Mrs.
when
panel
McKay speaks of are the things that
we TLC on a patient's chart,
tender
to
session will speak on an
McKay,
of the things the
are glad to have you put
the
morning
allied thing.
We were well
Auxiliary have done and are
it into national focus.
follow
and
to
finish
aware,
doing.
Mrs.
We
For this next panel,
I would like to follow the procedure we followed earlier and introduce to you, if I may,
perhaps out of good manners,
but for
practical reasons,
the
Legion panel on the rostum with me at this time.
Then we will
go to the people of the Veterans Administration.
Chairing this
particular panel is Dr. Charles Soforenko,
of Massachusetts,
and with him Glen Rardin of Virginia,
Ned Prator of Oklahoma,
Roy L. Carver of Missouri,
and our National Chaplain, Reverend
Moss, whom you all know.
In order to start this discussion
on the voluntary administration of voluntary service, Veterans
Administration Voluntary Services and VAVS, and that is like
rehab -- we use it without thinking, Mrs. McKay.
I
to
urge
the
would like to call
panel for questions
you
to
send
your
on two people
propounded on
questions
up
from
first before
page 18, and
the
floor.
we get
again I
To
start
this discussion,
I will call on I think at the moment the
ranking panelist even though the boss is still at the table,
Dr. Cohen.
I am going to call on Dr. Cohen,
to do the chore
before Dr. Middleton tells him to anyhow.
Dr. Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
Thank you very much, Dr. Booher.
I have been
taken a little off base here because I had fully expected that
Dr. Middleton was going to be in my place here right now, so
suppose I do that and present to you again Dr. Middleton.
DR. MIDDLETON:
Apparently Dr. Cohen hasn't forgotten the
Army habit of passing the buck.
May I say that I was deeply
moved by Mrs. McKay's presentation,
a very clear and lucid outline
of the functions of the volunteer service.
She, of course, went
into other areas than those affecting the medical system of the
Veterans Administration,
but they were nonetheless cogent in
their application to the particular function,
May I indicate,
furthermore,
that the volunteer service is one that has not only
all of the connotations of the qualifying adjective volunteer,
but also a singularity,
If I were to attempt to recover the
ground that has already been so well covered it would be but to
indicate that this is indeed a broad and important aspect of
medical
care.
I
am,
however,
ceive of the quality of
American veteran in our
that motivates the many
This,
of
course,
moved
to
say
medical care that
hospitals without
volunteers in our
is
an
extremely
151
that
I
cannot
con-
is available to the
this spirit of service
program.
important
element,
but
you
will perhaps be interested in the fact that an isolated physician myself would evaluate quality of management in a hospital
by the adequacy,
by the activity,
of the voluntary service.
I
would go beneath the service and beyond the terms of technical
medical care and look into this particular element that means
so much not only to the peace of mind and welfare of the veteran
within the hospital, but to his re-socialization.
It is so easy
to build up barriers behind hospital walls and these barriers
are
so
important
when
we
are
attempting
to
return
the
veteran
to
his appropriate place in the voluntary society.
So you will
bear with me when I say that this is the bridge between the
hospital and society for the veteran.
I am particularly relieved this morning,
and I say relieved because appropriately
the term is applied in the sense that I have the presence of my
own sex here.
At the earliest meetings with you there was only
a sprinkling of the male representatives of the Legion.
The
female Legionnaires and the Auxuliary were carrying the load and
we were hidden behind their skirts.
It is time we are coming
out and you by your presence here indicate that you have taken
that position.
I believe you realize that in our organizational
pattern in Central Office Veterans Administration we have made
a
change,
improving the dignity and the
stature of the Voluntary
Service by bringing.the Director of Voluntary Service,
the
Honorable James Parke, Jim Parke to most of you, into the staff
relationship
immediately with Dr. Thomas Arnett, Deputy Assistant Chief Medical Director for Professional Services.
This
was a very thoughtful device and it had as its objective bringing into the professional
area and into close contact with the
operations of the Professional Services division,
the Director
of this particular effort.
We
Director
have here then, first,
the
for Professional Services,
Director
of
Peter
Miller,
Arnett,
late
Voluntary
his
Services,
associate,
of Clarksburg,
Mr.
next;
West
Assistant Chief Medical
Dr. Cohen; we have the
James
and
Parke;
then
Virginia.
we
we
have
have
Mr.
Dr.
Thomas
DR. COHEN:
Thank you very much, Dr. Middleton.
While
Dr. Middleton accused me of passing the buck,
I think I was
doing an army job of sending up some heavy artillery to open,
and to help build some bulwarks,
and to present to you in an
orderly
fashion
some
of
the
things
that
we
wanted
to
talk
about.
I think Dr. Middleton set the framework for this in speaking
about the role of the volunteer in terms of establishing quality
of care in support of our veteran patients.
Briefly,
1 want to
expand a little bit further on the reason behind the placement
of the voluntary services in Central Office in the Office of
Professional Services and the individual hospitals in the Office
of the Director of Professional Services. As a staff assistant
to the Director of Professional Services,
I think you will recognize, of course,
that while at the very outset following the
war, the major role of the volunteer was to bring services and
supplies of a particular kind to the veteran,
this has changed
very sharply and Mrs. McKay has emphasized to you generally the
manner in which this change has come about.
Today the services are beginning to take shape in the direction of providing closer relationship to the professional
service with patients.
Someone from the floor in the previous
panel asked the question about the expansion of day care centers.
Dr. Casey might have spent a little time then, and I think he
deferred to us, to make a particular point with regard to the
152
establishment
and expansion of day care centers.
In and of
themselves,
the day care centers cannot succeed without the
support,
the strong support,
of volunteers;
volunteers who will
provide practically everything that they do in the hospital,
but
even more
will provide a very close relationship with the community.
They will be in the community a kind of shepherd to help
bring the individual away from the day care center ultimately into
as complete independence in the communityy as possible.
We look
to the Legion and to the Auxiliary to make its meeting places
available to men ready for and who have been discharged from
our hospitals,
our clinics,
and our day care centers.
The ultimate establishment of the restoration centers which Dr. Middleton
referred to in the earlier panel also will make very heavy demands for volunteers;
to provide the tie
with the community and
to help to bring into clearer focus the importance of structuring
voluntary services,
community services for veterans.
In structuring community services for the veterans the volunteer will be in
a
position
to
serve,
citizen and as
ready to leave
not
only
as
a fellow resident
the hospital,
the
a
volunteer,
but
of a community
center,
or the
also
as
a
to the veteran
restoration unit.
The actual placement organizationally of the Director of
Volunteers in the Office of the Director of Professional Services
makes it possible for him to be working directly with every professional element in the hospital,
bringing to those departments
who are most urgently in need of specific categories of volunteers
the skills of those volunteers to meet and to match the needs of
the patients.
The changes that are slowly beginning to evolve in
the care of the mentally ill patients beyond the day care center,
those having to do with the establishment of half-way houses, of
which there are more than a half dozen today in the country, will
also make it possible for volunteers to provide an entirely
different
type
of
service.
It will
be
amore
direct
kind
of
support service in the field of rehabilitation as it relates to
the various rehabilitation therapies,
and also in the form of
companionship therapy with close ties with the social service
staff.
We do
need in this area a very close relationship with
the professional services and hence this change.
Dr.
present
will
Arnett
some
proceed
will
other
with
speak
aspects
the
panel
with
of
the
you
at
program
this
time
change,
briefly
to
and
we
then
later.
DR. ARNETT:
Thank you, Dr. Cohen.
Members of the group,
I think this pass the buck really has been going around pretty
fast.
I was at the other end of the table and hoping it wouldn't
get down there, but I made it.
I would like to also say what
both Dr. Cohen and Dr. Middleton said; Mrs. McKay has about
covered the field in a very excellent address.
There is one
phase which I would like to mention and that is our administrative
assistance to the DPS and what is in the future in behalf of these
people.
You who are in the field deal with these people very
closely and I know you have some questions in your mind as to
their future.
At the present moment, we are going throughout all of our
stations getting and obtaining from the station an evaluation of
our present administrative assistants.
When this is completed,
we will then have a program established by centralizing their
positions back to Washington or into the area offices so that a
career program can be offered to these people.
This sudden
change has caused some upsets at various stations.
We believe
153
with an educational program now in its second or third month,
with the centralization of the position and
with the recognition that you people giwve to these people,
that we can
bring
the
professional
services
through
assistants closer to the volunteers.
try to answer any questions that you
I look forward very enthusiastically
the
Director
of Professional
the
VAVS
all
"at
stations.
Services
Thank
the
administrative
I would be glad later to
might, have on this matter.
to this new set-up because
now
is
the
Chairman
of
you.
DR. COHEN:
Dr. Middleton has already introduced to you
Mr. Parke, Director of Voluntary Services,
and at this
time I
would like to have him make a few remarks to the audience.
MR. PARKE:
Mr. Chairman,
distinguished delegates all,
I
think those of yOu who with whom I have been associated in this
program over the past 15
years would realize what a thrill I
have
gotten
at
the
session
thus
far
this
morning
from
Mrs.
McKay's excellent address and the backing from our medical people.
You know,
it is interesting that in this program in which you and
I have been associated there is no training for doctors in medical
schools so far as I know about the use of community volunteer resources as we know them.
We have had a long experience in the
VA in working with our medical staff getting them to see the
picture and as I
sat here this morning I realized that we have
graduate stadents on-my left in the meaning of purposeful use
of community resources.
I know that those of you, as I say,
you and I who have worked together over these years, must feel
a real sense of warmth at the comments that have been made about
what you are doing in our program.
There are some questions
from the floor and I will wait to speak upon them.
Thank you.
I
kind
CHAIRMAN
of held
BOOHER:
you off,
Dr.
but
Soforenko,
it is your
will you
turn.
go
ahead
now?
DR. SOFORENKO:
Before we open the panel discussion,
I
would like to make a few remarks and say that in the audience
are five of my severest critics from the Department of Massachusetts
and they are just sitting there waiting for me to make a mistake
so they can gloat over it, and I do make mistakes, when we get
back
to
Massachusetts,
so
take today.
However,
it
on this particular panel
feel and I note that the
that
voluntary
service
is
I
hope
the
panel
does
not
make
a
mis-
is a pleasure and a privilege to serve
today because we of The American Legion,
Veterans Administration does also,
a
very
important
adjunct
to
the
care
of our hospital comrades and I want to thank Bob McCurdy for the
honor in appointing me to this committee,
and also to those who
are responsible for my appointment.
Now,
only
one
we
will
question
go
on
ahead
the
with
agenda.as
mitted by A. R. Lindberg from
Mr. Rardin ask that question,
the
a
panel
discussion.
prepared question
Missouri,
please.
and
I
would
like
There
and
to
is
sub-
have
MR. RARDIN (VIRGINIA):
The question presented by Mr.
Lindberg of Missouri.
Please discuss under what circumstances
VA hospitals may provide transportation for volunteer hospital
workers.
We feel the transportation problem at the Jefferson
Barracks
VA
hospital
has
decreased
our
number
of
volunteers.
We
could have many more volunteers at this station;
however, many
are on pension and cannot pay the expense of transportation.
It
costs the average volunteer who comes by public transportation
154
over $1, as the fare
We have a county bus
line,
which
runs
in St. Louis has recently been increased.
line at the end of the city public service
approximately
every
hour.
The
fare
for
this
bus is 15
cents.
I feel that there should be some way the
station could pick up these people at the end of the public
service line.
We have transportation available on the station
and if it could be possible
to pick up these volunteers, we
would have no trouble in recruiting more volunteers, we would
have no trouble in recruiting more volunteer workers.
MR. PARKE:
This,
as I think most of you know, one of our
ma jor problems in recruiting volunteers and actually in retaining volunteers once recruited.
The results of a two-year study
of recruitment and retention of volunteers made by our national
committee clearly show that.
I am quite interested that Mr.
Lindberg who asked this question is a representative of the
Legion,
of the VAVS committee at Jefferson Barracks,
and that
committee,
as Mr. Lindberg knows,
I am sure,
is one of 14 committees throughout
the country making a study of this problem
of transportation.
One of the studies at Jefferson Barracks
will be in three phases:
determining what the station can do to
alleviate the problem, determining what each organization comprising our VAVS committee can do, and thirdly,
surveying community commercial transportation agencies to determine what
assistance can be gained.
Now, we have asked two hospitals in each of our seven
medical areas to make a year-long study of ways and means to
solve,
if possible,
this transportation problem.
While they
are doing that we here in the Central Office are doing what
we can to find out how VA can assist.
Now,
already where
there is transportation,
let's say between a downtown outpatient clinic and a VA hospital,
we have had approval from
the general counsel's office that that bus or car can stop
en route and pick up volunteers.
This is an opening wedge and
we are hopeful that by the hospitals working on it themselves,
the hospital committees working on it, and we here in Central
Office we can arrive at a happy conclusion of this; because
certainly,
and particularly with respect to the program of the
older and retired workers,
and we are emphasizing participation
by the older and retired workers in our program now, getting
them out to the hospital
is a major problem.
We are particularly interested in finding a solution, Mr.
Lindberg,
to this question and I hope very much
that your committee at Jefferson Barracks will come up with some of the
answers.
MR. KORELLA:
About a week ago, when I last saw Mr.
Lindberg and he informed me at that time
that he was in contact
with
the
officials
of
the. county
bus
line
in
this
respect.
What the end result has been'l do not as yet know.
However,
I do know that there are any number of retired veterans who
would be most happy to.assist in VAVS program if it were possible
for them to
expend that
get to Jefferson Barracks Hospital and not have to
dollar a day doing so.
Most of them, of course, are
on pension.
Some of them do not receive pensions,
but they are
on social security,
and as you well know,
the cost of living is
not a minor item and although they are willing they have no way
of getting there.
I told Mr. Lindberg that no doubt his problem
could be resolved when your study is completed.
155
MR.
PARKE:
We
are
hopeful
it
will,
and,
by
the
way,
I
might say to those of you who are working closely with the VA
hospitals,
if your hospital is not one that.is making this
study, don't feel that you don't have a responsibility to help
out because all of us need to put our best minds together on
this problem of transportation.
DR.
question?
SOFORENKO:
If
any
of
Any
other
you
have
comment
any
on
this
questions
you
particular
would
like
to
have answered,
if you write them down and present them to the
panel, we will discuss them.
I have two questions here I would
like to ask of Dr. Cohen or a responsible person.
What was
the prevailing purpose behind the change from monthly meetings
of the VAVS committee to quarterly meetings?
MR. PARKE:
I am not sure I have the answer,
but I would
like to give you a little background on this matter of the meetings of the committee.
I mentioned earlier that this year we
are celebrating the 15th
birthday of VA Voluntary Service.
Come
to our meeting in April,
and we will let you have a piece of
our 15th
birthday cake that we are going to have for it.
We
feel that we have reached a stage now where we wanted to take
a look at the operations of the program.
It was our feeling
that actually our work is involved in (1) somewhat of the nature
of
long-range
planning
and
thinking
about
this
program
and
(2)
the operating procedures of the program.
It was our suggestion
to the field that perhaps now we could have quarterly meetings
of the committee,
one meeting a quarter to discuss top level
planning for the future of the program,
new advances in medical
care
and
treatment
with
the
implications
for
volunteers,
because
very frankly,
and again something that makes me feel very warm,
jist as we have the backing,
as illustrated here this morning,
of our top medical men in Central Office,
so this program has
that backing of the medical men in our hospitals.
Our thought was that at these quarterly meetings top
people from the organizations would meet together sitting
around the council table with our top medical staff and top
specialists of other staffs of the VA to plan together for ever
more purposeful bringing of the community to the hospital and
the hospital to the community,
and while that’ long-range planning
is going on, bringing in, let's say,
the local Commander of your
Post,
the local President of the Auxiliary,
along with the representatives,
bringing in some of your department officials,
because this is an area where we haven't been able to educate people.
We
have
not
been
able
to
get
to
the
department
people.
However,
at the same time,
that we are looking to the future,
and I am
not talking about simply,
one, two, or three years from now;
I
am thinking about 10, 15,
20 years from now in this program as
we look forward,
because without vision the people fail and I
think we need this vision,
and as I say,
at the same time we
have that, we.have the operating details of the program to carry
out.
For example,
every hospital has coordinated Christmas programs.
Mrs. McKay referred to some of that a moment ago.
This
is an operating part of the program,
so we have a meeting for
that.
This would not be one of the quarterly meetings.
This
would be a-.called meeting for people on the committee who are
particularly concerned with that.
year.
Nearly every hospital has a
Here the operating head of
people,
hospital
and
can
here
have
would
as
be
many
a
special
meetings
156
carnival some
that needs to
meeting,
as
it
so
wants.
time during the
get together the
actually
the
We suggest four of these be the kind where you bring in the
top level people.
That is the thinking behind the planning for
the four regularly scheduled meetings and such operating meetings
involving,
for example,
not the Director of Professional Services
as Chairman, because he is not involved in the operating of something already established,
but he is involved in planning for
the future.
DR. SOFORENKO:
Mr. Parke,
I would like to make this comment:
that it has not worked out that way in Massachusetts.
We
feel that we have lost contact and rapport with other service
organizations
in the exchange of ideas as to how to best serve
our disabled comrades.
I am the VAVS representative at West
Roxbury VA hospital,
and I feel that I have personally lost contact not only with the other service organizations,
but I have
also lost contact with the Chief of Special Services and the
Director of Professional
Services.
When I go to the hospital,
I don't
would
tion.
feel
come
that
into
homey
the
feeling
hospital
and
that
we
used
that
is
why
to
I
have
when
we
asked
this
ques-
MR. PARKE:
My wonderment
there would be whether that
results specifically from a lesser number
of meetings,
or from
something else.
One of the problems we have had is attendance
at the committee meetings.
We have not had very good attendance
throughout
the country.
Our thought was perhaps we are calling
the people together too many times during the year so this has
been an experiment to try to find if we can get better attendance
at the four.
Then at the specially called meetings call just
those who will be involved in the project that is going to be
carried out, but if it is losing the thing that you are talking
about we will need to take another look at it.
DR. SOFORENKO:
The second question is this: did the
Veterans Administration feel that in abolishing the special
services unit at VA facilities and creating two separate divisions it would be more advantageous
to the veterans?
Does the
Veterans Administration feel that it has worked out that way?
DR. COHEN:
I think that we have attempted to give you
some insight into the reason for the organizational
change.
In
response to the latter half of this question or the direct
pointed part of the question,
I think we must admit that, while
the initial part of the change went smoothly and was properly
prepared for, any change brings with it certain problems and
that this change has brought with it certain problems.
I think
that Dr. Arnett attempted to point out to you the areas in which
we recognized the problems that have been generated and the
approach that we plan to take to deal with it.
Insofar as
specific relationship to problems of the special service program itself,
all of the functions of the special services are
still being continued.
The library program is being continued,
of course,
as you all know, and the recreation program is being
continued as part of the rehabilitation section of the hospital,
so that I think it is only a matter of organizational change.
In dealing properly with and in the placing of the individuals
who are working with the coordination of VAVS we must structure
a positive program,
and this is the program which Dr. Arnett
has already referred to.
DR.
SOFORENKO:
Dr.Arnett,
157
have
you
that
question?
DR.
.ARNETT:
Yes,
sir.
I think this question more or less falls on the one
that
Dr. Cohen just answered.
It is a very excellent question
from Mr. Henry, Department Service Officer from Kansas City,
Missouri.
The question:
since Special Services has been placed
under the Chief of Professional Services the Special Service
staff
has
been
cut
and
in
some
hospitals
they
do
not
have
anyone
qualified to supervise and instruct the volunteer worker.
Therefore,
the program has suffered.
Can anything be done to correct
the situation by adding a qualified person to the staff of this
hospital?
I think if the gentleman will not mind,
this is a
question that applies to many of our hospitals at the present
time and that is the reason we are having this evaluation and
centralizing of position,
so that we will see that the volunteer
service is covered.
. There is no question this was the one thing that we worried
most about in our reorganization,
that is, that the individual
would be too engrossed in his job of being assistant to the DPS
at those stations where the Director of Volunteer Services would
suffer.
I think with our centralization and our emphasis on it
that this will be corrected.
I don't know whether this a satisfactory answer or not.
This is our greatest concern in the reorganization and it is
receiving our constant attention,
because
the one thing that we assured all the service organizations,
and
we wanted to be sssured within our own group, was that the
volunteer program would not lose supervision by this reorganization.
We will admit to the gentleman that in some places that
has
occurred
does
and
we
are
that
satisfy
you?
MR.
HENRY:
I
am
taking
glad
to
corrective
hear
your
action.
answer
Mr.
on
Henry,
that
question.
In our area we have the Wadsworth VA Center and Kansas City VA
Hospital,
and I do see a contrast in the two institutions since
Wadsworth is a center and they do have assistants to special
services and they can carry on a volunteer program.
There at
Kansas City,
they do have a
limited number of employees working
for
at
special
the
Kansas
services
City
and
it
seems
Hospital
is
the
as
if
one
the
that
volunteer
has
been
program
suffering
because there is nobody qualified there.
The Chief of Special
Services there is busy covering all activities and there is just
no one there qualified to carry on and assist these volunteer
workers in carrying out the program they have had over the years,
and in which they have done a wonderful
job all through the years
at
the
Kansas
City
Hospital.
We
would
hate
to
suffer at any hospital for lack of someone that
on the staff that is qualified to assist in the
this program.
DR.
ARNETT:
Could
MR.“
HENRY:
"Yes,
I
ask one
see
the
program
could be
carrying
placed
on of
question?
‘sir.
DR. ARNETT:
I am not familiar with all these stations,
but I would presume that at Kansas City you do not have a Director of Volunteers as an assigned individual independent of the
administrative DPS.
MR.
HENRY:
DR. ARNETT:
station would that
Not
that
I
know
of.
If we had a Director of
resolve your problem.
158
Volunteers
at
that
MR.
HENRY:
Yes,
it
DR.
ABRNETT:
' Thank
DR.
SOFORENKO:
would.
you,
Thank
sir,
you,
Dr,
Arnett,
Mr. Rardin of Virginia, Assistant Department
Officer, would like to comment on the program that
adopted in his particular department.
a lot
MR.
RARDIN:
It
of
difficulty
obtaining
seems
the
trouble
volunteer
here
Service
they have
is
you
are
having
workers
for
the
hospitals.
We have a volunteer workers program at the Veterans Administration
Hospital,
the neuropsychiatric hospital,
Salem, Virginia which
has proved to be very good
and it may or may not be unique.
Since 1956
The American Legion hospital volunteer workers chairman has had
the assistance of our two local colleges and at the
present time 70 students spend three hours each week under the
supervision
of
their
professors
providing
services
in psychology,
occupational
therapy, physical therapy, manual arts therapy,
corrective therapy,
operating room, nursing service,
pharmacy,
chaplain service,
and so forth.
The work assumed now at the
hospital is considered the laboratory portion of their regularly
scheduled classes for which they receive credit. The college
students perform the work as the laboratory work for sociology
and abnormal psychology.
The students are directed to carry
out the
same responsibilities as volunteer workers and they
accept their assignment with a great deal of enthusiasm.
They
are well received by the hospital staff and the patients.
The
Director of Special Services at the hospital made this remark
about their work.
"The students provide the personal attention
so often lacking and necessary in treating NP patients.' This
may be a field in which you can find additional workers.
DR.
beyond
SOFORENKO:
Are there any
time so will
COLONEL
MURRAY
Thank
you,
Mr.
Rardin,
more questions?
We are running
you make it short, please?
(FLORIDA):
I would
like
to
ask
a
little
the
gentle-
man up there is they have any estimated evaluation of the three
VA hospitals in Florida,
and how are they performing in this VAVS
program?
Have you come to any point where you are getting a
picture of what the program is advancing?
Are we increasing our
numbers?
MR. PARKE:
One of the least’ happy things in our present
situation about decentralization is that we don't have the picture
we formerly had.
I have visited the hospital at Coral Gables,
but not within the last two years.
At that time,
I felt we were
much in need of a Director of Volunteers
there.
At Bay Pines,
we have a Director of Volunteers.
I have never been to Lake City,
so I cannot say.
I feel that we need in the Bay Pines Hospital
many more
volunteers than we were getting.
I think probably
that has improved.
I hope it has.
At Coral Gables Hospital
there was not the problem of the need of ¥olunteers because
seemingly there were so many more available.
I cannot speak of
Lake City at all.
I would say as far as our programs
, and I
haven't seen them now since this change-over,
that at the time
I saw them the volunteer program at Bay Pines needed more help
from the communities.
The volunteer program at Coral Gables
had excellent support,
though it probably needed more supervisory assistance from the VA itself.
159
COLONEL MURRAY:
Thank you very much,
sir.
I am Acting
Director of the hospital program and have been
for a number of
years as Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission,
and last
year -- I wanted to make this remark, Mr. Chairman,
for a
minute -- at our National Convention, which happened to be in
Miami Beach, we were able to give out seven of these special
volunteer pins and they were received very well.
I did it at
the rehab meeting at Miami Beach during the Convention.
I am
speaking now of just Legionnaires who are volunteering,
not
the volunteers of the Legion Auxiliary and those who come in on
part-time,
the rehabilitation part, particularly.
We have about
15 in
the state and we are having our problems in getting the
retired man on the job.
We are making progress.
I just wanted
to know how we are doing.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
DR. SOFORENKO:
Thank you, Cy. At this time,
I would like
to call on John Corcoran,
the Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission, for a few remarks.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The remarks will
be very short and brief.
I could not resist taking the microphone to tell you at least for the record the attitude of the
National Rehabilitation Commission on the VAVS program.
The
National Rehabilitation Commission wholeheartedly endorses and
supports the VAVS program.
It seems to me that in the beginning
of our rehabilitation efforts immediately after World War I,
there was a great emphasis upon hospitalization and medical care
of the returning servicemen.
I think that thereafter there was
some type of evolution in which at least on a national level, we
turned
our
attention
a
great
deal
to
compensation
and the legislative efforts in that direction.
partly attributable
to the superb job that the
Medicine and Surgery is doing.
and
pension,
This may be
Department of
I think that one of our great goals
at the present and. in
the immediate future returns now to the medical care, particularly as that great group of veterans reach the older category.
We want you folks,
therefore,
in the Departments to keep us
fully informed on such things as administrative
changes such as
the ones that were discussed this morning and how they affect
the volunteer program in your Department.
We also want you to
do one other thing and I think this you will enjoy.
At the
Minneapolis Convention,
there was approved a resolution authorizing us to create a design and then to distribute opinions for
those volunteer hospital workers who had achieved 1000 or more
hours of service in hospitals.
We began distributing those pins
in August of 1960.
We have distributed 380.
Thenational organization
pays
for
you
help
us
Thank
to
you.
these
spend
pins
some
and
of
for
Bob
these
bars,
McCurdy's
DR. SOFORENKO:
Thank you, John.
questions, we close the discussion and
back to Dr. Booher.
so
money
we
encourage
in
this
If there are no
I will turn the
direction.
further
Chair
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I want to thank in your behalf the members of the panel and friends from the Veterans Administration.
I have three announcements.
Many of you knew Edward Nowak.
You
know that he was with us in Buffalo, New York and we have just
been
informed
him
can
get
that
more
he
died
details
this
from
morning.
John
160
Those
Corcoran.
of
you
who
knew
. es
CHAIRMAN
until
to
1:30
this
Thank
you.
BOOHER:
The
Announcmenis,..
Conference
will
be
suspended
Conference
day).
recessed,
afternoon,
(Whereupon,
at
reconvene at 1:30
12:05
P.M.,
the
P, M,, the same
161
THURSDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
... The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel: Statler, Washington, D,'C.,
at -1:30'p.m,., Vice Chairman
F. Clinton Knight presiding:
CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
The conference will now come to order.
It is my privilege to present to you Mr. James W. Stancil,
Chairman of the Board of Veterans Appeals.
STATEMENT OF JAMES W. STANCIL, CHAIRMAN
BOARD OF VETERANS' APPEALS
MR. STANCIL:
I am not entirely sure of the significance
of all these TV sets around here but they all seem to be dark
so I guess I can proceed with assurance.
It is good to have
the opportunity to be with you again at one of these conferences.
I
have
met
a
lot
of
old
friends
and
some
new
ones.
You
are
even
more welcome this year as far as we on the Board are concerned
than you have been in past years because you seem to have brought
with you at least a touch of Spring.
Until just a few days ago
we had snow and ice and a great deal of it.
Mel claims that he brought.
the Florida weather and Bob
McCurdy tells me he
brought it from California,
but whichever
it is, we needed it and we are very grateful. Larry Pierce,
the
Vice Chairman,
is unavoidably detained, but I have a new face
for you, Woodie Flowers from Kentucky, who is the Deputy Vice
Chairman sitting here on my left whom I would like you to know.
I told you last year that
this year would be one of great change
in the personnel of the Board because we had some retirements
coming up.
There have been a great many changes.
In fact, out
of 30 some-odd board members,
14 of them are new since we last
met.
The year since we last met has also been a year of change
in a great many other ways and I think a year of some progress.
I would like to tell you some of the things that have
happened very briefly.
We have had organizational and operational
changes,
some of them growing out of study by the Board of
Veterans Appeals and recommendations by interested organizations,
The American Legion certainly being very concerned in that, Congressional hearings last year on the subject of judicial review,
and our own internal studies and our efforts to improve the
Board which go on month in and month out.
The most helpful and
I think welcome change is that we were authorized to increase
the size of the board from 11 sections to 14 sections.
We have
13 now and expect to have the 14th one in operation in July.
This will give us a little more time per case, and that is an
item that
got a lot of discussion at last year's Congressional
hearings:
whether 14 sections in the long run will be enough is
something that we will determine by time and experience,
but in
the meantime this increase is certainly going to help us and we
intend to use it to the best advantage.
We have effected an internal reorganization of the board
that probably will not interest you in itself in specific details,
but you are of course interested in the results that you can see
and can evaluate,
and we think it will pay dividends.
Briefly,
we have reorganized in a way to provide us with a substantial
increase in the facilities for our
professional training and our
162
quality control measures.
You should see increasing results
of this in more complete and better written decisions
in the
coming months.
We now handle our reconsiderations a little
differently.
The people who are operating in this field of
veterans
claims,
know
that
the
Board
operates
under
published
rules of practice and in these rules we provide for hearings and
briefs to show error in appellate decisions.
Each year we do
reconsider a number of cases, not a very large volume,
nothing
approaching any routine second appeal,
of course, but it is
important under our system and American concepts of good adjudication that a procedure exist for reconsideration where
there is a substantial allegation of error of fact or law in
the decision that you receive.
Heretofore,
these reconsiderations were always handled
by the same three signatory members to the decisions
that were
made initially.
These signatory members have to participate
in
any reconsideration because by law their unanimous conclusion
has certain legal impact and finality.
But we explored various
means of approaching as nearly as we could what the appellate
courts call an "en banc” rehearing.
‘We couldn't have all 13
sections act on an individual case without bogging down,
as we
have a case load volume of around 38,000 cases a year; but what
we did was to provide that when the board reconsiders one of
its decisions we add to the original section an additional
section, which is not committed on the case in any way, for the
purpose of reconsideration.
As another
item, the board no longer participates
in formulation stages of VA regulations,
instructions,
Administrator's
decision,
or other items of adjudicative policy.
This is specifically in line with an American Legion recommendation and
a resolution that The American Legion passed.
Removal from the
policy-making procedure places more responsibility on the board
of an evaluative nature when problems arise in cases that are
appealed
and
come
before
us.
Channels
exist
whereby
the
board
can bring to the Administrator's attention substantial questions that arise in our appeals practice as to whether some
enunciated policy should in our opinion be modified.
We are
bound by law, as you know, by the VA regulations,
by the Administrator's decisions,
and by the instructions,
but being out of
the policy formulation stage we are in a sense uncommitted and
this opens the way in appropriate cases to argue the propriety of
the governing criteria involved,
and I think,
if I understand
the reasoning behind the Legion's resolution,
that this is entirely in line with your thinking.
Board,
of
the
An item of interest that doesn't
but will be of some interest to
VA
has
underway
a total
and
directly involve the
you -- the General Counsel
comprehensive
review
of
all
published Administrator's Decisions.
The purpose of this comprehensive review is to insure that this body of binding precedents stands well in the face of today's law, to eliminate
ambiguities,
conflicts,
and in general improve this group of
precedents.
Last year the House of Representatives passed a bill
which would require the board to set out in its decisions speci-
fic and separately stated findings of fact and conclusions
which changes the format of our decisions somewhat. It was
of law,
not
acted on by the Senate.
It was passed by the House in closing
days but an identical bill has been introduced this year and is
being reported out by the House Veterans Affairs Committee.
I
think in all likelihood it will pass.
We certainly don't object
163
to
this
and
in
fact
have been
working
out
a
new
format
for
our
decisions that will accomplish the purpose of the bill and a
little more than that.
This is essentially a change in format
and not in substance,
but it is, I think,
going to improve our
decisions considerably from the standpoint of explanation and
detail and in general will be a better product.
You may have
seen some of them already.
We have continued since we last met sending a Section
of the Board out to a number of field offices,
one trip each
calendar quarter and the results of this have been good from
our standpoint
and I get good reports from a number of you people.
By June of this year we will have completed the first swing of
all
the
offices
except
for
a very
small
number
where
the
load
is
so small it doesn't justify the trip.
We will continue this
each quarter and on that kind of a schedule we will get back
to your office about once every two to two and a half years.
I
wish we could do better and perhaps we can in the future.
Plans
are being made which would provide the board with its own building, separate and apart from the VA Central Office.
We expected
to be moved in by the time of this conference,
but we ran into
a little problem of space for the people that are in that builds
ing now and that is delaying us, I hope no more than eighty to
ninety days.
The building that we are scheduled to get is not
far from here.
It is
at the corner of Fifteenth and "L", Northwest,
two or three blocks away,
a building that just fits our
space needs and we will be the only occupant of the building.
Most people think that this move is a good thing and that
it will help emphasize that appellate review is objective and
is independent of the operating departments.
I can't take the
time to give you much of a background on these new members
that I spoke of, but so you can get some kind of a quick impression I would like to ask them to stand up as I call their
names and very briefly,
I will tell you who they are.
Ed
Sugg
from
Tennessee
is
here
and
Ed
Shackelford
from
North Carolina.
Bill Cosgrove from New York, Jack Dabis from
Kentucky,
Dr. Thomas Wells is from Ohio,
and Larry Ryan is from
Ohio.
Emerson Johnston is from Michigan and Jim Burke is from
the District of Columbia.
(I didn't think there were any.
That
is a standing joke around here.
No one is ever born in the
District of Columbia.
They all come from somewhere else).
Leonard Alford is from South Carolina and Carlton Heyser is from
Maryland;
Donald Callison is from Virginia.
John Crogan,
from
Ohio -- Ohio is doing well -- Raoul Archambault from Rhode Island
and Johnny Catterton,
also from Virginia.
Mainly,
I wanted to
give you a quick impression of the changesof the board,
the fact
that it is changing very rapidly.
Fourteen new members appointed
within the last year is about a third of the Board,
the largest
number since its inception,
except the original Board.
These
men come from a variety of backgrounds
that will,
I am sure, bring
great strength to the board, not only because they are wide-spread
geographically,
but we have former consultants of the board; we
have former rating board members,
former adjudication officers,
a former vice chairman of the Board on Waivers and Forfeitures,
men from Mr. Stratton's staff in Compensation and Pension Service,
a former Assistant Director of the Bureau of the Budget and Chief
of Claims from V.B.O.
They will indeed bring a lot of strength
to: the board,
I
want
to
say
once
again
164
the
last
year
has
been
a
very
event ful one and that the Legion's constructive criticism as
always has been of material help to us.
I appreciate the opportunity to tell you a little something about what has been going
on.
While I am at the microphone to facilitate things here,
there is one question that has been submitted for the BVA panel
and I believe it is all right if I read that and proceed right
into the question.
The question is:
'"Under the provisions of
Emergency Interim Issue, EM 21-58,
dated June 17, 1960,
the
prohibition against withdrawing cases from appellate channels
has been deleted.
If a case has been certified to Centeal
Office on an
appeal,
and the accredited representative of the
claimant requests that the case be withdrawn from appellate
channels and referred to the Compensation and Pension Service
under the provisions of VAR 1142, will this request be honored?
If not, an explanation would be appreciated."
VA Regulation 1142, of course,
is now VA Regulation 1321 Larry Pierce,
our Vice Chairman,
just came in.
With respect to
VA Regulation 1321 or the old 1142, it is important first in
answering the question to understand just what that regulation is.
It contemplates a request for favorable action at the regional
office
rating
board
level
and
it
provides
a means
for
the
rating
board to request approval by the Compensation and Pension Service
of an action which the rating wants to.take but does not have the
authority to do so.
If the case that is cited in the question is
a pension case, I would have to assume that the rating board has
determined that unemployability is not shown and has declined to
recommend favorable action under Regulation 1321.
That being so,
then the certification of the appeal to the Board places squarely
in issue before the Board both the matter of whether schedule requirements are met and the matter of whether unemployability is
shown.
The Board is very clearly empowered to exercise any extraschedular authority that is involved in deciding either or both
of these issues and is thoroughly empowered,
clearly empowered,
to grant a pension on unemplowability irrespective of schedular
requirements.
This comes out of a regulatory change at the time
of this emergency interim issue that is mentioned.
Under those
circumstances
it seems to me that a review by the Compensation
and Pension Service at that point would be an administrative review rather than review of a 1321 recommendation.
I feel sure
that the Compensation and Pension Service doesn't
want to set
up an intermediate review of factual determinations.
In fact,
this would be contrary to the concept of administrative reviews.
So if the question supposes a reference purely for a factual
adjudication,
broadly speaking the answer would be no.
Now,
individual requests would have to be determined by a number of
things.
Is there a policy problem involved?
How urgent is the
need for its
resolution?
The number and purpose of such requests, and things of that nature.
If it approached a routine intermediate appellate review,
then something would have to give.
I hope that is direct enough
on the target of the question,
and that is the only question that
you
seem
to
have
CHAIRMAN
for
me.
KNIGHT:
If
there
any
discussion
Are
there
any
questions
of
that
question?
from
the
floor?
MR. HERMAN
Appeals Board on
WENIGE (Indiana):
We had an appeal before
a questionable sale of property by a widow
veteran.
were
As
you
a
member
165
of
that
appeals
board,
you
the
of a
may
remember the
is the story
The
husband
case, Jim
in brief.
Veterans
jointly
Mrs.
X
of
Jeffersonville,
Administration
owned
the
conceded
property,
both
as
Indiana.
that
both
to
the
she
Here
and
purchase
her
and
improvements.
The husband died in 1949,
Shortly after his
death the widow was offered $16,000 for the property and she refused to sell.
From 1949 to 1959
she repeatedly refused to sell
the property.
However,
in August,
1959,
the Federal Government
in conjunction with the State of Indiana surveyed for a new highway and that survey went through Mrs. X's property.
She still
refused
to
sell
the
property.
She
was
told
that
she
would
have
to sell or condemnation proceedings would be instituted.
That
would have meant considerable expense to the widow.
She would
have had to have legal counsel and she
couldn't afford it. She
had been offered $16,000 on several occasions.
The government
paid her $15,240,
which was $780 less than she had been offered
ten years ago.
She failed to report that transaction until
January 1, 1960.
The Veterans Administration then contended
she had not timely reported the sale and took her pension off,
retroactive to January,
1959.
Now, she used this money that
she received from the government to purchase a new home.
Our
contention was that this woman did not actually sell that property.
She had no idea of selling it.
As long as she hadn't
sold it it was not considered income and she refused repeatedly
to
sell
it.
The
government
stepped
in
and
told
her,
"We
have
to have this property.
You have to take this money."
We
appealed that case to the Appeals Board and the Appeals Board
upheld VARO at Indianapolis
in that she had not
timely reported
the sale,
‘I can't see any justification for that kind of a
decision.
This widow had no intention of selling that property.
the Federal Government and the State of Indiana compelled her
to turn that property over at an arbitrary figure.
She paid
more for the new home than
the government gave her.
It is
my
contention that that decision was wrong.
MR. STANCIL:
You certainly make out a good case for the
lady. One of the last things that I like to do is to say only
that I will be glad to look into it, -- and not answer as
directly as I can your questions.
Of course you pose a great
many technical questions which would require study, before I
could give you an answer that would mean anything.
We have
joint property.
We have his death and how much of the property
passes
to
her.
We
have
relative
values
as
between
one
point
in time and another point in time, which are determined by the
best appraisals that the VA can get, and all
sorts of things,
so I think that I am going to fall back on asking you to give
me the lady's name.
I don't believe I participated in that
decision personally because I haven't been signing decisions
for some three years now, but if you would give me the lady's
name and allow me to look at that decision, we will see if we
can do something different
for her.
CHAIRMAN
to
ask
a
KNIGHT:
Any
other
questions?
The
Director
wants
question.
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman,
I recognize that we are
approaching the end of this panel, but if I may have Dr.
Mandell's indulgence,
the next speaker,
I would like to ask Jim
Stancil to comment on something if possible.
Jim has outlined
for
you
of
Veterans
some
the
changes
Appeals.
of
Some
that
of
have
these
166
taken
place
changes
are
the
Board
physical.
in
Some
of these
upon the
changes are operational.
very mission of the Board
Some of
itself,
them seem to bear
This is a most
important subject
one of which,
and
is the continuing
usually,
but some
to The American Legion for a number of reasons,
this is the one I would like to talk about now,
proposal to establish some judicial review,
review of decisions of the Administrator of
Veterans
As
Affairs.
you
know,
the
decision
of
the
Administrator
in most cases is final and the Board of Veterans Appeals acts
for the Administrator
in most cases.
Therefore,
in effect in
most cases it is the decision of the Board of Veterans Appeals
which is final.
There
are some who feel that this is not right,
that there would be improved service and advantage to the veteran
if there were provided some judicial review of the decisions of
the
Board
Up
proposal
be
a very
of
to
to
Veterans
Appeals
and
the
Administrator.
this time The American Legion has
provide judicial review.
We have
difficult
and
delicate
question,
but
not supported
recognized it
we
feel
the
to
that
in
balancing the interests,
the interests of the veterans are best
serviced by continuing the authority that the Administrator has
at present. However,
we do feel that there is some room for
improvement
and
therefore
one
of
the
recommendations
that
we
have made officially was that the Board be withdrawn from the
policy-making process of the Veterans Administration.
Now, Jim,
I am finally approaching the point that I would like you to comment
on.
As 1 understand at present,
the Board is bound by the regulations promulgated by the Veterans Administration.
Is that
correct,
first of all?
MR.
STANCIL:
That
is
right.
MR. CORCORAN:
Jim says that this is correct.
He means
that if we approach the Board alleging that a case was denied
in accordance with a regulation, but our major claim is that
the regulation is inconsistent with the law, I do not think
that the Board could
accept our statement since the regulation
has been promulgated and the Board would have to say "We are
bound by this regulation.'
If the premises that I have laid out
so far, Jim,
are essentially correct, my question is; Would it
be possible to free the Board from this binding situation where
they must accept a regulation?
Would it be possible,
that is to
say, that the Board could find a regulation to be inconsistent
with
the
law
and
therefore
not
deserving
of
effect of the law? If this would be possible
necessary to secure legislation to make this
thirdly and lastly, would you be prepared to
opinion on such a change?
the
full
force
and
would it be
possible,
and
give your personal
MR. STANCIL:
This is a very interesting area where you
can generate a lot of arguments,
but first, John,
I would like
to add a word to your thought about our being bound by the regulations on any case that comes before us.
This is true, but
with the Board being removed from the formulation of policy,
the directive which I received from the Administrator made it
clear that this does not relieve me of the responsibility,
nor
does it take away my privilege,
of bringing to the administrator's
attention at any time some matter which arises in the course of
appellate review of the claims leading us to believe that some
enunciated policy should be re-evaluated.
is
in
Therefore,
effect the
while
Board
in a
must
given case as
tell you that
167
long as the regulation
we are bound by this
regulation,
you have to consider with it our responsibility for
attempting to change this regulation if we do not believe in it.
A recent illustration, without going into detail,
is a question
arose in a case, several cases,
in fact, over an instruction
issued over the Administrator's signature with respect to incompetent
in
be
non-service
connected
veterans
who
are
hospitalized
state institutions and the VA is paying, what otherwise
payable as pension, but for the size of his estate,
for
care
and
maintenance.
There
is
a cut-off
point.
I think
would
his
$2500.
was specified where we would stop paying and not pay for maintenance until the other sources gets down to a certain point.
The whole argument on the appeal was that the instruction that
was issued was inconsistent with the law and
exceeded our
regulatory authority under that law.
As we say our
responsibility in that case did not begin
and end with just stating - '""We are bound by the instruction of
the Administrator and this states so and so and therefore you
are in the wrong court," but rather we had to consider the basic
question and our choices of action were to either affirm the
instruction or to take steps to try to change it.
That is a little Dit in the direction you want to go, but
beyond that new to approach your other question, whether the
Board can be freed from the regulations and the instructions,
yes, this could be done.
It would take a change of law because
the law very specifically reads that the Board in its decisions
shall be bound by the instructions of the Administrator,
VA
regulations,
and precedent opinions of the chief law officer,
which means these published AD's that I referred to a minute
ago.
It is a general rule of law where a court or some independent appellate review authority is considering actions by
an agency of the executive branch of the government empowered
to issue regulations that in general you follow and apply these
regulations unless you determine they are inconsistent with the
law.
Inconsistency with the law is the test.
Conceivably -- I am thinking off the top of my head now -this can be done with the Board located just as it
is now.
However, another bill has been introduced this year in addition to
the bill for a court of Veterans Appeals and that bill would
give the Board of Veterans Appeals a measure of independence,
located in the VA for administrative purposes, but otherwise
more independent than it is now.
This bill specifically repeals
the section of the law that binds the Board by regulations,
and
instructions,
and so on.
Of course,
this is a bill that has
just been dropped in the hopper,
the VA has not been asked as yet
for its report and as far as I know it has been evaluated and
discussed by no one seriously or at any length,
so I won't be
prepared to discuss the merits of that at this particular point
beyond just informing you that it is in the hopper and that would
be the effect of it.
MR.
CORCORAN:
CHAIRMAN
MR. WEISS
allowed appeals
KNIGHT:
That
is
Any
fine.
Thank
you,
other
question
now?
What
the
(PENNSYLVANIA):
in 19607?
168
was
Jim.
percentage
of
MR.
STANCIL:
12-1/2
per
cent.
Incidentally,
just
to
take one more moment,
I may be repeating things that I have
said before but,
as you know, appeals are filed in the field
office.
The cases get a second look before they are certified
to the Board.
Statistics
show that approximately ten to eleven
percent of all appeals filed -- as a result of your presentation,
and study,
and identification of other evidence or one thing
and
another
--
on
this
second
look
are
without
the case ever reaching us, so
year was 12-1/2 per cent of those that
remand rate was in the neighborhood of
over fen per cent,
going
MR, WEISS:
Is the traveling
to continue this year?
Board
paid
at
the
local
level
the allowance rate last
did reach us and the
10 per cent,
a little
of
Veterans
Appeals
MR, STANCIL:
Yes, sir.
Our present plans and budgeting
are for one trip each quarter of approximately three weeks duration except for a long trip
such as the West Coast, which would
take four weeks,
and we cover as many offices as we can, up to
a week in the larger offices and two, three, or four days
in
some of the smaller ones.
We plan to keep it up, yes, sir.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
KNIGHT:
STANCIL:
Any
Thank
CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
pleasure to present Dr.
Staff.
other
you
questions?
very
much.
Thank you, gentlemen.
E. Mandell, VA Policy
It
and
is now my
Evaluation
DR. MANDELL:
Good afternoon,
ladies and gentlemen.
I
feel honored in being called before you and
having this opportunity to address you, primarily because the job that I am doing
or my group is responsible for in a sense is exactly the same
as your job, to try to determine what is good for the Veterans
and
what
is
good
for
the
Nation.
In this sense, we are working together.
I would like to
take a moment to allay any apprehension because there is some
rumor about that the group that I represent serve as egg-heads
to the Veterans Administration.
The idea of being an egg-head,
a thinker,
is occasionally frowned upon as something that is to
be looked upon with a certain amount of suspicion. As a matter
of fact,
I recognize in this audience a number of Hoosiers from
which state I just but recently have come and among Hoosiers
they look upon
anybody who has a great deal of academic authority
behind him as somebody to look upon with suspicion.
They assume
that all a man needs is good, common horse sense.
I would like
to remind you, therefore,
that I am a humble country boy.
I was
born on a farm.
Perhaps I should tell you first a word or two
about what the policy and evaluation staff is intended to do
because those who are engaged in the Veterams Administration
with the operation of its daily chores and the programs and
activities that are. the responsibilities of the Veterans Adminis-
tration
and
are
so
consumed
with
the
daily
thought that perhaps they did not have
about the problems that lie ahead.
time
operation
to
sit
it was
back
and
think
| As an illustration of what happens when you don't take time
to sit and determine what to do with problems,
you are
all aware
that all of us recognized during the World War II that the
169
Veterans Administration was going to be saddled with a tremendous
task,
General Hines was aware of this as was everybody that worke
for the Veterans Administration.
But the day to day operation
and the exigencies of war were so great that no one took the
time to actually plan how we were going to attack this tremendous
task which, it was recognized, was bound to come before the
Veterans Administration as soon as the war closed.
And so, many
of you remember,
the Veterans Administration attacked this problem as best they could, but there was a tremendous amount of
chaos and confusion.
In the hope that we will be able to recognize and do something about the problems of the future the
Policy and Evaluation Staff was set up to be able to take the
time to look into what will be the problems of the Veterans
in the future, what will be the problems of the Veterans Administration in the future,
and what are the best policies and programs to prepare for these problems.
Perhaps you would like to know some of the things that we
have done in the past.
As an illustration of our approach to
this problem,
I would like to call your attention to a monograph
that was prepared by the Economist of the Policy Evaluation
Staff, Dr. Robert Martin.
This is called The Aging American
Veterans and The National Economy."
Some of you have copies of
this
monograph.
Tomorrow
I will
send
over
sufficient
copies
so that each of you can have it.
But I think there is in this
a great deal to be learned about the problems that the future
may present.
Right now there exists in our society about 14
million males 65
years and older.
Of those 14 million,
50 per
cent right now are veterans.
Within the next 30 years twothirds of every male 65
years and older will be veterans.
This
fact alone poses a tremendous problem for the Veterans Adminis=
tration because in our studies of the problems of the aging
veteran a number of things have become crystal clear.
First,
that as a man ages his need for medical care increases.
The
length of time that he is going to have to spend
with each eipsode of hospitalization is going to increase,
so
that the patient load in a sense of the Veterans Administration
will tend to increase.
This is most true because also as a
man reaches 65
years and older his economic status in the
economy tends to decrease.
His income is less.
This will
also
pose a problem both because he will not be able to support his
medical needs and because he may not even be able to support his
general needs, so his pension needs may increase.
It is essential that the VA begin to study what the future may hold in store
as problems.
This is one area of problems.
This pamphlet
‘is
but the ground work to indicate how great that problem may be.
One of the other problems that we soon recognized was the problem
of the aging veteran in general and in this area
we recognized
that the aging veteran,
unlike our younger veterans,
(although
this
is
outside
also
of
true
our
of
our
younger
veterans),
often
needs
care
hospitals.
One of the things I think you will soon recognize,
as we
did, is that whether it is nursing care, whether it is a
sheltered home or a domiciliary care, or whether the hospital
care,
the problems are real, but these can be confused and we
can errode away our benefits if we do not approach them as
realities and entities in themselves,
I think you would be the
first to agree that we have probably the best hospital system
in the country in which our veterans get care second to none.
If that hospital is soon saddled with only chronic: cases,
cases
170
needing
the
primary
acutely
I
only
value
have
of
nursing
the
function
ill.
of
This
mentioned
home
care,
hospital,
the
is
are
we
because
hospital,
not
not
to
say
problems,
will
errode
and
we
will
have
that
the
other
which
but
is
to
we do
rust away
destroyed
the
elements
that
care
not
for
solve
the
those
problems simply by finding an easy method of solution.
We should
attempt to solve each problem by attacking it forthrightly and
directly.
We have therefore reviewed our present domiciliary
program.
This is a print of our domiciliary study- the first
copy has come off the press.
I hope in a short time there will
be enough copies so that each of you can have a copy.
We have
attempted,
in trying to determine whether what we are doing
for our veterans in our home is correct,
to try to get a profile
of
the
type
of
veteran
we
have
in
our
home.
We have studied 1,022 veterans.
They are scattered in a
majority of our domiciliary facilities -- in
large communities
like Los Angeles,
in small communities like Clinton,
Iowa, and
in those in between.
This gave us a cross-section of about 12
per cent of our total domiciliary load.
Included in this volume
is all of the background material from which we drew our conclusions,
so that if in
reading this you find that our conclusions are in error,
at least any student of the subject can
go back to the basic material,
the case histories,
the interviews,
and all
other things upon which the conclusions were
based,
and draw their own conclusions.
This we feel is a basic
document.
There are some rather significant things that have
come out of this study,
some things that I think may surprise
you.
We have been able to find that in many of our domiciliaries
veterans who have been there for five and six years and more,
sleeping in rooms that are barrack-like in which there are beds
next to beds, when asked the name of the Veteran sleeping in the
bed on either side of him says,
"I don't know.'"
"Where does he
come .from?"
"I don't know.!'. "Who is he?!’
"I. do not know."
This would indicate
that in some way we have failed to
make these men feel that they are part of our community,
part of
the life that they should be responsible for, because it is important that we integrate them in our society.
This is true
because of the type of facility we operate.
(Not that
they are
not operated well), but because they are probably too big.
We
have taken people out of the communities in which they have their
relatives and their friends and have moved them into a sheltered
existence in a strange area.
Thus they have built around themselves a barrier for their own protection.
Not only did we find that they did not know the names of
those who slept next to them, but our study group from the Policy
and Evaluation Staff who went up to Bath, New York, found other
strange and significant
things. At least a half hour before meal
time -- and in Bath, New
York, because of the number of members
and
the
limited
facilities
for
feeding,
they
have
to
have
two
servings -- the members line up waiting for meals.
They go
through the cafeteria line getting meals which are well prepared,
nutritious,
and there are no complaints about the meals.
They
sit at the tables in utter silence, never talking to their
neighbors on their right or their left.
My group who went to
Bath, New York said it was rather strange.
There was no noise
except the occasional clutter of tableware on dishes.
They
finished the meal and walked out without any communication between
each other.
We
can
cite
such
other
instances
171
that
make
us
feel,although
we have tried to do as humane and as proper a job as we could,
that our present domiciliary facilities do not answer the needs
of those veterans who need some kind of a home.
In order to
determine what a better kind of system might cost, we have also
set about to determine what the cost would be to bring our
domiciliaries up to what we would consider satisfactory,
modern
standards,
The cost runs somewhere around approximately $180
million.
It is not that we mean to spend this $180 million to
do this remodernization of our present facilities,
because we
feel that a much better type of facility and much better service
can be rendered to the veteran by building smaller facilities
closer to their homes and cities of residence in which every
attempt,
every modern device will be used to bring this man back
to activity in his own
community.
Whether that activity is
simply to go out into a foster home,
go out into a nursing home,
or go
out into a sheltered workshop,
at least he will not be
divorced
from
the
life
and
the
society
in which
he
was
brought
up.
If this new concept does not cost any more than the remodeling of the old concept, we certainly feel that this is
preferable.
This is one of the other things that the Policy and
Evaluation Staff is
attempting to find out.
There are problems
in
there
the
future
has
been
that
we
some
talk
want
answers
about
a
for.
You
all
know
government-supported
that
and
sponsored insurance program for the medical care of the aged
under socidl security.
We would like to do a study in the next
year or so to determine what such an Act would do to the Veterans
Administration.
We have a great many opinions, but we need facts
to determine whether a veteran who is eligible under social
security to go to any hospital of his choice would be willing or
would care to go to a veterans hospital.
If we should find that
the majority want to go to other hospitals,
we would have to
recognize that this would have a tremendous impact on our futuré
program, but until we have the facts and until we know what the
impact of this new kind of legislation would have on the Veterans
Administration,
there is no way to plan.
There are many other
areas of study that I think you would agree need intensive investigation.
We are gathering the facts upon which to determine
what
is
the
proper
answer.
In
a
democracy
such
as
ours,
the
answers must be developed by all people -- you and us -- who have
some interest in the problem based on knowledge of the facts.
The answers have to come because we working together,
us, you and
others, knowing what the facts are and what the future holds,
must determine what is the best program for the VA to follow in
the future;
best for the
veteran,
and best for the nation.
Thank
you.
CHAIRMAN
KNIGHT:
Any
questions
from
the
Conference?
MR. KOLENDA (NEW MEXICO):
I would like to ask Dr. Mandell
one question.
Actually I have two questions.
As you know,
there
is some criticism about the domiciliary missions of veterans.
If
you study only those veterans,
how are you sure that your conclusions will be adequate?
DR. MANDELL:
You are correct.
We have only tried to get an
idea of what we have now in our domiciliary program.
This is not
to say what we should have in the program.
As I told you, we
feel that actually the program that we are operating is not an
adequate program.
We should,
therefore,
change our whole concept
of the need of the veteran for this type of after-hospital care.
We
have
been
calling
this
172
type
of
care
rehabilitation
and
and what we are
restoration,
this will take some 10 to 15
and phase out the old,
is to
centers
across
the
country
and
hoping to do in the future,
years to build in the new program
build restoration and rehabilitation
close
to
our
present
hospitals
where
those veterans who are finished with hospital care, but not yet
ready for either economic,
social,
or physical reasons to go out
into the community,
will be brought into condition where they
can go out into the community.
These restorations centers will
help these veterans who need some kind of help to be able to get
back into their community,
and when I said back into the community
originally,
you may remember,
I said not necessarily back to his
own home.
It may be to a foster home,
it may be to a boarding
home, it may be to a nursing home, but at least back as close
to his original environment
as we can get him.
This would mean
our whole administrative policy in these new centers would be
based on different criteria entirely.
It would be for those
veterans who need some kind of rehabilitation and restoration,
to bring them back into the community in which they belong.
MR. KOLENDA:
Thank you, Dr. Mandell.
The other question
I would like to ask is, are you accessible for suggestions and
what is the procedure for making these suggestions?
DR. MANDELL:
We certainly are accessible to suggestions.
The way we have been getting our suggestions up until now, is
trying to go out into the field and meeting what we call the
rank and file,
the grass roots.
We would hope that we would
get suggestions from every possible place in the country,
from
every hospital in the country, from every individual in the
country.
We have no monopoly on all of the best ideas.
We are
looking for ideas.
We need suggestions.
Now, when you speak of
the method,
I suppose any one can forward any kind of suggestion
to the Chairman of the Policy and Evaluation Staff, VA, Central
Office, Washington, D.C,
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA):
Doctor,
I believe you touched
on your group also making a study of medical care for the aged.
You mentioned present legislation and proposed or pending legislation.
Apparently your group is making some study of this and
my question is, I wonder if you have given any consideration to
the possibility that the answer to the solution would be on
the
same basis as medical and hospital aid for Federal civil service
employees, whether something like that might take care
of the
aged?
You
DR. MANDELL:
Let me
mean that an insurance
MR.
SLONEKER:
see if I understand your question.
program be established for the aged?
- Yes.
DR. MANDELL:
As you know,
the social security program,
at
least as the President defines it, is called an insurance program.
It does not cover everybody,
only those who are covered by social
security.
There has been proposed that those not covered by
social security should be covered by some other method of insurance.
While we are interested in these particular areas of investigation,
they are not particularly pertinent to the veterans of America.
Our problems primarily,
I have to admit,
are the veterans of
America.
Now,
there has been a proposal,
and we attempted to study
this proposal to see whather there was a possibility of developing
an insurance program for the veterans of America entitling every
veteran to care in a Veterans Administration hospital.
This shows
173
you how far afield we get.
it was impractical,
but it
CHAIRMAN
DR.
KNIGHT:
MANDELL:
This proposal
didn't mean we
Any
Thank
other
you
we had
didn't
questions?
very
I
to drop because
investigate it.
guess
not.
much.
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Ladies and gentlemen of the Conférence,
we continue with the section of this Conference which is likewise
akin to the theme of the Conference, "Aging with Dignity."
We
have with us this afternoon several speakers who by virtue of their
background and experience,
are well qualified to address themselves
to this subject.
I shall leave it to the next gentleman that I
will present to you to introduce the speakers whose names appear
upon your program, but, first,
I have the privilege of presenting
to
you his
predecessor
in
office,the
former
Director
of
the
Special
Staff on Aging of the Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare.
He was here and addressed this Conference last year and I am sure
that most of you will recall that, and that many of you are personally acquainted with him.
In his position as the Director of
the Special Staff he had the responsibility for the conduct of the
White House Conference on Aging.
It is my pleasure now to present
to you, Mr. Robert H. Grant,
-Mr. Grant.
REMARKS BY ROBERT H. GRANT, FORMER DIRECTOR, SPECIAL
STAFF ON AGING, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCATION, AND
WELFARE
MR. GRANT;
Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
ladies and gentlemen.
I would say that I like to be introduced as the former Director
of the White House
Conference.
I would like to give you a
little history.
About two years ago, Congressman Fogarty, Democrat from the State of Rhose Island, having surveyed the field
of aging, having talked to many of his colleagues in both the
House and the Senate,
introduced a bill to set up a White House
Conference on Aging.
Why?
Because Mr. Fogarty and his associates felt that there prevailed in this country some significant
problems relative to our aging population,
and those problems
fell in categories such as housing, medical care,
income maintenance, free time activities,
religion,
and so forth.
In setting up the White House Conference,
the House and
the Senate appropriated for administrative purposes something
over $500,000
to take care of the administrative details of the
Conference.
In addition,
they made available to the Department
of Health, Education and Welfare approximately a million dollars
to be given to the states in the form of non-matching grants
so that each of the states and territories could survey their
problems in the identical fields of aging and to give their
surveys to the White House Conference, which was to take place
in the future. The Department,
as one of its initial acts, created
an advisory committee made up of well-known authoritative individuals
in the field of aging.
This group consisted of approximately 150
people.
The advisory committee was chaired by former
Congressman Robert Kean of New Jersey,
a Republican.
Initially,
the first responsibility of this advisory committee was to make
a determination as to what should be done in order to start the
Conference in its proper perspective.
It was decided to divide
the advisory committee into 20 subcommittees,
each of these subcommittees having a special responsibility in a field of aging,
that is, housing, medical care,
income maintenance,
and so forth
and so on.
174
Over a period of some months,
these committees turned
out what we call background papers.
These were documents which
were available to the states and pointed up‘facts,
figures,
and data relative to the particular subject matter.
While this
was going on, we initiated the grant mechanism to the 50-o0dd
states and territories.
Most of the states accepted a grant
of from 10,000 to 15,000
in order to make a survey of their
own problems in aging,
and as a result of this grant,
they
carried out at the grass roots level -- in the villages,
in the
towns,
in the big cities -- they found that there were a number
of problems dealing with our so-called "aging population."
turn
We
over
requested
to
us
the
a report
states
of
as
their
a
result
findings.
of
this
Prior
survey
to
the
to
White
House Conference we had received a detailed report from each
of the states in regard to this most significant problem,
and
as a result of these reports, we turned out a document called
"Aging in the States,’ which is a compilation of the facts
relative to this problem in each of the 50
states and territories.
At the White House
Conference, we had 2800 delegates from all
over our nation and in addition to this, we had close to 400
to 500
guests, newspaper people,
and interested individuals.
This is a familiar area.
Our headquarters for the White
House Conference was in this hotel.
Our registration facilities
were in the same areas that you now occupy.
How did we select
the delegates?
The Federal Government did not select the delegates.We gave a quota to each state based on a formula that
could be compared roughly to Congressional representation.
The
State of New York, for instance,
had 100 delegates;
Alaska,
ten; Puerto Rico,
ten, and so forth and so on.
It was the responsibility of the state,
the responsibility of the Governor,
to séiect the delegates.
Once selected,
the delegates had the
problem of determining to which of the 20 areas they preferred
assignment.
After some study and analysis and after initial
reports from the states, we found that we could combine the
20 subcommittees into roughly ten groups.
We notified the
states to this effect,
and asked them to assign their delegates
to the sections of their choice,based on the state assignment
each delegate was sent to the section of his or her choice.
This was not done by the Federal Government.
We had 20 sections,
ten working groups,
and 140 different working areas.
=
As you
Conference.
a great
deal
may have heard, we had a controversial White House
It was controversial to this extent:
that there is
of
public
interest
in
the
field
of medical
care
and how it should be paid for.
We did not receive a state report that did not in some way cover this subject. There is a view
point that is expressed by the American Federation of Labor.
There
is a viewpoint that is expressed by the American Medical Association.
There is a viewpoint that is expressed by individuals
who had no particular ties. The voting at the Conference took
place at the section level.
As a result of this Conference, we
have turned out 20 specific statements of policy and a set of
recommendations.
Each
of
the
upon
were
in
attendance
by
those
who
20
statements
at
the
of policy
were
voted
Conference.
In addition,
it is
proposed that a formal document will be
turned out by the White House Conférence Staff as a report to
the President.
The deadline on this report, as I understand,
is
April 9.
Now, I think that The American Legion, both as Legionnaires and as citizens,
have a responsibility in regard to the
$73
field
of
ference
at
the
aging.
as
an
We
Conference
Conference.
can
excellent
It
so
characterize
Conference,
much
doesn't
as
it
make
any
is
our
but
White
it
what
is
House
not
happens
difference
what
Con-
what
after
happens
the
the
viewpoint
of the American Federation of Labor is or. the American Medical
Association.
The difference that prevails is what is your viewpoint as citizens of this country in view of the
legislation
which is proposed.
Now, with these remarks,
I will stop here,
except to give you one other fact.
I just give you this backs
ground in relation to the introduction of my colleague.
I have
been an employee of the National Institutes of Health for about
12 years.
I was asked to assume the position of Director of
"the
White
stitutes
House
of
Conference
on
a detail
from
the
National
In-
Health.
Having gone through some 14 months of a rather rough
obstacle course,
I have elected to return to the campus of
National Institutes
good friend of mine
the
of Health and put the finger on a very
who is now sitting to my left to pick up
the cudgels,
and to assume the responsibility with his colleagues
for turning out the report. This has been an interesting, worthwhile experience.
Having worked in the field of aging related
to the White House Conference for 14 months, one does not cast
off the very real problem in regard to our older population.
We have reached one conclusion,
and when I started on the White
House Conference,
the definition of aging was anyone who is
ten years older than yourself.
Having
been through the White House Conference, we have been told that
there is another definition and that is that a women is old
when a man thinks she is charmless,
and a man is old when a
woman
thinks
he
is
harmless.
Thank
you.
I want to introduce
Executive Director of the
to you Mr. Warren Roudebush,who is the
Federal Council on Aging,
and who is
now
Special
Acting
Director
REMARKS
SPECIAL
of
the
Staff
on Aging.
Mr.
Roudebush.
OF WARREN ROUDEBUSH, ACTING DIRECTOR,
STAFF ON AGING, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH,
EDUCATION, AND WELFARE
MR. ROUDEBUSH:
Thank you, Bob, and thank you for the
opportunity to be here.
Last night, I read the statement filed
by Director Corcoran with the Senate Special Committee on Aging
outlining the activities of the Rehabilitation Commission.
It
is one of the most impressive demonstrations of concern and
effort
by
a national
organization
that
I know.
In
the
outline,
he refers to tbe interests of many Posts in encouraging adult
education,
to the support and cooperation of vocational and
rehabilitation programs,
the interest in special counselling
and placement programs for older workers,
the participation of
the Departments
and Posts in promoting educational efforts to
offset unfair age-discrimination attitudes,
the great contribution of volunteer services,
and the variety of activities
producing recreational and leisure time opportunities.
I refer to these activities in order to set the
perspective in which I think the White House Conference on Aging
should be viewed.
The Conference did not start your programs.
Most,
if not all, of your activity in this field grew out of
your concern with the needs to be met before the Conference
was even thought of, and even had the Conference never taken
place,
and
I
trust
your
efforts
would
effectiveness.
176
continue
to
grow
in
scope
Now, then, does the fact that there was a Conference fit
into this perspective? What was its purpose,
and how do we move
ahead?
I would say that the White House Conference on Aging
had a bhreefold purpose.
In part, it was to bring together
and pool the experience,
the understanding,
the sense of needs,
and
the
judgments
of
citizens
from
all
over
the
nation,
rep-
resenting the whole rangeof our society,
and then in part,
the Conference was to spread awareness and further stimulate
general public interest in opportunities and challenges inherent
in this situation that has developed so rapidly in our time, and,
thirdly,
the Conference
produced blueprints,
road-maps,
if you
will, for moving ahead more systematically, more comprehensively,
and with better coordination of all the resources of our society.
For
a
year,
true
some
those
of
us working
four
significance,
days
the
in
on
the
January
Conference
Conference
seemed
was
not
a
planning
climax.
But
a climax,
but
for
over
in
its
a begin-
ning.
The challenge is to see if those blueprints or road maps
can serve to move us all ahead, faster and more effectively,
to the objectives which you and other groups, public and private,
have already been moving toward.
This product of the Conference
has been analyzed to fall into
four basic areas; first,
the older
person's economic situation;
second, his health and medical problems;
third, his pattern of living; fourth the mobilization of
resources, public and private,
to improve these three preceding
situations.
As Mr. Grant said,
there were 20 sections at the White
House Conference.
The section on rehabilitation has made recommendations
that crop up in all four of these basic areas.
There are 53
specific recommendations.
I hope you know something of them already,
and it is not my purpose to go through
them here.
But I most sincerely hope that you will take time
to read and reflect on them carefully.
I am sorry only a limited
number of copies of them have been
in circulation up to this time.
They will
be in the official report to be published next month
and they will also appear in a separate Conference publication
devoted solely to the subject of rehabilitation.
White
How
House
you
take
advantage
Conference
of
on Aging
termine.
I wish to report
in the Federal Government.
to
this
fact
that
briefly
what
is,
you
of
course,
there
was
for
you
we
are
a
to de-
doing
In the Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare,
Secretary Ribicoff has the responsibility for a large portion
of the Federal program and resources devoted to older people,
and in addition to this, Secretary Ribicoff serves as Chairman
of the Federal Council on Aging,
a cabinet level committee that
includes
the
Departments
of
Agriculture,
Commerce,
Labor
and
Treasury,
and the Veterans Administration and the Housing and
Home Finance Agency.
Secretary Ribicoff has asked Assistant
Secretary James Quigley to give daily personal attention to the
matters in these fields,
to give them maximum support.
The
first job both in the department and in the Federal Council in
moving ahead with action on the WH Conférence recommendations.
Yesterday,
I sat with him and the heads of the six operating
agencies of Health, Education,
and Welfare while we reviewed
where
we
stood.
Systematically,
we
are
identifying
the
re-
commendations calling for Federal action.
These we classify
according:cto whether we can move under existing authority and
with available resources.
Some of those require legislative
T77
authorization and are already in bills before Congress,
such
as Senate bill 4222,
the Health Insurance Benefits Act.
There
are in the Conference report hundreds of recommendations.
Only
a portion of them are directed to Federal action,
and of these
some may be analyzed as not feasible or not desirable at this
time, but we are trying to make sure that every one is considered,
that decision is made on them, and that we move accordingly.
I hope this pattern of action may have some significance
for you
as you return to your Departments and Posts,
and for
those who feel they would like to. devote a little more study to
the situation of older people, please permit me to make a small
commercial,
I refer to the same book that Mr. Grant carried
with him and didn't quote, the chart book that the Federal
Council on Aging published for the Conference.
I can relate
it to the Veterans Administration,
for if we hadn't had Mr.
Whittier and his
Deputy,
Brad Morsey make Dr. Milton Forster
available to head up this project, we wouldn't have this
chart book today.
This is by way of giving recognition to a very fine public servant, Dr. Forster, who .is sitting right over there.
He
did a beautiful job with this chart book.
In it is presented
quickly and in simple fashion significant data on income, housing,
health, employment,
and retirement opportunities for older people,
so I conclude with an item from the chart book.
We had trouble,
of course,
in pinning down the age groups we were writing about,
so we came up with arbitrary definitions.
Middle age is 45
to
64; older people are 65
and over; and aging applies to both.
Then
we said in effect,
"For statistical purposes if I am past 45
and
relatively independent and self-directed I am in
the''aging category, but if I am substantially dependent for physical,
economic,
or other less tangible reasons,
then I am aged.’ The goal we all
share,
in rehabilitation and other fields,
is the well-being of
increasing numbers in the aging category and the reduction of
numbers in the dependent,
'"aged'" category.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
I am happy to learn that so far as
years are concerned,
at least I am still in the middle group.
These gentlemen very kindly consented to answer questions,
if
any of you have any which you would like to propound.
I understand that Mr. Roudebush took a little vacation in 1944 and 1945
to serve as a gunnery officer on a destroyer,
so I am sure we
would be glad to have you fire some questions at him.
Are there
any questions?
Does anyone have any comment that he would like
to make?
The question is whether the books will be available,
where can you get them, and how much will they cost.
MR. ROUDEBUSH:
Let me take advantage and refer to the
two things.
This is in print in limited supply.
Individual
copies are available if you will write to our department.
They
can be purchased in quantity,
something like $22 a hundred,
from
the
Government
Printing
Office.
The
other
document
that
I have here,
and I think I will wave
it just a little bit, is
the hard core product of the Conference,
the recommendations,
approximately 160 pages.
We put this together in a hurry and I
don't mind saying for the specific reason that a good many states
notified us their legislatures were in session and if they had
to wait until April 9, when the official report will be put out,
they would be severely handiciapped,
so that we got off just a
minimum number of an emergency publication and really I cannot
say that there is a supply of them available now, but on April
9 the official report will be available,
It will be sent to all
p
178
delegates.
It will be sent to the state commissions on aging,
a modest amount,
and it is my feeling that we must tie in as
closely as we can to the state commissions on aging working
through regional representatives of HEW and in your Departments
it
seems
to
me
want to make
as it may be
--
here
I
am
offering
advice
--
your own tie-in with the state
constituted in your state.
that
you
commission
would
on
aging
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Are there any other
comments?
If not, may
I take this opportunity
questions or
to express to
appearance
I
both
of
you
gentlemen
here
and
the
for
thanks
your
of
this
addresses
Conference
to
us.
for
your
understand
you
will stay with
us for a little time and it may be later there
will be some other questions.
At this time, we come to the next
part of the agenda in this section.
As most of you know,
the
National Convention at Miami directed that there be a committee
appointed,
a joint committee,
for the purpose of study of the
problem that we are discussing.
This joint committee consists
of representatives from this Rehabilitation Commission and from
our Economic Commission.
The gentlemen who constitute the
committee selected under that direction or resolution are here
on the platform and at this time it is
my pleasure to introduce
one of them who was, with the others,
a representative of our
organization at the White House Conference and who is a Vice
Chairman
of
our
Rehabilitation
Commission,
Milton
Applebaum.
MR, APPLEBAUM:
Thank you.
Mr, Chairman and conferees,
I was one of the three delegates invited to attend the White
House Conference which Mr. Roudebush mentioned.
The other
delegates, my colleagues,
were people well known to you.
Let
me introduce them at this time.
Clarence Bird, our Staff
Director on Economics,
and John Corcoran, Director of our Rehabilitation Commission.
I am sure you will be interested in
getting their
Conference as
immediate reactions
and impressions from
well as my own brief remarks that I have
the
re-
flected on at some length.
The semantics of these words 'aged
and aging" have given me as I have gotten into this picture,
and the preceding speaker indicated that he had a most serious
job
of
defining,
couragement
in
a sort
some
of
a feeling
of
futility
and
dis-
ways.
The other night,
and this is one of the benefits of
coming to these rehabilitation meetings,
a distinguished comrade
of mine, from Illinois and I hope he will forgive me if he is
in the audience,
if I just let his name be anonimous -- I would
be glad to identify him -- pointed out to me that in the winemaking process wine is considered young, wine that is aging, but
when it becomes ripe and fit and
reaches its proper purpose,
which is human consumption,
then it for the first time becomes
aged.
With that comparison,
I hope the human race will follow
and fulfill itself in that respect.
general field of rehabilitation, we
In this field, as in the
do not deal with the indi-
vidual who is provided for or can provide for himself.
He is
no problem to us.
But we do deal with the individual who for
some reason or another needs the help of his community,
whether
he is a veteran or non-veteran.
Therefore,
of the
people
older,
Burke
early
I was
quite
gratified
to know
that
the
Congress
United States had by resolution recognized the problem of
becoming older and the increased number of people becoming
and I was very honored to be named by National Commander
as one of the delegates and I came to the Conference the
part of January, right after my appointment and participated
179
with the other 2475
delegates.
I felt gratified that there
were so many prominent and able people interested in this problem, which in older days was not
a problem, but the life insurance companies tell us the longevity that you and
I can
have is so much more than what our fathers and grandfathers had.
Our three delegates participated in the various groups to each
one's
enlightenment.
I was
gratified
that
the
Conference
addressed itself to the general community problems that are
arising in this field and that there was no comparison,
invidious
or otherwise,
with religious groups or religious areas or sectional
groups or even veterans,
because we feel we have a hold on the
veterans' problems of longevity based on the great experience
we have had in working with one arm of the government,
the Veterans
Administration.
I have every assurance that when the official report comes out, it will give the general picture a great deal of
clarification as to the thinking that is going on among all of us,
and not only as to
the veterans' problems which have been
the
immediate concern of the conferees,
you people, myself,
that are
here today.
In many respects the Veterans Administration.
has carried
forward and for us, many of the recommendations
that are just
beginning to be expressed in a general way, and I preface that
because that is a preface to a point that I would like to impress
as being my own and I trust one that is shared by many of The
American Legion conferees here. The Legion has realized,
as we
have concerned ourselves for all these years with the veteran,
we would not be serving his cause if we urged that his specialized
interest should come first or should be combined in the general
picture.
Many of the things that we devote our attention to and
put concentration on are not part of the general public aid picture so we have never,
and speaking now on behalf of the Legion,
urged veterans'
views on this general picture,
the problems of
the aged and aging.
This is as definite as we would feel, with
‘the vigor we have had in the past and we have now, if there
was any attempt made to take away from the veteran any of the
things
for
of
or
based
our
benefits
that
on
problems
these
comrades.
we
have
fought
that
war
for
so
services
long
or
gives
sought
to so
many
I urge each of you, therefore,
to consider carefully this
proven experience of The American Legion that programs for the
older veteran and the general programs which should go forward
together are nevertheless somewhat mutually exclusive.
Now,
our National Executive Committee,
in May,
1960 I think,
appreciated that we should go forward,
and we can go forward for
ourselves as well as for the general public, as the Legion does
do, in creating the special committee of which I have had the
honor of heading since January 1961.
The committee's work as defined for us in the resolution,
is to study these problems of the aged and aging veterans and
report recommendations,
if any, to our commissions from which
we originate and to the the NEC itself,
and we hope we will
have at least a tentative series of recommendations in the Spring
meeting.
I would like to introduce to you the members of my
committee
know
is
who
are
There is
as Baldy.
here,
Clinton
up
here
on
the
platform.
J. Ross Foust of Pennsylvania,
whom
And our Chairman of the afternoon,
Knight
that is here with us
York, and James Doon
of Virginia.
And
this afternoon,
there
of New Hampshire.
So
180
then
from
you
who
probably
I am sure
our
committee
is Joe Holzka of New
with Economics and
Rehab together,
I hope we will produce some real good for the
organization,
and the conferees here.
We did hold a meeting
Monday,
and we surveyed veterans' problems in the field of
pension and compensation,
which are really big problems on
which we are going forward,
and in Rehab,
as you know,
the
full
commission
and
staff
is
going
forward
and
we
have
sur-
veyed the problems of medicine and hospitals with particular
attention to these things which the older veteran is concerned
about now, namely,
out-patient care and nursing homes and the
domiciliaries.
We want to go into a little farther this new
thing that John Corcoran mentioned at the Rehab Commission
meeting on Monday, namely,
the restoration center, which seems
to be a coming thing,
at least with reference to the older
veteran who has both an economic and medical problem.
We went
into
the
field
of
employment
and
the
question
of
hiring
the
older veteran and also the question of housing,
and we are
going to depend a great deal on our first-hand information and
contacts so far as the older veterans housing on the experience
that the Economics Commission has acquired,
and Clarence Bird,
of course, had a special meeting on that for his executive
session of the Commission.
As I stated at the beginning of this report,
aging is
a relative term.
Many of the best years a Legionnaire can give
to his Post sometimes comes after retiring from his regular job.
Not every Legionnaire can get to be a Department Commander
after retirement,
and yet it has been done and I know it has
been done in at least one Department.
No doubt, we all know
of Oliver Wendell, Holmes,
the jurist, not the poet, but his son
the jurist, who was left for dead on a Civil War battlefield,
but recovered and lived to sit in the Supreme Court of the
United States and write learned legal opinions to the age of
90, when he got around to the question of whether he should retire and he did.
I should conclude with one comparison or
little story.
Maybe it illustrates the problem that my colleagues
and I see in this problem of the aged and aging.
I have to go
back in this to the time when I was working for a government
agency,
the Naturalization Service.
We had occasion to interview great numbers of people in a
short period of time,
and we were scheduled for a visit to a
particular town.
We were given the courtroom of the courthouse.
We did go into business in the courthouse,
but there weren't
enough seats.
My chief told me to go out there -- and there
were 12 seats on the jury box which no one wanted to enter, without invitation -- so in my own diplomatic way I went up and said,
"There are only.12 more seats available,
but anybody over 50
who feels a little bit shaky can come up and occupy them."
And
I went back to my interviews and my chief did to his, and 30
minutes later he looked at me and said:
'You haven't solved
our problem.
No one has gone into that jury box.
I will show
you
how
to do
it."
He went up and said to that same crowd,
"We have 12 seats
available.
Any lady 39 or over who wants to come up and occupy
those seats may do so."
Maybe they were 30 minutes more tired,
but I prefer to think that he had a more diplomatic and cogent
way of solving a problem which existed 30 minutes later as it
did originally.
That's the way I think we are going to find
that our problem,
the problems of my committee,
may well have
to be solved, not in terms of aged and aging, but in other terms,
in other fields and explanations,
maybe different semantics;
I
181
don't know, but that's the way we are addressing ourselves to
It is not alone ours.
the problems that have been given to us.
It is a problem of our major committees and the problems of
everybody because aging may not even exist as a term by the
Thank
I hope it may well be so.
time we get through with it.
you.
do
you
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Thank
have anything to add?
MR. BIRD:
Conference.
As
talk
at
great
I
you
very
much,
Thank you.
Mr. Chairman and
informed my Commission this
length
on
this
problem
of
the
Milt,
Clarence,
delegates to the
morning,
I could
aged,
but
first
I
wish to tell you of my observations in regard to the White
House Conference on Aging.
I attended the sessions which were
held at the Shoreham Hotel..The Chairman recognized me as representing The American Legion,
and all were very complimentary
of
the
medical
and
hospital
program
in
our
far
flung
Veterans
Administration hospital system.
It was realized by those present
that I could not participate in any deliberations regarding
attaching to the social security program hospitalization and
medical care, but I want to say at this time the Economic Commission probably was the first American Legion group to realize
the problem of the older Legionnaire and we implemented the
program of employing the older veteran.
We have a citationn program by which the various Departments of The American Legion
award citations to employers who have an outstanding record of
employing the older veteran.
Representation
country,
from
labor,
at
this
Conference
came
from management,
public
from
all
interest
over
the
groups,
and right down the line,
I wish to touch on one item discussed which The American Legion could support wholeheartedly,
and that was employing the older citizen (veteran) without discrimination as to age.
There were recommendations made about
supplementing the social security payments for those who wouldn't
take them until age 66 when they were available at age 65.
To
give those eligible,
for instance,
a two per cent increase if
they
waited
until
age
to
67,
age
66,
and
so
or
on.
four
per
cent
That
was
discussed
if
they
didn't
draw
at
great
length.
There were arguments on the other side to retire workers
earlier to make jobs for the younger group coming into the labor
market, but that would be against our American Legion position.
The group went into many details about not increasing social
security benefits.
Many present didn't want any increase in the
social security tax because where they worked,
the company had
its own retirement program,
and the more the employee put into
that program,
the better his retirement benefits were.
Another special item that was taken up was housing for the
elderly and I was very happy to have had a presentation made to
our Commission yesterday by a large construction firm which has
interested itself in building garden-type apartments or elevatortype apartments for elderly persons, with the idea in mind of
having a national organization like ours, The American Legion,
sponsoring such a thing.
A report of this will be made by our
Economic Commission.
Right now the Federal Government has in
the process of being built four different projects of 50
units
each, with variations of having a small infirmary,
supplying
nursing care. This is just a pilot program which the Congress
has directed be finished as quickly as possible to give it some
182
guidance
in
future
operations
of
building
homes
for
the
aged.
I have taken up enough of your time, but I think The
American Legion as an organization should seriously consider
the problem of the elderly veteran especially our World War
I veterans,
I think it will be good for the Legion to show
our older veterans and our older Legionnaires that we are deeply interested in their problems of not only employment,
but
their housing, medical care, and so on.
Thank you very much,
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
At this time I would like to call
on our Rehabilitation Director, John Corcoran,
for additional
remarks on this subject.
John.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Emory.
As I passed Bob McCurdy
he said:
"You have
eight minutes.”
I can do it in five.
Let
me attempt to wrap up the discussions and the observations
that
we have had during this panel and at the same time in the course
of the remarks give one or two impressions that I received
while attending the White House Conference on’the Aging.
First of all, why was The American Legion interested in
the White House Conference,
interested as a national organization,
and why did we send delegates?
Well, we felt a very
real responsibility to contribute to the Conference our observations and our experience
in the field in which the Conference was working.
Experience,
for example,
in housing and
employment for the older veteran,
pensions for those that are
disabled,
and particularly older disabled veterans in need,
the experience that we had seen the VA acquire in the medical
research field in geriatrics,
the experience that we are having
with the nursing care problems.
of
on
ness
We felt that we had a great contribution to make on behalf
veterans of this country to the White
House Conference
Aging and that,
too, since we were convinced of the sound-
the
the
of
the
programs
that
The
American
Legion
was
following,
we
felt that here was a good opportunity to emphasize those specific
Legion programs that had application to the Conference;
for
example,
the program that Clarence Bird is the Director of, which
includes the employment of the older worker.
What
did
that your
gates.
we
do?
national
In
As
you
organization
addition
to
that,
have
we
was
already
heard,
represented
encouraged
our
by
we
saw
to
three
it
dele-
Departments
to,
wherever possible,
have their Governors appoint them as delegates
to the White House Conference on Aging.
What did we not do?
We
did not agree in advance on any positions that we would take on
the subjects presented.
We did not vote en bloc.
The Conference,
as you know, was intended to do a number of things and to have
certain characteristics.
Because there was so much going on and
because delegates could only be assigned to a very small part of
the total considerations
and deliberations,
any impressions that
you take away
from the Conference are somewhat limited and circumscribed.
The Conference was intended to be comprehensive,
that
is,
their
problems.
planned
to
by
cover
The
in
entire
field
was
intended
citizens
and
the
non-professionals
political.
ference
the
It
wherever
of
the
the
aged
and
be
citizen-directed.
It
was
to
Governors
possible.
aging
were
It
and
encouraged
was
intended
to
appoint
to
be
non-
Democratic Congress authorized the White House Con1958
and the law was
signed by a Republican President.
183
It was intended to be non-paternalistic,
that is to say,
was intended to emphasize the need for self-help and not
emphasize exclusively the role of government in the care
the aged.
In
my
opinion,
the
White
House
achieved these characteristics.
it set out
to. do.
intend
What do we in
to do next?
information
on
the
It
Conference
pretty
pretty
well
it
to
of
well
achieved
what
The American Legion national organization
First of all, we intend to provide as much
Conference
policy
statements
and
recommenda-
tions as we can.
We intend to stimulate action on the part of
Departments and local Posts because that is where the work
has to be done and can be done,
and we intend to provide leadership wherever we can to the Departments and Posts.
The problem
of the aging and aged is an essential part of the National
Rehabilitation Commission's program and we intend to address
ourselves to that problem with all the abilities we possess.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN
O'CONNELL:
Just
four
minutes
and
59
seconds,
Bob.
back
At this time, I have the privilege of turning the
to our distinguished Chairman,
Bob McCurdy. Bob.
meeting
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank you, Vice Chairman Emory.
I
don't know whether you all know Vice Chairman Emory, or Vice
Commander Emory of the Rehabilitation Commission.
I think this
is the first session of this Commission where he has presided.
He is a very high class comrade from Denver, Colorado and I
think we should welcome him here,
too.
Thank you.
Our
Commander
next scheduled
and reports of
program is a speech by the National
the other committees meeting here in
session.
It is scheduled for five minutes from
take advantage of this five minutes for a short
Be
Friday,
prompt
and
be
.e«.The Conference
March 3, 1961..
back
at
recessed
184
now and
recess.
we
will
3:30.
to
reconvene
at
9:30
o'clock,
FRIDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 3, 1961
... The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel Statler, Washington, D, C.,, at 9:30 A, M., Dr. J. B.
Hollis presiding.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
We have come to our last meeting of the
Conference here and at this time
I would like to ask that you
stand and we will have Reverend Bill Adams, Past Department
Commander of the District of Columbia,
open the meeting in
prayer.
REVEREND
gratitude
for
ADAMS:
all
Gracious
of
the
Master,
blessings
give
that
we
to us
enjoy
in
hearts
of
our
country.
May we ever be ready to acknowledge that they come from Thee.
Give to us hearts that have a feeling for those who are in need,
those who have suffered from the ravages of war, especially the
widows and the orphans of our comrades.
Give to us
grace to be
ready and willing to find out the wounds and heal the broken
hearted and to live in that confidence that Thou are still greatly concerned for humanity.
Enrich our Nation with the vietues
of peace that we may indeed fulfill what we have always believed
to be God-given destiny for our country.
May we close our conferences here with Thy grace upon us in the richness of Thy
benediction through Jesus Christ,
our Lord, Amen.
MR.
Chairman?
MARKOWITZ
CHAIRMAN
(PENNSYLVANIA):
HOLLIS:
Would
you
recognize
me,
Mr.
Yes.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I would like to request for those of us
who will not be here and those who are gone that this
Conference
be recessed or ended in honor of Edward Nowak, who died yesterday in Buffalo,
and who was a former member of the National
Staff,
always interested in veterans and their problems,
and it
is with a sad feeling of humility that I make that motion.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Thank you, Mike.
First on our agenda
this morning is Rehabilitation Staff -- Discussion of topics
and questions not covered in other panels.
At this time
I would
like to introduce Warren MacDonald, Assistant Director of Rehabilitation,
who will take over at this time.
REMARKS BY WARREN
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF
MacDONALD
REHABILITATION
MR. MacDONALD:
Good morning,
ladies and gentlemen.
As
Vice Chairman Doc Hollis told you, we are sort of on the last
leg of this 38th Annual Rehabilitation Conference.
As you will
note, from the program for this morning, we have reserved this
portion for a discussion of topics and questions not covered in
other panels.
We do
have one topic sent in from a service
office
to
take
up
in
a few
booklet
by
reason
of
the
officer
in
just
few
minutes.
the
Government
officials.
a
minutes.
fact
that
I will
it
call
It is
not
was
not
on
the
listed
a
in
your
question
for
interested
service
First,
I would like to comment,
however,
that this would
be an excellent opportunity for you
folks to tell us what is
good and what is bad about this conference, what you would like
185
to see in future
comments I would
to
give
back
it
home
a
years, and
appreciate
little
that
more
would
so forth.
If you have any such
hearing them and if you would prefer
thought
be
fine.
and
I want
write
to
to
us
remind
have not registered I suggest that you do so if
reason than it assures that you will get a copy
proceedings
of
the
entire
Conference.
after
you
for no
of the
other
printed
you
Programming
that
if
get
you
a conference
of this type is very interesting and sometimes very trying.
You
have to make a lot of last minute changes here and there and
almost nothing quite goes as planned,
but I have enjoyed programming this Conference.
I hope it has gone relatively well.
I would like to point out, however,
some of the things that can
happen.
Insofar as the selection of panel discussion leaders is
concerned,
the ultimate has finally happened.
All five members
of a panel will be umable to be present this morning.
That is
the panel beginning at 10 o'clock.
Elmer Barfield of Georgia,
Pat Kohler of West Virginia, Wilbur Henline of Oklahoma,
all
regret that they could not remain to serve on this VR&E panel,
but they had to return to their respective home states.
Chic
Madia, Department Adjutant of Wyoming,
could not attend.
In
addition, we had asked Jim Lockman of New York to serve on this
panel, but George Mead advised us just as we were about to go
to print that Jim had been involved in an
auto accident and
would not be in
Washington.
We certainly hope that Jim gets
well quickly,
However, we have plenty of other excellent Service Officers
to call upon and three have already graciouslv consented to fill
in and serve on the VR&E panel.
These are "Bubba" Akin of Georgia,
whom I will ask to serve as chairman; Reuben Garnett of Washington
State,
and Charles Kohler, Department Service Officer of
Pennsylvania,
for the Philadelphia Regional Office.
I Have no
further comments to make about the changes,
although you have
just observed that Reverend Bill Adams has come to us this morning to substitute for the
National Chaplain who had to leave
town last night.
The Reverend has also agreed to come back at
noon for our benefliction.
of
ing
the
or
Are there any comments at this time
Conference itself?
Aré there any
otherwise?
Hermann
Wenige,
Post
concerning
suggestions
Service
the
for
Officer
conduct
chang-
of
Indiana.
MR. WENIGE:
Mr. Chairman,
the question I want to bring up
this morning is why is not not commercial life insurance exempt
as income on the same basis as United States Government and
National Service Life Insurance?
Unddr our present regulations
U. S.
Government
and
National
full amount of $10,000
widow or children of a
Service
commercial
life
expense of
would like
my office.
last illness and
to cite and they
burial.
came at
No.
War
insurance
up to
only
in
the
I have two
practically
and
it
was
allowed
and
the
veteran
a $10,000
widow
186
was
died
amount
of
the
cases that I
the same time
National
granted
in
Life
the
to
childwidow
pension
carried
II
exempt
policy payable in a lump sum to his widow.
There were no
ren,
The burial expenses amount to $1100,
That left the
$8,900 out of that insurance policy.
I filed a claim for
He
A World
is
the
of the
hand,
Hospital
Louisville.
1:
Insurance
VA
at
Case
Life
is exempt as income in the case
deceased veteran.
On the other
Insurance
$60 a month.
This
was
A
shortly
World
The
able
the
after
War
in
a
funeral
P.L.86-211
I
veteran
lump
sum.
widow's
husband
expenses
into
effect.
also
in
the
Louisville
also
were
no
children.
died
carried
went
a commercial
There
were
the
same,
Case
policy
$1100.
of
No.
VA
As
That
2:
hospital.
$3000
it
left
the
pay-
happened
widow
$1900 from that insurance policy.
I filed a claim for her
pension and it was denied on the ground of excessive income.
$1800,
as you know, is the maximum amount of income allowable under
86-211.
This widow had $1900, or one hundred over the maximum.
She was 59
years of age.
She was too young for social security
and too old to secure employment.
I contended that that discrimination is eminently unjustified.
I can see no difference in $10,000 paid by the
government or $10,000 paid by a commercial insurance company.
In my
book
$10,000
is
still
$10,000
regardless
of
the
source
of the insurance policy.
I believe that that question is a
very serious one.
I know the service officers here have had
similar cases.
I have scores of them where because of a few
hundred dollars over the maximum amount a widow was denied
pensions.
It is my contention that something should be done to
equalize the insurance from whatever source,
that an amount up
to $10,000 be exempted in the matter of life insurance regard-
less
of
the
For
Winfield
gress.
source.
the
information
Denton
It is
my
of
of
Indiana
hope,
if
the
has
conferees
introduced
this
conference
here,
such
as
Congressman
a
bill
in
a conference
Con-
can
not take action on this matter,
that individual service officers
will urge their Congressmen to support that bill so that widows
in both categories will have their claims considered on an
equal
basis.
That
law
as
it
is
now
might
seriously
affect
the
widow
of any man in this audience today.
Only Tuesday the National
Commander in his talk before the Veterans Affairs Committee
stressed the importance of extending the time for reinstatement
of Government insurance,
showing that because of financial pressures a good many men had to drop their insurance when they came
out of service,
and that is true especially of World War I
veterans,
and then when it was too late to feinstate their
policies they were
financially able to do so.
They purchased commercial insurance at a great deal higher
premium in an effort to protect their loved ones and that very
act has jeopardized the returns which might be expected in the
way of pensions.
The Act to protect those loved ones has
succeeded only in for a period of time from several months to a
year denying pensions to these widows.
I ask the conferees
here to take that under very serious consideration.
MR. MacDONALD:
Thark
the subject I mentioned Mr.
wanted to raise here on the
you very much, Mr. Wenige.
This is
Wenige had written to us about and
floor.
Perhaps some of you have
further thoughts or comments to
issue of course goes to the law
offer in this connection.
itself which counts under
The
the
pension
insurance
for
system
commercial
dollar regardless of how
beneficiary, whereas the
life
much
same
and
law
as
income
regardless of
excludes from
how
the
dollar
used by the
computation
of income moneys received through the NSLI or USGLI,
or even
Servicemen's Indemnity System.
He feels that this money should
be equated.
I may make one further comment that this issue came
to the last National Convention and was discussed on the floor
there,
The Convention voted to reject the issue, resolution 499.
187
Herman, however,
cussion on this,
being adopted.
MR.
COX
feels that he
possibly with
(OHIO):
This
would like to hear further disa view to a subsequent resolution
is
the
last
meeting
of
this
con-
ference.
I have been to every meeting since Monday.
Since we
met here a year ago The
American Legion and other veterans
organizations,
every veteran and his dependents,
have lost their
greatest friend they ever had up on the Hill, Edith Nourse
Rogers,
I have been somewhat disappointed that ever since we
came here Monday I have never heard her name even mentioned,
even up on
the Hill where she always had that fine welcoming
speech for us.
The name was not mentioned,
let alone standing
in silent tribute for Edith Nourse Rogers.
I wonder why.
Thank you.
MR. MacDONALD:
I appreciate your comment and I do agree
with you very much, Mr. Cox.
As you know, however,
the National
Convention paid high tribute to Mrs. Rogers' Resolution 605
and
a part of the legislative program that the Commander presented
to the House Veterans Affairs on Tuesday incorporates a bill
introduced on our behalf which seeks to name the Bedford,
Massachusetts VA Hospital for Mrs. Edith Nourse Rogers.
I would
like to make this one comment in her connection.
It was brought
to my attention by Mr. T. O. Kraabel,
our former Director and
now Director of the VRE section in the VA, that it is
interesting to note that in a span of only ten months four of the principal architects of our Veterans Affairs program passed away and
all were above the age of 75.
This includes General Hines, former Congressman Rankin,
Mrs. Rogers,
and our own Watson Miller.
Are there any other
comments?
Thank you.
One other thought I would like to point
out is that in connection with the programming of this conference I have learned one lesson.
If I had to do Wednesday's
session over again I would have put the ADP discussion in the
afternoon.
I had the feeling when we came back after lunch
that day,
even though we had many questions and many interesting questions
to discuss,
that the session was sort of anticlimactic.
The big
show had been in the morning.
The next
time I will keep that in mind for purpose of scheduling program.
With that I think I will turn the rostum back to the presiding
officer, Doc Hollis.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Next on our agenda is the panel on
vocational rehabilitation and education and the fellow that I
am going to introduce now needs no introduction.
Youall know
him, but I will present him, T. O. Kraabel, Director of Vocational
Rehabilitation and Education Service of the Veterans Administration.
T. 0.7?
I have asked T. O. to introduce his staff in turn, so you
may proceed with your remarks.
REMARKS OF T. O. KRAABEL, DIRECTOR
VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION AND
EDUCATIONAL SERVICE - AND STAFF
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you, Dr. Hollis.
Ladies and gentlemen, three of my associates are with me today.
They are the experts.
I would like to have you know them. Two of them were
here a year ago and presented VRXE's part of the program.
Wilton
B.
Gundlach
from
the
188
State
of
Minnesota,
the
Executive Assistant Director.
Frank Page, from North Carolina
who is also Assistant Director.
And Dr. Joe Samler,
also
Assistant Director.
In the composition of VRE we have two
principal divisions,
the Counseling, Training,
and Adjustment
Division headed by Dr. Samler,
and the Benefits and Facilities
Division
headed
by Mr,
Frank
Page.
Central
Office
is
34
number.
now
in
Our
total
VRXE
staff
in
From the experience I have had in the past with these
conferences I think it would be well to get to the questions
that have been sent in, explore the answers,
and then go to
other
time
information
we
have
that
might
be
desirable
So
much
for
now,
left.
and
presented
in
the
Doctoe.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Thank you, T. O.
On my right we have
the discussion leaders from The American Legion.
At this time
I would like to introduce A.V.. Akin, Department Rehabilitation
Chairman from the State of Georgia, who will in turn introduce
his co-workers.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Doctor.
We have serving with us on
the VR&E panel representing The American Legion our good friend
Reuben Garnett from the State of Washington.
Charles Kohler,
Department Service Officer of Pennsylvania.
To get the
program
under way, we will move to the first question on the printed
program.
This was submitted from Georgia:
'Is a person who
was receiving War Orphans' Educational Assistance, which was
interrupted due to entering the Armed Forces,
eligible for
resumption
of
MR.
this
benefit
KRAABEL:
Mr.
after
his
Page will
discharge?"
take
that.
MR. PAGE:
The answer to this question is "Yes."
The law
provides that if an eligible person serves on active military
duty prior to his 23rd birthday that he will have five years
after his first discharge to complete his program.
This pro-
vision
is
unqualified
and
would
in
no
way
be
influenced
by
the
fact he had pursued training under Chapter 35
prior to his
entrance into service.
However,
no training may be afforded
beyond the maximum of 36 months or the eligible person's 31st
birthday.
MR.
Charles
AKIN:
Any questions?
If not, we are going to have
Kohler of Pennsylvania to take questions 2 and 3.
MR. KOHLER:
'Are the children of a Korean veteran
who
died in service in October 1955,
and who are in receipt of peacetime death compensation,
in any way eligible for War Orphans’
Educational Assistance?"
MR.
KRAABEL:
This
will
also
be
for
Frank
Page.
MR. PAGE:
This question may not be given a categorical
"yes!" or "no" answer,
Since the veteran parent died in October
1955,
his death occurred during the induction period as defined
in the PL 86-785
amendment
to Section 1701 of Title 38, U.S.C.
