Extracted text: Proceedings of the American Legion National Rehabilitation Conference, February 28-March 2, 1956 `

Extracted text: Proceedings of the American Legion National Rehabilitation Conference, February 28-March 2, 1956 ` results

Linna_Agne
Edited Text
PROCEEDINGS
The American Legion
National Rehabilitation Conference

HOTEL

STATLER

WASHINGTON,

D.

C.

FEB. 28 & 29, MARCH 1 & 2, 1956

TABLE

OF

CONTENTS
PAGE

Tuesday Morning
February 28,

Session
1956
Call to order by Chairman Robert M.
McCurdy... ... oc oviaieie isis
es
vie et

1

Invocation by The Reverend Joseph
MacCarroll.........................

1

Introductory remarks
Foust, Chairman of

by Mr. J. Ross
the session.....

1

Mrs. Esther Carrico, Department
President, District of Columbia
American Legion Auxiliary.........

1

Greetings:

Mrs.

Frances

Executive
National

R.

Norton,

Vice

Commander

Mr. Louis G. Zindel,
Commander, District
Mr. James
National
District

|

Response,

National

Committeewoman..........

by

W.T.Holliman

Department
of Columbia...

3

D. Hill, Alternate
Executive Committeeman,
of iColumbia..............

3

Mr.

3

James

Powers........

Appointment of Conference Committee on
RecommendationSic.
cc. vsicieiois
cnc sins
Vocational

RANCHO

Tuesday

Afternoon

February

28,

2
2

Rehabilitation

4

and

ore aia iiss ee nis olin otis wtiiate a i aia

4

Remarks by Mrs. Carl Zeller, Chairman,
National Rehabilitation Committee,
American Legion Auxiliary......... ..

17

Session

1956
Economic

Commission

Opening remarks by the Chairman,
Mr.- Adolph F. Bremer.............. .

20

Presentations by Government
Representatives:
Mr. Thomas J. Sweeney, Director,
Loan Guaranty Service, VA ........

20

Mr. P. N., Brownstein, Assistant
Director, Loan Policy and
Management, VA
e ovens
nisivneisy
Discussion....... os oleivisialnioinis

21
23

Mr. Bruce Stubblefield, Chief,
Veterans Counseling Service,
U. S. Civil Service Commission....

27

Mr. Alvin M. David, Assistant Director, Division of Program Analysis,
Social Security Administration....
DISCUSSION...
vic. cicicisieieioin
sivinie

28
30

Tuesday Afiernoon Session
February 28, 1956 (Cont'd.)

PAGE

Mr. Robert K. Salyers,
Veterans Reemployment

Director,
Rights.....

34

Mr. Edward L. Omohundro, Chief,
Veterans Employment Service......

35

Mr. W. J. Harren, Section Chief,
Bureau of Employees Compensation.

37

Remarks

VA

by

Mr.

Clarence

W.

Bird

Director,

NEC....ecovvverocsanens

37

Voluntary

Services......ceseeeesecs

37

Remarks

by Mrs.

Omar

Remarks

by Mr.

W.

45

McMackin......
Korella..

46

Claims.......

49

Remarks by National Commander
J. Addington Wagner......coceeoeaecs

62

Remarks by Comrade Howard Kingdom,
National Membership Chairman........

63

Veterans and Dependents Claims
Panel (continued).....oeeecesceceeee

65

Jackson

Wednesday Morning Session
February 29, 1956
Veterans

and

Dependents

Wednesday Afternoon Session
February 29, 1956
Veterans
Panel

and

Appeals

- VA

Appeals

- Armed

INSUTANCEe.
Thursday
March

Morning
1, 1956

Dependents

(continued)...

Claims

c.cceccceenrersini,

Board

of

Veterans

Appeals

Forces

Review

Board..

vet vvernonnsssssssesssnnnns

Session

Invocation by the Reverend Joseph
MacCarroll........
vee vencceverreenns

105

Opening
Milder.

remarks by Chairman Watson
cui. ceiciovinons
ves ssnee eyed

105

Comments

on

Dealing

with

Federal

Commissions

Veterans

Programs:

Mr,

T.:0.

Kragbells

Mr.

Edward

McGrail.......coveneeese

Legislative

cero

.

106
110

Program:

Mr.

Miles.

D.

Mr.

"Cap"

0180N.

ccc

Chairman

Robert

M.

Mr.

vevenne

Charles

11

Kennedy...

Stevens

vs sivcvosicins
rsevsivsrsvvvn

McCurdy.........
on

the

Hardy

Bill..

123

Thursday
March

Afternoon
1, 1956

Session
PAGE

Remarks

by

Dr.

William

S.

Recognition

of

Comrade

Herman

Wenige..

131

Medical

Hospital

Services

Panel...

131

Meeting of Commission on statement
of area of agreement with the
American Medical Association.........

155

Awards

and

Middleton...

128

Friday Morning Session
March 2, 1956

participation sv enisioieiete

163

Remarks by the Honorable Harvey V.
Higley, Administrator of Veterans
BELaiTE. oc .eniiv civics vo cv sv stein ieee lly
Discussion.................

for

VAVS

166
174

Report of Conference Recommendations
Committee... oovvtncev
ce ole eves ely

182

Ad JOUTTMENE,

184

toi civ: eo tiiie + savin sian ss ain vision

III

TUESDAY

MORNING

February

28,

SESSION
1956

The National Rehabilitation Conference of The American Legion, held in the
Presidential Room, Hotel Statler, Washington, D. C., was called to order at nine-thirty
o'clock by Mr. Robert M. McCurdy, Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Commission.
CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
The meeting will please come to order.
This is the place
and the time for the annual Rehabilitation Conference.
I believe we will proceed and
trust that when we start the proceedings, we will get the large audience out of the hall
into this room.
First, I want to say what a great pleasure it is for me to come to these meetings and renew old friendships and make new ones.
I have said for many years that all
you gain selfishly from The American Legion are some real fine friends.
I want to greet
my real fine friends and it is, indeed, a pleasure for me to see them all again.
If
I haven't had an opportunity to shake your hand personally, I certainly want to do it
before 1 leave.

for

the

I am now
invocation

going

to

call

on

your

National

Chaplain,

the

Rev.

Joseph

MacCarroll

THE REV. JOSEPH MACCARROLL:
Before the words of the invocation, may we stand
in silent tribute to Elsie Janis, who in World War I was not only the Sweetheart of the
AEF but who through the years has given to the veterans in her work in hospitals on the
West Coast unstintingly of her time,
She passed away yesterday, and may we stand for
just a few moments of silent tribute.
(A moment

of

silent

tribute

was

observed

in memory

of

Elsie

Janis.)

REV. MACCARROLL:
Eternal God, our Heavenly Father, we seek for Thy divine
presence and guidance to be with us in the meetings that are shead.
We know that without
Thee our plans are futile, and as we would commend unto Thee this great program in which
we show our concern for those less fortunate than we, may we do it as unto God and Country.
So guide and lead us that the outcome of these meetings shall not only be
well pleasing to Thee but shall work for the mutual welfare of our comrades who still
bear in mind and body the wounds and the marks of war.
Keep us keenly conscious of our
responsibilities and of our opportunities, for we ask it in Thy name.
Amen.
CHAIRMAN

McCURDY:

Thank

you

Chaplain.

Now, ladies and gentlemen, I have to announce that the Commander has requested
that I attend a meeting with him this morning so at this time I am going to turn the
gavel over to a very eminent Vice Chairman from the great State of Pennsylvania, Mr.
J. Ross "Baldy" Foust.
Baldy, please carry on and I will pe back as quickly as possible.
(Mr.

J.

Ross

Foust

took

the

chair.)

CHAIRMAN FOUST:
My friends, I appreciate the fact that it is really a job
to step into the shoes of our most capable National Chairman Bob, but we will carry on
due to the fact that, of necessity, he has been called to the Hill along with our National
Commander, to appear on one of our most important problems.
I know under the circumstances, even though we will miss our Chairman, we will carry on here and do the best we
can and I know that the meeting will be one of interest.
It is certainly grand to see so many familiar faces here from year to year.
I believe this is the thirty-third year that we have had our Rehabilitation Conference
and this morning, to start off our program, we have with us the Department President
of the District of Columbia, the American Legion Auxiliary, Mrs. Carrico.
We are all
80 very grateful to this grand organization for their wonderful support and I am highly
honored at this time to present to you, the conferees of this conference, our grand lady
from the District of Columbia, Mrs. Esther Carrico.
MRS. ESTHER CARRICO:
Mr. Chairman, Distinguished
Guests, Delegates to this
Rehabilitation Conference and Friends:
It is a great privilege to greet you this morning
and to welcome you in the name of the District of Columbia Department American Legion
Auxiliary.
We hope your visit to our beautiful capital will be a very pleasant one and
when you return home to the East, West,South and North of this great nation, you will
have many happy memories of this >Kehabilitation Conference and your stay in Washington,
Db. C.

and

The great work which has been given to our organization by The American Legion
in which we as American Legion Auxiliary members are active, is for America's veterans,

=1-

"for the nation's children,
of our country from foreign
your service to the veteran

for the communities which make
attack and many others, all of
and his family.

up our nation, for the security
which owe their existence to

One of life's great experiences is the opportunity of serving with and for
our fellow man.
To more fully realize what a wonderful opportunity is ours and to make
our experience a true and complete thing, we must daily strive to improve our service
to God and country.
It has been said often that part of our mission on this earth is to serve with
grateful hands, sincere hearts and clear minds, to live peacefully with our fellow man and
ourselves, and in all our relations at all times #o do our utmost to show our deep and
sincere gratitude for those things which others do for us.
It is in this spirit that I greet you
American Legion Auxiliary and ask God's blessing
and decisions during this conference, to the end
grateful nation never forgets.

in

We of the American
way possible.
Thank

every

CHAIRMAN

FOUST:

Legion
you.

Thank

you

on behalf of the District of Columbia
and guidance on all your deliberations
that our veterans will know that a

Auxiliary

are

ready

and

kindly,

Mrs.

Carrico.

willing

to

assist

you

And now we also have with us Mrs. Frances R. Norton, National Committeewoman
for the American Legion Auxiliary here in the District of Columbia.
If you will recall,
she appeared here last year and gave us a very nice talk.
We are glad to have her back
with us this morning.
Mrs. Norton.
MRS. FRANCES R. NORTON:
Mr. Chairman, Distinguished Guests, Delegates to
this National Rehabilitation Conference and Friends:
It is indeed a privilege to again
welcome you to Washington.
It is most fitting that this annual rehabilitation conference
be held here in the nation's capital, where, in the Congress of the United States, the
fruits of your labors for your disabled comrades and their families are either cultivated
and blossom into legislative reality or wither and remain dormant because of the press
of other legislative business and procedures.
This is a serious task to which you have devoted yourselves through the years
and you have never faltered in your determination to see to it that your fellow man, who
took the same chances you did and who was not as fortunate, who did not fare so well,
receives just consideration for his physical or mental handicaps and his economic needs.
Rehabilitation is not new.
It was practiced over nineteen hundred years ago
when the blind, the deaf and the lame were healed by the roadside, and the hand of
friendship extended.
You are merely following in His footsteps and in that same spirit,
may this conference take on an even greater significance, and may the deliberations and
decisions of the next few days result in an ever-greater rehabilitation program, for we
are truly our brother's keeper.

a most

the

On behalf of
sincere wish for

Mr. Chairman and Mr. Kraabel,
courtesy extended me this morning.
CHAIRMAN

FOUST:

I have just
Most of
this morning.
capacity of one of our
to this conference our
for

the District of Columbia American
a very successful conference.

Thank

you

may

very

I

take

much,

Mrs.

this

Legion

Auxiliary,

may

I

express
i

opportunity

to

thank

you

for

Norton.

been informed that we have a very distinguished friend among us
He has just recently been appointed to serve in the
you know him.
National Vice Commanders and I am very happy, indeed, to welcome
good friend W. J. Holliman, who I believe might have a few words

us.

NATIONAL

VICE

COMMANDER

W.

J.

HOLLIMAN:

Mr. Chairman, Distinguished Guests, Conferees of the National Rehabilitation Conference:
I would first like to say that this honor that has been conferred upon me by you came
as a distinct surprise, and while it is true that my post had endorsed me for such an
office and my Department had graciously followed through on that endorsement, it was far
from my comprehension that our good friend, the National Vice Commander, Jim Day, was
going
to resign January lst and you were just going to give me the office almost
immediately.
Of course, you can see that I am radiantly happy and I Ho hope that I
can translate into service my gratitude to all of you for your gracious bequest to me
of this honor.

this

area

It is
of the

my happy
national

{

privilege to extend to you the warm and friendly greetings of
organization.
It is our sincere hope that your stay in the
e congratulate
you on your constructive

legislative program for
your laudable endeavors
CHAIRMAN

the
for

FOUST:

current
God and
Thank

Legion year and wish for
Country.
I thank you.

you

very

kindly,

you

outstanding

success

in

Commander.

Now we have another distinguished friend and Legionnaire on the platform,
and I am taking the privilege at this time of calling upon a grand Legionnaire and,
as I said before, a very fine gentleman, Department Commander of the District of Columbia,
Comrade Louis G. Zindel.
DEPT.

COMMANDER

ZINDEL:

Good

morning

Ladies

and

Gentlemen!

At the third national convention in Kansas City, a commission was formed.
was a committee at that time on the rehabilitation of veterans and it was established
that the policies and programs set forth by that committee are still the policies and
the programs of this Commission thirty-five years later.

It

The problems are great and the solutions are hard to find, but if they are to
be found, this is the time and this is the place, because at this time, in this place,
are gathered together the greatest group of men and ladies who know their problems, who
know what must be done and are banded together for one purpose, the purpose of rehabilitation.
I
it
to
an

has many
a former
accepted

do not know what rehabilitation means to each
meanings, but I would like to read to you what
capacity and to rights and privileges lost and
respectability.

|

and every one of you because
I believe it means:
To restore
forfeited, or to reestablish

{
|

When that is analyzed, that is why you are here, and so in closing, I want
to say that the Department officers of the District of Columbia, elected and appointed,
the paid employees of the District of Columbia, the club house and myself are yours for
the asking.
I want to welcome you and wish for you a very successful meeting.
Thank
you.
CHAIRMAN

FOUST:

Thank

you,

|
|

Commander.

Now I am very sorry to announce that the National Executive Committeeman from
the District of Columbia, Robert Bunch, is unable to join with us this morning and to
present his greetings to this conference.
However, we are particularly happy that the
alternate National Executive Committeeman for the District of Columbia, Samuel D. Hill,
is here and at this time I am very happy to welcome to the platform our good comrade
Hill who is the alternate National Executive Committeeman from the District of Columbia.

Rehab

MR. JAMES D. HILL:
Mr.Chairman and Distinguished Guests
Conference:
As your Chairman has said, Bob Bunch is not able

HH
Ii!
I

and Members of the
to be with us today.

i

hi
|

May I say in his behalf, and on behalf of the District of Columbia, how very
proud we are that the National Rehabilitation Conference has met this year, as always,
in our Department.
We know full well here the importance of rehab to The American Legion.
We know it is the Legion's No. 1 program, that the Legion will stand or fall, or will
live or die on the effectiveness of the work that you people in the rehab field do,
and we know that the reason for the Legion's preeminent position as compared with other
veterans' organizations is because of the work you folks do in the rehab field.

|
i

All the rest of us in the rank and file bask in the reflected glory of the
works that you accomplish.
We are proud to have you here and we salute you.
We hope
that you will always come back to Washington for your annual meetings.

instruct
sorry we

CHAIRMAN FOUST:
Thank you, Comrade Hill, and I would be remiss if I didn't
you, if you please, to go back to our good friend Bob Bunch and tell him how
are to learn of his illness and we certainly wish for him a very speedy recovery.
Now,

I would

like

to

present

at

this

time

our

own

Jim

Powers

who

will

{
Hl
|

respond.
|

Comrade

Powers!

|

|

MR. JAMES E. POWERS:
Mr. Chairman, Madam President, Mrs. Carrico, Mrs. Norton
and Alternate Executive Committeeman Jim Hill:
It is a pleasure to reply to your warm
greetings and welcome here.
Let me assure you that no group in The American Legion recognizes more completely the seriousness of this meeting and the need for active participation in this meeting than do those attending at this time.

I
|
|
|

We are faced with the problem that today an insidious attempt is being made to
change the entire philosophy of dealing with those rights of veterans who have won our
wars.
That is being propaganized suddenly and consistently through media that are difficult
to counbat.
There is one group capable, there is one group with the ability, there is

|

“3

|
|

|

i

|

i

one group with the knowledge to combat this successfully, and that is this group of
trained rehabilitation workers who, across their desks daily deal with the affairs of
veterans in every field of activity in this great nation.
In this day and age when
we in The American Legion must hew to a line between those extremists who say that the
social advances have taken care of all the needs of veterans without a program for
veterans, and the other people who say that the entire treasury should be turned over
to the veteran, we have the great resources of this group of trained workers who ask
only that to which the veteran is entitled, that to which he is entitled because of his
service to his nation in time of war, be granted to him fully and freely and not as
charity.
That group is represented ably and competently by those in attendance at
this great conference of the rehabilitation workers of The American Legion.
Let me assure
you people in the District of Columbiassho
have welcomed us so graciously here that The
American Legion will never be satisfied with second-best for the veterans of our nation.
The American Legion will never be satisfied with anything less than a complete carrying
out of the responsibilities of this nation toward those men and women who have so readily
come forward and who have so readily served this nation in the times of its greatest’
crises,

Department

It
of

is
D.

a pleasure
C.

CHAIRMAN

FOUST:

for

us

Thank

throughout

you,

the

Comrade

nation

to

be

with

you

here

in

the

Powers:

There is one thing I wish to announce at this time and that is, the registration desk and the fine people who are manning the desk out there, and will be for the
remainder of the week.
They are serving us most efficiently and we want you to feel at
home and at liberty at all times, particularly after today, to appear at the registration
desk and to learn what, if any, of your friends might be here from other states or within
your state.
We want you to become acquainted with each other while here.
There is one
sure way not to overlook any of your friends who might be attending the conference and
that is to avail yourselves of the desk out there and the fine people who are doing the
work for us.
At

this

time,

Conference Committee on
Chairman, W. H. Colley,
Rulon, of North Dakota,
yourselves appointed.

I

would

like,

in

the

name

of

Recommendations will be Lewis
Jr., of Tennessee, William F.
and Louis S. Dennis,of Maine.

our

Chairman,

to

tell

you

that

the

S. Sloneker of California,
the
Grund, of New Jersey, George W.
You gentlemen will please consider

We are right on schedule.
As a matter of fact, we are a little ahead of
schedule, which is a good sign on the first day of the conference, and we are now going
to start the discussion with the V.R.& E. discussion leaders and those from the Veterans
Administration who might be present.
I would ask that they come forward if they are here.
I would like at this time to introduce the discussion leaders of this panel.
If they will come forward at this time, we will be prepared and ready to go when the VA
officials arrive.
May I ask the following to come to the platform:
Wilton B. Mackall
from Florida, Assistant Department Service Officer; Joseph D. Grady, Ohio,Department
Service Officer; and Leslie J. Crotty, New York, Regional Service Director.

panel

CHAIRMAN FOUST:
We are very happy now to proceed
subject, Vocational Rehabilitation and Education.

Before we introduce those of the panel who
own Chief of Vocational Training and Education, Cecil
stand.
I want you all to see and know him.

with

our

will carry on,
Munson, who is

very

important

I would like for
on the platform,

our
to

I have already presented our discussion leaders for this morning.
Our discussion will be led by W. B. Mackall.
At this time I am very happy and privileged to
present to you the Director of the Vocational Rehabilitation and Education Service,
Mr.
S. H. Coile.
I am asking him to introduce those who have accompanied him here this
morning.
Mr. Coile!
MR. S. H, COILE:
Mr.
are Mc. C. H. McCully, who is in
who is principal staff assistant
are Mr. Bronaugh from the office
Medicine and Surgery.
MR.

that

I am

MACKALL:

Ladies,
happy to

Thank

Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen:
With me this morning
charge of our Counseling Program, and Mr. L. W. Goulde,
in the office of the Director.
Also on the platform
of Legislation and Dr. Hildreth from the Department of

you,

Chairman

Foust.

Co-Legionnaires and Distinguished Guests:
First I would like
see so many Legion hats in the audience this morning.
I hope

lye

to say
there are

more

of

them

as

the

conference

continues.

It is my pleasure to assist in bringing you the Vocatiomal Rehabilitation
and Education panel, and I would
like to introduce my colleagues, Mr. Joseph D. Grady
from the Buckeye State of Ohio, and Mr. Leslie J. Crotty from the Empire State of New York.
It seems to be the general feeling among many people that the G.I.bill for
education and training is a program slowly fading out of the picture due to the fact that
July 25, 1956,
has been set as the end of the World War II training, Public Law 346,
and Public Law 16 for our disabled.
Those of you who are familiar with this program can
see that this fading picture feeling is as wrong as wrong can be.
The extension and changes in Public Law 16, the Vocational Rehabilitation Act,
and the great number of dischargees daily getting out of all branches of the service with
a possible 36 months of eligibility under the Korean G.I. bill, Public Law 550, are definite
evidence that the program is still very much alive.
The record will show that, percentage-wise, more Korean veterans are taking
advantage of this Korean Bill than did their brother veterans of World War II.
It may be
the Korean veterans are younger and it may be for other reasons; but the fact still remains that there are over 800,000 veterans presently in training under the various laws
as administered by the Veterans Administration, and the field of eligible veterans is
growing daily.
It is hoped that each of you will carry home the answer to your questions,
words of advice and instruction which will be forthcoming from members of this fine panel;
and a message to your Departments that we are rehabilitating back into community, state
and nation, our brothers-in-arms, and as long as one remains who is desirous and eligible
for receiving the benefits we of The American Legion will not and cannot let it be a
fading picture.
During this conference we will
am reminded of the little thought for the
God fashions us for better things.

have troubles, we
day that troubles

will have
are often

arguments, and I
the tools by which

We will now move into the first question which comes from Area C:
'That a
veteran held to be not feasible for training because of an NP disability be examined by
a qualified psychiatrist and be allowed to enter training if the psychiatrist states that
the veteran would benefit from training."
Mr.

Coile:

Mr.

McCully:

Would

you

care

to

handle

that?

Mr. McCully:
Questions as to the medical feasibility of training are yegolved
through consideration by the Vocational Rehabilitation Board working as a group. In the
case of a veteran with an NP disability, the psychiatrist normally serves as a member
of the board and brings to bear on the question his interpretation of the case, including
his recommendations based upon his own examination of the veteran if he deems it necessary.
His opinion and recommendations normally carry great weight in action by the
Board and are generally followedby them unless modified by other factors such as the
impracticability of providing the only type of training considered suitable for the veteran.
While it is the purpose of the Board to have the veteran enter suitable training as soon as it is feasible for him to do so, the training must give promise of leading
to employability.
Training which does not hold such promise could not be approved because
of the specific obligation in the law to restore employability.
MR.

MACKALL:

MR. CRIDER,
give me the regulation
psychiatric problem?

Mr.

Crider,

would

you

like

Tennessee:
Yes, sir, he just
which instructs your board to

to make

any

comments,

sir?

doesn't know the facts.
have a psychiatrist sit

Can you
in on a

MR. McCULLY:
We do not have a specific regulation that states that a
psychiatrist will always serve on a board when there is a veteran with an NP disability,
but in our Manual we do recommend that medical specialists whose knowledge is germane to
the case at hand be called upon to assist in the deliberations of the board.

Office

is

MR. CRIDER:
not following

Then,
that?

would

MR. McCULLY:

Yes,

if it is the case we would welcome

MR, CRIDER:
.I want to
Division the suggestion of a high
chiatrist sit in. on a psychiatric

you

like

the

information

that

your

Nashville

Regional

such information.

explain that I have in writing to the Chief of the VR&E
official of the Veterans Administration, that a psyproblem.
This was in regard to a particular case in

-5e

|

|

)

which I asked that an order for a decision be made instead of a surgeon sitting in on
a psychiatric problem.
This was refused and I was told it wasn't in order and they didn't
think it was necessary.
I will tell ‘you now that Nashville is completely out of line
with the rest, although from the conversations I have had, I don't believe that it is true
throughout the United States.

question

I think it would
being presented.

be

in

order

for

it

to

be,

and

that

is

the

reason

for

the

MR. McCULLY:
In terms of policy that I believe is pretty generally understood,
our Regional Offices are expected, and normally they welcome, the services and seek the
services of medical specialists.
I think there may be one or two Regional Offices in
remote areas where they may. have great difficulty in getting the services of a psychiatrist,
either within or outside the VA, but there are very few such areas, if any, and we will
be happy to take steps to see, if that policy is not understood, that it is better under=stood.
MR. MUNSON:
We have had this problem presented in a few cases.
I think Mr.
McCully should know, and he probably does, that this eituation.does exist.
We have had
doctors on the hospital staff very clearly and definitely recommend that a veteran being
discharged from the hospital be entered into training.
The Regional Office Board, including the doctor on that Board, definitely disagreed and there was no way of overruling
him.
Mr. McCully, has anything been done to adjudicate the counseling differences
which might arise in the hospital and the Regional Office?
This occurs when training
is recommended for a veteran being discharged from the hospital and the Regional Office
board refuses to approve training because of an NP disability.
MR. McCULLY:
Well, Mr. Munson, we have in our Manual provision for the manager
of the hospital to request the services of a counselor for the Regional Office on a
liaison basis, and where such requests are made it is mandatory upon our Regional Office
to comply with the request.
The intent of such liaison service is for the counselor
from the Regional Office to go and sit with the people in the hospital who are dealing
with the case and to try to work out with them the necessities that are incumbent upon
us when we enter a veteran into training under Public Law 16 so that those things will
be clearly understood and so that when the veteran does come from the hospital, if counseling has proceded along a given line, it will have taken those necessities into account.
Now, I think there is some indication that this liaison service has not been
going on in all areas to the extent that we would like to have it go on.
The pattern is
there for it and I believe, Mr. Munson, my comments here are specifically with reference
to the thing you bring up and it is intended that through such liaison service such

problems

will

be avoided.

:

I think, also, I might say that it is perfectly apparent and understandable
that the viewpoint of a physician might differ somewhat from the viewpoint of those who
have responsibility for administering the law because, understandably, the physician
is interested in any type of activity that may tend to aid the veteran along to recovery,
and he might envision the veteran's going into some kind of activity that would have good
therapeutic results, but would result in little promise of leading to employability.
Where such a situation holds, I think it is clear that there might be a difference in
point of view, and it is chiefly to bridge that gap and gain a mutual understanding that
we have at least provided the scheme to have liaison services by a counselor from the
Regional Office and at the hospital on a régularly recurring basis when it is requested.
MR.

MACKALL:

Are

there

any

further

questions

or

comments

from

the

floor?

MR. KORELLA, Missouri:
I would like to pose my question for Mr. Coile.
Since
it so happens that there are a number of veterans who are held to be medically unfeasible
for training and have been so considered by the Psychiatric Commission, and since the
delimiting date is 7-26-56, what provision is being made by the Veterans Administration
to take care of those people in the event that they should become medically feasible
between now and that date or hereafter?
I am intensely interested in that because I have
Louis that have me worried and I believe that those men are
same as any other veteran.

some fifteen cases
entitled to a fair

in St.
break the

MR. COILE:
If the disability and the medical infeasibility arise because
of a service-incurred condition, the provisions of Public Law 610 of the 83rd Congress
permit us to extend the period of training under Public Law 16, for as much as four years,
that is, up to July 25, 1960.
In other words, if the inability of this man to receive
training has been because of medical infeasibility from the service-incurred disability,
the July 25, 1956 date will not apply but July 28, 1960 will apply.

«Gs

i

|

MR. MACKALL:
Are there any further comments from the floor?
If not, we will
move on to the second question:
'In highly industrialized areas where the trades are
unionized, a $310 limit imposed on job and apprentice trainees under Public Law 550
eliminates a majority of otherwise eligible veterans wishing to pursue jobs or apprentice
training.
In view of this, why shouldn't the VA give consideration to revising this
ceiling upward?"
=
I would

like

MR. GRADY:
spend a fey moments in
appreciate what we are

to

call

on my

colleague,

Mr.

Thank you, Mr. Mackall.
In
giving a little background,
trying to do.

Grady
order to
and I am

from

Ohio

for

his

comments.

get to this problem, we
sure with that you will

must

This is the story of the expansion in Cleveland and the Great Lakes area,
Cleveland, of course, being the best location in the nation.
The story of progress and
expansion of business in the Cleveland and Great Lakes area can only be explained by
hindsight and projecting the future.
The St. Lawrence Seaway Project should be fully completed in 1962.
This project
will be in operation at least as early as 1959.
Cleveland and other Great Lakes cities
are optimistic because the Seaway wiil add some 8300 miles of deep water coastline, opening a new door into the industrial heart of the United States, Canada and the East Coast
ports.
A trip portraying the picture and the impact of the Great Lakes ports from Duluth
to Chicago, Detroit, Toledo, Cleveland, Astabula, Erie, gives you an idea of the areas
that the Seaway Project will expose, not only at the ports but by the tremendous depths
in miles projecting into the basic'mining to the steel mills and suppliers of all industry in the area.
We touch lightly on the advantages and anticipate the influx in excess of
15,000 families within a radius of 50 miles of Cleveland.
Within a radius of 500 miles
of Cleveland, there live approximately 86 million people, or roughly one-half of the
entire population of the United States.
With the expansion of industry, it would only
be normal to anticipate an influx of migratory people that would normally follow industrial
expansion in the area.
This sounds like the ballyhoo of the Chamber of Commerce of Cleveland, but,
rather ladies and gentlemen, it is only insight to bring out the inequality of Public Law
550 that places the income ceiling at $310 per month for veterans on-job training.
We charge that the law, inflexible at the ceiling of $310, is depriving veterans
in the highly industrialized
areas of benefits which they rightfully should have. In
fact, the veteran who may have entitlement to a maximum of 36 months on-job training may
receive a training allowance for only the first period of his apprenticeship.

The contracts in effect will give him far less than the basic training allowance
when we consider the maximum payment per month.
We feel that this is unjust and the law
should be changed or amended to correspond with the minimum basic apprentice wage and
high-cost-of-living allowance clauses in order to give the veteran that which he has earned
in entitlement by virtue of his military service.

;
The question that I pose, No. 2 on the agenda, I will not repeat.
Why shouldn't
the Veterans Administration give consideration to revising this ceiling upward?
There are
some 15,000 cases in our Cleveland Office.
It is one thing, of course, to criticize and,
when criticism is made, to offer what one thinks should be the answer.
We think the basic
beginning journeymen's wage should be established rather than an income ceiling.
We offer
that the earned wages and training allowance should equal that of a journeymen's wage,
thereby giving every veteran the entire benefit of training allowance under Public Law
:
550 while training under contract.

Let us consider the steel industry, the building business and their associated
trades, sheet metal workers, tool and dye makers, millmen and cabinet makers, which are
only a few of the heavy industry trades that are peculiar to the Great Lakes area.
Veterans in training under Public Law 550 are being deprived of the full entitlement for
training allowance.
We can cite a few examples of the inadequacy.
For instance, a carpenter's apprentice's basic training wage is $288.55 and the
training allowance in this case would be $21.45, but you can see that at the endo f six
months this eliminates him from receiving any more money from the Veterans Administration
in training allowance.
This is a case ofthe veteran, by virtue of the $310 ceiling, being
deprived
of 28 months' training time.
All of the trades that we have mentioned are in
the same category and all of them have lost anywhere from one year to two and one-half
years' training time under the current law.

not

kept

We further maintain
abreast of the change

that the law and Veterans Administration Regulations have
in the economy in the highly industrialized areas and benefits

a

due
the

veterans
times.

are

being

short-changed

by

placing

an

income

ceiling

not

commensurate

with

Industry is losing interest and in many cases is contacting the Veterans Administration, informing them that it is no longer interested in enrolling an apprentice under
Public Law 550.
When we consider the adjustments of awards that in many cases during the
second period of training reduce the training allowance to $1.50 per month, this hardly
makes it worth while for the employer to continue the program.
The small amount of money
that the veteran might receive, from a $1 minimum to $10 per month, is hardly worth while
for anyone concerned.
Consider the administrative costs to the employer and the Veterans Administration,
and we believe that we can arrive at justification
for either eliminating the ceiling,
as we suggested, or making it sufficiently high for all veterans to benefit under the
program.

to

this

I believe
question.

that

covers

it

and

we

would

like

serious

consideration

to

be

given

MR. COILE:
I think it is plain, Mr. Grady, and I am sure it is plain to this
group, that we are dealing here with a specific provision of the law.
I judge, however,
that the sense of the question is: Why doesn't the Veterans Administration recommend to
Congress that this specific amount be raised in the law; that is, why doesn't the Veterans
Administration recommend amendatory legislation?
I think fit probably be worthwhile to recall that the ceilings were introduced
into the law originally back in 1946 because of a tendency that had become manifest at
that time for job training to be given in certain types of managerial and professional
occupations that had not, therefore,been acquired through the process of job training.
In fact, there was grave doubt as to whether or not bona fide training situations existed.
I think that the concept of the ceiling was carried over into Public Law 550 because the
committees of the Congress desired that there not again be encountered problems and abuses
such as were becoming manifest back in 1946.
Moreover, the report of the committee of the House indicates that it was considered that at some point in a man's earning capacity, it should be considered that he
was devoting the principal amount of his time to productive work as distinguished from
receiving training, thereby justifying the discontinuance of his education
and training
allowance as would be done in a part-time course of institutional training that constituted less than half-time full load.
I think, also, that there needs to be considered the fact that all of these
amounts, whether they be: payment:amounts or ceiling amounts, are based upon averages, just
as all veterans' benefits are based upon averages.
Therefore, an amount that may be low
in one section of the country may be entirely adequate in another section of the country,
or perhaps a little bit on the high order in another section of the country.
Actually, no disposition has been manifest on the part of the Veterans Administration to seek amendatory legislation in this regard because the need therefor has not
been sufficiently demonstrated, and when I say that, I do not mean to dispute the statement that in areas such as mentioned by Mr. Grady, the wage scales are at a level that
causes the discontinuance of the training allowance early in the veteran's training program.
That, I am sure, is the fact and we recognize it to be such.

i
i

MR. MACKALL:
Thank you, Mr. Coile.
As Mr. Coile has explained it, it is a
part of the law.
You have heard my colleague, Mr. Grady, and the Chair will entertain
a recommendation if there be one, either from the floor or from my colleague, Mr. Grady.
MR. GRADY:
The recommendation, as I pointed out, I think is rather pointed.
When we consider this same law which governs institutional training, we can also see an
injustice there involving income of the individual trainee, whether it is institutional
or on-the-job training.
One who is doing institutionalized training can earn $1000 a
month if he so chooses, but the man who is in on-job training is being penalized by the
escalator clause of his trainee wage and the allowance of the Veterans Administration.

|

Therefore, Mr. Chairman, if it is in order, I'would like to recommend that this
question be given serious consideration, that it be discussed by the National Rehabilitation
Commission to determine what disposition they should make of it.

in

favor

MR.

MACKALL:

MR.

DYAR,

You

Illinois:

MR. MACKALL:
please signify

have

heard

I will

the

recommendation.

second

It has been seconded.
Is
by saying "aye"; opposed.

-8-

Do

I hear

a second?

discussion?

All

it.
there any
Carried.

of

those

{

CHAIRMAN FOUST:
of our conference from year
consideration that you will
Resolutions

Committee.

I

Please pardon my interruption here.
It has been the policy
to year that when you have recommendations to propose for
please draw up your recommendation and present it to our

assure

you

if

you

write

out

your

recommendation

in

the

future

and present it to our committee , it will be given due and careful consideration at our
meeting on Friday morning.
That has been the policy in the past and I believe you will
agree that we should follow this procedure throughout this conference.
MR.

MACKALL:

Thank

you,

Question No. 3:
'"Why
change of course to all veterans
their individual delimiting date
I again

call

on my

Mr.

Chairman.

shouldn't consideration be given to the granting of one
regardless of whether the change is made prior to or after
under the provisions of Public Law 5507?"

colleague,

Mr.

Grady.

MR. GRADY:
With this question, we again arrive at a point where some veterans
are being deprived of their benefits under Public Law 550 and the regulations which are
handed down under that law by the Veterans Administration.
There are many veterans who
do get into a course and after their delimiting date, they have a change of heart and want
to continue in some other field.
I think that after the delimiting date, consideration
should be granted and the request granted when made.
MR,

MACKALL:

Mr.

Coile,

would

you

care

to

comment

on

that,

sir?

MR. COILE:
Again
we are dealing with a specific provision of the law in
that the law sets forth two conditions under which the Administrator may approve a change
of program after the delimiting date.
In the absence of amendatory legislation,
the
Veterans Administration could not afford any relief in terms that have been recommended
in this question.
:
I know of no serious proposals being given consideration by the committees of
Congress to a question such as this.
In fact, I do not recall that any legislative
proposal has been introduced that would make a change in this provision of the law. As long
as the law remains as it now stands, the Veterans Administration would not be in position
to liberalize the regulation to accord with the proposal that has just been made.

law

and

the

MR. MACKALL:
Thank you,
Chair will again accept

Mr.
any

Coile.
Again, we are dealing with a part
recommendations from the floor or from my

from Ohio.

of the
colleague

J

There being mo further
I would like to call upon my good
two questions.

comment
friend,

on that, we will move on to the next question.
Mr. Crotty from New York, to handle the next

MR. CROTTY:
Question No. 4:
"What kind of evidence must a veteran submit
with his application for a course of training considered as avocational under provisions
of VA Regulations 1203 (1) (B) to show that the course applied for will be used in pursuit
of a contemplated business or occupation?"
MR. COILE:
Our position in respect to this, I think, has been consistent
since about 1948.
Our position is that the veteran, himself, is best able to determine
the evidence that will show the manner in which his desired course will prove of bona
fide assistance to him in connection with his livelihood.
The circumstances vary so
greatly from case to case and from course to course that the establishment of criteria
under which a decision could be reached would be a most difficult thing and we fear might
be more in the direction of a restriction than in the direction of a liberalization.

is able
will be

to
to

We think this is a matter of fact and the veteran, knowing his own situation,
decide on what evidence provide us with in order to show the use the course
him in connection with his earning a livelihood.
MR.

CROTTY:

Is

Mr.

Sanderson

of

Nebraska

here?

MR. DAWSON, Nebraska:
Thie is Dawson of Nebraska, in place of Sanderson.
What we would like to know in this case is what the VA classifies as approved or acceptable
evidence.
It might be better to set up an example where ve have a veteran in a small
town, say, five or six thousand population, where there is no photograph shop.
He thinks
there is a place for a good photography business in that town.
He has a family to support.
Therefore, he has to hold his job.
He hag to take the course by correspondence.
What
kind of evidence will the VA accept, including that of friends and neighbors in the town?
We have submitted several applications on that order and several times they
have been turned down as not being valid evidence because they say it is merely conversational evidence when we submit evidence from friends, fellow businessmen in the town
and so forth.
They aren't accepting the businessman's affidavit as valid proof.

“Je

would

you

is

MR. CROTTY:
required?

Mr.Coile,

evidence

MR.
DAWSON:
proof.

We

like

to

not

valid

would

care

know

to

what

detail

just

the

classifiesas

VA

exactly

what

type

valid

of

proof

or

MR.

MACKALL:

We

have

a

comment

from

a

MR. COILE:
Of course, it is always very difficult
to be specific in an
individual case.
All I can say is that statements of businessmen and of associates and
of the veteran detailing his expectation at establishing a photographic business
would
seem to me to be the type of evidence that we would be interested in receiving.
I don't
know what other facts may exist in the case, nor do I know the facts
in connection with
the particular course in which the veteran desires to become enrolled,but certainly
that
is the type of evidence that would be, I think, of the nature to establish
the case:
the

floor.

|

MR. LEWIS S. SLONEKER, California:
Mr. Coile, it seems to me from the comments
here, from our friends in Nebraska, that they have had a few individual problems and I
would like to ask if they might submit these cases to you?
Would you welcome such a thing?
In other words, they apparently have a case there on this photography deal.
You say it
sounds like the type of evidence you would be interested in.
Evidently they were denied
it out there.
Would you like to have it come in to you?
"MR. COILE:
That is a very good point.
Yes, we will be glad to review administratively cases that have not already been acted upon by the Board of
Veterans Appeals.
I might say that there is little to be gained in asking for administrativ
e review in a
case that has already gone before the Board of Veterans Appeals and in which
a decision
has

been

rendered

upon

the

evidence

of

would be very happy to review it, and
for corrective action to the Regional
MR.

DAWSON:

That

is

where

record.

Under

if the facts
Office.
we

are

so

stymied;

other

circumstances,

warrant

to

the

has

case

send

a

been

however,

i
!

|
|

we

recommendation

appealed

and

denied.

MR. COILE:
The mere fact that a veteran's principal occupation is reported
on a Form 214, which is the report of separation from the Armed Forces,
to be that of
farmer would not standing alone preclude favorable consideration of
a properly planned
program of institutional on farm training.
However, if an examination of other evidence
of record, including perhaps the information on Form 100 shows that
the veteran is now
or has been recently the operator of a successful farm similar to
the type on which he is
now to receive training, there would probably be justification for finding
that the veteran
is already trained in the occupation for which he is seeking training.
I recognize that these farm cases constitute considerable difficulty
in determining when a man is already qualified for the occupation that the training
is supposed to
prepare him for.
A determination is more easily arrived at in connection with some
other
occupations.
For example, in the case of a man who is already a brick mason, it
is obvious
that he should not be enrolled in a course purporting to qualify him
as a mason.
It is
expected, however, that our people will exercise reasonably sound
judgment and also will
ascertain insofar as is possible, the true facts in connection
with a veteran's previous
experience before they take definite and positive action to
deny his application.
I think there is a limit to the amount of inquiry that our officers can
do under
such circumstances but the regulation does contemplate that a man
will be found already
qualified if he has recently successfully operated a farming situation
similar to that
for which the training is supposed to prepare him.
MR.

CROTTY:

Does

the

gentleman

from

Nebraska

wish

to

comment

on

that?

MR. DAWSON:
A
you know, in our State of Nebraska agriculture is our main
business.
Many of our kids going into the Korean war went in after they got
out of high
school and were asked by the recruiting officer what their major
occupation was.
Many
times, instead of putting down a student, or something like that, they
put down farming.
The Regional Office back home is immediately, upon seeing that DD 214,
which
shows that he is a general farmer, _denieg him the training rather
than writing out to
the veteran for additional evidence and then making their decision as
to whether or not
he is eligible for training.

congidering

We maintain that the mere fact that
his age and everything, should not

a DD 214 shows
be binding and

-10-

that he is a general farmer,
the VA should write out and

—

MR. CROTTY:
Are there any further comments on Question 4?
If not, Question 5:
"Why are veterans denied a certificate for farm training because of information
shown
on Form DD 214 without an investigation of any kind being made
to determine whether or not
the veteran had actually been properly trained on a farm or in an
agricultural school?

before
to get

obtain evidence from the veteran
have denied him, it is difficult
MR.

CROTTY:

Mr.

Coile,

can

anything

be

done

to

correct

after

because

final decision,
changed.

making their
the decision

they

this?

I think that if they are denying it simply on the statement on the.
MR. COILE:
Hcwever, I might say that the statistics
Form 214, we can take some action to correct it.
show that the participation of the Nebraska veterans in farm training is much above the
In other words, the enrollment in Nebraska is one of the highest within
national average.
the country in that type of training.
We will
what, if

ascertain

be glad, however, to communicate with the Lincoln
anything, needs to be done in that respect.

Office

in

order

to
|
|

MR. BALDAUF, Nebraska:
1 would like to submit to the Veterans Administration
that we do have agricultural consultants in our communities who first pass on the application so far as the community is concerned.
The program is set up by our agricultural
It goes through our State Department of Vocational Education and, after
instructors.
the application is reviewed through those sources, I still don't see why the Veterans
Administration should be at such wide variance with other agencies involved.
It has
been a definite problem with us.

I
|

|

|
|

|

MR. MUNSON:
I spent many years as a school administrator in rural areas and
I am satisfied in my own mind that the gentlemen from Nebraska have a righteous complaint.
In Iowa we had a short course every year for farmers.
Many of those men had been on
farms all their lives.
They would come in every year for a course of from ten to fifteen
weeks, one or two nights a week.
They received instruction from specialists from the
State College on the progress made in the technical phases of farming.

|
|
|
|
|

Now, we are dealing with Korean veterans.
These are young men and even though
they write in, the average Regional Office man should know, that a veteran 21, 22 or 23
years of age is not a trained farmer even though he has lived on a farm all of his life.

!
|

If the veteran had graduated from a State College, you have something else
to consider.
However, this would not convince me that he was a trained farmer.
If the
veteran has been in service for two or three years, he knows very little about the progress
made in the technical phases of farming.
He may not need 36 months of farm training; he
certainly shouldn't be denied at least 12 months of farm training, and maybe 18 months
of farm training.
When you get these cases don't say - " We will appeal it."
You are not
necessarily going to get a satisfactory solution out of an appeal.
Once the appeal
denied, it is difficult to get reconsideration and a favorable decision.

is

ii
HH

I want to assure you that people in Central Office are honest and sincere in
trying to do a good job of evaluating these situations.
If you gentlemen who have these
cases brought to your attention, after training is denied for veterans ages 20 to. 25, will
send us information regarding the agricultural training and experience of the person in
the Regional Office who made the decision, statements from neighbors and others regarding
the veteran's training and experience, and how much farming the veteran has done as a
self-proprietor,

will

get

a

fair

I

am

satisfied

that

after

presenting

this

information

to

Mr.

Coile,

we

|
if you send a case to the Board of Veterans
very difficult to change the decision, once

It is not impossible to get a decision reversed.
However, if you were sitting
on the Board of Appeals I think you would probably -take the same attitude toward trying
to justify a former decision.
I repeat, give us an opportunity to submit these cases
for an administrative review before they go to the Board of Appeals.
Once you get a
decision from an administrative review, I assure you it will be based on an honest and
sincere evaluation of the situation.
Should the case be denied, you can use the statements justifying denial in preparing an appeal.
This alerts youvto factual information
necessary to get a favorable decision from the Board of Veterans Appeals.
It is possible to request reconsideration of an administrative
you do the veteran an injustice when you submit a meritorious case to the
Appeals first.
Give us an opportunity to get an administrative review of
have merit.

the
the

1
i

evaluation.

I want to assure you again that
Appeals, which is the supreme court, it is
the appeal is denied.

MR.

N
l
I

CROTTY:

Is

there

any

further

comment

on

this

particular

i 11 |
iit
|

I

review.
I think
Board of Veterans
cases you think

problem?

Let's assume that while one of these cases is pending
MR. SOMMER, Nebraska:
Under an appeal or administrative review,
veteran's eligibility for training expires.
Are we still lost?’
Then, what happens?
entitlement cannot be retroactive.
-i1-

i
i

MR, COILE:
I think, generally speaking, the chances are yes, that the cutoff
date would prevent the man from getting into training.
There have been sbme exceptions
to that rule where it has been determined that there has been mishandling of a case by
the Veterans Administration, and the man then is prevented from exercising his rights.
But
it takes a pretty clear showing that the fault lies with the Veterans Administration.
MR.

MUNSON:

Might

I ask

this

question,

If a veteran is crowding his delimiting
applies for training and emrolls before
though the application is denied by the
review

results

in

approval;

what

would

Mr.

Coile?

date, a farm is available, he starts farming,
the delimiting date, continues training even
Regional Office, end later an administrative
be

the

veteran's

status?

MR. COILE:
I think the status in that case would be all right, because the
would have commenced his course within the specified period.
Certainly that would
prudent thing for the veteran to do if he feels he has a good case; to get started
continue his course while the review is taking place.

man
the
and

MR.

CROTTY:

Any

further

questions?

If

Mackall.

to

ask

MR. MACKALL:
colleague and

my

Thank you.
good friend,

not,

I will

return

the

Chair

be

to Mr.

We will now move on to Question 6, and I would like
Mr. Grady from Ohio, to take care of that,please.

MB. GRADY:
Question No. 6, Mr. Sanderson of Nebraska:
"A veteran was home on
terminal leave and enrolled in a university for a course approved by the State Approving
Agency and the VA.
He was separated from service on October 17, 1955, and filed VA Form
1990 on October 28, 1955, and the application was received by the Veterans Administration
on October 28, 1955.
Why isn't subsistence allowance payable from October 18, 1955,
instead of from October 28, 19557?"

MR. COILE:
I think this is a perfect example of a case that should be submitted
in to us, because our staff says on the facts as stated here, that the payment would
have been made from October 18th, rather than the 28th.
So, on the statement of facts as
given to ue in this question, it is our opinion that the proper date of payment would have

been

to

October

have

the

18,

MR.
dates

of

1955.

Therefore,

opportunity

the

to

MACKALL:
18th

and

the

if

review

you

will

submit

this

case

it.

Mx.
Coile,
28, would

in

to

us

even though the man is on terminal
benefits
still be payable?

we

would

leave

like

between

the

MR. COILE:
No, not if he is on terminal leave, but the question states that he
was separated on the 17th.
Now, we have taken that to mean that that is the date of his
The terminal leave was before that date.
actual separation.
MR.
He

was

on

this course
of October.

DAWSON,

terminal

of

Nebraska:

leave

training

prior

at

to

the

That

is

that

and,

right,

university

he

while

and

was

separated

on

home

on

leave,

received

his

separation

he

the

17th

of

October.

enrolled

or

entered

papers

on

the

17th

The application was received by the VA within the fifteen-day limitation from
the 17th, but the subsistence was not started until the 28th, which was the date the VA
received the application.
We maintain payment should have started on the 18th.
:
will

MR. MACKALL, Mr.
definitely review it.
Are

there

any

Coile

further

has

requested

comments

on

that

you

submit

that

case

to

him

and

they

that?

We now move into the last question on the agenda:
"Why cannot the Veterans
Administration do away with the costly monthly certifications under Public Law 550 and
substitute a more efficient method for payment of subsistence?
If Pinance was authorized
to pay subgistence one month in arrears, this would enable the trainees and schools
sufficient time to notify the Veterans Administration of interruption
or change in status.”
Would

Mr,

McDermott

of

New York

like

to make

any

comment?

MR. CROTTY:
Mr. McDermott is not here at the conference.
What he is primarily
concerned with is the laxity of the schools in the New York City area.
They are sending
in the certifications possibly three or four weeks late and, as a result, the boys are
not getting the subsistence.

like

to

Mr. Coile, what could
hear your comments.
MR.

COILE:

Of

course,

be

done

to correct

this,

I

we

are

aware

there

has

id

that

just

don't

been

some

know,

but

laxity

on

we

would

the

part

i

We are aware of
in getting these monthly reports to us promptly.
of some institutions.
The
that having existed in the area of New York City during the last few months.
Veterans Administration, of course, is not in position to require schools to get these
However, we do feel that we are in a position to use the
reports in at any given date.
best offices we can to persuade those schools of the importance it is to veterans and
the VA for them to get the reports in during the first few days of the month.
Our Regional Office in New York is working on that problem to try to get the
highest possible degree of cooperation from some of the institutions that have been lax.
I think we all are aware that this is a requirement of the law.
It is one of the steps
that the congressional committees adopted to overcome the very great difficulty we had
with overpayments under Public Law 346.
I think most of us in this room will recall that at one time ‘there were outstanding some $200 million of overpayments under Public Law 346.
It came about among other
causes because we paid subsistence for a month of training, whereas the man had interrupted
and the schools had failed to notify us.
It is now a requirement of the law that we
not pay until we receive the reports.
We
have been lax
inconvenience

will do what we can within our authority to encourage
in the filing of reports to speed up their process in
to the veterans.

MR.

MACKALL:

I am

Are

there

comments

any

sure

that
on

Mr.

that

Coile's

answer

particular

is

the

those
order

only

schools that
to avoid further

one

he

could

give.

question?

MR. MUNSON:
I want to emphasize and back up the thing that Mr. Coile stated
here.
The question infers that the trainees in the schools would have sufficient time to
notify the VA of interruption or change in status, and our difficulty under 346 was that
the schools and the trainees didn't do that.
That is where the large overpayments came
into the picture.
Now, there are one or two other areas that are having this same difficulty and
I have discussed it briefly with Mr. Coile and he will correct me if I misinterpret any
of it.
There is nothing in the law that makes it possible for the VA to penalize the
institution for late submission of reports.
If you are going to get these reports in on
time, it will be necéssary for you fellows near schools to use your influence.
As Mr. Coile
has already suggested, urge the Regional Office to apply a little reasonable pressure.
I
also suggest that you discuss this with the State Approval Agency.
I realize that you
can't do much, with a state institution, but there are some proprietary schools that
probably could be influenced if an active State Approval Agency would help.
We need a
little home push to get the job done.
There is very little that Central Office can do
to assist you.
While I am on my feet, I would like to ask one other question.
Mr. Coile,we
have a problem in connection with the twelve months'
interruption period which is permitted
by the law.
Let us assume a boy interrupts at the end of a spring term or semester because
of sickness in the family.
He finds that he is going to have to go to work and earn a
little money to pay a doctor.
At the time for reenrdllment at the end of thé twelve months'
period, say June lst, the veteran learns that the summer session will not start until June
5th; what is the status of his interruption and reentrance into training?

is

longer

that

the

MR.
than

COILE:
twelve

interruption

Of course,
months and,
is

for

a

that example makes the interruption
therefore, it is incumbent upon the

reason

that

is

beyond

his

more than likely very difficult
for him to show that he
school at the beginning of the spring term, for example,
there existed a condition that was beyond his control.

control.

It

for a period that
veteran to show
would,

I

think,

We feel that we have no authority to extend the twelve months that is
law by a month or by a week or by a day, that the twelve months is a period that
designated and that interruptions that are longer than that must be supported by
to demonstrate that it was for a reason beyond the veteran's control.
MR.
a

question
to

JENSEN,
Mr.

Coile.

Georgia:
It

is

In
my

reference

be

could not have enrolled in that
in February, unless at that time

to

this

question

understanding

that

the

VA

No

pays

7,
these

I would
schools

in the
is
evidence

like

to

$1

for

pose

these reports that they submit for each one of the enrollees.
In order to speed them up
in these trouble areas,why can't you make a regulation which would penalize these schools
if they don't get these 1996A's into the office by the end of the month, as they are
supposed to by withholding their dollar?
;
MR. COILE:
Well, it is correct that the schools do
The law provides that they shall be paid for each such report.
be within our rights to establish a date before which we would

-13-

get $1 for each report.
I am not sure that we would
have to receive & report

ME

|

to justify the payment of the $1.
I question that we would be able to defend that
regulation, although we will explore the matter to see whether or not there would be
permitted to the Veterans Administration any leeway in that regard.
MR. MACKALL:
Thank you, Mr, Coile.
I am sure that we all have this problem
all over the United States which involves the late submission of these monthly forms.
If
there is any possible way under your regulations and the law that the schools can be
penalized for not submitting the forms timely, I am sure all of the veterans in the nation
would be very grateful to you.

questions

We have mow finished
from the floor.
(No

the questions
response)

on

the

agenda.

The

Chair

will

entertain

MR. BLALOCK, North Carolina:
In regard to this change of course after the
delimiting date, there was no recommendation.
‘I have in mind a case now in the Regional
Office in North Carolina in which an industrial school required the veteran to take
vocational advisement at the Regional Office prior to being enrolled in their school.
The veteran asked for the vocational advisement on November 12th.
He was advised
on December 20th.
On December 22nd he received his certificate approving training in the
industrial school.
He went back to the industrial school.
The school was full.
They
had their quota under the law.
''We cannot enroll you," they said.

"Well,

now,

He went back at the
you may enroll."

beginning

His

came

delimiting

date

of

each

class

7,

1956.

February

until

February

12th.

They

said,

The VA has now denied him because the delimiting
date has passed.
Now, Mr.
Coile, is there any provision under which the VA may waive that delimiting date for reasons
beyond his control?
I realize that under certain conditions the VA may waive certain
time limits but I do not believe you have the authority to waive time limit so far as the
delimiting date is concerned.
I would like a comment on that plegse.
, MR. COILE:
I think my comment ought to be very brief.
I don't
myself, Mr. Blalock, and I just consulted with my colleagues here and I am
you an answer to that question because I am unsure of what it should be.

answer,

MR. MACKALL:
there is no one

I might make
who does.

this

comment;

MR. BLALOCK:
Mr. Coile, may I, as
case to you for review?
I am afraid that the
back to the Regional Office in Winston-Salem,
get it up here for an administrative review.

number,

we

MR. COILE:
If you will
will ask for the case.

see

me

that

if Mr.

Coile

know the answer,
afraid to give

doesn't

know

the veteran's representative, submit
boy has got an appeal on it but when
I will cancel the appeal until after

after

the

meeting

and

give

me

his

name

the

this
I get
I can

and

C

MR. BEADLE, Massachusetts:
Why is it that a veteran can't change his program
after he starts his training and wants to go to something else.
I wonder if there eouldn't
be some way to counsel a prospective trainee, so he knows that he can consult someone
for
advice and be told what he can do.
If he can be told what he can do, Perhaps it would
help him in reaching the right decision.
Can this be done?

delimiting

MR. MACKALL:.
date?

Ave

you

referring

to

a change

of

program

after

the

veteran's

MR. BEADLE:
No, before that.
Say the veteran wants to change and go into
machinist training.
Could we have some setup whereby he gives his background, and so
forth, and then consultswith
the VA concerning his training and they inform him regarding
his status.
When he starts training he has some assurance that he will go through with
his training, if he is fitted for it.
That is what I mean.
MR. COILE:
Of course, I think every reasonable thing should be done to assist
these young men in making a wise selection of the field they want to get into.
We provide
counselling service if the veteran requests it.
There is some wait between the time the
man asks for such service and the time we are able to give it to him, but we will use the
best expert means we have to help him to make a wise selection initially if he does request counselling.
Any service that the community can give him that helps him to arrive
at a wise decision is all to the good insofar as the veteran is concerned, and I think
insofar as the government is concerned.

can

be

more

MR. BEADLE:
helpful to

What I wanted to get
you people in the VA.

at

-l4e

was

this:

Is

there

any

way

the

Legion

a committee,

Could

or

some

other

plan

provide

a date

that

would

make

easier

it

for

you?

I do think that you can
I don't kndow whether there is or not.
MR. COILE:
render a very great service in informing veterans that they should be as careful as they
The matter of giving counselling, I
can in making a wise de¢ision before they start.
"think, is one that is clothed with so many difficulties that anyone other than a skilled
person might give advice that is not as helpful as might be desired.
I don't

MR. BEADLE:
believe we have

Is there any list
one in our post.

of approved training courses
I don't know, myself.

MR. COILE:
The Regional Office in your
information, either throughout the state or in the
a list in Washington.

from

territory can provide
We do
specific area.

you
not

the

government?

with such
maintain such

MR. MUNSON:
I think every American Legion Post Officer and Department Officers
should pass such information along to the veteran.
The Commander and the Service Officer
Be sure the younger veterans
in the Post should become acquainted with their membership.
This information is available.
benefits.
other
and
training
about
have complete information
It is important that K-veterans know that the delimiting date
for training is three years
from the date of discharge, that they are permitted one change of course before that
delimiting date without any question if it is an approved training program.
If there is
a sufficient time before his delimiting date, advise the man to take counselling service
from the VA.
;
corrected.

If
We

in
as

counselling the VA makes
service officers must be

an error, then there is
able to recognize these

a possibility
errors.

it

will

be

If you advise these Legionnaires in your Posts about the training program,
emphasize the delimiting dates and the fact that one change of course can be made
before the delimiting date and that it is impossible after the delimiting date.
We get
many letters from boys who thought that if the delimiting date came the first of August
and school didn't start until the first of September, they would be permitted to enroll

on the

first

of September.

This is an impossibility.
course on the delimiting date.
It is
Post level.
It will help the veteran

:
Those veterans must be enrolled and pursuing a
important that we get this information down to
and increase membership.

the

There is another point I want to make relative to the submission of cases
for review.
If we all followed the same procedure in submitting cases, it would be helpful.
When you want to submit a case for review, be sure The American Legion has power of
attorney.
Be sure it is in the case folder.
Then write to Mr. Kraabel and tell him that
you want this case called in for an administrative review. Your letter will be referred
to me and I will then ask the VA to call the folder in for an administrative review.
In this way, I have an opportunity to review the case folder before it is
turned over to Mr. Coile for an administrative review.
It gives me an opportunity to
emphasize anything that might be of advantage to the veteran. Further, it gives me an
opportunity to maintain a followup.
If you will follow this procedure, I am certain you will receive very prompt
service.
I am not trying to infer that if you submit it direct to Mr. Coile, it will be
lost.
I don't mean that at all, but it does give us an opportunity to present to Mr.
Coile the pertinent facts in the case which we would like to have resolved in the veteran's
favor.
It also givesus an opportunity to follow up on the review.

for

an

If you think there is merit in the case,
administrative review before appealing.

give
:

us

an

opportunity

to

submit

it

MR. KORELLA, Missouri:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to pose a question to Mr.
Coile.
The question is this:
What is the difference between a general minister who is
studying in a ministerial college and an A.B. degree in Divinity?
I have a case right
now where a young fellow made up his points which were required for entry, he had counselling by the Veterans Administration, he was rated qualified for general minister, so he
decided to change schools.
In the change from one school to the other, the objective
was listed as A. B. degree in Divinity.
It was promptly turned down.

from
that
make

1 cannot see any difference between general minister, minister of the gospel,
any school, no matter which one it would be, and an A. B. degree in Divinity.
So,
case is coming up for appeal.
I am wondering whether Mr. Coile has any comment to
on that.
:
:
/

be

jas

one

of

the

Va.

He
or

has
two

met all of the requirements as to education, he made up his points and
points above the requirements as laid down by the counselling service

-15=-

MR. COILE:
I think the question involved there is whether or not he made a
course adjustment - or a change in program.
{Jt would seem that if there was no loss in
credit, that perhaps all he had was a course adjustment.
If, on the other hand, there
was entailed a loss of credit in changing from one ecurrigulum to another, there may have
been a change in program.

to

us,

to

If not,
welcome

We
see

would be very glad to review that
whether or not there has actually

case
been

administratively if
a change in program

MR. MACKALL:
Do we have any further comments
I would like at this time to call on Mr. Coile.
because they are always good advice.
I give you

MR. COILE:
Thank you, Mr. Mackall and,
a few things that I had hoped to say before we got
started before I had an opportunity.

you could
involved.

get

it

or questions from the floor?
Words from Mr. Coile are always
Mr. Coile.

ladies and gentlemen,
into the questions but

I have only
the questions

First, I want to express for myself and those who are here with me our
appreciation of having the opportunity to come here this morning.
We consider the
organizations our severest critics but also our best friends, and we always derive
from an exchange of ideas in meetings such as this.

service
benefit

I was interested
in what Mr. Mackall said at the beginning of the program
because it is in some respects similar to the things that I had in mind to say today.
I think that there is some disposition on the part of some people to think of this program
as a dying program and, mainly, I suppose, because it is not large in comparison with the
very large program that we had immediately following World War II.
The facts are, however,
that our total programs have been increasing over the past several months, the past two
years.
I think it is of some significance to realize that in these two programs of ours
we dealt last year with 600,000 new veterans.
That is a considerable number of young men
who are seeking education or vocational rehabilitation benefits.
I

think

it

is

of

that are made in behalf of
every twenty-four hours.

some

these

significance,

too,

young

in

men

are

to

the

Now, I give you those facts because I think
we consider these programs as being in their declining
attention to them than their importance merits.

realize

that

magnitude

of

the

total

something

that we need to be on
years and, therefore,

expenditures

like

$2

million

guard lest
pay less

We think, generally speaking, that the benefits that are derived by the young
men who are the beneficiaries of these laws are commensurate with what the Congress intended; that the programs are operating generally very satisfactorily.
There are, however,
two matters that are giving us some concern, and I think you are in a position to help us
to take such action as may be required in respect to these matters.
The first is that
the participation of veterans in the Public Law 894 program would seem to indicate that
there are some who are perhaps sleeping on their rights.
I think I can illustrate that
by telling you that, of the World War II veterans who had service-incurred disabilities,
twenty-seven percent of them were trainees under Public Law 16.
Now, under Public Law
894 for the Korean veterans, only seventeen percent so far are participants in the program
for

vocational

incurred

rehabilitation;

disability

to and who
benefit or
of concern

as

that

determined

by

is,

seventeen

their

rating

percent

boards.

of

those

men

who

had

service-

Now, certainly, we would all, I think, be regretful if men who are entitled
need training fail to avail themselves of it because they are unaware of the
because they are riegligent in making up their minds.
That is the first matter
to us.

The second matter of concern to us has to do with Public Law 550.
We are
concerned lest the generally satisfactory situation under that law lull us into a sense
of security that will allow some situations to exist where veterans' interests are not
protected, where they are exploited through schools or job-training establishments that
should not be participating in the program.
I don't think that there are great numbers of
such situations but there are undoubtedly some such situations where the veteran's time
will not be well spent in the course that he is pursuing and the benefit that he receives
from the government will not be fully justified in terms of the training that he receives.
I think it would be unfair if I didn't proceed to ask the question:
"What
about it?"
In regard to the first problem, I think the Veterans Administration
should again consider circularizing Korean veterans, who have substantial disabilities,
to make sure that they are informed concerning vocational rehabilitation, and that we
propose to go into.

can

we

do

What you could do, perhaps, is more important because you are in intimate
contact with these young men from day to day.
I think that you should make sure that
insof.r as you are able, the men do learn of their rights and that they do not allow these

lf

rights

to

lapse

through

neglect

on

their

parts.

In regard to the situations in Public Law 550 wherein a veteran's interests
may not be fully protected, we would solicit your support in the correction of those
situations, or if they are amenable to correction, in the elimination of those situations
so that a veteran may be fully assured that the institution or the establishment in which
he proposes to pursue his course of training is one that will provide him with the best
training of the type that is available to him in that vicinity, or the best that is available
in any vicinity insofar as is possible.

The elimination of these unsatisfactory situations, of course, creates some
In the long run, however, we are convinced that the weldifficult problems immediately.
fare of the total veteran population is improved even though there may be some temporary
and immediate hardships whose training has to be temporarily discontinued through the
situations.

training

unsatisfactory

of

elimination

I therefore leave with you the thought that we still have a very active program
that will not be declining for at least two years, as we now believe; that it is a vital
and important program that deserves and merits the best attention that we as administrative
officers and you as service representatives can give to it.
Thank

you

for

the

opportunity

to

speak

thus

with

you.

MR. MACKALL:
Mr. Coile, speaking for my colleagues and the floor, you will
always find The American Legion your severest critic but our criticisms will always be
constructive.
We will always attempt to help you as best we can and we will always defend
you when there is somebody also trying to run you down the road.
Ladies and gentlemen, this brings the Vocational Rehabilitation and Education
panel to an end and I would like to thank Mr. Coile and his staff for being with us and I
would like to thank my colleagues to my right for assisting me, and I leave you with this
one thought:
If you want a place in the sun, you must expect blisters.
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN FQUST:
If you will remain seated, ladies and gentlemen, we have a
distinguished lady who is going to address us, but before I call her to the platform, I
want to reiterate the remarks made about our good friend Comrade Mackall in that we are
most thankful to the distinguished gentlemen from the Veterans Administration for their
assistance in this panel this morning.

lady

to

the

At this time
platform.

I would

like

to

ask

Comrade

Pool

to

escort

our distinguished

The American Legion has always shown excellent judgment and for the many years
that I have served on this Commission we have always had a wonderful and outstanding
member of the American Legion Auxiliary as the Chairman of their National Rehabilitation
Committee,
They have been so outstanding that it follows that, the following year, they
usually become their President.
These fine women, in their work for our disabled and
their hospital services, and the money they raise for us, do a wonderful job, believe me.
We have so many things to be thankful for and I want to express our thanks and deep
appreciation to this fine organization, and I know that each and every conféree here joins
with me in saluting this very fine organization and {ts leaders.

the

I have the distinct pleasure, ladies and gentlemen of the conference, to present
Chairman of the American Legion Auxiliary Rehabilitation Committee,
Mrs. Carl Zeller.

MRS. CARL ZELLER:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Members of this Conference: I
shall preface my remarks by reminding you that the American Legion Auxiliary was formed
for the purpose of aiding The American Legion in carrying out the great peacetime service
to America, to which The American Legion is dedicated.
All of its activities are designed
to promote the work of The American Legion and to help The American Legion reach its
objectives.
During the past months this National Chairman has referred to the rehabilitation
program as the House of Rehabilitation.
The House of Rehabilitation is an old house,
built by The American Legion more than a third of a century ago.
It is true that during
the years additions have been made, repairing has been done, but the structure remains the
same

because

structure

that

it

was

built

rests

on

upon

truth,

a

firm

faith,

foundation,

hope

and

a

solid

substrata

of

integrity,

a

love.

It is a privilege to participate in this Rehabilitation Conference here today.
We are grateful for this opportunity to inform you of the activities of the American Legion
Auxiliary in the great task of caring for the disabled veterans of two.wordd wars and

the Korean Conflict.

Our

has

program each year

5

differed

little

from

the preceding

one

TEE

|

save in the scope and extent of the work, for loving care and attention and continuous
service know no calendar limits.
Every day and every month during the entire year you
will find the American Legion Auxiliary striving to meet the demands of our three-phase
program:
service in the hospitals, service in the community and service through education.
You will find the unit members making every effort to further the vast programs of service
to the disabled veterans, those young women and young men who have sacrificed their youthful health and strength in this nation's defense.
Yes,

we

be adequate, that
sideration we can

are

determined

that

the

financial

their hospital care shall be of
give them shall be fully given.

the

compensation

best,

and

of

every

these

veterans

kindness

and

shall

con-

When we direct our attention to service in the hospitals, our thoughts turn
to the volunteer hospital workers whose unselfish devotion make their services so valuable.
It is the volunteer hospital worker who brings the community to the hospital and, it is
said, the major purpose behind bringing the community to the hospital is the therapeutic
effect of keeping the patient surrounded with normality.
The American Legion and the
American Legion Auxiliary volunteer workers provide the "home away from home' atmosphere
and are instrumental in bringing sunshine into the lives of those who are broken in body
and spirit.
They do the heart things, the home things, the therapy beyond the scope and
time of the busy professional staff.
At the recent area rehabilitation conferences,
this National Chairman learned
of many department projects that will benefit the hospitalized and the disabled veteran.
We learned about the greenhouses that have recently been constructed at Veterans Administration hospitals to which patients are clamoring for assignments; and we learned of
others that are nearing completion.
Time does not permit a complete accounting of the
many wonderful projects but you will be interested to learn that departments are promoting
the sale of occupational therapy articles in their units.
They are making items of clothing that will add to the patient's comfort.
They are financially supporting American
Legion rest camps.
They are purchasing new furniture for reception and recreation rooms.
They are establishing and maintaining day nurseries.
They are providing transportation to
baseball and football games, sponsoring dances, movies, birthday parties, and special
treats during the entire year.
You will find them purchasing wheel chairs, television sets and special hospital
equipment.
They also establish special funds to pay insurance premiums, to pay for transportation for patients called home in an emergency, and to purchase insulin for the
diabetics and to provide expensive medicines for veterans in their communities.
The Christmas Season would be the loneliest time of the year for many of the
veterans were it not for the effort put forth by the American Legion Auxiliary to make it
cheery and pleasant.
The Christmas Gift Shops where patients were privileged to select
gifts for the home folks without any cost and with no indication that the gift was donated
and mailed by the American Legion Auxiliary, were again successfully operated at the
Veterans Administration hospitals.
Christmas parties for the patients everywhere were gala occasions, with gaily
decorated and lighted trees and the season's greetings.
They were remembered with brisk
$1 bills, a box of candy, a box of cookies or a carton of cigarettes.
In many instances
programs followed by refreshments were offered.

be recorded
quote:

The appreciation voiced
but certainly this one

by the
letter

hospitalized veterans in this nation could not
expresses their gratitude,
It says, and I
i

"I would like very much to express my thanks and appreciation for the warmest
Christmas reception I have ever attended.
If I live for one hundred years and if my
:
vocabulary was the most extensive in the world, I am sure that this span of life would not
be long enough and no words could express the gratitude I feel on this occasion.
"During my iife," he continued, "I have had many gifts but never in my life
have I owed so much to anyone as this obligation I feel today.
It is very true that 1
had anticipated Christmas in the hospital but I did not expect gifts nor did I expect
gifts for my wife or my children.
Nor did I expect someone to assist me in selecting
and mailing those gifts without cost to me.

when I
I pray

"I am sure
heartily say,
that God will

that I express the sentiment of every patient, as well as myself,
thank you, and to each of these persons individually and collectively,
grant you His richest blessing."

Most important, we are told, to the hospitalized veteran's peace of mind, is
the knowledge that the loved ones at home are not in need or suffering during the period
of hospitalization.
We have learned that our service did not begin and end at the bedside.
Service in the community, the personal contacts, service before and after hospitalization
-18-

is, therefore, a very important part of our rehabilitation program, and no effort is
Our advancement and security are totally
being spared to perfect it in every detail.
dependent upon our successful efforts for home life.

of

In the community, careful attention
veteran and his family when necessary.

the

is

given

in

supplying

the

material

needs

Service through education includes many things: supporting legislation that
concerns the veteran and his dependents, learning and cooperating with other agencies in
the community that have the welfare of the veteran at heart; educating not only our own
members but our fellow citizens; also that we must take our place beside the tubercular
patient; the patient with Hansen's disease and the mental patient.
Unemployment, naturally so closely allied with rehabilitation, has become an
integral part of this program.
The years since the beginning of World War II have seen
great improvement in the status of the physically handicapped veteran.
Thanks to
enlightened employment policies by large industries and some governmental agencies, the
handicapped veteran has the best chance for economic success that he has ever had.
But
the blind, the crippled, the victim of speech defects, are not able to prove that they
are competent to hold many positions.
Unfortunately,
the social recognition of the
handicapped veteran or one who has been released from a mental hospital, or a penal
institution,
to attend social functions, to establish a home and family, to lead a normal
life as a normal member of the community, is lacking.
It is vitally important that we
arouse public opinion in order that the communityas a whole will recognize the fact that
they need social recognition as much as any other citizen.

|
{
|
|

|

The story of the Memorial Poppy definitely has a place in the program of
service through recognition.
We must constantly remind the citizens of ur communities
that the disabled veterans in the hospital who make the poppies derive double benefit
from their work.
First, it gives them employment, the only chance they have to help
support themselves and their families.
Second, the work is of real value in aiding
their recovery, occupying hands and minds and restoring spirits crushed by hopelessness.
They must be told again and again that the funds derived from the sale of poppies each
year constitute the largest source of revenue for the rehabilitation and child welfare
work of The American Legion and the Auxiliary; that wearing the poppy means honoring the
dead and helping the living.

I
|

This year, the American Legion Auxiliary has pledged a full measure of service
to those who served.
It will continue to be our goal as long as there is a hospitalized
or a needy veteran.
By fulfilling that pledge
we will justify our existence as an
Auxiliary to The American Legion.
As long as the American Legion Auxiliary units remain
a living force in the community, the doors will never be nailed shut nor the windows
boarded up in our House of Rehabilitation.
I

Mrs.

Zeller,

thank

you.

CHAIRMAN FOUST:
I know
for her very splendid

you join with me in
remarks here today.

thanking

our

distinguished

lady,

noticed
with us
with us

Before closing the work for this morning, and as your presiding officer, I have
one thing that is most gratifying to me and that is the many ladies who have joined
in our discussions here today.
I sincerely hope that you will continue and join
throughout the many discussions we will have throughout the week.

and we
in the

Again, Mrs. Zeller, we are most honored to
express our gratitude to your organization for
interest of our program generally, and to your

here

this morning.

deliberations

afternoon,

and

I trust

that you will

join with

meeting

adjourned

at

twelve-twenty

AFTERNOON

February
The meeting was called to order at
Chairman of the Commission, presiding.

Chairman

of

28,

CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
It is now my pleasure
the National Economic Commission.

i

the week

in our many

-19-

sharp
Thank

this
you.

SESSION
1956

to

|

throughout

o'clock.)

one-forty

it

i
AEE 0
df 1 1

to be present; comrades, at one-thirty o'clock
herewith recess this meeting until that hour.

TUESDAY

Vice

us

|
i

have you here with us this morning
the many things that have been done
fine ladies who accompanied you

discussions.

I ask you kindly
and I hereby and
(The

Hi

o'clock,

present

Mr.

F.

Clinton

Knight,

to you Mr.

Adolph

Bremer,

{1

MR.

ADOLPH

F.

BREMER:

Thanks

very

much,

Vice

Chairman

Knight.

I suppose this is a real foolish approach and it is usually done in meetings
of this kind, but you know these men at this table here are all friends of ours and I know
they would appreciate it and we would, too, if perhaps the people in the back of the room
would move forward a little bit.
I
meeting

but

say that
I make it

is a foolish request.
It is always
for the record.
We sure would like

made by
for you

the Chairman of the
to move forward.

The National Economic Commission is very pleased to have a part in the program
of the National American Legion Rehabilitation Conference.
Compared with the time allocated
to rehabilitation, the economic discussions are brief.
We of the Economic Commission
feel, and we hope that you agree, that this disparity in time allowed does not detract from
what we judge to be important activity.
We believe further, or hope that .this difference
does
not mean that the Legion, and you in particular, are less interested in trying to
explain why we have only two hours in this four-day program.
We might suggest, facetiously,
that there are fewer problems associated with
the administration of the programs which come within the purview of the Economic Commission
than the problems associated with those of the Rehabilitation Commission.
At any rate,
for the next hour and a half or two hours, you will have an opportunity to hear administrators
and chiefs in several programs in which The American Legion is vitally interested.
We
appreciate their coming to visit with us in this way, giving us a report and providing
us the opportunity to ask questions and to react in other ways to the programs that they
administer.

Loan
with
that

We will begin by talking about loans.
Thomas J. Sweeney, the Director of the
Guaranty Service, Department of Veterans Benefits in the VA, has been associated
the G. I. Loan Program since 1944.
In 1946 he was named the Assistant Director of
service and since February 1955 he has been the Director.

estate
of the

Prior to his governmental service, he
business.
It is my pleasure to introduce
Loan Guaranty Service.
Mr. Sweeney!
MR.

THOMAS

J.

SWEENEY:

Thank

you,

Mr.

was in
to you

private mortgage loan and real
Thomas J. Sweeney, the Director

Moderator.

It is always a pleasure to address the rehab conference and the meeting here today is
rather timely because I have been on the Hill this morning before the Senate Banking and
Currency Committee, which committee was making inquiry into the financial status of the
G. I. program.
I am happy to report that our detailed statements of the record to date
were received and commended upon by Senator Sparkman, Senator Capehart, Senator Lehman
and Senator Payne.
.

I
to

give

you

won't take up too much
an annual report on the

time here
status of

going into all
the G. I. Loan

the details
Program.

but

I would

like

Up through December 31,1955, we have guaranteed 4,549,000 loans.
As you are
well aware, ' 4,256,000 of those have been for home loans, which is the biggest part of our
program, amounting to $32,955,000,000.
Now,
790,892 loans have been paid in full, the
original face value of which was $4,475,000,000.
That represents about 18.6 per cent of
the loans that were guaranteed that have now been paid in full =- that is, home loans.
We have had some unfortunate situations where some of the boys, due to unemployment or social problems, have gone by the wayside and resulted in the government
paying claims in the amount of $24,168,000, numbering about 2142.
This represents about
one-half of 1 per cent of the total loans.
Dollarwise, it is only about .06 per cent
of the original total volume.
I might add in connection with the $77,000,000
expenditures we had to meet in connection with protecting
those properties, which we have taken over and sold, that
the receivables, which we feel are sizeable, and assuming
of

the

trative

receivables

we

have

on

expenses

would

be

only

hand,

the

net

$19,000,000

cost

as

of

to

we paid out in claims and other
the equities, in protecting
if we were pioperly to write off
we would collect a greater portion

the

government

December

3lst.

outside

of

adminis-

I think that record speaks for itself.
We take no credit for what has been
accomplished.
I think that our veteran borrowers are the ones to be commended.
They
have recognized their moral obligation, particularly when it comes to home ownership, to
see that. a roof is maintained over the heads of their families, and so long as these men
who are gainfully employed, I think everyone will recognize his legal obligation for
paying monthly or otherwise on his mortgage, and particularly those which are guaranteed
by the government.
The record has been splendid and I am sure that if the economic
situation continues, we need not fear any great losses to the government.
-20-

1 mention that because I think the inquiry that we had before the Senate
in that specific subject
Banking and Currency Committee this morning indicates an interest
This is the first time any congressional committee has made any
of government laws.
astounded at the
inquiry into the financial aspects of the guaranty program, and they were
In fact, they felt an excellent record has been brought forward on this
splendid record.
program.

Admittedly, we have had our headaches, we have had problems throughout the
No doubt you have heard of a lot of the matters dealing with the administration
country.
of appraisals and our MPR's and publicity about veterans' complaints as to construction.
1 think you gentlemen can appraise the situation that when you put things in the right
prospective, the problems we .arxe confronted with in relation to this multi-billion dollar
program are minuscule and recognize those that are just some of the hazards of the business
regardless of whether it was a G.I.loan program, conventional or FHA.

|

We have closed 72,485 direct
1 would like to report on our Direct Loan Program.
Twenty-two hundred sixty of those loans are paid
loans in the amount of $518,000,000.
We have sold to private investors 6,742 loans in the amount
in full, about 3.1 per cent.
of $48,400,000, or 9.3 percent.

the

extent

state that
loans.

unfortunately,

We

have,

of

$1,200,000.

had

to

foreclose

Presently we have on hand 63,276 loans
the payment record on those is just as

on

207

loans,

amounting to
good, if not

4.3

of

1 per

cent,

|

to

|

$454,000,000, and I would
better, than on the guaranty

I might add that after we paid the interest to the Treasury and some small
losses that have occurred to date, we have put into the Treasury a little over $18,000,000
Knowing the pattern
as of December 31st, which we have earmarked as reserve for losses.
of liquidation of mortgage loans and knowing the respect our boys have for paying their
obligations, I think that that reserve is going to be built up so that it will exceed
In fact, I think the
by far any exposure the government would have to any great losses.
Direct Loan Program would be self-liquidating and no doubt turn a profit back into the
government .

|

For this coming year I feel that we are going to do the same business in ~
calendar 1956 as we did in 1955; roughly, that we will participate in the guaranty of
Our educated estimate is that we will
loans in a high percentage of the new construction.
guarantee loans on about 400,000 new units and about 250,000 loans on old existing houses.
There are signs coming forward
billion.
$7
or
$6.75
about
we will make loans at
Roughly
now that this tight money market insofar as mortgage loans are concerned is easing.
Now, admittedly,
There are certain forces coming into play that are generating this money.
The demand
there are a lot of areas where we still have a money and credit dislocation,
is high.
The secondary and the primary investors are rather reluctant to go into some
confident
feel
I
creditwise.
but
house
a
only
not
fields unless you have a prime security,
that the private lending industry will exert every effort to make sure that mortgage money
flows freely, and I think they recognize that if they don't move from that angle, other
factors being equal, the Federal Government may take steps to lend some support.

and

those

_ However, be
veterans who

that as
haven't

|
|
|
|
|

it may, I think that we can look forward to a good year
used their entitlements, will have opportunity to do so.

|
{

I might add, also, that we are going to be tough as to our compliance inspections.
We have attempted to keep an eye on that and, in our offices, we are going to be a little
tougher in connection with our compliance inspections; in other words, through our proWe will be a little rougher
cedures to insure that we don't have faulty construction.
We have had to disqualify many
in covering some of the activities of certain builders.
of them but, although we try to be equitable and fair in dealing with some of these
individuals and give them an opportunity to correct their deficiencies, apparently some
of them feel that they can get by with a minimum, so we are going to be a little rougher.

|

il
|

1

have now reported the status of the program to date and the outlook for the
coming year.
As you well know, we still have many loans exposed but I would like to
have Phil Brownstein follow me here and give you a little outline of what our policies
and procedures are in connection with keeping the veteran in his home.
Thank

you,

|

|
|]
| |

gentlemen.

il

Perhaps we could save any questions that you have until we hear
MR. BREMER:
from Mr. Brownstein, P. N. Brownstein, who is the Assistant Director of the Loan Policy
and Management Section for the Loan Guaranty Program.
Mr. Brownstein is an attormey who
was in private practice in Philadelphia prior to affiliating himself with the Loan Guaranty
Program in 1946, after service in the Marine Corps.
He also was in the Federal Housing
Administration prior to World War II.
Mr. Brownstein.

3 ie

[ {

|

MR. P. N. BROWNSTEIN:
On a program such as this where time is allocated, I
always think of the the teacher who was instructing her seventh grade pupils in theme
construction and she told them that the secret of a good theme was brevity and, further,
that there were four components which, if worked into any theme, would
make it sure fire.
Those components are royalty, religion, sex and mystery.
"If you can work those four
elements into a theme and keep it brief," she assured her pupils, '"you will
have no
trouble in being great successes in the literary field."
She then asked them to compose a theme combining the four elements and keeping
it brief.
After about thirty seconds a hand was raised in the rear of the room.
She
called upon the student and asked him what he wanted and he said, "I have
finished my
theme, Teacher.
She

said,

"You

couldn't

have

in

this

He

said,

"Well,

you

me

to

keep

elements

told

short
it

space

of

all

four

the

class."

have

a baby.

Good

Lord!

Maybe

I can't

work

in

rundown

on

the

Loan

"The

queen

is

I will

keep

this

brief.

Tom

Sweeney

has

given

you

going

to

a

in

mt

She said, "Do you have
"I sure do."
"All right, read it to
So he read it:

So,

time."

brief."
it?"

what

Who

done

it?"

those

four

Guaranty

elements.
Program

has

done

to date and what portends for the future.
As Tom pointed out, we can't accept much credit
for the fine record that the veterans have maintained in meeting their obligations.
It
is a source of extreme gratification to all of us who are responsible for
administering
the program, as we know it is to you who also are vitally interested in this
matter.
The veterans have demonstrated a keen responsibility in meeting their obligations
and
we think, too, that it demonstrates the fine cooperation we have had from
the lending
- industry in the underwriting and the servicing of the loans.
We in VA feel that, in administering the home loan provision of the Loan
Guaranty Program, there are two basic objectives to be achieved.
The first, of course,
is to do everything we can to assist the veteran in the acquisition of his
home.
That,
I believe, is probably less important than the second objective, the second being
to keep
him in that house which he has acquired.
There have been very few forced liquidations in this program.
There have been
nearly 4,500,000 veterans who have acquired homes and, ultimately, the vast
majority of
them will wind up with debt-free home ownership.
But there are a few who do fall by the
wayside.
One thing which we have in the past tried to do, and will continue to strive
for, is to have the veterans avoid some of the pitfalls that may be encountered
along
this road.
There are some people in some areas who have been known to grasp upon the
other person's misfortune and endeavor to profit by it.
We have put out releases in those
areas warning veterans that if they dispose of their properties, they should
be sure of
their purchaser, because the mere disposition of the property does not result
in their
being released on their mortgage obligation, so they may find out that if
the person to
whom they sell should default, they will wind up owing the government a debt,
and it is
something that they shouldconsider very carefully.
;
One way to avoid that, of course, is by requiring the purchaser to arrange
his own financing.
Now, we don't say that that should always be done because we recognize
that, with the favorable G.I. financing on the property, the veteran often will
be able
to get a much better price for that unit, so he should weigh one of these considerations
against the other and decide what is best from his standpoint.
ago

called

Many

of

"To

The

you

probably

Veteran

Home

are

familiar

Buyer."

to the Home-Owning Veteran," and we
the veterans that you come in touch

We

with
have

modestly
with.

the

pamphlet

recently

recommend

it

which

published

to

you

and

we
a

put

out

sequel,

you.

sometime

"Pointers

recommend

it

to

There was a supply of ene million copies of the pamphlet published initially.
I was advised today that that supply has been ordered by veterans around
the country and
that we are going to have another reprint, so you may have to wait for a while
before
you get a copy but, nevertheless, I do suggest that you familiarize yourself
with it because
we have endeavored to set forth in there the things that the home-owning
veteran ought
to know about and ought to look out for.

you

may

I will
have.

be

glad

to

join

with

Mr.

Sweeney

22.

in

the

answer

to

any

questions

which

Sweeney
presume

MR. BREMER:
Are
or Mr. Brownstein?
it will tell you in
MR.

BROWNSTEIN:

there any questions that you would like to direct to Mr.
1 should like to get a copy of that booklet, myself.
I
there how to meet the payments?
I need that book real bad.
By

check

or

money

order.

|

MR. BARRETT, North Carolina:
I would like to ask a question.
How can the
Veterans Administration help the veteran who has purchased a home with a G. I. Veterans
Administration guaranty if the home is found to be of faulty construction?
Just what
could the Veterans Administration do for that particular veteran?

|

How

can

MR. SWEENEY :
I am sorry, I didn't quite get
a veteran get a guaranteed loan on a house that
MR.

veteran

who

inferior

BARRETT:

has

purchased

No,

what

is

the

Veterans

a

house

and

found,

your full question...
Is
has faulty construction?