However,
the
answer
depends
upon
whether
the
veteran
parent
died of a service-connected disability as defined in Title 38,
as amended,
The amendment provides that the disability must
(A)
be
shown
to
have
directly
resulted
from,
and the causative factor therefore must be
shown to have arisen out of the performance
active military, naval,
or air service (but
189
of
not
including service described under
section 106 of Title 38), or
(B)
have resulted (a)
flict or (b) from
directly from armed conan injury or disease
received while engaged in extra-hazardous
service
(including such service under
conditions simulating war).
As ‘explained in Instruction
38, PL 86-785,
dated December 30,
that the disability causing death
1, Title 38
U. 8S. C., Chapter
1960,
it is
fot sufficient
has been rated as service-
conditioms service-connected under
the law are excluded.
The disease
the presumptive provisions of
or injury causing death must
connected
in
line
be
found
to
and
not
merely
MR.
be
AKIN:
of
duty
directly
compensation
traceable
coincident
Any
for
in
time
questions?
to
the
with
The
purposes.
performance
active
next
Thus,
of duty
duty.
question.
MR. KOHLER:
No. 3:
"Must a War Orphan with a physical
handicap wait until his 18th birthday before he can begin training under the War Orphans' Educational Assistance Act?"
MR. PAGE:
The answer is "No."
If an eligible person has
a physical or mental handicap and the Administrator determines
that his best interests will be served by pursuing a program
of special restorative training or a specialized course of vocational training,
the period of training may begin before his
18th birthday but not
before his 14 birthday.
There is a basic
distinction between restorative and specialized vocational training.
Special restorative training is designed to overcome,
or
lessen,
the effects of physical or mental disability.
Examples
of such training are speech and voice correction,
or retention,
language retraining,
lip reading,
auditory training, Braille
reading and writing,
training in ambulation,
one hand typewriting,
and personal and social adjustment.
Specialized vocational teaining which leads to a predetermined and identified vocational objective may be authorized
if it is found that such training,
either alone or when combined
with other training,
constitutes a suitable program and is required for a person who has a mental or physical handicap.
There
are two other instances
in which an eligible person may begin
training before his 18th birthday.
They are (1)- Upon successful
completion of his secondary schooling,
and
(2) if the eligible
person is above the age of compulsory school attendance under
applicable State law, and has not completed his secondary schooling but the Administrator determines his best interests will be
served thereby.
to
the
and
we
MR. AKIN:
Any questions on
next question, which comes
will
ask
our
Comrade
Garnett
No. 3?
If not, we will move
from the State of Washington,
to
handle
that
for
us.
MR. GARNETT:
PL 86-785,
Instruction 1, dated December
30, 1960 set up procedures and effects of the ACt.
Based on the
publicity given,
the widows have the impression that their
children would be eligible for benefits and are counting on it.
There are many limitations as set forth under the law and it is
subject to close scrutiny.
Question:
Why can't the Rating
Boards
this
set
forth
the
potential
eligibility
time?
190
of
the
children
at
In
MR,
PAGE:
recognition
The
of
the
answer
fact
to
that
this
question
widows
is
might
wish
that
they
to make
can.
plans
several years in advance for the education of their children,
VA procedural
instructions have for some time provided that there
is no objection
to a determination of a child;s basic eligibility
prior to the age at which he may become entitled to educational
assistance under the law;
that is, a determination as to whether
the
cause
of
the
veteran
parent's
death
was
due
to
a
service-
connected disability.
(See Parva. 27.2 ,M7-1, Change 10, dated
March 7, 1958).
This,
of course,
applies to the case of the
veteran parent whose death occurred during the induction period
as well as to one who died as the result of wartime service.
A
request for such a determination may be made by the widowed
mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian on the usual VA application
form.
If the child is found basically eligible,
the VA will
so- inform the mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian by letter.
The letter will state ‘that processing of the application will
be deferred until the child reaches the senior year in high
school or attains the age of 18 and also that the application
will be reactivated at that time upon request of the mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian.
I am
the person
would like
aware that this may not give a complete answer to
who submitted this question.
I think possibly they
to know also if at the time of the adjudication of
the
of
cause
the
parent's
death
the
mother
can
be
advised
without application whether her children would be eligible for
training.
I will have to answer that we will take this under
consideration with the Compensation & Pension Service.
I think
possibly it can be provided.
is
bers
the
MR. GARNETT:
I am glad you brought
main question that I had in mind.
MR.
of
AKIN:
our
Are
Legion
there
panel
on
any
questions
my
right?
that
up
because
from
any
of
the
that
mem-
MR. ‘GARNETT:
7T. O., with regard to this recent legislation passed last year which allowed veterans to take additional
training under Public Law 16 or to enter training,
just in a
short answer can you give us any idea of what number of veterans
have been able to come in under that and if we service organizations,
especially The American Legion,
can do something to help
get that across to the veteran and invite it to the attention of
the VA?
will
31,
MR.
give
1961
KRAABEL:
Yes, we have some information on that and
you a brief answer as to the number.
As of January
the
number
of
World
War
II
veterans
in
Vocational
I
Re-
habilitation was very limited,
178.
The possibility that we
can stimulate through publicity to veterans organizations
the
active interest of potentially eligible veterans will be treated
by Dr. Samler.
First as to the number estimated I would like to
have
Mr.
Gundlach
give
you
that
information.
MR. GUNDLACH:
We anticipated for the first year,
that is,
this current fiscal year beginning in July 1, 1960 and closing
June 30, 1961,
that there would be an additional 500
average
monthly enrollments under Public Law 86-721.
I don't believe
we will quite realize that additional number,
but it will be in
the neighborhood of 2 to 5 hundred additional veterans because
of the law.
There always is a question as to the means of
101
publicity that is given new legislation.
We have so far resorted to the normal channels of communication -- the newspaper,
radio,
and spot television statements.
They have in the past
been rather effective but I think your local posts have served
us best because you are, after all, the ones who are in most
direct contact with the men in the community who may have
eligibility under these new laws.
We are looking to you as our
most effective means of reaching these veterans.
We reach them
more or less by chance,
that is if they read the newspaper or
if they listen to the TV or radio.
If we look to you for assistance and I am sure that it will be as effective as it has been
in the past.
from
MR. AKIN:
any member
Thank
of the
you, sir.
VA Staff?
Are
there
any
further
comments
MR. KRAABEL: Dr. Hollis and Chairman Akin, you will notice
that the four questions sent in advance were answered by Mr.
Page.
They all pertain to eligibility and entitlement.
That
falls in his division of our staff activity.
Now, we are going to have Dr. Samler give us something on
a group of veterans,
the seriously disabled, and others who may
now come in under the terms of Public Law 86-721.
Dr. Samler
has been making a study of where these people are and what might
be done to help them.
Dr. Samler,
DR. SAMLER:
Friends,
I am going to report to you on two
important projects.
First,
the discontinued program about which
you may have heard.
You know we work in rehabilitation with
human beings
and moreover, with human beings with disabilities,
some of them very serious.
I need not remind you, of all people
of the range of human ills we and you encounter.
The basic problem in helping the disabled veteran is really in an area of
predicting the future.
Given a paraplegic or an NP veteran,
or
a veteran with multiple sclerosis, what kind of training and
other help is necessary in order for him to reach a point where
he can respect himself and contribute as a productive member of
the community?
’
Prediction,
even when using the best available scientific
and professional means,
carries a certain margin of uncertainty.
This is inevitable and follow-up becomes an essential part of a
sound rehabilitation program.
For a number of years,
therefore,
we have been concerned with those disabled veterans who with our
help, plan a rehabilitation program,
enter training, make progress in it, but then stop.
In our official language they discontinue.
In 1958
for P.L.894 trainees,
23 per cent were found to be
discontinued and it worried us a good deal and so we took action.
Following an ambitious pilot study in which we came to terms
with the nature of the problem and what we might realistically
expect to accomplish,
we initiated a program of systematic followup of
this group.
The instructions were carried in an issue
that you may know as EM 22-33,
in June,
1960.
We did it quite
systematically.
Our TMS sections identified the discontinued
veterans for us.
Each disabled veteran so identified was followed up and on the basis of information secured and our own records
we were and are able to determine whether the veteran was doing
all right or whether he needed and wanted our help.
In very
many cases such veterans were visited at their homes by our staff.
192
that 13 per cent
We estimated on the basis of our pilot study
of the discontinued group would be re-entered into training and
it looks as if we are going to come remarkably close to this
of this group had
582
1961,
At the end of January,
estimate.
and 2,027 had been scheduled
been re-entered into training,
for rehabilitation counseling preliminary to going back into
training.
2,500
We should
and 3,000
otherwise
we feel
Kraabel
item
come out
disabled
simply
would
not
good about it.
referred mainly
reported
on
to
of this careful follow-up with between
veterans in rehabilitation status who
have
been
reached.
You
can see
why
The second item and the one to which Mr.
really is a follow-up report on the major
you
just
a
year
ago.
We
were
then
happy
to
tell you that we had issued instructions to the regional offices
to address themselves in a way they had not done before to the
vocational rehabilitation problems of the seriously disabled
veterans who had not applied for vocational rehabilitation.
These are the veterans,
mind you,with physical disabilities
rated
100 per cent and the NP group rated 70 ‘per .cent.or: higher. We
told the regional offices how to identify such veterans, we told
them to find them,
to help them,
to help motivate them, and to
enter them if it is possible to do so at all into vocational
rehabilitation training.
As I recall it, we put you on notice that in going out and
knocking on the veteran's door we were making a profound change
in our policy of waiting for the veteran to come to us
and that
your
help
at
a
number
of
points
in
our
new
approach
was
not
only desired,
it was actively solicited.
I will make only two
points about this approach.
I think both will interest you.
When we last spoke,
and I think in response to a question,
one
of us said that of course the policy and procedure could not
apply to World War II veterans.
This is because the termination
date of July 25,
1960, simply made such an approach inapplicable.
However, with the passage of 86-721 the situation changed.
In
our
Instruction
Number
1
on
that
law,
which
I
am
sure
you have seen, we put into effect precisely the same policies
of identifying,
motivating,
and rehabilitating eligible seriously disabled veterans of World War II as we have for the Korean
veterans,
:
Second,
I would dearly like to be able to present a definitive report of progress made.
This cannot be done because
at this moment our regional offices are right in the middle of
this big job.
We have not wanted the regional offices to do the
thing in a hurry.
We have told them,
rather,
to do it systematically and carefully and if necessary to do it over a period
of time rather than in a great big hurry as a project.
But for
purposes of reporting to you today we have secured data from five
offices which we regard as meaningful.
I will give you only a
very few figures for these five offices, but you will want to
bear in mind that nationally we are talking about sixteen to
seventeen thousand of these very seriously disabled veterans.
2,800
such
veterans
have
been
identified
by
these
five
offices
and as of last week records have been reviewed for something
like more than half of this group.
About 600 had been seen by
VA staff and thus far 250
had been provided vocational rehabilitation counseling.
One hundred sixty-two actually had
been entered into training or are scheduled to be entered into
training.
Now, of course,
it is
hazardous to project from the
experience of these few offices to all offices and we will in
193
But if we safeguard ourselves by regardtime have firm data.
ing the experience of these offices as high, we may be not unwarranted in expecting up to 800 to 900 of these (once again)
very seriously disabled veterans to be entered into rehabilitation training. These numbers stand for human beings, most
seriously disabled in all instances.
I want somehow to bring
this fact home and will do so by referring to you a few brief
paragraphs not from one of our VA documents, but from one of
yours,
from
a field
service officers.
regional office.
of
his
These
are
report,
service
I
three
but
he
will
visit
not
paragraphs
is
by
one
identify
talking
and
about
of
the
right
the
your
own
officer
from
kind
the
of
field
or
the
middle
veteran
I
have been attempting to describe to you. "There are forty
such veterans in training at the present time," he writes.
"The courses taken include accounting,
electrical appliancerepair,
radio and television service,
lawn mower and power
saw repair,
tile laying,
upholstering, writing,
and tutoring,
to list a few.
Every effort has been made to obtain suitable
instructions for each individual veteran.
They have been
successful:in procuring the services('they'
is the regional
office) of college professors,
even deans of colleges,
as well
as certified public accountants and members of established
accounting firms.
The heart of the whole program is in the
selection of the right instructor.’
How right he is.
"So many successful cases shown
were most amazing.
One
case we cannot forget
and feel it should be mentioned.
A
24-year old Navy veteran whose hands and legs were paralyzed
became motivated toward taking a course in creative writing.
The high school principal began working with this veteran and
teaching him basic English and literature.
Next they looked
around for an instructor
to teach creative writing. A professor at a university was located while she was on a visit to
London.
On her return to the States she informed the Veterans
Administration
that she had a full schedule at the university
and furthermore,
the Veterans Administration could not afford
her price.
She was
asked only to visit this veteran,
to which
she agreed."
"After two visits she became quite interested and was
willing to do the job without pay.
After considerable study
the veteran finished the program.
His first article was
published in Harper's Magazine.
He was forced to move to
Florida because of a chest condition."
cation
"Recently,
he
as a regular
signed a contract with a Florida publistaff writer."
Just one more paragraph.
"Several of the veterans who completed their training in
special repair work are now being employed by chemical companies in the local area on an hourly basis.
They do not come
into the plants,
but rather the work is sent to them at their
homes.
One veteran repairs bicycles for a chemical company.
Another veteran who studied watch-repairing repairs gauges and
a third veteran repairs gown hoops."
I
think
this
is
a. good
place
toistop.
' Thank
‘you,
very
much.
T.
O.
MR.
and
AKIN:
Do we have any questions from the floor for
anv members of his staff?
We have another comment
194
from
T.
0.
T.
O.,
we
are
always
glad
to
hear
from
you.
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you, Mr.Chairman.
I wanted to comment
that these gentlemen have been
on the program both in the field
and in Central Office for the past 16 years. I recall,
as Mr.
Markowitz commented
a while ago, that the original educational
man on the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission
passed away yesterday, Ed Nowak.
We remember him with great
affection,
his dedication,
his devotion and how he carried on
in the initial stages of the GI Bill in 1945.
Upon his resignation in 1946, The American Legion went out to the Midwest
and called Cecil H. Munson to succeed Nowak. He has been in
charge of that phase of the National Rehabilitation Commission's
program since that time.
These gentlemen with me today know
him much better than they knew me, because always it was Cecil
Munson who would make the contacts on problem situations in
VR&E between The American Legion and the Veterans Administration.
The gentleman who has seen this program flourish,
go up to its
peak,
and decline is Mr. Gundlach,
and I am going to ask him to
make a few comments as to where are we today in VR&E.
MR. GUNDLACH:
I am going to assure you I will be very
brief, but I believe
that, as in the past years,
you have
evinced an interest as to where are we today with respect to
the veterans'
educational program.
We have 227,000 veterans
enrolled as of January 31, 1961,
and to impress you that we
still have a serious obligation in terms of numbers with whom
we deal,
I might put it this way: that
it represents about a
million dollars
a day in subsistence allowance given these
veterans.
Have you thought of it that way?
That to me is
rather impressive.
I am dealing primarily here with numbers
because that is the manner in which we can communicate best,
I believe,
as to where we are.
Dr. Samler,
on the other hand, has dealt with the character
of the work that we have had.
Numbers don't tell the whole
story.
I think he brought out clearly to you that as we have
progressed through the years, we have been
able to recognize
that we have added responsibilities
accumulating upon us in the
form of those disabled veterans, who for one
reason or another
have
left
their
training
and
still
are
sorely
in
need
of
attention,
so our program responsibilities do not diminish directly in proportion with the decrease in the number of enrollees.
Let's go back a moment to the 227,000 veterans that we still have
in
educational programs.
How do they break down?
We have
6,000 disabled veterans in training.
We have 205,000
veterans
of the Korean Conflict in the readjustment program and we have
15,000
children under the War Orphans Educational Assistance Act
now in training.
This represents,
as you know, only a small
fraction
of
the
workload
that
we
once
had
in
the
days
of
1946
and 1947.
We had at one time, you recall,
2,500,000
in training.
That was the peak of the program.
I might add one thing before
I conclude,
and that is, that we have to serve these people who
are still in training,
1,024 VR&E personnel in the 49 stations
in which we are still operating VRXE programs.
Thank you.
folks
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you,
have sensed and realized
definite
declination,
the
Wilt.
better
definite
Mr, Chairman,
I think you
than we, probably,
the
shrinkage,
of
these
programs
since the heyday of the GI Bill.
Only one has
shown to be
on
the ascendancy or increase,
and that for the next two or three
years,,
when
we
feel
decline.
I
am
referring
that
it
also
to
the
195
will
War
level
Orphans
off
and
gradually
Educational
Assistance
Act.
What does the staff do in Central Office in the face of
termination dates of these programs staring you right ahead?
The gentlemen have referred back to the time when these activities
were climbing - the hectic days when the bulge came in the GI
Bill,
They have concluded that probably the task of guiding
a declining program in its last days takes just as much tact and
resourcefulness as when it was climbing and increasing.
Here are some of the things that the folks have been
analyzing,
appraising,
and studying,
so that we might keep pace
staff-wise,
as well as personnel-wise in the field,
and still
keep the program at a high level in quality. As a staff. we have
no directive power.
We deal through the area field directors
who in turn communicate
to the managers on administrative matters.
As to policies and procedures,
interpretation of regulations,
and instructions
the VR&E staff also functions through channels.
Now, when,
and what does a program staff do to adjust the
activity in its decline?
Here are some of the considerations
that assert themselves.
We have to determine the accuracy of
prospective workload estimates,
look ahead for two or three
years,
and estimate how many are coming in to take advantage of
this law or that law.
How about the appropriaténess of the organization pattern?
Are we organized properly and effectively
to serve the weteran in the regional office and in the central
office?
Third,
the
adequacy
of
the
staffing
factors.
Are
we
meeting the requirements in training,
in counseling,
benefit
and facilities,
contract work,
eligibility,
compliance and so
forth?
Fourth,
the suitability of the operating procedures.
Has experience taught that there should be changes in some of
the operations that have taken place so far?
Number five,
the
validity of time allowances for the determination of operational
effectiveness,,’ Have we allowed too much time for each detail or
each step
or not enough?
Maintenance of the quality level;
this
is a great project in the Veterans Administration,
and in every
government agency these days - to maintain high quality of
effectiveness on an economical basis. Number seven,
the employee
morale,
always a big factor in the conduct of any program.
Eight, good public relations.
How are the folks reacting to
the administration of these programs which have such a great
out-reach from the government to the people back home.
items.
Time
does
Suffice
not
it
permit
to
say
detailed
that
based
exposition
on
of
each
experience
of
these
extending
back 18 years of program studies and periodic surveys,
every
effort is made to contract and reduce the program in a reasonable
manner without detriment to the quality and adequacy of service
to the remaining veterans in training or eligible to initiate
training.
Not
only
veterans
themselves,
but
also
Congressmen,
school
officials,
approval agencies,
service officers,
and interested
relatives are authors of innumerable inquiries which keep the
VR&E
regional
offices
alert to conduct these
in decline or not.
staffs
programs
When
in
one
contemplates
and
in
the
effectively
that
at
one
time
central
and
the
office
fully
on
the
whether
number
of
VR&E
people staffing these programs reached 26,550
in 1947;
the number
trained in readjustment,
the GI Bills, Public Law 346 and its
successor Public Law 50,
exceeded 10,000,000;
the number trained
196
in vocational rehabilitation nearly 680,000;
and the number whd
have so far entered training under the War Orphans Assistance
Act, 28, 244, the enormity of this total effort and coverage
can be gauged.
By way of comparison,
the total number in training under
all current laws, as Mr. Gundlach has told you, is around 227,000
and the personnel at this time
is 1024 in the field and 35 in
the
central office.
VR&E is still a going concern.
Every staff
member continues a vigilance to see that, although
patronage of
these programs is diminishing and the termination dates,
except
as to
the educational assistance for children of the service
connected deceased veterans,
are approaching,
the effectiveness
of service will be maintained.
Among the steps taken under
authority of the Chief Benefits
Director and the Administrator
to adapt the VRE organization to
change circumstances
are in two major areas.
Many of you may
have been aware of this.
Number
offices with
areas,
1.
The consolidation of VR&E workloads
those of larger ones within the same or
on smaller
contiguous
Number 2.
The combination of the two organizational elements,
counseling,
on the one hand and education and training,
on the
other into one known as the vocational counseling,
training,
and
adjustment
activity.
As
of
January
31
of
this
year
there
have
been 18 workload consolidations and at that date no further plans
for additional consolidations were authorized.
These have been
realized
with
a
minimum
of
adverse
consequences.
In
fact,
the
record shows a remarkable degree of smoothness in the change.
Personnel affected were for the most part absorbed or reassigned.
It is never popular to remove a program or unit from one regional
office and combine it with another at a larger office, but when
the
facts
of
life
make
such
moves
necessary,
the
Chief
Director,
the Area Field Directors,
the Administrator
program staffs face up to the realities.
Benefits
and the
Our administrative,
educational,
and counseling experts
have studied this and continue to study this situation to the
end that the consolidation of workloads will assure maintenance
of high quality service and depth of professional and technical
resources.
We are proceeding in the shrinking and consolidation
phase on the premise of maintaining the integrity of the VR&E
function as long as possible.
The other major step has been the
combining of counseling and education and training activities
into one organizational element.
Why did we do that?
The move
is based on the conception of vocational rehabilitation for the
disabled as a unitary task.
The progress of a trainee through
counseling,
training,
and job adjustment can be and ought to be
the concern of one staff member,
and this practice has been
observed by other agencies concerned who have responsibilities
in the vocational rehabilitation field.
Why didn't the Veterans
Administration follow this arrangement from the beginning?
The
reason is that the VR&E service in its early days experienced
such a rapid growth to such unprecedented numbers of trainees
that it became necessary to effect a division of labor to carry
out the functions of vocational rehabilitation properly.
Now, circumstances permit adopting the more acceptable
practice of vesting in one staff member all the responsibilities
involved in processing the training program of a disabled veteran.
197
We are hoping and planning that by July 1 of this year counselors
will have assumed the training functions and will be devoting a
percentage of their time to that purpose.
You who are in close
touch with the regional managers and their staffs in your day-byday work appreciate the task they have in adjusting to expanding
or declining workloads.
Administration difficulties,
budget
matters,
employee
morale,
and
staffing
problems
seem
to
persist
in attending the most diligent and careful of efforts. As the
program staff we recognize the remarkable achievements of these
managers.
The team play has been and continues to be of the best.
Mr.
Chairman,
on
to thank you and the
Thank you very much,
MR.
of
the
AKIN:
VR&E
MR.
in
We
behalf
of my
audience
for
have
Washington
MUNSON:
Just
Mr.
Munson
with
one
colleagues
listening
who
is
a
question.
brief
question
and
myself,
I wish
to
us
these
minutes.
the
chief
because
45
consultant
I
know
that
many of you are concerned about the orphans of those who were
inducted dnto service.
I am asking this question so that there
might be some clarification as to just when information should
be sought from the Veterans Administration.
Is there any age limit regarding application for training?
I am thinking of a mother whose husband was killed in service or
died in service and she has two or three children,
say, ten or
younger.
When can she apply in order to ascertain whether or
not her children are going to be eligible for training under the
War Orphans Act?
MR. PAGE:
There is no age limitation for receipt of application.
It can be reactivated after she gets the information
whether the child is eligible or ineligible and that application
can
be
reactivated
upon
her
request.
MR. MUNSON:
Mr. Chairman,
this is important because the
service officer can advise the mother to make an immediate
application for training for the oldest and then there will be
a decision made as to whether or not the children are eligible.
The mother can make plans in the future for her children to go
to school if they are eligible.
One more point.
Because the education and training program
is gradually fading out of the picture, don't forget that your
job in rehabilitation is not completed.
Coming into the picture
is the older veteran being discharged from a hospital where he
has received counseling,
corrective therapy and some training.
This veteran will be coming home seeking a place in the active
life of his community.
Our Post Service Officers should be ready to receive this
older veteran and help him find a place in his community.
Now,
don't forget that a little less than 50
per cent of the veterans
hospitalized are hospitalized in Veterans Administration hospitals.
The others are hospitalized in your local community
hospitals and they,
too, are receiving some counseling and rehabilitation.
This is a real challenge for all of us.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Cecil Munson.
from the floor to the VR&E section of this
any questions from our colleagues,
Garnett
198
Are there any questions
Conference?
Are there
and Kohler?
If
not,
Mr.
Chairman,
over
to
CHAIRMAN
HOLLIS:
time
in
of
I
would
like
to
turn
this
panel
panel
and
at
behalf
The
This
concludes
this
American
Legion
I would
like
to
T. O. and your staff for coming over and giving us
also we are very grateful
to Chairman Akin and his
for
back
you,
their
contribution.
At this
Chairman,
Bob
time,
I would
McCurdy.
like
to
turn
our
this
thank
you,
your time,
co-workers
and
over
our
meeting
to
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We anticipate that Mr. Teague will arrive
at any moment,
but I would like to take this opportunity to pay a
tribute to those who have probably been the most influential of
all in regard to our work for veterans.
During
the
past
year,
we
have
lost
four
in
ten
months,
the
original big four of those who supported the Veterans Administration and those who through so many years were staunch supporters of the veteran.
I call attention to Mrs. Edith Nourse
Rogers, who certainly was the greatest friend with the biggest
heart for all veterans
and particularly disabled veterans;
General Frank Hines, who for so many years served at his station
as the Administrator of Veterans' Affairs and who so ably aided
and assisted the enactment of basic law, rules,
regulations and
procedures;
John Rankin, who was for so many years the Chairman
of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs, who also was always
a champion of the disabled and made notable and great contri-
butions;
and
last,
but
certainly
not
least
of
the
big
four
was
our own
Watson B. Miller.
I know it saddens us all to see these
four superb people who have devoted so much of themselves and
their lives to the benefit of veterans,
and I am going to ask,
at this time,
that you stand for a moment in silence in memory
and honor of these four old timers.
A moment of silence was
observed.
former
old
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I
member of the staff
timer
from
the
great
am sure you heard yesterday that a
here, Ed. Nowak, passed on and another
State
of
Illinois
that
I know
many
of
you
knew well, Bill McCauley,
also has answered the call and I would
like to call on the members from the State of Illinois, Mr.
Applebaum,
if he
is here.
I will postpone this until later.
We
now have another great champion of veterans,
the Chairman of the
Committee
on Veterans'
Affairs,
one
who
is
a great
friend
whom
we don't always agree with, but by the same token, he does not
always agree with us.
I have found him fair and honorable and
always willing to listen and always able to give as well as he
gets.
In fact, he is just our type of comrade and he is a comrade in his Post in Texas,
and we consider it a high honor and
a great pleasure to have with us this morning as our speaker the
Honorable Olin Teagie, Chairman of the House Committee on
Veterans!
Affairs.
CHAIRMAN TEAGUE:
This morning your National Commander has
been complimented more on Capitol Hill on his talk last night
than anyone who has spoken in Washington for a long time.
He
brought a message that was appreciated by everyone I have talked
to.
wants
I
am
going
to
I
will
to
talk
attempt
to
to
you
for
answer
199
a
little
questions.
while
and
if
anybody
not
I
have
easy
to
said
this
represent
before
and
veterans
in
would
say
it
again,
We
have
Congress.
that
25
it
men
is
on
our Committee,
and our committee is the least political of any in
Congress.
I doubt that any committee goes through the democratic
processes as carefully as we do
in trying to work out legislation.
Already this year, we have about 300 bills in our committee.
As soon as a bill is introduced - and they come from
many sources - we send them
to the Veterans Administration,
Treasury Department,
Bureau of the Budget,
or whoever is concerned
with the bill,
and ask for
a report as to whether the agency is
for it or against it,
Sometimes we do
hold hearings on bills
and report and pass them before obtaining those reports,
but
generally we wait for a report from the department before we try
to pass a bill.
In those few cases where bills are reported
before a report is received from the agency,
the bills are noncontroversial and of a minor nature.
The first two bills we expect to consider this year will be
a housing bill and a compensation bill.
The housing bill is quite
controversial,
There is just so much money around this country
that we can get into housing,
and those of us interested in
veterans housing feel the powers that be are attempting to put
too much money in other housing and not enough in the veterans!
program.
Within the last week there have probably been 14 or 18
hours of discussion between the Administrator of Veterans Affairs,
the Bureau of the Budget,
the Treasury Department
and myself and
my staff.
There will be a housing message in the next few days.
Just what
it will recommend we do
not know but we suspect it
won't please us as
to the amount of money that goes into veterans’
housing.
If it does not we are going to try to pass a bill ‘to
put money into veterans'
housing.
We realize the Treasusy Department has a problem as to
raising money.
We have surveyed a number of veterans who applied for and got a loan and we do not
feel there is any better housing program in
the United States
than our veterans'
housing program, but certainly the program
is no good unless we can get some money into it.
I spent about
an hour last week with
the President,
talking about our veterans’
problems,
and
I
veterans
are
concerned
think
I found
a very
sympathetic
and
think
will
I
The only
Government who
people to receive
have not received
are
who
the
people
receive
a
a
we
check
raise
have
ear
a
as
good
far
from our United
in the past few
compensation,
our
disabled
as
year.
States
years
veterans.
Probably the second bill we will take up this year will be the
compensation bill.
The cost of living has gone up about 5%.
They passed a bill last year giving Federal employees a raise
of 7-1/2%,
so I would guess that we can pass a bill somewhere
between
5
and
10
percent
as
cerned,
and of course just a
tremendous amount of money.
far
as
small
disabled veterans
raise
like
that
are
runs
con-
into
a
We passed a pension
very controversial bill.
that went into that bill,
who represent you here in
bill in the last Congress.
It was a
You would not dream the amount of work
including the work of your own people
Washington;
and Bob McCurdy - he knew
every
veterans'
step
taken,
and
all
groups
knew
every
step
taken
and every thought we had.
By the time we got the bill to the
floor no one was completely happy with it but everyone felt it
was the best we could do.
This year we will hold a complete
hearing on that pension bill to find out whether or not it has
worked
it
out
would.
the
We
way
will
people
who
hold
complete
a
work
200
with
veterans
hearing
on
problems
pensions
this
thought
year.
|
We will also
hold a complete hearing on hospitals.
We have
population shifts in the country.
I doubt that veterans;
groups,
including The American Legion, know what a fight we have had over
hospitals in the past 10 years, but the hospital situation has
changed.
We finally got an agreement out of the Bureau of the
Budget with the VA in the last Congress that we would spend about
$75
million a year for 12 years on our hospital program.
We have
a physical plant across the country worth about $2 billion.
That
physical plant has gone down considerably and we need a lot of
replacements.
The hospital here in Washington is an old girls
school;
one in Florida is an old hotel,
and one in California
an old hotel.
We feel we have made a lot of progress in the
last few years in turning our hospital program around from going
down to going up.
I think in the next 12 years you will see our
hospital program improving to a great extent.
There are people
who oppose our veterans'
hospital program - if you can destroy
the hospital you can destroy the program.
I have reason to
believe that the President will approve $75
million - in fact,
there might be a little more put in.
I think the hospital program is in good shape.
review,
We
have
For
something
a number
of
else
we
years
will
I have
work
felt
on
this
that
year,
judicial
a veteran
should
have some appeal beyond the Board of Veterans' Appeals.
There
has been a very active,
a very effective campaign carried on by
some people within the VA against any kind of an appeal. I do
not know exactly what I should be; I am not a lawyer, but I feel
that the Administrator should not appoint an appeals board and
then be the reviewing officer on the appeal from the appeals
board.
In the last Congress,
not being a lawyer,
I thought the
smart thing to do was pick five of the best lawyers on our
committee and let them work on this appeals board idea, which
they did.
They came up with the idea of a complete court on the
order of our claims court.
When it came before the full committee the first thing that happened was that a non-lawyer on the
committee raised cain because it did set up a complete court and
because it would require a lawyer to appear before the court.
We will take it up again this year.
Whether we will attempt to
do something I do not know.
I have no desire to try to cram
something down anybody's
throat or pass something veterans as a
whole do not agree with, but we intend to keep working on it and
if it reaches the point where veterans’
groups think it is the
right thing to do we will attempt to pass it.
This year there
will be some non-lawyers on the subcommittee which works on this.
I had no idea they would come out with a complete court but after
they did make the report,
and after reading and studying the
hearing,
I have a feeling that probably we should have a complete
court.
The Supreme Court makes a study each year of all of the
courts of the United States.
When they first met and
talked
about this they opposed it and then last
September they went
over
it
again
and
the
Judicial
Conference
of
the
United
States
approved the general idea of a veterans'
court such as we have
proposed.
We will kick that around this year
and in this Congress we may pass something,
or it will be determined to a
great degree by what our veterans'
groups come up with.
The
National Commander of The VFW appointed a study group and they
have come out opposing judicial review.
The National Commander
himself has not expressed himself but we would hope that whatever
we do would be something that is close to being unanimously
approved by veterans'
groups.
"Cold
Another item we hear a
War GI Bill."
We have
lot of this year is the so-called
a Senator from Texas who is very
201
strong in his support of a "Cold War GI Bill."
The bill which
passed the Senate last year would cost about $3 million.
The
committee,
after very thorough hearings,
came to the conclusion
that if we are going to spend $3 million on the veterans programs
we should spend it on something other than a Cold War GI Bill.
That will be taken up this year and I would predict that there
may be some kind of a very moderate Cold War GI Bill,
It is
difficult to tell a boy we sent to Korea that he is not as much
a veteran as one who served in the Pentagon during World War II,
or during the Korean War, so I think there is a possibility of
some kind of a moderate GI Bill.
mittee.
affairs
Those
It
our
will probably be the major
will probably be the most
committee
has
had
since
activities of our comactive year in veterans’
I came
to Congress.
If we
can get a good compensation bill, work out legislation to put
money in housing,
if we can be sure that a sufficient amount of
money goes into our hospital program to maintain our hospitals,
I woitld think we would have
legislation is concerned.
Mr.
Service
McCurdy asked
Life Insurance.
a rather
him
to
good
comment
on
year
as
far
reopening
as
of
Federal
National
MR. TEAGUE:
We have had hearings in subcommittee a number
of times and it has been turned down.
It has passed the Senate
four times.
They never have a hearing,
just tack it onto some
bill we send over there and send it back to us.
We are going
to
hold
hearing
again
this
year,
a full
hearing
before
the
full
committee and the full committee will vote on it and it is
according to how good a lobbying job you do as to whether it will
pags or not,
We do not run a dictatorial committee -- we will
consider a bill and the committee will vote on it.
Another thing we have talked about - I suggested to the
President that the VA run a pilot program in some of our empty
beds as far as an intermediate care program is concerned.
We had
a meeting with Dr. Middleton,
some of my staff and other VA staff
members,
and I came away with the conclusion that Dr. Middleton
was violently opposed to an intermediate care program.
We have
a program for sick veterans and we have a program for older
veterans who are not sick, but we have no program where a man who
goes into a hospital receives hospitalization and comes out still
requiring not a doctor but some kind of nursing care - there is
no place he can go. I felt and still feel that the ideal place in
our country to run a program of this kind is within the VA.
We discussed this at length.
I found out that Mr. McCurdy felt
Dr. Middleton had approved this program and I was convinced he
was opposed to it, so we will have another conference to find
out who believes what and who will do what.
I still feel the
ideal place in this country to run a pilot program as far as our
senior citizens are concerned is within the VA.
We do
not pretend to know all the answers on veterans'
blems.
We take 300 bills and try to set up a priority as to
which are the most deserving and try to go from there.
MR.
KOLENDA
(MEXICO):
I
would
like
to
ask
a
question
the residents abroad,
the service-connected veterans
abroad.
Under the present law there is no treatment
in the countries where they live.
We live abroad by
we
do
render
a
service
to
our
government,
202
render
pro-
about
who live
available
choice but
service
to
our
commerce,
to our military.
A widow who has a pension can move
abroad and continue with the pension.
I have written you on this
subject and I know there have been several bills introduced on
this subject and each time they are denied.
It makes us abroad
feel like second-class citizens.
We have service-connected disabilities incurred in war.
We have no recourse to treatment
except returning to the United States, which in many cases is an
impossibility.
It incurs great expense,
means absence from the
family,
and sometimes for a great length of time.
Unless we can
get some kind of reiief on this I know the rest of the veterans
for whom I speak residing abroad feel we are second-class citizens.
I wonder if there is something that can be done in the committee.
It has come up for a vote and has been pigeon-holded most of the
time.
We feel we are rendering service to the United States
by
residing abroad.
There is a tremendous business program the
United States is trying to push in Latin America and throughout
the world.
This is all marginal production and we are the people
who are putting it across.
Will you give us some opinion on how
this might possibly be done.
MR. TEAGUE:
I think you make a very good point.
We have
had within the committee a continuing study for the past few
years.
This year there will be hearings on legislation of that
kind.
I cannot tell you how it will come out but can promise
there will be a hearing and I personally feel you have a very
good point.
We have made quite a study of that in the past few
years.
for
an
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank
excellent
address.
you
very
much,
Congressman
Teague,
MR. McCURDY:
Mr. Teague pointed out to us that in the
hospital in Dallas there was a ward of 80 beds which has never
been opened,
the hospital
5 years old, and he thought facilities
of that kind should be used for this program.
Our Chief Medical
Director felt that to use hospital beds for this purpose would
depreciate and less the quality of the hospitals and he is opposed
to that,
So Mr. Teague says that Dr. Middleton is opposed.....
They are going to start a pilot study at the VA hospital at
Hines to make this study.
His idea is to use existing domiciliary facilities with the idea that over a period of 10, 12
or 15
years the domiciliary program would be completely phased
out and those facilities would become this secondary care.
That
is another program.
Mr. Teague is opposed to that because he
says there is a definite place for domiciliaries and does not
want to lose them.
That makes us of the Legion feel pretty
good because we have a middle of the road program passed last
year.
We passed a resolution and requested that facilities
of this kind be furnished and that we do a pilot study in five
parts
of
the
country
and
construct
minimum
facilities
for
this
type of care adjacent to general hospitals.
This would give us
the facilities for the program that we are in complete agreement
on, that we need the facilities,
and yet would not phase out the
domiciliary homes which I believe there is a place for and would
not in any way lessen the quality of the general medical hospital
care.
I have suggested to both parties that our program is the
proper compromise and let's get on the road and build these
facilities and we will be making progress.
That is what Mr.
Teague referred to, in that he and I had different understandings
on
what
Dr.
Middleton
gram and all three
I still think ours
of
is
stands
for.
They
both
stand
for
the
pro-
us have different ways of accomplishing it.
the best,
to build additional facilities.
203
It will prove we need the
the domiciliary program.
vail.
...At
11:45
A.
M.,
restoration
I hope that
the
Conference
MR. McCURDY:
We will
Rehabilitation Commission.
and
on
the
Conference
the
first
order
of
Committee
center program and also
eventually that will prewas
adjourned.
now come to order as the National
We were recessed from last Monday
business
on
we
will
have
the
report
of
Recommendations.
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman and members of the Rehabilitation Commission,
your Conference Committee on Recommendations met on Wednesday afternoon,
immediately following the
close of the day's conference session,
and they elected me the
Chairman.
The Committee
then proceeded to a consideration of
recommendations referred to it.
This included seven areas of
conference recommendations,
one from area A and six from Area
C, together with two recommendations submitted by this Conference.
The Committee
thereafter held additional meetings as
were required to consider recommendations subsequently brought
to it by the conferees.
The area recommendations are printed on
pages 18 and 19 of
your Conference program booklet.
With respect to these,
the Committee agreed upon the following actions:
Recommendation
non-service
Number
connected
1.
veterans
From
to
Area
A:
receive
Cease
to
out-patient
permit
care
in
the VA's new day care centers.
The Committee is cognizant of
the fact that
the 1960 National Convention referred three
resolutions,
namely, No. 229, 500,
and 56,
to this Commission
for study and report, which seeks to extend out-patient privileges to non-service connected veterans.
It is
understood
that the staff is currently preparing
the necessary background
reports relative to the issue raised by these resolutions.
The Committee is of the opinion that Area A Recommendation
No. 1 should be associated with these three referred Convention resolutions,
and we so recommend.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
If there is no objection
saving time, we will follow the same procedure as
vention committees.
If there is any objection to
dation by a member of the Commission,
if you will
it laid aside, we will do so and discuss it later.
we
have
no
objection,
will
be
adopted
and purely for
we do
in conthe recommenask to have
Those where
altogether.
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Recommendation No. 1 from Area C was a
proposal that the VA
modify its annual income questionnaire
instructions to pension beneficiaries
so the form need be reported only if there has been material change in income or income expected.
The Committee recommends
that this proposal be
referred to the national staff for study and report to the next
meeting of the Commission,
or subcommittee
thereof,
for further
consideration.
effect
3.
a
backlogs
visions.
problems
the
That is
plan for
now
in
the
Regional
Office
Area C
of the
to put into
excessive
Adjudication
The Committee
is aware of the numerous practical
involved in this regard;
but, recommends approval
recommendation
The
Recommendation No. 2 from
the immediate elimination
existing
American
with
Legion
the
following
urges
the
204
change
Central
in
the
Office
text
of
the
Di-
of
thereof:
VA
to take every possible action so as to bring about a material
reduction in the existing adjudication backlogs;
such action to
include asking the Congress for additional funds,
if deemed
necessary,
for overtime pay and transfer of employees as needed.
4.
Recommendation
to modify its
Office "so as
sense
system
of the
of
the
No.
3
from
present system of
to reflect a true
recommendation
Area
workload
workload
that
the
is not representative of
time required to perform
the
the
C
calls
upon
the
VA
measurement in Regional
picture."
It is the
product
of
total pending
work on hand.
the
present
workload
or
The Committee understands
that the VA Central Office is
currently giving consideration to this matter,
and therefore,
recommends
that the national staff be instructed to prepare a
full report on the problem for consideration by the Commission,
or a subcommittee thereof,
at its next meeting.
5.
Recommendation No. 4 from Area C asks that Regional
Office and VA hospital out-patient divisions be maintained at
sufficient strength so that no veteran will have to wait more
than 45
calendar days before receiving an "at once' examination
ordered on Form 2507
by a rating agency.
if
The Committee recommends
rephrased as follows:
The American Legion
extra funds from Congress
sonnel at its out-patient
time between the issuance
amination,
now considered
duced to a minimum.
approval
of
this
recommendation
shall urge the VA to seek the necessary
to provide for such additional perclinics as will insure that the elapsed
of the Form 2507
and the date of exexcessive in most offices, will be re-
6.
Recommendation No. 5 from Area C calls for the immediate
abandonment of the Automatic Data Processing system now employed
by the Veterans Administration for purposes of making payments
to VA beneficiaries.
A similar recommendation has been received
by the Committee at this Conference.
Your Committee is cognizant of the instructions given the
Rehabilitation Commission by the 1960 National Convention as
contained in Resolution No. 149. The study ordered by the Convention has as its goal the development of an official position
by The American Legion as to whether or not the VA should continue the use of ADP equipment for the payment of benefits.
The
Director of the Commission's staff has advised that this
study
is not complete but is going forward as rapidly as possible,
considering the magnitude and the importance of the undertaking.
It is
made by the
its meeting
understood
Commission
early next
that the detailed interim
to the National Executive
May.
report will be
Committee at
Your Committee believes that the many service officers of
The American Legion in attendance at this Conference have performed a valuable service to the Commission,
to our organization
as a whole, and to the responsible officials of the Veterans
Administration.
They have done so by a forceful presentation of
the problems now being experienced,
particularly in converted
regional offices,
by service officers, VA employees;
and, most
important of all, by disabled veterans and their dependents.
205
The
service
consensus
officers
of
is
to
feeling
the
expressed
ww
that
by
these
the
ADP
practicing
system
as
now
operating has resulted in poorer service to veterans at increased
costs;
and, has seriously jeopardized the morale of VA employees
who, however,
are doing their utmost to cope with the situation.
From comments heard during this Conference,
it would also
appear questionable whether the ADP system will ever be capable
of providing the prompt,
personal,
and sympathetic service that
we of The Legion have always demanded of the VA in its relationships with claimants.
Granted that the VA should achieve its
ultimate goals,
strong doubt has been expressed as to whether
the ADP system may be expected to provide service better than,
or even equal to, that previously enjoyed.
On
advised
the
other
this
solve
the
existing
date
of
fects
in
the
ADP
target
payments.
hand,
Conference
July
It is
the
that
problems;
31,
1961
system
which
our
responsible
officials
have
the
agency
elimination
of
set
timely
and
proper
great
effort
and,
that
for
the
affect
understanding
that
VA
is
these
being
expended
has
same
those
to
a
de-
benefit
officials
have also promised that no further conversions of Regional
Offices will be made until these problems are solved in the
presently converted stations.
In
view
of
the
foregoing,
your
Committee
recommends
the
following:
(a)
That the Commission staff be instructed to continue
the study ordered by Convention Resolution No. 149, with a view
to completing the necessary survey prior to the 1963 National
Convention;
(b)
That the Commission give the National Executive
Committee at its next meeting a report of the findings as of
that time;
(c)
That particular attention be given to the VA's progress in resolving the current problems, which the agency promises to accomplish by July 31, 1961;
(d)
That all Commission members,
and all Department Service Officers,
are urged to cooperate with the national staff
in the furtherance of its survey of this vital problem;
(e)
That
the
Commission
establish
the
time
of
the
1961
National Convention as its goal for the completion of the task
assigned to it by Resolution No. 194; and
(f)
That, meanwhile,
in consideration of the VA's
assurance that no further regional offices will be converted
pending the solution of problems now encountered by converted
stations through the use of ADP equipment,
The American Legion
shall
to
by
continue
to
cooperate
relieve as quickly as
disabled veterans and
with
the
agency
in
possible the hardships
their survivors.
a mutual
effort
being
experienced
7.
Recommendation No. 6 from Area C calls upon The
American Legion to endorse and sponsor a '"Cold War GI Bill' for
certain persons inducted into the Armed Forces under the Selective
Service System subsequent
to the close of the Korean Conflict.
The Committee recommends that this
recommendation be rejected inasmuch as it believes the policy enunciated by the
National Executive Committee
in Resolution No. 28 of the fall,
1959,
meeting should be upheld.
This is to theeffect that the
issue of extending readjustment benefits to peacetime veterans
is not germane to a war veterans' problem.
206
MR.
of
Mr.
Chairman,
will
MR. KLEMMETSON:
The following
during this Conference:
ceived
rent
HORTON:
8.
That The American Legion
Rating Board make-up;
suggest
the
medical
or two doctors
consultants to
only.
doctor,
to
be
you
that
aside?
recommendations
were
re-
request a review
Boards be changed
of
by
the curremoval
replaced
be made available
all Rating Boards
set
by
a
layman;
and,
that
one
to Adjudication Divisions as
for consultationand opinion
The Committee does not favor this plan and recommends rejection of the recommendation.
It is believed that medical members should continue to be an integral part of Rating Boards and,
as such, responsible for participation in rating decisions.
9.
Whereas,
the Veterans Administration has recently restated its policy that only essential material will be filed and
that material of transitory value would not become a permanent
part of essential records;
and
Whereas,
instructions have been issued to remove any duplicate or unnecessary material from claims folders when they
are examined during the process of adjudication or review or
for another purpose;
and
Whereas,
it has been brought to the attention of this Commission that some regional offices have adopted the procedure
of
removing
letters
of
transmittal
or
other
transmitting
media
at a level below the adjudicating element,
and that personnel
removing documents or material from claims folders are not
qualified to judge the potential value of some material in future
claims;
Therefore,
it is recommended that the Veterans Administration be requested to revise existing instructions to managers
of
regional
and
other
offices,
to
assure
that
correspondence
and other written material,
having a possible evidentiary value,
will not be destroyed or otherwise disposed of before consideration by those persons charged in the Veterans Administration
with
the
responsibility
of
evaluating
of claims.
(Your Committee recommends
tional recommendations):
evidence
submitted
in
support
approval
of
the
following
addi-
10.
That the Commission go on
record as expressing its
appreciation for the services rendered
by the Government officials and The American Legion and Auxiliary representatives who
by their participation greatly contributed to the success of the
38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference;
and that the
staff be directed to send appropriate letters to these officials
and representatives.
11.
That
the
Commission
hereby
commend
the
entire
staff
of the Rehabilitation Division for the outstanding job done this
year in the planning and carrying out of the 1961 Conference.
12.
That, on behalf of the National Rehabilitation Commission,
the staff advise Mrs.
Inez Miller, widow of our late
beloved comrade, Watson B. Miller,
that the 38th Annual National
Rehabilitation Conference was officially dedicated to his memory;
and,
that she be supplied with the verbatim text of the remarks
offered
in
his
meeting
McCurdy
1961.
on
at
Monday,
February 27, 1961, and by Chairman Robert M.
the opening of the Conference on Tuesday,
February 28,
honor
by Mr.
E.
B.
207
"Pat"
Cliff
at
the
Commission's
I make a motion that all resolutions which
to be
set aside, which leaves only one, that all
approved.
CHAIRMAN
of
the
A
favor
McCURDY:
Recommendations
The
motion
Committee
VOICE:
Second
CHAIRMAN
say aye.
McCURDY:
Oppose,
is
be
that
the
approved.
are
the
not asked
rest be
recommendations
Is
there
a
second?
it.
Are
no.
you
The
ready for
ayes have
the
it.
question:
All
in
We will now take up the one resolution.
Recommendation
Number 6 from Area C calls upon The American Legion to endorse
and sponsor a '"Cold War G.I.Bill'" for certain persons inducted
into the Armed Forces under the Selective Service System subsequent to the close of the Korean Conflict.
The Committee recommends that this recommendation be rejected inasmuch as it
believes
the policy enunciated by the
National Executive Committee in Resolution No. 28 of the fall,
1959,
meeting should be upheld.
This is to the effect that the
issue of extending readjustment benefits to peacetime veterans
is
not
germane
This
since that
meeting:
to
a
war
is a reversal
resolution is
veterans'
program.
of the policy set
mentioned,
I will
by Resolution
read from the
No. 28
fall
"Whereas,
The American Legion has traditionally sponsored
and supported legislation pertaining to veterans of the periods
of hostilities in World War I (4-6-17 to 11-11-18), World War
II
(12-7-41
to
9-2-45),
and
the
Korean
Conflict
(6-25-50
to
7-27-53),
and surviving dependents of such war veterans;
and
Whereas, There is legislation pending in Congress extending certain G.I.Bill benefits to peacetime veterans;
and
Whereas, As individuals our members might approve such
legislation,
our efforts as an organization are devoted exclusively to the welfare of war veterans and dependents in the
field of veterans'
affairs,
in full accord with the Charter
granted by the Congress;
Now,
therefore,
be it
Resolved,
That the National Executive Committee of The
American Legion,
in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis,
Indiana, October 7-9, 1959,
declare that it is inconsistent for
our organization to support legislation providing readjustment
benefits based upon peacetime service;
and further be it
Resolved,
That in the event the Congress should enact
legislation of the nature herein considered,
that the administration of such a law will not be assigned to the Veterans Administration;
and Be it further
Resolved,
That The American Legion is firmly of the opinion
that such legislation should not be charged to the field of
veterans'
benefits.
It
is
now
open
for
discussion.
MR.
HORTON:
Mr.
Chairman,
I am Clarence
Horton
from
Alabama,
and
I am the
one who
asked
that
this
particular
resolution
be set
aside.
I
holding
would like to suggest to the Commission that we consider
this resolution in suspension until such time as we may
208
have an opportunity to evaluate the various bills introduced
into Congress on this subject to see whether or not some such
bill might not be more agreeable to ourselves.
The Chairman will
recall that I am somewhat inconsistent in appearing here since
I was a member of the subcommittee which drafted Resolution 28.
However,
the
Department
of
Alabama,
and
Area
C
have
directed
a
resolution to my attention in which they emphasize the fact
that The American Legion has long stood for improved educational
opportinities
in America,
that it believes wholly and completely
in national security,
and that it is not lacking in being germane
to the purpose of The American Legion to endorse a Cold War
GI Bill provided it is
not charged to veterans' benefits.
I simply would be unhappy and reluctant to see the Commission completely reject the resolution,
and if there is a procedure whereby you can hold in suspense the resolution,
I would
like to request that this
be done.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
McCURDY:
HORTON:
CHAIRMAN
be referred to
later date.
MR.
I
move,
(GEORGIA):
McCURDY:
referred for further
further discussion?
MR.
so
you
Mr.
care
to
make
a motion?
Chairman.
McCURDY:
The speaker has regularly moved that
the Commission for further study and report at
JENSEN
CHAIRMAN
Would
KOLENDA
It
study
(MEXICO):
I
second
that.
is
moved
and
and
further
I would
seconded
report.
like
to
that
Is
discuss
it
there
that.
it
a
be
any
I
am speaking for the motion to the extent that we have the term
'war' before us.
We were all members of a hot war.
This is a
cold war.
This is a war of ideologies,
a war that we are not
accustomed to.
We fought everybody in the world and we won and
we will win this one, but, on the other hand, it is going to
take strength in our military forces and the way to get that
strength is by having these people drafted into the services.
I can only think of this little bit that Commander Burke
said last night about the Senator from California who picked up
the rules and said,
"There is nothing in here that says we have
to be fair.”
Now, this is part of my talk that I would like to expound
on just a little bit.
Our ideological war has possibly been
hotter than any war we have ever had and unless we of The American
Legion support these men who are going into this ideological war
full
scale,
we
are
likely
to meet
with
a little
bit
of
disaster.
We have continually been on the upgrade protecting our own from
the hot wars.
We seem,
at this time, to be holding back and
this is where I would support Clarence Horton from Alabama in
suspending this.
Let's see what the Congress comes up with.
After all, maybe their influence is a little bit stronger than
ours at this time.
Maybe they will come up with something that
we can back.
Again,
I would say let's support this motion of
suspense
you
The
for
the
time
being.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Is
ready for the question?
motion was carried.
It
there any further discussion?
Are
All in favor say aye; opposed, no.
is so ordered,
and that will complet
206
the
report
of
MR.
submitted
happened
the
Recommendations
Committee.
CRIDER (TENNESSEE):
I had a recommendation that I
concerning the reevaluation of Rating Boards.
What
on
that?
MR.
KEEMMETSON:
It
was
read
MR.
CRIDER:
Excuse
me.
I
and
was
adopted.
dozing
a
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Are there any
report?
Jim, that is your resolution,
further
the one
removal
Board.
of
MR.
the
doctor
CRIDER:
from
From
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
remove
the
doctor
MR. CRIDER:
adopted it.
Am I
CHAIRMAN
CHAIRMAN
to do it.
Rating
signing
Rating
I would like
out of line?
We
I will
time?
McCURDY:
on
the
Boards
the proposal
was
on
adopted
the
recommendation.
can
move
to
rejected.
talk
that.
that.
yes.
to
concede
You
on
questions on the
that wants the
report,
By the action here,
the
McCURDY:
MR. CRIDER:
considered at this
want
from
the
the
little
that.
Can
the
You
have
question
reconsideration
if
be
re-
they
MR. CRIDER:
I would ask for reconsideration of that
particular resolution.
It was my error.
I did not hear the
recommendation read, but if it was moved for rejection,
I would
like to talk on that issue,
if the motion to adopt the Resolutions Committee report can be reconsidered to allow me to discuss this particular resolution.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
I
would
rule
that
that
was
in
order
since the vote was unanimous,
I am sure that he voted for it
and it is therefore in order to reconsider it, and he has moved
that Recommendation No. 8 be lifted from the report and reconsidered.
Is there a second to this motion? A VOICE:
I second
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It is moved and seconded.
All in favor
say aye; opposed, no.
I can't tell whether just the Commission
members are voting.
Will all those Commission members in favor of
the reconsideration rise?
All right.
Now will all those opposed
to reconsideration rise?
The motion is lost.
We will now hear from Judge Alter with a report on
committee of Certificates
of Appreciation.
Judge Alter.
the
Sub-
JUDGE ALTER:
Mr. Chairman and members of the Rehabilitation
Commission:
The National Executive Committee in 1958
initiated
a program of issuing Certificates of Appreciation to retired
Veterans Administration officials who had exhibited a special
interest in liberalizing, within their power,
the benefits to be
received by worthy veterans.
In 1959,
at Minneapolis,
the Rehabilitation Executive
Committee approved a motion authorizing the Chairman of the
habilitation Commission to appoint a committee to inspect
210
Re-
nominations received from various Departments in the national
organization and recommend that Certificates of Appreciation be
issued to those individuals.
According
to the rules which were
to govern this special committee,
two nominations might be received from a Department with a membership of less than 50,000),
three from
a Department with membership of 50,000
to 100,000,
four from a Department with membership of 100,000 to 200,000,
and five from a Department with membership above 200,000.
The
committee has carefully considered the recommendations submitted
by various Departments for consideration and begs leave to report
that in its judgment the following named retired Veterans Administration officials have earned recognition from the National
Rehabilitation Commission for their interest in those veterans
who were entitled to benefits provided by law.
Your committee, therefore,
of Appreciation be issued to the
Administration officials:
Central
Office:
recommends that
following named
Certificates
retired Veterans
C. C.
Brown, Member,
Board of Veterans Appeals,
B. A..Nolan, “Ad judicator.
William Y. Hester,
Supervising Attorney-Field
Examiner.
Dee H. Beer, Chief Attorney.
Dr. Roy H. Bryant.
DeLoss I. Marken, Chaplain
Arkansas:
Colorado:
Georgia:
Iowa:
William
Maine:
Michigan:
B.
Nugent,
Manager,
Regional
Office.
Malcolm L. Stoddard, Manager, Center.
Miss Grace S. Ross, Chief, Registar Division,
Charles Rogers, Chief of Contact
Asa Hursey, Contact Representative,
George N. Kinser, Assistant Supply Officer.
Harry H. Wilson, Contact Representative
Mississippi:
Missouri:
(Deceased).
Nebraska:
Dr. Milton P. Arnhold, Rating Specialist,
Harry Hall, Agent Cashier,
Samuel D. Smith, Chief of Contact.
Frank J. Hoesch, Manager, District Office.
Robert J. Foster, Member, Rating Board.
James Howze, Chief of Contact.
L. H. Hall, Manager, Regional Office,
R. L. Popwell, Adjudication Officer.
Henry Grady Goode, Member, Rating Board,
Hillary G. Hooks, Manager, Hospital.
Pennsylvania:
Tennessee:
Texas:
Washington:
West
of
be
Virginia:
Mr. Chairman,
the report has been signed by all the members
our committee and I now move that the report of the committee
approved.
MR.
JENSEN:
I
second
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It has been regularly moved and seconded
that the report be approved.
Are you ready for the question?
All in favor say I; opposed, no.
The ayes have it.
It is so
ordered.
Thank
JUDGE
under
service
you,
ALTER:
Judge,
Thank
for the
and
I
am
job.
you.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We
a different division,
officers,
fine
have one
one that
other citation that
we are empowered to
comes
award
to
going
call
for
this
award.
211
to
on John
Corcoran
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman
Rehabilitation Commission, by the
National Executive Committee,
you
a citation
that
for
meritorious
service
and members of the National
authority vested in you by the
have authorized the award of
posthumously.
May
I now
read
citation?
"Citation for Meritorious Service.
For meritorious service
and loyal cooperation in The American Legion's Rehabilitation
program, William C. McCauley is hereby awarded
this citation in
recognition
thereof
The
Legion."
Commission
of
Mr. Chairman, with your permission I would like now to
upon for a response Mr. Ralph Scott,
the Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission, Department of Illinois.
call
American
by
the
National
Rehabilitation
MR. SCOTT:
Director John, Chairman Bob, members of the
Rehabilitation Commission,
and friends,
it is with deep humility
and gratitude that as Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission
of the great Department of Illinois,
I accept this memorial to
William R. McCauley.
Bill was my sponsor, my tutor, in The
American Legion.
He spoke the kind of language that I understood
and that we all understand.
In
Commander
the
of
early years
Illinois
for
of
The
two
American
Legion,
successive
terms,
he
was
being
Department
the
only
man to hold that distinction.
He spent his own money to come to
Washington to fight for the veteran when the only agency he had
to deal with was the old Bureau of War Risk Litigation.
He was
one of the men who sat down at Salem,
Illinois to draft the GI
Bill of Rights,
so important to the World War II veteran and
the Korean veteran.
After the return of World War II veterans
he was one of the first to welcome us to The American Legion and
said,
"If you can't lick them,
join them."
And he did just that.
He was Department Rehabilitation Chairman of the Department
of Illinois for years,
until he was unable to carry on due to
his physical condition.
He died last month at the Marion,
Illinois VA Hospital,
that he worked so hard to establish.
He
was ""Mr. Rehab'" to the end.
Again,
I gratefully
Department of Illinois.
CHAIRMAN
We
have
McCURDY:
one
Monday which is
that resolution
referred
say
thanks
Thank
you.
to
resolution
Resolution 201
at this time.
and
I
you
that
will
on
was
ask
behalf
held
John
of
over
to
the
from
last
present
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman,
this is Resolution No. 201
from Minnesota,
as you said.
The subject is to
amend eligibility
rules pertaining to the gainfully employed when filing claim for
pension.
It is short and I would like to read the full language
of
the
resolution.
"Whereas,
the earned income of veterans before they file
claim for pension varies according to their accupations;
and
"Whereas,
the present rules and regulations pertaining to
the eligibility are unfair to the low income group, particularly
to the farmers who have a low net income;
"Now,
therefore,
be it resolved by The American Legion in
National Convention assembled at Miami Beach, Florida,
Oct. 17-20
a
212
1960,
that the eligibility rule be changed so that those having
a low income be no longer penalized because of their income or
the narrow interpretation of the words
'gainfully employed.'"
on
That resolution
Rehabilitation.
I
which
recommends
was referred to the
have in front of me
rejection
very difficult to
because, frankly,
of
this
standing Commission
a two-page memorandum
resolution.
I find
it
very,
attempt to discuss or debate this resolution
I simply do not understand its intent.
I think, Mr. Chairman,
that a more orderly way of proceeding, therefore, would be to ask Pat Cliff or some other member
from Minnesota if they have knowledge of this resolution to
present that aspect of it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
The motion was to reject, which was
seconded and then ordered held, so the parliamentary situation
is that there is a motion on the floor to reject the resolution.
It is now open for debate.
motion
dation
MR.
to
to
CLIFF:
Do.l understand, Mr. Chairman,
that that
reject was last made on Monday?
It was a recommenreject, but I have also a motion -=
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I
motion was not made.
That
care.to make, ahy
one,
MR.
motion
be
CLIFF:
Do
you
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
is made.
think you
is now up
want
me
to
It
isn't
are
for
right, Pat, that the
any motion that you
make
a
properly
motion?
on
the
floor
until
a
MR. CLIFF:
I wdll move, Mr. Chairman,
that the resolution
adopted and the recommendation for rejection be overruled.
CHAIRMAN
A
VOICE:
CHAIRMAN
resolution
the
McCURDY:
I
second
Is
there
a
second
to
the
motion?
it.
McCURDY:
It
be approved.
has
It
been moved and seconded
is now open for debate.
that
MR. CLIFF:
I think that there is some confusion probably
with reference to the resolution.
I didn't draft it and I am
not the author of the resolution,
but on the basis of experience
which we have had in our Department,
this idea
of fixing a
percentage of what a man may have earned as a basis for determining whether he is gainfully employed or not is not a desirable application.
You have an income limitation.
Why should
the income limitation based upon the interpretation of "gainfully
employed" cut down the amount of money that a man could receive
merely because he may be a laboring man or a farmer?
In discussing this with some of the others,
I understand that there are
some sections of the country that might feel this would put an
imposition on that they
don't like, but I can't see any interpretation,
How are we going to establish two rules, one for a fellow
who may have assigned his property to his wife, and has cut his
income down, who has retired,
and then one for the poor boy who
is
merely
still
not
trying
making
to
get
$1200.
along
and
213
still
hasn't
acquired
or
is
In my book the language of "gainful employment" would at
least mean that he would make that much money or more and that
income limitation pertains only to where a man then exceeds in
his income $1200 by his work,
and then he should be taken off
the roll, but to say that he can't get on the roll where he is
over 65
and has a disability required by that merely because
he
did
make
some
money,
I don't
think
is
justified.
There might be some discussion on that in view of the
fact that courts and everybody generally
recognized that the
value of the dollar has depreciated.
There may have been times
during his lifetime while, not measured in dollars, but in
purchasing power that he was making more than $1200 a year.
Now, you are running into a technicality there that we
don'tfeel is justified.
I have an instance myself where an
application was made and the fellow;s showing was not sufficient
to
show
he
was
making
$1200.
Now,
his
income
has
increased
and, of course,
if he had been put on the roll, he should go
off the roll, but why apply the limitation merely because a
man has not made that money?
That to us seems to be very,
very unfair and you are taking advantage of the fellow when
possibly that's all he has, while somebody else is sitting by
with a lot of property with his income cut down and he is
getting a pension.
It is causing a great deal of dissatisfaction
in our Department,
and we would like a clarification on that,
if the purpose of the resolution is that the limitation apply
to everybody, not to somebody who is retired, but also to the
men who are somewhat just hanging on for the purpose of trying
to do something, who should not be penalized by the interpretation of what is "gainful employment."
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
pretation of that is not
cause a single man
as you know.
What
employed of a
because he is
can
you
Then I
on the
understand,
Pat, that your interincome limitation itself, be-
go to $1800
are talking
and a married man
about is a rating
farmer.
Is that right,
gainfully employed?
that
he
can't
to
of
$3,000,
gainfully
qualify
MR. CLIFF:
I don't limit it merely to a farmer.
Anyone
who has been laboring all his life is still doing something
and he has to eat and if he isn't making that much money why
should he be penalized?
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I am just trying to clear up your
point;
that a man who
is making $1200, for instance,
a year,
any man, should not be barred purely on the basis that he is
gainfully
MR.
employed
.CLIFF:
and
That
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
MR.-CLIFR:
= That
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
therefore,
1s
cannot
qualify?
now
correct.
That
is
is
your
point?
correct.
I
understand
what
the
point
is.
MR. CORCORAN:
Pat, let's begin at the beginning on this
thing, because I am not sure that I do understand the point.
If
I understand the point,
I believe that this resolution should be
rejected.
The pension that we are talking about is, of course,
a non-service connected pension.
It is a monthly payment for
disability,
not necessarily the result of service.
214
One of the eligibility requirements
that a man must meet
before he gets a pension is he must establish he is unemployable
because of disability.
Once he has established that he gets
the monthly pension,
provided his income from any source is within the statutory limitations.
Therefore,
we
have
to
start
with
the
point
that
every
man
we are talking about is unemployable.
Now, the Veterans Administration has issued a number of regulations liberalizing the
interpretation of what is unemployability.
One of the liberalizations says and specifically mention farmers,
that where a man
is marginally employed,
that shall not prevent the payment of
pension.
They define "marginally employed".
Generally,
it
will be the sheltered type of employment or the employment where
he works less than half
the usual number of hours and receives
less than half the usual amount of remuneration.
They have, as
I said, specified farmers and have attempted recently,
as a matter
of fact,
just two months before this particular resolution was
passed by the Department
of Minnesota,
made a specific liberalization on farmers.
The amount of money that a man receives does not determine
whether or not he is held to be unemployable,
so that's why I
don't think that this resolution should be approved:
it seems
to me to say that a detemmination of unemployability is tied up
with the amount of money a man receives.
That isn't true.
I
am not sure whether I have made my position clear, Mr. Chairman.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
Is
there
any
further
discussion?
MR. CLIFF:
1: 3just want to make this point.
John, I
haven't seen that regulation.
'1 am sorry that I haven't, but
the term used,
as I understand it, is "gainful employment."
Now, you recognize employment,
don't you?
Yet, in the other
place you say he must be unemployed.
You have "gainful employment: in the Act.
If it is gainful,
then in our language he
should
be
making
that
much
or
more,
and
if
it
isn't
gainful
he isn't making that much or more and if they are putting
the interpretation that he must be unemployed, why is the
"gainful employment' there?
in
term
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I think those of you who are here and
heard this case come up specifically when we had the panel will
remember at that time in answer to the question he said if those
are all the facts, he would be entitled to send it in.
That is
what John was getting at, that we don't want to tie unemployment
which is one of the basic things,
to any amount of money because
there are others that may be taking as much as $1800 and that
still get it.
I remember a case that was appealed on a fellow
in Michigan that owned a little grocery store.
It was one of
those little family grocery stores where he and his wife both
ran it on one of those 12 or 14-hour day propositions and they
barred him because he was running that little business and
we sent that in and they said that because he was making something like $1500
a year,
and was
living on it, he
was substantially unemployable and gave him his pension.
So we
know
of many cases where they have been liberalized in the interpretation and there are adequate regulations covering it.
If
question?
there
A
CHAIRMAN
any
further
voice:
Yes.
McCURDY:
discussion?
The
question
215
Are you
is
to
ready
approve
for
the
the
resolution.
All those in favor
solution is lost.
say
aye;
all
those
opposed,
no.
The
Now, we have a brief report from Vice Chairman
on the organizational meeting of the Subcommittee on
Milton.
re-
Appiebaum
Aging.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
We met Monday
afternoon,
as we announced at the first meeting of the Commission,
with Director Bird.of the Economic Commission, Cecil Munson of
our
staff,
Joseph
Holzka
of
the
Economic
Commission,
Clint
Knight and Ross Foust of our Commission,
and myself,
of course,
we have all had the benefit now of our people from the President's
Conference on Problems of the Aged and Aging and I think we of
the subcommittee,
as well as yourself, must agree that we have
in the Veterans Administration a very extensive program to help
the veteran who is getting older.
I think there are
Veterans Administration
has
promoted
and
things that
program and
carried
on
for
care of his particular problems.
committee that the problem of the
exclusive problem when it appears
of public
the
in
aid
the
veteran
to
him
the
handle
in the
Legion
and
take
We, therefore,
feel in the
aging veteran is a mutally
that it is a general problem
aging.
of
field
are provided for
in the work that
We are, however, pursuing the various matters that come
under the purview of both Commissions, Economic and Rehabilitation,
and we will by the time of our spring meeting be able to make
some definite recommendations.
We are a recommending committee.
We are a committee,
not a Commission,
and our recommendations
will go to the Commissions and to the NEC.
If we complete our
studies in time we will do that.
I do want to say this because
I get
into
a field
where
I have
had
to depend
a great
deal
on
the professional and detailed studies that have gone before
my work and the work of my subcommittee.
I want to say I have
had to pick up a lot of information and get the benefit of other
people's studies.
I find that our particular subcommittee perhaps is going to make recommendations or do our best work where
we don't solve the problems before us in terms of aged and
aging.
This is merely a catch-all for a great many particular
problems that we in Rehabilitation have considered under the
headings of employment,
housing, pensions,
compensation,
hospitals,
medical
care,
and
loans
to
people
who
have
expectancy,
for example,
than the loan officers
they ought to have for good loans.
That is the
thing we want to examine carefully,
but we will
a great
many
of
the
problems
referred
to
us
in
a
shorter
life
and banks think
very detailed
hope to solve
terms
of
other
longer
they
problems and other solutions.
I don't think anybody ever feels
really old.
I know when I reached my age, I previously thought
I was going to be a pretty old man, but I can see
I am not, so
I am just beginning to know something about what I am doing.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
The
talk.
trying
MR.
to
APPLEBAUM:
do, Bob.
That
older
gives
you
they
get,
the
an
idea
of
what
we
are
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank you, Milt. Right along that line,
the VA has just put out this book which is a very interesting and
fine book, "The Aging American Veteran and the National Economy."
216
Since they were over
and we have a supply
they will be up here
that
would
you all
ing.
like
look
at
here yesterday,
they have gotten the books,
now, so that all of us
may have a copy and
on the table when we adjourn for anyone
to
have
it
because
one
of
it
these
is
books,
very
and
I
informative
recommend
and
that
interest-
Now, we have one more order of business and that is the
report from Area
Chairmen with respect to future meetings and
I would like to quickly have the report of these Chairmen.
Area
my
MR.
report
A.
THOMAS W. BYERS (CONNECTICUT):
I
with the Director, John Corcoran.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
BYERS:
CHAIRMAN
Area
McCURDY:
You
filed
it
in
have
already
filed
writing?
: Yes.
McCURDY:
Thank
you.
B.
MR. CHARLES E. JACKSON (DELAWARE):
A meeting was held of
Area B on March 2.
It was decided to continue our policy of not
having an Area B Conference each year unless the Chairman or a
ma jority of the members felt there was a need for one.
In such
case, we would request permission from Chairman McCurdy to hold
a conference.
gE
We also reaffirmed our position that we are not
opposed
to Area Conferences as such,
if the respective area feels
some good will
come from these conferences.
CHAIRMAN
Area
C.
MR.
W.
McCURDY:
W.
Thank
WADSWORTH
you.
(ALABAMA):
The
of Area C reveals we want to continue
area and called by the Chairman as to
CHAIRMAN
Area
D,
MR.
J.
R.
McCURDY:
LAIRD
Thank
(IOWA):
D will
not
hold
members
of
the
McCURDY:
Thank
you.
NEVADA):
E,
JOHN
LOUGARIS
(RENO,
our
Chairman,
we
have
delegates
in
the
area
con-
sir.
the
MR.
of
the
Area
Area
absence
of
C meeting
place.
of
ference unless the majority
that one is necessary.
CHAIRMAN
you,
poll
the Area
time and
decided
an
area
Mr.
Chairman,
not
to
have
decide
in the
a
conference
in the coming year.
If at the discretion of the Chairman,
he
decides to have a conference we will have one, provided that will
be highly attended.
Otherwise,
we will not have a conference.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
Thank
you,
217
John.
You have all had an opportunity to read the report of the
Insurance Advisory Board.
That report was just received at the
meeting on Monday.
Does someone care to make a motion regarding
the Insurance Advisory Board?
MR.
JENSEN:
COLONEL
I
move
MURRAY:
I
it
be
second
adopted.
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDYY:
It has been moved and seconded
report of the Insurance Advisory Board be approved.
Is
any discussion?
A
motion
VOICE:
that the
there
Question.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
was carried.
All
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
anything further that he
in
favor
say
aye;
opposed,
no.
The
Does any member of the Commission have
would like to present to this meeting?
MR. KOLENDA:
Most of you heard my question directed to Mr.
Teague,
and you heard his answer.
There is an absence of a mandate from the Convention in this respect this year.
There has
been a mandate since 1952
and for some reason or other,
this
year there has been none.
We will see that there is one made at
the 1961 Convention, but meanwhile,
I would like this Commission
to instruct the Washington staff to follow through on this and
give information necessary to passage of any legislation favorable to this type of program on service-connected disabled
veterans residents abroad.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Let me interrupt you to say the way
to do that is to say that "I move that we approve the action"
you want taken and get a second and we will put it to a vote
and then we can have it passed and effective.
It is not in
effect at the present time.
like
MR. KOLENDA:
to so
move.
This
is
MR.
(RHODE
ISLAND):
BROWNING
exactly
it,
Chairman
Second
the
Bob,
JACKSON:
CHAIRMAN
Is
there
any
:I.second
McCURDY:
discussion
It
on
I
would
motion.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
That is hospitalization
service-connected comrades in foreign countries.
regularly moved.
Has there been a second?
MR.
and
and
It
treatment
has been
for
it.
has
the
All
CHAIRMAN
Thank
regularly
favor
aye;
and
seconded.
Yes.
Lou,
I wanted you to stop while you were ahead.
There
also extra copies of the Insurance Advisory report available
you care to have them.. Does anyone have anything else?
are
if
I want to thank you sincerely and I also want
Reverend Bill Adams,
the Past Department Commander
who has returned to give the benediction.
218
the
you,
say
moved
VOICE:
The
McCURDY:
in
A
no.
motion
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
was carried.
been
question?
opposed,
comrades.
to thank
of D. C.,
REVEREND
ADAMS:
We
trust,
Oh,
Lord,
that
we
have
done
Thy work and will in this Conference.
As we depart, may it be
with Thy benediction so that we may return with Thy grace safely to our homes,
to our various business and professional activities,
and to our much greater service to God and Country.
This we beseech Thee in the name of Jesus Christ,
our Lord,Amen.
trip
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
home, everybody.
Thank
you,
Chaplain.
«ee. At 12:20 o'clock the final meeting
Rehabilitation Commission was adjourned.
* kkk
k kkk k
219
Have
of
a
nice
the National
The following is the transcript of the Joint Sessions of
Commission and Committee Members and Delegatesto the National
Commander's Conference:
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 1, 1961
. . . The Joint Session of Commission and Committee Members and Delegates to the National Commander's Conference convened in the Congressional Room, Hotel Statler, Washington, D.C.
at
9:00
a.
m.,
Rehabilitation
give
Mr.
Robert
M.
Commission,
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
the invocation.
McCurdy,
Chairman
of
the
National
presiding.
I
will
call
on
our
National
Chaplain
to
REVEREND MOSS:
Our Holy Father, we thank Thee for these
days together, days of inspiration, days when we find again that
The American Legion is planning well for this country that we
love. We praise Thee, Oh, God, for its officers and leadership
and
ask
we
We
hear
this
thank
blessing
and help
Thee
report
for
from
his
our
devotion
Commander.
to
duty
and
pray
continued
upon him.
Guide us, we pray Thee, during these
us to sense the importance of this, our beloved
zation, and
this decade
the life of this
of decision, for
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
great country as
we prayed in Thy
This
year,
we
days
organi-
we go forward to
Holy Name, Amen.
in California
are
very
proud indeed that we have the distinguished and outstanding
National Commander.
I can make a long Speech about my warm,
close personal friend,
Bill Burke.
I believe that he speaks
himself
by
calling
this
great
Conference
together
for
the
for
first
time in a Commander's Conference to coordinate our program with
all our committees and commissions in an endeavor to really make
contribution
to our country,
Bill,
I am just happy to have you
here.
We of the Rehabilitation Commission certainly feel highly
honored that you come here this morning and talk to us along with
your other committees and commission.
National Commander Bill
Burke.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Bob.
Ladies and gentlemen,
my comrades,
it is
pleasing to me to
see a majority here this morning because I agree with the great
Benjamin Disraeli that a majority is more convincing than the
best
of
oratory.
This
was
brought
home
to me
rather
silenced
and
the
program
and
future
forcefully
in Massachusetts
the other night, where after addressing a meeting of the Department
in Boston,
I never received such an ovation.
I was called back to the podium on three separate occasions and
someone in the rear of the room kept shouting,
"Three cheers for
the National Commander."
When
the
hall
was
finally
Chairman,
the
Department Commander,
asked the man in the rear of the hall what
he was attempting
to do, he said,
"Three cheers for the National
Commander for wearing his uniform."
I mention this to you because
it 1s particularly pleasing to see American Legionnaires,
better
than 2,000 strong, meeting in our nation's capital for the first
time with the major committees and commissions of The American
Legion,
in addition to transacting our normal business,
addressing
themselves
to
the
over-all
policy
220
of The
American Legion.
I think this is particularly appropriate at
this time when we begin a new decade of American history with
a new Congress and a new Administration.
set
As
forth
you
the
know,
in
fact
that
the
program
the
future
which
is
of
before
our
you,
we
organization
have
cannot
be distinguished from the destiny of the American people and
therefore, we believe that it is only proper that we address
ourselves,
in addition to our own parochial problems,
to the
problems of both our national organization as an organization,
and
the
American
people
Therefore,
reviewing
for
we
as
believe
ourselves
out
a
people.
that
of
we
our
can
42
make
and
more
a
contribution
years
of
by
history
how we can make a contribution
to the future of our country.
Therefore,
I have asked these committees and commissions to meet
jointly here in Washington.
I thank particularly the Legislative
and Rehabilitation Commissions for their willingness
to meet
here at one time and to make the sacrifice of some of their
normal prerogatives
in order that the work of our organization
may be advanced.
I thank the other committee and commission
Chairmen for the inconvenience which meeting here at this time
of
time
the
of
I
out
and
year
has
would
came
like
up
House Veterans'
American Legion
for
imposed
meeting.
a program
in
upon
them
particularly
such
to
strength
Affairs Committee
presented to that
for
the
coming
as
year.
opposed
thank
to
those
yesterday,
to
their
of
you
appear
normail
who
turned
before
the
at the time at which The
committee its recommendations
I have asked particularly that you come together here this
morning because in addition to transacting the normal work of
your Commission, we have prepared a guide list, and a check list,
and a series of questions which have been submitted to each
Chairman of a committee or a commission in order that tomorrow
afternoon when our Program Study Committee meets it will be
possible for the Chairman of each committee or commission to
briefly report to that Program Study Committee in order to afford
them guide lines for their work in charting our policies,
and
our programs,
and our organization for the years just ahead,
and
that they will have the counsel and advice of the Commissions
here assembled in terms of how they see their future goal, how
they see their job, and how they would like to see their Commission and the Division reorganized or reemphasized.
Therefore,
in addition to your normal work,
I ask that
you set aside a little bit of time while you are here in order
to assist your Chairman in preparing the recommendations which
he will support and will report to the Program Study Committee.
In addition to that, we are attempting to tighten up, to
streamline,
to gain new impact, for The American Legion on all
fronts.
As you well know,
there will be no
problem which will
face The American Legion in terms of next Congress which will be
of more importance than that of the recommendations which have
been made and will be made in the area of reorganization of our
defense establishment.
For your information,
therefore,
I have checked and I find
that we have no clear mandates in this area, with the exception
of Spike Kelly's demand that we reorganize and provide for a
single catalogue,
but that this
is an area which affects a number
221
of our committees and commission.
I have,
therefore,
appointed
a group of distinguished Legionnaires under the Chairmanship of
Past National Commander Preston Moore and the Vice Chairmanship
of George Craig,
and on the Committee are the Chairmen of th~
particular committees and commissions affected,
including Econo-
mic, Security,
Naval
Affairs,
Military
Affairs,
Air
and
Space,
and in addition thereto, have secured the support of men who
have had the background in the defense establishment,
including
our Past National Commander,
Louis Johnson, Paul Griffith,
and
Perry Brown.
We have other members of that committee,
but
essentially,
they are addressing themselves to the question of
what contribution may The American Legion make to the thinking
of our country in the area of defense reorganization and national
security.
This is the first time we have gathered everyone together
in this sort of a meeting.
We are bound to have some loose ends
and many of the loose ends are due to the fact that in a sense
we become a larger meeting than we anticipated.
Our banquet now
is just in excess of 1600.
Better than 400 Members of the Congress have accepted our invitation to break bread
with us on the
night
of
the
second.
There are actually no adequate facilities for a banquet of
that size
in Washington.
Even some of the halls which could
handle it under one roof,
cannot do so properly because of other
considerations,
so we have tied together all the rooms available
here at the Statler by a system of closed circuit television and
monitors,
and we hope and we trust that it will be a good,
and
a proper,
and an adequate method of putting together a banquet
of this size, and this scope.
I would point out to you that, while,
of course,
all of
us could not end up being front row center,
the manner in which
the banquet was organized and the priorities established were
set up on your behalf by your Department Commanders and Adjutants
at their meeting in Indianapolis in November at which the priorities were established by means of a drawing,
so that you have
no one to complain to but the Gods of Fate and the Gods of Chance,
if you are not front row center.
I am pleased to announce to you this morning that for the
first time this year,
after a late start,
a late Convention,
and
a lot of hard work in. the Department,
the membership of The
American Legion is now 5,000
ahead of a similar date last year.
I thank you for your participation and I invite your
comments.
Jim Watkins is here if you need specific information,
although I would suggest if it is not something that you need
immediately,
that you check our national headquarters just
across the street if you do need your tickets,
information,
or anything of vital importance,
the staff under Billy Hauck and
under Jim Watkins are there to assist you and be of
help.
I thank you for being here.
I believe that by our combined
efforts we will bring a new impact,
a new vitality,
and a new
freshness to the work of The American Legion.
I believe that
when we finish our work the President,
the Congress,
and the good
people of Washington will have known we have been here.
Thank you.
panel
to
the
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
to take questions
Commander.
If
It has always
from the floor
not,
you
may
222
all
been the format
if anyone has a
go
to
your
own
of our
question
several
meetings.
ov. + «AT 9:25
a. m., the
Joint Session of CommissSion and
Committee Members and Delegataes
to the National Commander's
Conference was recessed.
. .
223
THURSDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
. . . The Joint Session of Commission and Committee Members and Delegates to the National Commander's Conference reconvened in the Congressional Room, Hotel Statler,
Washington,
D. C., at 3:30 p. m., Mr. Robert M. McCurdy, Chairman of the
National Rehabilitation Commission, presiding.
. .
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Will the Chairmen of all commissions
come forward and sit on the platform, please?
Will you all be
seated?
This is the time and place set for appraisal of the
work and of the commissions who are participating in this conference.
We have here today to furnish us our inspiration and
to appraise the results of this first Joint Conference our
National Commander.
Bill, we are happy
National Commander,
Bill
COMMANDER
BURKE:
to hear from
Burke.
Thank
you,
offer
an
you
at
Robert,
this
time.
and out
of
Our
no
lack
of confidence in the work of the committees, but with a prayerful thought for the future, I would ask you
to rise and our
National
Chaplain
will
REVEREND MOSS:
growing awareness of
invocation.
Almighty God,
these days, of
ference, of the importance
of this fair land in which
of
we
we thank Thee for
the importance of
the
this con-
The American Legion in the life
live.
We thank Thee for the skill
and the vigor of its leadership.
We pray that the impression
made here may redound not only to our good, but to the good
of our Nation and thus to the good of the world.
Be Thou in
our midst.
May that spirit ever guide and bless us in
all
things,
in the name of our Lord, Amen.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you.
My comrades,
at our opening session,
as you know, we
assembled here our major commissions not only to conduct their
normal policy and administrative work, but likewise to give some
attention to recommendations
to be made to the Committee on
Program
and
Policy,
At
this
time,
therefore,
I will
call
on
the
Chairmen of the principal Commissions which have met here.
If
their reports are in written form, I would ask them to submit
them to the National Adjutant at the table to the right and to
give
this
Martin
minute
the
committee
and
for
the
benefit
of
its
Chairman,
McKneally,
our Past National Commander,
a three
precise statement on the contents thereof.
I would call therefore at this time, Mr.
Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission.
Robert
Mr.
to
M.
five
McCurdy,
MR, McCURDY:
It will De a little difficult to give such
big speech in such a short time.
I have chosen the subject to
report on in keeping with the theme,
"The American Legion in
America's Future,’ and the
sub-theme of our Commission,
'Aging
With Dignity."
The National Commander's is a great theme and
our particular sub-theme directs our attention to many great
a
problems.
of
all
You have heard in the course
the male population over 65
224
of our deliberations that 05 %
are now veterans,
and that 63%
over the
peculiar
age
and
of 65
will be veterans in 10 years,
definite problem for veterans.
so
it
is
a
The problems,
as outlined in our Commissiom,
fall into
three general groups:
economic, medical,
and social and recreational.
There are many subdivisions of these.
In the
economic group we must assure adequate income,
insure pension,
compensation,
insurance,
social security,
employment.
We should
consider taxes,
too - many of you do not know that a person
retired over 65
oftentimes can get more than $5000
tax exemption.
Housing
and
homes
are
another
problem;
for housing and homes where the
ference and material aid in the
income groups, or for financing
many
laws
aged can receive material
financing or building for
of nursing homes,
etc.
there
are
now
prelow
As to medical and hospital problems, we all have devoted
our lifetime to the protection of the veteran in his medical and
hospital problems.
These problems have grown with age and so
they are going to become more challenging to us in
the future.
In our conference here this week we have heard of the gradual
change that is taking place in VA; they are now starting a test
on the change to restoration centers,
rehabilitation centers,
something to provide intermediate care in a restoration program.
We must insist that these programs,
and particularly the programs for our comrades, will be continued and improved.
The social and recreational division is a great field
for
The American Legion.
You must have facilities; we have to have
a place where our older veterans and our older citizens can
discuss their problems,
discuss their community programs,
keep
Ain touch with legislation,
be available for volunteer service,
continue their education,
and enjoy some of the benefits of old
age.
There is a solution that we all may help and participate
in, I believe.
If you solve the veteran problem you are solving
a big portion of the problem of the county also.
Let's not say
that the veteran problem is a small segment;
it is
a large segment, but because it is a large segment perhaps it is
the opportunity for the greatest community service program that The
American Legion has ever undertaken.
I am going to specify in just one instance,
and demonstrate
how you might do this.
In thinking over this program,
after hearing all our
fine speakers on the subject,
I thought about my own
18th District in California.
We have 36 Posts,
33 American
Legion club houses.
There is only one club house that is used
daily,
the rest are used for meeting and special events.
I
wondered if it would not be a dynamic and challenging program
to
make
our
club
house
a
rallying
point
for
our
older
people.
We
had a
committee meeting four years ago in Pasadena Post and
they became interested in this subject.
They were ahead of their
time, because they saw that we had unlimited talent,
unlimited
ability in our older folks but there was no facility and no
opportunity to be together and discuss their problems - they were
sort of lost in the community.
They formed a committee and propositioned the city.
I had the privilege of selecting an architect
and supervising the construction of a $175,000
club house in one
of our nice parts for the
aged.
When this was done we got the
Junior League to appropriate $75,000
over the period of five years
and they took over the management of it under "Senior Citizens,
Incorporated."
They now have a place to play cards, dance, have
a band,
all the arts and crafts,
and the latent talent of our
community has been restored and has
made itself a voice and an
active interest.
225
United
but
Just consider, with our thousands
States, what a thing we could do
for
all
our
older
citizens
and
in
of club
for not
turn
for
houses in the
only our veterans
our
country.
I
believe that this would be a constructive program in keeping
with our basic theme.
"The American Legion in America's Future."
Thank
you,
COMMANDER
Comrade
Commander.
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Robert.
I was just present at Bob's retirement and I can
you that he expects to be more active since retirement
fore. You now know why the great Irish playwright said
a shame to waste youth on the young.
Bob, in your case
not been wasted.
assure
than bethat it is
it has
I present to you Jerome F.
National Legislative Commission.
of
bers
Mr.
MR, DUGGAN:
Mr.
of the Auxiliary,
Commander,
capable
tions.
going
we
filed
Duggan,
the
Chairman
our
Commander , my fellow Legionnaires, memand friends of the Legion.
Heretofore,
with
you and
with
the
Chairman
of
your
committee the necessary answers to your series of quesHowever,
I find that since coming into the room we are
to have
to
ask
leave
to
amend
them
because
of
the
appoint-
ment of a special committee to make a report tomorrow morning.
This special committee informs me that they
have come up with
a different
thought and a different idea concerning the matter
they were pledged to study,
and I think after we act on that
we will file an amended report with Martin McKneally,
Past
National Commander and Chairman of this committee.
We have
attached to the answers a report concerning legislation and we
of the Legislative Commission welcome this cpportunity to give
you in point of figures what we have been trying to do.
ments
The
in
first
the
question
past
five
dealt
years.
with
was
what
were
the
accomplish-
In 1955
your Legislative Committee had 210 resolutions
referred to it, either by the National Convention or the fall
or spring meetings of the National Executive Committee.
We
achieved a percent of passage of the legislation out of the
210 resolutions of 19.4 per cent.
In 1956
we had 129 resolutions referred to us.
We achieved a point of percentage in
passage by the Congress of 54.28
per cent.
In the 85th
Congress,
the first session,
1957,
we had 175
resolutions
and we achieved a percentage point of 10.40.
In the
second year,
1958,
we had 145
resolutions referréd and we achieved
a percentage of 47.58
per cent.
In
achieved
We
1959
we
had
a percentage
were only
151
resolutions
point
successful
of
referred
12.
with
18
of
those
to us
and
we
matters.
In 1960 we had 157
and we were able to accomplish the
passage of 38, attaining a percentage of "22.20,
and this year,
thanks to surveillance by various convention committees and
scrutiny by the National Executive Committee, we are down to
98 resolutions and we are hopeful that we will be successful.
I might say to you that the slogan
"Legislation is Everyone's Business,"
is
226
that we have
not original
adopted,
with your
Commission.
The title came into being many years ago through
the thinking and ability of the National Chairman of the Auxiliary,
a distinguished member of the Missouri Bar.
We have used it
occasionally,
We intend to use it hereafter as much as possible.
It is our thought that legislation does affect everyone, whether
you are a veteran or not.
After all, we are all subject to the
laws of the Nation,
the laws of our city,
and the laws of our
state,
and,
of
your
birth
for
did
We do want to take this opportunity to thank everyone
the aid and assistance.
We could not accomplish what we
accomplish without the assistance of the Legion and particu-
any
suggestions
larly
the
consequently,
up
to
the
Auxiliary,
to forward
them.
consideration
degree.
Thank
to
you
we
welcome,
to
our
assure
on
you
undoubtedly
very
behalf
you
almost
from
the
time
death.
and
in
fact
Commission,
they
they
will
will
we
ask,
please
receive
prove
of
if
you
feel
free
the
utmost
aid
in
have
of
some
much.
COMMANDER BURKE:
why over the years The
average in the area of
Congress of the United
ganization
affects
of
offer
We
and
it
time
of
I will say that
Room or the following
now but it will assure
Thamk you, Jerry Duggan,
and now you know
American Legion has had such a high batting
consent and favorable consideration by the
States of the recommendations by our or-
the
veterans
of
our
country.
thé music you hear from the Congressional
room behind may be an inconvenient sound
a better program tonight.
I will present to you the
Commission, Mr. C. D. DeLoach.
Chairman
of
the
Public
Relations
MR. DELOACH:
Mr. Commander,
Chairmen of the National Committees, distinguished guests,
and fellow legionnaires,
at the
outset, Mr. Commander,
I would like to point out to you,
to your
panel up here,
that the National Public Relations Commission will
not take a back seat to any other Commission in The American
Legion.
We are a little bit loud, poor but proud, but we have a
great deal of pride and I think one of the finest compliments,
without throwing too many flowers at ourselves was paid yesterday
by the National Chairman of another commission who said, Gentlemen,
your commission certainly has caught on fire."
I wish to assure you, Mr. Commander,
that it will continue
to catch on fire and keep burning or rolling,
or else there will
be many changes.
As to the accomplishments of the National Public
Relations Committee,
certainly they are not as many as we would
want, not as many as we need; we have just gotten started.
We do
have, however,
the faint beginning of a humanitarian image which
speaks
so
softly
of God
and
love
and
of
The
American
Legion,
That
image has not yet been created to its fullest length.
We have a
long way to go.
Hardly over 30 per cent of the American public
at the present time know of the humanitarian program of The American Legion despite the great work you do from the standpoint
of
child welfare,
aid to needy widows and orphans, veterans,
etc.
We have to capture the remaining 70 per cent if we are
to continue our "Aging with Dignity."
We congratulate our
National Commander and the National Advisory Committee for the
program regarding accent on youth.
We want to add to that program and bring as much of it to the attention of the American
public
227
as
we
possibly
can.
Speaking
again
of
the
image
of
The
American
Legion,
since
the movie
"We Who Serve" was created and it was produced under
the National Commander who was serving as National Public
Relations Chairman at the time, we have had over 7000 showings.
We have over 50
television stations in the United States
and of
that 50
this movie has been shown in every one of them.
The
movie has now been reduced from its original time down to ten
minutes and it is
still rolling a great deal and will continue
to roll in your various communities.
We would like to hear from
you and we urge you to write to us and let us know where we need
to fill in the gap by showing this particular movie.
We have
come up with a new gimmick or a new project,
as you might call it,
entitled "Project 61."
It is
a clipboard,
a board that is a
slide board that shows you various programs of The American Legion.
Regardless of what kind of speaker you are, for the simple sum of
a little over $89 you can get this and become a grand speaker for
the great benefit of The American Legion.
We will be very pleased
to
answer
any
questions
in
that
regard
What should we do in the future?
There are a great many
things that we want to do in the future.
We need a better coordination of public relations among The American Legion on a
wholesale basis.
At our national headquarters of The American
Legion,
none of the Commissions of course,
is autonomous,
and
neither should they be, but at the same time if you have any
public relations problem that is sorely troubling:
you, whether
it may be rabbits in South Carolina or some other particular
program,
let me say to you that it is a problem of the entire
American Legion.
Any problem affecting any post which may be
tagged with it is still a problem for the entire American Legion.
with
We want to help you with
you and
we want to decide
over-all
good
of The
American
it.
We want to
on the national
Legion
what
we
plunge into it
basis for the
can
do
for
the
best
benefits of our organization,
but we do need coordination.
Our
meetings for the past several days have been attended by over
75
people.
Our luncheon yesterday we think was a great success.
We had some of the outstanding personalities of radio,
television,
and the newspaper world attending that particular luncheon.
I
am sure that many of you who are here today heard the very visibly
emotionally disturbed Quentin Reynolds in his great sincerity
when his voice rang,
speaking of the book he has recently written,
"The Tomb of the Unknown.'
How he loved The American Legion and
how he respected you for your great humanitarian acts,
and I am
sure you heard Dave Brinkley and saw the National Commander present an award to Mr. Robert Sarnoff,
the Chairman of the Board of
NBC.
I am sure you at least know of, if you did not see, the
very distinguished personalities
we had there who came to pay
homage and tribute to you, The American Legion.
We know that
90 per cent of the people in the United States are in sympathy
with us for what we stand for, even though, as I have said previously, perhaps only 30 per cent know of our great humanitarian
programs and the heart which makes The American Legion beat.
But at the same time
we have to win over the remainder and we can
do that by instituting the various programs that we hope to get
your
approval
Relations
for
from
Division,
COMMANDER
BURXE:
time
to
time
Thank
you
Mr.
Thank
you.
228
in
the
National
Commander.
Public
I now present to you the gracious Chairman
Relations Commission, Mr. Emilio S. Inglesias.
of
the
Foreign
MR. IGLESIAS:
Mr. Commander,
ladies and gentlemen,
the
National Commander in a recent speech stated that the nature of
our organization cannot
be separated or distinguished from the
destiny of the American people in this decade of decision,
that
there is a demand for a redefinition of national goals and purposes,
and that veterans have a part to play in this role of
redefinition.
We are an organization which was formed as a direct result
of war and
therefore have an acute awareness of the dangers that
can result from a faulty foreign policy.
Now to direct ourselves
to the questions which were referred to the Commission.
One, we
feel the outstanding accomplishment of our Commission in the past
five years is that we have managed to conduct the affairs of a
ma jor standing Commission within a most limited budget and without a regular full time staff.
At the same time we have been
able to formulate a foreign policy program through these years
which has been adopted by The American Legion as being in the
best interests of our nation and its people.
I would propose the establishment of a full-time staff,
thoroughly trained and well qualified on the subject of foreign
affairs,
in order to function properly on a par with the other
major commissions in this increasingly complex and vitally important area of international relations which directly affects
the security of the United States.
If I were Commander I would
consummate this during my administration.
Because this Commission
has no staff it is unable to project or plan any future programs.
However,
the members of the Commission maintain a continuing
study of current world events and international affairs.
Regular correspondence
is impossible under our present
situation.
Members of the Commission receive notices of Commission meetings and reports of Commission and convention committee
actions.
There is a limited amount of correspondence between
the Chairman and the members of the Commission.
Efforts to promote the policy of the Commission are carried out by most of the
members in their respective departments with several of them
serving as Department Foreign Relations Committee Chairman.
We
encourage each department to create such a committee if they
have not already done so.
The greatest extent of The American
Legion is that, as the largest veteran's organization in the
world, we continue to remind the American people of the futility
and hopelessness of war and the need for constant vigilance
against any effort to undermine our American way of life or to
impair in any way the security of this Nation.
The greatest problem we have is the inability to sell our
program not only to the American people as a whole, but to
thousands of our own members.
Again,
as with the answers to
several of the previous questions,
the lack of a staff makes
it
extremely difficult to properly prepare our resolutions and
their supporting statements other than that which,
again,
is done
by the individual members of the Commission.
We are unable to
conduct any public relations program as a Commission.
The last question which I will answer to you is that it is
more important today than ever before that the non-veteran and
the veteran alike have an intelligent understanding of a sound
foreign policy program in our relations with the other nations
229
of the world.
At this time, we wish to acknowledge
the Director of the Washington Office and his staff
assistance,
for without it we could not function as
Thank you
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
and thank
for their
a Commission.
Emilio.
I appreciate the difficulties of working with improper
staff.
I don't promise you any great relief on that because,
as
you know, were you Commander you would find likewise that the
Commander proposes and the Finance Commission disposes.
However,
I am pleased to report to this extént: That in 1956
the reorganization committee of the National Executive Committee,
under
the Chairmanship of William McKinley recommended the establish-
ment
within
the
framework
of The
American
Legion
of
a research
division.
This was likewise a recommendation of the Program
and Policy Committee which is presently in session here today.
The funding for such a research division was approved today by
the Finance Commission,
which means that there will be available
to The American Legion,
its Divisions,
and its Commander,
the
abilities of a research staff that can provide for us the sort
of information which is needed in the formulation and presentation
of the programs and policies of The American Legion.
I
Lewis,
would like to present to you at this time
the Chairman of the Economic Commission.
Mr.
George
T.
MR, LEWIS:
Mr. Commander,
Fellow Legionnaires,
members
of the Auxiliary,
and friends of The American Legion and the
American Legion Auxiliary,
the Economic Commission as the committee
working within the framework of the Commission indicates,
deals
with such problems as housing,
the committee head by the capable
Sylvan King of Washington, D. C.; Veterans Preference, with the
committee head by Ray McEvoy of Massachusetts;
Agriculture and
Conservation,
head by Doug Kramer of Idaho; Labor Relations by
Al Chamie of California;
Employment by Elmore Torn of Texas and
of course we acknowledge thanks to our capable Director, Clarence
Bird, and to his staff,
and my thanks to all of the member of
the Commission.
My tenure as Chairman of the Commission,
as most of you know,
is short-lived,
only since the November meeting,
although it has
been my pleasure to work on some of the other national commissions.
Anything that I have to say this afternoon which might sound a
bit like throwing roses at the Economic Commission and its affiliated committees,
I want you to know that I take no credit for,
but give full credit to the other members of the Commission,
and
Committees,
and the staff.
I think that if I had to pick out
some one or two things which have been
the greatest accomplishments of the Economic Commission in the past five
years,
it would
be their dogged day-by-day efforts to obtain the Veterans Preference rights for the vetérans that were intended under the law
and their consistent work to retain those rights guaranteed by
the GI Bill of Rights,
to keep that program activated and to
extend some of the provisions of that program which you know have
been extended recently.
I think that the work that the Commission has done with the
Veterans Employment representatives throughout the country has
been a great service to veterans.
They have
placed on an average
each year approximately 1.5
million veterans in jobs and when you
multiply that number by the amount of average earnings shown in the
230
statistics
for
the
average
veteran
you
are
pouring
a
tremendous
amount of money into our present economy.
The work of the Commission is perhaps less dramatic than some of the others and
perhaps is more important in times of recession than it is in
better times.
We hope that the recession will not continue long
enough and with sufficient severity to make the Commission any
more important in this respect than it is.