Administration

after

he

has

able

purchased

to
it,

do

to

that

|

it:

|
[

help

a

was

of

it

|
|

construction?

|
|

;
MR. SWEENEY:
We all recognize there is no perfectly built house.
Under any
proposed construction or new construction, our policy and procedure that we follow is this:
That the builder files plans and specifications with us and superimposed on that are
minimum property requirements.
Through our compliance and inspection procedure, the
builder is supposed to build that house to meet those plans and specifications and the
minimum property requirements.

|
|

i

After the veteran has purchased the property, he will always find some adjustments to be made, some trivial and some very serious.
I refer to the serious problems.
If, for instance, he finds he has a wet basement or he finds that the plumbing or the
heating are not operating properly, or he has .a leaky roof, items of that nature are
complained of to the VA.
We then call upon the builder and determine whether it is his
responsibility.
If it is, we ask him to go in there and correct those deficiencies.

|

I adverted in my talk a while ago to that and I was referring to just those
types of occasions -- that we have many builders that will go out and correct construction
deficiencies, recognizing that it is good advertising for them to keep their customers
happy.
However, we have some few who are rather reluctant or dilatory about going back
and doing the job that we require of them.

|

Now, to answer you specifically, if we find a builder that will not meet
with our requirements, will not correct the deficiencies that we think are his responsibility, the only thing we can do under the law is blacklist him, if I may use the
word, from the program.
But we have found that in some areas, we have builders that
have these spurious corporations, and sometimes they are financially irresponsible.
Well,
there is nothing that we can do in those cases but, generally, we are successful in getting
the builders at least to do the necessary
work to make that house habitable.

il |
i
it |
it

ing

out

The only
what we had

sanctions
requested

that we can take if a builder
of him is to suspend him from

is uncooperative
the program.

and

not

follow-

MR. MICHAEL MARKOWITZ, Pennsylvania:
We find in Pennsylvania that your
ingpections that you are talking about -- I think you called them compliance inspections
are just cursory, you might as well say.
In other words, we have builders that we find
are putting up inferior buildings.
After the veteran has moved in, he finds that the
plaster is 1/4 inch thinner than it should have been.
Now, in order for the builder to
rectify that kind of error, he would have to tear out, I imagine -- I am not a builder,
myself, I don't know too much about construction but, having talked with them and also
Veterans Administration people, I understand that he would have to tear out all the
plastering and replaster, because you can't put 1/4 inch of plaster on top of whatever
plaster is there.
;
Your inspectors make only so many visits, very periodic types of visits, and
they don't do a thorough job.
That has been the complaint of the veterans and we have
problems in Pennsylvania continually about this kind of thing and I just wonder whether
the Veterans Administration isn't guilty to some extent of not doing a job for the veteran
that might be done in a better way than it has been in the past.
MR.
policing

these

SWEENEY:
compliance

we have had a high
built, we did have

have

to admit

situation,
also admit

that

1 will

have

inspectors.

to

admit
But

you

that

we have

could

recognize

volume of business.
In order to
to recruit people that purported

in some areas

we

have

that

done

during

a better
the

last

job
two

render service and get these
to be competent inspectors.

failed miserably.

--

il
Il
it
Ii

il
fl|
|
I

|

|

|

in

|

years

houses
I will

On the other hand, where we have found, maybe long after the fact, some such
we have attempted to take that type of inspector off the list.
I will have to
that a lot of them are exposed to this kind of thing.
We have people in the
© -23-

|

I

il

|
|

building game, you know, who like to throw the 'green lettuce' around and sometimes
bribe these people.
We have had innumerable investigations of things like that, but I
want to assure you that we are moving in on this situation.
In fact, the Administrator
has authorized additional personnel and funds, even though we are exceeding our budget,
to go out and hire personnel to police that situation.
We will never eliminate it but we
hope we can minimize it.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
Thank you Very much.
I am glad to hear it is being done but,
still, a veteran has purchased a home of that kind and he is stuck with it.
That is the
thing that bothers us.
I have a case here that I was showing to my colleague next to me.
I am not going to mention the outfit but I have specific cases right here.
We have
arranged for a meeting with the building group in Pennsylvania, where there are something
like fifty complaints by veterans who came to us.
We didn't look for this kind of thing
but they came to us -- one builder, with over fifty people making a complaint.
That is
a very serious proposition.
It will take tens of thousands of dollars to rectify the
errors this builder has made in one construction project, and the veterans living there,
on a Veterans Administration approved contract, are stuck and they may have to go to court
in order to get redress, and that costs money and we think some injustice is being done
the veterans, to say the least.
MR.

SWEENEY:

MR.

MARKOWITZ:

Those

fifty

veterans

have

They

have,

and

can't

they

now

gone

get

to

any

their

local

Regional

redress

there.

Office?

MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
I have one question I want to get clear in
my mind.
Under your present regulations, if a newly constructed house turns up with
water in the basement in the first twelve months, do you have a right to make the builder
fix that; is that correct?
MR. SWEENEY:
Yes, sir.
Now, under the warranty provisions, the builder
warrants, usually, that he will have a dry basement, and under the warranty provisions, if
-we discover that in the course of construction or subsequently, he did not do the necessary
things that would assure a dry basement, then we will request him to go back and to take
whatever steps are necessary.
They can put in a French drain, regrade or take care of
the walls, whatever Zs necessary, to be sure that the basement is dry.
MR. BROWNING:
If that water shows up in
the expiration of the first year's time to fix it?
in twelve months, he can fix it in eighteen months;

the first year,
In other words,
is that right?

the builder has after
if the watér shows up

MR. SWEENEY:
Well, sir, since we are guarantors on that loan, assuming that
eighteen months after there was a discovery of water and we determined that was the
responsibility of the builder, we make demands op the builder.

to

fix

it,

MR,
but

BROWNING:
he doesn't

But the water shows
necessarily have to

up in the
fix it in

first
those

twelve
twelve

months and
months?

he

MR. SWEENEY:
No, wait a minute.
He will have to go out with despatch.
you find in the ninth month that there is water in the basement, we ask him to move
correct it immediately.
We don't let him wait until the fifteenth month to go back
correct it.

put

it

MR.

BROWNING:

I wanted

to

be

sure.

We

have

MR.

SWEENEY:

No,

sir,

he

has

to

out

there

MR, LEWIS, Maryland:
up your program, that

Mr.
is,

MR.

SWEENEY:

correct,

sir.

MR.

LEWIS:

tight

you

go

a

lot

of

those

immediately.

has

If
in and
and

in

Rhode

Island.

He

can't

delay

and

off.

tightening

That
Just

is

how

Sweeney, you
in regard to

are

going

said just a while ago that
inspection; is that right,

to

get

with

you were
sir?

this?

MR. SWEENEY:
Our present plans are this:
That there will be one or more
employees who will be properly screened and their sole duty will be, No. 1, to check
the work of every compliance inspector on our roster; No. 2, to inspect his work at
the first, second and third compliance imspection.
We will take a good sampling of
every model or type of unit in each tract development.
I am now referring to the larger
tracts, ten or more houses.
!
No. 3, we are going to check the builder supervision.
We find a great fault
with some of these reported builders is that they capitalize a project and leave it up all
to
subcontractors and different trades that come in there and do the work, but there is
no coordination of supervision.
There may be someone on the job once a day, but we are

-24-

|

demanding that it be p:ioperly supervised and if they don't have the supervision
going to hold up a job until they get somebody on it.
That will follow through
tightening-up process.
Those
‘gentleman

on

are

the

the

right

highlights,

here,

that

but

we

we

need

do

to

find,

screen

apropos
the

of

the

comment

relationship

of

we
on

of

some

are
this

the

of

these

compliance inspectors.
They are private contractors but sometimes you find they have
vested interests and maybe they are influenced by people they are inspecting for.
We are
going to make sure they have divested themselves of any proprietary interests or relationship where their compliance inspection would be influenced.
MR. LEWIS:
the veteran?
or is it the
the home?

the home,
that home
dition of

One more
Does he
Veterans

question.
Who is responsible at the time of the sale of
have any responsibility at the time of the purchase of
Administration's responsibility, that is, for the con-

MR. SWEENEY:
Legally and morally, let me put it this way, any veteran buying
a home is also subject to the common law ruling of caveat emptor, buyer beware.
He is
supposed to go in and look the property over and if he can find some fault that he can
observe visually, he ought to call the attention of the builder to it and complain about
Anybody that is a good shopper, a good bargainer, who is buying a house, ought to look
those things over.

eligible
doing is

it.

On the other hand, as far as the government is concerned, to make that property
for the guaranty, we go in there with our compliance inspection.
All we are
to make sure that the builder is conforming to the plans and specifications.

I find so often, maybe due to the fact that the government is in the picture,
that they feel that, with what the government has done through its compliance inspection
system, we are the warrantor or guarantor of that property.
However, if we find that the
builder does not, by subsequent action, conform or we find that he is deficient, then we,
under the law, have the right to go in there and call upon the builder.
. To answer you specifically, I think the veteran should take caution at
he buys the house, check it with the type of builder he is buying from, look over
neighborhood, find out who his neighbors are going to be, and if he has any doubt
call in somebody that he knows in the building game and ask him to review it.

some
fall

the time
the
about it,

I think often we rely on our compliance inspections.
I think we have done
excellent jobs in some areas but, human nature being what it is, some of these folk
by the wayside.
I do think there is a responsibility on the veteran.

MR. LEWIS:
We have a development going up south of Baltimore and here about
two and a half or three months ago I went down there with the Chief of the Appraisal Unit
of the Baltimore Regional Office and together we looked it over.
It was found that there
was a lot of faulty construction.
I asked him what he meant to do about it and he said
he would have the man tear the faulty work out and do it over.

him

why

he

It was
didn't

done over but again
reject the project.

I

"Why

said,

"Because,"

it was done in an improper manner. - So,
He said, "I can't do that."

I asked

not?"

he

said,

"the

lending

agency

would

lose

about

$300,000."

I feel that in a case of that kind where we know the builder is not a reputable
builder, but yet you go ahead and accept his property, that the fault is on the VA.
I
don't think if a veteran goes there and buys a piece of property like that, he has any
responsibility.
MR. SWEENEY:
I might add this matter has been before the House Veterans Affairs
Committee and some consideration is being given to adopting legislation which will permit
the Administrator to qualify builders, and I think that will give us another tool by which
we

can

cull

out

some

of

these

people

financially irresponsible or do not
of work that we think is necessary.

that

want

are

to

not

follow

buildexs,

the

per

wishes

se,

of

the

and

those

VA

in

that

doing

are

the

type

MR. BLALOCK, North Carolina:
We have been discussing the compliance inspections,
and so on, but it has been called to our attention right recently in regard to the
veterans' applying for these loans and being 3ent through the volunteer home mortgage
credit program.
Many of our veterans are directed to these lending agencies and in several
cases the lending agencies had on the credit reports placed their fees, and so on, and
yet they turned down the loan but they have charged the fee to the veteran, about $25 per
case.
I

know

that

has

been

called

to

the attention
~Z5-

of

the

VA

before,

but

does

the

veteran have any recourse whatever to get it back, realizing if the loan was closed, it
could be absorbed in the cost, and so on, but where the proposal does not give it, what
recourse does the boy have to get his money back?

he not been
money back?

My point is
sent there

this:
by the

The boy would not have gone to that particular measure
direction of the VA.
Does he have any recourse to get

had
his

MR. SWEENEY:
Here is a case where he has applied to the Voluntary Home Owners
Credit Committee and no doubt they have indicated to him that they are willing to make the
loan.
In other words, they got a tentative commitment so he has put up the appraisal fee,
just like he would do for any guaranteed loan, the property is appraised, and for some
reason or other the lender has not gone through with the loan.
Do I understand that.
MR. BLALOCK:
Yes.
If I may take the time, I will read the letter returned
to the veteran from the company:
'We regret to return your application for a G.I.Loan
as it does not meet our requirements.
We are enclosing two checks representing the refund.
One check is for $26, zepresenting the refund on an appraisal fee, credit report and
photograph.
You sent us $28 and we have deducted the fee for the credit report.
From
the application fee we have deducted $25 for our expense and are enclosing our check for
$50."

wonder
this.
out of

So, you see
how many of our
Why, they could
it.
MR.

to

the boy there is still stuck for $25 from the company and I just
proposed lenders, through this mortgage lending thing, are doing
turn down applications all day long at $25 and make a good thing

SWEENEY:

Mr.

Brownstein

just

tells

me

that

this

matter

has

quoted

from

has

recently

the

letter

been

referred

him.
you

and

MR. BROWNSTEIN:
The letter
we are looking into it now.

that

office

BLALOCK:
it to be

I have

like

MR.
for

it.

would

MR.

JOE

I appreciate
looked into.

HOLZKA,

Staten

Island,

N.Y.:

a copy

Tom,

I

of

have

listened

come

here

with

in

to

our

now

and

I

a

great

deal

of interest to all these complaints and criticisms of the compliance inspection setup of
the Veterans Administration.
Being a practical mortgage operator, I wonder if most of the
people in this room who are good, active Legionnaires realize that not only the regulations
but, in one instance, the law has become so tight that a good many veterans are being
deprived of their right to buy a home under the G. I. loan because of the number of
builders, the increasingly large number of builders, who are avoiding the VA because of
what they call the excessive red tape.
This

is

following through
medicine which is

something

that

to correct the
more dangerous

The

American

Legion,

I

abuses, that we don't
than the disease.

think,

come

up

should

with,

bear

shall

in

we

mind

say,

in

some

The big thing that these builders back home are complaining about is the
tremendous amount of red tape in filing papers to meet the requirements of the Veterans
ddninistration,
There are two kinds of builders,the BTO's, the Big Time
Operators who
aren't

most

builders,

of

the

and

I

complaints

think

the

records

show

that

those

builders

and

operators

are

where

arise.

There is the other kind who is a builder who works on the project himself, and
most of the houses, believe it or not, are built by builders who build anywhere from
fifteen to thirty houses a year.
Isn't that correct?
The Levitts get the headlines
but the little builders go ahead and produce most of the houses and they are the ones
who, because of this red tape, are hesitant to get into this program.
They don't have
engineering staffs and don't want to be put to all the expense of complying with the law.
The American Legion a few years ago was instrumental in having a law put through,
which is now a matter of law, that provides that a new house will not qualify for a G.I.
loan until one year after it is completed unless it is built under G.I. compliance
inspection.

That
MR.

is

correct.

SWEENEY;

That

is

still

in

effect,

isn't

it,

Tom?

Yes.

MR. HOLZKA:
A-lot of the little builders to save some of the cost involved
in this program, are going ahead and building fine houses and the veterans want to buy
them and they find out, when they make an application for loan, that the house isn't
a year old and there is nothing the veteran can go ahead on.
It

is

all

right

to

file

complaints
-26-

and

say

this

is

something

that

should

not

have happened, but we
Is that correct, Tom?
MR.

questions
thanks to

SWEENEY:

won't

want

Thank

to

you,

carry

it

Joe.

Your

to

a point

where

observations

some

are

people

well

MR. BREMER:
The last one, Mr. Sweeney, was the easiest.
for Mr. Sweeney and Mr. Brownstein?
If not, we certainly
them for coming to report and to answer questions.

will

be

hurt.

taken.

Are
want

there any other
to express our

°

Of the various economic resolutions passed by the 1955 convention, directed
to the Congress, two have been given priority and one of those is the three-year extension
of the G.I. loan program.
Where you can be of assistance in securing passage of this
extension, it will be appreciated.
In looking over the roster for the economic panel this afternoon, I was amazed
to find that nearly all of them, interestingly enough, are veterans of the Navy, and the
next man is no exception.
Bruce Stubblefield is known to those of us through the Legion
and more recently through the Veterans Counseling Service of the Civil Service Commission
of which he is Chief.
A native of Oklahoma who now calls Maryland his home, he has been with
Counseling Service since its organization in 1944 and has been Chief since 1954.
Bruce Stubblefield!

the

MR. BRUCE STUBBLEFIELD:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I see that there is interest
in the loan business.
I didn't know so many of these guys were looking for loans.
It has
taken up a considerable amount of time so I am going to make this very brief.
It is a distinct privilege to me to meet again with this
the twenty-first, I believe, that I have been privileged to attend,
glad to see some of you old codgers hanging on, too, because if you
be awful lonesome, because I intend to be here.

conference.
This is
and I am awfully
quit I am going to

1 want to take this opportunity to introduce to you a gentlemen whom some of
you ‘have met.
Someone was smart enough to figure out here a while ago that when you get
up to my age, you have got to have somebody to do your work.
I brought with me today
the man who is doing my work for me, and I want you to know him because he is a World
War II boy and I think knows his business, my assistant, Ed Bechtold.
Ed is from the great
State of Pennsylvania and someone said that would make him a great man if nothing else did.
I think it was Bill Ilgendritz.
I have only one thing to say to you.
I am not going to try to tell this group
anything about our activity because I think you are thoroughly familiar with what we are
attempting to do.
There is one thing that we are pressing right now and we are pressing
it because The American Legion requested that we do so, and that is to set up and make
available counseling service throughout the country.
Our regional people are.-already
working inthat direction.
Many of you no‘doubt have been contacted-by them.
May I suggest
to you that in your departments you take advantage of this opportunity because the system
that we are using, we stole from you.
I spent some thirty-odd years trying to help train myself and other service
officers, and so we are attempting to use the same service that The American Legion has
been using all these years in training people who can help in employment matters and,
in addition to that, we are trying to broaden the meetings to where the United States
Employment Service, the Veterans Reemployment Rights Service and other services provided
through the Department of Laboror any other source, such as the President's Committee
on Employment of the Physically Handicapped, can be asked to participate and get a complete
employment picture available to your men who are going to answer the run-of-mine questions
in your offices throughout the country.
That is our objective.
Those of you who have trained service officers for
thirty years know that it isn't an overnight program.
It is something that is going to
take a lot
of effort.
But I submit to you that it is an important one, because, again,
I must repeat that there can't be rehabilitation without full employment.
In closing, I want to say this to you.
Every newspaper you pick up today,
and nearly every speaker that you hear speak, has some suggestion to make about amending
the Veterans' Preference Act in federal employment.
May I say to you that the Civil
Service Commission has been studying this matter of whether or not the Act should be
amended for several years.
Every time we read a speech or every time we read an article
in a magazine or a newspaper, we contact the authors of those publications to see what
facts such statements have been based upon.

facts.

We

I can
don't

say to you, truthfully, that up to this moment
have any facts in the Civil Service Commission
-27~

we have never gotten any
today that would justify

the attacks that have been made.
We are studying the situation because many people are
concerned and I take it they are honestly concerned, but I do want to say this to you,
and this is repeating what our Chairman said to the National Executive Committee of the
Legion and what we have said in writing to your National Economic Commission:
We are
studying, we are attempting to find out what the facts are, and if we do find that the
Veterans' Preference Act is detrimental to good management and good employment practices,
at that point your organization will be consulted to go over those facts with us prior to
the time that our Commission makes any recommendation to the Congress for such amendments.
Now, further assurance I am sure you would not expect but certainly that is
the policy we have followed in trying to work with all of the veterans’ organizations and
your office here in Washington is kept advised when changes are indicated.

As of
number
we get

heard any
and until

this moment, we don't know whether they are indicated or
of statements made but what we want are facts upon which
them, there is going to be a lot of talk.

not.
they

I have
are made

You know, about every ten or fifteen years any benefits that are granted to
veterans come under attack and usually it is the people who know the least about it who
do the most talking.
I said to someone here the other day that I felt it would be a pretty
good idea for people to finally realize that veterans are citizens, that veterans have
demonstrated their love for their country and that they are going to be, as a group, the
last group that would want to destroy the country they have defended.
It seems to me.that it is time for those who are considering changing these
things, particularly those who are not familiar with the background and familiar with
the end
results of these programs which you people have thought out carefully over the
years,to consult with those who know.
Until this group and groups similar to this are
moved in to the counsel table, we are going to continue every ten or fifteen years to
have these battles

know

We
will

and

assurance

from

are
not

doing our best to try to get the cards out
be taken by surprise when that- time comes,

your

on the table so that you
and I can give you that

will

Commission.

It is, indeed, a pleasure for me to
God's sake, you old codgers in my age bracket,
see you again next year.

be here, and, as I said
take care of yourselves

a moment ago, for
because I want to

MR. BREMER:
Bruce, I am certain that I express the feeling of everyone present
that that statement is an important one, the kind of thing that ought to be on record for
the American people to see, coming from a man who is among those most familiar with how
the veterans' preference program is actually administered in the Civil Service Commission.
Being a newspaper man, I can only comment that no doubt
representative here to hear that statement but, too many times, it
are represented when an attack is made on the veterans' preference

be

the

proposed

man

who

there is no press
seems to me the press
program in Civil Service.

We thank you very much
by the Commission.

for

that

assurance

Have

that

you

would

We want to thank you, then,
does all the work for you,

Mr.
and

Stubblefield, for coming and bringing
we know that you are going to be back

you

VOICE:
MR.

any

How

BREMER:

questions

old

is

he?

Well,

he

is

prematurely

of

liketo

consultation

when

direct

Stubblefield?

to Mr.

changes

will

with
next

you
year.

gray

Alvin M. David of the Division of Program Analysis in the Bureau of Old Age
and Survivor Insurance, Social Security Administration, has been with the federal
service
since 1936 when he became a training officer.
He joined the staff of the Actuarial and
Technical Division in 1937 and during World War
II he served in the Army Medical
Department.

In 1949 he moved to the Director's Office as an assistant on program matters,
a position he held until his recent appointment as Chief of the Division of Program
and
Analysis.
In this capacity, he has had an opportunity to work in every variety of program
and policy issue.
He has represented the Bureau on an extensive series of speaking engagements before national organizations, both public and private.
Yesterday he tells me
he was in Minneapolis, my home state, and just having eome from there myself I know
why
he hurried back to warmer Washington.
Mr. David!

remarks

at

MR.
the

ALVIN M. DAVID:
beginning about

Thank you,
the problem

Mr. Chairman.
of getting the
-28-

Apropos of the
audience up to

Chairman's
the front,

I am

reminded of the story of a congregation that was badly in need of a new church and a
wealthy member offered to build one all by himself, but he had one condition.
He said
that the pastor would not be able to enter the church during the construction or see any
of the plans.

that

Well, the offer was so good,
pastor didn't have any choice.

the

it was such a beautiful
He said, "Go ahead."

church

in

the

diagrams,

The first ‘service came around and he was very gratified that, as he started
to deliver his sermon, all of the pews that were empty disappeared below the floor and all
the pews that were occupied were brought to the front of the church.
He was so pleased
that he waxed more than usually eloquent in his sermon and he noticed after a while that
the hands of the clock had reached the time that the service was supposed to finish,
twelve o'clock, and he saw the hands reach twelve o'clock and the next thing he knew, he
was sitting on a cushion down in the basement of the church, having fallen through a
trap door that had been built immediately below the pulpit.
I

would

like

to

talk

about

the

old

age

and

survivors'

insurance

program,

a

part

of the social security system.
Under this program people, while they are earning, pay a
percentage of their earnings into the program amd when their earnings stop on account of
retirement in old age, or on account of death, benefits are paid by the program to them
or to their
survivors.
These benefits are a percentage of their earnings.
That is the
way benefits under most retirement plans in industry are figured and that is how the
benefits under the federal retirement plans are figured -- as a percentage of earnings.
They do pay more to those with higher earnings than to those with lower earnings, taking
into account the standard of living of the individual receiving those benefits.
This is, as we call it, a social insurance program.
It insures against earnings
loss.
When a person (and this is a point that is often misunderstood) reaches age 65,
having
aid his contributions, he thinks that the benefits should be paid to him at that
time regardless of whether he keeps on working.
The program is not designed to do that,
but rather to pay him only if he retires and his earnings stop.
The theory is that if
he keeps on earning he has not had the loss that the program insures against and, by
limiting itself to insuring against that loss rather than paying benefits just at 65,
regardless of work, the program is enabled to pay higher benefits than it otherwise would.
This sacial insurance is very much like group insurance in private industry
in the sense that the benefits do not relate directly to the amount that the individual
has contributed.
For example, the person who is in the higher ages at the time the
system starts, just as in private retirement plans, gets benefits that are quite a bit
higher, in proportion to his contributions, than is the case with the younger person.
That is the common thing in private pension plans.
It is not, as some have thought, a
mark or an indication that these benefits under Old Age and Survivors' Insurance are
in any way a windfall.
The
this

kind

of

program

thing

is

different

I

just

that

from

mentioned

group
a

insurance

little

bit

in

the

farther.

sense

that

it

It

only

pays

not

carries
high

benefits in relation to contributions to those who are old when the system starts, but
it also pays higher benefits to those who have dependents and to those in the lower
wage brackets.
This is one of the reasons why the program has to be compulsory.
If it
were a program that paid the actuarial equivalent of the contributions paid in, it wouldn't
matter whether it was compulsory or not, but because it pays some considerably more than
the value of their contributions, it can only be balanced out if it is compulsory and
if all have to contribute.
A second, and perhaps more important, reason why it is compulsory is this -and this matter comes up now because of consideration being given in the Senate to further
extension of the coverage of the program to certain self-employed groups, many of whom
urge that they ought to be allowed to come in on a voluntary basis.
The basic idea in this
program is that the protection of the American people against poverty in old age and
against want
is necessary

on
to

the part
make the

of families where
the
protection against it

earner has died,
is so important
that it
compulsory.
In that way it is perhaps

comparable to the importance attached by society
society says that it is so important that people
pulsory, and the support of the public education

to the public school system in which
have an education that it is made comsystem is also made compulsory.

This is another point that perhaps has come up in discussions you have had or
in articles you have read or speeches you have heard.
The program is fully financed.
By that, I mean that it has a schedule of contributions written into the law which, over
the tong run, will balance the expenditures to be made in benefit payments and in administrative costs.
The program is in as close to actuarial balance as it is practical

to make

it.

retirement

The
and

financing of this program is different from that of
survivors' insurance system for the reason that the
«29-

a nongovernmental
benefits can be raised

as wages and the cost of living go up without any change in the schedule of contributions.
The explanation of it takes
That is a point that has not been very easy to understand.
a little while but, in brief, the general idea is that as wages go up, the income to
the system in the form of contributions increases more rapidly than the increase in benefit
payments.
As a result, it has been possible to take account of the increased wages that
have occurred in the last twenty years since the system was started and the benefits have
been increased many fold in that time.
The benefits that were paid in 1940 averaged about
$22 for the retired person and the average
benefits now being paid are close to $80 a
month.

conditions,
it to do so

The program, in order to be effective, must keep up with changes in economic
in wages and in prices, and so far it has done so and its financing permits
without changing the contribution rate.

I might say one more thing
that it is a social insurance program
of the individual receiving them, and

about the general nature of the program and that
and its benefits are paid without regard to need
without regard to his conduct or his behavior.

}
|

is

At the present time, about one-half of the population aged 65 and over is
eligible for benefits.
The number eligible is increasing rapidly because, as people now
reach 63 currently, about three-quarters of them are eligible for benefits under this
program,so that in a few years, instead of half of the existing aged population being
eligible, we will have about two-thirds, and that percentage will go up.

A word or two about legislation that is currently before the Congress because
questions on it may come up and there are some points on it that perhaps will provoke
some discussion among you.
One of the pieces of legislation lowers the eligibility age for women
beneficiaries under the program -- and that includes not only women wage earners but wives
and widows -- from age 65 to 62.
Another major provision would pay benefits before the
retirement age of 65 to people who are permanently and totally disabled.
Those provisions
are very controversial.
I would be glad to try to answer factual questions about them.
I am not able to speak for the Department of Health, Education and Welfare on the point
of whether or not the Department approves the provisions.

to you for
before the
Survivors'
with their
the charge

The one on the payments to people who are disabled might have a special interest
the reason that one of the main criticisms of it that has been made recently,
Senate Finance Committee, is that if these benefits are paid under Old Age
Insurance to people who are disabled,
this will tend to impede or interfere
rehabilitation.
That is one of the issues.
I am not saying that I agree with
but that is a point that I thought you might be
interested in.

Another point that
not be made under Old Age and
receipt of another government
whatsoever

receipt
be paid

perhaps will be of interest to you is that payments would
Survivors' Insurance if the person eligible for them was in
benefit based on his disability, a benefit under any program

--

workmen's

‘compensation,

of an
under

amount as
this one,

large or larger under
and you may have some

veterans’

program,

oi.

any

other.

If

he

that other program, the veteran
comments or
questions on that.

is

in

would

not

Another bill that is not now under active consideration, but will undoubtedly
be of interest to you (and you probably will have questions on it), is the bill H.R.7089,
known as the Hardy Bill, which makes basic changes in the system of survivors' benefits
for veterans and for servicemen.
This is quite a big package and unavoidably complicated
because the problems that the committee framing it had to deal with are complicated
problems, but what they did come out with in this package does greatly liberalize the
existing survivors' benefit provisions.
It liberalizes the retirement benefits for servicemen, for career servicemen.
It removes a great many inequities and, in the process of doing those things, it extends
Old Age and Survivors' Insurance coverage to military service.
That will take the place
of the present provisions of law under which military service is credited under Old Age
and Survivors; Insurance with a flat credit of $160.
This credit is not an adequate way
of dealing with the problem and this bill fixes that up.
It also fixes up the financing of those credits so that they are not a burden
on the employers, employees and self-employed people who are covered under the program.
In other words, under this bill, the cost of those credits is borne by the Federal
Government, not by the other contributors.

door

I think I have gone on here long enough and I fear that there might
underneath, so I will stop and see if you have questions.
Thank you.
MR.

BREMER:

MR.

JOSEPH

Are

A.

there

PADULA,

be

a

questions?

New

York:

I have
~30-

a question

in reference

to

social

trap

]
|

|

security, for Mr. David.
Each and every week I attend the veterans' hospital in Albany
wherein 90 per cent of the sick know nothing about this freeze plan that they have in
social security.
On my return to Schenectady, am a public welfare worker, I am a consultant for the county of Schenectady, and I have called it to the attention of the
Schenectady office on three different occasions and they, in turn, have notified the Albany
office, yet my first call was in January and nothing has been done about it.
So, I wrote
a letter to the Schenectady office requesting that they send a copy of it to the home

;
|
i
i

office

of

Social

Security

in

Baltimore,

finding

out

if

there

wasn't

some

remedy

possible

to allow these men, some 984 of them in the hospital, at least 90 per cent of them
knowing a thing about this freezing of their social security rights while they are
in the hospital on their backs, in bed, to learn something of their rights.

sick
that

refers

I would like to see something done about
time frozen and not be penalized in the future
you could give me for that situation?

to.

MR. DAVID:
Let me say first
I didn't mention it because

what this
of trying

that so that these men can
in their status.
Is there

|

not
sick

have their
any remedy

provision is that the gentleman
to hit just the high spots.

here

The general idea in this provision of the social security program is that a man
or woman who is permanently and totally disabled has the period of his disability dropped
out in figuring his benefits and his eligibility.
Now, in this case of the people in the
veterans' hospital, I do not know, I had not heard of that situation, but it is entirely
inconsistent with what we have done across the country.
We have used every means at our
disposal to bring to the attention of people covered by the program, in pamphlets and in
all kinds of public information materials and speeches, the fact that they are eligible
for this disability freeze.
Where there is a large group of people who could benefit from it right away,
we have gone to the length of actually getting in touch with them through the institution,
or through the employer where it is a case of an employer who has a pension plan and has
a lot of people on his disability roll. This disability freeze, however (and I think
this may be the important point there), does not pay current benefits.
It does not pay
benefits right at the present time as this provision in the bill does that I just spoke of.
This provision in H.R.7225 calls for the payment of cash benefits to the disabled person.
The freeze provision does not do that.
It only protects his insurance status.
The only
place where it results in immediate benefits is if he is already aged. 65 or over.
In
that case, we can recompute his benefits, dropping out the period that we previously
had to count, the period in which he was disabled, and we have been giving priority to
those cases of people over 65 and wehave made our greatest efforts in getting in touch
with these groups where there are people in the group, or where a large proportion of
them, are over 65.
It is possible that in this case that you speak of, the work load of the .ffice
on these priority cases, where
immediate benefits were payable, has resulted in their not
getting around to these people that you speak of who will not be able to get immediate
benefits but whose benefit rights will be, when we get to them frozen, nevertheless.

J

|
|

it

ll

IH |
|

|
|

i

|

MR. PADULA:
The reason I asked that question, Mr. David, was this.
Many of
these men are 60, up to 65, or coming to the point of 65, but in our Welfare Department
we have what we call a PA-125 which freezes and a PA-126 which we send with a freeze
application, and cne of those forms are being sent to the veterans' hospital so that these
men can have those things taken care of in case they become 65 during this period of illness.

That

is

MR.

DAVID:

why

I brought

it

to

Yes,

not

familiar

I

am

this

body.
with

‘what

you

Welfare Department.
That is the State Welfare Department,
to do with this federal program that I am speaking of, Old

are

talking

about

there

in

the

I take it, and that has nothing
Age and Survivors' insurance.

MR. PADULA:
I understamd that, but what I was trying
we in public welfare departments do take care of our people but,
should be taken care of is neglected.
That is my point.

to do was to show you
yet, the veteran who

that

MR. DAVID:
I don't think in any of those cases the veteran has lost anything
unless he is 65.
Even if he were 65, we, of course, do not have the responsibility or the
money to go out and hunt up the cases.
We do all that we can do in the way of publicity
releases, and beyond that we go into institutions and organizations where there is a
population of disabled people and try to bring it to their attention, but we can't hope to
do it for every last one.
We must give priority
to the ones who are 65 already.

2

MR. PADULA:
Would you give us a suggestion as to where we could have our own
men, say, our own service officers or somebody, go to them, take a little time once a week
or something similar to that -- have the service officers go and talk to these men.and.
find
out the situation so that you can correct it?
Could you give us a suggestion along those
nes?
-31-

|

be

MR. DAVID:
trouble.
I

having

I don't see any reason
would like to look into

MR. PADULA:
It isn't the Schenectady
office isn't responsible.
It is the

Schenectady

MR. DAVID:
them, to give you the
glad to have you help
As you
They just

forms.

at all
that.

MR.

why

this

Schenectady

office; they are
Albany office.

doing

office

very

should

well.

The

In my opinion, this Albany office would be glad, if you would
leaflets and the explanations of this provision and they would
them in explaining it to these veterans and have them file the

undoubtedly
have to let

PADULA:

Thank

know, they don't have
us know and we go out
you.

You

have

given

to come into our office to file
there if they are unable to get
me

a

ask
be
forms.
the
out.

?

thought.

MR. W. O. ILGENFRITZ, Penna:
From a number of questions I have gotten in
Pennsylvania, there seems to be some confusion as to how many periods of employment are

necessary

to

at

60

or

627

in

order

to

create

maximum

eligibility

for

MR. DAVID:
The question
become eligible for old

is,
age

MR.

age?

ILGENFRITZ:

At

that

individuals
who

I take it,
benefits?

how

long

enter

does

the

the

system.

person

What

have

to

is

it,

work

MR. DAVID:
Of course, he can become eligible only at age 65 or after. Supposing
that he enters the system or coverage is extended to his employment, as you say, when he is
aged 62:
The answer to the question as to when he becomes insured is based on what his
age is, not at the time that he enters the system but what his age is at the present time,
if 1 make that clear.
In other words, to be insured, it is necessary to have what we
call quarters of coverage equal to at least one-half of the calendar quarters elapsed
after
1950 and before age 65.

|

Now, that sounds a little complicated but to take an example, a person now
reaching age 65, in this first half of 1956, would need to have ten quarters of coverage.
or the equivalent of two and one-half years of covered employment to be insured.

age
the

If he reaches age 65 this fall, he would need eleven quarters.
If he reaches
65 next year, the first half of next year, he would need twelve.
It is one-half of
time elapsing after 1950.

He doesn't have to have all the quarters
on the basis of the period after 1950 and we say he
that number.
He may actually, however, have earned
1951.
Is tnat clear?
MR.

ILGENFRITZ:

1

presume

in that period after 1950 but we eount
has to have a number equal to one-half
those quarters of coverage before
|

so.

MR. COX, Ohio:
I have something I would like to clear up in regard to disability.
In this new bill, I understand there is provision that any person who is disabled and receiving disability benefits under any other government program shall
have his
social security disability reduced according to but not less than to zero.
What I would
like to know is, does the social security count a person that is over 65 and drawing
social security disabled, or is this talking about the new law where he would be
declared
disabled before he becomes 65?
MR. DAVID:
No, this is talking about the new law -- not a law but a bill and
my crystal ball doesn't tell me whether it ever will be a law.
But it is a bill that
provides for something which we don't now have:
payments before age 65 to people who
are permanently totally disabled.
It has nothing to do with the people who are now
drawing benefits under the program, who are over 65, of course.
MR,
magazine
out that

account,

COX:

That

clears

it

up.

Thank

you.

MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
I have one question.
I recently read in a
article -- and this is no reflection on the magazine article, but I have
found
you don't want to take everything for fact that you read in a magazine article.

it

MR.

DAVID:

MR.

BROWNING:

could

not

I agree

This

be

MR.

DAVID:

MR.

BROWNING:

No,

with

article

corrected

that

you.

is

I didn't

said

farther

not

think

if
than

an

error

two

was

years

made

in

your

social

I asked

the

question.

security

back.

right.

it was.
-32-

That

is

why

Thank

you.

u.

MR
DAVID:
We do have a statute of limitations, as
errors in reporting cannot be corrected after a certain length
in the normal case, three years, three months and fifteen days
wages were earned.
That is, in the normal case the correction
and

three

or
is

months

failure on
no statute

after

the

error

was

made.

However,

the part of the employer to file
of limitations and the error can

if

the

a return, or
be corrected

it is called, under which
of time.
That time is,
after the year that the
can be made three years

error

is

the

result

of

fraud

something like that, there
forever, at any time.

The reason for this is that it becomes, as time goes by, too hard to determine
what the actual amount of wages was and in this law, as in a great many other laws, there
is a recognition of that which says that you don't have to deal with a thirty-year-old
situation and try to make a correction in a record where all the evidence is stale and
there is no way really to tell.
All you have is the allegation of the person that this
is incorrect.
MR.

BROWNING:

Is

there

any

provision

for

an

appeal

in

a case

like

that?

MR. DAVID:
There is provision for appeal in any case. The law provides for
appeal in any case but the statute is perfectly clear and if, within the terms of the
statute, the time has gone by, then the Appeals Council will have to turn it down.

pass
your

MR. BROWNING:
Then, it
this on to those under Social
account from time to time.

wouldbe smart
Security, that

business and I suggest that everybody
you write in and find out the status of

MR. DAVID:
I think that that is an excellent suggestion and it is another
one of the things that, in the time I have taken here, I have failed to mention.
It
probably would have been good to mention it.
We do have the service of giving you a
report on your account.
You can get a card from any district office, fill it out and
send it in to us and we will very promptly give you a
record of your earnings to that
point, including the total of earnings and the earnings for the last year.
MR. WILLIAMS, Vermont:
I just wantedto clear up for the gentleman from
Schenectady a point which I think is pertinent.
We are all concerned with the disabled
veteran who is permanently totally disabled, to protect him on the freeze.
Over at the
Veterans Administration hospital at White River Junction, recently
we requested the
appearance of a
representative from the Rutland Social Security office.
He came down
there and explained the whole program to us and left with us a form which is known as
a "lead" form.
We followed through with that, and it has been agreed that the hospital
representative,

the

contact

we

him

in

would

assist

the freeze,
seems to me
chief there

any

representative,

case

that

we

would

were

have

charge

interested

of

this

whole

program

and

in.

Every veteran who comes into the hospital, who presumably is eligible for
is covered.
No veteran is going to be left out of this whole program, so
that the same thing could be done at the Albany office by contacting the
and requesting that a similar program be set up.

MR. DAVID:
I am glad to hear you say that because the thing that you
is the normal and typical thing to have happen.
I don't know what the pressures
circumstances were in Albany that prevented it from going on there.

it

describe
and

MR. WILLIAMS:
This is not a service you must render, you are not obligated
to have an agent to do this in the hospital yourself, but you can get the cooperation
from the Veterans A ministration to see that this program is fully covered.
There is
no

obligation

either

to

the department

service

determine whether that man is eligible
we follow through with an application.
everything is satisfactory.

officer

or

the

contact

when he gets that veturn.
We don't have any trouble

VA

man.

You

merely

If he is eligible,
there, and I think

then

MR. DAVID:
I would be glad to meet that gentleman who had the question about
che eligibility provisions.
I would be glad to talk to you.
I don't know that I ought
to take the time of the whole group.
I am sorry if I didn't make it clear enough.
It
is a little bit complicated.
MR.
panel.
phrase

BREMER:

Ladies and
We don't want
your questions

Thank

you

very

much,

Mr.

David.

gentlemen, we are running slightly behind schedule on this
to discourage your asking questions.
However, might I ask
quickly and directly, to save time.

economic
you to

Mr. Robert K. Salyers, the Director of the Bureau of Veterans Reemployment
Rights, is a native of Kentucky and a graduate of the University of Kentucky, and it was
my unfortunate experience recently to see him humiliated when that great team from
Vanderbilt defeated that great team from Kentucky.

Well,

Bob

is

a veteran

of

the

Navy

-33-

and

he

has

served

in various

federal

and

-

state posts in his native state prior to becoming the Assistant Administrator and the
Acting Administrator of Retraining and Reemployment Rights Administration.
In 1947
he organized the Bureau of Veterans Reemployment Rights in the Department of Labor and
Bob Salyers!
he has been its Director since.
MR. ROBERT K. SALYERS:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Friends:
I heard the other
day about a farmer whose barn was struck by lightning and burned down during the night and
he caught cold fighting the fire, so a couple of days later his wife went into town and
called upon the agent that handled their insurance to see what they could do about the
fire insurance on the barn.

thing

After she had presented the papers
another, she said, "All right, when

and

another

The i:surance agent
barn just exactly like
She

said

and they
do I get

said, "You don't
the old one."

''You mean

the

same

get

looked up the
the check?"

a check.

We

color,

the

if that is the way
on my husband."

size,

same

the

money?"

policy,

are

going

and

H

one

to

build

same

dimensions,

same

you

folks

you

everything?"
"That's

right,'

"You

are

not

said,

"No."

He

he

said.

going

to

give

me

k

operate,

She said, 'Well,
you can cancel the

looking

I
tired

of

have

talked

give

us,

know
about

that
at

some

that

then
life

of

same

you
old

reemployment

young man,
insurance

folks
barn

rights

who
and

here

have

been

hearing

for

here

about

a number

previous

that

of

same

are

years
old

going

get

barn,

a

to

little

because

I

years.

I do appreciate the opportunity, always, to thank
because without your help we couldn't function.

you

for

all

the

help

you

Reemployment rights continue in effect very much as they have been in the
past for enlistees, inductees and men going into the service.
It is true today as it was
years ago.
There has been no change in entitlement to reemployment rights as there has
been in some of the other veterans' benefits.
There have been one or two things added.
As many of you know, the Reserve
Forces Act of 1955 will from now on impose a mandatory obligation for service in the
Ready Reserve on many categories of ex-servicemen.
That buildup will continue through
about 1959, when there will be some 2,900,000 people in the Ready Reserve.
They will be
obligated for weekly drills and for annual training duty, and some of them for longer
periods of training duty.

Those folks are covered by reemployment rights of a little different category.
As a matter of fact, if this thing keeps getting more complicated, we will really have a
problem.
We now have three kinds of reemployment rights for three different groups of
reservists, and it is possible for one reservist at some time or other to be in each of
those

three

categories.

So,

when

you

run

across

problems,

as

you

may

folks

in

the

field

don't hesitate to bring them to the attention of our
to give the best possible service we can on them.

from

time

to

time,

and

we

will

try

There is one other point that I probably ought to mention.
About a year ago
the Supreme Court handed down a
decision in the case of Diehl v. the Lehigh Valley
Railroad which has resulted in a good many complicated situations, particularly in
connection with veterans on the railroads.
The process has been under way for some time
now on many of the roads in connection with an adjustment of the seniority of veterans who
had been upgraded and who had not been advanced to the higher positions.
problems in
a good many

This, again, is a very
that area, be sure to
of the roads and some

doctor gave
tell me the

A man one day
him a pretty
bad news."

complicated issue.
If your folks come to you with
get them to us because we are now working on it with
of the other industries throughout the country.

went to his doctor and
comprehensive physical

he had been
examination

feeling pretty bad and the
and finally said, "Well, Doc,

"Well," the doctor said, "there are a number of things we could do but the very
best thing -- and I emphasize, the very best thing -- is for you to give up drinking and
give up smoking and give up any gambling or anything that excites you.
Go to bed early
at night, get up early in the morning and do a lot of hard manual labor."

<34~

|

|

entitled

to

entitled

to

The fellow
the best.
I have
the

shook
What

always

very

his head a little
is second best?"

felt

best

that

service

you

folks

that

any

bit

in

and

the

said,

''Doc,

Legion

government

and

agency

I never

those

can

whom

give.

have

felt

I was

you

serve

are

With

a

limited

staff like we have out through the country, sometimes we are a little slow on some of
these things.
If we are, I hope you will bear with us, but I also hope you will not
hesitate to needle us as occasion warrants and bring to us any problems you think we can
be of help on.
And now as they say up on the Hill, I am privileged to yield the balance
time to my colleague in the Department of Labor - Ed Omohundro, the Director of the
Veterans Employment Service.
Thank you.

Thank

MR.
very

you

BREMER:
Are
much, Bob.

there

any

questions

you

would

like

to

direct

to Mr.

of

my

Salyers?

When Ed Omohundro returned to his native State of Colorado after service in
the Navy after World War II, like a good veteran, he went to see the Veterans Employment
Service and there he was given tests and was counseled and he asked them what job he
might handle, what sort of work he ought to do, and they said to him, "You ought to be
a job interviewer right in this office.”
So, he became an employee of the Veterans
Employment Service in Colorado and shortly thereafter he became the Director for Colorado
and now he is the Chief of the Veterans Employment Service =-- a true success record.
In this position he has the overall responsibility of assisting all state
employment agencies in carrying out special services to veterans, and to see that policies
of the Secretary of Labor, in so far as special services to veterans are needed, are
carried out by the State Employment Service.
Ed Omohundro!
MR. EDWARD L. OMOHUNDRO:
Thank you, Adolph.
Friends, I served in the Army
and, upon discharge, I went in to draw my 52-20.
They told me I had better get to work
or they would cut me off from 52-20, and that is why I went with the Employment Service.
If

Bruce

Stubblefield

can

introduce

the

man

who

does

all

his

work,

I

think

would iike to present to you some of our Veterans Employment Service people who are
this afternoon.
Would you fellows kindly rise?
We have R. C. Goodwin, from North
Carolina; Abe Fennell of South Carolina.
Right next to him is Hugh Kerwin, our VER
the District of Columbia.

Grafton
Redden,

our

field

Pennsylvania

from

Maryland

is

representative

for

here

are

fortunate

We
of

Brown
staff

was

(George
Columbia Legion

but

I

here,
the

saw

Bill

dash

out

in

having

two

local

and

the

New

England

to

office

VER's

and

in

States.

up

Lane, Past Department Commander
were presented from the floor.)

MR. OMOHUNDRO:
to the Federal Government.
interested in the Legion's

gentleman

check

on

Heywood

his

the

back

Bill

Social

is

I

here
for

Harold

Ilgenfritz

from

Security.

here.
Saunders

of

the

District

I might add that these gentlemen are not here at any expense
They are here on annual leave because they are vitally
rehabilitation program and the Economic Commission's program.

The Veterans Employment Service activities are based on the statutory requirements of the Wagner-Peyser
Act, the Servicemen's Readjustment Act of 1944 as amended,
better known as the GI Bill, and the Veterans Readjustment Assistance
Act of 1952.
It
is the responsibility of the Veterans Employment Service and our State
VER's, in all of
the states and territories to exercise functional ‘supervision of the services
to veterans,
in the local employment offices of the state employment security agencies
to insure that
effective job counseling and employment placement are maintained for
veterans.
In other
words, it is their primary responsibility to see to it that the state
agencies are
carrying out through the local state employment services the policies set
forth by the
Secretary of Labor insofar as special services to veterans are concerned.
Let
and

give

you

an

me

very

example

briefly

go

over

of

we

are

how

our

five

attempting

major
to

responsibilities

carry

out

these

under

the

GI

Bill

responsibilities.

The

first, be functionally responsible for the supervision of the registration
of veterans
in local employment offices for suitable types of employment and for the
placement of
veterans in employment.
Our state veterans employment representatives go into the local
office of the various state employment security agencies, check
thz application cards,
check the employer orders to determine whether or not veterans are being
-given preference
and priority on job referrals.
;
information

The
as

second
to the

responsibility is to assist in securing and maintaining current
various types of available employment in public works and private
“35

industry

or

business.

I

believe

this

is

self-explanatory.

The third is to promote the interest of employers in employing veterans.
Our
state VER's, when they contact an employer, do not do so for the specific purpose of
soliciting a job order but to encourage that employer, qualifications being equal, to
give preference and priority in hiring to a veteran, and also to encourage employers to
set up a program of employing veterans.
No. 4 is to maintain regular contact with employers and veterans' organizations
with a view to keeping employers advised of veterans available for employment and veterans
advised of opportunities for employment -- in other words, inform the employer as to the
types of veterans that are seeking employment and that are registered in the various
employment service offices, and also to keep the veteran advised as to the type of jobs
that are available in the local employment offices.

the

The last:
Assist in every way possible
advancement of the employment of veterans.

in

improving

working

conditions

?

and

There are literally thousands of World War II and Korean veterans who took
advantage of their benefits under the GI Bill,
They furthered their education.
They
took advantage of opportunities for on-the-job training.
However, as they were going
on to school and furthering their education, or perhaps increasing their work skill in
on-the-job training, they took on family obligations, and, upon completion of their
training, they had to find a job.
So, literally thousands of World War II and Korean
veterans took the first job they could find.
We are taking it upon ourselves to try to
get these boys up to their highest working skills and to encourage many employers in
large plants, telling them that they no doubt have many men now employed in their respective plants that are working far beneath their highest skill.

I can't resist taking this opportunity to put in a plug for a strong employment
program within The American Legion.
When I say The American Legion, I mean every American
Legion Post.
If we of The American Legion have failed in anything, it has not been in
our American Legion program and our established policy, but, rather, in not letting our
communities know what The American Legion does insofar as its employment program is
concerned for its own members, what The American Legion stands for in its employment
program, and why.
I realize the importance of all the good work American Legion posts do in
all of their activities and I am a strong supporter,‘a very strong supporter of a strong
claims program, a good hospitalization program, and all the other service work that
American Legion service officers perform, but in my opinion, one of the most important
services that any American Legion post can perform is to help its members and other
veterans with their employment problems.

Let me give you a very, very surprising statistical example.
If every
American Legion post in the United States was responsible for the placement of only one
disabled veteran in a year, it would add $68 million to the income of veterans.
Now,
this figure is based on the average income of World War II veterans during the year
1953, and I am confident that it would be even higher today.
Let me repeat, if every
American Legion post in the United States was responsible for the placement of only

one

disabled

Now, ycu
per cent

veteran

in

a

year,

it

would

add

$68

million

service officers who are present today, think
compensation awards of pensions would have to

to

of
be

the

income

how many 10,
processed to

of

veterans.

20 or
equal

even
that

30
money.

So, in closing, I encourage each and every one of you, especially the service
officers,
to make yourselves available to your state VER.
If you have any particularly
tough placement problem, a severely handicapped veteran, by all means don't hesitate to
call upon our state VER.
Howeve:,
if you do have a veteran that just wanders into your
office seeking
employment,
refer that veteran to the local state employment service VER.
Finally,
tation

program

completed

I

know

that

is

concerned,

we

get

Thank

you.

when

MR.

the

BREMER:

you

veteran

Are

will

all

rehabilitation

there

on

any

a

agree

with

is

complete

not

satisfactory

questions

of

and

Mr.

me

that,
at

insofar
the

suitable

as

your

hospital

door.

rehabiliIt

is

job.

Omohundro?

Ed, I was wrong about your military affiliation and the reason why you went to
see rhe employment office in Colorado.
I got to thinking maybe you weren't even with the
Veterans
Employment Service but, after hearing that talk, I am sure that you are.
You are for the Veterans Employment Service.
Are
W.

there
J.

any

Harren,

questions?
the

Chief

of

Section
-36-

for

the

Bureau

of

Employees

Compensation

in

i

the Department of Labor
service since 1937.
In
Compensation.
It is my

is a native
that entire
pleasure to

of North Dakota and he has
period, he has served with
introduce Mr. Harren.

been in the government
the Bureau of Employees

MR. W. J. HARREN:
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
In view of the shortage of time,
I am going to limit myself to one observation.
The Compensation Act has been in existence
for forty years.
During that time its operations have been financed by direct appropriations by the Congress.
There is now proposed legislation which would place the burden
directly upon the various government establishments.
The proposal is to do it on a somewhat similar basis on which insurance premium
rates are based.
The purpose of this proposal is to place greater emphasis on the accident
prevention program throughout the United States.
Now with the shortage of time, I am
going to limit my observations to that, but I will be glad to answer any questions.

your coming,
tion.

MR. BREMER:
Are there any questions of Mr. Harren?
We certainly appreciate
Mr. Harren.
There was no intention of limiting you to such a short observa-

A little while ago Bruce Stubblefield introduced his assistant, saying that
the assistant was the man who did all the work.
He was spoofing, of course, but I am not
spoofing now when I say, on behalf of the Economic Commission, that I want to introduce
the man who does all the work -- Clarence Bird, Director of the National Economic Commission.
Clarence!
MR.

CLARENCE

W.

BIRD:

Well,

that

is

the

understatement

of

the

to introduce the guys who really do the work.
I just sit around and have
and I have two of the finest assistants in The American Legion and I want
how I got in the habit of passing the buck down and having everybody else

day.

I

I am an old department adjutant and I used to get the folks out in the
the 'blue-cap'" Legionnaires in the little posts up in Vermont, to do all the work
That is how I got kicked up to Washington.
I

you

service

want

to

introduce

officers

know.

And

ably

he

is

to

backed

you

up

my

by

able

assistant,

Austin

Johnnie

Mears,

want

a good time,
to tell you
do the work.

whom

a

field,
for me.

lot

of

Kerby.

My colleagues and I, every one of us here on the Economic Commission, appreciate
all of the fine cooperation we get from the field, and all.I can say is that we look forward
to serving you and if at any time we fall down on the job, please don't fail to send in the
complaints, because that will keep us on our toes.

and
but

I want you to know it has been a happy eleven years working for the Legion
I hope to have about eleven more and then I will be in Bruce Stubblefield's class -I am getting the guys to work for me before I get up to that 65 and social security.
Thank
MR.

you

very

BREMER:

much.

Thank

you

very

much,

Clarence.

That concludes the program for the Economic Commission and our panel presentation.
I want to thank every member of the panel who has participated.
I want to
thank you for your very fine attention to the program that was presented this afternoon.
On behalf of the Commission and the panel members, I really do feel that it would be
wonderful

there

are

CHAIRMAN KNIGHT:
Gentlemen, we now come to the
to VA Voluntary Services, and to lead the discussion group
Service Officer from Delaware.

part
will

problems

to

in

have

just

a

which

all

of

little

bit

us

participate.

can

more

time

because

Thank

many

facets

to

these

you.

Mr. Knight:

MR. THOMAS B. EGAN, Delaware:
Last
discussion by making the introductory remarks,
Mason who is the Director of Special Services.
brief.

of
be

our program devoted
Comrade Egan, Department

year at this conference I opened the panel
but I should have left that for Colonel
My remarks this year are going to be very

In recognition of the large part that the chaplaincy service plays in the VAVs
program, and the part that should be carried on by the department chaplains and the post
chaplains, we have the National Chaplain who will join our panel.
I would

like

at

this

time

to

introduce

-37-

the

members

of

the

panel.

The

first

one

that I would like to introduce (and later on each one will address the group) comes from
the American Legion Auxiliary, Mrs. Omar McMackin, Vice Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Committee of the American Legion Auxiliary, and she is also National VAVS tepresentative of the Ame.ican Legion Auxiliary.
Mrs. McMackin'
;

from

That
the

across

W.

man who needs no introduction to us all,
Delaware, Reverend Joseph MacCarroll.

Jackson

Korella,

Department

Service

known

Officer

and

beloved,

of Missouri

and

my

neighbor

long-time

Legionnaire.

will

I would
introduce the

noon

from

like now to introduce Colonel Mason, Director
members of his committee.
Colonel Mason!

MR.
A. S. MASON:
Mr. Chairman,
Ladies
and Gentlemen:
the Veterans Administration
Dr. Harry Kessler,
who is

affairs at the Veterans
for Patients' Discharge
Administration.
Mr.

Parke,

Administration and who also
Program which is
presently

who

is

the

Chief

of

the

they

will

have

something

is the
active

Voluntary

of

in

Special

Services,

who

There are here
this aftercharge of paraplegia

Coordinator of the Planning
in the hospital program of the

Service

Division

of

the

Veterans

Administration.

As

it

is

we

go

on,

to

Mr. Egan has been kind enough to ask me
particularly appropriate this afternoon that

history

of

the

founding

of

VAVS,

that

is,

Veterans

say

to

to make
I point

you.
a few remarks and I
my remarks somewhat

Administration

Voluntary

think that
toward the

Service.

think it is appropriate because this coming April, the week of April i5th, we
the tenth
anniversary of this program.
We will celebrate it with a ceremony
think will be most interesting and I hope memorable.

I

will celebrate
which I

Even so, I hesitate to speak about the history of the VAVS for I am sure
that many of you know about it, and particularly so those of you who have read The American
Legion Handbook for Volunteer Hospital Workers.
It is published by the National Rehabilitation Commission and, in my opinion, it is an excellent piece of work and, by the way,
it is the first of such booklets which has been published by any service organization.
1 congratulate the National Rehabilitation Commission and its National Chairman, Mr. McCurdy,
and its National Director, Mr. Kraabel, and his staff.
Hoping not to bore you but, for the sake of emphasis, I would like to read the
last paragraph of this booklet -- for the sake of emphasis because I think that it raises
something that I hope each and every one of you men and women will take to heart.
It is
entitled '"Jane and Joe."
"It is recognized clearly and universally that voluntary work in behalf of
others possesses a distinctive quality.
The impetus comes from the heart of the service
officer or hospital worker, each imbued to do the task at hand.
Rules and regulations
are difficult to apply.
However, the effectiveness of what the volunteer does in any field
is accentuated through coordination.
"With so many recognized groups available and eager to serve, a pattern of
operation had to be established.
Whereas The American Legion and Auxiliary many times
played a relatively lone hand in hospital and family visits of sick veterans during the
difficult years between the two world wars, it has readily adapted itself to the new order
and continues to play a leading role.
"Epitomized by many, many Janes who have become volunteer hospital workers, it
beckons and urges The American Legion to send ever more and more Joes to participate in
this nationwide program.
"/s/

Robert M. McCurdy, National Chairman
"National Rehabilitation Commission
"T.

"October

0.

Kraabel,

National

Director

1955."

If you will note, the emphasis
as I came into this meeting, say that the
(patting himself on the back) seem to pat

something

i

Well, it
for which

seems to
they can

is on the
Auxiliary
ourselves

Joes and I heard a certain comrade,
has done an outstanding work and we
on the back for it.

me that here is an excellent
pat themselves on the back.

-38-

opportunity

for

the

Joes

to

do

\

Now for a brief history of the VAVS.
At the end of World War II, the attention
of the American people was concentrated on the veteran, particularly the disabled veteran
in the VA hospitals.
The American people, men and women from every walk of life, came to
our hospitals to help serve those who had served their country so well.
It soon became
evident, as Mr. McCurdy has said, that some plan was needed so that VA could best use
these volunteer services and put the most meaning into their activities.
In
various

the

service

early

and

spring

welfare

of

1946,

officials

organizations.

The

of

the

VA

American

met

with

Legion

and

representatives
the

American

of

Legion

Auxiliary attended that meeting or were represented.
On April 15, this same group, who
had been given the name of the VA Voluntary Service National Advisory Committee, met again
after days of intensive work and recommended approval of the plan they had evolved, and
thus the VA Voluntary Service was born.
During the first year of operation, 55,000 men and women each month volunteered
thei. services and contributed three million hours in VA hospitals and domiciliaries.
Today an average of 86,000 volunteers, each one assisting in the hospital and domiciliary
program, are active in this movement and last year they contributed a total of 5,600,000odd hours of devoted and consecrated service to their fellow veterans.

give

In talking
the figure),

you

large

part

American

of

the

Legion

to Mrs. McMackin just
she called this to my

number

and

the

of

volunteers

American

Legion

and

before I came
attention and
of

the

hours

in here (and probably
I will say this, that

served

have

been

she will
a very

served

by

The

Auxiliary.

As to the history of the VA Voluntary Service, originally the volunteers served
only in the special service activities which then consisted of the recreation service, the
library service, the chaplaincy service, and the canteen service.
Today, volunteers are
serving in more than twenty-five different hospital programs.
There are today forty-one
national veterans' welfare and service organizations represented on the VAVS National
Committee.
Today, at the local level, the hospital or domiciliary level, there are over
four hundred different organizations and hundreds upon hundreds of individuals without
organizational affiliation who are serving in the 173 hospitals and domiciliaries.
Today, on an average, there are 110,000 patients and 17,000 domiciliary members
in VA hospitals and homes.
As you know, a good many of them will be there for days and
days and a good many of them will be there for years and years, and as times goes by,
the one-time friend ceases to visit Joe at the hospital.
Even the immediate families of
those in the hospital, the immediate families if they exist, cease to come.
Here is one
phase of the heart side of the program -- as Mr. McCurdy says, the service derives from
the heart -- bringing a touch of home and the community into the hospital or domiciliary;
and, of course, there are many, many other duties where volunteer assistance is found
necessary

as,

for

instance,

in

service,

physical

medicine

and

well and,
helped me

The volunteers have become a part of the hospital team to
to use the words of a veteran patient, I quote as follows:
toward recovery.
I bless every one of them."

Service

function?

.
I would
Division.

MR.

EGAN:

like

to

Would

the

dietetic

service,

rehabilitation,

introduce

to

you

over,

come

you

now

Mr.

just

the

nursing

to mention

service,

a

the

few.

pharmacy

help the veteran get
'Volunteers have

Mr.

Parke,

who

is

the

Parke,

and

make

an

explanation

Chief

of

the

of

Volunteer

your

MR. JAMES H. PARKE:
Mr. Egan, Mrs. McMackin, Ladies and Gentlemen:
Mr. Mason
has referred briefly to the history and background of VA Voluntary Service.
I would like
to underscore one aspect of that history and leave one ma jor point with you this afternoon.
It is a point on which all of us need your help over the next ten years of this program.
Mr. Mason mentioned our working together in the Voluntary Service program.
He
mentioned the 'sitting down around the council table on April 8, 1946, of three veterans'
organizations (The American Legion was one of the three) with each of their auxiliaries,
(obviously the American Legion Auxiliary was there), and two of our national welfare
groups.
From that "sitting down around the council table’ grew what we have come to know
as VA Voluntary Service.
In other words, the VA Central Office staff, in cooperation with
the national officials of three of the veterans' groups and their auxiliaries and two
of the national welfare groups, established this plan for meaningful volunteer service,
established a beginning, a blueprint to make volunteer assistance an integral part of the
care and treatment programs -- part of the care and treatment of the patients and domiciliary
members.
Now,

that

major

point

of

how

the

VAVS
-39-

plan

was

arrived

at

is

extremely

important.

It is important for us to remember that men and women of the VA staff and men and women
of the organizations sat down around the table and "talked out" this plan for a nationToday, ten years later, we are still sitting down around the
wide volunteer program.
council table.
It is now a somewhat larger council table.
As Colonel Mason has told you,
there are forty-one organizations working in this
program at 173 VA hospitals, men and
women of the VA staff and men and women from the veterans' and welfare and service groups
are sitting down around their council tables to plan for the most effective, the most
meaningful utilization of community volunteer assistance in over twenty-five different
hospital program areas -- from nursing service to library service, from physical medicine
and rehabilitation to dietetic service, and so forth.

!

The significance of this joint planning by the staff and the representatives
of the oiganizations was brought home to me when we were establishing plans for this year's
annual meeting of the National VA Voluntary Service Committee.
Colonel Mason told you
that we are combining our annual meeting this year with the observance of the tenth
birthday of VA Voluntary Service.

|

At our planning session last year, the Chairmen and Vice Chairmen of the three
subcommittees most directly concerned with the planning job were there in session.
These
subcommittees were the subcommittee on planning the meeting, the subcommittee on planning
the observance, and the subcommittee on public information.
Of that latter subcommittee,
I see back at the door our good friend Mr. Andy Andresen, who is chairman of that subcommittee, and his able vice chairman, Mr. Charles Drescher, a representative of the Jewish
War

Veterans.

The planning group chose Mr. Thomas Hinton of the National Catholic Community
Service to be their spokesman that afternoon with Mr. Higley, our Administrator, and with
Dr. Middleton, our Chief Medical Director.
Mr. Hinton is his organization's national
representative on the National VAVS Committee.
As his introduction to the presentation of the group's thinking to Mr. Higley
and Dr. Middleton, Mr. Hinton said this:
"I know of no other Government agency that has
established a plan such as the VA has established by means of which the voluntary organizations assisting in its program feel that they are part and parcel of the planning of the
programs in which they participate.
"The VA voluntary service program," Mr. Hinton went on,
significant undertaking in cooperation on a planned and continuing
and our country's voluntary organizations."

"a

unique

Joint planning
and significant

-- it seems
undertaking

to me that is the
in cooperation."

key

to

what

"is a unique and
basis of Government

Mr.

Hinton

|

f)

called

Now, the mainspring of our voluntary program -- and here is the point that I
particularly want to leave with you this afternoon and in which we need your help -- the
mainspring of the VAVS plan, from my point of view, is the VAVS Advisory Committee.
As
you know, there is one such committee at each VA hospital and domiciliary.
There is one
at the Central Office of the Veterans Administration.
Under the VAVS
VAVS Advisory Committee.
in the program.

plan, the means to achieve our
Obviously, then, the people on

essential joint planning is the
this committee are key people

The effectiveness of the program, I think, is determined by the effectiveness,
let's say, of the American Legion Auxiliary representative on the committee and her
alternate and by The American Legion representative and his alternate.
The program's
effectiveness depends not only upon you but upon the other organizations working with you.
It depends upon how effectively your representatives represent the Legion and the
Auxiliary.

He

must

the other

It depends,
see his job 2s

again, upon
a committee

organizations
and with
Of

course,

the

the effectiveness of the individual as a committeeman.
member and help to achieve the joint planning with

the

staff.

effectiveness

of

this

committee

also

depends

upon

the

VA

staff,

from the manager on down.
How much does the manager back this program?
How much does
he actively participate in it?
The effectiveness of the committee depends upon the
participation and active support of, for example, the Chief of the Nursing Service, as
well as all heads of the operating programs.

Mr. Mason mentioned The American Legion's admirable Handbook for Volunteer
Hospital Workers, the first such handbook published by a predominantly men's group in the
VA Voluntary Service program... I would like to add my commendation to that of Mr. Mason
for this most helpful contribution by Mr. McCurdy and Mr. Kraabel and their staff membeis.
It is one of the best guidelines to community volunteer participation that I have seen
-40-

{

|

0"

in my experience.
with which he sent
and domiciliaries.

I would like to read to you the last
copies of this excellent publication
Dr. Middleton wrote:

paragraph of Dr. Middleton's letter
to the managers of all VA hospitals

"You will, I know, agree with me that the issuance of such helpful guidelines
(as The American Legion's Hospital Handbook) for its members by a national organization
is most encouraging.
I feel sure that you will also agree that such a handbook gives
all of us in the VA who are'concerned with the VAVS program a valuable springboard for
reviewing our own responsibilities in this cooperative community-hospital endeavor.
With
this latter thought in mind I would urge you to familiarize yourselves with the contents
of the handbook for discussions with local representatives of the Legion.
In the event
you have established a VA Staff Advisory Committee on Voluntary Service (that is the
committee of staff members who assist in coordinating the program), I hope that
your staff
committee will make the handbook a subject of discussion at am early meeting,
along with
an analysis of opportunities for the most effective and meaningful utilization of the
assistance of men volunteers in your VAVS program."
I hope very much that we can expect and can get from you gentlemen of The
American Legion -- and I speak particularly to the men at this moment -- this important
bit of help.
The National Field Service officers visit regularly the VA hospitals.
I
hope that you gentlemen will familiarize yourselves with the Legion handbook, if you
don't know it already.
I hope that you will talk to the management of our hospitals and
ask them what opportunity they see from the point of view of participation by men in
the
volunteer program.
I hope you will look up your local representatives of the Legion and
the Auxiliary and talk with them about this program.
Ask them if they have discussed
with the hospital management this new handbook.
Let mesay to the National Field Service officers that I read your reports as
they come in where you mention the volunteer program.
You have a wonderful opportunity
at the hospitals to talk with you. people of the Legion and of the Auxiliary and with
the VA staff, to find out what particularly imaginative volunteer services are being done
by the women as well as the men, but we are particularly stressing participation by the
men now.
Then you can take this information to the next hospital where you go and spread
the word of this purposeful volunteer assistance in the care and treatment programs.

I hope also, Mr. Egan, if this is not out of order, that such imaginative
volunteer services might be mentioned in the reports that the National Field Service
officers send in.It would be very helpful, I should think, for your national
officers
to know about these services.
This assistance that I am asking from you gentlemen from
the National Field Service is not new to you.
You have already made a splendid start in
reporting the volunteer work being done.

post

I hope that
hospital chairmen

the department
will assist us

rehabilitation chairmen
along this same line.

and

the

department

and

Your VAVS representatives are doing an important job in this program.
In
my experience, where community participation has become a meaningful part of care and
:
treatment, the representatives on the VAVS committee have been the key people in helping
to assure this success, because this kind of coordinated effort doesn't just happen.
It
takes thinking and planning and working together.
I hope that you will give a well deserved pat on the back to these men and
women who are serving as your and the Auxiliary's VAVS Representatives.
They are doing
a job that is essential to the success of the volunteer program.
If, as our doctors tell
us, this is a meaningful service, a significant service, then these hard working VAVS
committee members are largely responsible for it.
You can be of immeasurable help to the program by telling throughout the country
this inspiring story of purposeful community participation in the care and treatment
programs for our veteran-patients and domiciliary members.
You can, by helping to tell
this story, help to make the next ten years of VA Voluntary Service an even more significant undertaking in cooperation between Government and our country's great veterans' and
welfare and service organizations.
MR.

you,

sir.

EGAN:

Thank

MRS.

JENNINGS,

I

Mrs.

am

Massachusetts,

The

you,

Mr.

Parke.

Massachusetts:

Jennings,

American

the

I would

Director

of

like

to

Volunteer

Legion.

ask

have

received

excellent

cooperation

Parke
for

the

a

question
Department

through
of

:

As part of our program, we have a fund set up for
year it was approximately $7,000.
We consult with the Chief
our hospitals and the manager as to the appropriate gift for
We

Mr.

Service

along

that

<4l=

line

and

it

our Christmas program.
This
of Special Services in all
their respective hospitals.
has

worked

very

wonderfully.

L

However, this year we have had an unusual request come
I am wondering if it is a change in the policy that we

from
have

one of our
adhered to

VAVS chairmen
in the past,

iho

and

The request from this particular VAVS chairman, brought to us by the Chief of
Special Services of his hospital, was that, instead of spending the $2000 that we do spend
in that particular hospital for a Christmas gift for each veteran, that that money be
turned over to the Chief of Special Services to permit him to purchase gifts that he thought
might be a little better, or perhaps give to those that needed more than others.
That,
years

and

I

of

just

course,

wanted

is

to

contrary

ask

you,

to

is

everything

that

a

that

change

in

we

have

done

for

the

last

ten

policy?

MR. PARKE:
May I ask, was this discussed at all with the people at the hospital?
You see, I have heard nothing about this.
It is completely new.
It does not follow any
policy we have.
You say your VAVS representative brought that request?

=
1d
~

MRS. JENNINGS:
That is right, it was presented to the meeting prior to planning
for the Christmas program, to approximately seventy-four representatives from equally as
many
posts of The American Legion.

War

MR. PARKE:
Actually, the Chief of Special Services, under policy, would
be allowed to accept this money, so there is something confusing somewhere there in
picture.
He could not accept the money in the first place, and follow the policy.

not
the

That is what I would suggest in this instance.
Here, again, the only way this
plan works is for men and women to sit down around the council table.
I feel here that
if anything comes up of this nature, or any other, your first move is to take it up with
the chief.
Is it for this coming Christmas or was it the past Christmas?

|
No, it is for the coming Christmas.

MRS. JENNINGS:
MR.

PARKE:

Would

MRS.

JENNINGS:

MR.

PARKE:

you

do

this?

Department

TI

would

ask

You

Director

this,

that

are

=--

of

VAVS

you

|

|

r

Program

request

b

in

your

this

VAVS

whole

state.

|

representative

to

go

|

back to the Chief of Special Services for a clarification at this point.
You have given
her, I
assume, your policy in the mattei, or perhaps she already knows it, in which case
if there is still any confusion, suggest she ask to discuss it with the manager,
Then, if
it

is

to

Ruth

not

clarified,

MRS.

but,
here

that

by

all

means

bring

it

to

Legion.

I

guess

your

department

and

would

it

McMackin.
JENNINGS:

I

am

I

take

it

can

to

T.

always

0.

or

come

|

Andy.

|

MR. PARKE:
You would take it to Mr. Kraabel oi: Mr. Andresen with the Legion
again, the key point there is that the Chief of Special Service (and Colonel Mason
to check me if I am wrong) would not be in a position to accept that money.
Is

right,

further,

Colonel

Mason?

COLONEL MASON:

That

MR.

PARKE:

I

MR.

SLONEKER,

Mr.

Parke.

of Special Services,
purchase gifts?

So,

I

is

right.

think

there

California:
see

that

through

the

the

§

,
i

is

[25
|

:

3
hig

I

must

be

I would
Colonel

some

like

has

manager,

confusion

to

carry

that

agreed

with

you

that

money

as

accept

there

somewhere.

question
but

a

little

couldn't

donated

the

funds,

bit

Chief

earmarked

to
1

that up.

MR.

PARKE:

MR.

SLONEKER:

Yes.

|

And

then,

in

fact,

he

could

accept

it?

I

just

wanted

to

[)
I

clear

COLONEL MASON:
You would have to understand that that would be a donation to
the general post fund, earmarked for a special purpose, and it would be spent according
to the purpose around which the donation was made.
There is, of course, the post fund
which can be handled that way.

|

Ie

J

§
|
|

MR.

YOUNG,

Kansas:

booklet that you have there.
follow the instructions, and
for

the

identification,

the

Tom,

this

question

is

in

relation

When we received thatin the field
I have placed an order through our
hat

identification

and

the

finally a month later, I think, reached the Executive
and behold, I later learned that the National Emblems
particular phase of the pamphlet regarding the making

star

to

the

"Joe

and

Jane"

we immediately set out to
National Emblem Division

mentioned

there,

and

my

letter,

|

Committee somehow or other and, lo
Sales had not been notified of this
up of these
materials.
Therefore,

A
}

-42-

[8]

we have not
information

received
on that?

them

yet.

I wonder

if

they

are

available

now

or

do

you

have

the

MR. KRAABEL:
Tom and Ken, we have this letter now from the National Emblem
Sales, that the arm band will be the same as featured in the current emblem catalog, 2
inches, embroidered emblem, eliminating '"post' and the post number, and lettered "Hospital
Worker," in small gold letters above the emblem.

bands
three

The price, in lots of 1, 6,
will not be carried in stock but
weeks for delivery.

10, and so forth, will be $2.25
furnished on special order only

each.
The arm
requiring two to

The small gold stars can be furnished in both gold and light blue at 5 cents
each in lots of 50, 100, and so forth.
The minimum quantity that can be ordered will be
fifty stars.
The stars will not be carried in stock but handled on a special order basis,
only, and also, two to three weeks will be required for delivery.
The basis for that, Ken, is that we are going to solicit inquiry and information
from the departments as to the amount that they may desire and try to group that in one
and get it over to the Emblem Division and have that many in stock for distribution as
you order from them.
Also,
the

hands

of

the

the

certificate

printer.

MR.

YOUNG:

MR.

KRAABEL:

MR. YOUNG:
Worker," with

Hospital

Then

for

the

number

That

is

the

the

hat

emblem

Which

latest
is

of

we

hours

have

worked,

on

that,

eliminated;

is

100

or

500,

is

now

in

Ken.
that

right?

emblem?

I thought the original
initials on it.

idea

was

a

little

hat

emblem

here,'Volunteer

MR. KRAABEL:
They have gone to the arm band
because they have that in original
stock by eliminating the post and number and putting in the words,
'Hospital Worker" and
they can do it at a better price.
That is subject to demand for any other type of emblem
that your organization may want as this program progresses and develops.
Would you favor
the one on the hat over the arm band?

it

is

the

request

MR. YOUNG:
Yes, we do, because we
especially made up for us.
We will
MR.
of

purchase a special hat.
It
get along with that fine.

KRAABEL:
1I think as the desire for any
the Emblem Division sufficient to alter

is

a Legion

change comes along, we
it to that end at that

can make
time.

hat

MR. YOUNG:
Tom, I have a question for Mr. Parke.
Last year, Mr. Parke, we
discussed the method of reporting volunteer workers and hours, you will recall.
Our particular criticism at that time was the fact that no mention was made (and I understand
at that time that no figures were available) setting out the number of hours from each
organization participating in your program.
Am I correct in the statement that you did
change the mode of reporting since that time, your form for reporting number of hours,
workers, and so forth?

is
do
of

MR. PARKE:
No, no change has been made insofar
concerned.
Those figures are available by organization
not come in to Central Office.
In other words, we make
each organization's participation.

MR. YOUNG:
I wonder if there would
those figures could not be compiled here, and,
be possible, say, for our Field Service people
regularly

for

reporting

be
in
of

any
the
our

as
at
no

reporting to Central Office
each VA hospital, but they
compilation here in Washington

reason why, in the first place,
second place, I wonder why it wouldn't
national staff to go into hospitals

services.

I wonder if in the individual hospitals, the special
have those figures not only of the Legion and of the Auxiliary,
available for other organizations.
I understand in some places
places it isn't done.

service people could not
but have figures made
it is done and in some

MR. PARKE:
That question has never been raised before.
The figures are available to each organization but your thought is that each organization should also have
available the figures of every other organization?
We haven't any plan on that.
MR.

YOUNG:

You

mean

you

have

no

directive

that

would

permit

that,

or

is

it

secret?

statistical

MR. PARKE:
No, no, the
information because we

information is there.
don't want to seem to

-43~

We have
have one

not publicized this
organization compete

a

EZ

but

against another.
any reason?
I am
MR.

Have you been asked for
trying to think through

YOUNG:

No,

I

haven't,

of obtaining those figures.
Of course,
along in relation to the other people.
MR.

PARKE:

That

is

such figures
on this.

but

our

field

so

am

I

would

I.

and

have

they

representative

I would

like

to

been

refused

for

has

and

he

is

desirous

know

how

we

are

getting
;

something

like

to

think

through

a

little

bit.

The
way we have tackled it is this:
Here in Central Office we did not publicize
that organizations X, Y and Z provided so many hours of service, because, you see, we felt
that that seemed to pit one organization against another.
For example, we don't publicize
the number of volunteers participating in Hospital X as opposed to Hospital Y, these
hospitals
being of the same type, because that would seem to pit one against the other
.
in competing for more volunteers.
I would be glad to go into that with you and see
make of it and see what would be involved from the point of
I just frankly don't know.
We have never had it brought to
review and
committees

4

what use you would like to
view of usage across the country.
us before.

Is this fair, Mr. Kraabel, to suggest that that be brought
maybe we could discuss it in either the National Committee
as a helpful way of tackling the subject?

up
or

as a matter of
one of the sub-

MR. KRAABEL:
I would say to the presiding officer, Mr. Parke, that certainly
it could be a conference recommendation and we could do our very best on it.
I understand readily Ken's view and his wishing to try to measure up on how we are doing in
relation to others participating in the same activity.
It is a good stimulus to improve
the activity and I think that is what Ken had in mind.

how

about

MR.

YOUNG:

Do

you

want

a

MR.

EGAN:

Yes,

I

think

that

MR. YOUNG:
drafting up
MR.

MR.
recommendation

Is there
something

recommendation,
a

recommendation

a member of
on that and

RULON:

I

YOUNG:
of that

Why don't we get the
type?
Otherwise, we

just

walked

in,

Tom?
is

in

order,

Ken.

the Recommendations Committee
we will work it over?

Ken.

You

draft

it

and

we

authority of the group
have to go back to the

will

here?

George,

consider

it.

here now to pass
group with it.

a

MR. EGAN:
What we will have to do is this:
The sum and substance of the
recommendation which you wish is to move this, that the conference g0 on record as
recommending a summarization of the VAVS participation in each respective hospital
throughout the country, that it be coordinated in a uniform Central Office report which
shall be available to all participating organizations.
MR.

YOUNG:

Right.

MR.

EGAN:

Is

there

a

MR.

BROWNING,

Rhode

Island:

MR.

EGAN:

All

those

second

in

favor;

The question that I would like
referred to by Ken, is that being carried
on the market within the next month?

MR.
he has
other,

will

the
and

most

KRAABEL:

Carl

hasn't

the

second

motion?
the

motion.

opposed.

to
in

ask
the

So

ordered.

T. 0. is
new 1956

this:
emblem

T. O., on the
catalog which

that

he has

insignia
is coming
[

indicated

original one that shows the
of course the gold star, we
MR. EGAN:
Carl
likely go out to

to
I

to us,

Tom,

post and post number,
already have that.

usually follows those up
all of the departments.

with

which

a cut

page

is

it in there

but

the

basis

for

the

itemization,

and

it

The VAVS program has been in existence since 1946.
As we approach the tenth
anniversary of the VAVS program we are asked:
What is new?
It is a program that is ever
old and always new.
The thing that we are asking our departments,
the posts, the units
and the respective members of the Auxiliary, from national on down, is to protect
that
considered thinking which you have given to those who have been in need,
our assistance
and service while they are hospitalized -- to provide an extension of that,
to provide
that which is necessary for their rehabilitation in their own community, a participation
and extension of discharge planning.
As the man who is adequately and completely versed

bl -

|
]

|

|

|

in the special needs of that particular class of veterans, our paraplegics, their needs
and the care they have had in the hospital, and what must be done to provide for them so
that they may return as useful members to their own home communities, I would like to
have Dr. Kessler's comments.
DR.
the

HARRY

standpoint

includes

not

KESSLER:

Thank

of

the

program

only

the

needs

abled veterans
who
families,
to thei.

of

of

you,

Mr.

Egan.

planning

for

the

the

paraplegics

have problems
in returning
family environment,
to the

but

I would
patient's

also

the

like

to

discharge,

needs

of

to the community
and in
community
environment.

speak

primarily

because

other

that

seriously

readjusting

from
program

to

distheir

Some years ago we determined that it was very important to have the community
come into the picture in this problem of a discharge plan.
While for the most part patients
who are admitted to theveterans' hospitals do not have any particular problem at the time
of discharge, we found that a small number of these individuals did have such problems.
A number of them, upon being discharged, following careful treatment, returned to the
hospital after a varying period of time because the community had not been prepared to
take these people under their wing, into their homes, into their hearts.
For many years now we have felt that the community has a definite responsibility
in taking up the care of these discharged patients, and so the program of planning for
the patient's discharge came into being.
It was a formalized
program developed in such
a manner that when a patient was found to have some problem upon his discharge, there
could come into the picture the representatives of the community by means of representatives
of the VAVS within the hospital.
That group, known as the Steering Committee, about which many of you know,
I am sure, has taken up a number of these problems at many of our hospitals and has brought
these problems back intd the community and has resolved them so that patients who ordinarily
might not have been discharged for prolonged periods of time, or who, upon being discharged,

would

not

have

been

able

to

remain

in

the

community

for

any

considerable

period

of time -- those patients now were able to come out with a prepared plan of community
cooperation, community responsibility, and have now been able to adjust themselves so that
they have a useful life in the community ~-- useful not only in terms of personal happiness,
of familial happiness, but also useful in terms, in many instances, of being able to contribute, themselves,
to the community welfare.

ee

I think that we have only just begun to scratch the surface of that program.
What we have seen thus far has been extremely encouraging and it has spread with extreme
rapidity over many areas of the country.
As a matter of fact, last November the Chief
Medical Director sent out a letter indicating that this program, which up to that time
had remained centralized, was now to be decentralized to the respective area medical
offices.
In other words, it brought the program closer to the field and the field then
did not have to come to Central Office for authority to establish such a program or to
develop various aspects of orientation of personnel, and so forth, but could now come
to the area medical office for that purpose.
Notwithstanding that decentralization, Central Office remains in the
of assisting the area offices as well as the field stations in the promulgation
program and in its further development.

done an
for its

position
of the

I think that The American Legion Handbook, which was mentioned earlier, has
excellent job in bringing that program to the attention of the field, and we hope
further extension not only within the hospitals but, more important, within the

communities.

Thank

MR.

EGAN:

you.

Thank

you,

Dr.

Kessler.

We have heard from the Veterans Administration representative a plan for a
program that they would like to have done and how we can try to accomplish it.
We have
very distinguished representative here, an outstanding member of the American Legion
Auxiliary, Vice Chairman of the National Rehabilitation Committee of the Auxiliary, and
the National VAVS Representative, who is here to tell us how they are doing the program
the Legion gets the credit for.
Mrs. McMackin!
MRS.

OMAR

McMACKIN:

Thank

you,

Mr.

Chairman.

Mr.

McCurdy,

Mr.

Kraabel,

a

Members

of the Panel and our Co-Workers:
This morning you heard our National Chairman, Mrs. Zeller,
refer
to the rehabilitation program of the American Legion Auxiliary as the House of
Rehabilitation.
In this House of Rehabilitation service in the hospitals is the largest
room.
We of The American Legion and Auxiliary are very proud of the privilege of having
a part in this panel and we thank you, Mr. McCurdy and Mr. Kraabel and all of you members
of The American Legion, for this opportunity to tell you of the work that our twenty
thousand volunteer workers of the American Legion Auxiliary are doing in the hospitals
throughout this country.

-45-

You heard Mr. Mason say that
I am happy to report that approximately
our American Legion Auxiliary workers.

nearly five
two million

million hours were donated last
of those hours were volunteered

We are proud to go into the hospitals and serve you: buddies.
We
to go into the hospitals and give them that smile, that kind word, that word
ment that helps not only the mentally but the physically ill.

do

not

want

We have been
any credit.

working for many
We do it because

years in the Auxiliary
we love to do the work

and
for

in the
you.

year.
by

are happy
of encourage-

hospitals.

We

In caring
for
the disabled
and in working
in the hospitals,
we have
tried
to
carry out the mandates
of the VA,
the Veterans
Administration.
As the representative
of
the American Legion Auxiliary on the VAVS Committee,
I have
tried
to follow
the wonderful

reputation of the representatives who have served on that
ment.
It is a pleasure to work with the personnel of the
with the representatives of our brother American Legion.

committee previous to my appointVeterans Administration and also

With the celebration coming up in April, we of the American Legion Auxiliary
will be very proud to take our place along with the forty other national organizations.
We are going to publicize this celebration because we want all of our members to
know that
we are proud to be a part of the Veterans Administration Voluntary Services.
We have carried out your program in every way that is possible.
We are calling
our program this year a chain of service, serving more and more.
Being a volunteer hospital
worker myself and traveling over seventy miles to the hospital one way and then working
eight hours and then traveling back that seventy miles gives a person much time to think
of
those boys that one has served during the day.
Mr. Egan said I am going to tell you how we carry out the program.
I want
to tell you and to thank the members of The American Legion for joining ranks with the
American Legion Auxiliary and serving as "Joes'" so now we have a partner for a '"Jane'.
We are revising our Guide for Volunteer Hospital Workers and we have taken a chapter out
of your Legion book and there will be a paragraph at the close of our Guide asking more
"Janes" to join with '"Joe'" and asking also for more "Joes" to join with "Jane.
I would like to ask the cooperation and the assistance of all of the Legionnaires
present in all of the departments to help get more "Joes" and to also get more ''Janes'.
We could use fifty thousand volunteers.
I do not need to tell you that the load in the
hospitals is getting greater each day, each week and each year, which necessitates our
having

more

volunteers,

and

invite

more

volunteers

to

Our

Rehabilitation

National

We visited
in your areas.
same enthusiasm
from both

so

join

We
the

won't

you,

our

ranks?

BO~N<™MmW®

EGAN:

Thank

you

Committee

travel

has

just

through

your

completed

departments,

five

area

presented our program.
Everywhere
we went,
Legionnaires
and the Auxiliary members,
and

our conferences,
that is, the Panel
which I should like to repeat.

MR.

when

you,

on

Services

in

the

we
so

hospitals,

with

this

Service is a beautiful word.
stands for Serve the veteran all
stands for Entertainment
- give
for Rehabilitation, each one all
for Volunteer Service every day,

the
him
the

year,
cheer,
way,

Initiate

a

program,

and

little

verse,

kind,

Choose what is best and relieve his
for Encouragement and peace he must
Mrs.

conferences.
found
the
we closed

mind;
find.

McMackin.

We are going to try to get a general response from the floor on the type
kind of participating interest which is shown in respective departments in the VAVS
I am going to call on my good friend Jackson Korella to speak for the Department of
Missouri and the posts and departments in that area.
W.