It is true, though,
that if we do not have jobs for veterans and do not have decent
housing for veterans,
and if they, constituting
the large segment of our population that they do, cannot lead lives of dignity
in their respective communities, won't be able to pay their
American Legion dues, and won't be able to be of any real service to their fellow man;
then the work of this Commission is
most important.
In conclusion, Mr. Commander,
we came to the conclusion in
answer to your 17 questions,
one of which was "What is the most
important accomplishment
of The American Legion,' that if we
could have answered these 17 questions in five minutes,
that would
have been it, so in conclusion may I say without taking further
time,
that we hope to have some additional recommendations which
we would like to ask permission to file at a later day.
Thank
you very much.
COMMANDER BURKE:
I think in your behalf I will be proud to
tell George and the other Commission Chairmen that they are doing
very well in presenting not only the work of the Commission here,
but what they foresee as the program of the future. As someone has
said,
I will have to make a long speech because I didn't have time
to prepare a short one.
I am pleased that the Commission chairmen
have taken time to prepare and present their ideas and recommendations in such succinct form.
P.
I would like to present to
Drummond,
the Chairman of the
you at this time,
National Security
MR. DRUMMOND:
Commander Burke, Chairmen
present, distinguished Legionnaires all:
of
Mr. Addison
Commission.
the
Commissions
That America must remain militarily
strong for the foreseeable future must be apparent to every Legionnaire in this room.
Without sufficient strength to discourage aggression, whether
it be a brush fire on freedom's perimeters or an all-out nuclear
war, the United States faces a grim future indeed.
Your National
Security Commission and its committees believe sincerely that
The American Legion bears a great burden of responsibility in the
future courses of action that this Nation chooses.
We believe
that the American people,
if fully informed, will willingly make
any sacrifices necessarily required for our
national security,
I use the phraseology "sacrifices necessarily needed" advisedly,
meaning that we did not believe that any one believes in writing
a blank check.
Without
strong military forces in being we become
subject to international blackmail.
To us it appears imperative
for every level of our great organization to come alive to its
responsibilities.
If Communists are dedicated to their cause,
can not we sacrifice in still greater measure for a system that
recognizes the omnipotence of God and the dignity of mankind?
yearn
It is
for
not
freedom
enough
and
our help to cast off
bodies and spirits.
to
love
contain
and
evil.
respect
as
Millions
we
do,
of
people,
desperately
the bonds of oppression which bind their
America and its dependable allies have a
221
who
need
compelling
will be no
ness of the
ing us from
challenge:
more.
Each
Combat communism or eventually freedom
of us must do more to create an aware-
diverse and deadly nature
within and from without.
of
We
the conspiracy
do not believe
is enough, but it is a beginning upon which
programs to further strengthen America.
even
The
if
it
American
serves
Legion
our
God
must
and
serve
Country
today
in
we
must
in an
time
build
uneasy
of war.
assailthat this
the
peace
Now, Mr. Commander,
to that short, brief statement,
I have
attached a lengthy memorandum answering the some 17 questions
that
you
submitted,
COMMANDER
the
sir.
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Mr.
Drummond.
I now present to you Mr. William Brennan,
Membership and Post Activities Committee.
the
Chairman
of
MR, BRENNAN:
Mr. Commander,
and distinguished ladies and
gentlemen,
Commander Burke in his preface to the program for this
conference has very aptly said, "The American Legion knows well
that its purpose and its future cannot be distinguished from
the destiny of the American people."
It is equally true that the Legion activities of rehabilitation,
legislation,
national security,
economics,
foreign
relations,
and public relations cannot be separated from membership.
For them to succeed, membership must succeed.
I am sure
it is for this reason the question of membership has been placed
on the agenda by your National Commander.
What is the national
membership situation today?
As
of
the
close
of
books
last
night,
national
membership
was 2,180,000,
a loss of 43,000 compared to the same date last
year.
Have the 1961 membership results been encouraging or
disappointing?
Definitely disappointing.
On January 1 membership was 90,000 behind.
On February 1 it was 70,000 behind.
You ask a very simple question.
What occurred to enable Commander
Burke to report a 5000
gain yesterday?
Very frankly,
a drive was launched to have all available
cards transmitted by departments to give us the best possible
membership picture,
the best impact for this important conference.
The results show it worked,
but these efforts distort the picture.
They borrow from tomorrow for a good picture today,
and from our
best judgment on membership we are still 50,000
behind.
What are
the reasons for the lag?
Some say a late convention,
a very
minute reason.
The 40 & 8's?
Possibly in a few local areas.
Some say the growth of the World War I veteran organizations.
A
small possibility in a few areas.
Economic conditions? Development?
I cite you two examples.
In the Gary area of Indiana and
the Niagara Frontier area of New York, both areas directly related
to the steel industry and both economically in trouble, membership
is ahead in 1961.
Lead in our britches at the Department,
direction and post
level?
Definitely yes, and 99/100ths per cent of the reason.
What are we doing about it at the National level?
On January 6 we launched a program that possibly some of you
know something about,'""Operation Welcome Back."
Our statistics
indicate in the past three years over 700,000 members have failed
232
to re-enroll in our organization.
Pilot tests have indicated
that if these drop-outs are contacted one-third will come back
in.
On January 6, National Commander Burke asked all posts
to prepare drop-out lists.
This was phase 1 of Operation Welcome
Back.
He also sought the all-out backing of each department
and asked that the departments report at this conference the
number of posts in their department participating in Operation
Welcome Back and the total number of names on the drop-out list.
Here are the results;
43 departments reporting:
Number of
posts participating to date, 3120, or 18
per cent of our 17,000,
This is interesting.
Total
of
our
posts,
number
of
names
on
the
drop-out
list
of
18 percent
151,000.
Phase 2 of Operation Welcome Back is being launched today.
Its objective is to
have all drop-outs on these lists contacted
personally between now and March 31.
What can you do about it?
First acquaint yourself with the program.
We have given you
a copy of Advance, which is a monthly publication prepared by
our Public Relations Department that goes to your Post
Commander.
This describes Operation Welcome Back.
He knows about this
because he has received that issue of Advance in advance.
There is a sidelight on this
ing when I arrived in Washington I
this question:
question.
Last
asked 15
of the
Monday evenconferees
"Do you know whether membership is ahead or behind in
your department?’
Only one could answer the question.
And it
just occurred to me is it possible these men have made the fatal
error,
the fatal mistake of thinking you can distinguish membership, separate it, from the other activities being discussed
at
this
conference.
Lastly,
find out if Operation Welcome Back or some similar
program is being worked in your local area, if it has not become
the motivator.
We have enough men right here at this conference
to bring back 50,000
members and solve our problem.
Many departments are doing a tremendous job and I would
like to quote one.
That is Alabama.
They have tied this Operation Welcome Back to a state-wide public relations program.
They have developed some interesting TV spots,
and Commander
Albritton and Adjutant Lawson Lynn are here in the room.
Will
you stand up so they can see you?
back
If any
to your
so well
of you men want to take what they have developed
post they told me they will make what
is working
in Alabama
available
to
you.
Ladies and gentlemen,
let's back up rehabilitation,
legislation, national security,
economics, foreign relations and
public relations efforts with an all-out enthusiastic backing
of Operation Welcome Back.
COMMANDER:
Thank you, Bill.
I ask the members of this
conference for the support of the activities being donducted by
Bill Brennan, George Rulon and those that are active in the
membership picture.
As you well know, The American Legion faces
233
a
continuing
placing
year by
replace
problem
in
membership.
We
have
the
task
of
re-
virtually 10 per cent of our membership loss to us
each
death or other casualties. ' That means that we have to
almost 2,000 members annually before we break even.
As Bill has told you, we went into this year better than
75,000
behind.
Since January, we have been gradually whittling
that down.
Operation Welcome Back is an application of methods
which are used in other industries and in other campaigns to
supply, on a limited basis and on a shock program,
a device
whereby within a limited period of time, with limited resources,
and with a limited amount of personnel it will supply us the sort
of kick which is necessary to put us over in terms of gathering
back into our folds the membership needed to bring us back to our
strength
of
last
year.
That, however,
as you well recognize, will not be enough
to solve our continuing problems.
In this area, however,
I am
pleased to report as I go about the country I find that our
younger
men
have
now
had
the
time
away
from
home
and
family
to
contribute to the leadership of The American Legion.
I find
that where this leadership is present our membership is moving
ahead as are our other programs.
Before we leave here, and if
it is not available it will be within a matter of days, we have
a new pamphlet on membership which points out some of the outstanding Americans that are presently active in The American
Legion and urges on a prestige basis the affiliation of others.
I am
fundamentally
convinced
that
out
of
the
program
and
planning of this conference and out of
will bring to this problem we will not
the resolution
only solve our
in
terms
which we
membership
both as to numbers
American Legion.
of
the
of
problem
in
terms
of
breaking
even,
and
qualities
as
to
but
of
going
program
ahead
The
I would like to pay a word of tribute to the staff of the
National Organization and to the committees and commissions and
the chairmen of divisions for the work which they have put into
this conference.
This is the first time that we have tried anything on this scale,
as you know,
in Washington.
It meant that
they were faced with unprecedented problems in organization,
in
housing,
in attempting to arrange a banquet for us tonight and
in order to make available to you the sort of facilities which
this conference requires.
I know
of my
own
personal
knowledge
of
the
many
nights
which our staff stayed up in planning for this commission meeting and this joint commander's conference.
If anything,
they
have proceeded too well because tonight,
as you know, we will
have approximately 1600 for dinner with over 400 members of the
Congress
of
the
United
States.
We are using all the facilities of this hotel.
We are
tying together our various tables and rooms by closed-circuit
television with minitors.
We expect,
in addition to a program,
to give you some fine entertainment.
We hope that you will not
only find it profitable,
but entertaining and I wish on your
behalf to thank our staff for the work which they have done
and the chairmen of the commissions for what they have done in
bringing to this program their best efforts on your behalf.
Now,
I
will
present
to
you
234
the
Chairman
of
the
Committee
on Reorganization to whom the various recommendations have
been directed, Mr. Martin McKneally, who can give you some
thought as to what the work of his special committee will entail over the coming months.
Commander McKneally.
MR. McKNEALLY:
Thank you, Commander Burke.
Fellow
Legionnaires and friends,
Bob McCurdy spoke feelingly about his
program to grow old with dignity and I think that is a very
laudible and noble thing, but, Bob,
the thing that disturbs me
is whether or not you can
find some means that will stop me
from growing old so fast,
and if we have many more conferences
on the program of The American Legion,
I think I am going to
be the first candidate for that pilot study
in the various
hospitals,
the aged veterans.
I want to speak to you in terms of two committees,
one
of them The Americanism Commission,
and then,
also the special
committee review of the programs of The American Legion.
Both
of those that come under the four great ideals around which
The American Legion was formed.
review
future
more
Under Americanism we are trying to do a study job and a
job reaching back into the past and projecting into the
to make that commission and the work of that commission
productive,
more
efficient,
in producing
a patriotic
view
and also establishing a more effective voice for The American
Legion in the affairs of what we call Americanism.
The preservation of our ancient date as Americans, which is under
attack not only by communists;
now it is easy enough to pin a
communist,
but the fellow that is difficult to pin is the man
who gives the communists his special support.
How does he do
that?
He does that by denying the
principles upon which this nation was founded,
and that
a conflict of basic philosophy.
great
involves
The basic philosophy of the man who doesn't share our
doctrine of belief is frequently called logical pacifism
and
he is the fellow who says, "I don't believe it unless you show
it to me in the Testament."
We believe it because it is part
of our great faith and because we have that great belief in our
hearts and our souls, what we have to do is make The American
Legion fake this great voice the voice of the majority,
in the
field
of
these
In
trying to do this and to make this a
to the youth of America and the youth
we
have
appeals
level
two
a
conflicting
great
deal
of
philosophies.
catching
up
to
serious voice that
of the college
do
because
the
people
who had captured the minds of the youth and made them less patriotic than they once were,
in the sense that we mean patriotism
and in the sense that we must have patriotism if the United
States is to survive and to lead, have been
working fervently
since before World War II and we have not been working so well
since World War II.
So, therefore,
we have to do a raking job
in the field of Americanism,
preserving all of the programs that
have shown themselves to be valuable to this commission over the
many years that it has existed and at the same time adding new
ones.
This is not an easy thing.
It takes a great deal of time,
a great deal of study and a great deal of reading.
We will
answer the questions,
of course, because I come immediately to
the fact that it was we who prepared them,
the Special Committee
235
studying all the programs, made up of Tom Miller, Jim Powers,
Jim O'Neil,
Roy Stone, Walter Alessandroni,
and Harold Redden,
and we have as our Director Ed McGrail.
We have met frequently and have looked at every one of
the programs again and again and now we are in the pasition
of writing an interim report and preparing it for the May meeting of the NEC, making certain recommendations,
the results of
which we hope will tighten up The American Legion and make it a
more influential and much more
effective organization.
To that end we prepared this list of questions,
not for
specific or precise answers, but as guidelines which the various
commissions could use in order that they
can report to our
committee in such a way as to
give us some insight into once
again their efficacy.
We appreciate the time that
you had to
spend in answering the questions and we know full well that they
will help us do our job.
It seems to me that The American Legion is going to profit
immensely from this mid-winter conference because it does begin
to tie in with what
we are all trying to do under the various
programs and especially with this most important restudy which
has never taken place in The American Legion.
We have never
restudied.
We have never gone back to restudy the total,
composite picture of The American Legion from within.
This is something new.
Not infrequently The Legion grew,
and the various work of The Legion grew in a sort of a shrub
growth,
a Topsy-like thing,
and that resulted sometimes in a
less efficient and a less effective voice and program,
and
influence than we must have if, to get back to the area of
Americanism,
this nation is to survive with its ancient traditions and if this American Legion is to be the sustainer of
that voice of the majority.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Martin.
We have completed the reports of our commission chairmen
on time.
I wish to once again thank the Commission and those of
you who have participated in helping us and helping our Commission chart its course.
On your behalf I have paid the respects of our organization
to the President of the United States early this week.
I presented him with an American Legion button which he had some
difficulty fixing to his coat lapel.
I likewise presented him
with a program for this conference,
and without quoting him, he
expressed gratification that The American Legion was addressing
itself to the problems which concern not only veterans,
but all
Americans.
who
time
At
this time
we
have
have
questions
or
comments
a few
minutes
left.
would
welcome
we
Well, when
to adjourn.
Legionnaires have
I thank you.
«ees
p.
At
4:30
m.,
the
kkk
no
Conference
kkk ok kkk
225
questions
If
there
are
any
them.
or
ad journed..
comments
it
is
The American Legion
National Rehabilitation Conference
HOTEL
STATLER
WASHINGTON,
FEBRUARY
D. C.
28- MARCH
3, 1961
PROCEEDINGS
The American Legion
National Rehabilitation Conference
HOTEL
STATLER
WASHINGTON,
FEBRUARY
D. C.
28- MARCH
3, 1961
Table
Tuesday
Afternoon
February
28,
of
Contents
Session
Page
1961
Call to order by Mr. Robert M. McCurdy,
Chairman of the National Rehabilitation
Commission. vescassssnssnsnssosionsseneesss
invocation
National
2 sleiere s
1
by Rev. William H. Moss,
Chaplain. sevessiesnosvnsssvmenssvesives
1
Greetings:
Mrs.
James
A.
DeForce,
Department
President,
District of Columbia, American Legion
AUXIN
ary. co ctv ive evininsnvesve essen sissivinsinis visio
2
Mrs. Bealon J. Orr, National Executive
Committeewoman,
District of Columbia,
American
Legion
Auxiliary....c..ci00eevnnnennn..
3
Mr. Joseph G. Weeda,
Department Commander,
Digtrict of Columbia.
ie vesnessanseiosnssnnsivin
3
Mr. Harold D.
Committeeman,
Beaton, National Executive
District of Columbia... ..cceesiniss
4
Mr. John J. Corcoran,
Director, National
Rehabilitation CommiSSion..
cessive sencevsnccnsis
4
Remarks:
Announcement
of
Conference
Rules...
ceezeeseosnss
5
Announcement of Conference Committee on
Recommendations. .ovesssesnvssecsvssunvosvsonsss
6
Insurance
7
Panel....ccvessivensesissssssnnnsoansontss
Address by Mr. P. J.
Director, Veterans
Budd, Acting Chief Insurance
Administration. .cescessceonns
10
Mr. John S. Gleason, Administrator of Veterans
Affairs. oon ivi vives Poise sicie v sPsiss un tualiin bre. thn a nee Ae
24
Address:
Wednesday Morning Session
March 1, :1961
Panel
on
VA
Automatic
Wednesday Afternoon
March 1, 1961
Panel
Page
on-New:
Data
Processing
Program....
29
(PL. 86-211).
cesses csicvee
75
Session
Pension
Law
Remarks:
Mr. Nicholas Lynch, Jr., Director, National
Pield Service von inenv sss sionsisnesocinisessns
vines 2d
Presentation
Panel
on
to
Mrs.
Veterans
and
Rachel
Koch...
vein ssiidicson
Dependents
ClaimS....c.e...
94
95
Thursday Morning Session
March 2, 1961
Invocation
National
Panel
on
by Rev. William H. Moss,
Chaplaif<scecoosvessesasswsnsmanmvensssr
Medical
and
Hospital
ServiceS...ccece...
L23
123
Address:
Dr. William S. Middleton,
Chief Medical
Director, Veterans Administration... ..ess.s.veni124
Remarks:
Mrs. J. Howard McKay, Chairman, National
Rehabilitation Commission, American
Legion AURELIary ue. vies cesses sion oicss.s since does
146
Panel on Veterans Administration Voluntary
SOY ViCOS ae suave sv issavesigvsaiseciuiaie
die
edsieinedeledilsy
Thursday Afternoon
March 2, 1961
Session
Remarks:
Mr. James W. Stancil, Chairman, Board of
Veterans Appeals, Veterans Administration......
162
Remarks:
Dr.
E.
Mandell,
VA
Policy
and
Evaluation
Staff..
169
Thursday Afternoon Session
March 2, 1961 (Cont'd)
Page
Remarks:
Mr. Robert H. Grant, Former Director,
Special Staff on Aging, Department of
Health, Education and Welfare... ....o<vrveor.-»
+174
Remarks:
Mr. Warren Roudebush, Acting Director,
Special Staff on Aging, Department of
Health, Education and Welfare......
ovens
Report
the
White
of
American
House
Legion
Conference
Delegates
to
176
on Aging......cceee...
179
Invocation by Rev. William Adams, Past
Department Commander,
District of Columbia...
185
Friday Morning Session
March 3, 1961
Remarks:
Mr. Warren H. MacDonald, Assistant Director
of Rehabilitation.
vee evis es esisestosesnivssnsssis
185
Panel on Vocational Rehabilitation
Bd
BANC AL LOD 5 sisie ss ieroiaserw dissin oioie. vis bin vin vi oie nintnie:. sr HBO
Remarks:
Mr. T. O. Kraabel,
Director, Vocational
Rehabilitation and Education,
Veterans Administration..eceececeecceccececccs
188
Address:
Honorable
Veterans'
Adjournment
MEETING
OF
Olin E.
Affairs
Teague, Chairman, House
Committee....c.cvevosssses
199
.ceeceecececescececscsocosccscccnscnsccn
204
REHABILITATION
Report
of
COMMISSION
Committee......e.o...
204
Report of Subcommittee on Certificates of
Appreciation. .ceessissssessessessssrsnisncnnins
210
Report
216
of
Recommendation
Subcommittee
on
Aging.....eceecessss
Friday
March
Morning
3,
Session
1961
Page
(Cont'd)
Report
of
Area
Report
of
Insurance
Benediction,
Commission
CRAITMANcelencsvasessnnssnssssnnes
Rev.
Ad
Advisory
Williams
Board.....ee.eve.-e
218
AdamS..c.ec.cocncnvee’:
219
ournment cee cs cv
JOINT SESSIONS OF COMMISSION
DELEGATES TO THE NATIONAL
217
cavsinsosetoncseorne
218
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND
COMMANDER'S CONFERENCE
Wednesday
Morning
SeSSioN.e.
ss ssessesisnvevveiann
220
Thursday
Afternoon
SesSsion..eevessssvsivssvsiaiv:
224
TUESDAY
AFTERNOON
FEBRUARY
28,
SESSION
1961
The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference of The
American Legion convened in the Congressional Room, Hotel
Statler, Washington, D. C., at 2 p.m.,Mr. Robert M. McCurdy,
Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Commission, presiding.
MR. McCURDY:
We have a full program with two distinguished speakers this afternoon.
To give us proper guidance and start on an
aesthetic tone this Rehabilitation Conference, we have with us today our National Chaplain,
the
Reverend William H. Moss.
REVEREND MOSS:
Just before I offer the prayer,
I want
to say that the most cherished letter that has come to me being your National Chaplain, was from a disabled veteran who
died only recently.
I would like to read just two sentences
from this letter.
with
I am
life
"I have had a stroke of paralysis,
and can only scribble
my injured hand and a pencil.
My stroke was heavy, but
grateful that I can think,
read, and reason clearly,
and
is still great
to me.”
I
May
we
thought
it
fitting
to
mention
that
for
this
Conference.
pray.
Most merciful God, we thank Thee for the Rehabilitation
Program of The American Legion.
It is truly the heart of our
organization.
We remember how important Thou didst make the
service to those who suffered and were in need, when
Thou
didst say, "Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least
of these ye have done it unto Me."
Oh, God, in turn, may we receive a blessing from men,
like the writer of the letter, who, from wheel chairs and
hospital beds can smile and say, "Life is still great to me."
most.
we not
it
was
Help us to gain from them the inspiration
For these comrades, who daily call on us
turn aside -- is our prayer.
In
Thy
Holy
MR.
McCURDY:
Comrades,
voted
to
by
Name,
dedicate
utmay
Amen.
Thank
this
to do our
for help,
you,
Chaplain
action
in
this
meeting
Conference
Moss.
assembled
in
the
yesterday,
memory
of
Watson B. Miller.
I am sure that you all knew Watson,
but in
keeping with the mandate of the Commission, we have prepared
a few words for the record, which I know express the thought
of all of us.
Watson B. Miller,
a gentleman with a gallantry of the
old school, with an intellect sharp and witty, with a compassion of the deepest, with an understanding of the broadest,
with the executive and administrative capacity of the greatest, with a friendliness of the most far reaching, with affection for family and friends, with a sincerity, with a devotion
to the Almighty,
and a loyalty to the country beyond question,
1
and with a personality of the most engaging.
That was our
distinguished and late departed friend, Watson Miller,
at rest
in the bosom of the verdant hills of Arlington,
enshrouded in
the
modst
of
eternity.
His legacy to us was a lifetime of work and talent in
behalf of others.
Gone, but not forgotten, departed and yet
living in the hearts of all of us, his spirit abides this day
and the days to come whenever and wherever the cause of the
nation;s endeavors engage the thoughts and words of his fellow
countrymen,
his colleagues,
and The American Legion.
From the deep recess of our composite heart, we
you, Watson,
and we give thanks for what you have done
for what you have been,
I
Watson
would ask
Miller.
A
to
stand
one
of
silence
was
observed.
McCURDY:
Thank
you,
Comardes.
moment
MR.
We
Comrades
greeting
you
have with us on
and ladies,
and
at this time.
First, we have Mrs.
President of the District
liary, Mrs. DeForce.
minute
in
the platform some
I am going to ask
silence
most
them
James A. DeForce,
the
of Columbia, American
salute
and
for
distinguished
for a word of
Department
Legion Auxi-
MRS. DEFORCE:
Mr, Chairman, National Commander Burke,
Mr. Corcoran,
distinguished guests,
and delegates to this
Conference,
to rehabilitate is defined as ''to reestablish,
to
reinstate,
or to put or bring into good repute again."
This is exactly what we of The American Legion Auxiliary are attempting.
Our aim and purpose is to restore the
veteran through a service of repair -- the worker to industry,
the citizen to society,
the man to himself.
In this Department,
as in others, we accomplish these results through the
leadership of our Rehabilitation Chairman and our volunteer
hospital director.
We sponsor regularly scheduled parties at
all the hospitals
in which there are veterans.
We have Christman
all
gift
free
shops
of
where
the
charge,
gifts
veterans
for
may
their
select
families.
and
have
mailed,
We have carnivals and watermelon parties on the hospital grounds.
We have parties for special holidays.
Our hospital workers work ikumany fields in the VA hospitals and by so
doing,
enable the nurses and hospital personnel to have more
time
for
the
disabled
veteran.
Nationally we have a new program of Volunteens which
gives our juniors a chance to not only keep themselves busy,
but to do worthwhile work in the VA hospitals.
A brand new
program is being slowly put into action here this year called
Companion Therapy, which simply means beside visits to a
specific patient over the period of time required to give the
patient the specific help needed both mentally and physically.
Each
year,
we
give
special
gifts
to
the
hospital
such
as
comfort and
TV sets, which directly add to the patients;
the man and wife teams in our hospital
We encourage
pleasure.
they are able to do much for the hospitalized
Together,
work.
I understand that again our national organization
veteran.
sum to the Legion for its replans to give a substantial
rehabilitation work in addition to all of the programs we carry
So you see, we of The American Legion Auxiliary not
out.
only say we shall, but we do participate in and contribute to
the aims and purposes of The American Legion.
We are proud to be
and we of the Department
that The American Legion
that we do.
an Auxiliary to The American Legion,
of the District of Columbia hope
will always be proud of the work
It is indeed an honor to extend to you greetings from
The American Legion Auxiliary, Department of the District of
Columbia,
and to wish for you a most constructive Conference.
May God grant you wisdom and courage along the path of peace
with justice for all and may you in your wisdom help keep our
asking God's blessing and his
great country strong and free,
help, but knowing that here on earth God's work must be done
truly as our own.
Thank
MR.
National
umbia,
you,
McCURDY:
Executive
Mrs.
Bealon
We
have
another
Committeewoman
J.
distinguished
the
from
lady,
the
of
Col-
District
Orr.
MRS. ORR:
Mr. Chairman,
allyou fine Legionnaires,
all
I am delighted to be here and
and guests,
Auxiliary members,
to greet you on this very important occasion and to say weleven though you have been
come to the District of Columbia,
here many times.
I hope that you will have a happy visit,
and
may you have a most successful Conference.
Thank
MR.
you
very
McCURDY:
much
for
inviting
Thank
you
Mrs,
I might tell you if you are
ing the Womens Division take care
them any time.
me.
Orr.
in
of
trouble for
Just
that.
We have some distinguished Comrades and I
to you the Department Commander of the District
Mr. Joe. GCG. Weeda, Joe.
food or
consult
houswith
want to present
of Columbia,
MR. WEEDA:
Chaplain Moss, Mr. Chairman,
delegates to
if I were a Commissioner
this 38th Rehabilitation Conference,
of the District of Columbia,
which I am not, of course,
I
would bid you welcome to this city named after the first President and founder of our country,
George Washington.
I would,
of course,
invite you to visit all of our government facilities.
I would also want to remind you that there are three and a half
million dollars worth of them for which the District of Columbia
receives no taxes.
They are exempt.
I
Secondly,
if I were
certainly would ask you
President
Kennedy
has
not
the President of the Board of
to spend and spend lavishly.
declared
Washington
to
be
a
Trade,
Although
depressed
economic
11
and
area,
February
yet
with
11,
our
the
70
inches
merchants
of
snow,
could
use
between
the
December
money.
But,
as
the Department Commander of the District,
and on behalf of all
my comrades here, we certainly bid you a hearty welcome.
We
certainly hope that your goals and your aims, and the purposes
for which you meet today will be further accomplished and we
certainly do, in our own
way, want to help any of you.
Our
facilities,
what limited facilities we have, are open to you.
Do not ask us to do anything for you that might be illegal,
immoral,
or sinful.
That we cannot do,
But I think we can
do just about everything else.
So let me extend this welcome
to
you.
If we can be of
quarters, . Thankiyou,
of
service to you,
Mr. Chairman.
MR.
McCURDY:
Thank
Our
National
Executive
Columbia
is
present,
also
you
give
us
a
call
at
head-
Commander.
Committeeman
Mr.
Harold
from
D.
the
District
Beaton.
Comrade
Beaton.
MR. BEATON:
Chairman McCurdy, National Chaplain Moss,
members of this National Rehabilitation Conference,
it is
indeed a great honor and pleasure for me to welcome you on
behalf of the Department of the District of Columbia.
Yours
is a dedicated task.
1 can think of offhand no higher aim in
life than to dedicate ourselves
to the rehabilitation of our
worthy veterans and their needy families.
I know that you
are anxious to hear the words of wisdom from Mr. Budd of the
Veterans Administration on the VA program and that you are
also looking forward to hearing from our Past National Commander, Jack Gleason,
who is presently the Administrator of
Veterans!
Affairs.
So
may
I be
brief.
I bid you welcome.
I bid you Godspeed in your endeavors.
I bid you fruitful deliberations,
a pleasant stay with us here
in the District of Columbia,
and a safe journey home.
Thank
you very much.
MR. McCURDY:
While the Commander was a little chicken
and declared himself out of some of your problems, Hal tells
me he will take charge of all the liquor and police problems
that you may have.
just
Thank you,
gave you.
informs
charge
Hal,
for
that
fine
volunteer
offer
The Commander always takes a legal approach.
me that he is an attorney and it is
too bad
him for
the
ad,
but
he
Now,
.I would like to
Corcoran,
who will ~xnlain
remarks
to the Conference.
New York and Washington.
MR.
watch
space,
he
that
He
we
now
can't
call on'our Director,
John: J.
the rules and bring the opening
Our Director, John J. Corcoran,
better
said
I
professionally.
you
he
Bob,
you
the Commander for advertising
advice that he gave us.
When
CORCORAN:
wants
that
they
could
4
do
may
out.
charge
everything
You
of
charge
you
except
for
that
the
which was illegal,
anything left that
I
would
immoral,
and sinful,
I
was of any interest to
like
to
make
just
one
or
wondered
anybody.
two
the
the
past.
The
of
these
Rules.
so:
this
the
ones
that
and
have
Rehabilitation
I
won't
name
than
as
take
will
No.
2.
without
‘No
No. 3.
Conference is
the Committee
of
used
has
and
applied
approved
They
are
in
the
rather
use
short
long.
seeking
use the
Department
once
been
now.
was
of our Conference.
The Conference Rules
Commission
read them
No. 1.
Any person
upon recognition,
shall,
her
same
there
announcements
an administrative nature at the beginning
The first point is the Conference Rules.
are
if
before
person
shall
unanimous
to address
microphone
the
and
Conference
state his or
proceeding.
speak
on
the
same
subject
more
consent.
Any recommendation raised on the floor of the
to be submitted in writing by its sponsor to
on Recommendations,
through the staff liaison
representative,
as
soon
after
a
word
of
representatives
to
the
the
close
of
the
session
as
practical.
Let
son
me
add
explanation
Committee
there.
on
staff
liai-
Recommendations,
The
which
Bob McCurdy will announce as soon as I finish,
are:
Warren
MacDonald and Ray macdouall.
They will work
with the Committee
as they have
in previous years, during the week.
They will
also see that the necessary stenographic and clerical assistance
are
available
and
they will
be up
recommendations
that
are
proposed
submitted in writing
soon as possible and
the convenient
time.
to
at
one
the
here
on the platform.
The
during
the session
should
be
of those
close of
staff representatives
as
the session,
if that is
No. 4.
The Committee on Recommendations shall receive
and consider all recommendations of the National Conference,
and shall report on same to the National Rehabilitation Commission at its meeting on Friday.
No. 5.
The Committee on Recommendations
shall hold such
meetings as it may deem necessary to consider all recommendations so received and to prepare its report;
such technical
and administrative services as may be required to be supplied
by the staff liaison representatives.
No. 6.
The Committee on Recommendations
is empowered to
consolidate duplicate recommendations,
to restate recommendations in proper form, without changing their intent,
and to
prepare such other recommendations
as directed.
No. 7.
In its report to the Commission,
the Committee
on Recommendations
shall recommend approval,
approval with
amendment,
rejection,
or further study by the Commission,
of
each recommendation
as it sees fit.
Another
announcement,
Many
of
you
like
the
would
so
that
you
can
service
Veterans
review
this
one
officers
have
Administration
them
in
5
the
not
on
the
rules.
notified
to
Central
call
us
in
Office.
that
certain
I
you
cases
remind
you that those cases
are available in Sam Rose's office on the
first floor in the Veterans Administration Central Office,
and
I hope that you will find time this week to review the file.
If you need any help from one of our staff members,
please let us know.
We have asked our staff people to make
themselves available to you at all times throughout
the week,
that is, at all times up until about midnight.
If you want to
find one of the staff, you can find him either by checking
over in The Legion Headquarters with our Chief of Contact,
or
here at the registration desk.
We have been asked by the House Veterans Committee to
call to the attention of those of you who have not seen this,
that they have published what they
call a calculator.
It is. a
rather handy device which provides some basic information.
To
this extent,
those of you who are completely familiar with rates
of compensation,
and the educational and loan provisions,
and
the
places
would
and
not
need
nature
this
of
hospitals
through
your
Department
calculator.
On the other hand,
for those of you who would find some
benefit in this essential
and basic information,
this calculator is" available,
The price,
according to. this, is 60
cents.
The House Committee said that,
anticipating somewhat
large gales,
they can make them available for 30 cents,
so we
will have a supply of these at the registration desk beginning
tomorrow.
If
haven't
back
you
been
the
out
in
them,
they are 50
because the House
calculators
The
make is
tribute
want
hurt
last:
not
and
the
that
comment,
you
Mr.
don't
cents.
If you
Committee will
pick
Chairman,
don't,
simply
we
take
up.
that
I
would
like
to
of an administrative nature, but it is a note of
respect to someone who is a staff employee sitting
audience.
We
have
reference
to
Rachel
Koch.
Rachel,
as most of you know,
is retiring today from her employ with
The American Legion National Rehabilitation Commission.
She
has completed a service of over 39 years in the Rehabilitation
Commission.
She has seen that Commission and its staff grow
from
a
one
or
two-man
for many years
Dependents and
ference
to
office
to
its
assist
the
reporter
with
information,
Rachel
volunteered
to
ference,
though
technically
and
severs
for
even
as
of
status.
Rachel,
names
work
and
other
through
legally
her
of
Con-
technical
this
Con-
employment
today.
I wonder
Rachel,
as
MR.
present
in addition to having been our Supervisor
Veterans'
Claims,
has the
job during this
if you could
I ask her to
CORCORAN:
Thank
join me
stand.
in a moment
(Applause).
of
you
much.
you,
very
Thank
applause
Mr.
Chair-
man.
MR, cMcCURDY: . Rachel,
TI just want to add
never forget your retirement date.
I, too, am
from service with the City of Pasadena of more
This is also my retirement date, and I propose
have a good party.
We
have
to
announce
the
Recommendations
6
that IT will
retiring today
than 30 years.
we go out and
Committee,
and
it
as
he
is
has not been possible for me
yet, and if there is any one
cannot serve, will he please
adjourned?
From
Price
Area
of New
A,
Fred
Clough
York;
from
Area
to contact all these people
that is appointed that feels
contact me before this meeting
of
C,
Maine;
Stan
from Area
Hudson
of
B,
Arthur
Kentucky;
from
Area D, "Skin" Laid of Iowa; and from Area E, K. Klemmetson
of Washington.
That is a subcommittee of the Commission.
They
are all Commission members and will serve as the Conference
Committee on Recommendations,
who will give their final report
on Friday.
We now will start with our official program,
and as you
know,
and which I would like to mention again, we have a most
important sub-theme,
"Aging with Dignity," and if we all think
of that,
aging with dignity is one of the greatest accomplishments that we could do for our
World War I men who are aging,
and now we are getting into World War II men that are aging.
What higher purpose or greater goal could this group of
dedicated folks have then to guarantee
these men their aging
with dignity?
So I commend the staff that selected this theme
for this Conference,
and I believe that for everything we do,
and not only we, but those other
fine committees and commissions
of The Legion that are meeting here jointly with us, we will
find a great program in our theme and I am sure we all are
happy about it.
One thing that lightens
the burden of the Chairman -- it
is not a burden, Comrades:
it is a lot of fun because you
fellows have been such nice guys to work for and with,
although
it
does
take
time
and
effort
--is
having
outstanding
and
fine
Vice Chairmen who have always stood ready and willing to share
a part of the work,
and presiding at this afternoon's meeting,
we have one of our very fine Vice Chairmen from the Department
of Illinois,
our Vice Chairman,
Comrade Milton Applebaum,
and
I am going to ask Milton to take over at this time.
Milton.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, Bob.
My function here will
be primarily to introduce at this time the members of our panel.
I want to direct your attention to the fact that we start on
page 4 and we are running ahead of schedule.
I believe we will
expect the Veterans Administrator,
the speaker of the afternoon,
to appear here somewhat earlier than on our printed schedule,
so
you will understand that we may interrupt our discussion for the
purpose of receiving our distinguished visitor at that time.
At
minute,
are
on
this time,
1
and await our
the
printed
am going to ask you all
Legion panelists.
Will
program
come
up
to
the
to relax for a
the members who
platform?
Let
me
introduce to you the panelists who are here:
Roy Riley of
Alabama;
Leland L. Day of Colorado,
Ralph J. Henry, Missouri;
and our staff representative Chuck Mattingly.
He is getting
our panel together so he will be up later.
MR. CORCORAN:
Milt,
let me interrupt for a minute.
Veterans Administration officials have not arrived yet, so
your indulgence,
I will make a few additional remarks.
I
ference
might allude somewhat briefly
that we are having tlis year.
7
to
I
the new
am sure
The
with
type of Conit has come to
your notice that this year we have something larger and bigger,
and we all hope better,
than the Conference that we have had
in the past.
This year the National Commander has combined at
the time of our meetings,
the annual meetings of the Rehabilita-
tion
Commission
and
Conference,
meetings
of
all
such
other
Commission that usually meet in Washington.
The National Commander has assigned to this Conference which,
as you know,
is
the National Commander's Conference,
an over-all theme, namely,
"The American Legion in America's Future,” As Bob mentioned a
few minutes ago,
the National Rehabilitation Commission has
adopted as its sub-theme - "Aging With Dignity."
The Commander has charged all Commissions
to appraise
their present structure,
organization,
program,
and mission
with particular attention to the needs of the future.
While
we recognize in the National Rehabilitation Commission that
the needs of veterans and their survivors are varied and many,
we felt that if we had to select one particular program to
devote special attention to it would be the problem of aging.
As Bob indicated,
we are devoting increased emphasis
and attention,
therefore,
at this time in the immediate and
the long-range future to the problem of the aging and aged
veteran,
I
need
not
mention
‘that
the
problems
include
the
in
econo-
mic difficulties,
the social difficulties,
the housing difficulties,
and many others.
We felt that if we could completely
satisfy the sub-theme that we have adopted,
that is, "Aging
with Dignity,'" as far as the aging war veteran is concerned,
we would be doing him the greatest possible service.
In the field,
for example,
of non-service-connected
pension,
if we provide a disability pension to the aging
veteran that permits him to maintain his dignity and his standing in the community,
then we have done both him and the country
a great service.
So we wanted to call your attention at this
time,
and I think it was most appropriate that we do
that,
the
fact that we have a place this year in a larger group of meetings, namely,
the National Commander's Conference.
I think it would also be timely to say a few words at
this time on the program of the National Rehabilitation Commission for the coming year.
As you know,
the program of the
Commission is established and is assigned by the policy-making
bodies of the Legion.
The first step in this policy-making procedure is the
National Rehabilitation Commission,
but it is the National
Executive Committee and it is the National Convention which
establishes the program that we are given to execute.
We have
over 80 resolutions currently in effect, which require some
action by the National Rehabilitation Commission,
and its staff.
Over 30 of these are legislative in nature.
The balance require either administrative action or some research and study
on the part of the staff and the
Commission.
In order to properly execute this mission,
the Rehabilitation Commission has taken what I think is a unique step in
the national organization.
It has established a particular
section of the staff with the immediate responsibility of making sure that the program we are given is adequately executed.
8
The
in
name
charge
Warren
of
of
that
section
to
to
all
our
completely
given
to
us
We
is
think
the
Program
one
that
of
our
we
can
Management
Section,
assistant
say,
directors,
therefore,
of you Legionnaires and we think we
Commission,
we are doing everything
execute
by
is
section
MacDonald,
assurance
assurance
to
that
the
Generally,
I
and
satisfactorily
policy-making
think
we
bodies
could
say
perform
and
with
can say
that we
the
with
can
platform
of
The
American
that
the
program
Legion.
we
are
given falls into three categories.
One is in the Claims category.
You are most concerned with that here this week.
I think you
will agree,
those of you who have had experience with us, we have
at your disposal in Washington a rather complete,
and I say
adequate,
staff of Claims specialists.
As you know, we have specialists on the Appeals Section,
on the Discharge Review Section, Correction Boards, Death
Claims, Veterans'
Claims,
and Insurance.
We try to cover
every possible field in the claims category.
You also know that
we have available expert medical and legal advice.
We have very
qualified professional men assisting these Claims representatives
when complicated medical and legal issues arise.
So I
part
ma jor
would say that
of our program
speaking in generalities,
is the Claims effort.
the
first
A second major part or aspect is the one to which I referred before,
that is, the area of making sure that the program is executed.
As a kind of a subdivision of that, we have
a very important responsibility and that is the research and
information
field,
also
under
Warren
MacDonald
Management Section.
We have placed in that
ponsibility for performing complete research
benefits
and
both
Commission
the
then
supplying
and
to
the
the
product
men
and
of
in
the
Program
Section the resinto veterans’
that
women
research
in
the
to
field.
Now,
this particular function is not to be lightly
taken.
Constantly,
studies are being performed by the cognizant agencies in the government,
such as the Veterans Administration and the House Veterans'
Affairs Committees.
Studies
are being performed appraising and evaluating the veterans;
programs.
It is necessary that we atthe very least stay abreast
of these studies and, where possible,
that we enable ourselves
and
empower
in
the
ourselves
to
anticipate
proposals
that
may
be
made
future.
This research takes us into sociological fields,
takes
us into economic fields,
and we are trying, as I said,
to give
sufficient attention to that endeavor and to make sure that the
Commission receives the results of our investigation so that
The Legion will be in a position to take a responsible stand on
any proposal that is made.
The last general area into which I would categorize our
national program is the legislative area.
As you know,
the
Legislative Commission has the ultimate responsibility for the
proper execution of the legislative program.
Therefore,
we work
in cooperation with and generally under the aegis of the National
Legislative Commission.
It is always somewhat hazaraous to
attempt to establish any priority of legislative proposals,
but
it is equally true that when you have resolutions,
over 30 of
them, calling for legislation,
it is just physically impossible
to devote the same amount of time and attention to all of these
9
resolutions.
Therefore, we have narrowed dowm to a smaller number at
the request of the Director of the Legislative Commission,
the
number of resolutions which we feel will require the most em-
phasis
and
require
the
most
effort
in
the
coming
year.
Incidentally,
the National Commander
touched upon several
of these this morning at the hearing before the House Veterans’
Affairs Committee.
The first one that we put on our list is the request that
Congress grant increases
in the rates of disability and death
compensation.
I won't go into detail on that, except to say
that we feel it is necessary for the Congress to face the
realities of the times that we are in, to give accord to the
inflationary spiral,
and to make the appropriate adjustments in
disability and death compensation.
Another major proposal is to ask the Veterans Administration to expand its medical care of the aged.
This may or
may not require legislation.
Another one, and this is very
important,
is to attempt to have
reopened for one
year the
National Service Life Insurance program.
We will be calling
on you ladies and gentlemen during the year for help on that
gone, and the others,
The last one that I would mention at this time
is a
demand on the part of The American Legion that Congress appropriate sufficient funds for the orderly and liberal administration of the entire VA program.
Mr.
Chairman,
like to make
Commission.
MR.
including
that
concludes
on the program
Thank you.
of
the
the
remarks
National
APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, .John.,.
T
Walter Kownaski from New York.
that
I
would
Rehabilitation
think we are all
here
Walter,
take a bow.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
When the Empire State is represented,
I
think we can proceed.
Our distinguished guests are here and
you will notice from your
program that we have Mr. P. J.
Budd,
Acting Chief Insurance Director of the Veterans Administration,
here in Washington.
Mr. Budd, would you like to
a pleasure to have you here and I
answers from you for sure, now.
ADDRESS OF P. J. BUDD,
VETERANS ADMINISTRATION:
and
I
MR.
BUDD;
are
pleased
Mr.
to
ACTING
Chairman,
have
introduce your staff?
It is
know we are going to get the
the
today.
We have had a number
we assume that you will have
ladies
CHIEF
INSURANCE
and
gentlemen,
opportunity
to
appear
of questionssubmitted
more from the floor.
DIRECTOR,
my
staff
before
to us
you
and
Before we begin with the questions,
I would like to mention several items that I feel will be of interest to vou.
They were of interest to your Insurance Advisory Board, when
we met Saturday afternoon,
and I hope they are to you, also.
Everyone
is
aware
of
President Kennedy's
10
instructions
to the VA, that we pay the 1961 dividends as quickly as possible.
It did not take us long to buckle down and get
things under
way.
The question was asked Saturday about the man who has an
option other than cash,
and leaves his dividends on deposit or
wants them for credit under the old P. L. 36.
What happens
to
him?
We are processing his dividend credit at the same time,
All veterans who have options other than cash are being credited
now in accordance with the option they had chosen.
They will
receive a statement from us showing the new credit and the new
balance.
Another question that seems to always come up currently is
disaussion groups,
is the special dividend.
This might anticipate some of the questions you might have.
Much interest has
been expressed in the President's statement that he hoped that
a special dividend could be paid this fall,
To date, no decision has been reached.
Early next week, we will take a preliminary step and lay
the facts before the Administrator,
Mr.
Gleason, who then will be in a position to determine what the
next step will be.
We anticipate that Mr. Gleason will want
to place this
matter before his Insurance Actuarial Advisory Committee and we
in the Department,
of course,
are anxious for a determination
because if there is to be special dividends in the fall, we will
need all the time, we can get to develop the ground rules and
the mechanics for paying them.
One last word.
Let me just say a word about ADP, Automatic
Data Processing.
I know that you know that there is ADP in the
Department of Veterans'
Benefits,
Maybe you don't know that we
also have
3,000,000 national life insurance accounts in Philadelphia on magnetic tape.
We have converted our N.S.L.I.
records --those are the World War II -- in Philadelphia.
We have
not converted World War 1, the U.S.G.L.I.,
nor have we converted our records in Denver or St. Paul.
Our plans today
provide that we will start converting our Denver insurance
records in October of this year,
and finish by April of 1962;
and that we will start converting our St. Paul records in May
of 1962,
and: finish in October of 1962.
There
is
a
chance
that
we
will
not
proceed
as
scheduled.
We can assure you that we will be the first to recommend further delay in the conversion of these offices,
if we have the
slightest fear that
we cannot convert smoothly and maintain
a service to our veterans
that meets our high standards.
Probably the best thing to do is to start
tions.
Before we do, let me introduce my staff
first gentleman is Mr. Robert Brown.
He is the
Insurance Director.
him
The next gentlemen
probably many times.
Department
of
Insurance.
is Mr,
He is
The
Oliver Clay.
the Insurance
next
gentleman
Mr. McGurn, Director of Insurance Claims.
is Tom Willett,
Director of Underwriting.
man is Ernie Benke,
the Manager of our VA
Colorado.
MR.
APPLEBAUM:
Conferees,
11
I
want
to
on the questo you.
The
Deputy Chief
You have seen
Counsel for the
you
have
seen
also,
The next gentleman
And the next gentleCenter in Denver,
point
out
to
you
the
two mikes in the center aisle.
They are stationary mikes,
and
at the question period be sure you get in front of the mike to
get the attention of the Chairman,
inasmuch as we want every
question heard distinctly by all of you,
as well as, perhaps
more
has
important,
worked
Legion
for
on
the
answers
veterans'
many
years
to
thereto.
insurance
come
back
I
on
to
do
expect
behalf
the
of
the
The
platform
man
who
American
and
I refer
to none other than Past National Commander, Milo J. Warner of
Ohio,
and when he comes in, I will ask him to take a bow in
case any of you should not be acquainted with Milo.
So he
will be back,
I am sure.
cussion
Meanwhile,
leaders,
may
Roy
I turn the meeting
Riley of Alabama?
over
to
one
of
our
dis-
MR. RILEY:
Mr. Chairman,
as you know, Alabama is quite
wet at this time,
and I sincerely hope that I shall not feel
the same when this panel is over.
However, we do have a very
interesting discussion here this afternoon based upon the questions that have been submitted and I think in all fairness to
those people who submitted the questions that we shall answer
the printed questions before entertaining any questions from
the audience.
As a member of the Insurance Advisory Board,
and I consider that a high privilege,
I am very much concerned with and
interested in legislation that will be sponsored this year by
The American Legion and that is the reopening of the national
life insurance for at least one year to give those boys who
allowed their insurance to lapse,
the opportunity of obtaining
the same.
In my humble opinion,
I believe that last year was our
greatest opportunity to have this legislation passed.
Unfortunately,
it failed.
This year, we have the same opportunity,
but our position may be weaker.
I do not know.
I say, again
in my own opinion,
our position may grow weaker each year, not
only from the standpoint of aging of the veteran, but from the
growing resistance of the large insurance companies.
Let me urge you, my comrades, when the staff calls upon
you for support to not hesitate to let the word get out in your
respective states not only to members of The American Legion,
but to rank and file veterans throughout the country,
that they
need contact their Congressman.
I don't care how, but you have
telegraph lines or whatever you want to call them
in your
section of the country.
Let them contact that way, telephone,
personal contact,
or any way they can.
We musthave the support
from the members in the field if we are to secure this legislation.
I believe at this time,
I should like to turn the mike
to Milton Applebaum.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
I do want to introduce Milo Warner, who
I announced before, was temporarily absent from the platform,
Past National Commander,
Milo J. Warner of Ohio, who has been
Chairman and is now Chairman of the Insurance Advisory Board to
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
Past Commander Warner.
The
rules
of
our
Conference
permit
us to
give
privileges should he hear something that he wishes
bute from his vast experience and knowledge.
12
him
to
floor
contri-
I think we should
questions at least,
and
now proceed,
conferees,
to the
then go forward from there.
printed
MR. RILEY:
Thank you, Milton.
I am going to call on
the members of the panel to read the printed questions and I
shall ask Mr. Kownaski of New York to read questions 1 and 2,
Mr. Day of Colorado to read questions 3 and Mr. Henry to read
questions 4 and 5.
I am sure that they do not desire to answer
the questions and will refer them to members of the Veterans
Administration.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
Akin of Georgia.
total disability
appealed?
connected
of
The
The
first
question
rejection
was
based
disability.
Mr.
Budd,
MR.
‘BUDD:
Tom
Willett
MR.
WILLETT:
Insurance
was
May the rejection of an
income provisions
(TDIP)
Yes.
for
It
has
been
a number
of
upon
will
a
our
take
where
by Mr.
minor
answer
policy
years
very
you
will
submitted
application for the
to an
NSLI policy be
service
that?
it,
in
the
the
.Department-
rejection
of
an
application,
involving medical examination,
is due to an impairment which is not acceptable from a selection point of
view,
the
veteran
has
the
opportunity
to
come
back
to
the
District Office and protest.
Upon review.of this protest by
the District Office,
they still feel they must
reject the
application,
our procedure provides that the application and
insurance file be sent to the Central Office for final review.
It is reviewed by our medical consultant within the Department
of Insurance from an insurability standpoint,
that is, medically.
When required our doctor or lay medical examiner will consult
the Department of Medicine and Surgery for the specialist's
viewpoint as to whether or not this impairment
is one that can
be waived.
We have in many instances overlooked certain impairments.
In other cases, we have asked the rating boards
to review the rating again to see whether or not they could include this minor disability,
that you refer to in the basic
rating.
Veterans have had,
as I say, over the years many opportunities and have submitted many cases through the District Offices
to Washington for the final review.
We are not permitted to
submit
these
to
the
Board
by the General Counsel's
that these cases are not
bility.
Therefore,
they
Appeals.
But
resentatives
have
reversed
there
here
the
are
in
of
Appeals.
There
has
been
a
ruling
Office in the Veterans Administration
benefits.
These are cases of insurashould not be given to the Board of
many,
many
Washington
District
instances,
can
Offices,
vouch
and
and
for
that,
suggested
your
rep-
where
that they
we
accept the application or call for an additional or supplemental
examination which would lead them to accept the application.
Thank you.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
Any
comments
from
the
conferees?
Now, we will go to question number 2.
What,
is being done to improve the handling of insurance
with the Automatic Data Processing Center?
to
we
MR. BUDD:
We have given an awful lot
this.
This is an area that has troubled
have devoted a lot of time and attention
13
of
us
to
if anything,
deductions
time and effort
very much, and
it, and I would
like to ask Mr. Melidosian, who is our Manager at the VA
delphia Insurance Office,
to speak on this because this
something he has been very close to.
MR.
MELIDOSIAN:
Thank
Philais
you.
Needless to say,
this subject has attracted a great deal
of attention.
You folks discussed it in Miami.
We honestly
think that there is a real improvement
taking place in the area.
I am not going to start back and talk about discontinuances,
the problem of whether we get it from the Hines Center to our
own center,
and then start the Data Processing,
but I think to
bring you up to date, we should tell you that for the past two
months,
and it is
going to continue in the next month and as
long as it is
necessary,
we have been
reconsiling the tape
records that we have in Philadelphia against the tape records
that are at Hines and we have washed out a great number of
discrepancies.
These discrepancies as far as the insurance
is
concerned,
are minor in nature.
However,
they are sufficient
that they disturb his account,
so 1 ami sure that he is really
not concerned about the extent of the discrepancy on the tape
record, but the fact that he is not getting service he wants.
Just to pick out one statistic from a whole raft of then,
that we found in trying to bring these records together,
in the
first go-around, which hdd about 1400 discrepancies in it, of
the reconciliations,
we had about 775
or so where a claims
number was wrong.
Now, in the Veterans Benefits Department,
the claims number is terribly important and that is how the
claims are handled there.
In our accounts, we chose aninsurance number and while
we may carry this claim number with a discrepancy in ir or
maybe didn't have the claim number,
it no way interfered until
the two
systems became linked.
This type of thing is easy to
correct.
We either went to the folder file some place, or to
an index where most of them were actually resolved,
and as
they are washed out one after another,
it is certainly going
to put both records in much better shape to give the man the
service that he is entitled to.
I think,
also,
the communications from Hines to our
center is certainly improving,
and speeding up.
We are becoming
more cognizant of the due dates,
the period of time beginning
the next check out, because the 30 days run very quickly,
This
will also
prevent a long period of time of back and forth
correspondence.
Hines,
of course,
has also stopped some of their payments
outside the system which should eliminate some of the problems
for us also.
We are taking steps in both Hines and the Philadelphia Insurance Center to make program corrections where
there are certain paper documents.
These are just forms, con-
ventionally
be
very
referred
shortly
to
converted
as
forms.
to
the
Some
of
these
punch
card
forms.
we
hope
will
While this is just another piece of paper,
as far as the
insurance is concerned,
it is a piece of paper which has one
less clerical operation on it.
It means it speeds forward that
much more quickly into the system andrwith that much less error.
I think in substance this is where we have been over the past
three or four months.
I think the picture looks quite wholesome
14
from
our
standpoint.
If
record conciliations
errors.
find
which
a great
deal
of
satisfaction
from
been
made
and
washing
these
have
out
Unless there are some questions,
I think that you should
find a marked change.
I think you would be interested to know,
also, in Philadelphia,
that we now have inventoried the number
of cases that we have which we think we have some problems with,
and we intend to move these up to a high priority and to start
work on these cases,
and I think that this should be the residuals that we know and these other cases may individually turn
up, but in large way this
should start to purge the system and
bring us up to the level we know you want us to
be at.
MR.
APPLEBAUM:
Any
comments?
MR. BLALOCK:
(NORTH CAROLINA)
- We are
trouble now under Appendix O.
Payments with
tions.
I would just like you to clarify how
deductions when we have to pay our claimants
cy procedure of Appendix O.
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
I
I hope you will save that
Benefits Section.
took
MR.
care
BLALOCK:
of it,
I
just
am not
until
going to
tomorrow
wondered
how
having some
insurance deducyou do make the
under the emergen-
venture
for the
your
into that
Veterans!
insurance
area.
division
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
Remember,
there are two computers and we
actually accept nothing on our deduction accounts which are on
tape, which are under the computer system in Philadelphia,
unless we receive some sort of documentation from Hines.
Unless
we receive that paper,
that documentation,
our machine will
take no action.
This doesn't come though as an independent
piece of paper that we wait for.
It goes in a separate pile.
These come through to us
and whatever the instructions are on
that piece of paper the machine slavishly begins to follow,
so
in this particular case, we basically look for the input to
our particular machine from the Hines Center and I think this
is the origin of the point you have.
MR. BLALOCK:
What we do is tell our claimants
going to pay them under Appendix ©.
For two
months,
pay the insurance premium direct.
if
we
we are
better
MR. BUDD:
No, I would not say that is necessary.
You can
be assured that if a man is paid his compensation or pension
without a deduction and he has a legitimate deduction authorized,
he is not going to suffer.
We have arranged with the Department
of Veterans'
Benefits to adjust that.
He is not in any danger.
There is no jeopardy to his insurance,
even though there might
be an emergency payment where some one failed to deduct that
premium.
MR. BLALOCK:
That is reminiscent of the time you sent us
a wire down
and said, '"Now, we didn't deduct in July,
so we paid
July, but we are going to deduct in August,’ and then we came
along in August and you didn't deduct either.
I hope you will
work it out better under insurance than you did under that.
MR.
BUDD:
Yes,
sir,
we
will,
15
MR. MELIDOSIAN:
I think in conclusion on this point,
I
will just reiterate what Mr. Budd has said, that if the money
is in the VA, while the veteran may have some inconvenience to
him, his insurance will not be in jeopardy.
The accounts are
there and the money is with the VA.
MR.
KOWNASKI:
MR.
DAY:
1
Any
other
submitted
comments?
question
3,
In the past, VA has refused to apply an annual dividend
on a pro-rated basis,
subsequent to the declaration of such
dividend and prior to an insurance policy's anniversary date
where an insured dies and his policy has lapsed but the proportionate part of the dividend is sufficient to pay premiums
in arrears and maintain the contract in force to death.
What
effect will President Kennedy's instruction concerning acceleration of dividends have on the existing VA ruling concerning
the above?
Mr. Budd,would you or one of your staff answer
that, please?
MR. BUDD:
Yes,
I would just say this.
This has been
discussed many times and I would like to ask Mr. Clay, our
Insurance Counsel,
to speak to that, and possibly Mr. Poissant,
also, because it does have an actuarial aspect to it.
MR. CLAY:
Ladies and gentlemen,
this proposal and the
ones I have seen in the past are restricted only to death cases.
Of course,
yow cannot run an insurance business by taking out
premiums only where the man dies.
Also,
it discriminates
against living insureds who have to pay premiums timely in
order to keep their insurance in force.
Let me go a little farther and see what we are getting
into.
The proposal would only affect those people who have a
dividend credit option or an option to use their dividends to
pay premiums.
This is a relatively small percentage of our
participating policyholders,
somewhere around 23 per cent.
Also,
the vast majority of the people who have a dividend credit
leave that money on credit.
It is a sort of bank account,
and
they earn interest on it every year.
They use the dividend
credit to prevent inadvertent lapse where they may be out of
town and something happens or they forget to pay.
There is a
small percentage of policyholders who every time they get a
dividend applied to their dividend credit,
they quit paying
premiums until the dividend credit is exhausted.
However,
every time we withdraw money from a dividend
credit account to pay a monthly premium the insured is sent a
notice which shows him the amount of the withdrawal,
the remaining balance,
the month for which the premium is paid, and when
his next premium is due.
Likewise, when an insured uses the
dividend to pay premium in advance,
he is sent a notice showing
how much in advance that money pays the premiums.
If the insured exhausts his credit and his insurance lapses, he also
gets
been
a
lapse
fully
notice,
thus,
advised
exhausted,
lapses.
as
and
premiums
The
dividends
law,
will
what
to
you
how
can
much
he
see
money
has
that
paid,
he
the
has
and
insured
left,
when
when
the
has
which provides for dividend credits,
states
be applied in payment of premiums which are
16
it
is
insurance
that
due
subsequent
to the date the dividend is payable.
In order to
have a pro-rated dividend,
as proposed,
it would mean that we
would have to pay dividends every month to approximately
5,000,000
policyholders.
You could not pay them just to the
insureds who have a dividend credit because an insured has a
cash dividend option,
has just as much right to payment as the
insured who has a dividend credit option.
You can see this
would be very costly,
and would create many administrative headaches.
As far as the accelerated dividend payment that President
Kennedy requested us to pay, it has nothing to do with pro-rated
dividends.
We are merely paying dividends in March for those
policies with anniversary dates between March and December.
That is entirely different
than the proposal to pro-rate dividends in death cases.
Are there any questions about that?
Thank you.
MR.
DAY:
Mr.
Mattingly?
MR. MATTINGLY:
Mr. Clay,
as I understand it, your inability to use these dividends in the past on a pro-rated basis
was that the dividend was not payable until the anniversary date.
The question that still is not quite clear in my mind is this:
recently,
the President declared these dividends payable and
you are now paying them on an accelerated basis.
You are paying these dividends,
so under the circumstances,
in spite of
the fact that a man's anniversary date might be in
October,
November
or December, would you not then have the dividend
available to prevent future lapse some time
between now and his
anniversary date?
MR. CLAY:
What you are saying is that since we made them
payable in March he’ is being credited with his entire dividend
in March.
That is true, Charlie, but if we started paying
dividends once a year that would not be pro-rating dividends
in death cases.
It would not help the man who pays three
or
four premiums then lets his policy lapse,
and subsequently
dies.
The thing that the insured should do, of course,
if he
has a dividend credit,
is leave his dividends on credit to
prevent inadvertent lapses.
If he
has a cash option he should
change it to a dividend credit option.
MR. MATTINGLY:
Mr. Clay,
let's assume the man has a dividend credit option and that his anniversary date, for simplicity,
is December 1, and let's say he lapses in August and that
he dies in November.
Under the circumstances,
the dividend became payable when the President announced it.
Would not you be
able to prevent this policy from lapsing by taking the premiums out of the dividend account?
MR. CLAY:
If the insured has a dividend credit option,
we would pay the 1961 dividend into such credit account in
March.
If he lapsed,
the dividend credit would be used to pay
premiums until it was exhausted.
However,
that is not what is
proposed in pro-rating dividends.
Tf you pay dividends once a
vear,
as we are doing pretty .much this year,
that would not help
the man who
dies,
after his dividend credit has been exhausted
and the insurance is lapsed.
MR. MATTINGLY:
When
credited to him.
While it
the dividend became payable,
it was
is laying there, may it be used.
x7
MR. CLAY:
It will be used until it is exhausted.
However, what you are really asking us to
do in pro-rating dividends in death cases,
is you are asking us to pay dividends
every month so that every month the insured has a dividend
payable to prevent a subsequent lapse.
MR. MATTINGLY:
I think really we are confused and I
don't want to belabor the point, but I would like to go back
and rephrase the question once more and we will let it go at
that.
We are talking about the man who has the dividend option.
When the dividend became payable on March 1 or whenever the
President made this announcement,
then technically speaking,
at that time, this man's dividends became payable?
MR. CLAY:
The dividend
to his account.
is
dited
MR.
is
true.
If
he
has
date
of
going
back
again,
if
1,
and
MATTINGLY:
December
if
the
1,
That
then
dividend
credit
September, October,
and
use those dividends?
Here
payable
was
November
March
sufficient
premium,
MR. CLAY:
Absolutely.
I am
is what I am trying to say.
You have
dend placed on
man lapses and
exhausted,
but
in
not
an
he
then
saying
and
is
cre-
anniversary
lapsed
August
to pay
the
August,
would
not
you
that
at
all
Chuck.
a dividend payable once.
Now, then,
that divicredit will be used to pay premiums whenever the
it will be there until the dividend credit is
let's take this example:
Suppose the dividend is payable on the anniversary date
of the policy in March and the dividend is based on the premiums paid during the preceding policy year.
The insured uses
that dividend under the dividend credit option to pay premiums
for the
months of March, April, May and June.
He lapses in
July and dies in November.
The next dividend is not payable
until March next year.
The proposal for pro-rating dividends
in death cases is to
use the dividend which may accrue from
premium payments for the months from March thru June to keep
the insurance in force until
November even tho next year's dividend is not declared and is not payable until March next year.
Also,
this is only to be done in death cases where it will keep
the insurance in force until death.
MR.
CLAY:
MR.
RILEY:
MR.
DAY:
Anything
I
else,
believe
gentlemen?
you
answered
the
question.
or
comments
from
Thank
you.
Any
questions
the
floor?
MR. EGAN:
(Delaware) - What we have here
is a simple proposition that has happened before and perhaps the Veterans
Administration Insurance Section is reversing its previous
policy.
Many claims have been paid in the past in similar cases
of this type based simply and solely and wholly on the intent of
the veteran.
In this case, we have a Presidential directive
to accelerate rate of payment of the accumulated reserve on the
policy.
Unfortunately,
the intent of the veteran at all times
was to keep the policy in force.
18
Suppose,
as happened recently in a case which will be
down here
shortly,
the veteran and his wife were in an automobile accident.
The veteran died before he ever arrived at
the hospital.
The wife will be hospitalized for many months.
Now, we take that case as it is now.
Suppose that man had
received the accelerated payments and had no carry-over and
he had carried on for a few months and then died.
His wife
is incapable of protecting his entitlement.
The concern of the
family is for the well-being of both.
The insurance, whether
it is in force or not,
is incidental to the pressing needs of
the family.
The intent was always there to keep the policy in
force.
The question simply resolved itself to this point:
has
there been sufficient accumulated reserve based upon intent to
keep that policy in force so that the veteran can be covered
on his insurance?
I think that is the whole problem.
It has been down here
before and we have won cases on that basis,
the intent of the
veteran,
I want to know definitely,
do you intend to nullify
the intent of the veteran of keeping the policy in force,
and
do you intend to nullify the action of the veteran by intent,
because you recognize a Presidential directive,
but refuse to
grant him the additional coverage of protection that should be
accorded him.
with
have
your
here,
that
MR. POISSANT:
Somebody said the road to hell was paved
good intentions.
It is
not enough to have an intent.
You
to meet certain contractual obligations.
You have to pay
premium when it comes due.
As I understand the problem
you want to apply this money retroactively when you know
the man has died.
Suppose that we set up an
insurance organization and
wrote contracts with a stipulation that we would not collect
any money from anybody until they died and at that time we could
take it out of the face of the policy.
Nobody is going to buy
any stock in this insurance company,
I am sure.
You are always
out of pocket.
You deduct the premium from the face amount.
The policy would always be paying out money and collecting nothing.
This is tantamount to what you want to do.
You want to
take this dividend money and apply it to pay for the protection,
but only after the man has died.
This is not fair to the other
veterans,
If you could take this dividend money and apply it across
the board like we collect premiums across the board,
this would
be a sound insurance proposition.
You want to take the dividend
out after death occurs.
You should apply it all the way through
so that we would not be out of pocket in all of these transactions.
Does that answer the question?
Did I get the idea across,
or am I confused?
Maybe,
I could explain,
too; that a dividend,
according to law, is not payable until the administrator
says it
is payable.
The Administrator made that declaration last December and said that a dividend was going to be paid but it was going to be paid on yhe day before each policy's anniversary.
This is our regular custom.
We pay the dividend on the day
prior to the anniversary in calendar year.
Because of the President's desire to do something to add purchasing power to the
economy, we accelerated the payment of these dividends,
but this
is on a condition that if we overpay anybody we will collect it
19
from any source that is available to us in the insurance department.
We changed his declaration and now say that the dividend
is going to be paid as soon as possible,
but not, of course,
after the policy anniversary.
This is a legal question.
The question at issue probably here is when does surplus evolve from a policy;
that is
the basic question.
Theoretically,
every time you pay a monthly premium a certain part of it is surplus, but that surplus
does not become a dividend until the Administrator says so,
according to law.
The Administrator has to make a declaration
that the amount of surplus which is part of the monthly premium
is payable as a dividend,
and each .year he decides when that
dividend is to be paid.
Is that cleared up at
all?
and
MR.
EGAN:
I
again
pose
the
would
like
question
to
that
answer
we
that
proposed
question
in
part
before.
You
say
that the dividend is not declared until it is declared by the
Administrator.
I believe that the President appoints the Administrator and I don't believe that any Administrator will
ever attempt to nullify or revoke a directive from the President.
Then,
in addition to the dividend which has already been
declared, which only tends to exemplify the program which we
are printing here,
the President has also requested the insurance section to make a review as to
the available money which
may be distributed at a later date which the accumulated reserve on these policies,
which you must admit does exist,
and
you have only declared that which your actuarial table showed
would not completely deplete the reserve and the additional
dividend is pending by Presidential directive,
subject toa
review and an accounting by the new Administrator to the
President.
Why could not that fund, because it does exist -- I am
quite sure that the President knows what he is talking about,
that it does exist -- be used to cover the contengency of the
reserve money which
we are discussing?
MR. POISSANT:
Even under the accelerated dividend plan,
if a man has elected a cash option and we pay him his money,
he is going to get his whole year's dividend.
He is on a cash
option dividend basis.
This man gets it in cash.
If this
policy lapses,
one or two months or three months afterwards,
we are not going to retroactively use this money to keep this
policy. in force.
Maybe there is a misconception there, because we cannot,
as I explained before,
retroactively write insurance and just
collect premiums from the face amount of the policy, when a
man dies.
The man has made an election.
He wants it in cash.
If he says,
"I want my dividend to carry the insurance forward
onder a dividend credit option," that's all right.
We willddo
that.
But he has not made that election.
He had this choice
and he didn't make it, so he wants it in cash.
I don't see
that the accelerated dividend plan changes the situation to any
extent as far as the difference between those who had elected
a cash option and those who elected a dividend credit option.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
I am going to come back to this just a
little later.
We do have several more questions and I want the
conferees who have submitted them as well as the answers to
get before this meeting before we proceed further.
If we have
time later, certainly we will come back to this knotty question
20
of Tom
actual
Egan's,
case, I
which is
believe.
a
good
one,
because
it
was
based
on
an
MR. HENRY:
Question No. 4 was submitted by the National
Rehabilitation staff.
The Administrator's decisiom No. 969,
approved under date of December 7, 1960, deals with payment of
permanent and total disability insurance benefits
(USGLI).
Will
the regulation,
when published,
have retroactive effect?
Please
discuss this change briefly.
MR. BUDD:
This is
most happy to speak to.
speak on this one.
MR.
recall,
out
that
MCGURN:
last year
if
an
one that we were very happy to
I would like to ask Mr. McGurn
see
to
and
This is a subject which we discussed,as you
at your meeting.
At that time,
I pointed
insured
who
was
found
permanently
and
totally
disabled under a United States Government Life Insurance
tract elected not to receive the monthly income payments
stopped paying his premiums
there would be a retroactive
of the insurance in the event that we subsequently found
he recovered from his disability.
Conand
lapse
that
This was because of a Comptroller General's decision
which held that if a man recovers from permanent and total disability you must consider
that he never,
in fact, was permanently totally disabled.
Accordingly,
under the circumstances
which I indicated we must consider that the policy did not
mature.
Because the man did
not pay his premiums the policy
would have lapsed.
This was a problem which gave us quite a
bit of concern for quite a while.
It was something which we
were
not
satisfied
with.
I am
glad
that
today
I am
able
to
tell you that the possibility of lapse in insurance under these
conditions can now entirely be eliminated by the Administrator's
decision 969 and the regulation which is based on it.
The Administrator's decision and revised regulation now
recognized that the insured is entitled to a waiver of premiums
during any period that we find that he is permanently and totally
disabled,
notwithstanding that he elects not to receive the
payments,
notwithstanding
that he may be later found to have
recovered,
As to those men who have elected not to receive the payments, we will let the payments accrue to their credit.
If they
later wish to receive them, we will pay them to them in lump
sum.
Otherwise, we will pay them to the beneficiary at the
time of his death.
If a man elects not to receive the monthly
income
payments
and
does
not
pay
the
premiums
because
he
no
longer has to, in the event of his recovery, he can continue
the protection under his policy simply by paying the future
premiums as they fall
due after the date of recovery.
Presently, we have 229 of these cases
on our rolls.
30
of these insured are still paying the premiums in order to
protect themselves.
The Administrator's decision will apply
to all of these cases.
We will credit these men with all the
installments which have accumulated up to this time.
We will
continue to credit them with the installments as they become due
in
the
future.
they
have
paid
and
totally
We
will
for
the
refund
period
to
these
that
we
disabled.
21
men
rated
any
them
premiums
as
which
permanently
MR.
a moment.
minutes.
RILEY:
We
We expect
are
the
going to halt
Administrator
the proceedings for just
in just a
few short
MR. BUDD:
I introduced these gentlemen earlier,
since
then another man has joined the group.
I would now like to
introduce John R. Murphy,
our VA Manager in St. Paul,Minnesota.
MR.
HENRY:
Question
Rehabilitation
staff.
What
do
effect
MCGURN:
5
was
disabilities
example alcoholism) have
for insurance purposes?
MR.
No.
The
on
fact
that
is
the
difficulty
an
we
impairment
have
in
within
Many of us
enjoy our
a sociable drink.
None of
feel that we are incurring
ism,
by
of misconduct
determination
the
conduct nature is entirely immaterial
man's rights for disability insurance
connection with alcoholism is not its
becomes
submitted
of
a
member
origin
total
disability
is
of
(for
disability
of
a mis-
as far as determining a
benefits.
The problem in
misconduct origin.
It
determining
when
the
of
meaning
the
our
condition
contract.
cocktail before dinner.
We enjoy
us, I am sure,
in taking a drink,
a disability.
This is not alcohol=
On the other hand, we know that people sometimes die
from alcoholism.
It is apparent,
therefore,
that somewhere
between these two extremes,
there is a point at which the continued use of alcohol can become a disease.
The point at which
it becomes a disease when it is no longer a matter of choice,
but a disease is very difficult to determine.
All I can say
is that,
generally,
we will consider alcoholism to be a disease
within the meaning of our contract, when the habit has become
very profound, when a man has reached the point,
so to speak,
of no
return, where he has reached a stage where he cannot get
a job if he wants it and he could not hold it even if he did.
It is seldom that we have to try to resolve this question
solely on the basis of the alcoholism.
There are other related
factors.
There is a question of the cause of the habit and a
question of the results.
We know that frequently there are
underlying psychiatric and emotional disturbances which cause
the habit.
We know,
too, that invariably,
there will be deterioration,
physically and mentally,
as a result of the continued and excessive use of alcohol --nervous and mental disorders, neuritis,
cirrhosis of the liver,
and impairments of
the cardiovascular system and others.
It is
these conditions together with the alcoholism which
constitute the total picture of disability.
The fact that
these conditions or the habit itself is due to misconduct has
no effect on a man's right.
MR. RILEY:
Are there any questions from the floor now,
particularly with reference to question 4 read previously on
Administrator's Decision 969?
That is something brand new.
Is there any one here that would like to discuss that particular
question further or the last question?
Are there any questions
from
the
floor?
MR.
HENRY:
In
regards
to
22
question
No.
3,
about
applying
dividends to the payment of insurance to the payment of insurance,
if this dividend check was received by the veteran either
prior to his death or shortly after and he was never able to
cash it and the widow later returned it to the VA, would that
insurance dividend be able to apply to the premiums and pay it
to her in a lump sum?
MR. CLAY:
You are asking,
1 gather,
that if a man asked
for his
dividends in cash and we paid them in cash,
and he
dies before his check is cashed,
or negotiated, will that be
used to pay premiums.
The answer is no.
The man has requested
that it be paid in cash, not to be used to apply to premiums.
Does that answer the question,
or did I understand it correctly?
MR.
HENRY:
That
answers
the
question.
MR. GORDON B. PEFLEY (Oregon):
I would like to refer to
question No. 3.
I would like to make it crystal clear that in
the minds of a lot of us
that portion of our insurance payments
which eventually will become repayable as dividends at the end
of the year is not actually earned then until the Administrator
says that they are payable.
If that is true,
that is one thing,
but if they are earned out of a portion of each one of the insurance payments that we make by what right do they say that
they are not earned until the Administrator says they
are payable?
They are still earned during the year not when the Administrator says they are payable,
but when the payments were
actually made.
MR. POISSANT:
I will admit that some surplus develops
each time you pay a monthly premium,
but the Administrator has
to make a declaration as to when gains and savings warrant the
declaration of a dividend.
You say the dividend is earned.
All right.
What do 1 do with it?
Some of them made a cash dividend option and some of them
have elected a dividend credit.
Do I apply everybody's dividend
that carries insurance,
or do I wait until the man dies and
then apply it?
This is the crucial, basic question at issue
here.
You can't just apply it on death cases.
You must apply
it on all the cases and in all the
cases you can't apply it
because some people have elected a cash option.
Is that clear?
To make it an insurance proposition,
I have to apply it on
everybody across the board and I cannot do that because a lot
of these policyholders,
in fact 75
per cent of them, have
elected the cash option.
We operate this program on a sound
technical basis to maintain equity among our policyholders.
It
would not be fair to do it the way it is suggested that it be
done.
time,
time,
MR. RILEY: We are going to conclude this panel at
since there are no further printed questions,
and
Mr. Applebaum,
I will return the mike to you.
CHAIRMAN APPLEBAUM:
Thank you.
to turn the meeting back at this time
all take a short stretch at this time
CHAIRMAN
to have
speaker
Today
the
and
MCCURDY:
Will
the
this
at this
My sole function will be
to California.
Will you
and remain in your seats?
meeting
come
to
order,please.
it is
indeed a high honor that is presented to me
rare privilege of introducing a most distinguished
I say distinguished advisedly.
I say rare advisedly.
23
We have a speaker today who has a long period of service and
not only a long period of just service, but service to The
American Legion,
and more particularly service to the veteran
and our disabled veteran.
You all know that for six years he
served as a Vice-Chairman of this Commissiom.
You all know
that he served,
and with distinction and honor,
as our National
Commander.
It is indeed a happy day today when we can welcome
our comrade here as the Administrator of Veterans! Affairs.
Our distinguished quest, Jack Gleason.
ADDRESS
OF
OF
THE HONORABLE JOHN
AFFAIRS
VETERANS'
S.
GLEASON,
ADMINISTRATOR
Mr. Gleason.
Mr. Chairman,
fellow Legionnaires,
and
fellow Americans,
I think all of you know without my having to
say it, that I am extremely happy and proud to have this
opportunity to be with you,
and I hope that you will still consider
me
years
from
one
of
now,
officially
at
your
for
least.
friends,
our
one,
two
relationship
or
will
even
possibly
be
little
a
more
changed-
A few years ago,
I had the great honor to serve as your
National Commander.
I now stand before you as the Administrator
of Veterans' Affairs,
a post that I am proud and humble to have
been appointed to by the President of the United States.
And so my friends,
our official relationship shifts. Although I certainly count on continuing
to be a part of your
family,
there may be times when you view me as something of an
"in-law,"
But
bank
I hope
tellers
you
thought
don't
ever
of
mother-in
his
think
of
law.
me
the
way
one
of
our
His boss confronted the teller and said: Joe,
you're a
liar.
You asked for yesterday off to bury your mother-in-law,
and yet I met her walking in the park this morning."
she
Joe thought fast,
then said,
was dead.
I just said I would
As all of you know, my job is
my assignment it will be to work as
very best of my ability -- to serve
for
the
United
States
of America.
"Sir,
I
like to
didn't actually say
go to her funeral.’
new to me, and as I view
hard as I can -- to the
all veterans who fought
But to do this I'll need all the help,
all the cooperation
and all the understanding I can possibly get from The American
Legion and from other responsible veterans!
organizations.
And I am not too proud to go hat in hand to ask for it.
For I know that The American Legion -- and especially,
you men
and women sitting here today,
are the very embodiment of service
to the veterans of our country.
Yet, today there are those who charge that leaders of
veterans'
organizations
are ''self-servers' who continually lobby
so that veterans may ''gorge at the public trough," or ''ride a
perpetual gravy train" of "undeserved benefits."
they
Such irresponsible
allegations have been heard
will be heard again.
These charges are not
new
24
before,
and
to you or
: |
myself
--
and
certainly
they
are
not
true.
Those who voice them should acquaint themselves with the
facts.
They should learn -- as I have -- that men like you and
other leaders in this work have a sense of responsibility,
high purpose and sincere dedication that is unexcelled in any
walk of American life.
To claim a disregard of national interest by veterans'
organizations
is not to know -- or to
simply
ignore -- your many programs which are aimed at a stronger,
more efficient,
and finer America.
For
the
past
few
weeks,
I
have
been
learning
about
this
vast Veterans Administration that I am now privileged to head,
and although after serving as your National Commander,
getting
all of my facts from Bob McCurdy in the past,
I was not absolutely ''green' about the agency,
I have been amazed by its
dimensions:
up -- down -- in -- out... measure it in any direction and the VA represents one big package.
The Veterans Administration employs about 170,000 people
more people by the way, Mr. McCurdy,
than live in Pasadena,
California,
Bridgeport,
Connecticut,
or Topeka, Kansas.
The Veterans Administration receives more mail each year
all of the people living in a city the size of Pittsburgh.
than
VA
than the
America.
hospitals use more sheets and pillow cases
combined amount used by 150
of our biggest
I've learned that the
more than a hundred million
aspirins ‘annually.
As
cargo
Administrator,
I find that I even hold
vessels that were torpedoes by U-boats
This
makes
which
is
me,
quite
I
suppose
a title
VA's
for
per year
hotels in
Veterans Administration purchases
eggs each year, and over 22 million
Our people provide guardianship service for
in-arms,
and pensions for Civil War widows and old
fighters,
to say nothing of benefits and services
of veterans of more recent wars.
66
-
an
Admiral
Army
of
the
more babesIndian War
for millions
title to
in World
Sunken
Fleet
some
War I.
--
man.
I knew that the VA had to keep lots of records, but I was
a little surprised to find that we have master index record
cards on more than 30 million veterans,
both living and dead.
As you might expect,
there are lots of Smiths on this roster...
300,000 in fact, and about 13,000 of them are named Bill;
12,000 named Bob, and 11,000 named John.
I learned also that I am keeping good company on the list
with 394 other John Gleasons,
and there are 133 John F. Kennedys,
including a former PT boat commander who now lives across the
park from the VA building.
(Despite all this duplication, we
found only eight Robert M. McCurdys, which just proves what I
have always known -- you have to go
a long way to find people
like
Bob
McCurdy).
Now, my purpose
and complexity is not
your indulgence.
in
to
detailing these statistics
impress you, but rather it
25
of
is
magnitude
to ask
This I ask, because in an agency
always been and there always will
have
I
present
am
just
areas
beginning
of
consideration.
it would be an
to know all the
We
will
to
concern
--
get
at
a
as
be
closer
questions
vast as the
problems.
look
that
at
some
deserve
VA
there
of
the
earnest
Knowing the short time I've been on the job,
insult to your intelligence for me to presume
answers.
But I want to emphasize this:
recognize
we will identify
they might be.
the
and
areas
never
of
hide
concern
from
our
whenever
problems,
and
and
whatever
Above all, we plan to meet our problems head on,and do
our level best to achieve proper and reasonable solutions.
The very foundation of the Veterans Administration is a sound
and durable, structure of benefits built by the Congress,
in
response to the will of the American people.
At the very
core of this entire structure stands this simple fundamental
principle -- Service to Veterans.
For in the Veterans Administration,
our job is to
serve
veterans,
their widows,
and their orphans in keeping with the
laws of the land. It may be that I'm old fashioned ... or call
me a fundamentalist
if you will... but I heppen to believe that
service to veterans is the very reason for our existence.
I
believe that all projects and undertakings in the VA must be
aimed at this goal of service.
Earlier this month, when I first came with the Veterans
Administration,
I received my initial marching orders personally
from President Kennedy,
The President said he wanted a ''speed
up" in the payment of the quarter billion dollar 1961 G.I. insurance dividend as an aid to some five million veterans and
as a stimulus to the nation's economy.
It is early in the game,
but I have learned already that when the President wants actionhe does mean action - and he means right now.
Considering
that it normally takes a full 12 months to
pay the dividend,
the question we asked ourselves was, ''"how
fast can we do it?"
At first, we set our sights on completion by not later
than June 30 -which would cut in half the normal payment
schedule -- but we were determined to beat that date,
if we
could.
Let me now give you the very latest report, which in
my mind stands as a tremendous tribute to the willingness and
energetic enterprise of all the people associated with our
Department of Insurance.
As of today, VA employees who are
working around the clock, have completed the processing of
over three million dividend payments.
over
it
Right now -- at this moment
140 million dollars into the
needed
a 1ift.
And
what's
-- this program has
American economy at
more..,
it
looks
now
like
pumped
a time
we
will
have this crash program completed by March 17.
For all of you
who don't know,
this is St. Patrick's Day. This would mean completion of the crash program within about six weeks from the
time President Kennedy ordered '"full speed ahead."
and
The VA has problems and challenges,
but it also has friends
supporters,
and you men here this afternoon are typical of
26
them.
And speaking of friends and supporters,
I personally -the Veterans Administration,
and veterans everywhere have lost
one of their staunchest
friends in the death of our beloved
Watson
B.
Miller,
understanding
America.
and
for
he
was
truly
was
a man
a
of binding
standard
But his spirit will go on...
will be carried forward by the Bob
and by all of you.
bearer
his great
McCurdys,
wisdom
for
and
great
veterans
of
pioneering work
the John Corcorans-
Any Administrator of Veterans Affairs needs lots of help
and assistance to do his job.
Fortunately,
I have good help
and great assistance right in the VA family,
and at this time
I would like to salute the loyalty,
the dedication,
and the
competence of my co-workers that make the VA the great organization it is.
An Administrator needs the cooperation and guidance
that
Congress
can
provide,
and
here
again,
I
consider
myself very lucky.
The Chairmen of these Committees,
especially
important to us - Senator Byrd, Senator Magnuson,
Senator Hill,
Senator Yarborough,
Congressman Albert Thomas,
and members of
these Committees are men of stature and have sincere interest
in the welfare of the veterans of the United States.
But the veterans of America owe an even greater personal
debt to Congressman Olin Teague, Chairman of the only Congressional Committee devoted entirely and exclusively to their
affairs.
It has been said that Olin Teague is tough.
That is
true.
But I can assure you, he is honest,
he is kind,
and
what's most important of all, he is fearless.
The Veterans
Administration and its Administrator are most fortunate to have
this man, and the dedicated members and staff of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs as our advisors on "The Hill."
But
perhaps
most
of
all,
I
need
the
''grass
roots"
kind
of understanding and constructive criticism that only the
American’ Legion and other responsible veterans'
organizations
can provide.
I am counting honestly and sincerely on your support,
each of you, and I assure you that I will perform my job as
Administrator to the very best of my abilities in order to
merit your support.
Even with all this help,
I might still
need just a wee bit of the luck o' the Irish. With my name and
my face,
it doesn't seem to me that this is too much to ask.
Mr. Chairman,
and all of you who are my friends,
thanks
for the opportunity to come back home with all of you.
Thank
you for
inviting me to join in your sessions,
It. .is good to be
with old friends once again.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I know that you are sure
good supporters.
It was
and I could not help but
would
buy
silver
fizzes
That's our boy!
Administrator Jack,
that we are your good friends and
interesting how much mail you receive
think that as many eggs as they buy
for
the
whole
group
for
a year.
And
I didn't quite catch the connection,
but I did hear him mention
the babes-in-arms
and I am more interested in that subject.
We
do know, Jack,
that you are a Major General; we know you are the
Administrator
of
your status is
We know, also,
changing,
but we are not about to
that you are a life member of The
Veterans'
Affairs;
27
and
we
know
you
stated
that
let it change.
American Legion,
and while you have these titles and you have these great responsibilities,
I am reminded,
and only bring forth this thought
to govern our future associations on the part of everyone in
this room,
that there is a place in the initiation ceremony of
The American Legion that says there is no rank among us and
each serves as the equal of his comrades,
and certainly this
group has always considered that and it is the great point
in
our ceremony that makes The American Legion a terrific,
strong
organization because we have men at the top like Jack, and
we
have
some
we
have
a
the
benefit
like
common
of
me,
and
ground
each
some
where
that
he
other.
we
gets
are
the
not
so
proud
benefit
and
of,
we
but
get
I say that in a most friendly spirit, Jack, and you can
be sure that you will always remain our comrade.
We may have
some arguments with you and I have never been known to get
along too long with someone without
arguing with him, but you
will always have our deepest admiration and you will always
have our deep respect,
and we certainly are going to try to be
your strong,
right arm.
We thank you sincerely for coming down
today.
Thank you, Jack.
I
want
tomorrow
to
call
morning,
attention
Commander
that
Burke
promptly
requests
at
that
here and in your seats..At nine o'clock sharp
ing he has a message of great importance.
nine
If there is nothing
tomorrow morning.
.
at
9:00
.
a,
.
At
m.,
4:05
p.m.
Wednesday,
further,
the
we
Conference
March
28
1,
will
be
all
o'clock
of
tomorrow
in
recessed
:1961...
nine
recess
to
you
be
mornuntil
reconvene
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 1, 1961
. . . The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel Statler, Washington, D. C., at 9:30 a. m,, Mr. Robert M.
McCurdy, Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Commission,
presiding...
This
Will you please come to order.
CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
that we
morning, we have one of the most important discussions
have had yet, certainly one of our most challenging problems,
and in presiding at this meeting, I have asked the help of
another fine and great National Vice Chairman of the Rehabilia gentleman from the State of Alabama, Vice
tation Commission,
Chairman, Comrade Clarence Horton.
Clarence.
Good morning,
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
We have a few little procedural problems
ladies and gentlemen.
to solve here this morning before beginning upon this most imI believe those of you who know me reasonably
portant panel.
Therewell might agree that I am not given to exaggeration.
fore, when I say to you that I believe the subject which we
have for discussion this morning is the most important which
perhaps any Rehabilitation Conference of the preceding five
years or of the coming five years has been faced with,
I am
almost tempted to say that since the National Recovery Act of
1933 no single thing involving veterans'
benefits has aroused
more interest and brought more pressure from the field than
the subject of Automatic Data Processing.
So great was the
pressure that for the first time in my recollection the National
Director of Rehabilitation,
John Corcoran,
and his assistant,
Ed Golembieski,
have found it desirable and necessary to visit
VA installations all over the country to try to arrive at some
solution to the perplexing problem which we have before us today.
Some insight into the depth and breadth of the problem
might be envisioned by the fact that when the Rehabilitation
staff prepared its rehabilitation memo on the subject of
Automatic Data Processing they began by saying,
"Into each
life,
some raih must fall,”
They
America
in
undoubtedly
would
supply
knew
the
next
that
every
line.
"but
service
too
officer
much
has
in
fallen
mine.”
It reminds me also of another guitar-plucking tune which
many of you might recall.
It goes something like this: "I
thought
I had seen pretty girls in my life, but that was before
I met you." Now, you will paraphrase it for me and you will say,
"I thought I knew what confusion was, but that was be A.D.P."
I believe, my friends,
that we have arrived at
of procedure which will please each of you, although
require some understanding on your part.
a method
it will
First of all,
I want to present to you your National
Director of Rehabilitation,
John Corcoran,
to make a sort of
opening announcement,
after which you will see the sequence
which follows.
We were primarily concerned in our little onstage discussion this morning with your feeling.
We want to be
extremely
careful
not
to
set
up
29
a
pre-planned
program
which
might lead you to believe that you were being excluded from
your right to participate
in the discussion,
but we did come
to the reasonable and sensible conclusion that if you would
allow us, first,
to present a sort of an over-all picture before we began to deal with specifics,
and individual matters,
we would all probably be a little bit better off, so expecting you as you always are, to be considerate of the rest of
the Conference and to be believing in our own
good conscience
in the matter,
I would like to present to you now your National
Director of Rehabilitation, Mr. John Corcoran.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Clarence.
I can begin by saying that I concur in your comments on the seriousness and the
importance of the subject that we are about to discuss.
In
our view,
it is the most important subject that will be discussed at this Conference.
A
gone
best
word
on
format.
along with the
approach,
that
that
Bill
Driver
or
The
panel
has
requested,
and
request,
because it seems to us
we follow the following format.
a member
of his
staff,
make
an
we
have
to be the
We ask
opening
presentation.
Then, we ask that the panel members headed by
Earl Merifield,
make statements and then that the subject be
open for discussion by all of the participants
in the Conference.
The major difference between this and other panels is
that we will not, unless you so request,
take up the questions
that have been submitted in advance.
The questions that have
been submitted in advance have been answered by the Veterans
Administration and their answers have already been distributed.
We
urge
questions
answered
you,
as
to
bring
and
if
time
you
permits,
feel
those
that
to
read
they
questions
up
over
have
in
your
not
the
particular
been
satisfactorily
course
of
the
debate.
At the same time, we urge you, when the floor is thrown
open for full discussion,
to bring up any question, whether
submitted in advance or not, which you feel is fundamental
to
the question before us.
I thought
that I might well begin the
panel by reading the resolution which is under discussion by
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
This is Resolution
No. 149 from the National Convention at Miami Beach.
This is
somewhat long,
so I am going to read it rather fast. The subject,
of course,
is disbursing VA compensation and pension checks by
Automatic Data Processing.
"Whereas,
in January 1960 the Veterans Administration began converting all monthly payments of compensation and pension
to automatic data processing by establishing a Center in Chicago
and many unlooked-for problems and delays in paying veterans
and their dependents have been and are being encountered in this
new system creating extreme Hardship to thousands of beneficiaries and in addition because of the complexities of the system
and the additional work involved in processing so many duplicate
awards huge backlogs have been created in the Administrative and
Adjudication Divisions of many offices which have delayed the
processing of new and reopened claims;
and
it is
shall
"Whereas, Congress has, on many occasions,
announced that
its intention that benefits and service to the veteran
be provided with the least possible difficulty;
and
"Whereas,
the
Veterans
Administration
30
has
repeatedly
stated that it is
dedicated to give the
men and women who have
served,
and their families,
their dependent widows and orphans
and parents,
the best service possible under the law; and
"Whereas,
The American Legion through the years has advocated and insisted on the decentralization of VA operations
in order to give improved service,
as experience has shown the
centralization of any of the operations has resulted in poorer
service;
and The American Legion has insisted that in any re=or
ganization plans of the Veterans Administration or consolidation
of workloads that they be given assurance that service to the
veteran would not be impaired and that only high quality service
be continued;
and
"Whereas,
the Administrator of Veterans' Affairs in 1959
stated that it was essential to use available modern business
methods to improve service to veterans and the VA has stated in
adopting ADP that it would improve service
to veterans and produce an over-all reduction in operating costs;
and further,
promises were made that this system would result in many improvements in service to beneficiaries
-- none of which has so far
been realized;
and
"Whereas,
after nine months of trial and error there
appears to be little satisfactory improvements in the correction
of basic problems that have arisen in attempting to apply this
system to VA payments,
and there still continues
to be a large
number of complaints because of nonreceipt of checks;
and huge
backlogs in the processing of claims are still evident,
and
the fact that an increasing number of payments in various categories must be paid outside of the system clearly proving the
system is not properly functioning;
and
"Whereas,
experience in some lines of industry has revealed that ADP does not necessarily lend itself to every phase
of business and endeavor and has had to be abandoned in many
instances after being thoroughly tried, and because of its
complexities,
the question arises as to whether it can be
adapted to the efficient and prompt payment of compensation and
pension because of the constant adjustments necessary in these
accounts;
and
"Whereas,
The American Legion,
realizing its responsibility to guard the interests of the veterans, his widow and
orphan,
to assure that he receives nothing but the best of care
and service,
questions under the circumstances whether ADP can
be made to work for their best interests,
for their better service and at a reduced cost; now,
therefore, be it
"Resolved,
By The American Legion in National Convention
assembled October 17-20,
1960 in Miami Beach, Florida,
that
the National Rehabilitation Commission is directed to immediately cause to be conducted a thorough investigation and survey
of the automatic data processing system for making benefit payments in the Veterans Administration,
for the purpose of determining whether its continued operation will be to the best
interests of the veteran;
and that they cause to be made a
careful comparison between this system and the prewious system
of processing awards to the local Finance Division and payments by a local Disbursing Office,
and that the approximate
costs between the two systems be determined;
and that if it be
found that the operation of the ADP system will be to the
31
benefit of the veteran and his dependent and will result in
lower costs,
that The American Legion pledge its assistance
to the VA in every way to perfect the system, but if on the
other hand, it be concluded that continuation of the system
will primarily result in poorer service and secondarily,
in
increased costs,
that every attempt be made to prevail on the
Federal Government
to abandon the plan;
and be it further
"Resolved,
that the National Rehabilitation Commission
of The American Legion immediately on completion of this survey make a determination as to the future position of The
American Legion with respect to the operation of ADP as it
affects veterans,
their dependents and survivors and that in
the meantime,
The American Legion insist that no additional
regional
offices
be
converted."
This resolution was approved by the National Convention
and, as you can see, mandated the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission to conduct a thorough study and report
back to the Commission.
This resolution actually instructed
us to do something that we had undertaken to do long before
October,
1960,
As Clarence said, members of our staff have traveled far
and wide in these United States.
We have been to Philadelphia,
to Detroit,
to Chicago,
to Los Angeles,
to Indianapolis,
to
Atlanta,
to Florida.
We have been many places.
The study and
the investigation is still going
on.
An important,
if not perhaps the most important, part of
this study will be the discussion here this morning.
What you
say, and what you suggest,
and what you feel will be a vital
element,
I am sure,
in the determination
to be made finally by
the National Rehabilitation Commission.
With
that,
Mr.
CHAIRMAN
HORTON:
We
with
tinguished
have
friends
us
Chairman,
I
conclude
Thank
you
very
this
from
the
morning,
Veterans
of
my
much
remarks.
Johnny.
course,
our
Administration,
very
dis-
headed
by
one in whom we have great confidence.
He is a man of many
talents and a man who
deservingly speaks this morning for the
Veterans Administration in connection with this most difficult
problem.
I think that when I speak his name by the applause
which you extend to him, you will join me in congratulation
upon his recent elevation to be Deputy Administrator of the
Veterans Administration.
Without further
comment,
I present
to you. Bill Driver.
MR. DRIVER:
Thank you very much, Clarence.
Ladies and
gentlemen,
this has been a very pleasant meeting and I wish
that we could terminate it now.
I have heard a great deal
about ADP already and I am sure that most of you have also.
You know,
there were days last year when we were working on
the new pension law when some of us thought that we never
would find an issue to take its place.
I think it is
a mark of
something -- I won't say what -- that we have succeeded so
admirably.
This is a simple procedural matter,
as distinguished
from something in the substantive law, and yet it has come along
and consumed us.
It burns feverishly in our breasts and in our
minds,
and I am sure that it will burn
some other things here
this morning.
32
I think that no better vehicle on which to base our discussion of this subject can be selected than the resolution
which John Corcoran referred
to.
I will feel
my way through,
referring,
if I may, to the salient points in that resolution
and indicate in a very brief fashion how we feel about the
subjects at issue.
Then I am sure you would prefer that I
sit down and:let someone
else talk.
I know that those of you who are here in the audience
this morning also are anxious to contribute to this most important subject.
Briefly,
however,
I would like to indicate
at the outset that ADP did not just happen.
It came along
after a very careful analysis reaching back over a number of
years.
In fact,
in 1957,
we began our initial planning to use
the automatic data processing system and we made better than
a year's analysis of the procedures
that would be affected and
the programs which would be necessary if we were to have a
successful operation.
Following that, we invited a management firm to come in
and review what we had done, either to bolster our convictions
that it was feasible,
or to
tell us wherein it was not. They
spent six months looking at the operation,
looking at the proposal that we intended to follow,
also examining the type of
equipment that it was our intention to use. Their conclusions,
with some modifications from our original findings, were
that this was indeed a suitable operation to be
handled through
a computer,
so we did go to it and we have had our moments
since,
It was not easy to change the basic program so that we
could use a computer instead of the
mechanized system consisting of the more conventional tabulating equipment and the
punched cards which have become so familiar on the American
scene,
in the form of a check,
in the form of a notice from
some business company that we receive magazines from, or even
bills.
We switched from this system to one using a computer -a computer which uses magnetic tape,
and which,
of course,
can
function much more rapidly than any other mechanical equipment
we had in effect prior to that time.
The
payments
Veterans
are
Administration
scattered
among
67
operations
regional
having
offices,
to
so
do
we
with
had
to
pick a place to start.
We sélected a group representing about
400,000 accounts in six offices.
We scheduled them for conversion after we had written approximately 250,000
individual
instructions
to
accommodate
the
system
to
the
computer.
In writing these instructions we made mistakes.
We made
plenty of them.
I think perhaps this is a natural thing.
We
are free to admit it and sorry indeed, but we did make them
and they caused a good many errors to come about in the conversion process,
errors which simply resulted in the fact that
the accounts that we fed into the equipment from the regional
offices did not convert to the magnetic tape from the punch
card,
thereby
dropping
.tions that were
to convert.
It
to
load
the
regional
that
was
While
office
before
all
out
of
payment
status,
under
the
opera-
in effect at that time,
the accounts that failed
also meant that these accounts had to go back
of
to
be
reprocessed,
us
at
that
this
was
taking
33
time.
adding
This
place,
we
to
the
work-
too
complicated
had
already
life.
alerted
another six offices to convert. We had proceeded down the
road with them to the point where we felt we could not retrace
our steps.
There were many people who recommended that we not
convert them.
I would have to say on hindsight
that I wish we
had not,
too, but faced with the decision at that time, we
felt we had proceeded too far with the conversion in the second
six offices and so we proceeded with them also.
ing
At
the
the
death
same
time,
accounts
you
from
will
the
recall,
we
Philadelphia
had
been
district
decentraliz-
office
to
all regional offices.
This was an action which I know all of
you are most interested in because it is
a principle for which
I think all of us stand -- that the basic adjudicative process
can best be carried out close to the veteran,
as near as you
can operate a large system which is what we have in the regional
offices.
This meant #n toto that we had then committed ourselves
to conversion of something in the neighborhood of with amounted
to, then, a million three hundred thousand accounts:
1,300,000
running awards.
We have today in the files something more nearly approximating one and a half million because,
of course,
the
offices whose accounts were converted have fed more new cases
in there since conversion.
So we have today for consideration
about one and a half million accounts in the automatic data
processing system being paid from Chicago.
The
in
the
resolution
early
part
to
which
Mr.
Corcoran
"unlooked-for
read
problems"
to
you
having
referred
been
en-
countered up to October and I would admit there is now no
question but what there were '"unlooked-for problems.'
There
were unlooked-for errors in the programs;
there were unlookédfor errors in the records which has been converted;
and therefore,
there were unlooked-for workloads at a time when we could
ill afford to receive them.
We, I
problem and
However, we
and we have
unlooked-for
we
have
think, have to say we could not anticipate every
I must say we succeeded admirably in not doing so.
have benefited by the experience we have gained,
corrected them to the point where I, think that the
problems cannot be said to exist today.
I think
recovered
our
position,
have,
to the point where
for the job and they are
with some benchmarks why
and
I
thank
the
Lord
that
we
the programs certainly are adequate
doing the job, and I will indicate
we think that, a little bit later.
The resolution refers to delays in payment being encountered.
We certainly agree to
this but I would like at this
point to remind you that in the adjudicative process,
the
veteran is concerned with one thing.
He makes application for
a benefit and then in some prescribed period,
he hopes he will
get a check from the Veterans Administration if he is found
entitled.
From the point when the application is received in the
Veterans Administration,
we try to keep track of the time which
elapses until a check is mailed to the veteran from the Treasury
Department.
Prior to the conversion to automatic data processing, we were meeting the acceptable range of somewhere between 70 and 90°‘days.
We succeeded because of conversion,
but
also because of the fact that we received 18 new pieces of legislation last year including the pension law,
which alone resulted
in a workload of better than 250,000
actions that had to be taken
34
in our 67 offices; we succeeded with all of this workload which
we processed at a more rapid rate than
we have ever in our history -- and at a time when we were losing trained adjudicators
and Rating Board members because of age of World War I veterans,
thereby further complicating life with a retraining program;
we succeeded in building up large backlogs of work which only
recently have begun to come within manageable form.
The workload which is coming to us now is down.
It is down to more
reasonable proportions.
The impact of the pension legislation
and the psychological effect that it had on any number of World
War I veterans to beat the July 1 deadline with an application
for pension so they could have the right of election either
way, created a tremendous workload.
That workload is gone, but
we got hundreds of thousands of applications which would not
have arrived on the scene had it not been for that one deadline
alone.
All
process
of
in
this
the
caused
steps
delay.
which
It
are
taken
lengthened
before
the
ADP
adjudicative
ever
enters
into it; points where we develop the case,
examine the evidence,
and this kind of thing.
:It increased those from 30 to 40, to
50,
to 60
days in many cases,
In this phase,
you realize,
there also is the examination.
We ask the hospital or the
clinic for an examination
and any delays that incur there add
to the total.
The point after adjudication,
the point when
the award is authorized,
where ADP really comes into play, represents only a handful of days compared to the two or three
months represented in the build-up,
so I must say that I consider we are concerned here this morning only with the time
between the point where authorization say, "Yes, pay the man,"
and the point where the checks go out to them.
This is the area
that
in
the
main
represents
the
ADP
procedures,
not
the
build-
up in the beginning.
The build-up in the beginning was complicated by ADP to some extent because of the workload it created,
but I would remind you in talking about delays in payment,
that
most of the delay occurred because of the large backlog that
developed from the new legislation,
the training,
the loss of
people,
and so on.
ADP had
its part, but it should not be
cursed,
I submit,
because of the total.
"The new system created hardships for thousands."
(Qoutes
from Resolution 149).Admitted. Because of the conversion procedures
that were followed in the beginning thousands of cases
were dropped from payment status.
This has long since been
modified.
All of you, of course,
are familiar with the fact
that local authority is present for the regional manager to pay
any
case.
I
believe
that
the
reports
we
have
received
recently,
(and I am sure we will hear some talk about them this morning)
indicate that it is
not impossible to get a case
processed.
In fact,
it is normally not difficult
to get a case paid once
it has been identified as a problem case.
We believe the procedures we now follow,
and willin the future,
are so modified
that that will not occur again.
Here again, we have benefited
by the experience we have gained.
I would like very much to
be able to say that it didn't happen.
It did.
We must admit
it, but I will indicate in this area the benchmark wherein we
think improvement
is definitely identified.
Now,
let
us
look
at
what
we
consider
to
be
the
benchmarks
or the indicators that tell us whether this plan is running
properly or running improperly.
We received at a high point in
September,
a little over 21,000 inquiries from veterans whose
35
checks were being paid from the Chicago Data Processing Center.
On converted accounts only, we received just about 21,000-plus
inquiries.
About half of these inquiries involved cases where
a check had been issued but there was a delivery problem.
The
address was not properly indicated on the check,
either because
the veteran did not inform us promptly,
or we did not process
it promptly;
or in printing it the Treasury Department garbled
the address or even the name to the point where
it could not
be delivered.
In
about half the situations this was the situation.
In most of the others,
a check had been issued, but the
amount was questioned.
These are still categorized as inquiries.
The remaining represented cases where a check had
not been issued,
and this was where
the trouble stemmed back
from the beginning.
This was in September,
just prior to the
time when you passed Resolution 140,
In February,
the month just passed, we received 10,191
inquiries as compared to 21,000 in September.
In half of these
cases,
a check had been issued to the veteran but we still had
the delivery problem.
We get down to a point somewhere under
5,000
where a‘check had not
been issued,
and this is out of
one and a half million accounts.
I believe that this indicates
improvement.
We, of course,
are still not satisfied.
We are determined to do something about the change of
address problem which has plagued us for years, but no one ever
thought it sufficiently serious to try to do anything about it.
Never in the history of the VA have we ever made
any attempt
to find out in how many cases veterans are moving without notifying us.
We intend to hit this hard.
We intend to make an
intensive campaign;
first to remind the man himself,
or the
woman,
that they must come
to us and tell us when they move
if we are to give them prompt service;
second,
to improve the
method whereby we process these changes of address after we get
them.
We are flirting now with the idea that we will handle
this by teletype instead of having the forms processed through
normdl mail.
I think there is a tremendous amount that can be
done in this area and we intend to do it.
Also
the
area
of
improvement
--
another
reason
that
causes difficulty with a case, as I explained earlier,
is the
fact that for some reason it cannot be accommodated on the
electronic equipment after it is
sent to the center for payment
or for change.
In September we were rejecting a little better than ten
per cent of all of the actions which were submitted for processing through the computer.
In October between nine and ten
per cent.were being rejected.
In the month of January,
this
figure had dropped to 1.7 per cent.
We are handling between
150,000
and 180,000 actions a month involving changes in the
status of the accounts on the computer.
We had been rejecting
at our high point approximately 10 per cent and are now down
to 1.7 per cent and still going
down.
There has been a decline in each month since September.
This results from the fact that the data coming from the regional offices has improved;
the péople there are better trained;
they are furnishing a higher quality of input data for the equipment.
Also the programs by which the computer functions have
been modified in many cases to remove errors which were in them
in the beginning:
errors consisting of inability to accommodate
36
certain
many of
types
these
functions
The
of transactions,
errors,
and for
for
that
example:
We have
removed
reason
the
entire
operation
better.
1.7
figure
bothers
us.
We
would
like
to
see
nothing
rejected, but remember,
this figure includes the cases that
are rejected quite properly.
We may be trying to do something
which is impossible.
We may be trying, for example,
to pay
an amount to the veteran for a disability which is not provided
for in the rating schedule.
The electronic equipment
is geared
to scan the information which comes to it in any one situation
and because it already has programmed into it, already has in
its mind,
if you will,
all of the data that is in the rating
schedule,
when
a
case
passes
through,
if
there
is
an
impossible
combination under the schedule,
it will throw it out and
say,
"Please correct
this,
there is something wrong with it."
When
we converted the cases in the first instance from the regional
offices,
we
found
any
number
of
thousands
of
situations
like
this.
1 think that our records should be accurate,
1" would
hope you would agree.
We certainly would like to think that
in this area the machine offers a definite improvement over
what we have had in the past.
I think that the last point I would like to mention from
the resolution is the question that I think is uppermost in
your minds -- it
certainly is in ours -- the question of decentralization versus centralization in regard to whether it is
providing adequate or inadequate service.
TI indicated earlier that it is our belief .that the basic
ad judicative process should take place at the regional office
level.
This is the reason we decentralized the running award
death cases from the district offices.
We feel that the veteran's case file,
the records whereupon you establish the
validity of a claim,
should be located so that the representative
of the man, you,
if you will,
can examine them where the veteran
resides,
so that you can have him come to the Veterans Administration and demonstrate to him or even plead in his own behalf
in regard to the claim he has presented.
We think this is
essential and we think that this serves the veteran's best
interests.
However, when it comes to the administrative processes, we do
not see the
essentiality,
in regard to service,
in having the operation,
the procedural details involving the
check
And
the
issuance,
for
example,
this is the area
regional office.
which
located
we
have,
at
in
the
veteran's
effect,
doorstep.
removed
from
I would also remind you that prior to conversion not all
regional offices had in their facility the finance activity.
I will use, for example,
the Phoenix Regional office.
Payment
activity for Phoenix accounts was located in Los Angeles.
The
payment activity for some other stations in the Southwest was
located in Dallas.
The payment activity for New England states
was located in Boston.
Payment records were not in all the
regional offices.
About 45
had payment activity and the
remaining 20-plus did not.
You also know that the Treasury maintained
about
22
disbursing
offices
prior
some along with our conversion and
Chicago,
so that not all of the 67
fiscal activities.
What
we
have
done
now
is
to
-37
to
conversion.
They
have
closed
transferred their records to
regional offices had these
embark
on
a
course
whereby
there will be no such
tions.
This activity
procedural device.
I
fiscal activities in any of our 67 locawould take place in Chicago.
It is a
believe that so long as we can render
satisfactory
in
service
terms
of
getting
the
check
to
the
vet-
eran promptly after it is authorized in the regional office,
and I think that the record of improvement that I have mentioned
here this morning is indicative of the fact that it can be done
with this equipment
-- under these circumstances we are not only
justified,
but impelled to conclude that such a system is
feasible and proper.
Thank you very much.
We will be glad to
participate in any discussion or questions you have on the subject.
Thank
you,
Clarence.
CHAIRMAN
HORTON:
Bill,
before
you
take
you present by name to the Conference those
on this panel from Veterans Administration?
your
seat,
associated
would
with
you
MR. DRIVER:
Yes,
I shall be happy to and I apologize
to you for not doing so earlier.
On my immediate left is Mr.
Ferdinand Petraitis,
Executive Assistant
to the Chief Benefits
Director;
and his left, Mr. Wallace Koseluk,
the ADP Director;
on
his
left,
Service
and
of
the
the
Director
Department
of
of
the
Systems
and
Veterans' Benefits,
Standards
Mr.
Gene
Mock.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
For fear I overlooked this very important mission,
I would like to present to you by name also the
staff representatives on this panel, Mr. Ed Golembieski,
Assistant Director for Claims.
I am about to introduce The
American Legion Panel for the discussion of our problems of
today.
After I have done that,
I hope to be allowed to take
my seat near the rear of the platform and I will not expect to
return to this lecture,
except in the unlikely situation where
it might be necessary to restore order,
or to
call the expiration of time, or to make sure that you in the audience have
an opportunity to express yourself.
To represent The American Legion,
I .think that we do
have
indeed a distinguished group of experienced service officers
and field representatives.
I think perhaps that you would like
to join with me in commending the Director or the person responsible for having selected these people to speak for The
American Legion at the head table,
so to speak, on the matter
of the automatic data processing.
The fact that one of the
gentlemen is from Alabama is no slight recommendation.
The fact
that another comes from the home state of our National Chairman
is not without being worthy of note.
But to be more serious,
the man who will preside as Chairman of this particular group
is a man who comes from a fully converted station with something
more than one year's bitter experience and I think that I would
be
unfair
to
him
and
to
the
great
days
and
hours
of
work
that
he has devoted to documenting his position if I did not call
your attention the fine attributes which this man possesses
and the devotion to the cause which is jointly yours, Earl
Merifield from California,
the Chairman of the panel.
bers
He will, as opportunity affords,
of the panel.
Mr. Merifield.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Thank
Veterans Administration
and
introduce
the
other
to
mem-
you, Mr. Chairman.
Gentlemen of the
members of the Conference,
I believe
38
I would first like to introduce to you who
may not know them,
the members of the panel of which Clarence mentioned.
First,
Charles A. Zeglin, Department Service Officer,
Pennsylvania,
J. B. Clark, Department Service Officer of North Carolina,
W. W. Wadsworth, Department Service Officer of Alabama,
Leo M.
Leggett, Department Service Officer, Michigan, John Corcoran
has very capably set forth the primary purpose of this panel
and what we expect to accomplish.
I was reminded of an article
I read here when
Johnny read that part of the resolution that
mentioned the fact that experience has shown that automatic
data processing is not necessarily adaptable to all lines of
endeavor.
I read an article here from the Navy Management Review
by an outstanding representative,
in fact the Chief of the
Navy Management office.
I thought it would be appropriate to
read it to: you,
"Today,
everyone is fairly well familiar with the premium
placed upon painstaking detail in computer installations.
Yet,
many installations
are failures and most of the successful
installations have so far provided only extremely marginal economic benefits.
As a matter of fact, when it comes to business
logistics applications,
electronic computers appear to be
like
politicians,
full of promises,
but short on performance,
and
there are many who think it is high time that we voted them
out of office.”
The American Legion is dedicated and has been built on
service and the rehabilitation division service to the veteran
and his survivor.
If we permit situations and conditions to
arise that prevent us from giving that service,
then we may
as well go out of business.
The American Legion has zealously
guarded
the
rights
and
benefits
of
the
war
veterans.
down through the years,
has been to recommend means
service to him by Federal agencies can be improved.
Our aim
by
which
The American Legion beginning as far back as 1942, with
the World War Veterans Act has insisted on the decentralization
of Veterans Administration operations
in order to give the
veteran better service.
That was proven when the old district
office set up was decentralized to regional offices. We successfully opposed certain provisions of the management survey
report made of the Veterans Administration a few years ago,
which attempted to reorganize it by centralizing many of its
activities.
We fought
finally won our
thereby.
service
service
It
to
as
has
fer years
point and
been
veterans is
a result.
our
to decentralize death claims and
the survivors of veterans benefited
experience
centralized
that
he
when
suffers
any
a
form
reduction
of
in
The National Executive Committee,
at its meeting last
May went on record that in any reorganization plans of the
Veterans Administration,
or consolidation of workloads The
American Legion be given assurance that service to veterans
not be impaired,
and so we come to the subject for discussion
today,
automatic data processing,
ADP.
ADP is primarily a system of centralizing payments to
veterans and because of our experience as cited before, we
must scrutinize very carefully any plan for centralization.
39
I am not going to take the time to go
tails of what we in converted offices
have had to go through in the past 13
touched on that.
into the harrowing deand veterans involved
months.
Mr. Driver
You who have experienced it need not be reminded and
those of you in non-converted stations have either heard about
it, or have some knowledge as to what you can expect through
your simulated processing.
All
created
VA
and
officials
the
problems
admit
that
the
chaotic
still
exist.
situation
They
which
tell
you
was
of
the improvement
that has taken place.
This is admitted.
It
difficult to see how it could have become any worse.
They
tell you about further improvements
that can be expected.
These I will .accept with tongue in cheek;
they have made so
many
promises
as
to
when
the
system
would
function
is
properly
that have not materialized.
I am sure they must understand our
position,
but for sake of argument let us agree with them that
the operation will continue to improve.
I have neverdoubted
that from an operational standpoint it can be made to work.
I remember on several occasions Mr. Whittier,
former Administrator,
telling me it must be made to work.
However,
the
question in my opinion,
and which is before us today,
is after
it has been made to work operationally,
will it offer improved
service to the veterans and their survivors,
and here is where
we who have had experience in converted stations and have
studied the system from every angle part company with those
officials of the VA who are trying $ohard to sell their system
to
us.
Remember,
improved service was the reason
for adopting this system.
The Administrator of
Affairs in 1959 said
and I quote:
given to us
Veterans!
"It is essential to use available modern business methods to improve service to the veterans."
And further,
"In
adopting automatic data processing to VA payments it would
produce an over-all reduction in operating costs.
Mr. Whittier in his letter of resignation to the President
of the United States,
as Administrator of Veterans! Affairs,
as late as December 31, 1960, said in part in outlining the
accomplishments of his administration,
and I quote:
"The ultimate result will benefit the nation in terms
of tax dollars saved and veterans and their dependents in
terms of improvement
in service rendered."
This I emphasize
is the only reason that I know that has been given for adopting
this system and if this cannot be accomplished then surely
there is no purpose in using it.If The American Legion should
permit the Veterans Administration without raising its voice
in protest to adopt any system that will result in poorer service to the veteran,
then we have failed in our responsibilities
and our
obligations
to him.
So far we have seen
nothing but poorer service.
All we
have had is promises that it will ultimately be better than
before.
When I think of service to the veteran I am thinking
in terms of personal and sympathetic service that can, and
has been rendered in the past by the Veterans Administration,
and the representatives of the veterans'
organizations.
40
the
What
is
Department
the
of
ultimate
service
Veterans
Benefits?
the
veteran
I say
expects
it
is
the
from
timely
adjudication of his claim and the
prompt payment of benefits
due him.
I say to you, based on my experience,
that an
electronic computer in Hines,
Illinois can never give him
this.
No matter how efficiently the system can be made to
work,
it can never give the veteran better service,
nor can
it give him as good service as under the mechanized system of
payments.
What is more important to the needy veteran than to be
promptly informed as to when he can expect his adjustment
check as a result of an original or an amended award,
or to
be told immediately on his making inquiry as to why he did
not receive his check and when he may expect it?
They may
reduce the time that
it now admittedly takes of from nine to
26 days to get a write-out from the computer to show the status
of the account to only a few days;
they may reduce the time
that it now takes to get the Form 6566
in the file,
indicating
what the master record shows, from a minimum of two weeks to
probably five or six days;
they may reduce the time it now
takes to get an answer by wire from the data processing center
to a check inquiry to a few days;
they may even reduce the
time it now takes to pay a rejected award or a hardship case,
under appendix O.
But when and if eventually they reath these goals,
they
are still far shostiof the service that all of us, the Veterans
Administration included, were capable of giving the veteran
while he was stillin the office or on the telephone,
or in
reply to correspondence under the mechanized system,
and as
a result they can never reach their announced goal of improved
service,
but, on the contrary,
this new system has and will
result in poorer service to him -- and that, my friends and
comrades,
is the crux of the situation and, in my opinion,
the
only part of this highly complicated and involved system in
which The American Legion is interested -- I would be remiss
in my duties as discussion leader,
if I did not comment on
some of the remarks that Mr. Driver has made and also some
that
appear in a Review of VA ADP System for Benefit Payments,
dated
March 1, that is signed by the Chief Benefits Director.
but
I
the
do
not
know
Administrator
how
of
many
of
you
Veterans'
are
familiar
Affairs
in
with
last
the
October
fact,
called for an evaluation of the ADP program to be completed
by the end of December.
This is in three -- at least I have
had the opportunity of seeing three -- large columes of this
report.
I noted that some of the figures that Mr. Driver gave
appear in that report,
but in any that have been
given to you
or any that will be given by Mr. Driver's staff here during
the course
of the discussion,
I want to call to your attention
one particular paragraph that is contained in that report so
that you will keep it in mind when they give you figures of
accomplishments,
and it reads as follows:
This,
mind
you,
is
an
evaluation
of
the
ADP
program
by
the agency itself, by experts in the Veterans Administration.
"The ADP impact on service,
costs,
savings, backlog,
productivity,
or staffing cannot be accurately estimated by the
Veterans Administration from available information.
This is
true both for defects that have occurred thus far,
and for
those expected in the future.
41
has
I also wish to refer to another paragraph
great meaning and has great significance,
a
possibly
they
program
and
follows:
"It
will
give
you
the
figures
of
its
accomplishment,
is
recognized
of
Veterans Benefits
Department
that
cost
this
and
so
evaluation
comes
at
a
because it
when later
forth
of
and
reads
it
of
time
this
ADP
in
when
as
the
current
problems obscure the prospects of a more rewarding future.
This evaluation has attempted to give the timing of the study
full weight and the projections throughout it are considered
to be as optimistic as possible.
"However,
in order to achieve desired goals,
the Department must direct its efforts toward many basic improvements
and establish controls to insure their accomplishment."
There are
challenge,
like
‘office,
and
several
myself,
there
is
one
here that I know
you particularly
here
that
you would want to
from a converted
I am
sure
you
from
non-
converted offices would want to challenge.
One of these has
to do with a comparison,
and this is fundamental because it
has to do with the job that the staff, under the resolution,
has to perform this comparison with the operations of ADP
with the operation of the mechanized system prior to ADP.
We who have converted stations particularly have had to
work with this tremendous number of check inquiries and the
difficulties involved,
and in this report the Veterans Administration says:
"The precise volume of such inquiries received prior to ADP is not known."
That is admitted.
They
do not know.
But then they go on to say: "The task
force
that looked into this indicates that the inquiries equalled
one per cent of the total number of running awards."
I
challenge that figure.
The Los Angeles Office converted
160,000 accounts and not by the widest stretch of the imagination did we have 1600 such inquiries on checks,
and I believe that every one of the rest of your offices will challenge
that
figure.
They
admit
they
do
not
have
a figure
as
to
how
many inquiries prior to ADP, but then they use a figure that
is all out
of proportion to the experience that you and I have
had.
I know that today in the Los Angeles office, we have
14 full-time people in an inquiry control point, who do
nothing but spend their entire time on check inquiries,
and
I know that before ADP we didn't have a single one in such a
division and it was easily handled by the Contact Service.
So
I desire to challenge that point as being inaccurate.
Let me read another one that I am sure you from converted stations will agree with me we cannot buy. "The ADP
system itself adds little,
if any, impact to the current workload in the regional offices."
And Bill made the remark that,
after all, all ADP has anything to do with,
in this whole 70
to 90-day processing -- which is now from 90 on up in our experience
--
is
all ratings and
sure that there
that
all
are
take
exception
to
other
operations,
me:
about
to
new
small
portion
at
the
authorizations have
those of you on the
that,
that
it
takes
no
because
I have
had
too
end
of
the
thing after
been completed.
I am
floor who are going to
longer
on any of
many
of you
talk
these
to
‘it.
And they say this:
"These conditions were due primarily
legislation."
Some 18 pieces of legislation were
42
referred to.
You and I know that four-fifths of that legislation created no workloads, practically no workloads whatsoever.
You also,
I am sure, will agree with me that the
ma jor portion of the
workload created by new laws was Public
Law 86-211,
and you also know, and I think I can make the
statement,
that every office in the country was allowed additional permanent personnel to take care of what was projected
as an additional worklodd created by that law.
I believe in
the Los Angeles office, we have eight full-time people as the
figure given which was supposed to take up the slack of that
Public Law 86-211.
Therefore,
I say that we cannot charge
that Public Law 86-211 created the workload because they were
given additional personnel to take care of it.
So,
we only
had a couple of laws there that temporarily would disturb their
workloads,
and they did.
Public Law 86-663 did considerably
to disturb it, but it was only temporary.
It is nothing new.
We have had new legislation in every Congress since I can
remember,
and we have always had to take care of a temporary
increase in workload,
so, therefore,
I cannot buy the thing
that it was not ADP that created this situation;
it was new
legislation.
And here is one I want to leave for someone else to
answer,
In this summary,
the evaluation of the ADP program,
they called attention to the increased time lag for adjudicating original claims,
showing how the line went up from some
70 days to 95
days.
Then, they say further on this new legislation, "But look,
in non-converted stations the line also
went up in proportion,
the same as converted stations,' and
therefore,
they deduce it could not have been due to ADP.
"It
must be due to new legislation because it is the same in both
stations," and I want you people in non-converted stations to
listen because I am not in a non-converted station,
and I
cannot
answer,
"We
have
but
no
some
of
evidence
you can
that
answer
these
this,
I
simulated
am
sure.
procedures
are adding to current workload situations.”
I will leave that
for some of you to answer.
I know that you probably can hardly
wait.” Those are to my mind at this time the most important
things
that
should
be
brought
to
your
attention,
and
with
the
permission of the Chairman,
I would like to give just a few
minutes to each of our discussion leaders on the panel here
to make any comments that they care to before this is thrown
onto the floor.
We will start out with Mr. Ziglin of Pennsylvania,
MR.
ZEGLIN:
Let's
go
to
the
grass
roots
of
the
auto-
matic data processing.
Mr. Driver stated that there was an
improvement in the service.
I would like to just generalize
on several situations which we have in the Pittsburgh office.
We have a case of a widow who has never received her check in
the system from the beginning.
I could not get anywhere with
it.
I appealed to John Corcoran'’s office.
They paid her, I
guess, on the "hard copy."
To date, she is still not in the
system.
Every month
comes up and we have to pay her under
Appendix 0; and that definitely is not an improvement.
Around the middle of February,
I received a 'phone call
from a postmaster in a small town in the western part of Pennsylvania,
He told me, "I usually get 40 to 50 Veterans Administration checks in the mail.
"This month," -- that is the end
of January -- ''there are none.' “These
people are making
43
inquiries and I am at
could have happened."
we
to
a
loss
to
give
them
any
reply
as
to
what
We had to take those cases
individually,
and I am sure
didn't find them all, and make inquiries and ask the system
check this out,
Here is an
example of an entire shipment
that
just
dropped
out
of
sight.
I would
briefly
like
to
make
a comment on the blind aspect of this system.
A while back,
I
got a letter from a veteran.
He said, "Thank you for continuing
the payment of my pension check.
You told me that I was not
entitled to any more, but you keep sending them to me and I do
appreciate them."
where
How
the
initial
many checks are
veteran doesn't
payment
payment,
I téll
they ask you for
it will stop and
is
being
in the system
speak up?
We
repeated,
say,
that
have
$400
are being paid
cases where the
or
$500
initial
the veteran,
"Put the money in the bank until
it, because if I make inquiry to the system
Lord knows when you will get your check."
We are faced with the change of address.
I say to the
veteran,
"Heavens,
don't change your address.
If there is
any way of forwarding your check you have it forwarded.
Don't
change your address because your check will fall out of the
system and Lord knows when you will get it."
That is a very
bad situation.
As I say again,
there is a blind aspect to this
system.
You can't ask the system,
"Now is that man entitled?
1s he getting a pension?"
Or, Is he entitled to get a check?”
They-éan't tell you,
It. is up to the: individual. to report.
What if this poor widow I cited didn't have a telephone?
She
is bedfast.
She is sick.
She asked somebody to make the call
for her.
If they didn't speak up, she would never get a check.
So the system is not good and at the grass roots it is not
working.
That is ail I have.
is
MR. MERIFIELD:
there any comment
MR.
CEARK:
It
Thank you.
you care to
would
be
Mr. Clark
make?
rather
of
difficult
North
to
Carolina,
add
anything
to what Mr. Merifield has already stated, but Mr. Driver in
trying to sell the ADP system to the committee the other day,
remarked about these machines are ‘the same as those being used
by the Army to compile data in regard to our missiles program.
Now, we know why it isn't working.
The same situation exists
in Winston-Salem,
I think,
that exists in all the other converted stations.
They talk about the improvement being shown
in statistics;
they are showing improvement.
They had to.
The
situation could not have gotten worse.
But it is only cleaning
up a mess that they
created themselves by adopting ADP, and a
service officer inr the field cannot any longer render service
to the veteran,
and, as the Administrator said yesterday,
that
is our primary purpose.
If they continue with this they may
as well just do away with all service officers.
Thank you.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Mr.
Wadsworth
Thank
of
you
Mr.
Clark.
Alabama.
MR. WADSWORTH:
I think Chairman Bob McCurdy pretty well
described it to some of us yesterday whenhe said, "It ought
to be changed to automatic dementia praecox.'"
Unless there is
much improvement
in a very short period I don't think we will
have enough beds to take care
of the service officers alone who
44
are being subjected to ADP.
Frankly,
and I thank the Lord
every day I am from a non-converted station and I certainly
hope that prior to going under the system or going back to
the mechanized system,
that there will be a great deal of
improvement;
this is the first time in my 16 years of experience and work that I am left hopelessly without an answer
and know nothing I can do.
You can obtain the C-folder,
or
the XC folder. There is no explanation as to
why a check was
not issued or received.
There is no explanation that you can
give as to when a check will be forthcoming.
It has taken
away
from
the
service
officer
for the beneficiary in
confusion,
overpayment
initiative
to
a critical situation,
and so forth.
the
We
do
something
talk
about
I ran a little survey in my non-converted station.
We
only have 23 per cent of our running awards under the system.
During the fiscal year 1960,
there were only 73 overpayments
in
the
regional
office.
From
July
through
December,
under
the
automatic processing alone,
and bearing in mind only 23 per
cent of the caseload under the system,
there were 282 overpayments.
I certainly think that if we are to continue in
this field that the Veterans Administration should set up some
type of liaison service between automatic data processing and
the disbursing office,
and the post office.
We are leaving
the burden of proof on the veteran when he does not get a
check to follow through in every aspect.
him
erans
a
The VA say, "We issued you the check.'
Then they
lost-check letter.
That doesn't come back to the
Administration.
It
comes
back
to
the
disbursing
send
Vet-
office
through the post office.
We don't give him service from the
VA standpoint,
in my opinion,
to help him find that check,
and help him locate the check,
and locate the difficulty which
caused him not to receive the check.
I certainly think that
during this critical period some type of liaison should be
set up to tell that veteran immediately why he didn't get his
check and when he will receive his check.
I certainly would like to see a great deal of improvement in the time period from non-receipt of the check until
an answer is received as to why a new check was not received.
We are experiencing at the earliest some 16 or 18
days after
we submit the inquiry before he gets an answer,
Quite often,
the answer is not satisfactory.
But all we get is we, is we
get the check number and a Form 162 letter was sent to the
beneficiary.
In that period of time, we are just about due for
another check to be issued,
and we still have not located the
first check.
I think that the Veterans Administration must
certainly do something to expedite,
if nothing else,
the
answer to the veteran as to non-receipt of payment.
improve
There
the
is
one
system.
other
The
thing
that
regional
I
think
office
we
hands
should
are
do
tied
to
after
they get that check number.
They said,
"There is nothing we
can do.
We can't pay under Appendix 0, or any other procedure."
I think we have to work the bugs out of this thing and set up
some type
of system to cancel and immediately issue a check
under Appendix 0 from the regional office.
Thank you very
much.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
And
Mr.
Leggett
45
from
Michigan.
Mr.Leggett
is
from
a
converted
office.
MR. LEGGETT:
Thank you, Earl.
Ladies and gentlemen,
certainly heard the pros and cons on this issue.
I am
have
going
to
repeat
observations
As Earl said,
at that time
ment in this
in Detroit.
fested
by
things
here,
other
than
to
just
empress
a
you
not
few
that I have concerning the Detroit regional office.
we were one of the first converted offices,
and
I couldn't foresee the possibility of any improvething for years to come.
I have seen improvement
Whether or not this improvement has been mani-
efficiency
in
the
worthwhile
efforts
of
the
Veterans
Administration employees themselves, I do not know, however,
I say this relative to the automatic data processing:
the
amount of inquiries that we are currently receiving of the
VA in Detroit certainly does not reflect a greater efficiency
on the part of ADP.
The inquiries that we are currently receiving have increased over the past months.
I have a member of my staff in
the office conducting a survey since this automatic data processing system became involved in the situation,
and we see
no definite improvement in payments.
We see in some areas
where a check was rejected and Appendix O put into force that
these individuals never are back into the system in a running
award.
It seems that you run into cases where they are continually being rejected,
each and every one, for no apparent
reason.
It
is
a
question
such
as
we
have
already
presented
here.
How do we stop these things?
It is an
impossibility certainly
on the part of all of us to do anything about it, other than
to advise a veteran that we cannot give an answer,
We can
only go to the VA and attempt to resolve this problem.
In the Detroit regional office we have had VA employees
working many hours of overtime to try and catch up with this
backlog.
We in Detroit,
have a terrific backlog in the adjudicative division.
When ADP came along, we had individuals who ©
had filed, who had not been awarded claims in eight, nine,
ten
and 11 and 12 months'
time, waiting all this time for a check.
The backlog in our office was very bad.
In summation,
I would just say this:
that I see no immediate improvement in the automatic data processing itself.
We
have shown very definite gmprovement in our own regional office
in the backlog that we incurred in the adjudicative division.
In talking with and in questioning the other individuals in the
various organizations
concerning this ADP matter,
they and my-
self
would
recommend
that
it
be
abolished.
Thank
you.
MR. MERIFIELD:
The Chairman,and Vice Chairman,
and the
discussion leaders agree that those who have sent in questions
on ADP for the Veterans Administration officials that have
attended this forum should be given the opportunity to express
themselves on this subject, particularly as to whether or not
they are satisfied with the answers that have been given by
the Veterans Administration to their questions so I will now
entertain that discussion by those who submitted questions.
I
have not. had an opportunity to go over the answers as yet.
They
appear
to
this.
Are
be
Administration
very
complete
personnel
there
any
and
for
I
want
their
questions?
46
fine
to
compliment
mathod
of
the
Veterans
presenting
MR. POWERS (GEORGIA:
We submitted some questions and
they cover a rather broad field.
I share with you the doubtful
privilege of being in a converted station,
and in addressing
myself to our questions and discussion that has taken place
here this morning,
I would like to review the entire matter
Just a bit.
I have been privileged to be here for 12 years.
In this
room are what I consider
to be the people who work most closely
with the Veterans and their dependents in rendering service to
them and in this 12 years'
time I don't recall having
to take
up the subject of getting the money into the hands of the
veterans and their dependents,
after the awards had been laboriously caught up and after we did succeed in getting the claim
through,
We had never been troubled with the payment so I am
disturbed
have
at
all
of
this
had
no
difficulty
In
our
station,
effort
with
we
to
over
were
correct
the
a situation
past
getting
12
that
we
on
new
years.
excellent
service
cases and amended awards and on those mistakes that needed
correction we were able to get one-day service
on the checks
and tell the people exactly when they could get their checks.
That was exactly what we wanted to render to them in the way
of service.
We carefully went along with the study of the ADP
system after it took place in Georgia.
We worked with every
one in our regional office in an -effort to be cooperative.
We
even withheld complains as long as we could on the non-receipt
of checks,
and the unavailability of information,
and we reached the point, finally,
of complete exhaustion,
and we reached
the point where our regional offices and our service establishment in Georgia were unable to render the service to veterans
that we felt they were entitled to.
Then we teed off on ADP and it is
our belief from our
careful study that you will never be able under ADP to render
a service to the veterans and their dependents equivalent
to
that which was being rendered under the old system.
We base
that
on
the
fact
of
the
growing
number
of
new
cases,
the
grow-
ing number of death awards,
and the growing number of amended
awards,
and our study shows that in each of those from the date
of final adjudication,
the date that the decision is finally
made to pay the man,
there is a lag of 21 days at best.
They
can correct the mails all they please,
and correct the machines
all they please, but they can't possibly tell the people that
under this system they can expect their checks before 21 days,
and that is not correction enough for most people who have not
received their very livelihood on the day that they are entitled
to receive the check.
Through
in
the
answer
this
to
whole
one
of
thing
our
there
runs
questions
as
the
to
tenor
what
which
effect
I
is
note
going
to come out of the teemendous overpayments that are involved,
and they say, '""We see no bad effect because we believe that
those are running awards and the people are still entitled to
the money and the VA will lose nothing because they can recover
that money."
That is a point that disturbs a service officer because
every bit of that recovery comes from people who cashed their
checks believing that they were entdtled to them.
They spend
the money for their livelihood and are later called on to have
it deducted from their running awards,
and the hardship and the
47
loss
to
gotten
on the
enough
In our
of the
those
people
we
serve
is
tremendous.
Had
they
not
the mistaken check,
they would have gotten by perhaps
amount to which they are entitled.
They are not smart
in every case to know they have gotten too much money.
regional office, we have gone from the very beginning
filing of the case right on through and we find not a
single
process
that
has
not
been
adversely
affected
by
ADP.
Certainly,
at the present
time,
there has been improvement,
but
I had a friend who suffered a complete hemiplegia,
and 30 days
later when he moved a little finger they said there has been a
dramatic improvement,
and that is the expression that has been
used in this, "There has been improvement and there will be
more in the mechanical process," but everything that has been
done to make that improvement reached its crux by this of
spending money,
every penny available,
I believe, for overtime
that the Veterans Administration has been expending.
Non-converted stations have had funds withdrawn from them
to pay for overtime in converted stations,
to pay for this
crash program of bringing this this up to the very best point
it could be by the time of this meeting,
and that point is far
from satisfactory to those of us who serve the veteran in the
field.
We cannot,
after careful study see any possible tiein with,
if you please,
1.7 per cent rejects or mistakes,
with
better than 700 brand new cases arising from deaths every day,
with every amended or every new case.
After all of the laborious process of weighing the case,
we don't believe that we should have to say, "There will be a
minimum of 21 days before we can do anything about it.
We
can't answer your question before that time.
We can't tell
you where it is or the date you are going to get your check."
In effect, we can't render advice to the veterans at the
Veterans Administration and in the 12 years I have been privileged to come here,
I have had nothing that has shaken the
confidence of the general public and the veterans and their
dependents in the Veterans Administration,
and in the service
officers
themselves
than
has
this
ADP
program.
It
does
not
render equivalent service to the old system.
It can never
render equivalent service,
and if The American Legion accepts
anything less than equivalnt or better service for the veteran,
then,
as Earl said to begin with, we ought to close up the
store and go home.
We are here to serve veterans and this
program will not serve them with the efficiency that the previous program would.
the
We in Georgia belive
quicker,
the better.
that
it
ought
to
be
abolished
and
MR. BLALOCK (NORTH CAROLINA):
If you will look you will
find that North Carolina has about eight
of the questions that
the VA has answered.
They reviewed the entire problem that we
have run into in our Winston-Salem office.
We will not go into
that because we have page after page of explanations as to what
they are trying to do to get rid of these problems.
Suffice
to say, we in North Carolina don't like the system.
The service
has completely broken down,
as far as the service officer is
concerned.
I think many of the things that have been
answered
here in much detail explain why we take exception.
We
have
seen
the
improved
48
procedures
at
work.
They
do
get
them paid occasionally and they do help to some extent.
I do
want to cite a few figures that we are running into in our
own individual office.
Before conversion to ADP we had one
GS-4 working half-time handling every payment.
He worked halftime.
We had between 150
and 200 overpayment-accounts outstanding.
As of February 23, 1961, we had 1,046 overpayment
accounts outstanding.
At one time we had up in our correction
room, and that is about all you can call it, 14 people working
up there to make this ADP work,
seven of these at one time
were our top-flight adjudicators.
No wonder we have a backlog
in adjudication.
At the present time, we still have four of our top-flight
adjudicators trying to make ADP work.
The number of people
working in adjudication at the present time, is 88 as compared
to 78 we had before all this started.
At one time, we had a
28.6 work day backlog in adjudication.
After spending 11,000
overtime manhours to get to this particular point, we are still
6.8 days behind in adjudication.
I wish we had time to go
into individual cases,
but we want to talk about the general
over-all picture and I would like to give the floor to Colin
McKine from North Carolina and let him discuss the over-all
economy and service in North Carolina.
MR. MCKINNE (NORTH CAROLINA):
My remarks in many respects are really to reinforce or substantiate
the remarks by
my collegue from Georgia.
Last October
the then Administrator
of the Veterans' Affairs, Mr. Whittier,
came down to North
Carolina in the regional office there at Winston-Salem.
He
seemed quite surprised at the position which we took concerning
ADP,
1 would like to say that, frankly,
1 do not think Mr.
Whittier
action
in
was
fully
informed
or
the
field
until
visited
he
had
full
our
knowledge
of
the
re-
office.
At that time, I discussed the over-all aspects of ADP
with him and he agreed with me that what we are after, basically,
is efficiency.
By nature and by my own individual training and
formal education,
I am sympathetic to any system which will
improve any administrative operation.
He agreed with me that
efficiency
could
be
brown
into
two
factoss.
One was
economy
of
operation and the other was quality of service.
Certainly,
when we are dealing with human beings and veterans,
and even
more important,
the confidence of those veterans,
the quality
of service is the most important of these two factors.
Mr.
Whittier conceded this.
I then proceeded to point out to him
that a standard for the service would be service definitely
which is no less or no worse than the service we enjoyed under
our then existing system,
our former system
of payment.
To
this he agreed.
We showed him then conclusively that ADP not only is not
as good, but is much worse,
and at that time we could show no
real improvement in the quality of service.
As for economy of
operation,
I had then seen
no figures on what was anticipated
through economy.
Mr. Whittier gave me no information and I
expected no detailed information from him, and I gave him questions and these questions prompted the meeting with Mr. Whittier,
and a written statement.
I was surprised to get a reply to my question:
''When
can we expect to be as economical and efficient as under the
mechanized system?"
Im part,
I say compare the two
systems on
-49
the
basis
of
economics.
Since the 18 pieces of 1960 legislation are already introduced,
the aging veteran population increased and with economic conditions such as they were, we experienced a workload
increase.
All of these things were fully known before ADP was
initiated
and
forced
into
these
other
offices.
Mr. Teague stood in this room a year ago, and told us
they expected Public Law 86-211 to be passed.
The Veterans
Administration,
so far as I can tell, completely ignored what
was coming and forced this thing through,
anyway.
They then
come along and compare the two things in their economic study.
The thing, as I have seen it, is giving us no better quality
of service.
As I see it, there is no economy of operation.
We in North Carolina agree with Georgia.
We do not think the
system will work and frankly, we are sick and tired of it.
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Thank
you.
Mr.
Dixon,
MR. DIXON (FLORIDA:
I think I probably stand here in a
rather confused state.
I have the greatest respect for my
friend,
Bill Driver.
I don't want ito say this, but I am of
the opinion that a lot of the decisions made in CO that I have
been involved in the Florida office have been based on figures
that I don't see how they can be substantiated.
Certain figures for Florida and the ones I have made do not coincide.
I will cite only
one example.
You
can
take
the
contact control
point.
They
keep
score
two ways, cases under seven days and cases over seven days.
They will
tell you it takes an average time of six days to get
an answer from Chicago.
My own figures show it takes an
average of 16 to 18 days to get an answer from Chicago.
I know
when you get to arguing these things based on what you have,
you run into a bunch of @obwebs that will drive you crazy. I
can't see why there is such a differnce.
What I can't seem
to get from the Veterans Administration any more is an honest
answer.
Let me give you something that I have happened to
steal.
This is how tough it is to get things these days.
This is for the week of January 3, 1961.
Inquiries less than
7 days 146, over seven days, 271; delays 1-2 months 56,
over
two months,
166.
This doesn't average 6 days.
To me it is
information that you can't get, it seems, for the men who rely
on the Veterans Administration for it.
Let me talk about the process that takes place up to the
time the award is to be paid.
The only information we get is
regarding ''pay rejects"
Nobody will tabulate these 7,000 to
8,000 6560's
that are coming into Florida every month that
somebody has to go over.
You go through this God-awful thing,
this long sheet of paper;I see 6 or 7 people trying to figure
out just exactly why this thing has been sent back,
so I say
to you, there is quite a delay in adjudication and I will say
to you also that in the finance service there were 3600 6560's
on accounts receivable that somebody had to go over. There is
no work measurement
to do this.
There are no people assigned
in any finance division to do this work.
They seem to do it in
their space time.
You can talk to people at the VA supervisory level and
it seems we receive the pat story that the situation is improving and it is going to work, but when you talk to people on the
50
rating boards,
invariably they will tell you it takes from
10:to 20 percent
longer to rate the case.
.You talk to authorizing people and they tell you it takes 30 per cent longer to
authorize a case.
I am not too concerned about the checks.
You can pay them thru the KKK as far as I am concerned.
I
don't know, but I feel that the luck will change.
What I am
concerned about is the guy who doesn't get his check,
I can't
even get a case file sometimes because you have so many of
them stacked up around the Veterans Administration
that it
takes these people from 30 to 40
days to secure the files
from
the
Veterans
We
have
appeals
that
Administration.
numerous
have
to
veterans
wait
coming
there
for
4
into
or
5
our
office
hours
and
on
have
to
go home without a hearing.
If it is in the ADP control he has
marked his time, because we can't pull them out of this thing
and talk to people.
You say you have no measuring point. We
do
have.
I
can
take
you
into
my
own
shop.
take care of check inquiries in my shop.
a half people following up on checks.
One
Now,
person
we
used
to
two
and
have
There is no doubt in anybody's mind that you can make
this work if you spend enough money and sacrifice enough veterans,
This may be the thing that will eventually work,
but
whether or not we can stand it is the question,
I have had
people come to me and say, "What is The American Legion going
to do about this?"
And I am talking about people in the
Veterans Administration.
You have beaten the people to death
and I say to you that no one has worked any harder than the
people in VA.
They have worked Saturday and Sunday and spent
11,000 in overtime since January 1.
We have cooperated.
We
have been apologizing around the country for the Veterans
Administration.
We just can't do it any more because we are
getting into irouble.
We heard here today about a report that was made by the
Veterans Administration itself in reference to ADP.
I understand one went to the Administrator and because the report was
not favorable,
it was rejected and another report was ansked
for.
I would like some
comment on this particular question.
take
MR.
MERIFIELD.
MR.
DRIVER:
On
your
question,
it
is
Mr.
Driver,
the
question
there
of
was
a
the
report,
report.
I
and
this
assume
I
you
are referring to the one covering the survey which was made
by the Administrator's staff on ADP, -- the one we have been
discussing this morning having to do with regional office payments.
There was only one evaluation.
The report itself
actually came from a number of drafts from a number of people
who participated in the avuluation.
So far as I know,
there
was only one report and I am happy to hear you say it was
favorable.
Frankly,
I must say I think the report in many
areas is properly critical.
I would also like to say while I have the opportunity
that I would like to stress myself,
the point you made about
the cooperation of The American Legion and other veterans’
organizations,
We are quite proud of the fact that you have
done this and we thank you.
At
of
the
the
same
regional
time,
office
I
must
personnel
51
acknowledge
have
been
too,
that
Herculean.
the
efforts
I
think
they do deserve the praise you have given them.
At the risk
of perhaps overburdening the subject,
I would like to join in
this.
I am happy
to work with people who are as dedicated as
these people are.
I must underline the fact, however,
that the
workload which they have encountere this past year is not
strictly the result of ADP.
It is
the result of everything
else which has been discussed here this morning.
We have had
more legislation in this past year than in the previous seven
years.
A lot has been said from the standpoint of overpayments.
You realize,
of course, many of these overpayments existed in
the records at the time of the conversion,
but were unknown
to any of us.
We discovered them because of the ADP system -=
and this is an advantage.
They must be recognized and dealt
with and we hope to keep them under control.
We believe in the system or we would not be
The question gets down to a discussion of whether
tremely high speed system is adequate in terms of
the veteran.
We want the veteran to have all the
may need that is relevant.
trying it.
this exservice to
data that he
MR. DIXON:
With respect to the report that I am referring to, I have heard rumors floating around,
and this is why I
asked my question,
that it was originated by some guy named
Riley and it went to the Administrator and he said that there
was too much adverse stuff,
Take it back.
Work on it some more.
This is what I wanted.
MR. DRIVER:
Frank Reilly was the director of the staff
which prepared the report that was referred to this morning.
As one of the staff he made his own studies in his particular
area
just
like
the
other
members.
I
presume
he
prepared
drafts
and may have discussed this with the Administrator,
but the
report,
and the only report I know of, is the one we made
available to your organization -- the report confronting the
new Administrator of Veterans' Affairs.
Frank Reilly was in a
large measure responsible for the report
.
Frank Reilly is the
man and that is the rfport.
There may have been several drafts
of the
report.
I
I would
hope
they
assume
they were
would
be.
Just
for a trial, you
You do your best
thing.
And this
start out and rewrite over and over again,
to make sure
that you have identified everyis how we get the report we have.
reviewed
ana reported
as a lawyer
prepares
a
out,
brief
MR. BLALOCK:
The statement was made here that we should
compare what we were getting to what we have under ADP.
In our
regional office, we had an average of some 20 check inquiries
a month before ADP.
Since this system went into effect we had
1,107 in October,
in November,
671,
in December,
568,
and in
February 308.
Those are the figures as of February 23.
I
have figures for the same months
that were given to me in
December and they are not the same figures.
Both were given to
me by the VA.
MR. DRIVER:
In the area of where the veteran says,
"I
don't get my check," or "I got it in the wrong amount," -- Before ADP there was no attempt made to count the inquiries in
this area.
I know that inquiries regarding checks and amounts
were handled in various divisions of the regional offices before
conversion to ADP, mostly in the finance activity.
They still
52
are in non-conveted stations.
One figure that we do
know,
that bears directly on inquiries is the fact that there were
more than 30,000 address changes put into the ADP system last
month,
The figures I just gave you showed the decline.
I
indicated that insofar as figures since ADP, in converted
accounts we had a high of 21,000 in the month of September
and it was down in February to 10,000.
This is the reason why
I say wei are improving ana:1 think this will work,
MR. DIXON:
In Florida, we get about 3,000 changes of
address a month.
There are about 5,000
laying there to be
transferred after ADP freeze.
We have these case files which
have to be moved from Florida to somewhere else,
With the
average number of employees
that you have today to transfer
file cases it would take three years.
You are getting current
and vou
are getting improvement.
Have you taken a good look at your diary system?
In
Florida, we got current last month.
I know also that the diary
system increased from 2500
to 6,000.
I found a lot ot it down
there.
MR.
DRIVER:
A
lot
of
work
naturally
results
in
a
aiary.
MR. DIXON:
[It is still-pending..
1 say it looks to
like you in the VA have used every means available to you
put us in a position where we have to buy this ADP.
This
resent,
MR. . DRIVER:
1 think, Mr. Dixon, we are
every effort to make this work and I am happy
we have done everything we possibly can to do
MR.
MERIFIELD:
As
MR.
PEFLEY
as
we
are
concerned,
forth
you say
is
the
Are
there
any
of
those
on
the
floor
who
(OREGON):
I am
rather
green
as
far
as
end of the questions.
care to discuss this?
far
putting
to hear
so.
me
to
I
that
this
service work is concerned,
but I do know something about the
mechanics of the thing.
Nothing has been said
so far about
the mechanical errors running into the system.
I visited a
regional office where they are simulating ADP ana I ran a program on the flexowriters.
It is my understanding under the
program the flexowriters
are to prepare the data to go into
the
computer.
You
are
supposed
to
be
able
to
run
the
tape
back
through the machine and it would write out the same as you put
in it in the first place.
There were three flexowriters
and
not a one of them could do it.
If that is so, we are going to
be fouled up in
the pure mechanical stage from here on out.
There is also one of these overlays to attempt to read it.
I
am told by those in the office there that it takes anywhere
from two to four hours to run it down, and then they just give
up because they can't find anything wrong,
so it must be purely
mechanical error again.
Nothing
machine.
has
been
said
so
MR. DRIVER:
TI am sure
could make suggestions as to
improved -- our training and
We
do
have
all
the
far
about
the
purely
mechanical
that you all are interested
how you think this ought to
conversion of the system to
flexowriter
53
equipment
available
in
and
be
ADP.
local
offices to prepare the punch tapes and when the time comes to
convert,
the operators will be properly trained.
We are very
much aware of the fact that the in-put data is the key to the
successful operation of this whole thing.
The fact is the number of transaction rejections has declined just as rapidly as
the pay rejects,
The same is {rue of all the other areas
where rejection have occurred.
The question of mechanical
error in the tape is absolutely de minimis.
I don't know that
you want to get into a technical discussion of how this
works.
I think the best possible answer would be for all of you interested in this to visit a regional office and sit down and
go through the steps with the service officers at the converted
station,
and I would hope that they would testify to the fact
that the ability of the personnel to handle this has improved
along
with everything else.
that
MR.
were
PEFLEY:
Don't these flexowriters
put in there in the first place?
put
in
the
errors
MR. DRIVER:
If the operator is beginning to learn he
might make errors.
But we would not expect him to write the
errors in.
1f you type an ®a’- into the thing and vou mean to
type an l'o!, you are going to get an "al out.
MR. PEFLEY:
@ don't seem to have made my point clear.
At the same time,
the machine punches a punch it also types
a copy so you can see what has been written,
and it is the same
thing you have typed in the first place.
with
MR. DRIVER:
Then,
the equipment.
MR.
PERLEY:
"YT
there
is
so,
too.
think
abviously
MR. DRIVER:
I don't agree with that
haven't had the benefit of operation yet.
has gone in and they have been maintaining
have done very
well.
something
wrong
as a whole.
You
The Friden Company
them and I think
MR. MERIFIELD:
Several of the fellows have brought up
this question of inaccurate statistics.
I thought I would
like to quote you one sentence from this evaluation report.
Several of you have mentioned what appears to be a conflict in
the statistics that you get.
In this summary of ADP you have
a sentence which reads:
"One of the important objectives of
conversion to ADP, accuracy of statistical records,
has not
been realized.
MR. WOODS:
(ARIZONA)
I would like to make one or two
comments on ADP,
something which you fellows have gone
through,
and that is with respect to the interim file, which is a nice
way of saying,
"Send this back to the file room until we can
take: a. ilook at it.
sent
We have found cases that have already
back into the interim file with action
This
we
have
corrected,
but
we
can
only
been rated benefits
to put it in ADP.
correct
those
that
have
come to our attention.
Very recently I received power of
attorney from our service officer
in Dallas.
It was stamped
in the regional office,
"August 8, 1960," and went to the
interim file.
This was an original claim for service connection.
On February 6, the Phoenix regional office made the
54
original request for military records.
They
on that claim when it was filed in August of
direet result of ADP.
have
MR.
gone
MERIFIELD:
Your
into the interim
point
file,
MR.
DRIVER:
say
1
would
took no action
1960.
This is
is that claim
I think.
more
than
never
a
should
that.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Mr. Driver made a statement
in which he
used the example of an office prior to conversion not having
its own finance office.
A representative of the Washington
central office was in L.A. not long ago, and
made the statement
that he loves offices that do not have finance offices,
because
this type of station gets better service under ADP.
Coming
from
coming
such
a
from
station,
such
a
would
you
care
MR. WOOD:
There has been a
months ago.
There is no question
been working overtime.
They have
long
some
to
comment
on
that,
you
station?
as I can
remember
on this
improvement,
but
I cannot
change from what we saw two
of that.
The people have
been working Saturdays and
problem,
say
it
and so there
has
been
compares
favorably
to
the old system.
We used to be able to get checks out in five
to seven days in the ordinary case and the hardship case in
two or three days.
The ordinary check was knocked out in about
seven days.
Now, I would say 30 days.
The thing has been so
complicated and so disastrous as far as Service Officers are
concerned,
that I also started a crash program to solve the
inquiries
that
you
get
the
first
of
every
month
and
I
started
this the first of February.
I don't write your check.
I wish
I did.
I would write you one right now.
Go see the VA.
Write
a letter to Barry Goldwater.
Write the President,
write to
anybody about your troubles, because I am sick of them.
MR.
KLEMMETSON
(Washington):
I come
from
a state,
Conners,
Minnesota,
where we teach our boys football and to respect the
name of the first President of the United States.
Two years
ago, I had an opportunity to teach a little history to the
Department of Wisconsin,
and some history to the Department of
Minnesota.
Now, going back to the question,
I think we all
agree that we are not getting any place.
We agree that ADP
does not work.
So the only thing here is a resolution.
I
would like to suggest that you bring out the problem before the
Resolutions
Committee.
:
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
I would like to suggest to the Conference that we not entertain any resolutions at this moment.
I would like to suggest that you withhold any recommendation or
resolution.
We must stop in ten minutes.
If you will indulge
me to that extent,
I will be grateful,
MR.
KLEMMETSON:
I
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Is
bow
to
there
the
wisdom
further
of
the
Chairman.
discussion?
MR. YOUNG (VERMONT):
I, too, come from a small station in
northern New England, where current payments are paid out of
Boston.
Presently all of our awards are still being paid from
Boston, but we have a very few death cases that are in the system -- only 16 or 17.
However,
the point I want to emphasize
is this, and we are back to service now,
If someone comes to
5
me now and asks about an award or when he can get
his check,
and bear in mind that the payment is made from
Boston,
I get
an answer for them within a very reasonable length of time,
if
it is paid from Bostonm but if someone comes to me and asks
me about a missing check in the system,
I am lost.
A widow,
when she first went into the system lived in Chester, Vermont
and her check was not received at the end of the month.
Her
daughter happened to be teaching my child in another town.
It
took
seven
her
checks
months
kept
to
get
going
to
this
case
straightened
Chester,
out
because
Virginia.
Somebody suggested we make a change of address and I said,
"Heavens
, no.
They will be sending it to Chester Gunsmoke."
In the meantime,
my boy's marks were going down, but when I
finally got this straightened out,
they started going up.
the
had
MR. BLALOCK:
This is one that the ADP knows
Treasury Department knows about.
The lady for
her checks addressed to Mrs. Silas City, Silas
North
Carolina.
said it was
and someone
After
four
months
and
telephone
and
months
calls
they
going to be right.
They made
the September
check
took it -we returned this check twice -- and
stuck
the woman's
ed this September
name down
on the front
of
check
back
to her,
and the
the same thing on it.
I am going to
Silas City.
That case
was too much.
case and the service officer wrote a
you have the poem.
Do you know that
woman in January under Appendix 07?
don't buy it.
the
four
about
seven
City,
MR. MERIFIELD:
Anyone
suggestion was made that
Date
affixed
and
$90.00
For
a
And
a piece of green
72,058
that can be
is
is
January
added
the
widow
seen,
31,
1961
for
fun.
just
in red there appears
this does add to our
while
Cora:B.
change her name to Mrs.
We have had this same
little poem.
Mr. Wilenski,
they still had to pay the
If that is service,
I just
else?
He mentioned the poem and
it would be polite to read it.
Enclosed is
With number
Circled
My, how
the
envelope,
mailcheck still
had
a name
fame
got
checks
our
faith
have
to
start
and
play
in
as
Haith
that
did
restore
It
looks
like
we
Or
go
join
the
VA
all
the
over
clover.
MR. DIXON:
I am sure that everybody up here from a conveted station has a big file on what is the situation with
reference to ADP.
Down in area C there was a recommendation
made in refernce to the automatic processing system.
I just
wonder when the representatives of the committee meet whether
it might be a good idea to thrash out that point as to what
we in The Legion are going to do rather than digging it out on
the floor right here.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
I
believe
that
the
proper
procedure
will be to present it to the Recommendations Committee, which
is a subcommittee of the Rehabilitation Committee.
I would
hope that the Recommendations Committee would give careful
NN
56
consideration to the thoughts expressed of the problem and that
they would attempt to bring forth a resolution to this Conference that is in keeping with the thoughts and wishes of all
the delegates,
you men who have the greatest knowledge of the
problem.
If you have
Committee so that
they will act on.
a recommendation give it
they may have a specific
to the Resolutions
resolution which
MR. EGAN (Delaware):
I just want to refer to the remarks of Bill concerning
the decision which has been made at
many of these previous Conferences and that the Veterans Administration concurred in, to adjudicate claims in the area of
residence
of
the
beneficiary.
Two
years
ago,
they
froze
the
transfer of claims and you can look at the panel that sits in
front of you and every member of that panel has had communications from me
because claims that belong in Delaware are
handled in their office as jurisdiction has been assigned there
by the central office.
I have just received correspondence from a claimant for
whom I filed a claim last February.
He told me in
answer to
a letter that I wrote him in November that when he finally
located his folder he found it went to adjudication in October.
1 want to thank Leo in the Detroit Office for an answer in
Delaware.
The claimant is from Delaware.
MR.
anything
MERIFIELD:
else
to
offer?
MR.
DRIVER:
No,
MR.
MERIFIELD:
Mr.
Driver,
we
are
Thank
do
you
or
your
people
have
finished.
you,
gentlemen.
We
appreciate
very much your coming and explaining ADP from your viewpoint,
and we have had the opportunity to give our impression of it
from
the
delegates
that
are
here,
and
we
hope
that
along the line, we can have a reconciliation of
Mr. Driver informs me that they have prepared a
they have given you this morning.
With
that,
I
will
turn
the
podium
back
to
somewhere
these viewpoints.
handout of what
you,
Clarence
Horton.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Before we close,
I want to thank the
participants on this panel.
I heard a story about a gentleman
of the Jewish faith who was asked about the death of his wife.
He was asked what was the cause of her death and his reply
was, "She died of improvement."
He was asked, "How?"
He replied,
"Every time I called the hospital and asked about her I
was told she was improving;
so I think she died of improvement."
Let us hope that there is not a parallel situation here.
mm
—————
Announcements
=-=====-
CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
Thank you very much,
Clarence and
gentlemen of the panel.
That completes the session for this
morning,
and please be in your seats promptly at 1:30 this
afternoon.
«
vene
at
« o At 11:30 a. m. the conference
1:30ip., m. the same day.
. .
57
recessed,
to
recon-
the
Due
the
The Veterans Administration has supplied the answers to
following questions which were submitted for discussion.
to time limitations
these questions were not reached on
regular agenda.
ADP
QUESTIONS
AND
ANSWERS
For more logical discussion,
questions and answers have
assembled by category of subject matter and arranged as
SUBJECT
QUESTION
Expedited
Processing
SRE
UE
Y6,:10
Hardship
Payments
15,11,
Transfers
Insurance
General
20,
Premiums
NO.
SRG
PR
Lr aN
4
21.22
16
Interest
ok
58
Firiel
9,2 8
E13
13,
been
follows:
A.
L.
Blalock
NATIONAL
REHABILITATION
-
Carolina
Loyd
V.
Q.
What can be done about getting expeditious
processing of the award through ADP System
Awards
a
North
CONFERENCE
leaving
minimum
through
of
the
the
North
Carolina
twenty-one
system
in that minimum
complication in
or is rejected,
days.
days
and
ADP
checks
time,
if
Chicago.
there is
they
No.5
action for the
in Chicago?
Office
can
issued,and
1961
Question
Regional
before
-
get
this
require
processed
happens,
only
the award does not run
into some
If it runs into a complication
further delay for as much as ninety
Time lags which occur in our over-all processing are considered our most significant problem at the present time.
This is a serious problem to us
not only because of its
obvious influence on service but also because of its effect
on all types of transactions.
It is
also a basic cause of
our inquiry workload.
We are concentrating our efforts in this area.
steps we are taking to solve this comprehensive
include:
Specific
problem
a.
Intensive study of data flow,
both regional offices and the
b.
Preparation of simplified procedures
and organizational
changes designed to bring about better coordinated efforts in processing ADP input,
inquiries,
rejects and
other feedback information as well as Changes of Address
and Returned Checks.
c.
Clarification
instructions.
d.
Improvement in data transmission between regional
offices and the Data Processing Center and between
Treasury
and the veteran.
e.
Continued and more intensive training
and Data Processing Center personnel.
of
computer
inclusing controls,
in
Data Processing Center.
writeouts
and
of
their
related
regional
office
We have found that the time-lag between completion of authorization action and dispatch of the check has been aggravated somewhat by increased workloads.
However, by concentrating on procedural and control problems we are confident
that our over-all processing will be speeded up considerably.
With any new system such as ADP,
there is a tendency to overcontrol at first - then as experience is gained you find
that some of the time-consuming controls and procedural
steps can be eliminated.
For example -
All
transactions
are
submitted
to
the
Data
Processing
Center under what we call an "ADP Transmittal Control
Sheet."
Each day's transactions consist of awards which
are punched into paper tape and various code sheets
including
those
for
changes
of
adaress,
all
included
on
ADP
Transmittal
Control
Sheet.
total
are
one
computed
on
rates,
59
dates,
and
of
C-number
which
are
Control
for
all
items on the ADP Transmittal Control Sheet sent to the
data Processing Center.
These figures not only have to
be computed and balanced at the regional office but also
at the Data Processing Center.
Also, whenever a single
transaction covered by the ADP Transmittal Control Sheet
is rejected at the Center,
the figures must be
re-computed and balanced.
We now believe that it may be possible to simplify the control procedure and save time at both the regional offices
and the Data Processing Center.
We feel that equal benefits
will be achieved from our efforts to improve data flow, data
transmission,
instructional material and training of personnel.
At the present time the post-adjudicative process in regional offices is taking about 5 days;
transmission to the
Data Processing Center is averaging 2 days; processing at
the Data Processing Center is completed in approximately
9 days; and operations at the Treasury Department require
2 days.
Considering the improvements
that already have
been made and those which we anticipate in the next several
months
we
feel
sure that
we
can
reach
our
"interim
Post-ad judicative processing
Transmission
DPC processing
Treasury operations
2
1.5
4.5
2
goal"
of-
days
days
days
days
The problem of ''rejects'" has been substantially lessened
in the past two months.
First,
the number of award actions
which cannot be processed for payment has dropped sharply.
Second,
the time required to return rejected transactions
to regional offices has been reduced.
office processing for resubmission has
Third, regional
been facilitated
by improving the :messages'" used by the Data Processing
Center to indicate the reason why the transaction was rejected.
All three of these contribute toward expected
final action.
As an added safety factor, where the Manager
feels that immediate payment should be made, he is authorized to pay any amounts currently due on rejected cases
through the use of our '"hardship'" procedure.
Loyd
V.
Q.
What can be done about getting adjustment checks for cases
converted from the old pension law to PL 86-211 or adjustment checks due retroactively for hospitalization,
or increase in compensation for addition of dependents,
etc.,?
This
Blalock
type
-
of
North
Carolina
adjustment
often
ADP
takes
Question
three
and two or three different awards as the
quite often rejects not once but twice.
to
No.
2
four
months
original
award
Most of the problem cases in these areas arose when the
action which should have created an adjustment check occurred
during conversion,
This was especially true with PL 86-211
elections at those stations which converted last July.
Practically all of our former conversion difficulties have
been identified and corrected.
However, we know that there
is still a hard core of problem cases.
However,
if you
feel:
that we are overlooking any of these,
you can help by
bringing
them to our attention.
60
ADP
Question
No.2
Processing
time-lags
difficulties
have
where
been some
have been
adjustment
procedural
responsible
checks
changes,
are
and
for
some
of
involved.
some
our
There
refinement
in
the Bata Processing Center operations,
but the biggest contribution toward overcoming the problem has been the experience gained in regional offices.
There is a much
better understanding of how awards are prepared, but we recognize the need for a more intensified training program.
There has also been the problem of accepting cases which
contain discrepant data.
The program changes whereby we
accept for payment those cases which contain identification
of the veteran, his address,
the rate and its effective
date have done much to minimize the problem.
Lloyd
Q.
V.
-
North
Carolina
ADP
Question
No.3
What can be done about getting dependent parents paid where
the veteran is hospitalized and the dependent parent is receiving an apportioned share?
We have had to resort to
special procedures,
including Appendix 0, on numbers of
these cases to get them paid one time, and then the next
month they still were not in the system and did not receive
their checks;
therefore, we had to resort to Appendix 0 procedure for the second month.
Very often, we have had to
have
A.
Blalock
these
dependent
as
four
months
At
this
time
we
mothers
or
under
Appendix
know
of
no
fathers
paid
for
as
much
O.
general
difficulty
being
ex-
perienced in processing apportioned awards to dependent
parents.
If you are still having problems with specific
cases in this area we would appreciate your identifying
them for us so we can straightened them out.
Individual
cases may involve difficulties other than programming.
The difficulties which we experienced in handling
cases were primarily due to programming problems.
programming changes have resulted in the solution
problems,
and as far as we know,
our programs are
of handling all types of apportioned cases.
apportioned
Recent
of these
capable
A.
V.
9
Q.
Why does the VA consider that the ADP method is better, when
everything being equal,
it takes a minimum of twenty-one
days more before the widows and orphans receive
their checks?
A.
: The VA certainly would not try to tell anyone that the ADP
method was better if it took a minimum of 21 days more before beneficiaries receive a check.
We know that processing ‘times vary from office to office,
and even by cases
within an office.
We, too, have seen many figures quoted
as representative of processing times.
But the importaat
thing is that we are not satisfied with any of these figures
and will not be satisfied until we reach the timeliness
goals established for our ADP system.
Frank
Q.
Akin,
C.
The
Jr.
-
Georgia
Bottigliero
time
limit
on
ADP
Illinois
a
cycle
61
ADP
at
the
Question
No.
Question
Automatic
Data
No.
14
Processing
ADP
Question
No.
14
(Cont'd)
Center should be 48 hours, but it varies from one week to
14 days.
Is anything to be done to comply with the oeiginal intent?
In our ADP procedures we repeatedly refer to '"bi-daily"
processing.
By this we mean that every two days (or 48
hours) we will introduce into the computer all transactions
that have been received and are ready for processing.
This
should not be confused with the total time required to
process a transaction.
The Data Processing Center is now
introducing transactions into the computer on a bi-daily
basis.
However, because of operations required before and
after
computer
Data
Processing
processing
Center
Our interim goal is to
Data Processing Center
Frank
Q.
C.
Bottigliero
-
the
will
over-all
normally
process all
within four
Illinois
time
exceed
required
48
transactions
and one half
ADP
Question
at
the
hours.
through
(4-1/2)
No.
the
days.
17
What,
it anything,
is going to be done to improve and expedite the 6560
form received at the Regional Office from
Center following transaction?
The time required to produce and forward VA Forms 20-6560
to regional offices has been reduced in the past two months,
and will continue to bé improved as we progress with the
plans we outlined in answering Question No. 5,
for expediting the processing of all types of transactions.
In addition we have a specific project underway to expedite
transmission of VA Forms 20-6560
to regional offices,
to
improve the legends which appear on this form,
to clarify
our instructions for interpreting them, and to simplify the
processing actions which should result from receipt of the
VA Forms 2066560.
For the February processing cycles,
eight shipments of Forms
6560
were made to field stations.
These shipments were
dispatched from the DPC on January 26 and 28, February 6,
30, 11,715
and "18,
Frank
Lloyd
Q.
C.
V.
Bottigliero - Illinois
Blalock - North Carolina
What can be done to
cessed into the ADP
month's check to go
ADP
Question
No.
1
expedite a change of address being prosystem in order to permit the following
out to the correct address on time?
The "Change of Address' has always been a document deserving
special attention.
The problems that have been associated
with it for many years have been highlighted by the advent
of ADP.
However, we are not content to live with them.
We
are examining every facet of the change of address procedure
in a determined effort to speed up their processing.
Here
a.
are
some
of
the
areas
In the regional office,
permitting transmission
62
receiving
we
of
special
have speeded up
certain address
attention:
processing
changes to
by
the
a.
Data Processing Center without reference to the claims
folder.
This eliminates the time required to pull,
review and refile the folder.
We will expand this method
as far as we can.
Also,
the simplification of the
transmittal control we mentioned before,
could further
reduce processing time.
b.
We are working closely with the Treasury Disbursing
Office to get addresses changed up to
as close to the
mailing of the check as possible.
Just this past month
procedures were changed at the Data Processing Center.
All address changes received near the end of the month
are now processed ahead of everything else and gummed
labels are sent to Treasury for redirecting the check
envelope.
The recent installation of a computer in the
Disbursing Office opens up new possibilities for improvement in this area.
We are determined that nothing
will be overlooked.
¢c.
We have found that the Post Office is as anxious as we
to resolve this long-standing problem.
Jointly we hope
to expand and expedite the exchange of information and
are exploring other means of expediting delivery of
checks.
One of these might be a method by which the
Post Office could be advised when a change of address
is received immediately after Treasury has released a
check.
Despite repeated attempts in the past to inform our beneficiaries as to what to do when they move,
they still fail to
notify the VA and many write to the Treasury to have their
address changed.
But we will try again.
We are planning an
intensified public-education program stressing the need for
promptly
notifying
both
serve
veteran
can
the
believe
We
results
address
ceive,
not
but
Lloyd
Blalock
Q.
V.
that
only
also
the
help
our
VA
and
the
in
this
regard.
Post
across-the-board
Office.
efforts
will
All
who
bring
in expediting the processing of changes
reducing the number of inquiries we now
of
re-
-
6
North
Carolina
ADP
Question
No.
What can be done about getting expeditious replies to check
inquiries?
When the Automatic Data Processing System was
established the accredited representatives were promised
three days'
service on check inquiries.
We consider ten
days now a speedy reply.
Sometimes it takes sixty days or
longer to get an answer that will really tell us anything.
We recognize the problem which exists in the inquiry area
but believe it is
possible ultimately to meet the originally
established three day standard for receipt of replies from
the Data Processing Center.
One of the basic problems in this area is the need for complete training of all field station personnel so they can
correctly interpret information which is available to them
within the station.
We must also assure that essential
information is available to them for interpretation.
Our
objective was, and still is, to make the claims folder self
sufficient insofar as providing all basic and essential
63
information
concerning
the
individual
beneficiary.
We
are
making every effort to insure that needed training and
information is furnished,
the meaning of documents is
clarified,
and that essential documents are filed in the
claims folders promptly.
When this is done, a much larger
number of inquiries will be promptly resolved and answered
in the regional offices.
For those inquiries which require information from the Data
Processing Center or the Chicago Regional Disbursing Office,
substantial improvements have been mand are continuing to
be made.
Specifically,
we have refined the processing of
inquiries at the Data Processing Center by a.
Establishing a permanently staffed Inquiry Unit to replace the previously temporarily detailed employees.
b.
Increasing
productivity
(1)
Intensive
(2)
Making sources
to them.
c.
of
permanent
employees
by
-
training
of
information
more
readily
Using a punch card as basic document throughout
entire Data Processing Center processing.
available
the
Also, we have tested a system to shorten the inquiry message and expedite preparation of the punch-card processing
document and are exploring the possibility of extracting
data from the master record in a form which could be used
to transmit it back to the regional office,
thus reducing
both processing and transmission time.
The comprehensive action we mentioned in answering Question
No. 5 that we are taking steps to solve the '"time-lag'" problem also will improve the inquiry situation.
Improvement
of procedures and simplification of controls in Regional
Offices and the Data Processing Center will reduce processing time,
reduce workloads,
and in turn, reduce the volume
of inquiries,
thus permitting faster processing of those
which are received.
A.
V.
Akin,
Jr.
Georgia
Q.
Why
doesn't
the
when
their
checks
being
returned
their
files
VA
due
they
make
are
to
would
an
effort
ADP
Question
to
locate
No.
10
beneficiaries
returned,
as
some
of
the
checks
errors
the
VA,
and
by
checking
in
are
find this?
On July 26, 1960,
in all-station letter No. 21-15
regional
offices were instructed to review the claims folder whenever the Data Processing Center advised that a check had
been
returned,
many
times
These
instructions
have
been
reiterated
since.
The VA is very anxious to release returned checks that could
not be delivered because of an incorrect address.
In the
past two months changes have been made
which we feel will
make it easier to get these checks to the veteran.
First:
All returned checks are run against
cords as soon as they are received.
64
the master reWhen we find
the
imme-
that a Change of Address was received after
returned check was originally processed, we
diately release it to the new address.
change of address is found we notify
The first such returned check
Office,
If no recent
the Regional
Second:
not
does
re-
effort
"every
to make
told
been
have
the
Instead,
payments.
future
stop
offices
gional
possible to obtain a new address or verify the
existing address" and notify the Data Processing
Center so the check can be released.
If the
address in the claims folder is very close to the
regional office there would be no objection to an
attempt
to
contact
as a general
the payee at
found
Third:
was
the
payee
policy, we
an address
incorrect,
personally.
feel that
which the
would
not
The Treasury Disbursing Office
equipment which caused many of
This will reduce the number of
However,
efforts to reach
Post Office
be
productive.
has replaced its old
the "garbled" checks.
checks returned.
You may be aware of a test that
has just begun whereby the
Treasury Regional Disbursing Office simultaneously notifies
the appropriate regional office and the Data Processing
Center when a check has been returned.
We feel this ad-
vance
to
notice
release
to
the
returned
Bottigliero
-
regional
checks
F.
C.
Q.
What,
if anything,
is
of Appendix 0 cases?
office
much
will
Illinois
ADP
being
make
it
possible
faster.
done
to
Question
improve
the
No.
15
handling
In some cases paid under Appendix 0 we receive a call a
month or so later that a check is not received.
In checking the case, we are advised that an overpayment is being
carried against the veteran. We understand the Regional
Office reports an Appendix 0 payment to the Data Processing
Center as an account receivable,
Why is this necessary?
a.
b.
An overpayment doesn't actually exist.
In some cases,
the 'overpayment' does not get into
the record and duplicate payments are made.
In some cases,
the 'overpayment' gets into the
machine and stops all future payments.
Ch
Why
can't
Data
Processing
the
Regional
Office
Center
pick
pay
up
the
all
back
future
payments
due
and
payments?
The fact that recurring payments are not picked up by the
Data Processing Center after an Appendix 0 payment is made
locally could result from a number of situations all of
which would be caused by erroneous processing.
Usually
in some
awards.
Appendix O
cases they
The
award
payments cover
include current
is
prepared
retroactive amounts but
monthly payments on new
showing
the
effective
date
of entitlement even though:zthe retroactive portion is paid
under Appendix O.
Since the Appendix O payment duplicates
the retroactive portion,
the award is introduced into the
ADP system accompanied by an Accounts Receivable equal to
65
the
are
amount that already has been paid.
If both actions
correctly prepared and submitted together,
the accounts
receivable
will
immediately
amount generated
. payments will be
be
offset
by the computer,
issued.
by
and
the
future
retroactive
recurring
However,
if the accounts receivable is incorrectly prepared
it will not be processed and a check will be issued as
though no Appendix O payment had been made.
When the corrected accounts receivable is resubmitted and processed at
the Data Processing Center the existence of a duplicate
payment will be discovered and an overpayment will be established.
This will,
in turn, be recovered from future
recurring payments.
When the duplicate check is returned,
the amount’ would offset the overpayment and recurring payments would be resumed.
One
other
pared
situation
accounts
could
result
receivable.
If
from
the
an
incorrectly.pre-
duplicate
payment
were
returned and processed by the Data Processing Center before the accounts receivable is corrected and resubmitted,
it could not offset the overpayment because that record
still had not been introduced into the machine.
This
situation would result in the automatic suspension of the
case,
and preparation of a notice to the regional office
which then must investigate the causes and take necessary
action
to
resume
the
proper
payments.
All of these
cessing,
and
provement in
complications can be avoided by proper proour experience to date has shown a marked imthe accuracy of original submissions.
There
reason
is
no
why
the
regional
offices
could
not
make
all back payments including those cases where an award had
already been submitted to the Data Processing Center. However,
the disadvantages in such action mitigate against
such
a
procedure
because
-
ai
The regional office may not know, precisely,
how
much money is due.
Under the present operations the
computer verifies the computations made by the regional office and adjusts the amount due if the
Appendix 0 payments were too much or too little.
b.
If an
award had previously
regional office decided an
in order,
a new award with
would have to be prepared.
been prepared and the
Appendix 0 payment was
the new effective date
Since a concentrated effort is being made to improve workload and processing conditions, we feel that this will produce a greater benefit by eliminating the need for Appendix
0 payments.
A.
V,
Akin,
Jr.
-
Georgia
ADP
Q.
If ADP is to correct all the ills of processing the checks,
then why does the Finance Officer
(Birmingham,
Alabama,
for instance) have to issue a check and send it Air Mail
when we have exhausted every means at our disposal to get
the award paid under extreme hardship conditions?
We
appreciate this being done on new awards-- but why does it
66
Question
No.
11
have
to
taken
as
come
on
to
a
continuing
awards
change-over
under
that
the
have
new
had
no
action
law?
As stated in answering Question No. 15,
when extreme hardship cases are properly prepared and submitted to the Data
Processing Center,
recurring payments will be initiated
and continued.
However,
incorrect processing of these
cases could disrupt the normal routine in which case they
would have to be returned to the regional office for
further action.
A large part of the difficulties we have had in the past
in making initial and recurring payments occurred from
conversion operations,
PL 86-211 elections or a combination of both.
However,
there should be no
difficulty in
these areas now, as we know of no
type of case where payment cannot be made provided it is submitted correctly.
There
ments
have
been
were
a
few
interrupted
which
caused
could
cases
be used to make
but in order to
an
award
a
and
check
an
isolated
because
to
be
cases
returned.
Q.
V.
Blalock
-
accounts
What
can
be
When
we
return
North
done
receivable
Carolina
about
these
recurring
difficulties
Appendix
O
pay-
procedures
an extreme hardship payment in these
reinstitute the recurring payment
submitted to the Data Processing
conditions we feel that the need
ments where there is a recurring
Lloyd
where
of mailing
must
ADP
eliminating
duplicate
be
prepared
and
Center.
Under present
for extreme hardship paypayment should be very rare.
Question
duplicate
payments,
Category 7, sometimes our claimants
of returned checks and it is two or
can get their checks started again.
even
No.
4
payments?
marked
under
are suspended by reason
three months before we
Everyone of the steps we mentioned in answering Question
No. 5 for reducing processing time-lags also will minimize
the possibility of duplicate
checks being issued.
To a large extent duplicate payments resulted from special
procedures
initiated to insure that the beneficiary received
a check.
However,
in some instances they were caused by
failure to "hold" a check which was to have been replaced
by another with a revised amount.
Our present Appendix O procedure permits regional offices
to authorize expedited local payment.
As explained in answering Question No. 15,
it may create a duplicate payment
if not followed properly.
However, precautions have been
taken to insure that the return of a check will not suspend
the ‘account.
The number of duplicate payments released in the last two
months reflect a sharp reduction in problems of this nature.
We feel that as conditions improve and Appendix O payments
are no longer necessary,
it will all but be eliminated.
Reuben
Q.
B.
Garnett
-
Washington
A veteran formerly
being converted to
ADP
Question
No.
20
resided in an area which has been or is
ADP.
Month after month payment
inquiries
67
are necessary in order for him to receive his check. There
is vast and undue delay.
Why can't the Regional Office
having
his
claims
file,
transfer
it
to
having jurisdiction over the area to
This would facilitate setting up his
him paid regularly through the local
the
Regional
Office
which he has moved?
pay card and getting
disbursing office.
We feel that the delays mentioned
‘in this question have
been reduced materially in the past month or two and that
our plans for concentrated action for further improvement
will produce greater benefits than a change in our transfer
policy.
One of the new features under our ADP system is based on
furnishing a Mailing Code which reflects the State and in
some instances the City to which the check is to be
mailed.
This makes it possible for the Disbursing Office to sort
the checks and deliver them to the Post Office in ample
time to assure delivery on the first of the month regardless of how far from Chicago the payee lives.
Under this
coordinated VA-Treasury-Post Office operation,
once a case
has been converted to ADP,
the location of the claims
folder should have no effect on prompt receipt of the check.
There are situations which justify
living-veteran case (see answer to
when
such
a
up for local
System.
case
is
payment
transferred
but
continue
transfer
Question
benefits
to
be
of a
21).
are
made
converted
But even
not
picked
under
the
ADP
Since we have been concentrating on improving the efficiency
of personnel at converted stations, we feel that any action
on a converted case can be handled faster and more accurately
by
Robert
Q.
these
E.
employees.
Wilson
-
Minnesota
ADP
Question
No.
21
Refusal to transfer cases into or out of stations converted
to ADP is working a hardship on veterans who are trying to
dewelop their claims.
It is causing a great increase in work
for Department Service Officers who must review cases at
his station for the benefit ot those in other states, not
to
mention
the
extreme
difficulty
encountered
by
a service
officer trying to develop a case not available for his review.
I was recently notified by an Adjudication Officer
in another state that it was their policy not to advise
out-of-state service officers of action in a case.
How
can I serve the veteransand their dependents of my state if
I am not informed?
I am convinced that considering all
aspects of the problem,
it would be easier and less expensive
to
take
accounts
out
of
ADP,
or
enter
them,
than
to
cope with all of the problems encountered by the refusal
transfer.
Certainly
there should be no freeze on the
transfer of cases not on the payroll.
to
(This question is similar to No. 20.
However,
different and should be commented on).
are
the
facts
In October 1960, we advised all regional offices that
TEMPORARY transfer of claims and XC folders between converted
and non-converted stations was authorized for development of
a case up to the point of actually rating the claim.
(This
68
was
now
contained in our Emergency Interim Issue 20-60
has been incorporated in Appendix J of our ADP
Since
a folder
can
be
made
available
basis for developing a claim,
this
you seek in assisting a veteran.
which
procedures).
on
a temporary
transfer
should
serve
purpose
the
Whenever a service organization has been instrumental in
developing a case our procedures provide that a copy of the
final award or disallowance action be furnished that service
organization.
We believe service otficers can help one
another
in
this
matter
if
the
one
located
having jurisdiction over the folder
the one who helped develop the case
in
the
would send
in another
office
the copy
office.
to
There are no restrictions on the transfer of a folder which
does not contain a claim for Compensation or Pension.
If
you are developing the first such claim,
even though the
veteran may have applied previously for other benefits such
as hospitalization or education,
the claims folder may be
transferred permanently to the office having jurisdiction
over
the
veteranls
address.
However,
if
the
veteran
had
filed,
and his claim was disallowed or terminated,
all the
statistical data relating to that case would be converted
to the ADP system at the same time all the running awards
were converted.
Therefore,
it is essential that such
a
case continue to be processed under ADP requirements primarily because all the basic data already is available and
the case can be processed with far fewer operations than
are
required
to
reopen
a
non-converted
case.
As
stated
in answering Question No. 20, we feel the actions relating
to such a case could be handled better and faster by trained,
experienced personnel at the converted station rather than
transferring it for action at a non-converted station.
Robert
Q.
E.
Wilson
-
Minnesota
ADP
Question
No.
22
The same problems referred
to in
question 21 attend the
jurisdictional rules concerning death cases,
1 am convinced
that we would all benefit by a rule, providing that the
widow is the principal beneficiary,
that the case file be
created in or transferred to the office having
jurisdiction
over her residence;
if there is no widow,
the residence of
the children would control;
and if no children,
the residence of the dependent parents would control.
I realize
that there are cases that involve multiple beneficiaries,
but estimate that those comprise no more than 5% of
the
total number,
It would be a simple matter to notify parents
that a case file has been transferred to the office serving
a widow or children.
In an
agency which boasts of regional
offices to provide service to veterans,
it seems riciculous
that I should have to write The American Legion in San
Francisco so that they could secure the case file to learn
that the Adjudication Officer had requested the Chief
Attorney,
whose office is next door to mine, to determine
whether benefits can be paid to my neighbor on behalf of her
children.
In
why
our
the
answers
transfer
to
Questions
of
C
and
20
XC
and
claims
21
we
outlined
folders
is
the
reasons
restricted.
Our rules for establishing jurisdiction in death cases are
based, primarily,
on the location of the veteran's folder at
69
the time
with the
ferring
of death.
In the majority of cases this coincides
address of the widow.
The restriction on transXC
Folders
of
does
not
duplicate
apply
-
a.
Adjustment
b.
Veterans
c.
K
d.
Benefits
e.
The primary beneficiary has a foreign address.
(Comp.
& Pension Manual 8-1 provides that the WIDOW will be
considered the principal beneficiary,
children are
second and parents follow children).
died
Insurance
in
is
are
claim
when
numbers
is
required.
Service.
active
payable
at
time
of
veteran's
under
US
Code
38,
death.
Section
412.
We expect very shortly,
to look into the possibility of
relaxing restrictions on transferring XC folders decentralized from the Philadelphia District Office since
these
acounts
are
all
converted
and
every
Regional
Office
has some of them.
We are particularly interested in reinstating the policy which would allow transfer of an XC
folder when such action would serve the best interest of
the principal beneficiarye.
Guardianship Folders are always located in the office hav-.
ing jurisdiction over the address of the guardian,
regard-
less
of
location
of
the
claims
that benefits have been
and they reside in your
well to check initially
office.
or XC
folder.
If
you
know
applied for on behalf of children
jurisdiction,
it perhaps would be
with the Chief Attorney in your
As we stated before,
you can now obtain the XC Folder
temporary transfer,
for review and development.
This
allow you to provide the type of service you desire.
Frank
Q.
C.
Bottigliero
-
Illinois
Question
No.
16
What,
if anything,
is being done to improve the handling
insurance deductions with the Automatic Data Processing
Center,
We have seen many cases
cerned in the fact that
made
by
Office
and
since
(This
the adoption by the Automatic
question is also submitted to
Panel).
During
the
cases
heavy
workload
were
stopped
for one
periods
erroneously
of
reason
August
as
a
of
has become confrom compensation
Regional
some
the
where the veteran
he had deductions
this payment stopped
Processing Program.
NSLI
A.
ADP
on
should
and
or
another
September,
by-product
of
special procedures which necessitated payments being made
outside the ADP system.
If these included accounts from
which premiums were being deducted,
suspension of the deduction resulted.
However,
in no case was this allowed to
lapse the insurance policy.
There are slighly under 62,000 accounts at the Data Processing Center from which Insurance Premiums are deducted.
Actions taken as the result of a reconciliation of the
70
Insurance records in Philadelphia and the DVB records at
the Data Processing Center, made at the end of last December,
have resulted in our accounts being brought into complete
agreement.
It was necessary to adjust some amounts during
January but in all of these cases the deductions were reconciled and the
Insurance policies were in full effect.
Robert E. Wilson - Minnesota
Charles A. Zeglin - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Is it possible to include one
that the service organization
present
system
keeping
our
is
causing
Post
and
more copy
can have
an
County
Question
g3
in
two
the flexo so
copies?
The
Officers
informed.
enormous
Service
No.
amount
It would, of course, be possible to produce
of the award letter.
However, we would not
such a step without a thorough study of the
would be achieved.
of
work
in
one more copy
like to take
benefits
that
At present, we buy blank award letters in sets consisting
of an original and 3 copies with carbon paper interleafed.
One of these copies is furnished the service organization
where one is involved.
This type of form is expensive but
since it simplifies the flexowriter operation and saves
the
manhours
forms
required
exactly,
we
to
feel
insert
the
carbon
cost
is
paper
and
align
the
justified.
We do not have specific data which tell us how many of our
actions do or do not require a copy for a service organization. We do
know that by adding one copy of the letter
and
one
piece
of
carbon
paper
to
our
present
sets,
the
cost
would increase by about $6 for every thousand sets purchased.
Before incurring
any additional cost, we would
have to compare this increase with the cost of reproducing
a single copy of award letters only in those cases where
an extra copy is essential.
Collin McKinne- North Carolina
Charles J. Kohler - Pennsylvania
Q.
When
can
we
expect
efficient and
ment System.
In
terms
of
service
economical
speed
and
ADP
under
as
ADP
Question
to
No.
be
at
the
Mechanized
it
is
under
accuracy
of
processing,
that within the next several months,
ADP System should exceed that of the
7
least
we
as
Pay-
anticipate
the efficiency of the
Mechanized Benefit Pay-
ment System.
The current improvements in our processing
time and the planned improvements discussed under Question
5 will make achievement of this goal completely realistic.
One
the
of
the
basic
accuracy
of
purposes
our
of
records,
the
ADP
Because
System
of
the
is
to
increase
computer's
capacity it is
able to perform many more checks than was
possible under the Mechanized Benefit Payment System.
In
addition we now have available statistical information that
is far beyond what was previously recorded.
It is difficult
to compare the two systems on the basis of
""economics' especially since in 1960 18 pieces of legislation were introduced,
the aging veteran population
71
increased,
and economic conditions
experienced a workload increase.
were
such
that
we
We do not have available at this time
the type of cost and
savings data that we feel are necessary and desirable for
preparing a statement on the economics of ADP; however,
plans are being develeped to assemble and compile this
essential data on a continuing basis.
There is no question in our minds but that the system will
ultimately provide substantial economies as well as operating improvements.
K. Klemmetson - Washington
Charles A. Zéglin - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Question
No.
19
Seven months have passed since the last Regional Office was
converted to ADP, yet the Center is unable to overcome
problems that still create hardships to veterans and beneficiaries all over the country through overpayments,
underpayments, delayed or no payments at all.
How much longer
is it going to take to get ADP on the track and running
efficiently?
A.
We think
has been
efficiency
No
our
and
of
additional
answers to previous
will continue to be
the
questions show that much
done to increase the
system.
conversions
will
be
undertaken
until
we
have
assured ourselves that all conditions are favorable for
such a move,
In order to make this determination we are
establishing criteria by which to measure the acceptability
of conditions.
These measurements will indicate a.
The current status of ADP operations.
rejects or inquiries can not be beyond
level.
b.
The readiness of a station to be converted.
This means
no out-of-line conditions as to workload,
staffing or
other operating factors - also that it will have reached
an established degree of proficiency through training
under simulated procedures.
c.
The capacity of the Data Processing Center to accommodate
additional accounts.
This is not restricted to computer
capacity,
alone, but includes adequacy of staffing and
proficiency of personnel as well.
When a detailed evaluation
teria have been met in all
additional conversions.
For example,
an acceptable
indicates that established crithree areas,
then we will consider
In anticipation of that time we have developed a new and
simplified conversion procedure.
Stripped of all technicalities it provides
that a.
During the conversion period,
the field station will
continue to make all payments;
the Data Processing
Center will operate a parallel system but without any
payment
functions.
b.
At
end
the
of
the
conversion
72
period
a
reconciliation
will
be made to assure that accounts converted and updated at
the Data Processing Center are in agreement with those at
the
€.
field
station.
Any account that cannot successfully be converted will
remain at the regional office for payment until it can
be converted without any interruption of continued payment.
We believe this new system will eliminate the problems we
experienced during previous conversions.
However, before
resuming any full-scale conversion it will be tested to
make sure it will achieve the objective of continued,
uninterrupted service.
Collin McKinme- North Carolina
Charles J. Kohler - Pennsylvania
Q.
ADP
Question
No.
8
When is it
calculated that the Veterans Administration will
recoup through ADP operations the losses sustained by this
conversion?
In this estimate include losses incurred from
errors. and excessive payment which.the Government will
never
expect
to
recover,
The installation of any large system such as ADP requires
a sizeable capital investment and unusual operating expenses in order to change over to the new system.
Since
the VA has spread out its conversion schedule,
it will take
longer to realize ultimate savings than we originally anticipated.
However, based on a recent VA-wide study, we
estimate that by April 1969 we will start to accrue some
"net profits."
At that point we will have amortized our
investment and will start accruing annual savings at the
rate
of
a million dollars
annually.
Should the VA decide to purchase the ADP equipment instead
of continuing to rent it, we would increase our initial
cost but recover it faster by not having to pay equipment
rent which amounts to more than $1,000,000.00 a year.
In
turn, this would move the 'break-even'" point forward by
about three years.
We have no reason to believe that there will be any material
losses from errors or overpayments.
Most of the beneficiaries
who may have been overpaid are still drawing benefits from
which recovery can be made.
In addition,
since we have consolidated the records of converted stations into a single
file, we have found a number of overpayments which had
become disassociated from the payment records and have been
able to take recovery action.
We should not lose sight of the fact that the ADP system is
benefiting other departments too.
For instance,
the Treasury
Department estimates that by the end of F.Y, 1970,
it will
realize an additional potential savings of more than
$18,000,000,00 through consolidation of its offices and refinement of its operations in conjunction with our ADP system.
A.
V.
Akin,
Jr.
-
Georgia
ADP
Q.
If the mechanized process for payments to claimants is reestablished in Atlanta, how long will be required before
every claimant can be assured they will receive their checks
73
Question
No.
12
each
month?
This
this
is a question
time.
that
we
cannot
answer
specifically
at
To re-establish the Mechanized Benefit Payment
system in
Atlanta we would have to go through the same process to
UNDO what we have done: write computer programs;
reconstruct the punched card records;
and re-establish old
methods of processing Compensation & Pension payments
through the Finance Division.
Further,
since the Treasury
Department has closed its Atlanta Office we would have to
know whether that Department wanted to keep the Atlanta
accounts in Chicago or transfer them to Birmingham for
payment with your other benefits.
All
this
mine
been
A.V.
Q.
would
require
extensive
study
to
followed.
Such
the methods
undertaken.
Akin,
Jr.
-
be
Georgia
ADP
in
order
studies
Question
No.
to
deter-
have
not
13
Since every thinking person knows that we are in the machine
age, and that machines can do the job when the proper machine
is employed,
couldn't Central Office of the Veterans Administration secure and place smaller ADP machines in Regional
locations to get away from the larger operation which has
caused many VA claimants to suffer for the lack of necessities due to non-receipt of VA checks?
When the VA first became interested in the possibilities of
using an ADP system,
serious study was made as to feasibility of installing small ADP machines in regional offices.
However, we found it would not be practical,
efficient nor
economical to do this - or even to place such equipment in
a number of Payment Centers.
Garland
Charles
Charles
0.
H.
J.
A.
Woods - Arizona
Kohler - Pennsylvania
Zeglin - Pennsylvania
ADP
It is requested that
up-to-date report on
the
the
Veterans
progress
dation
of
any
problem
we
have
blems
that
we
might
We
feel
that
the
Question
No.
Administration give an
of ADP concerning liqui-
met
in
the
meet
in
the
future.
answers
to
all
the
other
past
and
questions
identified and reviewed the problems of the
picture of our current status,
and provided
we can anticipate for the future.
74
18
any
pro-
have
past, given a
a look at what
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON
MARCH 1, 1961
SESSION
. « « The National Rehabilitation Conference of The American
Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room, Statler Hotel,
Washington,
D.C.Vice Chairman J. Ross Foust, presiding.
. .
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
Ladies and gentlemen of the Conference,
we have quite a number of important matters to bring before our
Conference this afternoon.
As you know, ADP utilized all the
time this morning so we will have quite a load this afternoon,
and I know you will join with me and expedite_matters
as best
we
can.
At this time, I would like to present our discussion
leaders for this afternoon:
first,
the Department Service
Officer, Comrade Likens from the great State of Nebraska,
and
the Department Service Officer from Massachusetts,
our Comrade
Buckley,
our Department Service Officer, Comrade Jensen from
the State of Georgia,
and the Department Service Officer from
Montana, Comrade Callaghan.
Comrade Weiss will be here a
little
for me
this
later.
He
to present
morning
from
has been detained.
I don't think it necessary
these fine gentlemen who served us so capably
the
Veterans
If, however,
there
us this morning,
and you
will be glad to hear from
Administration.
are any additions to those who served
would care to make that fact known,
I
you.
MR. STRATTON:
Thank you.
I am very happy to be back with
you again this year, or should I say this afternoon,
rather than
this morning.
I see that we finally got the group down to the
12 converted stations.
We were trying to see some dim light
of optimism this morning and somebody said, "Well,
after all,
you could have come to this conference with 5
stations converted and 12 non-converted stations."
And this is our shining
light.
I would like to introduce to you the group that will
attempt to answer your questions this afternoon,
and I know
that you are going to burst into tumultuous applause,
so if you
will wait
until we get all through here,
then we will hold it
down to one.
First is Mr. Edwaed Reinmuth, who is my assistant, who
works with me in the Compensation and Pension Service,
a good,
capable right arm; Mr. Louis Townsend,
staff assistant in the
Director's Office; Herb Moore,
the Assistant Director for
Policy and Planning, who has been with many of you at your field
stations; working in the same group with Mr. Moore, Mr. J. C.
Peckarsky, who is the Chief of our Projects staff and Mr. Jim
Donald, who is the Chief of our Policy Staff,
(I think in the
audience), Mr. Arthur Farmer, who is the Assistant Director for
Benefits Consultants.
He is the gentleman that handles your
administrative reviews and restores your service connections.
Next’is Mr. Sidney Kaltz, who works with Mr, Farmer and is in
charge of one of the consultants groups;
Woodie Morris,
recently the adjudication officer from Albuquerque,
New Mexico, now
we are pleased to say,
in central office, Chief of another
consultants group; Mr. Arthur Thompson,
the Assistant Director
for Analysis and Standards;
Dr. Nevill Joyner,
the Chairman of
the
Disability
Policy
Board.
This
75
gentleman
is
in
charge
of
the
group that writes and rewrites your rating schedule.
With
Dr. Joyner, we have Dr, Robert Muilenburg,
a medical consultant
on this same
board.
Also, we have W. B. Johnson,
recently. in
the Veterans Administration,
who is the Chairman of the Board
on Waivers and Forfeitures.
From other services,
if the gentleman will permit me, we
have Mr. Cahrly Curtis that all of you know very well,
the
Director of the Administrative Service.
Then I think we have
Mr. John Jackson, who is in the Office of Chief Benefits
Director.
Now,
Mr.
Chairman,
we
are
ready
to
deal
with
questions.
-CHAIRMAN FOUST:
Thank you very much.
Is the Department
Service Officer from Pennsylvania,
Mr. Weiss, here? If not, our
discussion leaders will take over
at this point, but before they
do, I think it only right and proper,
for fear some of you may
not know our good friend,
to introduce the Assistant Director
for
Claims,
who
will
serve
today
as
the
staff
moderator,
Ed
Golembieski.
Now we will proceed to our discussion on the
law, P. L. 86-211.
The discussion leaders will take over.
great
MR. LIKENS:
Mr. Chairman and members of the panel,
it is
indeed a privilege for me personally,
as well as the Department
of Nebraska to be able to participate in this program.
I have
a fine panel that has been assigned with me.
We are behind
time
so
to
curtail
with asking the
Service Officer
Jensen,
any
further
delay,
we
will
start
questions and we will start with
from the great State of Georgia,
right
the
Mr.
off
Department
Edward D.
MR. JENSEN:
Thank you, Val,
The first question was submitted by Akin of Georgia.
Why does the VA use different
standards of deriving "met profit" from sale of property on
various instructions for completing annual income questionnaires
for those on pension rolls?
MR. STRATTON:
Mr. Peckarsky will answer this question and,
Mr. Chairman,
if we may,
there are several related questions
here, Number 3 and Number 5,
and if hé could handle those at
the same time and ask the question and also answer, Mr. Peckarsky
will now filibuster,
MR. LIKENS:
No. 3. Is the VA contemplating revision of
instructions for income questionnaire forms?
Please comment,
No.
puting
net
5.
Why
income
veterans,
widows
there
be
not
is
there
from
and
a difference
sales
of
children
uniformity
in
for
this
in
property
PL
the
between
86-211
methods
of
com-
parents,
purposes?
Should
report?
MR PECKARSKY:
Mr. Chairman and ladies and gentlemen,
let
me take the third question first,
as to whether or not we propose to revise our instructions for the annual income questionnaires.
Yes, we do.
We try to improve them every year. As
you know, we revised them this year.
Right at the moment,
since we have them in what we consider the best shape we can
get them in, we don't have any concrete direction for a revision,
If you can suggest any, we would certainly be glad to
consider them.