JACKSON

KORELLA,

Missouri:

Mr.

Chairman,

Bob,

T.

0.:

First

of

all,

and
program.

I

want

to say that the people who are in the VAVS program are dedicated men and women.
They could
not be otherwise because they are following through on the teachings of the Lord and Master,
of being the Good Samaritan.
Since this organization of The American Legion is dedicated
to God and to Country, it is well to remember that those in the volunteer services are
godly men and godly
women.
They are dedicated to the task that the veteran in the hospital
is, indeed, their neighbor and their brother.
If there are present here some who have never been through a mental institution,
operated by the Veterans Administration, I beg you, please go.
You will have your eyes
opened to something that you never would contemplate otherwise, mentally or spiritually.

~46-

Let me tell you that, unfortunately,
them in a VA mental hospital because
the family name.
For shame on those

we have members of veterans'
of the fear that there might
people.

families who never
be a stigma placed

visit
on

I am leading up to something here that I think you will appreciate.
We in
St. Louis, have a mental hospital.
‘We have locked wards.
We have one individual in the
hospital who had not spoken one word for ten months. He was, according to the psychiatrist,
the gravest introvert that he had ever encountered.

in

St.

Louis

Now, then, what is the
are doing about it.

Legion

doing

about

this

thing?

I can

tell

you

what

we

We have one program that has now been taken over by the Eleventh and Twelfth
Districts of St. Louis, that has done more to bring the locked-ward veteran to reality
than anything else that could have happened.
That is not my statement.
That is the
statement of the manager and
psychiatrist in charge.
It does not cost very much and the satisfaction that you get in doing those
things that help your fellow man are well worthy of the time and money.
Every month we
have a certain number of locked-ward patients brought in to an excellent dinner.
We sit
around the table with these patients, both the staff of the mental hospital and the volunteer
workers.
I mentioned a moment ago that we have a veteran who had not spoken a word for
eleven months.
After twenty minutes at this table where they were served an excellent
dinner and where fellowship was the watchword, this veteran finally saw the light.
He
could see that there was no hatred on the part of those who were present.
He had the
complex that people were about to execute him for some unknown reason.
I am

here

to

tell

you

that

that

cost

is

particular

patient

is

well

when

stop

on

the

road

to

recovery.
It

so

happens

that

the

very

minor,

you

to

consider

the

amount

of good that it does.
Serving a dinner for some twenty-five persons will not cost you
over $40.
Our Central Executive Committeeof the Eleventh and Twelfth Districts took up the
torch where the smaller posts could not carry it.
It had been a matter where the individual posts and the Auxiliary units got together and put on these lunches every month.
When you have only twenty or twenty-five members in the post and the post is poor, it
cannot

be

done.

So,

the

Central

Executive

Committee

took

this

program

over,

after

as-

certaining the amount of good that it was doing towards rehabilitation of the mentally
ill.
We have a duty to that veteran.
That was the precept upon which our Eleventh
and Twelfth Districts operated.
They set aside enough money in the budget for the next
year, to carry on this program, not one month or two months but throughout the year, and
if that isn't enough we will dig deeper and we will get the job done.
The cooperation of the VAVS. program and the Special Services people in_our
hospitals in St. Louis has been nothing short of remarkable.
We .carry on our program
in the GM&S hospital once a month.
We have a bingo deal which is enjoyed by all of the
veterans who are able.
It doesn't cost much.
For a $10 bill you can amuse those veterans
for an entire afternoon in a bingo game.

and

sit

in

There are
the game.

a

few

members

of

the

different

posts

who

can

take

an

afternoon

off

Last Christmas your American Legion in St. Louis, along with other organizations,
raised a fund to go into all the veterans' hospitals in the area, both the Cochran Hospital,
the Jefferson Barracks Hospital, and the Koch Hospital for Tubercular Diseases.
The
donations made came close to $1000.
There was money enough to furnish every patient in the
three hospitals a certificate for $1 on Christmas morning with which to buy cigarettes or
anything else that he wanted.
We

feel

I could
to you mice people
departments, I can

that

that

is

part

of

our

rehabilitation

talk here for the next two
so, in closing, and before
only say this:

program.

days but that would
asking for a report

be entirely too boring
from various state

As

we travel along this highway of life
Let us be kind, considerate, forgiving,
Forget all otr worry, our envy and strife,
For then alone is life worth living,
Give to your fellow man a helping hand,
For that is the road that leads to Happy
I

thank

you.

yy

Land.

MR. EGAN:
The hour is getting late and I have a special message that I want
to give you.
We are going to have the National Chaplain.
He has a special message to
deliver on Thursday afternoon at the time that the medical panel is discussed in this
conference.
I

short

would

remark

word

or

such

to

words

introduce

again

our

as

care

to

he

may

good

say

friend,

at

this

THE REVEREND JOSEPH MacCARROLL:
Thank you
Don't ever give a preacher a second chance

now.

MR.

EGAN:

CHAIRMAN
Chairman

like

of

afternoon.

the

I

now

McCURDY:

Committee,

Clinton,

turn

I

the

Thank
Clinton

thank

you

panel
you,

back
Tom,

Knight,

who

to

and
has

National

Chaplain,

very much, Chairman
again, though.

Chairman
first
so

the

for

a

I have

no

time.

Bob.

I want

ably

Tom.

to

thank

conducted

our

the

fine

meetings

Vice
this

sincerely.

I think that just before I close, I would like very much to have Mrs. McMackin
come up here and stand by me a moment.
I always enjoy the ladies, and particularly when
they give poetry, and I am quite a poet myself.
I don't know what it is going to be yet
but I am thinking hard right now.
Service is needed everywhere
But sometimes service is laggin';
Don't just sit and hold your hand,
Call out for Mrs. McMackin.

Now, in addition to poetry, you heard about this pat-on-the-back deal.
I am
not too good at that, myself, but I am good at patting the ladies, and this is an official
pat from me to the Auxiliary and I want you to know how much we do appreciate it and how
we are thoroughly familiar with the wonderful work that you do.
I know I express the
thanks of every member of this conference when I say, from the bottom of our hearts, we
thank you.
So, there is the official pat.

thanks

back

MRS. McMACKIN:
Thank you very much, Chairman McCurdy, and I shall take
to our near million members of the American Legion Auxiliary, nyself.
CHAIRMAN

we

McCURDY:

Is

there

anything

further

to

come

before

this

panel

those

before

adjourn?

members

of

MR,
the

SLONEKER:
Mr.Chairman, if I may take the
Recommendations Committee to meet with me

privilege,
I would like for
for about five minutes after

recess.

that

hour,

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We
we will be in recess.

will convene at nine o'clock tomorrow morning.
Until
Nine o'clock tomorrow morning and please be prompt.

(The

at

meeting

adjourned

five

o'clock,)

-48-

the
you

WEDNESDAY MORNING SESSION
February 29, 1956

The

Commission,

meeting

convened

at

nine

o'clock,

Mr.

C.

C.

Horton,

Vice-Chairman

of

the

presiding.

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Take your places, ladies and gentlemen, and the conference
will come to order.
I believe I note the absence of the Chaplain this morning and we will
dispense with the invocationfor the time being.
At this time I am going to
Officer for the State of Michigan, to
the panel this morning.
Mr. Seaman!

ask Mr. Carleton L.
take over.
He will

Seaman, the Department Service
introduce the participants on

MR. CARLETON L. SEAMAN, Michigan:
Thank you, Mr. Horton.
Comrades and Ladies:
In the interest of expediting the discussions germane to the subject matter of this program,
we are going to forego all opportunities to make a speech.
We recognize the time limitations that we do have and your panel moderators will try to control debate so that the
questions can receive consideration within the time allocated to the panel.
It should be said at this time, however, that we are conscious of the thinking
and the expressed opinions of many groups, including some of our congressmen and other
non-veteran elements, who would like to see the veteran restricted to present benefits
rather than see those benefits extended.
It would appear well, therefore, in our deliberations for us to watch carefully the recommendations emanating from the panel and
from this conference so that we can accomplish our objectives rather than jeopardize any
of our obtained benefits.

hope,

to

So, we will expedite this
your entire satisfaction.

panel

as

rapidly

as

possible

and

keep

it

moving,

I

I should first like to introduce the Legion members of the panel and start off
with Willie C. Shorter, Department Service Officer of the Department of Colorado; Mr. Fred
Browning, whom some of our conferees are calling the other old man on the panel.
He is
the Department Service Officer of Rhode Island.
Fred Browning!
MR.

BROWNING:

MR.

SEAMAN:

Where
That

do

idea

you

get

that

"old

man"

stuff?

was

generated

out

in

corridor,

the

Fred.

We also have George Deris, who is the Department Service Officer for the Department of Louisiana; Mr. Walter Kownaski, who is Assistant Regional Service Director for the
Department of New York; and over on the more distinguished side of the panel we have our
very, very good friend Ralph Stone, who has been with the Veterans Administration for ten
years, whom I first knew and associated with very closely in Columbus, Ohio, and who is
the Chief Benefits Director, Veterans Administration.
Ralph, will you please introduce
the members of the Veterans Administration?
MR, RALPH H. STONE:
Thank you.
Gentlemen of the Rehab Conference and Ladies:
It is a pleasure to be here again to meet with you.
I am just rather astounded at the lack
of the old-timers'
faces that we are so familiar with, but we certainly welcome the new
and younger men into this great work that the Legion does through its rehabilitation program
I have been a member of it and a part of it for many years and realize the great importance
to your communities that you men and women are in these field operations.
We in Central Office realize that practically the whole strength of the Veterans
Administration lies in our field, our Regional Offices, hospitals, and our VA Offices, so
we have during the past two or three years given every possible support and hope to build
stronger and better offices.
The Administrator has delegated a great deal of authority to the Regional
Managers and we are hoping that they will take hold of it and build their offices in
better and stronger manner.

a

So, it is a pleasure to be here to meet with you and I hope that I will have
& chance to talk with some of you later, personally, about certain conditions.
I always
welcome your thinking, your recommendations, your fault-finding, anything that you have
in connection with our work is gladly received by me because you are our eyes and ears to
a certain extent.
You can spark-plug our work to better workmanship and you can help in
4 great way in doing a better job for the veteran.

hasn't
by the

There is one thing that I would just like to express at this time.
It really
anything to do with claims work, but yet it has.
We are beset all over the country
alleged selling of the veteran's eligibility rights on our housing program.

«49

Recently a survey was made in one of cur states and I just recently received
a copy of the
survey.
They estimate that over two thousand veterans have sold their eligibility
rights for
gums anywhere from fifty to two hundred, to four hundred dollars,
to salesmen who, in turn,
then resell the house.
The veteran sometimes is left holding the bag and he is held responsible for the guarantee of that mortage.
They don't know that.
I wish that you, in all of your areas, would bring to
everybody's attention the seriousness of selling his eligibility for a mortgage
guaranty.
The veteran practically swears that he is buying that house to live in, to use as
his home.
Yet, we have instance after instance where he never lives in that house.
He signs for it.
The deed is made, he then signs a deed in blank and the salesman fills that
in to whomever
he sells it to.
We
to

the

FBI

for

have

tried

to

police

it.

We

Now,

the

danger

investigation.

in claims works especially,
veteran he is endangered of

is the
losing

have

referred

many

all

this

and

fact that that if there
all of his benefits now

is
or

of

cases,
where

as
it

a fraud on
forever.

we

have

comes

into

the

part

to

do,

your

work

of

the

We are trying, through the newspapers and every other means possible, to get
to them a warning, but I think that you, through your local, your state papers,
your national
papers, can carry that a little further so that all are warned of the great dangers
to them
personally, or to their dependents in the future.
;
So, do what you can to keep our boys going straight.
They don't think they want
to buy a house.
They are not married, they are not interested, but tomorrow they may be
and they may want a house, and their right is gone.
So, I think it is up to all of us to
do everything possible to the nth degree to be sure they know the dangers of doing anything
of this kind.
We have with us our panel here from the Veterans Administration and I would
first like to introduce William Driver, the Director of Compensation Claims.
Mr. Driver
is new to most of you.
I found him in Central Office and know of his sterling character and
his full knowledge of our work.
I realized the need for youth in our department, as I looked
out here this morning and saw so many younger men here.
My choice, of course, would have
been for the Director of the Compensation Claims, the man whom I consider has earned
it
through the years and has performed outstanding work, and if there was such a
position, I
certainly would like to make Henry Brooks Director Emeritus -- but we must get some
young
people into our claims work.
In our offices and in our Central Office operation, the average
age is very high.
We have lost practically all of the younger men who came in as adjudicators,
clerks, rating board work. RIF's that have come through the years have been tremendous
and
we have lost a great many of these younger men, so I guess the only way that we can do
is
to put them in at the top and start them down, as we say, because they will have to be protected.
The age is so high that the men are retiring and we are going to be at a great loss.
It is necessary and vitally important
this work and it will be so important to all of us
not end with the life of World War I veterans.
It

I will

call

I would like to present
him Director Emeritus.

to

And

Mr.

the

Mr.

Reinmuth,

Mark

Robson,

Hinton,

who
the

the

is

you

Mr.

that we
through
will go

Brooks,

the

get the younger war veteran
the years ahead, because it
on probably forever.

Assistant

3

Assistant
Assistant

Director

of

Dependents’

Rating

Schedule

Director

for

These

have

into
will

Claims.

Claims.

Director.
in

the

work.

men

carried

on our work for many, many years in a most admirable manner: a grand manner; and we do honor
them and appreciate the fine work that they have been doing through these many, many years.
you

want

Veterans

to

So,
do.

we hope you will have a very fine conference and
I am very glad to have had the opportunity to be

MR. SEAMAN:
Administration.

Thank

you,

Mr.

Stone,

and

we

welcome

you

accomplish
here.

everything

gentlemen

from

that

the

If I remember correctly, my procedure on these panels in times past has been
this:
It has been the practice of the moderator of the panel to read the questions and
recognize from the floor the gentleman who presented them for any contribution on his part,
and then ask the Veterans Administration for their answer or their solution.
The panel
moderators have split these questions up among themselves.
I will ‘take about the first four
and we will introduce one of the other members to proceed to the next point.
Is Mr.

Dennis

The
in

first question is presented by Mr. Dennis
the room?
Is there anyone from Maine who

-50-

of the Department of Maine.
would like to comment on the

question submitted by Mr. Dennis?
In his absence, we will be glad to have you do that.
The question reads:
''Why should not x-ray evidence of tuberculosis condition of progression
be sufficient for an award inasmuch as modern medication may make positive sputum cultures,
et cetera, difficult to obtain?
:

for

If

there

anyone

from Maine

who

Dr.

Brick

from

the

Rehabilitation

National

would

like

a minute.

actions of
people who

to

comment

on

Commission,

that?
would

like

to

talk

on

that

DR. BRICK:
There are several unresolved problems with reference to the rating
tuberculosis at the present time, ‘seme of them occurring because the VA rating
are represented here have not caught up with the recent medical advances in

tuberculosis.

This

is

not

their

fault,

because

these

cases

decided and then when we get a backlog of cases we expect,
yet been made except in our own shop, to have a conference
specialists in the VA on several points.

have

to

come

in

and

then

be

althrough the overtures have not
with the rating people and the TB

A little background, I think, of what is going on in TB is quite interesting
in that with chemotherapy, with these modern drugs that are being used in tuberculosis,
a
good many of these veterans who have tuberculosis are being discharged from hospitals
sooner
than they used to be; they are being treated surgically because of the suppression
of the
organisms by these drugs, whereas in the older days they could not be treated surgically
so that a good many advances in the treatment of tuberculosis have been made.
.
Furthermore,
inished

are

because

being

of

the

discharged

a

all

of

you

know

fact

that

nowadays

lot

sooner

than

that
in

they

the
the

used

urgency

for

tuberculosis

beds

treatment

of

tuberculosis,

these

to

be.

has

dim-

patients

Now, where does that leave us so far as rating actions are concerned, with which
you are particularly
interested this morning?
X-ray evidence of tuberculosis is always a
bugaboo when a doctor tries to explain it to a lay group. The x-ray does not tell
what the
status of the tuberculosis is so far as activity is concerned.
The only thing the x-ray
can tell is that there is a shadow in the lung that has to be investigated from the clinical
point of view to determine whether there is activity.
I think the VA takes a moderate
stand on the point that if a cavity, if a hole is actually demonstrated by the x-ray,
they
are willing to concede activity, and I think from the medical point of view that
is correct.
Now, the question asks:
"Why should not x-ray evidence of tuberculosis con- dition of progression be
sufficient for an award?
If the x-ray does show progression, if
the infiltration for instance, is increasing, if a cavity appears where a cavity
had not
been present, in most cases -- and I think this has reference probably to Part
III more than
to

service-connected

cases

--

I

think

in

most

cases

the

VA

does

go

along

with

that.

He points out, "Modern medication may make positive sputum cultures, et cetera,
difficult to obtain."
This is very, very true, because some of these patients, veteran
patients who are seen on the outside before they go into a VA hospital are given
medication
by the doctor and a positive sputum or culture may be extremely hard to come by.
We have
' seen cases where a veteran gets a routine x-ray in a survey in a county or city
health
department suivey, a suspicious lesion is seen, he goes to his doctor and the doctor
doesn't
do any of the studies that the VA wants done such as sputum culture, gastric cultures,
et

cetera,

find any
doesn't

but

starts

him

on

The patient may
positive sputums or
mean that he didn't

medication.

not do very well and he goes to a VA hospital and they
positive bacterial cultures because of the medication.
have active tuberculosis.

can't
That

Now, these are some of the problems that have to be ironed out.
One problem
that has been taken cognizance of by the Area E rehab meeting was the business of Extension
6 and this is something we ought to hear from the people on my left about.
As you know,
Extension 6 ratings used to be based primarily on the fact that when a fellow
gets pneumothorax, they give him 100 per cent for two years automatically, and then they determine
the
cut-off date after that period of time.
In some of the cases now, however, that have been
brought to our attention by people in our office and by people in the field,
when the
patient is discharged from the hospital with a negative culture or negative sputum
because
of chemotherapy, the cut-off date in Extension 6 is being made from the time
of discharge
when they declare him arrested, this despite the fact that the veteran leaves
the hospital
and is on chemotherapy recommended by the Medical Board in the hospital to stay
on chemotherapy for six months or eight months or nine months, as the case may be.
. It is our feeling in our shop that this is incorrect, that as long as these
Patients are on chemotherapy they should not be considered for a cut-off date
so far as
the 100 per cent is concerned, but should only be considered , for the cut-off date
when
the chemotherapy has been completed.
We think from a medical point of view, for instance,
that chemotherapy is no different from pneumothorax or
pneumoperitoneum, so this is one of
the problems we want to get thrashed out.

51s

There is one problem with which I have been greatly concerned at the present
time.
An increasing number of cases are coming in from the field with the problem of
so-called tuberculoma.
What is a tuberculoma?
A tuberculoma is a lesion seen on x-ray;
it is a round little shadow and the reason these patients have to be operated upon is
because
medical science cannot always differentiate between an infection and a cancer, and of course
if there is a possibility of a cancer and it is a little thing, the doctors want to go
in
and take it out as soon as possible because in some cases these patients can be cured.
It
These

are

turns

lesions,

out

these

that
are

a fair
little

number

round

of

areas

these

are

caused

by

what

is

known

tuberculosis

as

tuberculomas.

which

have

become

extremely localized.
They do not cause systemic symptoms; they do not cause the symptoms
that all of you are familiar with, they are caused by active pulmonary tuberculosis, and
yet when these lesioms are removed, they are examined under the microscope, the report comes
back that these are tuberculomas, that they are lesions caused by tuberculosis.
Now, in some cases, actually, the active bugs can be seen.
They can actually
demonstrate the tuberculosis organisms.
In other cases the tuberculosis organisms cannot be
demonstrated directly but the pattern of the microscopic findings is such that everyone is
sire that this is caused by tuberculosis.

Now, what about the rating of these?
It has been a very difficult problem and
I am not going to criticize my friends over here on the left particularly, because we have
got other people to criticize, too, particularly the Board of Veterans Appeals.
We are
getting all sorts of decisions, one rating board saying this, one rating board saying that,
these people saying one thing and the BVA saying quite another thing.
It is our feeling
that when a tuberculoma is demonstrated within the presumptive period for tuberculosis and
if the organisms are found in the section, that they should be considered as active pulmonary
tuberculosis and the same ratings apply for them as apply for active pulmonary tuberculosis.
We have a case now in the works which is a test case, which Mr. Stone's shop
sent up to the Chief Medical Director and his TB expert said that this is the equivalent
of active pulmonary tuberculosis.
We are awaiting with interest the rating action in the
field on this case because if they come back and give him a zero per cent rating, we are
going to scream about this particular case.

We have a case exactly similar that the Board of Veterans Appeals has completely
denied anything but a zero per cent service-connection, and we are going to take that up
with the Administrator here, that is, the Veterans Benefits Administrator.
All of you people are writing letters in about these cases, why can't you get
these people the statutory award?
Well, if the VA rating boards say that active pulmonary
tuberculosis has never been demonstrated or has not been demonstrated by the criteria of
the VA rating actions, they are not going to allow the statutory award.
We feel that in
these cases the minimum rating should be the statutory award and we are not yet able to
get this .
So, this is a question that has not been resolved.
We think there are a lot
of things happening in the tuberculosis field that are going directly or indirectly to
affect rating actions with reference to TB and I think some of these things have got to
be thrashed out between the medical people in the VA and these people on my left, and in our
shop when we get more cases accumulated.
I now

have

four

cases

of

tuberculomas

on my

desk

that

we

hope

to

take

up

pretty

shortly.
With reference to the resolution
considered by your deliberations here because
these cases and maybe we will have some words

passed by Area E,I think that that should be
we think that something should be done about
on this from our friends over here.

MR. MARK ROBSON:
I am quite sure that Dr. Brick's comments were received by
you people with interest, and we too, and I am sure that we will have some correspondence
with Dr. Brick and the rehabilitation staff here and iron out some of our difficulties.
At the present time, I am going to confine myself strictly to the question,
"Why .should not x-ray evidence of tuberculosis condition of progression be sufficient for
an award inasmuch as modern medication may make positive sputum cultures difficult to obtain?"
It has always been our position that x-ray evidence of progression of a
tuberculous lesion is sufficient for a determination of activity.
I repeat that -- is
sufficient for determination of activity,
and may be the basis for an award of compensation
in a service-connected case, provided the x-ray study is made contemporaneously with
physical examination diagnosing active pulmonary tuberculosis.

I might say in that connection that today if a man is picked
up on routine X-ray
with a suspicious lesion and he is placed in a hospital
and the hospital gives us a diagnosis
of active pulmonary tuberculosis, we do not question that
diagnosis.
We do not, even though
it is principally on
nothing more than X-ray evidence.
«52

However, a determination of activity made in retrospect solely on comparative
study of x-ray films, while warranting service connection as provided under Extension 4,
will not entitle to a compensable rating.
A current examination with diagnosis of activity
is required before a compensable rating may be allowed.
This is for the reason that in
these cases (I am speaking of cases where the activity is determined in retrospect on a
comparative study of x-ray films) the veteran is not shown to have been given any treatment
for tuberculosis and there was no restriction as to his activity.
In other words, the
veteran was not aware that he had the disease.
MR.

Maryland:

SEAMAN:

We will go
'What agency

Is Mr.

answer
to the
on it.

before

Is

there

any

on to Question
was authorized

Lewis

here?

Would

further

comment

or

question

on

No. 2 submitted by Mr. Lewis
in 1949 to examine VA claims

you

like

to

comment

or

No.

1?

of the Department
folders?"

enlarge

on

your

of

question,

sir?

MR. LEWIS:
I don't think that I need to enlarge on it.
I just wanted an
to that because, in the Baltimore office, I seem to get a number of different answers
question and I would like to ask Mr. Stone or one of the representatives to comment

we

ask

MR. SEAMAN:
Would you like to have
Mr. Stone to answer the question?
MR.

LEWIS:

MR.

SEAMAN:

Mr.

Pool

or

Charlie

comment

on

it?

Stevens

comment

on

it

Yes.

Charlie,

do

you

want

to

MR. LOYD POOL:
The only thing we have was that, according to Mr. Stone's
letter addressed to Regional Managers, dated April 2nd, it was the review of an outside
agency which was the reason for Mr. Stone's writing that letter.
Now Mr. Lewis wants to
know which agency was authorized to examine those records, and I believe Mr. Stone will
supply the answer because we talked to him about it after this question came in.
Mr. Stone:
The agency referred to in the letter, of course, was the
Accounting Office, who have authority to go into claims folders or any records of
at any time whatsoever.
:
MR.

SEAMAN:

MR.

LEWIS:

Does
Yes,

that

answer

sir,

it

your

question,

Mr.

General
government

Lewis?

does.

MR. SEAMAN:
Mr. Lewis' second question:
'"Why is it that Regional Offices of
the Veterans Administration are using Chief Benefits Director's letters calling for review of
certain ratings as a basis to call claimants in for
examination and in many cases reducing
compensation or completely severing service connection?"
Do

you

want

any

further

comment,

Mr.

Lewis?

MR. LEWIS:
Yes, Mr. Chairman.
According to Mr. Stone's letter of April 2,
1954, and the two subsequent letters dated December 14, 1954, and December 29, 1954, this
review was to be made primarily to determine whether or not granted awards were properly
adjudicated under Veterans Regulation 1185.
I am wondering whether or not in those letters
(I didn't read them), Mr. Stone authorized the Regional Offices to call these men in and
give them examinations under this-review, and then reduce compensation and very often in
many cases they have severed compensation or severed service connection, I should say.
;
MR. STONE:
The review was caused, of course, by the General Accounting Office
review of folders in the Washington office.
Primarily, that was its first purpose, they.
found many veterans had not been called for an examination according to the laws and regulations administered by the VA.
In looking back through the record, we found that the Compensation and Pension
Service had sent letters to the Regional Offices stating, first, that only a certain pervcentage of examinations would be made.
At that time they had, I think, a waiting list
of two million awaiting examination.
They sent a letter to the Regional Office stating that
only 75 per cent of the examinations would be made and that cut the waiting list down some,
not enough.
per cent, and then
would be called in

another
for

That was brought to the attention of the Administration by the General Accounting
Office survey and we immediately started correcting it.
Under the law or the regulations,
it is definitely required that a veteran, before receiving compensation, be examined by the
VA.
=53-

ES

it was 50
cent that

a

Then, they sent another letter out, I think
one 25 per cent.
They finally got down as low as 10 per
examination, where they should all have been called in.

During the rush period of '45 and '46, in many cases they were not examined at all.
The
Army records were used entirely, it seems, in many, many cases.
So, we have been catching
up, putting our house in order to see that no accounting agency or anybody else can come
into the office and state that we have not followed the laws and regulations promulgated
for this work.

increases

in

In many cases
compensation,

the
and

examinations have
some decreases.

brought

about

increases

MR. LEWIS:
The only thing I can say in reply to that
decreases than there have been increases.
I haven't seen one

moire

in

is that
yet.

pensions,

there

have

been

MR. STONE:
That is right, and it is very odd that most of the decreases are
where your severances of service connection occur.
There have been very few letters about
them at all.
We have found some gross errors.
We are trying to correct every one up or
down, whichever way it should be, so that we are sure we are right.
powers

Everyone is
attdrney, they

of

carefully reviewed, carefully handled.
Whenever your
review them.
We are trying to do the job properly.

people

have

MR. THOMAS B. EGAN, Delaware:
Mr. Stone, these cases are coming up for review.
You are bringing them in straight across the board for examination.
The rating boards in
practically no instances are asking for a T folder which has been retired.
The veteran has
had out-patient treatment.
It is a matter of record.
He hasn't had treatment for a period
of years.
The T folder has been retired.
The rating board never even requests it.
Neither
do they ask for a summarization of even a current T folder.
What is the answer to that?
are

not

folder

doing

has
.

MR. STONE:
That is in your particular
the job according to regulations?
MR.

EGAN:

MR.

STONE:

MR. EGAN:
come in.

We

will

MR.

they

are

not.

You

think

they

are

not

1I'am

asking

for

the

report

STONE:

regulations,

and

rules

1 know

will

we

certainly

make

working

look

there?

according

You

feel

that

they

to

the

regulations?

the

out-patient

T

folder

it.

If

not

on

into

up

they

are

after

the

following

the

properly.

it

do

them

office

MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
Let me make one observation and then ask a question.
The answer to the last questions has been that the Administrator of Veterans Affairs has
been
replaced by the General Accounting Office and they are running the Veterans Administration and telling you what to do and what not to do.
With respect to this review, we are concerned with the fact as to whefher
you are rating these cases and considering these cases on review on the facts or difference
of opinion.
I can recall for the years that I have been in this work when I used to think,
and I have been told, that a case granted by aggravation was considered to be a better
service connection than a direct service connection, because it was a matter of opinion.
Now, you are severing service connection on the same matter of opinion, with a changed
attitude

towards

MR.

veteran's

STONE:

MR. CRIDER:
aggravation, and where it
or was not aggravated.

found

in

opinion

ment,

the

to

benefits,

We

are

not

as

I

view

changing

any

ratings

on

differences

of

opinion,

at

Well, you are severing service connection on those granted
is aggravation it has to be a matter of opinion whether it

MR. STONE:
The only ones that
original rating, gross errors.

MR.
begin

CRIDER:
with.

That

MR.

STONE:

No,

MR.
but I just

it.

CRIDER:
I
wanted you

can

only

be

are

being

severed

all.

by
was

are

where

errors

have

been

it

granted

on

a difference

of

opinion

and

realized when I got up that
to know I didn't like it.

we

weren't

going

was

sir.
to

reach

an

agree-

MR. LEWIS:
In December of last year the field representative of another
veterans' organization in the Baltimore office told us that the adjudication officer over
there told him that he was of the opinion that it was for the purpose of cutting benefits
that that is what they were goimg to do and they are doing it.

«She

--

MR.

SEAMAN:

MR.

LEWIS:

Yes,

MR.

SEAMAN:

Any

That

is

a comment

sir,

it

further

rather

than

a question,

I

understand.

is.

comment

on

the

question?

Mr. Lewis, has your fourth question been answered by Mr. Stone when you ask
the question, "What is to be done about reviewing claims rated '0° per cent which
could now
be compensable?"
Do you feel that question has been answered in Mr. Stone's discussion?
MR. LEWIS:
No, it has not, sir.
I feel this way.
If the Veterans Administration
made a mistake in overrating a claim or in granting service connection in a claim,
there is
the possibility that they have made a mistake in not
granting service connection at all.
What I would like to know is what, if anything, will be done to review those old
cases
where service connection was denied.
There is a possibility that a mistake was made then
and the man may be entitled to it.

as
of

MR. STONE:
1 said last year and I say again that as
as we can get caught up in our work, keeping current with
nature will be reviewed.

soon
that

soon as practicable and
our work load, all cases

MR. KLEMMETSON, Washington:
Mr. Chairman, I wonder if it might not save some
time in our panel discussions if we did this:
Certainly, the Chairman ought to read the
questions as they come up.
I think after that we ought to have the answer by the Veterans
Administration and then only if the question has not been answered satisfactorily to
the
writer of the question will we ask him to review his question at the beginning.
I think
in that manner we may save some time.
MR. SEAMAN:
The Chairman has no objection to that.
following a pattern that was established in the last two or three
pounder of the question to identify himself on the floor.
you

or

your

by

the

VA?

MR. KLEMMETSON:
panel, or anybody

It is
else.

MR.

you

SEAMAN:

(Calls

I am not
to other
Browning.

MR.
exactly
members

of

Do

only

a question

gentlemen

want

the

of

saving

I believe we have been
years in asking the pro-

time.

question

from

I am

the

not

floor

to

picking

be

on

answered

"yes").

SEAMAN:
O. K., fair enough.
I would like to move this thing along, too.
tired of being up here yet, but in the interest of giving some recognition
of the panel, I would like to turn the next few questions over to Mr. Fred

MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
The next question is No. 5, submitted by
Powell of Mississippi and Wadsworth of Alabama:
"Why shouldn't Veterans Administration
regulations be changed so as to permit a veteran, entitled to additional compensation
for
dependents, one year from date of notice of VA with regard to dependents, in which
to file
Proof of relationship and, when established, be paid from date of notice to
Veterans Administration?"
3
MR. HENRY BROOKS:
Veterans Regulation 2(a), Part I, paragraph II, provides
that "The effective date of an award of increased pension (or compensation) shall be fixed
in accordance with the facts found, except that no award of increased compensation may
be
effective for any period prior to the date of receipt of the evidence showing entitlement
thereto."
As you know, Veterans Regulation 2(a) has the force of law.
Therefore, we
cannot pay increased compensation prior to the date of the receipt of the evidence, and
of course ‘increased compensation because of dependents is just the same as increased compensation for any other reason.
It is specifically provided in the law.
That is why we
cannot pay it prior to the date of the receipt of the evidence.
.
MR. CHARLES W. STEVENS:
May I say that we have a national convention mandate
to seek amendatory legislation to accomplish this.
H.R. 1624, 84th Congress, was introduced
by our request to effect the purpose.
We testify for this March 22nd.

"In emergency
connection.

MR.

BROWNING:

Question

No.

6,

submitted

by Mr.

Why

call

then

abstract

for

Public

information

Law

239

cases

be

posted

the

abstract

cases

VA hospital
cannot

officials

often

Markowitz
on

of

Pennsylvania:

re service

cards?

MR. BROOKS:
Abstract cards are not prepared unless there is a claim for compensation or pension.
Claims under Public Law 239 are claims for hospital treatment or
outpatient treatment because of psychosis and are not recorded on the abstract card, for

-§5-

the

reason

that,

for

claims

statistics.

essentially,

these

cards

are

prepared

for

claims

purposes

and

as

a basis

Furthermore, once eligibility is determined under Public Law 239, a copy of
the rating sheet and Form 2731 are maintained in the hospitalization and outpatient treatment
folder; therefore, the information is readily available from the Medical.Eligibility Group
without recourse to the claims folder.
We think that they could get the information just
as readily from medical as they can from the abstract card.
Incidentally, I may add, in this connection, as you are probably aware, an
instruction was issued dated January 27, 1956, which authorizes hospitalization in these
cases on a prima facie basis in cases of veterans who served between 6-27-50 and 2-1-55
and who filed claim within two years from date of discharge.
In these cases the hospitalization is speeded up.
MR.

STEVENS:

Is

Mike

Markowitz

in

the

room?

May I ask this, Henry?
You have a prima facie showing of eligibility for those
that served on or after June 27, 1950, which come within the purview of Public Law 239.
That
doesn't apply to other cases that might be established -- the World War II veterans.
Would
it be a great task to post the abstract card with this information to make the information
readily available?
Mike Markowitz of Pennsylvania is
definitely interested in seeing that
that is done.
MR. BROOKS:
It probably would not be a great task.
from the usual procedure.
Heretofore the abstract cards have not
cases where the application was purely for outpatient treatment.
this situation.

It would be
carried any
However, we

a departure
record of any
can explore

MR. MELVIN DIXON, Florida:
I would like to ask Mr. Brooks a question as to
why the 239 ratings are not carried forward currently on the rating sheet.
We find that
the case has been sent down to Adjudication for consideration under 239; the award is made
one, two, three, four full ratings are made and the 239 rating is not carried forward on the
rating sheet in the case folder.
The man then has an occasion to re-apply for hospitalization for the mental
condition and, invariably, the Adjudication Section, in completing Form 2731, looks at the
top rating sheet in the case file and there the 239 rating has not been carried forward and,
invariably, those types of cases become confused.
I have been told in the Regional Office that there is a letter out which prohibits them from carrying forward on current rating sheets the 239 rating, but it is my
opinion if that 239 rating, once it is established, were carried forward it would eliminate
the confusion in completing Form 2731 going to the hospital and would eliminate a lot of
unnecessary
correspondence between the Regional Office and the hospital in establishing
the veteran's correct entitlement to hospitalization under 239.
Why

don't

they

put

it

on

the

current

rating

sheet,

sir?

MR. BROOKS:
Mr. Dixon, this is a re-hospitalized veteran.
We have already
furnished his eligibility to the medical people.
They should have a record in their treatment file . of his eligibility.
It seems to me that they would consult their treatment file
and it would be unnecessary to come to Adjudication.
MR. DIXON:
Unfortunately, on a lot of the people put in the hospital, they
don't establish an outpatient folder.
The man gets sick, he goes to the hospital and he
goes home.
He may not subsequently re-apply for outpatient treatment until he gets ready
to go back to the hospital again, and the outpatient service has never set up a file.
They
don't set up an outpatient folder on every man that wants to go to the hospital.
They only
set it up on the people who want
outpatient treatment authorized by the Regional Office,
and we are having lots of these people where the only time this 239 business comes into
consideration is where hospitalization is indicated, and once it is established, I don't
think there is any secret about it.
I don't see why it couldn't be carried forward on the
current rating sheet.
MR. BROOKS:
There is no question whatsoever about the secrecy of it, as you
know.
I was certainly under the impression that the medical records were complete.
If they
are not, there is no major objection to placing the 239 entitlement on a current rating
sheet.
We can do that.
MR. DIXON:
Then, sir, can you tell us this morning
instructions that the 239 ratings will be carried forward on all
the case file.
MR.

BROOKS:

Yes,

sir.

256

that you will put
subsequent rating

out
sheets

in

health

again

MR.

DIXON:

You

will

do

that?

MR.
and

BROWNING:
I am
on the job.

glad

to

Thank

see

my

you.

good

friend

Melvin

Dixon

is

back

in

good

The next Question No. 7, submitted by Mr. Markowitz of
Pennsylvania, and I
will read both parts and then ask Mr. Brooks to give us the
answer:
'(a)
A veteran drawing
Part III pension and additional allowance under P. L. 149 enters
a VA hospital and before
Adjudication Division takes steps to reduce his award, an
overpayment is created.
This
overpayment is usually collected by withholding veteran's pension
checks until entire amount
due is liquidated.
Why doesn't the VA recoup their overpayments by an easy payment
plan?
.
""(b)
After discharge from hospital it is often two or three months
before
veteran's award is restored.
Why cannot VA Regional Office officials and VA hospital officials
work out a plan whereby prompt notice of discharge from or
entry into hospital is furnished
to Adjudication and Finance Divisions of the interested
Regional Office?"
MR. BROOKS:
With regard to (a) of this question, there is procedure established
that if a veteran informs the Regional Office that the withholding
of the entire amount of
his payments is resulting in hardship to him, partial deductions
may be made and will be
made.
If you have knowledge in your own offices that this procedure
is not being followed,
let us know about it and we will see what the trouble is,
but there is no question about
the procedure being established that partial deductions
may be made rather than the full
amount,

With regard to the second question, the procedures are
adequate and certainly
any case in which the man who was in receipt of additional
allowance for a nurse or attendant
leaves the hospital and is still in need of a nurse or
attendant and does not promptly have
his award adjusted is a matter of grave concern to us.
In most cases we are able to bring
about these adjustments promptly and, again, if you have
any cases of this sort, we would
be more than interested to see them and I may assure you
further that we, on our own part,
will look into the situation.
MR.

BROWNING:

I

would

like

to

ask

Mr.

Brooks

in

the

case

of

these

men

being
discharged from the hospital, would it be possible for those
cases to get priority on
critical records going to the VA?
I refer to the cases that are helpless.
We understand
there are a lot of these cases coming out of the hospital.
To these men who are totally
helpless, it means a lot to them whether they get their
check on time or not.

MR. BROOKS:
statement that this money
to see that their records

|
|

i

|

There certainly would be no
disagreement with the gentleman's
means a lot to these men and we will certainly work out
procedures
are given priority and dispatched promptly to the Regional
Office.

MR. W. JACKSON KORELLA, Missouri:
I have a question of Mr. Brooks.
I wonder
if it would be possible for your office, Mr. Brooks, to
send out a directive to the Cochran
Hospital at St. Louis to send their medical reports on
those cases in to the Regional Office.
I have had case after case where two and three months have
passed before the final hospital
summary has been sent to the Regional Office.
The Regional Office has made request No. 1,
a second request and a third request.
I have taken the matter up with the manager of that
hospital.
I have had every assurance from him that that would be
done.

I

Ii

iH)

Then, by going out there and making a specific request, perhaps
they will send
in one or two reports.
But there are other veterans in the same position and predicament
,
and unless I step on them every time, it is absolutely
impossible to get those reports in
to the Regional Office.
It seems that there is laxity there somewhere and I believe
that
if you would use your good offices by sending a directive
out there, that those hospital
reports should be sent to the Regional Office in reasonable
time, we would eliminate a lot
of the unnecessary correspondence and the hard feelings
between the VA and the veteran.
I would like to get an answer to that, Mr. Brooks.

of

that

sort

MR.

BROOKS:

Which

hospital

MR.

KORELLA:

The

Cochran

is

i

that?

Hospital

in

St.

MR. BROOKS:
We will take it right up with
have to go through the Medical Service.

Louis.

the Medical

Service.

Instructions

MR. CRIDER:
Mr. Brooks, I realize what the intent of your previous statement
is.
I want to get back to it in just a moment, though.
With reference to the rating of
these cases for aid and attendance, 149, or with reference
to the rating of any case, the
situation that exists in Tennessee -- and I feel sure
that some of these other states must
be facing the same problem -- is that your rating boards
have cases waiting on them to go
into the boards that are six weeks and two months old.
If they don't get the case and if they
haven't the personnel or if they are not fast enough
in their rating, I don't see the solution
to the problem.
;
-57-

|

|

In other words,they rate the cases when they get them and they say (and
1 am using their statement now) that they are rating all they can, and the adjudicators say
that they are making the awards as fast as they can, but the fact remains that cases come
in with hospital reports attached, examination reports attached, that fit in a case file
awaiting their turn to get into the board for a month or six weeks.
Then, after the board rates it, it sits on the adjudicator's desk waiting for
him to write the letter and make the award, for another month or six weeks.
In the interim
period, three or four months have elapsed before the veteran actually gets his money, by the
time it goes through the normal procedure.
The only solution is that somebody is going to
have to mazeadetermination as to how these cases can be handled more quickly by the
Adjudication Division.
That is the problem that is existing, but I don't know what solution
you are going to offer to us.
You are going to say, ''Give us more money and we will give
you more adjudicators;' or perhaps you are going to get rid of those on the boards who are
not any good and are not rating any cases.
What are we going to do to solve the problem, which is a definite problem?
I
explained to you yesterday in private some of the problems we are facing, where a man is
eligible for Extension 2(a) benefits and has been out of the hospital for two months and
the board hasn't even considered his hospital report.
Extension 2(a) is to apply when a
man is in thé hospital, when he needs it the most and his family needs it the most.
MR. BROOKS:
At least, the initial
to the VA office.
At least we can do something
a matter of personnel.
MR.

DRIVER:

Is

it

peculiar

to

phase
about

of the
that.

problem is to get the reports
The rest of it seems to be
!

Nashville?

MR. MICHAEL MARKOWITZ, Pennsylvania:
I am a little late getting here.
I
apologize, but I had one of the most important questions propounded in Pennsylvania.
I am
not sure that I have your answer.
It has been given to me by somebody here, on Part (a) of
that Question 7 that we were discussing.
I am told that it can be done on.a pro rata basis,
that is, the repayment where no payment has been-made is not supposed to be deducted.
We
don't know that to be a fact in Pennsylvania and I would ask you, if you don't send it
anywhere else, please write to the three Regional Offices in Pennsylvania and tell them that
they are instructed to take those payments out on a piecemeal basis rather than hit that
veteran so hard when he is up against it for dough when he comes out of the
hospital.
MR.

BROOKS:

We

will

take

it

MR. MARKOWITZ:
I will speak
to give instructions to all your Regional
people who don't do those things.

Do

all

of

you

up

for the
Offices

MR. BROOKS:
Do you think such
have the same experience?
(A

few

"noes"

with

an

the

Finance

rest of
because

Service

immediately.

the country and I think you ought
every once in a while we find

instruction

is

necessary

to

all

stations?

heard).

MR. BROWNING:
Pennsylvania.
I am glad to
helplessness; be amended so
hands and both feet?"

We will take up Question No. 8, submitted by Mr. Markowitz of
see you are here; Mike.
'"Why shouldn't VA Regulation 1236(B),
as to include veterans who have suffered loss of use of both

MR. ROBSON:
Veterans Regulation 1236(B) is merely explanatory of the type of
conditions for which the maximum rate of compensation is payable in addition to obvious
anatomical losses or loss of use and blindness.
There would be no purpose in including
in this regulation the loss of use of both hands and both feet since the maximum rate is
obviously payable for such losses.

Regulation

Paragraph
1236(D)(3).
MR.

VA

Regulation

of

BROWNING:

Question
of

(0)

Law

Satisfactory,

No.

1216(C)

Public

9,
a

submitted

veteran

182

amended

is

clear

in

this

respect;

also

Mike?

by Mr.

rated

as

under

Markowitz,
Extension

Pennsylvania:
7

to

1945

'Under

schedule

provisions

when

hospitalized

in private hospital can only receive the increased amount from date report from private
hospital is received by Veterans Administration.
Why cannot the award be made to date from
date of admission to private hospital when hospital is an approved one and the report verifies
entitlement?"
;

admission

to

MR.
the

BROOKS:
The question reads,
hospital?"
TI think 'date of

''Why cannot the award be made from date of
operation" is intended, is that correct?

-58-

ar
et WE

The reason why we cannot pay the increased amount from date of
operation in
the private hospital is because under the provisions of Veterans
Regulation 2(A), Part I,
Paragraph II, which I referred to in answering another question, increased
compensation may
not be paid prior to the date of receipt in the VA of the evidence
showing entitlement thereto.
In the case of a VA hospital the evidence showing entitlement is
in the possession of the VA.
Therefore, we can pay from the date of operation in the VA hospital.
We cannot in the
private hospital.
It is strictly because of the regulation.
want

to

MR. MARKOWITZ:
All right, the regulation can be
That is not law.
It doesn't need legislation.

do.

MR. BROOKS:
No, Mr. Markowitz:
This
Regulation.
Veterans Regulations were promulgated
effect of law and can only be changed by law.

tions

MR. BROWNING:
Mike, I suggest that
Committee to cover that point.
I think it
MR.

MARKOWITZ:

I

think

it

it

That

you submit a recommendation
is very important.

too,

and

make

that

a written

recommendation

of

Committee

is

sitting

writing

right

now.

MR.

BROWNING:

Mike,

you

MR.
over.

MARKOWITZ:

The

Chairman

MR."

BROWNING:

You

give

it

to

the

him

in

is

what

you

a Veterans Regulation, not VA
the President which have the force

is,

a motion.

talked

is
by

changed.

that

is

what

we

to

propose.

the

and

Recommenda-

I make

such

to

the

Committee.

behind

me

and

we

have

Question No. 10, submitted by Mr. Sanderson of Nebraska:
"Is Paragraph (1)(d)
VAR 2584 for application under the General Law, granting pension to widows
of Civil and
Indian War veterans only, when forfeiture has been incurred under VAR 2602,
or does it apply
to widows of veterans of any war?"
I believe that regulation covers adultery.
MR. HINTON:
As shown by the title and opening statement of VA Regulation 2584,
this paragraph relates to awards under both the General Law and the Service
Pension Acts
relating to the Civil War, Indian Wars and War with Spain.
Subparagraph (A)(1)(d) is
applicable to awards of death compensation made under the General Law and to
awards of death
pension made under the Service Pension Acts based on any of these periods of
service.
The Act of August 7, 1882, which provides for forfeiture of pension rights
by
a widow who is guilty of open and notorious adulterous cohabitation subsequent
to a veteran's
death, is applicable only to the laws mentioned in VA Regulation 2584 and
does not apply
5
to widows of any war subsequent to the Spanish-American War.
looks

can

be

MR. BROWNING:
Question
it might be an individual

like

Opinion

Solicitor

given

questions

Department

of

622-50

a

supersede

Is

that

special

MR.

HINTON:

MR.

BROWNING:

MR. DAWSON,
a yes or no

The

case,

No. 11, submitted by Mr. Sanderson of Nebraska.
This
case and I will ask Mr. Sanderson to comment.
''Does

Solicitor's

Mr.

opinion

Solicitor's

Opinion

see.

Do

you

want

Nebraska:
answer.

No,

we

don't,

I

of

to

as

say

anything

that?

because

the

I will
of

in

re

result

of

XC

2,284

47272

we

on

think

a

the

question

that

case.

propounded

:

MR.

Officer

1939,

promulgated

question is
are correct

BROWNING:

10,

was

MR. HINTON:
The answer to that
facts, of law, and the opinions

Service

March

Sanderson?

now

turn

Louisiana.

MR. GEORGE F. DERIS:
Question
the Area C Conference:
"Extension 5 to the
more realistic the percentage of disability
requirement between the ages of 55 and 65."

panel

no.
Most of
on the facts

over

to my

good

these questions
as stated.

friend

George

involve

Deris,

No. 12, submitted by Crider. of Tennessee, from
1945 Rating Schedule be amended so as to make
required by establishing an intermediate physical

MR. ROBSON:
As you know, there is at the present time an intermediate requirement between ages 55 and 65, namely, age 60.
At age 55 the disability requirement
60 and at age 60, 50 per cent, and at 65, 10 per cent.
We do not think the present requirements are at all unrealistic.
I might say we are now placing on the rolls between
three and four thousand Part III claims every month and that any meritorious case
not

-59-

is

granted in
at any age

the field may be referred
with any percentage.

to

Central

Office

and

the

total

benefit

may

be

granted

MR. IVAN MARSH:
In that question, I should like again to refer to the service
officers who are responsible for either appealing or sending these cases in for review.
This
was mentioned during our Department Service Officers Association meeting over on the seventh
floor on Monday of this week.
In any case where a veteran does not have sufficient disabilities to meet the actual schedular requirements for Part III pension purposes, under no
circumstances, in my opinion, should that be appealed.
That case should be submitted to
your rating board with a request that it be sent in to Central Office under the provisions
of VA Regulation 1142, which will permit the rating schedule board in Central Office to
make a rating of P and T for Part III pension where, in their opinion, the actual disability
does preclude the veteran from carrying on a substantially gainful occupation.
Now, we know from past experience in the cases that have come in here that
they have been very liberal in that particular type of case.
We also know that the Board
Veterans Appeals will not and cannot actually take jurisdiction in an 1142 case, although
they do actually have the authority if they want to take it, to make a rating; what is it
they call it?
What is the term they call that, Charlie Stevens, the type of rating that
the Board of Veterans Appeals can make in those cases if they want to?

MR.
ferred

on

that the
his full

the

STEVENS:

Chief

The

Benefits

disabilities
opportunity,

Board

of

Veterans

Director

to

grant

merit it.
That
in our opinion.

is,

the

Appeals
an

has

award

Chairman

the

same

authority

administratively

of

the

BVA

if

doesn't

it

take

that
is

is

of

con-

found

advantage

of

MR. MARSH:
That was the word I was groping for, "administrative."
However,
they never exercise that.
That is the point I wanted to put over to this group, and you
should, under all circumstances,
take it to your rating board.
If your rating board will
not send it in, then, please, if you are still of the opinion that it is a good case, write
in to Mr. T. O. Kraabel, Director of the National Rehabilitation Commission, attention
Charles Marton oi myself, and we will see that it gets to the pioper source.
Thank you.
MR. STEVENS:
The Rating Schedule Board makes these determinations and my
friends Henry Brooks and Mark Robson just tell me that 80 per cent of the cases that are
considered as meritorious claims are in the Compensation and Pension Service granted the
Part III award.
So, take full advantage of the opportunity you have.

MR. DERIS:
Question 13 from Crider of Tennessee:
'That
or otherwise, by a veteran receiving Part III pension not be a bar so
income from all sources does not exceed the statutory limitations."

employment,
long as his

marginal
total

MR. ROBSON:
The annual income limitations of $1400 and $2700 are measures of
need.
The Congress has decided that if a single veteran has an annual income of $1400 from
any source or a married veteran or veteran with minor child or children, an annual income
of $2700 he does not need a pension.
These standards may not be accepted as determining
whether a person is engaged in substantially gainful occupation nor any other fixed
monetary standard.
Wages and standards of living vary in different parts of the country
and the determination whether or not an occupation is substantially gainful must be made
on an individual basis without regard to any specific numerical standards of remuneration.
MR. HUDGENS, Tennessee:
Questions 12 and 13 came out of the
and are not necessarily Mr. Crider's questions, and probably the Chairman
tions Committee from Area C is here and might like to comment.
VOICE:

No

Area C Conference
of the Recommenda-

comment.

MR. MARKOWITZ:
You say that there is no specific way that it can be figured,
but you have a measurement, a yardstick of measurement, down here in Central Office which
we were very, very much in disagreement with.
The yardstick of measurement you use is half
the usual time and half the usual amount of wages paid.
That is the yardstick you are using
under Extension 5, are you not?

question,

course,

we

MR. ROBSON:
that $1400 and

Yes,
$2700

MR.

MARKOWITZ:

MR.

ROBSON:

MR.

MARKOWITZ:

MR.

ROBSON:

but that is
be made the

Congress
They

didn't

not a specific
yardstick.

certainly

put

put

as

it

in

in

amount,

$1400

a yardstick

and

as

$2700

for

is

mentioned

for

some

measurement

in

reason.
of

--

You

fellows

have

are

giving

you

a very

elastic

MR. MARKOWITZ:
I don't believe
were up on the Hill yesterday and

you:
were

yardstick is quite elastic enough.
discussing this very thing, as you

We

made

-60+

the

the

yardstick.
yardstick.

Of
know.

|
{

:

The measurement yardstick ought to be what was the man able to earn before his disability
prevented him from following his usual type of occupation and, as a result of his physical
disability or because of his old age, he has now been relegated to a lower classification
as far as work is concerned because he can't live on $66.15 or $78.75 a month.
I don't
think any of us here could afford to live on that, whether we were single or married.

So, we ought to conside. that the yardstick ought to be that, because of his
disability, he was able to earn X dollars up here before his disability and now he is able
to earn only Y dollars down here because of his disability, and if his earnings, no matter
how much time he spends on that job, are below the $1400 ox the $2700 limitation, I think
it ought to be granted.
That is the yardstick of measurement I would like to have you people
accept.
;
yardstick,

MR. ROBSON:
but we are not

I am quite sure a lot of you would agree that
We are not.
in a position to accept that.

would

be

a

&
il
ft

splendid

MR. DIXON, Florida:
One more question.
I believe under the same regulations,
sir, if the veteran is rated 100 per cent disabled on his nonservice-connected disability,
the only thing you are interested in is his income.
He can work eight hours a day at any
trade of his choosing but he is 100 per cent disabled and as long as he doesn't make over
$2700, if he has dependents, he stays on the roll for Part III benefits; right?

MR. ROBSON:

Right.

MR. DIXON:
Then, by the same token, a man who has one disability,
let's say,
that is 80 per cent disabled, he has a wife, he is awarded $66.15 a month.
It is impossible
to feed the wife on the $66.15 a month and he is 80 per cent disabled, and I defy you to
draw the line between 80 and 100 on a bad heart.
If this man goes out and attempts to
secure any type of full-time employment such as watchman or anything where he puts in more
than one-half of the time, regardless of the amount of money he is paid, you are taking
him off the roll for the Part III benefits.
MR.

i
|

i

ROBSON:

Not

necessarily,

Mr.

Dixon,

not

Hh
IE

necessarily.

MR. DIXON:
I would like to know when you changed your procedure.
I have yet
to see one and I think Central Office is rougher now than they were a year ago with reference
to this question of gainful employment.
I think this is a good time to talk about it.
At
least the rating boards back in my state are as confused, sir,as I am with reference to
this question as to what can be said to be gainful employment.

fi!
I
|

You are taking farmers who
have farmed all of their lives, they have three
‘boys; because the old man sits on the front porch and tells them what to do, you find that
man gainfully employed in a supervisory capacity, if you please.
Now, listen, you guys
wrote this Extension 5.

{

MR.

ROBSON:

That

is

right.

MR. DIXON:
You wrote it; you all drew the yardstick, as Mike says,
have been coming up year after year since 1949 arguing about this same question,
to me like we will be coming for many more years.
MR.

MARKOWITZ:

Not

Now,

a man
ROBSON:

can

work

we
it

looks

me!

MR. DIXON:
Yes, you will, Mike.
But it looks to me like,
this thing, I was reasonably sure what you. answer was going to be, but
this Extension 5 business would be rescreened and relooked at with this
all they are doing is this more than one-half time.
2

MR.

and
and

19

hours

a week

and

make

$2600

a year;

in the purpose of
it looks to me like
in mind, because

he

stays

on

the

rolls.

”

That

is

correct.

MR. DIXON:
And he can work harder in those 19 hours in one week than a man
can who works 40 hours a week checking trucks in and out of a gate, but the man who is
checking trucks in and out may not have this amount of disability.
It doesn't check out
with the man who has 100 per cent disability.
Nobody argues about the man who is 100 per
cent.
He can go/ out and work and kill himself.
Nobody seems to be worried about him;
you will still pay him, but the 80 per cent veteran -- and we have got a lot of them in that
category -- starves to death on $66.15 a month because he can't
get any type of work to
supplement this $66.15 a month; and half-time jobs, my friends, in Florida are hard to get.
MR. ROBSON:
Mr. Dixon, these cases that you are speaking of, for instance, the
80 per cent group that your rating board in Florida has taken off the rolls ox denied, and
that you think are meritorious, have you submitted any of them up for our consideration?

-61-

|
Ih

are

uniform

MR. DIXON:
By the truckload,
~-- and now I will hush.

I may

add,

and

I don't

think

your

MR. DERIS:
Question 14, Ranney of South Dakota:
"In claims for
because of the need for aid and attendance, why have rating agencies
by Central Office publications?
This particularly applies to mental

benefits
stricted

considered
restricted

MR. ROBSON:
I don't believe Mr. Ranney's question
it at great length and it is not thought that rating
by Central Office instructions relative to the grant

Insofar

mental

as

cases

are

concerned,

this,

of

course,

has

decisions

greater
been so
cases."

pension
re-

is too clear.
We have
agencies have been unduly
of aid and attendance.

been

a

matter

of

discussion

at

several rehabilitation conferences and it has been explained that the need must be a personal
one, that is, the veteran must need assistance in dressing, feeding himself, attending to
the wants of nature, et cetera, and that mere supervision given him as an individual at
home or as- a member of a group in an institution is not sufficient.
We have made no change
in this rule at all.
MR. RANNEY, South Dakota:
The reference there is to an instruction issued
May 15, 1952, Paragraph (a) which provides, in essence, that a man must reach a stage of
vegetative existence before he qualifies for aid and attendance.
We believe, or at least
in cases that come before us, that rating boards are inclined, invariably, in fact, determine
that when a man reaches a state of vegetative condition he must be ready for the other
provisions that are contained in VR 1176 which it is contended is amply restrictive to contravene all of the provisions of 149 or the other legislation that has been enacted to
qualify a man for aid and attendance.
Vegetative existence in itself, or the term "vegetative existence," is a
difficult thingto explain.
A man, for instance, gets lost in his own living room; he is just
as disabled and just as much in need of service of regular aid and attendance as a man who
is totally blind or has both legs off, or meets the physical qualifications.
We can see no reason why the
ticular information bulletin because they
disregarding the provisions of 1176.

get

through

Joseph

Veterans Administration cannot issue this parare finding rating boards following the IB and

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Mr. Robson will
with the next item on the program.

At this
MacCarroll to

time I would like to call
deliver an invocation.

undertake

on

the

to

answer

National

your

Chaplain,

question

the

after

we

Reverend

THE REVEREND JOSEPH MacCARROLL:
Eternal God, our heavenly Father, we pause
in the midst of the concerns of our hearts and of our minds to return unto Thee our humble
and our hearty thanks for the privilege that is ours of serving our comrades who are less
fortunate than we.
Grant that we may ever serve with heart and head and hand to the end
that we shall not forsake the trust that has been given to us.
Bless
this nation.
Give
God and country to

us in this conference.
Be with our National Commander as he goes about
him guidance, health and strength and in all things may we seek to serve
the end that we shall be worthy of the name of American.
Amen.

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
I wonder if our friends near the door would step out in the
hallway and invite those to come in who are out there.
They are going to be privileged now
to hear an address by the National Commander.
Will some of you please try to inform those
outside.

Ladies and gentlemen, there are times when simplicity is the only rule and
guide that we should follow.
This is one of those occasions because we are highly honored
this morning to have with us our National Commander.
It would be presumptuous on my part
for me to try to explain to you some of his background and accomplishments.
Let me simply
say to you that this is our National Commander, J. Addington "Add" Wagner.
NATIONAL COMMANDER 'ADD'' WAGNER:
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much,
Vice-Chairman Clarence Horton.
Chairman Bob McCurdy, distinguished Guests and my Comrades
of The American Legion and Ladies of the American Legion Auxiliary:
Certainly this is a
privilege to which I have looked forward.
I have looked forward to it because it has been
my opportunity on more occasions to occupy seats out there with you at previous meetings
such as this, and I think you can understand the sincerity which I feel when you understand
that my first insight into the real American Legion came when it was my extreme good fortune
to hold the first office in The American Legion which I was ever privileged to hold, that of
Post Service Officer.
Certainly,
there I had a real insight into the purpose of The American
Legion.
I had an opportunity to see at first hand the warming feeling of satisfaction you
receive from helping others, and it has always seemed to me that those of you who devote so
very much time and energy and your own resources in the field of rehabilitation are expressing
«62-

our appreciation to God, our thanks for having been permitted to return from the service
of our nation healthy in mind and in body and expressing our thanks to Him through our
service to those who are less fortunate than we.

|

spose

Certainly, that is the foremost purpose for which we in The American Legion
This year your National Executive Committee has designed as our No. 1
were organized.
legislative objective the accomplishment of the enactment of the War Veterans Security Act.
Yesterday it was my privilege to testify before the House Veterans Affairs Committee on the
You know, when you go to bat, you*can either strike out or the other
features of this Act.
I say to you in all sincerity, I do not believe that The
extreme is hitting a home run.
Neither do I believe that we have hit a home run,
American Legion struck out yesterday.
but in all sincerity, I do feel that we are on base.
We made a base hit, and I am satisfied
that through your interest, through your effort and the efforts and the enthusiasm that
you can create throughout the length and breadth of America, by contributing .that barrage of
enthusiasm into the Congress, you can provide that barrage of base hits that can bring us
around to home base, securely home at this session of Congress through the successful enactment of this most needed legislation.

ith

Now, there are other fields that are equally important to The American Legion
and I know that you are equally interested in them.
We do have a tremendous job ahead of
us this year in assisting the American people in obtaining a clear vision of the efforts
of those who seek to confuse and divide all Americans.
I refer specifically to those
connected with the activities of the Fund for the Republic, who would seek to have Americans
believe that the dangers to this country and to our freedoms are those of us who are
fighting Communism; that the real danger lies in us -- that is, the real danger is not
Communism, but the real danger lies in those of ‘us who are endeavoring to fight Communism.
Certainly you do not uphold-and defend the Constitution of the United States of America,
the Bill of Rights or the Declaration of Independence by encouraging those through financial
grants who refuse to say whether they have ever been or are a Communist.
Neither do you
preserve the Constitution or our freedoms by encouraging those who have been unwilling to
tell our Congress, as a matter of civic duty and, voluntarily, what they know about
Communism, its methods of operation in this country and the people who take an important
part in it.
:
’
I say to you that we will continue this work: throughout this year.
your first and foremost interest in the field of rehabilitation but I urge that
equal attention to this most important fight in preserving the, freedoms and the
of the United States of America.

I recognize
you give
security

We have many other programs which are equally important but, to me, the enabling
program, the program which makes our wonderful work in rehabilitation possible, the program
which provides the manpower and the finances, is that of membership, and so it is with great
pleasure and pride that I present to you at this time the Past Department Commander of
the Department of Ohio, Past National Vice-Commander and presently the Chairman of our
Membership and Post Activities Committee, Howard Kingdom of the Department of Ohio.
COMRADE HOWARD KINGDOM:
Mr. Commander, distinguished Guests, Ladies of the
Auxiliary and my Comrades of The American Legion:
‘I appreciate very much having the
opportunityto appear before the rehabilitation workers this morning.
However, there is no
doubt in my mind that each of you are saying at this very moment, Just why is this fellow,
the Chairman of Membership and Post Activities, taking up our valuable time at this meeting?
I would hope that in the very beginning of my remarks I could answer that question.

If §
itd

;
I know, of course, that rehabilitation, the care of our disabled and their
dependents, is the very first obligation of our organization, but I also know that you
cannot do that job as successfully and as efficiently as you would like without a virile,
growing and ever-expanding membership.
This is true because rights and benefits now accruing
to our veterans come from legislation, and legislators know only one kind of Language and
that is the strength of their constituents back in their home areas.
The stronger The
American Legion is in membership, the better chance we have to secure new legislation and
to hold what we have.
:

|

;
And then we cannot overlook the fact that 25 cents of
every member of our organization are earmarked for rehabilitation,
the more money you have to do a more complete job.

the national dues of
so the more members,

These are the reasons I am appearing before you today and taking up your
valuable time to talk about membership.
Membership is a job of personal contact with the
member
prospect.
We can prepare and distribute brochures
and pamphlets from the national
organization.
We can have radio and television programs.
We can have newspaper advertisements
all telling of the fine work of this organization, and all of these things are important
in any membership activity; but in the final analysis, a Legionnaire must ask a veteran to
join,

and

the

picture.

here

is

where

you

Legionnaires,

who

are

-63-

the

rehabilitation

fl

workers,

come

into

|
is 1

I know of no group of workers in our organization who come in contact with
more member
prospects than you.
Furthermore, I do not believe it would be unethical for
a
rehabilitation worker, when he is talking with a veteran about his entitlements, or
processing a claim, or discussing any phase of service work, to let the veteran know
in a
nice manner that it was The American Legion that made possible his rights and benefits,
and that it will be The American Legion that will guard against any outbacks in those
.
rights and benefits in the future.
The National Commander Has put it this way in one of his recent speeches,
quote just one paragraph:
"Every veteran who is not now a Legionnaire, I am sure, would express concern
for the welfare of the former comrades in arms who may be less fortunate than he is, but
how many veterans actually contribute anything to the never-ending task of maintaining the
veterans' benefits obtained during thirty-seven years of work by The American Legion and
its
Auxiliary"
and

let

me

"Too many veterans think the job is done and that all
advantage of what has been provided for them.
How wrong they are.
that it is time for the veterans in America to stop riding free."
Tribune

Recently I read an editorial under that title which
let me quote just one paragraph from that editorial:

and

that remains
I, for one,

appeared

in

the

is to take
believe

National

"As anybody knows who has even the slightest knowledge of affairs relating to
the veteran class, every right and privilege accruing to the war veterans and their dependent
loved ones has come about as the result of the most arduous kind of work.
Every benefit
enjoyed was procured ‘through organized effort and trained organization leadership.
Months
and years of labor have gone into the maze of laws that have been enacted and equally as
much time and effort have been devoted to the preservation of those laws once they have
been placed upon the statute books.
.
"For the reason that veterans' benefits cost money, they are not only
achieved with the greatest of difficulty
and against taxpayer resistance but they are with
as much difficulty kept alive.
This has meant to educate the people, including veterans
themselves, and the tariff has come out of dues almost entirely by members of veterans'
organizations, and yet the vast majority of beneficiaries are free-riders.
Most of the
dues are paid each year by devoted men and women who will never collect anything for their
labors except personal satisfaction.
We think that it is time to drive this truth home
as forcefully as possible, and brutally, if necessary."
While the editorial did not mention The American Legion, I want to add this
fact, that when the editorial speaks of months and years of labor and money that have gone
into the work of securing such benefits, The American Legion can take full credit, and
I am in hearty accord with the last line that I quoted from this editorial:

and

brutally,

"We
if

think that it
necessary."

is

time

to drive

this

truth

home

as

forcefully

as

possible,

Here, again, you rehabilitation workers are in a strategic position to do the
job of driving home the truth to the veterans forcefully and, if necessary, brutally.
I am
a World War II veteran.
Comparatively speaking, I have been in The American Legion just
a few short years, but time and time again I have been thrilled when listening to the oldtimers reminisce about the fighting days of The American Legion.
My spine has tingled when
they tell the stories of the great fights led by Ed Hayes, Fritz Galbraith, John Quinn,
John Stelle, and many other Past National Commanders who so courageously led The American
Legion in the fight for veterans and for America, and I am confident that you feel this
morning, as I do, that we must continue to be a fighting organization for America and for
America's veterans.
Recently in a mid-western metropolitan newspaper I read another editorial which
made my blood boil.
It was entitled, "The Greedy Legion," and it had to do with the present
fight we are in to liberalize certain rights and benefits; but the thing that really got
under my skin was the last paragraph of this editorial and I want to quote it to you right
now:

objective:

ing

spirit

"It
stop

of

may
The

There,
every

be necessary to
American Legion

form
from

we have a challenge,
member of this great

a patriotic veterans'
wrecking America."

organization

a challenge which I believe
organization of ours.

will

with

one

arouse

the

fight-

I have gained new inspiration from the fact that our present National Commander
has not taken this vicious statement lying down.
He has prepared an open letter which is
now being mailed to fifty thousand key Legionnaires, asking them if they are going to take
this statement, that The American Legion is wrecking America, lying down.
In his letter to
these fifty thousand Legionnaires, he asked a number of questions and I want to present

Gl

those questions to you at this
said was wrecking America.

of
of

time

because

it

is

your

American

Legion

which

this

editorial

Can your American Legion, particularly you rehabilitation workers, be accused
wrecking America because the organization and you have been fulfilling the first objective
the Legion in providing the care of the disabled veterans and their dependents?

Boys'

Is your American Legion wrecking America when
teaching the fundamentals of good government

Nation,

Is your American Legion wrecking
contest, through which more than 300,000 high
about the Constitution of the United States?

program

Is
flag

of

it
to

sponsors a Boys'
the youth of our

State
land?

America through
school students

the sponsorship
each year learn

of its oratorical
a little more

your American Legion wrecking America when it actively
education to build a deeper respect for Old Glory?

Is your
Baseball Program for
on the sand lots?

participates

in

a

it sponsors
the lessons

an
of

annual Junior Legion
good citizenship

Is your American Legion wrecking America when it carries
back- tochureh program with full emphasis on religious training?

on

a back-to-God

and

on

a definite

birth

for

an

a charge is
been active

American Legion wrecking America when
thousands of boys in which they learn

and

Is your American Legion
program of
combatting

wrecking America when, since its birth, it
Communism and all un-American activities?

Is your American Legion wrecking America when
adequate system of defense for this nation?

it

has

been

fighting

has

carried

since

its

Of course you know and every loyal Legionnaire knows that the answer to
a resounding no.
Instead of wrecking America, you and every Legionnaire
in building America.
It is your American Legion and it is under fire.

such
have

The National Commander is convinced, and so am I, that the best and most
effective answer to such a vicious charge against your organization is to.immediately
membership strength in your own post and all posts to an all- time high.
:

build

I have brought with me this morning a supply of membership workers pamphlets
entitled "The Magic Formula."
I have asked the members of the Field Service, under Nick
Lynch, to distribute these pamphlets to you.
You will note that each booklet contains
five applications and I would say to you, I would appeal to you with every ounce of
sincerity, to take the lead in this drive by immediately signing up five new members in our
organization, and I would further appeal to you to get every Legionnaire to do the same,
and do it immediately.
Finally, I would hope that when each of you leave this conference and return
to your communities, you would return with the enthusiasm that it is great to be an American
Legionnaire, an enthusiasm so convincing as to prove to anyone that the original promises
that we made were not made just for the fun of it, but that they will ever remain our
common determination, and that our job will not be complete until every man and woman who
wears the blue hat in this organization can walk down Main Street in his 93 her community,
‘raise his head and mhout' to the world, "I am proud to be a Legionnaire."
Thank you.
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Thank you very much, Howard, and thank you, Commander Wagner.
I think I could safely say that both of these fine gentlemen have been talking to the right
people.
I am convinced that, year in and year out, the backbone of the membership program
of The American Legion in every single post of America is from the service officers and
the rehabilitation workers.
I think we could very well at this time, ladies and gentlemen,
renew our pledge of service to our National Commander and show him by a round of applause
that we will do all that we can to promote his administration and the success of our
organization.
Will you join me?
CHAIRMAN HORTON:
and he will take up

I would like now to
where we left off.

return

the

Louisiana,

We would
of it.

pleased

of

remain.

benefit

out

MR.
South

Dakota.

these

cases

be

very

have

all

you

to Question 14,
iike to comment

to

You

George

might

Deris

get

a

of

little

which was submitted by Ranney
further on that question.

of

MR. ROBSON:
With further regard to the question, I might say that some
in which we have to determine
whether a man FeuiTes: 4aid ‘and attendance

of
are

I

DERIS:
We will return
think Mr. Robson would

to

panel

=-65=~

difficult to decide.
We have enountered instances where Regional Offices were under the
impression that the veteran had to meet probably all of the requirements of 1176 in order to
be entitled.
We have instructed them of course, to the contrary.
It is not necessary that
all provisions or requirements of 1176 be met.
Also with regard to mental patients in
institutions, at one time it was thought that no patient in a hospital would be entitled
to the additional allowance.
That isn't true.
If he would be entitled to it on the outside,
he would be entitled to it on the inside.
That is to say, 1f he required assistance even
while in the hospital as a mental patient, in dressing and feeding himself, or attending
to any of his natural wants, he would not be denied.
I do not think we can at all restrict
Occasionally there are, as I mentioned, borderline
would suggest that you bring them to our attention

him in
regard to granting the
questions.
If you have any of
at Central Office.

benefit.
those, I

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
I wonder if I might interject myself here for a moment to
ask you, please, to refrain from your little private conferences in the back and from the
muttering and chattering that interferes with the proceedings.
I think you get the idea.
We appreciate it.
And thank you for your response.

Ladies and gentlemen, it is my great
of the greatest friends the American veteran ever
on us this morning, Admiral Joel T. Boone.
Won't
mighty glad to have you here.

pleasure
had.
He
you come

to recognize the presence of one
has paid us the honor to drop in
up, Admiral Boone? And we are

ADMIRAL JOEL T. BOONE:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen:
I must catch my
breath.
I just walked into the room, timing my arrival to hear the National .Commander, and
I am disappointed that I was delayed en route and deprivedof hearing him.

I, as
a lot of notoriety
I am just a little

could hear
fit to ask

you know, have been trying to get
these days, and I walked up these
bit short of breath.

over an illness which is
steps, which I shouldn't

one that gets
have done, so

I had no idea when I slipped into the room and moved up a little bit so that I
that I would be recognized.
I am very grateful to your Chairman for having seen
me to come forward.

If I might say a word, I just want to reiterate that even though I have retired
for the second time over five years ago from the Navy, after a long career; and celebrated
yesterday, if you may call it such, my first year in retirement as Chief Medical Director
of the Veterans Administration, it has been a rather tough year at making a comeback to
health, but it can be done.
That is rather significant, maybe, to say that today.
I feel that I am coming back.
I have said here before, before -this group and
other veterans groups, that I
have only one desire in continuing to live and that is if the
good Lord has use for me, and I shall reiterate
and assure you and promise you, as I have
in the past, that I shall always, as long as I live, be faithful to the veterans of this
nation and shall always be ready to serve them.
The other day, a few weeks ago, I was invited to appear before the Veterans
Committee of the House of Representatives when they had before them Mr. Higley and some of
the Department of Medicine and Surgery people discussing primarily the rehabilitation program
of the hospitals of the VA for those who so sorely need rehabilitation.
I was asked to come
forward and speak before the committee.
I was conscious that I had spoken and been called
upon before committees of Congress for thirty-five years.
1 have never appeared before any
committee of Congress which has been so courteous and considerate and I felt so informed
on their mission, as was the Veterans Committee of the House of Representatives.
I took occasion on that day to speak from the heart in regard to, as Mr. Higley
had projected the subject,the nonservice-connected.
I was glad he did because too often it
has been kept behind the scenes, and I do not feel that we need to have any fear about discussing the subject.
I said on that occasion, because I have had reason in the past year
to analyze it in my own case, "Who in this nation of my profession can determine in the many
disease entities from where an ailment came?"
I think we are on very firm grounds in doubting that you can make the line of demarcation as to cause between service and nonserviceconnected, and I feel a great disservice would be done to the veterans if they go too far
in trying to determine that the case is nonservice-connected or, rather, service-connected,
because no one knows from whence the ailment came or when it began.
It certainly is true in cancer; it certainly is true in cardiac situations; it
certainly is true in arthritics, multiple sclerosis, tuberculosis and others.
No one in my
profession has a right, I think, to say whether the condition did or did not emanate from
service, and I think that it is a subject that can be debated and I think there has been
too much disregard in relation to it, on the determination that it is nonservice-connected
and it attaches, unfortunately, a stigma to the individual on this subject, and I think a
very unjust and very unfair one.

-66-

So, I do not fear to face up to the issue.
I have had to face
issues in my time and as long as I believe in a principle and think a thing
prayerful consideration and analysis, I have no fear of the consequences.

up
is

to great
right, after

I think, too, that the Rehabilitation Commission has a great mission to perform,
first to educate a skeptical public because of the publicity given in a derogatory way to
refer to the nonservice case, as something that should be thrown aside as a discard and
left to his own devices.
So, I was glad that Mr. Higley, with his courage, injected the subject before
that committee.
We have heard a lot of it.
We will hear more about it, but, ladies and
gentlemen, be not afraid to take your position and stand on what you believe is a right
principle.
I do not mean the abuses.
I have no tolerance, and the Chairman of that Committee
referred to it, to the man or woman who will sign a P-10 fraudulently, any more than I have
for the individual in this country who signs his income tax fraudulently, and when the
challenge is made about the P-10 signature, remember, it is not only his signature but it
is an oath.
It is much more than your income tax signature.
Some say it is the weakness of
the law, but I say to you, and I said before the Congress, these laws have been made over
the years, approved by all Presidents -- no vetoes to them -- and by Congress after Congress
after Congress, with different men in them, and I believe that the laws as written on the
statute books of this land, made over those years, can be stood upon, and I do not believe
they are going to be changed.
3
Thank

you

very

much.

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
Thank you very much, Admiral.
Your presence
and pleasant interruption of our program.
We hope that through the
have other such delightful interruptions.

welcome
we will

George,

in receipt
the entire
income?"

will

you

take

here is a most
remaining days

over?

MR. DERIS:
Question No. 15, submitted by Cunningham of Indiana:
'"A veteran
of Part III pension owns a piece of rental property jointly with his wife.
Is
net income considered as income for the veteran or only one-half of the net
:

MR. BROOKS:
Separate income of a wife
with that of a veteran in determining the amount of
stances described in the question, only one-half of
determining the veteran's annual income.
MR.

DERIS:

Thank

you,

Mr.

of a
disabled veteran is not combined
his annual income.
Under the circumthe net income is to be considered in

Brooks.

Question 16 also from Cunningham of Indiana:
'"(a) If a veteran sells his
property on contract or holds the mortgage is any net profit as a result of the sale considered as income for the calendar year in which the property was sold?

income

"(b)
considered

If the property
was
as being one-half of

owned jointly
net profit?"

by

veteran

and

his

wife

is

veterans'

MR. BROOKS:
(a)
Where property is sold at a profit on contract or where .the
veteran holds a mortgage for the unpaid balance, no profit is considered to be received
until the costs of the property have been completely amortized through the receipt of
monthly payments.

is

realized,

owned jointly
death is sold
widow?"

(b)
only

If the veteran and his wife are co-owners of property upon which the profit
one-half of the net profit is considered as chargeable to the veteran.

MR.
by
by

DERIS:
Question 17, Cunningham of Indiana:
"If property is purchased and
a veteran and his wife during veteran's lifetime and following veteran's
the widow, what part of the selling price is considered as income to the

MR. HINTON:
VA Regulation 1228(C)(9) was amended on August 26, 1955, to provide
specifically with reference to property received by inheritance that, "where such property
is converted into cash, the amount of the claimant's personal contribution will be deducted
in determining the net income."

his wife
price is

This rule contemplates that where
and she receives sole title by reason
considered income, less the amount of

property is owned jointly by a veteran and
of his death, the whole amount of the selling
her personal contribution to the purchase piice.

~67-=

This

income

is

further

reduced

by

deducting

the

cost

of

conveyancing,

MR. DERIS:
Question 18, submitted jointly by Cunningham of Indiana and
Sanderson of Nebraska:
"A veteran who has been awarded a 100 per cent rating under Extension
7 as amended by Extension 9 to the 1945 Rating Schedule is discharged from a hospital and
is not entitled to a continuation of the 100 per cent rating according to the discharge
report.
The VA reduced his award effective the day following discharge from the hospital,
thus creating an overpayment subject to recovery.
By what authority does the VA make this
award
retroactive and proceed to collect from the veteran?"

by Extension
the physical

MR. BROOKS:
The 100 per cent convalescent rating under Extension 7, as amended
9, is granted for a specific period of time (30, 60 or 90 days) and only when
findings at the time of discharge from hospitalization indicate the need for

such

of

period

convalescence.

Therefore,

or the predetermined period of
application and the award must

when

the

requirement

of

the

time has expired, Veterans Regulation
be reduced on a factual basis.

Extension

2(a)

is

is

not

not

met

for

MR. CUNNINGHAM, Indiana:
Mr. Brooks, when this question came up it was our
opinion that the rating under Extension 9 which was granted to the veteran while he was
hospitalized actually became a running award just the same as Extension under 2(a).
Under
Extension 2(a), the provisions of Veterans Regulation 2(a) are for application.
I do not
believe that it is pioper to reduce a running award retroactively in view of the expressed
provisions of VA Regulation 2(a) or VR 2(a).
MR. BROOKS:
If a man is in
would apply.
However, by virtue of the
by Extension 9, the regulation, Veterans

and

an

MR.
Extension

CUNNINGHAM:
2(a) rating,

the hospital more than 21 days, Extension
prospective application of Extension 7 as
Regulation 2(a) is not applicable.

What would be the
except that it is

difference between
granted the day of

the Extension
surgery?

9

2(a)
amended
rating

MR. BROOKS:
They are both running awards, and on the face, it does appear
that the Extensiomsin that
particular are not too consistent.
However, all I can say to
you at this time is that we will have to review both of the Extensions with a view to reconciling them.
MR. GRADY, Ohio:
Let's dwell on Question 18.
In relation to this question,
why doesn't Veterans Regulation 2(a), Part I, Paragraph III(B) apply with the cutoff date
between the end of the month when the award is prepared; and then why doesn't Administrative Decision 544 cover these administrative deficiencies?
MR. BROOKS:
Administrative Decision 544 does cover the deficiencies when we
have paid a man beyond the period for which his award was originally intended.
As I have
said, it could be argued, of course, that 544 does apply in Extension 7 cases.
It could
be argued, as well, that Extension 2(a), Regulation 2(a) applies.
It is the same rule,
applying or dealing with running awards in both instances.

I have admitted the
them into line.

extensions

are

inconsistent

and

said

we

intend

to

study

them

to

long
also
able

MR. DERIS:
Question 19, submitted by Halligan of Colorado:
"Why are such
delays encountered in settlement of death compensation, pension and insurance claims,
burial allowance claims, in the Veterans Benefits Office when District Offices are
to settle claims promptly?"

bring

MR. HINTON:
We have recently made surveys with regard to the elapsed calendar
days required to process the various. types of death claims in the Veterans Benefits Office,
also in the District Offices, from the date of their receipt in the Dependents Claims
Division to the date of an initial award or disallowance.
These most recent surveys show
as follows:

sation and
Pension is

is

12.8.

District

for

In Veterans Benefits Office, time,
Pension is 22.9.
That time required
22.7.
That is very close.

The

calendar days for CompenOffice for Compensation and

In the Veterans Benefits Office, the time elapsed on all types of
time in the District Offices for National Service Life Insurance

The time for
Offices, 14.8.

Burial

Claims

The elapsed days shown
processing exceptional cases.

Benefits

average elapsed
in the District

We
Office

are
and

are

in

the

Veterans

averages

not aware of any undue delays
we are constantly striving to

-67A-

only

Benefits

and

do

not

Office

insurance
is 11.2.

is

12

days;

in

represent

the

time

required

at present existing in the Veterans
correct any out-of-line situations to

the

improve

the

operation.

MR. HALLIGAN, Colorado:
In reference to a death claim, then, why did it take
from Novembe: 16, when the application was first made, to February 12th to be paid off?
I will grant you this, that the request had been made for a death certificate.
However,
when the veteran died in the Veterans Administration hospital I don't think it was necessary to have the individual claimant supply the death certificate.
MR. HINTON:
Well, of
cases.
There are individual cases
District Office which require much
sometimes due to error.

course,

of

we

course, in these reports we didn't go into the individual
that go to the Veterans Benefits Office and in the
longer time due to various conditions, and so forth, and
:

However, we were just giving the averages
would be glad to look into that.

and

if

thereis

any

individual

case,

MR. HALLIGAN:
We don't care to go into individual cases.
It is the overall
coverage that we are interested in.
In this case, the claimant did not need the ‘money,
necessarily, at the time.
However, if it was a widow and orphans who needed the money,
it would be a mighty long time for them to wait to collect the money they had already paid
out.
Why was the death certificate requested?
MR.

HINTON:

It

was

obviously

requested

in

MR. HALLIGAN:
According to the District
formed the representative of The American Legion that
on the carpet the next morning.
Now, why doesn't the
"make those claims, and why isn'tit
corrected?
MR.

HINTON:

It

will

be

corrected

if

you

error.

Office, the
if they had
office that

gentleman out there inasked for it they would
handles the question

let

the

me

know

case.

MR. STEVENS:
Ray, can you tell me how many exceptional cases you have,
approximately?
We have ‘this belief, that it is taking an unconscionably long time in
many cases.
Your averages are fine, but your settlement of claims takes time.

that

have

MR.

HINTON:

You

MR.

STEVENS:

Yes,

are speaking

of

the Veterans

Benefits

be

too

Office?

sir.

MR. HINTON:
I don't believe we have
required an unusual length of time.

any

particular
g

record

of

any

of

the

cases

MR. STEVENS:
May I ask this question, please, Ray?
It is my understanding
that you reorganized.
You aren't
responsible for it’ -- I mean except as Director of the
Service -- any more than you are for the operation of the Regional Offices, but wasn't

there in the fall and winter a reorganization
over there that caused the delays?
been a failure of matching of mail and files in thousands and thousands of cases

weeks

and

weeks,

and

are

you

doing

MR. HINTON:
That
the past three or four months,
this month up to and including
much improvement, and I expect

something
and

have

you

done

something

about

Has there
that took
it?

is true.
There have been many changes made over there in
and this latest report which, as a matter of fact, includes
yesterday, shows considerable improvement, in fact, very
it will from now on.

MR. FARRINGTON, California:
I would like to ask one question, please.
Does
your office require the Dependents Claims Service to give you a monthly statistical report
cases that have been outstanding and not adjusted on a one-month's basis,or 60 days, or
8ix months or one year, so that you people in the top echelon, when you see something has
been hanging fire for six monthsor a year, can take some kind of corrective action to
eliminate those bottlenecks or delays?

constant

MR. HINTON:
No, we don't get reports
surveys, not every month, necessarily.

would

get

yourself

;

MR.

of

that

kind.

MR. FARRINGTON:
out

HINTON:

of

a

that

kind

but

we

are

making

these

I think if you would explore that thought a little bit, you

tight

That

of

on

is

spot

of

being

explored.

criticism

that
I have

we

feel

is

justly

deserved.

on my

desk

now

recommendation

a

S
MR. BROOKS, Ohio:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to inject a question at this time
while we are on death cases, relative to the nontransfer of outpatient treatment to the
District Office at time an XC case is made.
It is our feeling that there are instances,
especially in cases of World War II and Korean veterans who have died on account
of nonservice
disability, and in that case the District Office, without the availability of the outpatient

-68<

treatment
ment up to

folder -- there
practically the

are
day

cases where the veteran had been receiving
of death, and it is never reflected within

Therefore,

those

cases

are

not

getting

~ MR.

REINMUTH:

We

MR.

BROOKS,

Ohio:

folder

will

identical

MR. REINMUTH:
be transferred

a

true

evaluation.

will

look

into

that.

You

told

us

that

last

outpatient
the claims

year.

There is a procedure which indicates no outpatient
in a death case unless specifically requested.

MR. DIXON, Florida:
Sir, if you read
question.
I got the identical answer.

treatfolder.

back,

last

year's

program,

treatment

I asked

the

MR. HEINMUTH:
This question comes in connection with the work of the rating
board.
There were no questions handed in on that, and, hence, we don't have our people from
that board here.
All I can say is that we will look into it again.
I don't know just what
the problem is.
MR. DERIS:
recommendation on that?

Melvin,

with

reference

to

that

question,

would

you

care

to make

a

MR. DIXON:
I don't know whether it is necessary or. not, Mr. Chairman.
I am in
total agreement with our friend here that it is our opinion when an active C file becomes an
XC case, where there is service connection established, before that file
leaves the Regional
Office the outpatient file should be incorporated and sent along with it.
At the present
time, that is not the procedure.
I raised this question last year and we had a similar
discussion on it, and they finally agreed that maybe this might be a good idea, but nothing
has ever come out of it, and all we are asking -- and if it takes a recommendation, I think
we should make one -- bot it doesn't look to me like we should need ome.
It looks to me
like these gentlemen from the VA shouldn't hesitate with this thing.

with

it,

When
anyway.

they

get

the

outpatient

file,

it ‘lies

there

and

gathers

dust.

Do

something

MR. DRIVER:
Mr
Dixon, I wasn't aware of this, but since the matter has been
brought up here this morning I can assure you that we will look into it and we will do it
promptly, and we will write you and let you know what we decided.

over

MR. DERIS:
to Walter Kownaski

At this time
of New York.

I would

like

to

turn

the

next

portion

of

our

questions

MR. EGAN; Delaware:
In connection with the last question, we are back where
we started this morning on the retired T folder.
Will they pull the retired T folder out
and put it in the XC folder?
The determination of widow's entitlement many times is contained in that retired folder which is taken out of circulation completely.

them

in

there

Put
so

them
that

all in, whether they are
we get a clear picture.

MR. DRIVER:
Mr. Egan,
part of the whole problem.
We will
you a complete answer.
;

retired;

or

whether

they

are

active.

Get

that problem that you brought up before, I think,
consider it all together and I assure you we will

is
give

In that connection, the Public Relations Dizector, George Kelly, has arranged
for a photographer to be out at the registration desk at 2 o'clock this afternoon for such
of the state delegations who would like to have this photographic record of your attendance
at this conference.
It is with the understanding that each department will pick up the tab
for their own pictures, but it is for your home town and home department publicity, and we
“think it is right in line with what the National Commander and the Nacional Membership Chairman would desire of all of us.
Thank you.
MR. -DERIS:
I would
New

York.

like
;

Thank
to

you,
turn

T.

O.

over

the

next

questions

-69-

to

our

friend

Walter

Kownaski

of

Es

MR. KRAABEL:
Chairman George and ladies and gentlemen, I have an announcement
to make that has just come up.
In connection with the National Commander's address and
that by the Membership Chairman, there are some departments who have asked for the opportunity
of having photographs and pictures of their delegations at this conference to go back to
‘their home-town papers in the interest of arousing some more enthusiasm both as to what The
American Legion is doing in servicing all veterans and highlighting the aroused campaign
for membership.

Office

going

MR. WALTER KOWNASKI:
to issue a new Rating

Question No.
Schedule?"

20.

Davison

of

Kansas:

"When

is

Central

MR. ROBSON:
Work
on the revision of the Schedule is progressing.
It is not
possible at this time to forecast a completion date.
As the various sections of the Schedule
are completed, your rehabilitation representatives in National Headquarters here will be
afforded an opportunity to offer their comments and recommendations.
MR.
clarification of
disabilities?"

KOWNASKI:
Question No. 21, Davison of Kansas:
the 1945 Rating Schedule, as it pertains to the

'When may
rating of

we expect a
neuropsychiatric

MR. ROBSON:
Since the 1945 Schedule was prepared there have been several
revisions of psychiatric and neurological nomenclature by the Army, by the VA and by the
American Psychiatric Association.
In particular, it has become
recognized that a new
type of psychoneurotic reaction, the undifferentiated anxiety reaction, is the most common
of all, though it is not listed in the 1945 Schedule.
Any revision of the 1945 Schedule will conform to the current psychiatric and
neurological nomenclature.
However, no serious difficulty has been encountered in applying
the Schedule to disabilities diagnosed under the new nomenclature.
The name of a disease
is less important than the amount of disability produced, and the effort is to rate on the
amount of disability shown.
MR. DAVISON: The question I had in mind, sir, was this.
I am of the belief
that our rating boards are in the doldrums in the rating of neuropsychiatric disabilities.
The Rating Schedule as it now exists is separated into two parts: the psychoneuroses and
the psychoses.
Our rating boards are of the belief that all psychoses are organic in
nature.
Too many times a veteran is: gervice-connected for a psychoneurosis or an anxiety
state and has a maturation of that neuropsychiatric disability into a psychosis which is
also functional in nature but the rating boards are of the belief that when they receive
. a diagnosis of a psychosis that it is organic in nature.
MR. ROBSON:
We have had a number of cases come to our attention of that sort
and quite a number of them have been held, in the later diagnosis, perhaps, to be dementia
praecox as a maturation of a previous diagnosis, anxiety state or of psychoneurotic manifestations.
I couldn't say that in every case that has been held as true, but a number
of them have come to my attention and have been decided that way.
MR. DAVISON:
We shouldn't have to appeal all of those cases.
We
them and, through the good graces of Dr. Shapiro and the Appeals Board, we are
satisfactory decisions, but those should be handled on a local level and there
some instructions sent out.

have appealed
getting
should be

MR. BROOKS:
This problemof the maturation of the psychoneurosis into the
psychosis has been broughtto our attention by the Rehabilitation Commission here, particularly by Dr. Shapiro and Mr. Stevens and Mr. Kraabel, and we have amended the regulation
to provide that no certificate of error is necessary when there is a change in diagnosis from
a psychoneurosis to a psychosis, and I may say that there is in the course of coordination
an issue which I think will serve to clarify the situation.
DR. SHAPIRO:
Harry, I think Mr. Brooks' answer is the one that I was going to
give you.
The difficulty has been that in practically nineteen out of twenty of these cases
that we bring to the attention of either Mr. Driver's group, the Board of Appeals has allowed
and it seems to me it is an awful waste of time and money to have hundreds and hundreds of
cases coming in here when the thing is so patent.
The hospital, for instance, over at Winter VA Hospital where you have these
excellent facilities, from the Menninger Clinic, they state definitely that the present
diagnoses is a maturation of the condition that the man had previously, and yet your rating
boards say no.
In Kansas, you know the situation, Mr. Driver.
We had dozens of cases from
Kansas and other states.
This has been brought to the attention of the VA and, as stated,:
there is going to be an issue released very soon which will touch on that subject.
But that is not the only thing.
There is still a great disparity between the
various climical entities, as mentioned in your present Rating Schedule and the diagnoses
that are being made by the Medical Service, and in my travels around the country, I am -surprised at the lack of knowledge that the members of the rating boards have, yes, even
the doctors in understanding just what the psychiatric disability diagnosed represents in
terms of the present Rating Schedule.
You are just driving a team out of force in this
instance, that is what you are doing, and I think the quicker we get this revision the better
off we are going to be.

-70-

The medical people have put out an excellent manual on
what it is all about but it doesn't seem that the rating boards do,
revision (I have seen part of it) this will all be clarified.

it.
and

The doctors know
I hope in this

MR. GRADY, Ohio:
In relatiom to the subject which we are talking about, there
develops considerable time element in developing these cases and in discussion with the
local Regional Office.
When we do send them down and they are evaluated by administrative
determination, why is it that we can't go back to the date that the claim was filed or sent
in, losing all of this time in the development of the case, and then the date of payment
is only made from the date of administrative determination.
Why shouldn't it go back to the
date of the claim?
MR. ROBSON:
If I get you right, your question was, Why would we make a
determination that this particular disability,
this maturation, shouldn't go back all the
way to the date of the original claim, and why we are making it from the date of the administrative determination; is that it?
MR.

GRADY:

Yes,

sir.

MR. ROBSON:
That is because it is predicated on a matter
words, this term, the change in the diagnosis, is an opinion rendered.
The other diagnosis wasn't in error.
MR.

However, the time
on it, I believe,

GRADY:

MR. ROBSON:
. beyond the date that the
Medical Director renders
MR.

That

is

true,

it

isn't

in

element that it takes to develop
should go Back priorto the date

GRADY:

error

and

there

anything

to

bar

is

a

matter

of

such

a

In other
fact.

opinion.

these cases and get a proper
of the determination.

I am quite sure we would have no
determination was made, that is,
an opinion on it.
We couldn't go
Is

it

of opinion.
It isn't a

determination

authority to go back any time
the date, for instance, the
behind that.
:

situation?

MR. BROOKS:
I may say that in this issue which we are preparing,
to include a paragraph which will clear up the effective date of the award and
these cases.

we intend
rating in

MR. STEVENS:
A question while you are at the mike, please.
Say that the information is in the hands of the Veterans Administration, the veteran is under treatment
in a VA hospital for a functional psychoneurosis, supposedly and a full-blown psychosis is
detected, a functional psychosis.
Do you have to make the effective date the date of your
determination in the rating agency, or do you not have. full authority under Veterans
Regulation 2(a), Part I, to hold that the information was in the hands of the Veterans
Administration a year or so before the actual rating?
‘MR. BROOKS:
Charlie, if you don't mind, I would rather not categorically
answer that question.
There are certain cases where there would be a matter of a claim
involved, and I think the whole situation had better be covered in the issue as best we

e
can.

MR. KOWNASKI:
Question
No. 22, again Davison of Kansas:
''Should a widow
whose normal income is within the statutory limits show on Form 8-685 as anticipated income
for the year a sum of money which an attorney advises her will probably be paid her from
settlement
of an estate sometime in September of the current year?"
MR. HINTON:
Yes.
A widow is not entitled to réceive death pension for a
year in which her income exceeds $1400 (or $2700).
The VA authorizes payments of pension
on statements furnished by claimants that their income is not expected to exceed the .
statutory limitation, rather than to withhold payments until after the year has expired.
Where a widow has reason to believe that her total income for the year would
exceed the statutory limitation and fails to furnish an accurate estimate
on her income
questionnaire, it may be necessary to discontinue her award effective the first of the
calendar year.
MR. DAVISON:
A widow, sir, who meets the requirements otherwise, for example,
she filled out her questionnaire in answering form 685; her income, as far as wages or
outside resources, is going to be under the $1400 limitation.
Her attorney tells her that
the estate will probably be settled in September; it may be five years before that estate
is settled.
The attorney may die.
Maybe three or four of the brothers and sisters may die.
That is simply an estimate that may never come true.
Maybe she doesn't have any income at all.
Maybe she tells you she thinks she is going to get $3.000 in September, but she doesn't
have any income at all.
How

is

that

widow

going

to

live?

The

71

attorney

may

die.

It might

be

set

aside.

I

contend

it

is

not

money

until

it

is

received.

MR. HINTON:
Of course, there has to be a rule -- she is supposed to advise
us what her income is expected to be.
It doesn't always turn out that way.
Sometimes they
expect to receive more and it turns out at the end of the year that they are within the
limitations, then we pay for that year.
MR. VALIANT, Colorado:
Mr. Hinton, you are passing judgment on something that
is purely speculative.
On the matter of inheritance,
there are many instances where a
claimant may feel or may be given some understanding or some anticipation that she is going
to have the estate settled within a specific time.
I don't think it is proper to hold that
benefits shall be withheld until that is actually received or until she indicates that she
will not receive it during that year.
I think the purpose of the death pension is being defeated.
I would like to
suggest that, in the matter of receiving estates, the Veterans Administration withhold any
determination of income until it is actually received.
I think that is proper and I think
that any lawyer will tell you that is proper.
MR.

take

steps

to

HINTON:

We

will

give

that

consideration.

MR. KOWNASKI:
Question 23, Davison
further develop the following type

of
of

Kansas:
claims:

"Why

doesn't

VA

rating

agencies

'"(a)
Veteran rated 80 per cent and the type of disability itself indicates
entitlement to a 100 per cent rating based on Code R, or individual unemployability;

probable

unemployed,

'""(b)
hence

Veteran
probable

rated 80 per cent and evidence in the file
entitlement to a 100 per cent rating.'

indicates

veteran

MR. ROBSON:
The facts as stated suggest an attitude in a particular office
or perhaps in a specific case.
Certainly it is expected the rating agency will institute
furthef development where there is present 80 per cent disability and either unemployment
shown or expected from the nature of the disability.
If you have encountered such an
attitude generally by a rating agency or in a specific case, I would suggest that you bring
the matter to the attention of Central Office.
MR. DAVISON:
It is realized that adjudication people have instructions to
develop claims, but as the years go by and they sweat out retirement, it is a whole lot.
easier not to develop a claim than it is to develop it.
They will go out and develop a
claim for a reduction but they don't go out and develop a case for an increase.

whoever

it

You
might

take
be),

a case back to the
how about this?"

"It

sure

looks

like

he

is

rating

entitled

clerk

to

and

you

say,

'Joe

(Frank

or

Bill,

it."

They ask you for evidence.
You go out and get the material and give him the
Code R information.
It is only a few veterans in comparison of all the veterans in the
United States.
We don't have enough powers of attorney and enough people to represent all
the veterans.
What are other veterans doing, getting 80 per cent and being satisfied,
simply because the VA won't go out and develop a case when they have the information in the
files that indicates that probably they are entitled to Code R.
They are not developing
If the man isn't fortunate enough to
which he should have.

the claims.
have a power

They are leaving them up to us to develop.
of attorney, he goes without the Code R

MR. ROBSON:
Certainly, as I stated, we don't expect that attitude from rating
boards.
In other words, when the rating board has before it a man with 80 per cent disability and some evidence that he is not working, they certainly should inquire into the
matter of whether or not he is employable, for the purpose of applying Code R.
Unfortunately,
1 suppose we do have rating boards that treat such cases lightly,and I would like very
much, .if you people encounter any such boards or any such situations, that you let us know
about it and we will be glad to know about it.
;

veteran
thing."

to

MR. DAVISON:
The adjudication officer tells
try to get information on his employment, then

That

entitle him
or complete

is

a bad

attitude

to

us, "If we write a letter to the
he thinks he is entitled to some:

take.

MR. SOMMER, Nebraska:
Do the questions which the veteran normally answers
to examination; are they used as the basis of determining employability, partial
unemployability?

-72-

MR.

ROBSON:

Would

you

repeat

the

first

part

of

your

question?

MR. SOMMER:
When a veteran is re-examined at the examining center as an
outpatient and he is normally asked a series of questions as to his occupation, his earnings,
and so forth, are his answers used in any way in determining whether or not he might be
entitled to 100 rather than 80 per cent?

ing

of,

a

MR. ROBSON:
I wouldn't
regular examination?
MR.

SOMMER:

When

MR.

ROBSON:

And

MR.

SOMMER:

Right.

the

know.

What

examination

man

is

called

makes

a

statement

in

interviewed.
he

for

on

and

periodic

the

form

what

center

are

you

speak-

examination,

he

is

always

whether

he

is

employed

or

not?

MR. ROBSON:
I wouldn't say that that would be conclusive.
It would be reported
to the doctors when he was examined, that he was working; not how much money would be inquired into; but I don't think we should take action on discontinuing an award merely on
that basis.

a

thing

done

MR. SOMMER:
about it.

Our

experience

is

that

unless

you

get

it

in

there,

there

isn't

MR. DIXON:
Wouldn't this simplify it, sir, if you would get out a directive
to the field, to the rating boards, saying that where information.
is put on 2545 with
reference to employment, where the veteran has qualifying disabilities and states that he
is unemployed, that the case will be developed?
I think that is all we are asking for,
because it has been our experience that when a man who is 100 pe. cent comes in and states
that he is employed, there is no recitation with reference to knocking him off and writing
letters in reference to substantiating the employability.
All that we are asking, sir, is that you work both sides of the street, and if
you will write a memorandum or letter or something -- and this is not just one or two cases
and just tell them how you want the job done, because they don't know.
You have one board
who will go ahead and get this evidence when they read it on the 2545; you have another
board that says, 'We can't develop claims.
The VA doesn't pay us to develop claims."
So,
to

all

we

need

is

to

have

clarified

do.

MR. BROOKS:
Mr.
know definitely that they are
on this subject.
However, we
sides

of

the

back

down

the

line,

what

they

are

supposed

Dixon, these rating boards should be experienced and should
to develop claims.
There is no question about the instructions
will get out an instruction which will attempt to work both

street.

MR. FENNER, North Carolina:
I would like to say with reference to our ex.perience in North Carolina that the boards are experienced.
They are experienced in developing the evidence which will permit them to cut the veteran's compensation down.
They have
very little experience in the matter of developing the other side of the picture.
In order that their experience may have some new information, it will be
appreciated if you will inform them that they are supposed, if that is true -- we don't
go by our experience there -- if it is true that they are supposed to develop evidence
that might favor the veteran, it would be greatly appreciated if you would inform the
rating boards to that effect.
MR. STEVENS:
I have just one quick comment.
I think you have got some fine,
high-powered talent from the Veterans Administration here.
We work with them; they work
well with us.
They have prepared their answers to the questions and you must be satisfied.

But there are often times, through discussions of questions and answers from
the VA people, ideas that may develop that might lead to a better operation of the agency.
This is a very crucial question that was asked here and it tiés up with one which Jim Crider
asks later.
We have had a very unfortunate experience and it is indirectly related to what
I am about to say, the fact that the rating boards throughout the country were urged in 1944,
by directive and by word of mouth of those responsible, by every possible means, to put
these men on the rolls.
They did.
Since then, the '"productionitis" developing in the VA
because of limited personnel, because of their reluctance to ask for the funds they need
because they are too guided by the Bureau of Budgets' finger upon them has resulted in too
little attention being paid to the rating of living veterans’ claims, and I do think that
this deserves an answer from the Veterans Administration:
Have they the personnel they need

=72A-

--

to do the job they need to do?
Ate work measurement standards so inflexible that 'productionitis' must force a certain number of cases to be handled daily by the various
. personnel concerned with adjudication of claims, to the extent that these people, the VA
people here, themselves, are dissatisifed with what they are doing?

Henry

MR.

KOWNASKI:

Any

MR.

STEVENS:

Excuse

questions?

MR.

DRIVER:

me,

Walter.

(reading
May

Question

I

have

that

was

an

24).
answer

from

Bill

Driver

or

Brooks?
I

thought

for

a moment

a rhetorical

question,

Mr.

Stevens.

The question of work standards and the volume of work we expect to be turned
out by a rating board is one which is receiving consideration by all of us who have any
responsibility in the field.
We have recently installed new work standards which I presume
most of you are familiar with.
They are in the process of being validated and they have
shown us a lot of information which I think has been concealed over the years.
On the very point you raise, we notice that many offices are producing what
we consider to be a rather small number of work units with an inordinately large staff.
We
are very much concerned with that and are making a concerted effort to find out what the
reasons are, what lies
behind those things, and we hope we can correct it.
If I were to
say that we had too few people or too many, I would be speaking without proper information.
We don't know that.
Certainly most of our offices are nearly properly staffed.
Many of
them have too many people, we feel confident of that.
On the other side we feel just as
sure that many of them have too few.
It is our aim to correct that just as promptly as we
can.
MR. STEVENS:
Thank you, Bill, and I ‘think Henry has a comment maybe afterwards.
You know, what I wanted to ask was just that.
We are discouraged that a change in attitude
in the Veterans Administration is causing, has been
causing, over the period from December
1, 1954, hundreds and hundreds of veterans to have their service connection severed.
It
is being observed year after year by top-sheet rating, and, eventually, in the review that
the VA brought about by the issuance of the Service Letter in December, 1954, of World War
II claims, which has caused a tremendous load of work, and it is justified work but it has
also resulted in the depriving of veterans prospectively of those benefits that they had
come to depend upon and felt that they were clearly
entitled to receive.
They had been on the rolls for ten years,
this, that there is a lack of - concern in the Veterans
ulation governing the severance of service connection,
think that difference of opinion is often mistaken for
wonder if Henry thinks that is so, too.

many of them, or more.
We do
Administration today with the
which is VA Regulation 1009.
clear and unmistakable error,

think
regWe
and I

MR. BROOKS:
Whatever work measurement standards we may adopt, however they
may develop with regard to this office or the other office, I can assure you (and I know
Mr. Driver agrees with me 100 per cent) that we do not intend any sacrifice of quality whatsoever.
Mr. Stevens has gone into this matter of the review.
earlier this morning.
It has increased
the work.
It is not being
of the current operation.
No time limit for the completion of the
We

expect

it

to

be

done

as

it

can

be

Mr. Stone spoke of that
pushed at the expense
review has been fixed.

done.

With regard to the severance of the service connection, I can say, as you know,
that we have established a group at Central Office who review all of these before they
become final.
We did review those that had been severed.
We are reviewing now all of the
proposed severances.
We are using every precaution we can to see that all severances are
on the basis of clear and unmistakable error.
From my own experience in seeing quite a large
that in the vast majority of them, I ‘think they were put on
mistakably erroneous basis.
MR.

STEVENS:

Thanks,

number of
the rolls

those cases,
on a clearly

I can
un-

say

Henry.

At the request of Mr. Kraabel and some of us who sat down with Mr. Ralph Stone,
the Chief Benefits Director, Bill Driver, Henry and some more, the Veterans Administration
set up a special group to review these claims in which severance of service connection had
been effected or in which severance of service connection is proposed.
We think they certainly do a good job on those claims, but we do feel that too many are approved as being
properly severed on the basis of clear and unmistakable error when it is clearly and purely
a difference of opinion.

made

there

We aren't
because the

expecting to get those appeals allowed
Board of Veterans Appeals is afflicted

<73~

from
with

the
the

decisions that are
same present-day

thinking that apparently exists in the Compensation and Pension Service.
I think that
' needs to be said for the record.
I do believe, truly, that you folks in the field have a
very great obligation in those cases which The American Legion is appointed
representative
and we who work here in the Veterans Benefits Office have an obligation to watch carefully
to see that those claims in which you feel a difference of opinion is the basis for the
We need to know this.
severance are brought to our attention.
I

say

this,

that

there

is

no

limitation

be made, and it is a necessary review, we grant.
developed over a long period of years because, as

to

the

time

in

It is a cleaning
I say, there was

which

the

review

needs

up of a situation that
too much top-sheet rating.

However, we still think it is pretty tough to sever service connection granted
by aggravation once the initial rating is granted, other than through a difference of opinion,
and I did want the record to show that The American Legion is not satisfied that the actions
presently being taken are correct, and we think definitely that the General Accounting
Office as an arm of the Congress and the Bureau of the Budget as a part of the Executive
Office are responsible for a change in policy over these past ten years.
MR. DIXON:
Charlie,
that we people in the field be on
you, but, unfortunately, we don't
out and got it up here.
They are
ings.

you

see

MR.

STEVENS:

MR.

DIXON:

Not

let
the
see
not

|

me ask you a question before you sit down.
You asked
alert to watch for this difference.
I agree with
that case in the field before they have slipped it
sending them across the review table on routine rat-

where

they

are

proposed,

But we don't

get

them

in time.

no.

Where

they

are

severed,

yes,

them.

Legion

has

a day of

MR.
power

|

STEVENS:
Charles Marton of our shop sees every case in which The American
of attorney and is keeping a record of every case and there is going to be

reckoning.

i

MR. DIXON:
And that is the first we hear of it, Charlie, when we hear from
you up here that the case has been sent up here with a proposal to sever.
The local representatives are not informed, and I have raised Cain about it and they have said: that is
an administrative action, it is none of our business.
MR. STEVENS:
It is in the proposal until the
decided to sever, Mel, because they don't want the veteran
lose his service connection until they actually notify him

they

are

I will tell
reversed and it

try

to

But what we are anxious
something about it.

do

the field
shut.

MR.
and we

you this,
is better

in the
not to
for

time when it is
to believe that
he is.

definitely
he is going

frequently
notices.

but

fairly

record

of

each

these

hitch on
here and

it.
the

You ask
horse is

proposals
have sent
is

to

get

not
out
a

too
the

/

to

often
|

of

cases

and

then
|

DIXON:
You have to keep a tight
don't see them until they get up

us to be
gone and

alert in
the door

is

MR. BROOKS:
I would like to make one remark before closing this discussion.
All this procedure has done is to inject one additional step.
‘Insofar as this procedure is
concerned, it is identical with the procedure that has been in effect for years.
In other
words, there is a proposed severanceof service connection.
The man is given 60 days before
it becomes effective.
That is exactly the situation with regard to this review made by
this special group in Central Office.

of fact,
pay that

That man is not advised of any severance; he is given 60 days and, as a matter
under this procedure he probably draws perhaps one or maybe two or more months’
he otherwise wouldn't have drawn.

from

here,

up

the veteran.
proceeds just

MR. DIXON:
Where
doesn't it?
MR.
It
as

does

BROOKS:
No, from
comes back to the
heretofore.

the

notice

come

from

the Regional Office.
Regional Office with

that

goes

to

the

veteran?

It

comes

The office here writes no letter to
their opinion and the Regional Office

MR. STEVENS:
Mel, I did want to say that was what I was trying to say and
Henry is exactly right.
We think it is a good thing to have this additional step because
we don't believe we will have much success with the Appeals Board in reversing the severance
of service connection.

-74-

|
|

|

{

|

MR. MARKOWITZ, Pennsylvania:
Just one question along that line.
The field
still doesn't have an opportunity to look at it before it comes down here -- the field
doesn't have an opportunity to look at that folder because before it comes down to Central
Office to tell you whether there was a difference of opinion, to alert you ~-- and I think
that is what Mel Dimon was complaining about =-- the folder is sent down to Washington early
when the proposal is made for the severance of service connection.

have
That

Now, the veteran notifies the service officer.
The service officer doesn't
any folder or anything else to look at because it is here. - How do you overcome that? .
is the question I think is bothering Mel and some of the boys.

heard

about

MR.
it.

STEVENS:

MR.

MARKOWITZ:

The

He

veteran

just

hasn't

told

us

notified

you

he

days'

got

60

of

that

because

he

hasn't

even

notice.

MR. STEVENS:
No, no, the veteran doesn't get the 60-day notice until following
the review that decides whether or not the rating board action will be approved or disapproved.
That is what it is, Mike.
Here is the situation.
That is administrative.
It is in an
administrative channel but we want you to know and I hope you do have confidence in our staff,
that one of the best men on the staff, Charles Marton, is seeing every one of those cases
and making‘a record of them, because we propose again to talk to Mr. Stone and he is always
reasonable and willing to listen.
But we do believe that it will help us if, once cne severance of service
connection is threatened by the 60-day notice, that you, yourself, look over the file.
We
have got a good man looking at it but take a second look and if you feel you can get in
some evidence in there, get it in and still try to stop the severance, because you can do it
if there is that evidence obtainable.
Also, look to see whether in your judgment the severance is clearly and unmistakably erroneous on the basis of a clearly and unmistakably erroneous initial grant or
whether this is just a difference of opinion.
We want everybody to watch these cases and
protect those who deserve
protecting.
We aren't seeking to retain on the rolls people who
clearly had no entitlement, ever.
MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
Charlie, I am not going to buy your statement or your
thinking that having these cases sent up here, being another step, is a good thing.
That is
wherewe have gotten in trouble.
Central Office's attitude is the most vicious it has been
in the ten years I have been in this work. It is not the rating boards in the Regional
Offices that are giving us the most trouble; it is Central Office that is giving us the
trouble.
:
Now, I am not in a position to prove this, but, from the attitude I have seen
of the boards now, the number of cases they are wanting to send up here, I think Henry Brooks
must have told them he is going to give them a medal for the largest number of cases sent
up here in which they propose to sever service connection.

a

—

a ————

ee

ee

eee

Charlie, the greatest mistake that was ever made was when my friend from Alabama
- came up here with a group of cases -- they were good, and they thought they wére right at
the time -- and they said, "Look what they are doing," and they said, "We will call them
up here," and that is when the trouble all started.
When Central Office got hold of them
they didn't disapprove any proposal to sever service connection.
They sure as the devil
disapproved any proposal to grant service connection, but they don't know the other side of
the street.
MR. SHIELDS, Ohio:
I have heard mention made of the 60-day notice. - Is the
in d position to say to us that they will handle the ‘case in a period of 60 days so that
the event this man is declared eligible, his continuity of payment will continue?
My
question is, is 60 days sufficient time?
MR. BROOKS : Well, the 60 days has been inforce for many
question has never been raised before.
But insofar as this procedure
adopted, at the recommendation of the service organizations, bringing
these severances and these proposed severances.

VA
in

long years and that
is concerned, it was
these cases wo here,

Insofar as the procedure is concerned, it is the same.
If the case was not
sent in here for Central Office review, which essentially is a precautionary measure, you'd
be in the position of a
proposed severance of service connection, a memorandum rating,
advice to the veteran and his representative that it is
proposed to sever service connection,
and he was given 60 days in which to submit rebuttal evidence,

period

begins

That is
to run

exactly the same thing that 1s in effect now except
after the case is returnedto the Regional Office.

75=

that

that

60-day

MR. SHIELDS:
My question was, is that sufficient time?
I have seven counties
in Ohio.
That means a lot of travel.
Now, for me to go out and contact those men, as I say,
involves travel, and that must be done because, to give a true picture of the whole case,
you should be there to see the man, see the surroundings before you can intelligently give
these people an answer.
But

ever
rule

my

question

is

whether

60

days

is

sufficient

time.

MR. BROOKS:
Well, that is the first time the 60 days, so far as I know, has
been questioned, and it has certainly been in effect for years and years and the same
is in effect in connection with regard to reductions under Veterans Regulation 100(E).

MR. WADSWORTH, Alabama:
Mr. Brooks, it was stated, by a letter from Mr. Stone
dated December 15, 1955, that the purpose of the review was to be sure that all severance
was set up in accordance with district medical procedures; also, to look at the rating.
In
May of 1954, 1 was assured by Central Office that the purpose of the review was not instructions to tighten the purse string or to break service connection, yet by letter of
February
2, 1956, a letter goes down to the managers, personal and confidential, that the sole purpose
for the review is to correct clear and unmistakable errors, which in my opinion is being
interpreted to further sever service conmection of these cases which have been on the rolls
these ten and twelve years.
MR. BROOKS:
Mr. Wadsworth, there has been no change in the fundamental instructions as regards the preservation of service connection or the correction.of error on the
clear and unmistakable basis.
Fundamentally, there has been no change.
No instructions
have gone out from Central Office to any Regional Office, individually or generally, which
alter that basic principle.
MR.

WADSWORTH:

In

other

words,

you

deny

the

letter

of

February

2,

'56?

MR. BROOKS:
I am denying that any letter that went out gave the impression,
intentionally of otherwise, that there was any change in the fundamental
basis of severance
of service conneétion, or as a matter of fact, ratings, or what have you.
The whole purpose
1s correction of clear and unmistakable error.
If any office has the impression that
isn't true, we can't help it.
Nothing has been released
from Central Office which, so far
as I know, has changed the fundamental principle.
’
instructions,

MR. WADSWORTH:
I agree
I think, or the intent

with you, maybe the procedure hasn't changed,
of the instructions, is much different.

but the

‘MR. STEVENS:
I am very glad there was this discussion.
I am happy that Jim
Crider said what he did.
We are anxious to know field reactions.
That is why I brought it
up.
We thought we were doing the right thing.
I still think so in spite of the fact that
Jim doesn't agree with it, and I think a lot of Jim.

I did want this known, and we believe this to be true.
Ralph Stone has, not
once but on different occasions, assured us that there was no intention
in asking that the
review be made that there be a wholesale severance of service connection,
but it seems ta
be a change in the philosophy that has brought this about, associated with the
review.
We want to know if other folks here disapprove of the fact that we made the
arrangement to have the service connections that were severed, the cases in
which service
connection was severed, reviewed, or if they are dissatisfied with the preliminary
review
that is made before a veteran is even given his 60-day notice.
I ask this from others, if
they have objections as Jim has.
This is one thing that I think needs something done about
I don't agree ‘that there have been none which have been reversed in here.
We
have a record of them and we know that of all the severances of service connection
that were
effected in the field, not all of them were supported by the Central Office
reviewing the
case.
The men that are reviewing are men brought in from rating boards in the field.
Our
records will show as to the Legion cases that we see -- and those are all we
do see -that there are many cases in which the field action to sever and to propose
a severance
are not confirmed in Central Office.
They write back and tell them to put the case back
on and tell them why they should put it on.
MR. WADSWORTH:
I would say this in support of your making the arrangement to
call these cases in for review.
It was the salvation and saving of our situation in Alabama.
I would estimate by removing the authority from the Regional Office rating
board to sever
on the 1009(a) before it is
confirmed by Central Office in tbe past twelve months, we have
saved some three to five hundred service connections.

the case for
adjudication

MR. HUDGENS, Tennessee:
Prior to the time that the rating board submitted
the proposal of severance of service connection, does the
case go to an
officer for his approval or disapproval?

-76-

it.

MR.

Office

for

decision,

‘I don't

think

I understand

MR. HUDGENS:
Prior
review, does the case

to the
folder

time the claim folder is submitted
go to the adjudication officer?

as

BROOKS:

MR.

BROOKS:

MR.

HUDGENS:

MR.
you

BROOKS:
know.

Not

the

question.

necessarily,

no.

Can

he

stop

from

coming

up

No,

the

adjudication

officer

cannot

it

to

the

Central

here?
overrule

a rating

board's

officer

MR. HUDGENS:
Then, it looks like this situation should go to an adjudication
either for his approval or disapproval, like all other severance of service connection.

gsevers

the

MR.

BROOKS:

service

He

has

to

certify

connection

on

thé

basis

error
of

when

error,

the

not

rating

before

is

made

that

actually

then.

MR. DIXON:
I would like to make a statement for the record.
I think there was
a little confusion when I said we did not get to see the cases in the proposed state, where
the proposed severance was made.
The situation that I am concerned with (and 'concerned with"
is what I was trying to say) is where maybe there is a difference of opinion in the rating
board as to whether or not this case should be severed,
and it goes in to the adjudication
officer and then he sends it up administratively for a review. - That type of case, we never
get to see in the Regional Office until final action is taken, because that is an administrative action.
There is disagreement among the troops at home, so to speak, and we find that a great number of our cases are falling in that category where there is disagreement sent in
to the adjudication officer, say, and then to settle the argument he fires them up for
administrative review and the representative at home never gets in that picture until it
comes back from Central Office with the answer.
MR. MARKOWITZ, Pennsylvania:
It is a strange thing that all these things happen,
that is, orders are sent out of Central Office to the field to do certain things.
I have
very rarely seen where they are instructed in the field to be-a little more liberal in their
reviewing processes than they have been.
Usually the instructions that are sent out are sent
out with the thoughtin mind that they ought. to toughen up, and I am just wondering whether
we ought to disagree with the entire procedure that is being used and start out all ever
again and give the veteran a little bit of a break once in a while.
MR. MERRITT, North Carolina:
I would like to ask the gentlemen from the
Veterans Administration if they are in @ position to answer this question.
I know it
a statistical nature and they may not. be able to answer it at this time.
However, if
are not, I would like an answer later.

is of
they

As the result of the Service Letter of December 30, 1954, or any other Service
Letter or directives during or since 1954, what percentage of hearing disabilities have been
reviewed and what percentage of those reviewed have had service connection severed or their
ratings reduced?

type

of

hearing

a new

MR.

BROOKS:

MR.

MERRITT:

1 can't

give

Will

those

MR. BROOKS:
disability.

I don't

MR.
cases?

Were

MERRITT:

MR. BROOKS:
examination scheme

you

any

figures

think

there

we

not

figures
be

are

on

We

don't

any

figures

have

any

figures.

available?

collecting

special

that.

directives

particularly

specifically

earmarked

as

to

the

for

There is a program for re-examining the cases of hearing disability,
which I would suggest you discuss with the Medical Service Panel.

MR. EGAN, Delaware:
Since we are speaking on clear and unmistakable error in
rating and severance of service connection, I am wondering what kind of study the VA is going
‘to make where clear and unmistakable error has been made on the part of the Veterans Administration.
I have three specific cases which I am going t9 send down to you shortly, where
clear and unmistakable error unquestionably is shown.

review

their

: Since Delaware
records, also.

is

only

a

small

state,

perhaps

all

of

our

other

states

should

Case 1.
Seventeen veterans named John Doe.
We, at last -: this is a World War
I case -- have our Delaware John Doe selected out of the pile.
He has been rated on physical
examinations of the other sixteen John Does during the intervening years since World War I.

77

He has a clinically identifiable diagnosisof
What are we going to do about the error?
Are

tuberculosis, severe, at time of discharge.
we going to give him that $30,000?

And then there is this one.
Clinical diagnosis of active tuberculosis, severe.
Three of them.
They only happened to come in from New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and
Delaware.
One of them has a medical case in it.
The other one, the third one which is

coming

in

--

those

are

two

tuberculosis

cases,

and

one

of

them,

the

Veterans

Administration,

because they did not have diagnostic facilities available at the Veterans Administration
Hospital in Delaware, paid for thirteen days of hospitalization to receive a clinical diagnosis
of multiple sclerosis within less than six months of the date of discharge.
The effective
date of rating: 1955.
When was service connection granted?
From the date the claim was
The Veterans Administration didn't even attempt to secure the clinical records
hospital where the diagnosis was made.
They simply disallowed the case.

We

;
want

long

them

enough

If
to

clear and unmistakable
go back just as far as

error is in question, let it
That is all.
they go ahead.

CHAIRMAN HORTON :
Earl, will you excuse
to make a couple or three announcements,
(Announcement

regarding

banquet

be a

reopened.
from the

two-way

street.

me one minute?
I would like to break
and then to make a proposal to you.

in

tickets.)

CHAIRMAN HORTON:
I also want to announce, at the request of Charlie Stevens,
that the C folders which you have requested be obtained for your review are in Room 148 of
the VA Building, and Charles Marton.is over there to help you.

here at
at that

I wonder if you ladies
one-thirty.
Then, we would
hour, too.

and
ask

gentlemen would
these gentlemen

like
from

to adjourn now
the VA if they

and come back
would come back

MR. MARSH:
Just before Charlie Stevens, your Assistant Director for Claims,
was called off the platform, he asked me to ask for an expression of this conference as to
whether or not, in your opinion, the review of proposed sieverances should be continued in
Central Office of the Veterans Administration
under the special unit.
I think we should
have an expression from this conference.
(A number

of

calls

of

"Yes"

were

heard

and

Mr.

Crider

said,

'"No.")

MR. BROWNING:
Wait a minute.
I don't know how many of the members here have
reviewed the records from their own office. I took the time to do that before coming down
here and from the office, overall, not only my cases but others that were sent -down to this
office, and this office put back on twenty-one of them.
So, look out, now!
I might have
lost those to the Appeals Board.
¢
MR. EARL MERIFIELD, California;
Mr. Chairman, I was about to rise a few minutes
ago and remind the group here that Charlie had asked that question.
If you will recall,
Charlie Stevens said that the Veterans Administration had called these files back at the
request of The American Legion.
I want to say so far as the Los Angeles Office is concerned,
‘1 think this movement has had a very beneficial aspect (Charlie Farrington says to include
San Francisco in that.)
I think it has had this effect, that where rating boards might have
herétofore been a little promiscuous in their determination as to whether a clear and unmistakable error had taken place, they now, knowing that their proposed action is to be reviewed in Central Office, and knowing the regulations and the instructions that have been
sent out as to what constitutes clear and unmistakable error, it has been extremely beneficial
to have those cases called in and scrutinized.
HORTON:

Thank

only

hands

raised

CHAIRMAN
procedure.

HORTON:

It

this

with

us

that
have

I would also
you were all asleep,
known better.

many

CHAIRMAN
disagree?
(The

at

(The

in

seems

Earl.

Is

that

a pretty

disagreement

were

the

that

the

majority

general

sentiment?

representatives

sentiment

is

that

from
we

How

Tennessee.)

should

continue

return

and

;

Now, may I ask you
one-thirty?
We hate

We will

you,

like to
but you

resume

meeting

gentlemen, Mr.
to impose upon

apologize to the conference;
finally got going on a good,

the panel
recessed

Brooks and Mr. Robson,
you but we have gotten

at

at one-thirty.
twelve-thirty
-78-

o'clock.)

could you
behind.

be

I. thought earlier this morning"
lively 'discussion.
I should

TUESDAY

The

meeting

was

called

to

AFTERNOON

SESSION

February

29,

order

ome-thirty

at

1956
o'clock

by Mr.

C.C.

Horton.

MR. HORTON:
My good friend Jack Gleason has kindly consented to conduct the
portion of our panel remaining from this morning and the one scheduled for this afternoon
as well, and I would like at this time to present your Chairman, Jack Gleason.
?

(Mr.

Gleason

CHAIRMAN

where

you

left off

took

GLEASON:

the

Chair.)

Walter,

this morning?

will

you

take

over

and

carry

on

with

the

program

:

MR. KOWNASKI:
Question 24:
'Davison of Kansas wishes to know why VA claims
and VA Department of Medicine and Surgery do not cooperate inthe furnishing of outpatient
treatment records to €laims and Claims in furnishing up-to-date rating information for
outpatient records.
Replies should be fully coordinated between two departments on basis
of information furnished by Mr. Davison prior to conference."
MR. ROBSON:
Mr. Davison of Kansas, I believe presented this question and with
the question he made considerable comment in an attachment to his question.
We have read
that and thought it was an excellent presentation of the problem as it exists in the Regional
Office in Kansas City.
In the last analysis, it appears that the essence of the matter lies in the
fact that existing instructions which are adequate are not being followed.
Certainly in the
two examples cited in your presentation, material change did occur in the conditions of the
veterans which should have been reported to the Adjudication Division.
In one case, in
particular, I have in mind, the outpatient physician who examined the veteran not only found,
due to a neurological condition the loss of use of a hand, but he definitely stated that the
man had absolutely no use in the hand.
This should have come to the attention of the
Adjudication Division and should have been forwarded.
It is not believed that it is necessary for the medical service to be furnished
with the current rating sheets showing changes in the evaluation of the veteran's dis‘abilities, because they do not need to know the evaluation or ‘changes in the evaluation.
All they need do is promptly to report any material changes revealed in the course of treatment and Adjudication Fill take action accordingly.

will

be

given

This matter is being sain up vith the Medical Service and
to the situation as it exists in the Kansas City office.

particular

MR.

City.

DAVISON:

That

is

the

Wichita

office,

sir,

not

Kansas

attention

I would like to make a short comment.
It appears to me, Mr. Robson, that we all
get in a rut once in a while, including. the Veterans Administration and we in the service :
work, and I believe that it wouldn't hurt at all if there was a possibility of a reiteration
of this matter, that it be referred back to the Regional Office calling to their attention
again the importance of reporting a changed condition to Adjudication.
In years gone by, eight or ten years ago, after World War II there was a good
deal of material going from outpatient to the Adjudication Division and I will go along
with the VA and the Adjudication office’that a lot of the material was asinine and unnecessary.
Now nothing is going unless we request it and as I said this morning, we do not
represent all the veterans and if we weren't there to get the material out of outpatient
treatment and up to Adjudication, it wouldn't get there.
In the case of a lot of veterans
whom we don't represent, the materialin the outpatient treatment file should be going up to
Adjudication.
MR. ROBSON:
As I stated, we are going to take this up with the Medical Service
Director.
You do appreciate, of course, that it really is a problem for Medical Service
to .consider.
I think so far as I know, we have had no complaints in this situation in the
Wichita office and probably it is something that exists just in that particular office.
We will look into it or, rather, Medical Service will look into it, and I can assure you of
that.
We will take it up.
3
MR. KOWNASKI:
Question 25, Burns of Wisconsin:
"Why should
provide that on reelections between compensation and retirement pay award
governed by the date of receipt of the reelection?

MR. ROBSON:
MR.

KOWNASKI:

VA regulations
adjustments are

I believe Mr. Brooks will handle that.
We

will

hold 25

in

abeyance

79 =

until

Mr.

Brooks

gets

back.

Meantime,

I will
of the

take question 26, Russell of California:
deceased veteran's name on Form 8-685?"

The

amended

so

VA

boys

haven't

come

back

as

"Why

has

so

25

yet

the

and

VA

26

discontinued

will

be

held

the

in

placing

abeyance.

I will read No. 27, Russell of California:
"Why shouldn't VA regulations be
as to apply provisions of VAR1086 to those cases considered under VARL064 (B)?"

MR. ROBSON:
Briefly, Veterans Regulation 1064 (B) provides that in view of the
provisions of Section 300, Public Law 346, 78th Congress, benefits administered by the VA are
barred as to a particular period of service where the person is discharged or dismissed by
reason of a general court martial, as a conscientious objector who refuses duty or to wear
the uniform, or otherwise comply with lawful orders, or as a deserter or in case of an officer
where his resignation is.accepted for the good of the service.
However, if at time of commission of the offense such person was insane, he
shall not be barred from benefits to which he might otherwise be entitled.
In the case of a
veteran discharged or dismissed for any of the reasons cited, the fact of a psychosis becoming
manifest within the first year of discharge, while raising a presumption that the condition
had its inception during service, does not in itself serve to establish that when the acts
resulting in discharge or dismissal were committed, the veteran was insane.
The question
remains one of fact.

Mr.

Brooks

(Mr. Kownaski reread
when he returned.)

the

placing

. MR. KOWNASKI:
of the deceased

Question

25

and

was

again

No. 26, Russell of €alifornia:
veteran's name on Form 8-685?"

told

that

it

would

"Why

has

the

VA

be

answered

by

discontinued

MR. REINMUTH:
As you know, the 685 is prepared from the addressograph plates
of the Division of Disbursement.
In 1951 the Social Security Board, who issue checks
similar to the way the VA issues them, obtained the Comptroller General's approval of the
adoption of a shortened qualifying legend on benefits checks issued by that agencyin cases
of widows whose entitlement would cease upon remarriage. . At that time the General Accounting Office permitted the VA to eliminate the veteran's name.
That saved a great deal of
space on the addressograph plate and saved the Treasury Department a great deal of time
and money in changing plates.
Since it is no longer on the plate, it is no longer on the
questionnaire.
MR.

KOWNASKI:

Any

comments?

Question 25, Burns of Wisconsin:
‘Why
reelections between compensation and retirement pay
date of receipt of the reelection?"

should VA regulations
award adjustments are

provide that on
governed by the

MR. BROOKS:
VA Regulation 1302, which is the governing regulation on the
subject, reads as follows:
"Where
a person has a right to benefits under two or more laws,
he may elect to take under any law, regardless whether it is the greater.or lesser benefit,
and even though his election results in reducing the benefits of his dependents.
Any person
who elects to receive monetary benefits under any law places the right under another law in
suspense and may at any time, on election, cause the suspensionto be lifted by again electing monetary benefits under the other law,
However, benefits pursuant to a reelection are
payable only from the date of receipt of the claim (formal or informal) constituting the
:
reelection."

This regulation is predicated upon an.opinion of the Solicitor dated September
19, 1947, which, in turn, is based upon a decision of the Comptroller General of March 22,
1933, A-47575.
That is why reelection cam only be paid from the date it is made and processed.
;
MR. BURNS:
Mr. Chairman, I wonder if there is any recourse at all for taking
care of a case, for instance, that goes into a hospital.
A man drawing seventy-five percent
of his retirement on the enlisted man's rate goes into a VA hospital.
He is rated as
totally disabled but his examination in the hospital for it does not reach the Regional
Office until about six weeks later.
He is not informed of the rating until three months
later when he is rated 4s totally disabled.
In other words, the difference between compensation which he is- rightly entitledto is about $125 per month and it would seem that this
man had no notice at all as to what his rating would be; hence, he would have no chance
at
all to make a choice as to benefit he would prefer.

MR.

BROOKS:

This

is an original

. MR.

BURNS:

No,

on

reelection.

MR.

BROOKS:

I

think

it

would,

election?
Would

yes.

-80-

that
At

require

least

change

a change

in

in the

legislation?
decision

of

the

Comptroller

General;
MR.

and

I don't

think

he

Any

other

comments?

KOWNASKI:

changes

very

often.

Question 28, Merified of California:
'Why not
those in receipt of Part III and nonservice-connected death
of the award?"

request income statements from
benefits on the anniversary date

MR. BROOKS:
This same question was presented at the conference last year by
Mr. Merifield.
As you all will remember, at that time it was directed to the claims of living veterans.
There was considerable discussion.
It was our position that the present
practice gives the veteran better service in that he is accustomed to filing his income tax
return on a calendar basis and that it is easier and more convenient for him to use the
calendar year both for reporting his income for the past year and estimating his income for
the current year.
We also said, I believe, that it would cause administrative difficulties
‘because of the fact that we would very likely have to give up the help we now receive from
the Treasury Department in dispatching the questionnaires.
Mr. Merifield, I think, stated that processing the great number of questionnaires
in January of each year also caused administrative difficulties and seriously retarded the
current work and caused backlogs.
Certainly both arguments have merit.
However, we submitted
the problem to the Adjudication Officers at a series of conferences held with them last
spring and, after thorough discussion, it was the opinion of the majority that the practice
should not be changed.
Consequently, we accept this opinion and have not changed the present
practice.

Mr.

MR. KOWNASKI:
Any
Department Service

Shorter,

comments?
Officer of

At this time
Colorado.

I wish

to

turn

the

panel

over

2
MR. SHORTER:
Question No. 29, submitted by Mr. Crider of Tennessee:
Central Office defer action on claims and request verifications of facts contained
veterans service hospital records when such records are favorable to the veteran's
This is not being done in cases where service reports are unfavorable."

to

''Why does
in the
claim?

MR. ROBSON:
This question, presented by Mr. Crider, was presented originally,
I believe, on one particular case to Central Office, and we discussed it at some length
yesterday.
I want to assure Mr. Crider at this time that when the case was submitted to
Central Office, there was, of course, no thought of not accepting the facts recorded in the
official records, whether they were favorable or unfavorable.
However, following that submission, it is appreciated that there is a question with respect to the procedure followed
in this case and, for this reason, the case has now been recalled and we are going to give
it further study.
:
MR. CRIDER:
That is a good answer on that particular case but now let's talk
in generalities.
Mr. Robson, I have discussed with you and Mr. Brooks a number of times a
number of cases.
I would like to get an expression from the new Director, Mr. Driver, as
to what the position is going to be of the Veterans Administration where there is evidence
in the record favorable to the veteran, where you would question the authenticity of that
evidence.
Are you going to take the same position on evidence that is unfavorable and

question

the Service

Department

in the same way?

;
Now, I want to explain to this group, we did talk privately yesterday but I
want this groupto know just exactly what I am talking about because.l think this is serious.
In this particular case a man had twelve years' service.
He advanced from the rank of
private to master sergeant.
He served in the Pacific Theater combat, European Theater combat,
and Korean Theater combat and it wasn't until the Korean War that he became disabled.
The
service record said while in Korea, a shell exploded nearby and, although not physically
injured, he was shook up.
;
Well, they
in Tennessee.
He knows

sent
only

Administration

"inadequate

on this:

it down and we
one diagnosis.

have an incompetent chief medical officer down
I believe I want to quote from the Veterans

personality.”

I don't

care whose

case goes

down

there,

including Mr. Brooks and Mr. Driver, you are going to be an "inadequate personality" when
you come out, you can be assured of that.
The chief medical officer said, this is an inadequate
personality." The question sent up here was not at my request but at that of the manager and
Adjudication Officer and they said first, what authority hag the Rating Board to send this
case to a medical officer for a differential diagnosis when there is no differential diagnosis?
I think that is an important question.
:

There has been only one diagnosis made in that veteran's file by the service
department

but

one

without

andby VA

"anxiety

reaction,

secondary

They sent it down and what happens?
diagnosis: inadequate personality.
The second question they asked
sufficient evidence to sustain that

to combat."
The

was. this:
change in
-8l-

chief

medical

officer
:

doesn't

know

When the CMO changes the diagnosis
diagnosis,
do we have to accept it?
A

Do you
that.

know what Central Office did?
They said,
Go back to the Service Department and ask

"Don't pay any attention to
how the man was shook up."

that.

Ignore

I don't care if he was never shook up.
I am telling you -- and this is generalities, now -- if the facts are in the record, rate on the evidence of record.
Wouldn't
you have done the same thing if the records, the service records had said this man is an
alcoholic, he is a no-good, he is a CPI?
Would you have gone back to the Service Department
and said, "Prove it.
We don't believe it?"
You are not going to do it and I say to you, if there is evidence favorable
in those veterans' files, if you are going to question that favorable evidence, would you take
the same position and question any unfavorable evidence?
Will you go back to the Service
Department and say, "Prove to us this man is an alcoholic; prove to us he is a CPI; we are not
going to accept it until you do prove it?"

as

we

are

That is all
going to be on

back

to

MR.

case

have

ROBSON:

another

I want to
the other
We

have

look

at

know.
side?
tried

Are

to

we

be,

going

Mr.

to

Crider,

be

as

and

that

it.

MR. CRIDER:
Mr. Robson, I appreciate the facts
shouldn't have used an individual case in discussing it, but
I am trying to place before you.

fair

in
it

on

is

one

why

side

we

of

called

this particular
established the

the

ledger
;

your

case and I
problem that

At the same time, I am talking in general terms.
I have seen it happen before.
This isn't the first time this has ever happened.
This is one of the best cases it ever
happened to, I will guarantee you that.
I have never had anyone question a word in this case.
But I have seen others of a similar nature where it happened, and that is what I want to
know, what is going to be our position from here on out?
What are we going to do?
Are
we going to try to find some evidence -- why I know some rating boards that look at a case
and say, "What on God's earth can we find in here on which to deny the case?"
Or are we
going to look and say, 'What can we find that is in favor of the veteran and justify us
in allowing the case?"
MR. ROBSON:
You know, Mr. Crider, that
We have neve: issued instructions to that effect and
followed we will take steps to correct it right now.

is
if

not the
we find

policy of
that that

Central Office.
policy is being

MR. CRIDER:
Mr. Robson, we usually go through periods within the Veterans
Administration of different natures.
I have mentioned this before.
I can recall fo: a
time when the rating boards used to find every pretense on earth to keep from rating a case.
They would look at it and say, "Let's send it down to the chief medical officer," or "Let's
request some more service records , let's do anything to defer it."
We are in a period now where the rating boards are sending everything down to
the chief medical officer for differential diagnosis.
That sounds fine to them; they are
not going to have to rate that case for a month while they are waiting for the differential
diagnosis to come back.
That is what we are getting into now.
We find that boards lack the
desire, shall we call it, to face a difficult situation and they will pick on anything on
God's earth to keep from facing that issue, and maybe they think that by the time the case
comes back they will have been moved to another board, and the boards don't want to face
They don't like to do it.
that issue.
You get a difficult case before a rating board and they will worm and squirm and
do everything on God's earth to keep from rating a difficult case.
You carry a claim in
there that looks like a 1009 (a).
We would rather rate forty-seven cases than to make an
1009 (a) claim because that is difficult.
That is going to cause them a little more thinking
and a little more time and they have to put a little more down in writing on it.
MR.

ROBSON:

We

MR.

SHORTER:

Dr.

will

have

Shapiro

to

look

would

into

like

to

it,

Mr.

speak

Crider,
on

I assure

you

we

will.

this.

DR. SHAPIRO:
I would like to say, as long as you are trying to make an investigation as to what happened to this man in the service, about being shook up, while you
are at it, why don't you investigate the number of times that chief medical officer has been
reversed on this continuous diagnosis.
I ‘think, Jim, you sent me fifteen or twenty successive
cases where that chief medical officer was reversed.
I have called it to the attention of
your office.
Ask your manager, ask the other people what they think of these opinions.

If that is the case, if you are doing any investigating, find out why the rating
board persists in sending these cases to this chief medical officer who is reversed practically 100 per cent of the time when we call these cases in to Central Office -- and you

-82-

have

had

them

by
MR.

the

score,

SHORTER:

you

know.

Would

anyone

else

like

to

say

anything

on

this

question?

MR. DRIVER:
Mr. Crider, we appreciate your bringing this to our attention
as enthusiastically as you have. In your visit to Central Office -- and I understand you
are coming back again and we hope to go into it with you further -- I would like to tell
that we are preparing now for a meeting with our claims supervisors next month and these
exactly the things which we would like to get across to them.

you
are

It is easy enough to tell you, and actually sometimes it is easy enough to do,
to prepare instructions and to send them to the field and to tell them what we want, but as
you all know, the applications of those instructions sometimes are worse than the cause
which we are attempting to correct.
For that reason, we are attempting, through personal
contact, to correct these things -- and of course, one of the most useful and the most
frequent personal contacts in this service comes from a meeting of the supervisors.
We hope
to go over it with them and to bring uniformity into the program which will neither be so
liberal that we will all be subject to criticism, and at the same time so conservative that
it is obviously unjust.
‘MR. CRIDER:
I would like to make this observation, Mr. Driver.
The reason
I injected you into this, you know, I got to feeling sorry for Henry Brooks.
He used to
take about 50 percent of the brunt of this, and I knew you were new on the job.
I just
wanted to relieve Henry a little of some of this problem.
MR. DRIVER:
1 appreciate that.
As
office in hours very easily and I am not so sure
me to be subjected to this early in the game.
MR.

there

anyone

SHORTER:

Questions
who would

Anything

further

on

you know, I could measure my tenure in
but that it was a wholesome experience

for

29?

30 and 31, submitted by Davison of Kansas have
like to make a comment on either one of those?

been

answered.

Is

If not, we will pass on to 32, Laird of Iowa:
'Why are rating boards holding
veterans are no longer entitled to Part III benefits on basis. of information shown on Form
VB8-59 when this information in itself is insufficient to make a proper determination?
Further development might be indicated, but not termination of benefits."
MR. BROOKS :
I think the answer to that question is fairly obvious, that no
rating board, of course, should discontinue an existing permanent total rating on insufficient information.
Obviously, they should develop the case.
This is, of course,
a serious question and it is another one which we want to discuss fully with our field
supervisors when they come to Central Office next month, with the object in mind, of course,
of taking any DEcessary corrective measures.
MR. LAIRD, Iowa:
Mr.Chairman,
this was pretty well discussed under Question
13 this morning but it appears to me that this is simply a change in the attitude, for some
reason. - Maybe it is confined to the Regional Office in Des
Moines, only, I don't know,
but here they cut off, without physical examination, further development of the evidence
or anything of the sort, and a man who has been on since 1949, continuously, they now cut
off on the 38, 42, 47, and 54, and they cut every one of them off based simply on the fact
that on Form 59 they said it was shown that he was no longer incapable physically of continuous employment.

years was
irregular
know what
]

Now, let me just eite you this example.
This man went on in '38 and for three
without work.
He was formerly a farmer, then the next year,
'4l, he was in
employment; in '42 he got a job at $88 a month as a county bailiff.
Most of you
a county bailiff is. . All he does is sit around and do nothing.

Every year (and they cite me this in Des Moines) his wages have been increased
from $88 in '42 to $200 a month in 'S5.
That is just a -natural increase in compensation for
any employee of that county.
They have all had that same increase.

sheltered

The fellow is just as
employment, I don't know

unemployable now as he always
what sheltered employment is.

was.

If

he

isn't

in

MR. BROOKS: - It appears that he is in sheltered employment.
As I have said
before, we are going to try to get from our supervisors the full details of their examinations
at the Regional Offices as to these cases which ate heing discontinued as Part III cases
on the basis that they have been able to resume gainful employment.
MR.

SHORTER:

Question

33,

1s

Burns

there

anything

further

of Wisconsin:

on

Question

"It is believed
-83-

32?

that Form VB8-38' should

be

amended so that information regarding entitlement to outpatient
and training would be better understood by the veteran."

treatment

and

education

MR. BROOKS:
We agree with Mr. Burns that the letter should be clarified and
‘we have revised it to read as follows:
"You are entitled to necessary treatment by the
Veterans Administration for the conditions referred to above as service-connected.
This
letter will help to establish your entitlement to such benefits and should be presented at
This is not an authorization for treatment."
the time of application.
We expect
correct the

would

that

to have the
situation?

form

out

in

a very

short

time.

Mr.

Burns,

do

you

think

MR. BURNS:
I would suggest you tell him where to present himself for treatment.
What I want to correct is that some men have gone to hospitals, thinking they are going to
get outpatient treatment at the hospital, and I believe that all the questions of outpatient
treatment should be cleared through the Regional Office.
If you would add. that, that would

be satisfactory

MR.

to me.

}

BROOKS:

We

will

look

into

it.

;
MR. THOMAS B. EGAN, Delaware:
You can't clear them all through the Regional
Office.
We have just had our medical service decentralized to the hospital.
If you send
that out as% general letter, unless it applies to each respective state, you will have our
outpatient treatment patients coming down to the Regional Office and, again, they are on the
treadmill.
They are being shoved from pillar to post.
All our examinations and treatment,
including reports and physicals, are done at the VA hospital.
We have no medical service
in the Regional Office.
MR. SHORTER:
The same thing
Brooks said he would give it some

why Mr.

If there is nothing
the recommendations

exists
study.

in Colorado

further here, I will turn
of the Area Conference.

and

the

I am quite

mike

back

sure

to Mr.

that

is

Seaman

who

will

take

shall
would

MR. SEAMAN:
Thank you, Mr. Shorter.
The procedure provides that the conferees
concur in or reject the area recommendations.
However, before we go into that, I
like to recognize Loyd Pool to present a question to the Veterans Administration.

up

MR. LOYD POOL:
Mr. Driver, I am sure that the members of the conference and
the national ‘staff are pleased to know that you are going to hold meetings with your supervisors and take up some of these problems.
We would like to know, however, if, when you
take up these problems, you will bring to their attention the recommendations that might
come out of this conference wherein you have indicated that you would be willing to go along
and maybe make some of the changes requested by the men in attendance here.
MR. DRIVER:
We have made notes as we went along, especially
where we made direct commitments here this morning, and where any of them
ly handled with the supervisors, you may be sure that will be the case.

in the
can be

Jdffice and
in a month

In some situations it will require the development of a formal
whether the coordination process can stand the strain of getting
We will do our best, however.
is doubtful.

submitted

to the

MR.

SEAMAN:

panel

We

will

now

proceed

from Area E Conference

with

the

consideration

recommendation

No.

of

the

areas
appropriate-

issue in Central
something done

recommendations

4 of that Conference:

the National Rehabilitation Commission use all of the resourcés at its command to prevent
armed services from destroying the induction and/or separation chest x-ray films."
What

is

your

wish

with

regard

to

the

MR.

FARRINGTON,

California:

I move

MR.

KLEMMETSON,

washington:

I

MR, SEAMAN:
It is moved and
Conference be adopted by this conference.
usual sign.
Contrary,
It is so ordered.

second

adoption

of

that

recommendation

the

seconded that
All in favor

the

the

"That
the

recommendation?
be

adopted.

motion.
Recommendation No. 4 of the Area
of such adoption will signify by
-

the

Recommendation No. 4:
"In keeping with the long=standimg policy of The American
Legion: for the decentralization of the adjudication of death claims and related benefits to
the Regional Offices, we deplore the recent program of the Veterans Administrationof decentralizing to only a maximum of one Regional Office per state.
We strongly recommend for
economy, efficiency and better service to the widow, minor children and dependent parents,

that

all

the decentralization

Regional

of

the adjudication

of death

Offices."

claims

and

related

benefits

be to
:

-84-

MR.
recommendation

KLEMMETSON:
for

MR.

and

MR.
second.

the

our

Mr.

SLONEKER,

California:

SEAMAN:
You
All in favor

signify

back

to

I move

that

MR.

SLONEKER:

(The

motion

this be adopted

MR. SEAMAN:
by the usual

second

the

in the way of a

i

motion.
and you have heard the recommendation
sign.
Contrary.
So ordered.

6:
"That the application of Extension
rather than date of discharge from the

I move
was

1

have heard the motion
indicate by the usual

Recommendation No.
the termination of chemotherapy
TB case."

will

Chairman

committee.

the

seconded

adoption
by

Mr.

of

the

effective at
as an arrested

recommendation.

Klemmetson.)

You have heard the recommendation
sign.
Contrary.
So ordered.

I would like to recognize
Question 28 for the purpose of

6 become
hospital

and

the

Earl Merified of California
offering a recommendation.

second.

who

would

All

in

favor

like

to

refer

MR. MERIFIELD:
I wish to apologize to the Chairman.
I misunderstood the time
this panel was to be, but I understand that the question that I presented on the matter of
income statements being sent out on the anniversary date of the award was answered in
approximately the same way that it was answered last year.
You who were here at the conference recall that I called to your attention on this floor that we in Los Angeles Office
had some twenty thousand questionnaires last year on Part III cases and when I was back here
at the conference, we were still trying to dig out from under them and practically all other
adjudication processes in the office had to cease while an attempt was being made to clear
those questionnaires.
This year,instead of twenty thousand, because of the consolidation of the San
Diego Office and the increase of the number of Part III cases, we had approximately 25,000
questionnaires dumped into the office at the same time.
It affected not only the adjudication .
service;
it affected the Administrative Division considerably, to such an extent that it
created backlogs in other facets of the work.
I want to call to the attention of you representatives from smaller Regional
Offices, iho did not appear too much interested in the subject last year, that no doubt by
January 1, 1957, there will have been a decentralization of active awards on death claims,
and that in addition to your questionnaires coming through on Part III you will also have
all of the questionnaires coming in on death claims.
We anticipate in the Los Angeles
Office that will mean about fifty thousand death claims being <dumped in on us at one time,
that are going to have to be cleared out within thirty days, which means that, again, we.
are going to create backlogs.
Last year when I asked that consideration be given to the possibility of these
incoming questionnaires being sent
out on anniversary dates in the same manner that the
Veterans Administration now send out questionnaires on those service-connected ‘tases:rated
one hundred percent disabled on the basis of unemployment, that has worked out perfectly
satisfactorily and I see no reason why it shouldn't here, and I see no reason why our Regional
Offices should be bogged down for thirty to one hundred twenty days every year by reason
of these questionnaires, and get so far behind on the handling of the ordinary work load.

that
date

did

they

El
fil

I hope you will agree with me that this conferencego on record in recommending
the income questionnaires in Part III and death claims be sent out on the anniversary
of the award rather than all being sent out at once at the first of the year.

MR. FENNER, North Carolina:
With regard to annual income questionnaires, some
Regional Offices have been sending a notice instructing the recipients to report to a comtact
representative of the Veterans Administration, whereas in the past many of those World War
I veterans and widows and others receiving pensions have reported. to their post service
officers, county service officers, et cetra.
They are travelling many miles needlessly,
thinking that they have to see a contact representative.

or

1

they

did

states),
service

not

I am just wondering if those notices
or directives
originate at the Regional Offices, and the purposes
MR. BROOKS:
emanate from

were sent from
for those.

Very frankly, I never heard of any such
the Compensation and Pension Service of

Central

Office

instructions.
Certainly
the Central Office.

MR. FENNER:
In our state, (I feel quite sure it may be happening in other
those receiving such notices, who have been getting gssistance from their post
officers, have travelled, some of them, I know to my own personal knowledge, almost

-85-

i
|

il
iH

one

hundred

miles

to

reach

a contact

representative.

:
MR. BROOKS:
There is no particular reason for that so far as I can see.
I
don't see why in the world they can't continue to use the services of their post service
officer.
I am reasonably sure no such instruction as that ever emanated from the Veterans
Administration here in Washington.
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman, Washington is probably an average state insofar
as population is concerned.
The first three months of the year we have had one hell of a
time processing all these questionnaires that come up.
It would certainly seem to me that,
so far as the VA is concerned, it would be beneficial to you, too, to spread it over a much
longer period of time, such as recommended by my friend from California, so I am going to
second his recommendation.
MR.

this

SEAMAN:

The

recommendation

MR. RUSSELL:
Carleton,
recommendation is disposed of.
MR.

SEAMAN:

Is

your

MR.

RUSSELL:

I

think

I want

question
it

is
to

seconded

by

Klemmetson

bring

up

another

pertinent

to

this

of

question.

Washington.
I will

wait

until

panel? .

is.

MR. SEAMAN:
You have heard the recommendation
by Mr. Klemmetson.
Are you ready for the question?
All in
contrary.
So ordered.

from Mr. Merifield, supported
favor signify by saying "aye";

MR. RUSSELL, California:
I am very much embarrassed to refer back to a question
but it happens that, in addition to misfiguring the time %&i“the time 4% the conference this
afternoon, I was locked in my hotel room and couldn't get out.
.
Anyhow, I had submitted two questions to-the panel, 26 and 27, and I was not
sure what the answers were from the Veterans Administration.
The one, No. 26, had to do
with why the deceased veteran's name on Form 8-685 had been removed, why that had been
discontinued.
You see, we have about 175 thousand cases on our index, which are all indexed
under the name of the veteran, and I am sure every man at this conference keeps his indexes
on an alphabetical basis under the name of the veteran.
I am sure also that the Veterans
Administration is not concerned with our convenience with its own.

VA

to

repeat

MR. SEAMAN:
I am
their answers.

sure

we

will

indulge

you

to

the

extent

that

we

will

ask

the

MR. REINMUTH:
I explained that our questionnaires
are sent out on the basis of
the addressograph plates prepared in the Division of Disbursement of the Treasury Department.
In 1951 it was agreed by the Gemeral Accounting Office that the name of the veteran was
unnecessary in the legend on the check -- merely the admonition, "un-remarried widow" was
required.
This saved a great deal of time and work in the Treasury Department in making
plate changes for change of addresses and, consequently, the veteran's name has not been
included since 1951.
. MR. YOUNG:
I don't mean to correct you, or anything like that, but the income
questionnaires that are going out to the veterans,to the widows, that come through our
office, 50 percent of them do have the name of the veteran incorporated on the 685 and 50
percent of them don't.
:
In addition to that, many times the C number itself is obliterated or it is an
incorrect C number and now with a decentralization of death claims, the widow is quite likely
to send the income questionnaire back to the wrong office, there won't be any way of locating that case, and I will again have to write to the veteran.
This is not
think in the interest of
for you to have the name
hurry and not have to go

for the convenience of the service organizations alone, but I should
economy in man-hours it would conserve a terrific number of man-hours
of the veteran on there so. that you could index that thing in a
and try to find out if there is a file in the VA office.

MR. REINMUTH:
We have a duplicate copy of every income
sent out.
There is a check transcript card that is mantained in the
the office is printed on the questionnaire, the place to return it.
and if that questionnaire comes back we can readily identify it.

questionnaire that is
office. ' The name of
The XC number is on it

MR. RUSSELL:
We are taking into consideration
the fact that the District
Office in Denver has been discontinued for many widows and they are going to send their
questionnaire to Denver now whereas, actually, the case should be sent to the District Office
that has jurisdiction over the death claim. Agein, many of our service officers here are

-86-

acting as your agents in receiving and sending on income questionnaires, and if they get
a questionnaire with nothing but the widow's name on it and the name is Smith or Jones or
Johnson or Miller, they are going to have a devil of a time trying to figure out what case
it applies to and they will make no record of having submitted it and if anything comes up
in the future as to whether or not any income statement was ever submitted, she will have
no way of verifying the fact that the statement was ever received or sent in.

was

MR. REINMUTH:
All they
which is at the top of the

sent,

have to do is return it to the office from which it
form.
They are the ones maintaining the controls on

The reason some of the checks have
suppose, is because the Treasury Department has
presently in their files..

clients

or

REINMUTH:

We

haven't

had

any

complaint

about

MR. RUSSELL:
I wonder if I might move you, Mr.
record as recommending that the name of the veteran be
that is sent out to the widow, to return.

weakly

the legend
to correct

MR. RUSSELL:
Are we interested in maintaining an improved service
are we interested in the convenience of the Treasury Department?
MR.

g0 on
naire

been going out with
not made any effort

MR.

SEAMAN:

MR.

KLEMMETSON:

MR. SEAMAN:
approved by voice

Do

I

hear

a

I will

All in
vote.

second

favor

of

the

now

like

to

on them, I
the plates

to

our

|
|

before.

Chairman, that this conference
restored to the income question-

such

recommendation.

recommendation

turn

this

so

indicate.

Contrary.

Again,

|

to say to my Legion conferees, Mr. Shorter
was a very distinct pleasure for me to have
them for their participation with me on this

To Messrs. Driver, Brooks, Hinton, Robson and
Stone, we do express to them, for The American Legion, our
us and their cooperation with us.
We thank them very much
and again this afternoon.
would

i
il |

second?

In closing this panel, I would like
and Mr. Browning, Mr. Deris and Mr. Kownaski, it
the opportunity of working with them and I thank
panel.

"I

this

it.

panel

back

Reinmuth, together with Ralph
thanks for their courtesies to
for being with us this morning
!

to Mr.

Gleason.

-—---

CHAIRMAN

GLEASON:

Thank

you,

i

gentlemen,

for

being

with

us.

We are now going to take up the panel discussion on appeals.
Will all of the
Area E members please meet in Room 504 of this hotel at 9:30 p.m. this evening.
The discussion this afternoon is on Board of Veterans Appeals.
We have with us Mr. Jarnagin, who
is Chairman of the Board, and Clarence Scarborough from Connecticut, who is going to handle
it from the Legion viewpoint, along with Bill Wadsworth and Harry Carper.
I will turn it
over to Clarence.
MR. CLARENCE C. SCARBOROUGH:
First, I would like to introduce
the other members of the panel from the Legion; William Wadsworth, Chief of
Alabama; and Harry Carper, Department Service Officer from Virginia,

Veterans

I will now
Administration

you gentlemen
Stancil is an

please

introduce

the

my assistants,
the Claims Service,

members

of the

MR. JARNAGIN:
On my left is Frank Reagan, Vice-Chairman of the Board.
I think
have seen us before.
And then we have Jim Stancil and E, L. Shackelford.
Mr.
Associate Member of the Board and Mr. Shackelford is Chief of the Central

Office Appeals
were

ask Bob Jarnagin if he will
Board of Veterans Appeals.

Operations

Division.

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
submitted from the field.

It

|

|

:
seems

this

is

going

to

be

a

rather

.
I would like to say again, ladies and gentlemen of
the pleasure of meeting with members of the Board and the staff
Appeals and to hear from them and to discuss problems of mutual
Practicing service officers
Board,which we may well call the Supreme
are referred for appellate consideration

from every state
or High Court of
compensation and

-87-

short

panel.

the conference,
of the Board of
interest.

No

questions

that we have
Veterans
¥

have constant connection with-this
the Veterans Administration.
Here
pension claims, and authorised

i

claims for hospital
law, and many other

or medical expense,
related matters.

denied

applications

for

training

under

one

or

another

Generally speaking, a Service Officer will not appeal or recommend an appeal
to this Board, except it be the only course open.
Generally, the decision of this Board is
final except by an appeal direct to the Administrator, or by the introduction of new and
material evidence -- and it must be new and material to the issue, not cumulative in nature.
I am sure we will be interested to hear from Chairman Bob Jarnagin at this
time -- what his present appeal load is, what is the increase since March 1955 in the backlog,
if any.
Secondly, what effect has the DA letter of December 12, 1954, had on his appeal load.
Thirdly, what has been the percentage increase in appeals by reason of severance of service
connection

as

a

result

of

the

review

ordered

in

the

DA

letter

of

December

has there been an increase in appeals for Part III benefits where appeals
in farming areas on account of VA interpretation of marginal employment.

14,

1954.

Fourthly,

have

been

denied

We know the Board of Veterans Appeals operates under the same laws and regulations as the Regional and District Office rating boards.
Appeals are filed on the contention that there has been an error in law or fact.
In my experience, there has seldom
been an error in law.
The error, if there was one, has generally been in the interpretation
of the facts, perhaps not properly evaluating the evidence, medical or lay.
We must assume
the Board of Veterans Appeals has greater latitude in weighing the evidence and in granting
a favorable decision where there is a doubt.
:
going to ask Mr.
his Board.

Jarnagin

if

he

will

please

brief

the

conference

some

We
to

MR. JARNAGIN:
It is a pleasure to be here and discuss some of our mutual problems.
have a general
statement that covers most of these questions.
To save time, I am going
ask Jim Stancil, with your permission, to present that statement.

with
load

us,
and

of

With that, I am
the operations of

on

MR.
I would
some of
The

JAMES STANCIL:
Before we get into any specific matters you plan to discuss
like briefly to outline for you the Board's present situation, its work
our problems of mutual interest.
Board's

work

load

be

roughly

but

not

yet

divided

certified

to

into

three

the

Board;

Board;

and

One.

Appeals

Two.

Certified

appeals

awaiting

call

by

the

Appealed

cases

physically

on

hand

in Washington.

Three.

filed,

can

groupsof

cases:

Last year at this ‘time the Board had a backlog of such size that, with the
exception of certain categories of cases, field offices were required to certify appeals to
the Board and hold the cases until they could be called.
During the past year we have reduced
that backlog somewhat with results that are gratifying to us and, to a certain extent, helpful to you.
The number of uncertified appeals and the number of cases physically on hand
before the Board in Washington as of December 31, 1955, was approximately the same as of
December 31, 1954.
The big difference, however, is' in the group of cases certified as ready
for the Board awaiting call. ‘On December 31, 1954, there were more than six thousand cases
in that group. As of December 31, 1955, we had eliminated about 90 percent of this load.
This gain on the backlog obviously results in a substantial reduction in the
time between the filing of an appeal and the promulgation of the decision.
The gain on the
backlog also permits us to modify the docket procedure so as to allow all field offices to
forward appealed cases to the Board as soon as they are ready for certification instead of
holding them until they are called.
Instructiormsto that-effect have been released.
;
The total appellate
load as of December 31, 1955, was, in round figures,
eighteen thousand cases.
About eight thousand of these had not yet been certified.
Some"
of these will be withdrawn without submission to the Board by reason of grant at the local
level of the benefits appealed for.
Probably the major factor in such grants will be the
identification of opportunities to further develop the evidence.
It is at this point where,
insofar as this Board is concerned, your service can be most valuable. - A benefit has been
claimed and denied.
You are aware of the reasons given by the office of original jurisdiction
for denial.
You also have first-hand, personal contact with the veteran, and are in the
best position to know his reasons for believing he is entitled and to uncover any leads for
development that may not have been explored.
You get the opportunity to review each appealed
case before it is certified to the Board.
We think you will do a service to both the
veteran and to this Board if, in reviewing these cases, .you will bear in mind that insuring
the adequacy of the evidence is one of the principal contributions you can make.

modified

our

In meeting our production requirements
policy of providing reasoned decisions

-88-

and reducing
which answer

the.backlog, we have
material contentions

not
and

explain satisfactorily the conclusions reached.
In those cases in which subject matter
and relative lack of complexity permit, we still undertake to produce shorter decisions,
but
our efforts along these lines are aimed at reduction of words, not substance.
We still
intend that each decision justify its conclusion, and any decision which does not do this is
defective.
Our staffing problems have not materially changed in the past year.
We have
made some valuable additions to our medical staff.
Our World War II group improve their
cumulative effectiveness with each additional year's experience.
1It is our sincere belief
that a program of progressive, in-line training and experience is the best means of insuring
that the Board has and will continue to have an effective professional staff, and we will

to work

toward

this

end.

—

continue

We welcome this annual opportunity to meet with you.
We share mutual aims
and, therefore, we have mutual problems and responsibilities.
An exchange of viewpoints on
various issues, the opportunity to explain positions which are not clear and the identification of areas needing improvement through your constructive criticisms -- we feel all
these things are constructive factors that help us in our efforts to provide the best service
we can.
We sincerely hope our contribution to these conferences is of benefit to you in
the same manner.
:

Board

at&this

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
point.

MR. CARPER:
is being given to sending
done some years ago.

Harry

Mr.
out

Carper

has

one

question

Jarnagin, I would like
travelling sections of

that

he

would

like

to ask whether or not
the Board of Veterans

to

ask

the

any consideration
Appeals as was

MR. JARNAGIN:
Absolutely none at this time.
We don't have the personnel.
We
don't have the money.
We would like to make those trips.
They were very profitable.
We
enjoyed them.
They were instructive to us and maybe we did a little selling for the Board.
With the Chair's permission, and to save time, he has two or three questions
here that we would like to discuss.
The first is not a question.
It is a statement.
It
says that, generally, the decision of this Board is final except for direct appeal to the
Administrator.
That isn't what the law says.
The law says that appeals will be to the
Administrator, decisions to be made by the Board of Veterans Appeals.
There is no appeal
to the Administrator personally.
:
MR.

+ Reagan

to

SCARBOROUGH:

MR. JARNAGIN:
discuss them with

1I

stand

corrected.

There
you.

are

two

or

three

questions

here

and

I will

ask

Frank

~. MR. REAGAN:
The first question that was posed by your Chairman was as to the
present appeal load and I think that Mr. Stancil has covered that in his statemént that he
has made to you.
The second is what effect the DA letter of December 12, 1954, has had on this
appeal load.
Actually, we haven't felt any material increases in our appeal load by reason
of the review.
I suppose we do have.a few more cases but it is rather difficult to say
what percentage of thoee is attributable to the letter and what is a part of our natural
volume of appeals.
The

appeal

load,

frankly,

hasn't

gone

up

within

the

last

three

or

four

months.

As regards these severance cases, most of those are still in the status of
administrative review so that I presume it will be some time later that the Board will get
those cases wherein the administrative action has continued unfavorably to the claimant.
As regards Part III benefits, I might also say that we haven't noticed any
material increase in these appeals for Part III benefits and I am just wondering if that
isn't in part due to the fact that the administrative setup which you referred to this
morning in your talk hasn't been fairly effective in winnowing out these better cases.
1
am speaking of these references under 1142.
I think somebody made the statement this morning that a considerable percentage of those claims recommended under 1142 were paid, which
means, of course, that it is only the residue that may come to our Board.
We haven't
noticed any excessive volume of those Part III cases.
MR. SCARBOROUGH:
This question was just sent up by Mr. Wood of Arizona:
"What
is the policyof the Board of Veterans Appeals on claims referred by Regional Offices for
administrative review where a director of the veterans claims has previously ruled that no
clear and unmistakable error exists and severance action should not be taken?"
MR. JARNAGIN:
I can't imagine how we get that kind of case.
connection isn't broken.
There would be no appeal.
They are not referred
trative review.
Maybe I don't understand the question.
If the gentleman,
-89«

The service
to us by adminiswhoever wrote it,

will

restate

the

question,

I will

try

to

comment

further.

MR. WOODS, Arizona:
This particular claim was ruled upon some years ago by
the Director of Veterans Claims and it was his decision at that time that no clear and
unmistakable error existed and that severance action could not be taken.
One of the rating
board members dissented and once again asked that the case be referred to Central Office.
The dissent was approved and it has been referred now to the Board of Veterans Appeals, and
even though it was up here some years ago and a decision was made by the Director of Veterans
Claims.

that

such

I am wondering also if Central
cases should not be referred back

Office
to you

has a policy at
fellows on that

the Regional Office
kind of deal.

level

MR. REAGAN:
I might say, of course, any determinationof the Director of Veterans
., Claims that service connection should not be broken would be most persuasive but his previous
finding to that effect would be in the same category as other findings which perhaps are
unfavorable to veterans, which we occasionally reverse.
In other words, it isn't an action
that we would take lightly but his conclusion would not be final and absolute in the matter
of the adjudication of a particular claim.
I might say we get a good many cases in which, for instance, we have this
question:
A case is submitted administratively and is favorably considered by Claims but
only prospectively, because, as you know, that is the only way that those decisions can be
placed into effect, whereupon the veteran appeals to us for a prior effective date.
Well,
because we considered the case de novo and purely upon a difference of opinion, we may
go back and overturn the Director of Glaims and give the veteran an effective date from the
date of claim or some earlier date than that given in the administrative review.
So, the answer, briefly, to your question is that a finding of the kind you
speak of would be most persuasive to the Board and should be to the Regional Office but would
not in any eerse be final or determinative of the issue -in that particular case.
MR. MARSH:
I think, ladies and gentlemen, perhaps we should point out to the
Board of Veterans Appeals an earlier discussion had here today at the time the Claims Panel
was on, and that had very definite reference to the very thing we have been talking about
here now; that is, severance of service connection on the basis of 1009 (A) or on the basis
of clear and unmistakable error.
As the people here in this room know, this brought about a rather hot discussion between the people here in the room and the Claims Panel.
I believe it was the
consensus of the people in this room, the practicing service officers, that through this
review it had been brought out that although there probably has not actually been any change
in veterans regulations or the laws on what constitutes clear and unmistakable error, there
has been absolutely a change in rating philosophy, and I can only say to you, Mr. Jarnagin,
that I am not exactly sure yet how many of these cases may have come to you, but I am
piling up on my desk right now and I am asking our people who go before your Board to lay
every case on my desk where severance, before the Board of Veterans Appeals, is the issue,
regardless of the amounts.
While I haven't completed the survey on it, I
can't help but say right here
that, in my opinion, the same philosophy has got down into the Board of Veterans Appeals
that has appeared recently in the Claims Section, and I think that I wanted to bring that
out because so much has been said here this morning to the Claims group, and I wanted you
know exactly how this group felt about what does or what does not constitute clear and
unmistakable error.

to

1 think too many of our rating boards now are not judging the case on what was
in the file back in 1945 and '46 but are looking back in retrospect now and saying that this
was a clear and unmistakable error, and certainly it wasn't at that time.
It is now merely
a difference of opinion.
It is something that may have come in in the interim period.
MR. JARNAGIN:
Our Board likes to think that we stay in the middle of the road
so that when the economy wind shifts we don't have to go anywhere, but you are talking about
the reexamination and rerating program.
Now, Instruction One, Section Nine (a) and (b)
Public 144, when these men were coming out of servicé, said, "Don't examine the man.
Don't
investigate the evidence.
Don't consider doctors' records or hospital records prior to
service to show a condition existing at time of enlistment, not noted at enlistment."
The purpose of that was to expedite the adjudication of hundreds of thousands
of cases and it was represented to the then Administrator that we would get more criticism
if we delayed the adjudication of those cases while they were being developed than we would
if we put them on the rolls, then took them off, if necessary, after the examination and
rerating program could be accomplished.
i
?

purposes
than the

Well, in 1947, I believe, there were 1,200,000 examinations for adjudication
pending and because maybe the Medical Service was emphasizing the inpatient rather
outpatient program.
That service in cooperation with other agencies of Central

<90-

Office, made an effort to reduce that number.
It was reduced from 1,200,000 to, believe
it or not, 53,000 future examinations, so that when the budget hearings were held, Medical
Service had no backlog.
Claims had no backlog, so personnel was curtailed to the extent
that, when it was desirable to reexamine and rerate these veterans, we didn't have the
facilities with which to do it.
Now, to that extent, the instructions have changed, but not recently.
Many
years ago it was changed to authorize reemamination, rerating in accordance with the degree
of disability present.
Also, thousands of these men were put on a convalescent rating, some
of them 50 percent, some of them 100 percent.
Believe it or not, some of them are still on
the rolls at that rate and when they are examined, it is frequently found that they have
no disability,or maybe 10 or 20 percent.
:
You ask what is a clear and unmistakable error.
I was asked that question,
I think, at Philadelphia or Boston last year, at one of the conventions, and my notion would
be that if the action taken, that is, the service connection in effect could not be supported
on any tenable theory, than it was clearly and unmistakably erroneous.
Of course, I would
like to remind you that the purpose of reexamination and rerating is not to break service
connections.
Itkwas to adjust compensation up or down as to those veterans who had not been
examined for many years.
Breaking service connection is an incidental feature and there
haven't been so many of them, I believe.
You have the right to appeal if you feel in a particular case that the breaking was improper, but the philosophy hasn't changed.
We are just getting around in the VA
to doing something that should have been carried on year by year since '45.
This program
started in '45, putting the men on without an examination, without investigating the: evidence,
just on the service record.
As an illustration, and some of you have heard of this illustration before,
He
concerned a man out in Michigan who had been in the state insane asylum for eight years.
was in escape status thirty days when the Draft Board got him.
He didn't tell them he was
In other words, he made a better adjustment
After four months they gave him a CDD.
crazy.
in the Army for four months than he had made in the preceding eight years.

then

but

in

I

Nevertheless,
effect the man was

:
When
succeeded.

because it
put on the

wasn't noted
rolls and at

the case came to my attention,
I don't believe I did any harm

it
to

at enlistment and under
100 percent rating.
took me about a year to
the veterans program.

this

instruction

get

it

broken,

If
Mr. Chairman, I would like to make a comment here.
MR. KORELLA, Missouri:
I understand the question correctly, under 1009 (d), clear and unmistakable error, oftentimes
for
up
set
is
case
When that
an aggravation condition presents itself in the case file.
severance of service connection, is it not true that by reason of the very fact that the
of the Board of Jurisdiction
mind
the
in
doubt
a
is
there
Office,
case is sent up to Central
And is it not also
as to the propriety of maintaining or not maintaining service connection?
true that if there is a doubt created, the doubt should be resolved in favor of the veterah?

However, the procedure
That can be argued with some force.
MR. JARNAGIN:
calls for sending them up to Central Office before the service connection is broken, before
So, I believe that since that proThey have no option.
that decision is made effective.
cedure was adopted, no such inference as the gentleman states can attach to the reference of
the case to Central Office.
Incidentally, I might tell you that, of course, we get some of these cases on
appeal after service connection is broken and we make our decisions on the evidence and not
We have affirmed a lot
We have restored some.
on the procedures that have been followed.
?
But they have to be studied on the evidence.
more than we have restored.

I don't know what kind of case you gentlemen will agree should be broken on
clear and unmistakable error. You see, the law has always provided that fraud and unmistakThere has been no change in that,
able error are the bases for breaking service connection.
none whatever, no change in the administrative policy that I have heard of -- and I think I
would hear about it if there were.
¥

Mr. Jarnagin, I would like to point out a very simple case, just
MR. MARSH:
any case, but we have cases where rating boards out in the Regional Office have a dissenting
opinion on. whether or not it is a clear and unmistakable error and, by golly, if somebody
finds it is a clear and unmistakable error, them I would say there was a definite difference
of opinion that arose right in the rating board itself.

from

the

regarding

MR.
floor?

the

SCARBOROUGH:

MR. KLEMMETSON:
tighter rating

Have

you

any

questions,

Bill

or

Harry?