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
(PENNSYLVANIA)
76
Make
them
simpler.
in
am
aware
The
of no
basic
put
out.
we
sheets
made
were
that
are
that
we
take
property,
the
to
of
substantially
selling
the
from
that
subtract
They
any
in
difference
is
rule
general
concern themselves with differences
from the sale of property and I
questions
primarily
The other two
computing income
and if
glad to
to do, Mike,
certainly be
That we would like
MR. PECKARSKY:
you can suggest ways to do it, we would
incorporate them in our instructions.
the
price,
instruction
four
the
worded
the
same.
to
the
net
cost
subtract
any
the
expenses
base
subtract
payees,
improvements
of
sale,
There has to, of
left is reportable as net income.
be a slight difference on the various forms that
and this is from the
various categories of payees,
of equity.
and what's
necessity,
pertain to
standpoint
in the case of a veteran we cannot in good
For example,
conscience charge him with any profit that accrued to him before
so we tell
the day he became permanently and totally disabled,
the veteran to either report his cost when he bought the probecame
property
report
what
the
permanently
and
totally
to
or
perty
was
worth
the
on
day
he
disabled.
in the case of a widow we cannot in good conSimilarly,
science charge her with any income that accrued prior to the
date of the veteran's death where she acquired property prior
and so on the instruction to her we say that she
to his death,
shall report either the cost to her or the value of the property on the date of his death. Outside of those exceptions in
I know of no differences
the method of computing basic cost,
I
in our method of computing income from sale of property.
believe the instruction sheets are 'virtually identical in all
four instances.
MR.
comment
on
Val
for
to
JENSEN:
anybody
Does
this
from
the
the
rest
of
floor?
the
have
If
any
not,
further
I will
questions
turn
this
or
back
questions.
The next individual to ask questions is
MR. LIKENS:
Past President of the Department Service Officer Association,
Mr. Callaghan,
from the State of Montana.
What explanation should a Service
No. 2:
MR. CALLAGHAN:
Officer give a claimant when information contained in the
various instructions conflict with instructions furnished in
dated March 11, 19587?
VA Bulletin EM-21-9,
With
That was a short rest.
MR. PECKARSKY:
mission, Mr. Chairman, Question No. 9 is virtually
Shall I read it?
question.
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
Go
your perthe same
ahead.
When property is held
Question No. 9 is:
MR. PECKARSKY:
jointly by husband and wife and a claim is filed under PL 86-211,
considerable misunderstanding arises from the two different
rules followed by adjudication in making determinations of
corpus of estate and of income derived from this property.
two
the
What are the principal points of difference
Has the VA given any thought
determinations?
same standards of ownership to determinations
77
between these
to applying
of income as
are applied to corpus of estate when the property is held in
joint tenancy?
Here I.believe is possibly one of the questions
that was implicit in the first group that I answered.
It is
true
that
we
have
a different
rule
for
computing
property than we have for computing ownership
counted as corpus of estate and the differnce
difference
in
the
law.
Income,
as
you
know,
income
from
of property
stems from the
is
anything
that
can be relied on for maintenance.
It is
what the claimant Has
available for maintenance,
and in computing income the Attorney
General has told us in the decision in the Burkey case that
it
would not be equitable to differentiate between the laws of the
various states and to recognize such things as community property laws for divisions of income,
since this would give a
veteran,
let us say, in California the right to cut his
income
in half because half of it belongs to his wife.
For this reason, our regulations have required that in computing income
we go to the actual equitable ownership of the property whose money bought it, who earned it, and by that determine
all the money is reportable as income of the owner, regardless
of whether it is
a joint tenancy, whether he owns it in his own
name, or whether by operation of the community property law it
is in the names of he and his wife.
With corpus of estate we have a different situation.
Here the property has not yet been converted into cash,
and remember that in income we count only profit after it is converted to cash, but in corpus,
the property is still real property, and ,the determination in corpus is based on what does
the veteran have that is of such value that he could reasonably
be required to consume some part of it for his own maintenance?
Here
the
law
places
another
restriction
on
us
and
says,
"Now, in the case of a veteran,
although you may
count all
of his wife's income over $1,200,
you may count for purposes
of corpus of estate only what belongs to the veteran.
You may
not count the wife's corpus."
So that in determining corpus,
we have to restrict ourselves to what is the veteran's and we
have to restrict ourselves to what he can dispose of.
For
that reason,
in the corpus of estate portion of the instruction
to Public Law 86-211, we said that we would follow the recorded
title to the property and would not go behind it.
If it appears
as joint tenancy we will follow the joint tenancy rule and
count half of it as his, half of it his wife's,
and therefore,
when computing his corpus only his half counts.
It would be
nice if the rule could be the same for both corpus and income.
Under the law as presemtly written, we do
not think that it.
could be done.
Are there any further questions on this point?
MR. MARKOWITZ:
If you threw the corpus of
altogether we would be all right, would we not?
solwe the problem for you and for
us.
MR.
PECKARSKY:
It
would
solve
this
estate out
That would
particular
problem,
yes.
MR. CALLAGHAN:
No. 4:
Has the VA suggested that Congress
liberalize the obvious inequity which permits a widow to deduct
from her income the just debts,
the expenses of last sickness
and burial in the case of a deceased veteran,
but prohibits
the same application to a veteran in the event of the sickness
and burial of his wife?
78
will
Moore
Herb
Mr.
STRATTON:
MR.
question.
this
answer
I believe the discussion on this started
MR. MOORE:
We were talking about the section of
right here last year.
211 that permitted a widow or child to offset against their
the
income an amount equal to the amount thet they paid on
of course, would include the
just debts of the veteran which,
A bill has been introexpenses of last illness and burial.
Congressman
duced to do something similar for the veteran.
on January 6, 1961,introduced a bill which iis H.R.
O'Konski,
and it would exclude from his income amounts equal to
1954,
of
amounts paid by a veteran for the last illness and burial
That is pending before the Congress now.
his wife or child.
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
No.
6:
there
Are
this
any
questions
of
of
painting
houses
gentle-
man?
Why
purposes not be
cost of repairs
fore
deductible
porting
ceiving
cost
the
would
the
on expenses,
rental property,
a deductible item
as maintenance of
from
income for
pension or
the
income
gross
widows,
veterans,
death pension?
of
same as the
and there-
in
re-
children
re-
property
such
parents
and
rental
for
Now, to prove to you that we made these
MR. STRATTON:
question assignments when Mr. Peckarsky was off on sick leave,
he will answer this question.
This is a very easy question to answer
MR. PECKARSKY:
it is proper to
It does count,
because we agree with you.
any
subtract this item and as long as this is rental property,
upkeep, including painting, may be subtracted from net profit.
If you do have a case in which this was not done, or you feel
that your station does not understand this and
the case we will be glad to reassure them that
MR.
CALLAGHAN:
Are
there
any
questions
will give
it can be
us
deducted.
concerning
that?
We have a bunch of smart officers here this
MR. LIKENS:
Mr.
I am sure you have some questions some place.
afternoon.
I might
Stratton says "They must be in a state of shock."
go
suggest that if you do have any questions, please rise and
to one of the microphones in the middle aisle because it is
and when you get there please talk to
rather hard to hear,
if you don't
the microphone because it is just like a spittoon;
The next panel member to ask the
hit it, it is worthless.
questions is Mr. Francis W. Weiss, Jr., from Pennsylvania.
having
ing in
the
No. 7:
MR. WEISS:
a guardian living
another town with
eight
MR.
of
election
STRATION:
for
Mr.
incompetent widow
In the case of an
and her minor child 1livin one town,
a separate guardian, who would have
benefits
Art
under
PL
86-2117?
Parmer.
The short answer is the widow's guardian has
MR. FARMER:
It should be understood that
the right to make the election.
the child's rights are derived
when there is a widow living,
a widow, whether she is
There is one provision:
through her.
cannot reduce the
incompetent or not, by electing under 86-211,
That is
amount that the child will get under the old law.
paragraph 7¢0){3).
right in the instructions,
79
MR.
WEISS:
Any
questions?
No. 8, submitted by yours truly:
VA Technical Bulletin
8-265,
dated June 14, 1955,
based on an
opinion of the General
Counsel,
authorized waiver of pension or retirement benefit
payable under a private or public retirement plan for the
purpose of meeting annual income limitations for disability or
death pension.
Accordingly,
before the release of Technical Bulletin
8-272,
a number of waivers were executed by individuals under
private or public retirement plans and the reduced income established eligibility to death or disability pension which they
had received through December 1960.
IB 21-34, dated December 30, 1960, refers to a recent
decision of the General Counsel which states that the VA cannot
recognize any waivers of pension or retirement pay for pension
purposes other than those expressly authorized by Federal
statute.
This bulletin also stated that the instruction sheet
accompanying
the Annual Income Questionnaire directed the beneficiary to list those amounts previously waived which were not
specifically
authorized
by
statute.
What
is
the
status
of
a
beneficiary who reports on the Income Questionnaire for 1960-61
those amounts of private or public retirement previously waived
under
the
PL 86-211
under the
limits of
authority
of
TB
8-265?
Will
the
savings
provision
of
maintain the beneficiary's entitlement to receive
old law if the annual income reported is below the
$1,400 or $2,700?
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
MOORE:
Mr.
In
Moore
answer
to
the
question
as
to
what
is
the
status of someone who has relied on the provisions of the
TB 8-265
-- who secured a waiver, we acknowledged it and we
accepted it, I assume that this inquires as to whether we will
create an overpayment or whether we will adjust it as of the
date of last payment.
I believe the answer will be this:
Under
our Regulation 1253
(e), if a person notifies us promptly when
he knows that he is going to exceed his income limit, we will
discontinue as of the date of last payment and we will not go
back,
and I believe that regulation will be for application here.
This is where,
of course,
the claimant in good faith did
waive under the TB 8-265
and had no other knowledge.
We clarified this late in 1960.
In the instruction sheets to the
questionnaires we told them that they could not waive.
This
was their first knowledge,
so if
they did come in in
January
1961 and tell us of the waiver,
this would be prompt notice and
we would not create an overpayment.
As to part 2 of this question,
as to whether they will be
protected under the old law, we have felt
in the past that if
a person were receiving a pension on June 30, 1960, and we did
not go back and create an overpayment for that time,
that he
would be protected.
I will have to admit that a legal question
has arisen,
however,
in this situation as to
the propriety of
the June payment,
so we are going to have to submit this wuestion to the General Counsel.
We are now submitting it.
I am
sorry
do
get
I
cannot
the
MR.
give
answer
we
MARKOWITZ:
you
a
will
That
definite
answer
distribute
is
my
80
man
now.
it
and
up
there
As
send
that
it
soon
as
we
out
to
you.
asked
the
I decided not to say anything, but I cannot help
question.
I think there is a little misgexplaining a little further.
We have a situation in a depressed area in
understanding.
and the President is
There are many such places,
Pennsylvania.
with the
very much concerned and everybody else is concerned
We did not make the decision as to whether
depressed areas,
That was $100 a month origithis waiver should be permitted.
that they received from the Anthracite
nally and ‘then $50
longer able
Mine Union on behalf of those veterans who were no
We were permitted to make those waivers until some
to work.
smart guy working for the Veterans Administration decided,
The
"We better look up the thing and maybe it is illegal.”
it was
Veterans Administration itself made the decision that
it
legal first, and then they changed their mind and called
We are not concerned about the
illegal and now it is illegal.
We know that you are not trying to collect the
overpayment.
We understand that, but we are concerned about the
overpayment.
in a
hundreds or thousands of veterans who find themselves
to maybe $40
predicament where they have been cut from $78.75
I
a month or whatever amount under this new-fangled law which
do not know anything about, never heard of 4t, and I hope'l
never will be able to understand it, and I hope it will be
changed soon so that everybody understands it.
that is the crux of the problem and 1 think since
Anyhow,
the VA legal guys told these fellows they were entitled to
the veteran
that consideration and then changed their minds,
should not be penalized and his pension should be permitted to
be
remain at the old rate under the old law and he should not
That is the thing we
burdened with having his pension cut.
I do not
Whether you can answer. that question,
want to know.
know.
That is exactly the question
That is right.
MR.MOORE:
later
as I understand it and as you say, we said one thing,
that we
I believe,
we clarified it, and it is on this basis,
are not going back and create an overpayment where they do
As to whether they
and tell us in January 1961.
come in now
as I said, where a person dia get
will get this protection,
pension payments under the old law on June 30, 1960, and we
have not created an overpayment over that time and not attempted
to
get
it
back,
then
we
felt
have
that
they
would
be
protected.
in this situation there is a question whether there
However,
and this is the question we are submitting.
was a proper payment,
As soon as we do get the answer we will certainly let you know.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Counsel and give us a
Use your influence
favorable report.
with
the
General
I would add thereto and assure you
Mike,
MR. STRATTON:
will not
that when we submit this to the General Counsel, we
but we will make sure that we all
ask a flat legal question,
about,
have a common understanding of the things you are talking
and the
the administrative things that were done in the past,
the entire history of this thing,
bulletins,
different technical
so that he can look at it the fullest way possible.
you
are
very
Tell
him
also
Back on
possible
the
for
As
same question.
all these veterans
the
MR. MARKOWITZ:
problem.
TB
MR. WEISS:
made it
8-265
81
sympathetic
to
the
you know,
to waive and
subsequent TB 8-272, which I want to
for when you bring it to the General
in part as follows:
bring to your attention,
Counsel's attention,
states
"The entire matter of waiving a part of all of
pension or retirement benefits payable under a
private or public retirement plan for the purpose
of reducing the claimant's income to the amount within
the annual income limitations of Part 3, Veterans
Regulation
1(a),
as
amended,
and
Public
Law
484,
73rd
Congress,
as amended,
is being reconsidered pending
receipt of further instructions'" -- and I underline
"pending receipt of further instructions."
"No waivers of retirement or pension benefits will be
recognized by the Veterans Administration for the purpose of ‘reducing a claimant's annual income in an
amount which would render him eligible to receive
pension under Part 3."
Now, the Chief Adjudication Officer at the Wilkes-Barre
Regional Office -- I can't speak for other offices, but I can
speak for the Wilkes-Barre Regional Office -- at that time
stated to us that pending receipt of further instructions,
he
would continue the waiver of retirement benefits.
He has never
received those further instructions and for this reason we feel
that they should be given that right.
MR. STRATTON:
We are aware of this and this also is an
integral part of the history that we have to include in our
submission to the General Counsel.
There was a question at
this time
specifically on this group in Pennsylvania which
led us to continue this for a period and certainly it adds some
credence to the argument that you give us here.
Again,
I
assure you and Mike both
that the entire matter will be completely and historically documented when we send it up.
MR. LIKENS:
Are there any other questions directed to
this particular question?
We are about to conclude our portion of the questions and answers and the man to ask the
questions in the final phase is our friend Mr. Timothy J.
Buckley
from
the
State
of
Massachusetts.
MR. BUCKLEY:
The next question is No. 10.
A veteran,
his son and daughter were involved in a car accident.
The
veteran and the son were fatally injured.
The daughter was
hospitalized in a critical condition.
The mother and widow
of deceased
veteran
was
insurance
resulting
from
beneficiary
the
of
veteran's
$10,000
commercial
Will the VA allow the funeral expense of the
hospital expense of the daughter to be
deducted as
when the widow applies for pension?
MR.
tion
think
we
STRATTON:
have
they
had
may
to
have
This
this
heard
perhaps
point.
the
is
To
first
life
death.
the
most
make
sure,
part
of
son and
the
just debts
provocative
your
and
I
do
quesnot
question,
the
significance,
of course,
is one where the veteran has been killed
in an automobile accident.
One of the children has also been
killed in that accident.
The second child has been severely
imjured in that accident.
The question is what can the widow
offset against her income for the year of the death in deciding
82
whether or not she comes within the limitation on income for
the receipt of pension.
Of course,
the law, 86-211, permits
her to offset against that income the last expenses of the
illness and death of the veteran,
so we do not have a problem
there.
Our problem is she also can offset the just debts of
the veteran existing at the time of death.
We get then to
this point:
Are the funeral expenses of the child and the
medical expenses of the second child incurred in the same
accident just debts at the time of his death so that she
can offset them?
I will immediately say that the people that you see at
the front table are very sympathetic to this type
of situation.
It gets very complicated,
though, when you get into the
legal aspects of it.
It is
the type of situation that in the
legal profession you cannot avoid on occasion, but it is such a
fine line that you must hit it.
What we have here basically
probably in the legal aeea is did the father,
that is, the
veteran,
die first,
or did the child die first?
I do not know
that the question will fall or stand on that issue.
I do know,
however,
that there is a presumption generally in the common
law as to survivorship,
where it is not known in a common
accident as to which one died first,
that the older of the
group died first.
If the question ends up being settled on
that issue it would mean that the veteran died first and that
this would be a just debt of the widow and could be offset,
but it is
a very complex thing and, very frankly,
I would like
to say to the gentleman that asked the question that I would
appreciate it if you could give me a case in point on this
thing so that we could get a definite answer.
MR.
BUCKLEY:
Is
MR.
PRATOR:
Yes.
MR.
request?
BUCKLEY:
Do
MR.
PRATOR,
Yes.
MR.
STRATTON:
Mr.
Prator
from
you
intend
to
comply
us
a
It
would
help
Oklahoma
in
with
great
the
Mr.
deal
hall?
Stratton's
if
you
will.
MR. BUCKLEY:
Thank you.
The next question is No. 11. A
single veteran, whose minor child has been adopted by his former
wife and her present husband, has been found entitled to pension
under PL 86-211.
A.
Is he to be considered a veteran with
purpose of the annual income
computation?
B.
May he be paid additional pension for
C.
If
hospitalized
by
the
VA
in
excess
his payments would be subject to reduction
payments of the balance of his entitlement
behalf
of
MR.
the
child
STRATTON:
if
Mr.
need
is
shown?
to
be
of
a
child
his
two
for
child?
months
the
and
$30 monthly, would
made to or
on
Moore.
MR. MOORE:
The answers to the first two questions to this
are in the affirmative.
First,
in the case of the veteran with
a child, for the purpose of annual income computation under our
Regulation 1057
and 1058,
a child adopted out of the veteran's
family either during his lifetime or after his death is
83
nonetheless considered a child,
so for income computation
purposes we would consider that the veteran had a child notwithstanding
the fact that it had been adopted out of his
family.
May he be paid additional pension for his child?
The
answer again here is yes.
The law only requires that he have
a child.
It does not specifically require that he reasonably
contribute to the child's support,
so as long as he has the
child we would pay him the additional amount.
On the third
portion
of
this
question,
we
have
considerable
relates to whether we might apportion
the veteran had been hospitalized for
You
recall
tion
to
the
part
our
the
instruction.
wife
or
child,
it
might
be
First,
of
the
child
We
for
two
this
full
indicated
that
depending
questioned
adopted
out
of
on
doubt.
we
their
could
appor-
need.
whether
the
That
child after
calendar months.
there
was
veteran's
need
on
family.
We
have not had any case in point.
If you have a case, please
let us have it and we willget an answer for you.
As of this
time,
tbough, we have not had any case in point.
If you do
send that in, may I ask that you get evidence relating to the
child's need’ so that we may have the full facts when we decide
the
point.
rather
right
MR. STRATTON:
1 might add here, Mr.
striking coincidence you have given
Chairman,
that by a
us three questions
in
part
row
where
This
is
not
the
way
will
admit,
but
it
that
you
had
to
a
have
asked
defer
our
we
could
we
like
us
give
three
immediately say
on all the rest
that we will
of them.
MR.
Any
you
operate,
through,
answers.
BUCKLEY:
not
to
happens
I
straight
I will
try
as
I
of
apologize
for
to
a
you
BUCKLEY:
Mike
coincidence
where
that
we
and
have
then
definitive
answer
questions?
MR. FELLER (NEW YORK):
In the next panel,
is a question that I would also like to raise in
because I had a case in point to outline.
May I
tion?
MR.
answer.
even
complete
questions
give
the
think
know,
= You
may,
Question No. 6
this panel,
read the ques-
sir.
MR. FELLER:
It is
presented by Charles Kohler of Pennsylvania.
Under present conditions, peacetime veterans who are
zero percent service connected cannot receive VA outpatient
treatment or hospitalization for that condition.
Are any
changes contemplated in the regulations with respect to such
cases?
is
a
Now,
the
point
boy
with
a
according
to
your
that
peacetime
I
would
like
to
rating
schedule,
because
Rochester,
New
Eastman
York,
Kodak
and
he
Company
attempts
or
any
of
to
is
this
is
panel
rated
of
an
than 10 percent.
community such as
He
apply
the
to
hernia
it
innocent hernia and easily reparable,
less
then is zero percent.
He then goes into a
with
raise
service-connected
somewhat
for
larger
employment
choice
employ-
ment
opportunities.
It becomes
an integral
part
of that
employment
process
that
he pass
a physical
examination.
It is
impossible
for
him
to pass
this physical
examination.
With
the hernia
they will
not
take
him.
Then we submit
a 10-P-10
to
is
the hospital and we
out.
He is euchred
nowledged
it
is
get
out
service-connected
equity
the
way
this
Code 38 thrown at
of all benefits.
condition.
thing
84
works
It
now
us
He
does
and
I
and
has
the boy
an ack-
not
seem
would
like
that
to
present
sidered
the question to
in this respect
MR.
BUCKLEY:
Do
this panel.
Is
at this time?
you
care
to
anything
answer
that,
being
Mr,
con-
Stratton?
MR. STRATION:
I think that the basic question that you
selected there,
sir, comes before the medical panel tomorrow,
but you have established it as
part of this.
I will do my
best
to
answer.
I
just
assured
you
that
we
would
answer
all
the rest of them,
sol
‘am going to try.
It is true that under
the law, the person who has only peacetime service or regular
establishment
service cannot get VA hospitalization unless he
was discharged for a disability incurred in line of duty or he
is in receipt of compensation.
That is the basic requirement.
This veteran that you are speaking of here is zero percent
for a disability which did not cause his discharge from the
service.
Therefore,
he is not in receipt of compensation.
He was not CDD'd for that disability and under the law he is
not entitled to hospitalization.
of.
Now we get
He comes to
percent,
IT.
think
on the merry-go-round that you are
Adjudication and he says, "Instead
that
1
am
entitled
to
‘ten
percent
speaking
of zero
because
1
have a hervia.”
They rate the case and they say, "This hernia
is operable.
Therefore,
you are not entitled to ten percent."
He says,
"How can. 1. get ten percent?"
They say, "We have to
find out after you have been
operated on whether or not the
residuals would warrant it."
He says,
"How do I do that?"
He goes to the hospital and they say, '"We can't take you in
unless Adjudication gives you ten percent.’
He is on the merry-go-round and we acknowledge this is
somewhat of a merry-go-round.
It is created by the exact language of the law,
I fear, but I do know that there have been
bills introduced in past sessions of Congress.
I do not know
about this session.
But I would bring it up at the medical
panel session.
There have been bills introduced which would
correct the thing that you are speaking of.
MR. BUCKLEY:
Any further questions?
If not, we will pass
on to 12.
A World War II widow and her two
children had no
entitlement prior to the enactment of PL 86-211.
Her income
for 1960 is $1,400,
$200 of which is received from January 1,
1960, to June 30, 1960, and $1,200 of which was received from
July I, 1960,
to December 31, 1960,
What
1,
1960,
rate
to
MR.
of
pension
December
STRATTON:
should
31,
19607
Mr.
Moore.
this
widow
be
paid
from
July
MR. MOORE:
This, of course,
involves our proportionate
computation rule.
The widow would get $40 for
herself with an
additional: $15 for her
child, or a total of $33 from the date
of her entitlement,
July 1, 1960,
In this case
we have,
I
believe,
a pretty simple rule that we follow,
We do proportionately compute from the effective date in the case of any
veteran or widow.
In this case eligibility is first established
July 1, 1960.
The total income from July lst through the end
of
the
an
an
annual basis,
annual income
year
is
$1,200,
is
at
or
at
a rate
of
%200
per
month.
This,
$2,400.,
so her payments would be based on
the increment between $2,000 and $3,000.
85
on
We
pay
I
will
her
$40
plus
the
$15
MR. BUCKLEY:
Any
return the panel
MR.
LIKENS:
We have
members
unless
there
this
question
pertaining
CRIDER
the
child.
questions from the floor?
Hearing none,
to our Chairman, Val Likens of Nebraska.
panel
MR.
for
one more
question
from
one of our
is another
question
from
the floor,
to
PL
(TENNESSEE):
86-211,
Let
me
Mr.
go
Crider.
back
just
a minute
to this question on the zero percent peacetime veteran.
You
know,
in the past when a public law was passed we read it one
way and then when the instructions are written we do not recognize it to be
the law as passed.
Why can't you write instructions as you do on most of these laws regardless of what
the law says and go on
and fix it where the peacetime veteran
can be hospitalized,
because I am sure you have wiggled these
laws around in the past where you have done that.
Why didn't
you do this with the peacetime veteran?
MR. STRATTON:
I would prefer to just wiggle those laws
that pertain to compensation and pension rather than to the
Department of Medicine and Surgery but, as I recall, Jim, and
I have to call on my recollection here, because this is not
entirely
in my
MR.
field,
CRIDER:
Part
MR. STRATTON:
the law itself, not
tion of a peacetime
sation or unless he
in
line
of
duty.
as
you
of
for
disability
--
it.
As I recall,
the language of the law today,
the instructions, would prohibit hospitaiizaveteran unless he was in receipt of compenwas discharged for a disability incurred
It is
a little
could be interpreted so that
peacetime only, who had
zero
get the compensation and, on
not
know
incurred
hard
for
me
to
see
how
that
you could put a man in the hospital,
percent and has failed there to
the other hand, was discharged
in
line
of duty.
MR. CRIDER:
You come out with the 86-211 and others
where there is nothing said about these instructions and you
wrote instructions applying to it not identified in the law in
any way, and that is why I say if you can do that, why don't
you do the same thing on peacetime veterans?
You have done it.
It has been legal so far.
MR. STRATTON:
I think your latter remark certainly does
not apply to this panel and if you would show us where we have
broken the law 211 I will be glad to look at the instruction.
were
MR. CRIDER:
never in the
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
CRIDER:
1 say
law.
you
Almost
Thank
have
all
written
of
pages
them have
on
been
211
that
liberal.
you.
MR. LIKENS:
Are there any other questions from the floor?
If not, we will let one of the panel members, Mr. Weiss,
ask
this question.
if
the
MR. WEISS:
Mr, Stratton,
General Counsel contends
86
going back to Question .8 again,
that the veteran is eligible to
receive benefits under the old law, then what would happen to
this veteran who subsequent to January 1, 1961, had no other
alternative but to accept benefits under Public Law 86-2117
Would he be given the right to return to the old law, even
though he accepted and cashed his initial check under Public
Law 86-2117
MR. STRATTON:
I am going to need
I think.
This gentlemen under Question
cause of this waiver problem?
MR. WEISS:
of
or
under
MR.
"WBISS:.
one,
be-
Right.
MR. STRATTON:
At that point,
his union subsidy, he would have
$1,800
some help on this
8 has been barred
though,
a total
even counting
income under
all
$3,000.
Correct.
MR. STRATTON:
And at that point your question would go
to the fact that
he does then take benefits under 211.
At
some future date, perhaps when the payments are reduced from
the union,
and he gets back under $1,400, would he be
able to
come back under the old law, if the General Counsel so rules
on this retroactive payment?
I think I have loused this up.
MR.
this
WEISS:
Providing
that
income
is within
that
$1,400
year.
MR.MOORE:
Actually,
I was just milling this through my
mind.
The thought occurred to me that until he elects,
a man
does not come under 211.
He does not lose protection under
the old law if he were entitled on June 30, 1960, until he
elects,
and I believe that based on that theory,
if he did not
elect to receive under 211 and the decision is that he has
protection under the old laws, we could pay him under the old
law.
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
If
it is
MR.
MOORE:
is
correct.
That
declared
to be
legal.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Would he receive retroactive benefits
from July 1, 1960, when he did elect because he would have no
other recourse?
If the General Counsel decides it is legal,
will he be given retroactive benefits under the old law?
MR. MOORE:
We have another problem here, Mike.
As you
recall,
a man that has eligibility under the old law, that is,
he is protected under the old law and is receiving benefits on
June 30, 1960, and he elects under 211, we cannot pay him
under
211 prior to the date of receipt of his election.
In other
words, he has to take the good with the bad, does he not?
MR. WEISS:
We have here a miner at the present time.
His
income does not permit him to continue his normal
obligations.
Therefore,
he has no other alternative but to accept benefits
under 211,
It is a hardship to him so he elects to receive
under 211, but subsequently the General Counsel says he is entitled to payments under the old law.
Is he going to be penalized because he accepted that check under 2117
MR.
MOORE:
If
he
elects
87
under
211
and
receives
a
check
and negotiates it, he is bound to thereafter
211 only.
I realize the difficulty we might
which means that we are going to have to get
this
question
MR.
General
from
him
to
you
real
fast.
MARKOWITZ:
No, we
Counsel decides that
or
under
the
are
you
old law
you
receive under
get him into here,
the answer to
confusing the thing.
took his right under
took
it
away
from
If
211
him
the
away
and
you forced him to take benefits under 211, the man is innocent,
but he has to have dough.
He has to live on whatever he can
get.
He has no income,
or very little,
Are you going to
penalize
that fellow by keeping him under 211, or are you going
to permit him to go back where he ought to be?
Will you have
the
General Counsel
answer
Will you please include
to the General Counsel?
MR.
MOORE:
Suppose
it
that
in
the
part
your
of
very
General
the
question,
sympathetic
Counsel
protected.
If he
does,
I think we can.pay
all of this year, because no election will
he has no protection there is no election.
says
too?
presentation
is
not
him under 211
be required.
he
for
If
MR. MARKOWITZ:
If the General Counsel says,
"Yes, you
are entitled under the old law," will you let him go back to
that?
MR. STRATTON:
Mike, my earlier point where he helped
me out,
there I think was well taken.
In other words, what
Herb was saying was to exercise an election you hawe:to have
a right to two different
things.
You have to have two.
The
word absolutely requires that in its interpretation,
and since
you do not lose your protection until you elect,
the person
we are talking about here does not have a right to two things,
unless the General Counsel says he is protected;
he has only
a right to 211.
If the General Counsel says he is protected,
and he has, nevertheless,
taken pension under 211 because his
1961 income is over $1,400, he has made an election and must
stay under the new law.
Or he can wait - not take under 211 and then, if his income is reduced below $1,400 next year, he
can come back on the rolls under the old law.
MR.
WEISS:
We
will
accept.
MR. WOORS (ARIZONA):
I have a similar question along
that same line, except this pertains to a widow,
and this came
up very recently,
in fact in the past two weeks.
This widow
was under the old law and shortly after,
sometime in June or
July, we received the pamphlet and the stuff that went out on
the new law,
Now, at that time
we did not have enough questionnaires for the election.
We ran out.
So they sent out a 4100
form and there was another instruction in this, but we do not
know exactly what it was.
At any rate,
at that time the widow
was drawing about $1,000 social security, but she had failed
to report it, did not think that it counted as income,
so the
4100 came back, went into the file,
and she was put under the
new law.
She did not know that she was making an election.
There is nothing in the case file that indicates
that that
widow made an election under the new law.
She has
no instructions as to what they thought she was going to get under the
new law.
Now,
then, when the income questionnaire comes in now
I fill it out for her, but with the social security, which
should have been
in at first, but she did not know, she was
88
still under $1,400.
However,
this drops her down under the
new law.
Now, my contention is that this widow did not know
that she was making an election,
and she willmake such a statement.
1 am going to try to straighten it out, but she has
cashed all those checks since she went under the new law.
MR. MOORE:
Mr. Woods, do I understand that she at no
time actually elected,
that is, she sent in a Form 4100 but
at no time elected to go under 2117
MR.
elected,
strued
try
to
WOODS:
There
is
nothing
And you think
election?
MR.
WOODS:
Yes.
MR.
MOORE:
What
have
they
MR. WOODS:
They
correct. it,
have
indicated
that
not,
us
MOORE:
If
they
do
MR. LIKENS:
Are there
floor?
If not, I would like
Georgia once again.
MR. JENSEN:
1
conferees here if we
at this time to give
date.
MR.
STRATTON:
out
on
the
same
the
there
MR. MOORE:
this as an
MR.
start
in
that says that
regional
said
let
to
you
she
office
miscon-
about
it?
they
are
going
to
know.
any other questions from the
to recognize Mr. Jensen from
believe it would be interesting to the
would give Mr. Stratton an opportunity
the VA's experience under PL 86-211 to
Of
course,
base,
on
to
retrace
March
lst
we
a
little
sent
the
bit
so
we
election
form to all of the pensioners that come under 211.
Now,
immediately after we started receiving elections.
We continued
to receive elections to this time.
We received in the month
of January,
1,500
a week,
or about 6,000 during the month of
January alone.
This is about 500
more per week than we received
in December.
We received about 1,000 per week in December.
I
think the reason for that increase in January would be apparent
to you.
They got an income questionnaire and it rang a bell and
they said,
"Didn't I get something in last March on this
pension deal," and they looked into it and decided to elect.
I would not expect that 1,500
to continue indefinitely,
perhaps through February,
but not
probably through March.
As to
our experience totally in elections to date, we have received
about 17-1/2 percent elections.
About 255,000
elections have
been filed and have been accepted.
In the area of corpus of
estates, which is probably the subject that we
spent the most
time on in this conference shortly after 211 was passed,
I
can give you some experience under that.
As you know, we set up in the instructions a requirement
that we will review in Washington every decision that is made
denying pension benefits because of excessive corpus.
We also
asked to look at cases that were allowed where the estate
exceeded $10,000 so that we could have a cross-section of both
types of cases for one purpose only, and that was to see whether
89
the criterion
quate and how
that we had written in the instruction was adecould we improve it.
As to the immediate reaction
to
estate,
corpus
of
the large
represent
They came
that that
the
first
decisions
we
got,
of
course,
or
bulk of them, even today, were those decisions that
corpus of estate determinations made on elections.
out of these 255,000,
or that additional figure over
were not accepted.
Remember
that
we
told
the
claimants,
"Do
not
hold
back
on an election because you fear that the estate would be a bar,"
so when we got those they had not decided whether it was a bar.
They sent them in to us.
If we agreed it was a bar,
then the
person there,
the electee,
lost nothing.
It merely meant that
he stayed under the old law; he did not come under the new.
We have received since July 1st about 175,000
new claims for
pensions,
probably in that neighborhood,
which would also be
subjected to the corpus of estate test.
figure
I
I
give
am
you
going
this
to
background
furnish
now.
so
you
In
can
other
relate
words,
it
out
to
of
the
255,000
elections and about 175,000
new claims that are 211
only, or about 400,000 cases that are subject to the corpus
of estate test, we have disallowed 930.
This is the figure
that we have here
in Washington today.
As to equalization,
perhaps the greatest attention that should be given to 211 now,
and I think that most of the states are recognizing this,
is
more publicity on equalization.
We estimated early in the
game that we would probaply not get, but that there were
probably about 200,000 beneficiaries or dependents in the
country that would be qualified for the first time under 211
because no longer did they have to have this gimmick we had
before,
the service-connected disability at the time of death.
Now, here I am just estimating,
but the best figures
that I have would indicate that around 40,000 to 45,000
new
cases have gone on the rolls solely because &f equalization.
As to the 70 percent that was estimated,
the item that Mr.
Markowitz always wants to discuss,
the 70 percent figure was
not a figure of who would come in and elect.
It could not be.
But to Congress we are required to tell them the total number
that we feel would be entitled under any new piece of legislation.
The best figures we had at that time, based primarily,
it is
true, on 1954
and 1955
economic data, indicated that
about 70 percent of the people on the rolls would be entitled
to an
increase under 211.
This figure has been severely
challenged in many directions.
I will now give you the results
of the study that we made recently which I think to a very large
extent would seem to justify this original estimate and would
indicate that there are literally thousands of people still
throughout the country that on the basis of their present
income would get more dollars if they elected under 211.
We made a study
judicated in one week
had about 2,900 cases
What
did
we do
with
of every new pension case that was adin December,
all over the country.
We
that were adjudicated during that week.
them?
We
asked
each
office
to
code
for
us certain information about that case.
We asked them to make
a determination as to entitlement in every one of those cases
both under the old law and under the new law, even though we
knew
that
after
could
July 1, 1960.
We got income data
think of in connection with this.
most
of
these
were
only
90
211
cases
and
Of
because
they
everything
the number
filed
that
that
we
we
got,
and
I would
stand
back
of
these
figures
without
any
fear
because,
as I say, they were put on code sheets and they were
not run through the computer, Mike,
and they were sent to
Washington and we punched cards on them and ran
our counts,
we found that counting everything,
80 percent of the people
who had their cases adjudicated during that week in December
got more money or got money where they would not have gotten
it before.
Eighty percent of them were benefited by 211 in
some way.
There
were
a
number
of
them,
of
course,
who
were
not
en-
titled under either one of the laws because basically you have
to be P&T.
You have to have been honorably discharged;
you
have to have 90 days service, be unemployable,
et cetérag.
There were about 350
of them not entitled under either law.
In attempting to find out from this group what percentage
would be equivalent to the elect#ees on July 1, 19607 we restricted
ourselves
there
to
those
people
who
would
be
en-
titled under both laws to something,
on the assumption and
as an equivalent that electee,
after all, on July lst was entitled under the old law, was entitled under the new,law,
and
had
a right
of
election,
so
we
reduced
this
figure,
this
80
percent I spoke of, down to the number of people in that week
in December who were entitled under both laws basically to
something,
and without any preconception of what this figure
would show,
it turns out that 71.6 percent of these people
in that week in December got more money under 211 than they
would
have
The
that were
decreased
484
of
gotten
under
Public
Law
Noi2.
:
average amount of increase that they got of those
increased was $13.51
a month.
The ones that
were
under the new law, and, of course,
there were some,
them,
they
lost
$13.41.
The
spouses'
incomes
out
of
these 2,900 cases caused a reduction in what he would have
gotten under the old law in 23
cases out of 2,900.
The spouse's
income barred him from the receipt of pension in nine cases,
so
the spouse's income played a part in this to the tune of 32
cases out of the entire 2,900.
As to equalization,
and here a moment ago I gave you a
figure of about 40,000 to 45,000,
we found in that one week
670 favorable adjudications out of the 2,900 that would not
have been put on the rolls if it had not been for the equalization feature.
You can see at that rate, 670 a week, even at
the late date in December,
although we are still publicizing
equalization,
the big push is over.
Even at that point we were
getting around 2,600 a month in the country actually being put
on the rolls because of equalization.
The increased income
ceiling
from
$1,400
to
people.
Out
of
number
the
corpus
cause
of
the
of
$1,800
and
2,800,
estate.
$2,700
to
$3,000
we
disallowed
This
basically
that we have up to this point.
This figure of
is in my opinion not a firm comparison at this
70
percent
we
are
in
the
election
going
to
figure
try
When people
game,
this
great
deal
of
order
to
qualify
to
come on
is when
significance
coup
it
in
the
part
of
the
third.
on
the
first
I
that
clear
I spoke
this
the
the
for
cases
is
the
173
be-
resume
71.6 percent
point with the
one
reason
and
up.
rolls for the first time early
recoupment feature carries a
because
income
year,
maybe
it
feel
that
we
91
of
helped
20
if
means
you
part
of
had
a
have
to
recoup
that
generally
larger
number
the
second,
in
you
and
of
re-
maybe
recoupment cases in these new cases adjudicated in the 2,900,
a figure that is out of proportion to what we would have had on
comparing them with those on the rolls July 1, 1960,
and I
think that we are going to have to reduce that 71.6 by this
recoupment difference and we are calling a number of those
cases to Washington to find out exactly how significant
recoupment was, and we will honestly reduce the figure at that
time.
At that stage it is
my opinion that we will come up
with a percentage which is reasonably equivalent to the percentage of people on the rolls today under the old law that
would benefit under the new law.
I would hesitate to guess.
I think it will be reduced from 71.6 down to perhaps 65
percent, perhaps even a little bit lower.
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA:
I think those figures were
very interesting that Mr. Stratton gave us.
Do you have a
breakdown now on those percentages as to how many of them were
live cases and how many death cases?
The reason I am asking
the question, Mr. Stratton,
is that all of the live cases that
you include in that percentage are also subject to reductions
if they go into the hospital under 211 which they would not
have been under the old law.
MR, STRATTON:
1 do not have, Lou, with me here today a
breakdown as to
how many of these cases were live cases and
how many death cases.
The death cases are somewhat larger than
they would be ordinarily because this equalization brought them
in.
I do not know.
I can give you one additional figure on
the point that you mentioned,
though.
Of the 2,900, 484 people
got less under the new law than they would have gotten under
the old as against 1,221 who got more under the new law than
they would have under the old.
Of the 483 who got less under the new law, 458
of them
got less because of the annual income;
23 of them got less because of the spouse's income;
and only three of them got less
because they were in the hospital at the time and were going
to be reduced under this automatic reduction.
They would have
gotten more under the old law between the second and the fourth
month
we
get
those
cut
off
the
first day of
entire group
when
the
got
third month,
less because
but only three cases
of hospitalization.
out
of
(MISSOURI):
The
MR.
HENRY
cases.
These
men
figures
were
given
by Mr.
that
Stratton
are a little misleading
in the overall picture for the simple
reason that almost all veterans who are over age 65
going
under the new law for the first time will have credit coming
from
their
but in the
would be a
MR.
about
a
social
security
and
they will
be
following
reduction
year they will have to
if they were under the
STRATTON:
Yes,
sir.
We
recognize
moment
ago.
That
was
that
in
what
for
the
$90
have $75,
old law.
I
those
was
bracket,
which
talking
people
who
get
$90 today,
in that week in December,
because they are in the
recoupment area,
it would not be fair when we are trying to
make this figure equivalent to the 70 percent on elections to
count that disproportionate share in the category you mention
and that is what I said.
We are going to pull those cases in
and find out how much we should reduce that percentage to adequately represent what we actually had on the rolls on July 1,
1960, but you are correct,
after the recoupment he could end
up in a year and a half or two years getting less under the new
2
law
than
floor
we
are
under
MR.
the
old.
LIKENS:
to Mr.
Any
Foust.
CHAIRMAN
FOUST:
indeed
honored
other
questions?
Ladies
this
and
I
will
gentlemen
of
afternoon
to
have
return
in
the
the
conference,
our
midst
a
gentleman whom most of you should know and some of us are privileged to know,
and we are most happy to present to you at
this time for a bow the Honorable Oliver Meadows, who is the
staff director of the House Veterans' Affairs Committee.
We
are very happy to have you with us.
At this time I want to thank our members of the panel
who so efficiently served us in
this discussion,
and at this
time we will discharge them with a vote of thanks.
Ladies and gentlemen of the conference, we have in our
great organization a group of very fine Legionnaires who for
many years have been doing an outstanding job for us.
I am
referring,
of course,
to our field representatives,
and they
are headed by a very fine, capable,
and outstanding gentleman
whom we all love and admire,
and at this time for brief remarks I am very happy to present to you the Director of our
Field Service, Nicholas Lynch,
affectionately known to us as
Nick.
REMARKS OF NICHOLAS LYNCH, JR.
DIRECTOR, NATIONAL FIELD SERVICE
MR.
LYNCH:
Chairman
Baldy
and
my
fellow
workers
in
the
rehabilitation program of The American Legion:
Again it is
an honor to be granted an opportunity to bring the greetings
of the staff of your National Field Service,
as well as a
personal message.
This is a working conference because it is
composed of men who are dedicated in their work and who continually strive to make each day more fruitful.
The role of
a service officer is an honorable one and while the financial
remuneration is not great,
there is a remuneration that is of
far
greater
value
than
a pay check.
It is
human being
derives
the
form
of
the remuneration and satisfaction
from assisting his fellowman.
that
which
is
received
in
that
a
In the rehabilitation program of The American Legion
there is a double remuneration,
the remuneration that The
American Legion receives as an organization devoted to the
service of those who have served their country in time of war,
and the survivors of those veterans who have been
called to
their final muster,
and there is that remuneration which each
of you as an individual receives from serving his country as
well as his fellowman.
Over the past 40 years the term ''service' has become
synonymous with the name American Legion.
You and your predecessors have established a record unmatched in history,
but I
wonder many times how many of you who have surveyed in your
own minds and thoughts some of the developments,
innovations,
and changes that have taken place in veter ans programs and
policies have given thought to what will
be the final tally of
these events, what will be their ultimate relationship to
veterans .rehabilitation programs,
and yes, even the future role
of the Service Officer.
93
Will these
amen to the
fit,
fessional
of
in
your
the
it is
great
and
service
National
ranks
of
changing practices and
planned elimination of
policies
the role
Field
serve
officers?
the
improver,
is
my
as
review
they
rehabilitation
my belief that
rehabilitation
an
From
Service
army
of
of
target
of
some
of
the
with
The
the work of the Service
program of which he has
a
serve a proof the pro-
our
observations
you
American
daily
Legion,
Officer,
like the
been an architect
opponents
because
if the role of the Service Officer is de-emphasized and his
work hampered,
then it will become just so much easier to proceed with their attack on the program itself.
It is
not my intention here today to pinpoint or to
single out any one development,
even, or change that has
brought me to this conclusion, but I would like to leave this
request with you:
To review in your own minds and thoughts
events of the past ten years, of which many .of you are more
familiar than I, and analyze how each of these events has
affected
you
as
your
That
is
Service
role
as
a Service
something
Officers
that
could
I
Officer.
think
give
each
a great
and
every
amount
of
one
of
thinking
to.
In closing I want to express my sincere thanks to each
and every one of you for the always fine cooperation which we
have received,
and to Chairman Bob McCurdy and Director John
Corcoran our gratitude for the privilege of working with their
fine
staff
--
really
they. are
the
cream
of
the
land
--
and
to
assure you that we are always ready to march with you in the
service of our disabled veterans and to add further prestige
to The American Legion for God and Country.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
say, we appreciate the
are performing for our
Thank you very much, Nick.
very fine job you and your
great organization.
Needless to
assistants
Members of the conference,
at this time our Director,
John Corcoran,
has a very important and a most pleasing job to
perform and I would like at this time
to call upon our Director,
John Corcoran.
MR.
most
CORCORAN:
pleasing
task
Thank
and
it
you,
will
Baldy.
be
a
I do
surprise
rise
to
to perform
the
a
recipient.
Yesterday I told you of a woman who has worked with the
National Rehabilitation Commission for over 39 years,
and I
told you of her not only devotion to duty, her dedication to
service, but also of her great competence.
She is a woman who
symbolizes the growth of The American Legion rehabilitation
program and she is a person that the members of her fair -sex
can well be proud of because not only has she no equal among
her fellow associates,
her male employees,
but she has, as I
indicated yesterday,
risen to supervisory status in our organization.
When I told you about Rachel you joined me in applauding
her.
Today it gives me a great deal of pleasure to announce
that I have been authorized by the Chairman and the members of
the National Rehabilitation Commission to present a citation,
a somewhat more tangible evidence
of our esteem.
me
Ray, will you please
‘read this Citation.
Tt
bring
says:
94
Rachel
up
to
the
platform?
Let
"The American Legion National Rehabilitation
Commission Citation for Meritorious Service.
For meritorious service and loyal cooperation
in The American Legion's Rehabilitation Program,
Rachel Koch is awarded this Citation in
recognition thereof by the National Rehabilitation
Commission
:
It is
Director.
signed
by
of
the
The
American
Legion."
National Chairman
and
by
the
National
MRS. KOCH:
I am speechless.
Thank you all very much.
It has been an extreme pleasure to work with all of you and to
work mostly in behalf of widows and dependents,
although in
some years passed I have also
worked on veterans claims, but
when this was segregated in the Veterans Administration I felt
that my best service and my heart lied mostly with the widows
and dependents,
and so I chose to follow that line of work.
I
would like to say too, for the people in the Veterans Administration,
that I have made
many friends among your people and
I have enjoyed working with them,
and I am just sorry that the
time has come to terminate the association,
that is, the active
association,
but I will never forget any of you.
Thank you
very much,
we
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
have to lose such
I
a
know you
prominent
join with me in sorrow
ubdividual as Rachel.
that
Tonight we will start to proceed with our panel on the
subject of veterans and Dependents Claims Service.
Tonight
I would like the panel members to present themselves at the
platform,
namely, Harry Carper, Jr., Virginia, Department Service Officer; Walter T. Hyde, Rhode Island, Department Service
Officer; Vinson Rabern, Georgia, Accredited Representative;
Kenneth L. Harms, Kansas, Claims Supervisor;
and Dudley L.
Smith,
Idaho, Department Claims Representative.
And with this
group I would like to extend a most cordial invitation to those
who were unable to serve this morning because of the time limit
and I invite the following members to join in this panel,namely,
James
L.
man;
Gordon
Officer;
Crider,
Tennessee,
French,
Mentor
C.
Department
Connecticut,
Murphy,
New
Service
Acting
York,
Officer,
Department
Regional
Chair-
Service
Service
Director;
J. P.
Hone, Ohio, Department Service Director and; Glenn H.
Howe, Oregon, Department Service Officer.
In addition to this
group our staff representatives are R. F. Macdouall and B. A.
Nolan.
MR. CARPER:
Ladies and gentlemen,
there has been a change
in your printed program and that panel scheduled for eleven
o'clock this morning has been combined with the panel scheduled
for
3:15
this
afternoon
and
we
will
serve
as
your
panel.
Before
proceeding I would like to introduce very hastily the members
of the panel.
You have already been introduced to the VA
members of the panel.
I would like to introduce and have them
stand for a bow the remaining members.
Mr. Gordon French,
Acting Department Service Officer from Connecticut} Mr. Mentor
C. Murphy, Regional Service Director from New York; Mr. J. P.
Hone, Department Service Officer from Ohio; Mr. Walter T. Hyde,
Department Service Officer from Rhode Island; Mr. Vinson Rabern,
Accredited Representative from the state of Georgia; Mr. Kenneth
L. Harms, Claims Supervisor from Kansas;
and Mr. Dudley L. Smith,
95
Department Claims Representative from
number of questions on this panel and
body
off
from
a discussion,
but
we
Idaho.
do not
have
30
We have quite a
wish to cut any-
scheduled
questions
and I understand there are some from the floor.
We will allow
the members of the panel to take four questions each and they
have already been scheduled and we will for brevity allow them
to remain in their seats and call the questions and the microphone will be passed from one to another,
If the VA personnel
would like to stay in their seats I believe we can expedite
these questions.
I understand that questions two, three,
and
seven will be answered all at the same time.
If you will
turn to page 11 of your agenda we will proceed with the ques-
tions.
Tonight
I will
ask
Mr.
French
to
read
the
first
four
questions.
A.
V.
MR. FRENCH:
The
Akin of Georgia.
No.l:
Social
directors in lieu of
almost any statement
it that
nations
MR.
the
know,
quire
first
first
Security
to
admit
questions
accepts
as
of
it
submitted
from
They will
of birth.
by
funeral
also
Why
accept
is
liberal in making their determibirth and proof of death?
I will
that
were
statements
death certificates.
of evidence of proof
the VA cannot be
concerning proof
STRATTON:
four
attempt
that
becomes
somewhat
to you and to others that
different types of proof,
if
I may.
I would
aggravating,
be
I
different federal agencies rebut more aggravating, different
federal agencies have different rules or laws as to what is a
marriage, what is acceptable as a child,
et cetera.
This latter
to me, while it is
not part of this question,
is a very broad
area which I think the government can certainly improve on.
Being more specific,
however,
as to thesduestion, we require a
death certificate,
it is
true.
As 1 understand it, the Social
Security will accept something less than that.
We, however,
in
our
business
do
not
have
the
methods
of
verification
that
they
have,
that is, the tax deduction would continue in Social
Security if the person were not truly deceased.
We do
not feel
that basically we could eliminate the requirement of a death
certificate and our
experience has indicated that it is not
really too much of an imposition on the claimant to get the
death certificate.
As to the birth records,
that is, what will
prove the birth,
I really believe that basically our rules
are more liberal in this regard than Social Security.
We list
as acceptable items of proof a number of different things.
Social Security also lists these things almost entirely the same.
There is one difference,
however.
The Veterans Administration
does not require that these different types of proof be submitted in a certain order of preference;
in other words,
a
birth certificate first,
and if you cannot do that then something else, and if you cannot do that,
then do something else.
We will accept any one of these things as proof of birth and
will
not
go
for
the
best
evidence
if we
have
any
one
of
these
items.
From the Social Security handbook that I have an excerpt
from here it would indicate that they have about the same types
of proof listed, but they would require that they be submitted
in the following order of preference,
so I do not believe that
there would be any liberalization of the VA rule in this respect.
MR. FRENCH:
No. two, three and
time.
Are there any questions?
If
seven which will be answered
96
not
all
I will read
at the same
No. 2:
Social Security sendsto their beneficiaries at the
end of each calendar year income questionnaires
to be signed
only if they have exceeded their income limitation.
Why can't
the VA follow the same procedure?
No. 3:
Why is income from savings,
dividends,
considered as income by the VA
Security?
No. 7:
Why doesn't the VA
Social Security,
so as to reduce
increase their efficiency?
such as
and not
interest on
by Social
use income forms
some unnecessary
similar to
workload and
MR. MOORE:
I believe that all three of these actually
go to the same point.
Let me take No. three first,
the interest
on savings.
The VA is concerned with income and Social Security
is concerned with earnings,
so actually what we are looking for
here are two separate things.
Social Security does not consider
interest as earnings unless,
of course,
the claimant,
the wage
earner in their case,
is engaged in a business where he gets
interest as an earning.
For VA purposes it is income.
It
determines whether it shall be counted in meeting the needs
of the veteran and exceeds the income limitation so it does
count as income for our purposes and I believe this is the
difference between the two agencies.
As to questions two and seven,
they go to the procedure
we follow to get data relating to continued entitlement.
Here
again Social Security needs information concerning earnings.
The Veterans Administration needs information relating to income.
Now, for Social Security purposes I can imagine that it
isn't too difficult to define earnings.
Of course,
there are
many if's, but's and wherefor's in our laws and regulations
pertaining to what is income so we do require a statement each
year so that the claimant can tell us what his income is.
In
some cases we may not consider it income and in other cases we
may.
The Social Security does not require the detailed evaluation.
Another reason,
of course,
is under 86-211 we require
the
spouse's
income
to
be
reported.
We
require
corpus
of
es-
tate information.
Of course,
eventually all will be under 86211.
Social Security sends out a card, as I understand it,
once each year.
They state that the claimant should inform
them if his earnings exceed $1.200.
If this comes back in
the affirmative then they
send out a form and request detailed
information.
We, on the other hand, go for the detailed in-
formation
in
each
case.
The
gentleman
that
asked
this
ques-
tion undoubtedly had in mind the peak workload that we have
in January of each year,
and this is true.
We are working on
this, however, with the thought of perhaps spreading some of
this work out over the year. As you may have noticed,
over
the past two years we have coding each claimant into an income
group and we hope to use this in order to level our workload
which we have been getting all in January.
Any questions on
this?
you
MR. AKIN (GEORGIA:
Our questions on these matters,
remember as a carry over from Montgomery, Area C.
MR.
those
MOORE:
I
remember
MR. AKIN:
I thought
of us working in the
Montgomery
you would.
field,
that
S97
Herb,
well.
We find repeatedly,
the same claimants,
if
you please,
in many cases are dealing with their Social Security
contact people and on the other hand they
are dealing with our
people.
We are asked repeatedly why on the one hand Social
Security is asking for certain verification of documents.
Once
the contact man had an opportunity to take a look at them, they
are satisfied.
They pay death benefits and monetary benefits
as you do and we do, as you assist them in getting,
and they
continue
to
ask
us
why
in
so many
ways
it
is
so difficult
for
them to convince the VA.
Where, on the other hand, another
federal agency seems to want to pay them and they tell us, and
I have to share their feeling,
that the VA tries every way in
the world to keep from paying them.
That is the problem, Herb,
as we find it out in the field and I think a lot of these other
fellows have the same problem.
On the question about the income limitation,
the questionnaires,
they have a similar problem.
We know that a lot of
the income questionnaires year in and year out are strictly
down the line none, none, none, or within very rigid limitand your people have to spend yheir time considering
ations,
these questionnaires when they could probably be classified
and put out of the way and the claimant notified that if his
income does get extended to let you know,
just as you are required to do on a change of status.
Wouldn't that expedite
not only in Jamuary of every year, but won't it help the claimants all the way around?
Wouldn't it simplify things and
wouldn't it be an advantage
to do that?
That is our problem.
MR. MOORE:
It may be that in doing what we have in mind,
as I indicated,
the coding of the income groups, we will come
up with something along those lines.
Right now I don't think
we can promise you.
I believe we are headed in that direction.
When we will actually get to it I am not able to say.
However,
the proposal that we have,
the work that we have been doing
in coding these income groups,
could result in a similar procedure where the income is nil.
MR. EGAN:
Mr. Chairman,
I would like to revert to the
first item, because I was on the other side of the room,
the
Veterans Administration
acceptable proof of death.
I believe
that I am the only doctor of mortuary science present in this
room.
In other words,
I am an Undertaker.
Death certificates
are something that we seem to know something about, or should.
The answer that they do require a death certificate is not
true.
The Veterans Administration cannot obtain and neither
can a Service Officer obtain proof of records which do not exist.
Harry will tell you, and this is a specific case at instance.
The veteran died prior to 1913 in Virginia.
The official records of death in Virginia start in 1913,
The question at issue
in this case was a statement from the Undertaker that he buried
the veteran.
Failing in this the Veterans Administration then
requested the widow to obtain..a certificate from the sexton of
the cemetery.
It was a Negro cemetery at Hampton, Virginia,
which had been overcome in a real estate development.
The
records of the church were dissipated.
A simple statement
under 209 that she did not know that there was a legal impediment to her marriage was sufficient to grant entitlement to the
widow.
The death certificate was never produced.
MR. STRATTON:
I stand corrected.
I do
that we require a death certificate.
This is
is also not required on a preflerential basis,
98
recall saying
not correct.
just like the
This
birth
certificate, but I believe that also in the regulations we do
have a number of other ways that death could be established
which will be acceptable.
MR. EGAN:
you needed
ment
That is right, but you
death certificate.
a
MR.
STRATION:
MR.
HYDE:
I
know.
Question
You
are
number
made
going
the
to
catch
state-
me.
four.
No. 4:
On VA Form 21-4179, who can be
of deducting unusual medical expenses?
poses
definite
included
for
pur-
MR. FARMER:
Any persons who are members of the family
are included for the purposes of deducting unusual medical expenses
That's a slightly different rule than the just debts
under Public Law 211,
before
MR. CARPER:
proceeding
That concludes
I would like to
our first four questions,
make an announcement.
but
«ne esANIIOUNCEMENt
....,
We
will
continue
with
question
No.
5
and
I
will
call
have
one
question.
on
Mr.
Hyde.
MR.
SHORTER
(COLORADO):
I
just
Mr.
Moore made a statement
that everyone would ewentually be under
86-211.
Do you have any late scoop on that?
Are we going to
do
this
because
the
MR.
MOORE:
I
MR.
but
old
ones
are
going
to
die
off?
What
is
long
time
to
get
the
reaction
SHORTER:
couldnit
You got the reaction.
get the mike.
.I
got
up
MR.
MOORE:
The
MR.
SHORTER:
MR.
HYDE:
No.
that
5:
he
the
story?
waited
a
to
that,
times
only
thing
I
can
suggest
is
here
three
let's
wait
Thank
you,
and
see,
know
under
Section
timely
law
That
Question
a
No.
of
Title
38,
MR. FARMER:
The short
specifically requires
it
the date on which his
qualifying conditions
would
tainly
answer.
done for a veteran who
an automebile or other
USC,
and
therefore
did not
conveyance
did
not
answer to that is no, because the
be filed within the time limit spe-
You have five years after discharge to apply and in
if the qualifying disability arose after service,
he
has had three years
Notwithstanding the
that
VA
5.
Can anything be
was eligible for
1901
typical
apply?
cified.
addition
I
is
time
certainly
limit
like
MR.
to
AKIN:
to file.
And then there is
time limit specified he has
entitlement to
was determined
basis,
like
Mr.
to
see
any
take
a
look
at
it.
Thank
you,
sir.
Akin.
99
final right.
year from
compensation for
in which to file
claim
If
the
one
you
that
have
I am not
at
one of the
a claim.
has
been
I would
cer-
the
moment
familiar
one
denied
on
with where
brought to
that
your
MR.
ZEGLIN:
MR.
HYDE:
question originated
attention.
I
have
Question
three
No.
of
but
I
will
see
that
it
is
them.
6.
No. 6:
Will the VA authorize the cost of nursing care
in behalf of a veteran who is rated 100 percent service- connected for a neuropsychiatric condition to a member of his
family in whose home he is receiving such care?
A.
MR. STRATTON:
Mr. Akin, we
here in this question,
aid and
MR.
AKIN;
No.
are talking
attendance?
about
A.
And
sir.
MR. STRATTON:
You are not talking about aid and attendance.
Are you
talking about the possibility of some future proceedings
in the law under the Department of Medicine and Surgery whereby
some compensation might be paid for people outside the hospital
in the way of nursing care,
intermediate care?
Is that what you
are speaking to?
asked
which
If we
MR. AKIN:
I wish I could answer it but this
by one of the members in my department and I
one.
I will have to try to see him and pass
have a question we will bring it back.
question was
am not sure
it along.
MR. STRATTON:
Let's give it two shots.
I will talk about
A.and A, for a minute and then tomorrow you ask the
same questions of the Medical Panel.
In paying an additional allowance
for aid and attendance to a psychiatric veteran rated 100 percent outside the hospital there, of course,
is no bar whatsoever in the law to paying this additional amount which would
be the staturory L. rate just because the nurse that he contemplates is a member of his family.
There is no bar in this
regard whatsoever.
On the nursing home,
if that is the aspect
that you are
concerned about,
I would suggest that you discuss
that tomorrow.
I know this is a controversial subject right now.
If you would ask the Department of Medicine and Surgery they
could discuss it.
MR. HYDE:
question No. 8.
No.
7
having
been
answered
we
will
jump
to
No. 8:
Records Control Schedule VB-1 and other directives
charge the manager of a VA Regional Office with the responsibility of removing from claims folders for disposal,
duplicate
and unnecessary record material.
What are the qualifications
and training of personnel assigned to the removal of this
material?
When the removed material is ready for disposal,
is
it reviewed by adjudication personnel to assure that ondy material authorized has been removed?
the
MR. STRATTON:
We have Mr. Curtiss that you all know from
Kdministrative Service here and he will answer that question.
MR. CURTISS:
In answering this question,
and it has been
asked by several of the offices,
our TB 20-11 was issued last
July and the subject is "Unnecessary Material in Veterans Records."
It specified the Regional Office Managers are responsible for
100
assuring that employees designated to remove material from
veterans folders are qualified to make that determination,
The
designation of such employees is left entirely to the judgment
of the manager so that he may select the best qualified employees without restriction.
The directive stipulates that
employees delegated to remove material from veterdms folders
will be properly trained.
Again the training is the responsibility of the manager and it is
geared so that he may pick
out and select the employees who can do this best.
The Central
Office directives do not require that all material removed from
veterans
folders
be
reviewed
by
adjudication
personnel
before
it is disposed of.
Certain material is so sharply defined in
the directives and in the Records Control Schedule that it may
properly be removed by adequately trained administrative employees without review by Adjudication Division personnel. Other
material is authorized for disposal only after a responsible
Adjudication Division person has said that it could be removed.
It is not necessaey for adjudication personnel to review all
material in this category, but they may make spot-checks if the
material has been rémmved by trained personnel who have demonstrated their ability to make the proper selection.
In this
‘connection,
and I am sure you are all aware of this,
all of us
are equally concerned with the proper retention of necessary
records.
It is
really a reinstatement of the old policy of the
Veterans Administration and of our department.
We receive,
create, and maintain all records necessary to insure that significant action taken in reference to a claim is adequately
protected and documented.
This safeguard to protect the interests of the claimant and of the agency,
represents the basic
records
management
although of major
basic policy.
policy
of
practical
the
department.
importance,
is
Disposal
secondary
of
to
records,
this
We insist upon adequate documentation,
but we are desirous
that no unnecessary material be filed down and that the record
material of transitory walue be disposed of after the purpose
has been served.
If the material under consideration falls
within the description of records to be disposed of, that action
should be taken by whoever is compdtent and authorized to do so.
If the authority for disposition is questionable,
the decision
must favor retention in the folder.
If there is any doubt about
it we want it left there.
In this connection the VA has a
double responsibility both to the veteran and his dependents
and to the VA.
Disposal instructions will be developed,
coordinated,
and approved with full knowledge of this responsibility.
MR.
staff
CARPER:
would
like
Tonight
to make
Mr.
Golembieski
from
the
Washington
a comment.
MR. GOLEMBIESKI:
I just want to inform you that the
question was propounded because of a discussion that I had had
with Bill Grund of New Jersey.
He was concerned over the calibre,
and training,
and supervision of the personnel that were charged
with the removal of these redundant or surplus records from the
veterans claims folder,
and I see that Bill is getting ready to
rise to the question.
I would appreciate it very«much if you
would speak to it.
MR.
letter to
feel that
WILLIAM
GRUND
(NEW
JERSEY):
Our
manager
wrote
a
the Central Office in regard to this situation.
We
a mere clerk in Administrative certainly isn't quali101
fied to determine what should be taken out of a case folder
and destroyed.
We have had this edperience.
The clerk goes
back, particularly the folders of World War I, and pulls out
duplicate records just because they are duplicate records without reading or making any determination as to whether or not
they have any value.
I think that you will agree with me that
when this was done some years ago Adjudication was the one to
make the determination.
We feel that the Adjudication Division
should be the one to make the determination whether or not
material shall be removed from that folder.
At the present time
all gf the material that has been removed from case folders in
the Newark office has been retained because of the protests
being
made
by
the
Service
am just wondering also,
letter from our manager
from
MR.
the
CURTISS:
Newark
It
office,
Officer
Mr.
has
from
all
organizations.
Chairman, whether or
been answered to the
has.
I
were
might
sent,
say
that
with
I believe,
I
not this
Newark office.
two
the
letter
examples
of
what had been removed and I will read this one paragraph of our
reply.
Part of this letter contains some of the information
I just gave you before.
We have this answer with respect to
the exhibits they sent
in.
"We have examined the copies of materials submitted
with
your letter.
However, we cannot tell definitely the real
advantages
of
documents in
Adjudication
these
papers
the folder.
Officer?"
without
reference
What
the
was
to
other
decision
of
your
I might tell you this:
That this is nothing
new in the
history of the VA.
We have the same interest exactly that you
have.
There are many papers in these folders that can be removed by anyone with any intelligence and a little trainig -copies of the old changes of address and things of that sort.
There are others which are on the border line as to whether
they should or should not be retained.
If there is any doubt
about it, we keep them.
I think in the case of Newark, (and I
might tell you this letter is dated February 16 and I have a
copy here
and will be glad to show it to you if you would like
to
see
the
adjudication
should
it),
we
have
told
the
manager
to
refer
this
material
to
officer.
The two exhibits that were
not have been removed.
sent
in,in
my
personal
opinion,
MR. GRUND:
But this is not going to be found on the spot
check which is being done at the present time.
In other words,
they take this material and just spot check it.
MR. CURTISS:
1It depends entirely on who is doing it, the
training he has had and the confidence the manager and the adjudication officer have in those people.
Frankly, we have had
people in the administrative division that we wouldn't dare
permit to remove materials.
MR.
qualified
GRUND:
to make
We say that a poor clerk
that determination.
certainly
isn't
MR. CURTISS:
The answer to that is that the manager has
to pick people upon whom he can rely and in whom the adjudication officer has some confidence.
102
not
be
(RHODE
BROWNING
MR.
evidence
medical
any
will
there
folder?
the
from
removed
assume
I
Can
ISLAND):
MR. CURTISS:
The material which is to be removed is
listed not in its entirety,
but by examples,
in the TB 20-11,
The type of things we are talking about
issued July 20, 1960.
are these: Duplicate material,
including material specifically
required to be removed by VA directives,
such as duplicates
when the originals are the official copies.We dre talking about
exact duplicates.
We are not talking about copies that have
additional notations on them, but copies which duplicate the
official record copy,
including unnecessary suspense,
control,
and other duplicate copies of letters,
memoranda,
and forms,
copies and photostats of
documents,
unnecessary material which
has
no
reference
value
after
it
has
served
its
purpose
to
trans-
mit and/or to control that for which it was created.
These are
suspense and control copies of forms,
correspondence and
memoramdurs which were prepared solely for the purpose of suspense, pending,
or follow-up and which do not contain notations
of record value, diary cards which have expired,
envelopes,
transmittal media,
including those which are returned as
acknowledgements or receipts and which do not contain notations
of record value.
The key words throughout are 'of record value."
MR.
BROWNING:
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
Mr.
you.
Golembieski
would
like
to
ask
an
additional
question.
MR. GOLEMBIESKI:
Mr.
to the question of removing
non-record material when it
understand
that
in
Curtiss,
I wonder if you would
redundant or transmittal media
is received in the mail room.
in
room
that
the
the
the
letter
adjudicating
of
some
offices
strip
transmittal
and
you
do
have
incoming
then
forward
trained
record
the
speak
or
I
personnel
material
material
from
to
the
unit.
MR. CURTISS:
That is correct,
Ed.
As you know, we have
had considerable discussion about one office where the service
officer complained to the manager,
and I believe to the Washington office here,
that our mail room people were taking off
transmittal memoranda in the mail room and sending the documents with the file to the adjudication officer.
However, we
find from tk manager that he has an agreement with the service
officers.
I omitted one salient thing.
Each of these letters
that is taken off in the mail room is returned to the service
officer.
The service officer
knows what was taken off and he
is at liberty and has on occasion taken up with the manager any
case where in his opinion he felt the transmittal should not
have been so removed.
My
there
recollection
were
four
such
of
cases
it --
and
out
of
this
a
was
great
sometime
number
of
back--
is
transmittal
media.
MR. CORCORAN:
Charlie,
I would like to make a comment
on that point because I think it is terribly important.
It may
be more important than the question raised by the prepared
submission.
We are talking not about deleting from the record
evidence or material that was at one time necessary to document and support some decision,
but now we are discussing
material submitted and screened from the view of the adjudicators
103
and the adjudicating agency before
one, your reference to the service
not
cover
thie
bulk
of
the
people
any decision is made.
Point
organizations obviously does
who
are not
represented
by
a
service organization.
Point two, you say that where there is
a question about the essentiality or the value of the piece of
mail the matter will be taken up with
someone in the adjudicating division,
but you
have to have experience and you have
to have knowledge before a question arises in your mind and I
am not at all sure that the complete interests of the claimants
are being properly safeguarded by permitting persons other than
those trained and experienced in adjudication procedures to
screen out material.
MR. KORELLA (MISSOURI):
I have been wondering whether
the
purpose of removing these papers from the case file is merely a
matter of reducing the size and the space occupancy of the folder.
In that case, if that is true has the VA ever considered
microfilming
sheet rather
the records
than having
and having the
a folder, say,
thick?
I would like to know what
their thoughts on microfilming.
the
record on one-half
four or five inches
measure
is
of
the
VA
and
MR. CURTISS:
I am not able to tell you what the thoughts
are on microfilming,
except to say, for more than a year,
there
has been one or more groups in the VA concerned about doing
something about the folder.
This is one of our expensive expensive records
and certainly the most important.
I at one
time had been a member of such a group.
Microfilming has been
considered.
As of the moment,
so far as I know,
it was not
gone into because of the costs involved and the difficulties
of adjudicating cases on micro film.
I don't know what tomorrow will bring,
but the last report going to the administrator made the statement
that in view of the fast advance in
technology,
microphotography,
and so on, we don't know what
we might do tomorrow.
It is something that is now being considered by the VA.
How actively,
I couldn't say, but it certainly is one of the
things we want to do.
To answer your other question, we have
a dual purpose in keeping unnecessary papers out of the file.
The size of the folder is the major purpose.
Space is the least
one.
It costs money to find the space to put the equipment in,
but above everything else it takes your time, and the adjudicators'
time, and the time of the rating boards,
and the Board
of
Appeals
and
any
to
wade
unnecessary.
paper from a
through
itself
and
if
you
we
be
the
first
will
MR.
HURLEY
a
maze
We haven't
folder that
know
of
of
papers
which
are
irrelevant
the slightest intention of taking
has any
bearing whatever on the case
any
to
agree
(KANSAS
CITY,
instance
where
that
has
with
and
correct
it.
you
MISSOURI,
REGIONAL
been
done,
OFFICE):
I
would like to know what liability the Veterans Administration
recognizes where important pieces of paper have been removed
from the file such as an informal claim.
We submit a transmittal form on the bottom of which is specifies,
"This is submitted as an informal claim for part 3." or part 1, or. .whatever it is,
Two weeks later,
three weeks later, or maybe six
or eight,
it shows up.
We review it again for some reason.
It
comes
to.
the
is in the file
documents were
cation officer
rating
board
six
months
with a date stamp
submitted,
but in
says that so long
104
later
and
there
the
2-22
on it, the same date that both
our regional office the ad judias this other piece of paper has
been apparently thrown away by someone,
they cannot recognize
the date of the informal claim.
All they can recognize is the
date of the 526,
which may be two weeks later or six weeks
later, and consequently,
we have had possibly three or four
cases in the same exact category which the veteran has lost
anywhere from two or three days to six weeks pay.
Would you
recognize that you are responsible for the loss of pay to the
veteran to the extent of recognizing my copy in my office
and my 2-22 with a date stamp of the date that the informal
claim was filed.
That is my specific question.
MR. CURTISS:
That is:-a question: 1 wouldn't attempt to
answer but I will say this much.
If that is being done in the
regional office they had better get a new man.
MR.HURLEY.:
Now that the horse got out we. lock the
We have the situation changed.
But how about these ones
have already lost some money on the basis of your people
ing away vital records?
door.
that
throw-
MR. STRATION:
In the first place,
I certainly agree with
Mr. Curtiss that it should not be done.
The most innocent looking document sometimes
is very important and that is the type
of thing you are talking about.
In the individual case that
you are talking about, do you want my opinion? If I had your
file copy and your certification that you did submit this and
your 2-22 on the same day,
I would take it as an informal claim
whether
they
threw
it
out
of
the
Would
you
notify
MR.
HURLEY:
MR.
take
STRATTON:
I
care of it.
folder
Mr.
or
not.
Halloran
to
that
effect,
sir?
will
will
not
only
notify
Mr.
Halloran;
we
MR. CRIDER (TENNESSEE):
Let me go in a little different
vein,
I guess not so much of keeping something in as still
getting more out.
A paeticular interest of mine for more than
a year,
and the central office has been considering it, but
to what extent I do not know, has been the question of retaining
marriage certificates,
divorce decrees and birth certificates,
where
they
have
served
their
purpose
and
we
have
seen
files
where there has been as many as six marriage certificates
and
they just keep filing them in there.
Social security is a good
example,
where they certify that they have seen this divorce
decree or this marriage certificate and then give it back to the
man.
In other words, VA is the only agency that keeps it.
If
it goes to another agency first,
they certify it and give it
back to him.
If it goes to the VA, first they keep it and then
when he goes to other agencies he has to get another copy.
What has been done along this line, about keeping those out or
making them certify those?
MR. MOORE:
You threw a mickey at me there at the last
point.
I was goihg to say lt may fit in with this.
We are
testing in the Wilkes-Barre office right now a procedure on
what will be retained in the claims folder and active folder.
We have an action folder,
I believe it is called.
This is
being tested.
It goes to what will be retained in the folder
that is
apt to be needed immediately.
Then for a while the inactive material will be kept separately and perhaps ultimately
disposed of.
This is now being tested.
The results are not
yet
known.
This is being done by the group that Mr. Curtiss referred
105
to.
MR. CRIDER:
Herb, does
divorce decrees,
and such?
MR.
MOORE:
All
that
documents
in
include
marriage
claims
folder.
certificates,
MR. €RIDER:
The reason I say that is Russ Turrill came
down to Tennessee a year or so ago and we went to the welfare
department and the social security and the VA and we compared
the three and all three need in most instances approximately
the same information.
The welfare and social security had
that marked on a sheet.
The VA had them stuck in the file and,
as you know, many
of these increase the size of the file tremendously,
and 1f you want to reduce the file there is the
quickest way to reduce the file.
Our veterans and women in
Tennessee marry a lot of times and they get divorces once in a
while.
That is the way as I see it, that we can do more to
reduce the size of those files
than any other thing
right at
this point,
and it causes a hardship to the veteran in many
instances because he has only one copy.
If he ever gets to
the VA first,
then he is going to
have to get another copy for
these other agencies.
give
MR.
CARPER:
time
for
two
MR.
CENTOLA
Because
more
of
the
questions.
(LOUISIANA):
lateness
of
I have
refer
to
the
hour,
back
I
to
will
the
previous speaker, Mr. Curtiss.
First of all, I would like to
correct the record.
There is no agreement,
if he is talking
about my particular department, between the service officer and
the VA down there.
It is
true we are getting those things, but
we are doing it only to protect the veteran.
Secondly,
and the general opinion around here seems:
to be
that the adjudication department seems to be the place where
the removal should be done;
it is not being done and we forwarded five cases where it has been injurious to these veterans
and we would like to know wht it is still being
taken out at
the mail room level.
MR. CURTISS:
As I understand it, in the whole
letters that were sent up here there were four.
Was
talked to the manager, someone
in your office?
MR.
CENTOLA:
That's
MR.
CURTISS:
On
those
question about it they would
they do go back to when they
group of
it you who
right.
we
told
him
that
if
stay in the folder.
are removed?
there
Am
was
I
any
correct
MR. CENTOLA:
They go to the service officer
but we
be doing their work and our work, too. But how about those
gone over by a service organization?
can't
not
MR. CURTISS:
Let's put it this way.
We have 67 regional
offices.
As of right now I know of two from whom we have heard
anything at all on this subject.
One is the New Orleans office
and the other is Newark.
In your case have the exhibits which
were sent in given any indication that what was being removed
the Newark office was wrong.
In the case of the New Orleans
office as to
the exhibits that we saw there was nothing in
them that we could find that would alter the decision down there.
106
They were transmittal
heard this morning on
in adjudication.
media almost
this ADP and
in entirety and I think you
others about the workload
consider
1142
am
talking
about
one
the
MR.
CENTOLA:
Do
you
MR.
letters.
CURTISS:
No.
I
MR.
CENTOLA:
That
was
of
a
transmittal?
the
cases
typewritten
we
sent
up
here.
MR. CURTISS:
That one would have been corrected in that
particular case and again,
it is a question of training.
Don't
forget the adjudication personnel are just as human as any
other personnel.
Whether they are in one division or the other
doesn't affect their judgment.
room
is
MR.
CENTOLA:
and
it
is
Except
disposed
MR. CURTISS:
that correct?
when
you
take
it
away
from
it,
they
are
not
getting
them
at
the
of,
As
I
understand
MR.
CENTOLA:
We
are not
MR.
CURTISS:
You
are
MR.“CENTOLA:
' No,
sir.
this
destroyed;
point.
not?
MR. CARPER:
1 hate to shorten this discussion because I
realize it is important,
but I am going to ask the gentleman in
the rear to give his question and let's hasten along, please.
MR. HENRY(MISSOURI):
Along this liné last year|I believe
it was, instructions came out that they were going to go through
death cases and pick out the permanent information and put it in
a separate folder and hold it in the filing section and then
the original folder would be stored in a separate place down in
the basement or somewhere else.
I just wondered what happened
to that and if there has been any development on it.
in
MR. MOORE:
Wilkes-Barre,
MR.
will
That is the
Pennsylvania
MARKOWITZ:
The
test that
I
right now.
mentioned
is
going
place
could
in
the
best
you
MR. CARPER:
We will proceed with the
ask Mr. Rabern to read the question.
find
question
now
on
world.
and
I
MR. RABERN:
This question was submitted by Reuben Garnett
of Washington.
"On February 11, 1959,
veteran wrote to VA advising he is 47 years old and has just suffered a heart attack and
was ordered by his physician to quit work and 'how was he to
apply for disability pension.'"
He was sent a formal application that was executed and returned to VA on September 8, 1959,
claiming heart attack in 1958
and retired due to disability
January 1959.
He was examined by VA in October 1959
and it was
confirmed that he had sufficient disability to meet the schedular
requirement for a permanent and total rating.
Based on this
information on what date should disability pension commence?"
MR.
FARMER:
This
is
a
loaded
107
question.
I
recognize
it
as
such.
First,
it would be paid, under the facts that have
been recited,
from the date of the informal claim;
that is, the
date the informal claim was received by the VA, namely, February
11, 1959,
That is premised onthe basis that it is a good in=
formal claim and that within one year, namely, by September
8, 1959
a formal claim was filed.
He filed his form 526.
It is
also premised on the fact that he was in fact permanently and
totally disabled throughout that entire period.
MR.
RABERN:
Question
10
comes
from
Virginia.
"Information Bulletin 8-13, Paragraph 9, provides in substance a 0 per cent rating for resection of the right middle
lobe of the lung, whereas the Rating Schedule
provides a 30
per cent rating for removal of either of the remaining lobes.
Since there is some disability resulting from the removal of
the middle lobe, why is there not provided a rating of 10 per
cent or 20 per cent for the removal of the middle lobe?"
MR. STRATTON:
The rating schedule has to be based on the
average loss of earning capacity because of these different
degrees of disability.
This is the mandate we have in the law.
Apparently,
and at this point I don't think we have received
cases to indicate this is wrong,
the best medical opinion at
this time would indicate the average person is not economically
impaired because of the removal of the middle lobe of the right
lung.
This is the only way they could justify the zero per
cent that has been assigned.
Now,
this schedule is constantly being revised,
and let
ne take it more in order.
If you had an individual case that
had nothing but this disability,
and I mean this is your only
problem,
middle lobe,
and in this individual case it is
apparent
to you that he has been economically impaired because of this
we would have the authority in Washington,
if you would document this and send it to us in that unusual case,
to grant an
extra schedular rating.
If we received a sufficient number of
these to indicate that the average loss economically is not
zero, but is ten or 20, or 30 per cent,
then we would immediately
recommend to the Administrator
that he approve the proper percentage,
MR.
RABERN:
Thank
you.
Question number11 is submitted by my colleague, A. V.
Akin from the State of Georgia.
"May a widow continue to draw
increased compensation benefits at the same time the child is
receiving training under the War Orphans'
Educational Program?"
MR.
PECKARSKY:
The
answer
to
that
question
depends
on
the
age and the condition of the child.
Once there has been an
election of Orphans Educational Assistance for a child over the
age of 18, then concurrent benefits cannot be paid, but as long
as the child is under 18 or helpless,
both benefits can be paid.
MR.
RABERN:
'Thank
you.
Question number 12 comes from Illinois.
"It is our understanding that effective July 1, 1961,
retired civil service
employees will be eligible to obtain health
insurance through
the
Government.
to
$6
per
The
month toward
Government,
the
as
premium.
108
we
understand,
Will
the
$3
to
will
pay
$3
$6
paid
by
the Government be considered
service benefits?"
about
MR.
MOORE:
this
and
We
we
talked
found
income
to
that
the
there
for
Civil
are
veterans
drawing
Service
Commission
two
types
of
non-
policies
or insurance plans that the claimants could take.
One would
be where the Government makes a direct contribution of $3 or
$6 and paid this directly to an insurance company.
In another
situation the $3 or $6 could be paid to the claimant who would
pay for his
own plan,
They tell us that in the latter case
they will follow up to be sure that the claimant did pay this
to the company for his own plan.
If they find that he did not,
they will recover the money from him and on the basis of this
information on February 24 we released a teletype to all of
our regional offices telling them that this
$3 or $6 would not
count as income.
tion
MR.
13.
CARPER:
I
will
ask
Mr.
Harms
to
continue
with
ques-
MR. HARMES:
Number 13:
"Is it possible for the VA
do away with the requirement of information pertaining to
employability in cases of veterans over 65
years of age?"
to
un-
MR. FARMER:
“The answer to that is no.
«Section 321 of
Title 38 requires that a veteran in order to be entitled
to
pension,
that is, World War I, iil and Korea, must be permanently and totally disabled,
and there is no exception for
veterans that are over 63.
I think you are all familiar with
TB
21-18
which
makes
the
point
that
the
older
the
veteran
and
the higher the disability,
the less evidence of unemployability
is the rule,
That's the guiding light and certainly,
the
veteran over 65
with only the 10 per cent requirement with
evidence of unemployment
is in that category.
It just occurs
to me that if the TB 21-18 is followed,
the problem would be
minimal in this area.
MR. HARMS:
Number 14:
"Why cannot the VA make the
effective date granted cases considered under VAR 1142 by the
service organizations comparable to the dates assigned when
the case is submitted by the local rating board?!
MR. FARMER:
That is a good one.
As you all know, for
many years when cases were submitted under old VA Regulation
1142, the effective date was the date the CO approved it.
That was regardless of whether it had been submitted by a
service organization or whether it was submitted by the regional
office.
When the Administrator changed the effective date of
VAR 1142 cases to the date evidence shows entitlement or date of
claim, whichever was later, we were in a different situation.
Requests from the service organization are in the nature of
administrative review.
When it gets to the Central Office we
have to examine that case and we might apply
VA Regulation
1105(a)
to
determine
whether
or
not the
regional
office
made
a clear, unmistakable error in failing to submit that case
under what is now known as VA Regulation 1321.
That is old
1142.
If it is determined that the rating board or the regional
office should have submitted that case under that regulation
and that it was a clear and unmistakable error in failing to do
so, then CO will establish the effective date in the same manner
109
as they would have had the regional office submitted it; but,
on the other hand,
if the difference is in the area of opinion
we then have to apply the VA Regulation 1105(b)
which calls
for a prospective effective date;
that is, the date CO makes
the decision,
1t is as simple as that.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
It doesn't sound simple to me.
If a
fellow is entitled to it at the time it gets in your office,
and if you find he should have gotten it in August,
you should
pay him in August,
not in December.
MR.
FARMER:
What
difference between
able doubt,
and we
are
talking
about
1105(a)
and
could spend
we
1105(b),
the day
just as under reasonon that subject.
the
MR. HARMSs
case back to
differs
with
Number 15:
the rating
will
not
the
example
in
We
almost
birth
MR.
read
that
STRATTON:
now
is
the
'Why cannot the adjudicator
board when the veteran's date
considered
by
the
rating
board?"
the
example.
send
of
I
this.
have
to
read
I
have an answer here and now that I have looked at it and read
the example a little better I believe that the answer I have
written here is wrong.
The example that was given was that
the
rating board looks at a case.
They think the man is
over 65.
They don't look at the disability too carefully because he only needs 10 per cent.
At this point I would have to say that they should not
do this, but they go ahead and grant P and T.
This is the
example.
This goes to the adjudicator.
The adjudicator
decides the evidence he has in the file indicates that the man
is under 65.
Now, the example goes on to say that under these
circumstances
it
is
thenrvery
difficult
to
erase
the
of the case by the rating board.
In this case I get
pression that it was allowed first, etc.
I believe,
I know the purpose of the question and can answer it
denial
the imthough,
this way?
If a rating board grants P & T to a man they think is
over 65
and he has only a 10 per cent degree of disability,
if it turns out, and the adjudicator takes it back to them and
shows tham that the man is really under 65,
it is
impossible
for the board at that point to disallow that case. They have
already said that he is unemployable due to his disability
and once they
say that they either have to grant it locally
if he
meets their percentage standards or they have to submit
it in here to Mr. Farmer where the percentage standards have
nothing whatsoever to do with it, so I must say to the gentleman, from Illinogis that I am not as concerned about his example,
that is, the question itself,
as by the implication here that
a rating board
says in one breath that the man is unemployable
due to his disability and then when they find his age is not
quite what they thought it was, they then say he is employable
regardless of his disability.
This to me is wrong and if this
is happening in the region the question originated from, we
will certainly correct it.
MR. CRIDER:
Let me ask you about something in the same
vein, Mr. Stratton.
I have seen the rating boards take a case
and consider a man permanently and totally disabled and date
it from the date he reached 65.
Now,
the evidence was submitted and there has been no change from three or four months
110
before
when
he
filed
his
claim,
but
from
the
date
he
is
65
when
he
from
the
date
he
filed
his
claim.
MR.
STRATION:
MR. CRIDER:
couldn't do it if
That
is
was
they
will
permanent
That
only date
and
happens
it
total,
every
not
day.
right.
In a reverse trend you just said
they went from a different term.
that
they
MR. STRATTON:
Don't let me say anything too wrong here,
Art, but, as I understand,
it ‘is possible to grant that case
locally to get some money to that veteran immediately and pay
it from his 65th
birthday.
They are supposed to, after they
make the award,
send it in to
us to see if we can grant it at
an earlier date.
are
MR.
CRIDER:
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
going
= They
haven't
This
is
in
FARMER:
We knew they
to promise to give it
done
that,
an
that
is
being
printed.
were going
to them.
to
ask
it
IB
for
so
we
MR. STRATTON:
This makes sense to me.
If the man is
pretty close to being 65
and he meets the local percentage requirements and he is unemployable due to disability,
what we
are going to tell them to do is to
pay the man P.and T from
his 65th
birthday locally,
get the money to him, and then
immediately submit the case to us to see if we can't grant it
from
an
earlier
date.
MR. HARMS:
Number 16:
"It is requested that regional
offices be once again instructed concerning their responsibility
in forwarding an employment statement
to the veteran when it is
indicated on the 10-2545
that he might be eligible for a 100
per cent rating.”
MR. STRATTON:
I certainly would hope that rating boards
are doing this.
I would agree immediately with the implication
of the question,
that if a rating board has before them a document, whether it is an examination report or whatever and there
is an
indication medically,
for instance,
and they should look
to that first,
that the man is entitled to an increased rating,
that
is what
the
man
should
get.
If
any
other
aspect
of
that
document including the employment
information that he furnishes
indicates that he can't work because of his disability,
then
the case ought to be developed.
This is a criticism that I
have not heard before.
We have told
our boards to do this, but
on the chance that this is not being done it is so important,
because it is
this total rating that we are seeking here; we
are going to put out an IB
item which will tell them once more
that they have to watch this.
MR. CARPER:
Because of the lateness of the hour we would
like to proceed with the questions and then if you have one you
want to ask a question about at the close, would you please at
that time ask the question?
We will proceed and get to our
questions because we are running way behind.
MR. HONE:
Number 17:
'Would it be possible for the Administrator to bring again to the attention of the Postmaster
General and the postmasters
throughout the United States that VA
111
checks
may
be
forwarded
on
the
basis
of
a change
of
address
with the post affice?
All personnel of the many post offices
should be once again advised of the serious problem that develops
when a benefit check is returned to the Treasury Department
rather than being forwarded to an address on record with the
local post office."
Office
MR.
PECKARSKY:
Department.
We
We
have
are
very good
both
relations
interested
in
with
the
same
the
Post
thing,
which is getting as many checks as possible out to the right
address.
It was brought to our attention at a couple of local
stations that certain local postmasters were not forwarding
mail.
We called this to the attention of the Post Office and
through their regional supervision they corrected this at the
local stations.
Then it occurred to us that possibly there
were other postmasters
throughout
the country that were not
complying with their regulations that they forward mail to
the beneficiary at his new address.
So we again got in touch
with the Post Office Department and late in October -- I think
it
was
around
the
23rd
--
they
published
in
one
of
their
national postal bulletins a directive ordering all postmasters
to comply with their regulation that mail must be forwarded
where the veteran has left a forwarding address.
any
the
We watch this pretty closely.
If we hear any more about
further need of this we will certainly get in touch with
Post Office again, but we have heard no recent complaints.
MR, HONE:
Number 18:
"Why is it not possible for a
guardian of a minor beneficiary to pay the expenses of last
sickness
of his
sation
and
burial
national
benefits
of
a
deceased
veteran
from
the
proceeds
service life insurance policy or death compenthat have been
approved to his minor child?"
MR. PECKARSKY:
There are two things that prevent it.
The
first,
of course,
is that the Federal Exemption Statutes prohibit the use of these gratuitous benefits to pay debts.
Probably,
the most important criterion is the fact that although
the child has a moral obligation to pay for his deceased father's
funeral, he really doesn't have any legal obligation to do so.
There are a few states that do have an enabling statute where,
if there isn't anybody else who can come forward to pay this,
to
avoid
a
pauper's
grave
and
a
burden
to
the
state,
these
few states have enabling statutes which will permit payment
of a limited amount for burial out of the child's estate.
This
is not, however,
true in most states.
In most states the
guardian just would not be empowered by the court that appointed
him to pay a moral and not a legal obligation out of the estate
of thei child.
MR. HONE:
Number 19:
'Why isn't something being done to
alleviate the critical shortage of funds and personnel in DVB
field stations,
especially compensation and pension, where
these shortages are resulting in retarded handling
of claims
due to backlog?"
MR. STRATTON:
I knew we would get to it eventually.
In
the interest, Mr. Chairman,
of the speed that you want to go
at here, 1 am not going to repeat the things that Mr. Driver
mentioned this morning.
I am merely going to say a very few
things.
112
I am
a little
bit
offended
at
the
word
"backlog"
in
the
question as representative of what we were faced with in
September.
I think it is
too stong a term.
I would prefer the
term "horrible mess."
We had at that time over
160,000 cases
in adjudication all over the country.
We are now down to
133,000.
We have cut about 12,000 off during this past month
dueing the peak of the income questionnaire period.
We are
going in the right direction.
We have spent thousands of
dollars in overtime.
There have been many things that have
influenced this backlog.
Most of them Mr. Driver mentioned
this morning.
We are in better shape on income questionnaires
today than we were at this time last
year,
even though we have
a lot of 211's which are rougher than the others.
Again,
I
merely acknowledge that we had the horrible mess and then the
backlog.
We are not out of the woods yet.
As we have to increase
our capacity and our
productivity,
it reflects directly on you
gentlemen.
Then you have to press also,
We would be, as I said,
at about 130,000.
We are aiming for 85,000,
which is where we
were about a year ago.
Eighty-five thousand would represent
about a six-day workload,
not backlog,
not horrible mess.
We are
going to make it, but it is
going to take a little time because
as of the first of March, which is today,
over 100,000 pensioners
who did not send their income questionnaires to us are going to
suddenly realize that their payments have been suspended.
85,000
or 90,000 of those are going to come to us
tomorrow morning and when they do, they are going to file the income questionnaire we are going to have 85
or 90
thousand more cases in
the next three days,
God help us,
to
be
MR. CARTER:
‘a ‘real mess,
MR.
With
officers
that
"No.
20.
Some
years
have
elapsed
been
revised.
When
will
the
MOORE:
Soon!
MR.
CARTER:
I
MR.
service
has
MR.
budget
the
HONE:
Manual M8-5
manual?"
tions.
I
questions
all
want
to
thank
Mr.
failed to
beginning
introduce him.
Mr.
with question 21.
MURPHY:
Question
message
to
Congress
21:
Hone
for
Murphy
''President
mentioned,
VA
under
is
since
issue
those
will
going
VA
a
new
ques-
take
the
Eisenhower's
recent
compensation
and
pension,
‘expenditures for service connected death and disability compensation benefits continue a slow decline from the
1959
peak as compensation rolls are reduced by the death of the
veterans
of
their
widows
or
by
the
transfer
of
many
veterans
to the pension rolls."
Was not a great percentage of the
cline in the compensation benefits due to the reduction in
compensation ratings under the National Authorized Review?
MR.
FARMER:
We
have
to
start
from
the
premise
that
de-
the
review did have an effect on the running awards.
The precise
amount is a little difficult to measure,
but taking the six
years, fiscal 1955
through 1960,
after all the terminations
that were made
in the compensation and pension program,
7.4
per cent of them can be ascribed to the review.
In taking
that figure you have to remember that every case that was
subject to the review which came in routinely,
and we ordered
113
the re-examination on it, was ascribed to the review.
We know
that an unknown number of those cases would have come in any
way and the results would have been the same whether they were
under the review or not, so when I gave you the figure 7.4
per cent,
it really has to be minimized to an
unknown extent,
that is, how many cases would have come in routinely and would
have received terminations.
Yet, we do
report them under the
review.
To answer the question as succunctly as possible:
about 7.4 per cent
MR. MURPHY:
Question 22
from Minnesota:
'In a pension
program based on need, how can you justify denying pension to
a farmer earning $1200 per year, because he had mever earned
more than that, when pension is allowed to a person who retired
voluntarily from employment and whose income is more than the
statutory limits, while his contribution to a retirement fund
is being recouped?
The farmer cannot risk quitting until his
pension is assured.”
MR. FARMER:
Well,
of course, we have to start from the
premise that it is not proper to deny a pension to a farmer
earning $1200 because that is all he ever earned in his life.
If you will remember TB 21-18 has an unequivocal statement "Denial should never be based solely on the fact tgat this type
of farmer never operated his farm on a larger scale."
When
you
get
to
the
question
of
the
amount
of
income,
(out
of
the
employability feature),
the man who is recouping his annuity
does not have his income counted until it is recouped, whereas
the farmer is not subject to that recoupment feature and if I
understand this question,
they are not saying that the man
is denied because his income was excessive,
because obviously
$1200 would not bar him.
They are saying that he was denied
because he never earned more than $1200,
and I am saying that
we have already published a rather clear instruction which
says that isn't a proper basis for denial.
There really are
two different
things mixed up here, one income,
and the other,
the evaluation assigned.
MR.
MURPHY:
Thank
you.
Question 23 from Pennsylvania:
''Manual 8-1,40.07 D,
reveals in part that VA Regulations 2645
and 2973 provide that
where total amount of benefits payable on behalf of a child or
children, who are in the widow's custody, does not exceed $100,
payment will be made to the widow as the legal custodian without reference to the Chief Attorney.
Why cannot the amount be
increased to $300,
thus expediting claims much faster and preventing time-consuming work by adjudication and legal divisions?"
MR. MOORE:
We recently consolidated these two regulations
referred to.
It is now VA Regulation 1850(c)
that has already
been amended to increase the amount from $100 to $200.
There
was some delay in printing it so we released a teletype to the
regional offices announcing this change.
This $200 will permit
payments without appointment of a custodian where there is just
one child's pension payments under 211 for about six months,
and if there are two, for about eight
months.
We think that this
is reasonable and that is double the amount that was permitted
previously.
MR.
MURPHY:
MR.
WEISS
Thank
you
very
much.
A
legal
(Pennsylvania):
114
regulation
was
submitted
to the Legal Division on August 30, 1960.
The Adjudication
Division was not notified of this increase from $100 to $200
until January of this year.
Couldn't
there be more coordination between the legal and adjudication divisions?
that
that
MR. MOORE:
Somebody jumped the gun.
It was
long ago.
There was some delay in printing.
is the reason we released it by teletype.
not approved
As I say,
MR.
thing
they
the
MR.
include
WEISS:
According to the
some time in September.
MOORE:
the
$200.
The
Regulation
In
September
lease
was
ments
MR, WEISS: In addition,
of the guardian such as
not
want
legal
division
1850(c)
1960.
was
I
not
would
received
approved
say
that
to
the
re-
premature.
to
accept
at
small
are you aware that the appointa bank and trust company,
they do
stations
because
of
the
amount
of
work involved in paying this extra clerical work.
The VA
regional office in Wilkes-Barre experienced this fact because
in the smaller states the banks and money agencies don't want
to handle this,
MR. MOORE:
Normally I believe where the widow has custody
of the children we will pay the widow rather than a bank anyway.
That is the usual practice,
so I don't believe the amount here
goes: 10 that point, does it?
rating
MR.
WEISS:
Thank
MR.
MARKOWITZ:
MR.
MURPHY:
you.
Why
don't
Question
24,
"Please explain
board."
the
duties
you
compromise
submitted
of
the
and
from
say
$3007?
Pennsylvania:
medical
member
of
the
MR. STRATTON:
I will tackle it.
I will say the doctor
I used to work with on a rating board out in Wyoming for many
years used to tell me "Stratton,
if you will just leave these
legal questions
to me and concentrate on the medical questions
we will get these cases out a hell of a lot faster."
A medical rating specialist is equally responsible with
the other members of the board for the accuracy of the decision
that is rendered.
At the same time we certainly would expect
him to devote his skill to the end result.
He has to know what
every doctor should know over and above the treatment aspect,
which is of course the most important.
He has to be able to
determine the medical principles
in the case, the reasonable
probabilities in the case medically.
He has to be able to
associate primary conditions with secondary conditions that
originate after service.
He has to know immediately the direct
and perhaps the more complicated contributory cause of the
death,
These things he is responsible for.
These things in
my opinion he is doing in the country today.
We have some very
excellent medical rating specialists and it is of particular
interest to me on my rare visits to offices in talking to some
of
them
and
have taken
beyond the
some
of
these
doctors
to this work that you and I do
medical aspects
of the case.
it
is
rather
striking
and
have
gone
115
how
way
Some
hold
doctors
tbeir
own
with
in
the
some
offices
lawyers
in
that
the
I
have
office
met
on
can
the
almost
regulations
and the different
things that go into ratings.
We are
bettér on recruiting them now.
In the last quarter we
We. got nine.
We are actively recruiting for about six
doing
lost ten.
right
now.
The
but
the
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I find the reverse in the many instances.
doctor does a good job and he also knows the legal aspects,
I resent the fact that lawyers try to be doctors.
That is
point.
MR.
Question
CARTER:
1
will
now
ask
Mr.
Smith
to
continue
with
25.
MR. SMITH:
No. 25
comes from Pennsylvania:
"Too many
disallowances are being made on pension claims where a veteran
has passed his 64th birthday.
He is not employed and in many
instances has been retired for disability.
What can be done
to give this type of veteran a better break on his pension?"
MR. STRATTON:
Of course when you have advanced age
coupled with disability it is much easier in those cases to
prove that those two things have caused a man to be unemployed
and these are the things that are required.
Certainly almost
all of the claimants we get now,
that is, a high percentage of
the ones we get, are well over 64,
In fact, the majority of
them are over 65.
Once the Board has determined,
however,
that he is unemployable due to disabilities where he is less
than 100 per cent under the schedule,
they have no choice but
to either grant it or
send it in to Art Farmer and the rate of
allowance on those 1142cases
that come in here under that
regulation is extremely high,
I think iti/is around 30 per cent.
MR.
ZEGLIN
(Pennsylvania):
I would
like
to
refer
back
to
24.
The reason I put that question in is in many instances regardless of what the medical examiner says, quite pointedly
that his condition is apparently stemming from a serviceconnected condition,
and it is so constructed that there is no
way that the Board could deny this case for service connection,
for example,
a nervous condition is the result of a serviceconnected condition,
the rating board goes on ahead and says
no service connection where the medical examiner specializes
in his field says yes,
this is the result.
That is the reason
I posed that question.
That is being done.
MR.
CARPER:.
Thank
you.
MR. SMITH:
No. 26:
"In resolving service connection
based on field examination of a doctor's medical record,
in
the absence of written records,
the case is usually disallowed,
despite any statement made by the veteran's physician indicating his complete knowledge of the medical aspects of the case.
Please discuss. this."
in
the
MR. STRATTON:
I think that this is part of the
comment you just made,
is it not, Mr. Zeglin?
question
MR, ZEGLIN:
That is right,
1 would just like to pose
one question on that.
Is it necessary that the doctor produce
a record?
I mean should the Board give credence to the doctor's
word?
116
MR.
STRATTON:
MR,
ZEGLIN:
MR.
“Yes,
They
STRATTON:
to
when
he
sir.
don't
They
should
treated
the
word
as
what
you
referred
to.
MR.
ZEGLIN:
1I
MR.
STRATTON:
give
man
credence
to
what
found.
That
Washington,
just
and
he
the
doctor's
is
:
called
a
case
down
to
to
it.
one,
I
would
like
see
MR. ZEGLIN:
It is
along these lines.
A veteran is on
a short form 526
claim for service connection for a mervous
condition.
He is psychotic and needs help.
The doctor says,
"Yes, 1. saw this boy medically,” and it is apparent that he did
because he made claim for a nervous condition before he was
discharged on the short form,
and yet the doctor was unable to
produce a record.
They don't believe him.
It has been disallowed.
MR. STRATTON:
There must have been other things that have
led them to this.
I must say that,
of course,
the best evidence
you can get from the doctor is an actual transcript of his record.
This is the best type
of evidence.
But a statement from
the doctor should be given credence,
even thoughhe cannot produce the official record from his office.
In this case I don't
know.
I would like to see it,
Have you appealed this case?
MR. : ZEGLIN:.
MR.
STRATTON:
MR.
ZEGLIN:
Yes,
And
Yes.
1
appedled
they
Of
it.
disallowed
course
you
it?
know
Appeals.
MR. STRATTON:
I do know.
C&P started this and don't be
too harsh on the Board of Veterans Appeals right now because
he wouldn't have had to go there if we had not disallowed it
in the first place, but at this point we probably couldn't
do anything about it if the Board of Veterans Appeals has acted
on it.
However,
I. will be glad to take a look at it.
MR. ZEGLIN:
They have been disallowing every case.
Where the doctor can't lay his hands on the record they will
disallow it.
MR. STRATTON:
I cannot condone this as a general practice.
At the same time,
I cannot deny that it would be very possible
after all of the facts of the case were known and laid before
you that they would differ or they would disagree or they would
perhaps challenge what the file has said, but we make specific
admonishments
in this direction in our regulations where we
have said that a doctor's
statement will not be disregarded
merely because,
et cetera,
et cetera,
and no doubt will be
cast on the case unless there is good reason for it, but here
we get in such a factual situation that we have to sit down
and look at a case together before I could really answer it.
MR. SMITH:
No. 27:
"In severance of service connection
under the National Review,
the medical question involved
is not
actually considered,
especially in cases which involve tropic
117
diseases.
In fact,
there are not too many medical men who, in
our judgment,
are familiar with cases involving disease incurred in tropics.
Please discuss what means of review are
taken when severance in such case is referred to Central Office
byithe local rating. board.”
tell
MR. FARMER:
We bear down pretty heavily on
you that.
Tropical diseases are of course a
restricted
field
of
medicine
and
I can
assure
you
it.
I can
somewhat
that
there
is
not thé slightest hesitancy in submitting cases to the Chief
Medical Director for opinion of his consultants in this area.
We have done
it repeatedly and frankly we haven't seen any
cases that would indicate that that it has not been done where
appropriate.
We have ample facilities in CO.
There is no
barrier at all to submitting such cases and I am a little surprised to see this question come up.
MR. ZEGLIN:
The reason I brought that up is we have a
case of a man that has been severed of service connection.
He
had a diagnosis of cerebral malaria, with the result of hemiplegia,
and after all these years they severed service
connection
because apparently this paralysis,
this hemiplegia,
is not the
result of his malaria,
and we nosed around and it went through
our office.
Of
course
you
concurred
then
with
us have served in the tropics and we
we read a little about it.
There is
sporulation that causes paralysis.
MR.
FARMER:
There
is
a
lawyer
the
know
what
severance.
a little
you call
talking
like
Many
of
about it and
spontaneous
a
doctor,
Mike!
MR. ZEGLIN:
It is our business to know these things, but
I think it is most unfair in cases like this and other severances
too. I have a man where they severed service connection for a
chronic dislocation of his shoulder.
They blame it on an extraeous 8-hour day.
He would have to do some extraneous
labor in
the mill and they said due to that it preexisted service, where
it clearly showed it was a traumatic incident.
I think the
Veterans Administration is just a trifle loose on severing service connection.
MR. FARMER:
pletely but it is
a
proposal
to
sever
I don't expect
true that every
service
you to agree with this comcase that comes in here with
connection
means
that
three
men
are
on the rating board thought it should be severed.
Each case
that comes in here is subjected to painstaking scrutiny before
we say "Yes, go ahead."
Then after that we give them the routine
notice and he also has the right to appeal.
You have really
three distinct echelons,
each one of which is taking a hard look
at these.
Of course on any individual case you and I are going
to aggue about what probative value the-evidence has, but the
only thing we can say at this point is that we try real hard
to make certain that if there are any cases on which there is a
reasonable basis on which service connection can be maintained,
we do ii.
MR. SMITH:
No. 28, the last question,
by Mr. Zeglin:
"The application for benefits by dependent parents is being
denied where a slight margin of income,
above the set requirements,
is indicated.
Why are these cases
disallowed since
118
VAR 1250-B states
that consideration should be
mode of living the parents are accustomed to?"
does
says
given
to
the
MR. PECKARSKY:
One slight inaccuracy.
The Regulation
not say the mode of living they are accustomed to.
It
the reasonable mode of life of the parents.
There is an
element
of
reason.
If
they
have
been
living
at
$100,000
a year
we can't support them at that level.
However,
you are right
in every other aspect.
The dollar figures set in the regulation
are conclusive figures.
If those are met there is no further
question of dependency.
If those are not
met we then look at
all
of
the
other
elements
of
the
case
and
we
look
at
this
reason-
able mode of living in conjunction with where do they live,
in
the city or in
the country,
do they own a home, do they have any °
assets or not,
and all of these other things.
Taken altegether.
if we then find that under an equitable consideration of the case
we can hold dependency we do.
Two years ago, in 1959,
you asked
the same question and got the same answer.
In fact, we said if
you had a case you should send it in and we didn't get any.
In
1960 you let us off.
Maybe somebody needs reminding.
So we would be glad to
reissue this instruction in the form of an information bulletin.
MR. ZEGLIN:
This is the third year I asked this question,
but in regard to this run-down you gave us about we have considered this and we will consider that,
they don't do it.
They
just look at their income,
it is over, and that is it.
Goodbye.
I mean they don't examine into how they have lived or what the
resources are.
1 am particularly interested in one old man.
He
is seventy years old.
He lost two sons in combat.
He is only
two bucks over and that man is aged now.
He has to have somebody
come in and do his laundry,
and cut his grass,
and do this and
do that,
and he is disallowed and it is
not fair.
That is the
reason I keep plugging this thing.
Thank you.
MR.
STRATTON:
Send
that
case
in.
MR. ZEGLIN:
Question 29 deals with contact service and
will be read by me.
"Why has it become necessary,
as we are informed,
to discontinue weekly visits of contact representatives
at state and city hospitals?
Under new procedure,
contact representatives will only visit these hospitals upon request of the
hospital.
It is noted that in the Philadelphia Regional Office
the contact representatives were reduced from 31 to 26
during
the
calendar
ing
considered.
year
of
1958
and
it
seems
that
further
cuts
are be-
"This creates a hardship on the veteran,
as well as the VA
service,
as now we must depend upon unskilled clerks at these
institutions to notify the VA if the veteran is a service connected mental or tubercular case,I would
-appreciate your comment
if it seems to be a general problem or whether it is only a problem of local importance in the Philadelphia aeea.
In other
words,
is this procedure general throughout the country in the
various Regional Offices?"
each
ing
MR. KEITH:
Let me say under
manager is responsible within
service,
particularly
mental patients
regional office
be
rendered
once
to
the
the existing. instructions
budget limitations for render-
State
and
City
hospitals
where
are housed. We feel that the manager of the
is better qualified to say what service should
a
week,
or
that
119
the
need
is
only
once
a
month,
or
that
it
is
on-call
basis.
General
guidelines
to
the
manager
do say that he will render the service in the fashion and in such
frequency as to assure that service is reasonably available to
the veteran patient who is in
a non-VA hospital.
If you have
discussed the matter with your regional office manager and are
not satisfied that service on that basis is being rendered, we
would be happy to take it up with the regional manager for you.
I believe that answers that all right.
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
you,
George.
MR. CHARLES J. KOHLER (Penmsylvania):
I anticipated such
reply and I already contacted the regional manager and he blames
you people.
No. 1, you have said the thing so far, for these
last three days has been the service.
There are no mental beds
available for these types
of patients so what you do is you do
not accept these mental cases, because there are no available
beds.
You send them over to the city hospital.
They are de-
prived
already
of
one
service.
No. 2, there is no contact representative available.
You
do not know how long that man is in that particular hospital.
There is no follow-up.
We have cases sometimes over a period
of six months where a claim is not filed.
There are TB cases in
some of these hospitals
and you are crying for the TB beds, and
in other hospitals they are laying empty,
and I don't know how
many other important items you can stress for the cause of a
service connected patient that could be in a hospital.
We already
had one incident and somebody will have to pay the bill and refer it back to the regional office.
So if the theme is service,
you certainly are retarding your service and the manager said -
"It
is
coming
from
Central
Office,
not
fromime."
MR. KEITH:
I don't want to pass the buck back to the
regional manager since he has handed it to us but let me say
this:
That the fact that service we used to render in your
state involved weekly visits to the hospital does not necessarily
mean that the manager now needs to make weekly visits.
For
example,
if the number of veteran patients admitted to the hospital is increasing, we would expect the manager to re-evaluate
the need and go twice a week,
if the number were increased.
On
the other hand,
if the number were decreased, we would expect
him to re-evaluate the thing and go twice a month.
If the manager has said to you that he does not have the
personnel to render this service,
this is news to us
in Contact
because they haven't asked us for any more people to do it.
We
will be glad to get in touch with him and try to resolve the
question of whether he needs more people or not in order to
render that service.
answer
MR.
to
KOHLER:
I wish
everything.
you
would.
MR.
KEITH:
Be
to
do
it.
MR.
KOHLER:
Thank
very
much.
MR.
CARPER:
We
happy
next
you
come
to
I
think
Question
No.
that
would
be
the
30:
"Please discuss
the VA's Work Measurement Program.
We find
that the personnel of the VA is spending anywhere from twelve to
fifteen percent
of their working time coding,
screening,
and doing
120
the
endless
"The
paper
work
involved
abolishment
of
this
in
this
program
increased production,
especially in
the backlogs are daily mounting."
program.
will
the
definitely
claims
reflect
field, where
MR. STRATTON:
I am going to try to do this very briefly.
Work measurement has the following procedure.
When a case comes
into Adjudication we put a little card inside that case
and we
put a card number down on it as
to what the issue is in that case
and we have numbers for that.
We put down the man's name, C
number,
as. 1 recall,
and the date that it comes in, That's all,
That card stays inside that file throughout the adjudication
process.
It is not a handicap to authorization.
It is not a
handicap to the rating board.
The card is pulled off the
case
when it leaves the division and the issue has been settled.
The
card is filed and at the end of the month, usually by a machine,
those things are counted and the report is very simple.
This is
work
measurement.
We
spend
about
one
minute
per
day
per
case.
I think here what we are talking about really is quality control.
We do require our supervisors to look at a certain number of
cases every day to see whether or not the quality is good or bad.
I would expect that we would continue and extend this because
frankly,
I am more concerned about quality than I am about timeliness.
The third thing is that probably part of this questiom is
surveys.
We have not made any surveys in the past year.
Because of the work load situation we have not wanted to interfere
with the local office.
We plan to revise this type of procedure,
but I would be less than honest with you if I didn't say first
that work measurement
is here to stay and it is
no extra work,
that quality control is here to stay and will be amplified and
extended,
and that surveys in perhaps a modified form will
have
to
be
get
speeded
up.
We
will
this
present
situation
MR.
CARPER:
Thank
have
to
do
more
of
them
as
soon
as
we
concluded.
you.
That concludes the printed questions.
I want to take this
opportunity to thank the members of the VA for their efforts this
morning and this afternoon.
We appreciate their remarks and also
the members of the Panel who have assisted in this presentation
this afternoon.
Do you have one final question?
Is it
very
important?
DR. GORDON PEFLEY (Oregon):
It is in regard to work measurement.
I am wondering about the value of work measurement in the
Department of Social Services where it is being introduced at the
present time.
MR. STRATTON:
The Department of
the Department of Medicine and Surgery
question.
value
had
DR. PEFLEY:
The sort of work measurements there,and
it is, and how it could be justified.
I don't know.
what
MR.
we
they
Bernie
Social Services is under
and I cannot answer your
STRATTON:
will
not
If
find
they
it
have
difficult
the
to
same
experience
that
have
justify.
MR. CARPER:
I want to thank you for your attention and also
Nolan for assistance with this Panel.
Thank you, gentlemen.
121
CHAIRMAN
FOUST:
I
have
two
announcements,
«s+.
Announcements....
please.
CHAIRMAN FOUST:
I want to reiterate the thanks of the
Staff and all of the conferees present,
to members of the
Veterans Administration for their remarks and kind cooperation
this afternoon.
The
meeting
(Whereupon,
stands
adjourned.
at
p.
4:25
m.
122
the
conference
was
adjourned)
THURSDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
. . « The 38th Annual National
of The American Legion reconvened in
Hotel Statler, Washington,
'D. €., at
Booher, Vice Chairman,
presiding.
Rehabilitation Conference
the Congressional Room,
9:07 a. wm. Dr... Ns R.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Good morning.
May we have your attention,
ladies and gentlemen?
It is now seven minutes after nine.
We are seven minutes late, but we are going to start.
The cream
of the crop is here and the rest will just have to come when
they get their breakfast.
If I may,
I believe that our deliberations here might well
be opened by appealing to divine providence for assistance and
I will ask you to stand for the morning devotion by the National
Chaplain,
Reverend Moss of Pulaski,
Tennessee.
REVEREND MOSS:
Again,
our heavenly Father, we bow reverently in Thy Presence.
We come this morning thanking Thee for the
all going work of this Commission.
We thank You for the needs
of men that cause us to
give of our time and service.
We thank
Thee that this world is not complete in every respect.
There are
things that need to be done and we are called of Thee to render
such aid to our beloved comrades.
We pray that throughout this
day that spirit may undergird us and that much good will be done,
and that through it all the bonds of friendship and the tides of
love may make this a great calling,
and a great profession for
us.
In Thy name, we pray, Amen.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I think a pleasant note to begin the
morning with is for you to have called to your attention,
if
you haven't already seen it, that the House Un-American Activities Committee budget was passed to the tune of $331,000
late yesterday afternoon in the House.
this
It
has
been
particular
my
privilege
part
of
the
over
the
years
Rehabilitation
to
preside
Conference
many
at
times and actually I am always reminded of the story of the
young shiek who inherited the old shiek's harem.
Some of his
friends said,
"What are you going to do with it?"
He said,
"It is not a question of what I am going to do with it' it is
just a question of where to start."
I
am
going
to
do
a little
I may, with Dr. Middleton's and
like to introduce to you first,
on this morning's panel and the
will go to Dr. Middleton and his
As
chairman
of
the
panel
differently
this
morning,
if
his staff's permission.
I would
The American Legion representatives
staff helping them, and then we
staff.
today,
we
have
the
Department
Rehabilitation Chairman of the Department of Georgia, A. V.
Akin, Jr., and on his panel with him Maynard R. Young, Department Service Officer, Department of Vermont; Charles L. Michael,
Department Service Officer, Maryland;
Frank C. Bottigliero,
from our good Department
of Illinois; Director of Rehabilitation;
and finally,
that guy with the good Yankee name, Reuben B.
Garnett
like
of Washington.’
For
those
very
few
you
to
our
Chief
know
of
you
who
Medical
123
do
not
know
Consultant,
him,
Dr.
I would
Irving
Brick,
who
Dr.
is so helpful
Brick.
in
all
of
these
things
in
rehabilitation.
:
By the way, before I go any further, back here in the
back of the program there are a few places.
I hope you have
some paper to write on out there.
We don't have too many
written questions,
but knowing this panel from years past,
that does not mean a thing, Dr. Middleton.
I would like for
you to write questions that you have on your mind and get
them
up
to
the
table.
That
little more orderly
pass these along to
your questions,
and
audience as soon as
that are printed in
serves
two
purposes.
It
gives
us
a
procedure.
It also gives us a chance to
the VA experts that are here to answer
we will take up the question from the
we have finished the discussion of those
your program and in your hand.
Without further talk, on my part, I would like to bring
to the microphone at this time for I don't know how many years
it is now, but a very pleasant number,
the Chief Medical
Director of the Veterans Administration,
Dr. Middleton, who will
have a message for us and then in turn will introduce his people.
Dr. Middleton,
ADDRESS OF DR. WILLIAM S. MIDDLETON,
CHIEF
MEDICAL DIRECTOR, VETERANS ADMINISTRATION
DR. MIDDLETON:
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Aikin,
ladies and gentlemen, friends, Dr. Brick,
the opportunity to meet with you again,
my sixth year completed and this is the seventh appearance,
is
a welcome one.
Obviously,
the stewardship of the medical program of the Veterans Administration is a serious one and one
which we will periodically give an accounting of to any responsible American citizen.
As the representatives of The American
Legion deeply interested in the welfare of the American veteran,
you certainly have first call on any information,
any programs,
any progress that we may report.
Therefore,
it is with a warm feeling of responsiveness
on your part that I address myself to the progress of the past
year.
This has been a year in which there have been very
material developments
in the area of operations. The bringing
of the Area Medical Directors into line has meant a complete
change of the philosophy of the functions of this particular
element in our organizational pattern.
Under the old design
of the Gray Modification of the Booz-Allen-Hamilton recommendations they were really the watch-dogs of the Central Office,
reporting to the Central Office the effect of such policies,
such programs as outlined in the Central Office, or perhaps
even initiated from the area, but in the last analysis they
were not in line.
They had certain responsibilities without authority,
the anomalous condition that has been remedied,
first, starting October 1, 1959,
by putting the St. Louis
into
line
and
the
remaining
area
six
areas
into
line.
no
feeling
on
There
is
lst
of July,
the
part
1960,
of
putting
any
member
all
of
of
the
the
Central Office staff that there is omniscience in their numbers.
If there were such an individual,
I would like to single
him out and take him behind the woodshed.
We do not feel
that part.
Accordingly,
to attempt to organize,
to attempt to
operate,
under the 170 hospitals,
91 clinics,
and 18 domiciliaries from a central point without delegation of control
to areas was in our judgment an entirely fallacious approach.
124
With the areas in line,
there has been, of course, granted to
them the control of funds, and the purse strings are in the
last analysis the controlling element in the operation of the
field.
I
would
have
it
perfectly
clear
to
each
and
every
one
of
you here that Central Office does not hold a cushion of sums
that are available on call to relieve the weakened member in
the field.
These sums are all divided among the seven Area
Medical Directors.
With appropriate backing in personnel they
are able to control the operation of the field stations on a
very intimate level with ability to relieve minor pressures
and ability to control overages in other stations.
This is,
of course, fundamentally sound from an operational standpoint,
and it means that we are able,
through channels of communication
from the stations in the field to the area to Assistant Chief
Medical Director For Operation, Dr. Zink,
and then ultimately
to the Chief Medical Director,
better to control this total
operation.
It has been successful procedure to the present
time,
We ask for further experience before we can give a
final
reading
pattern,
on
this
rather
drastic
change
in
our
operational
By the same token, we have attempted to consolidate our
advantage in the field from a professional standpoint in the
marriage of the Out-Patient Clinic to the hospital.
This has
been the subject of consideration discussion by our own representatives and by individual veterans. Detroit-Dearborn consolidation has just been effected and two more are in progress,
namely, Kansas City and Hartford-Newington.
May I indicate
at the outset this is not a movement in the interest of economy.
There is not a prevailing thought of saving of a dollar.
It
is a movement in the interest of the better utilization of our
professional skills.
At this moment,
if there were any suggestions that this did not improve the care of the American Veteran,
I will tell you that the entire program would be scuttled, but
the real circumstance of concern to us is the deterioration of
medical service that will attend the aging staff in our detached clinics. Only by bringing these elements into the atmosphere of an active hospital program where they may follow
the profession of medicine,
where they may follow their patients
actually in person as they are admitted to the hospital,
as
they may participate in the educational programs and the actual
professional activities of the hospital,
can we hope to bring
rejuvenation to this very vital program.
The out-patient clinic constitutes the outguard,
the
actual outpost,
of our medical program.
We have the front line
in our hospitals,
it is true, but there is no medicine practices
at the Area Office,
or in the Central Office.
As a matter of
fact, we do not know how sick we are in the Central Office.
This,
I am saying lightly,
but what I am indicating is that this
entire system depends on integrity of the field stations.
I have said seriously to the central administrators that we
could abolish the Central Office.
We could actually get on
without Area Office in a technical sense, because the real work
is done in the field.
It is our desire to make these out-patient
clinics as strong as possible by the consolidation of our professional staffs.
We have had the tremendous advantage of the
letter
the
was
of
February
ceiling
granted
of
to
26,
1959
from
President
Eisenhower
fixing
125,000
beds.
Within that ceiling full latitude
the Administrator
to distribute beds according
125
to geographic need and to the functional requirement.
This,
of course,
is a very forward movement because, for this group
there has been given now a latitude,
a freedom of action,
that
has never existed before February 26, 1959.
The Administrator,
Mr. Gleason,
at the present time,
can distribute beds, wards,
buildings and actual hospitals according to the geographic
needs and to the diagnostic constituency of these patients in
such hospitals.
This means that he can move beds according to
the need.
He can move actual hospitals according to need.
Under
these
terms,
we
have
previously
outlined
to
you,
the
circumstances of growing pressure in the '50's,
there moved a
total population of 1,600,000 into Florida.
In the 1950's,
there moved into California 5,800,000.
There are also pressure
points in southern Texas,
in New Orleans,
in St. Louis,
and
particularly in the psychiatric requirement about New York.
This is a circumstance of immediate need for action and it has
been taken effectively in Florida.
Time only is denied us.
It
is part of the planning for the other areas mentioned,
but
keep sharply in focus the figure that I gave you in California,
because it is
pertinent to our discussion.
In the geographic movement
there is, of course,
the
change in the diagnostic constituency of our patient population.
1954
was the peak of demand for TB beds, approximating 16,000.
We have fallen below to 8,500.
We therefore have here a cushion
of beds that will be absorbed in other directions.
It has been
our privilege to change the designation of eight of our tuberculosis hospitals to GMS hospitals.
We have given up two
of our TB hospitals,
Waukesha,oWisconsin, andi-Kennedy General in
Memphis,
Tennessee,
and have consolidated those beds elsewhere.
I cite these experiences to indicate that we do now have the
capacity and the authority to move according to geographic and
functional needs.
With regard to the construction program familiar to all of
you, the tremendous gain under Mr. Whittier,
the $75
million
program of construction for 12 years,
the $900 million he has
reported to you before.
Of course it continues to be dependent
upon the action of Congress each year and the $75
million of the
current year is being appropriately expended for new construction.
I say new construction advisedly,
because actually of new hospitals there is only one, and that is Brecksville,
that will unquestionably be dedicated in September this year, completing the
original program of post-World War II construction;
but replacements are now under construction at Martinez, Jackson and
at
Nashville.
one in
put out
school
The
program
goes
locally
for the
the end
particularly interested we hope
replacement of Mount Alto girls
of June,
1961.
which we are
to contract
hospital,
by
forward
regularly.
The
first
to
We have a prospect of tremendous development
and of substantial growth.
It is not one of these flash-in-the-pan movements, but by reason of geographic study of needs and by reason
of the assessment of our physical properties, we have been able
to come up with clearer planning and with definite design for
the future.
As we turn to the real mission of the Department of Medicine and Surgery,
it involves patients and, obviously,
in this
direction already indicated
we can take care of more patients
by
reason
efforts to
reason for
of
the
gain
improve the
considering
in
the
field
of
TB.
We
have
care of the mentally ill.
the aging population,
and
126
studied
We have cogent
in this respect
I should like to direct your attention to one of the most important movements now under consideration and that is the
reconstitution of the design for the domiciliaries.
This,
is. still
in the planning.
With the assistance of the Policy and Evaluation
Staff of the Administrator,
the entire program of domiciliaries
has been reviewed.
As you recall, we have 18 domiciliaries and
of those 18 domiciliaries plants only two, if there were replacement under the present terms of reference of the physical plant,
Dublin, Georgia,
and Bonham,
Texas,
are in modern structures
that would not need modernization or replacement.
The other 16
would.
To accomplish this end under the present terms of reference would require approximately $181 million.
It is time then,
since some of these go back to the 1860's and early 1870's,
that
this entire situation be reviewed,
first,
as to
the responsibility
of the Federal Government,
and second,
as to how best to resolve
this problem.
Into this picture comes the very sharp relief of
Resolution 25
from The American Legion,
that suggested the development
of
convalescent
centers.
Under the present thinking we are attempting to resolve
our approach into the social responsibility and the medical
responsibility.
The social aspect can be taken over by other
elements gradually by very carefully devised methods of transtion.
There will be no crash program,
no idea of a sudden
movement of responsibility for now approximately 17,000 veteran
members.
These veteran members have certain call upon our interests,
certain call upon our care that cannot be discharged
fiat,
Accordingly,
of
developing
convalescent
there
is
Restoration
cottage
or
a design
Centers
center
of
off
on
replace
the
idea
Resolution
25,
In
to
to
start
a program
of
the
substance
these restoration centers of 150,
not to exceed 250
bed units
attached to General Medical and Surgery Hospitals to avoid no
dilution of medical care and will receive patients only in
transfer from the hospitals.
There, patients must have
a prospect of a definite gain, where there is definitely projection
for their restoration to society.
Now, I am speaking of physical,
sociologic,
and psychologic rehabilitation.
Under these
terms these will not be-@ead-end houses.
These will not be
centers to which patients are admitted in terminal illness,
where there is no prospect of restoration.
If we have this
objective clearly in mind, we are going to afford a cushion for
the added care of the American veterans.
We are going to better
testore
these
patients
to
health
and
self-sufficiency.
an entirely new approach and it will require study,
will not eliminate our domiciliary program at once,
maintain a certain number of the larger ones over a
years.
This
is
study that
but will
period of
We do not know the number of years actually,
because this
is entirely a new experience.
This will be a matter of careful
study,
initiated first in a pilot plantat Hines.
The plans
are already afoot and before the end of this fiscal year, June
30, we should have this plant under way at Hines.
Other trial
runs will be made and then gradually going into this program,
we hope to transform the now unsatisfactory domiciliary program into a revitalized Restoration Center program with responsibility for the medical care.
The social aspect would be
referred to the state,
the community and individual with
appropriate subsidy from the Federal Government.
That in brief
is a very broad,
and we think,
a very constructive approach to
27
the
situation.
"At the last session of Congress there was passed a bill
affording pre-hospital examination and post-hospital care to
non-service connected veterans.
This is an exceedingly important element in extending the usefulness of our beds, but
there are two sides to this particular point.
I have been quite
amazed to find certain of our hospital staff members saying,
"But we do not have a problem.
There is no waiting list.”
This,
folks,
ignores
the
other
side
of
the
coin.
If
I have
a hernia
and require surgery,
I would be in the hospital for three days
before surgery can be performed.
As you know, under these new
terms that three days could be gained if the patient were, as
in
civilian
practice,
given
those
tests
before
he
comes
into
the hospital.
We would like to improve our record on the
length of hospital stay.
This is one direction,
and at the
terminal period as to
discharge,
he may be discharged with the
request that he come back in a week or three weeks for the
surgeon to investigate his handiwork.
There is the other side
of this coin.
That patient will in that period be relieved
from hospital care before he comes .in and after he leaves, he
will be able to pursue his ordinary activities.
This,
I feel
is an exceedingly important advantage.
Our research program has grown from $5
million in 1955
to
$21,500,000
now.
The prospect for some amendment to that in
the present bill before Congress is indeed encouraging,
but we
are not
interested in overwhelming financial responsibilities
here.
We have the mandate of Congress that our research will
be directed toward problems affecting the health and welfare
of veterans.
We are following that mandate very closely and
I can assure you that we can give not only the sound account-
ing
im~the
field
of
the
treatment
of
TB
which
is
internationally
acclaimed,
but also in many other areas.
We have the unexcelled
opportunity for cooperative studies,
this fixed population that
enables us to keep our controls better than in any other segment
of the American public.
There is afoot a study in Boston that
involves these octogenarian veterans of the Spanish-American War,
and we find that the insurance companies are intensely interested.
We know that we have a very important part to play in the health
of
the
general
American
companiegrexpress
a
public,
tremendous
We .have
interest
found
that: theiinsurance
in
Boston
the
study.
Those
of you who know businessmen and how hard-headed they can
be in such matters, will agree with me that this is not entirely
an altruistic interest.
They want to know whom they should
insure and who will be the better risk.
I was interested to find
that
many
of
these
figures
were
figures
physically,
like
Winston
Churchill,
which gave me some heart that my pyknic constitution
was not going to shorten my years.
What I am driving at, ladies
and gentlemen,
is that there is no area of our research within
the Veterans Administration that does not affect the entire
American,
and indeed the entire civilized population of the world.
to
the
These
are
mundane
matters
detail
of
of
tremendous
budget.
May
concern
I
say
and
very
I
come
briefly
lastly
that
the budget for the Department of Medicine and Surgery now before
the House Subcommittee on Appropriations
is a very sound budget.
We have indicated the construction and the grain in research.
There is a gain in education of $519,000,
if it is approved,
and
remember that all these figures I am giving you relative to the
budget now before Congress are public information,
but they are
not
fixed
figures
because
action
128
has
not
been
taken
on
the
budget.
I would like to say that we are in a very healthy state in this
budget so far as in-patient care is concerned.
Improved staffing is assured if this bill goes through as it stands.
The outpatient is receiving bet¢er attention,
so that by and large it
is a very constructive and a very healthy budget for the care of
the American veteran,
the sick or disabled.
Thank you very much.
Then, if I may, introduce the folks who really do the work
in Central Office, we have Mr. Pauls who was in the chair next
to me a moment ago, but Mr. Pauls is interested in the Automatic
Data Processing.
We have a very definite interest and stake
in this area.
We hope to work out our problems before these
matters are brought into operation in the field.
Then, Dr. Arnett,
of course,
is in professional services;
Mr. Bowers is in operation; Dr. Zink in operations;
Dr. Cohen
in professional services;
Dr. Fauber, denistry, Dr. Casey,
psychiatry;
Miss Hauge, Chief of Nursing;
and Dr. Timm in
operations.
Hiding behind him is Dr. Blasko;
then Jim Parke, of course,
in voluntary service and his right bower, Pete Miller;
completes
our quota.
There are folks still working over in the Department
of Medicine and Surgery, but Norm Booher insisted that we had cut
down on him.
He said, "You usually give me 40 and now you have
20."
We do not have quite that quota.
There was a request from
Mr. Corcoran that we afford you some report of what is being
done in Automatic Data Processing in the Department of Medicine
and Surgery.
I have asked Mr. Pauls to present this particular
subject.
I would like to indicate that the Department of Medicine
and Surgery suffered a tremendous blow in the sudden death of
Dr. Milton Schwalbe, who had headed this particular effort and
who died in Union Station while hurrying to catch a train to go
to the West Coast, but Mr. Pauls will present our interest in
the field of Automatic Data Processing.
Mr. Pauls.
MR. PAULS:
Thank you doctor.
Mr. Chairman,
distinguished
members of the panel, members of DM&S staff, kind distinguished
guests,
I am sure you have heard much and read much about data
processing,
the emphasis that it has been receiving within the
Veterans Administration,
the Department of Veterans!
Benefits,
the Department of Insurance,
and very probably you have heard
rumors and tales of what is going on in the Department of Medicine
and Surgery.
While we have only had a staff formally established with
a planed program and policy in regard to data processing for
a relatively short period of time, one year to be exact.
1
think just a few words to bring your attention and ours to the
fact that the Department of Medicine and Surgery,
of course,
has been engaged in data processing activities for quite some
time, perhaps not to the degree of the other departments and
other governmental agencies.
In speaking of data processing within the Department, we
consider not only electronic data processing techniques and the
use of electronic equipment,
computers and other electronic
devices,
but we also consider the mechanized system,
the use
of punch cards and tabulating equipment,
and also within the
data
processing
plan
all systems, methods,
related and referable
and
program
of
the
department,
we
and techniques,
and applications
to data processing techniques.
129
consider
that
are
In
supply
this
regard,
operation
we
within
have
the
had
a
very
department
highly
and
mechanized
the
agency
for
many
years.
We have also, of course, been using mechanical equipment to handle many of the statistics and operational programs
of the out-patient program within the department.
We, of course,
use mechanized equipment for our
statistical applications in
central office.
Some of our personnel statistics are derived
through
the
use
of
mechanized
equipment
and
some
of
our
fiscal
applications.
The department has been using mechanized equipment for many years, for biometric purposes and administrative
reports and analyses.
In addition to this,
in medical activities,
from the
standpoint of clinical medicine and medical research many activities have been
going on at the field station level.
The vast
ma jority of these activities have been related directly to specific clinical and medical research projects and the work that
has been done has been done by the individuals concerned in
developing, perhaps building,
or finding electronic means to
conduct medical research projects
and to examine uses to which
electronics could be applied in the field of clinical medicine.
Early in 1958
the Department of Medicine and Surgery conducted a feasibility study.
This was aimed at determining to
what use we could put computers in particular,
but also other
electronic equipment - this new equipment within the Department
of Medicine and Surgery,
to aid us in
three principal areas,
and they are the
three principal areas of activity in which
any medical organization generally is engaged.
This is administration or administrative management,
as you may call it,
clinical medicine,
and medical research and education.
A small staff
devoted
a period
of
about
one
year
to
the
study of possible application,
ending up in a recommendation as
to what could be a feasible application of electronic data
processing equipment within the Department of Medicine and
Surgery.
Because,
in the conduct of this study we were asked
to consider in the administrative areas the needs and requirements of the other departments and the agency as a whole in
the fields of administration,
the
recommendation that emanated
from the department was necessarily one of rather large scope.
Since
it
affected
the
other
departments
and
the
whole in the administrative areas,
the agency
a much closer look at the recommendations and
needs of the agency.
agency
as
a
decided to take
the probable
This latter study was conducted in a period of about six
months.
Following that study,
the data processing staff within
the department was established with two major responsibilities,
one in the area of administration,
which considers the development and design of systems in what we call common service areas;
and these are in the major program areas of fiscal management,
supply management, pay administration with related personnel,
and medical and administrative operations.
The second and the other major interest of the department
are those things which are inherent in the department's own
program,
specifically those areas of interest which are directly related to our patient care and treatment program. The department then,
since January a year ago, has been engaged in the
development of the systems within the administrative areas.
We are supplemented by members of the key staff offices within
130
the agency and we
ment of Veterans'
maintain
Benefits
close coordination with the Departand Department of Insurance.
As of this moment,
there are perhaps ten people who have
programmed a payroll application considering the nationwide
personnel strength of the agency.
Integrated with this payroll
administrative application are personnel statistics.
Also
integrated in this application are fiscal accounting,
budgetary
considerations,
and cost distribution factors.
Our desire here
is to build an efficient and effective system to enable us within the department and the agency as a whole to relate dollars
to functional cost,
to operational activity,
and to personnel.
In addition to this, we have started an interim phase
of mechanization in the fiscal areas within the department.
To this extent, we have embarked on an installation program of
punch card equipment within hospitals to first, handle our
fiscal activities,
that is, fiscal accounting,
payroll within
hospitals,
and cost distribution.
This program has first
priority within the hospital.
Following this, other programs
will be mechanized within the hospital.
These will be in the
area of medical administration,
within supply and within the
capability of equipment to handle certain medical research
interests,
and certain other administrative activities.
By the end of this fiscal year,
approximately 40 of our
hospitals will have installed mechanized equipment which will
be in operation in one or more of these areas.
In the area
of supply management, while we are attempting to develop and
design an over-all supply management application for computer
technology, we are also interested in reviewing the total
supply management picture within the department.
To this end,
we now have in test at several stations a very simplified
supply system designed to reduce paper work,
to more effectively
determine cost,
and to get supplies from the depot to the hospi-
tal
and
into
the
hands
of
the
users
more
efficiently.
The project which happens has particular interest to us
within the department is a special project that is being worked
on at this time and is related to a national cooperative cancer
and results study.
This particular project, of which the Department of Medicine and Surgery is only a participant, perhaps a
major participant,
but only one of several,
is designed to
analyze and examine data regarding cancer cases at a certain
cut-off period.
Today it has been determined that at the expiration of
five years of a follow-up study,
one may examine the data,
determine prognosis on cancer cases,
and perhaps evaluate certain factors. The reason we are considering an electronic application for the cancer case study is that the volume of data has
become so great and the complexity with which the data must be
updated following a patient's admission,
treatment and disposition has become so voluminous that it can no longer be handled
with ordinary mechanical equipment.
We are endeavoring to construct a magnetic tape computer application for this cancer data
so that by the expiration of five years, we will be able to
analyze and evaluate certain of this data.
In addition to these things,
the department's primary
concern is how can we help the individual hospital,
the individual themselves and the individual staffs within hospitals,
131
to better perform their jobs.
We feel that the best approach
to this problem is to work within the field station environment, and as the first phase of this approach to do certain
research and development work which will evaluate needs of the
administrative elements of the hospital,
the clinical medical
elements,
the physicians,
the nurses,
the supporting staffs,
and the
medical research groups within individual hospitals.
To this end, we have embarked on, as I said,
a research and
development effort in conjunction with a research and development organization.
This very briefly covers the activities
to date, again much of which are in the development stage.
Thank you.
DR.
MIDDLETON:
CHAIRMAN
Thank
BOOHER:
I
ss
you
want
very
to
much
make
one
o+Announcement
i. .
announcement,
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I would like to now get to the thing
that is always of the greatest interest to this particular
part of our Conference,
the questions and answers.
I hope
that you have been writing some out there in the audience,
and
will send them up to us, but in order to start the ball rolling,
we will go to those on page 16 in your program that have been
handed in in advance,
as we asked you to do.
turn
will
To carry on the Dall for us on this phase of it, IT will
it over to Mr. Akin
of the Department of Georgia.
He
carry on.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
It is always a
pleasure to have an opportunity to serve with Dr. Middleton and
his staff.
I thought we were going to keep this particular
panel clean and almost before they started they began talking
about ADP, and in Georgia that is a dirty word.
We are going
to call on our good friend from Vermont, Mr. Maynard R. Young,
the Department Service Officer,
to lead off with the first
question.
MR. YOUNG:
Thank you, Mr. Akin.
The first three questions directed to this panel were submitted by the illustrious
gentleman from Georgia who is presently chairing the panel, Mr.
Akin.
and
is
Question Number one.
When a veteran becomes
acutely
taken to a charity ward of a civilian hospital,
why
the
emergency
VA
hospital?
DR.
in
his
case
cease
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers?
for
purposes
of
admission
ill
does
to
a
MR. BOWERS:
I believe we discussed this question two
years ago.
We apparently were not successful,
but we will try
again.
Priorities for admission to VA hospitals
are predicated
on the entitlement of the veteran to such care under the law.
However,
our regulations provide that emergencies will be
accepted ahead of any non-emergent applicants,
including the
service connected.
The reason is obvious -- and delay in hospitalization in an emergency may well endanger life.
However,
when the veteran has been hospitalized in a non-VA hospital,
he is receiving the emergency medical care which he requires.
For the purpose of hospital admission,
there is, then no
132
medical emergency and we cannot accord the veteran emergency
priority based on medical need even though there may exist an
emergent economic situation.
If the applicant is hospitalized
in a non-VA hospital,
he is then considered for priority purposes in accordance with his basic legal entitlement generally
in the urgent category.
To do
otherwise,
would be unfair to
the many other veterans hospitalized in non-VA hospitals who
have requested admission
to a VA hospital.
MR.
YOUNG:
Next
question.
the new 750-bed
GMS VA hospital
as to insure its opening by not
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Could
the
in Atlanta
later than
construction
be speeded
January 1,
of
up so
1963?
Arnett?
DR. ARNETT:
Mr. Akin,
I think there was a little program
propaganda to this because the last time you and I talked we
acknowledge it was a 580-bed
hospital.
The new GM&S hospital
at Atlanta will be a 580-bed
GM&S hospital.
The present
scheduling calls for its completion by late 1964 or early. 1963,
The Veterans Administration has requested technical services
(money for architects'
fee) dueing the fiscal year 1962.
It
requires approximately nine months for the blue prints to be
completed by the architect.
Following this, there is a 2 to
2-1/2 year period necessary for construction.
If there are
any delays due to strikes or shortages of materials further
delays could occur.
The hospital planning is being reviewed
by one of the country's best hospital consultants
and will
have the latest advancements
incorporated in its structure. No
earlier date than mentioned above can be assured.
Shall I
answer this other question, Mr. Akin?
MR.
better
MARKOWITZ
talk
to
the
(PENNSYLVANIA):
President.
He
May
says
he
I
comment
wants
to
here?
You
speed
up
everything in that deal because it is economic.
I just want
to help my friend from Georgia.
I think you have a point,
Mr. Chairman,
and I think that Dr. Arnett ought to take into
consideration,
and everybody ought to take into consideration
the problem that the President is posing to everybody in the
United States,
speed up all kinds of construction,
speed up
all kinds of things that can be accomplished faster than have
been planned,
and I believe if you do that you would get your
hospital in 1962, not in 1963.
MR. AKIN:
Please state your name when you come to the
mike and your department.
I believe that the questions being
submitted from the floor we will hold so that the VA people
can have plenty of time to study them.
We don't want them to
make any slips.
We want them to have every benefit of time
and we are going to hold the questions submitted from the floor
until
the
prepared
questions
are
answered.
Dr.
Arnett,
1
want to say this to you.
We said 750.
You say 580.
You
cannot blame us for trying. The next question will be taken
by Charles L. Michael,
from Maryland,
the Department Service
Officer.
MR. MICHAEL:
Question number three.
A veteran who is
service connected for multiple arthritis had all his teeth
removed by the VA Dental Service and dentures were furnished.
These dentures are now ill-fitting and he cannot properly
masticate his food.
May the VA provide him with new dentures
now?
Does the nature of the veteran's service connected
133
condition (stomach
this regard?
DR.
%Yilcer,
MIDDLETON:
for
Dr.
example)
make
any
difference
in
Fauber?
DR. FAUBER:
For the condition of multiple arthritis I
would say no, unless the physician treating this serviceconnected multiple arthritis prescribes new dentures for this
veteran,
This situation holds in practically every physical
service connected disability that exists.
If in the opinion
of the physician treating this veteran,
that veteran requires
some dentistry,
regardless of what the nature of that dentistry
be, whether it be filligs,
dentures,
bridges or what not,
if
this physician feels that the prescribing of this dental treatment will aid and assist in the treatment of this physical
service connected,
them it can be done.
As a matter of fact,
this is not a dental service determination.
This is a medical
determination.
Brooks
MR.
of
MICHAEL:
Ohio.
Question
Please
number
discuss
the
four,
reasons
submitted
for
by
Fred
long.delays
in
out-patient
treatment authorizations
in cases where the outpatient clinic is divorced from the regional office as in
Cincinnati,
Ohio.
Where there is no established treatment
folder on file, we find that the average period of time between
date of a veteran's application for treatment and date he is
called for examination to determine need for treatment is
approximately one and a half months.
We acknowledge that reimbursement may be made under certain circumstances for unauthorized emergency treatment,
but we have seen many cases
where such treatment was given by private physicians without
subsequent approval by the VA of a claim for reimbursement.
In
many instances,
the fault lies with the private physician
who undertook to give treatment too quickly, or who refused to
complete an adequate report within the time limitation.
In many other cases,
the veteran seeks private care during the long delay and when finally called by the VA is told
that no treatment is indicated.
We feel that return of the
clinics to the regional office jurisdiction would materially
reduce the delay between application and treatment,
and thereby minimize the problems referred to above.
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Zink.
DR. ZINK:
We know, of course,
that delays occur when a
veteran applies for out-patient treatment and no treatment
folder is in existence at the clinic.
Usually it is
necessary
to request a rating from Adjudication in these instances.
As
soon as the adjudicative decision is made,
action is taken to
authorize medical service to which the veteran is entitled.
The delays involved in these cases are directly attributable
to the time required to adjudicate the claim for service connection.
Therefore,
whether the out-patient clinic is located
at a regional office or consolidated with a hospital,
service
to the veteran will be the same.
It is
our constant aim, and
we are working constantly,
to decrease the time involved here,
but it must wait
on adjudicative action and if you have any
instances specifically wherein there is an excessive delay
here or problem we
certainly would like to look into it, but
we can see
no reason
because of the relationswe have with the
regional office why there is any difference between the geographic locations mentioned.
134
MR.
AKIN:
Any
questions?
MR. BROOKS (OHIO):
Not only does
this man have to wait
until they determine whether or not to call him in for an
examination,
but during the interim of this waiting period he
seeks private medical care and then when he does get in the
regional office the condition has become symptomatic and he
gets another slap in the face by them telling him he needs no
treatment.
I .don't think this dis fair, nor: is this a service
to the veteran who does need that treatment.
You cannot turn
that ‘condition on and off like a water tap.
DR. ZINK:
I couldn't be more in accord with what the
gentleman says.
However, we cannot accomplish treatment until
service connection has been determined.
This,
as we all know,
is an adjudicative function,
not a medical function.
The
element in that this we can hopefully improve is speeding up
the process once adjudication has been made.
This, we are
constantly trying to do, but the application must be adjudicated
before we have any authority to authorize or examine or recommend home town care or treatment.
This is something beyond
our control,
and as I said, we can see no relation to the geographic
juxtaposition of the clinic in this particular problem.
MR.
AKIN:
Mr.
Brooks,
are
you
satisfied?
MR. BROOKS:
No.
Your 2731 you acknowledge is your delay
in these cases, but it seems to me that there should be some
other recourse to speeding this thing up such as copies of
rating sheets on those cases going to the out-patient service
and set up in a file the same as your military files are in
your administrative division and when that man's application
comes in it can be run over in that file.
If he has an adequate
rating sheet in there showing his service connection that should
be basis enough for setting up and calling him in as quickly
as possible.
DR. ZINK:
1I believe in this latter instance you are assuming that there has been a rating, and in this instance there is
no problem necessarily,
and many times we do handle these by
‘phone.
Again,
the problem occurs of delay,
generally speaking,
in those cases that have not been adjudicated and determined to
be service connected, but certainly we use the 'phone frequently in securing the data just as easily as walking into the
office next door.
However,
unless there has been ad judicative
action,
there is some delay and that is just unavoidable.
MR. BROOKS:
I am speaking of the adjudicated claim and as
far as a woman is concerned,
yes.
If a man walks into the outpatient clinic and applies there they will call and sometimes
that man will wait three or four hours for a reply back from
Adjudication because the folder is out some place and they
have to hunt it, but what I am saying is this man has a service
connected disability,
but he does not have an established
service connected treatment folder,
and he is a man who is applying and they are not going to make a phone call on every 2827
that comes in.
They will use the routine 2731 form.
DR.
are
ZINK:
constantly
"I
can
reviewing
only
our
reply
to:
that
procedures
as
in
these things up. We will continue to do so.
any particular problem we would be happy to
135
I
an
did
before.
effort
to
Again,
go over
if
it
We
speed
you have
with you
further.
Certainly a constant effort is being made to speed
up the procedures,
either in hospitals,
clinics,
or any place
else to get the veteran treatment that he is entitled to just
as rapidly as we can.
MR.
BROOKS:
I
have
nothing
else.
MR. BROWNING (Rhode Island):
I have just one thought here.
With the study it might be possible that in all cases after they
are rated for service connection a treatment folder could be
made up of the rating and filed in the medical department.
Then
when they came
in they could pull the folder and there would be
no delay.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you.
Let me remind you that we urge you
to scribble down any questions that you want to present to Dr.
Middleton and his staff.
Send them up to the end table here
and we will be glad to slip them
over to him and get you the
answer
at
the
end
of
the
printed
questions.
Any
further
ques-
tions or discussion on question number four?
If not, we are
going to call on Brother Bottigliero of Illinois,
the Director
of Rehabilitation,
to give question number five, which I believe
he presents himself to the conference.
MR. BOTTIGLIERO:
has three parts to it.
approved July 7, 1960,
Thank you, Chairman Akin.
To what extent has Public
been implemented?
A.
Have any qualified
purposes of giving effect
to
been appoint?
to
B.
If
making
the
not,
what
is
services
the
optometrists been appointed for
this law?
Have any area directors
future
authorized
planning
with
this
available?
by
C.
What has been the experience
the number of requests by veterans for
metrist under PL 86-598?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Question five
Law 86-598,
law
reference
of Central Office as to
treatment by an opto-
Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
For many years wherever they have been
required, we have utilized the services of qualified optometrists
on the staff of VA hospitals under the supervision of full-time
ophthalmologists.
As of
March 31, 1960 there were 16 on duty.
The annual census to be taken the end
of this month will reflect the changes resulting from PL 86-598.
No
area
directors
have
been
appointed
and
we
have
no
need
for any
at this time.
Insofar as the Public Law is concerned,
it
was actually implemented by a DM&S circular on August 23, 1960,
and as demands for these services develop, we anticipate that
we will move into the useage of optometrists in the clinics in
the manner in which we have utilized them in our hospitals.
Several clinics
in several states have authorized fee optometric care as a result of the new law.
California has authorized
some
20
cases
in
the
past
few
months
to
optometrists.
MR. AKIN:
Any questions from the floor?
Question number
six in the discussion.
We are moving to questions six and seven
and we are going to call on our colleague,
Reuben Garnett of the
State of Washington,
the Department Service Officer,
for questions
136
six
and
seven.
MR. GARNETT:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Question number
six is submitted by Kohler of Pennsylvania.
Under present conditions, peacetime veterans who are 0 per cent service connected
cannot receive VA out-patient
treatment or hospitalization for
that condition.
Are any changes contemplated in the regulations
with respect to such cases?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers.
MR. BOWERS:
Veterans who have peacetime service only,
must meet the basic requirements of the law to be entitled to
out-patient
treatment or hospitalization.
They must have been
separated for disability incurred in line of duty or be
in
receipt of, or but for the receipt of retirement pay would be
entitled to, disability compensation.
The peacetime veteran who does not meet either of these
requirements but who has a disability incurred in service
rated O per cent is not entitled to treatment or hospitalization
for the service incurred disability.
Since such veterans do
not meet the requirements of the law, it is
not possible for
the VA to change regulations in this regard.
A change in the
basic law would be necessary.
is
it
MR. KOHLER (PENNSYLVANIA):
In your
necessary to have the law amended?
MR.
BOWERS:
Yes,
sir,
it
estimation,
Mr.
Bowers,
is.
MR. KOHLER:
The reason I brought that question up, was
this past October at a breakfast with the former Administrator,
we brought this up and he was quite startled to learn that
these zero per cent cases were not afforded treatment and he
made mention to one of his assistants who was with him to make
note of that because he wanted to bring it up and he thought
it was a very deserving issue to take up.
I was wondering
whether there are any changes contemplated.
on
that
the
MR. BOWERS:
part of the
There would have to be legislative action
Congress.
Of course,
you have access to
just
and
as
we
do
it
is
a
question
of
whether
or
not
this
will be presented.
There have been bills presented.
I think
there are one or two in the hopper now, which touch on this area.
I am not aware that there is any that would specifically make
the amendment that would provide that the peacetime man who has
a no per cent disability and has no other entitlement would be
entitled to treatment.
It does require-legislative change.
MR. GARNETT:
Question number seven submitted by our good .
friend from Arizona, Garland Wood.
Would it be possible for
central office to once again remind the VA hospital managers
that it is most important
in regard to severely disabled service
connected veterans that there be included in the hospital
summary some comment as to whether or not the veteran has been
employed and whether or not he might be employed in the future?
the
DR.
MIDDLETON:
MR.
BOWERS:
hospitalized
quirements
for
It
Mr.
Bowers.
is
presumed
service
temporary
connected
total
137
that
the
veteran
rating
under
question
who
the
meets
pertains
the
provisions
to
re-
of
Paragraphs 29 or 30 of the Schedule for Rating Disabilities.
VA Manual MI, Part I, Chapter 6 contains specific instructions
for the inclusion in the hospital summary of appropriate recommendations as to the capacity of such veterans for posthospitalization employment.
We are not aware of deficiencies,
nor have any deficiencies been previously brought to our
attention in this regard.
However, we shall be glad to consider any local problem you may present, or if this is a general
problem, we will bring it to the attention of all hospital managers.
MR. AKIN:
Woodie,
are you present,
and are you satisfied
with that?
Arizona prepared that question.
We are letting
them off too lightly.
We are still waiting for some good
questions up here.
We will move to number 8 and this comes
from the staff.
The
extend
to
provisions
veterans
of
for
Section
VA
106
purposes
(d),
the
Title
38,
U.S.C.,
"portal
to
portal”
principle
(traveling to and from drills or other training without specific orders).
If a person who is covered by this
section is severely injured while traveling to or fromwsuch
training,
and is taken to a private hospital for emergency
treatment,
is the VA responsible for reimbursing the payment
of these medical expenses?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Mr.
Bowers.
MR. BOWERS:
VA regulations provide
urauthorized medical expenses incurred by
under the following circumstances:
for reimbursement
eligible veterans
of
1.
Treatment must be for a disease or injury adjudicatservice connected by the VA.
2.
Treatment must have been rendered in a medical emergency.
3.
Government facilities were not feasibly available.
4,
Delay would have been hazardous.
ed
Persons whose basic entitlement
to medical benefits from
the VA would be predicated on the provisions of Section 106(d),
Title 38, U.S.C., would have to establish such entitlement by
filing a claim for compensation and receiving an approved award.
Reimbursement for unauthorized hospital expenses could then be
favorably considered from the date compensation was paid,
even
though compensation was paid retroactively, provided all other
requirements of the regulations were met.
if
he
MR. AKIN:
will come
I
in
am
on
going
this.
to
ask
Ray
Macdouall
of
the
staff
MR. MACDOUALL:
The question was submitted because opinions
have been rendered both by the medical department and the claims
service regarding this particular incident. A man was on authorized weekend training in the Marine Corps, and while returning home in a private plane crashed and was severely injured.
He was taken to a private hospital for treatment,
the treatment
in the private hospital for one day, and I believe that ran in
the vicinity of $80,
under Section 106(d)
The
question
to $100..
Service
the foliowing day.
now
arises
who
138
is
connection
going
to
pay
was
granted
for
that
one-
day hospitalization.
Under Code 10 the Department of the Army
says that they cannot pay it.
The Department of the Navy says
that they
cannot pay it, that Section 106(d) of Title 38 was
promulgated just to protect this man.
The man
has been to the
service department for pay.
He has been to the Veterans Administration to pay this one-day.
Neither government agency
wishes to assume the responsibility for this one-day hospitalization in question.
MR. BOWERS:
Mr. Macdouall is right.
We have faced this
problem.
I believe our General Counsel held that this man was
in service throughout the day of the occurrence of the incident
so that we can only pick him up after he is out of service,
so to speak, or on the termination of the day on which he performed this duty.
I believe the service department has also
stated that they do not have authority to pay for hospital care
in private facilities for this type of care.
I don't know the
answer, frankly.
It is a question that I believe will have to
be clarified either by perhaps clarifying some of the legislation,
or some agreement has to be developed between the military and the VA,
MR. MACDOUALL:
That is the answer I have been getting
for two years.
The Navy tells me they cannot pay.
They write
us a letter and say that the Commandant of the Marine Corps
has vested a great interest in this thing;
the Members of the
House and Senate have also shown an interest in this thing;
the President of the United States has shown an interest in
this thing.
But our hands are tied.
They say that Title 38
protects
this
man;
they
cannot
do
it.
Now,
the
Veterans
Ad-
ministration tells me that they cannot pay this man's reimbursement of medical expenses because he was not service
connected until the day following separation.
again
MR.
and
MARKOWITZ:
I think he
Mr. Bowers,
you ought
has the power today.
MR.
MACDOUALL:
Thank
you,
to
look
it
over
Mike,
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA):
Ray, I believe you said that
in this case you are talking about the VA rated him service
connected and my question is, did they include the day that
the General Counsel ruled that he was still in military service?
If so, I think the General Counsel,
and Adjudication,
and
Department of Medicine and Surgery better get together.
MR. MACDOUALL:
They
from the day following the
the 13th of the month.
He
of the month.
have approved service connection
injury,
The injury was incurred on
was service connected from the 14th
MR. AKIN:
Ray, you must feel by this time like the party
Clarence Horton told us about yesterday that was improving,
improving,
improving,
and finally they buried him,
We have two
questions
there any
submitted from the floor
further discussion?
but
we
want
to
first
ask,
is
MR. FELLER (NEW YORK):
I would like to refer back now,
as long as you have completed the printed questions,
to question
number 7,
It involves the zero per cent man and hospitalization.
It isn't clear to me from what I have heard, and I am not certain of just where the responsibility lies, but I would 1ike to
ask the question of this panel if there has been any recommendation
139
made
by
the
Veterans
Administration
for
a change
in
this
law
to take care of these unusual cases of where the veteran does
experience a service connected disability and it screams for
justice, but he still can't get it because he cannot get the
case rated at ten per cent or more and he is denied hospitalization because it is
less than then per cent.
Isn't it the
responsibility of the Veterans Administration to make recommendations and have these recommendations made?
MR, BOWERS:
This problem has been considered by the
Veterans Administration.
To my knowledge,
no specific legislation has been submitted.
The Department of Medicine and
Surgery has brought this matter to the attention of the former
Administrator.
One of the major problems involved here is the
dental
care.
The
no
per
cent
dental
cases
mendously large number of veterans and
considerable expenditure of funds. .
would
would
cover
involve
a
tre-
perhaps
MR. FELLER:
I hate to belabor this group with another recitation of the individual problem involved,
and after I recited
it yesterday I was informed that this
is not unusual,
that there
are many, many, many, many of these cases,
and the
man I was
talking to could think of probably a hundred cases not identical.
to the one I was talking about, but that involved hospitalization
of
a similar
nature.
:
This young man went into service and came out with an
acknowledged inguinal hernia.
Near the end of his tour of duty,
he was advised by the doctor at the station to wait until he got
home so it wouldn't hold up his discharge and let the Veterans
Administration do it at
his leisure.
The case goes into adjudication.
It is acknowledged,
It is in the service record
and then they adjudicate.
That becomes a problem to the man
because he cannot get first-class employment in many communities
because he cannot pass their physical examination.
You go to
VA.
It is the responsibility of the United States
Government.
Remember,
yes,
they drafted this young man in the service.
He
didn't volunteer and say, "I
want to get in there."
They
drafted him into service,
and the hernia occurred in service.
Doesn't the government have complete and full responsibility
and shouldn't something be done about such things?
MR, BOWERS:
Personally,
I would say yes, and
we have had
cases like this come to our attention.
As a matter of fact,
a
case of a similar nature was presented to the Berd of Appeals
and then brought to our attention.
The Board in this instance
gave
ten
per
cent
and his disability
This has been done
ment.
Frequently,
cent rating and we
and Dr. Middleton,
about this problem.
service
connection.
We
operated
on
the
man
rating was reduced to no per cent again.
where the no per cent man does require treatthe adjudicative boards will give a ten per
can treat him.
However,
I agree with you,
has gone on record in favor of doing something
MR. KLEMMETSON:
In a case of this kind where a man is kept
from employment because of a hernia condition he has, even say
it was non-service connected, wouldn't the Veterans Administration be good enough to take into account that this man cannot
work unless he gets this
condition taken care of and even on a
non service basis,
if you would say that is an employment emergency,
couldn't you put him in the hospital and take care of him
so he could go back to work?
140
MR. BOWERS:
If
per cent cases again,
service for that man.
you are
we have
talking about the peacetime no
no legal authority to render any
MR. KLEMMETSON:
non-service connected
No, I
case.
was
MR.
BOWERS:
An
eligible
not.
I
am
talking
about
the
veteran?
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Yes.
You do admit that there is such
thing as employment emergency which would take into account
when a man needs hospitalization for disability so he can go
back to work?
a
MR. BOWERS:
Oh, yes, we give consideration to the econoemergency.
We don't classify it as emergency,
but he is in
urgent category,
and we certainly would give consideration
mic
the
to
that
kind
of
case.
MR. DIXON (FLORIDA):
Doctor,
let me ask you a question.
I would like to know why you in the medical department discriminate against service connected cases in reference to 2507
examinations.
You say you do not. I say to you that in the medical
division we have a service connected World War I veterans who
files for a non-service connected pension.
The claim is labeled
on 2507
a reopened case,
and this is a group 2 priority in your
shop for examination.
In Florida, we had backlogs on 2507's
here not too long
ago -- we are a little better now -- where this group 2 priority
2507
was not even being considered or scheduled for any Act 1
examination.
You will find the same situation existing in the
service connected case on application for increase.
It is a
reopened claim.
It comes to your shop and under your group of
categories on examination it is a group 2 prioritye.
I contend
that this is discrimination against the service connected case
and this is the only place in the VA I can find it existing.
I
think that you ought to re-examine your priority of examinations
in the Veterans Administration because if every state is like
the State of Florida,
there is a great backlog of 2507
examinations.
There is a great delay in the length of time it takes
this man to be examined from the date the 2507
is received in
the medical department.
I, for one, just cannot figure out why
the service connected man does not get as good a break as the
veteran who has no service connected disability and comes in
and files for a non-service connected pension.
Yet, he gets
examined before the man who has been carrying the service
connected condition for the last 30 or 40 years.
I don't understand it and I think it should be corrected.
MR. BOWERS:
Mr. Dixon,
I would have to agree with you.
We should consider such reopened claims as top priority cases.
These are the cases that should be handled at once,
and processed
as rapidly as possible.
I would have to agree with you that
we
have
that
this
not
been
able,
to
we would desire.
We
as you know.
regard,
reduce
are
the
making
amount
of
time
considerable
to
the
progress
extent
in
MR. DIXON:
All you would have to do would be to rewrite
your old regulations and eliminate your group 2 priorities and
take all those men's claims as of the date you get them.
It
would certainly help a lot,
At least,
you would not be discriminating against a service connected reopened case.
141
MR. BOWERS:
We will look into that.
I wasn't aware we
are still classifying them in this manner.
We will check into
that.
1 agree these
are all top
priority cases. that should be
handled as soon as they get to the regional office.
MR. DIXON:
You don't have this problem until you get a
big backlog of 2507's,
but we have the big backlog of 2507's
and you
can have two men who file their claims the same day
who live next door to each other and the service connected man
will
be six
connected.
MR.
months
behind
BOWERS:
You
the
mean
man
the
who
didn't
initial
have
claim
is
the
service
handled
first?
MR. DIXON:
The original claim is the number one priority.
The reopened claim has number two priority.
The serviceconnected man is in the reopened category because he had a
service connected disability and he is discriminated against.
It ‘is not right.
MR.
BOWERS:
If
MR.
DIXON:
It is
he
is
filing
still
a
for
a
pension
reopened
--
claim.
MR. BOWERS:
This is not the problem that we discussed
at the local Atlanta Conference where they were
considering
this as a delayed reopened claim?
The man who has been examined, turned down, and then comes back again?
MR. DIXON:
another category.
what
No,
this
is
took
care
of
will
look
into
very
much.
MR.
BOWERS:
We
MR.
DIXON:
:Yes.,
MR. BOWERS:
we can do.
We
MR.
Thank
DIXON:
you
different
all
together.
that
one?
it,
Mr.
Dixon,
This
and
is
see
MR. AKIN:
We promised in the beginning we would give
priority to the prepared questions.
As soon as we get those we
will go right back to the floor.
We have a question submitted
by Korella of Missouri for Dr. Middleton.
What progress is
being made to add 250
beds to the Cochran Hospital at St. Louis?
Will it be possible to get action on the crying need for additional beds?
Dr. Middleton?
DR.:
MIDDLETON:
*Dr.
"Arnett.
DR. ARNETT:
I presume that also in this question you
considered the need for NP beds in this area, which is now under
study at Jefferson Barracks.
As you know,
at Cochran we are
very severely limited by the property we own.
To answer your
question,
specifically,
yes,
it is in our plan.
1 am not able
to give you the date because it is
beyond 1963.
of
at
MR.
beyond
KORELLA:
400 every
Jefferson
here
a
few
We have at Cochran Hospital
day.
There are some 590
on
Barracks.
months
ago.
The
He
late
was
142
a waiting list
the waiting list
Dr.
Drubn
met
an
untimely
death
very,
very
much
interested.
The
work that he has done at Jefferson Barracks is
markable and we were all very serry to see him
had done a job there that was nothing short of
certainly rego because he
miraculous.
Dr. Clairborne at the Cochran Hospital is what I might
call hog-tied as far as trying to do a job because he does not
have the beds to put these men into.
1 appreciate the fact
that your location does not have an awful lot of space,
but I
wonder if it would not be feasible to put the addition in back
of Cochran Hospital because we are pestered in the St. Louis
office every day by people who call up or some man's wife will
come in and say, "But, John has been on the waiting list now
for five months.
He will probably die before he gets into
the
hospital."
My primary interest is getting service for the
veteran that needs it and needs the service badly,
and I would
like to do so as quickly as possible,
and if you gentlemen
have any way in sort of boosting the construction of these
additional beds or allocating them from some other place where
they are not needed,
1 think our troubles can be solved.
Thank
you very much.
that
MR.
BROWNING:
zero
peacetime
I
want
to go
veteran
back
just
question.
I
for
a
second
presented
a
to
resolution
to The American Legion a few years back and was promptly informed that The American Legion had no authority to enter any
legislation for peacetime veterans, which I looked into and
found out is correct, but we have two newly elected men on our
Congressional staff,
a new Senator and a new Representative
in
Rhode Island and I am going to
ask as a citizen and as a
veteran,
not through the Legion,
that they submit a bill to
Congress providing for this zero peacetime man to get out-patient
treatment,
and also hospitalization,
Now, if some of the other
states will do the same thing, maybe we can get that.
Thank you.
MR.
AKIN:
The
next
question
flows
from
the
floor
by
Neikirk of Ohio.
Why is it necessary for periodic examination
for OPT purposes upon a veteran whose OPT is of many years’
duration,
and whose disability is indicated as static,
and who
medically requires said OPT with extreme regularity?
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Zink.
DR. ZINK:
This position of periodic review of cases
is
dictated by good medical practice.
True, we may feel that the
case is static and may remain static for a long period of time,
but no one can predict unless we periodically re-examine that
this condition is a static situation and continued treatment frequently does not entail a complete recheck of the case to determine the progress of the diseases.
We feel in the interest of
good,
sound medical practice that periodically a complete review
of the case should be done.
MR.
go
back
AKIN:
now
MR.
program
to
HYDE
on
Any
my
(RHODE
mental
question
friend
in
from
the
ISLAND):
health
the
gentleman
from
center
aisle.
We
in
Providence
service
connected
concerning
have
Ohio?
a
I
pilot
veterans,
mostly out of Brockton.
Could you give us briefly your current
evaluation of this project and also your
opinion of its future
prospects?
We are quite interested in the project.
While answering that, what is the possibility of extending this to true nonservice connected mental cases?
143
DR.
MIDDLETON:
Dr.
Casey.
DR. CASEY:
The day care center is one of the new things
that has been established.
We feel that this idea has very
excellent promise,
indeed, because it follows the line of psychiatric
thinking throughout the world at the present time in
relation to the care of patients, particularly those that have
been able to leave the hospital,
but who need a little bit more
supervision and care to help them
remain out of the hospital.
We, at the present time, have 11 such day-care centers throughout the United States,
the one you mentioned being one of them.
As I say, we feel that this is very much a coming thing.
We
plan to extend these programs as widely as possible as funds
are available to establish them.
The question of extending
this
to
a
non-service
connected
patient,
of
course,
is
a
legal
one and at the present time this is not possible unless we are
able to establish such a clinic in a hospital.
The recent
law passed last year would permit us to
do it if such a clinic
were established in a hospital and non-service connected patients
could come back to the hospital,
but not in a regularly constituted out-patient clinic.
Patients treated in such clinics
must be service connected under the law.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I am glad that the back row finally had a
chance to say something.
I thought all the brains were up front.
Particularly Bowers had all the answers.
I haven't heard Mr.
Bailey say anything.
I think that the question that I am going
to pose may be of interest here,
too, because it involves nursing care,
and I think very highly of nurses.
I have three of
them right along side of me
here from Pennsylvania.
Dr. Middleton,
I was very, very happy to hear your statement with reference to
the convalescent
care type
of thing we are trying to establish.
You know that I have been very much
interested in this for a number of years because I knew I was going to get old some day
and I am sure the young men here are beginning to appreciate the
fact that they are not always going to remain young, but I don't
think we are going fast enough.
I think we are planning too much; I think we are talking
too much; we are holding too many conferences.
I think that
we ought to go to the Congress.
I think you ought to go to the
Congress and I think we all ought to go to the Congress and
impress upon them the need for this.
Here is a hospital system,
the largest in the world,
the Veterans Administration and the
people who are entitled to hospitalization in these institutions
are all men and women who have served their country in time of
need.
They ought to be given primary consideration when they get
old, a little bit extra, beyond those of the other citizenry of
our nation,
and I think that the Veterans Administration should
be
in
the
I
think
I
trust
fast
forefront
in
the
would
to
have
over
we
DR.
there
are
like
leadership
elaborate,
actually
MIDDLETON:
you
of
this
elaborate,
further
on
this
or
particular
any
matter
activity.
of
your
and
see
brain
how
moving.
Dr.
Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
Mr. Markowitz,
I think you will recognize
that any new program that we begin designed to serve veterans
ought to be a good one.
You don't want us to begin a program
that we are not satisfied is going to serve the needs of the
veteran.
Our program,
the pilot project that Dr. Middleton referred to at Hines,
is designed to give us insight as to whether
we are stepping off on the right foot.
If we find that we are
144
proceeding apace and are satisfied we are moving in the right
direction, we intend to institute a program designed to build up
in tempo the number of facilities in locations where we feel
veteran need exists,
and I think you will be satisfied with the
progress.
We are beyond the thinking stage now.
We are beyond
the planning stage.
We are actually now in the moving stage.
MR.
for
not
my
be
MARKOWITZ:
I
hope
it
continues,
but
DR. MIDDLETON:
Mr. Chairman,
if I may
fellow Pennsylvanian's satisfaction.
taken from the 125,000
ceiling.
That
more
rapidly.
add just one point
These beds will
is very vital.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Might I point out to you, doctor, while
we are on that same subject,
that we are not depending entirely
on you,
We have asked the Congress by Resolution 25
to appropriate sufficient funds to do this job in addition to the regular funds that are being appropriated for the use of the
Bureau of Medicine and Surgery and I hope the Congress will look
upon-it with favor.
:
MR. AKIN:
At this time,
I would like to recognize our
distinguished Vice Chairman,
Dr. Booher,
for an announcement.
CHAIRMAN
BOOHER:
It
always
seems,
ladies
and
gentlemen,
a terrifically wasteful thing at this stage in our Conference
if we don't bring
before you our own
Medical Director.
He
travels all over the country.
As you all know, he has a great
deal of knowledge.
Apparently,
he does not have anything
bothering him,
too, but I still want to bring Dr. Brick to the
microphone for a few remarks.
Dr. Brick.
DR. BRICK:
I really don't have much to say and Dr. Booher
is just doing this to put me on the spot because there was nothing specific that I wanted to direct my remarks to.
At the
Medical Advisory Board meeting on Sunday, with some very distinguished Legionnaires a problem was brought up which has
plagued us over the past year, the problem of the effect of research in the VA hospitals on medical care, and I think it was
aired quite frankly and quite extensively.
There has been a
survey of research in the VA hospital system by the National
Research Council.
This survey was a rather lengthy one and our
staff has not yet had the opportunity to fully digest it, but
we are going to try to evaluate the survey.
I am sure that the
people on my left have digested this fully.
The sum total of
the discussion that took place with reference to research on
medical care in the VA system was to highlight its great im-
portance
not
only
with
reference
to
the
high
standard
of
care
in the institutions in which this research is taking place,
but also,
and this is most important,
to all of us, the availability of personnel in these hospitals largely depends on the
availability of the opportunity to do research,
This research,
as was pointed out briefly by Dr. Middleton,
not only benefits
the veterans throughout the country,
but the research is of a
caliber and character that benefits the whole medical profession in the United States,
and it has always seemed to me
that this is one of our great allies in any discussion of the
value of the Veterans Administration medical system not to the
veterans alone, but to the public in general,
and even to the
American Medical Association of which all the doctors on this
staff are members in good standing.
Thank you.
145
MR. AKIN:
Before
colleagues on the panel
It seems that there are
not,
I
will
turn
the
closing,
I would like to ask my
if any of them have comments or questions.
no further questions from the floor.
If
program
now
to:Dr,
Booher,
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I want to take this opportunity to thank
in your behalf not only Dr. Middleton and his
staff, but our fine
people from the Legion, Mr. Akin and his panel,
for their participation in this part of our program.
I have a couple of announce-
ments
I would
like
to make
.
eis.
before
any
of
the
AARIOUNCEMENTS,
ou.
rest
of
you
get
away.
At this time, we will conclude this part of our program
in order to bring you a very interesting program for the remainder of the morning.
I hope you will all stay and thank you very
much,
ladies and gentlemen, for your attendance.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I wonder if we might return to our seats,
ladies and gentiemen,
so we will keep this show on time.
It is
now eleven o'clock.
We will proceed.
Ladies and gentlemen,
in our work in rehabilitation,
which
we seek to feel is the heart of the work of The American Legion,
we have a good right hand always helping us. Representing that
large group of our auxiliary who make up that right hand it is
my privilege this morning to present to
you a lady who is a
past Department Auxiliary President,
the great Department of
Pennsylvania,
a member of the Auxiliary for over 30 years, has
been Chairman in her Department of the Legislative,
Child Welfare,
and Americanism Committees,
and has finally really reached
the
pinnacle of usefulness
in being our National Chairman of the
Women's Auxiliary Rehabilitation Commission.
She has been a
volunteer hospital worker,
you people in the VA on this panel
will be interested to know, and has put in over 800 hours in
the past two years in a hospital in her area.
Probably the most
important thing that she would have me tell you is that she has
six grandchildren.
It is
a great pleasure on behalf of the
Commission to present to you at this time Mrs. J. Howard McKay
of Springfield,
Pennsylvania,
the Chairman of the National
Rehabilitation Commission of the American legion Auxiliary.
Mrs. McKay.
ADDRESS OF MRS. J. HOWARD MCKAY, CHAIRMAN,
REHABILITATION COMMISSION, AMERICAN LEGION
NATIONAL
AUXILIARY
MRS. MCKAY:
Mr. Chairman and members of this Conference,
it is
a great pleasure to be
with you today and I wish to thank
everyone for all the
courtesies that have been extended to me.
I have learned much on rehabilitation and also on ADP.
I hope
that you note I said 'rehabilitation'.
We have been having a
little bit of fun in the Auxiliary this year and if anyone says
"rehab" we have been fining them ten cents and that is to go to
a project of our National President,
and I was sitting in the
meeting this morning and I thought,
"Well,
the Legionnaires are
better than we are."
I have very seldom heard the word "rehab"
in this Conference,
and lo and behold,
the Chairman of this
panel
him
used
about
the
word
rehab,
so
1
shall
certainly
have
to
talk
to
it.
Rehabilitation is such a beautiful word, meaning the rebuilding or the recreating and concerning the veteran it means
the recreating and the rebuilding of the body and the mind.
So
146
this year, we are all saying "rehabilitation."
So be warned
from now on.
‘First, 1 would like to thank Mr. John J. Corcoran,
Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission;
Mr. Nicholas
Lynch, Jr., Director of National Field Services and his representatives, wno have been so helpful in our Area Conference;
Mr. Doyle in Dallas, Mr. Burke in Providence,
Rhode Island, Mr.
Chillington in San Francisco, Mr. Toloczko in Washington,
D. C.,
and Mr. Morgan in St. Paul, Mr. Robert McCurdy, National Rehabilitation Chairman of The American Legion;
and the Public
Relations Division of the Legion for newspaper,
radio and tele-
vision
coverage
of
the
Conferences.
I would like to say a special "thank you" to the Field
Service Representatives who so ably assisted in planning our
meetings,
secured excellent speakers from whom we gained much
information,
arranged visits to VA hospitals,
and gave us a
little sightseeing along the way.
We also appreciated speakers
who came to us from other Commissions of the Legion speaking on
legislation,
insurance and other matters concerning rehabilitation.
I know I speak for my entire committee when I say it has been a
pleasure to be associated with such fine gentlemen.
Several weeks ago,
I enjoyed a Lincoln's Day program,
where the featured speaker told about the activities of women
during the Civil War.
Did you know that 400 women actually
served in the ranks of that war?
We learned of Dr. Elizabeth
Blackwell,
the first woman to concern herself with the plight
of mentally deranged persons and who was able,
through her tireless efforts,
to improve their condition;
Clara Barton,
a nurse;
and then Mother Bickerdike,
appointed by Secretary of War
Stanton to be in charge of the sanitary commission for the camps.
She supervised the spending of over three million dollars raised
by women of the North, mainly through bazaars to improve conditions in army camps.
Mother Bickerdike,
called the Cyclone in
Calico, went into the camps,
cooked, washed and sewed, had scant
patience for the purely feminine social visitors.
She wanted
action to make the camps more sanitary and the food more
palatable.
Even when
travel was not available,
and she was a poor
woman,
she got from camp to camp, becoming the nemesis of camp
commanders,
but she
did improve conditions for the men.
This,
starting with Florence Nightingale,
has been womens!
work during wars and following wars.
She has still served as
an angel of mercy to the disabled,
the ill and their dependents.
In the words of Dr. Osler,
it is our highest calling when "We
care for those unable to care for themselves, who need about them
gentle hands and tender hearts." The women of The American Legion
Auxiliary have been assisting in the program for veteran patients
since World War I in 1918.
This volunteer assistance at that
time was largely uncoordinated and the follow through,
the emphasis
upon integrating the VA hospital into the community life as part
and parcel of the community living,
thinking and planning, was
not implemented on a nationwide scale.
During World War II, the vast potential of service available through a coordinated volunteer program was early seen and
plans were developed which resulted in the establishment of coordinating agencies to mold the activities of hundreds of service
and welfare groups,
into a smooth working volunteer program for
members of the armed forces.
With the end of the war in 1045,
the immediate focal point of interest for many volunteer groups
over the country seemed lost,
But the leaders of these groups
147
realized that the training
certed and directed effort
outlet for their activity.
of
these
volunteers
the volunteers had received in conneed not be lost, if there was an
Since the focal point of interest
during
the
war had
been
members
of
the
armed
forces,
it was only natural that their leaders should see an
excellent carry-over of their war efforts to a peacetime activity
for men and women veteran patients. With such service in mind,
various organizations
leaders discussed with the Administrator
of Veterans!
Affairs the possible role their organizations might
play in the VA program for veteran patients.
Action on the matter was referred to the Assistant Administrator for Special Services and on April 8, 1946, The American
Legion and The
American Legion Auxiliary representatives met in
Washington with representatives of other groups to formulate
and suggest to the VA regulations
and procedures for the use of
volunteer assistance in the VA Special Service program for hospitalized veterans and in the establishment of the VAVS Advisory
Committee.
In 1950
came the United Nations stand against Communism
in Korea with the United States bearing the major part.
The
new wounded began coming home and hospital volunteers had
veterans of three wars for which to care.
The initials VAVS
stand for Veterans Administration Voluntary Service,
a plan for
community participation in the VA program for hospitalized
veterans.
One VA Administrator has called the VAVS the Vim and
Vigor Society.
The slogan of the rehabilitation committee of
the American Legion Auxiliary this year has been Service -- the
Volunteer Trademark.
Volunteers have come a long way since the
early days, when they were used mainly at the reception desk,
in recreation and personal service.
Much time was spent in
occupational
therapy,
needed.
The
recognized.
therapeutic
and
many
value
volunteers
skilled
of
busy
keeping
in
has
arts
were
always
been
Dr. Kirkbride of Pennsylvania wrote "Work is useful in
improving the health of the sick as in maintaining that of the
well,"
In a book entitled "Recent Advances in Psychiatry,”
an
example
is
quoted
of
improvement
from
occupations
when
a
mental patient became so intensely interested in weaving on a
small loom,
that he joyfully declared to the superintendent of
the hospital in which he was receiving
treatment,
"This house
has altered indeed.
It is now worth living in."
Nurses and
doctors
are
busy
people;
a
patient
can
receive
actual
service
from a nurse only about two hours out of the 24, and this is
where the volunteer enters into the pdcture.
They teach crafts
such as weaving,
copper enameling,
ceramics, painting and
knitting,
aid in the library,
the pharmacy,
the X-ray department,
the chapel and the blood bank program.
They teach dancing,
show
movies, write letters,
read to the blind,
lead songfests,
distribute mail,
sew and mend,
roll bandages.
There are very few
departments in the hospital where a volunteer cannot serve in
these
days.
Our greatest achievement
this year is the organization
of a corps of volunteers at the Carville Leprosarium
in Carville,
Louisiana.
There they are carrying out many of the
activities
that our volunteers do in other hospitals.
We now
have over eleven thousand volunteers serving in VA and non-VA
hospitals.
Recorded have been over one million hours of service by volunteers of all ages, husband-wife teams, mother and
148
daughter
teams,
and our
newest
volunteers,
our
Volunteens.
Articles distributed by our volunteers are too many to list
completely but thousands of cigarettes,
a thousand pounds of
candy,
cookies,
thousands of dollars worth Canteen books,
as
well as toilet articles,
stationery,
stamps, greeting cards,
scuffies,
pajamas,
bath robes and special napkins and tray
favors for all holidays,
as well as flowers, make our hospitals
cherry places.
Our Christmas Gift Shop program was carried on in 186
hospitals, with 318,376 gifts being selected by patients to
send home to their families,
at no cost to themselves.
Gaily
wrapped gifts, wrapped in brown paper for mailing, processed
by post offices set up in the hospitals,
cost Auxiliary units
over $500,000.
The total cost of the Christmas program of
gifts for each veteran was $263,654,
which gifts valued from
one dollar to ten dollars.
Noteworthy gifts were matching
dresses and sweaters for women patients,
a silver dollar on a
breakfast try Christmas morning,
telephone calls home on
Christmas Day and Christmas gifts left to be put under the tree
on Christmas morning,
for those patients unable to go home.
Devotion to duty even took some Auxiliary members into the
hospitals on Christmas Day for gift distribution.
We were delighted to have many Legionnaires help us and
they were invaluable in the Gift Shops.
In many departments,
the Christmas gift program for the veteran is carried on
jointly with the Legion and Auxiliary,
each contributing a
like sum for the cost of the gift to the veteran.
The Christmas
gift card bears the name of the President of the Auxiliary and
the Commander of the Post and they personally visit the hospi-
tals
to
make
the
gift
distribution.
By executive board action,
this year we shall present to
The American Legion $20,000 to further the rehabilitation program.
We cooperate
in the Hospital Veterans Writing Project,
the national organization and several of the departments contributing cash for awards.
Our volunteer hospitals workers are
urging participation in this contest to all patients.
Many
of our department presidents have special projects and I could
almost say they range from A for an aspirator and continue down
to Z for Zinnias.
Radios, High-Fi, Television,
record players,
lawn chairs,
service carts, motorized book carts,
soft drink
coolers,
libraphones,
a print washer for developing pictures,
furniture for day rooms,
sewing machines,
picnic tables,
softee
ice cream machines,
a tilt bed,
a kitchen for a soldier's home,
and planters for lobbies are just a few of the many desirable
items that make hospital life a bit more pleasant.
Some of the noteworthy special projects being carried out
constantly by departments
include gifts for veterans to send
home on Mothers' Day and their children's birthdays, wheel chairs
on loan when a patient is released from the hospital,
nurseries
where mothers may leave their children when visiting
their husbands,
insulin funds for indigent patients,
and the Craft Shop
in Chicago, where over $90,000 worth of veteran-made articles
were sold in 1960.
This shop is 30 West Washington Boulevard,
Chicago,
two blocks from Marshall Field's Department Store -visit it the next time you are in Chicago.
Several departments
help their Legion maintain mountain camps for convalescent
veterans,
149
One
season,
department
be tanned
to
collected
discarded
collected deer skins during the
and used in therapy craft work.
gold
and
silver
articles
relatives to the bedside of seriously
celebrating their centennial year and
made carpet bags.
for
hunting
Another
funds
to
bring
ill patients.
Kansas is
they are selling veteran-
We have many home-front volunteers,
the ones who live too
far away from any hospital to work there.
They are just at home,
baking cookies and cakes,
sewing needed hospital articles,
collecting gifts for the Gift Shops,
collecting coupons to redeem,
and holding rummage sales and card parties,
all necessary
to earn the money needed to carry on this vast program.
The
home-front volunteers,
the ones who live
too far away from any
hospital are also recognizing the needs of the older veteran in
the community, whether he is living at home or confined to a
nursing home.
Also,
the home-front workers are contacting the
families of a hospitalized veteran to determine if there is
need there.
On the return of the veteran from a hospital,
the
home-front worker calls to see if there is need of adjustment
or the need of a helping hand.
We must learn that we have a
new role to play -- we must not make the VA hospital,
an island
of
care
for
the
veteran.
be in need of help in
private nursing Home.
his
We
must
own
home,
remember
in
a
that
state
the
veteran
hospital,
may
ora
I remember the words of Milton Caniff in one of his comic
strips regarding the celebration of Veterans Day when he has
ane of his characters say, "I guess we'd all settle for a kind
word now and then from the folks who may be still alive because
we helped put out the
first so long ago."
Texas
Dr.
Buckholts,
had
this
to
say
manager
of
a
of
the
volunteer,
VA
hospital
'"What
in
makes
Dallas,
a
volunteer?
Not the headaches,
the sore feet and the sore back -- not for
glory,
not for pay, but for this feeling,
"I am my brother's
keeper!"
I shall close with the reading of an article written
by a volunteer in the Lebanon, Pennsylvania VA hospital entitled
"Certainly 1 Got Paid.”
Many times folks have asked me, "Do you get paid for what
you do at the veterans'
hospital?"
My answer has been, "Certainly
not.
I'm a volunteer!"
That statement set me thinking -- then
I realized I was not giving the correct answer.
Certainly I get
paid.
I get paid just by having the opportunity of helping sick
people.
I get paid when a patient says,
"Thank you," for an
eagerly looked-for
letter.
I get paid when I arrange a bouguet
of flowers and return them to receive a smile of gratitude.
I
get paid in the satisfaction of knowing that what may seem like
a very insignificant
task,
like helping a patient to Emergency,
directing a patient to the clinic,
steadying a cup while giving
nourishment,
even such a small task, is at the moment,
the most
important thing in the world.
"I get paid in knowing since there are people who must depend on others for help,
that I can give some part of that help.
I get paid in the friendships
I've made.
There are many things
in life that have no price tag and on which there is no room
for: a. dollar sign.
we
are
"In our
little
not doing big
corner of the world at
things,
just every day
150
the VA
little
hospital,
things,
helping
wide
our
field
brethern.
of
It's
service,
but
a
small
do
you
I am the richest person in the
another job at a higher salary
me,
Do I get paid?
Certainly
part
know
I
play
something?
world.
No one
-- there is no
I get paid.”
iin
this
I
big,
feel
can offer me
better job for
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Thank you very much, Mrs. McKay.
I
think I would be derelict
if I didn't take just a second to
call your attention to the fact that Mrs. Ahnemiller,
the
National President of the Legion Auxiliary has come to the
- room.
Would you stand and let them all see you?
we
The things that
doctors talk about
loving
care.
The
Mrs.
when
panel
McKay speaks of are the things that
we TLC on a patient's chart,
tender
to
session will speak on an
McKay,
of the things the
are glad to have you put
the
morning
allied thing.
We were well
Auxiliary have done and are
it into national focus.
follow
and
to
finish
aware,
doing.
Mrs.
We
For this next panel,
I would like to follow the procedure we followed earlier and introduce to you, if I may,
perhaps out of good manners,
but for
practical reasons,
the
Legion panel on the rostum with me at this time.
Then we will
go to the people of the Veterans Administration.
Chairing this
particular panel is Dr. Charles Soforenko,
of Massachusetts,
and with him Glen Rardin of Virginia,
Ned Prator of Oklahoma,
Roy L. Carver of Missouri,
and our National Chaplain, Reverend
Moss, whom you all know.
In order to start this discussion
on the voluntary administration of voluntary service, Veterans
Administration Voluntary Services and VAVS, and that is like
rehab -- we use it without thinking, Mrs. McKay.
I
to
urge
the
would like to call
panel for questions
you
to
send
your
on two people
propounded on
questions
up
from
first before
page 18, and
the
floor.
we get
again I
To
start
this discussion,
I will call on I think at the moment the
ranking panelist even though the boss is still at the table,
Dr. Cohen.
I am going to call on Dr. Cohen,
to do the chore
before Dr. Middleton tells him to anyhow.
Dr. Cohen.
DR. COHEN:
Thank you very much, Dr. Booher.
I have been
taken a little off base here because I had fully expected that
Dr. Middleton was going to be in my place here right now, so
suppose I do that and present to you again Dr. Middleton.
DR. MIDDLETON:
Apparently Dr. Cohen hasn't forgotten the
Army habit of passing the buck.
May I say that I was deeply
moved by Mrs. McKay's presentation,
a very clear and lucid outline
of the functions of the volunteer service.
She, of course, went
into other areas than those affecting the medical system of the
Veterans Administration,
but they were nonetheless cogent in
their application to the particular function,
May I indicate,
furthermore,
that the volunteer service is one that has not only
all of the connotations of the qualifying adjective volunteer,
but also a singularity,
If I were to attempt to recover the
ground that has already been so well covered it would be but to
indicate that this is indeed a broad and important aspect of
medical
care.
I
am,
however,
ceive of the quality of
American veteran in our
that motivates the many
This,
of
course,
moved
to
say
medical care that
hospitals without
volunteers in our
is
an
extremely
151
that
I
cannot
con-
is available to the
this spirit of service
program.
important
element,
but
you
will perhaps be interested in the fact that an isolated physician myself would evaluate quality of management in a hospital
by the adequacy,
by the activity,
of the voluntary service.
I
would go beneath the service and beyond the terms of technical
medical care and look into this particular element that means
so much not only to the peace of mind and welfare of the veteran
within the hospital, but to his re-socialization.
It is so easy
to build up barriers behind hospital walls and these barriers
are
so
important
when
we
are
attempting
to
return
the
veteran
to
his appropriate place in the voluntary society.
So you will
bear with me when I say that this is the bridge between the
hospital and society for the veteran.
I am particularly relieved this morning,
and I say relieved because appropriately
the term is applied in the sense that I have the presence of my
own sex here.
At the earliest meetings with you there was only
a sprinkling of the male representatives of the Legion.
The
female Legionnaires and the Auxuliary were carrying the load and
we were hidden behind their skirts.
It is time we are coming
out and you by your presence here indicate that you have taken
that position.
I believe you realize that in our organizational
pattern in Central Office Veterans Administration we have made
a
change,
improving the dignity and the
stature of the Voluntary
Service by bringing.the Director of Voluntary Service,
the
Honorable James Parke, Jim Parke to most of you, into the staff
relationship
immediately with Dr. Thomas Arnett, Deputy Assistant Chief Medical Director for Professional Services.
This
was a very thoughtful device and it had as its objective bringing into the professional
area and into close contact with the
operations of the Professional Services division,
the Director
of this particular effort.
We
Director
have here then, first,
the
for Professional Services,
Director
of
Peter
Miller,
Arnett,
late
Voluntary
his
Services,
associate,
of Clarksburg,
Mr.
next;
West
Assistant Chief Medical
Dr. Cohen; we have the
James
and
Parke;
then
Virginia.
we
we
have
have
Mr.
Dr.
Thomas
DR. COHEN:
Thank you very much, Dr. Middleton.
While
Dr. Middleton accused me of passing the buck,
I think I was
doing an army job of sending up some heavy artillery to open,
and to help build some bulwarks,
and to present to you in an
orderly
fashion
some
of
the
things
that
we
wanted
to
talk
about.
I think Dr. Middleton set the framework for this in speaking
about the role of the volunteer in terms of establishing quality
of care in support of our veteran patients.
Briefly,
1 want to
expand a little bit further on the reason behind the placement
of the voluntary services in Central Office in the Office of
Professional Services and the individual hospitals in the Office
of the Director of Professional Services. As a staff assistant
to the Director of Professional Services,
I think you will recognize, of course,
that while at the very outset following the
war, the major role of the volunteer was to bring services and
supplies of a particular kind to the veteran,
this has changed
very sharply and Mrs. McKay has emphasized to you generally the
manner in which this change has come about.
Today the services are beginning to take shape in the direction of providing closer relationship to the professional
service with patients.
Someone from the floor in the previous
panel asked the question about the expansion of day care centers.
Dr. Casey might have spent a little time then, and I think he
deferred to us, to make a particular point with regard to the
152
establishment
and expansion of day care centers.
In and of
themselves,
the day care centers cannot succeed without the
support,
the strong support,
of volunteers;
volunteers who will
provide practically everything that they do in the hospital,
but
even more
will provide a very close relationship with the community.
They will be in the community a kind of shepherd to help
bring the individual away from the day care center ultimately into
as complete independence in the communityy as possible.
We look
to the Legion and to the Auxiliary to make its meeting places
available to men ready for and who have been discharged from
our hospitals,
our clinics,
and our day care centers.
The ultimate establishment of the restoration centers which Dr. Middleton
referred to in the earlier panel also will make very heavy demands for volunteers;
to provide the tie
with the community and
to help to bring into clearer focus the importance of structuring
voluntary services,
community services for veterans.
In structuring community services for the veterans the volunteer will be in
a
position
to
serve,
citizen and as
ready to leave
not
only
as
a fellow resident
the hospital,
the
a
volunteer,
but
of a community
center,
or the
also
as
a
to the veteran
restoration unit.
The actual placement organizationally of the Director of
Volunteers in the Office of the Director of Professional Services
makes it possible for him to be working directly with every professional element in the hospital,
bringing to those departments
who are most urgently in need of specific categories of volunteers
the skills of those volunteers to meet and to match the needs of
the patients.
The changes that are slowly beginning to evolve in
the care of the mentally ill patients beyond the day care center,
those having to do with the establishment of half-way houses, of
which there are more than a half dozen today in the country, will
also make it possible for volunteers to provide an entirely
different
type
of
service.
It will
be
amore
direct
kind
of
support service in the field of rehabilitation as it relates to
the various rehabilitation therapies,
and also in the form of
companionship therapy with close ties with the social service
staff.
We do
need in this area a very close relationship with
the professional services and hence this change.
Dr.
present
will
Arnett
some
proceed
will
other
with
speak
aspects
the
panel
with
of
the
you
at
program
this
time
change,
briefly
to
and
we
then
later.
DR. ARNETT:
Thank you, Dr. Cohen.
Members of the group,
I think this pass the buck really has been going around pretty
fast.
I was at the other end of the table and hoping it wouldn't
get down there, but I made it.
I would like to also say what
both Dr. Cohen and Dr. Middleton said; Mrs. McKay has about
covered the field in a very excellent address.
There is one
phase which I would like to mention and that is our administrative
assistance to the DPS and what is in the future in behalf of these
people.
You who are in the field deal with these people very
closely and I know you have some questions in your mind as to
their future.
At the present moment, we are going throughout all of our
stations getting and obtaining from the station an evaluation of
our present administrative assistants.
When this is completed,
we will then have a program established by centralizing their
positions back to Washington or into the area offices so that a
career program can be offered to these people.
This sudden
change has caused some upsets at various stations.
We believe
153
with an educational program now in its second or third month,
with the centralization of the position and
with the recognition that you people giwve to these people,
that we can
bring
the
professional
services
through
assistants closer to the volunteers.
try to answer any questions that you
I look forward very enthusiastically
the
Director
of Professional
the
VAVS
all
"at
stations.
Services
Thank
the
administrative
I would be glad later to
might, have on this matter.
to this new set-up because
now
is
the
Chairman
of
you.
DR. COHEN:
Dr. Middleton has already introduced to you
Mr. Parke, Director of Voluntary Services,
and at this
time I
would like to have him make a few remarks to the audience.
MR. PARKE:
Mr. Chairman,
distinguished delegates all,
I
think those of yOu who with whom I have been associated in this
program over the past 15
years would realize what a thrill I
have
gotten
at
the
session
thus
far
this
morning
from
Mrs.
McKay's excellent address and the backing from our medical people.
You know,
it is interesting that in this program in which you and
I have been associated there is no training for doctors in medical
schools so far as I know about the use of community volunteer resources as we know them.
We have had a long experience in the
VA in working with our medical staff getting them to see the
picture and as I
sat here this morning I realized that we have
graduate stadents on-my left in the meaning of purposeful use
of community resources.
I know that those of you, as I say,
you and I who have worked together over these years, must feel
a real sense of warmth at the comments that have been made about
what you are doing in our program.
There are some questions
from the floor and I will wait to speak upon them.
Thank you.
I
kind
CHAIRMAN
of held
BOOHER:
you off,
Dr.
but
Soforenko,
it is your
will you
turn.
go
ahead
now?
DR. SOFORENKO:
Before we open the panel discussion,
I
would like to make a few remarks and say that in the audience
are five of my severest critics from the Department of Massachusetts
and they are just sitting there waiting for me to make a mistake
so they can gloat over it, and I do make mistakes, when we get
back
to
Massachusetts,
so
take today.
However,
it
on this particular panel
feel and I note that the
that
voluntary
service
is
I
hope
the
panel
does
not
make
a
mis-
is a pleasure and a privilege to serve
today because we of The American Legion,
Veterans Administration does also,
a
very
important
adjunct
to
the
care
of our hospital comrades and I want to thank Bob McCurdy for the
honor in appointing me to this committee,
and also to those who
are responsible for my appointment.
Now,
only
one
we
will
question
go
on
ahead
the
with
agenda.as
mitted by A. R. Lindberg from
Mr. Rardin ask that question,
the
a
panel
discussion.
prepared question
Missouri,
please.
and
I
would
like
There
and
to
is
sub-
have
MR. RARDIN (VIRGINIA):
The question presented by Mr.
Lindberg of Missouri.
Please discuss under what circumstances
VA hospitals may provide transportation for volunteer hospital
workers.
We feel the transportation problem at the Jefferson
Barracks
VA
hospital
has
decreased
our
number
of
volunteers.
We
could have many more volunteers at this station;
however, many
are on pension and cannot pay the expense of transportation.
It
costs the average volunteer who comes by public transportation
154
over $1, as the fare
We have a county bus
line,
which
runs
in St. Louis has recently been increased.
line at the end of the city public service
approximately
every
hour.
The
fare
for
this
bus is 15
cents.
I feel that there should be some way the
station could pick up these people at the end of the public
service line.
We have transportation available on the station
and if it could be possible
to pick up these volunteers, we
would have no trouble in recruiting more volunteers, we would
have no trouble in recruiting more volunteer workers.
MR. PARKE:
This,
as I think most of you know, one of our
ma jor problems in recruiting volunteers and actually in retaining volunteers once recruited.
The results of a two-year study
of recruitment and retention of volunteers made by our national
committee clearly show that.
I am quite interested that Mr.
Lindberg who asked this question is a representative of the
Legion,
of the VAVS committee at Jefferson Barracks,
and that
committee,
as Mr. Lindberg knows,
I am sure,
is one of 14 committees throughout
the country making a study of this problem
of transportation.
One of the studies at Jefferson Barracks
will be in three phases:
determining what the station can do to
alleviate the problem, determining what each organization comprising our VAVS committee can do, and thirdly,
surveying community commercial transportation agencies to determine what
assistance can be gained.
Now, we have asked two hospitals in each of our seven
medical areas to make a year-long study of ways and means to
solve,
if possible,
this transportation problem.
While they
are doing that we here in the Central Office are doing what
we can to find out how VA can assist.
Now,
already where
there is transportation,
let's say between a downtown outpatient clinic and a VA hospital,
we have had approval from
the general counsel's office that that bus or car can stop
en route and pick up volunteers.
This is an opening wedge and
we are hopeful that by the hospitals working on it themselves,
the hospital committees working on it, and we here in Central
Office we can arrive at a happy conclusion of this; because
certainly,
and particularly with respect to the program of the
older and retired workers,
and we are emphasizing participation
by the older and retired workers in our program now, getting
them out to the hospital
is a major problem.
We are particularly interested in finding a solution, Mr.
Lindberg,
to this question and I hope very much
that your committee at Jefferson Barracks will come up with some of the
answers.
MR. KORELLA:
About a week ago, when I last saw Mr.
Lindberg and he informed me at that time
that he was in contact
with
the
officials
of
the. county
bus
line
in
this
respect.
What the end result has been'l do not as yet know.
However,
I do know that there are any number of retired veterans who
would be most happy to.assist in VAVS program if it were possible
for them to
expend that
get to Jefferson Barracks Hospital and not have to
dollar a day doing so.
Most of them, of course, are
on pension.
Some of them do not receive pensions,
but they are
on social security,
and as you well know,
the cost of living is
not a minor item and although they are willing they have no way
of getting there.
I told Mr. Lindberg that no doubt his problem
could be resolved when your study is completed.
155
MR.
PARKE:
We
are
hopeful
it
will,
and,
by
the
way,
I
might say to those of you who are working closely with the VA
hospitals,
if your hospital is not one that.is making this
study, don't feel that you don't have a responsibility to help
out because all of us need to put our best minds together on
this problem of transportation.
DR.
question?
SOFORENKO:
If
any
of
Any
other
you
have
comment
any
on
this
questions
you
particular
would
like
to
have answered,
if you write them down and present them to the
panel, we will discuss them.
I have two questions here I would
like to ask of Dr. Cohen or a responsible person.
What was
the prevailing purpose behind the change from monthly meetings
of the VAVS committee to quarterly meetings?
MR. PARKE:
I am not sure I have the answer,
but I would
like to give you a little background on this matter of the meetings of the committee.
I mentioned earlier that this year we
are celebrating the 15th
birthday of VA Voluntary Service.
Come
to our meeting in April,
and we will let you have a piece of
our 15th
birthday cake that we are going to have for it.
We
feel that we have reached a stage now where we wanted to take
a look at the operations of the program.
It was our feeling
that actually our work is involved in (1) somewhat of the nature
of
long-range
planning
and
thinking
about
this
program
and
(2)
the operating procedures of the program.
It was our suggestion
to the field that perhaps now we could have quarterly meetings
of the committee,
one meeting a quarter to discuss top level
planning for the future of the program,
new advances in medical
care
and
treatment
with
the
implications
for
volunteers,
because
very frankly,
and again something that makes me feel very warm,
jist as we have the backing,
as illustrated here this morning,
of our top medical men in Central Office,
so this program has
that backing of the medical men in our hospitals.