Are

there

Mr.Chairman, in view of the remarks made by Ivan,
policy of the Veterans Administration which I have

-91-

any

questions

particularly
seen in the

Board of Appeals, I have seen it in the rating board in our
remarks made here, I would like to ask Mr. Jarnagin what is
this year in comparison with last year.

own
the

state, and
percentage

MR. JARNAGIN:
The Board has always allowed about 8 to 10
It has always remanded about 8 or 9 percentof the cases, and also the
jurisdiction, I believe, allow more appeal cases than do we.
In other
the 7 o1 8 percent of the appeal cases that they allow on the basis of
in connection with the certification.

that

are

That totals up,
allowed in whole or

I would say,
in part.

to maybe

20

percent

of

the

in
of

view of the
allowances

percent on appeal.
boards of original
words, we don't get
their development and

cases

that

are

appeaied

There has been no change, I believe, in the last ten or twelve years.
The
character of the appeals does change.
At one time we got a lot of gunshot wounds and before
the instructions went out to the field on how to rate them, I believe we had during two
periods of six months each about 63 percent reversals and allowances of gunshot wound evaluations, but that doesn't obtain any more.
You see these various percentages shift.
We had a lot of dental cases at
time; VR&E cases -- we had hundreds of those each week, and depending on the character
the load, the percentage of the reversals would change.

I think
that we
that as

remarks?
vote and

one
of

MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr.Chairman, that doesn't answer the question, of course.
What
we are entitled to in a conference such as this is to ask of the Board of Appeals
get a comparison over the past four years from official records.
I want to make
a recommendation.
MR.

SCARBOROUGH:

MR.

FARRINGTON,

Is

that

California:

recommendation

seconded?

I will

the

second

recommendation.

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
The recommendation is made and seconded.
Are there
All those in favor will signify by saying "aye"; contrary-minded, 'mo".
so ordered.

MR.

O'NEILL,

Indiana:

Mr.

Chairman,

I would

like

to direct

any
It is

a question

a

to

Mr. Jarnagin.
At what place does a man's possessions deny him entitlement to Part III
benefits?
I mean by that, how much money does he have to have or how much can he have and
still be entitled to Part III benefits?
I call this to his attention because of one particular
case that has been to his Board twice.
The evidence of record definitely shows, as established by a field investigation,
that the man's income was within required limits, that he
hasn't worked for more than three years, and that he is 67 years of age and has 40 percent
of disability, and yet his appeal was denied on the grounds that those disabilities wouldn't
prevent him from following a gainful occupation.
MR. REAGAN:
Let me say first, specifically, to the gentleman that such a case
as that, we would like very much to see.
We would like to have you give us the name and
C number and send the case to us.
I would like very much to review it, and I say not only
that case but any case of comparable merit that you feel that the decision is not in accordance
with the facts in the case or the law.
We are always happy to look at such a case again.
Now, generally, about Part III cases, I might say this:
that the trouble you
are having with these Part III cases we share right down to the hilt because, as you know,
the legislation and regulations regarding the granting of Part III benefits have been °
variously amended through the years since 1933 when you old-timers remember that a fellow
who got Part
III benefits then didn't live very long to enjoy them.
In fact; he was on
cordial speaking terms with the undertaker.
We have changed those things down through the years, from 1940 on down to
Extension 5 which was born out of the concept that we ought to individualize these cases if
we are going to get justice.
The whole purpose and intent behind Extension 5, is to find
out whether this individual veteran was unemployable, whether he worked when he was able
to work and had a chance to work, what his situation is now and what his need is now.
The complaint that follows Extension 5 generally has been -- and I might say
it has been almost universal -- that we don't get any uniformity.
Well, you just don't get
uniformity out of individual consideration of cases, because they aren't uniform.
The facts
in individual veterans' cases don't jibe with all of the other veterans that you come in
contact with.
To give you rules would be the easiest thing in the world, but it would result
in the poorest adjudication.
If you look at the book and tear out a strip of rules and. say,
"This is what the veteran gets," you will get the ‘sorriest adjudication you can possibly get.
We have these farm cases, men who are 65 years of age and, as farmers, they necessarily have
had to slow down in their activities.
They have 10 percent disability.
They are rough
problems of adjudication and I frankly state to you that I offer no theory of infallibility
in any individual case.
We, the Chairman and I, would be very glad to see .any case in which

«92

you genuinely
received.
We

felt that the facts measured up to more favorable consideration
would like particularly, sir, to have your case from Indiana.

than

the

man

MR. O'NEILL:
I will see that you get it, sir, and for your further information,
you have already had two cracks at it and you have turned it down both times and on the same
set of facts and evidence.
The reason you have given is because this man and his wife,
throughout their lifetime, managed to come within $15 thousand of paying for a motel down in
North Carolina, which they sold for enough cash to pay the balance due and to buy them a
home, and they have sold the balance on the basis of notes due each month, with interest.
They have already sold or collected, rather, thirty-nine of the notes that are
due on the motel and yet they are going to have to sell those notes at a discount because
you refused to grant him the benefits that he is entitled to under the law and on the basis
of the evidence in file.
The facts are all established, even down to a field investigation
ordered by your Board.
I will see that you get it.
MR.

SCARBOROUGH:

Are

there

any

more

questions

from

the

8
i

floor?

MR.

KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to address this question to the
Vice-Chairman,
if I may.
Last year it was my privilege to be Chairman of your Board of
Appeals Panel.
We tried to do something nice, I thought, in the way of a recommendation for
the Board of Appeals.
We asked that Mr. Jarnagin be given additional help so that he could
render efficient and speedy decisions.
We also took exception to the fact that the career men in the Board of Appeals
didn't always have the opportunity to come up the line and be members of the Board of Appeals
and, instead, politicians had been appointed to the Boardof Appeals.
What has been
accomplished so far?
MR. JARNAGIN:
As a matter of privilege if you will permit me to answer that,
I will be glad to.
I might say that I believe that of the thirty-four present associate
members, I picked and recommended thirty-three of them.
That is not too bad an average.
The personnel of the Board is adequate at the moment except in one category.
That is good medical service.
We need several board men, men who have passed their boards
in the specialties.
We have picked up a couple just recently but we need about five more,
five to eight in various other specialties.
We had those kinds,of people at one time but
they have retired or died.
We do need more good doctors. . If you know any, let me know.
MR. CUNNINGHAM, Indiana:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to direct this question
to Mr. Jarnagin or Mr. Reagan.
If the Board of Veterans Appeals grants a benefit administratively, is that incorporated in the decision?
Is that so stated, that the grant is
administrative?

MR. REAGAN:

.

Yes.

ll

MR. CUNNINGHAM:
The reason I asked that question, we recently had a question
e
come back from the Board of Veterans Appeals in which it was stated that reasonable doubt was
granted in favor of the veteran, and the case was allowed.
The adjudication officer as well
as the assistant adjudication officer in the Indianapolis Regional Office said that because
the Board said it was on the basis-of reasonable doubt, it was done administratively, and
the effective date of the rating was the date of the Board of Veterans Appeals' decision.
We argued this case at length with the adjudication officer and the assistant adjudication
;
officer and finally necessitated appealing the case back on effective date.
I wonder if it
was an administrative grant, if that is so stated in the appeal.

|
il
|

i
|

MR.STANCIL:
Yes, cases that are denied on regulatory or schedular grounds but
allowed administratively are so stated in the decision.
If we make the statement that we grant
the benefit administratively, we ordinarily include the statement, "effective the date of
this decision."
The effective date in the case you mentioned is an appealable issue, you
know.
I assume you have or are going to appeal it?

it

was

kind

MR. CUNNINGHAM:
of unnecessary to

Yes,
have

the case was
to do that.

reappealed

and

it

was

allowed,

but

I

thought

MR. STANCIL:
I agree with you.
Unless we are allowing one administratively
and setting the effective date as the date of the determination, we do not attempt to guide
the field office in the effective date because that is not the question before us.
That
is an issue to be decided in the field and then, subject to appeal, to give you two cracks
at it.
DR. SHAPIRO:
competent medical men even
discussed this matter many
I will ask him a question.

fh

Mr. Jarnagin brought up the question
of certified medical men or
not certified as being needed on the Board of Appeals.
We have
a time but I think I know his difficulty.
Perhaps we can help him.
What can you pay a board certified specialist on the Board of

-93-

)

I

Appeals?
MR.

JARNAGIN:

The

top

grade

14,

$11,400

or

$11,500.

DR. SHAPIRO:
You see, the difficulty is that this man can go into the Department
of Medicine and Surgery and get lots more money.
I just want to bring out his difficulty.
Perhaps the Resolutions Committee should take into consideration the fact that there are
needed certified medical specialists on claims.
After all, medicine is as important there
as it is in examining the man and perhaps we ought to see that a recommendation goes in that
these men receive adequate salaries commensurate with what is given to the Department of
Medicine and Surgery and maybe we will get these doctors.
MR.

FARRINGTON,

California:

Mr.

Chairman,

along

the

lines

of

the

recommendation

made by Dr. Shapiro of our national staff, I would think that a recommendation from this
committee on decentralization, again, of the Board of Appeals, such as existed prior to the
Economy Act, to the District Offices of the Veterans Administration, would solve most of
those medical questions.
Now, for instance, we centralize a unit of the Board of Appeals
in ‘San Francisco.
They have a medical consultant on the Dean's Committee there at Fort Riley.
They have those people who are on the job and who are already being paid and who are not
always too busy and they can make a few of those decisions, and you wouldn't have to go out
to the public again and try to recruit more medical men.
I think that the medical men on the payroll in the Dean's hospitals throughout
the nation would be better qualified, possibly, and it would be a younger group of doctors
who are not looking for retirement pay from the Veterans Administration, but could answer
those medical questions.
Along that line, I would like to move at this time that.the Recommendations
Committee bring in a recommendation along that line, looking toward the decentralization of
the Board of Appeals.
At least we would get a human element back into it.
I know when we
had the old Board in San Francisco, it wasn't difficult for us to obtain the funds from the
Auxiliary or the Legion or some of the county welfare departments to bring the man up to
San Francisco and sometimes to see how disfigured he was, or how bent his back was, or other
infirmities that he had, and we got some human decisions because they could see them.

from
word

I tell you the truth, I am so disgusted with the kind of decisions that we get
the Board of Veterans Appeals that I have made up my mind I would never say another
about them except for this one recommendation I am making now.

something,

MR.

SCARBOROUGH:

Does

anyone

care

MR.

KLEMMETSON:

I will

second

it.

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
I believe, that he

to

Before I call for
would like to say.

second

that

recommendation?

remarks

from

the

floor

Mr.

Jarnagin

has

MR. JARNAGIN:
I didn't want to give you the impression that we are making
decisions without adequate medical assistance.We have a big reservoir of the top people
the country right up on the eighth floor of the Veterans Administration and we use them
the time, but it is a part-time proposition, as it would be in any area in the field.

of
all

Those kinds of men are scarce, they are hard to get, they are busy, they are
better paid than we can pay them, but
it isn't administratively sound to have to go elsewhere
for some of your medical assistance.
We have to do that.
We use the medical men from the
Department of Medicine and Surgery.
They are very helpful, they are very cooperative, they
are fairly expeditious in their reaction, but we would Like to have these men in our own
staff.
.

motion

right,

MR.

SCARBOROUGH:

MR.
he

CRIDER,
Tennessee:
Mr.Chairman,
before
asked
for decentralization
of the Board

decentralization

or

does

he

Are

mean

there

any

itinerant

other

service

MR.

FARRINGTON:

Decentralization.

MR.

CRIDER:

against

I am

remarks

by

the

from

you
of

go

the
into

Veterans

Board

of

floor

on

it,

if

Appeals.

Veterans

this
I

motion?

understand
Does

he

the

mean

Appeals?

that.

MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman, I remember well when we had a District Board of
Appeals in San Francisco.
We received very fair, fairly liberal decisions at that time.
We
had the opportunity to go and appear before the Board.
Certainly we in Washington couldn't
come three thousand miles, that is a cinch, but it would seem to me, too, that there would be
a possibility of saving some money, that woulda’ t hurt and might be beneficial so far as
the veteran is concerned.

94

Having seen the work in the past, I am still convinced
better served when we had the District Board of Appeals back before
am still seconding that motion.

that the veteran
the Economy Act,

was
so I

MR. KORELLA:
A few moments ago the good Mr. Jarnagin informed this body that
the reason for no travelling Appeal Boards was a shortage of funds.
In thinking back over
the activities of the travelling boards some years ago, I recall most vividly the service
that was given the veteran by those boards.
They would come into the Regional Offices,
they afforded the veteran an opportunity for a personal appearance, and in many cases the
veteran would receive his just dues because it was possible for the medical officer on that
travelling board to see for himself exactly what the state and condition of that particular
veteran was, which could not be done otherwise.
I would suggest, then, to this body that for the purpose of rendering better
service and at the same time relieving the excess load that Mr. Jarnagin told us he had in
his office, that this body pass a resolution calling upon those in power to loosen the purse
strings and afford Mr. Jarnagin's office the necessary funds to reinstate a travelling board
in order that the service can be extended in a manner and fashion most helpful to the veteran.
I

so

move.

(The

Do

you

care

motion

was

regularly

seconded).

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
to make this as a

There is a motion before the house,
substitute motion or an amendment?

MR.

KORELLA:

an

MR.

SCARBOROUGH:

You

MR.

KORELLA:

sir.

MR.
that

SCARBOROUGH:
acceptable to

As

amendment

that

has

been

seconded.

to

the

motion

made

by

our

good

friend

from

making

that

as

amendment

to

the

previous

motion?

That was seconded and has been made as an
the person who made the previous motion?

amendment

to

Will

of

California.

motion.

Is

motion,

accept

CHAIRMAN
the

MR.

Yes,

GLEASON:

I

MR. KLEMMETSON:
KORELLA:

CHAIRMAN
MR.

state

the

the

man

from

an

California,

the

maker

the

the

original

amendment?

FARRINGTON:

MR.

are

do

I don't either.
I will

GLEASON:

CRIDER:

not.

make

O.K.,

I will

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
motion, please, sir.

it

as

is

Chad

second

it.

there

any

Are

a

substitute
a

motion,

in

that

case,

Mr.

Chairman.

second?

remarks

on

this

substitute

motion?

Will

you

MR. KORELLA:
The motion is that this body go on record requesting those in
power to furnish sufficient funds to Mr. Jarnagin's department to afford him the proper
facilities and money necessary to reinstate the travelling Board of Veterans Appeals in
order that the veterans in the various sections of the country have an opportunity personally
to present themselves, and that a proper evaluation can be made on the ground where the
appeal is located.

all

those

in

CHAIRMAN GLEASON:
Is there any further discussion?
On the
favor signify by saying "aye"; those opposed.
We will call
Those

stitute motion
opposed.

one

way

The

or

is

in ‘favor,

lost.

"aye."

Those

:

On the original motion,
'"noes" have it.

MR. KLEMMETSON:
the other.
CHAIRMAN

Mr.

GLEASON:

MR. KLEMMETSON:
I
an opportunity to appear before
out our differences. .

all

opposed,

those

in

favor

The

will

"noes"

signify

have

the

sub-

saying

"aye";

those

something

out

by

it

and

i

Chairman 6 it

All

"no."

substitute motion,
for it again.

right,

you

is
¢

evident

had

your

that

we

want

opportunity.

The

Chair

of

this

ruled.

suggest that we make it as a motion that both factions have
the Recommendations Committee and maybe we can straighten

:

-95-

CHAIRMAN
MR.

GLEASON:

KORELLA:

CHAIRMAN

MR.

ask

of

the

It

I

think

is

GLEASON:

that

is

a worthy

suggestion.

Is

take

very

long

to

get

into

a hassle.

questions

that

you

ladies

and

gentlemen

acceptable,

it

acceptable?

sir.

Fine.

SCARBOROUGH:

It

doesn't

Now, are there any other
Board of Veterans Appeals?

would

like

to

MR. FENNER, North Carolina:
With reference to the review which we have had
on the agenda for the past eight or ten months, I would like to ask this question:
When a
case is sent to Central Office for an advisory opinion as to the question of severing
service connection and.Central Office advises the Regional Office that it would be proper to
sever service connection and the 60-day waiting period has passed and the veteran decides
that he wishes to appeal, does he have a ghost of a show when the case comes up on appeal
without new and material evidence to support that appeal?
In other words, his contention is that the records then in the folder are
sufficient to justify that appeal and request that his service connection be reinstated.
it a mere waste of time to send that case up on appeal after Central Office, after the
Administrator has made the determination against the veteran?

Is

MR. STANCIL:
Whether it is a waste of time to send the case up depends on
the facts in the case, not the procedure that has been followed.
Of course, you do have a
set of facts where someone has determined before as to whether they think there has been.
clear and unmistakable error, but I can tell you from personal experience, we do not always
agree with it.
I have handled a fair number of severance cases.Some we affirm; some are
remanded, and some we put back on the rolls.
To answer your question, the fact that it has been up
that administrative review has not involved the-Board at all.
The
on the merits, not on the procedure.

has

MR. MARSH:
many of those

upset

you have
going to

some
call

I would
types of

like to
cases.

vouch

for

that

fact.

MR. SCARBOROUGH:
Ladies and gentlemen, we are
very important questions that you wish to ask
the panel finished.
Are there any questions?

The

for administrative review,
Board determines the.case

Board

well over
the Board

of

Veterans

Appeals

our time and unless
at this time, I am

1f snot, I would like to thank my colleagues here, Bill Wadsworth of Alabama
and Harry Carper of Virginia, for assisting in the panel, and also extend our thanks and
appreciation to Bob Jarnagin and the members of his staff.
I turn it back now to the Chairman.
CHAIRMAN
Forces

Review

Commission

as

Boards.

well

as

GLEASON:
Charlie

Earl

We

are

now

Stevens,

Merifield

of

going

the

to

have

Assistant

California,

a discussion

Director

will

carry

concerning

of

the

National

on

from

this

the

Armed

Rehabilitation

point.

"MR. C. W. STEVENS:
Earl Merifield is coming up here.
All we want to do, truly,
is to explain the situation that exists in the Army Board for Correction of Military Records
and to ascertain from the conferees here what their reaction is in those cases in which they
have submitted, through our office or directly to the Department of the Army, applications
for corrections of the record.
I may give this background information that in August of 1946 when the Reorganization Act of 1946 was approved by the Congress to reorganize its own operation, it
wanted to divest itself of the big load of work that it had in attempting, in individual
cases, to remedy injusticesor correct errors that had been made by the military or naval
services.
The only remedy in certain instances was through private legislation, private
bills on behalf of specific veterans, and in the Legislative Reorganization Act it was provided that no further bills of that character relating to the correction of military records
or removal of injustices created by situations which developed in the military or naval
service would be entertained, and it created boards in the various services under the
Secretaries of the Army, Navy, Air Force, and for the Coast Guard, of the Treasury to take
over this job.
These boards are composed of civilian employees of the respective departments.

can

hear

CHAIRMAN
Charlie?

GLEASON:

Could

we

have

just

a

little

quiet,

please,

so

that

everybody

MR. STEVENS:
The authority was conferred on the secretaries of the departments
concerned to make any changes where (and these are the key words) in their judgment an error
was made or an injustice was done.
The apparent intent of Congress was considered by the

-96=

Attorney General of the United States the next year and he decided it was the intent to
exercise that judgment liberally, as liberally, at least, as had congressional committees
when considering private bills’ for relief of individuals.

Boards of
functions

The various secretaries of
civilian employees but all of
as well.
This is a secondary

the different departments all established these
them are part-time Board members.
They have other
sort of job to them.

It is in the Department of the Army where our difficulty
same difficulty in the Treasury Department, the Air Force or the Navy
confine the remainder of these remarks to that operation.

lies.
We haven't the
Department, so I will

In the Department of the Army, an Assistant Secretary of the Army has been
designated to act for the Secretary of the Army who has jurisdiction over the Army Discharge
Review Board created under Section 301 of the Servicemen's Readjustment Act, the Disability
Review Board created under Section 302 of the Readjustment
.Act (and those are commissioned
officers in those two boards), and the Board for Correction of Military Records, composed
of civilian employees, and which is créated by Section 207 of the Legislative Reorganization
Act.
The Chairman has been there since the initial operation was begun in 1946,
ten years.
He has been the one whom we have been informed and who we believe to be a person
who is so inherently unreasonable that it is not, in our judgment, possibleto get many
meritorious claims considered and, where they are considered, to get reasonably just decisions.
What I am bringing to your attention is this, that before the cases are to be
heard a determination is made initially as to whether or not a hearing is to be granted.
They require that the record before them contain a prima facie showing of merit before they
will grant a hearing.
The Chairman has three jobs.
This is one of three jobs that he
has, as a civilian employee.
There are eleven other members amd they have two jobs, this
job and another job, the other job being their principal job.
They meet every Wednesday, one day a week.
On February 10, 1955, some of us,
through an arrangement with the Assistant Secretary of the Army, conferred with a General
McNeil, who is his advisor on the Board's operations. General McNeil gave us three hours.
Dr. Shapiro was there, Ivan Marsh, myself, other
members of the staff, and we talked to
him about the difficulties we had been having.
During
called

me

to

say

that

last

year's

conference,

the

he

wanted

The

Legion

American

Assistant
to

Secretary

know

that

he

of

the

was

doing

Army,

Hugh

Milton,

something

to

remedy the situation which we had called to General McNeil's attention.
That wasn't the
first time, I will say, that we had been there, however, before officials of the Army. However, the situation wasn't too greatly improved.
Before our discussion with General McNeil, it was the practice to have the
case reviewed by the Chairman alone to determine whether a prima facie showing of merit was
in the record.
The other members didn't participate in that.Mr. Milton, the Assistant .
Secretary of the Army, required that panels of three members each be set up to make these
preliminary reviews and if one member of any of the panels wanted a hearing held, then a
hearing would be granted.
Before other boards, constituted under sections 301 and 302,
hearings are granted on all cases.
More hearings have been granted, though we still believe not enough in the Army
207 board.
We have a National Convention Resolution which requires that we seek legislation
to require hearings in all cases.
It may be necessary to obtain enactment of that legislation if within another sixty days something isn't done about this.
In the conversation with General McNeil, we had asked that the Chairman of the
Board be present.
We presented five cases as typical examples of the difficulty we were
having in getting a case before the Board so that we could present argument on behalf of the
applicant.
All five of those cases were granted hearings by the Assistant Secretary.
At
least four have been heard.
The chairman, we feel certain, was very much disturbed that,
over his head, hearings had been ordered.
He had denied a hearing on one of those cases
on seven occasions over a period of about seven years.
He presided as Chairman when hearings on three of the cases were had.
Dr.
Shapiro, Loyd Pool and a distinguished psychiatrist who accompanied them, appeared on one
of the cases.
Three of the cases were denied.
The Chairman was absent when the other case
was heard.
That case was allowed.
The Chairman of the Board was offensive in his manner and very
listen to the very fine medical testimony that was there for him to have in
proper decision be made on the case in which Doctors Overholser and Shapiro
appeared, I was told.
Dr.

Winfred

Overholser,

the

Superintendent

of

St.

Elizabeth's

unwilling to
order to let
and Mr. Pool

Hospital,

a

a

former

~37{
|

i

President of The American Psychiatric Association an. internationally known diplomat in
psychiatry, accompanied, without fee, Dr. Shapiro and Mr. Pool to appear on two of the cases.
The Chairman, after the hearing, permitted Dr. Overholser and Dr. Shapiro to cool their heels
while another couple of cases ‘were run in.
Dr. Overholser had to leave, sickness in his
own family forced Loyd to leave, and Dr. Shapiro stayed for about three hours and then had a
hearing on that case.

we

want

The American Legion
something done about it.

isn't

accustomed

to

taking

this

kind

of

treatment

and

Now, briefly, here is what we recommend in a meeting with the General Counsel
of the Department of the Army when Mr. Kraabel was there and some of us sat in with him and
this General Counsel on January 19, 1956.
We recommended that these part-time people who
are efficient be continued but that they be put on a full-time basis.
When you have a
part-time job and you are working on the other job most of the time, you pay scant heed to
the part-time job, and that is the kind of attention these records are receiving in that
Board, in our opinion.
The actual case load is such that these members can't begin to review those
cases initially to determine whether or not there is a prima facie showing of merit, and
then once a hearing is held, they are in no position to make too much of a decision based
upon a competent review of the evidence.
There is just too much of a workload for these
part-time people to handle.
We think a full-time Board needs to be operating because of
the large load of cases under the Army's jurisdiction.
I do

want

to

say

we

have

asked

that

a

full-time

Board

be

established.

We have asked also that they employ doctors, competent medical officers, to
serve on those Boards, because medicine is involved in a lot of the cases that they consider.
Earl Merifield, I hope, will tell you what his situation is and will tell us what our
staff defects are in the operation and what the Board's defects are as he views them from
long distance.
MR. EARL MERIFIELD:
Charlie and Dr. Shapiro asked that I sit in on this panel.
Frankly, from the correspondence that I have received in my office on the cases that we have
submitted, with the request that we be represented by The American Legion, I have been very
much disappointed with the handling of them and the outcome of them.
Perhaps I was more
critical than I should have been of the manner in which they are handled by our representatives
back here -- I say that after hearing what Charlie has told you today and after discussing
the matter with individual members of the staff.
I am discouraged, in approaching the question; it is inconceivable to me that
this situation has been allowed to exist so long.
I can't help but feel that The American
Legion, considering our size and our influence, has had to put up with these things too long.
We have never put up with them in the Veterans Administration and to listen. to Charlie
get up here and say that they were not even treated courteously when they have gone before
the Board on the few cases where they have had the opportunity to go before them, and the
manner in which this law, Section 207, is being administered, I am
frankly astonished.
I
am familiar with the decision of the Attorney General in this matter that Charlie spoke to
you about.
I suppose I can disagree with him as well as I disagree with others.
I am
convinced, nevertheless (and I am sure you are convinced), that when Congress enacted Section
207 of Public 601 and set up civilian boards under the law to review discharges and to
correct injustices, it was obvious that the purpose was to provide that such Boards make
the review.
I appreciate that the actual wording of the law was that the secretaries of
the various services shall make these reviews "under procedures set up by the Secretaries
the various branches of the services."
However, it is not believed that it was ever contemplated or expected by this language that the purpose of the law would be circumvented
and defeated by the Secretary of the Army.
You
Boards set up by
Attorney General
not to allow the

of

heard Charlie tell you that they have hearings on all cases before the Review
the Secretaries of other branches of the service, and still he says the
turns around and says to the Army, "It is perfectly within your prerogative
reviews as you see fit."

I have had considerable correspondence on this that I brought with me when I
learned that they wanted.
me to say a few words on it. I have letters going clear back here
to '47, addressed to the Secretary of Defense, and I have the replies; and then you will
recall that three years later, after trying to get the Army to give us these hearings before
the Review Boards, we even had a bill introduced.
I even brought a copy of that along.
I
don't know what is the use of going through all of this again and, frankly, I think the most
important thing to do is to get on our records of this conference our great disappointment
and our opposition to the manner in which this is handled.

-98-

We introduced a bill, had a bill introduced in the 8lst Congress, second
session, which stated, in part, "No person applying under this section for purposes of
having his or her military, naval, air or coast guard record corrected shall be denied a _
fair and impartial hearing on the motion of the Board or on the action of the Secretary
respectively involved."
I don't know how to say it any better than to say what we
you still all agree with that.
I don't know what else to do except to
again, unless we can make a forceful recommendation here in such a way
of the Army will recognize the great worth of what we are trying to do
this organization is completely dissatisfied with the present setup.

be

repititious

said then.
I am‘sure
go back to Congress
that the Secretary
and recognize that
:

I have innumerable cases which I could go into here, which
of the experiences which you, yourselves, have had.

I know

would

only

I am dissatisfied with another situation.
I am sure that Kay Klemmetson and
many of the rest of you have had considerable correspondence with our Washington office, and
I refer to the case where we have records in the files of the Veterans Administration which
so clearly show entitlement, and then they refuse even to call the records in for review and
they, our Washington office, asks us to get copies of the records from the VA file.
‘I am
bitterly opposed to that.
These boards were set up to correct injustices.
You and I see them
everyday work and I am convinced that these civilian boards, if we could get the
them, would correct many of these injustices, and I think that that is the whole
to the problem, to get our hearings before the boards so that these veterans can
represented.
I

don't

know

whether

there

is

further

that

I can

say

on

it,

Mr.

in our
cases before
solution
be properly

Chairman.

MR. KORELLA:
Mr. Chairman,I should like to comment along those lines.
Since
it seems to be an absolute impossibility to get a review of discharges before this Board,
I must, of necessity, question the propriety of the Air Service and of the Army in issuing
general discharges to personnel who have no demerits against them, who have been in the service
all the way from twelve to sixteen and eighteen years, and it appears to me that the only
reason that these things are issued is to get rid of the personnel.
In my office in St. Louis, in the last year, I have had no fewer than fifty
general discharges come to my attention that were issued on the purely proprietary basis
of getting rid of the individual, ostensibly because the two-year period is close at hand
at which he could be retired.

es

Now, there have been very serious repercussions on those discharges.
It is
utterly impossible for the recipient of a general discharge properly to secure employment
for which he is properly fitted in the various categories.
Take, for instance, people
who have qualifications in aeronautics; they find it absolutely impossible to be employed
‘by

MacDonald

Air

Craft

and

sundry

other

organizations.

The

Police

Department

of

the

City

eo

of St. Louis will not even entertain an application 6f
a discharged veteran that has a
general discharge.
To all of them and some fifty organizations in our city, a discharge
of the general nature doesn't mean a thing.
He might just as well have an undesirable or
a bad conduct discharge, because
he cannot get to first base.
Now, I must further insist that this body go on record as questioning
propriety that I mentioned and take the proper steps to have those things properly
whereby the entire possibility of livelihood on the part of the individual who has
discharged with a general discharge, not having anything against him on his entire
be properly changed to an honorable discharge and eradicate the stigma of question.
CHAIRMAN
MR.

GLEASON:

KORELLA:

CHAIRMAN

Are

I will

GLEASON:

you

make
Is

that

that

there

(Calls

of

"Wait

a minute!)

VOICE:

I

second

the

CHAIRMAN GLEASON:

putting

a

in

the

form

the

form

of

a motion.

second?

Not

hearing

in

of

a

the
changed
been
record,

a motion?

second,

the

motion

is

lost.

motion.

O.K.,

there is a second.

All right,

it is open for dis-

cussion.

Correction
charges is

MR. STEVENS:
May I comment briefly, please?
This is not the Army Board for
of Military Records that considers those discharges.
The review of those dismade by the Army Discharge Review Board or the Air Force Discharge Review Board,

-99{

|

as the case may be, which is set up under section 301 of the Servicemen's Readjustment Act
Those .boards, consisting of five members on each panel, are composed of commissioned
of 1944.
officers and when we ask for a hearing, a hearing is granted in every case.
1f an appeal is taken from their decisions to the othei
for Correction of Military Records, however, it is almost impossible
wanted you to know that, Jack, and the folks here.

Board,
to get

the Army Board
a hearing.
I

However, one brief further comment.
We were anxious to know how general
charges which are issued under honorable conditions are accepted by employers, and he
tainly has brought it out and someone else may wish to comment.

do

something

MR.

YOUNG:

You

MR.

STEVENS:

MR.
and

YOUNG:
what we

mentioned

a moment

ago

the

way

we

spell

here

a

little

discer-

are

stymied

in

the

Army.

more

firmly

that

we

should

Yes.

Why don't we
should do.

out

MR. STEVENS:
On January 20, 1956,
to Assistant Secretary Hugh Milton, asking that
him.
Mr. Milton hasn't yet made an arrangement

Mr. Kraabel composed a letter which went
we be permitted to discuss this problem with
for us to sit down with him and talk it over.

I tried to have the chairman here.
I told him I was going to talk about this.
I like to have somebody sitting with me when I talk about him.
But he said he didn't think
anything could be discussed here in thirty minutes or in an hour that would accomplish any
results.

He

did

say

he

would

meet

with

us

to

discuss

the

matter,

at

our

convenience.

How-

ever, I wanted the record to show that we did object to the present operation of the board
and that we plan to take whatever corrective measures are necessary.
1 hope we can meet
with the Assistant Secretary, his advisor and the chairman shortly.
I do feel that reasonable
men do not have too much trouble reaching agreement.
MR. FARRINGTON, California:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to ask Chairman McCurdy
this question, please.
Would it be possible, Bob, that the transcript of Charlie Stevens'
statement made to this conference be immediately typed and sent to every member of the Armed
Services Committee so that it will come out in the Congressional Record and everybody in
America will know just exactly what is going on over there?
The shock troops at home don't
know about it.
MR. McCURDY:
I would entertain that as a recommendation
Committee Friday when we pass on their report, I have the microphone,
struct our Chairman to prepare such a recommendation.

say

'aye';

Board.

Now

CHAIRMAN GLEASON:
those opposed.
The

Is there further
"ayes" have it.

discussion

Gentlemen, we have
we are going to the

completed the panel
panel discussion on

to the Recommendations
I would like to in-

on

the

motion?

Those

in

discussion
Insurance.

on

the

Forces

Review

Armed

favor

MR. SLONEKER:
Mr. Chairman, May I make an announcement, please.
I don't know
just how many members of the Recommendations Committee are in the room but I would like
to make this announcement,
that there will be a meeting of the Recommendations Committee
right across the hall at four-thirty today.
Kay Klemmetson has reminded me that it might be well to say if any of you have
recommendations that you have written out, will you please get them either to me or to
another member of the committee, and if you want to discuss them, feel free to come before
the committee at any time to discuss them.
CHAIRMAN GLEASON:
We are ready for the panel discussion on Insurance and
Mr. Gardner from the Veterans Administration is here with us.
He is the Acting Chief
Insurance Director, and he is here with his staff.
I am going
to turm the meeting over
now to Melvin Dixon from Florida, who will make the other introductions.
:

MR.

MELVIN

T.

DIXON,

Florida:

Thank

you know the Appeals Panel didn't have any
hours, so, we have four questions.
Before
Insurance Panel, I would like at this time
as I call it, to assist me.
I would first
from the great State of Kansas.

Department

of

colleague

from

the

you,

Chairman

John.

Ladies

and

gentlemen,

questions at all and we talked
on that -about two
we get into the questions in reference to the
to introduce my colleagues on my side of the fence,
like to present to you Mr. Bobby Ray Swinson

Next,

my

grand

State

Now,
the

with your permission, before
Veterans Administration,
let

of

California,

I introduce
me say this

-100-

Robert

the Director of
to you, please.

K.

Russell.

the Insurance
Let's take the

questions first on the panel that have been submitted.
We will read the question.
We will
ask for an answer from the Veterans Administration and then we will accept comment from the
floor on that answer.
We will move through the questions on the program and then if there
is time left we will entertain questions from the floor in general.
At this time it is, indeed, a pleasure for me to introduce to you, and I will
ask him to say what he will and, in turn, introduce the members of his staff, Mr. E. O.
Gardner, Acting Chief Insurance Director of the Veterans Administration.
Mr. Gardner, please,
sir.
MR, E. O. GARDNER:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen:
It is a pleasure to
appear here to help you in your deliberations and to answer your questions.
I have no
particular remarks to make so I will proceed to introduce the members of the Insurance staff
who have accompanied me.
:

i

iE

‘E

First on my left is Mr. Poissant, the Chief Actuary of the Department; Mr.
Willett, the Director of Underwriting Service; Mr. McGurn, the Director of Disability
Insurance Claims Service; Mr. Cook, the Manager of the Insurance Center.

this
with

wotaiig
us.

Mr.Ralph Dority, the Director of our Insurance Accounts
and had to go home to bed, at the advice of his doctor.

Service was
I am sorry

taken
he is

ill
not

MR. DIXON:
Mr. Gardner, the first question on the program is submitted by
Mr. Davison of Kansas and reads as follows:
"Why cannot VAR 3442(C) be amended so that a
premium surplus brought about by a Section 602 (N) waiver be used, if refund not requested,
to pay preniuas if in an amount sufficient to continue policy in force through date of
veteran's death?"
le

Would

you

like

to

take

that,

or

a member

of

your

staff?

MR. GARDNER:
Section 602(N) of the National Service Life Insurance Act
specifically provides that premiums waived under that section shall
be refunded.
Now the
Veterans Administration has interpreted that as a specific directive that those premiums
will

in

all

circumstances

be

refunded.

We

have,

however,

as

you

will

note

from

a

look

at

the application for waiver, provided that if the insured specifically requests, we will
retain the premiums for application to premiums falling due after the action, but not any
premiums falling due prior to the finding of disability.
That appears on the lower part
Just above the signature on the application for disability waiver.
We will carry out the
insured's wishes, but they must be specifically expressed.
MR.

DIXON:

MR.

DAVISON:

MR.

DIXON:

Mr.

Davison

from

Kansas,

I do?

What

is

there

any

comment

you

would

that

by

like

to

make?
What
He

said

can

they

have

do

you

specific

think

about

instructions.

it?
Is

law,

sir?

MR. GRADNER:
That is by law.
The law specifically says that premiums waived
under the provisions of this section shall be refunded.
The word "shall" is a very strong
word in an act.
We have under consideration one thing. that might help a little in this
connection, and that is the possible revision of the application form which would invite an
election on the part of the insured.
If there is no legal objection to that when referred,
for opinion, to the General Counsel, you may find such a form available in a short time.

to

ask

Bobby

MR. DIXON:
Swinson to

So
ask

that the
the next

Insurance
question.

Panel

will

not

be

overworked,

I am

going

MR. BOBBY RAY SWINSON, Kansas:
The second question is also submittedby Mr.
Davison of Kansas:
"EM 9-585 dated 1-25-56 requires that a copy of VA rating sheet be forwarded to the Department of Insurance for the purpose of notifying potentially eligible
veterans of their right to purchase nonparticipating convertible NSLI under Section 620 or
to change existing contracts of nonparticipating term NSLI under provisions of Sections
&1 to Section 620 NSLI.
The rating sheet shows organization holding veteran's power of
attorney, if any.
Why, then,
cannot a copy of VA Form Letter 9-5 be furnished the ‘organization holding power of attorney for followup with vetegan?
MR. GARDNER:
That is a good question and it will be answered very quickly.
EM 9-585 will be immediately amended to provide that a copy of the letter be forwarded to
the accredited organization representative in the District Office.

very

MR.

DIXON:

Mr.

Gardner,

you

couldn't

Now,

since

the

next

questions

have

given

us

been

presented

a better

answer.

Thank

fi

you

much.
two

have
-101-

by

our

good

friend

from

California,

Bob,

come

on

up

here

and

you

ask

these

two

questions.

MR. ROBERT K. RUSSELL:
"With reference to VAR 3409 or 3410,
deduction of insurance premium from VA benefits, why cannot the deduction
to pay premium for the month in which submitted to the VA providing it is
to the premium due date?"

authorization for
become effective
received prior

We were a little reluctant to submit that question in the beginning because
we were afraid we would be asking to place the veteran in a rather untenable position by
always having to pay at a certain period, but we had in mind that the veteran might become
deceased or totally disabled after he submits an 887 and before he gets any money in.
MR. GARDNER:
In your remarks, you put your finger on the reason for this
regulation, namely, that even under the present regulation, when an 887 is submitted late
in a month and a premium is due the first of the following month, the payment is actually
made almost at the end of the grace period.
Therefore, when payments are terminated, you
are requiring the man to pay very quickly or otherwise lapse and have to be reinstated.
There is an additional reason for that regulation, namely, that it takes time,
of course, to process any piece of paper.
There are administrative actions to be gone through
with and frequently even under the present system double or greater deductions are required
when there isn't enough money to pay them.
We would simply compound that difficulty if we
permitted the authorization to become effective a month earlier.
MR. RUSSELL:
We had in mind a principle similar to that involving processing
of compensation claims in which we might submit a formal or informal claim which would
establish an informal date so far as protection of the veteran was concerned, and we didn't
know whether or not the submission of an 887 without any money to support the 887, or the 888,
I guess it is now -- doesn't that replace the 8877?
MR.

event

no

of

any

GARDNER:

Yes

-the

888.

MR. -RUSSELL:
The 888
unusual. circumstance

would serve to protect the
happening to him before he

MR.

GARDNER:

Do

mean

MR.

RUSSELL:

No.

MR.

GARDNER:

Obviously,

you

before

the

we

deduct

can't

money

a

is

interests of the veteran
got the money in.

in

the

due?

premium

from

a month

in

which

there

is

compensation.

MR. VALIANT, Colorado:
In the event there is sufficient compensation being
paid to pay these premiums, why shouldn't the date of the receipt
.of the 888 be the effective
date of that request for deduction -- I mean, request for deduction of compensation?
In
other words, if it is submitted, it will be payable for the month in which it is submitted
as a protection to the insured.
:
:

MR.

GARDNER:

Mr.

Valiant,

I

think

we

answered

that

first,

that

the

reasons

for the regulation are twofold: first, that ‘it is partially as a protection to the man because one submitted late in a month, where the premium is due the first of the following
month, actually pays the premium at the end of the grace period.
Therefore, if there is a
termination of compensation requiring termination of the deduction, the man has to take
awfully quick action in order to pay his premium on time.
‘So, it is partially for his protection that that regulation was adopted.
Now, the second question in connection with that: if we are given an authorization with deductions beginning in.any month in which the compensation becomes effective,
it will, of course, be honored to keep the insurance in force.
MR. RUSSELL: That question is not one that has created a problem in our
Regional Office but we were given to understand that in certain of the other Regional Offices
they had that problem and I was asked to request a clarification for the purpose of establishing uniformity.
:
MR. DIXON:
"If for any reason a veteran's compensation or pension is suspended
and subsequently restored as of the suspension date, why doesn't the Veterans Administration
automatically deduct insurance premium from date of suspension where veteran had of record
an authorization for premium deductions to be made for insurance purposes?
Authorization
should be reinstated and veteran's insurance rights fully protected."
MR. GARDNER:
I think I can give you
quickly.
This question requires negotiation with
as the payment of these deductionscomes ‘under the
-102-

a_ satisfactory answer to that fairly
the Department of Veterans Benefits inasmuch
jurisdiction of that Department.

We are in favor of the proposal but do think the safest thing to do when "comp" is suspended
is to resume premium payment by direct remittance.
Otherwise, the veteran might jeopardize
his rights if the 'comp'" is finally stopped as the result of that suspension, or for the
reason that it was suspended.

can

make

such

We will discuss the
an arrangement, we
MR.

DIXON:

Ladies

and

Thank

matter with the Department of
will be very glad to do so.

you

very

much,

Mr.

Gentlemen,

the

floor

is

Veterans

Benefits

and

if

we

ii
gl

Gardner.
open.

|

Do

I hear

I

comments?

MR. HUDGENS, Tennessee:
Where a veteran has been in receipt of retirement pay
and has an allotment to cover insurance premium, he waives retirement benefits in order to
be eligible for VA benefits; at the same time he files an 887 for deduction of his compensation to pay his insurance premium.
Then some two months later he gets a notice from the
‘Insurance Section that his insurance has lapsed, and very often it is beyond the grace period,
whereas it is not the veteran's fault because as long as he was drawing retirement pay he
had Class N allotment to take care of him.
When he transferred over to veteran's benefits
he signed a form authorizing the deduction of the first month's premium out of his first
month's compensation.
:

Io
i a

|

a
i

;
It is not being deducted and, therefore, the veteran loses his insurance.
This
has happened three or four times in Tennessee.
Could not there be some coordination worked
out between the Retirement Board and the Veterans Administration to take care of this situation?
MR.

DIXON:

Mr.

Gardner,

would

you

like

to

answer

that,

or

a member

of

your

MR. GARDNER:
I will be glad to answer it.
The question had not come up
Frankly, I didn't know there had been any lapses under those circumstances.
We would
glad to discuss the matter with the Service Department allotment offices to make sure
all of their allotments are on an advance basis.
I imagine your difficulty is coming
that rather than anything else.
:

rather
if you
I feel

than
know
sure

staff?

before.
be
that
from

Occasionally the allotments are registered so that the payment is on a current
an advance basis.
We surely don't want to see any man lose his protection and
any cases where it has happened, I wish you would bring them to my attention.
we can adjust the matter satisfactorily.
MR.

HUDGENS

MR.

GARDNER:

:

We

will

furnish

Address

them

Mr.

Gardner

with

the

cases.

to my

personal

attention.

-MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
I have one question for Mr. Gardner or any
member on the panel.
K Insurance, United States Government, World War I, a converted policy
fully paid up -- some of those policies at the time of issuance carried only three options.
Has there been a change in the law so that those policies now carry four options for the
widow?
MR.

War

I.

GARDNER:

You

MR. BROWNING:
A veteran dies; how

mean

Yes,
many

settlement

options?

option settlement of
options does a widow

MR. GARDNER:
The fourth option, namely,
available to United States Government policy-holders.
do bear a fourth option, which has virtually the same
higher ages.
MR.

BROWNING:

But

it

It

available

MR.

GARDNER:

240

installments

certain.

that

fourth

Question

1.

is

MR. DIXON:
1I wonder
option is available.
MRS.

RACHEL

KOCH:

MR.

DAVISON,

Kansas:

MR.

DIXON:

MR.

DAVISON:

We

is

Death

benefits?

payment
on
have?

a

lump

sum

policy,

Worla

the refund life income, is not
However, all the printed policy forms
effect overall but is superior at the

available?
in

a

different

form,

namely,

life

annuity

if that is general knowledge throughout the country,
Have you put out any information bulletins on that?
It

|

is

on

form

If

you

don't

succeed,

might

as

well;

come

on.

Under

the

phrase

with

that

66T.

''shall

ii

be

try

again.

refunded,"

I

I want

believe

to

that

go

back

there

to

are

-103-

federal court decisions that have
who has title to the money and if
your mind, Mr. Gardnei?
MR.

DIXON:

Did

you

held that
I furnish

get

that,

that phrase, ''shall
you with such court

Mr.

be refunded,'" simply declares
decisions, will you change

Gardner?

MR. GARDNER:
I get his question, yes, sir.
In the first place, the decisions
on this matter have been made by the Administrator of Veterans Affairs.
They would have
to be reversed by him.
You may not be familiar with them but Administrator's Decision 745
of May 20, 1947, and Administrator's Decision 794 of October 4, 1948, cover this matter.
You
may read them with a good deal of interest.
I

waived premiums
be very glad to

again

to
do

repeat

that

continue
so.

the

MR.

DIXON:

MR.

DAVISON:

if

Anything

I am

the

payment

else,

not

insured

of

Brother

getting

gives

premiums

us

a

after

specific

the

waiver

direction

is

o'clock

CHAIRMAN
sharp.
(The

GLEASON:

meeting

The

adjourned

meeting

at

use

these

we

will

Davison?

much

help.

Go

ahead.

MR. DIXON:
Do you have any more questions from the floor on
program?
If there are no more questions from the floor, let me thank Mr.
of the entire panel.
I don't know of anyone in the ten years I have been
that has gotten off so easy.

nine

to

terminated,

stands

adjourned

four-twenty

o'clock.)

-104-

until

the insurance
Gardner on behalf
coming up here,

tomorrow

morning

at

THURSDAY

MORNING

SESSION

March 1, 1956

of

The meeting convened
Commission, presiding.

the

CHAIRMAN
presiding

officer

the

democratic

great

THE

ask

MILLER:

I

our

great

State

of

REVEREND

at

o'clock,

Mr.

Watson

appropriate

think

it

is

friend

and

our

New

JOSEPH

nine-twenty

Jersey,

to

|

great

ask

MacCARROLL:

the

Grant,

B.

Miller,

Vice

Chairman

temporary

and

necessary

that

the

National

Chaplain,

Joe

MacCarroll

blessing

of

God

upon

Father,

that

as

our

nn

from

us.
we

begin

the

deliberations of this day we may be deeply conscious of our own limitations, but we may also
be conscious that as we commit our limitations to Thee, that Thou canst empower us.
Help
us never to mistake plans and programs for humble service in Thy Name and for the good of our
fellow men.
To that end bless us this day.
Amen.
CHAIRMAN

a beautiful

MILLER:

Thank

you,

Joe.

That

gives

the

few

of

us

here

a

nice

start

il

on

day.

I am Watson B. Miller and I have been detailed by Commission Chairman McCurdy
to work with you during this session of the conference.
I am proud of the assignment and I
am also proud of some other things.
I worked with the senior members of this conference,
this great group, for about eighteen years -- gallant men and devoted women they were and are.
There comes to my mind one of those great girls who has passed away from this great plane
in a corporeal sense a few years ago.
She was Rose Lynn, of North Carolina, a great nurse
in her earlier years, and it is said of her that despite the onslaught of the calendar, she
had marched in every Legion parade at every national convention since the birth of the

|
|
i
|

organization.

feel

like

laid

my

the

eyes

At the nurses' breakfast
peck of a tack
hammer,
Is
on

in Miami,
either.

Rose

gave

Mary Welch sitting out there?
I have
her since the conference started.

been

me

a kiss

longing

and,

gentlemen,

to

her

see

and

it

I

didn't

haven't

My debt of gratitude is very deep in respect to those who started with me
something like thirty-three years ago, and I remember that we had our first national conference on rehabilitation in the Racquet Club, of which I was a member then, and in a room
18 feet wide and 30 feet long.
I am proud of the growth in every aspect of our work since
those formative days.
:

i

We began with no great background of knowledge,
legislative, medical or otherwise.
We had to explore and carve out trails and to help the Legion at large to construct
objectives designed to relieve pain, surcease from mental distress, and to comfort, as
Lincoln said at Gettsburg,
the widowed,
the orphaned, to which we have added the mothers.
Like you fine. younger ones are facing these days, we had to learn something
about trauma, organic and constitutional disease, hospital management,
together with purely
administrative operation, and many other facets of our collective job which was not then
unlike your own now.

now travel.
as now, the

|

From all to which I sketchily make reference of here, much good has grown.
Then
we did not seek or expect praise, nor do you now.
We rejected the notion of either unwittingly or otherwise courting popularity over the shoulders of sick men and women veterans
suffering from their rigorous participation in the Great War.

{

I
listened,to

[
i

\
\

Perhaps we can modestly say that we sort of widened a bit the roads which you
My staff associates and I took lessons from the firing line in the field where,
problems and their potential cures were audited, assessed and frequently found.

have

their

watched

voices,

this
your

grand

younger

addresses,

to

phalanx
your

but

without

perplexities,

the

impudence
exchanges

fellows and with government, as to experiences,your experiences, good
your work striving to help other fellows and to make a better America

and
and

or

doubt.

with

I

viewing

have

not so good, in
a better world.

I have had no orders about the little job I have to do with you this morning.
the brief piogram, it seems to me that you are to receive some reports which will
-105-

iil

your

No man can stand and tell me moie than I already know of you.
I say with deep
sincerity that I see talent, imagination, earnestness and a valiant will to do.
Please let
me now,
an emeritus, be proud of you, too.
I would love again to guide such a battalion.
May God attend you every day.

Just

fi

i

i

be

of

import

to

every

one

of

you

and

to

every

one

of

us

older

ones.

I will conclude with this word of something deeply
consciousness.
What I have in mind concerns every one of you.
shortly hear some of the aspects of the work of the commissions
report on veterans' affairs.

within my knowledge and
It is my belief that you will
appointed to study and to

It is well within my knowledge that Bob McCurdy, with stalwart
courage, has never
lowered a single shield.
No timidity or diffidence has been displayed.
He has made graphic
and certain the Legion's position as to approval or otherwise,
actually done within the ranks
of the explorers.
I thrilled last year, I think, T. O., the anniversary of today,
last year,
standing with Bob and a dozen or more others of your group before
the President of the United
States hearing Bob speak for three million of us making our position
graphic and clear.

The rejoinder of the President may be classified
heard it already, but I gloried in the whole picture.
"There
of yours."

who will
ago, and
not only

-is

perhaps some of you have
no retreat in that bunch

Now, let me introduce, and offer to you the first panel
be my alter ego for a while.
He is T. 0., who followed me,
I think, the older men and women, at least, will agree with
succeeded me but he exceeded me. T. 0.

member of the
who succeeded
me when I say

morning,
me years
that he

:
MR. T. O. KRAABEL:
Thank you, Watson.
National Chairman McCurdy, Ladies and
Gentlemen:
I hope you will pardon just a brief reversion to some of the days
gone by and to
some of the things in our own memory.
I am sure some of the older members will join me in
recalling the days back in the Racquet Club, the Gold Room of
the Hamilton Hotel
and even
before that, the sixth floor of the Bond Building over here at
l4th and New York Avenue.

To hear Watson's voice again at the rostrum thirty-two
years after he started
these small meetings -- the first one I attended was twenty-eight
years ago -- sort of combines and makes whole and brackets those of the American citizens
who have gone through three
wars and find a community of interest in serving others.

is

have
a

comments

rundown,

on

probably

at

least
by

two

Federal

calendar

rather

more analytical, and also
Office of the President.

more

direct

Commission
than

in

reports

conclusions

that

it

is

to
o:

having

give

you

results;

the

today.

the

attention

other

of

The one I speak to you about now is the President's Commission
on Veterans'
Pensions.
You recall a year ago we were considering the fact that it
had just been appointed.
It hadn't started functioning yet.
Since that time, not only has the Commission been
organized and started to function, but the National Commander
of last year appointed a
special committee to be his eyes and ears with reference
to its report; and this year's
National Commander has continued the same arrangement.
That special committee is composed of Past National Commander
Don Wilsdn,
Carl Rees of Delaware and Dr. Deward Reed of New Mexico.
The committee, in turn, has had a
research analyst working for six months in the person of
Bert Davis, a member of the staff
of the National Legislative Commission, and more recently
two members of the staff of the

National

Rehabilitation

Commission

under

McGrail,

Warren

MacDonald

and

Cecil

Munson.

A year ago last August when the President sent his message
with reference to
signing H. R. 9020 and H. R. 9962, which became Public
Law 695 and 698 giving slight increases
in compensation and pension awards, he said this:
"Although additional benefits have been
granted from time to time, our basic veteran laws have
not changed materially in the last
thirty years.
We must also recognize the fact that because of the inauguratio
n and growth
of closely related and uncorrelated federal programs designed
to provide assurances against
want to all of our citizens, there are today many instances
of uneven and inequitable benefits.
Under the present system, for example,
there are no means of taking into account the degree
of the veteran's need, no relation between payments received
under the veterans' pension
laws and payments received, for example, under old-age
and survivors' insurance system.
"It

is

scope and philosophy
government prog.ams.

essential,

of
I

therefore,

that

steps

our veterans' benefit laws
am ordering such a study."

be

in

taken

relation

to

to

examine

each

the

other

entire

structure,

and

other

to

That was on August 28, 1954.
The following January the President issued his
Executive Order establishing the President's Commission on
Veterans' Pensions.
This is
dated January 14, 1955.
We took officiak notice of it at our last year's conference.
In the Executive Order he sets out
authorized and directed to make a comprehensive
structure, scope and administration of the laws
compensation and related nonmedical benefits to

the function of the Commission:
"It is
study and survey and appraisal of the
of the United States providing pension,
veterans and their dependents, and it shall

-106-

———

them

i

of

iy

We
One

by McGrail is
the Executive

11

‘er

make recommendations to the President regarding policies whichin its judgment should guide
the granting of such benefits in the future, and ghe Commission shall give particular attention
to changes in the military, social, fiscal, economic factors and conditions under which
benefits should be provided, and the relationship of the various veterans' benefits to each
other."
.

as

of

January

Those are the
14, 1955.

marching

orders

of

the

President

to

a commission

not

yet

appointed

In the first circular issued by the National Rehabilitation Commission of that
year, four days later, we made mention of this Commission and its request for funds in the
VA budget, $300,000to carry out its work.
You will recall they had considerable difficulty
getting the funds and finally it was O0.K.'d with the support of the Chairman of the House
Committee on Veterans' Affairs.
Then, on March 9, 1955, just following our conference of a
year ago, we issued and sent out to you the Presidential Release dated March 5, 1955, in which
he named his Commission.
This was practically two months after the Executive Order.
Named
were General Bradley as the Chairman, Clarence G. Adamy, William Donovan, Dr. Paul Hawley,
Martin Jenkins, Theodore Petersen, John S. Thompson as members of that Commission.

|
i|

Then in the survey of our own people as to our position with reference to some
of the points raised, we sent out the memorandum of April 11, 1955.
On the basis of the
returns, we made a compilation on whether some of the compensation structure should be changed,
or if there should be some amalgamation, some subrogation, some relationship between those
larger or more comprehensive benefit programs for all of the people that had come upon the
scene since the days of 1919,
'20 and the thirties when veterans' programs were established
for the veterans of World War I.
We have the compilation and replies as a matter of guides
to us in our staff approach to the staff of the Bradley Commission.
Under date of May 10, 1955, National Commander Seaborn Collins presented to
the Chairman of this Commission some of The American Legion views in the form of a general
and preliminary statement of The American Legion.
This was predicated upon long-time mandates, resolutions and expressions on the points that we felt would be comprehended by the
Commission's work.
This was quite extensive and is, I believe, familiar to all of the
members of the Commission and all the practicing service officers."
The appointment of the special committee came about after the May meeting of
1955.
Following that, the National Commander addressed himself to General Bradley and
alerted all of these members, as well as the staff at the Washington office, of what the
Legion was offering in the way of help to the Bradley Commission in its study.
It might be summarized in these words.
The Commander said that
Legion would be willing to share with the Bradley Commission its experiences
" over the years with reference to veterans' programs.

The
and

American
findings

That was well received.
The Executive Officer of the Bradley Commission became
Major General E. M. Brannan and we had informal meetings with him from time to time.
Also,
the special committee of the National Commander met here periodically after the work of the
research analyst got under way.
They would go over his findings and occasionally have an
informal word with General Brannan and his staff.
‘Then, in August of 1955 we had a request from the Commission to recommend men
of the medical profession to whom the Commission might address itself in seeking information
on some phases of medical import in the rating schedule.
In response to that request,
the Chairman of the special committee, Past National Commander Don Wilson, submitted the
names of our then Medical Advisory Board, much the same as it is today except now we have
the addition of Dr. Gunderson, the eye specialist of Boston.
These medicalmen, together
with members of the staff who are doctors, were named and received by the Commission as
reference points in the field of medicine, in addition to the many others they received from
other organizations.
At the Miami National Convention the organization went on record officially in
adopting Resolution No. 420 in which it expressed itself as opposing any move by the President's
Commission on Veterans Pensions, to do away with nonservice-connected pensions and any benefits veterans now received.
That resolution is in the hands of the National Commander's
Special Committee to be considered and timed as they deem best.
You

recall

the

article

in

the

Saturday

Evening

Post

of

November

5,

1955,

in

which the writer said this about the Chairman of the Bradley Commission:
"It is a certainty,
however, that he (General Bradley) will support the Hoover Commission's basic recommendations
for pension cuts and endorse some restrictions in the medical program.
Bradley clearly took
that position when I interviewed him recently."

in the
social

And then Bradley was quoted as saying, ''The great social advances we've made
last twenty years have reduced the need for old soldiers' pensions.
The Federal
security and old-age pension programs, state unemployment insurance, industrial-

«107

il

retirement plans and
65 in the future."

now

the

guaranteed

annual

wage,

will

take

better

care

of

people
i

over

To that, there was a response by the Chairman himself, in which
he said, on
November 1, 1955:
"The article in question is based on an informal interview
by the writer,
(Mr. Frank).
In this interview I described various problems which this Commission
is study=
ing as outlined in the President's instructions to the Commission.
reflecting

my

"The writer has, apparently through error, quoted this
personal decision or position on the issues involved.

"No. 2,
on the questions the
position as Chairman
until the Commission
commendations to the

statement

of

problems

as

I have kept a completely open mind and have at mo time
taken a position
Commission must decide.
It would be entirely inconsistent with my
to express my views publicly or privately on matters under
consideration
completes its studies, reaches its conclusions, and makes
its rePresident.

"No. 3,
The article in question also ascribes to this Commission certain
points
of view taken by the recent Hoover Commission and states that
our report will be released
this month.
As a matter of fact, no decisions have yet been reached and
our report will not
be issued until early next year.
We will take no position until thorough and comprehensive
fact-gathering studies now under way are completed.
These studies will enable the Commission
to get the benefit of data from all possible sources, including
confidential information
directly from thousands of veterans."
;
Then we come up to the days of. the questionnaire.
We first have the questionnaire
that was formulated by the Bureau of Census.
It was sent out to a specimen group of veterans
irrespective of disability and the degree of disability, the well
and whole and healthy,
as well as others.
Then, supplementary, or as an afterthought, possibly, the Commission
itself formulated a questionnaire which went out to disabled veterans
and there we find considerable resistance in parts of the country.
We were asked from different states,
'What
shall we do?"
We went to General Brannan, Executive Officer of the Bradley Commission,
and
asked what the purpose was.
You recall what Bradley said on Novémber lst, "That we are going to
interview thousands of veterans."
;
They assured us it was fact-finding, entirely, and based on ascertaining
to what
extent a service-incurred disability may have removed one from the
position he had, or would
have had, and forced him to change activity because of the disability?
Some of these questionnaires bore a number on the bottom of P.-4.
We felt that
was for the purpose of identifying the individual, even though
he did not have to sign, and
that possibly the refusal to answer, or the information given in
the reply, might be referred
to his C-folder in the Veterans Administration.
We checked this time and time again, brought
our report to the National Commander and to National Chairman McCurdy.
Over long distance
'phone with both of them, they instructed us, after being assured
that the purpose was as
stated, that we would not recommend opposition, but that we would
leave it to each individual
who received such a questionnaire to decide as between himself
and the Government what he
would do.

would

be

to

At
the

the same time, we encouraged the
benefit of disabled veterans.

replies

because

we

felt

that

fact-finding

At the November meeting of the subcommittee of the National Rehabilitati
on
Commission,
it was determined that possibly we might run a survey and have
findings that
could be used in rebuttal to the Bradley Commission.
That possibility was explored by McGrail
and myself, in contact with experts at the Census Bureau and those
who are trained in sampling popular opinion and sampling the reactions of the American
people.
Our conclusion was that, in the. time element given for the preparatio
n
of an
involved questionnaire that would have to be mechanically processed when
it got back in order
to run the replies and coordinate them, we would hold up until
we learned more of the findings and results of the government's own questionnaire.
Accordingly that is held in abeyance.
There is considerable bitter reaction to the questionnaire, as
you gentlemen
and ladies know, and in one instance it was put on the record before the
House Committee on
Veterans' Affairs.
Those who did not reply had follow-up inquiries and finally they
were
left alone, and those who did reply, their answers were put on the
record.
We do not have
the findings or report on them as yet.
Also in January of this year there were questionnaires sent out to certain
key
people with reference to the rating schedule.
That questionnaire, with its analysis, was
made available to you folks under date of January 16, 1956.

-108-

re

available

Again,
either to

the
the

findings of that questionnaire and the rating schedule are not
special committee or to any outside organization, as far as we

know.

Two important letters have been received from the Commission asking for American
Legion views, one last November addressed to National Commander Wagner and one on February
16th, two weeks ago, also addressed to National Commander Wagner.
The first was responded
to in that we gave a summary of The American Legion's position on all matters comprehended
by the work of the President's Commission on Veterans' Pensions.
The last one referred to, February 16th, brings us up to date and before I read
it I want to say again that the special committee, Don Wilson, Deward Reed and Carl Rees,
have been working, are still functioning; members of the staff named have continued their
research; the findings and product of such research are still within the committee itself,
have not been publicized and have not been formalized in any fashion.
The committee itself
will report to the National Commander upon completion of its work, and after these final
appearances which I shall now mention to you by reading the letter that Commander Wagner
got from General Brannan two weeks ago.
"As you recall, I indicated to you in my letter of November lst that the members
of the Commission wish to meet with representatives of your organization to discuss alternative
solutions to various key problems which have come up in the Commission's studies.
At a
recent meeting of the Commission, they asked me to arrange for your representatives to meet
with them at their mid-March meeting.
"Accordingly, I would like to know if it would be convenient for you or your
representatives to meet with the Commission on Saturday, March 17, from 9:30 a.m. to 12 noon
in Room 404 of the Windber Building.
At this meeting the Commission would like to have
your views on a series of key issues which have been identifiedin the course of its studies
and on which it expects to make recommendations.
"In order to help you make preparations for the meeting with the Commission,
staff of the Commission will undertake to give you and your staff a brief presentation of
the highlights of the results of our various fact-finding studies before your meeting with
the Commission.
This presentation will be made in a conference room of the Departmental
Auditorium on Constitution Avenue at 2:00 p.m. on March 8th.
(That is a week from today.)
At this presentation, representatives of the Commission will also provide you with a list
of the issues which will be the basis of the subsequent discussion with the Commission
members.
It is not planned, however, to discuss these issues at this first presentation.
"As you know, the Commission is operating on a very tight schedule.
In order
to firm up the arrangements for these two meetings, we would appreciate greatly if you could
advise us at the earliest possible date whether the time indicated for each of them would
be satisfactory to you.
"We would also like
from your organization who would
staff presentation on March 8th,
a large room."

to have you provide us in advance with a list of the persons
be expected to attend each of these discussions.
For the
space will not be a consideration since we have arranged for

At the present moment I am authorized to say that the staff membérs who will
' go over a week from today will be Stevens, McGrail, Davis, MacDonald and myself, and such
others as indications may point to between now and March 8th.
Mr. Hauck, Director of the
Washington Office will also attend.
The group will be a staff reception committee on our
part to receive what the Bradley Commission is going to ask us to develop for the National
Commander.
And at the later meeting on March 17th, I understand the National Commander,
the special committee and
National Rehabilitation Chairman McCurdy, will be the group that
attends and gets the views and give their views on the issues which the Bradley Commission
by that time will have formulated.

i
|

Now, the time is significant.
Four or five months have elapsed since the first
target date which the Executive Order set when the President created the Commission a year
ago last January.
The work that the Commission undertook was much more arduous, complex
and profound than at first understood, I believe.
Time was needed to go into the many
ramified fields that exposed themselves as they began their analysis.
It is going to be a most challenging period.
It is going to come at a time
when the National Commander and the National Executive Committee have set out on securing
the enactment of H. R. 7886, an improvement of the present disability pension law in the
War Veterans' Security Bill.
But with the leadership of National Commander Wagner, with the
guiding hand of our own National Rehabilitation Chairman and also with the work of the
special committee and its research specialists, I am sure that those things which have been
held dear by all of us over the past thirty-seven years of this work will be conserved and
-109-

{
|

observed, and the Commission will have in forthright language a presentation
of
of The American Legion and the American Legion Auxiliary in this great field.

the

views

We shall as soon as authorized by the National Commander release
the findings
of the Commission and may also ask you for reactions in your various
departments.
That brings
us up to the dates:
the meeting a week from today on the part of the staff, a meeting a
week from Saturday on the part of the National Commander, the National
Rehabilitation Chairman
and the special committee.
Thank

you

very

much

for

your

attention.

Watson asked me to present the next gentleman.
Our colleague pn the staff of
the Commission, Edward McGrail, the Chief of Information and Research,
comes with a lot of
experience in department work, national public relations work, and in
the matter of running
three or four national conventions in The American Legion.
:
in
of

He has an analysis of the Hoover
printed form, have been handed to you, and
:
Ed McGrail!
great value.

Commission recommendations, copies of which,
I think Ed's comments on that you will find

MR. EDWARD MCGRAIL:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen of the conference:
In brief, I would like to recall that a year ago, the Federal Medical
Services Report of the
second Hoover Commission was released just two days before the conference
began.
The
Rehabilitation Commission at that meeting went on record as opposing the
recommendations
of the Hoover Commission and of the Task Force report on the field Federal
Medical Services.

You recall that, in the main, the Task Force had recommended the closing
of
nineteen of Veterans Administration hospitals and the Commission report
itself recommended
that the Administrator of Veterans Affairs study the situation and if
he concurred or if he
found the basis of the Task Force to have value then to proceed with the
closing of those
hospitals or declare them surplus so that they might be otherwise used.
In the months
following and until June there were nineteen reports issued by the second
Hoover Commission.
The National Executive Committee at the May meeting last year went on record
as stating its
position with regard to the recommendations 6f the Commission as those
recommendations, some
314 in number, affected the programs operated by The American Legion.

You will

recall

that

the

second Hoover

Commission

did not

follow

exactly

the

same procedure as had the first Hoover Commission.
In the first Hoover Commission the
recommendations came out as applied to one single agency in each
report.
In other words,
they had a report on the Veterans Administration, one on the Department
of the Interior,
one on the Department of Defense, and so on.
In the second Hoover Commission report, they
had, in dealing with all the federal agencies, a horizontal approach to
all of the problems.
If there were personnel problems, it went across the board to all agencies.
If there were
a medical program, it went not only to the Veterans Administration but
to the Department of
Defense, Department of the Interior and the Department of Health, Education,
and Welfare,
and the others directly or indirectly concerned.
In analyzing the 314 recommendations we found that there were thirty-one
of
them that The American Legion could approve and we have so stated in The
American Legion
analysis of the Hoover Commission Reports which you have before you.
We found that there
were forty-six of them which we should oppose and are opposing.
In the remaining 236 we take
no position.
‘In all of the national organization's approaches to the recommendatio
ns of the
Hoover Commission, we have attempted to deal only with the official
agencies, that is, with
the Hoover Commission or with the Congress and the Executive Branch of
the government to whom
the report was submitted.
There have been in the first session of this Congress and since January
when
the second session opened, approximately three hundred bills introduced
to give effect to
one or more of the recommendations of the Hoover Commission.
Again, there was a change in
the procedure between the second and the first Hoover Commissions in
that the second Hoover
Commission had a legislative draftsman who came from the Congressional
Legislative Service
and drafted a series of basic bills which were designed to cover the
recommendations of the

" Hoover Commission.

Members of Congress have either introduced those bills as they
were drafted or
have amended them or rewritten them so that they would follow their
own ideas of how effect
should be given to the recommendation.
I believe that Miles Kennedy, the Director of the
National Legislative Commission, will a little bit later give you
an up-to-date report on

what has been

done with

regard

to those

bills.

In the final report issued by the Hoover Commission, they stated that
some fifty
of the recommendations had already been- given effect.
Well, that statement was made last
June.
We have been unable to identify or document which recommendations are covered in
that
«110-

statement

or

what

they

mean.

Our purpose in the publication of the analysis which you have before you was
not only to advise the members in Congress in detail what our position might be with regard
to the Hoover Commission recommendations, but also to place our views before the White House
and before the heads of the agencies concerned.
In making up this analysis, we have not
only dealt with the recommendations of the Rehabilitation Commission but we have cut across
the other commissions in The American Legion, since Personnel and Civil Service are handled
by the National Economic Commission, and the Department of Defense recommendations of course
will be covered by the National Security Commission, and there are a few recommendations
that would affect the operations of our National Child Welfare Commission program, so that
the amalysis you now have is the comprehensive opinion of the commissions I have just mentioned.
We felt it was necessary to go to the Executive Branch of the government since
it was reported that a high percentage of the 314 recommendations could be accomplished by
administrative or executive order, or by a reorganization plan. So far as we know, no
reorganization plan has been submitted to the Congress.
That is the special device under
which the White House sends in a plan to Congress to give effect to one or more of the
recommendations.
The plan is submitted to both branches of the Congress and unless either
of them, by a constitutional majority of the membership, rejects the proposal in sixty days,
that reorganization plan becomes law.
On the approximately three hundred bills that have been introduced in Congress,
there has been no definite action that we have been able to learn.
The Legislative Commission
and the other commissions of The American Legion are attempting to follow those bills.
They
are being analyzed as we get reports that there will be hearings on the bills by the various
committees, but to date nothing very substantial has been done on any of the recommendations
that might affect our organization. .
The quasi official Citizens Committee for the Hoover Commission has issued a
statement that some fourteen bills have become law, but when they are analyzed, I think
some of them might have been accomplished otherwise and that they are preening themselves
a little bit in taking credit for them, because I think that some of them might have been
accomplished even if the Hoover Commission had not been in existence.
That does not mean
to underestimate the strength of the support for the various recommendations of the Hoover
Commission nor to lull ourselves into any sense of complacency that the Congress won't act
upon them.
The President has a Committee on Government Operations that is composed of
Nelson Rockefeller as Chairman and Mr: ArthurB. Flemming, who is also the head of the Office
of War Mobilization, and a brother of the President, Mr. Milton Eisenhower.
The President
also appointed Meyer Kestnbaum who is identified in private life as the head of Hart,
Schaffner & Marx and who was the last director of the Commission on Intergovernmental Affairs.
You will recall that that Commission also made its report after considerable discussion and
study over a period of about two years and, so far as we can learn, nothing that the Commission
on Intergovernmental Affairs recommended had in any sense either a good or a bad effect upon
the operations of the programs that are conducted by The American Legion.
But the President did call Mr. Kestnbaum in as his special presidential assistant
to coordinate the activities of all of the executive agencies in the government in acting
upon the recommendations of the second Hoover Commission.

of

the

House,

Administration

Some of
in the
on

the

you may have seen how that is
84th Congress, first session,
recommendations

of

the

given
deals

Commission

effect.
with the
on

Committee print
comments of the

Organization

of

the

No. 174
Veterans

Executive

Branch.
That was issued December 31, 1955, and it covers all of the reports of the Hoover
Commission, even though some of them are not directly in point on the operations of the
Veterans Administration.
I think they have done a very good job in making some very direct
comments in opposition to the recommendations of the Hoover Commission, and we were happy
to see that they were not too different as regards the recommendations that The American
Legion itself has made.

|

!

You also recall that the House Veterans Affairs Committee last March issued
a blue sheet in which it expressed its opposition to the recommendations of the Hoover
Commission dealing with the Federal Medical Services Report.
Now, this morning's paper,
among other things attributed to the announcement made by the President of his future plans,
says that it may mean that the attention of the Executive Branch of the Federal Government
will be stepped up in relation to their attitude toward the recommendations which may be
accomplished by administrative or executive order or by reorganization plans.

|

Although Clarence Bird or John Mears or Adolph Bremer should comment on this
rather than the Rehabilitation Commission's Staff, I can say in passing that within recent
weeks the President sent to Mr. Young, the Chairman of the Civil Service Commission, a letter
in which he recommended that something be done about veterans preference, and particularly
that part of it which deals with job retention rights where, under the Veterans Preference
Act of 1944, the veterans have something approaching absolute retention rights.

11i-

i

I think that about brings it down to date chronologically.
We are in the
position of being on the alert as these things develop either in Congress
or in the Executive
Branch of the government.
Members of the President's Advisory Committee on Government Affairs
have acknowledged reports which have been sent to them, with the Commander's
etter calling
their attention to them, and we have heard semi-officially, at least,
that the White House
staff itself is studying the recommendations from an administrative standpoint.
I

or

six

years

initiated

on

think

that

about

MR. KRAABEL:
Mr.
ago, the study of
a

plane

of

a

brings

it

down

to

date.

Chairman, I wanted to comment that, as contrasted with five
the recommendations of the second Hoover Commission was

little

different

nature

when,

under

Past

National

Commander

Lewis

K. Gough, the Vice President invited him to have a meeting in his private
Senate luncheon
room just three years ago this month.
Attending that meeting
were the members at that time
of the President's Advisory Committee on the Reorganization of the Government.
They were
Milton Eisenhower, Arthur Flemming and Nelson Rockefeller, and the National
Commander had
with him the Rehabilitation Director.
That meeting was for the purpose of seeing if we
couldn't approach the second Hoover Report in a manner of studying and ascertaining
points
on which we could find an understanding as well as those on which we differed.

From that time on, that has been the pattern of the study.
Each National
Commander since has instructed the staff and the Commission to make the
studies on that basis.
Those are the steps that led up to the analysis which you now have in your
hands.
It is
probably an effective way since we have heard from the White House that when
this report
came there, they were very much interested in it and, as Mr. McGrail
has said, it is under
study by the Executive Assistant who is in charge of all of these commission
reports for the
President.
What the outcome will be, we will have to wait and see, but we will keep you
advised as soon as we have something on that.
CHAIRMAN MILLER:
Ladies and gentlemen, I have no temptation to correct or
scold, but it is my belief that many of us do not receive the issues of
the National Legislation Bulletin.
I have said repeatedly -- and I am not without experience -- that the
work
of the Legislative Commission and particularly, of course, of the staff
under Mr. Kennedy
with whom I am in contact personally, not every week but many weeks
throughout the year,
is of great value.
You read the issues as I do of the Rehabilitation Commission and you
read
them avidly, but I plead with you to make an arrangement to subscribe,
at a very modest
figure, for the Legislative Bulletins.
Without them you are not going to be soundly informed of the magnificent job being dome by your associates in Washington
and those of the
commission chairmen.

Mr. Luhrs of Michigan found it impossible to be here today.
It would, I think,
have been his first meeting or conference of a national character in
the field of legislation
as the current Chairman, but I feel
that you are not sufficiently continuously well grounded
in the great work being done by the legislative field, and I beg and
plead with you to get
on the band wagon and receive these issues twice a month.
I am an old hand at this business, both legislative and administrative, and I wouldn't be without it for
anything so long as
I can afford to receive it for something like $3 a year.

And now I want to offer you the man who runs the vessel here in
Washington in
the great ocean of legislation.
I have perhaps not said it to him but I have said it to
Cap Olson, that I think they have done a grand job.
I know you are going to be deeply
interested.
Can't
Mr.

speech

for

I

sell

you

this

Bulletin,

boys

and

girls?

Kennedy!

MR. MILES D. KENNEDY:
Thank you, Watson.
My good
me insofar as the Legislative Bulletin is concerned.
CHAIRMAN

MILLER:

Don't

make

me

out

better

than

I

friend,

think

you

have

made

my

I am myself.

MR. KENNEDY:
Chairman Bob or Mr. Rehabilitation, as I know you all call him,
and we do too:
I want you to know I appreciate the courteous invitation you extended
to
say something to you this morning.
First off, I want to offer the best wishes of my Chairman, Herman Luhrs, who unavoidably cannot be at the Conference,
much as he would like to.

At the beginning I want to express not only to Bob McCurdy
but to T.O. Kraabel,
your very able Director of Rehabilitation, Charlie Stevens,
Ed McGrail, Cecil Munson,
John Corcoran, the good doctors, Andy Andresen, and all the members
of the staff, without
exception, the thanks and appreciation of the members and staff
of the National Legislative
Commission for their always fine cooperation.
The only time I ever disagree with any of the
fellows in the Rehabilitation Commission is on Tuesday nights
when we have our bowling cone
tests and, of course, they being about twenty-five years younger
than I, (with one exception),
they take me over the hurdles a little bit, but it is all forgiven
by eight-thirty that night.
-112-

Now, I want to say to you, ladies and gentlemen, with all the sincerity of
which I am possessed, there is no group in The American Legion for which I have more respect
than you good people who work in the field of rehabilitation, you service officers, rehabilitation officers and others affiliated with the service which you and your associates perform.
After all, 1 feel the work you do is really the backbone of The American Legion
and I know the tremendous amount of work over the years that our good friend Watson Miller
has done in this connection, not only as a member of the official family but since he terminated his very able services with the National organization.
So, as I say, we of the
Legislative Commission salute you.
We commend you and congratulate you for the very fine
and exemplary record that you have established over the years since our organization was
founded.
While you are here, ladies and gentlemen, I do hope that, in spite of your
very busy schedule, you will find a little time, not too much, perhaps, but a little time to
80 up and see the members of your Congressional delegations on the Hill.
Without exception,
they know that you are in town and they are very happy and very glad to see you, and if they
know you go home without having dropped in to see them, either on the floor or in their
respective offices, they are going to be disappointed.
I have had many of them express the
wish to me during the past couple of weeks that I extend their invitations to you.

\

Actually, I am not going to tell you experts, with your professional staff here,
anything about your bills and their context or what they seek to attain because those matters
have already been fully covered or will be covered by men far more able than I am to do it.
I don't profess to be an expert in the rehabilitation field so, with that statement, I will
try to tell you a little something about legislative procedure.
As you know from what you have been told, what you have read in the papers and
the data received from Mr. Kraabel's office, hearings were held by the Veterans Affairs
Committee, the full committee, the day before yesterday on sixty-seven bills.
These were
bills dealing with compensation, pension, adjustment of widows' rights and various adjustments for the service-connected as well as for the nonservice-connected.
Many of these
bills, of course, we are not directly interested in or concerned with.
Nevertheless, in
keeping with the letter received from Mr. Teague of Texas, Chairman of the House Veterans
Committee, during the course of the testimony the day before yesterday there was filed what
I think was a very fine statement prepared by the staff of the National Rehabilitation
Commission covering each and every one of the bills.
I can't tell you right now when further hearings will be held before the
Veterans Affairs Committee on the remaining legislation in which you are interested, emanating from your National Rehabilitation Commission through the medium of resolutions adopted
at your 1955 National Convention or by the National Executive Committee.
The hearings now
going
on have been held in the mornings, and in the afternoons, which is an exception
to the rule on the Hill.
Most hearings only run from ten to a quarter of twelve, but Mr.
Teague has been conducting these hearings mornings and afternoons in an endeavor to get
through as much legislation as possible at an early date.
In the field of Americanism, I feel that the most important thing that will
come up this year is the attempts being made. by our opponents to either amend or materially
weaken the McCarran-Walter Act.
That, as you know, has to do with immigration.
Now, The
American Legion has gone on record continuously as opposing either the repeal of the Act
in toto or enactment of what we call weakening amendments.
Some hearings were held last
November before the Subcommittee of the Senate Judiciary Committee.
At that time Senator
Kilgore was Chairman.
Of course, you know he died three or four days ago.
Just when the
Committee hearings will be resumed, I do not at the moment know.
Of course, there will
have to be a new Chairman of the Committee appointed.
Then, in addition, some other bills
have recently been introduced as the result of the President's message to Congress, wherein
he asked for certain drastic amendments to the Act.
Those of you who are interested in that particular subject, immigration and
naturalization - will want to keep posted and, as Watson told you, the best way I know that
you
can do it is through the medium of the National Legislative Bulletin and the Americanism
Commission.
The Director of that Commission sends out information to the department officers
from time to time as it becomes available.

resolution
education.
you things

Another thing that is going to be very important to you
passed at the 1955 National Convention in the field of no
I am going to say something I may be criticized for, but
straight from the shoulder.

this year is the
federal financial aid
I believe in giving

We have received numerous letters from men and women in The American Legion,
complaining about this resolution.
I know that you are familiar with the fact that we of"
the Legislative Division have absolutely nothing to do with fixing legislative policy.
We
take our policy from resolutions adopted at either a National Convention or at meetings of
the National Executive Committee.
For years, The American Legion has gone on record as
-113-

|
to

opposing federal financial aid to education on the ground that
we do not want federal
control -- in other words, the theory being that if the Federal
Government gives the money
it will want to exert control over the education curricula, and so
on.

Previously, the National organization had a
resolution to the effect they
objected to federal financial aid to education except those
statutes which were already of
. record, and the necessary appropriation bills which have to
be enacted annually by Congress
to enable those pieces of legislation to be carried on.
That resolution was adopted at the 1954 convention.
However, at the 1955 convention the draftsmen of the resolution were very careful to exclude
-- I want to repeat that,
very careful to exclude -- the provision to the effect that they
did not object to the continuation of appropriations for legislation already of record.
I don't like to read things and I know that you don't like to have
people read
excerpts, but I am going to ask your permission to read in this
instance so that there will
be no misconception.
I am reading from a copy of the resolution itself and when I
read ic,
I want you to note that there are only two things that we can, support.
Now, if you
Legislative Commission.
1956 convention.
Here

is

the

"RESOLVED,

have any objections, don't make them to me.
Don't make them
Go back and take care of it at your NEC meeting in May or at
excerpt
That

the

from

the

National

to the
your

resolution:
Commander,

National

Legislative

Director

are

hereby directed and mandated to present the position of The American
Legion
to the Congress of the United States as above set forth, and to
vigorously
oppose all legislation seeking the destruction of state control
or making
appropriations of federal funds for the needs of general public
education;
or which in any way violates the principles enunciated above; provided
that
this: shall not affect existing legislation providing for surplus
agricultural
commodity donation to the public schools (there they mean ladies
and gentlemen,
the lunches) or existing legislation providing for financial assistance
to
critical defense areas."
Now, that, my friends is the resolution.
Many
plaining about the passage of the resolution and telling me
other thing.
When we have a resolution we have to carry it
and I only wanted to take the liberty of getting that point

of you have written in comnot to do this, that or the
out to the best of our ability
over to you.

The next thing that is very important
in the field of Americanism is UNESCO
and I am certainly not going to get involved in that argument.
A hearing is scheduled before
the Subcommittee of the House Foreign Affairs Committee on Internationa
l Organizations and
Movements on March 7th, at which time our people are prepared to
testify.
In the field of National Security and the National Security Commission,
you
will be happy to learn there will be no action taken so far as
we know at the moment on
Universal Military Training this year.
Of course, the National Security Commission of
The American Legion is doing everything it can to cooperate to
the end that boys will join
up in the program that we have advocated for many, many years, and
of course there was a
bill enacted into law during the last session of Congress but it is
not nearly as strong
as The American Legion would like to see it.
It contains no compulsory provisions.
Another piece of legislation the National Security Commission is vitally
interested in is the question of whether or not American ships shall
carry at least 50 per cent
of the surplus commodities that go to foreign countries.
Of course, those who come from
agricultural states do not like that law.
Those who do not come from agricultural states
like it.
However, The American Legion is on record as asking for the continuation
of the
present law which calls for at least 50 per cent of the cargoes in
that category being
transported in American ships.
;
,
.
Your National Security Commission is also vitally interested in the
field of
civil defense.
We feel that too many in higher échelons of government are Just sleeping
at the switch.

Going now to the Economic Division, I heard Ed McGrail, who was
speaking as I
came in, talking about some items that may come up in Civil Service
and advocated by the
Hoover Commission.
As you know, there was distributed to you some time ago a pamphlet
prepared by the various staffs of The American Legion on this subject
and it is pretty well
covered.
It shows each and every one of the Hoover Commission recommendations,
what our
position is on each, if any.
I presume that has already been mentioned here.
According

to

One of them may or may not come up tomorrow.
I can't tell at the moment.
reports that are in the press, and what I have been able to find out,
certain

-114-

gentlemen who are members of the House Subcommittee on Appropriations handling the Independent
Offices bill have indicated they would like to see a rider attached to the bill for the
Independent Offices to the effect that greater retention rights be granted nonveterans than
are nov in the statutes, when it comes to reduction in force and what they call 'bumping'" ox
retention rights of a veteran over a nonveteran.
:
_
Of course that is along the lines of the big row we had two or three years ago
when they sought to attach legislation to an appropriation ''rider'".
We were able to defeat
it when the bill came out to the floor but many of you have heard me tell you this.
I ask
you to warn your friends and alert yourselves -- many of you who are in federal civil service
- if the veterans in federal service don't get off their seats and do something, and do it
soon, your Veterans Preference Act is going right off the statute books.
There is absolutely no interest shown; I am dumbfounded.
I just can't understand it.
We had this fight three years ago on a similar matter.
A certain gentleman from
California took me over the coals on it.
We called for help right here in the District of
Columbia where we have hundreds of thousands of veterans working in the field of federal
civil service.
Many of them live in the District; others live in Virginia and commute here,
and others live in Maryland and commute.
How many came forward and offered to help -- and
their own bread and butter was concerned?
I will tell you.
Four.
Just four.
And that
same condition exists throughout the other forty-eight continental departments, so help me.
But just as soon as this Veterans Preference Act of 1944 is either thrown off
the books entirely or materially amended or weakened, then they will 'cry to high heaven,"
so if you have any friends or any members of your family interested in that, they had better
get busy and don't be telling me, or don't be giving me the alibi that you are afraid to
write your Senator or you are afraid to write your Congressman.
I made a test one time €wo or three years ago.
They were coming into our office
in droves.
I told my secretary:
"Remind me that as the next fifty men come in on a particular bill to ask each and every one of them if he took the time and trouble to write his
Senator or Congressman."
One fellow out of fifty had.
He said, "That is what we are paying
you for."
1I said:
"If that is all the help you will give yourselves, that is about all
the help you are going to get."

expected

to

We have a two-man staff in the National
do all these things.
You had better see

Legislative Commission and they are
somebody about giving us some more help.

Now, we have also asked to be heard on bills which, in keeping with our resolutions, would extend the GI Home Loan Program to July 25, 1960. Of course, we have had
many miscellaneous bills introduced in keeping with resolutions adopted at NEC meetings and
the National Convention.
I presume our Rehab representatives have already spoken to you
about the Bradley Commission.
I understand they are supposed to report sometime this month,
but you can be sure whatever comes out is not going to be good as far as we are concerned.
On the Hoover Commission, there have been no hearings on any of the bills except
one in the House last summer and it never got out of Committee.
No plans have been introduced
affecting veterans up to date, anyway, as was done back in 1950 and 1951.
There are over
three hundred bills in and I know Ed McGrail has talked to you in detail about them.
There is only one suggestion that I have to make, ladies and gentlemen.
When
you are talking against any of these bills that emanate as a result of the Hoover Commission
recommendations; a grave mistake was made, and made absolutely unintentionally, during the
campaign of 1950 and '51.
When many of our good people went out to make talks they said:
"I kicked the heck out of the entire Hoover Commission when I talked last night."
That is
the worst mistake they could make because, after all, that gave the smart boys in the publicity
division of the then Hoover
Commission the opportunity to say that The American Legion was
kicking the blank-blank out of the entire Hoover Commission report and all of its recommendations.
Of course, they couched their language in such a way that anybody not conversant with
the facts would think they had reference to the National Commander or your National or
department officers instead of Commander Joe Doakes who might have been talking in a meeting
of only fifteen or twenty people.

of

the

Let's not
recommendations

permit that to
we support and

happen again.
Of
those we oppose.

course,

you

have

already

been

advised

My good friend Watson has already covered what I was going to say on the
Legislative Bulletin.
We do hope that you will show an interest in it because, after all,
it is the only way I know that we can get to you quickly the status of your legislation as
it progresses throughout the year.
The cost is $3 for the calendar year; it is issued every
other week while Congress is in session and every month while Congress is not in session.
There are several copies on the table outside and Cap Olson and I would appreciate it if you
would help us.
;
We

have

to

run

the

Bulletin

without

one

-115-

nickel

of

expense

to The

American

Legion

--

go

to

the

General

Fund.

It

is

all
be GR

end of the year does
in Indianapolis.

a

OB

In the way of Congressional appropriations, of course nobody is ever satisfied
with the appropriations granted by the Congress.
Hearings have been held on practically
all of the bills we are interested in before the House Subcommittees on Appropriations and
if they retain the amounts as written in, I have been told by our respective divisions
they
will be satisfied.

"i

A

Now, for the information of you ladies and gentlemen who may be attending one
of these conferences for the first time (of course, I know you old-timers know this
as well
as I do and I do ask you to bear with me).
I would like to take a brief minute just to go
over the steps involved in legislative procedure.
As I told you before, not to be repetitious,
we of the Legislative Division do not fix policy.
Where do we get it?
We get it from
resolutions that are adopted at National Conventions or at the meetings of the National
Executive Committee.
Most of those come out of the spring meeting or the fall meeting.
Very
few, if any, emanate from the NEC meeting held in conjunction with your National
Convention.

-

|
{
!

a

as

Sl

I am pleading with you, and I mean it with all the sincerity I possess, that
you keep in mind a problem that has confronted our last three or four National Commanders.
They have urged that when you go as delegates to a National convention, or you have
any
influence with your friends who go as delegates to National conventions, especially
if they
become members of committees serving at the respective National conventions, and consider
resolutions that come up to stop passing. resolutions that have absolutely nothing
to do
with a veterans' organization.

That is the worst problem we have with Congress today.
I can show you letters
from men in Congress who are 100 percent Legionnaires, who are 100 percent in
our corner,
who have been in Congress since the early 1920's, who are pleading with us to stop
going
up there advocating legislation which has absolutely nothing to do, not only with
a veterans'
organization but with the program of The American Legion.
That
your time to give
do it, with these

is the greatest stumbling block you have today.
I am not going to take
you some of them.
We go up there time and time again because we have to
non-germane resolutions, pleading and asking for legislation.

So, you can be of great service, ladies and gentlemen, when it comes to these
National Conventions, if you will stand up and be heard.
Advise your people, and ask them:
"What has this resolution to do with the National organization of The American
Legion?
Is
Is it bad for it?"
it good for it?

Now, let's call a spade a spade and go down the line.
Of course some few blame
the National Executive Committee more than the members of the convention committees
because,
after all, a lot of these people are new at these conventions, and it is the first
time
they have served on committees handling convention resolutions.
Another thing members of the National Legislative Committee urge is that you
talk to your National Executive Committeemen and request them not to pass resolutions,
especially at the fall meeting of the NEC, three, four, five or six weeks after
the National
convention, where those same resolutions came up at the convention, were defeated,
and defeated
soundly, but the advocates go to the NEC meeting a month later and have them adopted.

:
Any resolutions that are not enacted into law at the time Congress adjourns’
this summer or this fall, whenever it will be, go out the window unless
they are reenacted at
your National convention this summer or at the fall meeting of the National Executive
Committee,
and that is a good thing, too, ‘and I hope you will forget an awful lot
of them and not renew
them.
I am not referring to the Rehabilitation Commission, because in all
sincerity they
are, with very few exceptions, the type that we can support in good conscience,
but some of
these others, my friends, are honeys.
Another thing that bothers us véry much today, ladies and gentlemen
-- and this,
again, doesn't apply to you; probably I shouldn't even be mentioning it.
It is like the
priest or rabbi or minister getting up and complaining about the poor
attendance at church
services.
He should be giving that sermon somewhere else, not to those who are here.
After
all, those who are here show their interest.
For your information, I would like to say,
thru the good office of Nick Lynch, who is in charge of the Field Service,
we caused a survey
to be made that covered thirty-five or thirty-eight of the Departments,
to see whether or
not there was any legislative interest.
There is absolutely no interest in legislation at all.
Let's get in on the line.
Absolutely no interest at all in nine out of ten
of the Departments.
We can't even get a legislative chairman named from many of the Departments until the year is half gone.
Up to a couple of weeks ago we didn't have names from
as many as sixteen -- as high as sixteen -- of the forty-nine Departments
including the
District
of Columbia.
How

do

you

expect

to

get

through

a

legislative

-116-

program

when

we

can't

even

get

a

at the
office

2, al” ph

but anything that is left
sent to the Comptroller's

‘

the name of the legislative chairman in many of the Departments?
Many of those departments
sent in reports to us and said, 'We are not interested in that.
All we care about is legislation in our own
legislatures
or assemblies,’ or whatever they may be.
'Let the fellows
down in Washington take care of it" -- and then you wonder why we don't get further with
your Federal legislation.
I appreciate the fact that it is the most natural thing in the world that you
are interested in your town or county or municipal or state legislation, much more so than
you are in federal legislation, but after all, I want to bring that out to you, and I am
not criticizing anybody here or anybody in the Rehab Division because, after all, if it
wasn't for you good folks, and especially those interested in the field of legislation, we
would be in a much worse fix than we are today.
There is absolutely no reason why our
accomplishments up on the Hill couldn't
be much better than they are, absolutely no reason, - but when it comes to legislation I know
what happens to that.
I have held every office, outside of chaplain, from a Post officer
up to Department Commander, and I know legislation goes to the bottom of the heap.
'We will
take care of it at the next meeting," or '"the devil with that," but let a law be enacted taking away some benefit from somebody or his son or daughter or father or an immediate member
of the family, oh boy, they come in crying to high heaven and then you remind them:
"All
right, we have been sending you bulletins and communications warning you of that."

They

say:

"I

I am talking of men
didn't
read it."

in

official

capacities

in

Posts

and

Counties,

or

Departments.

I had a visitor from one of the eastern states (it wasn't New York) and he peeled
me for twenty minutes and didn't give me a chance to open my mouth.
I knew he was a District Commander and finally I said to him, "Did you get the latest Legislative Bulletin?"
He

said,

I said,

'"Yes."
"Do

you

He

said,

'No."

I

said,

'"Can

He

said.

you

ever

spare

read

it?"

me

four

minutes,

after

peeling

me

for

twenty

minutes?"

'"Yes."

I called my stenographer and said, "Get me all the Legislative Bulletins issued
since the first of the year on this subject."
There were six issues uf the Bulletin, each
containing a paragraph or more on the very subject that he was complaining about.
He didn't
have time to read it.
I said, "Then why are you serving as a District Commander if you are
not interested?"
That goes on all of the time, ladies and gentlemen.
As I said before, we do
the best we can.
We did have three men on our staff, Cap Olson, Bert Davis and myself, but
Bert was taken away from us last May to work on a special assignment for Past National
Commander Don Wilson's committee dealing with the Bradley Commission and we have not had the
benefit of his service for one hour since.
In

addition,

our

clerical

staff

has

also

been

cut.

Just a word on members of Congress, and the number of veterans in Congress.
Of course, as you know, there are supposed to be ninety-six Senators.
At the moment we have
only ninety-five, due to the recent death of Senator Kilgore, and of that number, there are
forty-seven Democrats, forty-seven Republicans and Senator Morse of Oregon who votes most
of the time with the Democrats.
. Out of that number, fifty-nine are veterans and of the fifty-nine, fifty-eight
belong to The American Legion.
The only gentleman who does not is Senator Bennett of Utah
and the boys out there have been working on him for some time.
If any of you fellows from
Utah have any success with the Senator later on, I would appreciate your letting me know.
Over in the House, with 435 members, again we have one vacancy due to the recent
death of Congressman Reed of Illinois.
There are 232 Democrats and 202 Republicans.
Out
of that number, 239 are veterans and of the 259 veterans, 243 belong to The American Legion.
Legionnaires

Now, many people, as soon as we
in the Congress, say: "You must

come
have

up with
a cinch

that many veterans and so many
getting our bills through."

Nothing could be farther from the truth, my friends.
General John Thomas
Taylor, my predecessor, if he were here, would tell
you the same thing from his many years
of experience.
I will tell you why.
You can't take it for granted, just because they wear
The American Legion button, they are going to buy The American Legion Program.
Again it is

-117-

a question, and it has been so stated in the Congressional Record, they know how easily
resolutions are adopted at a State convention and also at a National convention,
and they
also know -- and this too has been in the Congressional Record -- how many of those are
not
germane to or have absolutely nothing to do with a veterans’ program, so they
don't worry too
much about them in many instances.

very,

The other reason
few exceptions, to

very

is they know there is no such thing as
haunt them when they seek reelection.

a veterans'

vote

with

Now, for the last and most important feature we have in the field of legislation
this year. I am not going to go into detail on the bill H. R. 7886.
I presume you have
been talked to about it during the week.
I know the National Commander is going to talk
about it tonight.
I have seen a copy of his speech, and it is not my intention to go into
any of the mechanics or details of what is in the War Veterans' Security Bill, so I will
confine my remarks to legislative procedure only.
I do again publicly want to thank the Congressmen who introduced these bills
at our request.
While we have used the official designation of H. R. 7886 to avoid duplication in referring to four bills and getting people confused, I think in all fairness
X
should compliment and thank the other Congressmen who introduced companion bills.
In the
House they have a rule that only one man can go on a bill.
We might have 150 or 200 members
of the House wanting to introduce and sponsor a bill, but there can only be ome bill
per
name.
Over im the Senate there is no limit to the number that can go on any bill.
I want publicly to thank these gentlemen:
Congressman Dorn, of South Carolina,
who introduced H. R. 7886 for us.
That is the bill we have heard so much about and we are
going to hear an awful lot more about it.
That is the official number we have been using.
Congressman Fino of New York put in H. R. 8126; Congressman Van Zant of Pennsylvania introduced H. R. 8406, and Congressman Christopher of Missouri who introduced H. R. 8111.

You will notice, ladies and gentlemen, there are two Republicans and two
Democrats.
We always try to keep it on a parity on both sides of the aisle.
As you know,
also, very bitter debate took place in Miami on this subject; three resolutions were enacted
and then you come down to the November, 1955 National Executive Committee Meeting and
these
three resolutions were rolled up into one, and at the same time a resolution was adopted
making this legislation
the No. 1 legislative priority program during the current session of
Congress.

Veterans'

You also know hearings were held the day before
Affairs Committee at which time National Commander

yesterday before the
Wagner testified.

full

House

i
Now, there is one thing I would like to kill right
now and here.
There is a
rumor going around, and I don't know where it emanated from, that this bill is going
to
slide right through the committee.
Just bury that rumor face down and cover it six feet deep.
We are going to have very, very tough going, ladies and gentlemen.
I don't mean to infer in
any sense at all that we are going to get a licking.
I think we have every reasonable chance
of getting the bill out of Committee.
We are, however, going to have to do an awful lot
more fighting than we have done up to date, and letter-writing, especially by The American
Legion.
So far 99.9 percent of the letters coming in to the twenty-four members of the
House Committee have been from the Auxiliary.
Many of the Departments think it is sufficient for the Department Commander and
the Department Adjutant to send in a letter.
Fine, we compliment them for doing it, but that
is not enough.
I have conferred personally with twenty-two of the twenty-four members of the
Committee.
The reason I didn't cover the others was that Cap Olson took care of one and the
other gentleman has been out of town until the day before yesterday.

Congressional

Some of those on the Committee didn't
districts but they did have a lot of

have one God-blessed letter
letters from other States.

from

their

I am not going to embarrass anybody by telling who they are or what States
they
are from, but I can name you six of the twenty-four who didn't have one single letter
up to
last Friday from the Congressional Districts they represent.
How do you expect people on
that Committee to put through legislation in which The American Legion is interested
if
somebody doesn't take the time and trouble to send them at least a post card urging enactment of this or a similar bill?
So, I say.I don't know who started this rumor --it may have been started by
some of our opponents.
It is an old trick.
I have pulled the same stunt myself when occasion
warranted, but whoever started that rumor is not doing The American Legion any good and
it
is absolutely false when this rumor says: "there is nothing to do, it is going to slide
right through."
Well, you are not going to be in the position of seeing this slide right
through.
We are going to be thrown out before we reach first base if we don't get off our
seats and do something about it.
-118-

I want to congratulate those departments that are working.
I am especially
grateful to the members of the Auxiliary for the magnificent job they do, and I do urge
those representatives of the other Departments who have done practically nothing up to date
to get busy, because as I said before, if Congressmen don't hear from you, don't expect them
to vote for your bill.
Now, of course, the best type of letter to send to a Congressman is your own
personal letter.
He doesn't care whether you write it on a post card, how bad the Language
- is, or how poorly composed it is.
That doesn't interest him.
What interests him is that
some uf his constituents, his or her constituents, took time out to write to him or her about
that particular piece of legislation.
And as to form letters, save your time and trouble
on form letters.
Do you know where they go?
The nearest waste basket in the office of the
Senator or the Congressman whose clerk opens that mail.
The form letter goes right in that
waste basket, the nearest one he can reach.
That is the end of that.

good
Nine
they
job.

Petitions are all right but they are not too good.
They are not nearly as
as your individual letters.
These people want to hear from their constituents back home.
out of ten members in the House are going to be candidates for reelection this year and
will pay attention to your letters.
Some departments, as I say, are doing an excellent
:

When I go up to their offices, some of the Congressional secretaries on the
list shake their fists at me and say, with a smile, "You are causing us a lot of work.
We
are breaking our backs getting out replies."
Such complaints I love to hear, but when you
go into some of the offices and they say, "Kennedy, I have no mail," then, I don't like it.
I went in to see one Congressman last Thursday and he had only two letters, and he comes
from a big Department.
Two letters.
How do you expect that man to vote for your bill?
He
is lukewarm, and I don’t blame him.

say,

"What

do

If he gets
I care?"

a

lot

of

mail

he

is

going

to

vote

for

it.

If

he

doesn't,

he

will

So, those form ietters -- don't bother making them up.
They will be thrown in
the waste basket and you might as well throw them there before you start.
It is a good idea
to get somebody in your Post to see to it that three or four or five types of letters or
suggested types of letters are prepared so that they won't all read the same.
Get people to
sign them.
Get one fellow delegated to mail the letters.
Don't leave it to be done haphazardly.
The National Commander has asked for the appointment of a Department Chairman
on the War Veterans' Security Bill and, in addition the appointment of a Chairman in each of
the 435 Congressional Districts, so he can follow through on this thing.
I may be wrong, but
I think there are fifteen States or departments, with four or less Congressmen, so that job
shouldn't be too hard.

ment

officers

When you go home, my
to get busy on that

good friends, urge your
if they haven't done so

Department
already.

Commanders,

your

Depart-

What is the procedure on this bill, your War Veterans' Security Bill?
The first
step is to get the bill out of the House Veterans' Affairs Committee.
There are twenty-four
members on that Committee.
You may want to know the individual states.
If you do, see Cap
Olson or myself later and we will be glad to give them to you.
If we don't
go any further.
It dies
Committee and time is of

get the bill
right there.
the essence.

out
It

of
is

Committee that
very essential

is the end of it.
It
that we get that bill

Now, if we are fortunate enough to get the bill out of the House
Affairs Committee, it goes to the House Rules Committee and, judging from the
it is not going to be easy to get it out of the Rules Committee.
However, we
that bridge when we come to it.

doesn't
out of

Veterans'
past experience,
will cross

If we are fortunate enough to get it out of the Veterans' Affairs Committee
and out of the Rules Committee, then it comes on the floor for debate and vote, and if we are
lucky enough to get it through the House we will have to go through the same procedure in the
Senate, where it goes to the Senate Finance Committee.
Unfortunately, we have not been able
to have a Veterans' Affairs Committee set up in the Senate.
Our legislation there goes
either to the Senate Finance Committee or the Senate Labor and Public Welfare Committee,
depending on context.
:
Do

not

--

I

repeat,

do

not

--

write

to

your

Senators

at

this

time.

It

is

toe

early.
Some Senators get two and three and four thousand letters a week and if you send
communications in now, your people won't write again.
Wait until the time is ripe.
We will
' let you know when that is.
Confine your efforts at the moment to thé twenty-four members

of the House Veterans'

Affairs

Committee.

-119-

As I said before, and I want to repeat, if you can't take the time and trouble -and when I say that, ladies and gentlemen,, I am not talking about you good people here,
>
individually, but if The American Legion, the members, won't take the time and make the effort
to let their members of Congress know how they want them to vote on this legislation, don't
blame the members of Congress if they don't vote the way you want them to.
Also, this is a golden opportunity for many Departments to build up membership.
You can rest assured, my good friends, that our opponents (and they are legion), are
going to let the people of Congress know how they stand on this legislation and there
won't
be any question about a Congressman's getting a few letters.
They are coming in and we have
seen the propaganda coming in by thousands and thousands.
1 am sorry, Mr. Chairman, that I took so much time and if I said anything that
: hurt ‘anybody's feelings, I apologize, but let's call a spade a spade on this, my good friends.
We are going to put this bill through.
But, to do it, we must get out and fight and work.

Thank
one

of

you

very

much

for

your

extreme

you.

courtesy,

and

good

luck

to

each

and

every.

CHAIRMAN MILLER:
Every once in a while you spring a surprise on the old boy.
You leave me breathless.
You are an eloquent extemporaneous and very sincere speaker.
I
hope the knuckles on your right hand, your points of emphasis, are not too sore.

While I listened to Miles' very sensible and very important talk to you, I
have had a thought, with no suggestion from anybody.
I am going to pull a new one on you.
I want to tell you now that you are going to hear from Mr. McCurdy a little while later,
who also has a set of knuckles, internal knuckles, himself.
I don't know what he is going
speak abdut.

to

I got this idea.
If you think it is too bold, I shall have to take the onus.
But, if you think it is a good one, I shall be glad ‘to hear from you without any reservation.
I have taken chances before.
I would like to make it easy, after hearing Kennedy, for you
to be able to read the Kennedy-Olson newspaper at least twice a month.
Many of us carried
newspapers in our younger days in our own communities, but few of us, I take it, have become
subscription
managers; so, I am going to sit here during the luncheon period and give you
an opportunity to take subscriptions from me -- right here at this table.
I will record
your subscriptions to our newspaper.
I want
be

here

and

the

legislative

groupto

be

as

proud

of

you

as

Maybe somebody will bring me in a package of cigarettes
I don't think you will want to disappoint Granddad.

I am.
and

a

sandwich,

but

I will
.

I want to see the guy that I have always loved and respected, another one besides
Miles, the Editor of your Legislative newspaper, affectionately called Cap Olson.
He managed
to make every war that came along.
I had to leave my service as a captain and this guy comes
out a colonel, or something .ike that.
He must have something.
So, I give him to you for
a minute here.
Cap Olson!
MR. OLSON:
Thank you, Watson, Ladies and gentlemen, I did not expect to be
called upon to make any remarks here this morning and, after listening to my boss discuss
legislation, I know there is very little for me to say.
However, I would like to bring out
a couple of points.
Miles mentioned a number of members of the House Veterans' Affairs Committee
who received no communications from their constituents, and we were quite alarmed when, about
two
weeks ago, the man who introduced our bill, H. R. 7886, Mr. Dorn, advised us that he
was getting a lot of mail from California, Montana and Illinois and many other states, but
he didn't have a single letter from the Congressional district which he represents.
I turned
to our tally clerk to see how they stood on Legislative Bulletin subscriptions.
I think I
can say this vith due apologies to our goed friends.
The American Legion had two subscriptions
and the Auxiliary had four, and at that time the only medium of information that had been
used to ask for the correspondence was the Legislative Bulletin.
I think that indicates
the importance of it and shows maybe, why some of our failures come.
I want to say this, that under the some over four thousand paid subscribers
we now have, the Auxiliary contributes about three thousand of those.
In contrast to the
organization of The American Legion, the American Legion Auxiliary early in the fall advises
us of the names of their department legislative chairmen and we immediately go to work with
them.
I want to say a word or two about these letters and the value of the letters.
First of all, the Auxiliary, of course, are the ones who respond to our request.
This
morning I looked at a couple of hundred from members of Congress that had come to my desk,
all addressed to members of The American Legion Auxiliary; not one to a member of The American
-120-

Legion.
We have asked the American Legion Auxiliary, when they
the members of Congress, regardless of what the issue might be,
us so that we may have an opportunity to observe the statements
to note any trends.

received their replies from
to send those letters on to
of the various members and

Now, Miles mentioned that I went to see one of the members of the House Veterans'
Affairs
committee.
The reason he sent me is because the fellow is a died-in-the wool
Republican and an ultra conservative and comes from a nearby western state.
My home is
:
‘Montana.
I talked with him at quite some length about the bill and then he got into the matter
of mail.
He said, "You know, I have been receiving a great deal of correspondence from the
people in my state and many of them are my friends."
He
letters

to me,

said, "Recently I have noted
and you may be sure they have

that some very
great effect.

important

people

are

writing

Now, most of us here today are average people.
We come from all the states of
the land, but in these states there are fellows who have grown to pessibly more importance
than we have, particularly in the political field and, believe me, the members of Congress
certainly do listen to letters from men and women of that type.
I would urge that you get
the most important members of The American Legion in your communities to join with you
in
asking your Congressmen to vote favorably for our bill.
What value do these letters have?
I have already made the point re one Congressman.
There is another Congressman whose mail I look at very carefully because I know
him quite well and he comes from my own state.
In the early part of the series of letters
coming in, he was very noncommital.
Finally, he started getting so many letters that he
mimeographed a reply in which he set forth four or five or six points, such as "I don't know
what kind of bill they will come out with and, naturally, I can't say I will be for it until
I see it," and so on.

and
"I,

this
too,

But today, just before coming over here,
time it was a personal letter in an entirely
am in favor of H. R. 7886."

I showed a letter to Miles Kennedy,
new approach; in this one he said,

it

:
will

and

that

The mail
be very,

is what changed
very helpful to

his
us.

mind,

I

you

the

opportunity,

thank

very

much

for

ladies

gentlemen,

Watson,

to

say

and

just

these

keep

in mind

words.

CHAIRMAN MILLER:
Thank you, Cap.
You can tell from the spontaneous response
that the guys and gals like you and wish you every success as their fellow worker..
I started
as an employee with what is now T. 0.'s outfit.
Now I am going to let you have Bob McCurdy for a little while.
He is the most
outstanding loyal opposition that I have ever met.
Last Sunday I heard him stand up gently
but firmly to a group of probably the most outstanding physicians in our land, on several
items, and they liked it.
He would be a great ornament to any legislative body.
MR. ROBERT M. McCURDY:
Comrade Watson and Comrades:
I have no
to add to this report from the Legislative Committee but I was reminded of a
thought I would like to tell and then make just a few remarks.

pearls of wisdom
story that I

This was an incident that happened to me when I went down into Jack Korella's
territory and was on a flatboat going down the Platte River and the driver of the team that
was pulling the boat along was chewing tobacco.
He spat every now and then into the river.
I remembered how in my youth I played third base on my high school baseball team and at that
time I chewed tobacco because I was sure that to be a good third baseman you had to chew
tobacco.
My ideal at that time was Charlie Diehl of the Chicago Cubs, who I am sure some of
you remember.
He is in Pasadena now and helps us with our Junior Ball Team, incidentally.
I found out if you chewed tobacco on third
wet, that these boys slid in hands first and would take
had a method in my madness and we had many cut-outs for

base and would keep
their hand off.
So,
that reason.

the
1

bag

reasonably

I want to talk just a minute about some things here.
You all have seen in the
press that the total cost of this bill is $77 billion dollars to the year 2000.
How many
of you have ever seen any other cost of government projected to the year 2000 and publicized
to the American public? That is propaganda and a phoney, Comrades, and I will tell you what
the answer to that is.
My answer, of course, is that it is a phoney and it is a figure taken
out of the blue sky and projected when they talk about what it will cost if every eligible
veteran takes advantage of every benefit.
However, Let's say, all right, it is $77 billion, and I counter and say,
"Did you know that by that time the total national income will be $5 trillion 300 billion?
They say, "Where did you get that?"
Then I say, "The same place you got the $77billion";
except I say I have a good basis for mine, and here is the basis.
In 1890 the total cost of
-121-

veteran's benefits, as related to the national income, was 1.2 percent.
In 1955 the total
cost of veterans' benefits as reconciled to the national income is still approximately 1.4
percent, and the percentage isn't raised, so I have a 66-year table of experience.
They
don't have that, and if they are going to project veterans' benefits to 2000, I can project
the total national income to the year 2000 and it comes out $5 trillion 300 billion, and we
are still out 1 5 percent, which isn't too much for your veterans.
I'll tell you another thing to say when you are writing your Congressman.
I
agree with Miles so well; don't write him a form letter.
It is better to say, 'Dear Joe, I
live in your district and I know that you are vitally interested in what I think, and I want
to tell you that I am for H.R. 7886 because I think it is fair."
I mean, just a simple letter
of any kind is what he wants; let him know that you know what you are talking about, but don't
send a form letter.
Write him a personal letter.
They like that.
I tried this on a member of Congress the other day and they agreed with me.
I
said that this is just ordinary progress.
I commended highly the members of Congress for
their forward steps in the first session and I called to their attention that, "You passed
a bill and you increased the pay of all our classified active employees.
You took care of
all your foreign service employees, and in that same bill you took care of some other employees
whose economic destiny lies in the hands of Congress, and it was right that you
should
do
that.
TI am for that.
"And then you got around to it and you took care of all the postal employees
and you saw that they got an increase, and not only an increase but you raised materially
great many grades.
You made adjustments so that the relativity would be better and you
adopted fine personnel action for the postal employees, and I am certainly for that.
passed that
$22,500, so

"And then you get around to the Judiciary and the
bill," and I am sure you know that Congress raised
that percentage is good, too.

and

I said I was for that, too, and I commended them for meeting
their business and I said, "You are certainly entitled to it.

running

"And then you got around to some of
some of you don't know that.
You raised the pay
was less than $4100," and I said I was for that.

a

members of Congress and you
their salary from $12,500 to

their

responsibilities

your old retired folks and," I said, "probably
of retired annuitants whose sole income
"I am for taking care of the aged," I said.

"Now, you didn't get to us this time.
We veterans are always with you, and
sometimes we are left to the last, and we don't press too hard but we are insistent that we
take our turn, and now you have got down to your veterans and they are asking for a modest
increase from $15 a month to $26 a month"; and I asked them, "What would you do with $15 a
month?"
T pointed out that, relatively speaking, for a fellow who has $66, $15 a month or
$25 a month is just a heck of a lot of money.
''We anticipate that you are all going to
support this."
I got a favorable response to that approach. The American Legion 'is never going
to let them forget us, and we will be patient, we will be reasonable, but we must be insistent that, right along with these other adjustments that have been made, they recognize
these men, too.

tell

you

some

Well, that is
other angles

just one angle.
of how to answer

I have got a million of
the criticism you might

them and
have.

I wish

I could

Then, I would like to remind all of you that at Miami we made a commitment on a
roll call vote to help these men.
Primarily, we are helping a lot of men from the Big War,
and I am for that, of course.
It is quite a challenge, you know, for you men of World War II.
I am now talking to you younger veterans.
You have to remember that we boys in the Big War
had no readjustment allowance, no bonus worthy of the word, no general educational benefits.
We didn't have those things -- no housing benefits, and all those things that you have enjoyed.
They were given you on a platter.
It was because we worked hard and met in such meetings
as this and were determined that your lot was to be better than ours.

Certainly
Certainly
mission.

Now, with your great numbers, if you can get inspired, we will have no trouble.
I think that these men, when they are 65, deserve our best help and best support.
I am going to give my best help and best support to see that we accomplish this

That leads up to just the last point.
It is fine to hear Miles and Cap tell
you that you have to have Congress hear from you.
-If you will all write that down and make
it the first order of business when you get home, that will mean so much.
Don't let them
hear just from you.
Call on other fellows in your post, let your post Commander know about
it and really follow through on it.
I

have

boasted

about

this

group

to

all

-122-

other

divisions

of

The

American

Legion

and I know how envious they are of the rehabilitation section, and that is because we really
do our work.
We really produce something tangible for our veterans.
Now we want to produce
something tangible, so I ask you all, I plead with you all please to take it to heart and
please follow through and please do it.
It is right, it is fair, it will be well received
from their home town folks.
Now, won't you all do your best and let's go back there and let
Thank you very much.
Congress know what we want.

CHAIRMAN

=

of

the

MILLER:

Bob,

we

might

letter.

even

promise

to

vote

for

him

this

fall

in

part

For the benefit of those of you who dragged yourselves out of bed this morning
and felt you couldn't digest a breakfast, this session is fairly near its close and I hope
you are not too hungry.
You see, I am well versed on what sometimes goes on in high places.
Charlie Stevens came in here a while back and said he would like to talk for an hour on the
Hardy Bill.
I told him if he undertook to speak longer than twelve or fifteen minutes (and
he can speak) I would speak a couple of hours on the value of silence.
I brought this guy from Chicago a lot of years ago when the late and wonderful
Jack Hartman finally convinced him that when he does get mad about disappointing matters in
relation to the care of disabled veterans, he should learn to say ''Damn,'' on appropriate
occasions.
He did and I loved it.
Let's see if he can say it today.

e—"

SS

MR. STEVENS:
Thank you, Watson.
This brief discussion for the next three hours
relates to the bill which will provide, prospectively, benefits for survivors of servicemen
and veterans, a combined program of the Veterans Administration, Social Security Administration
and Department of Defense.
About that three hours, Watson said an hour, God bless him.
He is very tolerant, but my most tolerant Director, T. O. Kraabel, said twenty minutes, that
you would get hungry.

discussion
consider

of

Just a little while ago Miles Kennedy (and I am making this remark before my
this bill) said that congressmen know that the national conventions don't

resolutions

so

they

aren't

too

concerned

about

them.

Well,

as

he

said,

that

is

true about rehab.
Bob McCurdy and I had our first nightcap together in 1929 when he was
Chairman of the Convention Committee on Rehabilitation at Louisville.
This dedicated man,
down through the years, has seen to it, as has every Chairman of Rehabilitation, including
my distinguished Comrade Watson, that rehabilitation resolutions are considered by annual
National Conventions and are considered by the National Executive Committee very carefully
before they are approved.
.

not

a

For the past eleven years we have had dozens of the very finest minds in
rehabilitation in the country serve on the Special Department Service Officers'
Committee on
Resolutions pertaining to rehab at our national conventions and they look these
resolutions
over very carefully, believe me, before they ever reach the Convention Committee on
Rehabilitation and then there is such a vital interest in rehabilitation that I
know you all
will agree in the convention itself, every word spoken by whomever is reporting
as Chairman
of a Convention Committee on Rehabilitation is listened to most attentively.
line,

that

I know so many Past National
Commanders
have
seen to it that rehab is thought of.

beginning
We don't

with John Quinn on down
dismiss
the care of the

the
service-

man, the veteran and his surviving dependents with just a few brief remarks at a convention.
We think about them.
Watson Miller was my Chairman and Director for many years. T.0 Kraabel,
God bless him, has been my Director since 1941, and they have seen to it that anything
dealing with rehabilitation is thordughly thought out before any presentation is made.
That,
I want the Congress to know and I will assure the members any time that I go
up there, that
that consideration is given.

That leads me up to this bill.
Many people have asked me, Why on earth is The
American Legion supporting the Hardy Bill?
Why?
And this is the answer, because The American
Legion very carefully considered what the Hardy Bill, H.K. 7089 of the 84th
Congress would do.
We are interested in war veterans.
We are interested in dependents of the war veterans and
the survivors of the veterans who served in World War I, World War II and the Korean
Conflict.
This
Program

from
band

and

when

bill
we

is

found

a peacetime
that

the present payments they
wagon and supported it.

150

bill.

It

thousand

receive
-

to

is

widows

the

a bill

to

improve

and

children

will

benefits

provided

by

the

survivors'

benefit

this

benefit

by

election

we

got

bill,

on

the

Our distinguished Chairman, Bob McCurdy, and members of the Commission, with
some of us, including T. 0. and some of us on his staff, very thoughtfully considered what
The American Legion might do in advance of a National Executive Committee meeting held May

4-6-,

1955,

and our Chairman

numbered 102 which
without amendment,

not

support

presented

to the National

in twelve itemized points stated
the National Executive Committee

At that time
many features

the thinking of our
of the measure that

Executive

Committee

what The American
adopted it.

Legion

the

resolution

thought

and,

organization was that The American Legion did
had been proposed.
The result, however, of a
-123-

study of what the bill would do brought about the
at its national convention in Miami in October of

position that
last year.

The

American

Legion

declared

:
May I say this?
I believe that not only The American Legion has conscientiously
studied the survivors' benefits measure, but the people in the Congress who had the most
to do with this legislation gave it their most earnest consideration.
This isn't a hastily
passed measure.
In the 83rd Congress, on August 4, 1955, House Resolution 549 was adopted
to create a Select Committee on Survivor Benefits.
This select committee was to inquire into
In the 83rd Congress,
the programs affecting servicemen and former servicemen's survivors.
Bill Bates, World War II veteran of Massachusetts, was the Chairman.
With him were people
who really were interested in seeing what they could do to make a positive program suitable
to the needs of all of the survivors.
There was Tiger Teague of Texas, the Chairman of the
Committee on Veterans Affairs, in our book, the greatest committee in the House of Representatives; there was Pat Kearney of New York, second ranking member, then on the majority
side in the Committee on Veterans Affairs, a man who all through the years has been dedicated
to the veterans' benefit programs.
On it also was Representative Kean of New Jersey and then Porter Hardy of
Virginia.
Now, Porter Hardy was the Chairman of the Government Operations Committee Subcommittee in the 82nd Congress that gave long and earnest study to the VA administered insurance programs and came up with a recommendation which, through the House Committee on
Veterans Affairs and the Senate Finance Committee in the 82nd Congress, was enacted as legislation which scuttled our contract insurance programs prospectively and provided a serviceman's indemnity program.
;
The
tinued

to

American

insist,

both

on

Legion
the

at

House

that

time

and

Senate

was

the

sides,

only
on

veterans
the

organization

preservation

of

the

which

con-

contract

rights so that veterans could pay for something to leave their survivors in addition to
seeing that they were provided the gratuitous benefits.
Porter Hardy did accomplish his
purpose there but, believe me, I give the man credit; he thought well and long before he did
what he did and he thought long about what was done in the bill, H.R.7089, of which he is the
author.

In the 83rd Congress, Bill Bates had open hearings and executive sessions starting in September of 1954 and they came up with a voluminous report of what they found.
On
January 31, 1955, because the study was so exhaustive that the first committee -could not
complete it and make a recommendation, a resolution, House Resolution 35, was passed in the
84th Congress to create again a select committee to provide a basis for a further study of
these programs.
Porter Hardy was the Chairman.
Pat Carney dropped out.
Kilday of Texas
came on replacing him. Teague of Texas continued, Kean of New Jersey continued, and Bill
Bates of Massachusetts continued.
This committee had fifty-seven sessions.
They had twenty-nine open hearings
and twenty-eight executive sessions.
The committee had a counsel, just one counsel and a
stenographer working with it.
They were aided by government agenciesconcerned;
there were
two experts from VA, two from the Department of Defense, two from the General Accounting
Office, two from the Bureau of the Budget, and two from the Social Security Administration.
They found it necessary to employ an actuary and engaged a New York firm.
They were aided
in their study by the thinking of The American Legion and other veterans' organizations.

again became
couldn't buy
ing, "Why is

The committee itself, when it was first created
a Select Committee on Survivor Benefit Programs
some of the things that are in this bill today,
The American Legion supporting it?"

in the 83rd Congress, when it
for veterans in the 84th congress,
so I can understand people ask-

they

They didn't buy
buy them if they

to the
doing.

had

to

some ‘of
were to

the things
do the job

but they
that did

came
need

point

that

they

knew

Now, in the creation of a select committee, something unique was done by the
;
House of Representatives.
This select committee was authorized, after its study, to report a
bill to the House.
That isn't a usual custom.
‘The reason for it is abundantly clear.
The
programs ‘created for the survivors of members of the Armed Forces and veterans who are
deceased covered many House Committees legislative-wise.
There are the primary programs of
death compensation, contract insurance and servicemen's indemnity administered by the Veterans
Administration.
The Social Security Administration is the responsible governmental agency
for administering the Old Age and Survivors' Insurance benefits.
The six-months' death
gratuity payment is administered by the various services of the Department of Defense.
The
Bureau of Employees' Compensation settles Federal employees' compensation claims.
In these
benefit programs administered by different agencies, different House committees are concerned.
The death gratuity is a responsibility of the House Committee on Armed Services,
VA administered programs of death compensation, contract insurance (USGI and NSLI), and the servicemen's indemnity are the responsibility of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs.
The Ways
and Means Committee is the body that considers legislation dealing with Old Age and Survivors’

Insurance

under

the Social

Security

Act.

The Education
-124-

and Labor

committee

deals

with Federal

Employees'

that
for

could
House

Compensation

You see,
obtain the

legislation.

with so many
thinking
of

House committees concerned, there was
the various committees and place into

consideration.

a need for one group
legislation something

SS

The legislation resulting from the careful study of these two select committees
over a nine-month period, H. R. 7089, was presented on a cloture rule by the Rules
Committee
of the House to the House, debated, and the bill passed on July 13, 1955.
There were questions
asked by members of the House about different features of this measure.

a

Careful thought was givem, I am sure, before any select committee was created
either in the 83rd or in the 84th Congress.
Now, it turned out that other House committees
were concerned because the Railroad Retirement Act came into the picture and that is legis-~lation that is handled in the House by the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce.

The measure itself is something to which I want now to address myself.
The bill
was referred to the Senate Finance Committee on July 14, 1955, and it has been
under study
of that committee since.
That committee, Miles Kennedy was informed, and he told T. 0. and
me, will probably have open hearings on about the middle of March.
We are going to testify
at that time and say that we still have some additional recommendations to
make to the committee.
After the NEC meeting of May, 1955 when The American Legion's position was stated,
it became obvious that the organization needed to assist in trying to prepare for legislation that would do the best possible job for survivors.
The then National Commander, bless
his heart, Seaborn P. Collins of New Mexico, said that he would urge the approval of
legislation of this character only if The American Legion had quite a bit to do with the preparing of the bill.
The first House committee print, a confidential committee print, came to
light on April 18, 1955.
A second print was made June 3, 1955.
Then Mr. Porter Hardy, the
Chairman, had open house
in his committee room for the recognized veterans' organizations
and other persons interested in the bill.
He then made known the featuresof the bill as
they were then in print, a completely tentative print.
The American Legion was represented
by Mr. Kraabel, Mr. Kennedy, some of us members of the staff and, boy, we were certainly
alarmed when we saw what that bill proposed to do.
We were terrifically disturbed.
On
Miles

Kennedy,

June 10, The American Legion, T. O. appearing,
the National Legislative Director, and the rest

stated its position
of us there.

with

Chairman Porter Hardy asked The American Legion's help in trying to work with
the committee in bringing out a good bill, saying that he wanted a good bill.
He wanted
to remove, he said, the valley of despair, as he called it, of the widow between
the ages
of 45 and 65 who was paid a paltry death compensation of $87 a month, not emough
for her to
live on.
He wanted to do something about that.
That had concerned him.
That is the age when
the kids are grown up and death compensation is paid her only as a widow, alone,
when probably
the contract insurance or indemnity payments have been terminated and she isn't old enough
to receive Old Age and Survivors' insurance benefits.
That was his idea, that something needed
to be done.
Another. idea that was obviously bought by all of the people that were there
was: don't discriminate between the survivors of members of the Armed Forces.
The Federal
Employees Compensation Act provided that certain members of the Armed Forces and their survivors, in the case of reseivists in peacetime, would be awarded disability and death benefits
payable by the Bureau of Employees' Compensation of the Labor Department.
Those benefits
became terrifically more valuable than the benefits paid under the VA programs, through
increased awards provided in 1949, so you had the regular or the emergency officer coming in
to do his job in the Korean conflict, and when he was killed or died as a result
of injury incurred in service, his survivors got only the VA awards.
The reservist got the
much better benefit payable by the Bureau of Employees’ Compensation.
They wanted to eliminate
this discrimation between survivors.

Now, five more minutes and then I am through.
Now, here is what this bill will
do -- and this is in conclusion.
First, there will be no more payments, prospectively, of
federal employees compensation, except as to those deaths before the enactment.
There will
be a revision of the basis for award of VA death compensation.
The Servicemen's Indemnity
program will be terminated, as we prophesied it would be when it was created by law.
A combination of the servicemen's indemnity and death compensation will be provided
as a benefit
known as Dependency and Indemnity Compensation.
There will be provided in the future, for veterans of the Armed Services, contract insurance rights only for those who have sustained a disability as a result
of service.
Instead of the $468 to $7656 six-months’ death gratuity being paid to specified
beneficiaries
of the serviceman who dies in service, there will be paid a six-months' death gratuity
but

it will

be not

less

than $800 nor more

than $3,000,

and

it will

no longer

be required

that

the death not be the result of the serviceman's own willful misconduct.
This will be paid
in any death and the bill demands that the payment be made promptly.
For 120 days after
service a man will still be protected; that is, the death gratuity payable presently
only to
-125-

survivors of members of the Armed Forces who die in service and in line of duty will be paid
to the dependents, the surviving spouse, child or children, parent, or brother or sister if
the veteran's
death is a result of service-conmected disability.
‘There is a provision made also in this enactment. For the Old Age and Survivors'
insurance payment now, instead of $160 wage credit monthly provided gratuitously between
September
1940 and this month, March 1956, there will be a contributory coverage for members
of the Armed Forces.
This is going to cost the military, on the present strength of the Armed
Forces, appro ximately 2,850,000 personnel, about $114 million a year.
There will be an equal
contribution by the members of the Armed Forces on the basis of their wages up to $350 monthly,
just

as

we

in

civilian

life

contribute.

This Old Age and Survivors' insurance coverage is a complement to the benefits
payable through the
Veterans Administration.
We have made sure that more veterans' survivors
are recognize d although this is peacetime measure and there are provisions of the Old Age
and Survivors' insurance program, that is, of the Social Security Act, which will take care
even of those people who did not benefit by the $160 wage credit gratuitously granted, and I
think this is something this select committee did in the bill that passed the House, that
is only right and just.
Already from the funds contributed to by workers and employers, there has been
paid out on t he basis of deaths in World War II and the Korean Conflict, $225 million.
This
committee proposes that, on the extended payment plan, of which we all take advantage on
occasion when we buy automobiles, houses and such, they will reimburse the fund from appropriations to the tune of $590 million.

Let me say that, on behalf of The American Legion, after careful study, thirtytwo recommendations were made and thirty-one of them were adopted by the House Select Committee
on Veterans Affairs before it reported the bill to the House on June 28, 1955.
We had full
opportunity to work with the staff, with members of the committee itself, and they know the
strength of The American Legion and they bought what we recommended.

gy

Now, in the hookup between the Veterans Administration, this "marriage" they
call it between the VA and the Social Security Administration, one thing that The American
Legion looked to was this, that the Veterans Administration remain an independent agency and
that there be no opportunity afforded for the Social Security Administration to absorb it.
That is one thing we did.
We saw that
Title II of the bill was administered by the Veterans
Administration, and that is what resulted from our approach.

I think I can assure you gentlemen that with the additional amendments that are
S enate side, the bill will provide the basis for payment of improved benefits
to the widows ,» children,
dependent parents of those who died in service in wartime or died
of the servic e-connected
disability incurred therein.
Although this is a peacetime measure,
there is a right of election for deaths prior to the date of its enactment and other provisions made
that take care of our people in whom we are vitally concerned.
made

on

the

Thanks,

Watson.

Thank

you

all.

CHAIRMAN MILLER:
Ladies and gentlemen, I thought that within the time limitation we had set here, some of you men and women could take these mikes, themselves, for
while.
I thought that some of our stalwart girls, who used to be prime fighters with us,
would have something to say, but they say they have not.

a

We have about five minutes.
Bob and Miles and Olson and the rest of them have
talked to you about the spontaneity of letters that we hope you will send from your districts,
particularly on H. R. 7886, the Security Bill for War Veterans.
I had some entirely false
esthetic internal mechanism that rejected in my thinking the idea of sending letters to
Congressmen from nearly under the dome of the Capitol.
But I have done it this time and I
have tried to make them spontaneous and a bit unusual.
Here is a short example of one of
those that has gone to several members of the ‘House:
"Information has reached me that the Veterans Affairs committee will shortly
have H. R. 7886 under consideration.
May I take the liberty of expressing
the hope that you will support the measure.
I am sure you will, knowing as
much as you do about the economic plight encountered by so many of the older
folks in our midst.
"1 was 39 years old when I entered the Army for World War
benefit under the terms of the bill because of income but
concern for the others.
Time travels on.
We cannot slow
Please help if you can."

bill

by

about

Off the record,
$60 of annual

I should like to say
income, so that what

I don't

that

think

any

of

you

can

that I would miss
I have said there

resist

the

appeal

of

I.
I would not
I do have deep
down the calendar.

the benefits of that
is not bragging.
the

National

Commander

-126i

a

and for the rest of us to get busy.
Time is of the essence now.
It is running out rapidly.
1 join Miles Kennedy in feeling that something will be done at this session
on that important
bill.
It is the most demanding- thing that we have before the Congress at the moment,
so let's
not sit back and let a few Georges do the job.

ag

this
have

one

Dr. William S. Middleton, the Chief Medical Director, will be here
afternoon.
His address will be interesting and I am pretty sure that many
an opportunity to ask the Doctor some questions.

Now,

on

subscription

from

there to start
on the right.

with.

this

legislative

each

state.

God

And

please

don't

newspaper
bless

let

business

Arkansas,

$3

deter

you,

here,
I

have

if

I would
one

you

from

have

at
of

like

to

our

friend

got

it.

one~-thirty
us will

have
The

at

least

Thompson

line

forms

I have a little story that will take about a minute or less.
A couple of lawyers
over here in the Barr Building were having a contest as to which one of them
had the dumbest
office boy, so they sent them out on an errand.
The boys happened to meet on the street.
One said to the
other, "I think my boss is a dumbell; he sent me out with a $5 bill
to buy
a Cadillac car for him and he didn't even tell me what color he wanted."
The other office boy said, "You have nothing on the fellow that pays
my salary,
He asked me to go over to the Metropolitan Club and find out whether
he was in the club, and
the damned fool was sitting at the telephone and he could have called
the club and asked them
himself."

this

Thank you very much for your sincere and meticulous attention
morning.
I think we have all in one way or another benefited from
The

line

starts

(The

meeting

on

the

adjourned

right!
at

twelve

o'clock.)

s—

iy

us

-127-

and kindness
what we have

to
heard.

Se

/
THURSDAY

AFTERNOON

March

the

I

The meeting convened
Commission, presiding.

think

these

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
meetings should

at

one-thirty

1,

SESSION

1956

o'clock,

Dr.

N.

R.

Booher,

Having a fetish with which the speaker of
start, and by the same token stop on time.

Vice-Chairman

the afternoon

of

agrees,

There was one thing I did notice in the audience this morning, that sometimes
you can't tell here at the rostum how the sound is coming to you in the audience, so if you
will indicate to us if we are not loud enough or if we are too loud and we are shouting at
you, we will try to adjust the microphone accordingly.

@

It is our annual privilege to hear from and speak to the people in the Veterans
Administration who each year, and at other times, perhaps are only names to some of you.
All
of us, whether we know these people personally or not, look forward particularly, I think,
to this Thursday afternoon panel because the medical programs of the Veterans Administration
do cut through every other program of the Veterans Administration. .

|

|

Without a long and flowery speech, I would like to say it has been my privilege
on several occasions to introduce the man occupying the post that our speaker today occupies,
and on those occasions when I have introduced Admiral Boone to this audience as the Chief
Medical Director of the Veterans Administration, I thought I could have the opportunity of
which I would never be more proud than in introducing him to you.
However, that proves the
word 'mever' in human existence should never be used, because today it is my privilege to
introduce to this audience a man whom I have known for a good many years in one capacity or
another, a man who not only brings a brilliant military record through two wars to his present
job but a man who is in close contact with clinical medicine in this modern day of the complexities of that subject.
From the State of Wisconsin, one of our Chiefsof the Medical Service during
World War II in the European Theater, long associated with the University of Wisconsin's
wonderful medical school, Chief Medical Director of the Veterans Administration, Dr. William
Middleton.
Dr. Middleton!
DR. WILLIAM S. MIDDLETON:
Dr. Booher, Confereesof the National Rehabilitation
Conference of The American Legion:
It is indeed a privilege to meet with you today on my
anniversary.
I say "anniversary" because one year ago I was inducted into this office and
my first public appearance was before the National Rehabilitation Conference of The American
Legion, so that in celebrating this anniversary I think it is entirely fitting that I should
at least have an opportunity to give an accounting of my stewardship of the past year.
When I came into this office of responsibility, I found that under my distinguished predecessor, there had been built a staffin the Central Office that has remained
unchanged -- a tribute to his leadership -- that there was in the field, in the Regional
Offices and in the various hospitals, delivering at the grass roots services to the veteran,
a very splendid medical staff.
Intermediate between those two was the Area Medical Director,
and in each instance, now multiplied to seven by the division at Columbus, I have found that
there was splendid staffing and excellent planning, so that the Veterans AdministrationDepartment of Medicine and Surgery, having taken as its objective and mission the best available medical service to every worthy veteran, can say that this is more than mere words; it
is an accomplishment to the best of our ability.
Last year I had occasion to cite to you three areas of particular importance in
our total program:
those related to tuberculosis, mental diseases and the problemsof the
aged.
Today I should like to report progress in each of the three areas.
In the first case,
the end of the year, 1951, there were 2292 veterans awaiting admission to our hospitals
for the tuberculous.
On December 31, 1955, there were 207.
This advance, ladies and
gentlemen, depends upon three circumstances: early recognition, the availability of antibiotic drugs, that are effective against tuberculosis, and surgery.
We must report that the
newer studies on the newest of these drugs that has had trial, cycloserine, indicated that
there have been some limitations; but by and large, the progress is material.
There is
definitely occasion for optimism but, as I cautioned a year ago, we do not think that we
have this formidable adversary on the floor, merely on the ropes; but we are pounding him
hard and are not losing sight of the ultimate eradication of a disease that I do not forsee
in the early future.
It may be generations removed.

for
the

The mission of these hospitals that are experiencing a decrease in the demand
tuberculous veterans must be reviewed from time to time.
That is the present status of
problem in our midst.
\

the
can

Turning to the mentally disturbed patient, there is an area of great promise in
tranquilizing drugs, sufficient experience to tell us that we have a medium by which we
bring these patients back to a plateau of improvement from which there can be projected
-128-

various methods of psychotherapy, occupational, and physiotherapy and
rehabilitate them faster.
However, again not cures, and it should be
advantage must be capitalized upon at its best.

other devices
stressed that

to
this

—

=

I envision, for example, a certain element of our hospitals for the mentally
ill will undergo a change in manning, a change in staffing that approximates that of the GM&S
hospital.
Our budget makers must be apprised of this circumstance because the cost per diem
may rise, will rise, I think inevitably; but the total cost per patient will, perforce decrease.
By this token there must be some readjustment of our total picture to bring us into
line with developments in this area.
Turning to the problem of aging, obviously we haven't
stopped the clock nor
turned it back, but we have made definite advances in the area of study.
It is important
that we project the future with the thought that .we may learn the better to delay, if not
prevent, certain of the processes of so-called natural deterioration that go with years.

can

certain

tell

whether

methods

in the specific

of

certain

staffing,

problem.

methods

methods

of

of

comstruction,

certain

distribution

of

patients,

medical

surgical

management,

have

their

and

|

yet
to

May I turn back one step to a consideration of another element that is not so
important in this respect but in respect to our problem of the neuropsychiatric patient. The
psychiatric evaluation program that was implemented last fall projects a very definite
design of studying the physical plant in which these patients are cared for, the staffing in
all elements, the various distribution of patients according to ward types, and so forth,
and the methods of treatment, both medical and surgical.
There is, ladies and gentlemen,
still no yardstick from which we can measure the improvement or the application of methods
in the mentally ill.
Now, this is a serious commentary upon the development in our knowledge
of mental diseases; but it is true nonetheless.
So when we, over a period of five years,
project this particular study it is with a design that we will create a base line from which
we

ly
i
i

application

|
ii
ih:

i

ih 8

:

So much for the projects of last year carried into the present and projected
to the future.
May I indicate to you that, as Chief Medical Director, I have been interested
primarily in the care of the veteran patient and I singularize it.
It is one patient.
When
I go into a hospital, my design is, of course, to observe certain physical elements, many
of which I am not qualified to evaluate.
I do like to go into the kitchens, into the mess
line, I like to go into the engineering elements of the hospital, the canteens; but I inevitably find myself at the bedside of a patient because, if I am not mistaken, the mission
is definitely designed for the care of the patient and hospitals, clinics, domiciliaries,
are designed toward improvement of the care of a veteran.

Il

Accordingly, I would .ike to relate certain isolated experiences as types.
1
believe that when the story is written of the contribution of the Veterans Administration to
the American citizen as a veteran, one of the most important elements will consist of the
manner in which our mentally ill have been treated.
I would like to take you to a hospital
and then witness the admission of a patient, assigned to a physician.
A team of psychiatrist,
psychologist, nurse, social worker, occupational therapist and physiotherapist will come into
the picture for the evaluation of that patient so far as his immediate treatment is concerned.
They will follow that same patient throughout his course, adjusting his treatment and the
various measures that will be applied.
Eventually in his improvement will come a period of
adjudication, mentally speaking, by which it will be determined whether he may become a
member employee; whether a trial visit is in order; whether foster home may be assigned.
Now, this is an extremely important concept because
skills into focus on the problem of one single veteran and it is
that same team follows him throughout his course.

it brings all
continuous in

of these
the sense

If we take it through the ultimate disposition in foster home care, I would
like to transfer the scene to one institution, Tuskegee.
At Tuskegee I found that in the
past five years there have been 160 veteran patients sent out under the foster home care
program.
First of all, the interest of the community, therefore, must be aroused.
It is
important that we keep clearly in mind that there is a human interest in the welfare of this
veteran.
The individuals who have volunteered to serve in this relationship come in and are
indoctrinated.
After this indoctrination and the assignment and the proper meeting with an
acceptance of the responsibility, the patient is sent to the home.
There are periodic visits
at stated intervals to Tuskegee and problems that are arising in the home are resolved at
first hand -- prophylactic if you please, before there is a real break.
In this period of five years, there have been sixteen of these individuals who
have been returned to the hospital.
In certain instances -- five, if my memory is correct -violence has been the basis of return.
In each instance the veterans in this particular
operation have been supported by the family and the attack or the violence was provoked by
an outside person, according to the family representation.
Now, in each instance they were returned to the hospital, I wish to make it clear;
what I wish further to emphasize is that the community, the family particularly, is behind
this movement, so that it is a distinct advance in the acceptance by the community of responsibility to the mentally ill patient.
It is acceptance of mental illness as an illness
-129-

Ll
|
|

|

fi

that

I would

leave

with

you

in

this

respect.

Turning to an entirely different relationship and to the Pittsburgh Veterans
Administration Hospital, I would like to have a word to say about the long continuance or the
duration of hospitalization that seems unreasonable to some of our fellows in civilian
medicine.
Actually, our mission, ladies and gentlemen, is different.
It is not enough for
a veteran with a fractured femur to have good alignment, excellent mending with the help
of nature, but we must rehabilitate him from a physical standpoint.
When we come to the
long-term patients, particularly in tuberculosis and the mental area, psychological rehabilitation is just as important, and how have we met this?
Aside from a very definite
studied approach in each of these fields, we have a program for the discharged patients.
This is particularly applicable for the long-term patient, let me say.
In Pittsburgh I sat
in on one of these panels.
The physician and nurse in attendance on an 8l-year old veteran
made full accounting of his course in the hospital.
Then there was the discussion by the
panel, first the physician, then a psychiatrist, a psychologist, a physiotherapist, occupational therapist, nurse and finally social worker.
All of the various elements involved declared
that they did not think there was any prospect of improvement. I am speaking from the
physical-psychological and the nursing standpoint.
When the matter was referred back, then,
to the leader, a physician, he said, "This 8l-year old patient, who has had a cerebral
accident, a stroke, has had some rcturn movement to his right hand.
I take responsibility
for rehabilitating him to the point that he may feed himself."

|
$

Now, friends, this is an aggravated instance, but I wish to leave with you the
fact that we feel that it is our responsibility to rehabilitate to the point of return to
full measure of that patient's capability, physically and psychologically, and the fact that
this medical man, Dr. Connor, took full responsibility for the maintenance of the care of
that patient, I think redounds to our eternal credit.
There is no civilian hospital that
can or will do that yet.
The future may find it.

I think that one of the most enlightening experiences I have had has been in
the NP hospital.
There we have patient councils made up, mind you, of patients from the
disturbed as well as from the other wards, ana wards where there are strict limitations of
the physical activities, with their full liberties on the other hand.
I have asked the
privilege of meeting with the patients' council as man to man.
I have gone in without any
member of the staff and I have simply said, "Now, this is my position.
Forget about that,
but I am anxious to know how things go with you."
I have been greatly enlightened by the
freedom of discussion.
The patient feels that there is a friend in court and he has his own
personal day in court.
We discuss complaints, real and fancied.
It is not too easy to get
the patient's viewpoint and I come away with the definite feeling that this is after the
American manner of approach.

{

In such connections,
ladies and gentlemen, it is distressing to find that in
certain of these patients there has been a complete lack of contact with the family and with
friends for as long as five years.
I found in one hospital a considerable group of patients
who had not seen one of their own comrades or a member of the family, for five years.
To
me, that is a serious indictment on the interest of our veteran groups as well as families
in the case of certain of these patients, detached completely from the community, therefore,
and building about themselves a barrier, a psychological iron curtain that is very hard to
break down.

|

Without extending these personal experiences,
I
should like to say that there
are three major areas of interest to all of us that should have some discussion:
first,
intermediate care.
We do not admit patients to our hospitals as intermediate patients.
We
have no desire to build intermediate hospitals.
An intermediate hospital is to say that we
commit ourselves to a deterioration of staff and of patient care.
Ladies and gentlemen, I
am not interested in two grades of medical care for American veterans and I will not take
responsibility for second-grade care for any American veteran.
In the next place, there is a consolidation of hospitals that has been undertaken
in the honest effort to see whether we may not do the same or a better medical job more
economically.
There have been five areas in which this has been effected after a pattern
that has existed for some years in three - notably, Augusta, Oteen-Swannanoa
and Aspinwall - Pittsburgh.
These five areas represent consolidation of common services in
the interest, frankly, of economy of personnel and of finances.
There is no design to
change the pattern of medical staff, which means that we shall continue in our plan of
giving the best that we have available in both hospitals entering into such consolidation.
There will not be a primary and a secondary hospital.
We cannot tolerate deterioration in
medical service, nor will we.
The pattern will fall of its own weight if there is any
suggestion of the same.

©

Then, there is consolidation of the Regional Office Medical Department or
Division with a fixed hospital.
This, ladies and gentlemen, is a design to conserve professional services and to give direction to the out-patient clinics that in certain areas
have undergone a distinct retrogression.
I have been more concerned about this particular
area of medical care than any other that I have encountered.
I have in the past year visited
sixty hospitals, ten clinics and twenty-seven Regional Offices.
I know something of the

|

-130-

{

picture.
I have not gotten aound too far, but I do say that my chief concern is in the ares
of the Medical Division of the Regional Office where there is no refreshment of constant
contact with the hospital service, no opportunity for following through the care of patients
seen casually in the out-patient clinic and, accordingly, a definite tendency downward.
This,
I cannot condone or witness without making some effort to correct.
There has been the plan, operative now in ten of these consolidations, that
encourages us to believe that we have a partial answer.
A man taken into the staff of the
hospital in our system is going to be refreshed.
If you have not been in a Veterans Administration Hospital and had any medical benefit, whether physical, dental or nursing, I think
that you would do well to go in and see just how live the medical atmosphere is.
There is,
in effect, for the first time given to these men who have had their lives, profesionally
speaking, in the out-patient clinic, refreshment, a oneness as belonging to the team that
did not exist before.
We feel it is a good movement.
We have certainly profited greatly by it in
the past and there is a plan to go forward with this particular movement, consolidating the
Medical Department or Division of the Regional Office, the out-patient clinic with hospitals
in.five other locations.
It is a studied effort and not just a decision arbitrarily derived.
In conclusion, may I say that there is one reaction that I have had over the
experience of the past year.
I have shared some of the casual experiences with you.
Deep in
my heart there is the sense of the singleness of our purpose.
Wherever I go, I have found
support at the hands of your service officers, at the hands of individuals interested in
rehabilitation wherever
they may be -- men and women dedicated to service, men and women
who are giving of themselves body and soul to this total effort, and so, too, the servicemen,
the various service officers of the various departments, of the various posts, to the
Veterans Administration Volunteer Service -- to them I wish to pay tribute.
It has been
my privilege to work closely through a solid year with Mr. T. O. Kraabel and Dr. Shapiro,
and better support I could not ask.
I thank you very much.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Thank you very much, Dr. Middleton.
I think probably the
key to this man's remarks, ladies and gentlemen, was contained in one of his last phrases
and that was the phrase, ''deep in my heart."
Those of us who have been privileged to know
him, if we were to describe one thing about him, we would say that his present effort, as
all his efforts over the many years as a doctor of medicine, comes from deep in his heart.
Before going on with the panel, I am going to take the prerogative of the
Chairman to do two things of personal privilege.
There are two persons here in the audience
that I think I would be very remiss in not introducing to you.
One of them is well-known
to you; one is not.
I see over here in the audience our very close and respected friend,
Admiral Boone.
Will you please stand up and greet your old comrades, Admiral Boone, and then
join us on the platform.
While Admiral Boone is coming up, I think it would be most appropriate, at least,
to take you back for two seconds to the grass roots where all of these things must be done.
Seated in this audience for every session of this conference this year, and to my personal
knowledge for several years before, always well forward where he misses nothing, is one of
the greatest grass roots rehabilitation men that I know.
This man will be 74 years old
on the Legion's birthday, March 17th.
Being 74 years old this year, he has already brought
in 464 memberships for his post, Lawrence Capehart Post No. 85 at Jeffersonvilie, Indiana.
He has served as county service officer, as post service officer, as post adjutant and editor
of the post paper, and has not failed each year to bring in over three hundred members while
at the same time serving in his rehabilitatiom capacity.
Those of you who were in Miami

ath

sav him receive
Legion

paper

row.

Thank

the National

last

year,

and

Award
that

I want you to meet
you, Herman, we are

for

was

on

the best
a

editorial

rehabilitation

Herman Wenige
real proud of

from
you.

in a post,

district

or department

subject.

Jeffersonville,

Indiana,

here

on

the

front

The plan of our panel this afternoon will be similar to that of all the other
panels.
I will first ask Dr. Middleton to introduce this fine staff of his here on the
platform, then I will ask Mr
O'Neill, the Rehabilitation Director of the Department of
Indiana, to introduce his panel.
We will then proceed with the questions that have been
handed in in advance which you have and which the VA panel have, and, time permitting, they
are willing to answer questions passed up from the floor after those questions have been
answered.
:
Dr.

Middleton,

will

you

introduce

DR.

MIDDLETON:

Thank

Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Dr.

Fellows, Assistant Chief Medical Director for planning.
Brewer, Assistant Chief Medical Director for Operations.
J. H. Smith, Deputy Director for Planning.
Harry Kessler, Chief, Paraplegia Affairs.

you

very

your

much.

-131-

group,
Dr.

please,

Wolford,

sir?

Deputy

Chief

Medical

Director.

Oregon, and
said, "That

Dr.
Dr.

John B. Barnwell, Director, Tuberculosis Service.
S. T. Ginsberg, Chief, Psychiatry Division.

Dr.

Raymond

Miss
Miss

Hauge, Director of Nursing Service.
Grace Bulman, Director, Dietetic Service.

Feldman,

Chief,

Outpatient

Psychiatry.

I might say that I was at Camp White a little while ago, two weeks ago, in
I saw an old codger about my age sitting off by himself and I went over and I
food looks very good.
That is just what we had for lunch.
Don't you like fish 21

i

He said, "No."
"Don't you like pork chop?"
He said, 'No."
I said, "What do you want?"
He said, "Sow belly."
Dr.
Mr.
Mr

Knudson, Director of Physical Medicine and
Trygstad, Director, Pharmacy Service.
Cumming, Director of Social Work Service.

Dr.

J.

E.

Fauber,

Dr.

J.

C.

Nunemaker,

Dr.
Dr.
Dr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Linus A. Zink, Deputy Director for Operations.
Irvin J. Cohen, Director, Hospitals & Clinics.
Earp, Acting Director for Clinics.
Chapman, Director for Homes.
McCoy, Director, Medical Administration Service.
Bowers, Chief, Medical Services Division.

Assistant

Acting

Chief

Medical

Assistant

Education.

most

to

the

R.

Stevens,

Director

of

Rehabilitation.

Director

Chief

Engineering

Medical

for

Mr.

Glenn

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

G. C. Parmelee, Director of Supply Service.
Larson, Director of Personnel Service.
Schoen, Acting Controller, DM&S
Daniel Rosen, Director, Medical Statistics Service.
Hildreth, Chief the Clinical Psychology Division.

I will
for the

now present Mr.
introduction of

for

Research

and

Service.

Now, friends, I want to tell you that, actually,
bare bone and left only Senator Bob Atkins behind

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
of the Department of Indiana,
questions.

Dentistry.

Director

we
to

have
hold

depleted our
the fort.

staff

al

O'Neill, Department Service Officer
his panel and the putting of the

MR. WILLIAM F. O'NEILL, Indiana:
Mr. Chairman, I don't think there is any
doubt in anyone's mind about what the subject is, so at this time I will introduce to you
the other members of the panel: Michael Markowitz, Director of Rehabilitation, Department
of Pennsylvania.
Mr. Charles Hazelwood, Department Claims Officer, Department of Oklahoma.
Mr. Timothy J. Buckley, Department Service Officer of Massachusetts.
Garland

H.

Woods,

Department

Service

Officer,

Department

of

Arizona.

So that no one will be overworked on the panel and so that you will all have a
chance to see and hear each of these men, the question will be read, the VA representative
will answer the question and we will divide these up.
I will take the first three and the
balance in order.
The first question was from Crider of Tennessee:
"It is recommended that the
VA take immediate action to make available intermediate beds for the care of the aged and
otherwise helpless veterans who need only nursing care."
I

think

that

has

been

assigned

to

Dr.

Cohen.

DR. COHEN:
Mr. Chairman:
The intermediate program is being expanded as rapid ly
as facilities and personnel can be made available by field stations.
Field station participation at our hospitals falls into two general categories:
those which are caring for
chronically ill long-term patients on the conventional wards, and then those which have
provided specialized wards for the care of these patients.
So far, five VA hospitals have
established a formal intermediate service comprising a total of approximately 600 beds.
Between July 1, 1953, and December 31, 1955, the end of the recent calendar year, over sixt een
hundred twenty chronically ill long-term patients were transferred from the neuropsychiatri Cc
hospitals to our general hospitals for continued treatment; and over two hundred nontuberculous chest patients, patients with chest digabilities, were transferred from domicil iary
centers to vacant beds in tuberculosis hospitals.
In all now, more than thirty VA hospital 8
are participating in the intermediate program.

While

considerable

progress

has

been
-132-

made

toward

resolving

the

many

problems

=a

inherent in any major change of this nature, there is still much to be accomplished before our
major objectives can be reached.
At the present time, a concerted effort is being made to
develop solutions to some of the more important problems by holding a workshop-type conference
in each of the Medical Areas.
These conferences are attended by key professional personnel
from stations which are or will be participating in the intermediate program, and includes
personnel responsible for the whole program and personnel directly responsible for the care
of the patients.
So far, two such workshops have been held and an additional one is scheduled
for next month at the VA Hospital in Dublin, Georgia.
On the basis of a one-time field station report made on March 8th of last year,
it is estimated that there were approximately eighty-two hundred veterans who are either patients in VA hospitals or members in our domiciliaries who are in need of hospital care and
treatment under the intermediate program.
The report revealed that over thirty-nine hundred
were so-called nonduty domiciliary members and approximately forty-three hundred were hospital
patients.
The thirty-nine hundred members needing hospital care represent approximately
twenty-three percent of the total number load.
This finding has resulted in a change in
the domiciliary eligibility requirements to preclude admission to domiciliaries of those
veterans who are too severely disabled to participate in the domiciliary program.
We are
currently engaged in making a second survey of our field stations to determine the extent
of the further need for intermediate beds.
It will be our policy to expand the program.
MR.

O'NEILL:

Mr.

Crider,

MR.

MACAULEY,

Illinois:

does
Mr.

that

answer

Chairman,

your

question?

do

you

What

mean

by

intermediate

beds?

DR. COHEN:
1I think that is the $64 question.
At our two workshops, more than
two days were sperit attempting to establish criteria for what we mean by an intermediate
patient.
I will give you what I consider our general picture at the present time and I
mention that this is one of the problems we are attempting to resolve.
There are a group of patients and members in the domiciliary who are suffering
from some degree of disability too severe to permit them to live in the domiciliary, or who
are
in hospitals and who have passed the point of attaining maximum hospital benefit, and
who as a result of all efforts, rehabilitation efforts, have reached a stage where they are
unable to return home because -- and this is an important point that I should like to make -all of our efforts to return him home have failed for one of a number of reasons.
It might
be because he is a lone individual with no home.
It might be that his family resources and
his physical home resources are unsuitable for his return home.
Or it might be because
he lives in a community which lacks any supporting facilities to permit his return home.
However, he is in need of continued active nursing care under medical supervision and, with
proper supportive techniques to prevent further deterioration in his physical, mental and
social condition.

hospital;

needs

or

MR.
are

MACAULEY:
you still

DR. COHEN:
continued hospital

Now you are providing for him
leaving him in the hospital?

We are still leaving
supporting care, and

MR. MACAULEY:
But if he
still has no place to go, or couldn't
the bed in the hospital?

interested

in

DR.

COHEN:

MR.

MACAULEY:

DR.

COHEN:

so

that

him in the hospital
he is a part of the

he

can

relieve

a bed

because we believe
hospital program.

in

a

he

has received maximum amount of hospital treatment
care for himself if he was at home, will he still

and
occupy

Yes.

No,

Or

have

you

he

will

still

other

MR. O'NEILL:
Are there any
this particular question?

plans

occupy

other

for

him?

a bed

in

remarks,

the

either

hospital.
from Mr.

Crider

or

anyone

else

.
MR. MELVIN DIXON, Florida:
Mr. Chairman, that was an Area C recommendation and
it came from the great State of Florida.
I would Like to ask the gentleman from the Veterans
Administration, in reference to the care of this type of case, a particular question about
a particular hospital, if you please, and that is the VA Hospital over at Lake City, where
you have just completed and moved into a brand new building.
In that move there were three wards of the old hospital which are sound construction, still vacant.
There were plans at one time to convert those wards into living
quarters for nurses and doctors, and it was our recommendation that these wards be turned
into a special ward which, I believe you will admit, makes the care of this type of patient
such cheaper than leaving him in a& bed in the hospital itself, and creating at Lake City
8 geriatric-type ward such as we have down at Bay Pines.
We have received the word from

you people

that

this

is in the overall

plan.
-133~

My point, gentlemen, is simply this, that for some reason we have a great
number of this type of patient in the State of Florida.
We have a huge waiting list at
three of our VA Hospitals,andit looks to me like, by spending a very minimal amount of
and by furnishing the very minimal amount of doctor.and nursing care, you could relieve
situation in that part of the state.

all
money
the

The survey made last month in that hospital shows that over 30 percent of the
patient load is remaining in the hospital over 60 days.
Now, that is because
the chronic
cases run their percentage way up.
We have had the chronic ward at Bay Pines for a goodly
number of years and it is a fine thing, a lot of good work is being done, but my point in
submitting this is, are you going to do this on a nation-wide basis or are you looking at
spots where immediate action can be taken, sir?
DR. COHEN:
TI can best answer that question by saying we are trying to do both.
We are looking at the overall picture in terms of where we can most quickly attain beds for
the care of these patients within national limits.
We are also trying to provide them where
beds are available and where staff are available, first, and where, of course, the patient
demand exists.
So far as Lake City, specifically, is concerned, it is one of many hospitals
in the forty-eight states and must be considered as part of our national program of utilizing thefacilities which are available to us and as part of our modernization program.
MR, DIXON:
Then, could someone on the platform answer me the question as to
whether or not the conversion of these three wards is going to go forward in making available
living quarters which will entail a great deal of expense, or has that plan been abandoned
pending further action on the question before the house?
DR. WOLFORD:
The Lake
moment.
It needs the consideration
and we are working on it as rapidly

City project is under very serious consideration at the
of other agencies outside the Veterans Administration
as we can.

MR, LEWIS SLONEKER, California:
I wonder if we might dispose of Question No.8
at this time, which is almost identically the same subject that you have been discussing.
We
have been told that these intermediate care beds apparently are being used in present hospital facilities.
This question here asked for additional beds, the same as the other
question does, by additional construction if necessary.
I wonder if we could have an answer
as to whether there is any planned program for any additional beds or. change-over of any
other construction that you may have to take care of the intermediate patient.
I refer to
Question 8, page 8.
MR.
MR.
this

O'NEILL:
SLONEKER:

time.

That is an area conference recommendation.
It is so related to this that I thought we

could

take

it

up

at

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
1I bélieve if you want to develop some questions or specific
data, it would be in order at this time, but we don't want to take up the recommendation as
to its disposition until a later stage.
If you have a specific question, that could be
entertained.
MR. SLONEKER:
Thank you.
That was my question,as to whether there is any
plan for additional construction for intermediate care.

BREWER:
This question No. 8 under the recommendations reads as follows:
beds be made available by additional construction, if necessary, to existing
intermediate care of veterans."

The possibility of providing additional beds by
the purpose of the care of intermediate-type patients is, of
the Congress.
The Veterans Administration has a program for
been explained.
MR. MICHAEL MARKOWITZ:
there is no money available for the
within their budgetary limitations,
possible?

I
for

necessary

In other words, are you telling us, Dr. Brewer, that
purpose of building additional beds but that they are,
doing all they can to provide intermediate beds wherever

believe the doctor said it will
additional beds.
Is that it?

DR.

BREWER:

Yes,

that

is

a

lot

be

MR. MARKOWITZ:
Administration!

Maybe

up

better

Markowitz.

Veterans

additional construction for
course, one for consideration by
intermediate care which. has Just

I am making

to Congress

to make

the

than

I could

possibly

have

in

being

employee

a mistake

MR. O'NEILL:
We will proceed to the
Klemmetson of Washington.
It is in three parts:
of Medicine and Surgery to consolidate activities

not

an

determination

said

of

it,

Mr.

the

second question, which was submitted by
'In view of the trend in the VA Department
such as outpatient and inpatient treatment

-134LP

:
DR.
"That additional
VA Hospitals for

and

to

place

two

or

(a)
""(b)
service
"(¢)

affecting

more

hospitals

under

one

manager,

would

like

to

be

informed

How are these consolidations working out?
Are they producing both efficiency and economy or are
to the veteran?
Why are service organizations not consulted when such

as

follows:

they

adversely

moves

are

con-

templated?"

it

“i

The

been
pick

question

has

been

assigned

to Mr.

MR. McCOY:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies
answered by Dr. Middleton in his address
up the parts in the order named.

McCoy

of

the

and Gentlemen:
In
to this body here.

Veterans

Administration.

i

part, this question has
However, I will attempt

to
lh

The rationale of operating two or three hospitals under single management has
been advocated from time to time.
It was agreed that this question would be explored by
actual experience.
Five locations were chosen and between July 14 and November 3, 1955,
the consolidations
were
will be made upon which

permanent

effected.
the Chief

At the
Medical

conclusion of
Director will

a reasonable
time,
careful
:tudies
pase his
recommendations
as to

policy.

The committee which worked out the consolidation procedures revisits the five
stations involved from time to time and at the conclusion of the test period their final
opinions will be prepared, both as to whether the move may be expected to produce efficiency
and economy, and as to the type of impact it has on the quality of medical care and treatment.
With
not
its

reference

be feasible
for
pilot programs.

comment

from

the

to

subsection

(c)

of

this

question,

it

is

obvious

that

it

I
|

would

the Veterans Administration
to consult other agencies with reference
to
The committee,
in making
its evaluations,
will be interested
to receive

service

organizations.

We operated pilot programs before establishing a policy that outpatient clinics
and hospitals would be combined where feasible.
The results established the fact that the
primary consideration of an increased quality of medical care and treatment was well served
and that the secondary consideration of increased efficiency and economy was also achieved.
This is now the permanent policy and is working well.

the

MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman, we
Portland, Oregon and Vancouver, Washington
MR.

McCOY:

That

was

two

of

the

are speaking
office.

here

of

the

consolidation

I
0

of

five.

MR. KLEMMETSON:
I can only speak for those two, but inasmuch as you are asking for an opinion as to the efficiency of that consolidation, I am telling you on behalf
of the Washington veterans that it is not efficient, it is not satisfactory to veterans in
our state, and I am going to ask Oregon, too, if they will comment.
In these two hospitals
we have 99 percent of all the hospitalized veterans in those states, that is, fromthe State®
of Oregon and the State of Washington.

satisfaction

MR.

POWELL,

with

this

Oregon:

Mr.

Chairman,

we

go

along

with

Mr.

Klemmetson

in

consolidation.

our

dis=-

:

There is a question I would
has been made, has the manager placed in
Dzan's-type hospital?

like to ask.
charge of the

In all cases
consolidated

il

where this consolidation
hospitals been from a

MR. McCOY:
Not in every instance.
You must remember in this connection, in a
test program of this sort, five representative types of consolidations were selected for
consideration and study.
These are representative.
Vancouver and Portland are a representative
type of consolidation.
The other five are not comparable to that particular comsolidation,
for

many

reasons.

Some

are

say in type of patients.
instance one hospital is
factors

entering

to receive
series and

type
ment

this

hospitals,

some

are

not

competitive;

this

thing

in

order

that

we

may

get

a

MARKOWITZ:

Mr.

McCoy,

you

have

more

than

that

is

to

Committee.
In one
you had various

pattern.

All of this will be a subject of final consideration and we will
your comments on any of the consolidations that have been effected
they will be considered along with all other data collected.
MR.

of

into

competitive-type

Some have Dean's Committee, some are not Dean's
a Dean's Committee hospital and one is not.
So,

five

now

in

be
in

operation,

very
this

happy
test

haven't

I

you,

fi

type?

effected
with an

MR. McCOY:
I speak of five for this reason.
We have five of this particular
in a given manner, where a consolidation of two hospitals under single manageintegration of common services and dual professional staffs.
In other woids,
-135-

li

the professional side of the house remains unaffected from the standpoint of staffing, from
the standpoint of types of beds, function et cetera, as before.
The other consolidations
that have been effected in the past, I believe perhaps you were thinking of Augusta as an
example, perhaps Pittsburgh is another, Oteen maybe is another -- these consolidations were
complete and total consolidations with an ‘integration of professional as well as administrative staffs.
In this situation we have a consolidation and an
integration of common
service elements under single management with dual professional services simply expressed.

MR. KLEMMETSON:
Mr. Chairman, I want to go back a little bit to this consolidation, if I may.
So far as the Northwest is concerned, I was ready and willing to agree
with the Veterans Administration that it would be feasible to consolidate supplies, personnel,
finance and engineering between these two institutions that were eight miles apart, but when
you tell me that a manager and assistant manager, covering these two hospitals, can do more
efficient work than two managers and two assistants, I don't believe it.
Even though I am
a layman, I say it isn't humanly possible.

I still say
Oregon are not satisfied
solidation, whom are you
I want to read it again:
contemplated?"

this so far as these two states are concerned:
Washington and
with that consolidation and if we are not satisfied with that contrying to serve in these two states?
Part (c) was not answered.
"Why are service organizations not consulted when such moves are

Any time we have legislation before the Congress of the United States, whether
it be the House or the Senate, we always have the opportunity to go up on the Hill and give
‘them our story.
I think some of the assistance we have given has been of value, particularly
to the Veterans Administration.
I am not forgetting, nor should you, that many times you
have come to us to go up to the Hill to procure more money for you, and I think we have
done
a fair job.
Why aren't we entitled, under the same circumstances, to be consulted
when you are contemplating changes in our hospital setup, that we are so much interested
in,
possibly even though we are laymen, some of us have been in this picture long before
the
Veterans Administration, possiblywe could be of some help to you.

MR. McCOY:
We agree that you can be of help to us, first of all.
Concerning
the first part of your question, it is difficult from the standpoint of management,
simply
stated, for an individual to serve two masters.
I think it is a settled principle of law,
as a matter of fact, so a chief of the Supply Division, Personnel Division, Finance
Division,
cannot well serve two masters because he cannot be a staff member on both teams
effectively.
He is totally on the team of one or the other.
The principle of single management as a principle
studying here.
That is one point I wanted to make.
The other
you have raised concerning why you were not consulted ahead of
Middleton.

is the thing that we are
phase of your question that
time, I will defer to Dr.

DR. WOLFORD:
Mr. Klemmetson, we agree with you that we are not perfectly convinced one way or the other whether this is a good thing or not.
We have pointed out that
this is a pilot program and so we are reserving our judgment until it has run a particular
8
time.

It has been in effect not too many months and as we have indicated, we are
keeping a very close watch on it.
There are people in the Department of Medicine and Surgery
who have to be shown, and that includes all of us, so I wouldn't consider this is
a permanent
situation until we are satisfied that the thing is the best for the care of our patients.
Now, when you get into the question of why you weren't consulted, I am very
sorry to say that we were not even in position to consult the manager.
The first that he
knew about the consolidation was when our people got there.
Now, we work within the framework of the Federal Government and when certain questions are raised and given to the Veterans

Administration

for

consideration,

at

what

we

least

prove
Dr.

think

Middleton

may

is

we

can't

right

or

want

to

always

wrong,

add

a

say,

and

little

I

''No.''

think

more

to

There

are

times

that

was

the

that,

but

that

when

situation
is

almost

we

must

here.
the

case.

DR. MIDDLETON:
Mr. Chairman, this is after the true American fashion of the
town meeting, but I think for the information of our friends here, it should be
known that
I was in Seattle on the 13th of February.
Mr. Klemmetson quite properly asked me for a
conference, which was granted.
We had three-quarters of an hour of very useful, helpful
conversation on this particular area.
What has been repeated from the floor and from the
stage here was discussed at that time.

should
is not

* I believe that in good
be given its fair trial, and
discrimination.

Vancouver

as

At that time,
our site.
We

faith, among
I assure you

people of good will, this particular effort
that we will have open minds and that there

my friends, I pointed out to Mr. Klemmetson that
did not pick it as a hospital.
It was forced on
-136-

we did not pick
the Veterans

Administration.
The mere fact that it is across the river from Portland did not determine
the conditions under which it was relinquished from military to the Veterans Administration.
We are doing the best we can with the tools that are given to us.
I think you must trust
us in that sense.
Thank you very much.
:
MR. KLEMMETSON:
Dr. Middleton, when you have completed this experiment, which
I understand is July lst -- at least that is the contemplated period, I believe -- may we at
that time have an opportunity to discuss these matters with you again?
DR. MIDDLETON:
My office is open constantly.
The door is never
to you nor to any other American citizen.
Thank you very much.

Klemmetson,

MR.

KLEMMETSON:

Thank

closed,

Mr.

you.

MR, BROOKS, Ohio:
Mr. Chairman, in the consolidation of outpatient service
into the hospital, will that outpatient service operate independent of the hospital or will
it come under the hospital's jurisdiction?
By that I mean, will the 0.P. set up and operate
as a division in itself?
MR.

will

it

McCOY:

be

I apologize.

With the
division

Can

I ask

consolidation
of its own?

of

you

your

to

repeat

the

outpatient

question?

service

MR. McCOY:
The Medical Division in a Regional Office when
family will become a service, the same as any other service in

hospital

MR.
the

hospitals,

an

outpatient

Earp

Sir,

MR. BROOKS:
an independent

BROOKS:
Will there
will the examining

or

You

MR.

Specifically

MR. McCOY:
It is
like to answer part

would

referring

my
of

the

hospital,

integrated in
the hospital.

be a rotation of the examining physicians such
physicians and outpatient remain the same?

MR. McCOY:
basis.
BROOKS:

are

in

on

to

the

pension

impression
that.

that

physicians

who

will

and

compensation

they

would

examine

the

as

in

routinely

on

matters.

remain

the

same

as

now.

Dr.

DR. EARP:
It is our hope that when the outpatient activities of the Medical
Divisions of the Regional Offices are consolidated with our hospitals and become the outpatient
service of the hospital, that that organization element of the hospital will be an integral
part of that hospital; that all the hospital facilities will be available to that outpatient
service

and

the

outpatient

service

will

be

equally

available,

hospital.
It is our hope that the personnel involved,
that the personnel involved will supplement each other

said,
Medical

for

MR. BROOKS:
TI think our primary
compensation pension.
As you know,

Division

have

in such a way that
the disability.

been

they

can

specifically

be

slipped

facilities

our
way

the

in

order

Rating

that

these

friend
pitals
and

MARKOWITZ:

We hope

to

Schedule

for

as I
your

may

the

rating

correct

the

intention,

examinations

DR. EARP:
That is true while in the Regional Office and
same staff will, of course, come over in the consolidation.
However,
any of the members of the staff cannot conduct an examination, a 2507
back a report equally as satisfactory to Adjudication.
I never heard
where they have not been satisfactory.
MR.

there,

hope but our
possible.

concern involves the 2057 examinations,
the staffs in the Regional Office under

trained

into

the

not only
in every

be

routed

on

in the hospital the
there is no reason why
examination, and give
of any reports so far

so.

MR. MUSCHETTE, North Carolina:
Mr. Chairman, I would concur in what my good
Kay Klemmetson said awhile
ago about the inefficiency of the operations of the hoswhere you have one manager, one head operating two hospitals.
We have that at Oteen

Swannanoa,

in operation,
originated.

as

you

the

less

know.

We

have

efficient

it

had

it

becomes.

now

for

There

several

years

and

is

less

supervision

much

the

longer

than

it

has

when

been

it

There hasn't been any complaint.
I think we have given you ample time in which
to observe and make the necessary corrections.
I sincerely hope that something will come
from this conference that will result im a thorough consideration of what is going on and the
supervision, or rather lack of supervision, in these dual hospitals.
As to
tried and tried to
in Swannanoa doing

the 2507's, the examinations, you said you had no complaints. We have
correct them on a local level.
We have doctors in our Outpatient Division
these examinations for rating purposes.
In the cdse of one in particular,
-137-

when he wrote your name, if your name was Jones, you couldn't read the "J" and the rest was
a line.
That examination was never adequate.
We had cases turned down time and time again,
because when it got before the rating board, they couldn't read the doctor's writing.
He
wrote in longhand.

not
was

even one
legible

When
copy

I tried to check back and see if there was a typewritten copy, there was
of it kept, and the only one made was the one made by the rating board,which

Those
MR.

are

the

O'NEILL:

conditions

which

I

Brewer

think

Dr.

exist
will

--

they

have

existed

answer

that

question.

and

still

exist.

DR. BREWER:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen:
With reference to Oteen, we
have the operation
of two divisions of a single hospital.
The question that was discussed
a few minutes ago involves the operation of two hospitals under single management with
certain common services.
There is a difference.
This particular pilot program that they
spoke of a moment ago does not apply to the type of organization you have down there in
North Carolina where Oteen is the hospital proper and they have a Swannanoa Division; or
to Augusta where we have the Augusta Hospital with the Forest Hills Division which was
formerly the Army Oliver General Hospital.
This whole problem of combinations is now under study; the problem of combining
Regional Offices and hospital; the problem of combining two hospitals such as has been done
in this particular pilot study involving five locations.
Naturally, Carl, along with that
problem will be the consideration as to whether the Oteen and Augusta type of operation is
a

sound

one.

with a policy
ing opinions.

It is my hope, at least, that when this is over we will come out of
and will not be constantly faced with four or five different types

this thing
of conflict-

With reference to the combination of a hospital and a clinic, again
I will
point out that when the clinic comes over -- and this is repetitious but
I think it is
necessary -- when a clinic comes over and becomes an integral part of the
hospital, the
hospital manager there has exactly the same duty to operate the outpatient
activities for
that regional area that he does to operate any particular segment of his
hospital.
At Oteen

and

Swannanoa,

of
It

a combination
is a hospital

manager

and

at

you

are

doing

hospital
in which

MR.

MUSCHETTE:

DR.

BREWER:

Oteen,

when

comprehensive

some

outpatient

Yes,

was

there

there,

examinations

there

the
are

entire
made.

why

the

that

are

not

area in
Is that

in

the

category

North Carolina.
not correct, sir?

sir.

Frankly,
he

examinations

and outpatient clinic sexving
some outpatient examinations

for

is

could

the

no
not

rating

reason
or

should

not

manager
have

at

Oteen

provided

or

the

legible,

people.

former

accurate

MR. O'NEILL:
The next question was also submitted by Klemmetson of Washington
and has two parts:
'VA Hospitals are operating both under strength and below maximum bed
capacity.
(a)
How can this serious deficiency be overcome?
(b)
If, as reported, the VA
is having trouble in obtaining and holding doctors, why shouldn't they
increase salary rates
and budget accordingly?"