Our thought was that at these quarterly meetings top
people from the organizations would meet together sitting
around the council table with our top medical staff and top
specialists of other staffs of the VA to plan together for ever
more purposeful bringing of the community to the hospital and
the hospital to the community,
and while that’ long-range planning
is going on, bringing in, let's say,
the local Commander of your
Post,
the local President of the Auxiliary,
along with the representatives,
bringing in some of your department officials,
because this is an area where we haven't been able to educate people.
We
have
not
been
able
to
get
to
the
department
people.
However,
at the same time,
that we are looking to the future,
and I am
not talking about simply,
one, two, or three years from now;
I
am thinking about 10, 15,
20 years from now in this program as
we look forward,
because without vision the people fail and I
think we need this vision,
and as I say,
at the same time we
have that, we.have the operating details of the program to carry
out.
For example,
every hospital has coordinated Christmas programs.
Mrs. McKay referred to some of that a moment ago.
This
is an operating part of the program,
so we have a meeting for
that.
This would not be one of the quarterly meetings.
This
would be a-.called meeting for people on the committee who are
particularly concerned with that.
year.
Nearly every hospital has a
Here the operating head of
people,
hospital
and
can
here
have
would
as
be
many
a
special
meetings
156
carnival some
that needs to
meeting,
as
it
so
wants.
time during the
get together the
actually
the
We suggest four of these be the kind where you bring in the
top level people.
That is the thinking behind the planning for
the four regularly scheduled meetings and such operating meetings
involving,
for example,
not the Director of Professional Services
as Chairman, because he is not involved in the operating of something already established,
but he is involved in planning for
the future.
DR. SOFORENKO:
Mr. Parke,
I would like to make this comment:
that it has not worked out that way in Massachusetts.
We
feel that we have lost contact and rapport with other service
organizations
in the exchange of ideas as to how to best serve
our disabled comrades.
I am the VAVS representative at West
Roxbury VA hospital,
and I feel that I have personally lost contact not only with the other service organizations,
but I have
also lost contact with the Chief of Special Services and the
Director of Professional
Services.
When I go to the hospital,
I don't
would
tion.
feel
come
that
into
homey
the
feeling
hospital
and
that
we
used
that
is
why
to
I
have
when
we
asked
this
ques-
MR. PARKE:
My wonderment
there would be whether that
results specifically from a lesser number
of meetings,
or from
something else.
One of the problems we have had is attendance
at the committee meetings.
We have not had very good attendance
throughout
the country.
Our thought was perhaps we are calling
the people together too many times during the year so this has
been an experiment to try to find if we can get better attendance
at the four.
Then at the specially called meetings call just
those who will be involved in the project that is going to be
carried out, but if it is losing the thing that you are talking
about we will need to take another look at it.
DR. SOFORENKO:
The second question is this: did the
Veterans Administration feel that in abolishing the special
services unit at VA facilities and creating two separate divisions it would be more advantageous
to the veterans?
Does the
Veterans Administration feel that it has worked out that way?
DR. COHEN:
I think that we have attempted to give you
some insight into the reason for the organizational
change.
In
response to the latter half of this question or the direct
pointed part of the question,
I think we must admit that, while
the initial part of the change went smoothly and was properly
prepared for, any change brings with it certain problems and
that this change has brought with it certain problems.
I think
that Dr. Arnett attempted to point out to you the areas in which
we recognized the problems that have been generated and the
approach that we plan to take to deal with it.
Insofar as
specific relationship to problems of the special service program itself,
all of the functions of the special services are
still being continued.
The library program is being continued,
of course,
as you all know, and the recreation program is being
continued as part of the rehabilitation section of the hospital,
so that I think it is only a matter of organizational change.
In dealing properly with and in the placing of the individuals
who are working with the coordination of VAVS we must structure
a positive program,
and this is the program which Dr. Arnett
has already referred to.
DR.
SOFORENKO:
Dr.Arnett,
157
have
you
that
question?
DR.
.ARNETT:
Yes,
sir.
I think this question more or less falls on the one
that
Dr. Cohen just answered.
It is a very excellent question
from Mr. Henry, Department Service Officer from Kansas City,
Missouri.
The question:
since Special Services has been placed
under the Chief of Professional Services the Special Service
staff
has
been
cut
and
in
some
hospitals
they
do
not
have
anyone
qualified to supervise and instruct the volunteer worker.
Therefore,
the program has suffered.
Can anything be done to correct
the situation by adding a qualified person to the staff of this
hospital?
I think if the gentleman will not mind,
this is a
question that applies to many of our hospitals at the present
time and that is the reason we are having this evaluation and
centralizing of position,
so that we will see that the volunteer
service is covered.
. There is no question this was the one thing that we worried
most about in our reorganization,
that is, that the individual
would be too engrossed in his job of being assistant to the DPS
at those stations where the Director of Volunteer Services would
suffer.
I think with our centralization and our emphasis on it
that this will be corrected.
I don't know whether this a satisfactory answer or not.
This is our greatest concern in the reorganization and it is
receiving our constant attention,
because
the one thing that we assured all the service organizations,
and
we wanted to be sssured within our own group, was that the
volunteer program would not lose supervision by this reorganization.
We will admit to the gentleman that in some places that
has
occurred
does
and
we
are
that
satisfy
you?
MR.
HENRY:
I
am
taking
glad
to
corrective
hear
your
action.
answer
Mr.
on
Henry,
that
question.
In our area we have the Wadsworth VA Center and Kansas City VA
Hospital,
and I do see a contrast in the two institutions since
Wadsworth is a center and they do have assistants to special
services and they can carry on a volunteer program.
There at
Kansas City,
they do have a
limited number of employees working
for
at
special
the
Kansas
services
City
and
it
seems
Hospital
is
the
as
if
one
the
that
volunteer
has
been
program
suffering
because there is nobody qualified there.
The Chief of Special
Services there is busy covering all activities and there is just
no one there qualified to carry on and assist these volunteer
workers in carrying out the program they have had over the years,
and in which they have done a wonderful
job all through the years
at
the
Kansas
City
Hospital.
We
would
hate
to
suffer at any hospital for lack of someone that
on the staff that is qualified to assist in the
this program.
DR.
ARNETT:
Could
MR.“
HENRY:
"Yes,
I
ask one
see
the
program
could be
carrying
placed
on of
question?
‘sir.
DR. ARNETT:
I am not familiar with all these stations,
but I would presume that at Kansas City you do not have a Director of Volunteers as an assigned individual independent of the
administrative DPS.
MR.
HENRY:
DR. ARNETT:
station would that
Not
that
I
know
of.
If we had a Director of
resolve your problem.
158
Volunteers
at
that
MR.
HENRY:
Yes,
it
DR.
ABRNETT:
' Thank
DR.
SOFORENKO:
would.
you,
Thank
sir,
you,
Dr,
Arnett,
Mr. Rardin of Virginia, Assistant Department
Officer, would like to comment on the program that
adopted in his particular department.
a lot
MR.
RARDIN:
It
of
difficulty
obtaining
seems
the
trouble
volunteer
here
Service
they have
is
you
are
having
workers
for
the
hospitals.
We have a volunteer workers program at the Veterans Administration
Hospital,
the neuropsychiatric hospital,
Salem, Virginia which
has proved to be very good
and it may or may not be unique.
Since 1956
The American Legion hospital volunteer workers chairman has had
the assistance of our two local colleges and at the
present time 70 students spend three hours each week under the
supervision
of
their
professors
providing
services
in psychology,
occupational
therapy, physical therapy, manual arts therapy,
corrective therapy,
operating room, nursing service,
pharmacy,
chaplain service,
and so forth.
The work assumed now at the
hospital is considered the laboratory portion of their regularly
scheduled classes for which they receive credit. The college
students perform the work as the laboratory work for sociology
and abnormal psychology.
The students are directed to carry
out the
same responsibilities as volunteer workers and they
accept their assignment with a great deal of enthusiasm.
They
are well received by the hospital staff and the patients.
The
Director of Special Services at the hospital made this remark
about their work.
"The students provide the personal attention
so often lacking and necessary in treating NP patients.' This
may be a field in which you can find additional workers.
DR.
beyond
SOFORENKO:
Are there any
time so will
COLONEL
MURRAY
Thank
you,
Mr.
Rardin,
more questions?
We are running
you make it short, please?
(FLORIDA):
I would
like
to
ask
a
little
the
gentle-
man up there is they have any estimated evaluation of the three
VA hospitals in Florida,
and how are they performing in this VAVS
program?
Have you come to any point where you are getting a
picture of what the program is advancing?
Are we increasing our
numbers?
MR. PARKE:
One of the least’ happy things in our present
situation about decentralization is that we don't have the picture
we formerly had.
I have visited the hospital at Coral Gables,
but not within the last two years.
At that time,
I felt we were
much in need of a Director of Volunteers
there.
At Bay Pines,
we have a Director of Volunteers.
I have never been to Lake City,
so I cannot say.
I feel that we need in the Bay Pines Hospital
many more
volunteers than we were getting.
I think probably
that has improved.
I hope it has.
At Coral Gables Hospital
there was not the problem of the need of ¥olunteers because
seemingly there were so many more available.
I cannot speak of
Lake City at all.
I would say as far as our programs
, and I
haven't seen them now since this change-over,
that at the time
I saw them the volunteer program at Bay Pines needed more help
from the communities.
The volunteer program at Coral Gables
had excellent support,
though it probably needed more supervisory assistance from the VA itself.
159
COLONEL MURRAY:
Thank you very much,
sir.
I am Acting
Director of the hospital program and have been
for a number of
years as Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission,
and last
year -- I wanted to make this remark, Mr. Chairman,
for a
minute -- at our National Convention, which happened to be in
Miami Beach, we were able to give out seven of these special
volunteer pins and they were received very well.
I did it at
the rehab meeting at Miami Beach during the Convention.
I am
speaking now of just Legionnaires who are volunteering,
not
the volunteers of the Legion Auxiliary and those who come in on
part-time,
the rehabilitation part, particularly.
We have about
15 in
the state and we are having our problems in getting the
retired man on the job.
We are making progress.
I just wanted
to know how we are doing.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
DR. SOFORENKO:
Thank you, Cy. At this time,
I would like
to call on John Corcoran,
the Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission, for a few remarks.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The remarks will
be very short and brief.
I could not resist taking the microphone to tell you at least for the record the attitude of the
National Rehabilitation Commission on the VAVS program.
The
National Rehabilitation Commission wholeheartedly endorses and
supports the VAVS program.
It seems to me that in the beginning
of our rehabilitation efforts immediately after World War I,
there was a great emphasis upon hospitalization and medical care
of the returning servicemen.
I think that thereafter there was
some type of evolution in which at least on a national level, we
turned
our
attention
a
great
deal
to
compensation
and the legislative efforts in that direction.
partly attributable
to the superb job that the
Medicine and Surgery is doing.
and
pension,
This may be
Department of
I think that one of our great goals
at the present and. in
the immediate future returns now to the medical care, particularly as that great group of veterans reach the older category.
We want you folks,
therefore,
in the Departments to keep us
fully informed on such things as administrative
changes such as
the ones that were discussed this morning and how they affect
the volunteer program in your Department.
We also want you to
do one other thing and I think this you will enjoy.
At the
Minneapolis Convention,
there was approved a resolution authorizing us to create a design and then to distribute opinions for
those volunteer hospital workers who had achieved 1000 or more
hours of service in hospitals.
We began distributing those pins
in August of 1960.
We have distributed 380.
Thenational organization
pays
for
you
help
us
Thank
to
you.
these
spend
pins
some
and
of
for
Bob
these
bars,
McCurdy's
DR. SOFORENKO:
Thank you, John.
questions, we close the discussion and
back to Dr. Booher.
so
money
we
encourage
in
this
If there are no
I will turn the
direction.
further
Chair
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I want to thank in your behalf the members of the panel and friends from the Veterans Administration.
I have three announcements.
Many of you knew Edward Nowak.
You
know that he was with us in Buffalo, New York and we have just
been
informed
him
can
get
that
more
he
died
details
this
from
morning.
John
160
Those
Corcoran.
of
you
who
knew
. es
CHAIRMAN
until
to
1:30
this
Thank
you.
BOOHER:
The
Announcmenis,..
Conference
will
be
suspended
Conference
day).
recessed,
afternoon,
(Whereupon,
at
reconvene at 1:30
12:05
P.M.,
the
P, M,, the same
161
THURSDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
... The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel: Statler, Washington, D,'C.,
at -1:30'p.m,., Vice Chairman
F. Clinton Knight presiding:
CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
The conference will now come to order.
It is my privilege to present to you Mr. James W. Stancil,
Chairman of the Board of Veterans Appeals.
STATEMENT OF JAMES W. STANCIL, CHAIRMAN
BOARD OF VETERANS' APPEALS
MR. STANCIL:
I am not entirely sure of the significance
of all these TV sets around here but they all seem to be dark
so I guess I can proceed with assurance.
It is good to have
the opportunity to be with you again at one of these conferences.
I
have
met
a
lot
of
old
friends
and
some
new
ones.
You
are
even
more welcome this year as far as we on the Board are concerned
than you have been in past years because you seem to have brought
with you at least a touch of Spring.
Until just a few days ago
we had snow and ice and a great deal of it.
Mel claims that he brought.
the Florida weather and Bob
McCurdy tells me he
brought it from California,
but whichever
it is, we needed it and we are very grateful. Larry Pierce,
the
Vice Chairman,
is unavoidably detained, but I have a new face
for you, Woodie Flowers from Kentucky, who is the Deputy Vice
Chairman sitting here on my left whom I would like you to know.
I told you last year that
this year would be one of great change
in the personnel of the Board because we had some retirements
coming up.
There have been a great many changes.
In fact, out
of 30 some-odd board members,
14 of them are new since we last
met.
The year since we last met has also been a year of change
in a great many other ways and I think a year of some progress.
I would like to tell you some of the things that have
happened very briefly.
We have had organizational and operational
changes,
some of them growing out of study by the Board of
Veterans Appeals and recommendations by interested organizations,
The American Legion certainly being very concerned in that, Congressional hearings last year on the subject of judicial review,
and our own internal studies and our efforts to improve the
Board which go on month in and month out.
The most helpful and
I think welcome change is that we were authorized to increase
the size of the board from 11 sections to 14 sections.
We have
13 now and expect to have the 14th one in operation in July.
This will give us a little more time per case, and that is an
item that
got a lot of discussion at last year's Congressional
hearings:
whether 14 sections in the long run will be enough is
something that we will determine by time and experience,
but in
the meantime this increase is certainly going to help us and we
intend to use it to the best advantage.
We have effected an internal reorganization of the board
that probably will not interest you in itself in specific details,
but you are of course interested in the results that you can see
and can evaluate,
and we think it will pay dividends.
Briefly,
we have reorganized in a way to provide us with a substantial
increase in the facilities for our
professional training and our
162
quality control measures.
You should see increasing results
of this in more complete and better written decisions
in the
coming months.
We now handle our reconsiderations a little
differently.
The people who are operating in this field of
veterans
claims,
know
that
the
Board
operates
under
published
rules of practice and in these rules we provide for hearings and
briefs to show error in appellate decisions.
Each year we do
reconsider a number of cases, not a very large volume,
nothing
approaching any routine second appeal,
of course, but it is
important under our system and American concepts of good adjudication that a procedure exist for reconsideration where
there is a substantial allegation of error of fact or law in
the decision that you receive.
Heretofore,
these reconsiderations were always handled
by the same three signatory members to the decisions
that were
made initially.
These signatory members have to participate
in
any reconsideration because by law their unanimous conclusion
has certain legal impact and finality.
But we explored various
means of approaching as nearly as we could what the appellate
courts call an "en banc” rehearing.
‘We couldn't have all 13
sections act on an individual case without bogging down,
as we
have a case load volume of around 38,000 cases a year; but what
we did was to provide that when the board reconsiders one of
its decisions we add to the original section an additional
section, which is not committed on the case in any way, for the
purpose of reconsideration.
As another
item, the board no longer participates
in formulation stages of VA regulations,
instructions,
Administrator's
decision,
or other items of adjudicative policy.
This is specifically in line with an American Legion recommendation and
a resolution that The American Legion passed.
Removal from the
policy-making procedure places more responsibility on the board
of an evaluative nature when problems arise in cases that are
appealed
and
come
before
us.
Channels
exist
whereby
the
board
can bring to the Administrator's attention substantial questions that arise in our appeals practice as to whether some
enunciated policy should in our opinion be modified.
We are
bound by law, as you know, by the VA regulations,
by the Administrator's decisions,
and by the instructions,
but being out of
the policy formulation stage we are in a sense uncommitted and
this opens the way in appropriate cases to argue the propriety of
the governing criteria involved,
and I think,
if I understand
the reasoning behind the Legion's resolution,
that this is entirely in line with your thinking.
Board,
of
the
An item of interest that doesn't
but will be of some interest to
VA
has
underway
a total
and
directly involve the
you -- the General Counsel
comprehensive
review
of
all
published Administrator's Decisions.
The purpose of this comprehensive review is to insure that this body of binding precedents stands well in the face of today's law, to eliminate
ambiguities,
conflicts,
and in general improve this group of
precedents.
Last year the House of Representatives passed a bill
which would require the board to set out in its decisions speci-
fic and separately stated findings of fact and conclusions
which changes the format of our decisions somewhat. It was
of law,
not
acted on by the Senate.
It was passed by the House in closing
days but an identical bill has been introduced this year and is
being reported out by the House Veterans Affairs Committee.
I
think in all likelihood it will pass.
We certainly don't object
163
to
this
and
in
fact
have been
working
out
a
new
format
for
our
decisions that will accomplish the purpose of the bill and a
little more than that.
This is essentially a change in format
and not in substance,
but it is, I think,
going to improve our
decisions considerably from the standpoint of explanation and
detail and in general will be a better product.
You may have
seen some of them already.
We have continued since we last met sending a Section
of the Board out to a number of field offices,
one trip each
calendar quarter and the results of this have been good from
our standpoint
and I get good reports from a number of you people.
By June of this year we will have completed the first swing of
all
the
offices
except
for
a very
small
number
where
the
load
is
so small it doesn't justify the trip.
We will continue this
each quarter and on that kind of a schedule we will get back
to your office about once every two to two and a half years.
I
wish we could do better and perhaps we can in the future.
Plans
are being made which would provide the board with its own building, separate and apart from the VA Central Office.
We expected
to be moved in by the time of this conference,
but we ran into
a little problem of space for the people that are in that builds
ing now and that is delaying us, I hope no more than eighty to
ninety days.
The building that we are scheduled to get is not
far from here.
It is
at the corner of Fifteenth and "L", Northwest,
two or three blocks away,
a building that just fits our
space needs and we will be the only occupant of the building.
Most people think that this move is a good thing and that
it will help emphasize that appellate review is objective and
is independent of the operating departments.
I can't take the
time to give you much of a background on these new members
that I spoke of, but so you can get some kind of a quick impression I would like to ask them to stand up as I call their
names and very briefly,
I will tell you who they are.
Ed
Sugg
from
Tennessee
is
here
and
Ed
Shackelford
from
North Carolina.
Bill Cosgrove from New York, Jack Dabis from
Kentucky,
Dr. Thomas Wells is from Ohio,
and Larry Ryan is from
Ohio.
Emerson Johnston is from Michigan and Jim Burke is from
the District of Columbia.
(I didn't think there were any.
That
is a standing joke around here.
No one is ever born in the
District of Columbia.
They all come from somewhere else).
Leonard Alford is from South Carolina and Carlton Heyser is from
Maryland;
Donald Callison is from Virginia.
John Crogan,
from
Ohio -- Ohio is doing well -- Raoul Archambault from Rhode Island
and Johnny Catterton,
also from Virginia.
Mainly,
I wanted to
give you a quick impression of the changesof the board,
the fact
that it is changing very rapidly.
Fourteen new members appointed
within the last year is about a third of the Board,
the largest
number since its inception,
except the original Board.
These
men come from a variety of backgrounds
that will,
I am sure, bring
great strength to the board, not only because they are wide-spread
geographically,
but we have former consultants of the board; we
have former rating board members,
former adjudication officers,
a former vice chairman of the Board on Waivers and Forfeitures,
men from Mr. Stratton's staff in Compensation and Pension Service,
a former Assistant Director of the Bureau of the Budget and Chief
of Claims from V.B.O.
They will indeed bring a lot of strength
to: the board,
I
want
to
say
once
again
164
the
last
year
has
been
a
very
event ful one and that the Legion's constructive criticism as
always has been of material help to us.
I appreciate the opportunity to tell you a little something about what has been going
on.
While I am at the microphone to facilitate things here,
there is one question that has been submitted for the BVA panel
and I believe it is all right if I read that and proceed right
into the question.
The question is:
'"Under the provisions of
Emergency Interim Issue, EM 21-58,
dated June 17, 1960,
the
prohibition against withdrawing cases from appellate channels
has been deleted.
If a case has been certified to Centeal
Office on an
appeal,
and the accredited representative of the
claimant requests that the case be withdrawn from appellate
channels and referred to the Compensation and Pension Service
under the provisions of VAR 1142, will this request be honored?
If not, an explanation would be appreciated."
VA Regulation 1142, of course,
is now VA Regulation 1321 Larry Pierce,
our Vice Chairman,
just came in.
With respect to
VA Regulation 1321 or the old 1142, it is important first in
answering the question to understand just what that regulation is.
It contemplates a request for favorable action at the regional
office
rating
board
level
and
it
provides
a means
for
the
rating
board to request approval by the Compensation and Pension Service
of an action which the rating wants to.take but does not have the
authority to do so.
If the case that is cited in the question is
a pension case, I would have to assume that the rating board has
determined that unemployability is not shown and has declined to
recommend favorable action under Regulation 1321.
That being so,
then the certification of the appeal to the Board places squarely
in issue before the Board both the matter of whether schedule requirements are met and the matter of whether unemployability is
shown.
The Board is very clearly empowered to exercise any extraschedular authority that is involved in deciding either or both
of these issues and is thoroughly empowered,
clearly empowered,
to grant a pension on unemplowability irrespective of schedular
requirements.
This comes out of a regulatory change at the time
of this emergency interim issue that is mentioned.
Under those
circumstances
it seems to me that a review by the Compensation
and Pension Service at that point would be an administrative review rather than review of a 1321 recommendation.
I feel sure
that the Compensation and Pension Service doesn't
want to set
up an intermediate review of factual determinations.
In fact,
this would be contrary to the concept of administrative reviews.
So if the question supposes a reference purely for a factual
adjudication,
broadly speaking the answer would be no.
Now,
individual requests would have to be determined by a number of
things.
Is there a policy problem involved?
How urgent is the
need for its
resolution?
The number and purpose of such requests, and things of that nature.
If it approached a routine intermediate appellate review,
then something would have to give.
I hope that is direct enough
on the target of the question,
and that is the only question that
you
seem
to
have
CHAIRMAN
for
me.
KNIGHT:
If
there
any
discussion
Are
there
any
questions
of
that
question?
from
the
floor?
MR. HERMAN
Appeals Board on
WENIGE (Indiana):
We had an appeal before
a questionable sale of property by a widow
veteran.
were
As
you
a
member
165
of
that
appeals
board,
you
the
of a
may
remember the
is the story
The
husband
case, Jim
in brief.
Veterans
jointly
Mrs.
X
of
Jeffersonville,
Administration
owned
the
conceded
property,
both
as
Indiana.
that
both
to
the
she
Here
and
purchase
her
and
improvements.
The husband died in 1949,
Shortly after his
death the widow was offered $16,000 for the property and she refused to sell.
From 1949 to 1959
she repeatedly refused to sell
the property.
However,
in August,
1959,
the Federal Government
in conjunction with the State of Indiana surveyed for a new highway and that survey went through Mrs. X's property.
She still
refused
to
sell
the
property.
She
was
told
that
she
would
have
to sell or condemnation proceedings would be instituted.
That
would have meant considerable expense to the widow.
She would
have had to have legal counsel and she
couldn't afford it. She
had been offered $16,000 on several occasions.
The government
paid her $15,240,
which was $780 less than she had been offered
ten years ago.
She failed to report that transaction until
January 1, 1960.
The Veterans Administration then contended
she had not timely reported the sale and took her pension off,
retroactive to January,
1959.
Now, she used this money that
she received from the government to purchase a new home.
Our
contention was that this woman did not actually sell that property.
She had no idea of selling it.
As long as she hadn't
sold it it was not considered income and she refused repeatedly
to
sell
it.
The
government
stepped
in
and
told
her,
"We
have
to have this property.
You have to take this money."
We
appealed that case to the Appeals Board and the Appeals Board
upheld VARO at Indianapolis
in that she had not
timely reported
the sale,
‘I can't see any justification for that kind of a
decision.
This widow had no intention of selling that property.
the Federal Government and the State of Indiana compelled her
to turn that property over at an arbitrary figure.
She paid
more for the new home than
the government gave her.
It is
my
contention that that decision was wrong.
MR. STANCIL:
You certainly make out a good case for the
lady. One of the last things that I like to do is to say only
that I will be glad to look into it, -- and not answer as
directly as I can your questions.
Of course you pose a great
many technical questions which would require study, before I
could give you an answer that would mean anything.
We have
joint property.
We have his death and how much of the property
passes
to
her.
We
have
relative
values
as
between
one
point
in time and another point in time, which are determined by the
best appraisals that the VA can get, and all
sorts of things,
so I think that I am going to fall back on asking you to give
me the lady's name.
I don't believe I participated in that
decision personally because I haven't been signing decisions
for some three years now, but if you would give me the lady's
name and allow me to look at that decision, we will see if we
can do something different
for her.
CHAIRMAN
to
ask
a
KNIGHT:
Any
other
questions?
The
Director
wants
question.
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman,
I recognize that we are
approaching the end of this panel, but if I may have Dr.
Mandell's indulgence,
the next speaker,
I would like to ask Jim
Stancil to comment on something if possible.
Jim has outlined
for
you
of
Veterans
some
the
changes
Appeals.
of
Some
that
of
have
these
166
taken
place
changes
are
the
Board
physical.
in
Some
of these
upon the
changes are operational.
very mission of the Board
Some of
itself,
them seem to bear
This is a most
important subject
one of which,
and
is the continuing
usually,
but some
to The American Legion for a number of reasons,
this is the one I would like to talk about now,
proposal to establish some judicial review,
review of decisions of the Administrator of
Veterans
As
Affairs.
you
know,
the
decision
of
the
Administrator
in most cases is final and the Board of Veterans Appeals acts
for the Administrator
in most cases.
Therefore,
in effect in
most cases it is the decision of the Board of Veterans Appeals
which is final.
There
are some who feel that this is not right,
that there would be improved service and advantage to the veteran
if there were provided some judicial review of the decisions of
the
Board
Up
proposal
be
a very
of
to
to
Veterans
Appeals
and
the
Administrator.
this time The American Legion has
provide judicial review.
We have
difficult
and
delicate
question,
but
not supported
recognized it
we
feel
the
to
that
in
balancing the interests,
the interests of the veterans are best
serviced by continuing the authority that the Administrator has
at present. However,
we do feel that there is some room for
improvement
and
therefore
one
of
the
recommendations
that
we
have made officially was that the Board be withdrawn from the
policy-making process of the Veterans Administration.
Now, Jim,
I am finally approaching the point that I would like you to comment
on.
As 1 understand at present,
the Board is bound by the regulations promulgated by the Veterans Administration.
Is that
correct,
first of all?
MR.
STANCIL:
That
is
right.
MR. CORCORAN:
Jim says that this is correct.
He means
that if we approach the Board alleging that a case was denied
in accordance with a regulation, but our major claim is that
the regulation is inconsistent with the law, I do not think
that the Board could
accept our statement since the regulation
has been promulgated and the Board would have to say "We are
bound by this regulation.'
If the premises that I have laid out
so far, Jim,
are essentially correct, my question is; Would it
be possible to free the Board from this binding situation where
they must accept a regulation?
Would it be possible,
that is to
say, that the Board could find a regulation to be inconsistent
with
the
law
and
therefore
not
deserving
of
effect of the law? If this would be possible
necessary to secure legislation to make this
thirdly and lastly, would you be prepared to
opinion on such a change?
the
full
force
and
would it be
possible,
and
give your personal
MR. STANCIL:
This is a very interesting area where you
can generate a lot of arguments,
but first, John,
I would like
to add a word to your thought about our being bound by the regulations on any case that comes before us.
This is true, but
with the Board being removed from the formulation of policy,
the directive which I received from the Administrator made it
clear that this does not relieve me of the responsibility,
nor
does it take away my privilege,
of bringing to the administrator's
attention at any time some matter which arises in the course of
appellate review of the claims leading us to believe that some
enunciated policy should be re-evaluated.
is
in
Therefore,
effect the
while
Board
in a
must
given case as
tell you that
167
long as the regulation
we are bound by this
regulation,
you have to consider with it our responsibility for
attempting to change this regulation if we do not believe in it.
A recent illustration, without going into detail,
is a question
arose in a case, several cases,
in fact, over an instruction
issued over the Administrator's signature with respect to incompetent
in
be
non-service
connected
veterans
who
are
hospitalized
state institutions and the VA is paying, what otherwise
payable as pension, but for the size of his estate,
for
care
and
maintenance.
There
is
a cut-off
point.
I think
would
his
$2500.
was specified where we would stop paying and not pay for maintenance until the other sources gets down to a certain point.
The whole argument on the appeal was that the instruction that
was issued was inconsistent with the law and
exceeded our
regulatory authority under that law.
As we say our
responsibility in that case did not begin
and end with just stating - '""We are bound by the instruction of
the Administrator and this states so and so and therefore you
are in the wrong court," but rather we had to consider the basic
question and our choices of action were to either affirm the
instruction or to take steps to try to change it.
That is a little Dit in the direction you want to go, but
beyond that new to approach your other question, whether the
Board can be freed from the regulations and the instructions,
yes, this could be done.
It would take a change of law because
the law very specifically reads that the Board in its decisions
shall be bound by the instructions of the Administrator,
VA
regulations,
and precedent opinions of the chief law officer,
which means these published AD's that I referred to a minute
ago.
It is a general rule of law where a court or some independent appellate review authority is considering actions by
an agency of the executive branch of the government empowered
to issue regulations that in general you follow and apply these
regulations unless you determine they are inconsistent with the
law.
Inconsistency with the law is the test.
Conceivably -- I am thinking off the top of my head now -this can be done with the Board located just as it
is now.
However, another bill has been introduced this year in addition to
the bill for a court of Veterans Appeals and that bill would
give the Board of Veterans Appeals a measure of independence,
located in the VA for administrative purposes, but otherwise
more independent than it is now.
This bill specifically repeals
the section of the law that binds the Board by regulations,
and
instructions,
and so on.
Of course,
this is a bill that has
just been dropped in the hopper,
the VA has not been asked as yet
for its report and as far as I know it has been evaluated and
discussed by no one seriously or at any length,
so I won't be
prepared to discuss the merits of that at this particular point
beyond just informing you that it is in the hopper and that would
be the effect of it.
MR.
CORCORAN:
CHAIRMAN
MR. WEISS
allowed appeals
KNIGHT:
That
is
Any
fine.
Thank
you,
other
question
now?
What
the
(PENNSYLVANIA):
in 19607?
168
was
Jim.
percentage
of
MR.
STANCIL:
12-1/2
per
cent.
Incidentally,
just
to
take one more moment,
I may be repeating things that I have
said before but,
as you know, appeals are filed in the field
office.
The cases get a second look before they are certified
to the Board.
Statistics
show that approximately ten to eleven
percent of all appeals filed -- as a result of your presentation,
and study,
and identification of other evidence or one thing
and
another
--
on
this
second
look
are
without
the case ever reaching us, so
year was 12-1/2 per cent of those that
remand rate was in the neighborhood of
over fen per cent,
going
MR, WEISS:
Is the traveling
to continue this year?
Board
paid
at
the
local
level
the allowance rate last
did reach us and the
10 per cent,
a little
of
Veterans
Appeals
MR, STANCIL:
Yes, sir.
Our present plans and budgeting
are for one trip each quarter of approximately three weeks duration except for a long trip
such as the West Coast, which would
take four weeks,
and we cover as many offices as we can, up to
a week in the larger offices and two, three, or four days
in
some of the smaller ones.
We plan to keep it up, yes, sir.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
KNIGHT:
STANCIL:
Any
Thank
CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
pleasure to present Dr.
Staff.
other
you
questions?
very
much.
Thank you, gentlemen.
E. Mandell, VA Policy
It
and
is now my
Evaluation
DR. MANDELL:
Good afternoon,
ladies and gentlemen.
I
feel honored in being called before you and
having this opportunity to address you, primarily because the job that I am doing
or my group is responsible for in a sense is exactly the same
as your job, to try to determine what is good for the Veterans
and
what
is
good
for
the
Nation.
In this sense, we are working together.
I would like to
take a moment to allay any apprehension because there is some
rumor about that the group that I represent serve as egg-heads
to the Veterans Administration.
The idea of being an egg-head,
a thinker,
is occasionally frowned upon as something that is to
be looked upon with a certain amount of suspicion. As a matter
of fact,
I recognize in this audience a number of Hoosiers from
which state I just but recently have come and among Hoosiers
they look upon
anybody who has a great deal of academic authority
behind him as somebody to look upon with suspicion.
They assume
that all a man needs is good, common horse sense.
I would like
to remind you, therefore,
that I am a humble country boy.
I was
born on a farm.
Perhaps I should tell you first a word or two
about what the policy and evaluation staff is intended to do
because those who are engaged in the Veterams Administration
with the operation of its daily chores and the programs and
activities that are. the responsibilities of the Veterans Adminis-
tration
and
are
so
consumed
with
the
daily
thought that perhaps they did not have
about the problems that lie ahead.
time
operation
to
sit
it was
back
and
think
| As an illustration of what happens when you don't take time
to sit and determine what to do with problems,
you are
all aware
that all of us recognized during the World War II that the
169
Veterans Administration was going to be saddled with a tremendous
task,
General Hines was aware of this as was everybody that worke
for the Veterans Administration.
But the day to day operation
and the exigencies of war were so great that no one took the
time to actually plan how we were going to attack this tremendous
task which, it was recognized, was bound to come before the
Veterans Administration as soon as the war closed.
And so, many
of you remember,
the Veterans Administration attacked this problem as best they could, but there was a tremendous amount of
chaos and confusion.
In the hope that we will be able to recognize and do something about the problems of the future the
Policy and Evaluation Staff was set up to be able to take the
time to look into what will be the problems of the Veterans
in the future, what will be the problems of the Veterans Administration in the future,
and what are the best policies and programs to prepare for these problems.
Perhaps you would like to know some of the things that we
have done in the past.
As an illustration of our approach to
this problem,
I would like to call your attention to a monograph
that was prepared by the Economist of the Policy Evaluation
Staff, Dr. Robert Martin.
This is called The Aging American
Veterans and The National Economy."
Some of you have copies of
this
monograph.
Tomorrow
I will
send
over
sufficient
copies
so that each of you can have it.
But I think there is in this
a great deal to be learned about the problems that the future
may present.
Right now there exists in our society about 14
million males 65
years and older.
Of those 14 million,
50 per
cent right now are veterans.
Within the next 30 years twothirds of every male 65
years and older will be veterans.
This
fact alone poses a tremendous problem for the Veterans Adminis=
tration because in our studies of the problems of the aging
veteran a number of things have become crystal clear.
First,
that as a man ages his need for medical care increases.
The
length of time that he is going to have to spend
with each eipsode of hospitalization is going to increase,
so
that the patient load in a sense of the Veterans Administration
will tend to increase.
This is most true because also as a
man reaches 65
years and older his economic status in the
economy tends to decrease.
His income is less.
This will
also
pose a problem both because he will not be able to support his
medical needs and because he may not even be able to support his
general needs, so his pension needs may increase.
It is essential that the VA begin to study what the future may hold in store
as problems.
This is one area of problems.
This pamphlet
‘is
but the ground work to indicate how great that problem may be.
One of the other problems that we soon recognized was the problem
of the aging veteran in general and in this area
we recognized
that the aging veteran,
unlike our younger veterans,
(although
this
is
outside
also
of
true
our
of
our
younger
veterans),
often
needs
care
hospitals.
One of the things I think you will soon recognize,
as we
did, is that whether it is nursing care, whether it is a
sheltered home or a domiciliary care, or whether the hospital
care,
the problems are real, but these can be confused and we
can errode away our benefits if we do not approach them as
realities and entities in themselves,
I think you would be the
first to agree that we have probably the best hospital system
in the country in which our veterans get care second to none.
If that hospital is soon saddled with only chronic: cases,
cases
170
needing
the
primary
acutely
I
only
value
have
of
nursing
the
function
ill.
of
This
mentioned
home
care,
hospital,
the
is
are
we
because
hospital,
not
not
to
say
problems,
will
errode
and
we
will
have
that
the
other
which
but
is
to
we do
rust away
destroyed
the
elements
that
care
not
for
solve
the
those
problems simply by finding an easy method of solution.
We should
attempt to solve each problem by attacking it forthrightly and
directly.
We have therefore reviewed our present domiciliary
program.
This is a print of our domiciliary study- the first
copy has come off the press.
I hope in a short time there will
be enough copies so that each of you can have a copy.
We have
attempted,
in trying to determine whether what we are doing
for our veterans in our home is correct,
to try to get a profile
of
the
type
of
veteran
we
have
in
our
home.
We have studied 1,022 veterans.
They are scattered in a
majority of our domiciliary facilities -- in
large communities
like Los Angeles,
in small communities like Clinton,
Iowa, and
in those in between.
This gave us a cross-section of about 12
per cent of our total domiciliary load.
Included in this volume
is all of the background material from which we drew our conclusions,
so that if in
reading this you find that our conclusions are in error,
at least any student of the subject can
go back to the basic material,
the case histories,
the interviews,
and all
other things upon which the conclusions were
based,
and draw their own conclusions.
This we feel is a basic
document.
There are some rather significant things that have
come out of this study,
some things that I think may surprise
you.
We have been able to find that in many of our domiciliaries
veterans who have been there for five and six years and more,
sleeping in rooms that are barrack-like in which there are beds
next to beds, when asked the name of the Veteran sleeping in the
bed on either side of him says,
"I don't know.'"
"Where does he
come .from?"
"I don't know.!'. "Who is he?!’
"I. do not know."
This would indicate
that in some way we have failed to
make these men feel that they are part of our community,
part of
the life that they should be responsible for, because it is important that we integrate them in our society.
This is true
because of the type of facility we operate.
(Not that
they are
not operated well), but because they are probably too big.
We
have taken people out of the communities in which they have their
relatives and their friends and have moved them into a sheltered
existence in a strange area.
Thus they have built around themselves a barrier for their own protection.
Not only did we find that they did not know the names of
those who slept next to them, but our study group from the Policy
and Evaluation Staff who went up to Bath, New York, found other
strange and significant
things. At least a half hour before meal
time -- and in Bath, New
York, because of the number of members
and
the
limited
facilities
for
feeding,
they
have
to
have
two
servings -- the members line up waiting for meals.
They go
through the cafeteria line getting meals which are well prepared,
nutritious,
and there are no complaints about the meals.
They
sit at the tables in utter silence, never talking to their
neighbors on their right or their left.
My group who went to
Bath, New York said it was rather strange.
There was no noise
except the occasional clutter of tableware on dishes.
They
finished the meal and walked out without any communication between
each other.
We
can
cite
such
other
instances
171
that
make
us
feel,although
we have tried to do as humane and as proper a job as we could,
that our present domiciliary facilities do not answer the needs
of those veterans who need some kind of a home.
In order to
determine what a better kind of system might cost, we have also
set about to determine what the cost would be to bring our
domiciliaries up to what we would consider satisfactory,
modern
standards,
The cost runs somewhere around approximately $180
million.
It is not that we mean to spend this $180 million to
do this remodernization of our present facilities,
because we
feel that a much better type of facility and much better service
can be rendered to the veteran by building smaller facilities
closer to their homes and cities of residence in which every
attempt,
every modern device will be used to bring this man back
to activity in his own
community.
Whether that activity is
simply to go out into a foster home,
go out into a nursing home,
or go
out into a sheltered workshop,
at least he will not be
divorced
from
the
life
and
the
society
in which
he
was
brought
up.
If this new concept does not cost any more than the remodeling of the old concept, we certainly feel that this is
preferable.
This is one of the other things that the Policy and
Evaluation Staff is
attempting to find out.
There are problems
in
there
the
future
has
been
that
we
some
talk
want
answers
about
a
for.
You
all
know
government-supported
that
and
sponsored insurance program for the medical care of the aged
under socidl security.
We would like to do a study in the next
year or so to determine what such an Act would do to the Veterans
Administration.
We have a great many opinions, but we need facts
to determine whether a veteran who is eligible under social
security to go to any hospital of his choice would be willing or
would care to go to a veterans hospital.
If we should find that
the majority want to go to other hospitals,
we would have to
recognize that this would have a tremendous impact on our futuré
program, but until we have the facts and until we know what the
impact of this new kind of legislation would have on the Veterans
Administration,
there is no way to plan.
There are many other
areas of study that I think you would agree need intensive investigation.
We are gathering the facts upon which to determine
what
is
the
proper
answer.
In
a
democracy
such
as
ours,
the
answers must be developed by all people -- you and us -- who have
some interest in the problem based on knowledge of the facts.
The answers have to come because we working together,
us, you and
others, knowing what the facts are and what the future holds,
must determine what is the best program for the VA to follow in
the future;
best for the
veteran,
and best for the nation.
Thank
you.
CHAIRMAN
KNIGHT:
Any
questions
from
the
Conference?
MR. KOLENDA (NEW MEXICO):
I would like to ask Dr. Mandell
one question.
Actually I have two questions.
As you know,
there
is some criticism about the domiciliary missions of veterans.
If
you study only those veterans,
how are you sure that your conclusions will be adequate?
DR. MANDELL:
You are correct.
We have only tried to get an
idea of what we have now in our domiciliary program.
This is not
to say what we should have in the program.
As I told you, we
feel that actually the program that we are operating is not an
adequate program.
We should,
therefore,
change our whole concept
of the need of the veteran for this type of after-hospital care.
We
have
been
calling
this
172
type
of
care
rehabilitation
and
and what we are
restoration,
this will take some 10 to 15
and phase out the old,
is to
centers
across
the
country
and
hoping to do in the future,
years to build in the new program
build restoration and rehabilitation
close
to
our
present
hospitals
where
those veterans who are finished with hospital care, but not yet
ready for either economic,
social,
or physical reasons to go out
into the community,
will be brought into condition where they
can go out into the community.
These restorations centers will
help these veterans who need some kind of help to be able to get
back into their community,
and when I said back into the community
originally,
you may remember,
I said not necessarily back to his
own home.
It may be to a foster home,
it may be to a boarding
home, it may be to a nursing home, but at least back as close
to his original environment
as we can get him.
This would mean
our whole administrative policy in these new centers would be
based on different criteria entirely.
It would be for those
veterans who need some kind of rehabilitation and restoration,
to bring them back into the community in which they belong.
MR. KOLENDA:
Thank you, Dr. Mandell.
The other question
I would like to ask is, are you accessible for suggestions and
what is the procedure for making these suggestions?
DR. MANDELL:
We certainly are accessible to suggestions.
The way we have been getting our suggestions up until now, is
trying to go out into the field and meeting what we call the
rank and file,
the grass roots.
We would hope that we would
get suggestions from every possible place in the country,
from
every hospital in the country, from every individual in the
country.
We have no monopoly on all of the best ideas.
We are
looking for ideas.
We need suggestions.
Now, when you speak of
the method,
I suppose any one can forward any kind of suggestion
to the Chairman of the Policy and Evaluation Staff, VA, Central
Office, Washington, D.C,
MR. SLONEKER (CALIFORNIA):
Doctor,
I believe you touched
on your group also making a study of medical care for the aged.
You mentioned present legislation and proposed or pending legislation.
Apparently your group is making some study of this and
my question is, I wonder if you have given any consideration to
the possibility that the answer to the solution would be on
the
same basis as medical and hospital aid for Federal civil service
employees, whether something like that might take care
of the
aged?
You
DR. MANDELL:
Let me
mean that an insurance
MR.
SLONEKER:
see if I understand your question.
program be established for the aged?
- Yes.
DR. MANDELL:
As you know,
the social security program,
at
least as the President defines it, is called an insurance program.
It does not cover everybody,
only those who are covered by social
security.
There has been proposed that those not covered by
social security should be covered by some other method of insurance.
While we are interested in these particular areas of investigation,
they are not particularly pertinent to the veterans of America.
Our problems primarily,
I have to admit,
are the veterans of
America.
Now,
there has been a proposal,
and we attempted to study
this proposal to see whather there was a possibility of developing
an insurance program for the veterans of America entitling every
veteran to care in a Veterans Administration hospital.
This shows
173
you how far afield we get.
it was impractical,
but it
CHAIRMAN
DR.
KNIGHT:
MANDELL:
This proposal
didn't mean we
Any
Thank
other
you
we had
didn't
questions?
very
I
to drop because
investigate it.
guess
not.
much.
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Ladies and gentlemen of the Conférence,
we continue with the section of this Conference which is likewise
akin to the theme of the Conference, "Aging with Dignity."
We
have with us this afternoon several speakers who by virtue of their
background and experience,
are well qualified to address themselves
to this subject.
I shall leave it to the next gentleman that I
will present to you to introduce the speakers whose names appear
upon your program, but, first,
I have the privilege of presenting
to
you his
predecessor
in
office,the
former
Director
of
the
Special
Staff on Aging of the Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare.
He was here and addressed this Conference last year and I am sure
that most of you will recall that, and that many of you are personally acquainted with him.
In his position as the Director of
the Special Staff he had the responsibility for the conduct of the
White House Conference on Aging.
It is my pleasure now to present
to you, Mr. Robert H. Grant,
-Mr. Grant.
REMARKS BY ROBERT H. GRANT, FORMER DIRECTOR, SPECIAL
STAFF ON AGING, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCATION, AND
WELFARE
MR. GRANT;
Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
ladies and gentlemen.
I would say that I like to be introduced as the former Director
of the White House
Conference.
I would like to give you a
little history.
About two years ago, Congressman Fogarty, Democrat from the State of Rhose Island, having surveyed the field
of aging, having talked to many of his colleagues in both the
House and the Senate,
introduced a bill to set up a White House
Conference on Aging.
Why?
Because Mr. Fogarty and his associates felt that there prevailed in this country some significant
problems relative to our aging population,
and those problems
fell in categories such as housing, medical care,
income maintenance, free time activities,
religion,
and so forth.
In setting up the White House Conference,
the House and
the Senate appropriated for administrative purposes something
over $500,000
to take care of the administrative details of the
Conference.
In addition,
they made available to the Department
of Health, Education and Welfare approximately a million dollars
to be given to the states in the form of non-matching grants
so that each of the states and territories could survey their
problems in the identical fields of aging and to give their
surveys to the White House Conference, which was to take place
in the future. The Department,
as one of its initial acts, created
an advisory committee made up of well-known authoritative individuals
in the field of aging.
This group consisted of approximately 150
people.
The advisory committee was chaired by former
Congressman Robert Kean of New Jersey,
a Republican.
Initially,
the first responsibility of this advisory committee was to make
a determination as to what should be done in order to start the
Conference in its proper perspective.
It was decided to divide
the advisory committee into 20 subcommittees,
each of these subcommittees having a special responsibility in a field of aging,
that is, housing, medical care,
income maintenance,
and so forth
and so on.
174
Over a period of some months,
these committees turned
out what we call background papers.
These were documents which
were available to the states and pointed up‘facts,
figures,
and data relative to the particular subject matter.
While this
was going on, we initiated the grant mechanism to the 50-o0dd
states and territories.
Most of the states accepted a grant
of from 10,000 to 15,000
in order to make a survey of their
own problems in aging,
and as a result of this grant,
they
carried out at the grass roots level -- in the villages,
in the
towns,
in the big cities -- they found that there were a number
of problems dealing with our so-called "aging population."
turn
We
over
requested
to
us
the
a report
states
of
as
their
a
result
findings.
of
this
Prior
survey
to
the
to
White
House Conference we had received a detailed report from each
of the states in regard to this most significant problem,
and
as a result of these reports, we turned out a document called
"Aging in the States,’ which is a compilation of the facts
relative to this problem in each of the 50
states and territories.
At the White House
Conference, we had 2800 delegates from all
over our nation and in addition to this, we had close to 400
to 500
guests, newspaper people,
and interested individuals.
This is a familiar area.
Our headquarters for the White
House Conference was in this hotel.
Our registration facilities
were in the same areas that you now occupy.
How did we select
the delegates?
The Federal Government did not select the delegates.We gave a quota to each state based on a formula that
could be compared roughly to Congressional representation.
The
State of New York, for instance,
had 100 delegates;
Alaska,
ten; Puerto Rico,
ten, and so forth and so on.
It was the responsibility of the state,
the responsibility of the Governor,
to séiect the delegates.
Once selected,
the delegates had the
problem of determining to which of the 20 areas they preferred
assignment.
After some study and analysis and after initial
reports from the states, we found that we could combine the
20 subcommittees into roughly ten groups.
We notified the
states to this effect,
and asked them to assign their delegates
to the sections of their choice,based on the state assignment
each delegate was sent to the section of his or her choice.
This was not done by the Federal Government.
We had 20 sections,
ten working groups,
and 140 different working areas.
=
As you
Conference.
a great
deal
may have heard, we had a controversial White House
It was controversial to this extent:
that there is
of
public
interest
in
the
field
of medical
care
and how it should be paid for.
We did not receive a state report that did not in some way cover this subject. There is a view
point that is expressed by the American Federation of Labor.
There
is a viewpoint that is expressed by the American Medical Association.
There is a viewpoint that is expressed by individuals
who had no particular ties. The voting at the Conference took
place at the section level.
As a result of this Conference, we
have turned out 20 specific statements of policy and a set of
recommendations.
Each
of
the
upon
were
in
attendance
by
those
who
20
statements
at
the
of policy
were
voted
Conference.
In addition,
it is
proposed that a formal document will be
turned out by the White House Conférence Staff as a report to
the President.
The deadline on this report, as I understand,
is
April 9.
Now, I think that The American Legion, both as Legionnaires and as citizens,
have a responsibility in regard to the
$73
field
of
ference
at
the
aging.
as
an
We
Conference
Conference.
can
excellent
It
so
characterize
Conference,
much
doesn't
as
it
make
any
is
our
but
White
it
what
is
House
not
happens
difference
what
Con-
what
after
happens
the
the
viewpoint
of the American Federation of Labor is or. the American Medical
Association.
The difference that prevails is what is your viewpoint as citizens of this country in view of the
legislation
which is proposed.
Now, with these remarks,
I will stop here,
except to give you one other fact.
I just give you this backs
ground in relation to the introduction of my colleague.
I have
been an employee of the National Institutes of Health for about
12 years.
I was asked to assume the position of Director of
"the
White
stitutes
House
of
Conference
on
a detail
from
the
National
In-
Health.
Having gone through some 14 months of a rather rough
obstacle course,
I have elected to return to the campus of
National Institutes
good friend of mine
the
of Health and put the finger on a very
who is now sitting to my left to pick up
the cudgels,
and to assume the responsibility with his colleagues
for turning out the report. This has been an interesting, worthwhile experience.
Having worked in the field of aging related
to the White House Conference for 14 months, one does not cast
off the very real problem in regard to our older population.
We have reached one conclusion,
and when I started on the White
House Conference,
the definition of aging was anyone who is
ten years older than yourself.
Having
been through the White House Conference, we have been told that
there is another definition and that is that a women is old
when a man thinks she is charmless,
and a man is old when a
woman
thinks
he
is
harmless.
Thank
you.
I want to introduce
Executive Director of the
to you Mr. Warren Roudebush,who is the
Federal Council on Aging,
and who is
now
Special
Acting
Director
REMARKS
SPECIAL
of
the
Staff
on Aging.
Mr.
Roudebush.
OF WARREN ROUDEBUSH, ACTING DIRECTOR,
STAFF ON AGING, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH,
EDUCATION, AND WELFARE
MR. ROUDEBUSH:
Thank you, Bob, and thank you for the
opportunity to be here.
Last night, I read the statement filed
by Director Corcoran with the Senate Special Committee on Aging
outlining the activities of the Rehabilitation Commission.
It
is one of the most impressive demonstrations of concern and
effort
by
a national
organization
that
I know.
In
the
outline,
he refers to tbe interests of many Posts in encouraging adult
education,
to the support and cooperation of vocational and
rehabilitation programs,
the interest in special counselling
and placement programs for older workers,
the participation of
the Departments
and Posts in promoting educational efforts to
offset unfair age-discrimination attitudes,
the great contribution of volunteer services,
and the variety of activities
producing recreational and leisure time opportunities.
I refer to these activities in order to set the
perspective in which I think the White House Conference on Aging
should be viewed.
The Conference did not start your programs.
Most,
if not all, of your activity in this field grew out of
your concern with the needs to be met before the Conference
was even thought of, and even had the Conference never taken
place,
and
I
trust
your
efforts
would
effectiveness.
176
continue
to
grow
in
scope
Now, then, does the fact that there was a Conference fit
into this perspective? What was its purpose,
and how do we move
ahead?
I would say that the White House Conference on Aging
had a bhreefold purpose.
In part, it was to bring together
and pool the experience,
the understanding,
the sense of needs,
and
the
judgments
of
citizens
from
all
over
the
nation,
rep-
resenting the whole rangeof our society,
and then in part,
the Conference was to spread awareness and further stimulate
general public interest in opportunities and challenges inherent
in this situation that has developed so rapidly in our time, and,
thirdly,
the Conference
produced blueprints,
road-maps,
if you
will, for moving ahead more systematically, more comprehensively,
and with better coordination of all the resources of our society.
For
a
year,
true
some
those
of
us working
four
significance,
days
the
in
on
the
January
Conference
Conference
seemed
was
not
a
planning
climax.
But
a climax,
but
for
over
in
its
a begin-
ning.
The challenge is to see if those blueprints or road maps
can serve to move us all ahead, faster and more effectively,
to the objectives which you and other groups, public and private,
have already been moving toward.
This product of the Conference
has been analyzed to fall into
four basic areas; first,
the older
person's economic situation;
second, his health and medical problems;
third, his pattern of living; fourth the mobilization of
resources, public and private,
to improve these three preceding
situations.
As Mr. Grant said,
there were 20 sections at the White
House Conference.
The section on rehabilitation has made recommendations
that crop up in all four of these basic areas.
There are 53
specific recommendations.
I hope you know something of them already,
and it is not my purpose to go through
them here.
But I most sincerely hope that you will take time
to read and reflect on them carefully.
I am sorry only a limited
number of copies of them have been
in circulation up to this time.
They will
be in the official report to be published next month
and they will also appear in a separate Conference publication
devoted solely to the subject of rehabilitation.
White
How
House
you
take
advantage
Conference
of
on Aging
termine.
I wish to report
in the Federal Government.
to
this
fact
that
briefly
what
is,
you
of
course,
there
was
for
you
we
are
a
to de-
doing
In the Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare,
Secretary Ribicoff has the responsibility for a large portion
of the Federal program and resources devoted to older people,
and in addition to this, Secretary Ribicoff serves as Chairman
of the Federal Council on Aging,
a cabinet level committee that
includes
the
Departments
of
Agriculture,
Commerce,
Labor
and
Treasury,
and the Veterans Administration and the Housing and
Home Finance Agency.
Secretary Ribicoff has asked Assistant
Secretary James Quigley to give daily personal attention to the
matters in these fields,
to give them maximum support.
The
first job both in the department and in the Federal Council in
moving ahead with action on the WH Conférence recommendations.
Yesterday,
I sat with him and the heads of the six operating
agencies of Health, Education,
and Welfare while we reviewed
where
we
stood.
Systematically,
we
are
identifying
the
re-
commendations calling for Federal action.
These we classify
according:cto whether we can move under existing authority and
with available resources.
Some of those require legislative
T77
authorization and are already in bills before Congress,
such
as Senate bill 4222,
the Health Insurance Benefits Act.
There
are in the Conference report hundreds of recommendations.
Only
a portion of them are directed to Federal action,
and of these
some may be analyzed as not feasible or not desirable at this
time, but we are trying to make sure that every one is considered,
that decision is made on them, and that we move accordingly.
I hope this pattern of action may have some significance
for you
as you return to your Departments and Posts,
and for
those who feel they would like to. devote a little more study to
the situation of older people, please permit me to make a small
commercial,
I refer to the same book that Mr. Grant carried
with him and didn't quote, the chart book that the Federal
Council on Aging published for the Conference.
I can relate
it to the Veterans Administration,
for if we hadn't had Mr.
Whittier and his
Deputy,
Brad Morsey make Dr. Milton Forster
available to head up this project, we wouldn't have this
chart book today.
This is by way of giving recognition to a very fine public servant, Dr. Forster, who .is sitting right over there.
He
did a beautiful job with this chart book.
In it is presented
quickly and in simple fashion significant data on income, housing,
health, employment,
and retirement opportunities for older people,
so I conclude with an item from the chart book.
We had trouble,
of course,
in pinning down the age groups we were writing about,
so we came up with arbitrary definitions.
Middle age is 45
to
64; older people are 65
and over; and aging applies to both.
Then
we said in effect,
"For statistical purposes if I am past 45
and
relatively independent and self-directed I am in
the''aging category, but if I am substantially dependent for physical,
economic,
or other less tangible reasons,
then I am aged.’ The goal we all
share,
in rehabilitation and other fields,
is the well-being of
increasing numbers in the aging category and the reduction of
numbers in the dependent,
'"aged'" category.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
I am happy to learn that so far as
years are concerned,
at least I am still in the middle group.
These gentlemen very kindly consented to answer questions,
if
any of you have any which you would like to propound.
I understand that Mr. Roudebush took a little vacation in 1944 and 1945
to serve as a gunnery officer on a destroyer,
so I am sure we
would be glad to have you fire some questions at him.
Are there
any questions?
Does anyone have any comment that he would like
to make?
The question is whether the books will be available,
where can you get them, and how much will they cost.
MR. ROUDEBUSH:
Let me take advantage and refer to the
two things.
This is in print in limited supply.
Individual
copies are available if you will write to our department.
They
can be purchased in quantity,
something like $22 a hundred,
from
the
Government
Printing
Office.
The
other
document
that
I have here,
and I think I will wave
it just a little bit, is
the hard core product of the Conference,
the recommendations,
approximately 160 pages.
We put this together in a hurry and I
don't mind saying for the specific reason that a good many states
notified us their legislatures were in session and if they had
to wait until April 9, when the official report will be put out,
they would be severely handiciapped,
so that we got off just a
minimum number of an emergency publication and really I cannot
say that there is a supply of them available now, but on April
9 the official report will be available,
It will be sent to all
p
178
delegates.
It will be sent to the state commissions on aging,
a modest amount,
and it is my feeling that we must tie in as
closely as we can to the state commissions on aging working
through regional representatives of HEW and in your Departments
it
seems
to
me
want to make
as it may be
--
here
I
am
offering
advice
--
your own tie-in with the state
constituted in your state.
that
you
commission
would
on
aging
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Are there any other
comments?
If not, may
I take this opportunity
questions or
to express to
appearance
I
both
of
you
gentlemen
here
and
the
for
thanks
your
of
this
addresses
Conference
to
us.
for
your
understand
you
will stay with
us for a little time and it may be later there
will be some other questions.
At this time, we come to the next
part of the agenda in this section.
As most of you know,
the
National Convention at Miami directed that there be a committee
appointed,
a joint committee,
for the purpose of study of the
problem that we are discussing.
This joint committee consists
of representatives from this Rehabilitation Commission and from
our Economic Commission.
The gentlemen who constitute the
committee selected under that direction or resolution are here
on the platform and at this time it is
my pleasure to introduce
one of them who was, with the others,
a representative of our
organization at the White House Conference and who is a Vice
Chairman
of
our
Rehabilitation
Commission,
Milton
Applebaum.
MR, APPLEBAUM:
Thank you.
Mr, Chairman and conferees,
I was one of the three delegates invited to attend the White
House Conference which Mr. Roudebush mentioned.
The other
delegates, my colleagues,
were people well known to you.
Let
me introduce them at this time.
Clarence Bird, our Staff
Director on Economics,
and John Corcoran, Director of our Rehabilitation Commission.
I am sure you will be interested in
getting their
Conference as
immediate reactions
and impressions from
well as my own brief remarks that I have
the
re-
flected on at some length.
The semantics of these words 'aged
and aging" have given me as I have gotten into this picture,
and the preceding speaker indicated that he had a most serious
job
of
defining,
couragement
in
a sort
some
of
a feeling
of
futility
and
dis-
ways.
The other night,
and this is one of the benefits of
coming to these rehabilitation meetings,
a distinguished comrade
of mine, from Illinois and I hope he will forgive me if he is
in the audience,
if I just let his name be anonimous -- I would
be glad to identify him -- pointed out to me that in the winemaking process wine is considered young, wine that is aging, but
when it becomes ripe and fit and
reaches its proper purpose,
which is human consumption,
then it for the first time becomes
aged.
With that comparison,
I hope the human race will follow
and fulfill itself in that respect.
general field of rehabilitation, we
In this field, as in the
do not deal with the indi-
vidual who is provided for or can provide for himself.
He is
no problem to us.
But we do deal with the individual who for
some reason or another needs the help of his community,
whether
he is a veteran or non-veteran.
Therefore,
of the
people
older,
Burke
early
I was
quite
gratified
to know
that
the
Congress
United States had by resolution recognized the problem of
becoming older and the increased number of people becoming
and I was very honored to be named by National Commander
as one of the delegates and I came to the Conference the
part of January, right after my appointment and participated
179
with the other 2475
delegates.
I felt gratified that there
were so many prominent and able people interested in this problem, which in older days was not
a problem, but the life insurance companies tell us the longevity that you and
I can
have is so much more than what our fathers and grandfathers had.
Our three delegates participated in the various groups to each
one's
enlightenment.
I was
gratified
that
the
Conference
addressed itself to the general community problems that are
arising in this field and that there was no comparison,
invidious
or otherwise,
with religious groups or religious areas or sectional
groups or even veterans,
because we feel we have a hold on the
veterans' problems of longevity based on the great experience
we have had in working with one arm of the government,
the Veterans
Administration.
I have every assurance that when the official report comes out, it will give the general picture a great deal of
clarification as to the thinking that is going on among all of us,
and not only as to
the veterans' problems which have been
the
immediate concern of the conferees,
you people, myself,
that are
here today.
In many respects the Veterans Administration.
has carried
forward and for us, many of the recommendations
that are just
beginning to be expressed in a general way, and I preface that
because that is a preface to a point that I would like to impress
as being my own and I trust one that is shared by many of The
American Legion conferees here. The Legion has realized,
as we
have concerned ourselves for all these years with the veteran,
we would not be serving his cause if we urged that his specialized
interest should come first or should be combined in the general
picture.
Many of the things that we devote our attention to and
put concentration on are not part of the general public aid picture so we have never,
and speaking now on behalf of the Legion,
urged veterans'
views on this general picture,
the problems of
the aged and aging.
This is as definite as we would feel, with
‘the vigor we have had in the past and we have now, if there
was any attempt made to take away from the veteran any of the
things
for
of
or
based
our
benefits
that
on
problems
these
comrades.
we
have
fought
that
war
for
so
services
long
or
gives
sought
to so
many
I urge each of you, therefore,
to consider carefully this
proven experience of The American Legion that programs for the
older veteran and the general programs which should go forward
together are nevertheless somewhat mutually exclusive.
Now,
our National Executive Committee,
in May,
1960 I think,
appreciated that we should go forward,
and we can go forward for
ourselves as well as for the general public, as the Legion does
do, in creating the special committee of which I have had the
honor of heading since January 1961.
The committee's work as defined for us in the resolution,
is to study these problems of the aged and aging veterans and
report recommendations,
if any, to our commissions from which
we originate and to the the NEC itself,
and we hope we will
have at least a tentative series of recommendations in the Spring
meeting.
I would like to introduce to you the members of my
committee
know
is
who
are
There is
as Baldy.
here,
Clinton
up
here
on
the
platform.
J. Ross Foust of Pennsylvania,
whom
And our Chairman of the afternoon,
Knight
that is here with us
York, and James Doon
of Virginia.
And
this afternoon,
there
of New Hampshire.
So
180
then
from
you
who
probably
I am sure
our
committee
is Joe Holzka of New
with Economics and
Rehab together,
I hope we will produce some real good for the
organization,
and the conferees here.
We did hold a meeting
Monday,
and we surveyed veterans' problems in the field of
pension and compensation,
which are really big problems on
which we are going forward,
and in Rehab,
as you know,
the
full
commission
and
staff
is
going
forward
and
we
have
sur-
veyed the problems of medicine and hospitals with particular
attention to these things which the older veteran is concerned
about now, namely,
out-patient care and nursing homes and the
domiciliaries.
We want to go into a little farther this new
thing that John Corcoran mentioned at the Rehab Commission
meeting on Monday, namely,
the restoration center, which seems
to be a coming thing,
at least with reference to the older
veteran who has both an economic and medical problem.
We went
into
the
field
of
employment
and
the
question
of
hiring
the
older veteran and also the question of housing,
and we are
going to depend a great deal on our first-hand information and
contacts so far as the older veterans housing on the experience
that the Economics Commission has acquired,
and Clarence Bird,
of course, had a special meeting on that for his executive
session of the Commission.
As I stated at the beginning of this report,
aging is
a relative term.
Many of the best years a Legionnaire can give
to his Post sometimes comes after retiring from his regular job.
Not every Legionnaire can get to be a Department Commander
after retirement,
and yet it has been done and I know it has
been done in at least one Department.
No doubt, we all know
of Oliver Wendell, Holmes,
the jurist, not the poet, but his son
the jurist, who was left for dead on a Civil War battlefield,
but recovered and lived to sit in the Supreme Court of the
United States and write learned legal opinions to the age of
90, when he got around to the question of whether he should retire and he did.
I should conclude with one comparison or
little story.
Maybe it illustrates the problem that my colleagues
and I see in this problem of the aged and aging.
I have to go
back in this to the time when I was working for a government
agency,
the Naturalization Service.
We had occasion to interview great numbers of people in a
short period of time,
and we were scheduled for a visit to a
particular town.
We were given the courtroom of the courthouse.
We did go into business in the courthouse,
but there weren't
enough seats.
My chief told me to go out there -- and there
were 12 seats on the jury box which no one wanted to enter, without invitation -- so in my own diplomatic way I went up and said,
"There are only.12 more seats available,
but anybody over 50
who feels a little bit shaky can come up and occupy them."
And
I went back to my interviews and my chief did to his, and 30
minutes later he looked at me and said:
'You haven't solved
our problem.
No one has gone into that jury box.
I will show
you
how
to do
it."
He went up and said to that same crowd,
"We have 12 seats
available.
Any lady 39 or over who wants to come up and occupy
those seats may do so."
Maybe they were 30 minutes more tired,
but I prefer to think that he had a more diplomatic and cogent
way of solving a problem which existed 30 minutes later as it
did originally.
That's the way I think we are going to find
that our problem,
the problems of my committee,
may well have
to be solved, not in terms of aged and aging, but in other terms,
in other fields and explanations,
maybe different semantics;
I
181
don't know, but that's the way we are addressing ourselves to
It is not alone ours.
the problems that have been given to us.
It is a problem of our major committees and the problems of
everybody because aging may not even exist as a term by the
Thank
I hope it may well be so.
time we get through with it.
you.
do
you
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
Thank
have anything to add?
MR. BIRD:
Conference.
As
talk
at
great
I
you
very
much,
Thank you.
Mr. Chairman and
informed my Commission this
length
on
this
problem
of
the
Milt,
Clarence,
delegates to the
morning,
I could
aged,
but
first
I
wish to tell you of my observations in regard to the White
House Conference on Aging.
I attended the sessions which were
held at the Shoreham Hotel..The Chairman recognized me as representing The American Legion,
and all were very complimentary
of
the
medical
and
hospital
program
in
our
far
flung
Veterans
Administration hospital system.
It was realized by those present
that I could not participate in any deliberations regarding
attaching to the social security program hospitalization and
medical care, but I want to say at this time the Economic Commission probably was the first American Legion group to realize
the problem of the older Legionnaire and we implemented the
program of employing the older veteran.
We have a citationn program by which the various Departments of The American Legion
award citations to employers who have an outstanding record of
employing the older veteran.
Representation
country,
from
labor,
at
this
Conference
came
from management,
public
from
all
interest
over
the
groups,
and right down the line,
I wish to touch on one item discussed which The American Legion could support wholeheartedly,
and that was employing the older citizen (veteran) without discrimination as to age.
There were recommendations made about
supplementing the social security payments for those who wouldn't
take them until age 66 when they were available at age 65.
To
give those eligible,
for instance,
a two per cent increase if
they
waited
until
age
to
67,
age
66,
and
so
or
on.
four
per
cent
That
was
discussed
if
they
didn't
draw
at
great
length.
There were arguments on the other side to retire workers
earlier to make jobs for the younger group coming into the labor
market, but that would be against our American Legion position.
The group went into many details about not increasing social
security benefits.
Many present didn't want any increase in the
social security tax because where they worked,
the company had
its own retirement program,
and the more the employee put into
that program,
the better his retirement benefits were.
Another special item that was taken up was housing for the
elderly and I was very happy to have had a presentation made to
our Commission yesterday by a large construction firm which has
interested itself in building garden-type apartments or elevatortype apartments for elderly persons, with the idea in mind of
having a national organization like ours, The American Legion,
sponsoring such a thing.
A report of this will be made by our
Economic Commission.
Right now the Federal Government has in
the process of being built four different projects of 50
units
each, with variations of having a small infirmary,
supplying
nursing care. This is just a pilot program which the Congress
has directed be finished as quickly as possible to give it some
182
guidance
in
future
operations
of
building
homes
for
the
aged.
I have taken up enough of your time, but I think The
American Legion as an organization should seriously consider
the problem of the elderly veteran especially our World War
I veterans,
I think it will be good for the Legion to show
our older veterans and our older Legionnaires that we are deeply interested in their problems of not only employment,
but
their housing, medical care, and so on.
Thank you very much,
CHAIRMAN O'CONNELL:
At this time I would like to call
on our Rehabilitation Director, John Corcoran,
for additional
remarks on this subject.
John.
MR. CORCORAN:
Thank you, Emory.
As I passed Bob McCurdy
he said:
"You have
eight minutes.”
I can do it in five.
Let
me attempt to wrap up the discussions and the observations
that
we have had during this panel and at the same time in the course
of the remarks give one or two impressions that I received
while attending the White House Conference on’the Aging.
First of all, why was The American Legion interested in
the White House Conference,
interested as a national organization,
and why did we send delegates?
Well, we felt a very
real responsibility to contribute to the Conference our observations and our experience
in the field in which the Conference was working.
Experience,
for example,
in housing and
employment for the older veteran,
pensions for those that are
disabled,
and particularly older disabled veterans in need,
the experience that we had seen the VA acquire in the medical
research field in geriatrics,
the experience that we are having
with the nursing care problems.
of
on
ness
We felt that we had a great contribution to make on behalf
veterans of this country to the White
House Conference
Aging and that,
too, since we were convinced of the sound-
the
the
of
the
programs
that
The
American
Legion
was
following,
we
felt that here was a good opportunity to emphasize those specific
Legion programs that had application to the Conference;
for
example,
the program that Clarence Bird is the Director of, which
includes the employment of the older worker.
What
did
that your
gates.
we
do?
national
In
As
you
organization
addition
to
that,
have
we
was
already
heard,
represented
encouraged
our
by
we
saw
to
three
it
dele-
Departments
to,
wherever possible,
have their Governors appoint them as delegates
to the White House Conference on Aging.
What did we not do?
We
did not agree in advance on any positions that we would take on
the subjects presented.
We did not vote en bloc.
The Conference,
as you know, was intended to do a number of things and to have
certain characteristics.
Because there was so much going on and
because delegates could only be assigned to a very small part of
the total considerations
and deliberations,
any impressions that
you take away
from the Conference are somewhat limited and circumscribed.
The Conference was intended to be comprehensive,
that
is,
their
problems.
planned
to
by
cover
The
in
entire
field
was
intended
citizens
and
the
non-professionals
political.
ference
the
It
wherever
of
the
the
aged
and
be
citizen-directed.
It
was
to
Governors
possible.
aging
were
It
and
encouraged
was
intended
to
appoint
to
be
non-
Democratic Congress authorized the White House Con1958
and the law was
signed by a Republican President.
183
It was intended to be non-paternalistic,
that is to say,
was intended to emphasize the need for self-help and not
emphasize exclusively the role of government in the care
the aged.
In
my
opinion,
the
White
House
achieved these characteristics.
it set out
to. do.
intend
What do we in
to do next?
information
on
the
It
Conference
pretty
pretty
well
it
to
of
well
achieved
what
The American Legion national organization
First of all, we intend to provide as much
Conference
policy
statements
and
recommenda-
tions as we can.
We intend to stimulate action on the part of
Departments and local Posts because that is where the work
has to be done and can be done,
and we intend to provide leadership wherever we can to the Departments and Posts.
The problem
of the aging and aged is an essential part of the National
Rehabilitation Commission's program and we intend to address
ourselves to that problem with all the abilities we possess.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN
O'CONNELL:
Just
four
minutes
and
59
seconds,
Bob.
back
At this time, I have the privilege of turning the
to our distinguished Chairman,
Bob McCurdy. Bob.
meeting
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank you, Vice Chairman Emory.
I
don't know whether you all know Vice Chairman Emory, or Vice
Commander Emory of the Rehabilitation Commission.
I think this
is the first session of this Commission where he has presided.
He is a very high class comrade from Denver, Colorado and I
think we should welcome him here,
too.
Thank you.
Our
Commander
next scheduled
and reports of
program is a speech by the National
the other committees meeting here in
session.
It is scheduled for five minutes from
take advantage of this five minutes for a short
Be
Friday,
prompt
and
be
.e«.The Conference
March 3, 1961..
back
at
recessed
184
now and
recess.
we
will
3:30.
to
reconvene
at
9:30
o'clock,
FRIDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 3, 1961
... The 38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference
of The American Legion reconvened in the Congressional Room,
Hotel Statler, Washington, D, C.,, at 9:30 A, M., Dr. J. B.
Hollis presiding.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
We have come to our last meeting of the
Conference here and at this time
I would like to ask that you
stand and we will have Reverend Bill Adams, Past Department
Commander of the District of Columbia,
open the meeting in
prayer.
REVEREND
gratitude
for
ADAMS:
all
Gracious
of
the
Master,
blessings
give
that
we
to us
enjoy
in
hearts
of
our
country.
May we ever be ready to acknowledge that they come from Thee.
Give to us hearts that have a feeling for those who are in need,
those who have suffered from the ravages of war, especially the
widows and the orphans of our comrades.
Give to us
grace to be
ready and willing to find out the wounds and heal the broken
hearted and to live in that confidence that Thou are still greatly concerned for humanity.
Enrich our Nation with the vietues
of peace that we may indeed fulfill what we have always believed
to be God-given destiny for our country.
May we close our conferences here with Thy grace upon us in the richness of Thy
benediction through Jesus Christ,
our Lord, Amen.
MR.
Chairman?
MARKOWITZ
CHAIRMAN
(PENNSYLVANIA):
HOLLIS:
Would
you
recognize
me,
Mr.
Yes.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
I would like to request for those of us
who will not be here and those who are gone that this
Conference
be recessed or ended in honor of Edward Nowak, who died yesterday in Buffalo,
and who was a former member of the National
Staff,
always interested in veterans and their problems,
and it
is with a sad feeling of humility that I make that motion.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Thank you, Mike.
First on our agenda
this morning is Rehabilitation Staff -- Discussion of topics
and questions not covered in other panels.
At this time
I would
like to introduce Warren MacDonald, Assistant Director of Rehabilitation,
who will take over at this time.
REMARKS BY WARREN
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF
MacDONALD
REHABILITATION
MR. MacDONALD:
Good morning,
ladies and gentlemen.
As
Vice Chairman Doc Hollis told you, we are sort of on the last
leg of this 38th Annual Rehabilitation Conference.
As you will
note, from the program for this morning, we have reserved this
portion for a discussion of topics and questions not covered in
other panels.
We do
have one topic sent in from a service
office
to
take
up
in
a few
booklet
by
reason
of
the
officer
in
just
few
minutes.
the
Government
officials.
a
minutes.
fact
that
I will
it
call
It is
not
was
not
on
the
listed
a
in
your
question
for
interested
service
First,
I would like to comment,
however,
that this would
be an excellent opportunity for you
folks to tell us what is
good and what is bad about this conference, what you would like
185
to see in future
comments I would
to
give
back
it
home
a
years, and
appreciate
little
that
more
would
so forth.
If you have any such
hearing them and if you would prefer
thought
be
fine.
and
I want
write
to
to
us
remind
have not registered I suggest that you do so if
reason than it assures that you will get a copy
proceedings
of
the
entire
Conference.
after
you
for no
of the
other
printed
you
Programming
that
if
get
you
a conference
of this type is very interesting and sometimes very trying.
You
have to make a lot of last minute changes here and there and
almost nothing quite goes as planned,
but I have enjoyed programming this Conference.
I hope it has gone relatively well.
I would like to point out, however,
some of the things that can
happen.
Insofar as the selection of panel discussion leaders is
concerned,
the ultimate has finally happened.
All five members
of a panel will be umable to be present this morning.
That is
the panel beginning at 10 o'clock.
Elmer Barfield of Georgia,
Pat Kohler of West Virginia, Wilbur Henline of Oklahoma,
all
regret that they could not remain to serve on this VR&E panel,
but they had to return to their respective home states.
Chic
Madia, Department Adjutant of Wyoming,
could not attend.
In
addition, we had asked Jim Lockman of New York to serve on this
panel, but George Mead advised us just as we were about to go
to print that Jim had been involved in an
auto accident and
would not be in
Washington.
We certainly hope that Jim gets
well quickly,
However, we have plenty of other excellent Service Officers
to call upon and three have already graciouslv consented to fill
in and serve on the VR&E panel.
These are "Bubba" Akin of Georgia,
whom I will ask to serve as chairman; Reuben Garnett of Washington
State,
and Charles Kohler, Department Service Officer of
Pennsylvania,
for the Philadelphia Regional Office.
I Have no
further comments to make about the changes,
although you have
just observed that Reverend Bill Adams has come to us this morning to substitute for the
National Chaplain who had to leave
town last night.
The Reverend has also agreed to come back at
noon for our benefliction.
of
ing
the
or
Are there any comments at this time
Conference itself?
Aré there any
otherwise?
Hermann
Wenige,
Post
concerning
suggestions
Service
the
for
Officer
conduct
chang-
of
Indiana.
MR. WENIGE:
Mr. Chairman,
the question I want to bring up
this morning is why is not not commercial life insurance exempt
as income on the same basis as United States Government and
National Service Life Insurance?
Unddr our present regulations
U. S.
Government
and
National
full amount of $10,000
widow or children of a
Service
commercial
life
expense of
would like
my office.
last illness and
to cite and they
burial.
came at
No.
War
insurance
up to
only
in
the
I have two
practically
and
it
was
allowed
and
the
veteran
a $10,000
widow
186
was
died
amount
of
the
cases that I
the same time
National
granted
in
Life
the
to
childwidow
pension
carried
II
exempt
policy payable in a lump sum to his widow.
There were no
ren,
The burial expenses amount to $1100,
That left the
$8,900 out of that insurance policy.
I filed a claim for
He
A World
is
the
of the
hand,
Hospital
Louisville.
1:
Insurance
VA
at
Case
Life
is exempt as income in the case
deceased veteran.
On the other
Insurance
$60 a month.
This
was
A
shortly
World
The
able
the
after
War
in
a
funeral
P.L.86-211
I
veteran
lump
sum.
widow's
husband
expenses
into
effect.
also
in
the
Louisville
also
were
no
children.
died
carried
went
a commercial
There
were
the
same,
Case
policy
$1100.
of
No.
VA
As
That
2:
hospital.
$3000
it
left
the
pay-
happened
widow
$1900 from that insurance policy.
I filed a claim for her
pension and it was denied on the ground of excessive income.
$1800,
as you know, is the maximum amount of income allowable under
86-211.
This widow had $1900, or one hundred over the maximum.
She was 59
years of age.
She was too young for social security
and too old to secure employment.
I contended that that discrimination is eminently unjustified.
I can see no difference in $10,000 paid by the
government or $10,000 paid by a commercial insurance company.
In my
book
$10,000
is
still
$10,000
regardless
of
the
source
of the insurance policy.
I believe that that question is a
very serious one.
I know the service officers here have had
similar cases.
I have scores of them where because of a few
hundred dollars over the maximum amount a widow was denied
pensions.
It is my contention that something should be done to
equalize the insurance from whatever source,
that an amount up
to $10,000 be exempted in the matter of life insurance regard-
less
of
the
For
Winfield
gress.
source.
the
information
Denton
It is
my
of
of
Indiana
hope,
if
the
has
conferees
introduced
this
conference
here,
such
as
Congressman
a
bill
in
a conference
Con-
can
not take action on this matter,
that individual service officers
will urge their Congressmen to support that bill so that widows
in both categories will have their claims considered on an
equal
basis.
That
law
as
it
is
now
might
seriously
affect
the
widow
of any man in this audience today.
Only Tuesday the National
Commander in his talk before the Veterans Affairs Committee
stressed the importance of extending the time for reinstatement
of Government insurance,
showing that because of financial pressures a good many men had to drop their insurance when they came
out of service,
and that is true especially of World War I
veterans,
and then when it was too late to feinstate their
policies they were
financially able to do so.
They purchased commercial insurance at a great deal higher
premium in an effort to protect their loved ones and that very
act has jeopardized the returns which might be expected in the
way of pensions.
The Act to protect those loved ones has
succeeded only in for a period of time from several months to a
year denying pensions to these widows.
I ask the conferees
here to take that under very serious consideration.
MR. MacDONALD:
Thark
the subject I mentioned Mr.
wanted to raise here on the
you very much, Mr. Wenige.
This is
Wenige had written to us about and
floor.
Perhaps some of you have
further thoughts or comments to
issue of course goes to the law
offer in this connection.
itself which counts under
The
the
pension
insurance
for
system
commercial
dollar regardless of how
beneficiary, whereas the
life
much
same
and
law
as
income
regardless of
excludes from
how
the
dollar
used by the
computation
of income moneys received through the NSLI or USGLI,
or even
Servicemen's Indemnity System.
He feels that this money should
be equated.
I may make one further comment that this issue came
to the last National Convention and was discussed on the floor
there,
The Convention voted to reject the issue, resolution 499.
187
Herman, however,
cussion on this,
being adopted.
MR.
COX
feels that he
possibly with
(OHIO):
This
would like to hear further disa view to a subsequent resolution
is
the
last
meeting
of
this
con-
ference.
I have been to every meeting since Monday.
Since we
met here a year ago The
American Legion and other veterans
organizations,
every veteran and his dependents,
have lost their
greatest friend they ever had up on the Hill, Edith Nourse
Rogers,
I have been somewhat disappointed that ever since we
came here Monday I have never heard her name even mentioned,
even up on
the Hill where she always had that fine welcoming
speech for us.
The name was not mentioned,
let alone standing
in silent tribute for Edith Nourse Rogers.
I wonder why.
Thank you.
MR. MacDONALD:
I appreciate your comment and I do agree
with you very much, Mr. Cox.
As you know, however,
the National
Convention paid high tribute to Mrs. Rogers' Resolution 605
and
a part of the legislative program that the Commander presented
to the House Veterans Affairs on Tuesday incorporates a bill
introduced on our behalf which seeks to name the Bedford,
Massachusetts VA Hospital for Mrs. Edith Nourse Rogers.
I would
like to make this one comment in her connection.
It was brought
to my attention by Mr. T. O. Kraabel,
our former Director and
now Director of the VRE section in the VA, that it is
interesting to note that in a span of only ten months four of the principal architects of our Veterans Affairs program passed away and
all were above the age of 75.
This includes General Hines, former Congressman Rankin,
Mrs. Rogers,
and our own Watson Miller.
Are there any other
comments?
Thank you.
One other thought I would like to point
out is that in connection with the programming of this conference I have learned one lesson.
If I had to do Wednesday's
session over again I would have put the ADP discussion in the
afternoon.
I had the feeling when we came back after lunch
that day,
even though we had many questions and many interesting questions
to discuss,
that the session was sort of anticlimactic.
The big
show had been in the morning.
The next
time I will keep that in mind for purpose of scheduling program.
With that I think I will turn the rostum back to the presiding
officer, Doc Hollis.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Next on our agenda is the panel on
vocational rehabilitation and education and the fellow that I
am going to introduce now needs no introduction.
Youall know
him, but I will present him, T. O. Kraabel, Director of Vocational
Rehabilitation and Education Service of the Veterans Administration.
T. 0.7?
I have asked T. O. to introduce his staff in turn, so you
may proceed with your remarks.
REMARKS OF T. O. KRAABEL, DIRECTOR
VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION AND
EDUCATIONAL SERVICE - AND STAFF
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you, Dr. Hollis.
Ladies and gentlemen, three of my associates are with me today.
They are the experts.
I would like to have you know them. Two of them were
here a year ago and presented VRXE's part of the program.
Wilton
B.
Gundlach
from
the
188
State
of
Minnesota,
the
Executive Assistant Director.
Frank Page, from North Carolina
who is also Assistant Director.
And Dr. Joe Samler,
also
Assistant Director.
In the composition of VRE we have two
principal divisions,
the Counseling, Training,
and Adjustment
Division headed by Dr. Samler,
and the Benefits and Facilities
Division
headed
by Mr,
Frank
Page.
Central
Office
is
34
number.
now
in
Our
total
VRXE
staff
in
From the experience I have had in the past with these
conferences I think it would be well to get to the questions
that have been sent in, explore the answers,
and then go to
other
time
information
we
have
that
might
be
desirable
So
much
for
now,
left.
and
presented
in
the
Doctoe.
CHAIRMAN HOLLIS:
Thank you, T. O.
On my right we have
the discussion leaders from The American Legion.
At this time
I would like to introduce A.V.. Akin, Department Rehabilitation
Chairman from the State of Georgia, who will in turn introduce
his co-workers.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Doctor.
We have serving with us on
the VR&E panel representing The American Legion our good friend
Reuben Garnett from the State of Washington.
Charles Kohler,
Department Service Officer of Pennsylvania.
To get the
program
under way, we will move to the first question on the printed
program.
This was submitted from Georgia:
'Is a person who
was receiving War Orphans' Educational Assistance, which was
interrupted due to entering the Armed Forces,
eligible for
resumption
of
MR.
this
benefit
KRAABEL:
Mr.
after
his
Page will
discharge?"
take
that.
MR. PAGE:
The answer to this question is "Yes."
The law
provides that if an eligible person serves on active military
duty prior to his 23rd birthday that he will have five years
after his first discharge to complete his program.
This pro-
vision
is
unqualified
and
would
in
no
way
be
influenced
by
the
fact he had pursued training under Chapter 35
prior to his
entrance into service.
However,
no training may be afforded
beyond the maximum of 36 months or the eligible person's 31st
birthday.
MR.
Charles
AKIN:
Any questions?
If not, we are going to have
Kohler of Pennsylvania to take questions 2 and 3.
MR. KOHLER:
'Are the children of a Korean veteran
who
died in service in October 1955,
and who are in receipt of peacetime death compensation,
in any way eligible for War Orphans’
Educational Assistance?"
MR.
KRAABEL:
This
will
also
be
for
Frank
Page.
MR. PAGE:
This question may not be given a categorical
"yes!" or "no" answer,
Since the veteran parent died in October
1955,
his death occurred during the induction period as defined
in the PL 86-785
amendment
to Section 1701 of Title 38, U.S.C.
However,
the
answer
depends
upon
whether
the
veteran
parent
died of a service-connected disability as defined in Title 38,
as amended,
The amendment provides that the disability must
(A)
be
shown
to
have
directly
resulted
from,
and the causative factor therefore must be
shown to have arisen out of the performance
active military, naval,
or air service (but
189
of
not
including service described under
section 106 of Title 38), or
(B)
have resulted (a)
flict or (b) from
directly from armed conan injury or disease
received while engaged in extra-hazardous
service
(including such service under
conditions simulating war).
As ‘explained in Instruction
38, PL 86-785,
dated December 30,
that the disability causing death
1, Title 38
U. 8S. C., Chapter
1960,
it is
fot sufficient
has been rated as service-
conditioms service-connected under
the law are excluded.
The disease
the presumptive provisions of
or injury causing death must
connected
in
line
be
found
to
and
not
merely
MR.
be
AKIN:
of
duty
directly
compensation
traceable
coincident
Any
for
in
time
questions?
to
the
with
The
purposes.
performance
active
next
Thus,
of duty
duty.
question.
MR. KOHLER:
No. 3:
"Must a War Orphan with a physical
handicap wait until his 18th birthday before he can begin training under the War Orphans' Educational Assistance Act?"
MR. PAGE:
The answer is "No."
If an eligible person has
a physical or mental handicap and the Administrator determines
that his best interests will be served by pursuing a program
of special restorative training or a specialized course of vocational training,
the period of training may begin before his
18th birthday but not
before his 14 birthday.
There is a basic
distinction between restorative and specialized vocational training.
Special restorative training is designed to overcome,
or
lessen,
the effects of physical or mental disability.
Examples
of such training are speech and voice correction,
or retention,
language retraining,
lip reading,
auditory training, Braille
reading and writing,
training in ambulation,
one hand typewriting,
and personal and social adjustment.
Specialized vocational teaining which leads to a predetermined and identified vocational objective may be authorized
if it is found that such training,
either alone or when combined
with other training,
constitutes a suitable program and is required for a person who has a mental or physical handicap.
There
are two other instances
in which an eligible person may begin
training before his 18th birthday.
They are (1)- Upon successful
completion of his secondary schooling,
and
(2) if the eligible
person is above the age of compulsory school attendance under
applicable State law, and has not completed his secondary schooling but the Administrator determines his best interests will be
served thereby.
to
the
and
we
MR. AKIN:
Any questions on
next question, which comes
will
ask
our
Comrade
Garnett
No. 3?
If not, we will move
from the State of Washington,
to
handle
that
for
us.
MR. GARNETT:
PL 86-785,
Instruction 1, dated December
30, 1960 set up procedures and effects of the ACt.
Based on the
publicity given,
the widows have the impression that their
children would be eligible for benefits and are counting on it.
There are many limitations as set forth under the law and it is
subject to close scrutiny.
Question:
Why can't the Rating
Boards
this
set
forth
the
potential
eligibility
time?
190
of
the
children
at
In
MR,
PAGE:
recognition
The
of
the
answer
fact
to
that
this
question
widows
is
might
wish
that
they
to make
can.
plans
several years in advance for the education of their children,
VA procedural
instructions have for some time provided that there
is no objection
to a determination of a child;s basic eligibility
prior to the age at which he may become entitled to educational
assistance under the law;
that is, a determination as to whether
the
cause
of
the
veteran
parent's
death
was
due
to
a
service-
connected disability.
(See Parva. 27.2 ,M7-1, Change 10, dated
March 7, 1958).
This,
of course,
applies to the case of the
veteran parent whose death occurred during the induction period
as well as to one who died as the result of wartime service.
A
request for such a determination may be made by the widowed
mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian on the usual VA application
form.
If the child is found basically eligible,
the VA will
so- inform the mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian by letter.
The letter will state ‘that processing of the application will
be deferred until the child reaches the senior year in high
school or attains the age of 18 and also that the application
will be reactivated at that time upon request of the mother,
guardian,
or legal custodian.
I am
the person
would like
aware that this may not give a complete answer to
who submitted this question.
I think possibly they
to know also if at the time of the adjudication of
the
of
cause
the
parent's
death
the
mother
can
be
advised
without application whether her children would be eligible for
training.
I will have to answer that we will take this under
consideration with the Compensation & Pension Service.
I think
possibly it can be provided.
is
bers
the
MR. GARNETT:
I am glad you brought
main question that I had in mind.
MR.
of
AKIN:
our
Are
Legion
there
panel
on
any
questions
my
right?
that
up
because
from
any
of
the
that
mem-
MR. ‘GARNETT:
7T. O., with regard to this recent legislation passed last year which allowed veterans to take additional
training under Public Law 16 or to enter training,
just in a
short answer can you give us any idea of what number of veterans
have been able to come in under that and if we service organizations,
especially The American Legion,
can do something to help
get that across to the veteran and invite it to the attention of
the VA?
will
31,
MR.
give
1961
KRAABEL:
Yes, we have some information on that and
you a brief answer as to the number.
As of January
the
number
of
World
War
II
veterans
in
Vocational
I
Re-
habilitation was very limited,
178.
The possibility that we
can stimulate through publicity to veterans organizations
the
active interest of potentially eligible veterans will be treated
by Dr. Samler.
First as to the number estimated I would like to
have
Mr.
Gundlach
give
you
that
information.
MR. GUNDLACH:
We anticipated for the first year,
that is,
this current fiscal year beginning in July 1, 1960 and closing
June 30, 1961,
that there would be an additional 500
average
monthly enrollments under Public Law 86-721.
I don't believe
we will quite realize that additional number,
but it will be in
the neighborhood of 2 to 5 hundred additional veterans because
of the law.
There always is a question as to the means of
101
publicity that is given new legislation.
We have so far resorted to the normal channels of communication -- the newspaper,
radio,
and spot television statements.
They have in the past
been rather effective but I think your local posts have served
us best because you are, after all, the ones who are in most
direct contact with the men in the community who may have
eligibility under these new laws.
We are looking to you as our
most effective means of reaching these veterans.
We reach them
more or less by chance,
that is if they read the newspaper or
if they listen to the TV or radio.
If we look to you for assistance and I am sure that it will be as effective as it has been
in the past.
from
MR. AKIN:
any member
Thank
of the
you, sir.
VA Staff?
Are
there
any
further
comments
MR. KRAABEL: Dr. Hollis and Chairman Akin, you will notice
that the four questions sent in advance were answered by Mr.
Page.
They all pertain to eligibility and entitlement.
That
falls in his division of our staff activity.
Now, we are going to have Dr. Samler give us something on
a group of veterans,
the seriously disabled, and others who may
now come in under the terms of Public Law 86-721.
Dr. Samler
has been making a study of where these people are and what might
be done to help them.
Dr. Samler,
DR. SAMLER:
Friends,
I am going to report to you on two
important projects.
First,
the discontinued program about which
you may have heard.
You know we work in rehabilitation with
human beings
and moreover, with human beings with disabilities,
some of them very serious.
I need not remind you, of all people
of the range of human ills we and you encounter.
The basic problem in helping the disabled veteran is really in an area of
predicting the future.
Given a paraplegic or an NP veteran,
or
a veteran with multiple sclerosis, what kind of training and
other help is necessary in order for him to reach a point where
he can respect himself and contribute as a productive member of
the community?
’
Prediction,
even when using the best available scientific
and professional means,
carries a certain margin of uncertainty.
This is inevitable and follow-up becomes an essential part of a
sound rehabilitation program.
For a number of years,
therefore,
we have been concerned with those disabled veterans who with our
help, plan a rehabilitation program,
enter training, make progress in it, but then stop.
In our official language they discontinue.
In 1958
for P.L.894 trainees,
23 per cent were found to be
discontinued and it worried us a good deal and so we took action.
Following an ambitious pilot study in which we came to terms
with the nature of the problem and what we might realistically
expect to accomplish,
we initiated a program of systematic followup of
this group.
The instructions were carried in an issue
that you may know as EM 22-33,
in June,
1960.
We did it quite
systematically.
Our TMS sections identified the discontinued
veterans for us.
Each disabled veteran so identified was followed up and on the basis of information secured and our own records
we were and are able to determine whether the veteran was doing
all right or whether he needed and wanted our help.
In very
many cases such veterans were visited at their homes by our staff.
192
that 13 per cent
We estimated on the basis of our pilot study
of the discontinued group would be re-entered into training and
it looks as if we are going to come remarkably close to this
of this group had
582
1961,
At the end of January,
estimate.
and 2,027 had been scheduled
been re-entered into training,
for rehabilitation counseling preliminary to going back into
training.
2,500
We should
and 3,000
otherwise
we feel
Kraabel
item
come out
disabled
simply
would
not
good about it.
referred mainly
reported
on
to
of this careful follow-up with between
veterans in rehabilitation status who
have
been
reached.
You
can see
why
The second item and the one to which Mr.
really is a follow-up report on the major
you
just
a
year
ago.
We
were
then
happy
to
tell you that we had issued instructions to the regional offices
to address themselves in a way they had not done before to the
vocational rehabilitation problems of the seriously disabled
veterans who had not applied for vocational rehabilitation.
These are the veterans,
mind you,with physical disabilities
rated
100 per cent and the NP group rated 70 ‘per .cent.or: higher. We
told the regional offices how to identify such veterans, we told
them to find them,
to help them,
to help motivate them, and to
enter them if it is possible to do so at all into vocational
rehabilitation training.
As I recall it, we put you on notice that in going out and
knocking on the veteran's door we were making a profound change
in our policy of waiting for the veteran to come to us
and that
your
help
at
a
number
of
points
in
our
new
approach
was
not
only desired,
it was actively solicited.
I will make only two
points about this approach.
I think both will interest you.
When we last spoke,
and I think in response to a question,
one
of us said that of course the policy and procedure could not
apply to World War II veterans.
This is because the termination
date of July 25,
1960, simply made such an approach inapplicable.
However, with the passage of 86-721 the situation changed.
In
our
Instruction
Number
1
on
that
law,
which
I
am
sure
you have seen, we put into effect precisely the same policies
of identifying,
motivating,
and rehabilitating eligible seriously disabled veterans of World War II as we have for the Korean
veterans,
:
Second,
I would dearly like to be able to present a definitive report of progress made.
This cannot be done because
at this moment our regional offices are right in the middle of
this big job.
We have not wanted the regional offices to do the
thing in a hurry.
We have told them,
rather,
to do it systematically and carefully and if necessary to do it over a period
of time rather than in a great big hurry as a project.
But for
purposes of reporting to you today we have secured data from five
offices which we regard as meaningful.
I will give you only a
very few figures for these five offices, but you will want to
bear in mind that nationally we are talking about sixteen to
seventeen thousand of these very seriously disabled veterans.
2,800
such
veterans
have
been
identified
by
these
five
offices
and as of last week records have been reviewed for something
like more than half of this group.
About 600 had been seen by
VA staff and thus far 250
had been provided vocational rehabilitation counseling.
One hundred sixty-two actually had
been entered into training or are scheduled to be entered into
training.
Now, of course,
it is
hazardous to project from the
experience of these few offices to all offices and we will in
193
But if we safeguard ourselves by regardtime have firm data.
ing the experience of these offices as high, we may be not unwarranted in expecting up to 800 to 900 of these (once again)
very seriously disabled veterans to be entered into rehabilitation training. These numbers stand for human beings, most
seriously disabled in all instances.
I want somehow to bring
this fact home and will do so by referring to you a few brief
paragraphs not from one of our VA documents, but from one of
yours,
from
a field
service officers.
regional office.
of
his
These
are
report,
service
I
three
but
he
will
visit
not
paragraphs
is
by
one
identify
talking
and
about
of
the
right
the
your
own
officer
from
kind
the
of
field
or
the
middle
veteran
I
have been attempting to describe to you. "There are forty
such veterans in training at the present time," he writes.
"The courses taken include accounting,
electrical appliancerepair,
radio and television service,
lawn mower and power
saw repair,
tile laying,
upholstering, writing,
and tutoring,
to list a few.
Every effort has been made to obtain suitable
instructions for each individual veteran.
They have been
successful:in procuring the services('they'
is the regional
office) of college professors,
even deans of colleges,
as well
as certified public accountants and members of established
accounting firms.
The heart of the whole program is in the
selection of the right instructor.’
How right he is.
"So many successful cases shown
were most amazing.
One
case we cannot forget
and feel it should be mentioned.
A
24-year old Navy veteran whose hands and legs were paralyzed
became motivated toward taking a course in creative writing.
The high school principal began working with this veteran and
teaching him basic English and literature.
Next they looked
around for an instructor
to teach creative writing. A professor at a university was located while she was on a visit to
London.
On her return to the States she informed the Veterans
Administration
that she had a full schedule at the university
and furthermore,
the Veterans Administration could not afford
her price.
She was
asked only to visit this veteran,
to which
she agreed."
"After two visits she became quite interested and was
willing to do the job without pay.
After considerable study
the veteran finished the program.
His first article was
published in Harper's Magazine.
He was forced to move to
Florida because of a chest condition."
cation
"Recently,
he
as a regular
signed a contract with a Florida publistaff writer."
Just one more paragraph.
"Several of the veterans who completed their training in
special repair work are now being employed by chemical companies in the local area on an hourly basis.
They do not come
into the plants,
but rather the work is sent to them at their
homes.
One veteran repairs bicycles for a chemical company.
Another veteran who studied watch-repairing repairs gauges and
a third veteran repairs gown hoops."
I
think
this
is
a. good
place
toistop.
' Thank
‘you,
very
much.
T.
O.
MR.
and
AKIN:
Do we have any questions from the floor for
anv members of his staff?
We have another comment
194
from
T.
0.
T.
O.,
we
are
always
glad
to
hear
from
you.
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you, Mr.Chairman.
I wanted to comment
that these gentlemen have been
on the program both in the field
and in Central Office for the past 16 years. I recall,
as Mr.
Markowitz commented
a while ago, that the original educational
man on the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission
passed away yesterday, Ed Nowak.
We remember him with great
affection,
his dedication,
his devotion and how he carried on
in the initial stages of the GI Bill in 1945.
Upon his resignation in 1946, The American Legion went out to the Midwest
and called Cecil H. Munson to succeed Nowak. He has been in
charge of that phase of the National Rehabilitation Commission's
program since that time.
These gentlemen with me today know
him much better than they knew me, because always it was Cecil
Munson who would make the contacts on problem situations in
VR&E between The American Legion and the Veterans Administration.
The gentleman who has seen this program flourish,
go up to its
peak,
and decline is Mr. Gundlach,
and I am going to ask him to
make a few comments as to where are we today in VR&E.
MR. GUNDLACH:
I am going to assure you I will be very
brief, but I believe
that, as in the past years,
you have
evinced an interest as to where are we today with respect to
the veterans'
educational program.
We have 227,000 veterans
enrolled as of January 31, 1961,
and to impress you that we
still have a serious obligation in terms of numbers with whom
we deal,
I might put it this way: that
it represents about a
million dollars
a day in subsistence allowance given these
veterans.
Have you thought of it that way?
That to me is
rather impressive.