(a)

of

the

DR. SMITH:
Mr.
question first.

Chairman,

Ladies

and

Gentlemen:

I will

attempt

to

answer

part

In general, the VA is operating its beds at optimum capacity consistent
with
the required standard of medical care.
Due to difficulty in recruitment and/or lack of
patient load at certain outlying hospitals, maximum utilization of
available beds has not always
been possible.
To increase bed utilization beyond the safety margin and, in the
face of

certain

staffing

deficiencies,

would

dilute

the

quality

of

medical

care.

The

VA

has

a

considerable number of older hospitals in which maintenance is a constant
problem.
A number
of these are slated for modernization.
Both of these operations make wards and segments of
wards unavailable to patients for varying periods of time.
In order to permit better equalization and distribution of patient
load among
hospitals within an area, the Area Medical Director has been given authority
to transfer
P-10's from hospitals where beds may not be immediately available
to another where beds of
the type desired are or will become available.
Beds to the limit of staffing in NP hospitals
are being fully utilized.
To increase available beds, selected groups of the more infirm
patients are being transferred to certain GM&S hospitals where beds
and staff are available
for the care of these patients.
Certain of our GM&S hospitals, particularly those associated
with a domiciliary, have a high proportion of chronic long-term patients.
These patients are
being transferred to other GM&S hospitals with available staff and beds.
With the decreasing
load in TB patients, which has resulted from the effectiveness of chemotherapy
, beds have
-138-

become available
ditiams.
The

NN;

SE

ly

increase

our

in

TB

hospitals

establishment
bed

for

of

the

care

of

intermediate

patients

beds,

as

with

non-tuberculous

discussed

by

Dr.

Cohen

chest

will

con-

undoubted-

utilization.

There is a shortage of certain categories of medical personnel in the Department
of Medicine and Surgery.
This is a reflection of a nation-wide shortage experienced in rnonfederal as well as federal medical programs.
In spite of these shortages, the standard of
medical care afforded VA patients is being maintained.
It was to meet, in part, these staffing needs that the VA embarked on certain training programs, without which the VA would be in
dire straits as far as medical personnel and the quality of care are concerned.
In order
more adequately to meet the need for certain specialists, the VA has recently established
a career residency program that is aimed at giving our own physicians training in the scarce
category specialties of psychiatry, neurology, physical medicine, and others under consideration.
These physicians are required to serve the VA'a given number of years following the training
period.

VA is
rates

The second part of the question reads as follows:
"If,
having trouble in obtaining and holding doctors, why shouldn't
and budget accordingly?"

as reported, the
they increase salary

Physicians in the Department of Medicine and Surgery, as other federal employees,
enjoy certain benefits such as the opportunity for advancement, sick leave, annual leave,
JAnsurance, and retirement.
Although the monetary value of these benefits, if purchased
privately, would be considerable, it is, nevertheless, true that our physicians do not fare
as well as those in private practice from the standpoint of financial remuneration.
There
is even a greater disparity between the salaries of VA and civilian physicians who are
specialists in their respective fields.

situation

It is believed
its physicians

of

that the VA has done everything within its power to
and would welcome any other effort in their behalf.

improve

the

MR. KLEMMETSON:
On that question of maximum bed capacity, Dr. Middleton, in
Seattle, you have the best, smallest, most efficient hospital in your system, the best managed
too, I believe, and marvelous cooperation between the Medical School of the University of
Washington.
We have only 285 beds in that little institution.
The capacity is 325.
We could
recruit sufficient doctors to staff that hospital fully and to keep it at maximum capacity,
but I suppose that is a question of money.
Is there any possibility that if the medical personnel could be recruited,
hospital could be operated to capacity, namely 325 beds?
I may tell you also that just
ly, for that very small hospital, we had a waiting list of 168.

is.

In

I have had a little other experience in that hospital.
I
talking to the young trainees in that institution, I find that

they wanted
talked
to a

here?

Are

to and
number

you
"I

they are fond of
of them in these

going

to

should

work
say

for

not,

the
not

told
they

the
recent-

you how fine it
came there because

the institution and the training
they are getting.
terms:
''What are you going
to do when you get out

I
of

VA?"
for

the

salary

the

VA

is

paying."

And that is a question we as Legionnaires can do something about.
I think two
years ago I had a resolution before the National Convention of The American Legion asking
that the doctors' salaries in the VA be increased.
The doctors get the same little salary
that the rest of their fellow employees get.
But take a board member, for instance -$12,500, I believe.
How can we expect to keep him?
How can we expect to keep the rest of
the good doctors if we are going to continue to pay the salaries to the VA doctors that we
are at the present time?
I certainly think there ought to come out of this conference a
recommendation that The American Legion do everything it possibly can to see that these
doctors are paid the salaries they are entitled to receive, so that. they will stay with us
and

so that we
present
time.

will

continue

to

keep

the

A-1

service

that

we

are

giving

ou.

veterans

at

the

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I would Like to call attention to the fact that as late as
the Miami Convention The American Legion did pass a mandate along the very lines that Mr.
Klemmetson proposed.
I would also like to call attention to the fact that the VA must
operate within the level set in their salary scales and grades by the Congress and within
their appropriation.
I feel that we have a good deal of evidence that they are just as
anxious to upgrade these individual classifications as we are.
Of course, they can't have
all generals and no soldiers, but we are already mandated as I think Mr. Klemmetson knows,
on this particular thing.
Does that help bring out the point?
MR. KLEMMETSON:
is the sum total of it.
Why
for increased salaries?

That is true, but so
shouldn't we dedicate
-139-

far
and

we haven't accomplished a thing.
restate a recommendation that we

That
ask

MR. McCURDY:
It isn't quite correct, Klem, that we didn't accomplish anything.
The first session of this Congress did make some adjustments but it wasn't
anywhere near
adequate.
I think that this sort of thing should be further supported.
We might ask our
Recommendations Committee to request that the VA request adequate salaries; that
the Bureau
of the Budget approve adequate salaries; and that the Congress support adequate
salaries
for the Division of Medicine and Surgery in the VA.
I think that we might reiterate our
stand through our Recommendations Committee here.

across

But
board

the

MR.

got
the

some consideration,
though it wasn't
first session of this Congress.

KLEMMETSON:

Mr.

Chairman,

may

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
To answer your
together, rather than take time out
for you?

tions all
procedure

MR.

will

have

will

bring

evaluate

it
in

a

the

KLEMMETSON:

Then

will

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Yes, if
special time to take those

in

it

go

it is
up.

I

make

that

7.5

percent

recommendation

at

this

before

Recommendations

made

the

from

Committee?

here

your

Recommendations

and

propound

Thank

you;

that

settles

it.

Markowitz,

you

can

over

time?

those recommendaa satisfactory

floor

CHAIRMAN

take

to hold
that be

the

time,

Mike

a

got

I would like
them.
Would

the interest of saving
on that subject.

BOOHER:

as

They

question,
to act on

MR. SLONEKER:
In
a recommendation

MR. O'NEILL:
answer.

enough.

today

it

your

will

and

we

Committee

question

and

MR. MARKOWITZ:
This next question is Question No. 4, presented by a fellow
named Markowitz from Pennsylvania.
The question says, "Why cannot rules be changed so that
VA hospital physicians may be permitted to express their opinion in writing that a condition
is considered secondary or adjunct to a servicee=connected condition?"
Dr.

Fellow will

answer

the

question,

DR. FELLOWS:
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen: I thinkit is rather fortunate
that Mr. Markowitz presented this question.
He no doubt has forgotten it, but I remember
distinctly fifteen years ago at Greensburg, Pennsylvania, having argued at great length over
this question and several other questions similar to it.
I know that he never forgets and
brings up the same question over and over again.
MR.

MARKOWITZ:

Maybe

it

is

a good

idea.

DR. FELLOWS:
These rules, as well as the zules which prevent examining physicians
from expressing conclusions as to service-comnection or percentage evaluations of disability,
are enforced as a direct benefit to the veterans themselves.
Fundamentally, the final determination of these facts is the function of the Adjudication Service.
If the examining
physician or the hospital physician responsible for the hospital treatment of the patient
were to express definite written opinions un these matters, their opinions would frequently
be found to be erroneous because of their lack of knowledge as to all of the processes involvedin making such determinations.
Under this circumstance, the patient would likely leave the hospital with definite
assurance from his hospital physician that he was entitled to and would receive treatment,
only to find that such was not the case, and frequently time and inconvenience would be
expended.
It has been the experience of many years -that in making determinations of this
sort, the one who is ultimately responsible for the determination can perform a better job
in the interest of the patient if a predetermined and unofficial opinion has not entered the
;
picture,

MR. MARKOWITZ:
I don't like the answer.
We have reference to a man having a
service-connected disability and another disability which may be of nonservice origin, but
one trespasses on the other or one aggravates the other.
That is the thing we have in mind
where the doctor might express
himself that it is adjunct to the service-connection so that
he can receive outpatient for both.
Now, what is your answer to that?
:

DR. FELLOWS:
I understand that is what you meant and I have in mind the very
patient you have in mind.
You probably have forgotten him but I remember him; the patient
who is being treated for a service-connected condition in the hospital and has, we will say,
a stomach condition which may or may not be adjunct to his service-connection.
During his
hospital stay, the hospital physician correctly will go ahead and treat the patient.
At the
time the patient is to be
discharged from the hospital, the patient's physician is concerned

-140-

with a problem to be decided.
The stomach trouble is in need of outpatient
some source and it is up to the doctor to advise the patient what source he
for his treatment.

treatment from
will appeal to

|
|

4
If it is adjunct to the service-connected condition he would be entitled to
treatment for that condition in the outpatient clinic, legally, so if the doctor expresses
in writing that this condition is adjunct to service-connection and tells the patient,
"You
go to the outpatient clinic and you will receive treatment," and he goes to the outpatient
clinic and, because of facts unknown to the hospital doctor at the time, the Adjudication
and the Chief Medical Officer of the original office will not find the patient's condition
adjunct, then he is not entitled to treatment.
By doing that, the patient has only the resource of obtaining treatment from
another source not in the Veterans Administration.
Had it been known at the time that the
doctor discharged the patient that he was not eligible, the doctor probably, through social
service and other things at his disposition, would have arranged for treatment through a
private source and then the patient would not be dissatisfied that he had been given a run
around and things would be much better.
I

at
to
He

think

that

is

the

same

position

I

took

fifteen

years

ago.

MR. MARKOWITZ:
Maybe we ought to modernize you.
It is very seldom that I am
a loss but I admit I am a little here, and I am going to call on my good friend Dr. Shapiro
project this thing a little further.
I am sure he can be of a great deal of help to you.
always is.
.

DR. SHAPIRO:
I think I know what is troubling Mike.
This involves the question
where there have been changes in disease or a secondary diagnosis which is definitely tied in.
For instance, a man may have had a severe head injury in service and it resulted in a true
encephalopathy.
He will come ‘along some years later and show convulsive seizures.
I have
seen the hospitals indicate that the convulsive seizures are considered part and parcel of
the traumatic head injury.

|
i

In the neuropsychiatric nomenclature, when there is a change of diagnosis, the
VA regu.ations not only provide but insist that the doctor show why the change in diagnosis
was made and why or how the previous condition enters into the picture.
So, there are VA
regulations on that, but not enough of that is done.
The basic adjudication regulations
indicate that where there is a change in diagnosis of a service-connected disability, the
examining physician should dispose of that and that is, I think, what Mike had mainly in
mind and I do want to show that it is part of the VA instructions but it is not generally
followed.
:
He mentions another thing, like a transfusion jaundice for a service-connected
disability, where a transfusion is given for service-connected disability and the man may
wind
up with a hepatitis later.
There are many things and I think the doctors in the field
should receive some instructions to completely dispose of the related conditions or where
a change in diagnosis is made.
DR. FELLOWS:
Dr. Shapiro, I feel certain that we in the Veterans Administration
are entirely in accord with you on this part of the question.
That, I did not have in mind
when I discussed it.
The question, as you know, says, "Why cannot rules be changed?"
Now,
to my knowledge, there is no rule that prevents a doctor in the Veterans Administration from
expressing his opinion, his medical opinion as to whether or not a symptom which has developed
sometime
afterwards may or may not be part of the original condition for which he may be
service-connected.
I believe we encourage our doctors to go into that, where we have a case
such as Dr. Shapiro described.

about

sof
it,

MR. MARKOWITZ:
Doctor?

DR.

FELLOWS:

I

think

we

might

be

able

to

get

something.

Will

you

do

something

;

Yes,

sir.

MR. MARKOWITZ:
Question No. 5, also propounded by that same fellow I mentioned
a little while ago:
"Why do Veterans Administration hospital authorities require applicants
for hospitalization to produce their original discharge or separation papers?"
I know of only one hospital where that does exist and, of course, we are going
to turn to Mr. McCoyon that and I want him to know before he answers the question that there
is one place where the admitting doctor absolutely will not admit a fellow unless he has his
original discharge papers with him.
So, instructions ought to go again to all field stations.
MR. McCOY:
Mr. Chairman:
There are no instructions to our knowledge which
prescribe that Veterans Administration hospitals will require applicants for hospitalization
to produce their original discharge or separation papers,
This practice was officially discontinued shortly after World War II.
VA Form, 10-P-10, Applicationfor Hospital Treatment,

-141-

:

:

|

formerly contained instructions regarding presentation of discharge papers,
dropped from the form during a routine
revision of this form in 1948.

which

were

From a practical point of view, there is merit in having applicants bring their
discharge papers to the hospital.
Frequently, legal eligibility can be determined without
any delay, and dispatch of VA Form 10-2731 to the Regional Office for eligibility data becomes
unnecessary.
It is conceivable that local recognition of the possibilities outlined has
stimulated a revival of the former practice.
However, in no event will Veterans Administration hospitals deny admissions to
a veteran solely because he did not produce his discharge or separation papers.
If there are
any known cases where this is being required, they should be brought to the attention of the
Central Office and we will be glad to look into them.
MR. MARKOWITZ:
We will be very happy to give you that information about the
hospital that we know of.
I know of only one, as I say, but I might point out, too, that we
have had to fight this particular question in another one of the hospitals I have been
connected with not too long ago.
A fellow who lived in the Midwest, a veteran, was travelling
and he came into the great State of Pennsylvania and he was taken ill.
He was a veteran
but he didn't have any record of his being a veteran at all.
I got a call from his friends
out in the Midwest.
I contacted the manager of that hospital and told him that the discharge papers were on their way by special delivery mail to the hospital; would he admit the
man, and the veteran was admitted, so I say not in all situations does it prevail but we
will give you the one where it does prevail and I am sure you will take care of it.
Any

further

discussion?

Does

anyone

on

the

floor

have

any

similar

problem?

No. 6 says, "Why cannot outpatient treatment records from VA Mental Hygiene
Clinics be made available to service organizations' accredited representatives who have been
given power of attorney by the veteran?"
Dr.

Feldman

will

take

that

one.

DR. FELDMAN:
Mr. Chairman:
Reports of the patient's mental hygiene clinic
treatment are prepared routinely and included in the outpatient medical treatment folder.
In addition, special reports describing the treatment given in mental hygiene clinics are
submitted to the Adjudication Service on their request.
VA Regulation 525(B)(4) titled’
"Inspection of Clinical and Medical Files by Accredited Representatives,'" described the conditions under which clinical records and medical files, including outpatient medical treatment folders, may be inspected by accredited representatives.
Essentially, it permits
these records to be inspected to the extent that "they are incorporated in the claims folders,
or are made available to VA personnel in the adjudication of the claim.
Records of data
in clinical or medical files which are not incorporated in the claims folder or which are
not made available to VA personnel for adjudication purposes will not be inspected by anyone
other than those employees of the VA whose duties require same for the purpose of clinical
diagnosis or medical treatment."

:
The reason the outpatient medical treatment records from VA mental hygiene
clinics are not made available to service organizations' accredited representatives who have
been given power of attorney by the veteran is because these records contain material which
is highly personal and confidential.
In order to be able to do psychotherapy and have the
patient participate freely in this treatment, it is necessary to maintain the confidentiality
of this material.
If this were not possible, it would offer a most serious obstacle to the
veteran's psychiatric treatment.
Often it would make treatment impossible.

respect

the

We simply cannot treat the veteran patient
confidentiality of the exchange between him

the

answer.

in

a hospital.

with a psychiatric illness and
and the treating physician.

not

MR. MARKOWITZ:
Has anyone any questions from the floor?
I asked the question and I am satisfied with the answer.

I am satisfied
Anyone else?

with

MR.

you

case

DAN

HANLEY,

West

Virginia:

I would

like

to

know

how

:
MR. MARKOWITZ:
That is not the question, Dan.
This has
treatment for mentally ill patients and has nothing to do with how to
hospital.
If you want to bring up the question we will allow you get
later, but not now, not while I am Chairman.

get

a mental

reference to outpatient
get the man in the
the floor a little

I want to say this, and then I will turn the microphone over to one of my
colleagues.
When I looked at this array of talent behind me and then I heard Dr. Middleton
introducing them, I knew we would get some answers, and I am happy to say that so far the
answers made to the particular questions propounded from Pennsylvania have been satisfactory;
Thank you very much.
I am happy to have the answers.

MR.

WOODS,

Arizona:

Before

going

into

-142-

Question

No.

7,

the

Chairman

has reminded

me that we
well ahead
with these

are falling quite a bit behind schedule and this auditorium
of time today in order to prepare for our banquet, so if we
questions as fast as we can.

is going to be needed
may, let's go along

Question No. 7 was submitted by Mr. Powell of Mississippi:
"In view of the
fact that most everybody now subscribes to some type of hospital and medical insurance plan,
we would like to be advised as to why the Veterans Administration cannot work out some plan
whereby these insurance companies would have to pay benefits when holders of such policies
are hospitalized and being treated in VA hospitals."

MR.

McCOY:

Don't

think

because

I

am

up

I don't.

here

so often

that

I

have

all

the

answers.

Since the Veterans Administration is not a party to the insurance contract which
exists between the veteran and his insurer, the Veterans Administration, as assignee of the
insurance contract, is unable to enforce collection action in any case where the insurer contends that his policy does not provide for the assignment of any of the benefits under that
particular insurance contract.
This matter of the right of the insurer to write its own type
of insurance contract is one that cannot be challenged.
As recently as June 1955, in the
case of the United States versus the St. Paul Mercury Indemnity Company, a Federal District

Court

ruled

that

the

Veterans

Administration

was

insurance monies under the terms of the particular
The Government, through the Department of Justice,
that case.
MR.

WOODS:

Is

there

any

question

without

authority

in

collecting

insurance
has filed

policy at
an appeal

the

on

from

floor

that

any

of

these

issue in this one case.
to the decision in
matter?

MR. POWELL, Mississippi:
The basic reason for that question was not particularly
to get it before the Veterans Administration but more to get it before this conference and
let us do some thinking on it.
I am thinking of the many veterans who are carrying types
of hospital insurance and they are carrying it because they need it for their families and
they are also included in that premium.
They go into the VA hospital for their treatment because they cannot afford to
pay the difference between what the policy will pay and what the hospital is going to charge
them, so that they come out with a very good bill from the hospital after all.
I noticed not too long ago that the American public was spending about the usual
proportion of its income for medical services, so that our hospital program is not depriving
the doctors of any money, particularly, and that has been raised as a question on their side
of the fence, of course.
But, since we are not doing that and since these veterans are
paying for hospital insurance, I think we ought to kick that thing about a little and I think
we in this conference and in The American Legion need to think about it.
I just want some
more thinking on the subject.
I wasn't particularly after the VA answer to it because I
understand that you were excluded by reason of the type of contract that these various companies are writing, companies and associations.

believe
program

we
if

I do know that there are a great many veterans who are already covered and I
could have many more, and I think it would give quite a lift to our hospital
there was some provision whereby the VA hospital could collect from the policies.
MR.
HMR.

we,

I

believe,

McCOY:

Thank

you

very

much,

THOMAS EGAN,
Delaware:
should consider.
I am in

sir.

There

Mr. Chairman,
we
full accord with

is

no

answer

required.

have an additional
extensionthat
my friend;
the determination
of

ability to pay is expressed in P-10.
Suppose you have a policy similar to the Blue Cross or
akin to that and the many policies of that kind.
You certify on that that you have a policy
under the Blue Cross.
They will not cooperate with the Veterans Administration and pay for
hospitalization.
You have a predetermined question upon which the Veterans Administration
has the ability to "close the bank' suddenly because he has a predetermined ability to pay
to a limited extent for a certain amount of hospitalization.
This
preference

in

type

of

policy

reverse.

A

veteran

I

resent,
who

and

I have

participates

in

resented
such

a

it

bitterly.

It

hospitalization

is

Veterans'

program

is

a

preferred customer of such an agency because he deserves hospitalization from the Veterans
Administration and, as such, he makes an additional contribution to the financial stability
of the company in which he participates without receiving one single iota of monetary recovery.

The question that we specifically would like an answer to is:
Is this type of
hospitalization coverage ever to be used adversely against the veteran's priority for admission in a VA hospital?

question
VA would

MR.

WOODS:

I

think,

Mr.

Egan,

that

and the case was being appealed by the
indicate to us that certainly in their

Mr.

McCoy

indicated

that

Department of Justice.
opinion, it would never

-143-

this

was

under

I believe that the
be used against the

veteran

to

keep

him

DR.

out

of

WOLFORD:

a VA

hospital.

Am

I correct

on

that?

Yes.

MR. WOODS:
Going along to Question No. 8, submitted by Mr. Muschette of North.
Carolina:
"Why do the Registrars in some VA hospitals determine that a veteran is financially
able to pay expenses of hospitalization and treatment when he shows that he has a bank
account
of $500?
This is done before they can possibly know. the extent of treatment and hospitalization
needed."
MR. McCOY:
Mr. Chairman:
No Registrar has authority to attempt a finding of
ability to pay for hospitalization in any case, regardless of ‘the amount of assets possessed
by the applicant.
There are no exceptions, and no otherwise eligible applicant will be refused hospitalization on this account.
The decision regarding the applicant's ability to
pay is personal, by statutory provision.
Furthermore, the governing instruction on this
subject, VA Circular No. 11, dated November 4, 1953, specifically provides that "This addendum
may be used in no way whatever to deny hospitalization to a veteran as the law specifically
provides that 'the statement under oath of the applicant.
. . shall be accepted as sufficient
evidence of inability to defray necessary expenses.''
MR.

WOODS:

Does

MR.

MUSCHETTE:

MR.

WOODS:

that

answer

the

question?

Yes.

Going

along,

then,

to

No.

9,

submitted

again

by

Mr.

Muschette

North Carolina, "What authority does the Veterans Administration have for billing
with a nonservice-connected disability for hospitalization and treatment when the
was admitted to the hospital as an emergency case?"

of

a veteran
veteran

MR. McCOY:
Mr. Chairman:
There is no authority for billing an otherwise
eligible veteran for hospitalization rendered to him in an emergency.
Furthermore, there is
no authority for billing any veteran hospitalized, whether an emergency or otherwise, provided
he is a bona fide veteran entitled to such hospitalization under the provision of the
applicable VA regulations.
Occasion may arise, however, where an individual is hospitalized
‘as a potential beneficiary and who, subsequent to admission, is determined to be’ not eligible
for one reason or another.
In these cases, because of the limitation in our appropriation,
it is mandatory that we bill the ineligible individual for the services furnished.
MR.

WOODS:

Are

there

any

comments

on

that

answer?

MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
Yes, sir, he certainly didn't know what he was talking
about, apparently.
Apparently you don't know, sir, that if a veteran goes into a VA hospital
and, as a result of his hospitalization, a lawsuit is filed, that he can be billed for that
hospitalization.
Are you aware of that?
MR.

McCOY:

It

has

been

suggested

that

we

submit

it

to

the

legal

people

for

a

MR. CRIDER:
The question is, if a veteran is in an automobile accident and
goes in to a Veterans Administration Hospital, legally entitled nonservice-connected, an
emergency, he is admitted and is treated and, as a result of this automobile accident
he
files a lawsuit in court and is awarded damages, can he be billed?

he

reply.

MR. BOWERS:
It isn't a question of billing.
That is a third-party liability
case, where he assigns certain rights to the VA to collect or to be reimbursed for the period
of care where there is a third-party liability involved.
He, himself, is not billed.

who

was

MR.

CRIDER:

Who

is

MR.

BOWERS:

The

insurance

company

or

MR.

CRIDER:

All

right,

let's

go

let's

he

killed;

say

is

billed?

now

billed

for

whoever
a

$5,000,

two questions I want to ask you in connection with
can be reduced?
That is, can it be reduced as far
an amount awarded him by the court?
i

MR. BOWERS:
That can be.
attorneys participate in any

your

chief

stand

against

responsible.

further

on

within

reason.

which

is

that.
as the

One, is
veteran

BOWERS:

Again,

that

is

subject

144-

to

negotiation.

that.

Let's
There

take

a man

are

there any way that that
is concerned for payment

It is subject to reasonable
negotiation of that kind.

MR. CRIDER:
Secondly, in the event of his death,
his widow and children for hospitalization?
MR.

rule.

is

little

does

negotiation.

the

There

Usually,

outstanding

bill

is

and

no

hard
:

fast

of

MR. CRIDER:
Tennessee now and I would
up with the legal people.

It is an interesting question
like to know what can be done

because we have that
on these things, and

involved in
I will take

it

MR. BOWERS:
I think, normally, we are only inclined to collect in third-party
liability cases to the extent that we do from insurance companies where there is definite
liability.
We are not attempting in any way, shape or form to take any benefit away from
the veteran, himself; only where there is a benefit for hospital care provided and it is
specifically
provided for, is it taken.
MR. CRIDER:
Your hospital in Tennessee, in a particular instance, was awarded
judgment by the court.
Of course, the insurance company is the one that .is going to pay
the judgment.
The court awarded judgment to the veteran and then the hospital didn't bill
the insurance company; they billed the veteran because he is the one that received the judgment.
;
MR. BOWERS:
In some instances that is necessary
judgment, or from the insurance company.
You have a specific
happy to discuss it with you.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
the reason that Resolution No.
and, therefore, it will not be

in order to collect on
case in mind.
We will

the
be very

I am going to rule that Question No. 10 is out of order for
117 of the Miami Convention of 1955 rejected the same idea
;
a subject for discussion here and we will go to Question No.ll.

MR. CHARLES HAZELWOOD, Oklahoma:
Question 10 having been ruled out of order,
we will move along to Question 11, by Burns of Wisconsin:
'Why cannot form 2731 establishing a veteran's eligibility to enter a hospital be cleared with VA Regional Office by 'phone
or messenger, thus saving several days' time?"
MR. McCOY:
There is no prohibition on clearing VA form 10-2731 by telephone or
messenger with the controlling Regional Office.
In certain areas, this is done by use of
the telautograph where the Regional Office has such facilities.
In all cases, however,
because of the importance of the information required for determining legal eligibility, it
is mandatory that some writing be received to eliminate the possibility of error when the
information is transmitted orally.
The Veterans Administration is reviewing the procedures
governing the use of VA Form 10-2731 and hopes to improve them as soon as possible.
MR.

HAZELWOOD:

Does

anyone

wish

to

comment

on

that

question?

Question No. 12, Mr. Sanderson of Nebraska:
'When it has been determined that
a dental condition is aggravating a service-connected disability, why doesn't the Veterans
Administration authorize immediate treatment by a VA dentist or an outside dentist?"
DR. FAUBER:
Mr. Chairman:
This is a matter of adjunct treatmentto a basic
medical service connection.
In most instances the Veterans Administration does take care
of this immediately.
However, the controlling factor in all cases is the basic serviceconnection and the extent of aggravation.
The necessity for this treatment is determined by
the Chief Medical Officer.
When he requests immediate treatment, it is provided.
When he
does not, then the treatment is provided in the order in which the request is received along
with other eligibles.
MR. HAZELWOOD:
Question No. 13, Sanderson of Nebraska:
'"A veteran has been
granted service connection for several teeth and at time of his VA examination is informed
that he also needs work done on several other teeth.
This he has done by an outside dentist
at his own expense.
When VA receives additional service records it finds that all of the
teeth are service-connected.
The veteran is informed that inasmuch as he has already received
one dental treatment he will not be entitled to further treatment.
Why is this when VA has
never had all of the service-connected teeth taken care of?"
DR. FAUBER;
Under existing regulations governing reimbursement for unauthorized
services, this type of case could not be paid.
We do feel that this regulation should be
amended to allow for reimbursement in this specific type case, and are recommending that consideration

be

appreciate

the

given

to

calling

revision

of

this

of

the

matter

regulation

to

our

to

provide

for

this

specific

type

case.

We

attention.

MR. TIMOTHY J. BUCKLEY, Massachusetts:
We go to Question No. 14, submitted by
Merifieldof California:
'Opposes the suggested termination of the 'Intermediaries' Contract
between the VA and the California Physicians Service, having to do with fee basis outpatient
treatment to service-connected veterans as suggested in the letter of 10-24-55 from the Chief
Medical Director to the Colifornia Medical Association."
DR. EARP:
Mr.Chairman:
The Veterans Administration Hometown Care Program is
conducted under the terms of a formal agreement between the Veterans Administration and the
California Physicians Service, a corporate subdivision of the California Medical Association.

to

those

From a cost standpoint, the major effort of the intermediary has been directed
transactiom involving issuance of authorizations and effecting reimbursement to
-145-

member physicians for services rendered.
Such activities parallel
ponsibilities inherent in the operation of Veterans Administration

and duplicate resRegional Offices.

The successful administration of the Hometown Care Program is in no measure
dependent upon the continuation of a third party type of arrangement such as exists at present
under our agreement with the California Physicians Service.
This has been fully demonstrated
in other states where contracts have been negotiated directly between this agency and the
State Medical Society concerned.
No change in policy is contemplated or proposed which would militate against
the opportunity of the service-connected veteran to receive professional attention from the
physician of his choice.
Fee-basis medical care is made available to eligible former members
of the Armed Forces under the many circumstances which prevail when it is not feasible for
the veteran to be seen in a Veterans Administration Clinic.
If the California Medical Association desires to enter into a direct agreement
with the Veterans Administration, there is no reason why there should not be full participation by member physicians.
The veteran will continue to have the benefit of medical care
provided by a physician of his own choice, in his home community, consistent with established
policy, and the schedule of fees, currently approved, will be used as the basis for authorizing services to participating physicians.
MR.

that
it

should
involves

be

MERIFIELD,

thoroughly

similar

California:

discussed,

contracts

in

seven

Mr.

in my
other

Chairman,

opinion,

and

this

is

a

protested

serious

and

by

American

The

vital

subject

Legion

as

states.

We have had experience in the old method of the VA trying to deal
examiners and, of course, know the tremendously improved service that veterans
there is a centralized agent for the medical profession,such as the California
Service, to carry out the program.

with designated
enjoy where
Physicians

We do not believe the facts bear out the Medical Director's statement that the
program has resulted, at least in California, in duplication and unnecessary cost.
Any reduction in cost can only be made at the expense of better service to the veteran.
The number
of physicians available to treat veterans under the present program is many times more than
could ever be secured by the appointment of designated examiners, and such treatment is
rendered more efficiently and with less delay.
The California Medical Association has protested the discontinuance of this
program and, without the cooperation of the California Medical Association, it would be
practically impossible for the VA to establish a schedule of fees under which a sufficient
number of physicians would operate under the program in fifty-eight counties in the state.
As a result, there would not be a sufficient number of physicians to serve the veteran in
his community.
Dr. Earp has made the statement that if the California Medical Association
desires that the program be continued through them, it can be done, but if we have to g0
back to the designated physician situation where we have to deal either with the individual
doctor or with individual counties on a fee basis, it presents almost an impossible situation.
Now, it might be well to say, and no doubt the good ‘doctor will tell you that,
well, there are only seven states in the Union, or eight states in the Union, that have a
contract with intermediaries and the rest of them get along without that; but we have
some
very interesting figures when we come to that situation.
We find that in California 58
percent of all treatment authorizations were through this California Physicians Service,
whereas in all other states that do not have this intermediary, only 27 percent of the
veterans received Hometown Care, and I suggest to you very strongly, you states that do
not
have this intermediate care, that you look into the matter because your veterans out in the
sticks and out in the small towns, it is very obvious from the figures, are not getting the
proper treatment.
Of course, this is an economy measure like many others that we are faced with.
There probably might be some reduction in cost, but even that can be challenged because I
have before me figures of the last thirty-one months that show that with the exception of
five months, your authorizations for your California Physicians Service medical treatment
-that in only five months have the non-CPS treatments been greater than CPS treatments in
cost.
Now, they will say, "Well, that is okay for the individual treatment of the veteran,
but that does not cover administrative costs."
Well, some of these costs run, they did at
one time, as high as $3 an
authorization more on a non-CPS doctor than they did on a CPS
doctor.
Suppose they only run $1 difference; we have twelve thousand treatments a month
in California, and ‘that is $12 thousand a month, or nearly $150 thousand a year, which would
pay for any administrative costs that mightbe greater.

sever
states
look into the
your veterans

It is a very serious matter.
I know how the representatives here of
feel, and I suggest very strongly that you other department service
possibility of someone to act as an intermediate in your states, to
get better service for outpatient.

-146-

the other
officers
see that

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
I think for the information of the conference, this has been
discussed and I believe, Earl, you were on the Hill at the time that this was discussed.
This matter has been thoroughly talked over in front of the Medical Advisory Board at its
meeting last Sunday and was brought before the Commission in its meeting on Monday.
It was
the opinion of those two bodies that while there are nine states that have this arrangement
at the present time with the VA, there are thirty-nine states that do not have it.
Of the
nine states having this arrangement, protest has been heard on this subject from four of them.
The other five have not.
It was the opinion of the Commission, in considering this after
the advice of the Medical Advisory Board, that it was a state matter rather than a matter of
national policy, and it was referred back to the individual states for their negotiations
with the Veterans Administration at that level.

part

of

I didn't
fight.

about

the

it

was

have

I didn't
talked

think you
about.

knew

all

MR. SLONEKER, California:
that information, either,

MR. GRADY, Ohio:
situation in the two

Before we
hospitals

that,

Earl,

because

you

were

up

on

the

Hill

when

Doctor, I appreciate those remarks of yours because
and we will be glad to take it up as a California

close this panel, I would like to
in Cleveland.
What is the status

know something
of them now?

MR. BUCKLEY:
We will continue with Question No. 15, submitted by Mr. Merified
of California:
'Requests Central Office to reconsider the Medical Budget for the Los Angeles
Regional Office in light of the new fee basis schedule and allocate sufficient funds to allow
this division to perform its operations in accordance with the intentions of the law."
MR. SCHOEN:
The new fee schedules approved for the State of California were
considered at the time the annual allocation for the Regional Office at Los Angeles was
prepared.
However, other factors have entered into their needs and we have recently
negotiated an additional amount for that office, which I believe satisfies the manager that
he can do a good job with the money we have given him.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Mr. Chairman, I wish to say that I found out that Central Office
did take into consideration the increase in the fee schedule, almost all of it I think
there was only an eight thousand shortage -- after I had submitted this question.
I am very
happy to hear about that and I have been told here that an adjustment has been made, because
I found in other programs, actually the pharmaceutical program which had practically doubled
over the last year, that it did create a terrific shortage and made it necessary to reduce
authorizations for medical treatment.
That has happened before and I have talked to others
of you here who have told me the same thing, that you have experienced the same thing in your
offices, where when we get toward the end of a quarter and money starts pinching, then,
unfortunately, the number of authorizations for treatment is reduced.
But I am very glad
to hear that an adjustment, at least, has been made in our office in Los Angeles.

funds for the
tion backlogs

MR. BUCKLEY:
Question No. 16, "Requests that Central Office obtain sufficient
Dental Ciinic, Los Angeles Regional Office, so that ths treatment and authorizacan be eliminated."

DR. FAUBER:
Mr. Chairman:
In the submission of the Fiscal Year 1957 budget,
cognizance was taken of the dental backlog in the Los Angeles Regional Office as well as
other areas, and it is believed that sufficient funds have been requested to bring the dental
load finally to a current basis, if our projected budget is approved for Fiscal '57.
MR. MERIFIELD:
Dr. Fauber, will that take care of other offices?
You are
speaking of all offices, are you, because I know the same thing applies in others.
In a reply that was received to a representative field service report of The American Legion,
it was indicated that this backlog exists in all offices in the United States, and it
seems after four years, as far as the Los Angeles Office is concerned, the day I left
we had 1197 dental cases waiting for authorization, and that represented just exactly
one year's backlog.
In other words, the veterans who filed the first of March, 1955,
have not yet received their dental treatment that they need, and I am very happy to hear that,
in the projected budget for the next fiscal year, which is what I presume you had reference
to, doctor, you had asked for sufficient money to pick up this backlog and get it out of the
way.
It has been extremely troublesome, as you know.
DR. FAUBER:
Mr. Merifield, I thimk you will find that the backlog in the State
of California is consistent with othe: states in our country.
One thing that may be of
interest to all of you, however, in view of the fact that you mentioned the three year period,
is that three years ago we had a backlog of 386,000 pending cases.
We have fortunately been
able to reduce that backlog to the amount of 105,000 cases nationally.
MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode
our dental backlog before I came down
Island as of January 3lst.
I hope it

Island:
I want to second that request.
here and we have 855 cases in our small
is cleared up down there, too.
-147-

1 checked
State of Rhode

MR.

two

BUCKLEY:

We

now

return

to

the

Chairman

of

the

panel,

Bill

O'Neill.

MR. GRADY, Ohio:
Mr. Chairman, can anyone on the panel give us the status
hospitals in Cleveland, Ohio, and phat is their status at this time?

proposed

I refer

to

the

general

medical

and

surgical

and

the

neuropsychiatric

of

the

hospital.

DR. WOLFORD:
The plan for the neuropsychiatric hospital at Brecksville is in the
Bureau of the Budget now awaiting approval.
We had a conference with them today which we
think will jar it loose and we will have it on the way.
The question of Wade Park is being
developed with the Office of Defense, that is Defense ODM.
We are still in a hassle over
the site there and we hope to get that under way in at least the next thirty days.
That is all
the progress I can report right at the moment.
MR. GRADY:
There is an issue in this proposed general and medical
the NP hospital in regard to the A bomb and hydrogen bomb, whether they will be
I just wonder, in this strategic area or any other place in Ohio, whether there
a hospital placed that wouldn't be vulnerable to the A or H bomb.
DR. WOLFORD:
That is a question I can't answer
very strongly in getting the hospital in downtown

interested

but I can tell
Cleveland.

hospital and
A or H-proof.
could be

you

we

MR. O'NEILL:
Since that concludes the formal questions that were
am going to turn the mike back to the Chairman and take this occasion to thank
Legion members for their participation.

floor

MR.
than

other

DIXON, Florida:
Are you
those on the program?

going

to

open

the

program

to

CHAIRMAN

BOOHER:

To

answer

your

question,

Dixon,

presented,
the VA and

questions

MR. O'NEILL:
The formal questions that were presented to the
The area recommendations are to be handled by Dr. Booher, and
thank the other members of the panel who served here with me.

considered.
occasion to

are

from

I
the

the

panel have been
I take this

yes.

Now, I want to pose these recommendations that I have here and ask for others.
You may handle this in two ways.
Lew Sloneker and his committee are here and he will take
note of these as they are debated, or we may do it by formal motion, which is not necessary
as I understand our procedure.
I have three of these recommendations that have been considered by the VA and if there is debate, we can go along on those three.
They have prepared answers for them.
These all come from Area E.
The first one reads:
"In view of the
urgent need for additional doctors for the active practice of medicine in many of
the
Veterans Administration hospitals and the seeming lack of authority of the Area
Medical
' Directors plus the large amount being expended for maintaining the Area Medical
Offices, we
recommend that our National Rehabilitatiom Commission make an adequate survey study
of the
advisability or justification of the Veterans Administration continuing such offices."

Is

there

any

expression

consideration?

I am

do

you

desire

that

Comrade

Sloneker

take

it

by

Area

E and

Brewer

who

to

MR. KLEMMETSON:
recommend it be

Mr. Chairman, this recommendation was approved
referred to the Recommendations Committee.

some

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
comments on this

Is it your pleasure
recommendation?

VOICE:

like

going

prepared

or

We

would

very

much

to

hear

to

hear

his

the

comments

comments,

Mr.

of

Dr.

for

has

Chairman.

DR. BREWER:
When it was known that the Branch Offices were to be discontinued,
the then Chief Medical Director, after careful study, determined that it was
not practicable
to operate a chain of hospitals efficiently and satisfactorily from one
Central Office.
The
Area Offices were set up to perform supervisory functions and to perform
certain operation
functions.

When the next succeeding Chief Medical Director assumed office, he explored
this
situation and agreed with the conclusions of his predecessor with reference
to Area Offices.
He strengthened them and advocated the establishment of an additional number.
The Booz,
Allen and Hamilton management survey recommendations comprehended a much
larger number of
these offices than have ever been considered by the Department of Medicine
and Surgery.
ly when

he

The present Administrator of
approved the activation of the

Veterans Affairs went into the
Columbus, Ohio, Area Office.

matter

most

thorough-

These facts are sufficient to indicate that this question has had repeated careful consideration at the highest levels and that in each instance the same conclusion
was
reached.
As a matter of fact, the number of full-time physicians in the Area Offices is small.
-148~

The present policy is to decentralize
ly as possible.
In certain instances
the Area Office level.

supervisory

The supervisory
functions of the

referred.

Is

to field stations
where this cannot

requirements
Area Offices

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
that right?

We

have

responsibility and authority as widebe done, there is decentralization to
:

increased as decentralization progressed.
The
will, therefore, be increasingly necessary.

in

this

particular

instance

a motion

that

this

be

MR. KLEMMETSON:
There was one other reason for bringing this resolution up.
At
this Area E Conference, which was one of the very finest we have had, we had very good representation from all other VA departments but we did not have one representative from the
Area Medical Office in San Francisco.
May we request that, in future meetings of Area E,
that we have a representative from the Medical Division in California?
CHAIRMAN

the

purpose

of
MR.

the

BOOHER:

If

the

answer

is

in

the

affirmative,

would

it

do

away

with

resolution?

KLEMMETSON:

I was

not

responsible

for

that

resolution.

DR. BREWER:
I understand your question, sir, is as to whether there will be
representation prospectively, and the answer is yes.
Furthermore, if the representatives
out there enjoy the associations as much as I have over the years, they wouldn't miss them
for anything, and I happen to know that Dr. Francis was otherwise heavily engaged this last
time.

tions

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
We will consider the recommendation
Committee for their consideration and report back tomorrow.

construction,

to

the

Recommenda-

Recommendation
if necessary,

No. 2:
'"That additional
to existing VA Hospitals

beds be made available by additional
for intermediate care of veterans."

Dr.

Brewer

prepared

that.

DR.

BREWER:

has

That

is

some

remarks

on

one

that

jumped

the

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
That was
Recommendations Committee would take it

reception
the chief

referred

was

Dr.
to

taken up previously,
into consideration.

Brewer

will

you

give

us

before,

and

I answered

it.

and

was

stated

the

it

that

Recommendation No. 3:
"That full time VA medical personnel be assigned
and admission service in all hospitals that are under the Dean's Committee
of this service have authority to admit eligible veteran patients."
Dr.

Fellows

of

the

VA

staff

has

prepared

some

those?

remarks

on

to the
and that

that.

DR. FELLOWS:
Mr. Chairman:
All residents employed in VA hospitals are graduate
physicians who have served at least one year of internship prior to their residency training.
All work under the direct supervision of their respective chief of service, and when working
in

the

Admission

Service

of

a

hospital,

is

also

under

the

direct

supervision

of

the

full-time:

chief of that service.
These residents have such professional qualifications that we would
be happy
at the very beginning of their residency to employ them as regular full-time
physicians if they would consent.

The manager of a hospital has the ultimate responsibility for determining the
eligibility for hospital admission of any applicant.
This responsibility he usually delegates
through the Director of Professional Services to various members of his staff, as the local
conditions would indicate.
This type of organization and delegation of responsibility results in most instances in the very best possible system for the determination of admissions
to any given hospital.
:
We have to remember that the local condition in each instance is the determining
factor and since it is the manager's responsibility, we usually feel that we would like to
have him work out such problems as this wherever possible.
CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
No. 3.
Referring has been the
Lew, and hearing no objection,

With that explanation, what is your
order of the day.
We will refer it
we will take it by consent.

pleasure about Recommendation
to your committee, then,

appropriated

I have another one that was not listed and it reads,
and allocated to provide that all VA Hospitals shall

"That increased
operate at full

Is there anyone who wants
to me on a typed slip.

know

It

was

handed

pleasure

about

I am told it
this one?

is

another

to

speak

to

recommendation
-149-

that?

of

I.don't

the

Area

where

E Conference.

it

funds be
.
bed capacity."

came

from.

What

is

your

MR. KLEMMETSON:
I don't believe I received the answer to it when I discussed
it under another question.
I am still going back to the Seattle Hospital and 285 authorized
beds.
The rated capacity is 325.
We have a waiting list for that small hospital of 185.
It
is a marvelous institution, Dr. Middleton.
We would like to keep it full.
We can procure
the personnel -- Dr. Nolan told me so.
It is just a question of money.
Do you have the money?
emphasizing

Chairman Booher:
Do you feel, Mr. Klemmetson, that for the
the previous mandates, that it should go as a recommendation

purpose of reto the committee?

MR.

it

KLEMMETSON:

DR. WOLFORD:
have 292 patients in there
pretty good operation.
Does

292

patients

could

we

have

and we are
we have no
care of.

of
to

that

Yes,

The
now

answer

MR.

KLEMMETSON:

DR.

WOLFORD:

MR.

KLEMMETSON:

the

your

question?

No,

it

Three

DR. WOLFORD:
‘We
in the hospital,

unless

Doctor

Seattle Hospital
and an operating

doesn't.

hundred

six

would

like

to

is running about
capacity of 324,

It

could

be

answer

now.

85 percent of capacity.
which, to our minds, is

operated

at

306

beds.

operating

beds,

and

they

for

285.

I am

agking,

They
a

beds?

Yes.

have 324
which is

beds.
about

That is their
85 percent.

MR. KLEMMETSON:
But the money that
sufficient money for 306 beds?

is

spent

is

only

have

DR. WOLFORD:
Of course, as you know, we have to look at this thing nationally
given funds to hit a certain target which we, ourselves select,
In other words,
trouble getting the money for the number of patients that we think we can take

Now, in the new fiscal
something like over two or three
that at this time.

year which will start
thousand patients per

in 1957, we will have
day, so we are giving

an increase
consideration

MR. KLEMMETSON:
I would like to have the VA take into account also that, within thirty miles of Seattle, we have more than one million people, almost 200,000 veterans,
and 285 general medical beds.
The nearest available for the rest of them who cannot get
into that hospital is Vancouver, Washington,
two hundred miles away, or Walla Walla, almost
three hundred, so I am wondering if you would keep that in mind in the reallocation of a
little more money for the Seattle Hospital.
DR. WOLFORD:
That is fine.
We watch the waiting
Chief of Medical Statistics that it is operating at 91 percent
little better than the figure I gave you a little while ago.

list and I am told by my
of capacity, so that is a

MR. SLONEKER, California:
I think that this question is much more of a major
problem than has been brought out.
If we are going to. pinpoint hospitals, we can be here
for the rest of the month.
I feel they are affected by not having sufficient funds to operate
at maximum capacity.
For example, Wadsworth Hospital, the VA Center in Los Angeles, until
six days ago had 103 beds closed because it didn't have enough funds.
If they did have funds,
the manager evidently was afraid to use the funds and open up the beds.
Here is the serious
part of it:
It is affecting the admission policies in your hospitals.
A lot of your doctors
are almost practicing medicine on the available funds and not on the basis of whether the
veteran needs hospitalization or not, and your denials and rejected P-10 applications will
show that.
It will show it all over the country and it will show it more in California than
in any other part of the country.
When we had sufficient funds there were 20 percent
denied
average of 45 percent denials, so you can see what is going on when you
funds to operate the maximum number of beds that are available.

and now we have an
do not have sufficient

MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
I would like to ask the gentlemen this question.
I was
surprised to learn that we have two hundred vacant beds in Murfreesboro.
They say they have
sufficient funds but not sufficient personnel.
Now, in line with the vacant beds, what is
being done -- if you have sufficient funds, what is being done in the psychiatric recruitment field; I am more concerned with that than any other field, to secure sufficient personnel
to open those beds?
I might explain, before you tell me that they have a waiting list of only eightyeight at Murfreesboro, which I found out the other day, that we have discouraged the making of applications to that hospital because we knew we couldn't get them in anyway, but I
have already sent word out to the field to load them up.
We are going to make them think
-150-

all

the

people

of

Tennessee

CHAIRMAN

are

BOOHER:

wanting
Dr.

to

Ginsberg

get

into

would

Murfreesboro
like

to

at

answer

once.

that

at

least

in

part.

DR. GINSBERG:
I think I have some good news for you.
I can't start out by
saying there are a lot of psychiatrists available and we will order as many as are available
immediately, because you know and I know, and all the rest of us know, that there is a definite
shortage of psychiatrists throughout the nation, not only in the Veterans Administration but
in

every

service.

However, several years ago the Veterans Administration, realizing this, developed
a new program of training psychiatrists.
The program I refer to is the Career Residency
Program, wherein we were training residents for a period of years and, through certain inducements, largely financial, we were able to obtain an obligated period of service in connection with each one of these career residents.
At the present time that program is doing exceedingly well.
So far, it has just
reached the point where the residents who started out originally have served their training
period and are now available for the obligations.
We have already assigned a few of these
psychiatrists who are trained now, who have a period of obligated service to the Veterans
Administration.
This next year we expect to have about forty trained men who have completed
their residency training available for assignment in just these hospitals that you are talk=ing about -- Murfreesboro and others that are in the isolated areas where not only do they
have difficulty in recruiting psychiatrists but all other specialties.
In future years, if this program continues to develop, we expect that those
hospitals that have been suffering so badly in the past will receive additional staffing so
that they can utilize all the beds available, will be able to treat the mental patient, the
veterans with mental illness adequately, and thdt the quality of treatment in those hospitals
will continue to improve.
MR.

DAN

HANLEY,

West

CHAIRMAN

BOOHER:

Are

MR.

HANLEY:

Virginia:
you

Mr.

speaking

Chairman
on

the

--

resolution?

No.

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Let's dispose of
length of the discussion on this recommendation
pleasure to refer it, along with the others, to
dissent from that ruling?
(Without

dissent,

the

CHAIRMAN

BOOHER:

It

that.
I take it from the importance and
that we read last that it would be your
the Resolutions Committee.
Is there any

recommendation

was

referred

to

after

four.

the

the

Recommendations

Committee).
is

now

seven

minutes

We

must

clear

this

room

in twenty-three minutes.
In those twenty-three minutes we will welcome questions from the
floor.
I will first recognize Dixon of Florida and Dan Hanley of West Virginia.
You will
not be recognized twice for a question until all who desire have asked questions in the time
available.

patient

MR. DIXON:
I would .ike to
treatment.
We have talked a lot

Pass~-A-Grille

ment due
too long
"This is

Regional

Office

there

has

ask a question in
here about budget
existed

and

is

now

reference to the budget for outfor hospitalization.
In the
going

on

a

curtailment

in

treat-

to lack of money.
Central Office says it is not available.
On inquiry here not
ago, I found out that Central Office sent back to Pass-A-Grille the word that,
all there is; if this won't do the job, then fire some doctors."

To me, that seems like a very foolish program, but I know in my office we are
receiving hundreds of letters from veterans who said, "I was previously authorized to see
my doctor four times a month and now I can only go once, and I am having to pay for the
other three visits out of my own pocket."
Now, I would like to hear some comment in reference to this particular question
from the Veterans Administration.
Is there any money in Central Office or do you recognize
the great work load in the Pass-A-Grille office during the winter time when they have a great
migration of veterans who come down there and throw this picture all out of kilter?
MR. SCHOEN:
We have had considerable discussion with Pass-A-Grille on this
problem of budget and I will say this, that there isn't any unallocated reserve of funds .in
Central Office.
In discussing the Pass-A-Grille problem, we have heard much about the increased work loads that are reflected in that station and when we take the figures reported
by that station, the tremendous increase in work load claimed does not reflect itself in the
work load reported by the station.
So, we have some serious reservations as to the present
status of Pass-A-Grille.
The Area Medical Officer has been in there -MR.

DIXON:

‘He

is

down

there

right

now.

-151-

MR. SCHOEN:
isn't settled as to what
process of negotiation.

He may well be.
He
is the proper amount

has been
of money

there several times and it still
for that station.
We are still in

the

Now, I would like to say this, there are considerable numbers of people who are
not doctors in these clinics, and the decision that was made did not direct the station to
lay off doctors.
We were primarily considering the size of the present clerical staff. As
you know, in order to achieve the best distribution of money, in order to see that all the
clinics get a reasonable allocation of this money, we must insist on efficiency in all clinics,
and at Pass-A-Grille we have been reviewing their operations and feel that they should be
able to do the job with what they have, properly managed.
MR.

DIXON:

You

are

insinuating

we

don't

MR. SCHOEN:
I don't believe that
managed economically.
We are still
of money they should receive.

it will be
the amount

have

proper

management,

I

take

it.

was the insinuation.
I am saying we expect
having a discussion with Pass-A-Grille as to
2

MR. DIXON:
It seems to me, sir -- and I have tried to stay pretty close to this
particular question because this is not the first time it has come up -- that I can only go
by this, and that is the number of letters which I receive in my office from veterans complaining about reduction in outpatient treatment, the fact that they are now having to pay
for part of their treatment out of their own pockets.
You take it upstairs and they tell
you, quite frankly, "We have to do this because we don't have enough money to pay for this
and we have to trim all across the board."

They have even cut veterans off of outpatient treatment until sometimes it has
become so critical that they have nearly gotten in trouble about cutting down on treatment.
I am speaking about diabetics and that type of thing.
They trimmed this thingto the bone.
I don't know what we have to do down there to convince you that there is a great need for
medical treatment in that state.
You say you are not convinced.
I don't know whom you
believe.
I feel as if the people down there in authority have sent up adequate information
to you.
I don't know why you would hesitate to believe it.
I don't know why you would
hesitate

to

take

their

word

for

the

fact,

and

I

know

they

have

asked

for

more

money.

MR. SCHOEN:
Mr. Dixon, I will be pleased to discuss with
you the background
of this problem, discuss with you the work load at this station and the other implications
that are involved in the Pass-A-Grille problem.
Pass-A-Grille consistently has received
increases in the last several years and the emphasis on work load from that station has not
been supported by the figures they have given us.
MR.

DIXON:

That

is

your

reason

for

hesitating?

MR. SCHOEN:
That is right.
We have a problem of assuring that everybody gets
a fair share of this money and this tremendous growth that we hear about, when we analyze it,
just isn't there.
On the question of individual veterans, we have a report from that station,
a status report which we received from all of the clinics, and I shall be happy to discuss
that report with you and try to come to a better understanding.
There is a tremendous number
of problems in this business of trying to decide who gets money.
Would you please come to
see me, sir, Room 8107?

to

have

the

CHAIRMAN
following

BOOHER:
members

Before I recognize you, Dan, Lew Sloneker would like very
of his committee report to him across the hall at once.

much

(Announcement)

MR. HANLEY:
Mr. Chairman, I would like to direct this question to a fellow
West Virginian, Dr. Wolford.
I don't see Dr. Arnett up there, but I believe that the Veterans
Administration is responsible for this condition that exists because they recognized an
institution for one quarter and then did not recognize it further, and I want to ask you, Dr.
Wolford, what are you going to do with those unfortunate veterans at that so-called
-oldiers
home in Weston, West Virginia, whom they are leaving there to die.
They are not doing a
solitary thing for them.
What are you going to do about that?
You are obligated, because
you recognized it and appropriated money.

troller

DR. WOLFORD:
I am very sorry,
General of the United States.

but

you

should

direct

that

inquiry

to

MR. HANLEY:
I know all about the Comptroller General and I talked
it isn't their obligation, it is the VA's obligation that you owe those men who
at Weston in a so-called soldiers' home.

istration

to

DR. WOLFORD:
I am sure
be in a penitentiary.

you

don't

want

any

of

the

charges

of
8

-152-

the

the

Comp-

to him, but
are confined

Veterans

Admin-

.

them

MR.
there,

over

HANLEY:
Those men
as of last Sunday.

themselves
aid.

MR.

BOOHER:

HANLEY:

Thank

you,

Dan.

over

here

--

We

are

would

like

I came

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
questions as possible.
MR.

take

criminals.

They

are

just

not

doing

a

thing

for
s

and it is in the‘hands of the
long as the Comptroller General

MR. HANLEY:
Naturally, I went to the Comptroller General, but the VA obligated
when they appropriated one quarter and allowed those men to receive that so-called

CHAIRMAN

many

not

DR. WOLFORD:
That is out of our responsibility
West Virginia, and we can't do anything about it as
his decision.

State of
has made

as

are

HANLEY:

I

I think

you

have

had

perfectly

glad

hear

from

you,

to

Dr.

have

to

Wolford

give

me

an

answer.

but

we

a better

want

to

get

statement

to

back.

MR. McCURDY:
Dan, I think you are entitled to a statement to take back and I
think Dr. Wolford attempted to give you the statement.
They can only appropriate money as
authorized.
Now, the decision was given once and then it was refused and within this last
week the Comptroller has again affirmed and reaffirmed his opinion that they could not
qualify for VA funds at the present time.
Unless there is further legislation or reversal of
a former position, Dr. Wolford was correct in saying that it would be illegal to grant any
further funds.
No one in the VA can help it or do anything about it and the proper action,
if any, that is indicated to gain funds for that particular facility would be through other
channels.
With that explanation, Dan, if you want to carry it further, see Mr. Sloneker
or the Recommendations Committee.
There is no use taking up further time with that explanation.
We don't want to take any more time here.
I will discuss it with you afterwards or
you can go to the committee and tell them and we will try to help you in your problem.
MR. HANLEY:
I want to make a public statement, Bob, that I helped the Comptroller
General in his decision, and Mr. Keene of the Veterans Affairs Committee of the House.
I have
a document here in my brief case and I want to know why those fellows can't be taken out
of there and put in a veterans' institution.
There is Dr. Ginsberg, who was up at Lees
Farm Road.
They have beds up there.
Why can't we get them out of there?

there
made,

MR. McCURDY:
Dan, perhaps one answer to that is
are seventeen thousand NP cases on the waiting list and
they would get out in their turn.

of

time.

and

I

With that, I am going
I want to answer you but

will

discuss

it

with

you

Who

was

it

wanted

MR.

FENNER,

North

further,

to

be

later

over

First,

sir,

there?
I

want

to

thank

the

Medical

Division

for their cooperation
clearing up in a very

with Dr. Spoffard, our Chief Medical Officer in Winston-Salem,
satisfactory manner a distinct backlog of examinations.
I say

sort

oil

of

cast

a

little

on

the

water.

The

was

on.

recognized

Carolina:

present time
if application

I am sorry, we have given you a lot a
Thanks,
time of all these gentlemen.

it, Dan.
take the

close
can't

to
we

that at the
undoubtedly

thing

I

want

to

ask

now

is

this.

We

in
that

have

to

a

1025 bed hospital at Salisbury with approximately 640 beds occupied, leaving 38 percent,
385 beds.
There have been a lot of rumors around to the effect that the Regional Office is
going to be moved to Salisbury.
I would like to ask if there is anything to that rumor or
whether those beds are going to be activated.
A lot of our NP patients are in jails and we
have no where to put them.
DR. GINSBERG:
The plans at the present time are to utilize all the beds for
veteran patients.
I know nothing about the Regional Office moving but I know the plans now
are that by the end of the next fiscal year all the beds will be activated and in use.
MR. EGAN, Delaware:
Speaking for Tom Lewis of Maryland, who was not able to
be present, he left a question with me that he would like to have answered.
It seems that in
the Baltimore Office they have a 500 backlog of hearing acuities.
There is a difference of
opinion and a conflict between the divisions there.
They recently sent out fifty cases to
Johns Hopkins Hospital and those are from the immediately adjacent states and they have only
one case in there from the State of Maryland.
There is a new Regulation PGS-9 coming out
and they are greatly concerned as to when they will have a possibility of eliminating the
backlog.
-153-

|

here

by

the

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
Thank you, Tom.
It is
Veterans Administration and Dr. Earp will

a problem that is being recognized
give you some data on it.

DR. EARP:
The problem that has been presented from Maryland is in connection
with the review of the hearing cases that is being held, and when you speak of a
large number,
so many cases, those cases are to be spread over a three to five-year period for examination,
so it is not a pending load right at the present time or a backlog of cases.
That is a
three to five-year program and these cases are all being examined in audio eliniés,
which
does in some instances require the veteran to travel for examination.
seemed

to

But the
indicate.

meeting over
meeting.

backlog is not a backlog as of the present time, which
I wanted to get that particular point across to you.

CHAIRMAN BOOHER:
At this time,
to the Rehabilitation Chairman,

ladies and gentlemen,
Mr. McCurdy, who will

I would
address

the

question

like to
you and

turn the
close the

MR. McCURDY:
Thank you very much, Dr. Booher.
I
want sincerely to thank you
and the members of our Legion panel for the fine job that you have done in this medical
session.
I think that I have had some interesting experiences here.
One was when Dr. Shapiro
greeted Dr. Ginsberg.
He said, "You look fine and you feel fine.
How do I feel?"
So, I think that I might just tell you one story to summarize some of our most
important problems, and probably the most important.
It reminds me of the story of the little
boy.
He was 10 years old and he was taking English and the teacher was giving him a word
and asking him to look up the definition and then use it in a sentence.
So, this little boy
drew the word "frugal," and he looked that up and he found out that was to save.
so

she

said,

So,
"Go

the next
ahead."

day

the

teacher

asked

him

if

he

was

prepared

and

he

said

he

was,

He said, "The knight in shining armor rode down to the castle to meet his sweetheart, and as he was approaching the castle she was out on the
balcony and, in great distress,
she was shouting,
'Save me; save me'; so he frugaled her and they lived happily
ever after."

Now, the moral of this story, in summing up this panel, is
that we want to be
saved from the frugal policy of the Bureau of the Budget,
that if we can be saved from that
policy and eliminate these questions that were based clearly
on economics, I am sure that
we are going to make fine progress.
It is certainly within our prerogatives to help our
friends in the VA do this.
And now, Dr. Middleton, I want to
tation Conference to you and to all these fine
and to you, too, Admiral Boone.
We appreciate

to the care
younger men

Over the years
of the veterans
coming in reach

we have found that
in the same degree
the same degree of

express the thanks of the National
gentlemen who have participated in
your coming to this most important

Rehabilithis program,
panel.

a great many of these men have become dedicated
that we are dedicated, and we hope that these
dedication to this cause as their predecessors.

Again, we thank you and I want to remind you that at
nine o'clock
morning -- your program says ten -- but at nine o'clock
sharp tomorrow morning
the meeting.
Just one announcement and then we will be in adjournment
.

tomorrow
we will start

(Announcement).

recess

until

MR.

McCURDY:

nine

o'clock

tomorrow

morning.

(The

meeting

adjourned

at

If

there

is

nothing

more

four-thirty

=154-

to

come

o'clock).

before

the

meeting

we

will

be

in

FRIDAY

MORNING

March
The

meeting

convened

at

2,

nine-twenty

SESSION

1956

o'clock,

Chairman

Robert

M.

McCurdy,

pre-

siding.

our

CHAIRMAN McCURDY: Will you please come
Chairman, Reverend Joseph MacCarroll.

National

to

order?

We

will

have

the

invocation

by

THE REVEREND JOSEPH MacCARROLL:
O God, our help in ages past and our hope for
years to come, our shelter from the stormy blast and our eternal home: grant Thy
guidance
upon us in this closing session and then implement our decisions with the actions of our
hearts and of our hands and of our heads, to the end that we may serve our comrades, whose
needs

are

Commission
ference.

the

way

proceed

so

vast,

with

all

of

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
and when Mr. Higley
So,

at

with

we

this

will

proceed

the

resources

We will
arrives,
and

see

that

we

have.

For

Thy

name's

sake.

Amen.

start this morning's sess on with a meeting of the
we will recessas a Commission and meet as a Conhow

much

of

our

unfinished

business

we

can

get

out

of

we

will

time.

I am

going

to

ask

Loyd

Pool

(Roll

call

of

Commission

to

call

the

roll.

members)

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
The roll
the unfinished business.

call

is

complete

and

a quorum

is

present

and

You will remember that at our first meeting on Monday, we had a report from the
Liaison Committee with the AMA.
The Liaison Committee was composed of the Commander, Past
National Commander Seaborn Collins and Past National Commander Harry Colmery, together with
our staff members, and they submitted for your consideration ten points of approval as the
basis of understanding.
After somewhat lengthy discussion, it was regularly moved by Mr.
Clamage that we refer it to a committee for further study and that the committee report back
at this time.
The
their meeting or
Clarence Horton,

committee was appointed with Clarence Horton as Chairman
meetings, and are now ready to report, so I will call on
for his report at this time.
Clarence!

and
our

they
Vice

have held
Chairman,

Mr. C. C. Horton:
We would like to give the names of the other members of
subcommittee who were John Walsh, Pat Cliff, Edward Clamage, Jimmy Crider.
You know, I
couldn't help, Bob, but recall Mother Goose's Winkin, Blinkin and Nod when you gave me
Clamage and Cliff and Crider.
They are a good team, though, and worked beautifully.

the

I would like to pay credit to others who came and contributed advice, counsel
and good thought.
They include, of course, Past National Commander Seaborn Collins and Past
National Commander Harry Colmery, Dr. Mellon, Dr. Shapiro of our own staff and Mr. Henderson
of the American Medical Association.
}

Before I read this, Mr. Chairman, I would like to say that we submit it to you
as a report of the subcommittee, not as some rigid, inflexible, perfect instrument, bearing
the seal and sign of complete blessedness and approval, but rather as a submission of a little
area of agreement between men of good will.
Sometimes the language may not be all that would
be

desired.

Maybe

it

doesn't

meet

the

high

standards

of

diction

and

grammar,

but

the

intent

is the important thing.
So, your committee has met and agreed that there were tentative
understandings in respect to these ten points.
With your permission I would like to read
them all and then, if necessary, try to explain what your subcommittee understood about the
separate points, our understanding of their inner meanings, and so forth, and then, of course,
it is going to be your privilege to criticize, condemn or request further explanation to

your complete satisfaction.

Point No. 1.
The number of operating beds now in existence or contemplated
the Veterans Administration, namely 131 thousand,is sufficient for the present with due
regard to the adjustment up or down as the situation may warrant.

or

hospital

local

2.
Nonservice-connected GM&S cases,
contracts, should be admitted only as

facilities

are not available.

adequately covered by workmen's compensation
an emergency or temporarily when adequate

:

3.
Veterans Administration residency training programs should be
in regard to the adequate supervision of all services rendered and comparative
for residence in VA and non-VA hospitals.
4.

Staff

liaison

should

be maintained.
=-155-

by

jointly studied
remuneration

5.
pitalization of
VA facilities.

In recognition of the fact that some veterans are unable to pay, the hosnonservice-connected GM&S cases is acceptable within the limits of existing

6.

Presumptions

7.

Both

of

ciples.

service-connection

organizations

the

best

any

abuse

type

of

medical

of

the

admission

based

upon

sound

care

for

medical

prin-

veterans.

requirements

for

non-

9.
Both organizations join in aggressively seeking an adequate program of
and treatment of mental disorders for veterans as well as the general public.

prevention

directed

be

174

favor

8.
Both organizations oppose
service-connected VA hospitalization.

should

10. Both organizations continue to study
toward improving hospitalization and medical

the possibilities of joint action
care for the American public.

Those of you who received with your packets copies of the tentative ten points
submitted by the staff here in Washington will have observed a few variances in
my report
from the one handed to you at that time.
My recollection is that the principal changes in
the subcommittee's recommendations were in Item No. 5 where an effort was made at
that time
to limit the admission of nonservice-connected cases to the chronic, the mental disorders,
and tuberculosis.
You will note
kind of desease and simply
unable to pay, all of them

that your subcommittee strikes out all reference to the type
says that, in recognition of the fact that some veterans are
should be admitted.

or

There is a little bit of twisted and somewhat awkward phraseclogy in Item No.2,
which reads as follows:
'Nonservice-connected GM&S cases, adequately covered by workmen's
compensation or hospital contracts, should be admitted only as an emergency or temporarily
when adequate local facilities are not available."
Your Chairman of the subcommittee gets this understanding out of the words,
''nonservice-connected cases adequately covered by workmen's compensation or hospital contracts should be admitted only as an emergency," or "admitted temporarily when adequate local
facilities arenot available."
That is the sense that I get from it and that is my understanding.

may,

I will

Another
just sit

member of the subcommittee doesn't quite
down now and let the questions come.

CHAIRMAN

McCURDY:

Thank

you,

Clarence.

Are

agree

there

and,

Mr.

Chairman,

if

I

comments?

MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
Mr
Horton, I
spoke on No. 1 the other day.
I want to speak on it again.
I believe that if we pass that resolution, stating that we
agree with the AMA that we have sufficient beds f6r the present, we are going to get a
terrific slamming from the veterans out in the field.
It is a matterof record that we have
about 18,000 on the waiting list.
We here in this Commission know the answers to this
question, we know why, but the public doesn't know why and, from past performances in
the
press, if they get that thing, when they publish it they are going to leave the last half of
that sentence off and they are going to make a nice headline that The American Legion has
agreed with the AMA and the Hoover Commission that we have got enough beds.
American

I think it would be
Legion if anything like

I have tried to
been able to do it to my own
the list entirely.

disastrous to our membership campaign
that ever went out, and I strenuously

see how we could
satisfaction.
I

rephrase
think we

it in
might

some way
be smart

and disastrous
object to that

to The
No. 1.

and, frankly, I haven't
if we left No. 1 off

MR. HORTON:
Fred, in response to that -- and I do appreciate what you have said,
I think I fully understand the premise from which you argue -- I would like to say again,
as I tried to express at the outset, that The American Legion is not making a compact that
we will forever live by this little tentative agreement or understanding.
On the contrary,
it is simply a ground from which we may be able to work and arrive -at other points of agreement, maybe less important or more important, but somehow to work together so that there
will not always be this continuing conflict between ourselves and their organization.

Also, you ladies and gentlemen will recall in the printed agreement handed to
you in your packet that Item No. 1, originally left out any reference whatever to the beds
but simply said that the number of operating beds now in existence or contemplated by the
Veterans Administration would be sufficient, with due regard to adjustment upward or downward for tubercular, neuropsychiatric and chronic cases.
-156-

ior

ii ~tn, \C

Now, your subcommittee says we won't go that far.
In the first place, you
The Congress has said, and we have been informed by all
How many beds?
have to be specific.
concerned, that 131 thousand is the present program and is all the contemplated beds that
we are going to have any. time soon, so we said we are not going to tie them down to anything.
We are going to reinsert the number one three one thousand and we are not going to say, with
regard to adjustment up or down for these particular types of cases but we are going to say,
on the contrary, that with adjustment up or down as the situation warrants, we will go along
with this.
I think we might as well agree right now (this is personal thinking and don't
:
let me be offensive because that is not at all my desire); I think we should agree right here
and now whether we want to have any tentative understanding
of agreement.
If we don't then
let's just not have any.
But if we are going to try to arrive at a little ground upon which
we can meet each other as good Americans, interested not only in the welfare of veterans but
in the welfare of all the citizenship of this country, let us just say that we will not
quibble over minor things with which we are not in complete agreement but, on the contrary,
that if we can get the consent of our conscience to yield a bit and take a bit, that maybe
it will all ultimately work out to our good.
MR. BROWNING:
I am fully in accord with getting all the agreement we can with
The American Medical Association.
I think that is the proper way to go at this thing, but I
still think, when we go out and read this, "Sufficient beds for the present,'" almost every
day and sometimes several times a day, I have parents coming into my office asking,
"What
can you do about getting my boy out of the mental institution at Howard into a VA hospital?
He is a veteran and he is entitled to VA hospitalization"; and if you think they don't get
tough, you sit at my desk for a week and you will find out.
It happens all the
man, can tell those people that
we haven't got enough beds.

time and I don't see how I,
I am satisfied that we have

as a service officer
got enough beds when

and a rehab
I know

I know the picture.
I appreciate the stand of the conference but aren't they go-ing to say to me, '"You sold us down the river, you quit supporting us?" I am telling you,
it is packed with dynamite.
I appreciate both sides of the picture but if that thing ever
gets out in the Providence Journal, I will have to move out of Rhode Island.
I think it is
packed with dynamite.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I certainly agree with the basic premise and, personally, I
don't think that this violates a basic premise.
It says '"for the present."
"For the present
means to me, 'mow.'
You heard the report of the Chairman of the Veterans Affairs Committee
of the House last night and what he had to say about the hospitals that are immediately going to be built.
Those have been authorized heretofore
and they are now going to start on
the undertaking of building them.
Now, if we wanted to go on record as of this minute to
build some more beds, it would be two, three, four years before we could possibly accomplish
this means.

tr

All this says is that we both agree to build those now authorized, and Mr. Teague
is reporting the bill out for appropriation this week.
There is a long process in this and,
where they have never consented before to the 131 thousand beds and have consistently tried to
block our appropriation and authorization for these new hospitals, they now agree that they
will no longer do that and, from a practical viewpoint, let's get this bill through, let's
work together on it, let's get them built, and then when we get this built we have kept the
door open and have an opportunity, together, to reconsider.
In their first draft of this thing they said, themselves, "With due regard for
the future need of the NP's and the TB's and the chronics" and it is as clear a statement
as you can get and, as far as accomplishing anything is concerned, it certainly is doing
just one thing.
They agree not to oppose appropriations for those beds authorized.
They
agree to sit down with you and reinspect the situation as soon as it is politically practical,
and we keep the subject wide open.
It.is not a closed issue and we are not agreeing for
all time.
As a matter of
needed, and I see

as

and

if

as

this

was

(Miss Tomlinson
a meeting of the

fact, they are for
nothing wrong with
of Philadelphia
Commission.)

building the NP beds
it, myself, at all.

asked

for

the

floor

and

‘and

was

the

chronic

ruled

out

beds

of

when,

order

MR. BROWNING:
Bob, I appreciate everything you said and I don't feel that we
should ask for any more hospitals at the present time, especially mental hospitals.
We can't
staff them.
That, we know, but I still say if we can come out and say at the present time
that we have sufficient beds, we are going to get a terrific bang from our veterans in the
field and the families and everybody else who are trying to support the veteran.
I think we
had better let that alone.
-157-

say that
thousand

I understand the picture and so do you, but the public does not, and for us to
we have sufficient beds at the present time when we know we have got eighteen
veterans that are not in hospitals, who should be, I think it is better left unsaid.
MR.

HORTON:

Are

there

any

other

comments

with

respect

to

Point

No.

1?

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I think probably, as bettertechnique, on these paragraphs on
which there is debate or some dissension, that we had better pass it as we go; or, if you
want to, we can follow convention technique and hold this one until we have gone clear through
all of the points and adopted such of those as you may care to, and then come back to the
individual ones that have been debated.
We will do that.
That is usual convention procedure
and I guess that would be the better way.
We will hold No. 1.
:

|
|
D

JUDGE ALTER:
Mr. Chairman, and members of the Commission:
I have great respect for the members of the subcommittee that drafted No. 2 and, perhaps due to my stupidity
I don't understand No. 2.
I read No. 2 and by my interpretation -- well, let me read it,
"'"nonservice-connected GM&S cases adequately covered by workmen's compensation or hospital contracts shall be admitted only as emergency or temporarily when adequate local facilities are
not available."
>
I interpret that to mean that if adequate local facilities are available they
may remain in the Veterans Hospital forever.
Now, I think that there is a negative there.
I think that you have either got to take out "as emergency" or "temporarily," and then I
think you must take out "not".
If you take out "not", then that would read, "if local
facilities are available."
They are only to remain in the VA hospital, nonservice-connected;
they are only to remain in the VA hospital when local facilities are available.
Isn't that
correct?
MR.

HORTON:

Yes,

sir.

-

{

JUDGE ALTER:
Then, why do you say -- you tell me what your intent is.
My
intent, as I read it, it says just exactly the opposite.
It says that they shall be received
as emergency or temporarily when local facilities are not available.
The "not'" destroys
the whole thing.
If there are local facilities available, then they remain in the VA hospital, notwithstanding the fact that they have workmen's compensation.

/

MR. HORTON:
No, sir, that isn't quite right, Judge.
If you would let me try
to explain to you now, first of all, I want to disclaim any responsibility for the verbiage
or phraseology used here.
It was prepared by the masterminds of the staff, I suppose, and
handed to us first in the form of the mimeographed sheet that you recéived in your packet,
sir.

|

When' your subcommittee met, we were a little bit puzzled by its contents and
we had to make a few changes also, but we did get this understanding.
Let me present it or
express it to you, if I can, and then you stand right on your feet and tell me wherein I am
failing to make it clear.

|

"Nonservice-connected GM&S cases,when they are adequately covered by workmen's
compensation or when they are adequately covered by hospital contracts, shall always be
admitted, even as an emergency, or they shall be admitted temporarily, when otherwise adequate
local facilities are not available."

to

3
a VA

JUDGE ALTER:
As I underatand
Hospital in an emergency.
MR.

HORTON:

Yes,

sir,

under

it,

any

the

nonservice-connected

cases

are

admitted

circumstances.

JUDGE ALTER:
Under any circumstances.
Now, why is that word '"not' there?
You
may get cne meaning out of it and I may get another, but I say that ought to read, 'Nonservice GM&S cases adequately covered by workmen's compensation, or hospital benefits, should
be treated in local facilities if they are available, except for the temporary emergencies."
MR.

HORTON:

JUDGE
MR.

ALTER:

HORTON:

JUDGE

ALTER:

MR. HORTON:
turn it around so.that we
acceptable?
JUDGE

ALTER:

Yes,

sir,

That
You

isn't

mean

Your

that

you

is

what

our
you

don't

understanding

understanding.
say.

understand

and my

Would you permit me to say
make it a sort of positive

If

that

word

"not"

is
-158-

that

I say

understanding
we will
instead

taken

out,

be
of

I

it.

I do

understand

makes

no

difference.

it,

glad to try to rewrite it and
a negative and make it more

think

it

will

satisfy

me.

4

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
You have all heard the Judge's version.
I believe he expresses
the thought contained in a different way than it is in this one.
Would there be any objection if we asked the Judge to ‘write that out and substitute it for this No. 2, so that
we can get along?
QUESTION:
that?

interpret

that

he

What

does

the

word

''adequate''

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I don't have
fully covered for hospitalization

is

DR.

SHAPIRO:

And

proper

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Is there any
with what the special committee meant to say
does -- certainly it is all right to have it
Judge, just write that out for us, will you?
MR.
ment

on

this.

It

HORTON:
is just

CHAIRMAN
MR.

in your

judgment?

Will

you

a dictionary here but
and medical expenses.

"adequate'

means

to me

specialties,

mean

everything

--

it means

McCURDY:

Now,

Mike,

I thought

he

is

covered.

objection if we reword that?
It is in accordance
and if that clarifies it -- and it apparently
in that language.
If there is no objection,

Thank you very much Judge, and thank you Bob.
a matter of how best to express ourselves.

MARKOWITZ:

that

we

are

meeting

as

I had

been

knocked

down

We

are

all

in agree-

a commission.
for

a moment.

MR. HORTON:
Now, we come down to point No.3 and I am going to rush you along as
best we can and, with your cooperation, try to get through this.
'"Veterans Administration
residency program should be jointly studied by the AMA and The American Legion in regard
to the adequate supervision of everything they do, all the services rendered and comparative
remuneration for residents in VA and non-VA hospitals.'
(No objection).
Item

No.

4,

"Liaison

should

be maintained.!"

(No

objection)

No. 5, "In recognition of the fact that some veterans are unable to pay,
hospitalization of nonservice-connected GM&S cases is acceptable within the limits of
ing VA facilities."
MR. BURNS, Wisconsin:
Mr. Chairman, I don't think there has
sideration given to those cases where they are service connected going in
connected disability.
CHAIRMAN

MCCURDY:

You

are

speaking

of

the
exist-

been any confor nonservice-

nonservice-connected?

MR. BURNS:
No, I am talking about where they have a heart disability, serviceconnected, and a veteran may need a serious operation.
All right, I think he should have
some priority and not be considered as a nonservice-connected case in the category of all
these other nonservice-connected cases.
I wonder whether the committee took into consideration
the fact that we have a great number of men that are totally disabled with one
disability and I think they should have priority next to service-connected disability in
a case going in for treatment of service-cdonnection.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
system

and

of

this

This has nothing to do with a disturbance of the present

priorities.

is

MR. HORTON:
one of them.
Item

No.

There

are

many

points,

of

course,

that

we

did

not

go

into,

Jim,

6 --

MR. BALDAUF, Nebraska:
1 would like to clarify a point there.
if we are saying there, in effect, when we say "existing facilities,' if we
that the existing facilities are adequate.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
No, that is the law at the present
admitted if there is a bed available, and this is a reiteration of
on hospitalizationof the nonservice-connected.
MR.

HORTON:

Thank

you.

No.

6;

I

think

Any

further

comments

"Presumption

of

service-connection

there

could

be

no

"Both

organizations

on

should

I am wondering
are granting

time, that they
our traditional

that

particular

be

upon

based

are
stand

item?
sound

medical

for

veterans."

principle."

Item

7,

objection
favor

to
the

-159-

that.
best

(No
type

objection)

of medical

care

It was handed to us with the word "available inserted and we removed that.
We were handed a copy which read, 'both organizations favor the best available type of
medical care for veterans," and we thought it would be stronger if we removed the word
"available" and made it 'best type."
No. 8, "Both organizations oppose
nonservice-connected VA hospitalization."
(No

of

the

in aggressively
for veterans as

admission

seeking
well as

requirements

an adequate
the general

program of
public."

Item 10, "Both organizations will continue to study the possibilities
action directed toward improving hospitalization and medical care for the American
a general statement I know you all approve.

were

MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
In the original
points.
We decided to eliminate No. 11.

eleven

MR. HORTON:
Items 3 to

a motion that
and the AMA.

for

—

"No. 9, "Both organizations join
prevention and treatment of mental disorders
(No comment)

any abuse
comment)

copy

that

came

to

the

of joint
public,"

subcommittee

there

Thank you for the comment.
The Chair will be happy to entertain
8 be adopted as areas of tentative understanding between the Legion

MR. CLIFF:
In view of the fact that I made a statement on Monday and was
appointed on this committee by the Chairman, I think this morning I would like to say this.
I still feel that there are some things in here, as I stated Monday, that might better not
be said and I agree with the gentleman from Rhode Island; but I think the understanding we
had,

Mr.

Chairman,

maybe

might

opposition, as I feel myself,
of tentative understanding.
CHAIRMAN

an

McCURDY:

area

of

tentative

CHAIRMAN

8
ploration

That

to

that

is

the

this

Commission,

is

McCURDY:

MR. HORTON:

That

is

--

is

that

an

that

maybe

agreement.

they

This

would

have

just

an

is

less

area
|

points

CLIFF:

of

That

is

(The

'mo."

:

to mean

those

particular

areas

are

for

ex-

correct.

Would you like to effer a motion we adopt this?
With

tentative

motion

correct?

correct.

that

area

of

understanding,

was

Mr.

Chairman, I

will

move

the

adoption

of

understanding.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
TI rule that points
discussion and the motion I accepted was from 3 to
of 3 to 10?

oppose

not

correct.

MR. CLIFF:
And I interpret that
not for anything permanent.

and

MR.

ten

out

understanding

CHAIRMANMcCURDY:.

the

put

MR. CLIFF:
‘I think there is some danger of adverse publicity coming out because
commitments.
I think some of these statements are almost impossible of adminisbut in view of the fact that the Liaison Committee assured the subcommittee that
not an agreement between the American Medical Association and The American Legion

of these
tration,
this was
but

be

knowing

regularly

I and 2 have been held
10.
Is there a sécond

pending further
to the adoption

seconded.)

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Are you ready for the question?
All in favor
Points 3 to 10 are adopted and we will now come back to No. 1.

say

"aye";

MR. HORTON: = Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Let me make another effort to understand
and see whether or not we approve Item No. 1.
Before doing that, however, may we read to
you the opening paragraph of the tentative understanding.
It says exactly this, Mr. Cliff;
"Areas of tentative understanding recommended by American Legion, American Medical Association
Liaison Committee to be referred through channels to the policy-making body of each organization."
So, it is clearly stated at the very outset that this is only a tentative under‘standing, that we are not making a sacred compact.
;

3
&

Item No. 1, "The number of operating beds now in existence or contemplated by
the Veterans Administration, namely, 131 thousand, is sufficient for the present with due
regard to the adjustment up or down as the situation may warrant."
Is

there

CHAIRMAN
an

a motion?
McCURDY:

For

purposes

of discussion,

item.
-160-

let's

get

it

on

the

floor

as

3

MR. CLAMAGE:
We went over both items, the original proposal and this amended
one.
The original was a bit ambiguous and did.not indicate the. number of beds that we really
were thinking about, and we decided, in view of the fact that there are about 108 thousand
beds being occupied, leavinga difference of 23 thousand, that we were very liberal and that
we would avoid criticism if we would use this established figure that we have been talking
about for a long time; and this would be more of a safeguard to the program by inserting 131
thousand.
’
What impresses me, of course, is that we had in here, "is sufficient for the
present."
In view of the fact that the date of this conference is inserted, I think this
is pretty much of an assured feeling among all concerned that we are honest with the veterans
“up and down the line,
I can see no harm in inserting 131 thousand, indicating, of course,
to all concerned that if we have the 131 thousand, there would be no reason for a waiting list,
and in view of what has been repeated here this morning by Chairman McCurdy, as to what
Congressman Teague had said last evening, I am certain that we are assured of the type of
support that we are looking for.

was

We
a statement

were
that

all happy to hear
we had had little

Accordingly,
CHAIRMAN
(The

Mr.

McCURDY:

motion

CHAIRMAN

was

McCURDY:

Chairman,
Is

It

I move

there

regularly
is

J

the congressmen
or no knowledge

a

the

second

offer that
about.

adoption

of

report

paragraph

to

the

motion?

moved

and

seconded

last

night

No.

1.

and

that

seconded)
regularly

that

No.

1 be

approved.

;
MR. KANTER, Pennsylvania:
This No. 1 is probably well taken from a technical
standpoint but let me give this example in the Philadelphia area.
We have 500 beds there
for about three million population.
Now, if we go back and tell them we have enough beds,
and for no particular reason we say, "Well we all agree that it is okay," it is going to be
a pretty tough problem to sell to the rank and file, to the thousands who are awaiting
hospitalization in the Philadelphia area.
I oppose this particular No. 1 point as very
impractical.
MR. CLIFF:
Mr. Chairman, I think that this matter has raised a point which
everybody should watch out for.
The thing is that they have some mislocated beds in this
country and we are too apt to go on the basis that the overall beds, some of which are in
areas where they don't need beds -- that we take that statement of fact as being sufficient.
As I said on Monday, a bed in North Dakota won't help anybody in Pennsylvania and, instead
of getting at the specific issue of the thing, I think -- and I am only issuing the warning,
Mr. Chairman -- that we should be very careful to make admissions on overall beds as affecting the whole picture, and particularly local situations.
In
of

this

you

have

a provision

for

adjustment

which

it

seems

to me

does

take

care

it.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
provides,
words, if

"with due regard
Philadelphia has

excluded

from

any

area

of

That

is what

I wanted

to bring out.

No.

1 within

itself,

to adjustment up or down as the situation may warrant."
that situation, it has due regard for that situation and
agreement

or

In
it

other
is

understanding.

MR. CALLAGHAN, Montana:
Mr. Chairman, last year at this time we in the conference found out that the boys that were put on these various committees to work out our
difficulties had made some progress.
I feel at this time that we are merely taking the chips
off of each other's shoulders and are out in the open willing to talk about our various
problems.
I will agree that we shall never tell anybody that we have enough beds, and I
don't believe we are telling anybody that.
:
Here is one thing that I would like to impress upon a lot of service officers
in this meeting.
When they go back to their states, they are going to have to answer a lot
of questions as to how they came out with the American Medical Association.
I think these
boys who have been on the committee that has tried to adjust these difficulties have done
a hell of-a good job and we should go back and say that we are out in the open now and, to
me, the most important thing that has been done is that the American Medical Association
has agreed not to buck the admittance of nonservice-connected cases.
That is winning the
battle, to me, and yet if they don't agree to that, then they are going to have to go along
with it to take care of anybody seeking admittance, so I don't think we are committing
ourselves telling the public that we are satisfied with the present setup.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I think you have put your finger on the crux of the whole
: thing in the matter, that is, that the most important thing is not stated; the matter of
the most importance that is not stated is that we agree to call the dogs off .each other.
You remember how much heat was generated by both organizations, how serious efforts were

e161

That point was certainly one well taken.
I see no harm in it at all and I want
to call your attention to this, that we are taking the action first, that if you think it is
difficult for us here when you get a group of doctors in the room, wouldn't we be in a
:
beautifully strong position to come out here and say,
''Yes, we have an area of understanding.
"We will have an area that we can have further discussions.
We will keep together in a spirit
of democracy and good will,’ and then have them refuse it.
I think it puts us in a pretty
strong position, and I am positive that we are not giving anything away.
We are not receding
from any position that we have ever had.
We are not saying that we limit it to this, that
or the other.
Everything is qualified, and I certainly see no harm in it.

—

made to discredit our program and, in turn, to discredit theirs, and while I am willing te
take one on like that and I have no fear of the outcome, and I restate that I am still going
to take it on, I think it is to the best interest of all of us if we can get together at some
point where we don't sharp shoot and try to discredit each other to the American public.

MR. CRIDER, Tennessee:
Mr. Chairman, could I make this short observation?
We
are trying to reach an agreement between two organizations that in the past have not been
together; their differences have had wide publicity.
It appears to me that on this first
proposed agreement, if there is a sacrifice to be made, the American Medical Association
would have to make the sacrifice to agree to this, because in the past I would say 50 thousand
beds would be more than they would agree upon, and if we come up with an agreement here, I
think they are going to be making the sacrifice.

|

MR. BARRETT, North Carolina:
Mr. Chairman, it seems to me that if the phraseology
was changed slightly, that this No. 1 would be much more acceptable to those of us here, and
I would suggest that it read as follows:
''The number of operating beds now in existence
with those contemplated by the Veterans Administration, will be sufficient for the present
time,''et cetera.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
We know that 131 thousand is
it.
Is there any further discussion?
Are you ready for the
adoption of No. 1.
It has been regularly moved and seconded
favor say "aye'; opposed, "mo."
( a few "noes" heard.)
The
just

want

please

so

the

raise

Commission

your

hands.

Down.

All

members

those

to

vote,

opposed

and

please

all

the

raise

your

the number and that qualifies
question?
We are voting on the
that it be approved.
All in
"ayes" have it.
To be sure, I

Commission

hands.

members

The

who

"ayes"

favor

have

it

will:

and

it

is

ordered.

L4
Now

we

JUDGE

will
ALTER:

go

to
I

No.

2.

Judge,

have

have,

Mr.

Chairman,

you

and

I

your

proposed

draft

would

suggest

that

ready?
No.

2

read

as

follows:
'Nonservice-connected GM&S cases adequately covered by workmen's compensation or
hospital contracts should be admitted to VA hospitals on an emergent and temporary basis
when adequate local facilities are available." That would .be my suggested amendment and I
think it is clear.
CHAIRMAN

McCURDY:

basis."

CHAIRMAN

adoption

as

McCURDY:

I

say

''should

admitted

think

you

only

to VA

need

be

admitted?"

hospitals

on

with

CHAIRMAN

the

motion?

McCURDY:

CLIFF:

I will

McCURDY:

MR. BARRETT:
Does
Veterans Administration?

Is

there

second

a

an

(
emergent

and

temporary

it.
and

CHAIRMAN

the

you

JUDGE ALTER:
I will be glad to add it
No, 2 in the report of the Committee.

MR.

of

Did

JUDGE ALTER:
"Should be
I could add the word "only."

second

to

that

addition,

I move

its

and

regulations

it.

Is

there

any

further

that

not

make

that

discussion?

contrary

to

current

laws

the

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
This doesn't change the law of the Veterans Administration
one iota.
They still can't refuse it. If the man comes in and qualifies, whether he has it
or not, they are going to continue to do it.
All it means is that we agree to discuss this
matter further.
It would require legislation to change it.

"ayes"

have

Will

somebody

Are you ready for: the question?
it and it is so ordered.
Now, I will just take
move the adoption of

one
the

All

in

favor

say

"aye";

more motion on the adoption
report of the Committee?
-162-

of

all

opposed,

the

report

"no."

as

The

a whole.

MR.

CLAMAGE:

MR.

CLIFF:

I

I move

the

adoption

second

the

motion.

as
is

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It
amended, be approved.
so ordered.

Commission

of

Will
the

—

committee
it and it

will

go

into

of

the

report

the

National

I will now, hearing no objeceion,
the Conference meeting.

recess

(At

Commission

o'clock

the

the

ten

points,

as

amended.

has been moved and seconded that the report of the subAll in favor say "aye''; opposed, "mo."
The "ayes" have

Mrs. Zeller please come forward,
American Legion Auxiliary.

ten

on

meetingof

the

the

Chairman

meeting

was

of

of

the

the

Rehabilitation

Commission

recessed

and

we

and

the

Conference

I would

like

to

reconvened.)
CHAIRMAN
the

Chief

Medical

McCURDY:

Director

DR.

WILLIAM

of

S.

For
the

the

purpose

United

States

MIDDLETON:

Mr.

of

a presentation,

Veterans

McCurdy,

Administration,

Friends:

It

is

Dr.

an

present

Middleton.

unusual

pleasure

to be here this morning because it is in recognition of services over and beyond the
duty of a citizen that we are reading two communications recognizing services by two
associates.
The first of this is to Mrs. Zeller.

ordinary
of your

"It is my pleasure to extend to you on behalf of the Veterans Administration
staff our sincere appreciation for the devoted work of the national representatives and
alternate national representatives of the Auxiliary on our National VAVS Advisory Committee
over the past ten years since the inception of the Veterans Administration Voluntary Service.
"You, of course, know that the Auxiliary has been
an active member organization
of the National VAVS Committee since the committee was established in April 1946.
Mrs. Norton
H. Pearl, then National President of the Auxiliary, participated with representatives of
the Legion and six other veteran and welfare groups and members of our Central Office staff
in a conference on April 8, 1946, at which plans were formed for the VA Service Program.
"Beginning with Mrs. Pearl, the list of ladies of the Auxiliary who have played
a leading part in the work of the National VAVS Committee reads like a Who's Who of the
Auxiliary itself.
Serving as National VAVS representatives and alternate representatives
have been the following:
Mrs. William Cashman, Mrs. Lee W. Hutton, Mrs. Hubert Goode, Mrs.
Ward McAllister, Mrs. Charles W. Gunn, Mrs. Leonard J. Bradley, Mrs. Norman L. Scheehe, Mrs.
E. A. Campbell, Mrs. John Engesather, Mrs. Harold S. Burnett, Mrs. Alvin G. Strum , Mrs.
Omar J. McMackin, Mrs. Barton Oplinger. Mrs. Omar J. McMackin is presently serving as the
Auxiliary's National Representative on the National VAVS Committee and Mrs. Barton Oplinger
is serving as her alternate representative.
"It would take a couple of volumes to describe the important assignments which
the ladies of the Auxiliary have accepted and completed so helpfully on the National VAVS
Committee.
I should like to mention a few of the many, however, as an indicationof the
Auxiliary's splendid support of our efforts.

Subcommittee

.

"Mrs. Hubert Goode, National Representative
on Orientation and Indoctrination Volunteer

as

"Mrs.
of our

Chairman

1948, served as Chairman
Hospital Workers.

Charles W. Gunn, National Representative
Subcommittee on Recommendations.

in

1949

and

again

in

of

our

'5l,

served

"Mrs. John Engesather, National Representative from '52 to '55, served as a
member of our Subcommittee on
Recommendations for two years.
Her alternate Representative,
Mrs. Alvin G. Strum , participated in the analysis and evaluation of VA Volunteer Service at
the Veterans Administration Hospital, Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, in 1954.
"Mrs. Omar J. McMackin is presently serving as a member of our Subcommittee on
Use of Activities in VA Voluntary service and our Subcommittee on Turnover in Volunteer
Workers.
Her altermate,
Mrs. Barton Oplinger, is serving as a member of our Subcommittee
in planning the coming meeting of the National VAVS Committee.
"The
briefly

outlined

work
and

of

the

indicsted

national
has

and

been

alternate

most

national

helpfully

representatives

suggested

over

the

which

I

by

the

years

Auxiliary National Presidents and the top leaders' backing is our first essential.
needed any evidence of that, you heard Mrs, Zeller's most eloquent appeal to us as
Legionnaires for support.’
"Again,
Auxiliary

National

space

does

Presidents.

not
As

permit
an

a

full

indication

-163-

outline
of

of

support,

the

fine

however,

have

If you
male.

cooperation

of

I

attention

call

your

the

to

an

article

over

the

signature

of

the

Past

National

President,

Mrs.

Willis

C.

Reed

in

American Legion Magazine for September 1951.
The article is entitled, "A Miracle in the
tals," and has this subtitle:
"How a Commonsense Pulicy for Service In VA Hospitals Has
Off In Five Years, as Shown in the Story of a Model Housewife and her Family."

the

Hospi-Paid

;
"In addition, I would like to express my thanks to Mrs. Jane Rishworthand the
members of her National Headquarters Staff with whom it has been our pleasure to work.
The
Auxiliary has a long and noteworthy record of service to veteran patients and domiciliary
members.
Your organization maintained this volunteer service over the years at times when
there were no flags waving and no bands playing; at times when, unfortunately, many of our
citizens did not remember.
Your long and devoted service as well as the fundamental purpose
of your organization has given us a position and given you the position of leadership in
voluntary service.

hd

:
"You have recognized responsibilities which such leadership gives you.
You have
most ably and helpfully joined your efforts to ours to make ever more purposeful the volunteer
effort of your organization and of other organizations working with you in the voluntary service program.
"Through your training schools for volunteers, through your national and area
meetings and through your Conference of Department Presidents and Secretaries, you have told
the story of meaningful voluntary service to the officials and members of the auxiliaries
throughout the country.

"Through your national representatives on the National VAVS Advisory Committee,
you have ably assisted us in telling
this story to other organizations.
As we observe this
year the tenth anniversary of our volunteer program, we in the Central Office staff of the
Veterans Administration pay tribute to the officials of the Auxiliary with whom it has been
our pleasure to work in planning this nationwide program of service.

{

"The theme that has been chosen for the observance of the tenth birthday of our
volunteer program is, ''VA Voluntary Service Dedicated Devotion, Citizen Participation, with
Government in Service Hospitalized Veterans."
We feel that this theme serves as an excellent
description of the volunteer program and equally of the fine work of your national representatives, past and present, and their co-workers on the Veterans Administration Voluntary
Service National Advisory Committee.
We count on your counsel and advice as VA Voluntary
Service enters its second decade of devoted service."
It

is

a privilege

and

an

honor

to

sign

my

name,

William

S.

|

Middleton.

MRS. CARL ZELLER:
Dr. Middleton, I accept this treasured document in the name
of the more than twenty thousand volunteer workers of the American Legion Auxiliary.
I am
confident that this recognition will inspire them to do even greater service in the years
ahead.
I thank you.
DR.

MIDDLETON:

No

such

recognition

would

be

complete

without

a word

to

Bob

McCurdy:
"Dear

Mr.

McCurdy:

"I am pleased to have this opportunity to express to you, and through you to the
members of the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission, our sincere appreciation of
your and their assistance in the Veterans Administration Voluntary Service Program.
I wish
particularly to thank Mr. T. O
Kraabel, the Legion's National Representative on VAVS National
Advisory Committee, and his alternate National Representative, Mr. William A. Andresen, for
their cooperation with the members of the staff in the Department of Medicine and Surgery in
this program.
"As you know, The American Legion has been a member organization of the VAVS
National Advisory Committee since the Committee's establishment in April 1946, and Mr. Kraabel
and Mr. Andresen have served as the Legion's representatives on the national committee since
the beginning of the VA Voluntary Service.
At the initial planning session of April 8, 1946,
when the leaders of eighty-six of our country's veteran and welfare and service organizations
met with the members of the Central Office staff of the Veterans Administration to discuss
coordination of volunteer assistance in our hospital and domiciliary programs, The American
Legion was represented by Mr. Kraabel and the late Mr. Jack Oakey.
"Mr. Kraabel served last year as the Chairman of our Subcommittee on planning
the seventeenth meeting of the National VAVS Committee.
He has servedas a member of our
Subcommittee on the Planning for the Patient's Discharge since the establishment of that
important subcommittee in September 1951, and I attempted before the Commission yesterday to
emphasize the importance of this planning for discharge of veterans.
He also served as a
member of the Subcommittee Planning the workshop session at the annual meeting of the National
VAVS Committee in February 1954.
This workshop sessiom provided an invaluable opportunity
for the National VAVS representatives to analyze their responsibilities in the program.and to
-164-

©

discuss ways and means to
hospital VAVS committees,

improve contacts
and I cannot too

between
greatly

them and their
emphasize that

local counterparts
point.

on

the

:
"Mr
Andresen, who is Mr. Kraabel's alternate on the national committee, is
currently serving as Chairman of our Subcommittee on Public Information, and we need him.
This important subcommittee has as its major mission to assist in telling the general public
the story of the work of the volunteers.
Mr. Andresen has served as a member of our Subcommittee on Recommendations, on our Subcommittee on Participation by Men in the Volunteer
Programs.
He also participated in the analysis and evaluation of the’ VA voluntary service at
the Veterans Administration hospital, Wilkes-Barre Hospital, in 1954.
"We are most appreciative of the leadership which you, Bob McCurdy, and Mr.
Kraabel have shown in informing the members of the Legion about the opportunities for men
again, men -- to assist in the volunteer program.
Your recently published Handbook for
Volunteer Hospital Workers, prepared by Mr. Cecil H. Munson, with the assistance of other
members of your staff, is an outstanding example of such leadership, and those of you who
have not read it should read it as your bible in this particular relation.
"We trust that the Legion
with which you conclude this Handbook.
The American Legion will send over more
this nationwide program.

the

--

throughout the country will take to heart the message
We hope, as you say in this concluding message, that
and more Joes to participate with Auxiliary Janes in

"it ‘is, 1 feel, significant to note that The American Legion
predominantly men's groups to publish a Handbook on Volunteer Service

is the first of
for its members.

“Another significant example of your leadership in our program of community
voluntary participation is your inclusion of a session on VA voluntary service in your program
at the National Rehabilitation Conferences. It is only through such opportunities for mutual
exchange of thinking and planning that we can build an increasingly effective program of
truly meaningful volunteer assistance and community understanding of its role in the care
and treatment of patients and members in the domiciliaries, the forgotten members, forgotten
veterans.
"We have been most encouraged by. the assistance which the National Rehabilitation Commission has given us in the programs
in planning for the patient's discharge.
In
addition to the counsel and advice which we have’ received
from your National VAVS representatives, we are appreciative of the fine interest of Dr. H. D. Shapiro, your Senior
Medical Consultant, as shown in this challenging program =-=- and if he is silent now, it is
the first time he has been silent since I have known him.

veterans
role

is

over

"As of course you know,
not new.
The Legion and

the

years

in

this

field

volunteer assistance
in programs for hospitalized
its Auxiliary have played an active and most helpful

of

service.

It

has

been

most

heartwarming,

therefore,

that

your two organizations have taken a leading role in the inception of the VA voluntary service
plan in assisting in our endeavors to educate volunteer workers and our staff members alike
in the new opportunities for service and, correspondingly, in the new responsibilities of
co-workers on the hospital team.
"Such an educational program is, of necessity, a long-range job.
You and Mr.
Kraabel and the members of the National Rehabilitation Commission staff have provided top
leadership in this respect for the Legion.
The National Field Service Representatives of
the Legion have provided invaluable assistance in this campaign of education in more purposeful community volunteer service.
As committee members on National VAVS committee, Mr. Kraabel
and Mr. Andresen have given our Central Office staff most helpful cooperation in stimulating
"the interest and participation of others of the veterans and welfare groups in the VA
voluntary service.
"The

work

of

our

National

VAVS

representatives,

the

work

on the National Committee, give a very real significance to the theme
for the observation of this year's tenth anniversary of our Voluntary
not

of

their

that has
Service,

colleagues

been chosen
which I shall

repeat.

"We look forward to your continued working together
in this fine program in
the future with us as we have worked together in the past, dnd I am very humble in signing
this recognition, through letter, to Mr, Bob McCurdy, our Chairman."

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:

I am sure

that all

the members

of the Commission

feel highly

honored at such recognition and I would like to make a few remarks of acceptance but if I did
that, I would be a phony.
Really, all I have been is an authorizing agent and I give full
credit to T. O. and his fine staff who have been in this work since its inception and who have
brought this fine citation about.
It was no effort.on my part at all but it was on T. 0.'g
part and on the part of the staff, and so I would like to have T. 0. officially accept this
for his records and to make the official acceptance.
Our Director, Mr. T. O. Kraabel.
MR.

T.

O.

KRAABEL:

Thank

you,

:

Bob,

Mrs.

Zeller,

Dr.

Middleton,

|

Administrator

-163od

Harvey Higley:
The matter of recognition of what service officers do has always lodged in
that inner feeling of satisfaction that comes unheralded but also on the record from the
messages and letters from thbse people.
When something like this happens, you sort of get a glow out of it and it does
add to the reserve of morale, stamina and I am sure that all of us on the staff who were
cited in the letter as well as those who help us, the staff of the National Rehabilitation
Commission, are very, very grateful and appreciate this very much, Mr. Higley and Dr. Middleton.
Thank you, Bob.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I don't know much about the achievement and accomplishment
at the national level.
I shall continue to work in my post.
Day after tomorrow at nine
o'clock in the morning, my District Hospital and Patients' Welfare Commission meets.
We meet
once a month and the rascals meet for breakfast on .Sunday morning, and it is really kind
of rugged, but I have agreed to be their speaker at the meeting day after tomorrow morning
and 1 will have 150 boys and girls there to whom I am going to bring this message and this
citation.
I know that they, too, will be reinspired, although they are the most dedicated
people in all the world and don't need too much inspiration.
They really work.
So, I will
carry on the best I can through my post.
MR. CLAMAGE, Illinois:
Mr. Chairman, I believe that all of us were deeply
impressed with the presentation of the documents to the American Legion Auxiliary and to us
The American Legion, and particularly to our Chairman, Bob McCurdy.
It strikes me that in
view of the fact that Dr. Middleton had drafted such long reports, and they are pretty well
personalized, and there has gone into these documents those items that are so well known
to all of us, that we should say it is with deep appreciation that we find that the Doctor
has taken so much time to draft these lengthy reports, and to all of us, they are highly
appreciated, as well, of course, as the direct recipients.

4

of

Since the Commission is in session at this time, I would like to offer the
motion that the Commission add to the thanks and appreciation already offered by Chairman
McCurdy and Rehab Director Kraabel; that we, too, express our deep and sincere appreciation
for the tribute and the honor that Dr. Middleton has paid to us as the American Legion
Auxiliary and The American Legion Rehabilitation Commission.

(The

that

we

express

McCURDY:

motion

was

Is

ourselves

there

regularly

by

to

motion?

a second

All

in favor

(The

and

applauded.)

arose

vote

the

of

thanks.

seconded.)

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
audience

a rising

ay,

I move

CHAIRMAN

please

rise.

4
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Certainly one of the highlights of all these conferences is
the
appearance
of the Administrator of Veterans Affairs and he has most graciously
consented
to come here this Friday morning and give us his time and his message
and, in turn, receive
your questions, and so I want to introduce the Administrator of Veterans
Affairs, our Comrade
Harvey Highley.
THE
stretch.

talk,

he

HONORABLE

HARVEY

HIGLEY:

Thank

you,

Bob.

That

was

a nice

seventh

The

last

time

inning

:

got

I am glad to know
off on Swedish or

that T, 0.
Norwegian,

can talk English,
or something.

too.

I heard

him

I want to add one word -- and by the way, this is going to be off the
cuff this
morning.
I hope you won't mind.
I would rather Just talk to you than give you a speech that
has been very carefully worded.
I hope I won't say things that will either mislead you or get
me into trouble, but I think both of us will enjoy it if we just
plain talk this morning.

I am very much interested in this VAVS program.
I just want to add one word,
if I may, please, and that is, I think there is room for a
lot of work on the part of
Legionnaires.
The women have done a marvelous job in all of our hospitals -- and
of course
in any hospital, as a matter of fact, where there are veterans, not necessarily
VA hospitals.
There is much work that Legionnaires can do, and I mention it because I
think it is a little
bit hard for a Legion post to get started on this kind of work.
You fellows are in hospital work, I know.
Practically everyone in this room
probably is.
You have been broughtup in it.
You have been doing it a long time.
It is
second nature.
But I am talking about the tremendous number of fellows who have
had little
connection with it.
I think you have got to lead them by the hand, show them what
they might
be able to do and get them interested.
The payoff to them will be tremendous; to the veterans
-166-

Q

tremendous; to us very important.
I think it is very much worthwhile and I really believe
that the more we can do that, the better American Legion we are going to have because we will
be working on the primary objective for which this organization was formed in the first place.
There is one other angle that I have mentioned before.
We are all deeply concerned with the NP part of our program, the mental cases, and somewhere along the line someébody is going to do far better than we are doing today to solve that problem.
Ther: are
probably sixty thousand right at this moment in our hospitals who are mentally ill.
It is the
major problem, by all odds.
I think some miracles have got to happen.
I don't know who is
going to do it or how it is going to come about, but we are harnessing all the forces there
are in this country and I just think they are good enough to break through this difficulty
that has seemingly not yet reached the proper solution.
I mention this” for this reason.
At the moment -- and probably it is inherent
in the whole process of rehabilitating these men I think the biggest jump and the toughest
jump of all is when that man hospitalized for a mental illness, has been declared ready to go
back and take his place in the community or to live a normal Life.
It is quite an abrupt,
a difficult change for that man or woman.
There are some women who are in our hospitals, too,
mentally afflicted.
It .seems to me that there we must have the help of The American Legion
and other fellows in other organizations, the other service organizations, any organization,
to help guide them across that abyss into normal living.
If they slip and they have to go
back, we have lost tremendously.
It is a disaster, usually.
This, of course, could apply back in almost every town and hamlet.
This
work that the VAVS do is largely among those who are not far distant from a hospital,
they do travel a hundred miles or more to get to a hospital to do this type of work.
general, it devolves on those who live near the hospital.

hospital
although
But, in

This matter of studying this mental proposi.ion and helping could apply in every
place where you have a post, and if we can get people on that level interested in this kind
of work, it is going to do more to strengthen The American Legion membership(which is always
paramount in peoples' minds), than anything else that we could do.
You know, the reason I like to talk about this is because it
of our work.
It is the ideal that makes service work click.
All the way
ideal, this work that people want to do, that radiates good to.the entire
can't give this subject too much attention.

is sort of
through it
programs.

I would like for you to hear a letter we received just ag few days ago
little boy out in Wisconsin.
It just shows how this same heart, this same central
we are talking about right now, is quite imbedded throughout our people.
Everyone
terested in this problem.
This is a letter just received by us.
It says:
"Dear

the heart
is this
So, I

from a
theme that
is in-

Sir:

"I am Edwin Leucher, age 12, and I have a German shepherd
dog about
six months old and I would like to give him to the blind soldiers as a guide
(he spells it g-i-d-e) for someone.
The dog is a nice one.
His name is
Smokey Boy.
Please come and get him.
It would make my two sisters and two
brothers
and I very happy to know our dog can help. someone.
"I thank you.
My address is Edwin Leucher, General Delivery, Lake
Geneva, Wisconsin" .. and as a sort of P.S. he said, "I live in Lake Ivanhoe,
Wisconsin; my phone number is Chestnut 8-4045.
Please let me hear from you."

together

--

As
but

you can
doesn't

imagine, we sent that
that warm the cockles

boy as nice a letter as
of your heart?
It does

we know
mine.

how

to

put

All through the VA, I still report to you that the same kind of devotion which
prompts you fellows and ladiesto be here at this meeting and work almost a whole week on the
many facets of this problem of better care for the disabled and other problems -- that
same sort of spirit is what .a very, very large proportion of the people who work in VA have.
I believe that to be true.
I think they are doing a splendid job.- I don't suppose we can
hope for perfection from any group but I think the spirit is ever and ever willing.
I think
the intention is there
and you can imagine how fine it makes me feel that we have that kind
of basis on which to operate, on which to try to solve our problems and to get ahead.
Now, I have been forwarded a set of questions.
I don't know if they are quite
as exciting as some of those: that you have discussed in the last few days.
They do not have
the heartthrob to them that some of these other problems have, but in the last ahalysis, they
are extremely important because they are sort of the inner workings of this thing, and the
better the inner workingsare,
the better results-we are going to get as we go along.
I will move along with the questions as they have been listed.
If I had been
putting these questions together, I don't think I could have picked.one that I would appreciate
tdking about more than the one that Mr. Klemmetson happened to put as No.l, which has to do
-167~

S

po

primarily with
simplification

management improvement.
He refers particularly
and work measurement, specifically, and then he

"Are

the

programs

producing

the

desired

in which

they

can

"Is

there

any

"Are

they

interfering

way

"What

additional

in

programs

any

way

should

be

be

work

results?
made

with

to. incentive awards,
asks four questions:

to

function

better?

service

to

the

veterans?

considered

to

further

this

Rather than try to answer them all individually under those
me deal with them in general and I think you will find when I am through
given you the picture that undoubtedly you wanted me to attempt to paint

objective?"

four headings, . let
that I will have
of what we are doing.

I like incentive awards.
I think it is one of the greatest plans that was ever
devised because if there is anything people like, it is to have somebody appreciate what
they are doing.
Now, in your work and in mine, there are those who will tell you where to
head in without much urging.
This is kind of commonplace, but I think sometimes we forget
to show appreciation.
You know, I think we are all just made out of about the same clay
and we not only like to be appreciated but we try to live up to what other people think we are.
So, if you are just patted on the back a little bit and you are told, "You are a great guy,"
then you try to be a great guy because you are trying to prove that that fellow is right.
That applies all the way through all of our
incentive awards.
It is one way to let people know, We
brother, you are all right; we are right behind you."

activities and
recognize what

that is
you are

why we
doing,

have

Now, you know, one of the finest incentive awards, and the cheapest and most
abundant, is just good old "Thank you."
The reason I put such a lot of stress on this program
is this:
I want our people to do their work in such a way that they will please the veteran.
I tell them that they haven't a thing in the world to give, it isn't their money, it isn't
their rights; these rights are all in the law and the government provides the money.
It is
a right they are dealing with,
If they can find that right for a veteran, remembering that
in a 50-50 case the veteran gets the break (that is in the law, too), we have nothing that we
are giving away, nothing gratuitous on our part.
Our job, then, is to do our .job courteously,
promptly, kindly, and thoroughly.
That sounds kind of idealistic, perhaps, but you would be surprised how many
are willing to give it a try and, when you do that, all of your work is lifted
up. You
do a better job yourself.
.It is far easier to handle a case if the fellow you are dealing
-with is kind of pleased.
You know, in an individual plant, you will have a purchasing
department and you will have people there who will say, "No," and you will have the salesmen
going out and saying, "This is the best outfit you ever heard of," and still he doesn't get
an order.
It is that ability to talk to people and deal with ‘them in such a way that they
are pleased even though they may not be able to get what they are after.
i

attitude,

So,

you

can

I like

this

type of program.

imagine

that,

in

striving

Remember

to

this:

get

to

have

the

In our doctrine

our

folks

and,

in fact,

best

possible

the

way we are trying to operate, .the VA is located right where the veteran is.
Somewhere out
there at a desk, at a table, at a hospital bed or somewhere, there fs a VA person and a
veteran.
Something is needed.
Something is being supplied.
That is the VA.
It doesn't
amount to much without that.
The super structure is quite essential but if VA doesn't work
at that point, it hasn't worked at all.
There is VA!
So, you see why I believe that the
way we get the work done at that level is all the difference between good work and bad work,
It is all the difference between whether you say the VA is fine or whether you don't use
words quite that nice, and there are those who know those words, too.
:

Now, getting back, however, to incentive awards -- and I won't take a lot of
your time -- what they mean by that is the suggestions that come in to us that
do all manner
of things to make cur work either better, easier, or more productive in some way, speeds up
correspondence, makes a veteran happier or more comfortable, eliminates an unsafe condition
or fire hazard, fosters teamwork, cuts out red tape; and then there is just a whole grist
of intangible and secondary things that you can't really list or perhaps name, but the whole
thing helps tremendously.
}
There are, of course, savings involved
in this.
To me, they are secondary, but
last year, (the official year '55), in a report we made to Civil Service Commission, these
suggestions put into effect saved the government $750,000.
Just to show you how it works, we received 7724 suggestions and adopted
That is about 50 percent of all suggestions
put in were put into use, and remember,
you have duplications and sometimes things that just won't work.
We

paid

out

$63,395

to

the

people

who
-168-

made

those

suggestions.

3821.
sometimes
:
}

In addition to that we have a Performance Award.
These are awards to people
who go far and beyond what we expect from them.
There were 538 awards for superior accomplishment for performance of the type I have described.
With awards totalling $58,418, therefore,
the total paid out in awards was over $121,000.
There were many Honor Awards, not only those Central Office might originate, but
the manager in any given facility can originate his awards for his people to whom he wants
to say, ''Thank you."
They don't carry any cash with them but they are very much appreciated.
As to making it function better, of course it can function better but it is just
one of those things where you keep trying and putting your shoulder to the wheel and letting
the people know that it is important.
You know, up to, I think it was December of '54, we
were limited to $25,000.
That was the law -- $25,000, I think it was, per agency per year.
Well, gentlemen, we have 175,000 or more people working for us and when you spread $25,000
out you haven't got much to work with.
They changed that law and now there is no limit,
except that no one person could get more than $5,000 without going through the Civil Service
Commission,
and of course the large awards are not at all normal.
It would be most unusual
if it ran into greater figures than that.
But just getting out of the rut of only $25,000
for a tremendous number of people has made all the difference in the world between having
a real program and a mediocre one.

covered

that

Service
subject

to the
pretty

veterans.
well.

Of

course

it

improves

that

service.

I

think

I have

I want to mention work simplification, which is also important and is in somewhat
. the same line.
That comes more in the insurance department for instance, where we are trying to mechanize and trying to eliminate as many unnecessary steps -as we can.
Now, you say,
“Well, that is just for saving money."
Yes, that is true, but the primary thing -- and we
must not forget this -- is accuracy.
Accuracy, particularly in the insurance business, is
of the utmost importance.
Even to this day, with all the work that has been done, errors
will occur.
And by the way, I bring you greetings from Gordon Beck.
Gordon Beckis now a
retired gentleman.
I know most of you gentlemen in this room probably know Gordon Beck.
He
did a tremendous job.
Buck Gardner is doing that job now.
In spite of all we do, we still
make mistakes.
However, it must be remembered that we handle about 6,500,000 policies.
You
know, when you are handling that many potential items, you are bound to run into some
mistakes, I suppose.
We are going to eliminate them if God is willing.
But we can mechanize
"and a machine, normally, doesn't make mistakes.
;
people

In
working

DM&S they
for them.

pay

a

lot

of

attention

to work

simplification.

They

have

120,000
.

They have a training course to stimulate their people in
plification of work.
Seventy percent of their supervisors have taken
fiscal year '55 two thousand ideas were sent in for consideration and
stalled.
That will give you an idea how important that work is.

the direction of simthat course and in
68% of them were in-

Now, we have the matter of work measurement that I want to particularly mention
because I think it is misunderstood.
No. 1, in the work we do quality,and quality results
must remain paramount and improved, if that is possible.
I mention that because the minute
somebody mentions work measurement, it may give the idea
efficiency experts who go out with
a stop watch to a lathe and stand there to see whether it is going to take 48 seconds or
53 seconds to turn out a certain piece, or how much time it takes to move the piece from one
place to another.

if
to

Now, that isn't
I were trying to describe
find some common language

work
work
that

measurement.
Our work as you know, isn't like that,
measurement I would say, in our business, it was the
we could talk when we are
referring to work. .

but
desire

For instance, let's take the hardest one of all, that is, adjudication of claims,
and I think everybody in the room would say, "You can't do it."
Sure, I know, one claim
takes ten minutes or an hour;. another may .take you all day.
It may take you longer than a
day.
But you see, on the average over twelve months -- and I don't know how many boards we
.have altogether, but a lot of them, a great number of boards and ‘a great number of cases -when you average that all up over, say, a l2-month period, you get an idea that, on the average,
it takes about so long to do so much work.
So, if you have ten thousand cases, you come to
thé conclusion that that amount of work requires a number of boards, and you can estimate
actual needs.
The principal thing in work measurement; and the thing that so many people
forget -- and even some of our managers were a little hesitant about this program to start with;
they think that the whole idea is to cut down.
Frankly, if there is a lot of fat lying around

ie is going

to be discovered and it will be cut out, but
-169-

the other half

is to be sure you have

enough people to do the work.
It works both ways.
We should not have people we don't need.
On the other hand, we certainly should be sure that we have all the people we need.
Now,
getting back to this matter of a language we can understand.
You realize the way we are now
operating, we are trying to make the manager the boss.
He sends in his budget figures to
tell us what money he thinks he is going to need.
I am referring to a Regional Office,
although it works the same in any station.
The manager tells us what money he thinks he must
have for the coming year.
Those figures are worked up by Mr. Kelsey and his budget crew
‘here in Central Office.
Then we send it to the Bureau of the Budget and they go over it.
We usually spend several months arguing back and forth trying to get the budget
worked out to mutually agreeable figures.
Then, the Bureau of the Budget puts together the
budgets from all the branches of government.
That becomes the President's Budget and that is
our budget as it goes to Congress.
We are now starting on the'58 budget and somebody has to say, "Well, I think
in the aggregate there are going to be 650,000 fellows who want to take training, educational
training."
Now, that is quite a guess.
You can imagine it isn't easy to do, but if that
is the figure and if we have a general understanding of what work is involved, then we
can
estimate at once the number of employees we are going to need in VR&E to do the job, and
how
much money it is going to take.
If we have work measurement, then the manager
.is using the
same measuring stick we use, and, mind you, all this is cleared with the manager.
It is not
superimposed or shoved down the manager's throat.
It is a tool for him as well as for
everybody else.
If he agrees, if we talk the same language and get the Bureau of the Budget
to talk the same language, we come to the same conclusion on the basis of the same figures,
and we have a chance of getting a good budget out of it.

think
be so

So, you see, work measurement is really a very
is excellent.
'I wanted
particularly to mention that
easily misunderstood.
All that it is intended for is

I think probably that
that is indicated here but I think
in the detail of the way we work.

valuable tool
because it is
to help us do

pretty well covers question No.
that you are more interested in

and one that I
a program that can
our workbetter.

1, maybe not in the detail
our philosophy rather than

The next question reads:
"In line with the consolidation of medical activities,
all in the interest of efficiency and economy, why not explore further fields in this direction,
for example, the consolidation of hospitals, and Regional Offices into centers whenever these
consolidations are geographicalland
y economically feasible, especially wherever there is
planned the consolidation of outpatient and inpatient activities?"
I like centers.
I think where you can have them, where they ‘are normal, where
they are operating properly, they are splendid.
Take Chicago, out on the West Side -- that
is a splendid set up.
Some places don’t lend themselves to centers.
Where it is feasible,
would say yes, we are working in that direction."
MR.

MARKOWITZ:

MR. HIGLEY:
office last week.
He is
excited, though.
"Are

not

Can

we

make

a center

at

I

Wilkes-Barre?

No,
just

not yet.
trying to

I had half of
continue that

hospital

grounds

adequate

the State of Pennsylvania
conference at the moment.

to accommodate

such

additional

down in my
Don't get

construction?"

In general, yes.
Of course, sometimes hospitals are not in a good locationat
all for this purprse.
Sometimes they are.
For instance, up in New York, at least at the new
one we buiit there, there is no room.
We do not even have decent parking space, to say
nothing about anything else.

Public

tracts

for

The
Law

next
560,

question is, "Could
83rd Congréss?"

not

funds

for

such

construction

That is Public Law 319, Chapter 560, which empowers the
construction by outside interests, to be paid off through

be

made

available

G.S.A. to make conamortization payments.

The answer to the question is yes, but it is a long road.
That is an invitation
to see if you can get a building.
We are trying to use the plan.
I don't know how good it
is.
We haven't a building as yet.
Yes, GSA is very willing to talk to us but they have
to go through Congress and many other steps.
There is one little wrinkle -- I don't know
whether it is important or not -- and that is, if they put up a building
for you, there are
a few difficulties.
No. 1, it becomes somewhat a single-purpose building, or might become
that.
It might be so located that it is useful for us alone.
In other words, suppose
we do not need the whole building.
We would have to deed land to GSA for the building.
You
know VA owns the land at the hospitals at the present time.
We operate them exclusively.
No one outside of VA has anything to do with running the hospitals.”
If GSA takes over and
the new building and property becomes their property, they become the
landlord and we the
tenant.
That means they can move anybody else into the building and they can somewhat
tell.
-170-

Sant

under

-

__

"

¥

I

EEE

us what space -we have and what we haven't.
Of course, we can argue any dispute, but in the
last analysis they are the landlord.
I think that DM&S just doesn't quite like that arrangement.
If you have always had your own way, you don't like to have somebody else tell you
what to do.
:
That may not be anything against trying out this plan, but I do think it has
acted as a little deterent.
On the other hand, I think there is some disposition on the part
of the Bureau of the Budget to let us have money enough to make additions and there are some
in being -- Isn't that right, Dr. Middleton?
There are several places now where the money
we have requested to do certain work at a hospital covers building a Regional Office or building an addition that will house
the Regional Office, and make a center out of it.
That is
another way of going about it.
We are interested.
We are pushing it.
Then, the question mentions economy and of course, this usually refers to common
activities, such as supply, personnel, finance and administration, not to mention the manager's
office.
We:rare now consolidating these same activities, even though the Regional Office and
the hospital may not be adjacent.
They may be, in fact, several miles apart but where it is
feasible, one or the other will take over the supply activities or the finance activities-so
that we have only one operating unit, even though it is serving both the hospital and the
Regional Office.
So, savings are now being made along those lines, but of course I presume it
would be a little better if the office and hospital were adjacent and opeiated as a unit.
Where it is practical, there can be one manager, particularly when you have a center.
That,
of course, is another possible saving.
There are a few cases where we have tried to consolidate managerships.
There
are some cases where we get into a lot of trouble when we try it, too, but those are the
operations we have to look into to see whether we are making the best use of our manpower.

in more
seem

recent

intent

"Would not this move tend to protect budgetwise
years have become more and more vulnerable to

on

emasculating

the

Veterans

Administration

and

the nonmedical activities
those members of Congress
producing

slow

but

sure

that
who

death?"

Under many circumstances, our budget is all broken down into different activities,
and, regardless of how you might have operations located geographically, the costs involved
for doing certain work would all be prorated to the proper budget, so I can't see that this
suggestion is of particular value.
At Chicago, for instance, that center is operated just
as if the buildings were quite apart from a budget standpoint, as the costs are prorated to
the different activities.

move

a wise

going

to

"Would
one?"
To

give

centralized

not

the

savings

the extent that
service, at least

"Would not such
benefits setup?"

in

rent,

salaries,

there are savings
as good or better

a consolidation

supplies,

involved,
service.

further

the

Now, moving
dollar allocation.
This
plan of allocating funds

so

forth,

make
;

this

yes, but you must be sure you
It is wise to that extent.

veterans'

I would say convenience is probably one of the
extent the veterans might get a little better service would
location has its own problems to be considered.

and

interests

major factors.
depend a lot on

by

providing

a:

To what other
each case.
Each

along to question No. 3, "Two years ago DM&S went on an annual
fiscal year the Veterans Benefits Department followed suit.
Is
to field stations satisfactory?
If not, in what way can it be

improved?

are

this

:

Of course, this is part of the idea of making the manager a real manager and
‘having him run his office and use his money in the way that he thinks will produce the best
results, rather than depending on Central Office to tell him what to do.

TP

In DM&S I believe it has worked out quite well.
Of course they have a more
stable program.
In general, their program can be anticipated with considerable certainty. It
hasn't worked perfectly.
We do have our troubles, but I do think that it is working quite
well and will work much better.
It is one of those things where experience is the best teacher.
In Veterans Benefits it hasn't worked as well, probably because there you have
quite a variable program.
For instance, let's take Loan Guaranty.
A year ago the number of
loans jumped tremenduously.
No one, including the best brains we have around the country, had
any idea that that program was going to mushroom.
You can imagine the difficulties involved
when you stop to think that these budget figures are made sometimes a year in advance of spending the money. Right now the money that Congress is going to give us, I think -- and they have
treated us very well, by the way -- we will start spending next July and it runs to July in
'57.
So, in requesting money, it is on the basis of what we think should
happen.
Well, if
-171-

things happen differently,
it means you have
dollar allocation you can readily understand
we find where they have overages and we have
have had the opposite experience.

to readjust, so when you give out an annual
there would have to be changes made. Sometimes
to take that to put in other places where they

{

The man who has less money to spend doesn't like it.
That is just human nature,
but we do have those adjustments.
However, I think the program is right.
I think we are on
the right road to handle it this way, to let a manager be a manager and run his shop in the
way he thinks is best.
However, we do have a large number of hospitals and offices.
We have
to think in terms of trying to keep them all. going properly and, of course, to that extent
adjustments are sometimes
unavoidable.
:
By the way, I have been in this job thirty-one months now; I am getting to be
a regular old-timer.
When some of the folks around here remark about their thirty-five years
of service, I just say thirty-one and if they don't press me, I don't add the months.
Anyway,
in the early days for me the first thing we did was to have manager meetings out in the field.
Primarily, I wanted to meet the managers and I saw no chance in the world of getting out to
173 hospitals and seventy Regional Offices and three District Offices and 250 contact offices
and supply depots, and so forth.
It just isn't possible and I believe my job is to stay on
the job here in Washington, and try to keep things going smoothly.
In any event, if I couldn't go to them, I arranged these four meetings around
the country and they came to where I could be and we found the meetings most helpful. You
see, the managers didn't believe us the first time we had a meeting and told them they could
say what they pleased, take their hair down and call a spade a spade.
The first meeting we
had, they weren't willing to buy that.
They felt there was a joker in it somewhere -- "We
stick our neck out and then what happens?'
But, you know, as we become better acquainted,
you would be delirhted to see how they do exactly what they were told they could do, namely,
call a spade a spade.

So, it is through these manager meetings that we have ‘promoted
tion. We try to find out how their problems are working and try to see that
as well as we know how to do it.

budget

his

"Are not our
on a veteran

needs

field

and

I asked
let me

western states suffering
population basis?"

from

Frank Kelsey, the Comptroller
read what he answered:

of

a

lack

of

the

Agency

this dollar allocaeverything is done
?

consideration

to

answer

in

that.

computing

This

is

in

"Budget needs are not computed directly on veteran population basis.
Needs are
determined on the basis of work load volumes experienced in the area served by each field
office.
Projected needs are estimated by field office management and reviewed by Central
Office in the light of administration policy and appropriations availability.
Because work load volumes generally, but not necessarily, correspond
it is true that fiscal allocations usually are in close proportion to

population,
Insofar

concerned,

western

states

a basis
patient

of veteran population.
The estimate is preload in hospitals and work loads in outpatient

some

record

medical

more

on

care

is

have

not

suffered

from

lack

of

con-

If that isn't a good answer I will refer
you to Frank Kelsey.
If you want
questions about that particular point, I know Frank will be glad to answer

Here is another one:
a more current basis?"

'What

means

can

be

suggested

to

keep

the

veteran

to
them.

population

Again Mr. Kelsey:
"Estimates of total veterans in civil life developed from
Armed Forces data on separations
and from National Office of Vital Statistics mortality
statistics are prepared every month.
Veteran population estimates for each state and for
each Regional Office area are prepared every three months, using the latest civilian population migration data available from the Bureau of the Census.
The Veterans Administration
veteran population estimates are as current as it is possible to make them on the basis of
the migration and mortality data which are used in their preparation."

see

a

tration
tration

We are under the impression that we are doing the best we can on that.
If
loophole in it, we would be very glad to have you tell us where we are at fault.

you

Hurrying on, No. 4:
''The desire of Congress to cut funds for Veterans AdminisInformation Service -- bring out value of the Information Service to Veterans Adminis-

programs,

service

organizations,

liaison

-172-

--

entire

veterans’

program.

|

to veteran
population.

sideration in computing the budget on
pared on the basis of the anticipated
clinics."

ask

as

i

VA is out where VA meets the veteran.
It either
we write the rules and regulations down here we
field and sense what it is all about, or we are

Develop

need

&

You see, as I told you before,
works out there or it doesn't work, so when
had better know what is going on out in the
liable to make mistakes..

)

-

A——
mr eper—

ie

can

way

2

Sm

Ee

sc

increase

to

but

Programs

Infoimation

the

of

only the continuation
and increased needs.

for not
tinuing

what

I

con-

to meet

it

In
How can the Legion further this program?
needs, if any?
Program be stimulated or supplemented to warrant this assistance?’

"What are those
the Information

In the
I don't need to tell you this is one of our very important programs.
much inforfirst place, I think it is our duty to send out to everybody who is interested as
that a veteran
‘mation as possible regarding our program, so that there is a minimum of chance
has something coming and is not aware of it.

any place
They will

We

Many people say, 'Weli, you have service officers
They know
of any consequence; they are very active.
Why do you have to tell them too?"
tell them.
we
We

Another will say
drumming up business.

are

bureaucrats trying to keep
a kind of sales force.

are
are

all over the
this program

jobs

our

country in almost
like a book.

going

full

at

steam.

Information Service is in the same category as conYou know that isn't true.
They, of course, must have a sufficient load.
I believe in contact offices.
tact work.
I don't believe in a contact office that isn't doing much business or ome that is artificially
But for an office that is doing a job, I am for them even
up a show of activity.
keeping
though there are those who don't agree with me.

Now, for the other half of information work, (I don't know whether you know
this or not) our men out in the field who work for Norman Lodge who is there today, tell
We often
They are sort of our antenna to pick up what is going wrong.
us what is going on.
Of course,
hear from them when something has gone wrong before we hear from anybody else.
it helps tremendously when any sort of inefficiency is promptly described to us or any misThese difficulties are inherent in people and they happen to us just like they do
conduct.
in any other segment of the population.
The

Information

Service

is

most

helpful

in

that

regard.

The history on personnel cuts in the Information Service seems to start with
1953, when our 1954 budget was being discussed.
Apparently, there was a $30,000,000 cut
in the hospital in-patient program proposed, which was objected to strenuously by many, with
veterans organizations in the vanguard.
The resulting organized pressure resulted in the
restoration of the funds.
However, it is my understanding the VA's Information Service was accused of
spearheading the deluge of criticisms and demands that accompanied the drive for restoration.
This was an entirely erroneous assumption.
The impetus, as always, came from the national
and department headquarters.
Apparently, in retaliation and based on the false assumption
the budget for our Information Service was cut by the House and allowable personnel for this
activity reduced from 51 to 26, a 50% cut.

under

the

The following year in our
same chairman and apparently

The

Senate

Committee

restored

20.

This

number

does

not

include

For

next

year,

we

do

have

our

situation

improved

in

this

Legion

is

the

1955 budget,
for the same

number

to

26,

but

stenographers,
not

know

how

activity.

the House Appropriations Subcommittee
reason, cut the personnel from 26 to 15.
in

conference,

typists,
we
I

will
am

not

the

number

was

fixed

at

etc.

make

as

yet,

suggesting

out

any

butwe
action

are
as

hoping

far

as

to
the

concerned.

In answer to the question, ''Can the program be stimulated?"
Information Service
has a magnificent program.
I wish we had time for Norman Lodge to tell you what they are
doing.
They have millions of dollars worth of free radio time.
It is remarkable.
In the
cost of the service, the manpower is a
drop in the bucket.
In our total budget,
it is just
a small item.
You see, the limitation isn't based on money; it is based on what the service
shall be permitted to do.
That is the crux of the difficulty.
In spite of all the handicaps
they have been doing a terrific job.
They write many of my speeches, and write articles
pes
speeches, letters, etc. for a lot of people around here for which they are seldom credited.
No, they are
are doing a good job and
of it before we will.

doing a swell job.
I don't think
if there is a better one that can

I will go on to two short
of California, "A request that copies
Regional
Offices."
I don't
he says about that:
are referred to the

questions and then
of all Solicitor's

we
be

need any stimulation
They
done, they will probably think

I am through
These are by Russell
Opinions be distributed to all

think Ralph Stone was able to get here this morning, but here is what
'Under present procedures prescribed by the Administrator, all opinions
interested department or staff element for consideration as to need in
-173-

If we are wrong about this, let us know.
It is our intent to do this thing
properly.
I will say this, that we send out much paper, many opinions, etc.
I do think if
we can hold the numbers down it helps everybody.
What we have in mind in this answer is:
suppose we have, we will say, a divorce problem down in Mexicojthere is no use sending that
out generally, things that are peculiar to a state or dependent upon state law.
We consider that it doesn'tdo any good to Litter up a desk in
Massachusetts if all that is involved is happening in Illinois.
It sounds to me like it is proper and good.
If it isn't,
let us know.

MR. RUSSELL, California:
May I explain, Mr. Higley?
Aside from the fact that
we are supposed to try to achieve the most favorable interpretation of the regulations for
our clients, your adjudicators are anxious to comply with Central Office policy and from
time to time these regulations will refer to a Solicitor's Opinion only by C number and date.
It is supposed to serve as a guide to the adjudicator in administering the law, yet when
they go to the Chief Attorney's office or to the Adjudication Division concerned, they have
nothing they can use to serve as a guide to them in applying that policy.
VAR 1028 (B) is
an example of that type of regulation.
It refers to a particular Solicitor's Opinion by C
number and date, and that is all it has, and it can't be uniformly applied in the absence of
distribution of that Solicitor's Opinion.
I am not thinking of some peculiar circumstance,
but’ the regulation itself refers to the opinion, yet there is no way it can be applied.
MR.

you

reference,

HIGLEY:

are

I

MR. RUSSELL:
short in trying

officers

MR.

see,

HIGLEY:

it

is

a

reference

matter

dry?

and

high

left

To
was

was

in

made

not

having

with

like

MR.
correct

don't

and

cuts

Bill

comment

on

that?

Driver,

I would

say

opinion

should

that

you

short

that

if

would

you

make

we

refer

have

to

been

any

HIGLEY:
We will
that.
Bill, you

have

the

the

adjudication

referred to an opinion, obviously that
we missed the boat in not distributing
an

opinion

in

a

regulation,

the

obvious

distributed

to

all

officers,

and

the

done.

What we are trying to do,
opinions which they will

offices

to

repeat,
that

when

Yes.
Cuts our service officers
to apply the regulation.

MR. WILLIAM DRIVER:
If the regulation
opinion should have been distributed.
I would say
the opinion.

intention

and

as Mr. Higley said, is to avoid cluttering
never have any reason to refer to.

check on that; to
take that as your

the
job

extent
to run

that
that

up

mistake

all

we are wrong, we would
down, will you please?

The last question on this agenda also comes from Mr. Russell:
"That Finance
Manual MP-4 be amended to provide that any change of address received over the veteran's
signature be filed in the C file after it is recorded in Finance."
Mr. Kelsey prepared this
answer for me"
"Past VA procedures provided for placing change of address requests over the
veteran's signature in the C file.
That procedure resulted in many files containing numerous
requests over the veteran's signature which required screening in any review of the file
for adjudication purposes.
The present procedure provides for inclusion in the C file of a
standardized VA change of address notice which is readily identifiable as such and is believed
to expedite substantive action on veterans' claims.

the

entire

"Consideration will be given to this suggestion
benefit payments process now being conducted."
Was

that

your

in

connection

with

a review

of

question?

MR. RUSSELL:
That was my question.
You see, from the standpoint of economy
and efficiency, we have any number of 7216(b)'s, those transfer notices that come to us,
files that come into the Los Angeles Office, but we don't have any local address on the
7216(b) and the only authority for the transfer is down at the bottom of the form, jurisdiction, or veteran resigning, or something like that, and when we go to get the C file
there is nothing in the C file to tell us why.
v
the

We go to the Finance and on the pay card you have the
statement that he came from so-and-so and the veteran will be
=-17.4~

veteran's old address and
calling on the telephone

a

offices other than the one raising the question which prompted the opinion.. If the information is considered of interest to other offices, recommendation is made for the printing
and general distribution.
If the information is not of general interest, distribution to
all offices would serve no useful purpose.
There is no apparent reason to depart from this
practice."

because he hasn't had an opportunity to get into
the money, but Finance can't make any payment on
current address to make that payment.

the office, he
it unless they

has been
have the

in dire need of
veteran's local,

arid:

Well, we found out that what happens is that the veteran writes to the Regional
Office where his case used to be, when he wants it transferred, it goes to Finance, and
Finance takes the letter or 92, or whatever it is, and they keep it in their own file and
keep it there for six months.
They don't submit the 572, they don't put the 572 in the C
file and transfer it out to the new office.

instructions

The
(I

file goes out, the 572 stays in Finance and six months
forget the number of the manual), they destroy that.

later,

under

their
:

It seems to me ‘that such a procedure as they are following is unnecessary from
the standpoint of filing, storage space, and destruction operations, when by all rights that
thing should go into the C file and then the adjudicator knows what is going on, the Administrative Division knows what is going on, and a Finance clerk who isn't qualified to know
what other matters are involved in the veteran's claim is not vested with any responsibility
to handle it.
So, from an economic standpoint, it would seem to me the 572 could go on through.
There should be no valid reason why it shouldn't go on through and be put in the C file.
It would make everybody's work here at Central Office a lot easier because they can get
the information in one spot, which they do with everything else, but they can't get this when
Finance keeps the forms and destroys them rather than putting them away.

doing things
or Bill care

certainly

because

MR.
is
to

HIGLEY:
I rather gather
absolutely right because
say anything about it?

MR. DRIVER:
We think
find out why it isn't.

what

the

572

our people
they offer

weren't too sure their present way
to change it, more or less.
Would

should

in

be

the

MR.
is

HIGLEY:
good for

We will go into
you is good for

this question and
us, certainly.

MR.

RUSSELL:

Thank

have

you.

We

the

them stated.

same

C

folder,

see

that

interests.

we

of
Frank

too,

and

will

it

is

operated

correctly,

It

is

a matter

of

getting

:

MR. HIGLEY:
Mr. Chairman, that completes the questions.
I want to add this.
Last night
Chairman Teague told you about our hospital rehabilitation program.
I remember telling you,
I think it ‘was a year ago, that now having completed or getting near the completion of our
new building program, which now has left only a 1,000-bed hospital out in California
and
one in Cleveland, NP's, that it was just about time we get some money and some plans for
rebuilding hospitals that are just plain worn out.
We had at that time a list of sixteen.
Now, what I was working toward is this.
As I think I told you, we must have a plan.
If
you don't have a plan, then many come in with a separate bill to build or rebuild this, that
and the other thing and we feel that the district that has the most pull or the one that
makes the biggest noise is apt to get the money when maybe the place that needs the help
most is not being taken care of.

o

I am very happy to report that what Tiger was referring to is the culmination
of this last year's work which boils this planning down into a program which has the blessing
of the Bureau of the Budget and the President's approval,
In this hearing which we had on
February 8th, we took up to the .Veterans Affairs Committee this whole plan.
It provides for
the rebuilding of ten hospitals out of the sixteen,
They are all going to be taken care of
but five of them, I believe, are not called a replacement.
They are called major modernization. The difference between those two is that in the latter class, (major modernization)
over half of the buildings are going to stay there. If less than half of the buildings are
going to be retained, it is called replacement.
Replacementis
for instance what we plan
for, Mt. Alto here in Washington.
It is not only a replacement.
It must be built on another
site. The same situation exists at Oakland, California; Jackson, Mississippi, is: another gne,
and you know we included in the budget last fall the money to make the five starts.
That is
Oakland, Washington, Cleveland, Jackson, Mississippi, and the first phase of Downey.
!

sure

it

will

Anyway, that is in the budget
be -- we will have the money

right now and if it is
to get the work on the

passed-- and I am
drawing boards.

quite

Now, the modernization programs come concurrently with the replacement work.
There are about two hundred million dollars involved in this program.
From my viewpoint,
the fine part of it is that we now have a meeting of minds and a definite program.
It is
similar to the plan after World War II when a certain number of beds were planned.
These
were to provide for the needs of veterans coming out of World War II at that time.
Now we
have the same program in connection with the rehabilitation of our facilities
and I think
it is going to work out well.
-17%-

pet

Any of you can get one of these reprints from the Committee on Veterans
Affairs,
which includes all the data we presented to them at that time.
It gives full information
on the replacements, with some time table as to how we think it is going
to work out.
We
couldn't get anybody to definitely promise money for years in advance;
but at least the
program is accepted which means that, other things being equal, we will be
able to get the
money as outlined approximately in this report.
In addition, of course, we have a big job to do at many of our facilities.
It
is not exactly modernization, it is not in this same category, but it is just things
that
need to either be replaced, enlarged, added on, and so forth.
That goes all the way from
chapels, that I think are quite essential in any hospital, right up through better
surgery
or better other equipment.
:
night,

to
MR.

Thank

you

proceed

know

it

is

in

be interested,

Tiger Teague

print

having made

if

you

to

it.

and

KRAABEL:

We

have

distributed

MR. HIGLEY:
very much.

You

will

be

with

interested

would

like

in

it.

I have

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Is there anyone who has
the Recommendations Committee's report?

MR. JAMES
hearing a person make
tomorrow?"
And

He comes
smiling,

you would

that

I

said,

reference

to this

get

hold

of

is

taken

up

enough

any

further

question

CRIDER, Tennessee:
Mr. Chairman, I can't help but
this statement.
He said, "You are going to listen
"Yes,

I plan

it,it

available.
—~——

I thought
last

or

recall
to the

of

your

shall

time.

we

last night
Administrator

to."

He said, "Well, you know, I am thinking it will be like it has been
in and he takes a piece of bread and lays it heavy with butter, and we
and then when I get home, I say, -'Dammit; he did it again!'"

in the
all go

past.
out

I am not satisfied that he hasn't done it again, except to me.
I am worried,
and I am disturbed, Mr. Higley, as to the future of the veterans of this country.
I hope
you will pardon me for making this statement prior to giving you the problem which I consider
to be imminent at this time.
I can recall when I first came into this work that the major
portion of the conference referred to the Economy Act and we used to think that was a dastardly thing to do to a group of disabled people; but as I look back today, I say they must
have had a lot of guts because they came out in the open and said what they were doing.
Today we are faced with that same issue, statements of responsible people to
the contrary notwithstanding, that we are going into an Economy Act but nobody will admit
We in Tennessee and we in the other states -- and I say the other states because I know I
am expressing the sentiments of a number of them -- are concerned that the Bureau of the
Budget, the General Accounting Office and other agencies not interested in veterans have
taken over the operation of the Veterans Administration.
They tell you when to move and
you become their agent.
I resent it.

it.

Mr. Higley, I have confidence in you but I want
you to be the Administrator of
Veterans Affairs.
You are the one responsible for the handling of veterans benefits and I
want to see these other agencies that don't give a tinker's darn about veterans stay out of
the veterans benefits programs, and give us what the Congress of the United States believes
that the veterans of this country need and should have.
Until that is done, the veterans
of this country are going to be suffering the same attacks they have received in the past.
I am not happy with the operation of Central Office.
I have said this before.
I think the trend is definitely shown by the decisions and the attitude that has been establi‘shed in Central Office, and it is working down to the Regional Offices.
Nobody has issued
any instructions, written instructions, and nobody has put anything in writing, but be that
as it may, our Regional Offices feel that there is a trend coming down to them and they have
to accept it.
:
Whether it is coming from you, whether it is coming from the Bureau of the
Budget or whether it is coming from the General Accounting Office or any of these various:
and sundry commissions set up to tear the Veterans Administration apart, doesn't make any
difference.
The trend has arrived in our Regional Offices from Washington.
I want to know
what we are going to be able to do about it.
Are you going to be assuming the responsibilities of the Administrator of Veterans Affairs, assuming the duties set up for that office,
or are you going to sit down and ask every agency on God!s earth what you can do before you
do it?

Bureau of
Congress.

MR HIGLEY:
In the first
the Budget and the General
.

place, you
Accounting

mentioned two agencies in particular, the
Office, that are subject to the will of
3

-176-

mn

=

a

Remember, it was Congress that set
czar on the spending of money and,
well, they can go into anything if
Are

you

talking

about

a

a

up the General Accounting Office and
as you know, they are very active in
they so choose.

they are
checking

the

part

review

that

we

have

had?

Is

that

of

absolute
up on ==

it?

MR. CRIDER:
That is just part of it.
I am talking about the trend that has
been established in the last few years toward doing away with consideration of veterans’
claims and being fair and considerate of them.
I used to see, a few years ago, when a man
had gunshot wounds, he was given every consideration on earth.
There was sympathy for him.
Check with your Central Office.
I carried a group of gunshot wound cases over there where
no more sympathetic consideration had been given to those gunshot wounds than if a man had
been out and had a dishonorable discharge.
They just don't worry about veterans any more
because somebody is shooting at them and they don't want people to think that they are being
friendly to these veterans.
I think you want them to be friendly, but your people out in
the field aren't feeling that way.
As far as I am concerned,
the part of the Administrator and the
confidence with me that you are going
are interested in.

words don't satisfy me.
It is going to take action on
officials of the Veterans Administration to establish
to do the job for the veterans, the gioups that you

MR. HIGLEY:
Of course, I don't accept your thesis that they have this attitude.
It would have to be spelled out to me because I don't know that it is so.
On those cases
that come as far as my desk, if anything, I would imagine that some men might accuse me of
being a little too soft, bot I take quite literally the statement of the law that where it
is a 50-50- case we can always give the veteran the break.
I don't know just exactly to what kind of cases you are referring.
I know of no
trend. ' I have never told anybody to get tough in any way, shape or form, nor do I know anybody who ever told them to, either through me or by me, around here.
I don't know what you
are talking about.
I must say, I don't think it is true in any degree at all.
If you are referring
to this seview, I-don't know how you can kick about that. That thing is intended to be sure
that a veteran is getting everything he has coming and it may be more than he is now getting
and, if you are honest, you know that men were put on the rolls that have no right to be
there and I think every man in this room knows that to be a fact and as long as they are
Shere; it jeopardizes this program.

in

order

so

The review is not intended to
that no one can come from the

eliminate somebody.
It is to be sure our house
outside and claim that we haven't done our work

is
well.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I must correct one statement.
Every man in this room doesn't
know there are men on the rolls that shouldn't be there, because I don't know that.
I tell
you, we don't know any individual case that collects compensation from the Veterans Administration that I don't think is entitled to it, and I know thousands of them that are entitle@
to it that are not collecting it.
MR. CRIDER:
Bob, let me make this statement to Mr. Higley, and I respect him
fully for having done a fine job-up here.
I am not running off at the wrong end, I don't
blame Mr. Higley, but I say to you now, I speak only for the veterans of Tennessee that I
have contact with..
We feel down there that there is a definite trend against veterans.
Now,
if Tennessee is the only one that feels that way, all right; but I don't belive it.
If we are
the only one that feels that way, I apologize for including the other states in my statement
to

you,

sir.

MR. HIGLEY:
I assure there is no need for any apology from anybody.
This is
your VA.
You mentioned one other point.
I don't believe I can go into it,
You must always
remember the Administrator of Veterans Affairs is a part of an administration and, as such,
is sometimes bound in certain directions because it is policy.
I think you can understand
that.
I will tell you quite frankly (you may be getting me into deep water), I don't have
much to do with forming that policy.
That is another part of the national setup.
It has
nothing to do with this Administration.
It is just inherent.
It has always been that way.
You indicated that I ought to be the champion of veterans' desires, that I ought
to get out and get to know the veterans themselves, what they want.
Well, I don't think you
can say that the Veterans Administrator is in a position to make himself felt in that way, as
long as he is part of a team and that team is, of course, the one that calls the signals.
It all has to be involved in one program.
In general, I don't know
That is, they haven't come to me and
up on review, and I thought that was

of any concerted action.to do what you have talked about.
said there is any such idea.
There is this tightening
just good business.
I would like to protect this whole

=177-

program in. such a way that we don't have any loose ends sticking out
where people who don't
like our program can get in and make something outof it -- and incidentally,
go lots further
even than the ill they would try to correct.
I think my job is to try to keep this whole
thing above board where you can defend any decision made.

|
|

|

Bob, you make the statement that there are thousands of them not on the
rolls
that should be there.
Do you mean by that that you think our boards, wherever they may
happen to be, are just arbitrarily wrong, or is it an honest difference
of opinion where
you don't agree with them?
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
I was speaking in just a little broader terms.
I think we
had a great inadvertence here this morning.
The press is represented here and when the
Administrator of Veterans Affairs said that every man in the room knows
that there are
thousands on the rolls that shouldn't be there, I think it is a great
inadvertence.
I don't
_ know any,
I went over and checked with Watson Miller, who has been in this business since
the Veterans Administration or before the Veterans Bureau, even was formed,
and I checked
with T. O. Kraabel who is his successor, and they tell me they don't know
anybody who is
getting benefits that they don't believe is entitled to them, that they
don't know anyone
who is on the rolls who should not be there, and we are pretty close to the
picture, too.
When we say that there is an attitude
been very gracious and very generous and you say,
we will help you with it and we will review it."

want

to

know

If you will
what cases

bring these cases
you refer to.

to

our

and
"If

we ean't get them on,
you bring these cases

attention,

we

will

help

you

you have always
to our attention

with

it.

We
|

MR. HIGLEY:
Maybe I overstated that, but there are men in this room who have
told me of cases that they know of, cases where service connection was given and
it cannot
possibly be sustained.
That is what I am talking about.
Mistakes were made after the second
World War when they were using a lot of new personnel and there was a terrific load
of new
veterans, when I think mistakes were made.
Now, if mistakes were made, you would agree
they should be corrected.
I am more concerned with Bob's
and we don't see it his way.
I don't know
whether it is inherent in our thinking for
would like to know.
CHAIRMAN

McCURDY:

some honest mistakes, which
mistakes and there may well

No,

in

view

statement that there are these who should be on
whether this is a new type of case or not, or
some reason or other we don't see eye to eye.
I

of

your

amended

we freely accept, in any
be.
1I don't think there

statement

that

there

have

[

i
(

|
¢

been

organization this size there are honest
are thousands of honest mistakes.

I didn't necessarily address my remarks to the work of the Veterans Administration
in their rating boards.
I have just had a couple of cases here recently.
I am addressing
myself to the overall picture that is doing violence to the veteran because there is perhaps
not sufficient law.
That is one thing.
:

¢

There are many other cases that we have had on appeal where all of our doctors
and all of our men are thoroughly convinced that they certainly should be granted, and they
are denied.
You have a great appeals agency here.
There is somebody
disagreeing with you,
and perhaps it is an honest difference of opinion, but I have heard not less than ten times
since I have been here these last ten days that there seems to be a change in attitude, that
where you used to get the benefit of the doubt, we don't get the benefit of the doubt any
more.
There are some complaints that the percentage of appeals allowed should certainly
be higher in these close cases.
I am just like you, if you ask me to pull the thousands of
cases that should be on the rolls, I think that I could do as good a job doing that as you
could do on a job of those that have been rated that shouldn't be.
I think probably we
would probably checkmate there, Harvey, and it would be a standout, maybe 50-50, and then
if you will let our group of sharks pass on it, I am sure I will win the decision, and if
yours did, you would win the decision, and that is because of the difference in attitude
toward the veteran.
:

}

J
Pp

area
less

He was disturbed by the proposition that many of the cases in the days of the
boards, following World War II, had been hastily granted service connection and rated
than 10 or rated 10 percent at the time, under instructions and hurried regulations
-178-

rw

MR. KRAABEL:
Mr. Chairman, may I make this comment, also, on the subject?
Sometime ago the National Commander was here as a guest of the Administrator, and I was present.
At that time the subject of reviews came up and I told the National Commander it was considered so important by us that we had assigned a special team of the staff, headed by
Charlie Marton, and he had dedicated himself to reviewing those folders in which The American
Legion had the P-22, and that he each week gave a report to Mr. Stevens and me on what he
had found.

]

rr

__

I

of that day, and that under
they were disconnected.

review

EE

now,

rr

RR

TR

applying

a more

stringent

view

of

the

whole

thing,

Charlie Marton has said that some cases
he could not justify, or make out a case
- for the service connection or compensable disability.
At the same time, he reported cases in
which he took issue and it was on these that he attempts to preserve the service connection
and the rating, or even a higher rating.
Now, that is the result of our staff study, by a team in the Claims Division.
It is a matter of review and finding out.
Charlie Marton has said that, in his opinion, we
should continue both as to the. total Part III cases and also as to the service connection
and the compensable ratings on these under review:
It is an objective appraisal by a skilled
service officer and claims man who brings back his reports to his Chief of Claims and the
Director and we go over it each time to find out in which way the trend is.
I think Marton’
has done and is doing a grand job.
That

is

the

situation,

Mr.

Chairman,

MR. FRED BROWNING, Rhode Island:
Mr. Chairman, I would just like to say one word
in support of Mr. Crider of Tennessee.
I don't want him standing all alone on the assumption
that there has been a change in the trend.
I feel the same way, that there has been a change.
I wish I could put my finger on it, but the closest I can come to it is to go back to the
Hoover Commission report in which he stated or recommended that claims should be reviewed
and studied on the existing prior-to-induction conditions.
N

in

the

That wasn't too bad but he folloted up and he said
rating philosophy.
I think that might be the beginning

there should
of it.

be

a tightening

CHAIRMAN MCCURDY:
I want it understood that I don't question the integrity of
a single individual in the United States Veterans Administration, and I have the utmost respect and admiration for the Administrator and a great many of the chiefs whom I have known
for a long, long time.
That isn't the point.
The American Legion has never taken exception
to review to correct error.
We, too, are anxious that the will of the Congress and the law
as passed by Congress be adequately carried out.
We think it is a little one-sided review
when vou will take those cases granted and review them and sever in numerous instances without taking those cases that were rejected and reviewing them and seeing what happens to those.
We have some feeling that if the rejected cases were reviewed in the same manner
that we would have service connections that were lost at the time.. If mistakes were made
one way, we have to assume that they were honest men and they were made equally the other
way, and so I would urge that while you are reviewing those granted, you also review those
denied.

com

MR. CLIFF:
Mr. Chairman:
Harvey, I have known you a long time and we have
been through a lot of these battles. I think that the thing that the people are concerned
about is that every time some review like this is started, there seems to arise in the minds
of those who are conducting it that there must be something wrong: and sometimes when you
find a case in which you feel that the service connection should be broken, it seems that
the people in the VA get the feeling that that is convincing concerning everyone, and they
certainly should be cautioned in this thing.
We have been through a lot of these reviews and, as you well know, we have been
through an Economy Act, too, that we had to fight and come back.
While I don't think,
possibly that ft is always intentional, there seems to be a feeling that some of the people
in the field are getting a little overimbued as to tendency of this review.
Now, maybe
there are some mistakes but I want to caution
you that if there are, they are mistakes of
the VA because, after all, you have the final say on whether a man is or is not serviceconnected,
There is no other form of jurisprudence that I know of in this country where
the adjudicating agency has such a final say as they do in the Veterans Administration.
The
service connection is determined by your doctor.
It is not determined as it is in general
practice where you submit it to a jury and you can introduce any sort of testimony you want
to, and so I think it would be in order that your people be cautioned, because of the power
that they have, which has been conceded to them over the years, that they must keep a balanced
mind whenever they eome into one of these reviews so that they are fair in reviewing the
case of the man who is accused of wrongfully having a service connection -- because you
granted it, and these men should be given the benefit of the doubt and the sincerity that is
behind the entire program.

yw

that,

and,

MR. HIGLEY:
Pat, they were, of course,
therefore, I rather assumed it was up to

our mistakes,
us to correct

there is no question about
them if we made them.

To get this thing in focus, I suppose you all know that it was the General
Accounting Office that spurred this type of work, because they found one of our offices where,
frankly, the work was not good.
They found quite a number of mistakes that were, you might
say, unpardonable.
It just seemed like somebody must not have been using his head.
-179-

Now, just using common language, they virtually said to us, "Here, this is
. your responsibility.
If you are not going to do it, we are going to do it."
Well, of course
we want to do it ourselves.
We want to be sure that we are the ones that are determining
these things, and if we have made the mistakes, we would like to be the ones to correct them,
not those who are outsiders.
So, that is why we got into this program.
Now, they started this review with no new people coming in.
We are using the
same men who are on the job today, not outsiders, and then in each case where there is
severance of service connection involved, it has to come in to a board here in Central Office,
that looks it over.
The principal point was to be sure, among other things, that they were
moving themselves back to the regulations that were in existence at that time. Do you see
what I mean?
There may be new philosophies today.
So if you are looking for mistakes,
‘we
must not try to apply some new, more modern medical knowledge or anything like that.
appeal, not
of case.

Of course, this board here did reverse some.
Even then, it is still open to
only to the Veterans Appeals Board, but to the Administrator, if it is that type

I didn't want to leave
scheme.
I do think we were trying
restrictions around it so that the
I just wanted
up, or anyone else.
This
of work should be done.

to
is

any impression that this was some kind of a hurried-up
to do our duty as we saw it, and that we did put enough
decisions ought to be quite accurate.

give you the background.
This isn't just something
a kind of sequence of events which pointed out that

I dreamed
this type

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Just to add a little to the background, it was three years
ago, I believe, that we reported to this conference how the General Accounting Office opened
this matter.
They took a team over and they gave them ninety days' training, at thousands
of dollars expense, and they became rating specialists, and then they went out in the field
and pulled these cases and brought them in and the total savings was approximately the same
as had been spent for their training.
Now, I don't concede that you
quickie training of that type.
That also
Office lowers the boom and it was exactly

make a rating specialist in ninety days on a
is in the background on how General Accounting
what Mr. Crider was talking about.
3

We want the VA to run the VA.
We don't want the General Accounting
a bunch of ninety-day wonders, going out and telling our VA specialists that he
wrong, and breaking service connection.
There ought to be some place along the
we can have something to say in that.

¢|

Office, with
rated a man
line where

If you want. to have a review, let's take the best board, the most seasoned and
experienced board, and let them review it.
That is what you are doing now, but in the
background, the way it started, none of us had any confidence in those ninety-day wonders
from the General Accounting Office, Harvey.

this

J
We
question.

must

hurry

along.

We

will

MR. BARRETT, North Carolina:
record at this conference as saying that
does exist in North Carolina.
MR.

MACKALL:

It

also

exists

take

another

question

or

two

but

let's

get

§

off

May I make one comment?
I would like to go on
the trend referred to by Mr. Crider certainly

in

Florida.

MR. EGAN, Delaware:
A review of previously disallowed claims:
I spoke.of three
cases on the floor yesterday.
One of them has been down for administrative review.
I wrote
Mr. Higley a personal .etter, requesting his kindly consideration.
The only way that justice
could have been done in that case was to have it completely rerated at Central Office.

What happened?
It was referred back to the office of original jurisdiction.
Now, let's see what happened in one of those cases.
You scheduled them (and, Harvey, you
are not responsible for this because it goes back to the original start of the Veterans
Administration) and these are errors, in fact, of ommission which never should have existed
seventeen veterans of the same name, their claims and their records all intermixed.
You
wrote, because you are the man who is responsible for the Veterans Administration now, to a
man in Alabama to come in for a physical examination for a man who lived in Philadelphia,
in order to rate a case of a man living in Marcus Hook -- and that was done.
Now, this is a disallowed claim for tuberculosis, diagnosis at the final examination prior to discharge.
It has neve. been rated.
It is going to be rated now.
But what
can be done in order to be fair and just to all of those men?
Those cases must be drawn in
You must have a board of kindly consideration sit down, review those
to Central Office.
physical examinationsand the ratings and readjust them.
It cannot be rated by the office of
-180-

ii

4

--

original
bringing

jurisdiction.
in cases which

The corrective action must be taken
have previously been disallowed.

here.

That

is

what

we mean

by

1f these awards are granted correctly and properly as they should be, these men
will receive the retroactive award because of clear and unmistakable error on the part of
the Veterans Administration over which they had no jurisdiction in excess of $30 thousand.
We would like to know what you are going to do when the error is on the other side.
CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Comrade Eagan,
I think that Comrade Harvey has freely admitted
that there are errors in the VA and we understand that, that there are errors in the VA.
Of course, as far as I have ever known, in cases such as you speak of, if they are brought
to his attention, he and his staff have been prompt in correcting them.
I don't think they
deliberately want to make a mistake on this.

all

MR. HIGLEY:
I will
forty-eight states into

the

admit that was a honey of a case, when we tried to bring
it.
I don't know how that happens.
I give up on that one.

I will say this, that when we refer it back to the office of original jurisdictiou,
almost always a letter has gone to that office telling them what we want done.
That is the
norm.
Your case may be different.
Maybe we sent that order down to Alabama or Florida or
some other place in this case you are talking about.
We evidently.were just bound to make
a mistake.
But sometimes if the case has not been appealed, if it is just our review (and
in this case it is), it is a review we are making of their decisions and it is our business
to check them,
It is not before the Board of Veterans Appeals and as the deciding board
is at the Regional Office, we send it back there.
But in the cases I have been involved
in, we tell them what to do and if a corrective measure was necessary we are probably not
leaving it to them merely to say they were right in the first place.
MR. EGAN:
I admit that part of that letter was a
suggestion as to what should
have been done, and should have been done long ago.
We hospitalized the veteran to find out
his exact physical condition now.
The rating: zero percent for bronchitis effective in 1945.
It will be back on an appeal.
CHAIRMAN

time

McCURDY:

MR.

HIGLEY:

MR.

EGAN:

MR.

HIGLEY:

there

Tell

me

sure

will.

I would

when

like

any

further

you

do

all

to

look

MR. WILTON B. MACKALL, Florida:
a public statement as to whether,

make

handed

economy move?

one

by

if,

I

Are

MR. HIGLEY:
I am happy
any chance, you think it

questions?

that,

into

will

you?

it.

Mr. Higley, would
to your knowledge,

to.
There is not
is in existence.

that

you or would you not at this
there is or is not an under-

I know

of,

and

I am

no

party

to

Mr. Higley, would you please, for the benefit not only of the State
MR. MACKALL:
of Tennessee and the State of Florida and some of the other states who have expressed their
opinion here, but all of us, pass down to the Regional Offices that word -- because, when
the General Accounting Office moved in, your Regional Offices immediately got the feeling
that there was an economy move here, there was a dollar-saving trend up here in Washington,
and I believe that is where it is coming from and it is moving into the veteran population
is
in all of the states and, in travelling around the state, the veterans want to know what
Is it on the Hill or just what is the
Why are they tightening up?
the matter with the VA.
trouble?
We
from

of

the

this

don't

Veterans

nation

get

the

consideration,

Administration.

are

so

vitally

So,

I

interested

we

don't

am

sure

in

the

that

work

get
you

which

the

sympathy

that

understand,

sir,

you

are

doing,

we

have

why

the

been

getting

veterans

sir.

MR. HIGLEY:
If you think that there is some feeling, an inborn sort of thing
that didn't start any particular place but an idea, I guess it is, that they are supposed to
be tight, or however you want to say it, I will be glad to tell them.
I suggest that you
and Bill Driver -- oh, Ralph Stone is here now -- would you personally see them and will you
put into words what you think we should tell them to undo what you think exists?
I am willing to admit I am a little at a loss, I am in a quandary because I don't know what to tell
them because I never have told them to do anything else except what you would like to have
done.
I don't know how to write and tell them not to do something when I don't know where
they got any such idea.
Would you help us to that extent?
I might

add

that

I don't

know

that

the

-181-

General

Accounting

Office,

in

talking

about this, had any idea of an economy move such as you described.
You understand that they
are the last word.
They look over every cent that is paid out and they have almost unlimited
power to be sure that the money has been properly spent.
I thought it was more or less in
the vein of their checking us that they ran across some of these things in one of our offices,
and that is what brought on this general review.

what

you

Even with the General Accounting
have called an economy move.
Would

Office
you do

I don't
that?

know

that

they

have

any

idea

of

. MR. MACKALL:
Mr. Higley, I thank you for the invitation but, as you know, we
have full confidence in you and I am sure that you have seen here this morning the opinions
of these men from all over the United States regarding what the feeling is in the field. I
am confident that you as an Administrator could pass down to the Regional Offices, Medical,
Adjudication and the other divisions of the VA, just exactly what you have said from the
rostrum,

sir,

MR.

HIGLEY:

I will

be

glad

to

do

that.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Thank you, Harv.
I might say that I was never so glad in my
life that you are a Past Department Commander of The American Legion.
I am sure you understand this kind of meeting and I am sure you appreciate this kind of meeting.
Again, I want
to assure you that we have nothing but the utmost respect for the Veterans Administration,
and for Harvey Higley.
MR.

HIGLEY:

Thank

you,

Bob.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
And it is very distasteful to me to invite a guest anywhere
and then be rough with him -- but I don't consider we were rough
with him.
We were just
discussing our problems in the good old Legion-democratic way and we are so happy that, as
a Past Department Commander, you understand that.
So, let's give Harvey and his staff a
good hand for their contribution this morning.

the

report

of

the

Recommenddtions

Committee,

We will now recess the conference and convene as the Commission for
receiving
the report.
We will use the same technique as we use in convention.
If there is any
recommendation to which you object, just speak up and say, "Hold that one
up," and we can
discuss it.
Otherwise, we will adopt the entire report at the conclusion of the report.
recognize the Chairman of the Recommendations Committee, Lew Sloneker.
(The

Commission

reconvened

at

twelve-twenty

“

have

I

o'clock.)

MR. LEWIS SLONEKER, California:
Thank you,Mr, Chairman.
Members of the Conference:
Your Recommendations Committee, consisting of W., H. Colley, Jr., Tennessee,
William
F. Grund of New Jersey, George W. Rulon of North Dakota, Louis S. Dennis
from Maine and Yours
Truly, had four meetings and have decided on twenty recommendations to submit
for your consideration.
The Committee wishes
June Bancroft and Loyd Pool from
assistance.

to thank most heartily Barney Gollinger, Ike Colkitt,
the National Rehabilitation staff for their most able

Recommendtion 1.
That the National Rehabilitation Commission give serious consideration and study to amendatory legislation to Public Law 550 for
the purpose of increasing the ceiling from the present $310 to at least $400 as it applies
to apprentice on-the-job
training programs.

be examined
states that

2.
That a veteran held to be not feasible for training because of his disability
by a qualified specialist and be allowed to enter training if the specialist
the veteran would benefit from training.

3.
That a summarization of the VA Voluntary Services, participating in each
respective hospital throughout the country, including
an itemization of the number of volunteers and hours served by each participating organization, be conselidated
in a report
issued by Central Office of the Veterans Administration to be available
to all participating
organizations and that each local VA hospital make available a comparable
report to all
participating organizations.
4.
That ‘this Conference urge enactment of legislation to change VA Regulation
2(a), Part I, so that veterans receiving treatment in private hospitals who are
rated under
Extension 7 of the 1945 Schedule be entitled to increased monetary benefits
from date of
surgery as indicated by hospital report, rather than from date of receipt of
report as is
now required under Regulations 1216 (C),
-182-

a

now

PPeau

will

=

We

applauded.)

er

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
Sloneker, Chairman.

and

er

Lew

arose

cm

Mr.

audience

Nt wf

(The

5.
That the National Rehabilitation Commission use all
command to prevent the Armed Services from destroying the induction
x-ray films.

of the
and/or

resources at its
separation chest

6.
In keeping with the long-standing policy of The American Legion for the
decentralization of the adjudication of death claims and related benefits to the Regional
Offices, we deplore the recent program of the Veterans Administration of decentralizing to
only a maximum of one Regional Office per state.
We strongly recommend for economy, efficiency,
and better service to the widow, minor children and dependent parents, that the decentralization of the adjudication of death claims and related benefits be to all Regional Offices.
7.

ties become
charge from

on

the

That

the

8.
That the
effective at
the hospital

deceased

veteran's

name

appear

in

all

cases

on VA

Form

8-685.

application of Extension 6 to the 1945 Schedule of Rating Disabilithe termination of chemotherapy treatment rather than date of disas an arrested TB case.

9.
That the income questionnaires on 8-59 and
anniversary date of the award instead of the first

8-685 be sent out to beneficiaries
of the calendar year.

10. That an immediate transcript of the record of the Appeals Panel on Armed
Forces Review Board of this Conference be transcribed and that it be studied by the National
Rehabilitation Commission in order that appropriate action be taken for the correction of
the existing situation.
It is further recommended that the Commission initiate action to
bring about amended legislation if necessary.

AT

Re

yy

yo

11. That the staff of the National Rehabilitation Commission compile the
figures for the last four years on cases allowed and denied by the Board of Veterans
and that such figures be sent out to the field by Rehabilitation Memorandum.

annual
Appeals

12. That the Administrator of Veterans Affairs take necessary steps to increase
the grade for medical consultants to the Board of Veterans Appeals with pay comparable to
medical specialists in the Department of Medicine and Surgery.
13. That employment, marginal
pension not be a bar so long as his total
statutory limitations.

or otherwise, by a veteran receiving Part III
income from all sources does not exceed the

14. That the Veterans Administration amend Extension 5, 1945 Rating Schedule to
make more realistic the percentage of disability required by establishing an intermediate
physical requirement between the ages of fifty-five and sixty-five.
15. That the Veterans Administration request adequate salaries for their physicians
in the Department of Medicine and Surgery, that the Bureauof the Budget request adequate funds
in its budget request and that The American Legion use all of its best efforts to influence
the Congress to appropriate sufficient funds to carry out the above which is in accordance
with our National Mandate.
§
16. In view of the urgent need for additional doctors for the active practice of
medicine in many of the Veterans Administration hospitals and the seeming lack of authority
of the area medical directors plus the large amount being expended
for maintaining the Area
Medical offices, we recommend that our National Rehabilitation Commission make an adequate
survey study of the advisability or justification of the Veterans Administration continuing
such offices.

to

;
existing

17. That additional beds be made available by additional
VA hospitals for intermediate care of veterans.

construction,

if

necessary,

18, That full-time VA medical personnel be assigned to the reception and admission
service in all hospitals that are under the Dean's Committee and that the chief of this service have authority to admit eligible veteran patients.

VA

hospitals

19. That increased funds be appropriated
shall operate at full bed capacity.

and/or

allocated

to

provide

that

all

20. That amendatory regulations be obtained to provide the five-year level premium
plan of National Service Life Insurance: cannot expire within the 31-day grace period for
the payment of the sixtieth (60) monthly premium.
LEWIS S. SLONEKER, Chairman.

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
cussed

further?

tions

MR.
Committee

Are

Is there any recommendation

you

ready

to

adopt

BROWNING,
as read.

Rhode

Island:

the

I move

the

adoption

-183-

cee

RT

that you want

held or want

dis-

recommendations?

RR

of

the

report

of

the

Recommendas
:

.

(The

motion

was regularly

seconded.)

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
It is regularly moved
of the committee be approved.
Are you ready for the
opposed, '"'mo."
It is so ordered.
Has

anyone

anything

else

to

bring

before

and seconded that the recommendations
question?
All in favor say "aye";

the

meeting

before

we

adjourn?

MR. BROWNING:
I would like to make a motion that this Commission go on record
with a vote of thanks to you as our National Chairman and to T. O. Kraabel and his entire
staff for the excellent planning and carrying out of this conference.
MR.

FENNER:

I second

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
staff is concerned, certainly
say "aye"; opposed, ''mo."
It

the

motion.

I am not bashful.
I will take that motion and, so
they deserve it.
They have done a yeoman job.
All
is so ordered.

far as the
in favor

MR. C. C. HORTON:
Mr. Chairman, do you think it would be altogether fitting and
proper that since, for the first time in the memory of man, the American Medical Association
and The American Legion have found at least one small area at which they find themselves in
tentative agreement, and that this desirable accomplishment is largely due to the efforts of
Past National Commander Seaborn Collins, Past National Commander Harry Colmery, the members
of the staff of both The American Legion and The American Medical Association, that we should
take some formal action to recognize and express our gratitude for the splendid work of
these gentlemen?
I so move you, sir.
(The

motion

was

regularly

seconded.)

All

in

favor

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
You have
say ‘'aye'; opposed, "mo."

so

that

you

Mimeographed
can all have

heard the motion.
So ordered.

Are

you

ready

for

the

question?

on

the

table

outside

copies of the recommendations are available
the recommendations to take with you.

If there is nothing further to come before the meeting, I want to announce that
our National Chaplain was honored this morning by being the official Chaplain in the opening of the United States Senate.
We think that is a great compliment.
And so, to close the
meeting for us, the Reverend Will Adams is here.
He is a Past Department Commander, he is
also a six-year Past Department Chaplain, and so I ask Comrade Bill if he will just send us
on our way.
THE REVEREND WILL ADAMS:
Gracious Lord, we thank Thee for the days when Thou
wast here on earth, when Thy didst heal the bodies, the minds, the spirits of people.
We
thank Thee for thse who are walking in Thy footsteps to administer to the people in need,
especially those who have given of themselves in the cause of our great country.
Bless, we pray, everyone in our veteran hospitals, especially those who are tak=
ing care of our comrades wounded in battle and others whose lives have been broken in different
ways.
Minister likewise to their homes, their friends, their families, their loved ones.

to

the

glory

As we depart, may it be in the consciousness that whatever
of God, for the benefit of our fellow men and to make our

we do, we are doing
country a better place.

May a special blessing rest upon the Chairman of this Conference who has so
nobly labored during these many, many years.
May we likewise all together depart with the
fullness of Thy blessing, Thy grace, Thy benediction, through Jesus Christ, our Lord. Amen.

is
to

CHAIRMAN McCURDY:
The conference and the official meeting of the Commission
adjourned, and thanks, fellows, for coming.
It has been a great conference and it is
see you all again.
I want to see you all next year.
(The

meeting

adjourned

at

twelve-thirty

-184-

o'clock.)

fine