I am dealing primarily here with numbers
because that is the manner in which we can communicate best,
I believe,
as to where we are.
Dr. Samler,
on the other hand, has dealt with the character
of the work that we have had.
Numbers don't tell the whole
story.
I think he brought out clearly to you that as we have
progressed through the years, we have been
able to recognize
that we have added responsibilities
accumulating upon us in the
form of those disabled veterans, who for one
reason or another
have
left
their
training
and
still
are
sorely
in
need
of
attention,
so our program responsibilities do not diminish directly in proportion with the decrease in the number of enrollees.
Let's go back a moment to the 227,000 veterans that we still have
in
educational programs.
How do they break down?
We have
6,000 disabled veterans in training.
We have 205,000
veterans
of the Korean Conflict in the readjustment program and we have
15,000
children under the War Orphans Educational Assistance Act
now in training.
This represents,
as you know, only a small
fraction
of
the
workload
that
we
once
had
in
the
days
of
1946
and 1947.
We had at one time, you recall,
2,500,000
in training.
That was the peak of the program.
I might add one thing before
I conclude,
and that is, that we have to serve these people who
are still in training,
1,024 VR&E personnel in the 49 stations
in which we are still operating VRXE programs.
Thank you.
folks
MR. KRAABEL:
Thank you,
have sensed and realized
definite
declination,
the
Wilt.
better
definite
Mr, Chairman,
I think you
than we, probably,
the
shrinkage,
of
these
programs
since the heyday of the GI Bill.
Only one has
shown to be
on
the ascendancy or increase,
and that for the next two or three
years,,
when
we
feel
decline.
I
am
referring
that
it
also
to
the
195
will
War
level
Orphans
off
and
gradually
Educational
Assistance
Act.
What does the staff do in Central Office in the face of
termination dates of these programs staring you right ahead?
The gentlemen have referred back to the time when these activities
were climbing - the hectic days when the bulge came in the GI
Bill,
They have concluded that probably the task of guiding
a declining program in its last days takes just as much tact and
resourcefulness as when it was climbing and increasing.
Here are some of the things that the folks have been
analyzing,
appraising,
and studying,
so that we might keep pace
staff-wise,
as well as personnel-wise in the field,
and still
keep the program at a high level in quality. As a staff. we have
no directive power.
We deal through the area field directors
who in turn communicate
to the managers on administrative matters.
As to policies and procedures,
interpretation of regulations,
and instructions
the VR&E staff also functions through channels.
Now, when,
and what does a program staff do to adjust the
activity in its decline?
Here are some of the considerations
that assert themselves.
We have to determine the accuracy of
prospective workload estimates,
look ahead for two or three
years,
and estimate how many are coming in to take advantage of
this law or that law.
How about the appropriaténess of the organization pattern?
Are we organized properly and effectively
to serve the weteran in the regional office and in the central
office?
Third,
the
adequacy
of
the
staffing
factors.
Are
we
meeting the requirements in training,
in counseling,
benefit
and facilities,
contract work,
eligibility,
compliance and so
forth?
Fourth,
the suitability of the operating procedures.
Has experience taught that there should be changes in some of
the operations that have taken place so far?
Number five,
the
validity of time allowances for the determination of operational
effectiveness,,’ Have we allowed too much time for each detail or
each step
or not enough?
Maintenance of the quality level;
this
is a great project in the Veterans Administration,
and in every
government agency these days - to maintain high quality of
effectiveness on an economical basis. Number seven,
the employee
morale,
always a big factor in the conduct of any program.
Eight, good public relations.
How are the folks reacting to
the administration of these programs which have such a great
out-reach from the government to the people back home.
items.
Time
does
Suffice
not
it
permit
to
say
detailed
that
based
exposition
on
of
each
experience
of
these
extending
back 18 years of program studies and periodic surveys,
every
effort is made to contract and reduce the program in a reasonable
manner without detriment to the quality and adequacy of service
to the remaining veterans in training or eligible to initiate
training.
Not
only
veterans
themselves,
but
also
Congressmen,
school
officials,
approval agencies,
service officers,
and interested
relatives are authors of innumerable inquiries which keep the
VR&E
regional
offices
alert to conduct these
in decline or not.
staffs
programs
When
in
one
contemplates
and
in
the
effectively
that
at
one
time
central
and
the
office
fully
on
the
whether
number
of
VR&E
people staffing these programs reached 26,550
in 1947;
the number
trained in readjustment,
the GI Bills, Public Law 346 and its
successor Public Law 50,
exceeded 10,000,000;
the number trained
196
in vocational rehabilitation nearly 680,000;
and the number whd
have so far entered training under the War Orphans Assistance
Act, 28, 244, the enormity of this total effort and coverage
can be gauged.
By way of comparison,
the total number in training under
all current laws, as Mr. Gundlach has told you, is around 227,000
and the personnel at this time
is 1024 in the field and 35 in
the
central office.
VR&E is still a going concern.
Every staff
member continues a vigilance to see that, although
patronage of
these programs is diminishing and the termination dates,
except
as to
the educational assistance for children of the service
connected deceased veterans,
are approaching,
the effectiveness
of service will be maintained.
Among the steps taken under
authority of the Chief Benefits
Director and the Administrator
to adapt the VRE organization to
change circumstances
are in two major areas.
Many of you may
have been aware of this.
Number
offices with
areas,
1.
The consolidation of VR&E workloads
those of larger ones within the same or
on smaller
contiguous
Number 2.
The combination of the two organizational elements,
counseling,
on the one hand and education and training,
on the
other into one known as the vocational counseling,
training,
and
adjustment
activity.
As
of
January
31
of
this
year
there
have
been 18 workload consolidations and at that date no further plans
for additional consolidations were authorized.
These have been
realized
with
a
minimum
of
adverse
consequences.
In
fact,
the
record shows a remarkable degree of smoothness in the change.
Personnel affected were for the most part absorbed or reassigned.
It is never popular to remove a program or unit from one regional
office and combine it with another at a larger office, but when
the
facts
of
life
make
such
moves
necessary,
the
Chief
Director,
the Area Field Directors,
the Administrator
program staffs face up to the realities.
Benefits
and the
Our administrative,
educational,
and counseling experts
have studied this and continue to study this situation to the
end that the consolidation of workloads will assure maintenance
of high quality service and depth of professional and technical
resources.
We are proceeding in the shrinking and consolidation
phase on the premise of maintaining the integrity of the VR&E
function as long as possible.
The other major step has been the
combining of counseling and education and training activities
into one organizational element.
Why did we do that?
The move
is based on the conception of vocational rehabilitation for the
disabled as a unitary task.
The progress of a trainee through
counseling,
training,
and job adjustment can be and ought to be
the concern of one staff member,
and this practice has been
observed by other agencies concerned who have responsibilities
in the vocational rehabilitation field.
Why didn't the Veterans
Administration follow this arrangement from the beginning?
The
reason is that the VR&E service in its early days experienced
such a rapid growth to such unprecedented numbers of trainees
that it became necessary to effect a division of labor to carry
out the functions of vocational rehabilitation properly.
Now, circumstances permit adopting the more acceptable
practice of vesting in one staff member all the responsibilities
involved in processing the training program of a disabled veteran.
197
We are hoping and planning that by July 1 of this year counselors
will have assumed the training functions and will be devoting a
percentage of their time to that purpose.
You who are in close
touch with the regional managers and their staffs in your day-byday work appreciate the task they have in adjusting to expanding
or declining workloads.
Administration difficulties,
budget
matters,
employee
morale,
and
staffing
problems
seem
to
persist
in attending the most diligent and careful of efforts. As the
program staff we recognize the remarkable achievements of these
managers.
The team play has been and continues to be of the best.
Mr.
Chairman,
on
to thank you and the
Thank you very much,
MR.
of
the
AKIN:
VR&E
MR.
in
We
behalf
of my
audience
for
have
Washington
MUNSON:
Just
Mr.
Munson
with
one
colleagues
listening
who
is
a
question.
brief
question
and
myself,
I wish
to
us
these
minutes.
the
chief
because
45
consultant
I
know
that
many of you are concerned about the orphans of those who were
inducted dnto service.
I am asking this question so that there
might be some clarification as to just when information should
be sought from the Veterans Administration.
Is there any age limit regarding application for training?
I am thinking of a mother whose husband was killed in service or
died in service and she has two or three children,
say, ten or
younger.
When can she apply in order to ascertain whether or
not her children are going to be eligible for training under the
War Orphans Act?
MR. PAGE:
There is no age limitation for receipt of application.
It can be reactivated after she gets the information
whether the child is eligible or ineligible and that application
can
be
reactivated
upon
her
request.
MR. MUNSON:
Mr. Chairman,
this is important because the
service officer can advise the mother to make an immediate
application for training for the oldest and then there will be
a decision made as to whether or not the children are eligible.
The mother can make plans in the future for her children to go
to school if they are eligible.
One more point.
Because the education and training program
is gradually fading out of the picture, don't forget that your
job in rehabilitation is not completed.
Coming into the picture
is the older veteran being discharged from a hospital where he
has received counseling,
corrective therapy and some training.
This veteran will be coming home seeking a place in the active
life of his community.
Our Post Service Officers should be ready to receive this
older veteran and help him find a place in his community.
Now,
don't forget that a little less than 50
per cent of the veterans
hospitalized are hospitalized in Veterans Administration hospitals.
The others are hospitalized in your local community
hospitals and they,
too, are receiving some counseling and rehabilitation.
This is a real challenge for all of us.
MR. AKIN:
Thank you, Cecil Munson.
from the floor to the VR&E section of this
any questions from our colleagues,
Garnett
198
Are there any questions
Conference?
Are there
and Kohler?
If
not,
Mr.
Chairman,
over
to
CHAIRMAN
HOLLIS:
time
in
of
I
would
like
to
turn
this
panel
panel
and
at
behalf
The
This
concludes
this
American
Legion
I would
like
to
T. O. and your staff for coming over and giving us
also we are very grateful
to Chairman Akin and his
for
back
you,
their
contribution.
At this
Chairman,
Bob
time,
I would
McCurdy.
like
to
turn
our
this
thank
you,
your time,
co-workers
and
over
our
meeting
to
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We anticipate that Mr. Teague will arrive
at any moment,
but I would like to take this opportunity to pay a
tribute to those who have probably been the most influential of
all in regard to our work for veterans.
During
the
past
year,
we
have
lost
four
in
ten
months,
the
original big four of those who supported the Veterans Administration and those who through so many years were staunch supporters of the veteran.
I call attention to Mrs. Edith Nourse
Rogers, who certainly was the greatest friend with the biggest
heart for all veterans
and particularly disabled veterans;
General Frank Hines, who for so many years served at his station
as the Administrator of Veterans' Affairs and who so ably aided
and assisted the enactment of basic law, rules,
regulations and
procedures;
John Rankin, who was for so many years the Chairman
of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs, who also was always
a champion of the disabled and made notable and great contri-
butions;
and
last,
but
certainly
not
least
of
the
big
four
was
our own
Watson B. Miller.
I know it saddens us all to see these
four superb people who have devoted so much of themselves and
their lives to the benefit of veterans,
and I am going to ask,
at this time,
that you stand for a moment in silence in memory
and honor of these four old timers.
A moment of silence was
observed.
former
old
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I
member of the staff
timer
from
the
great
am sure you heard yesterday that a
here, Ed. Nowak, passed on and another
State
of
Illinois
that
I know
many
of
you
knew well, Bill McCauley,
also has answered the call and I would
like to call on the members from the State of Illinois, Mr.
Applebaum,
if he
is here.
I will postpone this until later.
We
now have another great champion of veterans,
the Chairman of the
Committee
on Veterans'
Affairs,
one
who
is
a great
friend
whom
we don't always agree with, but by the same token, he does not
always agree with us.
I have found him fair and honorable and
always willing to listen and always able to give as well as he
gets.
In fact, he is just our type of comrade and he is a comrade in his Post in Texas,
and we consider it a high honor and
a great pleasure to have with us this morning as our speaker the
Honorable Olin Teagie, Chairman of the House Committee on
Veterans!
Affairs.
CHAIRMAN TEAGUE:
This morning your National Commander has
been complimented more on Capitol Hill on his talk last night
than anyone who has spoken in Washington for a long time.
He
brought a message that was appreciated by everyone I have talked
to.
wants
I
am
going
to
I
will
to
talk
attempt
to
to
you
for
answer
199
a
little
questions.
while
and
if
anybody
not
I
have
easy
to
said
this
represent
before
and
veterans
in
would
say
it
again,
We
have
Congress.
that
25
it
men
is
on
our Committee,
and our committee is the least political of any in
Congress.
I doubt that any committee goes through the democratic
processes as carefully as we do
in trying to work out legislation.
Already this year, we have about 300 bills in our committee.
As soon as a bill is introduced - and they come from
many sources - we send them
to the Veterans Administration,
Treasury Department,
Bureau of the Budget,
or whoever is concerned
with the bill,
and ask for
a report as to whether the agency is
for it or against it,
Sometimes we do
hold hearings on bills
and report and pass them before obtaining those reports,
but
generally we wait for a report from the department before we try
to pass a bill.
In those few cases where bills are reported
before a report is received from the agency,
the bills are noncontroversial and of a minor nature.
The first two bills we expect to consider this year will be
a housing bill and a compensation bill.
The housing bill is quite
controversial,
There is just so much money around this country
that we can get into housing,
and those of us interested in
veterans housing feel the powers that be are attempting to put
too much money in other housing and not enough in the veterans!
program.
Within the last week there have probably been 14 or 18
hours of discussion between the Administrator of Veterans Affairs,
the Bureau of the Budget,
the Treasury Department
and myself and
my staff.
There will be a housing message in the next few days.
Just what
it will recommend we do
not know but we suspect it
won't please us as
to the amount of money that goes into veterans’
housing.
If it does not we are going to try to pass a bill ‘to
put money into veterans'
housing.
We realize the Treasusy Department has a problem as to
raising money.
We have surveyed a number of veterans who applied for and got a loan and we do not
feel there is any better housing program in
the United States
than our veterans'
housing program, but certainly the program
is no good unless we can get some money into it.
I spent about
an hour last week with
the President,
talking about our veterans’
problems,
and
I
veterans
are
concerned
think
I found
a very
sympathetic
and
think
will
I
The only
Government who
people to receive
have not received
are
who
the
people
receive
a
a
we
check
raise
have
ear
a
as
good
far
from our United
in the past few
compensation,
our
disabled
as
year.
States
years
veterans.
Probably the second bill we will take up this year will be the
compensation bill.
The cost of living has gone up about 5%.
They passed a bill last year giving Federal employees a raise
of 7-1/2%,
so I would guess that we can pass a bill somewhere
between
5
and
10
percent
as
cerned,
and of course just a
tremendous amount of money.
far
as
small
disabled veterans
raise
like
that
are
runs
con-
into
a
We passed a pension
very controversial bill.
that went into that bill,
who represent you here in
bill in the last Congress.
It was a
You would not dream the amount of work
including the work of your own people
Washington;
and Bob McCurdy - he knew
every
veterans'
step
taken,
and
all
groups
knew
every
step
taken
and every thought we had.
By the time we got the bill to the
floor no one was completely happy with it but everyone felt it
was the best we could do.
This year we will hold a complete
hearing on that pension bill to find out whether or not it has
worked
it
out
would.
the
We
way
will
people
who
hold
complete
a
work
200
with
veterans
hearing
on
problems
pensions
this
thought
year.
|
We will also
hold a complete hearing on hospitals.
We have
population shifts in the country.
I doubt that veterans;
groups,
including The American Legion, know what a fight we have had over
hospitals in the past 10 years, but the hospital situation has
changed.
We finally got an agreement out of the Bureau of the
Budget with the VA in the last Congress that we would spend about
$75
million a year for 12 years on our hospital program.
We have
a physical plant across the country worth about $2 billion.
That
physical plant has gone down considerably and we need a lot of
replacements.
The hospital here in Washington is an old girls
school;
one in Florida is an old hotel,
and one in California
an old hotel.
We feel we have made a lot of progress in the
last few years in turning our hospital program around from going
down to going up.
I think in the next 12 years you will see our
hospital program improving to a great extent.
There are people
who oppose our veterans'
hospital program - if you can destroy
the hospital you can destroy the program.
I have reason to
believe that the President will approve $75
million - in fact,
there might be a little more put in.
I think the hospital program is in good shape.
review,
We
have
For
something
a number
of
else
we
years
will
I have
work
felt
on
this
that
year,
judicial
a veteran
should
have some appeal beyond the Board of Veterans' Appeals.
There
has been a very active,
a very effective campaign carried on by
some people within the VA against any kind of an appeal. I do
not know exactly what I should be; I am not a lawyer, but I feel
that the Administrator should not appoint an appeals board and
then be the reviewing officer on the appeal from the appeals
board.
In the last Congress,
not being a lawyer,
I thought the
smart thing to do was pick five of the best lawyers on our
committee and let them work on this appeals board idea, which
they did.
They came up with the idea of a complete court on the
order of our claims court.
When it came before the full committee the first thing that happened was that a non-lawyer on the
committee raised cain because it did set up a complete court and
because it would require a lawyer to appear before the court.
We will take it up again this year.
Whether we will attempt to
do something I do not know.
I have no desire to try to cram
something down anybody's
throat or pass something veterans as a
whole do not agree with, but we intend to keep working on it and
if it reaches the point where veterans’
groups think it is the
right thing to do we will attempt to pass it.
This year there
will be some non-lawyers on the subcommittee which works on this.
I had no idea they would come out with a complete court but after
they did make the report,
and after reading and studying the
hearing,
I have a feeling that probably we should have a complete
court.
The Supreme Court makes a study each year of all of the
courts of the United States.
When they first met and
talked
about this they opposed it and then last
September they went
over
it
again
and
the
Judicial
Conference
of
the
United
States
approved the general idea of a veterans'
court such as we have
proposed.
We will kick that around this year
and in this Congress we may pass something,
or it will be determined to a
great degree by what our veterans'
groups come up with.
The
National Commander of The VFW appointed a study group and they
have come out opposing judicial review.
The National Commander
himself has not expressed himself but we would hope that whatever
we do would be something that is close to being unanimously
approved by veterans'
groups.
"Cold
Another item we hear a
War GI Bill."
We have
lot of this year is the so-called
a Senator from Texas who is very
201
strong in his support of a "Cold War GI Bill."
The bill which
passed the Senate last year would cost about $3 million.
The
committee,
after very thorough hearings,
came to the conclusion
that if we are going to spend $3 million on the veterans programs
we should spend it on something other than a Cold War GI Bill.
That will be taken up this year and I would predict that there
may be some kind of a very moderate Cold War GI Bill,
It is
difficult to tell a boy we sent to Korea that he is not as much
a veteran as one who served in the Pentagon during World War II,
or during the Korean War, so I think there is a possibility of
some kind of a moderate GI Bill.
mittee.
affairs
Those
It
our
will probably be the major
will probably be the most
committee
has
had
since
activities of our comactive year in veterans’
I came
to Congress.
If we
can get a good compensation bill, work out legislation to put
money in housing,
if we can be sure that a sufficient amount of
money goes into our hospital program to maintain our hospitals,
I woitld think we would have
legislation is concerned.
Mr.
Service
McCurdy asked
Life Insurance.
a rather
him
to
good
comment
on
year
as
far
reopening
as
of
Federal
National
MR. TEAGUE:
We have had hearings in subcommittee a number
of times and it has been turned down.
It has passed the Senate
four times.
They never have a hearing,
just tack it onto some
bill we send over there and send it back to us.
We are going
to
hold
hearing
again
this
year,
a full
hearing
before
the
full
committee and the full committee will vote on it and it is
according to how good a lobbying job you do as to whether it will
pags or not,
We do not run a dictatorial committee -- we will
consider a bill and the committee will vote on it.
Another thing we have talked about - I suggested to the
President that the VA run a pilot program in some of our empty
beds as far as an intermediate care program is concerned.
We had
a meeting with Dr. Middleton,
some of my staff and other VA staff
members,
and I came away with the conclusion that Dr. Middleton
was violently opposed to an intermediate care program.
We have
a program for sick veterans and we have a program for older
veterans who are not sick, but we have no program where a man who
goes into a hospital receives hospitalization and comes out still
requiring not a doctor but some kind of nursing care - there is
no place he can go. I felt and still feel that the ideal place in
our country to run a program of this kind is within the VA.
We discussed this at length.
I found out that Mr. McCurdy felt
Dr. Middleton had approved this program and I was convinced he
was opposed to it, so we will have another conference to find
out who believes what and who will do what.
I still feel the
ideal place in this country to run a pilot program as far as our
senior citizens are concerned is within the VA.
We do
not pretend to know all the answers on veterans'
blems.
We take 300 bills and try to set up a priority as to
which are the most deserving and try to go from there.
MR.
KOLENDA
(MEXICO):
I
would
like
to
ask
a
question
the residents abroad,
the service-connected veterans
abroad.
Under the present law there is no treatment
in the countries where they live.
We live abroad by
we
do
render
a
service
to
our
government,
202
render
pro-
about
who live
available
choice but
service
to
our
commerce,
to our military.
A widow who has a pension can move
abroad and continue with the pension.
I have written you on this
subject and I know there have been several bills introduced on
this subject and each time they are denied.
It makes us abroad
feel like second-class citizens.
We have service-connected disabilities incurred in war.
We have no recourse to treatment
except returning to the United States, which in many cases is an
impossibility.
It incurs great expense,
means absence from the
family,
and sometimes for a great length of time.
Unless we can
get some kind of reiief on this I know the rest of the veterans
for whom I speak residing abroad feel we are second-class citizens.
I wonder if there is something that can be done in the committee.
It has come up for a vote and has been pigeon-holded most of the
time.
We feel we are rendering service to the United States
by
residing abroad.
There is a tremendous business program the
United States is trying to push in Latin America and throughout
the world.
This is all marginal production and we are the people
who are putting it across.
Will you give us some opinion on how
this might possibly be done.
MR. TEAGUE:
I think you make a very good point.
We have
had within the committee a continuing study for the past few
years.
This year there will be hearings on legislation of that
kind.
I cannot tell you how it will come out but can promise
there will be a hearing and I personally feel you have a very
good point.
We have made quite a study of that in the past few
years.
for
an
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank
excellent
address.
you
very
much,
Congressman
Teague,
MR. McCURDY:
Mr. Teague pointed out to us that in the
hospital in Dallas there was a ward of 80 beds which has never
been opened,
the hospital
5 years old, and he thought facilities
of that kind should be used for this program.
Our Chief Medical
Director felt that to use hospital beds for this purpose would
depreciate and less the quality of the hospitals and he is opposed
to that,
So Mr. Teague says that Dr. Middleton is opposed.....
They are going to start a pilot study at the VA hospital at
Hines to make this study.
His idea is to use existing domiciliary facilities with the idea that over a period of 10, 12
or 15
years the domiciliary program would be completely phased
out and those facilities would become this secondary care.
That
is another program.
Mr. Teague is opposed to that because he
says there is a definite place for domiciliaries and does not
want to lose them.
That makes us of the Legion feel pretty
good because we have a middle of the road program passed last
year.
We passed a resolution and requested that facilities
of this kind be furnished and that we do a pilot study in five
parts
of
the
country
and
construct
minimum
facilities
for
this
type of care adjacent to general hospitals.
This would give us
the facilities for the program that we are in complete agreement
on, that we need the facilities,
and yet would not phase out the
domiciliary homes which I believe there is a place for and would
not in any way lessen the quality of the general medical hospital
care.
I have suggested to both parties that our program is the
proper compromise and let's get on the road and build these
facilities and we will be making progress.
That is what Mr.
Teague referred to, in that he and I had different understandings
on
what
Dr.
Middleton
gram and all three
I still think ours
of
is
stands
for.
They
both
stand
for
the
pro-
us have different ways of accomplishing it.
the best,
to build additional facilities.
203
It will prove we need the
the domiciliary program.
vail.
...At
11:45
A.
M.,
restoration
I hope that
the
Conference
MR. McCURDY:
We will
Rehabilitation Commission.
and
on
the
Conference
the
first
order
of
Committee
center program and also
eventually that will prewas
adjourned.
now come to order as the National
We were recessed from last Monday
business
on
we
will
have
the
report
of
Recommendations.
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman and members of the Rehabilitation Commission,
your Conference Committee on Recommendations met on Wednesday afternoon,
immediately following the
close of the day's conference session,
and they elected me the
Chairman.
The Committee
then proceeded to a consideration of
recommendations referred to it.
This included seven areas of
conference recommendations,
one from area A and six from Area
C, together with two recommendations submitted by this Conference.
The Committee
thereafter held additional meetings as
were required to consider recommendations subsequently brought
to it by the conferees.
The area recommendations are printed on
pages 18 and 19 of
your Conference program booklet.
With respect to these,
the Committee agreed upon the following actions:
Recommendation
non-service
Number
connected
1.
veterans
From
to
Area
A:
receive
Cease
to
out-patient
permit
care
in
the VA's new day care centers.
The Committee is cognizant of
the fact that
the 1960 National Convention referred three
resolutions,
namely, No. 229, 500,
and 56,
to this Commission
for study and report, which seeks to extend out-patient privileges to non-service connected veterans.
It is
understood
that the staff is currently preparing
the necessary background
reports relative to the issue raised by these resolutions.
The Committee is of the opinion that Area A Recommendation
No. 1 should be associated with these three referred Convention resolutions,
and we so recommend.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
If there is no objection
saving time, we will follow the same procedure as
vention committees.
If there is any objection to
dation by a member of the Commission,
if you will
it laid aside, we will do so and discuss it later.
we
have
no
objection,
will
be
adopted
and purely for
we do
in conthe recommenask to have
Those where
altogether.
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Recommendation No. 1 from Area C was a
proposal that the VA
modify its annual income questionnaire
instructions to pension beneficiaries
so the form need be reported only if there has been material change in income or income expected.
The Committee recommends
that this proposal be
referred to the national staff for study and report to the next
meeting of the Commission,
or subcommittee
thereof,
for further
consideration.
effect
3.
a
backlogs
visions.
problems
the
That is
plan for
now
in
the
Regional
Office
Area C
of the
to put into
excessive
Adjudication
The Committee
is aware of the numerous practical
involved in this regard;
but, recommends approval
recommendation
The
Recommendation No. 2 from
the immediate elimination
existing
American
with
Legion
the
following
urges
the
204
change
Central
in
the
Office
text
of
the
Di-
of
thereof:
VA
to take every possible action so as to bring about a material
reduction in the existing adjudication backlogs;
such action to
include asking the Congress for additional funds,
if deemed
necessary,
for overtime pay and transfer of employees as needed.
4.
Recommendation
to modify its
Office "so as
sense
system
of the
of
the
No.
3
from
present system of
to reflect a true
recommendation
Area
workload
workload
that
the
is not representative of
time required to perform
the
the
C
calls
upon
the
VA
measurement in Regional
picture."
It is the
product
of
total pending
work on hand.
the
present
workload
or
The Committee understands
that the VA Central Office is
currently giving consideration to this matter,
and therefore,
recommends
that the national staff be instructed to prepare a
full report on the problem for consideration by the Commission,
or a subcommittee thereof,
at its next meeting.
5.
Recommendation No. 4 from Area C asks that Regional
Office and VA hospital out-patient divisions be maintained at
sufficient strength so that no veteran will have to wait more
than 45
calendar days before receiving an "at once' examination
ordered on Form 2507
by a rating agency.
if
The Committee recommends
rephrased as follows:
The American Legion
extra funds from Congress
sonnel at its out-patient
time between the issuance
amination,
now considered
duced to a minimum.
approval
of
this
recommendation
shall urge the VA to seek the necessary
to provide for such additional perclinics as will insure that the elapsed
of the Form 2507
and the date of exexcessive in most offices, will be re-
6.
Recommendation No. 5 from Area C calls for the immediate
abandonment of the Automatic Data Processing system now employed
by the Veterans Administration for purposes of making payments
to VA beneficiaries.
A similar recommendation has been received
by the Committee at this Conference.
Your Committee is cognizant of the instructions given the
Rehabilitation Commission by the 1960 National Convention as
contained in Resolution No. 149. The study ordered by the Convention has as its goal the development of an official position
by The American Legion as to whether or not the VA should continue the use of ADP equipment for the payment of benefits.
The
Director of the Commission's staff has advised that this
study
is not complete but is going forward as rapidly as possible,
considering the magnitude and the importance of the undertaking.
It is
made by the
its meeting
understood
Commission
early next
that the detailed interim
to the National Executive
May.
report will be
Committee at
Your Committee believes that the many service officers of
The American Legion in attendance at this Conference have performed a valuable service to the Commission,
to our organization
as a whole, and to the responsible officials of the Veterans
Administration.
They have done so by a forceful presentation of
the problems now being experienced,
particularly in converted
regional offices,
by service officers, VA employees;
and, most
important of all, by disabled veterans and their dependents.
205
The
service
consensus
officers
of
is
to
feeling
the
expressed
ww
that
by
these
the
ADP
practicing
system
as
now
operating has resulted in poorer service to veterans at increased
costs;
and, has seriously jeopardized the morale of VA employees
who, however,
are doing their utmost to cope with the situation.
From comments heard during this Conference,
it would also
appear questionable whether the ADP system will ever be capable
of providing the prompt,
personal,
and sympathetic service that
we of The Legion have always demanded of the VA in its relationships with claimants.
Granted that the VA should achieve its
ultimate goals,
strong doubt has been expressed as to whether
the ADP system may be expected to provide service better than,
or even equal to, that previously enjoyed.
On
advised
the
other
this
solve
the
existing
date
of
fects
in
the
ADP
target
payments.
hand,
Conference
July
It is
the
that
problems;
31,
1961
system
which
our
responsible
officials
have
the
agency
elimination
of
set
timely
and
proper
great
effort
and,
that
for
the
affect
understanding
that
VA
is
these
being
expended
has
same
those
to
a
de-
benefit
officials
have also promised that no further conversions of Regional
Offices will be made until these problems are solved in the
presently converted stations.
In
view
of
the
foregoing,
your
Committee
recommends
the
following:
(a)
That the Commission staff be instructed to continue
the study ordered by Convention Resolution No. 149, with a view
to completing the necessary survey prior to the 1963 National
Convention;
(b)
That the Commission give the National Executive
Committee at its next meeting a report of the findings as of
that time;
(c)
That particular attention be given to the VA's progress in resolving the current problems, which the agency promises to accomplish by July 31, 1961;
(d)
That all Commission members,
and all Department Service Officers,
are urged to cooperate with the national staff
in the furtherance of its survey of this vital problem;
(e)
That
the
Commission
establish
the
time
of
the
1961
National Convention as its goal for the completion of the task
assigned to it by Resolution No. 194; and
(f)
That, meanwhile,
in consideration of the VA's
assurance that no further regional offices will be converted
pending the solution of problems now encountered by converted
stations through the use of ADP equipment,
The American Legion
shall
to
by
continue
to
cooperate
relieve as quickly as
disabled veterans and
with
the
agency
in
possible the hardships
their survivors.
a mutual
effort
being
experienced
7.
Recommendation No. 6 from Area C calls upon The
American Legion to endorse and sponsor a '"Cold War GI Bill' for
certain persons inducted into the Armed Forces under the Selective
Service System subsequent
to the close of the Korean Conflict.
The Committee recommends that this
recommendation be rejected inasmuch as it believes the policy enunciated by the
National Executive Committee
in Resolution No. 28 of the fall,
1959,
meeting should be upheld.
This is to theeffect that the
issue of extending readjustment benefits to peacetime veterans
is not germane to a war veterans' problem.
206
MR.
of
Mr.
Chairman,
will
MR. KLEMMETSON:
The following
during this Conference:
ceived
rent
HORTON:
8.
That The American Legion
Rating Board make-up;
suggest
the
medical
or two doctors
consultants to
only.
doctor,
to
be
you
that
aside?
recommendations
were
re-
request a review
Boards be changed
of
by
the curremoval
replaced
be made available
all Rating Boards
set
by
a
layman;
and,
that
one
to Adjudication Divisions as
for consultationand opinion
The Committee does not favor this plan and recommends rejection of the recommendation.
It is believed that medical members should continue to be an integral part of Rating Boards and,
as such, responsible for participation in rating decisions.
9.
Whereas,
the Veterans Administration has recently restated its policy that only essential material will be filed and
that material of transitory value would not become a permanent
part of essential records;
and
Whereas,
instructions have been issued to remove any duplicate or unnecessary material from claims folders when they
are examined during the process of adjudication or review or
for another purpose;
and
Whereas,
it has been brought to the attention of this Commission that some regional offices have adopted the procedure
of
removing
letters
of
transmittal
or
other
transmitting
media
at a level below the adjudicating element,
and that personnel
removing documents or material from claims folders are not
qualified to judge the potential value of some material in future
claims;
Therefore,
it is recommended that the Veterans Administration be requested to revise existing instructions to managers
of
regional
and
other
offices,
to
assure
that
correspondence
and other written material,
having a possible evidentiary value,
will not be destroyed or otherwise disposed of before consideration by those persons charged in the Veterans Administration
with
the
responsibility
of
evaluating
of claims.
(Your Committee recommends
tional recommendations):
evidence
submitted
in
support
approval
of
the
following
addi-
10.
That the Commission go on
record as expressing its
appreciation for the services rendered
by the Government officials and The American Legion and Auxiliary representatives who
by their participation greatly contributed to the success of the
38th Annual National Rehabilitation Conference;
and that the
staff be directed to send appropriate letters to these officials
and representatives.
11.
That
the
Commission
hereby
commend
the
entire
staff
of the Rehabilitation Division for the outstanding job done this
year in the planning and carrying out of the 1961 Conference.
12.
That, on behalf of the National Rehabilitation Commission,
the staff advise Mrs.
Inez Miller, widow of our late
beloved comrade, Watson B. Miller,
that the 38th Annual National
Rehabilitation Conference was officially dedicated to his memory;
and,
that she be supplied with the verbatim text of the remarks
offered
in
his
meeting
McCurdy
1961.
on
at
Monday,
February 27, 1961, and by Chairman Robert M.
the opening of the Conference on Tuesday,
February 28,
honor
by Mr.
E.
B.
207
"Pat"
Cliff
at
the
Commission's
I make a motion that all resolutions which
to be
set aside, which leaves only one, that all
approved.
CHAIRMAN
of
the
A
favor
McCURDY:
Recommendations
The
motion
Committee
VOICE:
Second
CHAIRMAN
say aye.
McCURDY:
Oppose,
is
be
that
the
approved.
are
the
not asked
rest be
recommendations
Is
there
a
second?
it.
Are
no.
you
The
ready for
ayes have
the
it.
question:
All
in
We will now take up the one resolution.
Recommendation
Number 6 from Area C calls upon The American Legion to endorse
and sponsor a '"Cold War G.I.Bill'" for certain persons inducted
into the Armed Forces under the Selective Service System subsequent to the close of the Korean Conflict.
The Committee recommends that this recommendation be rejected inasmuch as it
believes
the policy enunciated by the
National Executive Committee in Resolution No. 28 of the fall,
1959,
meeting should be upheld.
This is to the effect that the
issue of extending readjustment benefits to peacetime veterans
is
not
germane
This
since that
meeting:
to
a
war
is a reversal
resolution is
veterans'
program.
of the policy set
mentioned,
I will
by Resolution
read from the
No. 28
fall
"Whereas,
The American Legion has traditionally sponsored
and supported legislation pertaining to veterans of the periods
of hostilities in World War I (4-6-17 to 11-11-18), World War
II
(12-7-41
to
9-2-45),
and
the
Korean
Conflict
(6-25-50
to
7-27-53),
and surviving dependents of such war veterans;
and
Whereas, There is legislation pending in Congress extending certain G.I.Bill benefits to peacetime veterans;
and
Whereas, As individuals our members might approve such
legislation,
our efforts as an organization are devoted exclusively to the welfare of war veterans and dependents in the
field of veterans'
affairs,
in full accord with the Charter
granted by the Congress;
Now,
therefore,
be it
Resolved,
That the National Executive Committee of The
American Legion,
in regular meeting assembled in Indianapolis,
Indiana, October 7-9, 1959,
declare that it is inconsistent for
our organization to support legislation providing readjustment
benefits based upon peacetime service;
and further be it
Resolved,
That in the event the Congress should enact
legislation of the nature herein considered,
that the administration of such a law will not be assigned to the Veterans Administration;
and Be it further
Resolved,
That The American Legion is firmly of the opinion
that such legislation should not be charged to the field of
veterans'
benefits.
It
is
now
open
for
discussion.
MR.
HORTON:
Mr.
Chairman,
I am Clarence
Horton
from
Alabama,
and
I am the
one who
asked
that
this
particular
resolution
be set
aside.
I
holding
would like to suggest to the Commission that we consider
this resolution in suspension until such time as we may
208
have an opportunity to evaluate the various bills introduced
into Congress on this subject to see whether or not some such
bill might not be more agreeable to ourselves.
The Chairman will
recall that I am somewhat inconsistent in appearing here since
I was a member of the subcommittee which drafted Resolution 28.
However,
the
Department
of
Alabama,
and
Area
C
have
directed
a
resolution to my attention in which they emphasize the fact
that The American Legion has long stood for improved educational
opportinities
in America,
that it believes wholly and completely
in national security,
and that it is not lacking in being germane
to the purpose of The American Legion to endorse a Cold War
GI Bill provided it is
not charged to veterans' benefits.
I simply would be unhappy and reluctant to see the Commission completely reject the resolution,
and if there is a procedure whereby you can hold in suspense the resolution,
I would
like to request that this
be done.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
McCURDY:
HORTON:
CHAIRMAN
be referred to
later date.
MR.
I
move,
(GEORGIA):
McCURDY:
referred for further
further discussion?
MR.
so
you
Mr.
care
to
make
a motion?
Chairman.
McCURDY:
The speaker has regularly moved that
the Commission for further study and report at
JENSEN
CHAIRMAN
Would
KOLENDA
It
study
(MEXICO):
I
second
that.
is
moved
and
and
further
I would
seconded
report.
like
to
that
Is
discuss
it
there
that.
it
a
be
any
I
am speaking for the motion to the extent that we have the term
'war' before us.
We were all members of a hot war.
This is a
cold war.
This is a war of ideologies,
a war that we are not
accustomed to.
We fought everybody in the world and we won and
we will win this one, but, on the other hand, it is going to
take strength in our military forces and the way to get that
strength is by having these people drafted into the services.
I can only think of this little bit that Commander Burke
said last night about the Senator from California who picked up
the rules and said,
"There is nothing in here that says we have
to be fair.”
Now, this is part of my talk that I would like to expound
on just a little bit.
Our ideological war has possibly been
hotter than any war we have ever had and unless we of The American
Legion support these men who are going into this ideological war
full
scale,
we
are
likely
to meet
with
a little
bit
of
disaster.
We have continually been on the upgrade protecting our own from
the hot wars.
We seem,
at this time, to be holding back and
this is where I would support Clarence Horton from Alabama in
suspending this.
Let's see what the Congress comes up with.
After all, maybe their influence is a little bit stronger than
ours at this time.
Maybe they will come up with something that
we can back.
Again,
I would say let's support this motion of
suspense
you
The
for
the
time
being.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Is
ready for the question?
motion was carried.
It
there any further discussion?
Are
All in favor say aye; opposed, no.
is so ordered,
and that will complet
206
the
report
of
MR.
submitted
happened
the
Recommendations
Committee.
CRIDER (TENNESSEE):
I had a recommendation that I
concerning the reevaluation of Rating Boards.
What
on
that?
MR.
KEEMMETSON:
It
was
read
MR.
CRIDER:
Excuse
me.
I
and
was
adopted.
dozing
a
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Are there any
report?
Jim, that is your resolution,
further
the one
removal
Board.
of
MR.
the
doctor
CRIDER:
from
From
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
remove
the
doctor
MR. CRIDER:
adopted it.
Am I
CHAIRMAN
CHAIRMAN
to do it.
Rating
signing
Rating
I would like
out of line?
We
I will
time?
McCURDY:
on
the
Boards
the proposal
was
on
adopted
the
recommendation.
can
move
to
rejected.
talk
that.
that.
yes.
to
concede
You
on
questions on the
that wants the
report,
By the action here,
the
McCURDY:
MR. CRIDER:
considered at this
want
from
the
the
little
that.
Can
the
You
have
question
reconsideration
if
be
re-
they
MR. CRIDER:
I would ask for reconsideration of that
particular resolution.
It was my error.
I did not hear the
recommendation read, but if it was moved for rejection,
I would
like to talk on that issue,
if the motion to adopt the Resolutions Committee report can be reconsidered to allow me to discuss this particular resolution.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
I
would
rule
that
that
was
in
order
since the vote was unanimous,
I am sure that he voted for it
and it is therefore in order to reconsider it, and he has moved
that Recommendation No. 8 be lifted from the report and reconsidered.
Is there a second to this motion? A VOICE:
I second
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It is moved and seconded.
All in favor
say aye; opposed, no.
I can't tell whether just the Commission
members are voting.
Will all those Commission members in favor of
the reconsideration rise?
All right.
Now will all those opposed
to reconsideration rise?
The motion is lost.
We will now hear from Judge Alter with a report on
committee of Certificates
of Appreciation.
Judge Alter.
the
Sub-
JUDGE ALTER:
Mr. Chairman and members of the Rehabilitation
Commission:
The National Executive Committee in 1958
initiated
a program of issuing Certificates of Appreciation to retired
Veterans Administration officials who had exhibited a special
interest in liberalizing, within their power,
the benefits to be
received by worthy veterans.
In 1959,
at Minneapolis,
the Rehabilitation Executive
Committee approved a motion authorizing the Chairman of the
habilitation Commission to appoint a committee to inspect
210
Re-
nominations received from various Departments in the national
organization and recommend that Certificates of Appreciation be
issued to those individuals.
According
to the rules which were
to govern this special committee,
two nominations might be received from a Department with a membership of less than 50,000),
three from
a Department with membership of 50,000
to 100,000,
four from a Department with membership of 100,000 to 200,000,
and five from a Department with membership above 200,000.
The
committee has carefully considered the recommendations submitted
by various Departments for consideration and begs leave to report
that in its judgment the following named retired Veterans Administration officials have earned recognition from the National
Rehabilitation Commission for their interest in those veterans
who were entitled to benefits provided by law.
Your committee, therefore,
of Appreciation be issued to the
Administration officials:
Central
Office:
recommends that
following named
Certificates
retired Veterans
C. C.
Brown, Member,
Board of Veterans Appeals,
B. A..Nolan, “Ad judicator.
William Y. Hester,
Supervising Attorney-Field
Examiner.
Dee H. Beer, Chief Attorney.
Dr. Roy H. Bryant.
DeLoss I. Marken, Chaplain
Arkansas:
Colorado:
Georgia:
Iowa:
William
Maine:
Michigan:
B.
Nugent,
Manager,
Regional
Office.
Malcolm L. Stoddard, Manager, Center.
Miss Grace S. Ross, Chief, Registar Division,
Charles Rogers, Chief of Contact
Asa Hursey, Contact Representative,
George N. Kinser, Assistant Supply Officer.
Harry H. Wilson, Contact Representative
Mississippi:
Missouri:
(Deceased).
Nebraska:
Dr. Milton P. Arnhold, Rating Specialist,
Harry Hall, Agent Cashier,
Samuel D. Smith, Chief of Contact.
Frank J. Hoesch, Manager, District Office.
Robert J. Foster, Member, Rating Board.
James Howze, Chief of Contact.
L. H. Hall, Manager, Regional Office,
R. L. Popwell, Adjudication Officer.
Henry Grady Goode, Member, Rating Board,
Hillary G. Hooks, Manager, Hospital.
Pennsylvania:
Tennessee:
Texas:
Washington:
West
of
be
Virginia:
Mr. Chairman,
the report has been signed by all the members
our committee and I now move that the report of the committee
approved.
MR.
JENSEN:
I
second
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It has been regularly moved and seconded
that the report be approved.
Are you ready for the question?
All in favor say I; opposed, no.
The ayes have it.
It is so
ordered.
Thank
JUDGE
under
service
you,
ALTER:
Judge,
Thank
for the
and
I
am
job.
you.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We
a different division,
officers,
fine
have one
one that
other citation that
we are empowered to
comes
award
to
going
call
for
this
award.
211
to
on John
Corcoran
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman
Rehabilitation Commission, by the
National Executive Committee,
you
a citation
that
for
meritorious
service
and members of the National
authority vested in you by the
have authorized the award of
posthumously.
May
I now
read
citation?
"Citation for Meritorious Service.
For meritorious service
and loyal cooperation in The American Legion's Rehabilitation
program, William C. McCauley is hereby awarded
this citation in
recognition
thereof
The
Legion."
Commission
of
Mr. Chairman, with your permission I would like now to
upon for a response Mr. Ralph Scott,
the Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission, Department of Illinois.
call
American
by
the
National
Rehabilitation
MR. SCOTT:
Director John, Chairman Bob, members of the
Rehabilitation Commission,
and friends,
it is with deep humility
and gratitude that as Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission
of the great Department of Illinois,
I accept this memorial to
William R. McCauley.
Bill was my sponsor, my tutor, in The
American Legion.
He spoke the kind of language that I understood
and that we all understand.
In
Commander
the
of
early years
Illinois
for
of
The
two
American
Legion,
successive
terms,
he
was
being
Department
the
only
man to hold that distinction.
He spent his own money to come to
Washington to fight for the veteran when the only agency he had
to deal with was the old Bureau of War Risk Litigation.
He was
one of the men who sat down at Salem,
Illinois to draft the GI
Bill of Rights,
so important to the World War II veteran and
the Korean veteran.
After the return of World War II veterans
he was one of the first to welcome us to The American Legion and
said,
"If you can't lick them,
join them."
And he did just that.
He was Department Rehabilitation Chairman of the Department
of Illinois for years,
until he was unable to carry on due to
his physical condition.
He died last month at the Marion,
Illinois VA Hospital,
that he worked so hard to establish.
He
was ""Mr. Rehab'" to the end.
Again,
I gratefully
Department of Illinois.
CHAIRMAN
We
have
McCURDY:
one
Monday which is
that resolution
referred
say
thanks
Thank
you.
to
resolution
Resolution 201
at this time.
and
I
you
that
will
on
was
ask
behalf
held
John
of
over
to
the
from
last
present
MR. CORCORAN:
Mr. Chairman,
this is Resolution No. 201
from Minnesota,
as you said.
The subject is to
amend eligibility
rules pertaining to the gainfully employed when filing claim for
pension.
It is short and I would like to read the full language
of
the
resolution.
"Whereas,
the earned income of veterans before they file
claim for pension varies according to their accupations;
and
"Whereas,
the present rules and regulations pertaining to
the eligibility are unfair to the low income group, particularly
to the farmers who have a low net income;
"Now,
therefore,
be it resolved by The American Legion in
National Convention assembled at Miami Beach, Florida,
Oct. 17-20
a
212
1960,
that the eligibility rule be changed so that those having
a low income be no longer penalized because of their income or
the narrow interpretation of the words
'gainfully employed.'"
on
That resolution
Rehabilitation.
I
which
recommends
was referred to the
have in front of me
rejection
very difficult to
because, frankly,
of
this
standing Commission
a two-page memorandum
resolution.
I find
it
very,
attempt to discuss or debate this resolution
I simply do not understand its intent.
I think, Mr. Chairman,
that a more orderly way of proceeding, therefore, would be to ask Pat Cliff or some other member
from Minnesota if they have knowledge of this resolution to
present that aspect of it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
The motion was to reject, which was
seconded and then ordered held, so the parliamentary situation
is that there is a motion on the floor to reject the resolution.
It is now open for debate.
motion
dation
MR.
to
to
CLIFF:
Do.l understand, Mr. Chairman,
that that
reject was last made on Monday?
It was a recommenreject, but I have also a motion -=
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I
motion was not made.
That
care.to make, ahy
one,
MR.
motion
be
CLIFF:
Do
you
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
is made.
think you
is now up
want
me
to
It
isn't
are
for
right, Pat, that the
any motion that you
make
a
properly
motion?
on
the
floor
until
a
MR. CLIFF:
I wdll move, Mr. Chairman,
that the resolution
adopted and the recommendation for rejection be overruled.
CHAIRMAN
A
VOICE:
CHAIRMAN
resolution
the
McCURDY:
I
second
Is
there
a
second
to
the
motion?
it.
McCURDY:
It
be approved.
has
It
been moved and seconded
is now open for debate.
that
MR. CLIFF:
I think that there is some confusion probably
with reference to the resolution.
I didn't draft it and I am
not the author of the resolution,
but on the basis of experience
which we have had in our Department,
this idea
of fixing a
percentage of what a man may have earned as a basis for determining whether he is gainfully employed or not is not a desirable application.
You have an income limitation.
Why should
the income limitation based upon the interpretation of "gainfully
employed" cut down the amount of money that a man could receive
merely because he may be a laboring man or a farmer?
In discussing this with some of the others,
I understand that there are
some sections of the country that might feel this would put an
imposition on that they
don't like, but I can't see any interpretation,
How are we going to establish two rules, one for a fellow
who may have assigned his property to his wife, and has cut his
income down, who has retired,
and then one for the poor boy who
is
merely
still
not
trying
making
to
get
$1200.
along
and
213
still
hasn't
acquired
or
is
In my book the language of "gainful employment" would at
least mean that he would make that much money or more and that
income limitation pertains only to where a man then exceeds in
his income $1200 by his work,
and then he should be taken off
the roll, but to say that he can't get on the roll where he is
over 65
and has a disability required by that merely because
he
did
make
some
money,
I don't
think
is
justified.
There might be some discussion on that in view of the
fact that courts and everybody generally
recognized that the
value of the dollar has depreciated.
There may have been times
during his lifetime while, not measured in dollars, but in
purchasing power that he was making more than $1200 a year.
Now, you are running into a technicality there that we
don'tfeel is justified.
I have an instance myself where an
application was made and the fellow;s showing was not sufficient
to
show
he
was
making
$1200.
Now,
his
income
has
increased
and, of course,
if he had been put on the roll, he should go
off the roll, but why apply the limitation merely because a
man has not made that money?
That to us seems to be very,
very unfair and you are taking advantage of the fellow when
possibly that's all he has, while somebody else is sitting by
with a lot of property with his income cut down and he is
getting a pension.
It is causing a great deal of dissatisfaction
in our Department,
and we would like a clarification on that,
if the purpose of the resolution is that the limitation apply
to everybody, not to somebody who is retired, but also to the
men who are somewhat just hanging on for the purpose of trying
to do something, who should not be penalized by the interpretation of what is "gainful employment."
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
pretation of that is not
cause a single man
as you know.
What
employed of a
because he is
can
you
Then I
on the
understand,
Pat, that your interincome limitation itself, be-
go to $1800
are talking
and a married man
about is a rating
farmer.
Is that right,
gainfully employed?
that
he
can't
to
of
$3,000,
gainfully
qualify
MR. CLIFF:
I don't limit it merely to a farmer.
Anyone
who has been laboring all his life is still doing something
and he has to eat and if he isn't making that much money why
should he be penalized?
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I am just trying to clear up your
point;
that a man who
is making $1200, for instance,
a year,
any man, should not be barred purely on the basis that he is
gainfully
MR.
employed
.CLIFF:
and
That
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
MR.-CLIFR:
= That
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
therefore,
1s
cannot
qualify?
now
correct.
That
is
is
your
point?
correct.
I
understand
what
the
point
is.
MR. CORCORAN:
Pat, let's begin at the beginning on this
thing, because I am not sure that I do understand the point.
If
I understand the point,
I believe that this resolution should be
rejected.
The pension that we are talking about is, of course,
a non-service connected pension.
It is a monthly payment for
disability,
not necessarily the result of service.
214
One of the eligibility requirements
that a man must meet
before he gets a pension is he must establish he is unemployable
because of disability.
Once he has established that he gets
the monthly pension,
provided his income from any source is within the statutory limitations.
Therefore,
we
have
to
start
with
the
point
that
every
man
we are talking about is unemployable.
Now, the Veterans Administration has issued a number of regulations liberalizing the
interpretation of what is unemployability.
One of the liberalizations says and specifically mention farmers,
that where a man
is marginally employed,
that shall not prevent the payment of
pension.
They define "marginally employed".
Generally,
it
will be the sheltered type of employment or the employment where
he works less than half
the usual number of hours and receives
less than half the usual amount of remuneration.
They have, as
I said, specified farmers and have attempted recently,
as a matter
of fact,
just two months before this particular resolution was
passed by the Department
of Minnesota,
made a specific liberalization on farmers.
The amount of money that a man receives does not determine
whether or not he is held to be unemployable,
so that's why I
don't think that this resolution should be approved:
it seems
to me to say that a detemmination of unemployability is tied up
with the amount of money a man receives.
That isn't true.
I
am not sure whether I have made my position clear, Mr. Chairman.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
Is
there
any
further
discussion?
MR. CLIFF:
1: 3just want to make this point.
John, I
haven't seen that regulation.
'1 am sorry that I haven't, but
the term used,
as I understand it, is "gainful employment."
Now, you recognize employment,
don't you?
Yet, in the other
place you say he must be unemployed.
You have "gainful employment: in the Act.
If it is gainful,
then in our language he
should
be
making
that
much
or
more,
and
if
it
isn't
gainful
he isn't making that much or more and if they are putting
the interpretation that he must be unemployed, why is the
"gainful employment' there?
in
term
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I think those of you who are here and
heard this case come up specifically when we had the panel will
remember at that time in answer to the question he said if those
are all the facts, he would be entitled to send it in.
That is
what John was getting at, that we don't want to tie unemployment
which is one of the basic things,
to any amount of money because
there are others that may be taking as much as $1800 and that
still get it.
I remember a case that was appealed on a fellow
in Michigan that owned a little grocery store.
It was one of
those little family grocery stores where he and his wife both
ran it on one of those 12 or 14-hour day propositions and they
barred him because he was running that little business and
we sent that in and they said that because he was making something like $1500
a year,
and was
living on it, he
was substantially unemployable and gave him his pension.
So we
know
of many cases where they have been liberalized in the interpretation and there are adequate regulations covering it.
If
question?
there
A
CHAIRMAN
any
further
voice:
Yes.
McCURDY:
discussion?
The
question
215
Are you
is
to
ready
approve
for
the
the
resolution.
All those in favor
solution is lost.
say
aye;
all
those
opposed,
no.
The
Now, we have a brief report from Vice Chairman
on the organizational meeting of the Subcommittee on
Milton.
re-
Appiebaum
Aging.
MR. APPLEBAUM:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
We met Monday
afternoon,
as we announced at the first meeting of the Commission,
with Director Bird.of the Economic Commission, Cecil Munson of
our
staff,
Joseph
Holzka
of
the
Economic
Commission,
Clint
Knight and Ross Foust of our Commission,
and myself,
of course,
we have all had the benefit now of our people from the President's
Conference on Problems of the Aged and Aging and I think we of
the subcommittee,
as well as yourself, must agree that we have
in the Veterans Administration a very extensive program to help
the veteran who is getting older.
I think there are
Veterans Administration
has
promoted
and
things that
program and
carried
on
for
care of his particular problems.
committee that the problem of the
exclusive problem when it appears
of public
the
in
aid
the
veteran
to
him
the
handle
in the
Legion
and
take
We, therefore,
feel in the
aging veteran is a mutally
that it is a general problem
aging.
of
field
are provided for
in the work that
We are, however, pursuing the various matters that come
under the purview of both Commissions, Economic and Rehabilitation,
and we will by the time of our spring meeting be able to make
some definite recommendations.
We are a recommending committee.
We are a committee,
not a Commission,
and our recommendations
will go to the Commissions and to the NEC.
If we complete our
studies in time we will do that.
I do want to say this because
I get
into
a field
where
I have
had
to depend
a great
deal
on
the professional and detailed studies that have gone before
my work and the work of my subcommittee.
I want to say I have
had to pick up a lot of information and get the benefit of other
people's studies.
I find that our particular subcommittee perhaps is going to make recommendations or do our best work where
we don't solve the problems before us in terms of aged and
aging.
This is merely a catch-all for a great many particular
problems that we in Rehabilitation have considered under the
headings of employment,
housing, pensions,
compensation,
hospitals,
medical
care,
and
loans
to
people
who
have
expectancy,
for example,
than the loan officers
they ought to have for good loans.
That is the
thing we want to examine carefully,
but we will
a great
many
of
the
problems
referred
to
us
in
a
shorter
life
and banks think
very detailed
hope to solve
terms
of
other
longer
they
problems and other solutions.
I don't think anybody ever feels
really old.
I know when I reached my age, I previously thought
I was going to be a pretty old man, but I can see
I am not, so
I am just beginning to know something about what I am doing.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
The
talk.
trying
MR.
to
APPLEBAUM:
do, Bob.
That
older
gives
you
they
get,
the
an
idea
of
what
we
are
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank you, Milt. Right along that line,
the VA has just put out this book which is a very interesting and
fine book, "The Aging American Veteran and the National Economy."
216
Since they were over
and we have a supply
they will be up here
that
would
you all
ing.
like
look
at
here yesterday,
they have gotten the books,
now, so that all of us
may have a copy and
on the table when we adjourn for anyone
to
have
it
because
one
of
it
these
is
books,
very
and
I
informative
recommend
and
that
interest-
Now, we have one more order of business and that is the
report from Area
Chairmen with respect to future meetings and
I would like to quickly have the report of these Chairmen.
Area
my
MR.
report
A.
THOMAS W. BYERS (CONNECTICUT):
I
with the Director, John Corcoran.
CHAIRMAN
MR.
BYERS:
CHAIRMAN
Area
McCURDY:
You
filed
it
in
have
already
filed
writing?
: Yes.
McCURDY:
Thank
you.
B.
MR. CHARLES E. JACKSON (DELAWARE):
A meeting was held of
Area B on March 2.
It was decided to continue our policy of not
having an Area B Conference each year unless the Chairman or a
ma jority of the members felt there was a need for one.
In such
case, we would request permission from Chairman McCurdy to hold
a conference.
gE
We also reaffirmed our position that we are not
opposed
to Area Conferences as such,
if the respective area feels
some good will
come from these conferences.
CHAIRMAN
Area
C.
MR.
W.
McCURDY:
W.
Thank
WADSWORTH
you.
(ALABAMA):
The
of Area C reveals we want to continue
area and called by the Chairman as to
CHAIRMAN
Area
D,
MR.
J.
R.
McCURDY:
LAIRD
Thank
(IOWA):
D will
not
hold
members
of
the
McCURDY:
Thank
you.
NEVADA):
E,
JOHN
LOUGARIS
(RENO,
our
Chairman,
we
have
delegates
in
the
area
con-
sir.
the
MR.
of
the
Area
Area
absence
of
C meeting
place.
of
ference unless the majority
that one is necessary.
CHAIRMAN
you,
poll
the Area
time and
decided
an
area
Mr.
Chairman,
not
to
have
decide
in the
a
conference
in the coming year.
If at the discretion of the Chairman,
he
decides to have a conference we will have one, provided that will
be highly attended.
Otherwise,
we will not have a conference.
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
Thank
you,
217
John.
You have all had an opportunity to read the report of the
Insurance Advisory Board.
That report was just received at the
meeting on Monday.
Does someone care to make a motion regarding
the Insurance Advisory Board?
MR.
JENSEN:
COLONEL
I
move
MURRAY:
I
it
be
second
adopted.
it.
CHAIRMAN McCURDYY:
It has been moved and seconded
report of the Insurance Advisory Board be approved.
Is
any discussion?
A
motion
VOICE:
that the
there
Question.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
was carried.
All
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
anything further that he
in
favor
say
aye;
opposed,
no.
The
Does any member of the Commission have
would like to present to this meeting?
MR. KOLENDA:
Most of you heard my question directed to Mr.
Teague,
and you heard his answer.
There is an absence of a mandate from the Convention in this respect this year.
There has
been a mandate since 1952
and for some reason or other,
this
year there has been none.
We will see that there is one made at
the 1961 Convention, but meanwhile,
I would like this Commission
to instruct the Washington staff to follow through on this and
give information necessary to passage of any legislation favorable to this type of program on service-connected disabled
veterans residents abroad.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Let me interrupt you to say the way
to do that is to say that "I move that we approve the action"
you want taken and get a second and we will put it to a vote
and then we can have it passed and effective.
It is not in
effect at the present time.
like
MR. KOLENDA:
to so
move.
This
is
MR.
(RHODE
ISLAND):
BROWNING
exactly
it,
Chairman
Second
the
Bob,
JACKSON:
CHAIRMAN
Is
there
any
:I.second
McCURDY:
discussion
It
on
I
would
motion.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
That is hospitalization
service-connected comrades in foreign countries.
regularly moved.
Has there been a second?
MR.
and
and
It
treatment
has been
for
it.
has
the
All
CHAIRMAN
Thank
regularly
favor
aye;
and
seconded.
Yes.
Lou,
I wanted you to stop while you were ahead.
There
also extra copies of the Insurance Advisory report available
you care to have them.. Does anyone have anything else?
are
if
I want to thank you sincerely and I also want
Reverend Bill Adams,
the Past Department Commander
who has returned to give the benediction.
218
the
you,
say
moved
VOICE:
The
McCURDY:
in
A
no.
motion
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
was carried.
been
question?
opposed,
comrades.
to thank
of D. C.,
REVEREND
ADAMS:
We
trust,
Oh,
Lord,
that
we
have
done
Thy work and will in this Conference.
As we depart, may it be
with Thy benediction so that we may return with Thy grace safely to our homes,
to our various business and professional activities,
and to our much greater service to God and Country.
This we beseech Thee in the name of Jesus Christ,
our Lord,Amen.
trip
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
home, everybody.
Thank
you,
Chaplain.
«ee. At 12:20 o'clock the final meeting
Rehabilitation Commission was adjourned.
* kkk
k kkk k
219
Have
of
a
nice
the National
The following is the transcript of the Joint Sessions of
Commission and Committee Members and Delegatesto the National
Commander's Conference:
WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
MARCH 1, 1961
. . . The Joint Session of Commission and Committee Members and Delegates to the National Commander's Conference convened in the Congressional Room, Hotel Statler, Washington, D.C.
at
9:00
a.
m.,
Rehabilitation
give
Mr.
Robert
M.
Commission,
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
the invocation.
McCurdy,
Chairman
of
the
National
presiding.
I
will
call
on
our
National
Chaplain
to
REVEREND MOSS:
Our Holy Father, we thank Thee for these
days together, days of inspiration, days when we find again that
The American Legion is planning well for this country that we
love. We praise Thee, Oh, God, for its officers and leadership
and
ask
we
We
hear
this
thank
blessing
and help
Thee
report
for
from
his
our
devotion
Commander.
to
duty
and
pray
continued
upon him.
Guide us, we pray Thee, during these
us to sense the importance of this, our beloved
zation, and
this decade
the life of this
of decision, for
CHAIRMAN
McCURDY:
great country as
we prayed in Thy
This
year,
we
days
organi-
we go forward to
Holy Name, Amen.
in California
are
very
proud indeed that we have the distinguished and outstanding
National Commander.
I can make a long Speech about my warm,
close personal friend,
Bill Burke.
I believe that he speaks
himself
by
calling
this
great
Conference
together
for
the
for
first
time in a Commander's Conference to coordinate our program with
all our committees and commissions in an endeavor to really make
contribution
to our country,
Bill,
I am just happy to have you
here.
We of the Rehabilitation Commission certainly feel highly
honored that you come here this morning and talk to us along with
your other committees and commission.
National Commander Bill
Burke.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Bob.
Ladies and gentlemen,
my comrades,
it is
pleasing to me to
see a majority here this morning because I agree with the great
Benjamin Disraeli that a majority is more convincing than the
best
of
oratory.
This
was
brought
home
to me
rather
silenced
and
the
program
and
future
forcefully
in Massachusetts
the other night, where after addressing a meeting of the Department
in Boston,
I never received such an ovation.
I was called back to the podium on three separate occasions and
someone in the rear of the room kept shouting,
"Three cheers for
the National Commander."
When
the
hall
was
finally
Chairman,
the
Department Commander,
asked the man in the rear of the hall what
he was attempting
to do, he said,
"Three cheers for the National
Commander for wearing his uniform."
I mention this to you because
it 1s particularly pleasing to see American Legionnaires,
better
than 2,000 strong, meeting in our nation's capital for the first
time with the major committees and commissions of The American
Legion,
in addition to transacting our normal business,
addressing
themselves
to
the
over-all
policy
220
of The
American Legion.
I think this is particularly appropriate at
this time when we begin a new decade of American history with
a new Congress and a new Administration.
set
As
forth
you
the
know,
in
fact
that
the
program
the
future
which
is
of
before
our
you,
we
organization
have
cannot
be distinguished from the destiny of the American people and
therefore, we believe that it is only proper that we address
ourselves,
in addition to our own parochial problems,
to the
problems of both our national organization as an organization,
and
the
American
people
Therefore,
reviewing
for
we
as
believe
ourselves
out
a
people.
that
of
we
our
can
42
make
and
more
a
contribution
years
of
by
history
how we can make a contribution
to the future of our country.
Therefore,
I have asked these committees and commissions to meet
jointly here in Washington.
I thank particularly the Legislative
and Rehabilitation Commissions for their willingness
to meet
here at one time and to make the sacrifice of some of their
normal prerogatives
in order that the work of our organization
may be advanced.
I thank the other committee and commission
Chairmen for the inconvenience which meeting here at this time
of
time
the
of
I
out
and
year
has
would
came
like
up
House Veterans'
American Legion
for
imposed
meeting.
a program
in
upon
them
particularly
such
to
strength
Affairs Committee
presented to that
for
the
coming
as
year.
opposed
thank
to
those
yesterday,
to
their
of
you
appear
normail
who
turned
before
the
at the time at which The
committee its recommendations
I have asked particularly that you come together here this
morning because in addition to transacting the normal work of
your Commission, we have prepared a guide list, and a check list,
and a series of questions which have been submitted to each
Chairman of a committee or a commission in order that tomorrow
afternoon when our Program Study Committee meets it will be
possible for the Chairman of each committee or commission to
briefly report to that Program Study Committee in order to afford
them guide lines for their work in charting our policies,
and
our programs,
and our organization for the years just ahead,
and
that they will have the counsel and advice of the Commissions
here assembled in terms of how they see their future goal, how
they see their job, and how they would like to see their Commission and the Division reorganized or reemphasized.
Therefore,
in addition to your normal work,
I ask that
you set aside a little bit of time while you are here in order
to assist your Chairman in preparing the recommendations which
he will support and will report to the Program Study Committee.
In addition to that, we are attempting to tighten up, to
streamline,
to gain new impact, for The American Legion on all
fronts.
As you well know,
there will be no
problem which will
face The American Legion in terms of next Congress which will be
of more importance than that of the recommendations which have
been made and will be made in the area of reorganization of our
defense establishment.
For your information,
therefore,
I have checked and I find
that we have no clear mandates in this area, with the exception
of Spike Kelly's demand that we reorganize and provide for a
single catalogue,
but that this
is an area which affects a number
221
of our committees and commission.
I have,
therefore,
appointed
a group of distinguished Legionnaires under the Chairmanship of
Past National Commander Preston Moore and the Vice Chairmanship
of George Craig,
and on the Committee are the Chairmen of th~
particular committees and commissions affected,
including Econo-
mic, Security,
Naval
Affairs,
Military
Affairs,
Air
and
Space,
and in addition thereto, have secured the support of men who
have had the background in the defense establishment,
including
our Past National Commander,
Louis Johnson, Paul Griffith,
and
Perry Brown.
We have other members of that committee,
but
essentially,
they are addressing themselves to the question of
what contribution may The American Legion make to the thinking
of our country in the area of defense reorganization and national
security.
This is the first time we have gathered everyone together
in this sort of a meeting.
We are bound to have some loose ends
and many of the loose ends are due to the fact that in a sense
we become a larger meeting than we anticipated.
Our banquet now
is just in excess of 1600.
Better than 400 Members of the Congress have accepted our invitation to break bread
with us on the
night
of
the
second.
There are actually no adequate facilities for a banquet of
that size
in Washington.
Even some of the halls which could
handle it under one roof,
cannot do so properly because of other
considerations,
so we have tied together all the rooms available
here at the Statler by a system of closed circuit television and
monitors,
and we hope and we trust that it will be a good,
and
a proper,
and an adequate method of putting together a banquet
of this size, and this scope.
I would point out to you that, while,
of course,
all of
us could not end up being front row center,
the manner in which
the banquet was organized and the priorities established were
set up on your behalf by your Department Commanders and Adjutants
at their meeting in Indianapolis in November at which the priorities were established by means of a drawing,
so that you have
no one to complain to but the Gods of Fate and the Gods of Chance,
if you are not front row center.
I am pleased to announce to you this morning that for the
first time this year,
after a late start,
a late Convention,
and
a lot of hard work in. the Department,
the membership of The
American Legion is now 5,000
ahead of a similar date last year.
I thank you for your participation and I invite your
comments.
Jim Watkins is here if you need specific information,
although I would suggest if it is not something that you need
immediately,
that you check our national headquarters just
across the street if you do need your tickets,
information,
or anything of vital importance,
the staff under Billy Hauck and
under Jim Watkins are there to assist you and be of
help.
I thank you for being here.
I believe that by our combined
efforts we will bring a new impact,
a new vitality,
and a new
freshness to the work of The American Legion.
I believe that
when we finish our work the President,
the Congress,
and the good
people of Washington will have known we have been here.
Thank you.
panel
to
the
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
to take questions
Commander.
If
It has always
from the floor
not,
you
may
222
all
been the format
if anyone has a
go
to
your
own
of our
question
several
meetings.
ov. + «AT 9:25
a. m., the
Joint Session of CommissSion and
Committee Members and Delegataes
to the National Commander's
Conference was recessed.
. .
223
THURSDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
MARCH 2, 1961
. . . The Joint Session of Commission and Committee Members and Delegates to the National Commander's Conference reconvened in the Congressional Room, Hotel Statler,
Washington,
D. C., at 3:30 p. m., Mr. Robert M. McCurdy, Chairman of the
National Rehabilitation Commission, presiding.
. .
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Will the Chairmen of all commissions
come forward and sit on the platform, please?
Will you all be
seated?
This is the time and place set for appraisal of the
work and of the commissions who are participating in this conference.
We have here today to furnish us our inspiration and
to appraise the results of this first Joint Conference our
National Commander.
Bill, we are happy
National Commander,
Bill
COMMANDER
BURKE:
to hear from
Burke.
Thank
you,
offer
an
you
at
Robert,
this
time.
and out
of
Our
no
lack
of confidence in the work of the committees, but with a prayerful thought for the future, I would ask you
to rise and our
National
Chaplain
will
REVEREND MOSS:
growing awareness of
invocation.
Almighty God,
these days, of
ference, of the importance
of this fair land in which
of
we
we thank Thee for
the importance of
the
this con-
The American Legion in the life
live.
We thank Thee for the skill
and the vigor of its leadership.
We pray that the impression
made here may redound not only to our good, but to the good
of our Nation and thus to the good of the world.
Be Thou in
our midst.
May that spirit ever guide and bless us in
all
things,
in the name of our Lord, Amen.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you.
My comrades,
at our opening session,
as you know, we
assembled here our major commissions not only to conduct their
normal policy and administrative work, but likewise to give some
attention to recommendations
to be made to the Committee on
Program
and
Policy,
At
this
time,
therefore,
I will
call
on
the
Chairmen of the principal Commissions which have met here.
If
their reports are in written form, I would ask them to submit
them to the National Adjutant at the table to the right and to
give
this
Martin
minute
the
committee
and
for
the
benefit
of
its
Chairman,
McKneally,
our Past National Commander,
a three
precise statement on the contents thereof.
I would call therefore at this time, Mr.
Chairman of the Rehabilitation Commission.
Robert
Mr.
to
M.
five
McCurdy,
MR, McCURDY:
It will De a little difficult to give such
big speech in such a short time.
I have chosen the subject to
report on in keeping with the theme,
"The American Legion in
America's Future,’ and the
sub-theme of our Commission,
'Aging
With Dignity."
The National Commander's is a great theme and
our particular sub-theme directs our attention to many great
a
problems.
of
all
You have heard in the course
the male population over 65
224
of our deliberations that 05 %
are now veterans,
and that 63%
over the
peculiar
age
and
of 65
will be veterans in 10 years,
definite problem for veterans.
so
it
is
a
The problems,
as outlined in our Commissiom,
fall into
three general groups:
economic, medical,
and social and recreational.
There are many subdivisions of these.
In the
economic group we must assure adequate income,
insure pension,
compensation,
insurance,
social security,
employment.
We should
consider taxes,
too - many of you do not know that a person
retired over 65
oftentimes can get more than $5000
tax exemption.
Housing
and
homes
are
another
problem;
for housing and homes where the
ference and material aid in the
income groups, or for financing
many
laws
aged can receive material
financing or building for
of nursing homes,
etc.
there
are
now
prelow
As to medical and hospital problems, we all have devoted
our lifetime to the protection of the veteran in his medical and
hospital problems.
These problems have grown with age and so
they are going to become more challenging to us in
the future.
In our conference here this week we have heard of the gradual
change that is taking place in VA; they are now starting a test
on the change to restoration centers,
rehabilitation centers,
something to provide intermediate care in a restoration program.
We must insist that these programs,
and particularly the programs for our comrades, will be continued and improved.
The social and recreational division is a great field
for
The American Legion.
You must have facilities; we have to have
a place where our older veterans and our older citizens can
discuss their problems,
discuss their community programs,
keep
Ain touch with legislation,
be available for volunteer service,
continue their education,
and enjoy some of the benefits of old
age.
There is a solution that we all may help and participate
in, I believe.
If you solve the veteran problem you are solving
a big portion of the problem of the county also.
Let's not say
that the veteran problem is a small segment;
it is
a large segment, but because it is a large segment perhaps it is
the opportunity for the greatest community service program that The
American Legion has ever undertaken.
I am going to specify in just one instance,
and demonstrate
how you might do this.
In thinking over this program,
after hearing all our
fine speakers on the subject,
I thought about my own
18th District in California.
We have 36 Posts,
33 American
Legion club houses.
There is only one club house that is used
daily,
the rest are used for meeting and special events.
I
wondered if it would not be a dynamic and challenging program
to
make
our
club
house
a
rallying
point
for
our
older
people.
We
had a
committee meeting four years ago in Pasadena Post and
they became interested in this subject.
They were ahead of their
time, because they saw that we had unlimited talent,
unlimited
ability in our older folks but there was no facility and no
opportunity to be together and discuss their problems - they were
sort of lost in the community.
They formed a committee and propositioned the city.
I had the privilege of selecting an architect
and supervising the construction of a $175,000
club house in one
of our nice parts for the
aged.
When this was done we got the
Junior League to appropriate $75,000
over the period of five years
and they took over the management of it under "Senior Citizens,
Incorporated."
They now have a place to play cards, dance, have
a band,
all the arts and crafts,
and the latent talent of our
community has been restored and has
made itself a voice and an
active interest.
225
United
but
Just consider, with our thousands
States, what a thing we could do
for
all
our
older
citizens
and
in
of club
for not
turn
for
houses in the
only our veterans
our
country.
I
believe that this would be a constructive program in keeping
with our basic theme.
"The American Legion in America's Future."
Thank
you,
COMMANDER
Comrade
Commander.
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Robert.
I was just present at Bob's retirement and I can
you that he expects to be more active since retirement
fore. You now know why the great Irish playwright said
a shame to waste youth on the young.
Bob, in your case
not been wasted.
assure
than bethat it is
it has
I present to you Jerome F.
National Legislative Commission.
of
bers
Mr.
MR, DUGGAN:
Mr.
of the Auxiliary,
Commander,
capable
tions.
going
we
filed
Duggan,
the
Chairman
our
Commander , my fellow Legionnaires, memand friends of the Legion.
Heretofore,
with
you and
with
the
Chairman
of
your
committee the necessary answers to your series of quesHowever,
I find that since coming into the room we are
to have
to
ask
leave
to
amend
them
because
of
the
appoint-
ment of a special committee to make a report tomorrow morning.
This special committee informs me that they
have come up with
a different
thought and a different idea concerning the matter
they were pledged to study,
and I think after we act on that
we will file an amended report with Martin McKneally,
Past
National Commander and Chairman of this committee.
We have
attached to the answers a report concerning legislation and we
of the Legislative Commission welcome this cpportunity to give
you in point of figures what we have been trying to do.
ments
The
in
first
the
question
past
five
dealt
years.
with
was
what
were
the
accomplish-
In 1955
your Legislative Committee had 210 resolutions
referred to it, either by the National Convention or the fall
or spring meetings of the National Executive Committee.
We
achieved a percent of passage of the legislation out of the
210 resolutions of 19.4 per cent.
In 1956
we had 129 resolutions referred to us.
We achieved a point of percentage in
passage by the Congress of 54.28
per cent.
In the 85th
Congress,
the first session,
1957,
we had 175
resolutions
and we achieved a percentage point of 10.40.
In the
second year,
1958,
we had 145
resolutions referréd and we achieved
a percentage of 47.58
per cent.
In
achieved
We
1959
we
had
a percentage
were only
151
resolutions
point
successful
of
referred
12.
with
18
of
those
to us
and
we
matters.
In 1960 we had 157
and we were able to accomplish the
passage of 38, attaining a percentage of "22.20,
and this year,
thanks to surveillance by various convention committees and
scrutiny by the National Executive Committee, we are down to
98 resolutions and we are hopeful that we will be successful.
I might say to you that the slogan
"Legislation is Everyone's Business,"
is
226
that we have
not original
adopted,
with your
Commission.
The title came into being many years ago through
the thinking and ability of the National Chairman of the Auxiliary,
a distinguished member of the Missouri Bar.
We have used it
occasionally,
We intend to use it hereafter as much as possible.
It is our thought that legislation does affect everyone, whether
you are a veteran or not.
After all, we are all subject to the
laws of the Nation,
the laws of our city,
and the laws of our
state,
and,
of
your
birth
for
did
We do want to take this opportunity to thank everyone
the aid and assistance.
We could not accomplish what we
accomplish without the assistance of the Legion and particu-
any
suggestions
larly
the
consequently,
up
to
the
Auxiliary,
to forward
them.
consideration
degree.
Thank
to
you
we
welcome,
to
our
assure
on
you
undoubtedly
very
behalf
you
almost
from
the
time
death.
and
in
fact
Commission,
they
they
will
will
we
ask,
please
receive
prove
of
if
you
feel
free
the
utmost
aid
in
have
of
some
much.
COMMANDER BURKE:
why over the years The
average in the area of
Congress of the United
ganization
affects
of
offer
We
and
it
time
of
I will say that
Room or the following
now but it will assure
Thamk you, Jerry Duggan,
and now you know
American Legion has had such a high batting
consent and favorable consideration by the
States of the recommendations by our or-
the
veterans
of
our
country.
thé music you hear from the Congressional
room behind may be an inconvenient sound
a better program tonight.
I will present to you the
Commission, Mr. C. D. DeLoach.
Chairman
of
the
Public
Relations
MR. DELOACH:
Mr. Commander,
Chairmen of the National Committees, distinguished guests,
and fellow legionnaires,
at the
outset, Mr. Commander,
I would like to point out to you,
to your
panel up here,
that the National Public Relations Commission will
not take a back seat to any other Commission in The American
Legion.
We are a little bit loud, poor but proud, but we have a
great deal of pride and I think one of the finest compliments,
without throwing too many flowers at ourselves was paid yesterday
by the National Chairman of another commission who said, Gentlemen,
your commission certainly has caught on fire."
I wish to assure you, Mr. Commander,
that it will continue
to catch on fire and keep burning or rolling,
or else there will
be many changes.
As to the accomplishments of the National Public
Relations Committee,
certainly they are not as many as we would
want, not as many as we need; we have just gotten started.
We do
have, however,
the faint beginning of a humanitarian image which
speaks
so
softly
of God
and
love
and
of
The
American
Legion,
That
image has not yet been created to its fullest length.
We have a
long way to go.
Hardly over 30 per cent of the American public
at the present time know of the humanitarian program of The American Legion despite the great work you do from the standpoint
of
child welfare,
aid to needy widows and orphans, veterans,
etc.
We have to capture the remaining 70 per cent if we are
to continue our "Aging with Dignity."
We congratulate our
National Commander and the National Advisory Committee for the
program regarding accent on youth.
We want to add to that program and bring as much of it to the attention of the American
public
227
as
we
possibly
can.
Speaking
again
of
the
image
of
The
American
Legion,
since
the movie
"We Who Serve" was created and it was produced under
the National Commander who was serving as National Public
Relations Chairman at the time, we have had over 7000 showings.
We have over 50
television stations in the United States
and of
that 50
this movie has been shown in every one of them.
The
movie has now been reduced from its original time down to ten
minutes and it is
still rolling a great deal and will continue
to roll in your various communities.
We would like to hear from
you and we urge you to write to us and let us know where we need
to fill in the gap by showing this particular movie.
We have
come up with a new gimmick or a new project,
as you might call it,
entitled "Project 61."
It is
a clipboard,
a board that is a
slide board that shows you various programs of The American Legion.
Regardless of what kind of speaker you are, for the simple sum of
a little over $89 you can get this and become a grand speaker for
the great benefit of The American Legion.
We will be very pleased
to
answer
any
questions
in
that
regard
What should we do in the future?
There are a great many
things that we want to do in the future.
We need a better coordination of public relations among The American Legion on a
wholesale basis.
At our national headquarters of The American
Legion,
none of the Commissions of course,
is autonomous,
and
neither should they be, but at the same time if you have any
public relations problem that is sorely troubling:
you, whether
it may be rabbits in South Carolina or some other particular
program,
let me say to you that it is a problem of the entire
American Legion.
Any problem affecting any post which may be
tagged with it is still a problem for the entire American Legion.
with
We want to help you with
you and
we want to decide
over-all
good
of The
American
it.
We want to
on the national
Legion
what
we
plunge into it
basis for the
can
do
for
the
best
benefits of our organization,
but we do need coordination.
Our
meetings for the past several days have been attended by over
75
people.
Our luncheon yesterday we think was a great success.
We had some of the outstanding personalities of radio,
television,
and the newspaper world attending that particular luncheon.
I
am sure that many of you who are here today heard the very visibly
emotionally disturbed Quentin Reynolds in his great sincerity
when his voice rang,
speaking of the book he has recently written,
"The Tomb of the Unknown.'
How he loved The American Legion and
how he respected you for your great humanitarian acts,
and I am
sure you heard Dave Brinkley and saw the National Commander present an award to Mr. Robert Sarnoff,
the Chairman of the Board of
NBC.
I am sure you at least know of, if you did not see, the
very distinguished personalities
we had there who came to pay
homage and tribute to you, The American Legion.
We know that
90 per cent of the people in the United States are in sympathy
with us for what we stand for, even though, as I have said previously, perhaps only 30 per cent know of our great humanitarian
programs and the heart which makes The American Legion beat.
But at the same time
we have to win over the remainder and we can
do that by instituting the various programs that we hope to get
your
approval
Relations
for
from
Division,
COMMANDER
BURXE:
time
to
time
Thank
you
Mr.
Thank
you.
228
in
the
National
Commander.
Public
I now present to you the gracious Chairman
Relations Commission, Mr. Emilio S. Inglesias.
of
the
Foreign
MR. IGLESIAS:
Mr. Commander,
ladies and gentlemen,
the
National Commander in a recent speech stated that the nature of
our organization cannot
be separated or distinguished from the
destiny of the American people in this decade of decision,
that
there is a demand for a redefinition of national goals and purposes,
and that veterans have a part to play in this role of
redefinition.
We are an organization which was formed as a direct result
of war and
therefore have an acute awareness of the dangers that
can result from a faulty foreign policy.
Now to direct ourselves
to the questions which were referred to the Commission.
One, we
feel the outstanding accomplishment of our Commission in the past
five years is that we have managed to conduct the affairs of a
ma jor standing Commission within a most limited budget and without a regular full time staff.
At the same time we have been
able to formulate a foreign policy program through these years
which has been adopted by The American Legion as being in the
best interests of our nation and its people.
I would propose the establishment of a full-time staff,
thoroughly trained and well qualified on the subject of foreign
affairs,
in order to function properly on a par with the other
major commissions in this increasingly complex and vitally important area of international relations which directly affects
the security of the United States.
If I were Commander I would
consummate this during my administration.
Because this Commission
has no staff it is unable to project or plan any future programs.
However,
the members of the Commission maintain a continuing
study of current world events and international affairs.
Regular correspondence
is impossible under our present
situation.
Members of the Commission receive notices of Commission meetings and reports of Commission and convention committee
actions.
There is a limited amount of correspondence between
the Chairman and the members of the Commission.
Efforts to promote the policy of the Commission are carried out by most of the
members in their respective departments with several of them
serving as Department Foreign Relations Committee Chairman.
We
encourage each department to create such a committee if they
have not already done so.
The greatest extent of The American
Legion is that, as the largest veteran's organization in the
world, we continue to remind the American people of the futility
and hopelessness of war and the need for constant vigilance
against any effort to undermine our American way of life or to
impair in any way the security of this Nation.
The greatest problem we have is the inability to sell our
program not only to the American people as a whole, but to
thousands of our own members.
Again,
as with the answers to
several of the previous questions,
the lack of a staff makes
it
extremely difficult to properly prepare our resolutions and
their supporting statements other than that which,
again,
is done
by the individual members of the Commission.
We are unable to
conduct any public relations program as a Commission.
The last question which I will answer to you is that it is
more important today than ever before that the non-veteran and
the veteran alike have an intelligent understanding of a sound
foreign policy program in our relations with the other nations
229
of the world.
At this time, we wish to acknowledge
the Director of the Washington Office and his staff
assistance,
for without it we could not function as
Thank you
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
and thank
for their
a Commission.
Emilio.
I appreciate the difficulties of working with improper
staff.
I don't promise you any great relief on that because,
as
you know, were you Commander you would find likewise that the
Commander proposes and the Finance Commission disposes.
However,
I am pleased to report to this extént: That in 1956
the reorganization committee of the National Executive Committee,
under
the Chairmanship of William McKinley recommended the establish-
ment
within
the
framework
of The
American
Legion
of
a research
division.
This was likewise a recommendation of the Program
and Policy Committee which is presently in session here today.
The funding for such a research division was approved today by
the Finance Commission,
which means that there will be available
to The American Legion,
its Divisions,
and its Commander,
the
abilities of a research staff that can provide for us the sort
of information which is needed in the formulation and presentation
of the programs and policies of The American Legion.
I
Lewis,
would like to present to you at this time
the Chairman of the Economic Commission.
Mr.
George
T.
MR, LEWIS:
Mr. Commander,
Fellow Legionnaires,
members
of the Auxiliary,
and friends of The American Legion and the
American Legion Auxiliary,
the Economic Commission as the committee
working within the framework of the Commission indicates,
deals
with such problems as housing,
the committee head by the capable
Sylvan King of Washington, D. C.; Veterans Preference, with the
committee head by Ray McEvoy of Massachusetts;
Agriculture and
Conservation,
head by Doug Kramer of Idaho; Labor Relations by
Al Chamie of California;
Employment by Elmore Torn of Texas and
of course we acknowledge thanks to our capable Director, Clarence
Bird, and to his staff,
and my thanks to all of the member of
the Commission.
My tenure as Chairman of the Commission,
as most of you know,
is short-lived,
only since the November meeting,
although it has
been my pleasure to work on some of the other national commissions.
Anything that I have to say this afternoon which might sound a
bit like throwing roses at the Economic Commission and its affiliated committees,
I want you to know that I take no credit for,
but give full credit to the other members of the Commission,
and
Committees,
and the staff.
I think that if I had to pick out
some one or two things which have been
the greatest accomplishments of the Economic Commission in the past five
years,
it would
be their dogged day-by-day efforts to obtain the Veterans Preference rights for the vetérans that were intended under the law
and their consistent work to retain those rights guaranteed by
the GI Bill of Rights,
to keep that program activated and to
extend some of the provisions of that program which you know have
been extended recently.
I think that the work that the Commission has done with the
Veterans Employment representatives throughout the country has
been a great service to veterans.
They have
placed on an average
each year approximately 1.5
million veterans in jobs and when you
multiply that number by the amount of average earnings shown in the
230
statistics
for
the
average
veteran
you
are
pouring
a
tremendous
amount of money into our present economy.
The work of the Commission is perhaps less dramatic than some of the others and
perhaps is more important in times of recession than it is in
better times.
We hope that the recession will not continue long
enough and with sufficient severity to make the Commission any
more important in this respect than it is.
It is true, though,
that if we do not have jobs for veterans and do not have decent
housing for veterans,
and if they, constituting
the large segment of our population that they do, cannot lead lives of dignity
in their respective communities, won't be able to pay their
American Legion dues, and won't be able to be of any real service to their fellow man;
then the work of this Commission is
most important.
In conclusion, Mr. Commander,
we came to the conclusion in
answer to your 17 questions,
one of which was "What is the most
important accomplishment
of The American Legion,' that if we
could have answered these 17 questions in five minutes,
that would
have been it, so in conclusion may I say without taking further
time,
that we hope to have some additional recommendations which
we would like to ask permission to file at a later day.
Thank
you very much.
COMMANDER BURKE:
I think in your behalf I will be proud to
tell George and the other Commission Chairmen that they are doing
very well in presenting not only the work of the Commission here,
but what they foresee as the program of the future. As someone has
said,
I will have to make a long speech because I didn't have time
to prepare a short one.
I am pleased that the Commission chairmen
have taken time to prepare and present their ideas and recommendations in such succinct form.
P.
I would like to present to
Drummond,
the Chairman of the
you at this time,
National Security
MR. DRUMMOND:
Commander Burke, Chairmen
present, distinguished Legionnaires all:
of
Mr. Addison
Commission.
the
Commissions
That America must remain militarily
strong for the foreseeable future must be apparent to every Legionnaire in this room.
Without sufficient strength to discourage aggression, whether
it be a brush fire on freedom's perimeters or an all-out nuclear
war, the United States faces a grim future indeed.
Your National
Security Commission and its committees believe sincerely that
The American Legion bears a great burden of responsibility in the
future courses of action that this Nation chooses.
We believe
that the American people,
if fully informed, will willingly make
any sacrifices necessarily required for our
national security,
I use the phraseology "sacrifices necessarily needed" advisedly,
meaning that we did not believe that any one believes in writing
a blank check.
Without
strong military forces in being we become
subject to international blackmail.
To us it appears imperative
for every level of our great organization to come alive to its
responsibilities.
If Communists are dedicated to their cause,
can not we sacrifice in still greater measure for a system that
recognizes the omnipotence of God and the dignity of mankind?
yearn
It is
for
not
freedom
enough
and
our help to cast off
bodies and spirits.
to
love
contain
and
evil.
respect
as
Millions
we
do,
of
people,
desperately
the bonds of oppression which bind their
America and its dependable allies have a
221
who
need
compelling
will be no
ness of the
ing us from
challenge:
more.
Each
Combat communism or eventually freedom
of us must do more to create an aware-
diverse and deadly nature
within and from without.
of
We
the conspiracy
do not believe
is enough, but it is a beginning upon which
programs to further strengthen America.
even
The
if
it
American
serves
Legion
our
God
must
and
serve
Country
today
in
we
must
in an
time
build
uneasy
of war.
assailthat this
the
peace
Now, Mr. Commander,
to that short, brief statement,
I have
attached a lengthy memorandum answering the some 17 questions
that
you
submitted,
COMMANDER
the
sir.
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Mr.
Drummond.
I now present to you Mr. William Brennan,
Membership and Post Activities Committee.
the
Chairman
of
MR, BRENNAN:
Mr. Commander,
and distinguished ladies and
gentlemen,
Commander Burke in his preface to the program for this
conference has very aptly said, "The American Legion knows well
that its purpose and its future cannot be distinguished from
the destiny of the American people."
It is equally true that the Legion activities of rehabilitation,
legislation,
national security,
economics,
foreign
relations,
and public relations cannot be separated from membership.
For them to succeed, membership must succeed.
I am sure
it is for this reason the question of membership has been placed
on the agenda by your National Commander.
What is the national
membership situation today?
As
of
the
close
of
books
last
night,
national
membership
was 2,180,000,
a loss of 43,000 compared to the same date last
year.
Have the 1961 membership results been encouraging or
disappointing?
Definitely disappointing.
On January 1 membership was 90,000 behind.
On February 1 it was 70,000 behind.
You ask a very simple question.
What occurred to enable Commander
Burke to report a 5000
gain yesterday?
Very frankly,
a drive was launched to have all available
cards transmitted by departments to give us the best possible
membership picture,
the best impact for this important conference.
The results show it worked,
but these efforts distort the picture.
They borrow from tomorrow for a good picture today,
and from our
best judgment on membership we are still 50,000
behind.
What are
the reasons for the lag?
Some say a late convention,
a very
minute reason.
The 40 & 8's?
Possibly in a few local areas.
Some say the growth of the World War I veteran organizations.
A
small possibility in a few areas.
Economic conditions? Development?
I cite you two examples.
In the Gary area of Indiana and
the Niagara Frontier area of New York, both areas directly related
to the steel industry and both economically in trouble, membership
is ahead in 1961.
Lead in our britches at the Department,
direction and post
level?
Definitely yes, and 99/100ths per cent of the reason.
What are we doing about it at the National level?
On January 6 we launched a program that possibly some of you
know something about,'""Operation Welcome Back."
Our statistics
indicate in the past three years over 700,000 members have failed
232
to re-enroll in our organization.
Pilot tests have indicated
that if these drop-outs are contacted one-third will come back
in.
On January 6, National Commander Burke asked all posts
to prepare drop-out lists.
This was phase 1 of Operation Welcome
Back.
He also sought the all-out backing of each department
and asked that the departments report at this conference the
number of posts in their department participating in Operation
Welcome Back and the total number of names on the drop-out list.
Here are the results;
43 departments reporting:
Number of
posts participating to date, 3120, or 18
per cent of our 17,000,
This is interesting.
Total
of
our
posts,
number
of
names
on
the
drop-out
list
of
18 percent
151,000.
Phase 2 of Operation Welcome Back is being launched today.
Its objective is to
have all drop-outs on these lists contacted
personally between now and March 31.
What can you do about it?
First acquaint yourself with the program.
We have given you
a copy of Advance, which is a monthly publication prepared by
our Public Relations Department that goes to your Post
Commander.
This describes Operation Welcome Back.
He knows about this
because he has received that issue of Advance in advance.
There is a sidelight on this
ing when I arrived in Washington I
this question:
question.
Last
asked 15
of the
Monday evenconferees
"Do you know whether membership is ahead or behind in
your department?’
Only one could answer the question.
And it
just occurred to me is it possible these men have made the fatal
error,
the fatal mistake of thinking you can distinguish membership, separate it, from the other activities being discussed
at
this
conference.
Lastly,
find out if Operation Welcome Back or some similar
program is being worked in your local area, if it has not become
the motivator.
We have enough men right here at this conference
to bring back 50,000
members and solve our problem.
Many departments are doing a tremendous job and I would
like to quote one.
That is Alabama.
They have tied this Operation Welcome Back to a state-wide public relations program.
They have developed some interesting TV spots,
and Commander
Albritton and Adjutant Lawson Lynn are here in the room.
Will
you stand up so they can see you?
back
If any
to your
so well
of you men want to take what they have developed
post they told me they will make what
is working
in Alabama
available
to
you.
Ladies and gentlemen,
let's back up rehabilitation,
legislation, national security,
economics, foreign relations and
public relations efforts with an all-out enthusiastic backing
of Operation Welcome Back.
COMMANDER:
Thank you, Bill.
I ask the members of this
conference for the support of the activities being donducted by
Bill Brennan, George Rulon and those that are active in the
membership picture.
As you well know, The American Legion faces
233
a
continuing
placing
year by
replace
problem
in
membership.
We
have
the
task
of
re-
virtually 10 per cent of our membership loss to us
each
death or other casualties. ' That means that we have to
almost 2,000 members annually before we break even.
As Bill has told you, we went into this year better than
75,000
behind.
Since January, we have been gradually whittling
that down.
Operation Welcome Back is an application of methods
which are used in other industries and in other campaigns to
supply, on a limited basis and on a shock program,
a device
whereby within a limited period of time, with limited resources,
and with a limited amount of personnel it will supply us the sort
of kick which is necessary to put us over in terms of gathering
back into our folds the membership needed to bring us back to our
strength
of
last
year.
That, however,
as you well recognize, will not be enough
to solve our continuing problems.
In this area, however,
I am
pleased to report as I go about the country I find that our
younger
men
have
now
had
the
time
away
from
home
and
family
to
contribute to the leadership of The American Legion.
I find
that where this leadership is present our membership is moving
ahead as are our other programs.
Before we leave here, and if
it is not available it will be within a matter of days, we have
a new pamphlet on membership which points out some of the outstanding Americans that are presently active in The American
Legion and urges on a prestige basis the affiliation of others.
I am
fundamentally
convinced
that
out
of
the
program
and
planning of this conference and out of
will bring to this problem we will not
the resolution
only solve our
in
terms
which we
membership
both as to numbers
American Legion.
of
the
of
problem
in
terms
of
breaking
even,
and
qualities
as
to
but
of
going
program
ahead
The
I would like to pay a word of tribute to the staff of the
National Organization and to the committees and commissions and
the chairmen of divisions for the work which they have put into
this conference.
This is the first time that we have tried anything on this scale,
as you know,
in Washington.
It meant that
they were faced with unprecedented problems in organization,
in
housing,
in attempting to arrange a banquet for us tonight and
in order to make available to you the sort of facilities which
this conference requires.
I know
of my
own
personal
knowledge
of
the
many
nights
which our staff stayed up in planning for this commission meeting and this joint commander's conference.
If anything,
they
have proceeded too well because tonight,
as you know, we will
have approximately 1600 for dinner with over 400 members of the
Congress
of
the
United
States.
We are using all the facilities of this hotel.
We are
tying together our various tables and rooms by closed-circuit
television with minitors.
We expect,
in addition to a program,
to give you some fine entertainment.
We hope that you will not
only find it profitable,
but entertaining and I wish on your
behalf to thank our staff for the work which they have done
and the chairmen of the commissions for what they have done in
bringing to this program their best efforts on your behalf.
Now,
I
will
present
to
you
234
the
Chairman
of
the
Committee
on Reorganization to whom the various recommendations have
been directed, Mr. Martin McKneally, who can give you some
thought as to what the work of his special committee will entail over the coming months.
Commander McKneally.
MR. McKNEALLY:
Thank you, Commander Burke.
Fellow
Legionnaires and friends,
Bob McCurdy spoke feelingly about his
program to grow old with dignity and I think that is a very
laudible and noble thing, but, Bob,
the thing that disturbs me
is whether or not you can
find some means that will stop me
from growing old so fast,
and if we have many more conferences
on the program of The American Legion,
I think I am going to
be the first candidate for that pilot study
in the various
hospitals,
the aged veterans.
I want to speak to you in terms of two committees,
one
of them The Americanism Commission,
and then,
also the special
committee review of the programs of The American Legion.
Both
of those that come under the four great ideals around which
The American Legion was formed.
review
future
more
Under Americanism we are trying to do a study job and a
job reaching back into the past and projecting into the
to make that commission and the work of that commission
productive,
more
efficient,
in producing
a patriotic
view
and also establishing a more effective voice for The American
Legion in the affairs of what we call Americanism.
The preservation of our ancient date as Americans, which is under
attack not only by communists;
now it is easy enough to pin a
communist,
but the fellow that is difficult to pin is the man
who gives the communists his special support.
How does he do
that?
He does that by denying the
principles upon which this nation was founded,
and that
a conflict of basic philosophy.
great
involves
The basic philosophy of the man who doesn't share our
doctrine of belief is frequently called logical pacifism
and
he is the fellow who says, "I don't believe it unless you show
it to me in the Testament."
We believe it because it is part
of our great faith and because we have that great belief in our
hearts and our souls, what we have to do is make The American
Legion fake this great voice the voice of the majority,
in the
field
of
these
In
trying to do this and to make this a
to the youth of America and the youth
we
have
appeals
level
two
a
conflicting
great
deal
of
philosophies.
catching
up
to
serious voice that
of the college
do
because
the
people
who had captured the minds of the youth and made them less patriotic than they once were,
in the sense that we mean patriotism
and in the sense that we must have patriotism if the United
States is to survive and to lead, have been
working fervently
since before World War II and we have not been working so well
since World War II.
So, therefore,
we have to do a raking job
in the field of Americanism,
preserving all of the programs that
have shown themselves to be valuable to this commission over the
many years that it has existed and at the same time adding new
ones.
This is not an easy thing.
It takes a great deal of time,
a great deal of study and a great deal of reading.
We will
answer the questions,
of course, because I come immediately to
the fact that it was we who prepared them,
the Special Committee
235
studying all the programs, made up of Tom Miller, Jim Powers,
Jim O'Neil,
Roy Stone, Walter Alessandroni,
and Harold Redden,
and we have as our Director Ed McGrail.
We have met frequently and have looked at every one of
the programs again and again and now we are in the pasition
of writing an interim report and preparing it for the May meeting of the NEC, making certain recommendations,
the results of
which we hope will tighten up The American Legion and make it a
more influential and much more
effective organization.
To that end we prepared this list of questions,
not for
specific or precise answers, but as guidelines which the various
commissions could use in order that they
can report to our
committee in such a way as to
give us some insight into once
again their efficacy.
We appreciate the time that
you had to
spend in answering the questions and we know full well that they
will help us do our job.
It seems to me that The American Legion is going to profit
immensely from this mid-winter conference because it does begin
to tie in with what
we are all trying to do under the various
programs and especially with this most important restudy which
has never taken place in The American Legion.
We have never
restudied.
We have never gone back to restudy the total,
composite picture of The American Legion from within.
This is something new.
Not infrequently The Legion grew,
and the various work of The Legion grew in a sort of a shrub
growth,
a Topsy-like thing,
and that resulted sometimes in a
less efficient and a less effective voice and program,
and
influence than we must have if, to get back to the area of
Americanism,
this nation is to survive with its ancient traditions and if this American Legion is to be the sustainer of
that voice of the majority.
COMMANDER
BURKE:
Thank
you,
Martin.
We have completed the reports of our commission chairmen
on time.
I wish to once again thank the Commission and those of
you who have participated in helping us and helping our Commission chart its course.
On your behalf I have paid the respects of our organization
to the President of the United States early this week.
I presented him with an American Legion button which he had some
difficulty fixing to his coat lapel.
I likewise presented him
with a program for this conference,
and without quoting him, he
expressed gratification that The American Legion was addressing
itself to the problems which concern not only veterans,
but all
Americans.
who
time
At
this time
we
have
have
questions
or
comments
a few
minutes
left.
would
welcome
we
Well, when
to adjourn.
Legionnaires have
I thank you.
«ees
p.
At
4:30
m.,
the
kkk
no
Conference
kkk ok kkk
225
questions
If
there
are
any
them.
or
ad journed..
comments
it
is